Grant Williams — Grant Williams, author/publisher of the Things That Make You Go Hmmm newsletter; Erik also calls him a founder of Real Vision Television (w11930) (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is. Bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 183 was recorded on September 5th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the only podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, which I highly recommend. Grant Williams, author of the renowned Things That Make You Go Hmmm newsletter, is back with us this week for a fantastic feature interview. We'll discuss negative-yielding sovereign debt, gold, unicorn stocks, and much more. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview. Patrick Ceresna is back from holiday and has another of his famous postgame chart books all wrapped up and ready to go.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 literally spent the entire month chopping around in that consolidation, and then as soon as September comes, we get a little bit of a short squeeze higher. Do you think this is for real?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think that the squeeze higher is really motivated by the de-escalation of political tensions in the last 48 hours. And I think the question is whether there's, there's follow-through. My view is definitely still that we're headed for a global growth recession. That view hasn't changed. The bond market, although it's backing up a little bit, just a few basis points this week, Basically seems to agree with me, but stocks are not taking that cue. I eventually think that President Trump and Xi will kiss and make up, and that hasn't quite happened yet, but when they do, it won't surprise me at all if that takes us to new all-time highs in the stock market. I don't want to be long here. I don't believe in this. I think we're already way overextended in valuations, but frankly, I don't dare to be short Because as much as it doesn't make sense to me, what I see in this market is that it's waiting for this Trump and Xi trade war drama to be over, and it looks to me like it wants to break higher at that point.
Makes no sense to me, but, you know, you can't fight the tape.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index because we had a breakout of 99, pulling back from here. Is this dollar strength continue?
Erik Townsend: I think so. You know, the breakout is back, and if you look at what's happened, we've had several times now the dollar index broke out beyond its resistance level. It really looked very strong, and then suddenly the President of the United States does something absolutely unprecedented and extraordinary that is dollar bearish, and that results in a knee-jerk pullback. But each one of those knee-jerk pullbacks has been smaller in magnitude. We're already at new all-time highs on the trade-weighted dollar index, and And with respect to the DXY, you know, the breakout has really occurred in the face of, as President Trump would say, huge headwinds. And despite those headwinds, we're still seeing the break. So, I think the dollar is moving higher. Now, the question is, if it's already faced huge headwinds, what would a hurricane-force Donald Trump anti-dollar headwind look like? Because the president is very clearly unhappy about the dollar's strength, outspoken about it, and talking about doing unprecedented things such as directing the Treasury Secretary to effectively bypass the Fed and directly intervene in currency markets.
So, my view here is all of the ingredients are set for the dollar to continue to rally and move higher on this global US dollar liquidity squeeze unless President Trump really, really gets extreme. And I think that's entirely possible. So, we've got to watch and see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to crude oil because pretty much the vast majority of the price action has been pinned between $53 to $57 for almost the entire month. Is it gonna start to break out here in September? What's your bias here?
Erik Townsend: I don't really think so. It could, but, you know, we saw a lot of strength in the last 48 hours. There's another big drawdown in crude oil inventories this week. EIA reporting a drawdown that was delayed by a day, so it was just reported today, of 4.8 million barrels on crude oil. Another big drawdown. Cushing, Oklahoma, though, only drawing down 230,000 barrels against analyst expectations of another 2 million barrel plus drawdown. That's really important to watch because Cushing has been hit with some really big drawdowns in the wake of a couple of new pipelines coming online where they can actually move oil not from the Permian where it's drilled into the storage facility, but the other direction from Cushing to the Permian because then they can take advantage of new Permian pipelines that take that oil down to the Gulf Coast. So, we're seeing a change in this trend maybe, or at least the first print that doesn't seem to be another 2 million-plus barrel drawdown in Cushing, Oklahoma.
But if we move on to product inventories, gasoline down 2.4 million barrels, distillates down 2.5 million barrels. So, Cushing's the odd man out in that it's only a small drawdown. Everybody else is looking at big drawdowns. You take those big inventory drawdowns plus the geopolitical de-escalation that occurred overnight, and you've also got the stock market breaking out of a fairly significant resistance zone. These things all helped us get all the way up to the 100-day moving average this morning on the data, but that was a few hours ago. As we're taping at about 2:30, we topped out at 57.70-something, just below the 100-day moving average, which is at 57.85. Well, we're all the way back down to $56.15 as we're speaking now. So, uh, you know, we've moved down almost $2 in, in the last couple of hours. It looks to me like it was a big pop on the inventory and we're going to retrace it and move back down to lower numbers.
We'll see what happens though. RBOB gasoline had been the holdout until inventory. As much as crude oil had broken above all of its short-term moving averages, RBOB gasoline was still running into resistance right on those short-term moving averages. It was the inventory report today that broke us out dramatically above that, all the way up to the 34-day moving average. And we're retracing there, but not quite as quickly as crude. So, what happens when RBOB gets back down to its short-term moving averages, and does it find support there? That's really what I'm going to be watching as an early indication as to what the crudes might do next after that.
I want to apologize to our listeners. We had planned to bring you our Energy Week podcast on Wednesday. The Zencastr podcast recording system, which we use to produce all of our content, had a nationwide outage yesterday, and unfortunately we were forced to cancel that. So we hope to be back with you next Wednesday with Energy Week, and we'll have an exciting show for you with a much deeper look at the energy market.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold bullion, because what a breakout August had. I mean, we went from $1,450 up to about just over $1,550 on a big push, but a big reversal day today. Do you think that's it for this push in gold, or what's next?
Erik Townsend: Well, it depends on what you mean by this push in gold. I think that might have been it for, uh, the short term in the sense that we're long overdue as far as I'm concerned. You know, the, the resilience of gold and, and the strength that it's shown really causes me to increase my bullish conviction for the long term. I really think gold is going to be the asset to own for the next decade.
The thing is, we're overdue for a pullback. We went up couple of hundred bucks in just a couple of months. And I've been actually very, very surprised and impressed by how resilient gold has been. You know, the dollar index broke out very decisively above 99. Gold was actually up on the day. So we really are seeing a lot of strength. I think we're way overdue for a pullback. Maybe that pullback has started. But as far as how far we pull back, I don't think we're going back to $1,200. I will be delighted to get an opportunity. I think we will see $1,400 before we see $1,700, and I would love I would love to buy some more gold at $1,400. I admit that I missed the boat at $1,200, and I think we're a little overdone here, but I'm looking for where's that pullback, where's the buying opportunity.
I think it's lower than we are, but not a whole lot lower.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's finally touch on that 10-year Treasury yield because we hovered around more or less around the 1.50 range for over a week, and now we just got a little bit of pop toward 1.60, but it's still below there. Do you think that's it for the short term on the Treasury push?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think the key to what you just said, Patrick, is for the short term. We were just moved so far, so fast to the downside in yield on Treasuries that we had to have some kind of relief bounce. And now we're getting it. The question is how far. And I think we are set to move to still lower yields on Treasuries. We're going to get into a lot of discussion with Grant Williams about this today. So I'll save most of it for the feature interview with Grant. But, yeah, I think this is a bounce. I don't think it's a reversal of the trend. I think it's a bounce in yields, a little pullback in prices. And the question is, how much farther does it have to go before we resume this secular decline in yields?
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, Erik, now we're launching a new format called MacroVoices Spotlight this week. Can you please explain how this came about?
Erik Townsend: When we launched our expanded content in May and began looking for sponsors to help us keep content free for everyone, the first thing that happened happened was that we were inundated by inquiries from people who hoped to buy their way into a feature interview on MacroVoices. Our answer was clear and firm: no way.
One of the things that I hate the most about the finance industry is this pay-to-play business model that most financial conferences use, where the speakers at the conference are just salesmen in disguise who paid to be chosen as speakers. We're not going to allow MacroVoices to be turned into an infomercial, and we're absolutely committed to that. Patrick does all the guest scheduling, and I deal with the sponsors, and there's a solid editorial wall between us. We've already said no thanks to all the people who offered to advertise with us in exchange for preferential treatment in giving them a feature interview, and we're absolutely committed to that policy. But then something unexpected happened. Our sponsor turned out to be a pretty interesting guy, and we're actually getting listener requests for me to interview Niels Kaastrup-Larsen from Top Traders Unplugged about trend following. And I have to agree, Niels is a fascinating guy, and he knows a lot about algorithmic trading and how it affects financial markets.
Well, this created a real conundrum, and the solution that we've come up with is to separate interviews with sponsors like Niels from the flagship podcast. So for those of you who have a strong emotional attachment to MacroVoices' policy of never compromising our journalistic integrity by stooping to the level of a pay-to-play business model, we've got you covered. The Thursday night flagship podcast will never sell interview slots to anyone for any price.
But for those of you who would like to hear an interview with our sponsors for the sake of learning what they do through an interview conducted by me, something which we've had actually quite a lot of listener requests for, we're introducing MacroVoices Spotlight for just that purpose. Bottom line, everybody should be happy here. If you have a religious opposition to hearing sponsored content, then don't listen to MacroVoices Spotlight. Simple. But frankly, I think you'll miss out on some great content. We absolutely do not intend to go into the infomercial business. We're only going to do Spotlight interviews with people who have something to say that we can be persuaded our audience truly wants to hear. I pride myself in transparency, so we're not going to do it on the flagship podcast. We've introduced MacroVoices Spotlight to make it absolutely clear that it's content that was paid for by the interview guest.
That way, people who want to hear it can tune in, and anyone who objects to sponsored content can easily tune out.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, so, uh, please give us a sense of what kind of content our listeners can expect for that MacroVoices Spotlight, and when will it air?
Erik Townsend: The first episode is all about algorithmic trading and trend following, and the guest is Niels Kaastrup-Larsen from Top Traders Unplugged and Dunn Capital Management. We're going to start by discussing the role of CTAs in the marketplace. Now, curiously, Niels does not agree with all of Charlie McElligott's views about the effects CTAs have on markets, so we're going to get a CTA insider's perspective on that. Then we'll cover the trend following strategy in detail, and Niels will explain how it works and the benefits that it offers in portfolio construction.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: The second episode will feature Bob Coleman from Idaho Armored Vaults. That interview is all about physical storage of precious metals. Now, this topic is extremely well aligned with our high-level mission of bringing our listeners more precious metals content, and we'll go over the differences between allocated, unallocated, and segregated storage of physical precious metals, the conflicts of interest that can arise between bullion banks and their clients, and the pros and cons of private vaulting.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: I learned quite a bit myself taping this interview with Bob, and I think it will be extremely interesting to that segment of our audience who are interested in owning precious metals in physical form. We're going to air the trend-following interview with Niels tomorrow, Friday, September 6th, and the private vaulting interview with Bob Coleman a week later. Going forward, we are only going to accept spotlight interviews from sponsors who have something to say that we are persuaded that our audience sincerely wants to learn about. Interesting topics like how does trend following work, or what are the options for private vaulting and storage of precious metals. Whole life insurance salesmen need not apply.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's feature interview guest is Grant Williams. So, Erik, why did we choose Grant to come back this week as our featured guest?
Erik Townsend: Well, as we're into September, it's time to really see what's going to happen next, and are we going to have a change of direction in markets. And, you know, Grant is a veteran of the industry. He's been around forever. And he writes one of the most respected letters in the industry. So it's— I don't know how long it's been since we've had Grant on the program, but it's overdue, I think, to get him back. He's a very, very outspoken gold bull. He's been a gold bull for a long time. And needless to say, he's been proven right with the breakout that we've seen in gold. He thinks it's got quite a bit further to go. So he's just a guy that, that really has had an excellent command of the macro market environment, and we're overdue for an update.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. You often hear me say that even if I have conviction about a market or trade, that you have to listen to what the market is telling you, not what you think it should be doing.
And that's exactly what trend-following managers have been doing for decades with great success. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well-researched and tested. And there's one podcast that covers trend following strategies better than any other: toptradersunplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book called The Many Flavors of Trend Following, explaining exactly how these systematic strategies can work for you. Just go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro.
Check him out, you'll be glad you did, and tune in tomorrow for my interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, Erik's interview with Grant Williams is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Grant Williams. I'm learning to say Grant and not sound American and say Grant Williams. Uh, it is so great to have you back on the program, Grant, and, uh, I want to point our listeners to a download that is available in your Research Roundup email. Grant is, of course, the publisher of Things That Make You Go Hmmm, one of the most respected newsletters in the industry. There was a piece just a couple of weeks ago on gold which Grant Grant has— there I go again. Grant has kindly offered to allow us to distribute for free to listeners. So, this is an excellent chance to get both a free copy of a great piece of writing, and particularly on a very hot topic. So, don't miss that in the downloads. Grant, let's talk— before we get to gold, I want to come back to that, but you were one of the first people to raise the flag and just talk about the The utterly preposterous notion that at the time you said it, we had $13 trillion of negative-yielding debt, sovereign debt around the world.
And it seemed crazy. And at the time, it almost felt like maybe it had peaked because that was just at the beginning of the, the last time interest rates were bottoming. And they started to go up and it was maybe that was the end of it. But now we've not only eclipsed that $13 trillion, it was $15 trillion last I checked, and I wouldn't be surprised if it's gone considerably more than that. I'm sure you must be on top of it. How much negative-yielding sovereign debt do we have around the world at this point? And probably more to the point, what the heck is going on here?
Grant Williams: Yeah, look, this negative-yielding debt is— I think we crossed $17 trillion this week. I mean, it's remarkable, Erik. I mean, we really are, again, in uncharted territories here. The amazing thing is we're all trying to figure this out. We're all being dealt a whole bunch of cards that we've never seen before. We're not getting the king of spades and the 8 of clubs. We're just being dealt a load of symbols. We don't know what they mean. We don't know how to play the hand, but we're all at the table. And everybody's figuring this out as we go along. So, you're seeing people do things. You're seeing some crazy articles about what the pension funds are doing with this negative yielding debt. There was a great snippet from a piece that Charles Gave, who you and I both know, wrote about a visit he made to, I think it was a Dutch pension fund, who told him, basically, look, I have to buy these things.
I'm being told that I have to buy these things, because I have to put this money to work. And I'm being instructed to buy these things, even though I know that it's a guaranteed loss in the long term, unless I can find a greater fool. So, here we are. I mean, people are being forced to do things that they know, not just through experience, is a foolish thing to do, but through common sense, But they have no choice.
We're in this TINA world, there is no alternative. And until the music stops, we go on. But what's been interesting in the last few months is the profile, and for want of a better word, the tenor of some of the voices starting to call this thing out is getting more high profile. We've seen luminaries like Ray Dalio and Paul Tudor Jones and Stan Druckenmiller not only call this out for what it is, but also talk about gold as being their preferred investment or their preferred currency in Druckenmiller's case. So, the sands are definitely shifting if you're paying attention. But there are some very smart people that make a cogent argument as to why this could go on for a materially extended period of time from here even. I'm not sure I buy that, certainly from a risk-reward perspective. But I think Albert Edwards' Ice Age theory is looking more and more like the playbook that everybody should perhaps be understanding.
Erik Townsend: What is your view on the direction generally of the US 10-year? For a while, it seemed like there was a lot of people really sold on this idea that that 1.36, or maybe it was 1.34 intraday, I don't remember, back from 2016, in the summer of '16, that was Going to be the forever low. It could never possibly go lower than that. Well, we're what, 15 basis points above that right now at 1.50% as we're speaking on Tuesday morning. Where do you think that we're headed with the US 10-year yield?
Grant Williams: For me, it feels like the yield goes lower. I mean, I said a while ago that I could absolutely understand it going sub-1%. It was probably at 2.5%, maybe 3% when I said that. And I still stick to that. I think we could get a real panic. Into dollars and into Treasuries particularly. And it could conceivably go down to those sort of levels that people just thought was impossible. But the more you look around the world, the more you realize that the impossible has not only become the possible, it's become the probable. And that's a material shift for people to try and understand what to do about that. I don't see the Treasury market losing the bid anytime soon, even though I know that a lot of the holders are very, very nervous because We are in these strange, uncharted waters. But if I'm looking to play something for the blow-off, Erik, I would frankly much rather play the Treasury market blow-off than the equity market blow-off, to be honest with you.
Erik Townsend: Grant, I want to talk about where this is really headed, because years ago, when I first heard you talking about the $13 trillion of negative-yielding sovereign debt, I thought, okay, this is crazy. It's irrational. It's not sustainable. Surely, it has to reverse. But my thinking has evolved completely from then. What I've realized is if I look at the social climate, whether I personally agree with it or not, it seems that modern monetary theory is really very, very quickly gaining a huge amount of political clout. And it seems that as we're headed into an election year in the United States, that probably what's going to happen is a lot of politicians are going to be calling for, look, we need to stop bailing out Wall Street with the last form of QE, and we need to look at QE for the people in the form of MMT.
And as much as $17 trillion of negative-yielding sovereign debt sounds crazy, it seems to me that we really need to think about what would actually stop it. And, you know, if we get to negative-yielding US sovereigns and deeply negatively yielding European sovereigns, what's really to stop any of this? And And where do you think it's headed? And what do you think the political climate is going to deliver in terms of monetary policy being affected by these political agendas like MMT?
Grant Williams: Yeah, it's a great question, Erik. And again, we're in uncharted territory. But I think there's 2 questions around MMT. One is, will it happen? And 2 is, will it work? And they're very important, right? Because they're not mutually exclusive, but kind of they are in some ways. It or something like it will happen because, as you said, it's become incredibly popular. And as soon as these ideas are floated and they gain some sort of tailwind, the other politicians are going to latch onto them. Forgiving student loans is another perfect example. I'm pretty sure that's coming at some point. It's going to be a really tricky one to work out how to do it. But all of these ideas, whether it is student loan forgiveness, whether it is MMT, are basically band-aid solutions to the problem that's been created, which stems from the fact that they've desperately tried to keep this expansion going to avoid a recession at any cost, to avoid the downward half of the business cycle that you and I have spoken about so many times before.
And as those natural forces try to assert themselves, it's a question of, okay, what can we do now to stop this? We've cut rates, we've done QE, we've done Operation Twist, we've come up with every scheme imaginable, and it still hasn't worked. And so maybe it's time to just print money. And maybe it's time for MMT.
To me, it's just symptomatic of the problem here, which is, again, too much debt in the world. We're once again going to try to cure too much debt with more debt. We're going to come up with a way to justify it. We're going to come up with a way to explain it. It's a horse of a different color.
There is a day of reckoning that is due. And maybe we can push it off into the future. Maybe we can. But I think every day you push this forward into the future, the more seismic it's going to become, and the bigger problem it's going to become. I mean, look where we are now.
And what's been fascinating to watch, actually, if you look around the world at some of these bond markets, my friend Peter Atwater calls these the no-skid marks charts. And we see bond after bond. We saw Steinhoff in South Africa. We saw Toys R Us in the US. We saw Argentina's 100-year bond recently.
The bond markets haven't sniffed out the defaults coming. These things have hit a wall, and the bonds have just cratered. That's not supposed to happen. It didn't used to happen. But it's happening now because everybody is under this assumption that everyone's going to be made good, and the bond market's going to be fine. And there's always a bid because there's so much money chasing the bonds.
At some point, that's not going to work. And I suspect that if we do go into recession, or God forbid it's proven later that we are actually in a recession now, none of this stuff's going to matter. I honestly don't think it's going to matter. I think we're going to be into interest rate caps. We're going to be into all kinds of desperate measures. So, MMT may not seem like the craziest idea out there at some point, mandating pension funds buy Treasuries. That's a very simple solution to a complicated problem. I think the crazy is yet to come. I think the crazy will be desperate, and I think MMT will absolutely be a part of that toolbox.
Erik Townsend: Well, I couldn't agree more, unfortunately. And one of my predictions here is I think MMT will appear on the surface to be wildly successful at first. It's going to look absolutely beautiful because, you know, you create a whole bunch of liquidity, you give it to people, it stimulates the economy, everybody feels good. Of course, it's going to appear to work at first, and eventually I predict that a very, very dire consequence will result. But it's something I've gotten wrong consistently in my experiences. I always think these things are going to happen faster than they really do. And it could take quite a few years for this to play out.
Grant Williams: Well, Erik, the other thing that's worth pointing out is that when you give money to people, if you start giving money directly to Main Street, it used to be that Wall Street were rational actors. And if you start funneling money to Wall Street, you have a pretty good understanding of what they're going to do with it, right? You knew when QE was coming that Wall Street was going to front-run the Fed bid for bonds.
You knew if the central banks were buying corporate bonds, that the professional investors were going to front-run that. When you start giving the money to Main Street, there's sometimes some strange things.
If they take that money and they start saving, God forbid, they start saving money so they can pay down their debts, that's going to be a major problem. And we have seen that If they start doing that at a time when the public are frightened, as we saw in 2008, you look at the savings rate in the US in '08, it jumped through the roof. So, you might find that the man in the street starts hoarding any liquidity that's thrown his way. So, it's not a guaranteed outcome. And you're giving it to perhaps the most unpredictable market actor out there. And that could surprise a few people, I think.
Erik Townsend: It's very interesting to hear you say that, because what I would have said, and it sounds like we disagree on this, is I would have said, as soon as you take it to the public, as opposed to bailing out Wall Street with QE, I would have said it has to be wildly inflationary, because that money is going into the real economy. It's being given to people who are likely to spend it. Do you think that this possibility of people surprising us and saying, no, we'd rather save it causes there not to be the inflationary reaction to MMT that I'm expecting, or— and I don't predict it overnight. I think it's a long lag time, but I think that eventually there would be a risk of runaway inflation. Do you have a different view about that?
Grant Williams: I think if you look at it as a cold, hard idea, yes, absolutely. What happens if we throw a lot of money into the economy? I agree with you. It should be wildly the inflation rate. What would have happened had you put a load of money into Main Street's pockets in October, November of 2008? They were not going to go out and spend that money. I mean, every headline was telling them this was the Great Depression Mark II, and they would have saved it. They would have paid down debt as they do in extremis.
So, I think if MMT comes at the wrong time, if it's a reaction to another massive leg down or another big leg in this deflationary vortex we seem to be stuck in, I think there's a very good chance that people save it or pay down debt with it instead of going out and spending on another car or some more white goods. I think the public's actions are dictated by how they feel.
And you can feel the tension, the anxiousness ratcheting up all the time. And so, for me, there's a big question of timing here. They would have to do MMT before things got really bad in the economy for it to have the effect you're talking about. If they do, then yes, I agree with you. But if it's the response to another '08-type situation, then I think the reaction of the public could be wholly different.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about where that recession or worse comes from, because something that you and I have discussed on this program, and you've certainly gone to great lengths on elsewhere for years now, is, hey, we're really long in the tooth on this economic cycle. It's time. A natural part of life. We're overdue for one. Well, Grant, we were overdue for one 5 years ago, and it hasn't happened yet. Do you think that this recent plunge in bond rates and inversion of the yield curve is telling us that finally we're gonna get that recession, or do you think that maybe that's another false flag?
Grant Williams: Well, it's interesting, Erik, because this is a metric that has been almost infallible over the years, and so it's fascinating to me to see people talking instantly. We've had small inversions. It hasn't stayed inverted. It hasn't been inverted for a long period of time. We've had these little inversions and a lot of headlines and knee-jerk reactions intraday.
But it's interesting how quickly people are now coming out saying, you know what, this doesn't matter anymore. This indicator doesn't matter because of negative rates, because of zero interest rate policy. It's a false flag now. And that's fine. But if you're in the business of investing, you're in the business of handicapping probabilities. That's what you're supposed to be doing here.
And so, if you want to take an indicator that's been a really, really good, as good an indicator of anything forward-looking that we can hope to see in what is, let's face it, a big game of read the tea leaves. Or you can look at the New York Fed's recessionary gauge indicator, which every time it's gone above 30 has been 100% correct. There's been a recession. Guess what? It's above 30. But people are very happy to say, this doesn't matter anymore.
And you know what? Maybe it doesn't Maybe it doesn't. But if you want to give me an indicator that is right 8 or 9 times out of 10, or 100% in the case of the New York Fed benchmark, then I'm going to at least listen to that and start thinking, okay, what does this do to my portfolio if this is correct once again? How do I need to change up my allocations? How do I need to buy insurance? How do I need to protect my positions, protect my profits? Do I take some profits?
That's what you're supposed to do when these flags get triggered. No, it's not a guaranteed assurance that we're going to be in recession, but none of us know what the future is going to bring. But it tells you there's a heightened probability that we are going to go into one. And so, then you have to decide, okay, what's my handicapping? Do I think there's a 50% chance this is right, a 70% chance? If you do, you have to take action.
Lacy Hunt has been calling this brilliantly, this bond market, for the longest time now. David Rosenberg has been calling brilliantly all the data points we're seeing. And he's adamant that we are, if not in a recession, we're going into one. These are 2 very, very smart guys who don't make outlandish calls often.
And when they do, you should listen to them. They could be wrong. That's fine. There's nothing wrong with being wrong. It's about putting out the reasons why you think something's going to happen and allowing people to judge for themselves whether they believe it or not.
There's too much store, I think, put in Who's right today and who's wrong today, and will you be right tomorrow? This is not predicting the future; is not a game that any of us can claim to be able to do. We're all guessing. We're all trying to make educated guesses, and time-tested signals of recession are tools you should use to make better guesses. That's all. That's all they really are. And right now, there is a preponderance of evidence that suggests it is time to. factor in recession to your base case and understand how it would impact you. And if you think it's a big enough hit, make plans and make adjustments to your positioning.
Erik Townsend: Well, Grant, I am very strongly of the view that we are headed into a recession. So, I think I'm in David Rosenberg's camp. But the place where I'm not so convinced is what the implications of that really are in markets. Because we always used to assume, hey, if you know you're headed into recession, or if If you think that's gonna be the outcome, it's gotta mean that the stock market goes down and probably down a lot. But the reason for that was because the bond market was so much more attractive in those recessions than the stock market.
Grant Williams: Right.
Erik Townsend: Well, guess what? We just talked about, what is it, $17 trillion now of negative yielding. So it seems like the artificial manipulation of these markets by central bankers is maybe changing the rules. And one of the ways I look at this is I think the recession signs are so clear That if the market was going to sell off dramatically in the next recession, it would have started by now, but it hasn't really started in any meaningful way. And so it makes me start to, you know, I thought Brent Johnson was crazy the first time he told me that he thought that things are really bad and stocks are going to go up as a result. But I'm seeing the argument now that if other people around the world start to view the US equity market as a safety trade because The choice, if they want to get out of their own stock markets, is to go into European negative-yielding sovereigns or into the US stock market as a safety trade where you've got also the FX benefit of this dollar squeeze.
All of a sudden, it makes it seem like maybe the US stock market could be recession-proof this time around. Is that a possibility?
Grant Williams: Of course it is. I mean, everything's a possibility. There's nothing that you can categorically say that cannot happen, right? I mean, who would have said that negative interest rates cannot happen? 5 years ago. Most people, I mean, we would have said that. But of course, the scenario you've laid out could absolutely happen. But I think if we go into a recession, if we start seeing poor numbers, we start seeing companies cutting jobs, we start seeing the human side of a recession, it's going to be very tough to just jump in and buy the US equity market, I think. I think people, if they see a recession, will close their eyes, hold their nose, and buy more Treasuries. I think that's the safety trade, the real safety trade.
Because it's amazing how suddenly, if there are signs that we're in a recession, it's amazing how suddenly a lot of these valuation metrics that we've kind of forgotten about start to matter. Price to sales, price to book, all the valuations that have just most of us shaking our heads who've had any kind of longevity in these markets, understanding not for a second why they're being bid up to the places they are.
Now, in a recession, those things do matter. And it won't just be a case of buy me stocks for the safety. It will be buy me Treasuries. Albert Edwards, and I think Raoul, were talking about -4% on the US 2-year as a possibility. I mean, think about that. We're at what, 1.4-ish now?
Just think about what a move that would be and what it would take to drive that down there. And that will not happen in the face of a soaring stock market.
So, is it a possibility? Absolutely, it's a possibility you could get there. And as you said, laid it out very well and very clearly as to how it might happen. To me, I think that's a very dangerous assumption to make, to trade long stocks with that as your base case, I think is a very risky thing to do. I really do.
Erik Townsend: I agree with you completely on that. I guess what is different for me is I'm the kind of trader who wouldn't be bashful based on what I see in this economy about shorting the S&P. with some leverage. And I'm not doing that this time around, just because the game's changed. And I don't know what the rules are.
Grant Williams: Yep, that's it. I think it's a great point you make. Because, because you are experienced, you do, you see things that previously, you would know how to react to them. You know, you know, in your heart, okay, I know what the right positioning is here. But I don't have the courage to do it because the rules have changed. But let me ask you this. What would it take for you to see, to have the confidence to do that again? Because there's a lot of people having exactly those thoughts that you are out there sitting there on their hands, experienced guys going, you know what, I need to see, just show me something.
Show me something that tells me that everything I've learned to now is actually going to matter again. Because it'll be different things for different people. But I'm sure there's something out there that if you see it, it will give you the confidence to put the trades on that you know you want to do.
And I think that that kind of realization, that kind of confirmation will come from different places for different people. And you'll start seeing people finally have the courage to put those shorts on that you're talking about. That's what I think we're missing. It's that, OK, if I see the market— maybe some people will be technical. Some people want to see reversals and all kinds of things on candle charts. Some people People will want to see good news sold. There'll be all kinds of things. But little by little, that confidence that everything they know in their gut to be true actually matters again, I think that will bring people like you back to the table, and it won't be on the long side.
Erik Townsend: Oh, absolutely. But I think the problem is that a lot of really smart people will get caught wrong-footed along the way to that eventual outcome, because there's been plenty of times so far where it looked to a lot of us like, okay, this thing's finally over, it's rolling over, it's time to be short now. And we were wrong each of those times to date. And I think that, as you say, it's left a lot of us to where we're not going to jump on the short trade until it's really clear. And then everybody piles in at once, and it really gets ugly really quickly. But, you know, at the same time, I look at everything that's, that's going on here. And I think, well, what do we know about the really big picture here? We know that none of the problems that led us to 2008 were ever solved. What we've done is we've papered over our problems in a way that I predict ultimately it's the, the higher you climb, the, the harder they fall.
So eventually things have to get really, really bad to clear the system.
But I used to think, oh, you can't just, you know, conjure money out of thin air with QE and solve everything. Well, boy, you can paper over problems for decades at a time. with money conjured out of thin air. That really does work to at least address the symptoms in the short term, and it works incredibly well. And I think it creates a complacency level that is going to make this thing go on for longer than anybody thinks possible, until eventually it turns really, really ugly really quickly.
Grant Williams: Well, you know, the poster child for this, Erik, if you look at Bill Fleckenstein, who I know you've had Bill on before, Bill closed his short fund in March '09, because he knew what they were going to do, and he figured it was no time to be short. And a couple of times, he's made noises about starting his short fund again, and a bunch of people have jumped on and said, hey, if you start a short fund again, I'm in, I'm in, I'm in. He's never pulled that trigger. He just hasn't seen what he wanted to see. And with Bill, it's feel. There'll be little nuances that he's waiting for. He's waited 10 years patiently for that. But I know when Bill sees what he wants to see, he'll go for it. And he's not alone. There are a lot of experienced traders like yourself who are just waiting for a setup they feel they can manage the risk effectively.
And when it comes, I don't think they're going to be shy in taking this market on, because we all know that if you get the short right, it's probably going to be the biggest short win you have in your career. It's just about being patient.
