Lyn Alden — Lyn Alden, founder of Lyn Alden Investment Strategy (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 299 was recorded a day early this week on Wednesday, November 24th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. Happy Thanksgiving. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective.
perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Lyn Alden returns as this week's feature interview guest, and we're going to keep the inflation debate going as Lyn weighs in on where she agrees and where she disagrees with the views Jeff Snider expressed on last week's podcast. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck is titled Talking Charts.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into the S&P 500 here. The market attempted to make a higher high earlier this week and rejected it, and it's been chopping Now for pretty much 5, 6 trading sessions, but really no bearish trend yet. What's your take on this consolidation?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I'm fond of saying that the market's reaction to the tape is more important than the tape itself. And, you know, we've got people that are starting to get panicky because it's been 3 whole days since there was a new all-time high in the stock market. I think that we're in uptrend conditions. The melt-up continues. There's no reason to question it.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik. Well, we gotta touch on that dollar index because it's ripping. And I mean, we are not only clearing the 96 level, Not just the 96 level on the upside, but almost at 97. What do you make of the dollar move?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as we've been saying on MacroVoices, I think that we are finally seeing that upside breakout that would tend to confirm the Brent Johnson, Jeff Snider view, which is that although the dollar is in trouble long-term as the world's global reserve currency, it's more likely that the final days of the dollar's dominance over the financial system will be defined by dollar scarcity as opposed to a collapse in dollar price. So I think that's what we're seeing, at least the beginnings of it, and it'll be interesting to see what happens from here.
Patrick Ceresna: You know, we— I'd like to touch on that in the postgame when I have a monthly chart of the dollar index and really can look at where it could go from here in the much bigger picture.
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway though, let's touch on crude oil because crude oil has more or less now been 2, 3 weeks correcting, and we've seen it print down toward the $75 handle temporarily. Looks like it's turning up. Do you think the correction in oil is over, or do you think there's more downside from here?
Erik Townsend: Well, it depends. My prediction has been that the downside ends when we get to the point of peak government stupidity. Now, we had the big Biden bazooka moment this week. That was where they announced an SPR release, actually a coordinated global SPR release. It was supposedly up to 50 million barrels. Now they're saying up to 70 million barrels. When they say up to, you start to get a little bit I'm skeptical just with the words up to in there. This is all political theatrics, Patrick. It doesn't really have anything to do with supply and demand. And already all eyes have turned to OPEC+ because there are rumors that OPEC+ could very easily essentially undo this move of the Biden administration simply by not moving forward with increasing production as they were expected to do, which would probably have an offsetting effect about the size of the SPR release. Now, if that were to happen, Patrick, I think I think it actually works well for the Biden administration because then Joe Biden can claim that he fixed the problem.
And it was, you know, let's scapegoat foreigners who don't look like us. It was those stinking Russians and the OPEC+ people who decided to screw it up after Joe Biden had solved the problem with the SPR release. I think that's the best messaging that the White House could possibly ask for.
If they get the OPEC response that some people are expecting, I imagine they'll play it that way. But, you know, I'm not convinced that I don't think the bottom is in, Patrick, because we still haven't even explored banning exports or price controls, which are both incredibly stupid ideas that wouldn't help anything. But that doesn't mean that Washington, DC is not going to explore them. And Joe Biden's got a long way to go to the 2022 elections. There's a lot of reason to think the Democrats are at risk of losing those 2022 elections. So it's a year where it's really, really important to do something about prices at the pump. And if you can't do anything, which is the case here, you got to at least look Look like you're doing something. And I think that's mostly what this is about. We'll see what happens next, but don't rule out some kind of export ban or price control. Really, really bad ideas, but that doesn't mean they won't do it.
Moving to EIA inventory. Crude oil building 1 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma building 787,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 603,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 2 million barrels. US production back up to 11.5 million barrels. It had ticked down to 11.4 last week. So we're seeing some stabilization there. And overall, Patrick, I think this is really going to be about the political theater. What is the Biden administration going to do next? And do we get to the point where they can just blame OPEC and kind of put this issue to bed? Or is it going to continue to be on the front burner for the Biden administration? I feel like the peak of government stupidity is not in yet. I think they're going to explore some of these other dumb ideas before they're done with this.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's touch on gold, 'cause gold, after having that extraordinary rip to the upside, finally had a catalyst to sell. And here we are down below $1,800. What's your take on the correction up till now?
Erik Townsend: Well, as we said last week, this was a perfect setup for a retracement back down to $1,800, and that's exactly what happened. And as I said last week, the reason for that is when you have a breakout, in general, it's usually normal after that breakout has played out for a little bit to go back and test that breakout zone that used to be resistance and tested as support. But it's particularly likely for that to happen when the breakout occurred on an extraordinary data print that's not likely to be repeated. And that's exactly what we had with that really big inflation print caused everybody to freak out. They're buying gold. Now we've seen the retrace back down to the breakout zone. The question is, does it hold here? And if so, I think it sets up a really strong Next leg in the bull market, particularly as we move above $1,880, above those previous highs.
That really would be the confirmation that says the bull market is on and the opportunity is to buy down here, not where we were a week ago. And as we said last week, save some dry powder for when we get back down to $1,800. And we're back down nicely below $1,800.
On the other hand, if this does not hold, if we see further deterioration from here, if we move back down below the 3rd of November's print, which was down around $1,700, $1,960 or so and close below that, that really says, okay, this was a false breakout, in which case it's potentially a very bearish sign. I do think that we're probably gonna hold here and move back higher. So this is the buying opportunity if that's right. But hey, the gold market has surprised us quite a few times.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's wrap by touching on the 10-year Treasury yield. And generally it's gravitating back to year highs. So we're trading around 1.65, just a stone's throw away from all the highs. But really the shorter-end bonds, the 2-year yield and the 5-year yields, Gold still ripping higher in trend. Any new views on the bond market for you?
Erik Townsend: No, I'm really waiting to see what happens here. As I've said before, it's only when you get above 1.75 or so, which everybody had drawn as a red line in the sand about a year ago, that this really starts to get interesting and you have a new price signal. So I'm waiting to see if that happens, Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, this week's feature interview guest is Lyn Alden. Erik, why did we get Lyn back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Lyn is a brilliant macro thinker, and she was one of the people that our listeners commenting on last week's show requested the most on Twitter as a response to Jeff Snider's comments about inflation, and particularly the bond market's track record at being able to predict monetary inflation. So, we wanted to get a contrasting view after Jeff Snider. We actually had chosen Lyn for that reason. We didn't know she was going to be the most requested by our listeners, but it worked out exactly as planned.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Lyn Alden is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon Investors seeking exposure to the FinTech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Lyn Alden, founder of Lyn Alden Investment Strategy. Lyn prepared a terrific slide deck to accompany today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you haven't registered yet at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Lyn, I have I've really been looking forward to getting you on the show because, frankly, one of the biggest names that's come up in reaction to Jeff Snider's interview last week was yours. And a lot of people saying, hey, wait a minute, Jeff is really telling us a story that banks heavily on the idea that the bond market is a really solid source of information. And of course, a lot of people are saying, wait a minute, if the Fed owns 30% of the 30-year Treasury issuance, or whatever the statistic is, I've lost track of it, it's kind of hard to believe that there could really be efficient price discovery in that market.
So, what did you think of Jeff's interview overall and in general, this discussion about secular inflation? Which side of the debate are you on? And particularly, what do you think about the value of the bond market as a predictive signal?
Lyn Alden: Well, thanks for having me on, Erik. Always happy to be here. Big fan of your podcast. And when it comes to Jeff's work, I have a lot of respect for areas that he covers. And one of the things we agreed to touch on was some of the things where I view differently than his discussion on your podcast. And so the areas that I would view differently is that I am more in the inflationist camp and have been for the past couple years. And I don't view bond markets as being a particularly reliable signal about forward inflation expectations overall. And I think history bears that out. So I'm happy to go over a couple of the slides that I brought here to kind of cover those points, but that kind of sets out the areas that I view things differently on.
And so if you look at, for example, So kind of to set the stage, the first slide deck, we can see kind of the long-term, century-long fiscal monetary policy that we're working through. So as the chart shows, I think the 1940s are an interesting comparison. Obviously, they don't cover every aspect of it, but in terms of fiscal monetary policy, I think that that's the closest period that we have.
And so you and Jeff discussed that period. So I think that's a period I like to focus on too. And so I think that's worth exploring in more detail.
So as we saw, when they think about inflationary decades, they think about the '70s. But as we can see from these charts, the '70s are actually quite different. So the chart on the left there shows debt as a percentage of GDP, and I break it into federal debt versus non-federal debt. And non-federal debt's mostly private debt, companies and households, a little bit of state debt in there as well, essentially all the debt that's non-monetary sovereign. And then you have federal debt, which is a pretty different beast. And we saw that private debt peaked in the early 1930s and then again in the 2008, 2009 period. And those are associated with major deflationary banking crises. And then what you have is the echo from that a decade later is that you had basically periods of stagnation and then some sort of external catalyst that resulted in a lot of debt building up on the public sector. And that tended to be more inflationary.
And when we look at the chart on the right there, We can see that basically short-term interest rates go to zero during those banking crises for the first time in decades, combined with the monetary base going up. And so that tends to be somewhat of a not particularly inflationary period. But when you go later into that and you have massive fiscal deficit spending at a time when interest rates are super low and the Federal Reserve's monetizing it, that's when you're more prone to get that inflationary type of environment.
So I think the biggest difference between the '40s and the '70s is that in the '70s, because debt was low, they were able to raise rates to rein in inflation, which was in large part driven by bank lending. Whereas 1940s, they were unable to raise interest rates because debt was so high and inflation was coming from fiscal spending rather than bank lending anyway. So it's unclear that raising rates would've even helped. And so basically you had a big disconnect between rates and inflation.
So on the second slide there, I show this. I show basically on both those charts, the blue line is the year-over-year CPI. So you can see that both the '40s and the '70s on average had pretty high inflation. And the big difference was that in the '70s, interest rates generally kept up with inflation more or less. Whereas in the '40s, you had a complete disconnect between inflation and rates because you had a period of financial repression. And I would contend that the 2020s are shaping up, at least in this regard, to be more like the '40s, where you're going to probably see ongoing disconnect between inflation and bond yields.
Erik Townsend: I think that's a really important point, Lyn, because so many people are saying, oh boy, inflation, we got to think 1970s. What lessons do the 1970s teach us? You're making the argument that the 1940s are the better place to look. I'm sure you've taken the next step, which is, okay, what do the 1940s teach us? And what should we be learning about what might be happening next? Because I think it is a very similar financial repression, can't really respond the way we did in the '70s with increasing interest rates because there's no room to do that with the amount of debt that exists. So what should we expect and what are the lessons from the 1940s that apply to the current environment?
Lyn Alden: Well, I think overall, basically, you have to consider this to be an era of wartime finance. So in the '40s, you had actual war, whereas in the 2020s, obviously, it's a different type of war. But we've had, for example, Biden has referred to it as wartime finance, right? So it's It's a similar type of being classified as this emergency response. And it's in large part, you had the pandemic and the lockdowns obviously, but the bigger issue was that a system that was already very highly levered and it was towards the end of this long-term debt cycle as the prior chart showed.
And so that's kind of the emergency of having such a highly leveraged system that can't absorb shocks, that has kind of been optimized for efficiency over resilience over the past 25 years. And then being hit by that type of external shock anyway, which sets up a larger than expected problem.
And so the similarities between now and the '40s are that debt is super high. And so they're unable to meaningfully raise rates despite inflation. And then 2, you have that kind of rising populism that kind of supports that type of fiscal spending. And so I think that's the biggest comparison. So really the fiscal monetary policy is what's similar.
Now, there are some differences. So for example, back in the 1940s, the United States was a trade surplus nation and a net creditor. So we were kind of the emerging market of the day, kind of the rising power, whereas now we're a structural trade deficit nation. So in some ways, we look more like the UK of the 1940s than the United States of the 1940s.
And then 2, you obviously have different demographic trends and different technology environments. And also equities and real estate are going into this decade at higher valuations. So the equity performance of the '40s may be less instructive. So there are certainly differences, but it's really the area of the inflation and monetary policy and fiscal policy that I think is the most instructive for this period.
Erik Townsend: Lyn, tell me more about the details of what happened in the '40s with respect to inflation. And particularly, Jeff made that point of, hey, you've got to look at whether consumer prices are increasing because of monetary inflation Or because of some short-term factor in supply chains. Is that instructive? And what can we learn from the '40s? Because obviously in the 1940s with the war going on, you had disruptions to supply chains then too. So it seems like there's a lot of comparison there. What do we learn from the '40s and particularly with respect to inflation? What does it mean?
Lyn Alden: So slide deck 3 covers some of the details of inflation of the 1940s. And that's an area where I view it differently than Jeff. And so On one hand, you did have supply chain issues, right? I mean, you basically dramatically increased the money supply with all this fiscal spending, and basically there's a global demand for commodities and labor because you needed every resource you could get during the war period. And you had, of course, real-world constraints on how fast you could produce those things. So you had periods of wage and price controls, and you had a rather inflationary period, but it was more off and on than the '70s. So rather than this kind of persistent inflation, You had these big spikes and then you had cool-off periods.
The part that I would disagree with Jeff on is that he talked about how this was supply shock driven and prices went back down. But when we look at the numbers, that's not really the case. And so on the left there, I show basically year-over-year CPI. I believe he showed a similar chart. That's where you have— you can see that the rate of change of inflation varied dramatically. You'd have these big spikes of inflation and then it would go away. You even have minor deflationary periods. But the chart on the right shows CPI in absolute terms. And what we see over the course of the decade is that prices went up 80 to 90% and then permanently stayed there. And so basically every time you got a big inflationary spike, instead of giving that all back when the supply chain abated, it would just kind of go into a plateau for a period of time. Then you'd have another leg up in prices.
And so basically if it was purely supply shock driven, let's say a copper mine gets flooded or a gas line breaks, for example, and there's a disturbance in some sort of commodity, that's the type of supply shock that when it all is said and done, you claw back those price gains and you go back to what the environment was before that happened, whenever that's resolved.
Whereas if you have an environment like the '40s where money supply goes up dramatically and you basically have these periods of running into supply shocks, when that supply shock goes away, it's not that prices They don't keep going up at the same rate that they were going up before, but they generally on average remain at that much elevated level.
So by any measure you look at it, the 1940s were incredibly inflationary. So you had, depending on what specific time period you look at, you had 5% to 6% average CPI growth. You had rapid money supply growth, and those prices on aggregate were permanent. You basically lost purchasing power if you held bonds or cash during those periods.
Erik Townsend: Now, I see a major difference though, which is before World War I, we actually had a formal gold standard. And of course, after World War I, we had the Bretton Woods system, which was kind of a pseudo gold standard. But the point is, there was not an ability for the central bank to use quantitative easing to just increase its reserves and, as some people call it, print money.
The game has changed. And I would say that you mentioned earlier populism. I think MMT is gaining a lot of traction in political circles. It seems that to me, maybe there's going to be a government sentiment toward responding to inflation, doing something that you and I might think is kind of counterintuitive, which is literally making more money, using more stimulus to basically bail the low-income earners out of the inflation trap that they've been stuck with.
And use that to kind of just keep the party going and keep the inflation going because they need to inflate away all of that national debt. Does that make sense? Am I right to be concerned that that's the way it could go? Because I don't think most people are planning that possibility.
Lyn Alden: Yeah. I mean, in short, I think that the Fed is not going to tighten as much as people would expect given the inflationary backdrop. I don't think it'll be like the '70s where they're constantly trying to fight it. Now, I think that in rate of change terms, they can go through periods of tightening. So when there's excessive reserves in the system and where there's no kind of new fiscal package on the table at the moment, I think they can try to reduce their rate of asset purchases. If they get far enough, they could potentially throw some 25 basis point hikes in there. But I think they're essentially going to be structurally behind the curve. And I think that this decade is more along the lines of these large fiscal spending packages.
And if you look at the '40s, it's interesting. Of course, they didn't have the term quantitative easing back then, but they still had the capacity to do essentially what that was under a different name. And so during the 1940s, the Federal Reserve increased their holdings of Treasury securities by about tenfold. And specifically, that all happened between 1942 and 1945. They had to buy a large amount of Treasuries in order to maintain their yield curve control peg. But in addition, they also mobilized the banking sector. So the commercial banks became very, very large buyers of Treasury securities. So that you kind of had a period of financial repression in multiple ways. You mobilized every resource you could to get those bonds financed. So the public were encouraged to hold bonds, banks were encouraged to hold bonds, and then the Fed also did dramatically increase their balance sheet in what today we would call QE. So even though they had the gold standard, they essentially ignored the gold standard And it was still, for a period of time, maintainable.
That didn't get marked to market until 1971. But if you looked at, say, the money supply going up quite a bit, it became increasingly untethered from that gold backing.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 4, you're showing us bonds and inflation. Tell us your understanding of the relationship between bond yields and inflation. Does one predict the other? How does this work?
Lyn Alden: So I think in the tactical sense, bonds have informational value about inflation. But especially during periods of financial repression, they're not always very clear signals. And the chart on the left here shows in blue, that's simply the 10-year Treasury rate over time on an annual basis. And it goes all the way back to the 1800s.
And so that's the expected forward return you get from holding that bond till maturity. And then the orange line shows what actually happened with those bonds on an inflation-adjusted basis if you bought those bonds that year and held them to maturity over the next 10 years. 10-year Treasuries. And what we see is that the 3 inflationary decades of the 1910s, the 1940s, and the 1970s, you got absolutely killed in real terms if you bought and held a 10-year Treasury to maturity. So you get as low as -5% compounded annualized returns, which over the course of a decade is like losing 40% of your purchasing power. And so the bond market, it is smart money in the tactical sense, right? Because it's not, it's largely institutional-driven and it pays attention to these shifting patterns in GDP growth and acceleration or deceleration, but it still gets absolutely blindsided for one reason or another, whether it's because they were actually blindsided or because they saw it coming but were financially repressed.
And so all these periods of actual major inflation, the bond market did get caught off guard and did lose a ton of value. And as we see that the bond market in real terms did just about as bad in the '40s as it did in the '70s. In fact, T-bills did far worse in the '40s than they did in the '70s.
And the chart on the right shows, again, we have a— much like the '40s, so far at least, we have a big disconnect here in the 2020s between what inflation's doing and what bond yields are doing.
And my contention is that it won't be a straight line, just like the '40s and the '70s were not a straight line in terms of their inflationary potential. But But I think basically you're going to see a big disconnect where it'll vary over time, but that bond yields will fail to fully account for the inflation that we're seeing. And they might show up in rate of change terms, right? So they can predict these periods of contractions or expansions. You could have fiscal roadblocks. You could have rising, say, virus case counts, lockdown patterns. You could have things like that that change the acceleration or deceleration of inflation. But I think overall, when we look back on this decade, it'll be one that's marked by these inflationary events that bond yields just basically got blindsided by and did not pay an interest yield that actually compensated for that level of inflation.
Erik Townsend: Lyn, how do you see this playing out when we get into this, what I call an interest rate trap? We're going to have a situation where inflation is eventually going to dictate that, at least under normal monetary policy, you ought to raise rates, but it'll be raising rates in an environment where it's nearly impossible to do so.
What do you think the resolution to that quandary is going to be?
Lyn Alden: So I think there are a couple resolutions. I think that the phase we're in now is jawboning, where you basically create a narrative of plausible deniability. So you can't just say, look, inflation's running hot and we're just going to let that happen. We can't do anything. Sorry. Debt's too high. We have to monetize it. That's not what you do. Instead, you basically keep the debate alive. Right now, for example, there's There are inflationists, there are deflationists. There's this active debate about what's inflation going to be.
And that maintains a degree of plausible deniability. So the bond market can say, look, if inflation gets hot enough, the Fed will probably try to fight it. And there are other people that are pointing out that they realistically can't do that.
And so I think the pattern in the near term, and probably extending out a few more years, is you keep pointing to the supply issue. You try to make it look entirely like a supply issue. And you say, oh, if it wasn't for these one-time unique events, we wouldn't have this high of inflation. And you basically try to disconnect it from your own policy choices, either fiscal policy or monetary policy, and you try to push that onto these external factors and then kind of wash your hands of it. And so every major inflationary period, pretty much by definition, has some sort of real-world constraints or bottlenecks. That's what inflation is. Essentially, you have an increase in the money supply, and then some sort of constraint that prevents you from just creating unlimited goods and services. So in the 1910s and the '40s, you had these war decades. You had big surges in commodity and labor needs. In the '70s, you went off the gold standard, so you had a monetary issue.
Again, you had a big increase in the money supply, but then you also had, say, US oil production peaked in 1970. So you became more reliant on foreign imports, kindness of strangers essentially. And so you had these real-world constraints again. So basically every time you get a mixture of money supply going up quite a bit and then commodities being tight for one reason or another, you're bound to get more price increases. And so I think that the pattern is essentially to divert attention to the supply side and then let the market debate it for years while inflation runs hot over bond yields. And only in hindsight do then you look back and say, wow, We've really got devalued over the course of this decade.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 5, where you're showing broad money versus the consumer price index. Let's talk about what money supply growth historically has done and how it relates to inflation.
Lyn Alden: Yeah. So it's a complicated measurement because there are different ways to measure money supply and there are different ways to measure inflation. But what this chart shows, I try to factor out in this chart the annual noise, because one-year changes don't necessarily tell us a lot. Sometimes you get a spike in money supply and it takes a year or two for price increases to show up, for example. So what this does, the chart on the left there shows 5-year cumulative broad money supply growth, that's M2, and 5-year cumulative CPI growth. Basically these rolling 5-year periods to look for these kind of sustained growth in prices or money supply. And what we see is that generally there's a correlation between money supply growth and inflation. I would describe it as that money supply growth is a necessary but not sufficient condition for prices going up.
Generally, you need money supply growth and then some sort of physical constraint. So for example, in the late 1800s, when you had the Industrial Revolution combined with a lot of land, cheap land, you had a pretty big disconnect between money supply growth and inflation. You had a similar one in the '90s and the 2000s, basically the last 25 years, because you had globalization. You had a labor arbitrage, a disconnect between productivity and wages. So those periods saw basically less inflation than you'd expect from money supply growth. But if you look at the 1910s, the 1940s, and the 1970s, that's where you had this really strong correlation between money supply growth and inflation because you also had these constraints that kind of pushed that to happen.
And the chart on the left, that goes back to just a year-over-year chart.
But what it tries to do is it shows the source of the money supply growth because it's really In our fiat currency system, there are 2 ways to create money in some sense. So the classic way is loan growth. Banks lend money into existence. And so if you look at, for example, the late 1800s, you see that deficits were not a big part of the money supply growth and that the money supply growth and year-over-year bank lending growth were pretty much the same number. All that money supply growth was actual bank lending.
And we also saw in the 1970s that a lot of the money supply growth that we saw during that time was actual bank lending. And then as you got deeper into that decade, you also had fiscal deficits kind of adding fuel to the fire there. But it was really a bank lending-driven money supply growth period.
And the differences that we saw in the 1910s and the 1940s and now in the 2020s is that you see a large fiscal stimulus. And that's what drives the money supply growth. Rather than bank lending. So that's where I would agree with Jeff, for example, that the '40s and the '70s are structurally different on where the inflation's coming from. The monetary inflation and the price inflation, they're coming for different reasons. But at the end of the day, it's still the same result of money supply going up quite a bit and prices going up quite a bit, and then structurally staying there forever.
Erik Townsend: Well, and I think that the fiscal spending aspect of this is really important, Lyn, because a lot of people, would say, look, quantitative easing is not growing the broad money supply, which you're showing here. It's only the narrow money, the base money. The money that really matters is the larger, broader money supply that has to be loaned into existence by the commercial banking system. You're making the point that's saying, wait a minute, commercial banking system is one way, but fiscal stimulus is just as effective at growing not just bank reserves the way quantitative easing did, but the broader money supply.
Well, that seems to me like that's inflationary. And boy, if you analyze the political climate, I think there's a lot of willingness to do a whole lot more fiscal stimulus in years ahead. So what does that mean in terms of what we should expect?
Lyn Alden: Well, so overall, that should be inflationary, especially if it's not combined with reductions in debt. And so we see, if you look at that chart on that right again, if you look at the 1930s, you saw an uptick in fiscal spending, right? So the orange line went up. But it was still a very deflationary decade or disinflationary decade because loan growth collapsed so much because you had so much loan defaults. And so even though deficits went up, it was more than offset by that reduction in bank lending.
And so you actually got a contraction of money supply in the 1930s. And then similarly, when you had the 2008-2009 crisis, we saw these large fiscal deficits, but it was offset by an equal amount of loan destruction. And so if you looked at money supply over the course of the global financial crisis, it was virtually unchanged compared to its prior pattern. It just continually kept going up slowly and it wasn't very notable.
And what characterized 2020 and 2021 was that we didn't have much bank lending, but we didn't have a destruction in bank lending either. And then we got these massive fiscal stimulus efforts and that's what added money to the money supply.
So QE alone just increases bank reserves and basically has implications for the financial system, but it's the combination of that with these fiscal stimulus. So whether it's doing massive infrastructure spending or it's handing money to people or it's cutting taxes without cutting spending, there's multiple ways to do it. But by getting money out into the system, that increases people's actual broad money. So their checking accounts, their savings accounts, the currency in circulation, That goes up substantially while the number of goods and services runs into some sort of constraint. And so basically that's what I would argue is fueling the inflation. And so my base case is that we're going to have structural deficits over the course of the 2020s that are going to largely be monetized and that they're not going to be very effective at fighting inflation.
Now, the caveat is that I don't think we're going to go in a straight line. And so for example, I can see a scenario where in say late 2022, You get an election result, you have more gridlock in Congress. We already see some gridlock in the Senate, right? So if you get more gridlock in the Senate, you could certainly go a couple years with more limited fiscal spending.
And so I think that there will be periods of time in the 2020s decade where the inflationists look like they're really correct, like right now, for example. And I think there will be other periods where the transitory inflationists look like they're correct, the deflationists, the ones that say this is not real inflation, I think there'll be periods of time where fiscal spending cools off and CPI levels out for a period of time and it looks like things are stabilizing. And I think the aggregate, when you look back probably at the end of this decade and look back over the 2020s, I think we're going to have called it an inflationary decade. I think it'll look like the '40s in the sense that you'll get these bursts of inflation that are not offset by increasing yields. And so basically people holding bonds and cash will get devalued Whereas people that have more hard asset exposure will generally preserve their purchasing power better.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 6, you're showing a comparison of inflation in different countries. Where's the relevance of the national perspective come into this?
Lyn Alden: So one thing I try to show is that it's not just a one-country phenomenon. I mean, this story is essentially similar for much of the developed world. Now there are differences, right? So there are, some countries have structural trade surpluses, some of them have structural trade deficits, some of them are running bigger deficits than others relative to their GDP.
And so on the prior couple slides, we showed the United States' 5-year cumulative broad money supply growth compared to CPI growth. And this one just shows a similar chart for the UK, Japan, and Australia to give some of a global perspective.
Because if anything, other countries have had tighter correlation between M2 and CPI than the United States, because the United States have been somewhat unique over the past 150 years in the sense that we're the ones that had unlimited land. In the late 1800s and were the ones that globalized more, basically ran structural trade deficits more over the past 25 years. So we see that the United Kingdom there, the 5-year cumulative money supply growth and CPI growth are very, very similar charts. You kind of had one following the other. Japan also shows a similar outcome. And we can also see basically the hyperinflations during the war years.
And generally, when you have a period where there's a big disconnect between money supply growth and inflation, you generally get radical productivity. Basically, some sort of technological shift or something allowed that to happen. And so in the United States, in the late 1800s and the 2000s, that was because of globalization and unlimited land.
Whereas, for example, on the Japan chart, we see that after World War II, they entered this period of dramatic productivity where you had inflation come back down while money supply growth remained very high. And essentially what that was, was they were organizing society in such a productive way that they basically pulled themselves out of that catastrophe.
And then Australia over there shows again, much like the UK, there's a lot of correlation between their money supply growth and their CPI over any given 5-year rolling period. Their biggest disconnect was over the past 20 years where they had pretty rapid money supply growth, but not really CPI growth. And that can be largely attributed to their connection with China and more broadly emerging Asia. Basically you had this huge commodity demand out of Asia and Australia's geographic positioning and of course their commodity positioning allowed for very strong ties. And so they went kind of a record period of time without a recession. They had this huge bubble build up in their housing market from foreign demand for their housing. And so Australia had this kind of period of pretty high productivity where you managed to have a big disconnect between money supply growth and CPI.
So generally I would say that when you're looking for price increases, you're looking for 2 things. You're looking for money supply growth, and then you're also trying to judge the measure of real-world constraints. And so that's That's generally commodity constraints, but it also can be all sorts of infrastructure and supply chains.
I think a final point with this slide deck is if you look at Japan, people always wonder, why doesn't Japan have inflation given the fact that their central bank is kind of the loose cannon of all the central banks? They're the ones that own more than 100%, their balance sheet is more than 100% the size of their GDP. And what we see there is that actually Japan is at very, very low money supply growth, broad money supply growth over the past 25 years. Despite the fact that their bank reserves went vertical, parabolic, their money supply didn't. And that's because even though they increased their public debt dramatically and they ran these kind of average 5% fiscal deficits that they monetized, they dramatically reduced their corporate debt.
And so they were destroying— they were basically reducing private loans at maybe a rate of say 3% a year. While they're running fiscal deficits of 5% a year. And so the net result was somewhere around the lines of 2% annual money supply growth, which is very low. And so that's in large part why they did not have high inflation, because again, it is the difference between looking at money supply growth versus simply bank reserves.
Erik Townsend: Lyn, you and I both know that energy is a critical factor in understanding any inflation picture. And it occurs to me that I think that this inflation that's beginning now is coming kind of at the end of the age of oil. You know, we're not done with fossil fuels yet, but the world's pretty much decided that we're going to move to electric vehicles. And unfortunately, what's happened is that means that it's become unfashionable to invest in any more oil production and discovery of new resources.
How is the final chapter of the age of oil going to end? Is it a question of oil losing value because nobody needs it anymore? Or is it more likely to be the case, as I think, that what we're going to end up with is kind of abandoning new investment before we're really done relying on oil, to the point where we get an oil price shock in the last few years of the age of oil? How do you look at this? And what do you make of energy? And how does page 7 fit into the story?
Lyn Alden: So over the course of the 2020s decade, I have a bullish view on energy. Now, I have less of a view on any given 6-month period. I don't follow it maybe week by week to the level that you do. And basically that can depend on OPEC decisions, that can depend on shifting rates of demand growth basically on the margins. And so there's all sorts of things that can happen over a given 6 to 12-month period. But I do think structurally we are setting up another bull market in energy.
And one thing I think is that I think the death of oil and gas is somewhat overblown. So this The chart on the right there just shows global energy consumption by source. And what we generally see is that when we find a new energy source, we add onto the prior one and we don't really stop using the prior one. The prior one just becomes a lower percentage of our total energy.
And so when we found coal, we still burned wood. We just kind of stopped increasing our wood burning. Then we found oil. We slowed down our coal consumption. We started using oil, but we didn't eliminate coal. And same thing with natural gas, nuclear, and then some of these newer ones like wind and solar.
And it's also important to think on the global scale. And so for example, one country can certainly reduce their energy usage of a certain type of energy. So for example, the United States can cut down its coal usage as an example, or Germany can cut down its nuclear energy. But that generally shows up somewhere else. And so for example, while the developed world has trimmed its coal burning, We've seen Asia continue to rise up in terms of its coal burning because that's the energy source that they have available to them in their region. And we've also shifted some of the most energy-intensive manufacturing out of developed markets and into emerging markets. And so we've kind of just shifted the balance sheet of where that energy consumption is taking place. And it makes it look like developed markets constrain their energy usage more, but it's not really true when you consider the full supply chain implications.
So overall, I think the age of oil and gas is still going to be around for a while, even if the growth rate overall is slower, maybe even just zero for a long period of time. And that when we look at the supply side, as you mentioned, when there's a lack of interest in investing in it, I think that's where you set up supply shocks and price increases. And so there's a combination of that. So one is the rise in shale oil over the past decade.
Basically, the 2010s can be characterized as a commodity-abundant decade. We had this slowing growth of all the BRICS nations, China and the other emerging markets, combined with all this nonprofitable shale oil. Most of that was not free cash flow positive for the companies. They were very reliant on issuing equity and debt in order to finance all of that.
