Ronnie Stoeferle — fund manager; principal author of the In Gold We Trust report (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Open and guest preview
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 221 was recorded on May 28th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is dedicated to healthcare workers all around the world, the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis, and is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases.
The In Gold We Trust report has become an annual event in the precious metals market, and its principal author, fund manager Ronnie Stoeferle, will join me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss all things gold, including precious metals and the mining stocks. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick has prepared another of his famous postgame chart books, this week focusing on commodities.
Market wrap: S&P 500
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to the S&P 500, which just has not let up. This rally just keeps going. It's unbelievable for me anyway. But what's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, I'm glad I didn't short it last week when I had yet another chance. And, you know, my hunch was right. I think that what's going on here is the market is more interested in central bank accommodation than the fears that are leading to that accommodation. I think that there's definitely a lot of reason to still be concerned about the economy and a prolonged recession as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis. But it seems like the market is more focused on the upside as a result of all of that central bank accommodation. And I think that a couple of technical things happened. We both decisively broke above that 61.8% Fibonacci retracement. In technical analysis, when you get beyond that 61.8% level, it usually means on a closing basis anyway, if you're past it, that you're probably going back to a 100% retracement. Likewise, we just moved above the 200-day moving average, which is another aspect of technical analysis.
When you're below the 200-day moving average, it's usually a downtrend. When you're above the 200-day moving average, a lot of technicians perceive that as an uptrend condition. So in the last couple of days, we've both clearly closed above that 61.8 Fib retracement, also broken above the 200-day moving average, as well as all the other short-term moving averages.
And you know, it just looks to me, Patrick, Stochastics are kind of high and wavering, but looks to me like we're headed back toward all-time highs. Doesn't make any sense on an economic level. I think that most market participants are underestimating just how long the effects of this virus crisis are going to last and how negative they're going to be. But it doesn't seem to matter. It seems like everybody's pretty excited about the Fed continuing to be accommodative, and that's driving asset markets higher.
Market wrap: dollar, crude oil, gold, 10-year yield
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar because the US dollar just is breaking down. I mean, we're essentially at this stage almost down to the 98 level and breaking multi-month lows at this stage. Is there another leg lower coming here or is this just a small fake-out?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as early as yesterday, I thought it was just a fake-out because, you know, the support has been pretty consistent at 99 on the dollar index. And we dipped below that intraday yesterday, But not on a closing basis. Now today what we saw was an outright close, not only just below 99, but way below 99. In fact, below 99.5. It was 98.40 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon. Now we're still speaking just before the close, so in theory a reversal is possible, but it's extremely unlikely. It looks like today is going to be that closing print signal below 99.
And you know, that's an important I don't get really concerned until we see below 94.5 or so, which was the March low. But frankly, you know, that, that low happened at the beginning of the pandemic cycle. I think it's very interesting to see this. I was expecting this trading range to resolve in the other direction. So it'll be very interesting to watch in coming weeks. All right.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to crude oil because crude at this stage, at least the July contract, is still hovering very close to multi-week lows. highs as we are approaching around the $34 level. Are we due for some sort of a throwback on oil, or does this keep going?
Erik Townsend: Well, we've been getting that throwback, that correction on oil, and it looked like, you know, okay, topping out, maybe reversing. But just in the last day or so, it seems like maybe that correction is ending already. We got on WTI not even kissing the, the 13-day moving average, which is at about $13.75. Usually if you get just a small correction in an uptrend, it'll go down and touch that 13-day moving average and then move back above the 8 and the 5-day averages. We didn't even get all the way down to the 13 on WTI. We got below the 13 on RBOB gasoline, but RBOB is rallying off of the 13. Looks like it wants to retake its 5 and 8-day moving averages. WTI is already above its 5 and 8-day moving averages. So as much as I thought that this market was kind of overheated and due for a correction. Seems like we got just a little itsy-bitsy mini correction in the last couple of days.
On the other hand, if I look at the time spreads on the back of the curve, they've been hit quite a bit harder than the front month has. Now sometimes those time spreads are a leading indicator. They give you an early warning of what the front month contract is about to do. So maybe there's still some weakness to come. I'd say that based only on the time spreads. If I look at the front month price action, looks to me like we're already back to uptrend conditions. So it's going to be very Interesting to see what the next couple of weeks bring us.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, how did the oil inventories come in this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's very interesting, Patrick. We got a build on crude oil of 7.9 million barrels nationally. Now, in addition to that, there was also a build on the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. So if you count both of them together, it was a 10 million barrel build. That's pretty darn significant. Cushing, Oklahoma, though, which is the critical delivery location for the West Texas Intermediate crude oil futures contract, still showing drawdowns, drawing down 3.4 million barrels this week. Gasoline drawing down 724,000 barrels. Distillates building 5.5 million barrels. So we've seen pretty significant builds on both finished products and on crude oil. You'd think that would be the catalyst to bring on more selling and maybe a deeper correction, but if anything, I would say that the recovery in price has been pretty much consistent With, uh, you know, as the, the data came out this morning, we saw a little tick down as a result of that build. It didn't last very long, and the rally seemed to start from there.
So maybe the market was fearing an even bigger build than this. I'm not sure.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because it looked like some form of a gold correction was happening yesterday, and then suddenly this morning we popped back up and once again holding some pretty good supports. Does gold still break out, or are you still looking for a correction here?
Erik Townsend: Well, I was getting all excited, just as you say, Patrick. It looked like, you know, maybe we were seeing the beginning of a breakdown. But if anything, as I look at this now, what I see is really a pretty textbook, you know, trading within the range. Yesterday we managed to just barely kiss the volume-weighted moving average at 1685, and, you know, it looked like, okay, maybe we were getting to that breakdown level. Nope, got a nice healthy bounce. And this morning we actually went and penetrated those 5, 8, and 13-day moving averages just briefly. We're back below them now, but it looks like, you know, the, the bounce is on.
And the thing is, Patrick, I have to revisit my outlook for gold because what I've been saying, as our regular listeners know, for many weeks is, hey folks, get ready for the possibility of a really big technical correction. I'm still super bullish on gold, but get ready because, boy, you know, when you have a stock market crash, it tends to pull the precious metals down with it. Well, I thought we were looking at a bear market rally in stocks. I thought that a really aggressive sell-off in stocks might be coming, and that might be what could pull precious metals down with stocks. We're seeing the opposite. So if I'm going to revisit my view on stocks and say, okay, looks like the bear market rally is turning into maybe a rally back toward new all-time highs, then I think we might be headed back to cycle highs on gold as well. I do still think that this market has gone awfully high, awfully fast.
