Mark Cudmore — Bloomberg Markets Live blog chief (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 178 was recorded August 1st, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the only podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, which I highly recommend. Bloomberg Markets Live blog chief Mark Cudmore joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss global and US growth trends, why Mark has turned bearish on the stock market, bond yield outlook, commodities, and much more. Be sure to stay tuned, though, for our postgame segment after the feature interview when former Dallas Fed insider Danielle DiMartino Booth joins us for extended FOMC coverage.

FOMC cut, Trump tariff tweet and the S&P 500

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's talk about this rollercoaster ride in the markets. Now, before we even get to the S&P 500, let's start with the bigger picture review of the major events that happened this week.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we had 2 really big market events this week, one widely anticipated, one not anticipated. So let's start with the widely anticipated event, obviously, was the FOMC statement, which came out on Wednesday afternoon. Now, it was already widely expected that they would cut 25 basis points. That's exactly what they did. No surprise there whatsoever.

The thing is, most people were thinking of this as the beginning of a new rate-cutting cycle. And Jay Powell went out of his way in the press conference to describe it as a mid-cycle adjustment, implying that it's not the beginning of a new cycle. It's, it's an adjustment in what perhaps is still a continuing rate hiking cycle. That's what spooked the market, and we got a nosedive in stock prices, much lower, very briefly touching that 2,960 or so level, very, very briefly, and then quickly bouncing back up to almost 3,000 level before the session was over. And then over the course of the day on Thursday, it seemed like we were almost completely retraced, well back above 3,000, everything's looking good, and then came the unexpected event, which was President Trump tweeting that they're going to effectively add a 10% tariff on the remaining $300 billion of goods and services coming from China into the United States.

So restarting the trade war effectively, and that caused a much more dramatic sell-off in markets on Thursday afternoon after President Trump's tweet.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to that S&P 500 to really kind of get what a roller coaster ride. Again, like the S&P 500 starts off with the first reaction to Powell's comments just with a dump to the downside. We were almost down to 2950 on the downside. Then suddenly a huge morning rally. And then came the Trump tweet and we were basically as high as just, you know, around 3010. And then we find ourselves just wiping out 50, 60 S&P points in a span of a couple hours. What's going on here?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, it is no surprise to me whatsoever that the knee-jerk reaction down in reaction to the FOMC statement had retraced almost completely less than 24 hours after it had happened. That didn't surprise me at all. So I thought we were frankly headed back toward new all-time highs. Now, in the past, President Trump making statements or tweets or whatever that seemed to restart trade wars have had a much more severe and longer-lasting impact on markets. So what's happened is we've come down now to the point where, as we're still about 15 minutes before the close as we're recording this segment, we are just barely teetering right on 2960 on the S&P. That is Nomura's number for where they believe if we see a daily close below 2960, it could beget more selling from algorithmic traders, CTAs particularly, who trade on algorithmic models. So it's It's going to be really interesting to see what happens next.

I think what's probably going on here, big picture, is President Trump is looking for the setup to say, okay, he's got things like the trade war, which he's probably wanted to do for a long time, but, you know, he didn't want to crash the stock market coming into election season.

Well, this is what I think he saw as an opportunity, if he's going to take policy action like tariffs on China, that he was going to do it right after the FOMC meeting so that he could blame any market reaction on the FOMC rather than his own policy actions.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: So, I think that's probably what motivated the timing here. In any case, it's going to be very interesting to see whether we bounce back from this or if it starts another wave down. Think about the last time we had a re-escalation of trade wars. It led to, what, a couple hundred points down in the S&P into that Christmas event. So, anything's possible here.

US Dollar: break above 98 and Fed-independence risk

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to the US Dollar.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, what we saw was a very clear break above 98, the exact event that we've been waiting for on this program. We've talked about quite a bit bit, and that came in reaction to the Fed using language to portray their rate cut, which was expected, as not being the beginning of a new rate-cutting cycle. We saw it really take off today before President's tweet. We were at, I think it was 98.60 or something, really just taking off to the upside. And I think that by itself, that was the indication to me that we were headed towards 104 on the Dollar Index. It's the breakout we've been waiting for. I thought this was coming. But you know what, when we saw that tweet, it caused everything to bounce back, and I don't think that this action around trade policy is really going to make a big difference. I think the retracement that we saw was a buying opportunity, and I bought more dollar index futures on the dip this afternoon.

But the thing is, Patrick, don't underestimate that outlier possibility of President Trump acting independently from the Fed. The president actually tweeted a news interview, a video interview, Where a commentator was describing a desire to end the Federal Reserve, abolish the Federal Reserve, and not have it anymore. Why is the president tweeting that? Is he just angry, or is he actually trying to signal an intention to really take things into his own hands and work around the Federal Reserve? That would definitely completely destroy my whole dollar bullish theory if President Trump were to directly intervene in FX markets and try to circumvent or undermine the Federal Reserve's independence by taking monetary policy into his own hands. That could cause a major loss of confidence globally. I think it would be a very bad thing for the country, but it's not out of the realm of possibility.

Barring that, I think we move much higher on the dollar from here, but that would be the risk.

Crude oil: EIA draw and 7-8% selloff

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's talk crude oil because that's where the biggest move has been. We're down about 7, 8% right now. What's, what's your thinking here on crude?

Erik Townsend: Well, let's start with the EIA inventory numbers. Crude oil drew down 8.5 million barrels. That's a massive, massive drawdown against analyst expectations of about a 2.5 million barrel drawdown. So massive miss there. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 1.5 million barrels and finished products also drawdowns across the board. Gasoline down 1.8 million barrels, distillates down 894,000 barrels.

Obviously, that would normally be a super bullish fundamental indication for crude oil prices. The tape reaction was an instantaneous pop up in prices, but it didn't last. It only lasted a couple of minutes.

We closed down on the day. U.S. production was back up to 12.2 million barrels. That's a huge difference from last week. So it confirmed that last week was really just a hurricane anomaly. The thing that's really interesting, though, imports 6.7 million barrels. Exports were 2.6, only 18 million barrels on the week. So where did that 8.5 million barrels go if production was back up to 12.2 million barrels? So there's no shortfall there, and exports are only 2.6 million barrels, which is not a big number for exports compared to recent history. Then what caused the drawdown? Where did that oil go? We talked about this in some detail in Energy Week. So for anybody who's interested, listen to yesterday's Energy Week episode for more discussion on that topic.

In any event, the market already looked Pretty weak this afternoon, Patrick, before President Trump's tweet came out. It looked like we were going to have a daily close below the short-term moving averages, which might signal the beginning of a new downtrend. But it was kind of close. Then came President Trump's tweet, and suddenly I think crude oil got hit harder than anything else. It was down more than 8% at one point during the day. I think by the close it was 7-point-something percent. Massive, massive down day. And it's going to be very interesting to see how this whole trade war thing plays out. But I don't think it's that trade wars are that much more impacting on oil than other markets. I think it was oil was ready for a catalyst to take it lower.

Gold and the dollar: retest risk

Patrick Ceresna: What's your thinking here on gold? I mean, that rebounded pretty quickly here after selling on Powell's comments.

Erik Townsend: Let's start with the roller coaster of the last 2 days and then zoom back out to the big picture. Gold was looking great before the FOMC press statement came out, and it seemed as if what was happening was we had the resolution to the symmetric triangle pattern, short-term symmetrical triangle. It had broken up, it came back down, it touched that trendline as support a couple of times, and it was starting to gradually move higher. Everything looked great. Then came the FOMC, and all of a sudden it really looked to me like gold was getting ready to tank on the much, much higher breakout on the US dollar. So we see the US Dollar Index breaking out above 98, very quickly moving through 98.50. Looks like we were headed toward 99, might have even gotten there today, and all of a sudden And then all of a sudden, the Trump tweet comes out and that reversed everything. That caused gold to be up upwards of $35 in just a couple of minutes.

And that's a combination of geopolitical risk as well as the downside to the dollar. The real question, I think, is what happens next with the dollar.

Let's assume that I'm right about the dollar and we don't see President Trump really take things into his own hands and circumvent the Federal Reserve as the nation's central bank, as we talked about earlier. Let's assume that does not happen. And the dollar moves much higher. Then we need to get out to the big picture of possibilities. If we see the dollar move higher and gold move lower, it's a really big question in my mind. I think that, for sure, if the dollar moves much higher aggressively, as I think it will if President Trump doesn't stop that from happening, we could see lots and lots of downside. But frankly, I won't be surprised if it just is the catalyst to get us back down to a retest of the breakout zone around $1,350 to $1,376.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: And then further upside from there. The other possibility is that gold just keeps on going up from here, and we've moved into that regime that we've been predicting for years on this program, which is we eventually get to gold and the US dollar moving up together at the same time.

Now, that sounds like great cause for celebration for traders, but frankly, that's a sign of things getting really scary. It means that there is a It's a double safety trade going on where people are moving into US dollars and into gold as safe haven assets, and it means that faith in the global economic system is deteriorating. So, if we're already moving into that regime that I didn't think we were ready for yet, it really makes me concerned about how other things are going. It's going to be very, very interesting to watch this correlation between gold and the dollar in coming weeks. I'm going to have Brent Johnson back on an All-Stars appearance next week to talk about this very issue. Okay.

10-year Treasury yields fall below 2%

Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's talk those 10-year Treasury yields because we are now decisively below 2%. What's going on?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, we came back down to 2.01 on the Fed news, and this morning we'd actually bounced very decisively. I think it was 2.05, 2.06, and it seemed like maybe we were headed higher in yield. Needless to say, President Trump's tweet was utterly devastating. We're actually looking at 1.89 just coming into the close at 4 o'clock on Thursday afternoon. So holy cow, I guess I missed I missed the opportunity. I was hoping to buy the dip. I thought we'd get back up to maybe a 2.20% yield or something, and if that had happened, I would have been buying. I missed the boat on that one, and it'll be interesting to see how much this continues and how far the trade war situation escalates from here.

Hot Topics Malmgren episode, ad agencies and why Cudmore is the guest

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, well, thanks for the update. Now, before we move on to this week's feature interview with Mark Cudmore, we're pleased to announce that we'll be releasing a second feature interview this week with another guest Erik, what led to this development?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I was talking to Dr. Pippa Malmgren when we recorded her All-Stars episode that aired last Friday. She, of course, lives in London now with her daughter, and her dad, Hal Malmgren, who lives in the United States normally, walked into the room at the end of the thing and said hi. And suddenly we just had this opportunity, and impromptu we recorded a double interview with both Dr. Harold Malmgren, Pippa's father, And Pippa Malmgren. So the setting here is the 14-year-old is cooking dinner. We have Hal Malmgren, who was an advisor to 4 US presidents. That was Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon, and Ford. And Dr. Pippa Malmgren, of course, has been an advisor to 2 US presidents. I kind of channeled my, my internal Jesse Felder and took a completely different approach. Instead of talking about markets, I got to ask Hal Malmgren how it feels as a father to both have been a presidential advisor himself versus watching his daughter follow in his footsteps.

And what was that experience like to see his daughter become a presidential advisor as well? Something I don't think anybody else in history has ever been able to say, that they advised multiple presidents and then their daughter went on to advise multiple US presidents.

So it was a very, very interesting interview. We didn't know what to do with it because it made a great full-length feature interview for a Thursday night MacroVoices podcast. And we've just got a really full schedule already with fantastic guests right through Labor Day. So when I told our sponsor, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen over at Top Traders Unplugged, about this, he said, look, if it's more Pippa, I'll sponsor it. And so we're going to air this as a Hot Topics episode, which we're going to bring you on Sunday this weekend. So look forward to that in your MacroVoices feed. And my thanks go out to our friends at Top Traders Unplugged for stepping up and making it possible.

I also want to take this opportunity to announce that we are now welcoming ad agencies to represent us. We really appreciate the listenership. Who've tried to help put us in touch with their companies who might make sponsors. We still want you to do that if you can help us in that regard, but it hasn't led to enough leads to really get the sponsorship we need to make all of our MacroVoices content free for listeners indefinitely. So we do welcome ad agencies to contact us. We're paying 15%, not 50%. We were born at night, but not last night, guys. But please reach out to us at info@macrovoices.com if you want to talk about representing us on a non-exclusive basis.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Bloomberg's Mark Cudmore. Now, Erik, why did we invite Mark back to the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Mark heads up the Bloomberg Markets Live blog, which is only available to people who have the Bloomberg Terminal service, so it's basically just institutional investors. But it's a very, very highly respected blog, and he's got a lot of perspective. Mark was a just steadfast bull last time we talked to him. I think it was close to 18 months ago on the program. Turned secularly bearish this spring, and I wanted to get his perspective as to what's changed his mind and his outlook on markets generally. So I think it was a great interview. It was taped before the FOMC statement, so we don't have the benefit of knowing about the roller coaster ride that was coming, but it's still an excellent perspective on markets generally.

Erik Townsend: And this episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. You often hear me say on the program that even if I have conviction about a market or trade, you have to listen to what the market is telling you, not what you think it should be doing, but what it is doing.

And that's exactly what trend-following managers have been doing for decades with great success. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well researched and tested. And there's one podcast that covers trend-following strategies better than any other. TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book called The Many Flavors of Trend Following, explaining exactly how these systematic strategies can work for you. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro.

Check them out, you'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Mark Cudmore is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here on MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Global growth and the collapse in trade

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Mark Cudmore, the global managing editor for Bloomberg's Markets Live blog. Mark, it's great to have you back on. I'm going to have to apologize to you because the last time we had you on We recorded your interview on an FOMC week before the FOMC meeting, so we didn't have the benefit of knowing the outcome. We learned a lesson and we promised ourselves we would never do that again. And it's you that we did it to again. So I apologize, and I'll ask our listeners to understand that Mark and I don't know, because we taped this ahead of time, what the outcome will be from the FOMC. But let's go ahead and dive in and start with the The global growth outlook for the global economy. My view is that we're seeing awfully strong slowing signs, but a lot of people have different views.

What's the big picture? How do you see this economy?

Mark Cudmore: I'm completely with you. And I think actually what's important to emphasize is that I'm not really sure that it matters too much that we're recording this before the Fed this week. I think that I do share your slightly more worried picture around the global growth outlook. I think that this is already set to be— well, we know it's already set to be the slowest growth in 3 years. But I think that the growth outlook will actually turn much worse towards the second half of the year. And I don't think that the Fed, no matter what they do, is going to change the story that much. Ultimately, we know from history that the Fed has a very poor ability to kind of change the economic cycle. They can kind of change the timing, alter it, but they can't stop a recession when it comes. And I think it's important to emphasize that the last 2 recessions that we saw in this century, we did see rate cuts come before the recession, but they didn't stop the recession coming.

So in September 2007, they cut by 25 basis points. Recession still started in December that year. And in January 2001, the Fed cut by 50 basis points. The recession still came starting in March that year. And I think in both those cycles, the Fed had more than 500 basis points to cut. In fact, they did cut at least 500 basis points in both economic cycles, both easing cycles. And yet it didn't stop the recession. Obviously, the Fed doesn't have that kind of ammo this time. And the transmission mechanism is even more impaired after years of QE. So the Fed was already poor at turning the economic cycle around even before QE, even when it had lots of ammo. Now it has neither the ammo and the transmission mechanism is broken. So I think that the global growth outlook is looking quite worrying. You know, we last spoke in April 2018, so 17 months ago. It's actually interesting to note that JPMorgan's Global Manufacturing Index has declined in every single month since then, which is quite a good track record.

And the preliminary PMIs from July almost guarantee we'll be in contraction. for the 3rd consecutive month when those numbers are released, I think the day this podcast will be published. So the collapse in global trade is really kind of impairing things. And I think that's kind of very important at the moment.

You just— as a summary of this situation, there's so many different metrics to look at this collapse in global trade. I don't think anyone disputes it. You can do clever things like look at FedEx earnings or any kind of number of indicators.

To me, I like looking at 2 of the kind of the world's best broad indicators. And that's Germany, which accounts for roughly 12% of global trade, and Singapore, the trade hub for Asia. So Germany 2019 GDP forecast has collapsed from 1.9% this day a year ago to 0.7% now. So it's quite an extraordinary kind of downgrade. And all the risks remain to the downside. The most recent IFO Business Expectations Index has dropped to the worst level in a decade. And at least a decade ago, it was on the way back up. Now it's actually on the way back down. It was on the way back up in the crisis back then. We're going back into another crisis, I think, but a more minor crisis. The most recent manufacturing PMI at 43.1 in Germany Germany suggests a recession is likely coming there, or it's certainly a high risk. And the manufacturing PMI has actually been in contraction territory all year. So Germany is not only the most important economy in Europe, but it's also so dependent on trade.

So it's a great broad measure, and it looks like it's heading for a recession.

So I struggle to overlook that signal, and especially when that's combined with what's happening in Singapore, where I live. Electronic exports, most recent reading, have seen more than 30% annualized decline, and that's for 2 consecutive months. We've not actually seen that kind of drawdown since the crisis again is quite incredible. Singapore is such an open economy, it really captures what's going on in Asia. I think that both the trade hub in Asia and the trade hub in Europe are showing this collapse. Now, there's not the same trade hub which matches up quite so well in North America because America is a little bit— US is a little bit more closed economy, but Mexico is the closest. As we know, the Mexican economy is in absolute dire straits as well. I think we're getting a very consistent message there. Just to emphasize this, the high frequency data is showing that this kind of slowdown we've seen is ongoing.

So the advance estimate, for example, for 2Q GDP in Singapore came in at -3.4% versus +0.5% expected. That's the worst quarterly reading since 2012. But all the high-frequency data like retail sales, industrial output, and PMIs suggest that contraction is ongoing. So there's clear problems for all the big trade indicators. I'm very worried about global growth that's primarily based on a manufacturing and trade situation. And so the outlook is definitely more negative than it's been for many, many years for me.

US growth, tariffs, trade war and recession timing

Erik Townsend: Now, Mark, I think the story on global growth, I mean, it's undeniable. It blows my mind that anybody could disagree. But in the case of US growth, I'm also thinking the US is not immune. Some people seem to think the US is somehow not going to be subject to all the same forces that everybody else is feeling. What's your take on US growth?

Mark Cudmore: So it's interesting you say that because, like, obviously there are these scary signs for the world's best trade indicators. And then you combine that with the message that we're getting from manufacturing. And I think that the optimism around the US is actually particularly misplaced. It's not that suddenly the US is going to have the worst growth in the world. It's that it's there that people are most in denial about what's happening. And I think not looking possibly ahead to how some of these indicators are going to play out. And they're taking a very optimistic kind of outlook. I like applying Occam's razor, which is, you know, make the least number of assumptions as possible. And I think many people's optimism is based on a number of things which don't look likely.

One is, of course, the US-China trade war being resolved. I think that's kind of particularly misplaced. So, you know, as I mentioned, the trade, the manufacturing is a problem. But for the US, particularly as the decline in the CapEx in the US will probably accelerate by the end of the 3rd quarter, just as the lagged impact of May's tariffs hit. So we saw that last year that the tariffs kind of came in in the summer, but we really saw the economic impact towards the kind of 4th quarter. And I think this year we've again seen the tariffs about a month or so earlier, and we'll probably see them towards the end of the 3rd quarter is when we'll start seeing the economic impact. And that's because there's like a little bit of front-loading, and there's just kind of delay in kind of adjusting business supply chains, etc.

Also, the guidance from US corporates in the past few weeks has made clear that 3rd quarter is likely to see earnings shrink for the first time probably since December 2015, which we seem to be ignoring because 2Q earnings are holding up okay, even though most of them came before the tariffs were in place.

So companies are going to get hit directly on the profit side, just as the economy is getting hit. And that's going to be a double whammy on CapEx to kind of help accelerate the end of the cycle. And I do think that's— this is Very much contingent, I will say. Like my bearish outlook, I don't think matters too much on on the Fed meeting this week and the guidance, as I mentioned. But it does matter a lot on the U.S.-China trade war. I don't see a resolution coming anytime soon in that, and I think if if I'm very wrong in that, if we do get a resolution which removes all tariffs, and I think it's important to emphasize the resolution needs to remove tariffs, not just call a peace. If we don't get something that removes tariffs, then I think the situation will be much worse.

And I think it's it's important to to emphasize that the the view on the trade war. Well, speaking in the US, I was in New York a few weeks ago talking to a lot of investors, and the view on the trade war in Asia is very divergent.

In the US, it's very much seen that it's entirely Trump's decision and that Trump will want a deal with China before the election in 2020, therefore to boost the economy. And therefore, because that will suit him, ultimately there will be a deal. I think the view in Asia is that since May, that's massively changed. Up until May, that was true. China wanted a deal as well. They were really downplaying the trade war domestically, and they were kind of happy happy to make some kind of peace with Trump, especially since they're going through their domestic deleveraging campaign. But what's actually happened since May is that the narrative onshore has completely changed. So rather than ignoring the trade war, kind of downplaying it, they've actually hyped it up quite a bit in the domestic press. And they now no longer can be seen to not get a win out of this. I mean, there's been reference back to the Opium War treaties of the mid-19th century, so going back 150 years, which kind of shows the timescale they're thinking of.

They're not thinking on election cycles. They don't need to think of election cycles.

Xi Jinping seems to have been given the message quite clearly from the Standing Committee of the Politburo, you must get a win out of this in some way. Obviously, there's many ways that both sides can sell whatever agreement as a win, and I realize that's a situation that can be fudged, but it's not that neither side can be seen to concede completely. Certainly, Trump has bipartisan support for a hard line on China in the US, even if maybe not his exact tactics. It's not something— and he's made it such a big part of his campaign that he's taking a hard line there. It's not something that he's going to concede publicly completely on. And I think likewise, China, while they might be able to, you know, convey the message in a certain way domestically, again, they cannot concede completely. So I think a deal is going to be very hard on US-China. And Trump even said this recently, that China may want to wait till after the election.

I do think that, you know, there's been some slightly better data in the US recently, but I do think that the focus is on the wrong things.

So people keep on pointing to unemployment as proof that the US economy is, uh, is doing wonderfully and the Fed shouldn't be cutting rates. I find this completely bizarre because Kind of one of the things you learn very early on in economics is that unemployment is a lagging indicator. And I think it's worth kind of pointing to what happened in the last 3 recessions as an example. So in 2007, unemployment had only risen from the 4.4% cycle low to 5% before the recession started. Unemployment obviously peaked at 10% in that cycle. So most of the pain came after the recession. Again, in 2001, unemployment had only risen from 3.8% to 4.3% before the recession started. It peaked at 6.3%. In 1990, unemployment had risen from 5% to 5.5%.

5.5% pre-recession. It peaked at 7.8%. So generally, there's been about a 0.5% climb in unemployment from cycle low before the recession officially starts. Of course, we don't get confirmation that the recession has started until many months later. So that will kind of tally with a recession starting around when unemployment hits 4.1% in this cycle. I mean, that's easily possible by end of this year, early next, which is when I think that we may get close enough to a recession starting in the US, probably maybe December or January type period. Obviously, these things are very hard I can't predict very exactly, but that's kind of my rough base case.

I should emphasize that there's a chance we might avoid a technical recession of 2 quarters of negative growth, but I do think it'll be close enough to recession in terms of severe impact on markets, which is what I care about most.

Structural bear on US equities

Erik Townsend: Well, let's move on to what you care about most then and talk about markets. Why don't we start specifically with US equities?

Mark Cudmore: Yeah, sure. I think this is probably where I've got the most interesting view. I think when I've been on with you before, I've been on in a good period and for markets in a bad period. And both times, I've really emphasized that I've been a deep structural bull for many, many years. I can't actually remember the last time I was a structural bear in US equities, but it was at least 2011. I did stay too bearish after the last cycle. I can't remember when I finally learned my lesson of what QE was doing to the system. But now, for the first time since at least 2011, I'm a structural bear on US equities. I think the timing of that decline is hard, but I guess I'd phrase it that up until now, for the last many years, years, I've had periods of being tactically bullish, tactically bearish, but I've always been in the mindset of ultimately, you're buying the dip.

It's just a change of how low you buy the dip. And I think it's now the mindset of— now, I think ultimately, you're selling the rally, but exactly where you sell the rally, I don't know. And that's what I'm trying to work out.

I do think that the sell-off starts imminently, but I would have said that to you a month ago and obviously been wrong because we're at record highs. But I think it starts by September latest, maybe October at the very latest. But really, I'd be surprised if it hasn't started by September, because by then, we'll have had the bad data from August, which is when the tariff impact will really start starting to hit properly. And it'll also, in my theory, be likely clear by then that US and China aren't removing tariffs soon. And then what happens is we'll see economic forecasts get slashed, and then we'll see earnings forecasts get slashed. We're seeing the earnings guidance come a lot lower over this earnings season already. But I think that we'll see Wall Street really react to the fact that the economic forecasts are getting slashed everywhere.

So the S&P 500 is trading at 17.2 times blended forward earnings, 12-month forward earnings. That's versus the 10-year average of 15. Now, if it's very expensive, there's a massive premium. Now, we all know that these things can stay expensive for a long period of time, but it just means that it's vulnerable if the narrative changes. Corporates are healthy. They've got like a good profit margin, and that makes it particularly hard to call a top. But I just will emphasize the narrative can turn very quickly if just one part of that jigsaw changes. People will go, whoa, suddenly that price looks weird. And I think that if you look at that forward P/E of 17.2, if the denominator gets cut there, earnings get cut, which we're seeing, we're starting to see, and we'll see that happen more from Wall Street in the next couple of months, then even without a price change, they start looking more and more expensive.

So ultimately, we're probably going to see price to come down a lot to make that P/E look normal. And then it'll probably overshoot, as it always does in these situations. Importantly, that impressive margin story is starting to be unwound at the— I guess at the margin, to excuse the pun.

We're seeing estimates revised down for the 3rd quarter, 4th quarter, and 1st quarter 2020. But bizarrely, we still expect an impressive rebound in 2020. Why is that? Well, the index estimates for 2020 are based on steady revenue gains and strong improvement in cyclical sectors such as technology and industrials. I find that very bizarre given that what we're seeing on the trade front and the economy front, it could be true, but it does look like at the moment that those index estimates for 2020 of double-digit kind of gains in earnings again are just wildly optimistic. And I just don't see what narrative they're based on. Actually, I can tell you what narrative they're based on. They're based on that US and China will definitely have a grand deal which kind of accelerates trade by early next year. And that is the narrative they're based on. And the Fed's expected easing, however much they do in the next few months, will kind of successfully restimulate the economy like the late '90s kind of insurance cycles in '96, '98.

I think it's bizarre that everyone seems to have convinced themselves that the Fed cut this time will be just like the insurance cuts of '96, '98. It's clearly possible. I find it bizarre that's the base case given that the 2 most recent easing cycles, as I said, didn't stop deep recession.

recessions and didn't stop, both in the coordinating with the recession in the early 2000s and the one in 2007, 2008. Both times the S&P lost more than 50%. I'm not sure we're going to get quite that big a dip this time, but something to be aware of.

Growth, earnings and liquidity pillars

Erik Townsend: Well, Mark, I couldn't possibly agree with you more that US equities are overvalued here, overpriced at these levels. But I've thought that for more than a year, and that hasn't caused the market to give up. And so I'd like to kind of play devil's advocate and run a couple of thoughts by you. One of the reasons is I struggle to figure out how the heck we got back to all-time highs.

Mark Cudmore: Okay.

Erik Townsend: You know, if you look at just the mechanics of what's been driving this market, it seems that corporate buybacks have played a huge role. And hey, if we're going to see Treasury yields continue to move lower, meaning cheaper, easier money for buying back your stock, that potentially propels the market higher.

There's also a view that a couple of our guests, Brent Johnson in particular, has expressed, which is, you know, things are going to get so bad for Europe and other parts of the world, and they're already at negative yielding Treasuries, so their safety trade can't really be into Treasuries as is the usual deal. They've got to look for something else, and maybe US equities end up benefiting from an international safety trade, and that propels the market higher. Now, I don't mean to suggest that I think the market should go higher, but since it hasn't been doing what I think it should be doing for quite a while now, what do you think about those scenarios as potentially frustrating our mutual view that the market ought to be moving lower?

Mark Cudmore: Great question. And actually, I love these kind of questions because obviously all the time what I want to do is kind of find out what I'm missing. So, I think I'll just say the context, and I'm not trying to be annoying to you, but I was staunchly a structural bull until May this year. And I think for me, always believed that we'd keep on going back to record highs. And I was very dismissive of previous concerns. And I think it's important to emphasize that backdrop just because I'm going to explain what's changed.

So for me, what kind of drove the rally before then were 3 pillars I used to refer to them, and that was growth, earnings, and liquidity. So like economic growth, earnings, good earnings, and liquidity in the system. Now, you've talked about the corporate buybacks being a really important part of the story. And I think that kind of comes into the liquidity thing. I'm probably going to come to that last because that's probably the most nuanced. So I think, first of all, one of the pillars is that global growth has been kind of subdued but absolutely fine for years. And as I explained kind of in the first part, I do think that kind of global growth picture is going to get severely downgraded largely because this trade war and just because we're at the end of the kind of economic cycle and then that CapEx deceleration.

So I think that growth is one pillar that's about to be taken out by the end of this year. The second pillar is earnings. Now, we've come off an incredible earnings period, you know, both internally in companies. We're making a lot of structural changes and then just technology help. But then, of course, we had the stimulus that came through the U.S. US, the tax cuts. So we've had a massive boost in earnings. And again, as I said, the earnings picture is changing very drastically. It turned out we didn't quite get, I think, negative earnings in first quarter this year. And I think second quarter we're going to be again slightly positive, but they're still massively down in the last couple of years already. The earnings outlook is less positive, but it's not been taken out yet. Now, the estimates show that third quarter is likely to be, as I said, the first negative earnings quarter for the S&P 500 since December 2015.

So suddenly that's the second pillar taken out. So 2 of the pillars have been taken out. Now, the third one is liquidity. There's clearly abundant liquidity in the system. And central banks are still overall pumping a lot of cash into the system. One of the favorite things I love pointing out, it doesn't matter too much about quantitative tightening. We discussed this actually a year and a half ago that the Fed is only the 4th most relevant central bank in the world when it comes to providing liquidity. The ECB, the PBOC, and the BOJ all have balance sheets around $5.3 trillion roughly, whereas the Fed's balance sheet is now around $3.8 trillion. So they're just like, they're 30% or nearly 30% bigger than the Fed. Each of them is nearly 30% bigger than the Fed. So I think that overall, we've got a lot of liquidity in the system. But it's interesting, if you take their combined balance sheets, the peak in central bank balance sheets was actually in March 2018.

So I think that's quite interesting to note. So we had a whole decade going up to March 2018 where central bank balance sheets just kept on growing, and they kept on pumping more liquidity into the system. So that was something that suddenly changed. So the firehose liquidity has been turned off. It's not coming massively lower, but it is a bit lower. Importantly, PBOC, probably the most relevant one, did peak out in March 2018. But the PBOC, ECB, and Fed all have smaller balance sheets today than they did then in dollar terms. The BOJ is the only one that's increased. So liquidity has suddenly stopped being pumped into the system. And as we, we know, it's very important in markets. It's the, it's the kind of second derivative. It's the rate of change. It's not necessarily the nominal level that matters so much.

I also think that the liquidity situation around corporate buybacks in particular can change very rapidly. So one of the things, the structural things that's happened in the markets since the crisis amid the regulation, is that liquidity in the credit market is incredibly impaired. And this is not a novel idea. Many people have warned about this. Many of the biggest credit buyers have warned this. Many of the biggest issuers have warned this.

So, you know, Bank of America, I believe they're some of the biggest kind of issuers of leveraged finance, and they've kind of warned about the liquidity in the system. PIMCO, for example, have warned about it. So, you know, many of these big names have warned that there's a liquidity problem there, and that's because banks can no longer be the middleman to kind of step in and provide a break in the system when things go wrong.

So the reason I kind of explain all this is credit's obviously pricing very tightly at the moment. There's this hunt for yield, etc. But that situation can change much more rapidly than it could 10, 12 years ago. The last crisis was a credit crisis. I was working in Lehman Brothers at the time, so I saw it from a front row seat.

Yet the liquidity couldn't disappear as quickly as it can now. I think that we've— as I said, there's 3 pillars that were driving the rally, and that's why I've been a structural bull for many years. Suddenly, I think in the 4th quarter of this year, we're going to have the growth pillar taken out. We're going to have the earnings pillar taken out in the 3rd quarter. And I think that the 3rd pillar of liquidity is no longer as dominant and strong as it once was. And it can actually quickly turn negative in practical purposes for companies if we get a bit more of a negative view. So if the credit cycle starts turning, it could turn much more negative very quickly. And I think that's where you get your little bit of a mini financial crisis. And I should emphasize, I'm not calling for a repeat of the great financial crisis or the global financial crisis of 2008, but just like a bit more risk-averse environment.

I think that that's the point to emphasize.

I think the final point you made is good in that, like, hey, if the whole world's in a bad place, where do you put money? Do you keep on putting it into European negative yields? I think that, as I said, if the credit cycle turns, there's a lot of leverage in the system. Suddenly, that actually, a lot of it just happens in deleveraging. Suddenly, people start cutting down. There's less need for this money to find a home if we do get that credit blowup, which causes deleveraging. I think that's the thing.

First point to emphasize that you can just get this wealth destruction like we see in every recession, like we see in every crisis. This is, again, not a particularly novel idea, but because we haven't seen one in more than 10 years, people can't always think about it or remember it. So we just get that generally de-wealthing effect. But I also say that one of, I guess, my central theories is that US has outperformed for the last 4 or 5 years for many valid reasons.

And I think that era of outperformance in the US is coming to an end or is at an end, essentially. And I think that obviously, US is still the world's largest economy. So if it goes through a bad period, everywhere is going to suffer. But I think that it's unlikely to pick up as quickly afterwards. And I think that there's many markets in the world, probably more in emerging markets, that will suffer that initial pain when the US catches a cold. But they won't suffer such prolonged pain, and where there's much better opportunities.

And I think you talk about where can you put money. There's not always liquidity. But many emerging markets do offer much higher real yields, are structurally much safer. They're much less deleveraged. Many of them do not have the external vulnerabilities They don't have the same financial instabilities they did have a few years ago. The currencies are super cheap. I mean, these are just incredible fundamental stories longer term. Of course, emerging markets are higher beta. So if US equity market suddenly is going to sell off 20% plus in the next year, then obviously emerging markets are going to have periods of pain, but it won't be lasting pain. There will be opportunities there. And I think that's what you'll see. You'll see money coming out of US equities and looking for opportunities elsewhere in the world.

Fed cuts and currency-war risk

Erik Townsend: I want to just push back a little bit on your final pillar of liquidity. We had a view from Danielle DiMartino Booth, a former Fed insider, Earlier this week on MacroVoices, and she said, "Look, the thing to watch for at this FOMC is what everybody does is they shift gears from everybody's anticipating the meeting to focusing on what's going to come next." She said the question you have to ask is: Is this this is going to be the Fed's assuming that that you and I both have the same assumption, which is by the time our listeners hear this interview, there will have been a 25 basis point cut. That will be. the first Fed rate cut in more than a decade. Is that the opening shot in what becomes essentially a currency war that's going to cause all the other central banks to pile in and say, no, no, no, no, no, we're going to ease just as much. We're not going to let you get ahead of us.

And you potentially get into a competitive devaluation kind of situation. Are we headed in that direction or could we be?

Mark Cudmore: In theory, yes. In practice, I think A, those rate cuts are already priced almost everywhere, and most of the rest of the world, they can't go much lower. So, you know, we've gone from a situation in November last year where almost every central bank in the world was pricing hikes ahead, and quite a lot of hikes. And now we're suddenly in a world where, in fact, every central bank is pricing cuts, and some of them are ahead of the curve.

