Grant Williams — Grant Williams from the Things That Make You Go Hmmm blog and Real Vision Television (as introduced on the show)
Announcer opening and episode preview
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the premier financial podcast featuring weekly interviews with the most brilliant minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is always free of charge, and unlike the mainstream financial press, we are not a platform for market cheerleading. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the business. MacroVoices is telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Nathan Egger.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices Episode 5 was recorded on March 10th, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. By popular request from our listeners, Grant Williams will be joining me as this week's special guest. I'll be talking to Grant about his forecast of an oncoming US recession, how economic conditions like those that we're seeing right now cause Grant to be concerned about a military conflict our future, and of course, Grant's work with Real Vision Television.
Equities: the ECB meeting and a bear market rally
Nathan Egger: And I'm Nathan Egger. We've got a lot to talk about this week, Erik, so let's get to it. We saw a lot of sideways chop in the stock markets this week with the S&P trading in a narrow 30-point range, probably in anticipation of this ECB meeting. And today that meeting happened. So why don't you bring us up to speed on equities?
Erik Townsend: Well, this was the big one. This was the big central bank meeting that everybody was looking forward to with great anticipation. And this is the one that we were told was going to make or break markets. If the ECB was accommodative, the market should go straight up. If the ECB was not accommodative, maybe not. What happened? The ECB was not only accommodative, they went far beyond the call of duty in being over-accommodated. And stock prices instantly went straight up where they stayed for all of about an hour. And then immediately began to correct sharply to the downside. So what this says to me is the market was waiting for this, maybe hoping for some kind of miracle to happen. You actually got a little bit of a miracle out of the ECB this morning. It was a pretty accommodative announcement in terms of what they're going to do. Yet we still can't get through the 200-day moving average on equities, and it looks like we're going to continue what I think is a bear market from here.
So I think that this has been a short squeeze and a bear market rally. I think it's over. Admittedly, I said that a couple of weeks ago at the 50-day moving average. Then I said it last week at the 100-day moving average. And here we are this week at the 200-day moving average. I do think that it's finally ending, though. And I'd say the caveat is if something unexpectedly happens and oil prices continue to move higher, that could pull equities higher as well. But I don't think that's going to happen.
Crude oil: production-freeze hype and inventory builds
Nathan Egger: All right. Well, let's cover crude oil next. The OPEC spin doctors have been in the driver's seat for the last few weeks. And last week you warned that If they could manage to jawbone the WTI market above $36, we could see that ignite some upside momentum, induce a short squeeze, and become self-reinforcing purely on the technical factors. And that appears to be exactly what happened. Good call, Erik. I'm sure you're very excited about this.
Erik Townsend: Well, I got stopped out of my short position in the process, so I don't know how excited I am, but it was pretty easy to read the handwriting on the wall here. What's going on is the market has become obsessed obsessed with this idea that a production freeze is a near certainty. Now, on the very first day that this production freeze discussion came up, it was debunked by all the bona fide experts who said this has no meaning. It's like saying we're going to freeze the Earth's oxygen content at no more than 21% of the atmosphere. Well, okay, it would be impossible with any known technology to change that number, so to say we're going to freeze it is a little bit It's silly, but that's what's going on here. It is ruling the market. My theory here is that in the old days, it used to be that oil was traded by oil traders.
These days, with the ETFs, retail investors and small hedge funds are all over trading oil, and there's a lot of people who don't know as much about it who are actively trading this market. A lot of people are assuming that production freeze somehow has some meaningfulness to supply and demand, which it doesn't.
So my fundamental view is as bearish as ever, no change there. I also want to emphasize, you know, my track record here. Last year, I was early twice. I had called both of the 2 major sell-offs in crude oil, but I was, at least in the second one, a couple months early. So maybe I'm a couple months early again. We could see this hope-driven rally, which is what I think it is, continue. I don't think that's going to happen now. And the reason I say that is if I look at the technicals, I think that the stock market is done. It's rolling over. I think that we've pretty much tested as much as we can in this crazy move.
Nathan Egger: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Unless we get an actual production cut, which would be completely, totally different, then I think probably the market is ready to roll over here. But I've been saying that for a couple of weeks. One possible scenario is we might have to wait for March 20th, which is the date that's been thrown around for this production freeze meeting. This morning I saw a headline that that date's off again. So maybe it'll be next week, the headline will be that that date is on. I don't know. We're going to have to wait until the market eventually figures out that production freeze doesn't mean anything and the market is still being oversupplied.
Nathan Egger: Right.
Erik Townsend: All right.
Nathan Egger: I want to stay on crude oil because 2 weeks ago, you and Art Berman agreed emphatically on a very bearish outlook for oil prices. You still maintain that view. But oil prices went straight up for the 2 weeks since that show. So, at first glance, it looks like you guys got the call wrong. So, with all due respect, Erik, what would you say to that?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think the question that you really have to ask yourself is, what would it take to prove that Art and I got the call right? That we were right in our fundamental view? And my contention is the answer is the last 2 weeks' DOE inventory reports. Art and I predicted that inventory would build and storage would be consumed. Not only did both of those things happen, but the March 2nd inventory build of 10.5 million barrels was just epic in proportion. This week's 3.9 million barrel build wasn't quite as huge, but it's still a very large build in inventory. Cushing was up 1.2 million barrels last week, another 693,000 300,000 barrels this week. So almost 1 million barrels a week on average that we're adding to Cushing inventory. We don't have 100 million barrels to spare. We only have 7 or 8 million barrels of spare capacity left in Cushing, and we're using it up at 1 million barrels a week.
So the bottom line here is that what Art and I actually predicted is already coming true. And we are being proven right in our call that oversupply would swamp available storage capacity. We're not wrong about that. What we also observed is that this cannot continue much longer because a storage crisis is on the horizon. So far, the market is ignoring that risk. But unless the supply is reduced dramatically, then inventory builds are going to continue and storage will eventually be depleted. That's an immutable fact, not an opinion. But oil prices are going up anyway.
So how is that possible? And I think the answer is very simple. Those of you who actually trade these markets actively know as well as as I do. Sometimes the market runs on fundamental data. Sometimes the market runs on human emotion. This is one of those times when it's running on human emotion. A whole bunch of people are really excited. Production freeze is imminent. Any day now, this is going to be over. It's been a couple of years. It's really frustrating people. They're ready for it to be over. They're psychologically and emotionally ready for it to be over. And that's all very fine and well, but it's not over. It's not anywhere close to over. We're still oversupplying the market by a couple million barrels a day.
So what is it going to take to resolve this? What are the risks in either direction? The answer is complicated, but primarily it comes down to understanding storage capacity and supply destruction risk. Now, obviously, you talk about supply, you got to talk about demand. Demand is obviously a consideration here, but I don't think it's going to be the driving factor of change in the price trend. I think this is mostly going to be about supply and storage capacity.
