Mark Grant — Chief Strategist and Managing Director at Hilltop Securities (Erik, w2114); 'Hilltop Investments Chief Strategist' (Patrick, w2062) (as introduced on the show)
Opening and episode preview
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 81 was recorded September 21st, 2017. I'm Erik Townsend. Hilltop Securities Chief Strategist Mark Grant will be joining me as this week's featured interview guest. Mark and I will discuss this week's FOMC announcement, why Mark thinks the US dollar has undergone a secular trend change, Mark's outlook for stock markets around the globe, Treasury yields, precious metals, the looming pensions crisis, and a whole lot more. Be sure to stay tuned though for our postgame segment after the feature interview when retired hedge fund manager Jesse Felder will be joining us to discuss the lofty valuations in equity markets and to give us an update on the equity indicators that he follows.
Market wrap: S&P 500 stalls after the Fed
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 certainly has started to stall out here as the Fed announcement came out on Wednesday. What's your feeling here on the S&P 500?
Erik Townsend: Well, a lot of technicians are starting to call 2,526, 2,526 as a short-term upside target that they see. Whether or not we get there, you know, remains to be seen. I feel though, Patrick, like I always say the same thing for the last several shows about equities, which is I think these valuations are crazy high, but at the same time, I don't see any reason to think that this trend is ending. Now, frankly, I don't follow equity markets as closely as I follow commodities, particularly crude oil. So, what I'm gonna do is ask our friend Jesse Felder to join us in our postgame segment. He does a lot of work following a number of indices, DeMark indicators, and so forth. I wanna get an update from Jesse on whether he's seeing any technical signs that this thing is really about to roll over, or if we're just gonna continue to march higher, as has been the case.
So, stay tuned for that after our feature interview with Mark Grant.
Market wrap: US dollar, bounce or secular turn?
Patrick Ceresna: Now, let's move on to that US Dollar Index, and it really looks like the US Dollar is finding some sort of supports here. We haven't really seen any big breakout just yet, but certainly some support in there. What's your feeling What's next for the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, to be sure, Patrick, this has got to be the biggest question in finance right now. Is this US dollar secular bull market set to resume the way Raoul Pal and Julian Brigden have told us to expect? Or are we in a secular bear market? Has the trend reversed, as Luke Gromen told us a couple of weeks ago? I'm definitely going to be asking Mark Grant that question in today's feature interview. Seems like we're bouncing right now. Hawkish FOMC meeting certainly helped with that. I think the FOMC's to begin quantitative tightening is really insignificant because it was so widely anticipated that it was fully priced in. Definitely, though, the important question to figure out, probably the single most important question in finance right now, is, is this a secular change of direction or are we going to see a resumption of the dollar bull market? Jury's out in my mind. I had previously been pretty convinced of the bullish argument.
The more that I see of really smart people that we've talked to in recent weeks coming around, more experts that have a bearish view, it's really opened And, you know, the first guy that really gave us a secular bearish view on this program was our friend, Mark Yusko. We ought to get him back on the program so we can get an update on his outlook. He certainly is the guy that has called it most accurately and earliest in terms of our past guests. I'm undecided though at this point, and I'm very much looking forward to having more experts that are dollar bearish on the program.
Market wrap: crude oil, the 200-day average, OPEC and EIA data
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, let's move on to crude oil. Crude oil seems to be surging higher in spite of all of these data points coming out. It's holding up around this $50 level. range. What's your thinking of the next step for crude oil prices?
Erik Townsend: Well, as I mentioned last week, we definitely saw a breakout from the downsloping channel that was in play. So, you know, that's a cup and handle formation that targets maybe as high as $52 or $53. We're hitting major resistance right now, right around $51. Now, it's fascinating, this $51.08 is getting a lot of coverage from some major analysts who are saying because that's the 200-day moving average, that that And that's the reason that we're seeing major resistance here. Now, that is, in fact, the 200-day moving average, Patrick, on the single contract chart. In other words, on the November 2017 delivery contract only. If you remember when we had Jack Schwager, the man who literally wrote the book on futures trading, on the program several months ago, he went out of his way to comment. I think he even used the word incompetence to describe professional traders who don't understand that moving averages are relevant, at least according to Jack Schwager.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: Yeah. And that's why I use the Schwager on a nearest futures chart, because if you plot it on a single contract chart, you're looking at a 200-day moving average of prices that were way away.
There was so much contango in the market 6 months ago that those prices were way away from the front month price. So, in order to get an average of front month prices, you need to look at a nearest futures chart. Now, Jack may be the man who wrote the book on futures trading, but it seems like a lot of really well-respected professional oil traders chart number. So, is the 200-day moving average 49.60, which is what I have plotted on my chart, the way Jack Schwager tells us in his books to do it, or is 51.08 the 200-day moving average according to the way it plots on a single-month contract chart? I would say that I'm right, but it seems like the market is paying attention to 51.08 right now. So, watch for that level. I think that probably what's holding us up here, because I have been expecting this market to roll back over, is the OPEC meeting, which is Friday.
So, We're recording this, of course, on Thursday afternoon. I don't know the outcome. I wouldn't be surprised if one of two things happens. Either there's no significant news or announcement out of that meeting and the market turns south from here. I think there's some hope in the system, people expecting that maybe something is gonna happen at the OPEC meeting. No reason to expect that. They've told us that there's not gonna be any announcement at this meeting.
Or maybe there is some kind of propaganda that is slung after the meeting and that pushes a false breakout up above that $51.08 resistance, maybe as high as 52 for a few days, and then it rolls over. Of course, I could be wrong. Maybe we're headed back to 55, but I'm waiting for this market to roll over. I think that as we start to get back to meaningful inventory numbers, which right now we still have a lot of noise in the system from the hurricanes, I think that you are going to see a trend of builds in inventory and that sentiment is going to change. From a seasonality standpoint, right around the middle of September is when we start to have a seasonal trend downward in prices. As far as inventory this week, crude oil building 4.6 million barrels, about in line with expectations, a little bit higher. Cushing, Oklahoma, 703,000 barrel build. Gasoline drawing down 2.1 million barrels and distillates drawing down a massive, massive 5.7 million barrels.
