Jared Dillian — author of the popular Daily Dirtnap newsletter (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview: Dillian, Cole and Anderson

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 104 was recorded on February 8th, 2018. I'm Erik Townsend. It's been a hell of a week, and we have a hell of a show lined up for you. Jared Dillian, author of the popular Daily Dirtnap newsletter, will be joining me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll talk about the role that the short vol trade played in this week's equity sell-off, as well as what's ahead for stocks, the US dollar, and much more.

You already know that the volatility complex basically blew up earlier this week, and if you're a regular MacroVoices listener, you know that we've both predicted this event and covered it extensively on past shows. 2 weeks ago, Artemis Capital founder Chris Cole laid out exactly how this could go down in his feature interview, which needless to say was prescient. Chris will be back for an update in our postgame segment after the feature interview with Jared Dillian. Regular listeners may also remember Devin Anderson joining us in our postgame segment back on November 30th when he described exactly how the volatility complex could blow up on a really big one-day move in equities such as we had on Monday. Devin will also join us in today's postgame segment right after we get an update from Chris Cole. We'll revisit what happened and what's next for the vol complex. If you missed Devin's first appearance, you can find it in the postgame segment after our feature interview with Jonathan Tepper back in November.

Just look for Jonathan's name and photo on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Chris Cole's interview is next to his photo on our homepage just 2 weeks back.

S&P 500 correction and the VIX narrative

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, that S&P 500 literally took a dive right after we finished last week's episode of MacroVoices and just started to roll over. We find ourselves near the 2,600 level on the S&P right now as we're recording. What's your thinking now on the S&P at these levels?

Erik Townsend: Well, the first thing to put in context, Patrick, is so far we've seen, and even on an intraday basis, about a 10% total peak-to-trough sell-off. So it's a big deal, but, you know, it's a correction. If we go back to normal times, excluding the recent few years of central bank-supplied liquidity, a 10% correction is really not a big deal. It's not out of the usual. It's not the end of the world. So if we want to think in terms of has the market crashed, is the big event that some people have predicted happened now. It's definitely not this. It's not big enough yet.

So the big question that's on everybody's mind is, is this the best buy-the-dip opportunity in years, or is this the beginning of a really big sell-off? Needless to say, the ratio call spread strategy that we've described and that you had a webinar on has paid off in spades. That allowed people who wanted to continue to have upside exposure to the stock market to close their long stock positions and to put a option trade on that had no downside. So people who got out of the stock market when we first recommended it and instead expressed their upside with that ratio call spread didn't lose a penny on this sell-off.

The next question, of course, that we have to get to is, are we going to see a retrace all the way back up and make some new highs and the 10% correction is in that was long overdue and it's all uphill from here? Or is it going to just get worse from here? It's important to understand what happened in the first place, and frankly, I don't I don't think anybody knows for sure, but one of the narratives that we're hearing is what I'm calling the tail wagging the dog scenario, which is to say higher interest rates are what got the equity sell-off started, but then it was the VIX blowing up. Basically, we got the VIX up to a point on natural selling in the stock market where it triggered that liquidation event we've been fearing for so long. And when that happened, VIX futures going up are a trigger because there are a lot of algorithmic trading systems that are programmed to start selling selling equities when the VIX goes up.

So I think that a big piece of what has happened here is, in fact, that the VIX has exacerbated the sell-off. There was room to say after that first event, hmm, maybe that caused it to go too far and we're gonna just recover, kind of flash crash style V recovery. What we're seeing today on Thursday afternoon is signs that that rally has failed at just more than a 50% retrace of the sell-off. We're not back to fresh new lows yet, but boy—

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Boy, we're getting close. And in fact, on a closing basis— intraday lows, we're not there yet— on a closing basis, it looks like Thursday's close— and we're taping this a few minutes as I'm speaking right now before the cash close at 4 PM on Thursday— it looks like we may be headed for a new closing low on Thursday. So it's not looking good for the recovery scenario. Now, does that mean that the end is nigh and the market is crashing from here?

I doubt it. And if I had to pick an analogy to what this feels similar to, Think about 1987, but not October 19th of 1987. Think a month or two before that, when we started to see significant increases in volatility in the stock market, but it wasn't over yet. It wasn't the big one. Now you might say, well, those were smaller than the 10-percenter. We got 10%. Isn't this the big one? Who says the big one is gonna be as small as it was in '87? I think the big one, when it happens, and I thought it was still at least 6 months off, maybe I'm wrong, but when the big one happens, I think—

Patrick Ceresna: It's coming.

Erik Townsend: I think it's a doozy, and I think it could be bigger than a 23% down move, which is what we saw in October of '87. I don't necessarily think that it's started yet, but I think maybe we're getting closer to it. It's gonna be very interesting in coming days to see whether or not we can get back up to, you know, further up the hill towards a recovery. So far, it's not looking good. If we sell off to new lows, you know, watch for it to accelerate, and think it's gonna be very interesting. We're gonna get all 3 of our guests to comment on where We'll see where things may be headed from here.

Options strategies after the volatility shock; webinar

Erik Townsend: Meanwhile, Patrick, I want to come back to the various option strategies we've talked about. Needless to say, getting out of equities and expressing your long interest in the market using that ratio call spread that you did a webinar on was a fantastic call. People who did that didn't lose a penny in this sell-off.

But you actually told me off the air, your Big Picture Trading clients really made a huge windfall profit this week because you were calendaring straddles. Is of interest to our listeners, I want to touch on that. But particularly, you know, it's a different game now because a lot of what we've said in past weeks has been, hey, options have never ever been cheaper. It's time to take advantage of that cheap optionality. That's a big different story right now.

So give us an update on some of the option strategies that you're talking to your Big Picture Trading clients about. And, you know, since the environment has changed, are you going to do another webinar to bring people up to date?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, it was really actually a great week for our members and congratulations to all of them. One of the things we were doing, 'cause we were opening all of these trades in that low vol period, one of the ways that I was expressing the trades was publishing a calendared straddle. Basically, we were buying a longer dated put option and hedging it with short-term calls and we kept rolling it up. So every time we were early and the market took another leg higher, we kept closing the straddle for a profit and rolling it to the higher strike. And so we basically rolled up that straddle right up to the mid-280s. on the SPY and suddenly the market reversed and we were able to cash in in a big way. But you know, the market has now completely changed because now that the VIX has exploded out and the vol premiums returned right in, like you're seeing options on the SPYs, right? The implieds are north of 30% on many of these options.

And so right now, all of those strategies we talked about as ratio call spreads or ratio put spreads or straddles and things like that, while they were really good a couple weeks ago, they're really expensive now.

And so you have to rethink the entire way to approach options trading in this environment, completely opposite of where we were earlier. And, you know, I was originally talking with you even potentially about doing another webinar because during the last one when we did the ratio call spreads, a lot of our listeners were making the comment, well, what about a ratio put spread? And we said, well, absolutely you could do a ratio put spread. And I was thinking, well, you know what, we got to have another webinar to kind of talk about how to take advantage of the market to the downside.

Well, it was kind of late. We were setting it all up and then the market started to dive. So we still are going to do a webinar this upcoming weekend. You can You can find the link in the Research Roundup email, or you could go to bigpicturetrading.com and register on there.

But we wanted to now flip it around because now have this very high vol period, and there's one of two things that are gonna happen. Either A, how do you keep expressing a downside trade? You think the market is gonna keep going lower, or more importantly, in this very high vol period, how do you call a bottom and use options to try to express the long side of the market and try to buy the dip while the volatility's so expensive? And so lots of really interesting things that I look forward to. actually discussing in that one. And that's gonna be on Sunday at 11:00 AM, and then another one on Monday Eastern time.

Erik Townsend: And I think the important thing for everybody to understand there is it's a different game. It's not time now to learn about the strategies we were espousing and recommending a few weeks ago. It's a different vol regime and it's a different strategy. And that's probably why you're doing a new webinar. Let's move on though, to keep things rolling, 'cause we've got 3 guests lined up.

US dollar: bottoming?

