Marin Katusa — Natural resources investing guru (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 173 was recorded on June 27th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the leading podcast when it comes to systematic trading and investing. Natural resources investing guru Marin Katusa is back as this week's feature interview guest. Now of course I'm gonna ask Marin about gold given the recent breakout, but Marin says he his next big focus will be on the oil sector and buying the oil sector specifically. Now, to be clear, Marin doesn't think the bottom is in yet for oil. He still thinks lower prices are still to come, and he also thinks that they'll represent a fantastic buying opportunity when they do come. So he's already making plans, which he'll share with us, for how to scoop up energy companies on the cheap as the sector continues to suffer. And be sure to stay tuned for our post-game segment when Patrick and I will discuss options strategies for trading a melt-up in stocks if one should occur.
And if you're like me and don't want to be exposed to downside risk by being outright long the market.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, that S&P 500 struggled up along its previous highs near 2,960, but this is not much of a sell-off just yet. I mean, we're trading around 2,930 at the time of recording. What do you think is in store next for the S&P 500?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, Goldman Sachs has a no doubt warning, and I'll quote Goldman here: purely based on elevated equity valuations as measured by the S&P 500 Case-Shiller PE index, and at current growth, the risk of an equity drawdown of more than 10% is the highest that it's ever been since the Great Financial Crisis. So I'm not the only one who thinks that on a fundamental valuation basis, these prices are crazy and that the stock market is ignoring what the bond market is telling us, which is that we're probably headed toward a recession in 2020. I could list 100 other reasons to be bearish on fundamentals starting with the bond market, but frankly, I don't think it's relevant because this bad news is the new good doctrine seems to be what's driving the market. It's been the driving force since 2009. Now certainly, US-China trade deal and the Fed rate cut are very, very likely to actually happen in coming weeks.
I think that we're going to get a US-China trade deal. It might not be a great trade deal, but we'll have some kind of token agreement. The market will probably celebrate that and trade again up to new all-time highs. The Fed is probably going to cut interest rates. Whether it definitely happens at the next meeting or it's not till the meeting after that, who knows? But they're going to cut interest rates at some point. The market is going to love that. Now, the fact that the reason the Fed is taking these actions is because they're concerned about bad news in the economy doesn't seem to be registering. The stock market just likes the idea of central bank policy accommodation. And I think that's a huge mistake for people to make in the long term in terms of how this is going to play out, because I think that that accommodation is going to be more directed at Main Street than at Wall Street this time around.
We're coming into an election year. It's going to be a very hotly contested public issue. One way or another, though, it seems like the market just loves anything resembling accommodation from the Fed. I think we're gonna get more accommodation from the Fed. They just love the idea of a trade deal with China. I think we're probably gonna get one. Now, from a technical analysis perspective, Patrick, and you know this better than I do, you're better qualified than I am as a technician, once you've cleared 3,000 on the S&P, it's not like, oh boy, we might get to 3,050. It's more like, wow, 3,500+ comes into sight on a measured move basis. So there's plenty of reasons to think about how a self-reinforcing vicious cycle that drives a melt-up could occur from here. It starts with this bad news is the new good doctrine.
Then you get continuing lower interest rates, 'cause the bond market's not stupid. They know a recession's coming. Those lower interest rates fuel more buybacks. And if the US dollar continues to rally, as I suspect that it will, that supports Brent Johnson's melt-up thesis, where foreigners have a much higher incentive to invest in the US stock market because they also get the FX benefit.
So I'm still very tempted to say, okay, I still think it's crazy here, folks. I don't think it makes sense. But you know what? Whether I think it makes sense or not, this new normal that we've had since the Great Financial Crisis has been markets go up when the central bank accommodates, and the market thinks the Fed has its back. I think it's foolish thinking, but it's what's prevailing right now.
So I'm really looking forward to our postgame segment, Patrick, because we're going to follow up on our discussion last week and talk about what option strategies you could use to play that upside melt-up if you think it might be headed toward a blow-off top where you don't want to be exposed to the downside when it reverses. So we'll come back to that in the postgame segment.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on then to the US dollar, because over the last week we had a pretty solid drop right down toward the 96 handle on the downside of the dollar index. Stable for the last few days, but the selling was pretty hard. What's your short-term outlook on where the dollar could head next?
Erik Townsend: Well, first of all, in terms of the numbers that we're looking at and talking about in the show, I just want to explain that we've had a contract roll in the dollar index futures contract from the June contract to the September contract. And what that means is all these numbers are going to be about half of a big handle lower than they were before. So where we've been discussing that 98 level that the market's been struggling to get above, that's really 97.50 on the new chart. So all the numbers are half of a big point lower.
As far as what's happened, though, Patrick, it's exactly what I predicted and exactly what should be expected when you get The central bank talking about a rate cut and further accommodation, that's going to cause some people to think, well, that has to be bad for the dollar. And I disagree. I don't think it's necessarily bad for the dollar, but some people think it is. And so it's no surprise that you'd see a pullback. What I said is that would probably be a buying opportunity.
We've had that.
And in many ways, looking at the chart, it appears in the last 3 or 4 sessions that we may have already put in a bottom. Now, I should qualify that to say, by the same token, if I look at this chart, I could also see this turning into a very steeply downsloping new channel that's forming. And if that's the case, we just touched that bottom channel support line. We would expect to rally up to about $96.60, $96.70, and then it would roll over and we'd go to new lows below $95.50, which is where we just were in the last couple days. We're at $95.76 as we're speaking now on Thursday afternoon. Again, that's on the September contract. So I think the jury is still I'm leaning toward an upside resolution here, but when we actually get that Fed rate cut, there's going to be another knee-jerk down, probably a bigger knee-jerk down. I'd say that as I look, Patrick, at the chart, I really feel pretty good about my bullish thesis.
The fact that we had a pullback here, it's the pullback that I expected that happened for the reasons I expected it to. It's a buying opportunity. Nothing wrong with buying opportunities. I like those. The thing that scares me a little bit is the size of the move that happened in gold.
Patrick Ceresna: Gold.
Erik Townsend: If I was wrong about the dollar, as I've said many times, I would also be wrong about gold. And boy, look at what happened with gold. Now we'll come back to that because I don't think the jury is quite in there either. But if gold were to really take off from here and start ripping, you know, north of $1,500 or something, I'd say, boy, I really have to rethink whether or not my basic theory about the dollar is correct or not. But for now, I'm sticking to my story. I'm bullish, and I look at what just happened as a buying opportunity.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil. I know you and Marin Katusa are going to take a dive into this even greater detail, but, uh, in the last 2 weeks we've properly retraced that big May mark, uh, drop in crude oil prices, and we're hovering just under the $60 handle on crude. What's next in for oil?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's been another big week. Let's cover inventory first. This was a really big one, Patrick. Crude oil drawing down 12.8 million barrels And that's the biggest— I forget how long it's been that we've had that big of a drawdown, but that's a really, really big drawdown. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 1.7 million barrels. It's not just the crudes, it's also the products drawing down. Gasoline drawing down a million barrels, distillates drawing down 2.4 million barrels. The tape action in response to this, something I've always said, Patrick, and it's particularly important this week.
You care more about the market's reaction to the inventory number than you care about the number itself. We just had an inventory report, Patrick, that it would be very difficult to imagine being more bullish than it was. 12.8 million barrel drawdown. Holy cow. And the gasoline and distillates drawing down in the same week. That's just the kind of thing that sends markets soaring higher. You know what happened? We got a pop-up for about 20 minutes or so, and it fully retraced. And we ended up closing the day below the 100-day moving average, which is about where it was when the data came out. What I draw as a conclusion from all this—it's certainly not that this wasn't a bullish inventory number; it was bullish. But I think the market was already pricing in as much bullishness as it could handle. And I think what we saw was the market got pushed from the 100-day moving average where it was.
There's a big cluster. There's a 200. 100-day moving average, there's a 55-day moving average, there's a— I think it's an 8-week moving average. There's a whole bunch of clustered resistance that was above the market yesterday. We went up and we tested that, but we didn't break through it. We stayed below $60.
And as we came into today's close on Thursday, we pushed back below that 100-day moving average. So I conclude from all of this that the market has gone up as far as it's going to go up based on the current news flow.
And I think that if the geopolitical risk with Iran and so forth were to blow over, and particularly if there was bad news on the China trade negotiations, I think this market could head south, and I mean hard. On the other hand, Patrick, there's plenty of reason to expect more geopolitical upsets to occur over the weekend. And, you know, it's Friday tomorrow. A lot of people don't want to be caught short into the weekend. It's very likely that we'll see some short covering. So if there's another escalation, if there's a US military conflict with Iran, that's going to just completely, uh, you know, anything is possible to the upside. But I think at this point the market's gone as high as it's going to go until there's new news flow to drive it higher.
With respect to Saudi Arabia, something I found very interesting, you know, Mohammed bin Salman said on one of his TV interviews, Saudi Arabia does not want war in the region. But will respond if attacked. And my immediate reaction to that when I heard it was, yeah, right. Saudi Arabia hates Iran. It's their archenemy. Saudi Arabia would love to see the US go to war with Iran because Saudi's greatest enemy is Iran. What I'm hearing though from people who really have a lot of very high-level contacts is no, actually in this case, Saudi Arabia, yeah, that's true, they hate Iran. That hasn't changed.
They don't want a regional war right now. There's just too many Saudi interests that are at risk, and they don't stand enough to gain from damaging Iran. They really and truly would prefer not to see any further escalation from here, is the word that I'm hearing from people who, as far as I can tell, really do know what they're talking about.
So I think we really have to watch the news flow here. If there is an escalation with Iran, anything's possible to the upside. If there's not, And particularly if there's not, and there's also a breakdown in China trade talk negotiations, I think we could be back down to $50 before you know it. But, you know, we could go up to $70 if there's a big war escalation. Pretty much anything's possible. It's going to have to be watch the news and watch the tape.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to gold because you mentioned it earlier and I really wanted to take a dive into this. This week we started off with continuation to the upside. We printed north of $1,440 on the upside temporarily. Now, in the last 2 days, We've been giving a little bit back on gold. What's your thinking? Is that far enough? Is, is that all we're going to see, or is this just the beginning of a new big breakout?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, signs seem to suggest that a breakout past a 5-year critical resistance level in gold may be occurring. And I, I still stress the words may be. Now, at this point, it seems pretty clear most of the indications that we have are that this looks like it's real. It really is, uh, is The thing is, you really got to be careful because so many people were just jumping for joy. I couldn't believe the reaction on Twitter. This move started on like a Tuesday evening at 8 PM or something. It's after market hours. There's no liquidity in the market. People were reacting thinking, okay, this is it. We're guaranteed to go to $8,000 on gold from now. Look, that's, that's crazy. This resistance has been in place for 5 years now. Now what could have happened is it could have retraced to the very next day. That didn't. We held those levels and they even moved higher from there. That's really good.
We got a weekly close the day after we got that daily close above that critical level. That's good too, more fuel for the bullish argument. But still, Patrick, this resistance level has been in place for 5 years and we're seeing a breakout that's occurring on the back of some very, very sensitive geopolitical news with, you know, war with Iran and all this stuff.
These are the kind of circumstances that can lead to false breakouts. Now, I'm not saying this is a false breakout. I would say that the preponderance of evidence probably favors that it's a real breakout, and it's a breakout that certainly has surprised me. But we don't have enough data yet. It hasn't been long enough to say conclusively, okay, that's it, the new bull market in gold is on. And, you know, we had Greg Weldon on the show last week, Patrick. He is— he literally wrote the book on gold investing, and he told us last week he is super duper bullish on gold, and he's also very bearish on the dollar. He has a different view than I have on the dollar.
Greg told me this morning that he sent a note out to all of his paying subscribers telling them to tighten up their stops on gold because he thinks it might tank from here, and he thinks that there's a very good possibility that this could turn into a false breakout that creates much lower, better buying opportunities. So he's telling his subscribers that they should tighten their stops up. I'm not gonna list the exact number because out of respect to his paying subscribers, you know, they're paying for Greg's private information. I'll say it's a number just below $1,400 that he's telling them to set stops because he thinks that it might dump here. And that's, you know, a super duper gold guy. I mean, he knows what he's talking about. So I'm not saying that this is not real. What I am saying is the people who are assuming that we've got all the confirmation we could possibly need are jumping the gun a little bit.
We need to watch here. So far, all signs All the signs are good, and it definitely makes me revisit the question of, okay, this has to mean one of two things. Either I'm wrong about the dollar, in which case I, I need to rethink my strategy there, and the other possibility is I'm right about the dollar, but we're going to move into that realm that I've expected for many years now. I didn't expect it quite yet, where the dollar and gold move up together. And I think that if I do put on a long gold trade, I'm probably going to do it with a dollar pairing at the same time. Long gold, long dollar. If they move up together, that's great. If it turns out that it was a false breakout in gold, or if the dollar tanks, well, at least I'm hedged on the other side of the trade.
Erik Townsend: So I do think that it's very important news, but I also think people are jumping the gun a little
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because it just stays pinned to 2%. I mean, it looks like it's about to start bouncing off that level and then it comes right back down there. We've been more or less muddling here for a week. Are we going south of 2% here or is this gonna be a turning point?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think eventually we definitely will, but it feels to me like it's a pullback point. And in the interest of full disclosure, I'm not active in the 10-year contract right now, but I was long 2-year Treasuries. I closed the other half of that position this week, taking profits there, not because I, I don't think it can still go higher in price, lower in yield, but because I think we're going to get a pullback and a chance to re-enter that trade at a more attractive price.
So I've taken my chips off the table on that one. I still think that lower yields are going to be the name of the game, but boy, we're way overdue for a pullback, and it feels to me like maybe one is starting, that pause that you're describing in the 10-year. And as I look at the 2-year chart, you know, You know, it's not decisively turning bearish, but it definitely looks like it's topping out. So I'm taking chips off the table, really hoping that we get a significant backing up of rates, a reduction of price, so that I can enter the trade on the long side of bonds at a more attractive entry. I do think it has farther to go, but we're way overdue. Let's hope for that big pullback that gives us a better buying opportunity.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, Erik, we normally do not comment on cryptocurrencies in the market wrap, but given the incredible volatility This week with Bitcoin moving up dramatically earlier in the week and then dropping $1,500 in a course of minutes on Wednesday. A lot of people are starting to wonder what's going on here with crypto. Do you have any comments on the subject?
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I have too many comments on the subject, about 45 minutes worth to say on this, and we don't have time for that in the program. So I'm producing a video, actually recorded a video entirely on this subject. Last weekend, and it's— I think Facebook's Libra announcement is driving this. The video, remember, we're just in the process of learning to produce video at MacroVoices, so it's going a little bit slower than our audio production. I'm hoping that by Friday or the weekend at the absolute latest, we'll have that up on the feed, and we'll certainly announce something on Twitter and so forth. You can just look at MacroVoices.com for that video, but I'll give you the very quick executive summary right now.
Now, the cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin that are based on blockchain, everybody's all excited about them. And for our listeners who are part of the religion, I mean you no offense, but look, I really don't think they have a future.
Blockchain is incredibly inefficient. There's a better way. And for years I've been saying, I've been predicting we would eventually break what I call the proof-of-work barrier. Proof-of-work is the algorithm inside a blockchain that makes it go ridiculously slow and inefficient. Right. There's a better way. It took a while to figure it out. People have been working on it for 10 years. We're finally seeing breakthroughs where a number of companies are breaking the proof-of-work barrier and introducing distributed ledgers. Distributed ledger is the underlying technology that makes digital currency possible. They're introducing distributed ledgers that don't rely on mining or miners or blockchains, and it works better. Think of it, you know, if you remember Microsoft Windows version 1, The first version of software usually sucks, and it's later versions that are pretty good. The first version of distributed ledger was called blockchain, and it sucks really badly. We're going to see something better coming really soon, and I think it's going to shake up the market.
What I think is really driving this excitement, though, is Facebook's Libra announcement.
Libra is a new digital currency being introduced by Facebook, and if there is any person on this planet who I think should not be in charge of designing how money works for the whole planet in the future, it's Mark Zuckerberg. As I'll describe in the video, I don't think Facebook's just introducing a currency for convenience. I think they have designs on eventually creating the currency system that becomes a global digital currency that replaces the US dollar as the kingpin of the global financial system. I'm certainly not saying that Libra intends that in their first version or anything like that. But I think Facebook has designs on controlling how money works for the whole planet, and I think that's a very bad thing. I'll leave it there, and there's 45 minutes on this coming in a video in the next couple days.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is natural resource investing expert Marin Katusa. Now, Erik, why did we invite Marin back to the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Marin's been on a few times now. I think we've had him 3 times previously, and he's made some really fantastic calls. The first one I try to always keep him honest about. It was an incredible call, seemingly, where he made a call for a company called Nevsun. And like 3 days later, after we had him on the show, it was up 50%.
Marin will admit that it was luck on the timing. It was a good call. It was a well-researched call. But it happened that the acquisition offer that Marin correctly predicted just happened to come 2 days after he was on the show, made him look like a genius, when in reality the timing was just luck.
But then we had him on a couple more times, and the uranium call, the Sun Metals call, they've all really been fantastic. And so I've been following his newsletter myself, and I want to get an update. Now, what's interesting to me, because I'm very involved in the oil market, is Marin thinks the next big thing— he says everybody's talking gold, everybody's excited about gold. He said the time to get excited about gold was back when it was, you know, $1,100-something. The thing to get excited about now is not gold, it's oil, and it's not yet. Marin thinks lower prices are coming. I don't want to steal his thunder, so So we'll let him fill in the blanks in the interview. But he thinks the thing to focus on is oil, so that's what we're going to talk about.
Erik Townsend: And this episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Now, although I'm a global macro investor myself, it has long been known to investors around the world that systematic or quant-based strategies are profoundly effective at extracting returns from the market.
Top hedge funds like Bridgewater Associates and Renaissance Technologies discovered this decades ago. And there's one podcast that covers this area of finance better than any other: TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book explaining how these systematic strategies work. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro.
Check them out, you'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks, Erik. So Erik's interview with Marin Katusa is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here Here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Katusa Research founder Marin Katusa. Marin, the last several times we've had you on the program, you made some really bold calls and you got lucky with one of them, which was Nevsun. I think I shouldn't say you completely got Well, you got lucky. It was a good call and it was good analysis, but you got lucky on the timing. It just broke out crazy about 2 or 3 days after you recommended it on this program. So I think the timing on that one was luck. The next one that you described on a subsequent interview, you couldn't tell us at the time the name of the company because it was only for your subscribers, but we can now tell them that was Uranium Royalty Corporation. You got your subscribers in on a financing on that How has that performed since we talked to you about it?
I can't remember how many months ago.
Marin Katusa: It's done very well, actually. Uranium Royalty Corp has done 2 rounds higher. For all of our subscribers, myself included, which I was the largest investor in the deal, we're up over 50% at this date. It's worked out well, specifically in a uranium market that's performed horrible. 50% gain may not sound like a big win for a lot of speculators, But relatively speaking, it's a significant outlier and probably the top gainer in that sector of that market cap size. It's not like a penny stock, right? So it's done very well.
Erik Townsend: And how do you feel at this point about the uranium sector? Because as you say, the sector overall hasn't really done as well as we might have hoped, even though Uranium Royalty Corp has done very well.
Marin Katusa: Well, that was my whole thesis. So I'm probably the most hated guy in the uranium rah-rah fan club sector, yet I'm probably one of the largest financiers in the sector. I've always said that, look, this Section 232, which was started by a couple of friends of mine, and they openly stated that they got the concept from my book. Jeff Klenda said that on stage. These are good guys that are fighting, and they've built producing assets in the US. So these are good guys, and they're doing the right thing for their shareholders.
But I always said, look, I don't see a tariff system coming.
And I publicly stated over a year ago that what would happen in this situation— I talked about this in 2015 when I gave the keynote at the World Nuclear Fuel Market in 2015— the elephant in the The elephant in the room is Kazatomprom. And what no one's really talking about is their cut-to-kill strategy. So what I said was, what I see happening— I said this publicly at my conference in January, it's videotaped and recorded— I see a quota system coming somewhere between 5% and 7% of domestic demand starting. And then every year, you could go 10%, 15%, 20%, 25%. It probably caps out at— for multiple reasons. It's about permitting built. And I said Look, you don't need to go to strange areas that have political risk, lack of infrastructure that need $90 uranium when you could just drive down in Texas or in Wyoming to permitted-built.
And my focus was stay on unobligated, so unhedged uranium production. And that strategy has served me very well. And I see it continuing. There's no reason for uranium to go— the spot price, $75 in a month the way so many people expect, because people forget to understand And that in Kazakhstan, which is 40% of the world's primary uranium production, even though uranium has been slaughtered, their currency has been slaughtered even more. So it comes down to it's an FX play also. So there's multiple angles here to play it. So that's how I'm playing it, and it's worked out very well.
Erik Townsend: And I think the last time that we had you on the program, you again described a few deals. You didn't list the names out of courtesy to your subscribers, but we can now say it was Sun Metals was the long and EQT, the natural Gas Company was the short. How have those performed since we last had you on the program?
Marin Katusa: Yeah, so the Sun Metals worked out fantastic. So that's over a 200% gain for our subscribers and they've made a true world-class discovery. So that's an interesting one and it's in a politically stable jurisdiction. Now, there's still risks, obviously. Anything in the mining world has risks. So Sun Metals has been a real good player. That's now a Katusa Free Ride for our subscribers.
And then the EQT, we published that in May. You're a subscriber. You saw the alert go out in the newsletter and unless less than, uh, what, 40 days, we were up 190%. So we closed that position fully and decided that, you know what, this happened faster than we expected. It's time to lock in those gains. And, um, it worked out fantastic. So we've had a fantastic 12 months. It's been a great, great year for our portfolio.
Erik Townsend: Well, I've got to hand it to you. And I do want to ask you a couple questions about Universal mCloud which is a new one. And I should mention too, in the interest of full disclosure, that I am a I'm a subscriber to your newsletter and have sent my documents in on one of these financings. So I'll come back to that. But frankly, I want to first talk about an area where maybe you and I turned out to be wrong. We both thought that gold had further to go down before— I think we both have felt ultimately there's a lot of good reasons to think gold goes up dramatically, but we thought it wasn't time yet. And maybe it's still not time yet, but boy, the tape is sure looking pretty strong. What do you make of this apparent breakout in gold? And what does that mean considering that you and I both thought maybe that there was a little bit more downside before this happened?
Marin Katusa: Well, we've been in the industry long enough that we've seen every head fake in the last 10 years, right? So it feels, number one, emotionally, let's talk about that. It feels good knowing, you know, we've got 5 gold positions in our portfolio. Again, you know, because of my situation in the resource market, I'm a major financier of these gold companies, the 2 largest financings ever on the TSX Venture were actually from me and my subscribers. So we broke the record, and then we broke the record again. So number 1 and 2 are ours.
What I see happening here is this is a fantastic price. Our picks, we're up over 33%, 34%, 35% year to date on just our 5 gold stocks. And we don't need higher prices to do very well because the stocks we're in make money at under $1,000 gold.
So what I was getting at was, look, there's a lot of reasons where I believe the US dollar has significant strength within the next 12, 18 months. And you look at what's going on globally, I think there's 3 main factors that are really pushing gold here in the near term— the China-US tensions, and I would include Hong Kong in that. Number 2, what's going on between Iran and the US right Now, and you see these factors in Vancouver. There's a flee for cash. For example, in West Vancouver and Vancouver, it's a very high-end area of real estate, probably one of the highest-priced real estate in all of Canada. You're seeing waterfront houses being sold for less than 50%. Now, that area is about 40% Persian, specifically from Iran over the last 25, 30 years. And because they have such capital restraints and inflation domestically, they can't get their money out, so they're hitting the bid on local real estate.
We're seeing that factor. And you're also seeing them buy quite a bit of gold. And I think just the global political— what's going on is causing gold to attract some more attention. We just published a chart on my Twitter handle that showed the low on the interest for the S&P for the percentage in gold investments was about 0.07%. Historically, the average is 0.23%. Still insignificant when you compare it to biotech or the banking sector. So gold is a very niche market.
And if we Right now, we're at 0.1. So we've gone from 0.08 to 0.1. And that's caused a $200 move in gold.
If we just go to 0.2, Erik, you're going to see a massive move in the gold price. But specifically speaking, the price in gold in Canadian dollars— so if you're a Canadian producer— is at all-time highs. If you look at Australian producers, all-time high. If you look at it in Russia, all-time high. And these are countries that are major gold producers. So So this is a great price for gold. Could I see some pullback? I'm just naturally a contrarian, expect the worst. So I'm very conservative in my price models. I still use $1,200, $1,250 in my NAV models. So right now, our picks are looking fantastic. And that's why we're seeing such big moves in them. So do I hope gold goes higher? Of course I do. I've got a major percent of my net worth in these gold companies, but it sure feels good But don't be surprised if you see a pullback here also.
Erik Townsend: Okay, I want to move on to the main topic today, which is going to be crude oil. But before we get into strategies for how to buy low oil prices, I think we need to first discuss what's going on in the market, because we had fairly low oil prices, and I thought there was a lot of indication a couple weeks ago that they were still headed lower as I looked at the series of inventory reports the other supply and demand data, the signs that we're seeing of an oncoming recession in 2020 looked to me like we were headed much lower still in prices.
Then we had the whole tanker attack thing. At first, people said Iran did it. Iran said they didn't do it. Some people believed Iran didn't do it. And then, as soon as that happened, Iran did something else that they didn't try to hide and shot down a US drone. drone, proudly proclaiming that they had done so. So needless to say, that has created just a straight-up spike in energy prices.
I observe 2 things. One is, given that we're talking about real honest-to-God war threats here, the price hasn't gone up that much. And it tells me that the fundamentals really are pointing toward lower prices if and when the geopolitics blow over. And I guess the other thing that I've seen is I think that probably even if we have these geopolitics, I don't see it, the geopolitical situation playing out to really affect energy that much. I mean, yeah, Iran is getting in big trouble with the United States. Iranian oil was already discounted out of production, really. I mean, it's in the gray market, but it's not really affecting things. So what do you make of the current situation with oil prices before we get into the the details of what the strategy would be for buying the bottom when that comes.
Marin Katusa: So a couple of things we should look at from that canary in the coal mine, things that I look at from a mass psychology standpoint is it's been over 100 years when Shell first increased the size of their tankers and the safety to go through the straits like Hormuz. Back then it was in Aden. And you look at what's going on and the biggest winner of all this isn't the oil speculators. It's actually the insurance companies because the price to insure a tanker is up over 1,000%. So it's 10 times more than it was just 60 days ago. And you look at, OK, let's think about— if you go back to over 100 years, if everyone thought that if something happened in the Strait of Hormuz, would Iran ever bomb an oil tanker or a boat or even threaten to do so? Historically speaking, Erik, I think everyone would agree if you go back 10, 15, 20 years that the price of oil should shoot up $10, $20, $30 or have a big significant move.
The day it happened, it moved up $1. And I got to say, I sat back and went, wow. That was a true signal that there's just a lot of contentment in the market.
Then you pull back to say, OK, let's focus on the US guys. And you look at what's happening there with the infrastructure. By the end of this year, you're going to have a major infrastructure project with the pipeline capacity finished in the Permian. That's going to unlock about 800,000, 900,000 barrels. So the velocity of oil movement is going to increase.
Then, because I'm Canadian, and naturally, you're always focused on things that are happening in your own country, the backwardation of the infrastructure, the resource sector in Canada under the current administration really is shocking, where we're the 3rd largest endowment of oil in the world, and we've actually been decreasing production. Why? Because we're relying on getting it out of rail, which is much riskier than the pipelines. And we just can't get these pipelines built. Even if they're permitted and they go through 10 years and spend $1 billion to get there, the local courts move it around. So it's turned no-bid in Canada, but yet there's a lot of oil waiting to get out. So I think the oil markets have figured out that there's no shortage of oil. So this peak oil thesis, which for 15 years I've been writing about, is false because technology will change it.
Right. You're seeing, and I think you and I are in the same boat in the near term. I see significant downward pressure in the near term on the price of oil. Now, then you got to look at what's OPEC doing, and then you look at Iran rattling the sabers with what their comment last night with their retaliation to Trump's new sanctions. So there's a lot of reasons to be bullish politically, the political risk in the oil markets. But I think the market has come to the realization that the supply. side will be there. It's just a price of getting it to the market, whether via rail or more tankers, and then paying for 1,000% more insurance to insure it through the strait.
So that's kind of where I'm at with the sector right now. And then you look at the producers and you look at their debt balance sheet and how can they handle— okay, at $60 oil, everybody extends and pretends their debt. At $50, how do they do? What about at 40 or 35? So these are the stress tests that you have to do to the financial analysis of these producers because the whole drill, baby, drill, well, the reality is even though the Fed may cut the rates, I've been publishing a lot of data showing, well, the real market, and because they've gone through this and they've seen that these companies aren't exactly the most disciplined or returner of capital, the real rate of lending to the companies is significantly higher and it's actually actually no longer linked to the Fed rate.
So this is where a lot of people disagree with me, but you look at what's going on in the bond market or even in the, you know, the junk bonds in the oil patch, and the reality is, is most of the debt in the intermediates and the mid-tiers and juniors is junk debt. So I see high single digits to the low teens.
Marin Katusa: And the reality is, is that $40, very few of these guys, you know, if you use $35, $40, very few of these guys
Erik Townsend: Marin, do you have a downside target number where you're saying, okay, I'm waiting for oil to get to price X and that's where we start really buying? Or are you looking at this more as something where you just scale in over time and figure that you're going to accept the averages?
Marin Katusa: I've been doing this long enough that I've never quite been able to pick a bottom and I've never sold on the top. I'm a big believer in scaling in and scaling out, Erik. In my newsletter, as you see, I do this tranche buying system, have this matrix, buy your first tranche at 25%, and then you kind of ease in. And as you start getting in, you start getting comfortable with the position, then you can get in through financing. That's something I do a lot of in my newsletter is because of the size I buy in, it's hard for me to get a position in the open market for a lot of these mid-tiers or juniors. So I structure a lot of these private placements. And then because of the size of my list and my following, I say, Hey, you're a subscriber. You can get in at the same price and same terms if you like it.
If not, no big deal. And then the subscribers get out two days in advance.
So where I'm at personally right now is I believe that we'll see more downward pressure in the price of oil, and I believe right now is not the time to jump in full throttle. I think it's time. You know, I've got my two or three favorite Canadian producers. I've got my two favorite U.S. producers and my international guys. That's what I'm going to be publishing about, and I've got. I've got a real big, interesting angle for my subscribers that I'm publishing next week on a really interesting angle that nobody has published in the institutional world yet about. But I think in 2 or 3 years, it'll be the hottest play in the oil patch. And people forget about, for every barrel of oil that gets moved, what other liquid is required, and what do you do with that? And there's a big value add to this whole oil game in North America. So, it's an interesting angle on it. And I think patience— and it's funny, Erik.
Everybody wants to be a contrarian, but very few people actually have the testicular fortitude to be a contrarian.
Right now, when I publish something on gold, it literally gets 10 times the reaction in the market than something if I publish on, say, uranium or oil or whatever. That tells me that the market's hot for gold. But 3, 4 months ago, when I would publish on gold, nobody cared. It was this interesting dilemma of what we see going on in the market. So right now, with oil, I think it's time to roll up your sleeves and do your deep dive analysis and stress tests. And I also believe there's no reason to take any risks in this market.
Things are getting so cheap in the oil patch that I can get a senior producer valued at 15- to 25-year lows on financial metrics. Because, why bother with a development story or something that is in a risky jurisdiction? You just don't need to do that. That's the beauty of being a true contrarian. Just like in gold, look at the move we've had. But for— you mentioned Nevsun, that it was a lucky pick, or on your show it sounded lucky. But I was there 5 years, 6 years at the site. I financed the company for years. I published 1 year before I came on your show. So yes, it looked like, oh, wow, I just talked about it, and a week or two later, then it got bought out 5 months later. But I was there for 2 years before it happened in a big way as one of the largest investors in the deal. So to be a contrarian is a lonely trade.
And that's what makes me excited about oil because people are starting to really hate it. And that's when I like getting into things.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit more about why you like it, why some people hate it, and so forth, because I think we have some very similar ideas, but in many In many ways, they may be a little different. You have, for as long as I've known you, been a peak oil disbeliever, and I've looked at it a little bit differently. I think of it as it's peak cheap oil. We're not going to run out of oil. What's going to happen is the amount of technological complexity that's required to extract it from the ground is going to keep getting more, and therefore, the cost of extraction is going to keep getting higher, and over time, the cost of energy as a percentage of GDP is getting get higher. Now, we've just for the last 10 years been on this amazing, amazing ride thanks to, I think, central bank largesse making so much money available to the shale patch that all of a sudden we've got overproduction of US shale oil.
What I'm starting to see is the rig count has been declining even when prices were reasonably economic, and we're starting to see a plateauing maybe of that US production growth. I'm not sure it's over yet, but maybe it's slowing down. The way that I look at this, Marin, is I don't think the world ever comes to an end. We always find a new technology that's going to, you know, produce more oil if we run out of the last one. But when we run out of the ability to produce oil using the fracturing and horizontal drilling technologies that have made shale oil possible. When that technology is not enough anymore, then we're really moving to higher prices because the next choices are deepwater offshore and Arctic offshore and, you know, all these things that are— they're all possible, but they cost a lot of money. So the real question on my mind is, you know, how much longer does shale have left in it before these shale plays are played out and the industry has to start looking to other sources?
And it seems to me like you want to be ahead of that before we get to that point. You want to have done all your buying. So how close are we?
Marin Katusa: So great, great point. And your comment kind of reminded me of the big debate my good friend Rick Rule and I had at a big conference in New Orleans in the fall of— or was it October, November of 2014? It's on YouTube. And his thesis was exactly what you're saying. It's expensive. It's cheap money.
And it'll never go under $75. And I said— oil was about $90 at the time. And I said, not only will oil go under $50, $40, we will see certain producers be able to make money at $30 oil.
Let me explain. You talked about the decrease in drill rigs. That number is absolutely irrelevant. People use, for example, and I use the example of historically speaking, guys in the industry, they used to use the dollar value of gas used to have a 6-to-1 ratio with oil, especially when they do BOEs or BOEs, barrel of oil equivalent, because It is on an energy equivalent basis, 6 to 1, just under 6 to 1. So they said, well, it should be priced 6 to 1. I said, that's irrelevant in fracking because it got to 20 to 1, and people are like, oh, gas has to go higher to match the historical average. And this is over 12, 13 years ago I wrote it and said, no, no, that is absolutely irrelevant. The price of oil and gas are no longer tied to that conventional BOE. And I think the whole concept of BOEs is ridiculous. because it's kind of like gold equivalent.
It's absolutely ridiculous because recovery rates are different, and the price the smelters pay for you are different. That's a side point. But what I'm trying to get at is the number of rigs used just 5 years ago, a rig that is designed today, like a 5th-generation rig, will do the trips, for example, that when you drill, then you pull up the drill bit to change the bit. The bits are getting 400%, 500%, 600% better utilization rates because of the compositions increasing. It's getting more specialized to the specific type of shale, then they realize with more examples, oh, we're going through this formation. Let's use this type of bit. And then now is when we're through it. Let's specialize it to the different bit, the type of fluids they're using. It's getting down to a science so that we all agree that rather than taking down your rig, they're walking them and they're doing all these factors.
Just, you know, 6 years ago, it'd take 45 to 60 days to complete a serious major frac and complete it, drill frac and complete tie-in. Now you're looking at less than 20 days, and you're doing multiple more fracs, and the intensity, the sand, and all those factors.
So now, I believe that technology is getting to a point that is significantly increasing. You and I agree there. Where I think we disagree is I think we still, in North America, have 10 years, a decade of major running room in stabilizing, and even in the near term, in certain areas, increasing production. You look at factors like the flaring the gas in the bottom. And in certain areas in the Permian. If the government just gave credits to the companies, like a carbon credit or some sort of financial benefit not to flare that gas, you would look at 2 BCFs of gas that could be imported. And now the US guys could actually be competitive to the Russian gas sector in Europe on the LNG side. So there's a whole geopolitical angle that the Americans can really rattle the Russians there, too.
Now, that's just North America because we have existing infrastructure, the technology, the industries built there.
But what about Europe? Now, you look at the infrastructure in Europe. The Russians haven't even started fracking. The Chinese have started in the Sichuan Basin, but they're still a couple of decades behind to getting to where the North Americans are. Europe is more of a political basket case. So even though areas in Paris have significant— in France have significant potential for fracking, or shale, as does Spain. The UK, the Bowland Shales with Cuadrilla, which I financed and was a large shareholder before Lord Browne, who used to run BP and Centrica Energy, and Riverstone bought us out. Incredible potential. South America, same thing, Argentina and the Vaca Muerta Shale. But the infrastructure lacks. So in the near term, it's going to be all North America for the next 10 years. Mexico has significant potential. And the key thing is to remember, shale is the source rock for the major conventional deposits. What about the Saudis? They're just starting to explore the potential there.
And they have incredible infrastructure. And the other OPEC nations are doing the same. So I think in North America, you've got 8 to 10 years of legroom.
Don't bet against the innovation and technology of the sector. And that's my beliefs. And then I'm kind of risk-off in the developments. 10 years ago, I did Cuadrilla and other things. But you kind of realize we got out and did well there, but it's a much harder play than in North America.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Marin. So if your outlook is that for at least the next 8 to 10 years, shale will continue to be a viable source of oil, and we're certainly going to need it, and I think that who's to say how low prices could go, but at least before this Iran kerfuffle came up, and I do think it will eventually blow We're probably going to get back down to some prices in the 40s. Is that kind of where you get excited and start buying, or do you really get excited and start buying in the 30s, or is your process disciplined in a way where you never get excited and you're just methodical about doing a certain thing at a certain time?
Marin Katusa: Unfortunately, my family and friends put me in the latter group, that I never get excited because I just stick to the numbers. I think once it touches that 40, You look at the metrics on the financial balance sheet of these companies, and you know, just because the WTI price or the Brent price may be 44 or 45, that doesn't necessarily mean what your company you're looking at produces. So you got to work backwards from their financial statements. What are they getting at the wellhead before? What are their costs in the pipeline? So you got to look at every company's balance sheet. I think that's a big mistake is the generalization going, oh, it's $50 oil. This is great. But then you look at the differentials and the costs. Cost to ship by rail or the pipeline tariffs, you look at it and go, wow, this company is only getting, you know, $28 a barrel. So that, you know, you have to look at the balance sheet.
But definitely I see, you know, I'm kind of— my friend Raoul is an ultra bear on oil. He thinks it's going down to maybe even break $20 or in the low $20s. I don't know if we get that low because the reality is, is very few— like, that's the lowest cost quartile.