Now, I talked to our friend Sam Madani, the founder of TankerTrackers.com. They had projected a 12.8 million barrel build this week, and the reason for that is they They are aware of about 5 million barrels of unaccounted-for oil. In other words, in all of the confusion after Hurricane Harvey, there were about 5 million barrels worth of customs receipts for oil that had come into the country and didn't get counted in last week's number. So, they thought it would be counted in this week's number. Sam was able to reach out to EIA after the number came out and said, hey, what happened here? And they explained to him, no, that's not the procedure. They don't add forgotten oil into the next week's number.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: week's number. What they do is they just sit on it, and at the end of the month, they issue an adjustment, but it doesn't get reported. So, we think there is actually 5 million barrels of unaccounted-for oil that got forgotten about in the aftermath of Hurricane Harvey.
And it sounds like it will never show up in a weekly build or draw number. It's just going to be adjusted out in the month-end EIA report. So, it probably won't affect prices. So, just to summarize, my view on crude oil is I do think that we're at very lofty prices here. I think that we're We're overdue for a turn back to the downside, but we need to get through OPEC and we need to get some unclouded data into the system before that may happen. So, could take another week or two. I am expecting a reversal to the downside.
Market wrap: gold, passing on $1,300 and eyeing $1,281
Patrick Ceresna: Now, let's move on to gold. And it really looks like the moment that dollar index put in that short-term low, that gold has really started to correct here. What's your feeling about where gold is going next?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, Patrick, I mentioned last week that I might buy gold at $1,300. And as I watched it, I decided not to. And a big reason is I definitely think that a bounce in the Dollar Index has begun. Is the Dollar Index in a secular trend reversal? As I said earlier, I don't know. But there's at least a bounce in play. Now, if we are going to see a resumption of a secular bull market in the dollar, gold is gonna tank here. So, I passed on $1,300. I may try a small position at $1,281, which is the next repair area lower. But, you know, I'm gonna have a tight stop on that because if the Dollar Index bounces meaningfully, I think I think that we could see much lower gold prices. On the other hand, if Luke Gromen is proven correct and we really are seeing a secular trend reversal, then that's a whole other story. And this is probably going to be a bargain opportunity at $1,281.
I think we are going to see that price. So, I'm still watching it. As we're talking on Thursday afternoon, we're just flirting with the 50-day moving average, which is around $1,291 or so.
Market wrap: 10-year Treasury yields
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, let's move on to those 10-year Treasury yields. What's your feeling about the next wave of interest rate trends?
Erik Townsend: Well, we're back at 2.27 as we're recording this around the close on Thursday afternoon. Not a big change from last week, right in the middle of that trading range between 2.12 and 2.50 or so. So, you know, which way is this going to resolve? I don't really have a short-term view. I do think ultimately that we're going to get back to lower interest rates, lower yields. 2.12 was the critical number. We thought we took it out. Looks like so far that was a false breakdown. I guess we need to wait and see if we get a solid break down below that number. I do think we're eventually headed towards lower yields, but I definitely want to ask Mark Grant about this because I think he's going to have some fascinating thoughts on the bond market.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for that market wrap, Erik. Now, for this week's featured interview, Hilltop Investments Chief Strategist Mark Grant is joining us. Now, Erik's interview with Mark Grant is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager, Erik Townsend.
Why the Fed decision matters less than central bank money
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Mark Grant, Chief Strategist and Managing Director at Hilltop Securities. Mark, thanks so much for joining me on the program. I wanna start by reminding our listeners that we taped this interview on Wednesday morning, so we don't yet know the outcome of the FOMC meeting. But just this morning, Wednesday morning, you published an article on Bloomberg describing why you don't think that this announcement that everybody has been looking forward to. Will she or won't she reduce the size of her balance sheet? You don't think it's nearly as important as most people seem to. So, please give us a summary of what's in that article, which our listeners will find a link to in their Research Roundup email.
Mark Grant: Certainly. My comment is that the Fed actions today mean much less than most market participants are taking it. And the reasons— there are a number of reasons for it. The first one is that the The Chinese Fed, in terms of their assets under management, is now the 4th largest of the central banks in the world, with the Bank of China, the ECB, and then the Bank of Japan all being bigger, in that order.
And consequently, while the people in the United States and the institutions in the United States tend to focus on what the Fed is doing almost with laser-like quality, What the other central banks in the world are doing is every bit as important, if not more important. The world is now global, and all 3 of them are continuing to print money at about $300 billion a month. And if the Fed cuts back today, it'll be minuscule by comparison. So, it'll only mean a little less money is globally available in the world to be invested. Okay.
A secular change of direction for the US dollar
Erik Townsend: We do have a link to the rest of that article in the Research Roundup email. Let's move on to the US dollar. You know, we've had so many guests on this program were all dollar bulls until recently, and of course now there's been a fairly abrupt change. Do you think we're nearing a bottom here and this dollar rally is set to resume, or do you think we're actually seeing a secular change of direction for the US dollar?
Mark Grant: I think we're seeing a secular change of direction. I think a lot of it is caused by What Europe and the Bank of China have done in terms of their own portfolios, it's had a material effect on the dollar. I think the line in the sand, if you will, is 1.20, which I've said for about the last 6 months versus the euro.
And if we break that support resistance line, we're currently at 1.1987 this morning as we're talking. I think that's gonna have a material impact on US corporations, both positive and negative. And especially the global corporations in terms of exporting our goods. And then, of course, in terms of our cost of importing goods from Europe and from Asia.
Equities and yields driven by $19 trillion of central bank money
Erik Townsend: And let's talk about the U.S. equity market outlook with that view on the dollar. So many people are calling tops here, saying it's just so overvalued and has to go down. But the market keeps on marching higher. What's your outlook for the U.S. equity market?
