Steve Keen — Professor Steve Keen from Kingston University (feature); Charlie McElligott, head of cross-asset strategy at Nomura (postgame) (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview: Steve Keen and Charlie McElligott

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 136 was recorded on October 11th, 2018. I'm Erik Townsend. It's been a hell of a week in the market, and we've got a hell of a show lined up for you in response. Professor Steve Keen will join me as this week's first feature interview guest. As regular listeners know, Steve predicted the 2008 financial crisis and has been one of our most popular show guests to date. Steve gave us a fantastic interview, and I'm sure you're really going to to enjoy it. But we had to tape this interview last week due to travel schedules, so unfortunately my discussion with Steve won't take into account Wednesday and Thursday's bloodbath in markets. But don't worry, we know you want an update on the market, so we tapped our friend Charlie McElligott from Nomura for a post-game interview to discuss this week's market carnage and more importantly what comes next. All of that plus a post-game chart book from our own Patrick Ceresna is coming up.

It'll be a long show this week, folks, but it should be a good one.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude, gold, 10-year

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 truly had a liquidity event here. The S&P 500 wiping out pretty much 100 S&P points in 24 hours. We're currently trading around 2,750 at the time of recording. What's your first impression on what just happened?

Erik Townsend: Well, October has arrived, that's for sure. Needless to say, you know, it's been quite interesting. What we've been saying for several weeks is we're in a topping pattern. We don't know exactly when the top is gonna come, but until now, it really had looked like, hey, maybe there was room for one final push higher. You're never really sure what's going to happen. Really, I think even the sell-off that you saw through Monday was still leaving room for the dip buyers to come in. That 2,865 level that we sold off to on Monday was right on a long-term trend line. It was a perfect test, and it really looked like maybe the dip buyers were showing up. At that point, 2,865 became the must-hold number. And Patrick, I am so frustrated with myself because I started to put on a stop order to sell short on another break below 2860, and I didn't get to it till the next morning, and by the time I did, it was already all over.

So I ended up missing a 150-point move on what would have been a fantastic short trade. At this point, I think it's definitely too late to get into the short. There's some kind of bounce coming. The question is going to be bigger picture. Is the high in for the year and for the entire bull market? At this point, I'm leaning much much more toward that case. I'm going to say maybe there's still room considering all of this happened with a major hurricane hitting the US. It kind of puts people in a panicky mindset. If we really started to see aggressive buying start right away, maybe there's still room to get a recovery back to a new all-time high. But I really doubt it at this point. It looks to me like the market broke finally, something we've been expecting and anticipating for many months on this program. We just didn't know when it was going to come.

The question now is what happens next, and I think it's going to be very interesting. Patrick, I've got to hand it to you though, because I know that Big Picture Trading clients rode this thing long right up to— I think you called not only the recent top but the recent 2 tops almost perfectly, using an option strategy that allowed you to capture both the upside and the downside. I want to come back to that in our postgame segment. I know you've got a chart book, and I particularly want to address the option strategy and how that plays into this. Meanwhile, we've also got Charlie McElligott, who of course heads up cross-asset strategy for Nomura. He'll be joining us for extended equity coverage in postgame as well, because needless to say, what's going on right now is really big and we need to focus on what might happen next.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to that US dollar index, because the one instinct that I'd have is that with a market panic like we've seen, I would have thought the US dollar would have actually instinctively been going higher and that we should have been catching a bid. But yet actually the last few days, the dollar's been giving back some of its gains that it had from last week. What's your thinking here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm thinking that what's going on is that we've seen some relief in the selling of Treasuries and that some of the move higher in the dollar was probably about higher Treasury yields. I mean, it's funny, we're now talking about how Treasury yields are down to 3.20% on the 10-year, as if that's a low number, but it's lower than it was. So I think that maybe the reason we're seeing a little bit of weakness is there. I'm not really sure of that, frankly. I agree with you that it would logically make sense in a sense sell-off in the equity market, that you might see more strength in the dollar. We're not seeing it, but at the same time, it's not like the dollar's crashing either. We saw several strong days there. We're seeing a little pullback. I think it's a little bit too early to call it. In any event, the real question, I think, is going to be what happens next.

Are we seeing the beginning of a really major move down in stock prices, and is the driver going to be the stock market? Or I'm actually thinking the more likely case is that the driver is the bond market, and it's going to be higher It's the higher yields, if they occur, that are the shock that results in the next move in the stock market. So, we'll see what happens. But so far, the dollar has been weaker than I expected, but not weak enough to really cause me to panic.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because we're back to the $70 handle in a very deep throwback in crude oil from its highs. First of all, how did the numbers come in? And do you think that this is a major turn in oil?

Erik Townsend: I think that it probably is a major turn, but it depends mostly on whether it's a major turn in other things. There was a perfect storm of factors here. One of them was the storm itself. As Hurricane Michael was approaching the Gulf, you know, you've got all the panic and fear of what could happen that's pushing the price higher. But as it's passed the producing assets and started, you know, even though it was carnage for Florida, didn't take out any oil rigs in the Gulf of Mexico. You know, everything continues. Life is on. The production that was shut down in the Gulf of Mexico will be restarted. So that uncertainty comes out of the market. That allowed the price to come down. That was one factor. Of course, Well, first, the equity market selling off so dramatically starts to signal potential recession coming, fears about the economy. That's helping crude oil prices come down. And then whammo, 6 million barrel build on inventory. And we'd already seen API— everything was delayed by a day this week because of the Columbus Day holiday.

But we had seen API predicting a 9.8 million barrel build on inventory. So it was only 6 million barrels when we got the EIA data on Thursday, but that still Still was more than double analysts' expectations of about a 2.5 million barrel build. So massive build there. Cushing, Oklahoma building 2.4 million barrels. Gasoline building almost a million barrels at 951,000 barrels. Distillates building 2.7 million barrels. So we got really big builds across the board. US production ticking up another 100,000 barrels to 11.2 million barrels. Remember, they only move the number 100,000 barrels at a time, so it's not particularly accurate.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: In general, I think all of these factors come together to say, hey, it really looks like there's a lot of reasons to be bearish in oil. Now, I don't think that necessarily means that we're seeing the beginning of some price crash. It could go that way. It's always possible if this is an actual stock market crash that's beginning that, you know, everything just goes down from here and oil goes with it. I don't think that that's the most likely case. I think we're more likely to get a bounce here in stocks. And if we do, it's going to be very interesting to see whether oil bounces with it or not.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because, wow, what a big breakout day, breaking out of a several-month range. Is this for real?

Erik Townsend: Yeah, you know, something is up here. And the thing I think is most interesting is it's not explained by the weakness in the dollar. Yes, the dollar was weak. That should mean gold is up. But this amount of weakness in the dollar should have put gold up $5, not $30.

So we saw this Very decisive breakout today. The, the gold bugs, I'm sure, would say, hey, it's the safety trade is finally happening. One day doesn't make a trend, so I'm not quite ready to say that, but something is going on here because it's not explained by the move in the dollar index. And also, we saw a break in the correlation with the Chinese yuan, which has been very tightly coordinated with gold. So something's up. It is the beginning of something. I want to ask Charlie McElligott, because he is so good at knowing, you know, that gold is traded by CTAs, among other people. Charlie is extremely good at looking at and analyzing the levels at which the CTAs are going to change their conviction and change their trading positions. And I don't know if it was a move through one of those levels that triggered today, but I want to know from Charlie what the levels are to watch for above the current market that might accelerate this move, because it feels to me like something's up here.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because we obviously had that explosion in yields to 3.25% on the 10-year. And then now that the markets were kind of roiled up, you basically had a throwback to about 3.15%, still above that 3.10% level that we've been talking about for months and months. Obviously, this seems like people are finding a little safe haven in the Treasury bonds, at least temporarily. Do you think this is a key turning point or is this just a pause?

Erik Townsend: I think it's more likely to be a pause, but I think the really interesting question is going to be what I What I believe is going on now is, okay, stock market is selling off dramatically. Everybody knows, and that's the everybody knows in air quotes, the kind of everybody knows that might turn into everybody's wrong.

Everybody knows that when the stock market sells off, that money goes into the bond market, up in price on bonds and down in yields. So yields are coming down on the 10-year because that's what happens when the stock market sells off. Now, I think, Patrick, it makes perfect sense on this first couple of days of selling that since that's That's what everybody expects. There's kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy there. The big question in my mind is, do we have the ingredients— and I think it's very likely that we do— for stocks and bonds both to sell off at the same time together, which would mean stock market accelerating to the downside even as bond yields continue to accelerate to the upside? That's not a prediction yet, but my point is, most everybody assumes, no, it doesn't work that way. They're inversely correlated. They're inversely correlated until they're not, and it's going to be very interesting to see

Patrick Ceresna: Thanks for the market update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Professor Steve Keen. Erik's interview with Professor Keen is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Steve Keen: sovereign vs private debt

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Professor Steve Keen from Kingston University. Steve, it's so good to have you back on the program. It's been way too long. I want to start with a topic that you and I have talked about a lot before, which is the massive overhang of sovereign debt around the world. And the view that I've been coming around more and more to is, you know, I'm convinced that we're headed towards some kind of a financial crisis as a result of all of this excessive Massive debt in the system. The thing is, everybody seems to assume automatically, okay, financial crisis, stock market's gonna crash. And what I'm starting to realize is, boy, you know, I think the driver is going to be bond markets, sovereign bond markets that are, in some cases, negative yielding. I mean, this is crazy. Eventually, it all has to come falling down. And I'm starting to wonder, is it necessarily the case that that means there's a stock market crash?

Or could it be that if the bond market is distressed and Treasuries are no longer a safety trade, That the stock market is actually supported by that, or maybe if it's not supported, doesn't get taken down as much. So the next financial crisis, which of course is the topic of a book that you wrote recently and has been extremely popular, we know there's a financial crisis coming. Is it mostly about the bond market or is it mostly about the stock market? What's the driver and how's it going to play out?

Steve Keen: We're going to have a good old argument here, mate, because I'm actually of the opinion that it's— except in the case of the Eurozone, It's not sovereign debt that matters. It's private debt. And there will be issues of private debt with countries running trade deficits. And so that includes potentially a country like Australia, for example, but it doesn't include countries like China or let's say South Korea that have substantial foreign trade excess trade surpluses and so aren't beholden to whether they can finance their debt in their own currency or not. So let's say— let's go back to basics. Where do we start on that one? Because I, I do see a rise in bond prices, in bond rates, and therefore a fall in bond prices because there is a sense of normalization going on right now with global interest rates. A false sense, but I think it'll last for about between 1 and 3 years. And as that does happen, of course, you know, with interest rates going up, bond prices go down.

But I think the governments that have issued bonds in their own currency still have the backstop of their central banks. And this is the thing that people who are expecting a bond market apocalypse aren't taking into account properly.

Erik Townsend: So you think that the bond market crisis, if it's a bond market crisis, is driven by corporates? Does that mean that sovereigns are still a safety trade and they're supported to some extent, and what we're looking at is really a change in spreads between corporates and sovereigns, or does everything fall together?

Steve Keen: No, I think a change in spreads is more likely. You've probably heard of modern monetary theory. Have you heard of that new non-orthodox approach to economics?

Erik Townsend: I have, but for any of our listeners who haven't, why don't you give us a quick overview?

Steve Keen: Okay. Well, I'm generally inconsistent with it, but I've criticized parts of its arguments on international trade, which I think are frankly bonkers. So I'm not an MMT fanboy, in case anybody's worried about that. In fact, I get criticized by a lot of MMT fanboys. So let's just go back to see what I see them saying, which is completely correct in an accounting sense. That first of all, if you think about the financial world, you have to divide to understand your own financial position, regardless of how many physical things you own. When you look at the financial value of what you've got, you work out your net equity by subtracting your liabilities from your assets. And the classic law of accounting that assets minus liabilities equals equity. And that's— we all, of course, strive to have positive equity.

Now, what we don't do, and this is, I think, I'm obviously the leading person on the planet about doing it, is seeing what does that mean at the macroeconomic level? Because individually, everybody has assets minus liabilities equal equity, and we all are striving to get positive equity.

Now, you look at the global economy, forget about national borders now, and imagine we've got an overall global economy. Then for every asset, there's a liability. What is an asset for one person is a liability for another. That therefore means that if there's one person whose assets minus liabilities gives them positive equity, and you take that person out of the equation and say, what's the rest of the world look like? The rest of the world has to have negative equity precisely equal to that person's positive equity. And that applies no matter who you're talking about, whether you're talking about a person or a sector or a country.

If assets minus liabilities leads to positive equity for sector X, Then sector everything except sector X has got negative equity. That's just a simple mathematical rule. In that sense, there's a conservation law applying. And what I'm doing is looking at the implications of that.

Now, modern monetary theory has done the same thing and have argued that if you look at a national economy, then because one person's asset is another liability, a person's liability, one sector's assets, another sector's liability, if the government is trying to achieve positive equity, So it's trying to make sure that what it gets in taxes is greater than what it pays out in services.

Its change in equity is going to be the opposite of the change in equity of the people it's taxing. So if the government pushes itself more towards its flow of expenditure such that its taxes are greater than its spending, it means it's reduced the equity of the rest of the economy by that much. So the government is tempted to say, if you get back to a budget balance, for example, or even running a budget surplus, means by definition the rest of the world with which it's interacting goes negative equity.

And they therefore say, that's not a good idea.

Because in fact, if the government runs a negative equity— or if you and I run negative equity, we get caught in that situation, then several possibilities exist. One is if we're a bank, we're bankrupt, period. Banks have to have positive equity. Secondly, if we're a company, we can handle having aggregate negative equity so long as we're getting enough turnover to service our debts as and when they fall due out of the profit we're making.

will often end up selling assets in that situation or trying to speculate on assets to get ahead. So when you look at the aggregate level, you can't say we should all strive to get positive equity. But that's like saying, you know, we should all strive to be on the upside of a seesaw. I'm sorry, there is no such possibility. If one side's up, the other side's down. So the question is, who can sustain negative equity? Can banks? Definition by definition, no. If they're negative equity, they go bankrupt. Can firms? Yes, if they've got enough cash flow coming in. But of course, if cash flow diminishes, they can go bankrupt as well. Households will feel distressed in the case of negative equity. The only institution which can sustain negative equity indefinitely is an institution which owns its own bank, and banks' liabilities are accepted as payment by everybody else in that particular society.

By definition, that's the government. The government, which issues its own currency, has a bank which effectively underwrites any bonds that it sells. And if it can't sell those bonds, to the private sector, if there's a shortfall, then the central bank can buy them. And what actually happens through open market operations is a convoluted way of doing that. So, so long as you're able to issue bonds in your own currency as a national government, you can then back them up with your central bank effectively operating as an underwriter that you own and that returns any profits it makes back to you. So in that accounting sense, it's foolish to worry about whether a national country government issuing bonds in its own currency can run out of money to pay— buy those bonds in the first place or to service the interest rate. It can do both.

Junk bonds, QE and QT

Erik Townsend: Let's focus on the corporate side of that because, as you say, and I think you make an excellent argument, if you're the government, you can get away with a lot. What you're saying is that corporations can get away with things as long as they're positive cash flow, even if it takes them into negative equity. But Steve, we've been over the last 10 years through this cycle where what's happened is so many corporations have seen the opportunity to finance share buybacks using, in a lot of cases, junk debt. They're issuing all kinds of junk bonds, and they're massively, massively indebted.

And everybody's assuming that, well, you know, in this Fed-created economy that we have, thanks to quantitative easing, everything is going to continue to be hunky-dory. At some point, if the cash flow is not there, as I think you're alluding, it would seem that the huge risk is to corporations not being able to service those debts anymore. And you would think that markets would see this coming and we'd be seeing high yield spreads blowing out to extreme proportions. But in actuality, we've seen the opposite over the last 6 months or so, where high yield spreads over sovereign yields have tightened. And, you know, we've, we've got junk bond indices making new all-time highs in the last few months. How is that possible? I mean, or I guess what I should say is why isn't the market seeing what you're describing coming? Because it seems to me that you make a perfectly persuasive argument, but I sure don't see the market fearing that we're about to have a junk bond blowup.

If anything, there seems to be increasing complacency around the security of this, this very, I think, excessive corporate debt that's been built up to fund all of these share purchases.

Steve Keen: I think that's a very good analysis. And that's, that's what worries me, because I think it is the spreads that are going to matter. And the reason is, if you think about the issues of junk bonds and all this stuff that's been happening, it has been— the share buybacks in particular— it's been enabled by the Federal Reserve running quantitative easing for the last— what are we talking— over a decade.

And now they're going towards quantitative tightening. Now, while they were doing quantitative easing, what it meant was that, first of all, they were— So take the Federal Reserve, the US case, which is the clearest case. The Federal Reserve committed itself to buying $80 billion worth worth of bonds per month, which is roughly $1 trillion per year. What they were effectively saying is, is the open market operations, which they engage in all the time to try to keep the interest rate within the target band they've set, they were saying, we're going to be on the buy side, net $80 billion per month indefinitely.

And they weren't just buying government bonds, they were buying high— supposedly high-ranked corporate bonds and so on. What that meant was effectively Basically, the financial sector was handing over $1 trillion worth of bonds every year to the Fed Reserve in return for $1 trillion worth of cash. Now, you don't want cash. You want something that's going to be an interest rate returning object. You've sold what could have been junk to the Fed Reserve at a nice price, thanks very much. But you now want to— with the money you've got back, you now want to use that money to buy something else. Now, you can't buy bonds. In the sense that you can't buy government bonds because the government said we're going to be on the buy side that substantially. You can't buy high-rated corporates because again, that's what the Federal Reserve is buying.

What can you buy? You can buy shares or you can buy low-rated corporates. And I think that's what's going on. A large part of the demand we've seen for the low-rated corporates and for shares, and particularly financing share buybacks, has been an impact of this massive creation of not of creation of money in the real economy, but creation of money in the financial sector by the government running quantitative easing to the tune of $1 trillion a year.

Now, what they're doing now is they've started to feel confident. First of all, that's, that's given you a background of people who've taken that as that's the scenery that's been happening for a decade. That's therefore the scenery. That's the context in which they're trying to interpret the current arrangements.

Of course, at the moment, we know the Fed is trying to switch from quantitative easing towards quantitative tightening and to go from buying $80 billion to the— at the moment, They're selling between $30 and $50 billion per month back to the private sector. And of course, when they sell it, they put all those processes into reverse.

Erik Townsend: So let's discuss how this plays out. For anyone who's not aware, you've written a book called Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis? The book has been extremely well received. But for anyone who wants the executive summary, no, we can't avoid another financial crisis. So how does this play out? Because it sounds like you're saying the real problem is private debt and the excessive amount of corporate credit, including these low-rated corporate credits. And I couldn't possibly agree more with you, Steve, that it makes brilliant sense, everything that you're saying, except for one thing, which is the market keeps paying more and more and more for, you know, European junk bonds that are actually yielding lower, lower than US 10-year Treasuries for European junk-rated corporate debt. And, uh, you know, obviously this is a result of governments monkeying with the economy. But if the expectation is, okay, at some point there's going to be an aha moment, the market is going to recognize that this junk debt is overpriced, people are going to short it aggressively, and there's going to be a crash— well, I agree completely with the logic, but it seems like there's plenty of signals in the system right now that things are starting to get dicey, yet we haven't seen any real dislocation in all of these low-rated credit markets.

Steve Keen: Right.

Erik Townsend: corporate fixed income issues. So are people just afraid to short it because they don't want to pay the carry on it? What's going on here?

Steve Keen: Well, that could be the case. I mean, it's also— shorting is always dangerous, as you know. Getting it— you can be right and get your timing wrong and go bankrupt because you're right at the wrong time. So shorting is always a dangerous pastime for most people. And I think what that means is that we don't actually see the turnaround until after the panic point hits. You'll get individuals who either set themselves up well or who've got deep pockets and can handle a bit of a loss for an extended period. But the majority wait until the turn occurs. And then it's everybody for the doorways at once. And that's when you see the crunch. So if you're talking about low-rated European corporates being overvalued right now, I think that's a classic case of the market reacting too slowly and then overreacting when it does because the European corporates are much more exposed exposed to the dangers of bad government policy than the US corporates are because they've got the European Central Bank and they only have the euro.

And with only the euro, of course, you have 18 countries effectively that don't have their own central bank backing themselves in their own currency. And therefore, if they start running trade deficits or if they start getting the insanity of the Maastricht Treaty imposed upon relatively trivial government deficits at the moment, then those economies could have a crunch. And of course, it will feed through to the corporates who won't be able to service their bonds. So I think that's an obvious play coming up right now, exploiting both misunderstandings people have about the actual thing where they tend to worry too much about sovereign debt issued by nations with their own currency. And at the same time, those nations, and particularly the ECB now, which manages a disaster called the euro, they are likely to trying to return to what they think is normal without understanding where the first crisis came from.

And I think they're going to trigger recession in their own economies over the next couple of years by trying to return to what they think is normal with the central bank interest rates rising up towards 3% and 4% again.

Where the next crisis starts: France, Australia, Canada, China

Erik Townsend: Steve, as we look at how another financial crisis might occur, and, you know, let's start with the last one. It started in the United States really because of this securitization phenomenon where there was just so much fraud Frankly, that had occurred in issuance of subprime mortgages, that it created a credit crisis in the United States and the contagion spread around the world.

I think a lot of people make the assumption that it has to work the same way next time. How would you see, since you wrote the book on the subject of the next global financial crisis, where would you see it starting? Does it start in the United States the way the last one did, or does it start somewhere else? And if somewhere else, where else and why?

Why? And how does it proceed from there? And what is the mechanism of transmission? And how does it eventually grow in scope to reach the global economy?

Steve Keen: Well, the starting point is what actually caused the last crisis. It wasn't so much that the securitization caused the last crisis, it's that it let the last crisis— delayed it so that it became bigger when it finally occurred. Because what drove the last crisis is what's driven every financial crisis in history, and that's too much private debt growing too rapidly. Because when it does grow too rapidly, what's actually happening is credit is too high. So if I take the United States data series for private debt, which you can find at the Bank for International Settlements, for example, and take it right back to 1950— back in 1952 or '53, the level of private debt in America was roughly 50% of GDP, and credit was running at about 5% or 6% of GDP. Fast forward to 2005, and the level of private debt had risen to 160% of GDP, so more than trebling. And credit was running at about 5%. Credit was approaching 15% of GDP.

Now, credit, which is the annual change in debt— and the reason I define credit as the change in debt is when you take out— when you get a new loan from the bank, that's the change in debt. That you accept that new loan for $1 million, the debt that gives you, because the bank's put $1 million in your bank account. They're precisely equal. You would not accept the bank saying, here's $1 million of credit, and we're recording $1.1 million of debt against you. You'd say, hang on a second. Wait a second. You're going to record $1.1 million? You give me $1.1 million. So the credit, which is your spending power, borrowed spending power, is precisely equal to the change in debt.

Now, conventional economists ignore this because they have this mythical view of banking that said banks are like introduction agencies for mature people who want to cheat on their spouses, who don't actually— they don't provide the service you're looking for, but they introduce you to somebody else who who'll give you that service. I call it the Ashley Madison theory of banking. What banks actually do is originate loans and originate money at the same time. And then the borrower doesn't borrow— pardon me— for the sheer pleasure of being in debt. You borrow because you want to spend the money. So that change in— that increase in debt, which is credit, is spent into the economy and becomes a significant part of aggregate demand.

Now, a crisis occurs when the borrowing money leads to ventures that fail and people can't pay their debt back, when people get too worried about the leverage of assets they've bought and they stop borrowing for that reason, when banks get scared about the level of leverage they've got themselves into and they stop lending as well, all those things bring it to a crunch and you go from positive credit to negative credit. And when you have negative credit, that's actually taking money out of the economy and directly subtracting demand. But that's what caused the crisis back in 2007, 2008. And I look at the data, I see that credit, which was between 1950 and 2007, was 100% of GDP.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Steve Keen: Maximum level was 2007 when it hit 15% of GDP. And by 2010, it was down to -5% of GDP or -6%. So that's what actually caused the crisis, a 20% of GDP turnaround in credit from positive to negative.

Now, that also happened in the UK on a larger scale there. It was bigger still in Spain, gigantic in Ireland. These are all the countries that had an obvious financial crisis during the GFC, Iceland as well.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Steve Keen: Well, all those countries that had a huge— a lot of it was driven by housing booms, of course.

Countries that avoided the crisis, ones that continued to borrow through the crisis or even started their borrowing after, like China.

And they're the ones where I think they're going to have a crisis because the solution was to have more of the problem. And to give you my favorite example on that front, which is actually a country most people wouldn't expect, it's France. Because if I take a look at France, And say, what was France's level of private debt when the global financial crisis hit? The answer is 150% of GDP. What is its current level of debt? 192% of GDP.

So in America's crisis, had private debt rising from 50% of GDP back in the 1950s to 166% when the global financial crisis hit, and topping out at 170% and then falling from there. Okay. There to 150% now. On the other hand, France just sailed straight through the crisis with borrowing rising. So its debt level back in the 1970s, about as far as I can go back, is about 80% of GDP. It flatlined at about 100% of GDP till the middle of the 1980s. Then when the euro was formed, it took off from of the order of 130% of GDP to 180% 150% by the time the global financial crisis hit, well below America's level at that time.

It is now 192% of GDP. So France has avoided the crisis by continuing to borrow money. Now what it means is when they flatline, they're going to have a gigantic fall in their level of demand. So I expect France to be one of the next major centers to have a financial crisis.

And the other countries I include in that list are Australia, Australia, Canada, China, and South Korea. But I distinguish between the first 2 and the last 2 because Australia and Canada are both running trade deficits. And that makes them, in my opinion, very exposed to a failure to have credit continuing. Whereas China and South Korea are running large trade surpluses. And with that trade surplus, they can mask the problems because the trade surplus creates money, making up for the money which gets destroyed when credit runs out. France is actually in a similar situation. It's pretty much running a balanced— a balance of trade.

It's relying on a large amount of credit. It's got a huge amount of accumulated debt that has to stop growing. And when it does, they'll either have a serious crisis or a serious slowdown.

And my money's actually on more of a slowdown than a crisis because even though they've got this huge level of private debt, they haven't reached the levels of the borrowing that America did. So at the moment, the level of credit in France is running at roughly 9% of GDP versus 15% for America when its crisis hit. But it's got a high level of leverage. As I said, it's got 192% 42% of debt as private debt as it's debtable right now versus America when the crisis hit at about 30% of GDP lower.

Erik Townsend: So if I'm assimilating all of this correctly, it sounds like countries like France and Canada and Australia, to a lesser extent China, because even though their debt problem is just as big, they have the cushion of a trade surplus to help them service that debt. You're saying that those would be the places where the You've talked about where you think the next global financial crisis might start to occur.

How would that happen? What's the transmission mechanism? What are the signs? Does this happen primarily in credit markets, or does it happen in equity markets? And if it starts in those countries, how long does it take, and what does it look like as it starts to go through the process of contagion into the rest of the global economy?

Steve Keen: The contagion won't have the same impact that contagion had from the States because, again, And then what happened when the States fell over, talking the world's biggest economy at the time, and in the UK, which is one of the world's top 10 economies, also having the same sort of credit crunch, and then Spain and Ireland, and a global tendency for credit to slow down. The countries where it turned negative are the ones that had the crisis. That's definitely UK, USA, Spain, and Ireland. Credit went from massively positive to massively negative, and the same thing was transpiring. Yeah. Transmitted throughout Europe by the euro and by the Maastricht Treaty. So like in the case of Spain, for example, negative credit went from +40% of GDP to -20% over the crisis. In Greece, it was about +15% to -20%. So in Italy, about +10% to -5%, something of that nature. So large turnarounds. I don't see the same large turnarounds being triggered by this happening.

But what I see happening at the same time is the countries that managed to avoid the crisis— and not avoid, they managed— the countries that experienced the crisis and then have slowly navigated their way out of it through quantitative easing and through, to some extent, government stimulus spending, those countries are now thinking, oh, the crisis is behind us. Of course, we know that it wasn't caused by credit because we're listening to conventional economists here and they tell us to ignore credit. So let's get interest rates back up to normal levels again, which means about 4% for For the central banks, they'd like— the Federal Reserve's favorite rate of interest rate is 4%.

And as they get back to that level, what they don't realize, they're making corporate rates at least 6%, probably 7% on mortgages. And with, let's say, the average rate of private interest on private, that then hits about 6% of GDP.

That means that because America's carrying a debt level of 1.5 times GDP, pretty much 10% of GDP has to be used to service existing debt. Now that is big enough to mean that corporates and certainly a lot of households are going to say, we can't afford this anymore. Bang, we cut back on spending. But that's the voluntary decision. But we might also have to declare bankruptcy. That's the enforced decision. And that'll happen to a lot of corporates, I think. And what you'll see as a result is a substantial fall in credit in America as well, not on the scale of what happened back in 2008, but more like what happened back in the 1930s and what's known as the Roosevelt And what happened then was Roosevelt was persuaded by his advisors that the worst was over. By this stage, unemployment had fallen from the peak of 25% in 1932-33 down to 11%. And he said, get the budget back into balance again.

He tried to get balance back into the budget. I think there were some rate rises as well. And the private sector started to delever again. And unemployment, having fallen from 25% to 11%, blew out to 20%.

Erik Townsend: Wow. Steve, let me interrupt you there because we've had several guests on this program tell us, look, if you want to know where the just huge credit expansion has occurred since 2009, China, baby, that's where it's at. If you want to know where the credit crisis that's going to take down the global economy is going to start from, it's going to be China. And it sounds like what you're saying is, yeah, maybe the numbers are there in terms of credit expansion in China, China, but China runs a trade surplus, and that's going to help them with cushioning the blow. And I guess I don't quite follow the logic, because it seems to me like if there is contagion to the rest of the global economy, then the demand for Chinese exports is going to go down, and that's going to impair their ability to use that trade surplus to service that debt.

What am I missing here?

Steve Keen: Not a lot. I think I agree with that generally, but I want to put some background on it again for For a start, China has its own currency, and they're trying to make that currency a global player as well. France does not. So, in terms of the government's capacity to counter what goes wrong, France hasn't got the capacity. China does. And that means that you can expect the Chinese government to be pumping large amounts of government fiat money into the economy at the same time as credit money is running out.

Now, to give you an idea of some of the numbers here, I'm looking at the data from the Bank for International Settlements now. So if you look at the level of private debt in China when the global financial crisis hit, it was about 120% of GDP, which is below my absolute danger line of 150%, but still high. But it was trending down because with the scale of trade surpluses China was running with government spending as well, that enabled the private sector in China to continue deleveraging. The crisis hit. And of course, when the global financial crisis hit, exports by China to America plunged by something like 40%. You had a massive Massive emigration of people out of the coastal cities and the factories there back to the rural counties where they were registered because they think there's no unemployment for you except where you're registered in China. So they had to leave. Huge political challenge to the Communist Party at that stage.

The response was to tell basically their banks, which of course are mainly state-owned or state-controlled, to lend with anybody with a pulse. And the biggest property bubble in history began in China.

If you go to 2009, 2009, the level of credit in that year started jumping. It went from, at that stage, 16% of GDP, and it blasted up to 39% of GDP by 2010. Now, it's been running lower than— not those high levels, but certainly, if I go to say 2012, it was running at 22% of GDP. By 2013, it's 30% of GDP. We're talking substantial numbers, twice the scale of what I was talking about for America. By 2016, still 28% of GDP. Now it's trending down now. It's still huge, but it's kind of— it's pretty well about 20%, maybe 19% of GDP.

So of course, a turnaround from that point towards negative credit with nothing else to counteract it would be a major crisis and feed through to the rest of the world. But at the same time, China is spending massively on what they're What they call the Silk Road project, the One Belt Road, the massive attempts to decarbonize the economy, which of course at the same time, there are other parts of the government pumping out coal-powered power stations, but lots of the attempts to put solar and wind power into China, the high-speed rail, all that expenditure, according to some sources I've seen, is totaling excess government spending over government taxation in China of about 15% of GDP.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Steve Keen: Now, to put that in context, that's 3 times the size of the New Deal and 1.5 times the size of the stimulus under Obama in 2009. So if that much is coming in from the government while the credit's going negative at the same time and the country is running a trade surplus, that buffers the extent of the downturn. So I do think there's a credit crunch happening in China. I do think it'll be big, but the Chinese have got a capacity to mask it by the level of government spending. And at the same time, time, because banking is basically double-entry bookkeeping and people can cheat at double-entry bookkeeping. I expect the Chinese government to tell its banks to cheat and continue operating if they are in negative equity. So you won't see the same impact on the downturn there that you saw in America where that sort of thing can't be done.

De-dollarization and the Bancor

Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on something you said a minute ago about China trying to make the RMB, its currency, into a global currency. And, you know, this really brings back to my

Steve Keen: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: In my mind, the subject of de-dollarization, Sergey Glazyev in Russia trying to persuade other countries to stop using the dollar for international trade settlement, for purchase of oil in particular. Now we've seen China with this yuan-denominated crude oil contract on the Shanghai Futures Exchange. But in the past, you know, this has been China and Russia complaining that they don't like the hegemony the dollar has over the global financial system. No surprise that China and Russia don't like what the United States are doing. But what we've seen, Steve, just in recent weeks is, to my thinking, is a fairly dramatic change in that the German foreign minister made a public statement with just so much frustration over President Trump's very aggressive use of withholding access to the SWIFT payment system as a way to impose sanctions, not only on on Iran, but on any country that's doing business with Iran, including countries that have not sanctioned Iran.

So what we saw was first Germany in August making this public statement that really surprised me, because it seemed like for the first time that I can remember, Germany is publicly taking, you know, Russia and China's side of this argument in not supporting the United States as their long-term ally. But in late September, about a month Later, we saw the European Union's foreign policy chief stand shoulder to shoulder with the Iranian foreign minister and announce that the European Union was committed to creating a mechanism to bypass the SWIFT payment network to allow European corporations to continue to do lawful business with Iranian corporations and with the Iranian government, intentionally working against US sanctions because those US sanctions had been imposed unilaterally.

Steve Keen: Right.

Erik Townsend: Unilaterally and did not carry the weight of a United Nations blessing. So, all of a sudden, the European Union standing shoulder to shoulder with the Iranian foreign policy minister saying the United States is wrong and we're committed to building a workaround to the SWIFT system, it gets me thinking.

And it clearly hasn't happened yet, Steve, but if Russia and China can somehow win over Europe and get them on their side of this de-dollarization,

Steve Keen: Right.

Erik Townsend: thing. That to me really brings serious question to the dollar's certainty of maintaining its reserve currency status in the long run. Am I crazy to think that?

Steve Keen: No, I don't think you're crazy. I think it's been crazy to use the American dollar for that length of time anyway. Donald Trump is very happy to talk about how he's great making deals and, you know, these are these bad deals to reverse. Well, there's one bad deal he should reverse straight away, and that's using the United States dollar as the reserve currency. Because that was Harry Dexter White at the 1944 Bretton Woods Conference rolling over Keynes, who wanted to bring an international payment system based on a non-national currency that he called the Bancor, which was to be issued by a body which was International Clearing Union, which was in some ways it's similar would be the International Monetary Fund today. But that currency would have been issued proportional to the size of each national economy. So America would have got the biggest number of Bancor, obviously. And then you were trading, you'd have to convert your national currency into Bancor to buy something off anybody else.

And there were controls to stop deficits and surpluses exceeding— and wait for it— 1% of GDP. Now we have got Germany running a surplus of 9% of GDP. China is fairly similar. And these surpluses, of course, necessarily mean deficits elsewhere in the world. One of those places being America, which is normally running a trade deficit of about 5% of GDP. And indeed, it has to maintain a trade a trade deficit in that sense, because since it's the reserve currency, other countries and corporations and people around the world have a demand for US dollars over and above their desire to buy US goods, which means, of course, that US industry is handicapped by an overvalued dollar. I'd just go with a rough ballpark at saying it's got to be at least 30% overvalued. I've seen people claim it's twice the value it should be. So in that situation, the only benefit America gets out of it is a big benefit.

It's got the financial muscle to push the rest of the world around. We've normally seen that in terms of American corporations being able to buy assets in the rest of the world with US dollars. But it also means things like the SWIFT payment system uses the American dollar. And if the Americans say, we're not going to let Iranians use SWIFT, then bang, Iran can't trade with anywhere in the world. And we get political blackmail on top of a stupid bloody system in the first place. So I think, you know, I've been making the case myself as an academic for 30-something years that we should go to what Keynes originally wanted, which was the Bancor for international trade, not the American dollar.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Steve Keen: And have controls to stop the deficits and surpluses getting out of hand. The myth that the market would do it itself is obviously wrong, given the sustained surpluses we've seen for countries like Japan and Germany, or Japan in particular, for 30 or 40 years.

