Lakshman Achuthan — Economic Cycles Research Institute co-founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 284 was recorded on August 12th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Economic Cycle Research Institute co-founder Lakshman Achuthan returns as this week's feature interview guest. Lak says all those economic cycle indicators that were turning up last we spoke with him are starting to turn down now, meaning the risk of an economic cycle downturn is heightened. But does that still translate into a bearish outlook for the stock market in this new normal post-GFC monetary policy regime? Maybe not. We'll find out in this week's interview. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Grant Williams joins us for a special cameo appearance. In keeping with tradition, we'll be skipping our usual market wrap and postgame segments for the next 2 weeks when we'll be airing our 2021 summer special on the decentralized finance revolution featuring Dr. Pippa Malmgren and Clint Cox. That special series will air on August 19th and 26th, and then we'll be back to our usual format on September 2nd.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, S&P 500, 52-week highs, more of the same. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, hey, we got a worsening pandemic with a new variant. That's, uh, you know, seems like just par for the course. The melt-up continues. I continue to think this is all about monetary policy. I do think, as Jeremy Grantham is warning, that it all ends badly someday. But boy, how many years Have so many people, including myself, been making those warnings that these valuations are just crazy stretched, only that for them to double again from there. How many times has the S&P doubled since the 666 print back in 2009? And how many times will it double again before this, this finally makes some sense? I don't know, but seems like the trend is up.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's talk about the dollar index because we continue to hold up around the 93 handle. I mean, it's still holding up along the top end. Do you think that there's at least At least over the short term, some further upside on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, we're holding, as you say, at the high end of the range, but we're still in a consolidation range. There is no higher high until we get a closing print over 93.50. And even then, you know, how much higher does it need to be to really confirm that you've moved out of a consolidation into a new uptrend? So I don't think there's any story to tell here about the dollar index other than it's still consolidating between 89 and so far about 93.50.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's turn to crude oil. I wouldn't mind knowing what the inventory numbers came in at, but it's interesting because crude oil really looked like even a week or two ago that it was ready to make another bull run. And just over the last two weeks, we've seen a distribution cycle right back to the July lows near $65. We're now approaching $70 again, $69 at the time of recording. How's this playing out in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think it's all about the Delta variant and particularly the pattern that we've seen where each weekend we get new negative news about the Delta variant and the number of infections and so forth. And it's really eating into Chinese demand. And that's where the price has been dragged down. And we get some of that news, and then it starts to look like it's all getting better. And then we get dragged down again with the next bit of news. I think that once we get to the point where the Delta variant bad news peaks— and are we there yet? Maybe— then I think the bottom will be in for crude oil, and that will continue a grind up higher from there. The whole story in crude oil for the last 6 months has been everybody's fear that this month, August, would be when we would be seeing like 20 million barrels per week of average drawdowns on crude oil inventories in August.
And that's going to just cause the market to go crazy. Well, guess what? We're seeing inventory this week of crude oil drawing down less than half a million barrels, 447,000 barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 325,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 1.4 million barrels. But that's offset by distillates building 1.8 million barrels. So on the whole, it's basically, you know, kind of flat. US production, meanwhile, is ticking up to 11.3. That's 100,000 barrels more than, than it was last week.
Overall, what I see is basically the bull market, I think, has been put on hold while we wait out this Delta variant and see how much demand destruction it's ultimately going to cause. I'm convinced, though, that it's just a matter of the bull market being put on hold. I think oil prices are going to resume their upward trend when that happens. When that happens, I'm not sure. It's gonna be when we start actually seeing some of the drawdowns line up with predictions. And for as long as Delta is driving the demand down in China, it's going to delay things. But I think that the higher numbers are still coming, probably before this year is out.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, well, we gotta talk about gold because for over a month, gold has been in a tight trade range of like $50. And it seemed like it was like watching paint dry. And suddenly come Sunday in the European session, The gold market came to life, and, well, to the downside though. What's your take on how this played out?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the Sunday move clearly has everybody talking about, you know, is this a conspiracy theory or what's driving it? Jeff Snider's done some interesting work giving alternate answers that it's not necessarily somebody intentionally trying to crash the market. But boy, showing up on Sunday night in thin liquidity and selling, what was it, $4 billion notional or something of gold futures, it sure feels like somebody is selling sloppy on purpose. purpose trying to crash the market. And we were right at a very vulnerable spot in market history when this happened. We were just teetering with that 1,800 support level. And remember me saying, boy, watch out if we get a daily close below 1,800, the move could accelerate. Well, the ingredients were there for it to accelerate. Somebody knew that and they decided to fan the flames, is the way this looks to me. That got us all the way down to 1,680 again. Congratulations to anybody who was swift enough to buy it when they had the chance below 1,680.
I still think that ultimately Hopefully this will resolve to the upside, but boy, this is, you know, definitely threw the technicals off. It's gonna take a lot of traders that trade primarily on technicals to— it's gonna force them to change their strategy and not be as optimistic. Might delay the recovery. So somebody did some real damage here. Was it done intentionally? It looks that way to me, but who's to say?
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on the 10-year Treasury yield because for several months we've had yields, you know, backing off from 1.75 all the way down to 1.15. After retesting last week, Right before the jobs number, the 115 level. Suddenly yields are ripping higher as bonds are consolidating. We're back to 136 on the yield at the time of recording. Do you think that that was a meaningful turn in yields?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's interesting. A lot of people thought 1.34 was gonna be either a support or a resistance level. Seems we've traded through it a couple of times now without it really showing either one. And of course, 1.34, I think that was the low yield intraday in 2016, the first time Jeff Gundlach declared that the bond bull market was over. So that number doesn't seem to be really that critical. The number that seems very critical to me is about 1.75, where everybody freaked out last time. If we get back up there, I expect them to freak out again, and everybody will be saying that the bond market is crashing and the sky is falling. I don't think so. I think this is just noise, but we'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is Economic Cycle Research Institute co-founder, Lakshman Achuthan. Erik, why did we invite Lak back onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Lak is a super guy, and ECRI, the company that he co-founded, just produces some fantastic data that, for anybody who's not familiar with the ECRI cycles indicators, I certainly recommend learning about them. And that's what we'll cover in this week's interview. We've had him on before. When we talked to Lak last time, he was telling us that a whole bunch of ECRI's cycle indicators were turning up, telling us that things are about to take off. And sure enough, they did. Now he's going to tell us in this interview that the cycle indicators are starting to turn down. So stay tuned. I don't want to steal Lak's thunder, but that's where we're headed.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Lakshman Achuthan is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX In the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon Investors seeking exposure to the FinTech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or
Erik Townsend: www.abaxx.exchange, or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Lakshman Achuthan, founder of the Economic Cycle Research Institute. Lak has prepared a slide deck to accompany today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, click the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads. Lak, it's great to have you back on the program. Last time we talked, you were, I think, earlier than most people, calling out the inflation turning up the way that clearly it has. Were we still looking at— and I think it was not just inflation, but you were looking at business cycles turning up and a number of things. Let's do a quick review of what we discussed last time we had you on the program and what's changed since then.
Lakshman Achuthan: Sure, sure. Hey, and good to be back with you, Erik. Thank you. I think we spoke in the last fall of 2020, and we were kind of updating several cycle upturn calls. And we look at many different cycles at ECRI. And so we had the business cycle upturn in the United States. We had the global industrial cycle upturn that we had also made from the spring of 2020, which was, I think has been a very key call. And then the related inflation cycle, it's a separate cycle upturn call. that we made late last summer. And on each one of those cycles, there's been really interesting developments. Mostly, I have to say, to the downside, decelerations that we've been working through with people we speak with and our clients in recent months.
And so last time we were on, we weren't equivocating. There was lots of drama in the headlines. It seems like that's the norm these days, but During the whole, all the upturn last year, we did not equivocate on those upturn calls at all. Stocks went certainly along for the ride. Commodity prices went along for the ride. Inflation stuff went along for the ride, even though, you know, there was lots of stuff going on, pretty serious stuff with the pandemic and also alongside the political strife.
And all those calls, they held straight through the winter, but They started to show up, like different cycles started to peak out. And you mentioned, thank you for mentioning the slide deck at the beginning of the call.
We have this many cycles framework, what we call the ECRI framework. It's not a model, right? So nothing I'm talking about today is about models. It's about an array of leading indexes, coincident leading indexes of different distinct but related cycles that we're tracking. And there's dozens of them. There may be dozens of them for one economy, and we're doing them for 22 economies. And so it's from that vantage point that I'm giving comments today.
And our basic process that, that's important to understand, and it kind of sets up this discussion, is that once we've made a cycle turn call, like last year is the— all the upturn calls, Almost immediately, our job is to be on the lookout for the next downturn. What's the risk of that cycle turn, that cycle turning again?
And as I've intimated now, global industrial growth, we've made a downturn call in global industrial growth. And I think we should get into the nitty-gritty on that separately. So full period on that and then a full stop and then a separate cycle. is growth in the US economy.
And so here it's quite separate from the global industrial downturn call. We have a US growth rate cycle downturn call. And there are some, you know, on the inflation cycle call where, you know, we did have that strong upturn call, our forward-looking future inflation gauge, the highest reading in that looks to be back in April, and it's, uh, kind of gone sideways a little bit. So we don't have the, the emphatic run-up that we had earlier, and we can get into what's going on there too.
Erik Townsend: This is fascinating to me. It resonates very much because I had Darius Dale on a few weeks ago who said, look, secular inflation is here to stay, but nothing goes in a straight line, and it's already gone too far too fast. And he thinks that we're about to see that That countertrend, wrong-footing move that throws everybody off. Everybody finally ready to, you know, dive in on the inflation trend, only to find that we're going to have a whiff of disinflation for 6 to 12 months before the secular inflation resumes. It sounds like what you're saying is very consistent with that. Would you come to those conclusions, or is that reading too much into it?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, no, I wouldn't. I mean, I wouldn't argue on the face of it with that view, but I think we probably build it in a different way. And that, that can be very interesting when, when the, you know, various listeners have a framework and an approach or some, some scenario that they're kind of thinking about.
What the cycle indicators can do is help time when some of those things might come to the fore. And so And we've talked before, Erik, I don't want to date us, but it's probably years ago about a long-term decline in trend growth in various major market economies that have developed and even the emerging markets. And along with that brings with it some longer-term or maybe secular disinflationary pressures.
And then you have the policy such as it is, right? It's mostly been monetary policy, but there's now the— there's some more deficit spending too, which is trying to push against that. And without debating all that, right, that's the tug of war that's going on here. And within that, as far as we can tell, and, you know, I'm the 3rd generation of this type of work, so it's almost reaching back 100 years at this point.
As far as we can tell, free market-oriented economies, right? I'm not going to be too dogmatic about it. There's plenty of machinations pushing around the free market, but as long as it's dominated by the free market, so even China or the US or other economies that have a lot of intervention going on, if you're dominated by free market activity, you're You're going to end up being cyclical. You'll have the ebb and flow. And so you can have a secular rise in inflation, you can have a secular decline in inflation. That could— you could have either one of those views, and there's still going to be cycles overlaid on that.
And there's this desire often, or not— I don't know if it's a desire or reflex or whatever, but there's a conflating that happens between the cyclical move And the secular view. And I think most listeners who've kind of had some experience in these debates and discussions will be comfortable with the idea that it's really hard to see a secular change when it's happening. You could see it in the rearview mirror, but super hard to see it like, hey, now we've switched and we've made a secular shift the other way. That's a tough one.
And it can often get confused with just a cyclical event, which may last for several quarters one way or the other.
And so I'm not entirely sure about the secular. I don't want to bang the table on it. I have some suspicions, but I am pretty sure about the cyclical. And I can say with pretty high conviction, we've got a global industrial growth downturn. I can say with almost as high conviction that we have a US growth rate cycle downturn.
The current inflation cycle upturn, I think everybody acknowledges the inflation cycle upturn. They may attribute it to different stories. From our vantage point, the cyclical component is pretty big. The forward-looking indicators on the inflation cycle for the time being seem to have topped out.
Erik Townsend: You alluded earlier to diving into the nitty-gritty of the cyclical indications. Let's go ahead and do that and talk about what's going on here.
Lakshman Achuthan: Sure. I think first and foremost, let's stick with the— again, I'm dating myself. I'm in my midlife crisis. I'm in my 50s now. So I'm saying, what are the really special things in life? It's really special to have conviction about something. The more you know, the more you know you don't know. And so when you When you go through your processes, and in this case, I'm sharing the cyclical process, and when you have conviction, it's kind of, you know, that's special.
We have conviction on the global industrial growth downturn. And I mentioned that again, I'll refer back to the slide deck. If you go to page 4 of the slide deck this time, there's a chart of indicators of global industrial growth. And on that slide, You could see why we have— I'll explain why I have some conviction.
So the target is at the bottom of the slide, and that's global industrial production growth for some 22 economies around the world, and it's slowing. Okay, so that's the target. And then there's the Global Industrial Growth Short Leading Index in the middle and the Global Industrial Growth Long Leading Index at the top.
And you can see that the Global Industrial Growth Long Leading Index has a very long lead, actually topped out quite a while ago. And it was at the end of 2020 that we first indicated to our clients that, hey, there's some storm clouds way out there on the horizon.
But we knew that the ongoing global industrial growth upswing was going to persist. I mean, there were a whole bunch of cyclical dynamics at play and we knew it was going to persist for a few more months. And we said so, we said, hey, you could still make hay, but start keeping an eye on the exit door.
Then in March of this year, several months ago, based on the Global Industrial Growth Short Leading Index or the GIGSLI, that's the middle line in the chart, we knew we were closing in. On the peak in global industrial growth. And so, these storm clouds were getting a lot closer to shore, so to speak.
And then by May of this year, it was pretty clear to us, and we said so, that global industrial growth, the slowdown was already at hand and it was beginning.
And the actionable kind of information here is that there's a a high rise in the risk of downturns in commodity price inflation and the global PMIs. And I know, I'm sure you've heard this a lot, a lot of people talk about the PMIs as a way to get a read on what's happening with economic growth.
So the PMIs are a survey and they have maybe in theory a short lead over the target The target is the hard data, actual industrial production growth. And as it turns out, the PMIs don't have that much predictive value. They're super important because everybody watches them. And so for that reason, you cannot ignore them because there'll be reactions to what the PMI does.
But what you could see from this chart is that— Now, if you go to slide Slide 3 now, if you back up a minute, you could see the global PMI against the same target, global industrial production growth. So the target is always that hard data, like what's happening in reality.
And that slide 3 shows that the global PMI actually turns around the same time as actual industrial growth. And this year at the peak in global industrial growth, which has already happened, The PMI, which has started to turn down, right? It's gone down a couple of months, global PMI. It actually is lagging the cycle.
So the way that our work is used is to time that moment of risk in the market when things that people pay attention to, say in this case, the PMIs, are going to maybe surprise and go the other way.
And that sequence that I showed on chart 4 of the long leading and then the short leading and then the actual, the target turning down, depending on your own risk profile, whoever, you know, whatever the institution is or the portfolio that's being managed or whatever it is, you know, you could be more or less aggressive in how you approach these cycle turns. But when we see a long leader turn and then a short leader turn and then very short leaders like the PMIs or commodity price inflation turn and actual the target in this case in industrial production growth turn, you have a lot of conviction that it's not noise, especially what's going on, say, with commodity price inflation coming down.
Or industrial production growth easing.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about how to extend that and apply it to markets, because I can see several points on this GPMI graph where there was a clear sign of topping and a turndown. But boy, it wasn't the time to short the S&P, was it?
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah, S&P is, is slightly different. Okay, so on this slide— and, and it's a great, it's a great question. And boy, S&P has kind of evolved in how it fits in a portfolio over the decades. But right here, I'm gonna kind of oversimplify with broad brushstrokes and say that this global industrial growth, the cleanest link there is with broad industrial commodity price inflation.
Okay, that's a nice clean link. to market prices between this cycle and that aspect of the market. Now, clearly, commodity price inflation then, or commodity price even levels, if the growth downturn is strong enough, you're going to see a move in the level. If those things start to move, they're going to impact other assets in the portfolio construction.
And so when you switch over to something like broad equities, right? Again, and let me put my own warning label here. ECRI doesn't make market calls. We make growth and inflation cycle calls. And then that's our bread and butter. And what I'm sharing after that is, hey, where there seem to be some linkages between the markets and those calls, calls in growth and inflation cycles. So we have conviction about calls in growth and inflation cycles.
And when we look at the relationship between, say, equities and cycles, the link seems clearest between cycles and overall growth, economic growth. So far, I've been talking about global industrial sector growth. So say the manufacturing sectors of all the major economies around the world. That's the cycle I'm talking about.
We're going to put a period there and move forward to cycles in US, in this case, US economic growth. And cycles in US economic growth have a relationship with, say, the S&P. And up until the global financial crisis, which kind of marks The shift towards extraordinary kind of— well, I don't know what you want to call it, whatever, some QE or whatever you want to call it, right? Up until then, growth rate cycle downturns, decelerations in US economic growth were associated with cyclical downturns in share prices. And when I say cyclical, I'm being very specific. I mean pronounced, pervasive and persistent declines in share prices. So cyclical declines, persistent could be a couple of quarters or more.
Post-GFC, the persistent part of the decline in share prices associated with growth rate cycle downturns was largely removed. Okay, so you'll have a Pronounced decline in share prices. You'll have a pervasive decline in share prices, hard to hide in, in say S&P, but it won't persist. It won't go on for a couple of quarters, which it used to do pre-GFC. Post-GFC, what you have are major market corrections are associated with growth rate cycle downturns.
So now we come to today, and I could We could talk about the history of that in the last 10 years if you'd like.
But the operative thing for today is that we have a growth rate cycle downturn call and the market is somewhere near the highs. So what does that mean? In our assessment, in our kind of observation of how share prices, S&P reacts to growth rate cycle downturns, That's where we see the larger now corrections in share prices. And so they could be double-digit percentage points, over 10% declines. And we haven't seen one of those since the COVID recession took hold.
So we would say another way of saying that is that the risk of a correction in the market has gone way up recently. Because of the growth rate cycle downturn, the cyclical growth rate deceleration that is unfolding now. And if you actually go to slide 6 and it's titled US Coincident Index, I think you can kind of visualize what I'm talking about.
Lakshman Achuthan: And it's interesting because it brings us to the current debate like, hey, Things are slowing, but so what? It's still pretty good. And that may be true, but the relationships are still as I just outlined them. So on this slide 6, you have US coincident index growth rate.
This is not a forecast. This is just a fact of the hard data that defines the economy outside your window. So it includes the key measures of output, employment, income, and broad sales, much broader than retail sales. And you could see the COVID recession, it was short and nasty, and the growth in the coincident index went negative 20-plus growth rate.
And then the rebound saw the growth in this indicator spike just as much to the upside. And some of that volatility earlier this year, end of '20 and into '21, is being kicked around by the income measures being hit by variations on the stimulus. It hits and then it's off for a few months and then it hits again. And so you get a little jumpiness there.
And if you kind of just even within your mind's eye, get rid of that jagged kind of peeking out in growth that occurred around the end of Q1, early Q2 in this chart, you could see that it's rolled over. And so coincident index growth has actually edged just below 5% from readings as high as in the teens and almost approaching 20%.
And so that's undeniably a slowdown.
The question is, where is it going to go from here? Trees don't grow to the sky. Hey, this thing had to turn down. We understand that, but where's it headed? And also, the analysis that there was going to be a slowdown is not based on some year-over-year comps getting harder or whatever. It's just that the forward-looking data turned down. And if you If you switch to slide 7, you get another view of this sequential monitoring of turns, again, from a slice of our framework. We have dozens of indicators for the US economy.
I'm showing you here a sequence of indicators on slide 7 of indicators for the aggregate economy, not for any sector. And the long leading index is on top. The weekly leading index is second from the top. The short leading index is second from the bottom. And the coincident index growth, same indicator that you saw on the earlier slides, 6, is at the bottom of the chart.
And what you see is that The long leading index growth rate for the overall economy turned down several months ago. And way before— this becomes important for the current headlines— way before the Delta variant became a concern. So something cyclical was getting set up a while ago. And it also doesn't have, as I mentioned, anything to do with the base effect issue.
That is going to make year-over-year growth rates go down. It's totally unrelated what I'm showing you here. And I'm sure a lot of people are still going to feel that you can dismiss what I'm saying because it's just kind of like tough comps and base effects or whatnot. But take my word for it that our analytical methods sidestep the entire issue of base effects.
What I'm showing you here is unaffected by that. And as I said, the downturns in the longer leading indexes started well before Delta surfaced in the United States.
And so when you have the long leading index turn down, the weekly leading index, it's a shorter lead, follows suit. The short leading index, shorter lead, also turns down. The coincident index itself turns down. Hey, if it walks like a duck and quacks or whatever, it's a duck, right? This is a cyclical downturn.
And the next question after having made that call is, is there any sign of an upturn? And our long leading index is not showing a sign of the next upturn in economic growth. And so here we are.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So if I summarize all of this, you've got a pretty darn good track record at predicting economic cycles. And back in the day, pre-GFC, economic cycles used to transmit pretty directly to stock market and other asset classes. It seems like what we're really dealing with is in this new era of monetary policy post-GFC, that price transmission mechanism is kind of broken down. Still works for commodities better than it works for stocks. But it seems like, you know, the stock market just— they keep buying the dip every time it happens, no matter what kind of data we're looking at.
It seems to me that, you know, where we ultimately have to be headed is a lot of people have said is someday They just do too much borrowing and spending beyond their means and blow up the whole system. Is there anything in your models that starts to track when deficits really do matter again and when that national debt reaches a point where it truly becomes problematic now, not just someday?
Lakshman Achuthan: The answer is yes. I mean, we're all about when, right? The problem is that the, at least in our view, when looking out, 2 or 3 years from now, that stuff may not have been determined yet, right? There's a lot of road between here and there as to what happens a couple of years from now.
When we are looking at our cycle indicators, and not for lack of trying, okay, but the farthest we can, we can really get, uh, some bead on, on, on the risk of a turn or the risk of something snapping is about a year. You can't go a lot farther than that with any usefulness in terms of applying that data to a decision. And that's why I say maybe it hasn't been determined. I could see the structural stuff.
There's a long-term decline in trend growth. We see that. And we see the policy response, which is to use more and more debt or interest rates or however you want to say it, low interest rates or deficit spending to prop things up, keep things going. And sometimes I guess if you double the amount of whatever you're doing, we used to use this phrase years ago, it's kind of like the Red Queen effect where if you have to run twice as fast just to stay in place.
And that may be what's going on here. And we don't know exactly how many times you can double the amount of debt. without something breaking.
But we can monitor the cycle indicators to see if things are running away one way or the other.
On growth, we see the deceleration. We can infer on this chart, by the way, that I just landed on, the chart 7. You could see, we don't forecast by analogy, but you could see what was going on post-GFC. And so post-GFC, the long leading index took off, the weekly, all those leading indexes anticipated the recovery. By the way, when most of the world was looking for a depression, these indicators went up.
And so they nailed the recovery call in March of that year. They were super early when people were still talking about depression and stuff. But then what's interesting is they nail the downturn call. So we make a growth rate cycle downturn call, I think in December of '09.
And back then it was Vice President Biden who in the spring of 2010 was tasked with kind of promoting the recovery summer, which ran right into the slowdown.
And it was important for markets. I don't want to suggest that the stock market has disconnected from economic cycles. You had a 16% correction in the market that began in April of 2010. So nobody wants to walk into that, right? As a manager of risk or a manager of portfolio, you definitely don't want to just take that.
So if you know they're going to buy the— they're going to intervene, and practically every one of these growth rate cycle downturns, Once the powers that be are confronted with that, they react. And that truncates maybe certain aspects of the market. In this case, we're just sticking with equities. So how do you manage that? I mean, there's one extreme version is that you just buy insurance.
But the problem is, you don't want to be buying insurance all the time. You don't need insurance all the time. You need insurance during a growth rate cycle downturn. You don't need insurance during a growth rate cycle upturn. To the contrary, you could sell it, right? So that's the way you may kind of modify how you interact, say, growth rate cycles with equities.
Now, switching gears, I'm oversimplifying. We got commodities, we have equities. You also have fixed income. Of course, right? And the 60/40 portfolios have a lot of money sitting in fixed income. And so there you have, you know, what are real rates and what are inflation expectations? And the real rate has collapsed totally in line with the growth rate cycle downturn.
So super important for that aspect of your portfolio. And we'll see where inflation expectations go. I think that we can't predict the predictors. We have to watch where the future inflation gauge goes. It nailed the inflation cycle upturn call. It has not given us an inflation cycle downturn call yet.
So those inflation expectations components, we don't have a clear downturn call there just yet. But But that's what we got to watch for. That's what we're paid to do is to determine, is there a cyclical downturn developing there? And that's what we're working on right now.
Erik Townsend: We've been talking about how the transmission of these economic cycles to the stock market is not really what it used to be pre-GFC. It seems to me though that commodity price transmission is a little bit more direct because those commodities are either needed or not needed and have to be produced in a certain way.
So in terms of what we're seeing here, as we think about other assets like, let's say crude oil and copper, which are traditional inflation hedges, should we be expecting a downturn cyclically in those assets as well?
Lakshman Achuthan: You know, the short answer is yes. Those are tradable, exchange-traded industrial commodities. And so we track very, very closely sensitive industrial materials prices, many of which are exchange traded, many that are not. And almost all the time, their cyclical direction is the same. And occasionally, for maybe speculative reasons, they'll diverge a little bit.
But then wherever those non-exchange traded ones are headed tends to be the right direction. Commodity price inflation itself has already Turned down, the broad commodity price inflation. So I'm talking energy, base primary metals, textiles, and other miscellaneous kind of building materials and other things. And that is not over. That is probably one of our higher conviction calls. You know, that global industrial downturn is not over.
And just as good as it feels on the way up, uh, in terms of, hey, this is really strong, it's one for the record books, and so on and so forth, you can get that same kind of violent reaction to the, to the downside. We, you know, it's known as the so-called bullwhip effect, where the size of the cycle really, uh, amplifies, gets amplified up the supply chain.
So commodities, industrial commodities are way up the supply chain, right? Or this could also apply, say, for something like semiconductors in theory, right? Because anything that's a really early input where you have a lot of capital investment to create it or to extract it or build it or whatever, and it's still this really early input. So your supply of that tends to be Kind of linked to whatever capacity you set up. So if you set up a lot of capacity to extract something, to build something, you're going to run it.
And the demand for that then can make those price cycles fluctuate very wildly. And that's going to happen here. It's already starting to happen and it's not over. So What'll be— you have different aspects of the market that are starting to move.
You have commodity price inflation starting to move, maybe even some levels. And I don't think oil or copper are going to dodge it entirely. There may be some supply things here and there that make a specific commodity act a little different for a little while. But the broad backdrop is a cyclical downturn in global industrial growth, which will take the whole group, it'll put downward pressure on the whole group in terms of the inflation cycle in those prices.
And as we said, the growth rate cycle downturn, let's say in the US or even starting in other countries around the world, that puts pressure on real rates. And so you're seeing those move. You're seeing, you're probably seeing, I think, I know you're seeing movement in commodity currencies.
So things are moving. And in that circumstance, I think saying that there's a growth rate cycle downturn, so the risk of a correction in equities is a lot higher than it was in the past year, it sounds entirely reasonable to conclude that, looking at what we're looking at.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit about precious metals, which is a near and dear subject for many of our listeners. On one hand, I suppose you could make the argument that economic cycles, industrial cycles don't really affect demand for precious metals because it has more to do with investor sentiment. On the other hand, that sentiment, I suppose, is driven to some extent by the cycles. How do you think about precious metals? Are your cycles effective in anticipating precious metals price moves or is it a little too disconnected?
Lakshman Achuthan: You know, I think it's more of the latter. It's a bit more disconnected. If you can narrow down to an industrial activity kind of driving the price of something, then we can make the cyclical link. But if there's the speculative component, which is pretty large, say for gold or something, then that becomes quite a bit tougher. I think if you get a market correction, and when I say correction, I'm talking double-digit percentage decline.
If you get a market correction, I think those assets will probably, at least on a knee-jerk basis, be a safe haven, I would think. But I just hesitate 'cause everybody's buying Bitcoin and stuff. But that's also a risk asset, right? So it's a very volatile asset. So I think that's where when you get the—
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Lakshman Achuthan: What is very likely to be a correction of size, I think, associated with the growth rate cycle downturn, those other assets are going to move. I want to correct— I just want to clarify something.
Since the GFC, I think there's been about 4 growth rate cycle downturns in the last 10-some, over a decade or so. And that's not a lot of sample size. Right? It's okay. It's not a lot.
And we've seen corrections show up rather quickly. I mean, in a matter of months or so after a GRC, a growth rate cycle downturn starts in 3 out of 4 of those instances.
During the '14 to '16, late '14 to '16 growth rate cycle downturn, It took a couple quarters until there was a correction in the market. And that was a downturn in economic growth that was focused very much in the industrial sector. There was actually a global industrial downturn and the US industrial sector also succumbed to that. So people who were focused on that sector or that aspect of the US economy, Certainly felt it or were aware of it pretty quickly, but maybe someone who was looking at the broad market just didn't see it right away.
And so in that instance, the correction took almost half a year to show up, but it still happened. It was still there inside the growth rate cycle downturn.
Erik Townsend: Lak, it seems like big picture here, you're talking about a pretty significant downturn in the economic cycle, not necessarily a direct correlation to the stock market cycle. How big of a— I mean, are we talking about a recession call? Is that really what you're making here?
Lakshman Achuthan: No, that's an excellent question. And the answer is no, there's no recession call. The reason it's a big call is because we're looking the other way, right? And not because of base effects and not because of the Delta virus. If none of those things were issues, we'd still be making the call based on the drivers of the cycle.
Consumption of goods, consumer consumption of goods hasn't only slowed, it's actually falling, right? The level of goods consumption is falling. And while our consumption of services is increasing as the reopening kind of progresses, it's not offsetting that downturn. So we have an overall growth rate cycle downturn call. It's bringing housing, there's stuff in there with supply and prices that are slowing some of the activity there.
Infrastructure is going to put some demand out there, but it's really spread out over so many years, it's not a game changer. And so my guess is that as people kind of come around to the idea that things are slowing, we may get people talking about recession. We don't see one.
We don't see a recession. But back in 2010, '11, with the disappointment That the growth didn't continue. The market's pretty manic-depressive. It goes from one extreme to the other. And so I wouldn't be surprised if that comes up, but we don't see it on our radar.
Erik Townsend: Lak, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, for the benefit of our institutional audience, please tell us a little bit more about ECRI, the Economic Cycle Research Institute. I started to call you the founder of that organization, but it's actually like 3 generations old. What's the story here?
Lakshman Achuthan: It's 3 generations old. So early years, first generation, it was the National Bureau of Economic Research. Second generation, it was largely the Center for International Business Cycle Research at Columbia University, which is where I joined. And then now since the mid-'90s, we've been known as the Economic Cycle Research Institute, completely independent.
So we're not talking anybody's line. We're just telling you where we're monitoring these indicators. And we have institutional clients and they're big fund managers or asset managers and big companies, C-suite type situations. And I wanna share something that came across in my email. It was a quote from Jeff Immelt. You'll remember the GE head for many, many years. And I'm using his words now, quote, knowing what to do isn't that hard. Knowing how to do it Isn't that hard. Knowing when to do it is really hard.