Look, we've already got, you know, bank RBA has already cut rates a couple of times, and, you know, it's already pricing in rates getting to half percent. And ECB is pricing even more deeply negative rates. Same for SNB. Bank of Japan is something somehow, you know, pricing in the idea of more easing. I mean, it seems frankly unbelievable. These countries that are already negative, deeply negative, are pricing in more easing.

So they can't do much more. And importantly, they can't do loads more than is priced. And I think this is one of the most important things about the Fed, about, again, you know, having been so positive earlier on this year. And like when, when January, when the Fed turned dovish and people were like, oh my God, what does that say about the economy? And I was like, hey, wait a sec, they surprised dovishly. This is only a good thing for equities. This should see equities roar in the next few months. The difference is now is it's hard for them to have that kind of dovish surprise impact.

We're already pricing in the Fed, you know, making 2.5 rate cuts by year end.

Yes, they still have a little bit of extra ammo to deliver more. Like we need to price in the fact that they, you know, they're going to cut probably 200 basis points in this cycle, ultimately 225 basis points in the cycle. So there's more to kind of price in, but it's not easy. It suddenly changed. Look, it's only a few months ago that we were pricing in rate hikes and then it was very easy to surprise.

Now that the 2-year kind of the shift in the 2-year yields has just been frankly incredible. And so I think that in theory, it's right. The Fed will cut 25 basis points, and then other central banks will soon follow, or some of them have actually got ahead. It's not even following. This is a general theme.

And I don't necessarily like the idea of currency war. These are people enacting monetary policy. And yes, currency is one side effect of that. I'm not sure they're directly targeting the currency. But there's only so much they can do, and most of what they can do is priced. So yeah, there's a little bit of positive support to come in on that front over the next year or so. But I think if we get to a world where we're pricing in the Fed cutting the full, you know, 225 basis points to get back to 25 basis points upper bound, then in that world, we're already in a super negative world. We only get into that world when equities have already sold off 25%. So I don't think that kind of negates the view. No.

Treasuries: no bond bear market

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to Treasuries. You know, a lot of smart people thought once you go past 3.10%, it's all over, secular bear market in Treasuries. And of course, we've seen the opposite. What has been the primary driver in your mind of this reversal?

Mark Cudmore: And does Treasuries, I've got a mixed one for you. I don't have super strong short-term views at these levels. I think it's very hard at these levels. I think it's one where— every time I'm going to go on this podcast, I'm not shy of my views. I'm going to get some things right, some things wrong. And the Treasuries one is one I got right last time in terms that I said to you— we were in April last year, and I said that I thought— I said I did not believe in the bond bear market at all. I was not believing that risk at all. And I think it was a big theme at the time because yields were just touching towards 3% for the first time in years, and everyone was going, this is it. And many people had called to the start of the big bond bear market.

And my theory at the time was that just because we're ending the 30-year bond bull market doesn't mean we need to go into the next long-term bond bear market. And the reason I'm repeating this is because the views haven't changed. So at the time, I said, look, I thought the top end of the range for 10-year Treasuries would probably be about 3.2%. I think in November, 6 months later or 7 months later after our podcast, it eventually reached 3.24%. But that was around the top. And my whole argument at the time was, A, we have structural disinflation, which I just think is completely underestimated, both from technology, not just through the Amazon effect, But also just because the extraction, production, and distribution of commodities is continuously getting much cheaper. And that's also the main input for prices. And also, you have the demographic effect. So we've had massive asset price inflation, but that does not feed through to the necessarily consumer price inflation basket.

So I think that people are understating those structural disinflationary impacts on consumer price inflation.

And therefore, I did not see inflation being a threat. And therefore, I did not believe that we're going to see kind of Treasury yields go too high. And especially because last year when we spoke, I didn't know that March 2018 was going to be the peak of central bank balance sheets. I was very much in the camp last April that there's just endless liquidity in the system that's still being added. As long as there's all that liquidity in the system, they're going to continue to buy yields when they get too high. That worked out in the past. I'm emphasizing that because at this point now, I'm struggling to have these views. I do actually believe that 10-year yields ultimately are going to have lower to go. The other view I had last year was that we'd see further flattening in the curve, and we But we've now had that flattening.

We're now close to inversion in the 2-year, 10-year bit. Many other parts of the curve have inverted. And I think we'll probably see a little bit further flattening at some point. And I do think that 10-year yields ultimately have lower to go. The problem is, as you know, close to 2% at the moment. Where's the next 25 basis points? I really have no clue. And my bias as a trader is kind of go, whoa, they've come a long way very fast in one direction, maybe a little bit of a bounce. But again, I would have said that a little while ago, and we haven't really seen much of it yet. So I don't have any conviction about where the next 25, 30 basis points is.

OK. I do think that 10-year yields around here completely make sense, that it's not illogical at all.

And this has always been my long-term view. And I think they'll probably continue to come lower. I think you do not see yields in the US sell off— I mean, something I've written many times last year is I never see 10-year yields in the US getting above 4% basically ever again until you have a US dollar currency crisis, which might happen at some point in the future, but I don't see it as close. So to me, I just don't believe the arguments into a bond bear market. I think we're in a massively wide range, and that's the status quo. quo for many years because I currently have a much— for the first time in many years, I have a much more bearish view on the global economy and US equities. I do think that those 10-year yields will kind of test much lower again next year at some point.

But the exact path is hard.

Dollar outlook and long-term themes

Erik Townsend: You mentioned the dollar. Let's, let's get your views on the US dollar.

Mark Cudmore: I remain a kind of secular dollar bear. So I was looking last time for 2018, looking for a powerful dollar bounce in the second half of the year, which we got. And I said at the time it wouldn't be a move to fresh highs. But again, I turned bearish. Basically, we've had that big powerful bounce at the end last year. And I'm now expecting the next kind of 10% move in the dollar will be for weakness. Again, though, the timing is super hard. And in very short term, especially given that I don't think the Fed that's going to come out just before this podcast is going to be overly dovish, I think even short term, there might be a very little bit of kind of upward pressure again first.

But as I mentioned earlier, I think the era of USA outperformance is at an end. I think that Trump's attitudes towards trade and his more isolationist approach is forcing other countries to try bypassing the US as much as possible, and companies. This is not easy because it's the world's largest economy, and it's something that people are very reluctant to do. But because he's kept up this isolationist approach for a couple of years, more and more companies are just going to try having their supply chains just bypass the US. So it's going to become increasingly less relevant. It'll remain dominant, but its dominance will decline. I think Trump's currency intervention threat will help cap the topside. I know it's not expected he's going to come in anytime soon, but if you suddenly see Eurodollar down at 1.05, or you see DXY up through 7.10, suddenly that might be escalated.

So I think that helps. That's capped the topside for the dollar. I think the— as I mentioned, the US actually has much more room to cut rates. So the rate of change in the US will be more drastic than elsewhere in the year ahead. So as I said, most of the countries are already deeply negative. There's not much lower they can go, whereas the US can go much lower. And I think that will change. And I think that's relevant because the reason I called for a large 2018 bounce was that the massive rise in US real yields hadn't been priced. And the US was outperforming in growth. And while the US still might do better than many on growth this year, it's where the optimism, as I mentioned at the start, is still most misplaced. Placed. So I think that real yield benefit will get slashed in the year ahead and the growth outlook will change a chunk.

I think I should mention again the secular argument of, you know, the US share of global GDP and trade is declining, and as the share of global reserves, which are still over 61%, but slowly declining over time. These are both really long, slow, kind of long-term themes. We are seeing them happen. And it's very hard to kind of trade these super long-term themes. They're important to have in mind. You can't kind of trade them on a month-to-month basis. I think on that note, like last time I mentioned that one of the problems markets in 2018 was that traders were really struggling to price in several of these long-term themes, and they're trying to price them in too quickly. And that's why there was this kind of— we believe that 2018 would see higher volatility than 2017. 2019 seen lower volatility again, but I think we're about to go back into that cycle where traders are going to realize, oh, wait a sec, some of these long-term themes like the trade war, they're not going away.

How do we price them in? And they try to price them in too quickly, and that's— you can't do it. They're going to ebb and flow over years. And I think another one is actually— I think we mentioned this before— is on tech stocks and the changing regulatory regime for tech stocks is one of those ones that's kind of suddenly come back into the news in the last week or so.

Again, I think that's a— that's absolutely happening, but it's happening over many years and it's not something you need to suddenly kind of sell all tech stocks because there's going to be more regulatory scrutiny, more tax costs, more compliance costs, more legal costs. But it's something you need to be aware of that is going to be slowly shifting over time. And again, it's going to ebb and flow. The tech companies are going to get some victories. Some governments are going to get some victories, maybe France with their kind of tax there. So I think that these are long-term themes which traders really struggle to battle with. And I think that was the shift between Tesla 2017, 2018. I think, again, now we're about to go into that shift where people are going to realize some long-term themes are very, very important, but it's how do you work out how important they are right at this moment, and that's really hard.

Commodities: Hormuz risk, gold and silver

Erik Townsend: Okay. If the dollar is topping here, and we've also seen some pretty soft commodity prices, does that mean it's time to buy commodities?

Mark Cudmore: This is hard. Look, I got commodities very wrong this year. I gloated of having got Treasuries very right, so I'll admit I got commodities very wrong. I think that was mainly due to the shift in the trade war. They were soggier than I expected, particularly on the metal side.

Look, that does validate the negative growth outlook, but I don't have particularly any strong views. I do think that the Iran-Middle East tension is underpriced, the tail risk in markets. Not that I'm saying anything's going to go wrong, but I think that people are underestimating how much of a shock that would be if there is military action which disrupts the Strait of Hormuz. There's no ability for other suppliers to fill the gap there. If the Strait of Hormuz is blocked. That will cause quite a big distortion in oil prices until that gets freed up. That's a risk I think might be underpriced.

I'm bullish gold, but silver even more so. Not short-term. I have no particular view short-term, again, commodities. But as QE comes back on the agenda globally over the next year, then the gold bugs will come out in force. Ironically, when the gold bugs come out in force, that's when silver outperforms because it's the higher beta one. We saw this in the last crisis when the gold-silver cross lost more than half its value between late 2008 and early 2011. Unless deflation becomes the consensus fear, silver should keep outperforming gold over the next year. It's complementary but tangential to my bearish views, because if the world gets in a deep, deep crisis, this view won't actually work, but then the bearish equity view will then outperform even my expectations.

China and the Baoshang Bank seizure

Erik Townsend: And let's talk about China since we're talking about trade wars. What's your outlook there?

Mark Cudmore: That's another one I think I got wrong, but again, due to the trade war deterioration, it suffered more than I envisioned. I thought there was more weakness last year, but I kind of argued that the long-term fundamental picture was quite positive. It's obviously at the center of current problems, and my view there is definitely shifting. I think that, again, when I was in New York and talked to a lot of investors, it's very easy to focus on all the problems China has and maybe not focus on the problems in the US. And I think one of the things I will say is that they're more aware and priced in China than perhaps they are in the US at times. But China is definitely at the center of current problems. And those Germany and Singapore weakness weaknesses that I spoke at the start about, at the start, really speak to its problems.

One thing I'll just say on China that, like, while I think my view is turning more negative, you know, last year I strongly dismissed the corporate debt concerns. And I think this has been a theme of the last few years. I'm always like, stop worrying about the corporate debt bubble. Yes, it's a massive corporate debt bubble, but this does not mean it needs to blow up anytime soon. And the PBOC has many tools. I find it really ironic that for the first time in many years, no one is overly concerned about China's debt problem this year, just as there are signs of problems.

And there are a lot of signs of liquidity problems. You know, the Baoshang Bank seizure really changed the It broke more links of trust. I think people have misunderstood the China credit problem. There's not a lack of liquidity in the system. It's not like— it's just the liquidity is not flowing to the people who really need it. Up until the Baoshang Bank seizure, it wasn't flowing to this small, desperate private companies. That was the link in the chain that's broken. With the seizure of the Baoshang Bank, what we're seeing is more links in the chain were damaged into the small and medium-sized banks, into the non-bank financial institutions. Suddenly, more links in the chain are broken, there's more of a problem.

I will emphasize that I still I still don't think that the corporate debt bubble in China— and there is a debt bubble— blows up in the next 12 months, because I think, again, people underestimate the number of tools the PBOC has to fight it. But I think that it's ironic that for the first time ever, I think, people should have it as a very unlikely tail risk on their radar, and yet people are suddenly stopping to worry about it, which is a bit weird.

The British pound and Brexit

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to a couple of currencies. Boris Johnson taking over in the UK, what about The British pound.

Mark Cudmore: The pound has got nothing good going for it. I've been a regular basher of the pound. Essentially, it just still remains a sell on rallies. The fundamentals just remain terrible. It's one of those things, though, that it's just gone in a straight line for like 3 months. And there's a natural instinct to wonder when the pullback is due. But the problem is the fundamentals just keep on getting worse and worse. The collapse in the PMIs across the board recently— manufacturing, construction, and services— suggests that the country may be heading toward a recession.

The current account outlook, which is the tail risk, continues to deteriorate. It's now— the consensus estimate on Bloomberg is now 4.3% of GDP for 2019. That consensus estimate was at 3.5% only 3 months ago. The collapse in the currency is not alleviating that key risk. That's reminiscent of an EM currency. Many people would say some of the times the politics has been reminiscent of an EM country as well recently. The UK is a leveraged economy. It's backed by by a large and growing current account deficit. It's got deeply negative real yields, and it's got poor growth. I mean, none of this is good for a currency. The only thing I'll say in sterling's favor is that all of this is super well known. None of it is new.

So surely, at some point, there'll be some type of relief rally. Just we get a minor bit of good news, and it's like, you know, hey, we've got some good news. Let's take some profit on our shorts. And that might be like a short-term powerful squeeze. But it's unlikely to be a turning point. And I think I will say that even though we've seen a lot of weakness in sterling, to me, the vulnerable side in sterling for the next kind of large gapping move is for further weakness again. Just, I think, and if we do go to that no-deal hard Brexit, I do think we'll get another large down leg. That might be the bottom. But I think unfortunately for sterling, even though everyone is bearish, even though there's likely to be the odd relief rally, the fundamentals just remain appalling and the currency has not weakened enough.

Hong Kong dollar peg

Erik Townsend: Let's touch on the Hong Kong dollar peg to the US dollar. Until very recently, I kind of thought, hey, that's— it's It's really unquestionable that they've got a very well-designed system. Nothing can go wrong. But I think the political situation in Hong Kong right now is, is just really off the charts. So is there a risk of breaking the peg for the Hong Kong dollar? And what would the consequences and knock-on effects be if so?

Mark Cudmore: I think the consequences will be massive. I think the political dynamics here with China at the moment are very important. I should emphasize, I'm really not I'm not concerned about the peg going still. I think obviously it's something that people need to be aware of, but I have just so little concern about this. And this is something we talked about last year, and other people were super concerned. And people keep on being really concerned. But I think there's a couple of things that aren't understood in the situation. I think that's most importantly the PBOC and its $3 trillion war chest stands behind the HKMA. So everyone goes, oh, the HKMA only have $450 billion of reserves, which is still quite a lot. And many people analyze how many of them they can use in reality. etc. I don't want to get into too details and arguing about that because we could have a whole other podcast about that.

I've written lots about this before, arguing with some other people about this. Essentially, the PBOC also stands behind them, and I think that's really important. You're basically taking on the most powerful other player in the whole financial markets at the time when that other player also controls the rules of the game and can alter them easily. I think people underestimate that. It's not just squeezing funding rates, which is their most obvious tool, but theoretically, they could take much more direct intervention methods in the Hong Kong dollar market, such as, for example, closing the nostro accounts of those borrowing Hong Kong dollar to short it. So essentially, I never, ever want to take on someone who is way more powerful than me and controls all the rules of the game. And I think that's really important. And also, their experience. The HKMA has dealt with peg situations or peg challenges in the past.

This isn't a novel situation for them. So I think that experience is crucial. And what's most interesting is Hong Kong reserves last month just hit a record high. There's no sign of attack. There's no sign of them needing to intervene. So I think it's It's funny that a lot of— particularly, again, in the US, there's very high-profile attackers of the Hong Kong dollar. And as I always say, look, I'm completely unconcerned. But if I'm wrong, I'm going to get advance notice. I can change my view in time. If I suddenly see Hong Kong reserves start falling precipitously, well, then maybe I'll change my mind. But I just find it bizarre that people focus capital and effort and time attacking something which is nearly going to be impossible to break on their terms, and second of all, shows no sign of any kind of weakness.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Mark Cudmore: Yeah, I do not think it's a risk, but obviously the political situation there at the moment is, is worth watching.

And in terms of consequences, it's absolutely massive if something does go wrong.

Erik Townsend: Well, Mark, I want to thank you for a fantastic interview. As always, you're just a firehose of fascinating information. Before I let you go, though, please tell our listeners a little bit more about the Markets Live blog and how they can follow your work at Bloomberg.

Mark Cudmore: Yep, sure. I think unfortunately for some of your listeners, most of my content is only available on the Bloomberg Terminal. Most of that is on the Bloomberg Markets Live blog, as you mentioned, and that's MLIVGO. I also do a column, an iMacroView column, but ultimately it's all on the terminal or occasionally on MacroVoices podcast.

Erik Townsend: Well, you've got to love that, and we'll have you back again soon. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Powell's mid-cycle message

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how We can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Mark Cudmore. But joining us now in the postgame is former Dallas Fed adviser Danielle DiMartino Booth. Now, Danielle, I have to say, like, Powell surprised the markets in a big way with his statement that this is a mid-cycle adjustment. What's going on here? I mean, is this really a one and done? What's your take on what has happened in the last 48 hours.

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, I remember when my former boss, Richard Fisher, said that we were in the late innings. And boy, did he get in trouble with that. On the other hand, because the Fed was not— the economy was not in the late innings. But nobody can get Jay Powell in trouble for sticking his own foot in his mouth and putting the supposition out there that we're mid-cycle under the assumption that, what, we're going to have a 20-year economic expansion?

So that really, really, really got things off on a bad foot at the beginning of the press conference. And then he actually managed to chase his tail at the podium and go back and forth, confusing markets. We were watching 200-point swings in the Dow while he was at the podium because he was giving out such contradictory signals to the market that the only thing that was apparent in the end was he didn't know what was going on.

Fed ends balance-sheet runoff early

Erik Townsend: Danielle, one of the other things that came up in this meeting was, and it doesn't seem to have gotten a lot of press attention is they basically pulled the plug on what they call balance sheet reduction, which everybody else calls quantitative tightening. What's the significance of this and what meaning should we ascribe to that particular policy move that nobody's really talking about?

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, so this is a tacit admission because they would never call it quantitative easing and they would also never call it quantitative tightening because they wanted for people to look at these policies as being simply Mechanistic in nature and easy to be wound up and just as easy to exit and wind them down. And it would be watching paint dry and put it on autopilot, but it was definitely not going to be a form of monetary tightening.

Well, guess what? If it wasn't a form of monetary tightening, then they would have let it— quantitative tightening conclude in September as originally planned. And instead, they pulled the plug at this latest meeting. Which again, they're saying, you know what, we were wrong. That is what the Fed said. We were wrong. It was indeed a form of tightening that at least gave the perception or exacerbated the situation of a dollar liquidity shortage.

Erik Townsend: Now tell me if I'm exaggerating or reading too much into this, but Danielle, September is only a month away. Is this an admission that things were going so badly that they couldn't even stay the course for one more month on their balance sheet reduction before taking reaction to avert something going Even more badly wrong? I mean, it seems to me like you don't pull the plug just one month early unless you're really worried.

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, not unless you listen to what else came out of the other side of his mouth, that we were mid-cycle. So again, it was a sea of contradictions. Because I, you know, but before we had today's rebuttal, shall we say, from the White House, before we had today's rebuttal, the markets had begun to price out that September, the certainty of that September rate cut. So even though there was a little bit of upset in the markets, they're still close to all-time highs. Jay Powell may have actually put his head on the pillow the night of the meeting and said, you know what, there was very little collateral damage.

The markets do not have September priced in as a certainty. I've had my cake, I'm eating it too. All is good. Until, of course, today.

Trump's abolish-the-Fed retweet and Fed independence

Erik Townsend: Let's move on then to the White House reaction, because not only has President Trump Trump said very publicly, you know, thank the Fed for this. You know, it's the stock market, it's the Fed's fault, the Fed let us down again. There's been some very strong rhetoric there. But I think what happened this afternoon is the trade war tweet about China got so much attention that most people missed another tweet from President Trump where he's retweeting a media interview with— I forget who the pundit was, but somebody who was calling to abolish the Federal Reserve completely. It wasn't Ron Paul.

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: It wasn't.

Erik Townsend: That was some other commentator on the abolish the Fed thing. So, all of a sudden, the President of the United States is retweeting media interviews with people who favor abolishing the Fed. Is this just the President venting frustration, or is there a possibility that we're actually headed into a situation where the President of the United States seeks to eliminate or take away the power of the Federal Reserve as an independent central bank?

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, so ask yourself this basic fundamental question. Can the president, after every time the Fed meets and does not satisfy what he wanted in terms of additional easing like that, that he feels his peers are getting in Europe and in China, does the president have the ability to, excuse the pun, trump out a fresh set of tariffs after every Fed meeting that dissatisfies him. No. So, he has to up the ante. He has to say, you know what, if you continue to defy my will, which is what the Fed, by the way, is obligated to do, the Fed is obligated to be independent. If you continue to defy my will, then I'm just going to take away your independence.

And it's not— there's no sure thing. There's no shoo-in at all. There has to be a few rational lawmakers left in Congress. I could probably Probably count them on 2 hands.

It wouldn't be a shoo-in, but boy, would it upset the global financial system because of the way that we are the world's leading central bank. We drive the train. And what if we tell the rest of the world the train is driving blind, we've fired the conductor?

Dollar reserve status, SDR basket and Lagarde

Erik Townsend: Well, I really want to pick up on that and particularly what it would mean in terms of the rest of the world's commitment to the US dollar. As the world's global reserve currency. Let's suppose, for sake of argument, that lawmakers would ultimately not allow President Trump to actually abolish the Fed, so there is no more central bank in the United States. Let's assume that we're not going to get all the way to that outcome, but we do go through a process where President Trump is very publicly and visibly seemingly trying to cause that outcome to occur. It seems to me like if I put myself in Mario Draghi or Kuroda-san's shoes, my confidence in continuing to rely on the US dollar as the world's global reserve currency when the head of state is trying to abolish its independent central bank, that just doesn't— it doesn't add up for me.

What do you think the consequences and implications could be?

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: So, you're describing a very logical potential progression. And that is that if confidence is shaken to a significant enough extent that you have some other major players in the world economy begin to contemplate more than they already are— we know that the dollar, in terms of its position in world trade, has declined over the past few years since China has risen up. I'm not saying that the Chinese currency has in any way displaced the dollar, but dollar transactions have indeed gone to other currencies as countries contemplate our runaway deficits and debt.

But what if such a move on the part of the White House was to amplify and expedite those contemplations such that the IMF or other global entities were to get in involved to say, okay, we need to come up with a doomsday plan in the event that this actually happens.

So think about that, because we're already on a slippery slope because we've used the greenback as a weapon of mass destruction towards our— even our allies. So you don't want global powers that be sitting around big tables in conference rooms contemplating They're already contemplating how and what they would do in a post-dollar reserve currency world, dot, dot, dot, just in case the man over in that White House succeeds.

Erik Townsend: Danielle, let's follow this through. One of the things that a lot of people have said is, look, even if various people, because of concerns about the US, in the opinion of some people, overstepping its authority in telling other countries what to do, particularly with With respect to Iran sanctions. What people have said is, look, don't worry about the US dollar and whether it's going to be the global reserve currency for one simple reason, which is there is no viable alternative to the US Treasury bond market for central bank reserve assets because there's no other bond market in the world with the depth and liquidity needed to absorb central bank-sized capital flows. Given that that's kind of the, the widely accepted view.

What actions would central bankers contemplate if suddenly the President of the United States— on one hand, you've got no replacement for the US Treasury market, but on the other hand, if the US Treasury market has certain characteristics of stability and volatility based on having a central bank, and the President of the United States is trying to abolish the central bank, what options would be available to foreign central banks, and what would they do in terms of their reserve assets? What could it mean for US Treasury holdings abroad?

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, I think, I think that a potential interim agreement could be, could be forged among the other countries who would have a potentially partially viable currency. I don't mean to be talking in circles, but I'm just saying that the euro can't stand on its own, the yuan can't stand on its own, and The yen can't stand on its own. But what if the other 3 most traded currencies, plus let's say, let's throw the British pound sterling in for good reason, even though I'm getting ready to schedule my trip to London, the sterling's so weak.

But let's just say you have 4 alternative currencies form a basket, and you have the blessing of the IMF because of the one-off and, you know, what they might consider to be craziness coming out of the United States, whereas we are supposed to be a harbor of stability for the world's financial system backed by a stable US dollar.

Erik Townsend: It seems to me that this sets the stage. We know that politicians always want to have a big win when they first take over a new position. Christine Lagarde has strong ties in the IMF, obviously, and she She's about to take over the ECB. It seems to me like a big win for her could be to take the helm of the ECB and say, look, we need a turbocharged SDR. We need to re-architect what the SDR is. And oh, by the way, I had my team start working on this before I even left. And now that I'm head of the ECB, I want to talk to the BOJ and other major central banks about moving from the US dollar to a new form of IMF SDR. Is that a logical progression, and what would be some of the, uh, the pros and cons of that approach if it were to occur?

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, look, it is certainly not impossible. I, I think it is not without some deep forethought that Lagarde is going to take on the helm of the ECB, because she is a political animal and she does understand negotiations, and she is so deeply respected on the global stage and has negotiated and dealt with every male and female major leader that you can name.

So there is something to be said for having a unifying individual who could potentially try and bridge all of the other countries' anxieties, because that is what is building on the world stage right now. We have— when things like throwing tariffs out there willy-nilly that throw crude oil prices worldwide down down 8%, hurting other countries that are oil-producing nations. When you have moves that produce such extreme levels of volatility, you could almost make the argument that you would need to have somebody come in and contemplate and lead an alternative type of regime, or at least bring together, I don't know, whatever bureaucrats

European rate-cut pricing, September FOMC and recession risk

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: bring together,

Patrick Ceresna: So, Danielle, it appears that the market is all of a sudden pricing in, in Europe, that there's going to be a rate cut before Christine even comes into power. Like, what's going on over there?

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: So, I think that, that it was Mario Draghi's dream to be able to get back to Rome and save face and not actually have to do, as I said, that he would do in Brussels 2 years ago, and that is lower negative interest rates further into negative territory, never normalize monetary policy.

But as soon as the Fed reduced rates by a quarter percentage point, the probability of a September 12th European Central Bank rate cut shot up to 92%. He's not going to be able to defy that level of market certitude on top of the fact that after this new tariff barb was thrown out there on the part of the United States here, back here Domestically, probabilities of a September 18th— the Fed meets 6 days later— of a September 18th rate cut also shot up to being an almost sure thing.

Patrick Ceresna: And so, with the market now pricing in September as a greater probability here, how does this work out? I mean, Powell's setting himself up, at least he gave the impression that this could be a one-and-done, but clearly the market doesn't think so. How does this play out here in the September meeting?

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, so I think what makes the bad situation worse. There were, there were stocks such as Abercrombie and Gap, some of the weaker links in the retail brick-and-mortar space that were trading down huge today after these tariff announcements. They're not going to have the financial wherewithal to do the panic buying ahead of September 1st implementation of higher tariffs. So Jay Powell is not only going to be quarreling with a market that is fully priced in the next rate cut, but one that is pricing in what he expressly wants to avoid and what he tried to communicate at this latest press conference, and that this is not the beginning of a rate easing cycle.

We've already got the manufacturing sector in this country on its knees. It looks like we've just twisted the knife that's already in the heart of brick-and-mortar retail. So if you start to add up the industry sectors, including transportation, We saw transportation layoffs spike in the latest Challenger Gray and Christmas data. If you start to add it up, this latest move on the part of Trump could push the United States that much closer to recession, such that when they're sitting around the table on September the 17th and 18th— shameless plug, September the 17th is my birthday— but when they're sitting around the table on my birthday, they're going to have to be contemplating what the rate easing cycle looks like, even though they have so little ammunition. They'll have 1.75 percentage points after the rate cut that is fully priced in on September 18th. Wouldn't we all like to be a fly on that wall?

Summer special with Peter Boockvar

Erik Townsend: Danielle, we're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. But before we let you go, I want to take this opportunity to announce a project that we're really excited about here at MacroVoices, which is For our August break, to give our staff a little bit of time off, we're going to have a prerecorded 2-week summer special. It'll be 2 episodes in a row that will be dedicated to Danielle DiMartino Booth and Peter Boockvar, getting into a big discussion about everything from negative interest rates to modern monetary policy to socialism to the of populism and so on and so forth. Danielle, why Peter Boockvar and what do you guys have planned for us? Give our listeners a little taste of what they can expect.

Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Peter has always been an inflationista and I have for many years been a deflationista. But when it comes to our criticism of modern monetary theory, when it comes to our criticism of central bankers taking us down the this rabbit hole. We have a lot of rich and wonderful areas of agreement. And I think just hearing Danielle and Peter talk, 'cause we talk every single day, will give people such deep insights into people who've been working together. Even while I was at the Federal Reserve for a decade, he was one of my advisors as I was an advisor at the Fed. Just to hear how the thinking comes together will be such a tremendous opportunity. I think, for all of your listeners.

Closing credits and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: We're really looking forward to that. And listeners, you can expect those 2 episodes to air on August 22nd and 29th. So that's coming up. And of course, Danielle will be back for all-stars appearances on our regularly recurring schedule. We're going to need to leave it there. Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy of The Many Flavors of Trend Following, and subscribe to their podcast as well. You'll be glad you did. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo.

And folks, don't forget to visit MacroVoices.com to register your free account. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email every week, which contains a compendium of links to all of the best content that we could find on the internet, including downloads of Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to some of Mark Cudmore's recent articles. There's also an interesting piece for, uh, talking about OPEC's oil production dropping to 8-year lows, as well as an interesting article that the Fed might not cut more than once. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup. Up email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and MacroVoices is a production of Bloomberg Television and Radio and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Peter Warburton — Dr. Peter Warburton, Director and Chief Economist for Economic Perspectives Limited (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is. Bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview: when does secular inflation return?

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 177 was recorded on July 25th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the leading podcast when it comes to systematic trading and investing. Dr. Peter Warburton joins me as this week's feature interview guest, and we'll be discussing what I think is perhaps the most important issue on the long-term macro radar screen. When will secular inflation return? What will cause it? And what will its effects be? Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will address a listener question about the difference between bull and bear steepeners in the fixed income market, as well as more discussion on financial repression and inflation.

S&P 500: on the sidelines, with a melt-up plan

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to the S&P 500 because just earlier, as the ECB was announcing, we had We had a break to a little bit of a higher high on an intraday basis. It looked like the S&P was ready to go and gave it all back. What's your thinking as we pivot here off 3,000?

Erik Townsend: You know, I don't really have any, any short-term view of significance here, Patrick. The fact that we were back at all-time highs this morning didn't surprise me that much. It's the same story in my book. Valuations are crazy too high. It doesn't make sense for me up here that markets are being driven higher. So the old paradigm is still in play using Ray Dalio's Aalo's terminology. For now, at least, I'm happily on the sidelines. We could go into a crazy melt-up. If so, I'll play that with 40 delta calls and just roll them every month. I definitely don't want to be outright long because I think the market should either be entering a secular bear market or outright crashing.

The thing is, you got to listen to what the market is telling you, not what you think it should be doing. What the market's telling me is it wants to go higher, as much as I don't think that makes any sense. When what's happening doesn't jibe with my fundamental fundamental view, I get on the sidelines and wait for things to start to make sense. That's where I'm waiting.

Patrick Ceresna: All right.

US Dollar Index at the 97.50/98 resistance

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to the US Dollar Index because the euro continues to be incredibly weak. That dollar index is back toward 98 on the upper end. Is the dollar strength still going to prevail?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the September Dollar Index futures contract touched almost contract highs. There was a very brief blip on May 23rd intraday, slightly higher. But in terms of a closing print, unless there is a sudden drop in the next few minutes here before the market closes, what we're going to see is a close above 97.50, and I think that will be a contract high closing price if we get that closing print. So, you know, we're, we're definitely right on the edge of annual R1 resistance, we're at the previous high on a contract basis, so I think we're maybe on the edge of a real breakout here. Now the thing is, the most skillful of the bears are selling short inside here above $97.50, they may push the market briefly back down. But if they're mistaken and I'm right and we do get a breakout, they're going to cover quickly above $98. So if we get that breakout, the smart ones will be covering or going outright long, and that's going to add fuel to the fire.

Maybe the third time's the charm here. This will be the third major test of this level. As I've explained in previous episodes, we kind of have a, a question about where the previous high was here. $97.50 is what we call the contract high. In other words, if you look at where this September contract, the one that's trading now, was at its prior high point, it's right where— here where it was. But on the prior contract, the number was 98. So do you go by the number before? So that's sometimes called the continuation high. Or do you use what's called the contract high? Some people use one, some people use the other. So you're going to find resistance at 97.50 and then again at 98. A clear breakout and a daily close above 98, I think, will unleash a whole bunch of buying, and I think it'll be a quick move from there much higher. But the breakout has not quite happened yet.

We're right on the hairy edge of that resistance level. It's always possible that I'm wrong and that the people who are selling in size up here at the contract highs are going to be proven right. We'll see what happens.

Crude oil: inventory draw, hurricane distortion, Iran

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to crude oil because crude has been incredibly weak for the last 2 weeks. I mean, we're trading near $56 a barrel on the WTI right here, and it— by all accounts, it looks like it wants to go lower. But what's your thinking here? What do What are they gonna be the drivers in oil?

Erik Townsend: Well, let's start with the inventory numbers. Crude oil drawing down an utterly massive 10.8 million barrels this week. Now, we have to qualify that. This is the second week after the hurricane, and you, you tend to have anomalies in the data where in the wake of the hurricane and the cleaning up and the getting things back online, you see depressed production and import numbers due to weather. Ships that were on their way to Houston turned around and waited at sea for the storm to pass and so forth. But we still have a really massive drawdown that, needless to say, spiked prices higher for all of about 10 seconds, and then they traded off for the rest of the day.

Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 1.4 million barrels, gasoline drawing down 0.2 million barrels, distillates building 600,000 barrels. So the tape action was decidedly down on a day where normally you would expect that kind of drawdown to result in huge action to the As I've said many times in the past on this program, one of my favorite personal rules is the market's reaction to the inventory number is far more important than the inventory number itself. To see the market sell off in reaction to what normally would be such a strongly bullish number, if it wasn't a weather anomaly, I would say, holy cow, this market really, really, really wants to go down. It's fighting that really bullish signal. I think what's going on here, though, Patrick, is people are writing off the big big drawdown as a weather anomaly. They're not taking it as if it was a real normal 10.8 million barrel drawdown. US production, meanwhile, holy cow, down 700,000 barrels to 11.3 million barrels.

We were holding above 12 million barrels. All of a sudden, we're way down to fully 1 million barrels below the 12.3 million barrels we were showing just a couple of weeks ago. The thing is, once again, 15 rigs were evacuated and shut in in the Gulf of Mexico during the hurricane. We're still feeling those effects. Now, if we see this trend continue and we're seeing less than 12 million barrels of production for the next several weeks to come, that's a really, really important signal that says, okay, maybe the, the shale production growth has really come to an end. We can't make that decision in a hurricane-affected week. Imports back up to 7 million barrels this week, exports back up to 3.3 million barrels. So as I've been saying for weeks, Patrick, The economics, I believe, the recession signals that we're seeing, the IEA's revised forecast saying that there's gonna be less demand in 2020, all of these things come together to point to much lower oil prices.

