Jack Schwager — author of the legendary Market Wizards book series (as introduced on the show)
Announcer open and episode preview
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the premier financial podcast featuring weekly interviews with the most brilliant minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is always free of charge, and unlike the mainstream financial press, we're not a platform for market cheerleading. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the business. telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Nathan Egger.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices Episode 7 was recorded on March 24th, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. Jack Schwager, author of the legendary Market Wizards book series, will be joining me as this week's special guest. I'll be talking to Jack about lessons learned from the Market Wizards experience, The human side of Jack's experience watching an entire generation of traders grow up reading his books, and his latest project, FundSeeder.com, which aims to help aspiring traders document a track record and draw attention to their trading talents.
Market wrap: equities, buybacks and the quiet period
Nathan Egger: And I'm Nathan Egger. Welcome back, everyone. Erik, we've just closed this abbreviated trading week with the S&P printing its first down week in the last 5 weeks. We've seen this ascending wedge pattern that has been forming since February 10th, and that appears to have just broken to the downside today, the afternoon. What's your latest take of the equity markets?
Erik Townsend: Well, as our regular listeners know, I've been saying for 3 or 4 weeks now that I think this is a relief rally and a short squeeze combined. I think that I'm surprised that it's gone this far, and I think it's due to roll over to the downside. It finally looks like that is coming true this week. It's a little bit early to say that decisively from a technical analysis standpoint. I think we really need to see a close on the S&P below about 2,000 in '27, 2028 or so.
And we haven't seen that yet, but I think we're getting pretty close to it. So I do think equities are headed lower from here. And I think also that we've seen equities definitely are starting to respond more. I've been watching the tape action for the last week and see that equities are really chasing the crude oil market. So I think what crude oil does is going to lead equities.
Nathan Egger: And earnings season, buybacks, do you see these things being potential catalysts for a move downward?
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I'm glad you brought that up, Nathan. I meant to mention it last week. We just came in this week. A lot of our regular listeners and people that have been following me for a long time know my view for several years now has been that the reason this crazy rally in the stock market has been able to continue nonstop since 2009 is in large part due to the easy money from the Fed enabling corporate buybacks. The basic thesis basis is there's a lot of easy money available in the junk bond market. The corporations borrow money in the debt market, use that money to buy back their own stock, boosting their share price, enhancing the CEO's year-end bonus.
That can only happen outside of earnings season for regulatory reasons. We just went into the quiet period around Q1 earnings this week. I think that that may be the catalyst that would suggest that until about the second week of April, corporate buybacks are essentially shut down for compliance reasons. I think that's going to be the catalyst to get the next move to the downside going in the stock market. And I would think that around the end of that quiet period, say around the middle of April, is probably when we could expect to see a significant bounce, probably from a number in the 1,700s on the S&P.
Market wrap: crude oil, the production freeze and inventories
Nathan Egger: And you mentioned that you expect oil to continue to lead or influence the equity markets, and oil's just recorded its first weekly loss in 6 weeks. It's been pretty quiet on the propaganda front this week, but we've got Plenty of influential data points that are still moving the markets. Are you still short crude oil here?
Erik Townsend: I am short crude oil. I was stopped out of my short trade just above $36 and got back in above $40. And I do think that there's a lot of downside. My downside target is $25, if not lower. I think that it's over here, this entire thing. If anything, I would say that the Oil ministers of the smaller OPEC countries like Nigeria and Venezuela. These guys deserve at least an Academy Award for their theater in jawboning the market higher with this nonsense around production freeze. The beginning of this week, they were still at it. This week it was Algeria. I mean, come on, who are we kidding here? Algeria. Who can even find Algeria on a map, for crying out loud? So Algeria announces that they will attend the meeting to talk about a production freeze.
That was more than a dollar spike up in the price of oil on that. That was Tuesday. Wednesday is the day they've been hitting us, and I think it's trying to offset oil inventory. So Wednesday is the day we usually expect the biggest propaganda. What happened was Wednesday morning, IEA came out and said, this production freeze thing doesn't make any sense. It's not relevant. It doesn't have any meaning. I think that's probably been the biggest catalyst to start oil selling off and moving in the direction that I think is long overdue. The big thing that Art Berman and I predicted, though, was an increase in crude oil inventories. We saw the beginning of that this week with a 9.5 million barrel build in US crude oil inventories. That's 3 times analysts' expectations of about a 3 million barrel build. And remember, we're running out of storage. You know, 10 million barrels in one week, that's a lot.
I think that the market would have dramatically, dramatically reacted to the downside, except for one thing. And that is that the Cushing, Oklahoma component of that inventory was actually a drawdown. So, we saw an increase nationwide, but a drawdown in Cushing, Oklahoma inventory. As we've discussed before on the show, Cushing is crucially important because it's the settlement point for the West Texas Intermediate crude oil futures contract. So, if you run out of storage capacity in Cushing, you're essentially eliminating the buyer of last resort that would normally step in and buy an expiring contract in order to sell it forward into the next month. So, Cushing is critically important. We saw a little bit of relief in the Cushing front. And I think that the expectation that Art and I have, which is several more big inventory builds, definitely heightened by the fact that we're going into refinery maintenance season right now. What happens is every fall and every spring, the refineries have to retool in order to set their production for the next grade of gasoline.
In other words, there's different grades of gasoline for consumption in the wintertime and the summertime.
Nathan Egger: Right.
Erik Townsend: They've got to throw all the valves and switches over and set the refinery up to produce summertime gasoline instead of wintertime gasoline. That maintenance period means that they are drawing less crude oil stocks. It puts more pressure on the storage capacity problems that we've talked about. So I think for the next 5 to 6 weeks, as we go through maintenance season, is when we're going to see a string of really big inventory builds. That's the prognosis that Art Berman and I have had. Started to come true with this week's report. It was a muted reaction because of Cushing. I think that this week's report was also affected by a lot of kind of crazy one-time factors. There were storms off the Gulf of Mexico that delayed the arrival of some ships that should have gotten to port 2 weeks ago, got to port this last week.
It looks like a huge, huge spike in imports this past week. I think that's more just a case of the prior week's imports couldn't get into port because of the weather, and now they arrived all at the same time. There was also some fog around the Houston Ship Channel that was affecting things. So there's been some disruptions here. I think we're going to see more builds not only on national inventory but on Cushing, Oklahoma inventory. And that will be the catalyst for the downside in the price. Finally, on oil, the thing that I observe is it looks to me— and this is just as we're speaking late session on Thursday— we could be seeing the beginning of a very striking head and shoulders pattern in the crude oil futures market. If you look at the CL futures contract and the May delivery contract, a very impressive left shoulder and then head, and we could be just this afternoon on Thursday seeing the beginning of the formation of a right shoulder.