And that's what we're about. We're about, hey, when is this going to crack and go the other way and surprise someone? And so I think the PMIs, for example, are great. Is it noise or not? They've come off for a couple of months. I don't know what it means. Hey, we know exactly what it means. It's all part of this cyclical array of indicators, and it's coming in right on cue, and, uh, it's going to be, uh, easing. And so that arms you to, to, to make a better decision in managing your risk.
Erik Townsend: Lak, we look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales.
It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: So joining us now for a post-game conversation is Grant Williams. Thank you for coming on the show, Grant.
Grant Williams: Erik's been schooling you in name pronunciation. I can hear that, Patrick. Nice attempt. Thank you.
Erik Townsend: I'm the schooler now. I am who you look up to as the pronunciation chief.
Grant Williams: Erik, it's your school. We're all just pupils in My friend, you know that.
Erik Townsend: Well, in that case, let's move on to my favorite subject, which is your absolutely outstanding Dollar Endgame series that you produced with Bill Fleckenstein, where you guys did a tremendous job of analyzing how the current fiat currency regime might end someday, right up to the point where Lacy Hunt handed you the answer to the grand prize question on a silver platter, and you guys both missed it, which is that the US dollar gets replaced as the global reserve currency with a digital reserve currency. And I'm not talking about cryptocurrency.
What do we have to do, Grant, to get through to you and Bill that crypto is not the same thing as digital currency?
Grant Williams: Well, I don't think you need to get that through to us, Erik. I think, look, I think I think a lot of people, us included, are guilty of using the term crypto in way too broad a fashion. I totally accept that. Instead of being somewhat more surgical with it, I think it's just become an easy catch-all. First of all, it was Bitcoin, and then people would distinguish between Bitcoin and blockchain, and then we got to crypto, and now you have to distinguish that and distributed ledger technology. So, your points about But digital currencies, I absolutely understand where you're going with that. And I'm happy to have that conversation with you. I know when you talked about it being dropped on a platter, I think the conversation we had post that with James Aitken, our second conversation with James Aitken, really brought that to the fore when he talked about the DCEP in China. And it was clear at that point that there is a whole other discussion to be had around Central bank digital currencies as opposed to Bitcoin or crypto or whatever you want to call it.
So, I'm very happy to have that conversation with you.
Erik Townsend: Well, I should let our listeners know too, this was not an outright ambush. Grant and I discussed this ahead of time. But I really do—
Grant Williams: Well, no. The conversation was actually, do you mind if I ambush you? And I said, no.
Erik Townsend: Which is a friendly way to do it.
Grant Williams: Well, okay.
Erik Townsend: That was good enough, right?
Grant Williams: Yeah, I think so.
Erik Townsend: Okay. Well, let's continue the ambush then.
Grant Williams: Yeah, let's go for it. I'm looking the other direction.
Erik Townsend: We're doing a special on this in the next 2 weeks with Dr. Pippa Malmgren and Clint Cox talking about the same issues. And I want to make sure our listeners understand too, it wasn't just a setup for the ambush. I very sincerely believe that the Dollar Endgame series is some of the best podcast content anywhere. So I really encourage our listeners to check that out. But I do think that the answer to the question ultimately is the current fiat monetary regime eventually gives way to a digital currency system, which is almost certainly not Bitcoin or another cryptocurrency. It's more likely either a central bank digital currency, CBDC, or what I call a Silicon Valley digital currency, SVDC, something like— I think Facebook's Libra was just a flash in the pan. But the question is, what's the next big tech currency system?
I think the really big topic that nobody is talking about, and you're the guy that I would expect to be talking about it, Grant, is the future is going to be about a space race for who's in charge of designing the digital currency system that replaces the US dollar and all the rest of the fiat currencies.
Are you on board that that's where we're headed? And do you think it's worthwhile to try to figure out who the winner is going to be or who the likely contenders are, or is it too early in the game?
Grant Williams: Well, look, to be honest, Erik, this— I mean, as ambushes go, this sucks because I largely agree with you. So, you know—
Erik Townsend: We'll work on that. Yeah.
Grant Williams: Let's change it from an ambush. But look, as I said, the conversation—
Erik Townsend: Bill's not here. Let's pick on him. Yeah, that's a good idea.
Grant Williams: That's a good idea. The second conversation Bill and I had with James Aitken, where he brought up the DCEP, the Chinese currency, was a real eye-opener for both of us. And I think that was where I had this nebulous concept of a central bank digital currency. I knew it was something they were working on. I knew it was something that solves an awful lot of problems that the central banks are going to face. There is no doubt they're going to face these problems.
They're not necessarily a good thing for the citizenry of the countries that ultimately institute them. But at this point, rather, that's very much a secondary consideration of a lot of these people, I suspect. So what James said, and I would urge people to listen to that conversation, he talked about conversations he'd had at very high levels with government officials in multiple jurisdictions.
The Americans were shocked at how far ahead the Chinese were with their central bank digital currency. And we've seen that now being trialed. There are millions of people trialing that in China already. He said that the powers that be, the penny had finally dropped and they recognized what a game changer this is and how dangerous it is to allow the Chinese to be that far ahead with the technology, the implementation, and every kind of facet of this.
So it's definitely on my radar. It's definitely on Bill's radar. We haven't covered it in that much detail since. People have touched on it, but it's not really been the focal point of a conversation. And I absolutely agree with you, it needs to be.
What I've found as I've kind of tried to navigate a path through the cryptocurrency world, and I will distinguish that from what we're talking about, but what I've found, I have a very high aversion to dogma. It's something that I've discovered over the last 15, 20 years that wherever I see dogma, I have a visceral reaction to it. Because I think anytime you run across people who have the answer, it's very dangerous. I don't have the answer to anything. I have an answer to lots of things, but I'm very much aware and conscious of the fact that what I have is an answer, not the answer.
I've found that whole space to be something where the dogma on both sides of the argument is problematic for me. And trying to have conversations, as I know you found in that space, is difficult simply because of that level of dogma. So when it comes to the central bank digital currencies, I'm hoping there is a little less dogma about it because they are nascent, even though we do have a very good example of of how they're going to work in China. But for me, Erik, the necessity of this as— I'm going to choose my words carefully— as a weapon for central banks makes it all but inevitable, I would think.
Erik Townsend: Oh, I think it's absolutely inevitable. And what I don't think most people in finance understand yet is that what money is functionally, what it does and how it's used, Is about to be re-engineered. And I think that part of that will be re-engineering the entire fractional reserve banking system, not just the currency system, so that how credit is extended can be modernized as well. And that potentially upends the balance of power in the entire banking system, because I don't think that the banking system as we know it today is really necessary anymore once we get to the technology that's coming, that's ahead of us. And And it will need to be replaced with something else. And anytime you have disruptive technology like that, it means that usually the longest-standing old players in the game get knocked out and they get replaced by newcomers that nobody's ever heard of. And I think that where this ultimately, the grand prize is whoever's in charge of designing the digital currency system that eventually replaces the dollar as the world's reserve currency.
That's the grand prize in this game. And I think that Google and Facebook and other tech giants have figured it out. And they're now strategizing, saying, hmm, do we work with the central banks and sell it to them? Or do we try to just take over and use our market clout in order to get public adoption of a new money system that's not government issued? Or do we figure that the crypto guys pissed off the government so much that we gotta get the governments on our side? I think Silicon Valley is struggling with that question now, as they basically eye how they're going to re-engineer what money is, how credit works, and how the entire financial system works over the next 20 or 30 years.
So I think this is just insanely big. And what's crazy to me is that this silly little sideshow called cryptocurrency and Bitcoin in particular still gets all the attention that it gets when it's obviously not the most important thing to pay attention to. So I think you and I probably agree on that point. But boy, nobody, as far as I can see, has really come to terms with the fact that how money works is about to be re-engineered.
Grant Williams: Well, I think a lot of people will use the terms digital currency and cryptocurrency interchangeably. I think that's one of the issues here. I know I'm guilty of it on occasions. There are times when I catch myself and I realize that I do need to be more surgical in my choice of words. I will use those 2 interchangeably. The question here is really one of money and power, because there's the Amschel Rothschild quote about, give me control of a nation's currency, and I care not who runs the armies. I forget, I'm bastardizing the quote completely. But money has always been power. And this is one of my big questions about what we're about to go through is, The necessity of the establishment, if you want to call it that, although that word is somewhat pejorative, or the current system, or however you want to term it, giving up that power of having control over the world's money is not something anybody ever does willingly.
So whatever happens here, there is going to be a struggle. Now, whether that struggle is between governments and Silicon Valley, or whether it's between Silicon Valley and the establishment banking system, or whether it's a, a melee between all 3, I don't know. But there will be a struggle. And, you know, as in the title of the film, there will be blood. Now, the, the question is for me, whose blood gets spilled? Because ultimately, uh, assuming a central bank digital currency is the way forward. And I'd love to come back to whether you are talking about, in effect, a digital SDR that will be a truly global currency, or if this is an arms race between sovereign nations. But let's come back to that for a second.
But ultimately, there is going to be real blood in some way, shape, or form amongst us, the people who use this money, because one of the big things that digital currencies do is enable deeply negative interest rates to be imposed. And I think we can probably all agree that there is a high likelihood that they will need to be imposed. So that could well be one of the first things that central bank digital currencies are used to implement.
We may find ourselves caught up in the battle and have ease of credit taken away from us. We don't know, but there are going to be an awful lot of dead bodies on this battlefield. when all's said and done. And I just wonder how that plays out, Erik, and how you think that battle plays out in the short term.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm trying to figure it out, and I'm trying to get more people that are willing to talk to me to try to figure it out, because so many people seem to be ignoring this, frankly. But I think, as you said, money is power. And more importantly, this technology has hit the scene at a time when there is a very, very strong social will to change the balance of power.
So some examples of things that could be designed into a government-issue currency system could be expiration dates. You've got some money, but we're only gonna give you X amount of— you've got 3 years to spend it, and those dollars expire worthless, like airline miles, at the end of those 3 years if you haven't spent them, because AOC and the Squad decided it didn't make sense for savers to be keeping their money and not sharing it with other people for years at a time, and then they decided to make it better. Obviously, I don't agree with that from a policy standpoint, but I think those kinds of things will be contemplated, and there will be a vicious public debate, mostly held by people who don't understand what's actually being debated, and it'll be driven by a lot of emotion, and, you know, just like tax things tend to be Debated.
But I think the real question, and it's a complete mystery to me at this point, is do we see Silicon Valley try to take the, the you can't beat them, join them approach of going to central bankers and saying, look, you guys have a monopoly on issuing money. We're not going to try to take that away from you because we saw what you did to Facebook when they tried to and, and kind of learned a lesson there. So we're going to design something. That we sell you, that we license you so that you, the central bankers, can issue the digital currency. But we're gonna design a really special Google digital currency that you can issue it through, that's going to do a whole bunch of cool things. And oh, by the way, benefit Google along the way. Does it go that way or does it go with Silicon Valley getting much, much more brazen and just saying, look, it took governments more than a decade to figure out what Bitcoin was and they still haven't figured out how much of a threat it poses to them.
Yeah. Them. We have the opportunity right now to just re-engineer the world's money, use a platform like Facebook to make it popular, and get to the point where truly governments don't have the ability to stop us because there would be such a public outcry if you took away everybody's favorite payment system that they'd all fallen in love with. The same way, you know, when we first introduced Apple smartphones that were going to take your picture, and it's widely known that those pictures got shared with the government.
Were people afraid of it? No, they were lined up around the street in sleeping bags waiting to buy the first one, even though it was possible to have one pre-ordered to be sent to your door the same day.
People get excited to get the latest technology. And I think Silicon Valley potentially has the opportunity to sell the world on non-government money, something the Bitcoiners think they can do. And I think they're crazy to think they can do that. But Silicon Valley does have the ability to pull that off. And I'm most scared of that outcome. I actually like the central bank digital currency outcome as the most preferable of the possibilities, just because I know if central banks are in charge, it'll take many, many years to implement it because they don't do anything efficiently. And we won't have to go through this change, which unfortunately, I think this could be the greatest change in monetary history for the benefit of society, if only you didn't have sleazy people trying to—
Grant Williams: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: To design features in for their own benefit rather than to benefit the common good. And I think that's exactly where this is headed.
And so I think it's a really scary story in terms of where it might end up, but I don't know the answer. I'm trying to get more people talking about it.
Grant Williams: Yeah, look, it's interesting the words you chose there when you talked about once it kind of got enmeshed, it would be difficult for the government to take away the world's favorite payment system. But that's talking about something completely different. When we're talking about payment systems versus money in the true definition of what money is, that brings in a whole bunch of other questions because it's perfectly possible to build a payment system on top of social networks, which doesn't use a Libra stablecoin, but which facilitates the transfer of goods and services via a pure central bank digital currency. So the two can live in harmony. I don't think there's any doubt about that.
But as I said, whichever way this goes down, there will be enormous benefits for the public in terms of convenience and ease and potential reduction of frictional costs in terms of transactional processes, which is obviously wonderful.
However, the likelihood is that, to your point about the phones and stuff, the freedom you have to give up in order to avail yourself of these marginal incremental improvements in efficiency and lowering of costs, I doubt will be understood by one man in 1,000, to steal Keynes's old quote. Or was it Lenin's quote? I think it was Lenin's quote, actually.
And that's the problem. The problem is a lack of understanding of what money is, of the reasons why this conversation is so important to have right now, because Because the monetary system is reaching the end of its useful life. And look, the only reason it's done that is because, to your point about self-interested actors using the system for their own ends, that's where we are. It just so happens that the self-interested actors have been central banks, and they've done what they've done and created this mountain of debt, which has now become way too big of a cancer to simply be cut out of the system.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Grant Williams: of the global economy.
So, so we're there anyway, but there's just enough complexity around this that it requires anybody who wants to understand it to, to do some work, you know.
And it's fascinating when you, when you realize the, the way that mankind has progressed, particularly as that progression has got faster, the amount of due diligence that the average person does on anything now. is falling just as quickly as the speed of being able to do something is rising. And so people now get all their news from the headlines. People don't read the story anymore. And headlines are 90% opinion-based rather than fact-based.
I'm just in the middle of listening to the great new book about WeWork, The Cult of We. It's a tremendous audiobook if anyone is into such things. And just listening to this story unfold, and I was like you, Erik, I was cynical about WeWork. But from day one and incredibly cynical by the end of it, and just amazed when the whole thing fell apart that people hadn't seen what this thing was in plain sight.
But when you listen to this story from the beginning, you realize this is just a story of ego. This is MBS having more money than he knew what to do with and wanting to be a big noise. It's Masa Son also wanting to be a big noise and going to MBS and selling him on this crazy vision that that would make him a big deal and would make Son a big deal. And then Adam Neumann picking both their pockets by pandering to their egos. And Adam Neumann is just an illustration of that class of entrepreneur that has no shame and can sell any kind of dream. And the bigger your dream, the bigger you're going to get.
But just listening to the level of due diligence that was done by anybody involved in this whole thing, it was pitiful. And why? Because in this day and age, we get the headlines, we don't want to read the story, and we want to be a big deal, and we want to have lots of followers and all this crazy stuff.
So unfortunately, we are playing into the hands of this massive shift in the monetary system because it will be sold to an ever more gullible, ever more willing, ever less diligent public. as incredibly beneficial. And in many small ways, it will be, but I suspect, Erik, in many large ways, it will be an absolute nightmare for the public.
Erik Townsend: Oh, I think it is going to be an absolute nightmare. And as you said, one man in 1,000 at most is going to understand what's happening as it's happening. And we're going to see a re-engineering of how money works so that suddenly governments have more control than anybody ever imagined possible. And guess what? It's all in there and working, and they have the ability to delete or extinguish money from your account so that it doesn't exist anymore at the touch of a button, and you can't do anything about it. And that's all in the interest of fighting terrorism, so it's a good thing, don't worry.
Right, right, yeah. And by the time anybody figures any of this out, I mean, I shouldn't say anybody, by the time the masses figure out what happened to them, we will have seen a change already occur that gives government so much power That they'll never let go of it.
So I think it's inevitable that there is a huge loss of individual liberty. And I said this as soon as I learned about Bitcoin in, I don't know, 2012 or so. I said, it's just so obvious what's going to happen here. It's like the little army that invents the howitzer. What happens is the big army sees you've got it and they outnumber you and they come steal it from you. And they take over that invention and they perfect it. And And they use it for themselves. Governments are going to steal the invention of the secure digital bearer asset and use it to create digital currency systems that give governments more power than they've ever had before. And it comes at a time when governments are able to slip things like this in without most people noticing.
And I think it's actually even worse than that, because it won't even be people not noticing, very similar to the lessons that have been learned now from things like the camera phones taking your your facial image and sending it to the NSA. What we're going to have is the advent of some really cool ease-of-use features that make everybody not just not complain, but enthusiastically embrace and welcome this change to digital currency, which dramatically undermines your privacy rights. And it's inevitable.
And I think the question I'll pose— this is the impossible question I can't answer, Grant. If you could be in charge of this one thing only, what would be better? To have sleazy bankers be in charge of designing the new money system, or sleazy Silicon Valley guys be in charge of designing the new money system? Which is better for society?
Grant Williams: Look, it is a great question, right? I mean, it's a really great question. I guess for me, amazingly, and I guess anyone that thinks I'm a boomer, which I'm not, but I've been called a boomer plenty of times. Will not be surprised. But the reason I would go for sleazy bankers, even though they are sleazy and plenty sleazy, is because at least the bankers care solely about the money.
The bankers aren't going to try and impose a social agenda alongside the currency.
And what I'm witnessing coming out of Silicon Valley is far more, I think, dangerous in terms of loss of social freedom, arbitrary decisions about what is acceptable, the clear challenges to free speech. You don't get that from bankers. There are plenty of scumbag bankers out there and they're a sleazy class all their own, but at least you know their motivation is purely to make themselves money. And whilst I applaud plenty of agendas that are out there, The problem with the power social media has right now is that it can impose the kind of censorship on people that is the thin end of a very, very dangerous wedge.
And we are seeing that. We are seeing that on a daily basis with the woke culture and the cancel culture. We're seeing just how quickly narratives can spread and be spread in ways that when you actually bother to dig into the whole story, it's never what it's portrayed on social media. So it's Sophie's choice, but I would choose the bankers over the Silicon Valley types, to be honest with you.
Erik Townsend: I can't believe it, but I have to agree.
Grant Williams: You know what? Some ambush this turned out to be.
Erik Townsend: I know. Patrick, help us out.
Patrick Ceresna: All right.
Erik Townsend: We need a proper ambush.
Patrick Ceresna: There you go. So Grant, I'm going to I'm going to ambush you here.
Grant Williams: Come on.
Patrick Ceresna: Recently, I read an interview with Jeremy Grantham, who's been outspoken about the extremes and excesses in the financial markets. And you obviously have a podcast titled Endgame, where you have the opportunity to pick the brains of the smartest money managers and economic thinkers out there about these excesses. Yet these markets keep plugging along. Like, in your mind, can these excesses just continue without a day of reckoning? Like, can this just be perpetually engineered?
Grant Williams: Well, look, I mean, it's can they continue? I mean, they've proved day after day, week after week, month after month that they can continue. And I think, look, it's very important for people to understand when you listen to someone like Jeremy talk, there's an enormous amount of prioritizing the scoreboard in this day and age.
Jeremy Grantham is a great example. John Hussman is another great example. Great thinkers, who, who put their thoughts out there, put their research out there, talk about what they see, talk about the risks they see evolving, and people then come back and go, well, you, you know, you were wrong. And I think the important point, particularly with someone like Jeremy, who is, you know, a remarkably thoughtful human being, he's, he's been a remarkably successful investor, and the rigor and the diligence behind the work that he does and the thinking that he shares with the world is literally the best we can hope for because he doesn't know the answer and he doesn't know what the future's going to be.
What Jeremy is saying effectively is, I've been doing this for 50 years. This is what the sum total of my experience has taught me. I am going to share that experience with you. And few of us have the kind of experience that Jeremy has. What we do with it then is entirely up to us.
And he's not saying, here's what I think, therefore you should invest this way. Instead of thanking him, going away, thinking about it, and then making up their own minds, investors kind of go, oh, that guy doesn't know what he's talking about, which is clearly ridiculous. Jeremy Grantham's forgotten more about investing than most of the people that will take potshots at him.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Grant Williams: Right. But there's no— none of us know the answers. None of us know the answers to an unknowable future. So the way I've always worked is listen to people who know more than me, which is just about everybody, take in what they say, stress test the rigor of their arguments, and then understand how, if at all, that changes my own opinion, what I need to take from what I've learned to improve my own feeling.
But ultimately, I'm responsible for my decisions and that's it. And thanks to Jeremy and thanks to John Hussman for sharing their thoughts, even though if you read them and go, well, based on today, he's wrong. He's not wrong. He's telling you what he thinks is going on and why it's important.
You do what you want with that information, but you should actually thank him for sharing it with you.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Grant. Well, we can't let you off the hook without talking a little bit about precious metals. Now, we're in a window of deeply negative real yields and many commodities in these huge bull trends, yet over the last 6 months, gold has been a big laggard. Do you suspect that this is just a short-term cycle, or do you think something has changed in the precious metals market?
Grant Williams: I think it's very unlikely. It's unlikely that something has changed in a 6,000-year-old asset. I think it's very unlikely that in 2021 something changed. Again, it depends on how much you've bought into the fact that gold absolutely should behave like X when the conditions are Y.
And of course, that never works. If you are trading gold, then it's disappointing you every day in how you would expect it to act based on technicals, based on the news flow. You would expect an asset to move in a certain way. And if you were trading it around, you've probably lost money.
If you are investing in precious metals because you think the price is going to 5,000, and you thought the price would be at 5,000 by the middle of August 2021, then gold has let you down again.
If you are buying precious metals and owning them as a liquidity reserve to protect and sustain your purchasing power over a a long period of time, over an investment lifecycle, over a career, gold is doing exactly what you wanted it to do. So it really, it really only matters in the short term if you are focused on the short-term price. It's like anything, you know, you don't check the price of your house every day.
You own that house because you want a roof over your head and you want somewhere to raise your kids. You don't check the price every day. But when you come to sell it, you may decide you want a different house. And at that point, you're going to check the price. And well, you know, at that point, you don't think to yourself, the price of my house hasn't gone up, you think, well, if I sell this house and I want to buy that house, how well has this house protected my purchasing power? And the likely chances are, because housing markets tend to move, you know, in reasonable symmetry, that owning that house, even if you've lost money on it, you can probably buy the other house you want to buy for less than you would have bought it 6 months ago anyway. So, you know, people get so fixated on the price of precious metals And I understand that if you're a trader, that's fine.
But if you are owning them, if you're owning precious metals for the right reasons, then the fact that gold has gone down to, you know, from $2,000 to the mid-1700s and below, it really doesn't make any difference. So I, you know, I, there's no real answer. It really depends on what you're looking for. And if you're looking for certain things, gold will be, you know, the biggest disappointment in your portfolio. There's no two ways about it. And if you're not, it's just doing fine.
Erik Townsend: Grant, I want to go back to your podcast before we close, because frankly, it's the only podcast that I know of that I think is everybody's good, is MacroVoices. I hate saying that, but it's true. I don't think everybody realizes what's happened though. You were one of the founders of Real Vision Television. You've now kind of moved on and you've got your own podcast, which is supported on Patreon. For anybody who doesn't know about it, guys, you're missing out. It's a really good one.
Tell us about it. Where can they find it and what can they do to sign up? Because it's now a paid subscription service.
Grant Williams: Well, thank you, Erik. I appreciate that. Finally, I've got everything in one place. So if you go to grant-williams.com, you can find out all about it. There's a ton of episodes of The Endgame which are out there free. You can find those in the Apple iTunes Store. And since I went behind the paywall, I put a preview out, 15, 20-minute preview of every episode just to give people a taste of what we're talking about. But everything you need to know is all in that one place now. grant-williams.com. So go take a look.
Erik Townsend: And I will be politically incorrect and say, if you want every bit of the quality that used to be in Real Vision, you can get it for a small fraction of the price at grant-williams.com.
Erik Townsend: Well, on that note, we're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the slide deck provided by Lak There's also a link to the Bloomberg article, This Turning Point for Markets Merits a Hard Look, and a look at an interview with Jeremy Grantham, this being the greatest bubble in history. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distribution If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Erik Townsend: Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account. At MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Brent Johnson — Santiago Capital founder and private wealth manager (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 283 was recorded on August 4th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow.
Santiago Capital founder and private wealth manager Brent Johnson returns as this week's feature interview guest. Brent says the US dollar isn't really crashing to zero as some have suggested, then goes on to articulate a balanced view on the inflation-deflation debate. We'll also discuss commodities including precious metals and why Brent thinks soft commodities in particular may be a good play if prices pull back. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck is titled Big Picture Look at
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's jump to that S&P 500. Literally nothing has changed from last week. I mean, we've— it's almost like if it was a gamma pin, yet we're not at an apex. It's, uh, we're just trading sideways. And while it's— the trend is very well established to the upside, it certainly doesn't seem to be going anywhere in a hurry. Any insights? Is this just summer doldrums?
Erik Townsend: I think it's summer doldrums. I mean, it's not going anywhere to the upside in a hurry, but it's still holding the 5-day moving average and all the other longer moving averages below it. So We're definitely still in uptrend conditions. The valuations still don't make sense to me, but I think it's a crack-up boom and I think it's likely to continue.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index. We are still holding above the 92 level, 92.25 at the time of recording here. And obviously the dollar's been relatively strong since June. Do you think that trend can continue?
Erik Townsend: Well, Brent Johnson is the man for this subject. We've had quite a few discussions with Brent about the dollar over the years. So I want to leave a lot of this to him, but really no change in my view. We're consolidating until there's a close below 89 or well above the recent highs. I think it's just a sideways consolidation. Frankly, I think the reason for that consolidation is too many people are confused about the fact that the dollar index is in fact a relative measure of the dollar against other fiat currencies, not an absolute measure. And I think that has a lot to do with why there's so much confusion and volatility in the market.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because to end last week, I mean, crude oil was approaching its previous highs, looked like the trend was resuming. We came into this week with nothing but selling and we're under some pretty key levels and specifically under $70 back down here. What's your take on the price action? And more importantly, how did the inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: Well, my prior prognostications of $80 to $92 by Labor Day on front-month WTI were based entirely on a cacophony of analysts that were forecasting up to 20 million barrels per week of average drawdowns in August. What, August is here and the very first August print was not a drawdown at all but a build of 3.6 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 543,000 barrels. We did still see a drawdown on gasoline of 5.3 million barrels. That's a significant drawdown, but distillates only drawing down 832,000 barrels. Still, on the net, it is overall a drawdown on crude plus finished products, but nowhere close to the 20 million barrels a week that some analysts had predicted. Now, of course, one print doesn't make a a trend, but this is the second week in a row that we've missed expectations of really big drawdowns and seen either small drawdowns or, in this case, a significant build instead. If that continues through the rest of August, all bets on much higher numbers are off.
I'm not persuaded yet, but definitely this is interesting. Now, I think the Delta strain is confusing the market. Definitely everybody is looking at this and saying, for good reason, well, wait a minute, look at China really starting to shut things down. China is a huge consumer of oil. If their demand is going down, it's going to bring the price down. And that's very real. But I think there's also a lot of fear in the system about, oh boy, the Delta strain could mean that we're going to shut the whole economy down and it's going to crash to negative prices like it did last year. I just don't see that as being in the cards, Patrick. Meanwhile, US production stayed unchanged at 11.2 million barrels. Where do we go from here? I think it really depends on what happens next with inventory in coming weeks. The recipe that was going to get us— and I still think it could get us above $80 before Labor Day— was about a series of really significant inventory drawdowns.
That doesn't happen, we may have already seen that the, the peak price is in for this year.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, uh, let's touch on gold because, uh, gold was making a pretty good press this morning toward $1,840 and then certainly has kind of come off a little bit. But overall, gold is holding in here north of $1,800. Do you think gold can resume its prior uptrend, or is this just more of gold being stuck in the mud?
Erik Townsend: Well, we're stuck in the mud consolidating here, and the support is on the short-term moving averages. 5, 8, 13, 21, 34-day moving averages are all right around where the market is or just below it. Meanwhile, resistance has been strong where the 55 and 200-day moving averages are co-located right around 1836. So if you see a closing print below 1800, that would take it below all of the short-term moving averages. That says maybe more numbers to the downside are coming. If you see that daily close above 1840, for that matter above 1837, that would suggest that maybe the resolution is to the upside. I still think the upside resolution is most likely, but so far, at least this week, the numbers aren't really cooperating with us. We saw a little bit of a tease this morning, but it all retraced pretty quickly.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, and let's wrap things up by looking at the 10-year Treasury yield, because late July we put in lows near around 1.15, and it looked like maybe yields hit a short-term low. But after just a quick little We had a several-day bounce. They rolled right over, and here we are under 1.20 again on that 10-year yield. I mean, that trend is pretty pronounced on the downside. Do you think we have lower yields from here still?
Erik Townsend: I think we probably do. You know, 1.34 was a key technical number that once that didn't hold as support, I think that we're probably headed toward lower yields. But frankly, I don't really have a strong conviction view here because we're already at super low yields, and who knows what's coming next in terms of monetary and fiscal policy. I think to trade this market, you've got to have a much stronger understanding understanding and stronger conviction than I have about where monetary and fiscal policy are both headed. Frankly, I think it's a political circus that's hard to interpret. Let's ask Brent Johnson though. This is certainly something he focuses on.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson. Now, Erik, why did we invite Brent back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Brent is one of our favorite guys, the kind of guy we got to get back at least every 6 months. We said, oh boy, we're overdue. It's been longer than that. Frankly, it's perfect timing to get him back because this The inflation-deflation debate is one where Brent has been identified as a deflationist, although he'll tell you in this interview, he doesn't really like that label because he sees both arguments. So we're going to get a very balanced view, I think, and one I found quite interesting. I think you'll really enjoy this interview.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Brent Johnson is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the fintech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange, or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchange
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson. Brent prepared an excellent slide deck for today's interview, and I strongly encourage you to download it as we will be referring to the charts and graphs it contains during today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not registered yet at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Brent, it has been way too long since we've had you on the show. It's great to have you back. Let's jump into your slide deck and talk about a favorite topic of mine when I talk to you, the US dollar. Everybody's asking me, I can't decide.
Brent Johnson: Well, I had a feeling you might ask me about the dollar, Erik. So, that was the first slide that I threw in here. But in any case, it's really great to be back. I always appreciate the opportunity to talk with you and your listeners. It's one of my favorite podcasts out there. So, happy to jump in.
And the point I wanted to make with this first slide here is I was here talking with you about a year ago, Erik, and the dollar was around 93. And since that time, I've had innumerable people tell me, remind me, try to convince me that the dollar is going to zero and there's just nothing that can stop it. However, you know, in the last year, despite printing over $1.4 trillion, despite having a Democratic president get elected, despite having a totally Democratic Congress get elected, despite numerous stimulus plans, contested elections, and social unrest, the dollar's at 92. So, I guess I would say is, are you sure? Are you sure the dollar's going to zero? I'll tell you, I'm not sure about anything, Erik, but I think it's a very uncertain time. And I think a lot of people who are certain in their narratives may be proven wrong.
And so, we'll just have to see how it goes.
Erik Townsend: Brent, let's talk about some of those reasons that some people say the dollar's going to zero. This has frankly baffled me because the usual argument I hear is, hey, look, governments are just debasing fiat currency. And I mean, it's a huge trend. Well, I couldn't possibly agree more with that, but the dollar index is a relative measure of the dollar against other fiat currencies where those other governments are doing the same stuff. So why don't we go ahead, looking at slide 4 here, I see you've got kind of the history of the various different programs of quantitative easing that everybody thought was going to crash the dollar.