Erik Townsend: Grant, I couldn't agree more that that's where the challenge is going to be, is the short trade of a lifetime is coming. And those of us who can see it coming have jumped early too many times. And Bill Fleckenstein has probably done a better job than I have. I've thought it was game on for the short side, and I've decided that we really need to wait until it's very clear because there's been a lot of false signals. But I want to move on to something where I think there is A very, very clear signal right here, right now. You have been an outspoken gold bull for as long as I've known you.
I have always agreed with you that in the long run, gold is the place to be. I'm convinced it's going to be the asset to own for the next decade. But at the same time, the place where we disagreed was tactical. And I thought, boy, Grant, you got to be able to see this global US dollar liquidity squeeze. It's going to drive the dollar higher, and that can only mean a headwind for gold. Well, I got half of that right. It has driven the dollar higher. And I think, to give you credit, when we talked about this before, you said, yeah, yeah, I see the dollar liquidity squeeze argument. That's a good point. But I still think that gold— being long gold, not waiting for it— is the place I want to be.
Grant Williams: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I thought you were going to be proven right in the end. I thought I was going to outsmart you a little bit by waiting for a better entry price, a bit lower, and I definitely got that call wrong. So, what's going on here that we're seeing? Not only has the gold breakout occurred, but the dollar breakout occurred too. And on Tuesday morning that we're speaking, we're seeing the dollar particularly breaking to new all-time highs on the trade-weighted dollar index.
Grant Williams: Right.
Erik Townsend: A recent cycle high on the US Dollar Index. And you'd think that would be a headwind for gold, and gold is up dramatically on the day. So, what's going on here? Why is it suddenly now that you're being proven right?
Grant Williams: Well, look, that sound you can hear is me rolling my sleeves up. We start to talk about gold. Yeah, this is something— and thank you for using the term bull and not bug. I appreciate that. When you talk about gold being something people should own, when it doesn't go up, they talk about you being wrong. And it's really not that, because to me, it's never been an instrument you trade with. I'm not a gold trader. I want to own gold for what I believe is going to happen and for what I think is starting to happen now. And this is the fact that the dollar and gold are going up together is not a good sign. That's not a good thing. Trust me, it has happened before, which is why I It wasn't that difficult to predict that you would eventually see gold and the dollar rise together. This is as big a screaming signal that people are worried as I think you can see. And when we talked earlier about, do we buy bonds?
Do we buy equities? I think gold is about to shove its foot in that door and enter that conversation. Do people allocate a couple of percent of their portfolio to gold? 5%, maybe some of the pension funds. And if they do, you better get ready to see some fireworks.
You know, I gave a presentation recently, which is the letter that I think you're going to link to in the downloads file, just talking about the similarities between 1930s, the Roaring Twenties, the blow-off top there, and what we've been going through recently, that there are all kinds of parallels in society and politics. It really is eerie how history rhymes. And you and I have spoken about history's tendency to do that numerous times. But the point I was trying to make there was gold really performed in the aftermath of the crisis. It wasn't in the lead-up. The Roaring '20s, everything was great.
But once the uncertainty rose, and once we entered the Great Depression, at the time, obviously, gold was— the price was fixed. Once they had to let gold off the leash, if you like, You saw the price increase dramatically, and it was after the pain happened.
And that's what worries me about gold rising so strongly now and really starting to confound a lot of the people that said the move is over and it needs to break out, but then it really needs to consolidate. Well, it's gone straight through that $1,480 level. It's gone straight through $1,500. We're closing in on $1,600. And as I said, when you've got You've got Paul Tudor Jones saying it's his number one investment for the next 12 to 24 months. You've got Ray Dalio saying everybody should have an allocation to gold. And you've got Stan Druckenmiller saying it's his single biggest currency position.
These are people you should listen to. And it's not about putting 70% of your assets in gold. It's not about that. It's about, is it time to have gold as an insurance policy for my portfolio? Well, if everything we talked about with the bonds and the equities is correct, and both of them are very dangerous places to be, then why wouldn't you take 5% of your profits and put it into something like gold, which has no counterparty risk, which is a currency, which is incredibly liquid, and offers solutions to all the problems that we've spoken about?
So, I think gold is about to make a move that we've been talking was a possibility for a long, long time. I very rarely talk about the price when I talk about gold, because it really isn't why I own it. But I think the action recently suggests that a lot of people are going to be looking at gold, are going to start to understand why it makes sense to own it. And if they decide to pull the trigger, even if it's just as a precautionary tactic, that will have a massive effect on the gold market. And if this fear of the dollar shortage continues, and it is aligned with fear of a recession, fear over market tops, fear over negative yielding debt. The chart of that $17 trillion of negative yielding debt is identical to the gold price. As negative yielding debt increases, gold goes right along with it.
So, I think gold has broken out. I think you'll see it move quite quickly towards testing that old $1,900 level in US dollars. But again, when we talk about gold and talk about how it's still $300 below where it reached in 2011, the dollar is just about the only currency you can say that. It's a new all-time high in Aussie dollars, in Canadian dollars, in British pounds, in Japanese yen, and as of yesterday, I think, the euro. Anybody who's ever bought an ounce of gold in any of those currencies is in the green now throughout history. I mean, think about that. That. And it's only picking up speed. You're starting to see a lot more coverage of it in mainstream media. And it's such an emotional asset that if it starts to be written about emotionally, it starts to be talked about emotionally, and it starts to become an apparent alternative or an apparent hedge or an apparent insurance policy, it doesn't take a lot to get this thing moving.
And I think I've been consistent about this. I think everybody has needed to own gold for some time now. The people that started buying it in the early 2000s, they could care less. They haven't watched the price really. They saw it go up to $1,900. Some of them maybe sold out, I don't know, but they certainly haven't sweated the $1,900 to $1,100 fall over that painful 4 years between 2011 and 2015.
But owning it is an important thing to have done. And I think if you've got it, it's a very comforting asset to hold in a very turbulent and troubled environment. And again, you're not going to put 100% of your money. It's not a 60/40 gold bonds portfolio we're talking about here. But we're talking about an allocation for protection, for insurance, whatever you want to call it. But I think the gold market has changed. I think the fact that it's going up in concert with the dollar is a big, big signal. And I think it really is time for people who've either thought about it and haven't done anything to at least go back and reconsider the argument for it, understand what you want to own it for. And again, then decide if you want to pull the trigger. If you don't, that's absolutely fine. But there's a lot of reasons why you should, I think, right now.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit about how you own it in this environment, Grant, because when you talk about the gold and dollar moving together up at the same time, I think that's a really important point. And it seems like it's a game changer in what some of the drivers are. So do the old rules of, you know, a lot of people used to be more comfortable with mining shares because they felt that was a comfortable way to get leverage on the gold price. Is that still right? Or are we in a situation where the metal itself is more likely to be where the action is?
Grant Williams: I think that the beauty of the gold universe is, is that it is actually, when all is said and done, pretty simple, right? It's, it's volatile as hell. You need a cast iron stomach to trade these things. But when the metal goes, for the most part, the miners will go right along with it. And they will outperform because they do have that inherent leverage. So, it's actually pretty simple. If you believe that gold is going to go higher, and you want to trade it, and you want a leveraged exposure to the price, then great. I mean, the gold mining stocks are a great place to be. And the point I was making in my presentation was, you don't need to get too cute with these, because as much as you could dig through and you could find some companies that will be stellar outperformers from the rest of their peers.
If the public decide to come for the gold miner stocks, they will come for the ETFs. They'll come for GDX, they'll come for GDXJ. So you don't have to be too cute. You don't have to expose yourself to a stock that we all know from experience could have a mine collapse or a permitting problem or a hostile government come in. There are so many things that can go wrong with gold mining stocks. But if this is a mainstream trade, and gold becomes the hot topic and gold miners become the hot stocks, you just have to own the ETFs, the GDX and GDXJ, because that's where people that don't really care what they do, they just want exposure, the price will go.
So, for me, owning physical gold just for those insurance reasons is always something you need to do. If you are trend chasing, if you just think this is going to be a great trade for me, then absolutely, you can get the leverage from the mining stocks. And look, let's face it, you can get even more leverage from silver. And we should definitely talk about silver. That was one of the charts I had in this thing showing as perfect a 50-year chart as I've seen that suggests silver is going to have a massive breakout.
And if you look at the gold-silver ratio, it's hugely skewed towards gold right now. Silver is gold's more volatile cousin. And so if it's leverage you want, if it's volatility you want, and exposure to potentially big upsides in a precious metals bull market, Then silver is a great thing to look at right now. And again, you know, you've got ETFs that will do the job for you without you having to dig through company reports and try and ascertain the quality of the company management, which is always one of the really difficult things to do with mining stocks.
Erik Townsend: Does silver now represent in your mind one of those rare second chances for people who maybe have missed the big move in gold? Is it really as simple as, hey, silver hasn't caught up yet, You've still got a chance to buy silver, or is there more to the picture than that?
Grant Williams: I think if you look at that ratio, if you're worried about it, you can, you can go long silver and short gold and look, just look for that ratio to come back into line. It's got a long way to move in your favor. So if you're nervous about it, it's just, it's a great trade. You know, we should talk about platinum as well. Platinum looks hugely undervalued here. If people are going to come for the precious metals, and it's a very illiquid market.
If this is a new precious metals bull market, which I sense that it might be, I wouldn't— even though gold's performed incredibly strongly and broken through these levels, I'd love to see it go through $1,600 before I felt, okay, this really is game on, as you said earlier on.
But there are so many ways to play it. And if you want leverage, the precious metals market will give you it in spades. But you have to have a stomach for it. You have to understand just how how wild these horses are to ride, and really know what you're doing. But I think if you believe that we are in a new precious metals bull market, and you want to trade it, then it's not so much about the metal, about the gold price, it is about these mining stocks. And look, you've got the triple leveraged gold miner ETF, there's all kinds of ways to add leverage on leverage.
I don't do that because, again, I'm not owning gold for a trade, even though I think there is a great trade to be done here in the miners. But there's enough leverage in those. I don't need to try and time it and be so cute with Nugget, N-U-G-T, and things like that, which are just things you have to keep an eye on 24 hours a day.
Erik Townsend: Grant, let's come back to the equity market. We already talked about the big picture macro drivers, but I want to talk specifically about these unicorn companies like Uber, and particularly WeWork, which you've written about, not in the issue of your newsletter that's about gold, which we have linked, but I think it was the one, most recent one just last week. You wrote about WeWork and these unicorns in general. What's on your mind there?
Grant Williams: Well, look, I mean, we've been marveling at these unicorn companies and some of the crazy stuff we've read about the valuations that they've been afforded by the markets. And look, many of us have been looking for a top. We all know that trees don't grow to the sky. But with each crazy new IPO, each crazy valuation, we've kind of scratched our head and said, well, where does it end? And I just get the feeling that WeWork may well spell the top, particularly if this IPO does coincide with this recession, because recession is kryptonite to WeWork's business model of taking on long leases and leasing them out short-term to people.
And so when you look at it, I looked at Uber, we saw this phenomenal loss that Uber came up with in their most recent numbers. Was it $5.2 billion they lost in a quarter? A lot of it was related to their IPO. But when you look at the performance of these IPOs recently, not just Uber, but Lyft and Xiaomi, the big Chinese IPO, they performed horribly. The numbers, I think Xiaomi is down almost 50% since IPO, Uber's down 20-odd, same as Lyft, Slack's down a similar amount, Dropbox, Spotify, they're all down. In fact, the only one that's gone up significantly from its IPO is Pinterest.
And so, if this is really the private equity guys and the private investors cashing out and taking out their stakes and selling them to the public, which it really does look like, then WeWork's valuation is going to cause, I suspect, all kinds of problems.
The S-1 they filed for the IPO was roundly laughed at in the media. There were all kinds of articles, scathing articles about about the stuff that was going on in there. I mean, you really have to look at this thing. We don't have time to go through all the fanciful stuff in there. But I look for changes in attitude, changes in tone, and the media coverage, which had been very sort of salutary and lauding all these unicorns as they filed for IPOs and saying what incredible companies they were and the wealth they were creating, et cetera, et cetera.
They're now being picked upon for things like community-adjusted EBITDA, which is a WeWork metric that that they came up with. They're being picked apart for some of the family connections. They're being picked apart for the fact that the CEO has bought a lot of buildings and then let WeWork use them to lease out to tenants. And there's so much hair on this thing. And it's never mattered before. All these, these big unicorns have got away, even though we've written about this stuff, and people have talked about it quietly in little corners of the market, it hasn't really impacted. They've been bulletproof.
Well, I think WeWork is going to be a real test of this because the coverage I saw was almost universally scathing of this company and scathing of a lot of the things in that filing. It's going to be very interesting as they go through this process to see what the chatter is, to see if they can get it away. Now, they may well be able to, but everyone I know is looking for a way to get short this thing at the IPO.
I just have this horrible feeling that the public is going to be left holding the bag again.
But to see the change in tone for WeWork, the change in narrative around the unicorn stocks, and the fact that this recession does loom ever larger in the background, I'm worried that we may have seen the top of the unicorn era, which incidentally will coincide almost precisely with SoftBank raising their second Vision Fund. Which would be another bell going off. So everywhere I look, I see signs that this unicorn era is, is going to struggle. And from $47 billion valuation for WeWork, that's a long way to fall. If people decide it should be valued as a real estate company, and not as what they call a space as a service company instead of a software as a service company, you know, things like that, just cute ways of trying to spin your valuation and call yourself a tech company.
They're fine when everything's going well, but they're the sort of things that people call out when the turn happens, and everybody is calling this stuff out. So, I'm very nervous, and I think WeWork is going to be a clanging bell.
Erik Townsend: Where does Tesla fit into this story? You did quite a bit of work on Tesla, and I mean, it was such a ripe short when you looked at it more than a year ago. It hasn't crashed yet, and it has had an up and down But it's still way overvalued from my perspective and seems to have that investor loyalty that's just unshakable. What's going to finally break the grip of something like the investor loyalty you see in Tesla?
Grant Williams: Yeah, it's— I'm way too fascinated by Tesla for my own good. I mean, I openly admit that. It's the thing that I am most focused on in terms of looking for signs that that we're seeing a crack, because it's not really investor loyalty, Erik. It's certain customer loyalty. And a lot of the customers have bought a few shares here and a few shares there. And they've really been evangelists. I mean, it is fascinating. This is something we could spend an entire hour talking about.
Because I think flippancy aside, and the pantomime that is Elon Musk and Tesla aside, I think it's a very, very important stock. Because I do think it's a fraud. I do think it will end up being an absolute unmitigated disaster. And I'm starting to see the fraud unravel in front of my eyes. If you look at all the things that are going on with other cars exploding— today, we've seen the assemblyman in Buffalo who gave $750 million to Tesla to build a factory on the promise of a certain amount of jobs and a certain amount of effect on the local community.
They've suddenly started saying, you know what? We want to audit them and see what we got for our $750 million. And it comes out today that Tesla won't let them anywhere near the facility. And there's a facility paid for by Buffalo taxpayers. And they won't let Buffalo lawmakers inside. Little things like that. Tesla's insurance product that they put out recently to try and lower prices. There are all kinds of things going on with this company that just don't pass the smell test.
And you can be an evangelist, you can, you know, I have nothing against electric vehicles. I promise you, I'm not in the pocket of Big Oil. No one's written me a check to bash electric cars or bash Tesla in general. I'm a huge fan of electric cars. I think the future is electric cars. But that's not to say that Tesla are going to be the one to do it. And this is all without even getting into the solar roof debacle, which I suspect when this plays out in the fullest of time, that's where you'll be able to go back and talk about where this turned into a fraud.
But the Walmart lawsuit and everything that's cascading off the back of it, there's so much hair on this company. And I'm watching it unravel by the day. And I think when Tesla goes, because it, as I've said before, it's the poster child for zero-cost capital, it's the poster child for the climate change argument, it's the poster child for, you know, the millennial generation, the Robinhood investment People buying stocks because they love the companies, not because they've any experience in the stock market. It's so representative of so many things, celebrity culture, whatever you want to talk about, our society today, markets today, capitalism today. Tesla has a place in that argument.
And I think that this is why it's so important that if Tesla goes, and I fully expect it to, and perhaps in fairly short order, I think that is going to be a huge wake-up call for inexperienced investors, for people that thought that there was nothing wrong, for people that didn't think a scandal of this size could happen. I think it's all going to come out. And I think it's going to be a massive bucket of cold water thrown over the markets.
Erik Townsend: Grant, I love the way that you express that. And I couldn't agree more. I really think, as we said earlier, or I should say, as you said earlier, what we've got to do is figure out what are the signals What are the signals you look for that tell you that we're back to economic reality matters again and we're out of fantasy mode in the markets and it's time for indications that shorts are prudent across the board? I think Tesla falling would be an indication that reality has taken effect again and we're out of fantasy mode in the markets. So, it's probably an important signal to watch to tell us when it's time for game on with a big cycle that I think I think it's long overdue. Grant, it's hard for me to believe anyone anywhere doesn't know who you are and know your relationship. First, 2 Things That Make You Go Hmmm, one of the most respected newsletters in the industry. Again, listeners, there's a free issue for you in your Research Roundup email.
You can get that download. And obviously, you're one of the founders of Real Vision Television. So, for anyone who might not be familiar, please give us the backstory on what the things are that you're involved with.
Grant Williams: Thank you very much. Real Vision has been a passion project of Raoul's and mine for 5 years now. It's a platform, an online platform where we just interview the smartest investors we can find anywhere in the world and just get their thoughts on markets. It's been a hell of a ride, and we've had a lot of fun doing it. It really is something that people seem to have latched onto and really appreciate. We're very proud of that.
Things That Make You Hum is— I've been writing it for 10 years now. And it's something I write every couple of weeks. And I just talk about, as we're going to hear, gold or Tesla or Uber or government bonds or Germany, whatever it is that I find interesting and I think is important to really dig into in financial markets. I write about it and I offer my thoughts and why I think it's important. So, they're both passion projects and I love doing both of them equally dearly.
Erik Townsend: Well, Grant, I really appreciate another fantastic interview. We look forward to having you back on the program. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions Please send your questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Grant back onto the show. You know, really, while it was always interesting and I was looking forward to getting an update on gold, his views on gold. But what was interesting was when you guys started talking about the unicorns, and obviously this WeWork is such an interesting topic, and I really thought his views were really interesting. What did you take away?
Erik Townsend: Well, I always enjoy talking to Grant, but I think that, you know, as we discussed this situation with negative yielding sovereign debt and everything, I predict that financial historians will look back on this and they'll say, you know, There was this time when there was a 5,000-year low in interest rates and negative-yielding sovereign debt around the world, and everybody just acted like it was normal and nobody thought it was extraordinary.
It is extraordinary, and how it's going to be resolved, I don't know, but it's going to be really interesting to find out in the next few years. In any event, though, let's find out not in the next few years, but right now, Now, I want to get an update, Patrick, because Labor Day is behind us. This is the time of year when things tend to heat up in markets. So, what we're going to do for the next few weeks with our postgame chartbooks, folks, is we're going to focus on specific sectors, and we're going to start with currencies this week. So, Patrick, let's dive into your postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in the Research Roundup email. If you're not registered yet, just go to MacroVoices.com and click on the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, and you'll get instructions for how to register and get the download.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's dive right into chart 2. You're looking at the dollar index here, and boy, it looks to me like a series of higher highs and higher lows.
Patrick Ceresna: You took the words right out of my mouth, Erik. And what is really interesting is the dollar, in spite of a number of bears that continuously trying to call the top of the dollar index, has been in a very clear channel higher. But what's really interesting to me is we have not seen an acceleration to the upside. I mean, if you look Back in 2016 and in mid-2018, we had true breakout rallies in the dollar index as it legitimately went up, you know, 5 to 10 points higher. And so, but we haven't seen this breakout even though we're making higher highs that really seen any acceleration. But the dollar index is made up of a series of other currencies. So I wanted to just take a deeper look into understanding what's happening in the currency markets. And so I wanted to start off obviously with a currency that actually isn't in the dollar index, but it's the Chinese yuan. And on page 3, we have it there.
And we definitively have a breakout in the US dollar and obviously a breakdown in the CNY as we're seeing the Chinese PBOC weakening the currency. And that certainly has Trump all wound up. What's your thinking? Is this now a sustained new trend?
Erik Townsend: I think it is, and, you know, I would have a slightly different read on what you said going back to page 2 for just a second. It's true that we're only seeing a modest uptrend in this time frame, but if you look at the much shorter time frame, what I've seen in the charts is there have been what looked to me like just screaming, ripping rallies, like it's here we go, we've broken that critical level, we're racing to the upside. It really looks like the beginning of of just a face-ripper higher. And then the President of the United States does something completely unprecedented and extraordinary that's very dollar bearish, like start a trade war. And needless to say, under those circumstances, obviously you're going to get a pullback.
I think what's happened here is the dollar index, as you say, it's kind of a mild uptrend. It's an unstoppable uptrend, I think, because it's had so many news events that should have turned it back to the downside. And it continues to push higher anyway. But I think a lot of people have gotten scared out of this because every time the bulls get excited about, okay, here we go, here's the breakout, let's buy more on the breakout, the President of the United States does something extraordinary and we get a big knee-jerk back. People are wondering, what else could he do? What's the next trick that he might have up his sleeve? And I think that's caused people, in terms of trading the dollar index or the euro currency pair, to be a little bit skittish.
On the other hand, that same news flow is very much reaffirming of, boy, looks like we've really got a breakdown in relations with China. Trade war is on with China. And so, for that reason, I think that the breakout in the US dollar relative to the yuan is much more profound and much more focused. And I think it's because people who might have been inclined to pile into more dollar index longs are not doing so because it It makes more sense to follow where the news flow is, which is the yuan trade.
Patrick Ceresna: Right, right. And so what I also thought was really interesting, now after the euro, which I have on page 5, the British pound and yen are the 2 second and third largest positions inside the dollar index. And so the pound has obviously been incredibly weak, largely because of all the Brexit no-deal story headlines. And obviously now all the political turmoil around Boris Johnson there. And this continues to be really interesting. But what I found fascinating was the technical level from which the event occurred. So after the first initial Brexit news back in 2016, the pound sterling broke down to 1.20 on the downside, and then it recovered all the way to 1.45, and now we trade all the way back down to 1.20.
And for, for what many technicians would identify as a double bottom retest. Curious question I have: are we going to see a breakdown to fresh new lows as this turmoil continues, or is this actually going to be a major support where, uh, where the lows can come in?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, that's the operative question. And I guess what I would say is, you know, just look at this chart. That's a really important low. If we break decisively below that prior support at 1.19, whatever it It is, and close there and stay there for a while, it really starts to look very ominous for the pound, and it further strengthens the dollar case. And Patrick, I think this is all a function of the US dollar global liquidity squeeze that we've talked to Jeff Snider so much about. So, I don't know, I don't really have an opinion here as to what happens next with the pound, but what I would say is if we do break below that level, boy, you know, you're the technician What's the next support below that?
I'm not sure there is one.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I know, but I mean, I think a couple of measured moves target down to about 115. So it would be at this stage about 700, 800 pips lower if it was to reverse and break from the current levels. So it'll be interesting to see. You know, I think that if the election is moving towards another Tories victory, if everything goes through with a snap election, I mean, that's the circumstances which I think we could see that kind of a break. So it's going to be really exciting to watch what happens in the next couple months, especially as a spectator. I don't know if I'd call it exciting if you're living there. But nonetheless, I wanted to move on to the euro on page 5. And particularly what I wanted to highlight here is that when you go back to the dollar index on the chart, you saw that it traded back in 2016 and 2017 up along the 104 level on the upside on the dollar index.
And really, that came about because back in 2017, the euro was trading down near 1.05, and that's, uh, that was a major low in the euro. And this is actually one of the more interesting charts because with a 57% weighting into that dollar index, whether the US dollar index is actually going to go back to those 2016-17 highs, I think, has everything to do with the euro and whether this breakdown actually is going to get some momentum to the downside.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think this chart clearly shows how important the euro is to this strategy. And unlike the pound, the euro's got plenty of room to, to go before it gets to a triple bottom back down to that, that blue range that you've got around 1.04. So, uh, It seems to me like we've got to watch the direction of all of these pairs, but particularly, I really think that Jeff Snider is onto something with this Eurodollar system liquidity squeeze. And I think that the question that I'm most interested in is not what are the natural forces in the market, but rather, what are the external forces? What is the next Plaza Accord type event to come along? What does President Trump have up his sleeve next? The headwinds he's been throwing at the US dollar have not worked. So, if he decides to go Cat 5 hurricane, what does that mean to him? How does he affect that viewpoint, if you want to call it that?
And what tactic does he use and how does it work? I think that's the big thing to watch for. I'm convinced something's coming, but with this president, it's kind of hard to know exactly what to expect.
Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. So I wanted to move on to gold, and, uh, we're going to talk commodities probably in next week's chart book, but I felt gold— a lot of people consider it a, a currency in itself, and so I figured I'd put it into this chart book, and particularly since Grant was talking about it during the interview. And really what I wanted to highlight was, uh, this consolidation zone that happened where from essentially 2013 through 2019, we had seen the major price-volume consolidation of gold for, you know, 5 years between this $1,200 to $1,350 area. And it just is showing the technical significance of this bull market breakout that we saw in gold.
And one of the interesting technical observations that I would make is that often the highs of a major consolidation like this act now as new support. And so it is likely that even if gold was to have some sort of backfilling retracement, odds are that it will find support even in a deeper pullback as low as $1,350. But I, I personally, if I was to make a call, I don't think we're going to see gold anywhere below $1,350 on any pullback. And I would argue that it would, it would probably even have a little bit higher levels like $1,400 where lows during pullbacks might come in. What's your thinking on that?
Erik Townsend: Well, certainly I think that we could agree, and I think almost any technician would agree, if we got $1,360 again, it's time to buy. If we manage to, to get that retest. The thing is, when we got to $1,400 the first time a few weeks ago, I said, okay, watch for that pullback down to $1,360. That's where you want to buy, folks. Well, guess what? We moved up $150 from So, needless to say, gold has surprised me by how strong it's been. I'm not going to wait for $1,360 in order to start buying gold. I will be delighted to buy gold at $1,400, and if this market continues to surprise me with the strength that it's shown, maybe I'll have to start buying above that point. Clearly, if you look at this chart, it's time for some kind of pullback. The question is, how much of a pullback?
Patrick Ceresna: Exactly.
Erik Townsend: And, uh, and how do you time that? If we get 1360, it's time to, to really start buying in size though. Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: So the, the last thing I wanted to touch on was the S&P 500, Erik. So on page 7, what I did was, first of all, I want to just talk about the candle chart, which is, uh, the S&P 500 chart. And obviously today on Thursday, we had a pretty significant technical breakout out of that August consolidation. What is interesting is, is that on Charlie McElligott's note, he was talking about the big gamma magnets with huge options expirations or huge open interest, I should say, at the 2950 and the 3000 levels on the S&P, and there being that gamma influence on kind of like a magnet dragging the S&P higher. It's going to be really interesting to see whether this is just a short-term liquidity event as everyone that got very aggressively short in August. Is getting a little bit of the squeeze, and whether that is just going to be short-lived and roll over later this September. But the big tell for me was in that orange line chart that's overlapping is the Russell 2000.
And what's amazing is how much the Russell 2000 small caps are lagging this S&P with no sign of life whatsoever. And that may that to me is the first clue that maybe this S&P move is. just exactly that, some form of a liquidity event, and that the real broader market's not ready to go in a bull advance the way that the S&P may be misinterpreted in signaling.
Erik Townsend: And I think that that argument is strengthened even more if you look on the chart here at that Christmas low. You're going from a lower low on the Russell to a higher high there in the end of February, where the Russell starts lower than the S&P on this chart and ends up higher than the S&P at the end of February. So it's a bigger move to the upside. There's more momentum upside on Russell than there is S&P. And then the Russell just stops and S&P continues. And to me, this so perfectly matches with the commentary that we've heard from several people, including Brent Johnson, saying, look, what's going on here is it doesn't make a lot of sense. We're seeing equities globally definitely moving into a bear market. They're selling But the S&P has that cleanest dirty shirt in a very, very dirty laundry pile effect. And so what's happening is the S&P is the choice for people globally who need to stay invested in stocks.
It's where they're going, and it's getting an artificial boost from that. It can't last forever, but it's allowing the S&P to be stronger than everything else is.
Erik Townsend: And I think that's what's going on here. But Patrick, I want to move on to another topic, which is the TMX exchange is hosting Options Education Day in Toronto once again. You've spoken at this event before, you're speaking at it again. Give us a little bit of perspective. What are you talking about? What's the topic? It's only 2 weeks away, actually it's less than 2 weeks away, and seating is limited. So anyone who wants to attend should register with the link that's in the postgame chartbook here, or you can go to the m-x.ca website for Options Education Day in Toronto. Tell us a little bit more about what you're going to be talking about.
Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. Yeah, so I've been an instructor for the Toronto-Montreal Exchange for almost a decade, and we host these options education days across Canada. This one is in Toronto, and I'm going to be covering the topic of using options to managing a portfolio of stocks, and also a little more of a fun advanced session called Option Acrobatics. And we're going to be looking at all sorts of things like bull call spreads and calendar spreads and other things. things that traders can use. It's a great event. There's all sorts of great speakers for a whole day of, of events and lunch included in that. So anyone who's in the Toronto vicinity and can make it out next week— it's already on Saturday, September 14th— please inquire, and, and I look forward to seeing you out there.
Erik Townsend: And just one week later, Patrick, on September 21st, you'll be speaking at the All-Stars of Options at The Money Show. Tell us a little bit more about that one and how people can attend there.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, that one is The Money Show in Toronto as well, and that one is the week after. It's on the— the show goes on the 20th and 21st, and I've got all sorts of really good presentations that I'll be doing out there. So anyone in the Toronto vicinity, you can get 2 back-to-back weekends of me talking nothing but options. It's going to be a great time, so hopefully you can make out to at least one of the two, but we look forward to a great event.
Erik Townsend: And if that's not enough Patrick for you, you can also sign up for that 14-day free pass to BigPictureTrading.com and get a sense of the webinar product that Patrick offers 4 days of every single week. Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro to claim your free copy of The Many Flavors of Trend Following and subscribe to their podcast as well. You'll be glad you did, and you can also tune in for my interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen airing this weekend. For more information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo.
And if you haven't yet, be sure to register for your free account at MacroVoices.com.
Erik Townsend: The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email, which contains links to all of the best free content we can find on the internet every single week. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: In this week's Research Roundup, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Grant, as well as the link to the Things That Make You Go Hmmm newsletter that Grant offered to share with all of our listeners. There's also the, the link to the chart book that we discussed here in the postgame. There's also a really interesting CNBC interview A video link to Morgan Stanley's Michael Wilson talking about a recession hinges on the labor markets, as well as an interesting Chris Whalen article called View from the Lake: Deflation and Debt. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets, I would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free list. listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.
Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship. From bigpicturetrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth — former Dallas Federal Reserve advisor (as introduced on the show)
Peter Boockvar — Chief Investment Officer for Bleakley Advisory Group (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is a special edition of MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the premier financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. Now for this special edition of MacroVoices, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 182 was prerecorded for release on August 29th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the only podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, which I highly recommend. We're deviating from our usual show format this week in order to give our production staff a very well-deserved summer vacation.