And so we created this period of commodity abundance, but that's been gradually tightening. I mean, investors are tired of, I think, lighting money on fire With basically financing these shale companies. And then when you add fuel to the fire with ESG mandates that make pensions and other large pools of capital decide not to invest in them anymore, it means that the companies that are investing in more oil and gas production have to be very prudent with the projects that they do. They have to finance what they're doing with their own free cash flow, and they have to be self-sufficient. And so I think that's a trend we're seeing. Basically, If you looked at investor presentations years ago, they'd be talking about how much they're drilling, how rapidly they're growing. Whereas now when you look at slide decks of oil companies, they're often talking about how constrained they are, how high their hurdle rate is for drilling, what their returns on investment are, how much capital they're giving back to shareholders in the form of either debt reduction or buybacks or dividends or special dividends.
So it's really about capital return, and per-share metrics rather than growth at all costs. And I think that's a big structural shift. And I think that's an important part of the supply characteristic going forward.
And the chart on the left, again, it shows 5-year CPI growth. So that's in orange. And then on a different axis, I have 5-year oil price changes. And we see that all the inflationary decades of the past 100 years, Pretty much basically commodity, especially energy going up a lot, is a key part of those inflationary decades. It's hard to get an inflationary decade without constraints in energy and commodities in general. Now, it's not necessarily a sufficient condition. So we saw, for example, in the 2000s that you had less CPI increases than you'd expect from what we saw in oil. And that's in large part because you had globalization. You had a lot of that oil demand come from other countries and you had enough disinflationary pressures from technology and global supply chains to offset a lot of that. But in general, the last 5 years, 6 years, we've been in this obviously this oil bear market, a very bad state of oversupply, unprofitableness like we discussed.
And I think that that period is obviously, I would argue, coming to an end, that we have a tighter market going forward and that that is on average a more inflationary condition. Especially when you combine it with these money supply increases.
And so overall, I think that any economist that's focusing on the big question of inflation versus deflation has to have an idea of key commodity markets as well as infrastructure limitations. So they have to look at what does energy scarcity look like over the next 10 years? Is it abundant or is it tight? They also have to look at key things related to electrification. So copper, nickel, cobalt, all these key grid and car battery metals. And they say, okay, are those tight? Are those likely to be expensive over the next 10 years? Or are we just awash in them? And generally the answer points towards being more tight in those relative to the amounts that you would need to not only build all those cars, but also redo the grids in such a way that you can actually plug those cars in and not have rolling blackouts.
And so when you add that together, I think that points to the 2020s again being a more inflationary decade on average than the 2010s, because I think investors get caught up with recency bias and they assume that these commodity-abundant decades last forever, whereas these things tend to go in these big 5, 10, 15-year cycles.
Erik Townsend: Lyn, let's talk about where we're headed in terms of monetary and fiscal policy. For a while, it seemed like there was a little bit of rhetoric in the system that President Biden might actually fire Jay Powell. Seems like now maybe Powell's position is safe. What do you think is ahead in terms of both the composition of the FOMC board and also the policy decisions, both FOMC as well as fiscal policy decisions by the Congress, as we look ahead into a year where throughout 2022, the Democrats will still have control of both houses of Congress, although there are more and more questions about whether or not that will continue to be true. after the 2022 elections?
Lyn Alden: So generally in any country where you get debt-to-GDP over, especially over 100%, let alone over 80% or so, you start to see less independence from the central bank. It might not be explicitly stated. Sometimes it is, but basically they start to work closely together out of necessity to maintain liquidity and functionality in their sovereign bond markets.
And so for example, during the 1940s, You had a 9-year period where there essentially was no central bank independence. And one of the Fed's mandates was basically to finance the war effort at rates that were low, despite what inflation was doing. And we saw that during 2020 as well, where you had that corporate bond vehicle. They basically had that off-balance sheet vehicle. And that was a combination of the Treasury and the Fed, because the Fed couldn't do that unilaterally, but they could do it with financing from the Treasury to cover any losses that they could have. And that basically was them buying a small amount of bonds to try to restore confidence in credit markets, which seemingly worked very well.
And so I think that we're going to probably see more of a pattern of that in the 2020s, where the Fed and the Treasury kind of have this less distant relationship than they're supposed to have in a theoretical framework like this.
And Powell has shown his ability to be flexible. I mean, he came in as someone that was perceived as leaning more hawkish than say Janet Yellen was. And he set up this course of raising rates and keeping their balance sheet reduction on autopilot. But he basically was forced to pivot a number of times when something in financial markets broke. And so for example, in Q4 2018, everybody talks about the famous Powell pivot. S&P 500 went down 20% in one quarter. But really under the surface, it was the credit markets that were freaking out. So there were no junk bonds issued for 6 weeks there. You had basically credit markets froze when it became clear that he was kind of on this warpath of tightening. And so when things became dysfunctional, he quickly backed up those comments and said, no, no, we're going to be data dependent.
We're going to respond flexibly. And then when you had the repo spike of late 2019, Again, they responded immediately by using the repo facilities and then buying T-bills. And then when you had Treasury market dysfunction in Q1 of 2020, in response to the pandemic crash and all that, the spiking dollar, he quickly brought out the various ways to provide liquidity to foreign central banks, as well as to backstop the Treasury market by buying $1 trillion worth of Treasuries in 3 weeks. And then maintaining ongoing purchases now for another year and a half, or it could be up to more than 2 years. And so he's shown this willingness to be totally flexible in a way that clearly works, I think, with the administration's agenda.
And so there was not an imperative to replace him. And basically by leaving him in place, it maintains, I think, some degree of narrative separation, right? Because you have the president did not appoint him, but reappointed him. And so that kind of keeps the illusion in place of there being some degree of central bank independence. When in reality, he's still dovish enough to basically, I think, meet their goals. Basically, when something breaks in financial markets, that gets fixed by more Fed liquidity. So it might not be as proactively dovish as some of the other members might be, like let's say Brainard, but it's still dovish enough that it doesn't conflict with fiscal goals regardless of who's in charge. And so I think that's because they've kind of trapped themselves into a corner mathematically, it almost seems less important who's running the Fed as long as there's some degree of competence there in terms of being able to roll out these programs fast enough.
And so my overall base case is that I think the Fed's going to try to tighten slowly. So they're going to try to reduce their rate of asset purchases as they've said. If they're successful in that, they might do some 25 basis point hikes. But I think it's going to be this complex narrative of trying to point to the supply chain issues as being the major cause of inflation, which gives them cover to act slowly and basically stay behind the curve of inflation and keep the financial pressure in place, keep bond yields below the inflation rate, keep their short-term interest rates below the inflation rate, and be slow to address that even as they seem like they're slowly making progress towards those goals. Now, I do think that, again, I think there could be periods of time where you get fiscal gridlock and you have a combination of Fed tightening and then you have a reduction in fiscal spending, And so you can get a cool-off in inflation, you can get a cool-off in GDP growth, and then you could have some sort of market dysfunction that requires the Fed to come back in and up their QE.
And I think that basically under Powell or anyone else, if they saw acute dysfunction in one or more markets, whether it's Treasury market or repo market or credit markets, if you have that multi-week dysfunction, Basically, the market's trained that they're probably going to step in and reliquify that market. And that's a trap that they put themselves in.
And so I think overall, I view fiscal policy as being more important to watch than monetary policy on average going forward, even though monetary policy is obviously very important around the margins.
Erik Townsend: Let's translate all of this to what investors ought to do about it in their portfolios. It sounds like you and I are very much both on a secular inflation view. We don't think it's just transitory, but we do think it's not going to be a straight line. And we've already seen some pretty big moves up. What is the investor positioning for this? Is it gold? Is it crypto? Is it oil? If it's oil, is it in the commodity or is it in the E&P stocks? And is it potentially someplace else like broader base metals and other commodities?
Lyn Alden: So I'm playing it in a diversified way. And so I think the general trend you want is to have real assets, things that can't be printed, things that are scarce in some way and that are not at bubble valuations. And so I like a combination of commodities, energy, Bitcoin, precious metals, certain types of real estate, and certain types of equities. And I think that depending on how investors play it partially depends on what type of investor they are, where their expertise lies.
I think energy could be played with buying, for example, long-dated futures. Or with buying a diverse basket of the energy producers that have say long reserves, low production costs, and reasonable balance sheets. And you probably want to diversify your jurisdictional exposure to reduce the tail risk associated with different markets trying to suppress their supply. And so I think that there are attractive American, Canadian, European, and say Russian oil producers you could buy. To spread out your risk. And so there's a couple ways to play that.
I think that metals that are associated with electric vehicles are attractive. I think that there was a period where I think copper was overbought earlier this year. So those can go through waves of being overenthused. But I do think structurally things like copper and nickel are attractive going forward over say a 5, 10-year period.
I think that Bitcoin is one of the fastest horses in terms of, say, risk-adjusted returns as a percentage of a portfolio. I think that there's still probably value accrual left in that asset. I think that basically its overall market cap and its percentage of global assets is still probably going to increase this decade. And so I like that play quite a bit. And so basically my overall approach is to recommend spreading it out to some extent and then focusing on whatever they happen to be an expert at. So if someone follows the energy markets closely, if they follow Bitcoin closely, if they follow equities closely, then they have an edge there that they can exploit compared to other investors.
But I think the main thing is that bonds are not likely to do very good on an inflation-adjusted basis, whereas real assets are likely to do better. But because it's also not going to be in a straight line, there is a case for holding things like short-duration TIPS and things like that, various dry powder that you can use to rebalance into these periods of, say, countertrend moves within this broader inflationary decade. So it depends on what an investor's time horizon is and how much they're willing to trade around that. So it's not foolish to own some cash and bonds even if they're getting devalued, if you're willing to use those to buy dips or corrections in assets that you think are fundamentally attractive when they go through those dips.
Erik Townsend: Lyn, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, please tell us a little bit more about what you do at Lyn Alden Investment Strategy and what services are on offer there.
Lyn Alden: So I provide basically a macro overview, kind of like we discussed here. And then I also cover some individual assets, whether it's certain equities or news on Bitcoin or certain topics around these more specific kind of micro decisions. And so I try to mix the high-level view with the low-level view. And I have public articles, I have a free newsletter, and then I have a low-cost research service for Both institutional clients and sophisticated retail clients.
Erik Townsend: Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. Escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds.
Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com. Listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it's always great to have Lyn back on the show. You know, it's amazing how you can have 2 incredibly smart people and, and just, uh, when they look at the data, they're drawing different conclusions. And it's, uh, but they're both such great arguments. And, uh, I, I really enjoyed what Lyn had to say. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I agree. Lyn is one of the smartest people that we have on the show, and it's great to have a contrasting view. I'm still definitely intrigued by Jeff Snider's arguments, but also intrigued by the people that have
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: ...expressed opposing views. And certainly, you know, the, the big elephant in the room is the argument that, hey, if the Fed owns 30% of the Treasury market, it's kind of hard not to consider that maybe they've got a corner on it and the price signal is not as reliable as it used to be. In any event, Patrick, I want to move on to our postgame chart deck, which is titled Talking Charts. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com.
Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, as per normal, on page 2 we've got that S&P 500 continuous futures contract chart. What's that telling us today?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, I wanted to really touch on, on the 3 equity markets I like to track in, in the US with the S&P 500, the NASDAQ, and the Russell on pages 2, 3, and 4. And it's really interesting, there's a bigger story that's that seems to be going on where suddenly a lot of the cyclicals and small caps have started to give back a lot of their gains. And it was like the FAANGs and growth stories were really starting to gain some momentum on the upside. And so what you can really see is an S&P 500 over the last 2 weeks that's been relatively flat. But when you look at the same 2 weeks on the Russell on page stage 3, it's been in an outright correction on the downside while it was only a day or two ago where the NASDAQ started to actually show signs of reversing off of its top.
And so the question in my mind is, will this trend continue? Will we continue to see a lot of these growth-driven narratives act as leadership and lead the way? And will the small caps return back to underperforming? And it's one of the questions I have. Like, the thing that I want to touch on on the S&P chart on page 2 is that what we've seen this year is on 8 occasions, we either saw a correction that returned back to the 50-day moving average, or in the case of the September-October correction, temporarily traded below it. And so in the past, we've typically gone about a month or more before at some point the market has some sort of a pause in its advance. and kind of corrects downwards towards its 50-day moving average before setting up another advance. With the fact that we've failed to hold the breakout on the S&P, the question now is, are we going to see a dip back toward that 50-day moving average, which lies just under 4,600, before the bulls re-resume the upside?
It's certainly on my mind when looking at the charts.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, on the Euro-US dollar cross on page 5, I know you were watching 1.1515 or so on that cross. Didn't hold.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, actually we were targeting a move down to 113 and we blew right through it. And it really— we're seeing an outright acceleration to the downside. The downside, the bears have just really are running with the breakdown of the euro. And when you zoom out, it's not captured on this chart, the last major support lines were all the way down around the 108 to 110 area. Question, with this kind of downside momentum, Is this still got another couple hundred pips to go before we start seeing support holding underneath? It's quite oversold already. Typically we would already see reactionary bounces and it just seems to be almost accelerating to the downside.
But what I wanted to touch on on page 6 is just like you were suggesting during the market wrap at the beginning as to the potential dollar move that could be underway. When we look at like a 3-decade-long monthly chart of the dollar index, looking really zoomed out, you can see that while the dollar rally we've seen is this little green candle that's turning up and certainly looks bullish, the thing is, is that we're still in the middle of a 5-year trade range. And by being in this 5-year trade range, we haven't really seen a decisive new bull trend resume yet in the dollar index. But it really does put the question of how much potential upside there is if this really did start building momentum. I mean, when we see some of the past dollar rallies, whether it's back in the kind of 2014-15 period, or whether you look back to the 1999 period, there's periods when the dollar really started to gain some traction and really bull trend.
Is this just going to bounce around in the trade range, or is it going to breakout to a new bull trend that runs this, you know, 10+ points. It's a really interesting thing to observe here.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to Bitcoin on page 7.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so what I wanted to just highlight here is we've now, for the first time since the October rally started, we are seeing that we're in the midst of some sort of a market correction. What is interesting here is that as Bitcoin slowly approaches this kind of $50,000 to $55,000 pocket, there's all sorts of support and Fib zones and things like that that lie in there. It'll be really interesting to see whether the buy-on-dip continues and whether this type of a market correction like it did back in September just spur the buy-on-dip traders to come in here and turn it. And this, I think it's a really interesting moment where where Bitcoin can in some degree or another put in a turn point. It'll be interesting to see if it plays out.
Erik Townsend: And we've got crude oil on page 8.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, you know, with crude, the interesting part— I mean, you were making the observation yourself just about the way the price action's trading. For me, I actually am really focused on the $80 handle, and I think the $80 level is really interesting on this contract because generally if the bounce that saw in the last few days was just a reaction from an oversold condition, then if there's more correcting and more selling to come, we should see crude oil fail below $80.
And if that's the case, you know, could we go back and retest $75 or even get into the low $70s? It would all be on the table. For me to really decisively turn back to the bull side of oil, I want to see that clear the $80 level on the upside and really once again put the bulls in control of this trend.
Erik Townsend: I agree, Patrick. I think there's a good chance that the bottom could be in, but that's only if we're done being stupid at the government level with policy, and I don't think we're done yet. I'm kind of eyeing the 100-day moving average all the way down at $72.88, just below $73, as where the downside potential might be if we see some kind of announcement or intimation that an announcement is coming about either an export ban or some kind of price controls, both of which are dumb ideas that are not going to solve anything, but it doesn't mean they won't be considered. Let's move on to uranium on page 9.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. We had that explosive rally in that Sprott Physical Uranium Trust back in September, and that really overshot. It's clearly in hindsight we can say that. And we basically have now spent several months backfilling and consolidating that breakout. But to me, seeing a sequence of higher lows as it seems to be accumulated quietly here, and what will be interesting to see is whether or not this becomes the platform for another leg higher in uranium. And just like crude oil at the $80 handle, I think watching the Sprott Physical Uranium Trust around the $16 handle will be really interesting.
If we can see $16 broken on the upside, It may re-resume this bull trend in motion.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the 2-year Treasury yield on page 10.
Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, we talked a lot about that 10-year yield, and really the 10-year has not cleared its 52-week high yet. But what we clearly can see is that the shorter duration bonds, particularly this is the 2-year, but the 5-year is moving at the same time. What we're seeing is that they are distinctly pricing in rate hikes and just ripping to the upside on the yields. And the interesting byproduct of this is that it's actually put in motion the flattener. And so when you look at page 11 and we look at the 5s-30s yield, I just cherry-picked this one. What we continue to see is the yield curve continues to flatten. And if you told me that we would've had a this inflationary environment that we're in and asked like whether or not we'd be seeing steepening or flattening in that environment, I would've never guessed that this would be going underway. Like just the fact that the yield curve continues to flatten, the question is, are they pricing in policy error at some stage in terms of what everyone is projecting forward?
It's really interesting that this trend is in play.
Erik Townsend: And also in play is the free trial at bigpicturetrading.com. You can get the information on page 12 and 13 or just Go to bigpicturetrading.com to try Patrick's service where you can get Patrick's chart decks every single day of the week. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: In this week's Research Roundup, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Lyn Alden's slide deck. You'll also find the chart book we just discussed in this postgame. There's also a link to a Variant Perception article on cyclical headwinds versus structural tailwinds, and an oil price article, Will the Global Effort to Ease the Oil Price Rally Pay Off? So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about these markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend, that's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance. and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests, and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com. If you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna. Shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Jeff Snider — Alhambra Investments CIO (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 298 was recorded on November 18th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Alhambra Investments CIO Jeffrey Snider returns as this week's feature interview guest, and I think you're really going to love this interview. Jeff gives the first truly credible counterargument that I've heard to date for the secular inflation thesis that so many of our expert guests and I myself have come around to in the last couple of years. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck is titled, Can the Trends Continue? And finally, you can expect MacroVoices to air one day early next week on Wednesday, November 24th, due to the American Thanksgiving holiday on November 25th.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into S&P 500. I want to talk about a chart in the postgame about it, but right now it looks pretty quiet. I mean, we haven't made a 52-week high in a week. It's crazy. But, but do you think the breakout potential is there?
Erik Townsend: Well, I certainly do. I mean, we're still above all of the short-term moving averages. I don't see any reason to think that the melt-up doesn't continue. To be sure, I don't think that this is about fundamentals. It's about liquidity, and it's central bank largesse that's driving that liquidity. But, you know, it's time— actually way past time for me and everyone else who's been banging their fists saying this is not based on fundamentals, it's unsustainable. Well, look, as long as the central bank continues to print money like it's going out of style. It is sustainable. And I think it's more likely to lead to an Austrian crack-up boom as opposed to a market crash in nominal terms. Eventually, it's going to end very badly, I think, potentially in an inflationary depression of some kind. But that's not happening anytime soon. And I don't see any reason not to expect the market to continue the melt-up.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's touch on the dollar index because what a breakout we had to start last week. It really has been following through early on. A little bit of a reversal in the last few days. We cleared 96. temporarily on the upside of the dollar index, coming back a little bit here. We're about 95.50 at the time of recording. What do you make of all the dollar strength?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think you already said most of it. The strength continues. We broke 96. Of course, you break a round number level like that, some people think it's going to be a top. They start selling, and that's the reason that you're seeing this retracement. That's perfectly normal. All bull markets climb a wall of worry. I think what's going on here is the Jeff Snider view about dollar scarcity, the Brent Johnson view, dollar Milkshake Theory. If anybody's unfamiliar with those views, please check both Jeff Snider and Brent Johnson's past interviews on MacroVoices. And of course, we've got Jeff Snider coming back this week to talk about inflation.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because, uh, after what it was, an epic 2-month run on the upside, we've now, uh, seemed to be in the midst of some sort of a correction. Uh, how, how far, how deep does this go before a buying opportunity emerges?
Erik Townsend: Well, there's a lot going on here with the Biden Administration SPR releases, uh, probably a little bit too much for the And you're a market wrap. So let's save some of that extended commentary for the postgame segment when we'll go into a little more detail on what the options are for the Biden administration, because very clearly Joe Biden has painted himself into a corner where he now has to do something— with do something in air quotes— about energy prices. It's not much he can really do. So let's talk about what those options are in the postgame segment. Meanwhile, EIA inventory came in with crude oil drawing down 2.1 million barrels, but that was really a 5.3 million barrel drawdown.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: before a 3.2 million barrel SPR release. So net of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve release of 3.2 million barrels, this would have been a 5+ million barrel drawdown during what should be restocking season, although we're getting kind of to the borderline of restocking season being over.
And we ended up with a print of 2.1. Now, this is freaking everybody out completely. Oh my God, what's going on? The SPR release is— they're selling oil out of the What's the SPR? Well, okay, look, let me read the press release.
It says the DOE announces this morning the sale of 20 million barrels of oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. That press release was dated August 23rd. Why is ZeroHedge printing articles saying we've just learned shocking information that there's, you know, this is crazy. This is not new information. And if you've been listening to MacroVoices, just 2 weeks ago, I told you that there was a very significant SPR SPR release, which turned what would have been a drawdown into a reported build. Nobody seems to have noticed the news, which was newsworthy on August 23rd, until this week. So much for the efficient markets hypothesis. Meanwhile, Cushing, Oklahoma building— finally a build in Cushing, Oklahoma. Only 216,000 barrels, but it's not another huge drawdown. Remember, Cushing, Oklahoma is really close to its minimum operating level, and if it gets too much lower, we've really got an issue there. So it's really It's good to see at least some signs of stabilization.
Meanwhile, gasoline drawing down 709,000 barrels, distillates drawing down 824,000 barrels, with US production staying unchanged at 11.5 million barrels.
We'll save the commentary on what the Biden administration's options are for the postgame segment. But the big picture here, Patrick, is I think the bottom of this correction comes at the moment of peak Biden administration stupidity. A lot of people are saying this morning might have been it. Maybe that was the bottom. I don't think the stupidity is done yet. I don't think that the Biden administration can just do nothing from here. They've made enough promises that they've got to do some kind of sign or something of doing something about this problem. And I'm not sure what that will be. Let's talk about it in the postgame segment. But I'm not convinced that the correction is over because I don't think the stupid policy decisions from the White House are over.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because last week we're highlighting that very decisive breakout. It started at the moment we had Ole Hansen on the show, and really it's been more or less holding the gains. I mean, we're at $1,860 right now. Do you think there's— that this is the legit breakout and we're going north of $1,900?
Erik Townsend: Well, I do think it's probably a legitimate breakout, but let's stop and remember that that breakout happened on a massive, massive— what is it, 30-year record CPI print? So finally, all the people that were in denial about inflation were given a wake-up call, and that jolted gold higher. Okay, remember that usually what happens in technical analysis is breakouts, especially breakouts that happen on what might have been a one-off data print, tend to retrace at least back down to that prior resistance level. They test that as support, and then if it really is a healthy breakout, it's going to move up from there.
So this seems to me like a perfect setup for that kind of retracement to happen. So yeah, I think it probably is a legit breakout. I think we probably are headed much higher, but I would be surprised if we don't see at least $1,835, which I think is maybe where you want to start to add a little bit to a long position.
And then $1,815 looks like another good spot to add a little more. And I won't be at all surprised if we get back down to $1,800, which is really where the breakout zone was before this is over. Now, that doesn't mean it's bad. It's just this is the way breakouts tend to go. Especially breakouts that happen on a data print, is people get all excited. Once that excitement wears off, you see the market retrace back down to the breakout zone, and then it recovers from there. And if that happens, it's, it's great. It's all off to the races. Let's see what happens, but I wouldn't be rushing to, uh, add a whole lot here. I'd be keeping some dry powder to see if that retracement gives you better location to add to your longs.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on that 10-year yield. I'm sure Jeffrey Snider is going to say something about it or another, but really at this stage, we had yields generally rising over the last week toward 160, 165. We're still hovering there. Do you think that there's room for yields to break out to a fresh year high?
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't wanna steal too much of Jeff Snider's thunder 'cause he's gonna talk a lot about bond yields in the feature interview. I'm just gonna say that I don't think there's reason to get too concerned until we get past about 1.75 or so. That seems to be the red line in the sand where people start to panic. The question is, if we're headed towards secular inflation, you're going to hear Jeff Snider make the argument that, hey, that never happens unless the bond yield predicts it first, and that's not happening yet. So we're not seeing that confirmation of secular inflation in the bond yields. And I think that's an important open question. Let me— I wanna save that though for Jeff Snider. Let's talk about it a little bit more in the postgame segment after Jeff's had his chance.
Patrick Ceresna: And Erik, as you were saying, this week's feature interview guest is Alhambra Investments CIO, Jeffrey Snider. Now, Erik, why did we get Jeff back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Jeff is one of the absolute smartest guys that I've ever met in finance. And specifically what he's smart about is understanding the international system for funding and creating US dollars, the way that US dollars are loaned into existence through the offshore Eurodollar system. Jeff's done an incredible amount of work on that. He knows a lot about it. And when I hear somebody as smart as Jeff Snider say, hey, I don't buy into this whole secular inflation argument, I think you guys all have it wrong, I really stop and listen because Jeff is somebody whose view I really respect. Now, I do wanna add
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I wanna set a little bit of context for our listeners before we get into this interview, because Jeff's such a smart guy, he sometimes assumes things are obvious that may not be obvious. Just for anyone who's not familiar with it, the formal definition of the word inflation in economics is not really the way most laypeople use it.
Laypeople say inflation means rising consumer prices. An economist would tell you, actually, the definition of monetary inflation is a growing money supply. And the result of that larger money supply means there's more money in the system chasing the same amount of goods and services, that results in an increase in consumer prices. So when you hear Jeff say that there are going to be significant consumer price increases, but it's not inflation, it sounds maybe initially like that's crazy. What is he talking about? Well, the distinction he's drawing is that it's not money supply inflation, which is driving that consumer price increase.
Okay, who the heck cares? Jeff's gonna make some really compelling arguments for why you should care. Because if it's not monetary inflation driving it, then the expectations about how long it lasts, whether it's transitory or persistent, et cetera, change substantially. I don't necessarily agree with all of Jeff's views, but this is by far the most credible counterargument that I've heard so far for all of the excellent arguments we've heard in favor of secular inflation.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Jeffrey Snider is coming up as MacroVoices continues, right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the FinTech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange, or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Alhambra Investments Chief Investment Officer Jeffrey Snider. Jeff has prepared a terrific slide deck to accompany today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you haven't registered yet at MacroVoices.com. Just go to the homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, looking for the downloads.
Patrick Ceresna: Jeff Snider.
Erik Townsend: Jeff, I am really, really looking forward to this interview with you because you are one of the absolute smartest guys that I know, and you particularly Particularly understand the dollar funding system internationally. And for any listeners listening who are perhaps new to MacroVoices and are not aware, at MacroVoices.com/Edu, for Eurodollar University, you can find a detailed series where Jeff explains the entire international global US dollar funding system, the Eurodollar system, which I think is gonna play a role in today's discussion.
Jeff Snider: Right.
Erik Townsend: The topic of which will be inflation. And particularly, Jeff, just about all of the smartest macro guys I know have kind of flipped from the deflation camp into the secular inflation camp. Just last week, we had Ole Hansen on this program describing how the lack of investment in oil-producing resources is likely to lead to a very significant oil price shock to the upside in coming years. And of course, And of course, oil prices, energy prices are one of the biggest drivers of inflation.
I think we've gotten to the point, Jeff, where the last 2 men standing are you and Dr. Lacy Hunt. We're trying to get Dr. Lacy Hunt back on the program. Our producers are working on that. But let's start with our own Jeff Snider, who knows the Eurodollar system so well. Why is it, Jeff, with everybody else saying, hey, look, secular inflation is just so clear, there's so many reasons to think that the MMT crowd is gonna keep printing money, debasing currency, and so forth, has to lead to runaway inflation someday. You're saying, no, you don't see it. How come?
Jeff Snider: Well, there's 2 things here, Erik. And by the way, thanks for having me back on to try to explain what's going on here, because I think, you know, inflation is the one topic that everybody wants to talk about for very good reason. And when I say, you know, there isn't inflation happening this year, people are like, wait a minute, come on. The CPI is at 6.2% in October, which is the highest it's been in 30— how can you possibly say there's no inflation?
And the answer is we have to define our terms. We have to be specific about what it is we're actually talking about. And the one part of it is what you just said, Erik, which is debasing the currency, money printing. And that gets to the heart of what we really wanna talk about. But there's other things involved too, specifically to start with, when we look at the CPI, is the CPI always talking about inflation? Is it always reflective of actual inflation? Or is there possibly different underlying, very different underlying circumstances that could be creating consumer price bubbles or consumer price deviation. That's the first thing. When we look at the CPI, is the CPI really just an inflation index or is it a consumer price index where consumer prices could be moved by other factors that aren't inflation?
And it's understandable why people would think that it's only the other, that CPI is always inflation because that's really how everybody talks about it. And it's true not just to the public but also central bankers and economists. They do all sorts of studies, for example, about the CPI and what's the best predictive model of the CPI because Obviously, we have a good interest in trying to figure out if we do see consumer prices rising, is it going to last? Is it gonna go on forever? Is there any sort of secular trend there?
And so these academic models take a look at the CPI as if every CPI is exactly the same. And so their conclusions are usually about what is the best predictor of the CPI? And I don't think that's really the right question to ask because again, there are different types of situations where consumer prices could be reacting or be responsible from other different factors, very different factors that lead And lead to very different conclusions and all sorts of different implications.
So if we get into the slides here, yeah, that's really our goal here. Start on slide 3 is we look at the CPI, we look at consumer prices, and what we're really interested in is, is it just consumer prices rising or is there inflation responsible for why consumer prices are going up? And what the academic economist mainstream orthodoxy tells you is that there really isn't a good way to sort out predictive CPI values. It's really pretty much a crapshoot. They figure the best methods is by using professional economists who use econometric models, things like the Blue Chip Economic Survey, because they have a more, at least a decent track record of predicting the CPI. And you look at some of the other factors they looked at, some of the other ways of predicting consumer prices, among the worst they say is financial markets or bond Yields, which is kind of what we're trying to get at here. Which is, do bond yields predict the CPI, or do bond yields react only to inflation in these CPIs?
And so that's that's really where we're going to start. If we go to slide four, throughout history, consumer prices have been driven by very different factors at very different times.
We're very much familiar with the 1970s and the Great Inflation, and so we're kind of led to believe that anytime the CPI accelerates, it's because of inflation. As you said before, printing too much money, currency devaluation, that kind of thing. But in truth, you have to go back to before 1955. But usually when the CPIs went up, it had nothing to do with monetary printing. It had nothing to do with money printing or excess currency. And a perfect example of that is 1950, '51.
We had what was essentially a classic supply shock, which was the North Koreans invaded South Korea on June 24th, 1950. Within a couple weeks, American consumers went to the grocery, went to every store they could find and started buying everything imaginable because they understood that pretty soon the U.S. government was going to start redirecting economic resources into the warfighting effort when the U.S. finally joined the Korean conflict. And so it was very much like World War II, where consumers understood that the availability of goods was going to be restricted. And so it created this massive bottleneck where consumers went absolutely nuts buying everything they could possibly buy while it was still available. At the same time, the supply. Side was not able to keep up with that demand because number one, it was a shock, a true shock in the fact it was unpredictable. But also as more and more resources were taken away from the consumer sector and channeled into the defense industries, it was again, supply just could not keep up with demand.
And so in terms of small-e economic prices from around July 1950 to February 1951, the consumer price index accelerated to at that time, which was an annual rate of more than 12%.
So it wasn't money printing, it wasn't currency devaluation, even though the Federal Reserve was convinced that it was. And the Federal Reserve actually provoked a political crisis to gain its independence from the Treasury Department because those at the Fed were absolutely concerned this rise in consumer prices was inflationary, therefore it was gonna continue unless they were able to gain independent monetary policy. But they, again, they got the inflation thing wrong. They didn't look at the CPI as a supply shock. And the level of CPI puts what we're seeing today to shame. Because again, the annual rate of 12%, that was a massive burst of consumer price inflation, but it wasn't really inflation. It was actually just a supply shock.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Hang on a second, Jeff, because you're making this distinction. You're saying it's not really inflation in the sense of, okay, technically it's not monetary inflation. Something else was driving it. That extraordinary increase in consumer prices that you agree did happen starting in 1950, '51. That did happen. You're just saying it wasn't monetary inflation. Is that correct?
Jeff Snider: Yeah, that's what we're trying to get at. There's—
Erik Townsend: Okay, but here's what I'm hearing. It sounds to me like you're arguing my side of this, because what I see is, okay, so maybe it's not monetary inflation, but what I see is we just had a global pandemic which caused this crazy event that wiped out a whole lot of the US shale production. capability. We now have an ESG trend, which says that we're gonna vilify extractive industries, whether that makes any logical sense or not. We're gonna punish them by not investing in them. So we're not doing any investment in new oil production resources.