Erik Townsend: US dollar, I am leaning now. I know it sounds crazy, but I really think that the dollar recovering I don't know if it's a new secular bull market, but more than just a bounce. A lot of people were thinking, yeah, we're getting a little bounce. It's the, you know, look for a chance to short it again here because it's headed down. Boy, I was coming around to that viewpoint, but, you know, if this was just a bounce, I can't reconcile it with what's going on with yields and gold. The only way I can reconcile the interactions between the different asset classes is if the dollar is perhaps bottoming here, at least in the short term.

Now, if yields turned around, that would be another story. But as long as we see this trend toward increasing bond yields, I think the dollar has bottomed and is headed higher from here.

Crude oil: inventories, production and positioning

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because really we saw that short-term overhead resistance and now a couple of days of straight selling down towards the $60 handle on the downside. What's happening here in oil?

Erik Townsend: Well, finally, you know, I've been saying for how long now that I really think we're overdue and particularly with regard to, you know, Like 12 to 1 speculative long-to-short ratio. It was just a setup for a big sell-off, and it has begun.

The big question is how far we go. Let's start with inventory, Patrick. We built on crude oil, building 1.9 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, still drawing down, but a very small drawdown compared to what we've seen in recent weeks, 711,000 barrels. Probably the Brent spread narrowing is the reason that we're not seeing as many exports and we're not seeing as much pressure On Cushing. The reasons for that were described in our interview last week with Pat Hemsworth. Gasoline, great big build, 3.4 million barrels. Distillates building 4 million barrels. So big builds, needless to say, very bearish news. And production, another 332,000 barrels all the way up to 10.25 million barrels. That's, I believe, an all-time record, even, you know, Topping whatever it was in the early '70s when the US was producing the most oil. And I'm pretty sure that we're now producing more oil in the United States than Saudi Arabia. Holy cow.

So the big question is, that's needless to say all very bearish news. How far does this go? Well, I can very easily, Patrick, make a strong argument for if you look at how extreme the speculative positioning was, everybody on one side of the boat, it was the same setup that we saw in the middle of 2014.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: It was a similar setup but even more extreme than what we had in February of last year. It's time for the beginning of a multi-month sell-off that takes us way down, at least $10, maybe even $15 lower. The thing is, Patrick, I have been wrong a lot this year thinking, okay, here comes a big sell-off, and I'm actually— my timing's been pretty good on when the sell-offs were gonna happen. I say we're gonna go down $5 to $10 and we go down 50 cents to a dollar. Now this time we finally got our $5 down, but if I look at the chart. If this is just going to be a correction to the bottom of the established upward sloping channel that we see, then it's over right here. It's done, and we can expect it to recover and start to move to the upside.

I am leaning not towards that case. I think that there is more selling and more downside to come in crude oil prices, but I have to handicap myself and say I have been bearish and wrong quite a few times. If we continue to see production numbers like this, And inventory building instead of drawing, I think things are going to finally turn around. It's been a long time in coming, but it's finally happening. We'll see what happens.

Gold as a macro signal

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik. Well, let's move on to gold because this moment the US dollar reversed, gold just started to downtick, and we're now heading down to around the $1,317 area on bullion. What's your thinking here on gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's pretty clear, at least in this cycle, that, you know, we're headed back down. We're not going to take out $1,400. At this point, as far as where is it going in the next few weeks, How would you trade it? I don't really have an opinion. I'm not so interested in gold right now for trading it. I'm more interested in the macroeconomic signal that it's telling me. And the signal is, this is not the catastrophic end of the world for the US dollar, 'cause it was so hard to reconcile increasing Treasury yields with weakening dollar. And that is a signal that I've predicted for a long time that would eventually come when it truly is the endgame for the US dollar's hegemony over the global financial system.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: If that was happening, we wouldn't talk about whether or not gold can get past $1,400. We'd be thinking about $14,000. So clearly, it's not that. And I think, all things told, I do expect a big move up in gold at some point here.

Eventually, we're gonna get back to inflation. We're going to get to a very difficult situation where central banks' hands are tied. They can't really solve our problems by printing money. And I think that gold is going to see a really big run to the upside. But I'm leaning more and more towards I'm leaning towards that not being time yet, that we probably have a wave down in gold. How far, I don't really know, but I don't think it's time for gold to make its big move up yet.

10-year yields and risk parity

Patrick Ceresna: Now, let's move on to 10-year yields because we had on Monday this quick, sharp reversal off of the 2.85 level going all the way down to 2.70 on the yields. And we were asking whether that was the big reversal. And yet now, just 3 days later, we find ourselves right back to the 2.85 level. It doesn't seem like these bonds are letting up here. What's your thinking here on interest rates and bonds?

Erik Townsend: Well, of course, when you had the VIX complex blow up and that triggered the algos to start selling, people who were panic selling out of the stock market have got to put the money someplace. A lot of that goes into bonds. Sure enough, that created a short-term reversal in this trend, and a lot of people were saying, okay, that was a head fake up to the 280-whatever, and, you know, it's not going to come back. As soon as that flow out of the equity market into the bond market slowed down, we saw the trend turn right back around.

And we're headed higher in yield, 2.85 this afternoon. So it seems like the Jeff Gundlachs and Bill Grosses of the world who have said, hey guys, the jig is up and rates are headed higher, are gonna be right.

The big question is, how far can it really go? At some point, you know, you can't get back to historically normal Treasury yields, I contend, because it would literally bankrupt the United States government if you did. I'm gonna ask Jared Dillian about this, and I wanna talk in more of our postgame segments in future shows about some different scenarios. But we've got to figure out what is going on in the bond market and how much farther it can go. I don't really have a strong opinion at this point other than to watch the trend. But if this continues, it's going to, I think, continue to create a lot of trouble for the stock market.

I think probably the reason— and as I'm speaking right now, we're just hitting 4 o'clock, and it looks like it is going to be a new closing low today on Thursday in stocks. I think the 2.85 that we see in yields is a big part of the reason for that.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: If this continues, I think the stock market's in trouble. And boy, stock market and bond market selling off at the same time. Talk about the carnage that comes to the risk parity trade. That, of course, was part of Chris Cole's pyramid slide where he talked to us about all of the different forms of the short vol trade. I want to get Chris's update on that. So I'll stop talking now. We'll save time for our expert guests because we've got 3 of them lined up.

Patrick Ceresna: All right.

Erik on Hedgeye (Bitcoin); lead-in to the interview

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, Keith McCullough had you on Hedgeye as a guest to discuss Bitcoin. Why don't you quickly fill us in on what you did on the show?

Erik Townsend: I really enjoyed that. Keith is a good guy, and I like the Hedgeye guy. Very professional crowd to work with. Basically, I do have a lot of opinions on Bitcoin. I don't want to editorialize here on MacroVoices. We've got too much else to cover. Keith and I went, I think, a good solid half hour on a video interview. You can find a link to it in your Research Roundup email. It has all of my reservations, and it's kind of an outline of my debunking blockchain. white paper, which was linked a couple of weeks ago. So let's leave it there and save time for our future guests.

Patrick Ceresna: That sounds good. I want to actually check that out. Now let's move on to our featured interview guest, which is the Daily Dirtnap author Jared Dillian, who also writes for Mauldin Economics. Erik's interview with Jared is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here on MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: This week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Jared Dillian: rates triggered it, short vol forced the covering

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Jared Dillian, the author of the extremely popular Daily Dirtnap newsletter. Jared, obviously everybody's mind is on the equity market this week, but I think it's really important to bring the volatility complex into this. As you know, your friend Devin Anderson appeared on this program back on November 30th, and he explained that a An equity move the size of what happened on Monday could potentially blow up the volatility complex. But I think what a lot of people have started to talk about is it may have actually been the tail wagging the dog, that what exacerbated, or some people would even say caused, this equity sell-off may have been the vol complex blowing up. So it's a question of cause and effect. What do you think is going on here? Is it possible that vol caused the equity meltdown, or did the rate hike Did the bank cause backing up in interest rates, cause this to start?

And how do you see the interplay between what's happened in equity markets in the last week and what's happened with the volatility complex? And of course, the XIV ETF being terminated after it blew up.