That's just a guess at this point. If it comes true, what we would see is oil rally from here back up to about $40, $40.50, in there somewhere. Somewhere below $40.50, it would roll back over in the next week, and then when it took out that neckline trading back below today's low, which was just around $38.60, $38.60 on the May delivery contract. If we were to go up to $40.50 and then back down below $38.60 or $38.50, say, that would be a completed head and shoulders pattern. I don't know that that's going to happen, but I'm certainly going to be watching it closely over the next week to see what comes to fruition. In both the chart and in, I think, finally with IEA denouncing this production freeze as being nonsense. The next question in my mind is, what do they replace it with? The production freeze is not going to buy anything anymore in terms of propaganda.
So is the next thing going to be production jubilee, a production something else? They can't get a cut. They know they're not going to get that. What rhymes with production cut that the market might buy now that IEA has discredited this idea of a production freeze? I think I think they'll come up with something. We'll see what next week's theater brings.
Market wrap: gold, the April Fed meeting and the dollar
Nathan Egger: Production, but— and the algos could pick up on that. Something you've been saying, Erik, since our inaugural episode and beyond is that on a technical basis, the breakout in gold has looked very convincing. And you haven't been able to put your finger on it exactly, but you haven't been buying this rally. Now it looks like that market's rolling over. It's been a pretty rough week for gold investors. What are your thoughts here, Erik?
Erik Townsend: Well, we're coming up on a very, very important crossroads here, which is the 50-day moving average. As I've said before, I can't believe in this gold rally, and I'm having a hard time putting my finger on why. In a lot of ways, looking at the chart, it appears to be an impressive breakout. I just have a feeling that the dollar rally is not over, and the bottom in gold prices is not in yet. I think we're gonna test $1,000 before this thing is over. I could be completely wrong about that. What's your target?
Well, we're probably about to find out in the next few days here, because if I'm right, we'll break down through the 50-day moving average, which as we speak today on Thursday afternoon is running right around $1,200. If we see the breakdown below $1,200, and especially if that were to continue below $1,140 or so, which is where the 200-day moving average is, that really would confirm my thesis that this was a false breakout. It's correcting back to the downside. It's not time yet for gold. If we bounce off of the 50-day moving average, or in other words, if the price stays above $1,200, and particularly if it breaks above $1,280, the previous high, that says to me, boy, this is really looking like a healthy technical rally, and perhaps it's got legs to it. So far, I haven't bought it, though.
Nathan Egger: And do you see expectations around an April rate hike influencing the direction of gold in the coming months?
Erik Townsend: Oh, absolutely. You know, I think that the fact that the April meeting is live again, the slang that's been used by traders is the meeting is live if it means that there is a possibility that the Fed will actually change policy and hike or cut rates. They've been saying that the April meeting is live. They don't need a meeting that has a press release in order to have a rate hike. If they hike rates, that, you know, gold's direct competitor is Treasuries. And the biggest argument against gold is it doesn't produce It doesn't produce any income, doesn't throw off any yield. If the yield on those Treasuries that gold competes with is getting better, that's bad news for gold. It has to be. I think also gold has gotten a lot of strength here. There's been an ongoing debate in macro circles about is the US dollar rally coming to an end or is it just taking a breather and about to really take off again?
Goldman Sachs says it's taking off again. It's got a lot more life left in it. We just had Axel Merk tell us that he doesn't think that the dollar rally is likely to continue. If Axel is right, then gold is probably headed higher from here, and that's the reason Axel was bullish on gold. I think the dollar rally is the big question, and that's still unresolved. The dollar got clobbered after the Fed meeting. Is the dollar going to recover from that and make a breakout above 100 on the dollar index, or is it going to break down into the 80s? as Axel seems to be predicting. I could see it going either way.
Market wrap: Treasuries, Bunds and high yield
Nathan Egger: Well, the long bond— you mentioned bonds, and the long bond continues to be one of the better-performing asset classes in 2016. But with this latest stall-out in the dollar, or downward move in the dollar, we're seeing long bonds moving sideways. Are you seeing any opportunities out there in the fixed income space at this point?
Erik Townsend: Well, from the U.S. Treasury standpoint, I don't see a trading opportunity. Right now, and the reason that I say that is just if you look at the dollar rally, I think it does probably have farther to go. That would be positive for U.S. Treasury yields. At the end of the day, though, you're making a loan. You're loaning money on an unsecured basis to an arguably insolvent borrower that you know is mathematically unable. It is mathematically impossible for the U.S. to ever pay back all of its debt.
So you're making a loan to a borrower that you know cannot ever repay it. It is a greater fool trade. You're expecting economic conditions to develop to where somebody will be willing to pay you more for that loan than you actually have into it, even though you know perfectly well that it can never be repaid someday. That's kind of a daunting proposition. On the other hand, if I look If you look at something like the German Bund market, I think German Bunds got ahead of themselves. They were already yielding zeros, what, negative 4 basis points, when Bill Gross came out and said, you know, this is insane. This is a very high-quality credit in terms of German credit rating, is better than most of Europe, and it's crazy for them to have a negative yield. It got more negative as a result of this refugee crisis. There's just been so much panic trade into safe haven assets. I just don't see from deeply negative yields on the 10-year German Bund how it can go a whole lot farther.
So I think if I had to look for a trade in fixed income, it would be shorting German Bunds. And I should, in the interest of full disclosure, say I am short German Bund 10-year futures here. Because I think they've probably gone as far as they can go. But as far as the US Treasury market is concerned, I don't see anything on the Treasury side. High yield, I'm short.
I definitely— when we talked about that trade on the Jim Rogers Show, there's a lot of reasons to be short high yield. But on the sovereign side, I don't see it in the US market. All right.
Why this week's feature departs from the usual format
Nathan Egger: Thanks for bringing that all together for us, Erik. And before we go to this week's feature interview, would you mind taking a moment to explain to our listeners why we're deviating ever so slightly from our usual themes here at MacroVoices?
Erik Townsend: Sure. Well, the theme of the MacroVoices podcast is that we are targeting more sophisticated investors, professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, more sophisticated retail investors. And normally we talk about markets and investing. And with a guy like Jack Schwager, who wrote the Market Wizards book, obviously we want to start by talking about the Market Wizards experience.
What Jack's working on now, though, is a completely different project that has to do with helping people who are amateur traders or who have an interest in trading get noticed and develop a track record and be recognized for their talents. Well, that's not really markets and investing, but it may be of interest to our listener base because we do have people like our friend Matt in Australia, who I actually brought up in the interview. Matt's, you know, wants to get out of the IT business someday and do this for a living.
Living. Jack is a guy who's working on a project that's designed to help traders like Matt move from amateur trading into professional trading. Is that of interest to our MacroVoices audience? We're really not sure. This was an experiment, folks, so we would love to hear from you on our listener forums. We did this just as a one-off, and next week we'll be going back to our normal format of focusing the interview on markets and investing and where the trades are.
