Alex Gurevich — HonTe Investments founder and CIO (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 153 was recorded on February 7th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. HonTe Investments founder and CIO Alex Gurevich returns as this week's feature interview guest. Alex and I will discuss everything from the business cycle to bond yields to global risks posed by China's debt overhang to the future of the European Union. We'll have an abbreviated postgame segment due to travel schedules this week.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's start off with the S&P 500. What's going on?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I've said in the last several weeks, I think that we've seen the first big wave down in a new bear market and that what we're in now is a bear market rally, a correction to the upside. Question is, is it over yet, or does it have farther to go to the upside before it's time to short this market? Now, it's difficult when you're dealing with views in different time frames. I'm definitely bearish in the long term. I think the top is in. I think we're in a new bear market, and that means at any point some bad news could really tip the scale, and all of a sudden, you know, major sell-off is upon us again. We don't really have that big news event or catalyst to the downside. Well, Patrick, all things considered, with corporate buybacks back on the radar screen and everything else, I'm guessing that we're not done yet and that maybe there is more upside in this market before we eventually top out, roll over, and head back down.
Well, Was today's abrupt sell-off on Thursday morning the beginning of the end? It could be. I kind of doubt it, but anything's possible. We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to that US Dollar Index. Is this thing going to break out?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I've been saying for I've forgotten how long now, I am definitely bullish the US dollar. Now, what I said last week is, boy, with the Fed pivoting to this very dovish stance, you know, maybe that's going to result in a pullback that would last for several weeks before a Eventually, my outlook for resolving to a higher dollar would be fulfilled. Well, geez, it's only a week later, and despite the dovish pivot from the Fed, already we've moved to a new, at least on an intraday basis, a new higher high. So we've put in a higher low on an intraday basis, a higher high in this dollar chart.
Everything is looking— and we've moved well above the level that we were at when the Fed made that dovish pivot announcement. So this incredibly dovish news has suddenly come back out of the market, at least as reflected in the dollar index, in just a week. How is that possible? Charlie McElligott had a couple of notes in his morning letter today. He thinks that as everyone else has pivoted dovish, it's basically the race to the bottom game. And the US still looks like the cleanest dirty shirt in a very dirty laundry pile. So that perhaps is explaining some of the strength. I think, though, that there's no way to interpret this but as Unexpectedly, you know, better than I thought. And I've been very bullish on the US dollar. The big test, though, we need to get to a close above 97, 97.50 maybe, in order to really show me that we're moving to the next level in this dollar bull market.
But I think the dollar rally is about to resume, and the next test is going to be 97 and then 97.5.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, let's move on to crude oil. What's your thinking here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I've said for several weeks now, I think we've already topped out in a consolidation range between 45 and 55. I think the next move is a slow grind back down to 45, and then it's going to be a question of whether we can go lower, say below 40. It would take some bearish economic news and inventory data to get us there. The market kind of dumped with equities and everything else this morning. We got down to about 51.80 this morning before bouncing back, and we're looking at We're sitting at about $52.70 as we're recording, just after the pit close at 2:30 on Thursday afternoon.
So, you know, as we get down to that level that we tested this morning, $50, high $51s, between $50.50 and $52, there's a fair amount of resistance levels in there. So I think it'll take several days to grind through it. But barring any unforeseen geopolitical news, I think the ultimate resolution is likely to be lower, down to $45 or so.
We'll see. I'll let you know when we get to that point.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what's your thinking here on gold? What's the next move?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, today is a perfect example of an up-up day where gold and the dollar index both moved up on the same day, and that's exactly the pairs trade that we discussed in your market huddle with Kevin Muir. So I think that something has definitely changed here. My view, the reason that I had been bearish about gold, is I really thought that Despite what the naysayers were saying about the dollar, I thought the dollar was going to move higher. That led me to be bearish gold. Well, I got the dollar call right. The dollar is moving higher, but gold is moving higher at the same time. Now, that outcome of the dollar and gold moving into positive correlation, where they both move up together, is something we've been predicting on this podcast for more than 2 years now. But it hasn't really started to happen in earnest, and now we're seeing some pretty strong signs that it is happening.
So, uh, I'm going to be I'm looking for a dip here. I think we probably do have maybe a little bit further to dip before this is over, but it's starting to feel to me like that pairs trade, long gold and long the dollar at the same time, is making an awful lot of sense.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what's your thinking here on the 10-year Treasury yield?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we're slowly trending lower, down to 2.66% on the 10-year, but, you know, Alex Gurevich is the man for Treasury yields, so I'm going to leave most of the commentary on fixed income for Alex's interview.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's featured interview guest is Alex Gurevich from HonTe. Erik, why did we choose to bring Alex back to the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's been too long. Alex is a really smart guy, excellent macro thinker, and I think it's been more than a year now since we've had him on the program. I was actually speaking to Juliette Declercq at MacroVoices Live, and Alex's name came up, and it caused me to remind you to get him back onto the program. So I'm really looking forward to getting his perspective on so many of the themes that we've been talking about, whether or not the business cycle is over and so forth. So, why don't we go ahead and dive in and listen to Alex?
Patrick Ceresna: Great. So, Erik's interview with Alex Gurevich is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Alex Gurevich, founder and chief investment officer at HonTe Investments in San Francisco. I am so excited, Alex, to have you back on the program. It has been so long. You are an interest rates guy from way back, and boy, you know, interest rates, Treasury yields in particular, have everybody's head spinning. Before we go into rates though, why don't we start with the bigger picture of the business cycle?
Is it finally over? You know, for so long, a lot of skeptics were saying, you know, it's overdue for this business cycle to be ending, credit cycle to be ending, but we kept getting proven wrong and it had a little bit more left to it. Is it finally done?
Alex Gurevich: Well, first, I'm glad to be back as well. And secondly, yes, it is done unequivocally. I called for the end of the business cycle actually exactly a year ago. I pinned my tweet that we're transitioning into the late-cycle dynamics. And I feel last 12 months, we're following step by step exactly the playbook of the ending of the last 2 cycles. And I think where people have disagreements and feel certain things as being the signs of economic strength, those exact things actually historically indicated the end of the cycle.
Erik Townsend: Now, there was something that we heard from another guest on this program, which he said, fear the steepener. That was Charlie McElligott. saying everybody worries about the yield curve flattening. It's actually when you get to a steepening just before everything falls apart that you have to worry. Are you echoing that same view, or do you mean something else when you say the opposite of what people were expecting?
Alex Gurevich: I am not actually using a yield curve as an indicator of anything. I've written about this for a while. I feel like shape of the yield curve is only as much of an indicator of economy as, for example, if you're falling off a tall building, and you're flying by the 10th floor, that's a good indicator that you're going to hit the ground, but it actually doesn't carry any new information.
So, I feel yield curve is based on information that is already available and actually does not say anything new to us. It's more of a product of the inputs.
However, in terms of playing the yield curve as it should be, it is indeed true The curve tends to be really flat when we go to late cycle. It actually stabilizes on the late cycle. It happens before each of the recent few recessions and refuses to invert too deeply, just as everyone is calling for inversion. And then when the Fed actually starts cutting rates, a very rapid steepening and somewhat sometimes defying logic, defying steepening starts to occur. Like, for example, when Fed starts cutting rates at the beginning of recession, usually long bonds don't benefit from those rate cuts at all, and all the benefit goes to 2-year notes.
Erik Townsend: So, we're talking about a bull steepener where it's not about the 10-year yield blowing out, it's about the 2-year yield collapsing. And I shouldn't say collapsing, but rather being forced down by policy action, which is trying to be more accommodative to the economy. Does that lead you to a trading strategy? I know you, you said the information is already there, but sometimes you can play it. Do you look at something like a 2s-10s steepener in this environment as a trade that you consider, or is there a better way to trade the market as you understand it?
Alex Gurevich: I tend to not enter long-short trades, so I typically actually don't do curve trades at all. Instead, I decide which part of the curve I want to be long. And for years, it has been— I've been focused on being long classical bond futures. And now I'm being distributing to the earlier part of the curve.
The classical bond futures, the long end of the curve would prevail if I'm wrong and Fed continues, stays on hold for a while or even hikes again, which seems increasingly unlikely, but many smart people still see it as a possibility. So assuming my view of the world is wrong, And Fed stays hawkish, long bonds would benefit tremendously, while the short end actually could sell off from here. However, my central scenario is that Fed is starting to cut rates somewhere in the middle of this year, probably June to September 2019. And for this purpose, I like being long the very front end of the curve, which will most benefit from this.
Erik Townsend: And with respect to what's going on in general with interest rates, so many people were persuaded of what I've come to call the Jeff Gundlach view, the notion that, hey, you know, we've reached the end of a 35-year cycle, it's time to move back up in interest rates. And everybody was so convinced if we broke 3.10 or so on the, on the 10-year yield that, you know, we'd never turn back. Well, needless to say, we turned back and we turned back in a pretty big way. So how do you see the overall development of the Treasury yield space over the next year or two? What's driving this and what should we expect?
Alex Gurevich: Well, first, I was really puzzled by people— well, puzzled, probably not the right word, because that happens at the end of every business cycle right before a huge rally in the bonds about to begin. A lot of people are saying that this is the end of the bond bull market. It already happened several times during this continuous 40-year-old bond bull market, which I think is only beginning. I think the real rally in the bonds is actually ahead of us.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Alex Gurevich: The last 40 years were just a taste. And because of convexity, actually, 30 years when they rally from 3% yield to 0 yield could rally as much in price as they would rally from infinite yield to 3% yield. So, convexity-driven rally could be really staggering going on forward from here. So, that's the big picture. I also put zero weight on discussions like breaking 3.1% yield. On 10-year notes, honestly, I think it's sheer nonsense.
I don't think interest rate instruments obey to any yield charts. Because when you— first of all, yield charts are meaningless to begin with, because they don't reflect actually anybody's P&L. Only total return charts matter for interest rate instruments, and fully funded total return. And even those charts, I think, have limited use in US interest rate markets. But that's a subject for separate discussion.
Also, yields have negative predicting power. So, the higher they go, the lower they're likely to end up eventually, because higher yields create tighter monetary conditions, which is easier policy. So, the fact that rates sold off last year only increased my conviction that rates are going lower eventually, because that created tighter monetary conditions.
And as for the longer story, well, we see the story playing out In every developed market country, we have population growth declining gradually. Japanification is unavoidable. Government budget deficit is expanding. Government debt is expanding. Rates are unavoidably pulled to zero. And I think US is possibly in the last spike of rates before we go into perpetual zero-rate policy.
Erik Townsend: Let's tie the US dollar into this because we've seen a very strong US dollar in the last several months. A lot of people, though, would say, You know what, of course you see that because the Fed was in a hiking cycle, and at the same time they were also beginning to reduce the size of their balance sheet through quantitative tightening. Now we've heard an announcement that maybe they're done with their hiking cycle, at least for now, and maybe they're even going to reduce the rate of balance sheet roll-offs. Does that change the outlook for the dollar? Is there an argument that the dollar has peaked here and it's time to move lower, or how do you see it evolving from here?
Alex Gurevich: Absolutely not. It would be intuitive to expect the dollar to get strongest at the end of the hiking cycle. That's not how dollar historically behaves. In fact, one of the first hints that I got that we reached the end of the business cycle was the big sell-off in the dollar that occurred in the winter of 2018, exactly a year ago. That actually is rather typical of the end of tightening cycle.
Interestingly, dollar index bottomed out the previous times in September '99, a few months before the end of the hiking cycle of '99-2000, and not that long before the recession. And it's also dollar bottomed out in February 2008, right at the onslaught of the Great Recession. After that, early in recession, even as the Fed is cutting rates, dollar typically rallies and rallies pretty sharply.
So, I would expect for the next 2 years, very strong tailwind for the dollar and dollar performing stronger. And I wouldn't expect to see serious weakness in dollar till we go to zero rates and new round of quantitative easing.
Erik Townsend: Alex, you just mentioned quantitative easing. But before we go there, the official story is still quantitative tightening. So, let's talk about the dynamics of how quantitative tightening affects markets. But why don't we start with how much quantitative tightening do you think is left? left before, as you say, they reverse policy completely toward another round of easing?
Alex Gurevich: My best guess is probably 2 or 3 months more, but the range of possibilities is very wide. I do think they're reluctant to stop quantitative tightening, and the evidence has to be very strong for them to change policy, which is very bullish for bonds because it makes me sure that Fed will not get ahead of the curve.
Which means that financial conditions will remain tight into the beginning of this recession.
With regards to quantitative tightening, I believe quantitative tightening is a counterpart to fiscal expansion, because it's essentially increasing the supply of US Treasuries out there that someone has to buy. And there are 2 possibilities. Either foreign buyers have to buy the incremental supply of Treasuries, which drives capital account surplus and drives dollar up because foreign buyers have to buy dollars to buy US Treasuries. It doesn't matter at what price they're buying them. Eventually, someone has to buy them. So, on a given day, we could have all sorts of price durations of Treasuries, but they have to clear somewhere.
So, alternatively, and I think we've seen more of that, that domestic buyers have to buy US Treasuries, but that just displaces other investment. They have to take money out of other things things and to put them into Treasuries. A third possibility that would deny this story is if the incremental buyers of Treasuries were institutions like banks who can use them essentially like cash as collateral.
Now, in this case, I'm going to give you my conjecture. My conjecture that banks are tapped out and are not strong incremental buyers of Treasuries. They've had as much of them as they could over the last few years. But I think due to various balance sheet restrictions and regulations, they can't really have too many of them. So, the incremental Treasuries will go either to domestic buyers displacing other investments and slowing down economy, or to foreign buyers driving dollar up.
Erik Townsend: Alex, you mentioned driving the dollar up. Something I've noticed in recent weeks or months has been the commodity currencies like the Canadian dollar and Australian dollar have been awfully volatile. What's going on there? And how does the commodity currency complex fit into this whole macro story?
Alex Gurevich: Well, Australia appears to have its own idiosyncratic story developing, just as it has been very much idiosyncratic over the last few decades and avoided recessions. It developed a housing market, which some people consider to be a bigger bubble and a bigger mortgage bubble than US had in 2008, both in terms of debt-to-income household ratio, and even in terms of actual quality of mortgages.
I cannot confirm it firsthand, but secondhand reading research, there are opinions that the quality of mortgage market in Australia is worse than it was in the US in '07. And the unwind could be even more brutal on a country scale than the unwind in 2008 was in the US. So Australia could be heading for a very, very deep recession. And it seems to be at this denial stage that US was in '07 when we started to have subprime mortgage problems. But people were saying, well, there is clearly a problem with the mortgage markets, but that's not a problem with the economy. And '07, when the Fed eased a bit, stock market even actually reached new highs in October '07. And that was already after the major freeze of financial markets and major problems in the mortgage market.
And somehow, for a few more months until Bear Stearns went down, things occurred— seemed to be kind of okay. And I think we're in the stage, both in the US in terms of broader markets, but definitely in Australia, people already absorbing the scare of housing market correction there.
But I don't think they yet realize how much damage it will do to the real economy there. That would be, again, my most likely conjecture.
So, I think a similar situation may be developing in Canada, because Canada debt-to-income ratio is also pretty severe and also higher than in US in '08. And they also may have a housing problem. I'm not really an expert enough to yet say that it's going to happen. In Australia, it just happens to be more observable already.
So, I think that's what's driving those currencies also. Especially Australia, not just the falling commodity prices per se, but the idiosyncratic housing market unwind.
Erik Townsend: So, just as housing was supposedly contained to subprime, Australia's problems are contained to the extent of their exports to China, which is like half of their GDP. So, let's talk about China and bring them into this, because I'm assuming you would agree with me that all of Australia's woes are really a reflection of China's woes. What's the story going on in China? Where is it headed? And how is it going to affect other countries like Australia and others around the world?
Alex Gurevich: Well, China is always a very difficult country to make strong predictions about, because even though I may have strong views, but the timelines they operate on are very different from the usual business cycles that we're used to in developed world. And because of their ability to, without any red tape, basically implement whatever stimulus measures they want, their ability to manipulate the situation and postpone any financial problems or gloss over them is very vast.
On the other hand, historically, the math of what's going on in China is not working out. They have huge amount of private debt, probably not precedented in history. And again, I'm not the person to do the first deep bottom-up research on what it is, but we're talking about tens of trillions of dollars, more than US, more than anything, both in terms of absolute numbers and in relation to GDP, it's also huge numbers.
And typically, such debt can only be sustained by very rapid growth, because when you have a very rapid growth, even if your businesses are not profitable, the cash flows generated by new growth can assure debt service. So, it's kind of like a Ponzi scheme cash flow situation. I think that game is over for China. Honestly, I thought it would unwind 3 or 4 years ago.
But 3 or 4 years ago, we had a very different picture. And that's why any calls for global recession 3 or 4 years ago were ex ante incorrect, because we had a positive momentum on interest rates.
So, interest rates have fallen globally very significantly by 2015, 2016. And that provided a relief for any kind of debt problems around the world. We don't have the situation today because the rates in the US have risen. The rates in other countries have stayed at least stable, but not fallen. And I believe that China cannot service the debt within its economy, and usually, some sort of catastrophic unwind should occur. As the history is with communist country, typically this unwind kind of happens in the background, but then it's much more abrupt and terrifying than it does— than it's in the market economy.
Erik Townsend: When we had things fall apart in the United States in 2008 and 2009, it was largely because nobody fully understood just how much was being securitized and how some of these very exotic mortgage products worked. And that led to an overleveraging and a misunderstanding of risk. And point— people have pointed out when they look at something like Canada and China's housing markets, where you don't really have that kind of risk, it seems to me like China is the place where you do have it. So if China were to really fall apart, if we had an unwind of the unsustainable debt, the excess debt in China builds up just as the excess unserviceable subprime debt in the United States built up to the point of bringing on a crisis. Is there a transmission risk? You said it was not justified several years ago when it was a popular narrative.
What about now? Is there transmission risk that China blows up and takes the rest of the world with it?
Alex Gurevich: Yes, I think there is definitely not a risk, but actually a very high probability of a shockwave from China. What we cannot estimate right now, how bad it is going to be for the rest of the world. My guess is, as you alluded to earlier, countries like Australia will be hit harder than countries like Mexico. But who knows? It's very hard to predict where the cracks— basically, when such a shockwave comes, think about this as an earthquake, right? Then wherever there is a crack, that building will fall. And it's hard for us to know which buildings have cracks unless— until you shake them very hard. But I think China could be that earthquake because in the past, for example, in '98, we had a Russian debt default, which proved to be an earthquake that brought down Long-Term Capital Management and shook the whole financial system, even though the size of this Russian debt default, it's really like laughably small relative to what China is dealing with right now.
So, yes, I think China is likely to have a crisis. And yes, I think it will likely to shake up the world, but it's very hard for me to estimate what exact impact.
Erik Townsend: Let's move over to Japan then, because certainly Japan, if we're talking about earthquake zones, is a place that's been talked about for a long time in terms of the excessive debt they have, but somehow they seem to continue to muddle through. What do you see on the horizon for Japan?
Alex Gurevich: Well, Japan wrote the playbook. I believe that all developed market economies are now going by Japan's playbook. One of the misconceptions I think people have is that fiscal deficit and fiscal expansion automatically leads to higher interest rates, or even weaker currency. And we can see how in Japan, it led to exactly the opposite. It led to fairly strong domestic currency.
So strong that they continuously complain of its being too strong. And it led to perpetual zero to negative interest rates. And in that environment, you actually can sustain very big debt. If you are a productive economy with a good manufacturing base like Japan and some good current account, you can actually have almost infinite amount of debt and just sustain it with zero rates. When it becomes unsustainable, if emerging market countries who have to borrow in foreign currency, then eventually that thing collapses and they all end up sooner or later with a balance of payments crisis. But I don't think Japan has any risk of balance of payments problems. So, as long as you have strong domestic currency, you can pretty much sustain any amount of debt, because the valve comes through the currency until your currency collapses. You have infinite tool to deal with your debt because you can keep monetizing it.
And that's how Japan is able to muddle through.
Erik Townsend: If that principle holds true, then would that suggest that the rest of the developed world, Europe and the United States, has much longer to get away with everything than everybody thinks? Because certainly, Japan surprised everyone. There were people talking about the collapse of JGBs and the collapse of the currency. 25 years ago. And it was a very good argument, frankly, at the time, but it hasn't happened yet. So, does that mean it's 25 or 30 years before all of these largesse of central banks catches up with the Western world? Or is there something that brings it to a head sooner than that?
Alex Gurevich: Well, it's very hard to look 25 years forward because even technological disruptions 25 years forward could really change the face of the world. That makes me difficult to make predictions that long.
But yes, I do think that US, as long as US does not succeed in undermining the dollar, which would be like shooting yourself in the foot, I think as long as US maintains the dollar strength, and I think it's very hard for them to undermine it because they could only talk it down, but all the policies actually leading to stronger dollar, they could sustain a lot of deficit and just take rates to zero like Japan and just muddle through it. Now, this is not an environment that makes everybody happy. And in Japan, while Japan wrote the playbook, I don't think many people are happy with that playbook. It's kind of a very mediocre playbook because you don't get great growth in this environment.
And it's also associated with negative population growth, where this is where the developed world is heading anyway, and probably US will be there fairly soon too. So, it's not really a super happy scenario, but it's a very stable scenario.
Erik Townsend: Let's go around the world to Europe and talk about the situation there. Seems like things are just escalating and there's more and more tension in Europe, and more and more people are starting to talk seriously about the European Union's days maybe being numbered. What do you see in Europe's future, and what would the economic consequences and knock-on effects be?
Alex Gurevich: Well, the breakup of EU Honestly, it's almost harder for me to visualize than China collapse because that's a very strong institution. And I think importance of EU is underappreciated in terms of even maintaining global geopolitical stability. One of the things that EU has accomplished is that France is no longer fighting wars with Germany as they were doing like for hundreds of years before.
So, once you put all the countries in the EU, create this economic union, you make them all beholden to each other economically, and that creates— and it's a big source of geopolitical stability. So, the risks to EU breaking up, probably as much geopolitical as economic. And it is hard to predict what's going to happen to the currency, because you don't even know what to do with the currency once they break up.
Paradoxically, if we default the Deutsche Mark, The currency actually could end up being higher because natural level of currency for Germany is probably higher than here because Germany is running a huge current account surplus at this level of euro. While for the rest of Europe, about 115, 120 seems about right. And our brief venture to 125 a year ago seemed to have brought on recession in Europe.
So, there are a lot of tensions there. I think they'll be reluctant to actually break up. And I think the example of Brexit is not encouraging other exits.
Erik Townsend: One of the theories that some people have brought up is to say that Europe is a proxy for the rest of the developed world. If you look at where European stock markets have clearly rolled over before the US did, European economic conditions are deteriorating. And of course, we also have the escalation of unrest with the Yellow Jackets movement. And so forth. So, Alex, is there any basis to this notion that Europe is maybe leading everyone else lower?
Alex Gurevich: Honestly, I'm not sure of that. As a general rule, I'm not sure. As of recent years, quite possibly, because I've seen a pattern in Europe that has developed last few years in Europe with very much predicted, I think, what was happening in US. I think about a year ago, European economic numbers looked very strong. And there was a lot of talk about Europe even potentially not just exiting quantitative easing, but potentially even raising rates. And there was this optimism about inflation rising in Europe.
But if you look back at Europe where it was a couple of years prior to that, in the end of, say, 2016, we could see euro being at 105, which for Europe as an export economy, very important, right? So, we had very weak euro. We also had strong stock markets for a few years up to 2016, whatever Brexit shook things up a little bit, but overall, right? We had also dramatic fall in interest rates all the way into Brexit.
And with those financial conditions inputs creating incentive for economic growth, it was not surprising 2 years later at the beginning of 2018 to see strong economic numbers. But by that time, while economic numbers as lagging indicators look strong, the concurrent financial conditions have been deteriorating. As you've mentioned, stock markets already have rolled over, euro got stronger, interest rates, though they didn't go higher, but they stopped falling.
And so, unsurprisingly, a year from now, we're seeing a lot of weakness in Europe. And that creates a playbook for US. Because even a year ago, we started to see weakness in stock market. But financial conditions in the US have not been tightening significantly yet, because we had weaker dollar.
We had a rise of interest rates and a shakiness of stock market, but weaker dollar, which somewhat compensated it. And stock market proceeded to still make new highs in 2018. But then we had a second bout of stock market volatility in US last fall. And that was already accompanied with meaningfully higher short-term interest rates. And the dollar this time was stronger. So, now we're getting a negative impulse from financial conditions, which I think gives us a hint how US will follow in the footsteps of Europe to start producing weaker economic numbers into the middle of 2019.
Erik Townsend: With all of these issues around the world that seem like potential cause for future concern, let's talk about precious metals, gold and other precious Precious metals. What's your outlook there?
Alex Gurevich: So, gold is a hot subject, and a lot of people think that really like being in gold, and I'm actually one of those people. I do like gold, but with the following caveat: I wouldn't play gold for the next 10% run up or down. I don't actually care whether gold is 1,200 or 1,400.
In fact, given where we are in the cycle, I don't necessarily expect very strong performance from gold because, as I've mentioned. I actually expect dollar to be strong in the next 2 years. And just because of the tautological correlation, when dollar is stronger, typically, it's harder for gold to rally a lot, though it can still rally. But it could be the best performing currency. But if you measure it in dollar terms, in terms of another really good, well-performing currency, it's harder to perform.
However, when you look through the cycle, when you say, well, we don't know when this— maybe they'll even hike this year, or maybe they'll ease this year. Sooner or later, we'll have a recession. That's everyone agrees with it. Sooner or later, we will get rates will probably go far down from here, even if they have to go a little bit up against first. But once the rates go close to zero, once we have a new bout of expansionary policy, whether it is quantitative easing or not, at the end of it, gold will probably triple from here. So I would look for gold three or four thousand. That will be consistent with what happened. at the end of previous recessions. So, looking 4 or 5 years forward, the outlook for gold is so positive that I would want to have some now, lest I actually miss that move.
Erik Townsend: But it sounds like you do leave plenty of room for a little move down before the big move up.
Alex Gurevich: Yeah, it just doesn't affect my strategy. But yes, I could easily see like 10% move down would not have any impact on my strategy at the moment.
Erik Townsend: Alex, I'm curious if you have a view on the changing correlation patterns that we've seen with gold. For a while there, gold and the Japanese yen just seemed to, you know, be almost pegged to each other. And then suddenly it wasn't the Japanese yen, it was the Chinese yuan. And on October 11th, that ended, and it seems to be that it's on its own new trajectory. Something I noticed since October 11th is that we're not really seeing the same inverse relationship that normally exists with the dollar index. We're seeing gold outperform not only on days that the dollar is down, but also on days that the dollar is up. Makes me start to think, because I have a very similar view to yours, that I think gold probably makes a push down before we eventually see a really big move up. Makes me wonder if maybe it's happening and, and I'm late to the party. Do you think that these changes in correlation have any meaning?
And do you Do you have any insight as to what might be causing them?
Alex Gurevich: Honestly, I would have a hard time reading into each of those correlation switches. But one thing to think about is gold is a measure of liquidity. Like, when there is more cash, more of it can go into gold. So, when we had— for a while, we actually had relatively hawkish shift to policies around the world. And now, we're beginning to get more dovish. So, it's not surprising that to me right now, that gold would perform in terms of euro, in terms of yen. Because they're pretty dovish, and they're sticking now to negative interest rates. One interesting thing observed about gold, for example, in euro terms, is that that it actually has positive real carry despite the storage costs. But when you factor in very deep negative nominal interest rates and very deeply negative real interest rates in Europe, gold actually has positive real carry. And I think that is beginning to catch up to the situation. When there was a speculation that euro eurozone might raise rates.
Maybe that was upsetting it. But when that speculation has gone away, like the nonsense it was to begin with, now I see a bid to gold in terms of euro, and probably the same applies to yen. And China, that's a hard subject. Well, first of all, they could be big operators on gold to begin with, right, in terms of managing their reserves.
But also, it's just kind of its own animal. It's very hard for me to read into it from the top of my head.
Erik Townsend: Alex, we touched earlier on the changing direction of interest rates. I want to come back to that because you wrote a book back in 2015 called The Next Perfect Trade, and a very central theme in that book was the predictive value of interest rate trends on equity prices. So, tell us a little bit more about both what the book predicted, but also how that's starting to play out in the marketplace.
Alex Gurevich: Okay. So, when I was writing this book in 2014, I was observing historical trends in the bond markets. One of the things that I noticed is the secular uptrend in the Treasury bonds when you take into account total return on the— total return on bond futures, for example. And I've also predicted that it would be a highly superior trade to be long bonds for the subsequent The interesting way that over this— so, the book, I wrote it in 2014, it came out in 2015. So, we have almost 4 to 5 years of data since then.
We had a lot of headwinds to the bond market since, from very robust employment market to elections in the US that could be viewed as negative for US Treasury bonds, to all sorts of other things, like even simple absence of huge catastrophes. Yeah. Is negative for bonds, because any catastrophe in the world could have given them extra bid.
So, still, the bonds performed well. A US Treasury bond delivered positive return since 2014, despite every possible thing being wrong. And that's a characteristic of a superior trade, what I talk a lot in my book. One of the interesting observations I made also in my book is since a lot of people try to predict performance of stock market. And I cannot claim that I have a perfect prediction. But what I found is a very good indicator is interest rate momentum. If you look today and ask yourself a very simple question, are interest rates today higher or lower than they were 2 years ago? That will give you a very good answer on how likely stock market will be higher or lower 2 years from now.
So, again, to repeat, Looking back 2 years on bonds will help you to look forward 2 years on stocks. So, when I drew this chart, I saw a pretty good fit, but I didn't have the data over the last few years. And when we extend this chart that I drew in the book, the fit was actually pretty amazing.
If you go back to 2016, you could have been concerned about stock market because there were severe corrections. But the interest rates in 2016 were significantly lower than they were prior, say, in 2014. And that, according to my observation, essentially precluded stock market from underperforming in the subsequent 2 years.
The interest rate momentum has not changed to negative till probably late 2016 after the election in the US. And guess when the stock momentum seriously changed? It seriously changed exactly 2 years from then, from that moment. Which is the end of 2018. And we are still— right now, we're still living in the world of flat to negative interest rate momentum.
And that allows us— because even though long-term rates may be the same, similar to where they were 2 years ago, but the short-term rates have risen significantly. And in this world, that does not by itself guarantee weak stock market, but it opens the door for weak stock market. That's why I think incrementally, the chances of weaker equity market in the future is more likely.
And I think those who want to read those chapters on my book on historical pattern and the last few chapters in which I discuss in detail the regime changes, which include the regime changes that occurred in the year 2000, which I described back then several years ago, but reading that piece right now feels kind of uncanny how similar it is to what's been happening last year.
Erik Townsend: Now, Alex, you manage a hedge fund which is only available to accredited investors, and your compliance department has asked us not to share with our listeners some of the investor communications that we received from you that helped me prepare for this interview. So unfortunately, we can't send those out for compliance reasons, but you do write a blog. Tell us a little bit about the blog, what is contained in it, and where people can access it.
Alex Gurevich: So my blog can be found very easily using my name, Alex Gurevich, at tumblr.com. It could also be accessed through my Twitter account, which is my A, like my first initial, @agurevich23. And it's a verified Twitter account. So, you can go from there to my blog directly. I post there various market pieces, which are not necessarily super time sensitive. Sometimes they could be excerpts of my investor letters, something just makes it to the general public a little after, a few weeks after it makes it to investors.