It does show signs of being due for a technical correction, but the impetus that I thought might bring one about, which was weakness in the stock market, looks like it's not happening.
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, let's just quickly touch on the 10-year Treasury yield, because really it's been range-bound for almost 2 months. One of the tightest ranges we've ever seen on a 10-year Treasury yield, just pinned between, you know, spot 6.0 and spot 7.0, just bouncing around. Do you have anything new to say about the Treasury bond at this level?
Erik Townsend: No, I really don't. And, you know, as I've said in the last several weeks, what I'm really focused on is the bigger picture of where are we in the longer-term story, not what's the next move from here, but, you know, is zero really a bound That matters. Are we headed toward negative interest rates? And what is the transition going to look like? I'm convinced within the next 5 years, we're going to get to secular inflation replacing deflation as the big picture macro backdrop. That's the really big, important story. Am I right about that? And if so, how's it going to play out? That's the question that I'm focused on in fixed income.
Why Ronnie Stoeferle and the In Gold We Trust report
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, this week's feature interview guest is Ronnie Stoeferle. Why did we invite Ronnie back to the show as a guest this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Ronnie is a fund manager, hedge fund manager, who's had a terrific performance record running a precious metals hedge fund. And in the last decade or so, he's kind of become semi-famous in the industry as the author of the In Gold We Trust report. Prior to this, the only way you could get that kind of detail on the gold market was to buy paid research, something like CPM Group's Gold Yearbook, which was very popular as well.
This is, you know, free stuff on the internet. It's available to everybody for free, and it's really excellent content. So the publication of the In Gold We Trust report has kind of become the event of the season for the precious metals market. It just came out yesterday, so we wanted to get Ronnie on to talk about it as soon as it happened. So we actually recorded this interview a few days in advance, but it was intended to be the first discussion. This is Ronnie's first public appearance since publishing this year's In Gold We Trust report. And of course, in your Research Roundup email, you'll find a link to download your own free copy of In Gold We Trust.
Sponsor message
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test.
But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Ronnie is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here.
Interview: origin of In Gold We Trust and why it is free
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Ronnie Stoeferle, managing partner, fund manager, and research director for Incrementum. Ronnie is best known as the principal author of In Gold We Trust, which, you know, it's almost bragging rights, Ronnie. I can say that I remember the, the old days when IGWT wasn't that big of a deal, but it's really taken on a huge following in the last few years. You're up to about 350 pages of heavy-duty research, and it's free. So tell us a little bit about how this came about. Why is it free? Why are you giving it away? And how did you get to the point of doing this?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Hi, Erik. Thanks for having me again. Well, I'm publishing this report for 14 years now already. I started writing it when I was an analyst at a bank. Back then, I kind of felt like the vegetarian in the big butchery because sitting in a bank and then writing about the gold standard and being bullish on gold is kind of weird. Then we set up our own company, Incrementum, based in Liechtenstein. And then the report got bigger and bigger. And for me, it's just It's just cheaper than going to the shrink because, you know, there's so, so much in my mind that I'm reading, that I'm researching, that comes from conversations with, with other investors, with people on the street, books that I'm reading, newsletters that I'm reading, podcasts that I'm hearing. So this is basically, I'm distilling this into one big report. And at some point we said, okay, we, we really have to take the next step. And now we are employing basically 20 people. To crunch the numbers, to edit the report, to translate it from German to English and also to Mandarin.
So it's a big project now, and I'm really, really glad how it's turned out. It's probably one of the most widely followed publications on gold nowadays.
The golden decade thesis
Erik Townsend: Something I've been saying since 2008 or maybe earlier was that gold is going to be the asset to own in the 2020s. I've got my reasons for that view, but it was very interesting to me as I saw the report, which was just released yesterday, Listeners, you'll find a download link to get a free copy of the report in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads.
Ronnie, as I looked at the table of contents, I see that you're, you're describing the dawning of a golden decade, which sounds like the same idea that's in my head, but I want to hear your version. of why we're at the beginning of a golden decade? Why is now the time to really be thinking about a secular move in precious metals?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah, well, we always got a leitmotif for the report. Last year it was the erosion in trust. And I think that the topic was really quite spot on. And this time we said, okay, let's really make a long-term outlook for this upcoming decade. And so we analyzed the whole macro picture. And I think this is something that differentiates our report from other reports.
This is— we don't really care about just the supply-demand picture of gold. We try to analyze gold from a macro perspective. And I think that if we kind of zoom out a bit, the environment for gold for this decade couldn't be better. I think the world at the moment is really running out of safe havens. From our point of view, the relative scarcity is one of the most important topics to understand gold. So the stock-to-flow ratio of gold is like 64. So you've got an annual inflation rate of gold between 1.5% and 1.6% every year, which is already quite a big advantage when it comes, for example, to the money supply that is growing on average by 7.8% since 1971.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ronnie Stoeferle: So I think this relative scarcity and this solidity and reliability that you cannot be inflated at will in gold, very similar to Bitcoin, by the way, this is one big thing. Then I think that gold in this upcoming decade could take more and more the role of bonds. We shouldn't forget in 2008, Erik, Treasuries were sporting yields of, I think, 3.5%.
German bonds had a yield of 4%. Now, Now at the moment, you know, we're basically at zero or even below with most government debt. So I think the risk-return is very asymmetrical. Now with this whole corona crisis, I think that we can all assume that currency devaluations will be used to try to solve all the structural problems that we have. So this should also be quite beneficial for gold. And then we're seeing a renaissance of hoarding.
One thing that is really important: gold is extremely liquid. We're quoting a study by the LBMA that shows that gold is actually at some points much more liquid than than government bonds. So so this study is referring to the European Banking Authority's measure regarding high-quality liquid assets, and for some for some assets compared to some assets like like some government bonds but also corporate bonds, gold is much more liquid. So I think going forward we'll really see this this re-monetization of gold.
A second thing that I want to stress is we will— and here really the corona crisis is one of the biggest triggers— we will reach the limits of debt sustainability. So the International Monetary Fund says for the industrial nations, debt to GDP will rise from 105% now to 125% in this calendar year alone.