So all of those things add up, Jeff, to say, in my mind, we've got huge increases in energy prices on the near horizon coming our way. That would be a factor that has nothing to do with money printing, but has everything to do with consumer prices going to the moon in the near future. And at the At the same time, we have, for now at least, the Democrats control the White House and the Congress. I just had a listener point out to me over the weekend that, you know, probably in 2022, the Democrats will lose control of the Congress. So that'll change things a little bit. But still, all of this MMT stuff is super popular. Lots and lots of politicians want to print more money, and particularly they want to get it out to Main Street, not to, not to Wall Street. These all sound like we're putting more money in consumers' pockets to drive prices And you're right, it has nothing to do with money printing and currency devaluation.
But I think that those factors are very much in play to set up a great big secular inflation.
Jeff Snider: Look, I agree with you, Erik, that, you know, again, when I say it's not inflation, I'm not saying consumer prices haven't gone up and they might not continue to go up a little bit further. What I'm saying was without the monetary component, without actually being true inflation, and I hate using that term, but inflation is a monetary phenomenon as we'll get to.
Without that monetary component, excess currency, if you want to do quantity theory, what happens is you have a sharp spike in prices for other non-economic reasons, as you just described, but then the economy is forced to adjust to it.
In other words, we're robbing other parts of the economy by paying, by having to pay higher prices at the pump, for example. And eventually, that's where the inflationary trend always breaks down, as it did in 1950, '51. Once the consumers stopped buying all those goods, inflation stopped because it wasn't really inflation. And if we're going to be paying $200 a barrel for oil, that's going to rob consumers of so much discretionary power that other parts of the economy are going to suffer in a deflationary way that is going to balance out what's going on in oil prices. So it's not going to be a secular inflation trend because it can't be a secular inflation trend without the monetary component. And if we fast forward to what I'm getting at here, here in the slide deck to, we'll go to slide 5 now.
You know, again, there's a difference when it comes to inflation versus this other stuff, this non-economic factors. And really, you know, even as the BLS pointed out not too long ago, inflation behaved very differently from around 1955 forward until around 2007, simply because there was the monetary system behind it that allowed inflation to react very differently than it had previous to 1955, as I'm showing in the 1950 example. which is that consumer prices tend to clump together in these supply shock spikes that never lasted because there was no monetary component. And the best way we can sort out between these various versions of consumer price index increases, what's inflation and what's it from other non-economic factors, is simply by using the bond market and bond yields.
So if you go to slide 6, as you can see, before 1955, the bond yields continued, stayed very low, which was consistent with the deflationary aftermath of the Great Depression, because we got to remember our interest rate fallacy. Low yields denote tight money, not loose money. And so low yields before 1955 were a signal that despite 3 massive shocks in the CPI, 3 huge double-digit increases in consumer prices, they were only ever concentrated into temporary, short, transitory periods of time because they were not real inflation. They were simply supply shocks. That when they ran their course, consumer prices then returned to the baseline, which judging by bond yields, these were non-monetary inflation, not money inflation. So it's not real inflation. That all changed around 1955.
This Eurodollar system got introduced in various ways and it started to leak back into the domestic United States system. And look what happened. Lo and behold, the bond market sniffed out the inflation before it ever showed up. And if you go to slide 7, you can see that bond yields were starting to rise years before the Great Inflation, the actual Great Inflation start, which the Great Inflation, I think pretty much everybody knows nowadays, was a monetary event. It was exactly the classic case of too much money chasing too few goods. And bond yields were absolutely spot on throughout that first, not just the initial period, but if you go to slide 8, you can also see how bond yields predicted the ups and downs during the Great Inflation themselves.
And what's interesting is not only are bond yields at least months ahead, if not years ahead of actual monetary inflation. Again, in 1973, we had the oil price shock with the OPEC embargo, which bond yields correctly saw as that's another supply shock that's being piled upon this underlying monetary inflation that had already driven yields upward and already driven CPI upward in a sustained manner. So what the bond market is telling you through this first half and the second half of the Great Inflation is that it is a very useful tool for sorting out what is the money supply problem, the real inflation versus what is these non-economic factors.
And if they're non-economic, again, what are long-term bond yields all about? As Irving Fisher said more than a century ago, long-term bond yields are growth and inflation expectations. Even if there's a secular non-economic reason behind consumer prices, then long-term bond yields would see that somehow as, okay, that's something I gotta factor. If I'm owning a 10-year US Treasury and I expect non-economic consumer prices to be accelerated, some secular trend to continue for 10 years, then I've gotta factor that into how I'm viewing my holdings of US Treasuries. So if the Treasury market says whatever's going on in the CPI, is not gonna affect the long run, then the bond market is essentially discounting these different factors, which lead to this ability to sort out different CPIs from one from the other. Is it monetary? Is it actual inflation? Or is it something else that isn't going to last, that isn't going to impact the long run?
I think people can probably understand where we're going with this.
If we flash forward to slide 9, we're getting into the 21st century. And again, the bond market has done a very good, if not perfect job of sorting out which CPIs represent monetary inflation. Which are just transitory supply shocks or transitory shocks for other factors.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Jeff, I just want to get this straight because it sounds to me if I plan to have you back on this program one year from today, we've kind of got a setup where I might say, Jeff, you said there was going to be no inflation, but now gasoline prices are $7.23 a gallon. And you might say, yeah, but that wasn't inflation. Is that where we're headed?
Jeff Snider: And it sounds like a cop-out, doesn't it? But yeah, you're right. That's what we're saying is the bond market has looked at the 2021 CPI spike and says, this is not money printing, this is not inflation, this is something else. And you're saying that there's something— you're agreeing with me, right, Erik? You're saying that— I agree, this is not money printing, this is not— this is—
Erik Townsend: I agree, this is not strict monetary inflation, but I still think that an energy-led price shock is coming, which is going to dramatically increase first energy prices and then almost everything else has energy as an input cost. So the price of everything else goes up. That results in even more unhappiness with lower-income consumers particularly. And it leads, I think, at that point to money printing, real monetary inflation as a government response. The way they respond to people can't afford that $7 gasoline is they print up a bunch of money and give it out as handouts or transfer payments of some kind to support the economy. And if you listen to what Joe Biden said about inflation, He said, listen, don't worry about it because we're going to pump so much money into this economy, it's not going to matter. And everybody who understands inflation rolled their eyes and said, oh my God, I can't believe he said that.
Jeff Snider: Well, they don't understand inflation. That's the point.
Erik Townsend: Take him at face value. What he's saying is what they're going to do in response to inflation— excuse me, what they're going to do in response to consumer price increases, particularly around energy, is they're going to generate real inflation. They're going to print up a whole bunch of money and you're going to get the inflation that you're saying is not coming.
Jeff Snider: The bond market says it's not happening. In fact, the bond market is unequivocal about how such a low probability that it is, it's not even worth paying much attention to. Look at, I mean, I just went through more than, what, 75 years of history and it goes back further. We've got over a century of history where the bond market has been spot on time and again, sorting out long-run consumer price changes. What is inflation? What is not inflation? What is the non-economic factors we need to pay attention to over the intermediate long run and which ones we don't?
And right now, the bond market is unequivocal, saying, yeah, Biden may say these things, but it's not going to happen. And there's a very specific reason it's not going to happen. If we go to slide 10, as Milton Friedman said in 1963 as he was touring India, inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.
Now, he didn't make this statement as sort of a, I'm just conjecturing here, or this is a theory I had that I'm bouncing around my head. He made this statement, he just wrote a monetary history. So he made this statement as an acknowledgment of empirical fact in reality. So inflation is everywhere a monetary phenomenon. In nearly 60 years since he said that, everything has only validated what he was saying, especially the later '60s and '70s of the Great Inflation. That, look, we know what inflation is. Inflation is money and inflation means long-run problems. And if it's a long-run problem, the bond market is going to find out about it and it's going to trade upon it. Upon it. And if the bond market says there is no long-run inflation here, there is no money printing, then that's a pretty good historically validated gauge that says no matter what's going on in the short run, we're going to shrug our shoulders and ignore it because there are other problems that supersede what's going on.
And as I said before, yes, we can have gasoline prices become extraordinarily expensive and painful, but all that's going to do in the absence of money printing and currency devaluation All it's going to do is create other economic problems in other parts of the economy that are going to balance it out so that these so-called secular trends never become secular in the first place. Again, this is the judgment of the bond market. It's not me saying this. I'm just telling you what bond yields are saying. And again, this has been a reliable, historically validated, empirically established indicator, which right now is saying, yeah, we hear all of this stuff that you're talking about. We see oil prices going up. We see the CPI at 6.2%. And used car prices being 1/8 of the increase in the October CPI. But that's not inflation. And inflation is what we have to look at over the long run, not the short run.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Jeff. So we're still in agreement that there is a good chance that energy prices in particular go to the moon from here, but it's not inflation. And then that gets transmitted into the rest of consumer prices going up dramatically, but it's not inflation.
Jeff Snider: No, that's not what I'm saying at all.
Erik Townsend: Despite— well, wait a minute. But I mean, it sounds what you're saying. It sounds like that's what you're saying. And then what I'm What I'm saying in reaction to that is the President of the United States went on television and already announced his intention of how he's gonna respond to inflation is by throwing money at it. So, that says to me, they're going to print money.
Jeff Snider: No, they're not gonna print money. They don't know how. And again, we've heard this, all this stuff before. It's just the numbers have gotten bigger. I mean, we're having the same arguments we had in 2009 and 2010. It's really just the same thing. And the reason the bond market skepticism is because it's been empirically validated time and time again. Yeah, who cares what Joe Biden has to say? He doesn't control money. That's really the whole point here is that inflation is all about money.
And I'm not saying energy prices will go to the moon. I'm saying energy prices can be temporarily elevated in extremely painful ways. But that painful, that pain that consumers will feel because of rising gasoline prices will rob other parts of the economy of vitality and economic activity such that you'll have one sector of the economy that's nominally growing going massively because of inflation and prices, because prices are going up, but that it's going to depress other parts of the economy. And over time, neither the energy trend nor the economic trend can survive that kind of split personality. You can't have rising energy prices and have economic growth continue for very long because again, history has shown what happens in those situations is you end up with a really nasty recession or contraction within very short order. And that necessary recession and contraction, as nasty as it gets reestablishes a very different price, consumer price environment, which is not inflationary.
In fact, it ends up being deflationary. Consumer prices, including those of energy and gasoline, will fall very quickly when we get into that sort of a situation.
So if energy prices continue to go as they are now, absent the money printing, which is not there, I don't care what Joe Biden has to say. The market says unequivocally the guy has no clue, just like Jay Powell has no clue, and just like economists don't have any idea what goes on in the monetary The bond market is telling you unequivocally that no matter how high energy prices get in the short run, it's not going to stick around for the long run because it just cannot. It's not actual inflation. It's a temporary trend that's based upon, as you said, supply factors and supply shock factors alone. And because of that, it's not an economy-wide, it's not a global situation that's going to last for very long because it can't.
Without the money printing, you can't get it. Again, Milton Friedman in 1963. This was not conjecture, it was empirically based. And the best way we have of telling us what is going on in the monetary system, what is going on in the real economy, not just today, but what is the best type of information or best real-time argument that we can make about what the future is likely to look like when the 10-year US Treasury is now what, 1.6%?
Even though it's up over the last couple weeks, I mean, that is an incredibly low rate. And I haven't even got to real yields yet, which are unbelievably ugly. So what the bond market is saying, this is not me, this is the bond market is saying, and bond market, by the way, that's the people who actually do the money in the global Eurodollar system.
So they're already telling you the money's not there. The money's not going to be there at any real probability for the future. And so this isn't inflation. This is just like the pre-1955 supply shocks where once they run their course, they will run their course and the CPI will eventually go back down and energy prices will eventually go back down. Whether or not that's triggered by a recession or not, that remains to be seen. But we're already seeing some signs that that's the case. This global growth scare that's emerging even in the mainstream narrative, we're seeing a lot of these transitory effects as transitory because without the money printing, it just won't And that's really, you know, moving forward in the slide deck here from '13, you know, to '14 to '15 and '16, '17 and beyond.
What I'm showing people is that what is the monetary system saying? What is it looking at? And the theme this year has been, as you point out, Erik, it's been inflation, inflation, inflation. And for people to pay attention to the Federal Reserve or even broadly monetary conditions, it's been too much money, too much money, too much money, whether bank reserves, the reverse repo, any number of things.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jeff Snider: Things. And yet, when you look at these indications, not just the bond yields, and it's not just US Treasuries either, these are bond yields all over the world. But we have TIC data, we have Chinese data, we have all sorts of data that tells us that it's not inflationary money in 2021.
It's the opposite. We have deflationary conditions rising throughout this year, which eventually lead into some sort of downturn, if not global recession, which will end any secular price trend in energy and everything else real quick. So the entire monetary system and the markets that trade off them, again, they're unequivocal in saying that whatever's happening in these consumer prices right now is not going to last. It's just, it can't last.
Erik Townsend: Jeff, I have to comment on slide number 14 because boy, every doomsday blogger on the internet back around 2009, '10, '11, '12 was writing the same story, which is you better watch out because what's coming What's coming is foreigners, foreign holders of US Treasuries are going to divest their US Treasury holdings. When that happens, it is going to outright crash the US Treasury market. We're going to have hyperinflation— my favorite word that people love to misuse— of the US dollar. It's coming as soon as those foreigners divest their Treasury holdings. Well, guess what? As you show in this chart, they were exactly right that foreigners were going to divest.
Jeff Snider: Right.
Erik Townsend: their Treasury holdings wholesale, just outright dumping them.
Jeff Snider: Yeah, they dumped them.
Erik Townsend: They dumped them. And there's no hyperinflation, and I don't think that the phenomenon that we're seeing right now is a result of that. What happened there, and what does it mean? Why didn't the dumping of foreign holdings of US Treasuries cause a crash in the bond market back when you saw this activity?
And now we're getting some inflation at a time when it looks like foreigners are actually starting to reinvest at least slightly in the Treasury market. It seems backwards.
Jeff Snider: It is backwards. And it's a fundamental misconception of how the global monetary system works. And again, it's understandable why people would say this and at least start to think about it, because it sounds intuitive, right? And if we've been told for years that without foreign buying of US Treasuries specifically, but also US dollars more broadly, that those markets would be toast, they would be without the foreign demand for Treasuries, Screw it. The treasuries are going to be—they're going to be worthless because we need foreigners because of people's theories on capital accounts and things like that.
But in the eurodollar system, as you can see clearly on the chart here, what actually happens in reality is that when there's more dollars in this offshore monetary system flowing all the way out, you know, through the vast corners of the global system, what happens is they end up in official hands—either central bankers or finance ministries—and those central bankers and finance ministries. They like to create a pile of reserves, which they think are some form of insurance against a dollar short in 1997-98, you know, Asian financial crisis type situation. And they like to invest those dollars in low-risk, high-liquidity assets like US Treasuries. So those things are always related. More dollars flowing in the Eurodollar system, more dollars end up in foreign official hands, more dollars end up being reinvested by these foreign officials in US Treasuries in particular, also agency and GSE debt as well. As well, so around as you can see, you know, foreigners tend to have problems when there's dollar problems in the global eurodollar system.
That started in August of 2007 and continued to 2008, which was nothing more than a global dollar shortage. And if you have a global dollar shortage, obviously there's fewer dollars flowing to these foreign central banks, which means they can't buy as many treasuries as they might have beforehand. And so, in the rare and more extreme situations of a dollar shortage. Whereas these foreign reserve managers actually have to sell their Treasuries to try to make up their dollar shortfall that the Eurodollar market isn't doing. That we have tightness in the Eurodollar market that causes problems for local banks and central banks sell their— they liquidate their reserve assets to try to supply dollars temporarily into the market. And so by the time we get to 2014, the global dollar shortage from the global financial crisis proved to be a series of crises, a series of shortages, not a one-off and limited to 2008, 2009. But 2014 was a particularly bad one that especially hit emerging markets like China.
And the Chinese and other foreign countries decided they needed to react to this growing dollar tightness by selling their US Treasury. It wasn't because they hated Treasury. It wasn't because they hated the dollar. It wasn't because they hated the Federal Reserve's printing money. In fact, they were reacting to the opposite of money printing. They were reacting to tightness.
So whenever you see foreigners, particularly central banks and foreign officials, institutions selling Treasuries, what that means is that there's a tightness of dollar funding outside the United States as well as inside, but mostly outside the United States. So it's a very good signal of tight money. And what you can see in 2020 and 2021 is that, yeah, we had a little bit of reflation up until around April of this year. And ever since then, it's been going the opposite way. So we've had tightening in the Eurodollar system. Which has led to, again, renewed, a little bit of renewed selling. But once the selling starts, it becomes difficult to stop. So it's falling US Treasuries or selling Treasuries. It's not a negative for the Treasury market. It's a negative for the monetary— it's a negative sign for the monetary system. And as you can see, those things go together because what have Treasury prices done since 2014? Just like the dollar's exchange value, both have gone up dramatically.
Because we're talking about deflationary money embedded within all of those processes.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So let's talk about what you think is going to happen, because it sounds like what you're saying is you agree with me and Ole Hansen that the lack of investment in producing oil resources is likely to lead to an oil price or energy price shock, which will probably be transmitted into a broader consumer price shock. But you're saying, okay, that's not monetary inflation and it's going to result in— essentially, it sounds like it'll bring on a recession, which is deflationary and everything corrects. Is that what happens or what happens from there?
Jeff Snider: Yeah, I think the energy prices make a bad situation that's already bad, makes it that much worse and more painful. Because again, consumers are paying more at the pump and they're doing so— it's not like their wages or their pay is rising to match the prices that they're paying. And it's not just obviously gasoline or energy prices. It in all sorts of supply shock-driven markets just for regular consumer goods, for example. Automobiles, another perfect example, which I have a couple slides for that. But yeah, that's what the market judgment is saying. We have on the one hand, not only do we not have the money printing that makes it monetary inflation or inflation going forward, we actually have the opposite trend starting to develop, which is deflationary or tightness in the monetary system.
We see this in any number of indications, data, and markets, including, by the way, inflation expectations in the TIPS market. If you go to slide 18, slide 17, you see the rising dollar. Rising dollar's always a negative sign. That's always a sign of tight money, just as it was in 2018 when the Reserve Bank of India's Governor Urjit Patel saw funding dry up in the dollar markets so badly while everybody was convinced that was gonna be an inflationary period. He's saying, wait the hell, out here in the rest of the emerging markets, dollar funding has evaporated. So rising dollar, you equate with tightness in money as you would some things that are going on in the Chinese People's Bank of China's balance sheet, which are dollar deposits that are being demanded from their local banks.
And even in just TIPS market, we see a surge in short-run inflation expectations, but yet the TIPS curve or the inflation breakeven curve itself is upside down. And lately it's upside down in absolutely record fashion, which is the market saying, short-run CPI, long-run less CPI, which you get to slide 19, which is longer-run inflation expectations, the 5-year, 5-year forward rate. And you can see even today, even as short-run inflation breakevens in the TIPS market are through the roof, long-run inflation expectations remain in that same post-2014 state that like officials selling their US Treasuries, is more deflationary or disinflationary than it is inflationary.
So every part of the Treasury market as well as the global bond market is uniformly saying this is not inflation. And whatever's happening in terms of the CPI, it's not going to last very long. And that's a term of art. And you're right to— that's sort of a cop-out too, Erik, because you say, well, it's not going to last very long. And the question immediately is, well, how long is it going to last if you say saying it's temporary or transitory, how long might it last? And the thing is, we don't really know, but the market is almost positive. It's unequivocal that it's not going to last. And historically speaking, some of these supply shocks can go on for a year or more.
Erik Townsend: Jeff, as I look through the next few slides in the deck, I see that you're saying a lot of the same things that I'm saying in terms of there are factors which, you're right, they're not technically monetary inflation, per se, but I think there's going to be an energy price-led consumer price increase, and it's going to result in a broader— the cost of energy is an input cost to almost everything. So, broader cost of everything from shipping to widgets to office supplies is going to go up.
And I see all of that coming. You're saying that technically that's not being driven by monetary inflation, But I'd like to challenge your conclusion that what it leads to is, okay, you said people's wages are not going up, so it's going to end up being deflationary because the economy can't afford it and those high energy prices cripple everything. Well, let's try a thought experiment. What if we take the President of the United States at his word? He says he's going to throw money at the problem of inflation, which is not usually what most textbooks tell you you do with inflation. But I think I think we should take him at his word. Suppose that what they do is they say, look, we gotta let inflation run hot because we've got to do something to devalue the real purchasing power of the national debt. We've gotta get the national debt under control. The way to do that is to inflate it away.
If we inflate it away, it's going to damage the lower-end income people in society the most. So hey, let's use this new MMT stuff. And Just print up a shitload of money and hand it out and say, look, yeah, we're going to let inflation run hot and we'll identify some boogeyman overseas who doesn't look like us. Hey, OPEC+, it must be their fault. And let's blame the Russians too, because, you know, Russians, they're to blame for everything.
Jeff Snider: And the Chinese.
Erik Townsend: We're going to blame— oh yeah, that's right.
Jeff Snider: Got to get the Chinese in there.
Erik Townsend: It's those stinking Chinese and their stockpiling of oil. That's got to be part of this. And those stinking Russians and those OPEC, those Arabs. Ooh, bad guys. Okay, we've got lots of boogeymen. We've got lots of people to scapegoat and blame.
And what we're going to do is say the Biden administration has got your back. We're going to take care of hardworking Americans by printing more money and exacerbating it. Maybe it wasn't monetary inflation when it started, Jeff, but I have complete confidence in the people in Washington, D.C. to respond to this by saying we're going to print up enough money to turn it into monetary inflation. And what we're gonna do is a whole bunch of transfer payments and handouts in order to buy off the populace so that they don't blame us for this. We'll blame the monetary inflation for people who have savings that are losing the value of their savings. We'll blame it on foreigners who don't look like us. There's plenty of those to choose from. And we'll just print money like it's going out of style with MMT in order to basically provide government transfer payments in order to solve that problem.
That doesn't lead to a deflationary result. And that's where you get to, I think, potentially not only secular inflation, but maybe even the beginnings of runaway inflation, not quite hyperinflation, but it could really start to run away to the point where they can't control it. That's what I see on the horizon. What's wrong with that theory?
Jeff Snider: Well, again, I go back to the bond market. The bond market hears and has discounted everything that you've just said because the bond market isn't some kind of, you know, some centralized person, some enlightened philosopher in a room. Staring at computer screens and listening to chats and things like that, the bond market is everywhere in everything. It's essentially a broad-based information system, sort of like big data, that is situated very close to the real economy. It actually is the big banks who run the monetary system as it is currently constituted, and it has looked at your situation, looked at your scenario, and it is pricing it as essentially a zero percent chance of happening. Well, you never say never. So maybe it's a, you know, 1/10 of 1% chance of happening. But as I said earlier, we have this information stream, this information sorting mechanism that tells you something very specific about the future.
It looks at the long run, the same long run that you're looking at, Erik, using the same information that you're using and the same pricing these, you know, hypothetically pricing these scenarios in the same way that you are.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jeff Snider: And it's saying they're not— it's not a realistic chance. The money isn't there.
Erik Townsend: Well, wait a minute. Why is the bond market saying that? Why is it not that the bond market is saying, well, yeah, all that stuff I just described could happen, but as part of that, the Federal Reserve's gonna continue printing money to also buy bonds in order to keep interest rates—
Jeff Snider: The Fed doesn't print money. That's— I mean, that's— it gets back to, do we understand what actually printing money means? Because I don't think people do.
Erik Townsend: Okay, let's not get hung up. Let's assume that there is another big round of quantitative easing so that we're creating bank reserves and that that is depressing the long-term interest rates and keeping those bond yields down. So it's suppressing— you've got to—
Jeff Snider: Absolutely not. That is not happening. That has never happened. Bond yields react most of the time opposite of quantitative easing. Erik, you gotta just look at a bond yield chart. And it shows you that when the Fed is buying bonds, interest rates tend to rise, not fall. And when the Fed stops buying bonds— and it's not just the Fed, you can look at the ECB, look at German bond yields in 2018 and 2019— German bond yields were falling as Mario Draghi stopped buying German bonds. They kept going down. The Fed does not control the interest rate, and the Federal Reserve nor any central bank is controlling any interest rates right now. They are not artificially depressing the bond market. That's not how this works.
And you could even ask the central bankers themselves, read the literature on quantitative easing. It all uniformly says bond market sets the interest rate and the yields in the real economy. And yields, as we all know, are about growth and inflation. So, you can't just wave your hand and dismiss these low yields as some kind of artificial signal that the Fed wants to send, that it's artificially depressing yields.
That's just not happening. And it hasn't happened. The bond market is independently assessing growth and inflation opportunities as it has since there's ever been a bond And it's saying, we see all of these things and we agree in uniform that we don't see consumer prices breaking out on some secular trend for reasons of money or not money.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So, your argument is basically the bond market is essentially always right or almost always right. And how accurate does the history in your estimation prove that out?
Jeff Snider: As I just went through in the entire first half of the presentation, it's pretty damn accurate. You know, the bond yields started rising in anticipation of the Great Inflation. The Great Inflation. So if we're moving into a second Great Inflation and bond yields are not moving and anticipating a second Great Inflation, why not? What has changed? What has changed? And you can't answer the Federal Reserve because that's lazy analysis, Erik. It's— you haven't even looked.
All you need to do is look at a yield chart and to know that the Federal Reserve does not have much of an impact on yields. Yeah. It's exclusively growth and inflation expectations that are being set in the market. And as I said before, the market is not some narrow clique that has, you know, that's trying to price some political agenda. It is a very broad-based global monetary system. It's the market that trades closest to the global monetary system that tells you what's going on in terms of money, what's going on in terms of the real economy, and what's really what everybody thinks is going to be happening in this marketplace. Place for the foreseeable future. Now, it's of course, it's not perfect. It's not, it's, you know, it's not a crystal ball.
But historically speaking, over the last century and more, it has been the best, most useful, most accurate tool for assessing inflation potential. Not CPIs, but inflation potential. And that's what we're really talking about here. And so yeah, the bond market's judgment right now is that for the last year or so that we've been hearing about all this stuff, for the last year that we've seen the supply shock And for now that we have this 6.2% CPI, that's the highest in 30 years, the judgment hasn't changed. The bond market still says this is non-economic stuff. It's painful. It's causing enough pain on top of a bad deflationary situation that is likely to result in an adjustment, an adjustment in the real economy that nets out over time to not inflation.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So to summarize, you're saying that you do agree that a significant increase in consumer prices led by energy is very possible. But because the bond market is telling us that it is not anticipating that turning into monetary inflation, you think that Janet is essentially right, that it is transitory. It's going to happen. It's, you know, we're going to see that big energy-led increase in prices, but it's not inflation, and it's all going to reverse because it's going to lead to pressure on the economy that takes us the other direction.
Jeff Snider: Yeah, and I love how you framed it that way, putting me on the same side as Janet Yellen.
Erik Townsend: That was pretty evil.
Jeff Snider: Yeah, I know. Well, you, you had to smile a little bit when you did that. No, it makes me tremendously uncomfortable to be, you know, to say I agree with Jay Powell and Janet Yellen, but, you know, they might be right for the wrong reasons. But yeah, and again—
Erik Townsend: Okay, we got a title for this episode. Jeff Snider, I Agree with Janet Yellen and Jay Powell.
Jeff Snider: Clickbait. Clickbait. No, no, no, no. But it's it's sad but true, and I think you know she's right for the wrong reasons. And it's it really your summarization is correct. I think we have these supply factors. We have a classic supply shock that's being that's that's developed, and it's it's especially over the last couple months, it's becoming extremely painful, and it becomes more painful by the day and by the week. And that eventually, without the money printing, without actual money in the economy—in fact, we have deflationary money in the global economy.
That's why the bond yields are so low. It's not the Fed. It's the fact that the bond market is saying, again, broad survey of actual real-time economic conditions that whatever happens in energy markets, it's not gonna lead to runaway secular inflation.
Erik Townsend: Jeff, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. But before I let you go, I wanna touch on a few of the other things that our listeners can do to follow your work. The first, if you haven't done it already, is definitely listen to Eurodollar University, which is several hours. I've forgotten how I don't know how many. Of Jeff's analysis and explanation of how the offshore wholesale US dollar funding system really works. And I've got to say, in all of the interviews that I've done on MacroVoices over the years, we've got a lot of opinions, a lot of viewpoints, and there's always somebody coming back saying, oh, that guy doesn't know what he's talking about. Ole Hansen doesn't even know what he's talking about. David Hay doesn't know what he's talking about. And usually people come back and say, Jeff Snider, that guy's over my head. I'm not sure what he's talking about. So I haven't heard the argument that says Jeff's wrong.
heard the, we don't know what he's talking about. And I think Eurodollar University is a great place to start. But also tell us a little bit more, you and our good friend Emil Kalinowski are producing your own podcast. What's that about and where can people follow it?
Jeff Snider: It's really an extension of what you and I started out doing, Erik, which is Eurodollar University, trying to explain the monetary system. And yeah, we have our own podcast that you can find on YouTube. It's called Eurodollar University's Making Sense, where we try to make sense of money printing, CPIs, bond yields, and all, you know, Federal Reserve policy and all these other things.
Again, you can find it on YouTube, you can find it on wherever you get your podcast downloads too.
Erik Townsend: And that all builds on the work that we did at MacroVoices.com/edu, which is probably the very first place to start. And also, of course, you guys manage money at Alhambra Investments. You can find information about that at AlhambraPartners.com. Jeff, I can't thank you enough. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message. From our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com.
escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was, uh, great to have Jeff back on the show. And you know, it really did get my hamster wheel turning because really, uh, this inflation has been truly supply And these commodities running higher are sprinkling higher prices everywhere. But he does make very valid points in terms of the fact that there isn't really the monetary drivers behind it that are gonna suggest that this is anything more than a supply shock. I mean, at least it's an interesting argument to consider. What did you take away from it?
Erik Townsend: Well, I still see very strong arguments in favor of secular inflation. And as I described, I think the political backdrop is very good. just set up for governments to respond with, you know, more stimulus, more stimulus, more largesse, and I think driving more money into the economy and driving prices higher. I think the strongest reaction I had to this interview is it really makes me want to do a little bit of homework and due diligence because Jeff is a very detail-oriented guy who, in my experience, knows his stuff.
Stuff. Now, he's making an argument that there has never been a significant inflation that was not preceded by long bond yields predicting it. And he showed that fantastic chart which told us that even though everybody thinks that August 15th, 1971, when President Nixon took us off the gold standard, was an unforeseeable event that brought on the Great Inflation and nobody could have known it was coming. In actuality, the bond market predicted it years in advance.
Is Jeff's research completely solid? And is it really true that the bond market always forecasts and predicts significant inflations? If that's really true, then boy, his argument is hard to argue. I feel like maybe some of our listeners know better than I do, or some of the other folks that we've had on as feature interview guests who have argued for secular inflation, which is certainly still my
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Any of you have done their homework and know better than I do, because I can't argue with Jeff. He's got better data than I have, and his graphs and charts are much more detailed than my personal research. I would love to hear the counterargument from somebody who's ready to explain specifically why it is that Jeff has it wrong when he says the bond market has always anticipated and predicted significant inflations. If Jeff has that wrong, I'd love to know who can prove that, and maybe we can get them on the show.
But right now, Patrick, I want to move on to the postgame chart deck, which is titled Can the Trends Continue?
Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you haven't yet subscribed at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, what do we have going on here with the euro? You usually start your chart decks with the S&P. How come we're looking at the Eurodollar cross this week?
Patrick Ceresna: Uh, because I wanted to basket all the equities together, and so we're going to put— we'll look at that a little bit further into the chart deck. But, uh, uh, I still do want to talk the S&P, and there's some interesting stuff to, to point out about it. But anyway, let's talk the euro. I just really want to highlight that the US dollar has literally been in a very predominant new breakout on the upside, but it's been very much driven by a breakdown in the euro. This has been, uh, it's not only the largest component of the dollar index from a trade-weighted basis, but it's also been one of the weakest currencies by far. Uh, where we've entered a zone around 113 where there's some Fib zones, some previous highs, lows, a level where arguably the euro could muster up a reaction. And what one of the key things I'm going to be watching is, uh, when we do get this bounce— we already started a bit of a bounce— can the euro bulls muster up something more than a, a 100 pip reaction.
If all we get is a quick bounce back to 114, 115 that is stalling out, it'll be interesting to see whether the trend continues on the downside of the euro.