Jared Dillian: Sure, I can cover all that. First of all, thanks for having me. You know, this vol blowup where the VIX went from 10 to 50 did not just happen spontaneously. This all was put in motion by the rates market, by the bond market, and the fact that over the last 3 or 4 weeks, rates started to leak higher in 10s and bonds because, quite frankly, the news that we were going to get $1 trillion in Treasury issuance this year. And this was the first time since at least 20 years, it's been a really long time that supply has mattered in the Treasury market. So the front end had been selling off for a while, and then the back end starts to sell off. And all of a sudden, the equity The equity market looks at this and says, we have higher rates and this is a problem. Once the sell-off got in motion, then the people who were structurally short volatility had to cover.

And basically, the world was short volatility. And that covering drove the VIX all the way to 50, and it blew up a couple of inverse vol ETPs. And there you have it.

Erik Townsend: And of course, we should mention that there are some of the algorithmic trading systems that are programmed when the VIX raises to start selling equities more aggressively.

Jared Dillian: Yes.

Erik Townsend: So there's kind of a self-reinforcing effect that, you know, the equity blowup causes the VIX to blow up, the VIX blowup causes the equity blowup to get worse, the equity blowup getting worse exacerbates the VIX blowup. It's all feeding on itself. Now, I think the, the big question that this has got to be putting in almost every investor's mind is, okay, it's pretty darn clear that although this was initiated by backing up of interest rates. I strongly agree with you on that point.

One thing led to another. These two, the interplay that we've just described between the vol complex and equity markets exacerbated the sell-off. So does that mean that we just hit the buy-the-dip opportunity of a lifetime because it was an artificial sell-off that went to levels that it shouldn't have? Or is it more likely the case that maybe this is just getting started because that change in rates is, It's a big deal. It's going to have a continuing effect on the market, and maybe we're looking at a change in overall trend here.

Jared Dillian: I think really the change in trend, it is in the equity market, but it really isn't. It's really more about the volatility market. And if you think about how the vol market has been set up, I mean, really, it has been about 20 years since you could make money being long gamma. Gamma, being long vol and dynamically hedging. It's been that long where you could really do that on a sustainable basis for a couple of years. So these short vol strategies have attracted a lot of sponsorship because they basically have a Sharpe ratio of infinity. I mean, if you're short S&P vol and the market realizes zero, which is basically what's been happening, then your Sharpe ratio is very, very high. So these strategies have been attracting a lot of sponsorship. And I can tell you that every vol desk on Wall Street, these are not long gamma traders. They have to be short gamma because that is the only trade that worked for the last 10 or 20 years.

And what we saw, what we've seen in the last couple of days is a regime shift in the volatility market where it will no longer pay to be short gamma. It will pay to be long gamma. If you think about what's happened just in these, the size of these equity moves. The Dow at one point was down 1,600 points, and then on Tuesday there was a 1,000-point bottom-to-top swing in the Dow. If I'm thinking about this as a vol trader and I'm hearing about 1,000-point moves in the Dow, that sounds like I really want to be long gamma. And I think people are gonna have to learn this the hard way.

You know, I remember when I came into the option market in 1999, I heard about all the old short gamma traders from the early '90s and the mid-'90s that blew up in the late '90s when volatility appeared. And we had a period of time from about 1996, '97 to 2002 when vol was very high and people had to adapt to that environment. They're gonna have to adapt again.

Regime shift in volatility and the short-vol pyramid

Erik Townsend: And what is the basis? It sounds like your opinion here is this is not an anomaly that's going to mean revert and we're not headed back to, you know, VIX at 8 or something. That's over and done with, it sounds like, is what you're saying. Why are you saying that? And I guess that would probably beg the question, you know, some people might be looking at this saying, holy cow, you know, here's your opportunity right now to short the VIX, get in on that short vol trade which has been working so well for so many years, and this is clearly a huge dislocation. Some people would be saying if there's ever been a buy the dip of a lifetime, It's going short vol here at these higher levels. So, it sounds like you think we've got a regime change that is going to be locked in for a while.

Why is that? And what does it mean in terms of other implications and knock-on effects?

Jared Dillian: Honestly, it's sort of my intuition, my opinion. I mean, if you think about the significance of what happened with XIV and SVXY, right? I mean, basically, these are funds which gained in value for a period of about 6 years and then blew up. 6 years of gains. Gains gone in one day. What that means symbolically, the symbolism of that, is that the short vol trade has been discredited, and that's an explicit short vol trade. If you're long XIV, you are explicitly short vol. If you're short VIX futures or variance swaps you're explicitly short vol.

There are also implicit short vol trades too that also are going to blow up if we have a regime. I don't really know how risk parity works really well, but it seems like an implicit short vol trade to me that is in danger. There's a lot of brokerages which market iron condor strategies to their customers. That is an explicit short vol trade. So, I think they're all in danger. I think we've had a regime shift.

Erik Townsend: Jared, we had Chris Cole on the program a couple of weeks ago, and he had this pyramid slide showing that the explicit short vol trade that everybody talks about, that's the XIV, XIV ETF and the other explicit strategies are tiny compared to the much, much larger pyramid of short vol strategies, which include risk parity that you just mentioned, but also pension overwriting and a number of other things. So do you think that we are at a point where potentially the whole pyramid gets unwound and we're only at the beginning of this? And what would you look for if the answer is, well, it's hard to be sure yet, what would you look for to tell you whether or not we've got a major regime change in terms of where vol is headed, or if this was a blip that maybe has room to mean revert?

Jared Dillian: No, I haven't seen Chris's slide, but from how you've described it, I agree with that. And I do think that this is in the beginning, the very top of the first inning, nobody out, of an unwinding process that's going to take a really, really long time. And I really think it is because of the psychological significance of what just happened. People are not going to be able to put the genie back in the bottle. And I think what you What you would have to look for is, just like any other chart person would tell you, higher lows in volatility. So if people try to stuff vol back into the teens, or 13, or 12, or 11, and it doesn't work, and we continue to get volatility in the stock market, then I'd say we have higher lows in vol, and the trend has changed. Right now, it's a little bit too early to make that call. I'm making that call just because of my intuition.

You do need a little bit more evidence.

Erik Townsend: Jared, I wanna focus specifically on the way the XIV blew up and the number of people that were hurt by it. Now, certainly on this program, we have been harping on this show after show after show that this short vol trade was destined to blow up someday. We're not the only ones. There's lots and lots of smart people all over the industry who have been saying this short vol thing is a disaster in the making. It's worse than picking up nickels in front of a steamroller. It's going to lead to disaster. Now what's happened is this trade originally was something that very sophisticated institutional investors put on, and then we had the creation of these retail products like the XIV that took a strategy that lots and lots of experts in the industry were counseling strongly against as having a blow-up risk, that exactly this would happen, and that's well known.

The people that make money on building ETFs went ahead and offered this to retail investors anyway. It seems to me, and I think Chris Cole said this in his interview, you know, this is the class-action lifetime opportunity, if you're a lawyer, to look at this and say, they didn't understand. This was a product that was not appropriate for retail investors. The experts were saying it was a bad idea, and those greedy ETF inventors went ahead and offered it to retail anyway and let them be the suckers to essentially provide that source of short volatility that was really writing disaster insurance, creating cheap tail hedges for everybody else. I've got to believe this is a class action law firm's dream come true. Do you think that it's going to change the industry in terms of what kinds of products are offered?

You know, we've still got triple-levered ETFs and inverse double-levered ETFs and all this. Do you think that what happened here is potentially going to have a serious legal risk for Credit Suisse? And do you think that it's going to change the industry? In terms of other offerings of strategies in ETFs that maybe smarter people would not recommend retail investors engage in?

Jared Dillian: The thing with ETFs is that you have a lot of ETFs which are really meant as institutional products, but they have retail appeal. And XIV is one of them. It's an institutional product. Joe Blow has no business shorting vol systematically, but it has a ticker, it's listed on an exchange, so he can do it. In terms of who lost money on XIV and SVXY, probably equal parts big boys and individual investors. And there's certainly a lot of people didn't know the risk. Once again, the SEC approved these products. They approved leveraged ETFs. I wrote a piece about leveraged ETFs on Bloomberg about a year ago about how the SEC probably regretted that it approved leveraged ETFs. And then they went and approved 4x leveraged ETFs. The SEC has been very permissive about allowing these types of products to exist. Now, if you think about why does an XIV exist to begin with? Well, XIV exists because VXX exists, and VXX was everybody's dream in the mid-2000s.