Nathan Egger: This is really important to today's market. So, yeah, I want to come back to storage capacity and talk about supply destruction risk. But since you said it's going to be a complicated answer, let's save it until after the Grant Williams interview.
Gold after the ECB decision
Nathan Egger: And let's talk gold. We saw it make a new cycle high at the end of last week, briefly popping its head above $1,280. But the metal appeared to be unable to sustain that momentum this week. Where do we stand now?
Erik Townsend: Well, we definitely got a huge bounce out of the ECB decision this morning. Before that, though, before the ECB decision came out Thursday morning, we were looking at gold prices trading below $1,240. So, as I look at this, what we've been talking about for the last couple weeks is what I'd really like to see is that $1,260 number exceeded and the market stays there. The definition of a breakout is when the market moves above a key level and stays there. When it pokes its head above a level for a couple of
Nathan Egger: Right.
Erik Townsend: And then goes back down, that doesn't really count. It was looking to me seriously like it just doesn't really count, like we're not really seeing the follow-through. Maybe this market is about to roll over, maybe it's a little bit ahead of itself. Certainly in terms of the breakout from the 200-day moving average, it's been very impressive. Maybe the market's gotten a little bit ahead of itself and needs to pull back, was my thinking.
Now, the picture has changed as a result of ECB. But that was obviously a dramatically more accommodative than expected announcement that we got from the ECB this morning. And what did we get out of it? You know, from $1,240 to $1,272, as I'm looking at the screen right now, that's $32.
That's pretty good. But that's all you can get out of an epically accommodative ECB announcement? I would have expected more, and I would certainly expect a retest of a higher high, higher than we managed to get to last week in gold.
Nathan Egger: Right.
Erik Townsend: We didn't manage to do that on an announcement that was profound in terms of how accommodative it was.
Bonds and stocks moving together; oil technicals
Nathan Egger: Okay. And what effect, if any, is all of this having on the bond market?
Erik Townsend: Well, what we're seeing— and of course, it's very unusual to see bonds and stocks trading in the same direction. They both sold off hard after the ECB announcement. Stocks recovering Thursday afternoon while bonds are still subdued. I think, though, in the big picture of things, what we're seeing here is we were pushing to lower and lower yields. We've had this rally for the last several weeks in the stock market. And of course, that's undone that. I'm really curious to see, are we going to get to still lower yields? Are we eventually going to retest that 1.36 yield on the 10-year from 2012? Are we going to see another, another opportunity like that? I think we probably will. Right now, we're going the other direction. Stock market has been going up. Bond market has been going down in price, up in yield. I think those Those two things are both about to reverse.
Oil is going to be the key if something were to happen, geopolitical upset. Based on what we, we look at the technicals now, oil could easily move to $40, $41 from here. But I'm hoping that this is over, that the market is going to wake up to the fundamentals and recognize we're still being oversupplied by 2 million barrels a day.
Nathan Egger: Thank you, Erik. We're going to come back and revisit the markets in more detail, including the European Central Bank announcement that we had today and more later on in today's show. But now This week's feature interview with Grant Williams right after this.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Grant Williams: the duck test and a US recession
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Grant Williams from the Things That Make You Go Hmmm blog and Real Vision Television. Grant, I want to start with a presentation that you gave recently, which you called the duck test. Why don't you explain what's a duck test? Why are you using this metaphor for talking about the economy in terms of what we're looking at in the macro picture right now?
Grant Williams: Hey, Erik. Thanks for having me on. Yeah, look, the duck test, I mean, look, it's an old test that many people do. And it's quite a simple one. It goes along the lines of if it walks like a duck, and it swims like a duck, and it quacks like a duck, it's probably a duck. And to me, it was really just an attempt to take a step back and amidst all the noise, and the differing opinions that we get, around the state of the economy at the moment, whether it be on a domestic level or a global level, just take a look at some of the top-line facts and strip out the noise and see what we get when we look at it.
And the point I was making was that we are heading for a recession in the US, and you're going to see an awful lot of people arguing both sides of that. And the economists will tell you that according to their forecasts, it's not going to happen. And one of the charts in the Duck Test, which was perhaps my favorite was from the St. Louis Fed website when they went through and they showed the probabilities of recession as measured by the St. Louis Fed going all the way back to 1970. And what fascinated me was that at no point in the last 45 years has that indicator hit 100%. So, even in the depths of 2008, there was only a 99% chance that we were going to hit a recession. So, clearly, there's something amiss here. And when you look at the various manufacturing numbers, you look at You look at what the equity markets are doing, you look at global trade, there are all kinds of high-level data points that suggest that this thing is looking, walking, and quacking like a duck.
So, rather than wait for it to be confirmed, which is always backward-looking, and rather than rely on the opinions of economists, my point was simply just take a look at the big data and see what your gut tells you. And to me, it's screaming recession.
One chart to rule them all: credit versus GDP
Erik Townsend: Well, I think that the presentation that you gave is extremely compelling. And, you know, the very first chart that you put up, I thought was fascinating just in terms of total US GDP versus total credit instruments.
Grant Williams: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And even finance professionals, people who do this stuff for a living, if you talk to 80% of them, what they'll tell you is, oh yeah, we had a big credit crisis back in 2008, too much credit in the system, and we've been deleveraging ever since. And it blows my mind. People really believe this. What's the reality of the situation?
Grant Williams: Well, it's funny that you picked that chart, because to me, I've called that chart in previous presentations the one chart to rule them all. I think that is the key chart that people need to look at to understand the big picture of what's been going on and what's happening here. And the chart— I don't know if we'll be able to put it up in the podcast, but just to walk people through it if they can't, it just shows the 2 lines of total credit instruments and US GDP. It goes all the way back to 1950. So, we've got a really good sample size.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Grant Williams: If you look at the chart, both lines grow in lockstep until 1971, which is when obviously Nixon closed the gold window, when they start diverging and the credit line starts to climb at a much steeper rate than GDP growth. And then you get to 1980, where we had peak interest rates. And from that point on, we've been in a declining interest rate environment. And the trajectory picks up. And so, what you see are these 2 charts. Just separating from one another to the point where you've got $60— $55, I think $55 trillion in credit instruments against the $15,000, $20,000, $15,000, $17,000 US GDP, which is obviously completely out of whack and just shows the level and the degree to which that expansion has been built on credit.
And at the very top of the credit instrument charts, you'll see this tiny little dip, which really, in the scheme of things, is nothing. And which is what 2008 looked like on this chart. And it just brings home the degree of pain felt in 2008 versus the total lack of any real deleveraging that we saw there. And obviously, since then, the chart has picked up the pace again and screamed higher because it has to. That credit has to keep expanding, or we're going to see some very, very bad things happen.
So I think everybody should familiarize themselves with that chart, if only to really get that slap-in-the-face moment where you realize that this entire edifice has been built on credit.