And then I think, and this is really a hot topic that we will be discussing hopefully, is we're seeing the end of central bank independence. So what we've seen in the last couple of weeks, I think Chris Cole said that on MacroVoices, he felt that capitalism almost died in the last couple of weeks. And I couldn't agree more. So from my point of view, this is really the point where MMT, helicopter money, universal basic income, yield curve control, and all those things will be implemented. Absolutely, absolutely for sure. So this, in combination with the current price action for gold that we're seeing at the moment, makes me pretty confident.
Inflation vs deflation and Rothbard's three stages
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, a theme that we've been focusing on here on MacroVoices for the last couple of months has been the The evolution from a deflationary macro backdrop, which has predominated the economy for the last decade, in moving toward, I think, either inflation or stagflation, something that is not deflationary. But I think that we've seen so much money printing and there's so much more on the horizon that it's likely that we move into a period of secular inflation or stagflation. First question, I already know the answer is, do you agree with that? And I think there's a yes because I saw it in the report. But give us your version of that. Why do you think that we may be headed towards inflation or stagflation? And how would it come about? And what would it mean for precious metals?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I mean, we all know from reading monetary history that gold is a pretty good inflation hedge. I think that's obvious. I think if we compare the current situation to 2008, 2009, let's have a look at TIPS, for example. The volatility in March and April was enormous. So TIPS were falling to -0.6, I think. And then within basically 2 weeks, they rebounded to positive 0.63. And this was really the biggest rebound in inflation expectations that we ever saw in history. Breakevens are currently at 0.7. And we've never seen a deflationary development like 2008, 2009, where the 5-year breakevens where we're at -2.2. So what this is telling me is that this time around, central bankers were acting much more quickly and much more aggressive compared to 2008 and 2009.
They've learned their lessons, but it's this time around, it's not only central bank action, it is also fiscal policy that is extremely aggressive. Until the end of April, we saw central bank liquidity injections of $10.4 trillion and fiscal stimulus of $10.2 trillion. So that's basically, I think that's roughly 20% of world GDP that was created just until end of April. So those measures of course are enormous, but we shouldn't forget that there's lots of deflationary pressure in the system. The problem is That that basically in this kind of creditism system that we are in now, we seem to have reached the limits for for loan growth coming out from from the traditional banking sector. So we shouldn't always blame just the central bank because we shouldn't forget that most of the most of the money is actually created coming out of commercial banks. And I think if we compare like really a big long-term view, if if we if we have a look at this inflation scenario. Scenario normally, and, and we quote Murray Rothbard from his wonderful book, The Mystery of Banking.
It's, it's really a great book. And, and Rothbard says actually there are 3 stages when it comes to inflation. So the first stage is when money supply is increased and, and prices, they hardly rise at all. So people think it's only temporary. And for politicians, this is like the land of milk and Then the second stage is when suddenly asset prices start rising.
And I think we've seen massive asset price inflation.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ronnie Stoeferle: This everything bubble that Jesse Felder described so well. So at this point, politicians are basically facing a fork in the road. Should they either allow some sort of natural deflation and painfully reduce the excesses and approve a recession, or should they continue with the path of cheap money and thus risk the third phase? And the third phase is this stage, and I think we could be on the verge from the second to the third stage at the moment, when the public perceives that the inflation dynamic cannot be stopped and that it's gradually accelerating.
At one point, And people just say, okay, that's it. We try to leave the system and choose alternative currencies and hard assets. Erik, I think it's no coincidence that Bitcoin is one of the best asset classes this year. It's up, I think, 25%. So from my point of view, we could really be on the verge of this third stage. Now, I don't think that this is going to lead to hyperinflation, but we shouldn't underestimate the time lag that we'll see from all those measures that were implemented in the last couple of weeks. It's a bit like drinking tequila shots. You know, after 2 or 3, it really goes well. And then you have another 1 or 2.
And then at some point, you just pass out and wake up with a huge hangover next day.
So I think that politicians and central bankers completely underestimate the the time lag effects. Now, once velocity starts rising again, once the economies open up again and, and, you know, the whole sentiment is getting better, then I think is going to be the point when we, we really will see if inflation picks up significantly. But some of the reasons for rising inflation from my point of view are, you know, we're seeing much lower productivity. We're seeing that increasing, you know, populism, but— and we'll see probably less trade, less globalization. We're seeing that, for example, the whole ESG development is something really big. If you want to set up a mine, whatever, a copper mine, a coal mine, whatever, it's just basically impossible. So, so those are long-term effects that now meet those monetary measures and those fiscal measures. So from my point of view, inflation, it's not something that we should expect in the next couple of weeks or months, but it is something that we will see in the next couple of years.
And don't forget, Erik, we're seeing $14 trillion in bonds at negative yields. Now, the biggest pain trade for those $14 trillion, of course, is rising inflation. And at the moment, I think the average investment advisor is 52 years old. So during their professional careers, they've never really experienced any inflation. So this will be a completely new ballgame for many people in the industry. And I think that gold is already telling us, okay, friends, inflation is around the corner. It's gonna happen. Yeah.
Recession, the Fed and Corona socialism
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, you've expressed a view which is very consistent with what we've heard from some of our other expert guests, which is this pandemic was not the cause of the recession which is beginning. Rather, the recession was ready to happen. It needed a trigger or a straw to break the camel's back. The pandemic was the trigger that got it going. Please elaborate. How does this situation compare, say, to 2008, 2009? And what's your outlook economically?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah, well, I think I've been on the show with you, Erik, in August last year. And I said, you know, a recession is basically— is gonna happen sooner or later. And don't get me wrong, a recession from my point of view is something normal, something healthy within a cycle. But I think, you know, last year we have seen a yield curve inversion, which is one of the most reliable recession indicators, of course. We saw that the OECD leading indicators declined for roughly 20 months in a row.
We saw that 70% of world PMIs were negative. The US was already in an earnings recession. Germany was very close to a recession. South Korean exports, which is also very, very sensitive to world trade, were down. So I think it was pretty obvious that the economy is weakening significantly.
Now, I just finished reading the FOMC minutes and they sounded very, very concerned. So they said, okay, they fear that many job losses will be permanent. They said basically the word medium term much more often than in the previous FOMC minutes. So this suggests that the Federal Reserve doesn't expect a V-shaped recovery.