What is this chart telling us, and what should we make from it?
Brent Johnson: The point I wanted to get across was that I don't disagree when people tell me that governments are debasing the currencies and it's a trick as old as time and you can't trust the governments and they're going to do everything they can to inflate away the debt. Of course, they're going to try to do that, but are they going to be successful? They may be successful against things like land and gold and other real assets. But again, to your point, fiat currencies are relative.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Brent Johnson: And think about all the different programs and everything they've tried over the last 12 or 13 years since the global financial crisis. Well, the dollar is higher today than it was when they started in 2008. So, despite QE1, despite QE2, despite Operation Twist, despite QE3, despite the repo crisis in 2019, and despite COVID over the last, call it 12 to 15 months, the dollar is higher than it was in 2008.
So, And then I'll hear people say, well, it doesn't really matter. Fiat levels don't matter. And the point I would make is relative fiat levels absolutely do matter. Now, if you want to just put 100% of your money into gold or Bitcoin or one asset, well, then just go buy that one asset and go to the beach. You don't have any more work to do. But if you don't want to have all of your money in one asset, you very much need to understand how fiat currencies trade relative to each other because it has huge implications for markets.
Erik Townsend: Brent, talk me through the next few slides. Why hasn't the dollar crashed the way so many people thought it would?
Brent Johnson: Well, again, I think it goes back to the relative level of currency. If this was a unique situation to the United States, if we were the only one that had committed these egregious fiscal sins, and we were the only ones who were trying to inflate away our debts and having to provide stimulus programs and thinking about MMT policies and UBI, then of course, I would expect the dollar to fall, but it's just not the case.
Everybody likes to point out the Fed this, the Fed that, and that the Fed is monetizing the debt, even though they're not calling it that. But what about the ECB? I mean, last year, the ECB monetized 85% of the net Eurozone issuance, and they're on schedule to do over 100% this year. So again, how come people aren't laying all the world's problems at the feet of the ECB? Why is it always the Fed? Again, the Fed is not alone. And then they'll say, going forward, the Fed is monetizing most of the debt, and it's all going to be sitting on the Fed's balance sheet. The US Treasuries are going to be sitting on the Fed's balance sheet. Again, I don't necessarily disagree.
But again, why aren't they talking about the United Kingdom? Why aren't they talking about Australia? Why aren't they talking about Canada, Europe, and Japan? All of those countries have dramatically higher percentages of their outstanding Treasuries on their balance sheets. So, again, this is a relative game, and we're not the only ones doing it. And as a result, I think people are going to be surprised at the dollar's resilience.
And I think we are still set up for the possibility for the dollar to go much higher. Now, that's not a guarantee. I don't know that that's going to happen, but I think all these people who are just sure of themselves that the dollar's headed to zero may be dramatically disappointed.
Erik Townsend: Brent, we've covered your Dollar Milkshake before on MacroVoices, but it's been quite a while. Let's do a quick refresher for any new listeners. What do you mean Dollar Milkshake here on page 10?
Brent Johnson: Yeah. So, on TIN, the point I've made is that the amount of debt that has been issued in the world is going to have consequences. And it's not just the US. The whole world has issued massive amounts of debt, but the US is the global reserve currency. So, a lot of that debt has taken place in dollars, and that puts a lot of demand under the dollar.
So, despite the fact that we've been printing a lot, other countries have been printing a lot too. And so, I've coined this term that they've created this milkshake of liquidity.
However, I believe that all this debt is going to have consequences. Now, it hasn't yet, and so I will hold up my hands and say I've absolutely been wrong as far as the timing of a global sovereign debt crisis or a currency crisis, but I still believe that's coming because I still believe that debt has consequences. And I believe when we enter the this currency crisis and this debt crisis, I believe the dollar will, for many reasons, be the last man standing. And I think as that happens, the dollar will suck up the global liquidity, hence the Dollar Milkshake. Now, if we enter a global monetary crisis and a global sovereign crisis or a currency crisis, and the dollar falls rather than rises, then I will hold up my hand again and say, you know what? The theory was wrong. I got it wrong. But until we get into that crisis and see how that crisis plays out, we just don't really know.
Again, I always remind people, I call this the Dollar Milkshake Theory. It's not called the Dollar Milkshake Fact. It's not called the Dollar Milkshake Guarantee. I don't know for sure how this is going to play out. But my suspicions tell me that when this happens, when we get into this event, or when we get into this time period where global debt actually does matter, I think you're going to see a rapidly appreciating US dollar.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the topic I've been asking all of our guests recently, which is inflation versus deflation. Janet says it's transitory, don't worry about it. And President Biden says you don't have to worry about inflation because we're going to pump money into the economy, which will make the inflation go away. That's a macro view I'm not really familiar with. What do you make of this?
Brent Johnson: Well, I do think that this is kind of the debate of our time, for lack of a better word. You know, I, I would say this, I have been labeled a deflationist, and, and I don't necessarily mind that, although I would say that I feel like I could flip to the other side pretty quickly if I see a few things happen.
Part of the reason that I've been put into the deflation camp is for my strong dollar views. And typically, a rising dollar is associated with deflationary pressures. I would say that over the last 12 to 15 months, after COVID broke out, and we've had the central bank reaction to it and the monetary authority, reaction to it, I'm not going to sit here and deny that prices haven't risen. Sometimes people will say to me, Brent, how can you not see the inflation?
The short answer is I can see it. It's pretty clear that prices have risen. The question I have is whether they continue to rise and if they continue to rise at the same rate at which they've been rising.
I am of the belief that in addition to just what the central banks have done, a big reason for the rise in prices has been the supply chain disruptions. And I think some of that will get worked out. Now, it's not going to get worked out overnight, and I'm not so naive to think that it's all going to be perfect tomorrow, but I do think a lot of that will get eventually worked out. And then I also think that a lot of the upside that we've seen for the last 15 months is starting to subside. And I think that the biggest near-term worry is deflation rather than inflation.
Again, I don't know this for sure, but I think there's a few things that we can look at to tell us whether inflation is sustainable or whether it's transitory.
And I've put a few charts up here that I know you've seen before, Erik, because we've talked about them before, and some other of your guests have talked about them before. But on slide 12, I've laid out the rate or the commercial and industrial loans. And what you see is last year, once they rolled out the PPP loans and the loans that the banks gave were guaranteed by the government, well, then the banks were happy to lend.
But as soon as those programs ended, you immediately saw commercial and industrial loans start to fall. And they've fallen with the exception of 1 or 2 months. They've fallen every month since then. I think in order to get sustained inflation— again, I'm not going to argue about whether we've had inflation for the last 15 months, But to get sustained inflation going forward, we really need the banks to lend because that's where the money supply is really increased. And they are just currently, they just aren't doing so.
I also talk about on page 13 that in order to get, again, sustained inflation going forward, we really need wages to rise. And again, they had a big jump last year. And now, and since then, they've just kind of crashed back down to the long-term trend. And long story short, wages just are not yet doing so. Now, again, if this last chart that I showed and then this chart, if we start to see some sustained changes, I'm happy to consider the fact that maybe inflation is here to stay.
But so far, the data is telling me that that's not necessarily the case. And that's why we still have such a low velocity of money. I point this out on slide 14 here, Erik. It still sits at its all-time lows, or at least near its all-time lows. I struggle to understand how we're going to have sustainable runaway inflation if money just isn't moving.
Erik Townsend: Now, you said the real issue was banks needed to start lending in order for inflation to be possible. It seems to me like, boy, the political sentiment is really growing in favor of universal basic income, forgiveness of college debt, a whole bunch of things. Isn't that enough to get inflation going, or do you really think there has to be bank lending to create more M1 money supply?
Brent Johnson: Well, you can get some inflationary pressures from some of these programs that you're talking about, but to get the sustained high levels of inflation that we've seen for the last year, then I think you do need lending. Because you got to remember, all of these programs that are, whether it's UBI or these PPP checks, they don't just come out of nowhere. At the same time they're created, debt is created.
And the bigger the debt grows, the more deflationary pressure it puts on the economy. So, you have to figure out a way to get more money coming in than the debt that's created along with it. And that's a big part of bank lending. When a company sells a bond, when a company or a country, when they issue bonds and the people go out and buy those bonds, they're taking money out of the system that already exists in order to buy those bonds. But when bank lending happens, when bank loans are created, that's new money. That's new money that's going into the system. It's not a recycling of the current system or the current supply. And so, I think there's no doubt that when a government spends money, you do get a short-term inflationary impact. The question is, is it enough to offset the additional debt that that country or company has incurred as well? And I think that without getting some lending, it just doesn't happen.
And again, you got to ask yourself, the banks probably understand the banking system better than most people. They're the ones closest to the money. You got to ask yourself, if we have such this great opportunity of growth coming up, why are the banks not lending to try to participate in it? Why are they instead buying Treasury bonds and sitting on them?
I think that that's a good place to look and see whether the banks really believe we're in an inflationary environment or a deflationary environment. And when I look at what they're doing, they're buying bonds, they're not making loans.
So I struggle to see without a few things changing, and again, I'm open to them changing, but without a few things changing, I struggle to see the sustained inflation that so many are convinced is here.
Erik Townsend: Tell me about your reaction on page 16 to the commodity prices, because boy, there's a pretty strong confirmation of an inflation perspective just from
Brent Johnson: Well, again, there's no doubt that commodities have had a huge run over the last year. They have made, you know, big moves. Many of them have broken out from long-term bearish patterns, for lack of a better word. Some of them are moving towards either recent highs or all-time highs. But again, you know, you're starting to see some of these economic forecasts fall short. Just the other day, GDP was forecast to come in at like 8% and it came in at a little over 6%. So you're already starting to see some of these economic growth prospects to get pulled back. In addition to that, you've seen a number of these commodities like copper had a huge move, lumber had a huge move, but those have pulled back anywhere from 5% to 20%.
And so some of these really inflationary commodities, You're starting to see a pullback. Now, I think we have to kind of wait and see how the next 6 months go. I, again, I tend to believe that the biggest risk near-term is deflation rather than inflation. But to your point, Erik, you can't ignore charts like this when they're going up that fast. So I don't think they can continue to go up at the same rate they've gone for the last year, but we'll just have to kind of wait and see how the data comes in.
Erik Townsend: Brent, one of the things I love about your work is you're really good at taking these macro views and translating them to actionable advice in terms of portfolio construction. I see on page 18, looks like you've got a picture here of a guy who's trying to figure out inflation versus deflation.
Brent Johnson: Well, yeah. And I think, you know, I have a picture of a guy named Chris Moneymaker. And Chris Moneymaker kind of came onto the scene 15 or 20 years ago. He was one of the first guys to grow up playing online poker, who then, you know, translated that skill into playing real poker. Real live pro poker and won the World Series of Poker.
And I think that was good in many ways because I think, I think you can learn a lot from, from, from studying poker players.
But there was one thing that I think that was bad with this advent of online poker and then, you know, also having poker on TV and people knowing the, the names of, of, uh, you know, these professional poker players, because one of the most famous lines, for lack of a better word, that goes along with poker is saying, I'm all in.
And so, somebody thinks they have a good hand, they see their favorite poker player on TV pushing all their chips into the middle of the table. That's kind of an exciting prospect. We're going to get rich. We've got the hand here and we're pushing it all in.
And on the one hand, while I like that, I think it's dangerous as well. And I'll tell you why, because I like playing poker, Erik, and I'm an okay poker player. But the reason I'm not a great poker player is I like to play poker. And what I mean by that is when I play poker, I tend to play more hands than I should because I want to be involved. The reality is, is professional poker players, the really, really good poker players, they play less than 20% of the hands that are dealt.
They just sit there and they wait and they wait and they wait and they wait for the cards to come to them. And occasionally, they will bluff. But usually, when you see a poker player start making big bets, he has the cards because he's waited and he's been patient.
And I think this is a big mistake that a lot of people make with portfolio construction these days. I think a lot of people go all in on a hunch, or they go all in when they have a pair of 8s, right? Or maybe they have 3 of a kind.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Brent Johnson: But I think people are going all in. You should not be going all in unless you have at least a full house and maybe a straight flush. But unfortunately, people get excited, they want to play, and they go all in on a pair of 3s. And I just think that's the wrong thing to do.
The other thing I should say is I always try to remind people, when you hear somebody, whether it's me coming on and talking on a podcast like this, or you're watching some other person on CNBC or you're reading a report, you have to put yourself in that person's shoes and understand what it is that they do.
I'm not a day trader. I'm not somebody who comes in and I'm whipping positions around constantly. What I do is I create customized long-term portfolios. And so, what I mean by that is I develop a basket of assets for my clients that are customized to them, And then for the most part, we sit there and we wait for those assets to appreciate over time. Because if you look at the arc of history, assets appreciate over time.
And then when we see a really good opportunity, then we'll go in and be aggressive. But we're not always trading. And I think sometimes when you hear somebody say, or when I've come on before and I've said, I think gold's going to go down over the next year, that doesn't mean that I'm rushing out to sell my gold. It doesn't mean that I've got a huge gold short position. It just means that I would not be surprised if I think this gold pulls back.
And so my point is, I think when you're constructing a portfolio, it's important to figure out what you're trying to accomplish and over what time period. I feel like there's a lot of certainty in the market right now. And I feel like this is a time of great uncertainty. And so I think when you're listening to somebody or when you're looking at your own portfolio, figure out what it is you're trying to accomplish. You do not have to be a day trader. Now, if you are a If you're a day trader, that's fine. But make sure that if you're listening to somebody's advice, you're listening to somebody who has kind of the same objective or the same mindset as you.
So I don't know if that's a good answer or not, Erik. I kind of went on a little bit of a ramble there, but I think that's, that's kind of why I put these slides in here.
Erik Townsend: So you're not going all in on silver, which is guaranteed to go to $1,000 according to WallStreetBets?
Brent Johnson: I think that when I saw that earlier this year in February, when everybody's piling into silver because WallStreetBets was going to take it higher. I was just— I knew that that was not going to end well. And I still think that silver probably goes lower before it goes higher. But yeah, but to your point, Erik, it's okay to have a silver position, but you don't need to go all in.
It's just, even if you think it's going up to $1,000, if it goes up to $1,000, you don't need to be all in. You put 5% of your portfolio, and if it goes to $1,000, you're going to be really happy.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Brent Johnson: So again, I think it's about position sizing and understanding what it is you're trying to accomplish.
Erik Townsend: Well, Brent, we've got a slide coming up later in the deck on gold, so I'll wait till the slide for that one. But why don't we move on to page 22 where you start to talk about an allocation or a portfolio allocation?
Brent Johnson: So yeah, so I put this slide in here, Erik, because this is not specific advice to anyone in particular, but as a general state of what I think is an appropriate portfolio for a long-term investor. is to have a very diversified approach. About 15 or 16 months ago, kind of in the middle of the COVID pandemic crisis, someone was suggesting to me that they should have 50 to 100% of their portfolio in gold. And I just didn't think that's the right way to go. And I suggested this portfolio as a good way to be prepared for anything should it come down the pike. Now, I'm very, very bullish on gold long-term, but I don't think that you should have 50 to 100% of your portfolio in gold. I just don't think that's the right way to do it.
And so, I think the point I'm trying to make here is if you have a portfolio such as the one that I suggest on page 22, you're ready for anything, whether you get inflation or deflation, whether you get a war, a revolution, a boom, a bust, you're going to be able to get through it. And then if you have some kind of a macro or volatility overlay that can take advantage when you get these crises, or if you can convert some of your short and medium-term US Treasuries into cash and then go buy some equities that have been beat up in a crisis, You can actually, you know, you can take advantage when you see the real opportunity. But the point is, is to have a diversified portfolio. Don't go all in on anything. And then when you see a really amazing opportunity, then that's when you go all in, or that's not when you go on, but that's when you make a more aggressive bet.
And so, you know, I know because I've been so outspoken on the dollar, a lot of people think that I only own dollars. And so, because the dollar's gone down over the last year, all we've done is lose money.
But the dollar's just one piece of what we do. I mean, I have clients that have owned equities for 15 or 20 years. We've owned gold forever. They all own big chunks of real estate. We focused our equities on big blue-chip US equities. Those have done fantastic over the last year. And if you had this portfolio that I suggest here, and even if the global macro and the volatility got cut in half, Or even went down by 60% or 70% over the last year, this portfolio still would've made money.
And so, my point is that you don't need to go all in on everything. I know I've said that a few times, but I just can't emphasize that enough. I think people go all in way too much. I think this is a time of great uncertainty, and I think we have a bull market in certainty despite the fact that it's a very uncertain time.
Erik Townsend: Brent, let's talk in detail about some of these asset classes that you're recommending allocation to. I see on page 24, you've got the 10-year US Treasury. Where are we headed in terms of Treasury yields?
Brent Johnson: Well, so this kind of goes back to what I was saying earlier about whether the next move is inflationary or deflationary. I'll tell you, Erik, the bond market certainly doesn't think that inflation is raging. If you look at this chart, you can see that other than the pandemic, when we had a massive move lower in yields last year and then a huge run-up, We just now broke back through support that goes all the way back to 2012. So, you know, when you're sitting here and you're thinking how great this economy is and that we've got all this growth and inflation is supposedly raging, why is the 10-year Treasury sitting just over 1%?
I think, you know, I have to laugh because in April, kind of the March, April, May timeframe, when bonds were selling off, and I was saying that I still expected us to have some kind of a disinflationary move, I had several people say to me, listen to the market. Don't try to force anything. The market is telling you that inflation is here. So, I think I would turn that around and I would ask those same people who were saying that to me in the spring, what is the market telling you now? Are you listening to the market?
Now, again, I don't know for sure what's going to happen, Erik, but when I see yields doing something like this, on page 24, and then I look at the long-term trend on page 25, this could go significantly lower. And if the certainty of the inflationary trade starts to come off a little bit, it wouldn't shock me at all to see yields under 1% again.
Erik Townsend: Is there a lower bound at 0% where it just doesn't make sense for the sovereign debt of the global reserve currency issuing nation to ever go negative? Or is zero just a number on the way to negative
Brent Johnson: So, I kind of depart from a lot of my, I guess, quote unquote friends in the deflationary camp on this because I personally don't think that the US Treasury is going to go negative. Now, it could. If it happens, it will not shock me, but that's not my base case.
Part of the reason is I think in a really deflationary environment, the market might take the negative under a very short period of time, But then I think that would force some kind of a reset, for lack of a better word. So, I don't think that we would have a multi-month or a multi-year scenario where the global reserve currency is at a negative rate.
Now, we've had negative rates on Swiss and other European and Japanese rates for years now. And that's a little different because it's not the global reserve currency. Again, I don't necessarily think that rates are going to go negative in the US, and if they do, I wouldn't expect them to stay there very long. But it's a very uncertain world. I do think rates are going lower. We'll just kind of have to wait and see what happens when we get close.
Erik Townsend: Brent, let's come back to gold, a subject that's near and dear to the hearts of many of our listeners. When you and I spoke last, I think we both thought that gold was probably due for some kind of a downside correction. I'm kind of feeling like the bottom's probably in. Didn't get as low as I thought it would, but feels to me like it's over. What do you think?
Brent Johnson: Well, so about a year ago, you know, I think it's— is it tomorrow or the next day? It will be a year from the high. So I think it was the first week of August of 2020 when gold put in its high at around, right around $2,100. I don't know if it quite hit $2,100 or not, but it got pretty close.
And at the time, I thought that gold would come back, and it has. Gold's about 10% down, about 10% over the last year, down 5% or 6% year to date.
Again, I would say, if inflation is just absolutely raging, why is gold— why is it down over the last 12 months? Why is it down year to date? I put on the chart here, we've got this rising wedge, for lack of a better word. It's in the middle of that wedge.
I think that it's more likely than not that we'll go back down and at least touch the bottom of that wedge. If we get into some kind of a deflationary environment or disinflationary environment, it wouldn't shock me at all to see it cut below that $1,800 level and then maybe go down to the $1,600 level or something like that.
I think the chances of it going back to $1,200 or $1,000 are pretty low. I think that that's quite unlikely at this point. And part of the reason is that if we get a big deflationary move, gold could certainly be seen as a source of funds for the very short term.
But if that happens, then all of a sudden, we get negative rates again. And actually, negative rates are better for gold than rising rates. Part of the reason that gold has sold off year to date is that yields were going higher. Until the last month or so here, yields were going higher. But now, as we've started to see Have we started to see yields fall again?
You've seen gold start to rise over the last month, let's call it, or over the last few months. And so, it's kind of, again, right in the middle of this range.
So, I do not think that we're going to see gold breaking out to all-time highs this year. Again, I can't rule it out. I still own it. If it does, that'll be fine, but that's not my base case. I would expect gold to— I think we've seen the high in gold for the year. I think it What did it get to? $1,950 last month or something like that? I think that may have been the high for this year and we may just kind of trend sideways or down for the rest of the year.
Erik Townsend: Now, some people would say it's all over for gold because Bitcoin is the new currency debasement hedge. What do you think of that argument and what are your views on Bitcoin and where it's headed?
Brent Johnson: So I have been pretty— what's the right way to say this, Erik? I actually like Bitcoin from a personal perspective, but for the last Since about last Thanksgiving, I have been very cautious on Bitcoin. And as it ran up from— I've owned Bitcoin for years. And when it hit $28,000 last fall, I sold a little bit. When it hit $38,000, I sold a little bit more. At $48,000, I sold a little bit more. And at $58,000, I sold a little bit more. I didn't quite sell any at $60,000. So, I still own a little bit, but I thought it was going to come back. And part of the reason I I thought it was going to come back is I was convinced that we were going to start seeing increased measures by either countries or authorities, however you want to describe that, to make moves, not necessarily to make it illegal, but to curb its use or to regulate it, maybe not let it be quite such a wild, wild west.
And so, we've seen that quite a bit over the last 2 or 3 months. And Bitcoin had a big pullback from, I think, $65,000 to $30,000. I think today it's at around $38,000. I still think we're going to see it go lower.
I'm not buying any. I still own a tiny bit. I've sold most of it. I think it has a place in a portfolio. If somebody wants to own it in their portfolio, I think that's fine. But again, I don't think it's something that you should be all in on. And as far as it replacing gold, I just don't think that that's the case.
And again, there's no reason you can't own both. A lot of people try to get into an either/or all-in scenario. And it's just totally unnecessary to do that. I think it's very likely that as they roll out these central bank digital currencies, which is about as certain— nothing is certain in this world, but central bank digital currencies coming down the road, that's about as certain as things get. And as those get rolled out, I would expect countries, they don't like competition.
And so, I would expect them to push back on crypto and Bitcoin as that happens as well. So, I think Bitcoin has a role in a portfolio if you understand the risks.
I think Tether is a huge risk to Bitcoin. I will just say that I think that Tether is a fraud. And I think if and when that is exposed, I think that will be, at least in the short term, very negative for the price of Bitcoin. So, that's probably why I'm cautious in the short term. But digital assets, tokenization, Bitcoin, they're probably here to stay. It's just a matter of at what level they will be and in what method they're allowed to be
Erik Townsend: Let's take a
Erik Townsend: look at the stock market on page 27. Boy, what a compelling chart here, you know, and I can't help but observe all that huge action to the upside in the S&P really has been driven mostly by the FAANG stocks.
Brent Johnson: That's right, it really has, it really has. And the reason I put this in here, Erik, is you and I spoke in either January or February of 2020, and at the time, you know, we were at point 1. I've, I've put a, a yellow circle with a 1 next to it, and at the time I was saying that I expected the pullback in equities. And I thought that we could go down to the bottom of that red channel. Now, I'm not going to sit here, Erik, and say that I thought that that was going to happen immediately and happen over a period of 3 weeks.
I was just saying I could see it pull back down towards the bottom of that channel.
And that did happen. And so, we were pretty lucky. We bought at the bottom of that red channel. It was a scary few days as it went a little lower than that. My mistake was that once it bounced back up into the middle of that channel and started getting into that green area, I thought we would probably see a retest back down to the bottom of that channel again. But you know what? It just never came. It just continued to run higher. And to your point, a lot of it has been driven by the FAANG stocks and the technology stocks. And so, the reason I've put number 3 on here is I think— So people have heard me talk before.
I think equities are going much higher in the years ahead, but I do think before that happens, we are likely to pull back, maybe retest the top of that channel. Now, that would be a 15% or 20% pullback from here, Erik. I don't know that it will come, but I'm certainly not allocating new money to equities right here. And I'm waiting for any cash that we have or to add to equities. I would be waiting for a retracement. At least back to that top of that channel before, before committing any new funds.
Erik Townsend: Now let's talk about where we go from there, because it seems to me, if I just look at this chart from a technical analysis standpoint, you've got this channel that has been operative here since the beginning of 2009. That's, you know, more than a decade. Yeah, you've got a very clear upside breakout. What technical analysis tells me is to expect a pullback back to test the top of the channel, now not as resistance but support. That's exactly what you've got for number 3.
And if that support holds, that would be a confirmation of that breakout and suggest that you're headed much higher from there. Is that your view?
Brent Johnson: That is my view as of right now. That is my view. Now, again, this doesn't mean that I'm going to go all in on equities at number 3, right? I will keep my, I will keep my exposure to equities and I may, and I'll probably add to it at those levels. But if that channel were to break, And it goes lower, then maybe we go back down to the bottom of that red channel. Again, I don't know for sure, but my base case is that we will go back down, test the top of that channel around number 3.
And then I think in the years ahead that we are going to go much higher in both the S&P and the Dow. Again, you've heard me talk about this before, Erik. I think that we are going to enter a period of sovereign debt crisis. And I think when sovereign debt starts to get sold, Those funds are going to look for a home, and I think one of the biggest and most liquid markets on the planet is U.S. equities. And I think that will get fund flows, and I think that equities have the potential to go much higher than anybody believes possible.
Now again, I just want to caution: that doesn't mean you need to go out and go all in on equities right now here today. I think we're going to get a pullback. But for anyone who thinks that we're going to go down to 200 on the S&P and stay there for 10 years.
That's not my base case. I don't think that's going to happen. Can't rule it out, but that's not what I'm planning on. I think we're going to see much higher levels in equities in the years ahead.
Erik Townsend: I don't think I've ever seen a chart with a 30-year-long head and shoulders pattern on it until we get to slide 28 here.
Brent Johnson: Isn't that crazy? So, you know, I've shown this to a few people and I really, really like long-term charts. I don't know if it's just a visual thing or what, but this is about as symmetrical of a long-term chart as you're going to get. Now, the interesting thing, Erik, is when I was here last year, we were actually sitting at the bottom of that kind of shaded channel. And so, and I thought that that might actually act as resistance. Now, it broke through there. Now, it's kind of come up to kind of the top of this shaded area. And again, this is not necessarily technical analysis on this right here.
Brent Johnson: I just kind of highlighted kind of the long-term. level here.
Again, because I believe that we're going to move into a disinflationary environment and potentially even a deflationary environment, I am not participating fully or aggressively, for lack of a better word, in the commodities. I think a lot of people are just convinced inflation is here and are going all in on the commodity trade. And I'm just not there That said, the one area of commodities where I am extremely interested and am looking to add positions on pullbacks aggressively is the soft commodities.
And I think I've put a number of charts here over the next pages, I think from slide 29 through 32 or 33, of a number of different soft commodities. And the reason I put these in here, Erik, is Soft commodities, for lack of a better word, have been not necessarily in a bear market, but just a sideways market for a long time. They had some big runs coming out of the global crisis in 2008 and '09, but then they slipped back and they haven't really done anything for a long time. But I am of the belief that even if we don't get this runaway inflation in overall commodities that a lot of other people are predicting, And even though I think it's very possible that some of the industrial commodities pull back and maybe even stay down for a while, I'm not sure that that's the case with the soft commodities.
And part of the reason is regardless of what's going on in the economy, you still got to eat. People still have to eat. So, I think the demand for food is going to be there. And I think we could continue to have some supply shortages in food. And so, I think that could be a recipe for higher prices.
And so, page 29, I have— this is the chart of coffee. Coffee had a huge breakout, went all the way up to almost like $220, $225, and now it's pulled back to the high, I think, $170s. If that gets back to the $150 range or the $140 range, I would probably start adding to something like coffee.
You get a similar chart on slide 31 with soybeans. Soybeans had a huge breakout as well. I mean, it went up 60% or 70%, almost 100% from its lows last summer. But now, it's pulled back a little bit. And again, I'm not chasing these commodities higher, Erik, but I've highlighted these channels where I think it gets pretty interesting to own them. And I think to the extent that people are looking to add some additional diversification to their portfolio or another way to play perhaps the devaluation of fiat currencies, I think the agricultural commodities might be a better way to do it than just the general industrial commodities.
Erik Townsend: Now, Brent, some people would say, look, you're misinterpreting the COVID crisis. What happened here was we had supply chain disruptions. Obviously, those soft commodities get hard. You know, you can't go out and pick the coffee beans and so forth. You know, it must be that this is a one-off thing. It's an anomaly. Don't read anything more into it, especially if you're not in the secular inflation camp. What would you say to that argument?
Brent Johnson: Well, I think there's some truth to that. And I think that's why I'm not chasing them higher right now. And that's why when you look at kind of the charts of soybean or coffee or some of these other ones that have had these massive moves, I think a lot of that was due to supply chains. So I, so I don't necessarily disagree. And so I think, you know, when some of that supply chain issue gets worked out, you're— we have the possibility to to pull back and in some cases, maybe pull back aggressively.
But what I would say is that I also am of the belief that demand for these food products is going to stay high. I don't think that supply chains, while they will get better, I don't think they're going to go back to be as efficient and as functional as they were over the last 20 to 30 years of globalization.
I also think what's kind of interesting is that we've had a number of There's been a number of issues over the last couple of years regarding different agriculture. China has had a number of problems, whether it's the armyworm attacking their crops or the swine flu attacking their livestock. We've also had some problems with— I can't remember the name of this. There's this type of beetle that's been attacking plants in the Midwest now, and that's been affecting crops. And then I also think that we could have— I know global warming is like this very popular thing and all the green initiatives, But, you know, there's also the possibility that, you know, with these grand solar maximums and minimums that we're going to get into a cycle of cooling temperatures. And if that's the case, maybe harvests aren't quite as robust as they've been for the last 10 or 15 years.
So, you know, again, I'm not going to go all in on the agriculture, but I'll just say that they're pretty interesting to me and that if we do get a pullback on some of these, I'm looking to add positions.
Erik Townsend: Brent, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, please give our listeners just a quick overview of what you do at Santiago Capital and how they can follow your work.
Brent Johnson: Yeah, sure. Thanks, Erik. Well, again, my job is a wealth management professional. I have a group of clients where I do customized long-term portfolios for them. And it's kind of a holistic scenario where we take into account their tax situation, their trust and estate You know, they're business owners and how does that play into things? And so, what we try to do is create customized long-term portfolios.
And then, in addition to that, we not only come up with the overall allocation, but then we actually go out and we implement those portfolios and we manage those portfolios for them.
In addition to that, as part of a diversified portfolio, we have a private fund that we manage that does some more high-risk, high-reward asymmetric-type trades. And that's kind of a hedge against the more traditional portfolio. I'm pretty active on Twitter. You can just type in Santiago Capital in the search function and probably find me. My Twitter handle is SantiagoAuFund.
I would also encourage people to continue to listen to MacroVoices. I've been on here a number of times. You can actually search for some of my prior interviews on here, and there were slide decks there. So, you can— I got to say, Erik, the great thing about coming on your show is Because you do a good job of keeping the prior interviews up there and the transcripts and the slide decks. So, all this stuff that we talk about, it's there in black and white and you can see where you got things right and see where you got things wrong. And I think it's a great way to kind of get a feel for what somebody's all about. So, I would encourage people to check out your website to find out more as well.