Nathan Egger: And of course, as Erik just mentioned, our listener discussion forums at MacroVoices.com/forums are the place to give us your feedback on both this week's content and more generally speaking. We'd love to hear from you. And you'll be hearing Erik's interview with Jack Schwager right after this.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Jack Schwager interview: Market Wizards and the Schwager Doctrine
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is a man who needs little introduction, no introduction for the serious traders in the audience. Jack Schwager, who of course wrote the infamous book Market Wizards back in 1989. For anyone in the audience who's not familiar with the series, Market Wizards was a compendium of interviews with the very most successful traders in history. The first book was in '89. There were 3 more follow-on books. Jack's books have become something of an institution among serious traders. Thanks so much for joining us on the program, Jack. We've had quite a few requests for
Jack Schwager: Thanks, Erik. Thanks for the introduction.
Erik Townsend: I want to start with the experience from Market Wizards. You know, when I teach people about trading, the very first thing that I teach them is what I call the Schwager Doctrine, named after you because you're who I read about it from. And that is that you have to find— you know, there's lots of different ways to skin a cat. You've got to pick the style of trading that matches your personality. It's not that there's a right kind or a wrong kind. There's a right-for-you kind or a wrong-for-you kind.
I know that's one of the things that you emphasize most strongly in your writing. What are some of the other top insights that you gained from this experience of several decades interviewing, I guess it was hundreds of traders over the course of the project?
No single right approach: risk management and discipline
Jack Schwager: So, Erik, yeah, even though you— yeah, I bet there's lots of other points, but even though you identified what I would consider the most important point about the need to find an approach that fits your personality, Maybe want to add a little bit to that simply because in my experience, particularly for novice traders or people who are not— don't have a wealth of experience in trading, there's a natural inclination to believe there is some sort of secret to the market, some sort of answer. And it's really about finding the right approach, the right method, the absolute answer, whether it's Elliott Wave or—
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jack Schwager: Gann or some fundamental approach.
And what I think is most important to understand is there is no such thing as a right approach. And I've interviewed people across the entire spectrum, people who completely disdain fundamentals. For example, somebody like Marty Schwartz would tell you he spent a career as a fundamental stock analyst and lost money every year. And then he got rich as a technician. And then you have somebody like Jim Rogers, who will say— will talk about chart analysis or technical analysis as if it's black magic, and make a snide comment like, the only rich technician I've ever met are the ones who sell their services. So, you really run the gamut. And what that tells you is that if people who are wildly successful have completely opposite views about different methodologies, Then there is no single approach. And I think the big thing anybody needs to do to be successful— in fact, the absolute first thing they need to do is to figure out what is their approach.
And it won't always be the first thing that they think it is. It really takes experiment, experience, and so forth.
I know from my own experiences, I've gone through different phases. And starting out with fundamentals, realizing that didn't work for trading, going to technical, and back and forth between systematic and discretionary until I finally settled on an approach which was comfortable for me. What that is is actually not terribly relevant, because that's what's comfortable for me. The point is that each person, each trader needs to figure that out for themselves.
OK, so you asked about other things that are important. Well, this is no surprise, certainly not to anybody who trades. But it can't be emphasized enough is that trading is more about risk management than it is about methodology. I mean, most people think that trading is all about finding the right approach, the right timing method, getting in at the perfect time.
And if they're more sophisticated, getting out at the perfect time. But really, the most important thing is not losing. And by not losing, I don't mean losing on individual trades. I mean by not losing on balance because of a lack of risk management. So literally, I think just about— I mean, I can think of one exception. But just about every successful trader that I've interviewed in my life would have told you that risk management was absolutely essential. And most of them would tell you that risk management is much more important than the method that they use.
So that's also critical.
Also, very, very high on the list would be something like discipline. The people that are successful are very disciplined. If you're sloppy, or if you say you're going to do things, and you kind of— let's say you put on a trade, and let's say you're not using stops for whatever reason. But you say, I'm going to get out at a certain price. And then the market gets to that price. You're losing money. You had said to yourself, based on my approach, it shouldn't get here. If it gets here, I'm going to get out. But then it gets there, and you say, "You know what? I'll give it another day.
If I get out here, I know I lose this much. If I give it another day, maybe I'll come back. Besides, I think this is right near the bottom." Well, that's like a sign of somebody that doesn't have discipline, and good traders will absolutely stick to their methodology. Now they'll change their mind if there's a reason to change their mind, but they they won't change it because. of hope or something like that. They will have the discipline to stick to what they know is right, not what they hope is right.
Early failure, Michael Marcus and Ray Dalio's learning model
Erik Townsend: Were there any big surprises in the Market Wizards project? In other words, were there cases where you just assumed it was all going to be about X, Y, and Z, and it turned out that it was all about A, B, and C, or that the traders that you talked to had a different perspective than you thought they were going to have?
Jack Schwager: Well, you know, I guess there are a number of things that surprised me over time. And if I think back to the very start of the project, before the very first book, I certainly didn't anticipate there would be such an extraordinary range of different approaches. And so, I mean, you could probably go through my books and identify, literally— I mean, there's 4 books, as you mentioned. You could probably identify 50 different approaches, meaningfully different approaches. And yet, all these people are successful.
So, the range of possible successful approaches surprised me.
I was, of course, surprised by how phenomenally successful some of these people were in terms of return to risk. And I guess, you know, it was another big surprise. Another big surprise was that even the very, very— not all of them, but even among the most successful people I interviewed, it was probably more common for them to have had failure early on than to have been successful from the beginning. So I guess I was surprised by the degree and scope of failure among the people I interviewed, not obviously as the end result, but as an early result.
And that actually leads to some important points. One is— and that's important people understand— is that early failure is not necessarily predictive. I mean, I've seen that time and time again. That doesn't mean that if you fail in the beginning, you're going to be successful. But conversely, just because you fail in the beginning also does not mean that you won't— that you don't have what it takes or won't be successful.
And I think of somebody like Michael Marcus, who was my first interview in the first Market Wizards book. And I put him first, actually, for a couple of reasons. Well, one, he was a phenomenal trader. I mean, this is a fellow who took a $30,000 account, a prop account that he was given. I know that, and I know this story to be true because I subsequently worked at the same firm, which was Commodities Corp. And Michael was well known to be not only the best trader, but by far the best trader, although he subsequently hired Bruce Kovner. And while Kovner was there, there was some competition between who was the best trader. But in any case, Michael turned that $30,000 into $80 million in the course of about 10, 12 years. And that was with them taking money out for expenses every year. So that is his performance. The thing with Michael, though, is his early trading— the story of how he got into trading, and his first couple of years of trading— is just one debacle after another, one wipeout after another.