Erik Townsend: I want to encourage our listeners to open the presentation, which they can get from the website at MacroVoices.com. Next to Grant's picture and the description of this interview, you'll see a link there for download supplemental information from Grant Williams. And that includes this presentation. It's just shocking to me, you know, if you were to look at how adults would look at the situation in 2008,
Grant Williams: Right.
Erik Townsend: We had this really, really big lesson, which was there was way too much credit in the system. There was way too much debt outstanding, and a lot of it was low quality. And if there was a lesson to learn, it was it's time to curb our appetite for debt, stop living beyond our means on borrowed money, and get our finances in order. And if you look at this chart, it literally is— it looks like noise. The 2008 deleveraging for however long it lasted, was a tiny little wiggle in what is really just a straight-up expansion of credit.
And it's nonstop.
I want to move into where does this take us, Grant? Because it seems that all what you and I might think of as common sense, looking at this problem, realizing that we have an out-of-control debt situation, that the entire Western financial world is potentially at risk long-term if we don't do something about it. It seems like other than a few crazy guys like you and me, nobody really takes this seriously. It looks to me like what's going to happen is we're going to continue to grow credit and expand credit, borrowing and spending and borrowing and spending until something breaks. So, what do you think is going to break first? What's it going to look like?
Faith in central bankers as the glue
Grant Williams: Well, you're absolutely right. That's what we have to do because human beings have a big problem and a blind spot. In looking at really big issues. Demographics is a perfect example. People can see demographic change coming from decades out. We can project decades into the future demographic trends. And people can see them coming. They know they're inevitable. But they're just too big to deal with. It's too big to think about what are the implications for my portfolio of the Japanese population starting to shrink in 25 years' time, which is a problem that we faced in 1989. We all knew it was going to happen. But how do you do anything about that? So, you tend to ignore it. And that's what happens. And the ramifications of this situation correcting are way bigger than that, because it's going to require events of a magnitude far more severe than we saw in 2008.
The problem many people have is that they think 2008 was the event, and that it cleared the brush, and we're back to a sustainable path. Nothing could be further from the truth. But it's such a big concept. That people struggle to get their heads around it. And they assume, based on 40-odd years of bull markets and credit expansion, that they won't have to worry about it anyway. When it happens, and it will happen, you can go back as far as you like in history, and you see these cycles roll over.
When it happens, it's going to be very, very bad indeed.
What triggers it? The problem to me is that the thing that's now the glue that binds all this together still unfortunately for everybody, is faith in the ability of central bankers to keep this thing together, because they have done that. And the politicians have promised us things are getting better, and the central banks have thrown everything in their arsenal and more at it. And it's that confidence that is essential for this recovery, such as it is, to continue.
And I think when you look at it, and you look at the chances of these guys being able to fix this, they're very slim indeed. And if people start to believe that they can't fix this, then they have to act accordingly. And that means facing some hard realities. And it means divesting yourself of an awful lot of assets, at which point, it's out of the central bank's hands anyway. So, to have something as ephemeral as confidence in a group of academics holding the world financial system up is a terrifying prospect to me, because we don't know when it will evaporate or what might trigger it. But it could be tomorrow. It could be in 3 years. It's impossible to figure out what it will be. I think we're starting to see it.
I think if you look closely at things like the reaction in Japan when Kuroda, the Bank of Japan governor, after 2 weeks after saying that he wasn't even considering negative rates, moved to negative rates, you saw the immediate action of the market was to fall very, very hard, very, very fast, and the currency to go in the absolute wrong direction for the BOJ. And it turned around intraday, and it bounced and went up again. But it's those knee-jerk reactions, those instant moves without any commentary, without any spin from governors. When you look at where those want to go, which is lower, it gives you the direction that the market naturally wants to take. And I think people should be very, very aware of that.
Democracy and extend-and-pretend
Erik Townsend: Grant, this brings up a really interesting question in my mind, because the way I look at this is I think if you wanted to solve our problems, our economic problems back in the '90s, when, say, Ross Perot first started complaining about the national debt, it was doable then. But in democracy, I think you would impose too much pain if you were to try to really fix it now, not paper over our problems by printing more money, but really address the problem systemically of too much debt and too much reliance on deficit spending and so forth and all these bad habits of government. You would inflict so much pain that Any politician attempting that would get booted out of office. So I think we've reached a point of no return where in democracy, you can't fix the problems. All you can do is extend and pretend and keep hoping that we can stave off these problems a little bit longer.
But basically, we're waiting for things to blow up, and there's no other choice. Do you see it that way? Am I crazy to think that?
Grant Williams: No, I think it's incredibly unfortunate. But I think that's exactly where we are. I think you're right that the problem with Western democracies is they've all as they've developed and matured, they've all promised way too much to their citizenry, which they have to deliver. And there's just no way they can do it. And so, at this point, as you said, going back to that very first chart we talked about, that little blip, we saw what that looked like from the ground up in 2008.
And in order to bring those 2 lines and converge them again, the lines of credit and GDP, the pain is unimaginable. And so, of course, no elected body is ever going to willingly Is it going to willingly inflict that inflict that pain upon people? So yeah, look, I think their hands are tied. They have to keep doing this. They can try to make adjustments at the margin, but we all know that if you want to get elected, you need to promise people stuff. So you know, unfortunately, this is going to come to a natural end rather than an imposed end by an elected body. And and unfortunately, you would then end up running into the laws of nature, and the laws of nature dictate that that this will end.
Very badly, but end it will. In the meantime, you extend and pretend. And I think what people— again, I get back to this point I was making about these big concepts being tough for people to get their heads around and hard to imagine, so they tend to consciously ignore them.
We haven't seen anything like this in living memory. Realistically, there's nobody around now that remembers the Great Depression clearly, which was a similar type of credit purge. And we can extrapolate the last 40 years, which have been a massive credit binge. But because we haven't seen anything of this nature during that time, people assume they don't happen or assume that this time is different and assume that those problems have all been fixed in the past. So, we're never going to see that event again.
But we will. And my worry is that we're going to see it sooner rather than later. And as you said, there's really nothing that can stop it now.
Debt, economic peace and the risk of war
Erik Townsend: Well, and what concerns me the most, I talked to Jim Rogers about this in the first show that we did. If I look at history, Grant, what it tells me is that when governments screw up as bad as they have here, inevitably what they end up doing next is starting a war, because that shields the elected officials from responsibility. When you have a war, you almost always get complete blind patriotic faith in the government by the people, and people stop questioning their leaders. When I said that to Jim Rogers, he was careful to say, well, you know, you have to be careful.
You can't
Grant Williams: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Now, you can't say conclusively that the government does it on purpose. It may be that the circumstances just forced it upon them. But the reality of the situation is, every time we've had these circumstances, these kinds of economic circumstances where governments have borrowed and spent beyond their means to the point where there's no plausible recovery, it always, 100% of the time, leads to a major global-scale military conflict.
