Jim Bianco — Bianco Research founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 289 was recorded on September 16th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Bianco Research founder Jim Bianco returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss secular inflation, demographics, decentralized finance, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick has prepared a terrific slide deck for you, which is titled Sizing Up the Markets and Emergent Trends.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's get to the S&P 500, which has been correcting for a week or so, but not a real breakdown or anything, just paused from its prior uptrends. What's your What's your take on the markets here?
Erik Townsend: Well, I agree with your characterization. It blows me away when I see some of these descriptions online about how the market is starting the beginning of the October crash. And I just think, boy, we're not even down to the 50-day moving average and people are worried already. And it's been, what, 2 weeks since an all-time high in the market? Now, I think it is worthwhile to explore how October crashes usually happen. October is the month that you remember, but usually the market actually tops sometime in August and then volatility Volatility really picks up in September. And of course, October is the month where the market really dumps and everybody remembers it. Honestly, Patrick, I'm curious to get your take on this, but I don't see any sign of the kind of— I don't think the top in August was a blow-off style top that typically looks like a market top. And I don't think the little bit of selling that we've seen looks anything like the kind of, you know, increased volatility in September that tends to presage a crash.
So I think if anything, the number of people that are focused on this October crash scenario just portends that much more likely of the opposite outcome. So let's come back to that in the postgame.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because, uh, the dollar's been relatively weak for almost a month. But today, after the retail sales numbers, we have a, a pretty significant uptick. But I don't know if there's any major technical levels yet still, uh, taken out. What's, what's your take on the dollar here as we're approaching 93?
Erik Townsend: Well, you said it all. You know, we're approaching 93. If we were approaching 95, I'd be much more interested. But, you know, we've been consolidating in this range between 89 and, I don't know, 93, 94 in there somewhere. The top of that range is not exactly clear, and it's going to take a significant breakout to really persuade me that there's a trend change. I haven't seen it yet.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because there we have had a breakout. I mean, we're trading very close to 52-week highs. Haven't yet got up to like the 74, 75 level on spot. But definitely oil has been trending higher in the last month. What's your take? Do we go to new all-time new highs?
Erik Townsend: Your characterization was almost perfect. The only thing you left out, Patrick, was, as predicted on MacroVoices, comma. Okay, no, it's, it's pretty much what we expected. I've been saying for a couple of weeks, I'm expecting that this, uh, this rout that we're in, what it's all about is there is a structural bull market in crude oil, but everybody had expectations of massive drawdowns occurring in August. They didn't happen in August the way they were expected because we had the Delta wave of COVID pick up. And also, I think the, the fears were a little bit exaggerated. That put the whole bull market on pause for July and August. And I think that bull market is back. I still think we're headed over $80. Obviously didn't happen before Labor Day, but I think we'll get there before the end of the year. And I think that we'll probably hit $100 $100 before 2022 is out.
With respect to inventory, Patrick, crude oil drew down 6.4 million barrels this week. That's a much bigger drawdown and very much in line with what people were expecting to see back in August. So we are getting those drawdowns finally. And remember the words of Phil Verleger, who told us that summer driving season has always been a fallacy and that the real phenomenon is summer homebuilding season, which creates a huge amount of energy demand. Well, guess what, Patrick? The construction market Demand is absolutely booming. Several people I've talked to can't get a contractor to call them back or to return their calls.
That's how bad it is, or that's how busy it is. And I think that demand is going to continue. So I still think we're headed well over 80 before the year is out. In any event, Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 1.1 million barrels, gasoline drawing down 1.9 million barrels, and distillates drawing down 1.7 million barrels. US production ticking up to 10.1 million barrels. Now, that's still way down from what it was before Hurricane Ida. Those effects of Hurricane Ida have been pretty persistent. Getting that production back online is going to take a little bit longer than some people at first anticipated.
With respect to tape action, we had a face-ripper of a rally before that data even came out. When the data came in and confirmed it, that we went even higher, kind of got to a blow-off yesterday, a little bit of a retrace down to the volume-weighted moving average this morning. And right now, as we're speaking before the close, we're still flirting just about A little bit below yesterday's highs. I won't be surprised if by the time our listeners hear this, if we've broken out above yesterday's highs. And I think we're headed much higher from here, Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because up until today everything seemed rather quiet and benign, but a big breakdown today in gold headed down towards $1,750, down almost 50 points at its worst. What's your take on the gold market?
Erik Townsend: Well, the gold market has been struggling for months and months here. It seems like it just can't get above $1,830. That's where the moving averages were at the tests in, in July and August. And now those moving averages, uh, 255-day moving average and the 100 is also co-located in there somewhere, those have come back down to much lower numbers around $1,800. But it seems like the resistance level which stopped us is around $1,833, which is also a pivot point on one of my chart studies.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: So that may be indicative. But, uh, you know, as far as where we go from here, so far the moving averages have broken down and it looks like we're headed lower. I won't be surprised if that turns around, but boy, that, that recovery that we've been waiting for to break out above the prior trading range has been very slow in coming.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's, uh, wrap up by touching on that 10-year Treasury yield. I know we got Jim Bianco coming on who'll have some insights, but, uh, really it's been almost 2 months of just sideways price action as we pretty much have been pinned between 1.25 and 1.35 on the yield. Do you have any intuition as to where the break is going to happen?
Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, Patrick, it's been a few months now. Now, if you go back to World War II, when interest rates bottomed then, it was like a decade that they just stayed at a permanent bottom before they really started to recover. So as you said, Jim Bianco is really the expert on this. He's a very strong fixed income guy. So I'm looking forward to asking him these questions.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Bianco Research founder, Jim Bianco. Now, Erik, why did we get Jim back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Jim is one of our all-time favorite guests. He is the guy, in addition to Dr. Chris Martenson, who really nailed the COVID call. He was ahead of me and just about everybody else in terms of his graphs and charts and in making the call that we had a global pandemic coming back in January of 2020. And it's been a long time since we've had him on the show. So I don't think we're going to talk COVID in this interview, but we're going to talk about just about everything else.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Jim Bianco is coming up. As MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems.
Two of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors. Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the fintech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Bianco Research founder Jim Bianco. Jim, it's great to get you back on the program. It's been such a long time. For any new listeners who aren't familiar with Jim, he's kind of our MacroVoices hero, the guy along with Dr. Chris Martenson who really helped us be the first financial media outlet to call the COVID pandemic. So, Jim, it's great to have you back. I think we've already covered all of the pandemic stuff back when. So I want to talk about the new big trend, which I think is not just transitory inflation like Janet says, but I think this is secular. What do you make of the inflation trend? And please make an argument either for or against secular as opposed to just cyclical inflation.
Jim Bianco: Yeah, put me in the persistent camp. I mean, that would be the opposite of transitory. I do think that what we're going to find over the next several months is the inflation is going to stick around a lot longer than we think, and it's going to be a bigger problem than we have.
Let's take the data for starters. The day we're talking is the day that the CPI report was released. And let's break it into 2 broad categories. Transitory inflation, and that would be things like airline tickets, restaurants, rental cars, hotels, motels, and the like, and non-transitory items. And what you'll find is that the transitory items have definitely peaked and they're on their way down. But the non-transitory items, that's everything else, with the big part of that being shelter inflation, which includes owners' equivalent rent, And rents of primary residence, that's moving up and that's at the highest level, at least in 4 years, and making new highs.
So there is a transition going on in the inflation dynamics from the transitory stuff to the more persistent stuff. Now, I'm not of the camp that inflation is going to be big numbers like 5, 6, 7%, because I do believe that demographics, globalization, and technology will hold it down overall.
But I think we could see a 3 handle stick around a lot longer than we think when it comes to inflation. And why is that an issue? Because we've got a 1.25% 10-year note yield. If we had a 3.50% 10-year note yield, no big deal. But when you have a 1.25% 10-year note yield and you have a realization that inflation might stick around in the 3 handle, that could pose a problem for the bond market.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jim Bianco: And if the bond market eventually gets a problem, then everybody has a problem.
Erik Townsend: We really haven't seen very much wage inflation yet, which a lot of people think is what starts that self-reinforcing cycle where the wage inflation, you know, means that the cost of everybody operating their business goes up and they all raise prices. And then people feel like they need more money and they, they ask for higher wages and it just keeps cycling.
Why haven't we really seen wages take off as we've seen commodity prices take off?
Jim Bianco: Well, to one extent, I do think we have seen wages take off. And the reason I think we've seen it take off is because it has been rebounding from the pandemic lows. So, you know, it's gone down, it's gone up, and it's now starting to make new highs. But to your larger point, you're right.
A lot of people don't think we've seen a lot of real big inflation, but I think it's coming. And the reason I think it's coming is what the pandemic did is it accelerated trends that were already in place.
One of the trends that it accelerated, we're, you know, conceptually speaking, 20 years ahead of where we should be, is in remote work, work from home. There is a big pushback in the economy right now about returning to the office, and it's not about health, and it's, it's about that they don't want to be there.
That they've looked at the situation and they've said that I've shown for the last year I could work from home. I don't want to be in the office anymore. Well, a lot of managers want people back in the office. A lot of businesses want people to take jobs where they have to commute to those jobs every day. Think waitress, think surgeon, think policeman, think construction worker.
And the way a lot of people are getting people to take these jobs is they're going to have to pay them more money. And I think we're beginning to see that now in the latest payroll report. The wages in the leisure and hospitality industry is up over the last three months, 18 percent, 18 percent annualized rate over the last three months. Now it's rebounding from a depressed low, so year over year isn't quite that big. But give it a couple of more months, and I think you're going to see these numbers start to really move.
So. I think there's been a change in the nature of work.
And I might add, when I say there's been a change in the nature of work, it really comes down to where you are in your station in life. If you are a manager, an executive with people that you employ, you're probably thinking, oh, there's no change. They'll come back. They'll run out of money and they'll come back.
And if you're a little bit younger or if you're in that category of people that think that they've proven their job at home, you're thinking, No, we like it the way it is right now. We don't want to change. I'd rather quit my job than go back to the office. And we're seeing a lot of that right now.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Jim. So you're saying inflation is here. It's going to be persistent. Now, I want to talk about what that means in terms of what we can expect in markets, but let's start with monetary policy. Normally we're taught, well, when inflation shows up, central banks respond by increasing interest rates. That's the traditional way that you fight inflation. A lot of people, myself included, have argued that we're now in kind of an inflation trap situation where the Fed can't really afford to significantly increase short-term interest rates because it would dramatically increase the US government's cost of borrowing and it would essentially bankrupt the country.
Is that a real concern? And are we in a trap situation where it won't be possible to fight this inflation that you see coming because of that situation that we're in?
Jim Bianco: Yeah, let's put it in terms of the way that the Fed is looking at things right now. They are suggesting in a lot of their work— well, let's back up. In 2019, they had a big thing called Fed Listens. It was a tour across the country, and the takeaway that they had from that was we need to focus more on employment. So last year, uh, summer of last year, they, they put a subtle change to their employment number or to their mandate where they're emphasizing employment. And that's where they talk about average inflation targeting, let things run a little bit hotter because we've got to get people back to work. Within that respect, they've been pushing back on inflation constantly by saying, oh, it's transitory. Of course, they never tell you what transitory is. Or do they tell you what they're doing about inflation to make it transitory? The answer is they're not doing anything to make it transitory other than just announcing that it's transitory.
So the Fed wants us to believe that inflation is transitory so that they can focus on the unemployment part of their job. And that's going to lead to a head at some point, as you said. On the one hand, they want to keep, keep everything easy. They want money to keep flowing. They want markets up. They want people to feel aggressive, go out and hire, keep the economy moving.
But if that meets headlong into persistent inflation, and what does persistent inflation do for the Fed? It makes bond investors think to themselves, I don't want to own bonds anymore because if this 3% inflation rate is going to stick around for a while, Why do I want to own something with a negative yield that loses me money?
And then they're going to have a real problem on their hands. So yeah, I don't think the Fed is going to ever admit that there is persistent inflation. They're going to have to be dragged screaming and kicking by the markets in order to act on it. They'll just always dismiss it. They'll always say there's nothing to see here. They'll always look to continue to stay easy.
Erik Townsend: A lot of investors believe that there's an inherent relationship, that as inflation picks up, interest rates pick up. Is that how it works, or is the interest rates picking up something that only happens when the central bank, through monetary policy, is taking action to fight the inflation?
Jim Bianco: Oh, I think it's the latter. I don't think that there's a one-for-one relationship that as inflation picks up, interest rates pick up. Now, big picture, if you want to show me a 100-year chart of inflation and a 100-year chart of interest rates, Yes, you could then say that when inflation goes up, rates tend to go up, and when inflation goes down, rates tend to go down. But in the interim, there can be many months or years where they seem to diverge. Ultimately, remember, it is bond investors that buy bonds, and it is whatever motivates investors to want to own bonds or not own bonds. And one of the big things that motivates them is monetary policy. So if you've got an accommodative monetary policy with no inflation and that the Fed is aggressively pushing up bond prices, I want to own bonds because the Fed's going to be the wind in my back.
If you've got a monetary policy that is fostering inflation, meaning that my value of my money is going to depreciate faster than the interest that my bonds are going to give me, which is known as negative real rates, I don't want anything to do with bonds then at that point. So I agree with you, it's really about monetary policy. So as long as the Fed can just continue to be easy, the bond market will stay okay. When the Fed is forced to be a little bit more aggressive on monetary policy, then the bond market can run into trouble.
Erik Townsend: Now, Jim, you're an expert on fixed income. Something that's really been on my mind a lot lately is a lot of people are saying, look at Look at this 35-year, or maybe it's longer than that, 37-year, whatever it is, bond bull market that we've had since the early '80s. We got down to, I forget what the intraday low was, 25 basis points or something on the 10-year at one point. And a lot of people are saying, okay, look, surely the bond bull market, it's gotta be over now. And I think that's probably right. But then they jump immediately to, therefore we're in a secular bond bear market. It's time to short everything. And I think, wait a minute, when interest rates bottomed after World War II, it was like 10 years before they really started taking off to the upside. So if— first of all, do you think interest rates have bottomed?
But if they have bottomed, does that mean there's necessarily a secular bear market to follow, or does it just mean we're going to stay bottomed for a long time?
Jim Bianco: I, I think they have bottomed. I— you're right, it was 39 years, and we hit 33 basis points in the 10-year in March of 2020. I think that was it. And you're exactly right, I've used that same analogy myself too. That following the 1946 low in bond yields, which was a little over 1%, it was another 8 years or so that we, you know, that bonds still traded around 1.5% before rates really started to move up, especially by the time you got to the late '50s. So I think what you'll see is you'll see interest rates are going to continue to probably meander around You know, this 1, maybe 2 handle for a while. Now, what's different now than in the, in the, in the '40s and the '50s is the sheer amount of leverage and financialization that there is in the bond market. Back then, the bond traders— there were bond traders, but they weren't, you know, as aggressive leveraged traders as they are now. And one of the things that I've cautioned about is, yes, If you're waiting for a big rise in rates, that's probably not going to happen for a number of years.
But could rates shoot up to 2.5%? Sure. And if you're not a bond trader, you might shrug your shoulders and go, 1.25%, 2.5%, is that really that big a deal for the economy? If I'm borrowing on a mortgage at 3%, does it now all of a sudden not work at 4%, 4.25%? Yeah, you're probably right. It's all the same there. But for bond traders, for leveraged bond traders, for bond dealers, a move from 1.25 to 2.5, very painful.
Big losses, especially if it comes very quickly. So that's where I think it matters. And if the bond market gets wobbly, everybody else will get wobbly. Everybody else would be the stock market, the commodity markets, the gold markets. They would all respond in kind, I think, to a wobbly market. So keep in mind That even though I might say, look, I think we could see 2.5% on bonds, you know, within the next year, which I do think that can wind up still being very painful for people in the bond market.
Erik Townsend: Let's come back to my question of are we actually looking at just a cyclical pickup in rates here, or is there actually an argument for a secular bond bear market that's already begun?
Jim Bianco: I think there's an argument for secular bear market in bonds that has already begun. Look, the, the 3 big factors that are holding down inflation— remember, 100-year chart bonds, 100-year chart interest rates, they seem to move a lot together with each other. The big factor that's holding down inflation is demographics, globalization, and technology.
Demographics— we're getting older. As we get older, we tend to want to consume less stuff. You consume the most stuff when you're in your 30s and your 40s. when you're starting your career and you buy a house and you have kids. But when the kids all grow up and they leave and you're grandparents and you retire, you consume far less.
Globalization, you know, I could build this anywhere, wherever the cheapest costs are. And the relentless push of disinflation or even deflation from technology making everything cheaper and cheaper has held stuff down. Well, now that we're in '21, you could argue that some of those might be questionable. Let's start with globalization.
Yes, globalization was a great thing, but all of a sudden there are nationalist movements all around the world. There is tension with the biggest, with the biggest manufacturer of the world, that is China as well too. And so you could argue that maybe we've seen peak globalization or we're very, very close to peak globalization.
Demographics. There is a big wave of millennials and then Gen Y right behind them. That is coming up, you know, in the, in the demographic chain. So while we think about the economy aging because of all the aging baby boomers, in a couple of years that's going to start to revert back the other way as the Gen Yers come into adult— into their adulthood more often, and the, the, the millennials get a little bit older, and then they start wanting to buy houses, buy cars, have kids, and the like.
Technology. Technology is the one thing that could continue to exert downward pressure on interest rates, but that's not enough by itself. It needs the D in demographics and it needs the G in globalization. And those 2 might be questionable. If they are, there's your case for that inflation. The inflation down cycle ended too, and we might start to see a turn up in inflation. Same thing. Remember, inflation started to turn up in the early '60s. It took 10 years before it really started to take hold in the '70s. I think you could see something similar to that now. We've, we've got a bottoming in inflation, and now we've got, uh, we've got potentially a turn higher in inflation.
One last thought for you on inflation. If you look back to the 1970s forward and you look at the inflation rate, The average inflation rate of every expansion was lower than the previous one. So the '70s had higher inflation than the '80s expansions. The '90s expansions had lower inflation than the '80s, so on and so forth. That cycle might be breaking now. The average inflation rate we've had since April of last year with the end of the recession is much higher than the average inflation rate that we had between 2000 and 2019. That'd be the first time in nearly 50 years that we've seen a turn up with the expansion. And so that suggests to me that maybe we've got a secular turn in the inflation rate. But again, don't think that we go from an inflation bottom secular turn to some magically high number on inflation right away. That could still be a decade plus away.
But for right now, we're talking about a bottoming of inflation.
Erik Townsend: Okay, let's translate this to how you actually make money in markets because it seems to me we've gone from really easy to really hard. What I mean by that is in a bond bull market, you fixed income guys, from my perspective, don't have to work that hard. You buy long bonds, you get a little bit of return on the coupon and a whole bunch more return on the capital appreciation thanks to a trending market and you're done.
But if you think the opposite is happening, it's not quite so easy because in that case you had a double tailwind. You got capital appreciation and the coupon helping you. If you're going to short bonds because you've got a secular bearish view, you've got to pay the coupon in order to be short. And depending on how you're, you're doing that short, whether it's in futures or, or in the actual bond market, you may be paying a borrow cost in order to short those bonds. So So it seems like it's much harder. And then you just made it even harder than that because when I said, is it about to really take off and go the opposite direction fast? You said, no, it could be a bunch of years before anything big happens. So what do you do in terms of how to trade that?
Jim Bianco: Yeah, it's going to be difficult. This is where the bond investor is going to get paid to earn his living right now is to try and do something in this environment. So the first thing I'd say is that the secular nature of interest rates Yeah. Is, is over. You're right that, you know, you just had the wind at your back. Just be long the market and don't do something stupid, and you, and you made a lot of money. Well, now you're going to have to be a little bit more nimble, you know, picking the right credits, picking the right instruments, playing the yield curve correctly. This is all really hard stuff to do as well. But let me write your question bigger, and let me say that if you were to look larger, say, to the equity market and everything else, Let's talk about how the markets have been working over the last several years.
They've all been flow-driven. If you look at valuations in the stock market, you'd be very hard-pressed to make the statement that something in the stock market is cheap. There's nothing cheap about the stock market. It's either fully valued or it's overvalued. But why is it that we— it just relentlessly goes up? Because the flows just relentlessly keep coming into the stock market, just like the flows relentlessly keep coming into the bond market. Now, the difference is the flows in the bond market are largely coming from central banks. The Fed is buying $120 billion a month in bonds. That's $1.5 trillion a year. As I like to joke, they're buying bonds so you don't have to. And all that money then reaches for risk and buys stocks. And, and most of that, that it's going into the stock market and flows is going into index funds.
Look at a chart of the S&P and look at a chart of the Russell 2000. They don't look much alike at all. And really what it is, is that most of the indexes are tied to the S&P. So it relentlessly goes up because money's flowing in. And there's a little bit of indexing in the Russell, but not as much as there is in the big cap index.
And it is a little bit more independent of just the flows. So as long as the flows continue, bonds will, you know, meander sideways and probably have their their fits and starts a little bit. Stock market will keep going up. You get a belief that inflation is persistent and a demand that the Fed do something about persistent inflation—that's code word for. Stop buying bonds, and if the Fed's going to stop buying bonds, I don't want anything to do with bond yields with a negative real yield. They sell off; the stock market gets very, very wobbly.
So really, this is a story of you're playing flows. You're not playing valuations. You're not playing relative economy recoveries, and the flows at its at its bedrock is central bank flows, whether it's the PEPP program from the ECB. Or the Fed or the yield curve control programs from the Bank of Japan or the Reserve Bank of Australia, they are producing flows, money to own bonds, even though they're having a difficult time going forward. But more importantly, they're telling everybody, you don't have to worry about the bond market too much. Go ahead and speculate in stocks. But the minute you get a perception that inflation is persistent, all that starts to reverse. And then you've got some issues on your hands.
Erik Townsend: Jim, do you think Jay Powell is going to be reappointed as Fed chairman? And if not, who is on deck and what are the consequences of a different chair?
Jim Bianco: Well, let's start with yes, I do think he's going to get appointed. If you look at the prediction markets like PredictIt.com, there is a betting market out there that's got him at 90% being reappointed. Now, what's important to understand about this is the progressives in the Democratic Party led by Elizabeth Warren have made it very well known they don't want Jay Powell reappointed, full stop. They want him out.
Their preferred choice is Lael Brainard, who is a Fed governor as well too. And she's more of the progressive camp as well. Now, normally when the progressives push on the Biden administration, they kind of get what they want. But in this case, doesn't look like they are going to get what they want because there's a fear of markets. There's a fear that if we don't satiate the markets by giving them the guy, the comfortable old sweater of Jay Powell, and we give them an unknown in Lael Brainard, that that could upset things. So that they're going to at least acquiesce to that. So I suspect that Powell will be reappointed. If not, it will be a big shock. His term ends at the end of January. If you work backwards with the Senate calendar to get him nominated, hearings, vote. It's got to come out probably in the second half of September, the announcement that he's going to get reappointed.
Where I do think you might see a change is Rich Clarida, the vice chair, might be out and that they might give Lael Brainard that position. They like her in the administration. She was on the shortlist to be Treasury Secretary. The scuttlebutt was she was ready to quit the Fed when she didn't get Treasury Secretary, and they told her, sit tight, we've got other plans for you. And that was kind of a wink nod that maybe Fed Chairman. Well, if they don't give her that, they got to give her something. And so I wouldn't be surprised if she winds up becoming the Vice Chair, and if at the very least the head of regulatory supervision for the Fed. Now, that would probably be a negative for the banks because they regulate the banks directly. But it wouldn't necessarily impact monetary policy. But if anything deviates from that, and what I've largely explained is somewhat of the consensus thinking, which I think in this case is right, Powell doesn't get it, Brainard doesn't get it, Clarida stays, some other thing that wasn't mentioned, then you've got potentially a market-moving event on your hands.
The big one being if they don't give it to Jay Powell. And they give it to somebody else because the other problem that they've had is they've looked at other candidates. Raphael Bostic of the Atlanta Fed as one example. Problem with him is he's a hawk, and that's one of the reasons why he's probably been scratched off the shortlist because the markets wouldn't like the idea of a guy that if it was up to him, we'd already be in the taper right now. It's not up to him; he's just one of the regional presidents. He's not the Federal Reserve chairman.
Erik Townsend: Jim, so far we've been talking primarily about US policy and markets. Let's expand this globally. And I want to talk specifically about China because I just see between the, the China conflict with the West seems to be heating up. I just saw over the weekend, it looks like China's relations with Taiwan are heating up. Where is this headed both economically and geopolitically? And what should investors be thinking about here?
Jim Bianco: So let's put this in a little bit of perspective. This started a year ago when Jack Ma, the head of Alibaba and Ant Financial, gave a speech and he basically criticized the banking system in China as being unfair for the working class and the poor. And that kicked off a whole series of events at that point, starting with Alibaba spun off their financial services into Ant Financial. Ant Financial. At its peak valuation, it was worth $150 billion, 50% more than Goldman Sachs.
That was largely taken away from him by the Chinese government. And in news this week, their, their, their very popular money transfer app Alipay is being told to divest itself of its lending and breaking it up into a lot of different avenues. The Chinese have also come down hard on a lot of the tech companies. They've come down on Didi. That's their ridesharing. It's it's five times the size of Uber. They punished them for listing on the New York Stock Exchange and not staying in Hong Kong or in Shanghai as far as listing to raise capital. They've come down on their on their education companies in China. It's very competitive to get your kids into school. So there's these after-school tutoring programs, which are so big that they're publicly traded companies. But a lot of these after-school tutoring programs have been really geared towards getting your kids to pass tests to go to a Western university, either in the United States or in Europe.
They've cracked down on that as well too, and they've been cracking down on a number of companies as well. I think it's made China uninvestable from a foreigner point of view. If you buy a Chinese stock, and it goes up, what do you own? They've already shown that it might be the CCP that owns these companies and you're just a caretaker for them until they decide that they're going to take it from you. And so that's the real fear that you've got to have. You know, question is, what do you own?
The bigger question is, what is China doing? Why are they doing this now? I think it has a lot to do with their economy slowing. Their economy is definitely slowing. Their economy definitely has some issues. There are some rumblings within the Chinese population. Look, they're very unhappy about having to be locked down last year. They're very unhappy about the lack of opportunities that they've had as well too. They're very unhappy about the amount of opportunities that the wealthy have had in China. So they've been kind of soaking the rich.
I think they're doing a mistake in China to the extent that they need an entrepreneurial class to create the Alipay, to create the Didi, to create a lot of these companies as well too. And if those budding entrepreneurs are not treated well, they're going to go somewhere where they are treated well, whether that's Silicon Valley or Europe or Singapore or anywhere else. Certainly can't be Hong Kong anymore because they've effectively taken over Hong Kong as well too.
So I do think that in the picture there, there is a message for investors. What do you own if you own China? And is this a signal that China is slowing? And let's go back to our earlier conversation about globalization holding down inflation. That's another reason why we could see fraying of the globalization between China and the West. if China wants to continue to promote policies that are going to be at odds with Western values as well too.
Erik Townsend: Jim, we just did a special with Dr. Pippa Malmgren and Clint Cox for our August summer special talking about the coming decentralized finance revolution. And I am absolutely convinced, although I don't think that cryptocurrencies themselves have as big of a future as the crypto fan club thinks, I'm convinced that the technology they invented is going to be used by someone, if not the crypto people, then by central banks, to completely change not just the currency system, but the entire global financial system. I think most Americans just assume, obviously, that's a big bunch of technology and financial progress, so it's going to happen in the United States.
You think it's going to happen in the United States, or you think that maybe the Chinese government's a little bit ahead of the US government in terms of of that? I think it's going to happen in the United States. figuring out how strategic this is to the future of the world?
Jim Bianco: Well, I agree with you that the United States has got a real issue. Let's back up. Decentralized finance is the ability to do banking without banks, do brokerages without broker companies, to do trading without exchanges, to do insurance without insurance companies. We don't need those companies if decentralized finance fulfills its promise.
In the United States, when you say, here's a way that we could do banking without banks and we don't need brokerages and we don't need Exchanges, everybody looks aghast in horror, especially the regulators, because that's their livelihood. We can't have that. But if you look in the rest of the world where the majority of people in a lot of countries are unbanked, that is an opening, a real opportunity for them to raise their standards of living. So I agree with you, decentralized finance and the whole ideas behind it is coming. One way or another, the loser in that scenario is the top dog, the reserve currency country that has all of the all of the institutions, and that is the United States.