So there won't be any market wrap or post-game segment this week. Instead, we're dedicating the entire episode to part 2 of our summer special on the future of monetary policy. This subject was inspired by the many listener requests that we've received for more content similar to the US Dollar Endgame series we ran over the 2017 Christmas holiday. For any new listeners who may have missed that super popular series, it's still available free of charge on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Just click the Timeless Series button on the black menu bar at the top of the homepage.
For this year's summer special, we've got 2 fantastic guests lined up. Peter Boockvar is a well-known analyst and frequent guest on CNBC. He's the Chief Investment Officer for Bleakley Advisory Group and the author of the popular Book Report blog. Danielle DiMartino Booth is a former Dallas Federal Reserve advisor whose book Fed Up was a bestseller. This week we're airing part 2. If you missed part 1, it's still available on our homepage at MacroVoices.com, and we suggest you start there.
This temporary show format change created something of a conundrum for us because our sponsor had already paid for a mid-roll advertisement that would normally air between the market wrap and feature interview. And as I mentioned last week, I really want to thank our sponsor, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen over at TopTradersUnplugged.com. He had paid for a mid-roll advertisement, so in theory he's entitled to have us break the interview in 2 just to make sure his ad gets put right in the middle of the episode. Niels said, no way. I'm a podcaster myself. The last thing we want to do is cut Danielle and Peter off in mid-sentence.
Erik Townsend: So I'm just going to bring you the message from Top Traders Unplugged right now before we dive into this feature interview.
This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. You often hear me say that even if I have conviction about a market or a trade, you have to listen to what the market is telling you, not what you think it should be doing. And that's exactly what trend following managers have been doing for decades with great success.
These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well researched and tested. And there's one podcast that covers trend following strategies better than any other. TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book called The Many Flavors of Trend Following, explaining how these systematic strategies can work for you. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro.
Check them out, you'll be glad you did. So without further ado, here's part 2 without commercial interruption.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, so I want to move now on to talking about inflation and deflation. And I know, Peter and Danielle, you both spend a lot of time talking about this between the two of you and have different views on, on what are the risks and where things are going. So let's start with you, Peter. What's your feelings about inflation and where we are in the market? And what are really the risks moving forward with inflation and potentially even deflationary risks?
Peter Boockvar: So it's very— most people and central bankers in particular, they look at inflation as black or white. It's either going up, it's going down. There's either inflation or there's deflation. And I believe that inflation is really in the eye of the beholder, in that you can argue, okay, we'll take the quantity of money that central banks have created. Well, that's highly inflationary, but where does it show up? Well, we know that there's been obviously massive inflation in asset prices, epic inflation in credit markets, and then on consumer prices, there's been more muted inflation. But even within that, well, what do you look at? Do you look at CPI or do you look at PCE? Do you look at the PCE or you look at the Dallas Fed trimmed mean PCE? Do you look at the CPI or the Cleveland trimmed CPI? Well, each of them measure different things. The PCE, the biggest component is healthcare. Well, healthcare, that's measuring Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement rates, which are artificially suppressed and priced lower by the government.
Well, should that be a good inflation gauge? If that's low, does that tell me that inflation is really low? Or should I look at CPI, where healthcare is a smaller part, but it's actually measuring out-of-pocket expenses? Dig deeper.
Inflation is services on one side and goods on the other side. Well, ever since in the history of the world, we've had a progression of technology, there's been goods deflation. As things get more technologically advanced and can be more efficiently made, there's a natural downturn in pricing. Well, is that a bad thing? No, that's good. So, to me, inflation is more of a cyclical event where you see a rise in goods prices that sort of matches up with persistent services inflation, and then you get a slowdown in inflation. When you get the reverse, you get a decline in goods prices because you rarely see much of a decline on the services side of the inflation equation if you're measuring healthcare correctly, not like the government does, as I said, in PCE. So, from here on out, To me, what happens with the goods side in response to the tariffs is going to be a key thing.
So who's gonna eat the tariffs? Is it the Chinese that are gonna eat the tariffs because they're gonna lower prices to US importers and they're gonna be able to offset by a weakening currency? Or are they gonna be limited in that? That will leave the US company that is literally paying the tariff to then try to offset that by higher goods prices in the US. And then you would join that with sticky services inflation, and then you all of a sudden have inflation that's higher than what people are anticipating. I think, so that's the key thing, at least right now. Where do goods prices go from here in response to these tariffs? Who is able to eat it and who is not going to be able to eat it? Who's going to have success in passing it on and who's not? And it depends. You have some companies like Walmart that said they're going to do everything they can to pass it on.
There was a furniture company in the ISM the other day that said, yeah, they're passing it on to everyone that they have.
I listen to a lot of corporate conference calls. I talk to a lot of business people, and everyone is trying to figure out a way to pass it on. And it's not all being eaten by the Chinese. So I'm worried that, yes, we've seen this drop in the recent inflation trends, but we're still running at around 2%.
The Dallas Fed trimmed mean came out a couple days ago. It was right at 2%. So this obsession with with getting to 2%. And you look where monetary policy has been driven by one number they happen to look at. And if they looked at CPI and PCE never existed, monetary policy might be quite different. So that's what gets to my point also, is it's in the eye of the beholder, how you analyze it, where the inflation ends up showing up, and also how you react to it.
And then one last thing, we talk about inflation expectations. You know, we look at the inflation breakevens, and inflation breakevens are just highly correlated to the price of oil. So, you have in every Fed statement, the Fed talking about inflation expectations, and really, it's just tied to the price of oil and other commodities.
Patrick Ceresna: And Danielle, what's your impression or counterargument to Peter?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, again, Peter and I are not on opposite ends of the spectrum. I focus on the core PCE, appreciating that the core PCE that the Fed uses is, as Peter explained, broken. And even when it does measure that other great big line item in a household's budget, housing costs, also understates it.
I nevertheless focus on the broken metric because my former colleagues at the Federal Reserve refused to focus on anything remotely closer to reality. And the reason I do focus on the core PCE is because as long as it's going to drive Fed policy, It's what we have to pay attention to. Would I ever dare tell my retired mother that inflation is running too low?
Well, not if I was within hitting distance of her, because she would slap me upside the head and say, what have you been thinking? I thought you were supposed to be some kind of an expert on these things, dear. Of course inflation's not too low. It's staring you in the face everywhere as rising at too fast of a clip.
But again, because of what I think is happening with the housing sector in particular, and I've written extensively on this subject, when you start to see things like the rate of home price appreciation has come down for 15, 16 consecutive months, again, it's still an appreciating rate of home price gains, but it is coming down. And once it starts to approach that redline and go negative, then the Fed is all of a sudden going to think that it has got like a DEFCON 1 situation on its hands, that inflation is so low and that it doesn't look like it's going to be transient or transitory in nature, and therefore they really need to do something to get out in front of it.
And when, when the doves really start to cry again, if we're in the midst of what I think is unfolding which is a slow-moving pathway to a recession than the fact that mortgage rates have come down and we haven't seen the transmission mechanism of lower rates spur a fast enough degree of purchase application activity. We've seen a ton on the refinancing side, but we really haven't seen what we would expect in terms of home purchases.
In fact, pending home sales were rising the most on the West Coast where home prices are falling. at the fastest rate.
My point is, if we start to see the stickiest form of inflation flip into deflation, if we start to see home prices come down outside of just California— and we're seeing weakness in the New York area as well, and Peter's written extensively about the SALT states and the fact that there's this exodus out of these states with high-priced housing. If you continue to see home prices come down and even fall into negative territory, I fear for the overreaction on the part of those on the FOMC as they react to this, because it's the last thing that people need is even lower interest rates when it's not the medicine that's going to cure the patient.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, do you have any insights to add to that?
Erik Townsend: You know, the question of when secular inflation comes back into the economy is beyond my pay grade. I'll leave it to Danielle and Peter's greater intellect to tell me when that might happen. What I do wanna comment on is what's gonna happen when it does happen, whenever that is. And this is really a story about preparedness. You know, one of the things that a lot of people have said is when we do get into another financial crisis situation, we have to be really careful because there's a whole generation of professional traders now working in institutions that came into the industry after 2009 and have never been through a bear market and don't know what it feels like and don't know how to navigate it because they've never had that experience.
Well, we have an entire industry which is categorically not ready to deal with the onset of secular inflation. The last time that happened was 1972. So in order to— for people who were working in the industry in 1972 have been through this before and they know what it was like. You gotta be upwards of 75 years old to be in that category. That means that everybody who works in finance read about this in a book in college and forgot about it years ago and has never been through it. It means every economic advisor to the government read about it in books and has never actually been through it themselves. So when it happens, we're going to have an entire system that is completely unprepared for it. And I think that the nuance between just straight inflation and stagflation, which I think is much more likely, is going to trip us up.
And a lot of people are not gonna know what to make of it.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: You know, if you imagine a trader who's never been in a bear market before suddenly being confronted with one, we've got an entire industry and an entire political system that has forgotten what the onset of secular inflation is like. So, when it comes, and I have no idea when that is, we are not ready.
Patrick Ceresna: Peter or Danielle, any comment on that?
Peter Boockvar: I agree. And it also gets back to when you think about the bond bubble that central bankers have created, And then they root for higher inflation that would implode the bubble. You know, God forbid we get that higher inflation scenario.
Patrick Ceresna: So I want to move now on to talking about financial repression and this idea of global debt, because, you know, when you look at some of the numbers coming out showing, you know, the $250 trillion of global debt out there, the massive growth in the global debt as a percentage of GDP, the $13 trillion of negative yielding debt that exists out there, we get to the scenario of how do governments deal with all of this debt, right? And of course, you hear a number of doomsayers that'll come out there, the idea that governments could just explicitly default on this debt, or a very common one is that they'll just inflate the debt away. But what we are currently experiencing is, in my view, is that a period of significant financial repression. This idea where, you know, they keep these nominal interest rates lower than they would otherwise prevail to reduce the government's interest expense, contribute to their deficit reduction, and a way of actually potentially liquidating the debt by repressing, creating negative real yields on interest.
And so this is where I wanted to sort of talk about how does this play out? Because repression does need bursts of inflation. But we were talking about this idea of, of they're gonna— they have been suppressing interest rates.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: And Danielle, I know you've talked about the fact that they changed the language from zero bound to effective lower bound and this idea that we are going back to potentially to zero interest rates. So this is where I want to go. So Danielle, what's your thinking of the change in the language in the Fed? Are we going back to zero? Is financial repression still a reality over the next few years?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: So I think that— I think if we could be a fly on the walls of the Eccles Building at the Federal Reserve Board right now, that there has to be a tremendous amount of furious debate. I mean, we're talking about academics gone wild here because the idea of negative interest rates works as long as there is one great big country with a reserve currency status that still has positive interest rates that makes all financial modeling on planet Earth work. That gives every other country access to positive interest rate financing, that allows some aspect of the global financial system to remain on solid footing.
I'm not sure if the people— I'm not sure if the PhDs at the Fed can wrap their heads around this, but I can tell you Jay Powell can. He understands this dynamic.
What happens, for example, If you put a negative interest rate into the Black-Scholes option pricing model, it will tell you that that put or call's value is infinity. All of the models collapse under the auspices of negative interest rates. The reason it's worked offshore, the reason the academics have been proven to be brilliant and correct, is because of the United States standing firm and having positivity in our interest rate structure.
If that falls apart, you're talking about the collapse of the banking system of the United States.
Go back to Peter's comment that Japanese stocks are down 90% from their highs. This simply would not work in our system. We would have to go back and, to borrow my buddy Jim Bianco's characterization, we would have to go back and recreate the banking and financial systems of the United States from scratch. under a negative interest rate regime simply because the rest of the world would lose an outlet, a conduit to which to find relief from their own negative interest rates.
Patrick Ceresna: Peter, uh, what's your take on this all?
Peter Boockvar: I mean, I, I've looked at negative interest rates as just being poison because it's a tax. It's a tax on capital that somebody has to eat. And right now the banks are obviously eating it. But now you have a situation where UBS is going to start passing that on to their customers, and that customers are now going to be penalized for depositing money with UBS. And as long as it's a tax, it becomes a drag on capital. And because it's costing banks money every year, and some estimates are $7, $8 billion, it doesn't sound like much on an annual basis, but considering that it's been going on for 5 years now, banking— European banks and Japanese banks are bleeding capital. Plus, then you destroy your yield curve. You essentially kill your bond market, and you're not going to get faster growth. You're going to get fucking trash.
And if the banking system is supposed to be the transmission mechanism of this policy, but then you're bleeding to death that transmission mechanism, then you are not really having accommodative policy. You have restrictive policy.
So, I argue that the BOJ and ECB are now running restrictive policy and have been ever since they went to negative interest rates. And I agree with Danielle that it'd be very difficult even to pull off here because the US money market industry is $3 trillion plus. You don't have that sort of equivalent in Europe and Japan. You would destroy the money market industry. And that alone would cause such a credit crunch and all that commercial paper out there that you would immediately go into recession. So I just don't think negative interest rates is even close to a possibility.
Now, in terms of one of the things you mentioned early on of how governments can default or not. Well, negative real interest rates is essentially a default. As long as you're earning less than the rate of inflation, the government is chipping away at your wealth and your standard of living, and that is essentially a default.
So governments have been defaulting for the last 10 years in terms of the money that they owe their lenders. So I'm very much against negative interest rates and think it's— we're going to look back and say it's the dumbest economic policy in the history
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, do you have something to add to that?
Erik Townsend: You know, I'll draw a really crazy analogy because I think these are absolutely historic times, and I think that most people are not recognizing how historic the events of the last few years have been. And I think we'll look back at this period in history and just say, oh my gosh, I can't believe that such significant things happened and I didn't even realize at the time. But my crazy analogy is this.
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, and that they are endowed with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Those words were written and signed by slave owners, but at the time, it didn't feel hypocritical or ironic to anyone that the men who wrote those words, the white men who wrote those words, owned Black slaves as property, because at the time, that was just considered normal and And they didn't think it really contradicted what they were saying in the Constitution. And I think we've gotten to this point where everybody's acting just because it's sort of like the frog boiling in water thing. We've gotten to this point where everybody in finance, you know, at first there were the people that said it's impossible, you can't have negative interest rates, that's not possible. And then we've got them and it's, oh, I guess it is possible.
And okay, let's move on. People are not, in my opinion, really absorbing the historic profound significance of this. And particularly, we have economists who are in positions of advising governments saying, look, we need negative interest rates because we need to stimulate the economy and get people spending again. So all those values that we were brought up with as kids, like save some money for a rainy day, and savings and investment is prudent, responsible behavior that makes society a better place if everybody takes care of themselves. That's out the window, and it's like, look, we've got a whole bunch of people that are acting intelligently and not spending what little money they have. They're saving it. We've got to do something to force them to spend it for the public good of everybody. That is so absurd, but that is the policy. That is the motivation that's leading us to negative interest rates, is policymakers believe it's a necessary step to stimulate spending.
And I think it's just as absurd as slave owners signing those words in the Constitution. It doesn't make sense.
Patrick Ceresna: So what I wanted though is, okay, you're suggesting that in that one angle, but what I look at it is, is that it's that Luke Gromen argument that we've heard, which is that it's the interest that it takes to service the outstanding debt and that cross-section of when the federal, US federal tax revenues simply won't be able to even service that interest on that debt. The idea of suppressing interest rates is not about necessarily being a stimulant, but it's even just about the idea that the government can continue to function this way. And then this is where obviously where MMT comes in in some degree or another. But how much of that is in your mind the current trend to much lower interest rates? Is it not just about the ability for governments to service their existing debts?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I didn't mean to end there. That's just— I think that we're in incredibly historic times and we've gotten to this point where We have to realize that, as Danielle said earlier, the entire design of the financial system is based on these academic concepts like risk-free return. Well, now we've got a risk-free premium, the tax, as Peter described it, of holding risk-free assets. And it does create a cash hoarding incentive. There is a risk of a run on the entire fractional reserve banking system if negative interest rates get negative enough to incentivize people to hoard cash.
Peter Boockvar: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: All sorts of things could go wrong that have all kinds of systemic risks, and I think that they're underappreciated. But I want to leave it to Danielle and Peter to, to opine on this. Danielle, what's your take?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, so, you know, you look back to the number one selling household item in Japan, and I know Peter's laughing right now, but the number one selling household item in Japan when negative interest rates were first imposed were household safes. So this starts to bring on the discussion of cryptocurrencies and capital flight. And discussions that you would think would be centered in a third world country.
And this whole idea of penalizing savers for holding money in bank accounts. And this is kind of the Ken Rogoff school of thought that if you insist upon keeping the money in the bank, you're only going to get $0.97 on that dollar. We're going to give you a haircut. And therefore people take all of their money out of the bank and hide it under the mattress or put it in a safe.
You know, Erik, to your point, you've actually inspired me. I'm going to have to go write about this. You know, I'm going to have to go back and study my founding fathers because this is a right. This is a right that we as Americans hold true and we should hold true. And to be pushed in one direction or another, I think would hopefully, hopefully get so much scrutiny by some politician that it would be prevented.
The only line that I could see, the only line that I could see drawn would be that of bankers and banking lobbyists saying, wait a minute, you can't do this. On the other hand, I just don't know in the current environment any politician who would stand up for the banks, no matter how much money they threw at them, given the animus and given the fact that wealth has become so concentrated in this country that there probably wouldn't be anybody to stand in the way of pushing these through. Even though Janet Yellen herself said that she wasn't quite sure that the Fed had the authority to impose negative interest rates.
Erik Townsend: Hang on, I want to qualify what you said. Do you really mean that you don't think that any politician would support the banks behind the scenes, or do you just mean in the public eye they need to appear to be not supporting the banks?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Oh, absolutely in the public eye. I think that taking I think that taking millions and millions of lobbying dollars from Wall Street is the way that the Beltway functions. I think that the Beltway itself would crumble.
Erik Townsend: So the politicians, we agree, are still working for the bankers. They just can't admit it publicly.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: They can't admit it publicly, but if we agree that Modern Monetary Theory can potentially be launched, somebody's going to have to be on the losing end of this. There are 2 parallel discussions that go hand in hand, negative interest rates and modern monetary theory. Modern monetary theory presumably assumes that borrowing costs are zero, or even better, that the government gets paid to borrow.
So you cannot have one run parallel without the other. You will not satisfy the, the people who are proponents of modern monetary theory and the bankers at the same time. It's impossible.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, so I want to move on to the US dollar and talk about the idea of where the US dollar is going. Clearly, we've heard the mixed messages from the administration where Kudlow and Mnuchin have been suggesting that there could be— or still supporting the idea of a strong dollar. But clearly, Trump is looking for the dollar to be lower and viewing a lot of different countries as currency manipulators taking a competitive advantage on the US. And then when we hear Kyle Bass coming out and saying that that if the Chinese free-floated their currency, that it would be as much as 30% lower because of their current account deficits and fiscal deficits that are running over there. I'm getting a lot of these mixed messages as to where the dollar's going next. What's your opinions on the dollar? Let's start with you, Danielle.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, look, I tweet out constantly, #RaceToTheBottom. And the thing about this is We're beyond a day late and a dollar short when it comes to labeling China as a currency manipulator. In fact, we're probably about 12 or 13 years late. So this is entering the realm of ridiculous. If there's an area of the world where the currency has stayed surreally strong, and Peter's written about this extensively, it's Europe, where the euro is about 23%, 22%, 23% overvalued vis-à-vis the dollar.
But once these things get started, and, and this is, this is kind of my bottom line on this, it is impossible to, to bring the train back into the station. Currency wars, by their very definition, mean that you, you don't have one shot across the bow that is not answered. Every move must be answered on the other side. And I think that that is why Even in Beijing, following the the labeling of currency manipulator, the authorities came out almost immediately and decided to back down from that seven handle on the yuan, so to speak, because there are no winners in currency wars. And as long as we have a ten-year yield that is positive. And world investors say, "Gee, should I invest in Greece or in the United States to get that yield?" There will be a rush into the dollar, and we will be constantly fighting a losing battle in trying to get it to weaken.
Unless some way, somehow, the administration thinks that it can it can recruit the Fed to work hand in hand with Treasury to weaken the dollar, I just don't see that happening unless there is some way of. of making the Fed do this under duress.
Patrick Ceresna: Peter, any comments?
Peter Boockvar: So, I try to look at it against different currencies. And yes, we've seen strong dollar rallies against the Turkish lira and the Argentinian peso and British pound. And now we're seeing the rally against the Chinese yuan. But the Euro-heavy dollar index, Today is at 97.60-ish and change. 4 years ago, the dollar index is at 97.80. So dollar index has really done nothing. It's obviously done nothing against the yen. So where the dollar comes from here, I think, is going to be very idiosyncratic.
If Brexit somehow gets resolved, the pound is going to roar higher against the dollar. And I'm sure it's going to take the euro with it.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Yeah.
Peter Boockvar: I think that the dollar certainly can continue to rally against the Chinese yuan, but I'm not so convinced that it's going to continue to rally against other Asian currencies. I mean, the dollar itself has its own challenges, and whether that's exploding fiscal deficits that are now running $1 trillion a year plus, and God forbid where it's going to go when we go into a downturn. But now we have the Fed that's going to be easing a lot more than all these other central banks. And I always like to go back to the euro when really measuring The health of the dollar.
I mean, you cannot throw more stuff against the wall and against the euro than what the ECB has done and what the European region has done. Anemic growth, sclerotic welfare system, negative interest rates, massive QE, a central bank that's going to try to get even deeper with negative interest rates, a collapsing banking system, and the euro still hangs in. Between this 110, 115 level. It just refuses to break. And that's partly because they have a current account surplus with us. So there's more euros going in than going out while we have these exploding deficits. So the dollar has a problem. And the only reason why it's rallied against certain countries is because those countries have a bigger problem than we do. But I think there are other countries that don't— that have less of a problem than we do, that the dollar is going to have difficulty rallying against.
I think the net result is, in trying to figure this out, and getting back to what Erik said earlier, I'm pretty confident that the currency that's going to win out in this environment is going to be gold, and silver is going to go up with it. So instead of trying to figure out where's the dollar going to rally against, I'm pretty confident that that and all these other fiat currencies are going to fall relative to the price in gold and silver over the next couple of years.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Amen to that, Peter.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, do you have anything that you want to put in on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Me have something to say on the dollar, Patrick? You know better than to ask. I think it is incredibly complex and intricate and hard to gauge in the short term. In the long term, though, it's much easier to understand where we're ultimately headed. The US dollar has been the world's global reserve currency since 1944, and that creates a tremendous artificial demand for dollars as well as for dollar-denominated sovereign bonds. And that demand had a tremendous amount to do with the strength of the dollar. And for all the negative things that you might say about the US government or the US dollar or the US economy or what have you, it's still the safety trade for most international investors. It is still the world's global reserve currency. And a thing that I don't think a lot of analysts really appreciate as much as they should is that global reserve currency is not a binary switch that's either on or off.
The transition from the pound sterling to the dollar didn't just happen at the flip of a switch at Bretton Woods. It really was a transition that occurred with both currencies being parallel global reserve currencies for about 20 years before it eventually became the dollar by treaty at Bretton Woods.
And I think that as the US dollar— and now, as Robert Triffin pointed out way back in the 1950s, No reserve currency can last forever. I don't know when it ends, but someday the US dollar's hegemony over the rest of the global monetary system has to not change overnight, but it has to fade out. And when it does, that diminished demand that we're so used to enjoying, the exorbitant privilege that we have of being able to monetize deficit spending because of all of the artificial demand for US dollar-denominated sovereign bonds, All of that is going to go away, and it doesn't go away overnight. It's a slow fade. But if you look at what happened to the pound sterling after Bretton Woods, it was a slow fade, but it was a really, really deep loss of value. So it's all coming, and I think Luke Gromen has the endgame exactly right. I think Luke might be a little bit early with how it happens.
I agree with Peter that gold is going to be the really clear benefactor, because as Danielle says, we're going to be in a race to the bottom, competitive devaluation, which means dollar relative to other currencies is just a question of who happens to be leading in the race right at this moment. But everybody's racing for the bottom. Gold will be the ultimate benefactor, and that's the reason that you've got to own gold in the next decade. But as far as what happens in the short term, we have right now a global US dollar liquidity squeeze. It's a really serious issue. And it could add to strengthening the dollar dramatically from here. So, you know, maybe that's that squeeze into the blow-off top. But I think Brent Johnson's arguments that we could get to a new all-time high in the dollar index before this is eventually over and the dollar follows the pound sterling's path into oblivion, it's not something that happens over quarters.
It's something that happens over decades. And exactly when it's going to start and where you want to be positioned. The only thing that's really clear to me is in the next decade especially, you got to own gold.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, and I think the flip side of what you're saying, and I happen to agree with you, Erik, is that, that people who think that, that inflation cometh, and I think we're all pretty much in agreement that if some of these MMT type of policies get implemented, that we are going to get inflation.
But I think that the stop along the way is going to be a 10-year bond yield that's lower than anybody could have envisioned and lower than even the lows of this cycle. And I don't think people, you know, some of the sell-side banks are starting to come around to the fact that we could certainly break 165, hit 150. But I'm saying there's the possibility that we actually break the 135 level. And I'm not trying to be hyperbolic. There's just only so much limited supply of this when the world is rushing in all at the same time because Because of a very mechanistic dynamic that is going on in the background while we're on our way, just the same as any other horse in a glue factory, to the slaughter.
Erik Townsend: Danielle, how low can we go? Because I remember when the German Bund, the 3-month paper, went negative yield, one of the first comments that people made was, well, one thing that would be absolutely impossible would be to get to the point where the, say, the 10-year yield is negative, because that's not possible. And it took a good year or 2 before it happened. At that point, when that impossibility happened, the next comment was, well, the 30-year, it's completely impossible. Well, guess what? Now it's happened. So, where is the limit for the US dollar? Is there any reason to think that we can't see the entire US Treasury curve negative the way the German Bund curve is?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, again, I think this is the beggar-thy-neighbor type of argument. Somebody on planet Earth has to have positive yielding interest rates, or your entire financial system is going to collapse under its own weight of negativity. Somebody has to have an outlet. Somebody has to have some curve in their yield curve, or I think this entire experiment fails.
Peter Boockvar: I think as long as the Fed doesn't lower the overnight rate to below zero, we won't see negative rates anywhere on the US curve. I still think that that 1.30-ish 10-year yield that we saw right after Brexit is going to be— that is going to hold, and that in light of everything going on, we're not going to go down to those levels in 10-year. You know, it's conventional thinking that we're just going to have the same yield curve as what we've seen overseas. I just I just don't think it's going to happen.
I have no question that the Fed is going to cut the short rate back to zero, but I don't think they're going to be able to drag the 10-year down to those levels.
Erik Townsend: You prefaced your statements, Peter, by saying, if they don't set a policy rate negative. Does that mean that you're predicting that they won't? And if not, why not?
Peter Boockvar: I'm highly confident that we will not see negative interest rates in the US. As I said earlier, I think the Fed will learn that they will blow up the US money market industry and do major damage to this financial system if they go negative interest rates. And I think that they will be smart enough to see the experience of the European Central Bank and the Bank of Japan.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. So I want to go back to gold. And Peter, you've brought in the idea that you're very bullish gold and silver, and I recently saw you You put up a chart that overlaid gold against the global aggregate amount of negative yielding debt, and you certainly are positioning bullish. But in your view, this breakout that occurred on gold, what was the initial catalyst here? And do you really believe that this is definitely the start of the new bull market, or is there still room for this to be a false start?
Peter Boockvar: So for full disclosure and perspective, you know, I've been bullish since 2000. Which means that I had a nice 12-year run, and I've had 7 years of bear market. So I've been on both sides and have been following it closely. And during those 7 years, the gold market has teased us into thinking, okay, this is the beginning of the bull again. This is the beginning. And then it would rally, and then it would fail. It would rally, it would fail. Rally, it would fail.
And when I did the last Real Vision, I felt like, well, this is something that is more Real, and that this is not going to fail because I think that we we sort of turned the needle on on on what the Fed was going to do, and all of a sudden you had gold trading well even with rallies in the dollar. And then you had this this this breakout in negative yielding interest rates where we know it's now it's about fifteen trillion, which is about a quarter of all sovereign and corporate bonds.
So here you have. So you have a bond which used to be an asset, now is technically a liability because of the loss to the owner of it. And gold is now a positive yielding security compared to these negative yielding bonds. And then you throw in the technical aspect of getting above this $1,350, $1,375, and all of a sudden it came together.
To me, the base case on gold was Fed's raising interest rates, quantitative tightening, US economy's doing better. Fed is far and away tighter and moving along on their tightening cycle compared to every other central bank. The dollar's gonna rip higher, so gold. And then all of a sudden, gold stopped going down when the dollar rallied. And then at least against the dollar index, the dollar sort of stopped rallying. Going into 2013, QE infinity for the gold bulls, and this is gonna be the blow-off.
There's a time to own it, there's a time not to own it. And I can't wait to sell my gold. I just don't think it's yet. So going into 2013, QE infinity.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Peter Boockvar: This is gonna be the blowoff. Gold's gonna go to $2,500, $3,000. Printing money. ECB's printing. BOJ's printing. And all of a sudden, gold collapsed. And it was because there was faith in the Fed. It was faith that the QE was really just to keep this cycle going and that it was gonna work.
And it was not— we weren't worried. We weren't talking recession in late 2012, early 2013. It was just growth was sort of mediocre and QE was meant to sort of kickstart it. Well, now we're entering into another easing cycle. Obviously, it's not QE, it's rate cuts instead. But this is actually in response to what is now a growing global slowdown. So the circumstances are different, and this easing will continue, I believe. And does it get to QE? Yes or no? I don't know. But it's going to be an easing cycle that's going to to lift gold. But most importantly. Gold is rallying against all currencies right now. And also lastly, you have the fall in real rates. And gold has very correlated not just to the negative yielding interest rate situation, but has very correlated to falling real rates, which obviously they're tied together. But that's been a bull case for gold also.
So I do think that December 2015, the bull market began, which ironically was just at the beginning of a rate hiking cycle. Counterintuitive to a lot of people that were bearish on gold. And now we are about 40% higher. And if I'm right that it is a bull market that started then and is now getting another wind behind it, then typically the new bull market takes out the highs of the previous bull market. And I do expect that over the next year or 2 and then some.
Patrick Ceresna: Danielle, how about your views on gold?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, so, you know, for the rest of my career, I think I'll have post-traumatic stress syndrome from being a bureaucrat inside the Fed for almost a decade. I don't think that's ever going away. And that means that you never forget how correlations feel when they align, and you never get over that, that, that kind of shock factor. And so I'm no gold bug, and people know that I'm no gold bug, but I look at it as being the ultimate hiding place where you want to be when the confidence bubble, as Peter says, bursts, when we finally figure out that the omnipotence of central bankers is an illusion, I think that there's exactly one place that's going to shield the rest of your portfolio from correlations aligning to one in an absolute sense, and that is gold.
And that is why I have taken Peter's guidance and in the last year personally gotten in myself. I don't mind being early, but I certainly do mind being wrong and unprepared. And I think that that is how investors should approach gold regardless of their feel for whether or not it could ever displace a fiat currency.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, you have anything else to add?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I've owned gold since 2007 and have a core position in it. And I have long said that in the endgame, gold is going to be not just something that you want But the asset that you have to have. And for all the reasons that Danielle just described, it's the one safe hiding place left. And so I think it's incredibly important. Now, I've also, on a speculative basis, I was short gold from 2011 to, I don't remember, probably 2016 or '17. I ended up covering my shorts at $1,180 the first time that we got to $1,180.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Wow.