Erik Townsend: Thanks so much for that, Brent. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. Escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds.
Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Brent back. That interview really inspired me to, to put together a little chart deck talking about the dollar and, uh, and all these commodities on a much bigger timeframe scale. I'm looking forward to getting through it all with you.
Erik Townsend: Well, let's dive right into it. Listeners, the chart deck is titled Big Picture Look at Commodities. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to the homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, page 2, Dollar Index. What's going on?
Patrick Ceresna: Uh, you know, I, I hear a lot of times you referencing this in the, um, market wrap, and then when we talked to Brent about, uh, the dollar as Well, it really made me want to just zoom out on that chart and really reflect upon where the dollar is in the bigger picture.
And when you really observe that through the 1990s and into the 2000s, or at least the first decade of the 2000s, the sheer volatility the dollar index went through was enormous. I mean, we had swings of the dollar index go from 120 down to 70 in a span of like, uh, 5+ years. And, uh, you know, we, we stare at this dollar on— and like you were saying, on a relative basis compared to other fiat currencies, but there really has been a lack of dollar trend. I mean, the most we can really identify is, is that the dollar's been in a very specific trade range between the 90 and 100 level, which is historically a very narrow range for the dollar. And, uh, for any So for anyone to be doing a victory lap saying that the dollar bear market is already underway, I think it's quite premature.
Now, I'm not trying to even suggest something alternatively overly bullish, but right now all we can really identify is that there's been a very pronounced trade range since 2014-15, and it's entirely possible that we stay within this range in the coming year. And so there'll be a very interesting see how this develops.
Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more, Patrick. And you know, the way to look at this is we, at the beginning of 2015, that's 6 years ago, we entered this sideways consolidation pattern on the big chart here, and we're still in it. And there's no great surprise here, and I think we stay in it until there's a clear signal that we're coming out of it. Let's move on now to my favorite chart, crude oil futures.
Erik Townsend: We're down a tick here. What do you make of this chart, Patrick?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, down a tick, I mean, we— this is, uh, the continuous chart going back to 1999, and so this is really just reflecting Collecting the different cyclicality of oil over that timeframe. And while there's always the backdrop based upon the evolving market as to could circumstances arise where oil could once again rise to previous high ranges, like north of $100, and now we certainly have a number of people that have suggested that's on the table. But when we really look at it back to the last 5 years and just that most narrow range, We've approached now the 2017-18 highs and at least temporarily paused along the previous overhead resistance. Maybe there's room for some squiggling as crude oil may, you know, backfill a move towards $60 on a bigger scale. But overall, the most interesting part on this chart will be, will there be a new pronounced oil bull market, which would basically mean that we'd have to break out of this resistance points around 2018 highs of around $75 and then really see a trend resume that could see us heading up to those much higher levels.
Do you think that the conditions are there for that kind of a breakout?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think the conditions for that kind of breakout are coming. I'm not so sure that they're there right now. What we're seeing, to a lot of people's surprise, is actual builds on inventory when we thought there would be massive drawdowns. Now, I think there's a sentiment in the marketplace which is saying, boy, if we can just somehow get through August, that's the big crunch period because that's summer driving season. And once that's over, we're going to be able to breathe a sigh of relief and not have to worry about inventory drawdowns anymore because summer driving season's over. Remember the words of Phil Verleger, the energy economist who is extremely well-respected, who told us that summer driving season has always been a myth. What it really is is summer homebuilding season. Now, I can attest from just the fact that my contractors won't return my phone calls that the builders are all super busy. They're going to continue summer homebuilding season right through the fall into the winter.
So I don't think that we're going to see as much demand drop-off after Labor Day as a lot of analysts expect. Now, I don't know yet that we're going to see a disappointment in, uh, in August where those the market just can't get going because those inventory draws everyone expected never happened. But I wouldn't be at all surprised, even if the price comes off in August, that as we get into September and October, if demand surprises to the upside as that so-called summer homebuilding season turns into autumn and winter homebuilding season.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on though, Patrick, to page 4, natural gas futures. What are we looking at here?
Patrick Ceresna: You know, it's interesting because Brent inspired me to kind of want to dig in a little farther to see where we are in the cycle on a lot of these different commodities. And natural gas, uh, has been in an incredibly pronounced bear market that has more or less been in place since its 2008 highs. I mean, the pre-2008 period saw natural gas have the, uh, fundamental backdrop of being able to get up towards $14 on numerous occasions. But really, in the, um, post, uh, 2009 period, natural gas has been bound by more or less a lower boundary of $2 and an upper boundary of, let's say, $5 on a— that encompasses the majority of the price action. And we're slowly edging toward the top of that range. And this is what a common theme that we're going to see on a lot of these charts, which is, is the question that the— are these commodities in the cyclical trade range and they're just going to come to the top end of their range and circle back down?
Down, or are we genuinely seeing the beginning of one of these, uh, very big pronounced, uh, commodity bull markets? Uh, and this is a question that's going to be solved in the coming year, but right now we're approaching some pretty big overhead resistance levels in the next, you know, 50 cents to a dollar on the upside of natural gas. And it'll be really interesting to see how natural gas reacts once it starts correcting a little bit.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 5 and gold futures. It kind of looks like a formative cup and handle pattern, doesn't it?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. And what, what's really interesting here, Erik, is, is that gold is one of the very few commodities, after we go through every single one of these charts, that actually has been in a sustained bull market pretty much since '99, 2000, right? So many of these commodities have gone through cycles higher and then mean reverted almost 100% of their prior rises. And the only commodity that really hasn't exhibited that behavior has been gold. And, and even though we've been in what's more or less a half a year consolidation of gold prices, which certainly has taken the wind out of the, the sails from a sentiment perspective, when you really step back and look at the way this chart is developed This is still probably the most pronounced bull trend in most commodity charts. And I mean, we're holding at a stone's throw away from that $2,000 level.
I mean, it is, I guess it's still a couple hundred dollars, but when you look at this chart, this still looks structurally very bullish.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I agree on the technicals and I think the fundamentals are there too. Of course, we do have this issue of crypto and gold competing for the same market share. And I think that's been a big headwind for gold, but I wouldn't be surprised if the bottom is already in. I was hoping for a deeper pullback before this was over, but I'm not sure we're gonna get it at this point.
Patrick Ceresna: So moving on here, Erik, what I wanted to do is to just circle to silver, the, the cousin of gold. And what's interesting is, is that the, the boom-bust cycle in silver to its 2011 high was much more pronounced. I mean, silver almost wiped out its entire higher prior 2009-2010 gain in the subsequent bear market that happened, uh, in the last decade. But what we're really seeing is, is that silver had almost a 3-4 year trade range between this kind of more or less $15 to $20 range, for the sake of rounding. And this breakout in silver is generally holding at these higher levels. I mean, at this stage, uh, arguably if this sideways consolidation we've seen here for the last half a year, uh, bullishly breaks out with a new high, this could send silver heading up towards testing some of those previous highs around $35 or more.
It'll be really interesting to see whether silver will in the coming half a year break out bullishly to the upside.
Erik Townsend: It'll be very interesting indeed, Patrick. I can't help but look at this and say, you know, there's a whole lot of silly money that went running into silver on the WallStreetBets, you know, it's going to— what was it, $1,000? You know, that stuff. When those folks figure out that that was kind of silly, I think that potentially there's a big wave of selling that creates a buying opportunity. We'll see what happens. I don't think that those guys are going to get their $1,000 price anytime soon, though.
Patrick Ceresna: Generally, if your narrative comes out, I mean, I think it would still be structurally very bullish if all pullbacks on silver stayed above $20, right? Where all the previous highs of that multi-year consolidation occurred. So long as silver had a short-term correction and let's say it dropped, you know, 10, 15% in a sell cycle, found solid lows, that would be still conditions that would allow a bull market phase to ensue on the other side.
Erik Townsend: Oh, I'd be buying it a lot sooner than $20. I'd be buying $22 hand over fist. But I do think that that pullback could be coming for that reason. Let's move on to copper futures. Um, this is another one where I hope the pullback's not over yet because I, I wish I had more exposure and don't want to buy it at these prices.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, for sure. I mean, copper hit a multi-decade high when it punched through $4.50, uh, earlier this year, but it did have an enormous move on the upside, and that rally is now being checked. It reminds me a lot of the the pullback in 2009-2010 after copper made that huge move off the low. It paused there and mean reverted a good chunk, but that was only a midpoint before the continuation pattern. It'll be really interesting to see whether these pullbacks are more or less contained above $4 on copper in the bigger picture. If they are, I mean, that could be the buy-on-dip consolidation that allows allows copper to, to bust to all-time new highs and, and run pretty hard. And but the observation here, which I think is the most important one to make, is there isn't much asymmetry in buying brand new copper positioning up here without, let's say, having some sort of option strategy to hedge it out.
The, the tricky part is that while there's a very easy case to be made to be bullish copper, It's actually quite challenging to manage the risk on it if you didn't get in on the copper bull market when it broke out $3 going back a year.
It really is a much trickier entry here at these levels.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more, and I certainly don't want to be putting new money to work in a naked long here. I agree with you, you've got to have a hedge strategy if you're going to enter this market here. I'm personally hoping for a deeper pullback so I can get that long-term long position in place.
Let's move on to Let's talk about a topic Brent mentioned in this interview, which is he thinks that if there's a pullback, soft commodities, he thinks, may be the place to play. I see you've got a series of soft commodity charts here.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I figured we'd throw them all up, at least the major ones, just to kind of put some context on the moves that happened and the potential moves still to come. And what's interesting, just to step back, and I attached articles to our Research Roundup, Felder report, one where he shows the— where Jesse Felder puts up that generational opportunity commodities chart, which is taking the commodity index divided by the industrial index to show just on a ratio basis how cheap commodities are to the general asset prices. And while, you know, you can make the argument that commodities are cheap, when you look at the individual commodities themselves, it's interesting to see how far they've already come And what it would mean for a new bull market to ensue in many of these. And so I wanted to start here on page 8 with the wheat futures and looking at just, I chose 2 of the grains, wheat and soybean.
And what we have here is there was a number of periods a decade ago that saw wheat prices temporarily advance up to levels in the $8, $9 level on the upside, $800, $900 on on this chart, but almost each time it was like the lumber chart where it was some short-term supply-demand imbalance that basically corrected itself and, and caused wheat prices to mean revert back to much more average prices.
And this is going to be the interesting storyline here. First of all, there is room for these grains to generally advance still to higher levels. I mean, there's the— we have had essentially a sequence of higher highs and higher lows and in bull trend. And there's no evidence that this trend has already stopped. But, uh, but really the question here is that, is this simply going to be a short-term trend move that is going to be emergent, and/or is it going to be much more like the gold chart where once it reaches higher levels it's going to sustain up there for extended periods of time? And, uh, and that's one of the bigger questions as to whether or not not even inflation is transitory versus whether inflation is here to stay is whether or not a lot of these commodities are simply structurally going to find much higher prices on a sustained basis. And watching with the breakout on wheat and on the next page, the soybean is the same thing.
Like soybean is basically already traded to multi-decade highs. And so really to be bullish the beans for a bull market would mean that it's a bold call that these highs that were in place for the last decade are going to be broken and somehow we're about to see a sustained new bull advance, which is not impossible. I mean, we saw in things like lumber, but that's pretty much what the call you'll have to be making right now if this is where you're starting your buying.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm reminded of Darius Dale's interview a few weeks back and just what we know in general about markets, which is I think I think this is the beginning of a really big inflation. What happens in the beginning of something really big? There's a great big panic move up, and then everybody realizes that it was a little bit too much, too fast. It was overblown, and you see a great big retracement, maybe a 61.8 Fib retracement, typically in that situation, and then that secular trend resumes. So I think Darius probably has it right that, you know, the first panic wave has already played out, and now we're in the retracement before the resumption of what will ultimately be a huge bull market. What do you think of that view?
Patrick Ceresna: It's entirely possible. I mean, right now, I think what I was trying to achieve with this is simply seeing where we are in terms of new opportunities on a lot of these commodities. I feel that if the right fundamental backdrop is there for general repricing, but I mean, I think the part that you've alluded to in previous shows is about the social unrest that could happen And if we did see this type of a commodity move, I mean, really, it's when it hits these types of commodities that really ends up hitting the grocery stores, that really ends up hitting the average person that hasn't seen a meaningful pay raise in a long period of time. And right now, these commodities, you know, while most of us have seen generally rising prices in the grocery stores, we haven't seen anything extraordinary. But if these soft commodities really start to bull run, I think that it's going to really be felt.
I mean, it's going to be hard for it not to be felt in the pricing on the grocery bill, right?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to page 10 and continue our review of soft commodities with cocoa futures.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And it's interesting, this commodity has actually been the most trade range bound. I mean, While we've seen a number of commodities that have demonstrated cyclicality, this is really, especially in the last 3 years, been in an incredibly tight range. And we're trading at least to several-year lows, or at least approaching it. It'll be interesting to see whether or not this, like a ping pong, just is bouncing between these trade ranges and a buying opportunity emerges here on these. So, Erik, though, what I wanted to do is move on to page 11. Where I have the chart on cotton futures. And what's particularly interesting here is cotton back in 2011 had a parabolic rise that was very reminiscent of what just has been happening with lumber and just had this really big squeeze that had a— that almost immediately mean reverted. But when you remove that, that one kind of outlier. You can define cotton as a trade range that more or less has stayed within the $50 to $100 range for, for several decades now.
And we are trading right to that top of that trade range. And what an amazing crossroad this is on the cotton futures, because, uh, just, uh, exactly like we were talking, is, is this transitory? Is this, uh, just temporary? Are we going to just hit the top of this range and trade back to the middle or bottom end of this range? Or do we have a breakout to almost a decade high with, with a breakout, let's say, to $100 or more and, and see a new commodity bull trend emerge on the weekly charts this way? It's, uh, really interesting to see where cotton is today, and it'll be interesting to see whether that breakout actually does play out.
Erik Townsend: Now look at the contrast in orange juice futures on page 12. We're nowhere close to the cyclical highs or the, the recent all-time
Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. And what is interesting though is, is that when you really step back and look at the behavior, this is one of the few softs that actually looks like you can get in at an asymmetric level. I mean, uh, we, we had quite an extensive multi-year bear market in, uh, orange juice futures that saw it go from $220 to under $100. And for the first time in the last year, we have seen the characteristics of base basing formations and higher highs started to establish. It'd be interesting to see whether orange juice futures are just breaking out, out of the gate here. That this is probably out of all of the commodities, this one from a technical perspective looks the closest to being at the starting point of a new trend. It'll be interesting to see whether this breakout actually sticks.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to coffee futures, Patrick. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Now, coffee has had an extraordinary run in the last 6 months. Months. I mean, we've all seen coffee futures almost double off of their 2020 lows, and we've seen in the past that when coffee gets going, it can actually have a sustained trend. And now obviously it's hard to justify a brand new position after such an extraordinary move on the upside, but it'll be really interesting to see whether, as it mean reverts and corrects, whether old dips are being bought and whether there's another leg higher coming in these coffee futures. If you're looking for something that is just building momentum to the upside, this is definitely one of the futures to watch.
Erik Townsend: Now take a look at lumber futures with that downside retracement continuing to the point where now lumber futures are literally trading at 1/3 of the price they peaked at just a few months ago.
Patrick Ceresna: And this, this brings me back to that cotton chart on page 11. And when you see these kind of huge runs on the upside and then the full mean reversions. Clearly lumber is going to be impacted by inflation, and generally higher lumber prices make sense. But when you really put it in perspective, for several decades the $200 to $400 range has contained lumber prices, uh, for, like I was saying, for several decades. And the fact that, uh, we had this extraordinary move was, was very much, uh, I think, a nature of the illiquidity of this market and, and some short-term supply and demand imbalances that ensued. But what will be really interesting to see is that now that lumber is settling down a little bit after its extraordinary pop and drop, the question now is, does it stabilize at structurally higher prices? And I would say that even if we saw a short-term pullback even to $400, so long as we see $400 to $600 be the new higher trade range, that's still a substantially higher price of lumber than we have historically seen.
And while I think I'm a seller on the idea that lumber is imminently going to head back to north of $1,000, we finally are seeing lumber reverting back to levels where one can entertain the idea of buying dips again.
Erik Townsend: Finally, on page 15, we've got sugar futures.
Patrick Ceresna: What do we make of Another one of these soft commodities that, you know, more or less has been in a pronounced bear market for pretty much the last decade. We put some major lows in around the $10 level over the 2015 to 2020 period. And for the first time, we broke to a higher high, beating those 2019, 2020 highs in this recent advance. And while it's a little bit of a chase buying sugar at this moment, it'll be interesting to see whether this is now the beginning of a new potential bull run in sugar. If, if dips continue to be bought here, maybe we can see prices north of $20 and heading toward $25 on the top end of the range. So this is certainly another one of these softs that is going to be interesting to see as it develops here in the coming weeks and months.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, you can get Patrick's chart decks every single day with a free trial of Big Picture Trading. Information's on page 16 or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the slide deck provided by Brent and the chart book we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to a Jesse Felder report on the generational opportunity in commodities, part deux, as well as an article titled, Maybe It's Not Transitory, Let's Try Tolerable. You'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write a blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent Updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices. Its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Bill Blain — Shard Capital strategist and alternative investments chief (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. And now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 282 was recorded on July 29th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Shard Capital strategist and alternative investments chief Bill Blain joins me as a first-time feature interview guest. Bill says secular inflation is here to stay and then goes on to explain several less obvious nuances of the finance industry's readiness for the coming change. We'll also discuss precious metals, bond yields, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our post-game segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck is titled Post-FOMC Market Moves.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's jump to that S&P 500. We broke to a 52-week high. Didn't take too long, did it?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, the melt-up continues. I think it is an Austrian crack-up boom. Why is it continuing? Well, I think that the Delta scare is abating. And just to be clear about that, I'm not saying that the risk of the Delta variant of the virus is abating. I think what's going on is the scare that it was going to crash financial markets is abating.
And the thing is, the threat to humanity is as real as ever. This is a big deal, this pandemic, but we're getting We're getting to the point where there's just no public tolerance for a continued lockdown situation. The economy is going to reopen, virus or no virus. And I think that is the conclusion the market's coming to. Accordingly, we're seeing the melt-up continue.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to that US dollar, because in the post-FOMC period, we certainly see the US dollar backing off. I plan on putting up a chart here on the EUR/USD when we get into the postgame. But what's your take on the first reactions here?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, before the FOMC, we were approaching resistance. But now what's happened is we've rolled over in post-FOMC, that acceleration to the downside says to me that, you know, we're really in just a consolidation between 89 and, I don't know, 93, 93.50, something like that. And I think that until we see a significant sustained breakout out of that range, this market is just consolidating.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because we obviously the other week had a big drop on the downside, but the bounce has come back in and we're almost a stone's throw away from the previous highs. Do you think that that was just a quick little dip and, and now oil is just going to head up to $80-plus. And how did the inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: Well, let's start with inventory, Patrick. Crude oil drawing down 4.1 million barrels. That's a big drawdown. But, you know, considering that people were expecting a whole bunch of drawdowns of 10 million barrels plus, it's not a super big drawdown as some have expected. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 1.3 million barrels. But the drawdowns continue across the board, not just in crude, but in the finished products, with gasoline drawing down 2.3 million barrels and distillates drawing down 3.1 million barrels. So that's 9.5 million barrels of both crude oil and products drawn down. U.S. production moved down 2 ticks, 200,000 barrels down to 11.2 million barrels. Inventory data is bullish here, but I think the Delta variant fears have been the bearish factor that's been preventing the market from moving higher. I think as people are coming to their senses and realizing the Delta variant is a big threat to public health, but it's not really the threat to, you know, shutting down airline travel and things that people feared.
We're going to reopen the economy, especially to fully vaccinated people. And I think that demand is going to come back. So I still expect a rally in August up to somewhere between $80 and $92 per barrel as a final high, which I think happens before Labor Day. And, you know, is that something that is really going to happen or just wishful thinking on my part because I'm long? It really comes down to the inventory numbers in August. Some analysts were predicting 50 million barrels. That's 5-0, 50 million barrels of crude oil inventory drawdowns in the month of August alone. So that would be, say, you know, 12 or 13 million barrels a week for every week in August. If that really happens, I think we're going to $90. If that doesn't really happen and those were exaggerated estimates and it's really 5 or 6 million barrels, I don't know that we get to $90, but I think we get over $80.
We'll see what happens. The real test comes in August, though, and see how those inventory draws match expectations.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, I was looking forward to touching on gold here because week after week it seemed like gold was just doing nothing and it's trading in a sideways trade range. And then suddenly today, Especially in that post-FOMC period as real yields turn more negative, gold finally has a breakout. Do you think this breakout's going to stick?
Erik Townsend: Well, my hunch is that it's going to stick, but I emphasize the word hunch. I like to work from data, and the data is not persuasive yet. What we need to see is a daily close and a sustained move over $1,839, which is where the 55 and 200-day moving averages are co-located. And we're still, you know, we're at resistance. We're right on those numbers, but we haven't moved above it yet. So the close The close over is going to be the final confirmation. I think we're going to get it in the next few days. But, you know, you don't want to jump the gun. Right now we're at resistance. If anything, if you're the swing trader, you're tempted to sell here. I wouldn't be selling here. I'd be waiting for the breakout to happen. But as far as acting on the breakout, hasn't happened yet.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's touch on the 10-year Treasury yield, which after running pretty strong for the last month or two, really the last week, we've been really trading sideways here and consolidating. You think that's it for the move in rates?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, no real change to my view. As long as we're below 1.5%, I think we're in a comfortable zone where nobody's freaking out about the bond market crashing. And, you know, we'll see what happens. As far as whether the yields go much lower, as some people have predicted, it would take a lot, but we'll see. Anything is possible. I think it really comes down to monetary policy and fiscal policy, and these are moving targets.
You know, we actually had President Biden tell people the other day that we don't need to worry about inflation because they're gonna pump so much money into the economy that inflation won't be a problem. Okay, that's actually not a view we've had on MacroVoices. Maybe President Biden has the new math or something. I don't know, but we're going to need to wait and see how all of this policy stuff gets sorted out. And the folks that are driving the bus in terms of being in charge of policy don't really see macroeconomics the way I see it.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Shard Capital strategist Bill Blain. Erik, why did we invite Bill onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Bill has gotten a lot of attention on ZeroHedge and elsewhere with a lot of outspoken views. And he runs alternative assets. He has an inflation view that we're going to discuss at length. And he's thinking really seriously about what are the asset classes that you want to be in. He's the alternative assets guy for Shard Capital. So he just seems like a really good person to talk to about not only this secular inflation trend, but what do you do about it in terms of investment strategy?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Bill Blain is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. Two of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors. Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon Investors seeking exposure to the FinTech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Bill Blain, strategist and head of alternative assets for Shard Capital, and probably better known as the author of Blain's Morning Porridge, one of the most intriguing investment blogs on the internet. Bill, it's great to have you on as a first-time guest. I've been asking everybody about inflation. Janet says it is transitory. I think my favorite quote that I've heard so far is World War II was transitory.
What do you make of this transitory argument? Is inflation here to stay? Is this a secular phenomenon and what does it mean?
Bill Blain: Yeah, I'm rather of the opinion that inflation is not only here to stay, but the most significant thing that's going on is we have long-term inflation is now being imported into the real world from distorted financial assets.
Everybody tells me that there's no inflation out there and what we're seeing is just a transitory spike caused by supply chains breaking down and things like the chip shortage and people who were anticipating a fast recovery. But what we're really seeing is all the inflation that's been generated over the last 12 years of monetary experimentation, quantitative easing, and buying back bonds and keeping interest rates artificially low. That's generated tremendous inflation in financial assets.
And that financial asset inflation is now creeping into the real world. So you're going to see a whole series of effects, inflationary moves that occur as a result of that. Plus, I think we're also going into a very different world that is not going to be one where you can easily simply brush off inflation effects as transitory.
I mean, let's just think for one second about some real-world events that have just occurred, like All these climate disasters we've seen in the last month, they cause real costs. These costs have to be paid from somewhere, and that is going to be inflationary in its own right. So I think we really have moved into a new world where inflation is going to start really impacting bottom lines again.
Erik Townsend: Bill, you and I both know that nothing ever happens in a straight line in finance. And something I've been pondering is, boy, I really think as you do that this inflation is here to stay, but it's gone an awful ways, especially in asset assets like copper that have just been up so much since the bottom of the COVID crisis. And I've been thinking, boy, it's awfully late to be coming into a market like that with new money. Now, I had Darius Dale on last week. His perspective, he agrees with us on secular inflation, but he says all of his signals are saying, look, that disinflationary wave that wrong-foots investors, at least in the intermediate term, that's here now. And he's saying, get ready for some disinflation before the bigger picture inflation resumes. What do you think of that view? Should we be thinking that maybe it's gone a little too far?
And there's a pullback before this trend continues.
Bill Blain: Okay, well, that is a very interesting and intriguing perspective. And I think he's probably right because, you know, we've got effectively a deflationary environment that is caused by ultra-low interest rates. I was asked a question recently about what do you think about Europe keeping interest rates lower for longer? And I turned around and said, well, to answer that question, you need to understand what's happened to Japan. For 20 years, they've had ultra-low interest rates and what has been the effect? A deflationary economy. But we still have this inflationary backdrop to the global economy and you can't separate the two. Now, it's not necessarily a Japanese thing, but I think we are going to experience multiple different things going on.
And the big word that scares me more than any other is stagflation. Now, I grew up in the 1970s and '80s in the United Kingdom. Where we suffered incredible stagflation during the 1970s that caused all kinds of social problems where you had massive inflation and jobs collapsing. It didn't matter what you did to interest rates, you couldn't change that.
And so although we're talking about an inflationary threat, you also have this secondary effect that could be deflationary in certain markets. And I think copper is an interesting one to talk about there. Because we clearly saw copper prices getting bid up in anticipation of a very strong recovery to the pandemic. Everyone piled into copper expecting that copper as effectively a proxy for tech sales would work. Same thing happened in lumber because of course we saw the most incredible market in lumber. Again, people anticipating recovery.
And we will see inflation as a result of that. It's occurring at the moment in the shops. You try and buy a fridge and it's 10% higher because of the copper price spike, but copper's already down. What if we get a situation where you've got real inflation in prices, but you have a deflationary economy? That's a classic recipe for this stagflation threat.
Erik Townsend: Bill, you and I grew up in the '70s, but we were kids at the time. And frankly, the guys that were working in the industry and were around in the late '60s when the onset of secular inflation began. They're all retired. And one of the biggest things I think about is, okay, who's going to be in charge of rounding up all the guys that have been through this before when this secular inflation really hits the tape?
Where's the finance industry going to know what to do? Because I think everybody who knows is gone or retired.
Bill Blain: This is one of the things that really scares me because the reason we're in this environment at the moment is, is a game of consequences. Everything that happens, everything you do today will have a consequence tomorrow. And the big issue for central banks, for it is they we are talking about, central banks have been experimenting with monetary policy since the great financial crisis began in 2007. And in 2009, they came up with this brilliant idea that they could kickstart the economy with ultra-low interest rates and they would get money to flow into the economy by buying back bonds, which means that investors would sell their bonds and then use that money to invest in the real economy.
But that's not the way that trading works. We all know what investors did was, of course, they sold their bonds to central banks and then bought more bonds to sell to central banks, and they used money from that to buy yet more bonds to sell to central banks. And this is what caused massive inflation in financial assets. The path of that happening was very simple. Interest rates started to fall.
As a result, people saw that the yields on bonds were unsustainably low for their investment purposes. So they started going what we call yield tourism, and they started buying equity. And remember, equity is a much higher risk market. And they started buying so much equity, the equity market went up and dividend yields in equities also came down.
Now, that has been the consequence of ultra-low interest rates, massive inflation in financial assets. But here's the critical thing, that started 12 years ago.
Now, 12 years in financial markets is an incredibly long time. The result is there's practically nobody under the age of 35 in the city, in what we in the UK call the city, but the world calls global finance, who understands investment markets where it's not completely normal for central banks to be repressing interest rates and distorting yields through their monetary experimentation and quantitative easing.
So every single fund manager under the age of 35 thinks this is perfectly normal. And that's why when I'm out doing my job as an alternative asset investor, I see a great divide between those of us over 40 and those below 40 who've got completely different perspectives on what value propositions are. If you're younger, you tend to think that value is all about the price set by the market as in a distorted market. Whereas anybody over 40, we're tearing our hair out and we're going, what is going on here? How can we accept interest rates being so distorted? Look at the effects. Look at the overvaluations. Look at the crazy stories that are created. So that point you just made about where are all the old guys? Well, those of us who are who've been around the block a few times. And the first time I traded Treasury bonds back in, I think, 1986, I think we were talking then about the beginning of the big bull rally in bonds, where the year before traders were frightening me with stories about how yields had been 18%, and they were down in double digits still when I started trading.
And now where are we on the 10-year? 1.2% or something like that. This is a completely different world, and there are very few of us left
Erik Townsend: Yeah. When you get runaway inflation, and of course, a lot of people would say that's not even in the cards, the deflationary backdrop is just too strong, it's never going to happen. I don't claim to be smart enough to know when it's going to happen, but my argument is this. If we have runaway inflation, I think that suddenly, the central bankers' hands are tied, because all of a sudden, the norm, the new normal that you're talking about, which is, hey, whatever goes wrong, they're just going to print money and that's going to fix it.
Bill Blain: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: When you get runaway inflation, you're going to have a lot of people who are going to say, hey, we've got to print money.
inflation, you can't do that anymore. And if the central banker's hands are tied, I don't think the industry knows what to do. Am I crazy to think that? And how realistic is it that this eventually gets to a runaway inflation kind of scenario?
Bill Blain: You know, it's a very interesting question to ask. What instruments are there for actually controlling inflation? The typical way you would control inflation would be to let interest rates rise. But if you were to do that today, the effect would be a massive collapse in financial markets, which are now completely addicted to the opium of cheap money. So you would end up creating massive defaults, massive job losses, complete loss of confidence across the economy. But then how do you stem inflationary bursts going around? Well, you got to then think about what creates inflation.
And inflation is not just oil prices going up as happened in the 1970s. Inflation is not just a drought season putting up the price of bread. Inflation this time is going to be a mix of very real inflation coming in from events like I described earlier, some of the costs that we're going to have to bear now for extreme weather events, the wildfires in California, the flooding in Germany and China. China, all these things. But also we'll see inflation seeping in from financial assets. And the way that's happening, if you take a look at what hedge funds are doing today, hedge funds are not buying Treasury bonds and they've stopped bothering buying things like stocks and shares. They're now buying real assets. Just earlier today, I mean, the reason I'm up at Edinburgh, Scotland today is I'm visiting my And I went and did the shopping for her this morning in Morrisons. Morrisons, one of the big UK supermarket chains.
And you know what? It's just been acquired by a group of hedge funds because it's a real asset. And it's been acquired at an incredibly high price that nobody thought Morrisons was worth. No one else was going to bid that for it. But that's an example of inflation in the real world pushing up the price of real assets.
Now, eventually, that gets down to the penny in people's pockets. And that's when we really start to see inflation occur. That starts to change the way that people behave in an economy. And I think that's already beginning. You've seen some incredible moves in house prices in the USA and the UK. Now, the US housing market's just had a bit of a blip from the last numbers, but here in the UK, house prices are now completely outweighing wages.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Bill Blain: With the scale that normal people could think about buying. All they can do is go and rent. And that's another example of inflation because that means the money they were going to spend on buying a house, and now they can't ever afford a house, is just money they spend on consumption. And if people are consuming lots, well, guess what? That causes real inflation as well. And that's all driven by ultra-low interest rates.