Patrick Ceresna: And that's certainly something I'm watching. All right, so Erik, though, I wanted to move on to page 3 where I have that crude oil chart. And so we can really see that after a really amazing run through September into early October where crude oil tacked on close to $25 on the upside. We've really retested the highs and started to break down in this correction. There's some Fib zones that suggest that we could go into the mid-70s during a correction. At least I'm siding with the idea that this is still going to be a buy on dip. I look at that correction and compare a lot to the consolidations we saw both in March and through July and August, which is the market just pauses, takes a period to backfill some of the rally, and then just resumes in bullish manner.
At least that's my starting base case. What's your call on this? And also, you wanted to talk a little bit about what's going on in the oil markets.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I said in the market wrap, I think that this is definitely a buy-the-dip opportunity that is upcoming. Maybe this morning on Thursday morning was a bottom. It did touch the 55-day moving average, and actually going back more than a year now to November of 2020, that 55-day moving average has pretty much held the market So there is an argument that this is already over. The thing is, the Biden administration, with all of its rhetoric around energy prices, has, I think, painted itself into a political corner where it has little choice but to, quote, do something about energy prices. The thing is, there's not much that the Biden administration can do about energy prices. The widely circulated rumor is that President Biden was supposedly almost pleading with President Xi Xi in China about asking President Xi to participate with a coordinated— it sounds like maybe the Biden Administration was trying to architect a global coordinated Strategic Petroleum Reserve release where they could somehow organize all the world leaders to agree that it was time to release from their Strategic Petroleum Reserves in order to bring prices down.
Now, it's tempting to say that no world leader other than Joe Biden could possibly be stupid enough to think that an SPR release is the the right way to address this problem. But it does appear that President Biden is having some success with persuading other world leaders, at least. And, you know, it makes me wonder what it is that President Biden offered in return in exchange for these favors. But China did announce just today that a release from its strategic reserve is in the works, although that announcement seems a little bit vague to me. And it makes me wonder if other world leaders are being pressured to cooperate with President Biden with a token or symbolic release, which I doubt is going to be very substantial. But this information is just coming out as we're going to airtime here. So it'll be interesting to see what happens in the next couple of days.
But the Biden administration is clearly going to try to do what they can to persuade other world leaders to participate in what I think is virtue signaling nonsense that has nothing to do with real long-term supply and demand fundamentals, but what clearly could impact the market in coming days and weeks ahead.
So it'll be interesting to see how this develops. So the next question is, what can the Biden Administration do with just a US SPR release? And again, the SPR, the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, was created after the 1973 oil embargo, and its purpose is to protect national security if there was an import embargo or some other So if there's some other issue that affected the ability of the United States to continue to function without imported oil, there's basically a buffer that is intended to protect us there. That Strategic Petroleum Reserve, the language around it is pretty darn clear that it's there for a bunch of purposes that have nothing to do with bailing the Biden Administration out of high energy prices due to policies that frankly were created by the Biden Administration.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: So it's not what it's there for, but the thing is, the way that the law is worded, the government has the authority to sell up to 30 million barrels if the president believes that the current situation might lead to an emergency, and they can sell an unlimited amount of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve if an actual emergency exists.
The thing is, what defines when an actual emergency exists? Exists, the language of that law is pretty darn clear. It's whenever the president says so. So as soon as President Biden is willing to use the word emergency to describe the situation, he's allowed to do whatever the hell he wants. And I think that the potential for him to do something foolish, which both undermines national security and doesn't actually achieve the intended goal and potentially sets up a situation Where you end up with exacerbating the problem because of the SPR release and the ultimate need to later resupply the SPR.
I think it's all a whole bunch of bad politics in play. But I also think that there is really not a lot of limitation preventing the Biden Administration from doing something very foolish, which could shock prices to the downside as people say, oh my gosh, the Biden Administration just sold, you know, whatever it is, 100 million barrels.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. Yeah.
Erik Townsend: We released 500 million barrels out of the SPR, and now, you know, we're $10 lower on crude oil prices. I'm already starting to accumulate calls on crude oil futures, just in very small size this morning, because I don't think it's over yet. I'll be a little more aggressive as we get to lower prices. And if we get to much lower prices, I'll really back the truck up because I'm convinced that this is not going to last.
Erik Townsend: Now, what if the SPR release is not enough? The next thing the Biden Administration might consider consider would be to at least temporarily outlaw the export of US crude oil, keep it in the United States in order to protect Americans.
Now, if you've listened to my interviews with Pat Hemsworth or Anas Alhajji over the years, you know that that doesn't accomplish the stated goal because crude quality matters. And what we have coming out of the US shale patch is ultra-light sweet crude, which you can't even do anything with in a US refinery until you blend it with heavy blendstock, with heavier sour oil that creates a grade of oil after blending that is suitable for refining. The way you get more of that, if you were actually trying to solve this problem, would be to look— and this is something that the Biden administration ought to consider since they seem to be very much focused on undoing anything that President Trump did— if you were to get Iran and Venezuelan imports coming back in. That provides you with the blend stock that you need if you actually wanted to disallow US exports. If you had that blend stock, which Iran and Venezuela are both excellent sources of, then you might be able to do something with that extra oil.
But if you just outlaw exports, what you're gonna do is you're going to create an imbalanced situation where there's a whole bunch of oil piling up that nobody can refine because they don't have enough blend stock in order to create a refinable grade out of it. You would think that the President of the United States and his administration would be smart enough to understand this stuff, but history teaches us they don't. They think crude oil is crude oil, and if we stop exporting it, we'll have more, and that just solves the problem. They don't think it through beyond that level, so far as I can tell. So I don't think that a ban on US exports is going to accomplish anything either, and frankly, I don't I don't think there's anything that the Biden administration can do to change the fact that we have an extremely bullish setup here. There has been a lack of investment in finding new producing resources that is, over the next several years, going to set up much, much higher prices.
Part of that is the ESG trend, and part of that is Biden administration policies. What the Biden administration appears to want to do next is to vilify big oil and blame the oil companies and blame OPEC+. OPEC+ and create even more enemies. These things are not going to help bring the price of energy down in the long run, but they could very well result in a short-term spike down. And if so, I think it's a tremendous buying opportunity. In any event, Patrick, let's move on since I just hijacked your whole chart deck for way longer than I was supposed to there, to slide 4.
Erik Townsend: It's your turn again since it's your chart deck. What's going on with silver futures?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, uh, what is interesting for me is, is that silver has been in a pronounced downtrend, uh, ever since putting in that January February highs, uh, at the start of the year.
Erik Townsend: It's going to $1,000, dude. I read it on Wall Street Silver.
Patrick Ceresna: Definitely. And, uh, but, uh, but one way or another, what we finally seen, uh, in September was, uh, a blow-off bottom. And what may be developing is an inverted head and shoulders pattern breakout that may be setting in motion a new trend. It's interesting because silver, obviously cousin to gold, is breaking out roughly Roughly about the same time, which is nice to see that the two are more or less running in unison. But it'll be interesting to see whether this is the beginning of a new bull run on silver with much more reasonable targets than $1,000.
Erik Townsend: And on page 5, finally, the S&P chart. I knew it was coming eventually.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: And there hasn't been a break. There hasn't been a new high for a whole week. My God, the market is crashing.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what? It is interesting because in very typical fashion, There was a very large— it is option expiration tomorrow, the OPEX into a monthly expiry. And there is a lot of gamma in those options. There's huge open interest. I was just reading Charlie McElligott's piece. There's a huge amount of gamma open interest at the 4,700 strike, something to the tune of $9 billion. And above there at 4,750 on the S&P is another $6.7 billion. And so with us going into this option It creates a bit of a gamma pin. It's the most common reaction is to see the markets just chop into this 4,700, and that is very not a shocker that we're trading exactly there going into Friday. With that said, what will be really interesting is volatility typically returns in the post-opex period. The volatility can be both directions, so we don't want to immediately paint it bearish. It could also be an explosive volatility. Delta move to the upside that happens.
But what's interesting is that going into this expiration, the, um, the S&P net delta was at the 99.9th percentile since 2013. But yet we have 24% of the delta rolling off and 29% of the gamma. And it's even greater on the NASDAQ, which is also in the 99th percentile, and you've got 42% of delta and 49% of Gamma rolling off. So what that implies is that it's like a thumb being pressed down on something. It's suppressing the volatility.
That thumb is being lifted. Which direction the volatility goes is something that I'll be watching next week. It's gonna— it's likely to be a move. And so I'm curious as to whether or not that's gonna be the bullish continuation higher or whether an overdue market correction begins.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, on page 6, you've got the consumer discretionary ETF, XLY. Why that particular chart.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's been one of the big leadership ones. It's up, you know, 30 to 40% on the year, uh, and it's been running. And it really looks like this entire space has been just such a huge bull run. And I wanted to dig in a little bit onto this ETF because most people, when they own a diversified ETF like this, they assume that they're getting the benefit of diversification, that there's— they're holding a big basket of these discretionary names. But when we look on page and look at the breakdown, basically Amazon is 20% of this index, Tesla is 20% of the index, and Home Depot is another 10%. I'm rounding, of course, but basically 3 stocks make up 50% of the holdings of this ETF.
And when you look at their performance, uh, looking at the industry breakdown on the, on the right, the, that automobile space, which is basically dominated by Tesla, contributes contributed 1,700 basis points to that performance. This has basically been a Tesla fund. I mean, the holding is almost double of what Cathie Wood holds in ARK, and it's been really one of the big drivers of this performance. And what I'm curious about, like, again, the whole title of this chart deck is, can these trends continue? This has been a sector that has been dominated by the performance of Tesla. And when we look at page 8, Tesla had that extraordinary gamma squeeze that happened throughout October that saw this amazing run on the upside, and it has stalled. And one of the big questions for me going into, into next week and the week after is, uh, is there more upside on Tesla? Can, can this all just keep feeding on itself and make another run? And will it, or have we seen this all blow off.
And now I don't want to make any crazy bold predictions, but boy, is that on my mind for next week.
Erik Townsend: Well, you didn't mention, I mean, it seems to me the blow-off top here was entirely about Elon Musk's little virtue signaling moment of pretending that he was supposedly trying to be sensitive to political pressures and feelings about unrealized gains when he basically sold a shitload of stock because he knows this shit is ridiculous. ridiculously overvalued, and even he's not that stupid. At least that's how I interpret it. So I question how much more selling Elon is going to do under false pretenses and how many people are going to wake up to the ridiculous overvaluation of this stock. Where does that come into this analysis, or how do you see that fitting into the equation?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's all a part of it. I mean, ultimately, if it was driven by a gamma squeeze, it's no different than a much bigger version of GameStop and see in the end when, uh, when all of that, uh, gets exhausted and runs through the system, then, uh, the stock mean reverts in a big way. It, uh, and I, I think Elon Musk is taking advantage of it, uh, and, and doing some selling like, uh, any smart investor would do after being lucky enough to hold it on the way up. Anyway, I, I certainly don't blame him for selling some. I would have done the same.
Erik Townsend: Well, Michael Burry has been Very outspoken on that. We heard a rumor that Michael Burry is a regular listener of MacroVoices. If that's true, sir, we would love to be the first one to persuade you to do an interview, 'cause we'd do it better than those idiots on CNBC. Anyway, moving on.
Patrick Ceresna: Moving on. Yeah, let's touch on the emerging markets on page 9. And what I just wanna highlight is emerging markets are flat on the year, just have not had anything to do with this upside on the market. Struggling places like Brazil, the China, A lot of the Asian markets have been dogging it. Generally, emerging markets have been stuck in the mud. And what is interesting about this is when you look at page 10, I thought it was a really interesting factor analysis of looking at the emerging markets against the S&P 500 going back a decade. And what's amazing is just how much relative outperformance the S&P 500 has against emerging markets. This has been an extraordinary bull run in the S&P on a relative basis, and this trend has been dominant for a decade. At some point, especially if driven by a commodity turnaround— obviously emerging markets are struggling a bit, everything from, you know, being behind the curve on COVID to the fact that the US dollar's been strong— but at some stage, uh, I think that there might be an opportunity to catch a trend change in this.
Obviously, this is not something that— a 10-year trend does not turn on a dime in a week or two. But, uh, boy, is it going to be interesting to see when emerging markets start to come back into play.
Erik Townsend: 10-year trend, and I'm sure it has nothing to do with quantitative easing and central bank largesse during the period.
Patrick Ceresna: No, it couldn't. It couldn't.
Erik Townsend: Can't be. Just a coincidence. Gotta be. And of course, listeners, if you enjoy Patrick's And if you want to get those chart decks, you can get them every single day with a free trial of Big Picture Trading, Patrick's service. You'll find information on page 11 or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective. Because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find a transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Jeffrey Snider's chart deck and the chart book we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to an FT article, The FOMO Rally: Fear of Missing Out Helps Fuel the Soaring Markets, and a Jesse Felder article, The Fasten the Seatbelt Sign Just Lit Up. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please Register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge.
You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is. Presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Ole Hansen — Saxo Bank commodity strategy chief (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 297 was recorded on November 11th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Saxo Bank commodity strategy chief Ole Hansen returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the outlook for commodities with the macro backdrop of secular inflation, which Ole sees on the near horizon, including a discussion of whether gold, copper, or other commodities will be the best inflation hedges for what lies ahead. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck is titled Tour of the Commodity Markets.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's jump straight to talking markets here. S&P 500 had a run where almost for a month it was going up almost every single day. We cleared 4,700 on the upside, and here we finally get the market pausing. A little bit of a thing that I wouldn't even wanna call this a market correction because it's just not deep enough. But finally, some, maybe the inflation numbers kind of spooked the market a little bit. What's your take? Is there more upside for the market from here?
Erik Townsend: I think there's plenty more upside. The thing that I find most interesting about this, Patrick, is the way people are reacting to it. What we had, Patrick, as you alluded to, was 16 out of 18 consecutive trading days being huge up candles. And then we got 2 tiny little down days, not even getting all the way down to the 13-day moving average. And I hear people freaking out about how the market is crashing online.
Look, this is not a crashing market. If you guys want to know over in the equity world what volatility looks like, come on over to the crude oil pit. We've got volatility there. Honest. For sure. This is not volatility. This is not a correction. This is not even a hiccup. This is an actual down day, 2 of them in a row. Oh my goodness. After 18 up days, we've got— I'm concerned, Patrick, that there is so much complacency that someday when we actually do see downside in the market, people are really gonna freak out. But for what I see here, there's no reason for concern.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index. I'm gonna have it charted in the postgame on it, but it finally broke out of its 1-month range highs. Above 94.50. Do you think there's something behind this?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's fascinating that both gold and the dollar broke out, very much consistent with a prediction we've had here on MacroVoices for years. You know, a lot of people think that gold and the dollar just have to be inversely correlated all the time. And clearly, that's not the case. But finally, we got something to talk about. We do have this, you know, clearly upside breakout in the dollar beyond its trading range. You know, I am convinced that the Luke Gromen view about the dollar fading out of relevance is He's going to be proven right in the end someday, but I don't think someday is here yet.
And I think the Brent Johnson view that we've had on the program quite a few times in the past, describing the reasons why, even though maybe the dollar's prominence as the world's global reserve currency is slowly coming to an end, that slow coming to an end process is likely to happen in the form of dollar scarcity and the dollar index increasing, not decreasing, into this. So I think maybe we're seeing the beginning of Luke being put on hold and Brent being proven right, at least in the short term. But let's give it a few more weeks and see what happens. This is a brand new trend.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, what I'm watching there, the euro has a whole bunch of different— like, the one level I'm interested in is if the euro gets down to about the 113 level. And so there's a little bit of further room for this follow-through, but we're going to come to, I think, a pretty interesting technical level. I'll be watching for sure.
Patrick Ceresna: Let's talk crude oil though, Erik, because it really looked like that at the start of the week that crude oil was setting up for a break to new highs, like maybe 90 was in the the cards and pretty strong reversal day the other day. And the question now is, what's your take here? I mean, is there— is this just a pause and that crude oil is still poised to go higher on that, or is this consolidation gonna continue?
Erik Townsend: Well, I wouldn't even call it consolidation. I would call it extreme volatility in the face of White House-driven political theater. And to be sure, it's theater. It's not economic reality, folks. So what's going on here this week? Prices were up and up hard on Wednesday afternoon when API, that's the private service, not the government service, Reported a drawdown in crude oil inventories. And of course, seasonally, we should be expecting builds this time of year. So a drawdown is a really bullish signal. That took us up not quite to last week's highs, but pretty darn close, or 2 weeks ago highs. I'm not sure. We, as you say, it looked like we were hitting almost $85 there, breaking out to the upside. Seemed like there was just, you know, no limits to things. Then we got a combination of data reports on Wednesday.
The EIA inventory report shows crude oil building 1 million barrels nationally, not drawing down. Well, okay, wait a minute. Look a little closer into that data. What it really shows is that the commercial oil drew down 2.1 million barrels. Then there was a release of 3.1 million barrels out of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. Net, that results in a build. But if you don't consider the Strategic Petroleum Reserve release, then there really was a drawdown, and it's a non-seasonal drawdown, and it should have been kind of a bullish signal. What else do we have in the data? Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 34,000 barrels, not nearly as big of a drawdown as we've seen in recent weeks. But as we get to finished products, still big drawdowns. Gasoline, 1.6 million barrel draw. Distillates, 2.6 million barrel drawdown. Boy, a lot of stuff being drawn down. Seems like that should be super bullish.
Why wasn't it? Well, the reason is combination of US inflation data, the dollar breaking out, and mostly, I think, President Joe Biden jawboning, talking about how he's going to battle with OPEC+ and blaming OPEC+ for current energy prices and so forth.
What we have, just to pull the big picture together, Joe Biden or any other president of the United States really has zero influence directly on supply and demand of crude oil. And frankly, I think all of this is political theatrics. But these are political theatrics being undertaken by the president of the United States. And that means just those theatrics can result in a tremendous amount of market volatility. And that's what we're seeing. So, you know, there could be plenty more volatility.
I'm not at all convinced that the bottom is in yet. But in the end, I am convinced that we're moving much higher in crude oil prices as we come finally to actually face reality, which is Joe Biden has no say in the fact that the fundamentals, some of which, by the way, are created by Biden administration policy, are very much favoring much higher prices to come. But They're not going to back off easily. There's a lot of political pressure on the White House right now to do something about OPEC+. So you can expect the White House to continue to play this political volley game. And I expect that the crude oil market is going to be whipsawed as a result of that. Buy the dips is my feeling here. I think we're going much higher, but maybe not for a while until all of this political theater is behind us.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. So let's talk gold.
Erik Townsend: Like, finally, there's something to talk about.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. I have a great chart I want to show actually in the postgame. But look, we've been in this trade range for— it feels like a year, but it's only like the real kind of sideways consolidation has been since the summer. But finally, that trade range has been resolved to the upside, at least for one day. I mean, I don't know whether we want to already do a victory lap that the bulls are back, but certainly some price action out of the trade range. What's your take?
Erik Townsend: Well, our regular listeners will remember just a couple of weeks ago, I was kind of criticizing the gold bug community who were saying, oh, look, there's a breakout in gold. And I was saying, look, That's not a breakout, but gold poked its head above a moving average for like 2 days and then reversed. That was a fake breakout, not a real breakout. Uh, channeling Joe Pesci here, Patrick, this— now this is what I call a freaking breakout. This is real. The thing is, it's, it's real, but the, the level that we care the most about, which is around $1,833 or so, uh, that's the level that But we're only a couple of days into this. Now, it looks really good because we got there through that level after a breakout from the moving averages down around $1,800 or so. And as we approach that next resistance at $1,833, it slowed down only for a day or so and then broke above it. And now we're continuing to break above.
Really looks good.
But I think what's much more interesting here is not the action in gold, but the correlations, because gold is breaking out to the upside at the same time that the dollar index is breaking out to the upside. And at the same time that crypto continues to do very well. Remember, one of my theories has been that the reason that gold has struggled here is that it's competing with crypto for a lot of market share. A lot of people think that crypto is the new gold. I don't happen to agree, but a lot of people think that. Well, we didn't see, you know, if this was a something went wrong in crypto land and everybody was afraid of crypto being outlawed and they all piled into gold. That would have made logical sense. That's not what happened.
We see strong crypto, strong US dollar, strong gold, all at the same time. I think what it's telling us is that people are realizing that we really are pretty much beyond any point of no return, so to speak, in terms of monetary policy. We're going to keep devaluing the currency, and that's why gold and the cryptocurrencies are doing so well. But hang on, if that's really the macro driver, how do you explain all of this strength in the dollar index? Now, that is relative to other currencies. But, you know, it's really interesting to look at those correlations. So that's something I'm gonna be looking at in the week ahead.
Patrick Ceresna: So Erik, though, I wanna talk that 10-year Treasury yield because all of the things you just said about why gold was breaking and the dollar moving, you would think that the bond market would give a shit. And here we are at yields at 1.55, and clearly the bond market is not, at least on the longer end of the curve, really showing any major concerns. Do you think that this is just a matter of time before the bond market does, or is this just Or is it simply just a different story?
Erik Townsend: You know, I don't claim to know, Patrick. And, you know, to go back to my Joe Pesci, if you want to talk about the 10-year yield, you can talk about it because I don't know. I look at this. The one thing I do notice is I look at T-bills. Now, for a long time, we had just crazy, crazy low, almost nothing yields at the front end of the curve. And that's still true. 3-month T-bill yielding 4 basis points, 6-month T-bill yielding 6 basis points. 12-month T-bill yielding 15 basis points. Still tiny little numbers. Hey, wait a minute. Look at the 2-year, 51 basis points. Okay, I know it sounds crazy to say 51 basis points is a high rate of return, but if you look at the progression, it seems like between the 1-year and the 2-year, you're seeing a much bigger lift in yields there.
So something's changing in terms of the structure of the curve. I don't know what's driving it. You know, I'd love to get a Jim Bianco or another really heavy fixed income guy to talk about what's going on, not just with respect to where the 10-year is, but the shape of the curve and what's affecting the shape of the curve and how that relates to what's going on in gold and everything else. I kind of got a sneaky, spidey sense here that these things are all related in a way that makes sense, and somebody's going to come explain to us someday soon. I don't claim to know the answer.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, this week's feature interview guest is Saxo Bank Commodity Strategy Chief Ole Hansen. Erik, why did we get Ole back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Ole is a commodities guy and he's a good commodities guy. He's had some really good calls. He called that bottom in gold around $1,680 or so. We almost made the call. We actually talked off the air. Both Ole and I had a feeling that this breakout was happening this week, but at the time we recorded it, we were still just below that $1,833 key resistance level. And we decided to, to not try to call a breakout before it's time. I guess maybe we should have done that. So you'll hear that in the interview. When we taped this on Tuesday, we were still below that level.
I know Ole was expecting this breakout to occur, and I think that he thinks, as I think, that the, the move seems to be on for gold. Now, I have seen a little bit of analysis. Some people still think this is a fake break and we're headed back lower.
You know, I've been surprised by things I thought were breakouts before, and we ended up turning back lower. So we'll see what happens. But so far, this looks really good to me. Let's get Ole's perspective on that and on many other things. I think you'll really enjoy this interview.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Ole Hansen is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas, and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the fintech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange, or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Ole Hansen, who heads up commodity market strategy for Saxo Bank. Ole has prepared a fantastic slide deck for us. Listeners, you'll find the download link for the slide deck in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads. Ole, before we dive into the slide deck, I know you've been writing a lot about inflation.
I don't know if you caught David Hay on this program recently coined this phrase greenflation, which I think perfectly explains how the goals of ESG are wonderful, but the way they're going about it by villainizing the energy industry is really, I think, setting us up for a big price shock in the future. Did you catch that interview? And what are your thoughts generally on secular inflation?
Ole Hansen: Well, good afternoon, Erik, and thank you very much for having me or inviting me back. I fully subscribe, and we at Saxo Bank fully subscribe to the non-transitory inflation outlook. The energy surge we've seen this year, or general commodity surge we've seen, is part of that process. Obviously, we come out of the pandemic, we've seen the global economy which has been absolutely overstimulated, surge in demand for power around the world, and we're ending up with shortages all over the place.
But part of that is also the transformation and the intense focus.
You can almost argue that, well, it's quite clear that back in the '50s and '60s, we had an arms race. It was all about developing nuclear technology and governments were throwing billions of dollars into it. This time around, we have another arms race, and that's the climate, and that's basically leading to billions of dollars being thrown into those efforts. And you can sometimes worry a little bit that the money not being used in the smartest way, but it is obviously also trying to send signals to the market and signals to population that something is being done. But we've seen this year how, especially in Europe and also in Asia, how we suddenly came short of power because we're not having We didn't have the gas we needed, and the wind and the sun was not producing the amount of energy that we had expected.
And it just highlights how we can be left exposed. And the coming years is going to— it's a development we continue to see because the transformation will require a lot of energy. It will require a lot of mined metals. And if the companies are producers, mining companies are being villainized and banks are not prepared to lend them the cash or investors not prepared to put the money in, then obviously we do have a transformation, which is just going to become ever more expensive.
Erik Townsend: Ole, is the greenflation argument that David Hay presented valid? In other words, is it really the focus on renewable energy that's going to increase the price of energy, or is the price of energy just really increasing because of lack of investment regardless of green factors?
Ole Hansen: I think it is a combination of both. First and foremost, global demand has recovered and it has recovered strongly following the pandemic and the collapse we saw in But going forward, the trajectory and demand tends to be relatively easy to work out. So I'll say the additional factor that has come into play is the uncertainty related to supplies, especially non-OPEC+ supplies where we are seeing the— just look at the US, we dropped from 13 million. We're now back in the 11s, around 11.6, 11.9. And that's really how far the EIA in their latest update think we can We can see production go next year. So we're not seeing the response to these very profitable high prices that we got right now from producers. And that really is because their focus is somewhere else. And part to blame for that is not only the ESG, but also just simply the fact that they're somewhat worried that the transition will take place or will occur fairly quickly. That basically means within the next 10, 15 years, and that obviously leaves some of these multi-billion dollar projects in doubt.
And that's part of the— I think that's part of the reason why we have these elevated prices.
Erik Townsend: Ole, I think that your view and mine are very closely aligned. I think we both see a secular inflation that lasts for many years and that we're just at the beginning of an epic commodity bull market. But anytime my views are aligned that much with the guest, I kind of feel an obligation as a journalist here to take the other side. So let's, for sake of argument, consider— wait a minute, what if you and I have this wrong? What if Janet Yellen has it exactly right, that inflation is transitory? And the reason we're seeing these spikes in commodity prices is just because, you know, we've got a global pandemic on that has disrupted supply chains. Those supply chain disruptions surely are going to, you know, get corrected sometime fairly soon here, and everything is going to all retrace. And it'll turn out that anybody who invested in a bull view on a long-term commodity bull market will have completely missed the boat and been upended and caught wrong-footed in the trade.
Frankly, I'm quite willing to bet against that view, but for the sake of giving it some airtime, what would you say in response to that objection from an investor?
Ole Hansen: Well, I'm struggling to see that occur, Erik. And so I'm struggling to take the other side of the argument because the demand looks strong, not only because the economies are recovering. And we have the transformation which requires major, a big increase in supply. I think the devil's advocate should probably be China because that's really where we see, where we have such a huge amount of demand for most major commodities. But at the same time, they're going through a soft patch now. But again, we've seen in the past China do respond to weakness by adding support to the market. So even though they're going through a phase now, especially with focus on the property sector, which could hurt some of the metals, we did also see oil demand drop somewhat last month in October. I think that's really the only risk. But against that, we just had the infrastructure bill in the US coming through, and that infrastructure and green transformation will, I think, will ensure that demand remains robust.
And into that, we obviously need supply to keep up. And again, the coming years, we may not— we just have to remember that commodity prices can rise even if demand doesn't, as long as supply doesn't If supply is struggling to keep up, then prices will move higher.
Erik Townsend: Okay. Well, I tried to give at least a little bit of airtime to the other view, but let's go back to the one that you and I share, which is that as we come out of this pandemic, there will be increasing demand. The supply will be constrained by a number of logistic issues that will continue to exist for a long time. And among them is lack of investment, especially in the industries that have been targeted by ESG as supposedly being the bad guys.
So, when I look at this whole picture, obviously energy is a very appealing thing to talk about. It's what I trade too. But let's look at the whole commodity picture. 'Cause one of the things that's really striking to me, okay, the big call here has been secular inflation. And I think we got that call right. And a lot of us who got that call right a couple years ago said the big winner's gotta be gold. And look at what's happened. We've got finally, maybe the beginnings of a breakout as we're speaking today, but we're still below $1,830. And that's been kind of the line in the sand.
Ole Hansen: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: that hasn't been crossed yet. And boy, copper is doing great. So what's the real inflation hedge in this environment? Is it gold or is it copper and other commodities?
Ole Hansen: Well, up until now, it has been oil and copper. Gold's had a troubled year because of several— for several reasons. First of all, the uncertainty related to what the FOMC is going to do next. I think some of that uncertainty has now been cleared. We are going to get the taper finally. Interest rates, they are not too keen on getting involved with hiking any Anytime soon, and at the same time, in this environment, I think the biggest well two things probably if you look at the gold market, a lot has been mentioned about the crypto space attracting attracting investors away from from from some of the metals. I think that's probably part of the story, but I think the the main story is just simply we have VIX at such a low level. It means that gold physical gold demand right now is is strong in in Asia, in India. It's picking up as they recover from the pandemic. But if you look at the ETF holdings, they have been on a downward The trajectory now for the past 18 months.
And it is fund managers who piled into gold last year as a hedge. As volatility didn't really spike and we've seen the stock markets continue to rally, then the need to have diversification has really been suppressed. And I think that's probably one of the main reasons why gold has struggled. Because right now, we have finally in the bond market, the recent months, on recent, yeah, last few months, started to see the inflation expectations start to build. At the same time, that's really only impacting the short end of the market because— or the yield rise we've seen has only been impacting the short end because the long end is more worried about growth going forward. And that has allowed real yields to drop to these current very low levels, nearly historic lows below -1%. So that thing is— that part of the equation is fully supported right now. Now we just— I think we just need some more volatility in the stock market for gold really to shine.
And you're a trader as well, Erik, and we know full well that one thing that drives markets are momentum. And we just simply haven't had any momentum in the gold market for a long time. And I think if you're looking at the chart, if we can take out that $1,835 to $1,840 level, then not only does it point towards a break of the downtrend from the highs last year, but also that I think 4 or 5 times back in July and August, we failed to break above that level. So if we do break that, that really will be the big test because at that point, Money managers and technical traders, they will have to respond. And it is my belief they will do.
Erik Townsend: And if you look at the volume profile above $1,840 there's room for a really big price acceleration above that level if it happens. I'm just— and it may have happened by the time this airs. We're actually recording this interview on Tuesday to air on Thursday. And we're right teetering just below that critical level. So perhaps we'll have new news to report to our listeners by then. Let's go ahead and dive into your chart deck and look at some of the details on specific commodities. Starting on page 2, you're You're kind of painting the big picture here on commodities and breaking it out in different sectors, agriculture, metals, energy, and so forth.
Energy seems like a very obvious one. What else should we think about in terms of the effects of this whole macro backdrop on commodities?
Ole Hansen: Well, I think first and foremost, I've been using the Bloomberg Commodity Index for those commodities that are part of that basket. There are quite a few which has been marked, and you can see they're actually some of the best performing. That's gas in Europe. It's German Power prices, the cost of emissions. These are really where we— they obviously stand out with gas at one point up more than 300%. It has come down today because it looks like Putin is finally delivering on his promise that Gazprom will supply additional gas over the coming weeks. And that should hopefully just alleviate some of the pressure on gas prices here. But generally, as you can see, there's really not many— that many markets sticking out to the downside. And then we talked about gold. It's flat on the year. And if you use gold as a hedge against— on Elsewhere, it's been a brilliant year because you don't really need any performance in gold when you have stock markets doing what they're doing right now, and bonds bond markets still reasonably well behaved.
So gold is sitting there and and waiting for for rainy day. Remember what happened a couple years ago when we had the worst months for equities since the 30s, 1930s? That was a that was a really good month for gold. So let's not rule that one out at this stage. But but otherwise, broad gains led by the led by the energy sector, and and after the recent small setback we've seen in industrial metals, part of that driven by China, where the industrial metals are, even despite of that, we're still up by a handsome, say around 30%. It's difficult to see the scale when it goes all the way out to 300, but we are seeing strong gains more or less across the board and look for that to continue into 2022. What I think is interesting if you look at the same slide is also the speculative interest because the market has become a little bit, or money managers has become a little bit lukewarm in recent months. There's actually been net selling ongoing now for the past 6 to 9— well, most of the year actually.