Erik Townsend: Since then, I have said, you know, I'm holding my core position, but as far as speculative leveraged money in gold, I was holding off before this breakout because I thought that there's a really strong argument for a US dollar breakout, and I still think that that argument exists. Now, once it happens, President Trump may go to extraordinary measures to arrest it. It seems like he's willing to— Yeah. Ignore all of his advisors and make policy decisions unilaterally in some cases. And that would be the biggest risk to that view. But I still think the US dollar breakout to 104 at least, and perhaps higher, should create some kind of headwind for gold. But in the face of this recent breakout, which was a very, very critical level at somewhere between 1350 and 1377, depending on how you measure the technical That cannot be ignored. So what I would hope for at this point is if we see a technical correction back down to that $1,350 to $1,377 level, I would be a speculative buyer there in addition to my core position.
Now, of course, you know, I had my chance when, when gold was recently $1,190 or whatever it got down to a few months ago. At that point, I thought the US dollar was gonna win. I was wrong. Happy to admit that I'm wrong.
Peter Boockvar: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: At this point, I'm no longer looking to fade gold. I'm looking for where is the buy-on-dip opportunity. I'm not going to chase it up here, though. I think we've got to have some kind of technical correction. Certainly, if somebody doesn't own any gold, maybe buying some here makes sense just so you don't get completely left behind. But if you're looking at speculative interest in addition to a core holding, or particularly if you're going to use leverage in that speculative interest beyond a core holding, then I think there's probably gonna be a better opportunity to buy at a lower level, still coming in a technical correction.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. So finally, I wanna move on to the ECB and I wanna talk about Europe. I mean, we're at a stage where we are probably seeing some of the deepest negative interest rates we've ever seen in Europe. And at the same time, Draghi is ending his term and he's gonna pass the baton over to Christine Lagarde. And I really wanted to get your impressions as to what this means for Europe and how you think this all plays out. So why don't we start with you, Danielle?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, I think that putting Christine Lagarde in this position, I mean, there's no, there's no worse position in the world after Janet Yellen's that you could inherit. Well, maybe Kuroda's in the running, that you could inherit, you know, aside from Mario Draghi. I'm sure that he has literally got a countdown clock, or at least Mrs. Draghi does, who apparently hates Frankfurt and is ready to get back to Rome, thank you. But I'm sure he's got a countdown clock to Halloween and he's going to be out there trick-or-treating, celebrating the fact that he is out of the ECB, even though he's going to have to lower interest rates further into negative territory before he even gets to leave. So he doesn't get to save face.
But why is Christine Lagarde being brought into the European Central Bank? And why from the International Monetary Fund? I don't think you can speak of the two separately. The IMF knows that the global economy is a ticking time bomb, and that all of the money printing that was done after the financial crisis is ending up being a gigantic bandaid, and securing adequate funding. For the IMF, for what is to come, is absolutely front and center for making sure that the euro experiment does not fail under its own weight.
And don't, don't get me wrong, the IMF has asked the United States to whip out the checkbook. And boy, I'm sure that there's a nice warm reception for that one in the White House. But barring that, given the cesspool known as Italy, that appears to be sinking into recession, given the fact that Germany appears to be sinking into recession. So you're talking about the 2 opposite ends of the fiscal spectrum there. What could the solution possibly be outside of bringing in a maverick, bringing in a big thinker, and bringing in somebody who can launch a euro bond to thereby top off what the IMF needs in terms of its funding, which is probably upwards of $500 billion or more at this point?
Patrick Ceresna: Peter, how about you? What's your take on what's happening in Europe and how this will play out?
Peter Boockvar: Yeah, I mean, I think that's what Lagarde is going to go for, is focus more on the fiscal side. But she's still left holding the bag of this negative interest rate environment. I mean, negative interest rates is not a sustainable forever policy. It has to end at some point. And obviously, who knows when? I am interested because internally within the ECB, they They can't get around how to mitigate the current level of negative interest rates. Now, obviously, mitigating is you just get rid of negative interest rates, but we know the damage that that would do.
And I'm wondering if, when Lagarde takes over, if they can't come to an agreement on how to mitigate negative interest rates, that maybe instead of lowering interest rates further, maybe they just rely more on this TLTRO, long-term refinancing option, as a way to help the banks.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Peter Boockvar: Which I think would be a good idea compared to going deeper into negative interest rates. But can you imagine what the bond market reaction is going to be if the ECB does not change their deposit rate from -40 basis points to, let's just call it -50 or -60? It'll be an eruption. And that's just by keeping interest rates where they are.
So I think that you can think, we can talk big picture about what Lagarde will do, but I think there's a, there, there's an imminent decision that is not as easily made as the markets are seeming it to be if the ECB can't figure out how to mitigate this negative interest rate environment.
Because again, to what I said earlier in the interview, you know, the banks are bleeding and you can just see it in their stocks. And imagine just the ECB residing over a failure in banks, not because they have bad loans that they can't service, but because of the ECB themselves, their own regulator has destroyed their profitability and they have no margin to cover their, their cost structure.
So Lagarde's been on board with everything that the ECB has done up to this point. If you just watch her public comments, but from here on out, it gets very difficult to pull off what they wanna pull off. I mean, people don't understand that at the peak of QE, the ECB was buying 7 times net issuance out of the European bond market on the sovereign side, the Fed was never really more than 25%.
So you can't replicate that, because even if they enlarge the capital key from, call it, a third to 50%, there's still not enough German bonds out there for you to even get there.
So we're about to experience the end of the road in terms of ECB easing, just as we've reached the end of the road with respect to the BOJ easing. And I think she's going to have a big problem on her hands. in presiding over, at some point, some revolt and some unwind that to me is inevitably going to happen during her tenure. One last thing, let's just say she's successful on the fiscal side and she generates quicker growth and higher inflation. Well, then she blows up the European bond market.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Peter is absolutely right. I would add to this, however, that she's also got Brexit to contend with. So, this is— I mean, she is stepping into some serious conflicts here. And the Germans appear to be trying to stand their ground when it comes to offering up big fiscal relief. But just listen to what Peter's described about the European banking system and what imposing deeper negative interest rates can do to, you know, a bank like Deutsche Bank, even if there's tiering as what has been suggested. So I do not envy Christine Lagarde on any level.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, you have some opinions on Christine as well, but particularly in In terms of her views on digital currency. What was on your mind there?
Erik Townsend: Well, as some of our listeners know, I wrote a book last year, Patrick, called Beyond Blockchain: The Death of the Dollar and the Future of Digital Currency. And the essential thrust of the book is my prediction is that the ultimate resolution to Triffin's dilemma will be the replacement of the US dollar as the world's global reserve currency with a digital currency, which is government-issued. Now, that could be the US government, or it could be some other government. I don't know. But the thing that I think most of the crypto world is completely missing, they think about digital currency in the sense of these cryptocurrencies, which were invented by libertarian, borderline anarchists with the goal of frustrating and upsetting governments. I think it's completely unrealistic to think that Bitcoin is going to be the new global reserve currency. I think that's nonsense, in fact. But what I think the crypto community misses is the inventions of distributed ledger and double-spend-proof digital cash have— they benefit government far more than they benefit anyone else.
So the reconfiguration of digital currency so that it's not cryptocurrency designed to prevent monetary policy from operating on the currency, which is the way Bitcoin is designed, But it is a new generation of central bank-issued digital currency, which delivers just profound advances. We could advance the international monetary system more in the next 20 years than the central banking establishment has advanced it in the last 500 years, simply by implementing new high-tech monetary policy tools that are possible in a digital currency system.
That's what my book is about. Now, While everybody else in the central banking world, Mark Carney making just astonishingly ignorant public statements about Bitcoin, Christine Lagarde was the one voice who stood up, ironically, on the very day that my book was released, and said, hey guys, we need to be looking at central bank-issued digital currencies. And I think it was Christine Lagarde who coined the acronym CBDC, central bank digital currency. So she's clearly a pioneer. She's one of the very few people in central banking who gets it and sees the picture. And she's taking over what probably is the 2nd most powerful central bank in the world. That potentially, you know, you think about what politicians do, they wanna have a big win while they're in office. Is she going to be the pioneer that takes the ECB toward a direction of leadership in the digital currency revolution that I've predicted over the next 20 years?
I have no idea, but I'll be watching really closely. She certainly is somebody who gets it and understands it. What I've done is I've put together, because my book made a number of predictions that have already come true, but there are also a lot of things like Facebook's Libra that I did not anticipate.
So I have developed a new 2-part video series specifically intended for central bankers and other policymakers, explaining to them what they're missing and what they need to be paying attention to as the digital currency revolution really kicks into gear and why Facebook is bad news for humanity that needs to be stopped. That 2-part video series will already have been released by the time this episode airs, and you can find it at MacroVoices.com/video or on our MacroVoices YouTube channel. So look to those 2 videos. I think it's close to 2 hours between the 2 videos going really deep on this subject. So I'll leave it there. But what am I looking at?
Peter Boockvar: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: In terms of Christine Lagarde, I'm going to be specifically watching what she does relative to central bank-issued digital currency in her new role as head of the ECB.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: To Erik's point, you know, the 3 countries that rolled out cryptocurrencies, the pioneers, if you will, were Venezuela, China, and Russia. So Lagarde is definitely grounded in understanding that cryptocurrencies are going to be some aspect of the future. Financial system. And, you know, the time to look at a Fed coin, I'm sure, has come and gone. I'm sure it's being explored internally at the Federal Reserve. But when you consider the 3 first countries out of the gate, then you have to come to an understanding that electronic currencies will become a matter of national security and have to be understood in terms of how they're going to interact with other countries and within the countries in which they are deployed.
Erik Townsend: That concludes part 2 of our summer special. Today's episode was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy of The Many Flavors of Trend Following and subscribe to their podcast as well. You'll be glad you did. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo.
We'll be back to our regular show format next week on September 5th. Until then, for the MacroVoices Podcast Network, I'm Erik Townsend.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteers. Volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily Reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and host Erik Townsend shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth — former Dallas Federal Reserve advisor (as introduced on the show)
Peter Boockvar — Chief Investment Officer for Bleakley Advisory Group (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is a special edition of MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the premier financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. Now for this special edition of MacroVoices, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 181 was prerecorded for release on August 22nd, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the only podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, which I highly recommend. We're deviating from our usual format this week in order to give our production staff a very well-deserved summer vacation, so there won't be any market wrap or postgame segment this week. Instead, we're dedicating the entire episode to the first half of a 2-part summer special on the future of monetary policy. This subject was inspired by the many listener requests that we've received for more content similar to the US Dollar Endgame series that we ran over the 2017 Christmas holiday. For any new listeners who may have missed that super popular series, which is still as relevant today as the day it was recorded, it's They're still available free of charge on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Just click the Timeless Series button on the black menu bar at the top of the homepage.
For this year's summer special, we're going to take a deep dive into monetary policy, not just where we've been, but where we're headed. We've got 2 fantastic guests lined up. Peter Boockvar is a well-known analyst and frequent guest on CNBC.
Announcer: Hi, everyone.
Erik Townsend: He's the Chief Investment Officer for Bleakley Advisory Group and the author of the popular Boock Report blog. Danielle DiMartino-Booth is a former Dallas Federal Reserve advisor whose book Fed Up was a bestseller. Danielle thinks that we're headed for negative interest rates in the United States, but Peter thinks that outcome is extremely unlikely. They disagree on quite a few other points as well, and that will make for an interesting exchange. I'll be joining Peter and Danielle in one of the panelists for this series, and Patrick Ceresna will be the overall moderator and emcee.
This week we're airing part 1 of this 2-part series. Part 2 will air next week on August 29th. We'll return to our normal show format starting on September 5th, when we'll have a market wrap feature interview and postgame segment as per normal. This temporary show format created something of a conundrum for us because our sponsor had already paid for a mid-roll advertisement, which would normally air between the market wrap and feature interview. We thought the only option was going to be to break up the interview and put an ad in the middle of it, but when our sponsor Niels Kaastrup-Larsen over at TopTradersUnplugged.com got wind of it, he said, no way. Niels said, look, I'm a podcaster myself, and the last thing that we should do here is to piss off the whole audience by cutting Danielle and Peter off in mid-sentence just for an ad. He said, look, just put my sponsor message wherever you can fit it, and let's give the audience what they want.
So I'm going to bring you the message from Top Unplugged now and get it out of the way before we dive into this
Erik Townsend: fantastic interview.
This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. You often hear me say that even if I have a conviction about a market or a trade, that you have to listen to what the market is telling you, not what you think it should be doing. And that's exactly what trend following managers have been doing for decades with great success. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well-researched and tested. And there's one podcast that covers trend following strategies better than any other— TopTradersUnplugged.com.
And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book called The Many Flavors of Trend Following, explaining exactly how these systematic strategies can work for you. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro. Check them out, you'll be glad you did. I really want to thank Niels at Top Traders Unplugged for caring more about keeping MacroVoices focused on you, our listeners, rather than getting the best possible ad placement. So without further ado, here's part 1 of our summer special with no commercial interruptions.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: So I want to start this conversation with the FOMC statement and the rate cut that occurred. And Danielle, you were on our show on the All-Stars episode before the FOMC meeting, and you talked about this as a historic rate cut and that potentially it was the onset of a potential new currency war, which you completely nailed. It was, it was a great call that you made. But now that this is now rearview mirror, what's your impression on the reactions after the FOMC and what are we What are we looking at here going into the September meetings?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, I think we have to keep in mind what all currency wars entail and the fact that there are, there are not just 2 players here. This is not isolated to China and the United States. No matter what happens between the 2 countries, whether it's South Korea you're talking about, whose stock market has suffered tremendously this year, or the events that have been underway in Hong Kong for some time, Or China's or the United States' other trading partners, whether it's the Japanese or the Germans.
None of these volleys in this war occur in isolation. And as much as even the most dovish members of the Federal Open Market Committee would like to present otherwise, to convey that unified front, there is nothing that the Fed can do or say to contain a trade war if the real economic damage, the collateral damage becomes to where it seeps onto our shores in the form of an increased recession probability, which is exactly what the yield curve has been communicating since that first rate cut that they said and hoped would be a quote unquote one and done.
Patrick Ceresna: So Peter, how does, how does your opinion differ from that? Or do you have a different view of what happened here at that FOMC?
Peter Boockvar: No, I feel the same way. And, you know, in engaging in the effectiveness of what the Fed is trying to do is, you know, we have to understand the basic function of what the Fed or other central banks do is when they cut rates, they're encouraging you to borrow money. They're encouraging, if you're a household or you're a business. So when you stimulate from a monetary or fiscal standpoint, You try to convince people to do something today that they may have waited till tomorrow because they were saving money, and you convince them to try to borrow.
Well, with borrowing costs so low right now across the world, as we know, particularly in the US where the Fed's trying to stimulate, there's nothing really to stimulate. So that's when you get into this Japanese malaise where low rates forever stops being stimulant because you're not convincing people to do things today. They're just waiting till tomorrow. And the same thing is happening in Europe, and the same thing is going to happen here. So what the tools that the Fed has really is irrelevant at this point. So to Danielle's point, when you get this sort of slowdown that's global right now, and industrial/manufacturing-centered, at least for now, because of the tariffs that are now spilling over into other areas, this is going to play itself out.
And what's going to differentiate this downturn And whenever the recovery after the downturn takes place is that relying on central banks to create some sort of V-bottom recovery is just not going to happen this time. There's going to be a lot of bouncing along the bottom. There's going to be a lot of churning in the economy for more time than people are accustomed to. If you look at the behavior in the stock market, the stock market still believes in this V-type recovery, and that the Fed can sort of create magic, and Powell can change his mind in January, and everything's gonna be fine, and we can compete in multiples that earnings will eventually substantiate, and everything's gonna be fine. And I think we're gonna realize that pushing on a string which has been around forever is gonna be a term that's gonna be used a lot more over the next 1 to 2 years.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Danielle, I wanted to circle back to your call that this was potentially the start of a new currency And clearly you nailed it because no sooner did the rate cut occur did we have the dollar strengthen and Trump get out there and immediately escalate tensions between China. So why were you on top of this? Like, what did you see coming? And is this playing out according to your— the way that you envisioned it when you were on the All-Stars episode?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, I don't think that anybody in, well, in America or basically on planet Earth can envision what our president is going to do next. If they tell you that they can, they're lying. But I did know that the 25 basis point rate cut would not be to the satisfaction of the White House. That much anybody could have said in advance. So his reaction, Trump's saying that he was going to impose the 10% tariffs as of the beginning of September across a much broader broader spectrum of Chinese goods was certainly something that could have been anticipated in order for him to get the reaction that he wanted, which was a full pricing in of the 25 basis points he didn't get at the July FOMC meeting. Now that occurred, and in that sense Trump was perfectly successful.
Where the backfire comes in, as we watched retail stocks melt down in the following days because there are so many companies in the country that simply can't withstand another body blow to their margins when they're already operating at such razor-thin levels.
What nobody anticipated, myself included, was that after over a decade, the Chinese authorities would allow the yuan to trade through the 7 level as retaliation against what Trump had done. The reason I'm bringing this up is because Trump tends to throw things out there and then pull them back once he gets the result that he wanted. Well, if the result that he wanted was simply the market fully pricing in a September 18th rate cut by the FOMC, then he might have taken back the tariffs knowing that it might not be such a good idea to try and forcefully put JCPenney, Macy's, and Gap out of business before the holiday season hits. I mean, I'm just throwing names out there, but because of what the Chinese did, because of their response and because of, of the Treasury Department's naming China a currency manipulator in further retaliation, this means that nothing can be taken back.
So Trump thinks he might have taken a baby move to push market pricing to where he wanted it to be, to get the easing out of the Fed that he felt Jay Powell did not deliver on And look what happened. That is the nature of a currency war and why it's different than simply President Trump tweeting something out saying, I'm not satisfied with the amount of love that I'm getting out of the Eccles Building.
Patrick Ceresna: So Peter, what's your impression of where Danielle was going with that?
Peter Boockvar: She's spot on, Ned. It's, it's gone to another level. We can even take a step back and say, you know what, this currency war actually started back in 2012. into 2013 when Abenomics came into being, where the yen was around 75 to the dollar. And one of the purposes of Kuroda doing what he did was to weaken the currency to try to import inflation. So their currency weakened from 70-ish to 120. And then you, then you go over to Europe and Draghi's intent when the euro was at 140 was to get it as low as possible and import inflation to get to their levels of 2%.
Well, we've seen a decline in the euro, of course, from 1.40 to 1.10-ish. We've seen the weakness in the yen, and neither central bank has been able to generate the inflation that they want. I think that's a good thing that they were unsuccessful, because the last thing those 2 regions needed was higher inflation. But the point is, is that they dramatically weakened their currencies, and Trump sees what they've done, and he's feeling, well, I'm here defending Middle America and the manufacturing base of this country, and we have all these central banks pissing on their currencies.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Peter Boockvar: And they get the benefit and we don't, even though Japan and Germany, these are export-reliant economies that really gained no benefit from the weakness in their currencies. So it really became the thing to do is depreciate your currency. And the Fed kept interest rates at zero for 7 years. So the war has really been going on for years.
But to Danielle's point, now it's just taken a whole new level. China has now gotten so in the middle of it as the second biggest economy.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, Erik, what's your take on the currency war and this idea of what happened with the FOMC and the rate cut we just had?
Erik Townsend: Well, I really want to credit Danielle, first of all, for calling it a currency war and describing this FOMC meeting before it happened as the first shot in a new currency war, because that's really what I think it is. And frankly, where I think the world has been stuck for the last several years Is we know a currency war is coming, but we're not quite ready to get into competitive devaluation yet because everybody knows that it's not really good for anybody in the end. And, you know, it's sort of like nuclear mutual assured destruction. You know, we're all smart enough not to get into it, but once you do get into it, everybody piles in at once. And I think we've been waiting for years for that moment where we really go into a, okay, this rhetoric war turns into a shooting war, except the shooting is not It's not real shooting, it's shooting in monetary policy through competitive devaluation. And I think that's now begun, and I think Danielle called it on MacroVoices before it happened, so I really credit her for that.
The thing that I'm perplexed by out of this whole thing is this language about the mid-cycle adjustment. I mean, and I think Danielle may have said this on the show too, so if this policy process started in 2009 and it's 2019, that's 10 years in, so if that's mid-cycle is 10 years, does that mean this is a 20-year cycle?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: What the heck is going on? And I don't know about you guys, but I never saw that one coming, that Powell would say, I just want to be clear, we're not starting a rate-cutting program here. This is, this is not a rate-cutting cycle. We're just playing around here in the middle of a different cycle. That seems to me like an incredibly self-defeating act. And I would have thought that based on the market reaction to it, that he would've done the usual politician thing and said, oh, you guys misunderstood me. That's not really what I meant to say. Let me now say something completely opposite and you just misunderstood. No, he's really went out of his way to stick to his guns and say, this is really what I meant.
Do you guys have any insight on what is driving him? I mean, Danielle, you've worked in the Fed. Why would he do that?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, so I think that there are several things going on here because Powell has continued to not get his way. I'm not trying to characterize him as a petulant Petulant child, but this is definitely the man who wanted quantitative tightening to go on in the background on autopilot. This is the man who wanted to get the Fed funds rate to 3%, and this is the man who wanted to rally his troops and come together and make sure that everybody, all the way to Bullard, his most dovish committee member, was unified that this would be a one-and-done. So I think him coming up with a clever little characterization of it being a mid-cycle rate cut was a way of conveying and cementing, driving down, driving through his point that this was going to be it. Of course, the minute the market heard those words, it proceeded to completely throw up, and the reaction was violent.
But I'll take a step back because Because a few press conferences ago, Powell was asked about whether or not he had killed the business cycle, which he's implying that he has if we're going to have a 20-year business cycle, which is ridiculous. But a few press conferences ago when he was asked about it, Powell actually looked happy for the first time in a long time. He got a little glitter in his eye.
And he was speaking lovingly of the Australian episode of a near 30-year expansion Well, well, guess what?
That was reliance upon a very quiet currency war. To your point, Erik, that's been going on forever because back in the '90s, obviously China was manipulating its currency. It is not today. But Australia was a huge beneficiary for decades, plural. And yet we've now seen— and Peter can jump in here because he's been a fan of Australia's discipline forever now— but we've now seen Australia's 10-year sovereign yields sadly trade through the 1% floor to the downside. I'm sure Peter was watching the same thing as it happened recently.
Peter Boockvar: Yeah, the Reserve Bank of Australia never really believed in negative real interest rates. And you had much tighter or smaller standard deviation, you can say, of monetary policy over many years, therefore reducing the odds of having booms and busts. Now, ironically, They've had a boom in their real estate market that is leaking air, but that's a separate conversation. But to the point of negative interest rates, or negative real interest rates, start there, creates a whole different dynamic compared to positive real interest rates.
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, do you have anything to add to that?
Erik Townsend: You know, what came to mind as both Danielle and Peter were speaking was Dr. Pippa Malmgren's comments. And this was relative to President Trump and the China negotiations, but I think I think the same principle probably carries over to monetary policy and what the Fed is doing. And what she described is kind of an attitude of US complacency, where I think President Trump is of the mindset that, you know, he's Mr. Art of the Deal. He's gonna squeeze the Chinese government as hard as he can to get the very best, to get 'em to the point where they're really just hurting for a deal.
And finally, when it's convenient and fits into his election schedule, He's gonna say, okay, I'm willing, I'm ready now. I'm willing to go ahead and cut a deal with you guys. And what Pippa said, and what I strongly agree with, is, hey, don't assume that the rest of the world shares this US view that the US is in charge of everything. China might just say, um, eh, no thanks, we're not playing your game anymore. You've been incredibly difficult to deal with. You had your chance. We're not going to deal with you. Now, I think China does want the deal, but I don't think they're going to kowtow to the US as much as the US is assuming.
And I think the same thing carries over to central banking. So many people in US markets, US financial commentators seem to be talking about how the Fed is going to do this and that and the other thing, as if the Fed were in a position to dictate to other central banks. Okay, here's— guys, here's the game plan. We're in charge. Here's what we want you to do, BOJ and ECB. Here's what we want you to do. And, you know, we're the Fed, we're in charge. I don't think it works that way.
I think the ECB and the BOJ are gonna do their own thing. And I think they're gonna see this as a competition. And I think it could get really, really interesting. I think we're in very historic times. I'm very curious to get Danielle and Peter's reactions as to whether they'd agree.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, look, dictating is— it's a difficult thing to do. Even if you are the Federal Reserve of America. And don't get me wrong, I believe that, that central bankers are in the habit of and regularly coordinate policy. And there, there was no— I don't think Powell was in the least surprised when at its July meeting the European Central Bank indicated that it would be, it would be easing policy on September the 12th when the ECB next meets.
And I don't think that the Bank of Japan's comments have in any way, shape, or form not been coordinated with the Federal Reserve. But it's amusing to me at best when you see the wheels come off in one day's trading and when you see credit volatility go through the roof and the yield on the 10-year US risk-free rate, the benchmark for the entire world, crash And that's not a— that's not an exaggeration, pushing the inversion of the yield curve to its most acute when all of the best-laid plans among central banks was to do this cute little 1/4 percentage point rate cut that would elegantly un-invert the curve and that they could get together and put their translating headphones on that they borrow from the UN and sing Kumbaya. It doesn't work like that. And I'm sure Peter would agree with that.
Peter Boockvar: Yeah. I mean, essentially, the Fed's winging it, and they've been winging policy for a while. So, for all the PhDs that they have there and all the models that PhDs create, there is a sense of winging it. And I think Powell and others realize that because they stopped raising rates at the 2.25%, 2.5% level, and Danielle said earlier they wanted to get to 3%, they realized they only had 9 rates to cut, assuming that they would eventually want to go back to zero again. which is a separate conversation. So when you have 9 rates to cut, you have to be very judicious with those 9 cuts. And I think Powell also is feeling an extraordinary amount of pressure from Trump.
And you can have Fed heads write articles, oh, we're independent, we block out the noise, this and that, but there's still an extraordinary amount of pressure that he is responding to.
Not that he cut rates because of Trump, But he still sees the weakness overseas. He sees the weakness in manufacturing, and he's saying to himself, okay, you know what? I can cut rates here, and then we can we can sort of stem that weakness and and create a firewall before it spills over to the consumer side of the economy, and and and everything will be fine. And I think that's how he viewed this in his mind. If this is quote unquote due to global developments, which is outside of her purview and outside of his influence because of the trade and manufacturing nature of the tariff-induced slowdown.
He's hoping, if I can cut here, and then maybe we can get a trade deal, and everything will end up being okay, then he can somehow skirt by this. But then, of course, he's getting dragged in every direction by what other central banks are doing.
And the key question from here is— and Danielle's heard me say this— is, does he get caught in this peer pressure vortex of going down the same path as the other central banks in order to keep up and satisfy what their models say, which is very simply, rate cuts good, rate hikes not good? Is where does he stop? So to me, it's not a question of, OK, is he going to cut here? Is he going to cut there? But where's the endgame for Powell at some point? Let's just take this further over the next 6 to 12 months that the economy slows down, that services start to weaken, and we begin to see layoffs, and consumer spending gets hurt, and the stock market falls.
Where does Powell take this? Well, in speeches, he said, yeah, it's not a question of if we go back to zero, it's when. And then he talked about it at— I don't know if it was a Fed press conference or a speech— yeah, there are plenty of Treasuries out there for us to buy.
So he's told us that, yeah, he's going to go down the road of the BOJ and the ECB. But he's going to also learn the hard lesson that it doesn't work, and it's not going to help, and you're potentially damaging your banking system. And you have the situation where the stock market's going to continue to rely on your rate cuts, but then when they finally realize that it's actually not helping spur faster economic growth, you're going to be back to that pushing on a string, and then central banks are going to have nothing.
But the Fed has an opportunity to learn the lessons of what other central banks have done, And the question from here is, are they going to learn those lessons? Because the odds of a soft landing are slim. Historically, they've been slim. They've only been achieved about 20% of the time. And I would say the odds of a soft landing this time are much less. And is a central banker with a president tweeting and breathing down your neck willing to vulgarize the Fed and say, you know what, our rate cuts aren't going to do any help?
And it's just going to get us trapped like other central bankers are going to do, or is he just going to fall for the same trap that the others have?
Patrick Ceresna: All right, so moving on, I wanted to go back to that statement of a mid-cycle adjustment, because assuming it's a mid-cycle adjustment, then all of the economic slowness we have here should be very moderate, and we should see everything start to pick up on the other side. Yet we're seeing a global manufacturing Potential global manufacturing recession starting and potential earnings recession starting. Everything is starting to weaken. In your minds, is this just a modest slowdown that will recover, or is this something that can morph into a much bigger economic recession? What's your take, Danielle?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, I, I think that if we don't fall into recession, that I'll have to, uh, excuse the pun, I will have to Trump out that phrase, it's different this time. And, you know, I'm remiss to do that. What I would point to, though, is the very slow degradation that we have seen in, in the creation of, of high-paying jobs.
And this is something that peaked out last fall, and it has slowly but surely been coming down on a monthly basis to where The bulk of the job creation that we're experiencing now is in what we call low-paying jobs— eat, drink, get sick categories— and that's not going to help propel the economy forward.
One of the datasets that we, that we pay close attention to that I've spoken to before is, is the Challenger, Gray, & Christmas data. What started out with, with Challenger and Gray was basically a retail story that made everybody's eyeballs roll to the back of their head. But what we noticed getting into 2019 was that we were starting to see not just automobile and industrial layoffs kick in in a big way, but we started to see that of information technology and transportation, and more recently even financials.
And we're seeing a lot of the big banks announce layoffs. So if you see, if you see the, the movement from the Gee, we can ignore the 11% of the US economy that is manufacturing. If you see seepage into the services sector, which is exactly what we're seeing, we've had 8 or 9 trucking companies go bankrupt so far this year. That is a services sector that happens to have led the entire economy in 2018. That was one of the recipients of all the panic buying ahead of the potential increase in Chinese tariffs. When you start to see the bleed from industrials into that 88% of the US economy that is services, then you know that barring some kind of fiscal stimulus measure— because I think as Peter said several times, it's increasingly apparent that the Fed is pushing on a string— if we don't get something from Washington, I couldn't throw the probability out there of of getting an infrastructure bill, say, before the election, dot, dot, dot, not.
If we don't get something of that ilk, I can't see a pathway for the economy not continuing its slow slide into recession.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And Peter, where do you stand on that view?
Peter Boockvar: So I think what will be the determining factor of whether this is going to be just a normal recession— when I say normal, somewhat being mild without any crazy exogenous effects versus something that will be deeper, where do asset prices go? Because if you look at the consumer right now is the strongest part of the economy, but of course showing vulnerability if services weaken and we start to see a slowdown in hiring, we saw a slowdown in hours worked in the last payroll number.
If all of a sudden the stock market stops getting the benefit of, oh, the Fed is going to save me, And actually starts to really correct, not just have you know your your V bottom that we've seen countless times over the past ten years, but a sell-off in the stock market that lasts, a sell-off in real estate prices that last, a widening of credit spreads that starts to impact the financing of small medium-sized businesses.