Erik Townsend: Bill, as we're recording this interview on Tuesday afternoon, the news that seems to be hitting the tape hardest beyond the Delta strain of COVID which of course has been big news for several weeks, this week it seems to be China talks and China negotiations are really starting to spook markets. Let's start with what's going on, but then after that, I want to move on to the bigger picture of what's the relationship with China and the future of China going to mean to the macroeconomy?
Bill Blain: That's an absolutely fascinating question. I mean, if we talk just for one second about what's the relationship between the 2 big powers on the planet today, the USA and China? Well, people have described it, and I'm not sure if I'm going to pronounce this, as Thucydides Trap. Thucydides, and again apologies if I pronounced it wrong, was a famous Athenian politician who very quickly realized that war between Sparta and Athens was absolutely inevitable as Athens started to challenge Sparta's military dominance of the Greek city-states. The result at the end of the day was they destroyed themselves, and within a few years, Rome had conquered the whole of Greece. But there's a lot of people who do think that that's the way that we're going to see it play out between China and the USA. I'm not so sure myself. I'm not going to paint myself as a predictor of global events, but I think it's far more likely that 2 very clever nations will find a way to live together.
And that's what's causing the interest in financial markets at the moment. When we talk about the USA today, after the events of the COVID pandemic and the way in which government has stepped in, and this is not just the Biden Administration, but previously Trump's Administration, government has stepped in and supported the economy. With massive bailouts and provided cash where required to keep companies open. We have a right-wing government under Trump that acted in the most socialist way imaginable. In the UK, we currently have a Conservative government which has done exactly the same thing and done— pursued policies that put the socialist Labour Party and make them look extremely right-wing because they provided so much support for the economy.
In contrast, the Chinese government, a Communist Party has done very little. They've really held back on supporting the economy but encouraged the economy through capital availability. Now, it's pretty clear to me if I step back and look that both economies are effectively capitalist. At the bottom of the day, the success of the US is down to its entrepreneurship, its inventiveness, and its ability to innovate.
These inventions. The success of China is being able to create capitalism with Chinese characteristics, which we all take to mean means that they're not terribly innovative and they steal ideas from others. Well, you know, that may be or may not be true, but the fact is they've created a very effective economy very quickly.
And what we're seeing in the market just now is really games being played, people trying to understand where this is going to go in the future.
The Chinese economy is absolutely massive. We know that it's going to soon be the same size as the US economy, and that's a massive investment opportunity. But the Chinese government takes a very different view, which is why we're seeing them clamp down as they've done in the last few months. Just in the last few days, we've seen them declare that education companies, which we all saw saw as a massive opportunity to profit from the Chinese market have been told that they are no longer for-profit companies and they are there to serve the needs for the state. Well, to us that sounds— well, that's frightening. We've invested all the— this money in all these free companies which we expected would be able to harvest enormous returns from the Chinese population who are desperate to send their kids to cramming schools to make sure they get into universities.
But from the Chinese perspective, the Chinese realize that they have a whole series of regulatory and especially social problems to solve. And one of these is the success of the one-parent family rules that were introduced back in communist times. As a result, you could only have one child, which meant that the Chinese favored having sons who would keep the family name going and provide for the parents as they get older. But the result is China now faces an enormous demographic— well, actually, 2 demographic problems. The first is China is getting old before it gets rich. And the second is they have a massive imbalance between males and females. There are far more young males than there are young females. Now, don't ask me how that occurred, but it was a form of selection that we would not have tolerated in the West.
As a result, the Chinese have got to find ways of encouraging families to have more kids. And one of the ways they're going to do that is by removing the threat of ultra-high costs of educating your kids by making education free, and at the same time being able to tell the population that, hey, look what we've done for you— education is free, everyone has access.
So when you're looking at the divides between Chinese capitalism and Western capitalism, you've got to try and put it into some form of context and understand why it is they've done these things. So I've just explained the thing about education, clamping down on fintech as they did with Alipay, and the problems we're now seeing with Tencent. You can explain these in similar ways. It's about the Chinese Communist Party making sure they maintain their control and relevance But for those of us in the West, we've got to say, you know, sit back and look and say, can we afford to be not invested in this economy? Now, there's lots of reasons not to be invested in China from a sort of social and governance perspective. What they're doing in Hong Kong appalls us. What they're doing to the Uyghurs on the western fringes appalls us. Their surveillance capitalism is something that doesn't fit here.
But at the same time, there's lots of things we do that they don't like either. I suspect the future is we're going to find an accommodation for China, but it's a very difficult market unless you're really prepared to take the time to understand what's going on to try and invest in. I hope that all makes sense because I kind of galloped through about 400 different points in 400 seconds.
Erik Townsend: Longer term, some people seem to be very concerned that we have an escalating Cold War that could take us to a US China situation, which is very similar to the US-Soviet situation in the 1960s, say. Is it really that bad or are people just a little bit over-concerned?
Bill Blain: I think we actually face something that's very, very different this time. The Cold War with Soviet Russia was, on the Russian side, an awful lot of bluster. I actually studied Soviet economics when I was at university back in the early '80s. And there was an awful lot of bluster about the economic might of the USSR. Now, there clearly is economic and productive might in China, so that's a fundamental difference. It will really come down to which country innovates faster. But I think, as I said earlier, both countries are far more anxious to find an accommodation because I don't think that the— what's the right word— the basis between capitalism and Russian communism Which, you know, they were poles apart. But the difference between modern communism, Chinese communism, and Western capitalism, that's not so far apart. I think what we're going to find is that there will be an accommodation found.
Erik Townsend: Bill, coming back to the inflation theme, you know, a lot of people, myself included, have really looked at gold as an inflation hedge. Frankly, there is a counterargument, although I disagree with parts of it. You can't argue that gold has not performed as well as some of us thought it might, and cryptocurrency seems to be at least the younger generation's favored currency debasement and inflation hedge. Has gold become your grandfather's Oldsmobile, or is it more likely that the crypto guys just don't realize the risk they're taking?
Bill Blain: Yeah, that's a fascinating question. I think there is definitely a behavioral link between the, the way that people understand gold and what they think about cryptos. And that's maybe worth talking for a second. Let me come straight up and say that I think cryptos are a complete and utter scam.
I can see absolutely nothing that a cryptocurrency can do that currencies don't already do better and gold doesn't already do better. And, you know, it's, it's dead easy to say enjoy yourself by being poor, but there's no real fundamentals behind it. When the, the pandemic started and I immediately predicted a massive economic shock even before we started lockdowns, one of the first things I did was transfer a large portion of what I was doing into gold in the expectation that we would see gold not only as an inflation hedge because we expected supply chain disruptions, but also because I could see it being a flight to safety hedge as well. So I put cash into portfolio cash into gold and into Treasuries and UK gilts. That's the UK government bond market.
And I've been kind of surprised at the way that gold has not performed better because you've got 2 classic gold pluses going on, which is uncertainty and inflation.
But yet people haven't gone for gold. And I sort of look at the crypto thing and let's be honest, cryptos, for all the trillions they talk about being invested in Coinbase and all the other exchanges, that's still a fraction of the gold markets. Yet it has got people thinking, are there alternative ways to hedge? I thought it was very interesting that you mentioned your grandfather's Oldsmobile.
I mean, one of the things I collect is art, and unfortunately I've bought all the wrong things. They haven't gone up in the kind of way you want because you just don't know or understand how the fashion for what is going to become big in art is going to develop. And I suspect that's also slightly true of what's going on in crypto because there are so many different choices now.
Erik Townsend: Bill, you run alternative assets for Shard Capital. Now, from everything that you've said, I'm assuming that you're focusing more on real assets, not just gold, but other things like real estate and so forth. Real estate's not exactly cheap. It's hard to be a value investor and also focus on real assets right now.
Where's the value or where is the hedge if you want to be in the real asset market? It seems like nothing's cheap.
Bill Blain: Okay. Well, the real asset markets are absolutely fascinating because they really began in the wake of the great financial crisis that began in 2007. If you remember back then, what we saw was banks under enormous pressure and the regulators and central banks very quickly changing the rules on how banks could use their capital.
And effectively, over the next couple of years, we saw that banks stopped being lenders. Yep, that's what I said. Banks effectively were no longer lenders; they were simply brokers. And what would happen is the banks would go and originate an asset, and then they would find real money to invest in that asset to finance it.
And you saw a number of the big pension funds, insurance funds. And particularly smart hedge funds who saw the opportunities in private debt and private equity. And of course they went out and while you're getting 1% for investing in US Treasuries, you can be getting a very well-constructed risk in private debt yielding a proper interest rate, say 6%, 7%, and often much higher. So I now spend most of my— and I've spent my whole career in the bond market, market before I got involved in developing the private asset, private debt, and private equity markets as the alternative asset sector. And what we look for is assets that are going to create really attractive yields and are secured in these assets.
And some of them we've learned some frightening lessons about. Aircraft is a great one, for instance. Before the pandemic, we assumed that aircraft would retain their value for years. And you could predict exactly what they would be worth in a few months' time and a few years' time. Therefore, you could create secondary markets. Therefore, you could create valuations, and you can sell them based on the resale value and even the scrap value down the line. That's all come to a crashing halt. But other assets— and you mentioned property— property is a fascinating market, especially here in the United Kingdom. Where residential property has been on an upward curve since before America was even conceived. I mean, we're talking about 400 years of UK residential property history. And every time we have a crash, within 2 or 3 years, that crash will have been corrected and the market will be slowly edging back up.
But what we've seen in the last couple of years is again, people understanding that the returns that they get from distorted yields in the bond markets and other financial assets means that they need to buy real assets. And of course, property is the one they've gone for. So you've seen UK property not rising 2 or 3% per annum, but 9% was the number that we had yesterday.
You know, 9% per annum just means property is running out of the affordability level for most But it's a great asset for those that have ready cash, and that money is still piling in, meaning the price is getting higher and higher.
Now that has a number of knock-on effects. It means that there's much greater demand for rental property, which again spells demand for people to to buy rental properties, therefore pushing up the price again. But it also means that people give up trying to afford. That changes their behavior. If they can't afford to ever buy their own home, why bother working so hard? Why not just take the government furlough scheme or just throw yourself on welfare for the rest of your life?
So, you know, you got to be careful. All these distortions, the consequences I talked earlier about, they have long-term effects and they're changing the behavior of populations. So I think it's very significant when you see house prices accelerate beyond the reach of the bulk of the population.
And this would then lead us on to another of my favorite topics, which is the pernicious Effects of Wealth Inequality. And that's something that I don't think is given enough attention when you see the dearth of opportunities available to many people now and the fact that the world is increasingly becoming divided into haves and have-nots. Now, that may not sound terribly capitalist, But the history of Europe tells you that when people don't get good opportunities, they tend to get rebellious. And in France, they revolt.
Erik Townsend: Bill, I think wealth inequality is the biggest challenge that we face as a society. And what scares me the most is, I think everybody is talking about it. The problem is people who are talking the loudest about it have solutions that I don't think are really solutions. I don't think they really solve anything. I think they'll actually make it worse in the long run. But boy, they sell a heck of a lot better than my solutions do.
What do you make of this whole populism trend? And it seems to me, at least in the United States, like this whole MMT phenomenon is really gaining a lot of steam. There's a lot of political support. There's a lot of public support for more nanny state government handouts and so forth. And it seems like Stephanie Kelton and the MMT crowd have the solution for how we're going to print up all that money without having to tax anybody. And Spend a lot of money and don't worry, it's not going to be inflationary.
Bill Blain: Okay, well, look, the only way to answer that question is to look at the bond markets and understand exactly what sovereign bond markets are. By sovereign bond markets, I mean, let's keep it to the US and the UK. Both are sovereign nations and they have financial sovereignty over their money supply, or they have monetary sovereignty, let's put it that way. There is no way way that the UK issuing sterling gilts or the USA issuing dollar bonds is going to go bust.
Whatever happens, they can press the printing press and they will repay in dollars or sterling the debt that they've issued. That is the basic premise of New Monetary Theory, that you can go out and print as much money as you want.
The problem then lies in foreign exchange. And if people lose confidence in the USA, and not in its ability to repay, but they know it will repay, but if they lose confidence in the USA because they're concerned about the political situation or they're concerned that it's losing the war with China, whatever, then they're going to start selling dollars and that's going to be massively inflationary. Again, coming back to our early chat about inflation.
And that's the big risk for any monetary sovereign nation, that although they can always repay their debt, if they lose confidence in the currency, then they will face massive inflation, which damages the nation.
That's the simple equation. At the moment, every single nation in the world is involved in a massive money printing binge to afford the costs of the pandemic. That's happening everywhere in Europe, in Asia, China, USA, UK. Everyone's printing money. Latin America, everyone's printing money. When that stops, then people are going to start paying attention to which countries do you actually have confidence in. Now, what countries would you have confidence in? Would you have confidence in a country that is confident in itself in being able to continue printing money to support the growth of the economy? Or would you lend the money to an economy where the government has decided to embark on crushing austerity, where they're suddenly cutting the money that was supporting the economy, putting companies into bankruptcy, causing massive social tensions Now, the conventional wisdom is that any responsible government will avoid overspending. But in that example I've just quoted to you, it looks far better that the government continues to spend to even out the economy rather than creating an austerity situation, which is likely to fuel further wealth inequality.
Now, wealth inequality is very important because what we've seen over the last 12 years of monetary experimentation is very, very simple.
If you own financial assets, stocks and shares, you have got phenomenally richer because that's where all the inflation has been. And if you didn't own these things, you've got much, much poorer. And of course, financial assets are owned by the richest in society who have got far wealthier. And when you see that these people are the ones who tend to pay less of their total income in taxes, that causes massive resentment. Now, that is what's driving the populist agendas across the US and especially in Europe.
And funnily enough, although we have the same problems in the UK, we're electing right-wing governments. And the reason we're doing that is the sheer incompetence of the left. And, you know, sometimes despite being a Scotsman, which makes me naturally tending towards socialism, Sometimes I wish that would continue. But this threat of rising wealth inequality and more and more wealth being in the hands of fewer and fewer people who can afford to take all the economies, that is bound to create resentment. And that resentment will be far higher in any economy that tries to create confidence by embarking on austerity policies.
So it's not an easy thing to simply say invest in nations that look to be the ones that are most careful with their money and create confidence in their currency that way. You really need to be looking at the quality of government, which governments are actually handling the process best. Now, the simple version of MMT that we can go and spend as much money as we doesn't take that into account. And if it's going to work, it's going to have to. And it really goes back to the 1930s when we first talked about the ability of nations to reinflate through fiscal and monetary policy.
And I think it's going to be fascinating as we come out of the pandemic, which nations do it well and which do it badly. And it's not just about social spending. And this is, I think, is the big question for the USA. How is the USA going to make its economy fit for purpose for the future with the massive infrastructure spending? And that's infrastructure in physical goods, but also in goods like education to make the US fit for purpose for the next 100 years if you have political impasse. And I think it's that political impasse that's the biggest threat to the USA. in the coming decade.
Erik Townsend: I want to move on to another big trend in finance, which is ESG, or environmental, social, and corporate governance-based investing. The idea of the owners of capital taking responsibility to invest in a way that benefits society. Now, I want to go on record as saying that premise, I don't think there's anything more noble or, or better that I've ever heard in my life. So I'm all for the concept, but frankly, I think this whole ESG thing is a bunch of baloney. I think that what's going on here is, you know, it's very similar in my thinking to what we see in the whole race inequality thing. We absolutely do have a race inequality problem. We have racist issues still. It's amazing to me we still have racism. But you know what? Burning stuff down is not a way to solve racism. And it seems like ESG has got the same anger In terms of a lot of people just want to do things to damage oil companies rather than engaging in those extractive industries and figuring out how to invest in making them better and making them less damaging.
What do you make of this and where's it headed?
Bill Blain: Yeah, I'm, you know, as I've said earlier, I would probably count myself as the last living communist in the City of London in that being a Scotsman, I am slightly left-wing, but I do believe that this whole ESG nonsense is, to use a quaint Anglo-Saxon word, bollocks.
It's just absolutely incredible how it's taken over the way of thinking. Now, back when I began in the markets in the 1980s, everything that ESG did, we did anyway. If you think about it, good corporate governance was always one of the reasons that you invested in a company. You invested in companies because they were well run and did what they said. And you invested in companies because they added to the sum of human wealth by not only paying your dividends but made sure that they were going to be there next year to pay your dividends and pay your debt back. So that ticks the environmental box. And socially, you invested in companies that treated their workers well. Well and made sure that everyone had opportunities. And that's always been true in investment. You don't need to have a checklist to do it.
But as soon as you create a checklist, you turn that into bureaucracy. And the fastest way to slow anything down is to bureaucratize the process. And that's very much what's happened. Now, I want to just share an example of a recent deal that we've been trying to do here in the UK that illustrates where ESG has gone Now, at the moment, the UK is doing phenomenally well building wind farms, but each wind farm that you stick out in the Thames Estuary requires 500 tons of steel.
And to make that steel, the 500 tons of steel, you need something like 250 tons of metallurgical coal, which you burn with the iron ore to create steel. Now, at the moment in the UK, we import all our metallurgical coal from Australia, which costs massive carbon miles, and we import most of our steel from China, which again creates massive carbon miles. And all you're doing is all the pollution that we create for our steel that we use here in the UK, all that carbon is still being made in China. So all you're doing is changing the place. So one of our clients had a brilliant idea.
Some of the best quality metallurgical coal in the world is sitting in an area called Cumbria on the west coast of England. And it would be really cheap and easy to mine it and export it around Europe because the whole of Europe is saying, this is crazy. We shouldn't be importing metallurgical coal all the way from Australia.
Is there any we can use here? And we managed to do that. We got the concept in place. We got the planning in place. But then, of course, every single investor, including the UK's National Coal Board pension scheme, which pays the pensions of over 300,000 former miners, said, "Oh no, we don't want to do that. It doesn't fit with our non-carbon ESG policy." Tick box investment. Eventually, we did find investors. And at that stage, the government took fright because we're hosting a big environmental conference in the UK this year, COP26. And the governor in charge of that did not want to be associated with it if the UK was seen to be opening coal mines. Yeah, I agree that coal, we've got to get away from coal and we've got to build more renewable I completely buy climate change. And if there's anything we can do to ameliorate the fantastic costs that are coming, let's do it.
But one of the ways to do it is certainly to reduce carbon miles. But the result of this whole story I've just told you, the coal mine never got financed because the bureaucracy that ESG has created said no. And that to me is a massive failure of financial markets.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Bill, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview, but before I let you go, I want to ask you about what you do at Shard Capital. You're strategist and head of alternative assets. What is Shard Capital? We have primarily an institutional audience, but also for the benefit of our retail audience, and I guess the institutional as well, please also tell us about Blain's Morning Porridge.
Bill Blain: Okay. Right. Well, there's quite a lot of— there's quite a story to tell there. Shard Capital is a fascinating firm. Firm. We started off 12 years ago as a small brokerage business, which was moderately successful. And we took on some asset management businesses, which we are now focusing on and expanding. And for the benefit of your particular audience, I should mention a product that we have called LeafBridge.
Now, LeafBridge, which is named after Leif Erikson and the bridge across the Atlantic that occurs in the middle of Iceland, the Atlantic Gap, is a fund that we've specially set up for American expatriates working in Europe. It solves all your investment tax issues for you. So it's worth thinking about. But otherwise, we have funds that invest in the credit markets, funds that invest in disruptive technology. Yes, we do disruptive technology as well. We just don't lose as much money as some others do.
And Shard Capital has become very successful in these spaces. I was persuaded to come on a number of years ago because I knew most of the guys who were involved in it from a previous business I'd set up.
My own background, as I said, had been in credit markets. I'd been head of debt capital markets for financial institutions at Bear Stearns before joining HSBC and had then set off to try and set up a hedge fund just before the financial crisis began. And I found myself thinking this would be a mad time to invest in credit, but we quickly discovered that you could make loads of money broking credit. And the easiest thing to do was buy bonds and sell it back to the banks that issued it at a discount, creating them capital. And we used the proceeds from that trade to create a number of new businesses, which was very interesting. But I found the whole process of what was going on to be absolutely fascinating. And clients would ask, what do you think's happening? Knowing that I used to be a financial institutions banker. So I started writing a comment every morning and I was looking for a name for it.
I thought, well, I'm a Scotsman. I have porridge for breakfast every day and porridge is a very healthy breakfast. So I'll call it the Morning Porridge. And that's how it started. Started 12 years ago going to all my clients and now it goes to over 7,000 clients throughout Europe and the States.
Erik Townsend: Well, Bill, I can't thank you enough, and we look forward to getting you back on the show in the future for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value— cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. Escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales.
It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of Freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I've been looking forward to Bill coming onto the show, and he didn't disappoint. I thought his views were really interesting. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, he echoed a view that I've expressed before on MacroVoices, which is when we get to runaway inflation, and we're nowhere close to that yet, we're seeing what I think is the beginning of secular inflation. We haven't got to a runaway problematic inflation, but when we do, and I do think it's coming in the next few years, there's nobody who knows what to do. There's literally nobody in the industry that's, you know, hasn't retired yet, except maybe Charles Gave is still around, who I think was alive at that time, but he was beginning his career last time this happened. So there's a whole generation of professional finance people who don't understand inflation and have never had any experience with it, who are going to have to learn for the first time what to do when it starts happening. And I think it's a setup for a lot of real serious volatility in the markets when it comes. We're not there yet.
It's probably years off. Who knows, maybe it's only months off.
Erik Townsend: But what's right now, Patrick, is let's hit our postgame chart deck, which this week is titled Post-FOMC Moves in the Markets. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click on the red button that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, what do we have here on page 2?
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I just always want to start each week with, uh, the S&P 500 chart just to update the trend. And you know, we're always looking for where are the key turn points in the markets, but, uh, there's one thing that is very clear that's been going on all year on the S&P 500, which is every dip has been bought. These corrections on average last just a few days. They all find mean revert down towards, like, in this case, the 50-day moving average does a great job of capturing that, and we're continuously breaking to new highs, and there's absolutely no reason to see why this trend is at risk at this moment. And so really, at this stage, if the market follows its natural rhythm, we could certainly see advances toward 4,500 on the upside in the coming week or two. I was looking to see whether the FOMC meeting was going to be a catalyst that could potentially trigger some selling. We've seen that in the past, but, uh, at this stage it really does look like a trend has been established and there's no reason to believe immediately that it's reversing.
And so I think, uh, at this moment we have to respect this prevailing trend.
Now, Erik, what I don't have on here is the chart of the, uh, S&P 500 Equal Weight Index, which, uh, we have compared in the past. And it is worth noting that while I don't have the chart up here, that for the first time in months it has actually broken out to a fresh new high. And so one of the things that we've been talking about is the lack of market breadth and that we really needed to see the broader market start participating. And with the breakout of the equal weight, I asked the question as to whether or not that is what the market needed as a tailwind to make another bull advance. And so that's certainly on the radar for me to watch Let's move on to page 3 at the EUR/USD cross.
Erik Townsend: Boy, it sure seems like the FOMC put a floor on that one, huh?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, we were at a major support line and we were losing momentum moving toward that support line, so it really isn't a big surprise that, that we're getting a reaction. And even a very typical reflexive snapback rally would easily take us to one— this 119, 120 level where the euro is approaching. But the real information will come in the, in the coming week or two as to whether this was exactly that, just an oversold bounce, and then we'll have a resumption in trend, or whether this strong dollar, weak euro trend that's been in place for 2 months is over. And I, I don't think 1 or 2 days is enough to, to already draw conclusions. But we do know a major support line is held, and on the short term there might be a little bit more upside. But I think over the next week or two, this is a very important currency cross to watch to see whether or not this is establishing new trend or whether it was just an oversold bounce.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 4 and look at my favorite subject, which is commodities. Boy, there was a significant resistance line. Looks like we're seeing a breakout.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I thought— I think this is really interesting because we can, uh, we're looking at the Bloomberg Commodity Index futures. And what is interesting is, is that while oil is not making new highs, there's all sorts of commodities that are off of their highs. Whether it's copper, lumber, gold, you can take all of these commodities, even many of the grains, all pulling back. But yet the commodity index futures didn't get the memo, and they certainly are breaking 52-week highs and not looking back. You know, what is driving this commodity index? And, and more importantly, will we see a lot of these other commodities join the party? There was a really good breakout in copper, gold, and crude oil strengthening, and we'll talk— look at some of these charts right now, but it'll be really interesting to see whether this kind of 2-month pause in the commodity index futures that's been consolidating is over and whether or not a new bull trend resumes in this index.
Erik Townsend: Our regular listeners know my favorite commodity is crude oil, which we have on page 5. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I mean, I could ask you the same question. In the end, Erik, like, what is interesting is I just pointing out that that correction that happened here in July went and tested all of those previous highs back in, in March and May. And, uh, as it made that pullback, uh, what was and always is very interesting technical information is, is that when you have a correction, if the buy-on-dip traders immediately use that opportunity to buy it up and, and recover the price quickly to continue to show that that the primary trend that was in play is still in force. And so, so far the bulls have done a pretty good job recovering the price of oil, which in the back of my mind has me still thinking that the bulls may still have gas in the tank. What I think is the most important thing to watch is as we approach these previous highs, will the bulls be able to defend any selling pressure that comes there, and will they be able to break it out?
If If it does, though, there's a number of measured moves that target $80, $85 on the upside, which would certainly be a huge tailwind to the cyclical trades and potentially even a reflation trade coming back in if oil was able to do that. Don't want to already be saying that this is money in the bank, but boy, this is something to watch into next week.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, you know, I think that it really is going to come down to whether or not those prognostications of big inventory draws continue. continuing through American Labor Day, the one that happens in early September. If that holds true, I think we're going to at least 85. Of course, you never know. There could be some major news event, but barring something else, I think we're going much higher.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So what I wanted to though touch on was energy stocks. And what is interesting about this to me, Erik, is that while, look, okay, oil's right back toward its 52-week highs and you're not really getting a big edge on buying crude oil necessarily up here. But what is interesting is many of those energy stocks, uh, that were benefiting from oil's trend since November through to the 2nd quarter of the year have been in this multi-month correction. In this case, I have the XOP ETF, which is that SPDR Oil and Gas Exploration Production ETF. They went through a 20% correction on this index, and there are some refiners and other oil stocks that are down 30-plus percent during this correction. And if oil was to break out to fresh new highs, it would be really interesting to ask the question as to whether these energy companies also establish lows and begin trending along with the commodity. Because here you're able to buy the dip at a much more favorable level than chasing oil higher.
And I'll be watching to see whether these energy companies start to, uh, to get the tailwind benefit if oil make that breakout.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, it's going to be very interesting because the Biden administration is not exactly a friend to the oil and gas industry. So although I think oil prices are going higher, how profitable oil and gas companies are going to be is really going to
Erik Townsend: depend on the regulatory environment. Let's move on in any case, though, to gold futures. Boy, we're right on the line there, just flirting with that 200-day moving average.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, Erik. So I put on the simple moving averages because that's the ones you were referencing at the start in the market wrap. And we're actually at a really interesting moment. Like, first of all, the velocity of the breakout is relevant because we basically in one day were able to beat the last 2 weeks of trade range, which in itself is showing that, uh, there's some very motivated buying coming in this morning. And we're approaching a very key level for the breakout because when you look at almost all bull trends that have established on gold, they've done it above those moving averages. And we're really about to get the, the valuable information as to whether or not the sell-off that's more or less been— well, I mean, you could argue that the sell-off started back in the summer of last year, which spent most of the time below that 50-day moving average.
But if we get above these moving averages into the next week or two, be really interesting to see whether gold finally begins trending higher and whether this is finally the beginning of a gold move that we've been waiting for for a Well, the question too is going to be what happens to the gold miners if gold moves higher.
Erik Townsend: Let's take a look at page 8 and see what's going on with the GDX.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, similarly, you've had consolidations in the miners, and in, in similar fashion, they didn't make lower lows than those February-March lows, and we're getting a nice breakout attempt on the upside of the gold miners. It will be really interesting to see whether all of this comes in. This is a very interesting moment for this move to start happening altogether, and, uh, all of them are breaking out. One day doesn't make a new trend, so I don't want to already come out and say that this is guaranteed to move, but, but, uh, this is how a lot of new trends begin. And so one of the key things to watch into next week is going to be whether or not gold and the gold miners and silver and all of those precious metals start to come to life, particularly since we're seeing real yield yields, you know, getting even more negative, which is typically a tailwind for the gold markets.
And so anyway, that is what we got to watch for next week.
Erik Townsend: Folks, you can get Patrick's ChartTechs every single day with a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading. Information's on page 9 or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: You're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a Mark Spitznagel article, At What Price Does Safety Come for Investors? And a Jeffrey Snider article, leading out from Japan. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. And for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend.
That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. Bag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Darius Dale — 42Macro founder and CEO (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 281 was recorded July 22nd, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow. 42Macro founder and CEO Darius Dale joins me as this week's feature interview guest. When we booked Darius for today's interview, he was firmly in the inflation camp, but he just crossed over to the dark side of the Force, and his models now predict disinflation in coming months. But longer term, Darius is still a secular inflationist. We'll cover inflation, deflation, and much more in today's interview. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck is titled Summer Doldrums.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's talk the S&P 500. We had a drop between Friday to Monday of about 150 S&P points. It seemed like the sky was falling. And, well, we're almost right back to the highs. What's going on in your mind?
Erik Townsend: You know, I think that a lot of this was driven by increasing concern about the Delta variant of the coronavirus. And, you know, frankly, we told you on MacroVoices like a year ago, if not more than a year ago, The story here is everybody was just so preoccupied with when are they going to be the vaccines, because the vaccines will solve everything. This is an RNA virus similar to the common flu. That means that it mutates very easily, and the vaccine has to be changed and updated constantly in order to keep up with all those mutations. And it's not as easy as other types of vaccines. So it was never intelligent to expect any outcome other than exactly what we have, which is the realization that, okay, there's going to be new strains. Some of them may be resistant to the vaccines and so forth.
Now, I think that there was a little bit of panic over that, but frankly, I think it was misplaced because the public sentiment is very much toward reopening the economy regardless of the health risks. And I think what we saw in both the stock market and in commodity markets was this panic of, oh my gosh, it looks like coronavirus is really going to get worse. The pandemic's not ending like everybody thought. But wait a minute, you know, we still are going to open the economy. So maybe this sell-off was, was not meant to be. That's the way I'm interpreting it. I think we're headed back to fresh all-time highs. We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because every time the dollar seems to have at least a small intraday drop, it seems to crawl right back to the highs. And there's a bit of an uptrend, at least over the last month or more, at least since June. Do you think that can continue on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the key in my mind is a closing print over 93.50 on the dollar index. We haven't seen that. So as far as I'm concerned, we're right at resistance levels, challenging them. And about to see what happens. Maybe we're going to have another reversal here and continue this consolidation. But a sustained move above 93.5, now that would suggest at least a pattern of higher highs and higher lows and maybe the beginning of a serious uptrend.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because while volatility is back, the whipsaw to the downside and to the upside is pretty violent right here. What's your take on oil and how did the inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: Oh boy. You know, the numbers I'm looking at are margin numbers. CME Group has almost doubled margins on some crude oil positions. And I think, frankly, they do They do this in response to volatility because they think they're making the world a safer place. I think they add volatility by forcing people to reposition when they change the margin rules. So what caused this panic sell-off, the just dramatic sell-off? 2 things, really. OPEC+ making a deal and then the COVID Delta variant situation. OPEC+ has been a really interesting story for the last several weeks. We've heard narratives that say if OPEC+ makes a deal, That means it can only be bearish. And we've heard them say if they don't make a deal, that's even more bearish. Well, that doesn't really make sense, does it? It seemed like there was just a sentiment in the market that, you know, when OPEC+ made a deal, they were going to increase production. The sky was falling. Everybody's freaking out about the Delta variant.