And I even got to the point, at one point in that interview, saying, my God, didn't you just think of— I mean, why'd you keep on? I mean, didn't you just think—
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jack Schwager: Hey, I'm not cut out for this. But no, he kind of just felt he could do it. And so, there are going to be people who fail in the beginning, but still have what it takes. And he's living proof of that.
And then the other thing about failure is that it's not the failure that counts. It's the ability to just keep at it. I mean, people like Michael and other people who had those early failures, They just kept at it. And they kept at it, they kept at it, they got better. And also, actually, maybe the most important things that were said about failure came up in the Ray Dalio interview. And Ray Dalio is probably a familiar name to most. Michael Marcus probably is a name that nobody, I think, would know had I not written a book, because he's an extraordinarily private person and never managed outside money.
Erik Townsend: But Dalio—
Jack Schwager: Should be familiar to most people, the founder of Bridgewater. Bridgewater is the world's largest hedge fund. And it also has the distinction of having made the most dollars for investors. If you actually looked at every hedge fund that ever existed— and I don't think I'm wrong on this. Maybe some other hedge fund has come across now and has eclipsed Bridgewater, but I don't think so. But at least when I interviewed him a couple of years ago, At least as of that point, Bridgewater had made more money for their clients than any other hedge fund in raw dollars, if you look at how much investors in a hedge fund made over time from the beginning of time. So that is a function of both performance, and performance with a lot of money under management. So it's not that Bridgewater has the best performance, but they have really good performance with incredibly large amounts of money.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jack Schwager: And that itself is a sort of almost miraculous feat.
Now, the reason I bring up Dalio on this point here with failure is because Dalio has a kind of a world philosophy, a management philosophy, a company philosophy. And anybody who works at Bridgewater, and the company has well over 1,000 employees, is imbued with this philosophy. In fact, they even hand out this pamphlet with something like 240 principles handed down from Dalio.
And they pertain to a lot of things, management and trading. But very, very much a running theme throughout those principles is the critical role of taking advantage of failure, to learn from failure, to learn from your mistakes.
And if there is the best description of what the Bridgewater model is, Without getting into the nitty-gritty of it, but from a philosophical standpoint, it is you have your model of what it is today. Anytime you do something wrong and you can identify why that was wrong or how it can be improved, you build that into the model. And that has been the process from the very beginning.
So I mean, Dalio began with taking notes of his trades. You know, what did he do wrong? In fact, I I, when I was more disciplined or putting in the time, remember keeping a day trader's diary. And I still think it's a very good idea. And if I wasn't so lazy, I would still do it. But it's something I think people should do for the main reason that by writing down any trade that you can learn something from, particularly the ones you made a mistake, that's the way you can improve.
And so failure is really, ironically, A critical element to success, because it is from failure that you can learn how to get better. And that's actually— I guess that's even true for computers as well as people, because I think— though this is not my area of expertise, but my understanding is that programs that border on artificial intelligence or whatever do learn from their mistakes. improved that way. So, I think that's an essential element.
Traders raised on the Market Wizards books
Erik Townsend: I want to focus on the people side of this, because when you wrote the first book in '89, it was a book about trading, and you were basically talking to trading experts, finding out how they trade, and writing it down. By the time you were writing the last of the series, or at least the, the 4th book in the series— it's not the last because there's one more coming.
You haven't interviewed me yet, so we know you're not done. By the time you got to the 4th book in the series, I think the most common theme that I noticed is all the guys you're interviewing are junkies who grew up on reading the first several books in the series. So, you actually now became part of the process where you're interviewing traders about how they got to be great traders. Great traders are all guys that read your books. So, what did that feel like and what was that experience for you?
Jack Schwager: Yeah, it's funny you bring that up because when I was writing Hedge Fund Market Wizards, it actually probably came up even more than I had put it in the book. But I started feeling, God, I felt big. I mean, I felt— because I didn't want to sound like I'm plugging my own book, but it was true. So many of these people I was now interviewing— this was 25 years after the first book— had grown up and come into trading. And I guess the original Market Wizards and New Market Wizards, those 2 books get passed around by traders and certainly prop shops and everything else.
And so, it got to the point where it was unusual for me to interview somebody who had not read one of those first couple of books. And a lot of them were influenced by it. So, I had this dilemma of, what do I do?
I don't want to sound like I'm plugging my own book. And what I ultimately decided was that if the reference to my book was something that I would have included if it wasn't my book, and if somebody said, you know what? What really got me into trading was I found this book, and he said, this is the book.
I would definitely put that in the interview. And just because it's my book, I decided therefore, then the right thing is to put it in. If it wasn't the type of thing where if somebody had mentioned it, where I didn't think it was germane, or I wouldn't have thought it was necessary to put in the interview, then I didn't put it in. So, probably the The references to one or more of my books came up even more than it appeared. And I ended up putting it in quite a bit because, I mean, just factually, a lot of these people were influenced by those early books. And it seemed like it's very awkward to put that down, but yet it seemed honest to do because, as I said, I would have done it if they had mentioned somebody else's book in the same vein.
Emmanuel Bolloré and the origin of FundSeeder
Erik Townsend: Now, as you got more involved in this, I think you took more of a personal interest in the path of people's individual development becoming traders, not just the trading, but the activity of watching people grow into becoming successful traders after reading your books and attending seminars that you've taught and so forth. At some point you end up having dinner with a guy named Emmanuel Bolloré. Who is Emmanuel? What was the dinner about? And what's FundSeeder?
Jack Schwager: Well, actually Emmanuel Bolloré— so when I had that dinner that you're referring to, we had known each other quite a while. So My previous— last time I was with a— the prior group I was with was a group called the Fortune Group, which was a London-based hedge fund advisory service. And I was always in the US, and I basically— I was the only US partner.
But they had approached me, or the CEO had approached me back in about 2001 when I had started my own little hedge fund of funds. And he met me at a conference, and he sort of pitched me on Fortune Group. And he said, why don't you join us as a partner? And it sort of was the appeal. It was a really appealing idea to work for a group and all that.
And I joined, and it worked out quite well. But while I was there, I actually— while I was there, one of the things that happened is towards the later years that I was with the group, I became more and more disillusioned with the structure of hedge funds from an investor's perspective, that is, and thought that the much better structure was a managed account approach, because it gave you transparency, it gave you control, and so forth. So, I was trying to I was the only one who came from a futures background. And for me, managed accounts were familiar territory. Everybody else, all the other partners, it was foreign to them. So it took me a while to convince other partners that we should do this. We started a— finally got a fund started, which was managed accounts. And Emmanuel was working with ADM. He still has an association with ADM at the time.