That's we go from a mild recession first from to something deeper. We have to remember the last two economic recessions really. Exaggerated by declining asset prices. You know, the decline in tech stocks led to a collapse in CAPEX, and obviously the decline in house prices led to a collapse in bank balance sheets, and then it went from there.
So to me, we have still this asset price dependent economy that affects not only the psychology of its participants, but also the financing of the Beyond Meats and other venture capital businesses. So where that goes in response to this economic slowdown, I think is going to be a really important determinant in measuring the extent and the deepening of any downturn.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. Erik, do you have anything to add to that?
Erik Townsend: My perspective is a little bit different because what I think about the most is, first of all, a recession has to be coming because you can't go forever without having one. It's been 10 years. We're overdue. It's beyond my pay grade to say whether that happens right now or not, you know, next quarter or the quarter after that. I'll be very, very surprised if we got to the end of 2020 and there had been no significant recession. I think it's much more likely that one has already begun and we don't realize it yet. But I don't claim to be able to time these things. That's past my pay grade.
What I think is much more interesting to think about is, will the next recession be the catalyst that triggers what Ray Dalio calls a paradigm shift? And for anyone who's not familiar with Dalio's writings on the subject, What Ray has predicted is he said, look, we're in a paradigm in markets now where central bank liquidity has been holding up asset prices and it's been working. And that cannot go on forever. It will stop working. There will be a loss of confidence in the system and it will eventually reverse to the point where central banks are completely unable to support asset prices with printed money. And at that point, the whole name of the game changes. And even Dalio, who's, you know, one of the most most respected money managers in the world, said it's beyond his pay grade to know when that's gonna happen, but he's convinced it's coming in the next few years.
And the big question in my mind for the next recession is, will that recession be the trigger that sets off that paradigm shift that Dalio is talking about? So we get into a regime where suddenly central banks are no longer able to support asset prices by conjuring money out of thin air the way they have been for the last 10 And I don't know the answer, but to me, that's the most important thing to watch for as we get into the recession, which I'm confident is coming probably within the next year.
Peter Boockvar: Well, we've reached that point overseas. I mean, the Nikkei is down almost 50% from its peak. The TOPIX bank stock index is down 90% from where it was 30 years ago. The European— the Euro Stoxx 600 is below where it was in 2007, and their bank stock index is down 80%. from where it was in 2007. So, outside of the credit markets, those central banks have already lost control of their equity market. Not that they have the same reliance on stock prices that we do here, but it's proven there to not have worked. And at some point, to your point, and what I believe will be eventually here, is the Fed will lose control of our stock market, which will then determine how deep that recession goes.
Erik Townsend: And that's where you want to own gold and a lot of
Peter Boockvar: Correct.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: I think right now this, this conversation can take a turn towards the societal implications of— which is, I think, what you were starting to get at, Erik— kind of the societal implications of Fed policy and what it has produced and, and where there might be resistance in, in the coming years, given some of the comments that Dalio and people like Stanley Druckenmiller have made recently.
Erik Townsend: Danielle, you hit the nail on the head. I think that's exactly the place to go next. And one of my predictions is it's not just how central bank policy will affect the social mood, but it's also how the social mood will constrain the ability of the Fed to act. And one of the things that I predict is that when we get to the next significant market crisis, and the Fed really does have your back, the Greenspan put is still there. Central bank do intend to save markets, and then suddenly there's a 10 times bigger than Occupy Wall Street uprising of the people that says, hell no, no more bailouts for Wall Street. Let the stock market crash. We're sick of bailing out the bankers. If you're gonna print money out of thin air, give it to us. Use it for universal basic income. Use it for forgiveness of student loans. Use it for, you know, whatever other social spending program.
And I think that there is a rapid growing support for that. So, I don't think it's just the central bank policy affecting society. I think it's society potentially, at some point, tying the hands of central bankers in their ability to rescue markets.
Peter Boockvar: And Erik, I agree with that. If you listen to some of the Democratic debates that we've seen, a few times I've heard someone talk about— people talking about, well, yeah, the stock market's up, but not everyone owns stocks. And I think that the politics around more QE and going back to zero to lift asset prices are going to be a lot more difficult from the Fed, from the Democratic side, than they've ever experienced before.
Erik Townsend: I completely agree. Danielle, what's your take?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, so I have some very deep thoughts and feelings that have been triggered by a recent interview that Stanley Druckenmiller gave to CNBC in which he said, that Fed policy has been fantastic for rich people and that, quote unquote, this is the biggest redistribution of wealth from the middle class and the poor to the rich ever.
I don't think that he's only speaking for his billionaire buddies, but I think rather he's speaking for the 99% who are quite certain they've been left behind. And the governor that I see on Fed policy that has not been as much of an inhibitant, if you will, to the European Central Bank, to the Bank of Japan, to the People's Bank of China.
The biggest governor I see going forward is that because there's so little ammunition— to Peter's point, we started out with 9 bullets in the chamber, not a lot compared to prior cycles when we've had over 5 percentage points of ammunition— but what happens if If, let's just say, the Fed gets to the point of needing to launch quantitative easing or feeling that it needs to launch quantitative easing, we know it doesn't work, so why go there? But what happens if they get to the point, if the Trump tweets— Trump's already started tweeting about quantitative easing. The volume's just going to get higher and higher.
But can you possibly see in this world of rising populism and the this feeling that we don't need to bail out Wall Street, but we need to bail out Main Street.
Can you imagine what happens the next time the Fed announces quantitative easing? It just doesn't wanna go there. I think they will have the wrath of Congress descend upon them almost immediately demanding that the proceeds of the Fed's printing press not buy Treasuries, that benefit the bank and the banking system, but rather that they fire up the printing press to pay for X, Y, and Z for the little guy who was left behind during the decade of unconventional monetary policy that clearly only benefited the fat cats on Wall Street.
That's going to become extremely problematic even for the crowd that is clamoring for the Fed to print money for social relief because of the effect such criticism and such skepticism would put— the effect that this would simply have on the stock market and on the credit markets. And these are the dots I don't think people are connecting. Erik, Peter, I'd love for both of you to tell me how you think risky assets would react if QE was announced But it wasn't going into Treasuries.
Erik Townsend: Oh, I think it's coming. I think actually QE will be announced into Treasuries, and it will not actually be implemented, because before they have a chance to click the button, they're going to have a revolt from the political left. And the political left is going to say, look, you need to use any printed money for the things that we want to use it for, which is social spending and universal basic income and so forth. And what's going to happen is the The policymakers at the Fed and the political right are both going to respond and say, wait a minute, wait a minute. You guys don't understand this stuff as well as you think you do. See, we're smarter than you. And we know that the way you want to do it would be like really inflationary. And the way we want to do it is not so inflationary. And you should trust us because we know better than you.
And the political left, which is going to have the majority behind them, and frankly, I think they should.
Patrick Ceresna: Good.
Erik Townsend: It's not my personal political belief, but I think they would make a very good point, which is, hey guys, we've tried the business of trusting the political right and their politicians on what the policy should be. We've seen how that went. No thanks. We're not interested in that. We want to do it our way now. And I think that the popular response that they would get would be unstoppable, regardless of whether policymakers want to do it or they would be forced to do it.
And I think that we're very likely headed to some incredibly inflationary and frankly reckless policy decisions ahead of us, not because the policymakers wanna make those decisions, but because they won't be given a choice. The political pressure will be so strong that there will be no possible way to oppose it. That's my take.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: So then, Peter, I'll put you on the spot here. Let's just say Erik's scenario plays out. How do you think that the frothy leveraged loan junk bond investment grade Bond, stock market, how do you think risky assets would respond?
Peter Boockvar: Well, it'd be a problem because if Erik is right and then it does lead to higher inflation, because when you look at QE, QE is just essentially an asset swap. But if QE is going to be used not to buy Treasuries but to basically hand money out to people, the inflationary implications then have a direct influence on where bond yields go. Bond yields will then rise and then squeeze every company that's too leveraged, because you're going to have a stagflationary-type environment with shrinking cash flows and higher inflation and rising interest rates. And that's like nightmare scenario.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: I'm not able to poke either of you into giving me the answer I want, though. But everything you said, Peter, and everything you said, Erik, all makes sense. But what happens if the beneficiaries of the Fed's next round of QE— what happens if the beneficiaries are not the market? And then the markets fall out of bed and you have everything that Peter described with, with inflation and rising interest rates, but at the same time layoffs and unemployment go through the roof.
Erik Townsend: Danielle, I think you get ultimately an inflationary depression. At least that's the potential risk. And the way that that would come about is we have dual bubbles in both the stock market and the bond market, and everybody assumes that they can't both burst at the same time. But if you suddenly had the realization in the marketplace that, hey, the Fed does not have our back anymore, they can't, they've been politically outvoted, and all of the sudden, they're not buying Treasuries, you've got a potential to set off a trigger for higher bond yields, not just for the reasons that Peter just described, which were all excellent, but also because there's effectively a bursting of the bond market bubble with a coincident burst of the stock market bubble, That in turn forces a systematic unwind of the massive institutional risk parity trade, because all of a sudden that correlation ratio that that trade is based on stops working, and you have a massive meltdown along with much higher bond yields, runaway inflation.
And the thing about all this is, you know, inflation has a lag effect. At first, it will appear that the policies are working beautifully.
The handouts are very popular. People love having the money. The inflation doesn't start on day one. It seems like everything's great. There's a jump for joy and a celebration, and let's do even more of it. Eventually, when the inflation catches up with the economy and you have out-of-control bond yields and suddenly the US government cannot service its own debt, even applying 100% of tax revenues to servicing its debt, you have to raise taxes in order to service the debt. And you can't because you're facing a stagflationary environment where nobody can afford more taxes. you've got an absolute crisis on your hand.
And I think that we have all the ingredients, certainly not that those things all happen overnight, but we have the ingredients for a social spending program where QE is used, as Peter described it, for handouts. And it works beautifully at first. It seems like it's working. They do even more of it. And eventually you get to a point of no return where there's this snowball effect and you can't stop it at that point. And that's what I'm afraid is perhaps the worst case that we may be headed to in the next decade, certainly not in the next year or 2.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I think there is a solution for that. At least it's been proposed, and that's MMT. So I'd love to move on to this topic and get everyone's opinions about modern monetary theory. So let's start off with you, Peter, and what's your impression? Is this something that's in our future?
Peter Boockvar: Well, I feel like we've sort of been living it right now in lower doses compared to what some proponents of it talk about, but certainly in Japan, you can argue that we've been living it for years, and we can see clearly what the results are. In Europe, you can argue, and in some way here. So, you take it one step further, and to the point of whether it can be contained in the sense that there are no side effects, well, that assumes that there's unlimited supply of things, that where MMT is the demand driver of things, But once you get into a situation where people realize that excess demand created by MMT, where money is just handed out to people, meets a fixed amount of supply or more limited supply, then you get into a dangerous inflation situation and everything unfolds the way that Erik just talked about. And the bond market revolts and sort of takes away this printing press and takes away this option of a government.
When you think about So, if you think about all this easing that we've done, it's okay, you originally have easing, it doesn't work. And then the government response is, let's do more easing. That doesn't work. So, MMT is then the next sort of doubling down and send in more because all the monetary stuff on its own didn't work. So, let's combine that with a fiscal push and then we'll really get to what we want, but that will fail as well. And getting back again, what will eventually call it out And eventually end all this, bond market revoking the inevitable inflation that that MMT creates.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. Danielle, what's your thinking on MMT?
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Well, I think MMT is— not to make any enemies here, but I find MMT to be amusing to the core, namely because when inflation rears its ugly head, and presumably in a situation in which MMT in the United States was being pursued, It would be running, to Peter's point, in hyperdrive in other countries. So there's this assumption that as long as you've got a printing press and you're issuing debt in your own denominated currency— thank you, Christine Lagarde, isn't she coming on at the right time? Eurobonds. But there's this idea that all of the countries with printing presses, China included, can carry on with their own MMTs in isolation, until which point you reach a debt-to-GDP level that triggers inflation.
And here's the amusement, amusement factor. Once this inflation is triggered, you simply fix it by levying higher taxes on those who can pay. Now, I think we're still talking about a United States of America with a Congress and the need for congresspeople when inflation is going haywire to come in with tax I don't see the political will or wherewithal to resolve the challenges that MMT will present via rising inflation by increasing people's taxes, kicking them while they're down, if you will.
You'll have billionaires simply get up and leave the country, and millionaires, if that level of socialism was to be imposed, along with what we spoke of earlier. What would be required of having the Fed be the conduit to print the money to solve all of society's woes?
And something else that would come into play here, and this is a huge debate that I recently launched on Twitter, is, well, let's just say theoretically that Wall Street is not bailed out and therefore the stock market and the bond market fall out of bed. And that might or might not take down a few states such as, oh, I don't know, New Jersey, Illinois, With it, the pension systems fail. Can MMT therefore just be deployed to make sure that we don't have pensioners with no pensions? Can MMT theoretically just be used for whatever ails the economy? Fill in the blank.
And the answer was— of course, this is via Twitter, and I'm poking bears on purpose at this point— but the answer was, you have a fundamental misunderstanding of what MMT is. MMT prints money in order to raise people up together. To which I replied, well, what happens to those who are falling down because of it? So at which point we kind of came to a stalemate and I pretended to be stupid and moved on.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, do you have anything to add to the MMT storyline there?
Erik Townsend: You know, I'll just build on what Danielle said at the end there. And my view on MMT is it is one of those very interesting things where I do not think it is possible for any person, and I include myself in this criticism, to separate their own political ideology from their opinion about MMT. You take a guy like Professor Steve Keen, whose whole story is entirely about there's too much debt and debt is the enemy and we've got too much debt, but Steve describes himself— these are his words, not mine— as being politically just left of Nancy Pelosi. And despite being a total anti-debt guy, Steve is a big proponent of MMT. He thinks it has a lot of value. I will be the first to admit my own anti-MMT perspective is based on what are admittedly political beliefs.
I don't think that you're doing anyone any favor by giving them free handouts. I don't think that it is beneficial to society for there to be free college tuition. I don't think that's a good thing. So I'm against MMT. But Patrick, I admit that my political ideology is influencing my opinion. And I don't think anybody has an unbiased opinion on MMT. Everyone is biased by their own political philosophy. And I think it affects the way that people think about this.
And it's scary because MMT is going to be a really, really big deal. And I think all of the people that— and this is probably a criticism that applies to the way most of our political policymaking occurs— all of the people involved in the decision-making are going to be making emotional decisions based on their own philosophy, as opposed to really looking at the hard facts of what works and what doesn't work, and what the cause and effect of various policy tools are in the economy.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: So, Erik, if I could jump in, I'm going to challenge you for just a minute. I think that if you look at the Scandinavian example of pockets of MMT already having been deployed and see that the people who are on the receiving end of MMT-type policies are decidedly happier, but at the same time, the employment situation is not improved in the least, I think you can look at MMT agnostically and apolitically and determine that if it's not going to generate a longer-term, higher economic growth trajectory, that in and of itself it should be abandoned. Because the MMT philosophy is that this will raise all boats by making people happier and therefore more willing and able to succeed and provide their own, whatever it may be, economic input into the longer-lasting, better growth rate for the country, which some MMT experiments are already proving not to be the case.
That's pure economics.
Erik Townsend: Well, Danielle, my hat is off to you. If you are able to be completely agnostic about MMT, then I think you are in a very small minority. And my opinion is most of the people who claim to be agnostic really aren't. They have beliefs about what is socially appropriate, what we should be trying to accomplish, socially. And I think that most people's opinions are biased by that. And I certainly admit my own opinions about MMT are biased by that. If you're able to be so intellectually disciplined as to stay completely agnostic and not allow your own political philosophy to enter the equation, my hat's off to you. I wish I had the same ability.
Peter Boockvar: And also it gets to, you know, do you believe in the effectiveness of the actual implementation? Because somebody has to implement this. Someone has to make the allocation decisions about where this money goes. And getting to your point, Erik, about the politics and what people think, yeah, you have more of a tendency to believe in it if, for those people, those of a political ilk that believe in the capabilities of the government. Those that question the efficiency of government, generally speaking, are obviously going to be more suspect of this policy. particularly on the implementation phase.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Right. And yes, and Peter, to your point, if you can imagine just one itty-bitty example of MMT, which is obviously a large one, is Medicare for All. There's an underlying assumption that the federal government can be an efficient arbiter of healthcare in America. I don't know of an efficiently run American agency in existence.
Peter Boockvar: Right. And getting to my point earlier about, okay, we're going to create all this demand for things, Through MMT, but no one's talking about what the supply is. I mean, let's try to figure out how many doctors are there going to be left if we have Medicare for All, and that a procedure for an hour is going to cost $26. Doctors are going to be falling out of the system by the wayside. Hospitals are going to go out of business. So in that debate, no one talks about what's the supply response going to be when all the money is then thrown on the demand side. Right.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: That's exactly right. In fact, we've already seen a taste of that with what has come across just in— with just with Obamacare. I mean, I personally have lost 3 doctors who've gone off to become concierge services because they simply couldn't make enough of a profit given malpractice insurance costs to make it worth it.
Erik Townsend: Danielle, I'm just gonna come out and say it. I think that in many ways your comments are actually revealing my point, which is Because if I listen to you and Peter talk about this, it's clear that your philosophy— you just said you've never seen a successfully managed government organization. You have a set of beliefs about the value of government. And I'm sure if we had an MMT proponent here, they would have a different view. They would think that government is capable of doing all sorts of wonderful things and people like you just need to get out of the way and government can do all sorts of fantastic things for everybody.
Your political philosophy and your, as Peter put it, your inclination to believe that government is the solution to a lot of problems strongly affects whether or not you buy the whole MMT story. I take a guy like Steve Keen, who's an absolutely brilliant economist. I'm sure he could make a very credible-sounding argument for why MMT really could work and it could solve these problems and we wouldn't have the issues with healthcare. And frankly, I think I think that I know that I'm biased by my views. I don't believe in handouts. I think that Steve's own description of himself as a very left-leaning guy, in my opinion, explains a bit of why he is such a believer in MMT. I certainly don't know that he would say that, but that's my impression. So I think it does affect all of us.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth: Fair point. I'll take that.
Erik Townsend: And that concludes part 1 of our 2-part summer special. Today's episode was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy of The Many Flavors of Trend Following and subscribe to their podcast as well. You'll be glad you did. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo.
Be sure to tune in next week on August 29th for part 2 in this 2-part series. Until then, for the MacroVoices Podcast Network, I'm Erik Townsend.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free research library, and the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week. Free of charge. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Daniel Lacalle — Professor and fund manager (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 180 was recorded on August 15th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the only podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, which I highly recommend. Professor and fund manager Daniel Lacalle is back as this week's feature interview guest. Then we'll have a detailed discussion of monetary policy, including what the political popularity of Modern Monetary Theory will mean for markets, and why Professor Lacalle thinks the bond market has it right, but the S&P 500 has been slow to get the proverbial memo. Be sure to stay tuned for our post-game segment after the feature interview, when Patrick and I will discuss risk in the BBB and junk bond markets. As MacroVoices junkies remember, Louis-Vincent Gave told us months ago that the whale in the BBB bond market was General Electric. Now, do you remember the name Harry Markopolos? He was the whistleblower who exposed Bernie Madoff's frauds to the SEC.
Well, guess who he just accused of massive accounting fraud on the scale of Enron? That's right, GE. Unfortunately, Louis Vincent Gave couldn't join us on short notice for our postgame segment, but Patrick and I will discuss whether a GE credit downgrade could be the catalyst to bring on a long-awaited dislocation in the BBB and junk credit markets. We also have a fantastic summer special planned for you, which will air during the final 2 weeks of August. And those of you who enjoyed our Dollar Endgame series at the end of 2017 are really going to love it. We'll tell you more about what to expect right after the market wrap.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into this S&P 500 because it continues to deteriorate on the bottom end Do you think the selling is going to continue here?
Erik Townsend: You know, I'm really starting to think so. And let's just review the recent history. You know, we were flirting around with all-time highs. There was the Fed panic, which retraced very quickly. Then came President Trump's tweet, essentially restarting a trade war with China. That resulted in a much bigger dump, and it started to retrace. But then, as I've been saying, the big risk, the reason I was hesitant to short this market, is because I thought, you know, any day now President Trump could come out and say, hey, Hey, he's kissed and made up with China and it's really all going to be better and they're going to make a deal after all. Well, that sort of kind of happened this week. We didn't get a complete reversal, but President Trump said that he wanted to negotiate with China and that he was delaying the imposition of tariffs. So it was a pretty strong signal that in the past it wouldn't have surprised me at all if that had taken us to new all-time highs, but it didn't.
In fact, the instantaneous spike up in equity prices, which was to be expected and unavoidable, only lasted for 24 hours before we were trading at a new lower number, below the number where the news first came out. I think this is really significant because what's happened in the past is as soon as there have been signs that trade war with China is, is not really happening, we've seen a moonshot back to new all-time highs. This time the bounce didn't even last 24 hours, so maybe finally reality is setting in, and I do think economic reality calls for much lower stock The bond market gets it clearly, but the stock market's been slow to take the memo, as you're going to hear from Professor Daniel Lacalle in today's feature interview. So I think maybe, Patrick, we're finally getting to the point where gravity is setting in, reality is taking hold, and I think there's lots of room for a whole lot more downside.
Let's save the rest of that conversation, though, for the postgame segment, because I know you've got some charts prepared, and I'm particularly keen to get your perspective on the technical levels that we need to watch.
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, for sure. We'll do that in the postgame. So let's move on to the US Dollar Index because obviously we had the other week a sell-off that was after breaking to a higher high, but now the dollar is back up toward 98. Was that just a little blip? Is the dollar gonna resume its uptrend again?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think it is, Patrick, but we're definitely at make-or-break time for the US dollar here. We were breaking out past that critical level of 98. It looked to me like things were really breaking out. Then we had the Trump tweet And the trade war and so forth. And it was unavoidable that there would be a very significant knee-jerk lower on the dollar. You know, the President of the United States starts a currency war, that's, that's kind of negative for the currency. That took us right back down to about 97 even, and now we're rallying pretty hard for the last couple of days off of that. This is the rally that is going to make or break this. In other words, if we can get a daily close above the previous high, which was about 98.60-something, let's call it 98.70 or so. If we can get a daily close above that number, it really confirms this was not a false breakout, that the move is on.
We just had a news-induced pullback and things still look good for the dollar. That's my base case. That's what I'm betting on. That's what I think is happening here. We do need to be fair, though, and say, look, from a technical analysis standpoint, if we were to see a failed rally here, we're right at 98 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon. If it stops here and then we go the other direction and see a daily close below 97— these numbers are all on the September futures contract— if we were to see that, I'd really have to say, boy, it doesn't jibe with my fundamental view, but that would be a technical signal that would tend to confirm that this was a false breakout and would signal much lower numbers to come.
I don't think we're going there. I think we're going north, and I think that once we clear 98.75, let's say, with a couple of days of daily closes above that, I think it's going to be an acceleration to the upside and 104 comes into sight. But let's not put the cart before the horse. Of course, right now we gotta clear $98.60.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's talk crude oil. It's been very choppy the last couple weeks, but the trend seems generally downwards. I mean, is there more downside? And also, how did the inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: I think that there is more downside. And because today was an option expiration day, we were pinned between some of the option expiration strikes. I won't be at all surprised now if I, if I look at RBOB gasoline as a signal that tends to be an early warning sign for crude oil. It's well below all of its short-term moving averages. Crude is still locked in between its short-term moving averages. I think that's about to change to the downside.
But let's start with EIA inventory. Crude oil surprise build this week again of 1.6 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, though, drawing down 2.5 million barrels, and it looks like that could be a continuing trend. Genscape, the private data service that reported this morning, is anticipating potentially another 2 million barrels next week. So Cushing, Oklahoma, that's the tank farm farm that's landlocked in Cushing, Oklahoma, is seeing drawdowns even in the face of nationwide builds. Finished products also drawing down this week. Gasoline down 1.4 million barrels, distillates down 1.9 million barrels. Now, even before the inventory data had come out, it was already a very big down day, and that just accelerated on that unexpected crude oil build. And we saw the, the tape action go profoundly down. US production 12.3 million barrels unchanged, still holding firm there at just about 100,000 barrels under the all-time record. Imports up to 7.7 million barrels per day. Exports back up to 2.7 million barrels per day after being depressed last week.
Options expiration day is today. As I say, I think that has been what has kept WTI crude oil pinned in a fairly narrow range. But as I look at RBOB gasoline, it gave up its 8-day moving average after yesterday Yesterday giving up its 5-day moving average and 3 days ago failing to break out through its 13-day moving average. So if RBOB is an early warning sign for where crude is headed, which I think it oftentimes is, that means that maybe lower numbers are in the cards, but we'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because after 3 up days in the dollar index, my first impulse would've been that this would've softened gold prices, but they don't seem to wanna back off their highs. I mean, does gold still have more to go? What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, I certainly agree with you on that. I was expecting as the dollar started to break up again that it would be at least a headwind for gold, and we did see that, you know, when the news came out that the tariff extension had occurred, there was an instantaneous drop in gold back down to $1,500. Can you believe that? We're saying back down to $1,500. Just a few weeks ago, we were saying up to $1,350. So, you know, it seemed like that signal that I expected to be bearish for gold was going to take effect. That only lasted a day or so, and I think we haven't quite taken out the previous high, but we're working our way back up to it. So I think that we have gone a little bit too far too fast.
Clearly, I was wrong with respect to thinking that the dollar was going to be a headwind for gold that might take us to much lower numbers, say below $1,200. That didn't happen, and you can't be right all of the time. But believe it or not, Patrick, what I bought today was puts on long-dated gold futures.
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, really?
Erik Townsend: futures. And I know that's gonna sound to our listeners like, oh boy, there he goes again thinking the price of gold's gonna crash. No, I don't think it's gonna crash. I think that I missed the call. I admit that. It's time to figure out how to be long gold here. But I think it's moved too far too fast, almost $200 up in 2 months. And I really think that there's likely to be a pullback at some point.
The reason that I'm buying long-dated puts on gold is a strategy that I've used before that I really like. It's called legging into a synthetic call. And the And the idea is, if we do get a move back down to, let's say, $1,380, I really want to buy gold and buy a lot of it there, because I think that if we get that retest of the breakout zone, it's time to buy. Well, the thing is, what if my original view from way back actually turned out to be right after all, and there is a big move down in gold? I want to be able to buy at $1,380 with a little bit of leverage. Well, in order to do that, you need some kind of hedge.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: Buying that hedge right here, right now, while gold prices are still high, is cheap. So I'm buying the put that's going to allow me to use more leverage to buy more gold at $1,380 and not worry about the downside because I'll be fully hedged when I make that call.
Now needless to say, gold could go straight up from here, in which case the options that I bought will expire worthless, and you know, so it goes. It was a small premium, less than $9 for $1,350 puts on the June of 2020 contract, and that sets me up to leg into a synthetic call on gold with leverage if we get back down to $1,380. Don't know when that's gonna happen, but I won't be surprised if it happens before this is over.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield, 'cause we dropped below 1.50 today. Like, this thing is just nosediving. When does this stop, Erik?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, we used to talk on this program about, you know, do you think that we'll ever get back to that, that all-time low of 1.36% on the 10-year. Now the question is, are we going to get there by the time that our listeners hear this program in the next 4 hours? I mean, it's, it's crazy how it's going. Needless to say, I do think that the argument is in place. I think the bond market is telling us that a recession is coming. Why the stock market is staying as high as it is is a mystery still. Maybe that won't last much longer. I'm certainly going to talk to Professor Lacalle about that in today's interview. But yeah, I wish that when I was waiting for a pullback to get to 220, I had just bought 210. At this point, I feel like it has gone too much too fast. I'm not going to jump into the long side of this trade here. But the macro signal here is that we're headed for trouble in the economy.
But Patrick, the point I really want to make about fixed income, we're going to have to save for the postgame segment. And that's actually the scenario that you called to my attention this morning with what's going on with GE as potentially being a whale in not in the junk market, but in the BBB market that could have knock-on effects and consequences. Let's save that conversation for postgame.
Patrick Ceresna: And before we move on to the feature interview, we need to announce our summer special on the future of monetary policy. But, and also, you got a couple videos you're about to release this weekend. So why don't you let all our listeners know what to expect?
Erik Townsend: Well, let's start with the summer special. Our production staff has been doing an absolutely fantastic job with all of our expanded content. They deserve a well-earned holiday just like everyone else. So we're going to take a little break for the second half of August There won't be any Energy Week shows for the next 2 weeks. And for MacroVoices, we've got something really exciting planned for you. Those of you who really enjoyed our end-of-the-year special in 2017, which was called The US Dollar Endgame, have been emailing us asking for similar content next time we do a holiday special. Well, you've got it. We've got Danielle DiMartino-Booth and Peter Boockvar joining us for the next 2 weeks.
Announcer: Hi, everyone.
Daniel Lacalle: Hi, Peter.
Erik Townsend: The format of the next couple of weeks shows we're not going to have a market wrap unless there's extraordinary market conditions that dictate we have to have one, and the way things are going, that's entirely possible. But what we are going to do is dedicate the entire show to a long-form interview which will run over the course of 2 weeks. I will be joining Danielle and Peter as panelists, and you, Patrick Ceresna, will be the emcee and moderator for the overall event. It's already been taped. It was a fantastic session that we had, and I think you're really going to enjoy it. Now, if something really crazy happens in the markets, we'll change our plans and come back and try to give you some kind of market wrap or commentary. But barring outright catastrophe, we don't expect to tape a regular show again until September 5th, when we'll be back with our regular format.
As far as videos, Patrick, we're going to continue to produce most of our podcast content as audio only. It just doesn't make sense to produce it as video podcasts. The production cost is isn't justified for that. But for longer shelf-life content, we're going to start introducing a series of advanced investor education videos. The first one explains how to trade hedge fund strategies like long-short equity in your own account. We're really excited about this, and it's going to be a video series that will be available on MacroVoices.com free of charge and supported by donations. So we've got videos coming, but before we even get to that advanced series, I've got 2 that will be Yeah. And then we have 2 more videos that are going to be released hopefully in the next couple of days here, certainly by the end of the weekend.
Those are an update on the digital currency revolution. And I really want to encourage everyone in the audience to check them out. I know a lot of our listeners are not interested in Bitcoin and cryptocurrency. Look, that's not what this is about. It's really more about what comes next after cryptocurrency and why digital currency, not cryptocurrency, but other forms of digital currency are eventually going to completely change the shape of the international monetary system. So I really encourage you to check those videos out. What you'll be getting on your iTunes feed will just be a 2-minute trailer, and then the full-length videos are available at MacroVoices.com/video. They're not up yet, but they should be before the weekend is out.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, thanks for the update. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Professor Daniel Lacalle. Now, Erik, why did we invite Professor Lacalle to return as our featured guest this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, listening to some old interviews, you know, he's one of the guys who has been saying for a long time that the stock market is not getting it, that we need lower prices. But he was also very prescient in saying, don't expect a crash to start tomorrow. He expected us to get back to all-time highs, exactly as has happened. So the forecast that he gave us last time he was on the show has been remarkably prescient and very accurate. So we'll find out what he's now expecting in the stock market, but clearly we've got a disconnect. Bonds and stocks don't agree. Somebody needs to be proven right.
Erik Townsend: We're going to cover that and a whole bunch of other exciting topics. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. You'll often hear me say on the program that even if I have strong conviction about a market or a trade, that you have to listen to what the market is telling you, not what you think it should be doing.