When I went to Kuwait in the Middle A fantastic well in Kuwait, the top-tier well in Kuwait works at $20 oil. But I don't see any unconventional in North America breaking even at $20 oil. So would I get excited at that price? Oh, most definitely. Do I see that? I just don't. I think we see maybe the $30s, low $30s, mid-$30s, high $30s, low $40s. That's kind of where I'm getting— where I see the sector going. I wish I had a number for you, Erik. I just don't. It's more of a range.
Erik Townsend: I see. And tell us your strategy as you get into these ranges that are attractive to you. Is it entirely looking at small producers where you can get in on financings and, you know, early equity terms, or are you looking at more established firms? Is it a combination? Tell us how you approach the field.
Marin Katusa: Yeah, great question. So in this cycle where we are right now in the shale, you do not need to to take a private placement in a startup that has high risk and execution risk because the intermediates, the guys producing anywhere from 50,000 barrels a day to 200,000 barrels a day, are priced like a junior. And they also, because of what's happened in the sector with the sell-off— for example, the Canadian pension plan is the largest fund in Canada, and it has essentially zero exposure to the Canadian oil patch.
These oil companies are very— they're like cockroaches.
They survive. They know how to survive multiple cycles. In this sector, a family office or a smart accredited investor gets his broker, or he does the extra work himself, or what I'm doing, I go to these bigger companies with cash flow, with dividends, and they will also, as they expand their infrastructure, build the pipeline, they will need to do financing or debt or a combination thereof. That That's my process. And once I— in Canada, I've narrowed it down to 2 stocks I really want in my portfolio. Now to be patient. Let's wait for our first tranche. You buy your first 25%. Let's see how it happens. Let's see where the market develops. And sometimes it takes off. And like, for example, one of our gold stocks, we bought only our first tranche. We're up 35%. And that's it. Now I'm going to wait to buy my second tranche, and we don't have our fill. So I have my quarter position in that one stock that I've wanted.
But you've got to stay disciplined. You can't chase these stocks. These are very volatile sectors, Erik. And patience. You've got to play the long game. Don't expect to become a Warren Buffett within a year.
I've been doing this for almost 20 years, and my strategy has worked. At times, it's boring. Because people— the biggest mistake a subscriber makes is they subscribe today, and they say, OK, I've got $200 grand, and I want to invest it all on Tuesday. That is the process of failure. The process of winning is saying, okay, how much of my portfolio do I want towards energy? And then within the energy, how much do I want towards oil? How much do I want towards uranium? How much do I— you break it down. How much of my portfolio do I want in precious metals? So for me, I broke it down in our newsletter saying 25% of my portfolio, of my net worth, is in the precious And that's across physical gold, producers, explorers type of thing.
And in the oil patch right now, I'm very underweight. I have almost no exposure to the energy sector. I have one position that I'm waiting out on. And I'm looking to add to it. Well, I'm going to publish my favorite stocks on that. Subscribers get 2 days to buy before I do. And the beauty is, is these are big liquid companies that are paying dividends.
They're going to survive at $35 oil. That's the stress test. And that's where I kind of see the market pulling back. I don't see $75 oil anytime soon. I see $40 oil before $75. That's kind of my process, Erik.
Erik Townsend: Well, Marin, that's one place you and I definitely agree, is that assuming that the geopolitical situation blows over, which I think it most likely will, that we head back back toward lower oil prices. When we do, let's talk a little bit more about your strategy, because you tend to invest in some smaller companies. And quite frankly, there has been some, some fraud and some, some outright misdirection that has occurred in the shale patch. How do you know that you're not getting suckered in terms of getting into a deal with maybe a company that really doesn't have all the resources it claims to?
Marin Katusa: That's a fantastic question and a big issue I see in the markets. It's not just in the oil patch. You see fraud in all of these juniors. And I know I'm known as a junior guy, but over 50% of our portfolio is actually dividend-paying big stocks. But the market loves that 10-bagger story, right? So that's what I've been famous for in our sector.
Regardless of that, you have to go and get to know the management team. You've got to go to the site visits. And the reality is, is I get it. A teacher, a doctor, a construction guy, a realtor, a businessman, he's busy with his family and his workday life. He can't go and do that. And sadly, they are at a disadvantage.
Believe it or not, most fund managers— I'll tell you a great story. In 2014, I took about 65 guys in the industry who are well-known guys in the mining sector, and we got on a bus. It was an invite-only thing. And we took them out to my copper mine that I was one of the founders of. It's the 3rd largest producer in the country. And as we go up, we had a microphone. I said, Look, I want every guy to come up in front of this audience of 65 on the bus. It's a 3-hour bus ride from Vancouver to Princeton. And let's talk about it. And the first thing I said, OK, guys, this is the story of Copper Mountain. We started in '06, blah, blah, blah. And I asked, how many of you guys have actually been to a producing mine? And it shocked me.
Less than 10 of the 65 guys— and these are some of the biggest names in the business and fund managers in the business and brokers— less than 10 put up their hand of 65 that have been to a producing asset.
So really significant. Signified that difference of going to the site. You know, we got a team of geologists and engineers here. You go out and you got to use independent research and know the management team, go to their office, get to know these guys' lifestyles.
And it's not that hard to figure out what the hell is going on in the game if you just put that extra factor. So, you know, the most famous scam in the industry was Bre-X. Well, interestingly enough, my partner was on site and he said, Wait a second, Bre-X isn't producing and they're the same market cap as Freeport. So you got to use a little bit of street sense. So hence, that's when Doug Casey sold Bre-X He got in at 25 cents; he sold it at over 200 bucks because it was just wait a second, this makes no sense. How can you be priced at the same price as the world's largest copper producer? So it comes down to doing your true due diligence. You got to be street smart, and you got to be financial savvy. You got to have the geos and the engineers that know what they're doing.
And a big scam that nobody talks about in the industry, Erik, is so many analysts and the fund managers in the business focus on the technical reports written by these companies. And I say, guys, this is a 400-page document that everybody thinks should be a pure document, a true technical document.
But I do it differently. I have a database of every single one of these companies. I have a database of all the engineering firms that do this. And the engineering firms, you have to remember, are paid by the company.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Marin Katusa: So they work with the company to publish a result. And generally speaking, whoever pays your check is your boss. So these engineers, even though they're trying to be independent, they're paid by these companies.
And they have to sign off on people. And I believe in Pareto's Law. It's a pure mathematics thing that I apply to all of my financial investments. A winner is a winner, and a loser is a loser. And so many times, these engineers at these different firms, they bounce around from one engineering firm to another, but they can't change their name.
So I track— before I go down to a 43-101, or a pre-feasibility study, or a bankable feasibility study, I break down all the names. I search back to their last 10 projects they've worked on. And I see, wait a second, this geologist said this. Oh, the deposit had 40% less gold when they put it into production. And then you see that this is a pattern in this individual's behavior and his technical ability. Or an engineer who did the metallurgy and said, oh, yeah, it's a 90% recovery. When they put the project into production, you realize that it had 70%. Well, that's a big difference. And that's the difference between being economic and uneconomic. And generally speaking, you have to follow not just the money, but the people.
That's another aspect that we do. And before I even start into the technical, I look at who wrote this technical report, who signed off on this technical report, and how good were their past work. Because there's no way a guy who is a loser, loser, loser, loser, completely wrong in all his projects before is all of a sudden going to become a great geologist or a metallurgist or an engineer.
It just— there's patterns to success and there's patterns to failure, Erik.
Erik Townsend: Let me understand then how we came to what I think is really your first oil-focused deal that you've described in your newsletter, because I've been watching the newsletter. I know from talking to you off the air that you've been thinking that it's time to start focusing on the these oil deals, I was expecting to see some kind of shale producer, some small company. You're very good at, you know, getting in on the ground floor with small companies, somebody producing oil. And of course, the deal that has been presented to your subscribers, which we can talk about now because it's closed already, is Universal mCloud. And when I first heard about this, I thought, okay, must be cloudy skies in Canada. someplace where there's an oil producer if it's called mCloud. No, this is like cloud computing. This is, this is Internet of Things company that Marin Katusa is involved in. And I'm thinking, wait a minute, Marin's the commodities guy.
This is like a high-tech thing. I don't get it. So I do now get it. But please explain for our listeners where the connection is between oil and Universal mCloud and what they're doing with their sensors and so forth.
Marin Katusa: For sure. Great, great thing, because I got a lot of feedback on that one. And so I've known the management team for over a year. And when they came and pitched, I said, OK, let's see what they do. And essentially, where I thought was incredible potential was what they were doing in the oil patch.
And like I said, nothing creates innovation more than a downward price in the price of oil, specifically in Canada. And that creates innovation.
So at the oilhead, they now have sensors where every second, you could analyze 500 different data points between your sulfur level, your water level, your pressure, your different aspects, your API, so many of these independent things that 3, 4 years ago, they didn't have. And the technology now has gone to the point where it's readily available. Now the question is, what does the company do with all this data? So Universal mCloud has a— one of their subsidiaries is called AutoPilot. Pro, and they really are a massively growing innovative company that has over $30 million in revenue just off of what I call the Fitbit for the wellhead. And it tells you exactly what's going on every second with hundreds of data points. Therefore, if the price of oil or your well pressure head, your sand level, it will be able to optimize each of these wellheads.
And that's just one aspect. Then you look at all of these existing— take the oil sands or a battery for the oil where all the oil goes to be held before it goes into the pipelines, or just your gasification plants.
All of these factors, it comes down to you've got to send a crew to innovate. And how do you get enough guys where you're in the middle of nowhere, you've got to send a welding crew, you're looking at a couple thousand bucks an hour to replace a valve or whatever price goes down. And they've created this ability where they've already pre-scanned— think of blueprints for a house. They make it 3D, and each point has a sensor that is telling, and it's predictive on how much of the valve is still existing or the pressures. You should take this out, or more importantly, when it does go out, now you don't need a senior guy because now you put on a headset, and it walks you through in 3D what to do. And it's proven to improve the speed by over 30%, which reduces the costs of maintenance. And that's a huge thing, is about utilization rates and downtime.
So this company is cash flowing. They make money.
The way I structured it was they went to do another deal, and they were going to raise $10 million. The management team were going to take $5 million, and a bunch of bankers wanted them to go on tour. And I just told Russ, who was the president of the company, going, look, I will do half of it personally, but I need these terms.
And it was a convertible And the convertible debenture feature pays me and all my subscribers 10% cash quarterly for 3 years. But if we convert the stock, we get a unit at $0.50 and a full 5-year warrant at $0.75 And you look at what's going on, they haven't even started in the US, which they will.
And then there are other aspects, like the HVAC business. They did a deal with Bank of America, Tim Hortons, Starbucks, and they're They're just about cash flowing and just smart business. I expect much larger funds in Canada, REITs coming in. And it's just smart business. So I've structured it where we get paid 10% for 3 years. And if the stock takes off, fantastic. We convert, and we're going to make a lot of money.
And if the stock just stays at its revenues, they're able to pay the debt. And it's a nice pass, is the way I see it. I actually believe this management team, who I've gone and spent time— and you go to their office, you go to their assets. assets, you realize that they own 43% of the company themselves post the financing we did. They got skin in the game. They've done it before.
I'm willing to back these type of right people. That's where that was.
Erik Townsend: Now, when I sent my subscription form in, they promptly sent it back and said, you only get 80% of what you're asking for. It's good to see that there's plenty of demand for this, but does all that demand potentially Eventually put pressure on the terms that investors are getting in terms of where these conversion prices will actually occur. What is, what is actually guaranteed in this debenture? Is there a specific conversion price and time, or is it—
Marin Katusa: So for 3 years, every single— so this debenture is going to be publicly listed and traded. So it's like a stock. I believe it's going to trade— we did the whole— we did like a 30-page report for all the subscribers, and we showed the true value of that debenture. We think it's going to trade at a big premium. It's going to be listed at $100. We think it's going to trade out of the gates north of $110. So you can sit there and say, well, I've already made 10%. Do I want to wait a year? Do I want to sell it to someone who wants interest or income or a dividend? And then for 3 years— it's only a 3-year term— for 3 years, every debenture holder has the right to convert into a unit at $0.50.
So if you look at— if you put $10,000 into the debenture, If you can collect $1,000 a year, or you get the right to come— if you put $10,000 in, you can convert to 20,000 units at $0.50. And with that, you get 20,000 warrants at $0.75. Stock goes to $0.80 or $1, you got a nice win there on a debenture. That's how we've structured it.
Erik Townsend: Now, is this representative of what we should expect? I mean, this is kind of out of character for Marin Katusa. Be doing sensors and Internet of Things and high-tech stuff, which is really cool. I mean, it's bringing automation and sophistication of technology to the oil patch. It's great, but it's out of the usual norm of producing resource companies that you usually invest in. What should we subscribers expect? Is this the new direction that you're headed? Is technology where it's at, or is this kind of a one-off?
Marin Katusa: Remember, I personally backed the financing. So it's about where I'm putting my own money. And I'm looking at aspects, and it's just about valuation. This company trades at less than a 0.4 NAV compared to its peers. It's just a cheap deal. And look, we have this thing called alligator investing that I kind of talk about all the time. A lot of people don't know that an alligator can go over a year without eating. It controls its metabolism. I just find that special. Yeah. Species, just incredible. Just fascinated by them. And when you take that predator approach going, you know what, I don't need to buy a stock every month. I don't need to trade in and out. If I can just wait and be patient, it's kind of like Warren Buffett's philosophy of wait for the fat pitch, right? Remember, there's no— you don't have to swing.
When I became one of the largest shareholders of Alterra Power, this was perhaps before I was on your shows, but people are like, what the hell is Marin Katusa doing investing in energy. I thought he hated green energy. Well, in 2009, I publicly said this stuff is so expensive, it's priced to perfection. And interestingly enough, the chairman and the largest shareholder of Alterra at the time was on a panel with me where I said his company will go down between 50% to 75%. I don't know when. It could be 6 months. It could be 12 months, 18. I go, I don't know. But right now, if you analyze the company, it's priced to perfection. At that time, it was priced at $25.
About— that was September of 2009. It's on YouTube. And Ross wasn't too impressed with me at the time. By 2014, I phoned him up. So you're talking almost 5 years later. And I said, Ross, your stock's $3 now. I would like to become the second largest shareholder. He owned 30%. I ended up buying just under 10%.
And the market was shocked going, what the hell is Marin doing? How could he like green energy? We're mining.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: people. And I said, it's got nothing to do with what your belief or my belief is. It's about making money. And Alterra was so cheap at $3.50 that I just, for 2 and a half years, Erik, I wrote about it and pounded the table on it. And people are like, ah, green energy doesn't work. I said, well, in 2009, it didn't make sense. But the innovation in solar panels, the cost reduced by 90%.
You look at the credits that the company got, this is Now, the company's actually built these assets. They're cash flowing and paying a dividend. And it's 80% cheaper than it was just 5 years ago. What about this does the market not get? But because there was so much fatigue, people just sold it and didn't care.
And then in late 2017, we got an $8.25 bid by Innergex. And it was a great score for our investors. So I will go wherever I see things that are cheap with significant value. Value upside. And I'm kind of off risk right now because the resource sector has gotten so cheap.
I don't need to put on body armor like I used to do in 2010, and '11, and '12, and 2005 to go to parts of the world that may not want you, and you need to have private security. That's bull market stuff. We're in the bear market. Now I can just drive up to a site that pays me 8% dividends.
I can see the stock tripling in a decent market. Why do I need to go somewhere where the person looks at me as a pirate or a predator? I don't need that. So that's where I'm in the market.
So I don't know when I'll be able to buy these oil stocks that I'm all excited about. It could be in 3 weeks. It could be in 3 months. But I really don't care because I've done my analysis. I'm just going to wait for the price to come to me like an alligator, and then Will I continue in the Internet of Things? I don't think so.
But if the opportunity is so incredibly valued, and it's a right structure, and I'm going to get paid to hold my stock, I'll definitely look at it. But right now, I think I've nailed the best one in the sector, the cheapest one. I don't need more of it in my portfolio. Hopefully, that answers your question.
Erik Townsend: OK. Well, it sounds like what we should expect then to watch for in your newsletter in coming
Marin Katusa: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: What Marin wants is the plays on the actual resource-producing companies, and it sounds like it's just not time yet to buy them. And I'll look forward to seeing that when it comes. I do want to stress for any newer listeners that Marin's newsletter is really not for beginners or for small investors. It's an expensive letter. It's one of the best ones around, but it's not cheap. It's, what is it, $3,500 normally? And Patrick has beaten your guys down. down again. So the offer for MacroVoices listeners is $1,999, $2,000 basically. I should stress, you know, it's a great newsletter. I'm a subscriber myself. This is not for somebody whose total portfolio is $10,000. You've got to have some significant assets in the resources space. Do you have a guideline, Marin, of how much money somebody should have in the natural resource sector?
Marin Katusa: You have that angle where, you know, obviously you don't want to spend 20% of your fund on research. That just doesn't make sense. But I created this— it's kind of an interesting story. I didn't go to school to become what people call a newsletter writer. I don't even see myself as a newsletter writer. In fact, I'm probably the largest financier, bigger than most firms in the sector, because of the size of my following. And we take no fees off of this. So one thing I want to emphasize, we've raised hundreds of millions of dollars for these companies we believe in, and not a penny has come to me— zero, nix.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Marin Katusa: Zilch, because I believe that the market has changed. Why do I need some analysts where I've got 10 of them, and they're all better than any of the firms out there?
We have our skin in the game. We are the largest investors in any deal we do, and it's about learning and the education, my framework, my process.
And when I first met Doug and all you know the Casey and all these guys back 20, 18 years ago, Doug was fascinated with my process. He's like, "Wait a second, you went to the site on your own?" Yeah, why not? You know, I was a young guy, I was a hustler, I had did quite well in the markets. I started structuring these deals, and then I started writing for Doug and doing— then I took over managing all his money. And I kind of find it funny that he's the chair of a competitor of mine, and he's one of the largest newsletters in the business, but yet I manage all of his money. It's almost ironic. And so many of these other newsletter writers are not allowed to buy stock that they talk about.
Now, why would you ever want to take advice from someone that has no skin in the game.
Number 2, I do this. So people go, why do you bother writing a newsletter? What the hell is the point? Like, aren't newsletter writers cheesy? Yeah, you're right. Most of them are total knobs. They're paid-for pundits. Stay the fuck away from all those morons. Okay, that's the number one rule. Now, guys who are— there are certain good guys that, you know, do the style, but they don't write flashy. They're not guaranteeing. Like, if you listen to what I'm saying, I'm like, look, be conservative. Use $35 oil in your numbers. I don't use $100 oil. If anyone's talking about $100 Stay the hell away from those guys. Or guys talking about $3,000 oil in their analysis, stay away from those guys.
It's about deal flow. So you look at mCloud. How did I get those terms that no one else in the market could get? He knows that, A, number one, that meeting, he doesn't have to go across Canada and spend 2 weeks trying to raise the money from all these brokers and guys that want 8% finder fees and all this bullshit like that. I said, look, if you do 5, I'll do 5. Here are the terms that work for me. Let's roll. And he knew that I would get it done. Secondly, I said, and I'll bring my subscribers in, and we take zero fees.
So I do this for deal flow because companies need access to the markets. And because now I've built up the largest resource newsletter, I've got thousands of people— I call them my Alligator Club— that are all looking to be predators like me, to gobble up stock at the best price in the best companies that have the biggest upside. That is why I do it, because I am much stronger with my alligator pack than if I was just a fund manager noodling away on my own. That's why I do what I do, Erik.
Erik Townsend: Well, Marin, I could go on for hours and hours talking with you about this stuff, but we are going to have to leave it here in the interest of time. Listeners, again, the Universal mCloud deal that we've been discussing, which is just fascinating to me, Internet of Things sensors in oil fields communicating wirelessly over, over the internet. It's cool stuff. That deal is already closed, so it's too late for that one. But information about Marin's newsletters for future opportunities is at KatusaResearch.com/MacroVoices.
That's also linked in your Research Roundup email. Again, the URL is www.KatusaResearch.com/MacroVoices. Don't forget the forward slash MacroVoices because that's the part that gets you the $1,500 discount. And that is a 30-day money-back trial, so by all means feel free to try it. If you don't like it, by all means you can cancel with no penalty whatsoever. We are going to leave it there. Marin, thanks so much for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time. in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was a great interview with Marin Katusa. Great to have him back on the show. It's always interesting to get an update on how his views on everything for, like, uranium and gold, which is something that interests me a lot, where it's updated. But I've always actually felt that these energy companies are just getting hammered, and at some point there's going to be a screaming buy. It's interesting he doesn't think it's time just yet, but it's certainly something that's been on my mind. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: You know, the thing that really strikes me, I think Marin is very good at what he does. He thinks of himself as a, you know, an expert on precious metals and natural resources and mining and so forth, and he's very He's good at all those things. Frankly, I think that really a lot of his success comes from his ability to structure deals. The warrants that he described on this Universal mCloud thing, it's just a way of negotiating. You sort of make the deal that makes sense and you throw in that, give us a warrant too, or a half warrant that's above the market, so it's not costing you anything. And of course, later on, it's delivering the investor optionality to potentially buy an option or to have an option that will be in the money when you exercise it. So I'm really impressed with the way that Marin structures his deals beyond just the fundamental market analysis of what deals to make.
And of course, that's really strong as well.
Erik Townsend: But in any case, Patrick, I want to move on to our postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says postgame chartbook. Or if you're not registered yet and don't have a Research Roundup Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com and click the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, which is right at the top of the page.
Patrick, here's what's on my mind. I think that the market should go down as I look at your chart number 2 where you've got, you know, what's going to happen next. I think that what ought to happen if I was in charge of the world is we would recognize that there's serious recession risk, that there's ridiculously high equity valuations.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: And that this entire house of cards that we call a financial market has been built out of central bank largesse.
I seem to be in the minority in that view. So the downsloping red arrow that you're showing here, even though I think that's what should happen, I'm rapidly coming around to recognizing the possibility that maybe that's not what's going to happen. And I do think that from a technical perspective, if we break above 3,000 on the S&P, we're probably going much higher. Much higher. So what I want to talk about for my own trading is, you know, I don't want to be long this market. I don't want to wake up that October of 1987 morning when you're down 25% overnight and the market's opening, you know, 20% below where it closed the day before. I don't want to be any part of that, but I do want to participate in the upside, even if it's a crazy melt-up. And the way to do that is usually through call options, but you've got so many choices to make around which contract you select and how far out of the money are you going to go and so forth.
So how should I be thinking about this problem and how should I be using options to structure trades?
Patrick Ceresna: It's a great question you're asking. And I think this is such a fascinating moment in the markets for this because to me, somebody is going to be spectacularly wrong, right? Like if you're loaded up on the belief that the market is going to keep ripping higher and we get caught in a major turn and it turns into a bear market, the losses could add up pretty quickly. But equally, on the opposite side, if you're completely on the sidelines and in cash, especially if you're an asset manager, you're— there's a serious risk, career risk, in terms of missing out on big gains to the upside, and you're sitting on the sidelines not participating, or even in the worst case, short.
And so this is a fascinating time to use options. The key here is that over the long term, just rolling call options is not a good strategy. The theta burn that occurs on rolling premium continuously on an ongoing basis dilutes your long-term returns. So if anytime you take a model and you, let's say, said, how would we have done, let's say, over the last 5 years just rolling call options, it's always going to underperform just owning the asset. That's just fact. But this is an interesting moment in the market where you don't want that stock market downside risk, and yet you want that optionality of that if the market rips higher, you're going to make money. And this is where I want to debate, well, what if you use call options? How would they perform? And which call option would you choose? Do you choose an in-the-money, at-the-money, out-of-the-money? How do they perform in comparison?
And let's see if we can draw some conclusions. Now, last week when we were talking about this, you suggested rolling like a 30-cent delta call option forward. So I made sure I included a 30-cent delta option in our chain to kind of look at it. But we're going to do a little case study. And what our listeners can see on page 3 of the chartbook that's available in that Research Roundup email and/or just Just get the chartbook off the website.
We're looking to gain upside exposure. We're comparing what if we, A, Investor A was just going to buy the shares and how would it compare if we started with August 16th options, which are 50 days until their expiration, right? Today's June 27th and we're going out to August 16th, so 50 days.
And we're looking at 3 particular call options, and I chose the strike prices of $285. Remember, the— at the time when we're doing this, the SPY was trading at $291.34, and the implied volatility close on it was just over 14%. So we're looking at a $285 strike, which is just over $6 in the money, and at the money, $291.34 $281 strike call option and an out-of-the-money $300 strike call option. So why these particular 3 strikes? Well, the $285 strike has close to a 70-cent delta. So we wanted to buy some intrinsic value deeper in the money, an option that will behave more like the underlying because the delta is higher. Just an at-the-money, just so we have a comparison, something close to a 50-cent Delta. And then I wanted to go with the out-of-the-money, which we're getting that 30-cent delta, which is about the $300 strike call.
So let's take a look at what's happening here.
Now, Erik, before we get to the actual outcomes, I wanted to jump to page 4 to actually just show the vol skew that actually happens in options on the S&P 500.
Now, in some places like the gold market, and Treasury bond markets, you have really nice U-shaped skews. What is normal in equity markets, particularly in indexes like the S&P, is you have this massive fat left tail and a downward sloping skew that the farther you're going out of the money on the calls, the lower the implied volatilities are. That means you're paying a rich tail risk vol premium, and it's It actually gets cheaper and cheaper to buy on a relative basis, to buy out-of-the-money call options to participate on the upside. A lot of people speculate that that has a lot to do with the amount of premium harvesting that is occurring on out-of-the-money strikes that creates the skew, as well as all the people that try to implement collars and other things that create this.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Patrick, let's go through the scenarios of different approaches using either at-the-money or well out-of-the-money or maybe partly out-of-the-money options and see how they compare.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So on slides 5, 6, 7, and 8 and 9 are all the different scenarios that happen. So what we wanted to do is take 4 investors, Investors A, B, C, and D, and each one are trading a different vehicle. So Investor A just buys the physical shares of the SPDR ETF on the S&P 500. Investor B is using a high-delta option. Investor C is using the at-the-money, and Investor D is using the out-of-the-money option. And we're going to pay a little attention to Investor D because Investor D is buying the lower vol out-of-the-money, and it's also a 30-cent delta, something that you referenced last week in the show. So we can kind of track Investor D to see what results they're getting by using that kind of 30-cent delta option as a way of gaining exposure to the markets. And so we wanted to do a case study of each investor just, A, buying either the shares, 100 shares, or just buying one call option of each.
Now, of course, many of our listeners, which are very smart, will know that you can certainly buy more of the cheaper option and leverage up and all these different variables. But just for comparison's sake, we're just going to assume one call option just so we can be comparing apples to apples on this.
And so on page 6, what I just show is the starting delta dollar exposure, which is essentially what is the aggregate amount that each option is behaving as, right? And so in Investor A, who physically owns 100 shares of the S&P 500, their 100 shares are at a delta 1, which is what stocks behave behave as, is literally behaving as the $29,000 that was outlaid to buy the shares. But what's interesting is Investor B, by buying some intrinsic value in a higher delta, is actually, even though they're only outlaying $1,137 to buy the call, they're actually getting 70 cents on the dollar exposure to the upside of the market. The delta dollars is $19,956, almost $20,000 of delta dollars, even though they're only outlaying a fraction of the risk capital that Investor A is doing. And when we go to Investor C, again, it's just multiplying the delta dollars through to being $16,000.
And Investor D, which is our 30-cent delta options trader who bought the $300 call,
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: strike call option, outlay $245 or $2.45 a call.
And at a near 30-cent delta, that starting delta for the position is $8,594. So that means that one call option that was purchased for $245 is behaving as though it was like $8,600 of S&P.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's look at this then in terms of the performance. What happens if the market's going up quickly as we think it could? What happens if the market stays flat? What happens if the market goes down?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is where we have to observe, like for everything that we said, this is where the really interesting part is. How much did the call option participate in each of the scenarios with the upside of the market? But what if the market crashes? How much did each one lose? And I think that's where the looking at the asymmetry in the trading really comes to light.
Scenario 1 on page 7, we're looking at well Brent Johnson and Kevin Muir and all these guys are right. The S&P 500 melts up and we find ourselves over the next 30 days. So remember, the options we bought were 50 days. They were the August 16th expiry. So over the next 30 days, let's say to the end of July, the S&P 500 breaks to a new high after the G20 and just rips. And we're now at. 3,100 on the S&P 500 in, in 30 days. So how did each investor perform? And what I find really interesting first is between Investor A and B. So Investor B bought in-the-money call option, which had that 70-cent starting delta.
Investor A, who owned the shares, and what's interesting is that their performance was actually pretty close. I mean, you had the Investor A, who owned the physical shares, outlaid close to $30,000 to buy them, finds themselves up just over $1,800 in profit, while Investor B, who would just outlay just over $1,000 to control the high delta position, finds themselves up $14 or $1,400 on that call option, more than doubling their return on capital risk outlay. on there. But, but the key here is, is that option that Investor B controlled really did actually behave a lot like the stock ownership.
Now I want to move right to Investor D because that's our 30-cent delta call, the one who bought the out-of-the-money $300 call. And this is where the speculator tends to often get big payoff for leveraging up, because what you can see is that while our investor was up $8.42 or $842. It's not as much as Investor B with the deep in the money, but our investor only outlaid $245 to buy that call option, which is now worth over $1,000, like a threefold-plus increase in its value. And so the key here is, is that Investor D was able to own an option with a very small capital outlay and capture pretty much almost half of the upside potential of the market with almost little to no risk outlay.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this slide is easy for everybody to like because everybody's making money. What happens if the market's flat or even goes down?
Patrick Ceresna: Right, so this is scenario 2, and this is where, uh, scenario 2 is just over the next 30 days, the market ends up going up a little bit, down little and remains unchanged over that timeframe. And so we have a scenario where if the S&P 500 is exactly where it started 30 days earlier, the options investors B, C, and D all equally suffered time decay, right? Which is the theta burn that comes from, from having paid premium to have exposure to the market and the market not doing anything while you own those calls. And so investor who owned the shares obviously didn't lose anything, obviously lost the opportunity to make money, but certainly not down from a profit-loss perspective.
But in each of those scenarios, what we did was experience considerable amount of time decay. But what is interesting on a percentage basis, Investor D, which paid $2.45, that option at this moment with 2 weeks left till expiry is worth about $0.74. And And has lost more than half of the premium that they outlaid in that option. And that's the cost of carry at this moment. Going back to that scenario we're saying where, well, let's roll every 30 days on this option, like we're going to go buy a 30-cent delta call and every 30 days we roll forward. Well, in this situation, that $1.70 loss was your carry, your cost of having held that option. rather than owning the market. And you would just roll it forward and go another 30 days out further from, let's say, August to September. And then you would continue to wait to see whether the market breaks out.
But where the asymmetry is the most evident is scenario number 3, which is on page 9. And this is exactly, Erik, why you were talking about wanting to use call options instead of owning the shares. Because all Ultimately, the scenario that bull scenario that you know the Brent Johnsons of the world are touting this idea the market can make big money on the upside is great. But what if what if the the bear market rears its head and what if this is a topping formation and what if what happened in October, November, and December of last year suddenly manifests itself here and we have the markets plunging lower? And this is in scenario. Scenario 3, I just took a market drop equal to what we experienced in October of 2018, just like the past October, the first leg of the market drop. And so here I dropped the SPY down to the 260 level, about a 30-point drop.
And what you can see is that Investor A, the one who physically owns the shares, definitely took the brunt of the hit, right? This is where you're down $31 a share. You're down $3,000+ on your 100 shares of the SPY. But where the asymmetry of using the call option is when you look at investors B, C, and D that used the options, their risk was very defined. And that was to the capital they outlaid for those calls. And while they participated on a very good chunk of the majority of the upside, their risk was quite limited to the downside. And that is actually that asymmetry that a trader is seeking in this current market environment.
And this is where the trade-off comes to what I said at the beginning, which is over the long term, this is not a great way to play options. Over a 5-year period, continuously rolling call options is not necessarily a way to create alpha. But in a unique time in the market like this, where we literally can have an explosive move one way and an explosive move the other way, using the, the asymmetry in limited risk with unlimited upside potential that you can gain from options makes it a very interesting way to express the trade, especially now the volatility is still relatively low. I mean, the implied volatilities right now are still in the lower end of the teens, right? And so it's not like we're dealing with a VIX up in the 20 to 30 range where these call options start becoming expensive and you have a big vega risk.
Erik Townsend: Okay, so to pull all of this together, as I think about the scenario that I'm concerned with, which is if a market melt-up starts, you know, I can buy the S&P— this is option A— at $29,134. The problem with that, Patrick, although you're showing a loss here of $3,134 here. That was on a drop to, you know, $2,600. What happens if we get more of an October 1987 event and you're down more than $10,000 overnight on that position? That's the risk I don't want to take. So if I think about this in terms of the way I might approach it is to think, okay, I want to be exposed to the market and I want to do it with call options.
As you say, it's not the right strategy to use most most of the time. But if you think there's going to be a melt-up where there's very rapid pace of price increase until you eventually get to a blow-off top and a reversal to the downside, which is what I think could be coming in the next 6 to 12 months if we do get this melt-up, then what you might do as a strategy is say, okay, I'll take 1% of my account size, I'll spend that on options each month, and I'm going to use those options to be exposed to the market. And, you know, if I make money, that's wonderful. If I end up losing all of the money I spent on my options, well, it's 1%. It's not the end of the world. It's certainly not 25 to 40% down, as you could see in an outright market crash if you were exposed to the underlying.
So the question is which of these different choices I might choose. Let's suppose for sake of argument that What I've got to spend is $1,200. Well, I could buy that one $285 SPY call. That really is giving me the same kind of upside potential as being long the shares, except I'm going to lose that whole $1,200. I'm not too crazy about that. If I've got that same $1,200 to spend, I could instead spend it on buying not just one, but 3 of those Investor D $300 calls.
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, okay.
Erik Townsend: calls. I could have triple leverage there so that if it goes above 3,000 on the S&P, I'm making, you know, 3 times as much as I would have made. It's gonna be great. The thing is, that option expires completely worthless unless you get from where we are right now to above 3,000 in just 50 days, or 30 days if you're gonna roll the option at that point.
So I've really got to think you only want to be that far out of the money if you really think there's a chance of the market moving up that quickly in the course of one month that you could be in the money by the end of the month.
And that really is where the trade-off is in terms of these different deltas. Is there any formula that we can use? I mean, it seems like, you know, it's hard to guess if you think a market melt-up is going to happen, you know, how many, how many points per month is it going to melt up? It's really hard to estimate.
Patrick Ceresna: I don't use a formula per se. I always work backwards, which is, you know, as a technician, I build on the charts my expectations where I think a market can go, right? So like last week's chart book, we were talking about where the measured moves on the upside of the S&P 500 would be if there was a breakout. And so in the end, what I do is I kind of build a scenario of the what-ifs. Well, what if we're And it bullishly does break out and it goes here to the second target level. Which option will give me the best asymmetry and make sure I can build enough intrinsic value if I'm right? But at the same time, how much leverage can I gain? And so you basically work backwards, first building the scenario you think will happen, and then you can stress test 2 or 3 different ways to put the options trade on.
And then And then see which one best suits the narrative you've built.
Erik Townsend: Okay, well, I think this pretty much explains it as best as we can in the time that we have available. Now, for our listeners who would have liked the deeper explanation and the full description of all the Greek letters that Patrick's talking about, the theta decay and so forth, keep in mind Patrick does teach options trading classes that go into the gory detail of all this stuff. You can get a 14-day free access pass to Big Picture Trading just by going to bigpicturetrading.com. The other thing, Patrick, I want to bring up before we close this week is you've got a speaking engagement coming up at Traders Expo Chicago, July 21st through 23rd. What's going on there? What can people expect?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I'm gonna be out at the show. Big Picture Trading has a booth going on there, but I had the opportunity to be a part of the Global Macro Edge series there with John Netto, who we're going to be having on the show in the coming future. And what we're going to be doing out there is I'm going to be a part of the Bull versus Bear Smackdown debate as to where stocks and bonds are heading next. And John Netto is going to be moderating that debate between me and Kevin Muir. And as well, I'm going to be doing a presentation on straddles again about how can use them to catch market tops. So I'll be doing that live out there, and it's going to be an opportunity to meet many of our listeners. So those of you that can make it out to Chicago during that July 21st to 23rd period, put it on your schedule.
It's, it's free to attend. It's going to be a great show. We'll be there talking with all of our listeners, so it'd be such a pleasure to meet many of you.
Erik Townsend: That's fantastic, Patrick. I'm sure that our Chicago listeners, as well as those that are able to travel to Chicago, will enjoy your presentation at that that event. Meanwhile, we're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time.
Today's episode was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/Macro to claim your free book and subscribe to their podcast as well. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices yourself, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. And folks, we really appreciate your ratings and reviews on iTunes. So please keep them coming. And likewise, I cannot thank the many of you who have donated enough. We are still in the process of trying to acquire more sponsors, and those donations are keeping us going in the meanwhile. So thank you to everyone who has donated. And listeners, be sure to go to MacroVoices.com to sign up for your free account so that you'll receive our free Research Roundup email each week, which delivers a compendium of links to of the best content that we could find on the internet, including the downloads for things like the chartbook that we just talked you through in the postgame segment, as well as downloads from our feature interview guests.
Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Marin Katusa, as well as the charts and explanation of the options we talked about here in the postgame. There's also an article from Jesse Felder titled You Better Be Careful and Keep Your Eyes Open, and a great article from Nouriel Roubini titled The Coming Sino-American Bust-Up. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup.
That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. For those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share That content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you next time. Thank you. We'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education. For traders, please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to. Our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions.
The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by. Sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Greg Weldon — Greg Weldon, founder of Weldon Live, well-known commodities expert (w2539) (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 172 was recorded on June 20th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the leading podcast when it comes to systematic trading and investing. And what a week in markets, from tanker attacks to Iran shooting down a US drone this morning, to central bankers turning back toward more dovish monetary policy, to the China trade talks, to stocks opening at new all-time highs today. It's been a hell of a week, and we've got a fantastic show lined up for you.
Many experts are expecting interest rates to fall much farther from here, and there are strong views on both sides of the US dollar debate. But what will all of this mean for commodities, which are usually priced in dollars? Greg Weldon joins me as this week's feature interview guest to explore that question in full detail, starting with monetary policy and then reviewing what it means for everything from precious metals to energy to base metals to grains. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will address a listener question about crude oil forward curves, and we'll also have another of Patrick's famous postgame chart books to discuss all the exciting action in markets this week.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's get right to this S&P 500, which this morning opened at new all-time highs.
Erik Townsend: What's going on Well, Patrick, I still continue to have many reservations about the economy. I think the bond market agrees with me about those reservations about the economy, but that's not what the stock market is paying attention to. We're living in this bad news is the new good news doctrine. Doesn't make sense to me, but it's been what's driving the market. They see Fed accommodation coming. More easy money drives risk assets higher, as counterintuitive as I think that really is. So what's going on here, Patrick, is the combination of market hopes of a Fed rate One is a rate cut at the next meeting, plus the China trade negotiations being back on. I think where we're likely headed is that both of those hopes come true.