But if you look at a breakdown of where cryptocurrency trading is taking place, Chainalysis does a good one of this. Of the top 20 countries where you can find crypto trading, only one country, one developed countries in the top 20. And that's the United States at number 9. Vietnam happens to be number 1, and they've got a new entrant at number 20, and that's Afghanistan. And that's because there's no functional financial system in Afghanistan, and they're turning to crypto in a big way. Because remember, the one constant that every country has is cell phones and mobile phone usage. So everybody can download an app and can get started with crypto, even in Afghanistan. If they have to. So don't automatically think that it's all terrorist money and drug money that, that's doing this. This is the merchant and the consumer on the streets of Kabul trying to figure out how to earn a living and how to get paid is what this is.
And the reason I detailed that is because that's where it's coming from.
So if the United States, if the SEC or the CFTC or who I think is behind all of this is Janet Yellen at the Treasury, is going to want to say crypto bad, decentralization we have to, you know, and they keep using the words investor protection where I think they really mean incumbent protection, then the US is going to sit it out. We'll just let the rest of the world design the new financial system.
Or we could say, look, we've got a handle, we've got a hand or experience in running a global financial system. Let us help you design this system. As we move forward from here. Right now, the US doesn't want to do that. The US wants to try and regulate it out of existence, but they're not going to be able to because it's so much in the rest of the world.
Let me push back one place a little bit on you here, and that's China. China's thrown all the Bitcoin miners out of its country. China has designs to have its own digital currency, the digital yuan, with hopes that it would become a reserve currency, not the reserve currency, but a reserve currency.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Jim Bianco: The problem China's been facing is they've been testing their digital yuan in China, and a lot of people shrug their shoulders and say, yeah, it's nothing big. I like Alipay better. I like WeChat Pay better. It does more things. It's more interesting to me than your digital currency. And in typical Communist Chinese fashion, when you've unveiled a product and then they said that the private sector has come up with a better product, They say, oh, well, let's make the private sector version worse. So let's break up Alipay. Let's put restrictions on WeChat Pay. Let's make them crappier so that our substandard product, relative— their digital yuan looks relatively better. So China's at risk of missing this too, largely because they've got their designs on their own digital currency, the digital yuan. They're probably going to roll it out at the Winter Olympics and then push real hard after the Olympics to try and see if they can get adoption on that as well.
Erik Townsend: Now, obviously, it's hard to have a crystal ball here, but it seems to me that all of the smartest guys in finance all see the same thing that you and I do, which is clearly there's going to be a decentralized finance revolution that's going to change everything and disintermediate finance, and it's going to be a completely different landscape 25 years from now.
But each one of those guys seems to have a different vision of what that actually means and what it looks like. So let's hear your version, Jim.
Jim Bianco: Well, first of all, let me say you're absolutely right because you could basically back up 20 years ago or 25 years ago and talk about the vision of the internet. And you could have been completely right and said, I think that things like search are going to really drive the internet and internet retailing is going to take off. And 20 years ago, you would have plowed all your money into Lycos, And you would have plowed all your money into Pets.com, and both of them went to zero.
Okay, okay, well then, you know, maybe then I'll plow my money into AltaVista, and it went to zero as well too. And then you would have given up on the idea that the internet was going to be anything more than a sophisticated fax machine, as Paul Krugman famously said in the late 1990s. And then it took off and it changed everything. That's the problem you're going to face with decentralized finance.
Yes. I can agree, you can agree with a lot of people, boy, this is coming and this is going to be big. But how, how do I invest in it? How do I make money on it? Where's it going to be big? The risk is the big thing that it's going to be doesn't yet exist, and a lot of the stuff we're investing in now might all be destined to go to zero. And the Google of this that's going to be the transformational part is still to come. Remember, Google didn't even come into existence as far as a public stock until 2004, 4 years after the tech bust as well. So that's going to be the, the issue with it right now.
I think as I look at everything, I think the place I'm focused most on is in the blockchain technologies and tokens that have smart contracts tied to them. That would be Ethereum, that would be Cardano, that would be Polkadot, that would be Solana and the likes of those, and to say, are those technologies and are those systems that they've set up, those protocols that they set up, are they in the process of becoming the foundation for this DeFi world? And I think in some respects the answer is yes for most of them. They all have their issues. Some of them, like the Solanas of the world, are not decentralized enough so that one or 2 actors can have a big influence on them. Some of them, like Ethereum, are very decentralized, so no one can exert control over it, but its processing is too slow to actually try and be the foundation of the world's financial system.
They need to speed that up without losing their decentralization. They've got some plans for it, but that's a tall order as well too. And there's more ideas that are coming as well, but I would say to most people This isn't necessarily— we're not necessarily at a stage where it's, here's how you make money in this.
I want to say this is more like the early '90s. Spend some time to understand this space. Spend some time to learn what's happening in this space because it is going to be big and it is going to be significant. Although maybe it's not going to be Ethereum, or maybe it's not going to be Cardano or Polkadot or Solana or any of these others. Maybe it's going to be something that doesn't yet exist, or maybe it will be those. and others as well too. So I still think we're kind of at the feeling around in the dark spot, but I do think we are all on a journey and we all know where that journey is going to lead to. As you said, Erik, in 20, 25 years, there's going to be a wholesale change in the financial system as we know it today.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about your expertise area, which is fixed income specifically. It seems to me that decentralized finance has I think blockchain has more applications in fixed income probably than anywhere else. And the reason I say that is, as you alluded, once you've got programmable money and smart contracts, a bond could literally be something different than what it is today.
A bond today is a promise for an issuer to repay if they keep their promise. But you could design a new kind of bond, Jim, where it's An obligation to repay where the system itself essentially forces the issuer if it has either savings or income. You know, if it has a revenue stream, it could be designed to essentially capture that revenue stream. So you could have revenue bonds that are programmed in through smart contracts. That seems to me like as soon as somebody comes up with a really novel innovative— and I don't think it's a software guy, but I think it's a fixed income guy like yourself that says, wait a minute, we could never do X before, but we can do it now because we've got this programmable capability where even if the issuer wants to default, they can't. It seems to me like that if somebody invents something like that, it could be a total game changer for the fixed income market.
Am I wrong?
Jim Bianco: No, you're exactly right. And I think, you know, to make it better understood for people, let's Let's say the same thing you did with the terms that you hear in the crypto space, tokenomics. One of the things, you're right, you've got smart contracts, you've got programmable money. Okay, so a bunch of coders know how to program money, but how do they set up the proper incentives and how do they set up the proper reward systems so that a token, which would be the equivalent of a bond that you were talking about in your scenario, would flourish, that people would want to own that token, that people would want, you know, it By owning this token, it gives me some some kind of rights to a revenue stream, an asset, or or some kind of privilege that you know you could you can get from the token that you can't get from other places.
Give you a good example: There's been an argument that's been made, and I happen to agree with this argument, that one of the things that say a Tesla and an Apple have going for. Is that the people that buy Teslas and buy Apple phones tend to own their stock, and they tend to be cheerleaders for those stocks as well, especially Tesla.
I mean, most people that own the Tesla car also bought the stock, and then they brag about the company because they're a part owner. They want to see the stock go up and they benefit from it. How about a dollar store, a Dollar Tree, or in a McDonald's? Most of the people that shop at those places are not owners of the company and they don't own the stock. But what if they issued a token and that token gave them discounts and certain privileges? And as they talked up the virtues of their— of those companies or any other company along those lines, those tokens appreciate in value. And all of a sudden they now partake in the same way that a Tesla owner owning Tesla stock partakes. You could change the whole dynamic of the way that markets work and the market structures, uh, our structures are.
The other thing that decentralized finance does is it removes the privilege out of decentralized finance. The difference between you and me and Warren Buffett would be the number of zeros after the size of his order or our order. It would not be the terms of the deal, because I've always bristled about these books that say invest like Warren Buffett. Yeah. Boy, I would love to. I would love people to call me up and give me sweetheart deals out of the blue like they give to Warren Buffett, but they don't. I don't get the same deal that Buffett does, but in a decentralized finance world, we all get the same deal. He can just add more zeros to the end of the deal, but the terms are all exactly the same as well too. So you're right, this can really democratize finance. This can really change the outlook for the markets. And of course, no one wants that right now.
Like, one of the big things that we have is we have this thing called accredited investors, that you need to have $1 million in order to put your money into like some kind of a hedge fund or some kind of a limited partnership that could give you, uh, you know, abnormal returns, because they've decided that as a substitute for investor intelligence, we're going to use net worth.
I think that's a terrible rule because there are plenty of people that don't have a million dollars that are completely capable of understanding a lot of these products and should have the opportunity to invest in them. In the decentralized world, that won't be— everybody gets the same deal. So yes, you're right, it will change a lot of how the system works. It will democratize it. It will give everybody fair footing on what they could wind up doing. And it could turn everybody into a projected owner or an advocate for whatever it is that they own, even if it's down to like a McDonald's or something like that, which you largely don't get right now.
Erik Townsend: Jim, part of your answer was that it democratizes finance, but you also said earlier that this is going to enable a market without brokers and a market without institutions, the ability to trade assets without middlemen. It seems to me that if you democratize finance, you're really putting a lot of very, very powerful people who are behind the biggest lobby in the United States, the Wall Street political lobby, you're kind of putting them out of business with a lot of what you're talking about. So how likely— I mean, how's this going to go? Because on one hand, it's very clear to me that the future of finance is decentralized finance. That's where it's all going going to be. But, you know, usually the people that are being displaced, the dinosaurs that are getting put out of business, don't go down without a fight. So are people going to wise up and be part of the future, or are they going to fight this?
Jim Bianco: Oh, they're going to fight it, and they are fighting it. 50%, 5-0, 50% of all crypto owners reside in Asia. There are more crypto owners in the continent of Africa than there are in the United States right now. If you Look again at the Chainalysis numbers. They're not going to accept that the United States Securities and Exchange Commission is going to shut all this stuff down in the name of investor protection. They've never had investor protection. They've been unbanked. They have been subject to scams and to losing their money for their whole life.
They see this as a way for them to. Have a fair fight in the economy and in the money-changing business. And so I think that yes, they're going to fight it, but they— Janet Yellen or Gary Gensler cannot convince the continent of Africa or the continent of Asia to give up on this because it's in their interest.
The Chinese can't even get their own population to really give up on this, even though they've kicked all the miners out of their country as well too. So I ultimately think just like big city mayors with Uber, you know, they threw them all out. They called it illegal. They said you needed to get a taxicab license to operate on their streets. But their populations wanted it so bad that they were forced to basically cave and allow it to happen. The same thing will happen here. Now that I've said that, it's not going to be clean and it's not going to be simple. It can be very messy along the way as they try to fight on this. But I do think that you're right, they're not going to give up without a fight. But at some point, they're going to have to realize it's a fight they can't win.
And then the question is, is just how bad do they want to wreck everything on the way out the door?
Erik Townsend: Jim, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, please tell us a little bit about what you do at Bianco Research for our listeners who want to follow your work, how they can do so.
Jim Bianco: We are an independent research firm. The best way is you could check out our website at biancoresearch.com, follow me @biancoresearch on Twitter, or Jim Bianco on LinkedIn. I try to, you know, post things from time to time in both of those spaces as well too.
Erik Townsend: And I've seen a lot of excellent articles on LinkedIn particularly. Jim, we look forward to getting you back on the program soon for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value— cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas or or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales.
It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Jim back on the show. You know, when he was talking Talking about interest rates and bonds and really what can happen in terms of the market responding to potentially inflation pressures. It made me really kind of reflect upon a lot of this financial repression that we have seen in the markets and whether it can persist. It's a really amazing conversation to have, and it's great to hear Jim's views. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more with what you said. And for me, it's always a pleasure to talk to Jim Bianco because he's such a smart guy. Talking to him about the interplay between interest rates and inflation and central bank policy and which one is really driving which and how it all works and so forth. He's really the right guy for that, and I think it's a very timely conversation. In any event, speaking of timely conversations, I want to move on to our postgame chart deck, which is titled Sizing Up the Markets and Emergent Trends. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to your homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the button that says is looking for the downloads.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's take a look at the chart deck. Starting on page 2, we've got that S&P 500, and boy, looks like we're just about flirting with that 50-day moving average.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, exactly. Like, all summer we've been showing this chart with the 50-day exponential moving average on it, and what we've seen was the pattern develop almost all year, which is that the market trades down to its 50-day moving average, which which is just an average price, which is a typical type of a, a retracement of a prior rise, uh, immediately find support, and the next leg of a rally would begin off of that pivot. And so we're interestingly at that same inflection point again, and it's really interesting to see whether or not the markets will once again deliver a déjà vu event as we approach this, uh, this area, which is the ascending trend line and Fibonacci zones all measure to. And what's interesting though about this sell-off that's slightly variant from the ones that we've seen in the past is that almost all of the ones we've seen over the summer had some sort of an almost 100 S&P point drop, like a one day that was kind of like a market gets spooked and it gets down to that moving average and then a reflexive rally almost immediately would begin and we would be just a new bull run would just have slingshotted higher from that.
What's interesting is, is that the sell-off down to this 50-day moving average this time around has not only now been double the amount of days, but we haven't had a really big down day. It's just been these, a slow methodical crawl lower down to these supports. And even yesterday on Wednesday when we had a reflexive rally, it didn't hold. And the market today is giving almost all of it back. And so it's interesting that we're at the exact same point, but how we got here and the fact that we haven't seen any real heavy selling makes it a little bit different. And it's an inflection point where really, if the pattern persists, then the buy-on-dip traders should emerge here somewhere. And if they did, there's at least 150 150 to 200 S&P points upside if we use the analog of any of those prior rallies. At the same time, wouldn't it be interesting if this was the first time we had a break of that 50-day moving average?
And especially if it happened here this week where we have the OPEX, where there's a whole bunch of gamma stuffed into these dealer books that could potentially exacerbate a sell-off. Now, that's not a forecast, but it is certainly a reality. as we go into Friday. One way or another, I think it's a really interesting moment to almost approach the market in a straddle-style way, which is like, look, if the market is gonna rally, then this is actually a great buy-on-dip point. And if it's gonna sell off, this is exactly where it would accelerate. And so it's a very important moment on the S&P chart to watch just to see which way the next trend emerges.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to page 3 and the euro.
Patrick Ceresna: Right, and so we typically talk the dollar index and the largest component of that and the real driver of the dollar index is the euro as it's trade weighted. And so the euro has been very weak, and what we had today was a legitimate breakdown of the euro, which drove that short-term rise in that U.S. dollar. And what's interesting is again we're at a very critical support line. This is. Where the euro has found lows in the past. So it's in a clear downtrend. It's coming to some key supports. And I think this is going to be a really important moment where we're going to get a tell, because if the US dollar was to break out as the euro breaks a major support line, there's all sorts of intermarket implications to that that will send, you know, shockwaves through the inner markets. And it's not Not necessarily that I'm forecasting it, but it's interesting that, you know, as we are at a very critical level on the S&P, we're also approaching some critical levels on a lot of the different currencies and other markets.
And maybe September, October will house some sort of a big move. And it's gonna be really interesting to see what these currencies do at these levels.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to my favorite chart, which is crude oil on page 4.
Patrick Ceresna: Right, I just wanted to observe here that crude oil's really decoupled from a lot of the other commodities. It's the one that's running. But a lot of the other commodities continue to struggle, particularly in this period where the US dollar might be strengthening. We're approaching that previous high where we're going to get, I think, at least crude oil bumping its head along that resistance. Not that I would imply anything bearish from that, but it'll be really interesting to see whether the bulls can hold the line up here and whether or not we do get that 52-week high.
Really, in my mind, a breakout in crude oil from these previous highs could easily head up to $80-plus on a short-term basis. And I know there's some bigger, longer-term targets that you can target, but it'll be really interesting to see whether the oil bulls can build on that. What are you watching for here?
Erik Townsend: Well, certainly breaking through to new highs above the red line you have on the chart there at $74 is going to be important. Important. I think really though it's going to be the trend in inventory drawdowns and how long those big drawdowns last into the fall. Normally seasonality says when summer, quote, that's air quotes, driving season ends, that we should expect a decrease in demand. If Phil Verleger is right and it's really about summer construction season, I'm quite certain that's continuing through the fall. So it's going to be really interesting, but I think that we're headed above $80 before, uh, this year is over. We'll see what happens. Let's move on to natural gas on page 5.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, what's interesting about nat gas is that, uh, it's one of the commodities here that has actually gone parabolic. And, uh, we saw that earlier in the year in lumber prices. And what's interesting is, is that while natural gas is doing this, there seems to be all sorts of, uh, shortages stories, uh, that are going around. But it also is driving coal prices. And it's the same time as uranium's running, which we'll talk about in a moment. But one thing that we can really see here though is that typically when we get to a parabolic stage of a rise like this, while you don't want to try to be too bold and predict the price level from which the highs will come in, the one thing that we have talked about in the past on the show is that when these parabolic rises tend to occur, they tend to blow off and mean revert often deeply. And what will be really interesting to see is whether natural gas follows that type of an analog.
You know, it wouldn't be a shocker to see nat gas print $6 or higher in this impulse. But what's interesting is that once it runs out of momentum on the upside, how deep will it drop on the other side of that mountain? Would be interesting to see whether or not we're going to see $5 and $4 prices on a pullback on the other side.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to uranium on page 6. Holy cow.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, exactly. Like, in page 6 and page 7 is the uranium stocks with the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF that we've featured on MacroVoices in the past. Like, I mean, both of them have pretty much in a span of just several weeks almost doubled in price. And just an extraordinary and very explosive move in uranium and uranium stocks. Again, we're in a situation where it's probably gone too much too quickly on the short term. But one thing that's for sure is that uranium bulls are now finally being rewarded for their patience. And we're seeing that a new bull trend is here. You know, while I anticipate that both of them will likely pause and mean revert some of this rise. I also think that this could be the beginning of a trend that may last for many months and may still go higher. So maybe all dips should be bought at this stage.
Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, I just had lunch with Marin Katusa yesterday, and I think we agree with you on this, which is what's going on here is the fundamental drivers for uranium couldn't be more bullish. It's a really good story. However, with a great big underscore, Sprott entering this market along with this WallStreetBets propaganda, whatever you want to call it, around uranium is really, really goosed this thing to the point where there's a significant short-term risk of some kind of blow-off here as that extreme momentum wears off and maybe a retrace. Think what happened to GameStop, the WallStreetBets manipulation stock.
You know, they got it way the heck up to ridiculously high levels, but with a lot of up and down along the way. So far, uranium's been straight up. I think we're in for at least a correction, but I do think that we're going much higher before this is ultimately over because they're right about the fundamentals. And of course, everybody's focused on those fundamentals. I still think it was the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF advertising on MacroVoices that started this entire trend. of uranium stocks, but that's just my take.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to gold futures on page 8.
Patrick Ceresna: Right, and what's interesting is, uh, well, we'll talk gold futures here, but gold miners and silver and then actually some of the other precious metals have all had a pretty bad down day today, and they've all, uh, really reversed back down. I mean, one of the things that I was observing about the reflexive rally that we saw throughout August in, um, in gold was that often these have to go back and retest some of those levels. And what we're probably seeing here is some sort of a key retest to just determine whether or not gold is putting in a bottom or not. And so one of the things is not necessarily to make the forecast if it is, but rather to really watch. I think the next week or two of price action in gold is going to be pretty critical because if the bulls dig in, and use this as a buy-on-dip opportunity, and we find ourselves higher later in the next week or two, then that could actually start to solidify that a change in the trend from what's been in place for almost a year-plus now might actually start working on the upside.
But I think it's very early to make that call. But I think that the kind of big tell is gonna happen here in the next week or two.
Erik Townsend: Is this an inverse head and shoulders that's formed since the middle of June here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, if, uh, if it starts to rally off this point, many technicians will see that pattern for sure. And that's, uh, that's why I think whether or not gold makes it all the way back to its previous lows or whether it turns off of this little dip is going to be a key part of determining whether that is a, a turn point.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 9, and copper futures still consolidating.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, what's interesting is, is that, well, you know, while we see oil breaking out, it's one of the few commodities that is. I mean, and uranium of course. But when you look here, copper had that extraordinary bull run that ran through the first half of 2021. But really, we've been now in a multi-month consolidation. And what was really interesting is last week we had a really nice bullish breakout attempt to the upside of copper, and the bulls couldn't hold it. And so far, they've given back the entire breakout attempt. At a minimum, What that is telling me is, is that it just might be a little bit early for the next bull run on copper to get started. It'll be interesting to see where and how the supports hold during these consolidations, and we'll be looking for, for when there is a bull breakout that sticks.
But right now, so far, the one that started last week has not been sticking.
Erik Townsend: Now, Patrick, when we talk bond yields on MacroVoices, we normally start with the US 10-year Treasury. How come we're looking at the the 30-year Treasury here on page 10.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's interesting is because when you go farther out on the yield curves, you're actually seeing that they're becoming actually less and less responsive to these inflation pressures. And what's interesting is that that 30-year yield still hovering around 1.88 here, well under 2%, in spite of the fact that inflation is probably running the hottest it's been in a very, very long time. And It's interesting to see that it's just simply not responding. And one of the ways to kind of reflect on that is because the 5-year yield has been somewhat working higher. When we look on page 11 and look at the 5s-30s yield curve, what you can see here is that this continues to decline. It's almost like the market is really almost buying in the transitory inflation argument, at least reflected in this. And really anyone who's been predicting inflation and using the bond market as the way to express it has really not been rewarded at all for that, making that call right.
And it's interesting how the bond market continues to manifest itself. But what is the most interesting about that is if you go on page 12 where we show the iShares TIPS Bond ETF, one of the best ways then to reflect or capture that has been to be long TIPS because they're actually pricing in that inflation versus those 30-year yields and 10-year bonds and so on that have not been reflecting that. And so it's gonna be really interesting to me to see whether the TIPS continue to outperform here in the next little while.
Erik Townsend: And listeners, if you enjoy Patrick's chart decks, be sure to check out page 13 where you can get a free trial of Big Picture Trading, Patrick's service, and get Patrick's webinars every single day of the week. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook, which is discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to a Knowledge Leaders Capital article on the 5 divergences in the stock market to keep an eye out for in the fall, as well as a great interview with Lyn Alden on the biggest thing in macro. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like If you have a research roundup that you would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, Thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com. The internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet. each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Paul Krake — View From The Peak founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 288 was recorded on September 9th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
View From The Peak founder Paul Krake returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss what Paul calls mega thematics, the important trends to watch in the current macro environment. Patrick Ceresna is off this week. Kevin Muir joins me as this week's co-host. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Kevin and I will discuss the US Economic Surprise Index as it relates to inflation.
Kevin Muir: Erik, great to be with you. Let's jump right into it. What are you seeing this week in the S&P 500?
Erik Townsend: Absolutely nothing that I haven't seen the last umpteen weeks, which is the melt-up continues. What's it been, all of 3 days now that we've gone since the S&P showed a new all-time high and already people are panicking. At some point, Kevin, you and I both know this has to end badly, but I don't think it's anytime soon.
Kevin Muir: It is being a slow summer. It's one of those things that you were better off just taking the month off and RVing across Canada.
Erik Townsend: Is that what you did?
Kevin Muir: Yes, that's what I did. Okay, so let's talk about the next asset that you love talking about is the The US Dollar, anything exciting happen there this week?
Erik Townsend: Nothing whatsoever. Nothing to report. Summer doldrums again. Until we see a daily close below 89 or above, I don't know, 93.5, 94 in there somewhere, we're consolidating. And I think that consolidation is likely to continue for an extended period. Why? Because nobody's really sure what to make of monetary policy. It keeps changing.
Kevin Muir: Well, surely there must be something that you can say about crude oil that's different. What do you got to say about crude oil?
Erik Townsend: Well, I've always got something to say about crude oil. I think what, what happened this week was we had what would have been a very bullish inventory report. Somebody probably saw that coming. So what happened was we got the famous let's release the bearish data just a few minutes before the inventory came out. So China announced that it back in July had released some oil from its SPR. Now, obviously, what happened past tense back in July is not relevant to the market.
around potentially China's future intentions to sell off more of the oil that it's accumulated in its Strategic Petroleum Reserve. That sent the market basically crashing until EIA inventory came out this morning, delayed until Thursday this week because of the holiday. Crude oil drawing down 1.5 million barrels. Now, that's a significant drawdown, but not a monstrous one. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 1.9 million barrels. Well, where's the monstrous drawdown? It's in gasoline. 7.2 million barrels of gasoline drawn down and another 3.1 million barrels of distillates. So 10 million barrels of finished products in addition to 1.5 million barrels of crude oil was drawn down last week. US production collapsing all the way down to 10 million barrels. That's down 1.5 million barrels from last week. That's not a new trend, folks. That's entirely hurricane related. So anytime you have a hurricane weather event, it basically invalidates a lot of the inventory data for several weeks, you know, until we get back to normal.
So I don't read too much into that. But in general, I think we're trying to break through a resistance level and get out of this downtrend and resume an uptrend. I think it would have happened today if not for this news release out of China. And it looks like what happened was we were down on that, then inventory came up, and it was right back up to the numbers we were at before the China news. Now it seems like inventory data is wearing off. We haven't gotten to the close yet. We're recording early this week, but we're almost down to the 100-day moving average. If we close below that, it could be another wave down to a new cycle low, down maybe below $60.
I'm leaning the other way, at least I have been until today's tape action, which is I thought we were about to see an upside breakout.
Kevin Muir: Sounds like some other people apart from me had the idea to go drive across the country, and the big gasoline draws might be indicative of more Americans doing that.
Erik Townsend: Well, that may be. You, you could be responsible for the new trend, Kevin.
Kevin Muir: Okay, let's move on to gold. Is there anything new that's caught your eye there?
Erik Townsend: Well, as I said last week, what we were waiting for was to get above those long-term moving averages. And I said we need to get a close above 1820 and stay there for a few days. Well, guess what? We got the close above 1820. We didn't stay there. We went straight back down the very next day. And at this point, we're back down to the, the lower end of the support range. And it's going to be really interesting to see what happens. I thought we were going to see an upside breakout, but a fake breakout is a very bearish technical signal, particularly Particularly if we get a daily close below that cluster of moving averages, the bottom of them, it looks like it's the 21-day moving average at $1,795. If we get a daily close or a weekly close even below that, it suggests we might be headed down to new lows below $1,680.
Kevin Muir: Well, one of the things that might be weighing on the gold market is the bonds. Bonds seem to just be grinding higher in terms of yield. What do you see there?
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't know what to make of yields. You know, everybody, I think, gets caught in this mental trap where they say, surely the 35-year bond bull market must be over now. So that means there has to be a 35-year bond bear market starting and it's time to short everything. Well, wait a minute. You know, end of World War II, it took 10 years for interest rates to bottom and finally turn around. It could be it takes several years. And I think there's lots of reasons to expect the rest of the 2020s to be a very low interest rate environment.
Kevin Muir: Well, thanks for those updates, Erik. This week's featured guest is View from the Peak founder, Paul Krake. Erik, why did we invite Paul back to the show?
Erik Townsend: Paul is a really smart macro guy, and we've had him on the show before. With everything that's going on with respect to inflation and everything else, I wanted to get him back on the show for an update. And I think it's very timely because you'll hear a lot of his views are very pertinent to a lot of the concepts we've been talking about on MacroVoices in recent shows.
Kevin Muir: Erik's interview with Paul Krake is coming up as MacroVoices continues, right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the FinTech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Paul Krake, founder of View from the Peak.
Erik Townsend: Paul, it's been several years since I had you on the program. It's great to get you back. I want to imagine, because, you know, so many people have said that in finance the week after Labor Day tends to be kind of when the, the big boys get back from the Hamptons and, uh, and things start to move. I want you to imagine you've been running the macro desk for the biggest bank in New York for the summer, and the big boys are back from the Hamptons, and your job is to brief them. What are the macro trends that they need to be thinking about? What are the thematic macro things that are on the horizon? What should they be thinking as they take over the, the reins of the macro desk?
Paul Krake: So, Erik, am I in the office or am I still at home?
Erik Townsend: I don't know.
Paul Krake: Because again, that's— and that obviously is a big part of it, right? Because, you know, if you're looking at this If you look at the world through a traditional macro lens, a lens that I think is structurally flawed, and we'll get into that a little later, but this rolling 3-month cycle that the macro world tends to live in.
Obviously, if you're looking between— let's take it a little further and say now in the end of the year, you've got the sort of the 2— I think there's 2 major narratives that you need to think about, or 3. Firstly is COVID and the transition towards the reopening world. Delta variant, then the vagaries around that and how that's affecting different parts of the world, putting them in different cycles and the like. Secondly, and most pertinent to the value of asset prices, is the prospect of tapering. Do they? Don't they? When does that begin? And how does that work into the economic framework that we look at going into 2022?