Actually, I don't see anybody but the stock market expecting a V-shaped recovery. So it means that the Federal Reserve will probably become much, much more dovish. Now, we have seen, and you did some brilliant shows on what was happening coming out of central banks, but we have seen from 2007 to 2014 that actually Fed total assets increased by 5 times from $900 billion to $4.5 trillion. From my point of view, at some point they will easily go to $20 trillion. I think at some point the Federal Reserve will start buying all sorts of assets. You know, they are now active in the junk bond market. At some point they will start buying stocks. Of course, I think the Federal Reserve Act would have to be changed, but it was already amended 4 times in history. So this just leads me to the conclusion that the market is conditioned to further stimulus like Pavlovian dogs. But those dogs now are really— they're fat, they're sick, and they're old.
So it needs much, much more food and much more stimulus to get them up. And this is something that really, really concerns me because it means that there will be less market forces, there will be more interventionism.
I once said it's going to be Corona socialism. And this is something that scares me as a libertarian. And this also means that after the Corona crisis, because now everybody is still kind of scared and nobody knows how this whole health situation is gonna turn out, but the next crisis will probably be a debt crisis. Ronald Reagan famously said, to say Congress is spending like drunken sailors is an insult to drunken sailors. Now, I think for last year, the deficit in the US was already 4.8%, despite the fact that the economy was still doing well. This year, I don't know what the number is going to be, $14 trillion or 14% of GDP. Nobody knows. It's an election year, so they will probably spend a little bit more. But those numbers are just outrageous.
And this just tells me, okay, we won't see positive real interest rates in the next couple of years. And this is then also a very, very good foundation for, for, for the price of gold.
Commodities and Opposite Land
Erik Townsend: Now, with the expectations that you have around inflation and so forth, normally that would be associated with a very bullish outlook for commodities generally. Of course, commodities have been really moving south pretty hard even before the crisis and even harder during the crisis. Sir, are you anticipating a turnaround for commodities generally? And does the weakness in commodities raise any caution flags with respect to precious metals?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I mean, commodities, it's tough. You know, the last few months were probably as turbulent and unsuccessful as, I don't know, Justin Bieber's latest attempt for a comeback. It was just the CRB, for example, I think is down like 30% this year. It's 72% below its all-time high while the Bloomberg Commodities is like 64% below its all-time high. So it's tough. And we're writing in the report, the whole world is upside down. And there's this great children's book called Opposite Land by Charlotte Rose, where basically she says everything is opposite in this book what it's supposed to be. So socks wear feet and broccoli is meat and behind is ahead and people poop from the head. So it seems to me sometimes like the whole world of investing is upside down, you know, with negative oil prices and negative yields now being, you know, it's just normal.
So from my point of view, when it comes to commodities, it's really a tough call. And actually making the case for commodities is painful. And when I tell friends that I'm pretty bullish copper, that I think that oil is having a pretty decent risk-reward, that silver looks fantastic. This is the point when people start ridiculing you. But that also tells me, okay, perhaps that's a good idea because most great investments, they start in discomfort. They really should hurt and they should give you perhaps sleepless nights. So from my point of view, commodities often come at the next stage. So first, there's always gold moving. Then it's normally silver. In silver, we saw a massive reversal from gold-silver ratio at 125 down to 100. So silver started outperforming gold in the last couple of weeks.
And normally, the third stage is that commodities pick up relative strength. So we make a comparison and show the parallels between the 1970s and the 2000s to the current situation. And each time we have seen previously a decade of booming stock markets, very aggressive central bank policy, and this basically fueled a rally in commodity markets. So I'm pretty confident because when our inflation view is right, then I think that people start buying real assets at some point. And I think that this fiscal stimulus, Those huge infrastructure programs that are considered now and that will be implemented. This could really be the catalyst compared, especially in an environment where basically nobody is bullish commodities and valuations are extremely low. So valuations of the commodity market versus the Dow Jones are at the lowest since the 1960s. So I see lots of value in the commodity space at the moment.
Gold as bond substitute and institutional demand
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, a question that you posed in this year's In Gold We Trust report is, can gold substitute for bonds in portfolios? Now, of course, historically, the argument against gold was that it doesn't yield anything. Of course, bonds don't yield anything these days either. So what's on your mind here?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah, I think that's— at some point, this might really happen. Erik, what we're seeing at the moment when it comes to gold is that generalists are getting interested again. This is something that we haven't seen like a year ago. Let's not forget one year ago when we published the last In Gold We Trust report, gold was below this $1,360 to $1,380 resistance. This is really, really hard to tackle and it tested this massive resistance zone a couple of times. Then early June we went above this resistance zone, and then gold really picked up momentum. And really, it started according to the Dow Theory. I think we're now in the second stage of this bull market, which is the public participation phase. So, so I see that many big institutional players are getting interested at the moment. I think the allocation when it comes to institutional players is extremely low, but we're seeing some, some hedge fund stars like, let's say, Paul Tudor Jones, but also Stanley Druckenmiller.
He became bullish gold a while ago. We're seeing Sam Zell, Ray Dalio, and so, so, so they, they already kind of rediscovered gold. From my point of view, and this is what we're, what we're doing with quite a lot of institutional clients at the moment, we're calculating for them actually what gold does to your portfolio.
Erik, you know our reports and we always emphasize that gold is not the answer to everything. It is not a religion. It's just something that has got pretty positive consequences for your overall portfolio. And I think we perfectly saw that in the last couple of weeks where gold actually really defended your portfolio. It stabilized your portfolio from losses in equity markets. So I think gold Gold did a brilliant job. It did exactly what it's supposed to do. And therefore, I think in this stage of the bull market now, more and more institutional players will come into the market. They will realize, okay, with 10-year Treasuries, with German bonds, there's only very, very limited potential. And basically with this whatever-it-takes approach to create inflation, to actually reach those 2 or 3% inflation rates. And at some point, I think they will say, okay, temporarily we need higher inflation rates. I think this basically tells you, okay guys, get out of bonds.
And then I think this will probably stimulate real estate markets. It will probably be positive for equity markets, but it will be most positive for gold, which is the most reliable inflation hedge that you can have.
