Harley Bassman — inventor of the MOVE Index (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode 225 preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 225 was recorded on June 25th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is dedicated to healthcare workers all around the world, the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis, and is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases.

Harley Bassman, inventor of the MOVE Index, returns as this week's feature interview guest. Harley and I will discuss everything from the recession outlook to the coming shift from deflation to inflation and what it means for fixed income markets, Harley's specialty. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick and I will play a game of breakout or fakeout, looking at gold, the euro, US dollar, Stocks, corn futures, and a bunch of other key financial instruments to discuss which ones are breaking out versus which ones are maybe just showing some fake signs of a breakout.

Coronavirus resurgence, D614G mutation, reopening

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, before we get to the markets, the coronavirus has moved back into the headline. What's going on here?

Erik Townsend: Well, indisputably, there's been a big surge in new infections. There's new cases soaring across the United States and globally. The Houston intensive care capacity has been breached, causing the Houston hospital system to have to activate their overflow plan. Some people are saying second wave is really not the right phrase to describe this because it's really not like a second wave that came, you know, with the fall weather or something. It's really the first wave never really stopped. And as soon as we've tried to reopen things, uh, and we've had all these protests and so forth with less social distancing, predictably there's been a dramatic increase in new infections. So it was easy to see this coming. It's not really news, But, you know, you look at what happened the first time around, the market didn't really want to take the news seriously until it was staring them in the face. So as easy as it was to see this coming, I don't think it's fully discounted in markets.

Patrick, I think the real essential point here goes back to that Hammer and Dance article that we recommended to our listeners a couple of months ago now. It's been— the whole idea of the hammer and the dance is you start with the hammer, which is the lockdown, but then it's a dance. It's a balancing act. The word dance was a metaphor to describe it's not easy to find the right balance of how quickly you can reopen things versus what the effect of that is in terms of bringing on more infections and causing the pandemic to grow in its proportions. It seems like we're trying to dance with combat boots on or something. You know, we're trying to reopen everything very quickly. President Trump, meanwhile, announced this week the solution is less testing. He actually said that we needed to slow down testing because more testing was leading to more infections being detected, making us look bad. And the White House, doing damage control, very promptly said, well, obviously, the president was just joking when he said that.

And then, sure enough, the president doubled down, both on Twitter and in a— I believe it was an NBC News interview— saying, no, I'm dead serious. We have a problem, which is we're doing too much testing, and it's causing an exaggerated number of cases to be detected relative to other countries that are not doing as much testing. Makes us look bad, and in reality, the situation's not as bad as it really is. Actually asking the federal government to start to remove the federal funding for state testing centers in order to try to test less. You know, Patrick, when Dr. Ben Hunt was on the program saying, you know, don't test, don't tell, I thought he was kind of being sarcastic. Well, it seems like it's actually becoming policy now.

Meanwhile, Patrick, the new big headline, and I think you're going to be hearing a lot more about this buzzword, it's called D614G, and that is a reference to a mutation of the coronavirus which has occurred at the 614th position in the genetic sequence. That's where the 614 comes from. And as I understand it, the whatever the amino acid is that starts with a D changed to one that starts with a G. It's just one little amino acid that's part of a long string of amino acids in the RNA sequence which defines the particular virus genetics. That according to— and this is important— according to new data out of China. Well, if there's ever anything you want to take with a grain of salt, it's new data out of China, because needless to say, the Chinese government has been a little bit guilty of massaging its data and sometimes twisting the facts a little bit. So is this propaganda, or is it all completely real?

We don't know that yet. This is not yet peer-reviewed. But what they're saying is this new mutation which the Chinese government is calling the European strain. They're saying it came from Europe, we didn't do it. They're saying it's much more infectious, more deadly, has a much higher case fatality rate according to new data in Chinese research studies which have not yet been peer-reviewed, suggesting that this new strain of coronavirus is more infectious and more deadly than the original strain, which is just being called D614. Now there's Very significant implications to this next point, which is not only is it more infectious, but people who tested positive for antibodies to the original coronavirus, the D614 version, are being reinfected by the D614G version. They're, they're finding that the antibodies do not protect you. The antibodies to the old strain do not protect people who had already experienced this disease. in the, the original strain, that doesn't protect them from getting it again with the second strain.

So in other words, there is no immunity between the 2 strains. That has very significant implications on the efficacy of any vaccine that might be developed. And I think if we zoom out to the, the big picture, you know, let's just assume all of this new data from China might be real, might be propaganda. We don't know yet. That, that research and scrutiny still needs to occur in the scientific community.

But if I step way back out, Patrick, you know, so many people are just assuming that a vaccine within a year is a given. It's really not a given. There's never been a successful coronavirus vaccine in human beings. Needless to say, we've got a lot more incentive to come up with one this time. But I'm gonna give it a 50/50. I think it is equally possible we could have a vaccine or we could go through a 5-year period of a slow development of herd immunity around the world. During which time we would still have, you know, what we're seeing right now, which is this dance continues for several more years while we don't have a vaccine. And basically we have to temper fully reopening the economy against exacerbating the pandemic. So this thing, you know, I think what we're seeing in society is people are done with it. They want it to be over. It could be that this is just getting started in terms of how long this story is going to affect the global economy.

Now, of course, I hope that that's a pessimistic view and that we end up with a vaccine that's ready in 3 months and solves the whole problem for everybody. But if we don't, you know, this could take a lot longer than is being priced into markets.

Now, having said all of that, Patrick, I want to be clear. I am not predicting that we go back to a new total shutdown where we lock down the economy. I think what's very clear now is a lot of people are very angry that the first lockdown happened. And regardless of whether those people are right or wrong, doesn't really matter. The point is there's lots of them, and there's a strong public sentiment against further lockdowns. People want to reopen the economy, and my prediction is we will reopen the economy, whether that involves a lot of public health risk or not. We're going to do it anyway. So now the question is how much public health risk and how much of an imposition that creates in terms of people making voluntary choices not to travel, not to vacation, not to travel internationally, and so forth, and how much that affects the global economy.

The economic analysis is much harder this time around because the first time around you knew what was going to happen. They're going to shut everything down. It's going to result in a sudden stop in the economics. This time it's much more complex. We don't know how much is going to be shut down, how long it's going to stay shut down, and what voluntary choices people are going to make. To my own surprise, Patrick, my own vacation rental on the coast of Maine I thought was going to be a total write-off for this season was sold out as of the beginning of the season before the virus.

And sure enough, we had almost everyone cancel, and then new bookings have replaced them, and we're booked solid again for the rest of the summer, at least out until the 1st of September. So it seems like there's at least part of society that wants urgently to get out and travel and spend money and go back to the old normal as quickly as they can. As soon as things are unlocked, let's go. On the other hand, I think there's probably other people that are more conservative that are going to stay home. It's going to take a long time to figure out what the real economic impact is going to be.

S&P 500 range and stimulus expectations

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that S&P 500. Well, in the last 24 hours, we saw some selling, but when you kind of zoom out on the chart, we've more or less been in an incredibly tight range for well over a week and almost 2 weeks going on this chop back and forth. Which way do you think it's going to break here?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I could see this going either way, and we're going to get into more detail on the possibilities in the postgame. But briefly, I see more resilience than weakness in this chart. Look at what's happened in the last couple of weeks. We've had more and more news flow confirming what I predicted, which is, you know, there has been an increase in coronavirus cases. There's a lot of reason for concern. And although there's been some selling, it really— you know, we're not dropping off a cliff or anything. I think that the market is expecting more stimulus, and those stimulus expectations are keeping things elevated. So no real change in, in my view. I, I think that as much as I'm not at all optimistic about the economic fundamentals, I think the market may just be held up by stimulus expectations and might even move back to new all-time highs.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index. We similarly had a bit of a breakdown at the start of the week. Much of it's been recovered. We're still below the 98 handle. What's your thinking here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, at least we're stabilizing here around the 97 handle on the September contract. You know, more coronavirus crisis, which clearly we're seeing, should be dollar bullish. But on the other hand, more stimulus as a result of that from the Fed should be dollar bearish. But if there's more stimulus from other central banks debasing their currencies, that should be dollar bullish. So, you know, which way is that all going to play out? I think it depends a lot on the news flow and, you know, who stimulates first between the central banks. I don't really have a strong view here.

Crude oil: rollover, targets, inventories

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to oil because oil at this stage had at least a reversal off of that $40 level. And we're now sitting around $38.86 on the August contract. What's your thinking here on crude?

Erik Townsend: Well, as I've been saying for the last couple of weeks, I told our listeners, watch for this rally to peak somewhere between $41 and $42 as that gap on the chart gets filled in. $41.66 was the peak. So that's just about exactly consistent with what we expected. Then it rolled over exactly as I predicted. The thing is, that was the easy part. The question is, rolled over to go down how far?

There's an argument, Patrick, that this could already be over. You know, what we saw was a very sudden sell-off over the last couple of days taking out the short-term moving averages. That set a target for the 21-day moving average. We traded below it on an intraday basis, so we fulfilled that target, but closed above it, which would suggest there's— at least for the immediate time frame— there is no further downside expectation. Until we get a close below 37.80 or so, which is the 21-day moving average on the continuation chart. And we're back up to just barely above the 13-day moving average at 38.71. If we can get a daily close above 39.57, which is the 5-day moving average, that would suggest that the uptrend has resumed. So it is possible this is over. That's not my base case. I think we've got further down to go. I'm just not sure how far. 100-day moving average is the next obvious target.

That's 36.03. If we get a close below that number, then the next target is probably down around to 33.50 or so. And I think to go much lower than that, it would take some nasty news flow. The thing is, I think we might have some nasty news flow in the works with respect to the coronavirus crisis. So, you know, as far as how far down it could go, I don't think you go below 26. So 26 to 30 might be, if the virus fears really kick up, where the target range is, but I don't think you go below $26 unless you get a return of storage crisis fears, another expectation that we're going to run out of storage and there's going to be no place to put the oil. Now that sounds— it seems like it's not going to happen because without a doubt the market has been pricing expectations that the storage crisis is all over and behind us.

But let's look at inventory. Crude oil building 1.4 million barrels plus another 2 million barrels that went into the SPR. And even though that's the government's SPR, what's being put there is commercial storage. The government's leasing it out to commercial interests. So really, the net build of commercial storage was 3.4 million barrels. That's a pretty big build, and it takes us to a new all-time high in US crude oil inventory. So, you know, this storage crisis is not necessarily over yet, although the market is definitely not pricing any expectation of running out of space. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 991,000 barrels, which says to me the industry heavies are still focusing on getting as much oil out of Cushing and into the SPR as they can to make more spare capacity at Cushing because it's running out in Cushing specifically that resulted in that blowup or breakdown, I guess you should say, of the May contract as it was expiring.

They don't want to let that happen again and they're trying to free up more storage space in Cushing. Gasoline drawing down 1.7 million barrels. Distillates building about a quarter million barrels, 249,000 barrels. US production back up to 11 million barrels. Now, it was down 600,000 barrels to 10.5 million last week. Looks like maybe that was an anomaly in the data because we're back up to 11 million, which is only 100,000 less than it was 2 weeks ago. Market reaction to the inventory data was an acceleration of a sell-off that was already in progress.

I also did an All-Stars interview with Anas Alhajji on Monday. Be sure to check that out on your MacroVoices feed for more color on what's going on and what to expect longer term in the oil market.

Gold nearing $1,800 breakout

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because yesterday we came within a stone's throw of $1,800. A little bit of backing up off of that price today, but what's your take here on gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, as I've been saying for the last few weeks, it's been looking more and more like that base that we're seeing forming at $1,700, maybe on an intraday basis is going to hold. And I think I, I, I said last week or the week before, the thing to watch for is we've been testing the bottom end of that range. Are we going to test the top end of that range? Well, sure enough, now we're testing the top end of that range. In fact, yesterday we broke out to a new 5-year high on an intraday basis but didn't close up there. We, we, you know, poked above it, played around a little bit, and back down. As we're speaking now on Thursday afternoon, we're sitting right about on the 5-day moving average at 1770. Now still, it looks to me, feels to me, like we're maybe on the verge of a breakout to the upside from this consolidation range. It hasn't happened yet, so we don't really have the buy signal yet, but it looks to me like we could be on the cusp of it.

I won't be at all surprised if it happens, and if it does happen, the way I see the chart, Patrick— I'd be curious to get your reaction because you're the, the better technician here. But it seems to me like the $1,922, the previous all-time high, is probably the next target if we get a breakout, say, north of $1,800.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, I think when we put up the chart on gold in the postgame was one of the charts we're going to have that very conversation as to whether it is a breakout and what would— you can even talk about where the next targets are. But for certain, when you're talking about all-time highs, like you were saying at the $1,922, that's always a target for most investors once a breakout occurs. So I think you're right about that one.

10-year Treasury yield and why Bassman was invited

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's touch on that 10-year Treasury yield.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, no real change to my view. I don't have any opinion up or down short-term. What I'm focusing on is the long-term picture, which is, is the almost 40-year bond bull market coming to an end or isn't it? And are we moving from deflation to inflation? And if so, what does it mean for the bond market? As far as the short-term outlook, I don't have a view, Patrick. Do you?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I continue to see that the path of least resistance is that the yields are heading lower, and this continues to be the big canary in the coal mine in my view in terms of a risk-off cycle. I mean, will we see the breakdown here in the 10-year Treasury yields, and is that something that is much more important on a broader intermarket basis? And that's certainly something that I continue to watch. Nonetheless, this week's feature interview guest is fixed income guru Harley Bassman. Now, He is the inventor of the MOVE Index, which is basically the VIX for the bond market. So, Erik, why did we invite Harley back as a guest this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I said, the reason I don't have a view on the short-term outlook for Treasury yields is I think we've really got to figure out the big long-term picture of what's going on with inflation to deflation and so forth. And I'm trying to get more guests on the program that are big picture macro thinkers who have a specialty in fixed income, who really understand the bond market. How could you ask for a better guy than the man who invented the MOVE Index, the Convexity Maven, as he's known in the industry? So Harley is a real pro when it comes to understanding the, the bond market, and he's got a very long-term macro perspective. So I wanted to get him on so that we could ask these questions that are leaving me with nothing to say every week when we get to 10-year Treasury yields. Meanwhile, folks, I also want to remind you, we really need your help.

If you can rate and review us on iTunes, Apple Podcasts, it'll get us back up to our deserved rating that we used to have as the best investment podcast on the network. We've fallen off of Apple's radar because we haven't had enough reviews. The instructions for how to post a review are linked in your Research Roundup email, or you can just go on iTunes and click on ratings and reviews.

Erik Townsend: Give us a 5-star review. It'll really help us out. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com.

In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out TopTradersUnplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Harley Bassman is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Bassman: the inverted curve and the 2020 recession call

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Harley Bassman, best known as the inventor of the MOVE Index, which is essentially the VIX for the bond market, and now known as Convexity Maven and publisher of convexitymaven.com. Harley prepared a terrific slide deck to accompany today's interview. Listeners, I strongly encourage you to download it as we'll be referring to those slides throughout the interview. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, Just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads. Harley, I want to start with a call that you made way back in November of 2018, in which you reiterated in May 2019, and you said, look, there is an economic recession coming at the beginning of 2020. Now, obviously, you didn't know that the COVID-19 pandemic was coming. Do you think that the recession is something that happened as a result of COVID-19, or do you think that COVID-19 team was just the catalyst that lit the fuse, so to speak, for something else that was already bound to happen.

Because, of course, the President of the United States told us we had a perfect economy right up until the virus hit.

Harley Bassman: Erik, thank you for inviting me back to your show, the best financial podcast in the market. So, I'll tell you, this kind of lines up with the 2 thoughts I always put up on the front of my website, which is number one, it's always about character. Character matters, and it's paramount. And number two is it's never different this time.

And when you saw the yield curve start to begin to invert, and so on slide one, that's the FRED database showing you know Fed funds versus the curve. But more important, slide number two, which where the funds rate was above the five-year five-year forward rate, the inversion was coming, and the yield curve has been the best predictor. of a recession.

And what always happens— I'm not sure always is the right word, but what usually happens is they kind of come out of nowhere. You never see these things coming. And people always say, what's the next surprise going to be? Which is kind of like jumbo shrimp. I mean, you can't see a surprise. It wouldn't be a surprise if that was the case. So do I see this? Of course not. I think I wrote multiple times, I have no idea how we're going to go into a recession. But the curve is there. Somehow, the market seems to anticipate this, and there we go. I suppose it was the match, I guess, but in general, these things always seem to occur in some fashion where something finally pushes the market and the economy over.

Demographics, labor force growth and immigration

Erik Townsend: Harley, we recently had Dr. Lacy Hunt on the show, and one of the things that he told us was that the population is declining, and that's one of the reasons that he thinks that unless there was a major change to the Federal Reserve Act, we're probably looking at deflation for the foreseeable future. I see on slide 3, you're not really showing a declining labor force or population. What's going on here?

Harley Bassman: Well, Dr. Hunt probably is one of the best economists in the market. He's been dead right for my entire career, calling the bond market to keep rallying. So, I highly recommend reading him as well as Gerard Minack, and that'll be another slide I have of his. I think what he's pointing to over here, is the concept that GDP, at the end of the day, is labor force, number of people, times hours worked, times productivity. That's GDP in a nutshell.

Productivity really hasn't altered that much in the last decade, despite the introduction of better technology. Hours worked, we're at the top of where we're going to be on that. The real difference is going to be the labor force. While he is, and many observers are right that Western democracies are having a declining population growth, what's happening in the US is the baby boomers are retiring right now, but soon we will deplete them. We're about halfway through the boomer demographic, and the millennials are coming on in.

What's happening is there's an inflection, and I've been writing about this for, oh God, 5 to 8 years now, an inflection coming 2023 to 2025, somewhere in there, where the Millennials are entering the workforce at a faster rate than the boomers are declining.

If you look at this chart on page 3, you can see that Dr. Hunt is right, you do have a declining overall population growth rate, but the makeup of it is altering. As these millennials come in, that's what's going to go and create demand for goods and services. This chart actually follows very closely. If you look at some of my past commentaries, on my website, you'll see I've noted that you should see that this labor force growth rate aligns very well with interest rates and inflation. I also note that, which is a current topic about immigrants, that I think immigration is going to be a gigantic impact, and that immigration is probably the most worrisome aspect that I have going forward in the next 5 to 10 years. I thought it might be tax policy. I thought it might be Buybacks, maybe trade policy, but immigration is probably it because we've had a very strong immigrant growth over the last, you know, forever.

And if we were to go choke that off, as we're trying to come out of this recession over here, that could be very problematic, because that will choke off your labor force growth rate, which would not be pleasant.

Stock-bond correlation and risk parity

Erik Townsend: Harley, our regular listeners know one of the topics that I've been most concerned about in the last year or so is the possibility of the historical correlation between stocks and bonds funds changing in a way that might force the unwind of the entire risk parity trade, which is probably the biggest trend in institutional finance. You've got a chart on page 4 from Gerard Minack at Minack Advisors.

What is this chart telling us? How do we interpret what's on this page in terms of giving us some insight as to whether or not that concern of mine may be well-founded or not?

Harley Bassman: You're exactly right. And as a macro concept, you got to tie together the entire notion of labor force growth rate with interest rates and inflation, which then bleeds into this chart over here. And the whole thing comes together in the next 2, 3, 5 years. And we should all be concerned about this. This is the big macro concept that I believe in. And so the correlation between stocks and bonds generally has been inverse.

One goes up, the other goes down. Risk parity has been the brilliant strategy for the last decade, because a portfolio, let's say a 60/40 portfolio, will balance itself out. Stocks go up, bonds go down, and vice versa. If we were to get inflation above 2.5% in the chart here on page 4, or let's say 10-year rates above 3.5%, above 4%, because you have real growth plus inflation gives you, in theory, the 10-year rate, You're probably going to see this correlation flip back to what it was in prior times, where stocks and bonds go up and down together.

This is going to be very problematic because so many people have blended portfolios, but what's really going to be the issue is the risk-parity types who use leverage, because stocks are more volatile than bonds. People will often say, you have $100 of capital, of assets, of money, And then you buy, let's say, $130 of bonds and $70 of stocks, so you now have $200 total of investments supported by $100 of equity capital. If they both go down together, well, now you got a problem, and you have to liquefy. That's what you saw in March, when both stocks and bonds went down together for a small amount of time. That's where you had the most volatility, because they were not acting as a hedge, but they're acting together.

So, I foresee this happening, but it's not happening until 2023 to 2025. That's what's going to happen because the labor force growth rate is going to turn up, and you're going to get the inflation. As a reminder, the last time we had this huge labor force growth rate was in the late '70s, early '80s, when, haha, that's when the boomers were turning 30, 35. At that age, what do you do?

Erik Townsend: You retire.

Harley Bassman: You get married, you have kids, you buy a house, you buy a car, a washing machine, and everything else. And all this demand is greater than the supply available from the previous generation. So the World War II generation, which was smaller, that correlates very well with interest rates and inflation. So that's the cycle that I'm looking for. It all fits together. So you're right, but you're early. It's not happening till 2025. At least 3 more years from now.

Positioning: credit, convexity and mortgage REITs

Erik Townsend: Okay, Harley, great. Let's translate that characterization that you just made of my being right but early, that we're headed toward a secular shift toward inflation and a different correlation between bonds and stocks. What does that mean in terms of right now with respect to portfolio positioning? Do you stay long-duration risk and, you know, continue to wait for a little bit more of the deflation trend to to bring bond yields down even more before you start figuring out how to reposition? Or is this something where it's hard to gauge the timing?

And, you know, boy, it's, it's been 40 good years of— or almost 40 good years of bond bull market. Is it time maybe to not worry about catching those last few percent and start to reposition a portfolio now, just in case I turn out not to be as early as we hoped?

Harley Bassman: I think you're leading me, the horse to water here, to the idea of negative rates, because that's what you would require to get a lot more upside in interest rate products. I'll say upfront, the answer is no to that. We're not having negative rates in the US. I guess in theory, it's possible, but no. It's just the way we're structured.

Frankly, the idea hasn't worked even where it's been tried. We're a financial economy, to disintermediate the banks, in such a way would be disastrous. Do I think you should be selling rates here? No. I mean, I wouldn't be buying 30-year bonds at $1.50, but I think that we're not going to have a huge rise in rates. What I would recommend instead is into other risks, such as convexity or credit, high-grade credit.

The reason why I like that is if you go to page 5, this over here, a couple of my favorite charts, is the relationship between the yield curve. The yield curve is the measure between the 2-year rate, the 10-year rate, 3-month rate, and the 5-year rate, whatever it might be, some measure of the slope of the curve, which indicates people's concern about the market and inflation.

The other line is going to be implied volatility. What you see happening here is when the curve flattens, volatility comes down. I think with the Fed holding rates low and steady for a while. The dot plot said they're holding the funds rate at basically zero for the next 30 months.

That means that volatility should come down. You've already seen it in the bond market, where you've seen the 10-year rates move, what, 20 basis points for the last few months? That's going to go and reduce volatility, not risk per se, but actually realized volatility, which is more important. I think that's going to make a number of investment instruments Interesting. Mortgage REITs, I happen to favor those, not REITs where you're actually buying the properties. I'm talking about the levered REITs where they buy secured mortgages, usually Fannie and Freddie, but it can be Alt-A or non-agency.

I like those a lot because I think it's going to be not that hard to hedge them, and they yield an awful lot in a 1% environment.

I think that if you look at page 6, what I'm showing here is the mortgage, the rate on mortgage bonds. So if you go buy a Fannie or a Freddie mortgage bond, there's no credit risk whatsoever to those. They're guaranteed by the government. And you look at that versus the 10-year swap rate, you can see that we're kind of about average right now.

You see the big jump we had. We're on page 6. The big jump we had when the financial crisis hit. But how it quickly came back once the Fed said, okay, we'll buy these bonds. We're average there. If you look at page 7, you could see how there's room for this spread to come in even further relative to volatility. That's why I like that asset class.

I think the Fed's goal is multiple, which I think we'll get into the inflation part soon, but they want to reduce volatility, they want to reduce risk, they want to bring risk-taking into the market, the idea of starting a new business or expanding a business you already have. That's the idea of holding rates low and holding them steady. 2 different concepts.

One of them is your cost of capital. The other is the risk that you're going to be wrong. By reducing volatility, they reduce the risk of uncertainty in the future. In theory, that should go make you willing to take more risk in starting or expanding a business. They're not wrong in the macro sense, but I mean, zero is kind of a tough number to use.

Fed junk-bond buying and spread trades

Erik Townsend: Here's where I get nervous about any kind of spread trade in fixed income markets, Harley, is, you know, we've got what I'll call policy risk, which is you could have made a really good argument a few months ago for, boy, look at what's going to happen economically, you know, the, the high yield spread above Treasuries has got to blow out.

Well, that would make sense if you were reading the Federal Reserve Act the way it's written, which is to say it's illegal for the Fed to buy junk bonds. But the Fed came up with its own interpretation of the Federal Reserve Act that it actually is okay for them to buy junk bonds as long as they play some little game with the Treasury of supposedly being an intermediary, that— which in my opinion was designed intentionally to undermine the intention of the Federal Reserve So, if you got the government changing their own rules kind of willy-nilly without warning, how do you bet on spreads between different interest rate products when you never know what kind of policy or legal interpretation might be coming next?

Harley Bassman: I think it depends upon if you're looking at the price of the asset or look at the underlying fundamentals of it. I think that buying junk bonds is ill-considered. For so many reasons. One of them being that it disrupts the signaling process. That's so important in a capitalist system is to have the market, free markets, where prices signal what might happen and get people to prepare for risk, to hedge properly, to be prepared for what might happen and not be over their skis, and thus really hurt if things go south.

Usually, when a bond goes below a certain price, that'll qualify as a I don't want to say junk bond, but something to be concerned about. When you see a stock with a very high dividend yield that's much higher than its peers, that's usually a signal there's a problem with the company. The Fed's covering that now, which I think is a bad idea.

On the other hand, high-grade corporate bonds, high-grade mortgages, those are basically probably fundamentally economically sound. Then you're looking at the concept of where does the Fed set the rate? If they've set the risk-free market rate at a at zero, and they said it's going to be here for 2.5 years, more or less, you could be more comfortable switching to that. Maybe I'd rather buy a 5-year corporate bond than a 30-year Treasury bond. I'm saying you should be altering your portfolio to take advantage of the fact that the Fed's going to hold rates down for a while, and they're going to reduce volatility, because a corporate bond or a mortgage bond The extra yield you're getting over a Treasury is effectively an option. The price of an option is driven by its implied volatility, and if that's going to come down, that asset should do better.

That's the concept there.

Secular inflation, timing and gold

Erik Townsend: Harley, let's tie all of these concepts together and relate them to a subject that I've discussed with quite a few of our guests, and I know you're a regular listener to the show, so you're aware of all this. Are we headed for a secular shift Not just to a little bit of inflation, but to secular inflation? And if so, how long does that take to play out? What does it look like? What's the transition look like? How do we get from here to there?

Harley Bassman: Well, I'm not a gold bug, but I like the concept because we're going to get inflation. The question is when. It's almost a religious belief in the sense, do you believe that you could print fiat currency at will, or at least at rates faster than the growth of the economy without inflation? I think no, that can't happen. The thing is the timing, it could take many, many years for it to bleed on through. We're going to have inflation. The question is, when will it occur? What will drive it? Once again, back to the idea of the match lighting a fire.

When's it going to happen? 2023 to 2027, somewhere in there. Going back to Dr. Hunt and talking about money printing, and he's a deflationist, at least temporarily, He's right in the concept the Fed is printing money. I know guys say they're not printing money, they're doing something else, but money is fungible. If it goes into the system, it moves around. You can't hide it.

The money's been printed. We've had inflation. It's just not CPI inflation. It's asset inflation, you know, with gold, with stocks, with bonds, with art, with jewelry. We've had huge inflation. Now, of course, this is a The massive problem we've had in society is that the inflation went to the 1% who have own assets as opposed to the others. The idea was to create inflation, which would eventually extinguish debt.

I mean, the way you get out of a debt problem is you default or inflate. And inflation is just a slow-motion default. So the notion 10 years ago that Bernanke had of creating inflation to reduce debt was right. It didn't work because the inflation went to the wrong place. We need to create inflation for wages for the middle class. Dr. Hunt is right in the idea that creating money will not create the inflation per se, because that money is not being spent. It's not going into the economy. It's just sitting in bank accounts.

When the 1% get money, they save so much more of it than the rest of society does. The question is, how do you get that money to go into spending. That is where you are going to need to have either fiscal spending to get the money into the hands of ordinary people, and I think that is going to happen hand in glove with this demographic change of the millennials becoming spenders. That is where it is going to come. I think MMT, it is preposterous. That is all I can say. It is a preposterous idea.

The thing is, it does not happen right away. It could take quite a while for this to change. Being a reserve currency, where we have almost 2/3 of all global trade going through the US dollar, there is no Plan B. In that sense, we have a Wile E. Coyote moment for quite a while, but it is going to come.

Going back to your investing question, you do not short bonds today, but I think you have time to prepare yourself for when it is going to come. Inflation initially will be good, and then it will not be. That's where I am on this thing. It's coming. What's the best way to hedge it?

Less clear, but I think real assets of some kind is what you want to own in a portfolio. I think owning gold, 5% to 10%, is not irrational. Remember, gold is not an asset. It's not like a stock or a bond. Warren Buffett dissed it a decade ago as a barbarous relic, and you could buy so many Exxons and all the US farmland with it. He's right about that, but it's not an asset. It's an alternate currency.

And currencies, cash in the— I mean, cash in your hand yields zero and gold yields zero. So, uh, that's what it is. It's a currency that can't be printed by other governments. So that's why you want to own it as a diversification.

Inflation, velocity and the bond market

Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit more about inflation and the bond market, because there's an old adage that inflation is a bond market's worst enemy. But I want to go a little bit deeper into that. Is it really true that inflation causes bond markets to sell off, or is it the expected monetary policy response that the central banks are going to fight inflation by raising policy rates which really causes bond markets to sell off? And the reason I ask that is it seems to me that when we get inflation that might cause you or me to think, boy, this could turn into a problem, policymakers ought to be fighting this I think they're going to continue encouraging it for a while after you and I think that's the bad move.

So, when do we worry about the bond market really selling off? Is it when the inflation starts or not until the central bank policy reaction is to try to fight it with raising policy rates?

Harley Bassman: Away from speculators, I would say you're wrong on both counts.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Harley Bassman: All apologies, please. I think the driving— what is money all about? Money is about delayed spending. You work, you make X dollars, and if you don't spend it all today, you delay it and you spend it at a different point of your life. So you have your savings for that. That's why you have cash. We're not in a barter economy anymore. I think what's going to drive bond prices is people looking at this delayed spending power and saying, how many loaves of bread can I buy with it? Oh my God, what if I could buy fewer loaves of bread? in X number of years, that's a bad idea. So you either spend now, and that gets the velocity back up again, or you get out of things that are fixed coupon, like a bond, and go somewhere else. So I think the dynamic of the investing class as a whole, all people moving money around to other things that will protect their savings, protect their spending power, protect their purchasing power, protect the number of loaves of bread they could buy in the future, I think that's what drives it.

You'll probably see spending pulled forward. Remember, GDP also equals money times velocity. The money has exploded with all the Western central banks, the velocity has collapsed in tandem, so we've had very little change in GDP. Once we get that velocity of money picking up, linking back, that'll happen when the millennials come into the workforce, start spending, that's when you get the inflation.

So I see that, that, that, that's how it's gonna occur. And the Fed is, is, is pushing on a string in the sense that they're pushing money into the economy, into the, into the Fed system, but it's not making people spend money. I think the spending's gonna occur with the demographic as well as with the fear of inflation eroding their savings.

So, I mean, that, that's kind of what you had like in Weimar Germany, which we're not gonna do, but people were trying to spend the money as fast as they could get it. You see that in Venezuela or Nigeria, the same idea where people spend money as fast as they could get it because the value depreciates so quickly. That's where it's going to happen. It all comes together at a point.

We're not there yet, but there's an inflection point coming. That's what you want to be thinking about and watching for. I think Fed has been saying over and over again now, time for fiscal policy. What's interesting is both parties, lined up to go and spend money directly to the population via various methods. My preferred method would be infrastructure products, so at least you get something out of the cash being spent, but direct funds to people, UBI or other tax rebates, either of those is basically the government borrowing money printed from the Fed and giving it to people whose propensity to save is very small.

I think that's where it's going to be coming from. I think that's when you're going to see rates start to rise, not because people are selling them per se, but they're not buying them while the government is continuing to borrow.

It's really a question of how long can the Fed keep buying securities? Looking at Japan, and the answer is an awful long time. Of course, the difference is Japan has a very different demographic than we do. Theirs is declining on all aspects, whereas ours is not. We are different than Japan in that respect.

Bullish on stocks: dividend futures and yield

Erik Townsend: Harley, what do we do in terms of portfolio allocation as this transition you're describing comes? You mentioned real assets and you mentioned gold. What other real assets? Are we looking at real estate? You know, things like real estate investment trusts were very popular decades ago. They've kind of been out of vogue for a few decades. Is that going to be the next big thing, or where should people be thinking about starting to reposition their, their portfolios?

Harley Bassman: Mortgage REITs. where the entity is buying mortgages on assets. I like that, especially when the credit is solid. Other kinds of property REITs, I have no interest in. I have no idea what commercial real estate is going to be doing for the next decade. That's a black hole I'm going to avoid.

Truth be told, what I like is— I'm careful when I'm saying this— I actually think I'm bullish on stocks right now. Stocks are actually a claim on a real asset, a company making a profit, making a business, making money.

If you look at the current structure of the market, the Fed has said, we are keeping rates at 0 or 0.1 for the next 30 months. At least that is what the dot plots say. They are probably going to keep the cash 10-year at below 1%. They have to. Is that yield curve control? Will they come out and say it explicitly, or will they just go and buy the bonds to make it happen? Unclear, but it probably does that also. If you look at the S&P, I mean, the trailing dividend yield of the S&P is about 2%. If you use the dividend futures market, which is a better idea. So let's go to slide 9.

This is on Bloomberg, and they trade futures on dividends. They trade it on S&P, on the European SX5E, on the Japanese Nikkei. It's not the most liquid instrument in the world, but they exist. You can see over here that the futures on the S&P indicate an annual dividend of about $50 going out to 2025.