We have to have another system. Now, it may be that the biggest gift Donald Trump is giving to the world is he's making it so intolerable to use the US system that we might finally see countries like Germany, as you say, Iran, Russia, and China coming together and saying, let's devise a different system. And I'm— I know that the Chinese central bank has been talking about a Bancor. So I hope this is what's going to happen.

Erik Townsend: Well, Steve, great minds think alike. I happen to be writing a book about this very subject, and my hypothesis is as follows. I think that China and Russia have already figured out that digital currency technology invented by the cryptocurrency crowd gives them exactly the leverage that they need to create effectively the Bancor, and it will come in the form of a global currency, a global digital currency, which is designed for the express purpose of upstaging the US dollar and replacing it as the world's global reserve currency. And I'm not talking about cryptocurrency. I'm not a cryptocurrency believer. I don't think that that movement has a whole lot of steam left in it, but the technology invention of distributed ledger and double-spend-proof digital cash are exactly what you need to build a global digital currency system, which I think has the opportunity to upstage the dollar. And I'm convinced that China and Russia are already working on it, which is the subject of my book.

I'm very curious, do you think I'm, I'm nuts to think that that's a possibility? And what do you think the odds are of someone such as China and Russia Russia asserting a potentially gold-backed digital currency, which is designed to replace the US dollar as the world's global reserve currency.

Steve Keen: I don't know about the gold-backed side, but you know, I'm a gold skeptic because I think the whole idea that people believe currencies need to have backing in terms of a commodity or anything of that nature is nonsense. The backing of a state apparatus or an agreed system between states, that is all you need. Now, if you have China and Russia and Europe and Iran saying, okay, we're going to invent an electronic trading system where we'll pay in Bancors to buy Iranian oil, to buy European goods in return, and so on. And we recognize that and accept it. That's enough for it to work. And of course, the distributed ledger side of blockchain, I think, is a disaster because of the enormous amount of processing time that gets wasted with millions of people maintaining the same ledger and all the time delays built into the system as well.

But if you're talking to a number of central banks just maintaining a copy of a ledger so that they know that the transactions are verified and accepted, and it's a reproduction of the multiple accounting system at the level of central banks, that works perfectly well.

So you're quite right. I think that's actually a very sensible speculation.

Erik Townsend: Well, I'll send you a draft of the book. I agree with you completely that blockchain is for the birds. I think blockchain's going nowhere. I'm talking about a permissioned distributed ledger, which is thousands of times faster than blockchain and eliminates its dependence on the proof-of-work algorithm, which is the whole problem with the performance that you're talking about. Anyway, let's save my book for a different day. I want to come back to your book, which is Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis? For anyone who's not familiar with it, give us just a real quick rundown of that, and then I want to move on to your work on Patreon.

Steve Keen: Okay, well, the basic thesis of Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis, of course, is what caused the last one. And as one of the handful of people who saw the crisis coming, the reason I did was I focus upon private debt and credit. And what I saw in the case of the last crisis was private debt in my home country of Australia and in America as well growing too rapidly, meaning we're too dependent on credit, and meaning that when debt stopped growing, total demand would fall and it would hit asset markets first and then pass through to the real economy.

That's what happened in America on a grand scale. My country, home country of Australia, avoided it because the government then encouraged the housing bubble that was starting to burst at the time to restart by doubling and trebling the amount of money they gave to first-time buyers to get into the market. And that credit boost followed by what China did with its gigantic internal stimulus as well put Australia into one of the survivor categories that didn't have a crisis back in 2008. So to me, it's a debt-driven, credit-driven crisis. America, the UK, Spain, and Ireland in particular had that crisis. Europe made it worse with the euro, but that's the basic crisis back in 2008. Now looking forward, what— from that point of time, I'd say the countries that had a crisis then are now what I call the walking dead. of debt. They're carrying such a level of private debt, any boost they get out of credit will be short-lived.

And looking at America in that case, for example, credit debt peaked at 170% of GDP in 2009, 2010. It fell to slightly below 150% by 2012. It's now rising again, but the rate of change of debt, which is what creates credit, is much lower than it was before the crisis. It's flatlined running at about 6% or 7% of GDP. So you don't get much of a boost out of the economy.

And when the authorities, who don't understand this at all, I'm afraid to say, when the authorities like the Federal Reserve decide to stabilize the economy by putting up interest rates to fight inflation, they will trigger another downturn with the private sector going back into deleveraging again. And that's what hit Japan for the last 25 years. So I call these the walking dead of debt, and they're never going to quite get out of it.

The zombies-to-be are the countries that managed to avoid a crisis by continuing to borrow money through the crisis back in 2008, keeping credit demand positive, but of course accumulating more private debt in the process. The primary country that did that is China, but China, as I've mentioned, has the fallback of enormous government spending as well. The countries that don't have that fallback and that have had the same credit-driven avoidance of the financial crisis back in 2008, they're the ones that are going to have a crisis in the near future. And that in particular involves Canada and Australia, which are the most obvious examples. It also involves France, which is the next biggest economy that has also relied upon credit to get through the crisis. And then of course you have a number of smaller countries, some of which are running trade surpluses. They may manage to, to buffet themselves from the crisis.

But fundamentally, all crises are caused by excessive private debt. All crises come to an end when private debt stops rising, and you then find yourself in the aftermath. And we are now carrying an aftermath of private debt, which is so great that I think the global economy is caught in credit stagnation rather than secular stagnation, and will stay there until we reduce the level of private debt. And we won't do it deliberately, we'll most likely do it by fighting climate change.

Keen's Patreon experiment

Erik Townsend: Steve, last time we had you on the program, you were exploring something new, and I thought very exciting, because you have for a long time had the reputation of being the A guy who, despite having a PhD in economics, still speaks and writes in plain English and is very good explaining economics in plain English.

In addition to your work as a university professor, you were undertaking something to create essentially a program on Patreon to get people who wanted to learn about economics to support you through the Patreon funding mechanism, and you were basically—

Steve Keen: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: going to supply a flow of writing and other services. It was a brand new idea that you were just experimenting last we spoke to you. How has that gone? How many followers have you managed to get on Patreon? Is it going well, and is it something that you're going to continue to do?

Steve Keen: Oh yeah, it's going very well. These things always grow more slowly than you expect, and then of course they have growth spurts when you, when you think they're going to go backwards. But when I started Patreon, in the first month I got to about 300 subscribers. Subscribers and $2,800 in revenue. I'm now running at about just under 1,000 subscribers, and the revenue is running at about $6,700 a month. And that's not quite as much as I was earning as an academic, but it's enough to mean I can continue being a rabble-rouser and not have to worry about all the nonsense that dominates universities these days.

And I've got quite a lively community of supporters there. And what, of course, what I'm going to be doing from now on is most of what I post goes out publicly. I use YouTube for my videos and I put my posts up for free after maybe a short delay for my patrons to see them first. But as I start writing the next couple of books, then all the draft chapters are going to turn up and I'm going to get feedback from my audience as I write them. So the main benefit is that feedback learning process. And what I'm going to consider doing as well when I cease working at the university sector, and at the moment it looks like being September of next year, I'll being employed at the university. I'll just be— I'll still be a professor, but I won't have a teaching role.

Then I'm going to start developing online courses using Patreon.

Erik Townsend: Well, that's fantastic news. I think that to give the world at large the opportunity to learn from someone with your perspective, and needless to say, having called the 2008 financial crisis in advance and having explained publicly why and how it was going to happen, you have a lot of credibility. For people who want to pursue this and find out more, where do they sign up or where do they find more information about what you offer on Patreon?

Steve Keen: Just go to patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen and they'll find me. So Prof Steve Keen is the handle. And of course, if they follow me on Twitter, you can't avoid seeing it there. I whack it in most of my Twitter posts. So it's quite easy to find. And the lowest level is $1 $1 a month, and the highest level anybody's actually putting money into is $100 a month. And there are various benefits for that, that I've, you know, I give various goodies out, maybe signed copies of books and stuff like that.

But the main reason people are there, and this is why I appreciate it so much, is they, they know we need a new economics, and they regard me as the leading person developing that. And they want to do their bit to try to bring about a realistic economics, because we can see the damage that unrealistic economics has done to the global economy and to human society, and it's about time we stopped it.

You can't— it won't happen at the universities. It'll only be rebels like myself, and maybe institutions like the OECD that are doing some work to try to bring about an alternative approach to economics that'll get us away from the religion we call economics as it is at the moment, get us something realistic. Forget ideology. Let's just understand capitalism before it— before we destroy it.

Erik Townsend: Well, I could not possibly endorse that view any more strongly. So amen to that, and I encourage all of our listeners to check out Steve's work. You'll find a link in your Research Roundup email to Steve's Patreon page at patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen. Steve, thanks so much for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven podcast. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction to Keen

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Professor Keen. As a Canadian, I guess I always am interested to hear what his opinions are because he's always been talking about the huge credit problems that are developing in Australia and Canada. And now obviously in this interview, he throws France into that mix.

You know, the Canadian situation is very interesting. It continues to be under a lot of stress. And I shared recently stories about how the carry on homes is coming to multi-decade highs and, and how the debt situation is becoming stressed with higher interest rates. It certainly is going to be very interesting to see whether in the next few years bring about that kind of crack that causes the final turn in this debt bubble that's developing in these periphery countries. What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: You know, Steve Keen never stops impressing me. The guy is just like a fire hose of macroeconomic information. What fascinates me, and I want to talk to him again about this sometime, is we have very different views. Steve actually thinks I'm not one of those people who thinks that the reserve currency status that the US dollar holds— I started to say enjoys, 'cause I think it enjoys it— is a negative for the US. I see the loss of US dollar reserve currency as a major threat to the US economy. And the reason is, at least according to me, and I should be careful who I compete with here, according to me, the whole value is there's so much artificial demand for dollars. And Luke Gromen has described this on the program. That what results is both for Treasury debt and for dollars themselves. The dollar is stronger than it would be if not for reserve currency status, and there is so much debt that we get away with deficit spending.

This whole idea that politicians have that deficits don't matter is nonsense. The reality of the situation is that deficits matter a whole lot, but you get away with deficit spending without immediately feeling the consequences when you are the world's global reserve currency. And I think loss of that status really puts the US ability to borrow and spend beyond its means without paying the penalty in the form of higher borrowing costs at serious risk. Steve sees it differently, and I'd love to do an interview with him just on that subject. We'll have to get him back on the program for that topic at some point.

Charlie McElligott: CTA deleveraging, dealer gamma and the outlook

Erik Townsend: But Patrick, I want to bring in Charlie McElligott, who of course heads up cross-asset macro strategy for Nomura. Nomura. Charlie, thanks so much for joining us again. Last time we had you on the program, I think your sentiment was very similar to my own, which is, you know, we're in some kind of topping process here, but maybe there's still room for another high.

Maybe we haven't seen the high yet. I don't know about you. I'm kind of thinking at this point that maybe the high is in. What do you see and what's the big picture and what should we make of the carnage in markets this week?

Charlie McElligott: Sure. So I do think we're Very much still on the same page there. I know that the last time we spoke, I was touching on that concept of mine, the 2-speed year, with the second phase being the tighter financial conditions tantrum phase, which is effectively the endgame as we transition from late cycle into pre-recession. And certainly the very acute nature of what some people would say looks to be an equities-centric deleveraging of the past 2 days to a week and a half actually has a deeper macro origin in my mind, which again, if I'm really stepping back and talking almost more philosophically, it's the bigger picture here is that a higher real interest rate environment is resetting term premium. And with that, the cost of Leverage.

With that, cross-asset correlations, asset price valuation, all of these constructs built in the post-crisis quantitative easing era are now ripe to tip over. And we're seeing these rolling Minsky moments as the pseudo-stability of lower interest rates, flatter curves, and suppressed volatility breeds instability through the leverage that's had to have been deployed. on strategies over the past few years as yield was chased. And that's what we're coming out of right now.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Charlie, this is Patrick here. And I just wanted to elaborate. I really love your work when it comes to the quantitative analysis of the cumulative flows and the way the liquidity is driving triggers in the markets. Right now, you were talking about some of these key levels where these CTAs were all 100% max long a week ago, and suddenly they're flipping and having to unwind their long positions. I remember you saying a number, something in the vicinity of like $88 billion on the— to sell on just the other day. And you were talking about some very key technical levels. So the one was that the 2,719 level on the S&P, where there's a potential another wave of CTA selling potentially triggered. And as well, you were also talking about all of the gamma influences on the option dealer books.

Charlie McElligott: Yeah.

Patrick Ceresna: Why don't you elaborate on what you're seeing and where the kind of liquidity levels are right now and what you're seeing here, the risks in the next couple days?

Charlie McElligott: Sure. So I know that various negative convexity strategies, which have proliferated in the prior quantitative easing era, those lower yields, flatter curves, suppressed volatility, have led to the growth in systematic trend, risk control, risk parity, vol-targeting annuities, leveraged VIX ETNs. That's all part of the market structure that we deal with. And to my prior point, as we've transition from QE to QT, quantitative tightening, we are now going to be forced to see structural unwinds of some of these forces. So as it pertains particularly to the systematic community and the role that they play in the market, the highest impact of unemotional selling in the most violent fashion typically occurs through the CTA universe, the trend universe, one, because it's so structurally leveraged. And most importantly though, it's a shorter-term vehicle, shorter-term signals. So our model looks at windows from 2 weeks to 1 month to 3 months to 6 months to 1 year.

And we see the different transitions and the different signals generated across those buckets for various asset classes. But when the bond-equities correlation breaks down, as it is currently right now, people will jump to the risk parity side of the equation, which per our construct is a much slower moving vehicle. Ours particularly uses a 2-year window so that there is a little bit of false attribution in my mind currently within the institutional marketplace, as far as trying to pin responsibility on the risk parity community, when in my mind, the much more powerful short-term force in the market are CTAs. With that, that 2,719 level that you spoke about was the next deleveraging point per our projections in the S&P for the futures to close below that level. It's not a one-touch, but to close below that level would see our current S&P position break down from what went into the day as a 43% long. And as of one week ago, that was 100% max If

we were to have closed below 2,719 today, that would've then taken us down to just 9% net long and would've triggered an additional selling of 57 billion S&P futures. This is on top of the number that you mentioned, which was a one-day, just an incredible one-day move yesterday in S&P. We went through so many triggers.

We started the day at 97% net long. We went through 76% net long, 57% net long, 55% net long. Wow. 50% net long down to 43% net long, various triggers over 2-week, 1-month, and 3-month buckets that flipped from long to short. And over the course of yesterday, our model estimates projected nearly $88 billion of S&P selling. So just absolutely spectacular flows going through yesterday. I think then to take a step back, today is Today is the day that discretionary managers had to figure out what they were doing. Yesterday's flows were so heavy, systematic funds, unemotional, as I always tell you, price insensitive. Today, this was much more about discretionary active managers sizing their portfolios for the rest of the year, which is probably a function of how badly their performance has come unglued over the last few weeks.

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Charlie, like I was suggesting earlier, you also like to reference a lot about the dealer exposure in terms of options the SPX and, and where the dealers are and how much gamma exposure there is. Obviously, with such a huge move, this throws a lot of dealers into a situation where they have to, to hedge into the futures market. What is the current situation? How much gamma exposure is there still in the options market?

Charlie McElligott: For sure. So we saw an enormous jump day over day with the S&P futures options and SPY ETF options cumulative, both delta and gamma on the day. So SPX net delta moved down $460 billion. That's a 0.1 percentile move since 2013. So the day prior, that net delta was negative $55 billion.

So just an impossible, almost 9 times growth over the course of the day with regards to how much delta was kicked off for sale from the options community yesterday. In just SPX and SPY. And what that means from the delta side of things is that, and this is as of yesterday's numbers, but S&P gamma is now $24 billion per 1% move, plus or minus. And those big strikes there are 2,800 and 2,750. And I think judging by today's spasms where it looked like we were going to break out and then it looked like we were going to break down, and it looked like we were going to break out, and it looked like we were going to break down.

Those levels kept us pretty well pinned. But the danger here is that on a close below that pretty heavy open interest line of 2,750, the more we start slipping below, the further out of position the short gamma is. And the more it slips, the more you have to sell to stay hedged. And that's always the danger of the options market, I think the one good thing going for us, it's all in context because there's not a lot of good out there right now, but is the fact that, and the point that I made earlier, that today was the discretionary community, the active fundamental managers' day to trade and make determinations on what they want to do with the rest of their years. Because I think the good news is that the last week, week and a half has seen a massive netting down of their exposure. So their net length is as low, net long, as it's been all year.

We're at the lows there as people of power sold their longs and pressed their shorts to some extent. But today, I think you saw some pretty gross down type of behavior. And that, to me, is a good thing with regards to the Greek implications, because I think it's possible that even though some people have been rolling out their hedges, now that I think the overall overall books have been shrunk down to such an extent that we might slowly begin to bleed out some of these delta and gamma positions, which could, of course, and will eventually further exacerbate any of these moves. Just at the end of the day, you have a smaller underlying book. You don't need your hedges at some point here. So it's gotten so massive and the overhedging had become so massive, and we are all aware of the very extreme skews, the skew in the Over the last month.

Now, some of those hedges have paid, and they hopefully, as you've taken down your longs and maybe covered some of your shorts, now you don't have so much to hedge, which could help minimize some of those really wild swings that we've been seeing in the market.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, I want to leave you with one question. Is there a real risk here that there's going to be one more downdraft, or is it likely here that as the selling, if they can defend the here that we suddenly have the buy-on-dip traders come in here and really rebound this? Do you have a bias here? Is the risk really still real for another liquidity drop?

Charlie McElligott: I want to be as black and white on this as possible and totally clear that if there was going to be a period of pullback with this tape, it was going to come in this 2-week window where we are at peak buyback. Back blackout. And that is absolutely where we are right now. The vast majority of S&P sub-industry levels are at effectively 100% blackout as of this week. Now, 10b5-1 plans allow corporates to buy outside of the blackouts, but with a number of limiting factors there. So we're not seeing— the bottom line, there still is a reduction in that corporate flow.

That is a critical facilitator allowing this risk-off trade to really proliferate. And just like February 5th, this move was precipitated for macro purposes, right? This isn't purely a sentiment trade. This certainly is negligibly about trade wars. This is really about the Fed and tighter financial conditions and higher real interest rates.

And there have been a number of developments over the last month that saw anywhere from the positive growth shock of last week's data and Fed speakers talking about higher neutral rates and hawkish Fed rhetoric thereafter, and most specifically, Chair Powell talking about running a deeply restrictive Fed policy and stating that we're a long way away from neutral on interest rates, implying more hikes that you've had this massive and violent, as far as the rate of change goes, sell-off in rates, sell-off in US Treasuries, and this power move in yields with an enormous bear steepening in the curve. And that bear steepening is a huge part of this underlying equities violence because that bear steepening has allowed for Value, which is all the stuff that's been left behind, the cyclical stuff over the last 5 years, to massively outperform growth. And growth is FAANG tech stuff that people have been parked in, the secular growth stuff.

It didn't need a cycle, a hot economy, a geared economy to work. And now those longs are really coming off. So there's a macro catalyst to this. The good news is that there's a tremendous October and frankly into year-end seasonal that The buyback will begin to start coming back online in the next 2 weeks.

And I do believe, as we talked about today, we're in a much cleaner positioning level, certainly both with the discretionary guys that I just talked about have really either netted or grossed down their positions, as well as these systematic funds where I just told you that CTAs in and of themselves are down to 43% long from a max 100% long one week ago. And that's S&P. The NASDAQ has been massively reduced to the 30s. The Russell is down to 9% long. The point is much cleaner positioning, meaning much less to delever.

Now, the market can go 2 ways. If people are really getting nervous with regards to another October volatility shock, and people start taking chips off the table, table because these stocks that have been most affected, all these momentum longs, all these growth tech stocks, if that starts bleeding into retail, then yes, this could very well perpetuate. I do think the other angle here too is that there has been a massive seller of the US long bond contract in the market the past few weeks.

And there are a number of folks fearing that it could be somebody, an entity overseas that would really cause the fixed income world to further wobble. If we see the long end continue to sell off and the curve continue to bear steepen, I think all bets are off and equities could absolutely continue trading lower.

I personally though believe that we are seeing de-risking now, and the de-risking is actually seeing money flow back into Treasuries. Especially as they've repriced attractively. To that final point that I'm making about the importance of the long bond, you had a huge 30-year auction today that was really taken down because buyers stepped up at these more attractive yield levels. So to me, as long as interest rates are stabilized, I think too equities will stabilize. And I think over the course of the next 2 weeks, the buyback begins to show back up and that too stabilizes. And I do think that then there still can be an element of performance-type chasing, much cleaner positioning, all of these things that set up positively into the year-end, certainly from this much more attractive valuation level.

McElligott: gold CTA trigger levels

Erik Townsend: Charlie, one more question. Gold got my attention today. Yeah, okay, the dollar's down a little, gold should be up a little, but gold's not up a little, gold's up a What's going on?

Charlie McElligott: I think gold is now getting more interesting for folks with what a lot of people would consider its core value, which is that break glass in case of emergency between— and it hasn't traded like that for so long. It hasn't traded as a risk-off flight-to-quality asset for a long time. Frankly, for the last year or so, it's traded almost exclusively like an emerging markets currency that yields nothing. But that's what's so interesting about today's move. And on top of this, it's getting really interesting because gold has been a max short per our systematic model for over a year now.

And we have, on today's kind of break out move. And of course, there's other strategies out there with similar triggers that might not necessarily be exactly our own that indicate to me that this thing might be turning. In particular, our model is now telling us that at the 1,245 level, we would see that 100% max short turn to just 12% short. And in In theory, if that were to trigger, meaning close above $1,245, you could see upwards of $46 billion of gold to buy.

And that's before it even turns long. That's purely on a cover. Either way, something is brewing within gold and you're getting nearer to that breakpoint. And I think it has a lot to do with this end-of-the-cycle debate that's being processed in the market real time that is effectively something to the effect of, are we tightening ourselves into a slowdown? And I think people are getting increasingly nervous that the vapor trails that the fiscal stimulus, the dual fiscal stimulus provided us so late in the cycle is maybe pulling forward the end of the cycle. And with that end of the cycle, what are central banks going to be able to do next as we see what's happening currently, as they've tightened policy and they've shrunk balance sheets, these rolling volatility events that we've seen over the last year. So, I think gold is starting to show up on people's radars again, and it's getting pretty interesting, certainly as some of the systematic positioning looks to be pivoting as well.

Erik Townsend: So, the trigger event is a daily close above $1,245, an intraday doesn't count. If we see that and it triggers $46 billion, with a B, dollars of gold buying, do you have a model for what that does to the price?

Charlie McElligott: I would need to run some projections, but I would say that at that point, the amount of new interest, new velocity, new momentum that that would bring in, especially from, you know, kind of off the radar from a lot of the, a lot of the macro set, just hasn't been a particularly interesting asset to trade It's been stuck at the $1,200 level forever, it seems. If this thing started picking up steam and brought in some new interest, a move up to that $1,299 level from there then sees it pivot 66% long. And after that, you could be off to the races, a real land grab.

Erik Townsend: Charlie, before we go, I am looking at a fantastic chart from your daily note, Which is really just fantastic content every day, and you've got all of these key levels clearly spelled out. Now, that is only available to your institutional clients. For our institutional audience, what do they need to do in order to get your daily letter if they don't receive it already?

Charlie McElligott: So, if you are facing off with, with Nomura Global Markets and you have an existing trading relationship with us, it's as simple as reaching out to your sales coverage and we can facilitate, certainly have the conversation with regards to making sure that you're able to, to access the content, and, and we'll take it from there.

Erik Townsend: And we should probably just mention, for the benefit of our retail audience, folks like Charlie are restricted by securities regulations. As much as he'd like to share the content with you, they're not allowed to do that. So please, only institutional inquiries in order to keep Charlie out of trouble with the regulators. Charlie, we can't thank you enough for joining us. We look forward to having you back on the program again soon.

Chartbook: calendar straddles, S&P 500 and gold

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I want to jump over to our postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says postgame chartbook. Patrick, as I look at page 2 here, this is obviously the before picture. We're showing that nice rally of the S&P up into that blue target zone from your measured move targets. Sure enough, we hit it exactly where you called You called it. I know that you guys really nailed it with your Big Picture Trading clients. And Patrick, page 3 clearly is the after picture showing with the result of this week's carnage what happened.

But I want to do a little bit of a review here because you had been long with your Big Picture Trading clients right up to almost exactly the top. You called both of these recent tops and traded them. I think we've got to say to some extent there There was clearly some skill involved because you nailed both of those tops, so congratulations, and congratulations to all of the Big Picture Trading clients that are in the audience. I know you guys made some money on that. But let's face it, there is always the possibility that you could have been wrong or you could have just gotten lucky with those calls. You also not just got the levels right, but you used options in a way that limited your downside and maximized Talk us through not only what drove this price action on the way up and then the way down, but also how you approach it from an option trading standpoint.

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, just to review, like, we were basically bullish the market all the way from April, and when we caught that breakout, we've been basically bullying the market saying that we're going to go and see measured moves to the upside and a potential rally into towards the year end. But as we entered the target zones above. There wasn't actually a lot of technical signals alone saying that we should be short the market. We only knew from a price level perspective that the— A, that this was overbought. It was already overextended. There was already a risk-reward proposition diminishing, which is that there's a marginal further upside and there's a growing potential of a big profit to the downside if you can catch the turn. And so the question is, how do you put on an option strategy that kind of allows you to game the scenario. One, a scenario where on the very short term the market can keep plugging higher and still make higher highs, but yet you're properly short if the whole market reverses.

And this is where we were using a strategy known as, uh, calendar straddles, where, uh, we were using short-dated calls against long-dated puts, and we were rolling with the market move to catch the top. And so it was a great strategy we executed, and it's one that I want to talk about in

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I want to pick up on what you just said,

Patrick Ceresna: webinar.

Erik Townsend: What are you planning? Is this a free one or do people have to pay for it? And what are you talking about?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, listen, I mean, this is a podcast, so here we're just describing things verbally. And really, I would love to show all of our listeners how this strategy is implemented and why it worked so well for us to catch both of the last 2 market tops and allow our members to profit really well from this. And so the whole point of a webinar webinars, I can share the screens, I can show different concepts, show the different way the option strategies work, so how the gamma works on the, on the 2 different duration options. And so I want to share all of that in the webinar. The webinar is completely free, it's available to all our members, and it's going to be on Sunday, October 14th. The link is in the Research Roundup email as well as at the end of this chart book. So anyone that wants to join me for that webinar on Sunday Please do. If you can't make the webinar, the recording is going to be made available afterwards.

So just register for the webinar and we'll make sure we send out the recording link to everyone that registered afterwards.

Erik Townsend: Okay, Patrick. So just to recap, it's a free webinar and free really means free. No have to put in your credit card or any of that nonsense. It's really free. And it is on Sunday, this coming Sunday, and I definitely recommend it, folks. The part to really pay attention to. It's not just that Patrick got lucky and called the top and made money. It's that he knew how to apply a strategy where it almost didn't matter exactly where the top came. He knew one was coming, and he set up a strategy that allowed him to capture the downside as soon as the market turned. And it's really a fascinating strategy, so I recommend people check it out. Meanwhile, we got to keep the show rolling, so let's move on to slide 4 here. This S&P chart showed one pattern that might have played out. Well, guess what? It didn't go exactly the way that next green line thought it might go to show new highs.

What do you think, Patrick? Are we looking still at a possibility of still seeing a new high, or is it pretty much jury's in after today's action that the high is in for the year?

Patrick Ceresna: The breakdown that we saw in the S&P 500 was some serious technical damage, and like Charlie was suggesting, there is definitely room for there to be a snapback season. Seasonal rally after the selling subsides here. But there, in my mind, with this type of a nasty break, the likelihood that we see still yet a higher high, that diminishes considerably. Now, while I don't think that this is a straight line down from here, we're already covering a lot of our shorts. The, the thing to me though is it's— if we have a rally and that rally does not make a higher high into that seasonally year-end, then that may already have marked a very key high for the whole bull market, the longest bull market in history.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, moving on to slide number 5. This gold breakout really had my attention before Charlie started talking about it, and now I'm even more interested. I have thought, and I still think, the dollar may have more upside, and that should have meant more downside for gold. But this move up is not explained by the weakness in the dollar. Something more is going on here. Do you think it's what Charlie described? Do you think there's something else driving it? What's your take?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, one day to me does not make a new trend. So, uh, what's really important on this chart when we're showing that big huge breakout in gold is really what it does here in the next week. A lot of times these markets will break out this way, and if it's not the real deal, the sellers will hammer it all the way back down into range changes and it was just a complete false start. But what's going to be the most valuable bit of information is throughout the next week is that do the bulls come in and support this breakout? And is every dip starting to get bought? And is, is gold working its way higher to, you know, $1,240, $1,245? Because then you, then you have a lot of those bull cases really start to develop. And it'll be interesting if there's a huge sentiment shift in this space.

You know, Charlie really nailed it, and I, I think this is something that has to be on our Yeah, I'm definitely going to be watching those levels that Charlie mentioned.

Erik Townsend: And, you know, it's something I've been saying, gold is going to have its day in the sun and it's going to be a big one. I thought we still had more downside to go, but, you know, even before this week, Patrick, in the last few weeks, we've seen reason that there should have been a breakdown lower in gold and it didn't happen. We talked about that in, I think it was last week, last week's show. And so, you know, we saw resilience where it wasn't expected. Now we're seeing strength where it wasn't expected. So it almost feels like this thing's turning. But as you say, one day does not make a trend. We'll see what happens. Moving on to slide 6, of course, we've got the link here for everyone to register for the free webinar on Sunday, which I highly recommend.

Sign-off

Erik Townsend: With that, we need to leave this show. We hope that we've covered everything that you wanted to hear, folks. It's been a hell of a week.

Thank you, Jeff. week in the markets. Definitely stay tuned for us next week. In the meantime, please help us to promote the show. Tell your friends and colleagues about MacroVoices, and most importantly, register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Only takes a couple minutes. We're not going to spam you. We're not going to sell you anything. We just want to send you our free Research Roundup email each week, which gives you the download links both for this program and for all the best content that we could find on the internet. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Steve. As well, you're going to find the link to the chartbook that we discussed here in the postgame. There's also an article titled A Roadmap to the Upcoming US Treasury Bond Bull Market. And another interesting Morgan Stanley article about this dynamic is The Ultimate Bear Case for Risky Assets. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback. And support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make this program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share their content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests, and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com. MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge.

You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Louis-Vincent Gave — Gavekal co-founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 135 was recorded on October 4th, 2018. I'm Erik Townsend. Our all-star fall lineup continues this week with Gavekal co-founder Louis Vincent Gave joining me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll cover emerging markets, US Treasury yields, gold, and much more. My interview with Louis was taped on Monday afternoon, so we were not aware of Wednesday's Treasury breakout at that time. So be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when MI2 Partners founder Julian Brigden will join us briefly to cover the Treasury yield breakout that occurred on Wednesday and its implications for equity markets. And finally, we'll touch base with Jay Martin from Cambridge House regarding the Gold and Silver Summit in San Francisco.

S&P 500 after Powell and the yield breakout

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 just earlier this week looked like it was winding up for a breakout to 52-week new highs. Everything technically was just looking like it was ready to go. And then comes Powell with his speech. We had the breakout and obviously in yields, and then the market just responded quite negatively. And in less than 24 hours, we found ourselves dropping from 2,940 all the way down to 2,890 on the S&P 500, a solid 50-point drop in short order. We're bouncing off of that right now. We're trading around the 2,907 level. But what's your feeling here? Do you think this is the real deal? Like, is this a meaningful turnaround? What's your take here?

Erik Townsend: You know, I don't think that we can tell yet. Clearly, we saw what could have been the first day of the big crash. It could have also been the day that people had a little bit of a knee-jerk and the dip buyers are going to come in and save the day again. I don't think that we've seen enough of a move. We didn't take out the lows from early September even, which were around 2,875 or so.

So, you know, I don't think this move was big enough to have meaning. Now, certainly, the breakout in Treasury yields resulting in a knee-jerk reaction in equity markets. It's time to pay attention. As I've been saying since Labor Day, this is the time of year when you got to pay attention to the market. But I don't think we've got a decisive signal yet. So I'm watching very carefully to see if there's follow-through. And to my mind, what's most important is not how big the move was today. It's what the follow-through is tomorrow. If we're going to new lows tomorrow and the tape tomorrow looks the way it did today, that would start to persuade me that maybe something is really beginning here. But I don't think we've seen enough to tell us that the move is

Patrick Ceresna: I couldn't agree more, Erik, because one thing that we have seen basically since that April low is that the buy-on-dip traders have come back every time. And so as soon as there's kind of a 50, 60, 70-point dip in the S&P was there, the buy-on-dip traders showed up. I think the one thing that will be the true tell is where all the reason for the buy-on-dip traders to show up and nobody buys. And when that happens and, you know, the music has stopped, that's when something more ominous can happen. But one day doesn't make a new trend.

Dollar index: bullish pattern above 95

Patrick Ceresna: So let's definitely watch that. Let's move on to the dollar index. On the December 2018 contract on the dollar, we are at 95.40, but we really kind of broke out all of those kind of key highs throughout the summer, except for the one false breakout that we had. I mean, the dollar really feels like it's going. I mean, we have that euro testing the 115 handle, almost like it's going to break down.

It's such a curious thing. Is the dollar index going to finally do this move that we've been talking about all year? What's your take here?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think that it is finally going to do it. But, you know, we've said that before and we've been proven early, if not wrong. So, you know, the things that I'm looking at, first of all, there was a pretty decisive head and shoulders pattern in the dollar index that was maybe targeting a 92 or so. We broke down below the neckline, which would normally be your confirmation of a head and shoulders pattern, but it didn't stick. And now we've seen with today's close, that's 3 daily closes in a row above 95. And all indications are, as I look at this chart, that it's a bullish pattern.

And I think if I look at the fundamentals, I really see a very strong argument for those fundamentals continuing. Needless to say, the breakout in bond yields, eventually there, there could be signs that there's dollar weakness associated with that. But the immediate reaction to higher bond yields is going to be dollar positive as more capital is attracted from international investors into higher yielding bonds. Now, if bonds start to crash, that's another story, but we're not looking at that yet.

As I interpret things, we're probably looking for higher, but it seems like every time I say that decisively on this program, we suddenly get a dip lower. We'll see what happens.

Crude oil: the inventory-build tape

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because ever since that head-scratcher number that came out yesterday, inventory and the reaction to it, I was like, I can't wait to get onto the show and ask you what the heck just happened here. I mean, crude oil at this moment is responding a little bit to the downside after the whole market freaked out a little this morning, but what's happening here in crude?

Erik Townsend: Well, yesterday's tape action, as you say, was extremely telling. So let's just go through it. First of all, how did we get there, all the way up to $75 in the first place? I thought that Art Berman made a very persuasive argument for why that rally should have been done at $72, $73 or so. We got all the way up to $75. So there was more strength in the rally than I was able to make sense of, than Art was able to make sense of.

And then what we saw this week with inventory numbers, we got a build on inventory of 8 million barrels. That's massive. It was the biggest inventory build in 19 months, more than a year and a half. Cushing, Oklahoma, building 1.7 million barrels. Gasoline and distillates both drawing down, but very small numbers compared to those massive builds in crude. 459,000 barrels on gasoline, 1.75 million on distillates. The thing is, Patrick, exactly as anyone would expect, the instant that that 8 million barrel build print came out, the market crashed.

Patrick Ceresna: Instantly.

Erik Townsend: Instantly, right back down to its 5-day moving average, which is where you'd expect to see some support. And you would normally expect that it would keep on crashing from there with that really big 8 million barrel build. Patrick, this weakness lasted about 2 or 3 minutes, and all of a sudden the dip buyers were back and they bought that 5-day moving average. And within 40 minutes after the data came out, we were substantially higher than before the data came out. A few minutes later, we were higher than we had been Previously, and we ended up reaching a multi-year high at just shy of $77.