US dollar and DXY risk
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, let's talk about the US dollar. A lot of people think it's about to crash and the, you know, the end is nigh. I don't really hold that view. I follow a lot of Jeff Snider's work looking at the global shortage of US dollars and the amount of outstanding US dollar debt. Now, historically, there's kind of an inverse correlation between gold and the dollar. And I think we should point out, you know, gold Gold has already broken to all-time new high prices in most currencies, but not the US dollar, probably because the dollar is so strong. So how do we reconcile for US dollar-centric investors, people whose portfolios are denominated in US dollars? Is there a caution here that maybe the strength of the dollar makes gold less of a good idea than it would be for investors who invest invest in other currencies?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I mean, you know, since the beginning of the year in dollar terms, gold is up 14%. Last year, gold was up 19% in dollar terms. Over here in euro terms, gold is up 16% year to date, and it was up 22%. And in other currencies like the Australian dollar, it is up 21% and, and so on. So of course, the dollar is The strongest currency at the moment. Actually, there's only one currency where gold is not trading at new all-time highs at the moment, and this is the US dollar. So we reached new all-time highs in Swiss francs, for example, a couple of days ago. So this tells me, okay, the world still regards the US dollar as the safe haven currency.
Now we're kind of interviewing 2 good friends of us, Luke Gromen and And Brent Johnson. And Brent, as we all know, he's making a tremendous case for a strong dollar while Luke Gromen makes, you know, more this de-dollarization view, which is much more of a longer-term negative case for gold. Now, Erik, I'm— I've got a very contrarian mindset, I would say. So, so we checked the analyst forecasts for the US dollar, the— or basically the DXY index on Bloomberg. And actually, there is no analyst, not one analyst, who's seeing a dramatically or a sharply higher dollar index in the next 3 years. So the consensus is basically it will go slightly lower over the next 3 years. And this is telling me, okay, Bob Farrell said when all the experts and forecasts agree, something else is going to happen. So I think that the risk is definitely out there that the DXY breaks to, you know, if we break the 102, then it can go to 115, 120 pretty quickly.
And this would basically cause the next crisis.
Now, I think there's a pretty big fight going on. And this fight is called Donald Trump versus the market. And we know that Donald Trump doesn't want to have a strong dollar, obviously. And he just said recently, it's $6.2 trillion and we can handle that easily because of who we are, what we are. It's our money. It's our— we are the ones. It's our currency. So this reminded me a bit of the, you know, John Connally back in 1971. The dollar is our currency, but your problem. And we know what happened afterwards. The US dollar devalued 50% against the German mark. So I think that Donald Trump, he's very, very much concerned about strength in the dollar. And we will see if actually the market will win or politics will win. From my point of view, I hope that markets will win. But we know that if the dollar breaks significantly higher, and I think it should be, then there will be a massive intervention from politicians, some sort of a Plaza Accord meeting, whatever.
But in the meantime, if it breaks $220 or even higher, this will cause dramatic volatility and turmoil in many markets, especially in emerging markets.
Gold miners
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, I want to talk about the gold mining stocks. And forgive me if I get anything wrong here, please correct me because I do not profess to be an expert on the mining stocks. But from what I remember over the last decade, it seems like usually Usually the trend is the mining stocks kind of anticipate moves in the market and they tend to be the leading indicator that lead the price of the metal. It seems very, very clear that mining stocks are trailing the price of the metal here. Is that normal? And if not, what's going on? Why is this happening?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, Erik, we do quite a lot of relative strength work because I think this is most valuable in a market that is basically just trying to discount and anticipate what central bankers are going to do next. So I think that absolute prices are heavily influenced by central bank interventions. Now, relative prices give us a significant amount of additional information. And what we're seeing now is that mining stocks picked up relative strength against the leading sector in the stock market, which is technology stocks. That's a fantastic sign. So mining stocks are outperforming technology stocks. Now, what we saw over the bear market, I mean, it was a brutal bear market. We saw that many, many companies, not all of them, of course, they really got— they did a good job. They did their homework. So the profitability of the producers has increased in recent quarters. We shouldn't forget that debt was reduced. They're having much more capital discipline, cost control. We're seeing that margins and cash flows are higher.
They even pay— and I think that's important because the Wall Street Journal just wrote that more companies in the S&P 500 have suspended or canceled their dividends so far this year than in the previous 10 years combined. Now at the moment, Yamana Gold, Newmont Mining, B2Gold, Kirkland Lake, they were all raising their dividends. So on a relative basis, I think that's a fantastic sign. Then we shouldn't forget that energy, of course, is a huge driver on the cost side and that most of the currencies are extremely weak versus the US dollar. So from the weak local currencies versus the US dollar, that's a strong effect for most of the miners that are in Canada, that are in Australia, and so on. So from my point of view, the miners really, really look interesting at the moment. They've got the highest leverage on a rising gold price probably ever.
And we are seeing that generalists are coming in. If you have a look at the charts and if you have a look at volumes, you can see that there's big volume in the large mining stocks like Barrick, like Newmont, and also in the royalty space like Franco, for example. So this tells me, okay, this is not only only the mining guys that are entering the market. This is really the big generalists that are now start investing in the mining space. So, so that makes me pretty confident. But I'm, I'm absolutely certain that, you know, with rising gold prices and rising share prices, many companies will, will screw it up again. They will do ridiculous M&A. They will start just, just stupid projects. So it is really important to, to do your homework in the mining space, to, to have a look, a very close look management, and of course also valuation measures.
I think it's a very demanding sector, but it's also a very rewarding sector. And this is why we enjoy investing in the mining space so much.
Silver and the gold-silver ratio
Erik Townsend: Talk to me about silver, Ronnie. It's an industrial metal, not just a monetary metal. That causes a lot of people to be concerned that in a recession situation, as you and I both predict, maybe silver's not gonna do so well. But the other side of that is, from a ratio standpoint, the gold-silver ratio hit— I think it was an all-time high recently. And that, of course, would make a very strong argument for a recovery in silver. So which way do you see this thing going down?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I— you're totally right. We've never seen a higher gold-silver ratio. It was at 125. So it basically means with 1 ounce of gold, you could buy 125 ounces of silver. Now we know that silver is kind of gold on steroids. So it's, it's, it's much more volatile. And we've seen that especially in the bear market. Now, from my point of view, if you have a look, and of course, industrial demand is much more important compared to gold and gold, it's just 10%. It's not really, not really relevant for prices. But But when it comes to silver's supply-demand picture, we can see several supply constraints working in silver's favor. So out of 8 sources of silver supply, only 2 are not in a state of near stagnation or even contraction.
So from my point of view, silver is definitely something that you should be considering if you're bullish on gold. Investor demand is basically nonexistent. And when it comes to the supply side, we shouldn't forget that silver is primarily a byproduct. It is a byproduct of copper production, zinc production, and so on. And if you have a look at CapEx plans for the big base metal producers, it was already supposed to be down big time before Corona and now even more so. So I think on the supply side, there might be problems arising. In the silver market, while when investors' demand really should be picking up, I think that silver can go quickly to, you know, $25 or even higher. It's just primarily from my point of view, and probably some silver bugs won't like this view, I think it's a function of the bull market in gold.