And what scares the heck out of me, Grant, is we don't know how to do this anymore. The world after the Cold War, you know, we sort of got to the point where we said, okay, nuclear war is such an unimaginably horrible thing, we can't let it come to that, so we just won't go there. Well, I'm really getting worried that if you look at the escalation of tension between Obama and the Russians and so forth, you know, we're not talking about Iraq and Afghanistan anymore. We're talking about very well-armed—
Grant Williams: Right.
Erik Townsend: industrialized nations that are getting very upset with us. And I'm really concerned that this economic situation is going to lead us into a major global war conflict. Am I crazy to think that? What do you think?
Grant Williams: Well, you know, again, this is— war is another one of those, of those big concepts that it's, that it's hard, you know, it's unimaginable in, in the literal sense of the word. And people just can't get their heads around the idea that they figure that's all done. But you're right. History is very, very clear, and it's a great teacher. And if you study it, you'll see that at these points in time, there is always a conflict somewhere between 2 global powers. And we're seeing the embers of that, I think, and we've seen them over the last few years.
What's interesting is I gave a presentation about this time last year called The Consequences of the Economic Peace, where I was talking about the path of the world since this peace that was broken after World War II and the Bretton Woods Agreement. And I was talking about big cycles, Kondratiev waves, natural cycles, and the war cycle. And as you said, it's a subject that when you talk about it, people instantly assume that you're crazy. And my belief is that these are all potential outcomes. As we've seen, they are potential outcomes regularly throughout history. So, you have to at least do the thinking about them and how they might come about and what you would do if they did.
And I gave this presentation first in December of 2014. And the room— I could feel the people in the room saying, what the hell is this guy talking about? There's not going to be a war. And the first question I got at the end of the presentation— and it was really based around the parallels between 1914 and the lead-up to World War I and the current state of the world, which if you look at those parallels, are absolutely uncannily similar.
And the first question I got was a guy put his hand up and said, so, are you saying there's going to be a war? And I said to him, no. I said, that's not what I'm saying at all. But what I'm very definitely saying is that there's not not going to be a war. And I wasn't trying to be cute. I think it's an important distinction to make. I'm saying that you cannot rule out the possibility of a war. And in fact, as always, there is a probability that we're going to have a war. And sometimes the probability may be fractions of a percent. But I think it's more than that right now. And it's something people need to be very much aware of.
And the more the economic pressure ratchets up on these governments, as you quite rightly pointed out, Erik, the more there is a need for a solution. And wars are, unfortunately, a very convenient solution to a lot of the economic problems that governments face. So, yes, I don't think it's It's a 70% chance we're going to have a war. I don't think that at all. But I think as the pressure increases, that level of probability increases significantly. And the possibility for a miscalculation ratchets up every single day. So, I think these outcomes are very much within the parameters of acceptable tail risk. And people need to at least do the thinking about what they might entail.
Why Real Vision Television exists, and the listener offer
Erik Townsend: I know that we're up against a little bit of a time limit with your schedule today, so I want to keep moving. But I've got to tell you, we're up against a conundrum now, Grant, because the tradition is to give the guest an opportunity to plug whatever they want to promote at the end of the interview. But I'm so excited about Real Vision Television that I want to tell them about it, even though it's your business.
Can I tell them, Grant? Please, pretty please, can I tell them?
Grant Williams: I would be far more comfortable if you told them anyway. Thanks, Erik.
Erik Townsend: Well, I really— and I think it's an interesting story. It's not just a matter of promotional consideration for what you guys are doing. You guys, you and Raoul Pal, are very accomplished in the industry. You have very, very complete networks of people, fat Rolodexes. There are a lot of things that you guys could do.
But instead of launching a hedge fund or doing something, any one of a number of things that would have been more financially lucrative for you, You and Raoul Pal launched Real Vision Television. So why don't you— I'm going to tell our listeners, first of all, it is the only thing in the world of financial reporting that I consider to be what we aspire to become. What we're doing at MacroVoices, what Nathan and I are doing, we're extremely proud of. I think that we're doing a lot better of a job, at least for the audience that we're targeting, which is sophisticated, high net worth, professional finance, more sophisticated investors.
We're doing a better job than everybody except you guys.
And Real Vision Television is who we want to aspire to be. You are doing amazing work. But I want to hit this from the human interest angle. What would cause 2 guys who have much more lucrative opportunities ahead of them to focus so much energy on creating Real Vision Television? What's it about for you guys?
Grant Williams: Well, look, I mean, that's incredibly kind of you to say so, Erik. And you guys are doing a great job here at MacroVoices. Look, Raoul and I, this all started over a dinner we had a couple of years ago, 3 years ago now, I think. And we were just talking about the fact that so many people— I mean, the general narrative around 2008 was nobody saw it coming. And it came out of the clear blue sky. And people were unprepared. And that's why it was so bad.
And Raoul and I said this thing. This is nonsense. So many people saw it coming. The stories of The Big Short and the stories of guys like Kyle Bass, fantastically smart investor and a great guy, making a lot of money out of being on the right side of that trade.
You don't need much more evidence than that. Of course, there were people that saw this coming, but the coverage in the mainstream media leading up to it was just very poor, and it served the public very poorly. People on the street were not prepared for it. And even within the industry, there's such a bias towards the bullish. There's such a bias towards a positive story and things going up because it makes everybody's business better. It makes everybody— it's easy to sell stocks to people. This is a business that's there to make money. It's the absolute ground zero of capitalism.
And so, people tuned out the bad stuff and focused on the good stuff, and that hurt the public. And so Raoul and I, as you said, we've put our time in.
We've both got— well, I've got the gray hair to prove it. Raoul doesn't. I don't know what the hell he does, but he doesn't have any gray hair. But we've been around a long time, and we do have decent networks of people. We've worked all around the world. And we know that hidden away in all the corners of finance, everywhere you look, there are brilliant minds doing fantastic jobs and really understanding what's going on. But they're never going to be put in front of the public.
They either don't want to be on TV, they don't want to go on to CNBC or Bloomberg, or CNBC and Bloomberg won't make the extra 3 or 4 calls it takes to find these people. We just thought, well, why don't we try and give the public access to a much broader array of financial minds who have nothing to gain from telling a bullish story, just want to talk about what they do in the world and how they see it.
And let people make up their minds. We don't want to sell advertising. We don't want to— it's not an exercise in dollar revenue maximization. This is an exercise in trying to bring some truth back to finance and give the public, and obviously amongst public, sophisticated investors, access to the pure thoughts of these guys, just the way you're doing. Let's sit down and have a conversation. There's no angle here. I'm not bringing you on for you to sell a product or raise money.