What it says to me is it's a more-than-meets-the-eye market. That's my own terminology for something's going on here. Somebody knows something. Now, obviously, you've got Iran and sanctions, and there's lots of reasons to think that there's bullish geopolitical information, but I don't see any public-knowledge information that explains this move. What it makes me think is going on is the people who didn't have the inside information The ones who did not have it, they were the ones selling in reaction to that massive build. Somebody knew something, and as soon as they saw the market start to stabilize around the 5-day moving average, they started buying. What is it that they know that I don't know? I have no idea. But the only explanation I can come up with to explain this tape action is there's somebody who has some information or is speculating as to something that's going on that I don't see, because I cannot explain the bullishness in the face of such a massively bearish inventory number otherwise.

What's going to happen next? Well, of course, we continued to hang out there at what was already a super elevated price. The fact that the market ended up correcting substantially to the downside today, really, if you look at what's going on with Treasury bonds and equities, it's no surprise. Everything was moving down today. It's going to be very interesting to see what happens if we move to still another high above $77. It's going to persuade me conclusively that somebody knows something I don't, because I I firmly believe that there is no public information available that justifies a move above $77. If there's something that takes us there, it's gonna be somebody who knows inside information that I don't have.

Gold holding $1,200 against a stronger dollar

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold's been consolidating in this range more or less around $1,200. But overall, I'd have to say in the last 5 days, we've seen gold catching a bid. And, you know, there is— it's actually being supported. But what's interesting in the silver markets, we've now broke out to a high that's higher than its September ranges. It seems like precious metals seem to be getting a little bit of action, but yet so many technical levels have not been beat, so we can't get excited about this. What's your thinking? What's the next move for gold here?

Erik Townsend: It's funny, you know, the way you're looking at it, you're looking at the chart and the tape action, you're seeing silver move higher and you're saying silver's bullish. I'm kind of thinking that gold is showing what I'll call extreme resiliency. We're seeing really strong signs on the dollar index chart that the dollar is moving substantially higher and probably is beginning

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: And that's the beginning of a move that could take it a lot higher. You would have expected that to be the signal that would cause the bottom to fall out of the gold market, and it hasn't happened. Gold has been holding strong here at $1,200. It isn't moving up, but it's not moving down either, and there's been plenty of news to suggest that it should move down. Certainly, with respect to gold, as we see higher Treasury yields, at least in the short term, Patrick, that should be bearish for gold, because gold competes with Treasuries in terms of safety trade, as a safe asset.

A lot of people think that Treasuries are just as safe as gold. I disagree with them. I think that's crazy, but a lot of people think that. So, if you see Treasury yields moving higher, that means they're paying even more interest that gold is not paying. That makes them more attractive. Now, eventually, if you see the bond market crashing, where people are afraid that bonds are going to fall off a cliff, now your safety trade is potentially more into gold than into Treasuries. But if you've got slowly increasing yields, it generally would be bearish for gold. Yet again, gold is holding strong at $1,200 here. So it feels to me like gold is much stronger than I expected it.

10-year yield breakout and Juliette Declercq's view

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, 10-year Treasury yields finally broke out that 3.10 area that you've pointed out to us. What's your thinking here on the yields?

Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, we broke and closed dramatically above 3.10 on the yield. I think I had said 3.13, 3.14 maybe was really the number to watch. And we ended up at, I think it was 3.22 on the day. as, as the high yield and close at 3.19 on Wednesday. Meanwhile, we're looking at 3.35 on the 30-year. We are seeing the breakout that everybody's been waiting for. But, you know, I had a chance to check in with Juliette Declercq today. She doesn't think that this move actually has legs. She was already short bonds. She took profits on this move and she's not convinced that it's really on yet. She thinks that the market was reacting to Jay Powell's comments and that it may have been a knee-jerk and she's waiting to She wants to see follow-through before she thinks that a bigger move is on.

Meanwhile, we were able to track down our friend Julian Brigden, who needless to say has been very, very prescient in terms of bond markets. He was one of the first guys to say that this was going to happen and has made a lot of really excellent predictions. So we're gonna have Julian join us in our postgame segment after the feature interview with Louis Vincent Gave to comment on this breakout that we saw this week. But it's a big deal. But I think the question, Patrick, is was this really the beginning of the big one? Was this the big one, or was this that pre-earthquake tremor that tells you the market is getting unstable and it's time to pay close attention, but it's not really going to break yet? I would have thought that there would be more follow-through given how substantially we broke critical levels and closed above them in yield, below them in price.

I would have expected more follow-through on Thursday. What we've seen so far has been a bounce, exactly what Juliette Declercq said to expect when I spoke to her last night before this happened, as she had just taken her profits. So Juliette's called it so far. She thinks it doesn't really have legs, at least not yet. But one thing is for sure, it is time to keep a very close eye on this market.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for the market update, Erik. This week's featured interview guest is Gavekal co-founder Louis Vincent Gave. Please keep in mind that the interview was recorded on Monday afternoon before Treasury bond yields broke out. So Erik's interview with Louis is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Louis-Vincent Gave: EM meltdown, the renminbi and Treasury yields

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Louis Vincent Gave, co-founder of Gavekal Research. Louis, thanks so much. It's great to have you back on the program. And, uh, your dad wrote an interesting piece called The Recession of 2019. We've got a link in our Research Roundup email to that piece.

Some of the things that he One of the things you touched on, I wanted to just discuss with you briefly. Generally speaking, emerging markets, it seems like we've had some really tough times. Is that driven by the rally in the US dollar? And how do you relate it to the situation in Treasuries? Because we've got everybody thinking the Treasury yield is about to explode here. What's going on?

Louis-Vincent Gave: Yeah, no, that's— there's a lot of the pieces in the puzzle that don't quite fit together. The one you just highlighted You know, I've been doing emerging markets for 20 years, and for the first time in my career, we have a situation where over the course of the summer, you have a complete meltdown in emerging markets. You know, Argentina down 50%, Turkey down 50%, South Africa, India, Indonesia, etc., you name it. It was a very ugly summer for emerging markets. And against that, you've had US Treasury yields that instead of falling actually rose. And, you know, obviously, we're about 3% now on the 10-year.

And here I'll be dead honest. You know, if you told me at the beginning of this year, oh, China will be down 20%, Argentina down 50%, etc., I would have said, hey, you can't own enough US Treasuries. But, you know, here we are where actually year to date you're losing money on US Treasuries. You're losing money on US corporate bonds. And so it's not your typical setup. Now, when you look at this disappointing performance from emerging markets, I think that the consensus view has generally been, oh, well, it's because of the strong dollar.

So it's the natural reaction, strong dollar equals weak emerging markets. And frankly, I don't buy it. I don't buy it because the dollar first hasn't been that strong. It's basically, you look at the DXY, it's roughly where it was a year ago. And so yes, you've had a move higher in the past 6 months, but it hasn't been a massive move higher, number one. Number two, I think really what— it wasn't as much a case of dollar strength.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Louis-Vincent Gave: As RMB weakness. And I've written a few pieces about this, but for me, the big shock of the past 3, 4 months was the renminbi falling 10% against the US dollar in a matter of a few weeks in late May, early June, early July, because this had never happened before.

You had never seen China let the renminbi go down so quickly against the US dollar basically since 1995. And so I think this raises a whole number of questions as to, you know, what is China doing? Is China changing the way it's running its currency? Is China signaling to the US that, look, if you want to make this economic, this tariff, this trade war worse, that we, you know, we've got lots of ammunition? You can take this, you know, many potential scenarios, none of which, of course, might be that exciting for emerging markets. And so for me, you know, when I look at the EM meltdown, It's probably less to do with what's happened in the US and a whole lot more to do with what's happened in China. Because the view, while the general media view is emerging markets are a leveraged play on the US dollar, the reality is that today emerging markets are a leveraged play on China.

If you look at the past 10, 12 years, emerging markets have only had short periods of outperformance. They've had massive outperformance in 2009, 2010. And big outperformance in 2016-2017. And both of these periods of outperformance were basically followed massive easing of monetary and fiscal policy by China. So today, I think emerging markets are really a levered play, not on the dollar, but a levered play on on what China is doing.

Now the reality today, of course, is that China is slowing, and the other reality is that the Chinese government is doing fairly little to restimulate the economy. The government feels pretty confident that yes, the economy is slowing, but it's not the end of the world. It's a slowdown that you know we can stomach against this against this background of RMB devaluation against against China slowdown against emerging market slowdown.

The real quandary is indeed U.S. Treasury yields. Why are U.S. Treasury yields going up against a background that should be fundamentally more deflationary for the world? And I think for me, the only answer that makes sense is the US Treasury market is responding not as much to the slowdown unfolding in emerging markets, but to the fact that US debt, US budget deficits are really starting to go through the roof, and that debt issuance in the US is going to be enormous for years to come.

US equities as the lone winner; liquidity and rotation

Erik Townsend: So much financial reporting is focused on US markets and the S&P and so forth. Everybody is obsessed, it seems, with, okay, is the S&P topping? Is it going to come down and so forth? And it's really not clear what's going to happen. Next, but something I've noticed in a lot of the research that you guys do is, you know, maybe it's not clear what's going on with the US, but it's much clearer between emerging markets and Europe. Most other equity markets around the world are really showing signs that they, you know, have rolled over and they're not necessarily crashing, but they're, they're not breaking out to new highs.

Does that mean potentially that what we're seeing is a global topping of equity markets, but some of that flight capital that's going out of other markets is pushing the S&P to maybe one last final high. Is that the phenomenon here? Or why is it that the US market seems to be out of whack with the rest of the world?

Louis-Vincent Gave: I think that is what is happening. You know, one of the charts in my presentation pack right now is a performance review of every major asset class since January 31st. So, you know, we start the year, everything goes up, as sometimes happens in January, all the capital gets put to work, you get a big rally, everybody's happy. But since January 31st, Every single asset class has underperformed US dollar cash apart from US equities. So basically, if you owned anything but US equities since late January, so the past 7 months, 7 or 8 months, you've lost money. And that's true of European equities, it's true of Asian equities, it's true of corporate debt, it's true of emerging market debt, it's true of commodities, so on and so forth. And so yes, you know, an environment I think where you're losing money on every single asset class, I think is an environment that tells you, except for one, that indeed tells you that liquidity is getting tighter. You know, we know that we have several liquidity drains today in the system.

We have, of course, the Fed, which is shrinking its balance sheet. Then we have oil, and oil, by continuing to rise, is a liquidity drain on the system. So just those 2 facts alone means that there's less money floating around the system to push up asset prices, to push up valuations. And yes, amongst this, you have US equities that are increasingly the only beacon of light in an otherwise tough environment for everybody else, but a beacon of light that is also getting more and more concentrated.

If you look at August, August was almost a parody in that respect, in that the world MSCI ex-US

Erik Townsend: Yes.

Louis-Vincent Gave: Was down 3%. The US MSCI was up 2%, but amongst that, Apple was up 20% and Amazon was up 13.5%. The 2 biggest stocks contributed $350 billion in additional market cap for the US. So you've had, you know, within the US, I think, a fairly concentrated rise. And so, you know, within global markets, it's been concentrated on the US, and within the US, it's been concentrated on a few mega-cap, large-cap tech stocks. And healthcare and basically growth stocks. Growth stocks that I think have done well, thanks in part to the flattening of the yield curves that you've seen everywhere around the world. Because, you know, as you get flat yield curves, you can project yourself further and further away. And so you don't, you don't mind buying stocks like Amazon that might be trading at 45 times EV/EBITDA. And so, yes, you know, this has unfolded and it's made the life, I think, of most active managers fairly miserable.

Erik Townsend: If that mechanism is in action, as you said, where what's going on here is global markets are rolling over, people are starting to lose confidence, and they're going into US equities as a safety trade away from other markets, how long can that last? Or what would you expect? Does it necessarily mean that US markets are likely to top after other markets? And is there a lag or a guideline as to what people should expect?

Louis-Vincent Gave: I wouldn't say that, actually. You have many potential avenues of exit here. The first one, of course, is that the enormous divergence we've seen really since mid-May between the US equity markets and global equity markets gets resolved not through US equity markets collapsing, but through European markets rallying, Japanese market rallying, Asian markets rallying. Now, of course, you could say, well, in Europe, you know, we have A lot of uncertainties. Italy, upcoming European elections, which should lead a lot of Eurosceptic parties to perhaps be in majority in the European Parliament for the first time, et cetera. So there are uncertainties around Europe, no doubt. But meanwhile, Japan has now started to break out to new post-1991 highs. So that's another beacon of light that is sort of emerging out there. China also seems, frankly, to be bottoming.

And now that we basically have a NAFTA agreement, that removes a lot of uncertainty surrounding Mexico, surrounding Canada, both of which are cheap markets trading at pretty much historical discounts against the US. So, I think you can make the argument to say, okay, all these cheap markets in Asia, cheap markets in the Americas outside of the US will start to suck up the relative underperformance That got put in in mid-May.

Now, for this to happen, of course, you need probably a fairly benign global macro environment. You need growth to be decent and you need the US dollar to not shoot up. Now, as it turns out, the US dollar, I think, has been under a little more pressure in recent weeks. It tried to break out, failed, and the reality is, in spite of a decently hawkish Fed, You know, a Fed that basically confirmed they've got 4 more tightenings over the coming 12 months. Even in spite of that, the US dollar didn't really break out to new highs. So, you know, I look at this and I think, okay, maybe the environment for some of the beaten-up emerging markets, but also for Japanese equities remains, and also for Canada and Mexico, maybe that's where the returns are going to be for the next 6 months.

Treasuries: deficits, recession risk and risk-reward

Erik Townsend: With that in mind, does that change your view, or how does it affect your view if you think that that maybe things are bottoming. Let's come back to US Treasuries. Should we expect this breakout that everybody's sort of waiting for past 3.10 on the 10-year and, you know, all uphill in yields from here? Or could it be that the bond market is bottoming and that maybe Treasuries are about to rally and we'll come back down in yields?

Louis-Vincent Gave: Well, you know, I don't want to answer your question with another question and do like a Jesuit priest. But here's the shocking thing for You know, a couple weeks ago, Larry Kudlow came out to, you know, to give his review of the US economy. And, you know, very rightly, he highlighted how great the US economy was doing, you know, all-time record consumer confidence, strong ISMs, industrial production, etc., etc. So, you know, there was a lot to report that was, that was extremely positive, very strong GDP print.

And then amidst all this, he was asked, okay, this is great. Where do you see the budget deficit? And his answer was, you know, the budget deficit is going to be between 4 and 5%, basically for as far as the eye can see, but we shouldn't worry about it.

Now, the reality is, if you have a US economy that is booming, that is really growing on all cylinders, and even with that, your budget deficit is, you know, 4 or 5% of GDP, I think the question then becomes, okay, what happens if and when there's a recession. Now, you know, why should there be a recession in the US? Well, the simplest answer to that is you have to look at the things that are already starting to roll over and break simply because of the rise in oil and the rise in, in interest rates. Because we know historically higher oil prices, higher interest rates are typically what breaks the back of any economic expansion. And today we do have higher oil and we do have have higher interest rates. And we are starting to see US housing roll over, and we are starting to see the US auto sector roll over. So basically, the most interest rate sensitive parts of the economy are starting to, you know, to feel the pain.

So you look forward, let's project ourselves 12 months, and you mentioned my dad's piece, The Recession of 2019. You project yourself 12 months and you think, okay, 12 months' time, if the Fed really has gone through its 4 rate increases, Where's housing? Where's autos? Where's overall growth?

Now you can say it's fine, everything is great because animal spirits have been rekindled, because we're deregulating at the same time. So yes, you have this increase in cost, but you have the lower cost of deregulation. And so everything, everything is fine. But even in this everything fine environment, you still end up with 4 or 5% of budget deficits.

So your first option The first option is the economy will be fine because of deregulation. Yes, you'll have higher interest rates, but the higher interest rates get compensated by a bunch of other factors. And so roughly your yields probably end up more or less where we are today.

The second option, the one with a whole lot more uncertainty, is you get your 4 interest rate increases from the Fed. The higher interest rates combined with higher oil price really start to take a bite out of the US economy, and the US economy starts to move towards a recession. And this is, you know, goes back to my dad's piece, The Recession of 2019. And if you get there, the big question is then historically, of course, you'd say, oh, recession, I buy US Treasuries. But of course, here the uncertainty is recession at a time where if you enter into a recession with your budget deficit already at 4, 5% of GDP, by the time you get into recession, your budget deficit is at 10% of GDP.

And the numbers get so big that the question then becomes, who's going to be the big buyer of these US Treasuries? And this gets me to the sort of odd policymakes that you that you have in the US today, where on the one hand you have massive funding needs, and on the other hand you have policymakers that are in essence excuse my French but telling the rest of the world. to bugger off and showing them the middle finger. So in essence, today the US is increasingly dependent on the kindness of foreigners to fund their debts, but the US isn't really treating the rest of the world with much kindness.

So if tomorrow there's a recession, are China, Japan, Indonesia, India, et cetera, going to rush and buy US Treasuries as perhaps was done in the past? Or will China be using this opportunity to perhaps make the point, as they've been trying to do for the past few years, to say, this is now our window of opportunity to de-dollarize Asian trade, de-dollarize the commodity trade, and start moving away from, in essence, this dollar world where the dollar dominates everything towards a more multi-currency world?

So again, I didn't really answer your question. I said, I'm sorry to answer your question. With another question, but in essence, the question on US Treasuries, it comes down to whether you fundamentally believe that the US running budget deficits of 4 or 5% in boom times and 10% in bad times is a stable situation or not.

I tend to believe it's not, so I tend to believe that US Treasuries are actually a dangerous asset class because the risk-reward is just not a very attractive one. If, you know, maybe bond yields can go back down to 2%, but if all of a sudden, you know, that the debt situation starts becoming alarming for investors, bond yields could easily rise to 6% or 7%.

And so with that in mind, the risk-reward for me in US Treasuries is not particularly attractive.

Weaponized dollar, EU workaround and RMB-gold

Erik Townsend: I want to stay on that de-dollarization topic for a minute. You know, something that really, really stood out to me was last week, week, we had the European Union's foreign policy chief standing shoulder to shoulder with the Iranian foreign minister, basically pledging solidarity. The 2 of them standing at the United Nations in New York City, saying that the European Union intends to create a workaround payment system to bypass the SWIFT payment network so that European companies' right to legally conduct Iran Notwithstanding sanctions from the United States imposed unilaterally without UN support, can be effective. So you're in New York City at the United Nations. You've got the foreign policy chief of the EU speaking out against US foreign policy, which they perceive as being completely inappropriate and trying to tell the rest of the world what to do. And, you know, they're fighting back with another payment scheme. My question to you is, you know, clearly that shows that there's some great frustration in Europe with the US attitude toward unilaterally imposing sanctions on a nation like Iran.

My question is, do you think that translates to European investors not buying US Treasuries because of that same frustration, or are they stuck in the no-alternative situation where, yeah, they don't like it, but there's really no viable alternative to the US Treasury as a safe reserve asset?

Louis-Vincent Gave: I think it all depends on your time Over the past really 10 years, but really the past 2 years, I think the US government has been weaponizing the US dollar like never before. And for me, the sort of breaking point moment was when the US government imposed an $8 billion fine on BNP for doing a deal in Sudan. And basically the logic was, you know, the loan you made in Sudan, was priced in US dollars. And so if it's priced in US dollars, we, the US government, have a right to look into it. So I think with that BNP deal of a few— fine of a few years ago, the US basically said anything that happens in US dollars, wherever it might be in the world, you and I do a US dollar transaction in between Canada and China, Well, the U.S. says we're allowed to look into that transaction, and if we don't like it, we'll fine it.

And I think for me that's that was a massive game changer because indeed it does mean for a number of countries that you then have two choices: you have to build a workaround, or you really can't have a foreign policy of your own because whatever the U.S. dollar dictates will have to go. And I think there's a number of countries for which. Which this latter option simply doesn't work. The fact that even the European Union, and let's face it, the European Union and the US are good friends. The fact that even the European Union is now saying, well, this really doesn't work for us, tells you, you know, if that's the case at the European Union, guess what's, you know, what they're thinking in Moscow or what they're thinking in Beijing or what they're thinking in Delhi or in Jakarta, et cetera.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Louis-Vincent Gave: Where they're a lot less sure that the U.S. and and themselves are friends. On this, for me, on this you know de-dollarization of the world, one of the the most interesting developments this year—I don't know if you've looked at this chart—has been the flatlining of the renminbi against gold, which is you know kind of odd because the Chinese government has a pretty good track record of saying what they do and doing what they say.

Now, for years they managed their currency against the US dollar. Then in 2015, they told us, oh, we're not managing against the US dollar anymore. We're managing against a basket. And they even gave us the basket. And you look at 2015, 2016, early 2017, there's fairly little volatility in the renminbi against its basket.

Fast forward to the past 12 months, and all of a sudden you have a whole lot more volatility against the basket.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Louis-Vincent Gave: But at the same time, you're completely flatlining against gold. So it's almost as if all of a sudden China is no longer managing the renminbi against the basket, but managing the renminbi against gold. Now what would be the interest in that?

Well, if China's long-term goal is to de-dollarize Asian trade, you know we know that's the goal. If China's long-term goal is to de-dollarize the commodity trade, and we know that's the goal, you know they've long. Launched the RMB oil future in Shanghai. They're already cutting deals with the like of Russia, with the like of Qatar, with the like of Iran to buy energy in renminbi.

Then fundamentally, over time, for this strategy to work, China really has 2 options. The first is to completely open up capital controls and let foreigners buy and sell whatever assets they want in China, just like foreigners can buy whatever whatever assets they want in the US. That's option 1. Option 2, you know, when you turn to Russia and you say, okay, let's sign a 20-year deal of oil for renminbi, the first question Russia is going to ask is, okay, that's great, but what am I going to do with these renminbi?

China's answer, buy RMB bonds, perhaps doesn't satisfy Russia. And so China turns around and says, well, instead of buying RMB bonds, You can trade your RMB for gold, and I'll make a market there, and I'll ensure a certain level of stability.

Now, I'm not saying that this has happened, but if you're China and if your strategic goal is to de-dollarize Asian trade and de-dollarize commodity trade, doing this through gold would be a very easy way to achieve that goal, and providing a certain stability in the RMB gold price would, would go take you a long way towards there. And sure enough, where are we today? Into a complete flattening of the RMB gold price, which I find very odd.

US and Chinese views of each other; RMB oil futures

Erik Townsend: I have one more question on de-dollarization, then I want to come back to China. I talk to a lot of investors in the United States, and you know, Louis, I'm surprised because I take this de-dollarization thing seriously. It seems to me that China and Russia are both pretty darn serious about doing whatever they to try and persuade the rest of the world to abandon the dollar. I'm shocked that most people don't take it seriously. I take it very seriously.

What are you seeing? Because you, you deal mostly outside of the US. Nobody in the US thinks this is a real issue. Well, whatever, it's just China talking, ignore it. I don't think we should be ignoring it. What are you hearing around the world outside the US?

Louis-Vincent Gave: I want to first start with the US because I think if you spend any time in Washington, whether you talk to journalists or policymakers or bureaucrats, there's a uniformity of views that really I haven't seen since really October 2016, when everybody was dead convinced that Hillary Clinton was going to win. Today, everybody is dead convinced that China is on the verge of imploding, that basically all the US needs to do is push a little bit and China economically will implode. You know, it's a house of cards built on debt, not creating enough value, etc. I mean, you know the whole story. And I think part of the problem is that everything that's happened in the past 5 months will have reinforced that view in that, you know, the US starts talking tough against China, the Chinese stock market goes down 20%, the US stock market goes up 12%, and this will have reinforced the view of everybody in Washington that, you know, China is really in deep, deep economic trouble.

Now, of course, a 20% drop in the Chinese stock market is neither here nor there. It's especially neither here nor there for Chinese policymakers. You know, that kind of thing happens all the time. But most importantly, it doesn't really matter because very few Chinese corporates actually fund themselves or fund their growth through equities. They mostly fund themselves through bank credit.

So the view in the US is China's about to implode.

Meanwhile, if you go to Beijing, the view is that the US is more politically divided than it's ever been, and that as such, the US is really incapable of taking any kind of economic pain. That if and when the next recession comes, you know, the political bickering that will unfold in the US will just basically tear society apart. I'm not saying that this is true. I'm saying that this is the view. I think the prevalent view in China.

Now, the first point I'd make is this is the worst possible setup for any kind of negotiations. You know, if you and I need to strike a deal on, on whatever, and if we're both convinced that each one of us has all the cards and that the other guy has none of the cards, then we're not very unlikely to compromise on anything, right? So the view in China today, I think, is we don't need to compromise in the US because we can wear economic If and when the next global recession comes, we'll wear it. As the Chinese say, we'll chi ku, which means eat bitterness, because you know we're used to that. And meanwhile, the view in the U.S. is if and when the next recession comes, China is going to completely implode.

Now, of these two things, and perhaps because I spend more time there, I'm more inclined to the Chinese view. I'm more inclined to the view that China can wear pain and the U.S. can't. And I'm not inclined to the view that China is about to implode.

And so to the point you were making, I do think that the likelihood that you know China is going to continue being very aggressive with this de-dollarization push is I mean that's going to continue for for months, quarters, and years to come. If only for the simple reason that for China, de-dollarizing Asian trade, de-dollarizing the commodity trade has now become a national security imperative. You know, today, what is the US doing? They're basically telling China, we don't want to run a trade deficit with you anymore. And, you know, that's fine, but that basically means we don't want to give you dollars anymore. Now, if you're China, you think, well, hold on, I need dollars to buy my oil. I need dollars to buy soybeans. I need dollars to buy copper. And if you don't want to give them to me anymore, how am I going to buy those things? Well, the only possible answer, of course, is I've We've got to change the way those things are priced.

Hence the launch of the RMB oil futures in Shanghai last March.

Now, this RMB oil futures, which, you know, came out of nowhere, launched in March of this year, already accounts for 14%. That's 1-4, 14% of the oil futures traded volumes from nowhere 6 months ago. It's a very impressive launch to capture 14% of one of the biggest commodity markets in the in the space of 6 months tells you, I think, how deeply, deeply serious China is about all this.

The Dissolution of Chimerica and an inflationary Cold War

Erik Townsend: Let's stay on the subject of China. You recently wrote a piece. We have a link in the Research Roundup email for our listeners. This is normally a research piece that's only available to your clients, but you were kind enough to share it with our listeners. It's titled The Dissolution of Chimerica. Give us an overview of what our listeners can expect from that piece, and how does it fit into this conversation?

Louis-Vincent Gave: Well, look, I think for most of my career, and in fact for most of my life— I was born in the early '70s— I think the policy of the Western world has been really to embrace China since basically Nixon flew over to Beijing to meet with Mao. The policy has been to embrace China and in essence bring it from the cold. And the view was that the more trade we do with China, the more we integrate our supply chains, then China will evolve. And just like South Korea moved from being a dictatorship to a democracy, and just like Taiwan moved from being a dictatorship to democracy, China will evolve in the same way. And at some point they'll become a member of the club. And I think this was very much the Western policy, probably until this year's 19th People's Congress, because at this year's 19th People's Congress, Xi Jinping came out and he came out with 2 very forceful policies.

The first was the One Belt One Road, which is very much an imperialist view of China's role in the world. You know, the One Belt One Road is we're basically going to tie up all of Asian economies all the way to Africa, all the way to Western Europe and Central Asia. We're going to tie all these economies into our own. You know, fundamentally, the history of every empire boils down to a road-building exercise. You know, empires want to build roads to bring in commodities cheaply. Deeper to the heart of the empire and push out finished goods to the outer realms. That's why in Europe we say all roads lead to Rome. Well, for Xi Jinping in the 21st century, all roads lead to Beijing. So the first thing that happened in the 19th People's Congress was Xi Jinping came out and said, we're going to basically tie in all these economies into our own.

And then the second thing he said, having done that, we're going to move up the value chain in terms of of the goods that we sell. So by 2025, and this was the Made in China 2025 policy, by 2025, we're going to be a world leader in semiconductors. We're going to be a world leader in artificial intelligence and in fintech and in satellites and in building airplanes, etc. Now, 5 years ago, China had come out and said by 2025, we're going to be leaders in artificial intelligence and fintech. People would have laughed.

But now, of course, nobody's laughing because they might already be there.

And I think it was these two policies that all of a sudden triggered a shift of thinking in Washington about China in general. And so what you've had in Washington now, I think, is a sort of union of different people who look at China no longer as a big opportunity or as a big market, but potentially as a threat.

Not least of which, of course, were America's big corporates themselves. Because, you know, for decades, the biggest pro-China lobbyists in Washington were all the big corporates. You know, as soon as somebody started to bash China, you could count on Boeing or John Deere or Caterpillar or Walmart to pick up the phone and say, hey, maybe you tone it down a little. You know, we do make a lot of money back there. But of course, if China comes out and says, hey, by 2025, you know, we're going to be producing our own jet planes, if you're Boeing, And you think, hold on, you're supposed to be my customer. You're not supposed to be my competitor.

And so all of a sudden, I think there was a sort of paradigm shift, a big shift in the way people perceive China. So combine that with all the national defense types, the John Boltons, the, you know, the CIA, the Department of Defense, et cetera, who are not so keen on China's imperialist ambitions.

All of a sudden, the view has become, instead of integrating our supply chains with China, we need to disintegrate our supply chains. And so that's why I think that behind all this rhetoric of the trade war, there's actually— the real threat is really sort of new economic Cold War, where, you know, after 20, 30 years of integration, we now look to basically break apart all the supply chains that were established for so many years.

Erik Townsend: You know, Louis, I'm just a small businessman. Maybe I don't understand high finance, but in my line of We usually looked for an alternative before we burned any bridges to suppliers. Who are we going to buy all the cheap stuff from if we disintegrate our supply lines with China? I mean, it's a serious question. What is the United States going to do as an alternative for all of the cheap goods and services that it sources from China, which is a lot?

Louis-Vincent Gave: Well, see, this is where I think the— this goes back to what I was saying earlier about how there on the one hand is US foreign policy, on the other there's the economic reality underlying in the United States. Today, I think the US foreign policy is fundamentally inflationary. You start tearing apart all these supply chains, to your point, you know, it's going to be very hard to reproduce elsewhere. You can't really reproduce them in the US. In the US, you already have a very tight labor market. You'll be able to do some in Mexico, perhaps some in Canada as well, which is why why, you know, signing this NAFTA thing was especially important. And by the way, to me, I look at the fact that NAFTA has now been signed as a way for the US to now be tougher on China instead of kinder to China.

So some of it can move to Canada, some of it can move to Mexico, some of it can move to the US. But beyond that, I think we have to accept that, you know, this— the foreign policy, this economic Cold War with China would be inflationary. If it does unfold, it will be inflationary. And if it is inflationary, that should lead to higher yields, higher yields at a time when government debt is already going through the roof. And here, just, you know, a little factoid for you, but in August of this year, for the first time ever, US tax receipts were not enough to pay for interest payments plus all your social entitlements.

So forget infrastructure, forget military spending, forget the government payroll, forget all these things. The US is now at a point where tax receipts cover interest payments plus entitlement spending, and that's it. And so if you follow a policy that is fundamentally inflationary at the back end, then you can probably assume that your interest payments are going to go up. And so I think that's where, for me, there's a sort of dislocation. between the foreign policy and the economic reality, the underlying economic reality in the US.

Gold outlook and two reasons to own it

Erik Townsend: Louis, I want to come back to gold. You mentioned something that we've certainly observed for many weeks on this program, that there has been an uncanny correlation, as you put it, a flatlining where gold is trading in sympathy with the Chinese RMB. You talked a little bit about why that might be happening, but let's talk about the outlook for gold itself, because we've had some radically different views. On one hand, people, you know, If you're dollar bullish, you ought to be gold bearish. On the other hand, a lot of people are thinking with this de-dollarization stuff, you know, maybe that's a catalyst that really says that flight capital is going to start to move into gold and not into US Treasuries. What's your outlook for gold and precious metals generally?

Louis-Vincent Gave: Well, let me preface this by saying that I came into this year with the view that if ever there was an accident on the markets, then the Fed would ease up policy. And thus the best hedge on any potential market meltdown was probably to own some gold and some gold miners. Now, as you well know, gold miners got absolutely smoked this summer in spite of the fact that we did have a financial accident, but the financial accident was in emerging markets. It wasn't on the US.

So I think for now, gold is still sort of trading on the view that, well, as the Fed tightens, You know, what's really the point of owning gold? And so you can say, well, the point of owning gold is when the market changes its mind about the Fed tightening, then everything— US dollar will collapse, gold will shoot up.

And so the first thing is gold remains a decent hedge against a financial accident, but really only a financial accident in the US, because as the Fed has shown, if the financial accident happens elsewhere, then the Fed doesn't care. Care. So I think that the first thing is you can own gold as a hedge against a financial market accident in the US, a market accident that would be big enough to lead to a shift in thinking at the Fed.

The second reason you own gold today is if, like me, you believe that China is on the path to de-dollarize, and if you think that there's some odds that China will be successful in this course, you know, if you think, okay, Okay, well, I think it's pretty obvious that China wants to de-dollarize Asian trade, that it wants to de-dollarize commodity trade. For me, there's at least a 50% chance that they are successful. And the fact that, you know, US fiscal policy today is so loose only helps China in that quest over time. So these are the 2 good reasons to own gold.

Now, right now, of course, as US equity markets make new highs, neither of these reasons seem to be making a case for gold immediately today. But these things, again, these things can, can change decently quickly. And so I own some gold, even if it has been extremely disappointing, no doubt, this year to date.

What Gavekal Research offers

Erik Townsend: Louis, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. But before we go, I want to talk a little bit about what you do at Gavekal Research. We do have more than half of our listener audience is institutional. I know you are an institutional research firm. We've got a sample of one of your daily research notes, which was the Chimerica piece. Again, you'll find the link, folks, in your Research Roundup email. Beyond that sample, tell us a little bit more about what you do and what services you offer at Gavekal.

Louis-Vincent Gave: Oh, sure. So we provide independent research for institutional investors. So we have a global macro product, we have a China macro product, we have a China corporate due diligence product for people who do We do a lot of deals in China. The best way to find out about what we do is probably to go through our website, which is Gavekal.com, G-A-V-E-K-A-L.com. And there should be plenty of info there. And if there's not enough, you can contact us through the website.

Erik Townsend: Well, Louis, thanks so much for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to Your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction to the interview

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Louis. It really made an impression on me when he was talking about the fact that the 10-year was not reacting to the breakdown in emerging markets. And I'm in the same camp as him. I was really looking at that breakdown in emerging markets and how everything was kind of falling apart. The safe haven trade of bonds was something that I really felt had a real shot at working. And literally, we're seeing absolutely no response from the bond market to what is a continuing and worsening situation in emerging markets. So it's going to be a really interesting thing to see how this continues to develop. What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Yeah, and I guess the other way that you could turn that around is you could say, let's assume that as people are freaking out in emerging markets, that there has been some cash flow into US Treasuries as a safety trade. Let's assume that that really did occur, as it almost has to under these circumstances. Well, guess what? It wasn't enough to push yields lower. In fact, yields are still moving higher despite the fact that that probably is happening. That was the way I interpreted that one. And what it really says to me, you know, Patrick, we are in an environment right now where major correlation relationships in markets that people have known for years and years and years always work in certain ways aren't working the way they usually do. It says to me that we are on the cusp of a major change in In the macro backdrop, in terms of the big picture of what is driving the global economy and what's happening.

Does that mean necessarily, okay, that's, you know, a signal that there's a huge recession coming or something? I don't know yet. I'm trying to figure it out. But it's very clear to me that we are on the cusp of major sea change kind

Julian Brigden: 30-year yield trend change

Erik Townsend: of moves in the market.

Patrick, I want to come back to the question of what's going on with this breakout or apparent breakout in Treasury yields. We have Julian Brigden, founder of MI2 Partners, and of course, very outspoken commentator Julian Brigden, who has been a frequent commentator in our past interviews on the subject of bond yields.

Julian, thanks so much for joining us. You've told us before, boy, if you saw a monthly close over 3.25% on the 30-year, that would be a 30-year change in trend. Now, we haven't had the monthly close yet, but we are well above 3.25%, and it looks like we're headed there. Meanwhile, we've got a new high in yield on the 10-year. A lot of people yesterday, when we saw that closing print, were saying, okay, That's it. The bond market crash has begun. But, you know, the follow-through today on Thursday really looks like we're bouncing so far. So what do you think's going on? Was this a false signal? Do we, do we have a bond market crash that's starting or what's happening?

Julian Brigden: Hi, Erik, and welcome to everyone. Look, I would say there was a couple of things that we were watching. One of them was a moving average, which was the 100-month moving average in 30-year yields. And in actual fact, we closed above that last Friday because it's been moving down since we last spoke. And I think it came in my head just around 315. So actually just quite bitterly wobbling last week. We did actually get a monthly close above that. So that is the first time that we've had a monthly close above that trend line since the mid-'80s.