If gold does well, silver at some point will dramatically outperform.
Gold versus Bitcoin
Erik Townsend: Okay, Ronnie, I want to take a trip to the dark side of the Force. There are a growing number of investors, particularly younger and more tech-savvy investors, who would say, Ronnie, look, you know, nice try on gold, but look, cryptocurrency is the new thing, buddy. Gold is an antiquated relic. The only real value that it ever had was its scarcity. And cryptocurrency invents a better way of creating a scarcity asset. Forget gold, it's all about Bitcoin, baby.
What would you say to that?
Ronnie Stoeferle: First of all, this competition between Bitcoin and gold is just ridiculous. I mean, it's like saying, are the Rolling Stones better or worse than, I don't know, the Strokes? It doesn't make any sense to compare them. I like both. I like the Strokes and I like the Stones. From my point of view, there are many similarities between gold and Bitcoin. And Bitcoin was designed to be digital gold. We have now seen this halving a couple of days ago.
So actually the inflation rate of Bitcoin is only roughly higher. I think it's 1.8% at the moment. So it's roughly higher than gold's inflation rate. Now in 4 years at the next halving in 2024, the stock-to-flow ratio of Bitcoin will be 121. So it will an even harder currency than gold in 2024. From my point of view, it's very binary. So if Bitcoin should still be around in 2024, and I think so, I think it will be significantly higher. I think, you know, we just launched a fund that is doing extremely well that combines physical gold with Bitcoin. And then we're doing something that we call vol harvesting. So we're basically making use via options of the significant volatility that we are seeing in the Bitcoin space, which totally makes sense. And we really want to embrace the volatility in this space. Now, as I've said before, Bitcoin, I think, did a tremendous job during the whole crisis. It is up 26.7% year to date.
So I think that Bitcoin is steadily becoming really an asset that will also be considered more and more by institutional players. I think that in 3, 5, 10 years from now, it will just be normal to have a small allocation in digital assets, like it's normal now to be in alternative assets, in private equity, in hedge funds, whatever. I think this is happening. We're seeing many, many signs that really big companies are becoming more positive, especially because the regulation is now getting better and better. So it is not, you know, the Wild West anymore.
They've got their regulatory framework in the crypto space now. And I really appreciate the fact, Erik, that there's so much young talent coming in. We're talking to so many— and I don't know if I'm old, but I'm 39 years old— but there's so many young kids in the market now. And you start discussing gold versus Bitcoin with them, and you can see, okay, they're really bright kids. They're extremely motivated. They're great entrepreneurs. They really want to deliver better solutions to the market. And when those young kids start thinking about what is money, where does money come from, is Bitcoin better money than gold, or is it better money than the euro or the US dollar? I think this is a really, really important discussion that is going on. And therefore, I really enjoy talking to those young people. And I think, you know, our view has always been that most of the problems that we're facing at the moment can be traced down to our monetary system.
So this is probably some sort of the endgame of our monetary system. We definitely came one chapter closer to the end. And therefore, I think it's really important to understand how our monetary system works. And I think that gold is one, let's say, insurance against, uh, those developments that we, we have to expect. But Bitcoin is another good answer to it.
Correction risk and the $4,800 / $5,000 target
Erik Townsend: Final question, Ronnie. I'd like to ask your advice on a conundrum in my mind that, that's just been frustrating me, which is, boy, you know, you just couldn't ask for better long-term fundamentals for gold than what we have today. But you know, the problem with that is everybody knows it, and it's It seems like a whole lot of people are all in and we've gone really, really far up really, really fast without any significant technical corrections along the way. Are we overdue for a technical correction or are we just going to keep moving higher?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I agree with you. You know, sentiment-wise, I think that, you know, according to Sentiment Trader, it's not extremely bullish yet, but of course it is not like the super contrarian bet at the moment. Just anecdotal evidence, but a couple of weeks ago when, you know, everybody was crazy about, we're running out of gold and there's no gold anymore. And I said, relax guys, this is mostly logistical issues. You know, there's huge demand, an explosion of demand for gold, and there's an implosion of supply because, you know, there's no flights from London to Zurich to New York. But back then, you know, even my ex-girlfriend called me and I haven't heard from her in 10 years. And she said, I want to buy gold now. And I said, okay, Well, this is perhaps some sort of a sign that sentiment is now pretty positive.
But on the other hand, you know, when you talk to institutional players and they probably will be the drivers of the next leg upward, they don't have any allocation in gold at all. So I have to say that, you know, we are pretty bullish on gold. Because, you know, gold is rising in every currency.
So actually, I also have to quote Bob Farrell again because Dave Rosenberg, he always brings it to attention. And he said, markets are strongest when they are broad and weakest when they are narrow. So actually, this bull market in gold is pretty strong. Gold is rising in every currency. Gold is outperforming stocks now and it's outperforming bonds. months. So this just tells me that we're really in an established bull market. Somebody, I think it was, was Harris Kupperman he wrote this is an asset that you don't have to worry going on the beach because, you know, it's just, it's gonna do well. Of course there will be short-term, there will be, there will be corrections, but you should buy the dips in the corrections. And, and our, as I've said at the beginning, you know, this is a decade And therefore, I always really enjoy reading Chris Cole's stuff. And I think it's great that you're having him on so often. And he has this 100-year portfolio.
And what we did in this report, we calculated the 10-year price forecasts for gold. Now, of course, it's not easy because you cannot do a discounted cash flow for gold. But what we did basically Basically, we used the money supply developments and an implicit gold coverage ratio. And then we did a distribution probability. And actually at the end of 2020s, we arrive at a gold price at $4,800.
Now, the interesting thing is the distribution is clearly skewed to the right. So this means that significantly higher prices are far more likely than lower Now, if you say now gold will be at $5,000 at the end of this decade, people will say you're crazy. This is impossible. But from my point of view, this is gonna happen because we're seeing so many things at the moment where we would have said a couple of years ago, this is crazy. Negative oil prices, impossible. Negative rates, the Federal Reserve buying, you know, junk bonds now. This will never happen. So I'm pretty confident that this $5,000 target for the next 10 years, which is obviously pretty long, that we're going to go there. And of course, there will be corrections, but I think the risk-reward for gold is the best that I see in the currency space.