But he had a subsidiary with ADM.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Jack Schwager: Which was interested in doing a fund. And so, they engaged Fortune to be the advisor, and I was the point person on this. And so, that's how Emmanuel and I got to know each other. I then subsequently worked as an advisor for ADM after Fortune got taken over, and I left the parent company, which was Close Brothers, which was a UK merchant bank. And really, as the only US person in a large corporation, with the prior direction of the company changed, there was really no role that I saw that I was interested in there. And so, we negotiated a friendly exit, and that's what I did.
So, I was on my own writing books, and Emmanuel came back to me and got me to be an advisor with ADM for one of their funds. And then we were at a conference together, and this was about 2, 3 years ago, and Emmanuel pitches this idea to me.
The idea was FundSeeder. And he says, I have this idea. I want to do a web-based tech company, technology company, that would be sort of the clearinghouse between undiscovered traders and investors. Like, the idea was that Too much or almost all the money, all the investment money gets funneled through the same small list of curators and to the same small list of hedge funds with huge amounts of money. And there's lots of trading talent out there that can't get identified, can't get the money, doesn't have the contacts, and has no way of so-called being discovered. And there are plenty of investors out there who are more interested in finding undiscovered trading talent than in just being the me-too investor in some hedge fund that already has $10 billion in assets. So that was his idea, create this website that would be sort of the central spot where traders could have their results.
The results would be gotten directly from the brokers, so they would be verified. And then investors would have a sort of verified verified, proven track records of traders that are— well, they could be traders who are already managing money. But for the most part, he envisioned it as a way for new talent and had the name FundSeeder. And I actually said, you know what?
I'm the first one to say, hey, that's a ridiculous idea. But it sounded like a pretty good idea to me.
And anyway, Got me to partner with him early on. And so, here we are a few years later. We just launched the— we started out actually about a year and a half ago. So, originally white labeling another software that would show account equity and analytics and all that. I was never a particular fan, but it got us going. sort of with very little staff.
But as we progressed, well, first, it became very— I never particularly liked that old original software. But it became apparent to Emmanuel as well, and our other partner, James, that it was not the best approach. There were lots of things we wanted to do completely differently. And so, we ended up hiring our own programmers.
We've got a whole team. Actually, our team is in Ukraine. But we have a technology team now.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Jack Schwager: I've worked with them as far as the analytic design, and Daniel's worked on the business side, and so forth.
But now, we've basically changed the original platform, literally 100%. And so now, I'm kind of— now, it's what I would have liked to have available, which I wasn't aware of anywhere where it had, which was that you could go on and put your account up, and you could generate an equity curve of your account. You could do analytics on the equity curve. You could do stuff like underwater curve, showing drawdowns, all the drawdowns of your equity curve, compare it to benchmarks.
You could do something like rolling window, like if you want to look, what are your rolling 6-month returns through every day?
And all the analytics was built on a daily basis. So, it's much more meaningful than monthly data, which is the industry norm. So, anybody who's on FundSeeder it's basically daily data. And that is far far, far more meaningful from a statistical standpoint. I mean, you're dealing with 22 times the amount of data points.
Levelling the playing field for undiscovered traders
Erik Townsend: Let's just take a step back, Jack, if I can interrupt you for a second there, because I want our listeners to appreciate the contrast of what it was like before FundSeeder. The hedge fund business is incredibly— what would you call it? Cliquish? It's like an Ivy League club, and you've got to know the right people and be from the right prep school and the right— It didn't matter previously how good you were or how strong of a proven track record you had as a trader. You're not going to work for any big hedge fund unless you've got the Ivy League MBA from the right school.
You guys are really leveling the playing field. You're saying, let's not make this about who knows who and who's from what family. Let's make this about who knows how to trade, and let's provide tools to objectively measure that so that somebody who's got talent can showcase that to the world at large.
Jack Schwager: Right.
Erik Townsend: The world at large can find them, and you don't have the private club anymore of prep school boys that are in charge of everything.
Jack Schwager: Yeah, Erik, you said it better than I did. That's the core of the philosophy, to globalize and democratize the trading and investment process so that it doesn't make a difference if you came from an Ivy League or not. It doesn't make a difference who you know. You could be like, for example, you could have some guy in In Ukraine, for example, we have a lot of really good, really smart math tech guys in Ukraine. But now, there could be other people— there are other people, let's say, in that country or a lot of other countries where there isn't much of a marketplace. There isn't really an opportunity for somebody who has potential skill to become a trader and money manager. But you could have somebody coming out of that type of environment who has, let's say, great— in this particular case, use the example of great quant skills and build some sort of mathematical model that has an edge in the market.
They would still— even if they were able to do that, they wouldn't have very much money on their own to trade. They'd have no access to other investors, and they'd have a very difficult time proving that they have something.
So FundSeeder actually provides that avenue. Somebody like that could go on FundSeeder. market, get their account on FundSeeder have the account directly linked to the broker. The results come from their broker. It's daily data. And over time, can build up a track record that can speak for itself. So you have the opportunity for people who would not have any access— would be virtually impossible for them to break into the investment arena, the money management arena maybe is a better way of saying it— now have a way to do it. And in fact, In fact, if I'm not mistaken, we probably have had people from over 100 countries register. It's really been very, very global where the traders are coming from.
How FundSeeder works for traders: verified and unverified records
Erik Townsend: Let's talk through this from the trader's perspective, because this podcast is targeted at more sophisticated investors, and some of them are advanced retail investors who have aspirations of wanting to become professional traders and work in the business. We have one frequent listener in Australia, for example, a guy named Matt Barrie. Matt, who's an IT guy, but he's very good at trading and he wants to do it full-time. He'd like to either make enough money to be able to support himself entirely on trading or somehow get out of the IT business and into the trading business. But the career path for how to do that has not been obvious. Now, in Matt's case, he's already met you and he's already got a FundSeeder account, but let's pretend that he's never heard of FundSeeder.
What do you do for a guy like Matt in terms of what does he need?
Because I think a lot of people wouldn't know that being able to evidence their track record is so important. Aside from a track record and the ability to evidence that it's real, what does Matt need to break into this? And what is a career path for someone who maybe discovered trading either as a hobby or, you know, they're a retail investor, but they're good at it and they want to do it as a career?
What would you recommend to them and how would FundSeeder help
Jack Schwager: Yeah, so FundSeeder for us, it's sort of like a search engine for trading talent. And we're just getting going with the new platform. And we're just— actually, this is actually probably the first interview I'm doing post the very recent launch of the new website. So we're just— and we didn't do any marketing deliberately before, because We wanted to get this new website going and get rid of— debug it to a comfortable standpoint and so forth. So now, it's just the point where we're beginning to do that.
And so what we would like is people like Matt, who have the trade, to get on the platform. And part of the platform has a search engine capability. Now, I should say, there's separate sites for traders and investors. And we focused on the trader side first. In other words, doing the analytics, the graphics, the tools, the free tools, everything for traders. So, we give them really great software for free, just in the hopes and expectation that enough good traders, or more than good traders, superb traders, will find it, get on, and we'll discover them before other people do.