In other words, we get some kind of China deal. I don't know what kind of deal, but I wouldn't be surprised if around the end of June we see some kind of a deal emerge. And I wouldn't be surprised if we do see an FOMC rate cut at the next meeting. If both of those things happen, it's likely to push the market even higher. Now, maybe that's your final sell-the-news moment and the topping cycle is over and that's it. But frankly, Basically, smart people learn from what's working, not what they think should be working.
And what's working is liquidity is driving the market higher, regardless of what I think the fundamentals should be. So we can go into some more detail on this, Patrick. I've got some other questions I want to ask you about option strategies in the postgame segment when we get into your chartbook. But basically what's going on here is I think that we're maybe headed toward a melt-up, which I don't think makes fundamental sense, but it appears that it's perhaps starting to happen.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US dollar because it looked like it started to recover and then came the Fed announcement and pretty much wiped out an entire week's progress higher. What's your thinking here on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, we did wipe out that entire week's worth of progress higher, but we didn't go lower than the previous low. At least we haven't yet. I won't be surprised if we do. Remember that we're reacting here to expectations. At some point, we're gonna get an actual cut, not just expectations of a cut. And I wouldn't be surprised if that results in a really big knee-jerk down on the dollar index. What we're seeing now is a medium knee-jerk down on expectations that that cut might be coming next month.
I think the bigger knee-jerk comes when we actually get the cut. But what happens after that? My expectation is that that knee-jerk lower is an opportunity to buy the dip because I think the dollar rally is set to continue because of the global dollar liquidity squeeze, which Brent Johnson and Jeff Snider have described in different ways on this program. There's lots and lots of smart people who disagree with me, Patrick, including Greg Weldon, today's feature interview guest. So you'll hear his reasons for seeing it very differently than I see it. There's lots of reasons that they could be right.
The reason that I think they'll be caught wrong-footed is because I don't think what's driving the dollar is entirely about the usual factors of interest rate differentials and so forth. I think it's about this global dollar liquidity squeeze, which Jeff Snider has opined extensively about. I too could be wrong. Time will tell. And if I've got the dollar story wrong, I've definitely got the gold story wrong.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because we got a pretty big reaction on, uh, on the news. So what's, uh, what's going on?
Erik Townsend: Much déjà vu to last week when I said, Patrick, I'm only gonna tell you what's happened since we recorded the Energy Week episode just 24 hours ago, and it was still a long report. So we'll start with a very quick recap of what happened before this latest escalation today.
There was a big spike up to range resistances on WTI on Tuesday morning in reaction to news of the ECB turning more dovish and a resumption of the US-China trade talks. Then came the EIA inventory report with crude oil drawing down 3.1 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma still showing a build of 643,000 barrels despite the national drawdown. Gasoline building 147,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 551,000 barrels. So we're finally seeing a crude drawdown after a string of consecutive crude oil builds over the last few weeks. Be very interesting to see where the trend takes us from here. The tape action was a pop up initially to range resistance, then a fade back down. But as we started to approach the close, we started trading higher.
And eventually, I think some people might have had early word about what was coming on the geopolitical front, because even before the news came out, we started to see crude oil just melting up higher. And now, of course, we're seeing crude oil is way up at north of $57 as we're speaking Thursday afternoon. That is a direct result of Iran shooting down a US drone and publicly admitting that they did so, causing a lot of people to be concerned about a further escalation of geopolitical tension in the Gulf. There's no limit to how much upside is possible in a Middle East conflict that has contagion risk to a larger war. But is that really the case here, or is Iran alone? Certainly, if Russia comes to Iran's aid, That changes the game dramatically. But if Iran is acting alone, I don't think it really does much to affect supply and demand fundamentals of oil because Iran's oil is really mostly out of the market except for the gray market action that continues to occur there.
The risk is contagion beyond just Iran-US conflict to something else, some bigger conflict. And I think that's what the market is afraid of. My view is that there is still a very good economic case for new lows below $50 if and only if the trend of stock builds continues and this whole geopolitical situation blows over somehow. If the geopolitics don't blow over, anything's possible in prices to the upside. That leaves me on the sidelines. I'm hoping to be short enough to know when to short this market when the prices peak out after all of this geopolitical tension blows over. But needless to say, that's a very difficult thing to time.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, it's time to move on to gold. I mean, we've had for over a year guest after guest talk about how important this $1,350 overhead resistance on gold is. And here we are clearing that zone. What's on your mind when it comes to gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, woo-hoo. Needless to say, this is a really big, important move. I wanna clarify though, it's really, it's a band of resistance between $1,350 and $1,375. Now we did break past all of those numbers. Almost testing 1,400 already. And as we're speaking right now, Patrick, I'm looking at 1,393 on my chart. So needless to say, the signs are that a big breakout past this very, very critical— it's been 5 years, Patrick, that we've been struggling to get past this resistance level at 1,350 to 1,375— that may be occurring now.
But I want to stress, it may be occurring. There's a lot of good economic reasons for why, but hold on, we need to see a sustained breakout. When you have a technical level that's been in play for 5 years, you know, people were, were just declaring victory on Twitter 10 minutes after the breakout occurred outside of regular trading hours. That's crazy. You've got to see the price actually sustain during regular trading hours and get a daily close above those key levels. Well, We're going to get that in the next few minutes here unless the market absolutely tanks. So it looks like we are beginning to see these confirmation signals. I think we need a lot more than just one day, though. And in this particular case, where we have so many geopolitical tensions, which are the kinds of things that tend to cause gold to spike up until the geopolitical tension blows over, if the whole Iran situation blows over, there's still room for this to reverse back to the downside.
So, you know, it's definitely looking— the preponderance of evidence suggests that most likely we're seeing the beginning of a major and important breakout, one that I was not expecting. And if that's what happens, I'll be happy to admit having been wrong.
But we're not quite there yet, folks. We need to see confirmation of this move, and it is still possible for this to be proven to be a false breakout. So I really don't think that the jury is in at this point. But so far, indications are that we're moving toward a move higher, and I could see it really, really accelerating from here if it is confirmed.
Patrick Ceresna: And now it's my turn to say wow, because the 10-year yield actually temporarily broke below 2%. It's trading a little bit above right now. But what's your thinking here? Like, the interest rates just keep going lower.
Erik Townsend: And I think they're going to continue to go lower. And in the interest of full disclosure, I should mention that I just closed half of my long position on 2-year Treasury futures on Wednesday evening, not because I don't think that rates are going to continue to go lower, but I think we're seeing some froth in the market in reaction to the FOMC press release. And I think that it's possible that we'll get a significant pullback. So I took half of my long off and hope to catch a reentry a little bit lower. But we'll see what happens. In any case, I do think that lower yields are coming. It's pretty clear to me. That we are headed toward a recession in 2020. The fact that the stock market is melting up anyway is a little bit crazy, but I don't think it's being driven by economic fundamentals. I think it's being driven by liquidity and easy money policy.
The frustration here is there haven't been any really good pullbacks for a long entry. I am already long those 2-year Treasuries. As I said, I just closed half of that position, but not because I don't think we're not going to lower interest rates. I just think we're a little overdone here, and I'd like to catch a pullback for another long entry. In the meantime— What's your view on the Fed? You know, I've been saying this for weeks. It's hard to justify new longs when we've already moved so far so fast. I've been suggesting wait for the pullback, but boy, there hasn't been a pullback. We just keep going lower and lower in yields. So we'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is commodities expert Greg Weldon. Now, Erik, why did we invite Greg onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Greg is a really solid guy. He's been around for a long time. But what I really like about him is he's one of the few commodity guys That really gets the macro and understands why macro is so important to the commodities market. And when I asked him off the air, Greg, you know commodities dude, we gotta talk about, you know, precious metals and energy and base metals, and where do you wanna start? And he's like, where do I wanna start? Obviously, we gotta start with the FOMC and monetary policy. That's what drives all of this. It doesn't make any sense to talk about commodities until we talk first about where the dollar is headed. And Greg and I disagree on the dollar. That's fine. The point is, He gets it. He understands that what really drives the commodity complex is a lot of macro-driving factors, and he's very plugged into that.
Not everybody in the commodities world is, and that's the reason that I really think he's a good guy to listen to when it comes to commodity markets.
Patrick Ceresna: And Erik, who's our sponsor this week?
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Although I personally am a global macro investor myself, it has long been known to investors around the world that systematic or quant-based strategies are profoundly effective at extracting returns from the market. Top hedge funds like Bridgewater Associates and Renaissance Technologies discovered this decades ago, and there's one podcast that covers this area of finance better than any other: TopTradersUnplugged.com.
And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book explaining how these systematic strategies work. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's toptradersunplugged.com/macro. Check them out, you'll be glad you did. And now let's move on to the feature interview coming up right after this.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Greg Weldon, the founder of Weldon Live, well-known commodities expert. Greg, everybody knows you as the commodities guy and probably is expecting me to dive right into commodities, but I think before we go there, we should talk about central banks, monetary policy, and the general condition of the world, because I think something you and I agree on is that to understand the commodities picture, you've got to understand the monetary policy picture first. So, where do we start in terms of the situation that the world is in and where we're headed? Do you want to talk about the Fed or the ECB?
Where do you want to start?
Greg Weldon: I don't know. You got 3 or 4 hours and we can discuss it all. What I find interesting is, you know, the commodities angle, because, you know, in the business 35 years, started on the trading floor in the COMEX in the World Trade Center back in the early '80s. And what I see is that everything has been commoditized.
We are the commodity guys because we look at everything, and so it includes stocks and bonds, and everything is now a commodity because of this secular credit bubble that goes all the way back to 1971.
And now you're at a point, and it's becoming more and more obvious, particularly today as we're recording, when Mario Draghi is in the headlines and this continued push for even more stimulus beyond QE, beyond negative actual deposit rates and official policy rates. That to me, I mean, you're at some kind of mathematical tipping point potentially where the amount of money needed now to stimulate, given the growth in credit, given the growth in sovereign debt, especially in the US going back even just to 2008 and 2009, has grown exponentially to the point where I'm not sure they can either A, have the political will to pump that much money. They probably will because they'll do whatever they have to do to avoid falling into the The debt deflation scenario. That's the biggest fear among central bankers.
And from that perspective, the question is, what if it stops working? What if it only works to keep things where they are? Because that's not good enough. You need growth. With all this debt and all this credit creation, you need growth to basically keep this thing floating.
So, I think Mario Draghi made a big misstep the first quarter of last year when they failed to raise rates when GDP was strong in a lot of member nations, when inflation was above target in several places, particularly Germany. That fed in through all the Eastern European states as well. They could have raised rates just even to zero to give themselves some back-end firepower. The Fed's done a masterful job of that, but now it's almost like the Fed is going to have to be the central banker to the world because they're the ones that have actually created some room to stimulate by cutting interest rates.
Erik Townsend: I want to talk about that point of the Fed being the central banker to the world specifically, because I think it's just paramount importance in the environment that we have right now. The US dollar, if you look at the fundamentals and what the Fed has done and the expansion of the balance sheet, on the face of it, a lot of people would say, okay, this has got to be negative for the US dollar. Just look at what they're doing to debase the value of the currency with all of the balance sheet expansion and so forth. But I've really come around to an opposite view, which is, as bad as it is, it's worse in Europe and Japan.
And as much as it seems to us like it doesn't make sense, the safety trade for most people is going to be into the dollar. Most institutions around the world will still see US Treasuries as their safety trade. And I think it continues to provide a very counterintuitive boost to the dollar relative to other currencies, even in the face of what seemed to be fundamentals that ought to be dollar bearish if you weren't considering the other currencies. Where do you stand on this whole debate. Do you think that we should be shorting the dollar here at its recent highs, or do you think that the dollar is going to get squeezed even higher?
Greg Weldon: First thing I would say is, bam! I mean, you just nailed it. I mean, it really does seem to be kind of counterintuitive. What I would say is there's a massive kind of conflict, almost a war going on right now in the dollar, and there's kind of 3 fundamental forces that I perceive.
Number one is all the dollar debt that's been created. So, this is maybe what's holding the dollar up a little more. Because really, if you go back to last, like, November, you had a major disconnect between the correlation of the dollar index and the forward Fed funds futures market and the implied rates. So, and what's interesting is, as that has occurred, you could even say that the fact that the dollar hasn't come off with that has actually intensified the push lower in yields in the fixed income market, and that there's dollar demand.
I mean, I'll throw a curveball at you just out of the blue. Take Angola, okay, where the Kwanza is the local currency. It's down like You know, relative to gold, it's down like 500% in the last 10 years. This is a country that's an OPEC member, produces more oil per day than right now Nigeria does, and their currency is just getting annihilated to the point where you can't accept the local currency, you can't use the local currency locally, you know, for goods and services. You have the same situation developing in a lot of places around the world. Venezuela is an obvious one. Argentina, it's infiltrating into Colombia. You got a situation in Pakistan. We know Iran. You can take even places like Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan. There are currencies that are getting slammed. And in this sense, it creates demand for dollars.
So, I think the dollar's being held up by that. But the fundamentals now going forward for me is if the Fed is gonna be the central bank to the world, because I totally believe that, the dollar is absolutely in play on the downside.
And now that Trump is tweeting about Draghi, I mean, come on, man, you just took it up a notch. It's like, you know, the old Seinfeld thing, Mandelbaum, Mandelbaum, taking it up a notch here now. And I think if you take out 95.02 on On the dollar index, the cash dollar index, that's a major technical breakdown. The entire rally has kind of been Fibonacci retracement almost to the bigger picture. It's always the dollar as the relief valve. I've been doing this 35 years. It's always the dollar. And relative to gold, the dollar since 1971 is down 86%. That's going to continue to be the case. So, I think the dollar is very vulnerable. It's in play, and that's what makes gold so attractive here.
Erik Townsend: And when you say it's in play, do you mean that you believe that Do you mean that the next move for the dollar is down, or do you mean that the game is on and it could go either way before that happens?
Greg Weldon: Well, it could go— I mean, I think it's gonna— I think they're gonna play to the downside. The question, of course, is if the demand is so great in some of these other places in the world, you know, how effective are they going to be? I would say that's already in question because you have the, you know, the Fed funds and now even the interest rate differential. So really covering like the US-German bond yield differential.
Again, highly correlated to the dollar, and more recently, that's kind of broken down to some degree. So, when you see those kinds of things, you start to ask yourself, why is the dollar holding up here when normally an intramarket dynamic like this that is bigger picture would drive it lower? And I think that the Fed will be as aggressive as they have to be.
They can't let the dollar break out. It goes to 104, it's another 5%, 6% to the upside, and you're looking at a 30% 5-year rate of change. That has always been problematic. In terms of the Fed's concerned about their— the credibility of their inflation target. They can't let the dollar go higher if they're concerned about the credibility of their inflation target. Case closed. So, I think dollar's in play to the downside if it breaks 95.02, because we could be wrong.
Erik Townsend: And what happens, let's suppose that we don't break 95.02 and we do see an upside breakout from 98, which seems to be where this overhead resistance is. And let's say in a few months we're at 100 on the dollar index. Let's talk about some of the knock-on effects. What kind of damage can that cause, and how does it play out and affect other markets?
Greg Weldon: Sure. I mean, first, if it takes out 98, it's not stopping at 100, it's going to 104. That's kind of your even bigger picture, longer-term, 61% Fibonacci retracement level. That was the high, you know, in the 2016-17 rally.
So, from that perspective, what happens is it depresses commodity prices. It then affects emerging markets. We were on the precipice of this, and to me, this is kind of why Powell had to, you know, do an about-face. It wasn't so much the US economy. People are looking at the US economy and saying, how can the Fed want to be, you know, a little, you know, beyond neutral to the easy side now when the economy is seemingly, you know, a juggernaut? Well, first of all, the economy is not a juggernaut. We could trash that to pieces, all right, at least in the underlying kind of pipeline for the economy. But the really bigger picture is What was happening was all of a sudden you had emerging market currencies going down, emerging market, uh, the commodities were going down, base metals cracked, you know, ags are at new lows. A lot of this is a dollar influence. And when emerging market stock index started to roll, come on, the timing was almost golden. I mean, Powell's
now changing his tune because they can't allow emerging markets to return as a deflationary risk when you're so far really out of the range of where you're gonna be going forward on your inflation target. And if they're worried about the credibility of their inflation target, and several members of the Fed have mentioned this in recent speeches, and they don't do that by accident, I don't think they can really accept the dollar going higher. So, I feel that there's monetary policy is kind of aimed at this thing more so than the real economy, which is kind of maybe causing some people to be confused.
Erik Townsend: Greg, obviously, precious metals have to come into this conversation. Based on what you've said about how you believe that the dollar is in play to the downside here, I'm assuming that you must already be long gold, but I want to also talk about where we are in this gold market. Let's assume at least some of our listeners don't yet have a position, because even for someone with a bullish outlook, I have to wonder just below this important resistance level whether it's the right place to be putting on new longs. So, how do you see the gold market, and what would you tell someone that doesn't already have a position?
Greg Weldon: It's a great question. That's a 2-pronged question, so I'll give you a 2-pronged answer. I mean, first, from the bigger picture, yes, we're long gold. We actually are long gold from $1,196. So, from below $1,200. And yes, you have resistance here. You have tried to penetrate this resistance on numerous occasions. It was actually $1,377, and it's $1,365.
Then it got down to around $1,345. So, you have this descending, you know, lower highs. Well, you broke through the first one. You're kind of poised. What I said yesterday is that the gold and even the GDX, the gold miners, to me, look like they're on a launching pad. You know, I mean, we're just waiting for the countdown here, and the countdown would theoretically be the dollar.
Is there risk to gold? Sure there is. If the dollar breaks out, there's risk to gold. But that gets back to the bigger picture situation where the dollar is basically near or at new highs, or it's at a very high level relative to the past couple of years.
And gold is up a couple hundred bucks from its lows. In a normal situation, gold probably trading $1,050 to $1,150 right now based on the correlation with the dollar. So what I do is take the dollar index and divide it by gold, and it's a very simple thing to look at. that is basically the gold-adjusted value of the dollar. And herein is where the big picture takes shape, because again, if the dollar is always the relief valve and gold is the flip side of that, it's already in play.
So from that perspective, we do believe gold is gonna break out here. We like silver, we like gold, we like the gold mining shares. You know, if it doesn't here, I think the downside is somewhat limited. So to me, I look at a breakout and then look at what's the upside potential And it's significant. I mean, you get above this $1,377 level, there is virtually no resistance until you're into the $1,700s, the high $1,700s. That's a nice first move. And that would come in context theoretically with a breakdown in the dollar. Otherwise, we're kind of just ebb and flow here and continue to go. But I think the downside is really not that much. And I think gold has proven that to us already. So, yeah, we're locked and loaded. We think this is big picture stuff.
And the biggest picture thing that I can say about this is you are starting to see a crack in the confidence of everyone in paper, in all paper, because currencies, sovereign debt, it's all IOUs. And at some point, you were kind of at the, at the precipice of this thing of what currency that's a paper currency do you even want to hold?
And I think that's the biggest case for gold. And I think ECB is going to stimulate from here. They're going to create consumer loans at -1%. I mean, come on. That's the biggest case for gold yet. So, we like it a lot right here.
Erik Townsend: We had Danielle DiMartino Booth on the program the other day, and she pointed out the change in language that the Fed has moved from the zero lower bound to the effective lower bound. And Danielle thinks that they're very intentionally setting the stage for negative interest rates. How far do you think we can get into negative interest rate territory before something really big breaks? Obviously, there's a cash hoarding incentive there. That at some point it's better for people rather than pay a negative interest rate to just take their money out of the financial system and store it in cash. And of course, there isn't enough cash for everybody to do that. So, you could have a run on the entire financial system if you weren't careful there. How far do you think they're going to push this on this next round that we go through with central bankers?
And what are the risks?
Greg Weldon: Well, I mean, I would agree with Danielle. I mean, she's obviously brilliant and she has great insight into the Fed. And, you know, I watch the language like a hawk. I mean, I'm from the From the old school, man, when you had to watch the repos every day and figure out what the stopout rate and what, you know, it was very much of a nuance, you know. So it's kind of going back to that a little bit.
What I would say is this is kind of where R-star comes into play and where the Fed is, is preparing for this. They know. And I think if you go all the way back to when they started to hike rates, what was really interesting was they wanted to get rates higher so they could use rates as the next stimulus instead of having to blow out the balance sheet again.
So, that's really interesting to me because, you know, the language then was pretty apparent before they ended, you know, the roll-off of the balance sheet. But I don't know. I mean, my thought process immediately when you asked me that question is, by the time the US gets to negative interest rates, the proverbial S has already hit the fan.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So, and do you think it's Japan or Europe or both? Where does it hit the fan first?
Greg Weldon: Absolutely Europe. Europe to me has been the setup the entire time. It really has. I mean, do I have to go through the litany? And, you know, it sounds like a broken record, but man, you are, you are here. You're at this time and space has kind of converged here, and it's time to see how things are gonna play out in a bigger picture way that may not be the end result that it's always been. So to me, that's kind of where it all gets interesting in Europe. I mean, you look at the fracture you have in Europe, it's kind of gotten lost in the translation. This is something people don't talk about anymore. You have separatist governments in Italy and Spain. Last year, last June, I mean, Spain had to include You know, the Catalonians and the Basque Party into their coalition government, and they wouldn't have been able to seize power.
And you know what's going on with Italy. I mean, the League is now rising in power. And so this is a huge dynamic in terms of the potential for blowups to where some of these countries go back to their currencies because— so Italy wants to expand their budget deficit. All right. And they wanna expand it not to a level above 3, which is the, you know, limit in Maastricht and their whole treaty.
What's interesting now is all of a sudden the EU Commission wants to impose penalties. They've been ignoring penalties for 2 decades, and all of a sudden they're picking on Italy, who wants to lift their budget deficit, which theoretically goes against the spirit of the agreement because they're expanding their budget deficit, but they're not exceeding the rules, and they're going to be threatened with fines. This to me was a bad move by the EU Commission because— or whoever is the ruling party that makes these decisions in the EU— because you put Italy in harm's way and you potentially giving them a way out. So I think, you know, there's so much risk in Europe. That's just one of them that comes about. And now, you know, again, the biggest risk is policy, monetary policy. And you look at places like, you know, Switzerland, -1.25% at the low end of their official target range.
You look at places like Denmark and Sweden, you know, that makes the ECB still look like child's play. Could the ECB go to -1.5%? There's a lot of talk about the LTROs, and what they could do is create almost a 2-tiered system. So, they wouldn't cut deposit rates. They might actually raise deposit rates, but provide funding on the back end to banks through the LTROs, where the banks could offer consumer loans at negative interest rates.
If that's not the case for gold over any paper currency, I don't know that I've seen it in 35 years of doing this.
Erik Townsend: Now, as we look at the stock market versus the bond market and what bond yields are doing, to me, you're getting a pretty clear recession-is-coming signal from the bond market. The stock market seems to just want to go up. to party on. And that leaves us trying to decide who's right. In terms of looking to commodities to find a tiebreaker, whether it's the copper chart or anything else, what are you seeing in some of the base commodities that might tell you about the direction of the economy in the next 12 to 18 months?
Greg Weldon: Well, it's interesting you mentioned base commodities. So, I would look at that twofold, outside of energy, all right, would be obviously the base metals, which are kind of in line with that recessionary— it's more of a global market, you know, LME. And you look at aluminum, it's making a new low here. It's through its 61% retracement. So it's suggesting, hey, this is not a correction in an ongoing bull market anymore. And relative to even the Trump rally in stocks, and you look at copper, I mean, these are not like commodities that are in hugely short supply outside of zinc. So that's number one is the base metal. So we're watching those and man, they're kind of close to cracking. If you get below $259 on the US copper futures contract, that would be a major technical breakdown.
On the other hand, if you look at something like the agricultural commodities, holy mackerel, love them right here. We have kind of been laying out this scenario almost for the last 18 months. It's kind of bigger picture. So I don't know if you— how much you want me to get into that right here, but that's where maybe some opportunity lies that ties in with the trade war, which is what's scaring the bond market so much. But stock market doesn't care. I think there's a reckoning that has to come there. And unfortunately, I think when you look at the Fed and what might have to push them to their next action, I always kind of come up with the question of, if they don't act fast enough and meet the timeline laid out by the Fed funds futures market and the 2-year and 5-year Treasury note, then that's going to be risk to the stock market. And that may have to be the catalyst.
So, and that may be the thing that breaks the dollar's back too, by the way. But from commodities perspective, like the ags specifically, you know, the oilseed market.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the grains specifically, because we've had this flooding situation in the central United States, which has just caused utter mayhem for farmers. A lot of corn crops just not being planted at all this year. And as much as we had this kind of deflation signal of the grains almost falling off a cliff to super low numbers a few months ago, last couple of months it's been just straight up, at least on the front months, the immediate delivery, which are affected by this. What are we seeing in the term structure of the grains and what does So, what does it tell us? Because when you say there's, there's an opportunity here in the grains, seems to me like it's kind of overdone to the upside, at least on those front-month contracts. Are you still buying there, or where do you see these opportunities?
Greg Weldon: I would agree with you 100% on corn. Okay, so in the commodities business, quote-unquote grains is, you know, corn and wheat and rice and so on and so forth. That's why I say oilseeds, because it is the soybean market that is the potential huge opportunity here. And what I find interesting, again, you know, not to hype on this point, but having done this for so long, I mean, I remember the day when $9 soybeans would have been like, holy mackerel, The world's coming to an end, you know.
So the fact is that yes, you had a bumper crop of soybeans really for the last two years in the U.S. It was interrupted by a big drought in Argentina that cut the soybeans, and that's a major supplier of soybean meal. That's what kind of brings China into the mix as a trade dynamic. It's not so much about soybeans as it is really they take the soybeans and make soybean meal out of it. There was a time actually just to kind of go off track for a second. We tied into China. Where when the trade war kind of first started and tariffs were first affecting these things, the US was still selling soybeans to China. They were selling it to Argentina, who was then shipping them to China, and so on and so forth. So the point of all that is, yeah, we've had bumper crops, but demand is at a record as well.
So what happens if crops don't stay at a record or don't continue to grow? That's a problem, because the margin for error, particularly in soybeans, is razor thin. And you wouldn't really think that given the price action of these things recently, because it's a lot of headlines, it's a lot of psychology, you know, and it is a bumper crop which gets the lion's share of the headlines coming into the near term.
What you have now, particularly with the weather, particularly with the rain, particularly with how wet it's been, you have a situation where the soybean crop was delayed, not as much as corn, but the problem is soybeans. So, we look at that, the crop is delayed quite a bit. And more importantly is the emergence numbers. All right. So, the crop that's actually emerging now, way behind schedule, way behind last year, way behind the 5-year average. I mean, half of it at one point. So, it was maybe 4 or 5 weeks ago.
So, from that perspective, not only do you have less acreage planted in the US this year, okay, but now with the later emerging crop, you're running the risk of lower yields than have been estimated. And if you don't get the kind of crop that the USDA is looking for, which is actually lower than last year, you're going to have a problem because demand is still kind of screaming. Demand from China is a little bit less, so that's maybe a wild card to see what happens, if that's just the trade situation or what actually there is some less demand. There's some thoughts around some of the, you know, animals issues in China, maybe crimping demand for feed, but that's more again in corn. So we look at soybeans. I mean, the balance sheet in soybeans could really tighten up dramatically. And if you look at where you were 2 years ago, when the situation was much less bullish, it became a thing of, is it getting less bearish yet?
And it just flipped because of the weather from less bearish to bullish. And I've been saying, waiting for this opportunity, because the people I think are misunderstanding or misunderestimating the tightness of the balance sheet potentially and what this could mean in terms of not having another bumper crop could be bullish onto itself.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Greg Weldon: So we like soybeans right here. Frankly, they just broke out yesterday, so they didn't have the move corn has had. And corn's overblown. I mean, it's completely kind of in the short term out of control. That's not the case in soybeans. So we really like the soybean market.
Erik Townsend: Is there a pairs trade there that's short corn and long soybeans to arbitrage that, that difference that's developed?
Greg Weldon: Yeah, I looked at that. Of course, you know, it's one of the first things I look at because I try and consider every angle. I'd just rather be long soybeans. It's just a better trade. It's cleaner. It just makes more sense to me. I don't want to necessarily get bogged down on a leg that may or may not work. I mean, it could be sold, but if you get the whole complex to go and then the dollar breaks, I don't really necessarily want to be short corn.
So I will say this though, and just to add on to the answer here, I mean, the DBA, okay, the ETF for the agricultural commodities is a valid way for probably some of your listeners to play this that don't trade futures or have commodity accounts and so on. It is the ETF, the stock stock that tracks a number of commodities, including soybeans and sugar. So, to me, this has so underperformed, has been so depressed, is so under-owned. No one's invested in this kind of thing. So, when you look at the longer-term chart, and then when you overlay kind of the DBA against the DBA versus the CRB index of all commodities, I mean, it's almost like you're getting these things on the cheap right now.
Erik Townsend: Greg, on Tuesday morning of this week, when we're taping this interview, we've seen just a dramatic rally. in energy prices. The price of crude oil, $51.70 this morning, just before we taped this interview. As we've been talking, we're now looking at $53.71. So we're about $2 up in the last couple hours here. I'm not aware of any specific news other than the ongoing— people are worried about the Iran military escalation potential.
Greg Weldon: Right.
Erik Townsend: What do you think is driving this? What's going on? And what should we be looking for?
Greg Weldon: Fear, greed, and hope driving this one. I mean, if you kind of break it down, you have the 2 sides. And what I said yesterday, I actually wrote a special energy piece on Friday. And what I came to the conclusion is, this is a market that looks really bearish, both fundamentally and technically. But the geopolitical situation is such that it may prohibit being short. So, that's kind of where I'm at with it. I'd probably like to be short. I mean, I know I'd like to be short. It's just a question of what's the risk here for the potential blowup geopolitically. And I'm sure you know some of the same people I know in the hedge fund industry. There are guys out there that refuse to go home over the weekend short crude. They just won't do it. And that's kind of like the psychology I think that applies right here. If you look at the fundamentals, US is pumping out 12.4, 12.3, just massive amounts.
When you have the demand numbers being cut everywhere, You're looking at a significant daily build of crude at a time when in the US inventories are now tracking up towards the upper end of the 5-year range. That in and of itself is bearish. And if you play this out and kind of project what the IEA and what OPEC— and we dissected both of these reports, really lengthy, in-depth reports that were fascinating to me— you know, you could construct numbers around the differential between supply and demand growth That's being projected for the third and fourth quarter, to where you could potentially get a build here in the U.S. You know, back above 500 million barrels in the commercial inventories. That's not going to be bullish. So what you do then, or what I do then, is you know we want to go to swaps. So the swaps are interesting here because the near term you're kind of in a potential contango situation where you know you've had this bullish backwardation in crude for a while.
It kind of got whacked and it went back into a backwardation. And now it's getting into contango again, meaning that the near-term contract is priced at a lower price than the deferred. And the market, by essentially pricing it that way, is trying to encourage storage. And that is interesting because if storage is encouraged, it's also a reflection of the fact there's not much demand. So you don't need the crude for immediate delivery because there's not the demand for it. And that to me is interesting. But if you look at the more deferred, If you go, for example, the December of this year to the December of next year, the 12-month December swap rate, it's actually still in a bullish backwardation. Now, some of that's the cost to carry and insurance and so on and so forth, but it's not in contango.
So, there is a real kind of bifurcated thought process around crude oil. To me, the technicals are kind of the key. And from that perspective, if you take out the lows that we set over the, you know, since the end of May, you know, there's 2 kind of spike lows. That were kind of— if you look at the candlestick, it was almost tailed reversal-type lows. And I watched the, uh, you know, watch— look at the August contract. I mean, it's down just around $50. It's above $50.
If those lows get taken out, I mean, the trade is to be short. The question is, is the geopolitical risk too high? And I'm not sure about the answer to that. I'm really not.
Erik Townsend: Greg, you are in Jupiter, Florida, just north of Palm Beach, a very affluent area. And something that I've One of the things I've noticed is there's kind of a disconnect when you see the kind of wealth that hangs out in South Florida. They don't really know what's going on in the market from day to day because a lot of them don't have to.
But when big things start to change, they seem to, to get the scent pretty quickly. What are you seeing being in the private wealth management business in South Florida? What is the mood of the wealthiest investors that you run into? down there. And how are they looking? Are they reacting to the central banks, or are they not paying attention to it? What's the mood there?
Greg Weldon: That's a great question, Erik. I mean, it really is. And, um, you know, I would say, first of all, I'm probably the least affluent person here in Jupiter, Florida. So, I mean, you know, yeah, there is a lot of wealth, particularly Jupiter Island, of course, and then Palm Beach Island. So, you know, I'm more inland. But, uh, from the perspective of the people that are around me that are smarter than me, wealthier than me, you know, however it is, these are people that are so successful in their own businesses, it kind of blows your when you visit their homes. I mean, it's kind of, you know, you're in awe. And the perspective that I get from them is I'm getting calls from them now. They're worried, and they're worried for the kind of reason that I laid out earlier in terms of, you know, and it's not— they don't put it in these words.
They never announce it in this way. They never literally tell you that we're worried about central banks, we're worried about how much paper is being created, and we think someday there might be a day of reckoning, so on and so forth.
They're just seeing kind of what's happening They feel it, I guess, is the best way to talk about it. And these are people that probably are so successful for one reason, that they've learned to listen to their instincts.
And these are instincts that are now coming out and causing them to call me and ask me about what I think about 2 specific things. Number one, and this will go to your South Florida thing and why it has absolutely been so insulated in the psychology here, and that's because of the housing market, and that's because of politics, and that's because of the migration of people to Florida. So real estate values here have been on fire to the point where it's ridiculous. And so that's number one. I would say you're reaching some kind of peak, but that could go on because of what we could see mortgage rates do.
I could easily create a scenario where you see the 30-year mortgage rate below 3%. So that's one of the firepowers that the Fed has created because, you know, everything's kind of going down in yield right now, but the spreads, the, the Treasury mortgage rate spreads are going up. So you're creating a lot of room in the So, it could be insulated for a while longer, but there is a concern here, and it is a concern of big picture magnitude where people are asking me, should I put some of my money into, get this, municipal and mortgage bonds or gold?
Now, they ask mortgage bonds because they're in the mortgage business, a lot of these people, or at least they're very, you know, they're property owners and so on and so forth. So, and then the muni bond thing was interesting. I had a conversation yesterday with someone and I'm kind of like, well, muni bonds may benefit from this, but, you know, look at the state of the financial condition of some of the states and some of the municipalities. I'm not sure I want to really own those longer term, but it always comes back to gold, man. I mean, it really does. And when I start to hear and see, you know, get the tells, kind of anecdotal tells I call them, you know, that's something I've learned to really pay attention to.
And right now it is fear, and right now it is protection, and right now it is Do I go to cash, or do I buy some bonds, or even gold? And to the point where there is a fear about gold is pretty interesting too. And I kind of tell them, I mean, if you start to look at the upside versus the downside, to me, the upside in the stock market, even if, you know, the Fed were to meet the expectation that's already baked into the Fed funds forward strip and the 2 and 5-year Treasury notes, they're at 1.75 practically. All right. They're pricing in the next year's Fed funds is pricing in now, you know, a 5th rate cut below 1.5. All right, so from that perspective, I, I fear that if you don't meet those expectations— and this is Powell, this is not Bernanke, this is not Yellen, they were students of the Depression— Powell in Jackson Hole speech made it quite clear he's, he's a student of the '70s inflation, and he vowed not to let that happen again.
And boy, if he wasn't successful, because he probably went— and I did a piece in December— a bridge too So, from that perspective, it does lay out to how people are perceiving things. And the perception is fear, the perception is protection, and the perception is even, should I go to cash?
And then that lays some of the big tech. I mean, if passive investors, wealthy individuals start to rotate capital or get out entirely, that's one of the reasons we like the gold mining shares. If we get some rotation of capital and some of these guys are more comfortable buying stocks than a commodity like gold, even though they can buy it through the GLD, I think there's great potential there. So, you know, I have my own feelings about the big tech stocks and their vulnerabilities on many, many different levels. The volume is dried up. These stocks are so high priced. If people go to liquidate, you're not going to have buyers of big blocks of shares. It's too expensive. And it could be a vacuum of buyers and it could be a real bad scenario in some of the tech space. So I think it drives people to cash or drives people to gold or some of the wealthy people I talked to down here, gold mining shares.
Erik Townsend: Greg, what's your feeling on gold versus gold mining shares? Traditionally, the argument has been, you know, you get more leverage with gold mining shares. Of course, you're a futures trader. You know how to get the leverage if you wanted to in the gold itself. So, let's assume you have the sophistication to be able to achieve whatever leverage you want. Do you think the play here in terms of the best opportunity, best risk-reward is in the shares or in the gold miners? I think the best opportunity, best risk-reward is in the shares or in That's a good question.
Greg Weldon: That's a really tough one to answer. It's been not advantageous to own mining shares versus gold recently. I think that that may change. So from that perspective, you know, I mean, the GDX is the thing to look at. You know, for your really adventurous types that are willing to jump out of a plane or something, I mean, the Nugget, the N-U-G-T, is a leveraged ETF on the mining shares. Risk capital only, you know, buyer beware. Okay.
But I mean, that could be a phenomenal way to play it. I do believe that if you get some rotation of capital, depending— because it's not like the Fed is tightening here, so if they're easing, it does make it a little less violent potentially. I'm not saying the market's like going to come down hard. I could see kind of just a cascade, a rotation, a reallocation of capital, and all of a sudden, you know, the indexes are down and this is kind of forcing the Fed's hand, which only plays into the— if gold's taken off You're going to see money move into gold mining shares. There's no investment there whatsoever. And that's been part of the reason they've underperformed. No one's been able to even raise money to a large degree. And that leaves you open to mergers and acquisitions, which we've started to see, which is a total wildcard and bonus potentially.
So I could potentially see some relocation of capital that would benefit the gold mining shares in an initial phase of a breakout. I would even go back now to part of our earlier conversation and say one of the risks to gold, as I'm kind of thinking about this today, Do central banks want to like continue to ease like crazy and see gold break out? Maybe there's a, maybe there's a thought process here that they're going to resist in whatever way they resist. And people say, do they manipulate the markets? And I say, I've been watching this for 35 years. They've always manipulated the markets. There's nothing new.
So could they step on gold and keep it depressed? They might. I might suggest they've already tried. I don't think they would ultimately be successful, but that is one of the risks to, you know, being long gold from here, like you say, at a higher level. Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Greg, several years ago you wrote a book called Gold Trading Boot Camp. I understand that you have created now a video gold investing boot camp that's a little more substantial than just the book. Tell us a little bit about that project. What brought it about? Why are you doing this now, and what does it involve?