If you look at slide 10, that is the near contract, and you can see that it was trading in the 60s, and then it dropped down to 40, and now it is about 52. These contracts were trading in the 60s at the beginning of the year. If you look at that $51, $52 dividend divided by 1.5%, you get the Dow, the S&P up to like 3,000.

Is owning a claim on the top companies in the country, not talking small, middle-sized businesses that are definitely going to get hurt right now, talking the largest companies in the country, owning a claim on their business, You could earn a yield of 1.5%, maybe 1.65% right now, with $51 of dividends.

You could earn that, and you have upside. Your stocks can go up. 30-year Treasuries go to par. 10-year Treasury now yields 0.6%, 0.65%. It's going to par. You could actually own a claim on a real asset, Get a higher yield, cash flow yield than owning Treasuries, and you have upside. As a matter of fact, it's better than that. It's actually a convex upside because stocks only go down to zero, but they can go up 1, 2, 3, 4 times. Look at from the '09 crash, we had the S&Ps at what, 650, 660? Now it's 3,000.

You could make a lot more than you can lose. I'm not saying it's going to happen, but there's the potential for it. You can get the same yield as a Treasury, and you have more upside.

It seems to me that over the course of time, insurance companies and other kinds of long-term liability managers are going to have to go to equity. They give up nothing in the cash flow coupon, and they have more upside. Most insurance companies, their cost of business is a lot more than 1.5%. I see this underlying support over time bleeding into the equity market, which seems incredible to me, but I'm actually— I'd rather be long than short, that's for sure. There's some very interesting trades you could do to take advantage of that. If you want to talk about that now.

The SPY call and put trade structure

Erik Townsend: Let's do exactly that, Harley. For our listeners' benefit, if you look here, we've been talking about the graph on page 9 and 10, but 11 and 12 and 13 provide some more charts showing the other dividend markets, not just the S&P, but also the SX5E and so forth.

Let's move on to page 14. You've got a specific trade idea here. Talk us through it.

Harley Bassman: I'm a macro investor. My concepts are 2, 3, 5 years in the future. I don't day trade. I rarely pick specific names. I like macro thoughts and what's going to happen in the big picture. And I size it appropriately to go and manage that risk.

What's the wrong price right now? What's the wrong price right now is interest rates at zero. That's clearly the wrong price. And if the Fed was not buying everything and holding rates down there, they'd be higher. If that's the wrong price, then what happens is if you look in the forward space out 2, 3, 5 years in the future, since all derivatives instruments price off of forward pricing, where an asset will be cash flow adjusted in the future. What's happening right now is the S&P, the Nikkei, SX5E, their forward, their future price is actually below the current price, which means if you do an option trade based upon those instruments, the market will look at the forward and not the spot price.

And so if you look at slide 13, you can see how the forward SPX price is actually below its current price. And then going back to slide 11, you can see how this relationship has changed over time with Fed action and ECB action.

So looking at a listed trade, and this is when the S&P was at 3,000, so the SPY ETF was at 300. The forward price— now I'm on page 14— forward price was 285 roughly. I could buy a call struck at 340, which is the old high, sell a put struck at 230, actually taking a small credit. Let's call it flat once you put in the bid offers.

I own the upside above the all-time high, and I own the stock market at 230, 2.5 years forward. This trade expires in December of 2022. I have a hard time believing that we're going to get below 230. I guess it's possible. We did that before a little bit. But if you think about that, if you put a PE of 16.75, so the inverse of that means that the earnings coming out of the S&P would yield 6%, 1 divided by 16.75.

If I compare that to the 10-year or the 30-year, that's like 500 basis points over a Treasury. So I'm getting a pretty good yield from the earnings, and then my dividend is above what they're kicking out. So it seems to me that that low is probably pretty good, unless you're a super bear, you think we're going into a massive recession, depression, and earnings are going to absolutely collapse. Because earnings last year, was 163, and the dividends paid last year was 58.

If you go put any number on these things, I could see 4,000 on the SPOOs in 2 years, which is utterly crazy. I cannot believe I am saying this, but if the Fed is going to hold rates at zero on the front end and 1% in the belly, I just do not see how money does not migrate there.

If you really think about it, this is a very sexy idea because an equity, a stock, is actually a call option on the company where the strike price is the value of the bonds. Because if you liquidate a company, you pay the bondholders first, what's left goes to the stockholder.

You have that leveraged upside on equity versus a bond, which all you get back is your principal. If the If an equity of a stock is a call option on a company, a real asset, a real company, and you're buying a call option via this structure, you're buying a call on a call.

It's a very levered way to express a thought, a lot of convexity, a lot of positive leverage in your pocket. This is an idea that I like a lot as a way to go take advantage of the Fed forcing the forward price down because of that 0% interest rate.

It's risky. Let's be clear. If we go below 230, you hold the downside. As a profile, I like having this trade, and then supporting that with mid-grade, mid-expiry fixed income products, 5-year high-grade, maybe some munis, some mortgage REITs. So you balance them out that way. That's my preferred portfolio, and then you toss in some gold.

If you have yields on some of these high-grade corporate bonds at 3% and change, some of the mortgage REITs are at 8%, 9%, 10%. Munis, they yield 2% and change, but if you're in a good tax bracket, then you're talking at 4%, 4.5%. That's not that bad. for a portfolio structure.

Risk management: why take equity exposure

Erik Townsend: I'm actually surprised, Harley, to hear you say 4,000 by the end of '22 is a crazy high number. I wouldn't have said that at all. Now, I certainly don't think that economic fundamentals are going to get us to those levels, but I have confidence in central bankers to get us to those levels, as long as nothing blows up first. So I think it, you know, the upside is very clear. But let's talk about the risk side of it. What if things do blow up?

up. And you do have to start thinking about below 2,300 on the S&P. How do you run the risk management on this trade? At what point do you start to bail out and eat a loss before you ride this all the way down?

Harley Bassman: I'm making the assumption that if you're a hedge fund manager running a levered portfolio, I'm not saying it was the best trade in the world, because this is a It's not an alpha trade. It's an alpha trade in the sense it's a better way to gain exposure to equities than just straight buying them outright.

I mean, you could do easy analysis on that showing why I'd rather have this than owning the straight-up futures or the ETF SPY. But if you're not willing to own equity risk outright as a proportion of your portfolio, this is the wrong ticket for you. But I suspect everyone's going to have some kind of of SPOOs exposure in some manner, fashion, or form.

You basically substitute owning this ETF or some other portfolio, and you put this instead in there. If you own equities outright, you already have some stop loss or thought in mind that you are running, but usually, you have no stop loss. You have a certain amount of portfolio allocated to this sector of the market. That is what it is. That is my thought on this. You buy enough of this, So it's impactful if you're right, and you can survive the drawdowns if you're wrong.

But the Fed's already said whatever it takes. Are they going to buy equities? I sure hope not. But we've already seen Europe and Japan go down this path. So if push came to shove, I mean, the Fed will do whatever it takes to go and do this. So I think— I'm not saying it's a Fed put per se, but it sure looks like there's something there.

Once again, you're not buying the whole economy, you're buying the top 500 companies. Frankly, you're buying the top 100 companies. I think they're going to do okay, because they have a population that is going to buy their products. I think you got to think about that. That's something else. Right now, the top 5 companies, 6 companies are 20% of the S&P 500.

You're buying The best companies out there right now, or at least the most valuable.

I view this trade not as pure speculation, but as a better way to gain exposure to an asset class you would already own. Then going back away from mom-and-pop investors, I just don't see how insurance companies or pensions, I don't see how they have this cash flow coming in, how it keeps going into only bonds.

The cost of— most pension funds, state pensions run 6.5% to 7.5% as their bogey. Buying Treasuries at 1.5%, 1%, they're locking in a loss at that stage of the game. I think you have to see a migration into those assets over time. If you put a— the dividend futures were trading at 65, Last year, the actual dividends were 58 last year. Let's call it 60 is going to be where it's going to be 3 years from now. You put in a 60 div, you put in a 1.5% yield on that 60, that's $4,000 on the S&P.

Will dividends be cut dramatically from here? Well, perhaps, but I think for the best companies, they're not going to be. What you might well see is money that was going to buybacks or other forms of spending might go to support their dividend. So there's plenty of room to go and, and support them for the best companies out there.

Position sizing and the Convexity Maven website

Erik Townsend: Harley, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Now, you're one of the few guys that we have on the show who's not selling anything. So we have no product for you to promote. But please do tell our listeners, you have a completely free website, convexitymaven.com. It's also possible to subscribe to a newsletter there. That you put out from time to time. What is that about? What can people expect? And where can they sign up?

Harley Bassman: The website is convexitymaven.com. If you want to get added to it, you can send me an email to harley@bassman.net. Happy to respond to your comments. I always learn a lot from people who know more than I do. And I, I write episodically. I think the key thing to note is that, you know, I'm a macro thinker. I am a long-term investor. I'm not a day trader. And that sizing is more important than entry level. You're not going to go call top or the bottom. You've got to allocate your portfolio accordingly that you can ride out the risk, because surprises always happen. That's why they're called surprises.

Erik Townsend: Size matters. And you heard it first from Harley Bassman. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction and chartbook setup

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Harley back on the show. You know, while he— you— we call him the Convexity Maven for his knowledge on bonds, he's also so smart when it comes to options and options trading. I just absolutely loved his ideas on On the S&P 500.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I know exactly what you mean because as soon as we finished taping that interview, he hit me and said, uh, I got a couple suggestions for you to pass on to Patrick. And he's going off around the theta decay of the gamma X-ray negative whatever. And I'm like, um, I think you should talk to Patrick directly about that one. So maybe we should get him back onto the Postgame in a future episode so that you guys can go heavy on the Option Greeks, and, and I'll try to keep up. But in any event, let's go ahead for today's show and take our listeners to this week's post-game chart book. It's called Breakouts or Fakeouts. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, click on the red button that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, Breakouts or Fakeouts, starting on page 2 here. with the euro against the US dollar.

What's going on?

Euro versus dollar: breakout or fakeout

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what I wanted to focus on was just bring a whole bunch of charts to our listeners' attention, just some really interesting things that are happening in the markets and setting up. And I think they're really important to watch as to whether they emerge as new major trends or whether or not this is just noise. And so I figured we'd play a game of breakout or fake out and see what we think on all of these. So on chart 2 is arguably the most important one because we always talk about the US dollar index, but the US dollar index, more than 50% of it is weighted against the euro. And so really, as goes the euro, goes the dollar index. And one of the big questions everyone asks today is, are we entering a period where the US dollar is going to enter some sort of a bear market and begin a sustained decline? That that will impact inflation and commodities and all sorts of other areas.

And what I thought was really interesting is when you go and zoom out and look at like the last 5+ years of the euro, and we overlay on a weekly chart the volume by price showing where— what price levels very large amounts of the volume has transacted, one can see we're slowly approaching the top of this band.

This is a big trade range between like 108 to 114. And while we've certainly had 2 very meaningful spikes higher in the euro this year, the real big question to solve is that, is this setting up for a big breakout? Are we about to see that US dollar breakdown and the euro breakout here? And watching whether this plays out, you know, that breakout above that 114, 115 is probably one of the single biggest intermarket macro events if it does play out. And that's definitely what I'm watching. My intuition is it doesn't happen, but if it does, we can't ignore it, right? What's your take on the euro?

Erik Townsend: I agree with you, Patrick. My intuition is it doesn't happen. I think we might have already seen the top there. Maybe we'll test the top of that range one more time, but I don't think we see a full breakout. Something like a daily close over 1.06 would really say to me, oopsie, we got that one wrong. If that's the case, I'd really be watching for the bottom to fall out on the dollar index because the euro makes up, you know, the biggest portion of it. But my gut feeling is that you're right, that it's probably done here and that we're gonna see the dollar strengthen. The reason that would change that view would be if the Fed gets into another round of stimulus and recession.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: In response to more bad coronavirus news, if the Fed responds with even more stimulus reaction, that could be what pushes us up out of this trading range, and maybe it starts to run away from there.

Commodity index, corn and grains

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to page 3, where I just wanted to look at the commodity complex broadly. And this is the Bloomberg Commodity Index futures. While we'll look at some individual commodities in a moment, what I thought was particularly is, is that commodities have not really started to rise in any meaningful way on a broad basis.

And this to me is one of the areas to watch whether or not the inflation boogeyman is really going to come out and we see sustained rising inflation expectations. You would think that broader rises in commodities would be accompanying that. And rather than seeing, you know, sustained gained higher highs, higher lows, and a clean uptrend. This has not been able to really get off the mat, and in fact it almost feels like it's rolling over. And so is this going to be a fresh new breakdown in the commodity index, or is this just more of a bottoming formation where this is gonna maybe retest some of these bottom ranges and turn up? And I really do actually think a lot of this will be linked with what happens with that euro-US dollar chart as well. And watching whether this breaks down in any meaningful way is, is really important.

Do you have a perspective as to whether you think this is going to break down?

Erik Townsend: Well, I would say the same thing that you just said. I agree with you on the US dollar to euro correlation, but I also think that inflation expectations are really where it's at. You listen to a lot of our smartest guests, they're all saying, look, It's definitely coming, but you know what? It's still a couple of years off. And what this chart kind of says to me on page 3 is, okay, we're having the little inflation scare here, and maybe we're going to go down to a new bottom, or, you know, a slightly lower low, or just stay in a consolidation pattern. Maybe what we're seeing is that low from back at the end of March versus the high that we hit in early June. Maybe that forms the The upper and lower bounds of a consolidation range, and we just consolidate for the next year or 2 before inflation expectations really start to take off and drive commodities higher.

Now, if you look at this chart on page 3, that one tiny little red candle below the blue line there doesn't really— it's only one itsy-bitsy little candle. It's just barely below the line. It doesn't say much. But if you move on to page 4, It's just one particular commodity instead of the whole index. But boy, if that's a leading indicator in what corn's doing, you know, you've got the same basic picture, but that breakdown is much more pronounced. So maybe that's an indication of things to come for commodities more broadly.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. Let's say we're— when we pull up oil charts, of course, oil and gasoline and everything have been moving relatively higher. But when you really look at the grains as an aggregate, like whether you're looking at wheat, which been pretty weak. Soybean hasn't been able to really get anything going, nor have— there was actually some crazy price action in rice futures. And really corn here, very distinct break on the downside. It's just in this segment of commodities, this is— there's nothing happening right now. They all look like they're rolling over, very weak, and it doesn't seem like there's an imminent bid coming in here. And so to me, these look like they're breaking down. And, you know, it's, it's— to me, they look like, uh, the early stages of the breakdown a month ago on natural gas. And it's just sometimes these commodities break on the downside and they can't seem, uh, to get any bids and they just bleed out. Anyway, I— this corn chart looks pretty weak.

Lumber futures

Patrick Ceresna: Nonetheless, I wanted to move on to the one commodity where there is some really interesting strength, and that's on page 5 And that's on the lumber futures. And, you know, it's interesting because when you look at a lot of the housing stocks and even some of the other homebuilder components, things like Home Depot or Lowe's, they all seem to actually be behaving like there's some sort of a new bull market. That's— it's certainly where there is relative strength. And over the last week, these lumber futures really started to move to the upside. It's going to be one of the really interesting things to see whether or not this bumps its head along these highs from February or whether this is a legitimate turn, because the lumber prices actually had much higher prices when you look back a year or two. And so the question here is, this just going to be a tap into this previous high or is this a real breakout?

That's one of the big questions to solve.

Gold breakout and 1,922 / 2,000 targets

Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to gold on page number 6, because As you're showing here, you know, there is one downsloping trend line that we've broken through, but if you thought about this as a horizontal consolidation pattern, we really haven't seen a breakout yet. How do you read this one? I mean, it looks like the way you've drawn it here, you're kind of showing the breakout version as opposed to the fake-out version. Does that mean you're expecting that, or is that just one way of drawing the line?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, at this moment, whenever you have a breakout, often the better thing to do is to to give the bulls the benefit of the doubt that they'll make it stick. I mean, I think at this stage, they're clearly attempting to take gold to the next level. And obviously, we were talking about that 1922 previous high, but there is that measured move that measures all the way to 2000. And so if this breakout sticks, there is plenty of upside on gold, especially after spending 2 months consolidating.

So that kind of unwinds the overbought state from that advance back in March and April. And so it really can slingshot higher. And so watching this over the next week to see whether this breakout is actually for real is going to be huge. It's one of those ones that has been— we've been waiting to see if it breaks out and it's attempting to do it. So that's on my radar.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more. If we see the price of gold move above $1,785 off the top of my head and stay there for several days, it really suggests that the next move higher is upon us. And as you say, that next move could be substantially higher. And, you know, as much as I, I want to say, well, keep in mind, folks, you know, we are overdue here for a steep technical correction— I've been saying that for months— this consolidation sideways here has been going on since the beginning of April. So, you know, we're, we're already into almost 3 months months of consolidation. A breakout, a decisive breakout above the consolidation kind of invalidates that expectation of a lower number. And I'm tempted to say, well, a stock market crash because of the coronavirus could pull it down. Well, the thing is, look at the stock market. It's not crashing. If anything, it seems to be expecting more stimulus as a result of the coronavirus to carry the market higher.

So I think the odds are on a move higher from here.

Silver, platinum and palladium

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, on page 7, I want to move on to the, the palladium futures. And what was interesting here is because we showed the chart on gold. And one of the things I would always like to see is to see a number of the precious metals all confirming this. And in the particular order, silver made it all the way back up towards its previous high and is kind of flagging for a potential breakout. And platinum has tried to get off of the worst levels but is not— is a little bit weaker than silver.

And then there's palladium here, and palladium seems to actually be actively distributed. Almost every rally seems to be sold, and it continues to, to just show signs of potentially breaking down. And I don't know, maybe we have some listeners that are more in line with understanding what's going on in these precious metals markets, but I find it, uh, at least I would have really liked to have seen all of them kind of behaving in a much more bullish manner to confirm gold. And maybe that's a warning, you know, we'll have to watch. But, uh, it certainly looks here that like palladium is breaking down. What's your take?

Erik Townsend: I think that silver is the important confirmation signal for gold, and we are seeing signs of silver echoing the, the bullish patterns that we're seeing in gold. So I think you got your confirmation there. Platinum and palladium futures, honestly, there's a lot of fundamentals that have to do with automotive applications and so forth that I don't fully understand it. It's not my area of expertise, so I don't really know what's going on here. I'm sure we probably have listeners who could tell us exactly what the cause is of this. But as far as looking for a confirmation signal to validate the gold chart, I think silver is giving you a pretty strong message.

High-yield bonds and the Fed backstop

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to page 8 where I just wanted to revisit these high-yield bonds or junk bonds. And, uh, we've obviously had a very strong recovery off of those March lows when the Fed gave indication that they would consider buying some of these ETFs to provide the liquidity to keep a stable bond market. But after seeing this initial strength in April, really junk bonds have not been able to make much higher highs, and they're not really gaining any momentum. In fact, they're losing momentum, almost like if they're slightly rolling over. I wouldn't call this a breakdown yet, but certainly they've stopped participating on the upside and have been lagging. So the question here, do we finally see this rollover in junk bonds? Do they break to a lower low? Do we see that this area of the market starts to show weakness?

This is definitely something that's on my radar to watch.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think that certainly if you were long junk bonds, getting out of them would would make a lot of sense. As far as shorting them, though, I still wouldn't dare. And the reason is we've seen the Fed clearly signal that they intend to support the junk bond market. So I think if you saw a crash in junk bonds, and I do see plenty of economic fundamentals to support exactly that, I don't think the Fed would let it get very far before they intervened again.

S&P 500: tug of war

Patrick Ceresna: All right. And finally, on page 9, just the S&P 500, right? And This is obviously that I'm a little bit bearish, and deep inside there's a bear tucked away. And I was looking to see whether this S&P rolls over in some, some meaningful way. But often when you had such a big advance in the markets, there's going to be a period of correction where it backfills the rally, consolidates, and then uses that base to begin a new advance. And I think one of the more interesting pieces to solve here is that, is this just the market taking a breather and backfilling some of that previous rise before it has a continuation, or was this it? Has the bear market rally really kind of played out, and is the market now rolling over? It's one of the more interesting things to observe which one of these play out.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I see this one purely as a tug of war between economic fundamentals, which definitely call for lower equity prices because it is a bear market rally and there's lots of economic reasons to expect much lower equity prices according to old normal rules. The other side of the tug of war is we've got the new normal where central bank accommodation plays a bigger role than economic fundamentals in stock prices, and that would support the, the case for higher stock prices, maybe even new all-time highs.

So far, as much as it frazzles me, it seems like the central bank accommodation side is winning the tug of war over economic fundamentals. Now, do you make the argument that, well, the economic fundamentals have to win in the end, or is it just the ability of the Fed to conjure unlimited amounts of money out of thin air that wins in the end, as seems to be the case? I don't want to bet either way, frankly. From what I see here. But where you can find a sure bet, folks, is a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading. Take a look at page 10 where you'll find all the information you need to get a free 14-day trial to

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Patrick's service. We're going to leave it there for this week's episode. Please do help us out by rating and reviewing us on iTunes. Again, the instructions step by step for how to do that are in your Research Roundup email.

This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to both the chartbook Harley Bassman shared and the charts we discussed here in the post-game, as well as a link to the Chris Martenson video going into detail detail on the D614G mutation of the coronavirus. You're also going to find a link to the video interview with Nouriel Roubini on Bloomberg, as well as an interesting article by Jesse Felder on the biggest disconnect between prices and profit in stock market history. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup.

That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow us on our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com. If you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.

MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna. Shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Art Berman — Petroleum geologist (as introduced on the show)

Show open

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 224 was recorded on June 18th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is dedicated to healthcare workers around the world, the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis, and is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases.

It's time for another MacroVoices crude oil special. Petroleum geologist Art Berman headlines as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from US production dynamics to the price outlook. Then our own Patrick Ceresna will expand the conversation in our postgame segment with a chart deck exploring energy equities, natural gas, and other energy markets.

S&P 500: Grantham, Druckenmiller and the bubble question

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into that S&P 500. We're just a day away from quad, witching S&P 500 more or less bounced off of its worst levels and is trading sideways more or less around the 3,100 level on the index. What's your take on all of it at these levels?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I was very interested to see Jeremy Grantham on an interview this week calling this bubble the real McCoy, implying that, you know, we're really at the end of the story here. You know, Patrick, Jeremy Grantham is another guy that I would really love to interview because the pattern I'm seeing here is some of the true legendary investors like Stan Druckenmiller and now Jeremy Grantham are calling this bubble, saying, okay, this has got to be it. These valuations are insane in the face of a global pandemic that we haven't really even got our heads around yet. There's a lot of reason to expect a global recession. These equity valuations—

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: don't make sense.

And, you know, these are our really, really famous legends in the market. The thing is, Patrick, I think we've got 2 possibilities. One is we're in the final innings of the biggest bubble perhaps in financial history. Or the other possibility is we've entered a new normal where central banks are just going to keep propping asset markets up over and over again until eventually someday the whole system blows up. Now, if you think that's the new paradigm that we're in, We're still quite a ways away from the whole system blowing up.

I don't think we're at that stage yet. So are we at the point where we're really coming to the end of this? What I would love to ask both Stan Druckenmiller and Jeremy Grantham is, okay, by all reasonable measures, you know, this is crazy, but it's been crazy for a few years and it's kept on going. So why should we believe that the old rules are going to apply in this new era that we seem to be in of central bank intervention seemingly having much more importance to asset prices than economic fundamentals. I'd love to ask those guys that kind of question. So I hope to get that opportunity someday.

US Dollar Index

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to the US Dollar Index because we were incredibly oversold. There was a substantial drop and that seemed to have bottomed last week. And we've more or less been doing a reflexive rally higher. We're slowly edging toward 98, but not there yet. Is this just a bounce in your mind or is this a meaningful turn in the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, all we've seen so far is a reflexive rally off of an oversold condition. Maybe it's just a dead cat bounce and we're headed lower. Maybe it's an actual recovery. I think the measures of that, if we can get back to $99, which was the major support level previously, is that going to become a hard resistance level or are we going to get back above it? A daily close over $99 would suggest to me that this was a panic reaction to the breakout of civil unrest in the United States, driving the dollar lower and maybe now it's coming back out of the market. On the other hand, if we saw a daily close below 94.50, that would suggest to me that, okay, this was just a dead cat bounce and the weakness is now accelerating in the dollar. So I could see it going either way, but given that it seems like we're on the, the cusp of a second wave of the COVID-19 crisis really starting to hit the tape, my bet is on a strengthening dollar and weakness in asset prices in the near term.

Crude oil: inventories, SPR leasing and US production

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil, which is a special for today. We are trading on the July contracts just under $39 at this moment. What's your take on crude here?

Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, that's the big topic for the day, so I'm gonna leave a lot of it for the feature interview with Art Berman. But let's start with inventory. Since we taped the interview with Art Berman earlier this week, it was before the inventory data came out.

Analysts were expecting a drawdown on crude oil inventories. Instead, we got a build of 1.2 million barrels nationally. Now, that's in addition to a 1.7 million barrel build on the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. I've had a couple of listener questions saying, you know, Erik, why, why are you emphasizing the Strategic Petroleum Reserve? The whole idea of the crude oil build is it's a build on commercial inventory. Well, the thing is, the game has changed. The oil that's going into the SPR now is not the government buying oil. It's the government leasing the SPR as a storage facility to commercial interests. So even though that oil is not being counted as commercial inventory, it really is commercial inventory. And if you make that correction for the SPR build of 1.7 million barrels, now you've got a net effective commercial build of 2.9 million barrels. Pretty significant build.

Now, of course, builds on inventory are normally bearish, and in this case, we got a build to what turns out to be a new all-time record high on US storage. So why is that not super bearish? Well, the reason is because in the finished products where we've had really big builds on inventory for the last weeks, we're finally seeing drawdowns on the finished product side. 1.7 million barrels on gasoline, distillates also 1.4 million barrels. Meanwhile, Cushing, Oklahoma is still drawing down 2.6 million barrels this week. I think a lot of that oil is going out of Cushing, finding its way into the SPR. The really big news that was particularly bullish for prices though was not the inventory levels but the US production And that's the production figure just crashing by 600,000 barrels, more than half a million barrels in a single week, all the way down to 10.5 million barrels.

Now, that's from a previous high of 13.2 million barrels. So we're almost 3 million barrels below the high, and I think we're going to get to that 3 million barrels below pretty soon. This is the big kind of drop in US production that I had actually expected a few weeks ago. My guess is it really did start a few weeks ago, and the numbers in the official reported data are just catching up to something that's already happened. Tape action in reaction to the inventory report was for the most part entirely bullish, moving a quick pop upside, then a little bit of retracement, then eventually a struggling climb back to higher prices.

So short term, I think probably where we're headed now is toward the fill of that gap on the chart, which is at $41.05 on the continuation chart and $41.88 on the contract chart. So somewhere between $41 and $42 is where I'm guessing this rally is going to top out. I think there's probably a pretty strong argument for a pullback there. But the real question is what happens after that? What's the long-term outlook? The key to that is understanding US production dynamics. How much oil has already been taken offline? How much more is going to be taken offline? And particularly, How easy would it be for all of that idle production to be turned back on? Can they just flip a switch and turn it back on and go back to 13 million barrels, or is that not possible? Well, needless to say, Art Berman is the man to answer those questions, so we'll save those topics for the feature interview.

Gold: the $1,700 base

Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to gold. And, uh, you know, after that extraordinary rally at the late part of March into early April where we broke to fresh highs and gold just ripped higher, the last 2 months basically has been this big sideways consolidation where gold just doesn't want to commit lower or higher, and, and we're coiling up here. What's, what's your take? Is, is this finally going to resolve itself in the next couple weeks with a breakout?

Erik Townsend: I think it probably will, and I think it could go either direction. But my prior conviction, which was really leaning toward a downside correction, because I was saying, folks, we're overdue for a technical correction— well, as you know, Patrick, as a technician, when you're overdue for a correction, that can resolve either by price movement or by time. And what we've seen is This really long horizontal consolidation. We're putting in a really good base here at $1,700. Now, it seems like every time we test that $1,700 base, I get my hopes up. I keep hoping for lower numbers 'cause I wanna buy even more gold on the cheap. But $1,700 has really been holding pretty well. Actually, we get down to $1,680 or so intraday, but by the close at the end of the day, $1,700's been holding really well.

So if that base continues to hold, it seems to me like the technical argument starts to move more and more in favor of an upside resolution, the longer that base is in place. The longer the base, the higher in space.

10-year yields as a canary

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's get to those 10-year Treasury yields.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, there's really been no change in my view, which is to say, I don't have a view on the short-term technicals. I've been focusing on the long-term question that I've been asking most of our feature interview guests, which is, are we headed for a secular shift from deflation to inflation? And if so, what does it mean for the bond market? So I'm kind of focused on that. I know you guys at Big Picture Trading do a lot of work on these short-term technicals. So what are you seeing in the chart?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I, I really thought it was interesting what we saw at the start of June where we saw those yields skyrocketing from this, you know, when it passed 70 basis points and was— it looked like 1% was just right in reach. And then the market just gave it all back. And what I find fascinating about this is that we're trading more or less right at the bottom end of that range that was established right the bottoms back in March all the way till now.

And one of the things that what I've noticed from an intermarket perspective is that the bond market in the past has often led the way of the equity markets, including, for instance, we saw yields starting to decline back in January of 2020, just a month before the stock market started to really move. And so the fact that the yields are working their way lower has got my attention. I don't want to say that I'm forecasting something by it right now, But I'll tell you, if we continue to see, in spite of the fact that rising crude oil, which tends to be very inflationary in its nature, if we see yields continuing to erode and 10-year bonds continue to do very well, it may be a canary in the coal mine that something is going to turn in the equity markets. And so I think this is something you don't take your eyes off in the coming weeks.

Erik Townsend: Well, I agree with that, Patrick. And, you know, if you think about what we're seeing in the dollar index starting to turn up, you know, it all sort of follows a pattern. As you say, of maybe we're at the cusp of another wave down in equities driven by what should have been obvious, because it frankly has been obvious, which is the second wave of the coronavirus crisis is upon us. And you look at how the first wave went, you know, we had Italy starting to go absolutely crazy and, and even Spain starting to go crazy, but it hadn't started in the United States yet, so everybody just ignore it and pretend there's no problem.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: I think if you go back and look at those charts, we were getting clues in the dollar and in bond yields before the move really happened in the stock market. So I think you're onto something there.

Why Art Berman: can shut-in shale be switched back on?

Patrick Ceresna: That's right. Anyway, so this week's featured interview guest is petroleum geologist Art Berman. So Erik, why did we invite Art back as a guest this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's because out of pure selfish interest, I can't wait to talk to Art to get some perspective on the mechanics of the physical market. Because frankly, I read a lot of research from a lot of I read a lot of big-name crude oil people, and, you know, a lot of these financial crude oil analysts are guys like me who think they know about this stuff, but they don't actually work in oil fields. They're not the hands-on guys like Art who actually drills oil wells for a living. And I read one guy who says, you know, look, there's a whole bunch of wells that have been shut in and plugged with concrete plugs that would have to be drilled through. There's no way to easily turn them back on. There's a huge cost associated with restarting wells that have been shut down.

Then I read other analysts who say, look, the latest technology that's used in shale drilling, really, it's a couple of taps on an iPad or an iPhone screen to restart some submersible pumps. Those wells can be restarted as easily and also be shut in in just a few taps on a touchpad screen. It's simple. It's trivial. It doesn't cost anything at all. So which is it? Who's right? And more importantly, all of this idle production, can it easily be turned back on? Can we get back to 13 million barrels a day of US production if we want to?

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: we need to, or are there serious hurdles in the way? It's been really hard for me to figure that out reading the Wall Street version of the crude oil market experts. So I wanted to talk to Art and find out how this stuff really works. But Patrick, before we dive into the feature interview with Art, I want to ask a favor of our listeners.

We've fallen completely off of the radar screen for Apple Podcasts and iTunes. We used to be the top investing podcast out there, and now we've gone to being nobodies. And frankly, this is just because The other podcasts are asking their listeners to rate and review them on Apple Podcasts or iTunes. So please help us out. Write us that 5-star review that'll help get us back to our status of being one of the top, if not the top, investment podcasts. All you have to do is open Podcasts in the iTunes Store, find MacroVoices. You can just type it into the search box, then click on Ratings and Reviews where you can give us 5 stars and

Erik Townsend: write a review. It's that simple. You'll also find these instructions in your Research Roundup email.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades.

To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following.

The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out TopTradersUnplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Art is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Art Berman interview: six failed oil rallies since 2018

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is petroleum geologist Art Berman. Art, I am so looking forward to this one. We're overdue to have you on the program. Welcome back.

Art Berman: Thanks, Erik. Good to be back.

Erik Townsend: I gotta tell you, Art, I have become convinced that most of the analysts in the oil and gas space are guys like me who are fascinated with oil and gas but have never been to an oil field in our lives and don't really know what the hell we're talking about when it comes to the actual mechanics of drilling oil wells and production and then how all of this stuff really works at the physical level. Now, what I can tell you, what I do feel very confident that I understand, is although I don't think it's going to happen as soon as a lot of people are assuming, at some point, you know, we're going to have a recovery. We're going to need to resume producing US oil as much as we can.

And I, I just get so many different analyst interpretations, and I think some of them are very misinformed. Some people are saying, look, you know, we were at 13.2 million barrels of US production. We have that capability. We got to push a few buttons, throw a few switches. We can turn it right back on and we're right back there. Other people are saying, no, there's aspects of the way this whole supply destruction event as a result of the coronavirus has gone down.

Art Berman: Right.

Erik Townsend: That it's gonna be hard to ever get back to those levels. And frankly, I don't think that a lot of people who are outside of the physical oil patch really know what they're talking about. Now, Art, as a petroleum geologist, you actually drill oil wells for a living.

So what I'm hoping to get out of this conversation is a much better understanding of how much oil production was taken offline in the US, how much of it is really still offline, because I'm hearing a lot of reports that a lot of it's getting turned back on already.

Art Berman: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Despite the fact that we are, by some measures, running out of storage. And I want to get to an understanding of, are we really able to just ramp things back up to where they were, or are there challenges that are going to make that really difficult?

So you and I talked about this off the air, and in your usual form, because you're very good at doing this for your consulting clients, you pulled together a slide deck to address all of these issues. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage and MacroVoices.com. Look for the red button that says looking for the downloads. Art, let's go ahead and dive right in here on page 2. You're showing us what's going on with the OPEC+ production cut and the spring rally. Talk us through the slide deck.