Mark Grant: I think the driver is not It's not PE multiples or earnings or the normal things that 10 years ago or more we would've looked at to be the causation of the S&P 500 or the Dow Jones. I think the driver of the equity market and the debt market, by the way, is one thing and one thing only at this point, and that's the over $19 trillion created by the central banks.
And that money keeps equity prices high. Keeps bond yields low and causes a compression of risk assets, both equity and debt, versus our sovereign debt or Treasuries. I think that single factor is the driver for all the markets at present.
Erik Townsend: Now, where you say that is the single driver, does the fact that the Fed is talking now about beginning quantitative tightening cause you to think that that factor is going to stop having the effect it's been having? Or would you say that the quantitative tightening they're talking about is small enough that it's not really going to make very much difference.
Mark Grant: I would totally be in the camp of your second point, that the amount that they're talking about is so small compared to the amount of money that's manufactured every month by the other central banks that realistically it's going to make very little difference. I'm in the camp that until the global central banks stop printing, that equities are going to head higher. Bond yields are generally going to head lower, and corporate bonds, mortgages, and all of the risk assets are going to continue to tighten versus Treasuries.
Erik Townsend: And with respect to the Treasury outlook, you know, we've had this debate as to— Jeff Gundlach famously called the 1.35 or whatever the number was on the 10-year as, you know, that's it, it's all uphill in yields from here. Other people have been as bold as Raoul Pal, say, calling for 50 basis points on the 10-year before this is over. Do you think the 35-year bond bull market Do you think it really is over like Jeff Gundlach thinks, or do we still have lower to go in yields?
Mark Grant: I think we have lower to go in yields. I know that Jeff called for 3% by this time on the 10-year, and not such a great call. I projected 2% in the short term. The lines in the sand, if you will, are a resistance level on the 10-year at 2.32% on the upside and 2.16% on the downside. We're right in the middle of that range right now.
And I think after the Fed comes out today, unless it's a huge surprise, bond prices are going to go higher, yields lower once again.
Inflation, hurricanes and mortgage risk
Erik Townsend: I had Hugh Hendry on the program last week, Mark, and he surprised me by saying he sees inflation coming in a big way. And, of course, we haven't seen inflation in the economy for a long time. With the beginning of quantitative tightening, it seems like that's even harder to believe. Do you see inflation as a risk anytime soon in the economy?
Mark Grant: No, I do not. I think inflation is very subdued, and I think in the upcoming weeks and quarters, because of the tremendous cost— Moody's Analytics estimates the cost of the 2 hurricanes, Harvey and Irma, at about $150 billion, and then we have, of course, Maria swinging our way— and I think that's going to be a big factor in continuing to control inflation.
And, of course, we saw that to some extent today in terms of home sales, and that weren't nearly what people had thought. And I think a lot of that reason had to do with the 2 hurricanes.
Erik Townsend: And do you have— I know that you are down there in Florida in the thick of this. Do you have a view as to how the hurricanes are going to affect markets in the sense of, you know, is this going to be the so-called broken window theory, that there's going to be economic stimulus because of all the rebuilding that's going to have to occur down there in Florida? Or do you think that this ultimately has a potential downside risk factor for financial markets?
Mark Grant: Well, the downside risk factor is the first factor before we get to the rebuilding, and that, of course, is the tremendous amount of property damage. Also, it's going to have a big effect, I think, on the mortgage markets, as a lot of people will not be able to afford their mortgage, or just frankly, they won't pay their mortgage if their house was demolished, such as about half of the houses in the Florida Keys. So, I'm looking for the first impact financially to be a negative one. And then in terms of the rebuilding, you have to look at the tremendous cost to the federal government, but also to the states, to the state of Texas and the state of Florida, and to the local municipalities that are going to probably have to borrow more money in the marketplace to Begin the rebuilding process, which is one of the reasons that I think that the Fed's timing would be very ill-chosen to raise interest rates at this point.
Erik Townsend: If we see people walking away from their mortgages en masse because the destruction that occurred basically left them, you know, underwater— pardon the pun— in terms of the equity in their properties, who takes the hit on that? I mean, obviously, most of this debt is securitized, so it's not bank stocks directly. Who holds all of that paper, and is there a concentration in Florida, As to how that's distributed, in particular bond holdings, or is it really just mortgage-backed securities in general that would take the hit from this?
Mark Grant: Well, that would be the banks in the first issue, though a very large amount of the mortgages, as you point out, have been securitized. They're held by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and we could see a material hit to their balance sheets if that takes place. And, of course, also So, in the case of the 2 housing agencies, those 2 agencies, there's been a lot of talk about privatization recently, and I think there's some risk there in owning those 2 federal agencies far greater than owning some of the other federal agencies.
Gold outlook: slightly positive
Erik Townsend: Mark, let's move on to precious metals, a topic that is near and dear to many of our listeners' hearts. Obviously, with the dollar, as you see it, taking a secular change of direction, that should be good for gold, I would think. Is your outlook favorable for gold? And how do you see the market evolving from here?
Mark Grant: My outlook generally is favorable, but not overly favorable. And the reason for that is that gold is driven usually by 2 factors: one, some sort of calamity, and 2, inflation. So, since my outlook is for a very low inflation rate, I don't think that's going to be driving gold.
2 of the things that could drive gold are political events. The 2 most The most dangerous of which, if you will, are what's happening with North Korea and then what's happening in Venezuela. And those 2 events, if something actually hits the wall or unravels, could certainly drive gold to a higher price. So, I'm slightly positive on gold, but I'm certainly not in any rush to go out and suggest that people or institutions buy it.
Europe: Macron and bank bondholder haircuts
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to Europe. We've seen so much happening there, and a lot of people see the election of Macron as maybe a turning point. turning point for Europe. And of course, we're seeing the euro strengthening against the dollar suddenly. Do you think we are at a turning point? And in terms of things like European exit contagion risk, do you think that's contained now, or do you think that there's still more turbulence coming for Europe?