And the third thing, which again, we are, as again, We are looking through this rolling 3-month window, is common prosperity, is the notion of what China is doing. And that, Erik, I assume we don't have 5 or 6 hours for that to explore that in the depth that that deserves. And I think if I was to make one observation at the morning meeting at my very large investment bank where I run macro, I would say to everyone that to look at this through a blanket approach or a singular lens is is the wrong way to look at China currently because it is much more nuanced and complicated than most people think. And, and frankly, that framework of China and common prosperity is more than a 3-month— is more than a 3-month view. And I think frankly, the other stuff of the lingering effects of COVID or this what I call COVID scarring, how that, how that plays out, and obviously the implications for tapering a rate tightening cycle? Do we actually get to that rate tightening cycle?
Obviously goes further than the end of the year, but within the 3-month window, that's what we think you should be thinking about.
Erik Townsend: I like some of the longer-term thematic things. So beyond China, what other thematic macro trends should we be thinking about?
Paul Krake: So, Erik, the way I'm sort of thinking about this, and I think it's my own deficiencies, but again, I'm not going to be the one who takes on the algorithms that win. So within that 3-month window that I was talking about, I mean, the ability for and I as, as human people to, um, you know, to outperform the machines is, is remarkably difficult. And we've got— every year that goes by shows how, how much more difficult that process, that process is. So, and I think before we, you know, before we started recording, we started talking about, um, you know, changing the framework for macro. And I think, and I think we need to— I think we need to be doing that and trying to look through a much further time frame. And obviously, that's easier said than done because, you know, we are victims of mark-to-market and the embedded volatility and the vagaries of prices, which you and I have no control over, can stop us out of the best-laid longer-term thinking. But no, I'm looking at the world through what I call mega thematics.
And, you know, obviously you have to have a bunch of assumptions when you look at the world through mega thematics. You know, I'm a believer that rates will not rise for years to come because of my inherent disinflationary biases. So that's part of it. Let's word it slightly differently. If you were going to build a research business or you're going to build a trading business, what areas should you look at? How should you bucket the research process? So everyone's got to have a climate bucket. So you've got to be doing climate research because you can't do research on China, you can't do research on the ECB, you can't do research on oil and gas without looking at that through a climate lens.
Goldman says $50 trillion by 2050 is going to be spent to decarbonize the world. All right? So let's say there's a margin of error of $20 trillion a side on that. It's a big bloody number. So climate has to be front and center in people's analysis for the next 2 decades, 3 decades and beyond, because it's going to be at the epicenter of everything. You know, China is going to be the world's largest economy. Most of us are deeply skeptical about Chinese data. The one data point you can be confident in is it's got 4 times the population of the United States, and eventually it's going to be the world's biggest economy. Now, whether that's the world's biggest economy that has truly outsized global influence, whether it's the world's largest economy where its asset markets are reflective of its economic might, whether it's the world's largest economy and looking inward from a technology perspective, whether it's the world's largest economy with a currency that is a true rival to the dollar, where they're all things that remain to be seen.
But the amount of funds that I know of, be them macro, be them global long-short equity, be them credit, who don't have dedicated China research is, I think, exposes the flaws in the ways that we are looking at macro markets, 'cause China does dominate a lot of them. And then you've got other big mega themes. Demographics is one of them, obviously, which there's a Japanification of the world argument that goes with deteriorating Western demographics. You can look at AI, you can look at biomedical, you can look at digitization. We can debate whether crypto and blockchain deserve to be in the group of mega thematics. And then for me, the one that I'm very, very focused on longer term is The notion of what I call the Transformative 20, which is the 20 companies that I think will redefine the ways we work, we shop, we travel, we communicate. And every decade since you and I were boys, every 10 years, the top 10 market cap companies changed.
And I believe that cycle has come to an end. So Exxon was once the world's biggest company, but Exxon will never make cars where Tesla can be the world's most profitable energy company. And Pfizer can never do search, but Google can do healthcare. And if I'm Jamie Dimon and I'm looking over my shoulder about who my biggest rival is, well, it's not HSBC or Citibank, it's probably Amazon. So the addressable market for these 20 companies is simply remarkable. I mean, I think that for me, you've got, if you as a macro investor, and I get this is a cliché that Google's the new dollar yen, but you've got to have a handle if you're a macro investor on what those 20 transformative transformative companies are doing, the fact that the majority of them are domiciled in the United States, for example, has real implications for the value of the dollar.
Are you going to see structural dollar weakness if the world's greatest companies remain domiciled in the US? It's an open-ended question. So there's some of the way I'm viewing the world, which is— and again, I don't use the word macro like I used to, Erik. In fact, I shy away, I run away from it a lot because—
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Paul Krake: Macro does have a rates and currency connotation, and rates around the world are anchored at zero, and the Sharpe ratio of currencies is what it is.
To be a true modern macro investor, macro has to have a broader definition.
Erik Townsend: I want to come back to climate and the tapering and a lot of the other things that you mentioned in that first answer, but let's start with China and really focus on China. Tell me what you mean by the situation in China, because I've talked to some people who've said, Look, the situation in China is bad. They're really struggling under COVID and lockdowns. And boy, the Communist Party could risk losing power because of how bad the situation is there. And I talked to other people and they say, look, China's clearly got a plan. We've got a very realistic risk of them starting World War III with the United States and winning.
Okay, wait a minute. Those are 2 very different stories. And yet I hear lots of people sort of They're all talking about China as the most important thing, but they've got wildly different views on what's happening in China. What's your take?
Paul Krake: Well, and there's also a third one where China just does what it does, looks inward, becomes the best society it can be, and doesn't really have global ambitions of a military nature. So there's all these things. Now, let me give you the optimistic version of this and where I think that the uber bears who have consistently gotten China wrong.
Right? So actually, let's start with the framework of why they've gotten China wrong, right? And I'm not talking about you know those who who have been bearish on China for five years or so. I'm going back. Let's go back to Deng Xiaoping, right? So the two the two great foreign policy mistakes the United States made in regards to China was a belief that you couldn't have economic prosperity without political freedom.
And to go back and quote Bill Clinton, that controlling the internet is like nailing Jell-O to a wall. Well, China nailed Jell-O to a wall. And the third one, which my good friend Louis Gave was talking to me about recently, Louis made the point that maybe you can have a closed capital account and still be on an organic path to being a reserve currency. So there's all these misconceptions that have been made against China. And certainly, look, let me start by saying I'm not here to defend the indefensible in regards to the actions of China domestically. I mean, their behavior over the years in many ways against the Uyghurs in Tiananmen Square back to '89 and the like has been absolutely abhorrent, but it doesn't mean that the model is going to fail.
So you get to the rise of Xi Jinping, a new style of leader, a leader who has taken very much a Maoist view on having the charismatic leader that the party can get behind. And sees that the Western world is pushing against— back against China in a myriad of ways. You know, you've got semiconductor embargoes and you've got a force for, you know, uh, issues over, over, you know, be it sanctions over human rights. And then, you know, the Chinese feel that they are under siege from the Western world. I mean, China never tried to deliberately destroy a global brand like Nike or Nike or Starbucks, but Huawei, China's true global brand back in the, in the, in the, you know, from 2015 onwards, was under systematic attack to put it out of business by the Chinese government on the basis of intelligence which was flimsy, which was flimsy at best, right? So China, China feels like it is under siege. And, you know, China has a, has a, an energy vulnerability. It has a set, it has a technology vulnerability, as was exposed through the semiconductor embargoes.
And it also has an overdependency on the, on the US dollar, which is, um, which is playing out through a slew of changes that are being implemented right now. So that's the framework that I think is, is in place. Now let's look at the, the blanket approach that people are taking to China, an approach which I think is deeply, deeply flawed, right? So, so suddenly China is uninvestable, and you've had these draconian measures against against Ant Group and against Meituan, against Tencent and the like. And it's making China uninvestable. And it's a sign that the fragility of the Chinese Communist Party, because they have to clamp down on these, on these great companies to control them.
Or they're just doing what every other country in the world wished it could do. So, Erik, just think about this. So my 14-year-old, when I told him that kids in China were banned from playing video games for only 3— or only could play video games for 3 hours a week.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Paul Krake: The look of horror on his face, as in he looked like he wanted to get on a plane and fight for the rights of Chinese teenagers to blur their eyes with video games, right? But you ask me, you ask other parents, and a ban on and restricting access to video games, maybe not a bad thing. Maybe not a bad thing, right? Meituan comes out and it gets a fine Because it doesn't pay its drivers minimum wage. The stock's down 17% and Meituan is uninvestable.
Until you realize that that's the same thing California and London did to Uber.
Data privacy provisions. The new data privacy laws are very, very similar to GDPR. So I think what we face is a massive, massive double standard here. And a good example of this is as follows. Tencent gets a $50 million fine over Tencent Music in terms of a An acquisition that created a monopoly of 80% market share in music streaming for Tencent Music. On the same day— oh, sorry, and the stock's down 8%.
Same day, the EU fines Amazon €900 million for a breach of anti-competitive regulation in Europe.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Paul Krake: €900 million fine. Stock doesn't move. China is uninvestable because it's putting anti-monopoly regulation on its companies. EU does that to Amazon and that's okay, right? So I think that if you look at a lot of the, the tech regulation that you have witnessed, it's really popular.
It's really popular, right? Because we have to at all times distinguish between the Communist Party and the Chinese people. And the Communist Party is all-powerful and, and the like, and we have seen them do, you know, think whatever they want. But enforcing regulation that's popular amongst the people is a hell of a lot easier. Right? So Chinese consumers are no different to British, Australian, American, or Canadian consumers. They know when free is not free. They know when they're getting screwed. They want their privacy protected from companies who are going to abuse that data. So therefore, a lot of the measures that we have seen, and particularly the measures that we saw in regards to for-profit tutoring, which was extreme— and by the way, we saw something similar in the United States in 2010 when President Obama banned for-profit student, uh, private student loans.
You know, it's— this stuff is really popular. Um, so the optimist, the optimist in me says that a lot of the measures that we have seen related to Chinese tech are measures that, you know, the US wished it could do, but it has a polarized political model that means that frankly not a lot gets done. And the EU, you know, does have GDPR, but GDPR took years to implement because you've got to have You have to have 27 countries in consensus for things like this.
These measures look really harsh in China, but the party being the party means that it can get stuff done.
Erik Townsend: I want to ask you about a specific aspect of this China situation, which is Hong Kong has served for decades as kind of the Western liaison or gateway city to Asian finance, to the point that you and I both have been Hong Kong residents, but neither one of us is spending our time now in Hong Kong because of the changes there and the loss of independence that's occurred.
What does this mean for the finance industry and for Hong Kong? And does Singapore come into the equation?
Paul Krake: I think that Hong Kong plays a vital role, particularly in the context of what I think is the inevitability of the delisting of Chinese shares from US exchanges. I do think that's coming. I don't think that's avoidable because at the end of the day, China views data through a national security lens and the Chinese are simply not going to let Chinese regulators fly to Shanghai and go through the books and records of its strategically important companies, right?
And, and I think you'll— what you'll see with Hong Kong is Hong Kong is going to play a vitally important role in the next 3 years as being the, the, the safety valve that allows, you know, China— those Chinese firms that are listed in New York on the NASDAQ or NYSE in particular to move to Hong Kong if they haven't already done so. So I think it plays, it plays a very important role in, in that regard. But look, longer term, from a purely from a capital market standpoint, the regulatory environment is going to morph more towards the Chinese regulatory environment than having its own Hong Kong's own independent regulatory environment now. And that's purely from a from a from a capital market standpoint. You know, look, I don't think there's a threat to the Hong Kong dollar anytime soon because obviously that creates that does create the It's the organic source of a separation between China and Hong Kong, which look, eventually it goes away. I mean, the joint declaration, as it stood when, as Deng Xiaoping referred to her as, that woman negotiated it, it doesn't resemble what Thatcher put together.
And it wasn't the intention of what Chris Patten was thinking about in '97.
And so I think that Hong Kong is not the place that you and I fell in love with. It is, you know, it's an incredibly problematic place, not only less so for expats, but, you know, it's certainly not an appealing place for expats to live like it used to be. Certainly a very problematic place for Hong Kong families who have been there, who are indigenous Hong Kong families who have been there for a very long time.
Look, I think the future is very bright for Hong Kong as a capital market, as this transition away from, you know, capital formation in the United States, you know, it takes, it takes its part. And that could be another, it could be another 3 years. Singapore will be always there on the, um, in the periphery. But, you know, from a capital market standpoint, Singapore has continued to be a constant sort of disappointment in that, in that regard. So I think there's, there's life in Hong Kong left yet. I think that the, you know, again, it's all about the capital market side of things and Again, the place you and I fell in love with, it's not that place anymore.
Erik Townsend: Paul, when you introduced the concept of mega thematics earlier, you mentioned climate as one of the important considerations there. Let's talk about climate and also this broader ESG trend, which frankly, I think is more marketing than reality. What do you make of— well, let's start with climate. What's important there? And then how well is Wall Street responding to that need with its
Paul Krake: Yeah. And it's— so just to make the point, Erik, that we run a whole program, we're launching a whole product called Climate Transformed, and you will not see the word ESG anywhere in what we do, right? Because we don't do ESG, we do climate research, and it's very, very different, right?
So I think of ESG as a fiduciary obligation. I think of it as a legal and accounting way of organizing oneself where what I call climate researchers investing in climate technologies and climate companies that are going to help in this decarbonization process. No, look, I think it's vitally important, not just through the sheer numbers of the sheer amount of dollars that will have to be spent in this decarbonization process, but I think the ECB is a wonderful example of this, who is prioritizing carbon-related infrastructure as part of its agenda. And I think that's a remarkable development, which will mean, you know, talks about the, you know, the monetization of green debt, you know, the ability to make it much easier for deficit spending on European infrastructure. You know, obviously there's massive asset allocation switches in regards to what industries are investable and the like, which that is part of the ESG angle. And I think just as, you know, investors had the right to to pick and choose whether they wanted to invest in tobacco.
I think that investors should have the right to pick and choose if they want to invest in, um, if they want to invest in carbon, in, uh, in, in carbon-heavy, in carbon-heavy industries. But, you know, I think that there's that angle. I think there's the angle of, from a research perspective, of, you know, really trying to quantify what the carbon bills are going to be for a company like Total or BHP or Freeport or whoever it is.
And it's hard if you try to find estimates of what the carbon liability is for these companies, it's really difficult to do. So I think that the amount of research that has to go into this is going to be just enormous.
And I wrote on the weekend that I think that if we are rethinking the way that we build a research firm, you don't have mining analysts and oil analysts and utilities analyst and mobility analyst or autos analyst, you have them all under the, the climate bucket because, you know, the regulatory frameworks, the, the taxation implications, the funding implications are going to be relatively homogeneous across a lot of these, a lot of these sectors.
But the big one for me and the, and the big challenge, the big challenge, Erik, that I face for someone who has been a card-carrying disinflationist for a very, very long time is the notion of the inflationary impacts of the climate adjustment. And I'm a huge believer that the consensus of the sale of 30 million EVs by 2025 is just going to be way off base. I think the number is at 40, is it 45, is it 50? It's some huge number, right? It's an enormous number, but it's not mutually exclusive because of the lack of investment that's going into Going into, um, you know, into fossil fuels that, you know, if you sell 40 million, 40 million cars in by 2025, you know, you've still got what, 400 million vehicles, cars, scooters, motorcycles that are running on petrol, right? And that's an environment for $150, $150 oil, $25,000 a ton copper.
These sort of numbers, which have rather hefty inflation implications if they play out like that. So the climate transition does have consequences. Look, if we crack the code to zero-cost energy, I mean, that's a remarkable world that we would live in.
But we got to get from A to B. And we're a lot closer to A than we are to B. And for all the opportunities that exist because of the climate agenda, there are plenty of externalities. And one of those major ones is a potential inflation externality.
Erik Townsend: I think it's really important to think carefully about this phenomenon that you just described of people overlooking the lack of investment that I think is really important. You just described a lack of investment in oil and gas because so many people have convinced themselves That oil and gas is going away because we're all going to electric vehicles. It's going to solve everything. Well, guess what else they're not investing in? It's the build-out of the electric grid that would be necessary to support all those electric vehicles. So you can't replace the oil and gas with the electric vehicles that you don't have the electric grid to support.
Yet we're making all of this huge investment because things like Tesla are incredibly cool and sexy and hot to invest in right now. But the products they're building won't work unless we do some other things like build out the electric grid that nobody has a plan for. What do we make of this?
Paul Krake: Well, I think we've got to be— when we say we, I think we've got to be very careful about this, right? So, you know, if we are— if we— if we is China, well, what you've just said is wrong because China's got a handle on that, right? Because they're building— they've got a plan and they've got an industrial policy that revolves around this and climate as a priority. And every facet of this climate priority has been has been thought out to the nth degree. Now, is it going to happen seamlessly? Absolutely, absolutely not. You know, when, when the coal industry employs as many people as the population of Norway, you know, you've got some— you know, this is not a seamless process. On the other side of the coin, I think you've described the US perfectly. You know, it's, it's going to be very, very problematic longer, longer term.
I mean, how do you get— you know, how do you encourage Shell and Exxon to build You know, to have electric charging stations inside all of their gas stations, right? How do you have a standalone charging center, which is a huge infrastructure spend across, you know, across I-95 or Route 66 or whatever it is, to allow the current range of cars, which will grow significantly over time, no doubt about that.
You know, these are huge costs.
I think Europe is somewhere in the middle. I think that Europe is, particularly with the help of the ECB, is in a better deficit position than the United States is in currently. And there's certainly more of an overriding priority to make sure that every facet of climate infrastructure is met.
Again, doesn't mean it's seamless. But look, the problem the US has is that you have this This polarized government, which means that very, very little gets done. You're on these rolling 2-year election cycles, which means that— if I put it this way, Erik, if I was to tell you that after all the spending that we've witnessed in the last couple of years, that we get to the 2022 midterms, Republicans take the House as they statistically will. Since 1938, there's only been 2 instances when the incumbent party has actually taken seats in the House. So let's assume the Republicans take the House in 2022. Are we discounting that there could be a Tea Party movement where they just turn around and say to Joe Biden, all these social programs, all these— all this green agenda, no, we've spent too much money, we're shutting it down, you know, and we go back to a Tea Party style movement? I mean, I can't think you can— you can't discount on that.
But the one given in all of that environment is the prospect of true structural, structural change, whether it's climate infrastructure spending, whether it's tax reform, whether it's dealing with, you know, unprecedented income inequality, whether it's dealing with— whether it's social issues, whether it's environmental issues and the like. Well, these things don't happen in an environment where you're on these rolling 2-year election cycles. And one of the big victims of that is what you just alluded to, which is How do you have a full climate infrastructure in a world where politically it's incredibly hard to implement?
Erik Townsend: Well, and I think that related to that too is going back to some of those shorter-term macro factors. Let's talk about rates. We've got the Fed threatening again to taper. Are they really going to taper someday? Is this just talk? And what does the actual cost of capital becoming non-zero again What's that going to mean to all these other trends?
Paul Krake: Well, okay. But again, there's 2 things we need to think about. There's tapering. There's tapering and then there's raising rates. Are they going to taper? They got to taper. They will. I think it's pretty safe to say that there is no good reason to have emergency measures in an economy that is growing at the rates that the US economy is growing at.
I think it is pretty— well, I think a better example is I haven't heard a Fed official in 6 months tell me a good reason why QE is good for the real economy, right? I know it's good for asset prices, but I haven't heard why it's good for the real economy. And, um, you know, I think that we have a Federal Reserve that is so fixated on, on asset values or preventing assets from, from contracting and thus tightening financial conditions that everything revolves around that. And we can have— still have emergency measures, you know, some 18, 18 months after the— after COVID began when there's clear evidence that, you know, economically we don't need, we don't need that. So tapering is, tapering is coming. You know, are we going to get to the Fed's unemployment targets by year end? That's, that's touch and go. So you'll, you'll be tapering into 2022.
But the scenario I've got, Erik, which again does have a lot of ifs to it, so please forgive me for this, but you know, what do we do? We can be confident that growth in from Q2 onwards growth and inflation from Q2 onwards is going to be slower than it was in 2021, just purely due to base effects.
You know, you will have, because they are a contentious midterm election coming up in, in November of 2022, which means that the chances of the Fed raising, hiking rates in Q4 is relatively, I think, relatively slim. So if you are going to get a tightening Hopefully it happens before Q4. But you would be clearly, if the Fed does raise rates in 2022 and 2023, I would argue that they are raising rates into a slowing growth environment, right? So my, my if scenario, which gets me to 10-year yields at zero in, you know, in the second half of 2023, is as follows: that growth slows, the Fed doesn't get a chance, you know, they may finish tapering, but they don't get a chance to raise rates because Growth is continuing to slow because of base effects. Republicans take the House in 2022, and what we can be confident in is that they're not going to support reconciliation.
Our deficit in 2023 is going to be a fraction of what it was in 2022. And frankly, there's no free lunch with all of this. If you take a deficit from 18% of GDP down to, let's say, down to 6% of GDP, which would— well, 7%, which was the non-crisis high under President Trump, post-war that is.
Suddenly, you've gotten the scenario where growth is collapsing in 2023 because of fiscal contraction and they haven't raised rates. And that's my scenario for rates to— for 10-year yields to go to zero as we go into 2024 in the year of the next presidential election.
Erik Townsend: And how long do rates stay at zero or very close to zero?
Paul Krake: I think it's considerable. I think it's a considerable amount of time. And again, my structural disinflation biases are coming out thick and fast here. I think that if you— put it this way, if you've got a recession, if you have recession in late '23 going into 2024, a recession, by the way, that has been— it will be the first recession that we go into where we have zero interest rates.
Right. And here's where we get into— if we're looking 2 years forward, there's more questions than answers, right? So is there pressure because the 2-year note goes negative for the Fed to go to negative yields? Is there pressure for QE to look at other assets? Clearly what we've seen with quantitative easing this time around was absolutely unprecedented.
Do we have the investment-grade bailouts that we had, like we had with every other crisis? that we have. And I'm not, I'm not saying we have the makings of a crisis in 2024, but you are going into recession with your potential recession with zero interest rates. And that's not, and that's not a good outcome for, that's not a good outcome for anybody.
And then we get into the arguments, Erik, about, you know, Japanification, bad Western demographics. And, you know, I look at it this way.
We keep talking about a normalized world, right? What does the normal— what does a normalized post-COVID world look like? Well, if we go back to what the world looked like Well, that was a disinflationary world, right? It was a deteriorating demographic world. It was a world where the dollar was doing very, very little. It was a world where growth equity outperformed. It was a lost decade for emerging markets. It was a decade where Chinese assets outside of tech did next to nothing. It's a world where Asian growth becomes a greater percentage of global GDP. But at the end of the day, if we are normalizing, and that's normalizing deficits Normalizing with COVID normalizing growth. Well, the world we left behind in 2019 and before that was a disinflationary, low-growth, poor demographic world. And that's the world I think we return to.
Erik Townsend: Well, let's talk about some of the knock-on effects and consequences of that, because one of the ways that some people value equities is by comparing the yield that the dividend produces to what the yield is on the risk-free rate The so-called risk-free rate of Treasuries. Well, if the Treasury rate is zero, then in theory, equities are valued at infinity. And as much as you want to say, well, it's impossible for them to go to infinity, dude, look at the S&P chart.
Paul Krake: Never say never. And Erik, by the way, what I'm about to say is going to annoy everybody, so please forgive me. And you've got two— so you basically have two arguments here, right? And by the way, of these 2 arguments, I tend to favor a watered-down version of what you implied.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Paul Krake: So if you've got rates at zero and they're stuck at zero and you've got a 10-year yield at zero, assume, right? You've got 2 scenarios, theoretically both correct and both polar opposite. And those 2 scenarios are the one that you described, which is where you look at the world's best growth and cash generative companies, and you think about what the value of those forward earnings are, and if you imply a discount rate of 0 to those, then the implied multiple on the world's greatest growth companies is really darn high. So Microsoft is fair value at 50 times forward, 60 times forward, 70 times forward— pick your number, right? Could be infinity, right? Pick your number.
That's theory number Theory number 2 is that zero interest rates are implying where the growth dynamic is. And if you add a reasonable risk premium to equity, risk premium to that low growth rate, you've still got a low growth rate. And that all we've done in a world that doesn't have further multiple expansion, because you do have just a slower growth and slower profit environment, that actually is a an era of weak, of weak returns in the years ahead.
So both those arguments are theoretically correct and absolutely polar opposite. I take— I, because I focus a lot on these, on these 20 transformative companies, and literally 15 picked themselves, and we can debate the others, you know, that they are so, you know, the cash generative nature of what they do, the dominance of indices for these companies like, you know, like Microsoft and Amazon and Apple, etc. And also the addressable markets that they have. You know, again, if we were to wake up tomorrow and Amazon is the biggest rival in life insurance to a company like Liberty Mutual, would you be shocked?
Probably not, right? Because the addressable markets of what they can do, because they attract the best people, they have the best data, they have effectively a negligible cost of funding, they can achieve a lot. And that's an environment for Microsoft in 5 years to be a $4 trillion company and Amazon to be a $4 trillion company and Apple being on its way when it makes its— when the Apple car comes out to be on its path to being the first $5 trillion company, right? I tend to favor those arguments a little better than the, than the low growth, the low theoretical return. But again, it's, it's, it's complicated, um, and it's very annoying because they're just totally different outcomes.
Erik Townsend: So it sounds like the bottom line is the companies that are able to make a profit, even in an environment where the entire economy is completely broken, are the ones you invest in because you have no choice.
Paul Krake: You have no choice. Yeah. You have no choice and you had no choice now.
Erik Townsend: And it explains why the FAANG stocks have seen this just extraordinary breadth divergence.
Paul Krake: Yeah. And look, do I want to own Virgin Galactic? No. Do I want to own Peloton? No. I mean, there's a difference between the reopening stocks and these companies that are so structurally, they're, they're an imperative to everybody's life. I mean, I'm a slave to— I'm a slave to my iPhone. I'm a slave to Google. I've got, you know, my wife thinks I'm having an affair with Alexa, right? I mean, we're all— yeah, we're obsessed with this stuff. And we never— um, and these are so ingrained in the ways we, we shop, we travel, we communicate, we, we work, that, you know, I don't see a scenario outside of of an inflation scare and spiking rates and flipping that, you know, that the value of those quality cash flows, flipping that on its head.
I don't see why these companies don't continue to, at a minimum, earn supercharged, supercharged profits in— and not only in the sectors they're in, but in future sectors as, as well. Now obviously tech regulation is, is a big part of this, and we've seen what's happened in China. If you can re— if you can regulate tech But look, it took 10 years to do to get the antitrust case against Microsoft settled, right? I mean, do we do we expect the United States government to move any quicker against a against an Amazon that I've got no idea what that company looks like in five years' time, and I don't know what Facebook looks like in five years' time. And God knows God knows how much money Google's going to make out of healthcare in five years' time.
So what do these companies look like in the years in the years ahead? Put it this way: without regulation. And without an inflation shock, the path to their continued rerating to become $3 trillion, $4 trillion, $5 trillion companies, I think is a path that is well lit.
Erik Townsend: Returning to the mega thematics, something you haven't mentioned yet is this digitization trend where we've seen everything from digital currencies like Bitcoin that were designed to compete with government money to governments beginning to look at central bank-issued digital currencies. To now, really the hottest trend, I think, in finance is DeFi, decentralized finance, looking at using these digital bearer instruments in order to make other things, not just currency, but things like stocks and bonds and so forth, tradable just like digital currencies. Where's it all headed?
Paul Krake: It's headed where you implied it was headed. Now, whether or not it's— and again, I think we've got— let's separate the digitization and the cryptocurrency side of things. Because I can be incredibly bullish on digitization and skeptical about the role of cryptocurrencies, particularly in a regulatory environment, which is going to clamp down on this stuff and clamp down on it hard. So I think we should separate that.
Look, I mean, what the Chinese with their digital RMB, the PBOC referred to its role as controllable anonymity. Right, which basically implies they're going to monitor every transaction. Right. So you know if you if we can get to that stage and that whether that's ten years ahead, twenty years ahead, where wherever it is, where the digital RMB or the digital euro, for example, can be you know can be completely programmable, where it can be sent to you know it can be you know so a digital can go to a part of Germany that's just had. A flood and there's a wave of digital RMB that expires in 90 days, digital euro that expires in 90 days, and they've got to spend it. You know, you can go in and there and make interest rates in on real estate in different parts of the country at a different level.
I mean, stuff's extraordinary when we, when we get there, and, and we eventually, and we eventually do, particularly in the Chinese case. And, and by the way, why, why at my core I'm such a structural disinflationist, because all these things in terms of, you know, getting rid of friction, which effectively is what, what the crypto world claims and what the, what the digital currency world will claim.