Art Berman: Yeah, Erik, I mean, the important thing about the slide deck is, is to understand that the price rally that we are, I think, pretty much done with is one of 6 price rallies that the market has been through since the middle of 2018, and every one of them has failed for the same reason, and that is that there's fundamentally too much oil in the system. The only reason that, that price ever goes up is because OPEC+ has been consistently cutting production since the end of 2016. And so, uh, they're keeping it within, you know, some kind of artificially maintained limit at which price can rise.

But the market really knows there's a ton of oil sitting out there. So the latest rally was really just, you know, when you're at zero, there's only one way to go. And so basically everybody was short in the market And it had to come back to some level that was much, much higher than zero, which it did. And then the market realized apparently late, you know, like late last week, oh my goodness, things are not really any different than they were before. We got coronavirus, we got too much oil, and so now prices are adjusting downward. That's that's the essence of slide.

Time spreads, storage, SPR and unaccounted-for oil

Erik Townsend: Art, I want to ask you about the time spreads on the WTI curve. We're looking here on slide 2 at a flat price rally. But the other thing that's not shown here is the time spreads, the difference between the July and the August contract. You know, when we were at the bottom there at $37.63, the May to June contract expiration, we were, you know, we got to $60 of price difference from one contract to the next, which was an all-time record.

Art Berman: Right.

Erik Townsend: There were sustained periods of weeks at a time when we were at $5 or $6 of price difference between one contract and the very next contract one month later. Now, that price differential is a proxy for the cost of storage. The thing is, and it's, it's inverse, as the, as the time spread goes down, it means that the cost of storage is going up. Right. Just as prices have rallied, time spreads have rallied to the point where right now, as we're speaking on Monday morning, the July to August WTI crude oil time spread is about 29 cents of contango.

That's typical of a fairly normal, regular market as you come into expiry for one of these time spreads. You know, 30 cents of contango, that is not an exceptional condition. But just last week We had an EIA report that said we just hit an all-time record on US storage levels. So if the, the time spread is a measure or a proxy for the cost of storage, how is it possible that we're seemingly, you know, we're using up more storage than we've ever used up before? The price was reflecting a huge premium for fear of running out. Seems like not only is there no fear of running out, but what the prices are telling us is the market is expecting that storage level to be drawn down dramatically very soon.

Art Berman: Is that—

Erik Townsend: am I interpreting that right? Is that what's happening? And why is it happening?

Art Berman: Yeah, it's, it's a mystery, Erik, because it is true that, you know, that we have avoided, you know, the tank-top crisis that many analysts thought was inevitable. I, I certainly didn't rule out that it could have happened, but I was, you know, I'm kind of a pragmatist and I say, well, um, has this ever happened before? The answer is no, it never happened before. Why didn't it happen before? Because market forces took care of it for us. I don't believe the market is always right, but the market is always ruthless, and negative $37 on Futures prices, I think, sent the signal home loud and clear. And so production was cut. The crisis was averted temporarily. Why does the market think that there's just no problem going forward, which you know is your point? And the answer is, I I think it has to do with the fact that Cushing inventories are going down. Never mind the fact that Gulf Coast is. Going up correspondingly.

But to my way of thinking, there are, there are 2 very important factors that are going on that nobody's talking about very much. The first is Strategic Petroleum Reserve. So the federal government opened up certain volumes of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve to people to lease and, and put their crude in. And there's no way to know this, but I think that a lot of the, a lot of the crude oil at Cushing is going into various salt caverns and, and whatnot of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. So that's bringing down Cushing storage volumes overall. You know, we're at like 80% of U.S. capacity, which isn't great, but it's not terrible.

The other thing, and this is much more obscure, I believe, and that is this whole business of unaccounted-for oil. And so unaccounted-for oil is simply produced oil that isn't entering into the flow, isn't entering into pipelines, isn't entering into storage. And so where is it going? And the answer is no one knows for sure, but I'm pretty confident that it's being stored in tanks on leases, which are considerable. I mean, that, that those facilities have expanded tremendously since 2015, 2016. So what we've been seeing consistently every week for the last 7 weeks is negative unaccounted-for oil, which means that oil is being produced but it's not going on to the market. That is a complete reversal of the trend for basically almost the last 3 years, where every week about 3, 3.5 million barrels are entering the market that are supposedly unaccounted for, meaning they were produced in some previous period.

Now the opposite is happening. So between the volumes that are going into the SPR and the volumes that are produced but being withheld on leases, if that's the correct interpretation, we've got a fairly substantial volume. So So there's kind of a choke, if you will, on storage building up. How far can that go? Well, you know, the Department of Energy is going to, at some point fairly soon, have to tell people, okay, we're going to make some more space available in SPR, or we might revisit the crisis. Who knows?

Shale restarts, stripper wells and decline rates

Erik Townsend: Art, there's a really important issue that I want to make sure we really get into because frankly, I'm convinced a lot of finance guys don't understand The perception in a lot of finance circles about oil is this. Look, we had 13.2 million barrels of US production before the crisis started. Now we're down to 11 million barrels per day of total US output. And the reason, or I should say the perceived reason on Wall Street, is because a bunch of these shale operators were forced to shut in wells.

Art Berman: Right.

Erik Townsend: About 2 million barrels per day worth of production. They turned a bunch of switches off and left them off. The perception is those oil wells that were shut in are still shut in. That's the reason that we're down to 11 point whatever it is million barrels per day. And the assumption I think a lot of people are making is those switches could be turned back on and we could be back up to 13 million barrels if we just turned those oil wells that were shut in and turned them back on.

Tell me what's wrong with that story.

Art Berman: Well, like most stories, Erik, there's some truth to it or it wouldn't stick, right? So here's the problem. Shale tight oil is a little bit more than 50% of US production. So what about the other 45%, which is obviously nearly half? So, you know, we're ignoring whatever happens to the other half.

And, and that turns out to be important because the other half are conventional wells. And all of the Wall Street assumptions about, you know, what does it take to kill— that's the, the very technical oil field term— to kill a conventional well are most— mostly true. So it's, it's not a trivial exercise. It's, you know, easy enough to do, but, you know, you, you're doing something which can be reversed, but But certainly not with the flip of a switch.

And so the question then becomes how much of that production will come back on. So several, you know, let's just say for round numbers, let's say a million barrels or 3 quarters of a million barrels a day is what is called stripper production. Okay, those are wells that produce very small volumes of oil every day and probably a lot of water.

And so the problem there is, is that at current oil prices, even though they're way above zero, they're still not at $35 or whatever we're at at WTI at the moment. Those wells are still not commercial. And the little operators that play with those, they just don't have the deep pockets to be, you know, unplugging and plugging and, you know, going back and forth as the market goes up and down. So Initially, that's all EIA was measuring were stripper wells going offline. So that's that's one little parcel of of reality.

The second is the shale wells, and the shale wells are different because they produce from fractures because they're you know they're more recently drilled. They're higher volume. They have higher pressure, and the truth is. That for all of the potential problems that could have emerged from shutting them in and leaving them shut in for a long time, most of those wells are back online. So that shut-in for shale wells, you know, was maybe a week or two. Prices came back up enough that operators, you know, the, the storage crisis apparently went away.

Almost all of those shale wells are back online.

So what will the effect be on production? Well, it's going to go back up. It's definitely going to go back up. I don't think it's going to go to 13 million barrels a day, but I think it's going to go to, you know, it's going to go north of 11 for sure. It's going to go up into the 11 to 12 range over probably June and July.

Erik Townsend: So we basically had one month of constrained production that was really a matter of Okay, but the point that I think is not so obvious to a lot of people is the shale wells that were turned off. There's not spare capacity to turn them back on because they've already been turned on. They're already running. And the stripper wells that were turned off are probably staying off. It sounds like it's not going to be economical anytime soon to turn those things on. So the ability of the infrastructure to keep the oil flowing to respond hypothetically if demand were to recover just suddenly overnight, which I do not predict. I don't think that's coming for at least 6 months longer than most people are assuming. But when it does happen, it's going to happen quickly. The ability of the industry to just, you know, push a few buttons and ramp back up to 13 million barrels, you're saying that ain't happening?

Art Berman: That ain't happening. So let's take a look quickly at slide number 6. Slide number 6 shows horizontal tight oil wells in the Permian Basin. And I, you know, I could have, I could have bored everybody with 3 or 4 slides, but this is the biggest volume. So let's, let's just look at it. And, and what I'm showing here is by year of first production, what the decline rates of each one of those, you know, 2018, 2019, 2020, group of wells is. And so this is what happens if you don't drill any more wells. And there's a table which people can refer to.

There are 2 key points I want everyone to take away. The first is that these shale wells decline at about 30% a year on average. Permian is 27%, and Bakken and Eagle Ford are a little higher. So it averages out at about about 30%. So if you don't drill any more wells, then tight oil production goes down 30% in the first year.

And if you look at the second column, which is the annual decline rate, what you see is that in general, the decline rates of the more recently drilled wells are higher than they were in the past. So for instance, 2018, those wells are declining at almost 50%. A year.

So what does that mean? Well, that means that for all the wonders of technology and, you know, more proppant and more frac stages and longer laterals and all of that, the wells are not finding bigger reserves. They're producing them more quickly. So we get bigger rates and we're getting higher decline rates. And so the good news is we have a lot of oil available to us in the short term, The bad news is it goes away quickly. So, you know, that's a real important takeaway. So that's the scenario if we don't drill any more wells.

Erik Townsend: Art, let me interrupt you there because I want to ask a question about these decline rates. Clearly, these things, if they're producing, you know, okay, so you drilled a well in 2016, you know, after the first year, 21% or whatever the number is, the production has gone down. Now, let's suppose that I've got an expected decline rate of 30% per year. Now, I shut the well in because of the coronavirus crisis, and I leave it shut in for a year. When I turn it back on a year later, does that mean it's producing at 30% less because that annual decline rate is still, you know, happening because of some geologic thing that's going on underneath the ground? Or is that, no, no, no, you know, you paused it, so you go back to right where you were, you didn't lose anything because no oil was coming out of the ground during that period, so no decline occurred.

How does it work?

Art Berman: It's the second one, Erik. Now, we can argue about, I mean, if you actually have it shut in for a year, are there complications that could arise that would cause it not to come back right away or without some remediation? So if you If you park your car in the garage for a year and don't use it, and then you say, okay, let's go start it up, you know, maybe it'll start right up, or, you know, you may actually have to replace the battery, or, you know, you may even have to tow it into the shop because, you know, it needs something else.

So to make it simple, the great likelihood is that most of those wells, with some remediation, you know, taking it into the shop or getting a new battery as the analog goes. Most of those wells can be recovered, but the answer is that when you shut in any kind of well— it's not a shale well— it doesn't keep declining.

The decline is depletion. It's the result of producing more oil and gas and reducing the pressure. It's a pressure phenomenon. So if you shut the well in, you're not extracting any more oil Well, in fact, the pressure is going to build up because it's capped. And so when you first unload or uncap that well, the initial production rate will be higher than it was when you shut it in because you've allowed the pressure to build up. So, you know, that's the simple answer. There are complications, but that's the simple answer.

Rig count, pad drilling and the 12-month lag

Erik Townsend: Thanks, Art. I wanted to clarify that. I apologize for sidetracking you there. Let's go back to 3 and 4 before I interrupted you and talk about this whole question of, okay, we're at 11 million barrels per day. Can we go up from here? Are we going down from here? What comes next?

Art Berman: Sure. Well, let's take a look at slide number 3. And what slide number 3 shows is the tight oil rig count, which is a proxy for total production, future production. That's in blue, and then lagged tight oil production, which is in orange.

Now this is a key point: that that because of the advances in technology, mainly pad drilling, which is to say you know we can drill seven, eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve wells with the same rig on the same drilling pad. Because of that, the delay. Between drilling a well, in other words, putting a rig on, and first production is much, much longer now because you need to drill all those wells. Let's just say it's 10, 10 wells per pad. You need to drill 10 wells before you bring the frac crews in to frac 10 wells, which also takes time. And when you're all done with that, then you can start producing oil. And so the empirical fit of these curves, believe it or not, is about 12 months.

Now, I went back and, you know, did some fact-checking and actually looked at the, the time from rig-on to first oil. And in fact, it varies, of course, with the length of the lateral, the number of wells on a pad, but it does average something around, you know, 300, 325 days. So, so this is actually So, you know, we talk a lot about, oh, isn't the technology great? Yeah, it's great, but it has a cost, as I've always said. And here the cost may be dollars, but it's time.

So what we see then is, you see where it says shut-in wells just below the March 2020 production? So that's what happened when there was a crisis with storage being filled. And so we, we went from 7 and a little bit of tight oil production, which corresponded to 12 and a little bit for US, down to 6 and a little bit for tight oil, which corresponded to 11.

And now we're in that reactivation stage, okay? And it may be faster than I've shown it there, I don't know, but that, that's what I've shown. And so what that means is that as those wells are— the shale wells are reactivated in this month, next month, maybe the coming month, production's going to climb back up. But the, the other very important thing that's going on is if you look down at the bottom of the, the blue curve down in the right-hand corner, we're at 165 tight oil rigs right now.

That's the average for June. We need about 500 rigs running to maintain production at 11 million barrels, and we need 600 or so to maintain production at what corresponded to 13,000 barrels a day that you've referred to. Okay, so at 165 there's no way in the world that we can get back to 13,000 barrels a day of US production. for a long, long time. We have to build that rig count back to 500 or 600 from 165, and we got to drill all those wells, we got to frack all those wells before it finally comes back up. So the, the presumption that you can just flip a switch there and we're back— we might get back short-term to something approaching 12 million, but we are in deep doo-doo as far as a country trying to rebuild our production. And that began long before coronavirus. I mean, that, that process was starting 18 months ago when the rig count started dropping.

So that is something that is just not appreciated.

Price map, 2021 production scenarios and rig-rebuild lags

Erik Townsend: Art, as I listen to you speak, I'm kind of forming a price map or a roadmap in my mind of where this is going. It sounds to me like we do have the ability to push a few buttons, get some production back online quickly, which I suspect is already happening because of the price rally. I think we're gonna find that the coronavirus crisis is not over after all and that this was all too much too fast. And so I think that what's going to happen is we're gonna find ourselves with too much oil again, and I won't be surprised if we have a round 2 of the fears of about storage becoming a serious problem.

But it sounds like that could mean another wave lower of oil prices, not to minus $40, but maybe back down to $20 to $25. Sounds very realistic to me. But then sometime after that, when we really do need to go back to 13 million barrels in order to address a bona fide full recovery of demand after this health crisis really and truly is over. It sounds like we're basically screwed. It ain't gonna happen.

Art Berman: That's exactly right. And I'm 100% with you, Erik. I mean, the last time I was on the show, I think it was in late January. The question then was, is coronavirus a big deal or not? Because most of the world, at least outside of China, thought it was not. And as I remember, you and I were in You know, frighteningly close agreement that it's a huge deal, and it's a huge deal for oil production, not just for public health.

And, um, you know, unfortunately we were right.

And so I'm agreeing with you again 100% that just because people are out and driving around in their cars and, you know, going to restaurants without face masks— and, you know, I was in that situation this weekend, kind of scary.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Art Berman: Um, it ain't over, you know, as some of the health experts, uh, you know, this, this fellow, uh, from University of Minnesota, I mean, he says we're in the 2nd inning of a 9-inning game. Now maybe that's pessimistic, but, you know, it doesn't really matter if we're in the 2nd or the 4th or the 5th inning. There's a whole lot more game to play, and no matter what the score is right now, it can change and it will change. So Yeah, we're screwed, Erik. I mean, we are screwed for being able to get back to levels that we have very recently thought were expected, and we've been screwed for a long time because of the declining rig count.

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 4, which looks at some of the lag periods inherent to the rig count versus production, let's talk about how long we're screwed for. Let's imagine that you and I are right, and what kind comes next is maybe another wave down in prices because we realize that we've gotten ahead of ourselves. But let's suppose for just the sake of round numbers that about a year from now, June of 2021, we get to the point where there is a viable vaccine for the virus that really allows the economy to go back to full swing, and we really need We need to get back to 13 million barrels, or by then perhaps 14 million barrels a day of US production.

When we say we're screwed, how screwed are we? How long would it take for the industry to react to that increased demand and really ramp up to meet that demand? And I particularly say, how plausible is it? Because I think the last time we went through this, where we got from whatever it was all the way up to 13 million, it was fueled by this massive investment in the shale patch, which frankly I think was driven by a whole lot of easy money from the Fed. I'm not sure that's gonna be there the next time around.

Art Berman: Well, before we leave slide 3, I wanna call attention to the table. And in the table, under the words, a thought experiment, and let me be really, really clear to, to you and to all of our listeners that this chart and a couple of the others I mean, you know, don't take this for the way it's going to be. This is— these are thought experiments. Nobody knows. I mean, we're, we're in uncharted waters here. So, you know, I'm sticking my neck way out and saying this is what I think is going to happen based on the way these curves have worked before.

So notionally, they're correct. Okay, just don't hold me to the absolute numbers because I'd be lying to you, and you know anybody would be who said they they know what's going to happen. But if you look at the table, what I've shown there is in the second column tight oil production and then U.S. production.

And so you can see what those numbers are. And I'm saying that you know based on all of this, by the middle of 2021, U.S. production could very well be seven to eight million barrels a day. A day, way, way down.

Now look at the far column. That's what EIA thinks. And I'm not saying they're wrong. I'm just saying that even EIA says we're going to be down 3 million barrels from, from where we were. So how long does it take to build rig count? And so let's go back. Let's go to the next slide, slide number 4.

And so in slide number 4, we can go to about 3/4 of the way over to the left where it says May 2016. We got down to a rig count of 193 when oil prices bottomed out at $30. And it took us until November of 2018, which is to say 2.5 years, to build back from a little under 200 to a little over 600. So that's the kind of build that we need to get ourselves back to anything approaching 12 or 13 million barrels a day.

And is there any reason to expect it would take less than 2.5 or 3 years, especially with your comment about the investment capital not being available. No, there's, there's no way to believe that. So, you know, the point of this chart is just that there's a lag also between changes in oil price and a company calling up an oil company, calling a drilling company and saying, hey, you know, we'd like to contract one of your rigs. And so that's about a 4-month lag.

And then you've got the 12-month lag about added into that between the time the rig shows up and first oil gets produced. So those are very, very substantial lags. And so it's going to take a long time to get back to the levels that you say, and I agree, we may need. And that's not because of coronavirus. Coronavirus has accelerated and accentuated trends that were already there. The declining rig counts began way before anybody had ever heard of COVID-19.

Price outlook and producer hedging

Erik Townsend: So it sounds to me, from an investment and speculation standpoint in this market, we're probably peaking out right now on the top of a first wave up in price. There needs to be some kind of a pullback. I don't know if that number is $25 or higher or lower than that, but something less than than the $40 that we've almost touched. We actually were above $40 briefly there. As we're speaking on Monday, we're back down to $36 and change. It sounds like we're headed down, and that next down is going to be a buying opportunity because it sounds to me like maybe there's a few more waves up and down along the way, but eventually we get a moonshot when there is a full economic recovery from this crisis. And the industry is just not able to respond quickly enough. Am I right to think of it that way?

Art Berman: You're totally right. And the question is, what's the timing on that? So let me just lay a couple little pieces in place before I get to that. If we go to slide 5, there's a perception that if oil price is $35 or $25, that that's what producers are getting. That's not right.

Most of these producers are hedged, and so in slide number five, I'm just showing the forward curves from late December to early January of this year when we had the Iranian general Soleimani assassinated. We had Iranian missiles attacking U.S. bases in Iraq nearby, and so. So that was a great opportunity for oil companies to hedge forward. And this diagram simply shows where those price points were for December '20, '21, and '22. So the point is, is that the companies that hedged intelligently are getting $55 a barrel for their oil right now, not $35 or $25. So that's why they turn them on. I mean, they turned them off because— not because they weren't getting enough cash. They turned them off because there was no place to put the oil. So that's slide number 5.

Erik Townsend: Now hang on a second, Art, because I want to qualify something here. If you were telling me, and I don't think you are, that 100% of all of the shale producers in the United States were hedging 100% of all of their production, and that meant that they could sell all of their oil between $52 and $55. Okay, that would be a totally different equation. That's not the case. So what percentage of the industry is hedged, and what percent of the, the overall production is hedged that's allowing those producers to sell it at elevated prices?

Art Berman: Yeah, it's, it's a complicated question that I'm not going to try to answer in detail. The simple answer is not everyone is hedged. So for instance, instance, the big players— Exxon, Chevron— they don't hedge at all. It's mainly the, the small independents, the, the Conchos, the Diamondbacks, the Pioneers, etc. They're hedged. And what percentage of their production is actually hedged at, let's say, $50 or $55?

I don't know, but I'm gonna say it's, you know, maybe it's 30%, maybe it's, you know, it's something— it's, it's less than But a lot of the oil that they're producing at less was hedged at a different peak.

So to really understand that, you've got to go into their investor presentations or their 10-K, 10-Q where they reveal all that. But it's according to a schedule. So you're 100% right. Not all of them are hedged. Those that are hedged, some of them are hedged better than others. Not all their production is being sold for $50, but some of it is.

Unaccounted-for oil, SPR and the Brent-WTI spread

Erik Townsend: We already talked about slide 6, Art, so let's move on to slide 7. Now, when I hear the phrase unaccounted-for oil, that sounds like one of those, you know, accounting footnote things where there's some tiny little amount that they couldn't account for. You know, it's like the rounding error that they don't know what to do with, and so they give it a name like unaccounted-for oil, and it doesn't really amount amount to very much. That's not what we're talking about here. Look at this chart on slide 7. This unaccounted-for oil is a lot of unaccounted-for oil. How is it possible that so much oil is unaccounted for?

Art Berman: Yeah, it really is a lot. And, and this is, this is, uh, something that very few people even pay attention to. You know, it's a, it's a little bit like a production impairment. Okay, I mean, a lot of these companies say, okay, we're taking an impairment or a write-down on our reserves, our booked reserves, but don't worry because it's not a cash item in this quarter. Well, okay, fair enough, but it certainly was money that was paid cash for in some previous quarters, so it's not unimportant or trivial.

Unaccounted-for oil is simply the difference between production and disposition. So I produce a barrel of oil, and if I go ahead and sell that barrel of oil within the, the week that it was produced, then it's a barrel produced and a barrel disposed, and unaccounted-for oil is zero. If I produce the barrel and keep it in a tank battery on, on the lease and don't sell it in that week, then it's a barrel of unaccounted-for oil. Unaccounted for simply means that it didn't go into the market. Basically, it didn't go to sales. That's all it means. So it's not a simple adjustment factor.

It's a, it's a very real number. There's nothing— well, the only mysterious part about it is where this inventory is actually being held. I think the possibilities are quite limited, which is why I think it's on the lease.

But the point of this chart is that from the middle of July 2017 until the tank top storage crisis reached a peak in mid-April of 2020, the average unaccounted for oil was a positive 3.3 million barrels per week. Since that tank top crisis, the average has been minus 5.8 million barrels. So this long-term trend has been reversed.

And so 35 million barrels of produced oil has been withheld from the market since the middle of April.

And then if you go down to the bottom, the yellow or the orange, those are SPR releases, withdrawals, and additions. And what you can see is that something approaching 15 million barrels of oil have gone from somewhere, either the wellhead or storage, into Strategic Petroleum Reserve. So just in the last few weeks, you have the 2 numbers and you got 50 million barrels. That's, that's a bunch of oil.

So this is a, this is a very critical thing for people to realize. And, and it's the reversal, the long-term secular trend of adding, adding more and more unaccounted-for oil That's all gone the other way.

Erik Townsend: Art, let's move on to slide number 9. What's going on with the Brent-WTI spread?

Art Berman: The Brent-WTI spread usually, or usually over the last couple of years, Brent is more than WTI, and that works great for US crude exporters because the difference is usually enough to pay for the transport of that oil, you know, to Europe or to Asia. That premium actually went negative for a couple of weeks, and as of last week, the premium was down to almost a dollar. So Brent's a little bit more than WTI. The problem is, is that by the time you, you move the oil from Cushing to Houston, put it on a boat and send it, let's say, to Rotterdam, you need something closer to $1.40. Right. To pay for all of that. So at $1.05, export is not commercial.

If we go on to slide number 10, that just shows again a lagged relationship to US exports. And what you can see is that as the Brent premium has gone down since middle of March, US exports have fallen a million barrels a day. And that's exactly what I would expect. And I anticipate That trend is going to continue. What that means is that less and less US production is going to move out of the US market, and it's going to have to either be shut in or it's going to have to be put in storage.

Global storage glut: is the crisis over?

Erik Townsend: Art, let's move on to slide 11, and I'm going to ask you to try to explain this slide in a specific context, which is right now a lot of people in the market, and certainly the price of WTI time spreads is saying, hey baby, the whole thing about the storage crisis and the tank tops, old story, it's over. There's no problem. Everything's fine. We don't have any problem with storage. Is that true?

Art Berman: No, that's not true at all. Slide 11. This is a comparative inventory slide. We're not going to get into the details. You've said before, people can check it out, but just think of the green as oversupply. That's supply that's going into storage. This shows OECD oversupply. So that includes the United States. OECD, of course, is, you know, all of the advanced countries of Europe and North America and some other places. And what you see is that our level of not just absolute inventory, but comparative inventory is higher than it's ever been.

May's number is even higher than the peak levels that we got back in 2016. And the way we got there is an absolute vertical wall.

So if anybody thinks that the storage crisis is over, I'll argue with them a little bit about the United States, but the global problem is absolutely not over.

Erik Townsend: Let's put a little more context around this, Art, because the only thing I can conclude here, you know, at some point At one point, we had a panicking market where the specific fear that drove contango to those crazy levels that we saw in the middle of April was a fear not just of a lot of oil, but running out of storage so that there might be no place left to put the oil that was being produced. That fear went to stark raging terror around the 20th of April. Right. When everybody just completely freaked out on that May contract expiration. Since then, it seems like what's going on, at least what the prices in the market are telling us, is somehow analysts have concluded that we're not ever going to get to the point of running out of space. That yeah, okay, we got a lot of storage and it's still building, but somehow apparently the analysts have decided we're not at risk of running out out of space.

Do you think that the analysts are right about that, or do you think that that's maybe just a reverse of the pendulum swing, so to speak, from what we had at the end of April?

Art Berman: Well, Erik, those same analysts were the ones that were telling us in January the coronavirus wasn't a problem for the world economy or the oil market outside of China. So obviously I respect those analysts. They're smart guys, men and women. But just because they say something, you know, look at their track record. They've been, they've been dead wrong very recently. So, you know, I can't tell you why I come to a different conclusion. I'm looking at data. I don't know what they're looking at.

Erik Townsend: And based on the data that you're looking at, what is the degree of risk in your mind of a situation where we get to a necessity to do another round of panic shut-ins because we're running out of storage capacity in the United States and we have to go through another panic drill of just shutting down oil wells because the production coming out of them, there's no place to put it?

Art Berman: I think the probability in the United States is relatively lower than it was 2 months ago because we've been through it once before. So producers are looking at it real carefully. They know they were able to do it once. They can do it again if they need to. In the world, I have no way to answer the question. That really comes down to, to what the, the big exporting nations decide to do. And we've seen that, you know, compliance inside of OPEC is, is questionable. Everybody's desperate. You know, the, the Iraqi government can't pay half of its government employees, according to, to some people. So if oil goes up a little bit, their production is going to go up. But bottom line, Erik, we're not out of the woods on any of the concerns that have arisen since the coronavirus became a crisis.

Demand recovery: gasoline versus diesel

Erik Townsend: Art, let's move on to slide 13. Now, if I look at prices in both the stock market and the oil market, it kind of looks like, hey, you know, You know, V-shaped recovery, baby. We're pretty much back, you know, not quite. We're approaching $40. We were above $40 before this started, but we're almost back to where we were before the crisis started. Does that mean that we're almost back to consumption that we had pre-crisis or anything close to it?

Art Berman: No way, Erik. That's— that is the popular misconception based on— I don't know, but I look at data And what slide 13 shows is data, and this is weekly EIA consumption data that I've averaged over two weeks because of a lot of reasons. But you've got to you got to average it somehow, and what it shows me is that the recovery, such as it is, is almost 100% gasoline.

So gasoline consumption has gone up a little more than 2.5 million barrels a day from the low in mid-April. But everything else is still languishing at pitiful levels.

And the one that concerns me the most is distillate, because distillate in blue, that's diesel. And diesel is the barometer of economic activity. So if we're not using diesel, that means that there are no orders for heavy, heavy durable goods that require ship, train, or truck transport. And so diesel consumption is up a little bit. It's up, you know, 0.7 million barrels on average, 700,000 barrels a day from what it was at the low.

But until diesel starts moving up, I say the recovery is superficial.

It's people driving around in their cars either because they're bored or because they're afraid to take public transport or a little bit of both. I mean, the real question you ask is how many of those people in cars are driving to work? Because other than that, it's, it's, it's not economic activity. that's productive. So again, glad to see it. That's great. But we're still 20% overall consumption below the 5-year average of 20 million barrels a day. We're at 16. So we got a long way to go to get back to where we were.

Berman's comparative inventory service and close

Erik Townsend: Now, Art, you have become recognized in the industry, perhaps first and foremost, for your comparative inventory price modeling system, which has been just remarkably accurate at forecasting crude oil prices. In the interest of time, listeners, what we had to do for this week's interview, I really wanted to focus the conversation on the developments that we've already discussed. So for those of you who were already expert on how the Art Berman comparative inventory system works, all of the data that you need for the update you were probably looking for forward to getting from Art in this interview is in the slide deck starting on page 14.

For those of you who don't know what we're talking about, I encourage you to go back and listen to some of Art's earlier interviews, the first interviews that he did on MacroVoices. Just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, type Art Berman into the search box, look for some of those early interviews where we described and discussed how the comparative inventory system Or better yet, Art, you know, in the beginning you just had this system that you used, you shared it with our listeners.

It's gotten so popular because it's been so accurate that you've kind of productized it and you're now offering a service. Tell us briefly before we close about that service.

Art Berman: Right, Erik. Well, I offer a weekly US comparative inventory and oil storage report, which is published every Wednesday right after, or as short after as possible, The EIA storage report, and it gives you all the insight into comparative inventory consumption. You know what what's up, what's down, and you can get that if you get it for a year. It's it's ten bucks a week. I don't see how how that could be beyond anybody's budget that is serious about understanding oil markets. So artberman.com, you can you can get the comparative inventory and oil storage.

Erik Townsend: And in the interest of time, we're going to leave it there, but I strongly encourage our listeners to check out the rest of the slide deck where you'll find an update on the comparative inventory price modeling forecast. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Patrick Ceresna: MacroVoices is brought to you by the members of MacroVoices.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts. Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: Erik's takeaways on shale, easy money and the Fed

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Art. You know, it's one of those things where I've— inside of me, I've always anticipated that at some point there will be an energy bull market that will come out on the other side of this. But really how things resolve themselves for the remainder of 2020 is one of the big puzzle pieces to solve on the short term. What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, the big question mark in my mind after thinking through everything I discussed with Art is, okay, what happened last time? A whole bunch of people, myself included, were naysayers on shale because we said the decline rates of shale wells, the economics of shale wells, are just not what a lot of people thought that they were. And I'm going back to 2010, '11, '12. I thought that shale, the shale revolution, was not really gonna happen the way it did. I thought that shale was going to disappoint the market in terms of how much oil it could produce, and I thought that that meant oil prices were going higher. Needless to say, I got that one wrong.

Well, what about this time? I want to say, okay, the reason that that whole shale revolution happened, it's not so much about new technology. This technology has been around for a long time. What it was really about was amount of easy money in the form of junk bond financing for all of these shale drillers to go and drill a lot of wells. And as much as it produced an incredible amount of oil, which is a phenomenal testament to American engineering know-how, you know, at the end of the day, they didn't make a whole lot of money in those investments.

And so I thought, next time around, there's not going to be this wall of money. But look at what we've been seeing in markets where in reaction to weakness in the market and the COVID-19 crisis, it seems like the Fed is just going into high gear and going crazy on expanding its balance sheet. So is there going to be a second wall of money? Who in the world on Wall Street would be dumb enough the second time around to finance a bunch of junk bonds for the shale patch? Well, nobody has to because they can float those junk bonds and sell them to the Fed.

I mean, the Fed's buying junk bonds. So I don't know. I think that the financing, the question of whether or not there will be that same huge amount of financing available to the shale industry is what's going to determine whether we see just a modest rise in prices or if we get the really big moonshot in prices that Art and I discussed. Anyway, Patrick, let's move on to the chart deck. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says Big Picture Postgame Chartbook.

WTI crude: 50% retracement and the gap fill

Erik Townsend: Patrick, energy charts. Talk me through what's going on here. Starting on page 2, you're looking at WTI crude oil futures in the July contract.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. Well, Art did a great job explaining what was going on in the crude oil markets, and you dissected it so very well. But I, I wanted to really take a look at all of the energy markets— gasoline, nat gas, and everything— and just see where the entire energy space, including equities, were. The only observation I wanted to make on page 2 was simply that, well, we had an incredibly oversold oil market, and right now we have more or less 50% retraced the huge sell-off that happened since the start of 2020. And often when you have a very oversold condition, the reflexive rally on the other side often will retrace about half of what the prior drop was. So this is almost, uh, par for the course for even in a bear market of what something will happen. So what to me, what I think is going to be the most interesting is what oil actually does from here, because the real— if it's a real bull market in oil that's going to launch from here, it should be able to clear $40 decisively and work its way higher.

And if this is where it stalls, then it's really hard to make an argument that, that the bull market has started It doesn't mean it won't, but it's just, it's a level that I think is very relevant for us to watch what happens here.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I've been dying to ask you, since you're the technician in the house, what you think about the gap fill. You know, there's, there's such a mantra in technical analysis that gaps have to be filled, although I'm not sure that there's any reason it happens other than people think that it should happen. Now, if we look at the continuation chart The gap-fill level is about $41.05. On the July contract, which is just about to expire, we're looking at $41.88 as the top of that gap-fill. On the August contract, I think it's around $42.25 or so. Do you think that that is going to act as a magnet to pull the price up? Would it make sense to look at that as a target before this market rolls over, if it's going to roll over the way Art thought it might? How do you see that here?