Greg Weldon: That's a good question, and thank you. What brought this about was my publisher, or my agent actually, who has been after me for the last 4 years to write a second book on gold. And, you know, I really wanted I wanted to do that when the time was right. And, you know, I needed the catalyst to get me to do it because it's probably the hardest thing I've done, you know, in terms of work in my career was writing a book, the first one. I know how to do it more now, so it would be easier, but it's still a really monumental task.
So, you know, she's been pursuing me and so on and so forth. And just in the last year or so, seeing this big picture crystallize, seeing the technical dynamic and go, I mean, it's everything to me. Again, this is like a crystallization of this next cycle that goes back to 2006 when I wrote the original book. It's— there's a lot of similarities. We have created this tremendous amount of credit against a paper asset, okay? In this case, it's equities, all right? In the case in 2005, '06, and '07, it was housing. And it was an asset that basically you had the unrealized profits in those assets that you borrowed against, and you were confident that central banks would always protect your back because because in 2005, '06, the belief was housing will never go down, home prices will never go down. It's almost the same now. I mean, investors have been kind of, you know, brainwashed by central banks into believing stocks never go down and stay down.
So from that perspective, I see this as a very similar situation risk-wise, where to cause the next reflation, they're going to have to do so much, and so much more than then, that this is going to be big, and it's going to be the next big bull leg in So, and I'm not like a gold bug. I mean, we actually, you know, got bearish in gold after the 2011 top and rode it to the downside for a while too. So, you know, I'm very much either to take either side of gold, but in this case, I just think it's the most obvious glaring thing to me.
And when I start to get questions from not only my clients, but just my friends and stuff about investing in gold, there's interest out there. And rather than answer all these questions individually, particularly for our clients, I decided I can create the material for the book by putting together a boot camp for my clients, and then, you know, I'd use that material. Well, the boot camp just became enormous, and what a project, but what a great project. Really enjoyed doing it. Going back to the history of gold, how you can invest in gold, whether it's futures or coins and bars or ETFs or the individual mining shares, I break all of that down. Some of the risk-reward dynamics that I would apply theoretically to creating a portfolio of metals investments against other, you know, being a part of your bigger portfolio. Dalio, and then took it down to the history of gold, to the history of the dollar, to the history of this whole credit bubble that began in '71.
You want to take it back even to FDR, you could. But from that perspective, then where are we now in the bigger picture? I think to me it's a 5-part video series. It's about 5 hours of video. Me personally, charts. It's a presentation. It's like you're going to a conference 5 days in a row for an hour a day. It's over 500 pages of charts and material and So, you have all of that together as the comprehensive guide to how to invest in gold and why now is such a critical time to be investing in gold.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Greg, please tell our listeners where they can find out about the Gold Investing Boot Camp video product, but also give us a quick summary of what you do with Weldon Live and what else people can expect to find at weldononline.com.
Greg Weldon: Sure. Well, I mean, weldononline.com, we are a CTA number one, so, you know, we We don't go out and hawk money because we trade futures and we use math that potentially creates returns that are maybe above average, but with that, you incur higher risk. But the real crux of the business is the Weldon Live. It really is. It's a daily research publication that covers the globe. We do everything. We break it down into a macro piece every day, and then we have fixed income, foreign exchange, stock indexes and ETFs globally, the metals, base and precious, energy, and ags. And we have specific trading recommendations in all of those sectors every day that we follow with hard stops.
So on and so forth. We track the trades. It's called Trade Lab. It's part of Weldon Live. So that's a subscription service that is sold on weldononline.com. You can come on and access a free trial if you haven't had one before. And then the boot camp we just added, just finished it. It's at the bottom of our webpage. There's kind of a big video that gives you more information on it. It's me talking to the camera and so on and so forth. So that's available and for sale on the website immediately.
Erik Townsend: Fantastic. And again, the URL for that is weldononline.com. WeldonOnline.com. Greg, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Greg come on to the show. You know, I would listen to the interview And while I agreed or disagreed with a few of his different points, but what really caught me was his conversation on gold. And obviously we have gold moving. I want to even talk about it with a chart in just a moment when we get to the chart book. But I think the big debate, of course, is what's the best way to express the trade? Do you go into bullion itself or do you play it through the gold miners? And I find this a fascinating debate because because the market capitalization of the entire gold miner space is so small that it makes up the same market cap of just one tech company. So if there's any half-decent allocation of portfolio capital towards the gold miners, there simply isn't enough market cap out there without it resulting in some sort of an extraordinary move in the miners.
I think there's some real asymmetry in that space. Gold itself is going to move as a great investment, But if gold is really going to kick, I think there's room for the gold miners to really get some momentum there. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as you say, the gold and dollar issue really is so central and it's so important. I have continued, as you know, to feel that probably Jeff Snider, Brent Johnson's side of the story is where I'm siding for now. It is very, very possible. It's possible that Greg could be right. And, you know, the argument for gold is very strong here. You've got what appears to be a reversal of central bank policy, not just the Fed, but the ECB too. We're headed back toward accommodation, lower rates, probably eventually moving back to either QE or some other form of unconventional stimulus. So the arguments in favor of gold are very strong here. Now, the counterargument is the Jeff Snider, and also Brent Johnson makes a different argument, really, both favoring a big dollar rally here, which could really be a big headwind for gold.
I think we may be moving into that regime that we've anticipated on this program for a few years now, which is eventually the dollar and gold move up together. Maybe that's already upon us. It's very interesting to see, but I can't stress strongly enough, it's, it's not quite in the bag yet. It seems like we have a breakout happening here in gold. It's only the first day. We're just waiting as we're speaking right now. We haven't even got the first daily close above those key levels. And as we're speaking, it appears very likely that we're going to have that close in the next few minutes. But, you know, we need to see more than just one day. in order to declare decisively that a 5-year resistance line has been broken out above. And perhaps it's happening, looks like it's happening, but it's not decided quite yet.
So let's wait and see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, I want to move on into the chart book, but before we get to the charts that I prepared, one of our listeners sent you a tweet asking to explain what's going on with the term structure between West Texas Intermediate as well versus Brent. And so on this chart, can you give us an explanation of what you're seeing?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, the topic here is forward curves in the crude oil market and what makes them take the shape that they take. And the first thing I want to say about that is, frankly, this is more religion than science. I have some very strong views about why the curves look the way they do. But frankly, other people that are very experienced in this field have different views about What drives these curves. Eventually, what I'd like to get to is an interview with Chris Cook someday, who's got as much fascination as I do with this subject, where we can really go deep on this. But just to address this listener's question, maybe as a holdover— and let us know, folks, on Twitter if there's enough interest in an interview going deep just on this subject— but looking at this chart on page 2, how is it possible that Brent has the most expensive contract by far, is the front month and the price goes down.
In other words, backwardation. As you go further out in time on the delivery curve, the price keeps going down. That condition of backwardation indicates tight supply, and that certainly jibes with geopolitical events. So it all seems to make sense. But how is it possible that the WTI curve— that's the US crude oil benchmark as opposed to the European benchmark— how is it possible that we have basically the same geopolitical conditions But the WTI curve is showing some contango at the front of the curve. That is, the first few months that curve is sloping up before it eventually rolls over and turns back down again. And the answer is entirely because— or I should say, my version of this religion says the answer is entirely because the front of the WTI curve is driven by storage dynamics in Cushing, Oklahoma, more than anything else. And that is a direct result of the fact In fact, that unlike the Brent contract, which is cash settled and it's based on North Sea Brent oil prices in the spot market, there is no actual taking delivery of those Brent futures contracts.
They're all cash settled. In the case of WTI, you can actually take delivery from the tank farm in Cushing, Oklahoma. And what that means is it creates a very interesting dynamic between the people that are rolling forward their positions and And the people that physically own tank storage in Cushing, Oklahoma.
So what's happening is the guys that are storing oil expect to be paid for that oil. And the way they get paid for that oil is they say, look, I'm not going to roll my short position. They own oil in a tank. That's their long side. They're not taking any market risk. They own an equal number of crude oil futures contracts, which are short. So their short position in the futures counters out their long position in the physical market. They're holding on to that oil, and the profit they make for being in that position of storing oil is they're capturing that contango as profit every month. They roll their short position, they close out their short, they reopen a new short on a contract one month later at a higher price, and whatever that difference in price is, that's the profit. That's what they got paid for storing the oil in the tank.
And they continue to roll their short forward, and it's hedged by the long exposure they have in the physical market because they've got oil in their tank. Well, when we start to get to curves moving in backwardation, the storage guys say, "Hey, wait a minute! There's no benefit to me in continuing to store oil here if I'm going to have to roll my contract forward, my short contract forward to a lower priced contract," which would be the case in backwardation. Why would I do that? I'll just deliver my oil out of that tank into the market and empty my tank and close my position completely. Why would I take a loss on continuing to store oil and pay for the pleasure of doing so? That doesn't make any sense.
So it's that storage-driven selling that pushes the front end of the WTI curve back down. And what it's basically telling us is there's a demand in the market place for storage. We need to store oil because there's a little bit more than we actually have buyers for right this instant.
Why don't you see that in the Brent curve? Because there is no Cushing, Oklahoma tank farm associated with the Brent futures contract. It's cash settled. So that's the reason that I believe that difference exists. And I want to stress again, there are some people who think it's driven by completely different factors. I'm convinced what I've just described is accurate. I wouldn't be surprised if Chris Cook, who's a very knowledgeable guy, has a completely different view about how it works. Let us know, folks, if you want us to set up a separate show at some point with Chris on this subject. It's kind of an unusual topic. I don't know how much interest there actually is.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's go to chart 3, where I actually have a crude oil— the WTI crude oil futures daily chart. And I want to just talk about this price action and some of the levels that you're watching. And where I'm watching as well. This kind of $50, $52 area was fascinating to me from a technical perspective because that if there was going to be a short-term bounce, that was a very logical support line that would have held. And if obviously it was broken, that's where some of the lower targets would come in. But with this bounce, it's being driven by the geopolitical news. At least that's the backdrop that's been created. Created with the Iranian tensions escalating again. I'm fascinated with what happens in the, the high 50s as we approach 60, because in my mind, so long as the price stays below 60, then the window remains for this to roll over and sell again.
But at the same time, that 60 is a line in the sand in my mind, because if the tensions, political tensions, continue to escalate and we see this ripping north of $60, that might actually mean something different is happening.
What's your take on the price action on crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the number one rule of the oil market is there is no limit to how much upside in price is possible when people start panicking over geopolitical events. And there's been some pretty big upside so far. Frankly, the panic over geopolitical events is small thus far. We don't have an actual war. We've got some pretty crazy things happening And it looks like there's probably gonna be more military engagement between the United States and Iran. The place you really get worried is when there's a conflict that has the potential to have contagion. So it starts between 2 different actors and then other people pile in. And certainly, if at any point you were to hear Russia say, look, Iran's our ally, we're gonna come to Iran's defense here, And so it becomes a proxy war being fought in Iran, really between the US and Russia. Holy cow, anything is possible to the upside in oil prices if something like that were to occur.
I don't think that is going to occur. I think that Iran is acting in a way that's going to result in some military engagement with the United States. I don't think Russia's likely to come to their aid. I don't think anybody else is. The amount of Iranian production that might be taken offline is really a gray market factor anyway because of the sanctions. So I don't really see it having that much to do with oil prices. It's the contagion risk to a larger conflict across the region that involves other countries and that grows into a bigger war that you have to worry about. And so far, I think what we're seeing is just a flinch in the market. I also think that the fundamentals in terms of supply and demand and storage and everything else that we talk about regarding the oil market are still in place for new lows below $50.
I think that if all of the sudden all of this geopolitical stuff suddenly blew over, the market would very quickly roll over and we'd be back down below $50 before we knew it. At this point, I don't think there's really a good play here other than to I'm going to step back and wait and see. I don't dare to short this here because who knows what could happen next in the geopolitical news flow. I do think it's quite likely though that if the geopolitics blow over that the fundamentals in the oil market are going to take us lower. But Patrick, I want to move on to slide 4 because the last few weeks you've been pretty clear
Erik Townsend: in saying, hey, you're sticking to your guns, this is a topping formation and probably Hopefully, maybe we'll see a new all-time high, but if so, it's time to sell it. It looks like from this chart you're starting to look at the potential of a serious leg higher.
Has your thinking changed?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, no, actually my thinking hasn't changed really. I'm still in the, the camp that this is a topping formation, but the thing that I really wanted to get across with this chart is sort of just putting into context what are the 2 scenarios that'll play out. I have to contend with Kevin Muir on a weekly basis. And obviously him, like Brent Johnson, is very much in that bull camp where they're expecting some sort of a melt-up move. And it's something that we have conversations about on the show on an ongoing basis as well.
And what I really wanted to get across with page 4 was just that this is no longer just about a move to $3,000. If the bull scenario was what ends up manifesting While I'm not in that camp, and I don't think that that's what's happening, if it was to manifest, this thing isn't stopping at 3,000. And so what I did was just put on a technical measured move, and I wanted to highlight 3 measured targets that are on the upside that if it was the bull narrative that materialized, where would it likely go? And what's interesting is, is that it heads towards 3,400 on the top end of that range. So in this kind of 3,200 to 3,400 are where all these targets lie.
And so, you know, if I am proven wrong about this being a topping formation and this rips, I mean, there is a solid 10-plus percent upside potential on a bull breakout in the summer. Not what I think will happen, but that definitely would be where I'd be targeting if it proves to be the case.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I've definitely adjusted my thinking here because as much as I think we're seeing recession signals and lots of reasons to think the business cycle is late cycle and time for things to roll over. The reality is the market hasn't been really following those signals. The market's been reacting to this bad is the new good doctrine where, as economic conditions worsen, people anticipate that the Fed is going to be more accommodative. They love that accommodative easy money policy, and that actually drives markets higher, counterintuitively. As much as it doesn't make any sense to me, it's what's been happening, and it's been happening for a long time now, and it seems like it's going to continue happening. And if I think about what could happen here, let's assume that we do break into real new all-time high territory, and at the same time, we continue to see bond yields tumbling, which I think ought to concern the market.
It doesn't make sense that the bond market is showing us recession signs and the stock market is racing But if we're gonna get lower interest rates as a result of this move now testing 2% on the 10-year as we're speaking, it's going to mean more corporate buybacks. And more corporate buybacks is gonna push the market higher. And if I'm right about the dollar, then the Brent Johnson scenario comes into play where what happens is for foreign investors who are getting frustrated with the situations in their countries, the US stock market just looks incredible because Because first of all, it is breaking out despite the disbelief of some of us that are watching. It is breaking out to new all-time highs. We are in this environment that's conducive to more corporate buybacks. And if you're a foreign investor who's also, as a result of investing in US stocks, getting the benefit of that foreign exchange boost as the dollar continues to appreciate, that's another reason to pile in.
So I do think there's plenty of room for that Brent Johnson scenario of a melt-up to occur. want to suggest, Patrick, I personally am not about to say, oh, okay, well, it's time here at new all-time highs that don't make any economic sense to me on a fundamental level to just buy and hold stocks for the long term. I'm not going to do that. But I've also made a huge mistake of missing a lot of the upside in the market in the last few years because I didn't believe in the fundamentals. And what I want to talk about, Patrick, is options strategy strategies that can be used to play a melt-up. If you think what's going to happen is prices are going to just go crazy high until there's a blow-off top and a crash, outright crash, which I think is probably coming someday, but it's a good chance that we're going to melt up to much higher prices before it happens.
How do I ride that wave up using options so that I'm not exposed when the crash happens? And I think there's a number of different strategies having to do with low-delta calls that you roll over every month. There's different ways of doing that. Why don't we do a whole postgame segment about how to play a melt-up if you don't believe in the fundamentals? Because that's something I'm very interested in.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, for sure. And I've done a presentation in the past for MacroVoices listeners on the ratio call spreads as one of the ways, but we can focus more on just the idea of rolling call options, especially when there's low vol conditions, as way
Patrick Ceresna: to participate on the upside there. With that said, though, I want to move on to charts 5 and 6, because this is where I continue to be torn. When we look at the scenario where this could be like 1998, the narrative we've heard from a number of these guests and other pundits out there, and it could rip higher. But what if this just continues to being a topping formation?
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: And what I wanted to do is on chart 5 was show the S&P 500 back in 1998 and looking at 1998 through 2001, and particularly from its 1999 high. What ended up happening was into the 2000s when the Nasdaq was melting up, each time the S&P 500 rallied, it just rallied to a slightly higher high.
And gave it back. It rallied to a higher high and then gave it back. Just modest little bumps higher that ended up developing a much longer 14-month topping formation in the S&P 500 that ultimately marked the top. So to me, even if the market pokes to a little bit of a higher high, just like what happened in 2000, 2001, there is always the chance chance that this is still just one bigger topping formation developing. And this is where the big, you know, $64,000 question is. Are we gonna get this last melt-up where the market just keeps ripping higher, or is this just once again the market retesting those previous highs before it rolls over again? I'm a bit on the other camp though. I still am skeptical of this rally. Maybe I'm— maybe I'll be proven wrong, but right And so now, even if this market pokes to a little bit of a higher high, I'm still skeptical of whether or not this is gonna sustain.
Erik Townsend: Well, I certainly share your skepticism on some levels, which is I don't think any of this makes any sense. This, this bad is the new good doctrine is nutso. But you know, we're in totally uncharted territory. We've never had monetary policy conditions anything like this. We don't know what can happen. here. And I am definitely coming much more around to saying, you know, as much as I have not in any way, shape, or form changed my convictions that these prices don't make any sense, the reality is there's a lot of reasons to think they're going to make even less sense and, and keep going up. And if you look at what we're seeing in the tape action, it's not time to be super confident that this is a topping formation. I think there's a good possibility of But we've got to start thinking about what happens if, you know, liquidity
Erik Townsend: wins out over fundamentals, as crazy as it sounds. But Patrick, before we move on from this slide, I want to ask you for an update on the calendar straddle strategy that we discussed with our listeners on MacroVoices several weeks ago.
How's that going? You guys were straddling from the old high. It was going great for a while. What's going on now that we're kind of back to all-time highs?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, one of the key things that we do is we, we put in adjusting trades at key technical levels. And one of the things we did when the S&P was down around the 2,800 level, we actually rolled down the call option within there to lock in an intrinsic value. So now that we've been making these adjusting trades, even though the market's back up to its highs, we're in a situation where we're still in a modest profit.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Patrick Ceresna: And it's a testament to the strategy where we had all of the potential to make money if this was the big kahuna short, but at the same time, we're not getting killed in any way even though, uh, the market has rallied back up. And so anyway, we're still in the trade. I'm debating whether or not we need to reposition or, or just get out of the trade at this moment and then look for another entry. But that's something that, uh, we're going to be doing with our members in the coming weeks and months.
Erik Townsend: Well, my hat's off to you, Patrick, because if you can put on a huge short bet, which is essentially what you did, and have what's happened happen and still end up basically breaking even or even making a couple of bucks, you're doing great
Erik Townsend: as far as I'm concerned. So congratulations on that. But let's move on to the gold chart. Holy cow, this is what, 5 years now that we've been stuck below that $1,350 to $1,375 level. As we're speaking on Thursday afternoon, I'm looking at $1,393 just about a dollar over the, the $1,392 that you have on this chart here. So what point— I mean, you're the technician, Patrick— when you have a consolidation like this that's been running 5 years, what do you need to see in order to be persuaded that this is a real breakout and not just a fake break?
Patrick Ceresna: This has been a trade range since 2013, right? And some argue that the actual bottom of the bear market was in that 2015 early 2016 low, and that this is just a market that's been basing. Now, on a monthly chart, you're looking for a monthly close above there. So I think a lot of people are going to be watching as we approach the end of June whether or not we close at this $1,400+ range. To me, there was a lot of short-term technical moves that were measuring out toward $1,400. If this was just a swing trade, this is where it should stop. So this is This is such an interesting level to me because if we're technically breaking north of 1,400, then something much bigger is happening. And so even though on, on the chart here looks like there's— it's breaking to a higher high, I still want more confirmation. And I think once we get north of 1,400 with any gusto, that's where I think they could really start to build momentum, and it'll be very hard for us it to turn back and turn bearish there.
And so this is a very important turning point in gold in my mind.
Erik Townsend: And I want to add something to that, Patrick, which is I think this is a very difficult breakout to gauge. And the reason is, first of all, you've got all kinds of geopolitical tensions that have pushed us up to this level above the red line there. You know, is that a temporary effect, or are we really seeing something structural in the market? And there is a very good argument for that something structural in the market, Which is, central banks seem to have taken a change of direction where they're headed back toward lower rates. That's gotta be good for gold. Most people think it's gonna be bad for the dollar. The thing is, even if Brent Johnson and I are right, and the dollar is gonna continue to appreciate, potentially causing gold to reverse direction and move lower here, I wouldn't expect that to happen overnight.
I think you've gotta see the move down in the dollar index in reaction to expectations about a rate cut first, and that's got to kind of play out and then surprise everybody when the dollar turns around. That could take a few days. So, you know, at what point do you declare that it really is not happening, the dollar is really done? Greg gave us a level that he's watching on the dollar index, and certainly if we see a close below that, it's maybe time to think about this again, but I think it's difficult to call the point where you say, okay, this breakout is real. I think we've got so many different factors, and that creates a risk. If you're waiting for that confirmation, you could miss the move, and, you know, you're above 1,500 by the time you get in. So I see it as a dicey trading situation, to say the very least.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, listen, what I wanted to touch on though is silver, because everyone's gold, gold, gold. And when we had Adam Collins on and we looking at the COT reports, one of the things he shared with all of our listeners several weeks back was the fact that silver was at a pretty extreme positioning when you're looking at it as a percentile of net positioning in the Commitment of Traders reports, as speculators were incredibly heavy short and commercial hedgers were not, that we were at pretty extreme levels. And what's interesting is silver's really been unloved. And when you look at it, I, I put on a weekly chart here And you can really see that silver has not even started to move properly in any way resembling gold. And I'm wondering whether the gold's little cousin silver has a lot more upside here on a relative basis if it suddenly gets the the tailwind of a lot of these speculative shorts starting to have to cover if in fact its breakout is for real.
So watching how silver behaves here is going to be really interesting.
With that said, I wanted to just leave it with one last chart. Chart. I wanted to touch on corn. I heard Greg talking about— obviously he likes the soybean because corn has run a little bit, but I wanted to give some historical perspective as to when corn really runs, what a run looks like. And you have to go all the way back to 2010 and 2012 because, I mean, we've had, you know, 5 years of pretty good growing conditions in corn which has not seen any real spikes. But if you go back and really look at the history of the price action, there are ample examples of times where corn even doubled in its price. And while we have seen that move from $3.50 to, to like $4.50 on corn, you know, if this flooding and the growing conditions are as bad as some of the people are suggesting, maybe this isn't done.
I mean, I think there's room for corn to keep going.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we definitely need to keep an eye on all of these markets. And for our listeners who want Patrick's help doing that, be sure to check out the free 14-day trial offer at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time for today's episode, which was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged.
Don't forget to go to toptradersunplugged.com/macro to claim your free book and subscribe to their podcast as well. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices yourself, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. And finally, don't forget to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which contains links to all of the best content that we could find on the internet, including supplemental information from our feature interview guests. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find that transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Greg Weldon's presentation slides, as As well as charts we discussed here in the postgame. There's also an article from Harley Bassman, the Convexity Maven, titled For Propeller Heads Only, and a Variant Perception article talking about those sky-high corn prices adding to inflation pressures. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking We're looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow us on Twitter @MacroVoices. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Josh Steiner — Hedgeye real estate guru (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 171 was recorded on June 13th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. We've had a lot of requests for an episode on real estate markets around the globe, so we're taking a deep dive on the subject with another MacroVoices doubleheader this week. Hedgeye real estate guru Josh Steiner joins me as this week's feature interview guest. And we'll focus on the US and Canadian real estate markets. Then Pete Wargent will join us in our postgame segment to talk about Australian real estate.
This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, the leading podcast when it comes to systematic trading and investing.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump right into this S&P 500 because after a huge short squeeze rally, we've really spent the rest of this week pinned in a sideways Which way do you think the S&P is going from here?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I'll just be candid and say I don't have strong directional conviction here because I still have very strong convictions in my own mind about reasons that I think the market should move much lower. But it's also been very, very clear for the last several weeks that those factors are not driving the market. What took us down was China, Mexico, and Iran foreign relations. Now, until today's news about Iran and the torpedoing of tankers in the Persian Gulf, It seemed like all of those situations were abating, and I'm also hearing rumors about a China deal perhaps being in the works for late June. So if what took us down in this recent downdraft in stocks was those factors, and they're all getting better, and maybe a China deal is coming toward the end of June, it could easily propel us to all-time highs. That doesn't make sense in the face of the way I see the macroeconomic backdrop.
I've got the consolation of the bond market seemingly agreeing with me, but the rest of the stock market doesn't see it the way I do. So I'm standing back here waiting to see what happens. I won't be surprised if a China trade deal took us back again above 2,900 or even to a new all-time high. The other thing, Patrick, that's really been on my mind with respect to stocks is there's a relationship with interest rates that's really only been prevalent in this recent cycle, and it has to do with corporate buybacks. The reason that the stock market has been in this crazy rally that just seems to know no end for the last several years, in my opinion, is largely attributable to corporate buybacks. When we had interest rates that were going up quickly and a lot of people predicting that it was gonna be a one-way trip to much, much higher interest rates, that needless to say made a lot of people think, okay, this whole trend of levering up on debt and using it to buy back your own shares, which frankly is a manipulation to increase the share price for the benefit of the CEOs, as far as I can tell.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: It's not going to work anymore. That's going to be shut down. Well, if we're headed back to much lower interest rates, it's going to continue working, and that could propel stocks even higher, even as much as I don't think it makes sense given the macro backdrop. So I'm bracing for the possibility of this market moving a lot higher. I can see lots of reasons that that could play out, even though it doesn't make sense for me. My only solace here is bonds are on my side of the argument.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because clearly we went through a cycle where those May highs near 98, simply it wasn't the level where we were gonna break out. And now we stepped back and had a pretty sharp correction in the start of June. That seems to be stabilizing. Where's the next move in the dollar in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, as I said last week, I think the pullback that we've been seeing has been all about the Fed signaling their intention that a rate cut is on the horizon. So it's no surprise that the dollar would pull back based on that news. Looks to me like maybe it's already bottomed in the last few days. A little early to make that call decisively, but it does appear to be bottoming out. And I think that's a buying opportunity, frankly. And I think the bigger buying opportunity will come when we actually get a real rate cut, not just talk about a rate cut. I think the dollar will move sharply lower in a knee-jerk reaction when that happens. And And when it does, I want to be there to buy it because I don't think that interest rate differentials are going to change the equation. Yeah, we can cut rates, but so are other central banks. And I don't think that the cutting of rates is going to lead to an interest rate differential-driven failure of the dollar the way some analysts seem to think it's going to.
Now, in the spirit of thorough journalism, though, I should say There's a lot of very smart people who disagree with me. Jeff Gundlach just tweeting this last weekend, okay, this is it, dollar's rolling over, this is the beginning of the end. Perhaps he's right. I don't think so. I think that we're going to see the dollar move higher, but before it goes substantially higher, I think we've probably got a bigger pullback to a lower number after we actually get that first rate cut. And to me, that's going to be a buying opportunity. I'm looking forward to it.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to crude oil here. What's going on?
Erik Townsend: Well, first of all, we did a full update yesterday on Energy Week, so I'm going to focus primarily only on what's changed since then. Now, this week, that's a lot. I'll probably be longer on crude oil even when I'm not covering anything that wasn't in yesterday's Energy Week. Let's just quickly recap EIA and what happened with inventory. Crude oil building 2.2 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, 2.1 million barrels on the build. Gasoline building 764,000. Barrels. The only drawdown was distillates drawing down a million barrels. With those big builds in crude oil and gasoline, that resulted in big selling on inventory day on Wednesday, and it really looked after Wednesday's close like, boy, we were on some critical levels and maybe the market was about to dump, because if we got through that critical support right around $50, there's not a lot of support under it till you get to $45, maybe even $44 to the downside. So it looked like there was a possibility that the market was going to dump.
Then, of course, overnight we had 2 tankers attacked in the Strait of Hormuz. The initial reports have focused on torpedoes or mines being at fault, and if that's true— it's a big if, frankly— that really implies a state actor. Terrorists have bombs, they have improvised explosive devices, they don't have torpedoes, they don't have submarines. So if this really was a torpedo attack, it kind of assumes there has to be a state actor behind it.
Now, we don't have to worry about a long, protracted investigation to come to a conclusion of that, because the US State Department, in less than 12 hours after the incident, has apparently been able to determine conclusively, beyond any shadow of a doubt, that Iran did it. And needless to say, that statement played a big role. Now, what happened in the tape action today was actually very interesting. After the news came out, The market had been on critical support. We springboarded off of that, went back above the short-term moving averages, the 5 and the 8-day moving average on both RBOB gasoline and crude oil. It only lasted for a few minutes and eventually we started trading pretty hard back down, retracing almost 50% of that move up on both RBOB and WTI. And then just about 15 minutes before the pit close, Secretary Pompeo came out with the news that the United States had decisively Absolutely. Concluded that Iran is the guilty party here, that it was a state-sponsored act and that Iran was at fault for it.
Needless to say, that sent both RBOB and WTI back above their short-term moving averages. But what was really interesting to me is where they had been trading in lockstep all day, RBOB stayed there. It stayed above its 8-day moving average ever since the Pompeo news came out. WTI was only there for a few minutes and then it retraced pretty hard back to the downside. So it seems like for now gasoline is kind of holding on to the message that there could be an Iran military conflict beginning in the next few days, whereas WTI is kind of shrugging it off. So it's been very interesting tape action. Bottom line, Patrick, let's bring this all together. The outlook had been big downtrend in play, good reason to suspect further downside. Now we have news that could result in the beginning of a US-Iran war. We have had Secretary Pompeo tell reporters today that Iran had done something that is on a scale of badness that would normally warrant a US military strike in retaliation.
One of the things that we see quite a lot in the crude oil market is Fridays tend to be up days when there's any fear about a military escalation because nobody wants to be short into the weekend. Needless to say, there's a very good chance of a rally tomorrow, Friday, as shorts cover to avoid being exposed over the weekend to the possibility of some kind of military upset that might result in a huge gap-up open on Monday. But very interestingly, so far the market is trying to shrug this off. So it's kind of a tug-of-war. It's going to be very interesting to see how it plays out.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold seems to be holding up. I mean, we haven't broken out above $1,350, but it certainly hasn't given back the early gains. What's your thinking? Do we finally break out to new highs?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think that gold was trying to give back those gains. We saw a pretty aggressive rejection of that $1,300— was it $1,352, I think, was the high trade? And it was straight down from there all the way back down to about $1,325, so giving up $25. It's been the last couple of days that we've seen more upside. And, you know, we just had the US Secretary of State, announced in a press conference that Iran had been at fault for this torpedo attack on 2 tankers, and that almost certainly would be a setup for military retaliation from the United States against Iran as early as this weekend. So the fact that we're maybe about to start a war with Iran, and it's not a rumor, it's not a speculation, it's something the US Secretary of State said in a press conference, and even that won't push gold back up above its recent high, that says to me that there's pretty strong resistance just above the market, and I've got to believe that people are buying gold on the news that came out today.
Somebody else is happy to sell it and keep the price right where it is, so it looks to me like this resistance is pretty strong. Doesn't mean we're not going to get through it, but I'm still leaning toward the scenario of resistance holds and we eventually trade lower.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because after dropping rapidly down toward the 2.05 level, we started to bounce, but suddenly we find ourselves right there again. Like if the yields wanna take a shot at 2%, do you think we're going down that low?
Erik Townsend: I think that the bounce was starting until the market got a whiff of this Iran situation. I mean, Pompeo saying Iran wasn't, we suspect them, it wasn't, there's a possibility that they might have been involved. It's in the assessment of the United States, Iran did this. That's pretty darn strong language that causes a lot of people in a lot of trades to start panicking into their safety trade, which is usually US Treasuries. That pushes the yield down. So I think that today's weakness in the yield, especially later after about 2:15 this afternoon, was probably driven by the Iran news. Before that, I thought maybe a nice bounce was underway, but still, this, this move has been huge. There's room for a big bounce back to, I don't know, 2.30, 2.40 or so would make plenty of sense, even if the trend higher in prices, lower in rates is set to continue. So, I'm looking forward to that.
It'd be nice to have a buying opportunity, but so far, we're not seeing one.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Josh Steiner, which is Hedgeye's Head of Financials and Real Estate. So, Erik, why did we invite Josh back onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, the last time that we heard from Josh was in Toronto at our MacroVoices Live event. And remember, at that time, interest rates were moving higher, and most people were expecting them to continue to move higher. And that kind of set a mood around real estate markets, because frankly, real estate prices are driven not by anybody making any sensible assessment of what the house is worth. It's all about what's the monthly payment, what's my mortgage payment going to be, and can I afford it? And that's a function of interest rates. As much as it surprised a lot of people, we've seen a complete U-turn in interest rates. Now that we have what appears to be the beginning of a decline in interest rates that may have some legs to it, that potentially changes the whole name of the game for housing. So we wanted to do an episode entirely about housing.
Josh has been probably our strongest expert guest on US and Canada real estate, and we're going to have Pete Wargent join us from Australia in the postgame segment so that we can cover that market as well and try to hit the macro analysis of all of those major real estate markets for our listeners in those geographies and everywhere else around the world.
Patrick Ceresna: And we're now delighted though to be airing our first sponsored episode this week, right? So Erik, who made this episode possible for our listeners?
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Although I personally am a global macro investor myself, it has long been known to investors around the world that systematic or quant-based strategies are profoundly effective at extracting returns from the market. Top hedge funds like Bridgewater Associates and Renaissance Technologies discovered this decades ago. And there's one podcast that covers this area of finance better than any other— TopTradersUnplugged.com. And right now, MacroVoices listeners can even get a free book explaining how these systematic strategies work. Just go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro to claim your free copy. Again, that's TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro.
Check them out. You'll be glad you did. Okay, that was their sponsor message that they paid for, but there's actually an interesting backstory to how Top Traders Unplugged became our sponsor. So we can come back to that in the postgame segment, but right now let's dive right into the feature interview with Hedgeye's Josh Steiner, coming up right after this.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Josh Steiner, who heads up the financials and housing sector research department at Hedgeye Risk Management. And I always love interviewing the Hedgeye guys because they always come with really great slide decks. Josh is no exception this week. He's put together a really excellent slide deck for us. It'll be a challenge to get to all of the slides, but I'm sure that you, our listeners, will enjoy You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered for Research Roundup, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, next to Josh's picture. Josh, last time that we had you for a housing update, I think, was when you spoke at our live event in Toronto last summer. Give us the update, US and Canadian housing, which is the same topic we've talked to you about before. Quite a bit has happened since then.
Let's go ahead and dive into your slide deck. Okay.
Josh Steiner: All right, great. Thanks, Erik. Yeah. So, why don't we start with the US? So, we've got sort of a summary of slides here. What we do is we like to put together a quarterly themes update. And so, these are slides from our most recent 2Q19 themes update. So, just to sort of set the table a little bit, this first slide we have really looks at the transition from late 2018 to early 2019. So if you look at the performance across the full year of 2018, you can see that the different US housing proxies— XHB, ITB, the S&P 500 Home Subindex— were the worst-performing subindexes and ETFs across the US market for the full year 2018, only to completely reverse course in the beginning of 2019 and in fact lead the way from an upside standpoint. So, you know, we think that's a pretty interesting reversal. We'll get to why that is, but to summarize it quickly, a lot of it revolves around rates. There's more to it than that, but rates are the biggest single driver in the space.
So if we think about what is the current positioning of the US housing market, we look at a number of different sort of core cyclical trends. On slide 5, we can see where the underwriting standards are currently relative to the trailing 15-year period. So you can see that we've bounced off the lows quite a bit. We've come up— this is the Mortgage Credit Availability Index from the Mortgage Bankers Association. We've come off the lows of around 100 to 182. That's down from the epic highs of almost 900 during the bubble years. But we think a normalized credit underwriting environment is going to be in the 3 to 350 range. So we think we still have a long way to go from a renormalization standpoint on underwriting.
And if we look at the cycle from a construction standpoint on this next slide, you can see residential construction as a percent of GDP normally troughs in the low to mid-3% range, typically peaks in the mid to high 5% range. Currently, we're at 3.9 off the lows of 2.4. So So even though we've come a long way from the bottom, we think we're still only at the mid-cycle, midpoint in the cycle here.
And then if we think about another phenomenon, which I'll actually come back to as it relates to Canada on this next slide, if you look at the amount of home equity cashed out quarterly in the US from the mid-1990s to present, in the sort of go-go years of 2005, '06, '07, you were seeing anywhere from $60 to $85 billion per quarter being cashed out of the US housing market. That was sort of the era when the home was viewed as an ATM. The proceeds were used to fund all manner of discretionary purchases.
And currently, we're at just under $15 billion. So, and this is not inflation-adjusted. So this gives you a pretty good sense of how still tepid the environment is relative to where we were for the better part of the 2000s. If we think about affordability in the US, you know, you see a lot of headline stories about places like New York City or San Francisco being highly unaffordable. But when you look at the country as a whole, affordability in the US is actually still quite good. So the ratio of median mortgage payments to median rent across the US, it typically peaks at around 2. So the trough has historically been around parity. Or roughly 1, and we're obviously much closer to that long-term trough than we are the long-term peak. And if we look at median mortgage payments relative to median income levels on this next slide, you can again see, you know, we tend to move between this sort of low to mid-20% range at the trough up to 35 to 40% when we're at the peak.
Currently, we're at 23.9%, so much closer to the trough. So all of this points towards this idea that we are still very much mid-cycle here in the US. And part of that is just born out of the fact that the housing market didn't really find a bottom until a full 3 years after the broader US economy. So, US housing market troughed around November 2011, US economy troughed really in late 2008, early 2009.
Erik Townsend: Josh, before you go on, I just want to ask you, you said earlier this is mostly about rates, and it seems to me like what we're seeing here is a lot of slides that suggest that, hey, the cycle's just getting going, there's a lot of room left to go. But at the same time, we're also in a cycle of rates coming down for the last several months. If we were to see— I don't think it's going to happen, but some people think that the bond yields are just way too low.
Josh Steiner: Right.
Erik Townsend: It's going to reverse. We're headed back to 3.5%, 4% 10-year yields.
I don't think that's going to happen. But if it did, it seems to me it would really, really squash this cycle that is otherwise recovering. Would you concur with that? And what do you see as the risks of a change in sentiment in the bond market?