Mark Grant: I think Macron's election in France was net positive. He's a businessman. He understands not only governmental affairs, but he understands how the capital markets I think that's always a positive to have a prime minister or president in that position. And he also seemed to strengthen somewhat his ties with Germany, which I think is probably a positive. The negative in Europe right now is in their corporate bond sector. What they did with the Italian banks, which was instead of using the European Stability Mechanism to deal with the bad loans and the bankruptcies and In Italy and also in Banco Popular in Spain, my opinion was a travesty. They said, basically, that any bonds that were sold to local investors were missold, which means that they paid— they're going to pay them back 100% on the dollar, while the actual institutional bondholders that own the subordinated debt, both in America and in Europe and in Asia, are going to have to take quite a haircut, a huge haircut.
And so, there's no question that the institutions that I speak with are very upset about what took place in the European corporate bond market, and they've cut back their positions substantially in a number of cases, and I expect that to continue. I would also make the comment that if Europe can do this for their banking They can certainly do it for other debts. And if they do it for subordinated debt, they can do it for senior debt. So, now we know that the indentures for European bonds have very little value because they can change them at the whim of their political process. And I've had any number of discussions with some major institutions in the United States, Europe, and Asia about that subject.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mark Grant: And I think American debt is a much safer proposition for bondholders, whether they're institutions or people.
China, Kyle Bass and the yuan
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to Asia. Kyle Bass was— has been very outspoken for several years now, and just last week kind of renewed his assertion that he thinks the massive credit expansion in China has to come to a very bad end. He, I think, just last week went on record saying he thinks it has to happen sometime within the next year.
And so, he's calling for potentially a major devaluation of the yuan, which he thinks will be necessary for China to be able to recap their banking system after a credit calamity. Do you think there's any credibility in that argument? Certainly, Kyle has been saying this for a few years, and it hasn't happened yet. Do you agree with him that it's coming, and how would you see it occurring?
Mark Grant: I've read Kyle's comments before. They're certainly well-reasoned. With the exception that I think he's left out a few issues out of his thinking process. One is, of all the central banks in the world currently, the PBOC, or the People's Bank of China, is the largest in terms of assets. They can keep increasing their assets because they can print money and raise it even further. That would be one comment I would make that Kyle hasn't thought about, and I think that's what's buoyed them to this point. Two, they certainly can adjust their currencies.
Many of your listeners probably know the Chinese have a two-tiered system: an internal valuation of their currency and an external valuation of their currency. So it's possible to devalue locally or to devalue internationally or to do both. And the offset, as I said, is the printing of more money to finance their debt expansion.
In normal circumstances, and given a country that wasn't so controlled politically, I would agree with Kyle's assertions. However, given that it's China and the way they operate, they could still go on several more years operating just the way they are now, either by the currency adjustment, as Kyle says, but they could also just keep adding to their printing presses, printing more money, and even expanding the balance sheet of the central bank further.
Follow the money: buybacks and negative rates
Erik Townsend: Mark, I want to go back to your earlier point, which was about what's driving these markets in general. Could you elaborate for us a little bit more? It sounds like you really think that this central bank-supplied liquidity is the key to everything.
Mark Grant: That's correct. I'm reminded of the movie All the President's Men where they said, follow the money. And I think that statement is accurate, not only in the context of that movie, but context of our current markets. You know, until the Lehman disaster and the financial debacle that followed, the markets were largely driven by P/E multiples, earnings, To some extent, and to a great extent now, stock buybacks. And I just don't think that's true anymore. And I don't think many large investors have adjusted to the fact that it's the money that's driving these markets. This tremendous creation of money at the central banks, as I said, now over $19 trillion according to Yardeni Research. You basically created an economy, or a country, if you will, With no name that has as much GDP or has an economy as large as either the United States or China. And by this time next year, they're printing about, still globally, about $300 billion a month.
We're going to have an economy that's bigger than any country in the world that's been created by 50 or so people at the central banks of the world.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Mark Grant: And we've never had in the history of the financial markets a situation like this. So, in my opinion, it's not a question of new normal or old normal, to quote my friend Bill Gross, but it's a question of absolutely no normal because we're in an economic situation, a financial situation created by central banks that has never occurred before. And I I think the flow of money is what's driving the markets.
Erik Townsend: A lot of people have asserted the viewpoint that corporate buybacks that, of course, are enabled by these very low interest rates that central bankers have given us, are the real driving factor here. Would you agree with that view? And it seems like they're slowing down at least a little bit, although I think if we continue to see lower interest rates, you know, you would probably expect that to continue as long as there's a junk bond market to fund these, these buybacks. Do you think that plays a really big role, and do you see it continuing?
Mark Grant: I think it plays a role, but not a really big role. And as a matter of fact, if you look at my general overall thesis, it's the fact that interest rates are where they are that is allowing these buybacks, because it makes sense economically. I would also point out that the United States, of all the major countries in the world now has the highest interest rates, which makes no economic sense given our size, the depth of our markets, and the earnings of our economy.
And yet the ECB has driven interest rates for various countries in Europe substantially below ours. So, even in some countries, if you look a few years out at the 2-year, you'll see that Germany and France and the Netherlands and a number of countries actually have negative yields. And here we are with our own 2-year at a 1.39%, while, for instance, Germany is minus, minus 0.70%. So, the world's bond markets are totally driven by what the central banks have done.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Mark Grant: And the fundamentals that used to apply in terms of a country's economic position have very little to do with where interest rates globally are at this point.
Erik Townsend: Is there a limit to how negative negative rates can go? You know, a lot of people have suggested if they go too far, it creates a cash hoarding incentive and potentially a run on the fractional reserve banking system as people start hoarding cash in order to get zero interest rates instead of having to pay a negative negative interest rate.
Does this have a limit, and how far do you think central banks are willing to push this?
Mark Grant: You know, since this is such a grand experiment, it's very difficult to know what any kind of limit is. If you look, for instance, at Switzerland, their 2-year is -0.94%. Could it be -1.94%? Absolutely. You know, the, the issue sometimes becomes, in a situation like this, and I've given a lot of thought is you can't invest off-world. So, you're stuck now in this global environment of the United States buying mortgages and agencies and Treasuries at our central bank, but in the case of Switzerland, in the case of Japan, Japan, the Central Bank of Japan now owns about 70% of the equity market in Japan, and they buy ETFs ETFs as well.