And it's more of general thoughts about markets or ideas about what's going on, something which I don't view as proprietary. Any investors who want to learn— any accredited investors who want to learn about us could just go to our website, www.honteinv.com. So, HonTe, like the name of the firm, INV, like investment, dot com.
Erik Townsend: Well, Alex, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program.
Announcer: Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Alex back onto the show. The first question you hit him with, which is where are we in the business cycle, in my mind, he's right on cue with what we were talking about, which is that the business cycle has already turned. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, for me, this entire interview was a series of confirmations, and I put a lot of weight on confirmations of my views from Alex because I know he's a guy who does not fall victim to that trap of, you know, saying the same thing everybody else is saying because it's the same thing to say. You know that you can count on Alex if he's got a different view that's out of consensus. He's going to express it without hesitation.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And the fact that a guy who's as smart as Alex, who I haven't talked to in more than a year, is right on the same page as I am. It's definitely, you know, business cycle is ending. We're late cycle. The market has topped. And we're probably headed toward lower Treasury yields, at least initially, until we get through this downturn. It all tends to jibe with the views that we've had. And to me, it's really just excellent confirmation to get it from a guy like Alex.
Patrick Ceresna: I've always been in that same camp that interest rates are going to gravitate towards zero again, and that when the central banks turn, that Treasury bonds will once again be a great performing asset. What's really interesting is Alex really has that strong conviction, and I have to share it. I think overall, there is only one direction for interest rates, especially if the business cycle's turned, for interest rates once again to turn once the economy starts to weaken.
On that note, Erik, I just wanted to thank you for coming on to the Market Huddle as a guest. It was great to have you on the show. Those of you that missed Erik's interview on the Market Huddle, the link is in the Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: And Patrick, I know that you are late for an airline flight, so we're going to have to make it an abbreviated postgame segment this week, but we'll be back to our regular format next week, folks. And in the meantime, we sure need your help, so please continue to let other podcasts know that I would love to be interviewed on more podcasts. It'll help us get more listeners on this one, and of And of course, we encourage you to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Won't cost you anything, you're not going to get spammed, and what you will get is our free Research Roundup email, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just a compendium of links to all of the best content that we could find on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find that transcript for today's interview with Alex, as well as the link to Alex's Tumblr blog. There's also an interesting article from Michael Lebowitz titled MMT sounds great in theory, but as well, there's an interesting article from CNBC about the Bank of England seeing the weakest outlook for the UK since 2009. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, Send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week. Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion. Forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.
Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com And by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Grant Williams — Grant Williams from Real Vision Television and the Things That Make You Go Hmmm newsletter; Kevin Muir introduced as macro tourist blogger and EastWest Investment Management portfolio manager (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 152 was recorded on January 31st, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Grant Williams returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from what's next for global equity markets to European exit contagion to populism and social unrest. Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when macro tourist blogger and EastWest Investment Management portfolio manager Kevin Muir will join us to discuss his recent piece on modern monetary theory, which has begun to go viral on the internet after being featured on ZeroHedge
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, before we even get into equities, let's start this week off with the guidance from the Fed. What happened this week and what should we conclude?
Erik Townsend: Well, the Fed surprised everyone and said that the next policy rate action could be either up or down, and also expressed an accommodative stance on ending balance balance sheet reduction sooner than previously communicated. Now, this is huge news because, frankly, if I talked to all of our guests at MacroVoices Live and there was some disagreement about things like the direction of gold and the direction of the dollar, there really wasn't that much disagreement on those things.
The disagreement was on whether or not there was a real chance of the Fed backing away from quantitative tightening. And when you had someone like Brent Johnson express just a really, really bullish view on the dollar, that was predicated on his view that there's no way that the Fed was going to back away from quantitative tightening. So the real change here that surprised a lot of us is the Fed's change in policy stance. And that really forces all of us to revisit our views on the dollar, gold, equities, and so many other things that were predicated on a belief system about what the Fed would do in terms of— Jay Powell really made it pretty clear in the beginning of his term as Fed chairman. He says, look, it is not our job to respond to markets. By changing policy to accommodate the stock market. That's not what we're here for. Well, maybe it's not what they're there for, but it's what they're doing suddenly, and that really changes things.
So now all indications are that the hiking cycle is not just paused or pausing, but perhaps it's over. And furthermore, that quantitative tightening is likely to be curtailed. When the facts change, we have to change our views. So I'm reevaluating my dollar and gold outlook.
I'd love to get Brent Johnson back on the program soon so that we can follow up on the conversation we had at MacroVoices Live about Luke Gromen's view. In that conversation, Brent expressed the view that Luke would be proven right in the long term, but there's no way he's going to be proven right in the short term because there's no way the Fed's going to ever back away from the commitment they've made to quantitative tightening. Well, needless to say, the Fed has surprised me, and I suspect Brent as well. And it's time for all of us to revisit our views. So I'd be very curious to get an update from Luke Gromen. from Brent Johnson and from several other people.
Bottom line, the picture has changed. Short-term, this definitely means more upside in equities and gold, and it means more downside risk for the dollar. But frankly, Patrick, I think that the consensus really has the wrong conclusion. Everybody is jumping for joy. The bulls are screaming for new all-time highs are in their sights again. What this really means, when you stop and think about it, is that Bernanke was wrong when he claimed that the Fed would have no trouble mopping up all of this liquidity that's That's being created.
The Fed has caught themselves in a trap where they cannot stay the course on policy and get us to the point where they've rebuilt enough ammunition to defend against the next crisis, because trying to build up that ammunition is causing a market tantrum. It's a market tantrum that a lot of people predicted. It's a market tantrum that Jay Powell said he was not going to cave to if it happened. But when it happened, actually, he kind of did cave to it. At least that's my interpretation of this week's events. Bottom line. My bottom line conclusion is that I still think there is a lot more downside because eventually what we've got to come to terms with is that the Fed is trapped here and they're starting to run out of options. But in the short term, they've just announced a radical dovish pivot to a much more accommodative stance than we thought.
That has to mean short-term upside in the market.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I couldn't agree more because the dovish pivot there has really been the short-term fuel that's pushed the S&P 500 up to this 2,700 handle up on the upside. What's your thinking here though? I mean, does this thing target 2,800 under this news, or what's in store for the S&P 500 in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it was interesting to me that so many people on Twitter were kind of shaming Charlie McElligott, saying, you know, he totally missed it and blew the call. I would say the exact opposite. I think Charlie perfectly, perfectly nailed the call when we had him on the program recently. Now let me explain what I mean by that. What Charlie said is that we were We're likely to see a short-term top around January 18th. He nailed that call. That's exactly when it happened. He said aggressive selling could follow. That happened too. Now, back when he was on the program, he predicted that that selling could last as long as January 31st or February 1st. In other words, today or tomorrow. And at that point, he predicted a resumption to the upside as corporate buybacks came back into the picture after their earnings reporting window expired and they were able to get back into that. It was only in the short term he was predicting that sell-off.
And for those of us who are fortunate enough to be able to read his daily letter, he's been changing his tune as the facts have been changing.
By the morning of Wednesday morning, January 30th, before the Fed announcement and before the big market move came up, Charlie had a letter out saying, hey folks, I think there's a strong case here for a move up to 2,750. Now, at the time, we were trading below 2,650 when he first sent that letter out. And he said, people People in his network are telling him that there's rumors that there could be a QT policy stance change or a reversal. And he made that call in his letter before the Fed meeting. So he warned people it was coming, and he said if that happens, it's going to be a bullish pivot and it's going to be scary. So Charlie has totally nailed the call. It's true that the way things unfolded was not exactly as he described on this program 2 weeks ago. But if you're following his daily letters, he has been a step ahead of the market and doing extremely well for people who are trading his advice.
So I just want to give Charlie credit there. So I really think that from start to finish, he has nailed it. He changed his view when the facts changed, and I think he got it.
Now, as far as an update in today's letter, what Charlie reports is that the NASDAQ model is already flipping today from 71% short to 100% long. All eyes are on the 1-year S&P model, which is still short, but it has a very good chance of flipping long on Tuesday of next week. And the reason he's able to predict Tuesday of next week is when some large samples come out of that trailing 1-year sample period. So he's watching it very closely and he does see a pivot back to bullish. But Charlie's overall commentary was very much in line with my own sentiment, which is, okay, it's got to go tactically into bullish sentiment. That's going to take us higher. I don't know if it's 2,800. I don't think Charlie actually had a target number published in today's letter. But But he definitely did agree that, you know, that's for now. Eventually, what is all this doing? It's confirming the message that Charlie's been saying for a year now, which is the cycle is ending.
If you look at his fear the steepener narrative, that's what's happening. And we saw the 5/30 spread move to a 1-year high on today's news. So all of Charlie's longer-term analysis is playing out and it's saying cycle is ending, but we're seeing what may be a last hurrah here, and to be sure, with this dovish policy pivot, it's got to mean that in the short term, all the screaming and yelling is going to be to the upside for stocks, for gold, downside for the dollar because of the Fed's pivot.
In the long run, which I think is much more important, you've got to recognize what's really happening here is the Fed is running out of options. They're in trouble and it's showing. But for now, the market's going to respond to a dovish pivot with a move upside in risk assets. I predict this is going to end very badly in the end, but the The end is not right now. We've got another wave up before this plays out. Remember that corporate buybacks are coming back into this short-term mania to the upside thinking, and they're probably going to propel this market higher. I look at this, Patrick, as an opportunity forthcoming to short this market from a much higher level, and I'm going to continue to watch Charlie's letter every day.
We have, by the way, gotten quite a few inquiries and emails saying Charlie didn't explain— He said very clearly in the podcast that his letter is The report is only available to Nomura's institutional clients. And he told you how to get it by contacting your Nomura representative. We don't understand why we're being flooded with emails from people saying Charlie didn't explain how to get it if you're not a Nomura client. He did explain that. The answer is, unfortunately, you can't. Please forgive us for not responding to your emails. There's too many of you asking that same question that was already answered on the program. We don't have time to respond to all of them. Okay.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, I have to agree with you though on the S&P. The short-term path has to be that the dovish pivot is going to draw buying. But really, in my mind anyway, it does signal the fact that the global economy and the economy is slowing enough that the Fed sees that they have to kind of take their foot off the pedal a little bit and see how this plays out before they make their next move.
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, let's move on to the dollar, because that's really in my mind where the first reaction function was to the Fed, which is that the dollar broke to the downside. What's your thinking here? Do we head still lower on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, actually, I'm surprised at how well it's holding up considering the news. I mean, yeah, we had a very sharp move to the downside, but this is an outright total change of story from the Fed. I would have expected a bigger move down. Now, I still think the bullish argument is there very much. There. But from a tactical standpoint, I would have said, okay, get ready for a pretty big pullback in the dollar before eventually that dollar liquidity squeeze argument kicks back in and we eventually resolve higher. So, I'm surprised by how resilient the dollar has been, and I'll have more to say about that when we get to gold.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because this whole impulse of risk-on drove a breakout to a little bit of a higher high, at least for the month of January on crude. It seems to back off from there. What's your thinking here on crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, in the interest of full disclosure, I sold that rally today. I went short from $55.25, and I'll come back to that in a minute. But let's cover inventory first. Crude oil inventories building 916,000 barrels as opposed to about a 3.2 million barrel build expectation. So a miss there. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 145,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 2.2 million barrels. That's the biggest drawdown in about 3 months. Distillates drawing down 1.1 million barrels. So generally speaking, we had some pretty good bullish news that propelled the market above $55.
Regular listeners will remember I've been saying for a while now, I think we're coming into a consolidation range here between around $45 and $55. We hit the very top end of that range above $55 today. I think that that may be at least a short-term top. We'll see what happened. I sold it hoping that it will be— hopefully I don't get stopped out if we move higher. Obviously, a geopolitical upset can change everything overnight in the oil market. But barring some kind of outside event, I think there's a pretty good case that maybe we've seen the short-term high and we're going to trade lower here. We'll see what happens, Patrick. But my inclination is to think that probably we've seen the upside for now. And the next question in my mind is, do we Do we go back down to 45 or so and stay in this consolidation range, or is there room for a combination of bearish both economic news as well as inventory data to push us below 40, say?
That's not my base case. My base case is a consolidation pattern, but either way, we're at the top of the range that I expect, and I think there's a good chance for a short trade to play out here.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to gold because that's where all the action seems to be on at least a relative momentum basis. A big breakout on gold Gold above $1,300 and seems to be having some traction here. Is this sustainable?
Erik Townsend: Well, as I've said for many weeks, if we saw a break above $1,300 that stayed there for several days— it hasn't been several days yet, but I think it's probably headed in that direction— you can't ignore it anymore. It's time to take this seriously. So I do continue to feel that there is a bullish dollar argument, but with this accommodative reversal from Powell, I think it really portends Higher equity prices, higher gold prices. And we'll see whether or not that plays out.
I look at this, though, in terms of an opportunity to get into that pairs trade that I've described: long gold and long the dollar at the same time. And what I'm doing, and it's much overdue, frankly, is analyzing what the hedging ratios need to be. And that's not at all a trivial task. It's not simply a matter of going long 5 gold contracts and 5 dollar index And it's not even a matter of figuring out what the equal notional principal amount is, because they're different contract sizes. What you've really got to do is look at a regression analysis of the historical volatility and the correlation that has existed between gold and the dollar, and figure out the right hedging ratio to put on that pairs trade. I haven't done that yet, but, you know, we've got Kevin Muir joining us in postgame. I want to ask him, because I know he's looked at that trade, too, and maybe he'll have a little bit of insight on the subject as well.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. Sure.
Patrick Ceresna: So let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yields, because really we saw us up at the 2.80 level off that low. But how quickly Treasury yields have come off, especially on this dovish pivot. What's your thinking here on the next direction of trends? Are we going lower than 2.50?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we're back to the middle of that narrow trading band between 2.60 and 2.80 that we've been watching for, looking for a signal as what should come next. And as you say, we touched 2.80, then this news from And the Fed has reversed things. I think in general, with seeing more and more recession signals, seeing that the Fed getting accommodative, suggesting that they're scared of what's coming in the economy, it all tends to suggest a downside resolution in yields. So it remains to be seen. I want to wait for a break decisively below 2.60% before I'm convinced that the move is on. But I do think that that direction is more likely than the other direction. Definitely, though, it's time It's time for us to get some more fixed income gurus on the show because bond yields are going to be one of the most important things to watch in the world of macro. You know, we've been trying to get Jeff Gundlach on the program for more than a year.
Maybe if everybody tweets @TruthGundlach all at once and encourages him, we can get him on the show. If not, maybe we can get someone else from DoubleLine. And certainly, I know, Patrick, you're working on a number of potential bond guys from other firms as well. So let's see what we can get lined up in coming weeks. Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: That sounds like a plan. So this week's featured interview guest is Grant Williams. Now, Erik, why did we choose Grant this week for the featured interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Grant is a brilliant long-term vision kind of guy. And frankly, he's been shamed a little bit by the bulls for his longer-term bearish outlook. He's been the guy who's standing up saying, hey everybody, look at trillions of dollars of negative-yielding sovereign debt around the world. This is crazy. This is not sustainable. This has to portend some really awful outcome. He was the guy going all the way back to the Brexit vote saying, look, this is just the beginning. It's the beginning of a much larger social trend.
And he's been laughed out of the room for a lot of people who thought he was crazy. And I don't think he's crazy. I think he's been early in a lot of his views. I think he's going to be proven right in the end about most of the things that he says. I do think he was early on some of his calls. But it feels to me like right now we're coming to the end of the cycle, and maybe it's time for a lot of Grant's views to start being proven right. And perhaps it's time, Patrick, that we'll find that Grant himself will be proven early as opposed to wrong, as some people said, with a lot of the views that he's expressed in the last few years. So it just feels like a really good time to get him back on the program and to get us thinking about some of the things he's been raising the caution flag about for years
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, the one thing I like about Grant, he's just such a great storyteller. So let's bring him on and see what he has to share with us. So Erik's interview with Grant Williams is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me next is Grant Williams from Real Vision Television and, of course, the Things That Make You Go Hmmm newsletter. I do want to let our listeners know that we are recording a week early in order to accommodate travel schedules, so our discussion about the markets will be about a week old. So we were not aware of anything that's happened in the last week or so. But Grant, I want to start with the big picture of markets, which doesn't really have to be timely, which is, okay, look, a lot of people, myself included, have said over and over again, this bull market is long in the tooth.
Grant Williams: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: tooth. It's the longest one in history. It's, it's due to end. And we were proven wrong several times over and surprised by yet another round of all-time highs. Have we finally gotten there? Is the top in for this cycle? And are we into at least a cyclical bear market? Or do you think maybe there's a chance that one more time I'll be proven wrong and we'll get pushed to new highs?
Grant Williams: Well, you know, Erik, you're not alone. I mean, we've— a lot of us have been We've been saying that we think we've seen the top of this market for a while now, and it has proved us wrong. It's like the guy in the Halloween movies, you just think you killed it off, and it keeps coming back somehow.
To me, though, looking across the landscape, it feels a little different this time. I hate saying this time is different, but it just feels as though the impetus for new highs now, it's not going to be earnings. It doesn't feel like it's going to be purely based on Fed policy.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Grant Williams: It definitely doesn't feel like it's going to be a strengthening economy. So, when you look at the things that have caused the surprise for us and have made us, let's face it, flat out wrong for a while now, I don't see an obvious catalyst for higher highs other than the Fed reversing policy, Powell basically chickening out. And I will say, I sent a tweet out, said 4 words, it said, I like Jay Powell. There, I've said it. And that marked the top in his hawkish policy, literally almost to the day. Yeah. If he backs down, we may get a reaction from the market who might think, hey, the good times are here again, but I think that will wear off very quickly.
Then people are going to start looking at the economy. Everywhere you look now, there are warnings coming out. Seth Klarman wrote a great letter with a very strong warning about the economy. A lot of the IMF, the OECD, they're all warning about problems with growth. We're seeing what's going on in China.
This time, everywhere you look, look, when you try and piece together a reason for markets to make new highs again, the only reasons I'm seeing are a change in the Fed policy, which I don't think is going to cut it this time, because it's going to happen against the backdrop of a weakening economy, and a short squeeze, a melt-up short squeeze. And I just don't see that happening. So, I think we're bumbling around the top.
Could we go up from here? Yeah, but I think it'll be a bull trap. And I think ultimately, the direction's changed, and the path of least resistance now is The other big one is bond yields.
Erik Townsend: We had so many smart people, whether it was Jeff Gundlach, our mutual friend Julian Brigden, had told us, look, if you see a break of that 100-month moving average on the 30-year Treasury bond, that's, that's a trend that has been in play since the mid-1980s. It's a major signal. Sure enough, we got that signal. A lot of people were saying it's the break above 3.12 or so on the 10-year. We got that signal. And so And so many people said, once you see that break, there's no turning back. You're never gonna see Treasury yields this low again for 30 or 40 years. And of course, it took 30 or 40 days before we had seen a reversal of that. And as we're speaking, what now is a week ago for our listeners, we're back in between that 2.60 and 2.80 range again, sort of chomping around here.
Where do you think we're headed? Is Lacy Hunt and Raoul Pal about to be proven right? Maybe we really are headed below that 1.34%, which so far has been the low yield on the 10-year, or is this just a temporary pullback before Gundlach and Brigden and others are proven right?
Grant Williams: Well, this is the really interesting thing to me. And this is— this to me is where when people say, well, where's all the damage that's been done by the last 10 years of monetary policy? And this to me is exactly where you're going to figure out what's happened, because I think the short answer is I think they're both I think they're both right. I think in a normally functioning market, I think Jeff and Julian and the guys that are calling for inflationary pressures and higher yields are absolutely correct.
What no one was really counting on is the fact that if that happens against a global slowdown, you are going to have these weird dynamics going on where the built-up inflationary pressures could be unleashed for a period of time. Yeah. Time, at the same time that the market is going into a massive slowdown. And I think the panic that you're going to see ultimately will possibly drive Treasuries down. I think Lacy and Raoul will be proven right. But once this breaks and confidence goes, once the panic grab for— and I use air quotes— safety is over and people have got their Treasuries, I think the economy is going to start to matter. More importantly, the US's finances are going to matter. And that's the point where this whole thing breaks. And I'm sure you and I are going to talk about some of the bigger picture issues, the strains on the system.
But make no mistake about it, this is definitely one of them. The US's finance haven't— they just haven't mattered. No one's really cared as the deficit's gone screaming up and the national debt has gone through $21 trillion. I mean, it's mind-boggling. But the day that matters, that's when you're going to see, I think, the Treasury yields go much, much higher from here. But as I say, the short answer, I think in the short I think Raoul and Lacy could well be proven right.
Erik Townsend: You know, this makes me wonder if we think 10, 20 years ago what happened in Japan. So many people in finance were saying, okay, look, Japan is so overindebted, the blowup of their stock market bubble in '89, this is all leading to a massive collapse of JGBs. We're going to see the yield blow out astronomically as everybody realizes the default risk is through the roof. And, you know, it's time to short JGBs. MBS, back the leverage truck up. That's it, baby. And what happened for decades is so many people made that argument, which frankly was a good argument on the face of it. The logic all made sense. But instead what happened is Japan found itself in economic stagnation that has lasted for decades. And I wonder if it's a precursor, if the whole world is about to turn Japanese, where per Lacy Hunt, we've got so much debt that we can't get back to historical normal yields.
Grant Williams: Right.
Erik Townsend: And we just go to a very low-yield, low-growth stagnation environment globally that continues until we get to the point where there's either some populist uprising or something that resets the system. Is that a realistic scenario to consider?
Grant Williams: Yeah, in my mind it is, but particularly the populist uprising, and I'm sure we'll come on and talk about that. But I've talked about this fairly often, that this Japanification of the There's two differences to think about. One is the fact that the Japanese bond market is essentially completely domestic. People overseas don't tend to own Japanese bonds. And secondly, as Japan went into its nosedive, there were other countries picking up the baton for growth. You had at that point you had China growing double digits. You had India growing double digits. You had the U.S. doing pretty well. So so there were other countries that could kind of carry the torch, and and there was organic growth in the world. So people had a place. Place to go, and the Japanese bond market just didn't really matter to anybody. Now, there are days when the whole thing doesn't trade. It's farcical if you think about it, but it's really just become a sideshow.
If we go into a period where the US sees no growth, and China is down at 4% and struggling and having to bail out its banking system, and India hasn't come through as people thought it did, even though we're seeing growth in the monsoon countries, which again, something Raoul spoke about, and he and I did a presentation about this a couple of years ago, That's not enough. Those countries— growth in Ethiopia is not going to help the rest of the world pick up the load. It's going to be a completely different backdrop. And so, I think this idea of a Japanification of the world is a little misguided. I think it's going to matter that this is a coordinated global slowdown as opposed to a Japan-specific thing. And I don't think that's something that is going to be looked past by bond investors.
Erik Townsend: I was reading Things That Make You Go Hmmm, on the airplane on the way to Vancouver the The other day, and I was particularly interested in your article on China and Taiwan because I'm not really an expert on all of these— China and all of its territories. I know quite a bit about Hong Kong just because I'm a resident there, but as much as they're saying, and you've covered this in your newsletter, okay, China has got to unify Taiwan with mainland China. They've got to toe the line, become part of the mainstream, no more independence.
Grant Williams: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Haven't they been in some version of that for like 25 years? And why would we believe that suddenly right now is the time that they're actually going to enforce that and perhaps it is about to come to a head?
Grant Williams: Funny you say that. The reason I included that in the letter was not so much the story, because you're right, that's been something that we have been talking about. When I was out in— working out in Hong Kong was when the Taiwanese held elections, you know, and There was a big fuss about it then, the Chinese talking about they can't do this.
For me, it's more about the timing. The fact that Xi Jinping is now making that a key plank of his policy tells you, I think, how much trouble the Chinese economy is in, because if he's suddenly trying to say, hey, you know what, everybody, forget the economy, look over here, and let's try and reunify China, this is classic. It's a classic tactic, populism, reunification, nationalism.
For me, it's not the story. The story has been there. It's been floating around, as you said, for years. What is interesting is that Xi is trying to focus attention on it again. And that, to me, is just a distraction sign. The economy is in real trouble. So, I need to galvanize people around a reunified China again, because that plays well. The fact that they haven't mentioned it in years, because everything's been going fine, tells you everything you need to know. So, to me, it's not the fact that they're going to change their policy, but they're bringing that back to the fore because they see problems coming. And look, you don't know— the problem is always miscalculation. All the tactics that the politicians are using, whether it's Trump in the US or Cameron obviously made a massive miscalculation with the Brexit referendum.
Miscalculation is what leads to problems politically. And who knows if Xi does bring this back to the fore and the people really get behind it, particularly in the face of a weakening economy. economy, you just don't know what he might do to try and unite the country behind him. So, I think it's an important story to watch. I don't think you're going to see any action on it, but watching how hard they try and push it to the fore is a really, really useful indicator for just how weak that Chinese economy is, because as you and I both know, the data never really tells the full story.
Erik Townsend: Another subject that you covered in your most recent Things That Make You Go Hmmm newsletter was Australia. Australian real estate. And this one particularly interests me because so many of us were right about this and just way too early. And in this business, early is wrong. I helped to organize a trader group in Hong Kong in 2010. And one of our big topics was, how do you short Australian real estate? And needless to say, we were 8 years early and therefore wrong. And I guess my question now is twofold. One is, one of the problems is nobody could figure out, you know, do you just short the bank stocks? And how is the weakness that we knew was coming in Australian in real estate because it's clearly a bubble. How is it going to translate and how effective is something like a short on banking stocks going to be to capture it? And of course, the other question was the timing.
Well, the timing seems to have resolved itself. We know there's been a significant pullback. How well has that translated in terms of any tradable strategy? And do you think that, you know, I guess a lot of people would say, well, they've had, what is it, a 20% or something pullback on the price of properties in some cities? A lot of people would say, okay, that's their correction. over, it's a time to buy the dip.
Is it just getting started with Australian real estate? And how do you play it?
Grant Williams: It's a fascinating story. Like, you know, this is something I've watched for a while. I lived in Australia for a number of years. And even, even back in sort of 2005 through 2010, the market was nuts. You know, in 2008, when the crisis hit, the very first action that the Aussie government took was to, was to give a $6,000 dollar windfall to anyone buying their first home, because they understood just how fundamentally important that housing market is to Australia, to Australians. It's the whole ball of wax. So, if you look at a chart of Australian housing, you'll see a tiny dip in '08, and then it went straight up again. And if you put that chart up against the US housing market, you'll see it's so much higher than the US was before the crisis in 2007, 2008. 2008 as to be almost laughable.
The entire Australian economy essentially revolves around that housing market. You can understand why they've been defending it tooth and nail. You can understand almost why the bears have been wrong for such a long time. A lot of that is to do with finding ways to be able to play the short, but there are a couple of things that happened which are starting to make it really, really interesting.
That is, first of all, the Commission on Financial A Royal Commission into Banking and Finance was called. This was, again, politics. When I talk about miscalculations, here's a prime example. The incumbent party have presided and been talking about how great the housing market have been. The opposition have been talking about how unaffordable housing has been, and they promised that if they got in, they would address housing affordability.
Literally, one MP was kicked out of his seat for for personal transgressions. And that lost the majority for the government in parliament, and the opposition was able to force through this banking and housing— banking and finance commission. Now, what that's done is start a whole set of dominoes toppling, because guess what? When they looked into banking and finance, they found out that all the stuff that was going on in the US with liar loans and forged documents, all of that stuff was all happening in Australia.
And the banks were up to their necks in it, as you knew they were going to be. This is the same problem. It's human nature. It's not going to be different anywhere else in the world. But once this thing started, the data that's been coming out of this Royal Commission, and it's an open commission, it's televised, you can watch it. It's been truly extraordinary.
And so, what's happened is the banks have cut back access to credit, and they've done it before they were told to by the commission. And so, you've finally got a catalyst whereby the banks are stopping lending now to housing. And it's credit that has enabled this whole thing to go on, because housing is completely unaffordable. Unless you've got access to cheap credit, it just doesn't work.
So, this is all still going on. The pig is still going through the python. But you've finally got a catalyst. Now, the problem with shorting the banks in Australia has been the size of the dividends. They pay massive dividends.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Grant Williams: The big 4, National Australia Bank, Westpac, ANZ, and Commonwealth pay huge dividends. So they're owned in all the public pension funds.
And so it's been a really tough thing to battle against them, simply because people would just own them for the yield. But with this commission, and with the restriction of credit, those dividends at some point are going to come under threat. And if they do cut the dividend, or even if it's just slightly, I mean, they may be forced to make significant cuts in the dividends. Happens, then you'll see a cascade in these things, and suddenly, the banks will just be in freefall. Now, against that backdrop, the other aspect of this, which makes it very, very interesting right now is we all know that Australia has gone a quarter of a century without a recession, but it now starts to look as though the Aussies might be staring their first recession in 26-odd years in the face. Happens along with this, then this could be a disaster for the Australian stock market and by extension, the housing market, because people are stretched.
Housing affordability is appalling in Australia. It's just one of those perfect storms.
If we get the recession that looks like it's coming, and we get massive contraction in credit, which looks like it's either going to happen voluntarily at first and then be forced on by the Royal Commission, There's really no way out of that for Australia, particularly if the third part of this, which is the Chinese economy, goes into reverse. That's it for Australia. I mean, you can stick a fork in Aussie for the time being. It's still difficult to play the banks because they're down, they're 20-odd percent down off the tops, but you've still got this need to own them for the dividend. This is something you watch the Australian economic data, you watch what the banks are doing in terms of making reparations or in terms of adjusting to the pressure being put on them by the Housing and Finance Finance Committee Commission, but I think this trade is in play right now. There's a couple of guys, a great friend of mine, Michael Schneider, down in Australia, who you should definitely have on to talk about this.
He's all over this. Bill Strong of Eskaton is also looking at this trade. I did a great interview with him for Real Vision about 6, 8 months ago, where we talked about this, but it's happening. And it's like all the other things that we've talked about, Erik, where we've been wrong for so This Aussie market, everybody's been wrong, but they've all been looking for the short. So, I think once it starts playing out, which it is, you will see plenty of people that want to pile on this thing, which is just going to drive these things down further. So, I think the trade's happening. I think there's a lot further to go. And I think people should be watching this very, very carefully.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit more about the first recession in 26 years. I know you are a serious student, as am I, of feedback loops and human beings and what tends to happen to people. You talk about the first When you talk about the first recession in 6 or 7 years, it might be that it's a little bit out of people's mind, and they got to refresh their memory of what that means. When you talk about the first recession in 26 years, you're talking about an entire society where the youngest generation has no concept of what a recession is.
What does that mean in terms of people's reaction and potentially exacerbating the effects of that recession?
Grant Williams: Well, I think you're absolutely right. That's, that's the problem, right? It's the overswing of the pendulum, if you like. It won't be a normal common or garden recession. You've got 26 years of imbalances built up that have been, let's face it, staved off. The Aussie economy was basically completely reliant upon China. And China happened to go big just as Aussie was weakening, which really saved them from a recession a decade ago.
But you're right. This is an entire generation that's gone without a recession. So the danger is that when one happens, and we all know it's going to happen, maybe they get through this year somehow. I don't see it, but maybe they do. But it's coming. And when it comes, people are going to be shocked to see mass redundancies and housing markets fall and stock markets fall. They just haven't seen that before. So people won't know how to react. They won't know how to invest. They won't know how to position themselves, and so they will do do everything out of a sense of panic, which always unsettles markets and causes them to overshoot. If you look at the Australian market, you'll see it's way too expensive for a country that's going through what it's doing, but probably more importantly, the currency.