But at the same time, I don't really read the same meaning that a lot of people are reading into this Iran situation. They think that President Trump's comments saying we're ready to negotiate with Iran means a de-escalation. I'm not persuaded of that. I think that President Trump may intentionally be jawboning the market lower in order to set the stage to get tough with Iran. So I would watch very carefully for geopolitical risks escalating in coming weeks. But in the absence of that, I think there's a lot of bearish downward pressure on prices. And right now we're still in between, we're right in the middle of the short-term moving averages. So that means the market's trying to make up its mind on direction. If we get a daily close that's Well below all 3 of the short-term moving averages, the 5, 8, and 13-day moving averages, that would really tell me this market wants to move lower.

Again, my caveat is watch out if Trump actually changes his mind on what he meant with his comments that the market so far has taken as a de-escalation relative to Iran.

Gold bought at 1,412 as a dollar hedge

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because last week it looked like gold was toying with a breakout to multi-year highs and was ready to go, and then the dollar index started to rally, and since then gold's been backfilling some of that strength. What's your thinking about the next move here on gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, I bought gold today at $1,412, which will probably shock some of our listeners, but it's, it's really not the reasons that you might be thinking. There is a technical setup here, which is we saw a breakout from a short-term symmetrical triangle pattern. Sometimes you get that and you'll go down and retest that upper trend line on the triangle as a support line before moving much higher. So there is a technical setup. But really, the reason that I bought gold today is I had wanted— I was hoping that the dollar was going to pull back to 96 even, and that I could buy more dollar index futures at 96. That limit order never got filled, obviously. I did end up adding to my dollar position today at 97.31. That really puts me in a precarious position if I'm wrong about the dollar, this turns out to be a topping market. If I've top-ticked the market and added to my long position, I'm kind of in trouble there.

I needed to hedge that. So I did buy gold today, primarily because if I'm wrong about the dollar, I know gold is going to go shooting hard to the upside as the dollar tumbles, and that gold position is going to very effectively hedge what would otherwise be a loss on my dollar long. I think the most likely scenario, frankly, is I'll be stopped out of my long on gold as the dollar moves higher. But needless to say, we'll see what happens. It's been 3 major tests of this exact level, and so far we haven't seen a breakout.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: We'll see what this one brings.

10-year Treasury yield holding near 2%

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because we've been hovering more or less in this 2% to 2.10% level for over a month, almost 2 months. We've been just toying back and forth, but it doesn't seem like bonds nor the interest rates are ready to make a big move. What's your thinking? Is, is this 2% going to hold?

Erik Townsend: You know, it's, it's hard to say. I kind of feel like I was waiting for a backing up in rates as an opportunity to get into the long side. I'm still on the downside of this trade, looking for lower yields. I still think the recession signals are telling us that that's coming.

I don't consider 2.08 or whatever it is this afternoon as an incredible buying opportunity. If it was 2.18, I might feel differently. So I'm waiting for a little bit more of a pullback before I would actually buy here. But I do think that other factors being equal, probably we're headed lower in rates. As you say, though, we seem to have gone from a very aggressive move lower in yields to kind of a holding pattern. We've been treading water for a while. Let's see which way it resolves. All right.

Housekeeping: server upgrade and Sunday outage

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for the update. Before we move on to this week's feature interview guest with Dr. Peter Warburton, we have a quick housekeeping announcement. What's going on, Erik?

Erik Townsend: Well, our listeners are absolutely loving all of our new expanded content, but they're loving it so much that our server has crashed twice now with the extra workload that comes. We've had basically— when we sent 2 All-Stars episodes out in rapid succession, it results in so many download requests that it's It's crashed the server a couple times. So we're upgrading to a bigger server on Sunday afternoon and evening. That is going to require a scheduled outage for the entire MacroVoices.com website. So we'll be offline from 5 PM to midnight this coming Sunday, July 28th. But we'll be back on Monday with a brand new server with enough capacity to keep bringing you even more download capacity. And we're going to test it and see if it works this time. We're trying to get the ability to send MacroVoices Videos out so they show up as a video podcast in your iTunes feed. That's what broke the server last time, so hopefully the new server has the the horsepower to handle it.

I want to send my thanks out to the many listeners who have donated and or set up recurring monthly donations in the last couple of weeks. It was your donations that paid for the server upgrade. So thank you so much for helping us to continue deliver even more fantastic content to all of our listeners.

Patrick Ceresna: All right.

Why Warburton: when does secular inflation return?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for the update. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Dr. Peter Warburton. Now, I had the opportunity to meet Peter in Toronto, and he impressed me with his understanding of inflation. Now, what was your thinking as to why it was a good time to invite him to the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, what impresses me is he's not just talking a lot like a lot of economists are about, you know, whether or not what the Fed did this week or last week is going to affect inflation or be successful at their inflation goals or whatever. He's talking about the big picture of, hey, we've got major changes in society's attitude towards spending and MMT and entitlement programs and so forth that could have profound changes in the backdrop that we're used to of disinflation or almost outright deflation. And Patrick, this dovetails perfectly into one of my strongest views that I've held for more than 10 years now. And what I've said is, look, Look, I don't know. It's beyond my pay grade to tell you exactly when we're going to get a return to secular inflation. But nothing lasts forever. The deflationary backdrop, it's going to continue until everybody thinks it has to continue forever, which feels like is what a lot of people think.

Eventually, inflation's going to take us by surprise. And when it does, that's where you get to what could be the beginning of the endgame. Because frankly, no matter what goes wrong in the economy, central bankers if there's a disinflationary backdrop and there's therefore no risk of runaway inflation as a result of accommodative monetary policy, they can solve just about any problem by printing money to throw at the problem. You could solve most problems that way, or at least I should say, you can mitigate the symptoms of problems in the short term by throwing printed money at them. When the keys to the printing press are taken away, and I contend that secular inflation is what takes away the keys to the printing press, because suddenly central bankers can't print money money without running the risk of exacerbating that into a runaway inflation or even hyperinflation. At that point, that's when all of a sudden the game changes and the central bankers' ability to paper over our problems with printed money goes away and we have to pay the piper and face reality.

So I don't know when that starts, but anybody who's got a qualified expert view on when we might expect a return, not just of a little bit of inflation, but secular inflation that we have to worry about, or worse yet, stagflation, where we get high inflation in the face of stagnant economic growth, that's where I think we get to risk of the monetary endgame really kicking into gear. I don't know when it starts.

Erik Townsend: I look to people like Dr. Warburton to help me understand when that could occur.

And this episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Although I'm a global macro investor myself, it's a fact that quant-based hedge fund strategies are dominating the rankings of top-performing managers. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well-researched and tested. And this year they're off to a flying start. And there's one podcast that covers this area of finance better than any other: TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book explaining how these systematic strategies can work for you. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/MacroVoices. to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro.

Check them out, you'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik's interview with Dr. Peter Warburton is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Why inflation now: Warburton's backstory

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Dr. Peter Warburton, Director and Chief Economist for Economic Perspectives Limited. Dr. Warburton, it is such a pleasure to get you on the program because something that I have been thinking about for years, and frankly people ridicule me about, is it seems to me like if you look at all of the policy decisions of the last several years and the people who have criticized them, myself included.

It seems to me like what's going on is we can get away with these things until inflation gets in the way. And once we have an inflation problem, all of a sudden central bankers can't just paper over our problems by printing more money because it would exacerbate the inflation. But most people think inflation— hey, we haven't had it in recent history, we've had a deflationary backdrop, it's not a problem.

You gave a presentation back at the end of June called Blowing Up the Box. And what I really like about this is your perspective resonates so well with mine that if you want to understand inflation, you can't just think about past history. You've got to think about not just the economics, but also the political environment. So please fill us in. What do you mean by blowing up the box? What's the backstory on how you got to this set of views? And before we get into your slide deck— and by the way, listeners, be sure to check your Research Roundup Roundup email, there's a link to download both the slide deck that we're going to be referring to throughout this interview. So you definitely want that download. There's also a detailed commentary on this subject in a separate download link. Both of those are in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered and don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage and you'll see a red button next to Dr.

Warburton's picture, which says looking for the downloads. Dr. Warburton, give us the backstory, the big picture. Why are you thinking about inflation now when so many other people are ignoring it?

Peter Warburton: Well, the truth is, I've been thinking about inflation a long time. My first sort of visceral reaction to the global credit crisis, which is now more than a decade past, was that the only credible resolution for the global credit crisis was a resurgence of inflation. And of course, the first thing that happened in 2010-11 was we got some inflation. We got some commodity and oil price inflation.

And it looked as though we were kind of on the way to a more inflationary world. But of course, that was a very temporary interlude, followed by five years plus of disinflation, and clearly a very dominant view that inflation was irrelevant to the conduct of investments and asset management. But no, my my gut reaction, which is also I think my considered reaction, is that.

There are many forces that bear down upon the longer-term outlook for inflation. Clearly, central bank policy, monetary policy is one, but the political economic environment is another. Socioeconomic tensions is another. Demographics is another. You know, basically, the reason we end up in a significantly different place in terms of inflation is a kind of societal culmination, and in the end, monetary policy just gives way to what needs to happen to resolve the issues that have arisen, maybe built up over many years.

Blowing Up the Box: the post-1980s policy framework

Erik Townsend: Dr. Warburton, as we look at your slide deck, the very first slide has this TNT explosive picture, and the, the heading is Blowing Up the Box. What box are we talking about? I assume we're talking about a policy box of some kind. Tell us, what is this policy box? How did we get here? And what can we expect next?

Peter Warburton: Yes, the idea of blowing up the box is that over the last 20, 30 years, we've constructed a policy box which essentially has been a protection, first of all, against inflation, Secondly, against unruly and excessive government spending and borrowing. And thirdly, interference from politicians in the timing of monetary and fiscal policy decisions.

So we've evolved over this long period of time. So if you like, we want to start with the chaos of the 1970s post-Bretton Woods. And we've sort of constructed this box.

We decided in the 1980s that inflation was public enemy number one. We needed a policy framework that addressed high inflation, brought inflation down. We needed a policy framework that brought public sector borrowing under control. So we needed some kind of a balanced budget rule. We had still very restricted markets. We had a lot of protectionism, a lot of controls, a lot of leftover stuff, really, from the Second World War. So we needed liberalization.

And so that's been another part of the framework of the blocks that we built. And interestingly, what we also did, we basically wanted to separate— this kind of came a bit later, but we wanted to separate the inflation control part of policy from the budgetary control. And to do that, essentially, we had to set up a funding rule whereby if the government did borrow to excess, then it was to be funded by the primary issue of government securities. And not through inflation.

So that's the policy box. And it served us pretty well through the '80s and '90s, leading into the crisis period in the end of 2007 and onwards. But essentially, it wasn't a perfect box. If it had been a perfect box, we wouldn't have had a financial crisis.

The bit that was left out was there was no control of systemic leverage. And so if you like it, for me it was systemic leverage that blew that original design. And so out of the sort of the ashes of the financial crisis, we put the box together as best we could. We made some changes. We brought in QE. So we broke the funding rule. We suspended the balanced budget rule because it was going to take a long time to repair public finances. And we ignored departures from inflation targets rather more than we had before. So there were a number of things that we did.

But essentially, Actually, that that sort of botched patched up on the run box has had some increasingly disturbing characteristics in terms of the relative fortunes of people across the income spectrum and across the wealth spectrum. And it is, I think, those design faults which have brought us to this juncture now, and why we have the politics that we have now, and why we have the threat.

Financial repression and its second act: unanticipated inflation

Erik Townsend: Dr. Warburton, as I look ahead to some of these slides, it seems like a really important theme here is that the reasons that you see this policy box potentially coming to an end or blowing up has to do with financial repression. So let's do a quick review of financial repression and how it relates to this story.

Peter Warburton: I think it's possible quite reasonably to describe the objectives of central bank policies as having a desire to repress the nominal value of interest rates. And clearly that originally was merely to lower short-term interest rates to their practical minimum, and latterly has become a desire to suppress, repress interest rates across the yield curve using large-scale asset purchases, using forward guidance, and using other technical techniques to manipulate the central bank balance sheet.

So why would you want to repress interest rates? Well, clearly, the context here is that post-crisis, the public sector debt ratio has increased very significantly. So in European countries where it was typically maybe around 50 or 60% of GDP, it's now pretty much 100% of GDP. Obviously, some countries started higher and have gone higher still. And the US similarly was down in the 60-70% range pre-crisis and is now up in the, in the 90s.

So the context here is wanting to minimize the burden of debt service for the government. I mean, that's a fairly obvious objective to have. Have. Otherwise, your debt service cost rises and it squeezes out all the other programs. So I understand the logic of financial repression. But what's happened here is that because financial repression has been successful in its initial stages, the assumption that many people are making is that this is the world in which we remain.

Indeed, some while ago, this was coined the new normal, you know, a world of very low interest rates, very low inflation, but very weak or stagnant growth. But what I'm arguing here is that financial repression, if it's to be successful, has to have a second phase. It has to have a second act, if you like, if it was a play.

And the second act is unanticipated inflation. And so the whole context of the presentation is to say, what is it potentially that brings us into a new environment in terms of much higher inflation and indeed, of necessity, unanticipated inflation. And so that's the context of the presentation. So the successful second act, as it were, of a financial repression is the unanticipated inflation that depresses the capital value of fixed income assets.

The four poles of the box and the political clamour for spending

Erik Townsend: Dr. Warburton, I just think this is such a timely topic because every time I talk to anyone in professional finance about inflation, they laugh at me and they act like, dude, you don't get it. You know, haven't you been paying attention? We've got a really serious problem with disinflation. We need inflation. We can't get it. And the more I hear that, the contrarian in me says, boy, we must be getting close to the point where everybody is taken by surprise.

And I'm not sure exactly what's going to trigger it, and I'm absolutely fascinated to find out. So, I think we've kind of covered the first few slides in the deck in the conversation we've had so far. But moving on to slide 12 or 13, tell us a little bit more about this policy box. What is causing it to be, as you put it on slide 13, be hastily and arbitrarily redesigned?

Peter Warburton: Sure. So, the box, as I've drawn it on slide 13, is So there are 4 vertical poles. So the first one is what used to be the fully funded budget deficit. It was the budget deficit to be funded by additional issues of debt. But of course, that's now been buffered by QE. So in other words, the central bank has taken huge responsibility, effectively, in the short term for the funding of government deficits.

So that's point number 1. But point number 2 is that the Obviously, the balanced budget edict itself has been significantly bent by the huge impact of the financial crisis and the deep slump that followed. So, we've relaxed the timescale over which we expect the budget to be balanced.

The third pole is about free movement of goods, capital, and workers. So, what we've seen really since 2009 is a kind of deglobalization. We've seen some capital protectionism come back. We've seen at the fringes clearly the grounds of some trade protectionism coming back, and generally issues about immigration have risen to the fore.

And then the fourth pole is really about the central bank inflation objective. And increasingly now, central banks cast their objectives in terms of anchoring inflation expectations. So if inflation goes wandering off either up or down relative to their objective, they tend not to take a great deal of notice, provided they can point to some kind of survey surveys that say, oh, the market is still confident that inflation will return to its objective.

But over this long period of time, what's happened is this rather arbitrary redesign of the box has created some unusual effects. Obviously, these have been well documented in that it's conferred an advantage to those that have had financial assets. So in a QE-boosted and protected world, capital asset values have tended to rise. In fact, they've risen powerfully out of the spring of 2009, which obviously has favored those who have more of those assets in the first place.

Also, there's been a compression of real incomes. So when we look at the income spectrum, we find that a lot of people people in the lowering income groups have suffered relative income declines in relation— the economy has been growing, but it hasn't been boosting their after-tax incomes. And basically, year by year, the consequences have got more and more extreme.

And so it's no surprise to me that what we have in the political dimension is now a clamor for a redefining of policy priorities. And we can think about maybe some particular themes.

So for some people, it might be about job guarantee. Other people, it might be about a Green New Deal. Other people, it might be about boosting the defense budget. Other people, it might be about infrastructure. But essentially, there are multiple narratives that say, look, we've got some These are really important spending priorities. They're not being addressed. We need a policy framework that allows them to be addressed.

And if that means higher deficits and more inflation, so be it.

MMT and why the constraints are self-imposed

Erik Townsend: Now, the argument of the MMT constituency is essentially, look, the only downside to printing as much money as we need to fund whatever social programs might benefit society is inflation. That's the only adverse consequence. And we don't have inflation, so why not do it? Now, it seems to me like the answer is because inflation has a long lead time and you can do a whole lot of damage before the symptoms actually show up. Am I correct to think that? And if so, what evidence maybe supports that?

Peter Warburton: The constraints of the box that I've described, they are— they're self-imposed. So if you like, they are self-denying ordinances. If you want to make that allusion, in other words, it's not that we have lost the capacity to generate faster rates of inflation. It is that we have, if you like, tied our hands behind our back, or rather we've tied the politicians' hands behind their backs, and we've we've put very strict limits around the mandates of our our central banks. In support of a stable inflation objective.

But if there are more important things going on in politics and society, then those restrictions, which are man-made, they are artificial, they are, if you like, a response to the last inflationary cycle. They're a response to the high inflation of the 1970s.

But if we want to loosen those constraints, then we can. And I think a lot of confusion has arisen because of the lack of inflation that has occurred in the context of large-scale QE. And it would take a long time maybe to unpack in detail why massive additions to central bank balance sheets were not inflationary. But I think that there's some good reasons why they weren't. And we can understand with hindsight much more clearly what they were. But it is a false assumption or a false progression of logic to say that we are now incapable of generating inflation. Essentially, we have the capacity either by requiring banks, commercial banks, to buy loads more government bonds than they currently do, or making more loans than they currently do, which obviously would require that we relaxed their, uh, some of their capital adequacy constraints and so on. But these are all man-made things. We, we can make some different choices.

And arguably, if we wanted to accommodate some other spending priorities, we would naturally undermine the framework that we have built. In other words, there would be, there'd be other, other priorities would have precedence, and we would subordinate inflation control Dr.

Inflation targeting's limits and the 2020 US election

Erik Townsend: Warburton, let's go a little bit deeper on inflation targeting and the history of inflation targeting. What is the backstory here, and what can we expect next?

Peter Warburton: Yes, I'm looking now at slide 25 of the pack and arguing that inflation targeting is now probably outgrowing its usefulness. So inflation targeting really only got going in the 1990s. Arguably, New Zealand was the first formal country to— the country to adopt formal inflation targeting. And it kind of spread across developed economies, such as Australia, and UK, and Sweden, and so on. And in time, dozens and dozens of countries have adopted inflation targets. But we have to remember that these are all 1990s babies, and some of them are 2000 babies.

This is not a longstanding institutional framework. It's something that we put together. Together relatively recently. And so, as I said, the inflation targets were there for a purpose. They were there to reinforce a commitment to low and stable inflation.

But we can ask now, what happens? We've got enough evidence of inflation target regimes operating in a wide variety of countries, including in Africa and Asia and Europe. What happens when the inflation target isn't allowing a necessary adjustment to take place. Well, we can see on slide 26 we've had some recent departures. So we have some big inflationary departures in, for example, Vietnam in 2008 and 2011. Since then, inflation's come back into range again. We've had big departures over the years in Russia. Yes, Russia, if you believe it, has an inflation target.

And most recently, we've seen Turkey experience, obviously, massively higher inflation than was consistent with their 5% inflation target. So to argue that somehow inflation targets are sufficient to establish permanent inflation control is nonsense. Basically, if the decisions that have been made around the conduct of monetary policy— in other words, decisions about public spending, decisions about the openness of markets, for example, inflation targets will just become a dead letter. They, you know, the inflation rate will just depart significantly and semi-permanently from the target.

So my point really is that we might not think that we can be put in the same category in countries like the US and the UK as Turkey, Vietnam, and Russia. But the principle still applies, is that if something more important needs to happen, inflation target is effectively disregarded, suspended, and so on. What's really interesting, if you look at slide 27, is we think, well, during the 1970s, that chaotic period, there were essentially no differences in the relative experience of those in the middle of the income distribution, the bottom of the income distribution, and the top of the income distribution.

We have to go to the 1980s and 1990s and the adoption of inflation targeting to find increasing disparity. So the whole issue of income inequality has arisen in the context of the policy box that we put in place to put inflation into a controlled policy framework and budget to be balanced and all of that.

So if you like, we have created a fertile environment for dislocation of outcomes throughout society. And I'm arguing that, if you like, it is this protracted period of dislocated outcomes, that's what brings us to the point now. And this is why the 2020 US presidential election is so significant, is because it is now a battleground for extreme policy proposals, And the voice of fiscal conservatism, the voice of the balanced budget, spending within our means, and all of that—that voice is is barely heard.

Essentially, the constraints that are in place at the moment, and on which so much of asset allocation strategy is based, I think are looking increasingly fragile. And the adoption of different policies. potentially either by an ongoing Trump administration or by an incoming Democratic administration, I think are incompatible with this policy framework staying in place.

How fast could policy change? Fed balance sheet and fixed income risk

Erik Townsend: With regard to how quickly these things change, help us understand what the driving factors would be. Let's suppose, for example, if I look politically at what's going on, the voices are very, very loud, especially on the political left. The viewpoint is that Look, we've bailed out Wall Street for way too long, way too many times. It's time to bail out Main Street. We need to institute universal basic income. We need to institute forgiveness of existing student loan debts. We need to institute new federal programs to provide free college tuition. We need to do a long list of other things. Nobody who's saying these things is offering the caveat Yeah. But I've also looked at Dr. Warburton's research, and I have some concerns about the potential inflationary impacts. No one's saying that. So, is this a matter of when there is a change of political control, when there's, let's say, a Democratic administration in the White House or Democratic control of the Congress that might lead to a lot of spending programs that suddenly inflation expectations change overnight?

tonight, or is this something that always has a lag effect where it's going to take a while before the effects are felt?

Peter Warburton: It's difficult to know exactly over what timescale even what looks like a very likely shift in policy behavior will occur. But the whole nature of financial markets is to be forward-looking, and it is the point at which investors begin to be unsettled on the horizon that they are used to investing, and where they begin to see capital risks for which they require compensation.

Now, as I say, there is a battle going on between financial repression and the most recent, I think, blatant example of that was the radical readjustment of the Federal Reserve's balance sheet management announced in March, which effectively turned us around from a $360 billion injection of further securities into the market to a $240 billion subtraction. So in other words, a $600 billion per annum turnaround in behavior. So if you like, the Fed has doubled down on its repression and substantially changed the prospective balance in the Treasury market as a consequence.

But clearly, that's a trick that it can only pull occasionally. I'm not to say— obviously, the Fed could revert to full-blown QE. And maybe this time, it might buy a wider variety of assets. I think many people from different points of view view the return of large-scale asset purchase as a very likely scenario.

And so you could say, well, I want to hold on to my financial assets because, you know, the central bank is going to be back, backstopping capital values. And, you know, therefore, I'm— I feel secure in that assumption. But obviously, countries are going to change their policies at different times and in different degrees.

And I think there are going to be some very important judgments around about the extent to which you really want to leave significant portions of your portfolio in a fixed income market where policy is likely to change radically and quickly.

Gold, negative yields and central-bank credibility

Erik Townsend: Something that's caught a lot of people's attention is the breakout through a very significant technical level in gold recently. And normally there's a very strong inverse correlation between the US Dollar Index and gold, and it seems like gold is suddenly outperforming the expectations that the value of the dollar would imply. Is this potentially a sign of the market waking up to and recognizing that inflation is, is about to pick up?

Peter Warburton: Not necessarily. I think obviously the ownership of gold is now quite diverse, and I think it is no longer dominated by those who hold gold very specifically as an inflation hedge. So I think the better way to understand this is if you put— if you correlate the value of negatively yielding government bonds or total bonds in the system with the gold price recently, you find you get a pretty similar curve. So you could say that it is merely the subtraction of real real yield— in other words, real yields going back down again to zero and below zero— that, if you like, that is the propellant for the gold price in the most recent period. In other words, it's the opportunity cost of holding gold has gone down.

But the broader point, I think, that I would make here is that— and this goes back to blowing up the box is to say, if the whole idea of central banks being, in some sense, independent actors at the heart of the financial system aiming to control inflation, if that whole idea is obsolete, then clearly, we might look to things like gold to be telling us that there's a general loss of confidence in central And, you know, one picture that I have is it's a bit like Superman and kryptonite. That basically the gold price is a bit like kryptonite to central bankers. That they they like to feel that they have provided a stable financial system, and that the yield that you get on an inflation protected government bond is better in every respect to. gold bullion that you have to pay to be stored and looked after.

But the reality is that recently gold has been outperforming inflation-protected bonds, which suggested that there's, there's something more serious going on.

Where consumer inflation shows up first: food and commodities

Erik Townsend: The last time that we went through quantitative easing and the market's reaction to it, there were widespread predictions that QE was going to unleash High inflation. Some people even went so far as to say hyperinflation. And of course, many people would argue that that didn't happen as predicted. I would say that the inflation occurred. It just happened in asset markets rather than in the broader economy. What are the things that we need to watch for? Obviously, you know, if we're looking at forgiveness of student loans and free college tuition, that's a completely different equation. than buying bonds to suppress interest rates. What are the things that are most likely to unleash consumer price inflation in the broader economy? And, and how might the next experience with QE differ from previous ones?

Peter Warburton: The way in which we might expect to see inflation return in the first instance might very well be through food and commodity prices. A lot of the work that we do on inflation is to try and integrate what's happening on, on the supply side, on the producer side of the, the goods and services market.

And I think the environment that we're heading into is a tough one for producers. I think that there are going to be all kinds of challenges to the continuity of supply. I think that diminished competition obviously is putting us more at risk of deliberate constriction of supply of food and commodities and natural resources.

So I think one avenue that we could expect to see inflation surprise might, again, very well be food price inflation, potentially perhaps another spike in crude oil prices, but also copper, iron ore, Copper, again, some of these key industrial metals could also surprise to the upside.

Stagflation risk and sector winners

Erik Townsend: Dr. Warburton, as we discuss the potential of coming inflation, one of the prognostications that I've seen from some very smart people is they're saying, hey, what's coming is 1970s or worse stagflation, not stagnant economic conditions where we don't really see growth in the economy, but we still have price inflation anyway. Is the recipe set to deliver that kind of outcome?

Peter Warburton: I think that's a risk that we should take much more seriously. I'd be ready to agree that we are probably late cycle in terms of global activity indicators. But I think what's fascinating about the latest batch of data, which we analyzed in some, in some detail, is that by numbers of countries that have a higher inflation rate that is measured in terms of their GDP, their national accounts, higher inflation rate than a year ago significantly outnumbers those with a lower inflation rate.

And at the same time, the number of those with a lower growth rate, a lower real GDP growth rate, significantly outnumbers those with a higher higher GDP growth rate of a year ago. So if you like, the twist in terms of numbers of countries is very clearly towards a more stagflationary outcome.

And we've always sought to keep the activity and the inflation narrative separate, and I think for good reason, because all 4 combinations are regularly recorded in economic history. So what it means, I think, in the broad analysis is that whereas at the moment you might say that, you know, sort of computer services and electronics and aerospace and defense might be quite sort of favored sectors for the environment as it is today, but we're moving into an environment where we should expect to see food producers, maybe pharmaceuticals, healthcare, beverages, Those kind of sectors to gain more pricing power and to obviously to be able to increase their margins and presumably record higher investor returns. So I, you know, it's, it's, it's still early days, but I, I think there's indications of a— the next twist will be in a stagflationary direction.

Wrap-up and how to reach Economic Perspectives

Erik Townsend: Well, Dr. Warburton, this has been a fascinating interview for me. Something I've said for 10 years now is I'm not smart enough to know when inflation is coming, but I predict it's going to be the return of inflation that really is going to bring about some difficult times for the economy. In any event, you are the Chief Economist for Economic Perspectives Limited. For our institutional audience who may be interested in following your work or learning more about Economic Perspectives, how can people contact you and follow

Peter Warburton: Sure. You can find us at our website, economicperspectives.co.uk. And, uh, yeah, you can find me on LinkedIn or indeed Economic Perspectives on, on LinkedIn and just, uh, shoot us an email at info@economicperspectives.co.uk. And we'd be delighted to engage with you and, uh, share some sample research.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. Well, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program Send your questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: financial repression needs inflation to cut debt

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Dr. Warburton on the show to talk about inflation. But what I took away from it was when he started talking about financial repression. And I thought it was really worth us kind of taking a deeper, expanded dive into understanding repression, because a lot of people, when they hear, you know, Juliette or any of our other guests talk about financial repression, a lot of people automatically just assume it's just keeping nominal interest rates lower than they would otherwise prevail to reduce government's interest expense and contribute to deficit reduction that a country is experiencing. But what What I find fascinating about it is that financial repression has a second element that is not always talked about. And it's this idea of how it is used to actually liquidate or reduce government debt.

And so, you know, governments have different ways they can get rid of debt. Obviously, Trump tried to economically grow out of the debt. And we saw in Italy and Greece where they tried austerity as a way to manage the debt. And then of course there's all the, the boogeyman guests that come out and talk about like the explicit default of government debt.

But through history, most governments deal with debt in 2 ways, which is they inflate it away or they engage in some form of financial repression to deal with that debt. And so, you know, to me, when, when we're talking about this inflation and this idea inflation is coming, to me it's an actual Yeah. It's an actual complement to financial repression, because if you're trying to suppress interest rates lower than they would naturally prevail, you're actually— the goal is to produce a negative real interest rate, which is that you create like what they reference to a financial repression tax or liquidation tax, which is if you create a negative real interest rate with the difference between inflation and nominal interest rates, it's a transfer from creditors to borrowers, and you can reset your debt that way. And that's why a lot of people, smart people, reference to, you know, during the Bretton Woods era as a period of financial repression in dealing with all the post-World War II debts where this type of exercise happened.

But one of the things I just want to kind of pick your brain on and really discuss it this way is like, in the end, financial repression needs inflation, not runaway inflation, but you have to create negative real yields. Like, in the end, we've seen financial repression in Japan for how long? But because they're having problems creating the inflation, they're not able to actually create debt reduction, and that's actually hurting their repression. So the question is, should we have inflation? Definitely, that's the goal, to have inflation. The question is, can they create it to the right amount to allow this to actually be able to reduce some of that debt?

Postgame: inflation lags, the MMT risk and pensions

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, inflation has a huge lag time, and I think what people have to remember— why Why is it that the Fed has been trying so hard to create inflation for so long and failing for so long? Is it really that they're stupid and inept? No, it's because there's a lag factor. And what I fear, Patrick, is we have this situation where we haven't had the amount of inflation that the Fed thinks is necessary. And people are thinking, oh, it's impossible, we'll never get it back.

Look, I have confidence in AOC and her squad. to create lots of inflation if they're given the opportunity to implement their policies. So we can get inflation back. But the thing is, what we have now is this attitude that it seems like nothing that you do creates inflation. So therefore, we don't have to worry about the risk of runaway inflation. And I think what happens is you have the risk of policy, which at first At first, it seems like the people who are proponents of heavy government spending, MMT, and so forth, it looks like they're being proven right because they pump lots and lots of money. It puts it in people's hands. Lots of people are happy. I've got money. It doesn't create problematic inflation at first. But when that inflation starts to get out of hand, it's already got momentum. And at that point, they can't stop it. And before you know it, we're into a stagflationary situation where the the inflation, because of the lag time, it really takes off.

And even after you slow down that government spending and entitlement programs and, and so on and so forth, the inflation is still crippling the economy. And I'm afraid that that's what we're headed to.

And I think as far as understanding all of this, Ray Dalio's article, which we had linked in last week's Research Roundup, I think gives an excellent explanation of what financial repression is all about. What the Fed is really in the business of doing, what governments in general are in the business of doing, is playing God and deciding, should we punish savers in order to make life easier for borrowers, or should we punish borrowers in order to make life better for savers? And it's so easy to say, oh, well, all the people of the world, you know, we need to take care of the borrowers because people are hurting and so forth. Well, what about all of the pensioners? What about the pension crisis we're creating along the way?

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: It's not as simple as a lot of people make it out to be.

Postgame: recession first, then fiscal spending and stagflation

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, the one thing though, I think it's pretty consensus that there's about to be a fiscal spend in our future. At some point, these governments are going to start even potentially printing some of this money or monetizing some of that debt in order to drive that fiscal spending. But if, you know, like we share a story in this Roundup about Jeffrey Gundlach saying that, you know, a recession is imminent. What if during the next slowdown is when this big spend occurs? Because during a recession you have asset deflation. So all stocks and real estate and things like this come under pressure and unemployment rises and most consumer confidence drops, which usually can be incredibly deflationary just from that entire cycle playing out. What if What if the fiscal spending is just actually keeping everything above water rather than creating inflation? I mean, do you see any merit in that kind of an argument?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think that that is a perfect setup if that happens, and that's exactly the way it will start. So I think everything you described is very likely in our future in the next year or 2. But what it does, Patrick, is it validates the proponents of MMT and heavy government spending And they say, look, we're providing all of these benefits to society. We're taking this printed money and we're providing universal basic income. And we're, you know, whatever they're gonna do, they're gonna forgive student loans and they're going to provide free tuition and whatever other entitlement programs they wanna add to an already overburdened system. They're going to be validated. It's going to appear to be working and working well because all this money's gonna be handed out, and we'll have a deflationary or disinflationary economic backdrop thanks to the recession. So, as you say, it all equals out and it's fine.

But that just allows them to build more political capital to spend and print even more. And my prediction is that it, it looks at first like the MMT crowd are the geniuses because they've delivered all kinds of benefit to society. It didn't cause runaway inflation in the first 6 months, and that means it's a success. And they do more of it and more of it and more of it. And it might take several years before the effects of that are felt, but when they are felt, it's going to take several years for that momentum of inflation to come back out of the system. And I predict that that will create stagflation at some point in our future. Probably not in the next couple years, but in the next 10 years, I think we've got a really heavy bout of stagflation, and that's where gold is going to be the asset to own.

Listener question: bull and bear steepeners and flatteners

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on, Erik, because I put together a chart because one of our guests emailed us asking for an explanation of the different types of steepeners and flatteners because they heard Julian Brigden talking about these and really wanted us to explain. And so I thought it was a great opportunity to put together a few charts to speak to it. So if you're looking for the downloads for this week's presentation, you'll find it in your Research Roundup email or look for the red button for downloads right beside Dr. Peter Warburton's picture on the homepage. So going into the chartbook, I actually want to jump to page 3 first here, Erik, where I show the 2s-10s spread, which is the way that we often show where we are in terms of whether there's an inversion or where we are in the curve. And what I wanted to do on slide 2 is really kind of see Where those numbers are derived from.

So what— here, what I'm showing on chart 2 is today's yield curve. And that is just showing where at the different durations of government bonds, what is the interest rate at that. So there's the 1-month, the 3-month, 1-year, 2-year, 5-year, 10-year, and 30-year yields here. And of course, where the inversion is, which is where the lowest part of the interest rates are, all lie in the kind of 2 to 5 year window, which has caused on the short end of the curve those inversions that we're hearing about. But yet we haven't seen inversion at the 2s, 10s.

So how does this work? What is this idea of a bull steepener versus a bear steepener? And so moving on to chart 4, we have the example of a bull steepener, which is the idea that short-term interest rates are falling faster than long-term interest rates. So what's going on here with the bull steepener?

Erik Townsend: Well, the reason that this is called a bull steepener is a little bit confusing and counterintuitive. What is a steepener to start with? A steepener means you're making a bet that the curve is going to get steeper. In other words, the right-hand side of the chart is going to be higher relative to where it is now, and the left side of the chart is going to be What that bet really is, the way you put a steepener trade on, is actually with 2 positions. One of them is a bullish trade on short-term Treasury paper. The other one is a bearish trade on long-term Treasury paper. Now, if either one of those bets pays off, the curve gets steeper. But the question is, wait a minute, when we said the, the curve is steeper, Steepening. It's steepening for which reason? It's steepening because the front end of the curve is going down in yield, or it's steepening because the back end of the curve is going up in yield?