And Switzerland is also buying equities along with debt. And there's been talk of some slowdown, which we're gonna see in a few hours at the Fed, and the ECB has made a noise or two about it, but so far nothing.
And it also means, of course, that you're paying a bank, say, if you're at negative interest rates, you're paying the bank to hold your money. So, we We have something that if 5 years ago I would have said out loud, everybody would have said that, you know, I'd lost my mind. And yet here we are in this very, uh, new situation where, uh, we have negative interest rates, which nobody ever thought could happen, and they've happened.
The pension crisis and CalPERS
Erik Townsend: Now, uh, the consequence of this that I see, and I'm surprised that it's not front-page news in, in the mainstream Is this situation of extremely low yields has, I think, basically paved our way to what I think has to be a pension crisis at some point. You see, the whole pension system, whether it be state-backed entities that are underfunded or corporate pensions that are underfunded, everybody's underfunded. Nobody is able to achieve the yields that they need, that their systems were designed for. And a lot of people have suggested that this could mean that, you know, and it's coming at the worst possible time, just as the baby boomers are entering retirement. Are we bound for a pension crisis? And if so, what's it going to look like?
Mark Grant: I think we're not bound for— I think we are already in a pension crisis. It's a, it's a very severe crisis, but this isn't something where you fall off the bandwagon tomorrow, because the municipalities and the states, of course, can increase taxes to deal with it. The pension assumptions that they've used, somewhat over 7%, aren't even close to reality, and we are now beginning to see tremendous pressure on a number of states. So, the worst states— so, I can provide some information to your users that might own municipal bonds— are New Jersey, then Kentucky, Illinois, Connecticut, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Florida, South Carolina, Rhode Island, Massachusetts.
And the situation year over year is worse. All of those states are at negative numbers in comparison with last year, which means their pension liabilities are increasing, and we're gonna start having some real problems because of this. I don't think it's a question of insolvency.
Erik Townsend: Mm-hmm.
Mark Grant: I just think it's a question Yeah. And you have the rating agencies, which did a terrible job during the subprime mortgage mess, I think have done a lousy job with many of the municipal credits. And I think anyone that owns municipal bonds or is planning on buying municipal bonds has to take a very close look at what the pension obligations of any state or municipal entity is to try to gauge The future economic health of the underlying entity, which obviously will affect the bonds that they own.
Erik Townsend: Let's carry this forward into how it might resolve, because I've been interested to see a lot of analysts have said, okay, so we're going to go a few more years and then these systems are going to blow up and the retirees are not going to get their benefits. It's just mathematically impossible that they're going to get the benefits. And I kind of think, well, okay, I believe that argument, but it's also It's also socially impossible for them not to get their benefits because, you know, it's a democracy. And if the largest demographic component that we have is the baby boomers and you just tell them, hey, sorry, we're gonna break our promises to you, you're not gonna get your Social Security benefits, that would cause a massive political upheaval. So, it would put tremendous pressure on politicians to, quote unquote, do something. What do they do? Do they just print more money at that point in order to satisfy all these obligations?
And how would you see it unfold?
Mark Grant: Well, as you know, the states can't print money. It's only the federal government, it's only the Fed that can print money. But what they have to do then is turn around and raise taxes to begin to deal with it. There was a very thoughtful article out recently by John Mauldin who was talking about that very issue. The politicians— I mean, he used very strong language saying that they lied, but they've certainly overpromised what they can deliver in terms of the pensions, and then they used all these very high pension assumptions in terms of the return on their investments, and that allowed them a number of years where they didn't have to put in nearly as much as they would have had they used more realistic pension assumptions, and now they're in trouble.
But I don't think it's a question of insolvency, meaning that they're going to fall over the cliff. What's going to happen is, and what we've seen happen, as a matter of fact, recently in California, is CalPERS, the large state pension fund for the state of California, has gone to any number of cities, and it's been in the press, and they've cut back what they're going to pay the pensioners. Of course, this is going to cause all kinds of social and political issues, But CalPERS said, we only have X amount of money, we're only receiving X amount, and they've cut back the pensions of a number of people in a number of cities in California. And I think that this could spread out to these other states that are in trouble, and it's gonna be a big mess.
North Korea, Venezuela and de-dollarization
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to geopolitical risks next. Obviously, you know, we've got sort of unprecedented events. North Korea is literally threatening to annihilate the United States. With nuclear weapons and may have the capability to do so, or at least take a serious crack at it. China, meanwhile, is threatening that if the US were to initiate or take a preemptive strike against North Korea, that China would defend North Korea. So, we've got a really big standoff. How do you see this both in terms of the geopolitical risk, but also it's striking to me that it hasn't had hardly any effect on markets? I mean, you'd expect to to see gold going to the moon and, and maybe the stock market at least taking a significant dip on this, and it's not happening. What's going on here?
Mark Grant: Well, what I think is going on is that rational people have a very hard time believing that something like that could actually happen, and so they dismiss it and don't pay attention to it and don't invest because of it. I think it's just the nature of being a human being that You can't believe that something like that could happen.
I think the situation, and I've written about it, is far more dire than most people think. I think head of North Korea is not a very rational person. You've seen what he's executed his relatives with howitzers and fed other people to dogs. I mean, you have to ask yourself what kind of guy this is, and could he make a mistake? Or could he push it too far?
I think the answer is yes. One of the commentaries that I wrote Out of the Box, which goes to— I write daily, which goes to about 5,000 institutions in 48 countries. I wrote that if some 9th-level technician had not programmed the last missile correctly and it had landed on Japan instead of flying over it, you'd see the 10-year Treasury at 1.5% before you were able to blink your eyes.
And I'm very concerned because I think this is a very dangerous and very irrational person, and he reminds me, in some extent, of a fellow that caused World War II in Germany. So, I think you can't dismiss it as that it can never happen. You have to consider in your mind that there's some possibility of it happening, even though all of us, any of us,
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mark Grant: As much as some of us hate to think of it.