I think what you'll see is the Aussie dollar is going to go back to 50, and who knows, perhaps below that. That's probably where it should be, but the overshoot could be could be severe. So, you know, the Aussie bond market and the Aussie currency markets, that's where I think there's some, some significant money to be made. And again, particularly the currency, because I think even where it is here, it's, it's, it's way overvalued.
Erik Townsend: Grant, you mentioned something a moment ago, which is that you and I and a lot of other smart people had been wrong about some things, or early at least, and we're now being proven right. There's one of these that I really wanted to be proven wrong on, and that is that for the last several years, you and I have predicted a dramatic increase in populism, social unrest, and violence.
And a lot of people thought we were conspiracy theory nutcases. Now Paris is on fire. And I really, really would love you to tell me that I'm wrong to say that what we've predicted is starting, but I'm afraid that's what you're going to tell me.
Grant Williams: Oh boy, Erik. This is, again, to me, this is the one that I hope and pray I'm wrong on. And I've been delighted to have been wrong for a while. Surprised by just how tolerant people have been. I think that a lot of that has been politicians standing up and telling everybody how great everything's doing. I think even when you've lost your own job, if you're being told that the economy is doing great and everything's fine and it's never been better, you hope that, oh, maybe this is good, at least I'll be able to find myself another job. There's the old joke about the difference between a recession and depression. It's a recession when your neighbor loses his job and it's a depression when you lose It was yours.
And that's what I fear. I think you'll find that after '08, people understand a lot more about finance than they did before '08. And they may not realize it, but I think they now understand bailouts. They understand how unfair bailouts are when they're targeted at Wall Street as opposed to Main Street.
And I think what you're going to see, sadly, is the Fed and the government will do what they've always tried to do, which is bail out Wall Street. Yeah. Bail out Wall Street to, quote unquote, save the system. Bernanke and Paulson managed to frighten lawmakers into passing TARP back in '08, $787 billion, which is a drop in the bucket this time around. And even though people thought it sounded wrong, they too were frightened by this whole, well, if we don't do this, the system's going to crash.
If you have a bad economy, and you have people feeling like they're disenfranchised, and you tell them, you know what, we need to do this to save the system. Well, suddenly, the reaction changes and the reaction is to hell with it, let's burn the system to the ground, which I think is your point.
If we're in that place, which again, it feels like we are, populism is on the rise, the fact that Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez can float this 70% tax in the US and have all kinds of polls say that a lot of Americans are for it tells you that the attitude has changed. Bernie Sanders was the tip of the spear in bringing this whole idea of socialism and fairness to a younger generation that haven't perhaps studied history or haven't lived through periods where they've seen the horrors that socialism, communism can cause. I don't think anyone's really paying too much attention to Venezuela right now, even though it's a fantastic case in point as to what can happen when these things go wrong.
But when things are bad, an alternative is always more appealing. Do you want the status quo, which you know is bad, or will you take a chance on something different? And of course, the big problem is people are saying that capitalism has failed. Well, we don't have capitalism anymore. We are not a capitalist society.
We have crony capitalism, which is completely different. And so, if we had capitalism where weak companies were allowed to fail, and companies were allowed to go bankrupt, and there was some check and balance in the system, we wouldn't be having these problems. Again, the decisions made in the name of defending the system and defending capitalism and bailing out Wall Street because it's in the best interest of Main Street, that's all going to come home to roost. I think what you're seeing in France is, again, another symptom of that.
We've seen it in the UK with the Brexit. Brexit vote. Obviously, we Brits are awfully polite until we're not. And right now, we're in the polite stage. But again, you can see with some of the demonstrations, some of the marches, and you can see the anger there. This story this past weekend, or a couple of weekends ago now, when this is going to go live, of the Native American protests and the young kid in the MAGA hat, and the blowback from that story. And I watched that like everybody else and looked at the smug smile on this kid's face and thought, oh, boy, can you believe this kid. But when you dig into the story, and it took a couple of days for the rest of it to come out, and you see there is another side of the story, and it's not as cut and dried as it looked at first blush.
Suddenly, you're being forced to pick a side, and people have already picked their side. Everything that happens, they see through their own prism, and it just drives both sides further apart.
When you have this chasm between left and right in politics, you have an economy that is running on fumes, you have a stock market that's is potentially at all-time highs, and you have a moment in time where things like the national debt start to matter, I worry like you do, Erik, that the only way that people are going to be able to express this is the way they're doing it in France now. And that is going to be a very, very bad outcome for one and all. As we record this, we are at the beginning of Davos, and there couldn't be a worse time if you ask me, to shine the spotlight on the elite, because that's what they are. Some of the numbers coming out in the press is really interesting. We talk about now, whatever you read about Davos, it's all within the context of how much richer the world's 1% have gotten since 2008.
When you look at— there was a chart in Bloomberg that showed the richest men in the world and the percentage that their wealth has increased over the last decade. It's extraordinary. Mark Zuckerberg's 2,000 times wealthier than he was. Mukesh Ambani, one of the big magnates in India, is up a couple hundred percent. Marc Benioff of Salesforce was up almost 1,000%. Jamie Dimon is 300% wealthier than he was back in 2008. The fact that this is the angle that the press is starting to take on Bloomberg shows you that they realize that the way to get people to read, because right now, in the world we live in, it's all about clicks. How do I get people to read my article? How do I get eyeballs on it for the advertising dollars? The way to get someone to read is to make a headline that is anti-the world's elite. I think the headline was Davos billionaires keep getting richer.
Back in 2018, Oxfam put out a study that said that 80-odd percent of the wealth generated in 2018 went to the richest 1% of the population. So, these headlines just fuel this populism. And I think it's Gerald Celente that says when people have nothing to lose, they lose it.
And that's where we're at, I think. So, watch the coverage, watch the angle people are taking with the wealth divide. Because when you start to see headlines that really play into the anger of the 99%, you know that that tipping point is getting closer. And look, as we started this off saying, I hope you're wrong. I hope I'm wrong. But every day that goes by, I fear that we're going to be more right than we thought we were. And that's trouble.
Erik Townsend: Another headline that you had in your most recent letter was, if Macron fails, Europe fails. What precisely did you mean by that?
Grant Williams: Macron was interesting, right? Macron came out of nowhere. Here we have an ex-Rothschild banker who was put up as the alternative to the very unpalatable to the establishment anyway, Marine Le Pen. Whose party was at its inception an overt far-right party led by her father. And there's a man you can absolutely apply the word racist to. But those connotations, she tried to weaken those. The establishment tried to strengthen her association with right-wing racism. And so, when she started to get some real traction in the polls, François Hollande was an appalling president. And suddenly, Marine Le Pen— if Marine Le Pen looks like a palatable alternative, you You know that you've got a country facing problems. Well, guess what? The establishment pulled Macron out of nowhere. Young, handsome, erudite, very much in the Obama mold, who again, before he got elected, was a junior senator that many people hadn't really heard of. But he spoke well. He looked great. He was very presentable.
He was stylish. And Macron was that in spades. The fact that he was an ex-Rothschild banker seemed to pass by most of the people voting for him. And he got in, and the establishment breathed a huge sigh of relief.
But guess what? He's turned out to, again, be an appalling president. His approval ratings are— I don't know if I'm right in saying they're below Hollande, but they're down there with Hollande, which I thought would be a remarkably difficult thing to do, but he's achieved it with some ease.
And so, I think Macron, to me, represented the establishment's last roll of the dice. Here's a guy, we're going to put him in there, we're going to get him to say all the things we need him to say. And he's going to calm things down, and he's going to help this whole thing blow over. And nothing of the sort has happened. And I think that is representation of what you and I've been talking about, about this populist movement and the fact that they're not going to just go away and be placated.
I think what's happened to Hollande in France is the absolute embodiment of that. So, the fact that he is struggling, the fact that he is looking as though— I mean, let's face it, in years gone by, he would have already stepped down. Back when politicians had some shame, he would have already stepped down and taken responsibility for the state of the country. But they don't do that anymore. Theresa May would have stepped down in years gone by, but she's refusing to do that despite various no-confidence votes and suffering a defeat in the Commons, the like of which has never been seen before in British Parliament. So, the establishment is kicking and screaming against this natural natural move towards a reset.
And I think if Macron fails, which I would argue that he already has, but failure these days is seen as you finally give in and step down. If that happens, then I think the establishment is under real, real trouble. And with that, Europe could see it go where I think it's been destined to go forever, which is back to individual European nations.
Italy is the other thing that people need to be watching very, very carefully. Because this situation in Italy with the League, or the Northern League, as they used to call themselves until they decided to get serious about uniting the country, and Five Star are playing for keeps. And they're not Greece. They do have clout in the middle of Europe. And I think if the Italians stick 2 fingers up at the EU, which more and more the response by the public to the way that the ruling party now are handling Europe tells you that's what the Italians want them to do.
Everywhere you look, Europe is coming apart. And as always, the European politicians, the Junckers, the Tusk of the world, are whistling past the graveyard, assuming that they have all the power and refusing to play ball. And everything is setting up for Europe to break. And I think Macron is— should he step down, that will be the catalyst for the whole thing to fall apart.
Erik Townsend: Let's take this a step deeper, because as we said It's so easy to come up with the catchy headline that gets clicks. Grant Williams says if Macron fails, Europe fails. That'll make ZeroHedge easily.
Grant Williams: I walked into that.
Erik Townsend: But let's— well, I'm gonna hold you accountable because the folks on ZeroHedge who read beyond the headlines want to know more. What specifically do we mean? Let's suppose we get into this subject, which you predicted before the Brexit referendum was even voted on, which is, you said it's inevitable. The ingredients are in place for the European Union to eventually fail and go back to individual countries.
Let's dive into the detail of how does that go? Does the currency start to fail, and then in reaction to failing currency, the countries kind of run for the exits and go back to their own currencies? Or is it not driven by the currency, and it's political, and for political reasons, borders go back up? How does Europe fail? What precisely does that mean for the folks who read beyond the headline and want to know more?
Grant Williams: Well, a failure of the EU is borders and individual currencies. That's the failure, because that's what they tried to do, was bring the continent together to create a continent, a federation of states, essentially, is what they wanted to create. And look, the reasons behind it were admirable. We don't want another war in Europe. If we can unite the French and the Germans at the If we can bring them into the heart of Europe and make them partners in something, then hopefully, we can stave off another conflict. And it's worked. Look, it's worked in terms of staving off conflict, but the EU and the euro, particularly as it was designed, was never going to work. The euro fiscal union has to be a part of monetary union.
And people would say, well, it worked just fine. Well, why is it not working now? Because we had everything going in the right direction. Countries getting ridiculously low interest rates—Italy, Greece, Spain—that would never have been able to borrow at those rates absent the EU. And guess what they did? They borrowed as much as they possibly could. Are they going to pay it back? No, they never have. They wouldn't have been able to. So, in a normally functioning world, they wouldn't have been lent that money at those rates because because the quote unquote bank would have not lent it to them knowing they couldn't pay it back. So, a failure of the EU. EU is everybody has their own currency, and everybody has a border again.
Now, the key to this is going to be the euro, because it's the monetary union that is creating the problems now. It worked great when interest rates were going in the right direction. It worked great for everybody. Now, they've started to go in the other direction, and the debts have started to matter, and the pressure is on these countries, you are going to suddenly see what being tied into this monetary union does.
And if you throw in all the stuff we've been talking about, the strains economies are under, the fact that EU growth is now falling, it looks like we could have a recession in Europe as well. When recessions happen, people suddenly stop worrying about how great things were in the past. No one's going to say, well, you know what, the euro has been great to us for the last 19 years. So, we'll give it a— we'll cut it a break, and we'll put up with some pain because it's done us so many favors. No, people don't understand what the euro represents. But they know that they can't make ends meet. And they know that an answer to this, from a political standpoint, is to go back to— I'll use Italy as an example— is to go back to the lira, pay off all your debts in lira, massively devalue the lira, and not be forced to maintain a budget deficit that is dictated by Brussels, and to be able to spend and help your country come out of a recession.
That's what's going to happen. It was always going to happen once we get these conditions and politicians realize that they cannot do what they need to do domestically. Forget international politics. This becomes domestic, and it always has done throughout history. Politics is always domestic first and international second. And they've clung on and clung on and clung on. But the way that the bureaucrats in Brussels treat everybody, because they have to, they have to toe a hard line, they have to use the stick and not the carrot to keep this thing together, is going to be what breaks it.
So, I think we will get a standoff. And either the EU will have to back down to Italy, because Italy is just too big to say no to. Either they have to back down and cut Italy a break and allow them to blow out their budgets, which means everybody else is going to come and want the same thing, or they hold fast and miscalculate. Calculate that the Italians will back down like the Greeks eventually did. And Italy says, you know what, we're big enough. We're a G7 country.
We're not going to play your rules. We shouldn't have to do what you tell us. We're going to do what's best for Italy and Italians, make Italy great again. And they go out. Now, the worst thing for Europe would be for the Italians to get out and be okay, or Brexit to happen and the Brits to be okay.
Because then That will make the rest of Europe realize, well, what are we doing here? Why don't we go back to our currency?
So, it's a series of dominoes toppling. It begins with the currency. Well, correction, it begins with politics. But the first brick in the wall that will be removed in Europe is going to be the currency. And everywhere I look, I see signs that that day is headed towards us. Now, as you keep saying, Erik, we've been wrong for a long time. We have been. Stable and imminent are mutually exclusive often, and that has been the case with Europe. But again, I think if you're paying attention to the headlines, and you're paying attention to the politics going on throughout the continent, you can see that it's bending. And it's bending so much that I suspect it's going to break.
Erik Townsend: One of the cardinal rules of financial podcasting is if you really want a socialist revolt, you have Grant Williams on your podcast, and don't ask him about gold. I learned this once the hard way. So, we better get, before we run out of time, to the punchline I know so many listeners are interested in. And I particularly want you to comment on an aspect of this. Certainly, for anybody who has been paying attention in the last few years, the reasons that gold is almost certain to have its day in the sun at some point should already be clear.
The thing is, some of us have held the view that because we really see a very strong dollar liquidity squeeze argument, we fear that If the dollar index is going to move higher, that's probably going to cause gold to move down in price before it eventually moves way up. And to be clear, I think the big move is up, but I kind of think there might be a little down left to go.
And I really have felt like that view has played out very well. I still see the, the long argument for gold. It's always made Makes sense. But, you know, gold had been trading off very much in reciprocal action to the dollar index. Just over the last, really since about October 11th, when something snapped and the gold seemed almost like a peg to the Chinese yuan snapped, it seems like gold's acting a little differently. So I guess my question is, what do you think happened on October 11th that suddenly pulled gold out of correlation with the Chinese yuan? And are we perhaps to the Are we at that point that your partner Raoul Pal predicted, where, you know what, the dollar bulls are going to be right and the gold bulls are going to be right at the same time? Both move up together. Are we at that point?
And what happened? Something changed dramatically in the middle of October. Any idea what it was?
Grant Williams: Well, look, let's talk about what gold's day in the sun means, because I think it means different things to different people. To a lot of people who have been frustrated Frustrated with gold, it's all about price. You know, they own gold because they think it should be $5,000, and they think they can sell it $5,000 and and you know double triple quadruple their money.
To me, gold's day in the sun is something completely different. The day in the sun is is when gold actually does what it's supposed to do and protects your purchasing power. You know, it doesn't matter to me if gold goes down 10%, but markets halve. Great. Holding gold has given me the ability to buy many, many more shares of the S&P than I would have been able to had I just held the dollar.
I don't look at the gold price so much. It's not so important to me. It's reflective of what's going on in markets, perhaps it's reflective of sentiment, but I don't own gold because I want to turn it for a profit. I never have, and I would never buy it for that. I look at it a little bit differently. To me, gold's day in the The sun is the day when I decide that I want to exchange my gold for something else, and I'm able to buy more of them than I would have been had I held cash.
So something clearly has changed. I have absolutely no idea what it is, because why gold would be for a period of time pegged to the Japanese yen, and then for a period of time be pegged to the yuan, who knows, Erik? I mean, we could speculate about that all day long. And the beauty of gold is it gives the conspiracy theories something to really get their teeth into.
But to me, it doesn't matter. I think, I think you will see a rising dollar and rising gold.
But for me, the next move in the dollar is down. My great friends Brent Johnson and Raoul Pal talk, as do you, talk very eloquently about this dollar super shock where it spikes to levels that would make your eyes water. I don't think we're going to see it. And if we do see it, I think it will be stamped on so fast that you won't have time to get out your position.
I think the dollar is going to go lower. I think we're starting to see that now, and that will be good for gold, but it's not necessarily the only thing that's driving it. I think gold is going to reach a point where if everything we've talked about in the last 45-odd minutes comes to pass, or certainly bubbles to the surface, if we get populism, if we get unrest, if we get falling markets, if we get the loss of confidence in the US government's finances, all of those things mean people will want to own gold.
The day that this whole thing really unwinds is when people will only settle for physical gold, they don't want paper anymore. They don't want a futures contract, they don't want an ETF, they want to own physical gold, because when that happens, that's when you're going to see the price do extraordinary things, because there simply isn't enough physical gold to satisfy all the paper promises on it.
I've talked about this, I've given presentations on it, but it hasn't mattered. If you really care about the price, it seems as though none of this is relevant. Because I don't care about the price so much, I care about the purchasing power, as I watch this rubber band get stretched further and further in terms of the world disintegrating and gold really not reflecting that, that to me says that on the day when people say, you know what, not so much with the ETF, how do I buy a gold bar?
The day that happens, you'll see some fireworks in the gold price that will satisfy all the people that have been waiting for it to do crazy things. More importantly, the people who've put 5%, 10% of their wealth in gold as an insurance policy are going to be feeling a lot happier. Happier about the state of their finances if markets are melting down.
So I don't know when it's coming. I try not to talk about the price or when, because as I said, it's irrelevant to me. But if you go back to 2008, and gold fell 15%, I think, 15% in early '08, when markets fell 66%. And so you were able to exchange your gold for all kinds of things. You could exchange it for houses.
You could exchange it for equities, and you could buy exchange for a lot more houses and a lot more equities than you could before the meltdown happened. So so this this focus on the price to me is completely the wrong way to look at it. I I think there are plenty of things you can buy if you want to try and make a 100% return. Doing it in gold is it's just it's just a pointless exercise to me. So I think gold's quote unquote day in the sun. is coming, but I think what that means is something different to a $2,500 gold price. It means gold is doing what it's supposed to do, and holding it is going to make you feel very, very happy, as opposed to not having any.
Erik Townsend: Let's very briefly, before we close, just touch on the dollar, because I know, Grant, that you are very familiar with the argument that I've made, that Raoul has made, that Brent Johnson has made, which is, look, quantitative Quantitative tightening just has to be dollar bullish because every quantitative tightening Fed balance sheet roll-off is equivalent effectively to a rate hike. Is the issue that you disagree with our logic, or is the issue that you don't think quantitative tightening is going to continue?
Grant Williams: I certainly understand your rationale. I don't disagree with, with the premise at all. I mean, I can absolutely see the linkage. I can see how it happens. I can see why a short squeeze could pick up momentum. But I think the damage that the scenario you guys lay out would cause would be so severe that it would have to get stopped. QT would be stopped. QE would be implemented. We'd have a Shanghai Accord of sorts. There will be an agreement to weaken the dollar by everybody, because it's become so systemically important. And the system is so fragile. So, the dollar is so fragile that it's in nobody's best interest for the dollar to strengthen significantly. It's not in the US best interest, it's certainly not in Asia's best interest. And so, I can see what you say happening, but I think the speed with which they squash it will make your eyes water. And I don't even know you'll have a chance to get out of your trade.
And QT, we've already seen Jay Powell come out with his Superman suit on and then walk it back very, very quickly. Yeah, all this talk about QT being on autopilot, well, he's backed down from that They understand the damage that QT can do. Absolutely, they do. They understand the positive effects that QE has had. And I choose my words carefully, because I think if they think it'll have the same effects next time, I think they're very much mistaken. I think they'll have to go much bigger, which won't be pleasant for the dollar. So, look, I think you could be right. I absolutely think you could be right. But I think you'll be right for a very, very short period of time.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Grant Williams: of time. And I think you're going to be wrong first.
Erik Townsend: For the benefit of our listeners who may not be familiar with the argument and the premise that we're discussing, go back and listen to Brent Johnson's interview on this program just a few weeks ago to explain it.
Erik Townsend: We are just about out of time, Grant. But before we go, we had such a fantastic experience with our second live event. It was such a grand success that Real Vision decided to not only copy the idea, but even copy the Tell us about Real Vision Live.
Grant Williams: Yeah, well, I'm not sure about the coffee, Erik, but it's something we've been kicking around for a long, long time is to start doing live events. And we've had a lot of requests to do one. So, next week in New York, February 4th, we've got a workshop, which is going to be just tremendous fun. We've got Tommy Thornton, Tony Greer, myself, Raoul Pal, and Dave Floyd are all going to give interactive workshops and talk about what we do, and more importantly, how we do it. So, as opposed to PowerPoint presentations, it's going to be a workshop. We're going to help people understand Raoul's macro view, how he builds it, how Dave sets himself up to trade, how Tony reads charts, how Tommy Thornton puts it all together. So, if you come along to it, you will really get a masterclass from a bunch of guys that that have great frameworks and are going to share them with you.
So, you can find out more at realvision.com. It's February 4th in New York City, and it's going to be an awful lot of fun, I think.
Erik Townsend: Fantastic. We're going to need to leave it there. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Grant on the show, but now in the postgame, joining us is my good friend, Kevin Muir. How you doing, Kev?
Kevin Muir: Great. It's good to be with you guys.
Patrick Ceresna: Great. So, Kev, listen, we just wanted to start off by asking you, what was your impression or what did you take away from the last Fed announcement?
Kevin Muir: Well, going into the announcement, I thought there was no way that Powell would find a way to be more dovish than the already dovish expectations. And I was completely wrong. He astounded us all by going even more dovish.
Erik Townsend: Very well said, Kevin. And, you know, I would go even a step farther and say it's not only dovish, it's proven to us that what Powell said when he took office, which is they're not going to cave to markets, they're not going to adjust their policy in order to react to markets having a temper tantrum, that was BS. They are going to react to markets. That's what they're doing now. It's pretty clear. And what it really brings to my mind is This question of where the trade is, because let's face it, people like myself who were convinced that Powell was going to stay the course on QT just got caught wrong-footed. If you had been either flat or short gold, and I was flat going into this announcement because you thought they were going to stay the course on QT, and if you had been long the dollar for reasons that I've described in the program, you got nailed.
Yeah. But what I think would work here is if you had been, and you get the ratios right, long the dollar and long gold at the same time. Gold really saw a pop here, and the dollar actually took less of a hit than I thought. And if this had gone the other way, I think the dollar could have been big to the upside while gold maybe would have been a little bit muted on the downside, because we've been seeing gold outperform its usual inverse relationship to to the dollar.
As you know, because you've worked on an institutional desk, this is not a matter of just saying the trade is long 5 gold contracts or 5 shares of a gold ETF and long 5 shares of something like UUP, which is the bullish dollar index ETF. You've got to calculate hedging ratios based on past correlation ratios. And that's an analysis function that requires a little bit of work. I know you're good at this stuff. Are you a step ahead of me? Do I need to do that work, or have you already done it?
Kevin Muir: Erik, that's a great question. And, uh, there's no doubt that gold has rallied stronger than the dollar has gone down. When you see the charts, you can see that gold's running like it stole something, and the dollar's had some— you know, it sagged a little, but it really hasn't been that bad. So it's been a terrific trade to be long the gold as well as being long the dollar.
And in terms of what the exact ratio is, that's a moving bet. It's always changing. The correlations are changing, and it's something that we should do a little work on, and maybe we can get back to you on that.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'll tell you what, you guys have been running— I think you're on your 12th or 13th episode of the Market Huddle, which is a video-enhanced conversation that you guys have been doing. You invited me to be on your show on Have you got time to work up a couple of charts? Because what I would love to see is not only the hedging ratios that you think are appropriate, but then if you plot the performance of that trade— long X number of shares or contracts or whatever it is of gold and long a bullish dollar product like UUP or DX futures— if you come up with that ratio, how does that chart look and how has it performed in the last few months? I wouldn't be surprised to find that from a technical standpoint, standpoint, that pairs trade actually is a pretty bullish-looking chart, but I'm doing that intuitively.
Can we do that for Saturday release?
Kevin Muir: Sure, that sounds great. Sounds like a terrific trade. We get you on the Huddle and I do a little work on the ratio.
Erik Townsend: Sounds fantastic.
Patrick Ceresna: Those of our listeners that are not familiar with the Market Huddle, Kevin Muir and myself have launched a little YouTube show, so you can just go on to YouTube and type in Market Huddle and you can view all the last few episodes.
Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on. Kevin, you wrote a great blog on MMT, on Modern Monetary Theory. And without me kind of spoiling it, why don't you give us a quick rundown of what your thoughts were on this?
Kevin Muir: Well, let me go back first and go to the kind of the origins of why I wrote this blog. About a year ago, I started to see this MMT up on the Twitter and I saw people talking about it. And I was a little embarrassed to kind of realize that, you know, although I knew what it stood for, Modern Monetary Theory, I didn't really understand what it meant and how it differed from other kind of economic theories. So what I did was I reached out to George Pearkes at Bespoke, and I— he kind of passed me on to Stephanie Kelton, which is really the face of MMT. She's a professor at Stony Brook University. And I just, I just started digging, and it was just fascinating stuff. And, uh, you know, I, I put together a blog piece of all of my journey in terms of learning about MMT.
And I included all those different kind of resources that I found while I was exploring this topic.
Erik Townsend: Well, Kevin, as you said in the opening of the piece, if there is one macro tourist blog post that you're going to make time to read this year, this should be it. And I really, really want to applaud you for the approach that you took because you do an excellent Excellent job of trying to help people like me who have a strong personal bias. I don't like the idea of what MMT is all about, and I think the way that you described it is essentially the view that governments should be at liberty to deficit spend all they want. Deficits don't matter. Governments have an unlimited ability to create more money. The only risk that really exists when they create more money is that of inflation. inflation, which is very true. And since right now we've had a deflationary backdrop, the MMT crowd led by Stephanie Kelton holds the view that, hey, if you've got a deflationary backdrop, it's a license for the government to print all kinds of money like it's going out of style and deficit spend to their heart's content.
Now, I personally couldn't disagree more strongly with the notion that that's a good idea. I respectfully disagree with Professor Kelton on almost I agree with almost everything that she says. But what you really brought home in that article, and what I think is so important, is my personal view doesn't matter. I don't like socialism either, but you know what? The trend in society is away from capitalism towards socialism. The trend in society is very much that more and more people are embracing MMT and really feel like it's the right economic model.
Right. Model, the idea that governments ought to embrace the opportunity to deficit spend to their heart's content. And I believe Professor Kelton even makes the argument that in her eyes, it's unethical for them not to spend excessively because it's an opportunity to help all sorts of people during an economic backdrop when inflation is not likely to occur right away.
The reasons I disagree so strongly with that are not important. What is important is this is the trend. This is what's happening. Other people, and there's more of them than there are of me, think this is a wonderful idea. And I think we're gonna see a lot more political sentiment growing around embracing MMT as the economic theory basis of this whole democratic socialist movement that is really taking the United States by storm. I think it's all very bad for humanity and society and the world. It doesn't It doesn't matter what I think. It's happening and it's real. And as an investor, you've got to get your head around the fact that whether you like it or not, this is the way things are going. And you've got to really think then whether you approve or not what the consequences and implications are going to be for financial markets.
Patrick Ceresna: I'm going to actually interject here because I wanted to just take one step back and explain one further thing to our listeners that they may not have gotten. And either of you can correct me if I'm wrong. Currently, money, the vast majority of money, is created, A, first through the monetary base at the central bank level, but then through the credit creation through the main money center banks. And so almost all money is financed through the bond markets. But the idea being floated by MMT is this idea of changing the rules and this idea that essentially governments can run big deficits and go directly to central banks that will fund the shortfall by just simply printing money. And to me, that's a complete game changer. Am I right in my interpretation of that?
Kevin Muir: Well, it's Kevin here. So both of you are still thinking about everything from a kind of an old economic vision. And before, um, Erik mentioned something about this being the domain of left-wing kind of crowd. I, I do want to point out one thing. There's actually some right-wing Wall Street guys that are behind this. Like, for example, Warren Mosler, who, who was, uh, an ex-hedge fund trader who actually ran for president. He's a big advocate of MMT. And interestingly enough, I found this other guy when I was doing my research, which is Glenn Hadden, which is one of the biggest bond traders on Wall Street. He used to work at Goldman Sachs and he eventually ended up at Morgan Stanley. He also is a big advocate of MMT. So it's not just the left that is embracing this policy. And, you know, Ben Hunt from Epsilon Theory, he had a great blog piece, and he, and he kind of predicted that it would also gain traction.
And one of the reasons he predicted it would gain traction is because it was going to be liked by both the left and the right, because as you say, it does give politicians more license to print more— more not print, but to spend more money.
And so that's the first point I would like to make. Now, in terms of the idea that this is just going to be unlimited and that there's no restraint on the government, I think that's also kind of a false notion. What they're saying is that the, the idea that the, the constraint on government spending is a budget, meaning it's like a nominal financial restraint, is wrong. What it is is it's a real constraint.
So in real terms, if, if the society is running and there's excess capacity in it, it makes sense to try to use that capacity in any way we can. So what they're trying to argue is why should we not spend if there's underutilized capacity within the economy? That spending will actually create a higher GDP and will actually be better.
And it's also kind of counterintuitive in that they argue that the government needs to spend first because they are the issuer of the currency, and that currency getting created is actually— has to be done by the government. And so the government's spending has to come before the borrowing. And so listen, I'm not smart enough to figure all these things out in terms of like— my mind races and, and kind of my eyes go, oh, you know, out to the top of my head when I start listening to all these things. And, and it gets very sophisticated in terms of the difference between a Keynesian and an MMT guy.
But I, I agree with Erik in that the big picture is that we are going to find that more and more people are going to embrace this sort of thinking.
And that we were always wondering, where was inflation going to come from? And I always thought that was kind of such a funny thing when people would tell me there's no way that the government is going to create inflation, there's too much debt out there. And I always said, with a political will, the governments can always create inflation.
And there was always this kind of pushback. They said, no, we can't, we can't create inflation because we can't figure out where the money comes from to spend. Well, MMT is now presenting us with kind of the idea that the government doesn't need to figure out where the money is first before they spend, and that really it's only inflation that will hold us back. So I do agree with Erik that ultimately inflation will be a problem. Like in most things, it, it will be a good idea that's taken much too far.
But I kind of push back on the idea that it's, it's as bad and as ominous as Erik is making
Erik Townsend: Well, my real point was not how bad I think it is. My point was whether you agree or disagree with me, it's coming. This is the trend. This is, this is what's catching on. And whether you agree with it or disagree with it isn't that important from an investing standpoint. What is important is to know that this is what the trend is. But I can't resist since we're on the subject, Kevin, and you seem to understand this pretty well. Help me understand I don't understand what seems to be missing from everything I've read on it, which is, if what Professor Kelton is advocating is in an environment— basically, the argument is you can print as much money as you want to, and the risk is inflation, and so therefore, if the inflation is not happening right now, there's nothing wrong with printing right now. If that's the case, why don't we stimulate the economy by cutting all taxes to zero and deficit spending on everything.
We know for a fact that cutting taxes is an effective fiscal stimulant that will dramatically improve the economy. Why wouldn't we just eliminate taxes if this is true?