Well, the way that we answer that question is by which trade is being successful.

If the bullish bet— and the part about this is that seems to be very counterintuitive— is, wait a minute, the front end of the curve, the yield's going down, how is that bullish? Well, remember that yields are inverse or reciprocal of the actual price of the bonds. So if you're making a bet which is bullish on the price of bonds, you're going to make money when the yield goes down. So the bullish bet on bond prices is the one that profits when short-term bonds go down in yield. The bearish bet is the one that profits when longer-dated bonds go up in yields. So the steepening that occurs when When the bullish bet is the one that's responsible for making your profit, that's a bull steepener. The bull bet paid off. A bear steepener is when the bearish bet pays off. And the thing that's counterintuitive is the bearish one is the one where the, the number on yield goes up, and the bullish one is the one where the number on yield goes down.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So you can see that on page 5, where we're showing that the yields on the long end of the curve at the 10s and 10s and 30s are where they're the ones that are going up at a much faster pace. That's where the long-term rates are rising faster than the short-term, like you're saying there.

When we go to pages 6 and 7, now we're talking about the flatteners, which is something we've seen a lot of. A bull flattener, at the same way, Erik, is that the long-term rates in this situation are actually falling faster than short-term rates.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Patrick Ceresna: Often this is when inflation expectations are curtailing, right?

Erik Townsend: Right. And again, the reason for that is if you're talking about a flattener, which is the opposite of a steepener, the flattener has a bullish bet at the long end of the curve, betting that the long end of the curve is going to go down in yield, which is a bullish bet on bond prices. And when that one is paying off, that is a bull flattener.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so obviously, and then to the other side of it is a flattener, which is that short-term rates are rising faster than those long-term rates, right? And so often that is occurring contributed by Fed raising interest rates.

Sign-off, sponsor reads and Research Roundup contents

Erik Townsend: And if all of that is a little bit too confusing to follow, one very simple financial equation that you can easily understand is a price of zero for a 14-day complimentary access pass to Patrick's Big Picture Trading service where he He gives daily webinars where you can learn a whole lot more about this stuff. But Patrick, we're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time for this episode. Today's episode was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro to claim your free book and subscribe to their podcast as well. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo.

And don't forget to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email, which provides a compendium of links to all of the best content we could find on the internet each week, including downloads to support our own presentations, as well as all the best research that we could find. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're gonna find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the Sharpe book for Dr. Peter Warburton. And there's a link to Dr. Warburton's presentation and the steepener charts that we discussed in the postgame. There's an article discussing Jeffrey Gundlach's view that the Fed will be in panic mode when the next recession hits, and a Jesse Felder article that leveraged investors could be signaling a bear market is underway. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners. And And we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and Macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents for from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if You haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall Not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Jim Rickards — Author (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 176 was recorded on July 18th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the leading podcast when it comes to systematic trading and investing. Author Jim Rickards is back as this week's feature interview guest and will discuss the content of his latest book. Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will discuss Ray Dalio's latest article, which concludes by saying something that we've said many times over here on MacroVoices, which is that gold will be an important asset to own in the 2020s.

Market wrap: S&P 500 and the paradigm shift

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 earlier in the week was making new highs, and we've since been backing off from there. We're just below 3,000 on the level at the time of recording. What's your thinking here on the S&P 500?

Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, I listened to the last few episodes and I seem to just say the same thing about the S&P every week and get longer-winded every time. So I'm gonna try to tighten it up. Look, what I've been waiting for is what Ray Dalio, in this article we're gonna talk about in postgame, calls a paradigm shift. We've been in an environment where central bank liquidity has been the driver of higher asset prices, and that's ultimately unsustainable. Someday it has to end and reverse. And that's exactly what Ray Dalio says.

Now, I've been thinking it's long overdue and surely about to be here. It's very interesting. You know, Ray Dalio is certainly far more accomplished than I am. He says it's coming, but could be a couple years still. So, uh, I don't know when it's happening. I do know that this market doesn't make sense to me. But as far as wanting to get excited about shorting the market or something, uh, no, I'm, I'm not doing that because the market's not doing what I think it should be doing. And I don't see any reason to think, just because I think so, that it's going to change. So let's go deeper into Ray Dalio's perspective in Postgame.

Market wrap: US Dollar Index

Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to the US Dollar Index, where it seems to be making higher lows but lower highs, consolidating sideways in, in a chop. But what's surprising is that when you go to the euro, the euro just looks so weak. Even the pound sterling breaking to fresh lows. It seems like the dollar may have a shot here on the upside. What's your thinking?

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm sad that it hasn't dipped down to 96 on the September contract because I'd love to Buy more there. And I think that would form a right shoulder on an inverse head and shoulders pattern. And if that were to occur, the target of that head and shoulders would take us right up into the major resistance zones at 97.50 and 98. And those are definitely the areas to watch. A breakout above 98, I think, would signal a move much higher. There's plenty of smart people that disagree with me and think it's topping here. So the ultimate test is gonna be, you know, daily close, or better yet, a weekly or monthly close above 98. In the meantime, I still think it looks very bullish.

Market wrap: crude oil

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, I've been waiting all week to ask you about crude oil and what's going on here, because as of Monday till now, we've just seen close to $5 wiped out to the downside. Is this a major reversal? Are we going lower here, or is this just a blip?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think that we're going lower until something changes. And, you know, as I've said for weeks on the program, I feel that the economics have been calling for much lower prices for several weeks. But the thing is, as long as you have escalating tension with Iran and big inventory drawdowns at the same time, obviously we're going to keep pushing higher and higher to the limits of how high it could go. I think we found how high it could go, and both of those 2 drivers fell out of the market this week. We had President Trump making a comment that they're ready to negotiate with Iran. Now, I'm not as persuaded as the market is that that really is, uh, is bearish for prices. I, I don't think necessarily that ready to negotiate and ready to make concessions are necessarily the same thing. But one way or another, the market took it as Iran is de-escalating rather than escalating further. And in the very same week, we got a much, much smaller drawdown in crude oil inventory.

So let's start with EIA. Crude oil drawing down 3.1 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 1.4 million barrels. Gasoline, though, building 3.6 million barrels. And distillates building a massive, massive 5.7 million barrels. So yes, it was still a drawdown on crude oil, but there are several factors to take into account here that really make this look bearish as opposed to bullish. The, the first one is, yeah, it's a crude drawdown, but it's offset by a much larger product build. The other factor is it was a hurricane week.

Imports are way down because the ships can't get in and out of Houston due to the hurricane in the Gulf. Production is down as a result of 15 rigs being evacuated in the Gulf of Mexico. So it's no surprise. Now remember though, these are weather-related anomalies. They're not necessarily the beginning of a new trend. So the tape action was down hard in reaction to the Iran news from President Trump, down even harder in reaction to inventory news. Although I would point out that there was a pause there. The market didn't really rifle lower the way it sometimes does in reaction to inventory. It was a slow reaction. Then eventually people thought it through and said, hmm, too many factors that are bearish here. Ended up closing way down on the day on Wednesday, inventory day, with more follow-through today. Now, US production was down to 12 million barrels from a high of 12.4 million barrels.

That would normally cause me some concern. It would make me to start to worry that maybe we're seeing a trend reversal here. But again, you've got to consider the hurricane effects. You've got production that was affected by all these rigs in the Gulf of Mexico being shut in temporarily to weather the storm for the hurricane. So we can't go by this week's number or next week's number because they're going to be affected by weather effects. Imports were down to 6.8 million barrels, exports down to 2.5 million barrels.

Now, the reason I'm skeptical of this de-escalation is, first of all, until now President Trump has been very clear and, and very committed to this policy of very firm negotiations with Iran. If you think about President Trump's history, you know, Donald Art of the Deal Trump has been very, very concerned about oil prices. He's done things in the past to send false signals that would kind of shock oil prices lower. If he wants to get tough with Iran, which I think may be what's really going on here, it would perfectly be in character for him to say we're ready to negotiate with Iran in a way that he knew was going to cause the market to assume that meant we're ready to, uh, to make concessions and so forth. Oil prices go down, which is what he wants. And then when they get into that actual negotiation, we find out that actually they're not really willing to make a lot of concessions.

Maybe I'm completely off base with that, but I don't think that we have sufficient information to conclude right now that the Iran situation is de-escalating. It looks that way, or the market is interpreting the signal that way. We'll see what ultimately happens. But certainly prices are headed down. And at this point we hit this afternoon, I I had a tweet out. We almost got to $3 on what's known as the 5-day gap, the gap between the current price of WTI crude oil. Actually, as I'm looking at my chart as we're taping, we just hit it again, back to $3, a 5-day gap. That's the difference between the current price and where the 5-day moving average is. It doesn't mean that there's not more downside. I think there probably is more downside coming unless we get a different signal on what's really going on with Iran. But the thing is, we're oversold here and we're way overdue for a bounce. So we've got to narrow that 5-day moving average gap, and that can happen either of two ways.

As we're speaking and recording now on Thursday afternoon, we're right at about $55. The 5-day moving average is all the way up at $57.93. So either we see a big bounce up to narrow that gap, or we see a little stabilization and trading sideways here to allow the 5-day moving average to catch down to the current price. But the gap being more than $3, it's very unusual for that to be sustained. So I think we're probably due for a bounce here. I do think that there will be further downside, and I think there's plenty of room to see prices go right back down to $50 if and only if the, the Iran message continues to be one of de-escalation. I won't be surprised if that changes.

Market wrap: gold

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold. And we're edging up once again to 52-week highs. Not there yet, but edging there. What's, what's your thinking here on where gold's going next?

Erik Townsend: Well, we've been in a consolidation range between $1,390 and $1,440. So a decisive break with a daily close, or better yet, a weekly close above $1,440 is super bullish. There's just no denying that. On the other hand, if we saw a break below $1,390, That could be either of two things. It could be just a setup for a very, very common pattern in technical analysis, which is where we would see a retest of the breakout zone, which is somewhere between 1350 and 1377. We would test that as support before moving to a much higher price. The other possibility, of course, is it could be the beginning of an actual breakdown to much lower numbers. Now, most people disagree with me on the dollar. I think the dollar has room to break out here and move much higher. The fact that so many people disagree with me means that most of them are not positioned for it.

And that means that if I'm right, the break will probably be a big and sudden one that catches a lot of people wrong-footed. That could spell serious trouble for gold if it happens. And again, I could be wrong about the dollar. Now, Ray Dalio commenting in his recent article that we'll discuss in detail in postgame that gold is the place to be was huge news. Ray Dalio is one of the most influential people in finance. anywhere, widely regarded as the most successful hedge fund manager in existence anywhere in the world. So the fact that Ray Dalio said gold is it and we didn't see an instant reactionary, you know, knee-jerk move above $1,440 actually surprised me. Now, to be clear, Ray is talking about the next decade, not the next month. But the way markets tend to work is, you know, it's Ray Dalio said it, oh my gosh, you know, buy gold, everybody Buy, buy, buy, run and be in a frenzy.

So that didn't happen, which actually surprised me. The thing to remember though about Ray Dalio's view, he's talking about the reasons that gold is going to be the thing to own in the next decade. And that's something that we've been saying for years on MacroVoices, that gold, I've said, will be the asset to own.

The thing is, gold can go down to $1,000 before moving sharply higher, and Ray will still be right, exactly right, in everything he says in this article. So the fact that Ray Dalio is saying buy gold doesn't mean that it has to go up from here. That's really not the call that he's making. He's not trying to make a tactical call. The thing though, Patrick, as you said, is we are— even in the time we've been speaking about gold, we've moved another dollar higher. We're well above $1,430 now. It's another $10 to the upside in a daily close there, and you've got a really serious bullish signal. So So the balance of evidence is suggesting that the move higher in gold is already happening. The place where I do see a surprise factor is if I'm right about the dollar, it would probably result in some kind of pullback for gold. Maybe what happens is I'm right about the dollar and that just gives us the pullback down to $1,377 again, and it goes all uphill from there.

But I think if you're buying gold here, you do have to be concerned about the dollar. As I've said before, I think the way to hedge that is to be long gold and long the dollar at the same time.

Market wrap: 10-year yield and European junk bonds

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yields, because after a week of rising yields, I think we were near 2.15 at one point, we're back down to around the 2.05 level on the yield. Do you think another spurt to the downside's coming here in the yield?

Erik Townsend: You know, I hope not, just because I was waiting for it to back up a little more. I was hoping we'd see 2.20 or so, so I could buy on the long side of this trade. I'm carefully watching it, but I don't really have a strong opinion. I think that Ray Dalio makes an excellent argument counter to someone like Jeff Gundlach or even Julian Brigden, who think that we're headed to much higher interest rates. Dalio says central banks have so many reasons to not allow that to occur that he expects that we will get to a stabilization, but then That will just stay at zero for a long time. So we'll come back to that. The other thing, I don't remember if we've mentioned in past episodes or not, but we're seeing more and more negative-yielding junk bonds in Europe. This is utterly ludicrous. Negative-yielding junk bonds is going to be something that will go down in the history books as one of the craziest things ever to happen in the history of finance.

And that doesn't mean it's time to jump on board and short them here, because the fact they got negative in the first place was crazy.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: It's not that much more crazy to see them get more negative. So, we're into just utterly nutso logic in at least some isolated parts of the European junk bond market. Who knows how much farther that can go?

Listener emails: donations as subscription prepayments

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, thanks for the update. Now, before we go on to this week's feature interview with Jim Rickards, please give us a quick update on the emails we've been receiving from our listeners about our expanded content.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I was really inspired by a couple of emails we got this week. Dr. Steve Bickel wrote in with a suggestion. Steve applauded us for doing all that we can do to keep MacroVoices free by looking for sponsorship rather than moving to a paid subscriber model. But since he knows that we're starved for cash to produce all of the new content we've been producing until we find more sponsors, Steve just decided to set up a recurring monthly donation on PayPal in the amount that he said he would expect to pay if we were a subscription service. Now, for Steve, that number was $50 a month, equivalent to $600 a year, which is what he figured a subscription ought to cost based on the value that he derives from MacroVoices. So he wrote to me and suggested, hey, why don't you explain the rationale that led me to this, and maybe other people will follow in my footsteps?

We also got another email from a listener who expressed the view that he too wants to donate, but he's a little bit worried that he could end up having to pay twice if we eventually do move to a paid subscription model and he has to buy a subscription after he just paid a big donation. That's a really good point that I hadn't thought of. So what he suggested, and what we're going to do, is to simply make a policy of counting any donations that we receive after January 1st, 2019 as prepayments toward a paid subscription if we're ever forced to go that route. So you'll be able to apply any donation you make now toward paying for your subscription if we're ever forced to charge you for a subscription. So consider that done. We do keep track of all the donations and we'll credit them, you know, as I've just described. Our strong hope is that we won't have to do that.

We want to secure the sponsors that we need, and we really need our listeners' help in doing that. So if you work for a company that would make a good sponsor for MacroVoices, please let the appropriate people in your company know about us. But I certainly agree that we should protect our donors in this way. So I hope some of you will consider following Dr. Steve Bickel's example Decide how much value you derive yourself from listening to MacroVoices every week and set up a recurring donation that automatically donates whatever amount you feel is fair for the value that you derive. It's very easy to set up recurring automatic monthly donations using the donate button on our homepage at MacroVoices.com, and any donations that you make will be counted as payments if we ever have to charge for a subscription model.

Patrick Ceresna: Oh, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Jim Rickards. Now, Erik, why did we invite Jim back onto the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Jim's books have been super popular, and we've also had a number of requests to get him back on the show. We haven't had him on since, I think it was the book before his last book.

Erik Townsend: So his new book is coming out next week. It seemed like a good time. And this episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Although I'm a global macro investor myself, it's a fact that quant-based strategies are dominating the rankings of top-performing managers. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well-researched and tested. And this year, they're off to a flying start. And there's one podcast that covers this area of finance better than any other: toptradersunplugged.com.

And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book explaining how these systematic strategies can work for you. Just go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro. Check them out, you'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Jim Rickards is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Jim Rickards: debt-to-GDP history and the broken pattern

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's Hedge Fund

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Jim Rickards, bestselling author, and Jim has a brand new book coming out next week. It's available now for preorder on Amazon and through other outlets. The title of the book is Aftermath: 7 Secrets of Wealth Preservation in the Coming Chaos. Jim, thanks so much for joining us. I want to start with what I think is really the core issue behind just about everything else we talk about in economics, which is just There's burgeoning debt around the world. And I think, you know, sovereign debt is what we tend to focus the most on. But frankly, the private debt problem is just as big. And I feel like the world ignores this. At what point is the question that's always on my mind. At what point do we get to where the breaking point is reached and the bad predictions that all the smart people like yourself have been making for decades, finally we hit that breaking point and things start to break?

Give us a little bit of perspective. I know you cover this early in the book about how there's been a progression of debt increase, and it's not linear. So, give us the backstory.

Jim Rickards: Sure. It's a great question, Erik. And by the way, in terms of predictions, I was in London in what they call a capsule on the London Eye. That's the big Ferris wheel on the South Bank of the Thames on June 20th, 2016. And I looked in the camera and I said, the UK is going to vote to leave the EU and you should short sterling and buy gold. We put that out ahead of the vote. Of course, the vote was a shocker that the UK did vote to leave. And I got emails after that, you know, thanks for putting my kids through college because I took your advice on that. And there was a lot of profit made from getting that right.

And then in late October, early November 2016, I was traveling around the world, Australia, Europe, and then in New York and kind of looked in the camera on a lot of networks and said that Trump was going to win the election and pretty much got laughed at. But we got that one right as well. I use proprietary models. They're quite different from what government officials and Wall Street use. But we've actually been getting very, very good results in our predictive analytics.

But yeah, you ask a bigger picture question, which is what about the debt? You know, you can go all the way back to David Stockman in the early 1980s. He sort of got— smart guy, nice guy, I know David, but kind of got booted out of the Reagan administration for sounding warnings about the debt. And here we are, you know, 35 years later, the debt's much bigger and the, you know, the end of the world doesn't seem to have arrived. So, so there are 2 things. Number one, when most people talk about it, they talk about high debt amounts. Uh, the, the metric I use is the debt-to-GDP ratio. And the way I explain it to people, you know, if you owe $25,000 on a credit card, is that a problem or not? Well, if you make $25,000 a year and you owe $25,000 on the credit card, you're probably going to go bankrupt. But if you make, you know, $500,000 $100,000 a year and you owe the same $25,000, you can probably pay it off with one check.

So in other words, you can't understand whether the debt's a problem or not unless you compare it to your capacity to pay the debt, which is, you know, income for an individual or GDP in the case of a country.

So I look at the debt-to-GDP ratio. Now what's interesting about that is a lot of people just assume kind of naively that, well, you know, George Washington became president in 1789 and started borrowing some money, and we've been borrowing ever since, and here we are, you know, at 23 trillion, which is the US national debt today. And it just kept going up and up over the course of US history. That's not true. Uh, first of all, we had national debt before we had a nation. When George Washington was sworn in, we already had some national debt left over from the Revolutionary War. And the Congress said, well, we have a simple solution, just don't pay it. You know, that's the American way, just, just default. And it was Alexander Hamilton who said, no, what we should do is borrow more, pay off the old debt, And then after that, we can borrow more and pay off the new debt and just keep rolling it over.

And that was the creation of the US Treasury market, the US government securities market. It's been working very successfully for the 230-odd years ever since. But the debt did not go straight up. It went up and then it came down and then it went up and then it came down. It's much more of like a wave, a sine wave than a straight line.

Well, what's the driver behind that? Well, generally, and it's more than general, it's pretty pretty high correlation. Debt goes up in times of war. We borrow money to fight a war, whether it was the War of 1812 or the Mexican-American War, the Civil War, etc. And then we pay it off in times of peace.

And there's good reason for that, because you want to have some dry powder. If you take US debt capacity to the limit in times of peace, and then so where's your capacity to borrow more if you actually need it for something more existential such as a war?

So the pattern has been up and down. In fact, in 1836, at the end of Andrew Jackson's administration. Jackson did 2 things. He paid off the national debt. We actually had zero debt in 1836, a lot less than when George Washington was president. And he got rid of the central bank. So from 1836 to 1913, starting with no debt and no central bank, we had a great period of prosperity. But the sine wave has now been broken. And that's, that's the news. That's the disturbing part.

So at the end of World War II, The US debt-to-GDP ratio was about 120%, the highest it's ever been in US history. Well, you look back at that and say, well, yeah, but we had the Great Depression. We had to try to spend our way out of that. And then we had World War II, where you don't care how much you spend because you have to win the war. So people understood that. But from 1946 to 1980, so think Harry Truman to Ronald Reagan, that debt-to-GDP ratio was whittled down from 120% to 30%. At the end of the Carter administration in 1980, early 1981, it was 30%, which is a very low, very manageable ratio. And what impressed me about that was that it was continuous. In other words, it was not a partisan issue. You had Democrats and Republicans. So Democrats, you know, Harry Truman, John Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, Jimmy Carter, and Republicans, you know, Dwight Eisenhower, Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, they worked together and along with the Fed and the Treasury, and they got that down.

And so that's the most impressive example of what I'm describing, which is it goes up during war and down during peacetime.

Now, Reagan took it up again. You know, this idea that Reagan was a fiscal conservative is not true. Reagan was a big spender. Reagan took the debt-to-GDP ratio from 30% to 50%, but he won the Cold War. So, you know, the Cold War wasn't as much shooting as these other wars, but it was just as much of an existential threat. So I give Reagan credit. I was like, yeah, he spent a lot of money, but you had Star Wars and a 600-ship Navy and a lot of other technology, and we won the Cold War. Yeah. So based on the pattern I'm describing, as I said, which is well over 200 years old, what should have happened after that would be the debt would come down.

Now, George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton, again, one Republican, one Democrat, they kept a lid on it. They didn't get it down very much, but they kept it from getting higher. And at the end of the Clinton administration in early 2001, the debt was $5 trillion and the debt-to-GDP ratio was a little over 50%. So nice job keeping a lid on it, but they didn't bring it down very much.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Jim Rickards: Very much, but that's okay. That's still a manageable number.

But there we ran off the rails. George W. Bush, Bush 43, doubled the debt from $5 trillion to $10 trillion. And then Obama in 2 terms doubled it again from a higher base, from $10 trillion to $20 trillion. So, so just, I mean, just think of that. When Clinton left, doesn't seem that long ago, it was $5 trillion. Today it's $23 trillion, and, and Trump's throwing another trillion on top of it. So all of a sudden 2 things have happened.

Number one, the pattern of trying to bring it down— yeah, I understand we had 9/11 and a war in Afghanistan and the Iraq War, which is sort of a war of choice, so you can make a little bit of allowance for that. But nothing really during the Obama administration and nothing so far during the Trump administration. Yet those 3 presidents— Bush, Obama, and Trump— have taken the debt from $5 trillion to $23 trillion, not in a time of war. Now we are completely off the rails.

Jim Rickards: growth, inflation or default

Jim Rickards: The pattern, this 200-year, 200-plus-year pattern I described, is broken. And something else has happened. The debt-to-GDP ratio is now 106%.

Now what's new is that there's some very good research, and here you have to look to Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff, and they, they have an 800-year study in their book This Time It's Different, but they have more focused studies over the last 200 years, even the last 100 years, with a large database of countries. And what they And to me, it's very convincing. It's all publicly available, of course, is that when you get to 60% debt to GDP, you're in the danger zone. You're not completely off the rails. And this is why Angela Merkel in Germany tries to keep Europe under 60%, and Germany is. But when you get to 90%, now you're in the red zone. What happens is you can still borrow more. It doesn't mean there's a debt crisis. But what it means is that you can't grow. All of a sudden, Keynes said in a depression or a liquidity trap, You can borrow money and increase aggregate demand and kind of grow your way out of it.

There's some truth in that if you're starting from a low base, a manageable base, if you're in a recession or a depression or just coming out of one and there's a lot of slack in the economy. If all those conditions are true, which they were in the Great Depression, that can work. But at current levels where unemployment's at 50-year lows, capacity's tight, we're in the 10th year of a recovery, not a recession, and the debt-to-GDP ratio is sky high, what the Ryan Reinhart Rogoff research shows is that more debt actually slows you down. You cannot borrow your way out of it. You cannot— borrowing doesn't give you growth. It actually just keeps you in a rut. Well, that's where we are now. So you've sort of got people running around Washington trying this Keynesian approach. Oh, let's just borrow more. But the evidence is that it doesn't work.

So the problem, Erik, is that it's not that there's going to be a debt crisis tomorrow. There could be, but I'm not forecasting that. What I'm saying is that we've got a different crisis, which is no growth. We cannot get enough growth. If your debt's growing at 5%, 6%, 7% of GDP, which it is, but your economy is only growing about 2% in real terms, or even, you know, 4% nominally if you want to throw on inflation, which it is, then your debt's going up faster than your growth. So how do you grow your way out of that? You can't. How do you pay it off? You can't. And so today, debt is a headwind to growth.

Now, how are you going to pay off the debt? People say, well, we can't pay off the debt. Well, you don't have to pay it off, but you do have to roll it over, meaning you have to borrow enough new to pay off the old debt, pay the interest, finance new deficits if you have any. So it's not like you got to pay off $22 trillion tomorrow, but you do have to maintain a bond market and you do have to maintain your borrowing capacity.

Well, how do you do that? Well, there are 3 ways. One is growth. The next one is inflation. If you get enough inflation, the debt kind of melts away. And the third is just outright default. I won't pay Well, let's just look at those 3 things. I just explained that at these levels, you're not going to get the growth. You're not. And we've had a 10-year expansion, yeah, but average growth is 2.2%.

All expansions since 1980, the average growth is 3.2%. So if you think that a percentage, 1 percentage point doesn't sound like a lot, it is. Because, you know, growth is kind of in a narrow range, maybe, you know, -4 to +5 at the extremes. Well, since Since 2009, when the expansion started, a 1% difference in growth compounded over 10 years, that's about $4 trillion of missing wealth.

That's how much richer the economy would be and we would be if we'd had 3.2% growth instead of 2.2% growth. $4 trillion. So that's the cost of low growth, and that's the cost of high debt. So we can't grow our way out because we have too much debt.

We can't get inflation because inflation is psychological. I mean, think about it. For 10 years to get inflation to 2%. They haven't been able to do it. They touched 2% briefly and it turned right around, and now it's back down to 1.6%. So I like to say it's a sad day when a central bank wants inflation and can't get it, but that's because they don't understand what causes inflation. It's not money supply, and that's nonsense. It's, it's behavioral, it's psychological, it's velocity, it's, it's people's level of confidence and their inflationary expectations.

So we can't default because we can just print the money. We can't get inflation because of psychology and lack of velocity, and we don't have the growth. So how do we get out of this? Well, the answer is you can't. You're either going to have a crisis, you're going to eventually get to inflation even though we're not there yet, or you're just going to basically have no growth as far as the eye can see, which is Japan. So I like to say the US is Japan.

So the point is, just to kind of wrap up, The debt problem— can you have an acute overnight debt crisis that would lead to something worse than 2008? Yes, that is possible. But it's not the only danger. The other danger is just a slow slog where you look like Japan. You don't have dynamic growth. Your debt-to-GDP ratio keeps going up. It's like you're in a lifeboat, but it's sinking. It doesn't have to capsize immediately. It can sink slowly, but you still end up underwater.

Jim Rickards: Modern Monetary Theory and dollar confidence

Erik Townsend: Jim, something that I've noticed is, as people start to become aware of these issues, the first human reaction you have to listening to David Stockman or yourself or Jim Grant is, boy, we got to do something about the debt. But if there's anything I've learned, you know, what you and I think is not important. What's important is to look at what society as a whole is actually doing, what the trend is, what they're likely to do next. And Modern Monetary Theory, theory is all about a whole philosophy that says, look, don't worry about any of this. We have a deflationary backdrop. This is an opportunity to monetize whatever the hell we want. We can do all kinds of social programs. We can provide universal basic income, free healthcare, forgive student debt, and we'll pay for all of it by monetization.

Obviously, that's completely at odds with what you and I might think is sanity, but I think it behooves us to just accept that whether we agree or not, that's what's happening in society.

So how do you see this debt situation playing out if you and I are afraid that we're coming to a total reset of the IMS because of too much debt, but really the trend in society is let's make some more?

Jim Rickards: Well, first of all, I think that's a very good capsule description of what's going on, Erik, so I agree with your your overview or your description. Right. Modern monetary theory. I've actually met with and spoken personally to a lot of the leading advocates. I think that the big brain in this is Stephanie Kelton. She's a professor at Stony Brook State University of New York. Paul McCulley, former, I think, number 2 guy at PIMCO for many years, is an advocate of this. Warren Mosler, former hedge fund manager, now lives in the US Virgin Islands, perennial congressional candidate from the Virgin Islands. Smart guy. But I've spoken to all of personally about this. And I have to say, modern monetary theory, of all the things I've debated, and I've debated, you know, whatever, gold, cryptos, debt, you know, you name it, it was difficult for me to form the rebuttal. My gut instinct was that it was wrong. It couldn't possibly be the way forward.

But the way it's presented is so kind of at least superficially appealing that it took a while to actually develop the rebuttal.

So anyway, here's what they say. So the US debt-to-GDP ratio I mentioned is 106%. Well, Japan is about 250%. So, they look at that and go, well, if you fly to Tokyo, it's not like people are living in tent cities the way they are in San Francisco. It's actually a very prosperous economy. The lights are on in the Ginza. Things seem to be doing fine. So, you sort of say, what's the problem? Debt-to-GDP ratio is not a big deal. And it used to be the case.

So, when you hear things like— you mentioned a few of them— healthcare for all, free tuition, forgive student loans, Green New Deal, you know, child care for all, guaranteed basic income, you know, whatever it is. It used to be there was a simple answer to that in a policy debate. You just say, yeah, well, interesting, but we can't afford it.

And then that would shut down the debate because you look at the numbers I described earlier, you say, yeah, you're right, we can't afford it. But now when you say to them we can't afford it, they say yes we can. What's the problem? Just borrow the money. And if the Treasury market gets a little balky, then the Fed can monetize the debt, stick it away on your balance sheet for 30 years and collect it at maturity. What is the problem? We're not using our debt capacity as aggressively and as extensively as we can.

And by the way, when you ask them for empirical evidence of that, they point to our friend Ben Bernanke. I mean, Bernanke kind of proved that you can print as much money as you want without adverse consequences.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Jim Rickards: Now, Bernanke and Yellen, although she actually kind of came in when they were trying to get it under control, but Bernanke printed almost $4 trillion. Now, new money. Now, he did it for different reasons. He was trying to run a zero interest rate policy, trying to bail out the banks. If the banks didn't have to pay anything for their liabilities and could lend at 2% and leverage it 10 to 1, you get a 20% return on equity. What's not to like? Kept Jamie Dimon's bonus in good shape. So Bernanke was doing it to bail out the banking system and protect Jamie Dimon. But Stephanie Kelton— by the way, Professor Kelton, she's a well-known economist, but she's also the chief economic advisor to Bernie Sanders' 2020 campaign. So Sanders, we'll see how he does. But if Sanders ever became president, you can bet that Stephanie would be something, Deputy Secretary of Treasury, head of the OMB. You'd see her in other places.

A very prominent position. So, so this is real. These, these people are making headway in the political system. But she would say, hey, if you can borrow $4 trillion to prop up Jamie Dimon, you can borrow $4 trillion for the Green New Deal, or you can borrow $4 trillion for, uh, to forgive student loans or guarantee basic income, or really anything you want.

Bernanke proved you can do it. His reasons were different from theirs, or His goals were different from theirs, but as far as printing money is concerned, Bernanke kind of proved that it's not a problem. So when you, when you put it that way, when you say, well, you know, Japan has a much higher debt-to-GDP ratio, Bernanke proved that you can print a lot of money and not, you know, get hyperinflation or destroy the world, and we have other priorities— when you say all those things, it's very hard to rebut. Like, how do you, how do you shut down? How do you rebut that? How do you answer that? Well, here's the answer, and it's something that they don't even think about, and that's usually what most people's blind spot is.

It's true, there is no legal limit on how much the Fed can print. In the short run, at least, there is a legal limit on how much the Treasury can borrow. There is a debt ceiling, but the Congress routinely raises the debt ceiling. So that has never been an impediment, and people would not see it as such. And there's no limit on how much the Fed can print.

I once had a dinner with one of the members of the Board of Governors of the Fed, and I said, It was probably after a half bottle of wine, but I said, you're on the board of an insolvent bank. The Fed is insolvent. And she said, no, we're not. On a mark-to-market basis, not on a historical cost basis. I said, the Fed's insolvent. She said, no, we're not. And she goes, no one's done that calculation. I said, well, I have, and I think others have. And then she kind of harrumphed and said, well, maybe, but central banks don't need capital. And that hit me right between the eyes. Like, well, legally you're right. Central banks don't need capital. They can take it as high as they want. So they say, what's the problem?

And there's one more element. This is critical. So what about confidence? What about the psychological aspects? Now, the MMT, the Modern Monetary Theory people say, well, that's irrelevant because the government makes you pay taxes. And only dollars can be used to pay taxes. Try paying your taxes with gold or silver or soybeans sometime. I mean, they won't take it. They'll take dollars. So as long as the government forces you to make dollars to pay your taxes, you cannot reject the dollar. You're locked into a dollar system. And this is actually called the state theory of money. And this, by the way, modern monetary theory, there's nothing modern about it. This goes back to the early 20th century. And, uh, it's not much of a theory because there's no, you know, not much empirical evidence to support it. But anyway, that's what they call it. So they say, no, you're forced to, you're forced to like dollars whether you like them or not because it's the only way you can pay your taxes.

So just follow that through. I said, well, okay, What if what if you don't pay your taxes? Not advocating that, by the way, but just as a thought experiment. What if you don't pay your taxes? Well, you get some nasty letters from the IRS, but then they stop with the nasty letters and they come with a marshal and break down your door and arrest you and put handcuffs on you and take you to jail. You end up in jail if you don't pay your taxes and you don't somehow resolve that with the government. So their idea of confidence in money is is achieved at the point of a gun, and it's really a neo-fascist theory in my view. Fascism defined as, uh, you know, not funny people with bald heads and black shirts, but fascism is just the government controls everything. And that is, is where they're going with this. Well, that turns out to be historically and, and factually incorrect. There are— just take Mark Zuckerberg as an example.

So he's worth, you know, whatever, $100 billion on a good day. How much in taxes Mark Zuckerberg paid? Well, the answer is very, very little because his wealth is from the market value of Facebook stock. You know, he got the stock as a founder, fine. Company is very successful. It's worth, you know, well over $100 billion, maybe multiple hundred billion dollars. His share is worth $100 billion. But if you don't sell the stock, you don't owe any tax. And he's given some to foundations. He sold some. He's written a few checks to the IRS. But my point is, his tax burden is minuscule relative to his wealth because it's tied up in mark-to-market gains on Facebook stock. And that's true of many of the wealthiest people in the country. You know, Elon Musk has got his Tesla stock and so on. And, you know, it's true of many others. And so the point is, there are a lot of alternatives to taxes. You can leave the country, you can buy assets and just hold them.

You can, you know, if it happens to be stock, you get capital gains treatment. So that's a much lower rate than people pay on ordinary income. So it turns out that the tax avoidance mechanisms, legal ones I'm talking about, are ubiquitous. And it's really kind of the average working person is the only one who actually pays taxes.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Jim Rickards: They withhold it from your salary and you don't have any shelters. So, that's the theory.