We got all the way down to the 100-day moving average, which I bought very aggressively. And it looks to me like we're well on the way to what I think will be a full correction and new highs. I still think over $80 on front month WTI before Labor Day. That's American Labor Day, the one in September. As far as EIA inventory, it was a surprise this week with a build on crude oil inventories of 2.1 million barrels. Of course, we were expecting another big drawdown. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 1.3 million barrels. Gasoline drawing down 121,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 1.3 million barrels. But still, even with that big distillate drawdown, net, the overall petroleum product, including both crude and finished products, was a net build, which nobody expected. Now, you'd think that would be very bearish, but the market barely even flinched and just moved higher. So I think we've had the realization that, wait a minute, OPEC's not falling apart.
The action of OPEC is not massively bearish. It's actually bullish for the market. And I think we're going to see a full recovery. But, you know, the reason I think we see a full recovery and prices up above $80 by Labor Day is because specifically I'm expecting a lot more big drawdowns on inventory. This week, maybe it was an anomaly, maybe it's a new trend. One print doesn't make a new trend, but we got to watch it carefully. Meanwhile, US production ticking up to 11.4 million barrels. That's up 100,000 barrels from last year. So the predictions of some analysts that we were going to see a big drop-off in US production this year, well, might still happen this year, but it's not going to happen before the end of summer driving season, which is where the real squeeze has been. So it seems like That didn't actually end up happening.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because basically we remain very trade range-bound. While we've seen substantial volatility in oil and the markets, gold seems to really be crawling around and no move of any conviction. When do you think gold's gonna wake up and which direction do you think it's gonna go?
Erik Townsend: I can't tell you which direction, but when it's gonna wake up is fairly soon. And the reason is you don't see it on the chart unless you put all the moving averages in. But what's really going on here is we're trading it back and forth with support on the short-term moving averages. And resistance on the long-term moving averages, particularly the 34-day moving average has been the one that has acted as resistance, and the 21 is acting as support. Now they're converging, they're about to cross. It's just like a, you know, a triangle pattern on a chart. It has to resolve one way or the other in the next week. I'm leaning towards up, but I don't know if it's gonna resolve down. Potentially we, we could be looking at another big wave. If I look at the stochastics already on the low side, says to me we got a few more days and hopefully we see a breakout, but we need above 1840 to really persuade me that— and that's a sustained move above 1840— to persuade me that the bull trend is back on again.
Patrick Ceresna: All right.
Patrick Ceresna: And let's wrap up with touching on this 10-year Treasury yield, because bonds continue to rally and yields continue to decline. I mean, we were well under 1.20 earlier at the start of the week. I mean, we've now rebounded. We're trading at the time of recording around 1.26. What's your take here on Treasury yields? You think the bond rally can continue?
Erik Townsend: Well, even back up to 1.26%, that's well below 1.34%, which we talked about last week as being a potential resistance level in price or support level in yield. And that didn't happen. So it seems like that's not going to be a technical level that's going to slow down this trend of lower bond yields. And I think that basically we had a big scare over the amount of money that the Biden Administration was going to spend. And just as we predicted on MacroVoices, once people really thought that through and figured out that, wait a minute, the Fed's going to monetize most to this anyway.
I think we're back down to calming down again. So the market, unless we get another move up above 1.7%, I think we're going to see a fairly docile and not too interesting bond market in the next few weeks.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is 42Macro founder, Darius Dale. Now, Erik, why did we invite Darius back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Darius is a really smart macro guy and he's a model-driven guy. And what I find most interesting about this whole macro situation that we face is, you know, I'm really convinced of my secular inflation view, but it kind of feels to me like it's gone too far too fast. And boy, I don't want to add to that reflation or inflation trade at these lofty levels because it just feels to me like maybe it's time for a pullback. I think, as you'll see in this interview, Darius has got a much more objective and data-driven view in which he's going to say basically, yeah, you know, he's still a secular inflationist, but not for the next year or so.
So I'll leave— I don't want to steal his thunder. Let's leave the rest for the interview with Darius.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Darius is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy is live now at smartermarketspod.com, and you can look for another terrific interview every Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Darius Dale, founder and CEO of 42Macro. Darius prepared an extremely complete chart deck for today's interview. I strongly recommend that you download it. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to the homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says, looking for the downloads. We're going to be referring to the slides in that deck. We're not going to have time for all of them, but I encourage you to go through all of them at your leisure because it's a really great deck. Darius, I want to start with a story which, you know, when we booked you for this, we said, listen, buddy, we're really looking for a deflationist because we've had so many secular inflationists, including myself.
We want to offset that with an opposing view.
Darius Dale: Right. Sorry, I'm a model-driven guy and my model says inflation.
Erik Townsend: Then something changed because I got an email from you just a couple hours before we did this interview on Tuesday morning, and you said you might get your deflationist after all. What did you mean?
Darius Dale: Hey, thanks, Erik. It's great to be back. Uh, so in terms of what changed, uh, we run this dynamic factor model that we use to nowcast what we call the dominant market regime, or what we believe, or how we believe investors should be orienting their risk management exposure. As we show on slides 6 through 13, that system, and it's born out of 42 market indicators that we're scoring through the lens of our volatility-adjusted momentum signaling process, that system finally tipped in favor of deflation as of this morning, Tuesday, July 20th.
Erik Townsend: Now, is that something that, you know, tips back and forth every couple of days, or is this something that tends to only give you a signal every, you know, few years or so?
Darius Dale: Yeah, no, that's a great question. So it pretty much lines up with the rate of change cycle for growth and inflation. So taking a step back, you know, looking at the slide deck on slide 3, we outline the sort of regime segmentation process that we use to measure and map the bottom-up macro regime cycle. And we're looking at this through the lens of the trending rate of change of growth, which we measure through the OECD CLI indexes. And we're looking at this through the trending rate of change of headline CPI. And so ultimately, in terms of how often the system signals a change in the state of the markets, which we believe are ultimately just pricing in those trending rates of change of growth and inflation, that happens 2.5 times per year where you really get a meaningful shift in that system. So a couple of times a year, on average 2 to 3 times a year, investors really do have to reorient their risk management posturing, i.e., what they're buying dips in, what they're selling rips in, how much cash do they have, how much You know, leverage and credit risk, or they're taking it in and across the portfolio.
So we got that signal this morning, and, you know, who knows how persistent it's likely to be, but I can make a case, a very strong case, that it's likely to be persistent for at least a few months.
Erik Townsend: Now, on page 3, it appears that this whole slide here is telling me I want to choose which one of these 4 possible places I am on your grid. So we just said we moved from increasing inflation to decreasing inflation, so we must be on the left half. Are we on the top or the bottom? Because I don't know how you're measuring the trend in growth, whether it's still accelerating or not, or how do you measure that?
Darius Dale: Yeah, actually a better slide to see that would actually be slide 25. So this is showing our United States grid outlook through the lens of that regime segmentation system. And as you can see, we've been in a state of trending acceleration from an economic growth perspective since going all the way back to July of 2020. In fact, the economy bottomed in April of 2020, but it wasn't until July that we actually started to record a trending acceleration. Our model has that trending acceleration projected to culminate in August next month, followed by a sequence of 6 to 7 deflationary months from the perspective of this model. Now, when I say deflation, I don't mean outright year-over-year price declines. It's really just a nomenclature associated with the confluence of trending deceleration in both growth and inflation.
Erik Townsend: Okay. Now, I just have to, you know, when I look at a chart like this, boy, we went to, it seems like the center of the chart where these 2 axes intersect is kind of the the mean. What a huge deviation there was out to— it looks like May of '21 was kind of where we got to almost the extreme of your scale there on the right-hand side. What does that mean? Why was there such a deviation? And, and was that a trend reversal, or how do we interpret that?
Darius Dale: Great question, Erik. Uh, so the x-axis shows the trending acceleration or deceleration in inflation. And so being that positively skewed on the chart to the right side Obviously implies there was a meaningful acceleration in inflation. It's actually easier to see in time series format on slide 28, where we show the secular view on U.S. inflation, and then we zoom in to show the cyclical view on U.S. inflation. And sort of there's two key takeaways I'd make on this chart: one, we've clearly broken out of the post-crisis era sort of secular in terms of the stationary mean of inflation. We're significantly higher than that. We're obviously higher than most economists' expectations, at least heading into the last few months. And the second point I'd like to make is that our models— and we run 2 models simultaneously. One's called our stationary mean reversion model. It obviously implies stationary mean reversion is the framework. And then we run a second model called our agent-based nowcast model.
And then we split the difference between the 2 to formulate the basis of our growth and inflation projections. As you can see from the chart on the right, we have inflation decelerating or disinflating really starting in July throughout the balance of our projection period. which extends all the way into the middle of next year.
Erik Townsend: Now, obviously you could have a little blip down that wouldn't mean anything, but you're interpreting this as a trend change. What do you use in order to measure that? Is it like a trend following moving average thing, or how do you decide when there's actually been a reversal of direction in the movement of these charts?
Darius Dale: Yeah, so I mean, it's a confluence of cyclical momentum, sequential momentum, and the associated buildup or dissipation therein. And it's also a confluence of the mean reversion towards that stationary mean. Now, I will say this about the time series. I have a belief, as you can consider me a longer-term inflationist, I'm a shorter-term disinflationist, but I do believe the stationary mean of the US inflation time series broadly, core PCE, headline inflation, core inflation, things of that nature, have transposed themselves higher relative to where they were in the post-crisis era. If you look at headline CPI, for example, The stationary mean of that time series, really from '09 or really started 2010 up until you know the end of 2019, was somewhere around 1.5%.
If you look at the chart on the right again on slide 28, in terms of where we're likely to bottom in the middle of next year on inflation, it's very likely that we start to reaccelerate in the back half of 2022 from an inflation perspective. But we're going to be reaccelerating from levels that are much higher than we start. You traditionally would start to reaccelerate from. I mean, it implies a stationary mean of about 3% now for US headline CPI relative to a stationary mean of about 1.5% in the post-crisis era. So that's a big deal longer term. I just don't know that investors have to price that in today.
Erik Townsend: Now, I want to make sure I'm understanding this because it really resonated for me, but I could be grasping at straws here and trying to put my own view on this. I personally am very much a secular inflation guy long term, and I'm not smart enough to figure out short term. I think what you're telling me is We just had the first wave of the secular inflation, which I expect to take a full decade to play out, if not more. You're saying it looks like that first wave is ending, but it sounds to me like you're also saying you see the second wave coming just like I do. Did I get that right?
Darius Dale: You nailed that, Erik. Thank you for understanding that. It's really about the sequence of events. I think a lot of investors are brilliant and they really focus on the destination or the outcome. And I do believe that's important if you're a long-term strategic asset allocator. However, if you're like most of us who, you know, eat food and breathe air and go to sleep, we have to worry about the sequence along the way because the sequence is obviously ultimately where our P&L is derived from. And in terms of getting to that second wave of inflation, it's very likely that we have to actually work through a meaningful acceleration in base effects. and a meaningful deceleration in economic activity, you know, between sort of, let's call it September of this year, October of this year, and really all the way through the middle of next year.
Erik Townsend: So on page 25, obviously some of these plot points that you're showing are in the future. So they're projections, not, not current data. And you go all the way out to June of '22. So it sounds like if I'm a secular inflation guy, you're telling me that probably through the middle of '22, I'm going to be having opportunities to get that second chance to buy copper and other things that would have been inflation hedge trades, whether have just gone too far too fast to be getting on them now. Does that make sense? And how else should I, as a secular inflationist, be thinking about the opportunity? If you're right in this model, you're basically saying, I got a second chance to get in at the bottom before the next inflation runs away, and I probably got plenty of time to take action. Is that the way I should interpret this? Or how do you advise your clients in terms of what they do with this information if they have a long-term secular inflation view?
Yeah.
Darius Dale: Yeah, I mean, for starters. I mean, so whenever you talk about going into a deflation market regime, again, we highlight the market regime signals, probabilities, and the dominant market regime on slides 11, 12, and 13. Whenever you go into a deflation market regime, it obviously sort of implies that investors should be taking down their risk to cyclical assets. At 42Macro, we call that high-grading your exposure. So within the equity market, you're You're getting into more size, you're decreasing the earnings volatility of the types of stocks you buy in, you're downshifting your beta.
In the credit markets, you're obviously sort of going up the capital structure and in on the credit spectrum and obviously buying duration, allocating duration, allocating to gold, allocating to the dollar, the yen, the Swiss franc. So that's sort of your traditional deflation playbook. Now, obviously, if you're a secular inflationist, as I tend to be, just going back to our stationary mean reversion discussion, You know, that means a lot of the stuff that you believe in longer term is likely to sell off and/or experience a trending bout of volatility.
So you can buy put exposure against that, although I would argue that's— that view has been— is widely shared by most market participants. If you look at slide 23, what we show on that slide on the left chart is the relationship between sort of the near-term at-the-money put implied volatility versus the near-term realized volatility regime or the local volatility regime. And across the board for most sectors, style factors, commodities, and sort of major macro exposures, there's just a tremendous amount of put premium out there in the market today. So either one of two things has to happen. The market has to go down a lot to realize all that put premium, or the market has to melt up because dealers have to cover those hedges if we don't actually see that realized volatility. Obviously, the transition to deflation from a market regime perspective implies that the probability of realizing all that volatility is much higher than than it was prior to today.
Erik Townsend: Darius, I'm feeling this confluence of different factors because on the one hand, you're a model-driven guy. You're telling me your model, your signals are telling you very clearly we're headed into a deflationary or disinflationary regime. But you're also telling me that you're a long-term secular inflation kind of guy, despite the fact your model says the opposite in the shorter term. So why do you think that in the longer term? I mean, I've got my reasons, but I'd like to hear yours. And how do you navigate this when your model is telling you, at least for now, That long-term view is not ready to happen yet.
Darius Dale: Yeah, that's a great question. So for starters, I do believe that we are well on the path towards realizing that long-term view. However, the path is not going to be linear and we have to deal with decelerating economic activity, decelerating inflation, you know, for at least a year until getting to that second wave that we discussed. You know, so as it relates to what, from my perspective, what drives asset markets from a longer-term, you know, headwind or tailwind perspective, I think there's 4 main secular forces in the economy that investors either have to risk manage or they're being forced to risk manage.
Number one, I think, or this is no particular order, but number one, that's demographics. That's on slide 34. We look at that through the lens of the 5-year old age dependency ratio relative to the working age population, that 5-year forward CAGR. So demographics are still where they are. That hasn't changed. So that's disinflationary. On slide 35, we show the balance of payments risk. On the x-axis, we show the current account balance as a percent of GDP.
On the y-axis, we show the sovereign fiscal balance as a percent of GDP. So as you can see where the US dot is all the way down there to the left, we have a lot of secular pressure on the dollar. It's a major headwind to the US dollar from a flows perspective. So that's something that we certainly think needs to be ironed out. And more importantly, I think the real key takeaway from this slide, and not to make your listeners jump around, I think that the most important takeaway from this slide is that somebody's got to finance these budget balances.
Whether it comes from foreign demand, you know, in terms of, you know, the dollar recycling that we demonstrate on slide 54. Again, making your listeners jump around. On slide 54, we show sort of the trend in dollar recycling in terms of foreign central bank assets relative to Treasuries, relative to US debt. That's obviously been straight down and to the right for an extended period of time. So that means the Fed really has to step in. If you look at slide 55, to incrementally finance all that public debt. Now, the issue with that, if you jump again to slide 57, you know, the issue with that is it doesn't seem like this Federal Reserve has really sort of bought into the MMT, you know, really transitioned to MMT. And part of the reason, obviously, is we haven't seen a tremendous amount of turnover on the FOMC.
But I also think the cyclical inflation pressure is really spooking some of the Fed officials that would otherwise be on board with such a transition. And the reason I bring that up is because when you look at Terminal Fed funds rate expectations through the lens of five-year, five-year forward overnight index swap spreads. You know those have plummeted since the end of March.
I mean we're talking about down a full percent, and to me that move down a full percent is really you know, and it obviously accelerated post the June FOMC. I think that is really indicative of the market saying, "Oh no wait, this is still kind of the same Fed that we're used to," right? It's obviously a little different. $120 billion of bonds a month with GDP growing, you know, 10%. You know, annualized. That's that's obviously a little bit different than what we saw in the post-crisis era. But in terms of their willingness to really take the cap off long-term inflation expectations and really allowing those to seep into the real economy, they haven't changed. And that's what they signal to investors with their hawkish dot plot revision going back into the middle of June. So this likely means that we're going to have this start-stop process. If you go back one slide to slide 56, we're going to have the stop-start process in terms of how do we finance these budget deficits.
So that brings me back to my point at the beginning of this. You know, the Treasury market sits atop the global capital structure. You know, who's going to finance all these budget deficits? Well, either the Fed's got to do it by accelerating its balance sheet purchases or at the bare minimum not tapering, or it has to crowd out the private sector and crowding out equity issuance, crowding out corporate debt issuance, crowding out, you know, speculation in other assets just so that you could sort of feed the beast, if you will.
Erik Townsend: Darius, I'd love to understand your perspective longer term because the way I see this is, you know, you just said looks like the MMT crowd has not taken over the government yet. I agree. They haven't yet, yet, with an underscore on yet. The way I read the politics, I think it's coming. And I think that we're headed toward a situation where younger generations are really going to push back on the boomer generation and say, look, we don't like your systems and your rules and we're changing the game. So, you know, that doesn't happen overnight. I really see that's where it's headed. Am I on the same page as you are? Do you see this differently? What's your long-term view?
Darius Dale: Yeah, no. So if I, if I have one long-term view, um, it's really born out of, you know, some awesome work, you know, by guys like Neil Howe with The Fourth Turning, Peter Turchin, you know, author of Ages of Discord, in terms of sort of the, the historical political response to these types of setups in, in the economy and in society. Um, if you look at slide 37, so, you know, rounding out the secular drivers that really impact asset markets, on slide 36 is the leverage cycle, which we look at, you know, historically, through the lens of private non-financial sector credit to GDP on a 3-year z-score basis, and also through the lens of the private non-financial sector debt service ratio on a 3-year z-score basis.
That's a mouthful, but the key takeaway when you just glance at this slide is that, you know, a lot of economies, including the United States of America, have really levered up to combat this cycle from a private non-financial sector credit perspective. So that implies that we're going to have a real tough time sustaining an economic expansion In the absence of a tremendous amount of incremental stimulus, and I think we're going to find that out. And maybe Biden is aware of this. I doubt it. But certainly, it seems in terms of the panic that they're you know perpetuating out of that side of the aisle in D.C., it seems to suggest that they're well aware that they got to do more to keep this game going.
And that brings me to my final secular driver, which I think is the most most relevant one to the discussion between secular inflation and secular deflation. On slide 37 here, we just show the x-axis, the Gini coefficient. Your listeners will know what that is. Is as a measure of income inequality. Higher is more unequal. And then the y-axis, we show the headline unemployment rate. Well, if you can just see where the US dot is, is north of 40 on the Gini and right around 6 on the unemployment rate, we're sort of hanging out with emerging market economies now. We're no longer down at the bottom left of this chart, which is where you would expect to be as one, as a major superpower, but certainly as a developed market economy in today's setup. So the fact that our dot is there, in my opinion, is really perpetuating a lot of the zeitgeist that you see out there from both sides of the aisle in terms of, hey, we're getting a raw deal.
Hey, we're getting screwed. I mean, you had protests in the street last summer and they had protests in the Capitol from the other side of the aisle this winter. I mean, there's a clear amount of anger and frustration out there in the US society.
And part of it, in my opinion, is driven by, on slide 38, the breakdown in the social contract. And so what I'm showing here on slide 38 is the blue line shows employee compensation as a percent of gross value added. The red line shows corporate profits as a percent of nominal GDP. And as you can see, just in terms of where those lines, those respective plots had trended, you know, really for 50, 60 years prior to 2000, you know, we've really turned that on its head in the last couple of decades. And obviously we've got some pretty key drivers of that transition. You got globalization, you know, China joining the WTO in 2001. You've obviously had the proliferation of the internet and the digital economy and all the disinflation that's brought. Relative to wages, and then you've also had a lot of industry consolidation born out of you know the private equity bubble. And so you know there's a lot of people out there that feel angry and frustrated, and I think they are aware of that transition.
And this is my opinion why we're seeing such bipartisan support for trillion-dollar budget deficits. Obviously, going back to Trump, you know he proved that this sort of concept of fiscal conservatism in the U.S., particularly born out of you know the right side of the political spectrum. Was really dying, and part of the reason it was dying is because you know I think we poor people from the left really migrated to the right because at the end of the day it wasn't really about you know Republicans versus Democrats; it was about populists versus austeritists. Or if I'm even I'm not sure if I'm saying that word correct, but I think people know what I mean. Were you going to be austere? You're going to be populist, and I think that's the real big transition in the economy.
So you have that from a political perspective, but then you also have on slide forty a lot of the secular drivers of disinflation are still intact. You know, the labor force participation rate is still obviously hampered by demographics. The velocity of money is still on its lows relative to a 30, 40, 50-year time series. And then on slide 41, you know, corporate America continues to be dominated by monopsonies and a broad-based preference for capital expenditures over labor. The blue line shows the market cap of the S&P 100 relative to the S&P 500. That's up and to the right. The red line shows the compensation of employees relative to CapEx, and that's down and to the right.
So a lot of these drivers are still intact, but ultimately in terms of how we think it resolves itself, we ultimately think that the 2020 election was no fluke. We're certainly moving in a direction where populism is not only sort of welcome, but it's cheered on by both sides of the aisle. And I think Mitch McConnell's going to have a tough time next fall if he doesn't understand that.
Erik Townsend: Darius, that covers the inflation view. Let's bring it to monetary policy. What's going to happen? Because in theory, The way this is supposed to work is when we get inflation, central bankers respond by increasing interest rates. Seems to me it really is different this time in the sense that they're really not able to increase interest rates the way Paul Volcker did in the '80s because they just don't have room without bankrupting the federal government through its borrowing costs. So I feel like we've got this inflation trap that we're setting central bankers up for where they're going to get to the point where their hands are tied and they say, uh-oh, we can't do— we just can't print money to solve this problem because that exacerbates the inflation and they're screwed. Am I right to think there's a trap there? And what do you think is coming in terms of central bank policy?
Darius Dale: Yeah, no, that's a great question. And this is part of the— from my view, I think you hit the nail on the head in terms of why that trap is maybe why our market regime signaling process is transitioning to deflation. I think asset markets are starting to figure out that if they did have a sniffle as a function of the Delta variant, as a function of decelerating growth and inflation, as a function of any sort of headwinds on fiscal policy and incremental fiscal stimulus, that the Fed can't necessarily step in and accelerate its pace of purchases. In fact, it might actually have to be sort of stepping into a tapering process, you know, into and during a market decline, which is obviously extremely anomalous relative to sort of how Fed policy, the reaction function has historically worked. So in terms of that, you know, kind of ironing that all out, Jumping to slide 44, there's obviously—
Erik Townsend: Hang on one second before we move on. I want to go back to that because wait a minute, you are saying that you think the Fed would actually taper into a market decline? Because I, I, at the risk of being cynical, I, I feel like for the last few years, if there's anything we've proven, it's that the Fed will basically do anything to bail the market out. I don't think that's just or right or the way it should be, but it seems like it's the way it is. Why would you think it would be different now?
Darius Dale: No, I actually don't think it'll be different, but I think, I think the, the markets need to find that out. And that, that to me is the scary part about, you know, from the perspective of investor consensus, that's the scary part about having a 5-handle on inflation is we don't actually know. And more importantly, we don't actually know what to look for in terms of the Fed's new mandates. I mean, they obviously have a new average inflation targeting mandate. They have a new sort of maximum and inclusive, you know, emphasis on inclusive employment mandate. And so the reality is I don't think the average investor, myself included, really understands You know, what does it take to actually achieve and accomplish those mandates? And quite frankly, I think Powell's done a masterful job of explaining to investors and policymakers that, hey, we don't know either. We're kind of, you know, kind of feeling our way out on this as well.
So ultimately, I just think that asset markets, if we're going into a regime where investors are going to start to receive broad signals from both economic data and other market participants that we should have a risk-off tone and discipline, To our risk management.
I think that there's a risk that feeds upon itself for at least a couple of months because again, we're not going to see a Federal Reserve that's going to be brazen enough at the early onset of that downturn, that market volatility to say, hey, no, we got your back. We're going to hold your hand. And that to me is potentially a big deal for asset markets, at least in terms of the next 2 to 3 months.
Erik Townsend: Thanks for clarifying that, Darius. I think you were talking about cyclical forces in the economy before I interrupted you.
Darius Dale: Yeah, of course. So, you know, just a few charts in that, you know, on slide 42. This is something I have a firm belief in, is that, you know, one, we already have, you know, lower highs and lower lows and economic surprise indices. And obviously, you know, going back to Friday's University of Michigan Consumer Confidence Report, you know, that was kind of the most recent in a series of sort of negative economic surprises. And I certainly think that's something that has the potential to persist throughout the back half of the year. Yeah. If you look at slide 43, we have growth expectations meaningfully elevated. We're still tracking at 6.6% for '21 and then 4.2%. We actually ticked up most recent data point for 2022. Well, the problem with those expectations being as elevated as they are in the confluence of a simultaneous deceleration in growth and inflation, it means that investor consensus, and what I mean by that, or sorry, not investor consensus, economist consensus and analyst consensus is very unlikely to take their numbers down, you know, sort of by a meaningful enough degree to have a real reset, which means that if we do start to see some trending asset market volatility, you know, more declines in the stock market, more declines in risk assets broadly, you know, it's going to be met with confirmation that, okay, the economic outlook, you know, certainly relative to very lofty expectations, is deteriorating.
So So that to me is, it's almost like we have this sort of air pocket of no more good news out of the economy from a rate of change perspective. We're not going to get bailed out, at least not in the near term by the Fed. And oh, by the way, fiscal policy could potentially be setting up to disappoint to the extent that the Republicans don't play ball and you actually have one or two Democratic senators defect.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Darius, how much downside could we be looking at here?
Darius Dale: So I'll start by saying I think it's pretty aggressive to have price targets in general. I mean, I think, um, you know, anyone managing money, even their own money, realizes that price targets are a fool's errand in this business. But, you know, I have been anchoring on the 2009-2010 analog because I believe it's a really good sort of, you know, sort of not only does it— the price chart analog look really good, but it also makes a lot of sense from a bottom-up macro regime perspective as well. So if you look at slide 59, what we're doing is we're overlaying the 2009 experience of the S&P 500 relative to the red line, which is the, you know, sort of 2020 to 2021 experience. And what you can see is that, okay, both plots bottomed in March. That was sort of the nadir of the economic deceleration that we inflected in the spring of both years and accelerated for over a year from that point forward.
And then ultimately, you know, the blue line, the 2010 example, started to sell off as the rate of change cycle for growth was peaking, right in line with And then ultimately on slide 60, we had a 16% drawdown in the stock market that in my opinion was a confluence of that rate of debt natural healing process off the lows of the GFC really coming to conclusion.
And then you also had a termination of QE1 in March of that year. So you had a liquidity drought during summer of that year that really culminated in a 16% drawdown in the stock market. I think that's a very reasonable expectation.
I mean, the setup from a bottom-up macro regime perspective is almost, almost perfect. You know, and you also think about, you know, the setup, uh, from a top-down macro market regime perspective in terms of how policy is feeding into that. It's very likely that, you know, at the bare minimum, the bare minimum, the Fed can't do anything else. You know, they're not going to go from $120 billion a month, 80 Treasuries, 40 mortgage-backed securities, to, I don't know, $150 billion a month on a 10% correction in the stock market. You know, certainly not with inflation at, you know, north of 5%. You know, north of 4% for something like core PCE. That's not going to happen. So you're probably going to have to see a bigger drawdown in risk assets to really get the Fed to materially punt its policy tightening expectations into the future.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Darius. So it sounds like you're saying the Fed's in a box and you think that could result in about a 15 or 16% drawdown in the S&P with the caveat that price targets are never really that meaningful.
Darius Dale: Yeah, no, totally. I'm just using that as a natural analog again based the fundamentals and the price action really kind of agreeing with each other. So I think it's reasonable to sort of say like it's unlikely to see a major material drawdown, you know, something that would obviously be a bellringer, 30%, 40%, 50%, like, you know, some of your guests have said in recent past. You know, I've seen analysis that would suggest that that's, you know, potentially on the tape and mostly through the lens of valuation. There's 2 ways we look at valuation. One, is, uh, through the lens of our, our sort of quantitative valuation overlay. And I think when you— so in terms of how we look at the stock market, you know, we're looking at the next 12-month P/E ratio, the spread of the next 12-month P/E ratio relative to the MSCI ACWI on a 1-year z-score basis, and we're right up at around 1.7.
You know, this is pretty, pretty rich, you know, in terms of where US equities are relative to global equities. But I also think when you look at, you know, something like, um, you know, the real earnings yield for the S&P 500, which is on slide 72, That number has recently declined to -2, which is, you know, right around the sort of all-time lows for this, for this, uh, for this time series.
And the reason I bring that up is because 5 of the last 6 times we've seen the real earnings, the real S&P 500 earnings yield as deflated by headline CPI go negative, it was just on the precipice of a major, major correct crash in the stock market. So sort of if you look at all, you know, the kind of the, the 6 last, the, you know, 6 or 7 of the last major crashes, 5 of them have been presaged by this time series, the real earnings yield going negative, and we're deeply negative as of now. So I do believe, and you look at something like Bitcoin, which would be on slide 71, at least over the last 4 years, Bitcoin has historically led major drawdowns in the stock market or things that I think investors would consider to be something they really want to risk manage ahead of time. So that to me is something that's sending a dour warning signal from a near-term perspective.
And obviously the real earnings yield analysis is sending a longer-term bearish warning signal. But ultimately, I don't think that that's a likely probability. You know, I certainly don't.
Erik Townsend: I don't—
Darius Dale: if I've learned anything from joining this industry in 2009 to getting to this point is that, you know, there's just a lot of wall of worry out there. And, you know, that wall of worry and most recent sort of thing on the wall of worry is sort of China, right? On slide 76, we're talking about the Chinese credit impulse. This is something we've been talking about for an extended period of time. You know, the Chinese credit impulse rolling over and leading to pressure on commodities, leading to cyclical— or leading to pressure on Chinese assets and ultimately pressure on commodities in that order. You know, that's something that's obviously been rolling over. But again, I just don't think it's prudent to go out there and say, hey, I think the stock market's going to go down 20%, 30%, 40% in the context of the Fed buying $120 billion of assets a month.
I think that's just crazy.
Erik Townsend: Darius, you've given me all kinds of interesting new perspectives. Let's try to assimilate all this into kind of a conclusion. What do I take away? I mean, basically it's, it's long-term secular inflation, except not right now, back into deflation or disinflation for a little while, but it's still coming back to inflation someday. And, and, you know, Fed policy, we've covered a bunch of things. How do we net this down to what do investors do with their money in the next year or so?