But digit— look, at the end of the day, the core of digitization is the eradication of friction. And at the end of the day, as we've seen with COVID you know, as we've seen with what happens if you, if you smash a tanker in the middle of the, of the Suez Canal and what that does to friction of supply chain and, and all this sort of stuff, It's friction that creates inflation, right? And the digital— and digitization at its core, its path is to eradicate that, is to eradicate that friction. So I think that that's important.
Um, just on to cryptocurrency for a second. I'm a deep skeptic. I'm a deep skeptic in the context of not that it's not going to play a bigger role in portfolios.
And I think we're in that phase of the transition or the evolution of crypto where people are saying it can't hurt to be 1% of the portfolio. And I think we're at that phase now. But look, the big thing for me and my skepticism about crypto revolves around regulation.
It revolves around the fact that it is still, you know, put it this way, if you were to go off and ban Bitcoin tomorrow, right? Now sure, my old buddy Mike Novogratz will be a bit pissed off because he's got, you know, because he's Lost a lot of money, and the Winklevosses will probably be a little bit peeved as well.
But who's really peeved? Well, every terrorist and drug and organized crime organization in the world is peeved because they've lost where they hide their money. Right. So, you know, we shouldn't lose sight of the fact that, you know, these— the cryptocurrency has been able to flourish because it has done so in an unregulated environment. And, you know, if you were to have a conversation with someone from the US Department of Defense as we speak, the reason North Korea has been so quiet over the course of the last 18 months is because their nuclear program is funded through their gains in Bitcoin, right? And these are the sort of things that really concern people in the Defense Department or the State Department and the like, that, you know, that the cryptocurrency being the unregulated entity that it is has been able to avoid jurisdiction and does.
And look, and there are some problems with this, you know, this being the the libertarian ideal because a lot of bad guys have profited from that. And frankly, it's at odds with the goals and ambitions of not just the United States government, but the EU, and certainly, as we've seen, is China, right?
It's, you know, Bitcoin is done. It's going away in China right now. If you're a wealthy first-tier, you know, live in a wealthy first-tier city in Shanghai, you might have an offshore account and you might be able to trade. That's fine. But locally, it's done. It's over. It's not going to happen because it is against the values of the party.
And what I think is going to happen is that more and more regulation is going to look at whether or not cryptocurrency is a good thing for a Western society and whether or not that is the— whether it should be prioritized or not.
Erik Townsend: Well, Paul, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Before I let you go, please tell us a little bit about View from the Peak and the website and what people can expect to find there when they check it out.
Paul Krake: Erik, you've got me on a good day because we've, uh, we, we've launched, uh, we are doing daily live webinars now for View from the Peak, which is broken down into US-China Series, which as it sounds is everything about China and the US-China relationship, and also, uh, Climate Transformed. So we'll be doing daily live webinars on Climate Transformed. You can, you can register for events at climatetransformed.com or uschinaseries.com.
And yeah, that's where we are. Again, it's me focusing more on these big mega themes and longer-term thinking than the rolling 3-month stuff that I've been doing for a very long time.
Erik Townsend: Kevin Muir and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Selling anything of value— cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars. Euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com.
escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts.
Kevin Muir: Erik, that was a terrific interview with Paul. One of the things about Paul that I— we didn't have a chance to discuss, but he's a hedge fund veteran that's worked for both Caxton and Moore Capital, 2 of the greatest hedge funds out there, Bruce Kovner and Louis Bacon. He's got a wealth of experience. It's just a pleasure to hear him speak. One of the things that I found most interesting is that in this day and age, there's lots of people talking about all of the bearishness versus China, all the things that could go wrong and all the different problems. And he comes at it with a very different point of view. He's much more upbeat on China and views this not so much as the end of the world as an opportunity going forward. What's your take?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think this whole East-West thing is going to be a major conflict in the world for For decades, probably, to come. But it's both of those things. I mean, if you're the West, things are winding down. We're seeing that there is a shift of power and wealth and influence from Western economies into Asia. And I think it's likely to continue. In any event, Kevin, let's move on to the postgame chart deck.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says Looking for the downloads.
Kevin, we've got a couple of fascinating charts here. You've been away for a month. What's going on here with this Economic Surprise Index and why is it important?
Kevin Muir: Well, one of the things that I found interesting, Erik, is that when I spoke to people and asked them how the month went, my bond bull friends told me, oh, the economy's terrible. The Delta variant's here. We're sliding back into the abyss. The sugar high is over. And what they would do is they would pull up to me and they would say, you know, look at this US Economic Surprise Index. And this is the Citibank Economic Surprise Index. And what it measures is the difference in the actual releases of economic numbers versus their expectations, meaning are they beating what the economists are forecasting or not? And ever since the 2020, let's just call it a spike higher after the initial problems, We had this spike higher, and since then it's been sagging. And what that means is that the market and the economy has just been disappointing in terms of, you know, the actual underlying fundamentals of the economy have disappointed versus expectations.
It's very important to think versus expectations is the most important part. And let's face it, we all play in a versus expectations world. And then I have my bond bull friends telling me this, you know, how bad the economy is.
But then my bond bear friends are sending me a chart of the Citibank Inflation Surprise Index, and what this measures is how much inflation you know releases are coming above or below the economists' forecasts. And this is a fascinating chart because this has recently hit an all-time high, or an all-time high since they've been recording it. It's an all-time high for the past two decades, and this is occurring at the same time. that we see the economy sagging.
Erik Townsend: How can that be, Kevin? How can we have— if these are both surprise indexes, they both go by a difference between what the expectation was and what really happened. If what we're seeing is the expectation was the economy was going to be really good, and that should lead to inflation, and it didn't happen, why would the inflation still happen?
Kevin Muir: Well, there's a lot of people are having trouble with this in terms of reconciling these 2, because for the longest time, those 2 would move together. But COVID has changed the game, and COVID is increasingly making it so that we're having supply shocks at the same time that we're having demand drags.
So these supply shocks are happening because people aren't returning to work, because we're having trouble with trade, countries and companies are turning off for a little while. So it's a very interesting and, and different macro environment that we're experiencing. Because in the past, that if you got a situation where COVID would flare up and you would think that we would run into troubles, you might rush out and buy the long bond because you think, oh, here we are, we're in a situation where this is going to mean less economic activity, which is going to mean less inflation. However, if what's happening from COVID flare-ups is that economies are getting turned, you know, off or people are forced to stay home, or for example, let's say as the kids go back to school that they all sudden are starting to get sick and more and more women are in— women or men are willing— are having to stay home with them, we could see a situation where there's less labor.
And this is in fact pushing the supply down at the same time that we're also having this demand shock. Now, in the past, we would see a situation where this would, you know, a problem with COVID would mean people would rush out to buy the long bond.
I think this has changed. I think that now COVID is going to mean higher prices because any sort of supply shock is in fact going to be monetized or in essence printed with, with more fiscal stimulus. So therefore, as COVID continues to flare up, and I do believe that COVID isn't going away anytime soon, let's face it, you know, when we were talking about COVID let's say 6 months ago, everyone had these images that we were about to have have what the vaxxed and waxed summer or the shot girl summer, all these fun things where everyone thought we were all going to get vaccinated and then the world would go on in terms of back to normal. Well, what we found is that COVID isn't going away. It's still here in many different forms. And yet as we go and try to get back to work, we're finding these supply shocks.
Kevin Muir: So I'm looking at this and I'm thinking to myself, how does an investor take advantage of this. One of the things that seems very clear to me is that we're going to see a steepening of the yield curve because we're going to see governments continue to try to print their way out or do fiscal regardless, you know, stimulate on that side. Yet at the same time, as COVID stays here and as we have flare-ups of different sorts throughout the world, we're going to see that supply continues to be constrained. So I think that has all the makings of a government and a central bank that keeps rates It's pinned to zero at the short end. And then meanwhile, bond investors start to get nervous and realize that although inflation, the big measures of inflation that everyone was worried about in terms of lumber and all those things, those are coming in and those parts were transitory, but there's other parts of the inflation story that don't appear to be transitory and look like they're going to be permanent, at least as long as this COVID continues to flare up throughout the globe.
So I think it has all the makings of a great Steepener trade, Erik.
Erik Townsend: That's fascinating, Kevin. The way that I reacted to this when I first saw these 2 charts is I thought, well, wait a minute. If you look at what the Economic Surprise Index is showing us, clearly the economy underperformed compared to expectations. And you know it has to be true that if the economy underperformed compared to expectations, That means that cyclical inflation had to be affected negatively. Well, if inflation is still going up and cyclical inflation, you can't really explain why it could be going up under that circumstance. The conclusion I come to is, boy, that must be secular inflation, not cyclical inflation, because the reason you expect that correlation with the Economic Surprise Index is if you're talking about cyclical inflation. If it's secular inflation, That's driven by expectations, growing expectations, I would say, of a completely different monetary policy regime looking forward. Well, then it really doesn't matter what the Economic Surprise Index is doing, does it?
Kevin Muir: Yeah. The other thing I'd just like to point out, Erik, is that everyone thinks that this has to be either hyperinflation, a Weimar Republic type inflationary event, or it has to be an absolute collapse, like we have to become Japan. And I always like to say that the truth is going to be somewhere down the middle. And I look at this and I see a situation where I could see inflation going up 3%, 4%, 5%, and meanwhile, rates staying at the front end of the curve pinned to zero. So, it doesn't need to be these extremes. And I think part of what we've experienced over the last 6 to 9 months is a movement from one end, which is when everyone was convinced that we were going to have the hyperinflation of the 1970s to now we've flipped a little much too much the other way, whereas like, oh no, this looks like the Fed was right. It's all transitory.
We're not going to have any inflation. What if the answer is somewhere in between? What if the answer is that we are going to have higher inflation and that the Fed is still not going to raise rates? That's what I'm looking for.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think that's going to be the very interesting tell is what happens when You have increasing inflation and you don't raise rates. Because historically, we've always raised rates in reaction to increasing inflation. We haven't had this problem where increasing rates would bankrupt the federal government if you did that. So it's going to be very interesting to see what happens. We're going to leave it there for this week's show, folks.
Erik Townsend: And we do have a Research Roundup email this week. Now, those of you who have sent us article submissions, they may not have made it in this week because Because Patrick's off this week. He'll be back next week. We'll get caught up. So you won't find any specific research articles this week. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole.
And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Kevin Muir: So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how to make the program even better. For those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend.
That is Erik spelled with a K. And you can follow Patrick @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend, Patrick Ceresna, and myself, Kevin Muir, thank you for listening and see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this episode of MacroVoices. Edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com.
Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit. MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Clint Cox — co-chief investment officer of Crypto Futura Fund (as introduced on the show)
Pippa Malmgren — former US presidential advisor, bestselling author, and partner in the Monaco Foundry, a startup incubator in Europe (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here's your host, Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 285 was prerecorded back in early August 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow. There won't be any market wrap or postgame segment this week or next. For this year's 2-part summer special, we're going to focus on the digital currency and decentralized finance revolution that has already begun. As many listeners know, I wrote a book on this subject back in 2018, but a lot has changed since then. So we're calling in the experts for an update on what I believe will be the single most important trend of the next 2 decades. I'll be joined by 2 expert guests for this 2-part special. My first guest is Dr.
Pippa Malmgren, former US presidential advisor, bestselling author, and partner in the Monaco Foundry, a startup incubator in Europe. Pippa, thanks so much for joining us.
Pippa Malmgren: Thank you for having me, as always.
Erik Townsend: Thanks, Pippa. And also joining me as a first-time guest on MacroVoices is Clint Cox. Clint is the co-chief investment officer of Crypto Futura Fund and has been following crypto closely and investing in it since 2015. Clint also spends considerable time looking at macro trends on a global scale. Clint, welcome aboard.
Clint Cox: Hey, thank you, Erik. It's going to be a blast to be on the podcast with you and Pippa. Much appreciated.
Erik Townsend: It's great to have you on as a first-time guest. I'm going to start by asking each of our panelists to share their high-level, big-picture view of both digital currency and decentralized finance, what it's going to mean to financial markets, and for that matter, to broader society and the course of world history. I'll start with my own view on the subject and then ask each of our guests to share theirs.
I am personally convinced that the invention of the secure digital bearer asset— that's the fundamental innovation that underlies both digital currency and decentralized finance— will make a more profound change to society and the course of world history than the advent of the personal computer or the commercialization of the public internet. I really am convinced that it's that big of a deal and that it will completely change what money itself is, how it works, and how we use it. We are very, very early in this story. Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin have been around for more than a decade, but they only play a small part in the much bigger story which has only just begun to unfold. The Bitcoin fan club acts as if Bitcoin is going to take over the universe, but I think that so far they're only seeing a very small part of the overall picture. Meanwhile, central banks have finally woken up and recognized the need for central bank digital currencies, or CBDCs, but frankly, their efforts to date have been lame at best.
So far, none of them seem to have recognized the opportunity to design digital monetary policy transmission tools into CBDC systems, something I'm convinced will eventually be seen as the principal appeal of CBDCs in the eyes of central bankers. Silicon Valley smells blood and already knows that the grand prize in this story goes to whichever digital currency system ultimately replaces the conventional US dollar as the world's global reserve currency. The financial media is completely out to lunch. The most common quip is, oh, but the financial system is already digital. CNBC hosts are not the only ones completely ignorant to the distinction between true digital cash and the digital accounting systems that have been used for decades to manage conventional currency deposits. Even big institutional funds that offer exposure to cryptocurrencies are often managed by people who, so far as I can tell, are completely clueless as to where all of this is ultimately headed.
Moving beyond just digital currency, decentralized finance, or DeFi for short, refers to the application of secure digital bearer instruments to trading of securities and other assets. This directly enables disintermediation, the elimination of the current institution-based financial system with an asset-based system where counterparty risk could be practically eliminated in ways beyond the wildest dreams of the designers of the current system.
What I've summarized so far is just the tip of the iceberg, the trends that are already hot topics in finance, but there's so much more coming over the near horizon. So far, almost nobody but me is talking about the benefits of a true digital sovereign bond market. Someday, a new generation of tech-savvy central bankers will take office, and they'll be quick to understand why secure digital bearer assets are inherently superior to any conventional currency as central bank reserve assets. When that happens, the US dollar's monopoly as the global reserve currency will end, but it doesn't end with digital currency and DeFi.
Ultimately, we have the opportunity to re-engineer the entire fractional reserve banking system, meaning that what money actually is, how it works, and particularly how credit is extended will change completely. This will be a complete and total game changer for the banking industry, and my prediction is that some of the largest and longest-standing commercial and investment banks in the world will eventually be displaced by new tech-savvy financial institutions whose names we haven't even heard yet. So my goal in this year's summer special is to really expand the conversation to not just digital currency and the current DeFi trend, but to the ultimate digitalization of the entire global economy. We're headed into an entirely new era of finance where this centuries-old fractional reserve banking system will eventually be replaced with something much better, and how credit works will change completely for all borrowers, from individual consumers to entire nations. So I think we have a whole lot to talk about today, but already I've gone on too long with my own vision of where this is headed.
So now I'd like to ask our expert guests to share their own vision of where this is headed. And by all means, feel free to disagree with me, guys, on anything I've said if you feel so inclined. Let's start with Dr. Pippa Malmgren. Pippa, Please share your vision of the future of digital finance with our listeners.
Pippa Malmgren: Erik, I am so delighted that you asked me to be on this program because the subject matter is so critical. It's— this isn't about, you know, which of the cryptocurrencies should we be investing in. This is about massive societal change. This is about completely new ways of creating money, extending credit, navigating through transactions in the world economy.
It's a shift in the balance of power in the world economy. And I want to begin with that kind of the very broad overview and create some context. And also, by the way, I just want to say thank you for letting me invite Clint Cox. I'm not at liberty to say how Clint and I met, but let's just say I heard him speak at something and thought, wow, This guy knows more about this subject than anybody that I've heard. And I really think that his practical understanding of this market is extremely deep. So it's a privilege that you've invited us both on to talk.
But let me start with this. You know that I've said in the past that sometimes in history we go through radically redefining moments where we literally abandon the old system of money and accounting and recreate a new one. And often I'm citing the event that happened in the UK in 1834 when we moved from a system that had worked perfectly for 1,000 years using basically wooden boards called tally sticks. And that was the system of money and accounting. And you can still see the tally sticks when you go to Parliament. They're in glass cases. But that was the way you kept a record of all of your expenditure and your tax payments. And it was the way that you knew what you owned and could prove what you owned.
And then they decided to change to this newfangled idea. It was completely brand new technology at the time, which was paper money. And people were horrified and they were like, I'm not going to use paper money. Are you kidding? It doesn't have my name on it. And so the government literally had to confiscate all the tally sticks and they took them to Parliament and decided to burn them so no one could ever use them again. They'd be forced to use this newfangled paper money, and they misjudged how much heat would be thrown off by the burning of the tally sticks. And that's what caused Parliament to burn down in 1834.
Today, we're going through a very similar reconfiguration of the financial system and abandoning an old system of money that was still very much paper money based, even if digitized to a degree, and instead adopting an entirely new technology, except this time you don't need to burn the old stuff. So there's no smoke, but that doesn't mean there's no fire.
And I would go even further and say that in keeping with the movement of society into the digital space, and I mean everything is moving digital, the conduct of war is becoming a digital phenomenon, for example. All of us have a digital twin that reveals and has more information about each of us than we even know about ourselves. That's true for corporations as well. The digitization of reality is a very profound phenomena. And one piece of it is the digitization of money itself. And so as a small example, I'm about to launch a business which is in part about how do you display who you are in this new world? Because in the old world, LinkedIn did the job. Because in the old world, you had a career, you had one job after another, it was sequential. You had a single job title with a single employer.
But in this new world with digitized everything, including digitized money, more and more people are going to have portfolio careers where they're doing multiple jobs at the same time for different employers. And now because of the digitization of reality, this will have a huge impact on things like legal contracts where you won't even need to have a legal contract anymore because blockchain-based digital money will provide you greater security than any legal contract ever could.
And so suddenly now you're talking about a world where people come together to work kind of like a Hollywood film. They assemble like a swarm. They take on a project, do it, and then they disassemble And then they'll come together again or not in a different group if it's interesting enough. This is a completely different way of working.
And I know you're all familiar with my dad, who's rather a legend in the financial world, and he was the chief trade negotiator under 4 presidents. But one of his specialties early on was the theory of the firm, and he worked with several Nobel Prize winners on the subject, Ken Arrow and Tom Schelling and Sir John Hicks. And we forget because we just assume that the modern corporation is the only way you can do business because we've all had it since the East India Company. And then we've had all these explanations. Why do people band together in a corporate structure? And we can all answer that question. But now the digitization of money itself means You don't need a corporation. You actually can band together in temporary and loose structures and create incredible value out of seemingly absolutely nothing. This change for society will be profound. So my startup is very much in this space.
And I'll finish with just one last thing because there's so much to talk about here. Another piece of this puzzle is— That our institutional structures will all change. And I don't just mean that banks won't be as necessary, if necessary at all. And I don't just mean that legal contracts won't be necessary, if necessary at all. I mean, the whole pattern of human relationships will be profoundly affected by this innovation and this new form of money, power structures, Who has power in this new environment? Does government really have power in this kind of environment that I'm describing? So that's why I say I'm really glad to open this conversation by saying, you know, the questions that you get from a financial market audience about Bitcoin and crypto are so narrow and so missing the point.
You know, it's not even that there are over 4,000 different digital currencies now and which one's the right one. It's a bigger question. It's like the question I faced when the financial crisis happened. And I had to say to my clients in the run-up to that, I'm not just saying sell the portfolio. I'm saying, ask the question if the financial institution you work for will survive this event. And people were like, what? What? That what? You mean my bank could disappear? And I was like, yeah. And then Lehman disappeared. So that's what I'm saying. banking and all the institutions we're familiar with down to the level of families may not survive this innovation.
And that's why I'm really glad to have Clint on because he too thinks in this context, contextual way, because it's very hard to place the investment decisions on individual pieces of this new puzzle if you don't understand the context. in which it's occurring. So there's my opening.
Erik Townsend: Wow, Pippa, that is a perfect segue for Clint Cox because Clint, you actually run a fund that invests in these assets. So my question to you is, first of all, what's the big picture? What's the long-term? Where are we headed? But also, are the assets that you can buy right now, such as Bitcoin, really going to play a major role in the long-term story? And if not, how do they fit into a strategy now?
Clint Cox: So first of all, yeah, these are all great questions, and I'm really honored and privileged to be, you know, on the call with you guys and, you know, on the podcast here. You know, this is, as Pippa said, a hugely important topic. This is, you know, the topic. And I guess to give a little historical context and like what has led to this moment where we are now, and then how that will affect the next, you know, 20, 30 years. It's just look at the layers.
The first thing I'll just look at is the technology layer that's led us here to this moment. You had the personal computer start with the integrated circuits, so the computer chip. That was 1958. That's when this whole thing started. But having a personal computer where anyone could have access, obviously, you had to pay a certain amount of money, and not everyone had immediate access, but in 1977, you had the TRS-80. Or the Trash 80, as we affectionately called it, and the Apple II. I first entered this realm with the Apple II Plus. So I think I got that in 1979, 1980 when I was 8 or 9. So I started programming when I was a kid and really loved technology. By 1984, we had the Macintosh that was introduced with that amazing cinematic commercial that they had at the Super Bowl.
The Macintosh transformed everything. So now, you know, by the '80s, people had access to data and computing, stuff that they had never had access to before. So, you know, what was only for, you know, corporations, governments, uh, is now accessible to everybody. That was amazing. Then you had the internet, and the internet really got its, you know, start in 1983 with TCP/IP and that introduction, and then the World Wide Web with Berners-Lee And then what really opened it up to the public once again and the larger, you know, group of populace is 1992, Mosaic, the graphic interface. Because let me just tell you, you know, it was really boring to just tap on that black screen with green, you know, text all day long. That was abysmal. But once you got to this graphic interface and you could actually start to see the internet in whole new ways, that is what helped explode the internet.
So it still took though, you know, almost a decade, you know, '92 to '99 to where it really took off. But then we had something introduced by a company called Apple, and it was called the iPod. And this started to transform music. And it was this little device, you know, you could plug your earphones into it. Fantastic. You could get the music you want and play it in the order you want it. That's amazing. So anyone could have access to this if they buy an iPod.
Then in 2007, the craziest thing ever was introduced, and it was introduced as— and this is a quote from, uh, from Steve Jobs on stage in 2007— it's an iPod, it's a phone, it's an internet communications device. Now that does not sound sexy at all. And matter of fact, if you watch the 15-20 minute video, it's, it's one of Steve's not greater, uh, moments in description because I think it was so transformative Nobody knew what he was talking about. This iPhone that he held in his hand was going to transform everything and give us mobile access and exchange of data everywhere. So, you know, no one knew what it was because no one understood the App Store, because the App Store wasn't even introduced until 2008, a year later. Now, all of a sudden, you know, you look at your phone now and all the things you do with your phone.
You know, it wasn't until 2009 that video was released with it. Now you see all the aspects of this and you're like, wow, think about how much video in our pockets has changed everything, right? A lot of accountability.
So then we get to crypto blockchain. We get to Satoshi Nakamoto's white paper in 2008, the launch of Bitcoin in 2009, and then you have Ethereum in 2014, '15, and the advent of smart contracts. And then let's just go to 2021 and Coinbase IPO. So, you have kind of these different segments. You have first the personal computer with access to data and computing. Then you have the internet with the global exchange of data. Then you have smartphones that give us mobile access and exchange of data. That's everywhere. And then you get crypto and blockchain, which gives you mobile access and exchange of data and value. And when I say and value, that's the huge part. Crypto blockchain allows you to exchange value. And that's everywhere. Now, when I say everywhere, that includes the International Space Station, which now has a Bitcoin node. Ethereum is actually going to have a node up there soon.
This is huge. So, that's one thing that's happening is technology.
Then another layer is world reserve currencies typically last 80 to 110 years. I mean, your listeners all know this. We are on at least the front edge. We're entering the beginning of the end of what may be US dollar dominance. At least historically. That may be, you know, we may be able to change history, but at this point, uh, since the 1400s, 80 to 110 years. Now keep in mind that, you know, what has allowed that dominance is trade, uh, is, you know, military might, those kinds of things. And the US is still in pretty good position there. Uh, there's obviously some competitors.
But then another layer on top of that is the corporation. It's been 400 years since the corporation was introduced. Arguably, we have had no new forms of human organizations since then. I mean, sure, you've had a couple offshoots and things like that, but nothing really new to organize people since the corporation 400 years ago. Now, with Satoshi's new invention, we have decentralized autonomous organizations. And as Pippa was pointing out, I mean, this is going to be crazy. Who knows what work is going to look like 10 years from now? Because now you have these decentralized organizations that are completely independent of a CEO dictating. It is the power of the group that is in that DAO that basically makes the decisions. So, much of what we do today is based on corporations. That's about to change because we now have a different way to organize. Now, I don't know how long it will take. It'll take some time.
But as we look at, you know, things like the Fourth Turning and this idea of things tend to change over these Fourth Turnings, if you layer all those things together, the technology and where we've gotten with technology, the world reserve currency coming to a possible, you know, the beginning of the end, and a new, completely new organizational framework for people, my goodness, this is— This is crazy. Like, where is this headed? The next 20 to 30 years, every human organizational system and structure is going to be transformed. Banking, government, work, our social networks, religion, trade, travel, education, our very identities and belief systems are going to be completely upended.
And part of this is because there are going to be new levels of trust and accountability. So I'll leave it there. I don't even want to get into like The combination of technologies like big data, AI, machine learning, quantum computing, additive manufacturing, robotics, drones, augmented and virtual reality, all those things are going to combine to shock us as we enter this new, I guess, really a new era for humankind. So I'll stop there.
Erik Townsend: All right. We're going to touch on quite a few of the topics Clint just mentioned, and that's coming up right after this message from our sponsor. This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a fintech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the fintech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Erik Townsend: Alrighty, before we go on, I think it's really important that we answer an essential question that oftentimes doesn't get answered in these conversations, which is what makes digital currency better than conventional currency? You'll hear so many people in finance not understanding this. They're saying, hey, it seems to me like the financial system's been digital for 30 years. You know, it's all been computerized. What's this? What's so important about this digital currency thing that makes it all that different? And why should investors care about whether or not this system uses these digital bearer assets, whatever that means. Pippa, why don't we kick it off with you? What's going on here?
Pippa Malmgren: So for me, the thing that makes it so profoundly different is about the data that gets connected to money. So I see this as a world where it's not just that you pay using your iPhone to swipe at the ticket barrier, It's that all of your activities are now observable, of which your financial activity is just one of the many things that you get up to.
And there are many parties from private companies to governments that are now able to read what they can sell to you, what kind of behaviors they can maneuver you into or maneuver you out of. Because money itself becomes a surveillance system.
And especially as we move into sovereign digital, where the government itself begins to issue money. And we see this already in China with the DCEP, they call it. And I've been trying to help people understand, just think of it as a surveillance system that's disguised to look like money.
That's kind of more. And so therefore, this has profound, profound meaning for democracy. for personal human freedoms, for your rights. And I'm not talking just about whether you should be surveilled. I'm talking about whether it's appropriate to take the accumulation of all your behaviors and then make judgments about you based on it. So for me, the digitization of money is like putting a grid over the entire world that geolocates not only what you spend and where, at what time, but it begins to gather information about why did you buy this at this particular time? How could you be influenced to do it again or not do it again? And so I see it as a part of a larger phenomenon, which is broadly called surveillance capitalism. Although, you know, the Chinese are pioneering the way in their version of more autocratic capitalism. So it's not just that the money is digital, it's that it's connected to a broader sieve of information gathering about every person and then the use of that data to impose outcomes.
And often without people having any realization whatsoever that they are being influenced by these mechanisms. So for me, that's the important part.
Erik Townsend: Well, thank you for that sales pitch, Pippa. Let's move on to Clint Cox. Why is it important that this digital money is digital and why is that such a big and important change from conventional money?
Clint Cox: Yeah, I mean, I think there's a lot of positives and negatives here, Erik. I'm not gonna act like it's all positive. I do like Pippa's take there. That might be on the negative side, but it is programmable. So, you know, you hear this phrase smart contracts And, you know, it's programmable money. That's amazing. So you can have if-then statements programmed into the money. If certain criteria is met, then certain things happen. Certain money is released, certain money is paid back. It's a pretty amazing system that basically disintermediates the need for all of these third parties involved in our financial transactions. Like, there's no need. Like, right now, if I wanted to send Pippa, you know, $100 worth of Bitcoin, I could do that. Before the end of this, she's going to have it. And there's going to be a very, very small fee on that, right? But it's all based on the fact that I've got a program, she's got a program, they talk to each other, it's done.