People wanted to securitize volatility into a product that you could trade that was listed on an exchange. People wanted a way to be long volatility without having to worry about all the other Greeks. So somebody came up with They listed VXX, and everybody knows what happened. It just went down relentlessly for 10 years and continues to go down. But the ETF does exactly what it's supposed to do. It does what it's supposed to do in the prospectus. And XIV was created as a reaction to that. If a long vol strategy goes down all the time because of carry, then a short vol strategy must go up all the time because of carry. Now, somebody who's a seasoned trader will know that short volatility as a strategy can give you 6 to 10 years of gains, and then you'll wipe them all out. One day. That's the nature of the trade. A lot of people didn't understand that. Are people being misled?

Probably not. I think if the SEC approved the products and all the risks were disclosed in the prospectus, everything— XIV and SVXY did exactly what they were supposed to do. They did not malfunction. So actually, I struggled to see the legal basis for a lawsuit.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I guess to my thinking, the legal basis for the lawsuit is there's enough money involved to motivate the lawyers to make up whatever story they need to. There is so much money that got lost in one day. I agree with, you know, half of it was institutional guys, you know, should be responsible, know what they were getting into. There's a whole lot of waitresses and bartenders that somebody told, buy this thing called XIV, it can only go up, it never goes down. And they didn't do any homework, they didn't read any prospectus, they didn't do anything. And I don't think it's a question of, I don't think it's so much a question of the product not performing. I think it's more of an industry direction and policy regulation question of, you know, is it the policy and intention of SEC and other authorities to say, hey, as long as the risks are properly disclosed, if somebody doesn't read it, it's their problem?

Or is it more the industry's posture that products like ETFs that are very popular with retail investors shouldn't be offered if they have risks that are difficult for a lot of retail investors?

Jared Dillian: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: to understand.

And I think that's going to be the legal battle. And I'm sure the battle will occur just because of the amount of money that's involved, regardless of whether there's any merit to an argument or a claim against Credit Suisse. There's enough money involved that somebody's going to bring one, and we'll see what happens in the court. I think we've covered the volatility side of what's happened this week pretty thoroughly.

Equities: February 2007 and 1987 analogies

Erik Townsend: Let's go back to equities now. Certainly, the blowup of the volatility complex contributed to exacerbating and accelerating the downside in equities. And at least as we are speaking on Wednesday afternoon, day before this podcast will be released, the trend appears to be a bounce, at least so far. We're maybe 50% retraced so far in terms of big loss that happened earlier this week. Do you think we're headed to new highs and the market continues on, or do you think that we're going to see a failed rally and eventually newer lows?

Jared Dillian: Where do we go I think it's possible that we get new highs. It wouldn't really make me happy, but I think it's possible. I think that there's a parallel here to a specific day in history that I remember quite well. It was February 27th, 2007. And if you recall, the stock market peaked in July of 2007, but there was a day of very serious losses, a one-day event in February. Right. February. And interestingly enough, both February 27th, 2007 and Monday were the highest vol-of-vol days in the history. So in 2007, on that day, the VIX went from 10 to 18 in one day, a very similar vol-of-vol type of move. And the catalyst for that particular move was China raising reserve requirements. And the ABX, which had been listed a couple months earlier, had gone down about 10 points. If you remember, the ABX was the index of sub- prime mortgages.

And I think there's a possibility that this little vol blowup, which caused the VIX to gap from 10 to 50 in a couple of days, it might not be the actual top of the stock market, but it could be the beginning of the end.

It could be a precursor to the top, and the top might be a couple of months from now. That's a possibility.

Erik Townsend: Or the other possibility is, is that, you know, we've seen the highs and the bear market has begun, which is also Now, one thing that occurs to me just as you were speaking there, if I go back to '87, you know, a lot of people remember what I think the date was, October 19th of '87, when the 23% or whatever it was in one day event happened. But really, that experience started with volatility spikes and crazy things starting to happen about a month earlier. So is there analogy here to, to maybe this is the tremor that comes before the big quake? I think so. And the October '87 event is still a month ahead of us?

Jared Dillian: I think that is the analogy for the reasons I described earlier, that I think that this is the beginning of volatility and we're going to get more volatility. And back when I was thinking about the short vol trade, like you guys were, I thought to myself, where would the S&P be in the event that the vol market broke. And I thought it would be similar to 1987. I thought it would be a 20% move. Now, the vol market didn't break. It actually functioned properly. It was just a giant dislocation. But I still think that the volatility is really ahead of us.

Treasury yields, supply and the limits of rate rises

Erik Townsend: We've talked about volatility, and we've talked about equities and what's happened here. But as you said earlier, what brought this all on was really a backing up in interest rates. So, you know, we've had Jeff Gundlach and several other notable people kind of make a declaration saying, okay guys, this is it. 35-year bond bull market is over. We're headed towards much higher Treasury rates.

And I guess the thing that I would have asked before this week is I would have said, wait a minute, I don't see how that's possible because I think, first of all, you run the risk of crashing the equity market. And second of all, at some point, if you try to get back to historically normal rates, the US government can't possibly— we used to have 7%, 8% Treasury rates, but we didn't have a $20 trillion national debt at that time. There's no way the US government can service its debt at what we think of as historically normal interest rates. So I kind of think in terms of how much farther can this increase in rates go before it causes big problems? And it seems like this week may have been the first of those problems. Would you agree with that? And how far can it go?

What's driving it? And do you think it's going to continue?

Jared Dillian: I think a lot of people sort of lose track of the fact that the bond market is dictated by supply and demand like any other market. It just doesn't seem like that all the time. Right now, we have the prospect of a lot of supply. I mean, the bond market honestly is a mess. It's an absolute mess right now as we speak, considering that we dropped on an intraday basis in the stock market 6%, and the bond market can't get out of its own way is not really a good sign. Having said that, I think the time to get bearish on the bond market was when 10s were at 1.6%, not when they're at 2.6%. That's a pretty big move.

And I think that there's a limit as to how high yields can go if you think that a recession is coming sooner rather than later. Having said all that, you know, you could make the argument that just on a valuation basis that the bond market and the stock market have been overvalued simultaneously and that both of them could decline at the same time. And that's exactly what's happening.

Erik Townsend: Let's assume that that is what's happening. I think there's a very strong probability that it is. A lot of really smart people have opined in the last several You know, people are worried about stock market crashes, but boy, if you see a popping of a bubble in the bond market, that's where you really talk about major, major consequences in terms of the global economy. Are we potentially at the beginning of something that could escalate into a bond market crisis, or is this just kind of a warning sign that maybe the market's going to correct? And what would you expect? I mean, obviously, we We could, you know, resort to more quantitative easing and buy up this excess supply of bonds in order to contain rates. That has not been the policy direction that's been announced, and everybody would like us to believe we're moving away from those kind of policies.

Do you think at some point policymakers would be forced to make a U-turn and go back to accommodative monetary policy in order to prevent rates from running away?

Jared Dillian: I think that we can sustain a lot I think you have to see a lot more pain in the bond market before people start thinking of that kind of stuff. I mean, even— so today, 10s are at 2.70%, 2.80%. 30-year fixed mortgages are around 4.25%, 4.5%. I mean, still really, really low. Nobody's experiencing any pain because mortgages went from 3.5% to 4.5%. I mean, you really have to get mortgage rates up to 6% before that starts making a difference.

Erik Townsend: Same thing.

Jared Dillian: Same thing with Treasury debt. I think that the interest expense has to go up by a couple hundred billion dollars in order for people to start thinking about what can we do to get interest rates lower. And keep in mind that the Treasury under Obama actually did a pretty good job of extending the duration of its maturities.

So I think we used to be at about a 3, 3.5-year duration in the bond market, and now I think we're at about 6 or 7. So, you know, and Mnuchin, when he was first named Treasury Secretary, wanted to issue 50s and 100s to extend the duration even more. So I think we— I think the Treasury has actually done a pretty good job of setting us up, uh, so we're not entirely dependent on short-term funding.

The dollar puzzle, euro and France

Erik Townsend: Jared, let's move on to the US dollar. Uh, something that's perplexed me for the last several weeks is, hey, in many ways it looked like the dollar is headed lower, but at the same time, Treasuries are headed higher. That's not the usual relationship. What's going on here and where do you see the dollar headed from here?