Josh Steiner: So, the premise of the question is completely correct in that, you know, we've done work that looks at the sensitivity of housing equities to short-term expedited rate changes, both on the way up and the way down. And effectively what happens is the housing equity driver framework essentially converges down to a one-factor model, which is rates. So unfortunately, I don't have the chart in this deck, but we do have a chart where we look at the rolling delta or rolling changes in the— In the— 10-year Treasury relative to its correlation to housing equity price performance. And when you get up to around 2 to 3 standard deviation moves in that 10-year yield, again, you do see that correlation with equity price performance for housing equities approach 1. So it really is a one-factor model when rates are moving significantly. As far as the outlook for rates, You know, we, we do have a slide in here, which I'll get to in a little bit. But I don't think the probable path for rates is to move meaningfully higher over the intermediate to longer term.
Sort of cover that in a little bit. But I don't think that's, that's the direction we're likely to take. So if I'm wrong, then, then this, this housing trade will go the other way. But, you know, we'll cover why we think that's not the case in a little bit.
Josh Steiner: So on slide 10, this is yet another sort of backdrop slide for where we think we are in the cycle and why we think demographics is going to be one of the big ongoing drivers here for the US housing market. So if you look at the number of people in the US who are currently aged either 32 or 33, relative to those who are aged 26, 27, 28, There's a large difference. You can see there's a spike in the number of 28- to 29-year-olds. The reason those age bins are relevant is because currently in the US, the average age of the first-time homebuyer is 32 to 33, whereas the average age of the first-time renter is 26 to 27.
So as those renters age up from being 26, 27, 28, 29, 30 to being 32, 33 and start to look to buy their first home, The point of this chart is just to show that there are many more people who are going to be looking to buy their first home in the coming 2 to 3 to 4 years than there are currently. So we think this creates a nice demand tailwind over the intermediate 2, 3, 4-year timeframe. So we've laid out why we think we're mid-cycle here on a number of other fronts. This would be another factor in support of that.
If we look at the shorter term, so sort of, you know, thinking about kind of quarter-to-quarter changes here on this next slide, slide 11, the Housing Surprise Index is a simple measure of whether the fundamental housing data is coming in better or worse than expectations. And so if you think of it, it's basically a diffusion index. And what's interesting about it is that late last year, around December of 2018, this series actually hit an all-time low, and pretty remarkable considering that in 2007 and 2008, we were going through the grips of, you know, what was the largest housing correction since the 1940s. And so coming off an all-time low, it sets a pretty— sets up a pretty asymmetric bounce environment, and that's really what we had in the first quarter of 2019. And you can see that, at least through April of this year, we had moved back essentially to the zero bound. So, you know, things had gotten really bombed out there over the sort of last 4 to 5 months of 2018, bounced back pretty nicely through the first 4 months of 2019.
If we look at the fundamental data on slide 12, these are the weekly numbers for mortgage purchase applications put out by the MBA, the Mortgage Bankers Association. You can see that, you know, going into late last year, activity levels were very subdued relative to where they'd been through the first 7 months of 2018. And then beginning really in January, but trending through March and through April, activity levels have generally been on the rise.
And if we think about the setup going forward on slide 13, the nice thing is that the comp setup for pending home sales— so sales of existing homes in the U.S.— are going to get easier beginning really in August. But very much easier beginning in November and December. So you're going to have this really nice sort of comp dynamic setup as we move into the 4th quarter of 2019. So really just a couple of months, we'll be at an— at a point in time when people are going to be starting to think about this environment.
So we generally talk about home prices whenever we talk about the fundamentals of the housing market. On slide 14, you can see a snapshot of how those home price trends have been going. In a word, not great. We've seen deceleration in home prices at both the national level and at the 20-city level. And that's coming off what were essentially the high-water marks in the March-April 2018 timeframe when U.S. home prices were rising between 6% and 7%. Since then, they've slowed down to around 3% to 4%.
We think that trend is going to continue. At least through the next several months. I don't know if we'll get down into the sort of 0% to 1% range, but I would expect at least another 100 to 200 basis points to come off of these because home prices are very lagging, and they're really reflecting or mirroring what's happening on the fundamental side on a very significant lag, anywhere from 6 to 9 months. So those will continue to soften for the next few months and then probably begin to stabilize. as we get into sort of the August-September timeframe.
Erik Townsend: Josh, I have a question about the composition or the sectors within the housing market. Something I can't help but think about as you're talking there is you're describing why so much of the demand is going to come from people buying their first homes. That means small homes. And although you didn't really get into it, another big part of this is boomers downsizing. It seems like that should put a lot of demand on smaller homes and probably leave a glut lot of large homes. Is that true? And is there a way to play that from an investment standpoint?
Josh Steiner: That's definitely the trend. You've got this sort of classic pincer movement on both sides with— exactly right, entry-level looking to buy their first home tends to be on the smaller side. And as people continue to age up, looking to reduce their footprint. So yeah, the challenge has been that Most builders have generally not been— homebuilders have generally not been catering to that smaller footprint because the costs to do so just really haven't worked out terribly well. It's expensive to permit and develop land, and generally when you do that, you want to get the most bang for your buck. There's also a fair amount of risk embedded in the fact that first-time homebuyers aren't necessarily always a slam dunk. Sometimes they come in with thin credit profiles, their ability to secure financing still isn't great. We looked at that chart showing the underwriting cycle still has a long way to go from a renormalization standpoint. So I think that's absolutely right. The one name where they're really in the sweet spot for this would be a company like D.R.
Horton, ticker DHI. These guys are more exposed to that entry-level segment than most of their peers. And on top of that, geographically, They have a very nice footprint, which is predominantly in the Southeast. So if you look at where most construction is taking place, it's really the South and Southeast are sort of the biggest segments of the country. So D.R. Horton's a pretty nice fit into both of those different bins. So if we— I had sort of foreshadowed earlier that we'd look at rates and the effect rates have played here.
Josh Steiner: And so without further ado, We've got a series of slides here. So slide 15 is actually from our deck at the beginning of the quarter, and it shows that the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage— this is the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey— that 30-year had come in from around 5% down to 4.08%. Well, since then, it's actually moved down to almost 3.8%. So we're down close to 120 basis points off the peak of late 2018.
That's a— pretty enormous move on a, you know, a 6-month basis. So if we look back in the next few slides, slide 16, at some of these rate shock analogs, you can see we've got 3 periods we're highlighting here. So the late '93-'94 timeframe when rates moved up by 240 basis points and then thereafter had a comparable move down in late '98 through sort of spring 2000. 180 basis point move up, followed by roughly 250 basis point move down. And then more recently, you had the taper tantrum in late 2012 running through sort of fall 2013 when rates moved up 118 basis points very quickly and then gave that back over the course of the following year.
So in each of those 3 instances, on the following slide here, slide 17, you can see what the impact was following those rate increases, meaning when the rates came back down, on the fundamental activity levels of home sales. So we show that in those green rectangles on slide 17, and you can see that sales activity generally picked up quite nicely in the wake of that, and that's exactly what we've seen at least so far through the start of this year. And then if you look at the equity side, so home prices for homebuilding stocks in this case, on slide 18, it's a similar dynamic. So here, we're actually highlighting the declines in those homebuilding stocks during the periods when rates rose. But if we sort of skip ahead, we'll, we'll take a look at what happened on the rebound.
But before I get to that, I wanted to spend just a second on slide 19. And, you know, I think really more than any other, at least in this deck, this slide sort of embodies this idea of what we were, Erik, talking about earlier, which is, if you look at this yield spread, in this case, just the spread between the 10-year Treasury yield and the 2-year versus the Fed funds rate, you can really get a sense for cycles in their broader context.
And I think what it speaks to is— so we map out this progression where you have stage 1, stage 2, stage 3, stage 4. And you can sort of see how those play out, or at least have played out, really over the last 40 years, sort of across cycles. And the idea is that, you know, when you get the yield spread as compressed as where it is today, it really tends to happen late in the cycle and after the Fed has already been raising rates for some time. And so even though, you know, the absolute magnitude of what the Fed has done isn't all that profound, at least so far, The reality is that where we are from a yield spread standpoint, coupled with looking at what the Fed has done at the short end, in the context of these prior environments, it really does look very similar. And so, for that reason, we think the most probable path here going forward is that the long end of the curve is likely to remain under pressure.
And that's not to say if the Fed is shifting from from being on the front of its feet to shifting back onto its heels, you can't get a little bit of a relief rally. But from a broader standpoint, where we are in the cycle, we think it's very late cycle. And so that's the idea there. And then to come back to rates and sort of their role to housing here on slide 20, we just sort of put together a simple snapshot here. If you look at the x-axis, you've got the quarter-over-quarter change in the average 10-year yield.
And then on the y-axis, you've got the quarter-over-quarter change on a relative basis, so relative to the S&P 500 of homebuilding stocks. And so, as you'd expect to see, there's a negative slope here, negative correlation. And the idea is that when you get more than a 50 basis point change in the 10-year on a quarterly sequential basis, you tend to see these homebuilding stocks move up or down sort of in the opposite direction. By around 10%.
And so that's exactly what we saw over the course of the first quarter. So you can sort of see what the predicted was and what the actual was. Pretty good fit. And then sort of a little bit bigger picture on this next slide, 21. You know, I talked about these 3 prior analogs for rate shocks and then what happened on sort of the other end of things. So to look at those briefly, so you had the December '94, December '95 period.
This is the year following that significant increase in rates. So here you had the S&P 500 Homebuilding Index gain 35% over that 12-month period. In the May 2000 to May 2001 timeframe, S&P homebuilding stocks were up 75%. Remember, that was a very challenging time for the broader market, especially in tech stock land, as I know you're familiar. But during that same timeframe, housing stocks were up 75%.
And then following the taper tantrum, you know, the September '13 to September '14 timeframe, homebuilding stocks were up 19%. So, you know, not a great relative return, but again, a pretty good absolute return. And then a pretty similar dynamic that we saw if we go to this next slide, 22. At the bottom left of this table, you can see in the first quarter of 2019, homebuilding stocks were up 18.4%. So, you know, pretty, pretty remarkable turnaround from where we'd been really all year in 2018.
And one thing, I guess, one final point on the US market on this slide 22 is that, you know, there's an interesting sort of recurrent phenomenon from an equity price performance, which is that most of the time, usually about 2/3 of the time, you get positive, very positive performance in housing equities in the 4th quarter of each calendar year. And then you tend to also see strong positive performance in the 1st calendar quarter of each year.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Josh Steiner: Whereas the middle of the year, so really 2Q and 3Q, these stocks tend to tread water. And I think part of why that's the case is you have this sort of recurrent hope springs eternal sort of spring buying enthusiasm that begins to take hold really around the sort of October, November timeframe. And so we think that's part of what we're seeing here again. We think things are setting up very well for this 4th quarter rally. So So that's what I would leave you with on the side of the US housing market.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So with respect to US housing, this sector looks pretty strong right now. The one thing that could turn it around completely on its head would be a reversal in the direction of interest rates, but neither you nor I think that's about to happen. And meanwhile, the best action seems to be in the smaller homebuilders, or I should say, builders of smaller homes, regardless Regardless of the size of the homebuilder, who are going to be addressing the markets where the most demand exists. Let's move on to Canada and see how that situation compares with the US.
Josh Steiner: Sure, absolutely. So, Canada is almost the mirror image of the US. Canada is very late cycle. Canada has a very significant overleveraging problem at the consumer level. And for these reasons, we'll take a look at why we think the Canadian housing market and the Canadian banking system are going to face a number of years of significant headwinds to come. So let's dive into a few of the more salient points that are really just sort of inexorable fundamental headwinds that the Canadian economy is facing. So the first is slide 24.
Just a snapshot of mortgage debt. And a lot of these slides juxtapose Canada relative to the US. I think it's important to have things to give you a frame of reference. We know obviously how the US experience evolved over the last few decades. So I think comparing that to Canada's experience is instructional. So on this first slide, 24, we can see that The Canadian housing debt relative to GDP has swollen pretty significantly, particularly since the start of 2000. And relative to the US, it's now at levels comparable to where the US was at its peak, right around 70% of GDP. On the right side, we show household mortgage debt indexed to 1970.
And on that basis, obviously, Canada is beginning now to— well, has been really for the last decade, leaving the US in its wake. If we think about home prices or the asset side, as opposed to the liability side, on slide 25, you can see where US home prices were in 2000, where they peaked in 2006, where they corrected to in 2012, and then since where they've since reflated to. And really over that timeframe, Canadian housing prices haven't really looked back. They did very briefly in the wake of the Great Recession, but the magnitude of the drop was de minimis. And, you know, the sort of rally then from 2010 through 2017 was pretty remarkable. And thinking about household debt relative to disposable income on the right, you can see how Canada has really undergone this enormous divergence relative to the US. We've got a couple lines in there for the US, one which is sort of excluding healthcare costs and the other which tries to make the US more apples to apples to Canada considering Canada's healthcare structure.
And then if we think about debt service ratios, which is really kind of the important barometer, this is the amount of money you're spending to service your debt. Slide 26. You can see on the left BIS data, Bank for International Settlements data. That compares Canada to the US. Again, obviously a very significant divergence that has sort of only grown wider over the last 10 years. On the right is that actual divergence mapped. And then on the next slide, 27, same sort of basic idea, debt service ratio. Here we're going about it slightly differently. We're using Federal Reserve data for the US and StatCan data for Canada, and we're showing that divergence on the right. Right here in terms of standard deviation bands, and you can get a sense for, for just how dislocated these 2 markets have become on that basis.
Erik Townsend: Josh, help me out here because these slides are striking to me. I mean, it, it really just jumps off the page. It appears that everything was the same in the US and Canada till about 2000, then prices went crazy in both countries starting around 2000. The US had a peak and a collapse and the event that we all know so well in 2008 and '09, and Canada just kept on going. Is there some fundamental reason that Canada is immune from gravity, or is it different fundamentals that caused the event in the United States? I mean, certainly the corruption around subprime mortgages and the, you know, the underwriting and the Canada doesn't have the kinds of structured products and sophisticated CDOs and so forth that got us in so much trouble in the US. But even if you separate out those factors, the Canadian numbers look kind of nutso to me.
Am I missing something, or is it really a situation where Canadian housing is just crazy high numbers that look unsustainable to me?
Josh Steiner: Well, I don't think Canada is immune to the realities of the fundamentals. And that's really what these charts are designed to illustrate. I think the reality is that Canada had a minor correction following the crisis. I think sometimes what happens in sort of studying examples throughout history is that economies sort of come out the other side of things.
You know, whatever doesn't kill us makes us stronger. It seems to be the prevailing wisdom. And I think based on the fact that the Canadian banking system appeared to be pretty all-weather and came out the other side relatively unimpaired, really emboldened the confidence.
And 2 of the markets where you really saw this were both Canada and also Australia, very similar markets in a number of respects. And I think that's part of what creates the real risk in the in the market is that, you know, you get this, this sense that, well, we came out of that crisis, okay, so therefore things must be fine.
And you've really only seen this sort of, you know, leveraging inclination rise over the last 10 years. And so it's really created a lot of the same sort of backdrop that we had in the US a decade earlier, you know, just a growing number of households that are, you know, extremely stretched from a debt standpoint. And, you know, I think there was some data that came out the other day talking about how 48% of Canadians are less than $200 away from being unable to meet their obligations. And, you know, so pretty extraordinary numbers.
And you think about the vulnerability of a system that itself is so dependent on the housing market from an employment standpoint, and a spending standpoint, and a wealth effect standpoint, and you have that large a share of its base that close to financial trouble, you have a really delicate, at-risk framework that really just isn't prepared to deal with any kind of exogenous shock. And so, that, to me, is really a risky situation you've got And I think these numbers and these charts sort of speak to why that's the case. So very high levels of debt, very high levels of debt service ratio.
Erik Townsend: Josh, how much of this is being driven by the fact that so many wealthy Chinese who are trying to smuggle money out of China are favoring the Canadian housing market as their favorite place to buy high-end condos, particularly Vancouver and Toronto? In particular, you said, you know, what if there was an exogenous shock? Well, what if China were to really clamp down on that and actually stop that capital outflow, and suddenly the demand by external Asian buyers for Canadian condos went to zero overnight? I mean, you talk about exogenous shocks, that would be a big one, wouldn't it?
Josh Steiner: It sure would. And actually, it's already been playing out to a fairly high degree. There's been a number of regulatory changes that have been put out both at the— well, at the provincial level. So if you look at the West Coast, Vancouver— well, really British Columbia sort of started this whole thing off with their 15% foreign buyer tax back in 2016. And then recently, I believe it was February of this year, they raised that from 15% to 20%. And then on top of that, you've had You know, homeowner vacancy taxes. You've had a number of initiatives put in place really to discourage foreign purchasing.
And the CMHC came out recently and said that they have pretty good data now to show what the percent of demand coming from overseas really looks like. And for Greater Vancouver, over the 2016 and 2017 timeframe, it looks like between 20 and 25% of all demand was originating from China. So that market has definitely cooled down very dramatically.
Volumes there in Greater Vancouver have fallen at 40% year over year for the last few years. And a lot of that is being driven by this reduction in foreign demand.
Ontario and sort of the Greater Toronto market are exposed to the same dynamics, but to a slightly lesser extent. So I think part of it is just just a function of proximity. Obviously, Toronto is quite a bit further from China than is Vancouver. It's also a larger market. And so the ability for China to simply play as large a role in a larger market like Toronto is a little bit more constrained. But the dynamics are the same. You've seen this foreign buyer tax imposed across the Greater Horseshoe region that had a significant chilling effect when it went into place.
You know, the other thing that's sort of interesting and we've been hearing more and more about recently is this idea that some of these Canadian housing markets are really being used for money laundering purposes on the part of overseas buyers. And that's been an area that has not until recently received much attention on the part of Canadian regulators.
And, you know, just now, really since the start of this year, you're starting to hear the volume get cranked up. So you're hearing different prominent Canadian regulatory folks begin to finally talk about the scope and magnitude that this problem has played across these housing markets, and they're finally really beginning to crack down on it. We think that's going to be the next shoe to drop that's going to further curb foreign demand.
Then the other thing to think about is that from the standpoint of the Chinese buyer, foreign property is, you know, not quite perfectly, but almost fungible in the sense that they can buy property in Australia, in Canada, in California, in different parts of Southeast Asia. And so they really do look at a lot of these markets sort of on a relative basis. So, you know, if Canadian house prices have risen threefold in Vancouver, which they have, and at the same time, now you have to pay a 20% tax to buy that house that's risen threefold, and you're considering that relative to, let's say, buying something in Thailand or in Vietnam, or somewhere else, that disparity, that relative divergence has just grown incredibly wide.
All else being equal, Chinese demand for property in Canada, and even on the margin in Australia, has really been receding over the last few years.
So, if we go back to some of the Canada fundamentals here on slide 28, one of the things
Josh Steiner: you look for are these so-called Minsky moments, these moments of sort of extreme kind of blow-off-top behavior. Think Nasdaq, you know, late 1999, early 2000. One of the gauges for that would be to look at the amount of brokerage activity, really just from, you know, as a share of GDP.
in the Canadian market relative, in this case, to the US on slide 28. And you can see on the right that in the US versus its long-term average, US real estate commissions as a percent of GDP hit about 3 standard deviations versus their long-term trend. And in Canada, it hit about 2.75 standard deviations at the beginning of 2017. So, you know, So pretty much a very similar dynamic. And again, this is what we look for when we think about housing markets that are sort of in excess. We look for similar patterns, similar dynamics. So I think this is one that sort of speaks volumes to some of the similarities.
And then it's important to remember that even though it's been a really long time since there's been a housing correction in Canada, there are prior examples. So if we look at If you look at slide 29, this is what happened to Canadian home prices in the early 1980s. You had a 17% decline nationally. At the same time, you had the TSX, the Canadian stock market dropped by 42%. So, obviously, a lot of that was clearly driven by sort of the energy policies of the late '70s, early '80s, the price run-up, and then the subsequent housing boom that occurred in conjunction with that. Right. But, you know, you can see what— that there is in fact vulnerability to this market.
We had a sort of a similar episode in the early 1990s. This one was fueled primarily by a much narrower sort of window into the Canadian housing economy, which was the Toronto condo market. But here, just Toronto condo market price corrections triggered an 11% national home price correction. Which also drove an 11% TSX correction. So it's not without precedent. It's just been an incredibly long time, about 30 years, since the last time there was a meaningful correction in home prices nationally across Canada.
And if we look at how fundamentals are beginning to trend here on slide 31, if we look at, you know, year-over-year changes in credit growth, you can see that residential mortgage credit, consumer credit, and then, you know, sum of those two household credit credit are all decelerating on a year-over-year growth basis. And that's really what is sort of keeping the main engine of the Canadian economy going, of course, is credit. So as credit demand is decelerating, that's going to take a toll on the potential for underlying economic growth.
And then on this next slide, slide 32, I had shown this slide earlier when we were looking at the US economy, or rather the US housing market as being being still mid-cycle.
So recall, these are the quarterly cashed-out home equity numbers from 1994 through present. What's interesting is, if you look at Canada— so right now, HELOC balances in Canada on a per capita basis, as of October, were $4,849. And if you compare that to the US on a per capita basis, US HELOC balances are $1,080. So you've got a 4, almost 5 times multiple. To put that into perspective on this chart, that would equate to quarterly home equity cash-out volume of about $67 billion in Canada versus where we were, or where we are currently, of around $15 billion in the US. And if you look at this chart, you can see where Canada would slot in, in these sort of high 60s.
You know, not quite as bad as we were at the peak there in 2005, '06, early '07 in the US, but clearly in a very different place than where we were sort of post the crisis or pre the run-up to the crisis.
Josh Steiner: So obviously a slide that I think is pretty alarming.
So now let's take a look at a few of the sort of regional data points. On slide 33, we have a sort of simple existing home sales stack here for the Greater Toronto market. So if we look at, you know, the most recent data, so this is through May, the first 3 months of 2019, Toronto sales were running at their lowest level of the decade. In April and in May, they've bounced back a little bit. I think part of that is that rates have cooled off a bit, and part of that is a bit of an easy comp phenomenon. But the reality is that even with the bounce in April, May, We're running near the lowest levels of the last decade. Really, the only levels lower are 2018. And if we look at the adjusted month supply, so on slide 34, and I apologize because these are not updated for the most recent data point, but we're generally running at levels that are sort of at or near their their high watermarks over the last decade.
And if we go to slide 35, we can sort of translate. Where adjusted months supply are and what that means for home prices. So when you get into this 2.5 to 3 adjusted months supply range, that's going to produce basically a static home price environment, which is what you can see sort of at the bottom there. So we've kind of highlighted in bold there the months supply 2.5 and 3 translates into 5 and 0. And the idea here is really to give people a framework for thinking about what do changes in demand mean? What do changes in supply mean for home prices? And ultimately, it's home prices that determine losses, and losses, of course, determine bank performance, but also bank underwriting standards, right? Because banks generally underwrite on a backward-looking basis, meaning that as loan losses begin to build up, they tighten credit conditions, and that's what sort of causes the cycle. to go in the other direction.
So I've got a number of slides here. I won't spend too much time on them, but looking at some of the different markets, in this case within the Toronto market, so sort of overall, if we look at detached homes in Toronto, they're down about 20% from where they were in early March 2017. The condo market's held up a bit better, detached market not so well. If we look at slide 37, Some of the sort of bigger suburbs within Toronto, so Markham and Richmond down 27% and 28% since the high-water mark in March 2017. On slide 38, you can look at Vaughan and Ajax down 23%, 17%.
On slide 39, we sort of highlight just a few examples, and we have, you know, a much more robust sort of sampling, but, you know, for this purpose, I just tried to trim this down a lot.
But if we look at the house on the right, just as an example, you know, here's a house in Markham that sold in 2017 in the spring for a little over $2 million, sold just recently for $1.3 million, so roughly a $700,000 loss, 35%, you know, in 2 years. Look at the example on the left. These are 2 virtually identical houses, just a few doors down on the same street. Street, you've got roughly a 27% difference in the selling price between the two. So I think some of the data you see, particularly from places like Teranet conveys sort of this underlying calm, which I think is belied by sort of the real examples you see when you delve into some of these individual markets and really at the sort of ground level individual houses. So I think there's a lot more weakness going on than what you would take away from looking at some of these broader measures.
And so if we transition from Toronto to Vancouver on slide 40, here we've got this existing home sale stack again. So Vancouver has just been getting worse sort of every year for the last few years since its peak in 2017. And the first 4 months of 2019, Vancouver have been the worst in the last decade.
May also the worst May in the last decade, a little bit better, but we think the bounce was largely driven by a bit of weakness in rates. If we go to the next slide, slide 41 here, you can see the adjusted month supply for Vancouver clearly trending up and to the right. To put that into the same context as we looked at earlier with Toronto on slide 42, you can see that 9 months of adjusted supply works out to a home price environment where you're going to see prices declining roughly 10% on a year-over-year basis. So obviously a pretty weak environment.
Slide 43, just a snapshot of different housing categories in the Greater Vancouver area. So, you know, you've got single-family, 2 stories, you know, apartments, composite, all categories rolling over. The change on a year-over-year basis there on the right, clearly moving lower and at a pretty steep rate. Okay. And then, if we look at here, just West Vancouver, as we did for Toronto, where we looked at some of the specific markets, if we looked at West Vancouver, you've got average sale prices of detached homes down 32% from the peak in
Josh Steiner: 2016. So, you know, obviously, a lot of weakness there.
The other thing that's going on across Canada more broadly, which is very interesting, is you're starting to see a very significant rise in consumer insolvency. So we actually— this data goes back all the way to the early 1990s. Beginning in 2012, they broke this data out from being just total consumer insolvencies to being both proposals and bankruptcies, and then the sum of the two, which would be total consumer insolvencies.
And you're seeing this just explosion in consumer proposals, which are really restructurings of debt. Right. And if you look at the trend, if we look at Ontario, for instance, consumer insolvencies in Ontario are up year over year every month now for the last seven months. They're up double digits every month so far in 2019.
And again, this really comes back to this idea that you have a very large number of people who have borrowed very large amounts of debt, and their ability to service that debt. Is very strained. And as home prices come down a little bit, and the employment picture dims a little bit, and remember, we talked about 48% of people being $200 away from being unable to service their debt, it's not surprising that you're seeing these consumer insolvency numbers really break out to the upside. And we would expect to see that trend continue. So this is a pretty important barometer, one that we keep tabs on. There's actually some great follows on Twitter for people who are sort of specialized in this business, if you're interested.
And then, so these last few slides are really just a snapshot of exposure profiles across the Big 6 banks in Canada. We profile residential mortgage and HELOC exposures on both an insured and uninsured basis, as well as the uninsured books relative to their respective regulatory capital levels. So, I won't spend too much time going through that, and I'll leave it at that.
Erik Townsend: Well, Josh, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. It's amazing how much this story has changed since we got the last update from you, which was back in Toronto. So, we look forward to getting you back on the program soon.
Before I let you go, though, we've got another big change from our friends on the marketing side at Hedgeye. The last time we had you guys on, they were promoting the All Access. Hedgeye has introduced a new premium product called Hedgeye Pro, and I had to call my friends in the marketing department to find out the difference. Hedgeye Pro is more organized toward longer-term investors. So where the All Access Pass includes those daily risk limits and some of the things that are more trading-oriented, Hedgeye Pro is more of the longer term. Now they've included in Hedgeye Pro a new product offering from Hedgeye, which is called QIO, Quarterly Investment Outlook.
For those of you who are familiar with Keith McCullough and the Morning Show, Keith loves to take everything and break it down into what's the most 3 important things this day that we need to talk about today. What Hedgeye has done is structured a product which is what are the 3 most important trends in the upcoming quarter, and they've written entire research pieces on each of those 3 topics. And that's called the Hedgeye Quarterly Investment Outlook, brand new product being introduced by Hedgeye, and it's included in the new Hedgeye Pro product. So Patrick has done a fantastic job, as always, at beating down our friends Dan and Matt over at Hedgeye to get a better deal. They're running a big introductory promo on the website. It's $899 for the Hedgeye Pro And we got an extra $150 off for MacroVoices listeners only. The process there is buy it on the website for $899 and then email Matt Moran, mmoran@hedgeye.com, and tell him you want your $150 refund because you're a MacroVoices subscriber, and Matt will hook you up.
And you can find all of that information on the final slide in the slide deck here, or you can You can just go to Hedgeye.com or email sales@Hedgeye.com and be sure to tell them that you're a MacroVoices listener to get that $150 discount.
Josh, we need to leave it there in the interest of time. It's really great having you back on the show. We look forward to having you back again as the housing market evolves to whatever comes next.
Josh Steiner: Happy to do it, Erik. Thank you.
Erik Townsend: Okay, we'll see you next time. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to hear Josh speak on real estate markets. I just found it completely fascinating that the situation in the US in his mind is a complete mirror image of Canada. Like when you look at so many of the things like interest rates and Between Canada and the US, you see so many similarities in their stock markets and so on. But when it comes to real estate and the indebtedness of consumers there, it's so bipolar almost. And Josh is really on top of this whole idea that in Canada, it's really still late-cycle housing and the banking headwinds that are still coming in Canada. It's always interesting to hear from him. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, Josh's comments about the impact of interest rates on the housing market really resonated for me. I mean, just a few months ago, A lot of us had been telling ourselves, okay, the housing market is rolling over, probably going to get worse before it gets better. What Josh very correctly points out is housing sales are not really about home prices. They're about mortgage payments. And therefore, the real estate market is all about interest rates before it's about anything else. And we've seen a major change in view. A lot of people thought once we got past
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Once we passed 3.10% on that 10-year yield, it was gonna be a point of no return. That was it. And the reverse has been true. Yields have been collapsing. So that should breathe new life into this real estate cycle in the United States. And, you know, I think that's good news for people that are selling homes. But it's gonna be very interesting because we've got some smart people like Julian Brigden saying it's gonna be a U-turn in yields.
There are lots of smart people saying that we're headed lower in yields, and that would be good. So we'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, Erik, before we move on to Pete Wargent on Australian housing, we're celebrating an important milestone, airing our first sponsored episode this week. Now, we already heard the sponsor message earlier in the program, but you said you had more to say in the postgame. What's on your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm really delighted that we were able to get Top Traders Unplugged as a sponsor. It, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, is a lot like me. He's a passionate guy who's very passionate about his particular style of investing. Now, in my case, that's macro. In his case, it's all about algorithmic trading based on trend following. So he's as passionate about that as I am about macro. He works for Dunn Capital Management, which is one of the big CTAs that's been heavily engaged in this whole algorithmic trend following something, and they've been offering that service to accredited investors for decades. So he really knows his stuff inside out. Just as I enjoy interviewing all of the smartest minds in the world of macroeconomics, what Niels is passionate about is interviewing the best of the quants who actually come up with the algorithms that are driving these computers in these trend-following and other systematic strategies. So the reason that I think this is relevant Is even for our— I mean, some of our listeners may be interested in learning all about that.
If so, that's great. Niels has a super podcast. But for our listeners who are not interested in that style of trading, when we get a guy like Charlie McElligott on MacroVoices talking about how Nomura has gone to all this work to create a predictive model that anticipates key market levels, what we're really talking about is Nomura has basically put together a model that predicts when computers that are programmed by guys like Niels, what they're gonna do next. So if you're one of our many listeners whose eyes glaze over when we have Charlie on the program and he starts talking about the CTA model and the levels, and you just can't help but wonder, like, okay, what's a CTA again? And why does Charlie think that's so important? And why should I care about this? I don't get it. How does it fit in? Well, look, the book that Niels is giving away for free at toptradersunplugged.com/macro gives a thorough introduction to what all of this computer-driven algorithmic trading stuff is, how it works, and so forth.
So regardless of whether or not you're interested in that in terms of your own investing, the point is it's a free book that will help you understand what the heck Charlie McElligott is talking about when he gets all excited about the influence that CTAs have over the indices. And Patrick, the part that I found most interesting when I got to talking talking to Niels about this on the phone was he explained to me that, you know, he listens to MacroVoices. He's a regular listener, and he's fascinated by Charlie's emphasis on specific price levels that would trigger repositioning by CTAs.
And he thinks that's very curious because, you know, he's one of the guys that programs these CTA models. And he explained that the computers generally care much more about factors like momentum and acceleration of a price move than they do about specific absolute price levels. So I want to ask Charlie about this the next time we have him on the program. I have a hunch that the Nomura guys probably have a lot more in their predictive model than just absolute price levels. But Niels makes a very good point. The way those computers work is really not about prices. It's about other factors. So I'd love to learn more about how the Nomura guys are modeling it because it's fascinating to me to see the interplay of all these things. Anyway, my bottom line advice to listeners is this: regardless of whether or not you're interested in listening to Niels' podcast, which is all about how the algorithms work in these algorithmic trading systems, consider claiming your free copy of the book because that will explain what these CTAs are and why people like Charlie McElligott go to such lengths to model and predict their behavior.
So that's relevant to you as a macro investor. Regardless of whether or not the CTA stuff interests you.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's great to have TopTradersUnplugged.com as a sponsor. So where does that leave us? Do we have all the sponsorship we need to keep MacroVoices free for our listeners, or do we still need their help in finding more?
Erik Townsend: Oh, we definitely still need our listeners' help. We have no idea whether Top Traders Unplugged will be our sponsor for the next 3 months or the next 3 years. And so far, we've only agreed to the next 3 months. months. Our goal is to have a maximum of 2 sponsors per episode. So we still need at least one more sponsor for MacroVoices regardless. Top Traders Unplugged is only sponsoring MacroVoices and one All-Stars episode a week in their initial trial campaign. So we don't have any sponsor for Energy Week or Inside the Investment Committee or most of the All-Stars episodes. So we definitely need more sponsors. And again, here's the drill for our listeners who want to help us, and we so tremendously appreciate your help. I made a detailed video at MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo that explains all the audience statistics so I don't have to bore you with them now. What we need is for our listeners to get that video into the hands of marketing departments of companies that would make good sponsors for MacroVoices.
You can think of this as doing your part to help keep MacroVoices free for everyone's enjoyment as we continue to expand our network and add add more programming. We're trying to be selective and only accept advertising from sponsors which you, our listeners, might sincerely want to learn about so that you don't hate the advertising. So companies like brokers that offer products to sophisticated investors, investment banks, wealth managers, and others whose products or services would truly appeal to the sophisticated investor audience that listens to MacroVoices are the best match. If you want to help us, please start with the video at MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for the update, Erik. So joining us now in the postgame is Pete Wargent, who— it's been a while since we had you on the show, but Pete, we just had Josh Steiner on the show talking about Canadian-US real estate, and I just said we have to get Pete back on the show to give us an update of what's going on in the land down under. So how are things on the real estate market developing in Australia?
Pete Wargent: Yeah, well, since we last spoke, I think 2017, Australia has been through some quite severe disruption. So the past year has really been characterized by a Royal Commission into banking and financial services misconduct. So that, in association with a regulatory credit squeeze, has had a lot of knock-on impacts for real estate. There's been very little confidence in lending from banks. And we've seen there have been regulatory caps on bank lending anyway. So we've got housing credit growth. The most recent stats running at the lowest level on record. Nationally, housing prices are down about 10% year on year, mainly driven by the big capital cities, Sydney and Melbourne.
And we also had— this has been an election year. Year, which rarely inspires confidence anyway. So the past 12 months, there's been record low housing turnover in the established market. Confidence has been at rock bottom. But there's been a few things that have just happened just literally in the last 4, 5, 6 weeks that might just brighten the outlook a little bit. So the forward-looking indicators aren't quite as bad as feared, but it's been a very tough year in real estate, lots of redundancies. construction slowing, and the economy slowing.
Erik Townsend: Now, when you say that there are some brightening signs, when we had you on a couple years ago, you were talking about a really major, major secular overpriced situation that seemed like it would need a really big unwind to fully correct. Are you saying we've gotten to that full correction condition yet, or are you just saying that maybe things are turning up temporarily?
Pete Wargent: Yeah, look, in Australia, it's very patchy. So it's a huge country anyway, Australia. And our markets tend to run in different cycles. So we have essentially the resources states, which are Western Australia, the Northern Territory, and to a certain extent, Queensland and South Australia. So they tend to run with a commodity cycle. And particularly Perth, I mean, that's been I mean, a 5-year downturn. States like Adelaide, there are very few housing affordability issues there over the past decade. So it's really been a Sydney and Melbourne thing where the massive overpricing was seen, and particularly in some of the secondary markets. So further out west, so in places like Western Sydney. So I think it's patchy. In some areas, we've seen corrections of 25% to 30% in nominal terms and more in real terms.
Inner city markets are still expensive, but then to some extent, they quite probably always will be. So there's still some pain to come for sure. But yeah, there's been a whole range of measures have been taken to get activity moving again. And in fact, there was a shock election result, which probably takes some of the pressure off because there were a whole range of tax measures were proposed by the opposition party, which would have made made housing investment far less favorable. So yeah, the correction has been varied across the country, I guess, is what I'm saying.
Erik Townsend: When we had you on the last time in 2017, if I remember correctly, you felt that the trade there was shorting the banking sector because of the amount of exposure that they had. How has that trade played out? And at this point, is there still an opportunity for a trade? Is it still short, or are we at the point where it's time to buy the
Pete Wargent: Yeah, so good point. So when we spoke, I was talking a lot about potential bank shorts and people shorting development companies, mortgage insurers, and so on. The banking trade played out pretty well, especially through the Royal Commission. So all of the major banks suffered big corrections, particularly one of the second-tier banks had a huge reputational knock, AMP. But in fact, all of the major banks Banks saw a pretty sharp fall during the Royal Commission. But since that time, and since the election, they've experienced quite a bounce. So yeah, possibly that trade is less popular now than it was during the Royal Commission. And particularly, I think there's a perception that the incumbent government might not go quite so hard on the banks from a regulatory perspective. So there's been a relief rally since the end of May.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Pete has shared with us a chartbook that all of our listeners can download in the Research Roundup email. Pete, you show in this chartbook the interest-only residential term loans and interest-only loans. What trend are you identifying here, and do you think this is a turning point?
Pete Wargent: Yeah, so what I wanted to do here is highlight a couple of the outstanding risks in Australia. So there are, there are 2 main risks that I see. So the interest-only loan reset is probably the big one. So if you look back to 2015, in many cases, we were looking at about 4 in every 10 loans was an interest-only loan. And what a lot of people were doing was using those loans speculatively, not only investors, also owner-occupiers, and just assuming that at the end of the 5-year term, they would just continue paying interest only. Now, what the regulators have done since that time is they've stamped down very hard on interest-only lending. And a lot of those loans that were written between 2014, 2015, '16 are now coming up for the— to the end of their 5-year period, and they're being automatically reset to principal and interest. So what you can see in the charts is there's been a huge drop in the stock of interest-only loans as borrowers are being pushed across to principal and interest, and that is causing a rise in mortgage delinquencies.
Now, if you look at the stats and track it back, the peak of interest-only lending was 2015. So that means the peak of the reset is going to play out over the next 12 to 18 months. So that's a risk that everybody is watching closely because if borrowers— they might see a 40% spike in repayments when they're pushed across to principal and interest. So if there are stressed borrowers and there's mortgage stress out in the suburbs, that's where it's going to show up.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. So what is your outlook for the next 12 to, let's say, 18 months in Australian real estate?