And it's very easy to do things that are next level speed. Speed is amazingly fast for these digital currencies.
Some of these things can actually transact in under 4 seconds. So you can look at your phone, send it somewhere else, and 4 seconds later, that person's got it. Now, that could be anywhere in the world that they're hooked up to the internet, right? So, that's phenomenal. The expense, it's actually much less expensive to actually manage. And now, we won't get into the whole mining thing and all the expense with that, but as far as just a system, it's very inexpensive. It's very efficient.
It's decentralized. Now, what Pippa was just talking about is the CBDCs and these centralized currencies by central banks. Those will definitely be centralized. They will make the most of all that data they're collecting. But this digital currency realm that has, you know, Bitcoin, Ethereum, uh, Litecoin, all these others, these thousands of, of cryptos, digital assets, those are decentralized. That's a totally different ballgame. That means that no one gets to control or dictate how things happen. It's a group effort. It's basically that network. But I mean, there are negatives here, right? It requires electricity, requires access to the internet. You know, some exchanges and wallets have been, you know, hacked. Now keep in mind, very few blockchains have been hacked. So like Bitcoin, the blockchain has not been hacked. So when you hear people saying, oh, it got hacked, no, the exchange didn't have correct security controls or a wallet was insecure. It was not the Bitcoin blockchain.
And then The other negative I would say is definitely what Pippa just said— privacy. What is going to happen with our privacy? And we're not even going to know how we're controlled because we're going to start seeing ads based on how we've spent. We could see ads sponsored by the government or different types of behavior that they want to institute. You could see that as far as that could all be integrated to our social platforms. Who knows? I don't know where this goes, but privacy is definitely a concern.
Erik Townsend: I'm going to add my perspective, which is I don't think most people in finance have figured out the concept of disintermediation yet. What we have today is a system of institutions. You do not own the money in your own bank account. The bank owes you that money. You're an unsecured creditor, and if the bank fails, you could potentially lose your money. Oh, but it's insured by federal insurance. Well, the federal insurance is not adequately reserved against a systemic fault. It's reserved against fraud happening in one little bank. But if the whole system starts to fail, there is no insurance for that that really exists, even though they say that there is.
If you go to secure digital bearer assets, you eliminate the concept of counterparty risk entirely. It's not like a wire transfer, which is not really guaranteed. With a crypto or digital currency transaction, you can instantly move money from one possessor to another. You can change who is in possession of that money instantaneously without the need for any intermediaries. And that means we could take something like the entire tri-party repo system and all of the reasons that it exists and say, wait a minute, we don't need that anymore. Because this whole idea of managing counterparty risk the way we do with that system, won't be necessary.
Now, that by itself would be just a huge game changer, and it would require rethinking almost all of finance. But I think that's just the tip of the iceberg, because as both of you just said, we heard Pippa's sales pitch first, then Clint is talking about programmable money. Look, here's how I see the finance industry in general. I think most of what the industry is about is you take some really smart guys and gals who went to Harvard and you figure out how to create financial terms and conditions that confuse the heck out of the people that are getting screwed over by them and are only understandable to really smart people. Now we're giving those smart people the tools of programmable money systems and maybe the ability to privatize what has traditionally been a government monopoly over the issuance of money. That's a really big deal.
What could go wrong in a story like that? Pippa, why don't we start with you?
Pippa Malmgren: Yeah, well, one thing that leaps to mind is how the tax system will change. So now armed with all this data about your behaviors, it's quite possible that government can say, right, we want to give a tax break to everybody who supported us in voting on issue X. And the way you give them that tax break is you literally just suddenly this digital money shows up in your account. That's what the Chinese are doing, by the way, with the DCEP. How do they get people to adopt it? It just literally appears on your iPhone and you're like, whoa, I suddenly have 10 grand that's just appeared. The government gave it to me. And you're just so delighted and then free to spend it as you like. But equally, they can also say, we don't like the fact that you're hanging out with the wrong people. You're in a rough part of town where we know bad stuff is happening.
'Cause we can see your location and we can see your life. And actually we're gonna dock you 10 grand, right? You start to get fines based on behaviors.
And this is one of the reasons that a lot of the central bankers I've talked to are uneasy, you know, 'cause it's also like, it's sort of heroin for politicians because you can double the money supply, you can halve the money supply just at a keystroke. But more importantly, it's not just the volume of overall, you can actually choose who gets money and who has to pay.
And that is a level of social influence, if not social control, that we really need to think about.
And I do think this is tied to something that sooner or later I'm sure we'll get into in the conversation, which is what are governments going to permit and not permit? And we've seen this huge crackdown on the crypto and private digital space, pressure being brought to bear on companies like Binance. And at its core, what it's about is government's never going to be happy with people moving large sums of money around anonymously.
And it's not just that they want to track what you're doing and know that you're not doing terrible bad things. It's also that it's part of this broader context of understanding all of one's data and connecting up all these dots in this global mesh of data about the population. By the way, I shouldn't say it's— these are not only negative things.
There are going to be some very positive things that come out of this. Like, for example, I could easily envisage— I mean, already your iPhone in your pocket can identify when you have a heart attack coming. It can tell this from your gait, how you physically walk down the street.
And Eric Schmidt actually said a few years ago at Google, if I had permission, if I had the legal ability to send an alert, we know who's going to have a heart attack because we can see from how they're walking compared to how they used to walk that this is a very clear indicator a heart attack is along the way. So that's an interesting question. Do you want to get the text message from Apple or Google that you need to get to hospital quickly? And then what if actually the ambulance is sent to you before you even make the decision? It's like, excuse me, you got to get in here because you're about to have a heart attack. Oh, and by the way, all of the payments for this process, this procedure you're about to have, is already taken care of because you have certain behaviors. Or you're going to owe a lot of money because you have the wrong behaviors.
There's a positive and there's a negative. All technology always cuts both ways. It's like a double-headed ax that it can cut both ways. It can do wonderful things. It can do terrible things. It's not the technology that does it. It's how we use it.
And my personal view is that the Wild West of our generation, is the digital space. And maybe one distinguishing feature of digitized money is that it occurs in a digital environment where we literally don't have any laws. We don't have any rules. It's, you know, again, back to Google. They've kind of said, well, hey, we got here first, so we make the rules. And everybody's going, hmm, not so sure that I'm comfortable with that. Like, is this a place where whoever sets the flag First, they win the territory, or is this something that as a society we're going to have to come up with what's appropriate? What are the right laws and structure for how decisions get made in a world where money is truly, truly digital and connected to all your other data?
Erik Townsend: Clint Cox, you and I, I'm sure, share a vision of just incredible, tremendous advances that could be made for society with the technology that now lays before How do we stop the greediest but also smartest people on Wall Street from hijacking the whole thing for their own benefit and screwing over the rest of society?
Clint Cox: That's quite a task, right? That's quite a task. You know, I think the easiest thing you can see here is— the easiest example is Facebook, right? Facebook introduced Libra, and that was, you know, perhaps going to be the first global um, currency that was, you know, run by a corporation. And, you know, now they have almost 3 billion users. That would have been overnight, you know, the widest used currency by individuals on the planet. You know, I mean, that, that was terrifying, right? And I think that's why there was such pushback so quickly on Libra. But the flip side of that is that's also what sparked the Chinese to hit the accelerator on their program for their, you know, CBDC. So I think, you know, as you look at both governments and, you know, companies that could dominate this next, you know, phase, I think it's going to be very, very difficult because they know and understand how to incentivize, how to control.
Many of these companies with machine learning and AI and their algorithms, they understand more about you than you understand about you. You know, they will know what you're going to choose and why you're going to choose it, whereas you might just feel like, oh, I think I'm going to do this today. They might already know because they know how, you know, your data combined with 500,000 people that are very similar to you have all reacted this way, so you're going to react this way. So I, I think this is something that's really, really difficult because the companies that have the expertise and the technology to basically control this next phase and to innovate through this next phase Those companies also have, you know, the incentive to make sure their company grows, make sure that they're, you know, satisfying their shareholders.
And how do they do that? They maximize everything they've got. And so I think it's, it's a very, very dangerous time because I don't think governments can keep up. If you remember the antitrust case against Microsoft, you know, it was started and then years later, might have even been a decade later, I'm not sure how long the timeline was, They finally settled it and everyone was like, oh yeah, I remember that. There was a case, right?
Technology had moved so far beyond where the government could actually dictate what was happening that the government just couldn't do anything that was really, really advantageous to control the environment. Technology moved on and the entire environment moved on.
But I think that that's where we're at this juncture. You know, we've now got Gensler, the SEC, you got Yellen, you got Congress saying, hey, let's— we're going to do some stuff with this crypto. We're, you know, we're going to put some things in place. That's great. I mean, I think there should be regulation, but there has to be a really, really thorough understanding before you start throwing guardrails up and, you know, stopping the innovation, not just of the big companies, but the innovations of the little guys who are actually doing really cool things. No one knows who Satoshi Nakamoto is still today. Is it a him, a her, a they? No one knows.
But it certainly wasn't a government organization, or it certainly wasn't— well, some people think it was, but— or some people, you know, think it wasn't a company that claimed it.
So that is the amazing thing, is there's still innovation that can happen at the smallest level, but we got to make sure that the big dogs don't stamp it out for everyone else. So I don't know how to answer the question other than say, Wow, anything could happen from here, from a social credit system to a corporate social credit system that, you know, acts in many ways as the one in China does, but it's more friendly. I don't know. I think we're headed into unknown territory.
Pippa Malmgren: Actually, can I just jump in real quick on this? As an example, I've been quite fascinated by McDonald's creating partnerships with cryptocurrencies. So now you have these crypto games And millions and millions of people around the world are not only playing them, but making money playing them. And one of the things you'll have to do with one of them is you have to actually go into McDonald's and buy something because it's only by scanning the QR code on the receipt that you can get more lives in the crypto game.
And so suddenly there's this like, you know, sheepdog effect that everybody gets corralled into McDonald's because It's that they actually get paid to be there, right? It's not just about winning the game. It's that you're making money. And so this is an interesting example of how the digital and the real-world space starts to interface with each other. And suddenly you're seeing, you know, people going into McDonald's and, you know, we can talk about what we think about McDonald's and healthcare, but, you know, suddenly there are behaviors that are occurring that are driven by this new digital relationship. I know, I know, Clint, you've got some views about that.
Clint Cox: Yeah, I mean, you also have, you know, entirely new ecosystems that allow, you know, people to make money in ways that they've never made money before. I mean, you can look at Axie, uh, that's an example that right now it's a game. You have to kind of pay money to get into the game. You have to buy little, you know, characters. You get into the game and then you can start earning money within the game in a number of ways. And I think that right now, most of the players, I believe the majority are in the Philippines, but there's a significant number of people in the Philippines making more than they would working in the real world by just playing this game. And they get sponsored by people outside of the Philippines and there's a whole ecosystem with that, as I said, but that is incentivizing people to be part of a system and they're actually making more money than they would Doing anything in the brick-and-mortar or real world.
It's really quite amazing.
Erik Townsend: Let's focus on digital currency now, and we'll come back to decentralized finance more broadly later on. I personally break digital currency down into 3 broad categories. I use the word cryptocurrency to refer to Bitcoin and other digital currency systems that were developed by non-government actors and which are generally designed with the goal of reducing the degree of government oversight, if you will, over private citizens' financial affairs.
The second category is central bank digital currencies. My prediction there is they're going in the exact opposite direction. They're going to focus on doing everything they can to design as much control and oversight into those systems as they possibly can. And I think that's going to be the, the rub in terms of which one gets acceptance. The final category is what I call Silicon Valley digital currencies. And the example there is Facebook's Libra, which is the first one publicly. to have been disclosed, although I'm convinced there are other projects going on behind closed doors right now. The idea there is I expect the big tech behemoths to recognize that the really big picture here, the endgame in this story, the big prize goes to whoever controls the digital currency system that ultimately replaces the US dollar as the global reserve currency. And I expect them to do everything they possibly can to try to be the one who's in charge of that currency system for their own benefit.
How do each of you think about this general landscape of digital currency systems? What are the categories? What should we expect from them? And what are the important things to understand about this market space? Clint, let's start with you on this one.
Clint Cox: Yeah, so I, I think, you know, as we're looking at this whole digital asset, digital currency space, first let me start with I think we are moving towards a digital cashless society. Okay. So I think we've seen that, like Scandinavia, a lot of the countries there are like 80% cashless. Korea's over 85% cashless. Even the US is 68% at this point cashless. UK, 58% cashless. So we're already moving in that direction, but this is taking it to a whole new level. So when we look at cryptocurrencies, and let me be very clear here, There's lots more than just currencies in the digital asset space. So, when you look at the 4,000, 5,000, however many thousand cryptos there are at this point, very few of those try to be currencies. Most of them have a utility or a purpose that's alternate to that of a currency.
But let's just stick with that currency aspect right now. So, you have your digital currencies, so Bitcoin, Litecoin, Bitcoin Cash, XRP, those kinds of things. You have your privacy coins, which are your Monero, Zcash, Dash, Verge, Beam, things like that. And then you have stablecoins. That's Tether, USDC, Paxos, and a whole handful of others. So, when we're looking at the currency aspect of this, it's actually split into a number of different groups. So, when we're looking at digital currencies, one of the things is I like to look at compared to the functions of money, Historically, so the store of value, unit of account, medium of exchange.
When you're looking at these currencies in that framework, yeah, they are a store of value. I can argue that all day long, because if you look at Bitcoin and the way it's performed against any asset class over the last decade, Bitcoin wins over everything. It's been amazing. Store of value, yes.
Is it volatile?
Pippa Malmgren: Yeah.
Clint Cox: It's volatile up and to the right. So, unit of account, it's really not, except none of these are a unit of account except inside the crypto system itself. So, at this point, the US dollar is definitely dominant. Medium of exchange, still US dollar dominant for sure. But when you start getting to the characteristics of money, so your durability, portability, Divisibility, uniformity, limited supply, acceptability.
When you start getting to that, crypto starts winning pretty quickly. Durability, I mean, Bitcoin right there, crypto. Portability, Bitcoin, crypto. Divisibility, Bitcoin, crypto. You can go to tiny amounts. Uniformity, it's about the same. Limited supply, Bitcoin kicks that to the curb, man. The US dollar, we have no idea where this ends. How much is print?
But acceptability, still, the US dollar is more accepted. So, when we start looking at these cryptocurrencies, I think it's important to understand in the context of functions of money, characteristics of money, where these stand. And I think the real target here is going to be the privacy coins. I don't think governments are going to really want those privacy coins to be the future of crypto. They want to be able to see what's going on Any nefarious activity, all of that, they're going to want to see that.
Stablecoins, these are another issue altogether, but that's like the cryptocurrency world of digital assets. Then you look at CBDCs, the central bank digital currencies. Now, what's really interesting here is you've got China, they're really far along in their program. They've already tested a lot of this, they're piloting it, they're actually doing airdrops.
I mean, they're really far along. The Bahamas, the Sand Dollar, it's already out there. So they're actually, you know, using it already. But you have a bunch of countries like Sweden, France, Philippines, Japan, Nigeria, Morocco, Switzerland, even the US is talking about creating a CBDC. So that is going to happen. I think that's inevitable.
Then you have another category, what I call the third category, and that's corporate coins or payment systems. So, you know, I think the precursors to this might be WeChat and Alipay in China. Because most of everything that you buy inside China, you're buying with WeChat or Alipay via mobile app. You know, but when we saw Libra, you know, announced, that was a game changer. You know, since then they've had to change it. It's now Diem instead of Libra, and there's a whole bunch of other changes that went with that. Things like JP Morgan Coin. But I agree with you, uh, Erik, for sure. There are programs at probably all of the big companies— Amazon, Google, You know, maybe even Netflix, etc., where they are going to be using their own crypto. Now, the problem is going to be like kind of what I think Kodak ran into.
You can't have a security when you already have a publicly listed stock. So, they've got to be really careful how they use this stuff, right? And I think you've got the regulators watching very, very carefully.
So, as we look at these 3, you know, categories, the cryptocurrencies, the CBDCs, and the corporate coins, I think the really important thing to watch here is interoperability. How are these 3 things, these 3 categories going to work together? And I think you're already seeing a lot of overlap. You're seeing Visa, Mastercard PayPal, Square, they're all allowing the use of crypto behind those payment systems. So, I think there's going to be more and more of this integration.
But how that goes when we actually have CBDCs, and these larger corporate coins? I'm not sure, but I think that's going to be the key space to watch is how they operate together.
Pippa Malmgren: Actually, Clint, what you just said is so important. Think about it this way. What if within 10 years, a Google or an Amazon could make much more money, achieve more value by its currency than buy its stock. And that actually it does what the big trend in the market is, which is publicly listed companies go private and actually may not even need to be companies anymore. They just become this currency.
And I mean, if you think what is the liquidity and the change in the value It's got to be larger than a stock, right? Because how many people play in the stock market versus how many people transact in the general economy? The latter is much larger. So, could we envisage a world where actually the corporation comes to an end because it's more profitable to have the consumer using your coin Than it is to have them buying your shares?
Clint Cox: I mean, that, that becomes a really interesting question on any number of fronts, right? Because then you're looking at, you know, how do we value everything? How do you value things in the digital world? How do you value things in the real world? You know, I think Amazon would be the really interesting example to look at here, is, you know, if you're in that Amazon world and you're able to buy whatever you need to buy to live inside that ecosystem. I mean, think about it. Amazon has Whole Foods. Amazon has pretty much anything you would want to buy— sporting equipment, you know, any number of things that— from any number of sectors. Why couldn't you just stay inside that ecosystem and just use the Amazon coin and not worry about anything else?
I don't know. I think it becomes really interesting to see how these systems are going to interact. I think you're right, there's changes coming. And I think Libra, you know, Facebook's first initial project on this, I think that was the biggest wake-up call. I think, you know, when there's case studies done decades from now, Libra is going to be looked at as really the shockwave because I think that scared a lot of people into saying, we better get on board.
Pippa Malmgren: And just one more thing on this, which is certification of value. And so I was fascinated by this really amazing story of the Italian artist who auctioned off an invisible sculpture for like 18 grand. It was literally in his imagination, made of nothing. And it was part of this NFT movement, which I'm sure we'll all turn to and talk about in a minute. But the point is, what the investor bought wasn't the artwork, it was the certification of its existence.
And I do think that in this crypto space, and the digitization of money, we're going to be shifting to a world where the certification of the thing is more valuable than the thing itself. And that ties into which community do you belong to? What do you think is certified? And you're sort of part of an Amazon tribe and you're basically trading in Amazon certifications.
Does that make sense?
Erik Townsend: Pippa, that makes perfect sense to me. And I think we should go through the cryptocurrencies, the CBDCs, and the Silicon Valley currencies. Let's start with the view that a lot of Bitcoin fans have had, which is they think that, look, Bitcoin is clearly the biggest and most widely used of the cryptocurrencies that exist today. So this view, and it's not one that I share, but they think that, look, the outcome surely has to be that Bitcoin eventually is what dominates the digital currency landscape. It becomes the, the eventual replacement for the US dollar. Of course, it would have to evolve quite a bit from where it is today, but it's intended to evolve. They think that CBDCs, the ones that come from central banks, first of all, they don't really exist yet. The government is so far behind, they don't think it's a threat. And they kind of have this view that look at the first mover advantage of Bitcoin, it's got to win, or some people have the same view on Ethereum.
Is that possible that ultimately governments end up being steamrolled by independent innovation and the money systems of the world are replaced by cryptocurrencies that are designed to minimize the extent to which governments can monitor and control our financial affairs? Is that a realistic outcome? Let's start with Pippa Malmgren.
Pippa Malmgren: Okay, so I live in England. Where when you say you're going to vacuum the living room, you don't use the word vacuum, you use the word Hoover because Hoover happened to be the first brand name that the general public got familiar with when vacuum cleaners were invented. So everybody says, I'm going to Hoover the living room.
Bitcoin is exactly the same phenomena, right? It's because it was the first mega brand name in this space. But the fact is these days, Nobody buys Hoovers anymore. There are all these different vacuum cleaner makers, including Jim Dyson, who's created the Dyson, and it's quickly becoming its own brand name. Like you're going to Dyson the living room.
So I don't think that there's this first mover advantage that the Bitcoin crowd seems to believe they have. I don't think the first mover advantage works in business generally. Usually the first mover gets killed. It's the second, third mover who learn from their mistakes that make it. So I don't really buy it. And let's face it again, what I mean, you look up on Wikipedia, there are over 4,000 of these different options these days. All of them are getting better all the time. So, you know, the fact that it was just there first, it's like saying the Model T because it was the first car that that's it. It's just not how innovation works. I'll probably get killed now on internet by saying that.
Erik Townsend: The cancel culture is out to get you. Clint Cox, you actually manage a fund that invests in these existing assets like Bitcoin and Ethereum and so forth. Is there a real chance that they're actually going to dominate the financial system someday?
Clint Cox: That's a really tough call. I'm not sure I would say they're going to dominate the financial system as much as I would say they're going to become very, very important to society in general and become essential to the way that we interact and do things. So I think that Bitcoin is a phenomenal invention.
I mean, it's really a game changer. And I think Satoshi Nakamoto did phenomenal thinking behind it, really produced an elegant solution. So I'm not a Bitcoin maximalist. I think there's a lot of things that Like, Ethereum is a great example.
Smart contracts are what has launched this thing into the next phase. You know, smart contracts really change things. Bitcoin could have smart contracts, you know, in the future. Bitcoin could have DeFi attached to it in the future. Right now, the whole DeFi ecosystem is really based on Ethereum. But, you know, can Bitcoin survive? Absolutely. I think it can survive. Now, whether or not it is as big a portion of the ecosystem right now as it is today. I don't know if it's going to maintain, you know, the market share that it, that it has, but I think it's always going to be a part of the system.
And I think it's proof of work, and that's when you hear about the mining and all this other stuff. Proof of work is basically saying you have to prove that you've done something and that you've earned the right basically to try to get Bitcoin and, you know, place blocks and this, that, and the other. I don't want to go down that rabbit hole. But it's just that whole thing, that whole design, I think is beautiful. And it has so much buy-in right now.
There's tens of millions of people that are using Bitcoin on a regular basis today that I don't think Bitcoin is going to disappear. I think Bitcoin is going to be a backbone of this system. I mean, it's kind of like even with the British pound, the British pound still exists today. And it's still one of the largest currencies traded in the world.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Clint Cox: But they're not the dominant world reserve currency. So, I don't think Bitcoin will dominate all the way through this, but I think it'll play an important role.
And let me just say this, governments, although they're really behind on this technology, I don't think you can count governments out, right? They can regulate and forbid on-ramps, off-ramps. They can tax it out of practical existence. They can pressure founders, developers, miners, Anyone who has to go on a border crossing can be held up. So I think they've got a lot of tools to make sure that they can still maintain some amount of control over the monetary system.
Erik Townsend: I want to move on to central bank digital currencies, or CBDCs, next. That's coming up right after this message from our sponsor. Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to Escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds.
Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN. Let's move on to central bank-issued digital currencies, or CBDCs. Now, China has been the early mover here, but already central banks around the world are evaluating CBDCs.
Erik Townsend: They're talking about it. I've heard every imaginable view ranging from these CBDCs are going to completely dominate the market as governments outlaw Bitcoin and other non-government currencies, which means they won't go away, but they would become You know, something only the, the bad guys are, are using. The opposite prediction, of course, could be that the people reject government-issued money completely and just favor the Bitcoin revolution. So what should we make about CBDCs at this point in the story? Is this where the really big future is, or is this still a question mark as to whether these things can compete with non-government cryptocurrencies?
Pippa, why don't we start with you?
Pippa Malmgren: So, I think that governments are definitely going to be introducing these. There's no question about it whatsoever. I think that they are going to have— that will split the private crypto market into 2 broad camps, those that fully comply with government rules and those that don't. The ones that comply will be allowed to be, as Clint says, interoperable and connected to that official system.
But because it's all about data gathering, I have some big questions about it. And so one of them is, why do we see the biggest target of defense spending these days is actually on computational power? It's governments in this massive space race for who will have the fastest supercomputers, the fastest quantum computers, And there's in fact a race for where can you store and manipulate data. And I see data centers being built literally under the depths of the oceans and in places like the Arctic because data gets hot really fast, physically it gets hot and you have to air condition it in order to keep the data sound. And so the easy thing is you start building data centers in cold places. I.e., under the ocean and out in the Arctic, or even in Antarctica eventually.
And so how far can you go? One question that I find a lot of people in the US military are already raising is China says they're creating this sovereign digital currency and they've got the social credit system, but how are they actually able to process all that data? Maybe they aren't. They just say they can, but they aren't actually doing it. It's a super interesting question. Like when you start adding the numbers up, how many petaflops can you actually process and manage? And if we're right that a digitized sovereign currency is really about data connectivity, then who really has the infrastructure for that? And I think that will define the timing of how and when, how quickly it gets introduced more than anything.
So that's one thing. Second, I don't think the option to opt out is going to be available. If you start transacting, you still have to touch a keyboard or you have to give a voice command. And more and more, as all the devices you use are connected up to the official spaces, it will be clocked that you're doing this, and then that will bring its own trouble. So I think that the split between the private crypto that adheres to government rules and private crypto that doesn't, private crypto that doesn't isn't going to last very long. Now, there are people in that world, the darknet crowd, who would say, no, no, no, we can outrun governments and watch us do it. Yeah, but somehow they all, as Clint said earlier, they get arrested when they go on vacation in Thailand, right?
I just I don't see how it's possible to move off the grid. And so yeah, that's where I am on that question.
Erik Townsend: Clint, what does it mean when CBDCs hit the market and how does that affect the existing crypto assets?
Clint Cox: So these CBDCs, they already exist today somewhat peacefully. I mean, it's just the nascent stages. So you have the Bahamian Sand Dollar that exists today. That is a CBDC. Now, it's not impactful because there's not a lot of people using the Bahamian dollar anyway, but that is going to expand. Pippa's talked several times already about what China's effort is in this realm. And I think that that is going to be the dominant player in China, bar none. That is going to be the dominant player. And what have they done in preparation of that? They are making sweeping changes, right?
Pippa Malmgren: Yeah.
Clint Cox: No more Bitcoin mining. They kicked all the Bitcoin miners out. You know, then they said, hey, we're gonna really clamp down on Tencent and Ant Financial, which is, uh, Alipay and WeChat. So I think these efforts to make sure in preparation that the CBDC can be dominant, China's clearing out the, you know, the competition. That's pretty clear. But when you look at the rest of the world, how is that going to be? You know, how is that going to integrate? Well, I think, you know, all of us have to pay taxes. Now, some of us have some kind of interaction with the government, but governments are going to be changing as well, right? I think— I don't think there's going to be this revolution where, you know, the people stand up and reject all this, but I think there's a rapid evolution of government. I think we're going to see voting on the blockchain. I think we're going to see voting on issues in real time. I think representatives are going to be able to get their opinions from all of their constituents in real time on any topic.
I think we're headed for a different representational system, and I think that's phenomenal. I think that's great. And I think that will lead to other changes as well. And I think CBDCs are going to bring infrastructure, they're going to bring adoption, and they're going to necessitate this interoperability because your big players, your FAANG stocks, They're going to have influence and lobbying influence in DC, and they're going to make sure that their systems, their coins may be interoperable with this system.
So, I mean, you can look at the things that have happened already. I think CBDCs are inevitable, but also keep in mind, innovation always moves faster than the government. So, as Pippa said, you know, some of these dark market guys, they think that they're always going to be ahead of the government. That's probably true in some ways, but I think that those margins are closing. I think innovation always moves faster because the government can't be organized in such a way that it can actually be on top of all this. But I think, you know, the lobbying efforts are also right there to make sure that some of these things happen. So I think it's going to be a combination. I don't think it's a clean, you know, this way or that way yet.
Pippa Malmgren: Actually, I got a question about that. So I've been watching JP Morgan's move into the crypto space, and it's been so fascinating because We all saw Jamie Dimon was like, this is just never going to happen. This is a dead end. And then suddenly they're like a major player in the space and deeply involved with Ethereum. And so is the JP Morgan coin the test run for the new digital dollar? That's one question I have. And second, what was so fascinating was watching the Chinese literally smash up the Bitcoin mining machines, but lots of them somehow managed to escape the country. And where did they go?
They went to Texas. And so is Texas the new minting center of the crypto universe? I'd love, Clint, if you've got views on those 2 things.
Clint Cox: Yeah, so I don't know if JP Morgan's actually a test case or a test run here. I think that's Probably an experiment that may turn into something else. But I also think they needed to show, and they were very clear on this, they love the blockchain, but they didn't like Bitcoin. Now, of course, they're also saying Bitcoin's okay, and maybe that's a good part of clients' portfolios and things like that. So they definitely come back on that, and it's no longer a fraud.
