Michael Lebowitz — 720 Global (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Hello, everyone. MacroVoices episode 33 was recorded on September 29th, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. Michael Lebowitz from 720 Global will be joining me as today's featured interview guest. Michael and I will discuss his very popular article describing the breakdown of the virtuous economic cycle of savings leading to investment leading to increased productivity and, again, back to more savings, and also what the impacts of that breakdown will be on global financial markets.
First presidential debate and election-market risk
Aaron Chan: And I'm Aaron Chan. Now, before we dive into this week's markets, the subject that's been on everyone's mind is the U.S. presidential debate. Opinions as to who won the debate vary widely and seem highly dependent on the political orientation of the person opining. So, Erik, what's your take on the influence of the election on financial markets?
Erik Townsend: Well, as we get into the thick of it with silly season here between now and the election, we're going to introduce a new policy on MacroVoices, which is that we're going to ask all of our guests, as well as myself, not to opine on their personal views about who should be president, because you didn't tune into MacroVoices to hear our personal opinions, but instead to try to comment objectively on what either presidential election outcome would mean for financial markets. And I'll kick that off by saying that I think Donald Trump really boxed himself into a corner with this debate, because by being so sharply critical of Janet Yellen and the Fed, he has accused them of essentially inflating an asset bubble by keeping interest rates too low for too long. Now, although I I don't agree with Mr. Trump on a lot of things, I couldn't agree more with him on that particular point.
But I think it's kind of political suicide for him, because what's going to happen now is markets will expect that if Trump is elected, that he's going to put a stop to this, or try to, you know, replace Janet Yellen, do whatever he's able to do as president to get the Fed to stop blowing asset bubbles.
And I happen to think that that's the right thing for the president to do, so I'm not disagreeing with that. But it means that the bottom is going to fall out of this market. So if there's any politician in the history of the world who knows how to play this in her favor, it's got to be Hillary Clinton. So I think that each time Trump surges in the polls, the market's going to take a nosedive. Each time Hillary surges in the polls, the market is going to be very strong. And Hillary is going to put a spin on that, saying, look, the market is smart. The market is telling you that Donald Trump should not be president. All of you Republicans who have assets in stock markets, you should recognize that if you go ahead and vote for Donald Trump, you're going to lose half of your net worth because the market is going to crash.
And, you know, there's some substance to that. The market likely will crash if Donald either wins or appears to be about to win. And it's not because the market is saying that Donald Trump is a bad guy. It's because the market is saying if Hillary is elected, it's business as usual, and government policy will continue to be for sale to the highest bidder— read Wall Street— in exchange for bribe money in the form of campaign contributions. So I don't think it's really the market saying Trump's a bad guy and Hillary's a good guy, but boy, Hillary is going to spin it in that direction. I'm going to ask today's feature interview guest, as well as all future interview guests until the election, to opine similarly on what they think the outcome is going to mean for financial markets.
Equities: S&P futures and the Deutsche Bank scare
Aaron Chan: Yeah, Erik, I definitely agree with you there. I was watching the dollar-peso cross and also looking at the Japanese Nikkei futures as the debate was going on, and it definitely corroborates with what you were saying. Moving on, the S&P 500 stock index futures definitely saw a pronounced bounce on debate night. Then almost fully retraced the next day. Well, since then, the rally had been strong but was off again today. What's happening over here, Erik?
Erik Townsend: Well, overnight Wednesday into Thursday, we hit 2167, getting close on the way back towards that 2191.5, which was the high print so far back in August. And it looks like Deutsche Bank took a plunge. I'm not sure what brought about that plunge, but it seems like the market panicked in reaction to that shortly after noon on Thursday afternoon. It's bounced back. By the close to about 2,146 on E-mini S&P futures at the close of trading on Thursday. And I think we're going to see more of this volatility, banking stocks leading the way here. I don't know what the news was about Deutsche Bank that kicked this whole thing off, but, you know, we're definitely seeing this pattern of September volatility, which sometimes precedes a big downside event in October. I think, though, that from here to the election, election outcome is going to be the biggest influence on equity markets. And, you know, as I've said before, it's tempting It's tempting because I think Mr.
Trump probably does have a better chance of winning than the market and everyone is giving him credit for. It's tempting to be short here, but boy, you could get clobbered if Trump sticks his foot in his mouth, which is not something that he's not known for doing, and Hillary suddenly looks like a shoo-in. So a shoo-in election result, or the perception of one in either direction, could cause the market to go wild. Upside if Hillary looks like she's got it, downside if Donald looks like he's got it. Okay.
Crude oil: OPEC freeze and US inventories
Aaron Chan: All right, well, crude oil has to be the next biggest news story of the week after the election, with OPEC tentatively announcing a production cap at 32.5 million barrels per day, but they said the deal wouldn't be finalized until November. So, Erik, what's your take on oil, both the news from OPEC and this week's inventory data?
Erik Townsend: Well, this is the long-awaited moment that we've predicted on this show for a long time, that eventually OPEC would come up with some kind of freeze which would be utterly and totally irrelevant to supply and demand. They're talking about freezing production at 32.5 million barrels per day, which is, you know, that was the all-time record high level of production just a couple of months ago. And they're acting like this is somehow meaningful. Now, it is meaningful in the sense that symbolically, a year ago, it appeared that Saudi Arabia was intentionally trying to beat the price of oil down in order to damage their competitors. Clearly, now the sentiment has changed, and that has a symbolic importance. But as far as supply-demand fundamentals, it doesn't It doesn't matter at all, because they're still peddling as fast as they can. It is widely known that there's a lot of cheating that goes on in the OPEC-producing nations in terms of these quotas. So, they're going to continue to produce as much oil as they possibly can, and now they're going to say that their production number is 32.5 million barrels per day.
And even since that tentative announcement was made from the OPEC meeting, Iraq has already come back and said, hey, based on what the numbers list our production supposedly as, we would not agree to this. If we get to the November meeting where this is supposed to be finalized, we will not agree as it's currently drafted. You've got to change our numbers. Who knows who else is going to come back? So, this, as far as I'm concerned, didn't really mean anything to actual supply-demand fundamentals, but was obviously very emotionally and symbolically important. Goldman Sachs had just yesterday had a research piece out saying there's nothing, including an OPEC deal, that could possibly stop oil prices from rolling over to the downside. Then today, they came And then they came out with another one saying, this ought to be good for $7 to $10 of upside. Okay, Goldman, which is it? Even an OPEC deal wouldn't prevent the downside, or the OPEC deal is good for $7 to $10 of upside?