Tested it once in '94, opened above it but never closed. Above. And as you remember, that was a pretty bad year for the bond market. So this is the first technical close. 3.25, I think, becomes important on the 30-year yield because it's the neckline of a big inverse head and shoulders.

And I think that's why you had people like Bill Gross and Gundlach also talking about that and tweeting about that, as indeed we did on our Twitter feeds. Have we definitively broken it? Look, The only way I think that we close below it is if you actually end up crushing the equity market. And to me, that is not my base case. I think some stocks, particularly the FAANGs, are very, very sensitive to the curve. In fact, if you go and look at the curve of 2s, 10s since over the last 18 months, it's almost perfectly negatively correlated to the FAANGs. So a steepening curve is definitely a danger to the equity market. But I'm not sure it's momentum given the underlying strong economics that would rip the crash of the market just yet. I think you're probably ready to see probably more rotation into some of these other sectors.

So I think there's a very decent chance. I'd like to see a monthly close above 325. But I think there's a very decent chance that we've started a broad up move. Technically, if you look at that inverse head and shoulders in 30 years or you look at the technical picture on the term risk premium of 10 years, Telling you 4.5%. Now, we're not going to be there straight away. It's not going to be a linear line. That's going to obviously put a huge amount of pressure on the economy. It could take many years. But, you know, I'm sticking with what I ultimately said back in the summer of 2016, that we put the lows in, in Treasury yields, and we are now moving inexorably over the next many years into a higher bond yield environment.

Brigden: bear steepener and the Fed

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Julian, I just wanted to ask you specifically about the actual credit spreads, because one of the reactions to the John

Julian Brigden: Yeah.

Patrick Ceresna: And I think the big jump in the 30-year was the fact that we saw this bear steepening right across the board. And like, for instance, the difference between the 2s and 10s jumped from, you know, the 20, 25 basis point range to now just over 31 basis points. And so, we have the steepening. Now, the steepening, is this in your mind just an impulse reaction, or do you think that this is a bigger trend that may actually see the trend change and a steepening thing is now Is this now something that can happen for the remainder of the year?

Julian Brigden: So here's the thing. I mean, look, you've had a Fed that's been playing, I think, very loose and dangerous with the economy. Steepening should happen as the Fed allows itself to get further and further behind the curve, unless we go from a bear steepener where the long end is selling off to a bull steepener where you've crashed the equity market and everyone moves to price out high The 2-year sector, broadly speaking, at the moment we have that bear steepener as long end sells off. Now, depending on the data will depend on how the Fed reacts. Powell has made it very clear to people that he isn't stopping. And I think this was one of the misinterpretations that the market had, that somehow we were going to stop and then they weren't going to go anymore and then the equity market could take off.

And of course, this is the fundamental problem that the Fed financial conditions broad metric, and if you look at financial conditions, that includes the short-term rates, long-term rates, credit, and stocks. Credit and stocks have been ignoring what the Fed has been doing for a very, very long period. So I'm not sure that we're going to get an extended steepening of the curve just yet. Actually, what we've been looking at is swaps curve for our institutional investors. If you go and look at the 2s, 10s, swaps, they actually tend to lead the curve and they're not yet steepening that much. I'm not totally convinced that we've got a real big steep move on. I'm also thinking, look, it doesn't mean it doesn't go 25 basis points or something, and we get to say 52s, 10s or something like that, but ultimately, there's a lot of real money that's just going to keep piling into that and continue to flatten out.

As long as the economy doesn't tip over and we move from that bear steepener to a bull steepener, as 2-year yields collapse because equities have dropped, I think broadly speaking we're still in a flattening environment or a flattish environment.

And this is just an interlude for the moment because I think the Fed has to raise rates, guys. But if you look at some of the data we've been getting from ISM, the Markit surveys, we're getting jobs growth in the service sector which has commenced 300,000-plus number. Now, do we not get it because of the hurricane? And in which case, we get it again— we get it next month. But we have an economy that's truly on fire. And there's a limit, I think, to how far the Fed can let this thing run hot. And I think we're getting to that inflection point. So I do expect the Fed to be a little bit more aggressive. And I think hopefully they'll hold the curve from backing up too much.

Brigden: equity implications and rotation

Erik Townsend: Julian, let's come back to the equity market implications. Of course, on Thursday— well, Wednesday we had the breakout in yields. The reaction or apparent reaction on Thursday was equity markets really taking a dive. But just in the last hour or so, we got down to 2888 or so on S&P futures. We're speaking right now just about a minute before the cash close and we're bouncing very nicely up to 2905. It almost looks like the buy the dip crowd showed up. So is, is this the beginning Are we setting up a huge move to the downside, or could it be that it's over?

Julian Brigden: No, I mean, I think you get a lot of rotation here. The reason why bond yields are breaking out to some extent is they've been suppressed by all this central bank flow, the ECB, in particular the ECB, but the ECB is moving gradually to end the QE program, which should stop some of the money that's been flowing from Europe into the US as bond yields start to rise.

You should start to see some of the— as long as the economy remains strong, you should start to see rotation in other sectors. Think that all the running has been made by these sort of very high beta FAANG stocks. Those are very sensitive to the curve because almost calling them growth stocks is almost an oxymoron. They tend to do well when growth elsewhere is actually weak. Elsewhere, we have strong wage growth. There are other better super cheap stocks that you should be buying.

So I do think that it's possible, Erik, we get some sort of rotation into, you know, financials, let's say signals and things like this. And the equity market, while I'd be very surprised to see in a rising bond yield environment the equity market not under some pressure, is this the collapse? I don't think so yet. In a way, that gives the bond market more room to run in this sell-off.

Brigden: trades (FAANG shorts, EM, dollar)

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Julian, let's put this all together. How are you trading this? What's the big trade here? I mean, are you trading this with just straight long or shorts, or are you putting this on as a steepening trade? What are you doing here?

Julian Brigden: So at this point, unemphatically, very bearish. And we wrote a few— 2, 3 weeks ago for our institutional clients that we were creeping up to these very big levels in the US bond market and in the global bond markets. So we've been pressurizing the long end of the trade. I mean, right here, right now, do you jump in and try and short the long end of the bond market? I'm not sure. I mean, the risk-reward is a lot lower. It doesn't mean that I don't think it's going higher. Yeah. Higher yields, but the risk reward is a little bit skewed. On the back of what we just discussed, the sort of FAANGs and the relationship to the curve, I do think there are some quite vulnerable potentially US equities, single names that I don't like.

So, for example, and this is purely just on a technical basis, I've been looking at Netflix as what we would call a classic bubble. You know, at these sort of levels, failing up here would be a very bad sign. The same is true of Amazon. I mean, these— I think, you know, for your clients who read Barron's, Abelson really summed this up, I think, brilliantly a couple of weeks ago where he talked about, you know, in an environment where we get rising costs of capital and rising rates and yields, the policy of a lot of these FAANGs to burn through either, you know, free investors' equity cash or borrow money becomes, quote, less salubrious. And so I think that's exactly the risk for some of these names. So some of these look really quite interesting shorts potentially to me at this point in a rising yield environment.

Then there's the emerging market space. A tightening of emerging market financial conditions is very bad news for some of these EM trades. And I think a lot of people have been very tempted to rush in and buy these dips. I mean, we've been conditioned since '08 to buy every dip, right? You switch on CNBC, the guys are like, buy every dip, buy every dip, buy every dip. This is not, for me, one of those points where you buy the damn dip, particularly in emerging markets. And I think there's still an awful lot of cash in them. And I think these could get really, truly tarred and feathered. I'm beginning to get worried about Korea. Korean equities and Taiwanese equities and even Indian equities, which I think structurally are fantastic trade, but technically are beginning to look very dodgy.

I think those are some potential interest opportunities.

Then finally, it comes back to the dollar. If this rise in yields truly turns us into a risk-off environment, then I'm very worried about the dollar, because I think, and I've been quoted, and I was quoted by you, Erik, as saying The last stage, I think, of any risk-off move would be a big risk-off dollar rally, which just basically becomes effectively the napalm run at end of a war movie. All you're left with is a smoking hole and a bunch of charred bodies.

To me, that would be the final— if we get to that point, that would be the final leg of that move. Ultimately, then the Fed is forced to step in, albeit late. So I think there's some quite interesting trades to start watching that are going to be led by the bond market and led by, you know, potentially 2-year yields, but a better risk-reward than the bond market itself at this point.

Recap: Declercq and Brigden

Erik Townsend: Well, Julian, I can't thank you enough for taking time out of your busy client schedule for us. We hadn't planned this one, but given news in the markets, we really wanted to get you on the program. Patrick is working with your staff to get you back before the end of the year for a full-length feature interview where we can get the benefit of one of your famous chartbooks. So, we're really looking forward to that. Thanks so much for joining us today.

Julian Brigden: Gentlemen, thank you very much for having me on the show.

Patrick Ceresna: Fantastic. Thanks, Julian.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, you know, I always love getting Julian Brigden's view. The guy is absolutely brilliant. I think it's really interesting, and what I'm seeing is a lot of people kind of thinking the same way, and it goes back to some of your comments. earlier in the program. It sounds like, if I summarize what I got from Juliette Declercq, she's saying, yeah, this, this is definitely interesting, but it's not quite time to panic. Juliette actually took profits on her bond shorts because she knew there was a bounce coming. And sure enough, we're seeing that bounce today. I look forward to finding out from Juliette what she's doing next. Meanwhile, I think that Julian Brigden is giving us a very similar theme, which is, yeah, you know, something Something big is afoot, but it doesn't necessarily mean the crash in the bond market is beginning just yet. It means that something is afoot, and we shouldn't read too much into it.

In any event, we received a number of inquiries after we announced last week that Patrick Ceresna is going to be speaking at the Silver and Gold Summit.

Jay Martin: Silver and Gold Summit and listener discount

Erik Townsend: We had a number of people ask us, Silver and Gold Summit, what's that? So, Jay Martin, President and CEO of Cambridge House, the organizer of the Silver and Gold Summit, Jay, please tell our listeners, what is the Silver and Gold Summit? What is the theme of the show this year? And in addition to our own Patrick Ceresna, who I'm sure will be the best speaker, who else do you have lined up on the program?

Jay Martin: Yeah, thanks so much. So the Silver and Gold Summit is a conference that we've been hosting in San Francisco for 5 years now, and the purpose of this conference is to educate investors who are interested in the precious metals or the natural resource sector. The show's changed a lot in the last five years. You know, we launched this show in San Fran pretty much strictly as a silver and gold investment conference, and over the last five years, and especially this year, the focus has shifted. We still have a ton of precious metals content and companies, but investors that come today are very interested in the energy sector. We have a couple of major features on renewable energy and traditional energy sectors, and battery technology, energy storage. So all the critical. Metals that are involved in creating this technology are a massive focus at this event.

Erik Townsend: Jay, this event is going to be held in San Francisco October 28th and 29th. I know some of this is a trade show. I usually find when I go to a trade show, once I've seen the booths, I've seen the booths. But you've also got quite a few speakers. Who else besides Patrick is there? And is it worth people's time to plan to attend both days, or is it one of these one days and you've covered it kind of things?

Jay Martin: No, it's equally valuable both days. And yeah, we pride ourselves on being content first. So there's a trade show marketplace where there will be about 70 companies exhibiting. But in the speaker hall, our main theater, and in our 3 workshops around the event, we're showcasing another 80 keynote speakers throughout the 2 days.

And the major themes are industrial uses for silver, for battery technology, energy sources. We bring in the heaviest weight natural resource investment speakers that are in the business. People like Marin Katusa of Katusa Research, Rick Rule from Sprott US Holdings, Doug Casey from Casey Research. He's a legend in the business. Over the course of 2 days, we've got over 80 speakers, panel discussions, Q&As, fireside chats, and debates occurring.

Erik Townsend: And Jay, for people who are able to attend October 28th and 29th, they can register online at CambridgeHouse.com. Use the promotion code macro in order to get an additional 30% off. There's already an early bird special that's good through the 12th of October, and there's a higher price after that. But either way, you can get 30% off of the advertised price using the discount code macro. Jay, thanks so much for coming and telling us about the program. Before we sign off though for the week, we understand there's also a reception. On the 27th. Tell us what that's about.

Jay Martin: Yeah, great. So it's available to all registered investors at the conference. The show itself is October 28th and 29th, but we open up with a party on the 27th of October. And this is actually a Hall of Fame inductee ceremony. This year we're inducting Rick Rule into the Natural Resource Hall of Fame. And so for all investors at the conference, it's open invitation, it's open bar. All of our keynote speakers will be there. So it's a great place to mix and mingle. And, uh, we hope to see all of your listeners there.

Outro and Research Roundup preview

Erik Townsend: Jay, thanks so much for joining us on the program. We really appreciate your help. Listeners, we need your help promoting MacroVoices, so please forward your Research Roundup emails, tell your friends and colleagues, and most importantly, register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Only takes a few minutes, and the benefit to you is that you'll receive our free Research Roundup email each week, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just a compendium of links to all of the best content that we could find on the internet in support of this program, as well as just interesting research. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, as always, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Louis, as well as links to a number of articles that Louis was kind enough to provide us with for some of his daily outlooks on what's going on in the markets and direction of the dollar and so on. There's also interesting article discussing Marko Kolanovic's concerns about the Fed is raising the risks of a policy error. There's also another interesting article that I shared in there from the Financial Post talking about the Canadian economy facing a deep-rooted problem as wages stagnate and household debts mount. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup.

So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support We get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, do not assume any responsibility for any is brought to you by MacroVoices. Erik Townsend losses incurred by participants. and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Keith Dicker — IceCap Asset Management Chief Investment Officer (as introduced on the show)

Announcer open

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 134 was recorded on September 27th, 2018. I'm Erik Townsend. IceCap Asset Management Chief Investment Officer Keith Dicker joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Keith thinks we're headed for an epic bond market crisis and has some surprising predictions for other asset classes. Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will discuss recent articles by Marko Kolanovic and Chris Cole. We'll also have a quick update for you on our live event plans.

S&P 500: topping process like summer 2007

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's talk about the S&P 500 because the stock market obviously rallied into last week. And then as that dealer gamma roll-off that we talked about came in and then we go into the Wednesday Fed, we obviously had almost a 50-point pullback in the S&P. Yet today it seems like it's breaking out again.

All the characteristics of a typical market correction and the buy-on-dip traders coming in. Is this all we're seeing again? What's your bias here on the S&P.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I do agree with that from a shorter timeframe. From a larger timeframe, you know, this feels to me like the summer of 2007, Patrick. Not '08, '07. And I definitely think that we've begun a topping pattern. It's so tempting to say, wait a minute, wait a minute, the smartest guys in the room are all saying it's, you know, it's, it's the end is nigh, it's, that's it. The smartest guys were all saying that in the spring and summer of 2007 too. It was very clear when subprime started falling apart that something really big was foot. But the thing is, it took a while for it to really play out in markets.

So I do think that we are in a major important topping process. But it's entirely possible that we could have, you know, 200 or 300 more points to the upside. We could be 3,250 on the S&P before the final top is in and have this still be part of a topping process. Could be the top is already in. But frankly, I doubt it. I think we've got higher to go from here.

Dollar index back above 94.5

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the dollar index because overnight we got a pretty strong reversal pattern. I mean, we were under 94 on the dollar index for a little while and a big surge, particularly coming on a very weak euro here. Do you think that that's it for the dollar index?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as you say, we're back up over 94.5. The December contract, I'm looking at 94.505 on my screen on Thursday afternoon. And we have to remember that there was backwardation between the September and December contracts, what that means is this 94.5 is really the old 95 level. So it's as if on the old number scale we had broken back above 95 again, which was that key resistance level. Maybe that could be the beginning of something really big to the upside. Now, as bullish as my longer-term outlook has been, I've actually been surprised that we've seen this much strength. I would have thought that it would have stopped short of here, and I was kind of thinking, you know, even Charlie McElligott had a 90 He had a 92 target on one of his daily updates this week, and that was before the Fed hike, so it was before the most recent news that we now have available. But, you know, there was a head and shoulders pattern that was very clear there.

Lots of good reason to think that we might be headed lower on the dollar before going higher. Now we seem to be going higher sooner. I don't know how long it lasts, Patrick. My bias is still bullish in the longer term, but as I've said before, I thought there was plenty of room to see a sell-off here, even for the next several weeks, before it eventually moved higher.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: Now we seem to be seeing a move higher starting already. I wonder if that might be short-lived. We'll take a look at it next week.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I couldn't agree more because really the whole narrative of a big October push higher, particularly in the cyclicals, in my mind was going to be on the idea that the dollar remains in consolidation. If the dollar's ripping higher here, that kind of redraws a lot of the storylines on, on all the intermarket relationships. But we'll keep an eye on that for sure.

Crude oil: inventories, WTI resistance, Brent breakout

Patrick Ceresna: Nonetheless, let's move on to the crude oil market. Let's start off with the inventory. How did things come in?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we saw a surprise build of 1.9 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma building 461,000 barrels. Gasoline building 1.6 million barrels. Distillates drawing down 2.2 million barrels. Production, meanwhile, ticked up. And remember that the production numbers are almost meaningless because they're rounding them to the nearest 100,000 barrels. But the point is where we had sort of seen a downtick and people thought, oh my gosh, maybe that, that increase in production has finally come to an end. Well, now it's gone back up. We're at a new high of 11.1 million barrels. 1 million barrels. So the increase in US production, that trend is still intact. I think right now where we are in terms of price, Patrick, is we're wedged between the 5-day moving average, which as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon is at $71.74. That's sloping upward very quickly as the price has changed. And there's a key R2 resistance level at $72.68.

I had been tempted When we tested that R2 resistance at $72.68 in the last couple days, I was tempted to short it, but you know, with all of the hurricane season, and frankly, Patrick, I think the, the weather is even more stormy on Twitter, where Mr.

Trump, the tweeter-in-chief, has been kind of doing battle with OPEC over oil prices. I think that there's always room for a spike higher in price. So I chickened out of the short, but I really think in a lot of ways that that $72.68 level ought to contain this rally unless something else changes.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: Just like the weather. And that could be political weather or hurricane season weather.

We'll see what happens. But for now, I'm on the sidelines.

Patrick Ceresna: It is interesting, though, that Brent has cleared $80. And even in spite of that talk from Saudi Arabia, we haven't seen much of a throwback on that at all. So like a full breakout to new highs there really feels like it could drag WTI up higher.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, you know, and that goes back to what we discussed with Art Berman is in many ways, the WTI chart looks done here. me, the Brent chart actually still looks bullish. Well, they can't both, you know, have opposite directions. The spread can't widen forever. So which one's gonna be proven right? I guess we'll see. My comments about where the resistance looks like it should occur really were based on looking at the WTI chart, and I agree with you, the Brent chart tells a more bullish story. So it's gonna be very interesting to see what happens.

Gold below $1,200 and the dollar

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's talk gold, because, you know, it looked like gold was finally consolidating, maybe even could potentially base. But as soon as the The Fed meeting finished and the dollar popped. Gold right back below $1,200 again. What's going on here? What's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: Well, the move down in gold, and we're looking at $1,188 as we're speaking Thursday afternoon, came as no surprise whatsoever because it's all about the dollar. We saw the pop up in the dollar, and if the dollar continues to move up, gold's going to continue to move down. The thing is, I'm really wondering if this pop in the dollar has any staying power. Maybe there's something I'm not aware of yet, but as I saw it, there was a lot of So, that's one of the reasons for even a dollar bull like myself to be thinking, hmm, we might be in a consolidation to distribution phase here where maybe we're gonna move a bit lower on the dollar before it finally turns around and moves higher. So, if we still see that move lower on the dollar, there's room for gold to pop here, and that would mean right here, right now, this is your opportunity.

We have only seen gold lower for one day, I think, you know, in the last year and a half, than it is right now.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: Now on Thursday afternoon. And of course, that day was just back in August when we saw that move all the way down to $1,165 or so. So, it could be that this is your opportunity. The thing is, I'm surprised by this strength in the dollar. If it continues, you know, it's going to be a sad story for gold. So, I would stay on the sidelines. I do think, in many ways, that gold is really going to have a huge run to the upside when it's time. And we're going to get into this in today's interview with Keith, and it'll be a fascinating conversation because you can make the argument that gold's headed to $800 and you can make the argument that gold's headed to $8,000. I think it is headed to $8,000. It just might be headed to $800 first. So, I really don't have a strong opinion here, but I think there's plenty of room, if this dollar pop is short-lived, for this to be at least a short-term buying opportunity for people with a shorter time horizon.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, I want to come back to this in the postgame because Marko Kolanovic had a really interesting comment on this in a recent piece that he did. And I think his insights on gold are pretty interesting.

10-year yield fails at 3.10 after the Fed

Patrick Ceresna: So we'll get back to that in the postgame. Let's move on to 10-year Treasury yields because we were literally at the edge of the cliff. We were at 3.10 on the yield and we were just waiting to find out what happened with the Fed. And after the Fed announcement, we come off of there where I think around the 3.05 level now on the yield. Do you think that that becomes now an overhead resistance? I mean, one day doesn't make a new trend. We have a little more information to find out, but what's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: Yeah. Well, as you know, Patrick, this is the way resistance levels work. They tease you. They play with your emotions. It's like, oh, it's gonna break, it's gonna break, it's gonna break. It was coming up into the Fed meeting that everybody was teetering on the edge, waiting for that breakout to occur on the news. And I think it was a buy the rumor, sell the news event. People were anticipating maybe the Fed hike was gonna be the thing that did it. I don't think there's a really good reason to anticipate that outcome because this Fed hike was widely anticipated. There were no big surprises here. So the The fact that we hit the resistance level is no surprise, and hey, resistance is working as resistance. We didn't move and close over 3.10, and really, I think you'd have to say 3.14 would be the number to close over in order to get an upward signal, which of course would be a sell signal on the bonds because they move inversely with the direction of the yield.

In any case, it ain't over till it's over. Right now what we've seen is a failed test of resistance. We're back down to where we were trading a week ago. I think it's a big question to see what happens Not only with the 10-year, but also, as Julian Brigden mentioned on our show several months ago, I'm very curious to see, you know, month end is coming up just tomorrow. What if we saw a move up in yield that took the 30-year back above 3.25%, which is Julian Brigden's call for on a closing basis as a game changer that would change a 30-year trend in the bond market?

Live events: Silver and Gold Summit, Vancouver plans

Erik Townsend: So it's going to be very interesting to see what happens next. It's, it's definitely time to pay close attention to what bond yields are But Patrick, I know some of our listeners want to pay attention to what you are doing, and that is speaking at the Silver and Gold Summit in San Francisco, October 28th and 29th.

What's going on? What are you talking about? And is there a deal for MacroVoices subscribers?

Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. I'm going to be, of course, talking about gold, silver, and particularly the use of options on them. So it's going to be pretty exciting. But what all of our MacroVoices listeners should be most excited about is the past guests that we've had on this show that are also going to be speaking there. Not only is Marin Katusa going to be speaking there. Rick Rule's going to be speaking there. Grant Williams from Things That Make You Go Hmmm and Real Vision's going to be speaking there, as well as Brent Johnson. So there's a great lineup coming. And what's amazing is that we were able to negotiate with the Cambridge House to get a 30% discount for our MacroVoices listeners using the promo code Macro. If you get in before October 1st, it's the early bird phase 1. And then between now and October 12th is early bird phase 2. You get an additional 30% off of the already discounted prices.

So if you want to come out and see that great lineup and meet me and everything, come on out. Otherwise though, Erik, what's in store for our Vancouver show? What do you think? What's going on there?

Erik Townsend: Well, let's keep it super tight, but we got a lot of feedback. We were thinking, okay, Vancouver, we'll just go to the resource conference in Vancouver and maybe hang out and have a beer with our listeners afterwards. People are really pushing us to do an event like we did in Toronto. The Vancouver crowd thinks that they deserve one just as good. So we're thinking about doing Vancouver Vancouver, January 19th. That would be the day before the January 20th and 21st Vancouver Natural Resource Investment Conference. Don't buy your ticket yet for the Vancouver Resource Investment Conference because we'll be bundling admission to that with whatever we do. George is still negotiating with the hotels. We'll see where that goes. Meanwhile, we're still going to do a US event someday, but I think we'll probably push it out to the spring. We've had a lot of feedback that people prefer a 2-day format, and we're thinking Dallas instead of Vegas right now.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Also considering Atlanta and Miami. But if you haven't yet, take our survey to tell us your desires there. We'll let you know when we have something finalized.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, thanks for the update, Erik. So now this week's featured interview guest is IceCap Asset Management's Keith Dicker. Erik's interview with Keith is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Interview: has QE really saved the economy?

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is IceCap Chief Investment Officer Keith Dicker. Keith, thanks so much for joining us on the program. You've prepared a fantastic slide deck for us. Listeners, you'll find the download link to the slide deck in your Research Roundup email. If you're not registered yet, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the information next to Keith's picture for how to get the download. Keith, you know, You know, the narrative that a lot of people would like us to believe is, hey, Ben Bernanke has pretty much saved the economy. Quantitative easing rescued the financial markets, and hey, everything's all better now. What could go wrong? I tend to be in the camp that at some point the piper has to be paid. There's no free lunch. But a lot of people have challenged, you know, what form will that come in? Where does the piper still need to be paid? And I think you've addressed a lot of those questions in your chartbook, so why don't we go ahead And get started here on page 1.

Tell us what, what's going on with what's coming on this first chart.

Dicker's thesis: the next crisis starts in bonds

Keith Dicker: Yeah, sure thing. Thanks. Thank you, Erik, for having me on today. So we'll have a good chat here with IceCap Asset Management. Our global macro view, it's attracted a lot of attention from around the world. And what we find most interesting is that, you know, this conversation we'll have today, it's happening in the US, happening across Europe, Canada, Asia, you name it. So it's not a country-specific concern that investors have today. This is really a global situation that we're in. So that's what we'll touch upon. You know, so you mentioned, um, Bernanke saved the day and, and all that stuff. Our view is, you know, a little bit different.

When we look at the world today, you know, because we are a global macro shop, it's really important to understand that we do not live in a linear world. And when you put I would put on top of that, once we understand how central banks, and in the Western world specifically, how they operate the economy and the global financial system, then you will better be able to see exactly what's coming down the pipe here.

And, you know, to give you the conclusion first, we have a very high conviction, there's a very high probability that we have another crisis, that it's coming in view right now. It's really started to ramp up this year, and we expect to see a significant crisis across the fixed income sphere. So most specifically, most likely sovereign debt, but it will spread across the entire fixed income industry. And so we'll talk about that, why that's going to come and what's happening. So when we're looking at our first slide deck that we have here, what we like to point out to people is that everyone in the business today in investing, we all remember the tech bubble almost 20 years ago now. That created about $5 trillion in losses, and then next up Apart from that, the housing bubble is about $15 trillion, 3 times bigger. What we have happening today in the bond world, no one has seen that happen before.

Every crisis that we've seen in the world today in our lifetime, it's always originated and reflected in the stock market. No one is really prepared for what's happening in the bond world. The best way to look at it, when we look at central banks, whether it's Bernanke or Yellen after her, and even Greenspan back towards The entire Western world, Erik, they've based their economy on Keynesian economics. And basically what that means for everyone is that when there's a crisis, the government will increase spending. So they'll run a bigger deficit because that's going to stimulate the economy. And then central banks, on top of that, they'll cut interest rates to make credit easier to flow and easier for people to borrow and so forth.

And what's really happened over time— so just going back to our first slide we have here. Every time that there's been a crisis in our lifetime, the actions of the central banks and governments specifically in the Western world, by saving one crisis, they really sow the seeds for the next crisis. So all the losses that we had back in '08 and '09, you know, they were never realized. They were simply, you know, taken away from the private sector and pushed over on the balance sheets of the government sector. So they like to call it they socialized the bad debt losses.

But we have another bubble that has been created, and most of the world, they're just not ready for it because they're not used to living in a world where fixed income can be risky and equities can actually be safe.

Equities as the safe haven in a bond crisis

Erik Townsend: Moving on to the second slide, it looks like you're kind of transposing the usual perspective. Normally people think of government bonds as the safest thing that there is. The risk is in the stock market. You seem to be showing a different view.

Keith Dicker: Yeah. Well, what we like to tell people is that, you know, we've all been bred to believe that bonds are always safe, stocks are risky, you know, therefore in the CFA world, we, you know, we live on this modern portfolio theory line where you get a combination of stocks and bonds. That's why you have all your balanced funds out there in the world.

And it's important for investors today though to realize Guys, this investment experience we've had in the bond market in our lifetime, it's really been predicated upon long-term interest rates going from high to low. Whenever rates go down, bond markets go up, and it's the easiest market to make money in, but we've never lived in the period where long rates start to go higher.

What we'll talk about now in a second is that when, unlike overnight rates with either the Fed or or any of the other central banks in the Western world, usually you can tell what they're going to do with overnight rates. Long-term interest rates, they surge. They go from 1 to 3 to 6 very quickly. And that hasn't happened in our lifetime. So because of that, people are not ready for what happens in the bond world.

The other thing to consider is that most of the investors that we've experienced in our career, these are truly global investors. So these are people that lived their lives in multiple countries. They have multiple currencies in their pocket. They have no home country bias. It's incredibly important for the average investor to know that with these investors, as soon as they get a sniff of trouble in the world, they run away from it.

And that's hugely important to know because, you know, the way the math works out, of course, you get a 50% loss in anything, you need a 100% return to get back to where you started. So avoiding losses in your portfolio, those are critical. And once we begin to see danger, And a crisis re-escalating in any market, that this large pool of capital in the world, they're going to run away from it. And once that begins to happen, then people will realize very quickly, oh wow, this— that market is trouble.

And it's important though to understand that when capital leaves one market, it goes to another, another market for safety. And those that follow us, they know that we believe there's going to be a lot of capital seeking safety in US dollars as well as certain parts of equity markets as well. So what we're expecting, a very different market outcome from what happens in the upcoming crisis in the bond market than what we've traditionally been led to believe what would happen.

Erik Townsend: Let me ask you a couple of follow-ups on that, because one view that you'll hear from a lot of people that we've talked to on this program is, look, the real risk is in the bond market, same thing as you're saying, and that means we're going to get to a situation which is unusual in which both stocks and bonds are selling off together, and that really means a lot of trouble for risk Risk parity strategies and so forth. But there's another view, and I'm curious what you think about it, which is, wait a minute, it could actually go the other direction to the point where there is so much danger in bond markets, particularly with the negative yielding sovereign debt that exists around the world. I mean, it's just so ridiculously overvalued that that sell-off, because bond markets are so much bigger than stock markets, that you could actually see the safety trade out of government bonds into stocks, and you could surprise everyone. with the stock market moving up in a crisis because it is the safety trade, which is hard to get your head around, but it seems plausible.

What do you think about that view?

Keith Dicker: Yeah, you know, we're, you know, 90% in the latter camp, Erik. However, before we get to that, though, the initial reaction was when this crisis reescalates, it'll be a pretty big pop in the world. You know, we fully expect equities will come down a little bit in the beginning. Whether that number is significant or not, you As a manager, we would have different models in place that would help us, guide us through that moment.

But once this crisis really does begin to escalate in the fixed income world, it's very likely money will flow into equities as a safe haven. I often say to investors, who would you rather trust with your money? The board of IBM or the Italian government? You usually get a chuckle out of it sometimes, but that's really what you're coming down to.

But what we expect will happen to fixed income People will, what we call sliding down the curve, so duration will get hit specifically. Any type of a spread product, whether it's credit or high yield or emerging market debt, that's gonna get hit as well. So money will seek safety within the fixed income world, which will be short duration and specifically Treasuries, as well as bonds for that matter. There's a high probability that equities can do extremely well, and that's gonna cause a lot of the value investing guys out there to get excited.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Keith Dicker: Sort of spin around because, you know, as we say now, I tell people valuations, they don't matter in the world right now. They will at some point in time, but right now, if you're a value investor, you're saying, wow, like none of these numbers make sense, you know, yet, you know, US equities continue to go up very strongly. So we often tell people, you know, it's not that markets should do what you expect them to do. You have to sit back and say markets are doing this and why?

And that really supports this theme that we're talking about.

End of the secular bond bull and the suppressed yield curve

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 3, you're showing obviously this huge secular bull market in bonds, lowering yields ever since 1982. You've got an up arrow at the end here. I'm very curious to know your view because we've had a lot of different people on this program express differing views from, oh boy, it looks like it might be over, to it's definitely over, to we're sure it's over, we're betting the farm on it's over. So do you think that the bottom is in? on Treasury yields and it's all uphill from here, or are we in kind of a bottoming process where we're not sure if there's another wave down that might take us to a new lower low in yield?

Keith Dicker: Yeah, the first part to comment with this slide— this slide is so simple, it's perfect. What we're showing everyone here is just the history of the US 10-year. So it's really— it's a proxy for long-term interest rates. And what we see is in the early part of the '60s, you know, long rates went from, you know, 2.5% Right up to almost 20% in 1982, depending on which rate mark you're looking at. And then from '82 down to basically just last year, you know, went down to zero.

And this is the key thing that most investors are really missing in the marketplace. We've all lived in a market, in a career, in a market environment where bond funds have always done well. So when you have long-term rates go from 20% to zero, any bond manager in the world can make money. It's the biggest bull market we've ever experienced in fixed income.

And what's interesting, if you think about this more from a practical perspective, we always try to make things very simple for clients to understand.

So I started working in the business back in the early '90s. So I was trained by a person who worked in the '80s. I then trained the person When I was in the late '90s, early '00s, I trained the earlier person 10 years behind me and so forth. Everyone in the business today, most people have either only lived and worked or been trained by someone who only lived and worked in a period where long-term rates have only gone down.

And the reason we say this, because it's hugely important to know that the majority of the industry has never experienced a market with long-term rates going higher. Then on top of that, they've never experienced a crisis in the bond market before.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Keith Dicker: So we like to tell people that the bond market, think of it— as you mentioned, the bond market is dwarfed the size of equity markets. But it's a crowded gymnasium. There's no liquidity to get out. You can move inside the market if you want, but it's similar to having a gymnasium that's packed and there's one door open at the end. You just cannot get out of it.

So to go back to your question, Erik, the long end of the curve, It's clearly already starting to move up. Whether you're looking at the US with the 10-year, we've gone from 1% to 3% now in about a year and a half. Same thing is happening in Canada. It's happening in other markets as well.

But the big point to understand is when we look at the yield curve today— let's just turn to the next page here, Erik, just sort of express this point a bit better.

Erik Townsend: Sure.

Keith Dicker: A normal functioning bond market market has a yield curve where short rates are— short-term rates are lower than long-term rates. Since the crisis in '08 and '09, because we've had so much— I call it interference from central banks— but we've had over $14 trillion in various forms of money printing, quantitative easing. Then you put on top of that, we had about 700 rate cuts around the world.

Then we've had a negative interest rate policy, and then, you know, of course, still have negative rates, you know, across most of Europe and Japan. That has artificially suppressed the yield curve. So in everyday language, it means that the price of bonds has been artificially locked in place where the private sector has not been able to get in and really affect what the price of bonds should be.

When we talk about a crisis in the bond market, It's because long-term bonds, all of a sudden, they are now freed from suppression by central banks. They're now open to the private sector to start repricing again. And when you get a repricing in the bond world, long-term rates are gonna go from 1 to 3 to 6 and then 12, and it just came over. It's similar to what happened to Italy back in 2011 and '12, back when they had the crisis there and Berlusconi was kicked out overnight.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Keith Dicker: And maybe ECB stepped in to save the day. So that's what we see happening. We do not believe that the long end is simply going to be affected by inflation expectations or the economic cycle. The key really comes down to what's happening from central banks specifically in Europe, and that's going to catch a lot of investors by surprise.

Italy, the ECB and the social-political collision

Erik Townsend: Let me just ask a follow-on on that, because the last time that this happened, when we saw interest rates bottom, was at the end of World War II, and of course that was a very different set of circumstances. But a lot of people expected a V-shaped recovery, and it didn't really happen. It ended up being a U-shaped recovery where those very low rates stayed about the same, very low, for 10 years, and then they finally started to take off. You're expecting rates to, to V-shape here and to take off. Is that specifically because of central banks withdrawing their liquidity? And if so, it seems to me like There's a— at some point, as soon as this starts to take off, maybe they, they go back to their old ways and try to suppress them some more. So what do you see on the horizon there?