Jared Dillian: I actually teach at a university. I teach finance. And whenever I talked about FX, we would spend, we would do a whole chapter on FX. And I would, the first thing I would say is 80% of currency movements are explained by interest rates. And look, I'm a pretty good FX trader and I made a living literally for the last 8 to 10 years of following central bank policy, predicting changes in direction, and trading FX off of it. And for the last 6 to 12 months, really the last 6 months, interest rates have had nothing to do with it. And you have the weakness in the dollar has been persistent and totally unexplained. And I don't have an answer to your question. I can't say, well, it's because of Trump.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Jared Dillian: Or it's because of trade, or it's because of— who knows? But it's been really hard to trade FX in this environment, especially if you look at the euro. I started getting bullish on the euro a while back because I thought that they would taper asset purchases, and I thought that they would eventually raise interest rates.

I thought it would take them a while. Here we are about a year, year and a half later, and they haven't done anything. And, you know, we're pricing in still, even with the downturn in the markets, we're still pricing in 3 hikes this year. The dollar should be a lot stronger, and I just don't have an answer. It's really perplexing to me.

Erik Townsend: I want to follow on on that and just see if you are as perplexed as I am by the relationship also to gold here, because the way I look at this, everything you just said, spot on. I I couldn't agree more. And the one exception I might say is, hey, if you wanted an explanation for how could the dollar be going down in the face of these rates, the answer would be, well, this is the kind of thing that you see not in developed markets, but in emerging markets. And what it means is that we're starting to see a loss of faith globally in the United States and in the US dollar as the hegemonic currency that drives the world. And, you know, the Shanghai Futures Exchange yuan-denominated oil contract is evidence of this, and what it means is the dollar is falling from prominence and therefore is headed down even though rates are headed higher. Now, I didn't think something like that was going to happen for several more years, but I do think it's plausible.

The thing is, if that was it, I would think gold would be just to the moon, and, you know, we're seeing gold roll over here. Am I right to think that the action in gold kind of rules out that explanation, or am I

Jared Dillian: I think gold has kind of done okay. I think what you might be missing is, believe it or not, I'm a France bull. I might be the only France bull in the world. And I was very vocal about the French elections, first at the possibility that François Fillon might win. I was excited about him, and I was also excited about Macron. And Macron has turned out to be a free market reformer. He is reforming a lot of the French economy.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Jared Dillian: economic system. And he, by getting elected, has made Europe stronger. So I think relative to Europe, you know, I mean, gold maybe necessarily isn't going up because there's actually a currency that's a counterbalance to the US. And even though the ECB isn't doing anything, I would offer that as an explanation as to why that exchange rate is where it is.

Canada: housing bubble and the Bank of Canada; Dillian's newsletters

Erik Townsend: Jared, let's move on to another subject you've written quite about, which Canada. Canadian equity market, Canadian housing, these are fascinating topics. We've heard a few different opinions on the program. What's going on with the Canadian economy, and how do you interpret the actions that you've seen both in equities and housing in Canada?

Jared Dillian: Well, most people have some understanding that Canada has a housing bubble. There's just no two ways about it. They have a housing bubble. The levels of personal debt in Canada are the highest in the world. The average home price is $500,000 in Canada. That's the average. And the central bank, Poloz, is sort of in a position where he's stuck. The economy has been strong. They've been printing 4% GDP. But it's very hard for him to raise interest rates because most people in Canada have an adjustable-rate mortgage.

And those adjustable-rate mortgages are indexed to 5-year notes. in Canada, and yields on 5s have gone from 80 basis points to over 2%. So there's been a huge tightening in Canada. The BOC has hiked rates 3 times since the summer.

And I think they're stuck. Poloz said that they're probably not going to hike anymore. They've been following the US. They've hiked 3 times. We've hiked 3 times. And honestly, I think they're done. I think that the The housing market is pretty close to the downturn that everybody's been waiting for the last couple years. Home sales just came out in Toronto. They were down 22% year over year. So you're starting to see some of that crappy data.

Erik Townsend: And do you think that there is a potential that the money coming in from outside the country— I wonder, you know, on the one hand, they've gone out of their way to intentionally impose these taxes on foreign transactions. But if the market starts to crash and they need to rescue it, I wonder if somebody will say, hey, that was a mistake, we need to de-restrict these. And if that were to happen, do you think there's a chance that that saves the market, or is it just too big that once, once the avalanche starts, nothing can stop it?

Jared Dillian: Well, I think most of that foreign money was coming from China. And, you know, since those foreign buyers taxes were imposed in Vancouver and Toronto, China has been pretty successful at imposing capital controls. So a lot less of that money is finding its way to Canada. So I think even if they were to reverse those foreign buyers taxes, it's a little bit too late. You're just not gonna see that flood of money coming from China anymore.

Erik Townsend: Well, Jared, I want to thank you for a fantastic interview. Before we go though, please tell our listeners about the Daily Dirt Nap and what you do there.

Jared Dillian: Sure. Well, first of all, if I write a lot of free stuff for Mauldin Economics, if you want to read me for free and test it out, go to mauldineconomics.com and check out The Tenth Man. But my paid newsletter service is called The Daily Dirt Nap, and you can go to www.dailydirtnap.com.

Erik Townsend: Jared, thank you so much for an excellent interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back, and be sure to stay tuned, folks, because Devin Anderson will be joining us in the postgame segment where we're going to come back and talk a little bit more about the Blowup that occurred in the volatility complex this week.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: Chris Cole on the short-vol unwind

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Jared Dillian. I wanna move on though to our postgame guests. We brought back Chris Cole to join us to give us an update on what was going on. Obviously, now Chris, the timing of having you on the show was just perfect. We came on and you talked about all of the risks associated with these short vol trades. And just 2 weeks later, we're seeing it all unraveling. We wanted to bring you back to get a postmortem as to how this all played out. First of all, welcome back on the show.

Chris Cole: Thank you. Yeah, thank you very much.

Patrick Ceresna: No problem. Just wanted to get your idea on how did this all play out from your perspective?

Chris Cole: In my letter in October, and actually, if you go even further back, actually, if you go back to some of the comments I said to Izzy Kaminska back in 2014 and then my letter in 2015, I talked about the unraveling of the explicit short vol trade particularly the VIX And to recap, even just a week ago on the show, I called these a class-action lawsuit waiting to happen. It was not if, but when. And I think the only thing that surprised me about their true unraveling was how fast it really was.

That's the only thing that really shocked me, just in a blink of an eye, how it was over. That after-hours session on Monday, where you just saw liquidity vanish in the VIX futures space, it's exactly what occurred, or what was prophesied and talked about in the letter in October, but it was just amazing to watch and surreal to watch.

Everyone talks congratulations about calling this. Well, I don't think what I've really talked about has come to pass yet. The VIX ETPs are the smallest portion of the global short vol trade. Talk about this idea of about $1.5 to $2 trillion worth of short vol exposure, both explicit and implicit.

Explicit short volatility are VIX exchange-traded products and vol overwriting funds. The VIX ETPs They're only $5 billion, right? You have $1.5 trillion of implicit short volatility strategies, strategies that may not be directly shorting options, but have the— use financial engineering to mimic the components of a short option portfolio. There's about $1.5 trillion worth of these, of exposure.

This is what we're seeing come online now. This is the real risk. So stocks and bonds sell off together. You have disorderly unwind, withdrawal of liquidity, and then all of a sudden volatility, increasing volatility results in a quick deleveraging of these implicit short volatility strategies.

This will drive the next leg of the crisis. I think people say, congratulations, you called the short vol trade. No, nothing has happened yet. This is an appetizer. This is just the appetizer for the unwind that is about to come. And I think this is what people should be really afraid of, and I think this is the next leg of this that we will see. Whether this happens in 2 weeks or whether this happens over 2 years, I don't know, but I strongly believe this will come to pass, and it will be quite disorderly and ugly.