Patrick Ceresna: I think you nailed it with when you were referencing that most traders that are observing it, it almost becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy where if enough traders are looking for the same price level by it being the focal point, and a lot of times it will actually fill the gap. I tend not to trade those moves myself because I think that there's better ways of targeting things, but it would not be a shocker if we saw oil temporarily trade up there just to fill that gap and then give it back. I mean, it would start to look like a pattern of almost like a little head of a head and shoulders pattern if, if we saw the gap fill and then gives it all back on the other side. I don't, I don't have any high conviction if it will happen or not, but it is something that is very widely being tracked.

RBOB gasoline and crack spreads

Erik Townsend: And, and whenever something is being tracked that much, it's something we have to pay Patrick, let's move on to RBOB gasoline futures on the next chart, seeing maybe a brisker recovery there and maybe a little bit more consistent trajectory to the upside. What do you make of this chart?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, interesting, because it does also have a gap that it's filling that, like you were mentioning, which would have gasoline head to about $140 if that gap was filled. But gasoline has pretty consistently since the bottom been outperforming oil, and the relative strength is very much there. We've already just broken to a slightly higher high, and so momentum is there. There's a lot of, you know, talk of driving season, summer driving season pushing gasoline demand and crack. We'll talk about cracks. Actually, let's— we can move on on page 4 there as well. There's the crack spreads, which is the spread for refined refining oil into gas, which is back to a relatively healthy range. I mean, over the last, you know, 5-plus years, we've seen crack spreads gravitate between this kind of $8 to $10 bottom end of the range and $20-plus on the upper boundary of the range. And while we saw those crack spreads hit zero during the actual oil crash, we're back to ranges where, where refiners are profitable again in, in doing this.

And so this is one of the really interesting puzzle pieces to solve, is, is, is gasoline going to recover quicker and stronger? And, and, you know, Art talked about that on one of its charts. And, um, right now there's no denying the relative strength belongs to gasoline when compared to oil, and that, uh, that will probably continue. What I do though want to work into is page 5 where while gasoline has certainly outperformed oil, the one market

Natural gas term structure, UNG and the widowmaker

Patrick Ceresna: that has not at all and actually is quite underperforming is natural gas.

And it's really interesting because natural gas popped back in April, May based upon this idea that with the capping of all of these wells that a lot of the oversupply issues would have been solved. But what is clear at this stage is, at least what the price is showing, is that oil prices didn't stay low enough and not enough wells were shut off in order to really change the supply dynamics in the natural gas market. So here I have the July contract breaking to a fresh low, and the trend is so ugly. It's just down, you know, it's moving from the top left to the, the bottom right of the chart, and it's just ugly, right?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's just ugly, but anytime that I see a futures chart looking this ugly, it always forces me to ask a question, which is, okay, this is the July contract. What's the August contract doing, and what are the subsequent contracts doing? And so let's move on to page 6, where you're showing the term structure, which is the map of what all the subsequent contracts are doing in price. And boy, I guess my intuition was right on. There's a huge, huge contango. What's going on there?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I mean, you can see the waves, which is the typical seasonality, which prices in those higher winter prices in, in natural gas. But what is amazing is the complete collapse of these summer contracts. Like, this July, August, September contracts are all very, very weak. But then it's almost like an explosive steepening, or at least moving up on the curve, where the December contract is almost double that of what this front month July contract is trading at. This is absolutely fascinating that we see this contango exists, considering that in the oil market that we are already very flat on that term structure, right? So, Erik, this is where I want to talk about the UNG, which is the United States Natural Gas Fund or the ETF that actually trades these natural gas futures contracts. And we've had numerous episodes here where we've talked about the oil one, which is the USO. And the USO, to deal with the fact that they're rolling their contracts, is now spread along the term structure.

I think even up to a year out that they're out on some of these contracts. But what I find fascinating is that even in spite of this massive contango, that we're seeing, this ETF is still very much a front-month ETF where they are just right now in the process of finishing rolling their July into August contracts. And so that means this ETF, and you can see on the chart just how much it's underperforming that of the natural gas contract itself. And so what's interesting here is, is that means that if this contango persists, This ETF is going to eat that contango roll as we get here into the 3rd quarter. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this just underscores the reasons that I'm so skeptical of these commodity ETFs. You take a market like crude oil where it's really important to understand the term structure, and you get a whole bunch of mostly lazy retail investors who don't really know what that means and don't care to find out, and they just take a gamble, not understanding the consequences of backwardation and contango and how it affects the roll performance of an investment like USO. Now, USO is a crude oil contract. UNG is natural gas. The natural gas futures contract is known as the widowmaker contract specifically because the term structure, the contango and backwardation, has caught so many professionals by surprise. It has ruined It has bankrupted funds because unexpected things can happen in the term structure of natural gas that just blows up all kinds of really smart traders.

Why in the world, if a lot of oil traders won't touch natural gas futures, and that contract is given the, the name Widowmaker by futures traders? Because if you don't really know what you're doing, it's so dangerous. Dangerous even for an experienced futures trader to trade it. Why in the world would anybody buy a fund like UNG where they don't even understand the underlying term structure implications on the performance of the investment and the tracking errors that it introduces? It doesn't make any sense to me that anybody buys these things.

But as you say, right now, for now at least, UNG is still all centered in the front month What happens if they have some crazy dislocation? Now, if you look at the performance of natural gas versus the performance of crude oil, if we go back for a minute to page 6, look at all of those wild undulations in this chart. The reason for that, as you said a few minutes ago, is because seasonality plays so big of a role in the shape of the natural gas term structure. Just imagine if UNG couldn't stay in the front month and had to push their positions X months into the future. Well, over time, where those contracts would be would either be on the upside or the downside of those really big sawtooth waves in the market. There could be all kinds of profound implications to that depending on how they ended up reorganizing their exposure, if they ever did that.

Furthermore, if you're the investor in that fund, you don't have any control over whether they change that allocation or the exchange makes them change that allocation or whatnot. So I don't understand why anybody gets into these. As far as the underlying futures trades here, natural gas, it's called the widowmaker contract for a reason.

You either really, really understand the physical market dynamics of natural gas, natural gas storage in particular, why it's so expensive and has such a high carrying cost. If you are really expert on that, you can make a killing in this market by understanding and anticipating those shifts in term structure. But if you're not that expert, you don't want to touch the NG futures contract, and that's the reason they call it the widowmaker.

Energy equities: XLE and OIH

Patrick Ceresna: Right. That's a good segue to then— a lot of people ask the question, well then, how do you play it? And I say that if you aren't someone such as yourself that knows your futures markets and knows how to play it on the term structure. The best thing generally is for traders and investors, especially at the retail level, just to stick with energy equities. I mean, there's enough correlation in the equity markets on energy stocks to the underlying commodities that you don't need to get into the complexities of how the commodities themselves work in the futures markets. But so that's where I wanted to go with on pages 8, 9, and, uh, and 10, which is what I have. I have the chart first on the Select SPDR Energy ETF, the XLE. And, uh, at least on this chart, what was interesting was, first of all, how the magnitude of the sell-off, just how ugly that, uh, January through to March sell-off really was, where it went from, from just north of $60 down to almost $20, just a, a complete and total halving of the ETF.

But even though off the low, very similar to how you can express percentages on something like Boeing off of its lows, this ETF doubled in price. I mean, going from basically the low 20s all the way up to $46, $47 on the upside. But what is interesting is that when you really look at the vast majority of equities in the markets, almost all equities outside of financials, have mostly recovered back towards those early 2000s, at least the 2019 levels. And we have not seen any recovery like that in energy. And so while we've had that reflexive bounce, the energy stocks are still very, very cheap. And, and if oil markets are to improve in the future, maybe they're still trading at a meaningful discount, and maybe this is still place where one could find opportunities in the future. So next chart, Erik, what I want to look at was the Oil Service ETF, the OIH.

And this one has been extraordinarily volatile. I mean, we went from this thing trading near $280 to it hitting a low down around $65. And similarly, we saw an extraordinary reflexive rally where it more than doubled Going from 65, hitting a high almost of 170 some odd dollars on the upside. Just a huge rally. The volatility has been considerably higher in this space, and this is interesting to me because in that oil service space, that's really where the big volatility is in terms of whether or not shale will be restarted up again. Right? Do you have a do you have a take on oil?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we have to remember that in this crisis what's happened is the frac spread count— that's the, the number of fracking rigs that are in place and fracturing wells in order to put them into production— just dropped off a cliff. So the companies that are in the business of not actually producing oil but in providing services to oil-producing companies— and that's what OIH is— Oil services companies that provide services to the oil and gas industry. They're more volatile for all the same reasons that gold mining stocks are more volatile than the price of the metal itself. If nobody is drilling any wells and nobody is fracking any wells, then you don't need the oil services guys, and they end up completely idled and, you know, they start to go bankrupt.

But if you listen to what Art said in today's interview, At some point, we're gonna get to where we need to try and get back to 13 million barrels per day of US production. And that is not, by any stretch of the imagination, a matter of flipping just a bunch of switches and turning stuff back on. It's about making a bunch of phone calls and calling those companies that are in the OIH and spending lots of money to get them coming in to run their drilling rigs.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: rigs and run their frac spreads and so forth. So eventually, I think OIH is going to do really, really well. But that doesn't mean right away, because we may be going into a second wave where we see a lot of the wells going back and being shut in. And of course, some of those OIH companies, they get a little bit of business out of shutting wells in.

But once they're shut in and idled, you know, it's not until we really get to the next wave of drilling new wells.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: wells and fracking new wells that those guys really start to make money.

E&Ps and refiners: long refiners, short XLE

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so let's move on though. What I want to now touch on is how did the exploration and production companies actually do? And again, this is a space that just suffered immensely on the way down, and they've been trending lower all throughout 2019. This wasn't just a break that started in January for this space, but they've also rebounded quite a bit, and it's just a higher volatility basket than the traditional large-cap ones. And what's interesting, and finally the one I wanted to touch on, was the oil refiners, the, the ones that are actually converting the oil into gas and usually have nice dividends and are much more stable businesses. And they've also obviously had a very difficult time throughout March March and have recovered very well. And this is where on page 12, what we have is the refiners versus the broader energy. So I just overlaid the XLE with the refiner space. And what we can generally see is the refiners have outperformed and done relatively better in general than the broader energy space.

And this is, uh, one interesting area that I wanted to touch on. I mean, Obviously, if we enter a period where there becomes a shock in the system and let's say some event in the Middle East and the oil prices go skyrocketing because of a shock, then that would be a period where I would anticipate refiners underperforming. But unless we get something of that nature, this might be an interesting storyline. Gasoline's doing very well. Crack spreads are widening again, and refiners may generally be a better place to be. And so one of my interesting ideas to watch over the next couple of months is whether or not a long-short combination of being long refiners against short the broader XLE will work. And that's definitely one of the things that I'm going to be watching.

Refining capacity

Erik Townsend: Boy, I'd love to ask Pat Hemsworth that question. As you were talking, the thing that hit my mind is I think a lot of the reason that the refiners have performed so well is there is a glut of refining capacity in the United States, but there's a deficit globally. And what I would start to think about is, okay, in the future, are we going to see a lot of capital available to build more refineries around the world where the finished products actually get consumed? Because, for instance, in South America, they don't refine a lot of their products. They end up buying finished products like gasoline. And, you know, they buy them from somebody like Pat Hemsworth and put them on a ship and send the finished product rather than the crude oil down to those countries. So are those countries going to build their own refineries, or are they going to continue to rely on US refining capacity, which seems to have become a very important export for the United States, is finished products as opposed to just crude oil itself?

I don't know enough about it. That's a question for someone like Pat. Let's ask her next time we get her on the program.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Meanwhile, Patrick, we don't have Pat on the program this week, but we do have you every single day at Big Picture Trading. So listeners, I want to encourage you again to check out the free trial at Big Picture Trading. You got the details there on page 14. And we're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances as well as, of course, our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Art as well as a link to the chartbooks both Art Berman shared and the charts we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to that Jeremy Grantham interview on CNBC and an interesting article from Chris Whalen Whalen about Powell missteps on corporate bond purchases. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com.

or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not. Necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management. LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Diego Parrilla — Quadriga Asset Management portfolio manager and bestselling author (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Introduction and episode preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 223 was recorded on June 11th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is dedicated to healthcare workers all over the world, the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis, and is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing. helping investors overcome behavioral biases.

Quadriga Asset Managers portfolio manager and bestselling author Diego Parrilla returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the post-COVID-19 economic and market recovery, the coming transition to secular inflation, or perhaps more likely stagflation, precious metals, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick is going to guide us through how to put on spread trades using options. We'll be looking at both crude oil and Treasury spread trades and how to put them on using options.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude oil, gold, 10-year

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, what a day on the S&P 500. It's been almost up every single day, and it's like, when will this ever end? And then it's like the floodgate opened. We're down about 167 points at the time of recording, and we're back to almost the 3,000 level on the S&P. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, you know, I've been dumbfounded by the strength of this rally. It didn't make sense to me. I had thought it was going to top out at the 61.8 fib retrace back down around 2930 or so, and we got all the way up to 3200. I was very interested in Stan Druckenmiller being quoted this week as saying that he was humbled by all the strength in the market. He called the top around the same time that I did, and, you know, it went several hundred points More than either Stan or I thought was possible. You know, I'd love to interview that guy, Patrick, because one of the comments that he made in another interview a couple years ago is he said, you know, I cut my teeth on old school, you know, back in the days when the market was driven by economic fundamentals, not by central bank policy. And I really think we've come into, you know, a new normal where central bank policy is more important than the things that used to drive the market.

Patrick, the thing that just Yeah. One of the things that dumbfounds me about this market is, although clearly we had the FOMC statement and their economic projections, and that is clearly feeding into part of what this market reversal seems to be doing, a lot of commentators, particularly mainstream media types, are saying this is all about the shocking revelation that it looks like there could be a second wave of the COVID-19 crisis.

Anybody who thinks that's news is absolutely nuts. It has been so clear for so long, even before we had any protests, A lot of experts thought that a second wave was very likely, perhaps inevitable. And then you put hundreds of thousands of people with no social distancing shoulder to shoulder having riots and protests and so forth. Obviously, there's going to be another big wave of infections. That should surprise nobody. So the notion that that's part of what's driving the market reversal is if people are surprised by this revelation is just It's baffling to me. But, you know, I was baffled at the end of January and all through February when I thought the market should have been crashing because it was obvious that a pandemic was coming. And it wasn't really until March that it hit the tape. So maybe we're just having that same delayed reaction. In any event, I don't know whether we're going to get back to old normal rules, which would suggest a really big move down.

A lot of us thought that the 2,174 was not the bottom and that we should expect a bear market rally and then a new test of new lower lows. Are we still headed there, or is the next round of Fed stimulus going to carry us all the way up to new all-time highs? I think the jury's out, but the more that I see, the more frankly that I'm, you know, I don't want to short this market. I don't believe in the market. I don't want to be long, but I don't dare to short it because I don't know what the Fed is going to do next.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar because, uh, really this risk-off impulse has caused selling in the CAD, the Aussie, and the Euro all turning decisively lower as the US dollar reverses off of some pretty oversold levels down at the 96 handle. What's your thing? Is that like at a short-term low here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think, you know, clearly for dollar bulls, it's nice to see that there is, uh, you know, a bounce here. But boy, that was a really big and, to me at least, unexpected move to the downside. We didn't quite get down to testing that 94.50 level. But at this point, I think that this move really could be the beginning of something bigger, so it needs to be watched. I didn't think it was going to happen. Now that it has happened, we have to take it seriously. If we get a rally from here and manage to get back up and test the 99 handle again, which is where the breakdown occurred from, as often happens in technical analysis, if you get that next chance to sell 99, I might be tempted to do so. Uh, I, I don't know if it's time for Luke Gromen to finally be proven right, but it seems like this dollar move has gone further than I expected it to.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because, uh, we're down almost $4 a barrel today on that break, and that's pretty much the biggest down day we've seen in crude oil since the bloodbath days of March and April. Is this, uh, in your mind, a major reversal in oil?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I think the jury is still out on that. I would have thought so because I and a lot of other people have been saying, look, this rally has gotten way ahead of the fundamentals. It's too much too fast. We're overdue for a pullback. And I definitely still believe that. I think there's plenty of reason for a reasonable person to think, hey, the market's overdone. Let's expect maybe a pullback to $25 or so on WTI next. Now, I'm not going to hold my breath waiting for that to happen, Patrick, because at every turn during this rally, every time I thought the market was starting to roll over, it turned out it was just consolidating for a couple of days and then it went even higher. And I've been very surprised by how much strength there has been in the market. So are we really going to get a big substantial pullback? Yeah, it seems like we got the ingredients.

Today we closed both on the crudes and on the finished products below the short-term moving averages, below the 5, 8, and 13-day moving averages. That usually is a sign that a new downtrend has begun. So we've got all the technical indications that the market's rolling over. Question is, rolling over for how far? Or are we gonna be surprised and have the pullback be just a tiny little pullback? One thing that I do note is we didn't yet fill in that gap that's at about 41.05 on the continuation chart, 41.88 on the contract chart for WTI. So, you know, I wouldn't be surprised if we just had another one of these mini pullbacks, turns out to be smaller than everybody thought, and we end up filling that gap first and then moving down into a more meaningful pullback. I really don't know what to expect next.

Let's watch the tape and see what happens.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because it's still in the middle of its trade range, more or less always heading down toward the bottom end, uh, towards $1,700, then working its way back to $1,750. No major breakout and certainly no major reaction today to the, the bigger intermarket moves that we're seeing in other asset classes. What's your bias here on bullion?

Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, we're still in that trading range. It's not like we've seen some major new bullish signal, but, you know, every time that we seem to test $1,700— and I think perhaps just wishful thinking because I'd love to see a big technical correction so I could buy some gold on the cheap, or add to my gold position on the cheap, I should say— it seems like we're just really rejecting $1,700, a pretty strong base. is starting to form there. And as technicians sometimes say, the longer the base, the higher in space. I think Louise Yamada used to say that. So as much as I have been saying for months and months now we're overdue for a technical correction, that overdue or overbought condition, it normally resolves itself with a technical correction, but it can also be resolved by just consolidation that lasts for a while and puts in a strong base.

Starting to feel more and more to me like maybe 1,700— seems like actually it's around 1,680.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: 1780 or so on an intraday basis. It's just a number we can't get through. If we saw a daily close below the 100-day moving average, which is 1661 right now, that would cause me to finally, with some excitement, say, okay, the move to the downside that I've been looking forward to is finally upon us. But so far it seems like 1700 has been a really solid base. So if that continues, and particularly if we get a daily close north of 1780, That would really start to sell the bullish story. So I'm starting to think more and more that that correction I've been hoping for might not be coming after all.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, and let's, uh, finish off with that 10-year Treasury yield. What a pop and drop that was. I mean, it looked like last week that this was a major breakout and some massive inflation was going to start being discounted into that yield. And here we are, just, you know, 4 trading sessions later, and we're back down to under 70 basis points again. Just complete fake out on that move. I mean, do you have any take on what's going on here in your mind?

Erik Townsend: Well, of course, it's been coincident with both the FOMC meeting and the change in direction for both the stock market and crude oil. So, seems like somehow between the FOMC statement, the economic outlook that the Fed published, and this newfound people waking up finally to what should have been obvious for weeks, which is a second wave of the coronavirus crisis is coming.

It seems like that's some, some risk-off. And of course, that tends to support buying of bonds and lower bond yields. So it makes sense. I really don't have any opinion, Patrick, on the short-term direction of Treasuries. What I'm really concerned about is, are we seeing a bottoming process here just above zero yield, or are we eventually going to get to negative yields? And that's what I'm going to ask all of our feature interview guests. including Diego Parrilla today.

Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Diego Parrilla. Now, why did we invite Diego back as this week's guest?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Diego Parrilla is a really strong macro guy. He's also— we didn't get into it that much in this interview, but he's also a very, very strong options guy, which I know is near and dear to your heart. I wanted to get him back because with everything going on in the market, okay, are we seeing a secular shift from deflation to inflation or stagflation? Are we seeing a bottoming of Treasury yields? These are the kind of macro questions that I'm focused on these days, and I'm looking for guests who I think are going to be really strong in those areas.

Erik Townsend: And same reason we had Daniel Lacalle back on recently. Diego Parrilla is a really strong guy in that regard.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Diego is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Three forces driving global macro

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Diego Parrilla, portfolio manager for Quadriga Asset Managers and bestselling author of 2 books, both The Energy World Is Flat, which he co-wrote with Daniel Lacalle, another very popular MacroVoices guest, and another book which we talked about and Diego's last interview called The Anti-Bubbles. Diego, it's great to have you back. Needless to say, what's on everybody's mind is, is holy cow, look at the stock market. It seems like there's a lot of good arguments being made that we've still got a global pandemic. It's not over. There's riots breaking out in the streets. There's a lot of, you know, stuff going on. But boy, the, the market tape-wise just couldn't look stronger. What do you make of all this and how should investors think about it?

Diego Parrilla: Well, first of all, thank you for the invitation. It's great to be back. I think there are really 3 major tectonic forces that are driving global macro. And to a certain extent, they're pushing and pulling in different directions. The first one is the fact that the damage was already done.

So, this is the idea that a decade of effectively artificially low interest rates, monetary policy without limits, had transformed the investment framework from what I would say the transformation of risk-free interest into interest-free risk. You have something like the bond, 10-year bonds going from 5% in the 10-year to 30-year negative nominal yields. This is effectively creating a total distortion of asset prices, effectively driven by mainly artificial low interest rates, but we discussed this at length. With the belief in the central bank put, the complacent desperate search for yield, and how that has created a series of global synchronous bubbles without precedent Then the second key thing is we are suddenly hit by a shock without precedent It's been a shock in multiple dimensions. It's been a volatility shock, where the VIX went close to 90, levels we haven't really seen since 2008. It's been obviously a demand shock with things like oil going into negative oil prices and massive destruction of jobs and the economy.

You have obviously a supply shock with logistical chains. You have a healthcare shock, you have a political shock, you have lots of things. This is obviously making things even worse.

Then you have the third force, which is effectively a monetary and fiscal response without precedent, both in terms of the size, which has dwarfed in a way 2008, the speed at which it happens, just within a few days or weeks, we have the mobilization, again, way notably than '08, in terms of scope, so the Fed going and basically buying beyond government bonds, going all the way to high yield, Also, hugely importantly, fiscally, which is something that had been planned for, you look at Europe, the transition, the central bank was already realizing the fact that monetary policy might be approaching its limits and how we would need to combine this fiscally. We've seen the recovery fund, we've seen all sorts of MMT with checks given to people, increasing spending, increasing debt, and we cannot underestimate the impact of this third force in multiple ways. First of all, obviously, cutting the tail risk associated with the utter collapse.

It's only a few weeks ago that lots of people were calling for a depression like in the '30s, and suddenly, it's all looking at historical highs. It's just extraordinarily brutal how things have moved, but also quantitatively. Once you remove this tail, The narrative of the market, the central bank put and the squeeze of lots of shorts has obviously contributed. What we're seeing now also is signals being triggered. You have volatility coming off from high levels to around 25%.

You see very strong trends that— and you see arguably some FOMO, but more importantly, in my view, also a lot of quantitative buying, which be careful with that, because I think we've seen this movie a few times already. We saw going into 2000, at the end of 2018, how trend followers were max long at the top in leveraged form, only to effectively be taken out in a— it was a sharp move, increasing volatility and collapsing prices, which effectively forced them to liquidate only to buy it back all the way through 2019, only to be taken out again in 2020. It's almost like this roller coaster is almost Darwinistically looking to take out all this massive increase of day traders and things that you might be fooled by this short-term dynamic. I think that from a bigger perspective, this is not a healthy situation. The damage has been done.

The current shock is to be assessed, really, how much permanent damage versus temporary. What we know with some degree of certainty is that perhaps the virus will go, hopefully soon, and things will improve, but a lot of this liquidity will stay. I think this has been a dominant feature in the markets where central banks and governments use these opportunities, this crisis to introduce dramatic measures, And then they take years, if anything, to unwind them and they become permanent. We've seen that dynamic happen after 2008, and that's why perhaps we have distorted even more what was already a highly distorted picture.

It's really— I think this shock has an extra level of complexity, which is the transformation of the world we live in. There are some businesses that are experiencing challenges like never before, and they're probably done by now, and there's other opportunities. I think this shaking up of the world, considering where we started, the dimension of the shock, and the responses creates a highly uncertain world, but certainly, in my view, highly distorted.

US dollar and the currency war

Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the US dollar next. Those of us who thought that there was going to be an upside resolution for the US dollar because of the extra flight capital moving into the safer currency and so forth. We've been surprised. We broke out of a trading range where we were really consolidating above 99 for about 6 months. And just in the last couple of weeks, it's broken down to below 97, most of that owing to a move on the euro. What do you make of the dollar? What comes next?

Diego Parrilla: Look, currencies, at the end of the day, is a relative game. It's very hard to call just directionally one thing. It's all relative. If I print $1 trillion, and you print $1 trillion, then we're flat. Here, what we're seeing with the dollar is I don't think the US could be trying any harder to devalue the dollar.

They are benefiting from the beauty of the status quo of being a reserve currency and the large benefits associated with that, not only seigniorage as a central bank who can print its own currency, but also with lots of people parking their money with you on the belief that you won't do crazy stuff.

I think if you think about what's happening and the response It's a clear exercise when you start bailing airlines and energy companies and whatever it takes, and you do that with money that has been effectively printed and lent. What's your downside? You're the central bank, and the minute central bank independence is gone, what's your downside? I will do this in whatever it takes fashion, and Powell has clearly said that. Your downside is obviously some lack of credibility, some inflation, and some devaluation, which arguably is something the US wants. Behind the global monetary policy, which is sold and presented as domestic, doing what is good for your own country, there's always been a big factor that is international, is the exchange rate.

The proof, if you think about why we We've had negative interest rates in Europe. It's pretty simple. The only reason we have negative interest rates in Europe is because the Federal Reserve in the US was at zero, and we needed to have a negative interest rate differential to devalue the euro in defense, by the way, to the attack of post-2008.

Ultimately, the dynamics with the currencies and the monetary and fiscal policies without limits are leading to competitive devaluations, yes or yes. This, in turn, is also leading to inflation dynamics. Whether you see them or not, and how they manifest through the exchange rate, and how much is Europe printing both in absolute and relative terms to the dollar, you could argue that Europe is actually printing even faster than the US. In that sense, I don't really see this currency race— I use the the analogy of a long-term race, like a marathon.

In the short term, honestly, we're talking weeks or months, who knows? It's complete noise to some extent. Over a longer term, I think that in this currency war, it's pretty clear to me who will win, and that will be gold. It's pretty clear to me who will lose, which are currencies that are printing and that have a lot of hidden leverage and lots of internal bubbles and inflation, such as China, not just the usual suspects being Brazil or South Africa or others. In the middle, when you look at the dollar and the euro and the yen and the Swiss franc and sterling, I think the dollar will come strong because of some of these shortage and global dynamics.

Against that, you can see that the US is really doing whatever it takes to try to devalue, in my view. You can read between the lines what's happening. and how they're expressing that they have infinite tools and they will use them. So that's, that's really, once again, is bringing us to, to the topic of inflation.

Gold correction, strikers and defenders

Erik Townsend: Diego, I couldn't agree more with what you just said about gold being the ultimate winner in this race to the bottom between the currencies. But, you know, as we're speaking on Monday, we recorded this a few days early this week, gold is back down to retesting levels not seen since early April. Almost looks like we're seeing the beginning of a technical correction to the downside. Does that just mean this is a big buying opportunity here, or is it maybe the case that we've got some down before the big up move happens?

Diego Parrilla: Look, I, I don't have a crystal ball, and I, I tend to look at these moves with a medium to long-term perspective. I'm on the record thinking that gold might be $3,000 to $5,000 in the next 3 to 5 years. So with that mindset, you know, a $20, $30 correction is It's just noise. Clearly, the market has been— what we've seen is not just gold. You've seen quite a few other tail or hedges that people might have in their portfolios against potentially a risk-off scenario. You see the move in dollar-yen, or the Swiss franc, or even Treasuries, of course, gold or the VIX. They're all telling you the same story.

I think that the move we're seeing is more of some relaxation of the tail, and some hedges being taken off and perhaps some shorts or some people being squeezed out, but I certainly don't think that this is over. When you look at these different assets I discussed, I think, yes, this could be an opportunity to to add or to rebalance the portfolio.

Every time we talk about adding, you need some dry powder, you need to have some money on the sidelines, but I think this is, to me, is more about rebalancing portfolios.

You have to have both, as I call it, strikers and defenders. When you have these portfolio dynamics, when equities perhaps are overshooting on the upside, or oil might be shooting on the upside in the short term, or others, When you have a more balanced portfolio, and you have the ability to take some of those out and add some of the defenders in, just like you would do the same situation when the market goes the other way, so when equities collapse, and some of these hedges or safe havens do very well, you can basically take some profit on that.

I take this view that you can't fight the stupidity of the market. You cannot fight the irrationality of the market. What we've always done is we try to embrace that volatility, that stupidity, that irrationality. In order to do that, you need to have a team. You need to have the different pieces. If you are just positioned one way, then this is potentially very painful. If you are leveraged, then you're dead.

I think that these short-term volatility dynamics are noise, but there's lots of people who base their entire trading strategies on technicals and things that for me would be noise. Yeah, they're probably very good at that, and maybe they're very successful, but it's not something that we look at. For us, these are, again, big moves, structural, we play through options, We take advantage of these, these moves through in multiple ways. And certainly as these moves increase, then, then we like to add, and, and this happens through rebalancing.

Crude oil outlook and contango carry

Erik Townsend: You mentioned crude oil a moment ago. Let's touch on that. Saudi Arabia kind of surprised the market this past weekend when they raised prices on exports of oil to Asia by the largest amount I think on record ever, about a $6 increase that most people didn't see coming. And even before that happened, I've been really surprised by the strength of this rally. Something I noticed about crude oil on the way down was, while the stock market could be held up by Fed speak and so forth, you know, crude oil couldn't be immune to the realities of supply and demand in the physical marketplace. It seems like on the way back up, it feels to me like it's gotten ahead of itself. Is that just me being pessimistic, or what do you make of the very rapid V-shaped recovery that we've seen so far in oil prices?

Diego Parrilla: I would agree with you. I think if you think about anticipatory assets such as equities that might be discounting the long-term picture versus the front-end oil, they're obviously very different. It's clear, and it surprised everybody, when you think about the severity of of the demand destruction, the increase in inventories during that time, and the delayed response of OPEC and probably insufficient at the time. It really took quite a bit to reverse this and you have second-order effects like China, potentially, people don't want to go on the transport public, and they want to go in their own car. It suddenly has this this incredible pickup in gasoline whilst diesel or kerosene are still obviously very subdued.

The OPEC dynamics, there are limits to what they can do. Certainly, they have to do something, yes or yes, because with that level of oversupply, then once you get to tank tops, it's game over. I think that issue is still there. We have a roughly a billion barrels of inventory overhang to deal with. It's not like suddenly the demand surprises on the upside and the market is balanced, that everything's over. You still have massive inventory to work through.

You have to— I think it's something that, again, the danger is still there. The danger is much more on the tank tops, let's say, than the other way. There are multiple risks, in my view, ahead, and I would agree with you that perhaps the momentum and the move, again, going back to not only physical guys, but also the financial flows, which might be taking place in the front and spreads and stuff have been contributing.

I think the general view is the market is almost pricing a perfect recovery right now. At least in the near term, and perhaps short term, the risk might be skewed to lower prices, not a collapse, but I think mid-30s probably makes sense from the low 40s where we're now.

Medium, long term, I think the challenges will be to balance back that inventory situation, and to what extent the demand recovery is is for real and what damage has been done also on the supply side. I guess the consensus is probably more constructive there, where probably $45, $50 is a reasonable target, medium, longer term.

The problem, as you know, for retail investors, and I think this has been the real shame in these moves, is how painful can the contango be for retail investors who are buying the ETF? It's part of the learning, I guess, but you're not just buying the price. Oh, I want to buy oil at negative prices. Great, let's buy your size. Yeah, it's not as simple as that.

I think there's some challenges there in terms of implementation. Again, I think if you combine that view that short-term, perhaps things are a bit overdone with, I think, the associated contango and negative carry, With a long-term view that is more constructive, it's not that easy to play, but I would think short-term cautious, medium-long-term more constructive, but mind the carry because it can eat away capital and create permanent loss of capital, as you know.

Inflation versus stagflation

Erik Townsend: Diego, you mentioned inflation a few minutes ago. I want to come back to that. A theme that we've seen with a lot of our expert guests is with differing time horizons, They see maybe a shift from the disinflation to deflationary macro backdrop of the last decade toward either stagflation or inflation. So I guess my first question is, do you agree in general with that view? If so, is it inflation or stagflation? And perhaps hardest question, how long does it take and what does it look like? What's the process look like to get from here to there?

Diego Parrilla: Well, I, I would say stagflation, and I think it's Timing is unknown, but I think it's important to understand lots of people look at the dynamics and they say, well, you have massive unemployment, you have technology, you have demographics, you have overcapacity, we have the bubbles. These are all very deflationary forces. At the end of the day, the way I think about this is, look, the more deflation you have, The more room you're giving central banks to print even more without effectively showing.

It's almost like a freebie that they have, but let's not fool ourselves.

Inflation is 100% a monetary phenomenon. The way I explain this is it's not really about the price of your house going up. It's not really about the price of bread going up. That's not inflation. Inflation is about the value of the money that you use to buy that bread or that house going down.

If you think about the sheer amount of printing out of nowhere, out of thin air, or it's not even paper anymore, out of zeros and ones and digits and bits, this is just, I think, unavoidable. If you think about it, It's probably the endgame of a decade where you've been literally just distorting valuations and creating bubbles through excessive monetary and fiscal.

There's no other real way out, I think, than inflation. This is what central banks want. This is the way to get your way out of the excessive debt. It's obviously a big problem for cash. It's a big problem for many things. I call it— the problem is what I call the frog in boiling water.

We are being diluted at— the target officially is 2%. You would argue 2% is, I think, scientifically calculated so that it's small enough that we frogs in the monetary pot are staying because it doesn't look that bad. If you actually stay in this for 10 years, you're going to get 20% compounded. If you're in this for 20 years, you're looking at closer to 50%.

Once you see that over that horizon, your money has been stolen really through inflation, then you see that. Right now, it's even worse. We are outright negative rates, you have very deeply potentially negative real rates. Beyond the naivety of savers who don't see that inflation because the goalpost has been moved and all the other forces, I think this is happening.