So far, it looks like it's good for upside, at least from what we're seeing in the tape action on Thursday afternoon. Meanwhile, you know, Art Berman and I have predicted— Goldman, by the way, had said by Q4 there would be massive builds in inventory and a storage crisis. Now, Art Berman and I have been predicting that that storage build would occur before then, like by now. And guess what? Another 1.9 million barrel drawdown in national crude oil inventories. 631,000 barrel drawdown in Cushing, Oklahoma inventories. Gasoline, meanwhile, 2 million barrel build on inventories. Well, that sort of goes in Art's and my direction, but after several weeks of drawdowns, I'm not sure that it really matters for that much. And besides, distillates this week, 1.9 million barrel drawdown. So if we've got a 2 million build on gasoline, a 1.9 draw on distillates, net-net in terms of finished products, it's basically flat this week. Front-month WTI crude oil futures now back trading earlier this afternoon above $48.
That of course is a reaction to the news out of OPEC. As we come into the close on Thursday afternoon, we're looking at $47.74, still up almost $5 from where it was before the news came out of OPEC. So we're seeing We're seeing a huge bounce here. Is it going to be temporary because this really doesn't matter to the supply and demand fundamentals? Or is it going to go another $5 or $10 higher? Because we've certainly seen rhetoric and emotion and sentiment drive oil prices all year.
You know, the whole buildup that we had going into the Doha meeting this spring was all about sentiment. So maybe this has got further to go. So, So, the view that Art Berman and I have had, which is that we still have a bunch of big inventory builds coming, the one that Goldman echoed with their research note earlier this week, still stands room to be proven right. But boy, if it's going to be proven right, we need to see those inventory builds start in earnest pretty soon here. And so far, we're just seeing inventory drawdowns. I traded emails with Samir Madani this week at #OOTT.
He said what's going on from their tracking activity is suddenly exports, both crude oil and finished products, exports are suddenly off the charts. So it is actually the export of product from the United States that is causing this change in inventories from what we expected. Sam's view is that that is distorting what analysts are concluding from all this, because people are used to the idea that the US is an importer. So you look at a change in inventory and you say, okay, that reflects a change in US domestic demand. Sam's take is it doesn't reflect a change in increasing domestic demand. It just says that we're exporting. exporting products suddenly, which kind of caught everybody by surprise. He even made a joke that if you look at the charter page of OPEC's website that describes the membership criteria for being in OPEC, according to that, the U.S.
qualifies to join OPEC. So, go figure.
Gold: consolidation range or descending triangle
Aaron Chan: Yeah, that's pretty interesting. Well, at this point, regular listeners know the broken record that comes next. We're still locked in a consolidation range in gold between $1,308 and $1,377. And it seems like every week we flip-flop from testing the high to the low side of that range. Now, I think it's the low end of the range this week. So how's the gold chart looking, Erik?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it's interesting. You mentioned this consolidation range between $1,308 and $1,377. That's what we've been describing this as, but as I look at the chart now, I realize that we've seen 3 reaction highs and 3 reaction lows that would support relabeling this chart pattern as actually a descending triangle. And that, of course, would portend a much more bearish outlook as opposed to the previous description that we had.
So if you look at the chart that way, maybe it's a little bit more bearish. And yeah, you're right, we traded below $1,320 earlier today on Thursday, looking at $1,323 right now. So we traded within $10 at the bottom of that range. It would be a closing print below $1,308 which would say that that bearish view really is confirmed. And if you wanted to look at this as a descending triangle, the new key resistance level would be about $1,347. So that's going to be a number to watch if we see a closing print above of that, it kind of invalidates at least the version of this that says we're actually looking at a descending triangle pattern.
10-year Treasury yields
Aaron Chan: Yeah, it's something that'll be interesting to watch, Erik. And it looks like this descending triangle is converging right at the election. So it'll be fascinating to observe. Now, 10-year Treasury yields gave up another 5 basis points since our last show, yielding 1.57% on Thursday afternoon. Erik, you said a couple of weeks ago that you'd been waiting to buy the 10-year futures when the yield touched 1.70%, but chickened out after a chorus of people, including Real Vision's Raoul Pal, said it might have been farther to go to the upside before eventually rolling over. So do you think you missed the boat by not buying the dips as you originally planned out?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm not too worried about it. Obviously, the way the tape action's been, I did— what I had planned to do would have worked and it would have been a profitable trade so far. But I think that there are so many moving parts here, so many variables with all this election stuff going on, and particularly with Mr. Trump being so critical of the Fed, that's going to lead to a lot of speculation as to how a Trump presidency, if he were elected, might change monetary policy going forward. So I'm happy to be on the sidelines until the picture gets a little bit clearer. But yeah, so far I missed the trade.
Dollar index, the Fed and the election
Aaron Chan: So lastly, on the dollar index, the big volatility we were seeing in the dollar index seems to have calmed down now, now that there are no more FOMC meetings until after the election, with the DXY trading on a 95 handle ever since last week's show. So any change on this outlook?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I think, again, election outcome risk is going to be the driver of everything for the next couple of months. I think that there's no reason for the Fed to admit that their hiking cycle is over, which I think it is, until after the election. I think that the Fed is going to try to be as apolitical as possible and not say anything more than they have to until the election is over. The question is, you know, if Trump surges in the polls, what speculation that might lead to. Certainly, if Donald were to make it clear that he intends to put pressure on the Fed to allow interest rates to rise substantially, substantially from where they are and stop suppressing interest rates, and at the same time he were to surge in the polls, now you could see the dollar index really take off on speculation that a Trump presidency would mean higher interest rates. And that, of course, would lead to a stronger dollar.
That could cause gold to take a real hit. So, it's very interesting, the comment that you made earlier, too, about the convergence that is coming up.
I think one of the things a lot of people miss in technical analysis, when you see a wedge or a triangle, looking at that convergence point, as you just And saying, okay, what event that we know is coming on the geopolitical horizon is this chart pattern pointing to? And I think you got it exactly right. The gold descending triangle, if that's what it is, is pointing to the election, saying once we know, you know, if Trump is elected president and the dollar is going to take off and interest rates are going to move higher, gold is going to take a nosedive. There's no doubt about it. On the other hand, it could go the other direction. So I think that once the election results get clearer, all of these markets are going to resolve their consolidation patterns.