Implicit short vol, risk parity and the doom spiral

Erik Townsend: I want to refer our listeners to the presentation that you did for us 2 weeks ago. You can still, if you're a registered user at MacroVoices.com, log into the website, go to the research library area of the website, Under guest downloads, you can find Chris's PowerPoint presentation. And there is one slide in particular, it's a pyramid that shows that what blew up this week, which is the explicit short vol trades through things like the XIV ETF, is like this tiny little top of the pyramid triangle. And there's a mountain of implicit short vol below that. And the thing that really hit me as I was thinking about this this week, Chris, is the next thing down is, I remember, Remember it in that pyramid, was the risk parity, which is just such a popular strategy.

I don't know how many gazillion dollars are in risk parity strategies. If we suddenly have the stock market selling off because of higher bond yields, that means stock market and bond market selling off at the same time, which the risk parity crowd thought would never happen. We're seeing that correlation between stocks and bonds change. And at the same time, it's Unwinding that next level in your pyramid, it sounds to me like that sets up a really, really ugly feedback loop. Am I correct to interpret it that way? And I guess particularly, what would be the signposts that we should be looking for to tell us when— we knew what to look for in this VIX trade. It was the VIX shooting up and the ETFs blowing up, or I should say the ETNs blowing up the way they did. What do we want to be looking for?

Is it just risk parity panic and everybody bailing out of that strategy?

Chris Cole: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Are there other things we should be watching for? And what comes next after that?

Chris Cole: You know, as I talk about in Volatility and the Alchemy of Risk, this is a snake eating itself. The snake has been eating its own tail. Lower volatility begets lower volatility. But the reverse can happen, where higher volatility begets higher volatility in a doom spiral. So what we saw happen with VIX futures is really about to happen with the entire equity market. Because it's not just risk parity, but you have risk parity, which is a short gamma, short correlation, short interest rate, strategy. You have vol control funds, which are a short volatility, short gamma strategy. You have risk premia strategies. This is $1.5 trillion worth of implicit short vol exposure that unwinds and uses volatility and stability as an input to unwind their portfolios.

And this unwind occurs nonlinearly. So now that volatility increases, I think the warning posts really are some of the signs we're even starting to see as a quick withdrawal in liquidity, simultaneous declines in stocks and bonds, wild gyrations in cross-asset and correlation breakdowns, and then finally deteriorating credit conditions. And this is where we enter into this reflexive spiral where now higher volatility begets higher volatility in a doom loop.

It's really driven weirdly and ironically, it's driven by the thing the Fed has been trying to create the last number of years, which is inflation. You know, you start to have some element of potential reflation and the withdrawal of stimulus because of that anticipated inflation. And this, this is what leads to this spiral of higher vol.

And back in '87, portfolio insurance was 2% of the market. Today, these strategies potentially are upwards of 10%. So what we saw with VIX futures is just the appetizer to a much more dangerous, The timing, you know, it's impossible to call that, but I think we'll see it either in 2 weeks or within 2 years.

Artemis soft close

Erik Townsend: Chris, unfortunately, we need to leave it there in the interest of time because we've still got to get Devin Anderson on the program to follow up on his comments from several weeks back. Before we go, you know, I think some people were confused when we had you on 2 weeks ago. You mentioned what you and I know is a very common lingo in the hedge fund business, which is you're You're getting ready to soft close your fund, meaning it has seen so much interest that you can only accept so much assets under management before you become capacity limited. And you are close to the point where you're obviously going to continue operating your hedge fund because you have a fantastic strategy, which needless to say has profited extremely well from your anticipating this event. For the accredited investors who are able to invest in hedge funds, they're going to need to move quickly because you're almost at your AUM target and about to close You said

you're going to close the fund to new investors. How do the accredited investors contact you if they want to find out more about your offerings?

Chris Cole: Yeah, thank you for clarifying that. Absolutely correct. What I meant to say is we're soft closing. We have an AUM limitation, and we're going to abide by that. We conservatively anticipate that that will be hit by the end of this quarter. But for those who are still interested, we do have— accredited investors can just contact us at info@artemiscm.com through our website. And those who are accredited, the fund is still open, is still running, and we're not shutting it.

to new investors by the end of the first quarter, we anticipate.

Erik Townsend: And for anyone who is not familiar with this, I'll just add that this is a very, very common phenomenon in the hedge fund industry. The very best funds tend to be capacity-limited and get closed. So if you are interested in this strategy, move quickly, because needless to say, recent events are going to create a spike in interest in this strategy. Chris, I really want to get you back on the program. I think we need to do a much more in-depth follow-up in a full-length interview. But let's give the market a little bit of time to play out and see where this thing goes. We'll get you back on the program at some point to do a follow-up and talk about the bigger picture of how the rest of this unwind is going to look for the implicit short vol aspects of that big pyramid of risk that you showed us 2 weeks ago.

Chris Cole: It's been a pleasure to be here, and say hi to Devin for me. He's a really smart guy.

Postgame: Devin Anderson on Monday's ETP unwind

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Chris, thank you so much for joining us. So now moving on to the second guest we have for our postgame is Devin Anderson, the managing director of a derivatives desk at a bulge Thank you for joining us, Devin.

Devin Anderson: Thank you for having me.

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Devin, you were on our show back on November 30th, and we were talking about, uh, the very circumstances of what would happen if this vol trade was to blow up and what kind of circumstance would have to lead to it. And you were suggesting that we'd have to have a 1-day move of even north of 7%, but really it played out a little bit differently. Why don't you give us a quick postmortem of how Monday played out and what are your thoughts on how everything, uh, ended up? ended up transpiring?

Devin Anderson: Yeah, so the ETPs, XIV and SVXY, are effectively gone at this point. They massively de-risked on Monday as the consequence of the rebalance. But the market started selling off on Friday after average hourly earnings kicked off some fear of higher rates and higher inflation expectations, and that carried through to Monday. Then Monday afternoon, spot and the S&P really started selling off. And accelerating. And vols were up. The weighted average VIX future that underlies those ETPs was up 5 to 6 points through almost into the close, then began to accelerate with spot off 3-ish percent. Spot began to accelerate. Kind of at the heights, aftermarket, which is where about half of the move occurred, the spot was off 5, 6 points. 96%, and the ETPs closed within 4% of their original AUM. So let me explain what that means. On Friday, the underlying VIX futures level, so you can think of it as the underlying for the ETPs, closed at 15.20.

On Monday, it went from 15.20 to 29.80. So the ETPs lost 96% of their value.

Chris Cole: Wow.

Devin Anderson: These things are designed to be the inverse performance of the VXX, which is long volatility. VXX went up 96%. These things went down 96%. And about half of that move occurred between 4:05 and 4:15 So that was against, you know, that whole situation and the acceleration of the bid for vol occurred a little faster than I thought it would. I really thought, based on the historical beta of S&P spot to the VIX, of the VIX futures, that it would have taken a bigger spot move. But I think one of the things that has changed is that there's been so much education and so much attention to this story over time that people were pretty prepared to try and trade in front of this. That's what accounts for the fact that essentially half of the move of the VIX futures that day occurred between 4:05 and 4:15, ahead of these things closing.

Chris Cole: Right. That 4:15.

Devin Anderson: Ahead of the 4:15 level because folks just knew that there was going to have to be a big covering of the short from the levered ETP complex. So, it was a smaller move than I thought, but I also want to point out that we've been telling clients, I mean, you talk about catching a javelin.

The difference between them closing with 4% of their equity left and none is the difference between $29.80 in the closing futures level and 30.6. They were almost there, almost negative equity. The last time I was on the show, we spent a bunch of time talking about, well, what would happen if either the XIV, the note, or SVXY, the ETF, finished in a situation where there was negative equity?

That almost happened on a 5-ish percent after-hours toll.

Chris Cole: Yeah.

Devin Anderson: Total move, and vol almost doubled, and then it kind of reverted, reverted small. Since then, though, the action has been pretty interesting. So there's been a sustained bid to the February VIX future, kind of well in excess of what we would expect for this absolute level of implied. And while spot in the S&P reverted, gave back about half of its move, you know, today's Thursday the 8th. In the afternoon, this sell-off in spot Yeah.

And now, like, our 5-day total return in the S&P is down about 8%.

So now we're really at this junction where I think we have to be careful about the other short vol strategies that we talked about beginning to come into play along with the vol control, but less so risk parity. We can talk about that. You know, there is a point where these things begin to feed on one another, and, you know, I'm a I'm a little afraid we're starting to get there, and I would not have said that even a day ago. This additional 3-ish percent sell-off in spot today is starting, along with the sustained bid for the February VIX future, is beginning to convince me that there's more risk out here as soon as the next few days than I might have initially anticipated.