And so I think that's good. I think that's showing that first there was real pushback. Now they're saying, okay, no, we're going to engage with this. So, I'm not really sure where JP Morgan Coin is going to go long-term, but I think there's a lot of potential there for what it could be. You know, you could be trading inside different supply chains with different clients that are all JP Morgan clients and not have to have these accounts, you know, these foreign exchange accounts that you're just having money sit there doing nothing. So, I think there are good ways it could be used, but I'm not really sure, and I'm not privy to the information that would allow me to give good information on that. And if I was, I probably couldn't talk about it. But as far as what happened with this Bitcoin mining thing in China, it's amazing to me that it looks like China is really giving up one of the great advantages that they had over this.
And one of the big arguments was China can control Bitcoin because they had more than 51% of the hash rate, which you don't need to know what that all means, except that it means that they could if they wanted to, if they acted in concert They could shift or change the way the Bitcoin blockchain operated and therefore shift or change where the value in Bitcoin was. That's now gone. They don't have that advantage anymore. And I think Texas is an obvious place to be. I mean, we've all seen the blow-off gas stacks when you're doing oil and gas production, and you don't need to blow off that gas anymore. You can now use it to mine Bitcoin. There's a lot of places.
You're looking at any number of things from hydro dams to geothermal to this natural gas blowoff. All that stuff is now being used for Bitcoin mining. And there's a few other cryptos that also mine. But yeah, I think it's amazing. I think strategically, a pretty large misstep by China.
And actually, I was thrilled when they made the announcement and actually dumbfounded.
Erik Townsend: I'd like to move on now to what I consider to be the single most misunderstood aspect of CBDCs. And by the way, I think I think it's the central bankers whose ignorance astonishes me the most on this. What I'm talking about here is the clear and obvious opportunity to design a digital currency system with built-in monetary policy transmission tools, replacing the conventional tools such as policy interest rates, forward guidance, and quantitative easing with a completely new and profoundly more effective suite of monetary policy transmission tools designed right into the digital currency system. I dedicated an entire chapter of my book to this topic, and I would love to get both of your views on where this is headed, because I think once the central bankers figure out that they can have even more power with more monetary policy tools by going digital, I think you're gonna see them jump on the bandwagon real quickly.
Pippa, what do you think?
Pippa Malmgren: So having worked in that world, you know, I was Often in meetings, they would have the so-called plus one in the White House. So Alan Greenspan and Roger Ferguson would be his plus one, and I was working for Larry Lindsey and I would be the plus one. So I've been in the room where discussions have been about these kinds of issues, and it's like a priesthood.
I mean, it's like there's a certain catechism. There's a certain belief system, and everyone in that world shares this belief system. And if you showed up with a different belief system, then you're a heretic in that environment. And so it's very difficult for someone to step up and say, actually, the whole concept of monetary policy is going to be totally, profoundly different.
in this new environment when the main line of discussion is that the traditional monetary policy we have all learned and we know all the words to all the songs for that, that is true and real and good. And this crypto stuff is fundamentally disruptive, bad. We got to be careful about this. It's the How do you even begin to have that conversation is my point. So I think they'll get there in the end, but it could be a very long time for the priesthood of monetary policy to really properly clock, as Clint said, the incredible scope and pace of innovation and catch up and say, oh gosh, What this really means is we need an entirely new definition of monetary policy, its tools and instruments. It's an understanding of if we do this, then what will happen?
Usually it takes decades in order for a consensus opinion to form about these kinds of things, and time is passing so much faster. This is one of the key features of the modern economy. The speed of change, and governments can't keep up with the speed of change. So I think we're going to have a wobbly period where central bankers, they launch into the future with a comment or a statement but don't have the infrastructure to back it up.
The market responds thinking that this is a well-thought-through strategy. Then they find out that it isn't. Then government has to go figure out a strategy. And it's this kind volatility introduced by a kind of arrhythmia of different speeds all converging on one subject, a different pace for change that's occurring at the government level versus the private sector level. And it's like a heart attack, an arrhythmia in your heart gives you a heart attack, and an arrhythmia in belief systems, comprehension of belief systems can do the same. So I think it's going to be volatile and bumpy and really hard for people who aren't paying close, close attention to what's going on.
Erik Townsend: Clint, what could happen when central bankers figure out the opportunity to design monetary policy into a digital currency system?
Clint Cox: I think that Pippa kind of put her finger on it. I mean, I think they're probably slow in thinking about doing this because they, you know, if you look at the US dollar, for instance, look at the Fed, US Treasury, we're the dominant player in the world. So you don't want to give up that position. And why would you change anything if you're the dominant player in the world? And I think that's why, once again, back to Facebook Libra and to what China's doing right now, those are things that are wake-up calls. Those are the smelling salts that either wake us up or don't. As far as getting them to actually embrace this, the idea is really to talk about what are the advantages? What if you could do XYZ? And some of those things like CBDCs, because they'll be programmable, you could adjust sales taxes on the fly based on income. For instance, you just got a bonus. Oh, we just changed your tax bracket.
Now you pay more. You know, I mean, it could be the great equalizer. What if you could say, yeah, you know what, if you're out there and you're a billionaire, when you go buy a coffee, it's $13,000 for a coffee, you know, instead of $6 for a latte. You know, it's like that kind of thing. You could adjust things based on that. There's a lot of things you could do. It would be automated. You could enforce child support, alimony. You know, you could also encourage spending by deteriorating value. You could basically burn small amounts of it so that people have to spend it faster if you wanted to incentivize spending in, you know, in the environment. You could have separate classes of CBDC. You could have like a corporate class. You could have a retail class. You could have different savings spending lockup periods. So, you could have like a saving class that, hey, if you park your money here, then you'll get a little bit of interest.
Or if you're going to spend money, you have to take it out of that. It's almost like the government could be its own bank. The ability to lock access when you travel. So, you could only have access to $10,000. You could have customized bonds based on bids. You could have tracking, tracing, timestamps, location. of all purchases, put that into, you know, machine learning and basically figure out why people are doing what they're doing. You might even be able to detect where COVID is picking up somewhere because, oh, everyone's buying this and this is related to COVID. I mean, they've already done things like that with Google, right? So I think you could have algorithm-based interest rate adjustments, airdrops, payments to the people. I mean, I think you'd be able to follow supply chains and trends in supply chains, analyze the big data, and see where things are coming from. And see where the pinch points are.
I mean, I think there's so many tremendous advantages. You know, I don't see that once they realize that, that they don't take advantage.
Erik Townsend: Clint, you made a couple of excellent points there that lead us directly to our next topic, which is the role of Silicon Valley digital currencies, or SVDCs, in the overall DeFi revolution. But that's a big topic, and we're out of time for this week. Listeners, be sure to tune in for part 2 of our series next week, when we'll continue the conversation about the role of Silicon Valley digital currencies in the DeFi revolution, and then we'll go on to distinguish digital currency systems from decentralized finance, the bigger, broader trend that is likely to be the biggest financial and general social trend of the next several decades. From there, we'll explore some ideas that I posited in my book, starting with the opportunity to re-engineer the entire fractional reserve banking system. And literally redefining what money itself is and how credit works. That could be the most positive thing to come along for society in 1,000 years.
Or, the process could be hijacked by greedy people focused on designing a system to benefit themselves rather than society as a whole. Finally, we'll discuss my proposal for a digital sovereign bond market that could completely Disrupt the balance of power on the global stage. All of that is coming up next week in part 2 of the MacroVoices 2021 Summer Special. We'll be back to our regular format on September 2nd. For the MacroVoices Podcast Network, I'm Erik Townsend.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Voices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to Mailbag@MacroVoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from
Announcer: time to time in our Mailbag segment.
MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices is presented by the MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Wayne Himelsein — Logica Funds founder (transcribed at w1716 as 'founder of Logic of Funds') (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. And now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 287 was recorded on September 2nd, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow.
Logica Funds founder Wayne Himelsein joins me as this week's feature interview guest when the topic will be trading the long volatility strategy. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick will present a slide deck which translates a lot of the concepts that Wayne presented into actionable long vol trades that work in today's market.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's jump to that S&P 500. We took a couple weeks summer break and ran that special and really Nothing has changed. The market just keeps plugging away on the upside. We're at 4,536 at the time of recording this on the S&P 500. What's your take on these markets?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, my view is really unchanged from before our summer break. I think we're in the middle of an Austrian crack-up boom, and I think that the market is likely to head higher from here, not because these valuations make sense, but because there's too much easy money chasing around in the system.
So, I think that this is likely to continue, and I don't see any reason for it to change. If it did change, boy, we're at an awfully long way up to fall from here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index, which is really for the last 2 weeks finally taking a bit of a pause and a break. We were as high as 93.50 on the DXY, and we've now backed off back to some of the early August lows near the 92 handle. Is that it for the dollar index? What's your take on there?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think we're still consolidating, same as I've been saying for, I don't know, months and months now. Until we see a closing print below 89.5, or let's say 89 to really seal the deal, or much higher, well above 93.5. We're in a consolidation. That's where we've been. And I don't see any reason to break out of it anytime soon because I think the market is trying to still figure out all of this monetary policy from all around the world and how it's going to conflict with one another and eventually what it results in. So, I think it's going to stay confused for a long time.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's get to crude oil. I was really curious to get an update from you because when we last were together on this doing a market wrap, Oil was on the way down and correcting down to the low 60s. In the last 2 weeks, we've seen a significant reversal. We, over the last few days, we consolidated. And then today on that bullish US demand data, we've got a punch above 70, at least temporarily. Is this back to an oil bull market again?
Erik Townsend: I think that the bull market is continuing. As I've said before, it was put on hold or on pause because everybody was assuming that August was gonna be the big month of huge drawdowns on inventory. When that didn't happen, and instead we saw a worsening of the Delta variant COVID spreading around the world, it just led everybody to start to panic and say, oh my gosh, we could be headed toward negative prices again. The fundamentals are not there for that. I still think we're headed above $80 into the mid-$80s.
I had said I thought that was going to happen by Labor Day. Obviously, it's not going to happen by Labor Day. I still think it'll happen before year-end that we'll be trading over $80.
As far as inventory this week, we had seen the market sell off before inventory.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: Probably on expectations that Saudi Arabia and the rest of OPEC+ was going to do exactly what they were expected to do and what they did do, which was to go ahead with their increase in production starting next month. That had the market down a bit, and of course it bounced right back up when we saw a fairly significant drawdown of 7.2 million barrels drawn down on crude oil in the United States. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 836,000 barrels. Gasoline building 1.3 million. Distillates drawing down 1.7 million. Wow. Million barrels. Meanwhile, US production ticking up again to 11.5 million barrels. That's a pretty significant increase, starting to look like a trend there, and it's in the opposite direction from what some people had anticipated. So it looks like, at least on the US production side, that's a little bit of slightly bearish data, but the rest of what we're seeing is pretty bullish, and I think that we're still headed above 80 eventually.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on gold because obviously we had that washout in that first week of August, but really gold recovered right back into that trade range where it was through much of July hovering just, you know, around the $1,800 level, give or take. We're closing around $1,810 or at least trading around $1,810 at the time of recording. What's your take here on gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think you're right that it's back to where we were, but back to where we were is stuck underneath the long-term moving averages. We've got the 100 and 200-day moving averages almost co-located Located now between $1,815 and $1,819 or so. So what we really need here, Patrick, is a daily close over $1,820 and for it to stay there for several days. That would be the green light for the next big move higher. Until we get over this critical resistance though, Patrick, we're back to where we were in July when we were saying, oh boy, we're sitting right here on this critical line. As soon as we can get over it, it'll probably accelerate from there. We ended up going way down instead of up. Now we're back up to where we started. Let's see what happens. But if we get that breakout above 1820, I think there's a big move ahead.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on that 10-year Treasury yield because it really does look like bond traders took the summer off. I mean, we're trading basically at 1.30 back in July, and here we are still trading at that same level. And it doesn't seem like the, the US Treasury bond markets are as— well, they're winding up sideways, but no big trend moves emerging yet. Do you have any intuition as to what's next?
Erik Townsend: Well, my intuition is that what's next probably doesn't come next or doesn't happen for quite a while. If you look at the history of the bond market, a lot of people want to say, okay, it seems like the bond bull market of the last 35 years is finally over. Okay, well, if you believe it's finally over, that leads a lot of people to jump to the conclusion, well, surely it must be reversing then. So, now it's all downhill from here. If you look at what happened after World War II, when the bond market bottomed, it stayed bottomed for like 10 years before it eventually started making a march to higher yields. So, I think it could be several years that we're stuck here at just above zero interest rates. And frankly, I don't think we're stuck in an interest rate trap. We can't go any higher in interest rates until we inflate away the real value of all of the public and private debt that exists in the system.
And that's going to take a long time.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Logica Funds founder Wayne Himelsein. Erik, why did we invite Wayne on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Wayne runs a fund that's all about trading the long volatility strategy. And when we had Chris Cole on the show just before the Volmageddon event back in 2018, Chris explained exactly what was wrong and why the short vol trade had the potential to blow up and talked about the benefits of the long vol trade. Ever since then, we've had quite a few listener emails saying, get, get Chris or somebody else back on to talk more about how you actually put on this long vol trade. So, we've got Wayne talking to that subject in today's interview, and then we're going to extend it in the postgame segment when Patrick has a chart deck of his own, which will take a lot of the concepts that Wayne relates and translate them into actionable trading strategies.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Wayne is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a fintech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. Two of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets, beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the fintech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Wayne Himelsein, founder of Logica Funds Wayne has prepared a slide deck to accompany today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, looking for the downloads.
Wayne, there's a backstory to how we got you on the show this week. Our listeners were treated way back in the beginning of 2018, in January, we had Chris Cole from Artemis Capital on the show, and I want to refer actually to your slide deck on page 7, because when we had Chris on in January, we were at the top of that big black performance line of this short volatility trade, which had gotten so much attention and frankly suckered a lot of people into taking risks they didn't understand. Chris told us what was about to happen, or what was at risk of happening. And of course, as your chart shows here, that's exactly what happened only a couple of weeks later. Since then, we've had a huge amount of interest in this subject, but we really have a lot of listeners who want to know, how do you put on on the long vol trade and what's the real secret sauce to getting a positive carry when you do that.
So, Wayne, you're kind of the guy for the long vol fund. Talk to us a little bit about how you see this long vol versus short vol space and how your views maybe differ from Chris Cole's, which a lot of our listeners are familiar with.
Wayne Himelsein: Sure. Yeah. So, long vol versus short vol space. I mean, that's just a giant question. And it's a giant question because short vol is really just everywhere. I mean, it's pervasive across All of Wall Street. And so when you say the space, it's— I look at it as like 99% is short vol and then perhaps 1% of space is long vol, which is certainly the contrarian view.
And to really highlight the extremes of short vol, there's a great graphic that we have on page 5 of the presentation, which shows the— how this is the negative skew across different hedge fund strategies. And so you see that we call it the blood chart. It's the blood chart because everything's red, right? And it just doesn't matter what type of strategy you are. And the top one is merger arb has one of the highest negative skews in the industry or across hedge fund styles, at least over that period. It's not totally persistent over time, but certainly over this period it was merger arb. And you go down the list, there's completely different things, event-driven and multi-strat, relative value. They all have their pitch books with completely different stories to tell about what they do and how they do it and how they identify cheap versus expensive and all these different facets of each strategy. And yet at the end of the day, they They all share the same exposure, which is this negative skew, i.e., their down vol is greater than their up vol.
They consistently make little bits of money and every once in a while have these extreme events where things go really out of whack and get this big downside move or big drawdown that creates this negative skew. So it's like always waiting for this event when you're invested in one of these strategies, which is really all strategies is the way to think about it. And the one last point of looking at this page and this chart of how widespread it is in our industry is, to me, it's almost ironic, is the, let's see, 8th one down is hedge fund index of multi-strat. So multi-strat shows to have a -1.2 negative skew. But the point here is the irony is that it's multi-strat.
Like, these are people who get into the business to say, we're gonna diversify strategies, right? Their sole job is to build a diversified book. And yet with all that they're doing, at the end of the day, no matter how diverse their pie chart is, They're still ending up with the same grand exposure to short volatility. And it's just fascinating, right? How much of it there is out there.
So when you say the short vol space, it's really, to me, the answer is pretty much everyone, right? So then at the other side, on the other side of the coin, you get the small group of people who say, okay, you know, we're gonna battle the world, right? We're gonna say, and it's really hard to do. It's, there's all these odds are against you when you're long vol. But the problem being that you don't wanna sit with that negative skew. You want the opposite. outcome in your book.
We want the fact that we want our upvol to be greater than our downvol. It's okay to make little bits along the way and then every once in a while have a home run. To me, that's a much happier, safer, and pleasant way to live is I'm not sleeping at night because the big event might happen tomorrow. I'm going to sleep comfortably because tomorrow I might have the big pop, right? And so it's just almost like philosophically, it's the other side that that, that is a pleasant way to exist. So that's, that's point number one, which is really the 2 different spaces.
Erik Townsend: Wayne, actually where I was headed with this is a lot of people, and I think yourself included, what you just said is to my thinking the, the key phrase here, which is you said make a little bit and then make a lot when you hit that home run. Well, wait a minute, if I go back to page 7 in your chart deck and I look at the way the short vol strategy works. It's making little bits of money over and over again all the time. And then of course it loses really, really hard at the end. We see at the beginning of 2018 on this chart. Well, what that says to me is, okay, short vol was winning, winning, winning. That means long vol was losing, losing, losing. All of a sudden, long vol has its big win.
Okay, it sounds like what we're talking about is an insurance policy. In other words, it's a negative carry. I've gotta pay money. I've gotta lose money to have this in my portfolio. And it pays off the day that something really big happens and the market crashes, and then I get that hedge component, but I got to pay for it. What I think you're advertising, and I know other people are advertising, is you don't have to pay for it. It's a positive carry, even though it's a long vol strategy. And I think that's where the skepticism comes into mind is, wait a minute, how'd you pull that off?
Wayne Himelsein: Yeah, that's a great question, right? So, how do you pull that off? So, before I jump into that answer of how and give away, of course, a bunch of secret sauce, let me Let me step back for a second, divide out the world of long vol.
We were talking before about broadly short vol versus long vol, and I said it's basically 99% of the world versus 1% of the world in long vol. So the bigger irony is that within long vol, within that 1%, there's also a big division where the grand majority of long vol achieves long vol with some use of short vol, right? Because to your point, how do you do that? How do you own insurance and make money? Really, the true answer is you can't, right? It doesn't, it's almost financially, it makes no sense. You can't own pure insurance and have a positive carry. Therefore, you have to introduce something, some source of alpha in your book, or potentially short vol exposure that generates the carry to pay for what people might phrase as net long vol, right? So, the broad majority of the 1%, the long vol community infuses a short vol overlay, or not overlay, really piece of their book to generate net long vol.
So, let me explain that. And generally the way would be through relative value trading, right? And relative value says that whether it's a moneyness spread, which is buying an option at one strike and selling at another strike, I might sell at-the-money options to buy out-of-the-money options, right? In that case, I'm short some volatility with my at-the-money short, but that premium I'm taking in is paying for my long volatility, which might be, let's say, 20% out-of-the-money.
If the market corrects only 10%, I may not be making money. I may even be losing because I'm short from from at the money. I'm short from from the beginning, and I need the market to drop enough where that's going to pass that inflection point, and suddenly my long vol position down at 20% is going to take off and and first overtake my short, and then start really getting convex where my short just goes away. Right? So that that risk associated with that short to pay for the long, I'd call that an attachment point risk or a path dependent. Where it requires by definition a certain magnitude of correction for that long vol to not only kick in to break even, but even to start making money, right? Or to start making real money. So you're great in an event like the COVID meltdown in February, March, because a 30% correction meant if you were short at the money and long out of the money, your short's gonna disappear, your long's gonna overtake it and make you dramatically more.
The problem becomes with smaller The average correction, quote, in the S&P is said to be around 10%. At that level, you're basically making no money, if not even losing on your, quote, insurance because you sold some insurance to pay for your real risk insurance.
So that's the broad world of, I'll call it spread trading. And of course, there's many ways to do it. The one I just described was a moneyness trade where your strikes are at different levels. There are also many types of spreads. There's, for example, calendar spreads where it's you're long one in January and you're short out in December or whatever it might be. Or the inverse of that. It's up the term structure where you're taking advantage of differences of option pricings along the calendar. There's also one of the ones that I'm really not a big fan of is doing shorting something where there's— you take idiosyncratic exposure in one thing to get some broader long volatility in another. Let's say, for example, I shorted some individual names in the S&P and had took in those premiums to buy S&P index of all, right? So that could work, but it has again a path dependency, a basis risk, because what if those things you're short are the ones that end up turning against you?
What if, you know, it could be, for example, in COVID there was the meltdown, but Pfizer did really well or Zoom did really well. So you could be short the wrong thing, so to speak. And so what you're using to pay for your long insurance has this idiosyncratic risk. Risk that ends up hurting you when you're trying to insure. So all of these have their exposures, but all of them together have some form of shorting vol to pay for long vol.
Okay, so let's say that that's the world, or that's the, that's the 95% of long vol books out there where they're choosing different varieties of spreads, as I said, whether moneyness, whether calendar, whether individual positions across different asset classes versus others. And therefore being different to each other. I stepped in and I surveyed that world and I said, you know what? I have a problem with that. I don't like that. It's really troubling to me that one thinks it's okay to sell insurance if you're offering insurance. It's like, imagine you have car insurance and you get hit and you go make the claim and the insurance company says, well, you know what? You were on the freeway. We only cover side Streets, right? That's not acceptable, right? If you're in the business of insurance, you want to insure no matter what happens. You want the most path independence, right? You don't want any form of event to not cover you, whether the market only corrects 10% or whether the market correction doesn't include a certain basket of names or of assets.
Wayne Himelsein: So I looked at this and I thought to myself, you know, there's an analogy I love to use, which is that the problem with getting short in order to pay for long is I call counterthesis, right? It's counterthesis because as a long vol manager, you're saying, I'm going to provide this long vol, I'm going to provide this convexity. And if you go short vol somewhere else to pay for that, then literally you're taking on a counterthesis trade.
It's like analogously, you're saying, I want to do the high jump, so I'm going to go put on a weight belt, right? You don't put on a weight belt to do the high jump. You take off the weight belt. And in fact, you take everything out of your pocket. Because your goal is to jump as high as you can. That's convexity, right? That's long vol. So I understood that, or at least I spent some time grasping what that meant to me and how problematic all of these short vol trades were in long vol books.
Wayne Himelsein: And I said to myself, I've got to find a way to not do that. How can I not have any short vol exposure in order to be long vol? And the problem is that's very, very difficult. But however, I came upon in thinking through this, my background started at a trading desk. And so I was around traders and I traded myself. I've traded myself for 25 years. So I know trading and I'm in concept, trading has a short vol component, but without short vol risk. And let me explain that for a second is when you, let's say trading is conceptually, right? What is a trade is to buy low, sell high, right? That's if you're a good trader, you consistently buy low, sell high. And let's put that on a ticker. Let's say you're trading S&P, right? So you buy S&P on a dip and it runs up and you sell some. In that example, I buy S&P at some level and I sell at some level higher, let's say 5 points higher.
When I've sold some of my inventory, my position, I'm selling stock. So it's the same thing as shorting because I'm selling. But in this case, I'm shorting some of, or selling some of my inventory. I'm not selling naked, right? I'm not selling inventory I don't have, therefore I'm not short, but I'm doing the same thing as a short vol trade because I'm taking off, I'm going against the grain. The market's going up. I bought it at some level. It's starting to run up and I'm not holding my position for the market to continue gaining, which would be a long vol trade. I'm taking off inventory to reduce that position. Therefore, I'm going against the grain of the momentum of the market. In that case, by literally selling inventory I own, I'm doing the equivalent of shorting vol, right? Except at the end of the day, I'm not short vol. I've still got only long inventory, just less of it.
So that idea struck me as a way to achieve long vol, or rather a way to pay for long vol with some embedded short vol exposure, but without literal short vol, right?
So now let's take this through a specific example. If one, let's say, wants to buy puts on the S&P 500, Right? So naive put ownership would say, let's buy some puts today and hold them for whatever, 6 months. And so now you have your put position, you have pure insurance, and all you see is it decaying, i.e., the opposite of the chart we're looking at on page 7, right? It's decaying. And then if there's an event in the S&P, that pops up. Okay, that's the naive position. Now I want to infuse my short vol-through trading onto that put option. So on Monday, I come in and, and, um, and I see puts are relatively cheap using our models, right? So we say, okay, let's buy 100 puts. Now on Tuesday, you come into the market and there's a little bit of a spike. Puts jump up. I bought them, let's say, at $1 and they jump up to $1.20. Well, great, I'm up a little bit on my puts.
I, I have an inventory of 100, so I sell 10 of them. I end the day with 90. Great. Uh, come in the next day, there's a little bit more of a put spike because S&P is down again that day, and I sell another 20. I'm left with 70 At the end of the day, by the fourth day or third day, whatever it is, you come in the next day, and now the S&P bounces. Right? Goes down a few days, and it has a rally, and and vol crushes a little bit. It gives back. So now I'm only in seventy. I can now go and buy back those thirty I sold at a buck twenty and a buck thirty. I can now go buy them back at ninety cents at a cheaper price.
Right? So now I'm back to my position of a hundred. But I've scalped some money out of the market. I've made money trading along the way by conceptually shorting vol, but shorting only through selling some of my inventory. So that's a really interesting way if one could efficiently and cleverly trade the market, scalp the market, one could consistently stay long volatility but pay for it along the way with the profits derived from that scalp. Scalping—that's how we set out to do it, and that's what we do.
So the other piece of that is that when you're doing that, you're going to say to me, "Well," or you—I don't—you might say to me, "You might your next question might be," but the question that immediately strikes me is, "Well, you've got to have some risk, right? The risk of the shortfall, the spread trades that I described earlier, where one is using some short to pay for long and getting net long—the risk there is the path dependency, is the attachment point."
So what is my risk? My risk is that, well, I never have any short. So I've got, I'm always long volatility. I'm 100% long, both net and gross, right? But my risk is that I have less options or less long vol the day I might need it, right? So if that day that I was down to, from 100 down to 70, if the next day was the start of the COVID meltdown, well, I'm not in 100, I'm only in 70.
So I'm not going to make quite as much when the market then cracks 10, 20, 30%, right? And I'm— and I am selling each day it's cracking, so I'm monetizing along the way, which means at the end of the event, once the market's down 30%, I haven't made 100% on my long vol. I've only made, let's say, 40% because I've been monetizing as it's cracking so that I can buy back cheaper because my My method is modulating my inventory, not shorting. So in that sense, the risk can be that I'm in less than I need to be. At the same time, I could have a lucky event where vol gets cheaper, and instead of 100, I buy another 20, another 20. I'm in 140 puts. I'm over my necessary number because I'm buying it more cheaply. And then the event happens that day. So instead of making 100%, like I would in my 100 inventory of puts, I make 130%, right?
So that's the lucky outcome. The point is that I have a probabilistic, or a probability rather, around having more or less on the day I need it. So, if you put that in a little kind of grid of outcomes, I could have right the right amount. I could have 100 and everything's good. I could have less than 100 and I make less. And I could have more than 100 and I make more. So, what is somebody suffering with me? They're suffering uncertainty around the magnitude of my payout. Depending on how much inventory I have the day of, let's say, Black Monday, right? And so to me, that is a worthwhile risk. That is a very worthwhile risk because no matter what, I'm long vol all the time. All I can tell you is you may not make as much or you make more, but no matter what, you're not going to not pay off. So that's the whole kind of crux of it.
That was a lot I just shared with you. So I'm going to now turn it back to you, ask if you have any questions or follow-ups.
Erik Townsend: Well, I want to summarize that and make sure I got it straight. So, what I'm hearing here is my real premise question was, wait a minute, it seems to me like long vol is an insurance product that I would expect to pay for. How the heck is it possible that I could get paid for it? What you're telling me is my premise was right. Long vol in its purest form is an insurance policy, and it is inherent Constantly negative carry unto itself. What the other guys are doing in this long vol space is they're making money with another strategy. They're overlaying what may actually be a short vol strategy on top of their long vol strategy, and they're making enough money to pay for that long vol so that they end up not posting a negative carry, a negative return at the end of a month when nothing goes wrong.
It sounds like what you're saying Is you do essentially the same thing, but rather than taking risk in order to overcome that inherently negative carry of the long vol position, what you do is trade around a portfolio of long vol positions, and you use your trading skill to basically produce alpha that overcomes the inherent negative carry aspects of what is really a form of disaster insurance.