Doing. And that's exactly what trend-following managers have been doing for decades with great success. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well researched and tested. And there's one podcast that covers trend-following strategies better than any other— toptradersunplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book called The Many Flavors of Trend Following, explaining exactly how these systematic strategies can work you. Just go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro.
Check them out, you'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik's interview with Daniel is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest. Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Professor Daniel Lacalle, Professor of Global Economics and both Chief Economist and Fund Manager for Tressis. Professor Lacalle, the last time that we had you on the program— I encourage our listeners to go back and listen to that interview— I think you anticipated and correctly predicted a lot of the things that are happening today. But clearly We need to start with this trade war slash currency war, potentially.
What do you make of this situation? Is President Trump just showing us a few of those Art of the Deal negotiating tactics, or is he serious about starting what could become a very serious and ongoing currency war with China?
Daniel Lacalle: Hi, thank you very much for having me on the show. Well, the first thing I would say is that President Trump is definitely using a negotiation tactic, and it's clearly a negotiation tactic with a very clear objective as well. When President Trump started what the so-called trade war, all the tariffs, etc., the idea was that China in the last basically 8 to 10 years has been increasing dramatically its presence in the global economy, yet at the same time, it hasn't opened the economy as much as it should So therefore, all of the different claims at the World Trade Organization that the United States made against China, etc., were not working.
The objective behind the tariffs was obviously to get China to understand that their position was a position of weakness, and that this was a negotiation between the largest supplier China. China with the largest customer, the United States. And as in business, the customer is the one who dictates the terms, not the supplier.
In that sense, tariffs were sort of implemented as a weapon to get China to accelerate the opening of its economy. Unfortunately, what we have seen is that, as in previous occasions, as we saw as well with George W. Bush and the tariffs on aluminum, as we saw with President Obama and the tariffs on solar panels is that tariffs tend to be used as an excuse for increasing protectionism, not as a way of improving the economy for the country that suffers those tariffs.
And unfortunately, that is what we have seen, is that the position of China has been of nice words, say that they're open to negotiations, that they're open to dialogue, at the same time arriving nowhere. And in the meantime, and this is critical, implementing further and more aggressive capital controls in the domestic economy.
And I think it was this increase in capital controls and the increased intervention in the financial system that triggered the next and final wave of more aggressive messages from the United States because it showed as a red flag of what was actually really behind China's intentions, which was not to open the economy, let alone to reach an agreement, but to protect itself as much as possible and actually implement a currency war.
Erik Townsend: Professor Lacalle, it sounds like you and I are in very strong agreement that President Trump's intention here was not to start a currency war, but rather to use a negotiating tactic to try to assert his position of power in a negotiation designed to result in some kind of deal. But some people have opined that perhaps President Trump has started a fire that he won't be able to put out, that what this could result in is other central banks around the world saying, okay, looks like game on for competitive devaluation, and potentially everybody jumps into easing mode And you get into a situation that you can't get back out of. Is there a risk of that?
Daniel Lacalle: There is a risk. However, I think that it's a moderate risk right now. The reason being the following. I think that what we have seen from the latest devaluation of the yuan, but also from the previous ones that we saw in 2016, also in 2018, is that the impact on the global economy and on global financial assets is much larger than what the central planners anticipated. And also, from the experience of previous misnamed competitive devaluations, we also know that policymakers are pretty aware that competitive devaluations have very little effect, very little positive effect on the economy. Rather, what they tend to do is to create a sense of concern from consumers, from investors. So decisions of consumption and investments tend to be stopped or postponed because of those competitive devaluations. In fact, a competitive devaluation first is not a competitive— doesn't improve competitiveness, but second and more importantly, it is the equivalent of a salary cut and a wage cut in the economy.
So as the global economy, and particularly the central banks that are more aggressive in terms of monetary policy, are in economies that are mostly service-oriented, They know that what we are already seeing, which is a recession in manufacturing, could trigger a recession in the service industry if you just destroy the purchasing power of currencies via artificial depreciation.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to financial markets then. Something that I've been feeling, and I think it very much echoes some of the sentiment that you described in the last interview that we did with you several months ago. As I look at the various different markets, it seems like the bond market is telling me we've got a problem here.
We're looking at collapsing bond yields, maybe a strong recession signal potentially. Gold breaking out potentially is the signal of trouble in the economy. But until this trade issue came up, seemed like the stock market was just immune to, to almost every other signal.
Daniel Lacalle: Right.
Erik Townsend: As soon as the trade issue hit the radar screen, stocks took a nosedive, but already they're starting to recover. So, does this mean that if you're correct and President Trump is just using a negotiating tactic here, that eventually stocks continue moving back to new all-time highs? Or does the stock market take a cue from the bond market at some point?
Daniel Lacalle: I completely agree that something does not compute. It is impossible that the message that we receive from the bond market is the same one that we receive from the stock market. From the equity market, which is the opposite. So, the bond market, more than $15 trillion of negative yield in bonds, is telling us a very high risk of disinflation, not deflation, and a very high risk of stagnation, very, very clearly. The equity market is telling us there's going to be QE no matter what.
And as such, it seems that the equity market is discounting that, Yes, the macro data is poor. Yes, earnings revisions are negative, and the earnings season was not anything to write home about. However, none of that matters because there will be a very significant, and it needs to be very, very significant round of quantitative easing ahead of us. So it's basically a preemptive. Call on easing.
Now, that's very dangerous from 2 perspectives. The first one is, obviously, there are people out there that say, hey, what the bond market is telling us is wrong, and growth will resume. The tariff situation will be resolved. And there is a great opportunity here, because we're going to see PMIs bouncing back, and we're going to see earnings and growth expectations improving. Remember that that was actually behind the idea to buy into the dip in December, that as from June, we would start seeing a strengthening of the global macroeconomic figures and also of the earnings profile of most sectors.
Those 2 things haven't happened.
But it's also very dangerous to believe that central banks are going to take such an aggressive stance simply to maintain the trend of asset valuations, because central banks absolutely do care about asset prices. However, they don't necessarily react in a way in which investors would expect in terms of timing. They tend to react, as we have seen, for example, in the United States, et cetera, they tend to react more according to what they see that other central banks are going to do rather than what asset prices are doing, the way that asset prices are fluctuating.
So I think that what the market has used the latest headlines on trade wars as an excuse to sell off an already very expensive market. And obviously what happens in that environment is that the marginal buyer is more scarce because it's more difficult to find somebody that is going to find value even after a correction.
The problem here is, Okay, what are we discounting in terms of monetary policy is already a very significant easing from the European Central Bank. I think that that was widely discounted after Ms. Lagarde's appointment and the latest conference from Mr. Draghi. What are we discounting as well? That the PBOC will continue to ease and support its financial sector via increasing money supply, and that the Federal Reserve will continue to cut rates, maybe even unwind quantitative tightening.
That is already in the market. So, what we are really betting, if we go into the more cyclical, the higher beta part of the equity market, if we buy into that, what we are actually buying into is something that is very, very difficult, because if a $20 trillion QE stimulus in total that we have seen was not enough. You cannot expect central banks to go out and say, oh, it's going to be $40 trillion now.
It's going to be very, very difficult to please an equity market that is already investing aggressively into the most cyclical part of the economy when the signals on that cyclical part of the economy have nothing to do with the trade wars, have everything to do with the excessive demand-side policies.
So the reason why PMIs are weakening, the reason why copper is is weakening, the reason why oil prices, despite massive supply intervention, are not rising as much as OPEC would like to, et cetera. All of that is telling you that there is too much overcapacity in the economy, too much slack. That is because, not as a consequence of lack of stimuli.
Erik Townsend: I'd like to expand this discussion of what monetary policy is being discounted and perhaps how that discounting may be Mispriced, in my opinion. It seems to me that although Modern Monetary Theory, MMT, is not a new idea, what is new is the way it's been politicalized. Suddenly, we have presidential candidates talking about how it's going to be possible to give away free college tuition and forgive student loans, and MMT is going to make it all happen. So, suddenly, there is a social component where it used to be just economists and and market geeks who were interested in monetary policy.
It's being politicized, and it makes me wonder whether we're headed toward an environment where politicians try to assert more control over the Fed. And certainly, one of the things that has been suggested, you know, a question that came up is, will Jay Powell be the last chairman of the Federal Reserve if President Trump actually gets serious about what so far have been seemingly idle threats about trying to abolish the Fed.
Are these things that we should be worrying about, or are these things that are going to affect where monetary policy really goes in coming months and years?
Daniel Lacalle: I think we should be very worried. I think we should be very worried because there's this feeling amongst politicians that there is no wrong that they can do in terms of monetary policy. QE embedded a view amongst politicians that you can print as much money as you want and nothing is going to happen, and that the economy grows, there's no inflation, unemployment is low, everything is great. However, that was not enough, so why don't we do 3 times more and printing Argentina style because we can?
This is the mistake. The mistake is to think that bad effects or that the negative implications of quantitative easing will be offset or improved by more of the same.
And there's a very important factor here, is that monetary policy and the Federal Reserve's monetary policy has always been driven by one factor more important than inflation or unemployment. The number one factor is global demand for US dollars. The reason why the Federal Reserve can undertake the policies that it undertakes is because it is the world reserve currency. And because commodities are paid in dollars, and because we all use dollars when we travel to exotic places, etc., that's fine.
Now, being the world reserve currency is not something that is granted, let alone something that lasts forever. Therefore, if the government in the United States doesn't have as a pillar of its policy that the US dollar remains the world reserve currency, it can unleash all of the negatives that modern monetary theory, when applied in countries as we have seen in Venezuela or in Argentina or in any country in which they decided that they can print all the money that they want and nothing will happen, and it does, is very, very dangerous. So I think that that there needs to be a process of education that starts from telling people that the mistakes of printing money and lowering rates are not solved by printing more money and destroying the price and the quantity of money. That is very simple. And it's very complicated because it's very easy to believe that 2+ 2= 22 if you're a politician.
But it's not true, and the problem of of modern monetary theory is that it only works in paper. You know, the the people say, oh, you know, you print all the money that you want, and if there's excess inflation, you tax away the excess money. Isn't that beautiful? Nobody thought about that about it in the past because it doesn't work like that.
Money creation is not neutral. Money creation. Disproportionately benefits the first recipient of money, be it the financial system in the case of quantitative easing, asset prices go up, etc., be it government. And the last recipients of money are always the most negatively affected. Those are salaries and savings. And those are the ones that are going to be obliterated. So, that's what people need to understand is that expansionary monetary policy, the way that it is presented, is not something that has a social component, it is actually the most antisocial policy that one can undertake. What everybody understands, that quantitative easing disproportionately helped the 1% richest part of the population, needs to be translated to what modern monetary theory is, which is to disproportionately benefit the 0.000001% of the population that is actually in government and doesn't suffer from inflationary
Erik Townsend: Professor Lacalle, you've just given an extremely credible, in my opinion, explanation of why 2+ 2 doesn't really equal 22, and why MMT doesn't really have the promise that a lot of people would like to believe.
Erik Townsend: But if I put myself in the shoes of the average millennial who's not an expert in financial markets, Professor Lacalle just said a whole bunch of confusing stuff I didn't understand, and Bernie Sanders told me that I can have my college tuition for free and my past student loans forgiven, thanks to something that some other PhD said would work. I like that better. So let's assume that the political process leads us down a path that you and I strongly agree is not prudent and doesn't make sense. But I have the sense you probably also agree with me that there's a very good chance that we're going to go down that that path anyway, because if you tell people they can get free stuff and it doesn't cost anything, they're going to take the free stuff.
And the politicians that are selling that message are going to be empowered to override cooler heads like yours and mine in the monetary policy process. What are the consequences? What does it mean for markets and for the world if all of your very well-spoken cautions are ignored, and instead, we just go and monetize in order to give away free stuff?
Daniel Lacalle: Well, what I would say to that millennial is a very simple question. What do you prefer to work for, a strong or a weak currency? Very simple question. And the answer obviously is a strong currency. No one will tell you, I want to work for a weak currency, because they know that their salary, purchasing power falls, then they know that their savings are destroyed.
So, that's the first part. The second part is, what do you do as a millennial, as somebody who earns a wage, as somebody who's going to start making a living, if you receive a salary in a currency that you know, that you are completely sure that the government will continue to depreciate as much as it can in order to sustain all those allegedly free services that are paid with newly created money. What do you do with your salary?
You go out and you buy anything that will maintain the purchasing power of your salary. You will buy gold, you will buy, I don't know, cryptocurrencies, you will buy anything, anything except keeping that currency that is burning in your hands or in your pocket. You will do what the very intelligent Argentine citizens that are trapped in the monetary monster that Argentina is do, which is to escape as quickly as possible from a government that is going to destroy the purchasing power of your salary with the excuse of an alleged social policy.
And what happens then is that everybody does what you would do. Of course they do, because they're not stupid. And if everybody does what you do, the government prints a lot more money than what is demanded. Not only that is demanded, the demand of that currency is actually diminishing while the government prints more in order to continuously finance those allegedly free services. What ends up happening is that the inflationary process and the destruction of the real economy is extremely evident. The first thing is because the one thing that you don't do with your salary is invest. Why don't you invest for the future? The reason why you don't invest for the future is because you know that the returns of your investment, if you succeed, will be absolutely absorbed by the government in its monetary destruction. The second reason is because you have absolutely no clue about the, the future in something that it already has a tremendous level of uncertainty, which is investment.
That is why in countries like Argentina, in countries like Venezuela, when they start that process, it becomes a downward spiral because the first people that are undertaking capital flights out of the country are their own citizens. The second is that real investment collapses because there is no way that anybody is going to undertake take really long-term investments into the economy. The third thing that happens is that those services that were supposed to be given for free actually don't appear because the currency becomes more and more worthless. And by becoming more worthless, the government does not even get close to offering those kinds of goods and services.
What the millennials should understand is that there is No public sector without a thriving private sector. A millennial needs to understand that, needs to repeat that every day until it sinks in. There is no public sector without a thriving private sector. If the public sector continuously erodes and crowds out the private sector, it ends up destroying not just the private sector but also the public goods and services that it promises to.
Erik Townsend: Well, we've just done a very thorough job of describing the backstory that might explain some of this disparity between the message we're getting from the bond market and the message we're getting from the stock market. But let's move on now and talk about the bond market and the stock market. What are your outlooks for both? Let's start with, with stocks. Given all of these conflicting signals, what happens next?
Daniel Lacalle: I think that what will likely happen next is that we will see a relief bounce from 3 factors. One, that China's devaluation, as we saw in the 3 previous ones, that China's devaluation is absorbed by the market, and it doesn't get any more aggressive because China needs to maintain on one side an artificially high currency and on the other side an artificially weak currency. On one side, to avoid capital flights and to maintain the purchasing power of salaries and wages, and on the other side, to try to export more. So, it's a very delicate balance that they try to manage. So, the first one is going to be relief post-devaluation.
The second one, in my opinion, is that because we have seen such an aggressive and quick slump in PMIs and in the macro data, much more aggressive than I actually expected in the first half of the year, the signs of stabilization will be seen as positives, very likely. You will see. You will see suddenly, we saw today with Germany, oh my gosh, factory orders are up 2%, still down on the year, it doesn't matter. But it's like a certain relief.
The third, obviously, is here comes the ECB. The European Central Bank is going to come up with very aggressive messages like it did in 2009 of stimulus plan, infrastructure, helping through monetary policy, fiscal policy. The European Commission might start to put ideas about a very large stimulus plan like the ones that we have seen in the past.
So we are likely to see a little bit of, let's say, tailwind coming from relief. And I'm sure that we will hear some mild messages coming from the United States and from China about the trade war. Now, what we need to do is to take those with a pinch of salt. And what we need to do is to take those with a pinch of salt because we have seen all of this in the past and we cannot fall into the same trap again. We have already seen the Juncker Plan. We have already seen the growth plan for Europe. We have already seen We have already seen the massive QE from the ECB. We have already seen the ongoing messages about it's coming, it's coming, the Peter and the Wolf message about the trade dispute. So, we need to take that bounce and reduce exposure to cyclicals.
Daniel Lacalle: We need to reduce exposure to cyclicals, absolutely.
Bond market, when every single central bank in world is telling you that they will do anything and whatever it takes so that governments finance themselves cheaply, even at negative rates, that happens, and it happens big time. And we think that we have seen— we cannot see any more of negative rates. Oh my God, we can.
Oh my God, we can. And we were talking before about the, the what academics say No, we are seeing so many papers out there saying how to make negative rates work this time— paper by the IMF that I recommend everybody to read and not to take very seriously, etc., etc. We are reading so much about the great idea about negative rates that they will be implemented further because there's no government in the eurozone and there's absolutely No contender to the government or in government in Japan that is questioning negative rates. So, we will likely see that getting worse before it— worse in terms of negative rates. But as a bondholder, as an investor in bonds, obviously, the dichotomy is going to exacerbate that as we have seen in the last 6 months, I believe.
Erik Townsend: Now, just a few months ago, a lot of people were still saying, look, that 4.34, I believe, was the low print on the US 10-year. Has to be, has to be the final end to the bond bull market. It's all over. It's going the other direction. Well, we're back to within what, 30 basis points as we're speaking today of that? So are we headed to new lows in yield, new highs in bond prices on the US Treasury?
Daniel Lacalle: I think we're going to new lows in yield. And the reason is that as all these things that we have been talking about so far unravel, there is a message that is floating in all of these policies all the time, which is buy dollar assets, which is what central banks are going to be doing. If the European Central Bank enters into a massive printing process, the collateral for many of the banks that are going to be in the Eurozone defending themselves against negative rates is dollar assets, is Treasuries. That's why China has been reducing its holdings of Treasuries and yields have fallen. So, it is very, very likely that if we go from financial repression to outright QQE Japanese style, then it is very, very likely as well that yields in the US are challenged beyond our expectations.
Erik Townsend: As crazy as this whole notion of negative-yielding bonds seems, I'm able to reconcile it. It's crazy, but if you think about it and you sort of say, okay, so it's really the banking system is not using sovereign bonds as an investment that they're expecting to make money from. They're really using it as a liquidity tool in their balance sheet. The Basel III Accords have some There's reasons for banks to be holding these negative-yielding assets. It seems crazy to us, but, but I can justify it, or, or at least I can explain it if I, if I struggle.
The thing that I cannot understand, and, and you're a professor of global economics, so please enlighten me. How is it possible in Europe that we now have a couple of dozen negative-yielding junk bond issues? And, and just to refresh our listeners' memory, what a junk What a junk bond is, is when a ratings agency who is expert in these matters looks at the creditworthiness of a borrower and says, you know, this is not a very good risk. This is a really risky investment. These are not the right people to loan money to. Why would someone loan them money? And you can't say it's just because of balance sheet requirements of central banks, so forth.
You know, junk bonds are not reserve assets.
Daniel Lacalle: Right.
Erik Townsend: assets. This has to be a bid that is coming from a free-willed private sector investor somewhere who thinks it's a good idea to bid the price of junk bonds up to a level that it has a negative yield. How does that reconcile with rational expectations theory? It doesn't seem rational at all to me that someone would buy that bond.
Daniel Lacalle: I don't think it is rational. I completely agree. I can understand logic, but it's again a very, very dangerous bet. This is the bet in my opinion. Okay, so if I buy the high-quality assets, they're too expensive and the yield is, is, is already too low and negative. So if I want to search for yield, I need to find something that is at the same time gives me a little bit of yield, but at the same time is extremely Why am I going into buying something that is extremely risky and at the same time has a negative yield? Because my bet, maybe conscious or unconsciously, is when the governments and the central bank in the Eurozone have one single policy, that is, we will take zombification of the economy, no problem whatsoever, nobody's worried about that. That we will take some vacation of the economy, but we will not let anybody fall.
I want to go into the riskiest asset. That is the problem. You see, the flawed logic is that while governments are willing to do anything, while governments and central banks are willing to do whatever it takes so that any process of change of economic cycle doesn't come back with the logic of any economic cycle, which is creative destruction, which some businesses fail, others thrive, et cetera.
When you're taking the first part of the equation out, which is nothing can fail, then you want to move into the riskiest assets because those are the ones that rise in price the most while the yield is negative in any case.
It's a very, very dangerous bet. It's like basically saying, because I have almost a safe bet in the fact that if I buy a sovereign bond, it will be repurchased by the central bank, and therefore, I may not make any money, but I'm sort of maintaining the value of my assets, I'm going to go not 3, but 4 steps further as an investor. And I'm going to go for the riskiest asset because if I and the rest of wave make that asset systemic, then it has to be bailed out. You see, it's a, it's a process. This is the collateral damage of quantitative easing, is that quantitative easing and expansionary monetary policies lead consciously or unconsciously investors to take a view that it is best to take more risk because in one way or another, that extreme risk will be rewarded with a bailout, with some form of bailout.
It can be an indirect or a direct bailout. Now, think about it. If the ECB is going to make a massive QE that has to give a message to the market that it's going to be bigger, bolder, and more aggressive than the previous one, we're talking We're talking how much? €5 trillion, €6 trillion?
So, that investor is thinking, my bonds of this company that cannot pay its interest expense with operating profits and is barely at the edge of bankruptcy, these are gold dust because of the previous. Because if the ECB says €5 trillion, where is it going to get it from? It's not going to get it from blue-chip investment-grade issuances.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Daniel Lacalle: Because it doesn't even start.
It doesn't even get it from financing all the deficits of the peripheral economies, because that's already happening. So, where's it going to get it from? You see, it's a massive bet on an indirect bailout of the zombification of the economy.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on as we talk about all of these bailouts and things that surely have to end badly someday. Let's talk about gold. Which, despite the strength of the US dollar that I thought was going to be a headwind for gold, we've seen a breakout above a very important technical level at $1,350 to $1,377, which has held for 5 years now. Not only did we break above that level, but we moved about $200 almost above the $1,350 initial breakout zone in a couple of months. What is this telling us?
And it's not At the same time, you know, we're not seeing the dollar dump here. We're seeing the dollar very much hold its own. And for a while, the dollar was breaking out until President Trump started, you know, talking about trade wars. The dollar was breaking out at the same time that gold was breaking out. So what's going on? What does this change in correlation between the dollar and gold mean? And is this the beginning of a really, really big move up in gold?
Daniel Lacalle: Well, on one side, gold Gold, the fundamentals of gold have improved quite a lot. Central bank buying of gold is at all-time highs. So on that, on one side, the supply-demand scenario is pretty good, and that sort of maintains a minimum price. The second one is that if people start talking of currency wars, they start to think immediately, what is the reserve of value here that I can look for.
Now, the reason why gold and the dollar were rising at the same time as Bitcoin, and while copper was coming not down, but sort of, you know, doing nothing, was because what ended up happening, which was a devaluation of the yuan, was already quite predicted by many Chinese citizens. And if you think about what has been going on in terms of gold buying. And in terms of dollar assets buying, a lot of it has come from Chinese banks and Chinese citizens. So, I think that that's why there was this correlation.
It was basically a negative yuan, positive any reserve value option. Now, what can we expect for the future? If we enter— let's start from my premise. I don't think it is easy, even politically beneficial, to enter a currency war. So if we don't enter a currency war, then it is quite possible that gold, which is an inflation hedge as well, gold gets a correction, but then continues its slow way up that is more driven by monetary insanity than anything else. But remember that gold tends to get sold off when markets perceive, oh, there's not going to be an inflation burst, B, there's not going to be a currency war. So that could happen. There could be a correction because of that effect that I was talking about before, the relief that things are not getting worse than what the market has already discounting. But I think that if we enter a currency war— and again, we cannot do anything else but guess— but if we enter a currency war and central banks not only start increasing money supply but actively targeting the currency, then obviously gold is going to rise significantly.
So what we need to pay attention is not to the messages. The messages are going to be the same as always. Central banks will absolutely deny any intention to manipulate the currency. Absolutely they will. What we need to do is to pay attention to the actions, and if the actions can be directly related to an active decision to influence the currency— not an indirect one, QE is an indirect sort of hopeful that the currency will weaken as a secondary effect. That is not what I'm talking about. What I'm talking about is actively selling reserves, etc. So, that's what we need to pay attention to because that is what will probably kick the price of gold above its resistance level.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to emerging markets. You told us in the last interview that they still had a long way to go before finding a bottom. What's your current outlook?
Daniel Lacalle: I believe that what we're going to see in the next 12 to 18 months is the effect of all the dollar-denominated maturities that are coming to be repaid. So, there's pressure to buy dollars, and there is pressure as well to refinance in an environment in which you have more risk attached to growth expectations than what we had last year in which there was a sort of expectation that things would bounce into the second half. So, I would be very cautious about emerging markets, particularly because in many cases, as we're seeing with India, as we're seeing with Argentina, as we're seeing with Turkey, in many cases, they don't have tools to defend the currency. And the currency itself is the only sort of valve that allows them to try to at least At least disguise the effects of the imbalances that they have built in foreign currency in the last 8 years.
Erik Townsend: Well, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview, Professor Lacalle. Before I let you go, please tell our listeners, I believe you write a blog, and for our accredited investors, you also manage a fund for Tressis. Please tell us how they can contact you to get more information.
Daniel Lacalle: Thank you so much. Yes, if you want to follow me, The blog is dlacalle.com. That is dlacalle.com. You have it in Spanish and in English, so impossible to avoid getting my opinions. Also on Twitter and on LinkedIn, etc. Not difficult to find me. I'm also the author of 3 books, Life in the Financial Markets, The Energy World Is Flat, and Escape from the Central Bank Trap. And I'm proud to say I will be publishing a new one in March 2020. It's called Freedom or Equality. The fund is called Adriza Global, and you can find more information on the website of Tressis, T-R-E-S-S-I-S.
Erik Townsend: Well, thank you so much for another fantastic interview. We look forward to getting you back on the show sometime around when that next book comes out. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And you can also join the conversation on our And Facebook page. we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Daniel Lacalle. He's always got some great perspectives on just how everything is developing, and especially his insights into what's happening in Europe were pretty interesting.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, he's based in Europe and he has excellent insights. I think he's a really brilliant macroanalyst. overall. Speaking of brilliant analysts, though, Patrick, I want to give you credit. You called me this morning and said, hey, GE. And, and I said, I know it's on the news. But then you connected a few dots that I didn't see right away. The news, for anyone who hasn't heard it, is that Harry Markopolos, the same whistleblower who blew the whistle on Bernie Madoff back whenever that was, 2007 or so, that same guy has basically accused GE of Enron-scale accounting fraud. Now, Patrick, you immediately connected the dots and said, wait a minute, Louis Vincent Gave told us that GE was the whale of the BBB credit market in a conversation which was about what were the triggers or catalysts that might lead to a much larger disruption in credit markets. Now, as I look at the market reaction, GE stock took a An absolute nosedive on this.
But as far as anybody making the same connections that you made and anticipating that this could lead to a major dislocation in BBB and junk-rated credit generally, the market hasn't figured that out yet. And of course, it's just speculation on our part, but I think it's very worth going over. So you put a chart deck together. Listeners, you'll find Patrick's chart deck linked in your Research Roundup email. It says Postgame Chartbook. If you don't have Research Roundup email, that means you haven't registered yet. Shame, shame. Just go to MacroVoices.com. On our homepage, look for the red button next to Professor Lacalle's picture that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, let's dive into this chartbook. Tell us what you've got here and give us the story.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. On page 2, all I have is the, uh, just a snapshot from CNBC's headline, just talking about some of the key points. Which is that Harry and his team were basically analyzing for seven months, thoroughly going through all of GE's accounting and believed that there's a $38 billion with a B fraud. And more importantly, he says that it's merely the tip of the iceberg. And I thought that was amazing when I hear like okay, I thought $38 billion is a lot, but he thinks that there is more. And he says that this could be a bigger fraud than. Enron, and the first thing that came to mind—and by the way, anyone that's interested—we included a link in the roundup to a website that they put up, which is the GE fraud dot com. And also on page three have have a screenshot of that website. And so they're really going all in on this on this idea that there's something going on.
And the first thing that came to mind was that we're always looking for a catalyst, some canary in the coal mine that sets in. Motion, a series of events that lead to ultimately a bigger unraveling. And I, to use an analogy, I was thinking like, is this like an earthquake in the middle of the ocean that just triggered a tsunami? That when you're sitting on the shore of the, of the beach, you don't really see that there's this big wave of water coming at you until it actually reaches you.
And that made me immediately think back to when we had both Professor Edward Altman and Louis Vincent Gave on our mid-December 2018 MacroVoices episode where we talked about junk bonds and credit risks. And Louis, give him credit, he nailed this one. So what I did on pages 6, 7, and 8 is I just took excerpts out of Louis Vincent Gave's chart book where he basically gave the analogy of dynamite Fishing, and he's saying you know they throw the dynamite in and a bunch of these fish come floating up. But it takes a while.
You know, sometimes you kill a whale and it takes a while for the whale to float up to the top, and you only after the fact find out. And he kind of using that same that idea and was asking the question back in December: Is General Electric that whale for the high yield bond market?
Now what happened at the end of the year when the markets bottomed, GE started to rebound. And then over the last 6, 7 months, everything seemed rather calm and everything seemed to stabilize. But clearly, this bombshell of the fact that there, there could be a massive accounting fraud— I mean, everyone's looking at what it's doing to the share price, which was obviously a 10-plus percent haircut in very short order. But the question is, will this now open up the idea that the rating agencies are going to now use this information to really assess whether or not General Electric debt and all of its money markets and everything need to get downgraded to high yield or junk status, and the implications that that would have. You know, I have that chart on page 8 where Louis Vincent Gave was showing the size of that BBB market versus the size of the junk bond or high yield market, and GE's debt is like $100+ billion of this debt.
And if this downgrade happened, what impact would that have?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think we need to put something in perspective before we go on. I agree with you that I like your analogies, and I think we need to think about whether there's a tidal wave that's below the surface that hasn't hit the shore yet. But before we go there, we need to put some things in perspective. When Harry Markopolos exposed Bernie Madoff as being a fraud back in the early 2000s. At that time, he was acting as a concerned citizen, a smart guy who's very good at forensic accounting, and didn't really have any financial motive associated with what he was doing. He didn't make any money from exposing Bernie Madoff. He is now working with an unnamed short-selling hedge fund on this project. So there is a financial incentive for Harry Markopolos and the people that he's working with to want to see GE fail here. And we just need to keep that in perspective.
It does not change my view that I think he's onto something that could be very real and could have very serious consequences. But we do need to keep this in perspective and realize that the people that are in this game are big boys that are playing for big bucks, and they have motives that we need to consider.
Having said that, I think you've got exactly the right analogy, Patrick. And just to refresh our listeners memory, the reason that GE is so relevant is that BBB-rated bonds in general are the last grade of investment-quality bonds. If they get downgraded just one rung from there, they're no longer investment-grade. And that doesn't mean that some people will feel inclined to sell them. It means that institutional holders will be required to sell them by mandate. And if that happens, we could see a really major dislocation in credit markets, and I think it could spread contagion into the junk bond market as well. So the question is, has the BBB-rated tranche of investment-grade credit— that's the lowest-rated investment-grade credit— is it actually junk in disguise that we just didn't know was junk, and are we just starting to find that, hey, junk really does mean junk. Now, until now, what's been going on is bond yields have been plunging, is that the value of junk bonds has been just going to the moon.