Perhaps phase 1 and the Gresham's Law is obviously much slower. You're looking at dynamics where it's not so obvious, but anybody that has experienced inflation, lots of listeners maybe in Latin America or other places know that once you go into a phase 2, where inflation expectations kick in, then the process accelerates massively. To what extent is this likely to happen in the near term, and what are the catalysts is harder to play out, but I think more importantly, it has created a change in the rules of the game. We used to think, and this is pretty much since fiat currencies were introduced, this is a game where central banks were effectively given the keys of the printing press, and where the independence of the central bank was at the forefront.

As Voltaire would have told us paper currencies eventually revert to their intrinsic value, that is paper. In this dynamic where we are faced with non-independent central banks, and where inflation, i.e., the fact that they would abuse that printing press because the government, which controls them, forces them to do that, I think that's the conventional rules of the game.

If you thought about, oh, inflation is going to be the problem, therefore, they're going to hike interest rates, therefore, bonds are going to go down, I think you would be missing the new dynamics because my feeling is that the bubbles we've created are so huge, they're effectively too big to fail. This is the new enemy. It's no longer about inflation, it's really about the bubbles.

The reason we will have potentially a lot of inflation. People might think hiking rates are coming. It's not going to happen because if you hike rates, then it's pretty much game over. If you hike rates, not just the zombies, it's just the entire system, I think, and the bubbles would collapse. It's not just bonds, it's the entire thing, this construct with zero and negative rates.

The rules of the game have changed, and we need to acknowledge that and know that in my view, We're likely to go to a world with zero interest rates and inflation.

Effectively, monetary policy and fiscal do not solve problems. No matter what central banks will tell us, they can prevent the utter collapse of the system occasionally, but if you don't remove these things and you just keep abusing them, they're not really solving any problems. They're just delaying, transferring the problem in form of currency wars, transforming the problem in the form of inflation, and eventually enlarging the problem.

I think inflation is at the forefront of the next 10 years. Just like I summarized the previous 10 years as the transformation of risk-free interest into interest-free risk, I think the next 10 years is the transformation of bubbles that are too big to fail into inflation. Or more likely stagflation.

False diversification and hidden leverage

Erik Townsend: Diego, I want to take all of these macro concepts and tie them together into actual portfolio construction concepts, because that's what matters the most to investors at the end of the day. You and I talked off the air about what some people have termed false diversification, the, the idea that the old rules of diversification don't quite apply the same way because some of the the dynamics of some of those asset classes have changed. Please expound on that. What are we talking about? And why is this important to understand?

Diego Parrilla: Yeah, it's hugely important. I call false diversification confusing 2 simple things. One is my portfolio has a lot of things. So, I have a bit of oil, I have a bit of Argentinian bonds, I have some Amazon, I have some whatever. Government bonds, and you have a lot of things and you think you're diversified, the conventional asset class diversification. The reality is that when these crises have come, many of these assets, if not all, have actually behaved just the same way. Correlations actually polarize, and you go from a portfolio that looks diversified and assets that are uncorrelated, to everything collapsing at the same time.

The false diversification is the risk by which investors think they were diversified, and the reality is they were not.

This can actually result, unfortunately, in some way as a hidden leverage. It's happened to many retail investors, but it's also happened to the most experienced investors. Take Ray Dalio, and his risk parity. Look, I have bonds and equities, and they're negatively correlated, and therefore, I can lever my exposure and I'm always hedged. The reality is in March, both were collapsing in ways the models were not predicting, volatility explodes, correlations break, and bang, he gets alongside with many other people completely under a lot of pressure.

What you need, and this is something that is not easy to achieve, but is what we specialize on, is really you need to find assets that are not just negatively correlated on paper, you need things that behave in a given way.

This leads me to this eternal debate between bulls and bears. If you're on Twitter, You just see all day, hey, I thought the dollar bulls, the bear bulls, and everybody's, I'm right, you're right, and no, this is going up, this is going— and it's just the whole day fighting over who's right or who's wrong.

To me, this is going back to my point earlier. I think to me, this is not about being correct or being a bull or being a bear, it's about having the right team. You want to have the best bulls in your team. effectively, your strikers in the team, you want them to score you goals. The market goes up, you want to make sure that you have parts in the portfolio that will score goals. Yes, or yes, or yes.

That's their role. Your role is to score goals. Of course, we need to balance out the downside risk when things go wrong. In an ideal world, your strikers are call options. You want to buy a call option on S&P or whatever. The other side is you also want to have strong bears. You want to have guys that when things go really wrong, no matter how unpredicted or surprised, they will do very well.

These are things like options, S&P puts, you could have VIX or calls on the VIX or gold or different ways that combine.

This is really what we specialize on. We designed our strategy, Igneo, which I believe was the best hedge fund in the world in February with +10%, and was one of the best throughout the crisis, we're 19.1% in March. Currently, and we also made money in April and May, by the way.

Strategy, you need to find ways in which you create that correlation of -1 when you need it. When you build these teams of strikers and goalkeepers, and you can rebalance them, I think it's actually really powerful, and you are embracing that irrationality, that volatility.

I would take my point further. I would say that there's lots of strategies that are being sold or missold as one thing. The capital sin in the industry, in my view, is to say that you will do one thing and you will do something else. In that sense, a lot of the trend following strategies, arguably have been sold as correlated and diversifiers, when in reality and by construction, you don't need to be a genius to realize that the CTAs are long the market at the top when the trend is strong and the volatility is low.

They're max long leveraged. That's not really— you cannot be a defender, in my view, when you're max long equities, for example, at the top. In that sense, the false diversification is critical to understand potentially accidents, and most importantly, it can— and most dangerously, it can lead to hidden leverage. Look, if you were buying a leveraged ETF, 3 to 1, you went in with your eyes wide open, you knew that if the market's down 20%, 30%, you're most likely completely wiped out. Because at that point, your $100 are $0.10, and it's just literally impossible that you will ever make your way up.

They're very dangerous, but it's something you do with your eyes open. Very often, these highly leveraged positions, people are not quite aware that they have them. This is where it's not just about the volatility of the individual players which can explode, it's also about the correlation between the assets.

I think this is something that, again, we are spending a lot of time educating investors in, first of all, avoiding these big drawdowns and these risks, avoiding leverage and trying to find ways in which those themes will be more balanced, because then, again, you can embrace the volatility of the market. In that sense, this is what we set up to do, the universe of strategies out there, probably the ratio of strikers to goalkeepers is 999 to 1. It's just quite easy to find long-onlys and ETFs and long bias and everything else. In this environment, it's a lot harder to find good goalkeepers and defenders, but I would argue that the next 10 years or whatever this is, the dynamics It's much more about finding that balance in the team than just pretending that this is just going to be like the last 10 years, just buy the dip, and this is it.

I think we're in a very different scenario. I think to paraphrase Howard Marks from Oaktree, one of his recent newsletters, and I got this forwarded by one investor of ours because he was like, look, Diego, someone seems to be converting to your thinking, or at least expressing it. He put it very nicely. He said, listen, I've spent the last few decades trying to effectively optimize between large cap, small cap, developed market versus emerging market, value versus growth, whatever, EM, DM, all these things, and equity versus credit. The reality is that you're just optimizing your strikers. They're all strikers. They're all the same thing.

And so, he said, I realize that this is more about balancing the offense and defense. And I think that, again, this is much more important to find the right defense and offense balance than just optimizing your strikers, because without defense, I think this match is going to be very, very tricky.

Risk parity unwind and correlation breaks

Erik Townsend: Diego, let's expand on this theme that we're discussing of false Diversification. And particularly, there's a theory that's been bouncing around, which is so much faith has been placed in the risk parity strategy, where a lot of institutional investors are long equities and leveraged long bonds on the idea that bonds and equities always have inverse correlation. If that correlation were to reverse so that bonds and started selling off at the same time, it would force a major institutional unwind of what's probably the most popular strategy in all of institutional finance. Is that just a conspiracy theory, or is that a realistic scenario? And if the latter, how realistic is it? How big is the risk?

Diego Parrilla: Well, it's pretty real. But even, even before we get into correlations, when you look at the track record of these strategies, Let's think about both parts of the trade. Your equities right now, you're looking at, let's say, the S&P around 3,200. How balanced are the risks? Who knows? But certainly, you could have very significant downside. It's not inconceivable that you could have a 10%, 20%, 30% downside.

On the other hand, when you think about your bonds, and your Treasuries, and you're looking at yields in the 10-year Treasury at, call it, 60, 70 basis points, if yields went to zero, your best-case scenario is you will be making 6%, 7%.

The first order of the problem is that these conventional 60/40 balanced portfolios or buy the sister strategy, risk parity, which actually levers those components because of this. It's in a way an extrapolation of dynamics that are assuming that if equities went down by 30%, in order to get your 30% basically coverage, you would be looking at deeply negative interest rates from current levels. This is even worse in Europe, because we're already in negative rates, plus, in some cases, many of these issuers have significant credit risk.

Spanish government bonds or Italian bonds or whatever at negative yields is just remarkable, if not insane, but it's the proof. The first point I would make is be careful with extrapolating historical returns because the distortion of monetary policy through artificially low interest rates or negative interest rates is creating a very asymmetric profile where you have a lot of downside on the equities, arguably, and not that much upside.

In that sense, I tend to describe the German Bund, the government bond, as Franz Beckenbauer. For those who follow soccer, he was this legendary German defender who was fantastic, and they won the World Cup in 1974. But he's now 74 years old. Yes, he used to be a great defender. He's actually not as fast in his ability to defend. The second point you make is on correlations breaking up.

I think this is something that we've experienced very clearly and in a very meaningful way during March.

It's important to understand a bit like in real life, in nature, If any of the listeners have studied fluid mechanics, for example, you have a very stable laminar regime where things are linear and predictable. Then at one point, things go turbulent, and then boom, things behave in a different way. This is nature.

The markets are a bit the same. You have laminar regime, and then you have turbulent regime. When you go into turbulent regime and volatilities explode, you start a mechanical process that is unstoppable. If you have your value at risk, your VaR, both through implied and realized volatility, as volatility increases, your value at risk increases, and you're forced to cut. It doesn't matter whether you are a day trader, and you're taken out in 3 seconds because the market's moving like 5% up and down every day, or whether you are a hedge fund who's value at risk has tripled, and your force asks you to cut.

You have effectively forced liquidation. As you start having forced liquidation because volatility goes up, then you start to see that everybody has the same trades, and then correlations start to increase. When volatilities increase and correlations increase, then the value at risk increases geometrically or exponentially. This creates an even bigger wave of forced liquidation, which effectively starts potentially impacting liquidity.

Good luck selling those high yield bonds in the middle of a crisis, and then these things boom. Even Treasuries gapped. It's just hard to believe.

This is something that is actually very predictable, and it's very mechanical. In that sense, the correlation breaks that you're discussing is something that could be triggered by many things. Right now, it's like, oh my God, now fine. Yeah, of course, we're pandemic under control. Who knows? You could have massive escalation of tensions with China. You could have hundreds of things that could happen that could trigger another wave of forced liquidation and correlations and stuff. If you think about the size and the leverage of these positions, they actually feed on themselves.

Once again, I don't think you can— you can count the beans and try to see at what point level things start to unwind and what's the pain threshold. We saw that in March. I'm sure that adjustments have been made, so things will not happen exactly the same way, but it's naive to think that we got it all figured out and it's not going to happen again, because it's just going to happen again. The more complacency we have, about the fact that it will not happen again and that I should have bought the dip, then the bigger it gets. I do have that feeling that we haven't really solved things. These things are actually compounding and getting larger and larger. We'll see, but the size is very meaningful. It's huge exposures that are subject to this arguably hidden risk and leverage.

Time will tell, but I think it's We're bound to repeat them again, but obviously I don't have a crystal ball for when, but mind those hidden risks.

Erik Townsend: Diego, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Again, for our listeners' benefit, the titles of Diego's books are The Energy World Is Flat, co-authored with our good friend Daniel Lacalle, and The Anti-Bubbles. And there was a discussion about The Anti-Bubbles on my last interview with Diego. So if you want to learn more about that, just put Diego's name into the search box at MacroVoices.com.

Diego, before we let you go, please tell our listeners your Twitter handle and how they can follow your work.

Diego Parrilla: Yeah, my Twitter is @ParrillaDiego, P-A-R-R-I-L-L-A Diego, D-I-E-G-O. And yeah, you can DM me if anybody's interested in following the views or also getting more information about the strategies that, that we run, please DM me or send me an email. It's diego.parrilla@quadrigafunds.es.

Erik Townsend: Okay, we look forward to getting you back in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: debrief and Long Gamma on the Wings

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Diego back on the show. What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I always enjoy talking to Diego. And, you know, the striking thing to me, it's not just this interview, but it's all of the smartest guys that we interview. They all have their own little, you know, quirks and opinions, but everybody is saying the same major themes, which is there's gonna be more debasement of fiat currency. Precious metals are going to be the place to be. We're probably going to see a secular shift from deflation to inflation or stagflation. Those are the really big themes, and Diego is echoing the same things that a lot of the other experts we have on the show are saying. Now, as we discussed off the air, Patrick, I forgot that Diego is also a big options guy. Listeners, Patrick was ready to strangle me for not asking Diego about what's going on with the market in terms of the, the gamma trade and so forth.

So what we're going to do in this postgame segment is we're going to make up for my failure to ask Diego those things, and Patrick is going to going to walk us through a presentation he's calling Long Gamma on the Wings.

This is a great chart deck. I strongly recommend that you download it. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says

Gamma, ratio backspreads and the S&P crash-hedge problem

Erik Townsend: looking for the downloads. Patrick, before we get into the ratio backspread strategies that you're describing starting on page 2, Let's start with the title, Long Gamma on the Wings. Refresh our memory in terms of both what gamma is, but particularly on the wings. What are we talking about here?

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so whether it's someone like Diego or Chris Cole, they talk about these strategies of being long the gamma or being long the volatility on big trend moves in the markets. And one of the things that you can always just go long gamma with just buying calls and puts, but they come at the expense of a very large carry cost as the time decay erodes your position quite rapidly if the trade isn't working in your favor immediately.

And so the question and the thing that option strategists always look for is, how can I implement an options trade where I reduce the cost of carry and yet at the same time position something in my portfolio that if one of these really big moves happens in the markets, I have the ability to capture the gain or hedge my portfolio with one of these strategies.

And so one of the strategies we've— and we've talked about it during our sessions right after Chris Cole's interviews as well— was the idea of doing ratio spreads, or also known as back spreads. And I thought it was a great opportunity for us to revisit this, because with, with the way that the market has made this extraordinary move, whether it's in equities or, or in oil or in bonds, we've seen these massive moves. And there is always the potential for really big moves to still play out from here, whether higher or lower. And so the question is, how do you position for a big tail move? This idea that, that, uh, it's going to be a 2, 3, 4 sigma move potentially? And if you're wrong, how do you make sure that the carry cost of the trade was very low? And so, so this is what I want to talk about, this ratio backspread.

And backspreads are this idea of selling an at-the-money option, which always has the largest premium, and then you use the proceeds of this large premium that you've been credited to buy a larger amount of out-of-the-money options. The typical way, and the way we'll talk about here, is 2-to-1 ratio, but there is no limit to amount. There are some people that will open up, you know, 3-to-1 or 4-to-1 ratios going farther out of the money. But for simplicity, we're just going to do today a 2-to-1 ratio where we sell an at-the-money option, buy 2 out-of-the-money options. And the goal in this situation, or often the goal, is to open the trade as close as possible to zero cost, where the debit or credit is very close to zero. Now, when I say that, it does— just because it's zero cost doesn't mean there isn't a margin to carry the position because it's still a spread. But by opening it very close to a zero cost, you don't have this big theta burn that is occurring.

And so rather, you— there's a whole other dynamic of the way the trade develops.

Erik Townsend: Okay, now let me see if I got this straight, Patrick. So if I'm looking at the S&P today, I I would love to buy puts. In other words, I want to bet on the possibility that maybe good old-fashioned economics are actually going to come back and start working like the good old days again. And because of the fact that we literally have riots in the streets and a second wave of a pandemic coming and a lot of economic difficulty that is not priced into the market, I want to profit. I want a windfall profit from the crash if the crash comes. But Patrick, I can't justify buying a bunch of puts in this environment because the VIX is really high right now. Those puts are expensive.

You're telling me there's a way for me to make that trade where if there's a crash, I'm going to have the windfall profit, but if the market just goes down a little bit, or even if the market goes up, I don't end up losing my premium the way that I normally would. How's that possible?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, there are other risks, and that's why we're going to talk about those. But particularly, I mean, you're talking about the S&P 500. And, and often I do like to put it on, on the S&P, but the S&P particularly has a fat left tail that basically means that you have to widen your strikes considerably to make it at zero cost. So at least in this environment, the S&P is not the most perfect place to be putting on the backspread.

But I do want to talk about where I think there are some really interesting ways to implement some of the intermarket relationships of a market crack. Things like, for instance, typically yields decline and bonds rise in a— during a period of risk-off. And at the same time, typically oil also weakens in that environment. And so I wanted to cherry-pick a couple of the other assets to kind of put on some of these spreads and give an example of what this would look like.

TLT call backspread example

Patrick Ceresna: And so let's jump into it. I first wanted to start with a call backspread and I wanted to put that onto bonds. And the reason I thought, I thought this was a fascinating place to start was because we've had so many guests on the show having this big debate as to whether or not inflation or stagflation or deflation is the dominant force. And it's truly a polarized topic and it really can have both extremes where we have this huge collapse in yields, but at the same time, in the right conditions, yields can skyrocket. And so I, I really feel that putting on these, uh, ratio backspreads on bonds is a really fascinating place to do it because in this example we're going to use the TLT, which is a Treasury bond ETF. But if we truly do have another leg of a bear market coming, it is entirely possible that, uh, the 30-year bond yield breaks to a lower low and we are under 1%, as even And no matter how much that seems unbelievable, it's just amazing what bonds and interest rates have been doing in this environment.

And at the same time, I want to have a way that it's not going to burn us if suddenly yields go skyrocketing. So the idea here is that, well, if yields drop below 1% on the longest end of the curve, that in that circumstance, the TLT entirely can head to $180 a share on the the upside. And so how do we put on one of these call backspreads to buy some of the upside of, of the right tail of this big move on bonds that can happen? But yet if bonds never move, it didn't cost us a lot of money to have this trade on.

And so on page 6 of the chart deck, we have the October option series, and I wanted to particularly focus on the 160 and $170 strikes on the TLT. So the TLT at the time of this example, like we look at on the chart, was at $163. So we're actually going slightly in the money on this short call.

And so what we're doing is for, uh, you can do this in a 2:1 ratio, but you sell the $160 call, which gives you a credit of $7.80 or $780 for every 1 contract, and we use the proceeds of that to buy 2 call options at the $170 strikes, $10 higher than the $160 strike. Those were asking $3.70, or would cost us $740 debit to buy 2 of those call options. So we're doing this 2-to-1 ratio, and we're doing this literally for, uh, almost zero It's a $40 credit for us to have this trade on. And what this does is it creates a payoff profile chart that shows on chart 7, which is this idea that, well, if the TLT goes crashing lower and we were, let's say, heading to— let's say we were dead wrong and the TLT heads to $150, $140, it doesn't matter that both legs of the options expire. And you're left with a $40 credit.

At the same time, if yields just keep nosediving and we're south of 1%, you can see is on this chart, the right side of the chart has all this 45-degree angle higher where you have all of the upside of the TLT north of 170. And really the only place that the loss occurs is if we have the Treasury bond rise and yields just slightly go down and then stay there between now and October. And so this is a really interesting way of implementing this bond view that either one of the 2 extremes is going to happen. Either A, yields are going to go skyrocketing higher and I'll lose nothing, or 2, yields are going to go nosediving and I'm going to make a pile of money. And the only scenario where the loss is occurring is if yields just slightly go down and stay there.

Erik Townsend: Okay, Patrick, so in this trade we're basically doing something similar to going long on bonds, expecting that we're going to see lower yields and we're gonna make money from the long side of bonds, but we're protected so that if that situation goes the other way where you see a backing up of yields because inflation expectations suddenly start to ratchet up, and boy, you You know, it's taken the last 10 years at least of people waiting for inflation expectations to come back into the game. Hasn't happened yet, probably won't happen between now and October. But if it did and you were outright long those bonds, you could really get taken to the cleaners. So this way you're protecting your downside, but you've still got an asymmetric opportunity for a much larger participation on the profit side of the trade if things go your way. Now, Let's turn this all around. This was a call backspread. What about a put backspread?

How would that work?

USO put backspread example

Patrick Ceresna: Right, and this is where I thought it would be really interesting to talk crude oil. Now, using options on futures is a little trickier because of the longer-dated options are associated with the longer-dated contracts, and, and like you've explained so many times about the term structure, it's a little trickier. So what I wanted to do was just keep it simple and focus on that USO contract on the short side. And this idea that, well, if the economy is not going to recover as fast as everyone thinks it is, then oil could easily gravitate to the bottom end of its trade range. And how do we profit if, let's say, oil was to go back— not go negative or anything like that, but retest some of the lows where the, you know, the July and August contracts were down in the, in the 20s. And so, uh, so in this scenario, what you can see on page 10 is, uh, with the USO trading at, uh, $26.29, again out to October, 127 days on this position, what we're doing is a, a put backspread between the $27 and $23 strikes on crude oil.

And so in the same spirit of what we did on the Treasury bond trade, what you're doing is you're selling the one put option at the $27 at-the-money strike— it's slightly in the money— for $3.65. So you're credited $365, and then you use the proceeds to buy 2 of those October $23 puts which are $1.79 on the ask, and therefore it's a $358 debit. So you can see here that we have done this almost at a zero-cost Again, it was about a $7 net credit of a combination of the two.

And now what we have is a scenario that if an economic recovery was still robust and oil shocks everyone by continuing to rise, we really lose nothing by the USO going higher through the life of the spread. But if oil starts to sell and heads right back down, and let's say the USO is going for a double bottom retest of its lows near, you know, $16, you're suddenly in a fabulous position to build a substantial intrinsic value on those put options as it heads lower.

So when we look at chart 11, you can see that it's just the reciprocal chart of what we were doing, looking at for the call backspread which is if oil goes higher from here, we basically did a zero cost with very little carry But at the same time, if we had a big drop in oil, you got that left tail of capturing that big move to the downside. Now, Erik, when we were talking about using this as an example, you immediately were pointing out, again, the flaws of that USO ETF as a way of expressing the trade. And even in your mind, you were talking about the idea that if we do have another drop in oil, oil that it probably would once again come at the front of the contract and potentially see the market back in contango. And so what I have on pages 12, 13, and 14 is a chart of the July futures contract, then overlaying the performance of the USO against that July contract, which is brutal tracking obviously because the USO now isn't in the front month anymore.

And then you have oil time spreads chart. So why don't you take us through what you were thinking on this?

Erik on USO and oil term structure

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as we've discussed before, USO is really a very imperfect instrument. Now, the way that it used to be structured, all of its position concentration was in the front-month futures contract. That made it a pretty good instrument for playing on the short side, because usually when the market's selling off, The biggest sell-off usually happens on that front-month contract, especially in a situation like we have now where storage is the driving force that's pushing the market down. The front month is what's going to sell off the fastest.

Thing is, a lot of people were bottom-feeding, trying to use USO as a long instrument, and it was really very, very badly suited to that because you get killed in the contango roll every month. USO has to roll its position forward from the front month to whatever the next front month futures contract is. And if you're long USO as opposed to short USO, it's extremely inefficient.

Now, they've been forced by market conditions to completely change their positioning. So I think now they're 10% in the front month contract— actually, they're not at all in the front month contract. They're 10% in the second contract, 10% in the third, fourth, fifth, And it goes all the way out to June of next year. They have 15% or 10% of their exposure, I forget which. It's all over the place. So they're not as exposed now to some of the problems that were really problematic when we had a super contango market. All of a sudden, we don't have a super contango market anymore. So where USO's previous positioning was suboptimal in that market condition, their new positioning is suboptimal in this market condition. Because you'd really like to be— if you want to short this market, you'd like to be concentrated in the front month. That's where the best selling opportunity would be. And I don't think this is a coincidence.

I think it's because USO has become so big that it literally is the existence of USO, the presence of those very large positions that USO held in the futures market was causing it to operate inefficiently.

But all of that said, Patrick, at the end of the day, it still is a reasonable proxy for the oil market overall. It's not as sensitive to super contango as it used to be, and there's a good and a bad side to that. For a short trade, as we're talking about here, it's really not optimal. The, the good news is that now that it's not as sensitive to super contango, contango, when you try to use it as a long instrument, it works a little bit better.

As we go on to page 14, we've got a picture here just showing the individual 1-month time spreads. And we see that in April, there was just that nosedive right off the bottom of the chart there, where we were getting to $4, $5, $6 of contango per month in the front end of the WTI crude oil term structure. Well, now even the, the widest of those spreads are like 25 cents. That's entirely consistent with a normal market when you don't have any pandemic crisis going on, when you don't have any special conditions. So I feel, and a lot of other people agree with me, that this market has moved too high too fast in both flat price and in time spreads. I think we're overdue to see a little bit of retracement back to the downside. That would suggest that a short on oil is probably a good idea here, and particularly either a short on the front-month contract or on some instrument which is going to benefit from the recurrence of deeper contango in the market.

And again, USO is not optimal for that, but as, as you said, the only other option is to trade options on futures contracts, and that's beyond the ability of some traders. Certainly for our more advanced traders, I think the same trade that you're describing could be put on using options on the front-month futures contract. But then you've got the problem when you're using this ratio strategy that you may need a little bit more time horizon. And as you described earlier, if you need that extra time horizon, you got to be dealing with a later contract. You don't have to go to what USO dictates though. You can choose your own contracts if you're trading options on crude oil futures. So I think it depends on the sophistication of the trader and their familiarity with the markets.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: And of course, if you want to improve your familiarity with the markets, the way to do that is Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading.

You can get a free trial. Sign up today. Just check out page 15. You got the link there for how to sign up for a free trial at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show.

Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at TopTradersUnplugged.com/MacroGuide.

For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to this chartbook that we just discussed in the post-game. There's also a Jeffrey Snider article titled Attention All V People, as well as Jesse Felder blog titled One for the Ages. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's research roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at research@researchroundup.com. Research Roundup at MacroVoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Erik Townsend: Thank you.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register today. Register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have. The more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com.

And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do. Not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Vikram Mansharamani — Harvard University lecturer and author of Boombustology, with a new book Think for Yourself coming out next week (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Opening and episode preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 222 was recorded on June 4th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is dedicated to healthcare workers all over the world, the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis, and is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases.

Vikram Mansharamani joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss how supply chains are restructuring around the globe in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, the coming secular shift from deflation to inflation, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment where we'll discuss the sudden increase in civil unrest in the United States, what it means, where it's headed, and what signs investors should watch for in the markets and in the news flow.

Market wrap: S&P 500

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's dive into the S&P 500, which a little bit of a pause today at 3,100, but it's been pretty much a steady climb higher, just crawling. It's not even huge momentum on the upside, but it's just every day seems to make a little bit of progress. Where's this all going?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, Patrick, the old adage is the time to buy stocks is when they're really low, when there's blood in the streets, Well, unfortunately, we've got blood in the streets in the most literal sense, yet we're basically, you know, looks to me like we're in a rally which is headed toward all-time highs. On a Fibonacci basis, we're well past the 61.8% retracement. Looks to me like we're headed to all-time highs. So how is that possible when you've literally got a global pandemic and riots breaking out across the United States?

How could it possibly be? We'll go into more detail We'll go into more detail on the civil unrest aspects of this in the postgame segment. But I think the only real explanation here is it's the expectation that investors have that the Fed is going to continue to accommodate. And BMO this week put out a poll of their clients asking them what's driving this rally. 76% said it's the Fed. So I think that's the pretty clear explanation of what's going on.

Now, Patrick, as I think about the big picture and where we're all headed, a lot of people, myself included, have been holding on to this view for the last 10 years that, hey, this rally has been artificial. It's been created by central bank largesse, not by real economic fundamentals. Therefore, it's all going to end badly someday. Well, I still think it's going to end badly, but I'm not sure that it's ever going to result in any kind of major stock market crash. I think we could be headed into an environment where we're both anticipating more accommodation from the Fed that's helping the rally. But part of it too is I think we are headed toward that secular shift from deflation to inflation. Now remember, as much as inflation eventually can have a debilitating effect on the stock market, as happened in the 1970s, generally speaking, the beginning of an inflation event is almost always good for the stock market.

So there's plenty of room to expect a shift to inflation to take the market considerably higher from here. So, you know, maybe we never see that big downside event that so many of us thought was inevitable. I'm really starting to open my mind to that view. I probably am long overdue in taking the step. You know, I really, I don't believe in the fundamentals, the old-school fundamentals behind this market, but I ought to be participating in the upside with a strategy to say, roll 40 delta calls or do something similar.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Market wrap: US dollar

Erik Townsend: that allows me to at least participate in the trend upside while protecting myself if there is a crash at some point, as I've long predicted that there might be.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US dollar because, I mean, I have to be the first to admit that I was anticipating it to resolve itself to the upside, but clearly this breakdown driven by a very decisive breakout in the euro has really taken hold here. What's your take on this whole dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, I mean, it kind of makes sense. We literally have blood in the streets, and the government's ability to maintain order in the United States is in question. And this is all happening in an election season. So the idea that the US dollar has kind of taken a beating here really shouldn't come as a surprise to anybody.

On the other hand, I suppose, you know, if this all got under control, I wouldn't be surprised to see us, you know, jerk back to the upside. The next big technical test, though, if we assume that the dollar is going to continue to move down from here, would be a daily close below 94.5.

Market wrap: crude oil

Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to crude oil because crude, it's been doing the same characteristic as the stock market, really. It's been just crawling up a little bit every single day. We're, you know, around the $37 handle on the July contract here. What's, what's your take on oil? Is there another correction coming at some point, or is this just going to hold up here?

Erik Townsend: Well, a lot of smart people have been saying that we're long overdue for a big correction, but it hasn't come yet. Why not? I think that a lot of what's fueled this rally all the way up to the 100-day moving average, and we're just a tiny bit below it right now. I've got the 100-day on the contract chart at 37.61. We're at 37.18 as we're recording on Thursday afternoon. So we're less than 50 cents below the 100-day, and we've, we've tested it a couple of times in the last couple of days. What got us here? I think it It was speculation about OPEC+ extending production cuts.

Now, I'm going to add a little bit of my own interpretation to events here. What I think has happened was the OPEC+ meeting was supposed to be today, where it was expected that they would make that announcement. As they were coming into this meeting and they figured out that Iraq has really not complied with the agreement— it's kind of funny, they're talking about extending cuts because The period during which the cut was supposed to be effective is coming to an end, but Iraq hasn't really even begun to actually comply with the original agreement, never mind extending it. You know, you can't extend Iraq's participation in something that Iraq has failed to participate in at all so far. So that seems to be where the rub is. And rather than have the meeting and have to, you know, have the outcome of the meeting be no action, they decided instead to postpone the meeting. So the meeting of OPEC+ that was supposed to be today is delayed and nobody's sure exactly when it's rescheduled for.

Meanwhile, the 2 technical committees which are part of OPEC itself— that's the JTC and the JMMC technical committee meetings— have been pushed out to June 17th and 18th. So hopefully by June 18th we should have some resolution to this.

Meanwhile, crude oil inventory drawing down 2.1 million barrels. Now that was after a build in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve of 4 million barrels. So if So if you net out the SPR build, it comes to an effective build of 1.9 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, though, still drawing down 1.7 million barrels. So you've got a build on US crude oil inventories, but only a fairly small one.

The thing is, it's the finished products where the really big builds happened. Gasoline building 2.8 million barrels. Now that's a pretty darn big build right there on gasoline, 2.8 million barrels. But it's distillates. Holy cow, 9.9 million barrels. Wow. I don't know where they're all putting it. There's been rumors in, in the industry about they're running out of storage for distillates for weeks now, and they keep on building inventories. And I guess they somehow have not run out of storage for it. US production down 200,000 barrels to 11.2 million barrels. And again, I think that number is lagging. I think the, the real decline in US production is probably bigger than what's been reported. There's a lot of articles that have been circulating saying, okay folks, the storage problem is anything but over. Sounds ominous. Doo doo doo doo.

Okay, but you know, if you look at the time spreads on WTI crude oil, it's telling us that it really is over. Now, I can't believe it myself. How could we have gotten past this major demand destruction event? They're already starting to restart some of these wells as prices recover. Where are we gonna put all this oil?

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: Well, for some reason, at least what the time spreads are telling us, is the market is not worried about running out of storage again. So the jury is out as to what happens from here. I think at this point, having rallied already this high, a major— as you know, Patrick, in technical analysis, gap fills seem to be just something that traders turn into a self-fulfilling prophecy. There's a gap on the chart, everybody's convinced it has to be filled. Well, we've already rallied all the way up to almost $38 here.

It's only another $3 to get to $41, and it's just above $41 that would fill that big wide open gap from when everything really started to fall apart at the beginning of the coronavirus crisis. So I wouldn't be surprised if this rally continues up to just over $41 to close the gap. But at some point, feels to me like we're way overdue already for some kind of significant correction. And I don't mean new lows or anything like that. Obviously, it's going to be next to impossible to go lower than minus $40 a barrel that we set back on the expiry of the May contract at the end of April. But, you know, I think a correction back down to $25 or so would be part of a healthy recovery rally, and we're overdue for that. So at some point it's coming, but so far no sign of it.

Market wrap: gold

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold, because like a ping-pong, it seems to be bouncing between, you know, more or less— I'm rounding— $1,700 to $1,750, but back and forth, and doesn't seem to resolve on a breakout. Reminds me, the dollar was doing the same thing for a while, and then finally the dollar began, but gold's still pinned in here. Which way is the gold gonna go here?

Erik Townsend: Well, I keep getting my hopes up for lower numbers because I'd love to see a deep technical correction so that we could buy more. I couldn't be more positive about the long-term fundamentals for gold, so I'd love to see lower numbers so that I can buy some more. I'm starting to feel a little more optimistic that that might happen, and the reason I say that is This week's version of the correction down to $1,700 kind of came without any good fundamental explanation. What are the reasons that you usually see weakness in gold? Well, good news in the world, when geopolitical tensions and so forth are de-escalating, then that sometimes causes gold to sell off. Well, we're not de-escalating. We've literally got riots in the streets across the United States, and we're in the middle of a global pandemic. Another reason for gold to sell off is a particularly strong Well, we got the opposite. We got a weak dollar.