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Listeners, again, the free research report is called In Gold We Trust. You can find the link in your Research Roundup email or just Google In Gold We Trust. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Postgame: hand-off and chartbook introduction
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Ronnie back on the show. And when I was listening to the interview, I immediately Immediately when he started talking about the weak commodity prices and inflation and what will turn everything and the impact it'll have on the precious metals market, I immediately thought that we were overdue for a quick little tour around in the commodity market. So I'm looking forward to doing that right now and taking a look at where we're trading on so many of these different commodities during this crazy cycle in the markets.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think that is an excellent topic for this week's Postgame Chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link for the Postgame Chartbook in your Research Roundup That's also where you'll find the download link for the In Gold We Trust report. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads.
Postgame: commodity index
Erik Townsend: Patrick, as we dive into this week's postgame chartbook, this chart on page 2 really jumps off the page at me because what I see here is, boy, commodities in general just on a nosedive.
Patrick Ceresna: Yes.
Erik Townsend: dive trajectory. And then we get into the COVID-19 crisis, looking at the middle of February. There's that bottom there at, what is it, 59 or so on the Bloomberg Commodity Index. And then you've got some consolidation, but never moving to a new low. Now, I don't think that we're going to have another worse crisis next week.
So it looks to me like there's maybe an argument that that 59 on the Bloomberg Commodity Index was a low, I mean, a final low, if you think we're about to see a secular shift into inflation. But then I sort of think about it and think, wait a minute, my interviews with a lot of our guests have said you got the right idea, but that secular shift to inflation is 2 or 3 years off. We're not done with deflation yet. How do you read this as a technician, Patrick?
Patrick Ceresna: Is this a meaningful bottom that we should be thinking might be the Well, in technical analysis, generally the first observation you're simply making is that the predominant downtrend has paused and we are in a consolidation phase. And determining now whether or not that consolidation develops into a major bottoming formation, because a lot of technicians could easily see that as a, you know, bottoming formation such as double bottoms and so on, but it also could be the midpoint of a continuation pattern.
And really, I think that to step back, we have to kind of ask ourselves where we are in the current cycle, because the economy is sort of marching to the beat of a different drum than the stock market. And so we can no longer take just the bias of this V recovery in the stock markets driven by a massive flood of liquidity by the Fed, but rather commodities are really demand-driven, which is about when will there be a true economic recovery?
The interesting part for me is that it's going to be really hard for the demand for commodities to get worse than when you literally shut off the world economy to fight COVID. So there is a legitimate chance that while the stock market may still have more bear market to go, it may be that we're in a far later inning in the cycle for commodities. And at minimum, commodities may stop going down. I mean, it's going to be hard, for instance, for, I think, crude oil to beat minus $40 to make a lower low, right? And so, I think that it's entirely possible that we are seeing the bottom end of the ranges. But one interesting thing that will be very interesting to watch on commodities in general is that will we now enter a period of extended purgatory where rather than a meaningful rally, it's just we spend multiple years just consolidating along those lows. If you think about where— what gold did after establishing its bottoms in 2014 and '15, we still spent years discovering where the real base of gold was before the bull market started.
And it's entirely possible that we're just witnessing that at this stage.
Postgame: gold and super contango
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to slide 3, gold. You asked me in the market wrap about this. What's your take on the technical analysis side of the gold chart?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, the one thing that the big debate everyone's having is almost the reciprocal of what we're seeing in that commodity index, which is that you seem to have now overhead resistance on gold. And the question now, are people seeing this as a topping formation or is this simply consolidation of that last bull run and the continuation pattern is about to come in? Now, for me, the most positive thing that gold has going for, which it could always change tomorrow, but right now, now, gold broke back in April to a fresh 52-week high, and the entire consolidation has actually occurred above the February highs. And so there's a, there's an old thing in technical analysis that what was previous resistance now becomes support. And so it's really curious whether or not gold can actually hold north of $1,700 in this consolidation, because that would mean that there's nice healthy accumulation that could be used as the— now the springboard to launch yet another advance.
And considering that the multi-decade highs of gold lie just north of $1,900, it's, it's entirely possible that if this consolidation holds, that gold may first try to go for a full retest of its all-time high before any bigger correction gets underway.
Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, something that has gotten my attention the last couple of days is we've now got super contango, which we've discussed in quite a bit of detail and what it means and so forth with respect to oil. We've got it in the gold market now. Normally, there's a rule for contango, which is there can never be more contango than what's known as the carrying cost, the cost of buying and storing the commodity, because otherwise it could be arbitrageable. Right. Arbitraged. If there was a really big contango from one contract to the next, somebody could buy and take delivery on the early contract, store it, and then deliver it into the next contract. Now, of course, with the COVID-19 crisis going on, the logistics of buying and storing physical gold and delivering it into other contracts is probably making those arbitrages difficult.
But I think it's really important for our I think it's important for listeners to know, when you look at the gold chart and you see, as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon, $1,713, and by the way, it got down yesterday to $1,685. Boy, sounds like a low number. Well, that's the June contract. And if you look at the December contract, just 6 months later, it's actually gotten to the point of trading $30 of contango, a $30 premium.
Patrick Ceresna: Wow.
Erik Townsend: Premium for the December of 2020 contract as opposed to the June contract. Now, there's no way that storing that gold just for 6 months costs $30 an ounce. So that's kind of an anomaly that probably is explained by the logistic conditions because of lockdowns and so forth.
But I think it's also a little bit of a signal that when we see this weakness in gold, it got down to Well, the only thing that got down to $1,685 is that contract that's about to expire, and maybe the reason that we've seen weakness in the price is because people don't want to take physical delivery of that contract because of these logistic problems that exist because of the lockdown and so forth. Just a little bit of speculation on my part that I could be off base on that completely, but something's kind of fishy there. with that huge amount of contango.
Postgame: silver, natural gas, iron ore
Erik Townsend: In any case, Patrick, let's move on to silver on page 4. What's this chart telling you?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, on silver, it's really interesting because gold was pushing basically 52-week highs on the upside, but silver was lagging in a big way. When, when it really got slammed back in February, March and sold all the way down to $12, it was basically trading at multi-year lows all over again. And when gold was recovering higher, silver barely retraced 50% of its prior loss. And so the last week or two really saw silver finally trying to catch up. And so silver edged higher and now is approaching that $18 level on the upper boundary where all those highs were from September and, uh, in the early first quarter of the year before the sell-off happened. And so So this is going to be really interesting to see whether silver actually has the gas in the tank to also break to a 52-week high here or not.