And so, the people on the site are not identified by name. They're identified just by a code number. And so, we will be using that site to search for trading talent ourselves. And 4, Emmanuel has— Emmanuel's real forte is the investors, his contacts, and knowing what investors need, and finding the right managers. So he's the one who's kind of the key liaison with investors. So he can use the platform to find the right managers for the right investors, depending on what they're looking for. Now, we will have an investor site.
That— well, right now, I think there is an investor site, but it's really just almost not much more than a landing site explaining what it will be. But eventually, the investor site will contain a subset of traders. And that subset of traders will be traders who have also gotten— for compliance reasons, we only want to have registered traders on that site.
But ultimately, investors will be able to search on that website and so forth. As far as the company goes, our own plans are to find trading talent, connect them with investors, connect them, or actually form single funds around them, or potentially actually do a multi-manager fund with emerging traders, and then market that fund to the— have that fund meet all the regulatory rules and everything else. And then we would act as the structurer, and the risk manager, and compliance manager, and so forth. and have a product that institutions and high net worth people could invest in. So there's all sorts of avenues of potential investment that would come out of this.
But the beginning part is getting the raw ingredient. And the raw ingredient is trading talent. And that would hopefully— what we will get by people signing up to FundSeeder and then using the search tools to identify the traders who have the best return-risk metrics. And then going from there, that's a starting point. Then of course, from there, you would go through the normal interviewing and compliance and other things. But the very, very first thing would be to use the database that is inherent in the FundSeeder site.
Erik Townsend: So the proposition for traders is essentially, for free, they can create an account. They can track their performance in a way which I suppose it's not technically a legal audit in the sense of being representable, but it's a heck of a lot better than, I said this is my performance.
Jack Schwager: Or like virtually every database out there, you know, basically, you know, people report their numbers, you know, they can be pulling them out of thin air. Now, I should say that because we, right now, there are— we link to a lot of brokers, we don't link to some other brokers. So really, it's not like we link to every broker in the world.
So there are certain There are certainly going to be people who have accounts at brokers which we don't have direct links to yet. And for those traders, they can upload their data on a template that we provide, which makes it very easy. Just if they— it's just an Excel-based template, they can just copy it off an Excel spreadsheet and drop it in, and boom, it's done. And then they will have all use of the same analytics.
The thing there is that in that case, we identify those as unverified. So, if we get the numbers from the broker, Those are in the verified portion of the database. If we're getting it from the trader, which doesn't mean that there's anything wrong with it, because like I say, there are going to be many traders that simply have accounts with brokers where we don't have the link. And in that case, it will show up as unverified, but they can still use the same analytics.
Erik Townsend: So to summarize, what FundSeeder is offering traders is the ability to document their track record and essentially like an actress who's Hopes to be discovered in a coffee shop someplace. It's putting those track records in front of people in the industry, potentially investors that might want to invest with you. It provides all these things. You're still missing something, Jack. You haven't told me how I get interviewed personally for a Market Wizards book. We're not going to finish this interview until we cover that.
Planned book: Undiscovered Market Wizards
Jack Schwager: Oh, yeah. Okay. So, one of the things, one of the ideas, and again, this is Emmanuel's idea was to do actually why not do another Market Wizards book, but basically do it on people we discover through the site? So, that's a planned future book. And the idea is that the best traders that we sort of uncover— and it'll take a couple of years, I think, for the site to be functioning.
And that assumes, of course, that people come on the site already have— many of them will already have track records of some length to begin with. With. But I think in a couple of years, we'll be able to discern that here is a good group of traders that we found through the site that are really excellent, and basically do a book with a working title, Undiscovered Market Wizards.
So, if anybody's really good out there, and they get on the site, that's one way to end up in the book as well, because if they pop up in terms of being really superior in performance, I would basically be looking at, for those people, as interview subjects for this future book.
The capital introduction industry: threat or symbiosis
Erik Townsend: Fantastic. I want to talk about how this project is being received so far by the industry. You know, something I think some of our listeners understand but others don't is hedge fund capital introduction is a very antiquated business. It's a lot of who knows who and It's frankly not a lot of gentlemen in that business.
I think that a lot of people could argue that the whole capital introduction business ought to be replaced, just as the travel agents were replaced by the internet.
Do you guys— first of all, do you see yourselves in that role in terms of providing an automated capital introduction service that eliminates the need for capital introduction brokers? And how are you being received by the industry? Do the cap intro guys see you as a threat? Are they excited that you're doing something cool with technology, or are they threatened that you're doing something that might usurp them at some point?
Jack Schwager: Okay, so that's perceptive of you. Yet there are a good number of avenues that we see as big potential for the company, and certainly this cap intro avenue is one very important one, because if you get a website that does— if we are successful and we do become sort If you're a trader, if it becomes a thing, if you're a trader, and you're serious, and you want good analytics, and you want to be potentially discovered, you need to get your account on FundSeeder.
If we get to that point, and that's our goal, then we've got an enormous advantage over the regular rest of the industry, because we can be finding people globally before anybody else does. And we also have the advantage of it being a technology company, and therefore, has all the efficiencies of a technology company. There's not a great marginal cost in finding more traders and so forth. So basically, I think we can offer a superior product in that particular sector, fulfilling that particular need. And that is certainly a potential. So that is one of the directions we do intend to go.
We have not actually focused— we've talked to traders, we've talked to investors. Actually, of obvious reasons— oh, I don't know if Emmanuel's talked to cap intro people, but not that I know of, nor does it seem a very natural place to go, because you're quite right. Ultimately, we would be competitive. Now, I guess initially, we might actually be— there might be a symbiotic relationship here, because if you're a cap intro guy, and you have Like a new trader that people don't know. And this would be a way of getting— and it's also true for a manager who is still looking for assets and is not widely known. Both the manager and the cap intro guy could direct the accounts onto the platform, because it's a way of getting free exposure and potentially an allocation.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jack Schwager: So, for now, I think we could be helpful. But ultimately, providing that cap intro role is one of the things we'll do. Now, I don't think we'd be replacing the whole industry, but I certainly think we'd be competitive. And there's also going to be people who have their own little niche of finding managers that are right for certain investors, and they'll still do fine.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jack Schwager: But I think for a lot of people, we could end up being definitely competition.
Parting advice and John Bender
Erik Townsend: As we close, Jack, I'd like to just come back to your parting words of wisdom. I think when it comes to educating traders, both participating in teaching traders and also observing people advance through their careers as traders, nobody's got as much boots-on-the-ground time as you do in terms of exposure to some of the most successful people in the world. world through Market Wizards. So for our audience, many of whom are either advanced retails or they're finance professionals or they're high net worth individuals who are more sophisticated investors, as these people who are very serious about this, who really want to advance their knowledge and wisdom about trading and investing, move forward, what would your strongest words of advice to them be?