Darius Dale: Yeah, no, that, that's a great question. That's the number one thing we specialize in at 42Macro is, is what to actually do with your money. You know, it's, it's, uh, I, don't get me wrong, there's some phenomenal investors out there who put together, you know, wonderful slide decks about the future, and it's great. But ultimately, I think if you don't have, you don't have a, if you lack the understanding of the sequence and the risk management of it all, quite frankly, the research just isn't as actionable or valuable. Um, so we really try to focus on that. That's not to say we obviously have everything figured out or right all the time, but it certainly means it is an explicit focus of our product. Slide 14 and 15 You know, we sort of highlight you know the pivots investors should be making across our four grid regimes with respect to those those market regimes. So obviously, the circle on the right shows deflation, and so as recently as as a couple of hours ago, you know we sent out a presentation to our subscribers that said, "Hey, we're pivoting to this full deflation portfolio."
So obviously, it means you should be you know eighty percent in fixed income and FX, and twenty percent in equities and commodities. And those numbers aren't arbitrary; they're obviously rounded numbers. But they're based on our grid asset market backtests. So we're looking at, you know, everything that ticks through the lens of global macro, US macro, US exposures to understand, you know, what's the annualized expected return in a potential regime? What's the percent positive ratio, the percentile of the return, the volatility, the covariance, the N-size, all those, you know, important descriptive statistics to ultimately get to, you know, those pie charts on slide 14 and 15. And so we've recently on slide 15, We came out of a scenario where we were hybrid allocated for Goldilocks and deflation because we knew deflation was coming. And then as recently again as today, we put the full deflation playbook on. Out of respect for our paying subscribers, I'll keep the actual ETF exposure that we're highlighting and the ultimate cash allocation off the record.
But obviously, your listeners should come check us out.
Erik Townsend: Darius, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Listeners, I do encourage you to peruse the entire slide deck at your leisure. It's got a lot of interesting slides. Fair enough on what you said about respecting your paying customers as far as the actual ETF allocations. Give us just the quick 60-second elevator pitch on 42Macro. Is it just for institutional investors? Is it also available to retail?
Tell us more about it.
Darius Dale: Yeah, no, it's available to anybody who's got $50 a month to read my morning note, $50 a month to look at our weekly portfolio construction changes, and $100 a month to look at our slide decks. I mean, quite frankly, you know, I— we obviously, you know, have partner relationships with all the major Wall Street firms and on the buy side and large RIAs but we also spend a lot of time liaising, interacting with retail investors. You know, some of our biggest clients are, you know, just people, retired rich people. And so quite frankly, at the end of the day, what I really believe in at 42Macro is the democratization of institutional-grade macro risk management. A lot of people do macro, but they don't necessarily have a real rooted macro process for you're making real thoughtful portfolio construction and changes therein. So that's what we focus on at 42Macro. I have a lot of experience with that, a lot of experience in regime segmentation and understanding those whole processes and the sequence of it all.
So to the extent that sounds good for you guys, check us out. Otherwise, just, we'll catch you back here on MacroVoices next time.
Erik Townsend: Well, Darius, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to Escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds.
Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Darius on the show. You know, one of the things that I find hardest in macro is we develop such strong biases toward our bigger picture views. And what I like about Darius is that by being data-driven and modeling, when the data changes, you have to have the flexibility to adapt your trading style and And that's really important to have that kind of a system in place. So it's really great to get Darius on, and in particular at the moment where his model is shifting like that. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, as you said at the end there, it's the fact that his model is shifting that I find so interesting because I am convinced of the secular inflation view. I feel like these trades have moved too far too fast. It'll be crazy to just put new money into copper longs at $100. At very elevated prices. What Darius is telling us is not necessarily contradicting my long-term secular inflation view at all, but he's saying, get ready for the pullback, guys. And maybe into next summer is when we'll be looking at a return of that inflation trade. Now, I don't know if he's right or not, but I think this kind of insight is super important because it starts to give you a little bit of guidance on how to maneuver into positions in a long-term It's a long-term strategy if you have that long-term secular inflation view, which I definitely have.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, as we navigate the summer doldrums, I want to move on to your chart deck, which happens to be titled Summer Doldrums.
Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, and click the red button that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, it's summer. It must be doldrums. What's going on here with the S&P on page 2?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think it's a good question. Well, you know what, you had to highlight the fact that I put a question mark at the end of it to ask whether in fact it will be the summer doldrums. But it is worth talking about just how this market continues to develop. I mean, we've, in these post-game sessions, we've had a number of charts talking through the way the S&P has been developing all year long. On this first chart, I just put that 50-day exponential moving average on there. And basically every correction this year, has more or less found immediate support on that 50-day moving average, reversed, and began a new bull run on the upside. And it just like clockwork, we had, you know, a 50-plus percent retracement of the prior advance in the market, hits right into that 50-day and bounces. And, uh, it's gonna be really curious as to whether this is enough for the bulls to take this market to a higher high, because I want to kind of, uh, put some other things into perspective than just what may obviously be this perception that there was a buying opportunity that just occurred a day ago.
So the first thing I want to highlight is that if we go on page 3, I just circled a couple sequences in the middle of market corrections. And, and again, I want to emphasize corrections. We're not talking bear markets and crashes and things like that. But often when the first wave of selling comes into a market, like I've circled here, often you're going to get this reflexive snapback rally. And in the past, those rallies last about 48 hours. And what usually will happen afterwards is the market will re-resume and go back and continue correcting downwards to establish a new base from which a rally will begin. And I think it's actually a really important moment on the S&P 500 now that we're, uh, you know, 2 days off of the low. Will the bulls make this stick, or will this roll over again for, uh, another wave of correction on the downside? But it— in order to kind of give us clues, uh, as to how that is developing, I have a couple other interesting charts.
So first of all, I wanted to highlight on page 4 the relative sector performance in the markets.
Patrick Ceresna: And, uh, obviously the energy sector has had an awful, uh, run as the cyclicals are being rotated out of. And it's interesting, crude oil where it is, this type of a material underperformance of this sector is a bit surprising that it's this deep. But again, beyond the technology, the areas and sectors that have continued to do well are the defensive-oriented ones, healthcare, communications, utilities, and REITs held up. And it really tends to be a lot more of the cyclical ones like basic materials and financials financials that continue to contribute to the weakness. But what I also thought was really interesting was the extreme readings we're seeing on a lot of breadth or sentiment indicators. And so one of the things that, Erik, that we put on before was the number of percentage of stocks in the New York Stock Exchange that were trading above their 50-day moving averages.
Well, this reading earlier in the week hit pretty close to 25. And what was really interesting about that is, is that if you go back and look at the last 3 years of markets, beyond the kind of more ominous 20-plus percent market drops that we had, every time the market has gotten this oversold on— based on this kind of metric, it led to a buying opportunity. But what's amazing is that the S&P 500 is not even 1% off of its highs. And so the— these readings are almost reading as though there were these extreme downside moves this correction was so robust. But yet from an index perspective, there is no sign of that correction. And that is obviously a lot to do with, uh, the breadth and the leadership in the FAANGs that we've highlighted in the past. But it's not just the reading is like this. If we go to page 6 here where I have that CNN Fear Greed Index, we are based on their readings at 24, which is a rating of in the extreme fear category.
This having been down into the teens just earlier in the week. Again, we're in a situation where we're less than a percent off the highs, but from a fear-greed index perspective of the way that they calculate this, we seem to have very negative or extreme sentiment towards the market, like if the sky was falling. And I'm spending a lot of time trying to reflect how we can have such divergent readings on these things versus the index. And, you know, it really asks the question as to whether there is still something more ominous coming for the stock market, or is it really just going to be able to brush all of this off and just re-resume in bullish fashion?
Erik Townsend: Well, and if you really look at what this chart is telling you, Patrick, it says that maybe there's a setup for a launch from here, a melt-up to much higher numbers. Believe me, I don't think that those valuations make any sense, but the crack-up boom narrative does make sense. And that could explain maybe a coming big move because we're at a sentiment extreme that should be a setup for a big move up in prices, shouldn't it?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what? I certainly don't want to rule out the possibility that that becomes the unfolding reality. But my speculation is that it's entirely possible that the summer ends up being far more range-bound With so many crosscurrents and so many different things that with many of these, the FAANG leadership stocks being so overbought, some of these other sectors simply not rotating. Like if Darius is right and there continues to be a disinflationary rotation, then the things that are most oversold are not imminently going to start rallying. Maybe they will months from now, but maybe the the stock market may be far more. A topping formation where, you know, 4,400 or in that zone ends up being the high and the market just chops sideways for the rest of the summer. You know, we're going to continue, uh, to give everyone updates here week in and week out to kind of see how this develops.
But it really is interesting, uh, you know, I've been watching charts for 20-plus years and I don't remember a market with this kind of divergence in it.
Erik Townsend: And it'll be really interesting to see how Patrick, let's move on to a subject that I've been musing on for years now, which is junk bonds and the credit spread. And we've got page 7 here. What's this chart telling us?
Patrick Ceresna: So what's interesting is, is that the way that bonds have traded all year, like when we're talking Treasury bonds, they've gone through a horrible decline and then a rally. But junk bonds, because they're shorter in duration and much more correlated to equity, seem to have weathered the storm very well in a period where many categorize as a bit of a bond bear market that occurred earlier. But what we saw earlier in the week was the first legitimate kind of fear spike in credit spreads. We saw credit spreads rise from just slightly above 3% to about 3.5% on the OAS credit spread reading which is the differential between Treasury and the yields on these junk bonds. But just like the stock market, it quickly brushed it off and heading to the highs. And it's interesting, but these junk bonds continue to trade more and more like the stock market and less and less like the bond market.
And it'll be interesting to see whether or not that correlation to the equities continues.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's talk bond yields on the 10-year Treasury. What's going on
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, you were talking about this in the market wrap at the beginning. What I did is I overlaid the 50-day moving average, not for a predictive factor, but it was simply to— as an identifier of trend. And what we clearly have is a sequence where yields continue to make lower lows and lower highs, which is the reverse for what bonds are currently doing. And this trend seems to be persistent. And obviously, you know, Darius was also talking about this idea of disinflationary pressures. But really, it'll be interesting to see whether every one of these rallies gets faded and whether we go even test 1% in the coming weeks. It's certainly one of the top things that I'm watching at this stage.
Erik Townsend: Do you think we've got a chance of new lows? I forget what the actual low was, what, 35 basis points or something?
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, I don't know whether I wanna be bold enough to say that, but we certainly at this stage though, the reflation trade and that bond bear that was running so rampant Rapidly since from November to March. That has clearly now rotated. And the question now really is how low can they take yields and under what circumstances? I think things would have to get pretty dicey for bond yield. Like there would have to be some serious disinflationary pressures, I think, for bond yields to head that, that low. I think at this stage targeting 1% is a much more realistic technical target. And then if it turns into something more, we'll have to call the play.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to my favorite chart on page 9, which is crude oil futures. Now, we don't have the moving averages on this particular chart, but that last move down was a pretty significant one because since November, we really haven't seen any sustained move below the 55-day moving average. This one took us right down to a good clean test of the 100-day.
I'm not that worried about it. I think people just panicked. But, you know, on a technical level, this could be the end of a dead cat bounce. We could be headed back down. What do you make of this?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I think it's a good point. I'm not opposed to your view. The way that I kind of look at it, just observing back in March and in April through May, crude oil made substantial highs along the $65 level, just rounding that area to $65. And this entire pullback that happened in the span of this last week basically came and tested that $65 level. Okay. But more importantly, when looking at the entire advance since the first quarter, this was more or less a 50% retracement of that prior rise. And so it fits all of the criteria of a typical market correction. And really, I think the evidence to me that we're going to be looking for in the coming week is, will the bulls be able to get this legitimately above this kind of $70 to $72 level? If we start getting back to $75, not only does that neutralize all the selling pressure and start to repair the chart considerably, but it really puts the launching pad there in play for a move up to that $80, $85 level, which could entirely happen.
I'm not ready to be fully bullish on crude, but certainly a key technical level was tested. And if the bulls can really follow through on the strength of the last 2 days, the chart can definitely start to get bullish here.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, we talked about the US Dollar Index in the Market Wrap, but let's look at the Euro-US Dollar cross because that really is the most influential in the dollar index. And boy, on page 10 we've got a chart, looks like we're in the red again. What does the red mean?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, Ole, I just wanted to do is highlight the, the supports that occurred on the Euro-US Dollar, and we're approaching that. And so while the US Dollar strength has been very pronounced over the last 2 months. We're approaching some very key levels. So to me, I don't see the asymmetry of pressing US dollar longs into that kind of resistance, or in this case, euro shorts into this kind of support. And I think at this moment we should watch and see how the bears react in this along these key levels before making another high conviction call on the currency.
Erik Townsend: Now on page 11, Patrick, is this a, a mistake on the chart? Because I read on WallStreetBets that silver had to go by the 4th of July to over $1,000 an ounce.
Patrick Ceresna: That is a bold forecast, Erik, but, uh, in this circumstance, uh, I think the only way to define silver really for the last year has been a, a, a considerable sideways consolidation. And, uh, with the recent drop last week, uh, we are slowly like a stone's throw away from some very key supports. No, not much different than the way the euro is approaching supports. And, and really, while that doesn't necessarily have to make an immediate bull case for silver, every time you approach key supports like that, it becomes a tactical place where you can find asymmetry in terms of, uh, of attempting in a long position. And so as silver is weakening into these supports, so it's going to be really interesting to see whether or not it presents a, a buying opportunity to take advantage of it a long Along a key support line.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, if you enjoy Patrick's Chart Techs, you can get them every day of the week by signing up for a free trial at bigpicturetrading.com. Information's on page 12 or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as the link to Darius's slide deck, as well as the chart book we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to a Jesse Felder article, The Triumph of Hope Over Experience, and a Charlie McElligott update on This Is How Overpositioning Tips Over. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @macrovoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register. Your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge.
Announcer: You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented by for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Aaran Param — Variant Perception market strategist (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 280 was recorded on July 15th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by farmtogether.com, Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors. Variant Perception market strategist Aaran Param joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss whether inflation is secular or transitory, stocks, US dollar, emerging markets, China, bond yields, commodities, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck is titled Sectors, Breadth, and the Gold Option Skew. In the interest of transparency, due to international travel, quarantine lockdown, and coping with having my luggage stolen, I'm not as on top of the markets as usual this week and will be relying on Patrick for some support in the market wrap.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's start with that S&P 500. Been kind of tapping toward that 4,400 level, a little bit of selling here. What's your take on all the price action here?
Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, the last few days I've been out of touch with my charts. Some equipment got stolen and I couldn't get things, and I've been reading ZeroHedge Futures down on declining bond yields. And I'm thinking, is it below the 50-day moving average yet? Is it really big? I finally got the charts working today. It's like, what are they upset about? It's because there hasn't been a fresh new all-time high in the stock market for like almost 48 hours now.
Is that the problem? So I don't get why anybody doesn't see this as anything other than just a continuing melt-up is the way I see it. What's going on here, Patrick?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, we are in the option expiration week, and like when we have Charlie McElligott on the show, we talk about all of the influences of the delta and gamma pins that occur during these OPEX periods. There is substantial gamma up in this 4,350 to 4,400 level on the S&P, which was a pretty key overhead resistance, and that has contained almost all of the overhead highs into this tail end of the week. But that all rolls off this weekend. And so usually when we have that gamma pin removed, it does usher in volatility. And I wanna say with volatility, it doesn't necessarily mean downside volatility, but it's simply that the markets become more on an intraday basis volatile, both higher and lower. It'd be really interesting to see whether we are met with just a very quick dip on the downside and whether that turns into buying. The interesting part is a number of these markets are getting heavy.
I wanna talk about it in our postgame where we talk about how the breadth of the market just has not been picking up.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: And it'll be really interesting to see what happens when the market gets checked on this rally at some point, you know, a quick 5% drop at some point. We're long overdue for that.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more. And I want to ask Aaran Param about this breadth issue in today's feature interview.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So anyway, let's move on to that US Dollar Index, which we're trading around 92.65 at the time of recording. Any insights on the dollar here for you?
Erik Townsend: Well, just looking at the chart, it seems like this rally is starting to run out of steam, but, you know, it hasn't reversed lower yet. To my eye, we need To get a new high, you know, to get a series of higher highs and higher lows, we'd need to have a higher high over 93.5 on a closing basis. We're a long way from that. So, I see it as just a continuation of the consolidation. And I think that this US Dollar Index market is really looking for direction because nobody can really sort out such a complex picture. You have to evaluate not just US monetary policy, but European and other central bank monetary policies to try to figure out what's happening. And these things are so political and in such a big state of flux. I don't think anybody knows.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. I mean, when I look at that dollar index, it is approaching a lot of key overhead resistance. When you go to some of the individual components like the Euro-US cross, that 117 support is right there. And it's a level where the market should find some support. So while the dollar, US dollar trend is up now for the last month, we have some very key levels that are going to at least act as a resistance point. So expecting some consolidation in the dollar along these key levels as expected. Anyway, let's move on to crude oil, which did not make a higher high and is off a few dollars.
Patrick Ceresna: We're down close to $72 right now after being as high as $77 last week. What's your take on crude here?
Erik Townsend: You know, it's really fascinating, Patrick, because last week, if you remember, the narrative in the marketplace was OPEC was unable to reach a deal on increasing production. And what that means is OPEC is about to, you know, completely fail and crumble and collapse. And that's going to mean that there's a free free-for-all and prices are going to crash because everybody's producing too much. So last week, the logic was if OPEC is unable to make a deal, that means price should go down. This week, the logic is if OPEC is able to make a deal and is able to increase production, that means price should go down. So it seems like everybody has kind of gotten to the point where they're just, you know, so much so fast, getting all the way back up over $75 so quickly, a number that a lot of people thought was impossible this year. I think we're still headed for $80 to $92. I think we'll get there before Labor Day.
But at the same time, it seems like right now we're in some kind of correction or consolidation before we move higher. I really don't see this going a whole lot lower, though. We've already hit the 34-day moving average today. We could still take a dip down to the 55-day moving average. That would be a target down around $68.98. So call it $69 would be— you know, that's the 55 has been what's caught the market on each of the serious corrections that we've had in this rally since November. So if it was gonna go down more than this, I wouldn't expect it to go down much more than that. But I think by Labor Day, we're gonna be looking at 80-plus.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I see the oil market very similarly to you. Using sort of like the analog of the March market correction in crude, when it failed to make a higher high in early March, it ushered in about a 1-month correction that saw back then close to a $10 drop. It wasn't quite that much, but a consolidation off the highs and just absorbed that previous advance.
But that became simply Or is it simply a buying opportunity for another move? I think that's going to be the real tell, is that if crude oil makes it down to that $70 or $69 level, will the typical buy-on-dip traders that have been here for what it seems almost a year, well, at least since November, will they reemerge and buy the dip on crude? And that's going to be one of the more interesting things to watch. How did the inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think this market is going to be all about inventory for the next month, because going back to what you said a minute ago, you know, are we headed much lower? Or are we going to have reality set back in as to the tightness that I think really exists in this market? It's going to be whether or not we get the series of, let's say, you know, 5 to 8 million barrel or more weekly drawdowns on inventory. Now, we got another one this week. It's kind of funny. EIA inventory was delayed. First time I've ever seen this. Not a scheduled announced delay like they do on holidays, but basically they just screwed up and they were about an hour late getting their data out this week. At least that's as far as I can tell what happened.
I don't have the numbers in front of me because of my logistics situation this week. It was about an 8 million barrel drawdown. So another big draw on inventory, but it wasn't enough to really push the market back up. And I think that's because everybody's saying, look, OPEC's about to make a deal and flood the market with a whole bunch of new oil. I think OPEC probably is about to make a deal, but I don't think they're going to flood the market with a whole bunch of new oil. And I think we're going to need a lot. So some analysts are saying there could be like 50 million barrels plus of inventory drawdowns in the month of August alone. If that really happens, I think things are going to be pretty stretched, but let's keep an eye on the, on the needle in coming weeks.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's touch on gold here. What's your take?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, everybody seems to be getting excited about this. I want to be excited too, but if I look at the chart, Patrick, where we are is right at key resistances, and the market seems to at least be stalling, at least in the last day or so. That key resistance is right around $1,840, and it's the confluence of the 34-50 55 and 200-day simple moving averages. And, you know, we got to get through those numbers and close above them and stay above them. So I think the, the number to close on, I think right now is around 1,843. I don't have the chart in front of me to know for sure, approximately that number. Let's say 1,845 to be safe. We get to 1,845 and stay above 1,845, and I get a whole lot more bullish. Right now we're at the key resistance level. If it's going to reverse and move lower, this is the place it ought to happen.
So let's see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: I have to agree with you on that level, but I actually look at it from a Fibonacci perspective, which also lines up with your moving averages right around this $1,835 level. It's a 50% retracement of the drop. And so when we were so oversold on the gold drop, it is very typical to see that mean reverting kind of bounce. And we're coming right to a critical level. I mean, if this is a bounce and if it was only a bounce from an oversold state and the downtrend continues, this is a level where it would likely reject. And And so what I'm looking for— I want to be bullish gold. And so what I'm really looking for is some real follow-through that, uh, that signifies that the bulls have regained control of this trend, and that will take a, a break of these levels. And so, um, it's interesting that you came up with the same kind of price levels with the moving averages as I did with fibs, but it's definitely a very critical level on gold.
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield. Uh, what's your, what's your take on it here?
Erik Townsend: Well, we're sitting at least this morning, we were sitting right on 1.34. Now, that is a critical number. Back in 2016, when I think Jeff Gundlach declared that's the forever low yield, that was a really key technical level at that point. And of course, that we did eventually break lower, much lower. And now the question would be, since we managed on this latest move to get up to 1.75, is 1.34 going to be a key support level or can we move back down below 1%?
I think that's a really, really good question. I certainly don't know the answer, but I'll be watching carefully. I think 1.34% would be, to my eye, a very logical support level, and it for now seems to be holding. What's your take, Patrick?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, what I find really interesting is once again we get some very high inflation prints both on CPI and PPI. That's 3 months in a row, and the bond market seems to be brushing it right off, and, and the bond rally continues, and, and yields yields are pressing lower, and something's got to give. And it's really interesting that no sooner did those numbers come out that the 10-year yields are pressing right back down. I mean, we're at 1.30 right now.
You know what, right now it seems like the bulls have some sort of momentum behind them, and I don't know if I want to stand in the way of this. I want to first see what happens here. I don't want to get bullish bonds outright, but they certainly are driving yields lower here, and it'll be interesting to see whether they can punch to a lower low into next week. Nonetheless, this week's featured interview guest is Aaran Param from Variant Perception. Now, Erik, why did we invite the Variant Perception team back this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, we wanted to get Variant Perception back because they're a data-driven macro shop. They've really given us some great interviews in the past. Aaran is one of their key market strategists, and he's one of the few guys, senior guys on the team there that we've never had on the show before.
Patrick Ceresna: So we wanted to change things up a little bit, and I think you'll find a fascinating Well, Erik's interview with Aaran is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy is live now at smartermarketspod.com, and you can look for another terrific interview every Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Aaran Param, investment strategist for Variant Perception. Aaran, great to get you on the program. Let's start with the big debate in finance: inflation. Some of us say it's secular. Of course, Janet says it's transitory.
Aaran Param: What is Yeah, thank you, Erik. Thank you for having me on. Um, I, I guess firstly, it's just worth saying you guys have done a, a great job getting some very excellent views on both sides of the inflation debate from previous guests on the show. In a nutshell, our view is that inflation risks are higher than they have been in recent decades and are largely reminiscent of, uh, a late 1960s, early 1970s US economy.
Uh, now that doesn't mean that we are guaranteed to get a, a secular rise of inflation. But the odds of a regime shift to a world of unanchored inflation expectations and upside inflation volatility are higher today.
In terms of structural risks, I think these are quite well known. We've got the fusion of fiscal and monetary policy working hand in hand. That adds weight to the whole debasement of the currency and unanchored inflation argument. With respect to cyclical risks, I think broadly we can sum this up in the sense that we've got pent-up demand being unleashed onto an economy with persistent supply-side disruptions.
And one area that we've been writing quite thoroughly about this year is housing. So if we were to just break down CPI into its various components, shelter CPI is about 30% of headline CPI and about 40% of core inflation. This series hasn't really been volatile to the upside before, but we're starting to see evidence that that's gonna change pretty soon. We know that house prices in the States lead shelter CPI by about 18 months, and more, more specifically, that's owner's equivalent rent. So with red-hot housing data through the pandemic, we are now starting to see owner's equivalent rents track higher. And yesterday's data was really confirmation of that, of this starting to happen. The CDC eviction moratorium expired at the end of June, and that allows landlords to boot out tenants essentially and demand higher rents from new ones. And we've seen asking rents from landlords surge higher recently. At the same time as vacancy rates are still very, very low.
So to us, it's actually very, very strange that we're seeing such a huge divergence between what's actually reflected in CPI versus reality. And to us, that really brings into question, you know, what's actually real. And that is a critical component for judging inflation expectations. So, you know, we can look at things like ShadowStats, for instance. These things tell us that the actual inflation felt by households It's probably a lot higher than what CPI is actually telling us. And we can also go through company transcripts. We see that their costs are rising all over the shop and they don't think it's transitory. And now they're starting to feel the pressure to really pass this on to consumers.
And so really what we are left with is that inflation expectations are the measure to watch right now. And that is really the propagation mechanism for turning cyclical or quote unquote transitory bursts in inflation. into a more persistent one. And of course, there are a lot of measures of inflation expectations, whether it's from market breakevens, household surveys, professional forecaster surveys. The Fed has tried to aggregate all of these different measures into one indicator, the Common Inflation Expectations Index. That's not actually useful for investors because it's a quarterly index, firstly, and secondly, it's released with a massive lag. So we tried to build one that's pretty similar and much more timely. And this indicator has been surging from its pandemic lows. And in level terms, it's probably back to 2013 levels, which of course is an environment with much higher yields.
I will say that it's still important to respect the broader deflationary arguments, technological change, debt dynamics, demographics, and so forth. But these structural arguments are quite hard to see in the data, and it's certainly possible that inflation and inflation expectations can spiral outta control with the backdrop of some of these structural headwinds.
In terms of cyclical deflationary indicators, one thing that we are watching quite closely is bank loan growth versus bank asset growth. And this has really summed up the QE era where money growth was surging, but there wasn't really any loan demand to mop this up. And the way the credit cycle works in the data is that supply tends to lead demand. So banks usually step up lending efforts if they expect there to be sufficient demand on the other end. And what we're seeing now is that bank lending surveys, they're showing a sharp easing of credit standards alongside lowering credit spreads. So we do expect loan demand to pick up. So some of these deflationary disinflationary indicators are starting to reverse now.
But I think, you know, just the final point really to make is, is more of a thought exercise. You know, I loved reading Stephen Roach's piece recently on the, uh, the Ghost of Arthur Burns, where he gives an inside view of the Fed's thinking during the 1970s. And really what was striking to me was that there was a massively dismissive tone to inflation in the 1970s where the Fed was essentially chalking down high inflation prints to, to noise and transitory factors.
So there are certainly some eerie parallels to today, but I think generally it's a great exercise just to invert the problem and then ask, what if what we're seeing today isn't transitory? And what if we keep seeing these temporary disruptions that cause bursts of inflation? And what if this is the moment where inflation expectations finally react and they become reflexive and unanchored? So I think that's broadly how we're thinking about inflation. And I think that's, uh, it's important to invert the problem always and think about, uh, the other side of things.
Erik Townsend: Let's take this view, Aaran, and extend it to the stock market. Because on one hand, I know from talking to some of your colleagues at Variant Perception, you guys have shared some of my concerns about high valuations. But at the same time, this inflationary outlook kind of says we could go to higher valuations. What do we make here? And what sectors do we invest in if we're still in the equity market?
Aaran Param: Yeah, I would say broadly, something that's resonated with a lot of people that we've been talking to is that we should try to think of a bull market in 3 different phases. And we're essentially in phase 2 right now.
Phase 1 is where the easy gains occur. And this is really where some of the great investors are able to buy at cheap prices, look through all the hatred and disgust. I would say that phase 2, generally what we see is that trading conditions become choppier, Uh, the recovery in growth is largely priced in. Markets are in show-me modes where earnings growth has to justify the previous surge in valuations. And it's in this environment where you start to see a lot of companies disappointing. And so naturally, I think in this environment, we need to start thinking more about stock selection, more about sector country rotation, because this becomes more valuable as the index itself starts to trade more sideways.
And phase 3 is essentially where the economic cycle starts to mature. Equity gains are driven by persistent earnings growth. And so really the difficulty today, and I think it's quite a unique difficulty, is that we've rapidly transitioned from phase 1 to 2. And just one way to see this is by looking at analyst estimates of company earnings.
Never before have we seen analysts revise up forward earnings estimates this quickly after recession. So the key conundrum for equity investors is that we've got an early cycle economy with late cycle asset valuations.
So really, I think any forecast model that uses valuations as an input, for instance, these are just going to look awful across the board. And I think it is worth paying a bit of credence to some of these forecasts because the track record for a lot of them are very good forecasts based on Shiller PEs forecast based on household allocation to equities. But the trouble is they're very long-term by nature, and it's quite difficult to translate that into an investment decision today.
So I think the argument is there to break it down a bit further, to look at various sectors and industries.
And I think the roadmap still is to favor the cyclical tilts in portfolios because something that we know about recessions is that they mark regime shifts both in economies and markets. And with a recession, we typically see a multi-year outperformance of cyclical assets. We see past losers become past winners.
But again, it's just incredible that so many of these cyclical assets have seen forecast earnings go well in excess of 2019 levels. And 2019 was a late-cycle economy. So The economic boom is priced in for a lot of the universe.
I would say that the standout exceptions are very much energy and banks. We do a lot of capital cycle analysis. So we look at variables like CAPEX as a percentage of asset base, the rate of asset base depletion, and various corporate return measures. And the energy sector, and in particular explorers and producers, have seen a massive collapse in CAPEX at the same time as the return on incremental investment is going up. And that's a great setup for shareholders because you've got this consolidation of the sector and supply rationalization means that the surviving firms can at least enjoy a period of less competition. And that's good for the share price. And, uh, you know, right now we know that no one wants to invest in a sector that has destroyed capital for, for so long. Particularly as we've got on the side this sexy clean energy space that's sucking in so much capital.
And the Dallas Fed Energy Survey, for instance, they've got some really great quotes on oil and gas companies, and it just gives us a sense of how executives are thinking about the road ahead. So one firm, for instance, they said they've got relationships with about 400 institutional investors, and just one of them is willing to allocate new capital to oil and gas investments. But of course, we need to acknowledge that the sector itself has rallied quite massively off March 2020 lows. So starting valuations aren't as attractive as they once were. But again, in phase 2 of the market, I think we do need to step up that focus on quality of management and quality of earnings. So we're not quite at the finish line for the cyclical trades, but it's now worth thinking about where where to tilt with respect to equity allocations.
Erik Townsend: Now, one of the things that you said there was that country rotation would come into this, obviously implying emerging markets. I want to come back to that. Let's start with the US Dollar Index though. What do you make of this dollar? It seems like everybody's confused about which way it's headed next.
Aaran Param: Yeah, I would say that's a good way to sum it up in that I think it's very easy to look silly when forecasting dollar returns. But At least from, uh, from our indicator standpoint, something that we are seeing in the data is at least is that, um, there is a, a dollar smile evident in the data.
And this is really based on, um, Stephen Jen's framework, who was an FX strategist at, uh, Morgan Stanley. And he posited that the, the dollar generally has a convex relationship to US economic performance. So the dollar is generally strong during risk-off periods in times of economic stress. But it's also strong when the US economy outperforms the rest of the world.