Kevin Muir: Well, she would argue that it's a societal choice of whether we deficit spend or cut taxes, but it's not like MMTers are against cutting taxes. That's the other thing that people believe, that MMTers somehow believe that 70% percent tax rate that's, uh, that's being kind of thrown about for the top marginal rate is something that they agree with. That is not what they agree with. All they are saying is that the constraint isn't a kind of a financial constraint, it is a real constraint. And when the economy has underutilized capacity, it almost kind of seems counterintuitive to not use it. It's resources that are going to waste.
Now listen, I'm not smart enough to figure out if this is something that's going to work in the long run. And I never kind of wrote my piece trying to say I am an MMTer and this is what I believe in. I wrote my piece basically from what you said, is that I believe that this is gaining more and more traction. It's something that young people really love. It's something that they can get their heads wrapped around. It's also an interesting thing.
After I wrote my piece, I was surprised at how many kind of closet MMTers are out there. And I'm talking big-time money managers that kind of emailed me and said, I actually believe in this. This is something that, that I think is correct, and I think that we should do it. So, I think there's a kind of an underground movement, and that is only going to increase, and we are going to see this kind of pick up steam, and it'll come out, and more and more people will come out of the closet, so to speak, and admit that they're MMTers.
Patrick Ceresna: You know what my pushback on this— I mean, this is redefining what we define I mean, this changes the game. This is, in my mind, almost like a Pandora's box, is once we go down this road, there's no going back. And what if there are things like when you— the only constraint is inflation? Really, the question becomes, how do you really put a limit on a government in terms of how far they take this? Like, once you allow this to become a way from which we conduct monetary policy, I don't know. It's, to me, I'm not sold on it.
Kevin Muir: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: on it anyway.
Kevin Muir: Well, so that's my biggest pushback as well. It's easy to go in the government to create inflation. The more difficult thing will be to slow it down when they finally start competing with the, with the private sector and pushing inflation up. And governments are, you know, it's always easier to spend more. It's more difficult to cut something back. And that's kind of my pushback. MMTers would tell you that they would advocate all sorts of programs that were automatically stabilizing the economy, meaning that they cut back as inflation takes off. And, and guys, there, there's a huge amount of debate, and even amongst the MMT community, it's not something that is, that is agreed upon. It is, it is still a kind of a policy that hasn't really been tried in the real world in terms of actually being implemented full-on. And so it's something that we're going to see that there's the debate of, of what it exactly looks like will vary as we proceed down this path. But make no mistake, I believe that we are headed down this path.
And Erik is right in that you need to start thinking about this from your portfolio perspective, because regardless of whether you think it's good or bad, I really believe— I think it's coming.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, that's a pretty solid case for the long-term bullishness on gold, that's for sure.
Erik Townsend: And I cannot possibly echo you strongly enough. This is not about whether you or I think it's a good idea. It's about a really big picture social trend change, where I think that MMT is going to become the monetary theory of the Democratic Socialist Party, which I expect will be stronger than the old-school Democratic Party before we know it here. And I don't happen to agree with those things. Some of our listeners might agree with those, and I certainly respect your view. But again, it's not about whether I disagree or you do agree. It's about whether or not this is a big trend that is going to change markets, and I'm convinced that it is.
Kevin Muir: Yeah, well, I would say one thing to Erik. What if Trump beats the Democrats to it? Think about that.
Erik Townsend: Oh, if Trump, who is very comfortable with debt, decides to make MMT his baby so that the Democratic Socialists can't claim it as theirs, that would be an interesting scenario. Certainly, that could play out. But, you know, in the grand But in the grand scheme of things, I can't help but come back to the big picture. We've got more than $20 trillion of debt, more than 100% debt to GDP.
You get to that point and you decide, okay, we're not creating debt fast enough. We need to borrow and spend more recklessly. That's the solution to our problems. Does not register for me. But I think that my strongest prediction is that the inflation that the MMTers keep talking about as a They will create their inflation. And because there's such a big lag effect in inflation, by the time that their controls kick in that automatically cut back, it will be too late. They will have created a tidal wave before they really register it on their radar screens as happening. But, you know, I could be wrong about that. It doesn't matter. This is the trend. And I think that in general, as Luke Gromen said on this program, if you don't like Donald Trump, wait till you see the next guy.
Kevin Muir: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: guy they elect. And I think it's going to be very interesting to see. The 2020 election is going to be profoundly important to markets, and the policy that we move forward with is going to be socially influenced.
I was very surprised when Louis Gave was, you know, just completely shocked when I said, what if we see that whatever the Fed wants to do next is vetoed by the people who say, you know, we're not going to let the Fed bail out Wall Street again, and they're literally rioting in the streets. And Louis thought I was crazy to say rioting in the streets. Well, look at what— they're burning Paris down. And it's not moved to the United States yet, but I think it's coming. And these social changes and these mood changes and these philosophical changes in the way government should be organized are going to have profound effects on markets. They're really big trends, and I think that they're unstoppable. But in the interest of time, guys, we're going to have to leave it here. I do want to continue the conversation.
Erik Townsend: So the Market Huddle will be where we can pick up this conversation. You've generously invited me to participate in this new program of yours on Saturday.
Tell our listeners who are not already familiar with it, Patrick, what is the Market Huddle? Where did it come from? What are you trying to accomplish? And where Where can they tune in?
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I love co-hosting MacroVoices with you, but I've been for many months getting together with Kevin, having a beer and just talking about the markets. And we said, hey, we should just get onto YouTube and create a show where we chat about putting on trades and what's going on in the markets, what we think is happening, and just have a great time. So we crack open a beer on a YouTube show here and we just talk about some of the really fun stuff going on the markets. And, uh, Kev's a lot of fun to do it with, right?
Kevin Muir: Yeah, it's a lot of fun. And, uh, we've, uh, we have the occasional guest, and it's good, good to have you on, Erik. We're looking forward to it. And, uh, it's, it's something that's a little more lighthearted than a lot of other ones. We try to, you know, remember and, uh, be a little more, uh, we poke fun at each other and of ourselves. So it's, it's something that makes, uh, for some great, uh, kind of weekend, uh, watching.
Erik Townsend: And where can people Where can people tune in?
Patrick Ceresna: Listeners can find it just by going to the website at www.markethuddle.com or just the YouTube Market Huddle on YouTube.
Erik Townsend: Well, Kevin, thanks for joining us on the program. We're going to need to leave it there in the interest of time. I do have a request for our listeners. We're trying to grow MacroVoices and get more listeners. We find that the best way to do that is for me to appear on other podcast shows. That gets people that are into podcasts Yeah. ...to become aware of MacroVoices. So my request to everyone listening is to write to the producers of your other favorite podcasts, whether they be political, financial, or otherwise, and encourage them to invite me, Erik Townsend, on their show as a guest, because that will help us to source even more listeners for MacroVoices. The more that we grow, the more that we're able to bring you a better show every single week, get more feature interview guests, and deliver even more great content in your Research Roundup.
Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Grant, as well as a link to Kevin Muir's blog on Modern Monetary Theory. There's also an interesting article on that same theme from Paul Krugman on MMT again, as well as an article discussing George Soros talking about the US and China Cold War threatening to turn into a hot one. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback. And support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you have haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Russell Napier — Financial historian (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 151 was recorded a day early this week on Wednesday evening, January 23rd, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Financial historian Russell Napier returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss what's next for Treasury bonds, what the knock-on effects of Chinese policy tightening will be on global markets, whether the decade-long bull market is over, and where developed market equities are headed from here, whether the Fed is out of bullets to fight the next economic downturn, and Russell's outlook for the US dollar, and much, much more. Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, where Patrick and I will discuss Russell's interview, as well as sharing some insights from this past weekend's MacroVoices Live conference in Vancouver.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, that S&P 500 now has finally paused after 4 weeks of ripping almost Almost 400 S&P points off of that low print. We find ourselves now taking a break here. Is that Charlie McElligott scenario finally here where we're gonna take a breather for a week or two? What's on your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Charlie has a fantastic track record, and I'm even betting on it. As attendees at your class last Friday in Vancouver know, I put my first S&P short trade on, and I forget how long it's been, at least a year. And the reason is I have been convinced that the big question has been, how high do we go in order to trap enough dumb money into thinking that we're headed back toward new all-time highs before this bear market resumes. And of course, last week we had Charlie McElligott say, folks, our models are showing us there's an impulse, maybe a push-up on Friday, and then down to a retest by February 1st. And of course, these analogs are never perfectly accurate, but if it's coming from Charlie McElligott, I'm willing to give it a try. So I sold 2675 on Charlie's call for a retest, and I'll watch and see what happens by February 1st to see We'll see how that plays out.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, that's a great call. So let's move on to the US dollar, because the US dollar more or less has been for several weeks now off of its worst levels. We've been testing just above the 96 level. What's your thinking here on the dollar? Is this the beginning of a bull breakout yet at this stage?
Erik Townsend: Well, I wouldn't say beginning of a bull breakout quite yet, but I mean, look at what you're saying. We're flirting with 96, struggling to get over 96. Well, last week we were struggling to get over 95. We had a pretty good pullback. It's no surprise that we had a pullback, because a lot of people are making, I think, the mistake of saying, okay, Fed pause, that means there's no longer a dollar-bullish argument. It's time for the dollar to reverse. You've got to remember that quantitative tightening is every bit as dollar-bullish as Fed rate hikes are. Now, if you think that the Fed is going to stop quantitative tightening and go back to quantitative easing, which I do not think is going to happen anytime soon, That would be a reason to get bearish on the U.S. dollar. That's not happening. I think that that pause or that pullback that we saw in the dollar is because a lot of people didn't think this through completely, and I think as reality sets in, we're eventually going to move higher.
When we break above 97, 97.5, it's going to kick in the technical traders, and I think we'll move sharply higher from there. We'll be close to 100 before we know it. But certainly, if the Fed were to start to signal that they are really considering not continuing quantitative tightening— Now, That would be a game changer. But until that happens, I think we're headed higher.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because we got all the way up to the $54 handle and it seems to have paused here. Does oil have more to go here?
Erik Townsend: Well, as I've been saying for a couple of weeks now, I don't think so. I don't expect much over $55. And of course, there's always a caveat in the oil market. A geopolitical upset, a war or something can change everything overnight. We could be looking at $100 oil if, you know, there's a major war in the Middle East. But barring a geopolitical upset, I think where we're headed is toward a consolidation range between, let's say, 45 and 55. We topped out at— what was it— 44.5 or so.
And, you know, if we get more recession indications or an economic downturn, that could bring us below 40. This week we had an unexpectedly large 6.6 million barrel crude oil build that got the selling started on Wednesday. We'll have to see where it goes. Certainly that crude oil build was good for a little bit of sell-off. Is it going to continue back down to Let's say below $50, which is where I think it's headed, maybe back toward $45. Well, time will tell.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's talk gold. Gold clearly has been struggling to beat that $1,300 handle and has kind of backed off of there. We're much more in the $1,280 range now. What's your thinking here on gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, as I said last week, my favorite case is it tops out here, retraces lower as the dollar index eventually recovers. But as I also admitted last week, gold has been stronger than than I expected. A daily close over 1,300 would really have to make me scratch my head. Now, what really came up— and this is something we discussed at length at MacroVoices Live in Vancouver— is a trade we talked about, oh boy, almost 2 years ago really starts to make sense in my head again, and that's to be long gold and long the dollar index at the same time. The logic there is if gold is going to break out here despite the strength That we're seeing in the dollar index, as so many people have said that it will, and to my own surprise, it's been stronger than I expected in the face of relative dollar strength. If that's going to happen, you want to catch it.
The thing is, if it turns out that I'm right and strength in the dollar is going to push gold back down below $1,200, ouch, that could be painful.
If you look at the pairs trade, long gold and long the dollar at the same time, there's a lot of arguments you can make for them to trade in inverse correlation, meaning you make money on one, lose money on than the other, but net-net, you don't lose anything. There's an argument for why they could both move up together, in which case it's a double win, but there's not a lot of arguments for why they would both move down at the same time.
So, my strategy is, I still think that $1,300 is probably going to hold this thing for now. I'm going to wait it out. I'm hoping to get a chance to buy gold much lower. I think that if the dollar really takes off, we could see gold retest $1,000 before— and I don't mean in the next few weeks, but eventually, I think we could see gold retest $1,000 before it really moves into its next major bull market. On the other hand, Patrick, if we get a daily close above $1,300 and it stays there for a few days, I'll probably put on that pairs trade, long gold and long the dollar, not because I'm so excited about gold at these prices, but because I know that pairs trade will work for the reasons that I've described earlier.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's talk about interest rates, because what an extraordinary move November and December was, where we saw 3.25% drop down, almost down to 2.50% on the yield. And but now we've been backfilling that. We're now trading around 2.75 on the yield. What's your thinking? Was that it for this yield move, or do you think interest rates can still go lower after a pause here?
Erik Townsend: I think interest rates can still go lower. I'm not convinced that they will. I think what happened is we had a false breakout above 3.12 on the 10-year, got all the way up to 3.25. Then we kind of had a panic short squeeze that took us all the way down to, I think, what was the low print, 2.58 or so on the 10-year yield. And now we're back up into
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: To the middle, erring on the high side of that technical range between 2.60 and 2.80.
If we move above 2.80 decisively and stay there for a few days, it's really going to make me scratch my head. But I think that if I'm reading the tea leaves correctly here, there is an economic signal, recession signal, that would portend lower Treasury yields, at least on a cyclical basis. We got a short squeeze that rocketed us all the way to 2.58. The panic ended.
We're kind of rebounding off of that. So we're back to 2.75. Maybe we get all the way up to 2.80. And then I think you might resume a more gradual move lower in yield if I'm right about the recession signal. The recession signal's a false alarm, then I think we do end up moving higher. But for now, I'm leaning toward maybe testing 2.80 and then moving lower in yield.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, MacroVoices Live this past weekend was amazing. What great reactions we got from everyone. What did you take away? from this weekend's event?
Erik Townsend: I was really— I'll just go ahead and say it, Patrick. I don't usually toot my horn this much, but I was proud of what we pulled off there. I don't think I can ever remember anywhere seeing a panel of people— as when we had our town hall forum in the afternoon, I don't remember ever anywhere seeing that much intelligence on one stage at one time. Meeting the people that came was amazing. The lengths that they went to— we had one guy come from Cape Town, South Africa, another one from Sydney, Australia. A whole bunch of people came from Beijing, and I lost count of how many flew in from cities all over Europe, all for a 1-day financial conference. And it is just incredibly flattering to me personally.
The big winner of the weekend, though, was Steve Staretsky, one of our attendees who won Macro Intelligence's draw. He threw his card into the fishbowl that Gretchen Brigden had set up. I thought that was for their retail product. Did you know, Patrick, that Gretchen gave away a $36,000 value, 1-year subscription to Macro Intelligence's not the retail product, but their full institutional product? So Steve's $250 ticket got him a $36,000 institutional research value.
Patrick Ceresna: I forgot to put my business card in there, so now I'm regretting it.
Erik Townsend: I am too. We have to make a rule next time Gretchen Brigden decides to give $36,000 away, she has to tip And give us at least a month's worth of it or something. I don't know. But it was just an amazing experience, and I really enjoyed meeting so many of our listeners and the enthusiasm and excitement that was in the room. Seeing the tweets— I gave up skiing 20 years ago, but a whole bunch of people went skiing. I saw pictures on Twitter of what looked like an incredible snow day up at Whistler afterwards, and it was just a great experience overall. So I really, really enjoyed it, and I look forward to doing it again sometime. Thank you.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, no, it was definitely a great event. Yeah. And I look forward to our future ones. Nonetheless, this week, our featured interview guest is Russell Napier. Erik, let's share with our listeners why we love to bring Russell back onto the show so often.
Erik Townsend: Russell Napier is one of my favorite interview guests ever. He was super famous back in his CLSA days as, you know, one of everybody's favorite macro analysts. And I remember when I first discovered, as a listener, discovered financial podcasting, just listening to Russell talk never ceases to fascinate me. And something I've noticed, these guys who are bona fide financial historians like Russell Napier or Niall Ferguson, they, they don't just talk like everybody else is about what's happening in today's market. They really have deep perspective on how what's going on today relates to the development of finance over a period not just of decades but of centuries. And the intelligence in this man's head never It's amazing. It was only in the course of doing this interview that I found out, normally, back in the day, Russell did a lot of conferences for CLSA. He's been kind of a hard guy to get ahold of, and he wrote an excellent book called Anatomy of the Bear, but to really get more than a podcast interview out of him has been difficult.
He's got a full program, a full training course that was only offered very occasionally in Europe. They're bringing it to Toronto, and we'll talk about that in this interview. So I know as soon as you heard it, you signed up for it. I would do the same thing. I'm supposed to be speaking at MIT that weekend. Otherwise, I'd be there with you. So he's just one of my favorite, most insightful guys in the entire industry, and I really look forward to this interview.
Patrick Ceresna: Without further ado, Erik's interview with Russell Napier is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Russell Napier, financial historian and the founder of the investment research platform ERIC. Russell, thanks so much for joining us again on the program. Last time we had you on was back in May of last year. At that time, you told us that it was likely that there would be continued weakness in the Treasury bond market because for the first time in many For many, many years, private savers had to finance what had become a situation of central banks being net sellers of Treasuries. And needless to say, we did see a big move up in Treasury yields since then, all the way up to 3.25%. Now it started to turn around. And I remember you also cautioned us. You said a lot of people really were convinced of an inflation prognosis. You said you thought that was not going to last. So as I see bond yields turning around, does that mean that the market is catching up? with your expectation that deflation rather than inflation would rule the day?
And where do you see Treasury yields going from here?
Russell Napier: Yeah, I think we have reached a tipping point. Back to that initial prognosis, when you see an incredible surge in the supply of Treasuries, the easiest forecast to make is that the price has to go down and the yield has to go up. And remember, that surge in supply comes from 2 sources. One, the United States Treasury, The fiscal deficit's effectively doubled over the last 5 years, so it's nearly $1 trillion. It was less than half a trillion in 2014. And of course, the second source of supply, brand new one, is the Federal Reserve. And that will be up to about $360 billion this year. Total, roughly $1.3 trillion. So we've never seen anything like that before. And as soon as I give you those supply numbers, the temptation is to say, well, yields have to go up.
However, that has not been happening for the last few months. And the reason is, I believe, that the Treasury yield is probably the most reflexive financial instrument on the planet. Remember Soros' definition of reflexivity? It is that the different— it's the reverse of the business school definition of how security prices are determined, which is those prices are determined by looking at the fundamentals. The Soros view is that sometimes, not all times, but sometimes, the security price changes the fundamentals. Now, that could never be more true than the US yield curve and the level of US interest rates. I think what message we got about 2 months ago is that at the level of interest rates then pertaining, there was ample demand for this massive supply of Treasuries. But crucially, it forced the liquidation of other securities from somewhere else in the world. That's why the equity market was going down. It was forcing a liquidation, whether in offshore equity markets or the local equity market, to cover this massive supply of Treasuries.
Now, if the fundamentals are changing, which is not just the price of equities, but economic fundamentals, if growth is slowing, Going somewhere, it doesn't have to be in America, it could be in China, it could be in Europe. But if that move in US rates is playing a role in slowing growth somewhere, then it's creating its own fundamentals, because clearly, it's creating a fundamental for lower growth and lower inflation. And I believe that is the phase we have now entered. So despite not forecasting this huge supply, because you don't have to forecast it, it's almost certain to occur. Despite that large supply, I think what happens is we liquidate other savings assets to buy the Treasuries.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Russell Napier: The Treasury yield continues to decline, and more importantly, by liquidating private sector assets, we begin to slow global private sector growth.
Erik Townsend: So, slowing growth, continuing lower Treasury yields. Let's tie China into this story. How does China affect this just on its own? And then how does the US-China trade relations and the negotiations that are ongoing between President Trump and President Xi? play into this whole story?
Russell Napier: Yeah, so we need to separate China into 2, monetary effect and then get to the trade. They are linked. It's really essential to consider China's role in funding the United States government. And that currently is zero. It hasn't been zero forever, as you're aware, really since the devaluation of the RMB in '94. China was a massive buyer of Treasuries all the way to 2014. So not only did we have a much smaller supply of Treasuries, we had a guaranteed forced buyer. The PBOC never woke up in the morning and chose to buy Treasuries. It was forced to buy Treasuries. That was a residual from its exchange rate policy, but its reserves are down.
They may be fluctuating a little bit, but they're certainly not growing at the pace they used to grow at.
So the PBOC plays no role now in financing the United States government. It's very hard to get clean numbers on this because of the way the PBOC buys and sells Treasuries these days, but it's certainly possible Given the recent trends in their foreign reserves, that actually they might be adding to the supply of Treasuries to the private savings sector, because they may be, at the margin, more a seller than a buyer. So, it plays into this dynamic. If we take away a guaranteed buyer, whether it's the PBOC, whether it's the Saudi Arabian Monetary Authority, whether it's the Bank of China, whether it's the Bank of Korea, if we take away those guaranteed buyers, and remember, those buyers funded their purchases of Treasuries Treasuries by the creation of new money, not by liquidating another savings asset, then more and more of the burden of funding the US government falls upon people— that's you and me— who can only fund the US government by liquidating something else or saving more.
So the economic impact of the PBOC not being there is actually quite profound, because it's forcing a realignment of savings for the first time. And that's been underway since 2014. So it isn't new. What is new, of course, is what we referred to earlier, which is a massive increase in the supply of Treasuries. So the fact that they're not there, and then you at least double the supply of Treasuries, I think has a profound impact. But I want to stress over and over again that the impact is that other assets have to be sold to fund the government. And that's where we should be looking for that to play out. So that's the impact on the Treasury market.
Domestically, of course, what it means is that if China's foreign exchange reserves are not going up, that's its central bank's key asset, its liabilities are also not going up. And remember, the liabilities of a central bank Bank are effectively what we call quantitative easing. So actually, China's involved in quantitative tightening. It's not deliberate, planned, managed, and voluntary quantitative tightening that the Fed is pursuing. It's an enforced quantitative tightening, because when its assets come down, its liabilities have to come down, and those liabilities are primarily commercial bank reserves.
So there's 2 negatives there for the world. One, the saver has to take up more of the strain of funding the US government if the PBOC isn't there. And 2, that's a tighter monetary policy. Now, I know the world is convinced That China's running a looser monetary policy. And China can proclaim all it wants as to what it intends to do, wants to do, and wishes to do. But when you run that exchange rate management policy, your monetary policy is forced upon you. And the lack of an external surplus, they're being forced to tighten monetary policy. And it's evident in the contraction in commercial bank reserves, which has now been underway in China for about a year.
And finally, on trade, the key way trade plays into this is China desperately needs an external surplus of some sort. That's how it could have exchange rate stability. And at the same time, print a lot of money and grow. But I think whatever the outcome, I think whatever the outcome of the deal between China and America, it's incredibly difficult to see that being positive for China's trade account.
The president has gone— the president of the United States has gone looking for concessions. I think he's going to have to get some concessions. We can all argue as to what concessions they would be. But as to how that would work to the benefit of China's trade account, I think that is the least likely outcome.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Russell Napier: from this. To the extent that China's trade account deteriorates and its capital account remains static, then we are looking at further tightening of Chinese monetary policy.
Erik Townsend: Further tightening of Chinese monetary policy, coming back to our previous discussion about the US situation, you said it's basically forecasting a slowing of global growth. Is this a global recession signal that we're receiving? At the moment, it looks like we're seeing a bounce in equity markets from the lows that we saw over Christmas. Is that likely to turn back down as we need to liquidate more private assets in order to fund government spending and government deficits?
Russell Napier: Yes. A lot of the reason for enthusiasm in the last few days has been the comments of Jay Powell last week. There is one thing Jay Powell could do to give us a sustained bounce in the markets. I don't think a bull market, but a sustained bounce, which would be to cancel his balance sheet contraction. Now, if you want to take last week's comments as being Of that magnitude? I don't think they were. I don't think they were at all. But that is the one thing that— if last week's comments mean anything that's bullish, it would have to be that. Short of that, I don't think it makes any difference. So I don't believe he committed to that last week. I don't believe he made any indication that that is more likely. And therefore, I don't believe the comments last week are ultimately particularly important.
What I would like to stress, and I've stressed before on this call, is this is about China. This is not about America. What is going on here is 100% about China. We like to believe that the Federal Reserve is the world's most important central bank, but it isn't. The People's Bank of China is. Remember, the Fed will set its nominal interest rates based upon its inflation expectations. So the most important central bank in the world is the central bank that dictates global inflation, because all the other central bankers, inflation targeters, will have to move nominal rates to reflect global inflation.
Now, I would argue very strongly that the key determinant of global inflation is the world's second-biggest economy, China, because it— not just because of its rate of growth, but because of its rate of investment. Also, because its exchange rate was very overvalued for nearly 20 years. And the overvaluation of its exchange rate and its need to slow at the current exchange rate means that we're looking at slower growth globally, tighter monetary policy globally. And the focus should really be on that dynamic. What's forced upon China rather than what decisions Jay Powell might make. We can get the decisions of Jay Powell wrong. That's a common thing. But I think if we look focused on the overvalued Chinese exchange rate, it's very difficult to see how they get out of that particular pickle. That one is much more important, I believe, than changes in the views of Jay Powell.
Erik Townsend: Speaking of changes in the view of Jay Powell and the rest of the FOMC, until recently, there was Widespread expectations that there would be several more rate hikes through 2019. And, you know, between the dot plot and the Eurodollar futures spreads, everybody was anticipating plenty more rate hiking to come. It seems like we've seen a total reversal now in sentiment, in that most people are now discounting— maybe the question is not how many more hikes, but when does the first cut come. So is this change in sentiment just catching up with something that was already going on in the market, or is the sentiment change overreacting? Are we really seeing a dovish pivot where the Fed is maybe moving back toward at some point responding to market conditions by cutting policy rates again, or where do you see this headed?
Russell Napier: Yeah, so I never believed that Fed rates were going to march off 2019. You know, even last May when we discussed this, I used the word deflation quite openly, more focused on deflation outside of America and credit crisis outside America. And I think in May, we were focused on Turkey. So that is where the pain will fall. And it was very difficult for me to believe that in a world of what I saw as slowing growth and falling inflation and credit crises— it turned out there was one in Argentina as well. There's been a myriad of them, by the way, across Africa. And they are spreading even as we speak— that US interest rates would continue to go up. In fact, on May 8th, Jay Powell spoke and said that at this His impact outside of America would have no impact on his monetary policy. That may still be true. What should have an effect on his monetary policy is he's not actually creating a lot of money.
Now, I realize there'll be a lot of people who will listen to that statement and think that's a form of madness to make that statement.
But broad money, which is the money that circulates around the economy for goods, services, and has a huge role in GDP, has been slowing dramatically in America and really across the planet, very dramatically in emerging markets. In China, it's had a huge impact. A new post-war low. It's down in Europe, it's down in Japan, it's down in America. And the market was sitting back saying, well, we're looking at a tightening here. Clearly looking at the jobs market more than anything else, tightness in the jobs markets, a little bit of wage inflation, and completely ignoring the money supply data, which has been getting worse and worse and worse for about a year to a year and a half. So that is the reality. It's very difficult to buy into a world of more growth and more inflation and higher asset prices in a world when the growth of Broad money is getting lower and lower and lower.
So the Fed is reacting to that.
And as I say, one of the crucial things about this are balance sheet issues. We can look at the P&L, which is growth, but this is not a robust global balance sheet we're looking at here. The total private sector non-financial debt to GDP ratio of the world is at a new all-time high.
And from memory, it's gone from 210% of GDP at the end of 2007 to 242% today. So we're looking at a more fragile system, I would say, particularly outside of the US rather than inside Outside the US, we're looking at slowing growth and movements we see in interest rates at the long end, and now also with changes at the short end, just reflect this reality. So, 10 years of extreme and exceptional monetary policy, and we've got some of the lowest levels of broad money growth ever recorded.
Erik Townsend: So, you, as the man who literally wrote the book on bear markets, how do you interpret all of this, bringing it together in terms of a forecast or outlook? outlook for developed and particularly US equity markets? Is this a bear market rally that we're experiencing right now? And what would you see the rest of 2019 bringing us in terms of equity market action?
Russell Napier: So by only focusing on 4 bear markets in that book, I clearly focused on very exceptional circumstances and not the traditional definition of a bear market, which is every 20% correction. But what I would say about all 4 of those where valuations got incredibly Incredibly cheap. Incredibly cheap, below 10 times CAPE, and we're currently close to 30 times CAPE. How on earth could any equity market fall that far? Well, history is very clear. Deflation. For these 4 big ones, not the average bear market, but for the big ones, it would be deflation. And deflation is falling cash flow. That's why it's important for equities.
And a falling cash flow, should it occur, can threaten the very existence of equity if you've got a very geared balance sheet. That is true. The United States has a very geared balance sheet. The non-financial corporate debt-to-GDP ratio is a new all-time high, just gone above its 2007 level. So it's a vulnerable balance sheet. But the most vulnerable balance sheets, I think, to any deflation are outside of the United States of America. So if we do think that this monetary policy has failed, failed to generate the level of broad money growth commensurate with inflation and growth, and we're rolling back over into no growth and a risk of deflation— once again, I stress, more likely outside than inside the United States of America— then this is a very Very big bear market.
And anybody who forecasts anything needs to look at the disease and the cure. This is a disease which may, in fact, not be as bad as 2007. But the cure's used up. I know that our central bankers are always finding new and innovative cures, but this one didn't work. It simply didn't work. It stopped the collapse of the global financial system. Absolutely correct. But did it prevent a surge in the debt-to-GDP ratio? No, it didn't, because it simply failed to create enough money. So the risk going forward is that people are not so frightened of the disease, but wonder if there's a monetary cure at least. And I think that would be the most frightening thing for investors who spent nearly 10 years now being told that buying on a dip is always the way to proceed because the central banker always comes and bails you out. And I believe that, and I've said it for some years, that one day that central banker arrives and he doesn't bail you out.
It doesn't work. And I would argue that in Europe in particular, That is the evidence. I mean, European equities are below 2007 levels. They're below 2014 levels. They're not far away from their 2011 levels. In fact, the EAFE index, i.e., the whole world except the United States of America, is very similar. So, outside the United States of America, there's really quite a lot of evidence that this magic wand of central banking does not create any magic.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little more about how that would unfold. Let's suppose that what we're about to learn here is that this experiment of the last 10 years proved that you can in fact paper over your problems and delay the inevitable by conjuring money out of thin air. But there's still no free lunch. The piper has to be paid eventually, and there's going to be a consequence for all of this loose monetary policy. It's going to come back and haunt us. If that's true, how would it come back and haunt us? What would What would it look like? What would the mechanisms be? And what kind of feedback loops would develop in terms of creating a new bear market from here? How would it all play out?
Russell Napier: Yeah. So just to be clear, the failure was that this monetary policy created debt much more quickly than it created money. So that's the failure. And we can all look at how much money it created, but all the statistics from the BIS show it's been creating debt even more quickly. The BIS also look at what, how you would analyze their debt-to-GDP ratio to say when this becomes a problem. And they've done that. And what they've looked at is not the level of debt-to-GDP, but the pace at which it grows. And then they single out, backtesting this, certain countries where the growth in the debt-to-GDP ratio, which I believe is a consequence of this monetary policy, has hit such a height and such a divergence from its long-term trend that you can expect something to give.
A financial crisis, a credit crisis, are the terms that they The one country that jumps off the page from these statistics, that screams something has to give, is China. Now, its debt-to-GDP ratio is very similar to the United States, but the growth and the pace of growth is just at an alarming rate.