Is that a fair summary?
Wayne Himelsein: Yeah. That's a very fair summary. Very, very well summarized. And with one minor revision is, to me, the difference is we all take risk. The big bifurcation is taking counterthesis risk, which is having some short vol to pay for your long vol versus taking prothesis risk. Like, what is your thesis long vol? So, if you have some short vol in your book, literally selling options in your portfolio, well then, or relative value spreads, well then you have a counterthesis position in your book versus the prothesis that everything you do is long vol and supports that thesis. That bifurcates the world to me of the one side versus the other.
Erik Townsend: So, for somebody who wants, because we have a lot of very sophisticated traders who are doing their own trading, we also have a lot of family offices that are constructing portfolios and using funds like yours. For the people that are trading themselves. It sounds like the question of, okay, what's the magic secret sauce that makes it possible to show a positive carry on a pure long vol strategy? The answer is, it's impossible. That doesn't happen. What people who appear to be delivering that are really doing is they have a long vol strategy and they overlay it with some kind of risk-taking strategy. And if you want to do the same thing, you've got to decide which risk-taking strategy, including trading around positions, which is your risk trading strategy or risk-taking modality. People have got to take some kind of risk in order to pay for what inherently has a negative carry.
That's a fair statement, correct?
Wayne Himelsein: Absolutely. And I would actually step out what you said further to the entire world of investing. I mean, there is no free lunch. Like, let's just call it what it is, right? You cannot make money without taking some form of risk. And anybody who says they can, it just doesn't know what their risk is yet, right? So, any form of upside has some downside exposure. That's what we all do. That's what we all know. That's the world we live in.
And going back to all the different arbitrage strategies, they all have a really nice consistent payoff. Mean reversion is great. So you find something cheap, you sell something expensive, and it reverts and comes back together and you make your dollar. Every once in a while, there's a blowup and an expansion event that causes things to go out of whack and hence the negative skew. That is the risk of those strategies. So we all accept risk for upside.
That's a In the world of long volatility investing, there, once again, to your point, to my point, there has to be risk. There cannot be. So now you say, what type of risk do I want to take to get my long vol? Because it's impossible to have pure long vol naively and have it be positive carry. That's impossible. That's not the way the world works, quote, right? So once you're taking risk, now your decision is what type of risk does one want to take? And my big position is take risk, sure, but don't take counterthesis risk.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Wayne Himelsein: Take risk that fits alongside what you're doing. In my version, it was probabilistic risk around the magnitude of payoff. That to me is a very acceptable risk for having long vol exposure.
Erik Townsend: Wayne, let's talk more about how people who want to protect portfolios can go about doing that. Obviously, one option is to employ a fund manager like yourself to invest through a long volatility fund. fund as a hedge, it sounds like the most important due diligence question to ask is, okay, we know you're taking some kind of risk in order to pull this off with a positive carry. So what kind of risk are you taking? In the case of someone who's doing their own trading, they've really got to decide what kind of risk is consistent with their portfolio.
Now, when you talk about trading around these positions, are we talking about putting on a certain number of straddles and then taking off a certain number of straddles, or are we talking about legging into those straddles because you have a directional view on where the market is trading when you put the first half of a position on? What kind of trading strategies do you use in order to accomplish this?
Wayne Himelsein: That's a wonderful question. So, the answer is that, I guess, for us, we have to, once again, going back, not even for us, let's go back to what you and I were just talking about is one has to take risk. somewhere, right? So where's the risk you're taking? The risk I'm comfortable taking, I would say, is in the middle of the distribution. When I say the middle of the distribution, it would be helpful to look at page 19 of the presentation.
So start with a distribution on top. And this is a simple normal distribution, which is not the way most strategies look, but this is just for illustration or example purposes, keeping it very simple. We call it redistributing the risk. And this is the point, right? So, most strategies look like the top distribution there, is the risk is on the left, the rewards on the right, right? You have your exposure gets more and more out into the tails if there's a big event and your reward is you make money.
Okay. So, in a long volatility trade, the way we do it, we're long a straddle, right? A straddle, you see that picture on the left there is a straddle. A straddle is you have an at-the-money call and an at-the-money put, which means you're effectively betting on the market going in either direction. You just want to move a lot, right? It's a magnitude bet. You're long volatility, so you want a big, a big move in either direction. And, and so of course the basic straddle, the which is the gray dashed line you see on the left, is underwater. It's underwater right away because you're paying for either side. Let's say you pay for just for simplicity's sake, you pay a dollar for the call and you pay a dollar for the put. So before you even begin in, you've paid $2 that is every day decaying because there's a cost of owning options. It's theta. It's— there's a decline with time, right? The, the, the time value of an option is, is losing per day.
So as soon as you pay that $2, by a week later, that's worth $1.90, just for argument's sake.
So now you have this cost of ownership, we'll call it, that you have to not only beat, but you have to overcome, like, with some alpha. So our Our job at Logica is, I'll call it very simply, raising the straddle. And we say that above this illustration. Raising the straddle is generating alpha that is simply paying for that cost of ownership. That's all we're trying to do is make that $2, right? And if we can make it much smaller, we have that blue V. And what we call the holy grail is that gold-V up above, which is literally a positive carry straddle, right?
Erik Townsend: Right.
Wayne Himelsein: You make money if the market goes up, you make money if the market goes down. The more it goes up or down, the more you make, and you make money while you wait.
That is of course the holy grail. We all want to do that. That's what we try for. And our straddle falls somewhere in between.
So now the question is, in falling somewhere in between, back to what you're asking is, where's the risk taken? So what this translates is, looking over to the right on this page, is a straddle turns the top distribution, which is the very typical distribution associated with any time series of most strategies out in the world, right? Most investment strategies look like the top one except for a slightly different shape. But the risk on the left, the reward on the right is the big point. Now you move down to a straddle, you get the distribution below, which is saying this is really interesting because by being long calls and puts, you are long the left and the right tail, right? So you make a lot of money if the market goes up a lot, And you make a lot of money if the market goes down a lot. Your risk is in the middle, right? That's the $2.
That's the cost of ownership.
So what we have done really by owning a straddle is redistributing the risk to the middle of the distribution. You can't blow up because your left tail— actually, your shoulder and your tail on your left is covered. And on the right side, you're covered because you're long calls. You're going to go up with the market. So you have some risk in the middle, which is your cost of ownership.
Now, we get to how wide we allow that band to be, right? Those black lines that I'll say are the boundaries for the risk in the middle is somewhat equivalent to on the left side, that same color in the blue V right below the x-axis, right? That red in there, that's the risk you're taking. And so, what we decide is how much risk do we want to take there and what type of risk? Now, to your question is we are willing to take some directional risk.
And in fact, that happens naturally with the way we modulate our inventory on the straddle.
So go with an example here for a second is if you jump to page 12 for a moment, page 12 shows a straddle, but it shows this movement, this modulation of inventory as we move through the market. So the example I gave in the beginning of our discussion was only talking about the side of puts. Now we introduce a straddle, which is puts and calls. It's just both sides of the market. So let's go through that example. Let's say on day 1, We're in 100 puts and 100 calls. So we have no directional bet and we're long vol. So we're long both tails.
Okay. So now we come in and the S&P's up a percent that day, right? It's Monday or whatever. The S&P's up a percent. So we say, okay, we made a little bit of money on our calls. Let's sell a few. So we sell 10 calls, right? So now we're in 90 calls, but still our 100 puts, which have drifted a little bit away, 1% away from From the money. So when we come into day 2, you see that right arm is now shallower. The angle has changed because we have a lighter inventory for market upside on our calls than we do on market downside on our puts, right? So the, the straddle has, quote, changed shape. Now follow that through for a few more days. Let's say day 2, we sell another 10 calls, right? Market's up again. And this day 3, market's up again, we sell another.
You take this through for Now, two weeks later, we're only in fifty calls and still a hundred puts. At this point, we're starting to lean short because we're selling our long inventory as the market's climbing. So, at the same time, what happens after the market's been up for a week or two? It has some give back days. So it gives back a few points after that, or it gives back a few percent. Well, fantastic for us because we're overloaded short.
So, i.e., we have more puts than calls. The right arm has gotten shallower. So on the day the market gives back. Now we sell or monetize some of our puts, and of course we buy back some of the calls we sold, hopefully at a cheaper price.
So what you see is happening is that because we're modulating our inventory on either side of the straddle, puts going up and down independently in number of in our size of position, calls going up and down independently in the size of the position, we are naturally going to get delta tilts. Any day of the week, we might be 100 puts, not 80 calls. We might be 100 calls, 80 puts. Whatever it might be is we're in some ratio. We turn what I'll call a naive straddle, which is 100 by 100, into what we call a dynamic ratio straddle. Very simple. It's dynamic because we're modulating either side independently. It's a ratio because once we modulate it, we're going to be in some ratio of calls to puts. puts, and it's a straddle because we're sticking to the straddle model.
Okay, so if you now jump back to our page we were on before, page 19, right? So we, we now look at the bottom distribution again, and we see that we're— by modulating that inventory, we are allowing those— the black lines that set the boundary of that, of that risk bucket is based on how much tilt we allow, right? So if I allow going back to my prior example, 100 puts and 50 calls, I get 50% short.
Well, then that boundary gets a bit wider, right? If I bring in— if I only allow my delta tilt to be 20% plus minus on either side, then that boundary gets a lot tighter, but then I can only make less money.
So the decision we make based on the behavior of markets and where things are in both the S&P and volatility and vol-of-vol, we look at all these parameters or these these variables that we study with our models, and we decide, number one, how much should we tilt left or right? How much should we sell or buy each day on either side of the straddle? And how wide or, or not should we allow this boundary of risk depending on the market's behavior? Sometimes we're in a tighter boundary and we cannot generate as much alpha. Sometimes we're in a wider boundary and we can generate more alpha. These are all the decisions that our models are to take the risk in the middle of the distribution and modulate the width of that risk. Does that all make sense or any follow-up questions?
Erik Townsend: That makes perfect sense, but help me understand the magnitude of this strategy in an overall portfolio. In other words, let's assume I'm a family office and I'm very focused on an S&P-centric investment strategy. Most of my investments are just S&P indexes. I'm using that example just because I'm assuming that that's what your data is mostly correlated against.
How much, what percentage of my assets would I have to invest in a long vol strategy in order to buy enough protection, so to speak, to be covered if there's a big downside event?
Wayne Himelsein: That's a very hard question to answer. I think it depends on how much downside you're willing to take. And let me expound on that is we are generally accretive to an S&P book, right? In the sense that an S&P, let's just look at the last 20 years, it goes up and up and up. And every once in a while it has these corrections or major sell-offs and then recovers and goes up and up and up, right? That's the market we've lived in for the last 20 years. And certainly I started in the markets in 1995, in the middle of the '90s bull market.
I mean, the first correction I saw was 1998, the blowup of Long-Term Capital and the default of the The Russian currency. So, all of these things though, that's the first, but that recovered in 3 months, right? And then, so I've watched this over time where S&P climbs, has this big event, and then recovers. We all call it the V, right, in the market. And these Vs even seem to be getting more aggressive, i.e., the recoveries are even faster. Look at COVID, April or February, March of 2020, we're back in 2 months or 3 months or something ridiculous after that sell-off.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Wayne Himelsein: So now we say, okay, really one could be, I mean, if we can't look at the data and say that's what the rest of the time is going to be, right? We can be somewhat empirical, but we don't know that that's going to always be like that. Of course, we can't sample that and say it's the future. But if we look at that and let's say we assume that's the future. So now somebody says, well, really it comes down to how much do I want to cushion that downside for having an average return on the upside that's a bit less, right?
But the more you cushion the downside at the same time, the more your geometric return, your compound return actually grows because more money is made by losing less than it is by making, right? So if we go to a COVID event, if you had some percentage, 10% of your portfolio in long vol, that 30% sell-off, if that 10% was enough to not be down 30, but to be, let's say, flat, Right. And then the rest of the time you carry similar to the S&P because the other return is not so dilutive, then of course, you're going to be the S&P but on steroids because you're the S&P without the drawdowns. That's got to be one of the greatest returns available, right? And so, I don't know that does it with 10%. I mean, to answer your question is the greater the percentage, 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, the more you're going to cushion that drawdown.
So let's say the 30% drawdown in COVID, COVID, you're not going to get to flat with just a 10% allocation to something like this. It might need to be 50/50, right? But at 10%, the 30, instead of being down 30, if you're pure S&P, maybe you're only down 15. I don't know. I don't know the exact numbers and I can't answer that because I don't have spreadsheets in front of me. But just think of it as the more you add, the less that drawdown will be. So the more you cushion that downside, And then the rest of the time, it's not that dilutive because it's not a negative carry, it's a positive carry.
So if the S&P's average year is up, let's say 8 or 9, if we realistically can achieve 8 or 9 in the trading, I'm not saying we do all the time, but our alpha-generating processes have the ability to generate 8 or 9 a year. Well, if they do, then we're matching the S&P in the positive times and we're cushioning it in the negative times. So you want it 50/50, right? Then you're just gonna be the S&P except it's a straight line, never with a drawdown.
Drawdown. So I guess going back to the point is it all depends on how much groups like ours can make during the positive times or the rest of the time, not in correction phase. And then it depends on how much somebody needs to cushion those events.
All of this, however, falls back on the point of us assuming that these recoveries or the V-shapes continue. If the Vs don't continue, if we get into a new world of S&P where there's a drawdown down and it sits for a few years— go back to 1973-74 bear market, things where it just kind of dwindles and it has slight run-up rallies and then gives it all back a few months later over the next few months and gets even— makes lower lows. If we get into this type of market, then things like this will be even healthier or better because vol will be spiking all over the place. And, and, and especially in what we do, I'll, I'll say that I think trading a straddle and trading both sides allows to be more favorable to swinging choppy markets because that's what effectively we're taking advantage of. So the choppier the correction, the better for us. But other people will like less choppy, a smoother, like a trailing bear market where the market's kind of just drifting down over years.
That would be tougher on us, but that might be better for a relative value long vol manager like the ones we were talking about earlier because their spreads are paying off while they're waiting.
So it all depends on what kind of market is our future market. This is uncertain. None of us know. And it all depends on how much somebody wants to cushion the risk. But the grand summary is that when you have a long vol approach that is accretive, that has a positive carry the rest of the time, then why not have it be a major portion of your book?
Why should portfolios be 99% short vol and 1% long vol? I'm a believer that whether it's us or us and a group of people, portfolios should have far more long vol in them than they currently do. You know, I mean, that multi-strat we referred to on that first slide, they should have no negative skew. If you're a multi-strat, you should not have negative skew. You should have as much long vol in your book as you do arb and mean reversion-based approaches that are short vol exposed. All right, because there's just no reason to. You can— if they can generate similar returns in uptimes, then how could you not?
Erik Townsend: And I guess that's the position I come Well, is it really similar returns in uptimes or is it modest returns in uptimes? I thought that the premise here was you're only trying to take enough risk to pay for those long vol exposures. So, as I understand it, if you're producing a positive carry, it's not like you're making 40% returns on your long vol strategy, right?
Wayne Himelsein: Perhaps during the meltdown of the S&P, but not the rest of the time. We're talking about the rest of the time. Right. We're talking about the rest of the time.
Erik Townsend: So, if you have a large— if you overweight that long vol component, you're giving up performance that you could have made by involving that risk capital in some other opportunity.
Wayne Himelsein: So, in one sense, you're giving up. So, yes, you're absolutely right. Long vol books are not likely going to make 40% during, quote, the rest of the time. Like, that's because what they're doing isn't really fit for that. That's not what they're trying to do. Other things can do that, right? They have the ability to. The The big difference I'll say, not necessarily disagreeing with what you're saying, but saying it from a different angle, is that that doesn't necessarily make you more over time because the long-term accumulation of wealth, of money, is all about geometric compounding.
It's all about don't lose a lot. So yeah, let's say there's 3 great years in the S&P and up 40, up 40, up 40 and whatever. Let's just say you're holding the S&P index, right? And there has been several years where it's been around 30% year And these strategies, to your point, are not going to make 30% in years like that. Let's say they make around 10%, just for an easy number, right? It's a modest return, which is the word you used, and I'll agree with that. So, you're off where you have this difference of 20% for 3 years in a row, 20, 20, 20, because instead of making 30%, you only made 10%.
And let's say there's some ratio of S&P to that long vol book. Let's say it's 50/50. So, you've diluted quite a bit of your return. But now you come along to the '08 or the COVID event, event, that one event where that S&P book draws down 30% off of your compounded number, where the other book is up 40% or 50% or whatever it may. So now suddenly you've captured 80% or that difference of spread back.
So over the course of those 8 years that you've compounded, the returns actually might even be similar. If not, the one with a long vol book is better because you cushion the return and it's smoother. And to boot,
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Wayne Himelsein: And to boot, it's nicer to sleep at night because you don't have the exposure that's going to ever wipe you out, right? So these are the differences. I'm a strong, big, huge advocate of if we look at the long-term compounding of returns with cushioned downside, with i.e., adding long vol in it, in one's book, the long-term returns end up being quite similar.
You don't get to feel the up 30% year because you feel like you're missing out that But it all comes back because the market keeps on redistributing itself. There keeps on being events that correct it and the long-term averages play out. That's how I've seen it over at least the last 25 years.
Erik Townsend: Well, Wayne, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, please tell us a little bit more about how people can contact Logica Funds and learn more about what you do there.
Wayne Himelsein: Sure. I mean, we're— so the easiest way is our website, logicafunds.com. Which answers both your questions. You can read a little bit more about what we do on our website. And of course, there's a contact page or a contact link, whatever it might be. So click there and say hello, and we'll be happy to talk. We love talking about what we do and the philosophy. And we wrote a great white paper. I'll say great 'cause we wrote it. Of course, we're biased, but it's called The Illusion of Skill, which I love people to read.
It's so solid. It's really looking at the Sharpe ratio and how it misses the short vol exposure in so many different hedge fund strategies. If you if you you could think of it as a negative skew adjusted Sharpe ratio, right? If you adjusted Sharpe for the inherent negative skew, you look at a strategy for three or four years, and it's got a Sharpe ratio of 1.3. It hasn't yet had its negative skew event. As soon as the event happens, now the Sharpe is only one, right? And so, if you had assumed that negative skew along the way, you wouldn't have thought it had a 1.3 Sharpe. You would have known it's 1.3 minus the embedded. Embedded event that's about to happen or will unrealized event that's going to happen. And therefore you have to adjust Sharpe with that in mind based on what the strategy, how it behaves. So that we call the skill metric, which is really the pure return outside of adjusting for this short vol exposure that's really so widely embedded in everything.
And so we're back to the website, would love people to download and read that. It's informative and it really gives you a new way to think about strategies and what you're exposed to.
Erik Townsend: And again, that white paper, The Illusion of Skill, is available for free at logicafunds.com Wayne, thanks so much. We look forward to getting you back on the program for an update in a few months.
Erik Townsend: Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor.
escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. Escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars. dollars, euros, and British pounds.
Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. Escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now, back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Wayne on the show. You know, I absolutely love talking about options and long volatility strategies, and he really got my hamster wheel turning. And I'm looking forward to kind of taking a deeper dive into some of these long vol strategies out there in a second.
Erik Townsend: What did you take away from You know, I thought the really important point was I have been kind of musing on this question ever since we interviewed Chris Cole a few years ago. What's up with these guys that are running these long vol funds where the premise is that you can get the insurance benefit of hedging, of protection against downside, but you don't have to pay for it?
You know, wait a minute, that doesn't seem like it's really straight. Well, what's really going on with these funds that claim to do this, at least what I feel was revealed in today's interview, is it really is an insurance product.
It costs money to put that protection on. It always has a negative carry when you're buying protection. What they're doing is they're also trading in these funds in order to make enough alpha to pay for that protection. So, it's not really a hedge that pays for itself. It's a hedge that costs money, plus some other kind of strategy which allows you to get that hedge effectively for free, but you're still taking the risk of whatever that other strategy is blowing up somehow and losing money. So, it clarified this whole situation for me. I want to get into your chart deck though, because we're going to talk about some specific trades that actually implement these concepts.
Erik Townsend: So, let's move on to the chart deck. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email in your inbox, that means you're not yet registered MacroVoices.com. So just go to the homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads.
Patrick, page 2 in the chart deck is the S&P 500 continuous futures chart. What's going on here other than up, up, up?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, that's exactly it, right? I just wanted to give our listeners a quick update on what's going on in the markets. I had some upper targets measuring out to about this 4,550 to 4,600. So we're slowly approaching what I would call the upper boundary of the short-term targets. That doesn't in itself guarantee that there's some sort of big scary correction. Every time we seem to have these corrections, they last about 2, 3 days, pull back, you know, a couple percent, find support on some moving averages, and they just become buy-on-dip opportunities. And I don't know if there's any immediate catalyst other than more volume coming back back into the markets. One way or another, it'll be a really interesting tell what will happen come post-Labor Day because that's really, again, when the volume comes back in and it'll be interesting to see how traders commit to new trends and whether that will be a transition
Patrick Ceresna: point for that.
Nonetheless, on page 3 though, I have the crude oil chart and I really wanted to kind of highlight that real breakout we got today and also get your take on this as well. Like, one of the things that we were talking about back in August was I just thought there was room for a very robust rally that happened from November to July to have a correction. And that's exactly what we got. We got that, you know, pullback from $75 to down towards $60 to where there was substantial support through March and May. But what was really surprising to me is just the magnitude of the snapback rally after that correction. It just started with huge velocity and it seems to continue. And it really does feel like the bulls are going to give this a shot to the upside. What I think really I'm using as a pivot is whether or not the bulls can hold $70.
I mean, really below $70, we'd have to always still entertain the idea that there could be another squiggle to retest that August low, but the 70 breakout might set things in motion. What are you watching on this chart?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think we're at a critical resistance level right now. As you can see, there's kind of a channel that was forming, a downsloping channel, and we're right at the top of the channel, right on the line, about to break out of it. It's not on this chart, but the continuation 55-day moving average as well as the 200-month moving average are also right there Where that— where the market is right now, around $70.50. And just above it, at $70.88, we've got the 13-week moving average. If we can get past that, that's kind of the last of the resistance that I see. And I think it's clear sailing from there back up to the previous high, and then from there up into the 80s.
It could be that we're about to see a reversal to the downside here.
We are right at the critical resistance, just like I said on gold. But I've got a feeling that this has already shaken itself out. There's really no fundamental driver for negative prices here other than August didn't go down the way everybody thought it was going to go down. The other side of it, which is the worsening COVID situation, yeah, that's true. But I think that we're going to run the economy through the worsening COVID situation. There's still going to be demand. So I think that we're probably seeing the beginning of the recovery. recovery. You're right, there could be one more, you know, wave down. We could get a test of 59 just to, you know, break through that round number support at 60 to see what happens. But I'll be surprised if we even get that. I think it's probably the worst is behind us.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, I wanted to jump on page 4 to actually one of the energy markets that is running pretty hot, and that's the natural gas market. And we really have seen a breakout, and it is very reminiscent of 2018 when there was the last little kind of mini melt-up in natural gas prices. Didn't sustain that much, but really seems to be accelerating to the upside. It feels almost a little bit like a lumber chart on there. I'm curious whether or not natural gas is going to be able to clear the $5 level on the upside, but clearly this is a hot market now, and it'll be really interesting to see whether or not bulls can follow through on this.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 5, Patrick, and take a look at uranium. What's happening here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's interesting because that Uranium Participation Fund, there was a lot of hype when it got converted into this Sprott Physical Uranium Trust. And what's interesting is that after all the hype, it spent a couple weeks backfilling and correcting downwards, stuck in a range. But uranium suddenly has woken up this past week and a pretty legitimate breakout attempt on the upside, breaking out of what was basically almost a 6-month sideways range. And so it'll be really interesting to see whether or not uranium's just started a brand new bull run on the upside.
I always say one day doesn't make a new trend, and I don't want to already be like touting that this is going to autopilot to $20. $20. But it is interesting that the range has broken out to the upside, and it'll be interesting to see whether or not the bulls dig in and really start to establish a sustaining trend on the upside and really set in motion a lot of those uranium stocks, which have corrected quite a bit over the last, uh, over the summer months.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, from what I'm reading, a lot of this demand is because of the Sprott Uranium Trust. Sprott's marketing is, is bringing a lot of interest, uh, into Let's move on though to the main subject of today's postgame segment, which is long volatility options strategies. You heard Wayne in the feature interview allude to a lot of these concepts. Let's get into the nitty-gritty of how this works.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. You know, I kind of, I found it really interesting the way he kind of tried to differentiate himself from not only other long vol funds, but other strategies in general. And just like how he manages his long volatility fund. But you know, to me, one has to put into context though that when you're you start a fund to be long volatility or short volatility through an income writing or something like that, you basically have a mandate to to invest that way. And you're always looking for ways to be in the case of Wayne's situation long tail risk and long volatility and. Profit from that.
My philosophy is slightly more dynamic because we're not a fund. You don't always have to be long volatility or short volatility. There's strategic and tactical times to deploy the strategies. So I kind of step back and look at the markets through cycles and the idea that there's periods of stability and periods of instability. You know, on page 7, I have that chart of the weekly chart of the S&P 500, and you kind of keep talking about this Austrian melt-up boom, but when I see this chart, I think we've been in the midst of it for quite a while. It really looks like we've started to run quite parabolic on this market. And the way I kind of look at the market where we are today is to use— and to kind of describe that period of stability versus instability, I like to use the analogy to visualize like a Jenga tower, like that game. And the game starts from a stable structure, and as the game progresses, the tower gets taller, but the base becomes more unstable, and inevitably the tower falls.
And so when applied to the markets, you go through this period of stability where the market is either consolidating for long periods of time or has just ended a market correction, and then it proceeds to rise run into a bull market phase, and as it's rising higher and higher, becomes more and more unstable inevitably until a market correction resets the market back to a stable state. And so I, I kind of look at this today where we're at, and we are now exactly one year. It was September 2nd, 2020, a year ago to the day that we had our last 10% market correction, and we are 530 days in a rally off the COVID lows back in March 2020, where the market is up over 100% off of the lows from that time period.
And inevitably, the market rally is going to be checked. And this is not about calling for a new bear market or some devastating market crash, but markets work in cycles, and inevitably, this leg of the rally is getting long in the tooth. As an example, Erik, if you go back to using like a 2009 period at the end of the financial crisis, there were 2 20% market corrections that followed in the year 2010 and 2011, even though we were in the midst of a new bull market. And so I think that at some stage here, we're going to end up seeing some sort of a market correction that is going to check this rally. And so it makes it really interesting to use one of these long volatility strategies to kind of reduce the overall volatility in your portfolio. But the, the interesting part about Wayne's interview is when you're long volatility and you're buying, let's say, strategies that are going to give you huge payoffs on the tail, one of the interesting elements is, is that, well, what if this is just a 20% correction, but not a devastating market crash?
What if it's like when you're building a strategy such as a backspread, let's say a put backspread, your real payoff is on that, you know, 2 to 4 standard deviation move to the downside where the market is really blowing out almost like the crash during the COVID that really those, that kind of a strategy it pays off.
But like Wayne was suggesting, there are situations with strategies like that where, you know, if the stock market only ends up being down 10%, you might actually be not only down on the market on your positions, but you might actually even be down on your long vol strategy, and it didn't actually provide a hedge because it wasn't deep enough of a market drop. So I wanted to kind of put some context into the different ways of being long volatility and what investors or listeners can consider when kind of trying to hedge out some of these different risks.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, you mentioned the backspread strategy. Let's take a look on page 8 at how that works.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so put backspread is a typical strategy utilized by the selling. So if you recall when Wayne was saying Meaning that you— infuses a short vol in order to pay for buying all of the long vol. And sometimes that can be calendared, that can be done at different strikes. But in its simplest form, you are selling, let's say, one at-the-money put for a very large and juicy put premium, and then using the proceeds to buy many more puts that are farther out of the money. Right. Money with the proceeds and the idea that you're buying all this long gamma below the lower strike. And so if you notice here on this chart, let's say we were looking at that put spread there on the left there, Erik. What you can see is that your point of actual loss— so let's say the starting point is $50 there— your actual point of greatest loss at expiry is actually at the $45 mark, or roughly 10% lower than the market where it is.
So in other words, you would need almost over a 20% market correction in this example that's illustrated here for that left-tail payoff of the long volatility strategy to really start to kick in and make big money. And that's perfectly fine, but usually if you're deploying one of these very low-cost carry backspreads, one has to recognize that you're really looking for a big outlier move, and it's going to do a very good job hedging a really big crash if that was what's happening.