In the case of Venezuela, you have virtually a socialist government that's become a dictatorship. They have big holdings in the United States because of their oil company. Mr. Trump and company has said that they're not gonna allow any more new financing in the United States. At some point here, if it gets bad enough and they cut them off entirely, then you're gonna see the court system probably seize their assets. assets for various creditors, and you have not just a South American problem, but you have an American problem. And, of course, then the price of oil could spike as a result of all this. However, having said that, one big change in all of our lifetimes, all of your listeners' lifetimes, is that the United States, because of our shale oil production, now has bigger reserves of oil than anybody in the world.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mark Grant: And we can, if we so choose, could literally choke some of these countries that are sponsoring terrorism just by keeping the price of oil low while their social programs in Saudi Arabia and Libya and a number of countries, including Russia, are $80 to $120 a barrel. So, again, it's not insolvency tomorrow.
But it's a grinding problem that's going to cause, in my opinion, material effects over a period of time.
Erik Townsend: One of the things that happened in Venezuela was there was a threat that, you know, one of the things we could do for sanctions would be to take away their ability to transact in dollars. And Venezuela almost preemptively responded by repricing their oil in yuan. Meanwhile, supposedly the Shanghai Futures Exchange is working on a yuan-backed oil contract.
What do you think of this trend of de-dollarization, of other nations trying to move away from the US dollar to reduce their dependence on the United States and its currency? Do you think that— and also, I guess, what impacts would you see it having on financial markets?
Mark Grant: I think that they're trying to do that. You can certainly price whatever commodity in whatever currency you want to, but you have several major problems with that. One is that most of the world Gold's transactions are done by using the SWIFT system, which is the American system which uses the dollar in terms of squaring up transactions. 2, while China would like to do that, they have a corresponding problem in trying to do that, which is that then they lose control of their currency both on an internal and external basis. Which would cause them tremendous political problems. So, I think there are people who are trying to do this, various governments are trying to do it. I think the chances of any kind of real success are minimal.
President Trump's agenda and markets
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to President Trump. And I think a lot of people have put a lot of expectation around the market responding to the very many things that President Trump campaigned and promised to do. Now, I don't know about you, but it seems It seems to me that President Trump is not exactly friends with a lot of people in Congress, and it's hard for me to see how he's going to accomplish these things. Do you agree with my view that maybe not all this stuff is going to happen? And if so, what does that mean in terms of any pricing that may already be built into markets, assuming it was going to happen?
Mark Grant: Certainly. So, on November 8th and 9th, I said publicly that Mr. Trump was going to win the elections and to buy equities. And I thought that was the right call at the time. I think in hindsight it was obviously the right call. The the issue here is complex because he certainly ran on the Republican ticket. We really only have two parties in the United States, and he won on that ticket. But whether he's really quote unquote a Republican is questionable. So we have a man in the White House. That, one, wasn't really a Republican, and two, is more of a businessman and used to doing deals, and he has his own view of things. And I don't think he understood fully that the judicial system and that the Congress, or the other co-chairman, that he thought he was going to be the CEO and chairman, and it doesn't work that way.
And I think he's learned that, or maybe still learning that.
Having said that, Congress, both Democrats and Republicans, have had a huge pushback against what he's wanted to do. And I think that probably has as much to do with his viewpoints as with the way he's trying to do things. We have Congress, of course, are chock-full of insiders. They've been there for years, any number of them. They know how to play the game. They know how to do the negotiations. And I don't think Mr. Trump came to the office with that kind of information.
One of the issues, I think, going forward for the markets is that a lot of President Trump's visions here, in terms of getting rid of Obamacare, in terms of building a wall, in terms of cutting back radically on taxes are being accepted very well in Congress. And while lately there seems to be a little bit of positive movement, I think that that's gonna cause an agenda that doesn't take place nearly as fast as many people thought in the early days of his presidency.
Hilltop Securities and where to read Mark Grant
Erik Townsend: And finally, as we close, give us a quick overview of what you do at Hilltop Securities and let our listeners know where they can follow
Mark Grant: I'm the Chief Strategist of the firm. We're 5,500, 6,000 people. The firm is headquartered in Dallas. We're a regional investment banking firm, plus we also have prime mortgage and prime lending, and we own a number of banks. And it's 6 different parts of the firm. Out of the Box does not go to the general public. Okay. Public, though they can read my comments in Seeking Alpha. It's published there almost every day. And Bloomberg, because I'm a Bloomberg Prophet, they publish my articles every Wednesday, so they can find what I'm saying on Bloomberg on Wednesdays. But Seeking Alpha is the best place to get it. And then I deal directly with some of the largest institutions in the world. Trying to give them some outside advice and helping them in executing their plans having to do with asset allocation and even as specific as certain equities or certain bonds. So, my day is rather full of that.
Hilltop is listed on the New York Stock Exchange. It's HTH is the symbol. And we're a rapidly growing company that's competing in the United States with all the other lead banks and regional banks.
Erik Townsend: And our listeners can find a link to your latest article from this Wednesday on Bloomberg in the Research Roundup email that accompanies this episode of the podcast. We're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. Mark, thanks so much for another fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at Macro
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program.
Now, back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Postgame with Jesse Felder: three questions after Grant
Patrick Ceresna: Now, joining us for this week's postgame is former hedge fund manager Jesse Felder. Welcome aboard, Jesse.
Jesse Felder: Thanks for having me back on.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, guys, what a great interview with Mark Grant. You know, to me, it's amazing that you can really see in the macro analyst space that there's really 2 camps. There's the camp of analysts that believe that inflation is about to surge higher. And those that continue to think that inflation is going to be pressed. And it's interesting to hear all these different guests come on and make their cases and arguments for this. What stood out for you in that interview? Let's start with you, Erik.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think there are 3 things that are absolutely critical here, and you just touched on one of them. The 3 questions in my mind that investors really need to figure out, the most important things that we need to figure out.