Now, I paused a little bit when I said financial crisis, credit crisis, because frankly, I just believe China would devalue and print a lot of money rather than begin to suffer the consequences of having a massive growth in debt relative to growth in money. But that is the catalyst. I can give you lots of catalysts for another deflationary shock, but I can think of none more profound and dangerous and changing things for a generation than a change in the Chinese exchange rate. So I believe that that is coming. And I believe that China could not and will not move to a new link to the dollar. They will not politically get away with undervaluing their exchange rate again. So we are looking at moving into a world where the renminbi is a flexible exchange rate, it should happen this year.
And the initial movement on the renminbi is down. That is deflationary because the dollar selling price of Chinese goods comes down. It's deflationary because of the impact it has on China's competitors. And that's where the deflation shock can come from. Most obviously, it will create bankruptcies amongst some of China's competitors on their foreign currency debt.
And maybe we can get onto this later, but I think in the very long run, it's highly inflationary.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Russell Napier: And once China lets that exchange rate go, we realize— for the first time, I think, people begin to realize that the Fed isn't determining global monetary policy, because it doesn't determine the global inflation. China determines global inflation. And believe me, with a flexible exchange rate and a truly independent monetary policy and a huge debt burden to be inflated away, China will be ultimately, after that first adjustment in the exchange rate, will ultimately be generating global inflation for the next 2 to 3 decades.
Erik Townsend: The things that you're saying kind of concern me, Russell, because it seems to me that if the biggest risk is in China, we know that China and the United States trade tensions are already very tight. The US president has been very aggressive. If China is going to experience economic difficulty and there's a transmission risk that that economic difficulty will maybe bring down the rest of the global economy with it, That sounds to me like a recipe for further political tension between the governments. Am I wrong to think that that's a serious risk? And if it is a risk, what are the financial implications? And what are the investment concerns that we should think about in terms of how further geopolitical tension between the United States and China, if that were to develop, how it might play out?
Russell Napier: Okay, so we have a blueprint for what this means. And it comes from a speech made by Mike Pence in early October at the Hudson Institute in Washington, DC. And I strongly advise anybody listening to this should listen to that and hear it, if you like, from the horse's mouth as to what the relationship between the United States and China is. And trade is a tiny tip of the iceberg in terms of the issues raised in that speech. Now, of course, it was pre-midterms, saber rattling. Were they just trying to get leverage on trade? Well, listen to the speech, come to your own conclusion.
But it attacked China for theft of intellectual property. It attacked it for pure human rights. It attacked it for attacks on religions. It attacked it for interfering in Western democracy. In fact, it was very difficult to work out a thing that wasn't attacked. Trade was just a very small part of the reasons that were brought up by the vice president for this change in relationship with China.
Now, I've spoken to many people about that, some of them in the defense business, and all of them believe this is important. They all believe it's profound, and many of them are prepared to go as far as saying this is the beginning of a new Cold War. Now, that may be too extreme, but I think, Erik, we are both old enough to remember the last Cold War. And here's some things that you don't do in a Cold War. Let's go back to that last one. I don't remember US institutional investors investing a lot of money in Russia. I think it was illegal. Didn't happen. I don't remember us doing a lot of trade with Russia, once again, for the same reason. I don't remember lots of Russians coming to visit us here in Edinburgh, nor coming to the United States of America.
If we enter a form of Cold War, it may— I mean, I hope it really isn't as bad as that, and it may not be anywhere near as bad as that. But the degree of movement of capital, of goods, and of people, which we currently expect between China and the rest of the world, could not and would not continue if this is genuinely the beginning of a new Cold War.
So investors are very loath to get into geopolitics, because, look, I wouldn't say 99 times out of 100, it's not relevant. What's relevant are cash flows in corporations and the price you pay for those cash flows. But China has become the 2nd biggest economy in the world. It's become such an integral part of the global trading/economic system that for a Cold War curtain to descend upon China and the rest of the West today would be phenomenally damaging for not just growth, but financial stability, and particularly for the Asian countries that border China. China would put them in an incredibly difficult position. They have benefited from a generation of the American defense umbrella while trading freely with China.
And if the Pence speech is in any way indicative of the future relationship, this dual benefit will not be possible. It's going to be one or the other, but getting both is very difficult. So I absolutely— and I may be reading too much into the speech of Mike Pence, but there's been plenty more from the US defense establishment There's been a lot of developments since then to suggest that we've looked at a shift towards a more Cold War.
Anybody who remembers the last one knows that that has dire implications for investors.
Erik Townsend: Do you think that we have reached a point where the top is in for the equity explosion of the last 10 years, which I think you and I both agree has been fueled in large part by central bank largesse?
Russell Napier: Is it over?
Erik Townsend: Or is it possible that what happens next is markets
Announcer: really start to take a dive, Powell comes riding to the rescue, and there's another round of QE or something, and it takes us to still new all-time highs in equity markets?
Russell Napier: So I believe it's over, but obviously that can happen. That second scenario is obviously a possibility, and we can try and weigh that possibility. But there was always a risk. You may remember this time last year, one of the big topics of discussion was the melt-up up, which is as the rest of the world slowed, America would import lower inflation, allowing interest rates to stay low with American growth high.
Put in a low discount rate and a high growth rate, you get a melt-up in equity valuation. As it turned out, in terms of equity valuations, if not price, they actually peaked at the end of January, and they've come down pretty significantly in America since then.
I just want to point out one thing. We are fixated with the American equity market, and we should be. It's 58% of global market capitalization. But the world is not in a bull market if you're not in America. Once again, these EAFE numbers show there is no bull market. The EAFE index is— this is without dividends reinvested, so if you want, slightly false. But looking at the capital market for EAFE in dollar terms, it is really not very far away from where it was 18 years ago.
So this is very much about a US equity bull market. There has been a bear market underway in most places in the world. And certainly since 2014, there's been a bear market in emerging markets. I see. European equities are below that level as well. So we're really talking about, can America continue to do what it's been doing, at least since 2014, arguably since much earlier, which is to continue to have a bull market as everybody else has a bear market? My answer to that would be no, because at some stage, what is out there in the rest of the world begins to infect America.
So I've written recently that this may be like the late 1920s, that through the 1920s, America had an economic boom, and America had a stock market boom, and things were pretty subdued. Viewed outside of America. But eventually, the economic problems of the rest of the world through the 1920s came home to roost and affected the United States of America. So the go-to book on this is the famous Golden Fetters by Barry Eichengreen, who argues that eventually, the problems for the rest of the world have to impact America. The question is, was it— is it happening already? Or have we got another 6 months to go? It's difficult to argue in such short-term time horizons. But my basic bet is that things are going so badly in the rest of the world that America America cannot continue to buck the trend with an equity bull market when the rest of the world's equity bear market drags on.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about that scenario where America's equity market does eventually take a more significant turn south from where it is already. A lot of people have talked about the Fed being, quote unquote, out of bullets now that they have done so much already. They don't have capacity. Capacity to do that much more. And of course, starting from very low interest rates, it's hard to reduce them very much.
How much— and I guess the counterargument to that would be, well, there's no limit to how much QE they could do. And, you know, they, they can go back to zero interest rates or even go to negative policy rates. What do you think? How much, if things really get bad— I guess what I really worry about is it feels to me like we're gonna have an awakening where at some point investors are going to realize, wait a minute, the Fed wants to have our back, but they can't anymore. It doesn't work anymore because the Fed is no longer all-powerful because they've used up all their ammunition. Are we really getting close to that point, or am I just being paranoid to worry about that?
Russell Napier: I worry about that as well, and I'll come to the reason in a minute, which is related with China and the lack Lack of potency of the Fed. But let's be clear what the Fed has succeeded at and what it's failed at. It's fairly, very, very clearly succeeded in asset price inflation. And obviously, when you're in the financial markets, you tend to think that that's success, because it's making you wealthier. It's making your clients wealthier. This is how we measure success. So therefore, we tend to think, well, they've always got another— something else they can fire, and they're always successful. Well, they failed to create money. This is the crucial, crucial thing. They're very good at creating narratives.
Erik Townsend: Mm-hmm.
Russell Napier: —expanding their own balance sheet. Nothing can really stop them from doing that. But there's screeds of evidence now that this has not fed into broad money. So, one thing they've failed in is broad money growth. And ultimately, that has to have some role in economic activity and inflation. So, I don't think they're as potent as the market seems to think they are, because they failed in that particular issue.
Now, let me give you the sort of scenario. It's really the scenario from The Wizard of Oz, which you'll remember. Dorothy spots that the Wizard is just a little man playing an organ behind a curtain. And here's the scenario in which I think the potency of the Fed would be massively questioned instantaneously. China devalues. The Chinese exchange rate is allowed to float. It comes down. We have Chinese goods pouring out at lower dollar prices. We have bankruptcies in other emerging markets, as we did post the 1994 devaluation. And any market practitioner could say, Well, I don't care what the Fed does, because the Fed can have some role in dictating US economic activity.
But if the rest of the world is going into the tank, and the Chinese are slashing all these prices, then how potent is the Fed? So, you know, I could make a long argument that really the PBOC has been determining global monetary policy for 2 decades. They've determined the marginal rate of inflation, therefore they've determined Nobody would agree with that, or few people would agree with that.
But the day they devalue is the day that it becomes very, very apparent that as powerful as the Federal Reserve is, and as infinite as its balance sheet can become, they're not the only player in establishing global growth and global inflation.
Erik Townsend: Russell, you mentioned Chinese currency devaluation potentially having very, very significant consequences transmitted risks into the rest of the economy. What other currencies around the world should we be thinking about, and what are the risks there?
Russell Napier: Well, there is one major currency in the world which is considered today by everybody to be a safe haven, but I do not believe it is so, and that is the yen. Now, why is something believed to be a safe haven? Well, capital flows into it when we have troubles. No one can deny that, and no one can deny that when there are problems in the world, the yen tends to go up. So, that's the status quo. That's the way it has traded.
However, there are 2 major problems for the yen. The first one is the Fed is contracting its balance sheet. The ECB has stopped expanding its balance sheet. There's really no prospect that the Bank of Japan is going to stop. It's going to continue. So I've made this analogy in the past, but it's like driving 3 Ferraris, all valued at half a million US, towards the first corner. They're all worth half a million until they come to the first corner, and we discover that one doesn't have any brakes. At which stage, the 2 that maneuver the corner are still worth half a million US, but the other one is scrap value. Well, that was all theoretical, because nobody else was braking But the 2 big guys are braking now So we'll see what impact it has as it becomes clear, I think, clearer and clearer and clearer that the Bank of Japan won't stop.
Now, once again, back to the analogy we made earlier with the US, it's fine for the central bank balance sheet to expand, but it isn't really creating great growth in broad money. And I think that's why the yen hasn't reacted more negatively already, because it's in the same boat as everyone else. They just can't create money no matter how No matter how hard they try, or at least they can't create very much money. However, even so, I think time will tell that when one balance sheet shrinks, one balance sheet stabilizes, and the other balance sheet keeps going like a rocket, there have to be implications for the exchange rate.
And then to that China thing, the whole of North Asia is incredibly vulnerable to a Chinese devaluation. So that is South Korea, Taiwan, and Japan. And it would be inconceivable if they were to permit the rise in the exchange rate. So I can't tell you exactly what they'll have to do about that.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Russell Napier: Get those exchange rates down. But the idea that they would sit by and watch as China devalues and they kept their exchange rates up, very, very unlikely indeed. So expect more concerted effort by the rest of North Asia to try and react.
Remember, there are 2 broad financial systems in the world. There's kind of the so-called free market system, which isn't that free, but it seeks ultimately profit. And then there's the North Asian model, which seeks ultimately the full utilization of resources. And in that model, the policymakers always have to devalue, because that's the goal. And they don't really care if they make any money, but they have to keep the full utilization of resources, whether it's people or factories.
So China devalues. There may be an initial spike up in the yen, but the Bank of Japan is going to have to get even more aggressive. And therefore, I think the yen ultimately comes down. And the big structural background behind this is one that's been around for a long time.
The Fed has shown it can reverse. The ECB can, I think, ultimately reverse as well. There's lots of private sector savings that can buy euro-denominated government debt. But Japan ran out of savings many years ago because its debt-to-GDP ratio is so high. So the other 2 can stop, but the Bank of Japan is caught in that traditional trap, which ultimately always leads to high levels of inflation.
Though nobody believes that in Japan, just because of our history of the last 30 years. But when you have a central bank that can't stop, You will get to inflation eventually. The first financial market that has always sniffed that out is the exchange rate. Despite the fact that it definitely trades as a safe haven currency, I think particularly as we get a movement in the RMB, I think we will change our minds on what the yen represents.
Erik Townsend: Let's come back to the US dollar while we're on currencies. The last time we had you on the program, your outlook was very much for a higher US dollar. US dollar, and you have been proven right. But now we're coming into a period of time when there's been this reversal of expectations around US monetary policy. Suddenly what everybody thought was 3 to 4 hikes is maybe going to be a question of how many cuts come in 2019. Does that change the outlook for the dollar? Have we maybe reached a top here, or do you still see the dollar moving higher?
Russell Napier: No, it doesn't change it for me. In fact, it makes me more convinced that we're looking at the dollar going higher. And you Now, you might think, well, that's peculiar, isn't it? I mean, how can we look at a lower outlook for US interest rates? A higher dollar, first of all, I'd always considered there'd be— interest rates wouldn't be rising at the pace the market had considered anyway. But remember, the real reason this is happening is not because of economic activity in the United States per se. It's because of what's happening in the rest of the world. We are focusing on US rates a lot, but look, the 10-year German Bund yield, just 3 days ago, was incredibly close to zero.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Russell Napier: We've got a negative 10-year back again on the JGB. This is really about growth outside of America. So US growth, I'm sure, will slow. I'm sure US inflation will come down. I'm pretty sure the Fed won't be putting rates up. But things are getting much worse in Europe. They're getting much worse in emerging markets. And it's all about the— an exchange rate is the relative between these 2 things. Nor does— I can't remember if we discussed it last May, but coming up this May, we have the European parliamentary elections.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Russell Napier: And in those elections, the extreme left and the extreme right are going to do incredibly well. How well? Perhaps 40% of the entire representation of the European Parliament will be extreme left and right. They have, according to Di Maio, the Deputy Prime Minister of Italy, already agreed to collaborate. This is not unknown for the extreme left and the extreme right to do because they share one thing in common.
And the one thing they share in common is they all want to bring power back to their sovereign parliaments and away from Brussels.
Now, that is a constitutional crisis on a grand scale, which cannot be good for the euro. It questions the entire existence of the euro when you get a constitutional crisis of that magnitude. So if currencies are relative, given what I said about the RMB, the yen, and this massive constitutional crisis coming for Europe, then it's very hard for me to stand here and tell you that the dollar's going down. Just by default, the dollar is probably going up. The reasons the dollar's coming down have really nothing to do with interest rates. They're much more existential than that. China has an overvalued exchange rate, which is tightening monetary policy. Europe is involved in a failed experiment to create a single currency. And Japan has run out of savings. 3 structural reasons why these exchange rates should come down. And the dollar has questions.
The US political system has questions. The US economy have questions.
Russell Napier: But they're not on the scale of the questions we'll be asking when the fascists and the communists
Erik Townsend: Well, Russell, I have always enjoyed interviewing you as well as listening to interviews with other interviewers because your background as a financial historian gives you just so much deeper and richer perspective on markets than most of the people that we, we hear in the press. And it's, it's just such a treat for me to have a chance to interview you. An even better treat might And I think it might be something that you are recently working to put together, which is a class called The Practical History of Financial Markets. And this is not just an hour-long talk at a retail investor conference. This is something that is designed for investment professionals and extremely sophisticated private investors. It's 2 solid days. Tell us, how did this come about? It's absolutely fascinating to me.
Russell Napier: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I'm very curious to possibly attend it myself. So, tell us more about it, how it came about, and what you intend to accomplish, and when and where it will be offered.
Russell Napier: Okay. Well, thank you for asking. I set the course up in 2004. I've taken it 4 times a year since 2004. So, I'm glad some of it's finally rubbing off. I'm a slow learner, but clearly I've picked up some of the lessons, and let's hope I continue to do so. The good news is we're bringing it across the Atlantic for the first time in a very long time. The course itself was put together in the early 2000s by asking fund managers with lots of experience what they knew today that they wished they'd known 40 years beforehand. And based upon the answers to that, we built this course. It's not a chronological history. It's not a developmental history about financial institutions. It's basically looking at why equity valuations mean revert, and they have mean reverted pretty consistently. I do understand that people think it's different this time, but there's some evidence already that they may be mean reverting.
We've got 7 teachers for this. It takes 2 days when we run it in North America, 2.5 days when we run it in Europe.
So we will be in Toronto on that incredible week, a week I'm sure you know very well. So on the Monday, Tuesday, we will be teaching in Toronto. On Wednesday, there's a famous value investing conference with the Ivey Business School. And on Thursday, there's an AGM for a famous value investor in Toronto called Prem Watsa. Fairfax Group. So we're trying to make that a bit of a learning jamboree for investors. And as I said, we don't come across the Atlantic very often, but we will, albeit north of the border. We also run in London on March 21st to 23rd. And for those of you who have a coat and thermal underwear, we will be in Edinburgh from the 21st to the 23rd of February.
Erik Townsend: Okay. And the dates again in Toronto? Toronto, sorry, 8th and 9th of April, 8th and 9th of April in Toronto, and there's another conference the following day if you want to get the, the jam-packed weekend. Russell, where can people find out about this and register if they're interested in attending on April 8th and 9th?
Russell Napier: Yeah, well, we have a website where you can get all those dates and a full teaching schedule to check whether this is something you're genuinely interested in and discover the price, of course, as well, at didaskoeducation.com So that is D-I-D-A-S-K-O, didaskoeducation.org. Or put my name, Russell Napier, and practical history course into any good search engine, and you'll find us quickly. My email address is there. Get in touch. It'll be great to see you.
Erik Townsend: Well, Russell, I can't thank you enough for another fantastic interview. We really look forward to having you back on the program again soon, and I hope to get the opportunity to see you in Toronto myself. So we're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. MacroVoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Russell. You know, the moment I found out about about that course, I said, well, listen, if he's coming to my backyard here in Toronto, I'm just gonna have to go. So I signed up. But one of the interesting things, when we did that MacroVoices Live out in Vancouver, one of my favorite parts was the reception, which is getting together with all of our listeners and having a beer. So I went and reached out to Russell and I convinced him to actually come out for a beer and for us to have a little MacroVoices meet and greet out in Toronto when he's out here teaching that course. So any of our MacroVoices listeners that going to register for that program, make sure you email me, patrick@macrovoices.com, and I'll let you know about the reception where Russell and I will go out for a pint.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think that's a fantastic call. And just to share with our listeners, when we did our first MacroVoices Live in Toronto, the restaurant meet and greet afterwards was an afterthought. We didn't plan it. Somebody suggested it. We thought, oh, okay, whatever. It turned out the feedback that we got is people valued the reception and the networking time, both to meet other listeners and get a sense of their background and talk to them about markets, and to have a chance to get some actual social time, face time, one-on-one with the speakers. People told us that was more valuable than the actual program, and that's the reason we did 2 full-length receptions at MacroVoices Live.
So we already heard from Russell how to get information to get registered on the course. When we taped the interview, Patrick had not yet made arrangements. So in addition to that, follow up with Patrick directly and find out what the story is on the meet and greet.
Patrick Ceresna: So Erik, I want to go back to the interview. What did you take away?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, first of all, as I said earlier, Russell just never ceases to amaze me. He's one of my favorite people in the industry, and he's very impressive. The thing that I thought was extremely interesting was his perspective that China may be the driver or almost the controller of tightening monetary policy and pushing inflation and so forth. And, you know, I think that unfortunately, call me an alarmist if you want to, but I think we're headed in this Fourth Turning into an era where everybody's gonna be pointing fingers at one another and governments around the world are going to be looking to excuse the situations that exist in their own countries, which frankly are usually of those governments' own own making. And they're going to look to excuse those situations by putting the blame on someone else and pointing fingers and saying, look, it's those foreigners. They're the ones that did it. It's all their fault. And I think we really have a difficult setup if you look at the tension that already exists, trade tension between the United States and China.
And there certainly is a part of the American demographic that is angry and feels that, you know, China's The problem. If we get to a situation where inflation really does become a problem and we're looking for a scapegoat, this potential for international scapegoating to lead to a further rise in geopolitical tension scares me.
It makes me worry that we're headed toward more global military conflicts. And something that a lot of people just don't What we have to understand is China is not Afghanistan. If we get into a shooting war with China, it's very likely that they could win. China has developed all kinds of missile technology designed specifically for sinking US aircraft carriers. This is not Scud missiles coming out of Iraq. So the potential— and this is something which I wish that I had had the presence of mind to ask Russell about during the interview— financial historians predict war between Japan and the United States something like 50 years before it ever happened.
Because what always happens throughout history is when there is one clearly established economic leader— not, not military leader, but economic leader— in the world, and another country is ascendant and begins to challenge that economic dominance, those 2 countries always go to a shooting war. And that's what happened with the economic ascendance of Japan before World War II. And there's a good argument to be made that there's a very serious risk of shooting war risk between China and the United States. And I think that some of these monetary trends are going to be the, the seeds that eventually lead to the excuses that government leaders use in order to justify military action. And I sure hope to be proven wrong about all of that. But on that cheery note, Patrick, what did you take away from this interview?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what? Russell, in my mind, nailed it. He just nailed it when it comes to the Treasury bond markets. So many people in my mind were looking at these massive budget deficits that were going to be run by the US government and said, because of this and because the world is not buying these Treasuries, that yields are about to skyrocket. And my view, and I got that from Russell as well, which is the government will not have any problems funding that deficit. The Treasury bond market is going to get fully funded. What is going to be a problem is draining the liquidity out of the system, and it's going to cause asset deflation because of that liquidity void that these massive deficits are running. And so to me, I see more deflationary pressures coming from that, not runaway yields. And I really got the sense that that's where he was going.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we're going to have to leave it there for this week. Folks, we need your help as usual, so please register your free account at MacroVoices.com if you haven't done so already. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just a compendium of links to all of the best free content we could find on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what they can expect in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to learn more about Russell Napier's course on a practical Practical History of the Financial Markets. There was a great interview with Robert Shiller out in Davos on bear market risks, and as well, a really interesting article from Jeffrey Snider on China's eurodollar stock reaching its final chapters. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Advice.
Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Charlie McElligott — Nomura (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 150 was recorded early this week on Tuesday, January 15th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Nomura's Charlie McElligott was the man who called the Christmas equity massacre before it happened, and he's become one of our favorite macro strategists on the program. Charlie will join me this week as our featured interview guest, and we'll be discussing the equity market recovery and how long Charlie thinks it will last, bond yields, gold, and much more. Now normally we tell you at this point what to expect from our postgame segment after the feature interview, and I've got a real treat for you this week. Charlie gave us such a fantastic interview that when we finally started to bump up against our time limit, I just threw the timer out the window. We let Charlie run long, over an hour, but I think you're really going to find this one In fact, it may be one of our best interviews yet.
So we'll have a very abbreviated postgame segment this week, and we'll be back to our regular format after we return from MacroVoices Live in Vancouver. And yes, there's still time to sign up to join us in Vancouver at MacroVoices.com/live.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's start with the S&P 500 because we continue to see the S&P hovering at this 2,600 level, continuing to push a little bit higher. What's your take on what's going on in the S&P 500?
Erik Townsend: Well, not a whole lot of change since last week, although the market has continued to do exactly what I thought it was going to do. Again, I am persuaded that the cyclical bear market has begun. We've seen the first significant wave down in that bear market, and now we're bouncing, and it's a heck of a bounce. We've now rallied about 50%, 300 S&P points off that low at 2,300. We're 2,610, so that's what, halfway back to, to 2,920 or so, which is pretty close to where the high So, you know, we're coming up on that 50% Fib retrace. Will we get to 50%? Will we get to 61.8%? I don't know, but the question on my mind is, I don't think there's that much left to go before we run out of steam on what I'm convinced is a bear market rally. And the question then is, how do we start to line the dominoes up for what's going to happen next?
I cannot think of a single person on earth that I would rather ask about this than Charlie McElligott. So let's stay tuned and see what he has to say in the future. Thank you, Patrick. All right.
Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to the US dollar because the dollar index traded temporarily below 95 and it kind of tapped down there a few times below, but never really broke below 95 and now has turned around and staged an impressive rally. Is the rout over? Are you bullish the dollar still?
Erik Townsend: You know, I think so, but I'm kind of leaving room. We're not out of the woods yet. We're getting so many conflicting messages— China trade, Fed tightening, dovish pivot, not dovish pivot. You know, it seems to just change every few minutes. I think that if I If I had to predict something, it would be more volatility and uncertainty, but I think it ultimately gets resolved higher. I won't be surprised though if we dip down to 94 before we go higher. If that happens, I'd look at it as a buying opportunity.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because we've been talking about, you know, how far this rally could go, and you shared with us that you didn't think it was going all the way back to 80. But, you know, we were talking about this overhead resistance near this 51, 52. What comes next here? Do you think oil still has a little more room to go?
Erik Townsend: Well, first of all, we don't have any inventory data because we're recording the show early this week and inventory comes out tomorrow as we're speaking on Tuesday afternoon. Saudi Arabia continues to jawbone the market and we've seen— looked like oil got a little bit of a boost today from President Trump talking about possible sanctions on Venezuela. I sincerely doubt that that will actually happen, but, you know, a little bit of rhetoric can spike the market a little bit. I still think that we are nearing the top of a consolidation range, and I wouldn't be surprised if we bounce around between $45 and $55, or maybe it's $42 and $52. I'm not sure. But, you know, low $40s to low $50s on WTI, a few dollars higher on Brent. I'm guessing that's where the consolidation range is going to be. I'll be very surprised if we move above $60 on WTI.
Below $40 is entirely possible, especially if we get a big inventory build and economic news in the same week. But right now my base case is kind of trading range here between low 40s and low 50s. And we're certainly at the high end of that range now. All right.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to gold because we saw a pretty impressive push in gold up towards the $1,300 level round number. And since then, that's clearly been at least an intermediate kind of— no, at least a short-term resistance level. What's your take? Is gold going to have the gusto to make this break?
Erik Townsend: I don't think so. But as I said last week, you know, my favorite case is gold tops out here and moves back lower as the dollar index eventually starts to recover. But as I also admitted last week, gold has been stronger than I expected in the last few weeks. We've seen it trading as more of a safety trade asset as opposed to an inverse dollar correlation trade, and it surprised me. So maybe I'll be surprised again. Certainly a daily close over $1,300 and then staying there for several days, that would really force me to reevaluate my view. But right now I'm leaning towards topping out here with this round number resistance at $1,300 And maybe rolling over and heading back to the downside. All right.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's get on to the 10-year Treasury yields, which are now hovering around this 2.70 level. What comes next here for— in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's really interesting to see whether we go below 2.60 again or above 2.80 first. Charlie clearly has been the man for making the tactical calls on this. So I'm going to save most of it for the feature interview with Charlie McElligott. But my view is not a lot of conviction here. I think that a move that's below Below 2.60 or above 2.80 and sustained above or below those levels would be a technical signal. Until we get that, I think the market is trying to digest a lot of conflicting news, and I wouldn't be surprised if we see some more volatility in the middle of that range where we are right now.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. So this week's featured interview guest is Nomura's Charlie McElligott. Now, Erik, we wanted to start having the conversation as to why we chose the guest and why we're bringing him on. So Erik, why Charlie?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, ever since Charlie joined Nomura and started publishing this daily institutional letter, which you and I both receive and which is available to our qualified institutional listeners, he's just really had a fantastic track record. He called this Christmas massacre before it happened. In a lot of these big equity moves, he was publishing that morning. He's saying, look, when we get to this level, that's going to tip our CTA model. Look for the selling to accelerate as soon as the S&P as this number. And those predictions were just spot on. They came true. It was really just phenomenal how accurate he has been. And really what's impressed me is every time I read his letter, it's just full of insight and it's thoughtful, and he just seems like one of the brightest minds in the industry right now. And I'm really glad that we're able to get him on the program. So needless to say, he called the move down Christmas.
He immediately called for a relief rally to begin. That was exactly right. to go long there on that Christmas bottom. And he was on the right side of that call. Let's see what he says in this interview about how much further this market has to run.
Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, I personally love having Charlie on the show because we have no shortage of people come on and give us a fundamental story, a macro fundamental driver of what's going to cause things. But bridging the macro fundamentals with the liquidity and using quantitative analysis to understand how money flows and moves between asset classes MacroVoices is so important and there's a lack of people doing it, or at least that we can bring onto the show. And this is why it's such a treat to have Charlie come on. So, I'm looking forward to it. Erik's interview with Charlie McElligott is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Charlie McElligott, the man who both called the Christmas massacre event and was very outspoken in telling people that his CTA model was expecting a dramatic increase in the pace of selling if certain levels were hit, which they were, and then right afterwards called for there to be a relief rally, which is exactly what's happened. So Charlie, congratulations. You are knocking it out of the park with the calls you've been making lately. I want to start with China, because that's what's on everybody's mind with the trade talks and so forth. Give us the update. And also, we do have a chart deck from you, listeners. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email or next to Charlie's picture on our homepage if you're not yet registered. Why don't we jump into your chart book and talk about China, what is driving the situation, and how China is going to play into market action as this whole trade talk thing gets resolved in the next several weeks or months?
Charlie McElligott: Sure, guys. So appreciate the opportunity to be on again and speak with you. I had a great time last time and expanded some of the folks that I interact with. So thank you for that. I think as we look to base this conversation out of the impulse that's originating out of China, and last time we spoke, we did touch on that idea of the Chinese credit impulse. That credit impulse, of course, with regards to the government's forcing, pushing on a string of credit out through social financing, through new loan growth, through efforts to stimulate money supply.
That has been the past is prologue playbook for Chinese responses to liquidity tightening and economic slowdown.
I think what the update is since maybe we last spoke with regards to the continued degradation of the Chinese economy, here has been twofold, frankly. You are dealing with a situation where policies have been very focused on preventing financial crisis and a credit freeze. Other policies, they are trying to support growth, but not enough to offset some of the negatives that are developing. It is both a domestic demand issue, and from the folks that we have boots-on-the-ground economic contact with there, I don't think a lot of folks in the West understand the incredible cynicism, skepticism, pessimism view from the ground within China. I think that also too, risk markets, global markets have been anticipating a more holistic boom-pow response from Chinese authorities, from the policy setters, from the PBOC, from the Ministry of Finance, that more than what the Chinese authorities are able to provide, Meaning there is no kind of short-term QE solution, rate cut solution that would give the market what it wants.
Instead, it's been these very piecemeal attempts, right? They've—I think we've had now four triple R cuts since last January. We've had a number of value-added tax cuts, some corporate income tax cuts. The fact of the matter is, and certainly mandating putting more pressure on local authorities and banks to you know stimulate that loan growth, that that credit impulse. They are now in a really tricky part of their process right now. I think generally speaking, it was consensus, folks understood that when you pile on the trade war and the impact that that is having, that the tariffs are having on Chinese trade, that you are in a situation where because of the tariffs implementation, there was this potential relief by pulling forward much of the ordering from clients of Chinese counterpart corporations.
And you did see that to a certain extent, very, very limited extent, in some of the now Q4 monthly data that's coming out. I think what's happened in the last couple of days is that you actually saw in the Chinese trade data yesterday, export growth was down 4.4% year over year, which is a negative read on industrial production, employment, on GDP. And then import growth was down 7.6% year over year, which also speaks to this further domestic demand slowdown, it's highlighting that we've already hit the end of that tariff frontloading effect.