Keith Dicker: You know, really, we tell people we're having this moment in time. You know, every crisis is a little bit different, but a lot of it is the same from previous crises. But right now, we're really experiencing a collision between social, economic, political, and monetary factors around the world. So everything Everything is hitting each other at the same time. It's created this chaos, whether it's within politics or social or economic and financial markets. There's a lot of confusion out there, what is going to happen.

Our view on why we get this crisis in the bond market, it's a combination of 2 things.

One, the financial conditions are just perfect for it. We'll show you in a little bit. that when you look at the percentage of many countries and their percentage of their tax revenues had to go towards paying just interest on their debt outstanding, it's significant, but it becomes even more significant once rates rise. So that will have a pretty difficult effect on a lot of governments trying to maintain their budgets.

But the other part of it though, is it really comes from the social and political side of the economy. There's a lot of unhappiness around the world right now, and that is getting reflected in the political world. And when we look specifically over in Europe, the Eurozone as well as the EU, the divide between the left versus the right, it's growing by the day.

And it's becoming increasingly difficult for the Eurozone, specifically the EU, to maintain what they have.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Keith Dicker: And specifically, when we look at what's happening in Italy these days, it's very likely that Italy is the one that will ultimately be the epicenter for this crisis re-escalates again. And it's coming at the exact moment in time where the ECB, they have to unwind their QE. Draghi's term is up now next year.

The German government, they are against the ECB's policy with QE. They want to turn it off. So at the exact moment in time where political and social stress are colliding with each other is the exact moment of time when the financial markets aren't able to absorb that type of crisis. So, you know, that's what we see really happening.

Erik Townsend: Now, I just want to follow up on that again, because what I can see is you've got, as you say, I couldn't possibly agree more with what you just said, which is we have a mounting economic crisis. Yeah, I agree. But boy, the mounting social crisis around the world is bigger, and it is going to have a greater impact on what governments are forced to do because they're going to be dealing with, you know, outright riot kind of situations among their constituents.

It seems to me like the thing that governments cannot afford is a secular reversal of the direction in interest rates because they're so overindebted now that they would be unable to afford to service their debt. And it seems to me that they would need to increase that debt with more deficit spending in order to deal with some of the social issues that you're talking about. So it seems to me like a setup for governments to panic at some point and say, we got to go back to doing everything we possibly can to suppress rates because we're screwed otherwise. Am I wrong to think they're going to find themselves in that pickle? And when they do, is there anything they're going to be able to do about it? Or are they going to have to just suffer like the rest of us through higher rates?

Keith Dicker: Well, you know what, obviously we have a very similar view of what might happen here. But, you know, first of all, when we say government, we specifically mean the elected office. And, you know, of course, then the ministries underneath them. You really have to separate that from the central bank within each country. To make the assumption that, you know, any government in the world today, you know, whether it's the American, Canadian, British, you name it, I find it's extremely unlikely any of these guys are going to be able to anticipate any crisis and then be proactive towards it. They just don't work that way.

Even in Canada, for example, during the last federal election, I had the Liberal Party stop by one evening, you know, they were canvassing for their votes. And, you know, they don't realize I'm a money guy. That's just the world I live in. It's pretty black and white to me. I asked them and I said, What are the Liberals going to do with the deficit that you expect to come up? And there was a whole team, there was about 6 or 7 canvassing in the neighborhood that night. And they all gathered around me and they said, well, we're expecting a $2 billion deficit. And I looked at them and I said, that's impossible. Oh, it's going to be— I said, you guys are going to be at least $20 billion. For all these things you say you're going to do, you're not going to hit $2 billion. It's going to be way north of that. And they quickly scribbled in their books, you know, that this may not be someone supporting their party.

But what happened afterwards, of course, you know, the Canadian deficit in the first year was $30 billion. So remember, they're telling voters it's going to be $2 billion and the final number is $30 billion. So to expect governments to be on top of this, I think that's just wishful thinking.

Sovereign debt, EM dollar borrowing and the Fed

Keith Dicker: The best way to really demonstrate what's happening, Erik, let's just shoot straight through to Slide number 12. So it's entitled Sovereign Debt Has Exploded. So this is a chart that's showing what the growth has been in total debt, and it's separated between the developed world and emerging markets. So, and what it shows here is that from 2006, just before the last crisis, up to 2016, so just a 10-year period, the debt outstanding in the developed world has grown by 25%, so from $128 trillion to $160 trillion. That's pretty significant. That's big.

The most important point to understand, though, is that underneath this, debt in the emerging market world has grown by 250%, so 10 times stronger growth of borrowing in the emerging market world. When we look at how the emerging market world, how they borrow, The 2 points to know is that they are primarily borrowing in US dollars, so that instantly creates a shortage of dollars in the world. So it is a short of dollars, which means that in the future they have to buy dollars back for this.

And then if you look over to our next page, on page— slide 13 here, this is the data point I referred to there a few minutes ago. It's showing the percentage of governments' tax revenues that has to be allocated to Towards interest on debt outstanding. All of these rates today are currently based upon artificially suppressed interest rates around the world with the central banks being heavily involved in suppressing the yield curve.

So when we look at, hey, can governments save the day? They'll be reactive. That's all they'll be. They cannot be proactive. So it's only after rates Rates start surging higher and governments sit down and, you know, they do their budgets and they say, holy smokes, how, you know, we're now, we used to allocate 6% of our budget for paying interest on the debt. Now it's gonna be 12%. So that's less money left over for this and that. And that's happening at the exact point in time when borrowing for dollars is becoming, you know, the demand is just increasing even more. So I hold very little little hope that governments around the world will be able to be proactive to correct this from happening, that they won't be able to do it.

And that's the same with central banks as well, Erik. Right now, the Fed has already stated when they started raising rates now, just recently, that, you know what, we're no longer gonna be the central bank for the world. We're changing our view. We're looking after the US. And every time you have the Fed Fed raising rates while the rest of the world continues to have QE running as well as negative rates and zero rates, that just sucks more foreign capital into the US market, which makes it even worse for foreign currencies and foreign debt markets.

So this is setting up to be, in our view, one of the easiest macro calls to make in our lifetime. And because of that, there's a significant opportunity coming up for people to both make and lose So, you know, people have to decide whether to recognize this is a risk and be able to capitalize on it, because we can't stop it from happening, or, you know, just to ignore it altogether, which is really going to hurt a lot of people's portfolios.

Warning shots: US, Japan, Canada and Italy bond moves

Erik Townsend: Keith, thanks for jumping ahead to answer my question, but I want to go back to where we left off. Let's go back to slide number 6. You're showing warning number 1 here. What's the warning?

Keith Dicker: Oh boy. Again, we really separate the industry from investment markets. What we'd like to do with these next few slides is to demonstrate to investors that in our mind, 90% of the investment world, they're not making big investment decisions. It's always thrown against the benchmark and manage cash flows, and that's it.

What we're showing here on page 6, we call it warning number Number one. So this, again, this is the US 10-year, and this is what happened.

It's showing the history of the 10-year from 1982 to the end of '16, 2016. We like to show this because this is what's happened with long-term rates in the US immediately after the 2016 American election. And so what happened after that, if people were following equity markets, markets, of course, but within about a 48-hour span, the US 10-year went from 1.7% to 2.4%.

So a 70 basis point rise effectively overnight. For most investors, they'll say, Keith, round it. It's gone from 2 to 2. There's no big change here. But this small 70 basis point change in long-term rates, it just creates so much chaos in the bond market world.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Keith Dicker: I was actually visiting with— I had meetings with one of the largest bond managers at the time, about a week after this happened.

I say to them, how were the last few days for you guys? With 1 being everything's great, 10 things haven't been very good. They looked at each other and they said, oh, it was an 8. I said, wow. So a 70 basis point unexpected increase in the 10-year to cost these guys. guys, one of the biggest bond managers in the world, to go down for an 8-count.

If you look at the slide here, you know, we have the headline stories from that day. One from Bloomberg is saying, global bonds suffer worst monthly meltdown as $1.7 trillion lost. Another one says, sleepy bond market stirred by November like no other. Again, this is to warn people that the industry and the bond market is not ready for a crisis or a long-term surge in rates. And then the same thing happens again on the next slide, on page 7, warning number 2.

So this here took place back in just about, you know, 7 to 8 months after the US election in Japan. I woke up one morning and I'm going through data points, see what's happening, and the Japanese bond market, it's going crazy. So what happened to cause it to go crazy? The 10-year in Japan, the Japanese government bond 10-year, 10-year went from 0.10% yield to 0.125%, so a 2.5-pip increase.

The BOJ went nuts. They said, we will never tolerate this again, and they bought everything they could in sight to bring the bond yields down again. Again, demonstrating that the second biggest bond market in the world, they couldn't tolerate a 0.0012% change.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Keith Dicker: in the yield curve.

We go to warning on page number 8 here. Same thing in Canada in August of 2017. You see the title here from a Bloomberg story, How Funds Are Regrouping After Worst Canada Bond Rout Since '94. Same thing in the bottom corner, they talk about the Australian bond market.

On page 9, Erik, it's probably the best, one of the best, easiest slides that we've shown in a while. This has come from March of this year, so not too far back. It's another Bloomberg story, and they say, not a single Japanese 10-year bond traded on Tuesday. Again, that's just crazy stuff. So an equivalent in the stock market, that would be saying like zero shares of Google traded today. People are not ready For this lack of liquidity in a crisis in the bond market.

Then the most recent one, of course, which should really plant the seed in everyone's head that the central banks are really suppressing rates, specifically in Europe. What we're showing here is what happened with the Italian 2-year bond. Just to refresh everyone's mind, the Italians, they had their election back in the And, you know, leading up to it, we wrote about this. We said, you know, it's very clear what's going to happen in Italy with the political scene. The 2 parties leading in the poll, number 1 and number 2, their main political platform, you know, they're both flipping the bird to the EU and the Eurozone in Brussels.

And so these guys are going to win, and this is going to create chaos in the European bond market.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Keith Dicker: Sure enough, these guys win, and markets were somehow surprised by it. And, you know, of course, a few days later, this new coalition party in Italy, they appoint their new FinMin, their financial minister. And this guy's entire career has been dedicated to trying to tear up the Eurozone. And the first thing that happens the next Brussels and Frankfurt and the ECB, they get together and say, wow, you know, the Italians are really rocking the boat down there. How about shooting one across the bow? And the ECB said, sure, no problem. So instead of buying Italian bonds that day, they, they sell some on the market. And this is the key point again where the market is not ready for this, that the 2-year yield in Italy went from 0.2% to 2.4% in one day.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Keith Dicker: So 0.2% to 2.4%, you know, that's equivalent of a stock going from 100 down to 2, like within hours. This should be sending shivers down your spine if you're long the bond market, or, you know, cause you to jump up and down with excitement if you're short the bond market. Because we're getting these consistent warning shots that the market is not ready for a crisis in the bond market.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Keith Dicker: market, and the bond market itself, you know, is not ready for it. So, this is enormous. This is a terrific opportunity coming up, depending on how you position your portfolios.

How the crisis plays out: central banks and currencies

Erik Townsend: So, Keith, to summarize all of this, it sounds to me like your views are very similar to my own. Let me state my own view and tell me, first of all, if it's similar, but most importantly, it's the what happens next and what can we do about it. My view has been that, you know, what we've done with short-sighted thinking is central Central banks have solved all of the symptoms of the last crisis by creating artificially low interest rates that have propped us up into this negative-yielding sovereign debt situation where there's no room left. When we get to the next crisis, you can't go to the safety of bonds because bonds are not safe. So we've got, at a minimum, the bond market, which is 4 times bigger than the stock market selling off in a way that could be self-reinforcing. It, it becomes a question of what could happen there. And it happens at a time when we're already reaching a boiling point on social crises around the world.

And I think that what it creates most likely is a situation where governments go into a financial crisis at the same time they're coping with a social crisis. And according to old-school Keynesian Keynesian philosophy, they most need to spend a lot of money on deficit at a time when markets are least allowing them to do so.

So, I guess the first question is, is my summary, which is my own view that I've had for many years about where we are, consistent with yours? But more importantly, to whatever extent it is, what the heck does that mean in terms of what's coming? Because I think when we get to the the next crisis. It's not a question of just turning on the printing presses and more QE. It's, it's a really global social crisis that I'm not sure what it's going to lead to.

Keith Dicker: Yeah, I agree, Erik. You know, our views are quite similar. We tell people that we believe there's a very high probability that the world does trend towards what we expect. So that is going to happen. As for how it turns out, we think we're probably 80% Correct. Financial— market-wise. So the first part of your question, from a social, political side, it's— there's going to be a lot of angry people out there. That will happen. Because again, like the conversation that we're having today, people listening, I think that represents a very small percentage of the marketplace. Most people are oblivious to these types of conversations that are happening. So yeah, there will be lot of confusion out there, and it will create some unfortunate times for a lot of people.

In terms of the marketplace and how this transpires, Erik, you know, the central banks have always been reacting towards a crisis that, you know, that's been created by the private sector. You know, you and I, you know, we caused the housing crisis, you know, we caused the tech bubble, and so Once this crisis reescalates again in the bond world, there's no blueprint for it. So I'm not quite sure how it looks, what the reaction will be from central banks. And specifically, everyone will be looking towards the Fed. I mean, even back in '08, a lot of investors don't realize is that without the Fed opening their lines to Europe, Europe would've went under.

Erik Townsend: Mm-hmm.

Keith Dicker: Everyone starves for dollars. Like, the US dollar, it's the only market big enough in the world to put money into during times of crisis. So, you know, people listening to this today, they're hearing your view, and a lot of other people have similar views as us.

As bad as things may seem in the US right now, from a singular perspective, the US dollar has the real potential.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Keith Dicker: to go significantly higher here. And we tell people really with markets, think of— you have to think of the world from a currency perspective.

We tell people really only 3 currencies matter in the world. So think of the US as the foundation base. Next to that, you have Japanese yen. And then on top of that is euro. Every other currency is sort of swirling around it, just making noise. We anticipate crisis in Eurozone First, capital will flow into yen and dollars for safety. And then all of a sudden, once the crisis, you know, more or less has sorted itself out in Euroland, then it'll hit the world of Japanese yen. Then, you know, finally, then, you know, the dollar will have their day as well. So, uh, you know, to get through this, thinking in a linear fashion will not work. You have to understand that it's going to be very fluid. Things happen extremely quickly.

But, and the main blueprint is that no one is ready for it. So, you know, you and I, we can't change it. Talking about today will help a lot of investors prepare for it. But this is happening. And, you know, it is what it is.

Dollar surge and emerging-market contagion

Erik Townsend: With the dollar strengthening, as it already has, it's retraced just barely more than half of the move down over the last year or so. And that already seems to be creating a crisis in emerging markets. markets. If we move to new highs above 104, whatever the recent peak was a little over a year ago, what does that mean for emerging markets? And what's the transmission mechanism into developed markets from there?

Keith Dicker: Well, first of all, you know, the recent strength in dollar, that's just been a— you know, it has been strength there, but it's not what we expect. We expect a surge in money going into USD. So whether we're measuring it by DXY or whatever other currency you want to look at, we're telling people that this is nothing. This hasn't even started yet.

If the dollar, once it does begin to strengthen— remember, all this happens simultaneously. You don't have a strong dollar and then emerging markets experience a weakness. One leads to the other. It's going to be extremely difficult in the emerging market world.

So we're already seeing it now. In several countries, it's happening. What I find most unfortunate, just sort of a side note, we continue to get calls from fund companies, ETF manufacturers trying to sell us emerging market debt funds. I say to these guys, are you joking? Do you have any idea what's happening in the world?

They don't. They look at it as the old story with emerging markets is that the fundamentals are better, than the developed world. They're growing faster, lower debt, better workforce, and stuff like that. But again, they just don't understand that probability of this group hitting a more severe crisis. It'll dwarf what happened in '97 and '98 with the Asian crisis back then. That's happening. And because we live on a global yield curve, banks are in a global funding space. That's where they We are, you know, one crisis in one market leads to the next, which to the next, to the next.

I often get people that'll ask me, you know, they'll say, Keith, you know, what will cause the housing market in Toronto and Vancouver to slow down? And I'll say, they must say, oh, that's easy. I said, it would be Italy. And, you know, they look at me like I have 10 heads and they'll say, well, no, we asked about Toronto. And I said, yeah, you know, you go through the Italian bond market, how they're relying on the ECB, you know, to finance their deficit.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Keith Dicker: You know, you go down that route and then you get, you know, they look at you like with deer in headlights. But the main point here is, you know, whether it's the Canadian market or US or emerging market world, everyone lives on the same yield curve.

And a crisis in one part of the market, it just spreads into the other.

I know we talk a lot about the bond market today, but again, we tell people it's extremely important to know that no one asset class operates in isolation. There's no zero correlation among asset classes. They're all connected. And, you know, this crisis that's facing us is coming up. It's, it's going to be fixed income, currency-driven. It's going to cause a lot of capital to go scattering around the world.

Gold: one more leg down, then a strong run

Erik Townsend: Let's touch on gold briefly, because, you know, according to conventional wisdom, at least, if you're expecting a huge surge up up in the dollar, that should be extremely bearish for gold. On the other hand, your larger picture outlook in terms of a major bear market in bonds could potentially be extremely beneficial to gold. So, is it time for gold yet? Uh, where's the trade there?

Keith Dicker: It could be time. Uh, you know, with IceCap, you know, we tell people we're asset class agnostic. You know, in more simpler terms, we don't love or hate any one asset class. As an example, We had a pretty significant allocation to gold bullion back in '11 and '12. And people in the gold world, they all remember what happened next. Gold broke from— almost hit $2,000, and then down to $1,600, then $1,200, and it's been there ever since.

People who follow gold, they all know the same fundamental story, why it should be surging, and the reasons why it hasn't, and so forth. Of course, we're a lot simpler with that. We don't disagree with that storyline. However, when any asset class or market, when it breaks specific support levels, you have to respect that, whether it's on the upside or downside. So, once gold broke back then, our last trade was out at $1,648, and we haven't been back in since.

And our story, of course, that we tell people from a market perspective, that we do expect the dollar to become extremely And initially, Erik, we expect that will be negative for gold. We think gold, it has an opportunity here to come down one more thump. But after that, we can see a period where both gold and dollar, you know, it does very well. So with us, we have our current strategies in place.

Then we also have, you know, other strategies on deck. And we've had gold on deck now.

People have been following us, you know, they'll say, yeah, you know, IceCap's been saying this for a while. We've had gold on deck now for a couple years. We really want to add gold to the portfolio, but the conditions are still under— gold remains weak, but we think the long-term outlook is quite big. But you got to get through this dollar market first.

Erik Townsend: Well, I couldn't agree more. I really, really believe gold is going to have its day in the sun, and I think it's going to be the trade to be in. But I don't I don't think it's time yet. I think we got more down before we go up. I want to go back, though, to something you just said about people following you. You guys have been extremely popular. ZeroHedge has really taken a liking to your research work. For people who are interested in following your work, please tell us more about what you do at IceCap Asset Management and where people can learn more about it.

About IceCap Asset Management

Keith Dicker: Yeah, sure thing. So, IceCap Asset Management, we provide investment portfolios for individuals as well as institutions. We are what we call absolute return. In more technical terms, benchmark unconstrained. We really focus on avoiding markets that we expect are going to produce losses, as I mentioned earlier, the importance of doing that, and constructing portfolios the right way, really from a currency perspective first and going out from that. For our global outlook, Erik, people can sign up for that. It's free. It's on our website at IceCapAssetManagement.com, and we're on Twitter as well at IceCapGlobal.

Erik Townsend: Well, Keith, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break: guest requests and mailbag

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: would stocks really be the safety trade?

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Keith. I actually want to opine in on what he was saying, but I want to first get your opinion. What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, what this one really got me thinking about is I agree with Keith that we're likely going to see the next major financial crisis be primarily a bond market crisis. It's the bond market that governments have most propped up with quantitative easing. That's where the most largesse exists. That's what could To get unwound. And the thing it really makes you think about is, okay, nobody anywhere is prepared if the way that institutional money has always been run, that the only thing that anybody in the business knows how to do is your safety trade when everything else is falling apart is the US 10-year Treasury. That's your safe instrument no matter what. Well, what happens, Patrick, when the US 10-year Treasury is exactly what you're running away from, what you don't want to be invested in? Now, Keep in mind that institutional investors, by mandate, the gold bugs would love to say, that's when they're all going to go to gold.

Well, look, they can't go to gold because, by mandate, they're not allowed to invest in gold. They have to invest within their mandate. We actually had, at one point, Keith saying, it could be that the equity market becomes the safety trade, where equities are moving up as the bond market is crashing. Now, that seems utterly crazy on the surface of it, but you've got to ask yourself, if the bond When the bond market is crashing, where does the money go? Presumably, it goes into shorter-duration fixed income. Well, what happens when all of the shorter-duration fixed income gets bought up?

It's a fascinating question, and I don't necessarily think that the answer has to be stock market surprises everybody and goes up when you would expect it to crash. But it's going to be very, very interesting to see what happens if we get into a financial crisis which is primarily about a bond market event as opposed to a stock market event.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. You know, Erik, I can't wrap my head around this. Keith is not the only one who's shared this idea before. I've actually heard this idea thrown out there before by a number of very smart people. But in the way that I look at the markets, I can't make sense of that because at least in my mind, what's happening is we got a Fed that— and now the rest of the central banks approaching this same kind of tapering that the Fed is doing, where they're reducing their balance sheets and drawing liquidity out of the marketplace.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Patrick Ceresna: Have at the same time the governments issuing more and more debt and they're soaking up all the available capital in doing all of their auctions and raising so much more additional capital to fund their deficits. This to me is soaking up liquidity. And as you're soaking up liquidity and it creates a bond crisis, when there's a lack of liquidity, I cannot envision a scenario where that inspires money to go to It's a reality that there is a direct relationship with yields and valuations on stocks because whatever the yields are, that's being discounted into equity valuations.

And so, yeah, they've diverged for a while, but if bond markets are crashing and yields are skyrocketing, it's making stocks incredibly expensive and justifying that people are going to chase equity because that— I just can't make sense of it. It's not something that in my mind I can compute.

Erik Townsend: Well, I can't compute it either, but I'm thinking more about what's the alternative. Let's assume that long Long duration, say 5-year and longer duration fixed income, including government fixed income, Treasury bonds, you don't want to be in because that's what's crashing as rates go through the roof. What are you going to do instead? And initially, you could say everybody goes to short duration. It's just all T-bills. Well, there's not enough T-bills for everybody to do that. Does the government stop issuing 10-years and just issue, you know, all short duration in order to respond to what the market wants to to buy, what would the knock-on effects and consequences of something like that be?

So I'm not saying that I think that there's any logical reason that you would want to favor stocks in that situation. What I'm saying is, if the money is coming out of the bond market, 'cause everybody's panicking about bond prices and sees that the avalanche has begun and is not likely to stop, where do they go instead?

Remember, the institutional guys can't just stay all in cash. They've got a mandate that they have to be invested in They normally would use the 10-year as their favorite safety trade. If that's what they're running from, what do they use instead? And I guess it's T-bills.

Postgame: where the bond crisis could start

Patrick Ceresna: Well, one thing that I would push back on there is that even Keith was saying, though, that he thinks that a lot of the initial crisis may actually start in Europe and then eventually even make its way to Japan, and that each of these countries are going to take their turn.

What if the bond crisis actually doesn't even start in the US Treasury bond market? Everyone's sort of pushing that narrative that it's the US Treasury yield, that's going to be the problem. But what if actually it's global sovereigns that are blowing out, emerging market debt that's blowing out? What if it's actually corporate and junk bonds that are having their spreads blow out? Maybe, just maybe, the US government bonds may still retain a bit of the safe haven element there, and it'll be actually the credit spreads that are blowing out on all the shittier debt.

Erik Townsend: Well, and that's an excellent point that you make, Patrick. Let's suppose that the fundamentals are there, as everybody seems to be expecting right now, for US Treasury yields to move much, much higher. But what happens is, before that really gets going, you see European junk, which— oh my gosh, talk about a ridiculously inflated bubble that needs to pop. You see things like European junk blow up first, and everybody is using that textbook safety trade. That's the only thing they know, which is US Treasuries. That's pushing US Treasury prices up, and we get maybe even a new lower print than what everybody is assuming, that 1.34, was the bottom of the 10-year market. And it could go that way too if enough other stuff blew up first. And I think you make a very good argument. You know, the US 10-year may not be the cleanest shirt in existence, but it's certainly not the dirtiest shirt in the pile either.

If you look at European junk and European sovereigns, negative-yielding sovereign debt around the world, there's a lot of other targets before US Treasuries that could blow up first. And so how does that play into the equation? And if it did result, let's say, in US Treasury yields surprising everyone and moving lower from here instead of higher. Well, how long does that last before they move a whole lot higher in a real big hurry? Because I think that the scenario that says it doesn't start in the US, it starts elsewhere. Yeah, that makes sense, but it doesn't end and not come to the US. It eventually gets to the US market. And if that's been inflated by a misplaced safety trade, where does that leave us? And potentially it's a blow-off on the 10-year, maybe even a double bottom on the 10-year yield. And abrupt reversal.

So many scenarios, Patrick, and we've never been in a situation like this. You can't say, well, let's look at the last time that all of the central banks in the world simultaneously conjured money out of thin air and bought bonds with them, pressing interest rates to millennial-low rates. It's never happened before. So we have nothing to measure this by, and I have no idea what's going to happen, but I am sure that it's going to be interesting.

Postgame: Kolanovic on short positioning in gold

Patrick Ceresna: Well, one thing I can assure all our MacroVoices listeners is that they'll get the play-by-play from me and you in the coming years as we're going to be on this every single tick. Nonetheless, I want to move on. There was a great article talking about Marko Kolanovic's recent piece about the profound danger of the dollar losing its reserve status. Well, that's a topic that we obviously had an entire year-end show and we picked apart in quite extensive detail, but it was still a great piece. But what was most interesting to me was Marko Kolanovic's comment on gold at the end of the article. He talked about and said, the preferred trade appears to be going long gold, not for strategic but due to tactical reasons. So the current positioning of gold is extremely short. He goes on to then talk about as when you take the aggregate of gold ETFs and futures as a fraction of the S&P 500 price, there were only 2 times in the, in the past decade where we were this low, that near the historical lows that were reached.

Once was shortly before the market crash in 2008, and the other one was right before the rally in 2016. And what was really interesting is both scenarios were very different. One was in 2008, a very risk-off moment, and in 2016, it was really a risk-on moment. But what's interesting is we are at that same kind of extreme level on gold. And what's interesting to him is that he just looks at it that there's— there may be an opportunity here on that. Now, tech Technically, we observed that gold is breaking down and that there certainly isn't a bid yet on gold. But boy, it's interesting to see such a smart guy like Marko having gold on his radar.

Postgame: EU, Iran and dollar weaponization (SWIFT workaround)

Erik Townsend: Yeah. And the comments about reserve currency status were really interesting to me too. Marko is not a fringe blogger raving about gold bug conspiracy theories. He's a JP Morgan head quant. And he's talking about the gold story, and he's talking about loss of US dollar reserve currency status.

Meanwhile, Patrick, earlier this week at the United Nations in New York City, who do we have standing shoulder to shoulder, showing solidarity with one another, and speaking out against the injustice in the world? It's not the usual characters. It's the Iranian foreign minister. Minister, and the European Union's foreign policy chief, Federica Mogherini, standing shoulder to shoulder, denouncing US policy to weaponize the dollar. And they have announced their intention to create a new payment mechanism as a workaround to the SWIFT system, which is basically the backbone of how dollar-denominated international trade is settled. So that businesses in Europe continue to have the ability to conduct legal commerce with Iran. Because, of course, Iran has not been sanctioned by the United Nations. It's only been sanctioned unilaterally by the United States. But even though the United States is acting unilaterally, it is demanding that European countries that are not under any sanction from their own governments stop doing business with Iran.

The European Union is making an official announcement at the United Nations in New York City, standing shoulder to shoulder with the Iranian foreign minister, saying, we're going to right the injustice of America abusing its reserve currency issuer status, and we're going to create an alternative payment system. I couldn't believe it when I saw this, Patrick.

I mean, just to— I want you to imagine, it's not just— when it was a month ago, it was Germany, and I couldn't believe Germany, a US ally, is speaking out publicly against US policy to weaponize the dollar as a coercive foreign policy tool. Now it's the chief foreign policy officer of the European Union in a public press announcement, shoulder to shoulder with the guy from Iran, and they're speaking out against US policy. It really is a very different world that we're living in.

Patrick Ceresna: To me, it's very relevant that it's coming from Europe because when you go back to Bretton Woods and how the entire monetary system we have today has its origin nations, it was truly an Anglo-American alliance between Europe and America that put it all together. And so it's sort of pretty significant that it's not Russia and China that is coming out to talk about de-dollarization, but it's Europe. It's pretty significant. For sure.

Postgame: Chris Cole on liquidity and VIX options

Patrick Ceresna: Nonetheless, Erik, one last thing I wanted to touch in postgame. There was a great sequence of articles published on ZeroHedge from Chris Cole, and the 4-part series was all titled about understanding the volatility storm to come. And obviously, we had Chris Cole on the show, and we're looking forward to having him back at some point later this year. But what was really interesting to me was he was talking about some of the different liquidity factors. And, and this really, you know, struck a chord with me, and I wanted to just share it with our listeners.

And he was talking about liquidity in the S&P 500 during the February flash crash, uh, that occurred on the VIX.

And he was talking about the S&P 500. He says the liquidity crisis in February extended beyond derivatives. Not only did the SPDR S&P 500 ETF itself, one of the most liquid exchange-traded funds in the world with capitalization of $260 billion— normally that ETF trades at a 1-cent spread— back on the 5th and 6th of February, the average spread blew out to historical highs, became 2 cents wide, uh, which, uh, in itself doesn't seem like a lot, 1 cent to 2 cents, but it's a, uh, to the 28th standard deviation move when that blowout of the spread. But what was crazy during that event was the SPX, the index options, some of the options actually had no bids or offers on them. And some of the, uh, other option spreads previously that had 5-cent spreads had the spreads widen as much as $3.

And I look at this, it kind of resonates with me with all those traders that are currently trading actually VIX options. Look, the S&P is the S&P, and he's talking about the liquidity there, but a lot of people are turning to the VIX options thinking that when the next time shit hits the fan in the markets, that they'll be able to cash in through volatility spiking in a very big way. But one of the things that I personally feel is that they will all be shocked in a very big way how there is going to be a total lack of liquidity being offered by dealers for them to actually monetize or profit all of their hedges from being right. To me, being in the most liquid assets when you're hedging the downside risk of the market is so important. And it really kind of resonated with me when I was reading that.

Postgame: bond bubble and the social cost

Erik Townsend: First of all, we got to get Chris Cole back on the program. So we should work on that behind the scenes. But, you know, it, It's going to be so interesting because I think this— a lot of what Chris Cole has said, you know, so many people congratulated him for being right, and he said, guys, you're missing the point. What I was predicting, you know, this was a backyard weenie roast compared to what I think is coming. He said the whole February VIX complex blowup event was nothing compared to what he sees on the horizon. And you listen to Keith Dicker's interview today where he saying, you know, when we get to the bond market bubble bursting— and of course, you know, bubbles are hard to predict when they're gonna burst— but when it does happen, it's been so inflated. I mean, when in, you know, recorded human history have all of the central banks of the world worked together to blow a bubble? Well, that's really what, if you think about it, they've done with sovereign debt, is they've done all this quantitative easing to artificially inflate the price of sovereign debt to bring the yields down.

And if, as I've always I've always said there's no free lunch and the piper has to be paid. It gets paid when that bond bubble breaks. And I don't know if that's coming in the next year or if it's still a long ways off.

I've been surprised that we've made it this long. When it does, though, as you say, a lot of assumptions are going to be tested and illiquid instruments won't work and there will be breakdowns all over the place. And I think, as we discussed with Keith Dicker today, it's bigger than just financial markets, you know. And I've worried in the past I'm not worried about the past, about conditions of markets and losing money and whatever. I'm worried about, as Ray Dalio has said so vocally, or tried to say if CNBC hadn't cut him off in mid-sentence, that this is going to be about the social impact to the world.

The next financial crisis is not going to be an event that finance guys care about. It's going to be an event for the history books that has to do with just horrific consequences for society, because we're not prepared to bail things out the way that we were in 2008. And it's going to be ugly. So as you said, we'll be there every step of the way reporting on it. But Patrick, I think we should leave it there in the interest of time.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: So please do work on Chris Cole, see if we can get him scheduled. I know you've got most of the rest of the year already booked out. And in the meantime, folks, we need your help promoting MacroVoices because the more registered users we have, the more able Patrick is to negotiate to get the very best feature interview guests. So please forward your Research Roundups, tell your friends and colleagues, and most importantly, if you haven't done so already, register your free account at MacroVoices.com.

Doesn't cost you a penny, only takes a minute. We won't spam you or sell your email address. What we will do is send you our free Research Roundup email each week, which contains download links for our own content as well as all of the best stuff that we can find on the internet. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Keith. You're going to find a link to the chartbook that also accompanied the interview, also the link to that 4-part series series from Chris Cole, so all of you can read that in greater detail, as well as that article we referenced from Marko Kolanovic about the danger of the dollar losing its reserve status. You will find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you next time. Thank you.

Announcer close and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education and research in financial markets. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education and research in financial markets. For traders, please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.

Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by. Sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Art Berman — petroleum geologist (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 133 was recorded on September 20th, 2018. I'm Erik Townsend. Our all-star fall lineup continues this week with everyone's favorite petroleum geologist, Art Berman, returning as this week's feature interview guest. Art will explain how the balance between comparative inventory and market price has shifted downward in the last 6 months and what he sees on the horizon for oil prices. Be sure to stay tuned for extended equity market coverage in our postgame segment after the feature interview, when Patrick and I will dive into another chart deck and look at what might be coming next for the stock market. We'll also have an update on our live event plans.

Market wrap: S&P 500

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, last week we talked about the fact that if the dollar weakness was to persist, that we could really see that act as a risk-on for the markets. And well, with a ripple like we saw today in the S&P 500 heading up towards like 2,940. It really feels like something new is afoot here on the upside. What's your thinking here on the S&P?

Erik Townsend: You know, the timing of this is so frustrating. I sat down last night, Patrick, and I made my comments for today's show, and I was gonna say to everybody, this resistance at 2,912 has been formidable, but I am making the prediction that we are on the hairy edge of breaking out, and when we do, we're going to at least 2,930. And of course, the market beat me to it. That's exactly what happened today. So, I'm a day late to make it, but I had the call right. The obvious question is, what happens next? And, you know, I think that we are still headed higher before this is over. But the big caveat there, Charlie McElligott is no slouch. And as he told us last week, late September is a time when historically you tend to get a pullback. So I don't know that it's straight up from here. I wouldn't be surprised if Charlie is right and there is a pullback that takes us back down.

But, you know, I think we're headed up towards high 2,900s to 3,000. Markets love round numbers. You know, why not put in that 3,000 print on the S&P? And I don't know that it's over there either, Patrick. I do think that we are in some kind of a topping formation. But as you know, Patrick, topping is a process, not a discrete event. And news flow can always change that process. So, you know, where is the top going to be? I don't know. I think we're coming there. I would be surprised if by the first of the year, if we haven't maybe put in a top, at least for some kind of significant correction, if not cyclical bear market. But I don't think there's any reason to say, okay, that's it, we're done. I think it looks to me like we're headed higher. Again, the caveat, as Charlie said, is maybe there's a pullback coming before that happens.

Market wrap: dollar index

Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, I want to actually talk about this in a little more detail. I prepared a couple charts in that chartbook for our postgame after our interview with Art, and I really want to kind of go through some of these different scenarios on the S&P and the levels that everyone's got to be paying attention to. So we'll get back to that in the postgame. With that said, let's move on to the US Dollar Index because we've We've broken that 94 handle, and that's really been a driver. But what's interesting to me is that it isn't actually a broad US dollar breakdown. It really is a euro currency break. The euro and the British pound are breaking out on the upside. You're seeing almost no response in the yen. You're seeing no movement in the renminbi. It really is just a euro currency move here.

But nonetheless, the dollar index is responding. And so we have a breakdown. What's your feeling on how this plays out here?