People listen to you, think you're a really smart guy and want to find out more, that's fantastic. But the idea of this is not to sell anything, is not to try and generate revenue for the people that come on, but just to spark an honest discourse about what's happening and just try and open people's eyes.
And so far, the response, I've got to say, has been incredible, both from the standpoint of the people we've asked to be involved and we've asked to interview, who've been incredibly gracious with their time and their thoughts, and the public who have embraced this project with something bordering on evangelical fervor. I think it's great to get this dialogue, this really open, honest dialogue going amongst engaged people to try and help everybody understand what's going on, and perhaps more importantly, what they can can do about it to position themselves for the next few years. So that's what we've tried to do. And we've been delighted with the response. And we've seen acceptance of the idea that we put together really start to pick up in the last few months as the visibility has increased. And 2016 looks like it's going to be a very, very exciting year for us.
So we're delighted.
Erik Townsend: I think that it's going to be an incredible year for you. And I guess we should probably take a step back here and just explain to our listeners, if there's anybody out there who hasn't heard about Real Vision Television yet, what it is, is essentially the antithesis of Bloomberg and CNBC. It is long-form, thoughtful interviews without interrupting the guest, very similar to what we do here on MacroVoices. But it is video and you get to see the person, you get to see a live interview. And what's your average interview, 45 minutes or so? It's definitely not the 3-minute soundbite.
Grant Williams: No, it's not. We did— we deliberately didn't want to do 3-minute soundbites. We We wanted to give people the time to talk and really explore their thinking and explain their views clearly. So, I mean, look, they range. We have some on there that are 5 minutes long. And we've done several interviews that in total ran to a couple of hours, but we spread those over a couple of weeks. So, the longest you'll find on there is about an hour, and the shortest you'll find is about 5 minutes. But they all average around, I guess, about 20 to 30 minutes.
Erik Townsend: But as you say, what I find fascinating about it is It is not marketing glitz and razzle-dazzle the way the cable networks do. You've got an unbiased, level-headed, bullish and bearish, both cases being told evenly. I'm just so impressed with everything that I've seen there. Myself, I have a fully paid subscription to Real Vision. I was able to negotiate with your partner Raoul to get our listeners an opportunity. So listeners, if you would like a a free subscription to Real Vision Television, go to realvisiontv.com/discounts/macrovoices, and you will find there an opportunity to sign up for a free trial. And I cannot recommend it highly enough. It is a subscription service. You have to pay for it, which certainly makes sense. You can't produce video for free.
And I think it's very attractively It's what, $400 a year?
Grant Williams: Yeah, $365, I think now, just $1 a day. So, we think it's great value. And we would urge people to give it a try. And as I say, if it's not for them, that's fine. We'll refund people's money, and we can all move on. But I think you'll find that if you are interested, and certainly, I know your listeners are very engaged, insightful people, I think they'll find an awful lot of really smart guys there that they can learn a lot
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I definitely would say that for anyone who finds an appeal to this podcast, you like our format, you're going to love Real Vision. Whether or not it's worth it to you to pay for a subscription, you need to make that decision yourself. But you're crazy not to take advantage of the free trial. It really is an awesome service. We're going to start there. And the other thing that we're going to do is we're going to get some of your classic interviews from a couple of years ago, and we're going to start playing them as a Sunday matinee. So in our MacroVoices iTunes feed, And at MacroVoices.com. Starting this weekend on Sundays, you'll find an additional program, not from us at MacroVoices. It'll be a rebroadcast of something from Real Vision Television. And we're going to run that for a month and see how it goes, see if that additional content is of interest to our listeners.
And if so, we'll continue it.
Closing thoughts: outcomes nobody wants to think about
Erik Townsend: Anything else at all, Grant, that you'd like to add? I know that you're on a very tight schedule today. We'd love to have you back on the program when you have more time to talk. Anything else you want to add to wrap it
Grant Williams: Erik, I'd be delighted to come back on anytime. But I just think the stuff you're talking about here, they're all extremely big concepts. And I think people really need to understand right now that it's a time to sit down and think about potential outcomes that you really don't want to think about. Let's face it, we don't want to think about deflation. We don't want to think about another credit crisis. We don't want to think about war.
But these are all possible outcomes right now. They're all in the mix, and you need to assign your own probability to them and understand, okay, what do I need to do to prepare for this?
I think if you do that, just going through the exercise will help you really get your head around a much broader range of outcomes. Listen to MacroVoices, watch Real Vision. The thing these 2 services have in common are just very smart people talking honestly, and you can't help but help shape your own investment strategies by listening to people who have been successful and are willing to give up their time and explain to you the lessons they've learned and the mistakes they've made, and what they think is going to happen. I just think you cannot have enough knowledge right now to inform your own decisions. Be curious.
Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more. It's something I've said before, and I really think that these are challenging times, if you are a little bit smart about macroeconomics, you put 2 and 2 together and you say, boy, I can use this knowledge of macroeconomics that I have and I can make a bet in the market and I can make a few bucks on a trade.
If you are really smart and know a lot about macroeconomics, I think you look at the picture now and you say, wow, this is bigger than making money and losing money. We're coming into a period in our lives which is going to be pivotal in history. Where our governments have screwed up pretty darn badly. And it's going to be a macroeconomic story that's probably going to be punctuated by horrible things, wars and so forth. And I just look at Real Vision and what we're trying to do here is helping people to understand the big picture of the world. And yeah, of course, there's application of that for those of us that make our living in finance, running money for a living. But I think it's more interesting just from the human interest aspect of where we are in history.
We're coming into an incredibly important time. And understanding the macroeconomic backdrop is going to be the most important thing, I think, in understanding the political, you know, the geopolitical near-term future of the world. It's scary, scary stuff.
Grant Williams: That's where we are. That's where we are, I'm afraid, whether people like it or not. There are a lot of scary outcomes. But, you know, I don't think you and I are having this conversation to try and scare people, just to try and make them aware of potential outcomes. I mean, the world carries on, the world gets through these periods, and we will get through this period. I don't think it's going to be without significant pain. So, it's really just a question of everybody trying to plot their own course through this as best they can. And services like yours, and hopefully what we're doing with Real Vision, I genuinely believe are ways for people to try and improve their possibilities of navigating these times successfully.
Erik Townsend: Well, Grant, I cannot thank you enough for joining us. Please feel free to come back anytime. We look forward to a continuing Partnership between MacroVoices and Real Vision, and Nathan Egger will be joining me as MacroVoices continues right after this.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your host. Erik Townsend and Nathan Egger.
Postgame: correcting the Real Vision offer; Grant's two presentations
Nathan Egger: Before we go any further, Erik, let's clarify that free trial subscription offer from Real Vision. What exactly is on offer, and where can our listeners sign up?