But other currencies tend to strengthen relative to the dollar when the US economy is middling. And I guess from the investor standpoint, there are higher returns to be achieved elsewhere.
And we can plot just US ISM versus rest of the world PMIs, and that actually has a nice lead on the dollar. It's not a perfect relationship, but it captures some of the key turning points. And given that our growth indicators right now are incredibly strong in the States, much stronger than anywhere else, certainly in DM, we think we're moving to the right-hand side of this dollar smile.
And this is an environment where the US economy, it can suck in capital inflows. Investors start to pile into dollar-denominated assets and the US economy outperforms the rest of the world. Another, I guess, technical signal that we're looking at, something to essentially check if this rally has legs, is looking at dollar breadth charts. And initially we've found signs that this recent rally does have legs. And one way we can look at this is just creating a cumulative advance-decline line for various DM currencies against the dollar, much in the same way that you can do for equity indices.
And so interestingly, at the start of the year when we had, uh, the dollar rally, it wasn't confirmed by breadth data, but today it is. So whilst we still have a lot of focus on some of the short dollar arguments, which still carry a lot of weight, things like the incredible twin deficits in the States, uh, the greater debasement of the dollar versus other currencies alongside a backdrop of booming global trade, there is room for a cyclical counter-consensus rally in the dollar, um, particularly As people start to continue covering their extreme short positions.
Erik Townsend: Let's go ahead and move into emerging markets then. Where are the plays if we're going to start trading out of developed and into emerging markets?
Aaran Param: Yeah, so I would say that broadly we favor the resource-heavy EM sectors right now. I mean, the EM index itself is incredibly concentrated right now, being mostly allocated to China, South Korea, and Taiwan. One way that we are looking at this is essentially wrapping up our growth-leading indicators for individual EMs with valuations and also with some technical signals. And what we essentially do is that we look at how many of these individual EM forecasts are positive or negative, and this works over a 6-month horizon. And right now it's the aggregate diffusion indicator is very high, and that's Broadly good actually for the MSCI EM index.
But as I said before, in this kind of phase 2 of the bull market, it makes sense to start to think about rotating within equity indices. And I would say that right now, just on a crowded metric, things like analyst ratings, things like long-term RSIs, institutional ownership, of stocks within each EM, a lot of LATAM looks incredibly undervalued, particularly as they've lagged the commodities rally. And we know that there's a ton of political stress in a lot of these economies. And typically, if you take a longer standpoint, these are typically the best times to buy.
And so we're starting to think that whilst the commodities rally may be running outta wind in terms of on a cyclical basis, some of these LATAM stocks are showing a potential for a catch-up trade there.
Erik Townsend: Aaran let's talk about China specifically. You know, so much angst in some places and other people see it as opportunity. How do you interpret the China situation?
Aaran Param: Yeah, I think this is important for EM investing, especially because, I mean, China is just— is the commodity consumer of the world. It is so so important for the global growth and global liquidity arguments. I would say the first thing that's worth addressing is that we're seeing a lot of charts flying around now with China's negative credit impulse being a reason to exit cyclicals and commodities.
I would say there's a bit more nuance to this because it is true that Chinese domestic data is slowing down and policy is a bit more neutral versus the rest of DM. Especially after the 50 bps reserve ratio cuts, which we interpret as more of a technical adjustment rather than the start of a full easing cycle. But what I would say is that what's perhaps missing from the mainstream argument is that external inputs into the Chinese economy are extremely positive. And we think that this is more than offsetting domestic weakness. So our China leading indicator is actually very resilient right now because of external inputs like global manufacturing data, global trade data.
And this really allows Chinese policymakers to pursue more structural issues like deleveraging for as long as the rest of the world keeps stimulating and propping up Chinese growth. Now, of course, this won't last forever, and it's probably a story for next year in terms of how China reacts to a fading external impulse. But I would say for the time being, the reflation trade is not over, and I think There is value in, again, rotating at the margin where necessary, but certainly for now, Chinese leading data is holding up.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to bond yields. You know, we had, I guess it seems to me like a scare after the Biden administration announced how much spending they were going to do. Everybody was afraid that bond yields were headed back to 5%. Seems like we're moving the other direction now. What do you guys make of this and where are we headed?
Aaran Param: Yeah, I would say in response to inflation data broadly, the bond market is looking through it and thinking that the Fed will hike For us, it's a bit premature because we are so early into the recovery and labor market data isn't that strong despite some of the headlines going around. So it doesn't make sense to us at least that the Fed will bring forward a set of hikes straight away. I think one way that we're phrasing it is that we've seen the Fed talk like an adult about inflation and policy normalization, but it doesn't necessarily need to act like an adult.
Over the last decade, we've seen that the Fed has Generally follow through on rate cuts when the Eurodollar curve is priced in cuts. But on the flip side, the Fed doesn't follow through when the market prices in hikes. It's happy to take a step back, let financial conditions tighten without much intervention on the Fed's part. Given recent moves, I would say yields are now trading quite low relative to where they should trade based on macro data, inflation growth, and also market inputs like Eurodollar futures and, and oil.
But on the other hand, I think we do need to respect the flow data because right now it is very attractive for foreign investors to buy US Treasuries after hedging out FX exposure. Pension funds as well. We've seen that their funding ratio has improved significantly after the pickup in yields, and that's allowing them to lock in higher starting yields and acts as a counterbalance to some of these inflation and growth arguments on the other side.
And of course we've seen a lot of technical factors at play here on the demand and supply side. Yesterday after the CPI data came out, we saw some curve flattening, but then we also saw that the 30-year auction was very poor. And so it led to a re-steepening of the curve. So there's a lot of supply-demand factors going on that's kind of muddying the picture. So in our view, it makes sense to focus a lot more on trade structuring if you were to bet on higher yields going forwards.
I would say right now it's difficult to short treasuries outright based on some of the flow arguments, the supply-demand factors. And we'd also bucket in direct steepeners with that. What we do like is yield curve caps, which are essentially steepeners expressed as call options. It gives some capped downside with outsized upsides, particularly if the Fed Remains dovish in the event of an inflation scare. And given the dynamic I just mentioned with the Fed not following through on hikes, and also with the historical precedent of the 1970s where Stephen Roach quite elegantly wrote about how the Fed chalked everything down as transitory, plus the fact that fixed income volatility is very low, it makes a lot of sense and it's quite attractive to put these types of trades on now.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the commodity supercycle, a subject that I have discussed with some of your colleagues at Variant Perception. I want to credit your firm for being pretty early on this one before everybody else started talking about a new commodity supercycle, bull commodity supercycle. You guys were onto this a while ago.
What do you see coming? How does what's happened already jibe with what you were expecting? And I guess the big question in my mind is, for a lot of these trades like copper, if this is a really big secular cycle, it's just beginning, but boy, it's already moved so much, it's kind of hard to justify new longs in a market that's already moved so far. So how do you think about this from a trading perspective?
Aaran Param: Yeah, I think you summed it up very nicely there, Erik. I think it is broadly very uncomfortable to see how quickly it's moved since Tian came on, I think it was in October, to talk about the supercycle thesis. I would say just refreshing some of the indicators there, the argument hinged on 3 key areas. The first being heightened inflation risks, as we've talked about earlier, which essentially leads to this increased desire to hold real assets. The second being that commodities themselves, they were very undervalued versus their own history and also versus other assets, particularly financial assets.
So after the recent rally, they still haven't really made a dent in terms of the long-term undervaluation. And also the third factor is that there's a big investor community underweight to real assets because they've been burned for so long over the last decade holding commodities that have disappointed time and time again. And the same goes for commodity equities as well. So refreshing the thesis today, we see that the structural arguments still hold and actually have strengthened in certain areas. So you mentioned copper, and I talked about energy earlier. These guys are very, very constrained in terms of the supply-side response. And that's exactly the behavior we want to see for a supercycle.
Before the pandemic, a lot of these miners, copper miners in particular, but also precious metals miners like gold and silver guys, they were slashing exploration budgets and weren't really making any new discoveries. And of course, the same goes with energy companies. And now this has very much remained the case going through the pandemic with prices is much higher than they were.
And it's not like these guys aren't able to bring back supply online very quickly at all. Of course, there's a massive lag from getting a new mine set up, getting a new plant, new semiconductor fab even up and running. So as demand comes back with the full reopening, really, we think that there's not going to be a sufficient supply response to meet it. And so we're likely to be in this kind of rolling scenario of persistent deficits, forcing more consolidation into the sector. And with that, it does bring the potential for explosive upside for commodities.
On the demand side, it's a bit more difficult to track this. We know that there's a structural bid for electrification and digitization of economies. Copper, of course, playing a pivotal role there. Now, this is quite well known and it's probably in the price at this point. I would just say that it is very uncomfortable just to see how hyped the supercycle theme has become and seeing so many people chase higher prices in commodities. So we are starting to see some speculative shakeouts, a little bit of disbelief creep back in, but our hope is that we just get more headlines about the death of the supercycle, and hopefully that will mark a nice point to then add back some more exposure.
But we do need to recognize that cyclical tailwinds are starting to fade. As I mentioned earlier, that China's domestic data is weakening in spite of of external inputs remaining strong. We've seen that their State Reserves Bureau is starting to release stockpiled commodities back into the market. But of course, nothing moves in a straight line for a long time. So yeah, the question is very much, how do you square that circle between strengthening structural supports, weakening cyclical supports? I guess our judgment is that if the cyclical data continues to weaken, and particularly as well, if dollar indicators show that there's more legs for the counter-consensus rally, then it's probably best to take profits, wait for a large shakeout, wait for more disbelief to return, and then buy back in for the next leg higher.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about oil specifically, because needless to say, oil is an input to the price of everything almost. And it means that from an inflation standpoint, if oil prices keep going, it's going to fan the flames of inflation. We've come a long ways. We're back above the prices before the pandemic, well above.
Uh, we topped out here, we still have quite a ways to go.
Aaran Param: Yeah, I would say, um, going back to the structural arguments of, uh, just incredible supply constraints, it does seem as though the, the direction of travel is higher. It's just that it's not going to move in a straight line. I think, um, a lot does of course depend on how OPEC responds. Of course, we've seen a bit more discord rather than harmony in recent meetings. I would say that the focus should be on how the supply side, whether or not they're attracting capital back in, because if we do start to see at the margin new entrants into the market, and this is quite an important point for the capital cycle because it is a cycle at the end of the day.
It's not something that runs indefinitely because we've seen such fantastic returns for energy recently. That's inevitably going to lead to a little bit more capital creeping in. And then as this capital creeps in, it pushes down future returns, both for the shareholder and for the company. And then that's kind of in the seeds of that capital destruction. We then have essentially a poor environment for shareholders where the supply side is too strong relative to demand. A lot of A lot of the lags that I was talking about earlier, those have now been brought forward and a lot of these guys are now exploring more and doing more to just bring oil to the market at whatever cost.
And I think until we see that behavior, it still makes sense to favor stronger oil prices, particularly as well because we know that the travel season is gonna be absolutely bonanza this summer. We've seen in various company transcripts that a lot of these guys are just seeing booming activity like never before. So I would say until we, until we run through that period, until we see the, the supply stress start to ease, I think it does make sense to, to stick with the oil is going up thesis.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about gold and precious metals, because boy, gold really looked like the rally was taking off. The bull market was, you know, above the 200-day moving average, seemed to be taking off. Then we had that One FOMC statement that just really put a wrinkle in things, and we were struggling to get above the moving averages. And now just today, I'm looking as we're speaking on Wednesday at about $1,830 on the gold tape. So we're recovering. Is it the beginning of another big move higher, or are we just going to consolidate here for a while?
Aaran Param: Yeah, it's a tough one because I think the structural arguments are all in place for gold. As we discussed earlier, the fusion of fiscal and monetary policy and the debasement of currency argument and so forth. That's a good environment for gold. However, I think it's worth going back to the '70s and remembering that gold crashed 40% during some of the high inflation episodes. And this was really when real rates turned extremely negative. And the argument, I guess, at the time was that real rates could no longer go any more negative. So until we get to that point, I think It does make sense to stick to the gold is going up argument, but just understanding that there is a sweet spot in terms of real rates being negative. You don't want them to be too negative.
Of course, I think the real 10-year now is still around -1%. That's quite good for gold historically in terms of the forward returns that you see cyclically. There's not a lot of interesting data to show for gold. As you mentioned, I think a lot of people have kind of chased the price higher, that it's now starting to wane. We know that, um, in August at least, positive seasonality can, uh, can kick in. Um, I think right now it's probably not worth adding more exposure at this point. Probably wait for the seasonal flows to kick in. Um, I would say as well that it's also worth thinking about structuring gold as, um, as an options play, thinking about risk reversals or call spreads. Because we know that gold option skew is quite high at the moment. And so there are other ways to play it.
I think also with gold miners as well, we know that those guys are still very capital scarce. So the supply side argument still holds there. It's just a question of waiting for perhaps more of a shakeout before adding more exposure.
Erik Townsend: Aaran, we touched on stocks earlier, but I want to come back now with the benefit of the conversation that we've had about emerging markets, about precious metals, about inflation and the dollar and all the rest. One of the things Patrick's covered in all of his ChartTechs is the breadth divergence in the stock market, where it seems like the FAANG stocks are most of the price action that's just dragging everything else higher. It seems to me like there's a lot of signals to be concerned about in the stock market. You're seeing breadth signals, you're seeing valuation signals or overvaluation signals. Yet at the same time, it seems like you do want to be in some kind of equity exposure based on the outlook that you've described for inflation.
Aaran Param: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: So how do we reconcile that conundrum and figure out which stocks are actually smart ones to invest in?
Aaran Param: Yeah, I think you made a couple of great points there. I think with respect to the breadth arguments, I think particularly with FAANGs just dominating the price action right now, it's leading to a lot of opportunities in some of the unloved areas. Banks, for instance, have terrible breadth right now. But of course, if we take a slightly longer-term view, when we see such selling exhaustion in these more cyclical areas, typically that's a nice environment to just buy the dip. And of course, we know with banks that these guys have been allocating back their loan loss reserves. They're going to pursue more shareholder-friendly policies, buybacks, dividends, and so forth.
And particularly with the credit cycle turning back up again, we think that's quite a nice environment to to play for. So I'd say that's probably how we'd square it for looking at the terrible breadth arguments in the shorter term.
Longer term, with respect to the inflation discussion we had, I would say that broadly we would want to be exposed to companies that just have strong pricing power and the ability to preserve margins. And typically these companies are in quite oligopolistic, quite anti-competitive industries. And broadly speaking, these are good environments for capital allocating CEOs because these guys, they don't need to worry so much about the threat of new entrants, about their products becoming obsolete and so forth. And they can instead focus on boosting ROEs for shareholders.
But again, it's not as simple as allocating to a quality ETF, for instance. And I think stock selection is very important here. Again, on the one hand, we've got the antitrust environment shifting. Biden's brought in a lot of big tech critics. These guys have spoken about the very poor record of historic antitrust enforcement. But of course, there are also some risks beyond big tech. The healthcare industry is quite vulnerable right now because we've seen a lot of FTC commissioners. These guys are trying to aggressively block some of the M&A.
And because we know that there's a patent cliff for healthcare companies with a lot of patents due to expire over the next couple of years, as these patents expire, new entrants come in and they just drive down drug prices. So if the big guys can't acquire new companies to acquire new patents, this could really wipe out a stream of future earnings. So quality really does need to be looked at more carefully and understanding the quality of the management, understanding the quality of earnings becomes very important.
And in terms of what we like within the quality basket, tobacco and food have cropped up as quite interesting to look into. Now, of course, tobacco names, these guys have been beaten up massively and they face structural ESG headwinds. So a lot of these names are capital starved, But I do think it's worth investigating there, understanding how some of these companies are allocating to heat, not burn products, but also packaged food companies. These guys have seen, of course, surging costs of feed grain prices. It's probably gonna be a feature of the next year or so because we've also seen massive crop destruction in the States, extremes in weather and so forth. And typically what we see in the cycle of feed grain prices is that it actually leads to prices of of chicken and beef.
So this is actually quite a worrying development for inflation in the States because now we've got food inflation to worry about alongside all of the other quote unquote transitory factors. So if we are heading into this higher inflationary regime, holding some of these guys with pricing power, the ability to preserve margins, we think that makes a lot of sense.
Erik Townsend: Aaran, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview, but before I let you go, I want to tell our listeners a little bit more about what you do at Variant Perception. Is it just an institutional advisory service? Is there anything available to the retail component of the audience? And for our institutional listeners, how do they contact you to find out more about what you're doing?
Aaran Param: Thanks, Erik. So Variant Perception is a data-driven independent research provider. We generally cater to institutional clients where we use our leading indicators to give us the bird's-eye view of what's going on. And then we pair that with bottom-up work to identify actionable investments and trades. So listeners can find us at variantperception.com to learn more about us and request a trial for our service. For our retail listeners, there is a blog that we post and updates once or twice a week. There we look at some sort of high-value charts and various blog posts that we've been reading and writing about, and we put that together.
Erik Townsend: Fantastic. We look forward to getting you back in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade. But the high cost of buying an entire farm puts this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did an interview with FarmTogether founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics.
If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview to learn why farmland investing just might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland in the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it's always great to have the Variant Perception team back. You know, they always have such a really data-driven way of looking at the markets, and it seems to always line up with a lot of the views that I have. And what I found particularly fascinating, which inspired me to kind of build a chart deck around, was the gold skew and the interesting way to put on the gold trade. So I'm looking forward forward to talking about it.
Erik Townsend: Well, that's fascinating, Patrick, because when I was listening to Aaran speaking live during the interview, I thought you were going to say sectors and breadth are something that you focus on a lot at Big Picture Trading, and I was expecting you to focus your chart deck on that. And I see as I look at the chart deck, you actually did all 3. So we got sectors, breadth, and the gold option skew. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you haven't registered a free account at MacroVoices.com. Don't worry, we won't spam you or try to sell you anything. What we will do is send you links to all of our cool content like these downloads. You can sign up at MacroVoices.com, just click the red button that says Looking for the Downloads.
Patrick, sectors breadth and gold option skew, let's hit it.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's, uh, jump straight to the first 2 charts on page 2 and 3. One is the S&P 500 and the other one is S&P 500 equal weighted. And one of the, the issues with a market cap-weighted index like the S&P is, is that it's very heavily weighted to the, the big behemoth, very large capitalized stocks like Apple and Microsoft. And so what we can see here is the S&P 500 looks very healthy, in a proper uptrend, everything is working fine. But when you look on page 3 and look at the equal weight index of the S&P 500, there has been absolutely no progress since May on the upside of the broader market. This has really been an incredibly narrow rally, and, and this type of a chart really shows it. And a chart that looks very similar to that equal-weight ETF is, of course, the Russell 2000, which a lot of people talk about, and where you can see the overweight into those kind of FAANG-style stocks is in that NASDAQ that's been running so strong.
And this really continues to be an interesting thing to watch because when you look at global developed markets, not even— and even emerging markets on a broader scope, you see the same pattern, which is, you know, the Euro Stoxx 50 stopped making higher highs, the Nikkei stopped making higher highs, the emerging markets as an ETF, the EEM, stopped progressing higher. You really have the entire stock market really have gone through 3, 4 months of more more sideways chop while the S&P 500 and the NASDAQ driven by these FAANG stocks continue. So that breadth deterioration continues.
And so when we look at page 4, we can really see this is the New York Stock Exchange, the percentage of stocks above their 50-day moving average. I like this just because it's simple. It's like stocks that are in an uptrend will typically be trading above their 50-day averages. And so for the fact that we are to 42% of stocks above their 50-day moving averages just shows you the deterioration of breadth. I mean, we have had a sequence of lower breadth numbers since November, December, and this deterioration continues. And we're not oversold enough to really signal some sort of great buying opportunity. And so the question that continues to be on my mind, is this the canary in the coal And, you know, usually you would think that if there was another substantial leg higher in this market, it should widen the breadth and have a stronger participation.
And we're just not seeing any sign of that. And what I— when I wanted to move on, and when looking at page 5, I just really wanted to show Apple because Apple or Microsoft, they have a very similar chart, which is that they've had this extraordinary run in the last last, you know, 5, 6 weeks, and they have continued to be the leadership.
But the thing is, is that you can't really basket Apple and Microsoft and Facebook and these FAANG stocks with the broader technology basket, because when you look at Page Six and we, let's say, take Cathie Wood's ARKK Innovation ETF, the ARKK—
Erik Townsend: Now, Patrick, in the interest of transparency, are you an investor in
Patrick Ceresna: No, I'm not.
Erik Townsend: I'm not either. I just wanted to make sure that we were clear about that.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay. All right. So, but anyway, when looking at this ARKK, the highs came in early in the year, and even though it tried to rally here in the last month, and on a percentage basis, it certainly has made a reasonable run, you know, up 20-plus percent in a month off that low, we are not making higher highs. How quickly has rolled over and started selling in the last few weeks. And when you even take global social media and you take everything from the Alibabas to Baidus to the Tencents, like the Chinese internet stocks and things like that, making lower lows, this is really a very narrow market. It's not even just being in long-term growth and technology. It's really been about being long FAANG.
And that really hasn't changed. And to me, at least that's making me pay attention because, you know, it doesn't seem right to be— for it to be trading this way. And I think that the stock market has a lot of hurdles ahead of it if it can't widen this breadth.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I've gone well out of my way in past episodes to acknowledge Cathie Wood for having really made a lot of money with her strategy. And I do that because I'm looking forward to telling the other side of the story when this all falls apart. I'm going to just throw in my commentary here. If you look back at post-'87, everybody looked back at portfolio insurance and said, how could we possibly have ever been so stupid as to not recognize what George Soros called reflexivity? That the presence of that insurance product that was designed to protect against a market crash would actually be the cause of the market crash.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: market crash, and that it would exacerbate the market crash because of the need to continuously, you know, continue selling and selling and selling S&P futures into a crashing market.
My prediction of the next time that the entire finance community just cannot believe how stupid we all were, most of them anyway, is when we finally figure out that passive investing and the trend toward almost all of the market being passively invested, so there is no efficient price discovery of individual And all of the speculative money gets thrown into either the FAANG stocks or the ARK funds and the things that are doing sexy. Elon Musk is gonna send a Tesla on a spaceship to Mars because he's gonna sell you tickets to his nightclub on Mars. It's coming, trust us.
Someday we're gonna figure out that the whole market being obsessed with this indexing fad, which never made sense, Plus the people who are not indexing, just speculating wildly on these stocks that don't make any sense. That's going to be even stupider in hindsight than portfolio insurance was. That's my prediction. But so far, Cathie's made a lot more money for her investors than I have. So I acknowledge her accomplishments to date so far.
Patrick Ceresna: All right.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on because I wanted to touch on crude oil for a moment. So we were just talking about the idea that crude oil may at least pause here and backfill, and there could be a potential correction. But I wanted to just circle back to the point we were making over the last couple weeks, which was the fact that the oil and the energy stocks themselves— a couple weeks ago, we looked at not only just the majors, but we looked at the exploration companies, the refiners, and oil service providers, and they all have been correcting ever since the start of June. And that trend continues as there is definitely an outright distribution in this space. And this is interesting to me because we have seen usually a pretty strong correlation between energy prices in the commodity space and the energy sector stocks moving together. And the fact that the energy stocks have all rolled over, over a month ago.
I continue to, to ask the question as to what is the driver, and is, is one leading the other? Is it simply that there's enough people nervous about the reflation trade forcing a rebalancing of how much of an overweight they have in this energy sector? I'm not sure, but it really is interesting that these energy stocks continue to be quite actively distributed off their highs. In spite of oil's recent strength?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's going to be real interesting, but I think inventory is going to be the tell. What was going on in the crude market is everybody was panicking because OPEC could not come to a deal, and everybody knows that the crunch is on. Now, what I think is interesting here is everybody's relaxing. OPEC, it looks like they're going to make a deal.
Look, the crunch period really is through Labor Day, summer driving season, although Phil Verleger told us be careful. That's actually Especially summer homebuilding season. So, and I think that could be extended this year. But even so, Patrick, I think what big picture is going on here is everybody is like, oh my gosh, the summer crunch that we feared in terms of inventory is going to be better because OPEC is going to make a deal. Look, if OPEC makes a deal tomorrow and they start increasing production, the lag time for that oil to get into the market and actually be delivered is not going to overcome any kind of crunch that might have occurred in August. So what happens in August is still, I think, set to happen. I don't know how bad the inventory draws are going to be. We'll see what happens, but I don't think there's any reason to think it's all over. Where I do want it to be all over though, Patrick, is lumber futures.
Erik Townsend: So let's move on to page 9 because building construction is just so busy and booming these days. But it's interesting. It seems like maybe the bubble in lumber prices has been averted, perhaps because there have been improvements in the logistics as we're coming out of the pandemic slowly. What do you make of that? of it reversing so much?
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it definitely had a supply issue, maybe driven by COVID. But what is clear is that that supply issue has now been cleared because when you look at these futures, I mean, we went from a November low of $500, $600 up to $1,800 on lumber. And that was one of the things that everyone that was crying secular inflation was pointing And how quickly lumber has gone from $1,800 back to $600 and just wiping out an unbelievable $1,200 off the high. And it seems like everyone stopped talking about it as an inflation risk.
I don't know if I want to overread into it, but it certainly is amazing to see this parabolic rise and how rapid that mean-reverting correction back to long-term average prices has happened. And, you know, the over— if you go and look at even a 20-year chart of lumber, that kind of $200 to $500 range has been a long-term kind of trade range for lumber prices. This breakout to $1,800 was an extraordinary breakout out of that long-term average. And it really looks like we're coming right back to test that trade range, at least to see, to test whether or not that That, you know, $500, $600 level, what was overhead resistance now could potentially act as support. One way or another, very oversold market. You would think that at some point it's going to even offer some sort of a reactionary bounce, but the selling just seems relentless. It's pretty amazing that this one commodity has truly— it's one of the few commodities that goes limit up or limit down on such a regular basis.
Just the volatility in this commodity. commodity is extraordinary. But we're down here. It'll be really interesting to see whether or not the support kicks in in the next $100.
Erik Townsend: And we're down 65% by my reckoning from that high. That's really a big, big move. And I feel sorry for the guy who signed the contract on the house at the peak and paid those lumber prices built into his house price.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to one that I think most of our listeners are hoping is going to go up quite a bit more. That's gold futures. It really looked like the bull market was on again until we had that one FOMC statement that just crashed the market. What do you make of this?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I don't think we need to repeat what we said in the market wrap at the beginning, which is, is that we're at a critical moment here around $1,835, $1,840, where if the bulls are going to make a trend out of this, we're going to beat this level on the upside. And it's a very critical pivot to find out. What I just really wanted to observe is that overall the gold miners using the GDX ETF have more or less traded in line with gold, which is what we typically see and what I, let's say for instance, would have expected the energy ETFs to be behaving similarly to oil. And nonetheless, gold and gold miners are really kind of trading in check. Gold miners haven't really turned up just yet, but But showing signs of breaking out. But really what I wanted to kind of use this simply as a reference point to talk about the gold options market, because Aaran referenced it when you asked him about how to put on gold or what his view on gold is.
He immediately referenced risk reversals and spread trades that can be done on gold. And largely because of the skew. And this is something that I've spent a lot of time doing presentations on at different shows, and I just thought it was a great opportunity for us to circle back and talk about the nature of the options market on gold.
Patrick Ceresna: And so what I wanted to just start with on page 12 is just showing a skew, and I wanted to go out something close to 6 months. In this case, we're going out to January 21st, 2022, into the first month of next year.
On the GLD, which is the ETF on gold. And what we're showing here is the skew that at different strike prices, what is the implied volatility being priced? For many people not familiar with the options market, they would perceive volatility to be linear in a sense of like, just like a VIX level, where if you look and it says the implied volatility is 15, you would think that all strike prices prices have the same implied volatility. But in fact, when you go to different strike prices on options, each one has a different implied volatility based upon market conditions and, and supply and demand and other variables that come into play. And what's interesting about gold and the volatility skew is it's a beautiful smile or a U-shape in the skew. And to give reference to this, if you were to, let's say, overlay the skew on the S&P 500, it has a huge fat left tail and a downward sloping right side of the skew into, you know, 5% out-of-the-money strike prices.
What this implies is that it's very cheap on the S&P 500. To buy call options, and it's relatively more expensive to buy downside protection or insurance. You have to pay up additional volatility premium to buy protection on the downside. But when we turn to the gold market, and what I'm showing here is, is that you have a very robust volatility premium on the calls on the upside that are out of the money, just as you do on the downside on the puts.
And this is where Aaran was referencing the idea of using things like debit spreads or risk reversals or collars to hedge out gold positioning, which I think is something I'm a— I continue to be a very big fan of. And we even have at Big Picture Trading a number of positions on in this manner. And so what I wanted to just do for our listeners is to just pull up on page 13, the January 2022 options chain. And I just chose $10 strike increments just so that we have less things to stare at. And, and I just wanted to kind of talk through a couple of these different strike prices to just show the different asymmetry that exists in this. And so as an example, let's say, uh, one was forecasting that by the end of the year, over the next 6 months, there could be a 10% rise in gold prices. And let's say you think it's reasonable that the GLD will approach $190 on the upside within the next 6 months.
Doing a, let's say, $180 to $190 bull call spread right here is just under $2. And so one could get— pay out a $2 debit for up to a $10 payout, getting, you know, a 4-to-1 payoff profile on the upside. And even if you wanted to be bold, and let's say bet on a 20% rise of gold by the end of the year, you could, let's say, do in this example a 200 by 210 bull call spread for essentially 50 cents for a $10 payoff and even have the potential of a 20-to-1 payoff if there was an extraordinary bull run on the upside of gold. Now, it's not that these things are guaranteed to pay out, but it's incredibly cheap to put these bets on. And so anyone who's trying to, you know, hedge out the idea that have some upside on gold and don't wanna outlay all the money of a big portfolio allocation, the option market is very friendly to buy upside potential on gold here.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Patrick, sanity check. Everything you said about option skews lined up with my understanding, much of which I learned from you in previous episodes. But in past episodes, when we talked about options skew, you also brought up collaring gold with options, and I noticed you didn't mention that. Is that because you don't think it's conducive to this market, or what?
Patrick Ceresna: No, it's still actually a great trade, and there is still a very natural and favorable setup here. As an example, let's just say you take the GLD and you want to— and you physically own the gold miner shares. If you wanted to insert a collar for hedging it out, and let's just say right now we're trading near $170— I'm going to do rounding numbers, but we're near $170— let's say you want to hedge $10 lower, but you want to sell a call, uh, to, uh, to pay for that premium $20 higher.
And so right now a $190 call pays you out $2.40, and a, a $160 60 put is just over $3. So under a dollar debit, you can have a collar in where you have almost twice as much upside as you have downside risk before the hedges kick in. It's still a really nice collaring skew for the gold market, and it's still one of my favorite ways to take overweight positions in gold. This is that if you're going to be overweight and increase concentration risk, You might as well use the options market as a tool to manage or hedge out some of that risk. And the options market in gold continues to offer so many great opportunities for that.
Erik Townsend: And of course, our pro option traders already know that, but for some of the retail audience, they don't. The solution for you is page 14, where you can sign up for Patrick's service for a free 14-day trial and get webinars and chart decks with Patrick every single day. That's on page 14, or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an interview with Russell Napier suggesting that we are entering a period of financial repression and a Variant Perception article on gold lessons from the 1970s. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share That content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week. Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education. For traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.