Erik Townsend: Well, there's actually 2 aspects to this. One, everything you just said is exactly right. But in addition to that, we just rolled over from the September to the December futures contract on dollar index futures. And we've talked about backwardation and how it works on other shows. So many of our listeners know this. If you don't, just trust me. 93.5 is the new 94. It doesn't mean that that 94 support level has changed or we've changed the opinion of where the level was. It's the same level that was 94 on On the September chart is 93.5 on the December chart, and it's because of backwardation in the term structure of dollar index futures. So really what we've said in the past about a close below 94 on a daily closing basis being reason for concern, 93.5 is the new number to watch, and that's where the reason for concern comes into play.

Even though if that happens, Patrick, and this is a tough one for me because, you know, I try to make my commentaries based Based on something that is objective where I can explain a reason for my views, I've got to just be honest and say I got a feeling that there's going to be a head fake lower than that.

And it's just a hunch, Patrick. I think we're headed below 93.5, maybe down to 93, uh, to fake out— markets love to fake out as many people as they can. Everybody would panic at that point. Oh my God, that's it, the dollar is crashing, it's over from here. And then it ends up going the other way, just as so many people got faked out, uh, when we dropped down below 90, you know, whatever that was 6 months, a year ago, and it turned out that it was a head fake. So I've kind of got a feeling that maybe a head fake lower than that is coming. In any case, 93.5 is the number to watch, and we'll see what happens. But I still think that from a fundamental standpoint, the dollar shortage view, which Jeff Snider has described so well, is still what I'm favoring. And until the fundamentals change, I would be inclined not to be shorting the dollar here.

Maybe I think it's not time to be aggressively long because there is room for that head fake. But I would not be going short if there's a daily close below 93.5. I think that there maybe is a head fake coming that's going to fool everybody.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, again, we have a chart that I want to speak to in the postgame about that. But I kind of like the idea of your head fake. But one thing that I kind of think about is, well, what if the head fake isn't just a short-term liquidity event, but rather even sustained distribution down to those kind of levels? Because that to me could really fuel that risk on through October if we have a dollar that's in the gutter. I think that if the dollar was to suddenly reverse and start skyrocketing higher, then that would suddenly derail everything.

Market wrap: crude oil inventories

Patrick Ceresna: So it'll be interesting to see how it plays out. I want to share some charts in the postgame about that. But nonetheless, let's move on to crude oil because, again, we had some interesting inventory numbers. What happened this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, we had crude oil drawing down 2.1 million barrels on the EIA report. That was after kind of a false alarm from API where they thought there was going to be a surprise build. Turned out to be a drawdown of 2.1 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 1.3 million We're getting back to that pattern, Patrick, of persistent weekly drawdowns in Cushing, Oklahoma inventory. And surprisingly, you know, when that was happening before, it was just causing those near-dated time spreads, the difference from one month's price to the next, to blow out to extreme proportions. We're not seeing the blowout in the time spreads that we were seeing before, even though the Cushing inventory has been pulled down to an even lower level. Gasoline drawing down 1.7 million barrels, distillates building 839,000.

Patrick Ceresna: Wow.

Erik Townsend: 100,000 barrels. So with the exception of distillates, drawdowns across the board. Obviously, that was bullish for oil prices. Didn't last though, and I think that on Thursday morning, President Trump tweeting Saudi Arabia saying bring prices down probably put at least a damper on the rally.

I don't know if that will last. I think we should probably save most of the rest of the price discussion about where crude oil is headed for Art Berman because he's obviously our subject matter expert in this week's feature interview.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Market wrap: gold

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to gold because gold bullion, it's staying above $1,200. I mean, it seems to have based here. But when we look at that dollar index, one would think that the gold would be more responsive, and yet it's not. I wanted to give everyone an update on a chart in the postgame in regards to how the gold price to yuan is trading. But nonetheless, for now, what's your thinking here on gold? Are we still going to get a retracement higher here?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think you just touched on it, Patrick, which is what we're seeing in the dollar index in terms of weakness that you would want to equate to a move up in gold. And it's like, hey, how come gold hasn't moved up even as the dollar's weakening? The dollar's weakening against the euro specifically. The dollar's not really weakening against other currencies. And as we've discussed quite a bit in past episodes of this program, the correlations, Patrick, that have been driving gold going back, oh, a year ago, it was really the Japanese yen. More recently, it's been the Chinese yuan, where that correlation has been the more important factor. So, when you see a move down in the dollar index and you expect that to be a move up on gold, you have to qualify what's causing the dollar index weakness. And if it's isolated to the euro, the way it is right now, that doesn't really produce the pop in gold.

Still interesting, though. I think it speaks to the view that we've had about gold here, which is that even with some weakness that should have at least spooked a few traders into thinking it's time to pile into the gold trade. They're not doing it. So I think that it's still about the dollar, and it's mostly about the dollar's relationship to non-euro currencies. And I think that we've probably still got more downside in gold, but we're not going to see the momentum pick up to the downside below $1,200, which has been a key support level, until we see the dollar recovering in a way that everybody can believe in. And as long as we've got this euro strength impairing the dollar index, it's hard for anybody to get super bearish on gold either. So I think gold's going to continue to consolidate here and then probably move lower as the dollar starts to recover on the dollar index.

Now, of course, if I'm wrong about the dollar and the dollar tanks and it's all over, and not just the euro but other currency pairs with the dollar show that to be the case, then perhaps the bottom is in for gold and it's all uphill from here. But I don't think so, Patrick. I think we've still got a ways to go. Now, to be clear, I definitely think gold will have its day in the sun because at some point Not straight away. I think into next year, if not later, we're going to get to the point where this crazy market that's been built up with easy money policy from central banks for the last 10 years, where we have dramatically inflated prices of both stocks and bonds, we're going to get to where stocks and bonds are both selling off together, which is unusual. At least that's my prediction. If I'm right about that and that happens, it's going to be a field day for gold investors to the upside.

And it's mostly about what? When bonds are no longer acting as an effective safe haven and people start turning more and more to gold. Now, most institutional investors can't do that. They have to use Treasury bonds as their safety trade asset. But other investors can look to gold as an alternative. And I think that when we get a systemic bond market sell-off— I don't think it's even about the stock market, it's about the bond market sell-off— that's where I think gold is going to potentially move into positive correlation with the US dollar and move higher. It's a story. That's a story that I think is still 6 to 12 months out though.

Market wrap: Treasury yields

Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to Treasury bonds because June, July, August, 3 months we stayed on the 10-year between 2.80% to 3%. And suddenly in the last 3 days, 3 sustained breaks higher. I think we printed as high as 3.10% on that yield. Is this breakout for real? Are we finally getting a direction that is developed or are you still thinking that this is a fake out?

Erik Townsend: Well, to be sure, we are seeing something going on here. And I would remind our listeners, So, this is a good example of the comment that I've made for the last couple weeks, which is, hey, right now, this time of year, it's time to watch carefully and see what happens, because this is the time of year, seasonality-wise, when things start to really happen and major moves in markets start to take shape.

But the caveat is, that doesn't mean that what you're seeing here is a head fake. The reason they call resistance levels resistance levels is because that's the number that the market tends to go to and then reverse direction and go the other way. That key level is either 310, 3.10 or 3.12 or 3.14, depending on exactly who's measuring it. It's right there, but somewhere between 3.10 and 3.14 on the 10-year yield. And we just barely touched 3.10. Now we're back down to 3.07 on Thursday afternoon. So, so far that resistance is holding. It doesn't mean it's time to panic quite yet, but it does mean it's time to pay very close attention to what comes next. If we see daily closes above 3.10, and particularly above 3.12, 14 on the 10-year yield, that really is a sign that maybe we have a directional move in play, and I wouldn't be surprised to see the trend accelerate from there.

The thing is, we haven't seen that yet. We're on the hairy edge of it, and that's where markets tend to fake people out. So we've got to wait it out and see.

Meanwhile, I want to mention, we normally talk about the 10-year, but Julian Brigden, one of our most popular guests on the program, has made the prediction that it's actually 3.25 on the 30-year Treasury is the number that he's watching most closely, because you can make a very strong technical analysis argument that if you were to see a closing print on the month, not just on the day, but if we got to the end of September and we see a closing print above 3.25%, that really means that there is a signal of a trend change for a trend that's been in play since the mid-1980s. It is a secular reversal in the direction of interest rates. And again, the caveat is the way these things work is markets love to take you right to that critical level, fake everybody out, get them to jump too soon, and then the market reverses in the other direction.

So we could just be seeing a test of that critical level that is not going to hold. And we're, you know, maybe we're about to go big into the opposite direction, head below 2.60% on the 10-year yield. But right now, we're teetering on the edge of a breakout on both the 10-year and the 30-year. And if that is confirmed, it's a really, really big deal. So, it's time to watch and time to watch carefully.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, thanks for the market update. Now, this week's featured interview guest is petroleum geologist Art Berman. Erik's interview with Art is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Berman: what comparative inventory is

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager

Erik Townsend: Joining me next is petroleum geologist Art Berman, and as always, Art has prepared one of his fantastic slide decks for us. Listeners, you can find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not registered yet, just go to Art's picture on our homepage, and next to that you'll find a link where you can obtain the downloads.

Art, it's been way too long since we've had you on the program, and because of that, since we have a lot of new listeners, let's do a quick review of a subject that we've explained in your past interviews, which is this idea of comparative inventory. A lot of people in the oil market look at the weekly inventory reports from EIA, and they just look at that number without adjusting it. Explain why you use comparative inventory, what it's all about, and maybe you can relate that to the graphs you have on slide 2 in your deck.

Art Berman: Well, Erik, it's really great to be back, and thanks for inviting me. And comparative inventory is a very simple concept. Let me explain it briefly. Basically, what we do is we simply take the current storage level and subtract the 5-year average from it, and that's it. Why is this important? As you said, people look at the raw numbers, and the raw numbers are interesting, but the key is not to relate the change in storage to what happened last week or 2 weeks ago, but what happened on this precise week over a period of time. What that does is it normalizes out all the seasonal issues, the refinery maintenance issues, Etc., etc. I've been using comparative inventory for a long time, and in my experience, it is absolutely— if you had to use only one tool, which would be crazy, comparative inventory is the most diagnostic tool to help you understand price trends and where those price trends might be going.

So if that's not a good enough endorsement, I can't sell it any better than that. So looking at slide two, I'm showing two simple charts. The one on the left simply illustrates the way comparative inventory works. And so in in gold, we have absolute stock levels inventories. In red below it is the five-year average, and the shaded area in blue is WTI price because here, of course, we're using U.S. inventories. And so basically. You take the, the gold, the inventories, subtract the red, the 5-year average, and bingo, you go to the right-hand graph, and that's the output. So you simply subtract those 2 curves. And as you can see in the left-hand graph, the red curve is above the gold curve on the left side. Move to the right graph, that equates to negative comparative inventory. The big build in inventory that we saw beginning in 2014, early 2015, 15 that explains the oil price collapse translates on the right-hand graph to the big yellow mountain, and then you can also see the beginning in March of this year where the curves cross again on the left-hand graph.

We move back into a comparative inventory deficit. So right there, in its simplest form, is what comparative inventory is all about. And as I said, the key is. To me, this explains price trends in the best possible way. If anybody wants to understand why we got into oil price trouble a couple of years ago, look at the graph on the right. If anybody wants to understand why prices rose in the first half or so of 2018, look at the graph on the right.

If we then take that same data, which is to say comparative inventory, and cross-plot it with WTI price, which I've already

Comparative inventory history and the repriced yield curve

Art Berman: shown you in the first graph on the left. So moving on to the next slide, which is slide 3, I'll expand that view and show you now the comparative inventory history going back to 2000 or so.

And just for reference, again, you see the big Mount Everest of yellow or gold. That is what we were looking at on the previous graph. And so the point of this graph is to show the comparative inventory ordinarily correlates with price inversely. Okay, so when, when inventory is low, price is high, and when inventory is high, price is low. And that kind of makes sense, except there are a few periods in history in which that has not been the case. And those are periods when the market doesn't care about how much oil is in storage. The market is deeply concerned about supply. And if you look at the circle on the first graph on the left, That's the period leading up to the financial collapse that we're coming off of low supply for several years. We've gotten into huge Asian, mostly Chinese demand, and the market says, "You know what? We don't care if there's a storage surplus.

We're concerned about prices, so we're going to drive the price higher even though the storage keeps getting higher." Similarly, if you look back on the far left of that graph, back in the late 1990s, we went into. Serious deficit, much more deficit than we're seeing right now. And yet, the price response was very muted. And the reason is that back in the late '90s, the market said, we don't really care. There seems to be so much oil in the world. Remember, prices were $18 a barrel in 2018. The market said, that's fine. So, I bring this up not to try to cast doubt on the comparative inventory story, but to try to explain what's going on right now.

So if we then move on to slide number 4, here I'm simply cross-plotting comparative inventory versus price. And so if we look at the graph on the left, I've selected 3 periods of history. I've selected the period in red from 2014 to the middle of last year. I've selected the current period from the middle of last year to right now in blue.

And then I'm showing that funny period in the late 1990s, early 2000s, when the market didn't really seem to care how negative comparative inventory was, price stayed pretty flat. What we see then, starting with the red curve, is coming into the oil price collapse, we follow that line, which is called the yield curve, down, and we see it intersected the price axis, the Y-axis, at about $80 or $85. Well, that is the 5-year average is what that axis represents. It went all the way down to, you know, to the low 30s and 40s, and then we come back to the left, and all of a sudden the trend deviated back in about July of 2017. And frankly, that surprised me. I thought we were gonna go right back onto the same trend, but the market was saying, you know, as we approach that 5-year average, we don't think we need $80 a barrel or whatever the correct price was, that intersection point.

We think that producers have lowered costs enough or that there's been enough deflation in the market that supply can be maintained at a lower mid-cycle price. Mid-cycle is the name of that intersection. And then going back to the 1995 to 2004 price cycle in green, you see we got way, way into negative territory. And yet that green, dark green yield curve, it hardly went up at all, because the market felt we had plenty of supply. So moving to the curve on the right now, this is just a blowup of the red and blue. So we're looking at where we are currently. This is as of last week, but the inventory report this morning doesn't change it hardly at all. And so what this is saying is that whereas in 2014, at the same inventory level we're at right now, we probably would have been at something like $110 a barrel.

Right now, we're at 72. So that's a you know that's a 35% price devaluation relative to what we were seeing in June of 2014. So this is a really important fact, particularly as as analysts and and traders are speculating of wow you know you think we're going to go back to $90 oil or $100 oil or you know whatever the price is, and what the comparative inventory yield curve is telling me.

Anything's possible, but that's not what the curve is saying. That curve is saying that we're about as high as we're gonna go unless the market changes its perception radically from where it's been now for 14 or 15 months.

Erik Townsend: Let me just ask you a question, Art, before we move on, which is, if I look at the red curve on the left, or on the right, either one, and then I look at the blue curve, obviously something's changed. It used to be that when we got to the level of comparison

Art Berman: Right.

Erik Townsend: —comparative inventory that we're at right now, the result was upwards of $100 in oil prices. And that's not the result anymore. I want to ask you about why that might be the case. And particularly, it seems to me like a big change that's occurred about at the same time is the legalization of US exports. I wonder if what's going on is while the overall supply-demand situation is not really what it was before, it looks like it in comparative inventory because now it's legal to export that US oil. Is that a potential explanation for the, the way that the yield curve has moved from the red to the blue curve?

Art Berman: Well, Erik, that's a real good point you bring up, but no, that, that, that, that's not what I believe is happening there at all. Now, you had Chris Cook on MacroVoices not very long ago, and he talked about some of the regulation changes in how Saudi Arabia and some other companies price their oil for European markets. That's exactly when this happened. I don't want to get into arguing the fine points of Chris's thesis, which I think bears attention, but something like that. We see this on— if you look at the Commitments of Traders charts, which I guess I'll show a little bit later, something happened there. But no, I don't think it was it was US exports. And the reason that I don't think that is because that is one of many, many changes that have occurred over the 25 years of comparative inventory data. And usually, it accommodates those things just fine. This is— I'll show you in a little bit the OECD minus US comparative inventory, and it shows exactly the same thing.

I mean, storage is storage. Inventory is inventory. If you've got a deficit, You got a deficit and price goes up.

I think that this change has everything to do mostly with the deflationary trend in oil and gas commodities, which is probably related as much as anything to the change in unconventional oil and gas production. It's also got to do with the fact that everything, at least for a while, was cheaper in oilfield services. So everybody's cost of marginal production went down. US exports are, you know, 1.5 million barrels a day on a weekly basis, which is important, but it doesn't change the dynamics of market balance that much. That's my view.

Tight oil response and positioning

Art Berman: So if we go on then to slide number 5, what I'm showing here is why I think that's happening, at least in gross aspects. So on the left, I'm showing US tight oil rig horizontal tight oil only in blue, and then I'm showing WTI price in gold. And I've just lagged the price back 3 months because that's, that's not only about the time it takes between a change in rig count when we actually see the change in production, which results in the change in price, but that's actually the correlation that works. And, and the importance of this chart, I'm showing $60 a barrel barrel. The key is that we went from 193 rigs at the bottom of oil prices in May of 2016 to 568 rigs by April of 2017 or '18, I'm sorry. We almost tripled the rig count with prices at less than $60 a barrel.

So why would the market not say the whole point of raising prices to get producers to drill more? So the market is saying, "Gosh, we're getting all the response we need at prices below $60. Why should we have to pay any more?"

And then similarly, on the right-hand chart here, we're looking at tight oil U.S. production in blue, and again that WTI price here I've. Lagged it one more month just to account for— well, it takes a little bit longer to get those wells on production. What we see here is that, yeah, living through this oil price collapse, it seemed like production went way down, but the point of this graph is that tight oil production returned to pre-oil price collapse peak level at WTI prices of around $50.

If I look at these 2 charts, I Why in the world do you think you need $100 oil prices to get the supply you want, assuming, of course, that US tight oil production is the marginal barrel or the swing producer or whatever garbage term you want to throw at it, but it is the variable. It is what has changed in the world. It is where we're going to get our surplus from. So that's really compelling thing that's going on.

If we then go to slide six, here we see the same thing going on in managed money net long positions that we did in the change in comparative inventory chart on the left. June 16th, 2017, net long positions are at a very low level, and all of a sudden they start climbing. They climb to a peak in early 2018. Chart on the left is just WTI crude plus product net longs. Chart on the right is Brent plus WTI net longs. Same thing. You've got a low in June of 2017. You go to a peak in January of 2018, and then it starts going down. So I look at these 2 graphs, and first of all, you know, I can't fully explain what happened in June 2016. Something big happened.

More importantly to the present discussion, however, is that since the beginning of 2018, things have been going generally downhill. Traders have been unwinding long positions both on WTI and WTI plus Brent. We saw our maximum comparative inventory negative in early 2018, and it's been climbing back up again. So to me, I see the overall price trend, we've probably We've probably hit the highest price on average that we're going to see in this price cycle until and unless something fundamental changes.

US exports, distillates and gasoline stocks

Art Berman: Looking at slide 7, you talk, Erik, about US exports. US exports have been a very important release valve on US inventories. The US never stopped overproducing oil. Okay. Was one of the key parties responsible for the oil price collapse, as I showed on that earlier graph, we didn't really slow down very much at all.

And we picked right back up, and now we're way past those earlier levels. So the reason that US inventories have not started to build more quickly than they are right now is because we're exporting 1.5 million or 2 million barrels a day out of the country. But the important point that I want to make on this slide, slide is I think that export party is starting to lose momentum. And what I'm showing then is distillates, distillates diesel, if you will. I mean, that is the big cash cow of US refined product exports. And you could see distillate inventories, when they were going down and down and down, price was going up and up and up. If we look then, I mean, distillate is 17% of US exports.

If we look at the graph on the right, what it shows very clearly is that although distillate exports remain strong and they are above the 5-year average, they've declined compared with the record levels in 2017. The reason for that, I think, is that some of our big takers of distillate, Mexico and Brazil, have started to build out their refineries and say, well, why should we pay your high prices? We can refine that stuff ourselves.

So to me, that's a that's another indication that you know maybe things have have reached a peak as far as price and comparative inventory go, at least for a while.

If we look at the next graphs in slide eight, here I'm just showing both distillate and gasoline inventories, and they're both building. Okay, they were falling for a long time. As I said, distillate inventory is still below. The 5-year average, but it's at the highest level that it's been since the end of the first quarter.

Gasoline comparative inventory is well above the 5-year average, and the difference between that 5-year average and stock levels is widening. Right now, we're in the destocking period for gasoline stocks, and yet, we see the trend is that stocks are continuing to move away from the 5-year average. That's another negative piece of evidence in this story I'm building.

Brent-WTI spread and diverging time spreads

Erik Townsend: Art, before we move off of this subject of US exports, what the heck is going on with the Brent-WTI spread, which has just been extraordinary in recent weeks? I've been completely baffled by that.

Art Berman: Right. You've got that 100% correct, Erik, that premium of Brent to WTI has gone from $3.67 to $8.13 just in the last really couple of weeks. So, you know, that margin has— that differential has, has really expanded. And the way I interpret that is that is a reflection of market concerns about supply security close to the Middle East, which is to say Brent. Supply security for WTI not so much concern.

And so when the market perceives that there's a supply threat potentially out there on one versus the other, they're going to buy up those near-term contracts. So that's what I think is going on.

And the other thing that I show in this slide number 9 is that, yeah, US exports are still kicking butt, but not compared with where they were earlier this year. So we've fallen. We were up to 3 million barrels a day in April, but now we're down to something like a million and a half. Last week was 1.6. So we've actually fallen below the year-to-date 2018 average. Now don't get me wrong. I mean, that's that's still a lot of oil, and it's a whole lot more oil than we were exporting a couple of years ago. But remember, you know this whole business of price. It's a razor's edge. You know, I'm starting to add up all kinds of little changes, maybe not so little, but a lot of changes in distillate and gasoline and comparative inventory and Commitments of Traders, and now in exports and Brent-WTI spread. And it's all starting to add up to maybe oil price is not going to go so high.

The other thing I'll mention before we move on, Erik, is that foreign refiners have started to understand the limitations of high API gravity US crude oil. It's great stuff if you want low sulfur, but it makes crappy gasoline, and you can't hardly use it at all to make diesel. Those are the 2 big products that the market's looking at. And the market has started to understand that there's limited use for this stuff.

And by the way, this trade war that we've got now with China, China was, you know, the biggest buyer of US exports, took over first place from Canada. So, they're cutting back. So, that all adds to the story.

Erik Townsend: Art, a topic we've talked about quite a bit on this program has been the bizarre behavior of time spreads in the WTI market. Now, if you go back a few months, there was a blowout to $3 a month at one point. of difference between the price of WTI from one month to the next, and that was August to September and September to October.

Now, as we're getting even deeper drawdowns in comparative inventory and inventory on an absolute basis is lower, you know, it seems like the problem's getting worse, but the backwardation is nowhere close to what it was a couple of months ago. I don't understand what's going on here. Why is backwardation seemingly collapsing on WTI when it was worse on WTI when the inventory numbers didn't seem to dictate it? It doesn't add up for me.

Art Berman: Right. So, there are a couple of things going on here, and I'm not sure I can fully answer your question, Erik, but, you know, building on the point that I made earlier about the Brent premium to WTI, what I see going on here here is that WTI and Brent are going completely in 2 different directions.

These 2 graphs on slide 10, this just shows the 6-month calendar spreads on both WTI and Brent. It was real interesting because it wasn't but a couple of weeks ago that those Brent spreads actually went into contango. We not only collapsed the backwardation, but we went the other direction, but all of a All of a sudden, in the last several weeks, those have turned around, and the backwardation on Brent is increasing. Conversely, WTI, the two were moving in tandem, it just keeps going down. Last week, we were down, those spreads were down from $7.77 to $0.99, a huge collapse.

I look at this simplistically as this is reflecting the two different worlds and how supply security is reflected in market price and in the way that people trade those things.

So what's happening there is that if we're worried about Brent, we're buying the front and we're selling the tail. And that increases the backwardation. If we're not so concerned with WTI from a supply security standpoint, we're kind of balancing the two. Maybe we're selling the front and buying the back. And so that backwardation collapses. I mean, you know, I'm a geologist and I'm no expert on trading, but that's the simple way that I understand it.

OPEC trouble spots and spare capacity

Erik Townsend: Art, moving on to slide 11. Needless to say, supply security has been a major issue with so much going on geopolitically around the world. What are these graphs on slide 11 showing us?

Art Berman: Erik, they're showing us on the graph on the left with all the pretty colors on it, this is the problem we all know about. These are the OPEC countries that are in trouble— Iran, Nigeria, Libya, and Venezuela. Iran sanctions have not even returned yet, and yet the production in those 4 countries has fallen 1 million barrels a day since January and 500,000 barrels a day just since May. So the output from those countries has fallen off a cliff. Now, it came back a little bit in August, which was principally because Libya, that's a situation, it's a seesaw. It goes up and down when they knock out a piece of a refinery or pipeline, it goes way down, they fix it, and it goes back up. But to me, Libya, Nigeria, they move back and forth. Iran's going down, Venezuela is hopeless. So, when the United States decided to pull out of the Iran deal, and of course, Saudi Arabia was really pushing us, or we were pushing together to do that, to put added pressure on Iran.

Probably Saudi Arabia told the US, no problem, guys, we'll just crank up our production. We got all the spare capacity. We'll get our buddies in Kuwait and UAE to help us out, and everything will be fine. Well, the graph on the right shows that that's not necessarily true.

So nobody really knows what OPEC spare capacity is. But let me just be on the record here and say that I don't believe the numbers that we see out of EIA and IEA of 2, 3, 4 million barrels a day. I just don't. It may be there, but it's not marketable crude. It's sour, it's heavy or something like that.

What I've done here, I think that the effective spare capacity is all Saudi Saudi, Kuwait, and UAE. So this graph on the right shows those 3 countries' output, and then in gold, their rig count. And what we see is that that output reached a maximum just at the time that the production cuts were announced in late 2016. Is that true spare capacity? I don't have any idea, but that's the most those 3 countries have ever produced.

So I'm saying for now, now, that's a benchmark or a proxy for spare capacity. So what we see is that about the time that, you know, all these blowouts started happening that you talk about, when the Iran situation became critical, when Trump said we were probably pulling out of that deal, that nuclear deal, these 3 countries started cranking up production. And they have increased production more than half a million barrels a day since April. Well, that's the That's the good news. The bad news is, is that if you believe that November 2016 number of almost 17 million barrels a day, we're just a couple of hundred thousand barrels a day below that. So if you believe this chart, they're going pedal to the metal right now, and they just don't have a lot more room to go. So this slide then shows—

Erik Townsend: I mean, I'll say, okay, So you've made a point, Art, that you know maybe things have maxed out on price. But this chart says, boy, you know I see a lot of potential here for price going up.

Art Berman: And and I acknowledge that. And I've I've said supply security is a big deal. But I've also pointed out that we're not going to go back to the same pattern we were on in 2011, 12, 13, 14. That the markets still think. thinks that it can be amply supplied at $60, $70, $80 a barrel. So that's, that's the point there.

IEA versus OPEC balance forecasts

Erik Townsend: IEA and OPEC famously have very different perspectives on what's really going on in the marketplace. What's going on here in slide 12?

Art Berman: Yeah, so what I've done here is I've taken IEA's forecast for demand on the left and OPEC's forecast for demand on the right. Now, neither of those 2 agencies provides a supply forecast past the present quarter, but EIA does. And so I've developed a calibration algorithm which goes back and, and looks at how IEA and OPEC supply correlates with EIA production, plugged it in, and have gone forward, you know, with this forecast of supply-demand balance. We can talk about where the hair on that is, but it's, it's the best we can can do.

What this shows is that the IEA model says that we have pretty much reached the point that I've described previously, which is to say that we were in deficit in 2017, we've been in balance for 2018, and hold on to your hats, guys, because in 2019 we're gonna go into a pretty substantial oversupply. Production surplus. Now, before anybody freaks out, I mean, it's nowhere near what we saw in 2015, '16, but it is pretty nearly 1 million barrels a day. So that's the IEA view of the future.

The graph on the right is the OPEC view. The OPEC view says, uh-uh, we are going to continue in deficit through the end of 2018. We're going to max that supply-demand deficit in the 4th quarter. And then similar to the IEA perspective, we're going to go into a supply surplus, which is going to be fairly substantial, certainly by the 2nd half, and then we're going to go back into deficit.

I present these 2 graphs not to cast aspersions on the forecasting capabilities of these agencies, But, you know, is it any wonder that investors are confused? You look at the IEA and you say, oh my God, you know, we got a supply surplus coming. You look at the OPEC on the right and you say, well, yeah, we do. It's, you know, but it's not gonna last very long. So, we're torn. Do we want to be long on oil? Do we want to be short on oil? And that's kind of where the market is right now.

Berman's outlook: range-bound oil and Iran

Erik Townsend: Art, moving on to slide 13, the final slide in your deck. You know, you've given us all these different points of view between OPEC and IEA. What do you think is going to happen from here, and what are the driving factors going to be?

Art Berman: Well, that's the question everybody wants the answer to, Erik, but my sense is I see more evidence on the downside for oil price than I do on the upside. I completely understand the upside argument. I completely get why people are very bullish and think that oil prices could be $90 Brent, you know, $75, $70 WTI.

Before the end of the year, and it wouldn't surprise me if they were, to be honest. But looking at all this evidence, I think the motivation towards higher prices makes sense, except when you add in all the other factors. The fact that we're really still in a deflationary cycle in the oil and gas market— it doesn't feel like it because we, we've come so far from, from $30 a oil. But remember, I mean, oilfield services prices are way down. The cost of producing the marginal barrel is way down for everybody, not just shale. The breakeven prices on everybody are way down. So the market is looking at the big picture and saying, yeah, I think we do have tighter supply coming on the horizon. There is an issue about supply security.

But that doesn't mean we need $90 oil or $100 oil to provide incentive to producers to produce more. That the market data says we got so much bang for our buck at less than $60, why should the market pay anything more than what it's paying right now? I could be way wrong on that, but my sense is, is that we're probably going to see range-bound prices. Going forward until something fundamental changes. What do you say to all the people that say, yeah, but look at your graph, look at Iran, look at Venezuela, you know, look at all those problems?

I'm saying I don't know how to answer that. Nobody does.

But my sense is on Iran, this is a completely artificial supply crisis. It is something that was put into place because the US decided, and Saudi Arabia helped us decide, that Iran needs to be punished. I don't want to get into whether that's a right or wrong decision, but it's artificial.

We created that. It doesn't have to be. And my sense is, first of all, those guys in Iran are pretty clever. They're not going to get their exports 100% shut down. They're going to figure out ways through the black market, through accounting methods, saying it's coming out of Iraq or something like And the other thing is, is that we are just getting started, the US is, on granting sanction relief. And the way that all of these aggressive hardline policies that have come out of the Trump administration, the way they've all gone is they get backpedaled. And in the end, it wouldn't surprise me if we gave a lot of dispensations. And And the impact on exports may not be as great as we fear.

Or I don't know that, but I think that's a possibility. Like I said, Libya and Nigeria, they go up and down. Venezuela is already baked into things. There's nothing that's going to happen there.

So, I look at all these factors together. Maybe OPEC's spare capacity is greater than I assume. I don't know. I'm using an empirical argument there. But again, I see we're in a period of secular deflation in oil prices that began in 2014. And I don't think we're out of it yet. The tendency to think, okay, things are finally back to normal, we're going back to the world before 2014, I don't think we're ever going back to the world before 2014.

Bottom line, Erik, I think that we're probably going to see prices range-bound pretty much near where they are right now, possibly going below for the near term. And if either of those forecasts by OPEC or IEA. are correct, looks like prices will go lower than whatever they end up at in 2018 and 2019. But as always, nothing would completely surprise me.

Peak oil and the end of cheap oil

Erik Townsend: Art, I agree with you in terms of where prices are probably headed, but there's one part of what you just said that makes me curious. You said you don't think they're ever going Going back to that pre-2014 level. It seems to me like, you know, peak oil was a very real thing. Now, people misjudged it because they thought it was going to happen on a global scale and prices were going to the roof. And the analysis that had been done was on conventional oil production.

The thing is, that analysis was right on conventional oil production. Conventional oil peaked in 2005, hasn't exceeded that peak ever since, as far as I I know. And the thing that everybody forgot to consider was that unconventional production totally outpaced it.

It seems to me, and a lot of this is based on some of your own writings, at some point, I don't know when, but someday we get to the point where this shale thing has played out. The depletion rates in those wells are just so rapid compared to conventional production. It seems to me that when we get to that point where we've drilled up the countryside like Swiss Cheese, there's no more fracking to do because we've used up all of these shale plays. And I realize that's not right away, but when that happens, it seems to me like really the longer-term picture is everything else is in decline in conventional production. That peak oil thesis comes back into play, I would think, and we do get much, much higher prices. Am I missing something to think that?

Art Berman: No, Erik, you've got it correct. It's, it's, it's really a question of perspective and scaling. Okay. So, let me just say that what peak oil got right was peak price. That got nailed. That was 2008 when price went to $147 a barrel for a day or a week or whatever it was.

Where peak oil got it wrong, as you correctly said, was forever saying, well, we're just— they weren't ignoring tight oil. They were just saying, well, we're not talking about that. We're talking about But I think the real point of peak oil, the part that I take away as true and valid, is that peak oil is really about the end of cheap oil. Okay, and whatever you think about the longevity of shale plays, etc., there's just no doubt that even at the very low prices we've had for the last couple of years, the real constant dollar value of barrel of oil is 50% higher than it was at the beginning of the 2000s. So, peak oil got that right too. And that's why I say peak price, that oil is definitely more expensive now than it used to be. There will be a moonshot.

Okay? I mean, there's going to come a time when you're right, that price is going to go way high just because we've used up all of these marginal shale productive wells.

But the other factor that I think is real important here is the demand side. And I'm not talking about peak demand, okay? I mean, that's a whole other subject that I don't want to get into right now. But I mean, the reason that both of the IEA and OPEC forecasts talk about a surplus in 2019 is not just supply, it's demand. They're both showing weaker demand. And that's not based on an algorithm that I'm using on EIA. That's straight from IEA, OPEC. Demand is weakening. Is it horribly weakened? No, but it's weaker than it has been. And you factor in this emerging market economy and higher interest rates, and you look at things like gasoline consumption in the United States, the vehicle miles traveled just came out this week, and it's actually going down. People are apparently choosing to buy less gasoline because of the price. I mean, we're at, you know, $2.90 or $2.92 a gallon. That appears to be a pressure point for a lot of people.

The Federal Reserve report on, you know, kind of the state of the economy in 2017, that 40% of Americans don't have a spare $400 for an emergency. I mean, it's easy to forget the details. But so it's not like people are saying, okay, I'm not buying gasoline. Of course, they got to buy gasoline. They're buying less. That's the point. And so I look at all these kind of larger factors that clearly get beyond oil fundamentals, but they're supported by the oil fundamentals.

So you're right. There's no doubt that we're going to have a price crisis, but how long will it last? Last. It might last a year. It might last 18 months, but that'll crater the global economy, those high prices. So, there will be a rebalancing which will occur. And when we come out of whatever that relatively short-term price crisis is, we're going to be in a low-price oil world again. So, peak oil is right. You're right. And yet, what I said before about not really ever going back to 2011-14, which is sustained $100, $110 prices for 4 years. I don't think we're going back there, Erik.

Where to follow Art Berman

Erik Townsend: Art, your blog at artberman.com is probably, as far as I know, the best free resource that exists on the internet relative to oil markets. For people who may not be familiar with it, first of all, it's free. Which is really amazing considering the content. It's always full of graphs and charts of the same quality of what we've seen in this deck. Tell people what they can expect to find there and also how they can follow your work more generally.

Art Berman: Right. Well, artberman.com, as you say, Erik, it's 100% free. I, maybe I need my head examined for doing that, but that's the choice I've made for now. You know, you will have to register because we're trying to keep trolls and bots out of things, but I try to post something every couple of weeks that summarizes the kind of thing that we're talking about today. My Twitter feed is on my website, but that's @AEberman12. And I put up lots and lots of graphs every day, have spirited discussions with smart people like you and other traders and refiners and analysts So, uh, if you want to know what I'm thinking, between ArtBerman.com and @AEberman12, that's the way to find me.

Erik Townsend: Well, Art, I can't thank you enough for another fantastic interview. We look forward to having you back on the show again sometime soon. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer interlude

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: oil takeaways and hurricane wildcard

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Art. You know, what's interesting for me was the fact that he's already seeing inventory builds and big supply coming on the markets here at these price levels where we have WTI give or take around 70 and Brent near 80. Yet we're seeing numbers that are starting to look like it was back in 2014.