Erik Townsend: My apologies, folks. I think at one point that I said a free subscription to Real Vision was on offer. Obviously, that's not what I meant. What I meant to say was Real Vision is offering MacroVoices subscribers a free trial subscription to Real Vision Television. I also misread the URL for where to sign up, so let's just do this a simpler way. Just go to MacroVoices.com, and on the homepage, in the description to the left of Grant Williams' picture, you'll find a link where you can sign up for a free trial subscription to Real Vision Television.
Now, if you're a real glutton for punishment and you prefer the direct URL, it's https://www.realvisiontv.com/realvision. And again, the easy way is just go to MacroVoices.com, look for Grant Williams' picture, just to the left of that, you will find a link where you can get a free trial subscription to Real Vision Television.
Nathan Egger: So, Erik explained to you the Real Vision Television offer, but we've got some more stuff for you. There were 2 presentations mentioned by Grant in that interview. The first is the Duck Test presentation, and we've got a download link for you on the MacroVoices homepage. There, you will also find a link to the second of Grant's presentations that he referred to. And I highly recommend checking out this piece in its entirety. It is called The Consequences of Economic Peace.
And while that presentation was originally delivered late 2014, its subject matter is truly timeless. And while the subject matter, which is to say war, is a little uncomfortable, it would serve us all to know our history a little better. And Grant does a fantastic job of putting history into perspective and parsing out relevant information so that we can make better decisions in the present and prepare ourselves better for the future.
I'm a huge Real Vision fan, as I know you are, Erik, but let's take a minute to share with the listeners why we're partnering with Real Vision to get our listeners both a new weekly audio interview from their rerun library and a free trial subscription to the full-service video product.
Why MacroVoices is promoting Real Vision
Erik Townsend: Yeah, you know, Nathan, as I hear you talking, it almost sounds like we're in commercial mode, like we're trying to sell something for these guys. And I suppose in a way we are. I'd like to help them out because I really believe in what Grant and Raoul are doing at Real Vision. But we're not making anything out of this. We're not being commissioned. We're not trying to make money for these guys.
The thing is that these 2 people just resonate so closely with what Nathan and I are trying to do here at MacroVoices.
We want to focus not on yet another retail podcast that explains the difference between stocks and a bond to some brand new retail investor. We're trying to focus on professional finance, net worth, serious, sophisticated investors. And that's exactly the market that Grant and Raoul are focusing on with Real Vision Television.
The thing is, I just have so much disdain for the mainstream financial press and what Grant and Raoul are doing. And they're the only people out there, as I said in the interview, who are doing an even better job of it than I think you and I are doing, Nathan, is we're really trying to bring substantive content.
These guys are passionate about the content and they're bringing you a full whole hour interview with somebody like Kyle Bass talking about details of sizing positions in a macro strategy. Absolutely fascinating stuff. And if you look at this market, you know, CNBC and Bloomberg have already saturated the biggest segment of the market, and that is people who work in finance who don't have a need to actually know anything but need sound bites that they can repeat. They want something that somebody smarter than them said so that they can say it again in a meeting and sound like they know what talking about. CNBC and Bloomberg perfectly fill that need. If you want to actually have deep, meaningful, thorough conversation about macroeconomics and how the course of the world history is likely to change because of current events in financial markets, Bloomberg and CNBC, they completely ignore that. That level of content doesn't exist. Grant and Raoul are doing that and they're doing a fantastic job and my hat is off to them.
And I told
Nathan Egger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And I told them when we invited Grant on the interview, I just said, anything we can do for you guys, I'm happy to do it. We're not trying to make a buck. I just believe in the work that you're doing.
And the other thing I would say is these guys are the adults in the room. It is so refreshing to deal with people that don't think this financial podcasting thing as competitive. You know, I talked to Grant and Raoul and they're always happy to collaborate on ideas of what we're doing on MacroVoices, what they're doing there, because we're all passionate about the content. We want to deliver really great content. The world of financial podcasting, listeners, you wouldn't believe some of the nonsense that goes on. A couple years ago, we actually had one financial podcast host threatening his guests, saying, if you go on that other guy's financial podcast, my arch rival, I'll never invite you back on my show again. You know, this is just utterly childish nonsense. And Grant and Raoul are doing financial reporting for grownups, and that's what we're trying to do here. And my hat's off to them. I just think it's awesome stuff.
So basically, the reason that we're promoting them is because we believe in what they're doing, and I hope it brings them some revenue.
They obviously can't do this for free the way we can. They're producing full television with— you need studio equipment and lighting and all that stuff. They can't possibly do it for free. I think it's a very cost-effective product. I didn't get a comp subscription. I didn't ask for one.
Nathan Egger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I was happy to pay for a full-price subscription, and I think it's a fantastic product.
So basically, I just love these guys, and we're trying to help them because we really believe in what they're doing.
Nathan Egger: All right.
Oil storage capacity, Cushing and the buyer of last resort
Nathan Egger: Well, when we discussed oil in the first segment of today's show, you said there was more to understanding the fundamental picture, particularly relative to supply destruction risk and to storage capacity. I know we've spent way more time on oil in the last few weeks than normal, but frankly, I think the equity market and Just about everything else probably hinges on whether oil can really stage a recovery from here, as many are hoping for, or not. So it's super important to understand this. So let's go a little deeper, Erik, first on storage capacity.
Erik Townsend: Well, Nathan, storage is kind of a moving target, because in the United States, the tank farms are pretty well inventoried. We know how much oil is in those tanks. You get to non-US tank farms, and the governments in other countries are not as complete in their record-keeping So we don't really know how much available storage capacity exists in tank farms outside the United States. The ones that are in the United States are inventoried, but even that data can be a little bit misleading because when you know there's a certain percentage of capacity has been consumed, okay, but you don't know what the effective capacity is. In other words, if you always have to have a couple of empty tanks to To pump things into after you mix them from 2 other tanks. Well, that's an extra tank you have to keep sort of set aside. We don't know how big that set aside is. Is the last 10% of the theoretical capacity of Cushing all available to store oil, or was it something where it falls over and breaks when we get to 95%?
We don't know for sure. The other thing we don't know for sure is when you run out of those tanks that are reliably inventoried in the tank farm.
Nathan Egger: Right.
Erik Townsend: The next choice is floating storage. That's chartering a crude oil carrier ship in order to use it as a floating gas tank. How many ships are available for charter? That number is not reflected in any total capacity figure. So, how much left is a relative concept. You can measure how much capacity is left in terms of empty space in US tank farms. But anything other than a US tank farm, whether it's tanks outside the US or floating storage or anything else, You don't really know how much is there.
Depending on who you listen to, there are a lot of estimates. They're kind of rough estimates. Right now, what we do know for sure is that Cushing, Oklahoma is more than 90% full. This is a really big deal because Cushing, I contend, is what really counts. Cushing is the settlement point for the West Texas Intermediate crude oil futures contract.
What that means is— it's really important for people to understand the mechanism.
Nathan Egger: Right. Mm-hmm.