But confidence at the point of a gun is extremely fragile. People can get around it. And that's really the danger because if people lose confidence in the dollar— so they're watching the Fed, right? So, the Fed goes from today, the balance sheet, M0 is around $3.5 trillion, give or take. Well, all of a sudden that goes to $4 trillion, $5 trillion.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Jim Rickards: $6, $7 trillion in accordance with what MMT is recommending. At what point do people just wake up and say, you know what, I may not have a PhD in economics, but, uh, I'm out of here. I just, I just think this is unstable. And what they do is they get out of the dollar and they get into everything else. It can be, you know, people talk about gold and silver, that's fine, but gold, silver, land, fine art, natural resources, water, oil, anything, buy a new refrigerator, buy a new car, whatever, just get out of the dollar and get some tangible assets.

Well, now you're back to the late '70s. I mean, I lived through that. From 1977 to 1981, the value of the dollar declined over 50%. Now, you know, a lot of people, gold bugs and others, like to say, well, you know, since the Fed was created in 1913, the, the value of the dollar has declined 95%. Well, that's true, although economists say, yeah, but your wages went up and your income went up and your stocks went up, and so yeah, the dollar's worth less, but you got, you got more dollars, so stop complaining. Well, there's more to that debate, but leaving that aside, here the dollar went down more than 50% in 5 years, not 100 years or 110 years, but in 5 years. That was psychological. It wasn't because G. William Miller or Arthur Burns printed too much money. It was because people lost confidence, and they started spending it as fast as they could and getting rid of it as fast as they could.

That can happen overnight, and it did happen overnight in the late 1970s. So, you know, Stephanie Kelton would say, well, her solution to that, by the way, is raise taxes. Really? So all of a sudden you have a panic in the dollar, inflation is skyrocketing seemingly out of nowhere, and her solution is raise taxes. Well, that's a, that's a nice recipe for collapse, you know, high inflation and high taxes. But this shows you that the modern monetary theorists are— they're kind of, you know, eggheads. They're locked in the ivory tower in the universities. They do have political supporters because what politician doesn't want to spend money? And if you can give them a superficially credible theory to spend as much as they want, of course they love it. But when you, when you look behind the curtain, the driver of inflation is not money supply.

It's psychology. It's inflation expectations, which feed on themselves and lead to more inflation. Again, almost overnight. And the idea that you could put the brakes on with high taxes is nonsense. The way you put the brakes on is to do what Paul Volcker did, which is raise interest rates to 20% and say, you know, your move, pal, and keep trying to keep the money in the banks, which works, but it causes a very severe recession. The recession we had in 1982, '81, '82, was the worst since the Great Depression. Of course, it was surpassed by the one in 2008, but at the time, It was the worst since the Great Depression. So modern monetary theory is deeply flawed because it ignores the real drivers of confidence, which is not the barrel of a gun, but your expectations. And people are far more inventive, creative, and adaptable than the professors give them credit for. And that loss of confidence can happen almost overnight.

So you're setting yourself up for a panic. It's just that they don't see it.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, it's very interesting, Jim, the way that you describe Bernanke proving, at least in the eyes of the MMT crowd that you can borrow $4 trillion and there's no problem. And I guess the way I would describe that is it really is the Japanese who proved the point, which is when you exhibit this kind of fiscal irresponsibility, what happens is the critics come out and they predict that it will lead to a massive crisis. And that crisis never ever happens. What happens instead is you get locked into decades of economic stagnation.

Jim Rickards: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: That there's really no way out of. But because there's no specific moment of crisis, the critics never get proven right. They never get to point to a specific event and to say, well, what really happened is the last 40 years of Japanese growth has been nonexistent. It's hard to point a finger at that because there's no event to point to.

In any event, I want to move on to the international monetary system.

Jim Rickards: international monetary system and a gold anchor

Erik Townsend: You've predicted, as I I have that the IMS needs to go through a reset. Something I've learned though is my reasons are not always the same as others. So give us your reasons why the IMS can't last in its current US dollar at the middle of it form forever. What has to change? Why does it need to change? And how is that likely to go down?

Jim Rickards: Well, I do forecast this and I can see how it— a couple of ways it could play out, not one and only one way, but sort of multiple paths. Best, but you need to consider them all. But I'm not the only one saying this and not the only, uh, the kind of analyst who's looking at that. I've heard this in, in private one-on-one conversations with, uh, Ben Bernanke and John Lipsky. Now everyone knows who Ben Bernanke is, you know, former chairman of the Federal Reserve Board. But I spoke to him privately in Korea and he said, he said that the system is incoherent. Those are his exact words. And you say, what do you mean by that? And it's like, we have a system, we have floating exchange rates, we have capital flows, we have capital markets, we have bond markets, et cetera, but there's no anchor. You know, what's the dollar worth? Well, it could be worth a certain fraction of a euro. You know, euro's worth $1.12 or $1.11, and, uh, it's worth, you know, 7 yuan.

And you stop for a second and say, well, yeah, but all you're doing, you're giving me cross rates. You're comparing the dollar to the euro or the euro to the yuan or the dollar to the You know, where it's worth 105 yen or 110 yen, wherever it is. But all you're doing is giving me cross rates. You have not given me an objective measure, a so-called anchor, something that you can measure all currencies against. And this is why, you know, you go back to 2010, 2011, during the early stages of the European sovereign debt crisis, you know, and you had people like Paul Krugman and Joe Stiglitz—they both won the Nobel Prize—Nouriel Roubini and others—they were running around with their hair on fire.

Saying the euro is coming to an end. Greece is going to get kicked out. Spain is going to quit. Go back to the peseta. Devalue. Lower the unit labor costs. There'll be a northern tier and a southern tier, you know, etc., etc. And I was the one who said nonsense. None of that is going to happen. Nobody's quitting. Nobody's getting kicked out.

The euro is going to stay united. It's strong and getting stronger, and new countries will be added. Well, that's exactly what happened. Nobody got kicked out. Nobody quit. When I said that, there were 16 members of the Eurozone who used the euro. Today, there are 19 members. There are a couple other applications pending, so it'll go to 20. I expect Scotland may join once they break away from the rest of the UK.

But the point being, in the early stages of the currency war, the United States set out to have a cheaper dollar. This was announced in President Obama's State of the Union address in January 2009. 2010. By August 2011, the dollar hit an all-time low, an all-time low. And by the way, gold hit an all-time high at the same time. Well, that's no surprise because the dollar price of gold is just the inverse of the, of the dollar. So cheap dollar means high dollar price for gold. But the point is, how do you have a cheaper dollar without having a stronger euro? I mean, that has to happen. You can— you cannot have a cheap dollar and a cheap euro at the same time.

Those 2 currencies make up about 80% of global reserves. They can't cheapen against each other at the same time. It's a mathematical impossibility. So if you're seeing a cheaper dollar, running around screaming about the end of the euro is nonsense because the euro has to get stronger. And it did. It went up to $1.60 in the timeframe I'm talking about. It's backed down since then, but at the time, it got close to an all-time high. But the point is, this is what people don't understand. Forecasting exchange rates is relatively easy because if you get one right, you automatically get the other one right. Because it's like 2 kids on a seesaw— if one's down, the other one has to be up.

But there's no 3rd metric. There's no thing, object, commodity, or whatever that against which you can measure everything and to see what they're worth, except gold.

Now, gold is not officially part of the international monetary system. But gold is money in my view, but it's not printed by any central bank. It's not subject to, as I say, quantitative easing. You can dig a little harder in the gold mines, but that's hard work. So the point is gold is the logical anchor. The reason that was settled on in the period between 1870 and 1914, which is the classical gold standard, or even after Bretton Woods, the reason people settled on gold was because it is the best form of money and it's not subject to manipulation by, by governments in terms of physical supply. You can manipulate the dollar price or the euro price, but you cannot manipulate the physical supply.

Jim Rickards: Lipsky, Geithner, the Fed and SDRs

Jim Rickards: So that's inaccurate.

So then a few months later, I'm in New York and I meet with John Lipsky. And I've had several conversations with John, including a great 1-hour conversation in, in Hong Kong last year, which I talked about in my, in my book Aftermath. This is all in chapter 6. And, uh, Lipsky said the same thing. By the way, people don't know who John Lipsky is. John Lipsky was Until about 2 weeks ago, the only American ever to head the IMF. I mean, today David Lipton is Acting Managing Director because Christine Lagarde's going over to the European Central Bank. But prior to that, there had always been an understanding that you would never have an American as head of the IMF because it gave America too much power, particularly after Bretton Woods. So if you look at all the directors of the IMF since 1944, they've all been Europeans, mostly French, but some others.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Jim Rickards: Some Dutch and Belgian and other nationalities, but mostly French.

Except that in 2011, our friend Dominique Strauss-Kahn got arrested on an Air France jet and charged with sexual assault, et cetera, and had to resign. And the board was not ready to appoint a new managing director at the time. So Lipsky, who was first deputy managing director, stepped up to become acting managing director of the IMF, the first American to head the IMF So I spoke with him for a long time. He said the same thing. He said there is no anchor. He said the system is incoherent. And it really struck me. I said, wow, I just spoke to Ben Bernanke and John Lipsky, you know, a couple months apart on 2 different continents, and they both use the same word, incoherent. So this isn't just, you know, me or other analysts or people on the sidelines saying, oh, you got to reform the international monetary system. This is the chairman of the Federal Reserve Reserve and the head of the IMF telling me privately that the system is incoherent.

So they see the danger. Now, no one agrees on what should happen, and there's no clear roadmap, but the idea that we have an unstable international monetary system that is badly in need of reform is something that everyone agrees on. Or when I say everyone, I mean the elites agree on it, but there's not necessarily an agreement on, on what should come next. But in my book, Aftermath, I have a whole chapter on this and I relate these conversations.

I also spoke to Tim Geithner privately about what would happen in a new financial crisis because I said to former Secretary Geithner, I said, well, it seems to me the Fed is out of bullets. If they had normalized their balance sheet and got M0 back down to, pick a number, $1 trillion, Okay, you could do QE4, QE5, take it back up to $4 trillion if you had to. You got a little headroom there, but the Fed has not done that. The balance sheet has not normalized. It's come down a little bit, but not a lot. So, the Fed's ability to do QE4, QE5, take the balance sheet to $6 trillion, let's say, I mean, the MMT people would say, what's the problem? But I wouldn't say that, and I don't think the Fed would say that. Because they had reasons for trying to get the balance sheet down, which is they're getting ready for the next recession. So there are serious limits there.

And then the next, the only clean balance sheet after the Fed QE is the IMF. The IMF actually is not that highly leveraged. The Fed looks like a really bad hedge fund. It's leveraged about 120 to 1. It's insolvent on a mark-to-market basis. The Fed's a mess, except it's the Fed, so no one worries about it. But they will in time, but not yet.

But the IMF actually does have a clean balance sheet. It's leveraged about 3 to 1. They have a lot of capacity to issue these special drawing rights, SDRs, which are world money. It's not walking around money, as we say in Philadelphia. You don't have it in your pocket. But for the members of the IMF, the countries who get possibly trillion SDR allocations— SDR is worth about $1.40— that's real money in the international payment system and to settle balance of payments deficits. And they can issue bonds and trade it among themselves. So, I asked Geithner if SDRs would be the solution to provide global liquidity in a new liquidity crisis. He said no. And he said— I disagree with that, by the way, but he said no. He said it's too clunky, it's too slow, there's no consensus, et cetera. And I said, well, what will it be? If it's not the Fed, because they're stretched thin, if it's not the IMF, because they're inefficient, what will it be?

And he said, And he told me, and again, I put this in chapter 6 of the book.

So the point is, there are multiple paths. You could have a gold standard, which could be loose or strict. You could have SDR issuance, which in my view is likely, but others disagree. You could have Geithner's remedy, which I don't think will work. But again, I talk about what he told me in the book. There are other things on the horizon.

Jim Rickards: crypto gold, Malaysia Plan and a new Bretton Woods

Jim Rickards: Crypto gold. I'm not a big fan of cryptocurrencies. We don't have We don't have to do a deep dive on that, but Russia and China are working on what's called a permissioned blockchain. A permissioned blockchain is more like a club. It has blockchain technology, but you can only use it if they say you can. So it's like joining a club. They only let the members in.

And they're creating— forget Bitcoin, and that's all junk— but they're creating a new cryptocurrency that they control. So we call it the Putin coin or the Xi coin, whatever you want. Interesting. Want. And they've— both countries have tripled their gold reserves in the last 10 years. Russia has gone almost quadrupled, by the way. Russia's gone from about 600 tons to close to 2,300 tons, and China's gone from 600 tons to, uh, just under 2,000 tons. So they've massively increased their gold reserves in, in the last 10 years. But now they have enough gold that if they issue this cryptocurrency and it's gold-linked, linked and they invite a network of trading nations. So who would be in the network? Well, it'd be all the people that the United States is trying to sanction. So Russia, China, Iran, Turkey, North Korea, Venezuela. You know, obviously Venezuela is the best case, but you could get the other BRICS nations. Now imagine getting Brazil, India, etc. Now all of a sudden, you know, Iran sells oil to China, North Korea sells weapons to Iran, China sells infrastructure to Russia.

Russia sells energy to China. Everyone takes a vacation in Turkey. You've got this large trading network, but nothing's in dollars. It's all being denominated in this new cryptocurrency, which you could anchor— again, back to the word anchor— to SDRs or any other unit you chose. And it's very easy to convert SDRs into gold by weight. And you have straight-through processing. And you don't have to move the gold around. on a gross basis. You don't pay for every shipment. What you do is you trade, you use the cryptocurrency to keep score, which is not a big deal. I mean, you can use baseball cards to keep score. And then periodically, you know, 4 times a year, twice a year, or whatever, you settle up in physical gold. But the point is you're settling on a net basis. If you don't need gold to settle on a gross basis but you only settle on a net basis where, you know, what I buy from you is offset by what you buy from me, You need a lot less gold.

You don't need nearly as much gold when you're settling on a net basis and then using the cryptocurrency to keep score.

What's missing in that network I just described? Well, what's missing is the dollar. There are no dollar payments. You don't need Fedwire. You don't need SWIFT. You don't need all the arteries and pathways that the United States controls. And there are no dollars involved, so you can't sanction it. And the thing about using physical gold as an anchor, it's physical. It's not digital. You can't hack track it, you can't freeze it, you can't intercept it. So now you've created an international trading system, and it might start out small, grant that, but it could grow. But the point is it's immune from U.S. sanctions, and U.S. sanctions are how we throw our weight around and kind of get what we want in foreign policy. So, and there are other plans I discussed in chapter 6, including what I call the Malaysia Plan. I met with, uh, several times with Prime Minister Mahathir of Malaysia who has been very interested in this for decades.

He had that famous shootout in September 1997 at the IMF annual meeting in Hong Kong, where there was basically a name-calling shouting match between George Soros and Mahathir, and Bob Rubin had to come in and break up the fight. I was actually in Hong Kong for that meeting. So this is not a new subject for Mahathir, but I explained how you can have a gold standard without much gold.

And the way you do it is you peg your currency to gold by weight, and then someone says, well, here's your currency back, I want gold. And what you do is you pay them in dollars, but you have some kind of operating agreement with, say, let's say the Shanghai Gold Exchange, where the dollars are converted to gold at the market. So what fluctuates is not the exchange rate between your currency and gold by weight, it's the dollar equivalent. So it makes the dollar just another currency, and you have what's called straight-through processing again, where You know, you send the dollars to Shanghai, they convert it to gold, deliver the gold to you, or keep it in safekeeping. But so you get a de facto gold standard for a relatively small currency like the Malaysian ringgit, but use dollars as an intermediate step. But it's a very quick step because you're working with automated systems on the exchange, and the recipient gets the amount of gold that they've been promised.

So that's a— they call it the Malaysia Plan. That's a gold standard without much gold because you're using the world supply of gold to settle your obligations in gold by weight. So, you know, take your pick. You've got crypto gold, SDR backed by gold, the Malaysia Plan, other plans, new ones that people could invent. But, but the point is something like this is coming. Now, will it be kind of calm and rational, which Bretton Woods was? I mean, Bretton Woods was convened before the end of World War II. FDR and Churchill knew that we were going to need a new international monetary system. They knew the problems of the 1920s and the 1930s. So they said, well, let's not wait until, you know, the war's over. And they could see that we're going to win at that point. So let's not wait until the war's over and then say, oh gee, what do we do?

Let's have a conference now before the war's over and set up a system that will govern the post-war world. And they did at Bretton Woods in New Hampshire. So that made sense. You could do that again. I, I called this— I call it the Mar-a-Lago Conference. You know, Trump and, you know, and some other convening power. Maybe Xi would have a conference at Mar-a-Lago. It could be anywhere. It could be— it doesn't have to be at Mar-a-Lago. I just kind of use that as an example.

Or will the panic come first and you'll have to do all this on the fly in very chaotic conditions with a lot of stress and a global liquidity crisis? And you're very likely to make a lot of bad decisions when you're doing things on the fly. It'll be one or the other. It'll either be convened or it'll It'll emerge in a panic. Well, why not do— why not convene a conference? Why not get ahead of the curve here? But I'm not optimistic that's going to happen. I think it will kind of emerge from the panic.

Erik Townsend: Well, Jim, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Again, folks, the name of the book is Aftermath: 7 Secrets of Wealth Preservation in the Coming Chaos by Jim Rickards. It's available for pre-order now on Amazon. Amazon and Barnes& Noble, and it ships next week, July 23rd, 2019. Jim, thanks so much. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik.

Postgame: Dalio's paradigm shift

Patrick Ceresna: What a great interview with Jim Rickards. I think it was a great interview. Rickards, I wanted to move on to Ray Dalio's new piece that he put out on a new paradigm. And I thought it was fascinating the way he put it together. What a great piece. I highly recommend all of our listeners read the full article on LinkedIn. And what I thought was really interesting was the fact that he identifies these paradigms, each one of them being about a decade long, and that when you transition from one paradigm to the other in this paradigm shift, that most people get caught overextended doing something that's very popular and then get hurt. And I can't think of a better example of that is like so many Canadians up here believed that you could never lose money with real estate and just because real estate every year kept going up and then they overextend one way and then they get caught the other way.

So identifying when the paradigm shift

Erik Townsend: Oh, absolutely. And to be sure, Ray Dalio is, you know, one of the most brilliant people of our time, and he is just so beautifully articulated in this piece. By the way, listeners, you'll find the link in your Research Roundup email to Ray's article on LinkedIn. I wish we could get him on the program because he's just such an amazingly smart guy, and he's so well articulated what's really going on, which is, you know, every decade that he describes in his article kind of has something that defines it from a financial standpoint.

And in the case of the 1970s, you know, it was inflation. And what he's saying is this last decade, the one that's ending in 6 months, has been the decade of central bank-supplied liquidity. Central banks propping up asset markets by keeping interest rates super low through various artificial stimulation mechanisms. And those are law of diminishing returns. Eventually, each unit of quantitative easing is less and less effective. Active as you get more and more swollen balance sheets. And what he's describing is you, you have these unsustainable things, and what always happens is they don't end because they're unsustainable.

They go on, they overshoot, they, they keep going because they've got momentum. And eventually you hit a tipping point and markets sort of figure out, hey, wait a minute, this is completely crazy. And what I've been waiting for for the last 2 or 3 is for what Ray is calling a paradigm shift, when the market suddenly figures out, hey, wait a minute, this whole model that we've been in is totally unsustainable. It can't continue. And usually what he says happens is the things that were working the best end up working the worst. The things that were not working very well at all end up working the best. And he explains that we've got asset prices artificially pumped up by central banks.

We've got all of these liabilities coming due in the form of pensions and government entitlements and so forth. And he describes all of the reasons, very similar to the late 1930s, that what has already begun and what he says will continue is just a major battle between capitalists and socialists. And, you know, we're seeing that with Bernie Sanders and AOC and Elizabeth Warren. There is a huge political divide. It results in a huge amount of of societal frustration and anger and, and people taking sides. And, uh, eventually what we're going to get to is the realization, hey, you just can't prop asset markets up indefinitely through these artificial means.

And Ray is saying it's, it's going to all go into reverse. Now, he's much more accomplished and smarter than I am. Where I've been saying it's way overdue, surely, please, any day now it has to happen. He's saying, look, who the hell knows when it's going to happen? But in the next few years, this whole thing's gonna go into reverse and it ain't gonna be pretty. And what he says is, you can pretty much bet that the central bankers are going to support the bond market.

So I think it's a very interesting insight. If you look at something like Jeff Gundlach's views about how we're headed to much higher interest rates, what Ray argues in this article is, wait a minute, why would central banks allow that to happen? They've got a printing press. They don't have to allow it to happen.

Postgame: Dalio's four features

Patrick Ceresna: They've got a lot of reasons not to So, Erik, what I actually wanted to do was just quickly jump in here and let's break down what defined the existing paradigm. So, he identifies 4 key points. So, you just talked about it right here, which is that central banks are lowering those interest rates and printing money, keeping financial asset prices— well, asset prices higher because they're suppressing interest rates and pumping the system with liquidity.

Now, the second component, though, which I thought was fascinating was where he talked about the wave of stock share buybacks, mergers, acquisitions, private equity, venture capital, which has been funded by all of this cheap money and credit. And what was interesting is, is that he specifically says it's unsustainable.

And I thought that was really fascinating because, like, you know, I think that when we go back, you know, 20 years from now, we look back to this decade, we're going to look back at all those share buybacks. Buybacks and say, was it really that simple that we just had to financially engineer higher stock prices by just pumping huge amounts of debt onto the balance sheets of these corporations and letting them buy their stock price higher? I thought it was really interesting that he didn't think it was sustainable.

Erik Townsend: Well, you got to consider though, Patrick, he's very clear in saying it's not sustainable, but elsewhere in the article, he says very clearly, these unsustainable things keep going on. They continue to happen, and they, they overshoot. They go too far, to the point where it just seems completely impossible that they could continue. And it persuades most people that they're going to continue forever, because it seems as though the people like myself that have been saying, I can't believe it hasn't ended yet, just look stupid. And, and we're proven wrong, and everybody thinks it's going on forever. And it's that point where eventually it does end, and it ends abruptly, and it's not

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so his third point, which I want to move on to, is he was saying that a lot of these corporate profit margins grew rapidly due to the advances in automation and globalization, but with the reduced costs of labor. And this is that big disparity where the populist movement you mentioned earlier is being fueled by the fact that there was no wage inflation while these profits of these corporations continued to rise. And You have to think that that can't sustain itself and has to mean revert at some point.

Erik Townsend: Oh, absolutely. And I think that the references to the populism, I mean, so many people, because of their own monetary values and ideology, refuse to learn anything about MMT. And I guess somebody famous, I don't know if it was Sun Tzu or somebody else said, know your enemy.

Even if you don't like it, you need to understand that there is a huge, huge groundswell of political support for more socialist-oriented policies—you know—more entitlements, forgiveness of student loans, and all these things. It's going to be very expensive, and the plan through MMT is to monetize all that. Whether you like it or not, you owe it to yourself as an investor to fully understand. what the people you don't agree with are going to do. Because guess what? There's more of them at the moment than there are of those of us who don't think that these things are a good idea.

Postgame: next decade, monetization and gold

Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. And so I want to move on now to what he believes will be the characteristic of the next decade as we go into that paradigm shift. And so the interesting thing, which is nothing new to our MacroVoices listeners which is one, they believe that central banks will run out of this stimulant to boost the markets.

And therefore, two, this enormous amount of debt and non-debt liabilities, such as all the pension and healthcare liabilities, will come due, will have to either be funded through, A, reducing what everyone is supposed to get, or, 2, it's going to have to be funded with larger deficits, which is going to be monetized. And there comes that really interesting idea where whether that's outright MMT or whether some other form of debt monetization, this is something he believes is in our future and in the next decade.

Erik Townsend: Oh, and I'm absolutely convinced of it too. And I think that it's so important to get your head around, you know, imagine if we did see a major change, not just of who the president is, but what if these Bernie Sanders, AOC kind of views really took over control of the government so that all forces were aligned toward much more monetization in order to provide more social services. It would be incredibly inflationary. It would have all kinds of effects. And it's so important to get your head around these things because I think— I don't know when it's coming, but it seems pretty clear that the direction in society is moving left on the political scale very quickly and toward much more socialization of of benefits to people in society.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so he basically leaves the article, and I thought it was really interesting. He basically says the current paradigm has resulted in a world that is leveraged long, holding assets that today now have a low real and nominal expected return into the future, obviously, particularly European junk bonds, right? But also providing historically low returns relative to cash returns. And so we have this, everyone overleveraged in this, and they're going to be disappointed, obviously, by the returns that will probably be over the next decade in those assets. And that's where he plugs gold as a diversifier, obviously, within a balanced portfolio. And that's what you were referencing earlier, right?

Erik Townsend: Exactly. And I think he was actually a little stronger than just to say a diversifier. What he said Look, you know, we've got to think about what's going to happen, which is central bankers are going to need to support the system. They've created this situation. They can't abandon it. They do have the ability to continue to keep interest rates at zero. Whether you and I think that's a good idea or not, they can continue to do it, and they probably will continue to do it. And that means that ultimately all currencies around the world get debased in real value, and that means hard assets like gold are What's going to benefit. And I— he didn't say it in the article, but I have to believe he would agree that other hard assets like real estate are probably going to do well as well. And Patrick, I'm sure the other thing that's going to do very well is our listeners who are lucky enough to be able to join you in Chicago this weekend.

Just for any new listeners who didn't get the memo, tell us what's going on in Chicago, what you and Kevin are going to be debating, and where they can find out more about it if they want to

Patrick Ceresna: No, absolutely. I'm looking forward to meeting many of our MacroVoices listeners out there. So if you can make it out, make sure you say hi, and it's gonna be great. You know, John Netto is going to moderate a bull-bear debate on bonds between myself and Kevin Muir. It's gonna actually be a lot of fun. So looking forward to it and looking forward to meeting so many of our MacroVoices listeners out there.

Outro and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Fantastic, Patrick. I wish I could be there myself. Today's episode was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free book and subscribe to their podcast as well. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo.

And don't forget to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email which provides links to all of the best content that we could find on the internet, including supporting materials for our feature interviews. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: So this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Jim, as well as the link to that Ray Dalio Paradigm Shifts LinkedIn article. There's also an interesting article discussing Marko Kolanovic's view that there's a once-in-a-decade opportunity in a particular sector of stocks. And as well, there's an interesting piece from David Rosenberg that is talking about the signs of a looming US recession are building. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode.

We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners. And we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or If you have a blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna.

Erik Townsend: Thanks, Patrick.

Patrick Ceresna: Patrick Ceresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.

Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Jesse Felder — Former hedge fund manager (as introduced on the show)

Announcer open

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 175 was recorded on July 11th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the leading podcast when it comes to systematic trading and investing. Former hedge fund manager Jesse Felder returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the stock market, bond yields, gold's breakout, and Jesse's concerns about surveillance capitalism and Facebook's Libra digital currency. Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when we'll have extended equity market coverage with another of Patrick's famous chartbooks.

S&P 500 at highs: bad-is-good liquidity market

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's dive right into this S&P 500 making all-time new highs. What's going on?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I have very low directional conviction at this point, Patrick. We're seeing such clear evidence that That what's in control here is what I call the bad is the new good doctrine. The reason that the S&P ripped vertically higher to new all-time highs on Wednesday morning was because the Federal Reserve chairman said very clearly that the economic outlook is getting worse.

And of course, the mechanism is easy to understand here. People anticipate that a worsening economic outlook means that there's going to be more accommodative monetary policy, and they know that this market actually operates on liquidity, not economic fundamentals. If there's more injection of stimulus, that money's got to go somewhere. It'll go into asset markets because that's the crazy way that everything has been working since 2009. So I completely understand the mechanism.

I think that people— it just amazes me, Patrick, that so few people are able to step back and see the really big picture. Why does this giant casino we call the stock market, why is it allowed to exist in the first place? How does it benefit society?

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: The answer is supposed to be that it enables the efficient formation of capital to grow and expand businesses, create employment, and so forth.

And you know, the thing is that when you completely jury-rig the market so it's entirely driven by liquidity and those economic fundamentals, the whole purpose of having the market is so that free market decision-making can determine the allocation of capital most efficiently. We're not allocating capital efficiently. We've got a

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: It's a casino, which is basically a gaming system that is now completely beholden to central bank policy, and it's driven by things that are not the right things.

Now, I'm not saying it can't continue. If there's anything I've learned from watching this market over the last few years, it's the fact that we seem pretty darn clearly headed for a recession, the fact that Chairman Powell has confirmed that by saying that the economic outlook is getting dimmer, his words, it just makes the market go higher.

And, you know, I know this can't go on forever. Someday reality has to kick in, but it doesn't have to happen right now, and I don't know how much higher it can go. So, you know, Danielle DiMartino Booth says the US is not immune to the global slowdown that's occurring around the globe. Well, I agree with her that the US economy is not immune, and I think the US economy is nearly certain to fall into recession by the end of 2020, if not much sooner.

The thing is, the stock market is not functioning as a leading economic indicator the way it once did. So the fact that I think the economy is headed for recession doesn't necessarily make me think that the stock market has to move sharply downward. I think it's entirely possible that the crazy logic that's been prevailing for the last several years will continue for a while longer. And that crazy logic says the worse it gets, the more the Fed is accommodative, and the more that that pumps money into markets, which can be used to bid up asset prices. This This makes no sense. And it just astonishes me, Patrick, that so few people recognize the total absurdity of it. But I don't see any reason that we should expect it to end right away. So I'm on the sidelines.

Dollar index: long position and breakout levels

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the US dollar. I find it fascinating that at least I saw a headline out there that was saying that, you know, Donald Trump being frustrated with the strength of the dollar. And it seems like every time that dollar has a dip, it's so quick to come back. I mean, we're more or less around that 97 handle right now. What's your thinking here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I see more reasons to be bullish on the dollar this week, not less, even though quite a few other people are saying, okay, this is it, the dollar's crashing. They seem to keep saying the same thing every time we get a little bit of a dovish policy indication from the government.

And frankly, I think that it is a fallacy that dovish policy has to lead to a lower US dollar. What really leads to a lower US dollar is a change not just in US interest rates, but in interest rate differentials relative to other sovereign credits. And I think that for everything that the Fed is doing dovish, that we can expect the ECB to be at least as dovish. So I think that a lot of this is misplaced.

As far as going to the technicals, the one thing that has been a little bit of a concern for me for the last couple of weeks— I've talked about it on the program— is, you know, as much as I think we're headed higher on the dollar index, boy, that chart was starting to look like maybe a downward sloping price channel was forming. And I said, watch out, you get to about Oh, 96.50, 96.55, in there somewhere. And if we start to see it roll over there, we really could be looking at that channel. What we saw instead, Patrick, was a decisive breakout above 97 on the dollar index, very clearly breaking that what would have been a channel resistance line. And then when we got another dovish policy message from the Fed this week, everybody starts screaming, oh boy, the dollar's crashing. And I just thought to myself, okay, This is such a classic setup. What we're going to see here is we're going to see a knee-jerk down lower to touch that same resistance trend line and now test it as support.

So last night I actually doubled down on my long dollar position, buying at 96.50 on the September contract. Now I should admit that I actually had a resting limit order that would have been filled at 95.50 a few weeks ago. I chickened out of that because of the gold breakout. The gold breakout really caused me to take pause and, and think, boy, I need to really carefully rethink my opinion on the dollar. I've carefully rethought it, Patrick. I think we're going higher, and I think what we just saw was that classic retest of a resistance level we just broke through, tested as support. Looks like we're already bouncing off of that line. We'll see what happens, but so far I wouldn't be surprised if we just move higher. Now the question is, what is the breakout level that we're watching for? 98 was the number we were watching when the June contract was still the active futures contract.

Now that we're into the September contract, there's half of a big point of backwardation. So the high on this contract is right around $97.50, not $98, but $97.50. So if you use what futures traders call the contract high, the contract high was $97.50. But if you look at a continuation chart, which shows what the front month was at the time of each bar on the chart, Then the high number to beat is $98. Well, what's the official answer on, you know, how that works? In the crude oil market, at least, what everybody does is they just have both lines of their chart because it seems like nobody can decide what the rule is. So I think what we're going to see is that there's resistance at $97.50 and then there's more resistance at $98. And when it's a clear break above $98 on the September contract, I think that's when we're really off to the races. And from there, I think we start to target $104 or so eventually.

For now, it's been quite a while. We've been waiting for a breakout. A lot of people think that we're rolling over here and crashing. I don't think so. But I'll also be the first to acknowledge, you know, I've criticized the gold bugs for being too early to claim victory. What I'm seeing here in terms of the things going in my favor in terms of technicals, we still need a little bit more time above these key levels in order to really prove out my point. But so far, I think it really looks good as far as further upside for the dollar.

Crude oil: inventory draw and Gulf of Mexico storm

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I've been dying to ask you about crude oil because a couple weeks ago we rejected off that $60 level, and here we are with that inventory draw that saw this pop now above $60. Is this a breakout or is this still going to be a false start? What's your thinking?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think the inventory draw, which everybody's been paying attention to, is only a small part of it. I think that the tropical storm in the Gulf of Mexico, which resulted in the evacuation of 15 offshore oil rigs probably has more to do with the price movement than inventory does. But let's start with inventory. Crude oil drawing down 9.5 million barrels, super big drawdown. That by itself is a very strong bullish signal. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 301,000 barrels. Now that's not nearly as big, but it is a drawdown in Cushing, whereas previously we had seen a trend of builds even in weeks that we had a national drawdown. Cushing was building, now Cushing's drawing down. Gasoline drawing down a million and a half barrels. Distillates was the standout, the single build on the board at 3.7 million barrels. Tape action— I think this is critical, Patrick— it was a pop-up off the 100-day moving average very briefly, kind of violating what might have been a resistance level, and then we very promptly retraced down through the 100-day moving average.

And it seemed at first like, okay, this is a pop and drop, we're headed lower, and then the prices really started to take off to the upside about an hour later. I think it It was the news of the evacuations of the rigs in the Gulf of Mexico that really drove that next wave higher.

Going back to inventory, US production 12.2 million barrels, up 100,000 barrels from last week, still staying right around that same range, very close to the all-time high at 12.4 million barrels. Imports were up to 7.3 million barrels, exports down to 3 million barrels, or 21 million barrels on the week. The tropical storm, I think, was a really big part of this. I had thought previously that we were topping out and the market was maybe ready to roll over toward lower numbers. Now, needless to say, you get a big trend of really huge inventory draws week after week, and you get the evacuation of 15 platforms in the Gulf of Mexico.

Now, even though that is a precautionary evacuation, it's not because they think the rigs are gonna be lost. It's just to get people out of harm's way as the storm blows through. It still takes production offline for several days, and that's just gonna contribute to more drawdowns. So I think it's mostly about that. If we get to the storms blow through, there's no particular damage to the rigs, everybody goes back to work and starts producing oil next week, I think the market probably rolls over at that point. But of course, you also have the possibility of, you know, big storm damage or geopolitical upsets or anything else happening between now and then. So I'm completely on the sidelines.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I think that there is an argument for a bearish view, but boy, we got to see that trend of big drawdowns abate before I'm going to get too excited about shorting this market.

Gold breakout levels and dollar pairs trade

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because it seems to be holding the $1,400 line pretty well. Every time it looks like we're about to see a little correction and give back this move, the buyers are right there to scoop it back up, and it seemed to be holding it up here. What's your take here on, on the gold price? Are we going higher from here?