You know, what did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, I thought that the repricing of the yield curve, the balance point between inventory and price, has clearly got to be super important. And to summarize, I think Art's own view, you know, you can speculate as to what the cause of that might be, but it's hard to tell exactly. It's fascinating to me to just puzzle on, hmm, what is it that caused the market to revalue that balance point in the yield curve? The other thing in terms of where the price action is headed that— it's not that I disagree with Art, just something that didn't really come up in this interview. He's saying, you know, it looks like maybe that price rally is over. And I agree with his analysis completely. But there's a really big caveat, which is we've never had this much activity in terms of named tropical storms in the tropics.

And there is always that wildcard event, Patrick, this time of year where if you get a Category 4 hurricane come barreling through the Gulf of Mexico and hit a lot of producing assets in the Gulf, taking them offline for a A few days, and then it hits the Houston area, and there's a lot of flooding and so forth.

That can have just a huge, huge impact to the upside in oil price. And it's a temporary function. It's a temporary event, but it's very real and it happens. So I would not be looking, despite Art's view, to short the oil market right here.

On the other hand, if we did have that event where one of these storms caused a price spike to occur in crude oil prices, particularly if it's not just in the, the front month that's closing, but if that price anomaly extends into the next contract month after that, I would be looking at shorting there because I think Art's got the right story here. The big picture story is we're probably at an intermediate-term top in this market. I don't want to short this price, but boy, if we got back up to $75, $76 bucks on a weather spike, I think that would be a tempting short.

Live event survey and city options

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, we prepared a really fun chart book that I want to speak to in just a moment, but before we get into our extended equity coverage, can you give our listeners a quick update what we're thinking about our plans for the live events?

Erik Townsend: Sure. I want to keep this quick this week just so we don't bore our listeners that are not interested, but basically we told you last week we really needed you to take a survey, and then the survey broke. I don't know how this happened, but the survey was designed It was designed to skip over questions. So if you answered, yes, I'm interested in coming, it wasn't supposed to ask you the question that says, we're so sorry to hear that you don't want to come. How come? It didn't happen. And we had people saying, you know, I'm 99% positive I'm definitely coming. And the survey asked them, we're sorry, you don't want to come. Caused a lot of people to give up on the survey. We had to ditch that survey, scrap it completely, because the SurveyMonkey system doesn't It won't let you change it after it's been used. So we had to throw that survey away and make a new one. Don't worry if you put the time into completing the survey.

We did very carefully read and take to heart your comments, but we have a new survey that is not broken. So anybody who hasn't yet, please go to MacroVoices.com/survey, read the description of what we're considering there. It's changed a little bit from last week, as I'll mention, but it's more detail on that page.

What we've gotten is some pushback from Europeans saying, hey, we really enjoyed flying all the way to Toronto, but, you know, that was a little bit closer to East Coast. It wasn't so far from Europe. Vegas is a connecting flight. That's kind of tough for us. We have a question for you Europeans. It's on the new survey. How do you feel about Dallas? Yeah, it's almost as far as Vegas as the crow flies, but you've got a lot of nonstop flights from Europe. The reason we really like Dallas is we've got quite a few of our most popular speakers, including Art Berman, who live there. So it gives us the ability to put some really popular speakers at the event. Other considerations: Miami, I think, is what we would do to try to accommodate our European audience. It's impossible to do Miami in January. It's totally sold out. If we go that option, we're going to have to slip the date out a month or two to say March or April in order to accommodate that.

Also looking at Atlanta specifically because that is such a big hub airport. There's nonstop flights to Atlanta from almost every place on Earth. The new survey asks you about cities. We don't have Atlanta on there, unfortunately, because that just came up today. But we are asking you about Dallas and Miami.

We are starting to think that we'll do something a little bit more formidable because people in Vancouver have been asking us to do something more than just hang out and have a beer. Maybe we'll put together an event at a restaurant or something. Where we do some presentations. It's probably going to cost about $100, and it's going to get you into the Natural Resource Conference where we'll be speaking, and also to a MacroVoices event where we might have some speakers and party and some networking and so forth. We're still working on figuring that out. Meantime, we're thinking that we'll probably slip the dates in order to maybe accommodate a different city. A lot of people don't seem to like Las Vegas, but we want your continuing feedback. We will keep you updated as things progress, but please continue to email us events@macrovoices.com. Let us know your preferences and your ideas, and please take our survey at macrovoices.com/survey.

Chart deck: S&P 500 targets and topping template

Erik Townsend: Patrick, moving right along, you put another fantastic chartbook together. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or if you're not registered yet, just go to MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says looking for the download. I see here, looking at page 2, that you've gone from a 4-hour chart that you've been using in our previous postgame chart decks to a daily chart. What's the story there, Patrick?

Patrick Ceresna: It just fit on the chart better at this stage. We've already had such a prolonged move from that February and April bottom that it's worth just kind of looking at this in a little bit of a zoomed-out shot on the traditional daily charts. Nonetheless, let's take a look at the chart book there on page 2, I overlaid the original targets we had somewhere in the $2,880 to $2,940 levels, but I also added one additional measured target in the box which actually measured a chunk of the 2017 rally to project out. And interestingly enough, some of these targets do push into that $2,980 level, so we're starting to approach the $3,000 upper target zones. But, you know, obviously we got a breakout. It may still follow through for another day or two. Will be interesting to see if a dealer gamma roll-off over the weekend really spurs a little bit of a throwback next week, but that's yet to be seen.

But really, it's on page 3 that I wanted to talk about, and it's this idea that what would it look like if what we're currently in started to develop a topping formation into the end of the year? It's a narrative that both me and you share as an idea that could play out, and certainly Charlie shared with us last week a really interesting scenario where we have, you know, a step back here in September, and then we have a big performance grab coming in October that may push that market even towards 3,000. And then we have some sort of a tantrum event that kind of happens at the late October into November. I sort of put it on so visually we can see that this is now starting to technically look what maybe we can argue oil's been doing for the last 3 months. And so to me, it'll be very interesting.

Obviously, this is not necessarily a forecast, but rather it's just a template for us to kind of keep an eye on to see whether the price action is actually confirming that kind of move.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this diagram that you've shown on page 3 is exactly what I was kind of thinking of in my head when I was describing in the market wrap where I see things going. I think the direction's up. As Charlie said, you could see a significant pullback late September, early October, because seasonally that's what tends to happen. I don't think it's all over there. I think there's still a push higher. You know, is it one push that's a final top like you've got on this chart, or is there another down and another push up? And, you know, who knows? But I think we're in a topping process here, so I couldn't agree with you more. Moving on to the dollar index on page number 4, what are you telling us here?

Chart deck: dollar index and euro

Patrick Ceresna: I just really wanted to identify that while we were pointing pointing out this big consolidation zone on the dollar index between 94 and 95 and looking for the break. When you put it into a traditional technical analysis format, the— a natural retracement from the— that April to August dollar rally that we saw, the natural retracement is as low as the kind of 92.5 to 94 level.

And so really, while we are getting technical breakdowns of the dollar index, it still actually fits a lot of the criteria for a retracement. But really, the story of showing that retracement zone is actually moving on to chart 5, because chart 5 I think tells us a better story. And here what I'm showing is the Euro-US dollar cross, and what I added on here is the volume by price bars. And what it shows is that there is a huge series of volume nodes trading between the, uh, one spot, uh, 115.50 to 117 level on the euro, and that there was a substantial amount of consolidation and trading that occurred in that. And today's breakout in the euro really is going to test whether or not we're going to get some sort of US dollar long cover and some squeeze on the euro. And if this breakout happens, we're looking for potential surges up towards, let's say, 119, maybe even 120 on a bit of a squeeze.

And it's really watching this euro and what happens here that I think drives it, because that dollar index is 58% weighted into the euro. So I think that this one chart is going to tell us what's going to happen with the dollar here in the next few days even.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, going back to slide number 4 in your deck, your graph here really shines a lot of light on what I was thinking about the dollar, as we discussed back in the market wrap. Because remember, I was saying, you know, I got a feeling here that there's, there's more lower coming, and I just can't put my finger on it. As I look at this, you know, there's such an obvious head and shoulders pattern here. I don't think that it really is the end of the world and a major reversal. But if you look at that head and shoulders that's now broken the neckline in the last couple of days, it would target about the bottom of that retracement zone. And so I I think that it makes perfect sense to expect the dollar index to sell off into the lower half of that retracement zone blue box that you've got here. And, you know, once that's played out, I think that my view from a fundamental basis is probably the rally resumes at that point.

So, this definitely sheds some light on the perspective that I had on that hunch that maybe there was a head fake lower coming. before we moved higher. What's going on on page 6? You're switching back to the oil market, my own favorite market. What are you showing here?

Patrick Ceresna: The last thing I wanted to just quickly add on this, and it really kind of shows this idea that if this dollar consolidation happens, it doesn't have to be a fake-out where it's just like exactly that, oh, you know, 1 or 2 days or like a week. And the question really becomes if this sustains itself for a good chunk of the October, it really does feed that narrative that Charlie shared with us that the cyclicals could really roll up and retrace and even the emerging markets and other sectors because really they've all been hammered by the strong dollar. So this period where the dollar is pulling back and there's this relief coming, that may mean a lot of these risk-on assets will actually potentially fuel the October

Erik Townsend: You know, I couldn't agree more, Patrick. And I think that it fits so perfectly with Charlie McElligott's view from last week, which is, you know, we see maybe a little bit of risk-off, but a strong rally in October. And as you say, you need to have some dollar weakness in order to allow that to happen. And that, you know, maybe I'm using the wrong word, if a head fake, but a move that is not a directional reversal, but something that is temporary in nature, that is a pullback, maybe is a better word than head fake, would perfectly fit into that scenario. And it would leave us at the end of the year, let's say in December, with the dollar rally resuming, and maybe the top is in at that point on the equity market.

Chart deck: Brent, WTI and Saudi Arabia

Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, I could totally see something like that happening. Really, I think that we should first see whether or not that, that we have a bullish response to the October earnings and what levels that takes us and how the market responds. And then we could kind of fish around to see whether or not this thing has the legs to go to December. But I think right now we have a pretty good template for how things can play out here in the next 6 weeks. So let's, let's see how it plays out. So I wanted to move on to chart 6 though, because really what I have here was I just overlaid Brent oil and the chart for WTI. WTI. And really what I want to show is that most people that track the WTI chart and see like that head and shoulders kind of topping that we're seeing there, we can really identify how Brent really looks actually rather bullish, and it's actually approaching those key $80 levels along the upside that if it breaks out,

it may actually be a full new bull breakout on it that could surge Brent up higher, and that would certainly drag the WTI with it. So I just really wanted to visually show. I share the importance of this $80 level on Brent and, and likely what it would impact on WTI.

Erik Townsend: And I'll just add a comment to that, Patrick. I think that early— well, tomorrow, Friday, and early next week's action is going to be really telling because you've got, from a political standpoint, 2 very strong and important signals in opposite directions. Saudi Arabia commenting publicly this week that they would be entirely comfortable with oil prices moving above $80.

Big green light there to move higher. Then this morning, President Trump angrily tweeting at Saudi Arabia, get those oil prices down. I think that that leaves markets wondering. There have been times in the past when Saudi Arabia was extremely responsive to pressure from President Trump's tweets. Now, my feeling, Patrick, this is just my opinion, is that their apparent readiness to just take what the president says and act on it was because of circumstances that were prevailing at that time that maybe don't exist today. So is Saudi Arabia going to say, yeah, you can want that, but we still welcome higher prices? Or are they going to say, oh, well, as a courtesy to our relationship with President Trump, we're going to back off? I think that Saudi Arabia's next public statement is really going to be a big goose in one direction. direction or the other for the oil market. Because if Saudi Arabia says, thank you, Mr.

President, we'll take your tweet under consideration, but frankly, we don't care, I think that the market's going to move substantially higher on that news.

Chart deck: gold and renminbi

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to chart number 7. And really, again, just a very quick update on where that correlation between gold and the Chinese renminbi stands. And what's amazing is while we keep talking about gold and dollar index correlation. Well, it's just uncanny how, uh, how right now gold is just tracking the renminbi. And, uh, I, I personally still don't really know and can't even rationalize why this is developing, and nor does it mean that this has to continue being the case. But so long as this correlation continues to stick like this, I think we should keep observing and seeing whether or not gold is being responsive to the, to this particular

Erik Townsend: Oh, I couldn't agree more, Patrick. And as we said in the market wrap, you know, this is where it's really been at. And before the yuan, it was the yen. It's not the euro that's been driving gold. And we have to understand that the dollar index is so, so impacted by the euro. So I think that if you're watching the dollar index, because we've been telling you that the dollar is what really is going to govern the gold price, you really should be looking at other pairs, not just the dollar index, but dollar-yuan, dollar-yen, and so forth, and particularly dollar-yuan. I mean, just this chart speaks for itself in terms of how strong the correlation has been.

Chart deck: Eurodollar spread and the Fed

Patrick Ceresna: So, and finally, on chart 8, I just really wanted to touch on interest rates and what the market is pricing in for the Fed. So, what I have here is the Eurodollars, and I took the spread between the December 2018 and the December 2019 contracts. What was interesting is we spent pretty much February through August with the spread being somewhere around 30, sometimes at the upper boundary of 40 basis points, which is more or less that the market was baking in about 1, 1.5 rate hikes for the Fed. What's interesting is that the bond traders made a very decisive call here in the last week, and I really can't figure out what has been the driver of it, but we had this sudden surge between last week this week, shooting this up to now 50 basis points.

Basically, I take it away that they're pretty much banking in 2 rate hikes now next year, which is a very hawkish Fed. And I don't know if I have a full explanation for it, but it's certainly worth observing that the market is actually pricing in that Powell's going to just keep going here. I'm curious what will actually happen. What's your take on this?

Erik Townsend: I think it is so critical, as you say, and it's And that's also very important to our discussion of what's happening with bond yields. The way that the market perceives the Fed policy is just so important, and I don't think it's super clear. I think the market is trying to feel it out, and right now leaning toward a hawkish interpretation. So it's going to be, as you say, very interesting to see how it plays out.

Erik Townsend: Meanwhile, Patrick, I want to move on to slide 9 in your deck. As I was going through the survey responses for our live event that we're planning, one of the comments that I got from one of our listeners is, boy, he said, you know, I don't really care how you organize it. I just want to spend as much time as I possibly can looking over Patrick's shoulder and seeing how he does all this options stuff.

It makes me wonder, Patrick, if people realize what business you're in, because they can look not only over your shoulder, but they can receive basically a detailed daily briefing from you, which you provide as one of the services that you offer to your Big Picture Trading clients. So for some of our newer listeners who may not be familiar with what you do at Big Picture Trading, how about giving us a little bit of an introduction to what you do there, what the service involves, and how people can get a free trial, which I believe this is an honest-to-God free trial, none of the business about give us your credit card first. It's, it's no kidding, no obligation, no credit card, no payment required. Just a free pass. Tell us what's going on here.

Patrick Ceresna: What I do for my paying members is I essentially get onto a webinar every single morning, Monday through Thursday, analyze the markets very similar to the way we talk about the market during this podcast. I get on there and I show the charts and I look at where all the setups are and what we're doing. And then we, we talk about where we're gonna do trade implementations. We do that all real-time during the webinar and it's posted as a recording. And then we send a weekly summary to our our members. And then of course I have educational programs that really bridge the gap. Those people that don't know how to— have issues with implementation or how to put on the options trades, we have different master's programs to actually educate them to fill those gaps so that they can actually train themselves to make good money.

Erik Townsend: So for the listener who wanted to get as much options training from Patrick as he possibly could at the live event, sir, if you're listening, you don't need to wait for the live event. You can sign up for the Options Masterclass at Big Picture Trading and get that education anytime you want. On that note, Patrick, we need to leave it there and wrap the show up.

Wrap and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: So folks, we sure could use your help promoting MacroVoices. Please forward your Research Roundup emails, tell your friends and colleagues, and most importantly, register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Doesn't cost you a penny, only takes a few minutes. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email, which never contains contains any advertising or marketing. It's just a compendium of links to all of the best content that we could find on the internet each week.

Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay. Well, first, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Art. So everyone that wants to go and actually look at the text and absorb what Art's views were, that is available as well. The chartbook that accompanied Art's interview is also available for all of you to accompany listening to this session as well. There's an article from Bob Pisani at TraderTalk, who basically wrote a piece talking about the rumor that the buyback blackouts means weak stocks. No, in fact, not really. And he kind of goes into explaining how companies buy back stock and, and what it really means to go into the blackout period. You'll also find an interesting YouTube video from our MacroVoices alumni Steve Keen, who talks about the US heading for a recession in 2020. So it's a great little YouTube video That's on there. You'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.

Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge.

You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Charlie McElligott — heads up cross-asset macro strategy for Nomura (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Opening: McElligott preview and Dalio's free book

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 132 was recorded on September 13th, 2018. I'm Erik Townsend. Our all-star fall lineup continues this week with Charlie McElligott, who heads up cross-asset macro strategy for Nomura. As many of you know, Charlie's in-depth analysis of the knock-on effects of the vol complex blowup in February got a huge amount of attention on institutional desks all around the industry, and Charlie was kind enough to put together a fantastic chart deck for this week's interview. I think you're going to really enjoy this one, folks. We'll also have an update for you on our efforts to plan another MacroVoices live event after the market wrap. And be sure to stay tuned for our post-game segment after the feature interview, when Patrick and I will discuss Ray Dalio's new book, which MacroVoices listeners can get for free using the special link in your Research Roundup email. Now, to let the truth be told, anybody can get it for free just by downloading it because it's a free book.

But somehow that free offer for MacroVoices listeners sounded so good I couldn't resist.

Market wrap: S&P 500 and the dollar index

Patrick Ceresna: And now I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump right into this. The S&P 500, after having consolidated in what was just a, a very traditional, you know, 50-60 point pullback over the last couple weeks, really the buy-on-dip traders just showed up right off that level that we talked about last week. That kind of 2870 level held the line, and it seems like right after After those CPI numbers and after the ECB announcement, the market just went risk-on, and we've ripped now and are trading very close to 2910 at the time of recording. What's your feelings about the market here?

Erik Townsend: Not quite back up to that August 28th, 29th high, whatever the, the high was, but rapidly approaching it. And, you know, from my perspective, the key point here is the bottom didn't fall out. Remember a week ago everybody's saying, oh my God, you know, September is here, the, the market crash is starting.

It hasn't happened yet. And my gut says the I think the final high isn't in yet. Doesn't feel to me like that. You know, usually when you hit the final top of a market, it's a one-time event. You hit a high and it reverses, never to be seen again. It doesn't feel like that to me. I think we're edging higher towards a breakout to yet another round of all-time highs. Could be wrong, but we'll see.

But as far as any kind of precise tactical view, Charlie is the man. So let's hold the rest of equity commentary for the feature interview.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index because one of the drivers of that kind of risk-on upswing was the fact that the dollar once again pulled back. Really did happen after that ECB announcement where the euro kind of gave that pop, the dollar came off, and, you know, gold popped, the market popped, everything kind of moved.

What's your feeling here? Is this just a short-term blip on the downside, or is there something more to read into this dollar move?

Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, this happened on news, and, you know, it's not like the bottom fell out and the end of the world is nigh. We are below 95, daily close below 95. In fact, 2 daily closes in a row below 95. As I said last week, that's definitely cause for raised eyebrows.

Now, I don't think that we've gotten down to the previous low from a couple of weeks ago. So, you know, I really don't think that it's time to conclude that it's all over here. I would say that it's not looking quite as strong as it did last week. The real number that I would be concerned with is if we saw that support that's been pretty consistent at 94. If we saw a daily close below 94, that would be reason for concern.

Right now, though, I think it really goes back to what I said last week, which is, you know, after Labor Day, this is the time when directions get set in markets. It is entirely possible that we're seeing a top and that we're going to start moving dramatically down on the dollar. We have not seen enough of an indication yet to yield that conclusion. conclusion. But it's the time of year when it certainly makes sense to pay attention and be ready for anything to happen. My expectation, though, is I'm guessing that today's event was mostly a reaction to the inflation print and ECB, and that probably, you know, this too shall pass. I'll be a lot more comfortable with my bullish view when we see daily closes above 95 again.

Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, one thing that I was sort of thinking about in terms of the dollar, wouldn't it be interesting if the dollar just did a proper mean-reverting retracement which is that it kind of even drops down to the 93 handle, breaking a very key technical support where all the consolidation's been happening throughout the summer. A break like that could theoretically drive a true risk-on period where all those cyclical beaten-down sectors rip higher and the stock market rips higher. And that could actually be the fuel that pushes that stock market to the peak. And then the real next meaningful rally in the dollar may truly be when Things are unraveling, and then the safe haven asset of the dollar becomes really relevant again. What do you think of that idea?

Erik Townsend: Well, I certainly think that if the dollar were to break all the way down to 93, say, that you're exactly right, that that could be the impetus for stocks and gold and a bunch of other things to really take off. Would that be the impetus that then pushes a final high, and would the dollar then reverse after that final high? Well, now we're lining up quite a few dominoes in a row. So, I don't really have a strong view, but I do agree with you that if we are to get several daily closes in a row below 94, I think that a lot of people are going to change their bullish view on the dollar, and people that have been waiting to buy gold are going to start buying gold. The stock market's going to be propelled higher. A lot of things could happen. Would that lead to a final blow-off?

I'm not so sure.

Market wrap: crude oil inventories, WTI-Brent spread and hurricane season

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, let's move on to crude oil. Let's start off with the inventories. How did things come in this week?

Erik Townsend: Crude oil drew down 5.3 million barrels, not quite as big as API had expected it to. Cushing drawing down 1.2 million barrels. Now, that's significant because what we've seen for the last couple of weeks is Cushing finally recovering, building inventory even in the face of nationwide drawdowns. That trend has changed. And furthermore, on Thursday, I saw a copy of a Genscape print, which is a private data survey, expecting Cushing to continue next week to fall even further in terms of inventory. Gasoline building 1.3 million barrels, probably a good thing considering the hurricane that is about to hit the East Coast. Distillates building a massive 6.2 million barrels.

Now, all of this resulted, at least immediately after the print, in crude oil trading up. But then by the time that Wednesday was over, it was back down to about where it was before the data came out. And sure enough, Thursday proved to be a pretty big down day. Frankly, I don't have a lot Yeah. There was a really big move down in crude oil at just about 10 minutes after 10 o'clock on Thursday morning, and I don't know exactly what the driver was for that particular move, but it took oil out and equities down with it. Equities recovered, oil didn't. So it remains to be seen what the driver is there.

Production, meanwhile, ticked down to 10.9 million barrels. Now, remember that because they round to the nearest 100,000 barrels, this number doesn't really mean very much, but the point is there was a pretty solid uptrend of production moving up. It's come back down a little bit, so it may be an anomaly in the data, maybe not. If we were to see it go all the way down to 10.8, another tick down, that would definitely cause me to think that maybe the recovery in the shale space is faltering. We'll see what happens.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's talk a bigger picture because I've sort of been looking for a crude oil topping formation. In fact, WTI seems incredibly toppy. Almost every rally seems to be fizzling out and over resistance at the $70, $72 seems pretty formidable. But then you look at Brent. I mean, there's an $11 spread now between WTI and Brent, and Brent actually on the charts looks actually very bullish. Something's got to give. You ain't going to have one blow out to new highs and the other one rolling over and selling. One of the two is going to be a false start. It's really hard to make it out. What's your thinking here on what's happening in the oil markets in the bigger picture?

Erik Townsend: Well, I agree with you on the false signals. It seems like Brent is bullish and WTI is bearish, and they can't stay that way for too long. The spread is already It's already $10 wide. That certainly creates a lot of impetus for exports of US oil. I expect US exports to continue. As far as where is it going from here, I think that hurricane season in general creates a lot of uncertainty premium. Now, this particular storm, Florence, that's about to hit the Carolinas, it's pretty clear that it's missed the Gulf and the Gulf production, and it's missed the Gulf Coast refineries.

But still, it's a major hurricane that's going to disrupt things on the East Coast. Perhaps. Perhaps more importantly, though, there's never been so many big storms building in the tropics at once. It looks like there's 3 or 4 more potential hurricanes. Still, some of them are hurricanes already, some are tropical storms, but they're gathering steam in the Caribbean and in the tropics and maybe headed our way. That brings more uncertainty risk into the market, and I think that's one of the reasons that we've seen oil trying to push higher here for the last several days, as everybody's unsure as what's going to happen.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. Yeah.

Erik Townsend: And we'll see what happens with Hurricane Florence and who knows what in the storms after that. I think once hurricane season is over, though, I'm kind of with you. It feels to me like we're looking at a topping pattern, even with this storm risk and other uncertainties in the system.

We're not getting to a new cycle high above $75 or anything like that in WTI. And so it makes me think that, you know, the market wants to find a top here, but I think maybe hurricane season has to play its course first.

Market wrap: gold

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to gold, because initially gold got a pretty good surge on the fact that the dollar broke and the whole risk-on. But it seems already here, within less than 24 hours, we're almost all the way back down to $1,200. We're trading at $1,207 at the time. I think— why can't the gold seem to get anything in the tank here?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think that the gold market is not very strong, and, you know, it sort of gives a false signal of looking like it strengthened up. Well, look at what happened to the dollar. Meanwhile, the last time that the dollar was down at these levels. We saw gold getting all the way up to— what was the number— around $1,220, $1,221, something like that. Got down to the same level on the dollar, didn't get up as high on gold. And even with the dollar still at 94.5, we're looking at gold losing its steam here. So it feels to me like the gold market wants to roll over and move further to the downside when the dollar reverses and continues further higher. Now, that's assuming that my view is correct about the dollar and that's what's going to happen.

If the dollar breaks below 94, and especially if it keeps on dropping from there, I think that's when a lot of people who've been waiting on gold would maybe change their mind and say, oh, okay, maybe it's over for the dollar. Maybe it is time to buy gold. And I think that would create a real impetus for more gold buying. But I don't see it until we get a clear sign that the dollar is dropping, and we don't have that sign yet, Patrick.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: All right.

Market wrap: 10-year Treasury yield

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because we're slowly here ticking away, approaching at that 3% mark again. You know, when the inflation print numbers came in earlier this morning on Thursday morning, they came lower than expected. I was initially thinking that low inflation, the inflation boogeyman that was messing up bonds, could kind of subside. But really, yields have not really changed much after that inflation number. We're still trading around like the 2.98 level here. What's your thinking on bonds?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, here we are again at the very top of the narrow range between 2.80% and 3%. And each time we've gotten right to the edge and we've said, okay, it looks like maybe we're starting to break past that 3% number, we end up just reversing back the other way. So I think for swing traders, you know, it's time to start betting on the yield coming back down, which would be bullish on buying Treasury bonds. I don't plan to trade it myself. I think that there is a good possibility, and certainly And certainly, as I've said before, now that we're into the middle of September, it's time to watch for significant market directional trends to develop. And I think that it maybe is time that we should be looking for a breakout, but we got to get through 3% first, and we got to get through probably 3.10% after that before we can really say that the trend is on. So I'm still in hurry-up-and-wait mode.

I think it's time to pay close attention to this market. Daily closes above 3% in yield, and certainly above 3.10% would be a very very important signals. But until they happen, I think it's hurry up and wait.

Housekeeping: Toronto videos, live event survey and Vancouver get-together

Patrick Ceresna: Thanks for the market update, Erik. But listen, before we move on to the feature interview, we have some housekeeping items. Many of our listeners are waiting to access the video presentations for the MacroVoices Live in Toronto. What's the status there?

Erik Townsend: Finally, Patrick, 99% there. All 6 feature presentation videos are up and visible at MacroVoices.com for people who've donated $50 or more to MacroVoices in 2018. Now, there is one more video coming, and it's a really good one. It's our town meeting. Where we had all 6 speakers on stage at once, and we had a group conversation with lots of questions and audience interaction. So that one is not up yet. It should be coming by the end of the weekend at the latest. It may even be up by the time that you hear this episode air on Thursday evening.

Meanwhile, I just want to remind people that the way this works is you log in using your username and password. Once you're there, on the black menu bar at the top of the screen at MacroVoices.com, you click where it says MacroVoices live videos. We've had several emails from people who don't seem to be able to find that button. It's right under the MacroVoices logo at the top of the page.

Patrick Ceresna: And since our Toronto event was such a roaring success, what about organizing another live event?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, we've got George and Kathy, our volunteer event organizers, working away on this, but we absolutely need your help, folks. If there is any chance that you may want to attend our next event, we need you to take a survey at MacroVoices.com/survey. This is not just to Forget your wishes. So those of you who are thinking, oh, I'm sure it'll be fine, I'll just wait till it's announced and I'll sign up then. No, look, we need to know how many people want to come because George can't negotiate with the hotel in order to secure event space until we get an idea of how big this thing is. The problem that we have is that in Toronto, we sold out in 10 days. We cut things off. We know that we've got about 75 people who are ready to jump on a plane and fly across the country or even across the world in some cases to come to it.

What's the total audience? Sold out. Is it 80 people or is it 800 people? We have no idea, and until we figure it out, we can't really negotiate with the hotel. The concept that we're thinking about is a longer conference.

We've tried to be driven entirely by participant feedback and the survey that we did from Toronto. We're thinking Las Vegas. We're thinking around February. We're thinking 2.5 to 3 days, lots of speakers, some of the very best interview names that we have at MacroVoices, and we're thinking about introducing a new VIP pass concept, which would which would give you much more personalized access to the speakers. We'd be seating you at meals with the speakers and creating other opportunities for more personalized interaction. There's a lot more information at MacroVoices.com/survey. I don't want to take a lot of time for those listeners who are not interested to not have to listen to this. So please, if you have any interest, go to MacroVoices.com/survey, take our survey, let us know what your interest is, whether you're interested in the VIP option. Once we have that information, we'll be able to proceed.

with our planning, and we'll give you an update on future shows as to where we're headed.

Patrick Ceresna: Also, Erik, our listeners can also find the link to that survey in that Research Roundup email we send every week, and we'll probably keep it in the email for several weeks in a row. So, please, if you're listening to this and you open up one of the— you'll find that survey in the email. So, now, that survey pertains exclusively to the multi-day event. We're considering Las Vegas or one of these other warmer weather cities in the winter. But what about the separate question in regards to MacroVoices event that we were thinking about doing at the Natural Resources The Soros Investment Conference in Vancouver, Canada, out in January.

Erik Townsend: So that one is not our event. We're not producing that conference. The thought was, since we have a lot of listeners in Vancouver and you and I have been invited to speak at that conference, maybe we should do some kind of MacroVoices event on the side. We're struggling to decide, should we just do a party, like get a restaurant and rent a room and have a few beers with MacroVoices listeners, or should we actually add some kind of presentation or something to it? We're not sure. So, for people that are interested, it's January 20th, 21st. What we would be doing is selling you some kind of ticket that includes your admission to the Natural Resource Conference, which has got all kinds of big-name speakers. Rick Rule's gonna be there, Jim Rickards, a whole bunch of big-name people will be at that conference. Again, that's not our event, but we would organize a MacroVoices get-together separate from that. Let us know if you wanna go, 'cause we need a headcount.

And also let us know, do you want us to just organize a get-together, or do you want us to put some kind of presentation together? And if the latter, what subjects interest you the most?

Patrick Ceresna: And those of you that want to let us know, make sure you email it to us at info@macrovoices.com. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Charlie McElligott, who heads up the cross-asset macro strategy at Nomura. Erik's interview with Charlie McElligott is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Charlie McElligott: the two-speed world thesis and the February vol event

Announcer: And now with This week's special guest. Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Charlie McElligott, who heads up cross-asset macro strategy at Nomura. Charlie has put together a fantastic slide deck to accompany this conversation, so please download it. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Charlie, you know, for people who have been following your writing since you joined Nomura in January, I remember the first piece that I saw that really got my attention was where you You described this perfect storm after the VIX complex blew up, and you said, look, if we get to certain levels on the S&P, it's going to trigger the commodity trading advisors. They're going to start systematic selling. It's going to unleash a whole bunch of things. And fortunately, we never got to that level, but I was very impressed with your analysis. And as I followed your work since then, I noticed that although you tend to be writing about the here and now, because that's the way institutional research is structured, I'm able to assimilate kind of a framework, if you will, that seems to guide your thinking, which I've pulled together from reading several of your pieces.

Can we try to present to our listeners a summary of that framework, how you think about markets and how this all fits together? And from there, I want to go into much more detail on your slide deck and a number of other questions.

Charlie McElligott: Absolutely. And I appreciate the opportunity to be here, Erik. It's a great program. I would say that the way that I approach the job with regards to assessing kind of the cross-asset macro landscape from a high frequency, meaning a more of a closer to the net end user, the net end trade idea-driven approach, as opposed to a research deep analytic dive, slower moving, is that because in the post-financial crisis world, trade time horizons, macro regime shifts, factor rotations, systematic leveraging, deleveraging are a permanent part of our landscape. So, what I need to do then is I need to have a medium to longer-term, 6 to 12-month view on where we're looking. Looking while still having a day-by-day directional call, favorite trades, worldview, where are the pressure points, where could things go wrong, where is consensus, and where are the asymmetries there when crowding can tip over.

So, with that said, as I started here at Nomura back late January, right before the vol event, I saw this framework that I called a 2-speed world thesis. And mind you, as I got back in my seat in January after my non-compete gardening leave time, what I saw was immediate. As I mentioned earlier, the importance of systematic strategies, vol control strategies, risk parity, of course, trend following, CTA, those are a critical part of what it is that I do on a daily basis, certainly based within a very vol-centric world. Because the changes, the inflections that are made happen unemotionally and happen with significant leverage behind them. And what I saw when I immediately came in and was reassessing the world at the time was that the most crowded trade in the world, ex-long FAANG tech at that time, was that there was an implicit short-dollar trade in almost every macro trade that we look at across both our risk parity and CTA models.

That was— certainly, there was a max long equities worldview, obviously large-cap equities, certainly tech, NASDAQ, which benefits from those overseas revenues. But then also, too, there was a huge bearish rates trade as people set into the year. There was massive length in euro and yen on the view that policy was going to reconverge, this idea that we were hitting kind of this dual growth. So, as opposed to the prior 2 years where it was just US at economic escape velocity and rest of world behind, everybody got really bulled up on the prospects for Europe, for Japan, for emerging markets, for the rest of the world to play catch-up. And with the twin deficits within the US, this very bearish US dollar view began. People were max long crude, max long commodities. Commodities, it was a pretty consistent theme. When I see something that consensually embraced, and certainly within the systematic leveraged community, the trend community, coming off a year like 2017 where being long S&P was a 4 Sharpe ratio trade, my warning signs were up.

Promptly, we had the equity vol event, which I joked to clients, we all knew what was happening within the leveraged VIX ETN complex.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Charlie McElligott: We knew that those daily rebalancing, the daily vega rebalancing at the end of day was going to tip over at some point. I called it a neon swan for a long time, but something set that off.

What in my mind set that off was if you went back to December, you had the first passage of tax reform bill in the Senate. Shortly thereafter, at the start of December, you had the bottoming, the cyclical bottom in US Treasury term premium, basically interest rate volatility risk. I think I think what that spoke to was that we were late cycle and the economy was already at breakout speeds at that point.

Now we're adding gasoline to this fire. And effectively within the next month, we also got this dual fiscal stimulus of the deficit spend. And what that did, when Treasury term premium bottomed, the entire cross-asset volatility world also pivoted and broke higher after that point. So, in my mind, that moment when the forward-looking path for interest rates became clouded for investors across the world, across multiple asset classes, you no longer knew that late in the cycle, adding on dual fiscal stimulus, what that was going to do with regards to central bank policy, with regards to inflation. That's where the rolling volatility events of this new regime took place.

So, within a week of that, you had the peak in S&P 1-year forward earnings estimates. You had that same week the peak in cryptocurrencies. Within a few weeks, you saw the tights in credit spreads, right? In January, you had a spot-up, VIX-up environment across the equities complex where you had that massive risk rally within stocks, but at the same time, VIX was trading up, which is a precursor, one of those moments where sitting on a vol desk, you're anticipating some sort of crashy, wingy type of event. There was a number of indicators in that 2-month period that something had inflected.

So, to take it back to that larger 2-speed year thesis, the first phase was what I called the cyclical melt-up phase, which was classic late cycle, where the economy in its current shape with the enhanced expectations, the animal spirits of the tax cut, the animal spirits of the deficit spending, You typically see commodities and inflation-centric high-beta assets outperform. So, my view at that time was, you want to be within the rate space, you want to be long TIPS, short nominals, long breakevens. You want to be bearish fixed income in general from the US Treasury side. And on the equity side, you want to be long cyclicals, the stuff that works that frankly had been— some of which had been left for dead. Fed for a long period of time, the stuff that gears when you have interest rates moving higher from real growth. So, financials, materials, energy, industrials, those deep cyclical types of sectors. And that's exactly what we got over those next 6 months.