And of course, our friend Josh Crumb, in an interview here on MacroVoices, explained the reasons why the price of crude oil can drag gold prices down with it when crude oil prices are crashing. Well, guess what? Crude oil is unexpectedly strong here. So none of the obvious suspects explain why the weakness, why we're testing $1,700 again. This is probably partially hopeful thinking on my part, Patrick, but I really am starting to feel like maybe Maybe we're getting close to that downside breakdown because I do think that we're overdue. We're holding on to 1,700 sort of psychological round number support here. If that breaks, I think we could see a significant correction to the downside. Maybe that's just wishful thinking. We'll see.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's touch on the 10-year Treasury yields. Now, I want to elaborate more on it in the postgame, but do you have— just during this initial market wrap, do you have any comments on what's going on?

Erik Townsend: Well, just that we are finally, after consolidating in a very, very narrow range, it looks like maybe it's starting to resolve to the upside. That's going to cause the momentum chasers and the trend followers and so forth potentially to start selling bonds here. Let's wait till the postgame segment when we can look at some charts and get into more detail.

Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Vikram Mansharamani. Why did we invite Vikram as a guest this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Vikram was actually referred to us by our good friend Grant Williams, who said, you gotta interview this guy. And I have a lot of respect for Grant— I should say Grant, as he prefers to be pronounced— and, uh, I have to agree, Vikram has got a lot of excellent perspective on a number of macro topics ranging from supply chains to inflation, deflation, and so forth. So I think you'll really enjoy this interview.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com.

In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades.

To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following.

The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Vikram is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here on MacroVoices.com.

Interview: recovery shape, PPP and unemployment

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Vikram Mansharamani. Harvard University lecturer and author of first the book Boombustology, but Vikram also has a new book coming out next week called Think for Yourself. We'll find out a little bit more about that at the end of the interview. Vikram, I want to start with what's on everybody's mind. Okay, seems like at least for the first wave, the worst is behind us in this COVID-19 crisis. So what does the economic recovery look like? Is it V-shaped, U-shaped, L-shaped, W-shaped, some other symbol shaped? Uh, what should we What should we expect in terms of what happens next economically?

Vikram Mansharamani: Well, it's a great question, Erik. And of course, the alphabet soup of describing economic activity today has become quite the rage. One letter that I've recently heard, which I think is quite fascinating, is a lowercase h, meaning that we went straight down, we're bouncing and sort of rolling over only to go back down and no apparent sign of return at that stage. You know, my sense is that we're probably more towards a W-type trajectory, and the rationale is as follows. We obviously had a big downdraft. And when I start talking to a bunch of people about the fact that the consumers are saving money, they haven't had a chance to spend money. And the support from the government, unemployment, more money in people's pockets without the expenditure rate that they used to have means that they've effectively been saving. And folks are really chomping at the bit to go out and do something. And so I think that there's There's some possibility of a bounce.

However, I don't think it's a sustainable bounce. And the reason I don't think it's sustainable is if you just look at the unemployment numbers. If we look at the unemployment numbers, I think they're massively underestimating true unemployment right now, mainly through this PPP program. We've basically used the PPP program to funnel unemployment insurance through firms, and therefore the unemployment numbers through the Bureau of Labor Statistics would be higher, I think, if we hadn't done it in that way. Now, Some portion of that perhaps might not ultimately lead to unemployment, but some portion of the PPP-funded employees will result in unemployment. So I think there's some upside pressure on unemployment. But that's the quick summary of my thinking.

Civil unrest and investor implications

Erik Townsend: Now, just this past weekend, we had a major increase in civil unrest all around the United States. Some people are saying, okay, that's because George Floyd was killed by a police officer. It's all a reaction to that event specifically. Other people are saying, oh, wait a minute, it's really more of pent-up up anger and frustration over a lot of issues. Some people think it is the fact that people have been cooped up in this lockdown over the crisis that's led to all of this. How do you interpret the meaning of this increase in civil unrest? What is it telling us and what signals should investors interpret from it?

Vikram Mansharamani: Sure. So, if you had asked me which of those I was thinking is perhaps the most prevalent cause, I would've said yes, meaning all of the above are probably true. Yes, there was a catalyst. Yes, people have felt cooped up. Yes, there's an overarching feeling, I believe, among the American population that the system is rigged, that it's not fair, and therefore we need to do something about that. There's, of course, very visible signs of systemic racism, which is unacceptable, and all of the above.

I think the way to think this through as an investor or someone paying more attention to the economic and financial implications of the unrest is this is just another issue that I think will create downside pressure on economic activity. I think people are getting nervous. I think it will cause perhaps a secular wave of deurbanization. We've been so excited about living in urban areas. With that comes all sorts of interesting implications, whether it's, you know, this mixed-use housing, real estate implications, et cetera. Urban living may seem less desirable for some period of time going forward, whether it's the density because of the public health concerns or now the urban unrest that's been striking in many cities. So I think that's one possible implication to think about. Another possible implication to think about is we're starting to see companies like Amazon as well as Target say, hey, we're not going to operate in certain jurisdictions while this unrest is rising.

So that's also problematic. But ultimately, I think it also has an impact on possibly the election cycle. And I haven't thought through enough to be able to comment on where it goes, but I do think this is going to become a more and more prevalent issue on the minds of political candidates at all levels, local, state, and national. So I think there's some pretty big implications for the unrest. Ultimately, it may even be to some extent more than just a public safety and policing concern. I think it has the potential to snowball very dramatically into inequality of all sorts. And that, I think, could result in a greater pressure towards socialist-like policies And what I mean by that is probably more redistribution tendencies on the part of government policies. So a lot there. I'm happy to dive deeper in any of those if you'd like.

That's my quick high-level thinking about it.

Remote work, offices and transportation

Erik Townsend: Let's start with the things that might change as a result of this pandemic crisis, the changes that have been forced that might become permanent. The one I've been thinking about quite a bit is people have been forced, companies have been forced to learn to deal with most workers working at home, and it's gone better than expected for a lot of them. Is this going to lead to a new trend where people just say, hey, wait a minute, this whole business of there having to be the overhead of an office and everybody works in an office and most people are not allowed to work at home needs to change, or do we go back to, to the, the pre-crisis normal?

Vikram Mansharamani: Yeah, Erik, I think it's a great question. I think absolutely we're going to see more people working remotely. We saw that with Facebook indicating that We've seen it with other companies saying that that's true. It's a greater form of efficiency. I think we will have some office space that companies will retain because having in-person gatherings and sort of the fortuitous interactions that come from social mingling will still be desirable, but you don't need it 5 days a week for 100% of your staff. And so I think office space probably does see a headwind against it for that reason. And I do think the technology's improved tremendously for virtual work and virtual collaboration and virtual communication. And folks are finding that, you know what, I don't really enjoy spending an hour getting into some mass transit system to get downtown into an urban setting to go to an office where I work for a while, and then I do the same thing in reverse.

So I do think that's probably a more permanent pressure. And I say pressure because it's not binary, obviously. You know, some percentage will work from home, some percentage will work in the offices, and I think the percentage working from home is going to be rising, and that'll be more of a structural tailwind towards remote work. And that has implications for a lot of things, including, you know, education and how people educate and remote education and all of the above. So yeah, I do think that's right, that, that specific point.

And if we play through that point, Erik, and think about some of the second-order effects of more remote work, you might say, okay, well, what does that do for demand for transportation and mass transit in certain urban areas? Well, probably less demand on the margin. Add on top of that the density of mass transit and you say, okay, well, does that mean there's more demand for vehicles if people drive? Well, on the margin, yes, more demand for vehicles because people would prefer a vehicle over mass transit, but also on the margin, less demand for vehicles because fewer people are going to be driving into urban areas. So, you know, maybe vehicles are a push, but probably also less corporate gatherings. Less flying around the country to get together for a 3 or 4-hour meeting. That means there's probably downside pressure on hotels, probably downside pressure on airlines, probably downside pressure on transportation, probably downside pressure on rental cars, et cetera, and the whole ecosystem that supports this movement of business people around the country.

Higher education unbundling

Erik Townsend: Vikram, I know you're good at thinking out of the box, so I want to take this just a little farther. We've talked about work at home and the first and second broader implications of that. What if we go much broader to just what else could change? What are the— let's say, what are the least obvious implications of this crisis? What are we going to look back on 5 years from now and say nobody saw this change coming?

Vikram Mansharamani: Yeah, you know, that's an interesting question, Erik. I mean, one area I've been spending a lot of time thinking about, mainly because of my role as a faculty member at Harvard, is the future of education. And thinking about in-person education versus, you know, remote education. Harvard is the kind of university that I would humbly suggest would never ever have tried a 100% online education experiment. They just wouldn't have done it. The faculty is very proud of their accomplishments and think that their form of teaching is probably among the more effective. And so this forced experiment resulted in things like. Like classes actually performing as well, if not better. I would argue that my class, which is a discussion-oriented class, had some real positive benefits and surprises in being taught remotely.

You know, we were able to have discussion groups that were separate within the class, have segmentation of groups to be able to poll them differently, get honest assessments, et cetera. Now, of course, the surprise may be that the belief is you can't do that with physical lab-oriented classes. Well, I've had colleagues of mine that have actually prepared kits and sent them home, mailed them to students. And so you could do a physical experiment in front of a Zoom camera with your colleagues and peers all over. So I think there is a massive shift in higher education that is likely to happen. I think a large number of universities will probably fold. I think the residential education model may be shifting so that you will have students in person because there's some educational value for educational interaction outside of the classroom with peers.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Vikram Mansharamani: But there's a tailwind here that the cost of education is going to be tapped down.

And one way to think about it is we're unbundling. We're unbundling the social and residential experience from the educational experience. And residential liberal arts colleges will tell you those are intermingled and you can't separate them. But I think in some places you probably can. So I think that could actually help address the student loan problem. So that's a big change.

The other thing I think, and we can get into this, this is separate and it's related to the COVID pandemic, but it's also So part of a much broader trend, I think we are going to see a massive regionalization that accompanies a deglobalization, and that has huge implications for supply chains. And I think that has not been fully thought through. So those are some quick thoughts. Again, happy to go in whatever direction you think makes sense.

Supply chains and two ecosystems

Erik Townsend: Well, let's go next to supply chains and what changes in the global economy in In the broadest sense, where are we going in terms of the way business changes and the way we do business changes as a result of this? And how do supply chains fit into that story?

Vikram Mansharamani: Yeah, so the bottom line truth is there has been a massive increase in global economic uncertainty as perceived by corporate boardrooms of the multinational companies of the world. They've said, uh-oh, you know what? And by the way, this is a trend that was started well in advance of COVID-19 and will be accelerated because of COVID 19 and be accelerated because of other dynamics.

So what do I mean by that? What I mean is we had this trade war start really 16, 17 into 18, and that changed the dynamics of corporate boardrooms by saying, hey, you know what? This one part that was critical for my manufacturing used to cost $7, and now it's $48 because of tariffs and other things. That doesn't make me feel good. Now my profits are at risk. I'm not sure how this is going to work. Okay, we got to think about the supply chain shift so I don't have this geo economic pressure of a trade war that throws my profit projections and stability out the window. I got to change that. So supply chains started tiptoeing in a different direction.

COVID-19 comes around, and because of the lockdowns, now companies are saying, wait, hold on a second. I think there was a— I think it was Fiat Chrysler had an issue in one of their plants in Europe that couldn't get a part that was essential for production out of China. And they said, wait, hold on, it's not even now about price. Now it's about security of supply, the availability Wait, we got to really think about our supply chains shifting.

Throw on top of that some geopolitics and the US-China trade war as being a lot more than a trade war. Think of it as a great power rivalry that comes with military escalation and all of the above. And now you start saying, you know what? Now there's a reason I just need to get my supply chains out of Asia because I'm a little bit worried. Maybe it's Chinese military modernization that leads to effectively a threat to US interests in Asia and my supply chains run there. Uh-oh, now I really need to move it back. Add on top of that a couple of other dynamics. One is with technology. Because of automation and automated manufacturing, what we've seen is the labor component of manufactured goods has been plunging. And as it plunges, the labor arbitrage value of producing your goods in a country that has cheap labor has fallen. And so, you know, why should I bother putting my factory where there's lots of cheap people, cheap labor, if labor is not a big component of what I'm doing?

So, you know, the labor arbitrage value disappeared. Throw on top of that the, the rising ESG concerns, and you remember and you think then that the longer the supply chain, the greater the carbon footprint. And so now there's an ESG pressure to make supply chains And lastly, you know, there used to be a tax arbitrage where I added the value would be taxed there. It turns out now with the US corporate tax rates a little more competitive on a global basis, the tax arbitrage value disappeared. And so things like freight actually become more important. And so what you find is that these supply chains are going to shorten.

As they shorten, you're going to have manufacturing come closer to the end consumer. Consumer. And when that happens, I think it creates a lot of pressure towards the emergence of 2 global ecosystems, a Chinese-led ecosystem and then a US or Western-led ecosystem. And that has massive implications for corporate boardrooms as well as companies and countries all over the world. So yeah, I think that, that's, that's sort of a real big picture answer to your question of how I see some of these pressures unfolding. And I think COVID-19 was an accelerant of some of these trends and made it a little more obvious that these other things mattered as well.

China decoupling and US complacency

Erik Townsend: I want to come back to US-China geopolitical relations because I think that's a very important topic. But first, just because you touched on it, I think there's a complacency in the United States. We have an attitude of, look, we took China from being this rinky-dink third world country to the second biggest economy in the world by outsourcing our manufacturing to them. We got them under our thumb. They need our money in order to grow their economy. They can't exist without us. Therefore, we can call all of the shots.

I worry that that attitude of a lot of Americans embodies a lot of complacency and that maybe there's a risk in coming years that China is working very intentionally to get to the point where they can say, you know what, we don't need you guys anymore. We've gotten to the point where we can both develop our own internal economy and sell our stuff to other people in the world, and we're ready to part ways, sort of the way the, the Cold War between the US and the Soviet Union led to no trade between Eastern Bloc and Western Bloc countries. I think that we could be headed toward a China that doesn't want our business as opposed to one that is desperate for our business. And I'm convinced that's what they want. I just don't know how far away it is from being reality. Are we anywhere close to that?

And is it realistic to think that's coming someday?

Vikram Mansharamani: Oh, I think it is coming, Erik. I totally agree with your assessment. And I think the fact that I see a world emerging with 2 economic ecosystems, that the trade between those ecosystems, I think it's going to plunge. And that's exactly in line with your thesis that you suggested. Now, how far along are we in that process? That's a tougher question to answer, and it's a tougher question to answer because of goods moving in intermediate steps, et cetera. So we don't really have, I think, a great understanding of China's ultimate dependency upon US demand. There's still some dependency for sure, but the fact that the Chinese Communist Party took away their GDP projections this year, the fact that they've been emphasizing the Belt and Road to build future markets for their goods and services, and they're turning themselves west rather than east towards us.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Vikram Mansharamani: The fact that they're building out this Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank and co-opting a whole bunch of countries that are not the US indicates to me that that's absolutely part of their strategic game plan.

And that's the progress that they've been making is in that direction. Add on top of that, Erik, that I think they had a credit-fueled investment bubble that burst. They overbuilt. But in the process of that overhang, Some of us are missing the fact that under the surface of this investment-led slowdown and export-led slowdown is a consumer-led growth. Now, the COVID dynamics obviously disrupted that, but the Chinese economy was in fact transitioning towards more of a consumer-led society, in which case they needed exports less, they needed investment less, et cetera. So they were going in this direction, and I think you're very astute to suggest that that's their game plan.

US-China rivalry: Hong Kong and Taiwan

Erik Townsend: Vikram, let's go ahead and get into US-China geopolitical relations. Kind of feels to me like the calm before the storm, like maybe the, the attitude, at least in the beginning of the US administration, was, okay, we got to have a talk with China, but let's get through this crisis first. And it seems like that's even changing to now we're not going to wait till the crisis is over, we're going to mix it up with China right now.

Where is this all What do you think is coming next for US-China relations? And particularly, we negotiated this big trade deal. Is that all forgotten now or are we going to abide by that or what do you think comes next?

Vikram Mansharamani: Yeah, Erik, this is a gigantic question. I would argue this is probably the single most important issue facing the global macroeconomic and geopolitical environment for the next, call it, 10 years or so. This is a gigantic issue and this is not just a trade war. This is not just a This is great power rivalry. This is a trade war. This is a currency war. This is an economic war. This is a space race. This is an arms race. This is a geopolitical influence race. This is ultimately a competition of values.

And that suggests to me that we are on the path towards whether it's a cold or cool or warm war, however you want to define it. One hopes it stays peaceful, but it seems destined for issues and conflict in this rivalry. And again, one hopes is not militarily or, uh, you know, physical war, but that's a risk.

So I would think a couple things are critical here. Number one, Hong Kong. Hong Kong situation is a tinderbox, and because of the fact that the government of China did agree to treat it differently and are now saying they won't treat it differently, I think that risks generating a geopolitical alliance led perhaps by the British to say, hold on a second, we had some deal here with Hong Kong and you're not upholding your end of it. And that could create pressure on China.

Secondly, and a huge issue, I think one that's being severely underestimated as a major issue by the world, is Taiwan. I believe the Chinese are done with this idea of foreign influence on their soil. They view it as part of that century of humiliation, the fact that the foreigners carved us up, and Taiwan is this glaring sore thumb that's out there that they feel the need to address. How and when, I can't comment, but I do know they want to have Taiwan back in, and they're very upset about the fact that the U.S. sells military equipment to their wayward province. They're highly aware of the fact that the United States signed agreements that said there's one China based in Beijing, et cetera. So I think that's another flashpoint that could emerge to be a potential problem.

And then ultimately there's this sort of war of values, globalization, good or bad. I remember in 2017 listening to Xi Jinping in Davos and his talk was about globalization, free trade, and how the world can all prosper and we're one big community and we're going to move forward together, while the US line at that point was, we're going to make America great and focus on ourselves first and protectionism, et cetera. So I think there are a whole bunch of different crosscurrents here and that will be played out and affect almost everything.

The big geopolitical implication, I think, of this rivalry, and it goes back to my comments earlier about the supply chain, is that countries around the world are going to have to choose. It's going to be very difficult to be a country and be effectively friends, if you will, with both China and the US. And I think one country that's going to feel really torn is a country like Australia.

Politically, definitely in the US camp. Militarily, definitely in the US camp. Economically, Uh-oh, now we've got some tensions. The growth of China has supported the growth of Australia, and that creates some real internal tensions in a country like Australia. So I do think that the pressures of the geopolitical rivalry are going to be felt far and wide across many different countries and across many different sectors, obviously, but definitely economically and politically.

Chokepoints and economic fragilities

Erik Townsend: Vikram, let's tie that perspective on foreign back into the economic situation and the risks that exist both to China's economy and to the US economy. Now, something I never knew until this COVID-19 crisis is that the US is completely dependent on China for prescription drugs. Almost all of the antibiotics are made either in China or they're made in India using raw materials sourced from China. So China has the ability to literally cut us off from prescription drugs, which if they were to do it in a sudden and, you know, using that as a military tool, if you would, they could literally cut off all of the aging and pharmaceutically dependent American population from the drugs they need to stay alive. And we don't have a backup plan. And we apparently never thought this through. What else is at risk and what are the risks to China's economy as well if the US-China relations go south as you and I both seem to think they will?

Vikram Mansharamani: Yeah. Look, the pharmaceutical ingredients actually, it's yet another component of the supply chain pressure, and you're 100% right to talk about it. I mean, some stats I remember, I recently gave a talk on this, but 95% of even non-prescription things like ibuprofen, Ibuprofen come from Chinese sources. 90% of vitamin C come from Chinese sources. And then I think it's like 91% of hydrocortisone, 70% of acetaminophen. And you're right, I think it's like 97% is that stat I remember of antibiotics come from Chinese sources. So yes, they have a major stranglehold on a key ingredient for which we are dependent upon them right now.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Vikram Mansharamani: Now, I think that'll change over time, hopefully quicker, to remove that vulnerability.

But obviously another area and sector that people talk about are things like rare earth materials and rare earth metals. And these are needed for magnets and they have some national security implications. They have some alternative energy implications, et cetera. And that's a choke point right now in the world. Now, the benefit is rare earths are not actually that rare.

They're actually spread all over the world. But they haven't been developed elsewhere. And so there's a couple of projects I'm aware of in North America that are working on trying to restore rare earth capacity here, given its strategic role in national security, as well as alternative energy, et cetera. And there's a lot of other sort of vulnerabilities, some with less significance. I mean, look, I think some double-digit, large double-digit percentage of footwear comes out of China.

Okay. I'm pretty sure we can find other sources for footwear and we can sort of deal with that, but it's more of the strategic ones that I worry about. The flip side is I think the Chinese are actually dependent on finding sources of food and agricultural inputs, and the US has historically supplied some of those. Obviously, Australia can supply some and Brazil is another meaningful source, but it's a vulnerability that they think about, I think, a little bit. So I think those are some of the big sort of interrelated supply chain vulnerabilities that one should at least worry about and pay attention to.

But your larger question about the economics, uh, the sort of domestic economic situations, I think China has a lot of internal issues. Their economy has suffered tremendously because of the COVID crisis. They had a credit-fueled bubble, as I talked about earlier, that burst because they overbuilt. They're seeing a, you know, an explosion in bad debt internal to their country, mainly because of that astronomical amount of debt that was issued to fund the buildout, and then an economic slowdown. And that also is a toxic combination that could create unrest domestically. So I worry that the Chinese Communist Party might, quote unquote, wag the dog, for anyone that's seen that movie, but use some sort of distracting event outside the country to stir up nationalism and get people to be a little more oriented towards saying, hey, we're in this together, it was their fault. It was, we need to suffer a little bit, but it's okay because we're on this long march towards greatness.

And so I think there's some vulnerabilities domestically in China that are meaningful. And the thing I watch there is sort of bad debt levels.

Now, obviously the US economy, I think, has a whole bunch of issues as well. 70% dependent on the consumer, of which 70% are services. Some of those services I don't think are going to have the pent-up demand that people hope for, and talking about a V-shaped recovery. Erik, if I go out to dinner with my family once a week and my wife and I take our kids and we go to a nice restaurant, we sit down, we have a nice meal. Well, we've missed the last 10 of those or 15 of those, right? When are we going to feel comfortable going? I don't know, maybe it's another 5, 10 weeks. When we do, are we going to really go out 25 times in the first month or 2? No, that pent-up demand doesn't exist. So in some of these services, you have to see a headwind to the the US economy. And so consumer services being almost 50% of the economy, that's concerning.

Throw on top of it bad debt, throw on top of it unemployment, and then a major issue, which I'm sure we'll talk about, is the faith in the US dollar, which I think at some point could result in a newfound vulnerability for the US economy. I mean, right now as the global reserve currency, we're able to print, we're able to have a budget deficit That's— I don't— I can't even guesstimate where it's going to be, 20-something percent of GDP in the United States.

I mean, as a student of emerging markets and as someone who's paid attention to financial booms and busts and bubbles bursting, when I hear of a budget deficit to GDP in double digits, I get concerned. When we're at 20-something percent, oh my God, I am really concerned. And the US gets away with it because we have the global reserve currency. Now, if that were called into question, then I think we got much deeper issues at work that the US economy will have to grapple with.

Reserve currency, yuan, gold and crypto

Erik Townsend: Let's talk then about what some of the things are that would bring that into question. Because as you say, ever since 1944, the US dollar has enjoyed this role of being the world's global reserve currency. One of the things I question is whether we need to have just one specific— you know, in the old days, you had to choose one so that people didn't have to hold lots of different currencies. In an environment where you can just do a forex transaction at the click of a mouse, you don't need to have a single currency for global trade the way you used to. But you still have the question of the network effect of central bank reserve assets. So what are the Factors, obviously, there's a lot of frustration around the world. Russia and China have been very outspoken in saying they don't like the fact that the US dollar is the global reserve currency, but there doesn't seem to be a viable alternative either.

So what would happen or what could happen to create that viable alternative that would cause the dollar to lose its hegemony over the global economy?

Vikram Mansharamani: Sure. I think you're hitting the nail on the head here, Erik, by saying that it's really the lack of an alternative that it's sort of the TINA logic, if you will, right? There's no alternative to the dollar, so therefore the dollar will reign supreme. So I think there's a couple of different options that could emerge. Number one, I do think, as you've highlighted, the Chinese and Russians are very upset about this US dollar reserve status and would love to change it. Now, could you imagine a world where over time certain commodities are priced not in dollar terms, Perhaps the reference price for oils moves to being in yuan, or the reference price for gold or for other commodities moves to being in another currency. So that might be a start, and then you might see some dynamics around that. But ultimately, I don't think the global community of users of currency, meaning large corporations, individuals, et cetera, will have the faith in a Chinese currency unless it gold or precious metals backed in some capacity, and they may do some percentage backing or what have you.

But I think that's one possibility, and I think that's a 15, 20-year type plan. I think the Belt and Road Initiative was actually part of that strategy, right? I mean, the US Marshall Plan that took place here post-World War was to effectively rebuild Europe using our extra capacity, build it, create markets for our goods and services, services and ensure trade took place in US dollar terms. If we drew the analogy to the Belt and Road, well, the Belt and Road is using extra capacity within China to build future markets for goods and services in Central Asia, into Africa, up to Europe, and hopefully, or I mean, I think in the Chinese eyes, hopefully have that trade take place in Chinese yuan or renminbi terms. So I think this is a sort of grander, longer-term plan, and they may chip away at the dollar hegemony in the short run, but I don't think there's any meaningful full risk to dollar hegemony anytime soon. Now, with that said, there's some sort of non-currency currencies that I sort of refer to them as, which is you can think

of gold as a non-currency currency, but trade is not taking place in gold. But from an investment perspective, that's one way to sort of protect yourself. And then of course, there are some of these digital and cryptocurrencies. I'm by no means an expert on them, but the idea of something that cannot be politically manipulated or printed gives me great comfort in today's

Erik Townsend: Well, don't put it past them to come up with digital currencies that can be politically manipulated and printed.

Vikram Mansharamani: Sure, sure.

Deflation to inflation: what to watch

Erik Townsend: So there's lots of possibility on the horizon, needless to say. Let's move on now to another topic that we've been covering quite a bit here on MacroVoices, which is for more than a quarter of a century now, the economic backdrop has been either disinflation or outright

Vikram Mansharamani: Right,

Erik Townsend: deflation. A lot of people are starting to anticipate that maybe we're close to a shift, a secular shift to inflation or stagflation. Number one, do you agree with that prognosis? And much more importantly, number two, if so, what does it look like? How would that transition occur? How long would it take? What would the implications be?

Vikram Mansharamani: Yeah, look, it's, it's a fabulous question, Erik, because it transitions nicely from our prior discussion here of reserve currency status. So in the long run, I do think if the US dollar's at risk, we would see a massive devaluation of dollars, and that would result in a massive importing of inflation, right? So we would see if the dollar depreciated dramatically that the cost of imports would rise, goods pricing would rise, et cetera.

I mean, I don't want to be alarmist, but if we were to go back and study history to see how did Venezuela get hyperinflation, how did How did Zimbabwe get hyperinflation? How did Weimar Germany get hyperinflation? There's a couple of ingredients that tend to recur. One of them for sure is printing money, right? So, all right, we'll check that box here in the United States. Another one is deficit spending of large amounts.

Okay, well, I guess with a 20% budget deficit or plus, even higher than that, you can probably check that box. And then massive devaluation. occurs that results in the inflation getting out of control. We haven't had that here in America. In fact, we've had the opposite, strong dollar in this world. And so that would be something to watch. If you were watching for hyperinflation, I would watch the dollar. That could create the hyperinflationary dynamic.

On the flip side, the shorter term, let's call it a 3 to 5 year view, if not even shorter than that, the pressures I think still show that technology— so let's talk about the pressures. One is for sure, Technology, massive deflationary force on the world, on the economy, on goods and services, et cetera. And for better or worse, technology seems destined to continue providing that deflationary pressure.

On the flip side, I think we're starting to see more friction in the system, right? The build-out of a totally new economic— separate economic system, going from one globalized system to 2 globalized ecosystems, that's friction. And friction sort of adds, sort of, or sort of subtracts supply, if you will. And so maybe that's actually a little bit of inflationary pressure by having that frictional sort of introduction in that mix.

But then you have a reduction in demand because of demographics. So when you look through demographics, you see the aging of the world's largest populations. That's probably a reduction in demand. And so when I look and put all these in the mix together, what I see is Mild inflationary pressure building, if you will, here in the United States. But the things to watch that I'm paying attention to is number one, friction in the build-out of these supply chains. The higher the cost, the slower the time, the flow-through cost impact, that would change my view to say more inflation sooner. Secondly, I'm watching technology. If we in fact choose to regulate it, tax the robots, in fact break up big tech, put sand effectively into the gears of productivity that technology's provided. Well, that would be inflationary and I would be concerned and watch that. And then obviously the traditional metrics to watch are wages rising. And if we've got this dynamic where wages rise and prices rise, well, that of course, that wage-price spiral is something to always watch for.

And I think the central bankers are good to watch for that. But for better or worse, I think right Now, barring meaningful pressures in those ways that I just highlighted, we're sort of deflationary into slightly inflationary, but nothing alarming anytime soon that I see. Now, I'm watching very cautiously and very alert. I mean, my ears are perked up, my eyes are wide open, and I'm paying attention because it does feel like there's an imminent change in this deflation to inflation dynamic.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Vikram Mansharamani: thinking process in the data. It hasn't yet come through. And so I'm watching it, but I'm sort of nervously watching, but I don't have strong convictions yet.

Boombustology: five lenses on bubbles

Erik Townsend: Vikram, I want to go back to 2011 when you wrote a book called Boombustology, which was quite popular. For our listeners who may not be familiar with it, please give us the rundown on that book before we move on to your recent book.

Vikram Mansharamani: Sure. Well, thanks for asking, Erik. So that book was really a framework for thinking about financial bubbles before they burst. And so it was actually a fairly straightforward framework, which is using 5 different lenses to gauge whether you're in a bubble and the relative maturity of that bubble. Obviously, it's impossible to precisely time things like a bubble bursting, but you can get yourselves in the right neighborhood. And so what were those 5 lenses? The first lens was microeconomics, looking at prices and demand. So historical economic analysis, would have you lead to the conclusion that higher prices equal less demand or lower prices equal more demand.

But what happens when you get higher prices resulting in more demand? I would argue to you, you've got a bubbly dynamic underway. And by the way, you can see this. I mean, this is the FOMO trade, right? Higher prices, oh my God, I'm afraid. Let me, I'm going to miss out. Let me get in. And so higher prices resulting in more demand is a bubbly dynamic. Doesn't mean you're in a bubble. Just check one out of 5.

The second one is, let's go to the macroeconomic lens first, which is mispriced money.

So mispriced money is misused money. So when money is allocated in ways that might not make sense if it were priced more normally, then you'd be concerned. So one way to see a difference in sort of the appropriate pricing of money is to look at the delta between real economies, sort of economic activity and financial market activity. And when you see big divergences there, that may be that money's being channeled towards more speculation rather than investment. And so that's a concern. Mispriced money, misused money. So investment in the face of overcapacity is a telltale sign. And so, you know, when I looked at Las Vegas in 2007 and '08, there was plenty of overcapacity and people were investing a lot in the gaming sector to build out more casino capacity, et cetera, using borrowed money. That's a, that's sort of a classic example. Lens 3 is overconfidence. The, the fact that it's quote unquote different this time, there's a new technology, it's the new new thing.

And there's lots of ways to see this, but you can watch honestly popular sentiment where magazine covers talk about it's different this time. How, insert the technology, back in the 1920s it was the car, radio, back in '99, 2000 it was the internet. Every time there's something that says it's different usually.

And then the 4th lens is political manipulation and moral hazard. And so when investors believe that there's a heads I win, tails you lose trade, or you might think of, hey, I have an embedded put for whatever reason, central bank oriented or otherwise, that I'm more willing to take risk. And so I don't worry about losses. And when you have that biased risk-reward trade-off, you see bubbly activity.

And then finally, I look through a lens of sort of epidemiology to look at thinking about a bubble as a fever running through a population. And if you draw that analogy, what you start looking to is how many people are still left to infect. And there, when you have dinner party conversations talking about a particular asset class, or your taxicab driver's giving you a stock tip, or the bellman at a hotel you visit says, hey, I just bought and flipped this condo, or did that, then you know it's too late. That's a late-inning phenomenon, if we stuck with the baseball analogy. And so anyway, the Boombustology Boombustology was that framework described, used through historical cases. And again, in 2011, I then applied it to the case of China and suggested that China was in the midst of a credit-fueled investment bubble that was going to slow down, burst, and the result would be a sort of headwind against Chinese economic growth and implications for commodities, emerging markets, et cetera.

So yeah, that was Boombustology. Thanks for asking.

Think for Yourself

Erik Townsend: And you've written a new book called Think for Yourself, which will be released on June 16th, but available right now for preorder on Amazon. What's that one about?

Vikram Mansharamani: Yeah, so this is my attempt to take that same multi-lens logic and apply it to navigating all forms of uncertainty. And one of the biggest challenges I think many of us face today is how we interact with experts and the inputs we get into our decision-making processes.

And so what I'm suggesting in this book is we all need to take ownership of our decision-making. We have to stop outsourcing our thinking to experts, and we need to reclaim control. The phrases I use to, to talk about that are things like, we have to keep experts on tap, not on top, that we need to triangulate through multiple expert opinions, not just one, because every lens is biased and incomplete. So let's use multiple lenses, and that means tapping into multiple experts. And ultimately, it's about trying to think for yourself by imagining the opposite of expert advice, imagining alternative futures, and then owning your own decision by thinking about the big picture. So realizing, for instance, that experts all live in silos and are structurally unable to see the big picture. And when they're unable to see the big picture, they therefore can't take over your decision-making.

Now, you shouldn't So, you know, there's other messages in the book, the fact that breadth is undervalued relative to depth and that we should maybe have a more healthier balance when thinking about broad versus narrow and deep and dynamics like that.

But the book is really about navigating uncertainty and a framework for doing so in all walks of life, medical decision-making, financial decision-making, education decision-making, et cetera.