So you're really now dealing in the market, and we're going to talk on this very tactical, very positioning-driven risk rally that I've been making the case for since mid-December. But I think now you're at that point in the market where there is There's a lot of discomfort in owning this rally because you're seeing this negative global growth impulse out of China really get picked up in the global data. Our view, our in-house view, Ting Lu, our Chinese economist, has been way more aggressively negative than the rest of the market and continues to be, is that it's only going to get worse in Q1 and Q2, especially now. that that tariff front-loading effect is gone. And I think we print the absolute lows in Q1 into Q2 2019, which then forces the— as I referenced earlier, that escalation of Chinese stimulus responses, of Chinese easing, that you can then begin to see some of the lagging impact of the fiscal stimulus, of the easing, to actually then start to see the global economic relief begin to register.
Erik Townsend: Now, I want to ask a qualifying question. And when you say that it gets worse into Q1, I'm assuming we're talking about the Chinese economic data getting worse. But I could imagine that translating to more accommodative policy and potentially US markets maybe rallying as the US Fed gets a little more accommodative because of what they're afraid of. So, are we necessarily expecting global markets to, to be worse, or you just mean the Chinese economic data gets worse in Q1?
Charlie McElligott: No, it's the right question to ask. It's a critical clarification. So, we're absolutely speaking with the Chinese economic data, which in turn is having this dragging effect globally, right? We saw the German GDP print yesterday confirm the slowdown fears. It's, of course, a known thing. Germany is the world's 3rd largest exporter, the largest economy in Europe. It's very much representative of the flu that has originated out of China. I think what this next wave is with regards to that Q1, Q2 behavior in China is that you're now going to see a situation where instead of this growth deterioration or growth deceleration, it's now going to become which has been due to this deleveraging campaign they began 2 years ago, so it's self-inflicted.
You're now going to see the credit crunch in H1. That's really where I think you're going to start seeing the narrowing impact and the smaller response that their economy is getting from these various piecemealed stimulus and easing efforts. They're smaller, they're more narrow, they're less effective than past policy stimulus.
Now, you're going to see the payback for the frontloading of exports. You're going to see probably now the property market corrections, certainly in the lower-tier cities, is our house view, and probably more defaults and widening of credit spreads in China. That ultimately, which you were highlighting specifically here, Erik, that is things getting worse to force that more aggressive, much more aggressive policy response from Chinese authorities That ultimately puts us back on track for a kind of a global economic pivot off of these, you know, H1 '19 lows is what we are anticipating.
Erik Townsend: Charlie, let's move on now to the bigger picture of where we are in the market. You've talked a lot about being late cycle, and you've described a lot of things just impeccably well. The way I assimilate all of this is it feels to me like the top is probably in. for this equity market and we're into a bear market. The first wave is over and we're into that first significant bear market rally. First question is, is that view consistent with your view? And of course, the much bigger question is, if it is, how much further does that bear market rally have to go before it's done? When do you start to, to look at changing direction? And I— something I've noticed that you are exceptionally good at is lining up the dominoes of what are the events that need to happen in order for the market to get to a certain resolution. So, how do you see this whole thing unfolding?
And how am I doing in terms of the view that I've assimilated from some of the things you've said in the past?
Charlie McElligott: You know, when I was on the last time, I was really speaking to my 2-speed year thesis for 2018 and specifically highlighting that we had transitioned into this new macro regime from quantitative easing to quantitative tightening. And the impact that QT was going to have on financial conditions tightening from there. Financial conditions tightening bleeds into the real economy, the behavior that we began to see and were highlighting on our last visit, specifically within the housing sector, the automobile sector, regional banks, supercyclicals like semiconductors, chemicals, all of that price action that truly went remarkably recessionary, If you look at the Q4, certainly the December price action, markets, and this time, may I add, it was equity markets, not fixed income, that priced in this growth scare and priced in ahead of other markets. Oftentimes, people take knocks on equities for being more the confirming agent instead of the leader. Equities were way ahead on this overall downshift message.
And my whole message has been, that we are pushing into the end of the cycle and we've tightened ourselves into a slowdown.
That tightening ourselves into a slowdown was the key delta as far as the market behavior in Q4 as well. There was a period in Q3, let's say September, where we made again new local highs and S&P highs. People thought we had escaped the equity volatility regime shift that was experienced after the vol event in February of last year. But that wasn't the case. And part of that thesis where I had a big October financial conditions tightening tantrum call was that October was going to see a significant month of balance sheet inflection. And balance sheet inflection meaning 2 very large Fed SOMA runoffs, right? So the SOMA account, the securities account at the Fed, where there was going to be maturation of large notional US Treasuries, And maturation of large notional mortgage-backed securities. And George Goncalves, our rate strategist, was almost 7 months ahead of anybody else in the street when we worked with him on this, as far as highlighting last July the quantitative fact that is large balance sheet runoffs within the Fed, particularly in mortgage-backed securities, see a corresponding move lower in risk assets, in particular S&P.
With that in mind, the fact that we had these 2 massive runoff days, let us say, because we have to group— we have grouped these on a weekly basis in October with the Fed's balance sheet corresponded with the ECB's own tapering from $30 billion of purchases down to $15 billion of purchases, as well as at the same time, the Bank of Japan was conducting stealth tapering of their own bond buying operations. You ended up having this very volatile October trade momentum on unwinds across the equities, long-short, market-neutral space caused huge performance decay.
What we did, and I digress going back to the original point, was that we transitioned from that very September idea that we were growing faster than we were tightening to this glass-half-empty view that we had tightened ourselves into a slowdown.
That match was lit by Jerome Powell on October 3rd with his now infamous misstatement with regards to the far from neutral commentary, which implied to the market that the Fed was setting us on a course for Fed policy error, and that we were indeed going to tighten until something broke.
What has since transpired, of course, is a reversal. And that's the way that markets work in this day and age. The reaction function, unfortunately for the Fed, is the market tail wagging the dog. So instead of Fed policy dictating asset behavior, markets now dictate Fed policy behavior.
So as we in December kind of hit the peak panic button, and a lot of that was due to year-end timing, a lot of that was due to multi-year highs in gross notional exposure within the leveraged hedge fund community needing to be unwound over the course of 2018, you saw such terrible performance you saw such leverage removal precipitously in Q4 that we just got that final purge of positioning. It was really just a value at risk, a VaR, a risk management event, that final impulse. When markets got that bad, however, it forced the policymakers, specifically within the Fed, as well as this also happening within China at the same time, it forced them to take more action.
Those are 2 critical sequences that needed to shift us into this current stance, which is this much more sympathetic, much more constructive qualitative macro backdrop. The third was that knowing that there was going to be these ongoing US-China trade negotiation talks in a 90-day window, which actually wasn't 90 days, it was actually after the G20, it was actually more like 60 days plus a week, that actually made us realize that there was going to be increased likelihood of positive leakage because both Presidents Trump and Xi needed market relief for their own purposes. And that has allowed this very slashed positioning, slashed exposure, max short CTA behavior as certainly the long equities trade lost momentum and pivoted max short. We've seen an environment where with risk risk parity funds. Our internal models have shown them positioning for a slow growth, slow inflation backdrop, which is adding massive fixed income, adding to their gold positions, cutting equities, cutting credit, cutting commodities like risk commodities as well.
And you've effectively had this backdrop where people have purged their risk exposure right into the policy inflection. And that's more or less, without getting into the systematic flows, that's more or less what set the table for where we are now at this current risk rally.
Erik Townsend: Now, let me make sure I'm not missing something, because what I'm hearing is you've got the Fed threatening at one point last fall to tighten, tighten, tighten until something breaks, and people are panicking. And you've got these big Fed balance sheet roll-offs that are equivalent to a hike in many respects. And a lot of people have proven the numbers behind that.
Now what we seem to have is the Fed has blinked and it's saying, okay, the market is no longer pricing lots of hikes in 2019. We're down to either no hikes or even some people are talking about cuts.
Everybody's breathing this huge sigh of relief. Okay, it's better now. Wait a minute. The Fed still has a whole bunch of balance sheet roll-offs in 2019. And Powell's been pretty darn adamant saying that they're sticking with that. So am I missing something, or are there really effectively stealth hikes in the form of balance sheet roll-offs that maybe the market hasn't fully priced in yet?
Charlie McElligott: QT is unequivocally a financial conditions tightener. It saps dollar liquidity, and dollar liquidity is the reason that we've had shrinking, contracting dollar liquidity is the reason that we've had rolling volatility events for the last year plus. So yes, unequivocally, the balance sheet tightening, the balance sheet runoff is an ongoing negative risk asset impulse. It's an ongoing financial conditions tightener. What the Fed did from a very forward guidance central bank speak perspective, think about Mario Draghi and whatever it takes, that commentary single-handedly turned for a multi-year period, the European crisis on its head. without spending one penny of euros on their emergency bond buying program.
In this sense, what the Fed did was that the Fed hasn't just capitulated with this now code speak for patience, which is equivalent to the Fed pause thesis, which I think last summer when I was bringing up the concept of a Fed pause, 90% of the fixed income world was laughing at me saying, no way, this thing is preset autopilot, lights out.
And my point was that the markets wouldn't allow it to get to that point, because the impact is too massive. The perceived impact is too massive. What they also did too was open up the possibility of decreasing or outright cessation of the balance sheet unwind over the last week and a half since this most recent Fed meeting. And what that has done has thrown a lifeline to folks that are concerned about this. That said, You've got it exactly right. In the meantime, it's still going on at the same clip. And that is part of my longer-term structural thesis, why if you are an investor, if you're an owner, and you're looking at this end-of-cycle trade— and remember, the catalyst for a US slowdown, or at a minimum, or a recession, whether it's late 2019 if you're on the bearish side, or a 2020 story, which I think would put you in the consensus—
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Charlie McElligott: These are very much tangible and frankly accelerating.
So you have a still ongoing and lagging negative impact of Fed tightening. So real yields, yes, have come off significantly, but they remain at multi-year highs while inflation breakevens and inflation expectations and breakevens have dropped to multi-year lows. You have the fading US fiscal stimulus. The tax cut impact continues to diminish and half-life.
You have the dragging wealth effect of what happened last year with all assets in investor portfolios and people's retirement accounts and things that make them feel like they have paper wealth. I mean, at the end of the day, we have to acknowledge what a large part of quantitative easing was, and that was to create a wealth effect. That was to create a sense of wealth that will help stimulate discretionary spending. And that just took a wallop to the face.
And then I think the final reality, which is incredibly cyclical, of course, is the corporate deleveraging, which inherently means lower CAPEX. I referenced a bunch of times, I think it came out late November, potentially early December, but either way, the Fuqua School, the business school down at Duke, releases a corporate CFO survey on expectations, on business environment expectations. And particularly, they ask a number of questions with regards to recession timing, CapEx spending environment, things like that. And nearly 50%, I believe it was 48% off the top of my head, saw recession hitting in calendar 2019.
By 2020, that number went up to north of 90%. So the point being that these are the people that are making— these are the C-suite of corporate America, Fortune 500, S&P 500-type companies, that have this late days, late cycle view, what are you going to do with your cash? Are you going to go out and create organic growth, or are you going to batten down the hatches? Are you going to hike compensation, or are you going to sit tight on your cash stockpile and buy back shares?
That speaks very pessimistically, and that's a way that you can get a tracking A current tracking, say, 2.7% GDP, 0.5% here and a 0.3% there and a 1% here, all of a sudden you could get to a recession, a negative GDP growth type of a number in the coming quarters.
So that is very real. And I think that the market was pricing that type of environment in, pulling forward, understandably. Everybody sees the strength of the consumer. Everybody sees the strength in labor markets as per the most recent nonfarm payroll, of course, with a very strong average hourly earnings print. But I think at the end of the day, equities markets know that the data is lagging and that the markets are real-time. And that's why the Fed didn't just back away and transition to a coordinated pause message, which again was reiterated today from multiple Fed speakers, taking a couple quarters off. My view June is the earliest they would possibly look at a Fed hike again. And frankly, the rates market continues to call that bluff, pricing in the end of the Fed cycle still to this point and almost a full cut again in 2020.
That's what forced the Fed to not just go with the pause story, but I think also too, the break glass scenario, which would be them decreasing or even outright stopping the balance sheet unwind. In the meantime, it's continuing until markets get sloppy again.
Erik Townsend: Let's bring the dollar into this discussion about the Fed balance sheet roll-off, because I think most people are kind of hugging the view that, okay, look, there's been a big run-up in the dollar, but that was to be expected. The Fed was hiking, and of course, it's all about interest rate differentials. That's what drives everything. Now that the Fed is pausing, then the dollar's got to go the other direction. But from what you're saying, really, the balance sheet roll-offs are dollar liquidity exacerbators. So are balance sheet roll-offs just as dollar bullish as rate hikes are?
Charlie McElligott: I think in the scheme of things, at a minimum, equally important. And if you're talking about— I think the idea is this, people understand after the crisis or into that crisis period and thereafter, how much dollar-denominated debt around the world exploded, multiple trillions sense in the post-crisis environment. Between that mix of rate hikes, between that mix of quantitative tightening, which is pulling dollars out of the system, and then you add in a third point, so not just the hikes and the quantitative tightening, but the massive uptick 2 years in a row of year-over-year doubling of expectations for Treasury issuance to deficit fund you're just hoovering dollars that used to be there for anything in the world, whether it was risky assets, whether it was for emerging markets credits, whether it was for industrial metals.
These were all excesses of the QE regime that are now being reversed. And look, I think part of this, and this is not something that I can quantify or point to, but I think part of the Fed's desire to talk dovishly with regards to willingness to touch, to modify, or to even halt QT, while in the background continuing on with it— and I said it's their break-glass option— is that they know that in the case of the inevitable next recession or next crisis, that it is a very, very high likelihood that they're going to have to add to the balance sheet again.
I'm telling you right now, whether it's conversations with massive institutional investors or macro traders on a desk, they will all tell you to their face that if we do hit that panic button and we do hit the slowdown into recession, Fed cuts alone don't mean squat to markets. You don't care about a 25 bps cut when we've still barely gotten off the zero bound.
What matters are the purchases of assets, are the purchases of Treasuries, are the perpetual flattening of curves to ease financial conditions, are the purchases of mortgage-backed securities to help clear, which is a legacy construct of the prior crisis, but to help with that massively economic multiplier amplifier that is the housing industry in our country.
Ultimately, I think in the next crisis, we turn to look like the BOJ, and Janet Yellen has already outlined this years ago, that we could, in fact, be buying ETFs. I think that is just an inevitability of where we are going, and that is a point for the future, but it is clear to me that part of the reason they are so committed to maintaining this balance sheet runoff, say, over the next year to year and a half, is because they know they need to create room before they start adding again.
Erik Townsend: Charlie, I want to move on to your CTA model, which has become extremely popular with our listeners. But before we even get into the slides that you have starting on page 9 of the deck, I wonder if you could just explain the big picture of how this model works, what it predicts, and why the numbers that you use for thresholds are kind of moving targets. We had you on Last time you mentioned gold really had a magic number around $1,245, which it was on the day that we spoke. 3 or 4 weeks later, we had people on Twitter saying, hey, we hit the number. Charlie said the magic number is $1,245. What's going to happen next? And of course, at that point, your number in your daily note was up to $1,298 or something. Why is it a moving target? And what do we actually learn from this CTA model?
How does it work?
Charlie McElligott: Sure. So there's a number of proprietary signals of momentum that are everything from traditional classic technical measures, as well as because of the vol component to any sort of trend strategy, any sort of strategy that is levering onto lower realized volatility assets, levering more there's a negative convexity.
Because of that, realized volatility are critical to sizing and scaling the long or the short position, meaning the size of the overall position within this large portfolio of 58 cross-asset futures contracts that our model replicates. What's important to note, and to your point, We, our QIS team creates these. We have these outputs. And what is important to note here is a number of things.
CTAs in general, trend models in general, are shorter-term in nature. And certainly, CTAs got a ton of press last year because they got lit on fire, in all honesty. And that's the purest representation that last year was the anti-trend. You had this huge macro regime shift. You had rolling volatility events. You had the unwind of systemic leverage accumulated over the 10-year post-crisis period in quantitative easing, and that forced a lot of positioning overshoots, positioning asymmetries, leverage blowouts, VAR events, that you had this incredible chop, intraday, across the days, different vibes from one day to another, from one week to another, month over month, quarter over quarter, complete reversals.
So that's why CTA models did so poorly last year. The fact of the matter remains that these are short-term in nature, and especially in a market where fundamentals tend to get pitched and people are trying to get their legs on what is the new macro regime and what is the policy backdrop, where is growth going with these rapid deceleration in global data, these types of strategies become that much more important. Important in becoming the price setters, because one, there still is a massive amount of assets in them, and it is one of the most heavily leveraged strategies on top of that.
With that same confusion that I spoke to with regards to the fundamental backdrop and where we are in the cycle and all these questions on policy and all these geopolitical issues that are still floating out notwithstanding as well, you are in a situation where the fundamental discretionary active folks of the world, are an even smaller part of the overall liquidity profile.
The impact of these systematic strategies, whether it's a CTA trend model, or whether it's risk parity, or whether it's a target volatility variable annuity fund, all of these different strategies have an outsized impact because the liquidity deteriorates due to this tightening liquidity environment, the reduction of leverage in the environment, they're having an outsized impact. That's why the CTA model, I think, got so much received so much notoriety and attention last year, and it is a really good model. This thing backtests to the index on a 3-year lookback within 50 bps of the actual index. This thing has been engineered brilliantly by our QIS team.
With that said, you are dealing with a 2-week window. You are dealing with a 1-month window, a 3-month window, a 6-month window, and a 12-month window. And especially looking at the 2018 landscape, which was, say, within equities, for instance, up 2% one day, down 1.5% the next day, down 2% the next day, and up 2.5% the next day after that, it's very important to understand which days are rolling into and rolling out of these various lookback windows across the different tenor models.
So for instance, we might touch on this later in the call, But day over day in our S&P model, for instance, in our S&P 500 model, which per my call back in early December that we were going to see this major sell impulse when our models went almost consensually max short positioning across global equities futures, we've been sitting near this threshold to actually cover some of that short over the course of the rally over the last 2 weeks. Weeks, and which was a large part of my base case for this tactical rally call that I started making in December. And to capture this point with regards to the movement of the trigger levels, yesterday was still 100% max short in the S&P, and the trigger level to cover down to just 82% short, so reduce roughly 20% of the scale of the outstanding notional short in S&P, was sitting at 2,595 in S&P futures. So close above that level, we would have triggered the cover You know, it would
have been somewhere around $9.2 billion to cover. We closed right below that.
But then coming in today and rerunning the model, what happened was that you lost a particularly volatile day in the 1-month window. So basically December 14th rolled out of sample. What that December 14th day rolling out of sample did to our trigger level was it dropped the S&P covering level down a full 50 handles to 2545. And that speaks to the movement.
These are not static data points held constant in time. This is a daily reset based on the trailing realized volatility plus the price behavior. And with that drop, we were preordained basically today ex the absence of a major risk sell-off or some sort of a tape bomb, and a noisy Brexit vote, which people have just completely tuned out, was not going to be that catalyst. We closed the day— currently I see futures at 2,606— nearly 60 handles above that deleveraging level. And in fact, our S&P model estimates that there was $9.2 billion of S&P covering to reduce that short. So that speaks to how these things are organic, how they're evolving, how they're constantly moving. And it's based off of the past performance windows across the 2-week, 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month, as well as not just the price behavior, but the volatility, the realized volatility profile therein. Because again, these strategies need a trend.
They will load more size, load more leverage onto something that is trending and creating positive P&L. Which are why you get these brutal, unemotional reversals too. That's the beauty of these strategies. They'll go from a max short, cover it to a long, and flip max long before you can blink. And that's why they are first movers, and that's why they're so important right now as far as giving me those incremental short-term directional leans that we've used to make a bunch of good calls in the last year.
Erik Townsend: Tell us a little bit more about the timing of these signals, because when you first described it to me on your last interview, I thought that what you were saying was this is effectively if you see a daily close past this number, that's going to cause the algorithmic trading systems the next day to start doing their buying or their selling. But there have been a couple of occasions where in your daily note you said, okay folks, if we get to X level during the day and it goes past that, it's going to accelerate, watch out. And you were just uncanny accurate with those calls. So clearly this does have an intraday action reflex function. How does that work? Who's making these decisions?
Charlie McElligott: That's a great point. There are 2 things there. We make assumptions as to how our strategy is set up to act, and that is off of a closing level. We are making assumptions based on the entirety of a universe that very well may trade intraday, let alone have different signals and different levels different inputs create different outputs.
For sure, there are certain strategies that I am sure hit a threshold, and boom, they are going long, boom, they are covering, boom, they are pressing their shorts. I think the other component, though, that really captures what you are speaking to is the self-fulfilling nature of what these models have become. That absence of a real fundamental view, especially which is a chicken or the egg impact of the performance environment, sees discretionary managers, active traders, fundamental folks increasingly at the mercy of these levels.
I am absolutely 100% certain that folks then build these levels into their psychology and into their framework.
Not only are there folks that will try to front-run these levels for day trades, I know that for a fact, I talk with people that do it, and they feel like it helps their cause. just quick in and out of trades. But it also too, these things tend to self-fulfill where clearly over the course of the last 2 weeks, my identification that this max short positioning was now established and now was a likely catalyst for a squeeze, especially once you got that Fed reversal towards easing of policy and then talking about willingness to touch the balance sheet.
The escalation of China policy easing and capitulation there, and then this resolution progress, positive leak stuff out of China trade negotiations, all of that has created the backdrop by which you've had this very much grabby behavior from people that frankly don't have, certainly within the equities complex, for instance, don't have the exposure on. Their beta to the S&P is low. They've taken their grosses down. They've taken their nets down. They're high in cash.
They have taken their portfolio beta down and are very defensive in posture, and they are missing this rally. Now, people know that these numbers are out there, they get itchy trigger fingers, and they think that the systematic strategies are going to be buying ahead of them, they buy ahead of the systematic strategies. There is this feedback loop impact as well, Erik, and I think that is— well, I know, frankly, that that is also part of the calculation.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Charlie, with that backdrop in place, let's go ahead and dive in at page 9 in your deck to the CTA model positioning estimates that you're showing now. What is this graph showing us, and why don't you walk us through the next couple of charts in the deck here?
Charlie McElligott: Sure. So, I, you know, I think really what I wanted to grab there was not simply just regards to kind of this, you know, this capture of kind of general risk sentiment, But also, 2, capture this idea that the trend has been very much about a slowdown posture. And of course, a CTA model is not worrying about a macro output per se. There might be macro overlays unequivocally. There could be humans that are tilting the behavior to some extent with regards to exposures, but generally speaking, that's against the point of the quantitative strategy.
What this is capturing, though, against the backdrop of some other things that I'll bring up, is that you've really seen markets, whether it's these systematic trend models, or later risk parity or discretionary equity long-short, pivot into a very risk-off stance, which is part of, a huge part of the reason that we find ourselves now 270 handles in the S&P off the lows made 2 weeks ago. What you are seeing particularly here, that top bucket, you see major markets, it just goes through some of the primary risk asset and key cross-asset securities that can give you a sense for this much more risk-off positioning. You see the max short in S&P 500 and Euro Stoxx and Nikkei, the 2 G10 FX crosses there, euro-dollar, Euro-US Dollar, and US dollar yen, obviously the dollar yen short, I think both of those expressions are very risk-off there.
Short dollar yen and short euro speak to that similar footing in the FX space. Then that middle bucket is looking at rates, so Treasuries, 10-year Treasuries, and you have a max long. Then you look at crude, Brent and WTI as global growth consumption, the global economic engine are also max short. Then And then you look at gold, and this is, I believe, 2 days old, this snapshot, but gold at basically 50% long position. You look back to the far right column versus a month ago, that was an incremental short. And you see, again, looking in that month prior, that far right column, 1 month in parentheses, you see the, generally speaking, the escalation of this kind of risk-off positioning over the last month. That next bucket down goes just a little bit more granularity across the global equities bucket. And you see the extent again of the short positioning. A lot of max shorts, negative 100s in that today snapshot. However, again, as I highlighted, this was a snapshot, I believe, from Monday morning.
You do see that Russell 2000 had begun covering. You see that FTSE 100, Hang Seng, ASX, and KOSPI had all covered from that max short position. Which was a precursor that told us that we were getting the ball rolling, that this max short bearish positioning had overshot.
And then the right side of the screen speaks to the fixed income side of the risk-off positioning, where you recall, and for almost the entirety of 2018, one of the most crowded trades on the board for sure was bearish fixed income, was bearish Treasuries, bearish rates. It was based upon above-trend growth, above-trend inflation, the tailwinds of fiscal stimulus, of the Phillips Curve, of labor impacting wage inflation, all of these very globally cyclical bullish phenomenon, plus the reality of Fed Treasury issuance, where supply— there was going to be this supply shock due to the deficit spend realities that we touched on earlier. That it was just going to really lean on global fixed income.
By the end of the year, and this is always part of my thesis, and it goes back to that Chinese credit impulse slide, is that once you lose that credit impulse in commodities and inflation expectations and industrial metals and cyclicals versus defensives ratios, those all start coming off because you're unable to create the demand side into this tightening liquidity backdrop via Fed's QT, via China's deleveraging efforts, via later the ECB slowing their bond purchases, and even the BOJ tapering their bond assets, what it ended up doing was create this very real slowdown in the back half of 2018 that got picked up in the very cyclical data, the very cyclical US data, as well as global manufacturing data. I think you have The JP Morgan Global Manufacturing PMI Index is down 9 of the last 10 months.
Those types of things forced people into this much more defensive slowdown posture, which was the opposite of the bearish rates, bearish Treasuries trade. It was instead max long Treasuries, max long European government bonds, max long JGBs, and onward from there. That's slide 9 for you.
What I touch on in slide Slides 10 and 11 is something that I just mentioned earlier too, which is that risk parity, which is a systematic long-only strategy, to be fair, but it's obviously become quite a talking point over the last 5 years. And it's critical, right? It's with regards to the assets deployed under the various iterations of the strategy around the streets. The leverage deployed in many versions of the strategy.
And the strategy is this. There is a— instead of allocating assets, what you're allocating is your volatility of your portfolio. So in a 60/40, the old line of thinking in the Bridgewater marketing pitch is in a 60/40 equities bond allocation, 90% of your volatility is in the equities, but And what you should be doing instead is allocating your volatility. So to grossly oversimplify, because oftentimes there is a macro overlay that I will touch on, but to grossly oversimplify, you lever up the historically low volatility asset class. And that historically low volatility asset class is, of course, fixed income.
Now, this is something I wrote about back in 2013. Before the taper tantrum is saying, well, wait a second. What if the historically low volatility asset class, Treasuries or global fixed income, is a product of a 30-year bond bull market? And what if you actually have a rogue inflation print? Or what if the market, who was already at that time hooked on quantitative easing and hooked on bond purchases by central banks, picked up wind that the central banks were going to stop buying bonds? Bonds, i.e., the taper tantrum, and boom, pow, you had those massive risk parity unwinds that due to, again, the assets under management, due to the leverage of the strategy, you had these huge cross-asset volatility blasts as these positions had to be deleveraged.
Well, fast forward to slide 10, and what you see is actually a very, from a macro perspective, a very slowdown risk-off type of positioning here. And that is what a number of risk parity strategies will actually look at. They'll look at kind of a— if you look at a Punnett square of like 4 scenarios with higher growth, higher inflation in one, higher growth, lower inflation in one, and the permutations therein all the way around, what this current positioning estimate as per our in-house model shows is that you've sharply reduced the US equities exposure. You're now just beginning to reduce the credit exposure. So on a 1-month basis, the largest single contract in our risk parity model sold is US investment-grade credit index. And then also too, on page 11, you see the commodities, particularly the energy commodities, and the largest part being being oil crude coming off sharply as well, near 5-year type lows, all against a huge buildup of length of leverage, again, in traditional fixed income product.
Particularly over the last month, we've seen that. We've seen large buying in US Treasuries, but enormous buying in JGBs. And JGBs, understandably, in light of 25 years of QE from the BOJ, are pretty much the lowest volatility asset class out there in the global spectrum. The idea being, they are very much aligned with my end-of-cycle view with regards to this downshift into a slow growth, slow inflation, low inflation environment. Those are the key points that I wanted to bring up on pages 10 and 11.
Erik Townsend: Charlie, I want to skip ahead in the interest of time to page 20 in the deck, because I want to revisit a topic we discussed in your last interview, which is where so many people fear an inversion or a flattening of the yield curve. You say we should actually fear the steepening of the curve. What do you mean by that? Why?
It seems counterintuitive to a lot of people. What do you mean by it? And maybe talk us through the charts to explain your point.
Charlie McElligott: My longtime message has been that the key here with regards to the hyperventilation on curve inversions, the inversion obviously precipitates the steepening of the curve, but what really matters is that the curve steepening side of where we are in the cycle indicator is telling us I have used the term in a number of my pieces, and maybe even on our last call, is that the market has finally sniffed out the slowdown. We have figured out that policy tightening, that normalization have impacted the real economy, that the lagging impact of tightening is starting to bleed into financing and funding, the cost of capital. And it's causing behavioral shifts with corporate management, CAPEX discussion that we had before, and then ultimately, it's affecting the actual output in the real economy.
So when I say that what matters most is actually the steepening as the cyclical risk-off signal, that's exactly what we've seen over the last number of US recessions. Is that you don't need to worry about trying to reverse engineer the timing of the inversion into when does the US recession start, just because there is no historical signal there. It's incredibly noisy. What does signal, because it's closer to the real event happening, is that when you get the steepening, that's the market picking up the slowdown and confirming the slowdown. So the slides on 20 show you the extent of the front end.
So we're looking at Eurodollar spreads. And this shows you the extent by which the markets went pricing out the end of the Fed normalization cycle and pricing in the easing cycle. And at the peak of early January, before the Fed's pivot, basically, before the Jerome Powell and Richard Clarida double whammy messaging that the markets had forced them to take a knee We were at a point where we had priced in almost a full cut in the end of 2019. Earlier, I spoke about, and there was times since July of last year that the Eurodollar 2020 calendar spread was telling us that the Fed was on the margin looking to cut. That clearly escalated to a full cut over the course of the last couple of months. What was so amazing in that real panicky December and then pre-Powell period in January was that we pulled forward that Fed easing, that Fed cut from 2020 into end of 2019.
And that just captures the accuracy, frankly, by which the equities markets began pricing in this real recession risk. And that, you know, we spoke about in those deeply cyclical sectors. So we have since moderated, right? The dovish Fed pivot It has done enough right now to offset the policy error concerns. They're telling us they're going to be patient, meaning there's no pause probably for the next 2— well, let's say this.
There's probably going to be a pause through at a minimum June. That's why you've seen a modest steepening again in these curves, in these Eurodollar short-term curves. What I think is pretty important though here is that on that next page, just to get a little perspective, on page 21, of the more traditional US Treasury curves and just get a grasp of where we have come on a larger lookback since, say, 2009 over the post-crisis period.
You are looking at 5s-30s, you are looking at 2s-10s, you are looking at 2s-30s, and you get a sense for the incredible flattening that has occurred, which has been by design. That has been by design because it eases financial conditions. It eases financing costs for corporates. to do things that could stimulate growth. That's what the Fed has been doing with their balance sheet purchases, with their reinvestment plans. That's what they have been trying to create. Now, the market is seeing the impact of the reversal of these policies, and we are just now beginning this very nascent steepening.