Aaron Chan: Okay. Well, thanks for the market update, Erik. Michael Lebowitz writes for institutional advisor 720 Global, and an article Mr. Lebowitz published back in June about the breakdown of the virtuous economic cycle has gotten a lot of attention from investors. Erik's interview with Mr. Lebowitz is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Interview: Michael Lebowitz, 720 Global, on the virtuous cycle
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Michael Lebowitz from 720 Global. And Michael, normally I like to start these interviews with the US dollar rally because everything else is priced in that. But I want to take a little deviation this week because you wrote a fantastic article back in June that's gotten a lot of attention called The Death of the Virtuous Cycle that really takes a step back and looks at the macro picture in probably a broader timescale. So I'd like I'd like to talk about that article first, and then we can move into our usual macro subjects. Why don't we start with The Death of the Virtuous Cycle? What's the premise of this article? What's it about?
Michael Lebowitz: So the purpose— and first of all, thank you for having me— the purpose was to provide a much more in-depth explanation on why economic trends are so poor, why they're stagnating, why productivity has ground to a halt, you know, real median wages are are still at levels from late 1990s. And there's all kinds of answers on a very short-term basis. We haven't fully recovered from the financial crisis, blah, blah, blah. But we believe there's much more to it, and we wanted to educate our clients and educate many others as to why this is occurring.
Erik Townsend: So, the death of the virtuous cycle. Let's start with what was the virtuous cycle? Describe the virtuous cycle that existed before it died.
Michael Lebowitz: So the virtuous cycle is an economic cycle that feeds on itself. It is basically— it's based on the discipline of saving. You save money, that money is invested, it's invested ultimately into production. Consumers invest it into various ways, but ultimately it's channeled into better means of production, more productive means of production. And as you get more productive, You get a couple things coming off that. You get higher earnings for corporations. You get higher wages because there's more money to go around.
With the higher earnings, with the higher wages, you also get a couple things. You get more consumption, but you also get more savings, and those savings go right back into this the virtuous cycle. So it's a organically self-sustaining cycle where you're consistently getting more and more production. And you're increasing wages, you're increasing earnings, and you're creating a more prosperous country. And if you look at the U.S., we were, you know, we started off as, you know, some guys landing on the shores of Plymouth Rock, and now here we are, that the U.S. is far and away the largest economy.
There's no question about that. And we've done it through all these incredible innovations that were a result That's the result of the virtuous cycle and the discipline that we had and the fortitude that we had to not just spend everything we had, but save it and invest and, and try to create a better tomorrow. And here we are now where this generation coming up is most likely not going to be as prosperous as the one before it, and that's going to be the first time that's happened.
How the virtuous cycle broke
Erik Townsend: So the cornerstone of the virtuous cycle is savings. Savings enables investment. Investment in investment in turn enables more productive, more efficient ways of doing things. That allows consumers' needs to be met with more leftover savings, and the cycle just feeds on itself. Why do you believe it's broken down, and how has it broken down?
Michael Lebowitz: So it's broken down over time, and certainly can't blame anyone specifically. You know, I do think the Federal Reserve has a lot to do with it. Certainly some rules out of the government have a lot to do with it. Basic mentality, consumer mentality, behaviors has a lot to do with it. But essentially what started happening in 1971, Nixon took us off the gold standard and that gave the Federal Reserve flexibility.
We wrote about this in an article called August 15th, and it gave the Federal Reserve flexibility to really screw around with the money supply, boost Boost it up, boost it down, or bring it down without having to worry about gold backing such moves.
So over time, and not immediately, the Fed became more and more aggressive. And what they really started doing, especially in the later '80s and the '90s, and aggressively more so after that, is trying to remove— trying to get rid of the business cycle. They were trying to alter recessions. And recessions are a good thing.
They eliminate bad investments, they enforce discipline on lenders and borrowers, and they have repercussions. It allows the business cycle that at times can get stretched, it allows inventories to come down. But in trying to get rid of recession, they didn't allow the recessions to fully play out. And there are many means of doing it with a series of low Lower and lower interest rates.
So as you bring down interest rates, people stop saving. They don't— they're not— they're not as incented to save. So you're starting to erode the virtuous cycle and essentially skipping— you're short-circuiting the whole virtuous cycle and you're going to the endgame, consumption, because consumption is 70% of economic growth. It's 70% of GDP.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Michael Lebowitz: 70% of economic growth.
And the feeling is that an expedient way to get ourselves out of recession, cut a recession short, is let's get people to borrow. They're going to borrow, they're going to spend. And if they spend, that's great because consumption is going to go up and it's going to look like economic activity.
And it does look like economic activity. And I would argue that for a long time it's hard to whether it's virtuous cycle economic activity or unvirtuous cycle economic activity. It kind of looks the same. But underneath, there's telltale signs.
Like I mentioned earlier, the flat earnings, flat wages, or negative wages. Productivity has been declining, and most likely productivity is going to be going negative. Some signs of labor productivity have gone negative. And total factor productivity could likely go negative at the next update. And I would also mention, this is not just a United States thing. This is going on in almost every developed nation.
Erik Townsend: You know, I agree with everything that you've said. I would add to that that I think there's a cultural shift that's occurred, certainly in my lifetime. When I was a kid growing up in the 1970s, you know, you get all of the messages from parents and teachers and school principals about how you're supposed to be, you know, don't do drugs and be a responsible citizen. Be a good citizen, don't be a criminal. And one of the strongest messages that we got, you know, every single time we went to school was personal responsibility. Be accountable for yourself, be responsible for yourself, and save for a rainy day.
We were given piggy banks when we were kids and taught to save. And now you've got congressmen on the floor of the United States Senate that are proposing why we need to change laws to punish savers and create debit cards that expire if you don't use them by a certain date so that people won't be selfish and save, which they think is wrong for society. So we've had this, this dramatic swing in terms of the public sentiment and what our children are taught about responsible financial planning.
Michael Lebowitz: I just wanted to add one more thing on more of the behavioral front too. It's also this short-termist attitude we have that we need everything today. We want everything today. And corporations are the same way. It's all about next quarter's earnings. Forget the future. What can we do today to make our lives better, make our company look better, or whatever it may be, without any regard for the future?