At the end of Tuesday, we thought that this blowup in the VIX futures was going to be isolated pretty specifically just to equities. And we were getting a lot of client questions that they didn't even understand what was going on because in their asset class or their region of the world, it didn't look like that big of a deal. It was just a very US equity-centric story. But now with spot down 8% or so, I'm beginning to get a little bit more worried.

Algos or VaR: what drove the equity sell-off?

Erik Townsend: Devin, one of the narratives that's been floating around this week is people are saying, you know, it's not the case that the equity market blew up and that blew up the vol What they're saying, and I don't know what they're basing this on, I'm hoping you can debunk it or tell me if it's true, is that really what happened is a fairly modest move in equities, in the equity spot price, led to that panic point in the VIX because so many people have been talking about this short vol trade, the explicit short vol trade through the ETPs like XIV and XIVE.

Devin Anderson: Right.

Erik Townsend: SVXY.

That led to the blowup in futures, and it was actually the VIX futures that were essentially being short-squeezed by people panicking out of these ETPs that caused the algos to react and start selling equities aggressively, and that's where the sell-off came from. Is there any truth to that story, or is that just urban legend that we're hearing?

Devin Anderson: I don't think there's an algo interaction. All of these things are related to one another, but it's not because I don't think it's because of algos. I think it's because of human behavior. Let me talk about why I think that's true.

So, the ETP universe blows up. And by the way, I should mention, if we were to envision all of the possible ways that the VIX ETPs could have de-risked, this is about the most benign one.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Devin Anderson: This is, to make an interest rate analogy, I mean, this is about the softest landing possible. There was a steady bid for the futures all day. They accelerated after market, which I think is a time when a lot of people aren't paying attention. They knocked out without developing a negative equity, and then over the next 2 days and up until this afternoon when the spot sell-off began to reignite, things were beginning to look like they would normalize.

The question is, why has there been this weird bid for front-month volatility, and why did we have another 3-ish percent sell-off today, I don't think that that's because of algos.

I think it's because there are plenty of clients and there are plenty of professional asset managers out there that use value-at-risk-based metrics to measure their risk. And a lot of those value-at-risk-based metrics take in inputs of implied volatility or realized volatility to develop essentially their distribution of outcomes. So the way VaR works is it says, I'm going to take all the positions my portfolio, and then I'm going to develop a distribution to say, well, probability adjusted, what could happen to that particular portfolio? Well, the width of that distribution is, of course, volatility. And if what you use as an input, if what you use to inform the width of that distribution is implied or realized volatility, well, we're in kind of a unique situation whereby the thing that blew up on Monday were products directly tied to your measurement, right?

So I think if you're trailing along at, at a 12 to 14 realized vol, you throw a 2.6% move close to close— the move in the S&P, I want to say, was, uh, a little more than 4%. Yeah, 4.1%. Now all of a sudden, 10-day realized vol is 28, right? And 30-day realized vol is 18. So on a percentage basis, that's a really big change. And the implied vols, because that's actually— that's specifically where the squeeze was from the VIX ETPs, were up 100% on Monday.

And that's since reverted a little bit. But my point is, any kind of metric you could have pulled about an expectation of market volatility, whether it's realized or implied, and turned around and stuck in your value-at-risk model, On Tuesday, you came in and all of a sudden you had way more implied market risk than you did the day before, even if you didn't do a single trade on Monday.

So people then react to that and have to de-risk. I think that's why there's been— that's at least partially why there's been a sustained bid for the February VIX future relative to the March. There's why there's been a sustained bid for the weekly S&P options and the March S&P options. Options and why we've seen a little bit of this dislocation, because one, people are going to have to de-risk a little bit in response to their increased VaR metrics, and two, there's going to be less supply of options coming into the market, because if you're being told to de-risk, you're certainly not selling anything, and there's less sellers of vol around.

Now, I don't want my comments to be extrapolated into I think that there's a giant VaR shock coming. I throw that phrase around and it tends to incite riots. I don't mean that at all, but I do think that there has been an increase to most folks' VaR metrics, and that's what's now showing up both in the supply of volatility to the market and this, what I think is rebalance flow from investors happening at the end of the day.

Feedback loops: vol control and risk parity

Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit about where markets are likely to go from here, because it seems to me that if I ask myself, why is it that we have had this just steady, very, very solid equity bull market here. Well, with just incredibly generationally low vol, that means that tail hedges are super cheap. So the argument to lever up your long equity strategy, protect yourself with puts, those puts were just pennies on what you're used to paying for them. Why not? Well, the answer to why not now is because It ain't cheap anymore. So does that kind of put a lid on the structural ability of this market? The really big question is, are we seeing the beginning of that big event that really creates a secular change in direction for equity markets? Or is this a blip we need to get through before we end up eventually getting through it and powering on to even new all-time highs in the stock market?

Devin Anderson: Right. So I think there's good paths from here and there's bad paths from here. And it all depends on speed. So I'm very sympathetic to the observation that a critical driver of both the bid to equities and the very low realized vol has been the process of asset substitution generated from low rates. So this is something I talked about last time. People go up the securities market line and take more risk when vol is low because They need the returns.

So, to some extent, this vol regime is going to end by the reversal of that process, and it's very much a question of how quickly that process runs in reverse, just as it ran forward for the last few years. I think that, you know, starting from here, there's, there's good ways that it goes and there's bad ways that it goes. And all the good ways involves that process running slowly in reverse, and the bad ways that it goes Revolve around that process running quickly in reverse.

So the bad ones are a little bit more exciting, so let's start there. Like we talked about last time, the VIX ETPs are really only one way that people sell vol. There are other ways. There is a big, very big community of people that sell outright puts and condors. That stuff sold out of private banks, kind of into the IRA community and to clients of that private bank, either from the strategy manager in the bank or from an overlay provider that's external that markets directly to retail. Those guys are pretty big, and they sell out-of-the-money options, and they have an exposure directly to the total return of the market kind of in short periods because they sell mostly 6 to 8 week options. I would say that, that, you know, somewhere around 10% in like 3 weeks is a down 10% move in 3 weeks is where that stuff is probably going to start to get sensitive. That's just my guess based on the types of strategies that we know that they employ.

Then there's a whole group of institutional asset managers that are selling options via variance swaps and delta straddles and what I would say more sophisticated strategies that require more maintenance.

All of this stuff together can form a feedback loop with other short gamma strategies. I know you had Chris Cole on. Chris and I have spent a lot of time talking, so I'm sure Sure, he talked about the embedded short gamma and other strategies like vol control and risk parity.

So let me talk about those quickly, and then I'll try to tie it all together. Vol control is an interesting phenomenon whereby mostly insurance companies ask asset managers to give them the return of an asset, but with a mandated target vol. So the insurance company goes to the asset manager and they say, okay, well, I want you to give me the S&P, but I want the S&P on a Target vol of 10. So that means if they asked for $10 million worth of exposure and trailing realized vol was 10, the asset manager would have $10 million of exposure.

If trailing realized vol was 15, they would delever by 50%, right? Just the ratio of those 2 things. If trailing realized vol was 5, they would lever up. They would lever up to $15 million—

Chris Cole: Or relative—

Devin Anderson: Excuse me, to $20 million or some cash. If there was a cap involved. Sometimes these things are capped. But the point is, the exposure of that mandate goes up and down with respect to the level of trailing realized vol. So as realized vol goes up, they have futures to sell because they have to make their mandate smaller because their bogey is to hit this target that they've been given. And if the market is more volatile, they just have to own less of it. That's how target vol mandates work. So that's a mandated trading that occurs in response to the price action of the market.

And that is exactly what a short gamma gamma profile is, but it's not coming explicitly from an option.