Erik Townsend: Well, clearly, the longer that we stay above 1,377, the stronger the case becomes that this is a very historically important breakout that has legs and is headed higher. But at the same time, I think the confirmation signal that would really solidify that is, let's say, a weekly close, not just a daily close, above 1,442, which has been the high to date. As long as we continue to consolidate in this range between, let's say, 1,377 on the downside and $1,442 on the upside. There's still room for this to resolve to the downside, but frankly, as much as I have perhaps been proven wrong here, I have to acknowledge that the preponderance of evidence, I think, at this point is on the bullish side. That will be confirmed when we see first a daily close and then a weekly close above $1,442. If I go long, it will be a pairs trade, long the dollar index and gold at the same time, because if gold is going to Fail here and actually turn out to be a false breakout and, you know, end up going back down below $1,300 again, the only way that's going to happen is on a dollar breakout.

So if I'm long gold and I'm also long the dollar, I've got a hedge there. And if it turns out that we're moving into that regime that we've predicted for years, which is eventually we get to the gold and the dollar moving up at the same time, then I've got a double win. The scenarios where there's a double loss because gold ends up going down and the dollar goes down at the same time. I don't really see how that could play out.

Treasury yields and getting back into bonds

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yields because we've had this huge bond rally and it seems to have held for just forever. And finally, we're seeing yields rising and bonds coming off the top. Is this finally the beginning of that correction we've been waiting for?

Erik Townsend: It seems to be. You know, we're finally backing up a little. I don't think we've backed up a whole lot at this point. I'm watching carefully, but I haven't bought yet. I did close my long fixed income positions on the 2-year Treasury several weeks ago. Did pretty well there, got lucky and got out just about right at the top. As far as getting back into the 2-year and maybe also getting into a long on the 10-year, I'm watching that. Now, remember that Julian Brigden, who's no slouch, predicted months and months ago that we would see a drop all the way down to 2% and then a reversal much higher in bond yields. So I'm very curious to know how Julian is looking at this. Given my recession outlook, I still tend to think Lower yields are to come. But I do want to ask Julian about this. We already taped Julian's interview that's gonna be on tomorrow's All-Stars.

We didn't cover it there, but next time I get Julian on the program, I wanna get an update from him on his view because he's the one person who's had the other argument. Right now, I'm just looking for this pullback to move a little further and an opportunity to get back in the long side of this trade.

New MacroVoices content, sponsor search and donations

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, thanks for the update, Erik. So before we move on to this week's featured interview with Jesse Felder, please give us a quick update on your efforts to expand the MacroVoices brand with all the new content we've launched since early May.

Erik Townsend: We're really excited about the new content, and there's more of it coming your way this weekend. We have Julian Brigden on deck for All-Stars tomorrow morning, and then he'll be back along with Juliette Declercq and Alex Gurevich for another installment of Inside the Investment Committee. So all that is coming your way this weekend. But frankly, we still really need help finding sponsors. To be sure, Top Traders Unplugged has been a fantastic sponsor, and their sponsorship allows us to cover the production expenses for the Thursday night podcast. But we still don't have any sponsorship for the new content, and frankly, the leads that we have are starting to wear thin. So Patrick, I can't even find words to express our gratitude to the people who have donated in recent weeks.

Frankly, Patrick, I would have had to put the brakes on the new content and stop producing some of it by now, but the donations that we've received have saved the day. There's still more new content planned, and I'm really excited about introducing it when the economics allow it. But for now, we're already overextended. And we need to find sponsors just to continue producing the content that we're already producing. Launching new content is going to have to stay on hold until we have revenue to support it.

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, some of our listeners have asked why you keep asking for help from the audience to find these sponsors when it seems obvious, uh, as an alternative that we would simply call an ad agency to find these sponsors. What's the story there?

Erik Townsend: Well, that's definitely an option, and it's one that we will soon be forced to resort to if we can't find the right sponsors through our own listener community. But it's full of downsides. The biggest problem is that my strong hope and desire is to find compatible sponsors whose products and services are actually a good fit for our audience. Top Traders Unplugged is a perfect example. Some of our audience has absolutely zero interest in that style of trading, while others in our audience might find it to be even more compelling than the macro approach that we discuss here on MacroVoices. The point is, everyone listening can appreciate that at least for some people in our audience, learning about something like Top Traders Unplugged could be really valuable to them.

Now, I already have several ad agencies hounding me, but they want to fill MacroVoices up with screaming announcers pitching vacation condos in Belize and investment schemes involving ostrich farming and all sorts of nonsense that I just don't want littering up our program. The other problem is that the ad agencies are really aggressive. They start by trying to negotiate a 50/50 revenue split where they keep half the money just for being the middlemen. They try to push for exclusive relationships just to see if you're stupid enough to agree to one. It's a business that has more than its share of shady characters, and I haven't met anyone that I really trust and respect in the ad agency business yet to represent us. So Patrick, these things translate to an outcome where if we're paying huge commissions to agencies, then we'd have to have twice as much advertising as we would if we found our own sponsors. And what's worse, it would be a much lower quality of advertising.

I'm passionately committed to avoiding that if we possibly can. And that's why we're holding out for our listener community to help us make connections with companies that would make good sponsors who our audience would actually appreciate hearing from.

We have a sponsor pitch video at MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. And the most important thing that anyone listening can do to help us is to first watch Watch that video yourself, and then think about who you know in the marketing department of a company that would make a good MacroVoices sponsor, and reach out to them. We already have a few listeners helping us in this regard, and I can't thank them enough. But we really need help finding more. We need several strategic sponsors so that we can both pay for the expanded content that we're already producing, and then begin introducing even more. And as I said earlier, the donations. are the only thing keeping us going in the interim. So I want to again thank everyone who has donated through the donate button at MacroVoices.com.

Why Jesse Felder is back this week

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, well, thanks for the update, Erik. This week's featured interview guest is Jesse Felder. Erik, why did we invite Jesse back onto the show this week?

Erik Townsend: You know, Jesse's been a friend of ours and a friend of the program for a long time. He's a super guy. He's a great interviewer himself in his own podcast. And, you know, he's a guy who's been bearish on the market, or I should say bearish on the economy, as I have been for the last couple of years. And, uh, you know, we both have had the same experience of feeling like, you know, we think we got the economics right. It's just that what's driving the market is liquidity, not economic fundamentals. So with the market at new all-time highs, I thought it was an opportune time to get Jesse back on the program. And this episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com.

Erik Townsend: Although I'm a macro investor myself, it's a fact that quant-based hedge funds are dominating the rankings of top-performing managers. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be researched and tested. And this year, they're off to a flying start.

And there's one podcast that covers this area of finance better than any other— TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can get a free book explaining how these systematic strategies can work for Just go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro. Check them out, you'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Jesse Felder is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Jesse Felder interview: market breadth divergences and extreme valuations

Announcer: And now, with this week's special Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Jesse Felder, author of The Felder Report, and from time to time also the producer of an excellent podcast. Jesse, it's been too long. It's great to have you back on the program. Let's start with the stock market. Here we are, much to my surprise at least, not quite all-time highs today, but within the last several sessions we've been at all-time highs. I don't know about you, I don't know about you, but the economic message of everything's rosy and it makes sense for the stock market to be at all-time highs is not resonating in my mind. How do you see this market?

Jesse Felder: Yeah, you know, it's actually been, I think, a year since you had me on. And back then, I shared a bunch of charts with your audience showing the breadth divergences and really the number of Hindenburg Omens was the thing that really stood out to me. And we had that steep 4th quarter decline kind of right after that last time we talked. I think we're at another similar point right now where stocks are kind of still trickling higher, But valuations are extreme almost no matter how you measure them.

And I'm seeing that kind of deterioration under the surface again. We're seeing, you know, Stan Druckenmiller gave an interview recently where he talked about certain subsectors of the stock market are the best economic forecaster he's ever come across. And he specifically mentioned, you know, small caps, retail, transportation, those types of things. And when you look at the relative performance of those sectors, metals and mining was another one, it's horrendous right now. I think small caps, recently just hit their lowest relative point to the S&P since the 2009 bottom. So these subsectors are sending a pretty serious message about where the economy stands and also just the overall breadth of the market as it hits these new highs.

Foreign safety trade, junk bonds and the topping process

Erik Townsend: We talked about breadth last time we had you on the show. I can't believe it's been a whole year. We need to get you on more frequently. It seems to me like we've got a different kind of breadth now. It's the international breadth issue that, as Danielle DiMartino Booth pointed out recently in one of our All-Stars interviews, Look, the message is really clear. The decline in equity values is already happening and has been happening for a while now, internationally, on a global scale. But somehow the US has managed to stay immune. And Danielle's comment is, look, the US can't be immune forever. There's another argument, though, that Brent Johnson has posited, saying, look, what's going on is normally, under normal circumstances, in every little economy, every little market around the world, when stock When the stock market takes a dive to the south side, what happens is people pile into sovereign bonds in their own country. That's their safety trade.

The thing is, those markets are deeply negative yielding in a lot of cases, and it doesn't make any sense to pile into those. Brent thinks what's going on is there's this international safety trade that is holding the US market up. What do you think of that theory? Because frankly, Jesse, I don't think you and I were wrong when we thought this market should have out a long time ago, but it hasn't. And it seems like it behooves us to figure out what the heck is going on, why it has been so resilient. Do you think Brent's ideas make any sense? And if not, what other ideas do you have that would explain why the market has stayed so high for so long in the face of so many reasons that it shouldn't?

Jesse Felder: Yeah, and I'm a huge fan of Brent and Danielle, both their work. I pay attention to what they write and discuss. But I do think that makes a lot of sense, and I do think that does That's helped to explain it. I think there's been a lot of foreign money that's poured into our markets here in the US, just fleeing negative yields.

But I think this probably comes back to the currency discussion. I think you have to be a dollar bull to think that the stock market is going to hold up. I'm not bullish on the dollar. And we can get into that if you like too. But I do think that, yes, if you look at just relative yields, relative returns around the world, there's been this flight out of Japan, out of Europe out of negative yields, and it's gone into our sovereign bond market here in the United States. It's gone into corporate bonds here. Junk bonds have done really well. I mean, you look at these big Japanese banks buying leveraged loans as much as they can get their hands on. So yeah, there's been this hunger for any type of yield, but reaching for yield never ends well. And that's exactly what's going on right now is you look at junk bond yields with 5%, 6% nominal face value yields on them is at a time when there's no covenants on these things and leverage among corporate America is at record highs, it's going to end badly.

And so they might think they're getting a positive return today. There's going to be a fleeing out of these assets at some point. My friend Helene Meisler said that her mentor taught her the last people to buy are always dentists and foreigners. And I think that's what's going on in the market. And it's funny to me too, I think, too, that when you talk about the US stock market, we've essentially gone nowhere for 18 months. And this is how markets top.

They take time to build kind of a rounding top. Bottoms are a point in time and tops are a process. And I think we're still in the middle of this topping process right now for the US stock market.

Dollar outlook and the fiscal deficit

Erik Townsend: Let's move on then and go a little deeper on the US dollar. Lots and lots of fundamental reasons that I can see to be short. In my mind, they've been outweighed by the global dollar squeeze argument. How do you see How do you see this whole thing and what are your views on the dollar?

Jesse Felder: I think when you look around, to me, I try and keep it simple in terms of my currency views. And I look around and I see the fiscal situation in Europe led by Germany is much, much better than our fiscal situation. We're running a budget deficit of 5% of GDP right now and growing, trillion-dollar-plus fiscal deficit. And you look at the zeitgeist in Washington right now. No worry at all about the growing deficit, the growing debt pile. In fact, we have on the Democratic side, people talking about forgiving $1.5 trillion of student loans or giving every American $1,000 free every month. We have these kinds of the policies that are being discussed.

And at the same time, a real effort on the part of the Fed to rethink its policies towards inflation in order to stimulate inflation or at least stimulate inflation expectations. And you have the president also pushing for that type of policy, weak dollar policy. Everything I look at in terms of macro here in the United States is pointing at a lower dollar. And to me, when you look at currencies, you look at the dollar, it's very highly correlated to the deficit. The deficit's widening and the dollar hasn't really responded yet. I mean, it did peak a couple years ago. We've had that rally so far over the last, I don't know, 9 months or something. But I do think this is a bear market rally. We haven't made new highs in the dollar index. And I do think that it needs to catch down to the fiscal situation. So that's kind of my view on the dollar.

And if you think about it, it fits well with this move. Japanese investors, European investors have been very comfortable coming and buying our assets and not hedging their currency risk because of the fact that once they hedge, They lose all that pickup in yield. And so they're very exposed that if the dollar does begin to turn south, they don't have that currency hedge on. They're going to have to sell assets and move back into their home currency. So that to me is the trade that's on the horizon. And it's a bearish dollar, bearish US financial assets kind of in total.

Bond yields, stagflation risk and risk parity

Erik Townsend: Let's talk about bond yields because as much as it seems like the stock market The equity market is not taking the message I think it should be taking and moving lower. The bond yields sure seem to be sending a message that the bond market gets it. What do you make of this divergence and what do you see on the horizon for bond yields?

Jesse Felder: The way I view what's going on in the bond market is just a panic into bonds. It's panic buying. There's, yes, the economy's slowing, but if you look at inflation, I just think it doesn't make any sense. Warren Buffett was talking about this recently and Charlie Munger. Howard Marks wrote about it recently too, saying that all of these things together, The worsening fiscal situation and low bond yields and a strong dollar. It's a thing that you can't have all 3. Historically, they've not been able to coexist. And so it doesn't look like the fiscal situation's going to change anytime soon.

And to me, that suggests that interest rates must be higher. And if you look at the term premium on long-term treasuries right now, it's the lowest in history. So to me, that is the ultimate sentiment signal that investors are willing to accept very little, if nothing at all, in terms of the duration risk that they're taking right now.

What I think is probably the biggest risk for the markets right now is that there was an article in the Wall Street Journal earlier this week where they interviewed a bunch of just retail investors who were some of these people pouring money into the bond market. And they said, I don't even care what it yields. I just want the hedge against a stock market decline.

And I think probably it's not difficult to imagine a situation where stocks and bonds decline together in a period, a stagflationary environment. And I really do think that's what we're headed for, slowing top-line growth, slowing economic growth, and rising inflationary pressures as a result of a number of factors.

Erik Townsend: And that's just probably the worst possible environment for financial assets, both stocks and If both stocks and bonds start selling off together, one of the theories out there, and certainly it's one that I subscribe to, is really we're in almost completely uncharted territory as far as what could happen with an unwind of— you know, there have been times before where bonds and stocks both sold off together, but not in an environment where you have this massive, massive institutional allocation.

Jesse Felder: Right.

Erik Townsend: to this risk parity strategy, which basically has to be unwound if that starts to happen. So it seems to me like if there's a recipe for a really, really big, you know, 2008-sized, what's the crisis that nobody saw coming? And of course, there's always somebody who did see it coming. It seems to me like it is the self-reinforcing nature of both bonds and stocks selling off at the same time, resulting in a mechanical unwind of that institutional institutional risk parity trade. Have you done any analysis of that? What do you think of that theory? How much does that resonate for you?

Jesse Felder: Yeah, I mean, it's all guesswork. Obviously, it's something that I have thought about. I think risk parity, to its credit, has volatility triggers so that prevents them from just riding those trades into the ground. And I don't know if this is— stagflation would strike me as less of a one-time trigger event like the financial crisis and something more that's maybe just a slow bleed or slow burn where you just have a longer, more drawn-out bear market in stocks and bonds together. And maybe they don't move perfectly correlated the whole time, but the general trend for both is to the south side.

I'm more worried about individual investors who today think that buying bonds is going to balance out their portfolio. And the only reason they believe that is because over the Over the last 30 years, it's worked that way. But if you look back further in time, you needed to have other assets in there. Financial assets do move in tandem. They're not— stocks and bonds aren't negatively correlated for actually most of history. And so the risk parity question is really difficult to answer.

But I do think that this 10-year period of ultra-low volatility and rising asset prices, I've been calling the everything bubble for 2 or 3 years now at least, has really given people incredible confidence in a number of really risky strategies, whether it's leveraging up bonds through risk parity or selling put options or volatility targeting, short selling volatility, selling catastrophe insurance. I mean, investors got into buying catastrophe bonds, essentially selling catastrophe insurance. There's just too many of them to count, and you know who knows how they're going to unwind. But history shows that whenever people become way too confident like this, it does end in some type of a painful thing. And really, I do think passive investing in both stocks and bonds, saying I'm going to buy financial assets and I'm going to dominate my portfolio with financial assets regardless of the price that I pay, is one of those you know one of those.

systems, strategies that I think is just built on overconfidence generated by 10 years of wonderful returns.

Value plus momentum: Bed Bath & Beyond and short semiconductors

Erik Townsend: I know that your personal favorite style of investing is value investing. How do you do that when by your own description, almost everything is overpriced?

Jesse Felder: There are good values in the markets to be found. I think one of the stocks that I like right now is Bed Bath & Beyond The stock trades at 2.5 times free cash flow, has almost no debt. I think it's $500 million in debt and they do $750 million in free cash flow every year. So that's a stock that's extremely cheap. The short sellers have gone crazy in this thing. I think more than 50, roughly 50% of the float is now short. And so if this company just stays in business, it's going to triple in price. So those are the types of things that I look for to own on the long side. And I sell short other names on the other side to try and ameliorate just general market risk.

Erik Townsend: So even in your value investing strategy, you're still running a long-short equity interpretation of value investing where I guess, would you consider overpriced stocks that you can short a form of value investing?

Jesse Felder: Yeah. So I try and pair value with momentum. And so I look for things that are cheap that I want to buy that have waning momentum on the downside. They're usually typically in downtrends, but I don't want to buy something that has strong downside momentum. I mean, that's the classic, you know, catching a falling knife, things I want to avoid. And same thing with selling something short. I don't want to short sell something that has strong upside momentum. I want to find something that's— I think Nvidia last year was a perfect example. I'm still short semiconductors pretty heavily. They're extremely highly valued right now. Momentum has been turning for just like the broad stock market for the last 18 months.

And so I think the combination of those and the fundamentals are deteriorating rapidly. I mean, these companies are seeing sales declines 20%, 30%, 40%, 20% year over year and the stock prices are still holding up. And so investors essentially gambling that this semi-down cycle is going to rapidly reverse itself to the upside and these insane valuations are going to be justified. But Nvidia was a great example last year where it was pretty obvious with the implosion of the crypto markets that mining was going to take a hit and that was all of their incremental demand for chips.

And so Nvidia was trading at its highest valuation in company history, even higher than it traded in the peak of the dot-com mania. And a lot of it was built on that excess demand that was just evaporating along with the Bitcoin price. And so those are the types of things I look for on the short side. And I will qualify that by saying I don't put on huge positions on the short side. I use indexes a lot for hedging and my short positions I keep relatively small compared to what I do on the long side. When I find ideas that I like on the long side, I feel pretty comfortable putting on big-size positions. The other factor that I use besides valuation and momentum is insider buying and selling. So when I see insiders buying 3, 4 times their annual salary in stock in a company that I see is very cheap, that's something that gets me really interested.

When I see insiders on the other side, Nvidia insiders were selling massively, talking a good game during the quarterly conference calls. And then as soon as the conference call ends, let's go dump half our shares, 60%, 70%, 80%. of our stake in the company. And that's usually a pretty good sign too, that it's confirming my other ideas about the company.

Gold breakout, silver and miners sentiment

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to gold. I have to admit that I was caught off guard by this breakout. I do believe very strongly that as central bankers paint their way into a corner they can't get out of, that gold is going to be the asset to own in the long run. I didn't think we were quite at the point where it was going to be time for gold to take off. But this $1,350-$1,375 resistance level has been there for 5 solid years. So far it's been, what, at least 2 or 3 weeks now that we've sustained a breakout above it. And, you know, it's— we haven't gone super high to the upside, we're not ripping higher, but we're not retracing down lower either. I'm guessing that you probably were bullish before that happened, but what's your take and how has this breakout

Jesse Felder: Yeah. I've been really bullish gold since mid-2015. I think when the Wall Street Journal published Jason Zweig's article, and I'm a big fan of Jason, I think he's a brilliant financial thinker, but he wrote an article suggesting that gold was a pet rock. And when that gets highlighted by the Wall Street Journal, the biggest financial publication in the world, you have a pretty good idea where sentiment stands towards something. And after it peaked in 2011, 4-year bear market, created tons of pain. Meb Faber's done research that when you see an asset class decline, whatever it is, 20% a year for 3 years in a row, it's usually a good buy. Gold did that for 4 years in a row into '15, and it became a great buy at whatever it was, $1,050 back then. And I've been really bullish on the gold price since then. I love the fact that it's essentially $1,400 now.

It's up $350, and people are still skeptical about gold. It's up, what is that, 30% plus in the last several years. I think it's roughly equal to the stock market over that time. People are extremely bullish stocks and extremely skeptical towards gold. And to me, those are just wonderful sentiment signals that when the stock market goes nowhere for 18 months and people are still bullish, that's kind of what happens early on in a bear market is people don't give up on it until prices really break lower. Same thing with an early bull The bull market in gold to me feels like 2010, '11 in the stock market when people were still, even '12. It wasn't until 2013 when stocks really broke higher, the Russell 2000 broke above a really important resistance level, just like gold did recently, that people started figuring out, okay, now it's time to go buy stocks. And I think that's where we are in gold.

Paul Tudor Jones recently said, if it breaks above that $1,350, $1,400, it's going to $1,700. Pretty quickly. And that's just the technical target that makes sense with that projecting off that rounded base that it's made. And I think the way we get there is from people realizing this desire to create inflation, this desire to create a weaker dollar is something that almost has to happen. It's something that we're seeing in the White House. We're seeing Elizabeth Warren talk about it. We're seeing the Federal Reserve talk about we need to create more inflation and they're going to do whatever it takes to make it happen. And if they do, the dollar is going to tank and everyone's going to realize we have to have a ton of gold in the portfolio, a significant allocation. Once that realization happens, that's how you get $1,700 gold.

Erik Townsend: Now, a lot of gold investors are also, at least the speculative gold investors, are also really big on silver. And something that surprised me a little bit is I would have expected that when you saw this very strong technical confirmation signal that says, hey, gold really clearly has caught a bid here, something's going on.

I would have expected silver to just be crazy up at that point as all of the, the really speculative interests said, okay, we got our confirmation, let's, let's pounce on silver. Seems like silver's lagging a little bit. What's going on?

Jesse Felder: You know, I, I've thought about this. I, I think it might just be, you know, like I said, the semiconductor industry is, is really hurting right now, and, you know, silver does have industrial applications that people might just be worried that if we are heading into recession, the demand for silver might collapse. And that might be what's holding it back. But it hasn't been this cheap relative to gold since I think the early '90s or something. It's ridiculous how cheap silver is. But then again, you look at the gold mining stocks and they're as cheap. They haven't been this cheap relative to the metal since early 2000s, 2000, 2001, something something like that. And so to me, those are all signs. Another sentiment signal I look at for the metals is, you know, there's the— used to be the Central Fund of Canada. It's now the Sprott Gold and Silver Trust. It still trades at a discount to its net asset value. And to me, this is amazing because Sprott, when they took it over, announced a conversion feature.

They will convert your shares in this closed-end fund to bullion whenever you want. And so there's no reason it should trade at a discount. I'm surprised somebody He hasn't just bought up shares and converted just to arbitrage the difference. And so to me, all of those signs, the silver relative to gold, the miners relative to the gold price, these discounts in the closed-end funds still all suggest to me that people really just haven't embraced the bull market yet.

Surveillance capitalism and the tipping point against big tech

Erik Townsend: Jesse, I had a conversation recently with Pippa Malmgren about surveillance capitalism and this change that's going on. When Silicon Valley got into the software business with, I don't know, I guess it was Microsoft and Apple and Macintosh and Windows and so forth. These things were cool. Everybody liked them. There was no threat that anybody thought was a bad thing about computers other than maybe young people spent too much time on them and were undersocialized. Now we've gotten to the point where Facebook has material influence over elections in multiple countries.

And something that I've become even more concerned with, in fact, I produced a video recently, Which is at MacroVoices.com. For people who only get MacroVoices, by the way, in your iTunes feed, there is more content there. We haven't figured out how to get the video into the iTunes feed. So that's at MacroVoices.com on the homepage. But I did a 45-minute video on this subject about digital currency and where it's headed and my concerns about Facebook. You've been writing quite a bit about this subject for years now. We talked a little off the air and you said you think it's maybe coming to a tipping What did you mean by that? What's the tipping point and what can we expect?

Jesse Felder: Well, it's interesting. Malcolm Gladwell wrote his book, The Tipping Point, in the early 2000s, really before we had this idea of things going viral, really before social media and all this, and before network effects and these kinds of things really became the jargon for the internet industry. And then you had companies like Facebook and Google and they really became what they are today because of these network effects and viral spread of information. And I really do think now that this backlash against big tech is going viral and they are at risk of these viral effects being as negative for them as they were positive in the beginning.

Gladwell, in his book, says you need 3 different things to get to a tipping point where something, a trend, goes viral. And the first is you need a handful of kind of really insightful and influential people to take up the message. Then you need to have a message that resonates strongly with other people, and then it needs to be spread in an environment that's fertile for that type of a message to gain traction. And I think we have all those things today.

We had somebody like Lina Khan who wrote about how Amazon had created such anti-competitive business practices that we really need to rethink the antitrust framework. And now that's being discussed by the Department of Justice. And there are attorney generals, state attorney generals all over the country that are looking into this. And so you had a handful of people like Lina. Roger McNamee was somebody who I interviewed on my podcast who came out and said, Facebook was maybe my greatest investment ever, but now I'm absolutely frightened at what it's become and it desperately needs to be regulated. So you have a handful of these people people, they're spreading this powerful message that these companies, maybe they're not hurting consumers in terms of raising prices, but they're hurting people in other ways. And they're actually severely and demonstratively hurting competition within their industries.

And so, the third thing is you need this fertile environment. And I do think when you think about what's going on with populism and why we're seeing these populist uprisings around the world, It's due to wealth and power inequality. And when you look at these companies, they are the poster children for wealth inequality. You look at Jeff Bezos, the richest man in the world, and the workers in his warehouses are some of the poorest treated workers in the country. And so the dichotomy there just makes them the perfect target for these sentiments, these sentiments that are the backlash towards wealth inequality and power inequality. So I think all these things are coming together right now. And we're And we're seeing at the FTC and at the Department of Justice, they're saying, this is not a political issue. This is bipartisan. It's people in both parties and people from all walks of life saying that we need to figure out how to regulate these companies because they're hurting competition.

They are potentially the poster children for what's gone wrong with capitalism over the last 10, 15 years too. So I do think this movement, this backlash against big tech is growing and it has major implications. for these companies and as leaders of our stock market over the last 10 years has major implications for the stock market too.

Will users leave? Acquisition limits and data disclosure laws

Erik Townsend: It's very interesting. As you were talking there, I couldn't help but think, it seems to me like Malcolm Gladwell maybe left out a 4th bullet point there, which is you've got to have influencers and the various other things that he said. But I think you also have to either not be taking away something that was really Or you've got to be providing an alternative to it that's safer and better. And, you know, what I see in this public discussion is there's a lot of people, I mean a lot of people in society who are fighting mad at Google and Facebook because of these things that have come out about how they mine our personal data and use them for reasons and purposes that we never consented to and so forth. And they They're just absolutely bitterly angry. But do they stop using social media? No. Why? Because that's what keeps them connected to their friends, and it's really cool.

They like it. And I guess what I fear is unless you're going to replace these things, and maybe regulating them in a way, you know, I would like to see it resolved through free market enterprise, you know, for somebody else to come along into a Facebook that comes with promises that they're not going to misbehave the way Facebook does.

But it seems like once Facebook is entrenched, it's very hard for someone else to come in and compete with them. So I just wonder, you know, are we really going to expect people, even though they get angry, are they actually going to delete Facebook and close their accounts, or are they going to just gripe about it and keep using it?

Jesse Felder: That's a really good question, and I think we've seen a little bit of both. I saw something this week, I think it was the Telegraph reported engagement in the UK. Facebook engagement is down 40% in the last year since the Cambridge Analytica scandal. This is why Facebook stopped breaking it out and they started putting it together and reporting WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook together because I think they're afraid that yes, the Facebook brand is dying on the vine and people are abandoning that platform. Maybe not everybody, but there's definitely signs that show engagement. engagement here in the US and in the UK is down dramatically over the past 12 months.

I think one of the things that regulators are talking about doing, which would really be perhaps detrimental to Facebook and Amazon and Google, is to simply just bar them from making any more acquisitions. You look at how important the Instagram acquisition was to Facebook. If they had not bought Instagram for $1 billion, and it's probably worth more than the Facebook platform is today, that would be a completely different company today. You look at Google and they've made billions and billions of dollars of acquisitions in just the last 18 months.

DoubleClick was an acquisition. These companies, if they were just the original platforms, it was just Google Search, it would be a totally different business. Same thing with Amazon. If Amazon were not allowed to go into and buy up competitors, and this is the thing, the real antitrust argument that I think the regulators have is that these companies have such a great hold on the data. They can see where their consumers are going. They can see where their users are going. And they can say, wow, there's already a Decent viral shift towards this new platform. We better buy it, and that's what's allowed them to dominate their markets.

And so I think if regulators say we want to really spur competition in these areas, the way to do that is prevent these companies from making any more acquisitions. If they do that, then that potentially—you know better than anybody, Erik—in such a fast-changing world, as you know, technology and these things—if you can't. keep up, you're going to be left behind. And I think that's something that's already being talked about. And in fact, people are speculating that these companies are already going to just of their own free will slow down their acquisition spree just to try and get regulators to not pay so much attention to them. So that's just one area of it, but I think it's a really important one.

Erik Townsend: I see your point, but it seems to me that mergers and acquisitions also play a very valuable role in growing the economy and growing the efficacy of businesses that do good things. Is there a way to address this with disclosure? I mean, you know, when you apply for credit or something, they have to tell you certain things about how information is being used. It seems to me like what we really need is a law that says anytime anybody on the internet is collecting any information about you, they have to do 2 things by law. They have to, number one, disclose what it is that they're collecting, even if it was something that was being collected in an unobvious way that you might not have noticed otherwise. And they also have to tell you what they're going to do with the information that they've collected. It seems to me if you, if you had a law about that, yeah, compliance with that would be expensive.

It would be a burden. And I hate to see businesses burdened with regulatory compliance. But it seems to me that would more directly address the real issues than something like a ban on acquisitions. Is there a downside or am I missing something or do you think that wouldn't be practical or what?

Jesse Felder: No, I absolutely agree with you. And I think it's probably a combination of these things. And Europe has really tried to lead in this direction with the GDPR legislation. And I think it's probably coming here. There was a great article in the New York Times this week about this very topic that these companies rely so heavily on data that the only way you're really going to be able to rein them in is by regulating the data. And I agree with that completely. I think we should have the right to tell people to stop tracking us or to delete our data and all those things. But it's really, really difficult to do.

There have been ideas about breaking up the companies and separating platforms and data collection from if you want to be an advertiser, if you want to be selling advertising, you need to separate yourself from the platform. So that would apply to to Amazon, Facebook, what have you, that they have too much power in trying to create the platform and then also use the data and then sell the advertising to that data. So there's a lot of different ideas there. I don't know where it's going, but I do know that I think we have reached a tipping point. I do think there is going to be regulation coming down the pike. It's probably gonna be a combination of all of these things in some way or another.

And if you look at the history of regulating, trust-busting, antitrust history, the sector that's been at the center of it has always gone from being the most powerful and the most profitable in the market to becoming an also-ran within the market. Once Washington turns its eye on a sector in this respect, it usually means the end of that, the leadership of that sector in the market. So I do think, People need to pay attention to this in terms of their equity portfolios and say, what kind of exposure do we want to have to this right now?

These companies are already beginning to price it in. Google is not extremely overvalued. Amazon probably is. Facebook is— valuation has come in, but everything depends on what this regulation is going to look like. If you look at even Microsoft, once they reined it in, the stock didn't do much. Also, the other thing to point out with that episode was that the lawsuit against Microsoft really coincided with the bursting of the dot-com mania.

I really do think this new bipartisan regulation could represent a similar type of catalyst for the broad stock market right now.

Facebook's Libra and the future of digital currency

Erik Townsend: Something I thought was very interesting was that as soon as Facebook announced Libra, first of all, the reaction of Congress Congress was kind of unprecedented, I thought. They didn't really cite any authority or, you know, under the— according to the powers vested in us by the such-and-such act, we ask you to stop doing this. So they just said, look, we don't like this. This is really not cool. Please stop doing it. It seems to me that they're not going to stop doing it. And if anything, I think the message is out that governments are starting to recognize what I've said all along, which is digital currency is going to change the world completely. And it's going to be a question, it's going to be a challenge as to how much control government actually has over it. What do you make of Facebook's Libra currency and some of the other things that are going on in the digital currency space?

How do you interpret all of these things?

Jesse Felder: Yeah, well, I have to say, I loved your conversation with Pippa, and your book informs a lot of my thinking on, you know, when it comes to these things. It's funny, every time— I think when Libra was announced, I said— I put out a tweet, said, everybody should go back and listen to my conversation with Erik because it was so relevant to what's going on. I do think that— I mean, all the central banks are looking at creating their own digital currencies right now. I think the Bank of China was the last one who came out just yesterday or this morning or something and said that Libra does pose a risk to— it's a systemic risk to the global financial system.

And so there's no way that central banks are going to allow any kind of currency like this that crosses borders and whatever and kind of completely makes them impotent in terms of their abilities to manage the financial system.

And I do think this is another horrible— I mean, I try and think about what's Facebook's thinking here. Obviously, if they could pull it off, it'd make them incredibly powerful in terms of the additional data collection that it would give them. And I mean, essentially make them their own central bank. And so, to me, they have to realize that in this current environment, in terms of the perception of Facebook, them announcing this right now is like, wait a second, after Cambridge Analytica and all this kind of stuff, you think we're going to trust you to run the world financial system? You got to be crazy. So, to me, this really smacks of desperation that the Facebook platform is dying on the vine and they need something like this in order to try and save that platform.

Otherwise, they would They would've held off and wait until there's a better environment PR-wise for them to come out with something like this.

So I think in the end, there's no way the powers that be are going to allow something like this to have its own autonomy over financial transactions and what have you. It's going to be regulated somehow. And more likely, I agree with your idea that central banks are going to come up with their own cross-border digital currency that they're going to be able to keep control of.

Erik Townsend: That's fascinating, Jesse. We actually disagree pretty strongly on this, and I just want to run my thoughts by you because they've changed quite a bit, or I should say they've evolved since I wrote the book. I'd love to get your reactions because I know you do a lot of thinking about this.

When the cryptocurrency guys, the Bitcoin maximalists, talk about how Bitcoin's going to change the world and become the new government, replace the US dollar as the center point of the global financial system. I just don't know what these guys are smoking because, as you just said, there's no way governments are going to allow that to happen. And whether the crypto community wants to admit it or not, governments very much are able to stop that from happening. I think what's going on here is I think the Silicon Valley giants, the Googles and the Facebooks, are saying, Yeah, you know what? There's no way that the crypto guys would ever pull this off, but we could. If we wanna create a currency system and use all of the weight of Google or Facebook, these very, very influential large companies, I think they think they've got a shot at basically beating central banks to the punchline.

If central bankers had their act together, they would have benefited from the invention of double-spend-proof digital cash, and they would have created their own central bank-issued digital currencies. And yes, we've seen, you know, there was just a conference in Sweden about central bank-issued digital currencies that our friend Steve Keen spoke at, and there's a lot of thinking going on. But I think that Silicon Valley is saying, wait a minute, governments are thinking and acting at government speed. We can act at Silicon Valley speed. We can design a currency system that is so much better that governments can't do anything to stop it. And they won't do it the way that the crypto guys did it, trying to intentionally alienate and frustrate law enforcement. They'll take a very different approach that will allow them to be compliant with taxes and so forth. But I think they want to get market share behind a currency system that works so much better than paper money that there's enough public will that it's very hard for central bankers to compete with it.