We peaked in January in terms of net long held across 24 major commodities. And that does indicate that there is plenty of room, but also the fact that volatility has been rising in some of these markets. And that basically has forced some of these hedge funds to reduce exposure because a lot of these, they're tracking volatility as part of their risk management. And as volatility goes up, then they have to cut exposure. So I think that's part of the The story that explains why even though we're seeing Bloomberg Commodity Spot Index at a multi-year high, we've seen a reduction in positioning over this year.
Erik Townsend: On page 3, your title says, Tightness in Energy and Industrial Metals Still Points to Higher Prices. Now, okay, help me understand that logic because boy, the price movement upward has already occurred very dramatically in both energy and in industrial metals.
Ole Hansen: So what makes you say it's got further Well, this is just to explain what these charts are showing. It's basically the 12-month spread between the front futures contract and the contract 12 months out. And it's interesting if we look at the— I didn't put in the whole sector as a whole, but we can see some of these markets that we've had several years. If you look at something like industrial metals, we had half a decade from '15 to '20 where basically that spread was negative. That basically means the market was trading at contango. Spot prices were trading lower than futures prices further out the curve, indicating a market with ample supply. And the same goes for some of the other markets. Agricultural especially has been on a downward sloping trajectory during that past 5-year period as well, whereas the energy has been a bit more on the plus side to where we had been experiencing periods of tightness.
And then we did have that massive slump last year when we saw oil prices go to negative in WTI, and that obviously caused some volatility in these spreads.
But generally, right now we are seeing that for the first time in 5 years, a solid backdrop for investments in commodities, because you have to remember that backwardation and contango is either hurting your investment or supporting your investment. When the market is in backwardation, you are having a positive roll on a monthly basis. You're not, but the provider of your investment is rolling, selling Expensive to buy the next one at a cheaper level, that roll yield is benefiting you on your return. And that's what we see now very strongly, especially in the energy market and industrial metals. And it just tells us that the market is tight. And I see very limited reason for that tightness to suddenly evaporate because that's for the reasons we talked about.
And on the page as well, just Some of the some of the the factors that that drives this this focus on on on commodity supercycle, and as you can see, rising physical demand and tightening supply. And and that supply is is quite often tends to take time to to come into the market. And I think the big difference now compared to previous cycles where we had tightness in the market is is due to ESG because the the old saying that the best cure for high price is a high price because it incentivizes production while potentially cutting demand.
Those functions has to a certain extent been hurt by ESG because even though prices are moving up, we're not seeing the producer response that we may have or would have seen in previous cycles. So that's also still part of the story that's driving this tightness in the market.
Erik Townsend: Well, Ole, you just quoted one of my favorite sayings, which is the cure for high prices is high prices. And if you look at the backwardation that exists, particularly in the energy market, if you think like a So if you're a commodity guy who hasn't been introduced to the new thinking of ESG, you'd think, boy, they've got to be really just opening the floodgates on CAPEX to do major investments. And we should expect energy prices to take a nosedive a few years from now when all of those big capital expenditures that are being made now because of this price structure actually hit the market. So let's look at the next slide at how big those capital Investments that are being made now actually are. Hey, wait a minute, is this slide right?
Ole Hansen: It is indeed, Erik. And when we looked at it, it was actually my colleague Peter Garnry who pulled that out. And when we looked at it, we just couldn't believe what we're seeing. Basically, real capital expenditure so far this year is basically back to— and if that's for the MSCI World Materials and Energy sector, we're basically back to levels we saw 20 years ago. And that's clearly not what we need at this moment in time where demand is only expected to increase. Remain firm over the coming years. And it's also telling that back then, we remember around the 2000s, that's really when China entered the global stage as a major buyer of everything. Commodities took off and it almost took a doubling of the Bloomberg Commodity Index between 2001 and 2005 before CAPEX actually started to pick up. So that's how long it took before money was really starting to be spent on increased supply because the market or the producers realized this is much longer term than than we may perhaps had expected initially.
And fast forwarding to today, we are potentially at the beginning of a similar move. This time around, it's not China, it's the green transformation and infrastructure spend that's going to be part of it. But are we going to see that response? And potentially that response could come quite a bit late.
Erik Townsend: And Ole, this is intuitively obvious to you and I because we both trade in energies, but just for the benefit of any listeners who are not seeing this, I want to make it super clear. What this chart is showing us Is that oil comes from oil wells, and oil wells wear out over time. They have to be replaced, especially the newfangled shale ones, which wear out even faster than the old style.
What's being done to invest in replacing the wearing-out oil wells is exactly nothing, because it's fallen out of political favor to invest in energy companies. And I just can't see how this chart can be true and not lead to a major price crisis in the future. What am I missing that's not going to take us to oil prices to the moon in the next few years when we haven't made the investments we needed to make in replacing those declining shale wells that are not going to be able to continue to produce the same amount of oil that they do today?
Ole Hansen: Well, it's first and foremost really depends on the amount of spare capacity that OPEC+ countries still have available. I think there are some Some concerns that they may not be as high as we potentially could calculate given the data that we've seen in the past. And we've got a slide a little bit later taking a look at that. So it is, what's going to give? Well, it could be an economic slowdown. Basically, high prices kills growth. That's obviously not the venue we want to go down, but that ultimately could be the risk that could help balance the market.
But in the short term or medium term, we still have supplies coming from OPEC+, and that will take us well into next year, perhaps even '23. But as you said, Erik, wells don't pump forever. They need to be replaced as they expire. And that's really the challenge, which means that the sector constantly needs billions of dollars investments, of new investments. And right now we're not getting them.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Ole, when I take a look at this graph on page 4 and I think about everything that I know and everything I've ever heard about OPEC spare capacity, lots of people in the industry passionately disagree about how much spare capacity OPEC really has. But, you know, it's somewhere between a couple of million barrels a day to, you know, 10 million barrels a day. It's not like they can turn the screws up and increase by 40 million barrels a day.
Ole Hansen: No.
Erik Townsend: I look at this graph and I look at what's going to happen to investment, and I know that demand is not going to zero overnight just because everybody wants an electric vehicle. That's not reality yet. It's coming. I just can't see how this graph is possibly going to be solved by OPEC+ spare capacity. Am I missing something? You guys study OPEC spare capacity more than I do. Is that really a potential solution? I think it's a potential solution.
Ole Hansen: Well, that will be the savior event. And again, when we had the focus here in Europe just a few months ago when the gas prices really took off, where there was some speculation, would politicians fear blackouts more than climate change? And again, it's 2 horrible things that have to weigh up against each other. But if we do run into a period of prolonged high prices, then we could potentially see that resolve fade somewhat, but we need to get there.
But at least over the coming years, at least the next 5 years, we need to rely on good old-fashioned fossil fuels. And it still accounts for around 80% of the total global energy mix. 1% right now is renewables, 5% is nuclear. So those 80%, it will take, unfortunately take a much longer time than I think than expected to get that down to a reasonable level.
Erik Townsend: Now, Ole, on page 5, you're arguing that an overstimulated global economy, because of the stimulative effects that central banks have done in reaction to COVID-19, presumably, have been driving this energy crunch. Does that mean that as that stimulation is no longer needed, that the energy crunch is going to be over?
Ole Hansen: No, because at the same time, we are just rewind a little bit because, because this is part of what we talked about in the beginning, that we had the— we had this massive handouts from governments into the pandemic just to keep the wheels turning.
And we all went on a spending spree, sending all our handouts to Asia in return for consumer goods. Power consumption in China accelerated very strongly. That required a lot of coal and gas to keep that power running. And that's why the Chinese demand suddenly took off in a strong way, and especially on the gas, because at the same time, they're also trying to wean themselves off coal consumption, which is for now is not working because they've had to increase production. Domestically in order to keep the power production or prevent them from having power cuts. So that was just the start of this overstimulation. And we've now seen that spread to first the gas market, no, sorry, the coal market, and it spread to the gas market.
And right now the gas markets are, it has become the transitory energy because if we need to move away from coal, then gas needs to be there to keep the turbines running on the days where the wind isn't blowing. And that basically means the demand for gas in Europe and in Asia will remain firm. And that competition for gas basically means that we have LNG in Asia and gas in Europe basically just taking off, moving far away from gas prices as you know them in the US.
And I put in on this chart just for reference, just to show the— it's not scientific, but just to give a rough idea about how these gas prices are, what levels they're trading at if we price them in Brent. And as you can see, We at one point traded close to $200 a barrel, and historically as well, you can see that gas prices tend to trade below Brent. And this is obviously a golden opportunity for Russia because they would like to have their long-term contracts reinstated. Question is whether anyone will buy gas on long-term contracts at these very current, very high levels.
But you can see this market is out of whack, and the question is obviously how quickly we can get that normalized. And for now, with a very, very cold winter winter potentially looming on the Northern Hemisphere once again, I think the competition for gas this winter will be quite intense, both from China and from Europe.
Erik Townsend: Ole, moving on to page 7, we've got the crude oil rally coming into focus. And I should mention just in the time we've been speaking, it's Tuesday afternoon that we're recording this particular interview, and we have broken out above the short-term moving averages on WTI crude oil, back up almost to $84 as we're speaking, having opened $82-something this morning. So it looks like maybe the crude oil rally is back on as of this week. Do you agree with that? It seems like that's what you're showing or predicting here on your chart. If so, you got it right. And what comes next?
Ole Hansen: Well, I think just to— before that, we just rewind one slide because I think we need the gas, just the gas part of the oil equation right now. We talked about gas before, and then this is just highlighting again the gas prices in Europe and in Asia and the gas-to-oil switch that really became a big That's a big talked about theme here during the past months. I think probably which has driven up oil price by at least $5 as we saw gas prices surge, we saw the substitution into fuel products. So I think the short-term key to oil is probably to a certain extent, again, being driven by gas because if we do see Russian supplies to Europe pick up and gas prices come back below this gas-to-switch area, then that potentially could take some of the sting out of oil because demand may just stabilize somewhat.
But you are right, Erik, we've taken out that very, very long downtrend that we had from the highs back in 2008. We moved higher today on Tuesday, and that's actually interesting enough because we're trading higher today because the EIA report was actually a bit dovish. That basically meant the market was removing, or they were thinking that the risk of an SPR release was less likely. So that's why oil Oil prices are somewhat higher here this Tuesday. But I think over the next months or so, gas could be a major theme for the oil market. If we should see prices come down, that would help just at least in the short term take some of the sting out of the rally in crude oil. But if you look at Brent here, $86.75, we're not far away from it. That's the recent highs from 2018. If we do break that, then the call for $100 will start to But I think also at the same time, and we talked about that, where can the extra barrels come from?
Because that really is a key right now.
And I think just looking at the OPEC+ meeting recently where they just went for another 400,000 barrel increase, we have to remember that what they're agreeing to increase is not really what's actually hitting the market because we have 2 laggards right now. And that's shown here on page 7, Nigeria and Angola. They are currently producing combined 450,000 barrels a day less than what they can according to their quota. And that's a full month increase plus some that we are not getting into the market. So I think in order to help stabilize price, we need really to see these 2 countries get their production back up. And the outlook for that is not terribly promising. One area that could be promising is Iran because we got the nuclear negotiation resuming here at the end of the month.
Again, Iran knows full well that the US is quite desperate to get prices down, and they potentially hold the key to that because they have, compared to the recent peaks back in 2017, '18, they have 1.2 million barrels of additional supply that they could increase production by. Probably not that much because there is a lot of oil probably leaving Iran covertly that we don't really— that we don't get counted. But still, it's a sizable increase that could come from an Iranian of the removal of sanctions. So I think that's really what we should be looking at over the coming months to see if there's any sign of relief coming from that front. But looking at the US strategic reserves are coming down, rightfully so, because there's no need for them at these current very high levels because imports into the US has come down during the past decade.
But at the same time, we talked about US production earlier. And the EIA today in their forecast, they see production in December this year around 11.6. They see the average for next year around 11.9. So it's only a 300,000 barrel increase over the next 12 months. And that's really a far cry from the 13 million barrels they produced before the pandemic.
So we probably need to focus on OPEC and their ability to increase production in order to avoid that we are going to talk about potentially $100 oil next time we speak.
Erik Townsend: Let's come back to that 13 million barrel figure for the United States production. I've heard a lot of other people tell me that it's basically impossible to ever get back to that because that happened as a result of the shale revolution and the incredible mountain of easy money that was available thanks to Federal Reserve largesse. Junk bond market was very supportive. supportive of the oil patch in that timeframe. What people are telling me is that's just not true anymore. The money is not there. We don't have easy money to fund these things. It's much harder to get financing, and it's impossible to get back to 13 million because of that. But at the same time, a lot of people who told me we were going to just be in permanent decline didn't forecast that we are seeing at least a slow recovery in US production.
So what's the real story here? How much can the US recover?
Ole Hansen: Well, it's somewhere in between, I think, because I just recently made an update on, on some of the market caps for for the 15 biggest shale oil producers in the US and obviously realized that quite a few of them had disappeared from the face of the earth during the past 18 months because they've been taken over by larger entities. And I think that's part of the reason why we're not going to see a return because the willingness to pump at will and just take on, accumulate a lot of debt to do that, that is well and truly, that has been put to rest. So it's more whether some of these These more much bigger oil companies following several mergers, whether they have the incentive to ramp up production, which they obviously can if they feel they're allowed to, and if they can see it makes economic sense, then that is an option.
But the kind of production binge that we had leading up to that collapse before the pandemic, just before the pandemic, is difficult to see that being repeated. But Again, the best cure for a high price is a high price.
And again, land areas are available to increase production. But in order for that to happen, we still have to remember as well, shale oil producers don't necessarily sell oil at $84 a barrel. They're selling at forward prices, which are with a very, very steep curve we have right now, selling forward at much lower prices than the one we see on our screen. So that's also a thing that has to be taken into consideration.
Erik Townsend: On page 8, I see you've got a chart showing the December '21 through December '22 backwardation spread. That happens to be one that a lot of our MacroVoices listeners bought in contango at -3.20 and have ridden all the way up. So one of my favorite spreads. What's going on? Why is it on your chart and what is it telling us about the market?
Ole Hansen: Well, it's just, I brought it with me because there's been quite a lot of focus on Cushing, Oklahoma recently. And I think that's part of the speculative interest, which tends to be concentrated at the front of the curve, which to a certain extent can drive maybe the backwardation a little bit out of whack compared to what the supply and demand actually looks like. We have been seeing the emergence of a real threat to supplies because Oklahoma crude stocks has been shrinking as fast as they've been doing in recent months. And we have to remember, it was also Oklahoma that— or Cushing, That was the reason why we hit $40 briefly, minus $40 briefly last year.
And this time around, it's the opposite because while back then we were worried about tank tops, we are now worried about hitting low points where the whole system is not functioning well enough. But there are signs that I think we've just seen some reports that some of the price differentials between especially Midland has moved more in favor of WTI. WTI, and that should lead to more supplies hitting Cushing. So I think it's just for reference that if you're watching the curve, you should also be watching what's going on at Cushing because it is obviously the landlocked delivery point for WTI futures.
Erik Townsend: Ole, let's shift gears and move on to gold bullion on page 9. What's going on here?
Ole Hansen: Well, as we talked about at the beginning, at the top of the show, we are getting close to a level. This chart is a little bit below that level, but we are currently challenging or getting very close to once again challenging that 1835 level. And as we talked about, the real yields developments are currently very supportive. We've got real yields moving firmly into negative territory. And we have to remember that the way you construct a nominal yield is basically taking the inflation part and then you end up with the real yield. And as inflation expectations are, breakevens are expected to remain elevated, and if nominal yields are not going any everywhere due to growth worries, then real yields will continue to remain into deeply negative territory. And that's a key source of inspiration for gold, or at least has been in the past.
I would argue at current levels, if you look at the real yields, gold is probably somewhere around $40 to $50 too cheap. I should have put a chart where I showed the correlation between the two, but based on recent history, I would say that the gold is trading cheap at these levels. So it's more a question that the market comes to the conclusion that these real yields are going to stick around at these deeply negative levels for a prolonged period of time. And that combined with the prospect for inflation to remain elevated, for economic growth to potentially be challenged, I think that's setting up for a renewed upside attempt in gold.
And if we do take out that $1,835 level, then I think I could see that market pop $100 relatively quickly because we will see renewed momentum from a lot of speculative traders who have been looking elsewhere while we've been trading range-bound for the past 6 to 9 months.
Erik Townsend: I definitely agree with that outlook. And as we're speaking, we're still looking at $1,831 So we're close, but not quite. Maybe by the time this airs, we'll already have the breakout underway. We'll see what happens. Moving on to page 10 though. Boy, copper's doing better than gold in an inflation environment. I was expecting gold to be the outperformer.
Ole Hansen: Yeah, and copper's actually doing incredibly well. If you think about all the worries that we had about China during the past 3 months, especially the property sector, which is a key source of demand for copper due to all the wiring and electrical wirings and so on. And despite of this, we have not even had a 38.2% retracement of the rally from the March low last year. We stopped short. I'm using high-grade copper in New York for as a reference. And as you can see, we, we found quite a solid floor around that $4 pound level. The recent spike up, uh, to, uh, to near the, the record high we had back in, in May was, uh, was triggered by, by some, uh, uh, almost call it shenanigans in the London market where, where big firms were hoovering off stocks, thereby driving the visible stock levels down, creating a, a sense of, of shortage in the market. And that was some of that was given back. But but just look at the monitor exchange monitored inventories there on on slide ten.
We are we are dealing with with levels which is approaching the lowest levels in in more than a decade, and some of that can obviously be taken out for speculative purposes, taken out of visible storage into invisible warehouses where it's not being monitored. So that creates a sense of of tightness in the market. But it's happening right now both on the LME and it's also happening in in in Shanghai. So it does indicate to me that gold is still one of the king of the— I'll call it the king of the green metals because just look at the whole electrification, electrical vehicles, the supply which potentially could struggle to keep up.
And also the speculative interest from money managers, which is also part of my weekly update, which is available on Mondays. You can see the speculative interest right now is probably around half of what we had when we visited those highs on a previous occasion. So plenty of room for funds to get involved. I'm not chasing it right now because I think we still need to get China growth worries and developments there out of the way. So I cannot rule out that we could on a rainy day see it break below $4 to challenge that $3.77. But I think that whole area below $4 is a buy for a longer-term move to fresh record highs.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 11, you make the argument that we need metal prices to be high in order to have the energy transition work. I understand what you mean, but I'm not sure everybody does. Please explain.
Ole Hansen: It's all to do about what we talked about earlier, that we need high prices to incentivize miners, mining operations to maintain a solid funnel of new supply to meet these increased demands over the coming years. And as As you can see, we're not just talking about a couple of metals. It's almost the whole spectrum of industrial metals that in some way or another can be used and will be used towards that transition. So we need all of them.
Erik Townsend: And let's talk about weather on page 12. How does that come into the equation?
Ole Hansen: Just because we haven't talked too much about weather. And again, when people ask, well, what's your outlook for weather for the agricultural production? Well, I think, well, I'm not a weatherman. Man or someone sitting above us all looking down deciding what's going to happen next. But what we can see is that there is a risk of another La Niña building over the coming months. And that will create— if that becomes as strong as it was last year, that will once again create some worries about the supplies or outlook for crop production in South America and to a certain extent also the US.
So we focus there on the key crops, wheat, corn, soybeans, but also our Brazil-centric commodities such as sugar, coffee, and just returning to the US, cotton as well, which cotton will be competing with other crops. And I think also, once again, just mention the gas surge because it has led to a phenomenal rally in fertilizer prices. And if we have high diesel costs, we have high fertilizer prices, that is a risk to production next year because some farmers may opt to use less fertilizer and that could obviously bring the crop production in doubt.
So unfortunately, from a global perspective, I think we have to worry a little bit about the agricultural space, that prices there will continue to rise as well.
Erik Townsend: And finally, on page 13, uranium and nuclear power, a subject that we covered with a whole special back when it was time to buy it right here on MacroVoices.
Ole Hansen: Yeah. And I think that's just, again, this whole thing about how do we go about the transition in the smartest way. And we had a podcast in Saxo Bank recently where we had invited one of the company, a local company in to discuss some of the new technologies that they're working on.
And one thing is for sure, that if nuclear power is known and the new generations of nuclear technologies are somewhat more safe and easier to and faster to build than the technologies we know today, which most of them were developed back in the '50s and '60s. So we see a future for uranium nuclear or for nuclear power because it is the fastest way to to achieve the baseload that is required so we can get rid of coal to begin with, and then over the coming decades reduce the need for something like gas.
But I think it's a long-term view. So I think investors there has to be patient. We've seen some volatility this year, especially with the Sprott ETF joining the fray. But I think we just have to keep in mind it is a long-term prospect for the sector. Do not expect very big moves in the short term, but it is most certainly a sector that I believe will continue to attract demand over the coming years.
Erik Townsend: Well, Ole, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, I want to fill our listeners in on where they can follow the work that you do there at Saxo Bank, because you guys have your own commodity podcast, which you actually produce. Tell us about that and what else they can do to follow your work.
Ole Hansen: Well, you mentioned the podcast is not only commodities, it is a macro-based podcast. The base commodity podcast that we do on a daily basis from our headquarters here in Copenhagen. And we just basically take the temperature on the market, what happened overnight, and potentially where we go next. It's gained a lot in popularity over the last couple of years. So that's really, I would say, our flagship production. We also got a Quick Take every morning that is available on analysis.saxo. Otherwise, you can always follow us on our individual Twitter profiles. I put in the individual Twitter profiles there on slide 14 as well.
Erik Townsend: Well, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview, Ole. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Selling anything of value— cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australia.
Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. Escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was, uh, great to have Ole back on the show. I mean, he's by far one of my favorite commodity guests to have on. He's just so smart and on the ball with so many of these, uh, things. And it's just, you know, when I heard in the interview him talking about, uh, you know, the oil service industry and just, uh, how there's still a lack of investment in this. It makes me think like there's got to be still such an extraordinary opportunity in the years to come as this has to all work out. Like there's going to be a catch-up period in this. It's certainly on my mind and I'm curious whether or not this is a— how— I'm certainly thinking about how to trade this. There's going to be an opportunity here for sure.
Erik Townsend: I agree. And Ole is one of my favorite guys as well. But I want to move on now to your Tour of the Commodity Markets chart deck. Listeners, you find the download link for this chart deck in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you haven't yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, we've got the Dollar Index, and boy, look at that breakout that jumps off the page on the right edge there of page 2. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, it's still a very bullish-looking chart. Obviously, one thing that me and you talk about all the time is that it's all relative to other fiat currencies. So we're just talking about, you know, which fiat currency is the hot one in any short period of time there. But there's definitely a dollar breakout. And what's interesting about this is that that hasn't really taken too much of the wind out of the sails of the commodity markets. Typically, over decades of intermarket analysis, usually commodities tend to do poorly in periods of dollar strength.
And yet that doesn't seem to be manifesting at all in this window. And obviously there's, uh, there's actual real supply issues that, that are overriding any currency correlations. But it is interesting that we're getting a gold breakout and some of these other commodities we're just going to talk about here in a moment, at the same time as the dollar is pretty much breaking out of a 1-year range. I'm curious whether the dollar will make this stick and, and what, what will happen from here.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to crude oil futures
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so the interesting part to me that I wanted to observe is like, even let's say if you go back into the July, August part of the summer period where oil, you know, went from the mid to low 70s down to like to the low 60s, it was about a $10 correction. But generally, you could argue that throughout the entire 2021 year, oil was structurally bullish and poised to go higher, but there are periods when crude oil goes through corrections. The interesting part about the reversal that happened yesterday is it rejected oil along its previous highs, and that while that in itself one day is not enough information to make a market call, it'll be really interesting to see whether this continues to be a period where oil now consolidates and/or backfills some of that extraordinary bullish bullishness we had through September and October.
And watching whether or not it can get north of $85 in the coming days is on my mind.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'll tell you, in this case, I tend to actually discount the value of technical analysis because technical analysis is really based on figuring out what the traders are thinking. And I think this is more about political theater. I say that the fundamentals are still very strong for a continued crude oil rally. But the political risk of Joe Biden managing to figure out what to say to freak markets out to get the price back down to, oh, let's say where the highs were in July, you know, around— what is that, $73, $74?
I could easily see that happening from here, or I could see it just being straight uphill from here if we don't have too much political influence. I think we are going to have more political influence. So I'm waiting for more down. And, you know, hopefully I'll be smart enough to pick the bottom and add to my longs there.
Patrick Ceresna: But I'm with you that it's a buy on dip. It's just the question is, is that does it go and give a much better tactical entry at a better price? Right?
Erik Townsend: Right. And I don't think it's possible to use technical analysis to figure out where that is. It could be right here, right now, today is the bottom. And it could easily be that we're down to, you know, low 70s again on some kind of really trumped-up White House rhetoric about how supposedly they're going to battle with OPEC+ or whatever it is. But if that's not confusing enough, let's go to the famous widowmaker contract, which is natural gas futures.
Erik Townsend: Uh, if I said I wasn't sure what was about to happen next with crude oil, I'm double not sure what's going to happen next with natural gas.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what I mean, uh, there was a seasonality trade and all sorts of, uh, you know, weather considerations and things, but nat gas had just an extraordinary run for over 6 months where we went went from basically, for rounding, went from like $2.50 up to like, uh, $6.25 to the upside on that natural gas continuous contract. It was just an amazing bull run that had a real acceleration to the upside. But what we can really see now, what over the last month is, is that we've, uh, we've now entered more, far more of a trade range up along these highs. And all of that upside momentum that was built, uh, through coming out of the summer has now dissipated. The question really here is maybe from a seasonality perspective, is that all we're going to get on this particular cycle? You know, usually once, once the winter has been fully priced in, usually we have some, especially on the continuous contract, it rolls down the term structure into the summer.
It'll be interesting whether this is going to be, at least for this leg of the bull, all that we're going to get.
Erik Townsend: Well, let's take a look at gold futures on page 5. That breakout above the trend line really stands out, and, uh, I think this is the real one, but we'll see what happens. I suppose we need to get above those May highs before we really have a confirmed breakout, right?
Patrick Ceresna: I mean, in the end, uh, there's confirmation, and then there's also when traders actually enter. And I would argue that many traders are entering with the anticipation that'll be confirmed with the break above the $1,900 level where those previous highs were. But one One thing to highlight was that there was an extraordinary bull run in gold in 2019 going into the summer of 2020. And, uh, we really have spent a year with gold just in a deep consolidation. When you really step back— and I wanted to focus on a weekly chart— so when you really step back, gold has not really done anything bearish. I think the, the thing that bothered everyone was simply the fact that the rest of the commodity markets were rallying and gold just didn't want to participate on the upside, and therefore many people just viewed it as dead money on the short term.
But overall, I think that the consolidation still can very much be leaning toward a very bullish chart in the much bigger picture. And like, when you step back and look at, you know, 3, 4, 5 years of charts, this still looks like it's, it's in a primary bull trend, and it looks like this could be a place where it turns up. Obviously, one day doesn't make a new breakout. I don't to already be getting overly excited about just a couple good days, but this is how sometimes how bull markets begin.
And it'll be really interesting to see, or at least another bull leg higher begins, and it'll be interesting to see whether this is where the breakout happens.
Erik Townsend: You know, both Ole and I couldn't put our fingers on this when we talked off the air, but this was before the breakout above that line really happened this week that we had this conversation. And we both just had a feeling of something It feels like this is it. It was the action and the vigorous action of the breakout from below $1,800 and how quickly it got up to $1,833. And at that point, it hadn't broken above it, but both Ole and I were feeling like it's about to. We just had a feeling, and sure enough, that's what's happening. So I think it's on. I think the gold bull market is back on. We'll see. But while we're talking precious metals, why don't we include platinum, Patrick? Why do we have platinum?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, Erik, so we got this platinum chart up here on page 6, but I also just wanted to note before we talk platinum, uh, just on what's going on in silver. Uh, while I don't have a chart up, what's interesting is silver actually has been trading in a pretty good correlation to gold. And without silver breaking that key level above $25, where I would argue a lot of resistance levels, silver does look like it's ready to go as well. And so this is where I wanted to just focus more on the other ones, like, uh, in the case platinum. And what's interesting is platinum has pretty much followed the same timeline script as gold, which is more or less spent most of this year just consolidating off of its highs. And it's more or less retraced about half of the prior bull run that it had from the COVID lows and is now also turning up.
It'll be really interesting to see whether the entire precious metal space is breaking out together, and that would actually add a certain Certainly more support to the idea that gold's going to work.
Erik Townsend: Or I guess the question that begs is whether the entire commodity complex is breaking out together. And hey, take a look at page 7, wheat futures.
Patrick Ceresna: You know, the wheat futures have actually been quite bullish, even arguably for, uh, for much of the year. I mean, there was a little bit of a summer pullback in, in wheat, but really grains have— it's been a tale of multiple, uh, grain markets. Like, for instance, the Soybean has really actually been the dog and the laggard, but wheat broke into fresh new highs. The pullbacks are being bought on dip and continues to look very healthy.
And that's a— it's really interesting to see that the grains, even corn is finally based and is starting to roll up. It'll be interesting to see whether the grains really start running from here.
Erik Townsend: But if you move to base metals and look at copper futures on page 8, you know, I would've expected copper futures to be pressing new all-time highs with everything else that's going on. And they're just barely maybe bottoming, it looks like, on what may have been a consolidation.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, you know, my thought on that is— and, and I'm just asking more as a question as opposed to a conclusion— but like, maybe it's the, the drag coming from, uh, the last 3 months of what's going on in China. Just, uh, you know, iron ore continues to dog, and a lot of the industrial metals, uh, are a bit of laggards in this window. And so it'll be interesting to see, like, maybe this is just, uh, offering a phenomenal opportunity to be buying copper at reasonable prices because I'm sure it will resolve itself. Uh, there's a lot of fundamental reasons why copper can still go much higher in this EV revolution and, uh, and the way that the things are evolving in the entire ESG movement. So nonetheless, copper, it's basing, it's at a key support line, it has not broken out for a technical thing.
But what'll be interesting to see in the next week or two is whether copper breaks $4.50 on the upside. I mean, if we see, uh, that it finally shows like it's coming back to life, it may very well be ready for another leg higher. But it certainly has not had the breakout candle that we've seen on a lot of the other commodities. So certainly a very early time to be watching whether copper starts to turn bullish because it hasn't yet broken out.
Erik Townsend: Let's take a look at the soft commodities. We, we've got a couple of charts for sugar and coffee futures.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, like, uh, overall what's interesting is, is that they are all sort of setting up like almost like where wheat was, uh, a couple months ago, uh, you know, tested overhead resistance on numerous occasions. You can see sugar up along that high, or you look at that chart on coffee futures retesting the high multiple times. And in both these charts, you're seeing them winding up like they're ready to go for a 52-week high breakout. Now, how do they Have they broken out yet? No. But this is a really interesting moment to see whether we see many of these softs breaking out. I know like cotton has already taken off and a couple of these others are moving. So watching whether coffee and sugar join the party is something that's on my mind.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, if you enjoy Patrick's ChartTechs, you don't have to wait for Thursday every week. You can get them every single day with a free trial of Big Picture Trading. Information's on page 11 or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Today you're going to find that transcript for today's interview as well as a link to Ole Hansen's slide deck and the chartbook we just discussed. here in the postgame. There's also a link to a Jeffrey Snider piece on how bond yields astutely, accurately sort out past inflation panics, and a Bill Blain article on bond yields, Fed head, and unsustainable markets. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program Even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K. And myself, @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.
MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as an investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Mike Green — Simplify Asset Management Chief Strategist (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. And now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 296 was recorded on November 4th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Simplify Asset Management Chief Strategist Mike Green returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll start with a review of this week's Federal Reserve announcements, including the Fed's comments on inflation and asset purchase tapering. Then we'll move on to the question of where digital currency is headed and who will be in control.
We're going to experiment with a format change this week, adding an editorial by yours truly. This week's editorial topic will be— The badly misunderstood and often misused term hyperinflation, why most of the people using that word really don't know what they're talking about, and what's important to understand in the coming secular inflation, which is not likely to be a hyperinflation. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck is titled Going Parabolic.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's jump right into it. That S&P 500, and particularly the NASDAQ, have really accelerated in this post-FOMC. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I really am coming around to appreciate that although I don't think any of this is organic or about a healthy economy, I think it's all about central bank largesse. I think that this acceleration to the upside in equity futures is really because the Fed statement this week was much more dovish than expected. Mike Green is going to cover that in detail, so I don't want to steal his thunder. We'll save it for Mike.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because it continues to hover to the top end of multi-month ranges. Euro continues to break down. What's your take on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Really nothing to add this week, Patrick. You know, it's the same thing we've been saying. We're in that trading range. We're consolidating sideways until we see a decisive breakout above 94.5. We're just consolidating.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because quite a bit of volatility in the last 2 days. What's your take on the price action here?