Number one, is inflation a real risk as Hugh Hendry very much thinks it is, as we discussed last week with Hugh? Or is it not, as we just heard from Mark Grant? Number 2, US dollar rally. Is it the Raoul Pal, Julian Brigden view that this is just a normal correction and we're about to see resumption of a secular bull market in the US dollar? Or is it the secular change of direction that we heard from Luke Gromen and now echoed today by Mark Grant? So, that's number 2.
Number 3, I think, is this question of stock versus And what I mean by that is the way that Ben Bernanke has told us that quantitative easing works is it's the creation of all this money. The fact that that liquidity is in the system and is displacing other actors that might have been competing to own the same Treasuries. It's the fact that it exists. And that was certainly echoed by a few of our guests like Pippa Malmgren.
On the other hand, there's this competing view that it's not the amount of liquidity, It's the flow in and out. So, it was when new liquidity was being created that creates buying pressure. And when liquidity is being taken out of the system, as the Fed has now announced that they're going to do, that means that it is essentially the tide going back out, that that's creating selling pressure. And I think that was an analogy that one of our guests used on the program was, you know, the tide was coming in, now the tide's coming out. So, which is it? Is it the stock argument or the flow argument? And it's pretty clear to me that there's merit to both of those arguments.
I'm sure there's some truth I think there's a lot of truth to both of them, but which one is the driving factor? I think we're going to find that out. I think if you can figure out those 3 key questions, you've got a huge lead on this market. Frankly, they're all challenging to me. How about you, Jesse? What did you think of Mark Grant's comments?
Inflation, demographics and outsourcing
Jesse Felder: Well, you know, I think the, the inflation discussion is a really important one. And there's one thing I, I talked to a couple of individuals I've been talking to individuals with very different backgrounds recently. I had William White on my podcast, who's head of the economics board at the OECD, former chief economist of the BIS. And he echoed something that Bill Fleckenstein told me a few months ago, which is the central banks can have the markets under their thumb until the bond markets take the printing press away. And it was interesting for me to hear from 2 different guys looking for the same catalyst to the end of this central bank experimental monetary policy. And so, the inflation discussion becomes maybe the most important one. And I did listen to Hugh on your show last week. And I think it's fascinating that he's looking at this as a mid-'60s type of environment, right on the verge of inflation taking off again.
William White brought up something to me that a lot of people are thinking about inflation the wrong way. And they're looking at demographics as potentially deflationary. And he makes a point that demographics are actually just the opposite. Very inflationary currently, because we had the baby boom generation that came in, and that's a huge new supply into the labor force, which is a deflationary force on wages. Now that the baby boomers are leaving the workforce, that deflationary force is being removed. And one that I would liken to that is also the trend towards outsourcing, which is also another massive deflationary force, which now, it seems like a lot of companies companies have basically outsourced as much as they possibly can. And now, we're talking about reshoring of labor. And we have an administration that's talking about potential nationalistic type of economic policies, all which could be a potential reversal in that deflationary outsourcing trend. And so, the combination of those 2 things could potentially be very inflationary over time.
And it's interesting to me to hear Hugh say that he thinks We're very close to that time.
Market breadth and DeMark Sequential sell signals
Erik Townsend: Let's come back to the stock market because, you know, you and I could agree with each other until we're blue in the face that valuations up here are kind of crazy on the high side. But we also know that expensive things get more expensive. And if we look at how bull markets tend to end, usually there is a euphoria stage at the end where there's some kind of parabolic rise to a blow-off top. And we haven't really seen the parabolic rise yet, although these valuations are I have heard a few comments from technicians about breadth, you know, not being what it was. We had Mark Grant comment today that the FAANG stocks have not made new highs, even as the index is. I know you follow DeMark indicators and a number of other technical signals. What are your signals telling you? Is there reason to think that this is actually coming to an end, or are we maybe just looking at a continuation of more of the same?
Jesse Felder: Well, you know, breadth is one of those things where you could look at a variety of different indicators and they'll tell you a variety of different things right now. The most popular one is probably the advance-decline line, which keeps making new highs.
And I wrote a piece very recently suggesting that the money that's flowing into indexes could be hiding very bad breadth under the surface. So, the advance-decline line, number of advancers versus decliners, when money's flowing into the index, it's flowing into all the 500 stocks in the S&P 500 or everything in the Russell 2000. And so, everything goes up based on— or up or down based on money flow.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Jesse Felder: Flows to the degree that money is being indexed. And so much money is being indexed today that I think it potentially is diminishing the value of the advance-decline line. Because when you look at other things like the percent of stocks above their 200-day moving average, I mean, 40% of the S&P 500 stocks today are below their 200-day moving average even as the index makes new highs. That's a lot of stocks that are technically in downtrends or technically in bear markets, whatever you want to call it, while the index is making new highs.
You have other measures like cumulative volume on the New York Stock Exchange has had the biggest divergence with price of whatever you want to look at, S&P 500 or the New York Stock Exchange Composite, the biggest divergence in over a decade, meaning that as prices are going higher, cumulative volume is not making new highs. It's actually flat for the last 12 months. And so that tells me that there's not as much buying power pushing prices higher.
And one other indicator that I look at is just the ratio of an equal weight index to the market cap weighted index. And that ratio tells you, is it all the stocks in the index pushing it higher? Is it just a select few? And whether you look at the Russell 1000 versus the Russell 2000, or the S&P 500 versus the S&P 500 equal weight, that ratio has just been plummeting this year. And so, that tells me it's fewer and fewer stocks pushing the index higher. And that's a classic sign of the waning or an expiration of a bull market. Lowry's has done a lot of research in that regard. And so, that's kind of a classic That's a classic indicator to me that I'm seeing right now. These types of breadth divergences are the biggest in a long, long time.
Erik Townsend: I know you mentioned in the feature interview that you did on this program that you follow the DeMark indicators. Give us quickly just a little bit of background for anybody who's not familiar with that as to what it is, and what are those indicators telling you now about this market?