And I think that they have a very real chance of doing that if they're not stopped. And I'm not really sure what could be done to stop them. And I know you haven't seen the video that I have out yet that talks about a lot of this. There may be another one coming behind it, but just based on what I said there, any reactions to that?

Jesse Felder: I agree with you in terms of, I think Silicon Valley thinks that they can accomplish this. Yes, somebody's going to do it. The Bank of China said that the problem with Libra is they still haven't solved the— they said the code is buggy. It's not going to work. They tested it and that they still haven't figured out how they're going to process that number of transactions on the blockchain. They think that it's probably not going to be blockchain-based entirely because they still haven't solved that problem. But I do think if you look at the letter that Congress sent to Facebook, they basically— it was almost a cease and desist. It wasn't technically a cease and desist, but it was basically saying, if you guys move forward with this, we're probably going to have to shut it down while we investigate it. So I just don't think think that central banks around the world are ever going to say, we'll allow Mark Zuckerberg to have this kind of power.

And I do think they do have the power to shut it down. The other side of it too that I think about is when I look at this tipping point against big tech, I think most people probably would look at this and go, do I really want to give Mark Zuckerberg that much information about myself and that much power over my funds and And what have you. And I do think that the majority of people today, you look at the polls right now where they're polling trust in Facebook and trust in Instagram and these platforms, the majority of people say, I don't trust Mark Zuckerberg. And that's probably why he's not branding it Facebook Coin.

But at the same time, I think it's a pretty big stretch to get people to see, with 30%, 40% drops in engagement on Facebook, to say that they're going to come back to the platform in order to send money is a stretch.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Jesse Felder: If it were a different Silicon Valley company with a different brand, I might see it differently. They'd have a better chance of succeeding. But with Facebook's brand so tarnished right now, like I said, I really see this as an act of desperation on behalf of the company more than anything else.

Erik Townsend: Jesse, well, it's really going to be interesting to see how all of this plays out because I really do not want Mark Zuckerberg to be in charge of how money works. I think that's the scariest thing that that I've ever heard. And that's what I said in the, in the video. And I may do another video just for central bankers to try to explain some of these concepts to them a little bit better.

The Felder Report newsletter and podcast

Erik Townsend: In any case, we're out of time. I want to touch on what you're doing. The Felder Report is one of the, the best free newsletters in existence. Tell us about that. But also, you had taken a little hiatus from podcasting for a while. I believe you have resumed the Superinvestors podcast series. Tell us what's going on there.

Jesse Felder: Yeah, I did. Yeah. So the free weekly newsletter I put out is basically, I just do a ton of reading and research every week. And every Saturday, I put together the 5 things I found most valuable. Last week, I shared your interview with Pippa because I found that so valuable. But that just is a free email that goes out on Saturday mornings. But yeah, I took a little hiatus from the podcast, but I'm at the point where I have some really interesting people I want to talk to. And to me, that's where it comes from. If I get really curious about something and say, hey, I got to talk to this And so, I just interviewed Michael Oliver, Momentum Structural Analysis. That podcast is going to come out, I think, this week. And what a brilliant guy. And so, I'm just so excited to share his unique methodology with my audience.

And I have a couple more lined up, probably going to be on a once-a-month schedule going forward, just because that's about all I can manage.

Erik Townsend: And that's all at thefelderreport.com. Jesse, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues. Right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. We'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: chartbook preview and negative-yielding junk bonds

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Jesse back onto the show. And, you know, he inspired me for this week's Chartbook because one, right off the bat when he started talking about market breadth and the divergences we're seeing in the markets, I thought it's a great idea for us to put some visuals to this and really kind of go through all of this and see where all those divergences are. So I want to go into that here in just a moment. But before we do, last week we started talking about all the negative yields in Europe, and we were just having a conversation. You wanted to take another dive into this. What's on your mind here this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Bloomberg had a piece out this week describing how there are now 14 separate junk bond issues in Europe that are negative yielding. And this to me, it just epitomizes the argument that I mentioned at the beginning of the market wrap, which is we are way past crazy in this regime of markets being driven by the way the system is being gamed by central banks, not by economic fundamentals. Just think about how preposterous Preposterous this notion is that you would have negative-yielding junk-rated debt. So, you know, it's— I've got money, why would I loan it to a company who gets a lousy credit rating and might not pay it back? Because I've got the opportunity to lose guaranteed— there's no way to make money on this, but I'm only going to lose a small amount of money for the privilege of being in this bond that is issued by a company that— I guess the only way you could possibly make sense of this is the negative yield is perhaps not as deeply negative as the sovereign yield is.

But the notion of a guaranteed loss for the sake of buying a bond— and, you know, it's a guaranteed loss if you hold it to maturity. If you're speculating on it, the only way you can possibly make money speculating is if that yield goes more deeply negative, if the idea of wanting to loan monies to companies with shaky credit history somehow becomes even more appealing so that more people want to do it at more deeply negative yields. That's the only way a speculator can win in that. So you really have to ask yourself, how is it even possible that markets have gotten here? And the answer at the high level is very simple. It's because markets are being driven by these liquidity influences that don't really have much to do with economic fundamentals. Someday this whole system has to break and come to an end, and when it does, I don't think it's gonna be a pretty picture.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, in Chicago I'm gonna be talking about this because I think that this is just a testament to the financial repression that is actually being pushed through the whole system. And the negative yields is not a decision of a, you know, what return I'm going to get, but is a function of just the fact that the bond market has been repressed to this magnitude that it's leading to even junk bonds being negative yielding. Anyway, let's move on to this chart deck. Now, for those of our listeners that want to download this, you can find it in your Research Roundup email. Those of you that are not registered for the Roundup email, you can go to MacroVoices.com

Shale decline rates and US oil production

Patrick Ceresna: and register your free account and then be able to access the chart book from there. So now, Erik, in the charts, even though I wanted to talk about the market breadth and divergences. You asked me to add this one chart on oil and what's going on in the Permian Basin.

What's on your mind here?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this chart caught my eye just because it's so visually intuitive, and it makes a point that Art Berman has made on this program and I've made, and it's just to show you the decline rates in shale oil are such that just a couple of years after these rigs go into production, the rate of production declines very steeply. And what this particular graph is showing us so nicely visually is that the amount of shale oil that is currently being produced by shale wells that went into production before January 1st, 2017— that's the whole shale revolution up to 2017— that's less oil production than the new rigs that have been drilled just since January of 2017, which is the orange and the blue color that we see at the top of the graph. And the point is, those are going to decline rapidly, as you can already see the orange doing. The point is, when shale plays out, and when I say plays out, there is a geological argument that at some point we've drilled up the whole country like Swiss cheese and there's not enough resources left that are economic.

But there's also the argument of what happens if we get into market conditions where suddenly all of the free-flowing money that has financed shale drilling isn't there anymore. If you're not able to make new shale wells, then the production, which has been the savior of this entire market for the last decade, suddenly collapses very, very quickly. And my point is, I don't think we're there yet. I think oil prices are probably headed lower before they go higher. But when they eventually go higher and we get to the point where we're not adding more shale because the, the sweet spots have already been exploited and the easy money is no longer there, you could get a really, really dramatic price appreciation in oil very, very quickly. We're not there yet, but this chart just really visually shows you why that's coming someday. And it really makes me think about watching that US production number that right now seems to be plateauing just over 12 million barrels.

Is it going to continue to grow past its current all-time high at 12.4, or is it going to fall back below 12? The reason I'm watching that so carefully is epitomized by the visual effect you can see on this chart on page 2.

Breadth divergences: Russell 2000, transports, banks, autos, XME

Patrick Ceresna: That was really interesting, Erik. So let's move on to the rest of the chartbook because this is where I wanted to talk about these divergences in the markets. And Jesse, during the interview, referenced Stanley Druckenmiller and well, some of the divergences that are occurring in the markets. And I thought we would visualize them and just take a look at what's going on here. And so what I have on just page 3 is the chart of the S&P 500, which as we can see is making 52-week and all-time new highs, broken higher. So what I wanted to do is obviously cherry-pick the segments of the market that are simply not playing along with the S&P. And where is all this divergence that, that is, uh, happening. And so on page 4 is, uh, the industrial index, because a lot of people are referencing a lot of these industrials. And, and, you know, if you particularly pick on something like a 3M, the chart looks, let's say, far more bearish than the broader industrial index does.

But the one thing we can see when looking at, uh, the industrial index is that it is not in a position to make 52-week highs immediately. I mean, it's retested those highs, but each high that it's made, even though it's very modest, each high that it's made in 2018 and 2019 is a consecutively lower high.

This is far more evident in the Russell. Now, the Russell 2000, which is the small caps, had a pretty strong push in the first half of 2018, but after putting in its summer high of It was particularly hammered hard during the sell-off at the tail end of the year and has barely recovered half of the losses that it incurred during that September to December sell-off that we saw in 2018.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it definitely begs the question of why the S&P is getting all of the attention. You know, when I think about why that might be, because clearly you're seeing these divergences very clearly here. The Russell's not seeing it. Well, let's think about Brent Johnson's argument for foreigners buying. If foreigners are buying, they're much more likely to buy the S&P, which is the biggest, most well-known index, at least to institutional investors, as opposed to be buying the Russell or something. So it really says to me that maybe Brent's idea that foreign capital flows are what's keeping the S&P levitated might be at play. But let's go ahead and move on to slide number 6 and look at the transports and see what that tells us.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, on the transports, actually an interesting little bit of information is that the transport index actually is older than the Dow Jones index. Charles Dow and Edward Jones, when they were putting together these indices even a decade earlier, put together transport index, Obviously, to follow the rail stocks back then. But this is the longest-standing indice in the world. And the transport index obviously today has these 30 transport stocks that is a mix of rails and the whole mix of them all. It also has been substantially divergent from this. I mean, we're nowhere near the 2018 highs and even not even close to clearing those March, April May highs that were, were put in earlier this year. The transports continue to be a major laggard.

All right. So moving on to slide 7, what I wanted to just show is how huge of a laggard even the regional banks have been. The regional banks have barely recovered even half of their losses from, from that 2018 plunge. And so, you know, the, the meat of the US stock market, all of the plumbing down below simply is not participating the way that you see with those mega large caps that are continuing to drive this rally. But then when you go to the heart of some of those transport sectors, such as let's say the airlines, the airline sector has just been nothing but just sideways chop for 2 years straight. And then if you let's say move on to chart 9 and you looking at those, the global auto index, all of these auto stocks have just been devastated. And not only have they not recovered like some of the others, they're actually a stone's throw away from their 52-week lows. So this idea that there's a recession being led by these kind of autos and rails and things like this makes a lot of sense.

And finally, what I want to do is just take a look at that metals and ETF, which is the XME. And again, very similar to the autos, this thing is not only not recovered from the 2018 carnage, but similarly is sitting near its 52-week lows, just, uh, just about to tip over, like if it's got another leg lower coming. And so when you look outside of those technology names and those really large-cap consumer staple and discretionary names that have truly been running the S&P 500 higher. These kind of core sectors within the market are showing very little sign of participating in the upside of the market.

Percent above moving averages, NYSE vs S&P 500 and buybacks

Erik Townsend: Okay, Patrick, clearly what we see comparing the S&P to all of these other charts you've presented is there seems to be a good argument that there's really some, some breadth issues and divergence between the most popular index in the rest of the market. What other measures can we look at to try to get our heads around this besides just looking at other charts?

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So this is where I wanted to look at 2 more breadth indicators that are actually very similar in their nature. One, it looks at the percentage of stocks that are above their 50-day moving averages, and the other looks at the percentage of stocks above their 200-day moving averages. Now normally these are just looked at just in isolation to just see where the get a sense of whether the market is overbought or oversold. But I wanted to actually look at the divergence between 2 sets of data points. The first one, the black line on chart 11, which is the percentage of stocks above their 50-day moving average. Let's just clarify for our listeners, what this is doing is taking the 500 stocks in the S&P 500 and asking a simple question: of these 500 stocks, what percentage of them are trading above their 50-day moving average? Right. Day moving average. And it's a simple thing. It's an oscillator that oscillates between 0 and 100%.

And right now the S&P 500 is at 80%. And that's actually something you'd expect at a market that is making 52-week highs, that we're somewhere definitely in top quartile on this indicator. But what's interesting is I overlaid the percentage of stocks above their 50-day moving average for the entire New York Stock Exchange. So rather than just the 500 stocks that make up the S&P 500, now we're talking broadly all of the stocks that are— that make up the NYSE. And that is sitting down well under 60%.

And so we have a scenario where it really demonstrates the fact that when you broaden the stock market outside the S&P 500, there is more and more stocks that are simply not participating. This is really just a focus on a core group of those large-cap names that are driving all this. And, you know, some contributors to that— people can make an argument that it's the share buybacks and other things that are going on in the S&P 500 that are contributors. Sure it is. But, but really what we're trying to do with these charts is simply demonstrate the divergence once you look under the hood and look at the internals in the So when we move on to page 12 and we're looking at the percentage of stocks that are above their 200-day moving averages, what I thought was interesting here was that, like expected, the S&P 500 is like over 70% of their stocks above their 200-day moving average. But when we move to the New York Stock Exchange, it's barely above 50%.

That means that like only like 1 out of every 2 stocks on the NYSE are above their 200-day moving average.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Patrick Ceresna: day moving averages. And that makes me kind of go, hmm, right? You would think that if we're— but I mean, maybe that's what happens in late-stage business cycle when you have a blow-off of the stock market. It's not, I guess, not a healthy broad rally. It's really, you know, like the equivalent in the '70s of the Nifty 50 that would kind of drive the whole stock market and the perception that the stock market is doing well, but the breadth is just awful, right?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, you mentioned in passing buybacks. I think they're probably a critical part of this. Now, I should be careful because I am not an expert on financing of buyback transactions, but off the top of my head, I would guess that it's a lot easier for the CEO of an S&P 500 company to get financing through the junk bond market to do a massive share buyback. It's going to be easier for the S&P 500 CEO than it is going to be for the Russell 2000 CEO to make that same transaction happen with his investment bankers. It seems like the story here is if you're in that exclusive club called the S&P 500, you've got access to capital for buybacks, and you've probably got more attention from international investors that are looking to buy the most liquid and widely used index. It all seems like it's a recipe to say the S&P gets favorable treatment.

Now, the question that that really evokes in my mind, Patrick, is, okay, is it set to continue? Because as Brent Johnson thinks, the, the foreigners are going to keep on buying the S&P, especially if the dollar starts to appreciate? Or is it one of those cases where the breadth is really telling us that the S&P is about to give out and catch down to the rest of the market? I could make the case either way, and normally I would favor the latter case. It makes more logical sense to me. Frankly, things that make logical sense haven't been working in this market recently. So as far as I'm concerned, the jury is out. So I don't see any certain conclusion here, Patrick, on slide 12.

Chicago Traders Expo bull-bear debate

Erik Townsend: But if I move on to slide 13, we do have a certain conclusion, which is our listeners who want to meet you and our good friend Kevin Muir and watch Kevin kick your tail in a debate can go to Chicago for Traders Expo, July 21st through 23rd.

Tell us what's going on there.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, right, it's— I can't believe it's already just one weekend away. But on Sunday, July 21st, It's free to attend. It's at the Chicago Traders Expo. John Netto is going to moderate a bull-bear debate between Kevin and myself. And while we're going to talk about stocks in it, it's really— I think the meat of it is he's a legitimate bond bear, and I tend to have a much more bullish outlook on bonds than he does. And we're going to do a smackdown, and it's going to be a really interesting showdown. A lot lot of my narrative is, is built around the continuation of the financial repression we've seen, that it's just going to continue. And I'm going to explain my whole case during that session. So anyone who wants to join us, it's free to attend. But the best part is, after listening to that session— first of all, John Netto is running that whole Global Macro Edge event during the Sunday morning, and afterwards we're all heading for a We're gonna meet up at the bar over there at the Public House on State Street.

We're gonna meet up around 2:00 PM and we're gonna hopefully meet up with all of our listeners. It's free to attend. Anyone who comes out can join us. We're gonna have a pint to drink and it's just gonna be an opportunity to meet so many of our listeners and get feedback. So I'm looking forward to meeting any of you that can make it out.

Erik Townsend: So we should organize an online poll for who won the debate and the loser of the debate buys the beer for everybody. Sound like a deal?

Patrick Ceresna: That sounds like a plan. I'm in. No. Oh boy. I plan on winning, so that's, uh, that's, uh, that's gonna make it easy. I'll have to find out whether, uh, Kevin agrees to that, right?

Sign-off, Research Roundup and announcer close

Erik Townsend: We'll have to hit Kevin up and see what happens. I wish I could be there myself. In any event, we're gonna have to leave it there this week, folks. Today's episode was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free book and subscribe to their podcast as well. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo.

And of course, don't forget to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email, which will provide you with download links for our content as well as all of the best free research that we could find on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the charts we discussed in the postgame. There's also an interesting article from Lakshman Achuthan, which is talking about the myth of the tight labor markets. I thought it was really interesting as well. There's an interesting article on what will an earnings recession do to stocks. And, you know, since this is potentially this earnings cycle going to be the second quarter of contracting earnings, it's going to be really interesting to see what impacts that has on stocks. And it was a really interesting piece on all of that. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners. And we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.

Now, for those of our listeners that write Or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank Thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed The views expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading. And by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

John Netto — Author (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Show open: episode 174 and S&P 500 at 3,000

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 174 was pre-recorded on July 3rd, 2019 for release on July 4th, 2019, when fireworks will celebrate independent— no, wait a minute, it's 3,000 on the S&P that those fireworks are celebrating. In any case, I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the leading podcast when it comes to systematic trading and investing. Due to the US holiday, our market commentary will only be current through noon on Wednesday, July 3rd.

Author John Netto joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss current market drivers and then move on to some bigger picture topics, which John covers in his book, Global Macro Edge. We'll have an abbreviated postgame segment this week with a quick chartbook update on a number of different charts, particularly the S&P 500. Holy cow, folks. 3,000 on the S&P. Who would have seen that coming? Oh yeah, we did.

Market wrap: S&P 500, rate cut and summer scenarios

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick. So, Erik, let's get right into that S&P. You've referenced it now twice, the 3,000 level. It's— we're right on the cusp of it. Obviously a really bullish reaction after the G20. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I've been thinking, Patrick, once the China deal is done, and I'm convinced we're gonna get some kind of China deal, I don't know if it's gonna be a good, bad, or indifferent one, but we're gonna get some kind of deal. Both leaders have too much at stake to let this fall apart, to just go to no deal.

And I think we're going to get a rate cut. Is it 25 or 50 basis points? Well, we'll see what happens.

Okay. After those things happen, what's left to drive the next leg higher after that? Well, one answer is declining interest rates fueling even more stock buybacks. But at what point are Democrats going to begin trying to intentionally sabotage the economy in the run-up to the election? And what are President Trump's options to defend against that?

So I think that there's a case to be made for a summer rally, maybe a September rollover and the potential for an October massacre. That's one plausible scenario. But I also see an entirely plausible scenario for a melt-up fueled by declining interest rates, which of course support more corporate buybacks.

And Brent Johnson's scenario, if Brent and I are right that the dollar index is going to continue to move higher, that really creates a strong incentive for foreigners to pile into US equities. So the viewpoints that I think are most important to understand right now are the contrast between Brent Johnson's view versus Danielle DiMartino Booth's view, which we've interviewed in very recent MacroVoices All-Stars episodes. So let's come back to that in postgame where we can go into a little bit more detail. But I think that's kind of the trade-off. I could see it going either way. But boy, a daily close above 3,000 hasn't happened yet because we're recording before the close on Wednesday. Sure looks like we're headed there. That would be a sign that maybe much higher numbers are still to come.

Market wrap: dollar index

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to that dollar index, 'cause you just referenced it and the fact that you're still bullish. And I'm bullish on the dollar as well, but certainly Donald Trump seems to be talking that down. Where do you think the next move on the dollar is then?

Erik Townsend: Well, he's trying his hardest to talk it down, that is for sure. But as I look at this dollar index chart, what I said last week is it looks like it's bottoming out where it was last week and moving higher. And sure enough, it has broken considerably higher.

What I also said last week is be careful though, because we could be seeing the beginning of a new downward sloping price channel. And if that was the case, we should expect a rally up to about $96.60 or $96.70 on the September contract, and we could then see a rollover to lower numbers below the recent low, right around $95.50. If that were to occur if we moved to new lows and it seems like a downsloping price channel is in effect, that would really cause me to have to revisit my view and think, okay, maybe I got this thing wrong. So I'm really watching carefully to see, first of all, can we get past that 96.70, 97.

Let's call it 97 just to be really safe. If we get to 97 on the September contract, we're not in a downsloping channel, or if we were, we've broken out of it to the upside. And I really think that the bull case is on. If we move to new lower lows below the recent lows, okay, I gotta really question whether I got this thing wrong.

Market wrap: crude oil and RBOB gasoline

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to crude oil because the first reaction after the weekend was actually a breakdown rejecting the $60 level heading back down. Is this a new breakdown in oil from here?

Erik Townsend: It sure looked like it, Patrick, until Wednesday afternoon. And again, I wanna emphasize we're recording before the pit close at 2:30 on Wednesday afternoon. So the jury's not completely in yet, but it sure looks to be. Very, very interesting action.

Let's start with inventory. EIA data reporting this morning, crude oil drawing down 1.1 million barrels. Now, that's a drawdown which is normally a bullish signal, but API had expected more than 5 million barrels on that drawdown. And needless to say, this wasn't anything close to that. Meanwhile, Cushing, Oklahoma, building 652,000 barrels. So there was a build in Cushing despite the nationwide drawdown. The nationwide drawdown not nearly as big as everyone expected. Gasoline drawing down 1.6 million barrels, but that's almost completely offset by a build of 1.4 million barrels in distillates. Now the tape action was down hard in reaction to the data in the seconds and minutes afterwards, and we moved back down to the low of the day, but only to the low of the day on the crudes.

And then something really bizarre happened, which is RBOB gasoline really started taking off to the upside. Now why would that occur? Certainly if you had a situation where there was a refinery, you know, fire or outage or something that would cause gasoline to be in extreme demand and reduce demand for crude oil, as happened with Hurricane Harvey, or as would happen if there was, you know, a disaster at a refinery someplace. That would make sense for gasoline going straight up even while crude oil is down. So for quite a while today, we had a very unusual situation where RBOB gasoline was trading all 3 of its short-term moving averages, the 5, 8, and 13-day simple moving averages. That is bullish uptrend conditions. Meanwhile, WTI crude oil was trading below all 3 of its short-term moving averages. That's bearish downtrend conditions. Well, they can't both be right unless there's some major refinery outage issue, and I don't see anything in the news to do that.

So it created a tug-of-war between the bulls and the bears. Is RBOB gasoline going to pull the crudes higher, or are the crudes going to pull RBOB gasoline lower? As we are recording right now, Patrick, it is still about 45 minutes before the pit close on Wednesday. RBOB looks so far to be very clearly winning this tug-of-war. We've moved considerably above the 5-day on RBOB, and now crude oil has been pulled above its prior high of the day, and we're looking at more than $57.

So it looks like what's happening is So far, all indications seem to be that yesterday was a bear trap and that we are going to see a retracement higher in prices, something I was definitely not expecting. So it'll be interesting to see. Again, we did record this before the close. The jury's not in quite yet, but it looks like gasoline is pulling the crude higher as we speak today.

US production ticked back up to 12.2 million barrels. That's particularly important because we were concerned that maybe there was a new trend of gasoline production moving lower. I've been saying, watch, if it drops below 12 million barrels, we need to start to get worried. Well, it's ticking back up. It's only 200,000 barrels off of its all-time high of 12.4 million barrels. Imports were up this week. Exports were down. That probably explains some of the reason that we didn't see as big of a drawdown as a lot of people expected.

Now, something that Pippa Malmgren kind of set me straight on in her All-Stars interview, which will air on Friday morning, July 5th. I've been thinking about the geopolitical risks in this market probably the wrong way. My thinking was, you know, as much as John Bolton very clearly wants to go to war with Iran, if I'm reading the tea leaves correctly, I think President Trump really can see that getting into a war just as we're coming into election season doesn't make any sense. And I've been kind of discounting— I think President Trump is not I'm not going to let that happen. Pippa pointed out to me, you know, don't assume because it's an election year that that means a president doesn't want to be at war. War conditions generally cause the population to become patriotically aligned behind the president, even when they wouldn't normally support him. So it's not a good assumption that because it's an election year, President Trump will be inclined to avoid any kind of military conflict.

So I want to thank Pippa for reminding me about how some of those dynamics work.

Our view has been that unless there's new news to push the market higher, that what we're going to see is a resumption of lower prices. And that's exactly what we were seeing until this afternoon. I really don't know what got under gasoline and got such a bid going. But so far gasoline is leading everything higher this afternoon. It makes me think there's news that I don't know about yet. In any case, we'll see what happens as this develops in coming weeks.

Market wrap: gold breakout and the Judy Shelton nomination

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to gold because I thought Monday we were gonna begin some sort of a throwback correction, and suddenly we find ourselves here as we're recording, uh, the stone's throw away from breaking to a fresh high. What's the next move on gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I've been back and forth too on this, Patrick. At first, when I saw the size of this breakout, even though, you know, it basically is proving me wrong— I didn't see this one coming— I was thinking, okay, it looks like this is the big one, like we're really seeing a breakout. Then that sell-off that we saw and the gap-down open and the market just didn't seem to want to close that gap, it really said to me like, hmm, maybe this is a fake breakout, we're getting ready to trace lower. Now Tuesday this week we saw a huge spike right back up to the previous high right around 1440, whatever that number was, and you know, I thought, boy, that sure looks like it's game on and we're moving much higher.

But then I read the news and discovered that That move seems to have been inspired by President Trump nominating Judy Shelton as a Fed governor. Now, I certainly support the idea of Judy Shelton, a Fed governor. Imagine that, someone sitting on the Fed board who believes in sound money and doesn't really buy into the religion of fiat currency that so many other central bankers share. But I don't know what people are thinking if they think that President Trump nominating someone who is likely to see great opposition and probably will never make it onto the Fed board. If they did, it would be just only one voice. Why would gold suddenly go up in price dramatically just because one person who maybe believes in a gold standard might have a slim chance at maybe being a Fed governor who would be outvoted by everybody else? So what I said last night as I was making notes for today's show is, I think this is a setup for maybe a retrace back down for this big move that we saw.

And as I look at the tape this afternoon, we've seen almost half of that big move up retraced down, not all of it yet. So I think the jury is still out. I would still say the preponderance of evidence is probably that this breakout is real and has legs, but I do still see a very distinct possibility that we could be in a little bit of a panic situation that's eventually going to blow over and we're going to see a retracement lower back down towards $1,350 again. Time will tell, and I certainly have to handicap myself because this breakout is something I didn't see coming. I was very skeptical that it would occur. And I've been proven wrong there. So we'll see what happens next.

Market wrap: 10-year Treasury yield below 2%

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's finally touch on the 10-year Treasury yield, because after consolidating at 2% for over a week, we finally had a break and we're down decisively below 2%. What are you thinking here?

Erik Townsend: Well, what I'm thinking is I sure wish the break went the other way. I've been waiting for some kind of pullback in price or, you know, backing up of yields just to get onto this long trade. Because as you remember, several weeks ago, I said on this program, folks, pay attention here. We're retesting 2.60 here and now. This is your buy the TIP moment. Well, I said that to you. I didn't do it myself. The reason I didn't do it myself is I already had a significant position long the 2-year. Needless to say, the longer duration risk would have been the place to be. And, uh, well, so it is. I, I've been waiting for a significant pullback so that I can buy the dip and get in on this move, and so far we haven't seen

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's feature interview guest is author John Netto. Now, Erik, why did we invite John to the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as you know, John is an excellent macro analyst. He wrote an excellent book with several other authors, which is called The Global Macro Edge, and has had a lot of good perspective. And ironically, in this interview, you will hear John predict that Christine Lagarde will be selected as the new head of the ECB. And we We found out at the end of the interview, as we looked at the news, that while we were recording this, that exactly happened. So needless to say, he's gotten a few calls right, including one that he made during the interview, which actually came true before the interview was over.

Erik Townsend: So he's a really sharp guy that we've been looking forward for a while to getting onto the program.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Now, although I'm a global macro investor myself, it's long been known to investors around the world that systematic or quant-based strategies profoundly effective at extracting returns from the market. Top hedge funds like Bridgewater Associates and Renaissance Technologies discovered this decades ago. And there's one podcast that covers this area of finance better than any other: TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book explaining how these systematic strategies work. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro.

Check them out. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with John Netto is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Interview: what is driving the market after the G20

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is author John Netto, author of The Global Macro Edge. John, it's great to have you on the program. I want to start with— usually I ask the question about the issues that I see as the real drivers of the market. Frankly, my question today is, what the heck is driving this market? Because it seems like everybody's obsessed with this Trump-Xi negotiation thing. Frankly, it feels to me like it's produced for public consumption. I think we're going through theatrics here.

John Netto: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Is this really about FOMC policy and expectations of rate cuts?

Why are we seeing over this last weekend the huge gap-up open? What is driving the market, in your opinion, right now, and what should investors be paying the most attention to?

John Netto: First of all, thanks for having me on, Erik. It's a pleasure to be here. Longtime fan of the show, so I feel like I'm in hallowed ground right now. To your question, so I think when you look at the gap-up that took place in the S&P from the G20 reconciliation the Trump-Xi trade talk reconciliation that happened in Osaka. It's more about a quasi-Goldilocks scenario. And I use that term hesitantly because we've heard it when it applies to inflation that's just low enough, but not running away, growth that's in that 1.5% to 2.5% threshold, no threat of the FOMC coming in and getting in the way because you're in that area where corporations can continue to generate profits and cash will remain fairly cheap. So, I think while not the quintessential Goldilocks situation, the sentiment, not that I agree with it per se, but being that, okay, the Fed is going to be moving 25, maybe even 50, although 50 doesn't seem like a possibility in July now, but the Fed is now going to be reducing rates, inflation is in check, the trade war is not escalating.

And this is where I think technical analysis can benefit Even in regards of what is the price trend? Okay. So, was the outcome a base case for a lot of people from the G20 meeting? Absolutely. All right. But if it was a base case with the S&P making new lows or selling off in the throes of a bear market, then your inclination is that the previous price action will resume. Well, we happen to have a market, equity market, risk markets that are near highs. Now, the composition of what has them near highs is a little concerning. In terms of the consumer staples and dividend-paying stocks like that, which have led the way up. But looking at the price action of the S&P, and looking at no further tariffs were happened as a result of the G20 meeting, at least gave enough factors for the S&P to continue not going lower. And so in which case, what do we have, 20 points or 15 points from the close, from Friday's close, the session close?

So net-net, That's what I see on the risk side.

I think more broadly and more importantly is what has happened since the June 19th FOMC meeting. A couple of things happened within that statement and within the Summary of Economic Projections, which lent themselves very favorably to the price of gold, and really to global yields that are going to keep heading lower. We saw, of course, the dot plot projections came down surprisingly, I build models that synthetically score FOMC events. And that was— the dot plot movement was definitely a surprise. What was also a surprise occurred in the second paragraph. And this grabbed one of the Bloomberg hot headlines, was the reference to increased uncertainties. Now, in the second paragraph of the FOMC statement, they walk through what their base case is. And of course, up until now, it considered a return to their symmetric inflation goal, and growth as the most likely outcome. Well, the Fed really hedged that statement with a qualifying sentence in the second paragraph, which these qualitative

things, Erik, don't necessarily get insta-algoed into the market. There's a digestion period. And effectively, what that qualification statement did, that was, again, another surprise and skewed the statement surprisingly dovish relative to what market expectations were. And really gave the all clear for Canadian dollar to perform as well as it has been. We have oil rallying, we have Canada looking better. Also, I'm a little surprised at the lack of performance from Mexican peso, but also gave really the go ahead for gold to pop.

Gold that night put in a $40 move within hours of the FOMC statement. Again, sometimes this stuff just takes a while to process. And so, for me, it's just the synchronized G3 central bank dovish chorus that has basically said that, which has basically highlighted that growth is going to be an issue and further compounded this chase for yield.

And so, what does that do? That sends Bunds higher. And now we're talking about Christine Lagarde potentially being a prospective ECB head. And I think the idea that she's in place or potentially in place would mean a further 10 or 15 basis point decline. On what are already negative yields. I believe I read this morning that 62% of all European debt is now yielding negative rates. So, imagine compounding that even further. So, when you look at all this stuff, I think it's very conducive for gold, which is why gold rallied as high as $1,440, gave us a nice pullback. And it really sets up tactically to buy any dip in fixed income. So, if there is positive news out of China, out of a trade deal, that's simply an opportunity to buy because on a more broader scale, global portfolio managers have to own yield that's safe. There's simply not much else to do out there.

So, that means dividend-paying stocks, that means consumer staples. Those guys should continue to perform really well. As ridiculous as that sounds, given where they are on the chart, the macro environment is very much in place for that to continue. That's why I think gold's going to be— we're going to print a $1,500 price sometime here in July.

Gold: Netto vs Weldon and upside options

Erik Townsend: I want to come back to that subject, John, of what is going on in the fixed income market. But first, let's go a little deeper on this subject of gold because it's on so many people's minds. I was really, really surprised before the FOMC announcement and the big move happened. I had Greg Weldon on, who is a very well-known— you know, he literally wrote the book on gold investing and was just uber, uber bullish gold when we interviewed him a couple of weeks ago. To my surprise, I talked to him off the air a little bit after the announcement, and I was expecting him to say, I told you so, it's headed higher from here, you know, jump on if you were late. To my surprise, what he said is, you know, hold your core position, but we moved awfully hard, awfully fast. I think it's time to take some profits tactically and wait for a pullback. And if you get a dip below about $1,395, it's probably time to get ready for the possibility of a dump and much lower numbers.

And I was really surprised to hear that from such a gold bull. And it's certainly, it's not changing his long-term view, but he sees room for this to have been a false breakout that could potentially break down and lead to much lower numbers, or at least that was his view as of a week or so ago. How does that jibe with your view? You know, we've closed the gap now that we saw. If that's going to be proven true, I guess it could be all downhill from here, or it could be all uphill from here.

John Netto: His view is the antithetical of mine. In every sense. Actually, not every sense, but in terms of the tactical sense. And obviously, I have a great respect for his opinion. However, my perspective rests in the fact that we are once again reemerging in a complete debasement of global currencies or of prominent G7 currencies out there. And we've seen this— naturally, Bitcoin has pulled back as well, that we are seeing a migration into gold. We are seeing after months or even a protracted period of consolidation that gold has made a key breakout. Having traded gold in the 2000s and then in the early 2010s, and been through the ups and the downs of it, with every trade you put on, Erik, it's about what your views are, but then also how you structure it. To me, what's compelling about gold right now is that you can purchase upside optionality on it, which they're at elevated prices for over the last 3 years, but they're at much lower prices than what they were 6, 8, 10 years ago.

And so he can be right, and I can be right, because the structuring of the trade, there's value on both sides. I believe there's value in terms of owning gold, because I believe it's going to have a $1,500 print on it here in the month of July 2019.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

John Netto: And I'm saying that as we're at $1,407 right now.

All right? But I also think that I can own gold via options, because I can own 23 days out for 120 basis points for upside optionality. Now, that is a little richer than what it has been. But if we take on a regime or a profile, especially with the nonfarm payroll number coming this Friday, and a broader chase for yield taking place, the structure of that becomes very compelling and gives me multiple outs. The guy that lives in Las Vegas as a professional speculator, It can't just be your view, but how are you effectuating that view? How are you executing that view? And for me, controlling risk through options on gold right now, so that if it does turn back around and dump again, we'll at least provide a defined risk point. But everything I'm seeing and the price action around this and how they've been into this pullback is indicative that we're headed topside.