Erik Townsend: Yeah, there's really a huge amount of volatility. Now, I'm still super bullish in the long term, but I think what we're seeing is there's been a huge, huge fear that Cushing, Oklahoma was going to run out of oil, or at least run out of deliverable oil. I don't have any inside knowledge on exactly what's happening, but I can look at the futures term structure and oh boy, the backwardation across the curve, even in the back of the curve, is just collapsing. So what this means is the market is suddenly thinking that, that, you know, oil is just not going to be that tight of supply after all. So I think that's a combination of some expectations perhaps that the White House will eventually succeed in pressuring OPEC to increase supply, and perhaps also the expectation that Asset tapering, when it does occur, might slow the economy some, and that might reduce demand. So what we're seeing is backwardation collapsing across the curve, and that's also bringing down the front-month price.
A couple of really big, heavy down days and a lot of volatility. Boy, this today was a real roller coaster ride in WTI crude oil futures.
Patrick Ceresna: How did the inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: Crude oil building 3.3 million barrels nationally, but still drawing down 916,000 barrels in Cushing, Oklahoma. Now, that's the trend we've been very concerned with— Cushing drawing down even when there's a national The thing is, even though it's still happening, if I look at what those time spreads are telling me, all of a sudden the market is not as afraid as it was before. Meanwhile, it's a mixed bag on the finished products, with gasoline drawing down 1.5 million barrels and distillates building 2.2 million barrels. US production up 200,000 barrels to 11.5 million barrels. So we're fully recovered from Hurricane Ida and moving up to new— not all-time highs, but certainly cycle highs post-pandemic. Looks like the fear in Cushing in the time spreads is reversing. Now, if you really felt lucky, those front-of-curve time spreads that just blew out to the moon all the way up to $1.85, $1.90, something like that, they're back down around $1.15, $1.16. If we do not run out of oil in Cushing, those time spreads are going to, you know, by the time those contracts expire, they'll be back down to 60, 75 cents or less.
The thing is, if we do run out of oil in Cushing, they could go to $5 easily or more almost instantaneously. So Boy, that's a really dangerous trade, but could be a lucrative one if you get it right.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on gold while we're stuck in that multi-month trade range. It was interesting because yesterday we did see, uh, before the FOMC, a breakdown that looked like gold was ready to go, uh, for another downtrend, but a pretty sharp reversal today in that post-period. We're back approaching $1,800. Does this change your view at all on gold, or is it pretty much still the same view?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm still skeptical as to where gold is really headed because, as you say, the expectation that the Fed was about to taper, and they are gonna taper, but they weren't quite as hawkish as people thought they would be. The expectation of a hawkish announcement seemed to have gold taking a nosedive, getting ready to maybe, you know, head to new cycle lows. Who knows what was about to happen? Then the Fed came in much more dovish than expected. We didn't really see a big reaction in gold on the day of after the FOMC statement. It wasn't until today that it retraced, and it retraced Not quite as high as it was 3, 4 days ago. You know, it didn't really get above the 100 and 200-day moving averages, which have been the critical resistance. So we still don't have a breakout even on a dovish Fed report, whereas look at equities, you know, flying to the upside on the dovish Fed.
So I really think that you have to— we got to get Ronnie Stoeferle back on the program at some point. I really think you have to acknowledge that regardless of whether you agree or disagree with the cryptocurrency, you know, investment thesis, The fact is, it's taking a lot of market share away from gold. Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing, everybody's got their opinion. But I think gold investors have to look at this and say, wait a minute, we got the call right when we said big inflation is coming, and that has to be good for gold. Except guess what? The inflation showed up, the has to be good for gold hasn't really panned out yet. So I think what's really happening here is we've got to accept that a lot of people think that cryptocurrency is the new gold, and It means that gold is losing its market share.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's just touch on that 10-year Treasury yield because we did see almost a 10 basis point pullback in the post-FOMC period. We're approaching 1.50 on the downside of the yield. Do you think that the Fed really changed the direction of bonds here, or is— are interest rates just consolidating that big run before?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I don't think you can say that we know for sure that the Fed changed anything. I think that the market was headed back toward that sort of danger zone area thinking that the taper announcement might be more hawkish than it was. When it came in more dovish, then you saw, you know, a pretty natural retracement back down. I think we've gotta watch what happens from here, and particularly once they really do start tapering, whenever that turns out to be. We'll get a briefing from Mike Green on that.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is Simplify Asset Management's Chief Strategist, Mike Green. Erik, why did we get Mike back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: We haven't had Mike on in a long time. We've gotten a lot of feedback from our listeners who disagreed with some of his cryptocurrency views in his his previous interview. So I wanted to give him a chance to do an update on that and talk about where he sees digital currency going. He's also an expert on monetary policy and a perfect person to comment on today's interview about this week's FOMC release.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Mike Green is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets. Beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the FinTech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange, or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Mike Green, Chief Strategist and Portfolio Manager for Simplify Asset Management. Mike, it's great to have you back on the show. We had the big day today on Wednesday afternoon. We're recording this the day before this podcast airs. The Fed announced that they're intending to do what? Why don't you give us the full briefing of What the Fed did today and what it means and what you see on the horizon?
Mike Green: Well, I think the easiest way of just describing what happened today with Jerome Powell's testimony and the release statement is that the Fed came out more dovish than I think people had broadly expected them to. They indicated that yes, they will begin tapering. They have the ability to either back off or to accelerate against that.
But I think the most important piece of information that came away from it was the Fed's continued emphasis on the fact that they believe inflation is transitory. And importantly, even in the labor market, which has traditionally been thought of as a key driver of the Fed's behavior, that they do not see us as having normalized or come anywhere close to reaching full employment. And they're largely discounting many of the wage pressures that they're seeing.
Powell was relatively humble in terms of the certainty of where they are, but I think it was somewhat unequivocal that this was a very dovish presentation. And the real question I think I think is going to be how credible does the Street view the uncertainty around whether they should hike or not, right? The direct words were, when we reach full employment, then we'll figure out whether we're addressing the inflation components, whether we've adequately met the inflation objectives.
And I think that's a pretty important statement for one of the very first times. You almost would've expected something like this out of a labor economist like Yellen, but Powell very clearly came out in favor of the Fed continuing to hike.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Mike Green: of let's let the economic environment run hotter as we try to get people back into the labor force.
Erik Townsend: What is this going to mean for, let's start with equity markets?
Mike Green: Well, equity markets obviously are enthusiastic about it. We've seen a bit of a sharp rally in terms of US equities in particular. It appears to be led by many of the larger stocks, so not necessarily a remarkable move in terms of either inflation-oriented assets. And obviously that's being affected by some dynamics that are going on in the commodity markets as we'll probably talk about later.
But you're broadly seeing this dynamic of the traditional leaders of the market, the large-cap names are rising. My guess is that that's a function of people trying to put money to work rapidly. So buying the S&P 500 futures, for example, or buying the NASDAQ 100 futures with the objective of trying to put money quickly to work. And then we'll shake that out over the next couple of days as people try to decide how they want to actually fully deploy that capital.
Erik Townsend: Well, you mentioned commodity impact. Let's talk about that next because gold took a real nosedive, but it looks like it retraced almost half of that move. Crude oil, on the other hand, just kept on nosediving.
Mike Green: Yeah. So to me, those are interesting, right? So gold is more inflation in terms of monetary sensitive or real rate sensitive. I would argue that I've been concerned about crude for a while, primarily because I think that China is significantly weaker. than people think. And that is the primary market for crude, right? So yes, we're absolutely affected in the United States. We are absolutely looking at a situation where high crude oil prices are influencing our economic behavior and have suggested that we would see inflationary conditions. I guess what I've been trying to reiterate, and I've said it over and over and over again on Twitter, part of what we need to remember in commodity markets is that China's the largest consumer. They're slowing dramatically.
It's very unclear what 2022 is going to look like once we clear many of the supply challenges here in the United States, to a lesser extent in Europe. There's been an awful lot of goods demand that has been pulled forward. And as China is slowing in its economy, the crude markets are going to be pressured on that front. So again, it's a supply issue. And you see that, I would argue at least, in terms of the construction of the curve, which has been very sharply in backwardation. So at the front of the curve, we're looking at $80 oil. At the back of those, and that's $4 down from where it was earlier today, at the back of the curve, 2 years out, 3 years out, we're still looking at $60 oil. So this is a market that is very clearly saying this is a short-term issue.
And now I'd suggest that there's some uncertainty coming around in terms of what the potential demand curve looks like.
Erik Townsend: Why do you see that uncertainty? Is that China or something else?
Mike Green: China is the area that I'm most concerned about in commodities. The other component I guess I would highlight is in very classical terms, the cure for high prices is high prices. What everybody had kind of hoped for was that cure was going to manifest itself in terms of higher production. In other words, the US was going to tool back up in terms of its supply dynamics.
We've seen resistance on that, and obviously we've seen the Biden Administration push back against the idea of expanding fossil fuel production in the United States. I think that had led people to think that we were going to see the potential for I believe we heard Goldman Sachs come out with a call for a potential spike to $120 next year a few days ago. My sense is that that is unlikely to happen if China continues to slow.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the big one, which is fixed income Treasury yields. Of course, the big fear was, hey, if this is really the beginning of the next taper tantrum, you could be looking at a bond market crash. Well, we got a much more dovish statement But still they are talking about tapering. So which way does this go in terms of bond yields?
Mike Green: Well, and I think we've talked about this before, right? So the question is, how much should bond yields actually reflect inflation fears, the current level of inflation fears versus a longer-term question about the stability and the inflationary conditions? I don't think, and I think Powell actually speaking to this, what he told us very specifically is we're not in any rush to hike in the near term. We're waiting until we actually see the economic behavior. And we have seen some increase in yields in reaction to that. That dovish statement did result in bond yields rising by about 3 basis points, but we're a long way away from a bond crash. And it's important to just highlight for people that while it feels like 1.57 on the US Treasury, the 10-year is ridiculously low, that's actually quite high on a global basis.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Mike Green: So I struggle with a lot of the interpretation that people have had that we're going to have a bond crash because the Fed steps away and stops buying. I'm actually just about to post a piece on Medium talking about the dynamic of who is buying bonds. And I think people underappreciate the unique role that bonds play in portfolios. They are unique amongst financial assets in offering certainty about future value in nominal terms.
Other assets behave very, very differently. And so there's always going to be demand for bonds in portfolios. The idea that it's just going to collapse because people are fearing Jack Dorsey's hyperinflation is coming, that's going to be a long time before we actually end up seeing that dynamic play through.
Erik Townsend: Mike, you mentioned your Twitter audience. You get beaten up a lot both on Twitter and when you've been on this show before. I think a lot of people think you are the, I don't know, the crypto Antichrist or something. I want to try to set a record straight. I'm going to ask you some true or false questions, and I think that the answers are probably going to surprise our listeners. So, Mike, in your opinion, true or false, the invention of the tokenized secure digital bearer asset— that's the underlying invention that makes Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies and also decentralized finance possible.
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Is it true to say that that is an utterly game-changing invention which will completely reshape the face of finance over the next 25 years?
Mike Green: True.
Erik Townsend: You crypto guys that don't like Mike weren't expecting that one, were you? Let's take it the next step. Is it true that it is a near certainty that conventional currency systems will eventually be replaced by tokenized digital currency systems because they are inherently superior and offer so many benefits that we just can't possibly resist long-term the temptation to replace all conventional currency with tokenized digital currency.
Mike Green: True.
Erik Townsend: You guys weren't expecting that from Mike, were you either? And is it also true that the benefits that these things offer substantially reduce counterparty risk and the systemic risks that have inherently plagued the financial system for years? Specifically, you think about the so-called Lehman moment where one institution can take down the entire system because of how deeply its counterparty risk goes. Is it true that decentralized finance, that's the application of that secure digital bearer asset, not just to currencies, but actually to all of the other securities, creates an entirely new financial system that's based on assets rather than institutions, and we don't have to have systemic risk that's tied to any one institution?
Mike Green: I'm going to give that one a partially true one because I think the design of that system, there's a choice. The current system relies on a— and this is very well described by a very unpopular individual right now, Omarova. The idea that what we have now is we have a banking system, we have a currency system that relies on agents of the government, not actually members of the government, but effectively the banking system and the shadow banking system to create most of the money that we see.
The uncertainty about the quality of those counterparties is what you're referring to, and the crises associated with that is what you're referring to. I agree with you that it is likely that that will change radically with the introduction of tokenized and digital securities.
Erik Townsend: So with tokenized securities and a tokenized financial system, we can really make a better mousetrap, a better financial system that has less systemic risk, more transparency, Transparency. It's a better thing. It is the way of the future. You and I agree on that, don't we?
Mike Green: Yes, 100%.
Erik Townsend: Okay. Now, I think this is where we really have to draw the line and just say the only place where you and I don't necessarily agree with the Bitcoin maximalist crowd is the idea that it will continue to be possible for private actors. That's basically the developers all around the world that contribute to the creation of the Bitcoin network.
What I've predicted and you've predicted is that governments will eventually wake up and recognize that, hey, these guys are not the bunch of jokers that the central bankers have described them as. They really do pose a threat to the government's monopoly over the issuance of currency. And eventually, you and I have predicted that governments will figure out, hey, if we don't do something about these guys, they really will replace all government-issued money with something better, because they have come up with something better.
Mike Green: Right.
Erik Townsend: The only place where you and I disagree with the crypto crowd is we think that governments eventually will wake up and recognize they're about to lose that monopoly, and they'll probably freak out in a way that is extremely damaging to the privately issued cryptocurrencies that are designed to compete with government-issued money. Is that the gist of it?
Mike Green: Yes. And I would go a step further and say that where my concern lies is mostly in that reaction function and the fact that it could end up much worse. If that recognition is delayed and we develop effectively a shadow currency system or a shadow riskless asset system, shadow collateral system that is in opposition to the interests of governments, and by extension, governments that are perhaps not competently pursuing it, but generally trying to do the right thing, in particular in the case of the United States.
That the reaction function to that is going to be much worse. And so my biggest concern is the broad attitude of, you can't stop us. You have no power of us. You can't regulate us. If you try to, we're just going to pick up and take our ball and go home and play somewhere else. I just don't think that that's a realistic proposal.
Erik Townsend: And I think it becomes quite Well, now I'm really going to surprise our listeners. And part of this, I'm playing devil's advocate, but my view is evolving. When I wrote my book on this 3 years ago, I said, look, there's no way governments are ever going to allow the monopoly over the issuance of money to be taken away from them by a bunch of hackers on the internet who came up with the invention of a better kind of money. What always happens when you invent a really cool weapon and try to oppose a really powerful government with it is they come and kill your soldiers and take your weapon away from you and copy it and use it for their own purposes. And I predicted that would happen, but I also said, you know, there is a certain point where it becomes politically very, very difficult to outlaw something if it has received already enough government endorsement where people have put their savings into it and so forth.
And we've reached a point, Mike, where we have SEC-endorsed, blessed Bitcoin ETFs that people are putting their retirement savings into. It would be very difficult for the government to say, look, in the interest of national security, we have to ban this cryptocurrency stuff. And oh, the fact that a whole bunch of voting Americans put their life savings into this stuff through a regulated ETF that the SEC blessed, well, sorry, shit happens.
I think it's already getting to the point
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Where, although I do think that the stakes are so high that once governments figure out what really is at stake, they'll do what they have to do. But I think that the scenario I first saw where it's a very easy fight, there's not a lot of bloodshed, governments just say, look, we're gonna shut this thing down. The way we do that is we just outlaw the conversion. You know, we make it a crime for any bank to, you know, convert anything into or out of it, to facilitate any kind of exchange into or out of cryptocurrency between fiat currency and cryptocurrency. Just doing that makes it so impractical that it would really, really take a huge dent out of it. Well, it would be really hard to do that now politically, and it's getting harder. So at what point do you get to where it really becomes a major political bloodshed for the government to change its view on this thing?
Mike Green: I think 2 things. One is, again, it goes— and I, by the way, have had similar observations where my view is the The best case scenario for the Bitcoin proponents, and again, this is going to draw massive amounts of hate, but is that ultimately it turns into an executive order or 6102 where the government says, here's the price that we will buy these assets from you for so that you don't experience a crippling loss. But it doesn't become a pure taking in terms of it's forced to zero, but it does become a taking in the form of we will no longer allow this to develop.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Mike Green: To me, that feels like the best case and is roughly, I think, what you're alluding to.
Erik Townsend: Well, I actually have a different view, and I don't think we're there yet. I think there is still room for governments to wake up and recognize the threat that a better currency system poses to their monopoly. But if it goes much farther, what I would anticipate is that governments realize they can't outlaw it. And so what they do is they simply, quote, regulate it. That's regulate in air quotes, meaning that they're basically going to say, you have to completely redesign it to do the opposite of what it does, you have to replace all of those wonderful privacy features of Bitcoin and make it so it's completely, totally traceable by the government. And if you don't do that, well, then it's illegal. And so we didn't outlaw it. We just said you had to add safety features to make it better. And of course, those features would really undermine what Bitcoin was actually designed to do.
So I think they would force the fundamental change of what these things are in a way that undermines their design intention. And that would cause probably a fork where there's a bunch of people that say, I want to have legal cryptocurrency, whatever that means. And a bunch of other people who say, F that, we're sticking with the good old Bitcoin standard and let them try to shut us down. And I think they will shut them down eventually, but it'll be a difficult fight. And the days of where I used to think it would be easy for government to shut it down, I think those days are numbered, if not over.
Mike Green: So I think it's always been difficult to shut it down. And I think this I think this has been one of the broad misunderstandings. Nobody is arguing that it is easy to shut this down. You absolutely can start up a meth lab or start up a crypto mining rig and try to keep Bitcoin alive. There's no question about that. But the question for me is, do you want to bear the costs associated with that? There's remarkable rewards that accrue to somebody who opens up a meth lab in terms of monetary compensation.
There's also remarkable penalties associated with getting caught doing that. And so it exists in our society, but it is not celebrated on CNBC. That I think is— I would argue that unfortunately, I would agree with the way that you were saying it, that there is the potential for there to be a neutered asset that can be used as collateral, et cetera.
At Simplify, we actually offer exposure to Bitcoin and to crypto in ways that are consistent with the regulated environment. I don't know how that is going to play out. I can't know with absolute certainty, but the whole focus for us is on encouraging that people take a responsible allocation to it rather than treat it as this is the certainty, this is an unstoppable force.
So I don't know exactly how it's going to play out. It obviously is stochastic and depends upon the reaction function, but there are lots of things that are illegal that have not been stamped out that I would guess the vast majority of people really even though they can be profitable, really don't want to be involved with.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm sure that might be true, like meth labs, but we really are talking about a superior form of currency system. And I think that the reason that I have predicted and you've predicted that governments should object to it is it really is better, dramatically better. And that means that their monopoly over the issuance of money is at risk if they allow it to continue.
I'm astonished that most government officials, and particularly central bankers, have not figured out that reality. They certainly seem to have woken up to the need for central bank digital currencies, but they don't seem to realize that there is, I think, a very real risk if they don't get their act together, that Ethereum or some other digital currency will reach a point where it really is very hard to stop. I think that's—
Mike Green: I mean, again, I agree. I'm not suggesting that it's going to be easy in the same way that it's not easy to stamp out all sorts of illegal activity, but I still don't see the scenario in which it is embraced. And that may be where we differ. I also would suggest that while I think that there are features around the tokenization and digital nature of the assets that are unique and superior to the attempts at tokenization that we have around the US currency, for example, right? The serial numbers that exist on a dollar bill are a form of digitizing the asset, to create scarcity around that individual asset. Now, they're used ineffectively for tracing things like forgeries, counterfeiting, et cetera, but they are not in any way, shape, or form native to it. You cannot track it in the same manner.
I think the point that I would broadly make around Bitcoin in that framework is that it is an asset that does a remarkably good job of one thing, which is if the government were to actually decide this is not okay, It would be very easy for the government to actually identify who were doing the things that are not okay.
I think that's something that people need to take very, very seriously.
Erik Townsend: Let's take a step back then from Bitcoin and just talk about secure digital bearer assets, which you and I agree are going to completely change the face of finance and that really provide a way to create a far superior currency system that's much better than any conventional currency.
Now, I know we've got a lot of listeners rolling their eyes saying, wait a minute, the financial system's been digital for 30 years. I do everything online, wire transfers, whatever. What is this tokenized? What is so special about this? Why is it actually so much better, Mike? Other than a bunch of kids like it, what's so special about these tokenized currency dollars instead of just regular good old green dollar bills?
Mike Green: Well, the primary feature is actually that it allows you to One, have a much more robust relationship between the government and most of its citizens. So many in the Bitcoin world highlight the challenge of the unbanked, that there are people who do not have access to financial services. Ultimately, digital securities allow you to create an individual relationship that doesn't require the outdated franchise relationship, again, to steal from an unpopular author. That is what we have in the banking system. So the banking system basically exists as an authorized entity that has the capability of tapping into the Federal Reserve, tapping into the actual core of the banking system, and does so by offering me assets that are the exact same thing that we see, by the way, in stock markets where I don't actually own the stock.
I am a semi-secured creditor of Merrill Lynch or Fidelity or JP Morgan in terms of a brokerage relationship. The same thing is true within the banking relationship, absent the FDIC insurance. As a depositor, I am an unsecured creditor within that banking system.
The digital token allows you to have a direct relationship where your claim is against the government itself. And so effectively any abrogation of that becomes the equivalent of the government choosing to default. It's a much harder, much lower counterparty risk, as you were referring to earlier, Now, the fear, and this is a very valid one, is that when you replace that relationship, you've effectively created lots of small individuals against one giant bank. And that giant bank is presumed to have power and a willingness to use things like financial repression and inflation to steal the money of the population.
That's one of the things that I think is so caustic about the current narrative is that inherent lack of trust. Have they done the best job possible? Absolutely not. Have they done things to engender our trust? It's very debatable. Are the choices that they have made as irrational as they're often presented? I don't think so.
Erik Townsend: Now, I'm fascinated. You said that the principal benefit was that it allows essentially a direct digital relationship between the holder of currency And the government. I'm sure that a lot of the crypto audience is not going to enjoy that comment and say, wait a minute, it's not the government. It's specifically in the case of Bitcoin, not the government. So it really is the currency system that you have. You actually have a digital token that can't be counterfeited.
You don't have to worry about whether your bank goes under because you don't need the bank. You can keep your money in this digital tokenized system, which you might have a custodian for, or you might not have a custodian for, it's secure. And once we get to tokenized assets, not just currencies, but also securities, you're using one tokenized asset to buy other tokenized assets. You don't have any counterparty risk or any custodial risk because you don't depend on a custodian to hold your stocks for you. They're actually in your name in the digital system, so to speak. But what you're saying is, well, you're making the assumption that the government is in charge of this digital system.
Let's at least consider the possibility that what a lot of people are saying is, look, governments are slow and inefficient and screwed up. And what the Bitcoin crowd think they're doing is to create a better currency system. And it absolutely is better. Now, right now in its current implementation, using the proof-of-work-based validation architecture, it's extremely inefficient in how it uses resources.
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: That's all going to change. The first version of any software, it always gets better over time. We'll eventually outdo proof of work with proof of stake-based systems. It's going to get much more efficient with time. But the question is, is it valid to say, you know what, government's never going to do this. It's going to be the private sector that creates the new currency systems of the future. And it is, it's probably not going to be Bitcoin, but it's going to be Facebook, whatever they're calling Libra these days, or it's going to be Google Money or Apple Bucks or Whatever.
It's gonna be Silicon Valley that basically partners with the government and saying, look, you let this crypto thing go too far. And now if you wanna save it, you're not gonna be able to save it with the pace of government. You're gonna have to make a deal with us. You're gonna have to make a deal with Google. And we'll create Google digital dollars, and you can bless them as United States Google digital dollars. And we'll be your vendor who's in charge of administering the global currency system that, by the way, we'd like being in charge of.
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I think that is a plausible scenario. Now, the one where Bitcoin, which is designed to intentionally alienate and offend government officials with the features that it has in order to allow people to hide their transactions from government oversight, I don't think that stuff's gonna fly long-term. I think it will eventually be outlawed. But the idea of a Silicon Valley giant like Apple or Google or even Facebook Facebook making a deal with the government saying, look, you guys let the cryptocurrency stuff get out of control. You got to have digital currency, but you got to get it at Silicon Valley pace, not Washington DC pace. Sign us up. Is that realistic?
Mike Green: I think that's super realistic. I don't know that it necessarily is Silicon Valley, and I don't know that it's not some form of government contractor. For all intents and purposes, it could end up being Lockheed Martin. We don't know the answer. Now, I would suggest that Google is better positioned for it, or Facebook is better positioned for it than Lockheed Martin in this situation.
But ultimately, I completely agree with you that the government fully recognizes that their inability to work at that pace that is required for that adoption is likely to push it into a public-private partnership.
And if you want a very simple model for how that could work, just imagine effectively a base layer system that is provided free of charge to all members of our society. So every individual receives a Social Security number when they are born or when they become a US citizen. And on the back of that, or an employer identification number when you become a company, on the back of that, you effectively have that as your bank account number sitting in a central repository that is then able to say, again, to use the today example for it, this piece of paper that we call a dollar bill that has this particular serial number, right? Now, add the richness of the digital tokenized format to that, sits in this account and is available to be spent by this individual. And they're is no indication or no confusion about who actually owns and controls that.
That base layer can be provided free of charge to everybody in our society. The next layer of service, let's say you are a corporation that wants to exceed a certain number of transactions or wants to access complex financial relationships, things like OTC derivatives, et cetera, then you have to pay for value-added services on top of that.
That, to me, makes perfect sense. It feels like that's absolutely the direction that it's going.
Erik Townsend: I think that's the direction it's going to. I call them SVDCs, for Silicon Valley digital currencies, and I suppose you're right, it doesn't have to be Silicon Valley, although I think that's the most likely origin of such a thing. And I really think, unfortunately for the Bitcoin crowd, it is going to be the absolute antithesis of Bitcoin. I think that some big Silicon Valley company, might be Facebook, might be Google, will get in bed with the government and design a digital currency system with features exactly the opposite of Bitcoin's design objectives.
Every single transaction will be traced. You know, there'll be a permanent audit trail that allows the government to see exactly every penny of wealth that you've ever had, who you got it from, what circumstances you got it under, where it came from, where they got it from. It's all gonna be traceable, and it's all gonna be billed as a security feature that helps us to fight off terrorism. And all of Satoshi Nakamoto's goals are— they're gonna use his technology to create something that achieves exactly the opposite goals. And I think it will be private industry, something like Facebook's Libra growing into a government— I don't know if it's sanctioned or government-chartered thing, which eventually creates a private label digital currency that is adopted by several nations and becomes the new global reserve currency, replacing the US dollar.
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Now, if that happens, there are very significant consequences to the US dollar and the US currency system in losing reserve currency status. And that would have to all be factored into the plans. And right now, the planners don't seem to have figured out what Bitcoin is yet, like 15 years later. So I'm not sure this is all going to go down in a most perfectly efficient way. I don't know about you, but if there's one thing I do not want to see the George Washington dollar bill replaced with, it's a Mark Zuckerberg dollar bill.
What could be the risks here?
Mike Green: I think you just hit on a bunch of them, right? This is part of the point that I make and it tends to drive people a little reactionary, I guess, is the kind way of saying it. The US has many faults and has made terrible policy choices. That's true for all countries. We tend not to pay attention to that for the very simple reason that they are much smaller on the global stage.
The closest analog that we have to ourselves at this point is obviously China. And I think very few in the audience, even those who are Bitcoin maximalists, would argue that they would prefer to live under the Chinese system than the US system. The US is somewhat unique in its willingness to consider these alternative systems. And ironically, many in the United States who politically value what they refer to as freedom, Right? I'm skeptical that what Ted Cruz really wants is freedom, but who speak in that way are willing to consider systems that, quote unquote, weaken the government, right?
The classic smaller government component. Again, we're kind of 40 years into the Reagan revolution, and I know that everyone is going to push back and say, oh, well, the government's bigger than it's ever been sort of thing. The reality is, is that we've gotten to this point that we say the government accomplishes nothing good, and that's just not true.
Governments exist for a variety of reasons, but the most important one is that they are representing the social will of the people in the case of an elected democracy or an elected representative government like we have in the United States. Do they do that particularly well? In many cases they don't, but the alternative is much, much worse.
And so when we engage in an attempt to tear down the US dollar and reduce the influence of the US on the global stage, The real risk is not that a Bitcoin emerges de novo and becomes this fantastic new standard under which we all become wealthy and happy simply by participating in the system.
The risk is that that power vacuum is filled by far more nefarious elements.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the subject of stablecoins generally, because I think as much as there's so much attention and hype and hoopla around Bitcoin and the cryptocurrency Most people really don't want to take the speculative risk of betting on something, even if they're real true believers in where it's headed. You know, betting your life savings on an incredibly volatile asset class like Bitcoin, it's hard to sell most grownups on. On the other hand, if you're talking about the promise, and I emphasize the word promise, that is, if you believed the sales pitch on stablecoins, it's kind of got all the benefits of a digital currency system, and it's a tokenized asset. It exists outside It's outside of the institutionalized financial system.
It has all this cool stuff to it, but it's magically tied to just automatically, like a money market fund, it just never breaks the buck. It always stays tuned to the US dollar.
So you've got the stability of something like a money market fund, but it's all tokenized with all these benefits. Sounds like a perfect thing to put your whole life savings into, doesn't it? Well, you and I think no. But the reasons that you and I think no are really not obvious to the average retail investor, are they?
Mike Green: Well, I don't know that they are or they aren't, but effectively what it really is is counterparty risk. So we have no idea about the stablecoins that are in existence today in terms of what the actual assets that back them are. And the sponsors of these stablecoins, the Tethers, USDCs, et cetera, have completely failed despite incredible opportunity to do So to publish actually audited results, right? So telling us exactly what they own, what the assets that they own that back these assets are, what the degree of backing is.
We just don't know, and there's no reason why they can't. And so you mentioned money market mutual funds, for example, right? Money market mutual funds are heavily regulated on every single day. Literally, actually minute by minute, we can know what these things own. The filing dynamics of a Fidelity money market fund are going to tell us in excruciating detail, not only the individual securities that they own, but the broad classes, the liquidity characteristics, the interest rate that's being earned on those assets, et cetera.
We have nothing equivalent in the stablecoins that exist today. And that's what I think you and I ultimately object to because there is a demand for this digital asset. It is a superior security to a dollar bill that exists in my pocket that I can only send you economically if you and I both happen to have banking relationships that allow us to easily transfer funds between ourselves. Now, that can occur over a Venmo and it seems relatively simple. It can occur over a PayPal or it can occur by my handing you a dollar bill.
A stablecoin theoretically functions similarly in the digital world. The question is we just don't know what they actually are.
And that has always been the issue associated with these unregulated banking systems. It is an asset that we presume has stability that we really can't actually tell. And so it has very high, what's referred to as jump-to-default risk. If it turns out that Tether is actually not money good, the risk is not that it's 99 cents. The risk is that it's 3 cents.
That changes things, or 0 cents.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think this is really important, Mike, because first of all, a lot of people would say, you're crazy. You don't understand. Tether's perfectly fine. But based on what you've said, and I happen to agree with you, I'm not an expert on this, but what little I know of Tether is they've sort of kind of got a bank account in the Bahamas, kind of. Not sure I really think that meets my definition of a secure currency system or asset banking. But it seems to me like this concept of a stablecoin, Stablecoin that is backed by a fully audited book of assets that fully secure those stablecoins. So they really and truly are tied to the US dollar and they can't break the buck. I mean, all the technology exists to create that. It seems like the market for it is definitely there. You're saying Tether is not that. It seems like it's a fraud or it's a sham or it's a whatever.
Why wouldn't somebody, I mean, why wouldn't your company create a better Tether?
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: That really and truly does have the assets and it's not in the Bahamas, it's in a US financial institution. It's fully audited by a top-shelf US audit firm. Why doesn't somebody create one of those?
Mike Green: Well, the simple answer is that's what Libra was supposed to be. And what they discovered with Libra, the idea was very straightforward under Libra, which is we're going to offer this stablecoin. We're going to create a deposit-taking institution. That allows people to take their fiat currency, put it into a quote unquote stablecoin, the Libra coin, and we're then going to benefit from the fact that we've taken in billions of dollars, which we can invest and earn a float for providing the services associated with that superior asset.