Erik Townsend: Well, Vikram, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues. right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: Erik's civil unrest predictions

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was a great interview with Vikram, and even during the interview, you guys touched on the riots and everything that's going on. So in this postgame, let's touch on the civil unrest in the United States over the last week. Listeners, I've prepared a chart deck showing market reactions to prior civil unrest events. You'll find that link in the chart book in your Research Roundup email. And if you don't have the Research Roundup email, you can just go to the homepage of MacroVoices.com and click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Now, Erik, you've been predicting an increase in civil unrest in the United States for years now.

Is what we're seeing this in the past week, what you were predicting, and what caused you to make those predictions to start with?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, for the record, when I moved out of the United States and moved to Hong Kong in 2009, one of the reasons is that I predicted riots in the streets by 2012, approximately the same thing that we're seeing this week I thought was going to happen 8 or 9 years ago. So I was either dead wrong or Almost a full decade early, whichever way you want to spin that. And there have been several false starts where I thought what I had predicted was starting with Occupy Wall Street, which ended up kind of fizzling out. Then in 2014, there was the Ferguson, Missouri riots. And then the next thing was probably around 2016, the 4 Dallas police officers who were killed. Then in 2017, we had the Charlottesville car attack. In each of those cases, I was thinking, okay, maybe we've just hit the self-sustaining chain reaction tipping point, which is going to cause this violence and unrest to escalate rather than de-escalate.

In each one of those cases, I couldn't be happier, Patrick, about admitting that I got those calls wrong or early or something, because in each of those cases, there was several weeks of unrest, but it did eventually de-escalate, thankfully. Now, as far as what's going on this week, certainly the killing of George Floyd by a police officer was the catalyst. It was the spark that got this going, the straw that broke the camel's back, if you will.

But I don't think that George Floyd really has anything to do with the true cause of this. The reason we're seeing all of this unrest around the country is because of what Chris Martenson has described as wealth inequality for a decade now. What we have is a situation ever since the great financial crisis where the government is bailing out financial markets, frankly, at the expense of hardworking people. And those hardworking people are, in many cases, don't fully understand what's happening to them, but they do understand that there's inequity there. And I think that's what's been driving driving this.

George Floyd was just the proximal catalyst that got this particular round going.

Postgame: the tipping-point chain reaction

Patrick Ceresna: A minute ago, you were saying something about a tipping point where escalation of civil unrest becomes a self-sustaining chain reaction. Can you explain and elaborate on what you mean by that chain reaction?

Erik Townsend: Sure. And this is based just on my own theory and my own interpretation of history and past events. There's a 2-part tipping point system, which I feel is essential to understand. And think kind of like a nuclear fission chain reaction, where there has to be certain elements in place in order to sustain the chain reaction. And if those elements are in place, it just keeps escalating and getting bigger from there. So the first side of this is what I call the public perception tipping point. In normal times, Patrick, clashing with the police is something that only criminals do.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: Criminals do. So good law-abiding citizens don't do it. They don't get involved in clashing with police. And they— if there's a peaceful protest that starts to escalate into something violent, all of those good law-abiding citizens just turn around and walk away and don't want to have anything to do with that violent escalation.

What happens is those people never make a decision, hey, I'm going to become a criminal and start clashing with police. Rather, they experience a perception that the situation has changed to where it's no longer that the criminals are clashing with police. Rather, they perceive it as people are fighting back against tyranny. They're being oppressed, and good law-abiding citizens ought to fight back and resist that tyranny. So it's a perception by public that suddenly the police are the ones that are breaking the law and that they're not doing something wrong. They're not being criminal to resist it violently.

What that leads to is the second side of this, which is the law enforcement tipping point. Now, as much as a lot of people will criticize police and say they're all corrupt and so forth, the reality of the situation is you've got some really bad apples in the police Unfortunately, but the majority of police officers are doing their job and doing a good job of respecting the rights of citizens and so forth. What happens is, as those guys see their fellow officers literally being run down in the streets, as has happened this week, run over by cars, police officers being shot and killed, just being attacked for no reason other than being police officers. Officers, then law enforcement goes through their own perceptual tipping point where they perceive suddenly, okay, this has turned into all-out war. It's us against them. We gotta shoot before we get shot. And all of a sudden, there's a major escalation of force by law enforcement because they're going through their own tipping point.

That escalation of force leads to a larger percentage of the public having its perception tipping point. Point triggered where they perceive this is no longer something about the criminals and the police, this is the police attacking law-abiding citizens, and now we're at war with one another.

That's the way that the chain reaction works, is you have those 2 tipping points where each time one gets triggered, it feeds into and allows the other one to get triggered to its next level of escalation. If that process continues And if that continues and they continue to escalate back and forth, eventually it goes completely crazy and you get to, you know, outright revolution and civil war and that kind of thing. Thankfully, every time these things have gotten started, whether it was Ferguson or Charlottesville or the Dallas police killings or what have you, there was a few weeks of unrest and it all settled back down again.

Postgame: is it different this time

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, but to your own admission, you first predicted this tipping point of self-sustaining chain reaction escalating a full decade ago, and despite a We've had a few false starts like Ferguson, Missouri, Charlottesville, and Dallas police murders. In each of those cases, there was a brief period of escalation, of violent protests, but in each of those cases, it settled down and de-escalated after a few weeks. Do you see anything different about this current outbreak that makes you think that it's different this time?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, let's hope not. I certainly hope that things de-escalate, but what could be different this time, what feels like it's different this time is in the past we've had an event happen in one place. A guy got killed in Ferguson, Missouri. There were riots in Ferguson, Missouri. There were some bad actors who traveled to Ferguson, Missouri just so they could be part of the protests and so forth there, but it kind of stayed localized. There were some sympathy protests around the country, but they never got to be as big as the protest that was going on in Ferguson, Ferguson.

What you see this time is all of a sudden, all across the country, all at once, there are massive protests. In some cases, the protests elsewhere are bigger and more violent than the ones that are going on in Minneapolis. Now, if all of those things were happening spontaneously and organically, suggesting that everybody across the country is just so fed up and so pissed off that they're resorting to to violence, then I would say, hey, that's a really big sign that it's different this time, and the first half, the public perception tipping point, is getting triggered in a much bigger way than the previous events, and that could lead to a really, really negative outcome.

The thing is, I'm not at all persuaded that this is happening organically. Now, at first, when people on Twitter and around internet were pointing out the mysterious appearance of pallets of bricks in these cities where protests were occurring, they were instantly labeled as conspiracy theorists and nutcases and alarmists who were circulating propaganda that was nonsense and so forth. Well, just today the Department of Justice announced a formal investigation because police departments around the country are reporting that they are encountering countering what feels to them like signs of coordinated command and control, that these protests are being orchestrated by some kind of centrally planned entity.

So how you interpret that is really a big question mark. Does that mean that we've reached the perceptual tipping point of the public where things have gotten so that a whole bunch of people have gone out and gotten organized, which would be a very bearish case, if you will, in terms of where it could be headed? Or is it just that a very small number of particularly bad actors are trying to influence the system and make it worse than it really is by organizing these events to occur in a way which creates a perception of a

Postgame: second wave, election, lab-leak narrative

Erik Townsend: much more upset public than actually exists. I'm not sure which is going on here, but I do think that we have a potential perfect storm setting up in terms of what is on the calendar in coming months, because a second wave of the COVID-19 crisis was very likely, from all the reading that I've done, completely independent of this unrest and so forth.

Even if there had been no civil unrest, it was still very likely likely, probably right around election time, around, you know, as the weather starts to get colder in the Northern Hemisphere, that you would have a second wave of the COVID-19 crisis.

Well, what we've got a setup for is current events. The current uprising is almost certainly going to be blamed by the other side, if you will, as the primary cause of the second wave. We were out of the COVID-19 crisis. We had passed the peak. Everything was better. We were on our way back to prosperity. And then those stinking protesters went, and because of their riots in the streets, that's what caused the second wave. So you'll get one large group of people who believes that story with incredible passion, because in many cases they'll have loved ones who were killed by the pandemic, who died from COVID-19.

And they feel that it's the protesters that caused the second wave that led to the death of their loved ones. Meanwhile, you've got already a rapidly growing group of people who think that this entire lockdown thing was a contrived act of tyranny, that it was never necessary, that it was invented by government, that it never should have happened, and that it was an This is a outrageous affront to the civil liberties of the American people. Those people are gonna feel, you know, it just creates this big us versus them blame game of who was responsible for the second wave and was it caused by the riots or did the riots have nothing to do with it.

It doesn't matter who's right in this story. You know, I think to the analogy of a religious war where the problem you have is everybody thinks God is on their side. You have a situation where people have such strongly held views about whether or not the pandemic itself is real and whether the lockdowns are a good idea that they're going to be blaming the other side for not respecting their interpretation of the facts. Doesn't even matter what the actual facts are. The point is, it's a setup for further divisiveness, for further tension, and for a further further escalation of unrest and social tension across the country. When might that lead to some kind of crescendo or breaking point?

Well, the US election in November is the obvious make-or-break event. So I think that, you know, hopefully what we'll see is a de-escalation from here. Everything will get better, and hopefully the, the officer who appears to have murdered George Floyd will be held accountable for his crime and there will be justice served and everybody will calm down and the violence will go away. Unfortunately, the risk is that it doesn't go that way, that we keep seeing an escalation of social division and of violence leading up to a crescendo with the US election. And at that point, you've got a setup where half the country is going to feel like a horrific injustice has occurred. The anti-Trump crowd is going to feel if the president is reelected as though that was a horrific miscarriage of justice. The Trump supporters, if he's not reelected, are going to feel like he was taken out unjustly by the deep state and it was all, you know, unwarranted.

Again, it doesn't matter who's right or wrong. The point is it's a setup for a lot of really strong social division across the country. Now, this whole thing thing has the potential to take on international proportions because the narrative that says the COVID-19 virus, SARS-CoV-2, was made in a laboratory and leaked out of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, that narrative is gaining more and more traction. And again, it doesn't matter whether it's right or wrong. The point is some people are going to think it's right and some people are going to think it's wrong, and that could lead us to the point where there's a major backlash of anger around the world against China. China, of course, will feel like they are being unfairly targeted. They'll respond with economic sanctions and so forth. And it just leads to more and more potential tension and growth of geopolitical tension around the world. So needless to say, we live in interesting times.

And I think now through the November elections is going to be a big tell. Is everything going to de-escalate or is it going to get worse from here? I have no idea, but this is a time to pay close attention.

Postgame: stocks and civil unrest history

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's talk about what this means for the stock market. You know, obviously stocks are up during this week of the violence, and I put up some charts to talk about it, but let's start with what is your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, as I said in the market wrap, my sense is markets are anticipating massive government stimulus, primarily accommodative Fed policy, to a lesser extent fiscal stimulus. It looks like another trillion-dollar round of fiscal stimulus is about to come out of Congress. I think that's what's driving markets. But it's important to Patrick to remember, you know, it's tempting to think, oh, well, clearly in a normal circumstance, the kind of unrest that we're seeing would normally imply a crashing stock market. That's not really true. I want to thank you, Patrick, for putting together a Terrific chart deck. Again, listeners, you'll find the download link to the chart deck in your Research Roundup email. Patrick, let's go ahead and dive into the chart deck starting on page 2. You're showing here the Martin Luther King assassination. You know, that didn't cause a crash in the stock market. On page 3, you're showing the Rodney King riots didn't cause a crash in the stock market.

So what does history teach us about what we should be expecting during times like these?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think the single thing to take away is that there isn't a lot of precedent that the stock market is responsive to the social unrest and civil unrest that it's happened in the past. And at least there's no precedent for it. And it doesn't mean that inevitably can't. I mean, I think of what was happening with the Yellow Jackets in France, and the CAC appears to have been dropping during that time, but that was during that really big market, global market drop. And so I don't think you want to even associate it with that. The point is that these things are very emotional and they're scary, but the stock markets don't seem to take it as a react— they don't react anyway to it, at least in the past. So what I wanted to touch on though, Erik, moving on, is I wanted to just touch on this move in yields.

Postgame: yields, dollar and inflation turn

Patrick Ceresna: And to me, it is certainly very interesting that we had this pop in yields up to 80 basis points on the 10-year Treasury yield. But really with the Fed intervention and the Fed funds rate being basically pinned to the lower bound, this is entirely a bear steepener that is kicking in.

And really, to my mind, there are 2 drivers. I don't have a chart of the dollar here, but clearly the dollar breakdown as the dollar weakness tends to be one of the core drivers behind inflationary impulses, as it usually drives commodity rallies and other things that cause inflation expectations to rise.

And so the big question that we want to continuously ask here, is this really it? Is this the turning point that is going to drive yields higher, create the steepener because the front end of the curve is pinned, drive a substantial rise in steepening and inflation expectations. And I'd love to get your take on it. Like, because this, to me, this is really about, is this dollar move just noise, just one of its normal temporary moves, or is this a major shift in the dollar? Because I think that would be a massive contributor to a rise in inflation expectations and subsequently drive these steepening trades to really start to gain some momentum here. What's your take on that?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the best that I can do is to answer your question with more questions. I think the important questions that we have to ask to eventually get to the real bottom line is, number one, is the zero bound a meaningful number? Is it, you know, the reason that we're kind of bottoming out here because we got to almost zero, or is zero Or just a step along the way to the possibility of deeply negative yields on the US 10-year?

I don't know the answer as to whether or not there's a meaningful boundary there. That's the reason I've been asking a lot of our expert guests that question. The other, I think, probably more important question is, I'm pretty much convinced that we are nearing a transition phase where we move from secular deflation or disinflation toward inflation or stagflation.

Well, is that really starting now? If so, that would explain this reversal, and it would suggest that we're about to move to much higher bond yields. Or is it more likely the case that it's going to take 3 to 5 years for that transition to play out, and maybe there's still more deflation to be felt before we get into that transition, in which case that's a different story. So, I think those are the 2 important questions that you have to ask. What the answers are to those, it's beyond my pay grade. I don't know. That's the reason I try to ask all of our feature interview guests those questions wherever I can.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I really do believe that the thing to watch is the dollar, right? I mean, there's no doubt that we just saw the break, but is this a sustained trend, because when currencies start trending, they don't trend for one month or a couple weeks. They trend for half a year or even multiple years. And I still don't believe that this is the beginning of a major dollar breakdown, though over a long enough time horizon, we will eventually be due for one. And so solving that puzzle is going to be, I think, one of the key pieces to determining whether or not inflation is starting up sooner than not.

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, another way to put that, Patrick, something I've said for years, is there's no doubt in my mind that our friend Luke Gromen will be proven right in the end. The thing is, I thought he was early when he started talking about the dollar really entering a secular decline phase several years ago. I'd say that I've been proven out as being correct that Luke was early in his view. I don't think he He was wrong. So is it time already for Luke to be proven right, that the dollar is going to make a final reversal to the downside and kind of lose a lot of value as the US dollar stops being the de facto global reserve currency and a lot of things change in the system? Or are we not quite far enough into this story for Luke to start being proven right?

I still don't know, but I'm convinced in In the end, Luke's view will prevail.

Postgame: range of outcomes and wealth inequality

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's return now back to the bigger picture in terms of the civil unrest. What's your take on the range of possibilities and where we could be headed here?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's a massively wide range of possibility. Crowd psychology is famously difficult to predict. A distinct possibility is that the current unrest dissipates after a few weeks, just like Ferguson, Missouri dissipated. That was a situation that was brought about by a remarkably similar catalyst, a person of color being killed by a police officer. It seemed like the situation was just crazy and going out of control. A few weeks later, things started to settle down. So there's the potential that this settles down as well.

The potential accelerants, like the catalysts that could make things much worse, number Number one, the COVID-19 blame game. If we get into a situation— I'm noticing this already— whether you wear a mask out in public is taking on this social meaning. It's almost like wearing a red Make America Great Again baseball cap. It's as if you're associating yourself or taking sides in a very strongly divided political divide just by the act of wearing a mask. Because people on one side have one strong view about how all responsible citizens have to wear masks in public. Other people feel like wearing a mask is a sign of not believing in freedom and liberty and so forth. Again, it doesn't matter who's right or wrong. The point is the people on both sides have very strong convictions in their views. It's a setup for more social division and potential Potentially a further escalation of civil unrest.

Next thing, number 2, presidential election. Either outcome is gonna leave half of the country feeling like a horrific injustice has just occurred. Doesn't matter who's right or who's wrong. The point is half the country's gonna be pissed off no matter what. So at the time of the election, when the announcement of the result occurs, that's potentially a trigger. Trigger point for more unrest.

Number 3, if the lab-made narrative about the SARS-CoV-2 virus gains further traction, if more people believe that it was a result of a leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology that led to this entire pandemic, that potentially— and again, it doesn't matter whether that's right or wrong, whether it really happened or not— the point is, if people perceive that to be the case, it leads to anger against China. That leads to China reacting defensively. It leads to compromised trade and geopolitical tension between nations, potentially even leads to military escalation. A lot of things that could go wrong there.

The real big if here is if we get to the point where that 2-part chain reaction, where first you have the public changing their view to where people who never would've clashed with the police start to think it's not a criminal thing anymore because the circumstances have changed. That leads to more violence against police. The violence against police leads the police to get even tougher in their tactics because they're watching their fellow officers get killed in the line of duty. And all of a sudden you've got a massive escalation.

Now look, those are the kind of things, you know, that if you wanna know What the beginning of a civil war looks like. Those are the kind of events that precipitate it.

Now, before everybody freaks out on me, I did not just predict a civil war. I said that's the way it starts. Most of the time when you have the circumstances which are the way civil wars start, they don't start civil wars. Things de-escalate, people calm down, and those moments in history are forgotten. Hopefully this moment in history will be forgotten. forgotten too.

The point is, though, that, you know, there's really no limit to where this goes. It's a question of how much that tipping point of tension between the government and the people escalates. And unfortunately, when you have catalysts like a global pandemic, even though that's not really the core issue, it really just adds fuel to the fire because people are blaming one another for who caused the pandemic, who What caused this second wave to occur? Was it because of the riots that are going on right now, that that's what caused the second wave? It's gonna lead to a lot of social division. So it's all a really big boiling point. And again, I don't think any of this is about George Floyd.

The real underlying issue is wealth inequality. Chris Martenson has a chart showing that the top 0.1% The top 1% is almost at the point now of owning more wealth than the entire bottom 90% of society. That's got to piss a lot of people off. And I think that that trend, which has really been going on since about 1980, of financialization of the economy, supporting Wall Street, it's not the kind of capitalism that I believe in. Unfortunately, I think capitalism is being blamed as the problem. It would be a return of capitalism that I think would be the solution to our current problems. A lot of people don't see it that way. So there's really no limit to the range of possibility here. Let's all hope that things de-escalate and we learn to get along with one another. And on that note, Patrick, we're going to call it a show for this week.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com.

Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to preorder Vikram's Think for Yourself new book. You'll also find a link to Variant Perception article about the pandemic as a potential trigger for QE in emerging markets, and an OilPrice.com article about what's holding natural gas prices back. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com.

Or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please rate Register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library, and the more registered users we have. The more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do. Not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Ronnie Stoeferle — fund manager; principal author of the In Gold We Trust report (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Open and guest preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 221 was recorded on May 28th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is dedicated to healthcare workers all around the world, the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis, and is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases.

The In Gold We Trust report has become an annual event in the precious metals market, and its principal author, fund manager Ronnie Stoeferle, will join me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss all things gold, including precious metals and the mining stocks. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick has prepared another of his famous postgame chart books, this week focusing on commodities.

Market wrap: S&P 500

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to the S&P 500, which just has not let up. This rally just keeps going. It's unbelievable for me anyway. But what's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, I'm glad I didn't short it last week when I had yet another chance. And, you know, my hunch was right. I think that what's going on here is the market is more interested in central bank accommodation than the fears that are leading to that accommodation. I think that there's definitely a lot of reason to still be concerned about the economy and a prolonged recession as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis. But it seems like the market is more focused on the upside as a result of all of that central bank accommodation. And I think that a couple of technical things happened. We both decisively broke above that 61.8% Fibonacci retracement. In technical analysis, when you get beyond that 61.8% level, it usually means on a closing basis anyway, if you're past it, that you're probably going back to a 100% retracement. Likewise, we just moved above the 200-day moving average, which is another aspect of technical analysis.

When you're below the 200-day moving average, it's usually a downtrend. When you're above the 200-day moving average, a lot of technicians perceive that as an uptrend condition. So in the last couple of days, we've both clearly closed above that 61.8 Fib retracement, also broken above the 200-day moving average, as well as all the other short-term moving averages.

And you know, it just looks to me, Patrick, Stochastics are kind of high and wavering, but looks to me like we're headed back toward all-time highs. Doesn't make any sense on an economic level. I think that most market participants are underestimating just how long the effects of this virus crisis are going to last and how negative they're going to be. But it doesn't seem to matter. It seems like everybody's pretty excited about the Fed continuing to be accommodative, and that's driving asset markets higher.

Market wrap: dollar, crude oil, gold, 10-year yield

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar because the US dollar just is breaking down. I mean, we're essentially at this stage almost down to the 98 level and breaking multi-month lows at this stage. Is there another leg lower coming here or is this just a small fake-out?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as early as yesterday, I thought it was just a fake-out because, you know, the support has been pretty consistent at 99 on the dollar index. And we dipped below that intraday yesterday, But not on a closing basis. Now today what we saw was an outright close, not only just below 99, but way below 99. In fact, below 99.5. It was 98.40 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon. Now we're still speaking just before the close, so in theory a reversal is possible, but it's extremely unlikely. It looks like today is going to be that closing print signal below 99.

And you know, that's an important I don't get really concerned until we see below 94.5 or so, which was the March low. But frankly, you know, that, that low happened at the beginning of the pandemic cycle. I think it's very interesting to see this. I was expecting this trading range to resolve in the other direction. So it'll be very interesting to watch in coming weeks. All right.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to crude oil because crude at this stage, at least the July contract, is still hovering very close to multi-week lows. highs as we are approaching around the $34 level. Are we due for some sort of a throwback on oil, or does this keep going?

Erik Townsend: Well, we've been getting that throwback, that correction on oil, and it looked like, you know, okay, topping out, maybe reversing. But just in the last day or so, it seems like maybe that correction is ending already. We got on WTI not even kissing the, the 13-day moving average, which is at about $13.75. Usually if you get just a small correction in an uptrend, it'll go down and touch that 13-day moving average and then move back above the 8 and the 5-day averages. We didn't even get all the way down to the 13 on WTI. We got below the 13 on RBOB gasoline, but RBOB is rallying off of the 13. Looks like it wants to retake its 5 and 8-day moving averages. WTI is already above its 5 and 8-day moving averages. So as much as I thought that this market was kind of overheated and due for a correction. Seems like we got just a little itsy-bitsy mini correction in the last couple of days.

On the other hand, if I look at the time spreads on the back of the curve, they've been hit quite a bit harder than the front month has. Now sometimes those time spreads are a leading indicator. They give you an early warning of what the front month contract is about to do. So maybe there's still some weakness to come. I'd say that based only on the time spreads. If I look at the front month price action, looks to me like we're already back to uptrend conditions. So it's going to be very Interesting to see what the next couple of weeks bring us.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, how did the oil inventories come in this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's very interesting, Patrick. We got a build on crude oil of 7.9 million barrels nationally. Now, in addition to that, there was also a build on the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. So if you count both of them together, it was a 10 million barrel build. That's pretty darn significant. Cushing, Oklahoma, though, which is the critical delivery location for the West Texas Intermediate crude oil futures contract, still showing drawdowns, drawing down 3.4 million barrels this week. Gasoline drawing down 724,000 barrels. Distillates building 5.5 million barrels. So we've seen pretty significant builds on both finished products and on crude oil. You'd think that would be the catalyst to bring on more selling and maybe a deeper correction, but if anything, I would say that the recovery in price has been pretty much consistent With, uh, you know, as the, the data came out this morning, we saw a little tick down as a result of that build. It didn't last very long, and the rally seemed to start from there.

So maybe the market was fearing an even bigger build than this. I'm not sure.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because it looked like some form of a gold correction was happening yesterday, and then suddenly this morning we popped back up and once again holding some pretty good supports. Does gold still break out, or are you still looking for a correction here?

Erik Townsend: Well, I was getting all excited, just as you say, Patrick. It looked like, you know, maybe we were seeing the beginning of a breakdown. But if anything, as I look at this now, what I see is really a pretty textbook, you know, trading within the range. Yesterday we managed to just barely kiss the volume-weighted moving average at 1685, and, you know, it looked like, okay, maybe we were getting to that breakdown level. Nope, got a nice healthy bounce. And this morning we actually went and penetrated those 5, 8, and 13-day moving averages just briefly. We're back below them now, but it looks like, you know, the, the bounce is on.

And the thing is, Patrick, I have to revisit my outlook for gold because what I've been saying, as our regular listeners know, for many weeks is, hey folks, get ready for the possibility of a really big technical correction. I'm still super bullish on gold, but get ready because, boy, you know, when you have a stock market crash, it tends to pull the precious metals down with it. Well, I thought we were looking at a bear market rally in stocks. I thought that a really aggressive sell-off in stocks might be coming, and that might be what could pull precious metals down with stocks. We're seeing the opposite. So if I'm going to revisit my view on stocks and say, okay, looks like the bear market rally is turning into maybe a rally back toward new all-time highs, then I think we might be headed back to cycle highs on gold as well. I do still think that this market has gone awfully high, awfully fast.

It does show signs of being due for a technical correction, but the impetus that I thought might bring one about, which was weakness in the stock market, looks like it's not happening.

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, let's just quickly touch on the 10-year Treasury yield, because really it's been range-bound for almost 2 months. One of the tightest ranges we've ever seen on a 10-year Treasury yield, just pinned between, you know, spot 6.0 and spot 7.0, just bouncing around. Do you have anything new to say about the Treasury bond at this level?

Erik Townsend: No, I really don't. And, you know, as I've said in the last several weeks, what I'm really focused on is the bigger picture of where are we in the longer-term story, not what's the next move from here, but, you know, is zero really a bound That matters. Are we headed toward negative interest rates? And what is the transition going to look like? I'm convinced within the next 5 years, we're going to get to secular inflation replacing deflation as the big picture macro backdrop. That's the really big, important story. Am I right about that? And if so, how's it going to play out? That's the question that I'm focused on in fixed income.

Why Ronnie Stoeferle and the In Gold We Trust report

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, this week's feature interview guest is Ronnie Stoeferle. Why did we invite Ronnie back to the show as a guest this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Ronnie is a fund manager, hedge fund manager, who's had a terrific performance record running a precious metals hedge fund. And in the last decade or so, he's kind of become semi-famous in the industry as the author of the In Gold We Trust report. Prior to this, the only way you could get that kind of detail on the gold market was to buy paid research, something like CPM Group's Gold Yearbook, which was very popular as well.

This is, you know, free stuff on the internet. It's available to everybody for free, and it's really excellent content. So the publication of the In Gold We Trust report has kind of become the event of the season for the precious metals market. It just came out yesterday, so we wanted to get Ronnie on to talk about it as soon as it happened. So we actually recorded this interview a few days in advance, but it was intended to be the first discussion. This is Ronnie's first public appearance since publishing this year's In Gold We Trust report. And of course, in your Research Roundup email, you'll find a link to download your own free copy of In Gold We Trust.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test.

But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Ronnie is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here.

Interview: origin of In Gold We Trust and why it is free

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Ronnie Stoeferle, managing partner, fund manager, and research director for Incrementum. Ronnie is best known as the principal author of In Gold We Trust, which, you know, it's almost bragging rights, Ronnie. I can say that I remember the, the old days when IGWT wasn't that big of a deal, but it's really taken on a huge following in the last few years. You're up to about 350 pages of heavy-duty research, and it's free. So tell us a little bit about how this came about. Why is it free? Why are you giving it away? And how did you get to the point of doing this?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Hi, Erik. Thanks for having me again. Well, I'm publishing this report for 14 years now already. I started writing it when I was an analyst at a bank. Back then, I kind of felt like the vegetarian in the big butchery because sitting in a bank and then writing about the gold standard and being bullish on gold is kind of weird. Then we set up our own company, Incrementum, based in Liechtenstein. And then the report got bigger and bigger. And for me, it's just It's just cheaper than going to the shrink because, you know, there's so, so much in my mind that I'm reading, that I'm researching, that comes from conversations with, with other investors, with people on the street, books that I'm reading, newsletters that I'm reading, podcasts that I'm hearing. So this is basically, I'm distilling this into one big report. And at some point we said, okay, we, we really have to take the next step. And now we are employing basically 20 people. To crunch the numbers, to edit the report, to translate it from German to English and also to Mandarin.

So it's a big project now, and I'm really, really glad how it's turned out. It's probably one of the most widely followed publications on gold nowadays.

The golden decade thesis

Erik Townsend: Something I've been saying since 2008 or maybe earlier was that gold is going to be the asset to own in the 2020s. I've got my reasons for that view, but it was very interesting to me as I saw the report, which was just released yesterday, Listeners, you'll find a download link to get a free copy of the report in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads.

Ronnie, as I looked at the table of contents, I see that you're, you're describing the dawning of a golden decade, which sounds like the same idea that's in my head, but I want to hear your version. of why we're at the beginning of a golden decade? Why is now the time to really be thinking about a secular move in precious metals?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah, well, we always got a leitmotif for the report. Last year it was the erosion in trust. And I think that the topic was really quite spot on. And this time we said, okay, let's really make a long-term outlook for this upcoming decade. And so we analyzed the whole macro picture. And I think this is something that differentiates our report from other reports.

This is— we don't really care about just the supply-demand picture of gold. We try to analyze gold from a macro perspective. And I think that if we kind of zoom out a bit, the environment for gold for this decade couldn't be better. I think the world at the moment is really running out of safe havens. From our point of view, the relative scarcity is one of the most important topics to understand gold. So the stock-to-flow ratio of gold is like 64. So you've got an annual inflation rate of gold between 1.5% and 1.6% every year, which is already quite a big advantage when it comes, for example, to the money supply that is growing on average by 7.8% since 1971.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Ronnie Stoeferle: So I think this relative scarcity and this solidity and reliability that you cannot be inflated at will in gold, very similar to Bitcoin, by the way, this is one big thing. Then I think that gold in this upcoming decade could take more and more the role of bonds. We shouldn't forget in 2008, Erik, Treasuries were sporting yields of, I think, 3.5%.

German bonds had a yield of 4%. Now, Now at the moment, you know, we're basically at zero or even below with most government debt. So I think the risk-return is very asymmetrical. Now with this whole corona crisis, I think that we can all assume that currency devaluations will be used to try to solve all the structural problems that we have. So this should also be quite beneficial for gold. And then we're seeing a renaissance of hoarding.

One thing that is really important: gold is extremely liquid. We're quoting a study by the LBMA that shows that gold is actually at some points much more liquid than than government bonds. So so this study is referring to the European Banking Authority's measure regarding high-quality liquid assets, and for some for some assets compared to some assets like like some government bonds but also corporate bonds, gold is much more liquid. So I think going forward we'll really see this this re-monetization of gold.

A second thing that I want to stress is we will— and here really the corona crisis is one of the biggest triggers— we will reach the limits of debt sustainability. So the International Monetary Fund says for the industrial nations, debt to GDP will rise from 105% now to 125% in this calendar year alone.

And then I think, and this is really a hot topic that we will be discussing hopefully, is we're seeing the end of central bank independence. So what we've seen in the last couple of weeks, I think Chris Cole said that on MacroVoices, he felt that capitalism almost died in the last couple of weeks. And I couldn't agree more. So from my point of view, this is really the point where MMT, helicopter money, universal basic income, yield curve control, and all those things will be implemented. Absolutely, absolutely for sure. So this, in combination with the current price action for gold that we're seeing at the moment, makes me pretty confident.

Inflation vs deflation and Rothbard's three stages

Erik Townsend: Ronnie, a theme that we've been focusing on here on MacroVoices for the last couple of months has been the The evolution from a deflationary macro backdrop, which has predominated the economy for the last decade, in moving toward, I think, either inflation or stagflation, something that is not deflationary. But I think that we've seen so much money printing and there's so much more on the horizon that it's likely that we move into a period of secular inflation or stagflation. First question, I already know the answer is, do you agree with that? And I think there's a yes because I saw it in the report. But give us your version of that. Why do you think that we may be headed towards inflation or stagflation? And how would it come about? And what would it mean for precious metals?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I mean, we all know from reading monetary history that gold is a pretty good inflation hedge. I think that's obvious. I think if we compare the current situation to 2008, 2009, let's have a look at TIPS, for example. The volatility in March and April was enormous. So TIPS were falling to -0.6, I think. And then within basically 2 weeks, they rebounded to positive 0.63. And this was really the biggest rebound in inflation expectations that we ever saw in history. Breakevens are currently at 0.7. And we've never seen a deflationary development like 2008, 2009, where the 5-year breakevens where we're at -2.2. So what this is telling me is that this time around, central bankers were acting much more quickly and much more aggressive compared to 2008 and 2009.

They've learned their lessons, but it's this time around, it's not only central bank action, it is also fiscal policy that is extremely aggressive. Until the end of April, we saw central bank liquidity injections of $10.4 trillion and fiscal stimulus of $10.2 trillion. So that's basically, I think that's roughly 20% of world GDP that was created just until end of April. So those measures of course are enormous, but we shouldn't forget that there's lots of deflationary pressure in the system. The problem is That that basically in this kind of creditism system that we are in now, we seem to have reached the limits for for loan growth coming out from from the traditional banking sector. So we shouldn't always blame just the central bank because we shouldn't forget that most of the most of the money is actually created coming out of commercial banks. And I think if we compare like really a big long-term view, if if we if we have a look at this inflation scenario. Scenario normally, and, and we quote Murray Rothbard from his wonderful book, The Mystery of Banking.

It's, it's really a great book. And, and Rothbard says actually there are 3 stages when it comes to inflation. So the first stage is when money supply is increased and, and prices, they hardly rise at all. So people think it's only temporary. And for politicians, this is like the land of milk and Then the second stage is when suddenly asset prices start rising.

And I think we've seen massive asset price inflation.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Ronnie Stoeferle: This everything bubble that Jesse Felder described so well. So at this point, politicians are basically facing a fork in the road. Should they either allow some sort of natural deflation and painfully reduce the excesses and approve a recession, or should they continue with the path of cheap money and thus risk the third phase? And the third phase is this stage, and I think we could be on the verge from the second to the third stage at the moment, when the public perceives that the inflation dynamic cannot be stopped and that it's gradually accelerating.