Debt-driven growth and tapped-out borrowers
Erik Townsend: Let's move to the consequences of this change. I agree with you completely that that virtuous cycle where society values savings and investment as the cornerstone of what enables prosperity. That message has gotten lost. I agree with that. So what are the consequences? How does it play out in markets? And, you know, if you're wanting to trade this, what would you look for in terms of trends that are actually actionable?
Michael Lebowitz: So it's essentially what we've done is turn the economy into a Ponzi scheme where basically more and more debt is needed to keep economic growth going, because at the end
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Michael Lebowitz: At the end of the day, there's really 3 components to economic growth. It's productivity, which is basically flatlining now. It's demographics, which helped our country immensely as the baby boomers were going through their 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s, but that's starting— that will become a headwind at some point.
And it's credit growth. So we have an economy that's highly dependent on credit growth. In fact, of a personal consumption, which again is about 70% of GDP, there's close to 40% to 50% of that is coming either directly or indirectly from debt. That's a massive amount of our GDP that is reliant on debt and not underlying organic economic growth. So you get to a point where you keep pushing debt, you lower rates, you make debt more affordable, but at some point, the debt is not serviceable. With wages, wages incomes have really lagged, and that's where you start seeing signs.
We saw that hit the consumers in 2008, and they've been very slow to increase again their debt. They're basically, to a large degree, tapped out.
Now we're starting to see it with corporations that are they're running they're running cash flow deficits because they're using their money. To do kind of silly things like stock buybacks. They're increasing dividends. They want to increase the share prices as much as possible. They're not investing in the future. CapEx spending— the age of their capital stock is increasing to 40, 50-year highs. They're not investing in the future.
They're cutting wages, and they are essentially killing their future, all to make this quarter's earnings look wonderful. So, so I think the sign is basically like 2008. When do— when does the marginal user of debt that's using debt to consume get to the point where they're tapped out? And I think we are very close to that.
Debt monetization and central-bank credibility
Erik Townsend: I want to talk more about how this ends and how close we are to that point. Something that I've felt for a number of years is when you get How did we get to the point where we are now, where this irresponsible live-beyond-your-means-on-borrowed-money attitude is not just something irresponsible people in society do? It's literally government policy to endorse and promote that kind of behavior. My contention is that with the government promoting it, it's going to go on until something breaks and ties the central bankers' hands so that they cannot continue to effectively monetize debt. And I realize The argument is that QE is not technically debt monetization, but it's only because there's an intermediary between the Fed and the government issuing the bonds. In all real intents and purposes, it really is debt monetization. I would contend this goes on until something breaks in the night, and the only thing I can think of is at some point we get to runaway inflation, and at that point the Fed has to stop doing all of this crazy money printing, otherwise we get into a hyperinflation.
Would you agree with that view, first of all? And more importantly, can you think of any other scenarios besides runaway inflation that would tie their hands and prevent central bankers from conjuring the next couple trillion dollars out of thin air?
Michael Lebowitz: Well, no. So I agree with you. They're going to keep trying to do what they're doing. They're going to get into negative rates. But the game is quickly coming to an end because as we're seeing here, we're seeing it in Europe, we're seeing into Japan, especially Europe and Japan, rates are negative. There are actually companies borrowing at negative rates or, you know, very, very low interest rates measured in basis points.
And it's not creating economic growth.
And so what I think is a very important issue is trust and confidence and faith in the central bankers. And as long as they can continue continue to make politicians, to make consumers, and probably most importantly, make investors in the financial markets believe in their voodoo, they can keep the ball rolling. They can keep kicking the can. But as we approach negative rates, I think it is quickly coming to an end. And I think what's interesting is the criticism on the Federal Reserve has been increasing, and it's not
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Michael Lebowitz: Not just guys like me and you that, that, that are viewed as alternative, that they, they look at things differently, they don't get it. This is coming from Lawrence Summers, has been very vocal. I actually just listened to an incredible interview from the Peterson Institute from Jason Cummins, and I apologize, I forgot where he's from, but he used to work for the Federal Reserve as an economist. He's basically an insider, and he's calling calling the Fed out in this interview, and it's truly amazing.
Erik Townsend: Well, I hate to find myself agreeing with Larry Summers, but—
Michael Lebowitz: No, but, but I think people are finally figuring out that the Fed does not have the answers. And I don't think they've gotten to the point yet, but I think they'll get there soon, that is it possible the Fed is actually causing these problems? And when that happens, it changes things drastically, because we both know that these financial markets are not priced at these levels based on their own merits.
Negative rates and the war on cash
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about negative interest rates some more, because, you know, as much as you and I might think, okay, this is crazy, because what it does is it basically creates a financial incentive for anyone who has any savings to spend it and not save it. So you're effectively creating a financial incentive for the entire nation nation to deplete itself of its savings, erasing the wealth of the country in terms of personal savings, which is crazy. But as much as you and I think it's crazy, you've got really, really high-level government officials that with a perfectly straight face are saying we need urgently to ban cash.
Even Ken Rogoff, who's very well respected for his work on the unsustainability of the national debt, has got a new book out trying to encourage the banning of cash, supposedly to stem criminal activities and terrorism and so forth. But if you get to, you know, any serious discussion of economics, people understand the reason for banning cash is to overcome the incentive that's created to hoard cash and potentially create a run on the fractional reserve system if you were to go to deeply negative interest rates. And you've got central bankers around the world talking about the need for negative interest rates, deeply negative interest rates sustained over a long period of time, because they believe that that is an effective and appropriate policy tool. So, guys like you and me see the lunacy of this, but, you know, the people that are in charge don't. What do you think would change that?
Michael Lebowitz: Well, first of all, I think it's downright scary, this call for getting rid of cash. Summers came out with that, I think it was during the summer, maybe 6 months ago or so, and he took the same approach as Rogoff, that criminalizing cash Criminal activity thrives off cash, which is okay. There is some degree of truth to that. But we also know, and HSBC has been caught up in this, that criminal activity also uses wires and they barter. And there's many ways that criminal activity occurs without cash.
And it's funny to me that Summers and Rogoff and others all of a sudden are concerned with criminal activity.