Erik Townsend: Of how the market works here. What happens when a futures contract is about to expire and there's not enough buyers? Well, the price goes down. What stops the price from just falling out completely to where it goes to zero? The answer is normally there's always a buyer of last resort, and that buyer of last resort is the storage arbitrageur, the guy who says, wait a minute, this month's futures contract is expiring
Nathan Egger: Mm-hmm.
Erik Townsend: $2 lower than next month's futures contract. I can buy the oil now, store it for a month, and sell it into next month's contract, and I'll pocket that $2 as guaranteed profit. It's that guy, that storage arbitrageur, being able to step in. He's providing that buyer of last resort that stops the market price from crashing completely. If there's no storage, there's no buyer of last resort, and all of a sudden, And then the price can go completely to zero.
So, it is an inherently fuzzy number, especially when you consider floating storage.
But as far as on-land storage is concerned, I think that we have at most 2 to 4 months before it tops out. I think probably less than that. If you look at the last 2 inventory builds in Cushing alone, it's been running about 900,000 barrels per week on average for the last 2 weeks. If you kept up that rate, which I don't expect we will,
Nathan Egger: Mm-hmm.
Erik Townsend: You'd have less than 10 weeks of storage left before we run out completely in Cushing. Of course, there's other factors. Some of the oil that's in Cushing will be moved out of Cushing, pipelined down to Houston, where there might be more capacity available. There's a lot of moving parts. It's very hard to tell. But in general, I think we've got a couple of months at most before this thing really blows up.
Now, if something happened in the meantime, if there was an OPEC production cut, if the If the oversupply were somehow eliminated by some other means, then that would change everything. But failing that happening, I think within the next couple months, we're going to be up against a storage crisis.
Oil supply: four upside risks
Nathan Egger: So that's storage capacity, Erik. What about potential risk to the supply?
Erik Townsend: Well, if we reach the point of a storage crisis, oil prices will crash until production is abruptly cut off. And that would probably mean prices in the teens. So, it's all about understanding what could happen to reduce supply before we get to that point. In other words, if we have the market oversupplied by 2 million barrels a day, as it is now, we're going to have a real problem, Houston, unless something happens. So, what are the things that could happen that would change the whole picture? And if those things don't happen, we got a real problem.
Well, the first thing— there's really 4 big risks that come to mind in terms of upside risk to oil prices. If OPEC and Russia and other large producers were to actually make a deal on a production cut, that would totally, completely change everything. Price could go anywhere from there. I want to emphasize again, that's OPEC and Russia agreeing on a production cut. Production freeze is meaningless. A production cut of 5%, both OPEC and Russia cutting 5%, would completely eliminate the oversupply. That's what we need to see happen here. I don't think it's in the cards anytime soon. I think that OPEC will hold out for several more months.
I think that OPEC— I say that, I really mean to say Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, and United Arab Emirates, which are the 3 countries that are acting together and really in charge of OPEC. I think that if those 3 countries hold out for several more months because they want to see the washout in US shale, they want to see the junk bonds collapse in the US so that there will never in the future be a source of funding for more shale wells in the US.
Their incentive is to not cut production. If I'm wrong about that, if they do cut production, everything totally changes because that could eliminate the oversupply before we get to a storage crisis.
The next one, production freeze. I put that on the list just to reemphasize. It is completely, totally meaningless in terms of effect on supply and demand. There's a caveat though, which is it has been a tremendous influencer of price. And these guys in the Middle East, you know, the Russians and the Saudis and the Venezuelans and Nigerians, they've heard of technical analysis. They know that there are key points where the market reaches a certain level, and if it gets some kind of catalyst that'll pull it up to the next level, usually it stays at that next level.
Nathan Egger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: These guys have gotten into the catalyst delivery business in the last month or so. Usually just a couple of minutes after the US inventory data comes out at 10:30 on Wednesday mornings, some oil minister from someplace has got some nonsensical rhetoric about how the production freeze is a near certainty, and it causes prices to rally. So these guys can influence price. I don't know how long they can keep it going. I think eventually—
Nathan Egger: They can't.
Erik Townsend: Eventually, the production freeze will be forgotten about when people wise up to the fact that it didn't mean anything. How long does it take? Well, how long does it take for the mainstream media to wake up to the fact that they're not reporting the news very accurately? At the end of the day, the point is that this production freeze thing is affecting emotions. As long as it continues to affect emotions, it will be meaningful, and then at some point it will be forgotten.
Nathan Egger: Geopolitical upset.
Erik Townsend: That's it. What if a new war broke out that takes 2 million barrels a day of oil production offline because somebody's oil field just got blown up with a bomb? That would certainly do it. And you might think, well, yeah, there's really not a whole lot of geopolitical risks other than the ones we already know and understand pretty well in Syria and Iraq and so forth. Well, wait a minute. Look at what's on the cards here. Don't rule out the possibility of one of these countries that's trying to support the price recognizing, okay, Okay. If we take one of our competitors, and remember that with the whole Sunni-Shia backdrop that you have in the Middle East, it's very easy to find a competitor who's also an arch rival, religiously, culturally, everything else. Let's take one of these guys and let's go bomb their stuff, their oil-producing assets, so that our oil will be worth more money.
That's an entirely plausible thing that could happen before this is over.
Finally, the last upside risk, US production decrease. Clearly, it's coming. No doubt. There has been a total collapse in drilling rigs, in the rig count in the United States, drilling new oil wells. And we've already seen that production has begun to decrease. It will continue to decrease, and it will accelerate its pace of decrease. But it's not going to be enough. We're not going to see the degree of supply destruction that we need to rebalance the market.
Nathan Egger: Right.
Erik Townsend: just coming out of the US as a result of what's already happened. We need to see a profound reduction in US production in order to balance this market. And that's not going to come just from the fact that we've been drilling less wells. The price is going to have to collapse in order to force that to happen.
Listener question: why not demand?
Nathan Egger: Well, an excellent point was made by one of our listeners and forum users. The forum user's name is GHF6. And he pointed out the demand side of oil. The discussion with Art got us well-versed in the supply and storage side of the equation, and we just recapped and updated our listeners on that. But we haven't really touched on the demand side. Can you explain why you didn't put more emphasis on the demand side of this picture?
Erik Townsend: Really excellent question. And I'm sorry, I can't repeat the gentleman's username from—
Nathan Egger: there was too many letters and numbers. GHF6.
Erik Townsend: I was just gonna say that. Hi, GHF6, whoever you are. Thank you for the question. It's a fantastic question, and there is a good answer to this. Normally, obviously, supply and demand go hand in hand. You can't talk about one without talking about the other.