They're moving in sympathy with Treasuries, as if that additional credit risk that's represented by their lower credit rating didn't matter. What if it's about to start mattering and start mattering a whole lot? That's the real question. So far in today's market, market action that's not being discounted. If it is being discounted next week, we're definitely taking credit and saying MacroVoices is where it all started.
But the question is, what happens next? And we have to remember too, it could be that the people that Markopolos is working with are frauds and they've been playing him in order to use his name in order to do some sleazy short sale deal, and then maybe GE did nothing wrong. Frankly, if I had to flip a coin, I would guess that There's something very real here. And I think that you're right, that it could be the catalyst to start a major dislocation in credit markets if it's real.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so this is where I wanted to move on and actually talk about where investment-grade bonds and high-yield bonds are trading by just looking at the ETFs that represent them, right? So on page 10, we have the chart for the investment-grade bond ETF, the LQD And when we're looking at this chart, I find it fascinating, this beautiful uptrend that investment-grade corporate bonds have been in. And really, I guess the best way to describe it is that as interest rates have been collapsing on government debt, that has basically caused almost all bond proxies and corporate bonds and everything to rise as the structural interest rates are going down. And so we've had this enormous enormous rally. And what you can see on page 11 is I show the credit spreads of the BBBs over that of Treasury. And what we can see here is that the credit spreads have actually been rather narrow. In other words, all that's been happening is that these investment-grade bonds have been more or less moving in lockstep with Treasuries on the upside.
And this is a beautiful bond market rally occurring. But we now are continuing to hear more and more people voice their concerns with yield curve inversions and all of this, that US recession is imminent.
And one thing that we have seen is that whether it's an economic slowdown or an outright recession, that it tends to put stress onto corporates, whether or not investment grade or junk, which usually causes that credit spread to widen. As an example, in 2016, even though we never saw a US recession officially, the credit spreads blew out all the way to 300 basis points back then. And so we're— here we are trading at 165 basis points, potentially, you know, a stone's throw away from a potential recession. And these credit spreads have not begun even to widen.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, going back to slide 10, we should point I should point out that the LQD ETF represents investment-grade bonds generally, not just BBBs. Probably about half of the contents of LQD are BBB, the others are higher rated. So it's not quite apples to apples there. But what we can see, I think, if you look at slide 10, and then we move on to slide 12, which is junk bonds, the junk bond chart looks much more similar to an S&P 500 chart. Yeah. Stock market chart than it does to that straight-up line that we saw on LQD. So there's a little bit of risk being discounted here, but I would say not enough risk. We're still seeing high-yield bonds acting as if nothing's wrong, and I, I think that that junk rating is not really being discounted in prices as much as it should be. So what do you think the trade is here?
Should we be looking at something like shorting JNK and HYG against a long in Treasuries in order to hedge out that risk of even lower interest rates?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. Now, the one thing to observe— and now I don't know the exact math because I didn't do it, but I've heard a number of people reference the idea that the correlation of the junk bond markets or the HYG is like as much as 80% to equity. So you have a very equity like component feel to the, uh, junk bonds. With that said, the breakdown here is clearly that the high yield looks like it's topping and rolling over. It looks like it's a, it's a much more relevant trade here. The problem here is obviously you have to be very careful with your timing. You can't really just short sell and hold the high yield market because you have that huge negative carry of the yield. So you really have to have a confidence that the break is happening now, right? And I think that it's certainly worth exploring going into this period of September, October, which are generally periods where equities do very poorly.
If we start seeing that, that yields bottom on the broader markets just because they've overshot, then maybe the whole thing starts to sell here. I mean, it's certainly worth exploring a trade. The problem is, is in the options market, the options are not that liquid. And, you know, you'll pretty much have to go in there and be aggressive with it if you believe that this move is imminent, right?
Erik Townsend: Well, and we should mention too, a lot of people think that from a seasonality standpoint that market crashes happen in October. But actually, Patrick, the real seasonality pattern there is that October is the month you tend to remember because that's when the worst of it happened. But usually those October crashes actually followed a high that occurred in August. And now we are in the second half of August, or, or we will be in one more day. It's the second half of August, which is when stock markets usually peak before they get into really serious trouble in the fall. So from a seasonality perspective, what we're seeing here would make sense if maybe The big selling is upon us. I think we, we really need to talk more about the technical levels that you think are important. Where would you throw in the towel and say, okay, look, it's time to say the bear market is really on here, we're not headed back to all-time highs, we've got clear and decisive indications that it's over?
Is it a particular price level or some other indication?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, on the S&P 500, just the fact that the sell-off that occurred here at the start of August was so deep in its magnitude that it almost wiped out the entire June to July rally. Immediately, from a technical perspective, starts to look like a topping formation. Some technicians will want to cookie cutter a head and shoulder style looking pattern on top of there. It's certainly possible, but to me, definitely we've hit some intermediate top now. For me, like you were talking about in the market wrap, the fact that the selling almost immediately reversed that update is telling you that the sellers are not done selling. For me, there's immediate vulnerability for the market to still continue this downwards. Now, measured move targets down towards about 2,700 on the S&P. And so if we break this 2,820 level, really there is still room. There's a pretty good air pocket in there. where we could see the selling drop a solid 100 S&P points in short order.
But then it'll be really interesting is if we kind of bounce from those levels back into September, things to calm down. And then we sort of have this around the Fed when we have quadruple witching coming in all sorts of different crosscurrents, whether that is where the really bigger sell-off may ensue.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we're going to be taking a couple of weeks off at a very interesting time. And as much as I've been wrong before,
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And I think I was on the show before saying I think it's finally time for gravity to set in. I won't be the slightest bit surprised if when we come back the first week of September, if we're looking at lower numbers on the S&P. But time will tell. And for those of you who want even more of Patrick's fantastic chartbook content, be sure to sign up to attend the Toronto Money Show on September 21st. The All-Stars of Options event is being hosted there. Patrick is headlining along with a couple of other speakers. You can find all of the details on page 15 of the chartbook, or you can find that information at BigPictureTrading.com. Attendance is free for the All-Stars of Options in Toronto, and if you like free stuff, you should also sign up for a free trial of BigPictureTrading.com.
All of that information is available on the website. Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy of The Many Flavors of Trend Following and subscribe to their podcast as well. You'll be glad you did. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please go to macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo.
And be sure to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free research roundup Roundup email each week, which provides links to all of the best content that we could find on the internet. Patrick, tell them what to expect in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Daniel, as well as a link to the charts that we discussed about General Electric in the postgame. You'll also find that link to the GE fraud website. There's also a really interesting article discussing Jeffrey Gundlach warning that the Fed cut Cutting rates will not stop a US recession. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening and we'll see you all next week.
Erik Townsend: Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information Please. Register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week.
You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants. And do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital. Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Ronnie Stoeferle — fund manager and principal author of the highly respected In Gold We Trust report (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 179 was recorded on August 8th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the only podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, which I highly recommend. Gold broke through $1,500 an ounce this week. That's fully $150 an ounce above the key resistance level at $1,350 to $1,377, which had been in place for the last 5 years. So, we're bringing you a gold special this week, and there will be plenty more precious metals-related content in coming weeks on MacroVoices. Ronnie Stoeferle, fund manager and principal author of the highly respected In Gold We Trust report, will be joining me as this week's feature interview guest, and we'll cover a host of topics ranging from fundamentals to current technical levels. Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, when Patrick and I will take a big step back from our Market Wraps' usual short timeframe perspective and discuss the big picture, explaining why I'm convinced that gold will be the asset to own in the next decade.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's dive right into this S&P 500, 'cause that's some pretty serious volatility we've been seeing. What's your take on what's happening in the markets?
Erik Townsend: Well, we've already retraced 50% of the panic move down. I think that it's probably no surprise that we had this panic move down. The question is, what's next? And I think it really hinges on what President Trump's intentions are. In the past, most of the time when he suddenly comes up with a bold tweet announcing that there's going to be some new aggressive policy, it seems to me that it's usually part of a negotiating strategy. And I won't be surprised if behind the scenes You know, there's some negotiation, and maybe we find out that this 10% tariff was more of a threat than an actual intention to impose that tariff long-term. And I speculate that President Trump may be using it as a negotiating tactic to pressure China to agree to some kind of deal which is more in liking with what he desires.
The thing is, and Dr. Pippa Malmgren talked about this in her All-Stars episode, There's an attitude in the United States like, hey, we're the United States, we're in charge here, we've got all the power, we're holding all the cards, we're going to tell China how it's going to be and they're going to play ball because we're the, the big dog.
A lot of people outside the United States don't see it that way. They think China is holding more of the cards than the United States is. And I think there's a very real possibility that President Trump is very aggressive in his negotiations. He gets to the point where he says, okay, I'm finally willing to, to make a concession and Make a deal with you guys, and they say, no thanks.
Now, at the same time, same guest, Pippa Malmgren, has also said China is viewing this as this president, President Trump, will probably be their last chance to make the magnitude of deal that they would very much like to make.
So both parties have a strong incentive to come to terms, and I think if they do come to terms, if we suddenly got an announcement that, okay, there's been another negotiation, turns out that Trump and Xi have been hanging out at Mar-a-Lago and everything's better now. I think we're going straight to all-time highs on the stock market despite all of the economic slowdown and all of the very good reasons that I see to be bearish. I think that if this China thing blows over, it's probably going to take us back to all-time highs even though it doesn't make sense to me. On the other hand, if you were gonna see the beginning of a really big bad bear market, this is what it would look like: a big panic spike down, 50% retrace, and then perhaps the selling resumes. So I think it really is a question of of what policymakers are going to do next.
And a truce with China would go one direction. More aggressive talk would probably take us back down and back down hard. But Patrick, I couldn't help as I was describing that but think of the trade that you described in a webinar and also in some of our past postgame segments. For any new listeners who are not familiar with the calendar straddle trade, I'm guessing that you guys are knocking it out of the park with that trade. How's it been going with this recent volatility?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, the market drop that finally came here finally put the trade in motion. I mean, we were fighting the theta monster for months, and it was a little more challenging than the past 2 market tops. But with this break, we were able to roll down the call and lock it in. So we're in a pretty good situation here and looking to find out whether there's another round of selling coming in the weeks to come.
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, Erik, let's move on to the dollar index because obviously we attempted to break to an all-time new high and then came right back in into that range. What's your take on the dollar here?
Erik Townsend: Well, what some people are saying is they're saying, okay, this is a false breakout. You know, you broke above 98, and technical analysis tells you that if you break above a level and it doesn't last and you end up going back below that breakout zone, that's a false breakout. It's a very bearish signal. The way I see it, it's a little different than that. I think that the dollar bull case was at first being proven correct. That breakout past 98 and the rapid acceleration to the upside After the breakout, it all spelled dollar moving much higher. 104, here we come.
Well, the fact that we've had a really big pullback in response to the President of the United States basically starting a currency war is really no surprise. The question is what happens next? I'm still long dollar index futures. I'm still leaning towards the case that the global dollar liquidity squeeze, which is very, very real, is going to trump— pardon the pun— other factors in the market. And the reason I say that, Patrick, is that my leaning is I don't think that President Trump really wants to have a currency war with China. I think that he's talking tough and negotiating and eventually wants to make a deal and call a truce. If we really go into an all-out competitive devaluation currency war, no-holds-barred currency war, then that changes everything. And we've really gotta rethink the, the strategy on the dollar. But so far, I'm sticking with my bullish view. And as Jeff Snider said, it's not really a bullish view in the sense of thinking the dollar is really strong and going to move higher for economic reasons.
It's a, I think the price of the dollar goes up relative to other currencies because of the liquidity squeeze.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because we see not only US trading right back down to the June lows, but Brent oil is trading all the way back towards January trade ranges. What's going on here in crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, let's start with the EIA. Crude oil building 2.4 million barrels. Everybody was expecting another drawdown after a long series of big drawdowns. Cushing, Oklahoma had a drawdown of 1.5 million barrels. That was smaller than expected, though. Gasoline building a massive 4.4 million barrels. Distillates building 1.6 million barrels. So we've got builds across the board. And needless to say, the tape action was a nosedive in reaction to that. We were already very Very hard down on the day before the data came out, and I think everybody was expecting a great big reversal as big drawdowns came in, and we got builds instead, and it was an instantaneous down. US production ticked up to 12.3 million barrels. That's up 100,000 barrels. It's within 100,000 barrels of the all-time high set a few weeks ago. I think that's a really, really important point. The idea that some people were fearing, which is maybe US production is going to start declining as the shale drillers are pressured by lower oil prices, Hasn't happened yet.
The U.S. production is still cranking along. Imports up to 7.1 million barrels, exports down to only 1.9 million barrels. And I would think that the trade war tensions probably contributed to lower exports. There's your explanation right there for why we got all of these inventory builds. It's because of the very low export number combined with the high import number. Doesn't necessarily look to me like a sustainable trend. It may be just a one-off anomaly. It would be very interesting to see what the data tells us ahead.
The thing is, as much as this was very bearish news, it resulted in an aggressive sell-off back down to just above $50. The low print was actually around $50.55. $50 even has been a really, really strong support level recently. So if we break it decisively, I think we're going back down to the Christmas low of whatever it was, $49-something. $47.50. 4 or something. But on the other hand, Patrick, as I said, it's been a really solid support level.
And something that everybody else seems to have forgotten about, but I haven't, is Iran. Yeah, I know that President Trump said he was willing to negotiate and work on things, but I don't see the risk of further conflict with Iran being totally out of the system yet. And that could be a catalyst for a move to the upside. Feels to me like we're a little bit oversold here. So we'll see what happens, but certainly if the trade war gets bigger and gets worse and it really looks like we're headed toward a global recession, then anything's possible to the downside.
Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to gold because we obviously have Ronnie coming on, but what's your take with gold above $1,500?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm gonna save the big picture for the postgame segment. That's where we'll talk about the long-term outlook. What I want to talk about now in the market wrap is just what you said, that $1,500, breaking above $1,500, that was a serious news event and some Something I noticed, there was no round number resistance. We basically went right through $1,500 without— you know, usually you hit a round number like that and you kind of bounce off of it and trade off $50 and then come back and try it again, and the third time's the charm. We went straight through it. So I really think that this gold chart is looking incredibly bullish for the long term. But the caveat here is it's also starting to really take a parabolic form now. So So I think it really comes down to the US dollar currency war question. If we're going to see an escalation of tension with China, if we're really going to get into a currency war scenario, hey, there is no limit to the upside for gold.
But if we were to see some kind of truce between Trump and Xi and they back off on the very aggressive rhetoric that's been coming from both sides recently, I think there's plenty of room for a very significant correction here. It's just a correction, but just to go back down and retest that breakout zone of $1,350 to $1,377, which would be a very typical thing after a breakout, you go back down, you retest what used to be a resistance level as a support level, that's $150 of downside, that's a pretty big correction. So I won't be surprised if that's in our future, especially if there's some kind of truce in this whole trade war thing. But if the trade war accelerates, there's no limit to the upside, Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, I want to move on to the 10-year Treasury yields because, wow, I mean, we went almost down to— or did we hit 160? Wow, just like it— just a drop in yields so quickly here. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Holy cow, Patrick. You know, I thought we were going lower in yield, but we had gone so far so fast, I thought there's got to be some kind of a pullback here. I was waiting for that buying opportunity, and, uh, I missed it. And at this point, it's It's moved so far, I'm not gonna chase it. I am frustrated with myself for missing the trade. You didn't miss the trade though. I know you and your members at Big Picture Trading have been long TLT for, for what, more than a year now? Give us a little bit of an update. And I think I saw that you sold yesterday.
Do you think the move is over or has it just gone so far so fast that it's time to take profits?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, we've been bullish on the TLT for like 18 months and it's, it's just been a great run. But with this parabolic rise almost at the tail end here, Like at some point you have to take your money. And while I still think yields can go much lower, at some stage when you have this kind of a move, you have to lock in those gains, right? And it's been a great move.
Patrick Ceresna: And now we're just gonna have to see how this continues to play out here. So Erik, why a gold special and why Ronnie Stoeferle?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I wanna start with why a gold special. This will be the start of a trend here on MacroVoices toward a lot more precious metals content. And I've intentionally kind of gone I've been soft on gold for the last several years, and the reason is I just feel that there are so many gold bug podcasts out there. There are so many of these guys that are just singing the story that it's always time to buy gold. If you want to hear that, there's lots of other places to hear it. Now, I will admit to having gotten a tactical call wrong. I thought that the dollar breakout, which does still appear to be happening— I'm still leaning toward that happening— I thought it was going to create a headwind for gold.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: That it wasn't quite time yet, and I was wrong on that call. It's pretty clear now from this breakout that we're moving into something that I've anticipated for many years.
I've always said that gold is not going to be just an interesting asset, but it's going to be the asset to own in the 2020s.
And Ray Dalio did a better job of articulating the reasons than I could possibly do. We had a link a couple of weeks ago in the Research Roundup to his article on the subject. Essentially, we've got We've got dual bubbles in the stock and bond markets. Financial markets are being held up by central bank-supplied liquidity, and that's an unsustainable long-term pattern. It can't go on forever. Exactly when it will end and when we're going to experience what Ray Dalio calls a paradigm shift is not completely clear, but what the gold market is telling us is it maybe has started a little sooner than I thought it was going to start.
So I feel that there's lots and lots of coverage in the podcast world about precious metals, and especially some of the conspiracy theories and, you know, how you can put JP Morgan out of business by buying silver coins. That always was a source of amusement to me to read that stuff. We're not going to do that. We're going to do gold for grownups because it really is a very important asset class to understand for the next decade. And I think it's going to be incredibly important. And I wanted to start with a well-respected guest. And Ronnie has a very broad background. He's the principal author of In Gold We Trust, which is an annual report that covers the fundamentals. He talks about comparing gold versus cryptocurrencies and, you know, all of these different subjects, physical vaulting of gold, allocated and unallocated storage, a whole bunch of concepts that we will be getting into in future episodes of MacroVoices. Ronnie just seemed like a really solid guy who's not another conspiracy theorist, but somebody who really understands this market.
So I wanted to start with him, and we'll be having more precious metals-oriented content in the weeks and months ahead.
Erik Townsend: And this episode of MacroVoices with Ronnie Stoeferle was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. You often hear me say that even if I have conviction about a market or a trade, you have to listen to what the market is telling you, not what you think it should be doing. And that's exactly what trend-following managers have been doing for decades with great success. These are rules-based strategies that remove human emotions and therefore can be well-researched and tested. And there's one podcast that covers trend-following strategies better than any other: TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book called The Many Flavors of Trend Following, explaining exactly how these systematic strategies can work for you. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro.
Check them out, you'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Ronnie Stoeferle is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Gold is on everyone's mind this week, and we've got a gold heavyweight for you for today's feature interview. I'm joined now by Ronnie Stoeferle, who is managing partner, founder, and fund manager for Incrementum. He's also probably best known as the principal author of In Gold We Trust, which is probably one of the most respected— I think it's annually republished documents that really makes the whole fundamental case. If you haven't read it yet, I strongly recommend it.
Ronnie Stoeferle: Thank you.
Erik Townsend: I highly recommend it, and we do have it linked to your Research Roundup email. Ronnie, thanks so much for joining us. I want to dive into some fairly advanced topics with you today, but just for the benefit of any newer listeners who may not be familiar with the high-level picture, let's start with gold. Why is it so important?
Why is— I'm convinced it will be the asset to own in the next decade, but let's hear it from you, your perspective. Why would we care about gold in our portfolios?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Hi, Erik. Thanks for having me. It's been a while and I'm really looking forward to this. Well, I have to say that gold is an extremely emotional topic. It seems that everybody has an opinion on gold. They're either radical gold bugs or people that hate gold. So from my point of view, I'm not a radical gold fundamentalist. It is not a religion. It is a prudent, and I would say some sort of an inexpensive hedge against recession risks, against equity risks. And inflation. So my finance guy view on gold is that it's some sort of an option on aggressive monetary policies, a potential monetary endgame. It is a zero-yielding asset, of course, and therefore a long-duration asset. And as currently, as the market moves to the view of lower interest rates, gold should not only begin to outperform shorter-duration asset classes, it should also— continued to show a very high inverse correlation to bond yields. This is basically what we're seeing at the moment.
But nothing more, nothing less. So that's kind of the finance guy view that I have on gold.
On the other hand, I'm writing the In Gold We Trust report for 13 years now. And many people think this must be the most boring job one can have. But we published more than 3,000 pages of research about gold and all influencing factors. And it's still continues to fascinate me because there's so many different things involved. Of course, opportunity costs like equity markets, bond markets, inflation. It's about geopolitics. It's about development in our society. So I think it's really something, something extremely fascinating. It is no coincidence that the history of the world is also a history of gold. And if you study gold, you will learn that That basically it is precious and valued on every continent, in every religion, in every society. So if you learn about monetary history, of course you learn about gold. And that's a bit something that perhaps differentiates us from many other people in the gold industry.
We really try to make this holistic view. As you can hear perhaps, I'm not only— I've got an Austrian accent. So I was born in Vienna. And And therefore, I very much adhere to the Austrian School of Economics. And therefore, what's really important for us is to explain people stuff like the stock-to-flow ratio, for example. I often hear that the annual supply and annual demand for gold is so important, but that's totally, totally useless. We once called that the greatest misunderstanding in the gold sector. So if you understand the stock-to-flow ratio of gold, you will see gold from a completely different viewpoint. And those are the things that we try to, to analyze and to explain in our reports. And I think that's something that makes us a bit different from the rest of the analysts in the, in the gold space.
Erik Townsend: I want to talk now about something that's probably the hardest thing in trading, which is getting the timing right. Sometimes when an asset makes a big sudden move, it's a signal. You want to jump on it because it's the beginning of something really, really big. But almost, I'd say, more often, those big moves, if you chase them, you know, there ends up being a retrace and you get clobbered. Is it time here, with the really big move that we've seen up in gold in recent weeks to the upside, is it time to fade it because it's overdue for a retrace? Or is it time to really feel like, hey, this thing is really taking off, we're gonna jump in with both feet here?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think we were gonna talk about the technical details a bit later on, but, but from my point of view, it is crystal clear we are are in a bull market again. You can see that every dip is being bought at the moment. You can see that even diehard gold bugs, they still not really believe in this move. And from what I see talking to institutional clients, we have seen that in 4th quarter 2018, when basically every asset class was down, stocks had their worst performance in December since the Great Depression. This was a big warning shot for many institutional investors. And I think then Then gold reappeared on their radar screens. Of course, then first quarter was pretty good, especially for equity markets. But now as we're above this massive resistance zone at $1,360, $1,380, this is basically exactly what we explained in our 2019 gold report.
We have seen massive momentum kicking in. We have seen that institutional buyers were going into gold again. Massive flows in the ETFs, in the physical market, but also in the mining stocks. From my point of view, Erik, at the moment we're in some sort of a macro regime shift. So we have seen more and more dovish comments by central banks. We are seeing all those really complex trade and geopolitics and recession risks strengthening. So the breakout of gold is basically some sort of a recalibration of commonly accepted macroeconomic fundamentals. I think We are pricing in or discounting recession risks. So from our point of view, from a let's say from a longer perspective, we really like the commodity complex at the moment because gold has now taken the leadership role, a bit like in the commodity upturn in 1976-1977. Now silver is following, and we wouldn't be surprised if commodity would be next.
Next, we make the case, we compare the current situation a bit to the 1970s and the 2000s where we first had extremely expansionary and aggressive monetary policy, then a booming stock market, and subsequently a decade of surging commodity prices.
So we have seen very, very aggressive and let's say experimental monetary policy. But it hasn't reached commodity markets and the gold market yet. So this is one of our core theses.
The second one that I want to briefly talk about is inflation. Of course, gold is highly correlated to inflation. We know that the US dollar is or has been some sort of the linchpin of this deflationary mindset. And therefore, I think, you know, the strong dollar has kept commodity prices, has constrained growth in emerging markets, and fueled capital flows to the US. It seems that this is now changing. For inflation, I think that June was the low and we expect rising inflation in 4th quarter. We have seen just recently the PCE rose quite sharply. On the other hand, 5-year breakeven rates just fell to 1.4%. And we are also seeing deflationary pressure with, you know, MZM, but also Also M2 growth being pretty sluggish. But it seems that, you know, this inflationary pressure— and this is exactly what central bankers and politicians want to achieve— this is building. And, and probably in the next couple of quarters, inflation might become a concern.
We shouldn't forget, at the moment there's probably like $13 trillion in bonds with negative yields. My home country Austria just sold a century bond with the yield of 1. So, so actually for governments, the biggest hope is rising inflation, while for investors, that's probably the biggest pain trade that you can imagine— rising inflation. And it is very much of a contrarian topic nowadays.
The second reason why I think that gold might be a pretty good idea at the moment is that it's a pretty good equities hedge. We have seen that in fourth quarter, basically every asset class was down. But mining stocks, gold mining stocks were up 17% and gold was up 7% too. So gold worked well as a portfolio hedge.
And now we are seeing, we're working quite a lot with ratio charts. And the ratio charts of gold and gold stocks versus the S&P 500 just broke out. And this is a very, very strong sign for us.
When it comes to the equity markets, I mean, that's no secret for you and your listeners. We are in an earnings recession. So we We've basically seen 3 quarters in a row with falling profits. We're seeing pretty big divergences in equity markets. So basically the S&P and the Nasdaq is one of the very, very few really strong equity markets. I mean, today not so much. And most of the other equity markets all over the globe, they are already showing lower highs. So there's a big divergence. It's also internally In the US, you know, Dow Jones Transports, the small caps, they are already pretty weak. Then we're seeing losing momentum.
We're seeing pretty low volume in US equity markets. So we are, from my point of view, in a process of rolling over. And what we've seen in the last couple of weeks, this unusual calmness and the deterioration in breadth, it's not a very good setup. setup for pretty overvalued stocks, I would say.
So the big question from a portfolio point of view is, will bonds again be a good equities hedge in the next downturn? We shouldn't forget, in 2008, US Treasuries were trading at yields around 3.5% to 4% before the downturn. The 10-year bonds from Germany had a yield of 4%. Now, even the 30-year German yields are negative. So from my point of view, gold might be a much better hedge than bonds in the next bear market.
And then the third point is gold as a recession hedge. We crunched the numbers in our last gold reports and it's absolutely sure that gold is a very, very good hedge in recessions. We're already seeing that the bond market has perfectly signaled that, yeah, we're seeing some sort of a global cooling. In the US, In the US, I think it's a bit different as we're seeing that government spending is skyrocketing higher. It was up 5% annualized. While in the Eurozone, it seems that we're really, of course, especially Germany, but also France, Spain, and so on, they're coming in weaker and weaker. And it's not only the Eurozone. It is really a synchronized global slowdown. So Mrs. Thunberg, she might be scared of this global cooling that we're seeing at the moment. 64% of the world, we are seeing PMIs coming in negative. 11 countries— that's according to Dave Rosenberg— 11 countries have posted at least one negative quarterly contraction, and 16 central banks have cut rates already.
So from my point of view, in this, you know, we are seeing a pretty, pretty long period of growth.
I still believe in cycles, although central bankers want to get rid of those economic cycles. So from my point of view, a recession And the recession is something just normal, something healthy, is around the corner. Perhaps we're already in a pre-recession phase. And gold, according to our research, is a pretty good diversifier and a pretty good hedge in a recessionary environment.
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, for dollar bears, this is easy. If you think the dollar is done here, it's so easy. You've just— you're way late, but you want to be in But a lot of us, myself included, feel that there is a very strong argument that there's been a US dollar liquidity squeeze globally, and that that is causing the dollar to appreciate against other currencies, and that that would potentially create a headwind for gold. So for US dollar-based investors who care about what their ultimate return is in US dollars, That was a real concern. Now, in the last few days with President Trump's actions on China, we've seen the US dollar take a nosedive. But before that, it really was breaking out above, just as gold broke above a key technical level, the dollar was also breaking out.
And I guess what it really brings to my mind is, you know, for a long time I've argued that someday we're gonna get to where gold and the dollar move up together. And frankly, that's not a good thing. That means that the world is getting really scary. There's a double safety trade into both gold and dollars at the same time, and they both move up. Is that already happening? Is that what we're seeing here, or is there more to this story? And, you know, how do you feel about the dollar? How do you feel about a US dollar-gold long, long pairs trade? What do you see in, in terms of the relationship with the dollar?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, you know, I love listening to your show, and, and I'm very proud to, to call Brent Johnson but also Luke Gromen friends of mine. And, and we did lots of work together with them. We interviewed them for In Gold We Trust report, so I think actually their views are pretty similar. It's just that the time, the timing is is the big difference. From my point of view, you know, our clients are mostly euro or Swiss franc based. So I would say if you compare on a longer term basis the euro versus the U.S. dollar performance, it is actually very very similar.
You know, just like since 2004, for example, the annual average performance in dollar terms of gold is 9.3%, while on a euro basis it's 10.3%. So that's not a very, very big difference actually.
The only paper currency that really, really outperformed, I would say, on a relative basis, so where this loss of purchasing power wasn't And that dramatic since 1971, we are calculating most of our numbers since 1971 because that was like the beginning of this new monetary era, was the Swiss franc. And it's no coincidence because the Swiss franc until May 2000 was backed with 40% gold. And this was one of the main reasons why the Swiss franc has always been this safe haven currency. So from my point of view, it is— I can really understand and follow the case that you and also Brent Johnson make for a strong dollar within the environment of a liquidity crunch.
The question is what would then happen? We would see major volatility in emerging markets. We would see very strong deflationary pressure in the US. And actually, that's the very last thing that Donald Trump and the Federal Reserve want. So I expect that they would take countermeasures pretty quickly. Of course, the big difference or the big question is also always the time lag. You know, let's remember what happened in 2008 and when equity markets really started to move. That was like 5 months after, basically.
From my point of view, when it comes to the correlation between gold and the US dollar, we wrote about that last year. And of course, the consensus always seems to be that a strong dollar automatically means lower gold prices. And this theory can empirically be substantiated. So the negative correlation is 0.5.
But our quantitative analysis shows that there's some sort of an asymmetrical correlation. So a strong US dollar does much less damage to the gold price than a weak US dollar does to gold. And it seems that this historical pattern is currently changing. From my point of view, I'm not 100% sure about the reason of this change. And it seems that this, what we call the autonomous rate of increase, so the rate of the gold price increase that is independent of exchange rate fluctuations, might continue to rise. And I think the main reason is probably that 70% 70% of all gold demand is nowadays coming from emerging markets. So we'll see.
What's good for the US dollar doesn't always have to be bad for gold. We're seeing at the moment that gold is pretty strong, that equity markets are extremely weak, and that at the moment this safe haven move into the US dollar doesn't really happen.
We wrote recently that the US dollar feels like a stock that doesn't rise on good news anymore. I mean, structurally, I wouldn't say that I'm a big euro bull. But it is like, you know, I have never met in the last couple of months probably somebody being really bullish the euro. It is a bit like finding a polar bear in the Sahara, or I once said, like a good song on a Britney Spears album. So, I mean, we're having so many troubles over here. You know, there's the Brexit mess, Italy's open rebellion against the stability pact. We've got the Yellow Vests in France. We've got Germany being on the verge of a recession. But still the euro, from my point of view, is holding up pretty much okay. So the reaction to the news, from my point of view, is pretty strong.
So long story short, from my point of view going forward, it won't be a huge difference if you hold gold in euro, in US dollar terms, or in whatever other fiat currency. I think it's just a very, very good hedge and a very safe currency going forward.