Yeah. But we both know the real reason that they want to do it is that if you, if you go to negative interest rates, people will hoard cash and they can't have that. So if your bank today was to call me and say, hey, we're gonna— your deposit rate that right now is zero or right around zero, we're gonna start charging you 5% a year to keep your money in our As soon as I get off this interview with you, I'm going right to that bank and I'm taking my cash out. And that cash is out of the system, which means I'm removing leverage from the system due to our fractional banking system.
And they know they can't have that, so it's a big impediment towards negative rates. But there's no common sense in negative interest rates.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Michael Lebowitz: Rates. We've never had negative interest rates. And there's this thought that's been going on in my head, and it's that interest rates are implying that the future— positive interest rates basically imply that the future is more uncertain to set. There's a risk premium. Now, there's other, there's other parts that go into the pricing of interest rates too, but can we also say that negative rates imply more certainty than today?
That's complete illogic. That doesn't make any sense.
And they're trying to keep this, for lack of a better word, debt scheme or Ponzi scheme going. They're to the point where we need negative rates now to generate very, very little growth. And the more they do it, the more they're eroding that virtuous cycle, that the productivity gains, the innovation, the new forms of production.
And it's— they're suffocating the economy all to get out another quarter of slightly better growth or to avoid a recession for another quarter or 2.
Erik Townsend: It's absolutely amazing. And, you know, something I don't think they've thought about— they use this scapegoat They're using the scapegoat of criminal activity as the reason for doing this. But if you actually think this through, it's true that if they ban cash, criminals will be forced to start transacting their business in something like precious metals, which is the obvious alternative. And can you imagine if we were to ban cash, essentially to enable negative interest rates? Eventually, those negative interest rates cripple the economy. You have a meltdown of the global sovereign debt market. And the only real The only wealth that's left in the world is precious metals, and criminals have all of the precious metals because the government banned the cash. I mean, it's, it's just absolute insanity.
Michael Lebowitz: So, so this is what bothers me. It's— we get it, and we're having a conversation about how insane it is, but the common person, the, the citizen, doesn't raise a stink about it. They don't Okay, it's negative rates. I get it. The economy is bad. They don't get it, and there's not more of a backlash And maybe there is a backlash and they just don't know how to economically talk about it or understand it. But they're starting to get it.
It's like that with inflation too. Why is the Fed demanding inflation? As a citizen, I don't want inflation. I don't want to have to pay more for whatever I'm. To buy tomorrow than today, but they accept it. And I'm really hoping that, you know, what we saw with Bernie Sanders, what we're seeing with Donald Trump, that we're starting to— the people are starting, finally starting to not only realize that things are wrong, but to take action.
Public anger, Brexit and European fracture
Erik Townsend: So maybe there is some hope, and maybe that's what Sanders and Trump are a signal What scares me is when you had something like World War II, okay, you know, the Nazis' agenda is very easy for everybody to understand. It's basically people of a certain race need to be executed in genocide. Okay, that's wrong. Everybody gets it.
When in order to understand what the battle is about, you need almost a degree or the equivalent amount of personal interest in macroeconomics to really understand the issues, then what happens is people just trust the government and let things go until the point, which I think we're reaching now, where they intuitively sense that something is deeply wrong and they start throwing Molotov cocktails at government buildings because they don't know how to explain what's wrong or what to do about it. They just know that it's unjust and corrupt. And I think that's what you're seeing with the political situation is most of the people in Occupy Wall Street, which is, you know, one political bent, or Or Tea Party is the opposite political orientation, but neither side really understood the issues very well. They just knew something was very deeply wrong, and they got upset about it.
And I think we're headed to more people being upset, and unfortunately the issues are complex enough that only a very small percentage of society listens to shows like this and cares to understand the details and the inner workings of it.
Michael Lebowitz: So here's one of the problems, and that's really bothers me is that it's not really that complex. Economics is not that complex. But most economists, and myself in my writings, they're not the easiest things to read, tend to be very technical and use jargon and are very confusing to the public.
Frequently, you know, my mom will call me and say, what did you mean by And I'm trying to, to make it as simple, and it is simple, but I think we really need more, more people like us to just simplify this and spread the word that this is not right. And negative interest rates should be the tip-off that it's not right.
Erik Townsend: We actually have negative interest rates and have had them for some time now in Europe, and a lot of people are getting worried about Brexit maybe being just the beginning and European exit contagion. Being a major macro risk over the next few years. What's your outlook? Was Brexit just a flash in the pan or was it the beginning of something that's only just begun?
Michael Lebowitz: Well, I think it all goes back to Sanders and Trump. People want something different. They're looking for anything different. And I think the fact that they voted to remove themselves from the euro region was stunning. Granted, they haven't The legislators have yet to pass what's called Policy 50 or Article 50, which starts the process in motion. But we are seeing fractures in the euro system, and I think these will continue as the people get upset. And there's also some geopolitical concerns as well. This immigration crisis is a big deal. And while they're trying to do the right thing and try to shelter people that are, that are in harm's way and living miserable lives, they are, they are letting in some terrorists as well. And it's a very touchy issue, and both sides have very good arguments, but it is just further leading to fracture.
But I think underneath all this fracture is the economy. Its wealth distribution has been horrendous. Wages aren't going up, but the wealthy are getting incredibly The very wealthy, and it's largely a function of central bank policy around the world, has been to inflate asset prices. And who owns assets? The wealthy, at the expense of productivity, which helps everyone.
Japan: demographics and yield-curve control
Erik Townsend: People who look at the long-term outlook for financial markets and asset prices in the United States are in many cases concerned about the retiring baby boom generation because it changes the demographics. backdrop of the country and points towards lowering productivity in the future. Japan, though, is really the poster child. Of all the countries, Japan is worst in terms of those twin forces of demographics and productivity. So what do you see for Japan, and do you think it's a harbinger of things to come for the United States as the baby boom generation ages and we get into this demographic change?
Michael Lebowitz: Yeah, I mean, they really have a worse than everyone. Their demographics are worse. They also have loaded up the boat on credit, and their productivity is now in decline, and it will most likely go further into decline. And they are really not allowing immigration into their country, which could change some of the demographics a little.
So they are the poster child, but they are also the poster child for central banks because somehow they have staved off a deflation.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Michael Lebowitz: —fall to bankruptcy despite numbers that are just stunning, debt-to-GDP type numbers. But again, I think they're starting to hit the end of the line, that they just can't keep doing what they've been doing. They're going deeper into negative rates. And one thing they just did, which is very, very concerning to me, is targeting the yield curve, targeting 10-year rates.