So that top panel there on page 21, that's the 5s-30s curve. In July of last year, the 5s-30s curve traded down 19 basis points. And that's when people were, amongst many of these other curves that had hit local lows at that time, decade lows, people were really hyperventilating, getting very scared about the implications for what that's telling us with regards to the recession. And since then, since July, 5s-30s has nearly tripled. There's another powerful steepening move today.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Charlie McElligott: I think 5/30s closed at 54 bps. So it's chopped around a little bit. But what that's telling us is, again, this: the market has priced out further hikes in the front end and not just moved to a pause stance, but moved to a view where within the next 12 months, we are anticipating the beginning of the Fed easing cycle.
And that is hyper, hyper, hyper critical because the shape of the yield curve impacts so many things across the asset spectrum. In particular, I've always focused on the impacts that this has within the equities space, things like cyclicals versus defensives, and certainly a real talking point that I'm going to be focusing on, I focused on my note today and in the months ahead, huge impact with regards to this value versus growth debate within the US equities space.
But yes, the concern and the trigger and the more near-term tactical signal is the steepening of the curve, because that's telling us that the slowdown is here, the slowdown is real, and that typically at that point, even though the Fed can have some impact with regards to liquidity provision, as far as softening the impact on the depth of the recession, a slowdown The steepening down is an inevitability. And that's where we need to watch because in prior examples, and that's what I go over in slides 22 and 23, kind of a year before the ultimate risk-off events, you begin seeing the curve steepening begin.
And sometimes it's less than a year. That's also important to note.
Erik Townsend: And I think it's a really critical point because there's a lot of people, I've seen this just reading around on the internet, people saying, boy, You know, that curve inversion was really scaring us, but, well, we got some relief. It looks like it was a false alarm. It's all getting better now. You're saying it's not getting better. We're getting to the point where the Fed is recognizing, or the market is recognizing, that the Fed will need to recognize the need to take action because the shit's about to hit the fan. Am I correct to interpret it that way?
Charlie McElligott: Absolutely. And look, I'll say it. There is still, and I referenced this earlier, the strength of the consumer, the strength of the labor section of the economy is no doubt maintaining and offsetting what's going on in housing, what's going on in manufacturing. But there are, especially once you look at the disinflationary impulse that we're seeing globally right now, there's a lot of worrying signals. And this is This is something that I think is very interesting from a timing perspective that I've called my confirmation of imminent Fed easing signal has been, and back to the Eurodollar curve, the Eurodollar 2s-6s spread. That's the 2nd Eurodollar contract spread to the 6th contract.
This spread is now inverted. It went almost negative 25 bps, I would say, in the last couple of weeks.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Charlie McElligott: It's currently negative 14 basis points. So with the Eurodollar curve, you're dealing with the very, very front end of the curve, not looking out in the tenor, the year tenors of Treasury curves.
And what this shows is something very interesting. So we've done some work here that shows over the past 5 easing cycles, the Eurodollar 2/6 spread has inverted prior to each.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Charlie McElligott: So this thing's got a 5-for-5 track record over the last 5. And it's inverted about 6.5 months on average before the first Fed cut.
So if I look at this in a different way and broaden out the sample size to look back at the last 9 Eurodollar 2/6 inversions and not including this current inversion, because that would be number 10, but the past 9 that we've had the post-trade period, a Fed easing cycle has followed in 7. And the average length has come— that easing cycle began 8.2 months after the inversion.
So to me, this continues to corroborate that we are slowing, and that that slowing for reasons that I, you know, brought up before— the lagging impact of Fed tightening, the ongoing QT, the fading fiscal stimulus, the dragging wealth effect on consumers due to the recent market shocks, and then the cyclical reality of corporate deleveraging, which inherently means lower CAPEX, which means from an economic amplification perspective, you're going to continue to see that contraction and shrinkage, and capital is going to be used for non-growthy things like buybacks. That's how we get that slowdown impulse.
And I think we're getting there, and the Fed is trying to ease the things that they can ease, and that's the market volatility, and that's the tightening of credit spreads, but that ultimately, the slowing is what bleeds through, and the end of the cycle overrides all.
Erik Townsend: So as we assimilate all of these signals that we've talked about today, let's come back to the original question, which Which is, as we look at the S&P, it's very clear that we're in some kind of relief rally. I think it's a bear market rally that's not going to take us to new all-time highs. How do you interpret these various different signals to tell you when it is time to actually be short and to look for this market to turn back down in the other direction?
Charlie McElligott: You know, as mentioned, in mid-December, after I saw this complete overshoot and purging of exposure and max short positioning and trend and capitulation into Fed easing, Fed cut being pulled into a 2019 event coming from a very different place, a diametrically opposite place just 3 months prior. It created this opportunity for this tactical rally, and we've gone over those catalysts. And that is what we're seeing now. People are being forced back into the market as the systematic, unemotional, first mover quantitative strategy reduce their short exposure and cover.
And obviously, we're going to keep getting this Fed dovishness, which eases the financial conditions tightening. It helps VIX settle back in and helps credit spreads normalize. It certainly helped crude bounce. Crude is critical because of its impact on inflation expectations, and inflation expectations are the most significant macro factor for everything from US equities to US rates You're seeing the same thing with Chinese policy capitulation.
All those pieces are in place. I think to me, the way that I'm envisioning this now is that yes, we are beginning to reduce some of that underexposure driver of this tactical rally I've been calling for. The key here is this, and I've compared it to— we ran an analog on the desk that is is just shockingly accurate thus far.
And we are now— we just completed the 15th day of this analog. But the analog is looking at scenarios where the S&P sold off greater than 17.5% as a trigger in 67 days or fewer. The overall idea being prior scenarios where you had this just massive violent de-risking in a very short period of time.
The highest correlation, the highest R-squared of this current trajectory versus one of those prior trigger dates in our sample set is actually October 2007 through October 2008. The analog is tracking to just a shocking degree of accuracy thus far. Then those slides are not in this deck in particular, but I am using that in my background As kind of a triangulation point against what I see as this slow forcing of positioning. So to really oversimplify the way that the analog is projecting where we go from here, we're 15 days in.
We are almost identical with regards to this current positioning analog on where the performance should be on this rally. We, per the analog, peak out on Friday of this week. And from there, you would see then over the following almost 2-week period, a 5% decline.
And I think that's important because it actually does fit a lot of the qualitative discussions that I have with clients, where so many folks, and myself included, because I believe the analog, anticipate a squeeze, you know, this little bit of a force in, and then they want to fade it for the retest.
And that retest is going to be everything. You know, I said in a note, I believe end of last week, that this next kind of week and a half, 2-week period is going to be so important because you're going to basically determine whether or not you squeeze in the people that have been waiting for the pullback in equities or whether or not they actually feel confidence that it doesn't realize, they begin to short it, they begin to press it, and it completely resets the environment that we're looking at. I personally feel like the timing is very interesting because you're now just beginning to see people get very nervous that are underexposed, and the tape held and the tape came back today, that you're going to see this discretionary active fundamental investor Adding back their exposure.
And then you also have in the backdrop the earnings call. And earnings is a volatility suppressor. And earnings also is important because by February 6th, you'll be through 75% of the S&P 500's buyback blackout. And that's that next leg, which corresponds actually with the local low that our analog that you then see a resumption in that trade higher. And that would really correspond with the corporate buyback bid reentering the market and being able to buy back their stock still at these much more attractive valuations than what they were looking at a year ago. And that's when corporates like to be in there buying their stock, defending their stock, and using their cash. So I think that you're going to get a local high in the next couple of days, and then you have basically 2 weeks to retest the low before you get that buyback resumption. And I think we probably start trading higher from there.
After that point, then it comes down to just how bad the data gets, how bad China gets, how bad the rhetoric around the structural issues with the Chinese trade negotiations go. You can't get much more dovish Fed speak unless things get worse. Right? So I think we're going to be back in that chop thereafter. But to summarize, near-term squeeze out in the next, say, 3 to 4 sessions to localize. The next 2 weeks thereafter, you get a, say, 5% pullback. And then that should correspond and put us on track for the return of the buyback, the corporate buyback bid, which should see markets begin to get pretty constructive again, especially if we get a really solid purge, a really solid retest of some of those recent lows, that would be the perfect scenario for me to get a little bit more tactically constructive and play this from the long side again.
I think right now, this tactical rally is in the late stages before the next phase.
Erik Townsend: Charlie, these fantastic graphs and charts that we're looking at in this deck are representative of the content that you send out every single day to your institutional And that email is free for qualified institutional clients. Please tell us a little bit more, and I'll apologize to our retail audience. Charlie doesn't make the rules that he's regulated by. He would love to share it with you, but he can't. So, who is eligible for this, and who do they need to contact in order to get on this fantastic distribution list?
Charlie McElligott: Sure. I appreciate that, sir. The easiest route is to reach out to your Nomura Global Markets sales contact, whatever asset class. And we can put them in touch with the right people on our end. Typically, we do have a revenue threshold, and there are certain regulatory dynamics with regards to domiciles, which I can and cannot send into, but we can work all that out behind the scenes. The path of least resistance, as always, call your salesperson, and we can get the ball rolling to begin dialoguing.
Erik Townsend: Well, I cannot recommend your daily letter strongly enough to those listeners who qualify for it. So I strongly encourage you to add We'll come back to that. Charlie, we really look forward to getting you back on the program again soon. You just give a fantastic interview. We're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email You can email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Charlie. It almost immediately struck me when he was talking about the idea of when the Fed finally starts to cut rates. He, uh, at least I don't want to put words in his mouth, but I kind of got this idea where he's basically saying rate cuts will mean squat. And it's really about when will the central banks once again start asset purchases. And he was even talking about Japanese-style asset purchases occurring here. And, uh, that really struck me because to me, And this is inevitable in my mind that once the business cycle turns and the credit cycles turn and the liquidity disappears, they're going to have to inject that liquidity back into the system some way. And it's going to be really interesting how it plays out. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I have to agree strongly with you and disagree at the same time. I couldn't agree more with what you just said, which is we're going to get to a point where things get ugly in the markets. And the way that Fed officials feel is that they have to really get accommodative and start buying assets and so forth. The thing that I don't think market participants are discounting adequately is what happens when this Yellow Jacket movement in Europe comes across the pond and we've got the general public saying, hell no, we're not gonna bail Wall Street out again. Again, we're not going to let it happen. If we're going to print money, damn it, then give it to the people. Don't give it to Wall Street. Let's not buy assets. Let's print money and, you know, give it as some kind of helicopter money handout.
And I think that what's happened is the political left that would favor a helicopter money kind of solution, they've had time to fully educate themselves about what happened last time and what they'd like to see go different next And I think that what we're going to see is a huge political debate that surfaces over this, and I think it could get a lot worse for markets.
So many people just assume the Fed's going to come riding to the rescue. What happens when the cavalry comes riding in and it meets a picket line of yellow vest type of characters who are saying, no, you're not going to rescue Wall Street again. Rescue us. We're starving. We're the ones who, who do the voting here. You're going to help us.
Patrick Ceresna: And Not them.
Erik Townsend: So I think that's a really big thing. In general, the, the other thing that really stood out to me in this interview was the discussion about the fact that Fed balance sheet roll-offs are just as constructive to the dollar index as rate hikes. I think so many people are making an erroneous assumption. They're saying, okay, it really seems like we're coming to a pause or the end of this rate hiking cycle.
That's gotta mean the dollar rally is over, 'cause everybody knows what drives the dollar rally is those interest rate differentials.
You've gotta remember this liquidity squeeze problem. What does the Fed balance sheet roll-off mean? It means that billions and billions of dollars of money in US dollars that get repaid to the Fed are not going back into the financial system because the Fed just rolled over that debt. debt and decided to buy new bonds with it that are new issues. It means that they're shrinking their balance sheet, and that is a huge dollar liquidity squeeze. It is very, very bullish the US dollar long term. And I think that it's very, very possible, as we discussed in the market wrap, maybe we do get a dip to 94 or something because there's a lot of volatility, a lot of uncertainty, a lot of confusion in this market.
Erik Townsend: But I think eventually we move much higher You know, what I wanted to touch on is the Steepener and the yield curve.
It was saved till the end of the interview, but to me, it was actually one of the most important parts of
Patrick Ceresna: the interview by far. And we didn't get into the details of how the curve is currently shaping, but what's particularly interesting is there's been a considerable steepening at the farthest part of the curve. When you look at the 10s and 30s and the 5s and 30s, we've We've seen that it was in the summer of 2018, over 6 months ago, that we saw the spreads narrowed down to like 10 basis points. We are actually at like almost 1-year highs. It's not yet 1 year, but we're, we're definitely close to 1-year highs on the spreads widening. We're like at 35 basis points on the 10s-30s, and we're on the 5s-30s, we're over 50 basis points widening. But what the interesting part here is the 2s-10s, which is the one that most people watch, has not begun to steepen yet. So the entire steepening that we've seen is only on the farthest end of the curve. And what will be really interesting to see is when do we see the steepener at the middle to the short end of the curve?
And that is a lot about when the market starts to price in the potential rate cuts by the Fed, that bull steepener. And that is something that I think is— we should not take our eyes off. When that starts to happen, we should have Charlie back on the show for sure. What's your thinking on that?
Erik Townsend: Oh, I couldn't agree more. We definitely need to get Charlie back. He really needs to become one of our frequent regular guests on the program. But I think another aspect of what you just said is we need to remember that the move that we saw— you say, you know, we haven't really seen the steepening in the 2s, 10s.
Well, of course, what's happened is there has been a huge, huge move on the 2s. But the thing is, there's Been just as big of a move on the 10s. Why the move on the 10s? It's the unwind of a big speculative short that turned out to be wrong, and everybody's getting squozen out of that trade.
The thing is, the 2s were not subject to that big speculation that was in the 10s. So we haven't seen it yet, but I think it's still coming. And what may be happening with this bounce that we're seeing off of— what was it, 2.58 on on the, the 10-year and we're back up to 2.70 now. Maybe the 10-year kind of went through a short squeeze all the way up to 2.58, just barely breaking through that 2.60 support level on the yield, and maybe what's going to happen now is the 10 bounces back but we still seem to see a bull steepening as a result of the 2-year yield starting to, to move down more rapidly, and that would happen in anticipation of Fed cuts and further accommodative policy, a pause in the rate hike cycle, or even a pivot all the way around to a rate cutting cycle. So it's going to be really, really interesting to see what the rest of 2019 brings.
I think we are, we're coming up on some really big market moves. I'm not smart enough to know exactly what's going to happen. I think Charlie's a lot better than I am at laying out the dominoes.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And talking about the sequencing of events that might play out. But, uh, it seems to me like some pretty big moves are in the cards. But speaking of big moves, Patrick, we've got to get packed up for our own move over to Vancouver to host MacroVoices Live this weekend. Anybody who wants to sign up last minute, you can still do so at MacroVoices.com/live, and we'll see you on Saturday in Vancouver. We'll be back next week with our regular show format and another fantastic guest. Meanwhile, we need your help promoting the program, so please Please tell your friends and colleagues about MacroVoices. How could they not have time to listen to Charlie McElligott in this interview? And send them your Research Roundup emails, and most importantly, register your free account if you haven't done so already at MacroVoices.com.
It only takes a minute, it's free, we're not going to spam you. What we will do is we'll send you the free Research Roundup email, which contains links to our featured interview content as well as all the best content that we can find on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: In this week's Research Roundup, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Charlie's chartbook that was referenced throughout the interview. There's an article from Jeffrey Snider titled Insight Japan, as well as an interesting article about the next 10 years in emerging market stocks. You'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. For those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge.
Announcer: You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.
Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Marin Katusa — Natural resource investing guru (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 148 was recorded on January 3rd, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Happy New Year. Natural resource investing guru Marin Katusa will join me as this week's feature interview guest. Marin sees opportunity in energy, steel, and diamond mining shares, and we'll also discuss precious metals. Be sure to stay tuned after the feature interview when Patrick and I will continue extended equity market coverage, including a post-game chartbook.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 has been on a rollercoaster ride for the last 2 weeks. We ended that interview with Daniel Want back on the 20th of December, and since then, the S&P 500— we had that Christmas Eve massacre to the downside where the S&P hit down towards 2,300, and then we've had an epic bounce rally on the other side. What's your take on all of this? What's your thinking on the S&P here?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm definitely persuaded that the cyclical bear market has begun, and I think that Christmas Eve massacre was a case of people taking advantage of thin liquidity and running stops. So it did create a very significant low. I keep wanting to say, okay, look, Patrick, the, the short-term low is in, we should expect a multi-month bounce now. And that doesn't mean to new highs. I think the bear market is on, but we're so oversold here, it's kind of time for a bounce. The thing is, at every turn, Patrick, Each time we've said that, and we've said it a few times now on this program, the market surprised us and was weaker than we expected.
So I really feel like we've sold off an awful lot and that it's time for some kind of a bounce. Now, I don't think that that's a bounce to new all-time highs. I think it's a bounce and we'll eventually move lower. But I'll be surprised if we move immediately below 2,300. I think we've got several weeks of bounce coming before we move much lower. Of course, I've said that a few times before and been proven wrong as the market proved weaker than we thought otherwise. As we'll get into in a few minutes, there's a lot of signals that are really telling us the economy has taken a turn for the worse.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US dollar. Now, earlier in the week, we had a dollar index trading below the 96 level, where we got above there the other day. Has this changed anything in your mind? Is the rally in jeopardy in the dollar?
Erik Townsend: No, I don't think that the rally is in jeopardy, but it's pretty clear that we're in an extended consolidation pattern, and I'm not sure how long that's going to last. We need a daily close above 97, not 96, but 97. And as we're speaking now on Thursday afternoon, we're actually below 96, a high 95 handle. So, you know, we need to see some significant strength before it's time to really say the rally is on again. But the, the dollar bears that are saying, oh, it's gonna crash any day now, I just don't see that case.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, moving on to crude oil, the oil seems to be mustering up some sort of a bounce. So, I mean, we traded as almost down to the $42 handle and since have been rallying. What's your take here? Does it still have more to go on the downside?
Erik Townsend: I think it probably does, but there's a good argument that a bottom could be in. First of all, inventory is delayed until Friday this week, so we don't have the benefit of inventory numbers to share with you. If I look at the chart, you know, there's a double pipe bottom on the daily chart. $42 is a low enough number that that could be it. Frankly, I doubt it, and it's more of a gut feeling than anything else. I think we've got a lot of uncertainty in this market. We don't know what's going to happen next with Saudi Arabia. We don't know what's going to happen with China. So, the news action could definitely influence it in either direction. It's quite possible that the bottom is in. I think that a move still lower is more likely, but we'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to gold because it continues to edge higher here. What's your take on what's happening in the gold markets?
Erik Townsend: Well, you said it, Patrick. It's edging higher, and it's surprising me by edging higher. But let's be clear, it's edging higher. It's not breaking out. It's, it's not leaps and bounds higher. It's higher than I expected, and it's also no longer just about the inverse US Dollar trade. So, something's going on here. I would definitely want to ask Marin Katusa. This is his specialty. But, frankly, I'm still skeptical of this rally, and, you know, I think it could have further to go here. But remember the 2008 pattern, whereas the economy started to turn, stocks sold off aggressively, gold was up initially as a safety trade, but then gold sold off with everything else and hit a new low. And I still think that that's a very good possibility. I could be wrong. I definitely will admit to have been caught by surprise here. I didn't expect, in the face of this much dollar strength, to see gold continue to push higher, which it's done.
But am I rushing in to buy it here? No, I'm waiting this out. If we make a decisive move above $1,300, it's gonna be really hard for me to explain what's going on. But am I buying it?
Patrick Ceresna: No. Let's move on to that 10-year Treasury yield. It fell below the 2.6% level today, a level you've described in the past as pretty important. What's coming next here in your mind in terms of yields?
Erik Townsend: Well, wow, Patrick. Holy cow. I mean, when we were speaking just a couple of weeks ago, we were eyeing 2.80% as the level that we had to see if that support was going to hold. I was talking about 2.60%, saying, look, that's the longer-term downside target for where we could get to in yield. We need Watch that support level if we ever get to it. And over the holiday break, you know, whammo, we're already below it. So, it's very clear. I think there's lots and lots of signs that this economy is definitely rolling over.
Jeff Snider had a fantastic piece on ZeroHedge today, which we have linked in your Research Roundup email, saying Eurodollar futures, and particularly the spread between Eurodollar futures at different points out on the curve, is also sending a very strong signal. So, we're getting a lot of recession signals here.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: I'm really looking forward to MacroVoices Live, getting Julian Brigden and Juliette Declercq and Brent Johnson and all of the rest of our speakers together on stage, because I want to ask them what's going on and where this can go and where we're headed. I really don't have any firm opinion other than that I think this is surprising everyone with respect to how vigorously we're moving down in yield, much more quickly than I expected.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, any updates in regards to MacroVoices Live in Vancouver now that you mentioned it?
Erik Townsend: Well, we are really looking forward to the event. I've been getting emails from the speakers. They're excited, I'm excited. Really looking forward to meeting more of our listeners. Again, it is the 19th. That's just a couple of weeks away. So be sure to get your tickets if you haven't already. They're available at MacroVoices.com/live.
You'll find all of the event details, including the detailed schedule there. A couple of people have asked us in email what the schedule is, and they don't realize the full schedule is on the website at MacroVoices.com/live.
Be sure to get there in time for the 6 PM reception on Friday night. You asked us in Toronto for more time to meet and socialize with the speakers, and we're giving it to you in the form of 2 receptions, both Friday and Saturday night, 6 to 9 PM, on the top floor at the Hyatt. So be sure not to miss that, and we'll look forward to seeing you in Vancouver.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Katusa Research founder Marin Katusa. Erik's interview with Marin is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is natural resource guru Marin Katusa. Now, as many of you know, Marin was our most requested guest speaker for Unfortunately, we couldn't get him on the schedule because Marin is one of the sponsors of the Vancouver Natural Resource Conference, which starts the very next day, and has a lot of responsibilities. The trade-off was we were able to get him on the show a couple of weeks ahead of time. So Marin, thanks so much for taking time out of your busy schedule to join us on the program today.
Marin Katusa: Oh, it's a pleasure, Erik. Always a pleasure.
Erik Townsend: The first time that I interviewed you on this program, you described an opportunity to buy Nevsun on speculation because you thought it was a takeover target, and you became something of a rock star in the eyes of many of our listeners, because that stock just shot up like 50% 2 days after your interview. But as much as that was a great call, and you deserve credit for that, by your own admission, the timing that it happened 2 days after you made that call was pure dumb luck. It was a stock that you and your subscribers had been watching for several months before that happened.
So, Marin, I'm going to hold you accountable, because the next time that you were interviewed on MacroVoices, you told us that you had just recommended a private placement in a uranium streaming And at the time, you were not able to tell us the name of the company out of respect for your paying subscribers, but you were very excited about it. So now that plenty of time has passed, I'm hoping that you can tell us the name of the company and also how has it performed since your recommendation? Because needless to say, the rest of the market has suffered pretty badly.
Marin Katusa: So the markets have been very volatile. The company that we specifically were referring to during your podcast was a company called Uranium Royalty Corp. And what I like about them is Because they're unique. They were the first in the world to do what they're doing. It's run by a very competent and, more importantly, invested management team. So when we got in at the same price as the insiders and management team at $1, the company is literally right now closing another financing at $1.50. So it's a 50% jump from where we're in at, and it's still very early days in the story. I do believe The company's going to do a lot more. And where is the uranium market now? Well, in the last 12 months, uranium's up a little over 40%.
But more importantly, the assets of this company— they're the largest shareholder of a UK-listed holder of uranium called Yellowcake— is up over 40%. And their streams are what I call in non-AK-47 nations, meaning relatively politically stable now. So after you invest in resources for a while, you'll find out there's no such thing as no risk. Every jurisdiction has some sort of risk. The question is, is how high is that risk? So Uranium Royalty Corp has done fantastic for myself and my subscribers thus far. Look, it's going to be volatile just like the markets, but thus far the management have exceeded my expectations. I do believe they'll continue to do that, and I think we'll do very, very well on that story. So we're up 50% in a market where most people are down.
Erik Townsend: Well, congratulations on that. It's fantastic that you're up so much considering the market overall. But that leads me to my next question, because The market overall is a serious concern. As we all know, natural resource companies tend to be fairly volatile to start with. A lot of people, myself included, think that we're headed toward weaker economic times, possibly into a recession in the next 12 to 18 months. So how do you manage a natural resources portfolio if you have a view that maybe the economy is going to get weaker? Do you hedge your longs with short positions, or do you just wait for the opportunity to buy when there's blood in the streets? Or, or What's your strategy? How do you manage this?
Marin Katusa: That's a great question, and we've written extensively over the last 12 months how, how much I believe how volatile we're gonna get. And, and I've talked about how oil is gonna go down and how copper has downside. Now, I'm very bullish both on long-term prices for those and gold, but what we've been very fortunate is I've kept emphasizing in 2018 how the US dollar will outperform other currencies. So number one is You can't take advantage of market capitulation in any market, and I focus on the resources, is if you don't have cash. The other factor is, is if your currency is depreciated at a level compared to the US dollar, you're also at a disadvantage.
So we've been heavy US dollar. We've been very happy with that. But I also have a strategy of being an alligator. And when it comes to investments in the resource sector— so what I mean by investment is something that pays a dividend, is the lowest cost quartile of producer, is Is in a jurisdiction that I'm comfortable, and not just going myself, but taking my family, too. Because I've been around the world. I put body armor to go to assets when I was younger. I've kind of figured out that those are more bull market phenomenons. When you really come to the Warren Buffett style, you just want the bread and butter, lowest cost quartiles with a good balance sheet and stay away from the debt.
So I have got a strategy for the investments. And I never allow any one investment to make up more than 10% of my resource portfolio. Now, for the speculations, I never allow my subscribers, and I talk about this and I really emphasize, never to put over 5% of your resource portfolio in any one speculation. And then the key is, is to reduce your risk.
So that's where I'm very big on— we were joking earlier about the Katusa Free Ride, but the reality is you have to remind your subscribers to take profits because, especially in the resource market, my favorite thing is a portfolio full of warrants.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: And free rides and a lot of cash. That's the best way to take advantage of a distressed sector.
Erik Townsend: I want to stay on that distressed sector subject because I think economically we probably haven't seen the worst yet. But when I look at oil specifically, it feels to me like a lot of this price slide has been driven by this whole Jamal Khashoggi murder fiasco where obviously Saudi Arabia has embarrassed themselves to the point where it's very difficult for them to be aggressive in their policy.
Is it time already to be thinking about buying oil, or is it something that we want to wait out? Do you think it still has a lot more downside, or are we seeing it starting to bottom here?
Marin Katusa: So I personally believe we're going to see it break $40. That's the US WTI pricing. Now, a lot of people may not know this, but in other parts of the world, it's been under $20 per barrel in US dollar equivalent prices. So that's places in the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin, which is Alberta mainly in Canada. There's been times in the last 3 months where the gas has been negative, meaning the producing companies had to pay to get rid of their own gas. Like, think about that. So there's like a negative cost. That's actually happened in the oil patch. So I believe that the US will significantly increase their oil production. They're the world's number one oil producer right now. And I think that's going to continue by at least another half a million barrels a day at the end of 2019.
What will happen with Venezuela? A lot of people are expecting Venezuela to fall apart. I don't think they'll allow the production of oil to fall apart as much as the market expects, because that's That's only generating cash flow asset is the oil. And then the question of OPEC, they came out and said, we're going to cut. Do you really believe OPEC? Can the countries actually stick to it? I doubt it. And then the Russians always increase their market share during a market pullback because of the nature of the producing assets. So I do believe, Erik, that oil will go lower. And that's music to my ears because what I want to buy is big production.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Marin Katusa: At a huge discount. And I'm publishing on that today, where strong balance sheets that if oil goes below $30, their dividend is rock solid. That's what I want. And you can get in the market now companies with strong balance sheets paying an 8% yield that are down 50% over the last, say, 90 days.
But nothing's really changed with the company other than market sentiment. That's how you take advantage of the oil markets.
Erik Townsend: And is it time now, or are you recommending buying oil companies that obviously are depressed dramatically in the last 90 days, or do you think that it's something we want to wait out in order to get to lower price targets?
Marin Katusa: So I have a tranche method. So we have actually today published our buy your first tranche, which is your first 25% of an investment. So that's 2.5% of the portfolio. And I said buy under $4 on this specific stock. It was $4.10. So, you know, I expect within the next 10, 15, 20 days that the price will hit, as I believe oil will come down a little bit. Oil had a little bit of a pop today, specifically today's January 2nd, mainly because OPEC came out with some bullish, we're gonna pull back and we're gonna hold the markets. You know, there's only so much you can believe OPEC. And, you know, Erik, you and I have been doing this a long time. Go back to all of the comments OPEC have stated.
Yes, it's done— their comments have kind of propped the market in this last run, but I really think oil can pull back another 10% at least.
Erik Townsend: I agree with you on that. So for oil stocks, it sounds like you're starting to average in, but only at these prices are you just starting, and you're keeping a little bit of dry powder for even Better buying opportunities on the horizon.
Marin Katusa: Correct. I have a specific buy-under. So we're very disciplined in our style. We call it the way of the alligator. You know, an alligator just sits back, and when it's time, he pounces. It's more like a predator mentality. That's where I am in these markets. I'm staying away from high-risk juniors. I want to buy value at a significant discount where it would cost the management teams of these companies more to build these assets than they're trading for in the market today. And you got all of that execution risk out of the market because they're producing over 100,000 barrels a day.
So the stock prices are liquid, doesn't trade by appointment. That's where I want to be in this market.
Erik Townsend: And do you publish what all of your price targets are for future tranches, or do you wait out the market and just see where it takes us over time?
Marin Katusa: No, I actually have targets. So for this specific oil target, I said, look, I think this is going to bounce within the next 3 to 6 months by about 25%. And at that point, At some point, we're either going to close the position or at a minimum take a free ride. It's just, you know, with an 8% dividend, that's pretty juicy. But I put specific how to buy and when I think we'll sell the target.
Erik Townsend: Now, I know that you are also following the steel sector, and I should probably disclose, in the interest of full disclosure, that I am a subscriber to your newsletter myself, so I know some of what you're writing about. Help us understand why you would be looking at steel. A lot of people think a recession is coming.
Historically, you know, people kind of associate steel and copper as things you buy at the very bottom of the recession, not when we're just maybe coming into one. So why are you looking already at these sectors?
Marin Katusa: Great question. Now, to be a contrarian, you know, you truly have to be a contrarian. Everyone likes to think they're a contrarian, but you have to have an outward-thinking mentality. So if you look at what's going on with the American and Chinese tariff situation, who are the victims unintentionally? Well, the non- US producers of steel. So when you start going through the list of global steel producers, you see that many of them have incredible amounts of debt that they've put on because to build a steel mill is not cheap. So companies have billions and billions of debt where they're 2 or 3 times their debt is what their market cap is.
But when the tariffs came in almost across the board, these steel producers have been down 25%, 30%, 40%, 55% down.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Marin Katusa: Down, and yet the lowest-cost quartile producers who have no debt on their balance sheet have gone down just as much as the worst-run steel companies in the world. And you sit there and, okay, let's dig it down a little deeper. So we see the market sentiment so negative on steel producers, and yet why are they trading the way they are? But let's actually look at steel prices. They're still holding very strong. And what type of steel are they producing. Hot rolled, cold rolled, you know, there's different forms of steel, different areas, different cost structures. And what we've started with is your first tranche, so your first 25% of your desired position, because these positions sometimes take 12 months to buy the way I, I do this.