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, a lot of really smart people have convinced themselves that the 35-plus-year bond bull market ended in 2016 and that we are now in a secular bear market, meaning that we should expect steadily increasing interest rates, which of course would compete with gold because the more you've got real interest as an alternative to gold, which is a zero-yielding asset, the more that tends to hurt gold. So that doesn't happen to be my view. I don't agree with that. But a lot of smart people think that. So if that were true, if the bond bull market really is over, how would that affect the outlook for gold?
Ronnie Stoeferle: First of all, I would say I don't think that the US Treasuries bull market is over. I mean, over here in Europe, you've seen that now even 30-year bonds are trading with negative yields. If you follow the European bond markets, it really looks like this blow-off top that comes at the very end of every trend. So from my point of view, the developments over here in the Eurozone are really scary. And every pension fund manager that buys, you know, German 10 years with significantly negative rates now guarantees that he's gonna destroy cash.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ronnie Stoeferle: When it comes to the US, I'm not sure. I, from my point of view, I sense that we will see zero yields for US Treasuries before we see 5%. So why shouldn't US Treasuries trade at zero yields or even negative yields in the course of the next recession?
Erik, I remember a couple of years ago we had a meeting and I think the bond future was trading at 120 or 121. It must have been like 2011, 2012. And somebody told me that it is mathematically impossible that the bond future would trade above 160 because that would basically imply negative yields. Now the bond future is trading at 175. So why shouldn't US Treasuries go significantly lower? And I don't see any blow-off top in US Treasuries at the moment. Of course, the 2 years made a big move, the 10 years make a big move, but I don't see such a big move yet in the Treasuries. And, you know, normally equities, you know, the bond market has been sort of diverging from equities. Normally I would say the bond market is right and he signaled this global cooldown pretty well. So from my point of view, having a short position or no position in equities probably is a pretty safe bet. And as I've said, I think the 10 years, I mean, they're not cheap anymore.
But from my point of view, they'd rather go to 0% before they go to 5%.
Erik Townsend: 10 years ago, when Russian economist Sergey Glazyev started this de-dollarization campaign, trying to persuade countries around the world to reduce their use of US dollars in order to reduce the ability of the US government to control the financial system through its currency, frankly, at the time, 10 years ago, when that started, it was ignored by most of But it's really come around to the point now where even the European Union has warmed up to this idea of eliminating dependence on the US dollar.
So, what does this mean for gold? And I guess it also brings a related question to mind, which is, how much do we really know about sovereign gold holdings and the trends? Because that certainly is an indication. If people really do want to dump the dollar, then you would expect to see more increases in gold holdings.
Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: increases in sovereign gold holdings around the world?
Ronnie Stoeferle: When it comes to sovereign gold holdings, as far as I know it from conversations with central bankers, I think the gold community often thinks that everything central bankers do is just sit on their Bloomberg screens and just follow the price of gold. I think for them, it is something that, of course, they have a look at. But it is not something that they focus on every time. So I think this is a bit of a misinterpretation in the gold scene quite often.
But this de-dollarization that we're seeing at the moment, that's a big trend. And I think many people think that the US dollar will be kicked from the throne by the Chinese yuan, by the euro, whatever. But if you study the history of reserve currencies, you can see that it always takes many, many years, mostly decades. And we just finished reading this wonderful book by Barry Eichengreen about reserve currencies and the fate of reserve currencies. And you can see that basically the British pound and the US dollar, they were basically both reserve currencies alongside each other for many decades.
But we are seeing a strong trend when it comes to gold from emerging markets. And if we take a step back, I would say it's interesting that gold always moves out of countries where the capital stock is declining and it flows into countries where capital accumulation is taking place, where the economy is prospering, and where the volume of savings is increasing. We've seen that, you know, the Romans realized that more than 2,000 years ago when the Chinese and the Indians The Persians accepted only gold and not Roman goods in exchange for spices and silk. So gold goes where the money is, and it came to the United States between World Wars I and II.
Remember, the US had more than 30,000 tons of gold, which also, of course, later on was the basic for the Bretton Woods agreement, I would say. Then it was transferred to Europe in the post-war period. We've seen the gold drain, the Germans and the French, of course, wanting their gold back. Then it went to Japan, to the Middle East in the 1970s and 1980s. And now it is going to China, it is going to Russia, it is going to India, to Vietnam. We travel those countries quite a lot. We just started publishing the In Gold We Trust report in Chinese as well. And you can tell, you know, those guys, they are really in for the long game. They don't care about daily price fluctuations. They really want to accumulate gold on a monthly basis. They see it as a monetary hedge. And we shouldn't forget that in 2020, 50% of the world GDP will be generated by emerging markets, while in 2000 it was only 19%.
So I think this is some sort of— a friend of mine calls this the love trade— with those emerging market economies really, really having a high affinity for gold.
And we're not seeing it for the central banks where, of course, Russia, China, but also recently Turkey, Poland, and so on. They are buying gold. It is also private people from those, from those countries. Last year we have seen that central banks purchased 650 tons of gold. This year, according to the World Gold Council, it will probably be 750 tons. So it is really a big increase compared to the last couple of years. And we're seeing, for example, I mentioned Poland. Poland is the largest purchaser in the last quarter. They bought more than 100 tons. And it is not only that they are buying gold, they are also repatriating it.
And this brings me to this loss of trust on the international level that we were describing in the last gold report. And I think there's in general many, many things going on with this whole de-dollarization. So, Europe has taken, you know, the new US sanctions against Iran and now wants to build up the infrastructure when it comes to payment systems. Jean-Claude Juncker, he just said that it is absurd that Europe imports crude oil and gas worth around $300 billion annually but pays 80 to 90% of those imports in US dollars. So I think there's quite a lot going on with this de-dollarization, but people should not forget that this is really a long-term topic and a long-term trend.
And of course, this trend will also have an impact on gold. Gold plays a major role in this de-dollarization game. But we should not overestimate the impact, I would say, on the shorter-term price movements in gold.
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, there has been a global change of social attitude. The social landscape is changing. There's been a rise of populism. A lot of younger people are very openly advocating a departure from capitalism in favor of socialism. We've also seen central bank policy already starting to favor zero or negative interest rates. Modern Monetary Theory, which advocates monetization of government spending, has become extremely popular.
So it seems like— and I guess the other thing is that at some point, we all know there's an inevitable day of reckoning. reckoning for all of the unfunded liabilities in the form of pension entitlements and so forth that cannot possibly be paid in the long run. How do all these things affect the long-term story for gold?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, that's a tough one. And Erik, I've got 3 little daughters and the change in the social landscape, all the populism from the very right and very left side of the spectrum. This is something that really concerns me. And yeah, it gives me sleepless nights sometimes.
We have written about this matter of trust this year. So this was basically the leitmotif. We wrote Gold in the Age of Eroding Trust. And actually, when I— 13 years ago, when I was a young analyst sitting in a bank, when I wrote my first In Gold We Trust report, I didn't realize that this name is a really good one, In Gold We Trust.
But actually, for this year's report, we studied the matter of trust quite a lot. It might sound a bit philosophical, but trust is the basic value of all interpersonal cooperation. And it is basically the foundation of our social order.
And we're seeing at the moment this erosion of trust capital. We're seeing it in society. We're seeing it, of course, in media. We're also seeing it in concepts like fundamental concepts of science. We're quoting some, some articles showing that the Flat Earth Society, for example, it is incredible how many people nowadays started believing in this stuff. And, and this is a sign that people lose trust in those fundamental concepts of science. And of course, we're seeing this loss of trust in politics. We're seeing this loss of trust in institutions.
And it is pretty frightening. There is the General Social Survey for the US, and it shows that since 2000, confidence in all institutions has eroded. So at the moment, only 1 in 5 persons still has any confidence in banks, churches, or businesses, and only 1 in 10 in government.
And I'm not sure if it's similar in North America, but over here in Europe, it seems that the level of polarization, of xenophobia, of nationalism, the loss of the middle class in, in the political realm is, is really, really frightening. It's scary. There's a huge, let's say, divide in society.
And the interesting thing is, I, I think Dave Rosenberg wrote about that quite recently, at the moment we're probably at the peak of the stock market cycle and the economic expansion. Now, if you Remember the Occupy Wall Street movement that began in September 2011? It was pretty peaceful. But now the next recession and the next stock market correction, crash, whatever, will happen with income and wealth disparities basically at the highest levels ever. So I'm not sure if the next Occupy Wall Street movement or whatever will be that peaceful. Full again.
And so this is something that's really a big concern for us over here. And this is also why I think that the 2020 US presidential elections are so important. Because it is gonna be a vote for extreme or against extreme policy proposals. I don't know if there's any voice of fiscal conservatism, of a balanced budget and spending within our means. But so far I don't really hear that voice. And the thing is, when it comes to MMT, and I think this will become a much, much bigger topic in the course of the campaigns, it is only— a friend of mine said it's only the newest addition to the central banker alphabet soup.
So those new acronyms like QE or LTRO, they always sound extremely sophisticated, but MMT is just a new darling of the inflationists. And from my point of view, I've said earlier that, that I'm very much influenced by the Austrian School of Economics. Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk, he said political power can never invalidate the economic law. And this is what we're trying to do. We try to invalidate the economic law, and this won't happen very well. We've tried that in Weimar Republic and it ended catastrophically. So from my point of view, coming back to financial markets, if some sort of MMT will be introduced, it will perhaps be a bit more fair for people. And it will have much more direct effects and quicker effects on the economy and especially on inflation. So I think if MMT really in some sort will be introduced, I think this might really be the point when the inflation gets out of the bottle.
Erik Townsend: John Maynard Keynes famously referred to the gold standard as a barbarous relic, and we have a new generation who are calling gold a barbarous relic. And their argument is, look, the whole point of gold was that it was a way to have an asset outside of the financial system that derived its value principally from its scarcity. And their argument is cryptocurrency creates a new way of essentially a high-tech solution to that problem that's better than gold. Now that we have cryptocurrency, forget about gold. It's on the way out. I personally couldn't disagree with that particular view more strongly than I do myself. But for those who may hold that view, what's your perspective?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, when it comes to cryptos, it seems— I mentioned in the beginning that gold is a very, very emotional topic and everybody seems to have a view on gold. But when it comes to Bitcoin, it is even more emotional. So, you know, from my point of view, there's actually quite a lot of similarities between gold and Bitcoin. And when you read the white paper by Satoshi Nakamoto, you can see that actually Satoshi understood gold and he understood the stock-to-flow ratio. My colleagues, they are publishing a crypto research report where we basically want to educate people about the advantages and disadvantages, about the flaws and the scams. Sometimes in the crypto scene, they regard gold as Bitcoin without electricity. So from my point of view, they are relatives, but not like father and son. Like, you know, what was it, Darth Vader and his son Luke Skywalker?
I think they're rather like cousins. And therefore, I think it's pretty strange when people from the gold industry attack people from the crypto industry and the other way around, because both are basically anti-government minds.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ronnie Stoeferle: And I think these new technologies that are coming up, they are a direct consequence of the erosion of confidence in our international monetary policies. So from my point of view, the stock-to-flow ratio that is so important for gold, you know, there's 190,000 tons of gold and the annual inflation is 3,200 tons. So basically 1.7%. It is pretty similar when it comes to Bitcoin. Bitcoin. So Bitcoin's inflation rate at the moment is 3.6% and it will slope lower. So, you know, the amount and the supply of newly Bitcoins, it kind of follows a pre-programmed, transparent, and predictable schedule. And this is totally unaffected by fluctuations in demand. So this extremely inelastic supply makes the prices of gold and Bitcoin completely dependent on their demand. Not on the supply, I would say. So I think that when it comes to gold, physical gold, let's say, it is for the younger generation, for the millennials, it is, you know, it might be a barbarous relic. They don't care about physical gold.
But at the moment, there are many gold-backed crypto things coming up, gold-backed stablecoins, and so on. I'm pretty critical when it comes to that because they are centralized. There is counterparty risk. Some of them are extremely expensive. So there's quite a lot of trust required for those gold-backed cryptocurrencies. But from my point of view, and you know what's going on in the scene, there's so much financial but also human resource moving into this market. I think it's really interesting what's developing in this whole ecosystem.
So the big question for an investor, and and I have to say that we're about to to launch a strategy with physical gold, 75% and 25% Bitcoin. The big question is: How will Bitcoin perform in a recession or a market crash? Because we haven't experienced a full cycle yet. From my point of view, I would say it will perform pretty good because there's very. Very little credit involved in the Bitcoin and in the crypto market. So normally within the bear market or a crash, it's a reallocation of credit, it's a restructuring. So I think this is the main reason why those cycles in crypto are much shorter than general market cycles. But going forward, I think, you know, Erik, will Bitcoin be around in 10 years? I'm not sure. But if it will be around, I think it will be significantly higher. I don't know, $50,000, $100,000, whatever.
Or it will go to zero.
For gold, I'm absolutely certain that it will be around in 10 years and then that it will have a monetary aspect and that it's gonna probably protect you from monetary policy, from inflation and so on. But I think, to put it in a nutshell, I think that crypto assets are here to stay. And in 5 to 10 years, I think it will be pretty normal for every asset allocator to have at least some allocation in crypto assets.
Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on something you mentioned a couple of times in that last answer, which was physical gold bullion. There's an argument that a lot of people have made, which is, look, if your reason for wanting to own gold in the first place is that it gives you some insulation from things going wrong in the financial system, then you don't want to own your gold through the financial system. So, so-called paper gold instruments such as shares in an ETF or futures Contracts, they say, are not as good as owning physical gold in your possession. To what extent is that real? And if we look at something like even some of the funds that you manage, you know, on one hand, you're running physical gold strategies, actually vaulting the bullion. But if someone's investing with you through a fund, to some extent, that's a paper instrument. They've got ownership in a fund that you're managing through a piece of paper they hold.
They don't have the gold in their own possession. What are the trade-offs in terms of physically holding your own bullion versus owning it through a financial asset like ETF shares?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think the answer is pretty easy. Every time somebody says, you know, but it's— I want— I don't want to have paper exposure, I say, okay, then buy physical gold. I mean, that's fairly easy and not expensive. And then you only have to care about, you know, how to store it. I think this whole paper versus physical gold discussion, I think sometimes it's a bit naive because we've got the same or even more extreme ratios when it comes, you know, to the paper oil or the paper copper market. But nobody is talking about that.
So I think we should not forget that gold is one of the most liquid currencies. It is basically traded 24/7. It's got very, very tight spreads. And this, from my point of view, is also the reason why in liquidity crises gold is often sold. And then most people say, okay, gold is now manipulated. But I think it is basically funds, hedge funds that desperately have to get liquidity, just dumping their gold futures. That's the main reason. But I think when it comes to funds, I mean, we're managing some gold strategies. Of course, gold is not in our possession. It is in the possession of the fund. So in German, it's called Sondervermögen. That means, yeah, it's, it's very, very much safeguarded. So I wouldn't take that as a criticism.
But on the other hand, you know, if you really want to hedge against extreme scenarios, if you want to really have what I call safety gold, then just buy physical gold. But if you want to make performance, Then you can buy mining stocks. Then you can buy futures, options, whatever. But, but I think people have to ask this question first: what is the motivation? Do I want to hedge against extreme scenarios, or do I want to make performance?
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, final question. Let's talk about technical levels. Is right now a good time to be buying, or is it time to wait for a pullback after this really big move up that we've already seen in recent weeks?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think we're, as I've said at the beginning, we're in a bull market. There will of course be pullbacks. And I think it seems that gold is really back on the watch list and everybody wants to get in. We have seen a very strong US dollar in July and gold held up extremely well. We have seen some profit taking after the rally. But it doesn't look toppy to me. And, you know, I think the whole breakout happened on very large volume, on pretty negative sentiment. sentiment. And this, this big breakout from the 4-year consolidation area, basically that the measured move would be, you know, the zone, um, the, the consolidation zone was $300. So basically the measured move would be up to $1,650. We're seeing, um, positioning when it comes to Commitments of Traders report.
Many people think it's negative, but I think this switch to gross COT longs that we have seen dominating the flows is just a sign and indicative of this buy-the-dip mentality. And there are still remarkably few gold bulls in financial markets. According to the World Gold Council, we have seen ETFs at 2,500 tons at the moment, which is worth $120 billion. So that's still fairly small, I would say, relative to other asset classes. I think, you know, Isaac Newton once said, truth is to be found in simplicity.
And if you have a look at the monthly and the quarterly chart of gold, it looks fantastic. It is confirmed by the mining stocks that look extremely good at the moment. It is supported by strong seasonals. Pre-election years are very positive. The second half of the year is especially strong. We are seeing that gold stocks— we crunched the numbers— in, in the past 65 years, in 11 of 13 rate cut Gold stocks averaged a return of 172%.
So I think, you know, we're back in the bull market, and just let's ride this bull market.
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. But before I let you go, please tell our listeners, first of all, what they can expect to find in the In Gold We Trust report, which they can find the download link in their Research Roundup email. Folks, if you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage, look for the red button that says Looking for the downloads next to Ronnie's picture. And also tell us a little bit more about what you do at Incrementum and where people can learn more about your services.
Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah, thanks, Erik, again for having me. It's been great fun. Well, the In Gold We Trust report, we are publishing it for 13 years in German, in English, and now in Mandarin. There's an extended version with roughly 340 pages, so you really have to take off at least a weekend to work through it. But it is a really high-level or holistic analysis of the gold market, about opportunity costs, about hyperinflation, about gold and Bitcoin, about mining stocks, technical analysis, and so on. You can register for it. It's totally for free.
This is basically— I feel a bit like a distillery. So I read quite a lot, books, research, whatever, and then I try to distill it once a year into the In Gold We Trust report on ingoldwetrust.li. LI, which stands for Liechtenstein, where Incrementum is based. Incrementum is an independent and owned by, you know, entrepreneurs wealth manager based in the Principality of Liechtenstein. Very, very good jurisdiction, probably the best within Europe, I would say. We're managing funds, we're doing wealth management for high net worth individuals, and you can have a look at our funds that are mostly, I would say, in the precious metals and commodity space on webpage, www.incrementum.li.
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, I can't thank you enough. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Ronnie on the show So it's a— and it's a great way to start our entire project to get more coverage on gold on MacroVoices. So you've been for the longest time talking about gold being the asset to own going forward. And so why don't we take a dive into that? And why don't you start us off with your, your kind of views and your take as to what's going on here in gold?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, the reason that I have always said that gold will be the asset to own is because the entire economic regime that we've been in for the last 10 years is one of central banks propping up asset markets with liquidity, which is money conjured into existence out of thin air through quantitative easing. That has gone on and continued to work for longer than I ever thought possible. But even Ray Dalio has been very clear saying, look, I don't know exactly when, but it can't go on much longer. And at some point, we're going to go through a paradigm shift.
We have dual bubbles in both the stock market and the bond market. Nothing is cheap. There's nothing for value investors to buy. The real problem that we had in 2008 was too much debt. We have done exactly nothing to solve that problem. What we've done is paper over our problems by propping asset markets up through central bank-supplied liquidity. Now, at some point, we've got to deal with the real problem, and there's really only one way that you can deal with that problem— actually, 2 ways. You can default completely, which I don't think is going to happen.
Or you can devalue the currency in order to inflate away the value of all of that excessive debt. And that pretty much is the only option that's going to exist here once the central bank liquidity game stops working. When exactly it stops working— are we seeing this current breakout in gold signaling to us that it has stopped working? Maybe. Maybe it's got a couple years left to go. But before too long, Patrick, we're going to come into what Ray Dalio calls a paradigm shift, and a new paradigm in which the only way for central banks to deal with the problems that we have is to devalue the currency and inflate away the value of all of that excessive debt. That has to mean that you're losing real purchasing value by holding dollars. And even though your stock prices may be going up, you might still see the stock market going up, the actual purchasing value of how many loaves of bread you can buy by selling a share of stock is going to go down as the value of the dollar itself goes down.
Gold is the time-proven hedge against that. Now, I didn't think it was quite time for this yet, but as you've heard me say even in the sponsor message in today's episode, you got to go by what the market is telling you, not what you think is supposed to happen. What I thought was supposed to happen was the global dollar liquidity squeeze, which is very real. I thought it was going to provide more of a headwind for gold than it has, and it did provide some headwind for gold, but gold is still breaking out even despite dollar strength.
So it says the game is on for gold. It's time for us to really get serious about something I've always known was coming. I didn't really focus on it as I described before the feature interview because there's so many other people covering covering gold. Now that it's timely and it really is coming into view as an asset class that we need to understand, I think it's time for us to add a lot more coverage. And there's a lot of topics that we didn't get into in this interview because we didn't have time. We didn't talk about physical vaulting of gold, paper versus physical, and all of the allocated versus unallocated bullion accounts and so on and so forth. We didn't have time to get into any of that. So we've got a lot more coming in future episodes. But why don't we go ahead and start with the chartbook that you prepared, Patrick?
Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. And our listeners that want to have a look at that chartbook can download it from their Research Roundup email or go to the MacroVoices homepage where there's a red button in the center saying, looking for downloads. So on page 2 here, Erik, I just have that monthly chart of gold going back to 2001 where the lows came in. And you can see that pronounced bull market from 2000 to 2011, that awful bear market that we've seen that since then that put in its lows in 2016. But what really is the notable thing that I think everyone is identifying is that this kind of 6-year trade range bottoming formation almost in gold has finally seen that big breakout. And, uh, for me, the breakout looks very real. But as a technician, I think the single most important thing is to see that when inevitably some profit-taking starts to happen, will it be well supported and, and will pullbacks be bought?
And if, if you see that really become pronounced during the next pullback, I think that that's really the big tell for, for the bull side of gold. What's your take on the price action?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as you can see from the chart on page 2, this big run-up in gold started around 2001. It was modest at first. It really started to get going around 2005, and it started to turn parabolic in 2007. I really want to focus on 2007, and I'm gonna come back to that, but first, let's talk about the rest of the story. We ended up having this massive run-up after 2007, that blow-off top in 2011. It got ahead of itself, and this was the reaction to a loss of confidence and an expectation that what was gonna happen was governments were going to have to debase the value of money through inflation. It turned out, to the surprise of a lot of people, myself very much included, that central banks were able to pull some pretty fancy footwork and they managed to conjure money out of thin air with quantitative easing to support asset markets and delay the inevitable.
We never really dealt with the problem of too much debt. We haven't really dealt with the problems that led to the 2008 financial crisis. Basis yet, and we've managed to, to kind of chug along here and support the stock market to new all-time highs for the last 10 years.
Take a look now at what you see in the last 6 months of another move up that started in the end of 2018, and it wasn't much bigger than other moves that you had seen. It got up to around 1,300, a little pullback, and then boy, there's that really steep move up from 1,300 to where we are now $1,510 on this chart. That looks like a signal that maybe it is the beginning of something really big, and I think that's exactly what it is, is a signal that this is the beginning of a move up that's probably going to be a really, really big move up. I would say to at least $2,500 per ounce, probably a lot more than that.
But now let's go back to 2007. Look at the similarity of the first half of 2007. And that big move up, which was in fact— if you, if you look at the years before it, gold had been moving up. It started to accelerate in 2005 into 2006. Then there was a really big move in the first half of 2007. That was in fact the signal that something really big was beginning. Okay, but then look at what happened in the second half of 2007 and 2008. My point here is not sound bearish, which some people keep thinking in listening to MacroVoices that I'm bearish on gold. Nothing could be farther from the truth. What I'm pointing out is simply that there is so much similarity between where we are right now and that top in the, the middle to the end of 2007. It's very possible that we see a pullback to $1,300 or even lower before the really big move to the upside gets going.
So my point is not that I'm not bullish gold. I'm extremely bullish gold. I just want people to be careful and realize we're up $200 in 2 months. There's plenty of room for a technical correction that could take us considerably lower to better buying opportunities. I wouldn't be chasing the price too hard here. Hopefully you've owned gold since 2007, as I have, and you've got a core position. But as far as speculative, really adding leverage to, to really try to ride a big move up. I'm gonna wait for a pullback before I jump into that strategy. I'm glad to already have some gold now, so I've profited modestly in this move up even though I was wrong. I didn't think this move up was coming. I thought we were gonna go lower first. It seems like I was wrong, but I'm gonna look for an opportunity to really start buying aggressively when we get a pullback.
But I do think that just as that move in 2007 was a signal that the beginning of something really big was upon us. I think the move that we've seen now is also a signal of that. Just remember, these signals come with pullbacks after them, so don't chase it too fast. That's my message here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, listen, if we go to page 3, we have that silver chart, and there's no sign of that bigger picture breakout on silver the way we have on gold. And it was really interesting because Variant Perception put out a recent piece— our friends over there put out a piece saying silver to continue to outperform gold. And I thought it was really interesting. I mean, when do you think silver really starts to get that kick from gold to the upside and really start to see that momentum build there? Do you, do you think silver's gonna have its day in the sun here?
Erik Townsend: Oh, I definitely think silver will have its day in the sun. When you get into the speculative exuberance phase with these precious metals moves, usually silver is basically gold on steroids. It's turbo gold. But that works in both directions. Let's go back again and look at the 2007 event, comparing page 2 and page 3. What we're looking at here is you see a bigger move down on a percentage basis in 2007. There was a bigger move up, it was a sharper move up, and it's a bigger move down. So it's more exaggerated moves.
Silver is both a precious metal and an industrial metal. And that means that if you're going to have a stock market crash, which I think is very possible that we have some really serious turbulence in equity markets and possibly in bond markets at the same time, there is a good chance in a deep economic recession that silver will sell off more than gold will. So there's a caution there. It's you know leverage works in both ways, but silver tends to be gold on steroids. I agree that it hasn't really caught up with gold.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: If you want to ratio trade it where you're long silver and short gold to try to arbitrage out that ratio, maybe that makes sense. But to say, hey, it looks to me like, like, you know, there's a magic pill here, I can buy silver because it hasn't moved yet, but since gold did, silver is certain to move big. Well, remember, gold might have a pullback before it goes even higher, and silver could have a pullback too. And it wouldn't be surprising to me if the stock market were crashing if silver had a bigger pullback than gold.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so when we look at pages 4 and 5, I have the GDX, the gold miners ETF, as well as the GDXJ, which is the junior golds. And what's— what I find fascinating is that while on a percentage basis they've had great, great performance for the last 6 months, but what's amazing is that when you look at the monthly charts going back a decade or more, I mean, the big move to the upside hasn't even begun. If this breakout's for real, there's got to be more upside to this. What's your take on these miners?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, the usual argument for the gold miners is that they provide leverage to the gold price because as gold goes up in price, the miners tend to become much more profitable. The thing to remember, and I don't think it's really a risk anymore, and this is a bullish reason to think seriously about the miners, what I had really been concerned about with the miners is if you got a further move down in the price of gold below $1,000, let's say, the miners would be absolutely devastated because at that price, it's not just that they're not very profitable, it's they're going out of business. It's really, really drastic. So when I became concerned that this dollar liquidity squeeze could put more pressure on the price of bullion, I really thought it created a lot of extra risk for gold miners. Now that it seems like we're really seeing a very strong breakout to the upside, I'm not so worried about that.
So I feel a lot better about the gold mining shares down here.
Keep in mind, they are still stocks. Stock market in general is probably going to get hit if we get into another major financial crisis. GDX sold off in 2008. It will sell off again. Look at the size of that 2008 sell-off. That's That's a gift horse if it happens. You want to be buying the bottom there. But just keep in mind at these levels, if you think a stock market crash is coming, the mining stocks are going to get nailed. But in the long-term picture, I think that the outlook for mining shares is excellent.
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, what can our listeners expect in the coming weeks and months from us starting to cover gold more?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, MacroVoices has always focused on sophisticated investors, family offices, high-net-worth individuals. And people who are serious about their investing. So there's a lot of topics like vaulting of precious metals, the notion of different jurisdictional comparisons.
One of the widely accepted pieces of advice is at least some of your gold holdings, if you're a high net worth family or individual, should be in a legal jurisdiction other than the one that you live in. Okay, if that's the case, where do you want to consider? Switzerland's not what it used to be in terms of their independence of banking and privacy laws. There are places like Australia. There's some really good deals in some of the Central American countries, but are there risks there that you need to be concerned about? So the whole private vaulting thing, we need to cover that. We need to get into allocated versus unallocated bullion accounts, physical versus paper instruments, different mechanisms of leverage, if you If you want to use leverage and you're expecting a really big move, as I am, do you use something like mining shares or junior mining shares, which are a very leveraged way to play the price of gold?
Or do you just use leverage in the futures market? What are the trade-offs between those things? I want to cover the more advanced topics that you're not getting anywhere else. There's so many precious metals podcasts that are doing all of the usual topics about how central banks are supposedly conspiring. conspiring to suppress the price of gold and so forth. I don't even want to waste our time debunking that nonsense. There is certainly plenty of truth to the fact that the gold market is manipulated, just like all other markets are. There's more misinformation, frankly, than there is reality about gold price manipulation out there on the internet. I don't really have time for that. I want to do gold for grownups and talk about why, as Ronnie Stoeferle said in this interview, gold can be an emotional metal.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: for a lot of people. I want to take the emotion out of it and do Gold for Grownups and really focus on the topics that are of interest to serious investors looking at how to hedge against absolutely unavoidable devaluation of fiat currency in the coming decade and the paradigm shift that Ray Dalio has written about.
So we're going to be trying to focus on the more advanced, serious topics. I call it Gold for Grownups. I don't mean to offend I don't want to offend anybody. If you're absolutely convinced that there's a secret cabal of central bankers manipulating the gold price, that's fine. You're entitled to your views. There's lots of podcasts that talk about it for hours on end. I don't want to do that on MacroVoices. We're going to talk about some of the issues like comparing jurisdictions for where you might store your physical gold and that kind of thing.
Erik Townsend: But Patrick, speaking of what's coming in weeks ahead, I want to focus on the 21st of September because that's when the Money Show in Toronto Toronto is hosting a special session called the All-Stars of Options. Now, you can't have an All-Stars of Options in Canada without Patrick Ceresna headlining the speaking list. So who else is going to be speaking with you? What's it about?
And how can our listeners find out about attending?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So in this chartbook, there's the link to register. So just download the chartbook and click the link. It's free to attend. And yeah, I'm, I'm still actually I'm going to be sorting out the final topic I'm going to be speaking about. It'll be posted there by next week, but it's free to attend. It's on September 20th and 21st. Make sure all of our listeners that can make it out to Toronto for then, make it out, say hello. We'll probably arrange a time to go out for drinks and some sort of a meetup afterwards as well. Richard Croft and Sarah Potter will also be talking there with me. And so it's going to be a great event. And put it on your calendar, and hopefully we'll see a bunch of our members out there.
Erik Townsend: And also on that last page in the chart book, there's a link for the free trial of Big Picture Trading. Folks, that's where you can learn more about what Patrick does. You can also find out about the calendar straddle strategy, which has worked so well for playing this equity market. Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy of The Many Flavors of Trend Following and subscribe to their podcast as well. You'll be glad you did.
For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo. And of course, remember to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides links to all of the best content that we can find on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what they can expect in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as the link to Ronnie's In Gold We Trust report and the chartbook that we discussed in the postgame. There's also an interesting article from PIMCO asking the question if interest rates are naturally negative and a link to that Variant Perception article. Suggesting that silver will continue to outperform gold. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag Twitter and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Bloomberg. Necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management.
LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.