The yield curve is a barometer. It's what so many, so many economists use, so many corporations use to help them better understand where they should or shouldn't invest their capital into growth. And essentially, I feel like what they're doing is they are the equivalent of, say, like solving global warming by distorting thermostat or thermometer readings.
They're getting rid of the tool that we could use to help efficiently allocate capital. And that to me is extremely scary. It's also scary that they've been buying equity. It's scary to me that the Europeans were buying corporate debt. And then yesterday or 2 days ago, I saw various people noting something to the effect that down the line, Yellen could see potentially buying equities. It's frightening to me.
That's nationalization.
Bonds, precious metals and the 'bullish bear' view
Erik Townsend: So based on the things that you've said in this interview, it sounds like you agree with the view that equity prices are definitely extended and stretched here, but also bond prices, although they may still have further to go, are probably overvalued in the long-term picture of things because we've seen all of this artificial policy pushing yields So, what does that leave in terms of alternatives for savers? Are we looking at precious metals or something else? Where do we go at this point?
Michael Lebowitz: I do prefer precious metals. That being said, it can't be 80%, 90% of a portfolio. But I think it is an alternative, and it's not looked upon highly by many investors, so it's not widely owned. But if you're looking for something to protect your money, something that has done It's a viable alternative. It is a rock, I get it, but money is also not backed— money is paper.
So, uh, you know, I prefer to go with history and thousands and thousands of years of history and have an allocation to gold.
I am on the fixed income side. I guess I would call myself a bullish bear. I think yields can go down lower.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Michael Lebowitz: I think any kind of crisis, especially Europe, Japan, could send the dollar flying, and it could send so much money into the United States it could push yields much lower.
Fundamentally, we do have very low inflation, very low growth, so you can make somewhat of a fundamental case. But at the bottom line, these rates are not sustainable, and I think in the long run rates will be much higher. So it's, it's actually created quite the conundrum in the Treasury market. Rates are so low that even if you're bullish, is, is the risk-return skew really worth it?
And it's the bond market.
One of my biggest concerns with the bond market is that the marginal transactors are traders. They're not investors. When rates were at 5 5, 6, 10, 12%, investors were buying bonds. Grandma and grandfather and parents and everyone were buying bonds, and they didn't care about bond prices or changes in yield. They were going to hold it to maturity and they were going to make their set interest rate.
As rates go lower and lower, you get less investors that really buy— who's going to buy a 30-year bond at 2.3%?
Erik Townsend: That's right.
Michael Lebowitz: Hold it for 30 years. That's, that's an insane bet. So you end up with more and more traders. Traders are interested in price. They want to buy it at par, they want to sell it at 102. They don't have any intention of clipping a coupon, or the coupon they clip is meaning, you know, is not that great.
And there's also, because it's not that great, there's very little cushion for error. So My concern is that when the bond market turns, and I'm not— I don't think it's going to turn necessarily anytime soon, that traders exit en masse and there's no one left to pick up, to pick up the pieces. So you could have a pretty bad downdraft in bonds and yields, which has pretty big repercussions for a debt-driven economy.
Long gold, long dollar
Erik Townsend: I'd like to ask you about a trade that I discussed a couple of weeks ago on this program with Raoul Pal from Real Vision Television. Raoul and I both have been looking at the same trade, which is long gold futures and long dollar index futures at the same time. And of course, normally that trade wouldn't make sense because they're inversely correlated assets, and, you know, it doesn't seem to make sense. But Raoul and I both see the potential of a home run for both gold and the dollar appreciating, mostly because of flight capital capital going out of other markets around the world into both precious metals and US Treasuries as a safety trade. And of course, we could be wrong about that. You could have one go up as the other one goes down, which happens most of the time. But the scenario where they both go down at the same time, neither Raoul or I can see how that could happen.
So, it seems like a fantastic asymmetric return trade. What are your comments on that? Can you think of any scenario where both gold and the dollar index could trend downward at the same time?
Michael Lebowitz: I don't think the dollar index can trend. I think the dollar has been in consolidation now for well over a year, given that the Fed is still in a— I guess you could call it a hawkish mode, but they're the only central bank that's somewhat hawkish. And I use that term loosely, but they are talking about raising rates when everyone else is talking about new and creative ways to lower rates. And frankly, our economy is doing a little better than most of those countries.
So the dollar is the place to be, and it's hard for me to see the dollar selling off drastically. You know, a few points here or there, that's fine.
Gold, I'm a big supporter of it, but what bothers me, keeps me up at night, is what happened to gold in 2013. 2014, where there were massive orders to sell gold during illiquid markets. Why that occurred, who knows? What I do know is that central banks do not like the signal that gold sends, and they're trying to break signals.
You know, just like we discussed earlier with Japan and their 10-year, they're trying to break signals. If gold were at $2,500 right now, I am pretty sure that there would be a lot more concern about the Federal Reserve and what they're doing, what other central banks are doing. So, by however it can be done, by keeping a lid on the price of gold, they can keep a lid on a signal that all is not right.
So, I can't say that, you know, the dollar could go down a little and I could see gold getting smacked down a little. But that said, I agree with you guys.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Michael Lebowitz: I agree with you guys. I think there is the potential for them both to rally and rally significantly. Again, especially if something happens in Japan and Europe overseas, the flight to quality back to dollars could be amazing, and that could show up in Treasuries but also in gold.
Clinton, Trump and owning volatility
Erik Townsend: I'd like to move on to a topic that's on everybody's mind this week after the debate on Monday, which is the U.S. presidential cycle. We're asking all of our guests on the program to try to comment objectively on either outcome, Clinton or Trump. What do you think either outcome would mean for both the US stock market and generally global financial markets?
Michael Lebowitz: So I'll start with Hillary, I guess. She is kind of the status quo. She is the establishment. So in general, I think she would continue to push Obama policies. Be protective of the Fed. She'd probably push for some sort of infrastructure. So I think for the market, she's a safer bet. I think Yellen is safe with Hillary, at least to finish the term.
That said, Lawrence Summers is lurking in her shadow, and he's been critical of the Fed raising rates. I think he was out there this week too, again criticizing their rate hike in December.