At one point, And people just say, okay, that's it. We try to leave the system and choose alternative currencies and hard assets. Erik, I think it's no coincidence that Bitcoin is one of the best asset classes this year. It's up, I think, 25%. So from my point of view, we could really be on the verge of this third stage. Now, I don't think that this is going to lead to hyperinflation, but we shouldn't underestimate the time lag that we'll see from all those measures that were implemented in the last couple of weeks. It's a bit like drinking tequila shots. You know, after 2 or 3, it really goes well. And then you have another 1 or 2.

And then at some point, you just pass out and wake up with a huge hangover next day.

So I think that politicians and central bankers completely underestimate the the time lag effects. Now, once velocity starts rising again, once the economies open up again and, and, you know, the whole sentiment is getting better, then I think is going to be the point when we, we really will see if inflation picks up significantly. But some of the reasons for rising inflation from my point of view are, you know, we're seeing much lower productivity. We're seeing that increasing, you know, populism, but— and we'll see probably less trade, less globalization. We're seeing that, for example, the whole ESG development is something really big. If you want to set up a mine, whatever, a copper mine, a coal mine, whatever, it's just basically impossible. So, so those are long-term effects that now meet those monetary measures and those fiscal measures. So from my point of view, inflation, it's not something that we should expect in the next couple of weeks or months, but it is something that we will see in the next couple of years.

And don't forget, Erik, we're seeing $14 trillion in bonds at negative yields. Now, the biggest pain trade for those $14 trillion, of course, is rising inflation. And at the moment, I think the average investment advisor is 52 years old. So during their professional careers, they've never really experienced any inflation. So this will be a completely new ballgame for many people in the industry. And I think that gold is already telling us, okay, friends, inflation is around the corner. It's gonna happen. Yeah.

Recession, the Fed and Corona socialism

Erik Townsend: Ronnie, you've expressed a view which is very consistent with what we've heard from some of our other expert guests, which is this pandemic was not the cause of the recession which is beginning. Rather, the recession was ready to happen. It needed a trigger or a straw to break the camel's back. The pandemic was the trigger that got it going. Please elaborate. How does this situation compare, say, to 2008, 2009? And what's your outlook economically?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah, well, I think I've been on the show with you, Erik, in August last year. And I said, you know, a recession is basically— is gonna happen sooner or later. And don't get me wrong, a recession from my point of view is something normal, something healthy within a cycle. But I think, you know, last year we have seen a yield curve inversion, which is one of the most reliable recession indicators, of course. We saw that the OECD leading indicators declined for roughly 20 months in a row.

We saw that 70% of world PMIs were negative. The US was already in an earnings recession. Germany was very close to a recession. South Korean exports, which is also very, very sensitive to world trade, were down. So I think it was pretty obvious that the economy is weakening significantly.

Now, I just finished reading the FOMC minutes and they sounded very, very concerned. So they said, okay, they fear that many job losses will be permanent. They said basically the word medium term much more often than in the previous FOMC minutes. So this suggests that the Federal Reserve doesn't expect a V-shaped recovery.

Actually, I don't see anybody but the stock market expecting a V-shaped recovery. So it means that the Federal Reserve will probably become much, much more dovish. Now, we have seen, and you did some brilliant shows on what was happening coming out of central banks, but we have seen from 2007 to 2014 that actually Fed total assets increased by 5 times from $900 billion to $4.5 trillion. From my point of view, at some point they will easily go to $20 trillion. I think at some point the Federal Reserve will start buying all sorts of assets. You know, they are now active in the junk bond market. At some point they will start buying stocks. Of course, I think the Federal Reserve Act would have to be changed, but it was already amended 4 times in history. So this just leads me to the conclusion that the market is conditioned to further stimulus like Pavlovian dogs. But those dogs now are really— they're fat, they're sick, and they're old.

So it needs much, much more food and much more stimulus to get them up. And this is something that really, really concerns me because it means that there will be less market forces, there will be more interventionism.

I once said it's going to be Corona socialism. And this is something that scares me as a libertarian. And this also means that after the Corona crisis, because now everybody is still kind of scared and nobody knows how this whole health situation is gonna turn out, but the next crisis will probably be a debt crisis. Ronald Reagan famously said, to say Congress is spending like drunken sailors is an insult to drunken sailors. Now, I think for last year, the deficit in the US was already 4.8%, despite the fact that the economy was still doing well. This year, I don't know what the number is going to be, $14 trillion or 14% of GDP. Nobody knows. It's an election year, so they will probably spend a little bit more. But those numbers are just outrageous.

And this just tells me, okay, we won't see positive real interest rates in the next couple of years. And this is then also a very, very good foundation for, for, for the price of gold.

Commodities and Opposite Land

Erik Townsend: Now, with the expectations that you have around inflation and so forth, normally that would be associated with a very bullish outlook for commodities generally. Of course, commodities have been really moving south pretty hard even before the crisis and even harder during the crisis. Sir, are you anticipating a turnaround for commodities generally? And does the weakness in commodities raise any caution flags with respect to precious metals?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I mean, commodities, it's tough. You know, the last few months were probably as turbulent and unsuccessful as, I don't know, Justin Bieber's latest attempt for a comeback. It was just the CRB, for example, I think is down like 30% this year. It's 72% below its all-time high while the Bloomberg Commodities is like 64% below its all-time high. So it's tough. And we're writing in the report, the whole world is upside down. And there's this great children's book called Opposite Land by Charlotte Rose, where basically she says everything is opposite in this book what it's supposed to be. So socks wear feet and broccoli is meat and behind is ahead and people poop from the head. So it seems to me sometimes like the whole world of investing is upside down, you know, with negative oil prices and negative yields now being, you know, it's just normal.

So from my point of view, when it comes to commodities, it's really a tough call. And actually making the case for commodities is painful. And when I tell friends that I'm pretty bullish copper, that I think that oil is having a pretty decent risk-reward, that silver looks fantastic. This is the point when people start ridiculing you. But that also tells me, okay, perhaps that's a good idea because most great investments, they start in discomfort. They really should hurt and they should give you perhaps sleepless nights. So from my point of view, commodities often come at the next stage. So first, there's always gold moving. Then it's normally silver. In silver, we saw a massive reversal from gold-silver ratio at 125 down to 100. So silver started outperforming gold in the last couple of weeks.

And normally, the third stage is that commodities pick up relative strength. So we make a comparison and show the parallels between the 1970s and the 2000s to the current situation. And each time we have seen previously a decade of booming stock markets, very aggressive central bank policy, and this basically fueled a rally in commodity markets. So I'm pretty confident because when our inflation view is right, then I think that people start buying real assets at some point. And I think that this fiscal stimulus, Those huge infrastructure programs that are considered now and that will be implemented. This could really be the catalyst compared, especially in an environment where basically nobody is bullish commodities and valuations are extremely low. So valuations of the commodity market versus the Dow Jones are at the lowest since the 1960s. So I see lots of value in the commodity space at the moment.

Gold as bond substitute and institutional demand

Erik Townsend: Ronnie, a question that you posed in this year's In Gold We Trust report is, can gold substitute for bonds in portfolios? Now, of course, historically, the argument against gold was that it doesn't yield anything. Of course, bonds don't yield anything these days either. So what's on your mind here?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah, I think that's— at some point, this might really happen. Erik, what we're seeing at the moment when it comes to gold is that generalists are getting interested again. This is something that we haven't seen like a year ago. Let's not forget one year ago when we published the last In Gold We Trust report, gold was below this $1,360 to $1,380 resistance. This is really, really hard to tackle and it tested this massive resistance zone a couple of times. Then early June we went above this resistance zone, and then gold really picked up momentum. And really, it started according to the Dow Theory. I think we're now in the second stage of this bull market, which is the public participation phase. So, so I see that many big institutional players are getting interested at the moment. I think the allocation when it comes to institutional players is extremely low, but we're seeing some, some hedge fund stars like, let's say, Paul Tudor Jones, but also Stanley Druckenmiller.

He became bullish gold a while ago. We're seeing Sam Zell, Ray Dalio, and so, so, so they, they already kind of rediscovered gold. From my point of view, and this is what we're, what we're doing with quite a lot of institutional clients at the moment, we're calculating for them actually what gold does to your portfolio.

Erik, you know our reports and we always emphasize that gold is not the answer to everything. It is not a religion. It's just something that has got pretty positive consequences for your overall portfolio. And I think we perfectly saw that in the last couple of weeks where gold actually really defended your portfolio. It stabilized your portfolio from losses in equity markets. So I think gold Gold did a brilliant job. It did exactly what it's supposed to do. And therefore, I think in this stage of the bull market now, more and more institutional players will come into the market. They will realize, okay, with 10-year Treasuries, with German bonds, there's only very, very limited potential. And basically with this whatever-it-takes approach to create inflation, to actually reach those 2 or 3% inflation rates. And at some point, I think they will say, okay, temporarily we need higher inflation rates. I think this basically tells you, okay guys, get out of bonds.

And then I think this will probably stimulate real estate markets. It will probably be positive for equity markets, but it will be most positive for gold, which is the most reliable inflation hedge that you can have.

US dollar and DXY risk

Erik Townsend: Ronnie, let's talk about the US dollar. A lot of people think it's about to crash and the, you know, the end is nigh. I don't really hold that view. I follow a lot of Jeff Snider's work looking at the global shortage of US dollars and the amount of outstanding US dollar debt. Now, historically, there's kind of an inverse correlation between gold and the dollar. And I think we should point out, you know, gold Gold has already broken to all-time new high prices in most currencies, but not the US dollar, probably because the dollar is so strong. So how do we reconcile for US dollar-centric investors, people whose portfolios are denominated in US dollars? Is there a caution here that maybe the strength of the dollar makes gold less of a good idea than it would be for investors who invest invest in other currencies?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I mean, you know, since the beginning of the year in dollar terms, gold is up 14%. Last year, gold was up 19% in dollar terms. Over here in euro terms, gold is up 16% year to date, and it was up 22%. And in other currencies like the Australian dollar, it is up 21% and, and so on. So of course, the dollar is The strongest currency at the moment. Actually, there's only one currency where gold is not trading at new all-time highs at the moment, and this is the US dollar. So we reached new all-time highs in Swiss francs, for example, a couple of days ago. So this tells me, okay, the world still regards the US dollar as the safe haven currency.

Now we're kind of interviewing 2 good friends of us, Luke Gromen and And Brent Johnson. And Brent, as we all know, he's making a tremendous case for a strong dollar while Luke Gromen makes, you know, more this de-dollarization view, which is much more of a longer-term negative case for gold. Now, Erik, I'm— I've got a very contrarian mindset, I would say. So, so we checked the analyst forecasts for the US dollar, the— or basically the DXY index on Bloomberg. And actually, there is no analyst, not one analyst, who's seeing a dramatically or a sharply higher dollar index in the next 3 years. So the consensus is basically it will go slightly lower over the next 3 years. And this is telling me, okay, Bob Farrell said when all the experts and forecasts agree, something else is going to happen. So I think that the risk is definitely out there that the DXY breaks to, you know, if we break the 102, then it can go to 115, 120 pretty quickly.

And this would basically cause the next crisis.

Now, I think there's a pretty big fight going on. And this fight is called Donald Trump versus the market. And we know that Donald Trump doesn't want to have a strong dollar, obviously. And he just said recently, it's $6.2 trillion and we can handle that easily because of who we are, what we are. It's our money. It's our— we are the ones. It's our currency. So this reminded me a bit of the, you know, John Connally back in 1971. The dollar is our currency, but your problem. And we know what happened afterwards. The US dollar devalued 50% against the German mark. So I think that Donald Trump, he's very, very much concerned about strength in the dollar. And we will see if actually the market will win or politics will win. From my point of view, I hope that markets will win. But we know that if the dollar breaks significantly higher, and I think it should be, then there will be a massive intervention from politicians, some sort of a Plaza Accord meeting, whatever.

But in the meantime, if it breaks $220 or even higher, this will cause dramatic volatility and turmoil in many markets, especially in emerging markets.

Gold miners

Erik Townsend: Ronnie, I want to talk about the gold mining stocks. And forgive me if I get anything wrong here, please correct me because I do not profess to be an expert on the mining stocks. But from what I remember over the last decade, it seems like usually Usually the trend is the mining stocks kind of anticipate moves in the market and they tend to be the leading indicator that lead the price of the metal. It seems very, very clear that mining stocks are trailing the price of the metal here. Is that normal? And if not, what's going on? Why is this happening?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, Erik, we do quite a lot of relative strength work because I think this is most valuable in a market that is basically just trying to discount and anticipate what central bankers are going to do next. So I think that absolute prices are heavily influenced by central bank interventions. Now, relative prices give us a significant amount of additional information. And what we're seeing now is that mining stocks picked up relative strength against the leading sector in the stock market, which is technology stocks. That's a fantastic sign. So mining stocks are outperforming technology stocks. Now, what we saw over the bear market, I mean, it was a brutal bear market. We saw that many, many companies, not all of them, of course, they really got— they did a good job. They did their homework. So the profitability of the producers has increased in recent quarters. We shouldn't forget that debt was reduced. They're having much more capital discipline, cost control. We're seeing that margins and cash flows are higher.

They even pay— and I think that's important because the Wall Street Journal just wrote that more companies in the S&P 500 have suspended or canceled their dividends so far this year than in the previous 10 years combined. Now at the moment, Yamana Gold, Newmont Mining, B2Gold, Kirkland Lake, they were all raising their dividends. So on a relative basis, I think that's a fantastic sign. Then we shouldn't forget that energy, of course, is a huge driver on the cost side and that most of the currencies are extremely weak versus the US dollar. So from the weak local currencies versus the US dollar, that's a strong effect for most of the miners that are in Canada, that are in Australia, and so on. So from my point of view, the miners really, really look interesting at the moment. They've got the highest leverage on a rising gold price probably ever.

And we are seeing that generalists are coming in. If you have a look at the charts and if you have a look at volumes, you can see that there's big volume in the large mining stocks like Barrick, like Newmont, and also in the royalty space like Franco, for example. So this tells me, okay, this is not only only the mining guys that are entering the market. This is really the big generalists that are now start investing in the mining space. So, so that makes me pretty confident. But I'm, I'm absolutely certain that, you know, with rising gold prices and rising share prices, many companies will, will screw it up again. They will do ridiculous M&A. They will start just, just stupid projects. So it is really important to, to do your homework in the mining space, to, to have a look, a very close look management, and of course also valuation measures.

I think it's a very demanding sector, but it's also a very rewarding sector. And this is why we enjoy investing in the mining space so much.

Silver and the gold-silver ratio

Erik Townsend: Talk to me about silver, Ronnie. It's an industrial metal, not just a monetary metal. That causes a lot of people to be concerned that in a recession situation, as you and I both predict, maybe silver's not gonna do so well. But the other side of that is, from a ratio standpoint, the gold-silver ratio hit— I think it was an all-time high recently. And that, of course, would make a very strong argument for a recovery in silver. So which way do you see this thing going down?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I— you're totally right. We've never seen a higher gold-silver ratio. It was at 125. So it basically means with 1 ounce of gold, you could buy 125 ounces of silver. Now we know that silver is kind of gold on steroids. So it's, it's, it's much more volatile. And we've seen that especially in the bear market. Now, from my point of view, if you have a look, and of course, industrial demand is much more important compared to gold and gold, it's just 10%. It's not really, not really relevant for prices. But But when it comes to silver's supply-demand picture, we can see several supply constraints working in silver's favor. So out of 8 sources of silver supply, only 2 are not in a state of near stagnation or even contraction.

So from my point of view, silver is definitely something that you should be considering if you're bullish on gold. Investor demand is basically nonexistent. And when it comes to the supply side, we shouldn't forget that silver is primarily a byproduct. It is a byproduct of copper production, zinc production, and so on. And if you have a look at CapEx plans for the big base metal producers, it was already supposed to be down big time before Corona and now even more so. So I think on the supply side, there might be problems arising. In the silver market, while when investors' demand really should be picking up, I think that silver can go quickly to, you know, $25 or even higher. It's just primarily from my point of view, and probably some silver bugs won't like this view, I think it's a function of the bull market in gold.

If gold does well, silver at some point will dramatically outperform.

Gold versus Bitcoin

Erik Townsend: Okay, Ronnie, I want to take a trip to the dark side of the Force. There are a growing number of investors, particularly younger and more tech-savvy investors, who would say, Ronnie, look, you know, nice try on gold, but look, cryptocurrency is the new thing, buddy. Gold is an antiquated relic. The only real value that it ever had was its scarcity. And cryptocurrency invents a better way of creating a scarcity asset. Forget gold, it's all about Bitcoin, baby.

What would you say to that?

Ronnie Stoeferle: First of all, this competition between Bitcoin and gold is just ridiculous. I mean, it's like saying, are the Rolling Stones better or worse than, I don't know, the Strokes? It doesn't make any sense to compare them. I like both. I like the Strokes and I like the Stones. From my point of view, there are many similarities between gold and Bitcoin. And Bitcoin was designed to be digital gold. We have now seen this halving a couple of days ago.

So actually the inflation rate of Bitcoin is only roughly higher. I think it's 1.8% at the moment. So it's roughly higher than gold's inflation rate. Now in 4 years at the next halving in 2024, the stock-to-flow ratio of Bitcoin will be 121. So it will an even harder currency than gold in 2024. From my point of view, it's very binary. So if Bitcoin should still be around in 2024, and I think so, I think it will be significantly higher. I think, you know, we just launched a fund that is doing extremely well that combines physical gold with Bitcoin. And then we're doing something that we call vol harvesting. So we're basically making use via options of the significant volatility that we are seeing in the Bitcoin space, which totally makes sense. And we really want to embrace the volatility in this space. Now, as I've said before, Bitcoin, I think, did a tremendous job during the whole crisis. It is up 26.7% year to date.

So I think that Bitcoin is steadily becoming really an asset that will also be considered more and more by institutional players. I think that in 3, 5, 10 years from now, it will just be normal to have a small allocation in digital assets, like it's normal now to be in alternative assets, in private equity, in hedge funds, whatever. I think this is happening. We're seeing many, many signs that really big companies are becoming more positive, especially because the regulation is now getting better and better. So it is not, you know, the Wild West anymore.

They've got their regulatory framework in the crypto space now. And I really appreciate the fact, Erik, that there's so much young talent coming in. We're talking to so many— and I don't know if I'm old, but I'm 39 years old— but there's so many young kids in the market now. And you start discussing gold versus Bitcoin with them, and you can see, okay, they're really bright kids. They're extremely motivated. They're great entrepreneurs. They really want to deliver better solutions to the market. And when those young kids start thinking about what is money, where does money come from, is Bitcoin better money than gold, or is it better money than the euro or the US dollar? I think this is a really, really important discussion that is going on. And therefore, I really enjoy talking to those young people. And I think, you know, our view has always been that most of the problems that we're facing at the moment can be traced down to our monetary system.

So this is probably some sort of the endgame of our monetary system. We definitely came one chapter closer to the end. And therefore, I think it's really important to understand how our monetary system works. And I think that gold is one, let's say, insurance against, uh, those developments that we, we have to expect. But Bitcoin is another good answer to it.

Correction risk and the $4,800 / $5,000 target

Erik Townsend: Final question, Ronnie. I'd like to ask your advice on a conundrum in my mind that, that's just been frustrating me, which is, boy, you know, you just couldn't ask for better long-term fundamentals for gold than what we have today. But you know, the problem with that is everybody knows it, and it's It seems like a whole lot of people are all in and we've gone really, really far up really, really fast without any significant technical corrections along the way. Are we overdue for a technical correction or are we just going to keep moving higher?

Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I agree with you. You know, sentiment-wise, I think that, you know, according to Sentiment Trader, it's not extremely bullish yet, but of course it is not like the super contrarian bet at the moment. Just anecdotal evidence, but a couple of weeks ago when, you know, everybody was crazy about, we're running out of gold and there's no gold anymore. And I said, relax guys, this is mostly logistical issues. You know, there's huge demand, an explosion of demand for gold, and there's an implosion of supply because, you know, there's no flights from London to Zurich to New York. But back then, you know, even my ex-girlfriend called me and I haven't heard from her in 10 years. And she said, I want to buy gold now. And I said, okay, Well, this is perhaps some sort of a sign that sentiment is now pretty positive.

But on the other hand, you know, when you talk to institutional players and they probably will be the drivers of the next leg upward, they don't have any allocation in gold at all. So I have to say that, you know, we are pretty bullish on gold. Because, you know, gold is rising in every currency.

So actually, I also have to quote Bob Farrell again because Dave Rosenberg, he always brings it to attention. And he said, markets are strongest when they are broad and weakest when they are narrow. So actually, this bull market in gold is pretty strong. Gold is rising in every currency. Gold is outperforming stocks now and it's outperforming bonds. months. So this just tells me that we're really in an established bull market. Somebody, I think it was, was Harris Kupperman he wrote this is an asset that you don't have to worry going on the beach because, you know, it's just, it's gonna do well. Of course there will be short-term, there will be, there will be corrections, but you should buy the dips in the corrections. And, and our, as I've said at the beginning, you know, this is a decade And therefore, I always really enjoy reading Chris Cole's stuff. And I think it's great that you're having him on so often. And he has this 100-year portfolio.

And what we did in this report, we calculated the 10-year price forecasts for gold. Now, of course, it's not easy because you cannot do a discounted cash flow for gold. But what we did basically Basically, we used the money supply developments and an implicit gold coverage ratio. And then we did a distribution probability. And actually at the end of 2020s, we arrive at a gold price at $4,800.

Now, the interesting thing is the distribution is clearly skewed to the right. So this means that significantly higher prices are far more likely than lower Now, if you say now gold will be at $5,000 at the end of this decade, people will say you're crazy. This is impossible. But from my point of view, this is gonna happen because we're seeing so many things at the moment where we would have said a couple of years ago, this is crazy. Negative oil prices, impossible. Negative rates, the Federal Reserve buying, you know, junk bonds now. This will never happen. So I'm pretty confident that this $5,000 target for the next 10 years, which is obviously pretty long, that we're going to go there. And of course, there will be corrections, but I think the risk-reward for gold is the best that I see in the currency space.

Erik Townsend: Ronnie, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Listeners, again, the free research report is called In Gold We Trust. You can find the link in your Research Roundup email or just Google In Gold We Trust. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Postgame: hand-off and chartbook introduction

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Ronnie back on the show. And when I was listening to the interview, I immediately Immediately when he started talking about the weak commodity prices and inflation and what will turn everything and the impact it'll have on the precious metals market, I immediately thought that we were overdue for a quick little tour around in the commodity market. So I'm looking forward to doing that right now and taking a look at where we're trading on so many of these different commodities during this crazy cycle in the markets.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think that is an excellent topic for this week's Postgame Chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link for the Postgame Chartbook in your Research Roundup That's also where you'll find the download link for the In Gold We Trust report. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads.

Postgame: commodity index

Erik Townsend: Patrick, as we dive into this week's postgame chartbook, this chart on page 2 really jumps off the page at me because what I see here is, boy, commodities in general just on a nosedive.

Patrick Ceresna: Yes.

Erik Townsend: dive trajectory. And then we get into the COVID-19 crisis, looking at the middle of February. There's that bottom there at, what is it, 59 or so on the Bloomberg Commodity Index. And then you've got some consolidation, but never moving to a new low. Now, I don't think that we're going to have another worse crisis next week.

So it looks to me like there's maybe an argument that that 59 on the Bloomberg Commodity Index was a low, I mean, a final low, if you think we're about to see a secular shift into inflation. But then I sort of think about it and think, wait a minute, my interviews with a lot of our guests have said you got the right idea, but that secular shift to inflation is 2 or 3 years off. We're not done with deflation yet. How do you read this as a technician, Patrick?

Patrick Ceresna: Is this a meaningful bottom that we should be thinking might be the Well, in technical analysis, generally the first observation you're simply making is that the predominant downtrend has paused and we are in a consolidation phase. And determining now whether or not that consolidation develops into a major bottoming formation, because a lot of technicians could easily see that as a, you know, bottoming formation such as double bottoms and so on, but it also could be the midpoint of a continuation pattern.

And really, I think that to step back, we have to kind of ask ourselves where we are in the current cycle, because the economy is sort of marching to the beat of a different drum than the stock market. And so we can no longer take just the bias of this V recovery in the stock markets driven by a massive flood of liquidity by the Fed, but rather commodities are really demand-driven, which is about when will there be a true economic recovery?

The interesting part for me is that it's going to be really hard for the demand for commodities to get worse than when you literally shut off the world economy to fight COVID. So there is a legitimate chance that while the stock market may still have more bear market to go, it may be that we're in a far later inning in the cycle for commodities. And at minimum, commodities may stop going down. I mean, it's going to be hard, for instance, for, I think, crude oil to beat minus $40 to make a lower low, right? And so, I think that it's entirely possible that we are seeing the bottom end of the ranges. But one interesting thing that will be very interesting to watch on commodities in general is that will we now enter a period of extended purgatory where rather than a meaningful rally, it's just we spend multiple years just consolidating along those lows. If you think about where— what gold did after establishing its bottoms in 2014 and '15, we still spent years discovering where the real base of gold was before the bull market started.

And it's entirely possible that we're just witnessing that at this stage.

Postgame: gold and super contango

Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to slide 3, gold. You asked me in the market wrap about this. What's your take on the technical analysis side of the gold chart?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, the one thing that the big debate everyone's having is almost the reciprocal of what we're seeing in that commodity index, which is that you seem to have now overhead resistance on gold. And the question now, are people seeing this as a topping formation or is this simply consolidation of that last bull run and the continuation pattern is about to come in? Now, for me, the most positive thing that gold has going for, which it could always change tomorrow, but right now, now, gold broke back in April to a fresh 52-week high, and the entire consolidation has actually occurred above the February highs. And so there's a, there's an old thing in technical analysis that what was previous resistance now becomes support. And so it's really curious whether or not gold can actually hold north of $1,700 in this consolidation, because that would mean that there's nice healthy accumulation that could be used as the— now the springboard to launch yet another advance.

And considering that the multi-decade highs of gold lie just north of $1,900, it's, it's entirely possible that if this consolidation holds, that gold may first try to go for a full retest of its all-time high before any bigger correction gets underway.

Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, something that has gotten my attention the last couple of days is we've now got super contango, which we've discussed in quite a bit of detail and what it means and so forth with respect to oil. We've got it in the gold market now. Normally, there's a rule for contango, which is there can never be more contango than what's known as the carrying cost, the cost of buying and storing the commodity, because otherwise it could be arbitrageable. Right. Arbitraged. If there was a really big contango from one contract to the next, somebody could buy and take delivery on the early contract, store it, and then deliver it into the next contract. Now, of course, with the COVID-19 crisis going on, the logistics of buying and storing physical gold and delivering it into other contracts is probably making those arbitrages difficult.

But I think it's really important for our I think it's important for listeners to know, when you look at the gold chart and you see, as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon, $1,713, and by the way, it got down yesterday to $1,685. Boy, sounds like a low number. Well, that's the June contract. And if you look at the December contract, just 6 months later, it's actually gotten to the point of trading $30 of contango, a $30 premium.

Patrick Ceresna: Wow.

Erik Townsend: Premium for the December of 2020 contract as opposed to the June contract. Now, there's no way that storing that gold just for 6 months costs $30 an ounce. So that's kind of an anomaly that probably is explained by the logistic conditions because of lockdowns and so forth.

But I think it's also a little bit of a signal that when we see this weakness in gold, it got down to Well, the only thing that got down to $1,685 is that contract that's about to expire, and maybe the reason that we've seen weakness in the price is because people don't want to take physical delivery of that contract because of these logistic problems that exist because of the lockdown and so forth. Just a little bit of speculation on my part that I could be off base on that completely, but something's kind of fishy there. with that huge amount of contango.

Postgame: silver, natural gas, iron ore

Erik Townsend: In any case, Patrick, let's move on to silver on page 4. What's this chart telling you?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, on silver, it's really interesting because gold was pushing basically 52-week highs on the upside, but silver was lagging in a big way. When, when it really got slammed back in February, March and sold all the way down to $12, it was basically trading at multi-year lows all over again. And when gold was recovering higher, silver barely retraced 50% of its prior loss. And so the last week or two really saw silver finally trying to catch up. And so silver edged higher and now is approaching that $18 level on the upper boundary where all those highs were from September and, uh, in the early first quarter of the year before the sell-off happened. And so So this is going to be really interesting to see whether silver actually has the gas in the tank to also break to a 52-week high here or not.

And so this is definitely one of those things to watch.

Erik Townsend: Let's move on and look at natural gas prices, Patrick. We've done quite a bit of coverage of crude oil, but we haven't really talked about natural gas. What do you see on this chart on page 5?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's interesting because the nat gas continues to also have a substantial contango in it, and obviously there's seasonality. and different storage issues. And, and a lot of the big storyline of nat gas is really, will, will these different shale producers end up having to, uh, shut down or not? And that will substantially impact, um, the supply-demand of, of, of natural gas, at least the supply side of it. And so, uh, it's interesting that we continue to see a massive lag on nat gas on the downside, never really participating whatsoever on the turn, but it really does seem to have established the lower boundary of this current cycle. I mean, it seems that we've now throughout the year tested this kind of $1.60 level on the downside numerous times. And so it's really interesting to see whether or not this is finally where a short-term low established on natural gas and whether it could actually do something bullish. I mean, I don't want to say anything and get excited about it yet. I mean, there's

no evidence that even the first inning of some sort of bull advance could even be underway, but it usually starts with an extended basing formation, which we can at this moment say is at least forming right now in natural gas.

Erik Townsend: Now, Patrick, a really important commodity is iron ore because it's a proxy for Chinese economic activity. Australia's biggest export is iron ore that goes to China, and China consumes a huge amount of it making steel and so forth. You'd kind of think, boy, it must be, you know, hitting a multi-year bottom right now because of the economic situation in China after the virus. But it looks like, if anything, you know, we're, we're almost on the verge of touching a new high, really, that's almost a 1-year high. What's going on?

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, it's, it's very strange what we saw in iron ore, at least not— I don't want to say strange. It's certainly not what I would have expected if you asked me what intuitively I would have thought would have happened to iron ore during this entire economic slowdown. But really, it never sold off during March. In fact, it held up as we approached the latter part of March into April. It went and just retested the bottom end of its lows. And throughout the month of May has now broken to multi-month highs. We're pretty much edging to breaking out a fresh 2020 high on iron ore. And I'm not sure what the supply and demand dynamics are driving it, but certainly this is not the, the type of a chart I would have been expecting when you told me that most of the world was shut down due to this COVID.

Postgame: copper, lumber, uranium

Erik Townsend: Well, let's take a look at another chart, which is a very different chart on page 7, and that's copper. But, you know, it's, it's kind of interesting because in many Copper is a proxy for the real economy. It's a proxy for industrial demand. China uses a whole lot of it. You'd think that, okay, we looked at iron ore, let's look at copper. It'll probably be a very similar chart. Totally, completely different. What do you see in this chart?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is exactly it. Like, iron ore held up very well, but copper took it pretty hard. I mean, we went at the start of the year, we were trading as high as $2.87 And, and then on even on an intraday basis, we're approaching $2 on the bottom end of the range during the very heavy sell-off. So very, very strong selling during the cycle. And really the recovery looks very much like, um, if I— a chart on the emerging markets or something where we had a very heavy sell-off and it's just retracing that very, like, in a reflexive rally, that move on the upside. And So this to me seems far more a reflection of what I actually would've thought we would've seen in the iron ore chart, and we did not. But the interesting part that will be the real tell for me is that copper established some very important lows originally in the summer of 2019. And now the rally is just approaching a retest of that, what it will now be an overhead resistance level.

And I think the real tell on, uh, Dr. Copper in terms of the health of the economy— will, will it be able to behave in a bullish manner and break this out?

Now, I personally am quite bullish copper in the long term, in the bigger picture, but I do think it will be, uh, quite sensitive to this actual economic cycle. And so whether or not copper manages to undo all of the early part of the year selling, or whether it rolls over here, I think is going to be a really important tell that we should not ignore.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, one of the tricks of the trade that housing analysts use is they look to lumber futures as a proxy for demand in residential construction because that's where most of the lumber gets used. What is this lumber chart showing us on page 8?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I was just going to point out that it's— isn't it amazing that the lumber chart actually echoes the copper chart? And therefore, it's the 2 commodities I think that are worth watching to actually really really see whether there is a true V recovery coming in the economy. 'Cause I'm more of the U-shaped recovery kind of in that camp. But yet if we really saw copper and lumber legitimately undo almost all of that selling and recover higher, that may mean that things are a little more optimistic than maybe we're giving them. But right now I think that lumber Copper approaching key levels where where if they were going to reject and let's say head back down to retest those lows, I'm not necessarily forecasting lower lows on either of the two commodities. But but usually if there's going to be an extended recession and prolonged period, then we should go and see a retest of the lows and establish a a core base from which the major lows will or the next major bull market will.

use as a foundation for a rally. And so these are 2 commodities that I think are a must-watch for anyone who's really trying to get a pulse on what's really developing.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, uranium is a commodity that certainly Marin Katusa has emphasized on the program. We've had a couple of other guests mention it, but holy cow, look at this recovery profile. What's the backstory to explain why in this, even during the, the crisis before the recovery really began in the middle of March. You can see a bottom there and just straight up from there. What's going on?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, the prices of uranium, like any— and like Marin was talking about, are actually considerably below their cost to produce. And that— a large part of that was because there was a huge supply, excess supply, that had to be worked through the system. And one of the, um, things that we saw was that with this COVID shutdown, it actually shut down a whole wave of different production of uranium and a lot of the uranium mining projects, which has allowed a lot of that supply now to actually be worked off the system, which means that uranium has to more than likely continue heading to a level where it's actually economic for a lot of these uranium producers to actually produce it, which some argue is in that approaching $40 level. And so the— this rally, while it looks like it's been a big one, it may actually still have a little bit of more meat on the bone, and there might still be some further upside for uranium prices.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: And of course, Patrick, these kinds of chart books and little updates on the market is what you do every day at Big Picture Trading. Listeners, as described on page 10, you can sign up for a free trial at bigpicturetrading.com. We're gonna leave it there for today's show. This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com.

Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the In Gold We Trust report that Ronnie provided, as well as this post-game chartbook we finish discussing. You'll also find a link to a great interview with Cullen Roche, as well as a Jeffrey Snider article titled The Optimists Have Some Terrible News for the V. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share If you have a great idea for a podcast episode and you'd like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, From myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com. The internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your device. Your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top