That's a lot different than the risk parity world. Risk parity is a portfolio construction method that says, I'm going to take a bunch of assets and scale them to a similar vol, and then I'm going to weight according to what I think my fundamental and technical views are. That community is extremely slow-acting. So, it's not like the market sold off just about 3% today. It's not like those managers are recalculating their Sharpe ratios and correlation matrices, resolving for their portfolio to trade tomorrow. And it just doesn't work like that. These folks rebalance on 2-week to 8-week type time horizon, and their reaction function would have them trading in a 2- to 8-week type window. Where I differ a lot from the rest of the community is that on a big enough move, the risk control world absolutely is going to have some There's a lot of stuff to sell, but the risk parity world, barring a catastrophe where the market sells off 20% in a day, I actually don't think is that meaningful of an exposure.

And actually, kind of on that comment, Cliff Asness from AQR put out a note, a public note last night, that he titled, kind of rather humorously, Risk Parity Derangement Syndrome. So, I don't share people's concerns about risk parity.

I do share the concerns about vol control. And the way that stuff can all begin to act together is you get a market where things are down around 10% inside of 2 weeks to 3 weeks, and it looks like it's accelerating. And then the fundamental guys come in and start selling just simply because they have to de-risk because the market's down. You get the quant factors start to look a little poor, like low beta is selling off and value is selling off. And then you add on top of that, the vol control guys show up with With another— and I want to say, for every 3% move, another $9 billion or so for sale. And all this stuff can start to run in a loop, right?

And as of the close today, we're down about 8% in 5 days. So, we're starting to creep towards the point where I would start to get worried, where these feedback loops could actually develop and interact with one another. But it's all about acceleration. If we accelerate from here, I think it could get fairly ugly. If we come in tomorrow and things are up 2%, and then Time passes, which is the critical part, because as time passes, these things restrike, and the risk becomes diffuse over new and different strikes. So, it's all about speed, all right? An accelerated move down here, and I'm really worried. Up until this afternoon, I actually thought we were on the good path, where things looked like they were starting to normalize, except for the front end of the vol curve. But it actually looks a little bit more like— Spot and the rest of the market, and to some extent yields are coming around to the elevated vols rather than the elevated vols coming around to a retracement, the retracement that we had previously seen in spot.

A new volatility regime and less short-vol supply

Erik Townsend: So, to summarize, if I'm reading your view correctly, what you're really telling us is there's still, just barely, room for this to all blow over. We could see a resolution where, hey, you know, the blowup of the explicit short vol complex caused a great big temporary panic, but we got through it and we're recovering. But we need to see that recovery. If we don't see that recovery and the weather does not clear from here, then we could be looking at a perfect storm scenario potentially developing. And the real thing to watch for is acceleration on the downside.

Devin Anderson: I don't think there's any outcome where we go back to a trailing realized vol of 6. I don't think that's happening. I think that the VIX ETP situation has, has caused people to reevaluate their risk profile, either qualitatively because the market sold off and vols went up a lot, or quantitatively because they have a value-at-risk-based risk system that is, that is now signaling their portfolio suddenly became riskier. And the way that that works itself off is time passing, right? So a continued move quickly possibly ignites these things into Right. And that leads to a feedback loop. Time passing lets all these risks diffuse.

From here, at the end of the day on Thursday the 8th, I think it's fairly tough to tell which one is going to happen.

I certainly am not rooting for a meltdown. I can tell you that. But I absolutely think there's a window where either one could happen safely. And it was a positive outcome that the VIX ETPs delevered fully on Monday without negative equity. Right? That's a really welcome development. But I do think that that changed things with respect to the volatility regime. We're not going back to 6. I think we're probably going back to a world where trailing realized vol over most time horizons is something like, you know, 14 or 15, and implied vols are something like 15 to 17. I think that's probably our new normal rather than the ultra-low world that we were in, you know, again, as long as we don't accelerate.

Erik Townsend: Now, it seems to me that in terms of the big picture, the regime that we've The environment that we've had until now is one where shorting vol is a super-duper popular strategy, and that's basically supplying the market with a huge supply of cheap optionality. Does this really mean that we're entering a new regime where, you know, there's a self-reinforcing process here? As you said, we're not going back to trailing 6 implied. It seems to me that there's not going to be a whole lot of people rushing back in to fund the launch of the next ETN that replaces XIV because they can't wait to get back into this just wonderful strategy of shorting vol. So does this mean that systemically we have much less supply of vol than we used to have, and it's going to stay that way for a long time?

Devin Anderson: Well, I think that there is going to be less supply because the ETPs are smaller. Although that said, they have had a few hundred million dollars worth of inflows post-Monday already. I think there's going to be less interest in that and doing it when, when you see something go down 96% in a single day, I think it makes people reevaluate their sizing.

What I would generally say about short vol is that there's nothing wrong with short vol. I think the people that say that you just never should have a short vol strategy are trying to make a safety statement for everyone, but I think the more complete statement is you need to have a properly sized short vol strategy.

The thing about it is that the proper size is never really the size that you want. People want to make a lot of money from them, but in all the cases where you make a lot of money from those short vol strategies those are also the cases where you're probably taking too much tail risk. So I think properly sized allocation to these things is appropriate for many different types of investors. But people get out over their skis on their allocations to this because it starts to feel like easy money. And if it feels like easy money for a long enough time, the allocations get too big.

And that unfortunately has probably happened. So I think these things, like I say, losing 96% of face in one day, it's going to make people reevaluate their sizing. And that's probably, that's probably a healthy thing. But I also think the first-order drivers of vol in financial markets are not these dynamics. These dynamics matter on the margin, of course, but are actually the volatility around our expectations for inflation, specifically inflation. That's what started this whole thing last Friday, and our expectations for volatility around growth and GDP are also going up. And those are really the first principal drivers. Those are the things that really underpin what makes volatility, because those are the things that really change people's view about growth. And people's differing view about growth makes people buy and sell stocks, and vol is price movement.

So the thing that matters the most is that. On the margin, weird things can happen because As a financial product, for sure. But I just think we're entering a new regime where there's going to be, to your point, there is going to be less vol selling. It's not going away. I mean, let's keep in mind that despite the volatility and increase in interest rates, the 10-year is still 2.82, right? That's not a sell stocks and replace it with the 10-year and retire level just yet, right? So there's still going to be interest in carry strategies.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Devin Anderson: The question is, can you design them in such a way that you're taking a little less tail risk? Something we spend a lot of time talking to clients about. But as far as the regime goes, fundamental factors are picking up, less sellers, and that's going to lead to a higher base for realized, which underpins the whole volatility complex.

Rising Treasury yields as a warning signal

Erik Townsend: You've talked about acceleration to the downside being the biggest thing to watch for in terms of a warning signal. Is a continued increase in Treasury rates another warning signal? Just because it seems like that, that intolerance of higher yields is what started this, or do you think that that's not necessarily a risk factor?

Devin Anderson: I think it can be. I think the, the long-term driver that will take us from one regime to another is the process of asset substitution unwinding, right? The people that went up the securities market line and took more risk will come back down as they get the same yield for a lower volatility, or from a lower volatility asset. Again, it's just a question of speed, right? A very quickly increasing interest rate moves people down the curve faster, right? And that takes up liquidity and, and can create shocks. So I think it all depends on the path of how things go up. If this process of substitution runs quickly, we're going to have a more volatile market. If it runs less slowly, we're going to have a slightly more volatile market, but Probably not one at an increasing rate.

Outro and Research Roundup preview

Erik Townsend: Well, Devin, I really appreciate you coming back on the program. Your insights are fantastic with the exposure that you have there running a derivatives desk for one of the major firms on the street. So we really appreciate your input. Folks, we obviously need to wrap it there in the interest of time this week, but we do need your help promoting the show. Where else are you going to hear 3 guests in one week on a week like this than MacroVoices So please tell your friends and colleagues, forward your Research Roundup emails, and most importantly, register your free account at MacroVoices.com, because the more registered users we have, the more able Patrick is to negotiate to get the very best feature interview guests on the program. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email each week, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just a compendium of links to all of the coolest free stuff that we could find on the internet.

Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: You're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Jared, as well as a number of the issues he provided for our listeners to be able to read of the Daily Dirtnap newsletter. You'll also find a link to Erik's appearance on Hedgeye, where him and Keith McCullough discussed Bitcoin as the biggest speculative mania in history. You'll also find a link to an article talking about Gundlach suggesting that the market unwind will be turbulent and not just a few days. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. For those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

Now, if you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also Also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Devin Anderson: Thank you.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com.

Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature. Interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time. In our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.