Erik Townsend: Sure.
Michael Lebowitz: So on the margin, I don't think Hillary, at least initially, is a huge negative for equity prices.
Donald Trump, on the other hand, I like to say he has the ability to break the trade. Yellen could resign, he could release her, and he could really put a dent in Fed confidence, Fed credibility. Right. That's actually a big deal. And, you know, we saw the market get a little volatile. We saw things like the Mexican peso get volatile around the results of that, the perceived results around that debate.
So I think that Donald Trump has much more of an ability to upset the apple cart, so to speak. He's also, you know, very early on in that debate, and actually throughout the debate, kept talking about trade deals and renegotiating, restructuring trade deals. Well, many trade deals, the prime beneficiary of those trade deals, besides the people in these other countries that are getting jobs, are the corporations.
They're employing cheaper labor than they can employ at home, and they're getting rid of tariffs that allow them to sell their products. So Trump also has the potential to fundamentally hurt companies by by restructuring some of these trade deals.
What I think is amazing though is that the complacency in the market, and you can measure it a number of different ways, but the most simple way is the volatility index, VIX, has been very low. And we recently wrote about it and it's lower than, or when we wrote about it a month ago, it was lower than at any point in any, like the last 6 or 7 years. Elections at that point in time.
So the market, like everything else, is complacent. But I think there's a real risk here that there could be some extreme volatility. I actually saw Howard Marks' quote, I think it was yesterday, something to the effect that the riskiest thing out there is to believe that there's no risk.
And I think that sums it up well, that there is a lot of risk out there with the election. And you throw on top of that stagnating economic data, and I see no reason not to own volatility here. Obviously trade it because it's a tough instrument, and/or hedge your portfolios. But to me, again, you know, we talked about the skew in bonds. There's not that much upside and a whole lot of downside.
I think, uh, very similar on equities. Yeah, the markets could go up more. It's hard to see them going up much more because valuations are already beyond stretched, but, uh, the downside could be tremendous.
Erik Townsend: Unfortunately, we've run out of time. Before we close, please tell our listeners who'd like to follow more of your work what you do at 720 Global and where they can find out more information about it.
Michael Lebowitz: So we like to think that we're outsourcing CIOs, CIOs for hire. We basically offer consulting advice to professional investment advisors, and we basically want to help them make better decisions, providing them with unique research and guidance. I think most importantly, we're independent, as you've probably gathered through this conversation, and we share plenty of views that a lot of times are not popular, and we're beholden to nobody.
Uh, currently we publish research. We've put out there 50, 60 pieces. Some of them, like the Death of the Virtuous Cycle, as you mentioned, are very macroeconomic-based. Some will discuss specific numbers. We put out one recently on GDP, but we also discuss investment strategy and behavioral aspects as far as investing goes. So we really try to help advisors Help money managers, help endowment funds, help family offices provide their clients something, something better than what everyone else is doing.
Erik Townsend: And for our registered users at MacroVoices.com, this week's Research Roundup email will contain links to a couple of sample articles that Michael has written, and particularly the Death of the Virtuous Cycle article. Michael, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. We really appreciate it. Aaron Chan and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer break
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time. in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program.
Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan.
Postgame: Dwight Anderson's Real Vision interview
Aaron Chan: So Erik, for this postgame, I actually want to get your take on a recent Real Vision TV episode that Raoul Pal recommended back when we interviewed him 2 weeks ago. Now, the specific must-see interview that I'm referring to is Dwight Anderson's conversation with Dan Tapiero. Now, I thought it lived up to everything Raoul said, and it's definitely something that I'm bookmarking for future viewing. In listening to Dwight Anderson's background as a manufacturing consultant to ultimately becoming a commodities investor, I couldn't help but notice parallels between you and him.
How has your business background helped you to become a better investor, and how did you go about developing your framework for viewing the world?
Erik Townsend: Wow. Excellent question. Just for the benefit of anybody who's not a regular listener and didn't hear that interview with Raoul Pal, we are talking about a Real Vision television interview that Raoul had recommended Real Vision, of course, is a paid subscription service, but if you haven't already used up your free trial subscription, you can get a free trial just for being a MacroVoices listener, and you can hear this interview that Aaron is asking me about.
But to go back to your question, Aaron I enjoyed this interview. I always like finance guys that actually have a background in really and truly running a business first before they get into finance. Maybe that's just because it's how I relate to it, but something that I always noticed before I got into finance and was involved in the corporate world is, you know, You see these guys that are super duper smart, Ivy League, Harvard MBA types, and they're just saying, what is wrong with this stupid CEO? Why doesn't he see that to get his ratios where he needs to be, he needs to increase his revenue? These dummies. And you sort of say, you know, there's this thing called a customer who has to consent in order to get revenue increased.
Aaron Chan: Oh, right.
Erik Townsend: It's not something you just turn a dial up on. And I often feel like even the smartest finance analysts, guys that have been studying business for all of their careers but never actually ran one, are kind of at a disadvantage.
And frankly, I think that the country is dramatically disadvantaged because the whole corporate management just preoccupation with short-sightedness and focusing on next quarter's earnings, never paying attention to the next 10 years' strategic strategy— it's not because the CEOs are stupid, it's because they are being compensated and paid based on how Wall Street Wall Street responds to them and what happens to the stock price. And they have learned that all that Wall Street cares about is next quarter's earnings, not the strategic prospects for the company. So it's very interesting to me to make the transition from the corporate culture into— I don't know I'm really part of the Wall Street culture, I don't want to be— but, you know, into the world of investment management and investment analysis. So it has It has helped shape my view of the world. And I think that people who've actually run a business are better qualified to invest in them than Ivy League guys that never actually ran one.
Inflation versus deflation
Aaron Chan: Yeah, the tangible experience definitely sounds useful. Now, I want to pivot to an economic issue here. Now, we've all heard the deflation versus inflation debate. And Dwight sees both sides of the argument. On the one hand, there is the debt load, demographics, declining productivity, the viability of the E.U. All that leading to deflation. But he also sees the erosion of the good faith of paper currencies, and in particular the dollar, and the subsequent march towards inflation. So, Erik, where do you stand on the spectrum and how do you think about this position?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think about it in a different paradigm than what you just described, because you're kind of talking either/or. Is it an inflationary or a deflationary story? And the way I look at it is history teaches us that every epic inflation in history was preceded by a really strong whiff of deflation.