In this case, I really believe that this situation in oil is a man-made problem. It is a man-made problem on the supply side. If you wanted to ask a question like, hey, does this How does this slowdown that we're seeing in the economy jibe with the oil price? And could it be that the oil price being so low is causing the economy to slow down? If you wanted to look at a question like that, then certainly you've got to get into demand on oil. But if you're just trying to understand what's happening here with respect to oil price, first you had this— First exogenous condition was central bank liquidity. A wall of money coming out of the Central Reserve. A lot of it went into malinvestment in the shale patch.
Then you've got the next man-made event, which is the Saudi decision not to cut production. I say Saudi position; in theory, it's an OPEC position. As far as I'm concerned, it's really a Saudi decision not to cut production in order to support the price, but instead to try to defend market share.
So these are all things that have had a profound effect on supply, and I'm convinced that they are the factors that are driving the market.
In a normal market, I would want to know about demand if I were concerned about a question like, what does the price of oil mean to the economic outlook for— is there a recession coming? Then you've got to dive into demand. If you're looking at what's happening with the oil price, I think this is all about a supply-side disruption, a disruption in the supply side of the supply-demand curve. And I think that's where the action is, and that's why we've been focusing on it.
ECB aftermath, next week's Fed and the oil-stock correlation
Nathan Egger: All right. I'm pretty certain that we've used up this week's time budget for crude oil. If anything else remains unclear, please ask us in the forums, you guys. So moving on, the ECB meeting today, it's a big deal. It's been widely anticipated. And markets didn't move in either direction. Well, they moved in both directions before moving in no direction, really.
What do you make of all this? What have we heard from the ECB today, Erik?
Erik Townsend: Well, ECB was way more accommodative than anybody expected, and it still didn't move markets higher. And what it says to me is that the markets were kind of waiting for a miracle that was not really possible. And when the impossible didn't come to fruition, the market started to roll over.
I suspect that we're going to still have some hanging on of people thinking, well, we've got a Fed meeting next week. So before the bottom falls out of oil prices and the stock market and we're headed down into the 20s in oil prices and below 1,800 in stock prices, when does all that start? I don't think it probably starts till after the Fed meeting next week. We'll see.
Nathan Egger: So we're looking for a Fed response to the ECB action today or the ECB announcement today. And how is this— how is this going to affect the US dollar rally that we've been seeing for years now?
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't think it's necessarily the Fed reacting to the ECB. It's a question of what's the Fed's policy statement going to be? And particularly, are they going to hike interest rates again? Almost everybody is assuming that an interest rate hike is off the table because it's completely crazy. They got to support the market with all the negative, you know, bad problems in the They can't do that. Well, hang on, look at the stock market. It's all the way back up as we're speaking now, just about 1990, 10 points shy of 2,000. It's not so bad right now. If you are trying to justify your decision and you are the Fed, the Federal Open Market Committee, next week, it's hard to say that we have to be accommodative in order to arrest a stock market crash.
Nathan Egger: Right.
Erik Townsend: The stock market has been rallying enthusiastically for the last 3 weeks. So I think that most likely they do nothing. It is possible— Jim Rickards in particular has been outspoken in saying that he thinks the Fed is going to hike rates again, hike rates next week. So if we just saw the ECB be profoundly accommodative and the Fed responded and was not at all accommodative, and—
Nathan Egger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: surprise the market by being tighter than anybody expects, that could really be fireworks. I'm a little bit skeptical. I think that Jim Rickards' idea of a hike coming next week is maybe a little bit too pessimistic, but it's possible.
Nathan Egger: So we didn't see a lot of action in the stock market in response to the ECB announcement today. But we have seen, at least since the middle of 2015, a pretty strong correlation between the stock market And the crude oil market, is that something that you expect to continue beyond this ECB meeting and, and further beyond the Fed meeting of next week?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's been uncanny how strong the correlation between the S&P and crude oil has been. And I think it's a matter more of crude oil pulling the S&P down. I think that most likely what will happen is that regime of strong correlation between S&P and crude will resume. That's my expectation. I have to point out, though, that today, in the wake of this morning's ECB announcement, it's the first time in weeks that I've seen, you know, crude and stocks and bonds all moving independently. You know, for a while, we just had stocks moving opposite of bonds and stocks and crude were moving in lockstep. Now they're moving all in their own independent directions today. It'll be very interesting to see if we come back into that strong correlation regime between S&P and crude oil that we've had for the last couple months. I think we will.
Where to hide: crude bottom, gold doubts, cash and the dollar
Nathan Egger: So if you're bearish on stocks and commodities, crude in particular, and you expect them both to roll over, where do you hide right now if you're, if you're an investor?
Erik Townsend: I think if I'm looking for new things to invest in, the bottom in crude oil is by far my favorite. I think I think that's the opportunity, certainly, of the last several years, if not of a lifetime. I do think it's early to get into the long side of that trade. So I think it's a wait for that. But I would be mostly waiting to make my move in crude oil.
Gold, I have mixed feelings about. And it's funny, I have a really hard time. I've been thinking about gold for the last few weeks because we bring it up on the show every week. I can't put my finger on why I'm just not buying this rally. If I look at the chart, very, very, very strong momentum above key technical levels. This is a classic breakout, has all the signs on the chart of looking like it's going much, much higher. For some reason, I can't put my finger on it, I'm just having a hard time believing in this gold rally. If you feel differently, though, in general, it looks like, at least on the charts, I don't know why I'm And I'm feeling this, this spidey sense is telling me something's wrong with the gold rally. But if I look at the chart, it really does look like a strong breakout. If you're a gold bull, buying precious metals here is certainly an opportunity.
And finally, I think cash is an attractive place to be. You mentioned the US dollar rally. I want to come back to that point. US dollar rally, I expect, will probably continue. It stalled out here at about 100. I wouldn't be surprised I'm surprised, especially if the stock market rout continues, to see the dollar rally continue as well. And so, you know, being in cash and US dollars is really not a bad place to be. I don't think you need to be fully invested in a market that's as crazy as this one.
Next week: Axel Merk; sign-off and disclaimer
Nathan Egger: I think we've just about covered everything that we need to this week, Erik. And listeners out there, know that we're working on another fantastic show next week featuring Axel Merk. And as many of you know, Axel is a currencies guy. So, I'm sure he'll have plenty to say in the wake of the ECB and Fed meetings. I'm really looking forward to that.
In the meantime, your subscriptions, your ratings, and your reviews on iTunes have been incredibly helpful and overwhelmingly positive. Thank you very much for all of them. If you haven't done so yet, we could really use your help. You can follow us on Twitter, @MacroVoices.
Erik Townsend: @MacroVoices.
Nathan Egger: And keep in touch with us in the MacroVoices forums, where we're still trying to stimulate conversation and follow up on the topics that we cover each week on the show. With all of your continued help, I think that we'll continue to recruit the best names in the business as future MacroVoices guests. That's going to do it for us this week. Tune in next week right here at MacroVoices.com. Take care.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.
Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Nathan Egger shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented. On MacroVoices, MacroVoices is made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