Pete Wargent: Well, it's brighter than it was. If you'd have asked me pre-election, there was a lot of nervous operators. There was a lot of uncertainty. So the Labor Party had proposed some major changes to the way in which housing is taxed, specifically on negative gearing rules, which allow housing investors to offset net rental losses against their salary. Those changes are not going to happen now because the election result went against polling.
APRA, the Australian prudential regulator, has removed some of its previous caps on interest-only lending. It's removed some of its caps on investor lending. And importantly, in the past couple of weeks, it's proposed removing its interest rate buffer when mortgages are assessed for being written. Previously, all mortgages were assessed at above 7%.
That buffer is now being replaced. By a 2.5% interest rate buffer. So there's a whole range of changes coming through. The government is also proposing a first homebuyer deposit scheme to increase demand in the market. So the outlook for the next year is for stabilization of prices after a 10% fall over the past year. But of course, while prices are still declining, there's a lot of uncertainty. The other outstanding risk— and there's still a lot of apartments under construction, particularly in Sydney and Melbourne. So there's an oversupply risk or a temporary glut of new apartments hitting the market. So there's a high vacancy rate in Sydney and Melbourne. So that's another thing that people are watching pretty closely.
Erik Townsend: Pete, obviously interest rates are critically important to any housing market. That was one of the points that Josh stressed in today's feature interview. I understand that there is contemplation, at least in Australia, about quantitative easing. I believe it would be the first time that Australia has ever ever considered quantitative easing as a monetary policy tool. Give us the rundown. What's going on and what would the impacts and implications be for the housing market if you were to see QE in Australia?
Pete Wargent: So at the moment, so the Reserve Bank has been through a period of stability. They wanted to be a source of confidence for the economy and they held the cash rate at 1.5% for a very long period of time, several years. But recently, they've buckled, and we've started a new easing cycle. So interest rates have been cut by 25 basis points to a record low 1.25%.
And if you look at what financial markets are pricing out to Q2 2020, that's a further 50 basis points of easing and possibly more to follow. So the Reserve Bank has flagged in previous speeches that obviously monetary policy is reaching the limits of what it can do. So he's called on the government to loosen fiscal policy to help stimulate the economy, because in per capita terms, the economy has essentially stalled over the past 3 quarters or 9 months. So what happens next? Well, there's a potential for some unconventional measures, and possibly to a greater extent than we've seen previously. And I don't think it's particularly well understood what those measures might be, but most likely the buying of mortgage-backed securities and possibly the provision of attractive funding to banks. So other things being equal, lower interest rates tend to be supportive of housing market conditions in Australia, especially with the attractive tax benefits for investors.
But to a certain extent, that would be uncharted territory, and there might be some nervous buyers if they start seeing unconventional measures and interest rates at levels we've never seen previously.
Erik Townsend: Okay, well, thanks for some fantastic perspective on the situation there in Australia, Pete. Before we let you go, Please tell our listeners where they can follow your work and learn more about what you do.
Pete Wargent: The easiest place to track me down is just at petewargent.com. I do a range of different things in the housing market, but we have an advisory business for fund managers and anyone who's interested in an Antipodean perspective. We put out reports quarterly in terms of what's going on in Australian construction, in the housing market, and in the economy. So yeah, you can track me down there at PeteWargent.com
Erik Townsend: Pete, thanks so much for joining us. We look forward to getting you back for an update. Listeners, today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Top Traders Unplugged. Don't forget to go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/macro to claim your free book and subscribe to their podcast as well. We'd also really appreciate your help, listeners, by rating and reviewing us on iTunes, because those reviews on iTunes make a world of difference in our ability to find sponsors to help keep MacroVoices free for you, our listeners. So please take a moment, go on iTunes, give us that 5-star review. It really makes a big difference. It'll only take you a couple of minutes. And while you're at it, stop at MacroVoices.com to register your free account, which doesn't cost you a thing. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which contains links to all of the best content we could find on the internet each week.
Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, uh, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Josh, as well as a link to the chart book for Josh Steiner's presentation and the charts we discussed with Pete Wargent in the postgame. There's also a link to a Bloomberg interview with Paul Tudor Jones on his views on gold, and a Jeffrey Snider article titled Commodities and the Future of China. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distribution.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes This edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com.
Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview You guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our Mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Brent Johnson — Santiago Capital founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is. Bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 170 was recorded on June 6th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. We've got a fantastic show lined up for you, a doubleheader, in fact. Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson headlines as this week's feature interview guest. We'll briefly review Brent's Dollar Milkshake thesis and then discuss how that translates to an outlook for stocks, bond yields, gold, and much more. We aired the first episode of an experimental new podcast format called Inside the Investment Committee this week, and we particularly welcome your feedback on the new format as we continue to expand the MacroVoices brand and experiment with new innovative formats. So please let us know what you think about this one, and be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment where we'll be joined by Adam Collins from Movement Capital, who operates the freecotdata.com website which reorganizes the government's Commitment of Traders reports into a context that's much more useful to traders and investors.
We're going to take a closer look at those Commitment of Traders reports and how they work in our postgame segment coming up right after the feature interview with Brent Johnson.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Let's get right into the S&P 500 here, Erik. I mean, we had a pretty solid sell-off and then it ended with what has been now a pretty solid rebound in the last 3 days. What's your thinking here on the S&P?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm not the slightest bit surprised that the market is going up when I think that the economic reality suggests that it should go further down. But if you look at what's been driving the market, it really should come as no surprise. A lot of this has been driven, Patrick, by the Chinese trade deal and Fed policy and so forth. And now we've got this comment from Fed Governor Bullard saying that the Fed is going to have to cut interest rates or is likely going to have to cut interest rates, something that all of the smartest guys in the room already knew and had been saying on MacroVoices, but now we've got a Fed governor saying it.
So that was one signal. There are also rumors starting to circulate that maybe there's some kind of China trade deal at the end of June that's going to come out. You never know what to read into those rumors, but one way or another, it's helping the market to recover. Now, as far as I'm concerned, the market ought to be looking at Bullard's comment as an admission the Fed was unable to stay the course on its quantitative tightening and hiking cycle because the economy can't tolerate it. The economy is much worse than they thought.
This is all, in the big grand scheme of things, reasons for concern, not reasons for excitement. But the market can't seem to see past, okay, more Fed accommodation is coming, more easy money, let's jump for joy, and stocks are rallying. As far as the real problems that I think are going to cause really serious problems for this market down the road, it's not what's driving the tape action right now.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US Dollar Index because for the entire month of May, we kept toying with a bull breakout that it was gonna go. And no sooner do we have Brent Johnson coming onto the show, we have a dollar that's at least retreating off of the highs. It doesn't look like a new downtrend or anything, but what's your take here on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's entirely explained by Bullard's comment that the Fed is likely going to ease. Patrick, the way most market participants think about the dollar index is that it's all about interest rates. interest rate differentials. So clearly, Bullard's comment that the Fed is likely going to have to cut interest rates is dollar negative according to that old-school rationale that that's what it's all about. My contention is that's not what it's all about. I think that Jeff Snider's thesis about a dollar squeeze and a global dollar liquidity shortage are really what's driving this. Now, we've seen this before when there was a dovish pivot by the Fed. All of a sudden, there's a pullback in the dollar and all of the dollar bears are screaming at the top of their lungs, this is it, the dollar's crashing, the, the end is nigh. And after a few days, we see that there's just a knee-jerk reaction lower, and then the dollar resumes its climb.
So I think this is a buying opportunity, and I think there's a bigger buying opportunity coming, and that's when the Fed is not talking about cutting but actually cuts rates, especially if it catches the market by surprise and there's a 50 basis point cut that nobody saw coming. You could see a huge spike down in the dollar, and I think again, that that will be a buying opportunity. So yeah, the, the tape's looking a little bit weak here, but even in the face of this comment from Bullard talking about a change in direction in FOMC policy, we're still seeing what I think is a modest pullback, and, and I think that it's a buying opportunity before the bullish trend continues.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because I would love to get your opinion on, uh, what happened here. I mean, we were just toying with $60 a week ago, and suddenly we found ourselves in a pretty heavy Sell-off, not so much today, but what's going on here in crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, of course, we've got our new Energy Week program, so we went into more detail on this on yesterday's Energy Week. So I'll just give a quick summary. But basically, yeah, we've seen a major change in sentiment. It's been driven largely by inventory. And let's cover those EIA inventory data. Just massive, massive builds on inventory. Crude oil building 6.7 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, building a massive 1.8 million barrels. Now oftentimes when we have those big crude builds, they're offset by drawdowns in finished product, and you kind of have to say, okay, well, net-net it's not that big. This week it's just builds across the board, Patrick. Gasoline building 3.2 million barrels, distillates building an utterly huge 4.6 million barrels on the week. Needless to say, the tape action was not just down but panic down in both RBOB gasoline and the crudes.
The thing is though, we hit A pretty good technical support level yesterday. We actually went through it, recovered to close about on it, and then today on Thursday, most of the day it was kind of sideways, not much going on, and then just into the pit close at 2:30 there was a sudden last-minute rally and we recaptured the 5-day moving average at $52.98 on WTI crude oil. RBOB gasoline, as I'm looking at the tape just a few minutes before 4 o'clock here, we're not quite back to RBOB's 5-day 5-day moving average, but we're just a few ticks away from it. And it looks to me like we're at least going to test the 5 days. Maybe this is the beginning of a bigger bounce. Now, I do think that the downtrend is likely set to continue unless there's some material change in the news flow. But, you know, we've come a long, long way down. We're overdue for a bounce right now.
We've got a technical level that's holding so far, and a rally into the pit close today suggests to me maybe the bounce has begun. But at this point, I think the question is how high do So we bounce before the selling continues. I don't think this is over yet, but I do think there's a very good chance that a bounce has begun.
Now, beyond the inventory numbers, US production ticked up to a new all-time high of 12.4 million barrels. Keep in mind that the rig count had been declining. A whole bunch of people were predicting that there would be a reversal in the trend of US production. We went up to 12.3, then we came down to 12.1, and a bunch of people were saying, okay, this is it, the trend reversal.
Well, clearly the trend reversal is not on us. We're back up to yet another all-time high. Imports 7.9 million barrels per day this week, exports 3.3 million barrels. So that's 23 million barrels on the week of US crude oil exported out of the country. And even after you take those 23 million barrels out, you've still got 6.7 million barrels of additional stock built after the 23 million barrels were exported. So I think that the downtrend, which is clearly in play, is probably not over, but we're already overdue for a bounce, and it looks like maybe one is starting.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold, because what a change week over week. We cleared that $1,300 level and it just took off like a rocket. What's your thinking here on gold?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, my first comment is a one-word comment: wow. And I should admit that I was not expecting this. Now, this clearly qualifies as a breakout by any reasonable measure. So we've broken the downsloping trend line very aggressively, and now we're retesting that just super, super critical resistance level, $1,350, $1,360, depending on how you measure it. I think $1,360 is a safer number to use as critical resistance. It's been close to 5 years now that we haven't been able to get above that number, and if we are able to, you can make an argument that there's a cup and handle formation in the chart that looks very bullish, so it could be a setup for much higher numbers if I just look at the technicals.
Now, this, needless to say, is an outcome that I was not expecting. I do still think that the most likely outcome here is a failed test at this level and a reversal lower, but frankly, I've got to handicap myself. I wasn't expecting it to get this high, so, you know, my ability to read the market, at least with respect to gold in the last few weeks, is, uh, not exactly perfectly tuned. So we'll see what happens. Now, if we do get a breakout, I think it's very tricky to trade because this resistance at $1,350, $1,360 has been here for 5 years. That means that in order to really have a decisive breakout, it's not just a daily close once over those numbers, needs to stay there for a while. And of course, if you wait for it to stay there for a while, you might miss the move.
So it's going to be interesting to see how this plays out. Patrick, I think there's a good chance this is going to play out the way the 10-year Treasury yield did, where we, we got to 3.10 and everybody said that's the critical level. We started to break out above it, everybody piled in, it got all the way to 3.25, turned out to be a false breakout, a reversal, and it was a very bearish sign. Now, needless to say, I've been bearish and I've been wrong in recent history, so I might be wrong again. But certainly, I'm not buying here, just a few points below a critical, critical resistance level. I'm waiting for the breakout, and I may jump on the boat if I'm convinced the breakout has legs.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because we dropped almost 50 basis points in a month. It's an incredible move. I mean, we're a stone's throw away from 2%. What happens next here?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's really just amazing. You know, just this afternoon as we're getting ready to tape the show, I'm putting my notes together and it's like, yeah, I've got to get things. I'm looking at things, 2.09. No, no, I want the 10-year yield. Where's the 10-year yield? Oh, that is the 10-year yield. And it's back up now. I'm looking at 2.13 just before the close. But I did see 2.09 go across my screen earlier. So needless to say, wow. So the conundrum here, Patrick, is I do think that the fundamentals are in place for even lower yields.
I think this move does have room to continue, but boy, it's moved so far so fast. Certainly count yourself lucky if you bought 2-spot 60 when I told you to on this program a few weeks ago. But now that we're here at 2-spot 13, below 2-spot 10 earlier in the day, we've gone so far so fast it feels to me like time for a pullback. So I would think about taking some profits here if you've been long since 2-spot 60 and waiting for that pullback. But frankly, I thought that last week And we still surged even lower in yields. So who knows how far this can go, but it's, it's gone awfully far without a pullback. I think we're overdue for one.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, before we move on to the feature interview, please give us a quick update on your efforts to secure sponsorship for the new programming so that we can keep MacroVoices free for our listeners.
Erik Townsend: Well, first of all, I really want to thank everyone who has donated to MacroVoices using the donate button on our MacroVoices.com website in the last few weeks. Those donations have directly enabled moving forward with Inside the Investment Committee, even before we secured our first corporate sponsor. So we really need help from listeners who work in companies that would make a good sponsor for MacroVoices. We have one sponsorship discussion that has moved on from our listener to a serious negotiation with the appropriate department in his company. And there are about 3 other listeners advocating for us inside their organizations as well. But we still need more help. It's going to take more than one sponsor to keep MacroVoices going. So to make this easier, I've produced a pitch video describing the history of the MacroVoices brand, all of the audience demographics and download statistics, and a description of our expansion plans, a description of the sponsorship packages on offer, the whole 9 yards.
The idea is that our listeners who are interested in helping us can watch the video to arm themselves with all of the facts and figures needed to make the case on our behalf to your marketing department. And then once you've got their attention, you can send them the video, which is basically the sales pitch for why they should sponsor MacroVoices.
In hindsight, at 24 minutes long, the video is probably longer than it should be, but I think it makes a really strong case for the values that sponsors will receive. You'll find the video at MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo. That's all one word, no punctuation. MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo. So if you want to help us keep MacroVoices free for listeners, please have a look at the video and consider who in your organization you might send it to.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, thanks for the update. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson. Erik, why did we invite Brent onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, this was an embarrassing story for me, Patrick. When we were taping Brent's interview, I asked our production team, guys, be sure to get links to all of Brent's previous feature interviews into the article so our listeners can find them. And they couldn't find them. They're telling me, you gotta send me the link. I said, come on, guys, put it in the website. It's in the search box. Look. And then Brent piped up and said, Erik, this is my first time. I've never done this before. And I said, oh! It's funny because, you know, Brent is one of our MacroVoices All-Stars. I chose the All-Stars as the very best of our feature interview guests that our listeners want to hear more from. And Brent is in All-Stars without ever having done his first MacroVoices full-length interview. And I think the reason is we've had him at MacroVoices Live as a speaker where he was fantastic. Fantastic. We've had him in a couple of postgame segments reacting to one of Luke Gromen's interviews, and I didn't even realize that we had yet to give him his own feature interview.
I kind of feel badly about that. I have tremendous respect for Brent, and, and I think the combination of Brent and Luke Gromen's views is just so important because these are 2 people who on the surface appear to be in diametric Disagreement with one another. But I think if you really look beyond the surface, they really do agree in the long term. They have very different views on how things will play out before we eventually get to that Luke Gromen endgame. I don't know which one of them is right, but it's very interesting to me to weigh these opinions. And I think particularly the way that Brent thinks about what some of the consequences and ramifications of a big dollar rally could be in terms of how it would affect other markets are particularly insightful. So I'm really excited about this particular interview and looking forward to it with Brent.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, Erik's interview with Brent Johnson is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me next is Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson. Brent is extremely well known for his Dollar Milkshake Theory, which in my opinion, along with Jeff Snider's Dollar Squeeze Theory, are really one of the most insightful explanations of what's been going on with the dollar index and the reason that we've seen so much strength in the dollar, even when interest rate differentials would seem to suggest otherwise. I want to refer I want to refer our listeners, before we get into the interview with Brent, to a couple of previous episodes. We've had Brent on, not in his own feature interview— this will be Brent's first feature interview today— but we had him almost as a rebuttal to Luke Gromen's last feature interview. The link to that episode, including Luke Gromen's very dollar bearish story along with Brent's dollar bullish rebuttal, you can find that in your Research Roundup or on our homepage at MacroVoices.com next to Brent's picture. Also, Brent recently did an all-stars appearance for MacroVoices where we talked a little bit about the dollar.
Brent, I think that since we have not had you on the program as a feature interview guest before, I'd like to just do a quick recap of your Dollar Milkshake Theory. What is this all about, and why is it that you think about the US dollar index a little differently than most analysts who tend to think that really the the value of the dollar has everything to do with interest rate differentials. And a lot of analysts really don't see some of the other aspects that you believe is driving the dollar.
Brent Johnson: Yeah, sure. Well, thanks again for having me, Erik. Always happy to talk to you and your listeners. I'll go through the Milkshake Theory pretty quickly. There's a lot of info out there on it for those who want to have a deeper dive. But essentially, the Dollar Milkshake Theory is kind of a play on a movie about where this guy was drinking up the oil of his next-door neighbor by using a straw. And so, what I mean by that is that over the last, let's call it 10 years, the central banks took out their monetary syringes, and they pushed down on their plungers, which is the interest rates, and they flooded the market, the global market with liquidity. They printed yen, they printed yuan, they printed dollars, they printed euros, they printed British pounds, et cetera, et cetera. So, there was this big pool of capital out there.
And that went on from, let's call it, 2010 to 2015, for lack of a better time period.
And then at the end of 2015, the US got rid of its syringe and they stuck a straw down into this milkshake that I call it. We've got this currency milkshake out there, and the US stuck their straw down in there by raising interest rates. So now, rather than pushing down on their syringes, they're lifting up on their syringes and they're sucking that capital up. Into the US economy. As that happened, the dollar, I think, started to get stronger. It has not broken out yet. And in some cases, I would argue that the Milkshake Theory is only just getting started. Some people think that it is in. I really do not even think it has really started yet. But that higher differential in US interest rates versus the rest of the world, and the fact that our domestic economy, at least on a relative basis, has been stronger than others, domestic economies has pulled capital into the US.
And as we move forward, I think that that continues. Now, that doesn't mean that things are good here. It doesn't mean that the US economy is accelerating. It doesn't mean it's hitting on all cylinders, for lack of a better analogy. It just means it's better than everywhere else. And for those who argue that it's not better than everywhere else, I ask, why was the US able to raise interest rates 9 times when Japan has made modern monetary theory their national pastime, and Draghi has never raised once in 10 years. So, the fact that we were able to do 9 of them, and nobody else can even do 1, to me, validates what I'm saying. Now, again, it doesn't mean that the global economy is strong. It just means that on a relative basis, we are stronger than everybody else.
And I think that that continues. And I think as that continues, it pulls capital into the US, and it makes the US market It's on a relative basis better than everywhere else.
Erik Townsend: Now, Brent, when I've talked to you about this theory before, and I agree with you, by the way, I think the dollar is definitely getting ready to break out, and I expect it to move much higher. There are a lot of people who disagree strongly with us on that, and they've made their arguments, and that's great. But boy, if you're us and you think the dollar is moving higher, and one of the views that you and I have both had is that all the people that want to get excited about gold— and I think gold is going to be the asset to be long in the long run, but I haven't felt like it's time yet. I think the dollar goes higher and gold goes lower before this is all over. Well, boy, look at the last couple of weeks in gold, Brent. It looks like to a lot of people the market is starting to prove us wrong with a breakout that I didn't expect in gold.
I thought we might get a little breakout above that downsloping trend line that's been in play for several months. Only because so many people think the Fed is maybe getting ready to pivot back to a more accommodative cutting cycle as opposed to a hiking cycle. But I didn't expect it to go this high. Now, as we are speaking on Wednesday morning, we are flirting with $1,350, which has been— what is it, for 4 or 5 years now? That has been the level that has capped gold. So a lot of people think it's about to break out above $1,350, and that would seem to prove us wrong. What do you think about that? about the message we're getting from gold here?
Brent Johnson: Yeah, it's been quite a couple weeks for gold. And, you know, kind of what you said, I was expecting a little bit of a bounce. I didn't expect it would be this high. But I'll tell you, I, I have not changed my, my opinion. And before I answer this question specifically, I just want to say that, listen, I'm a huge believer in gold. There may be a handful of people out there who've put out more work than I have of why everybody should own gold in their portfolio, and I still believe I just don't happen to think it's going to pay off right now, even despite this short-term bounce.
I actually bought some puts on the miners earlier this morning as a short-term trade, because I think this is a little bit overdone in the short term. And so, I do think that gold is going to pull back.
Now, I might be wrong. And here's the thing is I don't mind being wrong. You know what? I've been wrong many times in my life. I'll be wrong many more times going forward. That's the nature of this business. Nobody's going to be in this business for 20 years and not get it wrong on several occasions.
One of the key things is when you get it wrong, not to lose too much money. And so, I own gold. I don't expect it to pay off now. I thought this morning provided an opportunity to make a little short-term trade, which I entered. But if I lose money on that trade, I'll make money on my long-term gold thesis, and it'll be fine.
But I just think that the dollar hasn't even really broken out yet. And I think when the dollar finally breaks out, I think that that's going to at least initially be bad for gold. Now, we've spoken before and we've talked about how eventually, I think that there will be enough chaos out there that both gold and the dollar will rise together versus all other currencies. I don't think we're there yet. We might be. And like I said, if I'm wrong and the gold keeps going up, that's fine. I'll say I was wrong and I'll move forward. But in the short term, I think gold's a little bit overdone here. I'd be a little bit careful chasing it.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I couldn't agree with you more. I have not dared to short it here, but I expect what's likely to happen is $1,350, $1,360 in there somewhere. somewhere. That's where the very, very strong resistance level has been. And certainly, if we see a decisive breakout above that level, it's time for me to rethink my view and buy some gold too. But so far, I'm not expecting that to happen. And exactly as you say, you know, this is the beauty of these markets. Once you get the process down, it's okay to be wrong as long as you've got a plan for what to do next.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to bond yields. A lot of people thought, you know, boy, we were going to hit that, that 3-spot 10 on the 10-year, and it was just gonna be all over after that, and we couldn't go anywhere but higher in bond yields. Now we've got moving down to crashing— crashing's maybe a little bit of an exaggeration, but boy, collapsing bond yields. What's going on? Is this about a recession signal, or is there more to this story?
Brent Johnson: I think it's a little bit of both. I think that, listen, the smartest guys I know are all bullish rates, or that they've all been telling me that rates are gonna go much lower Perhaps to zero and to be buying bonds over the last 6 to 12 months. And you know what? I give them credit. They have been right. It has been a great call. I have exposure to short-term bonds. I have never loaded up on the long-term or anything, and I have not made a killing by owning bonds in the last year, but that is okay. That is a trade that I am okay sitting on the sideline and letting somebody else make money. I completely understand the argument for rates going much lower. I am just not convinced it is going to happen. And I think it's actually possible that we're seeing somewhat of a low in rates being made now.
Now, again, if I'm wrong, that's fine. I don't have a problem being wrong on that. It's just if you look up the interest rate probabilities on Bloomberg, the market is saying there's a 99% chance of a rate cut in the next 7 months. And listen, that is not a contrarian trade. Rates going lower is not a contrarian trade right now. It is very much the consensus right now. In fact, them not cutting would be a very contrarian stance. Now, what ends up happening? I am not sure. I actually do not think that they are going to raise. Now, if I am wrong on that, again, fine, I will adjust and we will go from there, but I am not sure that cutting rates does what they think it will do.
The stock market, the US markets are within 2% or 3%, maybe 4% of their all-time highs. Inflation is around 2%, give or take a little bit. Employment is extremely low. I am not sure that they need to cut. Again, I understand the argument for rates going lower, but I just do not think that the Fed needs to cut.
And here is the thing, if they do cut, let us just stand back and think about what a rate cut tells you.
A rate cut by the Fed, when the market is near its all-time high, inflation is low, and unemployment is low, tells you that behind the scenes, somewhere that you can't see, things are really bad. To me, that's a very bearish signal that the Fed would be sending to the rest of the world. Now, there's 2 things from this. If you send out that negative signal, does that really help markets, or does it hurt markets? Well, the dollar would probably at least initially go down on that news. So, from a headline perspective, maybe it provides a little bit of a down push on the dollar, and that provides a little relief for the people who are having trouble getting dollar funding.
But what are the other central banks going to do if we cut? Remember, Japan has been doing QE or modern monetary theory moves for 20 years now. The ECB has been doing it for 10. Nobody can get off zero except for the US. Are they— after everything they have done, And now the Fed comes in and cuts. Do you think those guys are just going to sit there and do nothing? I think as soon as we cut, Japan probably cuts, and maybe Europe goes even more negative. I just don't see this being a huge thing where the US rates are all of a sudden falling, the rest of the world is raising, and the dollar just goes to zero. I actually think that even though if the Fed were to cut and the dollar were to fall on that headline, I think it would be an incredible, incredible buying opportunity.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Brent Johnson: I think I mentioned to you in January, Erik, that I am so convinced that the dollar is going higher over the next couple of years, I'm in the middle of setting up a vehicle to actually play this theory, and we literally are just launching this month. I am looking across the board at all these different opportunities, and I just cannot believe that they exist.
Erik Townsend: Brent, I want to jump on that and talk about a little bit more specifically, what are these opportunities that you're looking at? We've talked about a view that we share, which is the dollar's headed higher. Are you just talking about being long the dollar, or is there more to the story?
Brent Johnson: Well, there's a little bit more to the story, but I'll tell you, Erik, I really think the whole world is a dollar story right now. As goes the dollar, so goes the world. And as we've discussed before, I think ultimately, the dollar goes much higher before it goes lower. And the knock-on effects of the dollar going higher, I think, create a lot of disruption in the market. And because the dollar is not expected to go as high as I think it is, the pricing of some trades out there is very favorable for those who do think it's going to go that high. As an example, if you look at currencies like the yen or the Australian dollar, or even the Swiss franc, the euro, because of the wide differential in rates, the The option pricing to buy puts versus these other currencies, puts on these other currencies versus the dollar are very favorable.
You can go out and buy a 2- or 3-year put on the euro or the yen and outlay a very small amount of premium to buy a very large exposure should that reverse or should the dollar strengthen versus them.
The US dollar, for all its flaws, and believe me, I agree, it is very flawed, but for all its flaws, It is still the world reserve currency. It is still used for 90— or not 90, a huge percent of the world's trade and trade finance. Not only that, but a number of countries have gone out there and borrowed in dollars. The rest of the world, not the US, the rest of the world owes $11 trillion in dollars.
And so, there's still huge demand for the dollar. And so, when the US has rates significantly higher than the rest of the world, And the rest of the world is, in many places, negative rates. The pricing for that to reverse, because I do believe it will reverse. Now, whether it reverses next month or next year, I don't know. I think it happens sooner than many people think it does. But if you give yourself a 2-year window for this to happen, the pricing on some of these puts versus the dollar are really spectacular.
Erik Townsend: Brent, I want to move on to the stock market because if I think about the way most people think about relationships between markets and macroeconomic theory. They would say, okay, this Brent Johnson fellow, he's very, very bullish the dollar. Dollar rallies tend to go with stock market crashes. And furthermore, he's not particularly saying that the dollar strength is about a strong economy. He says it's other factors. So not a really strong US economy, dollar moving higher. Sounds like this guy must be a super stock bear.
But that's actually not the case. Please explain why you have a theory that this dollar rally might actually be the catalyst that causes stocks to move much higher.
Brent Johnson: Sure. You know, and I'll tell you, out of all the parts of this theory that I get challenged on, this is, this is the one. There are a number of people out there who can understand the dollar getting stronger. They often will come back to me and say, I just don't get the hot stocks going higher part And my thought is that if I'm sitting in somebody else's shoes and I'm not in the US, let's say that I'm in Italy as an example, and I'm managing some kind of a pension fund or an endowment or even just a very large portfolio.
Now, say whatever you have to say about the US economy and criticize it as you will. Fine, I'll accept that. But then compare it to the Italian economy. Now, do you honestly think that the Italian economy is better than the US economy? I have a hard time getting to that conclusion. one, especially with their banking system, which everybody knows is, for lack of a better word, insolvent.
Now, you also have the potential for Italy with their government to not play nice with the rest of the EU. And so, you're sitting there looking at, as a manager, an asset manager in Italy, and trying to figure out where to place your assets. You can buy European sovereign that's giving you a negative yield. Or you can buy a US Treasury that's giving you 2% or 2.5%. To me, that's not such a bad idea because if the euro goes lower and the dollar goes higher, then you get your 2%, 2.5% coupon and you get the dollar strengthening versus it. All of a sudden, maybe you're at a 4% or 5% return. Well, then you also go out there and you look and you say, okay, what about equities? Do I want to buy an Italian or a Spanish or a UK equity? Blue-chip company, or do I want to put my money in a big blue-chip US company?
I've used the example of Philip Morris before, and I always use that because I think it's a very big company. It's got a great management team. Its product is somewhat recession-proof, and it pays like a 4% dividend. So, if I'm sitting in Italy, and I am looking around where to put money, and I can buy US blue-chip, and the dollar goes up by 4% or 5% versus the euro, And I get a 4% or 5% dividend on top of it, all of a sudden, I'm at 8% or 9% return. That's not so bad.
I just think that that— and I use the Italian example, but I think it exists for somebody in Australia. I think it exists for someone in Canada. I think it exists for someone in Japan. I think it exists for someone in Spain. I think it's a global thing.
Again, it's a relative world, and I think that when things start to break, that the US will be seen as a relative safe haven. And here, this leads into why I had said earlier in this conversation that I'm not even sure that the Milkshake Theory has really gotten started yet. And that is because the dollar hasn't really broken out yet. And the rest of the world, even though they're not growing gangbusters, they haven't really started breaking down yet.
I think when other markets start to break down, and they start to realize that their economies are in worse shape than they think that they are, and they start looking for safe havens, that's when I think that the stock— that's when I think the flows are going to start coming back into the US. And I think that that can push US equities higher.
I saw a chart yesterday, and it showed all the flows that have been going out of equities over the last, I think, 4 or 5 months. And it's a huge number. I don't have it right in front of me, And I was thinking, okay, we've had this huge outflow from equities, and yet, they're still within 3%, 4% of the all-time highs. What happens when those flows come back? Or what happens if the flows just stop leaving? So, I think that there's an opportunity for the US equities to go higher, not because things are good, but because, in some ways, because things are bad. And that's how it ties into the Milkshake Theory.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think that's extremely insightful, Brent, because I have been bearish on US stocks. But if there is one theory that I've heard that really explains to me why I should think about a serious upside risk in stocks, it's exactly what you've described. And I guess the way I would put it is, you know, there's never ever in all of recorded monetary history been a time when we had dual bubbles in both sovereign bonds and in stocks. Right. Created by 10 years of accommodative central bank policy. That's never ever happened before. We're in uncharted territory, and any assumption that we might have about what happens when things start to turn south— normally what happens in, in most markets is the stock market goes down dramatically and the money flows into the bond market because the bond market was probably already Well, the bond market's not depressed at this point. It's at all-time highs, all-time low yields, or close to it, within a percent of being the 35-year low.
So when you get people panicking, the idea of let's sell all of our stocks, you know, let's say you're in Europe and you've got both European stocks and US stocks in your portfolio. Things are getting bad. It's time to panic. Let's sell all of the interest that we have in stocks. That's ownership.
Brent Johnson: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: In productive companies that actually produce a profit, and let's instead throw the money into negative-yielding sovereign debt in a currency bloc which a lot of people think is collapsing. It's not necessarily true that people are going to exit stocks and go into bonds, sovereign bonds in their own countries, the way it's always worked in the past, because these circumstances are so different. And nobody knows what's going to happen. So I certainly don't, you know, interpret what you're saying as any kind of certainty that the stock market's going to go way up. But if it does, I think this is probably the explanation.
You know, it's the same thing that so many people have said to me about gold. I've expressed a real skepticism that it's not time yet for gold. And I really think that I'm right about that in US dollars. If you are a European investor and your savings are in euros, The time to get into gold was a long time ago. You know, it's a, it's a whole different game. And you've got to understand that that's really big.
There is a risk that the European Union is beginning to fall apart. And if it starts to look like it's really falling apart, that's going to create a mass panic exodus. And it's an exodus from what into what? We don't know because the dynamics are completely different. Have you found any corollaries or examples in history where you had a situation where, you know, there was a setup like this where maybe the economy is finally turning south, but you're going into a situation where any flight capital coming out of stocks would have to go into what's already a bond bubble? I mean, out of stocks and into the safety of negative-yielding sovereigns?
Brent Johnson: Well, and that's why I say, listen, there's that famous saying, there's nothing new under the sun, right? This has probably happened before. I don't have a good example off the top of my head, but I just look at now and I say, there's no real easy answer here. Listen, there's this theory that's gone around for the last 2 or 3 years, maybe 4 years, where they would talk about TINA when talking about the stock market, which means there is no alternative. And I always hated it because there is also— you can always sit on the sideline. You don't have to invest. Unless you're a manager of a mutual fund or an endowment or some institution, you do not have the ability to go to the sideline.
Your mandate says you are invested. Where are you going to place the money? And so, you do actually have to put your money somewhere. And I do not believe that people are going to continue to plow their money into a negative-yielding bond.
Brent Johnson: Now, could I be wrong? Of course, I can be wrong. But as I look around, I have a hard time believing that is the case. And you mentioned something when you were just talking there, that made me think of something else regarding bonds. And I don't have a big desire to get into the big bond debate. Again, I completely understand the arguments for yields going lower, and very, very smart people believe that that's where it's going. Again, I'm willing to sit on the sideline and let that trade go by.
But if I had to take the argument on the other side, and I had to challenge the view, this is one thing that I think people may be forgetting or overlooking. Part of the reason that a lot of people think interest rates are going lower is there is very low inflation, and the prospects for inflation do not look great. If I was going to argue for the upside of inflation, this is how I would start it. As part of my whole worldview, I have said before that I think that the rest of the world, as the dollar gets stronger, the rest of the world is going to experience deflationary effects because of all the dollar debt that they owe and the dollar funding that they But maybe I should have said it more of a stagflationary as opposed to just pure deflationary, because if you look around the world, especially in emerging markets, food makes up an incredible amount of the cost of daily budgets or daily living expenses.
And I think I can make a case where food prices 12 to 18 months from now might not only be higher, but could be significantly higher. And that leads to inflationary effects. And if we start to get those, and that starts to percolate up, then maybe the Fed has a harder time continuing to drop rates. If there start to be some inflationary effects, now they've got to start taking that into consideration.
Here's how I would argue it. In China, they have the— I guess I'd call a hat trick of problems in their food industry. They've got the Asian swine flu, which I promise you is a bigger issue than even the people who are out there ahead of it are saying it is.
There's the armyworm, which is now hurting their grain crops. And then last week, they have bird flu outbreak. So, now it's attacking their poultry. Now, for the biggest country in the world to potentially go into a food shock, trying to feed all their citizens, that's a big problem.
And that can lead— you're already starting to see that lead to higher prices in substitutes, such as beef, Now, that's on the meat side of things, but let's talk about the grain side of things.
Again, they have the armyworm problem in China, but now in the US, we've had some severe storms in the spring. A large percent of the farmable land in the Midwest has not even been planted because they can't get into their fields to plant, and there's still standing water, and the banks of the Mississippi have flooded. We've had the biggest floods along the Mississippi in like 100 years. And so, the crop production 6, 12, 18 months from now could be constrained, or the supply of grain could be constrained. Now, all of a sudden, you've got rising food prices because demand is still there. We've still got all the people, but we've got less supply. And now, you start to get social unrest in these countries where food prices are going up, but their earnings aren't going up, and their wages aren't going up.
It was 5, 6 years ago where we had the big Arab Spring uprisings across the the Middle East and North Africa. It all started because of food prices. So, I just think that it's a fascinating world right now. I'm not convinced that inflation is as contained as many people would say it is. And I think that we could start to see some real, not just social, but geopolitical knock-on effects of what's going on. And when that happens, I think the dollar and the US gets capital flows as a result.
Erik Townsend: I want to talk about the long-term view that you've described associated with the Dollar Milkshake Theory, where you've said that there could be— and I want to be careful, you have not predicted this is a certainty to happen. You've just said there is plenty of possibility for a really, really big move in the dollar index to all-time highs. So they say 125+ on the dollar index.
Here's my problem with that. I'm going to make a little bit of a crazy analogy. If you were a structural engineer and you told If you told me you've done some analysis and you're convinced that the Brooklyn Bridge is going to collapse and the cars driving across it, everybody's going to be killed as a result of this horrible thing, I'd say, wow, that's a big prediction. You know, let's see what your data is. I can believe that that's possible. It's an old bridge.
But if you told me that what's going to happen is the bridge is going to collapse and then for the next 2 months, all day long, cars are going to drive off of it and everybody's going to die, I would say, Brent, you're crazy. They would close the road.
Well, I guess what I'm not seeing here is there is so much risk to the global economy if the dollar really, really starts to take off. Let's say above 110 on the dollar index, for the sake of a round number. That would cause so many problems with so many countries and major corporations around the world, foreign companies that have borrowed in US dollars that would suddenly be unable to repay their debts. It would make US exports next to impossible because nobody would be able to afford them. It would cause so much damage, it seems to me like they would close the road and it wouldn't go any higher. And what I mean by that is some equivalent to the Plaza Accord back in, I think it was '85, when there was an agreement explicitly for governments to work together to suppress the dollar.
It seems to me that for any theory that involves the US dollar moving above 110 on the dollar index. There's got to be some analysis of when they at least try to close the road and what happens. So how do you think this would play out? You know, at some point, is there a Plaza Accord? What happens?
Brent Johnson: Yeah, so very good question. Ultimately, I do think that there will have to be some kind of a Plaza Accord. I think the dollar will have to get revalued lower. I've said before that I actually think when that happens, the Plaza Accord will be welcomed And the rest of the world will beg us to devalue the dollar because they will need it even more than we do.
And listen, Trump is a very, very big part of all of this. Now, Trump hates that we have this strong dollar, and he's come out several times and said he wants a weaker dollar. But why does Trump want a weaker dollar? Trump wants a weaker dollar because he wants the stock market to go higher.