What they discovered is in a world of zero and negative interest rates, man, that's not a very profitable business. And so this is part of the challenge that we have. Yes, absolutely, that's a service in the same way that the US government loses loses money when it prints a dollar bill.
It's far more efficient for them to create a digital one. Currency exists as a service to the US public. We lose money on nickels, we lose money on pennies, we lose money on dollar bills. That's unfortunately where we would be in today's low interest rate world if somebody tried to offer that service. It costs more than you're generating in return from it.
Erik Townsend: Oh, I trust the boys at Facebook to figure out all sorts of hidden ways to make a buck that nobody really knows what's going on until it's Too late. So I don't know that they can't make it profitable, but certainly if you did it above boards and advertised it was doing nothing more than be a stablecoin, I agree, that's not too profitable. But I think this really is the crux.
Whoever is in charge of this, this goes back to the age-old issue of governments not being able to understand and keep up with technology. Whoever's in charge of this is going to have incredible power.
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And regulators in charge of regulating it aren't going to really know what's going on.
Mike Green: I tend to think that's true. I think unfortunately, and this is absolutely true as it relates to something like Tether, when it exists and has grown in the manner that it has grown outside of a regulated system where there is no regulatory authority who has the ability to say, you must show us exactly what you own at every moment, or we at least have the ability to go in and take Because again, Tether is not regulated. They'll point to FinCEN, et cetera. FinCEN is not a regulatory body, it is a registration body.
Meaning in other words, it's just, hey, give us your phone number basically, and maybe we'll call you at some point in the future. When you have that type of framework, it encourages all sorts of bad behavior. The worst case scenario would simply be that Tether is just taking the funds and absconding with them. I think that's probably unlikely.
The second alternative is that they are providing a service primarily to the unregulated exchanges that facilitate the banking relationships effectively that are required for people to trade crypto. Because I have to put money into an exchange, I have to put money into an account in order to effectuate trades.
The role of that in a stock market, for example, when your brokerage relationship is by the money market mutual fund. It becomes the zero base asset, the zero volatility base asset that allows me to comfortably exist within a Charles Schwab or a Fidelity. That's what they're effectively trying to create. And it's possible that they have relationships with the FTXs and the Krakens, et cetera, of the world, the Binances, where that's the service that they're providing and they're charging a fee for it associated with it. And they're choosing to invest those assets in things that are more speculative than we would otherwise believe. That does create the potential for earning float. And there's a lot of rumors that float around things like Tether owns Chinese commercial paper.
Again, we just don't know. We don't know. My hunch is that to the extent that they have backing by assets, it's ultimately just an IOU from their customers, the exchanges. You don't have a direct relationship with Tether. You have a relationship with Tether through an exchange. That's my hunch. My hunch is that to the extent there's assets there, it's effectively credit that is being extended to the exchanges.
Whether that is good credit or bad credit is somewhat unknowable. But when you are dealing with unregulated exchanges, the risk of them becoming regulated and being shut down and those assets going to zero, and therefore everybody discovers that there's not enough assets to back the Tether component, are quite high. And it doesn't feel like people are aware of that or willing to accept the role that that might play.
Erik Townsend: Well, it seems to me that the real point here is we urgently need a true stablecoin that is absolutely solidly backed and audited and nobody questions whether it's a sham or not. And it seems like we don't quite have one yet.
Mike Green: Well, that's the whole point behind central bank digital currencies, right? Because it eliminates the question of, is it exchangeable for fiat in a one-for-one basis? Right? I mean, the irony that I would argue within the Bitcoin community is the role of stablecoins in playing that and facilitating it exactly as we're describing, like a money market mutual fund within your Schwab account that allows you to buy and sell, right? Because you have to remember, when I buy Bitcoin, I need to have funds available to execute that immediately. When I sell Bitcoin, I need to have a place to put the proceeds.
That's what a stablecoin fills. Right? I can't. I don't actually have magically an ATM that then prints out U.S. dollars from my computer. What I have is I have the ability to put it into a zero volatility asset on deposit effectively at that exchange or through that relationship. That we have absolutely no idea what's underpinning that theoretically stable asset.
I don't understand how people don't understand how important that is. And the second thing that I would highlight is that there's an awful lot of language around the idea that this can't possibly be in. Can Tether be influencing Bitcoin in this manner? It absolutely can, because this is the source of liquidity for a very illiquid asset. There's no question that that can have a huge impact.
Erik Townsend: Yeah. It's to say that Tether has no impact on Bitcoin is to say that the US dollars have no impact on stock prices.
Mike Green: Correct.
Erik Townsend: Pay for them.
Mike Green: 100%.
Erik Townsend: Pay for them with US dollars.
Mike Green: Right. And so a perfect illustration of this is actually what happened in 2008. So if you remember, the first reserve There are two issues associated with the failure of Lehman. One was a large money market mutual fund, First Reserve, held Lehman bonds. And because Lehman bonds— and again, money market mutual funds are regulated, they can only hold assets that have a certain rating— because Lehman failed so quickly, it never had the opportunity to be downgraded. The process of downgrading the asset would've meant that it was transferred out of a riskless vehicle like First Reserve And sold at a very minor loss to the next person down the risk curve who would be willing to take some speculative risk or had the capability of taking some speculative risk.
Because it was a very sizable component and this happened, First Reserve quote unquote broke the buck. That meant that people who were using money market mutual funds as collateral in leveraged relationships or who were relying on X amount of cash in their portfolios suddenly found themselves with less cash cash, that meant they had to sell stocks or other risk assets.
The second source of the panic that occurred around the collapse of Lehman was many hedge funds had a relationship with Lehman as a prime broker, where what they thought was their cash was sitting at Lehman. And when Lehman failed, it actually turned out that they just became an unsecured creditor and had to step into the Lehman claims line, which meant they didn't have cash.
In order to transact and deal with things, you need cash. So they had to sell securities. When everyone has to do that together, you get the crash of Lehman.
Erik Townsend: Well, Mike, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. But before I let you go, tell us a little bit more about Simplify Asset Management. Now, you and our friend Harley Bassman both kind of changed jobs in order to go co-found this company or were involved with other founders. What's it about and why an ETF at this particular point in your career?
Mike Green: Yeah. So both Harley and I actually left to join a group of founders who had founded Simplify. Simplify is an ETF provider that is taking advantage of a significant change in the rules that governed ETFs and mutual funds that occurred in a combination of 2019 and 2020. The rule changes to the ETF rule, which was introduced in 2019, effectively made it much easier to introduce new and innovative products in the ETF space without a lengthy comment period And so it's facilitated the growth of things like actively managed ETFs. We're trying to do things a little bit differently. The second rule change happened in late 2020. It was what's referred to as the derivative rule, and it facilitated the ability to include derivative strategies within ETFs in a way that hadn't been done before. There's efficiencies associated with this. It removes the requirement to have complex relationships with a brokerage firm in terms of things like ISDAs, right? So a That's
effectively a credit agreement that exists between a hedge fund or a very wealthy individual and a bank. Because of the introduction of the derivative rule, we're now able to include derivative overlays within products like an S&P 500 index fund that allows people to participate in the market. And many of your viewers have heard me talk about passive and the dynamics of how that's causing prices to The growth of passive is causing prices to rise. Our objective is to take strategies that allow participation in that and effectively put a seatbelt on it, right? So protect against the more adverse conditions that people have heard me talk about.
Erik Townsend: Mike, we look forward to having you back in a few months for an update. Meanwhile, listeners, be sure to check out simplify.us for more information on Mike's ETF offerings.
Erik Townsend: Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices The conversation continues right after this message from our sponsor. Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. Escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion. on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales.
It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, great to have Mike back on the show, but now we're going to experiment with what might become a regular new segment, Erik's own editorial on a timely subject in finance. To kick this experiment off, Erik's editorial this week is on hyperinflation. Erik, take it away.
Erik Townsend: Last week, Twitter founder Jack Dorsey added his voice to the choir of ignorance predicting hyperinflation of the US dollar in the near future. Now, to be sure, Mr. Dorsey's command of macroeconomics is on par with that of Paris Hilton, so the grown-ups who actually understand such matters were never likely to have taken anything he said seriously.
But he's a very prominent public figure, and he's contributing to a growing ignorance which absolutely will not help society to navigate the coming secular inflation. But what really scares me is not Jack Dorsey. What scares me is when the captains of finance, world-famous hedge fund managers, and institutional investors go on the cable networks and talk about how we're definitely headed for hyperinflation, and that hyperinflation might even be as bad as the hyperinflation we experienced back in the. 1970s.
Look, I'm going to make this simple, folks. Anytime that you hear anyone talk about the hyperinflation we had back in the 1970s, you should instantly recognize that you're dealing with a macroeconomic imbecile, a person who literally has no qualms going on CNBC or Bloomberg and pontificating on a subject such as hyperinflation without so much as bothering to acquaint themselves with the meaning of the word. It's shocking, and I would be tempted to criticize those networks' producers for inviting such idiots back on their channel. But, ahem, if I did that, I'm sure some of our more astute longtime MacroVoices listeners might point out that I think we've even had a guest or two make that mistake, that astonishingly ignorant mistake, right here on MacroVoices.
Now look, I'm not trying to be a pedantic jerk and nitpick terminology. Secular inflation, something that really is coming, is a completely, totally different phenomenon than hyperinflation. They have little in common in terms of cause, and confusing the two phenomena is extremely dangerous because they're caused by completely different things that result in different outcomes. There was no hyperinflation or anything remotely related to hyperinflation in the United States in the 1970s. '70s, and there's no reason to expect or fear hyperinflation now.
Now don't get me wrong, I think we're headed for at least a decade of sustained high rates of consumer price inflation, almost certainly exceeding 10% per annum for several years and possibly exceeding 20% per annum for a few years as central banks around the world inflate away the purchasing power of their national debts, just as they did after World War II. And that inflation is really nothing more than an incredibly devious form of taxation, diluting the value of everyone's savings in order to make up for the government's past mistakes. Secular inflation is a period of many years during which too much money is chasing a limited supply of goods and services, causing prices to rise. In the present example, the source of the excess money will be central bank largesse which has already fueled asset price inflation for the last decade. Now don't get me wrong, inflation is coming and it's going to be a really big deal.
I personally wouldn't be surprised if it's an even bigger deal than the inflation of the 1970s. But none of that has anything to do with hyperinflation, which is neither imminent nor likely if we're talking about the US dollar.
Hyperinflation is the wholesale loss of faith in a currency system. It's not about too much money chasing not enough goods and services driving up prices. That's regular inflation, and that's what we should be focused on because that is what's actually coming. There are several textbook definitions of hyperinflation. The most commonly cited one stipulates a minimum price appreciation rate of 50— that's 5-0— percent, not per year, but per month. That annualizes to well over 1,000% per year. And by that measure, not even the 2000 Argentine inflation, which reached annualized price appreciation rates over 80%, qualified as a true hyperinflation. And the American secular inflation and stagflation of the 1970s never came anywhere remotely close to that, never mind to actual hyperinflation. inflation, and that inflation was driven by factors completely different than those that drive hyperinflation. These phenomena are completely different, and we need to stop confusing them.
Hyperinflation is not about prices rising because too many people with money are competing for a limited supply of goods and services. Hyperinflation is when the general population loses faith in a currency system and is willing to do just about anything to avoid holding their savings in a currency they no longer trust and believe in. It happens when the entire currency system is failing and the people who used to use it are finding alternatives. Examples are the recent Zimbabwe hyperinflation, when the government began printing trillion-dollar banknotes which still wouldn't buy a loaf of bread because nobody wanted or trusted Zimbabwe's official currency system.
Another example is the Weimar hyperinflation that resulted from the German printing way too much money trying to cope with the country's war reparation obligations after World War I. As a general rule of thumb, systematically important currencies such as the US dollar, the euro, the yen, and the British pound are effectively immune from hyperinflation unless something changes their systematically important status in the global economy.
Am I saying that a US dollar hyperinflation is impossible? Well, of course not. Anything is possible, and I never say never. But let's talk about what it would take to actually bring that about. Now, if the US were to get into a shooting war with China and lose, and if that war outcome resulted in an entire world abandoning the US dollar as the global reserve currency, and all foreign central banks divested their US holdings, well, that would certainly be a ripe setup for a true US dollar hyperinflation to occur as the American people lost faith in their government, and the government responded by panicking and printing too much money trying to save the economy in an environment where they no longer had that systemic importance of their currency system to the rest of the world to prevent it from hyperinflating. But what it would take would be for the American people to lose faith in their government and ditch their dollars in favor of euros or Bitcoins or bullion or After World War II,
it was actually cigarettes that became the principal currency in war-torn Europe when there was no banking system. But short of a major shock that unseats the US government's command over its economy, US dollar hyperinflation is almost impossible. Was Jack Dorsey really anticipating a war or other series of events which would completely unseat the US from its current position of power in the world? Or is Jack just an idiot in a tie-dye t-shirt? t-shirt who people inexplicably take seriously for no apparent reason as he mouths off about something he obviously does not understand? I think that answer is obvious, but again, it's not Jack that worries me.
We have people who are in charge of our pension funds and financial institutions running around using the words stagflation and hyperinflation interchangeably as if they were synonymous. But again, I'm not trying to nitpick the terminology. Look, if we're going to get through the coming secular inflation, we're going to need people in the finance industry who understand what the hell is really going on and why it's happening. But what we currently have in the ranks of the best and the brightest who run our financial institutions are macroeconomic imbeciles who, to any trained observer, have obviously never bothered to so much as read up on the most basic fundamental concepts of the different types of inflation. and how they work and what the correct terminology is. So next time you hear anyone tell you that we're headed for hyperinflation, just like the hyperinflation of the 1970s, don't take one more word they say on any subject seriously. You're dealing with an imbecile who uses loaded terminology without so much as bothering to acquaint themselves with the meaning of the vocabulary they profess to be expert on.
Folks, please let us know if you want more editorials. We're thinking about a few ideas for sprucing up the show for format, and the possibility of a weekly or monthly editorial is one of the ideas that we're toying with.
Erik Townsend: Whether or not we do this again will depend on listener feedback. But right now, let's move on to Patrick's post-game chart deck, which is titled Going Parabolic. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Now, that Research Roundup email may be delayed this week, so bear with us. It'll be out at some point on Thursday evening. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to the homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says Looking for the Download. All right.
Let's go ahead and take a look at the chart deck. You start off with a chart of the NASDAQ. What's going on?
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I want to start off with the NASDAQ. Normally we talk S&P 500, but it is really worth noting how the market really has accelerated, and particularly in the last few days has really started to almost feel a little parabolic in this rise. I put the trend lines not for predictive value, but rather just to identify the slope of the rise and really shows how the market really has just taken off on the upside. And it really is interesting to see how far this will go. I mean, there's a lot of people that have played out that melt-up scenario and saying that that's the way the equity markets were going to finish this move. And really, that is now looking to be the case. The question now is how much gas is in the tank and how far far can they take it?
Uh, we'll be doing the play-by-play on this, but boy, is this, uh, a chart that's,
Patrick Ceresna: uh, accelerated to the upside. So next here on page 3, I wanted to really touch on Tesla because this is where that real parabolic price action can be really identified. It's not that there aren't other stocks out in the market that have this type of a parabolic move, but it's the fact that it's a trillion-dollar market cap company that's doing it. And this move has just been phenomenal to the upside. The bears are being squeezed out, the shorts are being knocked out, and at the same time, all those call buyers and the huge call open interest is just grabbing at all that gamma on the upside, driving this parabolic move. I mean, when you see this type of acceleration, it's a, it's a bold thing to suggest that we know what price level this will stop. Arguably, when something goes parabolic like this, it could go to $1,500, it could go to $2,000.
But bottom line of what I've seen in the past with these types of patterns is that they tend to blow off in a relatively reasonable time frame. And so while how much more upside there is in the coming week or two is something that we have yet to determine, it is likely that there is going to be some sort of a short-term blow-off top and a pretty meaningful mean reversion that comes on the other side as the profit takers kick in. One of the things I'll be looking for is when will there be a material and significant spike in implied volatilities to particularly on the right end of the curve to truly discourage call buying, further call buying by simply making the options so expensive. Certainly going to be something that's on my mind watching as we move forward. The last thing I wanted to touch on the equity charts was to have a quick peek at the
Patrick Ceresna: Russell 2000.
And what's particularly interesting about about the small-cap space is that while the S&P and NASDAQ have been generally trending all year, the small caps have been in a very tight sideways range-bound market for the entire 2021 year pretty much. And we just this week got the first technical breakout of this. And while that in itself is not a guarantee of anything, but usually When you have new highs develop this way, it draws a lot of attention. And certainly the overbought state that the market was at the start of the year has been completely unwound. It'll be really interesting to see whether or not this will mark the beginning of a new bull trend in the small caps and whether they'll participate on the upside.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, next you've got the Euro-US Dollar cross and crude oil. What's on your mind?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, I just wanted to give an update on this Euro. We were looking at it last time as the ECB announcement was coming out and it tried to pop higher, but really in the last week and then subsequently in the post-FOMC, we continue to see US dollar strength and the euro deteriorating back down to October lows. It'll be really interesting to see whether the support line holds. If it doesn't, I mean, that opens the window for the euro to head down to like 113 or 112 on the downside. And certainly that's a pretty significant overhead resistance on on the dollar index itself. And so this is such an important currency to watch in my mind.
And just touching on that crude oil chart, really what I wanted to highlight was simply that pop and drop that occurred today in that post-OPEC meeting period with the fact that it tried to rally and then gave it back really does increase the likelihood that we are now in the midst of some sort of mean reverting correction. And that doesn't in itself make crude oil bearish, but simply the likelihood now that it's going to consolidate some of this prior bull advance is certainly on the table. What I suspect is that this should be well defended during pullbacks, and I'm not looking for anything extraordinarily deep, but certainly this could be a prolonged multi-week process of, of backfilling and consolidation. before the next buying opportunity emerges.
Erik Townsend: And listeners, you can get Patrick's chart decks every single day with a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading. You find the information at bigpicturetrading.com or on page 7 of the slide deck. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, The world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to the Hoisington Quarterly Review and Outlook and an article discussing taper rates, bond markets, and consequences. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Erik Townsend: Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we The more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com.
And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants. And do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
David Hay — Evergreen Gavekal founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. And now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 295 was recorded on October 28th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Evergreen Gavekal founder David Hay returns as this week's feature interview guest, when the topic du jour will be greenflation, along with the usual macro suspects such as stocks, precious metals, and bond yields. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck is titled What's Going On in the Bond Markets?
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, that S&P 500 had exactly like a 24-hour market correction that lasted, uh, just a quick moment, and we're back up toward the 52-week highs. Uh, this thing just keeps going. Any insights on your end?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm going to discuss that with David Hay in today's interview. You know, I have really come around. I used to say years ago that, look, this whole thing has been driven by central bank largesse. It's unsustainable. It can't last forever. Surely, there's got to be a moment of reckoning when we're going to have a stock market crash. I don't think so. I think it's a melt-up into a crack-up boom. And I think it's an inflationary Great Depression, a greater depression, that is ultimately the big price that we pay for all of this central bank largesse. But we're not there yet. We got a long ways to go. And I think the stock market keeps on grinding higher.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's take a look at the dollar index, down 50 cents today. A bit of a reaction now in ECB and the euro. Uh, what's your take on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I really don't think there's anything to say. You know, we're between 89 and 94.5. I really don't try to swing trade it or anything. I don't have a view other than we're consolidating in a range, and until we break out of that range, I think we're just trading sideways here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's talk crude oil. First of all, how did the inventory numbers come in? And then let's talk about that little pullback. I mean, we had about a $5 pullback off the highs over a couple days. Is this a buy on dip?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I do think it's a buy on dip. We got down to the 21-day moving average, touching it exactly, and that has been what has caught this market for, I don't know, the last however many corrections. And we closed above the 13-day. We need to get above the 5 and the 8. If that happens tomorrow, then I'd say we're headed back toward new cycle highs. As far as what's going on though, it's really important to understand that Cushing, Oklahoma is having an oil inventory crisis. So this week's EIA inventory had crude oil building 4.3 million 4 million barrels nationally. But wait a minute, Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 3.9 million barrels. So, you know, around 4 million barrels, but it's opposite directions. National building, Cushing drawing down. What's going on is the ARBs are open out of Cushing to the Gulf Coast. They're drawing a lot of oil out. There's been a pipeline that— I can't remember if it was a pipeline reversal or just a capacity increase that has contributed to all this.
I don't really follow all the details in the physical market, but there's pipeline stuff going on contributing to this. And what it means is Cushing, Oklahoma is really about to run out of Deliverable oil. Now, the key word there is deliverable. There's lots of oil in those tanks in Cushing, Oklahoma. In fact, they're still at about 30% capacity, or almost 30% capacity.
The thing is, the WTI contract, which settles in Cushing, that's a specific grade of crude oil. And if the crude oil that's in those tanks is not that grade, if it's not deliverable against that grade, it means it can't be used to settle that contract. If you run out of deliverable oil in Cushing, Anything could happen in terms of manipulations of price and all kinds of crazy stuff. That's in the next few weeks. Now, at the same time, the old saying is high prices cure high prices. We've got massively wide time spreads at the front of the WTI term structure. That creates a huge incentive for anybody who's gotten the oil to deliver it into the front month contract. That would be what saves the day. But it looks like we're really going to run pretty close to running out of oil in Cushing in the next few weeks. So it's going to be really important to watch.
That could rocket the front month price to the moon. Anything is possible there. US production, 11.3 million barrels, unchanged. And again, it's going to be really interesting to see what this Cushing situation does to the price of WTI. It could turn the Brent-WTI spread upside down. A lot of things are possible. But again, high prices cure high prices. And maybe this is all going to get resolved as people respond to those prices by delivering more oil into Cushing.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's touch on gold. It's above $1,800, but then it's not. And then it is. And then it's not. So what's going on here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, you said it all. You know, I'm seeing all the gold bugs are on Twitter saying, look at the breakout, it's a breakout. Wait a minute. Look, a breakout is when something moves above a key technical level and then the price action accelerates from there and just takes off. What we've seen here is gold poked its head above the 100-day and 200-day moving average, which are co-located just below $1,800, and they got one daily close above. Then there was a daily close below. Then there were 2 daily closes above. It looks like today But not by very much. I want to see, you know, another $10 of upside beyond this and have the price stay meaningfully above that cluster of moving averages. Right now we're seeing a, you know, sort of kind of want to try breakout, not a real breakout. I'm still holding my breath.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Let's touch on that 10-year yield. It's interesting that on the 10 and the 30s that we're seeing pullback in the interest rates while it's changing at the front of the curve. We'll talk about in the postgame. But right now, we tested 1.70 the other week on the yields. And we're pulling back here to about 150. What's your thinking on interest rates?
Erik Townsend: Well, 170 has been the line in the sand that we've seen. That's where people in the past have started to freak out. In this case, we got there and I don't know that anybody freaked out, but the markets turned around. We don't have people this time. Last time we got to 170, there were all kinds of voices saying, okay, this is it. Bond market crash is on. The bond bear market that's going to go for the next 35 years to replace the bull market of the last 35 years has begun. I don't hear those voices anymore. So it seems like maybe the panic is down on that line in the sand at 170. Maybe that means there's room to go further. I don't know.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is Evergreen Gavekal founder David Hay. Erik, why did we get David on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, as you know, secular inflation has been the topic that I think is most interesting, and we've talked to all of our guests about it. David's been writing about what he calls greenflation. I don't want to steal his thunder, so I'll let you wait for the interview to hear what that is. But I think it's a fascinating Fascinating concept, and I think it's very much apropos to the markets today.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with David Hay is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the FinTech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or
Erik Townsend: www.abaxx.exchange or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is David Hay, founder and co-CIO of Evergreen Gavekal. David, it's great to get you back on the program. I've been asking everybody the same question as an opener, which is, okay, inflation. Are we talking secular structural inflation, which is what I think, or do we believe Janet and her friends in the government who say it is transitory? So I want to get your take on that, but particularly you've been writing about something called greenflation. What the heck is greenflation?
David Hay: Well, first, Erik, thank you very much for having me on the show. It's a privilege, especially since I just listened to your podcast last week with one of my heroes, Luke Gromen. And he did not talk about greenflation last week, even though he's written on it somewhat. So I appreciate the opportunity to talk about that because I think it's hugely important. And I think it plays a significant role in this debate about whether inflation is transitory, as the Fed is saying, or it's much more enduring.
Which I'm with you on that and Luke. And, you know, frankly, based on the Fed's forecasting record, which is horrific, and I think the fact that they're saying it's transitory is probably a pretty strong indication that it's not. Maybe once they finally concede that it's here for years, that'll be the time to take the other side of the trade. But basically, the idea of greenflation has to do with the reality that the planet is involved in a great green energy transition. And just one key element of this, which I think is inarguable, is that this is the first time in human history that we're moving from more efficient fuel sources to less efficient fuel sources.
And I'm aware of, you know, of all the environmental reasons why we're trying to do that, but that doesn't change the fact that it's extremely daunting to make this happen. And especially on the very ambitious and I'd say overly ambitious and unrealistic timeframe That policymakers around the world are trying to achieve.
And we're seeing the wages of this already with tremendous energy inflation occurring in Asia and Europe.
I think most Americans are unaware. I mean, we have natural gas, it's doubled. Natural gas is trading for around $6 per million British thermal units, MMBTUs. But in Asia and Europe, it's $30 or more. So you've got, you know, really a shocking amount of energy inflation occurring. And And real risks of rationing and outright shortages that could take lives if the winter is cold, as a lot of forecasters are predicting in Europe.
So, you know, we've got this war on fossil fuels where you've got a number of American cities that are trying to prevent natural gas being utilized and fighting the transmission of hydrocarbons, you know, pipeline shutdowns, even existing pipelines. There's a— The New Yorker gave the platform to a a Swedish professor who's written a book on how to blow up pipelines. He's avidly recommending that people go out and blow up energy pipelines. It's just unbelievable that he would be given that kind of a forum. But regardless, I mean, obviously we know that US policy is very anti-fossil fuels. So guess what? This is the first time in history that we've seen huge price spikes without a supply response.
So we still are at a point in this country where the drilling rig count is inadequate To offset the decline rate in the shale area, which is of course where we've had the tremendous growth of both natural gas and crude oil, is because of shale.
But as you know, Erik, and a lot of people don't, shale has an extremely rapid decline rate. So you have to drill a lot just to stay even. And that's hard to do when you've got pressure from your investor base about ESG, and you've also got pressure to, to not make those investments, but rather to buy back shares, which these companies are doing. So all these things are feeding this greenflation type of thing, and it's not going away. It's going to be with us for years to come, whether it's right or wrong.
Erik Townsend: Well, I have to confess, this is the first time I've heard the particular phrase greenflation. I agree with you.
David Hay: Well, good. I created that. I'd like royalties because I'm starting to hear some other people use it. I'm teasing.
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I want to push back a little. You've come up with a very catchy— I love the name, but But I think the gist of what you're saying is, hey, green energy is going to be more expensive. And it's an understood thing that we're trying to make the planet a better place. And it does mean you're going to have to have some additional expense. But if green energy costs more, then obviously the cost of energy is an input to the cost of everything. I think you've made that point.
David Hay: Precisely.
Erik Townsend: But I also think you just made a different point, which I personally think is even stronger. And I'll call it not greenflation, but really stupid policyflation. And that is where you say, look, let's vilify the, the oil industry. Let's take the people who are producing energy the old way, the kind that pollutes the environment, which is the only way we knew how to do it a few years ago. The people that are still in that business, let's make criminals out of them and let's punish them and treat them like bad people.
And whatever we do, let's make sure that we never, ever, ever invest money in their companies so that they can create more of those polluting resources because we have to clean this planet up. Okay, great. So you've just taken the people that are your lifeline to run the economy on, and you've turned them into the villains, and you've cut off their funding so they can't make any more oil wells in order to keep up the current supply. And you've also got this pipe dream that the whole world is going to be driving Teslas in 3 years, which is just not real. Where's all of this headed?
David Hay: All very well said, Erik. It's, it is kind of mass insanity. And that is what I'm seeing around the world in so many ways is Just these policies that are are illogical, irrational, you know borderline lunacy. And it's not that it doesn't make sense to try to to emit fewer pollutants; it obviously does. But I mean what you're seeing is as these energy crises hit in Asia and Europe is a surge in coal usage. And of course coal is one of the worst forms of fossil fuels that you can use. I mean CO2 is not a pollutant, but N2O nitrous oxide, which comes from burning coal, is an extreme pollutant. And and really kills people. Another thing that's that's bizarre about this is that two to three million people die every year in the developing world because they don't have access to clean burning fossil fuels such as natural gas and propane.
So actually, U.S. energy industry is making a big shift to to export large quantities of propane to, for example, Africa, so they don't have to burn dung and wood and other. You know, nasty things in their their little homes, which is terrible for people's health. So really, you know, I do. I think you're right. I mean, it's like we're treating the energy industry like the tobacco industry twenty years ago. Actually wrote one of our newsletters back in December called Totally Toxic. That you know, instead of saying, hey, this we need that we can't run our planet this day and age without energy.
So to demonize this industry, well, guess what? They're going to say we're not going to produce. We're just going to I mean, they'll drill a little bit here and there where they have fantastic returns, but we're not going to get that typical supply. You know, I'm a big believer that the cure for high prices is high prices, but that's not going to happen in this environment. And that's why I believe that the greenflation is going to be quite persistent.
Erik Townsend: Now for the challenging part, David. Let's take these ideas and talk about how to translate it to an investment strategy, because I see this as very difficult. One of the things that's going on here is Oil companies are not getting investment from funds because ESG mandates are basically vilifying them and saying, don't. In theory, that ought to mean that those oil companies are exceptional values because they're not getting the buyers from the funds. And therefore, you know, you can buy them on the cheap and it's a fantastic deal. But wait a minute, I'm not sure it's a fantastic deal to buy something on the cheap if there is this somewhat insanity-driven public agenda to treat those industries like criminals, even though we're dependent on them for the lifeblood of the economy. So does this mean that investing in oil companies is an incredible opportunity because they're undervalued right now?
Or does it mean it's a dumb idea because they're going to continue to be the victims of all this?
David Hay: I think it's the latter, Erik, and I'll tell you why. And again, this relates back to the newsletter I wrote, Totally Toxic. If you went back and bought Philip Morris 20 years ago, you would have absolutely crushed the S&P. I can't give you the exact data off the top of my head, but it's immense.
And so what— and that was, you know, those guys produce products that actually kill people, not that are essential to the operation of industry and, you know, basically maintaining human welfare, which obviously fossil fuels have been incredibly beneficial at over, you know, ever since they were invented. The energy density of gasoline, for example, is just remarkable. But The reality is even with the, you know, a horrible product for the last 20 years, they've been phenomenal investments. So I think that's what you're setting up for.
But what they did was they basically decided they're just going to raise prices. They're not going to go for market share and they're going to buy back immense amounts of their own stock and raise dividends. And that's exactly the model that the energy industries are already following. So what you're seeing is that a number of these companies have 15% free cash flow yields and even in the mid-20s for some of the The mid-tier operators.
And so yes, I think those are going to be very good investments for years to come. And I think the fact that so many different types of investors around the world won't touch them is actually a good thing for the contrarians. So I would argue it's a very good setup for years to come with energy, despite, and maybe because of, all the hostility towards the industry.
Erik Townsend: Now I'm just going to push a little harder on that because if I think about what you said, Is it really an opportunity for those energy companies, which are going to be the ones that are victimized by stupid government policy, or would it be smarter to say, no, I'd actually rather bet on just energy prices, buy the crude oil, buy the commodity rather than the companies that produce it?
David Hay: Well, that's a good point. I think the answer is yes. In fact, to your point, what's interesting is the futures curve in oil. Right now, oil is trading in the mid-80s, WTI, Brent's a little closer to 90. And yet, if you were to go out to 2023, 2 years from now, it's $15 a barrel lower.
And if you go out another year, it's $20 a barrel lower. So you could buy those futures contracts and just let them, let them go. And you're going to get a high rate of return just having it converge to today's spot price, which I actually believe is going higher. I think prices are, instead of going lower as the futures curve implies, they're going higher. Because we have an extreme shortage of oil right now, and it's getting more and more acute, which is exactly what the futures market tells you.
When you have that kind of what's called backwardation, where the spot price is so much higher than the futures price, it's telling you that the market's in an extremely tight, even deficit supply situation. By the way, the International Energy Administration or Agency, IEA, has drastically underestimated the demand of crude oil for years, and that number today is about 2.8 billion barrels. That's how much they've underestimated demand. They continue to do it. People continue to focus on their numbers, which is amazing.