Where to enter long Treasuries

Erik Townsend: John, let's come back to fixed income because this has perplexed the heck out of me. I've been saying Okay, we're here at 2% and we've moved so far, so fast. There's gotta be a pullback. There's gotta be a pullback in yields. There's gotta be a chance to buy this long duration trade at a better price. It's gotta be coming because we moved so fast. There has to be a pullback. Well, what has it been, 3 weeks now? And we're almost pinned on 2%.

Am I making a mistake to wait for the pullback or what do you think is coming here? Because I wanna be exposed long. I was exposed to the short end of the curve and 2-year futures. I want to be long 10-year futures, but I was hoping for a better price. What should I do?

John Netto: Take a tactical or more tactical approach than what you already are. It sounds like you have obviously some aspect of tactical entries into how you're putting this on. I would say that, you know, when you really look at the chart of the 10-year Treasuries, like you're saying, like it's obviously in a projected uptrend since mid-April, but, you know, sentiment has shifted rather violently as well. I mean, let's keep in mind As of May 3rd, before Trump tweeted out, May 1st, the Fed had a— and I'm going to give some backdrop here and then get directly to your question, Erik.

On May 1st, the Fed had a meeting where Powell referenced— it was more of a hawkish press conference following the FOMC meeting on May 1st. This was Wednesday. We came out Friday, May 3rd, with one of the more bullish and more hawkish economic reports in some time. I believe we hit close to 300,000 jobs on the payroll. Sunday night, And the tweet war begins between Trump and Xi.

This obviously began a pretty dramatic shift in sentiment that coincided with a broader shift in the economic data out there. And that reprice that we saw in May, where effectively, you did see that precipitous decline in 10-year yields, was part of a more natural reprice. And when you get caught in these reprices, Erik, they tend to move pretty dramatically. So, the question then to you, and we can maybe go back to gold a little bit honestly, Well, John, I want to find a spot. I want to find an entry point.

I would say that maybe part of your entry point is a derivative trade, which may end up being long gold, because gold has broken out, but gold hasn't seen necessarily the same risk-adjusted appreciable decline that fixed income has since early May. Gold has obviously put in a great move, but maybe playing gold to $1,500 becomes a way that you benefit from this larger, more prolific, more structural central bank accommodation flattening the yield curve. And that's something to keep in mind that maybe it's not just with US Treasuries. I'd also say that markets are a function of a lot of noise. They're a function of rebalancing. So, as fixed income does better, and there's a little bit of rebalancing going on, it's measuring how that rebalancing and measuring how maybe a headline can influence things. For example, this Friday, we have a nonfarm payroll number.

Maybe it comes in a little stronger than most are suspecting. That strength is large— should it come in stronger, to me, is largely inconsequential to what the Fed does. Maybe even on the Fed decision, Jerome Powell speaking on July 11th, he may make some comments that cause people to square away some of their positions beforehand, at least square away their positions before that happens or subsequent to those comments.

None of those, or very few of those things, are going to derail what's happening in this fixed income rally right now. All right? And as a result of that, this chase for yield, which is happening at a trillion-dollar level, you get these tactical pullbacks, Erik. That's where you step in and buy it, and you work these thresholds, and then you play these bounces back. And it's been a very reliable trade, and I think that's going to continue.

Why the Fed cuts now: 25 vs 50 basis points

Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit more about what, to me, is an unobvious aspect of the drivers for this widely, widely expected Fed rate cut. The usual story, at least for the last few years, has been, okay, it feels like the stock market is on the edge of crashing and the Fed's got to come to the rescue, and a rate cut is always the way to save the day. Well, clearly, that's not the situation or the setup here. We've got the S&P literally at all-time highs or within a few points of all-time highs. So that's not the driver. Why is it that now is the time that the Fed has to cut rates? What are the things that are causing so many analysts to conclude that it's nearly inevitable that there's going to be a rate cut?

John Netto: Well, the obvious answer is because the Fed has told us. And there's a historical— I mean, they're pretty reliable that if the Fed funds futures are above 30% going into a rate hike or going into a rate decision, either a hike or a cut, the Fed does that. What the Fed does not do, Erik, is surprise the market. So the first reason is that the Fed believes based on their own internal analysis, based on their own process, that it is appropriate to cut rates. Let us just start with the big picture on that. We know that through their communication mechanism, when they lay out a framework that says, we are going to make a policy decision either one way or the other, or none at all, whatever message they give to the markets, and that gets priced in above a certain level, that is what happens. That is number one as to why we are going to cut in July.

Now, taking a little bit of a deeper dive, when the Fed did their first rate hike back in December of 2015, the 5-year Treasury at that point in time was sitting at 175 basis points. And it's a good rule that when the Fed rate hiking cycle would finish, it would match up to where the 5-year Treasury yield was at the time that the cycle started. Well, we went about 75 basis points above that. Or at least 50 to 75 with a lower bound, upper bound dynamic with a 225 to 250. To me, and to a lot of people as well, some maintenance cuts to return us back to there, especially given that they, at least some of the guys, they want to reach their symmetric inflation target, is defensible. Given the slowdowns we've seen globally, the global PMIs that we've seen, it really is a question of 25 or 50. Now, again, I talked about the surprise factor.

If we're at 50 basis points, it's almost negligible. There's a very small shot right now. We're going to cut 25 in July, and we'll see what they lay out for the rest of the year. But I think we're cutting 3 times this year and on track to cut another 2 or 3 times next year.

Mexican peso: USD/MXN back toward 18.50

Erik Townsend: John, I also want to touch on the Mexican peso. What's going on with the price action there?

John Netto: To my surprise, the Mexican peso has not responded as well. To the Fed decision that took place 2 weeks ago. I actually think that when you look at, again, what the narratives are out there, the yield paid by the Mexican peso, the fact that it's on our border, and sets up for a situation where— I think the peso could get back to multi-month highs here relatively quickly. I think what's also unique about the peso is that it's purchasing optionality on it is not that expensive.

Obviously, there's a different level of emerging market risk that goes with that, but if I'm as bullish as I am on gold, and I think that the Fed is cutting to the extent that it is, and I see this global chase for yield that we've talked about, looking at Mexico now, clearly, when we talk about a global chase for yield, there's some hedging costs involved, but 850 basis points for owning MEX, energy prices that are rising, We work out a trade deal that seems to suggest that that's going well, and just in an obligatory way or in a derivative way, that this Mexican peso turns around and we see it appreciate rather considerably over the next even 90 days, then I think that us going back to the 186 level is a real possibility, even the 185 level by Labor Day. I'm speaking USD/MXN on that.

I'm getting back down to 185. Okay.

The Netto Number and risk budgets

Erik Townsend: John, I'd like to shift gears now and step back to the bigger picture because I wanted to start with some tactical issues because everybody's so interested in what's going on in the market. But a lot of what you're known for is your book, The Global Macro Edge, and the whole approach that you take to global macro investing. So why don't we start with the Netto Number? What's the Netto Number and how did you come up with that?

John Netto: Sure. The Netto Number allows me to measure the performance of a stock, a market, a portfolio, a strategy on a return per unit of risk basis. And that's critical because a lot of mistakes that investors have made, that I have made, have come from only having a 1 or even a 2-dimensional perspective on the market. So, when we talk about 3-dimensionality, well, let's talk about what 1-dimensional performance assessment entails.

So, at the one-dimensional performance assessment, it might be, hey, Erik, how much is gold up today? Gold's up 1%. All right. Well, what's lacking from that, Erik? Well, we know it's up 1%, but we don't know how much it was down. We don't know what's it up 7%. We don't know how much one had to risk coming into the day to make that 1%. Okay? So, let's go to the second part of that, which is pretty common amongst institutional circles. You'll see it on a manager tear sheet, which will be, okay, What is the risk-adjusted return of gold today, or of gold for the year, gold for the month? And you'll hear terms like a Sharpe ratio, or a Sortino ratio, or a Calmar ratio, which helps measure gold relative to the realized volatility it has. So if gold was trading at a 1% standard deviation on a daily basis, and it makes 50 basis points, well, that's cool.

But it's more impressive if gold makes 50 basis points that only has a 30 basis point standard deviation. And so that comparison helps out.

However, what the Netto Number does is it takes a predefined risk budget. So for a manager, if I say, Erik, I'm going to give you $1 million, all right? But if you lose $200,000 of that, okay, that's your risk budget. If you lose $200,000 of that $1 million, I'm going to stop you out. Another investor says, well, I'm going to give you, John Netto, that same $1 million, but I'll I'm going to give you a $400,000 risk budget. Well, at the end of the year, Erik, you made 15% on that, and I made 15%. We had similar drawdowns and a similar Sharpe ratio, but the one thing missing, and this is what hangs up investors so much, is Erik, you only had a 20% risk budget. You can only lose $200K, while I can lose $400K.

That flexibility premium, that risk budget that went in, is that third-dimensional component that isn't known by many investors and is not commonly used.

So what I do when I measure performance of markets, when I look to assess where money pools are going, when I look to assess opportunities of a strategy, is I take the Netto Number and measure, okay, I want to take performance and measure it against a risk factor. And so the risk factor consists of the size of that risk budget, which in your case, in that example I just showed, would have been $200 grand, plus the volatility associated with those returns. Okay, and so I take those 2 I equally weight them, and then I take the average of them. Now, all of a sudden, I've rewarded someone that manages, that keeps volatility down while making money. At the same time, I've also rewarded someone who does well to, in essence, make more by risking less.

The Netto Number divides the performance by those 2 components. It's obviously elaborated on in my book, and I'll stay away from abstract mathematical formulas on your podcast, but to be gracious to your listeners. But that, at its essence, is how I begin to assess the macro narrative. Because we talk about China trade talks, or we talk about what the Fed is doing.

To me, it ultimately filters down to how you can synthesize that information into something that's actionable. And so, I can say that this macro narrative is, in fact, what's leading things. But if I don't have the Netto Number, or the equivalent Netto Number, demonstrating to me that that is in fact the narrative, then that's something that I'm going to take a backseat to. So, when we go through repricings of markets, or when the macro narrative changes, that's where you can combine both the quantitative studies, which are things like the Netto Number, and I have other unit of risk ratios, like the Agony-Ecstasy Ratio, which measures how much a stock was up on the day versus how much it was down from its previous net change. I have the Impact Ratio, where I measure how certain events impact certain asset classes, and how that can affect a risk budget behind things. Then ultimately, what I do is, let us just say I am a money manager, I will use the Netto Number to determine how much compensation I should get.

The higher the Netto Number, I would say in your case, Erik, in our situation, again, you would actually be entitled to, if you made 15% and I made 15%, you would be entitled to a higher percentage compensation. Because you made more with less risk. When people talk about, oh, I run this strategy, and I am this great trader, it is like, great, let us figure out a way to create a goal-congruent compensation structure that rewards managers when they maximize return per unit of risk, which is the subtitle of my book, The Global Macro Edge, Maximizing Return Per Unit of Risk. Let us have a way that does not reward them when they do not. If you go and take a big shot, you take a big bet, Okay? And you win, that's not as impressive as if you take a small bet, but you manage to parlay that small bet and generate the same returns. And so, the Netto Number and the risk factor compensation system account for that.

And it's a big— that's a big part of how I conduct my macro analysis.

Sharpe ratios, XIV and volatility as a risk proxy

Erik Townsend: John, I want to go a little deeper on this because quite frankly, having run a hedge fund and having met some other people who have run hedge funds, funds. I personally have become pretty cynical about Sharpe ratios and Sortino ratios and all of these other hedge fund risk metrics because I know what really goes on is these are numbers that are tracked based on monthly closing performance. And I've met plenty of managers who have had absolutely crazy risk excursions that happened intra-month And they didn't close the month with anything close to the crazy 45% drawdown that they had on the 12th of the month. And nobody ever finds out. And it seems to me that these risk metrics that are only calculated from monthly numbers are almost completely irrelevant.

Now, what a lot of people are doing, at least a lot of very sophisticated institutional investors, are they're insisting on separate managed accounts for this reason, so that they can see the daily volatility as opposed to just monthly. Is there a reason that investors investing in managed funds, whether it be a hedge fund, managed commodity pool, or whatever, should take things like Sharpe ratios and Sortino ratios, which are only represented on a monthly basis, seriously? Am I missing something there?

John Netto: Listen, let's talk about the good and the bad, because you hit on a lot of great points. And the 2 main points you hit on are, one, One, the limits with the Sharpe and Sortino ratio, and then 2, the granularity and the temporal aspect with which you receive investor data. There's 2 aspects to that, and I can speak extensively about both of them.

The first side about the Sharpe and Sortino ratio of why it is limiting from a monthly perspective is everything you just mentioned. The fact that it misses so much is limiting, but it's also why you need to have a risk budget in place Because that at least gives you some semblance of security that this person was trading with a risk budget. So, a Sharpe ratio of 1.6, while Erik was running— like, let's go back to the example of your million-dollar allocation that I gave to you, okay, with a $200,000 deal. One, if I know that your Sharpe ratio, even on a month-on-month close, is a 1.6, but I know that the entire time, Erik, you were managing it around a risk budget, that Sharpe ratio has a little more credibility to it, because you never were down, like you never blew through your risk budget in the first place. That is why that lack of 3-dimensionality is such an issue. Let us take something like the kind that you and I love so much, the option selling strategy.

You see investors see these incredible returns month after month, allowed to make these returns, but they are not asking the right questions, Erik. They are not putting the returns in the right context. How much were you risking to generate those returns? And what the Sharpe ratio doesn't do, what the Sortino doesn't do, it doesn't ask those questions. It gives you a realized— it gives you a performance relative to realized volatility on a monthly basis.

Okay, so if you generate, you know, a 2 Sharpe, but in order to generate that you had to like put 70% of your portfolio out there at risk, or in the case of risk $700,000 in a potential XIV moment, if you will, well, then it doesn't give investors that granularity. It's a lot like a sailing map used 400 years ago. If you looked at it, the size of Greenland looked like the size of North America, but that's not true because it didn't have the right dimensionality behind it. Yes, you can generate 20% returns, but I was literally selling 10 delta options for 3 years in a row until one day I lost it all.

So, without having that risk budget as a context, that 3-dimensionality, the Sharpe ratios are very limiting. And that's why.

Erik Townsend: John, in my opinion, we have an epidemic in institutional finance, and it's an epidemic of understanding what risk really is. And you mentioned an XIV moment. Before the vol complex ever blew up, I remember going to institutional conferences and talking to people who should know better. Fund managers saying, look, these guys on this short vol trade are crazy with the risk that they're taking. And I would have people who are fund managers interrupt me and say, you don't know what you're talking about. That's a low-risk strategy. Just look at the Sharpe ratios these guys are delivering. And it's like, dude, you don't get it. You don't get it.

John Netto: I know it's ridiculous.

Erik Townsend: It's ridiculous. And it said to me, there is And so what you end up with is this really huge problem, which is we've got this academically prescribed model where the reason that volatility is perceived as a meaningful proxy of risk is based entirely on this conceptual idea of evenly distributed normal returns, which is not the way the real world works, despite what academic finance thinks. And so what you end up with is these guys who really believe that these risk models accurately measure risk. You know, one of the most famous things, the guys that are just selling, they lever up these strategies to sell out-of-the-money calls and puts on the S&P because they know that they're going to make a lot of money in their own pocket before the day comes that that strategy blows up and they lose all of their investors' money.

And the people that are evaluating these things, professionals, that's their job, are saying, well, look at the Sharpe ratio. It looks great. There's not a lot of risk here.

John Netto: Right.

Erik Townsend: here, and they don't think through where the real risk is because they don't understand that this business of volatility equating to risk is entirely theoretical and it's based entirely on normal distribution, which is not the way the world works. Does the Netto Number make a meaningful inroad into solving these problems?

John Netto: Yes, because what the Netto Number does is what a Sharpe ratio measures performance relative to realized vol, the Netto Number measures performance relative to implied vol. So, we think about how, going back to the institutional case you just brought, a lot of institutions, when they allocate, will set what's called a volatility target, where they give a manager— now, by the way, that doesn't insist that a manager adheres to that target, but that's what the target is. So, I give a manager, okay, your vol target for the year is 12%. Your vol target is 16%. So, if we back this out, whereas the Sharpe and Sortino measure performance relative to that realized vol, Well, the argument to have with those guys at that conference is, well, guys, the mistake you're making is that you're measuring performance relative to realized vol, when you should be measuring it to implied vol. Now, we go one step further with the Netto Number because it puts an actual hard budget there.

Because back to your point, what the academics do is send this sorrowful letter about how somehow, Erik, can you believe their model experienced a 1 in 10 million event when the XIV moment happened? That's only supposed to happen once every 17 million years. But apparently now it happens every 4 years. I don't know what happened. Okay.

And so the risk budget acts as a real-world braking system for a portfolio manager. And the Netto Number catches that because by having the braking system in, it limits your flexibility. But that's okay because that's real. Because as managers, Erik, when we lose money, we have to tighten our belts. We have to trade within that budget.

Households have to spend within a budget. The government, well, they don't spend within a budget, but we have to spend within a budget in the real world. And so why shouldn't the manager have to manage risk within a budget? And a Netto Number tells you how well a manager does that. So you can still sell option premium, but the risk budget Netto Number is going to capture how much of your portfolio you have to risk to do that. And as a result, you can actually say, oh, so your Sharpe ratio is 2, but your Netto Number is only 0.6. Well, that tells me me that, yeah, you had great returns, but man, you had a lot of risk out there. Or your Sharpe ratio's 1, 1.2, but your Netto Number's 2.7. Wow, you made, you made some great returns relative to the small risk budget I gave you.

Because we're in the business, Erik, of risking less to make more.

Erik Townsend: Well, John, I'll just correct you that that event on the VIX was in fact a million-year event. It was impossible for any Anyone to have seen it coming. I've been assured of that by lots of people. And the fact that 3 separate MacroVoices feature interview guests saw it coming and predicted it within 6 months of it happening was just pure coincidence. I'm sure of it.

Trader psychology and sentiment signals

Erik Townsend: Anyway, let's move on in the subject of academic nonsense, and there's plenty of it. One of the things that is taught is this whole idea of rational expectations theory efficient markets hypothesis, nobody in the professional finance community ever allows their emotions or human factors to get involved, and psychology doesn't enter the market according to a lot of academic models. I'm sure you know where I'm going, which is chapter 19 of The Global Macro Edge. Talk to us about traders and psychology.

John Netto: Sure. So as a person that uses both both quantitative tools and qualitative tools, I rely very heavily on my ability to use a skill known as cognitive empathy, or to, in essence, think about how other people will likely behave in a situation and to feel what other people may be thinking or feeling. And so I have spent an exhaustive amount of time, over 15 years, journaling and building to weaponize my emotions. for the purpose of creating more robust trading signals. So, what do I mean by that? I actually spend a lot of time journaling my emotions when I'm trading, because I incorporate them into what I do. So, if I'm feeling particularly fearful, or if I'm feeling particularly complacent, these in and of themselves can be signal sources for me on top of that. And so, let's just take a step back for a moment.

It was important for me when I wrote The Global Macro Edge, Erik, that if people were going to spend the time and money to read a 600-page book, that they knew that the people who wrote it, myself and the other contributing authors, were actual successful practitioners.

What I did was hire a CPA to come in and verify my trading P&L. Effectively, what he did was show that from January 1st, 2010, up to when the book had to go to press, which was December 31st, 2015, before we sent it off to the press, I took a $100,000 account, and I generated $3.1 million in P&L over that 6-year period. By any metric you use, those returns are pretty profound and pretty compelling. What I am telling you now about the intuition infrastructure was a key component, it was integral to generating those returns, along with the other stuff I have shared with you, but that intuition infrastructure, that understanding of when the market is in a sweet spot and what I like to call the factor, like when And you have these butterflies in your stomach when you're in a position. Those butterflies, Erik, are a real signal.

That complacency when you feel— have you ever noticed when you get into a trade, and you feel really good about it, and you start IMing all your friends, that pretty much marks the high tick if you bought it at that point in time?

It's almost destined to not work out for you. When you can confidently and exuberantly say, hey, my goodness, look at this trade I just bought. The other day, actually, I saw when Bitcoin hit like $13,500, I believe, One of the Winklevoss twins tweeted out about it going to the stratosphere, the metasphere. That was actually when you feel confident enough to exhibit that much enthusiasm, that much unbridled enthusiasm about a particular market. Those can be very powerful sentiment indicators. And so how do we internalize? How do we harness? How do we memorialize those sentiment indicators?

How do we incorporate that into what we see? And so, all of chapter 19, with Micheal's help, she wrote Market Mind Games, very prominent performance coach in the hedge fund industry and helping people really take their emotions, use them, use that intuition on top of all the hard skills that are necessary to be a great trader to succeed.

Erik Townsend: Now, I want to go a little bit deeper on this because there's an aspect of this, which is using these signals to gauge what might be going on inside of oneself. I know Rick Rule is famous for saying, if you're feeling smart, I mean really smart, sell. You know, it's time to get out of that trade because you've already had your success.

And I guess there's another aspect to it though, which is, do you use these signals based on your own feelings in order to gauge what the rest of the market is feeling, or do you only use it to gauge gauge your own personal mental condition relative to your own trades?

John Netto: A little bit of both. Let me elaborate on what I mean by that. I spend a lot of time canvassing my network and trying to form a consensus of what the market is thinking. For example, the Federal Reserve meeting 2 weeks ago, I'd formed a consensus, a pretty crystallized view of what was expected to come out from both the dot plot and the composition of the And so, the sentiment, the feeling I get is relative to what the market is expecting. Now, I have my own internal feelings as well in terms of I just bought this or just bought that. But the first point of origin, the first point of reference, I should say, is how is the market responding to this? And that's where I go back to the whole cognitive empathy thing and the whole intuition thing. It's like, wow, the market was not ready for that qualifier in the second paragraph when it described that uncertainties have increased about this most likely scenario happening.

And the market was not ready for such a dramatic drop in the dots for 2019 and 2020, and the downgrades to the inflation forecast. So, at first, it's refracted through that lens of, okay, how is the market feeling about this? Now, we get into more tactical situations of like, am I becoming complacent or brazen about a position And that feeds into still some of the more management styles as well. So, it's a combination of both, but that's what I'm looking for on both sides of it. So, I have my own internal thing, what I'm doing, but also, it starts with what the market is doing and how the market should respond to this. And from a temporal perspective, when the market will respond to this. Like I said, some of this takes time to process and filter. They just simply— portfolio managers can't process this and allocate the kind of risk to this in an instantaneous manner.

It takes days, even weeks, to truly work its way in sometimes.

Traders Expo Chicago and book details

Erik Townsend: John, I could go on for hours about this stuff. Unfortunately, we need to leave it there. But before I let you go, I want to ask you, on Sunday, July 21st, you and Patrick Ceresna, my co-host, and our good friend Kevin Muir are all going to be traveling to Chicago for an event called Traders Expo, and you're actually running a series there. Tell us about what you're doing, how Patrick and Kevin fit into it, and how people who are interested in attending can find out more information.

John Netto: Sure. So on Sunday, July 21st, we will continue an ongoing series that has happened in New York, in Las Vegas, and now in Chicago that is put on for free. It's, it's part of the Traders Expo. It begins at 9 AM Chicago time on Sunday the 21st. It goes to 1:30, and it's very much emblematic of MacroVoices itself. We believe that we live in an era where there's more information available to a more diverse group of people than at any point in time in the market's history.

For those of us that do this for a living, this is our way of giving back. We believe in investor empowerment, as does the MacroVoices show. That's an opportunity to do that. In particular, You just mentioned Patrick and Kevin. They will be having a Bull-Bear Smackdown where they will be sharing different opinions and different ideas about why stocks can go up, why stocks can go down, why bonds can go up, why bonds can go down, and I will be emceeing that event. And so, when you look at the substantive content that we shared on today's show, imagine how that spread over 4.5 hours.

And so, for us, it's critical that we can share these ideas, share these approaches, share the processes So that investors can now take them and apply them to their own portfolio, to their own investing. And that in a nutshell is what the series is about.

Erik Townsend: And John, before I let you go, give us your Twitter handle. And for people who are interested in learning more about your book, The Global Macro Edge, please tell them where they can find it.

John Netto: Sure. My Twitter handle is @JohnNetto, @J-O-H-N, N as in Nancy, E-T-T-O. And The Global Macro Edge, the link will be available on my Twitter handle. Find on Amazon, order on Kindle, and would appreciate any interest you have.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. Well, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview, John. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: takeaways from John Netto

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have John join us for the interview. Now, I just wanted to point out that he's mentioned that he's going to be in Chicago, and myself and Kevin Muir are going to be a part of the Traders Expo having the big bull-bear debate on, on bonds and stocks. But what he didn't mention, and which is an invite that is open to all of our listeners, that if you do come after the Macro Edge Series event that is occurring We're all actually going out for some drinks at a pub nearby and it's free to join. I'd love to meet all of our listeners. So anybody that wants to join us afterwards is also welcome. Anyway, Erik, what did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it's such a pleasure to talk to someone who can see through the BS of academic finance. All these Sharpe ratios and Sortino ratios, they're true to the extent that the underlying assumptions are true and the underlying assumptions are not true. Investment returns are not really normally distributed, and volatility is only an indirect proxy for risk at best. So it's a real pleasure for me to talk to someone who sees through this stuff and sees as clearly as I do that the industry deludes itself with a lot of these numbers that supposedly tell you so much about the risk-adjusted returns of investment funds. And again, when when this stuff is being measured on its monthly volatility. It doesn't tell you what happened intramonth. And believe me, I've heard lots of stories from fund managers about crazy things their investors never found out about because it happened intramonth and they managed to make a Hail Mary trade and, you know, make back their loss and nobody found out what happened.

There's more risk in hedge funds than meets the eye from some of those ratios.

Postgame: Booth vs Johnson, slowdown or US safe-haven bid

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, listen, in the market wrap, you mentioned this big polar difference between the views of Danielle DiMartino Booth and Brent Johnson. And so, Erik, what's on your mind here?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think that the contrast between Danielle and Brent's views really, to me, epitomize what you need to think about in order to understand this stock market. What Danielle is saying is, look, there are just such clear signs of a global economic slowdown. So far, the rest of the world is feeling it really badly. The US hasn't felt it in its markets yet. The US cannot be immune forever. What's happening to the rest of the world is coming here. Don't delude yourself.

It has to hit. What Brent is saying is almost the same thing, which is, it's hitting the whole world, but you know what's going to happen? We're going to see the US become a safe haven trade because European bonds are so ridiculously overpriced in negative yield territory. That they're not going to provide the safety trade that they normally would. And what will happen, especially if the US dollar continues to appreciate, is that the European safety trade will be into US stocks because European investors will correctly recognize that in an uptrending dollar situation, they get both a stock market benefit as well as the foreign exchange benefit of being in a dollar-denominated asset.

And Brent thinks that despite the fact that what's really happening is worsening fundamentals driving this, that the result for US stocks could be much higher. So it's a really interesting contrast. And, you know, it's something I see too in the data. If you look at the University of Michigan consumer confidence, it's off the charts to the upside. And I'm seeing this myself. I have my vacation home on the coast of Maine on VRBO, you know, for vacation rentals.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: Vacation rentals. And for the first time ever, first of all, we're booked completely for this season, with the exception of the week leading up to Labor Day, which is usually one— that's an anomaly, because it's usually one of the most busy weeks of the year. We've only got one week that isn't booked this year. The rest of the season is booked. That's unusual. But what's really just completely unprecedented is we got half the season booked next year. And normally, we don't get any bookings on vacation rentals, at least my vacation Until, you know, October, November, people are thinking about planning ahead for next year maybe, but certainly not this early. So it says to me that consumer confidence is really strong. People are planning their 2020 vacations already. Yet if I look at what the bond market is telling me, it says that we're headed straight into a recession. They can't both be right. So I'm seeing signs everywhere that there's this big dichotomy of views that can't both be right.

It has to get resolved one way or the other. And what I'm coming more and more around to is the Brent Johnson view, which is, even though I am absolutely irrevocably convinced that this is bad economic news, that's really what's happening here, I think the bad economic news in a bizarre way could drive the US stock market much higher for the reasons that Brent has described.

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, why don't you do a shameless plug for the URL for your VRBO That's good.

Erik Townsend: Well, we're looking for sponsors. This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by VRBO.com/1498342, Erik's house in Maine. But if you want to book it, email us at info@macrovoices.com. Don't pay VRBO a commission. We'll give you a discount. Seriously though, you know, it is unprecedented to see— I've had this house rented for like 5 years as a vacation rental, we have never seen the next year book out. And we've only got the week up to Labor Day left this year. Don't bother inquiring for this year.

Patrick Ceresna: It's sold out.

Erik Townsend: It doesn't happen. Actually, that's not true. It's not sold out after Labor Day, but the season, the busy season is until Labor Day. And with the exception of that last week, it's already sold out.

Postgame: new video on Facebook Libra

Erik Townsend: I've never seen it happen before. And the other thing I want to mention today is we do have a new video at MacroVoices.com. With a full update on the digital currency situation. Now, as a lot of our listeners know, I am not a huge fan of cryptocurrency. That's really not what the video is about. I'm explaining why I think Facebook's Libra announcement, the Libra currency, which the Congress has now asked Facebook to stop development of, and I think that makes lots of sense. It is a real risk to humanity as far as I'm concerned.

I think Facebook has designs on doing all the wrong things for the wrong reasons. Anyway, there is an update on my outlook for what's coming next in the digital currency revolution. It's not just more of this cryptocurrency Bitcoin stuff, and I think that it will interest a lot of our listeners. You'll find a link to that in this week's Research Roundup, and it's also on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. But in any case, Patrick, I want to get to the postgame chartbook.

Chartbook: S&P 500 above 3,000

Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered, just go to the homepage at MacroVoices.com, click that red button that says looking for the downloads. And what we see here on page 2, Patrick, is the S&P 500, and it only shows 2,996 on this chart, which was snapshotted just before we recorded today. But as we are speaking, we're looking at 3,001 on the S&P, and probably a good chance that we'll close above 3,000 today.

And needless to say, that is a very bullish indication.

Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. And what I just wanted to do on this chart was highlight the fact that 3,000, while everyone is caught up on the round number of this 3,000, it's like a big mile marker for the S&P. But as a technician, there isn't a lot of relevance to 3,000 beyond the round number. In fact, almost all the major measured moves, and that indicates that this kind of a break breakout can easily still run 100 to 150 S&P points higher. And so all I wanted to just show with this chart is the fact that, that it's now far beyond that of just the round number.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I agree on the round number, uh, aspect of this, but also the breakout to new highs, first of all. And there's also, you know, as a debatable issue, uh, you could almost say that there's a cup and handle pattern here on the chart that would be very bullish. Now, Normally, a cup and handle has to have a rounded bottom. This is a V-shaped bottom, so maybe it doesn't count. But as I look at this chart, it looks very bullish to me. And that's totally at odds with my fundamental view of what would normally happen in a normal economy. But I think this market is operating on alternate logic that has to do entirely with what we can expect in terms of monetary policy.

Chartbook: gold flag and the $1,500 target

Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. So I wanted to move on to chart 3, where I just put on a chart of gold. And what I thought was also interesting was, John, Obviously mentioned $1,500 for gold. And what was interesting is that if in fact the flagging formation that gold just pulled, if we did see a break to a higher high above $1,440, a number of the measured moves do actually clear $1,500. So there is some technical aspects that, that support John's view that gold could go up there. That's why I'm going to be watching whether or not gold can actually break to a higher high.

Erik Townsend: I agree with you. You know, as much as I really feel like there are still reasons to question, is it possible? It seems most likely that this breakout is real, but I think it's a little bit too early to say that the jury is completely in. This is, you know, resistance has been in place for 5 years. Maybe it's a false breakout and we're going to actually retrace lower. You break to a new higher high from where we are now, It's awfully hard to stay on that story. You really just have to throw in the towel and say, okay, I was just plain old wrong and we're moving higher on gold. And it's looking more and more to me like that could be the case. But as I say this, it didn't look that way until this Judy Shelton news came out. And I don't see the fact that President Trump tries to appoint somebody who will probably never be confirmed to the Fed, who happens to believe in gold, as reason for the price of gold to move higher.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: That seems to be the driver.

Chartbook: European yields and bank-run risk

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on, 'cause on charts 4 and 5, I just had to bring it up. Like, how can we not be talking about what's happening in those yields in Europe? And I highlight on page 4, the 10-year German government bond yields down near -40 basis points. It's unbelievable. And what's amazing to me is that that's all-time lows for the yield on the 10-year, and there is no crisis from which this is happening. It's obviously there's buying by central banks and other things, but like it's just I find it fascinating that this is happening. But what's even more fascinating is the dramatic move we're seeing on the 10-year Italian government bond. There was that whole news that the European Commission decided to avoid disciplinary action against Italy over its soaring debt and growing deficits, and Italian government bond. Bonds just went soaring and the yields collapsed. I mean, I think the spread now between the 10-year Italian and German has narrowed less than 2%.

So just extraordinary bond moves going. I mean, I thought— we thought the, uh, the US bond market was on fire, but you just go right now to Europe and things are really moving there.

Erik Townsend: And, you know, Patrick, it's something I've said many times before, and, and I, I really wonder if regulators And central bankers are thinking as much about this as they should. We're moving into pretty serious negative interest rate territory on the German Bund. At some point, when you really get significant, substantial negative interest rates, it creates a cash hoarding incentive that literally puts the entire global fractional reserve banking system at risk of a run that could turn into a global panic that crashes the entire international monetary system.

Now, in order for that scenario, that doomsday scenario to occur, you'd have to have negative interest rates, not just on German bunds, but on a lot of different instruments, and they'd have to be more negative than they are now. But look at the trends on these charts, Patrick. It doesn't have that much farther to go before you get to that scenario.

And again, just to explain, in case the rationale for that is not clear to everyone, The, the reason here is when you get to negative interest rates, it makes more sense for the investor to buy a safe or a vault and just take your money out of the banking system and store the cash in a vault, because you do better that way than tolerating negative returns on keeping your cash in the financial system. The problem is the way fractional reserve banking works, everybody can't take their cash out. It would crash the whole system.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: There's not enough. It's the reason it's called fractional reserve. We don't have enough reserves for everybody to take their money out. And what we're doing through policy is we're creating a financial incentive for people to do exactly that. That financial incentive doesn't really kick in until we get more substantially negative interest rates. But look at the trend here. It seems like it's coming. I haven't heard anybody talk about what the plan is to prevent that run on the banking system. if we were to get to sufficiently negative rates that it motivated large investors and large institutions to simply take their assets out of the financial system. And one final note, Patrick, just some feedback that we've gotten from listeners.

Research Roundup and sign-off

Erik Townsend: It seems like not everyone understands, you know, we know that it's a real pain in the tail to have to go to our website and get the download, and you've got to navigate to a lot of different places.

The reason we provide the Research Roundup email is it gives you everything in one place. You get an email every week that's got a link to play the podcast, it's got the link to download the handouts, it's got the link to any supporting information, and it also has links to all the other free cool stuff that we could find on the internet. So if you're finding it frustrating to deal with having to jump back and forth from the podcast to the internet and everything, we really

Erik Townsend: do have a solution for you. It's called the Research Roundup email. You You can subscribe for free by creating a free account at MacroVoices.com.

Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro to claim your free book and subscribe to their podcast as well. For information on your company sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. And a Again, in order to make this whole process simple so that you've got the podcast, the downloads, and everything in one place, what you want is to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. It only takes a few minutes, and the benefit is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which makes all of this easy. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we discussed in the postgame. There's also an interesting article from Bloomberg that emerging market investors will need more than a truce to turn bullish, and a Financial Post article on why Canada won't necessarily follow the US rate cuts. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by viewers like you. Made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best. Free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not. Be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top