Jack Schwager: Well, My strongest words of advice is go with where the passion is. So for those people who are really passionate about trading, and that's really what they love doing, they may have another job, but they really would ideally prefer to be trading. This is really what they want to do.
Then go for it. I mean, I'm not telling people to quit their job, to have no source of income. But use all your spare time to develop a methodology. Get to the point where you have confidence, and maybe at some point, then spin off.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jack Schwager: And go for it.
So, I think if the real desire is there, and if it's what they really love doing, then make the leap for— not to the point of not being able to pay next month's rent, but to the point of maybe giving up a much better paying job if it's not making them happy, and trading is what they really want to do, and they can still get by on trading, and they still have enough money saved up to get by.
On the other hand, or conversely, I should say, there are lots of people out there who think they want to be traders, but what they really want is to make a lot of money. And they think this is an easy way to do it. It's not. Or they are enamored with the Hollywood image of trading, which really has very little to do with trading, but they want to be a big shot hedge fund guy. Or they want to have the power. There are all these other reasons. Now, I think those are all not very good reasons, and they're reasons which ultimately, for many people, end up being routes to failure. So, I think you have to be clear whether trading is what you really want to do.
So, for those people who really want to do it, then I'd encourage them. For those who are in it for the wrong reasons, or who think they want to be traders, but really don't enjoy it, they like what trading could do if they were successful, but they're not enjoying the process, they don't have the confidence, then they need to recognize that maybe trading isn't right for them. Maybe it isn't what they should do.
In fact, I myself, and I make this point, I mean, I trade. Sometimes I trade every day. Sometimes I don't trade for a couple of years. It really depends. But I'm not a trader. I do lots of things. And trading is one of the things I do. It's like I'm a hobby I come in and out of and whatever. But trading was not something that I ever thought I was either good enough to be just a source of livelihood, nor actually wanted to do full-time. I mean, I had too many other things I wanted to do, including writing, analytical projects, speaking, et cetera. So, it was never for me the career path. And I realized I realized that probably a long time ago.
But I think a lot of people sort of get into this thing, and they think they want to be trading. And if they really were honest, they might realize that, hey, it's not the right thing for them.
So the most important thing in that respect is really doing an evaluation to decide, is it the trading that's really attractive that you really want to do? And do you really want to be a trader? I think in one of my books, or more than one of my books, I probably tell people, hey, make sure this is what you want to do.
And I also want to make this point, that some of the things that are involved in being really, really good in trading and really successful are not necessarily things that are good for living a great life or a happy life. It is for some people. It isn't for a lot of other people.
I'll give you an example. I mean, there's one trader, for example, And this trader died at a very young age, but he was a brilliant options trader, a fellow by the name of John Bender. And actually, my most successful investment I ever made was in his fund. This was a guy who made triple-digit returns, at least for a number of years. He was a physicist by background. He was brilliant and obsessive.
And And when he traded, he basically would trade primarily Japanese options. Then he would stay awake and trade the European options market. And very often would then stay awake and then trade American option— US option markets. And literally, many days would be trading 19, 20 hours a day.
Now, he was enormously successful.
He was incredibly obsessive. And that hard work and obsessiveness were key elements to his success. This was part of it. I mean, he was brilliant, yes, but a lot of brilliant people aren't great traders. But his obsessiveness and focus and super hard work were some of the key elements that made him so enormously successful.
However, I would not want to live that life. I mean, trading 20 hours a day is just not my idea of a good life. So, you got to put things in perspective. And for some people, it might be, but in any case, I think that's what people have to do a self-evaluation on.
Book plugs and sign-off
Erik Townsend: Well, Jack, thanks so much for joining us on the program today. The website is fundseeder.com. The upcoming book, and it sounds like it's a couple years out at this point, will tentatively be called what, Jack?
Jack Schwager: Undiscovered Market Wizards. That's the working title. There is a book I have. I will put it— I will put this out for the For the very analytical people out there in your listening audience who are futures traders, later this year, I will have an update of— most people think Market Wizards was my first book. It was not. I had an analytical book called— many years ago, written actually in 1984, called A Complete Guide to the Futures Market.
And it's finally getting updated, the second edition coming out now, which is like—
Erik Townsend: 2023.
Jack Schwager: Well, over 30 years later, but with the help of my co-author, who did a lot of the legwork on the update, Mark Etzkorn, who's done a great job. So, that book, which has everything from fundamental analysis to technical analysis to spread trading to options to trading principles to you name it.
So, that will be coming out later this year. And that's called The Complete Guide to the Futures Market. A book by that name exists, but it's the '84 edition, so people who have interest should make sure they're getting the 2016 edition, which won't be available for about half a year.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Jack, thanks again so much for joining us. Nathan Egger will be joining me again as MacroVoices continues right after this.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Nathan Egger.
Postgame: how cap intro works; Townsend's route to a hedge fund
Nathan Egger: So you've just heard from Jack Schwager. And as Erik previously alluded to, we usually talk about markets and investing on MacroVoices. But this week's interview was primarily about the industry and the path that an amateur trader might take to eventually become a professional trader. Personally, I, Nathan Egger, think it's very interesting. It's something that I'm interested in. But I also know that I'm probably not alone in feeling confused by some of the terminology that you and Jack were throwing back and forth. So, before we close the show, I'd like to go over some of that terminology.
One in particular that you guys alluded to was the conventional cap intro business. You mentioned it several times, but you guys never really defined it.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Nathan Egger: Can you explain to myself and our listeners how accredited investors find money managers to begin with?
Erik Townsend: Sure. We should probably take a step back. Let's imagine that we have somebody who is a trader trading their own account, so forth, that has aspirations of wanting to do this professionally. And this is, of course, an experience that I went through several years ago myself as I made the transition from being a private investor to running a hedge fund.
If your background, you know, I'm a retired software entrepreneur. I don't have a finance degree. I don't have experience in finance. I've never worked for Goldman Sachs. I don't have pedigree and so forth. To go and work in the finance industry and run a mutual fund or a pension fund or something else is generally not realistic for a guy like me or a guy like Trader Matt in Australia.
What's realistic is to start a hedge fund because a hedge fund is essentially an unregulated entity. It's only available to accredited investors. That is generally defined in the simplest form of the definition anyway as more than a million dollars of net worth, excluding your primary residence. So if you have aspirations of being in this business, you might think all you have to do is be good at trading. Demonstrate a track record, use a service like FundSeeder in order to share that track record with the world, and build it and they will come. Investors will come running to you with money to invest. Doesn't work that way at all.
There are databases of hedge funds' performance, and people can search through them.
Postgame: cap intro brokers, Madoff and the case for disruption
Erik Townsend: Very few people actually do that.