And so this is definitely one of those things to watch.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on and look at natural gas prices, Patrick. We've done quite a bit of coverage of crude oil, but we haven't really talked about natural gas. What do you see on this chart on page 5?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's interesting because the nat gas continues to also have a substantial contango in it, and obviously there's seasonality. and different storage issues. And, and a lot of the big storyline of nat gas is really, will, will these different shale producers end up having to, uh, shut down or not? And that will substantially impact, um, the supply-demand of, of, of natural gas, at least the supply side of it. And so, uh, it's interesting that we continue to see a massive lag on nat gas on the downside, never really participating whatsoever on the turn, but it really does seem to have established the lower boundary of this current cycle. I mean, it seems that we've now throughout the year tested this kind of $1.60 level on the downside numerous times. And so it's really interesting to see whether or not this is finally where a short-term low established on natural gas and whether it could actually do something bullish. I mean, I don't want to say anything and get excited about it yet. I mean, there's
no evidence that even the first inning of some sort of bull advance could even be underway, but it usually starts with an extended basing formation, which we can at this moment say is at least forming right now in natural gas.
Erik Townsend: Now, Patrick, a really important commodity is iron ore because it's a proxy for Chinese economic activity. Australia's biggest export is iron ore that goes to China, and China consumes a huge amount of it making steel and so forth. You'd kind of think, boy, it must be, you know, hitting a multi-year bottom right now because of the economic situation in China after the virus. But it looks like, if anything, you know, we're, we're almost on the verge of touching a new high, really, that's almost a 1-year high. What's going on?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, it's, it's very strange what we saw in iron ore, at least not— I don't want to say strange. It's certainly not what I would have expected if you asked me what intuitively I would have thought would have happened to iron ore during this entire economic slowdown. But really, it never sold off during March. In fact, it held up as we approached the latter part of March into April. It went and just retested the bottom end of its lows. And throughout the month of May has now broken to multi-month highs. We're pretty much edging to breaking out a fresh 2020 high on iron ore. And I'm not sure what the supply and demand dynamics are driving it, but certainly this is not the, the type of a chart I would have been expecting when you told me that most of the world was shut down due to this COVID.
Postgame: copper, lumber, uranium
Erik Townsend: Well, let's take a look at another chart, which is a very different chart on page 7, and that's copper. But, you know, it's, it's kind of interesting because in many Copper is a proxy for the real economy. It's a proxy for industrial demand. China uses a whole lot of it. You'd think that, okay, we looked at iron ore, let's look at copper. It'll probably be a very similar chart. Totally, completely different. What do you see in this chart?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is exactly it. Like, iron ore held up very well, but copper took it pretty hard. I mean, we went at the start of the year, we were trading as high as $2.87 And, and then on even on an intraday basis, we're approaching $2 on the bottom end of the range during the very heavy sell-off. So very, very strong selling during the cycle. And really the recovery looks very much like, um, if I— a chart on the emerging markets or something where we had a very heavy sell-off and it's just retracing that very, like, in a reflexive rally, that move on the upside. And So this to me seems far more a reflection of what I actually would've thought we would've seen in the iron ore chart, and we did not. But the interesting part that will be the real tell for me is that copper established some very important lows originally in the summer of 2019. And now the rally is just approaching a retest of that, what it will now be an overhead resistance level.
And I think the real tell on, uh, Dr. Copper in terms of the health of the economy— will, will it be able to behave in a bullish manner and break this out?
Now, I personally am quite bullish copper in the long term, in the bigger picture, but I do think it will be, uh, quite sensitive to this actual economic cycle. And so whether or not copper manages to undo all of the early part of the year selling, or whether it rolls over here, I think is going to be a really important tell that we should not ignore.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, one of the tricks of the trade that housing analysts use is they look to lumber futures as a proxy for demand in residential construction because that's where most of the lumber gets used. What is this lumber chart showing us on page 8?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I was just going to point out that it's— isn't it amazing that the lumber chart actually echoes the copper chart? And therefore, it's the 2 commodities I think that are worth watching to actually really really see whether there is a true V recovery coming in the economy. 'Cause I'm more of the U-shaped recovery kind of in that camp. But yet if we really saw copper and lumber legitimately undo almost all of that selling and recover higher, that may mean that things are a little more optimistic than maybe we're giving them. But right now I think that lumber Copper approaching key levels where where if they were going to reject and let's say head back down to retest those lows, I'm not necessarily forecasting lower lows on either of the two commodities. But but usually if there's going to be an extended recession and prolonged period, then we should go and see a retest of the lows and establish a a core base from which the major lows will or the next major bull market will.
use as a foundation for a rally. And so these are 2 commodities that I think are a must-watch for anyone who's really trying to get a pulse on what's really developing.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, uranium is a commodity that certainly Marin Katusa has emphasized on the program. We've had a couple of other guests mention it, but holy cow, look at this recovery profile. What's the backstory to explain why in this, even during the, the crisis before the recovery really began in the middle of March. You can see a bottom there and just straight up from there. What's going on?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, the prices of uranium, like any— and like Marin was talking about, are actually considerably below their cost to produce. And that— a large part of that was because there was a huge supply, excess supply, that had to be worked through the system. And one of the, um, things that we saw was that with this COVID shutdown, it actually shut down a whole wave of different production of uranium and a lot of the uranium mining projects, which has allowed a lot of that supply now to actually be worked off the system, which means that uranium has to more than likely continue heading to a level where it's actually economic for a lot of these uranium producers to actually produce it, which some argue is in that approaching $40 level. And so the— this rally, while it looks like it's been a big one, it may actually still have a little bit of more meat on the bone, and there might still be some further upside for uranium prices.
Sign-off and Research Roundup
Erik Townsend: And of course, Patrick, these kinds of chart books and little updates on the market is what you do every day at Big Picture Trading. Listeners, as described on page 10, you can sign up for a free trial at bigpicturetrading.com. We're gonna leave it there for today's show. This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com.
Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the In Gold We Trust report that Ronnie provided, as well as this post-game chartbook we finish discussing. You'll also find a link to a great interview with Cullen Roche, as well as a Jeffrey Snider article titled The Optimists Have Some Terrible News for the V. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share If you have a great idea for a podcast episode and you'd like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, From myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com. The internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your device. Your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.