Well, if the stock market is going higher, I think his concern about the dollar goes to the back burner, and he's more worried about other things and worried about other fires that he's got to put out. And if we get back into a situation where the dollar's going higher, it creates pressure on other economies, the capital flows from those other economies into the US, and the US stock market goes higher, that perhaps keeps Trump happy. Now, maybe happy is not the right word. I don't think that guy's ever happy.
But maybe that keeps him from continually jawboning down the dollar. But I do think that as we go along this road, there are going to be attempts to counteract the dollar.
This is not going to be a smooth ride from $1.98 to $1.50. It will be extremely scary. It will be extremely volatile. I think there'll be periods where the dollar really spikes, and it will pull back hard. And it'll spike again and it'll pull back hard. Think, let's go back 10 years to 2008. You make the comment that the world just doesn't work with the dollar going to 120, 130, 140. Well, the world didn't really work with the Dow going from 18,000 to 6,000 either, but it happened anyway. If you look through the summer of 2008 and into the fall of 2008 and into the spring of 2009, the markets would go down. The monetary authorities, the central bankers, the governments would come out and they would institute policies. They would ban short selling. They would do some stimulus plans.
They would cut rates, and the markets would rally a little bit. And then pretty soon, you're back to reality, and the markets would crash again. And they'd come out, they'd say something else, or they'd institute some other policy, and markets would bounce a little bit, and then back to reality, and it goes down again. So, I do think, to your point, there will be cops that will approach the bridge and tell people, don't drive off the bridge.
But then I don't know that those cops are going to be able to stop it, to be honest, until they— put up road barriers and completely shut the whole thing down.
So, I mentioned to somebody before that my theory is not called the Glass of Milk Theory. It's called the Milkshake Theory. And there's going to be a lot of shaking going on. And even if I'm right, Erik, even if I get this right, there are going to be moments of pure terror for me along the way, and everybody else. This is not a nice, smooth ride to the endgame.
Listen, this is going to be crazy. I guess that's the best way I can say it. To think it's going to be anything other than crazy, I think, is naive. Even if I get part of it right and I'm able to make money on it, it doesn't mean that it's going to come without some real white-knuckling along the way.
Erik Townsend: Now, I want to ask you how in the long term your theories eventually meld together with others, because a lot of our listeners are familiar with Luke Gromen's views. And at first glance, it would seem that you and Luke are just polar opposites who see the world in a completely different way and just can't agree, because Luke has been hugely dollar bearish. And he is, I think, right now tactically still long the dollar, but he's waiting for it to reverse. He thinks it's imminently upon us, and he thinks that the road is much, much lower.
Brent Johnson: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: So, I think most people, casual observers, would assume you guys never see eye to eye. Personally, the way I see it is I am absolutely convinced that Luke is going to be proven right. I just think you're going to be proven right first. And I think Luke has the story exactly right. He's just early. But I want to know what you think about that. Luke's view is basically that the US dollar is going to lose its hegemony over the global financial system. Probably lose its reserve currency status and fade into the sunset, very similar to the way the pound sterling, which used to be the world's global reserve currency— currency never went away. We've still got the British pound, but it is nowhere close to the importance that it used to have in the global financial system, and it devalued a long way along the way.
Do you think that Luke's got that wrong, or do you think he's just way early to
Brent Johnson: So I think a couple of things, and I say this every time I get this question. I like Luke. I actually consider him a friend. If I bumped into him in the airport and we had to sit there and hang out for 2 hours before we each caught our flights, I would enjoy that 2 hours. So I don't have a problem with Luke's criticism of my theories or our debates or however you want to define that. I think it's actually maybe perhaps a mutually beneficial thing because there's times I probably make him think about things he hadn't thought of and vice versa. He definitely makes me think about things that I haven't thought of. I think you're largely correct on how to define our views. I think he is really early, but I do think ultimately, a lot of the things that he is talking about will come to pass.
Part of the reason that I perhaps come back against him as strongly as I do is that I actually manage money for individuals. And so, when I'm investing and we're going over, I'm sitting there looking the person in the eye, talking to them about how their results have gone and how this is personally going to affect them. And that's a little different than managing money institutions, where you never actually see the people that it affects. And it's a little different than writing research, where you're not actually placing money in the market.
And my experience has been that everybody says they're a long-term investor, and they're in it for the long term until it goes against them. There's that famous saying that everybody has— Mike Tyson said, everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth. mouth. And I think there's real truth to that. Now, I guess the reason I bring that up is if you are seeing what Luke is talking about, and you are placing your assets for 5 to 10 years down the road, and you don't mind, and you have to be really honest with yourself here, you don't mind getting punched in the mouth really hard over the next couple of years, then sure, then you place your assets for the dollar getting weaker, because 5 or 10 years from now, it will be a lot weaker.
I I think, but I think it's very possible in the next, call it 2 years, the dollar just pummels everybody. And I don't know a lot of people who can withstand the pummeling. They say they can, but when they start getting hit, they want to get out. And so not only that, but I think there is a great, great number of incredible opportunities to play the move in the dollar over the next couple of years.
And I just want people to know that even though Luke might be right in the long term, it's possible that he's wrong in the short term, and that it's possible that I'm right in the short term. And I want people to go in with eyes open and understand that the move before the dollar going to zero could very well be going back to all-time highs. And I would hate for them to get shook out of their long-term trades if they weren't prepared for that.
Erik Townsend: Brent, you said earlier that there's a possibility that foreign capital flows could drive equity markets much higher. Now, we talked about that in terms of how it is plausible for the mechanism to operate in the current environment where we're seeing what to me are a lot of recession signals and bearish stock signals.
Is that mechanism Is optimism strong enough to overcome the bearish factors, or is it maybe a setup that we're going to see a bear market that I think is coming, that maybe still it's a short-lived cyclical bear market and there's still another wave higher? Or is it really that you think stocks are headed higher from here right now?
Brent Johnson: So, you know, last fall in Q4 and specifically very end of December, I was pretty aggressively buying equities, and that turned out— we were fortunate that that was the right call, and we had a very good first call it 4 months of the year. And just as being prudent, we took down exposure a little bit and bought some puts in early May, which has really helped us out. I just think that the next 3 or 4 months are pretty uncertain. Let us just say it that way. And I think prudence says to just be careful for the next 2 or 3 months until we get some more visibility on what is actually going to happen.
I think that the dollar The dollar breaking out is, I think, going to be the key to the US market maybe moving higher, the US equities moving higher when that starts to cause problems abroad.
I actually think the dollar is going to break out later in the fall, but it could be as soon as next month. There's a couple of things that I'm looking at that tells me that we're not going to have to wait another year to see what the dollar does. Because we were fortunate to have a good first part of the year, we had the luxury of being a little careful over the next 3 or 4 months. And so, we're going to be careful.
And listen, I should always caveat this, my mind can change later today based on what I see. But as of right now, I think it's probably likely that equities consolidate, maybe go up and down over the next 2 or 3 months. Perhaps we have a volatile summer while we're trying to figure out which way to go. But ultimately, just to be clear, I ultimately do think that we are going to see higher highs before we see significantly lower lows in equities.
Erik Townsend: I want to come to a very similar question, but let's go back to gold now. You and I, I think, both agree here as we're speaking Wednesday morning, we're flirting with that $1,350 level. So far it's been rejected pretty aggressively, but of course anything is possible. Let's suppose, Brent, going back to your statement that your mind can change very quickly, let's suppose that by the time our listeners hear this interview about 36 hours from now on Thursday evening, that we have seen a breakout in gold and we've got a daily close over $1,400.
At that point, is it time to just throw in the towel and say, oh, okay, we got the gold call wrong? It turns out that the move is on to the upside, and it seems like dollar and gold are going to move up together, and, you know, it's time to roll with it and increase your gold holdings.
Or is that a signal that, okay, it's gotten ahead of itself and it's about to reverse maybe as the dollar comes off of a low?
Brent Johnson: So, you know, it's a very good question because I'm sure there's a lot of people out there who are kind of wondering this exact thing right now. I would be very, very, very careful chasing it at 1,400 right now. If we're at 1,400 by the end of the week, you know, that would be a pretty strong sign that we're looking at a breakout, right? But even if we have a breakout, I think we'll probably come back and test the $1,360, $1,375 area before then moving back above $1,400 again and up to $1,500 or whatever it is.
I've seen too many times people buy these breakouts, quote unquote, only to see gold pull back $50, $60 in a very short period of time. I think it's worth remembering, I would suggest that investors do this or listeners do this, go back and look at a chart of gold last year versus this year, year to date.
Now, they're not exact, but they are very similar. In 2018, we had a big run-up in the spring. We had a pullback into May. Gold then popped back to like $1,315 or $1,320 right ahead of the Fed meeting in June. And by the end of June, we were at $1,250. So, it's not exactly like that this year, but it's pretty similar.
I mean, you just don't know where we're going to go. This is part of the reason why for last 6 or 7 years, I've been encouraging people to just buy some gold and forget about it. Now, I don't think it's going to pay off yet, but I think you should own it. Hopefully, people listening already have some gold in their portfolio. If you already have some gold in your portfolio, you don't have to chase it here.
If it goes to $1,400, be patient. When it pulls back to $1,370 or something like that, then maybe start adding. But I wouldn't be buying— if I wake up tomorrow morning and gold's at $1,400, I'm not going to be adding until at least the end of the month. I would wait and kind of see where we're at 2 or 3 weeks from now.
Erik Townsend: Brent, earlier in this interview you mentioned that you're in the process of launching a special purpose fund to pursue the opportunities that you see relative to the dollar index. Now, just to explain to our listeners, because that fund is only available to accredited investors, Brent is not really at liberty to make any specific representations about it, the investment strategy.
And so But what I do want to ask, Brent, is just what is the approximate timing? And for the accredited investors who are qualified to invest and learn more about that, how should they contact you in order to find out more about what you're up to?
Brent Johnson: Yeah, I think it's important to start off and say, listen, this isn't something for everybody. We designed this— I'm partnering with Keith Dicker of IceCap Asset Management to launch this vehicle, and we're doing it because we both have very similar businesses where we manage money for high net worth individuals.
We see the dollar getting stronger as the biggest single factor influencing global markets over the next 2 or 3 years. And it has the potential to impact markets extremely negatively, especially for investors outside the United States. And so, it's very difficult to protect against these types of moves in separately managed accounts for individuals. We wanted to have a vehicle through which we could could put some of our clients' capital in there to help protect against the potentially negative effects of a stronger dollar, but then also capitalize on what we see as incredible opportunities as the dollar does get stronger. It's not for everybody, but we think it plays an extremely important part of an overall diversified portfolio.
And if somebody wants to learn more about it, I'm available at brent@santiagocapital.com. Happy to discuss in more detail.
Erik Townsend: Well, Brent, it's great to finally get you on the show for a full-length feature interview. Look forward to having you back, and in the meantime, we're gonna have you every few weeks on MacroVoices All-Stars to get an update on some of these views. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to finally have Brent on for a full feature interview. We had so much fun with him out in the MacroVoices live event in Vancouver, and he certainly has been a contributor to your All-Stars. So it was great to have him. You know, the one thing that I took away from that interview was when you and Brent started talking about food inflation and what's happened happening obviously out in the farms in the Midwest and the flooding. And it really made my hamster wheel turn because when we had strategists like John Greenwood come on, a lot of their theories around inflation is very much linking it to money supply. And whenever there's these big surges in money supply, that inevitably leads to inflation and it needs to be fought with higher interest rates. But when you have food inflation impacting the CPI and you have basically farm goods and things like this rising in their price and it's causing the CPI to rise, is the raising interest rates or the interest rates rising to fight that the solution?
I mean, in my mind, these farmers are heavily indebted and on the verge of bankruptcy in many cases and tightening up credit conditions and making it more expensive for them to access capital would only bankrupt more farmers. I would think the solution to actually lowering those inflationary pressures is by making the capital more available to them at much cheaper prices and providing subsidies or other things to those farmers. So I'm thinking that this type of inflation, is this one that would lead to a monetary policy response if the primary input is food?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, of course, the BLS excludes food and energy prices from core CPI. So, you know, in terms of what would drive a monetary policy I don't think food prices drive it, but it's another indication of a systemic problem that we have, which is things that you absolutely must have to survive, like food, the prices is going up. And it's not a matter of too much money recklessly chasing, you know, not enough goods and services. It's a matter of the food that we need to feed ourselves costing more and more. So I don't think that's a monetary That's a monetary policy issue. But in any case, the reaction that I had, the strongest reaction to Brent's interview, is it's
Erik Townsend: really fascinating to me to hear someone who has an out-of-consensus view, as Brent has, about the stock market. Because, you know, frankly, as much as I've heard plenty of people just tell me that everything's rosy and nothing is wrong, and because the US economy is wonderful, the stock market's going to go up.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: go up. I just don't buy that. And I think bears like me really need to check ourselves with people like Brent who are saying, wait a minute, what if everything is not rosy and it's not good, but things are worse in Europe to the point where people whose safety trade was historically into their own sovereign bonds don't want to buy sovereign bonds issued by a country that's part of a monetary union That might be falling apart and which are already negative yielding. And so the US stock market becomes the safety trade because the appreciating dollar delivers so much carry. That's the kind of scenario that stock market bears need to think really carefully about and consider. Okay, what are the things that could really foul up a view that is economically driven on fundamentals that yields a bearish view about the stock market?
market. So I found that aspect of Brent's interview most interesting.
Patrick Ceresna: So moving on, we have Adam Collins joining us from Movement Capital, and he's also the creator of the website FreeCOTdata.com. And we wanted to bring him on to the show to talk about Commitment of Traders reports. So welcome, Adam.
Adam Collins: Hey everybody, happy to be here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, so Adam, let's— for the benefit of our listeners that do not understand Commitment of Traders or what it is, why don't we take an opportunity just to explain to them what the Commitment of Traders reports are?
Adam Collins: Yeah, for sure. So the COT report basically shows how different types of traders are positioned in the futures markets.
Patrick Ceresna: And there's different classifications, right? There's the speculators or small traders, and then there's the hedgers and the larger speculators. Is that correct?
Adam Collins: Yeah. But before we get to the different trader categories, One thing to understand is there's actually, there's like 4 different types of COT reports. The main one to sort of figure out in the front end is whether you're using what's called the legacy report, which has been out since like 1986, and then the newer disaggregated report. The main difference is that the legacy report has a fewer number of categories, so it's a little more opaque in like who the people actually are. And then the disaggregated report, it just splits it up into more granular categories, So first, it's like figure out if you're looking at legacy or disaggregated. And then the second decision is whether you're looking at the COT report that just looks at futures positioning or looks at positioning on both futures and options on futures. So personally, I use the disaggregated report.
It's got a bunch of different categories. And then the futures and options report to sort of have the most comprehensive view of positioning.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay. So now just for our listeners, I didn't mention it earlier, but Adam put together a great chart book for us. So we can look at these different Commitment of Trader reports. So let's take a dive into it. Uh, where do you want to start off and taking a look at this?
Adam Collins: So we've sort of gotten the, the intro stuff out of the way. We can look at slide 6 where I sort of break down all these different trader categories that you mentioned. And it's important to note that the categories are different based on the contract type. So for example, if it's a commodity contract like corn, that has different positioning categories than a financial contract like the Swiss franc or something. So for example, in commodities, these are the main trader categories. We've got producers and merchants who are sort of like the commercial producers and users of that commodity. We've got swap dealers who use futures to hedge price risk related to swaps. We've got money managers, which is the biggest speculative category, and that includes registered CTAs, CPOs, or other fund-like entities. Then we've got other reportables who are basically not registered funds, but they are big traders trading above a contract's reporting limit, and that sort of depends on the contract. And then the last category in commodities are non-reportables.
So these are typically called small traders who are trading below the reporting limit.
Now to get into the different categories for financials, these are the main ones. We've got dealers, which are analogous to hedgers in commodity, but in financial contracts, dealers, think of them like sell-side companies who use futures to sort of hedge the price risk they sort of carry when they sell products to end users. It's the same end goal, which is the reason why they're transacting in futures markets isn't to speculate, but more so to offset price risk. Then when we turn to the speculative categories in financials, we've got asset managers, leveraged funds, and other reportables. That's sort of an overview of the different types of categories.
Erik Townsend: Adam, I use the Commitment of Traders reports myself, and like most government data, it's not exactly optimal. What is wrong with the way that the government organizes it and what opportunity is there to improve on it?
Adam Collins: Yeah. So I think the COT report in its raw form, it's released weekly and it just shows spot net positioning. You definitely got to give it some context. So one of the first things I do is rather than just look at net positioning, like let's say hedge funds are net long 20,000 contracts or commercials are net short It's important to take that net figure and divide it by a contract's open interest, because the truth of it is a lot of these contracts have significantly fluctuating open interest figures. So they get sort of ebb and flow in their popularity. One of the biggest examples of this over the past few years has been VIX futures. So VIX futures, 10 years ago, relatively small market, low open interest. Now, much more frequently traded, right? And so if you're just looking at net positioning The current net positioning will look drastically more extreme than it actually is if you don't take that net number and divide it by the size of the market.
And so that's where the first thing I like to do is to scale the data by open interest. Then the second thing I like to do to make COT actionable is you've got to normalize net positioning across contracts. So for example, let's say somebody comes to you and says, All right, traders are net long 40% of the interest in platinum. You don't know if that's historically extreme or not, right? There's no historical context for it.
People solve this 2 ways. Some people create percentiles, some people create a z-score. I personally use a percentile. I think they're both valid. The whole point of this is to transform that current reading and to show you whether it's high or low relative to the past few years. For example, So for example, if you make a 5-year percentile, it will read 100% if a trader category has its highest positioning over the past 5 years. And the main benefit of normalizing the data across contracts is it allows you to, at a glance, know if a trader category is super long or super short, just because everything is sort of rebased to between 100 and 0 with the percentile. So in summary, summary, it's important to scale the data based on open interest and then also normalize the data so you can sort of compare it across contracts.
Patrick Ceresna: So Adam, going into that, obviously there's some traders that just love to trade around these COT reports, but you think there's some pitfalls in this. What's the major pitfalls of reading too much into these positions?
Adam Collins: Yeah, 100%. So for people looking at the chartbook, this starts with slide 14, and I think the biggest pitfall is just reading too much into the data. The truth about positioning is that more often than not, it's not extreme. And so therefore, you shouldn't sort of pay attention to positioning if we're, you know, right in the middle of where traders have been positioned over the past 5 years. So there's, there's no signal there. It's a bunch of noise. So to me, you know, first pitfall is at any given time, there's likely only a handful of contracts where you can truly call it extreme
The second pitfall on slide 15 is sort of this knee-jerk reaction to wanting to fade extreme spec positioning. And I understand why people want to do this because, you know, let's say you see a chart going around, you see, oh, you know, speculators are all on one side of the trade and everybody wants to be the contrarian and deflator, right? But the truth of it is you, you have to sort of gut-check it against price action. So let's say we've got a contract of where where speculators are all long. Let's say the percentile's maxed out, they're carrying a very big long position.
But if it's a scenario where price action is only helping them, and let's say everybody's long and price continues to rip higher, they don't have an incentive to liquidate that position, right? They haven't been put under pressure. So to me, it's not enough to have extreme positioning. That can sort of exist by itself, but it does get more actionable when you sort of combine extreme positioning with price action that is hurting the majority. Think of it like, you know, the common analogy for crowded trades is like people yelling fire in a crowded theater. Somebody yelling fire is equivalent to price action going the opposite way of how everybody is positioned. So I think that's sort of a pitfall, is just analyzing positioning in isolation and not asking yourself, okay, is price action helping them or is it hurting Or is it hurting them? And if it's hurting them, that's where positioning can actually lead to a move. And then let's see, on slide 16, another pitfall, I sort of call it market relevance, but all it means is this, is that this COT report, it's looking at all these different asset classes, right?
We're looking at stocks, bonds, FX, commodities. And the reality is that commodities are really only— they're the only asset class where futures is the primary market. So So when it comes to all the other financial contracts, futures are— that's not the main destination, right? If you're looking at a COT report on a foreign currency pair, you're completely ignoring the spot FX market. And to me, while futures positioning is typically representative of broad market positioning, you just have to take it with a grain of salt because you're just observing a small slice of the overall market.
Erik Townsend: Adam, you've done some fantastic work on your website addressing— obviously, we can't address the pitfalls that have to do with traders' human behavior, but the part about the government not really presenting the data with the context that's needed to interpret, you've really worked some wonders on it. Tell us a little bit about what you've done and maybe show us some examples of how those data are presented from some screenshots from your website.
Adam Collins: Yeah, for sure. So the whole point of the website Is to give context. And rather than focusing on a snapshot of current positioning, to show you with graphs of whether that current positioning is truly extreme or not. So the main indicator on the website, it's got all these different contracts, but what I basically show a lot of is that 5-year percentile metric, which is normalizing across all these different contracts, whether current positioning right now is actually historically extreme or not. And so that's That's what you're mainly going to find on the website are graphs of 5-year percentile. So you can see at a glance where extreme positioning is. But in the chartbook, I've sort of pulled out some contracts where position actually truly is extreme right now. So for people turning to it on slide 17, one that stands out is definitely silver. And so in this chart, remember I'm showing not just speculators, but also producers and users too.
But you can see that traders haven't been They haven't been this bearish on silver in a very long time. And in fact, on slide 18, I don't just show the 5-year percentile, I convert positioning into a dollar figure. And so right now, traders are net short silver futures, which is a really, really rare thing. In fact, it happened in summer 2018, but outside of summer 2018, it's basically never happened in silver futures over the past decade or so. And so One thing that stands out is you could definitely label trader sentiment in silver as bearish because they're definitely positioned that way.
Another one that stands out, or 2 others very quickly, are cotton and sugar. Similar story. These are both very crowded net short trades. Cotton and sugar, and honestly, a lot of soft commodities have fallen in that basket over the past few months. And that's why I think it's super important to To not just see something like, oh, all these traders are short sugar and cotton and want to go out and go long. You have to contrast it with, okay, are these commodities in steady downtrends or are we at an inflection point of where they're ripping and everybody's still on the wrong side?
Another current graph would be on slide 21, another commodity. It's WTI crude oil. We can see how there's definitely a very tight relationship between price action and position. We've seen it in WTI over the past few weeks. As we've corrected lower, speculators have pulled long exposure. In this graph, it's also another dollar-based graph. So you can see how back late 2017, early 2018, that's when sort of spec positioning got at its most net long. It sort of eclipsed net long $50 billion in futures and options. And now we're definitely a lot lower. Collectively, they're net long around like $27 billion. And some other contracts we can quickly run through. So I've sort of talked about commodities. And with the COT report, I definitely think you should lean toward giving it more importance in commodities because that's the primary market futures are.
Adam Collins: But we can touch on some financial stuff. So first off, in slide 22, we've got the Swiss franc.
So basically, there's 2 currencies that are crowded net shorts against the USD. First one is the Swiss franc. The second one is the New Zealand dollar. Similar story in both. Traders are just very, very short.
Brent Johnson: Yeah.
Adam Collins: short those 2 currencies against the USD. And then on slide 24, I turned to positioning in stocks. And so this chart, it's sort of an aggregation of multiple contracts. So we're looking at how traders are positioned in both the E-mini S&P, the E-mini NASDAQ, and then the mini Dow contract. And this is sort of a nuts chart. Patrick and I, we talked about this on Market Huddle a couple weeks ago, but you can sort of how trader sentiment has changed and has drastically changed when it comes to equity futures over the past 3 years. So at the start of 2016, traders were extremely pessimistic. In fact, they actually got net short equity futures, which is something they did not do in 2008.
So, you know, as the market turned in Feb 2016, they were very slow to sort of like, you know, pile on back to the long side as the market went higher. But then once they did, they did it very quickly. And basically it peaked at— it was in late January 2018 when the net spec position eclipsed— it was like net long $120 billion, which was an all-time high. That was at that point in time, traders had never been that net long more US equity futures. But they definitely got spooked after both February and Q4 last year.
And although I know we're roughly Roughly 5%, 6% from all-time highs, trader positioning has come back a lot. The net spec position has come back from $120, $130 billion to being about net long $50 billion now. And so that's sort of a snapshot of how traders are positioned in equity futures. And the last graph I've got, it's on slide 25 for people looking on the chartbook. This is sort of my dashboard graph. So this is looking at a summary of all these different commodity contracts and specific spec positioning in these contracts, right? And so you can see on the left-hand side, this is stuff where people are really bullish. On the right-hand side, these are contracts where traders are leaning more so bearish.
And what stands out is there aren't really any contracts that are crowded longs from the spec side, but like we talked about earlier, silver, cotton, and sugar definitely stand out as 3 of the most crowded shorts.
Erik Townsend: Well, Adam, thanks again for sharing this excellent presentation with us. And listeners, again, Adam's website is FreeCOTdata.com. FreeCOTdata.com. And really reorganize this Commitment of Traders information in a much more meaningful way. We're gonna have to leave it there in the interest of time for this week. I just want to remind our listeners, we sure would appreciate your help with a review on iTunes, because as we're looking for sponsorship, that's exactly what they're looking for, is who's given us those 5 5-star reviews on iTunes. So if you can help us out, we'd tremendously appreciate it. And be sure to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit is you'll receive our Research Roundup email. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. This week they're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook prepared by Adam here that we discussed in the postgame. There's also an article titled The Fed Has No Choice But to return to ultra-low interest rates, as well as Harley Bassman, Convexity Maven, and piece that is titled "Can You Hear Me Knocking?" So you'll find this and so much more in this week's research roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like. If you have a great idea for a Research Roundup and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend From myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's Premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week.
You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Lakshman Achuthan — Economic Cycle Research Institute co-founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 169 was recorded on May 30th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Economic Cycle Research Institute co-founder Lakshman Achuthan joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll explore the differences between business cycles, credit cycles, and inflation cycles, and Lak will explain why he disagrees with those who are saying that all of the signs of an ending business cycle are present.
We're getting rave reviews on our new expanded content, and we plan to keep giving you new content each trading day. The 4th episode of Energy Week aired yesterday with Chris Cook, Ole Hansen, and Pat Hemsworth on the panel, and we also aired All-Stars appearances featuring Dr. Pippa Malmgren and Luke Gromen. Danielle DiMartino Booth's All-Star interview airs Friday morning, so be sure to follow your MacroVoices feed or go to MacroVoices.com and enjoy all of the exciting new free content on the feed. And be sure to stay tuned for today's postgame segment after the feature interview. Patrick has pulled together another one of his excellent chartbooks. We're going to be looking at equities, bonds, and the whole macro picture in a little bit more detail because needless to say, it's been a heck of a time in markets.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 can't seem to have any rally stick. Once again, from yesterday to today, the S&P tried to bounce off those lows and it seems like it's rolling right over. What's your feeling here? On the S&P?
Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, I read an interesting commentary this week that I don't completely agree with, but I think it's really good for establishing the concept here, which is what this particular writer said is, look, this is a kabuki theater about the trade deal thing. They're eventually going to come up with a deal, but it's probably going to take longer than most market participants are expecting. And by the time that a trade deal comes together, it's gonna be really clear that this economy is headed down for other reasons and the market is gonna keep going down regardless of a trade deal.
Now, I don't agree with that. I see it differently because frankly, I don't think we can tell what the timing is of the trade deal. And I think that if a sudden rabbit out of a hat, Xi and Trump sat down, worked things out, and we've got a solid deal tomorrow morning, I wouldn't be the slightest bit surprised if that took the S&P to new all-time highs. Temporarily. I emphasize temporarily. But I do agree with this writer that before too many months go by, we're definitely headed lower. I frankly hope that we get new all-time highs. I'm really, really hoping for that because I would love to short them.
This is a very difficult market, Patrick. I do think that we have begun a cyclical bear market. I think that the top is probably in. But, you know, you look at the news flow and so many moving parts. If you get the right combination of news events, we could get— A big move. another big push up to an all-time high before the reality eventually takes over and we move lower. So I don't think you want to be putting new shorts on down here at these numbers because of the risk of vicious rallies. I'm actually looking at long positions on 2-year Treasuries as a smarter way to play a bearish view on this equity market.
Now I've got to assume your straddle trade that your Big Picture Trading members are in has got to be very profitable by now. Have you guys taken profits? What are you doing?
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, we're still in the trade and short the markets, and we're looking for obviously a window from which to monetize that, but we're still riding that in there. Anyway though, Erik, how about that US dollar though? It keeps edging to the top end of that range, just toying with the breakout, but can't seem to break to a fresh new 52-week high. Is it going to happen this time around?
Erik Townsend: Well, we did finally get a daily close over 98 yesterday. I think that was the first for this contract. And, you know, as I As I've said many times, it's puzzling to me that as we hit what I thought would be technical levels that would really trigger more buying and you'd see an acceleration, a good old-fashioned breakout, we haven't seen that breakout. But if I look at this chart, it's a steady grind higher and it looks like it's set to continue. I'm a little surprised it isn't accelerating to the upside. That is reason to kind of recheck my thinking. But frankly, as I look at the many smart people who think the dollar is topping here and about to crash. I just don't see that argument. I'm still in the Jeff Snider and Brent Johnson camp that I think a dollar liquidity squeeze globally is going to take the dollar higher against other currencies, especially the euro.
The only part that surprises me is that we haven't seen that move accelerate.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because it looked like for a few days that we were stabilizing. But this morning, the selling came in hard, breaking a fresh new low for the last week anyway. What's your thinking here on crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, boy, what a rollercoaster ride. You know, we, we had a new panelist, Ole Hansen, who runs the commodities desk at Saxo Bank in Copenhagen, was on the panel for Energy Week, which is on your MacroVoices feed, folks. If you didn't listen already, it was published yesterday. My first question to Ole was, why don't you just give us the quick rundown of what has happened since last Wednesday in the market? He went on for about 5 minutes, and he wasn't rambling. There was that much stuff to talk about between inventory and China trade flow. Flooding in Cushing, Oklahoma, pipeline outages, trade wars. I mean, it's just everything.
We did a really thorough coverage of market direction and everything else in yesterday's Energy Week, which is on your MacroVoices feed.
So I'm going to focus on the things that have happened since then. There's actually a fair amount of that to talk about because inventory was delayed by a day this week due to the US holiday Memorial Day on Monday. So our inventory numbers were not available when we Publish the Energy Week podcast. So on Wednesday afternoon, which is virtual Tuesday in a holiday week, API, the private service, reported a 5.2 million barrel drawdown. That's a super bullish signal on crude oil inventories in the United States. That plus news of a pipeline outage situation maybe being rectified that came out a little earlier in the day really sent The oil market screaming higher on Wednesday afternoon because, hey, you know, 5.2 million barrel drawdown, that's a really big deal.
Well, I guess the market forgot it was API who said that, and API is not all that accurate. We got the real numbers from EIA this morning, a de minimis 282,000 barrel drawdown, smaller than expectations. And needless to say, that was a very bearish signal. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down a de minimis 16,000 barrels. So effectively flat in Cushing. The big news was gas Gasoline building 2.2 million barrels at the beginning of summer driving season. Distillates drawing down 1.6 million barrels. That's a little bit of a smaller drawdown than what API had anticipated, a 2.1 million barrel drawdown. Needless to say, the tape action was down and it was down hard, with RBOB gasoline being hit the hardest because that's where the big inventory build occurred. We took out yesterday's lows, and Patrick, I'm absolutely convinced that we have begun a very significant downside price cycle.
And I think this trend is going to continue. The thing is, there's just so many moving parts and so many reasons to be wary of vicious rallies along the way.
Let's finish the inventory numbers, though. US production ticking back up to 12.3 million barrels. That's an all-time high that was set just a few weeks ago. We've just come back up to it after the last couple of weeks, just ticking down a little bit. To me, this is very, very significant because there were people saying, okay, We saw that tick off of 12.3 down to 12.2 down to 12.1. It can only mean one thing, which is that the fall-off in rig count is now translating to US production's about to fall off a cliff. The sky is falling, the world's coming to an end, oil prices are moving higher. Well, guess what? That's not happening. We're back up to that all-time high, and I won't be surprised if we move even higher. Imports, 6.8 million barrels, very small change from last week. Exports, though, up to 3.3 million barrels per day. So that means on the week, 23.2 23 million barrels of US oil exported last week.
And despite exporting those 23 million barrels, we still ended up with a drawdown on inventory of about a quarter million barrels, 282,000 barrels.
Very, very clear to me that a downtrend is in play, but vicious rallies possible. I'm hoping for one of those vicious rallies. I'd like to add to my short position.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold seems to, at least today, be responding half decently to the conditions in the markets. We, we're slowly edging towards $1,300, not there yet, but where do you think gold's going here?
Erik Townsend: You know, not too far is, I guess, my most immediate reaction to that. Yes, the bullish argument is that we have moved decisively now above a downsloping trendline that had been capping the market going all the way back to February. We've very clearly broken out above that trendline. That's your bullish argument. Frankly, that's the only bullish argument that I can come up with. But Patrick, look at what's happening in the world between the The threat of a military conflict with Iran, the trade wars, and everything else. It would be next to impossible for gold not to catch some kind of a bid under these conditions. Yet even under these conditions, we can't even seem to get back over $1,300. So what's going to happen to gold when the dollar continues to appreciate and maybe this trade war debacle turns out to not be as bad as everybody is afraid? Maybe even a deal comes together. What's going to happen to gold then?
I think the answer is much lower. Until Until then, I think the only really strong argument for why you might consider new long positions in gold here is if you disagree with me about the US dollar.
If you're in the camp of someone like Simon White from Variant Perception, who we interviewed recently, who thinks the dollar is topping here, okay, well then maybe gold is bottoming and this is your chance. And we are seeing that trendline breakout, and that's your signal to go ahead and go long. I don't see it that way, and I think unless you are bearish the US dollar, it's hard for me to construct a bullish gold argument here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that 10-year Treasury yield because we're under 2.25%. I mean, these yields continue to decline at an accelerating pace as the bond market is definitely sending signals right across the board. What's your take on this drop in yields?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I haven't checked my screen in over an hour. Is it sub-2% yet? That's the way this week has felt. Actually, I do have the screen right in front of me at 2.25%. 4 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon. Patrick, it's very clear that what we've predicted on this program— remember several weeks ago when we hit 2.60 on that hawkish Fed surprise? I said, folks, this is your buy-the-dip opportunity right here, right now for long bonds. Well, it was the right buy-the-dip opportunity. That trade has been fantastically profitable. But, you know, it's gone farther, faster than I thought it was going to go. And it feels to me like the prudent move here is not to be adding new longs, but to take profits on this really big move that has happened so quickly. I'm curious though, I'm pretty sure if I remember from listening in on one of your Big Picture Trading member webinars that you run, you guys were also long the 10-year.
Are you guys still in that trade or did you take profits already?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, we were long the 10-year and the 30-year, or at least with the TLT, the long bond. But yeah, we are doing some profit taking here on it right across the board, or doing some risk reversal hedge wraps on them. I think the move has gone just a little too far too fast, and it's a good time to lock in a little bit. But we'll see. It's a move— still has a lot of velocity, right?
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, let's move on. But, uh, before we do go on to the feature interview, give us a quick update on your efforts to secure sponsorship for the, uh, new programming so that we can keep it free for our listeners.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, we're making fantastic progress, but we still need our listeners' help. Just to be clear about specifically what we need, it's for people who work in companies that would make good sponsors for MacroVoices and who are willing to advocate for us within your organization. Please contact me. We already have 3 different listeners making the case on our behalf to their marketing departments, and we're beginning to make some progress and starting to get into some negotiations that may lead to sponsorship. But we need more people doing Doing exactly the same thing. I just got an email this morning from one gentleman. So if you're able to help us in that way, it is the best thing that you can possibly do to help us keep MacroVoices free for everyone indefinitely. Meanwhile, I cannot thank the people who have donated enough.
We're going to bring you a brand new show called Inside the Investment Committee next week, featuring hedge fund manager Alex Gurevich and institutional advisors Juliette Declercq and Julian Brigden.
Announcer: Hi, everyone.
Erik Townsend: The concept is to take you, the listener, inside the investment committee so you can hear the interaction when an institutional advisor pitches a trade idea to a fund manager, and then they discuss how to put the trade on and what the risks are and under what conditions they should abort and exit the trade, and so on and so forth.
The original plan was to wait until we had some kind of sponsorship revenue before introducing any more new content. So I want to let the people who made all of those $100+ donations in the last 2 weeks know, The direct result of your donations is that we have accelerated the pace of introducing this new content. So on behalf of all of our listeners who are going to enjoy that show next week, thank you for your donations. They directly enabled our acceleration of this process of introducing more and more free content for everyone's enjoyment. And I really look forward to the help of our other listeners so that we're not going to have to keep asking for your donations. For the moment, though, please keep those donations coming. They make all the difference in the world, and for the moment, they are our sole source of income to cover our production expenses until we do secure formal sponsorship.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, well, thanks for the update, Erik. So this week's featured interview guest is ECRI co-founder Lakshman Achuthan. Erik, why did we choose Lak to come onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, as our longtime listeners know, we've been struggling with this problem, which is normally we don't source our guests with any specific view. And recently, we just had a rash of, you know, everybody's They're very bearish. They see late-cycle dynamics. And we've been looking now for somebody who's got the other side of the argument. And we've already done one interview like that last week. What Lak has done for his entire career is intentionally ignore all of the fundamentals and all the usual technicals and just focus on the cycles, looking at the cycle dynamics, timing of cycles, and so forth.
So I thought, okay, if the common thread that we're hearing from all of these equity bears is they're saying late-cycle dynamics, late-cycle dynamics. Why don't we get a cycles guy to tell us whether or not we really are seeing late-cycle dynamics, if that jibes with his research or not? And sure enough, it turns out that does not jibe with Lakshman Achuthan's view. I don't want to steal his thunder, so I'll let him explain that in the interview.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, Erik's interview with Lakshman Achuthan is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now on the program is Lakshman Achuthan, co-founder of the Economic Cycle Research Institute, or ECRI. Lakshman prepared not just one slide deck, but actually sent us 4 different slide decks, all of which are linked in your Research Roundup Roundup email, and we'll be referring to some of those throughout this interview, so I encourage you to download them. If you haven't yet registered at MacroVoices.com for your free account to receive our Research Roundup email, you can just go to the homepage at MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Lakshman's picture on the homepage.
Lak, thank you so much for joining us on the program. The reason I really have been looking forward to this particular interview is you are an analyst of cycles. You've been looking at business We've been talking about business cycles and economic cycles for as long as anybody can remember. We're suddenly seeing this phenomenon where so many of our expert guests on this program are using the same phrase, late-cycle dynamics, saying that we're very late in the current business cycle, get ready for it to end soon. And we're looking for both confirmation or opposing views.