And I think we're in the deflation that comes before the big inflation. Without a doubt, the people that have said that the US dollar is doomed to collapse someday because fiat currency has been stretched beyond any reasonable limit, it's not backed by any hard asset, and the US debt is just so phenomenal that, you know, this whole house of cards has to come crashing down and the dollar is doomed, they're going to be proven right someday.
Aaron Chan: Right.
Erik Townsend: But before that happens, I think the US dollar is headed much higher against other currencies because of the whole best-looking, you know, dirty shirt in a very dirty laundry pile, or cleanest shirt in dirty laundry pile, whatever the analogy is. So, I think what we're going to see is a continuing deflationary force, a very pro-US dollar, dollar index probably moving substantially higher from here, especially if a dollar Trump presidency scenario were to cause the Fed to stop keeping interest rates artificially low.
I think at some point that dollar collapse scenario becomes real, but we're in uncharted territory. And the worst mistake you can make is to think that because something has to happen someday, that that means it's going to start happening tomorrow. So, I don't look at it as an either/or. I look at it as a question of where are we in the timeline? At some point, we see the bottom of the deflationary pressure and we move into an inflationary period. And eventually, I I think we have to combat runaway inflation. Are we getting close to the turning point? I have no clue, and I don't think anybody does.
Electric vehicles and the WTI term structure
Aaron Chan: Got it. So you look at this temporally, and then there's some sort of inflection point. Now, Erik, I want to pivot to something that's in your wheelhouse. And Dwight brought up a thesis that I thought was variant and different from anything else I'd ever heard. And it's that the penetration rates of electric vehicles will lead to higher crude oil prices, because oil companies will be concerned about where oil prices will be, given the inroads made by electric vehicles. So, in response, they'll cut major production projects. And I want to get your take. What do you think about this opinion?
Erik Townsend: I'm so glad that you asked me about that one, because I wanted to crawl through my Real Vision viewer and strangle Dan Tapiero for not asking the obvious follow-up question.
Aaron Chan: Erik, easy. We want to interview Dan hopefully someday.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I meant to say, as we look forward to inviting Mr. Tapiero onto the show, one of the questions I'd like to ask him is. He didn't ask about the term structure of what would be going on, or they didn't talk about the term structure of the crude oil futures market, because the assertion that was made by Dwight is, look, the CEOs of oil companies are gonna be spooked out by a growing acceptance of the electric vehicle revolution, and they're not gonna wanna invest in really expensive projects. Well, look, they don't care what the future of electric vehicles is. They care whether or not they can justify their projects. based on what they can hedge today. So, if you were to have a situation where electric vehicles had taken over sentiment of the markets, and there was an expectation reflected in the term structure of WTI crude oil futures specifically. So, let's say it's a year from now or 2 years from now, front-month WTI is trading, let's say for sake of argument, at $120 a barrel.
But the 5 or 6 or 7-year-out contracts are down at $50 a barrel because the market is expecting a collapse. Okay, now, yeah, that would lead to even higher short-term prices because nobody is going to build any projects. But no, it doesn't matter how convinced you are that electric vehicles change everything. If there's still contango in the market and the 5, 6, 7-year-out futures are trading at $140 or $150, you're gonna do that super deepwater Arctic, whatever it is, frightfully expensive project because you can sell forward right now, hedge your future production, and eliminate your market risk. So it's not about what electric vehicles are going to do. It's about what the term structure of WTI futures looks like. And I was shocked that Dan didn't think to bring up that question.
Sponsor message
Aaron Chan: Well, hopefully, if we can get Dan Tapiero on, you can ask him that question, Erik. Well, I've got quite a few more questions I'd like to ask you, but we'll have to save it for another time. Guys, I highly recommend you check out this interview if you're a Real Vision TV subscriber.
And if you're not, don't fret. You can trial the program for free and even get a 10% discount on your subscription by signing up at www.realvisiontv.com/discount/macrovoices. So, Erik, that's all I've got for this week. Anything else to add?
Research Roundup and sign-off
Erik Townsend: Well, our listeners already know the broken record. We really appreciate it when you help us promote the show, because the more that people have heard of MacroVoices, the easier it is for Aaron to recruit the very best guests to put on the program. So please help us out by retweeting our announcements if you're on Twitter. Tell your friends, forward your Research Roundup emails to your colleagues so that they can get interested and sign up for it too. And of course, most importantly, register your free account at MacroVoices.com. You get a benefit of a free weekly Research Roundup email. Let's tell them what's in it this week, Aaron
Aaron Chan: Right. I'd like to start by highlighting an excellent research note from Shannon McConaghy of Horseman Capital on why Why Japanese Regional Banks Are Ultimately Going to Zero. Now, we've all heard about how negative interest rates are killing the banks, and with Governor Kuroda recently committing further to cutting short-term rates, as well as introducing yield curve control, this is one of the most succinct and comprehensive treatments of this issue in a mere 3 pages that I've ever read. So you definitely don't want to miss this. Now, next up is an excellent note from Daniel Oliver of Myrmikan Capital, in which he discusses where we currently stand in the gold mining recapitalization cycle, and why asset developers might be the place to be in the medium term. He then quotes Senator Root's extraordinary 1913 speech in opposition to the Federal Reserve Act and provides data in support of the inevitable economic laws of credit expansion. Finally, one of our biggest proponents on Twitter, Michael Medici, put together an excellent slide deck which organizes what our past guests have articulated on various topics they've discussed with Erik, and I highly encourage you to check this out.
Personally, I think it's a huge value add because it's a great way to view our past content in a way that is comparable and actionable because you can also compare the different trade strategies that are brought up. So big thanks to Mike, and anyone who is interested in this project should reach out to him on Twitter @MikeRMedici. You'll find all this and much more in this week's Research Roundup.
So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we've gotten and continue to welcome your suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For our listeners who write or blog about global markets and would like to share that content with our pro finance community, shoot us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag and we'll include it in our weekly distribution. If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for the latest updates and interview releases. You can also follow Erik @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna.
Erik Townsend: Thanks, Patrick.
Aaron Chan: For Erik Townsend, I'm Aaron Chan. Chat with you next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at www.MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup. Up email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week, which never includes advertising or marketing.
You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we're able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can also subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag Bag segment.
MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's host. Or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