You had very consistent, pretty high Sharpe ratio, even with the volatility event in February and some disruptions thereafter in the coming months. These trades kept generating returns in June.

To fast forward, May and June, I started seeing some signals that there was this shift developing into my phase two, right? My phase two was what I call the financial conditions tightening tantrum phase, and from that, this is basically a transition from a very directional long risk, long inflation, long cyclical. Bearish fixed income type of view to a much more difficult tactical phase, right? Where trading windows, time horizons on trades were going to be multi-week, every month kind of powerful reversals, market-neutral trades to protect yourself, seeing relative value, sector selection really take precedent. And in mid-June, I sent out a note talking about this downshift and that it was time to get tactical.

And, you know, I think it makes sense probably to go over some of those indicators that I saw at the time that frankly signaled to me that we were transitioning out of this smooth sailing phase into this very late cycle and effectively pre-recession phase.

September seasonality, the momentum trade and the QT impulse

Erik Townsend: Well, and as we are now recording this interview in September, I think of September as a very important month because, you know, the big boys are back from the Hamptons, the, the big decision makers on the desk. It's maybe time for something to happen. I think you've written recently about 2 flavors of September, so I'm curious I'm curious, what do you watch for? Where is September? What are the possibilities of where it might take us? And how does that fit into your phase 2, everything's changing, market tantrum scenario as far as what we might expect in Q4?

Charlie McElligott: Absolutely. When I speak to those things that started inflecting in June, what ended up really happening too was that the status quo momentum types of trades that had been driving performance for the last 1 to 2-year period for frankly, started coming a little bit unglued, whether it was bouts of extreme reversals in equities growth versus value, where suddenly value would start ripping over growth, or that period of cyclical outperformance over defensives would start reversing. Those were generating signals of performance pain. So, for the next— in that June, July, August window, some of the most acute acute drawdowns within the hedge fund communities, whether it was more within the equities community, but also too, parts of the macro community were giving back their entire year's performance in a matter of weeks to months. And that is a signal. I monitor performance very closely, the same way I monitor positioning and sentiment and where consensus is. And when you start seeing those types of reversals, where crowded shorts are outperforming longs, momentum on You started seeing from a macroeconomic perspective, Treasuries rallying on strong inflation data.

It told me that there was some sort of macro regime shift happening. So that big performance drawdown painfully set up a call that I made in the beginning of August, that looking at the seasonality of equity factor performance, that there was going to be a huge momentum rally, which is a perverse dynamic after you've had such a drawdown. I mean, there There was a number of very large funds that lost anywhere from 6% to 8%, 9%, even 10% in a few, say, 5- to 8-week period there, that playing the seasonality of September— and September is dating back to 1984, the second-best month of performance for a momentum factor strategy. And a momentum strategy is very simple, right? You look at the Russell 1000.

You take the top decile of performance names over the last 1-year period from a price return perspective, and you go short the bottom decile. And this is the Fama and French stuff that's been so documented with regards to what are the actual drivers of equities. You can rationalize why does September see such a momentum outperformance, which of course would be this big, massive pain trade for so many funds that had grossed down their positions, meaning that that all those macro regime signals that I was speaking about in the June, July, August period, where crowded growth names, tech, FAANG, started coming unglued, and the underweights, the shorts in value sectors started squeezing higher, that means the funds were grossing down. So, they were covering their shorts and selling down their longs. That's a classic de-risking reality when you're— the shoulder tap, right? You had an environment where people had grossed down And/or taken their net exposure down. So, just either by selling their longs or growing their short books, thinking that the market was at risk.

And there was a lot of growing skepticism and pessimism over the course of the summer, obviously around the rolling volatility events within the emerging markets complex. Commodities were down 10% plus from their earlier in the year peak. The developed markets within Europe around Italy, there was a lot of bearish stuff going on, and a lot of it tied into the escalating trade tensions.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Charlie McElligott: that there was this kindling basically for a massive rally.

And the September rationale is very simple. Momentum works as fund managers' window dress. So, at the end of every quarter, what many fund managers have done is that you add to the stocks that have worked when your investor letter goes out, your filing goes out to your investors, and you sell down the names that haven't worked because you don't want to look like a clown. And particularly in September, Then this phenomenon really escalates because in September, you start getting a number of very prominent mutual fund year-ends. Both the September and October window are the vast majority of mutual fund year-ends. It's not actually calendar. So, that accelerates that tax loss selling component on the momentum short side. And on the momentum long side, people are window dressing. They're marking up, they're buying stuff that's worked. So, over the course of August, exactly what I spoke about played out.

Massive rally, 10% rally in the momentum long-short momentum market-neutral strategy, which just really crushed both the hedge fund and mutual fund community.

September now has an incredibly distinct seasonality dating back well over 30 years, is that you actually see people get back to work. It's conference season. Investors, PMs, CIOs are getting ready for the earnings season that kicks off in October. There's a refocusing, there's an optimism in the air, and you see the first 2 weeks after Labor Day, the market slowly grind higher. Then the back half of the month, almost like the 15th to a T, you begin to see risk come off. You begin to see defensives outperform cyclicals, which of course, again, is a pain trade. That's not how people are set up in their current worldview. And so you have this dynamic where the back half of the month you fade. And I think, frankly, a lot of that is tied both into September expiration, where you have a lot of dealer gamma rolling off, and as well into the October earnings season. You see 2 of the 3 biggest buyback sectors being tech and being financials.

Those folks begin to enter their blackout windows. So we all understand the dynamic that in the quantitative easing period that you've incentivized corporate malinvestment, bringing debt for free, basically, to buy back stock and strike your options, and makes your shareholders happy and makes the C-suite happy. That buyback virtuous cycle has not stopped. And frankly, after the tax reform package, has only accelerated with the repatriation of those dollars. Most of that has gone to buying back stock. You hit the blackout window, you have a downdraft in the equities market in September. So, we put the momentum trade on in August, it crushed it. Now, I've taken off the long momentum side, and I'm just keeping the short momentum trade on for the back half into then what I expect to be another powerful rally starting in October, largely, again, driven by this performance chase phenomenon, because funds have just so massively underperformed index and benchmark over the last 3 months that now you're you're in career preservation mode as you push through Q3 into Q4, and people will start grabbing at the market again, especially around earnings season, where it's a well-documented phenomenon where managers put on their blinders, put on their macro blinders.

They tune out the emerging market stuff. They get very into the health of the balance sheet, the earnings growth story, the scale of the buyback. And typically, that's a constructive environment for equities.

From there, I can go in a lot of different directions, but what it speaks to is that almost without a doubt, on a 1-month basis, you have these entirely different trading environments, entirely different regime changes, just as the same way as you went from this June, July downdraft in risk, and then you had this huge momentum re-risking in August ahead of the September seasonality.

And September then has 2 different feels. October is going to have a big risk melt-up move into actually a macro phenomenon that I think is going to be a very powerful negative force, a quantitative tightening impulse, that where the 3 largest central banks in the world, ex the PBOC, are all going to be quantitatively tightening. The US Fed SOMA account, the Fed balance sheet runoff escalates to the $50 billion a month At that same time, the ECB's bond purchases taper in half starting in October. And then the BOJ, who recently moved their yield curve control range up, that's effectively going to create a further stealth tapering because you simply don't need to buy as many bonds and potentially as many equity ETFs because of that yield range gives you more flexibility on volatility. So I think you could actually have have the potential for another potential interest rate shock that, you know, risk assets obviously do not tend to like, as we experienced back in January, February period.

Slides 2-4: ED5-9, macro factor model and the dollar

Erik Townsend: Charlie, why don't we go ahead and jump into your slide deck? It's pretty darn clear here from page 2 in the deck that ED5-9 is almost at the low point in terms of where its cyclical lows have been. That part's clear. What may not be clear to some of our listeners is what the heck is ED5-9?

Charlie McElligott: So the Eurodollars curve is a way to trade short-term interest rates, or Eurodollars, that is. And it's not the currency, but it's talking about US interest rates, US interest rate futures. And what is important here is these, again, so often we quote the yield curve from a 2-year, 10-year, or a 5-year, 30-year basis, which have absolute value, right?

There's a long-term view with regards to economic sentiment, inflation, Fed policy contained therein. But what's so important about the short-term interest rates and these spreads or these curves is that it's giving us a much more real-time prognostication tool with regards to where the market thinks the Fed is nearing the end of this normalization cycle. And the end of this normalization cycle is critical for the culmination of this phase transition from the cyclical melt-up phase into the phase 2 financial conditions tightening tantrum phase that is going to have major implications for cross-asset universe and fund performance.

Erik Townsend: And moving on to slide number 3, what are we looking at here?

Charlie McElligott: So, slide number 3 is telling a story that is picking up within a macro factor PCA model that I use as part of my framework. Framework, where what we are beginning to see then is that that same phenomenon that slide 2 was showing, which is that as that curve inverts, and that's looking out a year, a year to 2 years from now, then inversion there means that the market is now believing that somewhere within that time period, looking out 1 year to 2 years, that the Fed is going to stop hiking, and it's now more likely that there's a slight easing.

And why that's important is that that gives us a goalpost. And on slide 3, my macro factor PCA model is showing that the equities complex is now registering that tighter financial conditions are now having a negative impact on S&P, meaning stocks, US equities are now picking up on this very late cycle nature of where we are.

are picking up on this tighter financial conditions phenomenon that I'm speaking to. And in this particular slide, it's showing that the US dollar, which is maybe the most important financial conditions measure of them all, is now— a higher dollar is now a negative for stocks. And that is important because, as you can see, just recently, as of this summer, we were at year positive correlation between the dollar and US stocks. And my rationalization of that is because the US at that time was this lone beacon of growth in the world, right? So investors wanted to be long US assets.

Crude's bounced at that time. And the fact that the US is now on pace to be the largest exporter of crude in the world, long dollar is a very pro-cyclical, pro-US economic indicator.

Now, the data is showing us in our macro factor PCA model that a stronger dollar is now officially a headwind because it tightens global financial conditions.

Erik Townsend: And is that a prognostication that the dollar rally is about to end, or does it mean that it's going to continue, but it's going to be bad for stocks and watch out, look out below for equity markets?

Charlie McElligott: Well, I think that there is— and frankly, this touches on slide 4 as well, where it's also the same tool that we use looking at the 2 other main indicators that I use to assess financial conditions. You see both inflation expectations, which for the last 2-year period have been massive positive US equities drivers, have now too inflected negative, as well as global real rates. And real rates are nominal interest rates that you are actually including as well an inflation outlook in as well. So, real rates are are the purest indication of financial conditions tightening. Right now, we have all 3 of these things moving higher in unison.

That's why this is now confirming to me that incremental moves higher in the dollar from here are going to be perceived as pretty powerful risk asset negatives. Frankly, by the time that that affects what the Fed is going to end up You know, whether or not that means that they say sometime in 2019 reduce the number of hikes that they currently have planned, the curve will steepen. And by the time the US Treasury curve steepens, that's when equities begin to sell off.

Slides 5-6: funding costs and China's credit impulse

Erik Townsend: And as we move on to slide 5, it looks like we can expect tightening conditions across the board in all sorts of different measures of short-term credit cost.

Charlie McElligott: Right, right, exactly. I mean, the key here is I just wanted to highlight those 2 boxes that we're back at 2009 levels. 2008 levels, excuse me, of tighter financial conditions. That's looking at 3-month T-bill, the ultimate cash equivalent, LIBOR as obviously the cost of money, US aggregate credit yield to worst grinding back to 2009 levels, commercial paper. This is the stuff that lubricates the financial system, general collateral repo on the bottom. That's the stuff that makes the system work, that funds businesses. It's critical to keep moving.

That's simply higher yields on that stuff, higher interest rates on that stuff slows down the velocity of money. And that's ultimately pure financial conditions tightening.

Erik Townsend: We've had a lot of conversation on this program about the risk that's created by the massive credit expansion that has occurred in China since 2009. What is slide 6 telling

Charlie McElligott: So, it's an interesting slide that I reference a lot. I have so many requests, you know, okay, can I see the updated Chinese credit financing impulse framework? Because it tells a story, you know, it flows down. But what you can see in that top panel is that the Chinese credit impulse, which is basically the 12-month change in new credit as a percentage of GDP, has now moved sharply negative and back Back to levels last seen 4-plus years ago. And what is key there is that this comes off the back of something that we're all very cognizant of right now, certainly as it pertains to these occasional global growth scares, certainly the EM wobble right now, the emerging markets wobble right now, is that over the last 2-year period, the Chinese, knowing that they have a debt bubble on their hands, a credit bubble on their as they try to transition their economy to a service-based economy from a commodity-centric manufacturing one, have tried to rein in the aggregate social financing, have tried to begin deleveraging movements, have tried to begin controlling the shadow banking system.

Ultimately, what that's done is they've created tighter conditions there as well. As that credit impulse, these new loans that are being forced out to banks per quota, Kuroda, those asks from the PBOC and from the central planners have eased.

What ends up happening is that in that second panel, all system liquidity then slows as well. There's a seasonality. There's a very powerful seasonality with Chinese credit impulse, Chinese financing, certainly into their New Year at the start of the year. There's a huge impulse to feed that multi-week shutdown, and then you taper off from there. What ends up happening though, is that you're seeing under this deleveraging regime, a diminishing magnitude of these impulses. And all of those middle panels lower show what the diminishing magnitude of that credit impulse has on Chinese financial conditions, meaning on that 4th panel, Chinese financial conditions moving lower, that means tighter financial conditions. The next panel speaks to Chinese inflation surprise Index trailing lower. You see these peaks and then these fades. And the yellow line is that global inflation surprises, meaning is inflation data, CPI or CPI core data around the world beating or missing? On average, those are missing now, those global inflation.

China is the engine that drives global inflation is what I'm communicating here. From there, that blue line is US Economic Surprise Index. You see it correlate with those credit Impulse dryings, those credit contractions.

You see our own Economic Surprise Index contract significantly, where currently we're actually still negative, meaning we're missing more on average. And the ultimate cyclical indications, industrial metals or equities cyclicals versus defensives, follow that exact same pattern. And why this is all very important right now, obviously, there's been a ton of press on this. And I think it's a little bit noisy, but is the scale of the— within the leveraged fund community, certainly macro funds, absolutely the CTA side of things, trend followers, is that there's a huge short in Treasuries, right? And the huge short in Treasuries is based on inflation escape velocity, but you have this drying of the Chinese credit impulse that's actually creating a disinflationary impulse, especially with the yuan depreciating.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Charlie McElligott: And that is risking, of course, potentially, you know, significant short squeeze in the US Treasury space.

Slides 7-8: autos, homebuilders and curve steepening

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide number 7. I know because I have a home on the coast of Maine for sale, and the realtor tells me it's past peak in the cycle. Don't expect great prices for a while now. Looks like you're seeing both home and autos telling you the same thing. What's going on here?

Charlie McElligott: You know, again, I think context is important when you look at prior cycles, prior recessions. And what I want to communicate here is that by the time that the Fed has stopped hiking, in the months and 1 or 2 years prior, you've seen near-term peaks in the auto sector and the homebuilder sector. And that makes sense, right? This is very rational. These are incredibly interest rate-sensitive parts of the economy.

And those sectors in particular begin to pick up on this fact, right? I mean, it's Simple, say after a Fed hike, there's an initial impulse that then creates higher mortgage rates, that then creates buyers to move to market. I got to get off the pot and transact in this house. Well, you got that, and now you're fading. Obviously, part of this story here, too, is inflation. There's inflation and the tariffs and building products and things like that in this current, more steeper fade in the homebuilder space, but these are large purchases.

These are large purchases, 30-year mortgages, large auto loans, they're very interest rate sensitive. And both of these sectors are incredibly cyclical and pick up on this late-cycle shift back to that bottom panel is telling me that we are probably nearing the end of the Fed's hiking cycle. My major message here is that I think there's an increasing likelihood that 2019, even though the Fed is currently telling us they're projecting 3 hikes the market is only pricing in 44 bps of hikes versus the Fed's 75 bps, that there's an increasing likelihood that the Fed might have to pause, if not never get to those 3 hikes. And this is just another kind of signal that we are very late in the process.

Erik Townsend: And I see on page 8, you're looking at a comparison going back to 2003 through 2008. What's the story on this particular chart?

Charlie McElligott: You know, I think it's, it's kind of a narrative clarification where you see it every day in financial media. And I've spoken about it too, how important the inversion is as a signal, the yield curve inversion is as a signal. But I think what people are missing a point there, this signal is telling us that we are transitioning, right? But what you need to, as say, an equities investor, is realize that it's when the curve steepens, that's the moment when equities come off. So, you can see here in early 2007, The yield curve began to steepen. If you recall, early 2007, before the mortgage crisis was— that's just when you started seeing the signals. I think in January or February, you had HSBC pre-announce on their mortgage portfolio. By the summer, you had the Bear Stearns structured leveraged credit hedge funds blow up. You started seeing the yield curve steepen because you began to pick up up on the fact that the Fed's hiking cycle had paused and was nearing an end.

That's the top white line there. And the curve steepening accelerated because what happened was the market began to remove hikes from their projections. And what that does is that the front end rallies massively, yields move lower in the front end, the curve steepens, and that's when that blue line, the same time By the time that the Fed began cutting, it was too late, and equities sold off, and equities were smoked while the curve continued to steepen.

So, it's when the curve steepens that equities investors need to be afraid. And I think that's why one of the most popular trades we've done all year for clients have been these curve cap options. They're constant maturity swaps, but basically, it's a very simple tool that lets you bet on the direction of the curve. And what people are doing are putting on these 1-year or 2-year expiry steepening trades via these options with a defined P&L and timeline that are huge risk-off hedges. We've been putting them on in massive size for macro funds, for credit crossover funds, for equities funds, because ultimately, the takeaway here is that the curve steepener is the risk-off move. When the curve begins to steepen, that's when the market smells the slowdown, smells that the Fed is done, smells that the financial conditions tightening has negatively impacted or is beginning to negatively impact the real economy.

And that's when you have the risk-off move.

Slides 9-14: late-cycle inflation and labour indicators

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 9, it looks like even more late-cycle indications.

Charlie McElligott: Yes. Slides 9 through 14 are just a number of metrics that I look for a signal in. And you can see the pressure building on the Fed with regards to— and I'm just looking at a couple of Dallas Fed metrics here in particular on slide 9. But with the idea that inflation is finally percolating and is here, whether it's wage inflation, wage outlook at 11-year highs, prices received at 7-year highs, prices paid for raw materials, 7-year highs, those are speaking to the really difficult position that the Fed is now in. Tomorrow's CPI number is going to be massive in that sense, because it's either going to tie their hands or it's going to allow the Goldilocks environment to continue. And slide 10 is similar. You know, more that price is paid.

You're talking cycle highs since the financial crisis. This is classic pre-recession behavior. The next slide on 11, the wage surveys, expectations for wages, you're at cycle highs. And frankly, you're back to secular highs at these current levels. Again, a useful indicator that we're entering that pre-recession phase.

Erik Townsend: Slide 12.

Charlie McElligott: 12, the U-rate, obviously, with a 3 handle now, these typically max out in late-cycle pre-recession phases. As the economy overheats, you can't find employers. We hear about it every day in the front of the newspaper. Employers are having a difficult time hiring. That creates a drag. So that's very consistent. Then on 13, this actually goes back to that cyclical melt-up phase, right? You have crude as a tell for this late-cycle inflation when the economy is overheating. heating, you see these significant crude rallies.

Back in the early '90s, 131% move in crude. In the late '99 move into the internet bubble burst, you had 120% move. In the pre-financial crisis phase, a 230% move. Right now, we're nearing a 90% move in crude. So, that's also beginning to rhyme. And then finally, this is a pretty unique one, but one that I love. It's consumer confidence expectations minus the present conditions and speaks to this tremendous overshoot of confidence. And you see these kind of cycle lows where we currently sit as a great tell on a pre-recession period coming soon.

Erik Townsend: Now, since you mentioned tomorrow's CPI print, I should mention for our listeners, we're recording this interview Wednesday afternoon, which means we don't know Thursday's CPI print or the outcome of the ECB press conference also scheduled for Thursday.

Slides 15-20: hedge fund underperformance and factor reversals

Erik Townsend: Just to make sure our listeners are aware of where we are. Moving on to slide 15, it says a lot of really, really rough times for equity hedge funds. What is causing this underperformance for equity hedge funds?

Charlie McElligott: Erik, I think it's the purest example of the regime change catching folks flat-footed. You know, it goes back to that transition window. You can see where the drag really started in, you know, kind of mid-July. This idea that we're moving from quantitative easing to quantitative tightening tightening. And what that does is create— and as the term premium bottomed, you've had these rolling volatility events in emerging markets. You've had flash crashes in BTPs and US Treasuries. This is an environment where it began to then play out, as I spoke to in June when I made that downshift note, where I started taking off those very pro-inflation long directional risk trades and moved into defensives over cyclicals, moved into value over growth, which is a huge status quo momentum reversal.

That's exactly what happened. Hedge funds got caught in legacy positioning and began to get crushed for it. In mid-August, when I put on that long momentum perverse rally that I spoke to earlier, that's exactly what you saw. You saw some relief, because the growth stuff began to work again into that seasonal phenomenon of momentum performance in September. Now, because that trade worked so well, it returned 10% in a month, you're seeing performance fade again while the tape continues to hold. So, it's just been an extraordinary period of reversal. And most importantly, almost in a month-by-month or 2-week-by-2-week swinging from one side to the other. That has just made it very, very difficult for the average manager to perform.

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 16, it looks like even more indications of reversals.

Charlie McElligott: Exactly, Erik. This is just a factor monitor, a US equities factor monitor that I look at that just captures these rolling reversals that are very performance negative for folks, where you have all this stuff on the far right, second to last column, all the year-to-date performance sharply reversing in the short term. And that just speaks to, as you said, it's picking up quantitatively the phenomenon that is this macro regime shift to tighter financial conditions. The next slide, you just see hedge funds grabbing at market exposure, which speaks to their performance undershoot, speaks to the fact that they've had a hard time making money. So now they're grabbing at the market, which again, Again, makes me a little bit uncomfortable for the setup, and I think sets up nicely for a pullback in the end of October. Slide 18, same way.

You see it's capturing some of these quant momentum unwinds. And you can too see on slide 19, just equity long-short hedge funds really struggling into what you capture on slide 20, which is this herky-jerky seasonality. Yeah. And after that, it's more of the same. Crowded trades are at risk of tipping over. And ultimately, the jewel trade is going to be 2019 when the yield curve steepens and you begin to see US value stocks, which have suffered post-crisis period, begin to outperform growth. That's the trade that every fund in the world is scared of missing. But if you're early, it's killed your performance. So a lot of this stuff is really just capturing So, I think that's a really important part of capturing the current environment and picking up on the fact that the game is real-time changing from where we've been the last 10 years.

Outlook: tactical path for Q4 2018 and 2019

Erik Townsend: Why don't we leave it there in terms of the slide deck? Because we've only got a couple minutes left, and I'd like to end with the big picture. With all these things together, it seems like there's just every place you look, there's another sign that we're at the end of the cycle, that maybe it's not over yet, but we're getting close. Where does that leave you in terms of outlook? We've had some people say, look, you know, this is it, the bull market's over, it's time to expect a major reversal. Other people are saying, hey, wait a minute, do not discount that possibility of one more melt-up to a blow-off top before it's finally over. Where do you think we're headed? What's your best guess as to what we can expect for the rest of 2018 and into 2019?

Charlie McElligott: So, as per the message in that Downshift note that I sent mid-June, it's the same view. You have to be completely tactical. You can't just be lazy long, and certainly You certainly can't be lazy short right now because yes, I do agree. I think that probably into the December Fed hike, which could be one of the final hikes, some people say it might be the last hike, in all honesty, I think we print probably cycle highs for stocks. Incredibly, between now and then, I think there's probably 3 or 4 different directional trades, as I referenced earlier.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Charlie McElligott: I think right now, you're getting ready for that September, back half of September pullback in risk, which again, is related very much to dealer gamma runoff around expiration, as well as the buyback blackout for financials and tech sectors. And then that sets up into earnings season in the macro blinders trade, higher equities, and probably a really powerful grab. And frankly, one that I'm interested in playing with probably an emerging markets long, because it's been so distressed at this point.

We're seeing some upside option trades going through, pretty good size, and EEM, EWZ, FXI. I think that people are getting ready for that potential upside move into October.

And then, as I mentioned, the potential for a risk-negative impulse in the end of October and beginning of November, not related to US midterm elections as much as some people want to talk about that, but more with regards to that quantitative tightening impulse that I spoke to earlier where the Fed, the ECB, and the BOJ are all tapering asset purchases or their balance sheets. And with that, I think you could have an unruly move higher in interest rates that the cross-asset or risk asset universe doesn't like. So, again, almost on a monthly, biweekly basis, you're going to be in a different regime, long, short, long, short again, and then long rip into what I think will be highs into one of the last hikes of the cycle in December.

Erik Townsend: Well, Charlie, I want to thank you for a fantastic interview. It is no surprise that you have gotten so much attention since joining Nomura in January. For our institutional listeners who do use institutional research, please tell them where they can contact you, where they can find out more about the work and the research that you have on offer.

Charlie McElligott: Sure. As it's a product of global markets, you know, off the trading desk, if you are covered by Nomura within the global markets business, whether that's fixed income, rates, credit, FX, or the equity derivatives space, just contact your salesperson and, you know, we're happy to begin that dialogue. Use the Daily piece as a conversation starter and go from there.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. And for our retail audience, you just have to keep— needless to say, ZeroHedge has been all over your writing since you joined Nomura, and we look forward to having you back here on MacroVoices at some point in Meanwhile, Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction to the interview

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Charlie. Now personally, I'm a big fan of macro cross-asset quant analysts. Uh, the 3 of them that I enjoy the most is Charlie, also Marko Kolanovic at JP Morgan and Michael Hartnett at Bank of America. So this week's show was near and dear to my heart as I always like to approach the markets in a similar manner that they do. It was interesting to me that his narrative was that there was going to be a very volatile 4th quarter with multiple tradable swings both higher and lower. And this generally fits well with, as a technician, to the storyline of a bigger topping formation because usually at the tail end of a major bull market begins a period where this beautiful bull trend starts meeting heavy supply. And so every rally is met with heavy distribution, but it's not ready to begin heavily selling to the downside. It's a lot different than what we experienced back in January because that vol event created an almost, almost immediate crash to the downside on the markets.

But I think this time it'll be a little bit, uh, choppier, uh, in trying to catch the turn point in this market. Anyway, what did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's interesting you say that because I had a very similar reaction. The thing that really speaks to me about Charlie style, and I noticed it in that first piece that he wrote in February after the vol complex blew up, is, you know, everybody else in the industry, they just look at either fundamental analysis or technical analysis. It's, it's, you know, the, the old-school stuff. Charlie's not looking just at that. He's looking at the cause and effect of, okay folks, if we get to such and such a level on the S&P, it's going to cause the commodity trading advisors that are all running algorithmic strategies, it's going to trigger a sell signal, and that's going to cause them to do this and this. And when they do, that's gonna cause so-and-so to do that and that. And this sets up this vicious cycle, which could lead to this, that, and the other thing. On the other hand, if it goes this way, these people are gonna do this and those people are gonna do that.

He's very in touch with what the real drivers in the market are, which is what the big funds are doing, what the algorithmic traders are doing. And he's got a very good sense of what the trigger events are gonna be that could cause a series of knock-on effects to occur. So it's a style of analysis that I just have tremendous respect for, and I really

Postgame: Ray Dalio on CNBC

Erik Townsend: felt this was one of our better interviews that we've done on the show. The other thing, though, Patrick, that really spoke to me this week was Ray Dalio's interview on CNBC, and we've got a link to that interview, or the video of that interview, on the Research Roundup email. And, you know, I don't know Ray Dalio personally. I wish that I did. I have a tremendous amount of respect for him, but reading between the lines in that interview, I noticed something. First thing, the book is free. He's in philanthropist mode.

Why is Ray Dalio, whose entire life has been about making money in markets, suddenly giving away things for free?

And if you listen to the way he speaks, if you can get him to speak without the CNBC hosts interrupting him in mid-sentence, what he was trying to say is maybe this is not a bigger financial crisis than 2008 for financial markets, but Ray is very concerned that for Main Street, for average American citizens, that we could be headed for a situation that's really, really ugly. And I think that what he sees in markets, and I agree with him, is that, you know, in many ways Ben Bernanke pulled a rabbit out of a hat and delivered a miracle with quantitative easing and so forth. But it was a miracle for Wall Street. It completely saved the million-dollar banker bonuses and all that. It didn't do that much for Main Street. It did get the economy restarted again, but we shot our wad. We don't have enough resource now. The next time that we get into a crisis to deal with what's likely to be much deeper social problems.

And I think what's going on, if I— this is totally my speculation, just the strong impression I got reading between the lines in that interview, when those lines weren't being interrupted by CNBC hosts, was, you know, it felt to me like Ray has decided that he has made a fortune in financial markets and it's time for him to redeem himself and give something back by raising the alarm bell, not on We're about to have a bigger-than-2008 market event, but we're about to have a bigger-than-2008 social event, which is going to be harder for working-class people. And I think Ray is very sincerely concerned about that. I wish that his people would accept our interview invitations. We've been trying to get him on the program for a long time. I guess we're just a podcast. And it's true, we're just a podcast. We would let Ray finish his sentences on this podcast, something he doesn't get the chance to do on TV.

He tried to tell people Patrick at least 3 or 4 times, if you just read the first 60 pages of his book— and I think he knows it's a 500-page book, some people are going to be intimidated by it— he said, if you just read the first 60 pages, what you're going to get out of it is— he tried 4 times to say that and they cut him off every time. So I still don't know what I'm going to get out of reading the first 60 pages, but I plan to read it in order to find out.

Postgame: Dalio's Debt Crisis book

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, I also watched the video and I did actually have the opportunity to read the first 60 pages. And so I really, uh, I took a lot away from it, and I actually thought that what best way to plug this to our listeners is give a couple excerpts that I thought were really meaningful in the book, kind of inspire everyone to pick it up and read it. So on page 19, Ray Dalio was talking about the role of monetary policy, and he goes on to say, this is one of the biggest problems with most central bank policies because central banks target either inflation or inflation and growth and don't target the management of the bubbles. The debt growth that they enable can go on and finance the creation of bubbles if inflation and real growth don't appear to be strong. What's interesting is, is that it's asking the question, are central banks actually targeting the right thing by targeting inflation directly and rather than targeting actual bubbles and asset and debt bubbles?

And he's asking that question, is that have a congressional mandate given the wrong goals to central banks and what they're targeting? And is that one of the reasons why these debt bubbles actually Well, I certainly agree with Ray.

Erik Townsend: Unfortunately, what I fear is that, you know, the status quo, the central banking elite and governments in general are stuck in this deficits don't matter and the national debt's not that big of a problem mentality. And it's something that's just not a big deal until the day that it blows up and bites you, and then it's too late.

And I couldn't possibly agree more with Ray's view. I'm just afraid that it may fall on deaf ears because certainly central bankers are not thinking about using monetary policy to manage the debt. I think that the view of central bankers is that it's not their problem. It's Congress's problem to worry about whether or not the national debt is out of control. And Congress, frankly, is not doing a very good job with it. So, I agree with him. I just don't know what the solution is.

Patrick Ceresna: I couldn't agree more. So, now, I wanted to just touch on the next thing, which is he then gets to a part on page 20 where he talks about spotting bubbles. Like, what does a top of a debt crisis or debt cycle look like? And what he identifies, and I thought this was really interesting, was in terms of what a top looks like. He goes, early on in the top, some parts of the credit system suffer, but others remain robust. So it isn't clear that the economy is weakening. So while the central bank is still raising interest rates and tightening credit, the seeds of a recession are already being sown. And he goes on to say, the fastest rate of tightening typically comes 5 months prior to the top of a stock market.

And I thought that was really interesting because when we listened to Charlie McElligott, he already thinks that we've got only a few more rate hikes left and the Fed is done. And that means the fastest rate of hiking actually already happened. And so, I wonder whether we're now deep into this 5-month clock that Ray Dalio seems to be referencing in this.

Erik Townsend: Well, I certainly think that it's consistent with the conversation that we had with Charlie in this interview. Charlie doesn't think it's over quite yet, but he thinks that we're getting close. And I don't know if it's a 5-month clock or what the exact number is. As you know, tops are processes, not events. But it feels to me like we're getting closer and closer to this thing finally being over.

Postgame: three forms of monetary policy

Patrick Ceresna: The last thing that I wanted to touch on here was starting on page 35, which he titles Pushing on a String. And what's interesting, he touches on the 3 forms of monetary policy that central banks can use. Obviously, the first one, the most well-known One is the interest rates, which is the movement of raising or lowering interest rates as a way to actually stimulate the economies. But the second monetary policy approach is quantitative easing, which is the idea of buying financial assets, particularly debt assets, which is something we already experienced.

But what's interesting is then he gets on to monetary policy number three, and this is where or the idea of monetary policy number three is the money is more directly put into the hands of spenders instead. Of investors and savers. And so this is where it gets interesting because he talks about the idea of the increase in debt-financed fiscal spending, the idea of increasing the debt-financed spending while Treasury isn't on the hook for that debt, not bothering to go through issuing debt and instead just giving newly printed money directly to the government to spend. Then goes on printing money and, and, uh, doing a direct transfer to households, also known as helicopter money, something that many of our listeners may have heard before. And of course, the idea of big debt write-downs accompanied by big money creation, or the kind of a debt jubilee. And I thought it was really interesting because that's the type of monetary policy we have not yet experienced.

And so we saw number 1 and 2, where we first went from just interest rate responses to now quantitative easing responses. So the question becomes, if the next debt crisis comes around, are we now in store for this next phase? And you know what, if that's the case, that's a pretty good case for the gold bulls, isn't it?

Erik Townsend: Oh, it certainly is a good case for the gold bulls, but I also think it is a huge societal story. And this is the reason I'm so frustrated that we can't get past the people that filter Ray's emails, because the interviewer in me, Patrick, is just itching to talk to Ray. And, you know, obviously you got to ask him the question about what's going to happen in financial markets. He's a financial markets kind of guy. But I don't get the sense that that's what he really wants to talk about. I think what he really wants to talk about is those of us who work in financial markets have made a lot of money and are better off than most people in society. What's going to happen in this next crisis, and what do we owe to society in terms of making things right? Because I think that there was a lot of injustice in the way that the 2008 event was handled.

Yes, Bernanke pulled a rabbit out of a hat and managed to save the markets, but folks on Main Street didn't fare as well as the folks folks on Wall Street. And from what Ray said on CNBC, I think he's very concerned that the folks on Main Street are going to be much worse off in the next crisis that comes about. And it's just overwhelmingly clear to me that he has very strong feelings about that, and I would love to do a feature interview. So if we have any listeners who have access to Ray Dalio, please reach out to him. The folks who screen his emails for him have been extremely polite. They respond to us politely and decline our interview requests. And, you know, It certainly is understandable. Ray is one of the most famous people in the entire industry. It's no surprise that if they've never heard of a podcast and he's only got time for TV appearances, that that's their position.

I really wish that we could get through to Ray, and perhaps the way to do that is to promise him that we really would let him finish his sentences and say what's on his mind and not be interrupted every time he tries to tell us what to expect if we read the first 60 pages of his book, which I'm looking forward to And on

Wrap-up and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: that note, we need to wrap it there, folks. We really appreciate your support, particularly with helping us to promote MacroVoices. So please tell your friends and colleagues about MacroVoices, and most importantly, if you haven't yet, go to MacroVoices.com, register your free account. Won't cost you a thing. We won't spam you or sell your email address. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email each week, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just a compendium of links to all of the best free content on the internet.

And it's free. we could find on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: So this week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview. You'll also find that link to the chartbook that accompanies Charlie's interview. You'll also find the link to download Ray Dalio's free Debt Crisis book that we just talked about. There's also a link to Kevin Muir, the Macro Tourist's most recent blog, which talks about the, the big bond short illusion. And what's interesting is he sheds some light on the flaws of how the COT reports are actually compiled. That was a really interesting read. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners. And we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag. tag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

Now, if you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Erik Townsend: Thank you.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-quality guests. profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. Sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit. MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top