They've just been as inaccurate, frankly, as the Fed has with their economic forecasts. But it's an important point in this way regarding equities is because equities are based upon earnings estimates, right? Forward earnings estimates. And the forward earnings estimates are a function of the futures curve. So those earnings estimates are incorporating $65 a barrel oil. And if it's going— if it's just going to maintain where it is now, those earnings estimates are going to come up drastically. Yeah. And I think that's exactly what's going to happen. And I think that's going to be your next up leg in this energy bull market that has been playing on. I mean, a year ago, Jim Cramer was telling the world energy is uninvestable and he had a lot of company. And yet, you know, what's been the, you know, by far the best performing sector this year, not counting cryptos, energy is up over 50% this year. Even the midstream pipelines are up over 50% this year.
Who'd have thought that at the beginning of the year? Well, we were, we were pounding the table on energy back last December. when I wrote that Totally Toxic newsletter. So it's, it's still very much of a contrarian play, and I think it's going to stay a contrarian play, frankly. And that's kind of the good news. And plus, as you know, the dividend yields on many of these companies are extremely high.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the stock market more broadly and just talk about where equities are headed, because, boy, you know, there's so many reasons. I mean, the last time we had a taper tantrum from the Fed, I mean, it was a big market crash and everybody was afraid the bond market was going to crash and the world was coming to an end. We've gotten to a point now where it seems pretty darn clear that the equity market can shrug off just about any news and keep marching higher. Is that just set to continue because of central bank largesse, or do we have a day of reckoning ahead of us? And as we address that, you sent me something this morning talking about a Paul Tudor Jones quote, talking about range expansions. What's a range expansion? How does that fit into the story?
David Hay: Well, that is his term. It's something that we've used with different terminology for years. I think it's the best way to make money and avoid losing money, anything I've ever stumbled on. I do think most people in the industry just intuitively get it that when something has a major breakout, uh, let's go back to the S&P.
One of the biggest mistakes I made in my career was when the S&P had its big breakout over the 2000 high back in either 2012 or 2013. It was around 1550 on the S&P, a clear breakout to an all-time high, and I missed it. I, you know, at that point I was worried that the Fed was, you know, which was already doing QEs, was artificially stimulating. And that there would be a day of reckoning much sooner than has turned out to be the case.
So, you know, bad mistake to have missed that warning.
If you want to look at one today that's giving you a tremendous buy signal, look at what's happening with the Japanese stock market, which recently made a 28-year new high. And so our— in our way of looking at the world, and I think Paul Tudor Jones would agree with this, the longer the range has been in place, or the trading range, you know, basically just if something's been oscillating between 20 and 40 for many years and it goes to 42, That's telling you that something has changed and it's likely to keep on running.
So that's really what it means. Paul Tudor Jones said something to the effect is that when a range expansion happens, whatever it is is going to keep trending in the direction of that range expansion, which is just another way for us to say if something's breaking out, it's likely to keep going. And oftentimes it's, it's, you know, really quite a big percentage move after the breakout occurs.
And what's really interesting and relevant to the images that I sent you earlier, which are to do with the economy, you know, things like inflation or the, you know, the job— the jobs market, that when you see these breakouts occur, let's say with inflation, that was a big warning sign earlier this year that the Fed was wrong about inflation being a flash in the pan.
So it's, it's amazing. It's almost like fractals, you know, in, in math and fractals in real life, that you see this pattern replay itself time and time again. So I mean, For your listeners, I think one of the key takeaways, and again, I've learned it the hard way over my 42-year career, is that breakouts and breakdowns are hugely important.
And you could see that in some of the Chinese stocks earlier this year when they broke below multi-year, below where they were even during COVID And that's a classic sell signal. So hopefully I covered that.
Erik Townsend: Okay, David, that covers a definition or an explanation of what these range expansions are, but help me connect that to the current stock market because it seems to me if I look at the S&P chart, I don't see I don't see a sudden breakout out of a trading range that has existed for a long time. What I see is a march straight up for like 10 years that I think is driven by central bank policy. And I thought it couldn't possibly last this long, and clearly I've been wrong. Where is the breakout here?
David Hay: I'm right there with you. I mean, I don't think any rational person would have believed 6 or 7 years ago that we would still be not only doing QE, but that we're actually doing MMT, Modern Monetary Theory. Which is, you know, that, that is one point that I'd like to make is I hear people say, well, they're doing QE. They're not doing QE. They are doing full-blown MMT. And that's what's different versus 10 years ago. As you're aware, uh, I think it was Dylan Grice you had on back a number of months ago. And he was saying, geez, you know, I really blew it back in the early 2010s because I saw this money being printed and I thought it would be inflationary. And it was asset inflationary, but it didn't create CPI inflation.
But this time is very different because you're not only is the Fed creating trillions of dollars of their magical money, but it's actually getting spent by the federal government. Federal government has spent $14 trillion since COVID started, which is about $1.2 billion every hour. It's a pretty sobering statistic. About $7 trillion of that $14 trillion has been deficit spending.
So and the Fed has bought a large degree of that. Now some of that has gone into mortgage-backed securities, but I don't think really matters. As long as the Fed is buying securities with fake money, it's, uh, you know, it's, it's really debt monetization. And that is, of course, the hallmark of MMT.
And the proof that we're doing MMT is that Stephanie Kelton, who is one of the founders of the whole MMT school of economics, if you can call it that, is very happy with what the Fed and the federal government's doing. And of course, we have another multi-trillion-dollar spending orgy coming up here with, you know, it's going to get downsized a little bit, but it's still going to be A shocking amount of money. The folks at Invesco say that the money supply, which has already increased by $5 trillion since COVID is going to increase another $3 trillion.
So it's a very inflationary set of circumstances that we have currently. And it, you know, I think if you look at the history of MMT, Erik, what you'll see is that you get this initial asset boom because there's just so much money sloshing around. France did it back in the early 1700s and they had a terrific Stock market boom, and then of course real inflation showed up. That's always the Achilles heel of MMT, which even people like Stephanie Kelton admit. And they say, "Well, when it happens, you know you can raise taxes." Okay, well, maybe they can raise taxes a little bit, but or the Fed can start tightening. And I think that's the real fallacy. I mean, the Fed's always telling us that they can tighten if necessary to control inflation. I think in this environment, their ability to tighten is almost nil. I mean, they have truly, you know, the old saying: they painted themselves into a very tight corner.
In the Fed's case, they've printed themselves into a very tight corner.
Erik Townsend: If you go back to so many smart people in, let's say, you know, early 2010s, 2010, '11, '12 in there, lots of smart people were saying, look, this thing has been driven by— this rally has been driven by central bank largesse, and there's no free lunch, and it's certain that a big crash is coming someday. I used to believe that very passionately, and boy, I've been wrong for a full decade. I've come around to a different view, which is, yeah, the part of that story that was right is this all comes to a very, very sad ending someday.
But I think it is more likely to be an inflationary Great Depression where the direction is up, not down, in nominal stock prices. Because what's happening is that inflating currency is causing people to flee to hard assets like real estate and precious metals. But of course, the biggest asset class that you could escape into would be the stock market. So I think it is So I think there's a very, very big day of reckoning that's coming, but I don't think it's a crash. I think it's a melt-up that sets off just an unbearable inflation. Does that make sense?
David Hay: Well, I would say yes. I actually think that you're onto something. If you look at the history of inflation and stocks is that stocks struggle, at least most stocks struggle when you go from low inflation to rising to moderate inflation. Interestingly, we haven't seen that yet, right? I mean, the stock market's up 23% this year, the S&P. Even though inflation is clearly going from low to more moderate or high moderate.
So that hasn't happened yet. Now, maybe it will, but it is interesting that if you use the 1970s as a template, the stock market did very poorly, but hard asset-based stocks did extremely well.
And I think that is the more likely outperformer over the next decade are those that are resource, basically that are scarce. They own scarce assets. And, you know, what is— and that's one of the things, if you've ever heard Tony Deden interviewed, brilliant man that Grant Williams, my great friend Grant Williams, has interviewed multiple times. And Tony Deden says invest in scarcity. Well, what's not scarce? Certainly not Treasuries, which are being created at an unbelievable clip, or the US dollar. That's not scarce. So I think you want to be invested in scarcity. And I think a lot of US stocks aren't scarce. I mean, with all the IPOs that are occurring and, you know, just the, uh, any going To quasi-stocks with things like SPACs that are being created overnight. And so it's— there's— I think it's a 2-tier market, basically, Erik. I think there's parts of the market that are absolutely nuts.
And ironically, those are the parts that don't do well with rising inflation, these highly speculative securities, because rising interest rates, which comes along with inflation, tends to be very hard on high-multiple securities. And it tends to be much friendlier on those value plays that that also have scarce assets underlying them.
So I think you're right though. I don't think we're going to see the typical grinding multi-year bear market. I think what we're looking at are kind of these flash crashes. I mean, obviously what happened back in March of 2020 was one of the greatest buying opportunities of all time, but it happened in about 3 weeks. And really, like 1 week toward the very end, toward like between March 15th and March 23rd, that was really the great buying window. You had to move fast.
And I think that's the way it's going to be the next time we have a market problem, because I'm convinced— and by the way, one of the reasons that we went bullish back in March of last year was because the Fed did what I'd been saying that they were going to do for several years, which most people thought I was crazy about, which was that they were going to target credit spreads. They would actually start buying corporate bonds to bring credit spreads down. And that's, that's what turned the market back on March 23rd of last year.
Well, this time I would go so far as to say, I believe in the next bear market, the Fed's going to buy stocks. They will print money to buy stocks, which is another way of saying, I think you're right. And I think because they can pull that off, that will again rally the market. Interestingly, they didn't have to buy that many bonds. They only bought about $18 billion worth of bonds. Just the fact that they told the bond market, we've got your back. I think kind of the same thing's going to happen with the stock market. Once people say, hey, the Fed's in there buying stocks, we'll buy stocks.
So, you know, you get a 15%, 20% pullback. I think that's about it for the time being.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
David Hay: Now, eventually, at some point, I mean, obviously, if inflation becomes too much of a problem, then every time the Fed says, we're going to print to do this, instead of being beneficial, it's counterproductive. And I think they're at that point in the bond market, but in the stock market, they could still have a huge impact.
Erik Townsend: David, you mentioned that quote from Paul Tudor Jones, who I'm sure most of our listeners know is an extremely famous futures trader, legendary name in the industry. I was really surprised by a quote that I saw, I think it was on ZeroHedge or someplace, Paul Tudor Jones supposedly said that in the next reckoning, that he thinks cryptocurrencies might do better than bonds as a safety asset.
Boy, I was really surprised by that. I'm going to go out on a limb here and suggest that perhaps I might personally understand tokenized secure digital bearer assets, including cryptocurrencies, a little better than Paul Tudor Jones does. But you know what? I'm a great big nobody in the world of finance, and he's a great big somebody. And when you get people like that saying cryptocurrency is the future, it's going to be awfully difficult for governments to outlaw it. So I'm really wondering what's going to happen with this crypto craze. I think it's a craze more than a good idea, but it's taking on proportions much larger than I ever thought possible. What do you think?
David Hay: Well, I'm right there with you. I mean, obviously Bitcoin's got a market cap equivalent to Tesla, a trillion dollars, for something that is just this kind of amorphous item. And I'm not at all denigrating the blockchain technology and that that's not going to be a big part of finance going forward. I think it will be. And I think Bitcoin's a survivor. I think Ethereum's a survivor.
So those things have— I do think there is— I mean, obviously there is this built-in scarcity. So getting back to what I said about Tony Deden, so Bitcoin's got that going for it.
The problem is I think the rest of the crypto universe or crypto space is very questionable, and certainly in terms of scarcity. I mean, Dogecoin, which got up to a market cap of $80, $90 billion here this year. I mean, it's just a joke. The founder admits it's a joke, and it's created an unlimited supply. A lot of these things have unlimited supply. Plus, you can obviously come out with— and I think there's something like a dozen different Dogecoins now.
So that's the problem there.
And the other problem is Tether, which is something like half of all Bitcoin purchases occur using Tether. And Bloomberg Businessweek just had a cover story on Tether, and basically pretty much recapped a newsletter that we put out back in the summer called Untethered that used a lot of the information that Grant Williams and George Noble and Bennett Tomlin came up on. They've done tremendous forensic investigations along with a lot of governmental authorities of just what a con job Tether is. I mean, if you haven't read that Bloomberg article, I'd recommend it, or email us and we'll send you our Untethered EVA that we did. So to me, that's the concern, is that at some point, if there's a blowup in the, in the stable, so-called stablecoin, which I think it's more like fablecoin world, then that could really spill over. And if Bitcoin's extremely extended in price as it is right now, that's— it has had these multiple crashes in its history.
But I think the remarkable thing about Bitcoin that tells you there's something there is the first asset class, if you call it that, which I think it is now, wasn't at the time. But back in 2017, what got me writing my book called Bubble 3.0 was an enormous bubble in Bitcoin in 2017. It was at that the biggest bubble of all time. Like all bubbles, it crashed and went down 80%. But what I've never seen happen before is that it's gone up and not only made a new high, it's basically tripled from what was like an outrageous point at, you know, $20,000 back in late 2017. So there's something to that that I greatly underestimated. And I think that's kind of what he's picking up on.
And I think the thing with bonds is he's right. I mean, bonds are not performing their counterbalancing function to an equity portfolio any longer. The 60/40 portfolio that was, uh, you know, the, the champion for basically 40 years, I think, is, is gone. I think that the 40% in bonds could actually be a risk enhancer rather than a risk mitigator, because if the problem is rising inflation on a secular basis, you're just going to lose money and lose money and lose money.
And I think that's what frankly has to happen. That's how the Fed or the federal government needs to deleverage is by keeping interest rates suppressed and running inflation hot. And they'll, you know, they'll try to understate it, which they're already doing. We can get into that if you want. But I think that right now, the Fed, for most of the last 40 years, I think the inflation numbers have been reasonably accurate. But I think in the last couple of years in particular, they really started to diverge from reality.
So that's the problem with bonds in a rising inflation period. And look at the 1970s. Bonds were— you were losing money on bonds at the same time that you were losing money on stocks.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
David Hay: Now, I personally believe we're going into a decade that is more similar to the 1970s. And one of my colleagues on the Gavekal side, Anatole Kaletsky, who is extremely highly regarded in Europe, and he's been mostly right about the macro environment over the last dozen years, he's saying this is going to be the 1950s and that these policies that we're following are actually going to be vindicated. They're the right thing. And we're going to have low inflation and high growth.
And I don't believe it, but we're running his, uh, his overview as our guest newsletter this week. We try to show both sides of the argument.
Erik Townsend: You know, I think what you said about Tether is really important. I mean, it is just so obvious to me that the Tether stablecoin— they've supposedly got a bank account in the Bahamas that seems very sketchy. The whole thing, to anybody who's looked at it in detail, it's just crazy. But you know what? If you look at the average Joe on the street, they're not listening to MacroVoices. They're not listening to you. You take somebody as famous, as infamous in the industry as Paul Tudor Jones, and there's a lot of other people that have been saying similar things.
I can see very easily how you could get a trend going where a lot of retail investors are saying, boy, I should get rid of the 40% of my life savings that I've put into bonds because all these guys are saying the bond market is crazy with what the government's doing.
David Hay: Right.
Erik Townsend: I should put it in something safe, like Tether. That's what I should do. And I mean, frankly, I shouldn't probably say this on the air, but I think that Mr. Tudor Jones should restrict his public comments to topics he understands, because although he is a far more accomplished futures trader than I'll ever be, I don't think he knows what the eff he's talking about.
David Hay: Well, he may be looking at charts, and I think that's the only way to really trade, effectively trade Bitcoin, is to use chart technical analysis and maybe a extreme sentiment readings. So when, you know, people are in complete panic mode on Bitcoin, that's when you step in and buy it. But I, I personally think— and, you know, I, I'm no crypto expert, I've got a great friend who is— and my big fear, as I've conveyed to him, is I think you're going to have a blowup of these other cryptos, you know, the 99% that are absolutely, you know, I'd call them, you know, to be a little profane, I'd call them shitcoins. I'm not the first one to refer to them that way. And there's an enormous amount of leverage involved. And then you got all these, you as they call them, stablecoins, the Tethers. To me, it's like the classic speculative asset class in very late-stage bubble.
So I think there's going to be an enormous shakeout in that space. And when there is, I think that's when you step up and buy Bitcoin and Ethereum, because I do think there is obviously persistent demand for these guys. There is a need. And I think it's a direct function of these extremely dangerous central bank policies in the Western world.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think that it goes beyond the money printing. If you look at what's going on, Bitcoin really is a challenge to government-issued money. It is an effort to create private label money to replace government money. And that dramatically undermines the government's authority in many ways. And what governments are doing is laughing at it, saying, these silly little children think that their silly little currency is going to replace the US dollar. Well, if they continue to ignore it, it really will.
I mean, it is a better kind of money. They should have learned from it a long time ago, outlawed it, and figured out how to incorporate it in government-issued money. But they're not going to do that, and they're not apparently going to wise up to what's really going on here. If it continues much longer, it will reach a point of no return where even though it didn't make sense, it will be impossible to stop it.
David Hay: Well, I do think central banks in the West are— and in China as well— are going to try to come up with some kind of digital coin of their own. How successful that will be, I don't know. I mean, obviously it doesn't appeal to the people that feel like they're, they're outside of the, the fiat or governmental-controlled ecosystem. So I think that's going to be a big hurdle that they have to deal with to try to popularize them. And they can come out with them, but can they actually make them popular is a whole other story.
So, um, I don't know, but I do think that it's here to stay. But I also think you're just going to have enormous volatility. You already have had. I mean, I'm not— I'm just— I guess to be like George Soros, I'm not predicting. I'm just observing. You know, there's— it's just going to be because there's really— there's just such a psychological element to these things. You're not getting earnings. You're not getting dividends. So the price is whatever the speculative crowd puts on it at a given time.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to cryptocurrency's competitor, which is gold, the historical scarcity asset that you use as an inflation hedge. Boy, the inflation that was predicted by the gold bugs happened, but the big run-up in gold prices predicted by the gold bugs hasn't really happened yet. We're just— as we're speaking on Tuesday, I'm looking at what might be another false breakout above the 100 and 200-day moving average, which are both co-located in the $1,790s.
Uh, we had a couple of daily closes above, but it looks like as we're trading right now, we're back down below those
David Hay: Well, I think gold is going higher, probably a lot higher, but it's, it's not going to be, you know, like a straight shot. It's going to be the typical, you know, up sharply, you know, hard correction when their sentiment gets too bullish. And, you know, just this back and forth, but, you know, jaggedly higher. But obviously last year they had an enormous move, gold and silver, particularly the miners. And I do think that is the better way to play. I mean, I'm not saying you shouldn't have some physical gold, but I think the miners are the better play. Yeah. Actual physical gold and silver. But the miners, just like with energy, it gives you a lot more bang for your buck, plus you get dividends. And these mining stocks are very cheap and they're generating a lot of free cash flow. They're also buying their own shares. So, you know, there was such a near-death experience with the mining stocks and with the energy stocks that these management teams, the guys that were the permabulls, have all been kicked out.
The ones that are in there now are very careful stewards of shareholder capital, which is a good thing. So I think that's the way to play it. And they, they did have spectacular moves last year. We did a lot of profit taking during that. But at this point, I think the gold miners are back in accumulation mode.
And I just think there's so much upward pressure that if you look at foreign central banks, not the US, but foreign central banks, almost every single one of them is an aggressive accumulator of gold. And they're not aggressive accumulators of treasuries. Basically, foreign central banks have quit buying treasuries. So they're buying gold. They're not buying treasuries. And I think they're on the right track.
Erik Townsend: David, I want to move on to something that we've talked to your friend Louis Gave about in the past, which is Gavekal, which is an institutional research firm, tends to break the economy down into quadrants. I know that you guys use that at Evergreen Gavekal as well. First of all, explain what are these quadrants? What do they mean? What does it have to do with anything? And how does that fit into your investment process?
David Hay: Well, their belief is that any one time the global economy is in Either one of the 4 different categories. One is a deflationary or disinflationary boom, a deflationary disinflationary bust, an inflationary boom, or an inflationary bust. And obviously right now, it's the question is, which is it from the inflationary standpoint? Are we in an inflationary boom or an inflationary bust? Interestingly, Erik, if you look at Google searches for stagflation, which would be the inflationary bust, those searches have gone ballistic in recent months, whereas inflation searches have gone way down.
So it would tell you that— and you're starting to see this, including with energy, where you're getting some experts to say that because energy prices have gone up so much, we're going to have a recession next year. So again, that would be an inflationary bust kind of scenario similar to what happened in the 1970s. That, I think, is the big question of the next 12 to 24 months. Which of those 2 quadrants is the global economy in? And at this point, I put myself in the inflationary boom category. But But this isn't as high a conviction as some of my other calls.
And the reason I believe that, I think this is a lot like after World War II, where the economy was basically shut down. At least the private sector economy was all focused on the war effort, and US consumers built up a tremendous amount of savings coming out of World War II. A lot of people thought, oh, we're going to have, just like some people are saying today, a nasty recession. And, you know, for the reasons of all those soldiers coming back with no jobs and because the government was going going to be buying aircraft and aircraft carriers and so forth. And instead, we had a fantastic post-war boom, but with quite a bit of inflation. Inflation was running in double digits for a while in the late 1940s. And what that allowed to do, kind of back to one of our major themes of this call, this podcast, is it allowed the government to drastically deleverage from 1945 to 1952.
By 1954, we had the debt-to-GDP down to about 70%. It had been about 120% at the end of World War II. And that's, I think, what we're going to see happen again, both the fairly rapid economic growth because we have $2.3 trillion of excess savings that consumers are sitting on that they accumulated because of all the excess of government stimulus and inability to spend. You look at what's going on with the auto industry right now. I mean, it's in a nasty recession.
And at some point, we're going to get cars again and people are going to buy cars again. So I do think that we're going to have a year or two of very good economic growth, but with a lot of inflation. And interestingly too, Erik, that if you look at—
Erik Townsend: Well, wait a minute, back up a second, David. Maybe I misheard, but did you just say you're expecting government deleveraging? You're saying that we're going to get responsible and pay down our debts?
David Hay: Well, I wouldn't say responsible. This is a stealth form of default, is high inflation, right? But it's already happening. It's already working.
Erik Townsend: Okay, so you're saying deleveraging not by paying any debt down, but by inflating to the point that that debt Yeah, God forbid we would pay any debt down in real money. Well, it sounded like you were saying that for a minute there.
David Hay: No, but if you look at what's happened to the debt-to-GDP over the last year, it's gone from 135% to 125%. So it's already happening. Now, there's no free lunch. Who loses in this? Well, it's just like who lost in the tremendous deleveraging the US actually lasted from 1945 to 1980.
Where we, we brought the debt to GDP down from about 120% down around 25% at the end of the 1970s. Those stagflationary '70s actually did the trick in turn. That's what allowed Volcker to be able to really crank up interest rates to 20%. So, you know, I know Luke Gromen believes that once we get debt down to more like 60%, 70%, then finally the Fed can allow interest rates to go to something that's, you know, actually, you know, truly a a real yield. But, you know, right now, I mean, the Fed would have to raise rates 400, 500, 600 basis points to get anything close to a real yield, and that ain't gonna happen.
Erik Townsend: David, we've been talking about inflation, but I think it's really important to break that out. Are we talking about just prices? Is this ever going to be wage inflation where people actually get paid more that they can pay these new prices? And what's going to be the, the, the interplay between those? Because There's different kinds of inflation, whether it's wage-driven or cost-driven and so forth. How is this going to play out?
David Hay: Well, I think it's interesting to look at how it's playing out already and looking at what's occurring and just following the trend. Obviously, there's a lot of wage inflation. What's interesting is the wage inflation is apparent everywhere except in the official data. By that, I mean, if you look at the Atlanta Fed's wage tracker, it's looking at 3% to 4%, but you look at the real world. And it's just unbelievable. I mean, just one anecdote is there are nurses in the Seattle area that are getting paid $200,000 to $250,000 a year.
And that's what happens when you have extreme shortages of essential workers. You start to get some unbelievable pay increases. I mean, you're seeing it all over the place in terms of union militancy, which is back. It's back both in the United States and in Europe. Strikes are happening and wage settlements are pretty amazingly high. I mean, you look at what Amazon is doing and all the inducements that they're offering to hire another 125,000 workers. I heard John Mackey, the founder of Whole Foods, still the CEO of Whole Foods, and he said they have 125,000 employees and they need 15,000 more employees. They got 15,000 job openings. Everywhere you go, it's help wanted. And I think that's, that's one of the real fallacies of the inflation is transitory, transitory narrative is that wages are very sticky and there's a lot of upward pressure on wages, which I think has not fully played out.
The other thing that hasn't fully played out is, is rents. Now rents have been indicating very low inflation until lately, and the Fed's owner equivalent rent is really kind of a bogus thing. But regardless, rents are now starting to really kick in. So I think the Fed is going to have a problem, what I call the REW problem, of rents, energy, and wages as we go into 2022. And I think they're going to rue all the times they told us that was temporary inflation.
So I think that's a big, big deal and a big, big change.
Erik Townsend: Well, David, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, I want to talk a little bit about what you do at Evergreen Gavekal. You know, when we used to have Louis Gave on, the feedback we always got, the institutional audience loved him. But the complaint we got from our retail audience was, hey, I want to subscribe and it's only priced for institutions. I can't get it. Now, it sounds like the way Gavekal has solved that problem is to merge or acquire, I'm not sure what the relationship is, or partner with your firm to essentially be their retail end. Does that give people access to Gavekal's institutional research or some watered-down version of it? Or what's the product on offer there?
David Hay: Well, that's great, great questions, a series of questions there. And we are partnered. We're not owned by, certainly not fully owned. We have a minority ownership with Louis himself. And we do offer some of the Gavekal research. So it's a limited or as you would say, watered-down version.
But we also do a weekly newsletter. So once a month, month, sometimes twice a month, we actually publish some Gavekal research. The rest of it is either something that I've written or we use guest sources, you know, like a Luke Gromen or Grant Williams, you know, some of the really some of the brightest minds out there we will run as a guest issue. And people can't complain about the price because it's free. So if somebody really wants to get at least partial access to Gavekal, see what I'm thinking, what our firm is thinking, you can subscribe to our Evergreen Virtual Advisor, EVA. Is what it is for short. And I've also been publishing some of the chapters of Bubble 3.0, my new book, in that because I really do believe, like I think you do, that this is the 3rd bubble of the last 25 years.
So that's a really good way to connect with us. And we obviously manage money for individuals. That's really our main thing. We're one of the few people that still does research. We are definitely not part of the passive investing herd these days. I think it's a great opportunity to actually think and do things differently.
So that's a little quick overview of Evergreen.
Erik Townsend: Well, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value. Cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales.
It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euro, And British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. Escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have David on the show. He really is a great macro thinker.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I agree, and I think the greenflation theme is a very important one. I'm glad he coined that term. Let's go to our postgame chart deck now. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, what is your thinking on these equity markets?
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's start on page 2. Here we have the S&P 500. I just really want to highlight that the, the trend really has now broken out to the upside, and it wasn't just a short-term breakout for one day and then pops back down below, but this is a legitimate breakout. We talked about in our Chart Decks throughout late September and early October asking whether this was just going to be a shallow market correction and really has proven to be the case now. Really what will be interesting is to see whether or not all little corrections and consolidations can hold decisively at or above 4,500. What we're going to see under those circumstances is that the bulls will prove that they're decisively in control of this and that really would open the window for easily another 3 to 5% upside potential in these markets. It'll be really interesting to see whether we have a year-end rally off of that.
I mean, in order for these charts to start even beginning to look bearish, it would take a decisive breakdown day that starts wiping out 100 or 200 S&P points to the downside just to do the technical damage to start making these markets look a little bit bearish. And that's therefore really— we have to give the kudos to the bulls here and let us see where they're willing to take this.
When we go to page 3, I just once again wanted to highlight the volatility index. We still have not broken to lower lows on volatility. And this is interesting because throughout this entire bull advance since the COVID crash, volatility's lows have generally been held to about the 15 handle. And in the prior to the COVID period, the VIX was as low as 10 to 12. This— we are at sustained higher volatility premium. And it's interesting that we're seeing that. The question really is, is there a new breakdown in volatility coming where we can go back down to those lows? And that's something that's on my mind. So far, the lows from July continue to hold the bottom end of that range.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, the next few charts, you're looking at the euro and a few commodities. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I wanna start off with that euro. The ECB just came out with their press conference and a very strong reaction to the euro. This is what caused that dollar index or drove that dollar index down 50 cents on when we look at the DXY at this stage. This is a really important moment. This entire euro consolidation, euro has been in a very clear decline from June all the way through October, and we really are seeing just the beginning of these bouncing markets. What will be interesting to see is whether or not the euro legitimately is putting in a bottom and changing trend, or whether this is just a false start and euro weakness prevails. The dollar has been divergent from a lot of the different natural intermarket correlations that we're seeing in commodities and other assets. And so if the euro turns here, it would actually start to bring the entire intermarkets in line.
And this is probably one of the more important charts to watch here in the coming week to see whether that becomes the unfolding reality.
Touching on to the crude oil chart that you were talking about earlier, there's that 2-3 day market correction that we've just been in. And it's interesting because, you know, typically a solid $5 pullback has more or less been a pretty good short-term pullback for crude. It's a big question as to whether this is going to be a bigger or deeper correction or whether this is it. If this is a shallow flagging formation like we saw in the middle of October, then the bulls should get this back above $84 in a matter of just 2, 3 trading sessions. I think that's what's on my mind, to see whether or not the bulls can actually fuel a new launch towards $90 if, if they can turn it here.
The other chart that I wanted to just highlight in the commodity space was copper. And copper had been consolidating from May all the way through October in that a downwards correction after what was a pretty distinctly pronounced bull market run through most of 2020 into the early part of 2021. After this consolidation, we had a really legitimate breakout on the upside of copper, retesting the May highs. With this pullback here, this is a, a really important moment to find out whether the bulls are willing to buy dips. And it'll be really interesting to see whether copper actually turns here in price and whether this becomes a buy point. If it does, that certainly would continue to support the idea that there might be more upside on copper.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, starting at page 7, you have the 2-year yields from a number of countries. What's on your mind? How come different countries?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, Erik, what interesting price action we're seeing in the bond markets. You know, we were touching on that 10-year Treasury yield earlier, even the 30-year Treasury yield that we see actually yields backing off and things pretty quiet. But the higher inflation and the central bank tightening has really created a very strong move on the short end of the curve, particularly in the 2-year yields. And the interesting part is that this isn't a US-specific story. What we continue to see is that the 2-year yields around the world are all skyrocketing higher. So while we see here that the 2-year yield has increased, uh, from— in the US has increased from about, you know, 20, 25 basis points to over 50 basis points in a span of just a month. But when we go and look at, uh, page 8 and look at the Canadian yield, after a very hawkish, uh, Bank of Canada statement, yields have rocketed from 40 basis points to over close to 110 basis points on the upside.
When you go to Australian 2-year government bond yields, just a rocket of a 2-day move where we saw the yields go from 15 basis points to 45 basis points. You saw even in the German yields, even though they're still very negative, we're breaking now out of a 1-year range. And so we're seeing these short-term yields right across the board rising. And but it's not the whole yield curve is is rising, and that's the most interesting part. And I think to best illustrate this is to look at what's happening in the 5s-30s yield curve on US Treasury, and you can continue to see the flattening is underway. And this is, uh, something that, uh, I think has at least surprised me a little bit. I didn't— while I didn't necessarily think we had to have a huge steepener in play, but if, you know, if you would imagine that if secular inflation was real, that the long-term government bonds would start to actually price long-term inflation expectations higher.
And that should at least have kept this relatively flat. And what we continue to see is that that belly of the curve continues to move so aggressively. And yet those long bonds are not responding. And that's continuing to create this flattener. Now, while the Fed and central banks around the world are more or less pinning the front of the curve, we are starting to see a lot of pressure to raise interest rates on it. This is a really interesting moment, and the way it's materializing in the bond markets is something to continue to watch. It's something that I don't hear too many people talking about, and it really just is such a big move, at least on the shorter-dated notes.
Erik Townsend: And listeners, you can get Patrick's chart decks not just once a week, but every single day with a free trial of Big Picture Trading. The information is on page 13 of the slide deck, or you can just go to bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook that we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an interview with stock market wizard Mike Masters and an article discussing Marko Kolanovic, Did the World Change Yesterday? So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make this program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, Send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend, that's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, Thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com. The internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet. each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically downloaded to your iPhone or iPad. And if you're listening on iTunes, please rate the show and leave a review. Delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.