Jesse Felder: So, I mainly use the DeMark Sequential indicator. This is something that Tom developed years ago to determine likely points of exhaustion in all different types of markets. And so, he discovered these a long time ago, and they became very popular with certain traders like Paul Tudor Jones and Steve Cohen have used his Sequential for a long period of time to determine points of trend change. And so, one of the ways I like to use it is use it, look at them across multiple timeframes. Look at a daily, weekly, and a monthly. When those kinds of things line up, like for instance, at the 2009 bottom, we had buy signals on the DeMark Sequential indicator on the daily, weekly, and monthly chart. They all lined up. It was a beautiful buy signal right in March of 2009. And we're kind of seeing the opposite of that today. Actually, Tom was on Bloomberg recently saying that all of his timeframes are kind of lining up across a variety of different indexes.
And so, that's the type of thing that you look for, for major trend changes. And I think that's what we're seeing today.
Erik Townsend: He said all of them are lining up with a sell signal that's active at this time, or
Jesse Felder: No, absolutely right. The DeMark Sequential sell signals are triggering on multiple timeframes across multiple indexes. And just to put a point on top of that too, usually I look at daily, weekly, monthly, but there's a quarterly sell signal gonna be triggered on the S&P 500 on October 1st also, which is very, very long-term timeframe that also lines up with these other shorter-term indicators.
Stock versus flow: does QT matter?
Erik Townsend: Now, as I mentioned earlier, there's this debate about stock and flow, and it seemed at least in this interview, Mark Grant feels He feels like, look, you've created all of this money. There's so much of it. The fact that you're starting to quantitatively tighten by removing some of that liquidity from the system, he thought was almost irrelevant because it's small. Other people would say, wait a minute, tightening is tightening. If you're taking liquidity out of the system, that's creating more downward pressure. First of all, did you agree in general with his view that it is central bank liquidity that's driving all of this? And if so, how do you see this stock versus flow thing? Which one do you think is more true or more operative in the market?
Jesse Felder: It's kind of a chicken or egg thing question, I think. I look at it as this whole thing with central banks is a great confidence game. So long as market participants believe the central banks are in charge and holding up the markets, then that will be reality. But as soon as market participants lose confidence in the central banks, which happens every time, the central banks lose their power to prop up the markets. And that's a common theme throughout market history. So, I do think right now, The Fed tapering is— if quantitative easing was bullish for markets, quantitative tightening has to be the opposite.
But I'm really more focused on the European Central Bank and the Bank of Japan, because I think rates over there have been pushed so low that that's why we've seen for the last few years dollar assets in such high demand, is it's investors just fleeing to where there's real returns. And so, when you see corporate bonds in Europe yields lower than Treasuries, that's going to create a dynamic of money flowing to the United States and into our asset markets. And that's what we've seen. So, I'm more concerned with if we start seeing tapering in Europe or a rise in inflation there that forces central banks to start reining back their policies there. I mean, frankly, the European Central Bank seems like they could be running out of things to buy pretty soon, which would be— which Which is going to be an interesting point. So, yes, I do think quantitative tightening is net-net bearish, but because it's only $10 billion right now a month, it's probably not the end of the world.
Positioning: Apple, the credit cycle and the short side
Erik Townsend: Now, with all of these sell indicators lining up across the board, I know from several things that you've written months and months ago that you and I are in agreement that for people that maybe have been long this market since 2009, hey guys, it's a pretty good time to be raising cash, take your profits, and maybe weather out what could be a storm here. Are you at the point now where you think it's actually time to go short this market, or are you just in take-the-profits-off-the-table mode?
Jesse Felder: I'm pretty much long-short all the time. So, I have things that I own, although they're much more difficult to find these days, and they're much more obscure things that are not included in indexes, and so get kind of left behind. But yes, I do look at a few things. Technically, right now, I'm looking at something like Apple, which looks looks very expensive relative to its own history and potentially facing a disappointing couple of quarters with the new products coming out. And that is probably the most important stock to the market. Semiconductors are going to trade off of how well the iPhone sells.
And for me, I'm also looking at the credit cycle. And a lot of these things point to me and telling me that it is time to start focusing on the short side or at least be prepared to take advantage of it. You look at auto sales, and we look at credit card defaults rising across the board, and the Fed tightening into this. Ray Dalio has brought up the 1937 scenario many times recently, but also for the past couple of years. And I think that's something to keep in mind, too. Fed tightening when the average American is not doing so hot, and we're seeing rising defaults in auto and credit card loans, is potentially problematic. And so, I think, yes, it's I think it's going to be an opportunity to play the short side very soon.
Research Roundup and close
Erik Townsend: Well, Jesse, I cannot thank you enough for joining us in our postgame segment on today's show. I really appreciate your insights. Now, I'm sure most of our listeners already know this, but you have your own blog as well as an excellent podcast of your own. Both of those are available at thefelderreport.com. Again, that's thefelderreport.com. We're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. Folks, we need your help promoting the show. Please like and tweet us, forward your Research Roundup emails to your friends and colleagues, tell people about MacroVoices. If you can, we sure do appreciate the donations that we've been receiving. There's a Donate button on our homepage at MacroVoices.com.
And most importantly, please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The more registered users we have, the more able Patrick is to recruit the very best feature interview guests. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just a compendium of links to all of the coolest free stuff that we could find on the internet every single week. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, you'll find in this week's Research Roundup the transcript with the interview from Mark Grant. You'll also find the link for Mark Grant's article that you referenced during the interview titled There's Too Much Attention to the Fed. There's also a great article written by Ambrose Evans-Pritchard about Canada flagged as hidden $14 trillion credit bubble stokes global crisis fears. It's a very Jeffrey Snider feel, as it is asking if inflation emerges, forcing the Fed to tighten, will it drain worldwide liquidity and potentially surging the US dollar? So, it's a really interesting argument made by Ambrose Evans-Pritchard about that more of a US dollar bull suck type scenario emerging. There's also an interesting article from Kevin Muir titled The Fall Guy, discussing the idea of fading that US dollar bear trade. So, you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.
Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share their content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distribution. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit us at MacroVoices.com. Visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information.
Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com.
And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's. Hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, Visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.