Most people that want to invest in hedge funds work through capital introduction brokers. These guys are like travel agents. Their job is to put a plan together to introduce an investor, whether it be a high net worth individual, a family office, a small institution, or what have you, with a fund manager and potentially broker a deal where the investor invests money with the hedge fund.
These guys would tell you, if you are the investor, that you are crazy to consider investing in a hedge fund without their help because you need their expertise. You need someone with their background to do due diligence work and to vet these hedge funds and to figure out which ones are the fraudsters and to protect you from all the bad guys out there. Very, very effective sales pitch that they use.
In reality, the way Bernie Madoff made all of his money with the fraud schemes that he had was he just paid a higher commission rate to the capital introduction brokers than anybody else was. paying. All of a sudden, he was their best friend, and they said, you know, you can't go wrong with Bernie Madoff. He is the most reputable, secure, safe, reliable guy on Wall Street. Well, of course he had that reputation. What he was doing was overpaying the middlemen. These guys, frankly, are pretty darn sleazy, and I'm sure there are perfect gentlemen in the capital introduction world. Perhaps some of them are our listeners.
I mean, you gentlemen and ladies, no disrespect. Yeah. Respect whatsoever, but you know as well as I do that most of your industry is pretty darn sleazy.
If you look at this whole thing and you say the traditional business of capital introduction is so hard, even if you are good at trading and you launch a hedge fund, unless you have lots and lots of your own money to seed it with, it's very hard to find seed investors. And so what Jack is trying to do is find a way for talented traders to be matched up with investors who want to invest in them or seed their funds or do whatever in order to get them going.
And I think, frankly, that they're doing something that's interesting. It certainly is of great benefit to a guy like Trader Matt in Australia. I frankly think that if they really wanted to look at a lucrative opportunity, they'd be better off just focusing on replacing the traditional capital introduction business, just the same way that travel agents were made obsolete by the internet in the '90s. You don't need these cap intro guys anymore. They don't deliver any value added. In many cases, it's value subtracted. If you had an introduction service that was based on a website that was basically accreditedinvestor.com that allows you to search through all of the hedge funds and, you know, potentially get somebody else's due diligence research on them, that would be profoundly valuable.
But right now we have an antiquated market and a business model that frankly is decades out of date. I'm surprised that they're not focused more on that than they focused on the FundSeeder idea, which is more helping amateur traders as opposed to established small emerging hedge fund But one way or another, I think it's a fantastic idea that they're trying to do something to automate what traditionally has been an extremely non-automated and very archaic capital formation business.
Postgame: technology disruption and an accreditedinvestor.com idea
Nathan Egger: You mentioned Madoff and how he was paying the cap intro guys more money than they would— than they were even asking for, so that the cap intro guys would then vet Madoff forgivingly, let's say. So if I've got this straight, you've got the hedge fund industry, trillions of dollars of assets under management, and you're not saying that the whole business is sleazy, but that there is a sleazy element, that there are certainly people out there who are not— there are strong conflicts of interest. And that's something that usually the markets tend to work themselves out. Like you said, we've seen technological disruptions across a host of industries, from Uber replacing taxi drivers, travel websites like Travelocity replacing travel agents, Amazon replacing traditional retail.
So, you're a software entrepreneur guy. And if you could just take a moment, you see this cap intro business as being another area that we can expect big changes due to advancements in technology. And given your, your history, I'd love to hear more about how you think exactly we can solve this if we view it as capital introduction, as indeed there being problems in that industry.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's an industry that is long overdue for an overhaul. Just the way the travel agent industry was overhauled, and I think maybe the issue is just that it's small enough. You know, travel agencies—they're dealing with a smaller price tag than a hedge fund in terms of you know how big a ticket is, but they're dealing with lots and lots of tickets. So it's a very, very large market. Maybe the hedge fund business is small enough that that's the explanation. I'm not sure. But if I were to look at this from an opportunistic standpoint as a software entrepreneur. Oh, absolutely.
You need a website called accreditedinvestor.com that allows sophisticated investors, whether they be professionals or high net worth individuals or family offices or what have you, to have a one-stop shopping experience where they can not only look at what say the existing hedge fund databases like hedgefund.net do today, which is just look at everybody's. Performance, but also if you were to go and do due diligence reviews and sell that as a service. So, you know, you look at a hedge fund on the website and you can see that it's got such and such a tear sheet performance, but there's also a $100 report available that gives you a due diligence background that somebody went and actually met with these guys at their office and looked at what they were doing and so forth.
It's very easy to imagine a platform that would completely obviate the need for traditional cap intro to exist. And believe me, I've thought about doing exactly that project. I'm 50 years old. I'm at a point where I'm running a hedge fund and living where I want to live and enjoying life. I don't want to go back to the life of being a software entrepreneur, but it is an incredibly ripe opportunity for somebody to tap.
Postgame: Real Vision Television Encore update
Nathan Egger: Real Vision Television, Erik, just a quick update. Some listeners may have noticed that Last Sunday, there was no Real Vision Television Encore. Can you tell us what's going on with that?
Erik Townsend: Sure. I've been in touch with Raoul Pal. We're going to actually try to get on the program at some point as an interview. We had originally talked about just putting up a couple of Encore episodes from Real Vision Television just to give listeners a taste of it. I'm talking to Raoul now about doing that maybe on an ongoing basis. So, what we're going to try is every other week, we're going to put up an encore episode from Real Vision Television. So, you had one 2 weeks ago on Sunday, skipped last Sunday, you're going to have this coming Sunday, March 27th, and then the following week will be off, and then the subsequent week we'll have another one.
I'm going to see if I can talk Raoul into doing that on an indefinite basis. We've only gotten an agreement to try it for a couple months right now. We're going to see where it takes us, and we really want some feedback from We're adding that extra content in hopes that you guys will find it interesting. If it's of interest, we'll continue to bring it to you. If it's not, we'll drop it.
Outro and disclaimer
Nathan Egger: All right, you guys, I think that's gonna pretty much do it for this week's episode. Please follow us on Twitter @MacroVoices and join us in the forums at MacroVoices.com/forums. Subscribe, rate, and review on iTunes. The feedback continues to be incredibly satisfying. Satisfyingly positive, but above all, helpful to Erik and I as we continue to take this MacroVoices project forward. Despite the deviation from our usual subject matter, I hope our listeners still found value in today's show. It was slightly different, but we'll be getting back to our primary focuses of macroeconomics and financial markets. And we've got some heavy hitters coming up in the forthcoming weeks, not the least of which will be Bill Fleckenstein, who Erik will be talking with next week. Thank you, Patrick.
But until then, that's going to do it for us. For Erik Townsend and myself, we wish you all a terrific extended weekend. We'll see you next time.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices Automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions.
The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not. necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Nathan Egger shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