So as a cycles guy, what do you think? Are there really justifications to say that we are late in the business cycle? And for that matter, What cycles are we talking about? Because some people talk about the business cycle, some people talk about the credit cycle. Are these the same thing, or are they different things, and what should we be looking for?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, Erik, first off, thanks a lot for having me join you today. I obviously think those are really important questions you just asked. So I'll just lead off with my quick take, which is that the concept of late cycle cycle, which is widely used. We all hear it all the time. I think it's important to understand it's based on a huge misunderstanding of what is a cycle, how does a cycle work.
Maybe looking at the past few cycles and averaging them, you think we're late in the cycle. Maybe because we're about to become, in this current expansion, the longest in US history, you think that we're late cycle. Those are examples of not a lot of analysis, I think, or understanding of what the business cycle is.
For the past few years, you've been hearing this, and I'm just gonna pick on one guy because he can afford it, Ray Dalio. No disrespect to him at all, but I've heard him also saying this. And he believes, I think, that you're in the late part of the cycle when the demand for things is kind of pressing up against the capacity to produce them, and then interest rates are gonna rise to put on the brakes And therefore, you're in the end of the cycle. But really, what's going on there, and I hope we get into this during our talk today, I think we'll try to, is a confusion between the business cycle and the inflation cycle. And these are radically different things that a lot of people conflate, including the Fed. And I think it's at the heart of this mysterious kind of where are we in the cycle.
Answering this really basic question, what is a business cycle? We actually have a slide on this in one of the slide decks that we provided. I think it's the Mauldin deck. I believe it's on slide 9. We answer this question. It was addressed by my mentor, Geoffrey H. Moore. He created the original leading indexes back in the late '50s and early '60s, 1960s. His mentor, So, now we're back pre-Depression in the '20s. His mentor was a man named Wesley Mitchell, and he defined what a business cycle is, what a recession is.
And business cycles consist of alternating periods of expansion and recession.
So, when you drill into what is a recession, we have a schematic there, it's on the slide, it's a specific sort of vicious cycle that under certain circumstances, when you have a decline in something like sales in the overall economy, that can trigger a decline in output.
You have a little less sales, you have a little less output, like GDP or industrial production, something like that, which in turn, under certain circumstances— this doesn't always happen— sets off a decline in employment, which in turn depresses income, which feeds back into a further decline in sales. And so, you have a cascading decline from sales to production to employment to income and on and on, and it starts to spread. It starts to rev in a vicious cycle, which can spread like wildfire from industry to industry and region to region.
That is what is happening when we have these recessions every once in a while. Or in this case, after 10 years or so, right? That is what's going on. And it's not 2 down quarters of GDP, and it's not simply that the Fed put on raised interest rates. It's a very specific cycle. And this is something that's not only stood the test of time in the United States for 100 years, but since the late '70s, Geoffrey Moore, who's since passed away in 2000, He began using that definition and developing cycle dates all around the world for 21 economies where we have those cycle dates. And it's a condition. It's been described as the Achilles heel of market-oriented economies.
Free market capitalism is really the best way to organize your economy. And the Achilles heel, you know, the rough spot occasionally, are these business cycle recessions.
Erik Townsend: Well, I definitely want to come back to inflation cycle versus business cycle later in this interview, but before we get there, let's just stay on this topic of, you know, we're late in the cycle. That's, that's the phrase you're hearing everywhere, and I think the primary intention of the people saying it is they're trying to communicate, okay, maybe it's not the bottom of the 9th inning, but it's at least the 8th inning. Get ready, because before too long, The economy is going to be heading into recession. That means that we're going to see a depression in Treasury yields, and probably it means that sometime, perhaps very soon if it hasn't already, the stock market is going to top and we're going to move into a cyclical bear market in stocks. All of these things are the conclusions that a lot of people would like to draw from their belief that we are quote in late cycle dynamics.
So are we really in late cycle dynamics, and do those predictions? carry any weight as far as you're concerned, based on what you're seeing in terms of how this cycle is developing?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, okay. So, from our perspective— so, again, it's a purely cyclical perspective. We're very different from other forecasters in that we are not using any econometric models to make our forecasts. We're instead using cyclical indicators to monitor where we are in the cycle, and in particular, the risk of a turn in the cycle. And we believe, I think we're on record publicly as saying this for quite some while now, that we're in the 4th growth rate cycle downturn since the Great Recession. So the last recession was '07 to '09, and we've been expanding, we've been growing Ever since, which is why we're approaching the 10-year mark in this expansion. However, that has not all been in a straight line, that growth. We have had 3 full-blown growth rate cycle downturns and then recoveries. 2010-11 was a slowdown, 2012-13 was a slowdown, and 2015-16 was a growth rate cycle slowdown.
And then we were accelerating in the second half of '16 into '17, and then we turned down again.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Lakshman Achuthan: And started decelerating in '18 into '19. And so we're in the 4th growth rate cycle downturn. Every time you go into a growth rate cycle downturn, the risk of recession starts to increase. But in order to forecast a recession, which we have not done, is what we would require is for our indicators to— our leading indicators to decline in a pronounced, pervasive, and persistent manner. In terms of pronounced and persistent, you could see the leading index itself doing that. We have a number of them which we should get into. But in terms of pervasive, they all have to be participating in the decline for it to be really objectively believable or kind of a real turn. And so, we have a so-called 3 Ps: pronounced, pervasive, and persistent decline in the growth We have an absolute full-blown growth rate cycle downturn right now going on in this US economy.
It has not turned up yet, and therefore, we're edging closer to some recession risk, but we've not made a recession call because we haven't gone to a situation where the levels in these indicators are falling in a pronounced, pervasive, and persistent way.
If and when they do, and at some point they will, If not this cycle, maybe another cycle. If and when we do have a 3 Ps downturn in the levels of these leading indicators, then what happens is— and this is how you predict a recession— a window of vulnerability opens up. It's like the economy's immune system becomes compromised, just like a person's can become compromised. And an otherwise non-recessionary shock becomes recessionary. So almost any negative shock when a window of vulnerability has opened up is a recessionary shock. And it's how you can kind of tell the difference between which shocks you have to worry about and which shocks you don't have to worry about.
Is the window of vulnerability open? And today, right now, it's not open. And we've been having our share of negative shocks. You could, you know, somebody who's Who's maybe more bearish would point around to different shocks and say these are negative. And it's not that they aren't negative, it's just that the window of vulnerability, since it's closed, makes them non-recessionary shocks for the time being.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Lak. So to summarize, just saying it's late-cycle dynamics because the usual business cycle is 4 to 7 years and we're already at 10 years, that doesn't cut it. We've got to see actual indicators that are telling us the cycle is ending. And what you're saying is that you follow a number of indicators. You've got one cyclical economic downturn, which is maybe flashing yellow but not red. What are the other indicators that you follow to tell you when a cycle is ending? How are they looking, and what are they signaling?
Lakshman Achuthan: So the idea of leading indicators, right, they start in the '50s and '60s. And as I mentioned, Geoffrey Moore, my mentor, created the original leading index, Which the Commerce Department took over. And now I think the Conference Board is attempting to update. Now, that's kind of old technology in a way.
It's over half a century old at this point. What we've learned in the interceding decades is very, very important. First, there are long-leading indicators and short-leading indicators. So you want to be looking at them in sequence. You look at long-leading for your first sign of a cycle turn, then short-leading. Okay. Then the coincident Stocks, listeners will be interested to know, are short-leading indicators. Many market prices tend to be short-leading indicators. So, looking at longer-leading indicators can be a little helpful in gauging some cyclical risk around different asset prices.
But you can also, and what we've been doing for some time now, for decades now, is looking at leading indicators for major sectors of the economy. So we're tracking leading indexes for the manufacturing sector, for the construction sector, for the services sector. Within services, financial services on their own and non-financial services. The latter is very important because that's about— that's where about 5 out of 8 Americans work, is in non-financial services.
And then using this same indicator framework, we've been developing indicators around the world. And what's very important to understand when Dr. Moore began developing international indicators in the late '70s is that he had a choice. He could either fit his leading index— and I'm doing air quotes while I talk to you on the phone— he could fit the leading index to the data that was available, Or he could say, I'm going to stick with these indicators that I've been using for the United States, which are based on theory as to why they should turn, as opposed to just data mining.
And in many cases, asked these different countries to start collecting data that we needed to develop our leading indicators. And as a result, we have leading indicators for 21 economies. Including all the BRICS. And these indicators are built the same way with the same types of inputs. So we can very honestly compare them across borders and their relative strength has meaning to one another. So it's really, you're comparing apples to apples when you look at, say, leading indexes for Europe or Asia or wherever and the United States.
And those indicators collectively— now, we've been talking about the US so far. We have a growth rate cycle slowdown. Services are always a little softer on the slowdown. They're just a little less cyclical, the amplitude. Many people might not know this, but it was only in the Great Recession that the service sector actually contracted. In all the earlier recessions, services just slowed down a lot.
They didn't contract. Right. But the larger cycles in manufacturing and construction brought the overall economy down. Now, the US has its slowdown. Europe obviously has its slowdown, and Asia too. So we had a synchronized global slowdown that's been going on. And, you know, there's maybe one or two spots that are bucking the trend, but generally, that growth rate slowdown globally is fully intact.
It's happening here in the US. There was, I think, some hope that the US had decoupled somehow from this, but that seems to have given way, and people recognize that the US growth rate cycle slowdown is also happening.
Erik Townsend: I want to come back to those international cycles in a few minutes as well, but first, let's talk about a trend which seems to be gaining a lot of popularity, not only in finance circles, but also in the the public debate in the political stage, which is people are saying, look, what's really going on here is Ben Bernanke was a genius. He figured out a way using innovative new approaches to monetary policy to tame the business cycle. We don't have to worry about business cycles anymore because the Fed has figured out by expanding its balance sheet that it can basically tame the business cycle. It can eliminate this recession risk. So we don't have to have recessions anymore. And in fact, I think in the Mauldin deck that you sent us, you quoted a fund manager saying, look, you know, recessions are a thing of the past. We don't need to worry about them anymore. And that's led on the political stage to this whole discussion of modern monetary theory suggesting that, hey, look, we don't have a big inflation risk right now.
So it's okay to monetize and to cover a lot of of government spending and entitlements and so forth, just by effectively monetizing any debt that's needed in order to fund them. So, what do you think about this? Is it possible that we've, you know, Bernanke has discovered how to tame the business cycle? We don't need to worry about it anymore?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, that would be nice. And you might guess, and the listeners might guess, that my answer is absolutely not. But this is also what you've described is not unusual. In the sense that as expansions age and get longer relative to earlier expansions, people start to think, you know, they pat themselves on the back. It's kind of an attribution bias. It's a psychological effect that's actually out there where you attribute something that you perceive as being good as your own fault.
And here, maybe policymakers or others are saying, hey, you know, we figured it out. We know how to extend the business cycle. And you're right, I did, Mention a venture capitalist who's been saying that we're not gonna have any more meaningful contractions, but we can pick on Barron's. Barron's had a cover story explaining how the very existence of the business cycle may not be relevant. That's current news, right? Current headlines.
Because maybe we can just create debt, the Fed can do things, or we can create other types of credit to boost the credit cycle, and therefore, override the business cycle and just have this continued expansion. Just so everybody understands, in the late '90s, there was the same kind of thinking. It wasn't exactly the same rationale, but with globalization and the tech boom and the supply chain management improvements, the argument was that we had arrived at the end of the business cycle. And that was just shortly after— some may remember Francis Fukuyama had declared the end of his history just about that time. So we had a lot of end of everythings, and of course, nothing ended. Life went on much the same way it did before, including cycles.
In the late '60s, which was the earlier long expansion, same kind of thing. The end of the business cycle because of Keynesian fine-tuning would repeal the cycle. Everybody remembers Irving Fisher, the Yale economics professor in '29, proclaiming the permanent plateau of prosperity just That was actually a couple of months inside the Great Depression.
The basic issue here is that this notion of creating a lot of debt to fuel growth feels good for a little while. It does. It seems to work. The combined debt of the US, Europe, Japan, and China has risen more than 10 times the rise in their combined GDP over the past year. That's a fact.
Okay? So it happened. That happened. You had a lot of debt growth and you had some GDP growth, and there was probably some connection between the two. The problem is that to do it again, you probably have to do twice as much or 3 times as much. We've called this the Red Queen effect. after Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass, where the Red Queen explains to Alice that in order to stand in place, you have to run twice as fast. And to get anywhere, you got to go 3 times, 4 times, 5 times as fast. And I think when you start talking about getting things for free, in a sense, that's what we're talking about. You have to do more and more of this debt growth In order to kind of keep the game running. And it may be that another round is possible. Who am I to say it isn't possible?
But some people might remember another book. I'm a sci-fi buff. So, Robert Heinlein's The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress introduced this idea called— this acronym called TANSTAAFL meaning there ain't no such thing as a free lunch. And He was making the point that anything that seems free costs actually twice as much in the long run or is worthless.
And that certainly is how I would kind of view this idea that you can just create more and more debt in order to subvert the business cycle. The business cycle is bigger than simply the credit cycle. As I described earlier, it's all those different elements in sales, income, employment, production. It's not just all about asset prices.
Erik Townsend: Lak, I want to come back to that in just a second, but first, you just mentioned there's no free lunch. That's a very popular expression. Another popular expression is the higher they climb, the harder they fall. Is there basis in data to believe that the longer this cycle runs, the deeper and worse the countercycle will be, or is there no correlation to evidence?
Lakshman Achuthan: That is a great question and one that I'm working on right now, to tell you the truth. And it's a nuanced answer. You know, there's no straight answer here. I'll say a few things. If you have a synchronized downturn globally, they tend to be more severe. Okay? And we don't know if the next recession is going to be a global synchronized one or not. We don't know that now today.
But if it were, that That would suggest something more severe. Another thing that can suggest a more severe recession is if you see some extreme, and they're not obvious. They're not all obvious in advance, right? But if there are some extremes in the economy or in the markets, and there's a financial crisis associated with the recession, they can be more severe. That's observational looking at history.
Now, digging into the data on length of expansion and severity of recession, it may actually be a little counterintuitive because if you've had a long expansion that has been relatively low growth, the amplitude of the cycle may end up being a little softer, which would argue for a less severe recession.
But that's a very nuanced kind of insight where you're looking at the amplitude of the growth over the course of the cycle.
Erik Townsend: I want to come back to inflation cycles in a minute because I'm personally convinced that when we get the next secular bout with inflation, it's going to cause a lot of problems. But before we even go there, let's talk— you know, so many people just interchange these terms: the business cycle, the credit cycle, the inflation cycle.
I think you've already made it clear, these are 3 separate cycles. So, what are the characteristics of these different cycles? And are there patterns, say, where, say, you know, inflation peaks first, and then the business cycle peaks, and then the credit, you know, is there a relationship? Or are there predictions that you can make by examining these 3 separate cycles independently and comparing them?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, with respect to the business cycle and inflation cycle, this was— so, after Geoffrey Moore created leading indicators half a century ago, in the '70s, right? We have this stagflation. And that really turned him on to the idea, the notion of inflation cycles as being something that are closely related to business cycles, but distinct. They're different.
And he began working on this inflation cycle idea. And determined that the inflation cycle itself actually is something quite different and is actually a bit more frequent than the business cycle. And I'll refer listeners to one of the slide decks called the ECRI Minsky deck. And there we define and show cycles in inflation and what they are and an inflation cycle chronology. Somewhat analogous to the idea of a business cycle chronology.
And what becomes immediately apparent when you're looking at those charts is that the frequency of the inflation cycle turns are many times that of business cycles. And as it turns out, they're more closely related to what we talked about earlier, growth rate cycles, the accelerations and decelerations in growth.
But this causes all kinds of havoc for economists because economists are looking at, and they've been taught to use models which are kind of rooted in these extrapolative relationships and may equate some amount of growth with some amount of inflation. But if you're looking at 2 different cycles where the turning points are quite different, you're going to get in a lot of trouble. So the same way that we had stagflation in the '70s, we had kind of the mirror image of that. We had growth without inflation in the '90s.
And this is very relevant today because people are reminiscing. In particular, when I say people, I mean Powell is reminiscing. about the mid-1990s as a way that we ought to run Fed policy. But I think he has the story wrong. You see, Dr. Moore created— first, he saw the inflation cycle, then he created leading indicators of inflation, and it's called the Future Inflation Gauge. It's a leading indicator of inflation cycle turning points. And when I say inflation cycle, it's not too mysterious.
It's accelerations and decelerations in CPI or PCE, PPI growth. So those kinds of things, and we can have a chronology based on the cyclical turning points in those things. Now, Dr. Moore also happened to have been Greenspan's professor, and Greenspan was Fed chairman in the '90s. And in the mid-'90s, there's an interesting episode that some people may remember. The Fed hiked rates in early '94 and then cut rates In '95.
And that episode is one of the only episodes of preemptive Fed monetary policy moves where they were moving ahead of actual CPI inflation as opposed to after it had moved. And it's interesting because Powell was reminiscing about this last August at Jackson Hole, talking about about how Greenspan had this hunch about productivity growth allowing inflation-free growth in the '90s. But if you actually look at the data, and all this is in that Minsky deck again, the increase in productivity growth that we saw from the mid-'90s through the recession, actually, into the 2000s, just continued. Productivity went up and it stayed up there. But for some reason, which isn't explained by this productivity miracle, The Fed hiked rates in '99, right?
And what does explain what happened there is a Future Inflation Gauge. There was a cyclical upturn in underlying inflation pressures. And that becomes, I think, very relevant today. That's all history, like, you know, storybook stuff. But I think it's important for people to know what happened in the '90s because the story that's out there is just dead wrong.
It's important today Because that same Future Inflation Gauge, which had run up in 2016 very hard, correctly calling the reflation, turned down early last year, and we recognized it as a 3 Ps downturn, a pronounced, pervasive, and persistent downturn in the summer of last year. And so, in the context of that inflation cycle downturn, you know, the September rate hike was a big question mark. The December Doubly so.
And then you see the Powell pivot. In fact, not that we would forecast a recession this way because there's not enough observations, but when we see the Fed not cut rates after the Future Inflation Gauge has made its cyclical downturn, if the Fed doesn't literally like immediately cut rates, After some period of time, there's a recession.
And so, you know, just empirically, this is not how you forecast a recession. We do not make a recession forecast this way, and I make that clear in the deck. But the Fed has already made a mistake, and that was evident since last fall by staying too tight and not cutting. And so pausing— I think, you know, this is somewhat— I'm making a little bit of a joke here, but pausing is not cutting.
And there's potentially still some damage being done to the economy with the rates where they are now. And as we said from our leading indicators, we're not forecasting a recession today. There's no window of vulnerability that's open, but the growth rate cycle downturn is continuing. And before anyone who is concerned about the amount of debt and the amount of money out there and how it may ultimately lead to inflation is offended, I'd like to point out, when I say cyclical indicators and these leading indicators, we're looking ahead a couple of quarters.
So this inflation gauge and our leading indicators, they can turn and they can turn quickly. What they're telling us right now is that inflation has been in a cyclical downturn and is going to continue to move down for the next couple of quarters. That's it. Doesn't say anything about beyond that. They could easily turn up.
Erik Townsend: Well, maybe along those lines, or to pick up on that theme of what might happen beyond that, it seems to me— and I don't know if this plays into your cycles analysis work or not— but it seems to me like there's a really long-wave cycle, and it's a cycle of public attitude about, I guess, ideology, for lack of a better word. You know, 20, 30 years ago, nobody was talking about government handouts or free college tuition or any of these things. The generally popular attitude was the government should help people by keeping taxes low.
What we're seeing now is a very significant change in public attitudes that seem to me like they may not be causing any inflation yet, but I think if we were to get to the point of so-called helicopter money, if we had free college tuition and forgiveness of student debts and some of the other things that are being promoted by some politicians. That's got to be very inflationary at some point. So, are the public attitudes that drive policy, which is either inflationary or non-inflationary policy, is that a cycle that we can follow as well?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, I think we can, we can follow it the way you described it and think about it on our, on our far radar. But to the extent that's going to show up in our leading indicators, our objective leading indicators, which look out just a couple of quarters, it'll have to seep into those underlying drivers of the inflation cycle. And so far, that's not there.
The whole MMT thing is an interesting question, right? You know, in essence, it would amount to the Treasury ramping up fiscal spending funded by issuing greater and greater amounts of debt, like that Red Queen thing I was talking about, that the Fed would then buy. And the Treasury would, I guess, in theory, the theory goes, they would raise taxes to counter inflation if and when it shows up.
Just so everybody knows, that's the general idea. Now, I think we would worry, and I think you would worry, and a lot of people would worry about the assumption that it's easy to raise taxes to head off inflation after it rises. And in fact, the very practical danger is that, and you could see it right in front of us, is that without being able to see an inflation upturn coming, inflation can surge long before the government takes any action to hike rates. You see how the fiscal side works now. It doesn't work very fast. I mean, decision-making is not pretty, right? It's not gonna— nothing would happen happen very fast. So inflation can get very high and pretty entrenched pretty quickly.
And at that point, you know, again, a kind of a rhetorical question, uh, is anybody up for— is, is there a Paul Volcker in the house, you know, or someone with guts like he had who would just walk out and engineer a recession to kill inflation? You know, I don't, I don't see any fiscal policymakers Who would be willing to do that? So that's how I would answer this. I think it's one of these kind of theory things, but in practical life, I think it could be very dangerous.
Erik Townsend: There's another aspect to this which fascinates me, which is most cycles work that I've seen over the years tends to focus on some national economy. The US economy looks like such and such, and the
Lakshman Achuthan: Right.
Erik Townsend: And the indicators suggest this and that and the other thing. But it seems to me, this is really the first time I know of in recorded monetary history where all of the central banks around the world— they're not necessarily acting in an actual coordinated policy in the sense of there being a treaty or agreement about it, but effectively, just about every central bank around the world has been easing for the last several years.
And it seems to me that that maybe has a unifying effect. effect that brings these independent cycles in different nations together into one cycle. Now, since you said earlier in this interview that when you have a downturn which is global in nature, that it tends to be worse, does that mean that by having all of these central bank policies kind of unified for the last several years that we're setting up for the entire global economy to altogether? And it sounds like that could have negative consequences if we are.
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah, it's a, that's a great question. It's one we think about. So Japan started on this road first, right? And we've given other presentations where we explain how, while we're not analogous to Japan, we're a very different economy, some of these basic ailments are common. You know, there's a demographic issue, Combined with a low productivity growth issue, which ails the US and Europe and even the developing world by and large. Maybe India has an asterisk on it, but generally speaking. So the policy response for all this has been central bank focused, and some are further along in the journey than others.
And Japan is probably in the vanguard at the moment. And what you end up with is, you know, you look globally, look at rates globally. So we have rates at the 10 years, I think it's below 2.30 today or so, but that's relatively sky high for major sovereign debt globally.
And if the market is any indication, it's moving lower. And of course you have negative rates in some economies, some major economies. So we are maybe farther along this journey. It's kind of been played out, right? You can go into negative rates is where they may be able to go.
And in a synchronized global recession, there may be at least temporarily a rush to the dollar, right, as a safe haven. So there's that one aspect to consider. But then ultimately, the US doesn't want to have the strongest currency around because there's all kinds of trade implications with that and may work to lower the currency, or if they lower their interest rates, and relatively speaking, they may become a little less attractive.
So we're, in a way, kind of all of us are kind of circling the drain on this policy. It's been played out largely, and with the US being the 800-pound gorilla in this game. As we get lower and lower in our rates, that game may be running its course.
And what will ultimately have to be questioned is the presumption of higher trend growth. I think that's the, the thing that nobody wants to really face, is that higher trend growth may not be attainable. That may not be in the picture unless we have some productivity-changing, productivity growth-changing dynamic that presents itself. And I'll be the first to admit it's hard to predict productivity growth. That's a really, really hard thing to predict. But from everything that we're able to look at, it's hard to be emphatic or assert that there's a surge in productivity growth And therefore, you know, I am worried about what happens at the next downturn.
I think the Fed is worried about that, which is why they probably tried to raise rates a little too much in some sense so they had something to cut. And when you look at, you know, different pieces of information that come out, the Bank of Japan, I think, is reported to own almost 3 quarters of the ETFs in Japan.
And you hear about, I think it was Yellen a couple of months ago speculating about maybe buying equities as a way to stimulate things. So those kinds of financial market manipulations are a bit troubling in the context of that idea that there is no such thing as a free lunch.
And so, you know, one of the things, the big picture here that I've always felt is that I don't know why we have to treat recessions, even the next one, which we maybe have pushed off for a while. I don't know. We'll, we'll see what the indicators say, why we have to treat them as the end of the world, as Armageddon. They, they aren't.
They are part and parcel of free market economies. That is how the free market works.
Recessions are part of them, and they serve a purpose. It is arguable that the low-rate environment has kept a lot of so-called zombie companies or excess capacity or misinvestment. It has supported all those kinds of things, which are not great for productivity growth, which is one of the things that ails us here.
So I certainly don't wish the collateral damage that comes with a recession on anyone, but it serves a purpose in a free market economy. It's part of how we stay healthy.
Erik Townsend: Well, Lak, I want to thank you for a fantastic interview, but before I let you go, please tell our listeners what you do at ECRI and what services you offer.
Lakshman Achuthan: I love what I do at ECRI, obviously talking about cycles and having a different perspective on the world. And what we do is manage cycle risk. So cycle risk is not a constant, right? There are times when you need insurance and there are times when you don't and you can let things run either on growth or inflation at home or in all these economies around the world. And so we consult with different money managers and also some corporations about managing cycle risk, looking out several quarters, maybe a year.
On a couple of global cycles, we could see out about a year, and that's about as far as you can see. But we do constantly update this array of leading indexes, and so we're getting new information every month.
Erik Townsend: Well, fantastic. And of course, our listeners can find more information on your website at BusinessCycle.com. Again, that's BusinessCycle.com. Lak, thanks so much for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com.
Erik Townsend: And please visit MacroVoices.com. The conversation continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Lak on the show. You know, I'm a big fan of cycles. I obviously am one of these late-cycle guys. And so it's really important to always hear some different perspectives. particularly from the smartest people that have done the most work on understanding these cycles and get their perspectives on where we are in the cycles overall. What did you take away from it?
Erik Townsend: You know, as we discussed off the air, Patrick, I really think that we need to add Lak as a regular guest and get him back in 6 months or so, because this angle, as you say, of cycles is so important. And the one that I'm particularly interested in is the longer-term inflation cycle. And no, I'm not predicting a return to runaway inflation next week or next month. But folks, it's coming and it's coming someday. And it is gonna be the biggest thing that's happened in our careers when it does. There's nobody in the investment business almost who remembers the last time. And we had inflation ending around 1980. But when's the last time we went from secular disinflation to secular inflation? Basically, the beginning of the 1970s.
Who's still alive that was working in finance in 1969? That's the kind of shift that is coming. Now, is it coming next year or is it coming in 5 years? I think the cycles analysis is one of the best ways to tell that. And I'm looking forward at some point to getting Lak back just to talk about inflation cycles and when we might expect inflation to make a meaningful return.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I'm looking forward to that as well. Before we move on to the chartbook, though, we had some housekeeping to discuss.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I just want to put a call out to our listeners because as we're bringing you all of this new content, uh, it's kind of stretched our audio editing team a little bit too thin. We need to add another freelance audio editor. Now, before anybody gets too excited, it doesn't pay very much, but it's, it's an entry-level thing and it's something that doesn't really require a lot of experience. It's tedious work, but it's very easy to learn how to do. The kind of stuff that's perfect for a college student or someone who's just passionate about the And might enjoy doing what is otherwise a tedious job. If anybody's interested in being an audio editor for us, regardless of your previous experience, please drop me an email, info@macrovoices.com, and I'll let you know what's involved. But Patrick, I want to move on to our post-game chartbook.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link in the Research Roundup email. It says post-game chartbook.
If you're not registered yet, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that It says looking for the downloads next to Lak's picture on the homepage. Let's dive right in here, Patrick, on page 2. Well, that green box that was the danger zone— can't go through that or we could be in trouble— was our message last week. Guess what? We're through that. What comes next?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, we obviously broke below that 2,800 level on the S&P, which really does open the window that, that some further liquidity is potentially going to come into the market and drive it lower. But the question I had was, okay, what, what conditions do you want to see for a bottom? Or at least what, what are the conditions we've seen at previous short-term bottoms that spurred the turn to the buy side and, and it was bought on dip? And so on, on pages 3 and 4, I show the breadth indicator of the percent of stocks above their 50-day moving average, at which on the S&P 500 we're about 30%, which is 30% of stocks above and 70% of the stocks below their moving average. A lot of the short-term market bottoms that we have seen in the last 2 years, 3 years, have all come in when this number hit under 20%.
So we're still not oversold to a level that we have seen where previous lows have come.
The other interesting thing on chart 4 is we're showing that volatility index. And what's interesting is even though the market broke below 2,800 and broke to a little bit of a lower low, at least in this correction cycle, we have not seen that accompanied with a spike in volatility, not at least to the levels we saw in early May. And I would think that usually, at least we have seen in the past that, uh, there tends to be like a little bit of a volatility blow-off as, as fear comes into the market to really mark that, that short-term low.
So going back to chart 2, I just think that there's still room for the S&P to continue to deteriorate. We continue to see failed rally attempts. There's no big intraday reversals that stick and are, you know, have follow-through to the upside. The vulnerability down down towards, you know, 2,750, and even under the right conditions, down to 2,600 to 2,650 is all really possible. Like, what's interesting is, is that as we get down to below the next 50 S&P points, there could be some of those Charlie McElligott CTA sell signals coming in there, which could exacerbate the selling pressure coming from all the CTAs, and that could really be the fuel that drives That, that kind of final push lower that at least on the short term could mark a tradable low.
Erik Townsend: You know, I definitely see that argument, but frankly, Patrick, there's so much that could go wrong that I could easily see— not tomorrow or next week, but, you know, in coming weeks— I could easily see a retest of that Christmas low or lower. But frankly, I could also see new all-time highs because we're getting so much changing and rapidly developing developing news content. I mean, just imagine if we really do get into an Iran military strike situation and an outright breakdown in Chinese trade negotiations to the point where China really does, you know, stay the course and truly continue this ban on export of rare earths, and that whole situation escalates, and we're going to war with Iran and everything else. I mean, I could easily see taking out that Christmas low to the downside. If you were to see John Bolton get fired and President Trump kind of walk back away from the war talk and come up with a China deal at the same time, I could see a panic rally to new all-time highs.
And it's— I kind of emotionally want to short this market. I don't dare to short the market down here because I see that vicious rally risk. And It's so easy to get whipsawed in an environment like this.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I'm— I still remain in the camp that this is one very big large topping formation and that, uh, that we are in the, the starting points of a bear market. So to me, I, I have that downwards bias, quite the opposite of Brent Johnson, but that's what makes a market, right? And, uh, at this stage though, I think the most important thing technically that I'm looking is where is there going to be a short-term low? Because I, I don't think we're going to take out the December bottoms in one shot. I think that a drop down to those levels is probably reserved for like a September-October style sell-off. I think that once, once this wave of selling subsides, that there'll be some, some bounces and mean reversion into the summer, and then we could see how the price action develops into there before making the next market
Erik Townsend: Well, I would love to see
Erik Townsend: a summer rally to new all-time highs because then I could short it.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, for sure. Anyway, moving on to chart number 5. Chart 5 and 6, I put on the 2-year Treasury bond and the long bond on page 6. Both are obviously showing us that we are having a huge rally in bonds right now. That 2-year is ripping higher. You know, kudos to Chef out to Alex Gurevich, who when, when he was on our show, he was talking about going long that 2-year Treasury note. And it's, it's just been a great trade.
It's been ripping higher. I, though, continue to believe on the very short term that this move may be a little bit overdone. And it was interesting is that when, when I've been recently taking some profits on my TLTs with members, And it was on page 6 where I snipped a little tweet from Jeffrey Gundlach who basically said that in the tweet that long maturity US Treasury price action today was consistent with a blow-off momentum top, and I suspect buyer's remorse will set in fairly soon. Even Jeffrey talking about how this has gone a little too far too fast, and it's, it's going to be interesting. I still remain in bigger future bullish bonds. But I do think that on the short term, this is a little bit ahead of itself. What do you think?
Erik Townsend: Yeah, Patrick, I see your argument. And certainly on the 2-year especially, and for full disclosure purposes, I am long 2-year Treasury futures myself right now. It's true that it's already kind of run very well. It is, as Alex described that trade, it is just such a perfect way to play this environment. And the I'm still in that trade, although I do agree with you that it has run quite a way here, is that I see it as a much safer way to express a bearish view on stocks. There are so many risks that could create a sudden and unexpected vicious rally in stocks.
The only way, Patrick, that I can see 2-year Treasuries moving dramatically down in price, meaning higher in yield, is if the Fed were to surprise everyone and say, yep, we're hiking after Overall, time to keep that hiking cycle going. This economy is going so strong, we need to make sure that we fight inflation by hiking rates. What are the odds of that happening? Now, I think that the market has already pretty much baked in that a 50 basis point cut is coming sometime in the next year. Nobody knows when. And so it has gotten ahead of itself, but I'm still comfortable being long here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, moving on to charts 7 and 8, what I just thought was really interesting was looking at that Eurodollar spread between June 2019 and June 2020. When you're looking at those LIBOR rates, you're seeing that we're now down to -56 basis points on that spread, which is now the market baking in more than 2 rate cuts in the immediate 1-year future. And so once again, it shows that the market continues to anticipate that the Fed is going to provide some form of ease in the markets. And what's interesting is that when you go go to chart 8, it was a chart that Michael Wilson at Morgan Stanley was talking about, which was their US cycle indicator. And even though Lak was on here during the session talking about that he hasn't seen the business cycle turn yet, like for an outright recession, what is interesting is the Morgan Stanley US cycle indicator has in fact signaled red for a downturn.
And so it at least At least one other strategist out there is already seeing that cycle turn.
Erik Townsend: Well, and Lak was very clear saying we're not quite there yet, you know, in the way they do their calculations. He hasn't seen his indicator turn from yellow to red the way the Morgan Stanley one did, but it just did. And so who knows what's coming next?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, for sure. I wanted to move on in chart 9 and 10 and 11, actually, the next 3 charts here. What I have is that US corporate high-yield credit spread, the OAS credit spread, showing that, you know, where, where the yield over on the high yield is over Treasury, which we're hovering around 420 basis points. But it's interesting, back in December we had that spike to north of 500 basis points and it's really stepped back. But as Treasury bonds are rallying here, as, as the yields drop on Treasury Treasuries, junk bonds have paused, and that's actually causing this credit spread to widen.
And it's a really interesting question to ask, are we seeing finally the rollover of this space? And that's where on charts 10 and 11, I just have the chart of the junk bonds, and you can see how at least in the last month, they haven't upticked at all the way Treasury bonds have been rallying. And even when we go to chart 11, when I have the Minsky's Senior Loans ETF, that also has really rolled over. That was a heavy seller back in November, December. That was where a lot of the big warning signs were coming in the markets, and, and it seems very toppy, like it's rolling over here.
Erik Townsend: Well, and you know, I'm convinced, Patrick, and I, I have been convinced for several years now that the fixed income trade of the decade is going to be shorting junk bonds when it's finally time to short junk And the big question, which has evaded many of us who have been way too early, is when is that right time? And I think we're getting closer and closer. Are we finally there? Maybe. I've been a little bit early before and lost money by jumping the gun on that particular trade, so I'm going to wait until I see a little more clear indication that it's time. But I mean, look at where this is headed. Look at the mountain of junk finance financing that's out there that's been accumulated in the last decade of central bank largesse. When we get into a recession and dramatically declining stock prices, you know that those spreads are going to blow out.
And I think the trade there is going to be long Treasuries, short junk.
Patrick Ceresna: I like the idea and concept, but, you know, I've tried shorting junk bonds a number of times, made some money actually back in December catching that move. But the problem is the big negative carry. If you're early to this trade, you're just burning pretty hard in trying to carry this trade. And so timing is everything in trying to play the junk. And unfortunately, I personally love to use options. And when you're going into something like these ETF options, the liquidity just isn't there to, to be able to access that option market very well. And so it's, it's one of those things that I love your idea, but it's, it's all about execution for that, right?
Erik Townsend: Oh, absolutely. And you know, the other side of it though, the other side of that argument is, yes, it is true that it's very easy to be early with this trade. There's a huge carry on it, so you don't want to be early. But once it does get moving and it's really clear that that move is underway, it's got a long way to go. Because those spreads that are— what's the OAS spread right now? 419 basis points? It can go to 1,400 basis points if we get into a really serious crash situation in the stock market. And, you know, I don't know that that's going to come, but I think there's a very good chance in the next 12 months or so, you know, certainly before we get into the end of 2020, that we're going to have some serious carnage in the equity And you know that spread is going to blow out when that happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I agree. And that's where watching the Lak's work here, and when the actual recession indicators start kicking in, I think that that will play an important part of timing this trade.
Patrick Ceresna: Nonetheless, the final 2 charts I wanted to reference on pages 12 and 13 is I put up a chart of the German and Japanese 10-year government bond yields.
Erik Townsend: Yields.
Patrick Ceresna: And it's just worth noting that the German 10-year bond yield has now traded back to its 2016 low at -17 basis points, and we're once again in negative interest rate territory. And this thing looks like it's ready to break. I, I just can't believe that we're, we're here this quickly out there. And when you go to the Japan While Japan has not yet reached its 2016 low, which was like -30 basis points, we are definitively now trading lower than the trade range that was established in 2017. And so again, these negative interest rates in both the 10-year in Japan and Germany are really taking hold.
Erik Townsend: This is déjà vu to the conversation we just had about junk, Patrick, because The mistake that a lot of really, really smart people have made in the last few years is being early to the trade, which is going to be long US Treasuries, short German bunds. And quite a few famous people have been early into that trade and gotten burned from it.
At some point, it's gonna be time. And when it's time, boy, there's an opportunity there too.
Erik Townsend: As we close, Patrick, I wanna ask one more time of our listeners, please help us with a review on iTunes. It is so important as we are working now. We need sponsorship in order to secure the funding we need to keep MacroVoices free for everyone.
What's the first thing the sponsors look at? Well, how do your reviews look? How much do they like you on iTunes? So those reviews that you put on iTunes, for those of you who may not be able to afford a cash donation, the donation of your time to go into iTunes and put in that 5-star review for us and tell everybody how much you love MacroVoices really is going to make a difference. difference, a material difference in our ability to secure the sponsorship that we need. So thank you very much in advance for writing that 5-star review on iTunes. The other thing you can do, if you haven't already, is to register your free account at MacroVoices.com so you can receive our free Research Roundup email. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbooks that were discussed by Lak during the presentations, as well as the charts we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a really interesting article from Variant Perception titled The Short CAD on Structural and Cyclical Risks in Canada, and also a really interesting piece by Ray Dalio titled Beyond the China-US Trade War. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup.
That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets, and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening.
Erik Townsend: Thank you.
Patrick Ceresna: Thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's Premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week.
You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.