It's not like, okay, I've got $200 grand and I want to buy all the stock today. That's the wrong way of buying resource stocks. First you have to educate yourself, understand the Understand the company, get familiar with the way the stock trades, and then start building your different tranches. And I think that some of these companies, specifically one that I'm in at the same price as my subscribers, is significantly oversold. It's the lowest-cost producer in North America, has no debt, pays a strong dividend. I'm comfortable with that type of position, but I'm also only in on my first tranche. So it'll take me about 12 or 18 months to build my full tranche position. Okay.
Erik Townsend: You know, that phenomenon you just described never ceases to amaze me, the way that the industry will look at something and say, okay, steel producers, really heavy debt sector, sell them, they're going to be in trouble because of their debt load. And they're selling the whole sector without regard to which company has a lot of debt and which doesn't. And it happens in all industries. It's really amazing how the industry tends to just look at a sector as being weak for some reason and then sell the companies that are weak for that reason and sell the companies that are not really weak for that reason altogether in a batch. It's, it's kind of like racial discrimination for stocks.
Erik Townsend: It's an amazing phenomenon. I want to move on to another sector I know you've been looking at, which is diamond mining. Why diamonds, especially as we think maybe coming into a recession? You know, it's, it's not time for people to be spending a whole lot of extra spare money they don't know what to do with on luxury items like jewelry.
So why diamond mining at a time Well, again, it's a contrary bet.
Marin Katusa: So when people think about diamonds, what do they think about? They think about blood diamonds, they think about man-made diamonds, and a lot of that is true. So first of all, if you're going to look at a diamond company, stay away from what I call small carats production and stay away from dirty diamonds, obviously. You know, and those are in— like a blood diamond comes from an AK-47 nation, the way I call them.
Okay. Call it. So again, you look at the diamond companies, because of the threat of man-made diamonds, and more, more specifically what's been called Lightbox, which is owned by De Beers, who's the world's largest producer in dollar volume— largest producer of diamonds actually the Russians with Alrosa— but De Beers has been involved in mining for over 100 years.
Man-made diamonds first started in the '50s. It's gotten to the point where De Beers is able to make a small man-made sub-1-carat diamond for about $800. Now, I don't want to be competing with that, but there's an old saying, buy bonds, wear diamonds. And yet, when you look at the plus 10-carat diamonds, the big ones, they're actually going up in value year over year because of the concentrated wealth. If you look at the auctions for the big diamonds, so you want to stay in the highest quartile of value but the lowest quartile of cost. Cost in a built mine. So I'm staying away from any exploration of diamond. I have no interest in high risk. I'm coming in now and buying asset at a significant discount to where it traded even 6 to 12 months ago. That is a low-cost producer and essentially has a monopoly in the big diamonds, which have a huge value.
Like, the price of diamonds are exponential as they get bigger. That's— a lot of people don't understand the diamond pricing.
But people talk about buying gold for value as a safe haven. Well, with the uber-rich, you actually buy big diamonds because where are you going to store all that gold? So the big diamonds has its own market. It's a very niche market, but yet the company I'm talking about pays an incredible dividend of over 7%, has no debt, and it's the Ferrari of the diamond world.
So that's another alligator concept of buying things that are unloved for the wrong reason. And you wouldn't believe how many analysts, Erik, have talked about the company and combined it with the low-carat producers, like the small carats, the sub-2-carat diamond producers. And I'm going, are these analysts morons? Do they not understand the profile of what this company produces? It's all about the big diamonds. And moving forward, I think those will trade at a premium, which actually in the market they are, and stay away from the small-carat producers like Alrosa. They are the world's largest producer of diamonds, but they also produce those micro diamonds, which are going to be competing with man-made diamonds. I don't want to compete with man-made diamonds. I want to cater to the uber-rich, I call it, and that's the big diamond sector.
Erik Townsend: You mentioned gold a minute ago. I want to come back to that because something that you and I have agreed on in the past is we both feel that there is a very strong macroeconomic argument for the US dollar to strengthen even further, and that's led both of of us to agree that gold is probably going to face some serious headwinds. Well, we got the dollar part of that call right. The dollar has been strong, just as we expected it to be. But look at this gold chart. It's really surprised me. It seems like gold has kind of changed its personality, and it's trading more as a safe haven asset as opposed to an anti-dollar trade. What do you think is driving the change, and has it changed your view on gold? Because last I spoke to you, you and I both were kind of not necessarily bearish, but kind of meh on gold.
And it's been up since then.
Marin Katusa: Yeah, it's up. But where it's really up is in the— so if you're a producer, let's say in Canada or Australia, you know, I joke, I wrote, I teased an article many months ago called The Commonwealth Takeover. When you're producing in a lower currency, such as even the Russians or Chinese are the world's largest producer of gold, a lot of people don't know that. But when you're producing in a weaker currency, such as the Canadian dollar or Aussie relative to the US dollar, it's touching now about $1,700 an ounce. So that's your Canadian cost relative. So where I think— will it go to $1,400, $1,500 in the near term? No. But for US dollars, if these producers are in debt in US dollars, which when you build a mine, it's always US dollar debt. That's a lot of people don't know. When you build— if you try to buy a fleet of 30 big trucks from Komatsu or Wherever, it's always in US dollars, or big shovels, the steel, the mills, the ball mills, the SAG mills, it's always US dollars.
So it's priced in US dollars. So it's held well. Has it really gone front page yet? No. Have the share prices of the senior producers done well relative to gold? No. So it's not done well enough to spill over into the producers area. And I don't see that happening in the next little while, near term, meaning next few months.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Marin Katusa: I think gold will be very volatile, sub-$1,300. I think it'll touch $1,180. I think it'd easily break $1,200, but I think it's range-bound for the next few months.
Erik Townsend: And range-bound for the next few months before a move in which direction, or don't know, or what's your perspective on what comes next?
Marin Katusa: So, this is where I'm going to get more hate from just, uh, not just your viewers, but also my viewers. There's almost There's this mentality that if you invest in the resource sector, you have to be a gold bug or you have to cheer for higher prices. Look, I think gold goes lower. I think we'll see $1,180 gold before we see $1,400 gold.
Erik Townsend: And is that because of the dollar expectations or for another reason?
Marin Katusa: A few reasons. I believe the US dollar, like you stated, I believe it will do well. I think the next few months it'll be bouncing around. It's just trying to find itself, but I think the next leg of the dollar is higher. Therefore, the producers in non-US regions like Canada, Australia, go to Africa, Russia, they'll be able to produce more, meaning you can start processing your lower grades of gold, which may be at $1,600 Canadian equivalent gold, or $1,250. You can't, but at $1,300 you could.
But because of the FX reasons, that's one. Number 2, there's no shortage of gold mines. I know a lot of people talk about peak gold, I actually don't buy that. What it is, is what price do you need gold to be? And everyone thinks in US dollars on the cost, but if you go to enough mines that I've been to, if you can get non-US dollar funding, so let's say a partner from the Chinese or the Russians, there'll be more supply come on. So I think in a few years, I'll be— we'll see $1,750, $1,800, maybe even $2,000 gold, but not this year.
Erik Townsend: Marin, I want to pick up on something you said a minute ago about gold, where you said, you know, almost everybody expects you that you have to be on the cheering squad for it. Something else I've noticed about your style, you know, a lot of people, they want to pick a really solid— and I'm talking about stock investing generally now— they want to pick a really solid company that has a future that they can believe in and buy and hold it for several years. Something I've noticed about your style is you very, very rarely hold positions for that long. So give us a little bit of perspective on what your strategy is. And is it that it's just Marin Katusa is different from other investors, or is it that the natural resource sector is different from other sectors in terms of how you have to approach it?
Marin Katusa: I think that's a really good question. I think the answer quickly is I think I'm very different than most commentators or writers in the sector, such that I'm a very large investor in the sector, so I've got significant skin in the game, whereas many newsletter writers aren't actually allowed to buy any stocks, so they're more, you know, armchair analysts. And the second thing is, is I really do believe the resource sector is different than many other sectors. Now, I solely focus on the resource sector, but it's so cyclical, so volatile, that you have to be very active.
And the absolute key is risk mitigation. There's a reason why my fund is one of the top funds over the last decade, and it's about risk mitigation. When the times are great— just, just think about this from a broad perspective— in 2017 and Q1 I was offered hundreds of millions of dollars to manage by very well-known names in the industry, and I said, this is ridiculous. A year and a half ago, when I made my big moves on Northern Dynasty and these other deals, those same individuals thought I was crazy. But the reason is, is they get all this capital allocated to them when things are good, and then it trickles down to the best money managers, and then they're almost forced to invest in the sector.
The only way to truly be successful in the resource sector is to be actually a true contrarian. And to be a true contrarian, even if you find a stock that you really like— look at the one that we just did in December as our number one tax loss. We had a strategy. We thought it was a fantastic story. I had a very specific buy under this price. And in less than a month, it's up over, what, 40% and change. And today we published to take a Katusa Free Ride at a minimum or close the position because that's not really a realistic gain in one month. So if the market gives it it to you, take it. And you have to have dry powder. You have to have cash on the side to take advantage of these markets. And that's something I've learned about doing this for almost 20 years is the guys who've made the biggest scores were the ones who were able to take advantage of the markets when no one else had cash.
So you can't fall in love with these cyclical stories. Like, for example, everyone's talking about Kirkland Lake today. But the true asset of Kirkland Lake is an asset, Fosterville, which was in a company called Newmarket. I wrote the first report on Newmarket, and it was the first thing I ever published under Katusa Research. I bought 10% of the company. Doug Forster who ran the company, the first meeting he took as the president of the company when he took over a company called Crocodile Gold was in my office in Vancouver. And I literally wrote up a 17-page report on it, still on my website, and saying, I'm going to be buying 10% of this company, and here's why. Now, that stock went from under $1 to today to, I don't know, it's like $35 a share today, Kirkland Lake.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Marin Katusa: But at $2 and change, I had a double, so I sold half my position and the rest was free. And I sold half my position to a guy named Eric Sprott, who's the chairman of the company that bought out that stock, and he's the chairman today of Kirkland Lake.
So what I'm trying to get at is, okay, sure, I should, you know, in retrospect, if I held the whole position, but this game is about risk mitigation. So if I can have a free round or, you know, a free position, position like the one that we just took today on Sun Metals. This business is so cyclical, so risky, anything can happen. You try to just build your positions, reduce your cost base, and grow your net worth. It's kind of a boring strategy. You have to stay active, but it works, so stick with it.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's a very important commentary on this market sector is unlike a lot of other stock sectors, you got to be on top of this stuff. You, you can't just sit back and, you know, buy something and look at your portfolio again for the next time in 6 months and see how it's doing. You've got to be an active investor in order to speculate in the kind of stocks that you get involved with.
But Marin, I want to come back to the question I asked you a minute ago about the way that you move into these positions in tranches where, you know, you start with your first quarter or your first third of the position. I've noticed from following your newsletter, you don't always get filled on all of those, or at least you haven't in the time that I've been reading your letter. Do you adjust your positions? In other words, if you've decided you're going to buy so much of a certain company, if you don't get your price, do you eventually move your limits up and buy it at a higher price? Or do you just pass and say, okay, if I couldn't get the price I wanted, then I'm going to pass on that trade and look for a different opportunity down the road?
Marin Katusa: So I'll share the, the 2 ones that you're talking about in the newsletter. The chairman of the company and the founder of the company is a very, very, very close friend of mine, and he calls me a very stubborn individual. He's like, just move your price up. And I said, I'm not, because I do believe that the market will pull back, meaning gold and silver prices, the spot prices for these will come down a little bit. And I'd rather be patient.
And these are world-class companies run by great management teams, lowest-cost producers, no debt on their balance sheets. But I've done this long enough that, look, if you're looking for a newsletter that you want 7 stocks to buy, today and put your whole portfolio into gold, I think that's wrong, and that's not my strategy, and I'm not the type of publication you should follow. My strategy is what I've been doing with my own money and my fund, and I'll put my track record in the resource sector up against anybody. And it's not the most sexy or entertaining newsletter, but this is how it's done properly.
And on that one specific stock, look, it just took over another stock that has a lot of shareholders that have been locked up in the company. If the silver price pulls back a little bit and those sellers now, they've been taken out by the bigger company and they want to hit the bid, that's 2 extra events that will cause selling pressure potentially. It doesn't mean it will, but potentially. So if I can pick the stock up for, say, 15% or 25% below where it's today, that's really good. But also, I missed it by 40 cents. the last pullback in silver, which was almost, what, 60 days ago.
So that's telling me that, you know what, just a little bit of a pullback in the market and that price will come back to me. So I'm fairly stubborn, and usually if you're patient enough, the market will come back to you. So I'm a big believer in don't chase stocks.
Erik Townsend: Well, certainly what you're doing is working because your track record, as you say, is very well respected. And with some of the calls you've made just on this program, like Nevsun and Uranium Royalty Corp., you're certainly doing very well. Patrick has been trying to wrestle with your staff to get them to let us publish a current issue of one of your newsletters, and they've explained you just can't do that because your paying subscribers would be too upset if you did. But we have managed to get permission to publish the July issue of your newsletter, in which you made the argument for Uranium Royalty Corporation, so that our interested Listeners can get a sense of how you do what you do. Now, it's probably already too late to buy that one because it's already up 50% from the time that you made that recommendation back in July. But just as a sample of the approach you take, we've got that linked in your Research Roundup email.
So listeners, you'll find the download link there. Again, that's not a recommendation that you're making to buy it now because it's already moved up dramatically. Patrick also persuaded your staff to repeat your deep discount offer, which you did for us before on MacroVoices. MacroVoices.
But before we cover that, I feel obliged to explain, this really is not for everyone. You have a fantastic reputation and a fantastic product, but frankly, it's not cheap. Regular price is $3,500 a year. So who is this actually a match for? How big of a natural resource portfolio does an investor need to have before a higher price tag newsletter like this makes sense?
Marin Katusa: Yeah. I really believe that if you're an active investor that wants to, number one, educate themselves on how the resource sector really works, number two, you want to get to the point where you're accredited. So if you're an accredited investor, it's a no-brainer for you. Like, look, just the December issue alone would pay for 5 years of the newsletter in profits. But really, this is not for day traders. This is not for someone that wants to just kind of have a stock pick and they don't care about any anything else.
This is really an education. We dig deep into the fundamentals of the stock. And then also, when I do my site visits, I bring my film crew. It's kind of like a documentary style. You get to watch me going underground or to the wellhead or to the copper mine, gold mine, whatever. The uranium facilities, we're one of the few people to get approval from Areva to go into the world's largest uranium facility. And then I bring my film crew and they get to see how I interact with the management. They get to The one-on-one interviews with the management team, the workers at site, just to get it like a— to see what I see when I go on site. So you get the written reports, you get these, uh, all the videos online, and the whole archive of what I've been writing for, you know, now 4 or 5 years.
So it's all there online. But I really think that, you know, I started out as a teacher in math and physics, and what I try to write it for is that person who wants And I guess if you want more out of your finances, I've got a personal logo that is personal freedom through financial independence. And I guess anyone who wants that, my newsletter's for you.
Erik Townsend: Okay. Again, with the caveat that it is for investors with a significant portfolio, because it did, you know, if you've only got $5,000, it doesn't make sense to spend half of it on a newsletter. So I just want to make sure that we're clear about that. We were able to get to knock you down quite a bit from the $3,500 regular subscription price to $19.99. $295 with a 30-day money-back guarantee for MacroVoices listeners only. Listeners, you'll find the link to that special offer in your Research Roundup email, or you can just go to KatusaResearch.com/MacroVoices.
Marin, I know that you have specific stock recommendations for oil, steel, and diamonds that we were not able to mention in this interview out of respect for your paying subscribers. Patrick asked your staff to make up a report for MacroVoices listeners who subscribe to your letter detailing those 4 picks. So I guess that will be available to anyone who subscribes. We were going to get 4, we're only getting 3.
So was that— I'm guessing that was Sun Metals, that by the time we could get it out, you're taking profits.
Marin Katusa: So, so when— remember when we, when we discussed this, it was before Christmas. And, uh, first of all, we've never done this before where we've given publications But I look at you and Patrick as kind of like Batman and Robin. I like you guys, so I only work with people I like. Number 2, I love to put my stuff out there, and with that comes the good, the bad, and the ugly. You get people that love your stuff, then you just get trolls and haters, and I have fun with them.
Number 3, we were going to have 4, but the Sun Metals, we're taking a free ride today for the subscribers. It's liquid. There's a big fund trying to buy stock in it.
Erik Townsend: Oh, wow.
Marin Katusa: Why not mitigate all your risk as a subscriber and see what the drill bits find for free? It really is what I call smart speculation. So you'll get all the research part of that, but when they sign up, they're not just going to get the 3 stock picks that they can buy now and following the tranche pricing, because the prices are where I'm buying them now, but more importantly, it's how to use my newsletter. There's kind of like a starter's guide, because truthfully, you're probably going to be overwhelmed with the content on the site. Every month I publish somewhere between 20 and 30 pages of research. Sometimes there may be multiple issues between months if I find that the markets may need an update or our price target gets hailed or if there's a take profits or sell a position. So there's a How to Use This Newsletter guide, which explains my tranche concept and how to buy and how to sell.
Also, you know, where do you go to buy these stocks? Do you use a full-service broker or a discount online broker? I talk about the pros and cons of each. So they'll get the how-to-use the guide, the top 3, and instant access to everything I've written up in the history of the firm and all the videos too.
Erik Townsend: Marin, let's move on to January in Vancouver. We had hoped to get you to come and speak at our MacroVoices Live event event at the Hyatt. Unfortunately, you had to decline because you are one of the major sponsors of the Vancouver Resource Investment Conference, and your counteroffer was to very generously give all of our attendees at MacroVoices Live free passes to come to VRIC, which most of us are intending to do. I'm actually speaking on a couple of panels there myself, looking forward to that. Give us a little bit of perspective on what VRIC is and what people can expect to find there when they get there?
Marin Katusa: So it's the largest conference for junior mining and mid-tiers in the world. It was started over 30 years ago by the Martin family. So Joe Martin started it. His son, Jay Martin, took it over about 4 or 5 years ago. And I don't know if you know this also, but I'm a partner with them on the Vancouver Resource Investment Show, so VRIC.
So I get involved in who speaks at the show, hence why you and Patrick are talking at the show. And I love bringing controversy. Like, I'm not just about pushing what I believe. I like being challenged. So you'll see my buddies like Grant Williams and Doug Casey and Rick Rule, all the different guys I bring up on stage. And we'll challenge each other because, you know, Grant and I had the great debate on why he thought the US dollar was going down. I said, no, man, it's going up. And then you get to, to see that in live form, different people's opinions. These are all smart people. And see where it goes. So this You're going to have 6 different workshops with many, many well-known speakers. And then in the big room, like the big main hall, you'll be on stage. I'll be moderating you and Peter Schiff and a few other people. So it'll be fun.
So, you know, and there's a lot of guys that I don't agree with, and I'll challenge them in front of everyone because I think our styles are pretty same, Erik. We, we say what we think. I don't tolerate bullshit very much on stage. I call people out on their calls. You know, you can't just be a gold bull for 35 years because you'd be broke, right? So—
Erik Townsend: Well, some people are. They manage anyway.
Marin Katusa: Yeah, and I just don't understand how they do it. And so, you know, if a guy's been right once every 25 years, how long can he milk that for? So, you won't see any of these paid newsletter writers at my show. I'm a big believer in skin in the game. And look, it's not like everything I do is perfect. I've got lots of losses on my track record, but I move along and I wear those losses with my subscribers. So the key is, is try to find the best ideas and, and submerge yourself with the best minds in the business. So that's what I try to do. At the show, you'll see many geologists talking, engineers talking about feasibility studies and what they mean and what to look out for. We also do a cool thing on a Sunday night, something I'd love to share with your people They may not know what we do, but we induct someone who's done something excellent in the industry, and they get inducted into the Resource Hall of Fame, where every one of the shows, we open up the bar and they get to drink and listen to how did he get into the Hall of Fame, what was it about his career.
And this January, we're inducting an individual who's built 5 copper mines throughout his career.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Marin Katusa: Now, to build 1 copper mine is an achievement. To build 5 major copper mines is an achievement. copper mines, and then he's going to walk through how he did it. So if you have a chance, I know it's a Sunday and, you know, most people are going to be watching the playoffs, but do your portfolio a favor and come out, and hopefully you'll be at least educated and hopefully entertained.
Erik Townsend: Well, fantastic. I look forward to seeing you there. Meanwhile, Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now, back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Marin back onto the show. So looking forward to seeing him again out in Vancouver. It's going to be a great time, both at MacroVoices Live, which I'm looking forward to meeting so many of our listeners, but also for going to the resource show and seeing Marin there. So what did you think of the interview?
Erik Townsend: You know, what really struck out to me, it's interesting, Marin is buying NAV.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: But, you know, he's, he's just following a process of starting to average in. And I'm doing the same thing. I've been accumulating long-dated calls on crude oil. Marin is trading the stocks. I tend to trade the commodities directly. So for me, it's been calls on long-dated crude oil futures. He's starting to average into the oil stocks. But, you know, I don't think we're at the bottom yet. And I think Marin felt the same way. We've got lower to go here. It's gonna be very interesting. I really agree with his view on gold. And, you know, we've both been kind of proven wrong, at least in the short term, for the last several weeks. So, I'm sticking to my guns on this. I think there's plenty of room for gold to break here and for this to be it and to move back down before this is over. I could be wrong, because I've definitely been surprised by it. So, it's going to be really interesting to see what comes next.
I want to get, though, to where I think we're headed economically, which is we're seeing a lot of recession We talked a little bit about steel in this interview. I wanna get to copper and a number of other things. So let's go to your chartbook. Listeners, you'll find that linked in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: If you're not subscribed yet, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, at page 2 of the chartbook, you've got an equity update for us on the S&P 500. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, chart 2 actually is not an update. That's going back to December 6th from our last chartbook. And what I was trying to highlight here was, We were trading back around just under 2,700 at the time, and I was talking about measured moves on the— technically as to where the S&P could go if it was to break to lower lows. And we measured out down to more or less 2,500 and then 2,400 on the downside. And, uh, what was interesting is I got a number of comments from some people that were listening like, you really believe it could go to 2,400? But it, it was just amazing to just see the magnitude of that selling in December, wasn't it? It was just relentless selling, wasn't it, Erik?
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I think that the Christmas Eve event had to do with people running stops in thin liquidity. I think that it was pretty easy to see that there was a bounce coming after that, and I won't be surprised if it carries us forward for several weeks to come.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so on page 3 was where I then over a laid the existing price action over those 2 measured targets. And, uh, clearly the market on that final day did that big blow-off to the downside. This is a 4-hour chart, so it was a couple of 4-hour candles that blew past that 2390 lower target. But we then have that bounce, that 1,000 Dow point up day on the markets, and the dead cat bounce is underway. And one of the things that I wanted to just kind of touch on is what to expect next. And one thing that I thought was particularly interesting and noteworthy to point out is that while I suspect that that low that we've established here in January is likely to hold for maybe even several months, while I'm bearish, I'm in your camp that I believe that the stock market is in a bear market. And over a bear market, we're bound to make lower lows at some future point.
But I believe that there's a good chance that January and maybe even February will have have their lows contained there. But what's interesting is, is that if you go through the last 4 kind of market events where we had one of these liquidity washouts in the stock market that happens a couple days, once that short-term low happens, we've seen on numerous occasions— on actually all 4 occasions— the market retests the low in some form or another over the next month. Now, in some cases, like the days after the February February vol event, a double bottom retest was there within 4 or 5 trading sessions. But in situations like after the April low that was established earlier this year, we just went and kind of retested the low. It wasn't a full double bottom, it was a little bit higher, but it retested a whole month later.
And so what I really wanted to get across is that just because we've probably seen the low doesn't mean that the market isn't going to spend many weeks probably establishing a base along these previous lows and that we could get a little bit of chop in here before there's any kind of a legitimate bounce.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to the 10-year yield on page 4.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And I just really put this chart up just to really hammer home the point that you were talking about in the pregame or the market wrap where we were talking about just this extraordinary move. Like, we saw those yields double top around 3.25%, and it's just been a relentless Endless drop in yields to the downside. I mean, we've broken that established trading range where around that 2.75, 2.80 level where all of the key lows of 2018 came in. I mean, we have to go back to late 2017 to see yields at levels where we're currently trading. And so it's really interesting to see where bond traders— do you, by the way, Erik, think that this is a squeeze of some sort, too many people just short yields at this stage? What's your thinking on that?
Erik Townsend: I think the acceleration that we've seen in the last week or so is a result of a squeeze. I think that the shorts are getting kicked out, but I think there's more to it than that. I don't think this is just the kind of squeeze that kind of tricks people out of their trade and then retraces and reverses. I think that what we're seeing here is economic signals that are very real. Usually, there's always 2 sides to every argument. You can make the bull case and you can make the bear case, but just look at what we've seen here. with the equity market keeps surprising both of us. You and I both were very quick to say, yeah, we do think that the bear market is on, but look, it's oversold, it's time for a bounce. And at every turn when we say that, okay, it gets more oversold, it, it doesn't bounce nearly as much as we expected.
You look at the 10-year yield here and it's plunging on page 4. If we move on to page 5, gold is moving up even when the dollar isn't, which is telling us that there's a safe haven trade going on. And as we get on to copper, which is coming up later in this, we'll see copper's falling off a cliff. Where's the good news in this story? Where do you even begin to make a bullish argument? It really says to me that we're getting signals, macro signals, from all different asset classes telling us the same thing, which is this economy is in a lot more trouble than most people thought it was.
Patrick Ceresna: I couldn't I couldn't agree more. It really is a situation where I think there was this one eureka moment where the market participants said, well, you know, they've been all saying, well, eventually this will come. But it seems like everyone all woke up one morning and said, holy cow, the business cycle's turning and my portfolio's not positioned for this. And suddenly everybody's off to the races to make their adjustments.
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, I wanted to pull up that chart on gold. So on page 5, I put up just a chart on gold. And what was particularly interesting to me on gold is I've heard so many different people come up with the $1,290 level on gold from different sources. So like, first started off with Charlie McElligott many weeks ago, was talking about the CTA pivot around that $1,290 level, give or take. But I've heard a number of different strategists talk about $1,290. To me, $1,290 is important because it's the 61.8% fib retrace off of the, uh, from the previous sell-off.
But what's interesting here is that in my mind, if gold is going to do a pullback the way Marin Katusa suggested in the interview, I would be highly suspicious of it failing here. But if gold continues this breakout above $1,290— and I, I, we haven't had an update from Charlie in a while on that level, we should get him back on the show sometime soon to sort of see where his thinking is on that But in my mind, if we beat $1,290, there could be a liquidity surge that drives us to the 2018 highs, which is all around that $1,350, $1,360 levels, or $1,370, sorry. And once we get up there, I'd find it hard-pressed to see gold go all the way back to $1,180. So, you know, for Marin Katusa's kind of scenario, I'd wanna see gold reject about this $1,290 level, and then maybe a retest of those lows would be something I could see.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Patrick Ceresna: What do you think of that?
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I guess the— as I heard you describing that, the one caveat that comes to my mind is if you think about what happened in 2008 when panic really struck, gold was immediately moving up. I could easily see us getting to about that, you know, 2018 high level, $1,360, $1,400, in there somewhere, before you get to the point where gold starts selling off with everything else because everybody's selling everything that isn't nailed down in order to raise cash. Now, that's if we get into a real crash kind of situation. We don't have those kind of market conditions yet. But look at all these indicators that we just talked about, and we'll get to copper in just a second, that are really telling us, hey, you know, something's up here. So I don't know.
Patrick Ceresna: There's no denying that in 2008, when the real liquidity event occurred in September, that gold got hammered from— I'm rounding— from $1,000 down to $700 an ounce during that sell-off. But what doesn't sit well with me with that narrative is the fact that in the 2 years prior to the peaks in 2008, gold was up several hundred percent. I mean, it was ripping from the $400 or $500 an ounce level and then rips to $1,000, and then it pulls back to $700. But the last 7 years of gold have been a bear market, and gold's been consolidating. It didn't have this massive rise that is being checked. I don't think gold is going to have as big of a drop. I mean, listen, we don't know the severity of a liquidity event. And I guess when— if the correlation of all assets can go to 1 if there's truly a liquidity event.
But I actually don't know if I subscribe to the view that gold's going to get super hammered this time around.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to crude oil on page 6. You're showing here, it looks like, you know, we did just test a bottom. And I agree with you, if I look at that range, it seems like it could be over here. I'm not dismissing that possibility. What do you think? I'm still leaning toward the possibility that we've still got lower to go.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And I don't think that that's the conclusion I wanted to draw on this chart. So, for our listeners that don't have the chart in front of them, what I did was here, I put the volume by price levels, which shows that on the weekly charts going back over the last 5 years, that there was a major consolidation of oil in this, let's say, $42 to $52 range. And what was interesting was that even in spite of spot prices back in 2015 going into 2016 dropping to $26 a barrel, the majority of the term structure of oil was very much in the mid-$40s. And oil had a very solid base here. And so we ripped down to what I view over the last 5 years to be a very important established support line. Now that in itself doesn't make me interested in buying it. To me, it's just maybe the downside risk is not remotely as severe anymore as when you owned it up in the '60s and '70s.
But that doesn't necessarily make it outright bullish. But what my view here, I think even if we see spot prices drop down below $40, which Marin and yourself might be right, I think that the term structure and longer-term oil is not going much lower here. What do you think of that view?
Erik Townsend: I think you're probably right there. Even when we saw $26 oil, that was with super steep contango. And the back end of the curve never really got substantially below 48 or so, and we're already very close to that.
Erik Townsend: So it'll be very interesting to see. But, you know, if you want to know where this market might be headed in terms of what macro signals we're seeing, let's move on to page number 7. Look at that break in copper. I mean, Dr. Copper is sending a pretty strong message here.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And this is a weekly chart on copper futures, and one of the interesting observations was that this kind of $2.50 to $3 range— I'm just rounding— was the most recent consolidation zone in copper. And we had a pretty nasty break this week in copper prices heading to a major consolidation level. And if we break lower from here, we haven't yet broken that major support around $2.50, but what will be interesting is that if we do, that ushers in a window that opens up back to the 2016 lows near $2 on copper. And would that not be the biggest advertisement of a global economic slowdown if we saw the copper prices follow through on this.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I couldn't agree more. And it's not just copper, it's bond yields, it's stocks, it's everything else. We're seeing across the board signs that 2019 is likely to be a very tumultuous year.
Erik Townsend: In any event, I want to move on. You have just published your 2019 predictions for Big Picture Trading members. For anyone who's not a member of Big Big Picture Trading, you can sign up for a free 7-day trial and gain access to Patrick's 2019 market predictions. Slide 8 in the slide deck tells you how to do that. In case you don't have the slide deck, just go to bigpicturetrading.com and look for the 7-day free trial on Patrick's services. Folks, we need your help promoting MacroVoices, so please tell your friends and colleagues about MacroVoices, forward your Research Roundup emails, and most importantly, sign up for your free account account at MacroVoices.com. It only takes a minute and we're never going to spam you or sell you anything.
What we will do is send you our free Research Roundup email each week, which never contains advertising or marketing. It's just a list of links to all of the best stuff that we could find free on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Marin, as well as a link to the Katusa report on Uranium Royalty Corp. There's also the chart book that Erik and I discussed in the postgame. There's an interesting article from Jeffrey Snider titled Mispriced Illusions and a great story on why global liquidity crashed again. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's research roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us Send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank Thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the. show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.