But if, let's say, you're, you're right now listening to this and you're worried about a 10 to 20% market correction, odds are that the backspread will disappoint you in terms of your payoff. What makes it even worse is the fact that the S&P 500, or many beta-1 kind of securities, have left tail skew in the the vol premiums, and therefore, as you're going farther out of the money, those out of the money puts are being priced at higher and higher implieds, making you have to widen the spread even farther in order to make even let's say a two to one ratio on the back spread. And so the only thing I wanted to highlight here: there's nothing wrong with this strategy, but it's it may not be the right fit if you're just You're just simply trying to hedge out that kind of 10% to 20% market drop.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So, the backspread, which some people call a ratio spread, really the lesson to pay attention to here is it only really works if you have conviction about a really big event happening, a really big outlier event happening. What if we don't have that expectation of the big outlier? What strategies can we look at that maybe have better characteristics?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is where one, we can highlight the long straddle and long strangle strategies that Wayne talked about. Now, what was really interesting about Wayne's approach is that through the fact that they are active traders and they're very good at what they do and they're sitting at the machine and have some sort of a process from which they are kind of adding and taking away positions to dynamically try to create Alpha to pay for the fact that they're long a straddle, and that's that's a great way to approach it.
But it's not an easy way for an average investor to to approach it. Ultimately, when you're long a straddle, you're long obviously Vega or long volatility on both ends. But you're starting pretty much at a very neutral stage, and you also need a relatively larger move for these things to start legit. Legitimately paying off. But like we've talked about on many past MacroVoices sessions, this comes at the cost of quite a heavy carry. I mean, you're theta burning on both a call and a put, and you have to find some way of actually getting a reasonable payoff in order to justify having carried that. And this is where, you know, we're using all sorts of different ideas and strategies for how to deploy this. One of my favorite is, is an actively managed spread, which is something that we have currently going on in our portfolio. And I think it's a more tactical way to hedge out the most immediate downside risk of, of a market correction and able to still mitigate some of the carry costs associated with it.
And so there are all sorts of really neat And, uh, and I'm looking forward to actually taking our listeners through some of them in a live webinar.
Erik Townsend: And listeners, you can get Patrick's chart decks and webinars every single day with a free trial of Big Picture Trading, which you can find information on at page 10. But Patrick, you mentioned you're doing a specific webinar about these volatility strategies. When is that happening? What do your members have to do in order to get signed up for it? And for people who are not members, will they be able to watch that one with the free trial membership that's available for free at bigpicturetrading.com?
Patrick Ceresna: No, you said exactly right, Erik, which is all of my existing members as well as anyone who signs up for the free trial can get access to this webinar for free. We're going to be hosting it on Thursday, September the 16th at 4:00 PM Eastern time. But those that can't attend it live, the recording will be made available immediately afterwards and sent to everyone's inboxes. So anyone who wants to see us review the pros and cons of each of these long vol strategies with real simulators and looking at the live markets as to what they are and how I think one can approach adding hedges into their portfolio, then come join us for a trial and, and see what it's all about.
Erik Townsend: And that's on September 16th at 4 PM Eastern time. We're going to leave it there for this week's Before we get to the show, this episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better serve the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow.
Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the slide deck provided by Wayne and the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a Variant Perception article on the crude oil recovery and a great interview by Moore Sachs interviewing Kevin Muir. So, you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So, that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend.
That's Erik spelled with a K. And myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship From Big Picture Trading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information.
Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer Research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.
Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information. Or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Clint Cox — Dr. Pippa Malmgren and Clint Cox, returning from part 1 (no affiliation read in this episode's intro); later self-described as partner of the Monaco Foundry (Malmgren) and co-chief investment officer of Crypto Futura Fund (Cox) (as introduced on the show)
Pippa Malmgren — Dr. Pippa Malmgren and Clint Cox, returning from part 1 (no affiliation read in this episode's intro); later self-described as partner of the Monaco Foundry (Malmgren) and co-chief investment officer of Crypto Futura Fund (Cox) (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here's your host, Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 286 was prerecorded back in early August 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
There will be no market wrap or postgame segment this week, but we'll be back to our normal format starting next week. Welcome to part 2 of our 2-part summer series on the decentralized finance revolution. We kicked off this series last week with Dr. Pippa Malmgren and Clint Cox, when we talked through digital currency systems, including cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, central bank digital currencies, and now this week we're going to kick it into high gear, starting with a discussion of Silicon Valley digital currencies. And then we'll broaden the discussion to the decentralized finance revolution more generally, where it's headed and what it means for investors.
Erik Townsend: Let's pick up right where we left off at the end of part 1. Let's move on then and include Silicon Valley digital currencies, or SVDCs. Now, Facebook's Libra project was the most visible example to date, but I'm convinced that more projects like that with similar aspirations are already under development behind closed doors.
And to be sure, this is where I think most of the conflict of interest exists, because Big tech is clearly best equipped to design a global-scale digital currency system, but frankly, it's also strongly incentivized to design it for their own benefit rather than for the maximum benefit of society.
So, the way I see this, going back to Pippa's comments, I think you're exactly right that the central bankers are not going to wake up and smell the coffee, but I think Silicon Valley will, and I predict that Silicon Valley will design a digital currency system that's Yeah. Purpose, that's design center, is to appeal to central bankers so they can go all around the world, probably not starting with the Federal Reserve, but saying, look guys, we've designed something better with built-in digital monetary policy tools that are just so much better than anything you have with conventional monetary policy that you need to do this. And I think that what they will try to do is hijack the US government's monopoly over the global financial system and its in its issuance of the global reserve currency by coming up with something better that becomes so big that it's too big to fail and it can't be stopped, kind of like Facebook in the social media space.
Pippa, with that perspective, what do you think of the possibility of Silicon Valley designing something which maybe gives central bankers tools that we'd prefer they not have?
Pippa Malmgren: Well, let's talk about 2 interesting phenomena. One is GPT-3, and the other is something that actually Clint and I were talking about yesterday in preparation for this podcast, which is Rally. So GPT-3 is, put in really simple terms, it's the ability to code in plain English. So more and more, like, you know, when you make a website on Wix and it's really easy because it's in plain English, you don't have to be a coder to build that website anymore. Wix lets you do it in English.
Well, this is happening across the board, and there's a wave that is coming, and it's effectively a democratization of the access to the capacity to code anything, including money itself. So I think we're going to see a wave of competitors to Silicon Valley.
Your largeness alone won't guarantee that you maintain a monopoly position. Although it's going to be a super interesting fight between the little startups and the big players, the David and Goliath scenario. And we'll see, again, as Clint said earlier, whether people prefer to be in the Amazon tribe where they buy and transact everything on Amazon, or whether they want to be part of something that's even more decentralized, because that's obviously a very centralized world to live in.
And that's where Rally comes in. And again, I'm going to defer to Clint because he knows so much more about this. But I think Rally is very interesting in that it's permitting regular people, not just famous people, to create their own coin and to get to interact with their followers, not having to be, you know, Jennifer Lopez to do it. You know, that anybody can begin to create a community using plain English to create your own coin. Maybe, Clint, can I defer to you on this to tell us a bit more about that piece of it?
Clint Cox: Yeah, I mean, I, I think it's important to understand, like, when you're looking at these different platforms where these influencers participate, you know, Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, you know, they're kind of at the whim of whatever those new rules are, however they wish to, you know, or they can be, you know, shut off, whatever. There's a lot of different ways that they can make money off of that with advertising and stuff like that. But there's a lot of other things that they leave on the table because these influencers have influence over huge numbers of people, millions of people. And so what if you could take that and with the decentralized monetization system enable you a sustainable form of revenue just because you have a community, not because they're on YouTube or Twitter or anything else, but because they follow you?
And so what Rally allows these creators to do is actually have their own coin. That's part of this ecosystem. And the bigger the ecosystem is, the more successful Rally is. Now, you know, I, I think that's one of those things where, as you're looking at this, I think it becomes really, really interesting to say that this is the kind of innovation where people are gonna start creating their own groups and saying, what if we do this?
And everyone in the group benefits. That's what's gonna become fascinating is those are the type— types of things that can grow up from not much to become really big.
Erik Townsend: So far, we've been talking about digital currency systems. We'll broaden the discussion to decentralized finance right after this message from our sponsor. This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Abaxx, a FinTech company traded under ticker symbol ABXXF on the OTCQX in the United States and ABXX on the Aequitas NEO in Canada. Abaxx was founded on the principle of creating market-based solutions to solve the world's most challenging problems. 2 of these issues in particular, the energy transition and climate change, are creating once-in-a-generation opportunities for investors.
Abaxx is leveraging proprietary Web 3.0 technologies to digitize and accelerate the velocity and security of commodity trading markets. beginning with liquefied natural gas and carbon. Investors seeking exposure to the fintech applications powering this new era of the ESG economy can visit www.abaxx.tech or www.abaxx.exchange, or check out ABXX on the Aequitas NEO or ABXXF on the OTCQX exchanges.
So far we've been talking about the currency system, so let's move on now to the broader trend which has become known as decentralized finance, or DeFi for short.
Erik Townsend: We're talking here about using the same basic invention of secure digital bearer instruments, but this time the instrument is not a unit of currency, but rather it could be a share of stock, a bond, any other conventional financial asset, or for that matter, any other kind of asset, including some that we haven't even invented yet. So let's start with the big picture, high-level overview. overview of this new trend. How advanced is DeFi at this point? I'm not sure we even have everybody agreeing on what it means. How big of a deal is it going to be and why is it so important? Clint, why don't we start with you for this one?
Clint Cox: So yeah, I mean, I think DeFi— and let's just talk about the size of the growth, right? So DeFi as a sector was back in February of 2020 was about $1 billion. By September 2020, it was $10 billion. And it's currently about $75 billion. So, you can see that is crazy fast growth. That's really amazing. And I think, as you just insinuated, there's all kinds of definitions for DeFi, right? So, I think there's part of it which is taking the old and translating it into the new, such as tokenized stocks.
And part of the advantage here is going from this T+3 to T+0. So, you trade it and it's done now, and you can trade it 24/7, 365. There's groups like Bittrex, which does have a large number of tokenized stocks. These are common stocks like Apple, Microsoft, Tesla, that kind of stuff. But that's still centralized.
You cannot take or transfer your stocks off of Bittrex or the value of those stocks off of Bittrex. And then on Binance, they just announced that they're taking stock tokens off forever. By October, they're done with all of this tokenized stock idea.
But there is a much, much bigger idea here, and that is replicating the entire financial system in a decentralized way. And I think that that's what, you know, inside the crypto world, that's what we're really talking about, is how do we replicate what's out there. So this means, you know, lending, trading, investments, insurance, you know, all kinds of payment systems, settlement layers, all of that in a decentralized way. So, I think that that's really where we're headed, and that's what's created this huge growth.
And part of that is because of what's called proof of stake. And proof of stake is instead of proof of work, where you have Bitcoin miners and other miners out there with these GPUs and all these computers trying to compete to basically use energy to show that this is the legitimacy of that block. So instead of doing that, it's proof of stake. How much are you willing to purchase of these cryptos and then basically lock it up and say, I'm going to stake it right here. I'm not going to move it. I'm not going to use it. And I'm staking it and I get to have some kind of decision-making power over what happens. And so if you stake tokens, you have this idea of, oh, well, maybe I'll get some return. And you do. It's programmed. So, you know, the yield that you can get from staking tokens can be anywhere from, you know, on the low side, a few percent, up to 30%, 40% in some cases. You know, I would
say the average is a little below 10%, but with the 10-year Treasury yielding 1% to 1.25%, you know, 5%, 10%, that starts looking pretty good. Well, if you start lending with that and trading with that, and doing investments with that and getting insurance on that, you're creating this entirely different system. So, there are a bunch of different categories when you look at DeFi.
Right now, you've got exchanges, decentralized exchanges, which are called DEX. You've got lending, derivatives, insurance, asset management, wallets, oracles, which actually go out there and retrieve the data that actually triggers smart contracts, scaling, analytics, stablecoins. These are all things that basically are part of that system and have different cryptos involved with, you know, there's multiple cryptos involved with each of those categories I just described.
Um, so it's pretty amazing. They're taking the intermediaries out. And, you know, here's the thing, you control it. You control it, right? So I think there is an upside here and a downside here. You know, the upside is You know, you get all these new services, anyone can participate, it's completely transparent. You get, you know, right now at least, you get better returns.
But, you know, they got the downside too. There's a lot of risk, lack of regulatory, you know, oversight, and the SEC is coming. And you got really high leverage that could turn into, you know, something ugly if it's not controlled.
So a lot of upside, a lot of downside. But in the end, this is an entirely different world that is growing. And, you know, once again, $1 billion a year ago, $75 billion today. That's amazing growth.
Erik Townsend: Pippa, how big of a deal is DeFi to society at large and how much does it change society's interaction with government?
Pippa Malmgren: So I'm putting a whole chapter in my new book on this. It's so enormous. It's back to what we opened with. We're talking about profound changes in society. That you won't work for a single employer, you'll work for multiple employers at the same time. To be honest, once you are making finance fractional in this way and so easily accessible, I do suspect that it'll spill over into culture and you'll be also able to have— I know it sounds kind of crazy, but let's multiple families at the same time.
It's a kind of natural progression. If you have the power to sustain different households and fractional finance permits this, I don't know, I could see that we go in that direction too. I mean, it literally will challenge the morals and the mores of modern society. And make us rethink all of these very fundamental ideas about relationships between people, between institutions, between types of organizations and others. So I know it sounds sort of both shocking and vague what I'm saying, but I think this is why I keep saying it's like the Wild West of our time. It is so unclear. how DeFi as a broad category doesn't just disintermediate the banks, it's going to disintermediate culture itself.
It's going to create a whole new set of assumptions and relationships.
Again, as Clint said earlier, you don't need legal contracts anymore in this environment.
Well, if that's the case, then what happens to the whole court system, legal and justice enforcement? Maybe it takes place through money itself. And as you said, Clint, it happens immediately. If you get into a dispute with somebody, it becomes public immediately. And you don't dare get into disputes with people because its impact on your life is so severe. Like there's there's just an unlimited possibility here, and that's the important thing for people to think about. This is not going to be the old culture taken into this new financial system.
The financial system itself will change culture. It will change how we conduct war and conflict. I mean, again, to go back in history, you know Genghis Khan had two inventions that led to the creation of the largest. area of control, of power, territorial power known in history. One was the invention of the stirrup.
It sounds so small, but it's only with the stirrup that you're able to wear armor. So suddenly you had armored humans on horseback, which was a massive strategic advantage over humans that were not armored.
But the other invention that he brought was Paper money. And paper money contributed enormously to the creation of that empire. And so do we really think we can create digital fractional money and not have it radically change the culture, just as Genghis Khan's empire radically changed the culture of the eastern part of Europe, of what we used to call Persia? And India. I mean, it totally radically changed their culture. This is going to change ours as well. And you can say, well, I'm scared by that. Well, culture is always changing. It's just the speed at which this is happening is so quick and the direction is so unknown.
But cultural change is a permanent feature of the landscape. But our ability to process it, that is not very high. So I am anticipating enormous cultural change as a result of these new technologies.
Erik Townsend: Pippa, you're saying that this is a complete unknown. It's going to be profound cultural change, and we don't even know where it's headed. Yet already we're seeing DeFi funds and ETFs being launched. And quite frankly, based on what I saw of Wall Street almost taking a decade to figure out what Bitcoin is, I'm not so sure about my confidence in all of the fund managers to pick the best horses to bet in, in this race. So is this just a shotgun type of investment strategy where you can't tell where the winners are going to be and you invest in everything? Or is it possible— I want to ask Clint Cox particularly because you actually do this for a living— to take that rifle investment strategy where you really try to pick the winners in a game which really is very, very early? in a long-term evolution, which we don't know where it's headed yet.
Clint Cox: So, you know, I think you, you know, put your finger on it, is how do you approach this, you know? And because this is a new sector, new industry, you know, we only have a decade's worth of data to even look at, and that's just for Bitcoin, right? I mean, a lot of this stuff hasn't even been around for a decade. So, you know, when we first started this, we spent months looking at actually the FAANG stocks, some of the stuff that you mentioned. You know, we looked at Facebook, Amazon, Google, Netflix, Apple.
We looked at these companies and we said, okay, what are the technologies? What are the factors that made these companies successful? And which of these factors might apply to crypto? What are the things that we need to be thinking about? Then we sat down, we worked with data engineers to figure out what are the best metrics to measure the factors that we think are important.
And that's how we basically, you know, we started looking at the DeFi market. Is how do we approach, you know, what we think will be successful long term? How do we approach the market, get the data we need to make the decisions that we need to make? So if I'm talking about, you know, to other investors and to folks looking at this, you know, first thing is you got to do your research. You got to understand these markets. It's really difficult. It's really difficult for beginners to basically get into this and really understand it, but incredibly rewarding. I mean, one of the things that we like to do, you know, you ask about shotgun or rifle.
We look at different DeFi categories, some of the stuff that we talked about earlier, you know, exchanges, you know, decentralized exchanges, lending, derivatives, insurance, oracles, all that stuff. We look at each of those and then we pick what we think are the best players from each of those categories. Like, you know, this might be the best here, this might be the best here, or we might choose 2 or 3 which we think are leaders. And there's a lot of different factors that go into choosing. But I think it's when we look at all of those different categories, I don't think every crypto within each category is going to be successful. It just doesn't work like that. So yeah, you have to be pretty precise, but I think you also have to cover a variety of different areas because I think it's very difficult to say one company's going to win. I mean, look at the winners from the internet cycle. It's been really difficult to pick the winners, you know, especially if you were doing this back in the mid-'90s.
But when you get into today, you see who the winners are. That's very difficult.
But the other adage is the rising tide lifts all boats. Maybe in some ways that's true. If DeFi continues to grow, I mean, there's going to be a lot of winners. But the internet is that cautionary tale. There's bound to be a lot of complete losers too.
Erik Townsend: Pippa, how do we navigate this new landscape with DeFi funds, ETFs? Are these things smart to invest in or are they just guesses at this point?
Pippa Malmgren: I think that if you want to understand the future, you've got to get involved. I think as an economist, I made a decision in my career to get involved in the building of the real economy and trying to understand these instruments. So there's a learning curve. And so I think you can't be an armchair investor. You can't sit back and say, well, I'll just observe.
I think somebody needs to get involved in order to learn.
Having said that, I don't know if you guys remember some years ago there was a company called Thinkorswim and it ended up being sold to GE 3 times. They bought a piece, then they bought another piece, then they bought the whole thing outright. And the thing about Thinkorswim was that it was such a simple idea. It was designed to teach investors about derivatives. And it's not that long ago that investors had no idea what a derivative was. Like, that's literally only, you know, 30 years ago that people were like, what's a derivative? You know, how do you play with that? It was the same level as your question now, should we get involved? And so, Thinkorswim was created by a former colleague of mine, and it was designed to teach, just teach people about derivatives, give them a trading platform where they can play around with it without actually having to put real money at stake. but give them the experience so they can see.
They thought they made a good trade and they got killed.
And people were incredibly loyal to that platform. They loved it. And then GE bought it. And what was interesting was GE thought what they were buying was a customer base. And so they didn't want to invest anything in teaching because that was like an unnecessary overhead. And actually, the whole community disbanded because what they really paid for and wanted was the learning.
And so, I predict someone is going to create the Thinkorswim of this crypto DeFi movement and teach people all the stuff that Clint knows so much about. I don't know who that is, but I'm just predicting if someone does that, Then that's going to make a fortune because there's no way you can really do this by yourself.
It's already a decade too late. You're so far behind. So my answer is yes, you got to get involved, but boy, the market definitely needs somebody who's going to provide some teaching as well.
Erik Townsend: Now I'd like to run a couple of ideas past both of you, which I proposed in my book 3 years ago, but frankly, which I haven't heard many other people talking about. The first is that I think we have the opportunity to completely re-engineer the 500-year-old fractional banking system, not just the currency system, but the entire fractional reserve system. And specifically, what I'm talking about today is that almost all money, what we call the M1 money supply, is loaned into existence by commercial banks. So, implicitly, the commercial banking system kind of has a monopoly on loaning money into existence.
And I would propose that there are better ways to extend credit that does not require fractionalization of the money system the way it has existed for hundreds of years. I think there's a better way to do this, which involves a digital currency system that includes features to extend credit in ways other than fractionalizing the banking system. Now, of course, it's entirely possible to fractionize Bitcoin or any other digital currency system, and that's already been done. But I'm really thinking that, frankly, feels to me like you're trying to point searchlights at solar panels in order to create electricity. It's not a sensible way of doing things. I think we need to look at the entire fractional reserve banking system and re-engineer it from the ground up. To my surprise, I'm not aware of anybody who's really looking at that problem and trying to think about it as a technologist in terms of how to do it.
Am I onto something here? Does this make sense? And, uh, Clint, in particular, I'm curious if you've heard anything I haven't around someone actually starting to work on this problem.
Clint Cox: Yeah, I would say, you know, as far as that specifically and taking a look at the fractional reserve banking system, you know, I'm sure there's been conversations around the water cooler, maybe at the Fed and Treasury and things like that. But, uh, you know, I, I think if nothing else, I think bankers know that the handwriting's on the wall. Like, there is change coming. And once again, even as we talked about earlier, I think you're going to see every bank have some level of embracing of blockchain and crypto. They, they have to. And for investment's sake, they have to. Uh, I think there's a lot of reasons. So I think they'll embrace digital assets. It makes for better, more efficient banks in the end. And I think they're realizing that As certain banks are embracing it, all the banks have to embrace it because they don't want to get left behind. So, you know, I still think we're going to have very strong, powerful banks. I don't think that's going away.
But when you start looking at what does this digital currency revolution look like, I don't think it displaces banks necessarily in the initial stages here. You know, it may take over some of the, the bit parts and things like that, but it's not gonna, you know, make their role obsolete. I think it'll create immense value elsewhere.
And I think as you start looking at that fractional reserve system, you look at like, what's the basis of that? Why would you do that? How do you do that? And I think you're really going to start looking at these ecosystems, you know, DeFi, NFTs, rewards programs, micropayments. I think, you know, and Pippa alluded to this earlier, you know, getting paid by the task instead of getting paid by the hour.
You know, we haven't even gotten into digital identity and AML and KYC. I mean, I think one of the things that bankers would love to do is digitize the AML KYC portion of their business because that's such a pain. You know, you have OFAC, you have all these other regulations around it, and that's a real issue. So I think, you know, part of it will be as they digitize that, how does that change the way the banking system works? And once you have digital identity, And you can use these zero-knowledge proofs and other things to make sure that, hey, I want to show somebody that I fit a criteria. I mean, the easy one to say is I would love for, you know, the bouncer to be able to see that I'm 21 and I can get into this club, but I don't want this bouncer to see where my address, you know, where I live. So it's like you can show the necessary information without showing all the information. I think there's a lot of things like that that will, you know, come into the market.
One of the other things with the digital currency revolution is supply chain management. And as you know, banks get involved in a very large way in supply chains, right? You've got all this foreign currency exchange, you've got a big business surrounding this. Well, a lot of that is because supply chains, right? How they work, how they go between countries. Well, I think there's going to be a lot of things that come from crypto, blockchain, things like that, that allow for You know, a real enlargement of the way banks operate in those realms. So micro bonuses based on ESG or location, speed of delivery, consistency. Like, I think there's a lot of things to, to do with instant payments, efficiencies in shipping, and how you're no longer going to have to use the local currencies. You're going to be able to use these larger corporate currencies.
So how does that fit back with the fractional reserve banking system. I think you're going to have multiple versions of that. And the question once again comes down to interoperability. How is all this stuff going to work together? How are you going to lend? Well, right now, DeFi, there's a lot of lending based on these staking mechanisms. And I think that there's going to be a lot more of that. And so will that transform the world as we know it? Yeah. You know, but what are some of the other bonuses from this? Reduce fraud. Free up, you know, all these foreign currency accounts, empowering people in struggling economies. You know, if you have a phone, if you have a, you know, a smartphone, you can actually participate in this economy. You know, instant digital microinsurance, credentialing. Do you have the skills? You know, then you should be credentialed that you have those skills. You know, so I think there's a lot of ways that this will influence that greater question of the fractional reserve system.
The question is whether corporations and these small innovators will innovate so fast that basically these fractional reserve banking systems will have to catch up. And I'm not sure what that looks like, but I think it's going to be really messy and really exciting over the next couple decades.
Erik Townsend: Pippa, I'm going to ask you to respond to a hypothetical scenario. Let's suppose that within the next year or 2, Google or one of the other tech behemoths comes out and introduces something that's, you know, 3 times bigger and grander than Libra was. They've really invented an electronic digital money system that is going to integrate with all of their other products, and it's going to be super easy to use, and it's going to be popular for people because it's so easy and it's integrated with your phone and everything else. And guess what? It actually offers a better way to structure lending, and everybody figures out, wait a minute, this really is better than the fractional reserve system. It would make sense for the entire economy to work on this, but that threatens the existence of the entire conventional banking system where there's a huge amount of political capital parked right now.
What happens? How does government deal with the advent of technology that potentially wrong-foots the most powerful actors and the most powerful influencers in terms of the people that pay the biggest campaign contributions, which frankly is Wall Street. What if suddenly big tech invented a better kind of money that replaces the banking system and does a better job?
Pippa Malmgren: Well, it wouldn't be the first time in history. We've seen over many generations a shift in who controls, who has power. I mean, we went from princes and royal families in Europe to one in which bankers actually had more power than those political leaders. That's what Machiavelli wrote about, was the transition from you as prince, you think you have all this power, but actually the bankers have it, and here's how to manage this situation. It was like a user manual for the shift in the power structure. And this will happen again.
And yeah, so then people wake up one morning and go, wow, I used to be fill in the blank, and now that doesn't even exist as a profession anymore. Bankers are just as susceptible to that as farmers in the last century.
So what I think is more interesting is, let me try this idea on you. I'm going to kind of shift the lens. We assume that money has to include several different features. It's got to be a store of value and a unit of account and a medium of exchange, but they don't have to all be embedded. That money could actually exist that is a unit of account, a medium of exchange, but it doesn't move around in the price. It's stable.
And so that unlocks a kind of barter element in the economy, which I think this digital money is going to do. And it's going to be like putting turbochargers on the world economy because suddenly you'll be able to unlock a huge amount of value through barter that previously you needed to have money in order to transact.
But I'll go even further than that.
What I find really interesting is what is the one thing Throughout all of human history that every religion says you shouldn't do when it comes to money. They all say you shouldn't charge interest, right? It's the one thing the Bible, you know, the Islamic community, everybody says usury is a very bad thing.
Well, actually, with the advent of digital money and the separation of store of value, unit of account, medium of exchange, We could introduce money that doesn't charge interest. And I don't think this is such a radical idea. We could see a world where the additional value or the cost of a transaction isn't based on an interest rate.
It might be based on a set of behaviors. And you get paid, as Clint just mentioned, If you're really good in ESG, suddenly you will get a benefit from that, but there's no interest rate, right? Because it's not about lending in the traditional sense.
I'll go even further and say most societies that humans have constructed have traditionally treated money and borrowing as a cyclical phenomenon rather than a linear one. So we currently treat this as linear. You're going to borrow the money now and you're going to have to pay it back by a deadline. And if you don't, then that's a default.
Most previous societies said all loans only last 7 years and doesn't matter what you do in 7 years, that whole loan is just going to disappear. It's just cyclical. It's circular in nature. The Babylonians and the Sumerians invented this approach. Well, in a digital currency world where everybody's almost using money as if it's a game, you know the rules of engagement are for 7 years you have to do something with the money. If you don't do something productive, A, you lose the opportunity, and B, you might not qualify to be in the game again. So you still have an incentive to perform, right? To not like take the money and run because then you can't— nobody will let you in the game again. But if you know That if there's a screw-up, if you don't get it right, that instead of being in hock for the rest of your life, like student loans where you can never escape from that burden, you know that in 7 years, if you fail, yes, there's a price to pay, but it's not a financial price.
It's an access to the system price. Think of how profoundly that would change human relationships in modern society. How profoundly would that change our willingness and capacity to take risk. So when you asked me this question, you know, could we shift to, you know, some corporate digital unit of money?
I'm like, yeah, but what's really interesting is it might not involve interest. It might not involve any fluctuation in the value of the currency, and it might not involve debt that would have to be that would be defaulted on, that would just automatically be built into the system, just like we used to do in the old days. So the disentangling of value and unit of account and exchange and the need for usury suddenly could all disappear and change our world radically. And that's where banks are no longer needed because all of those functions are just totally different than they were before.
Clint Cox: And a fascinating thing about that, Pippa, is that a lot of these cryptos, you know, especially the proof-of-stake cryptos, they already have yield built into them. So the need to actually gain interest could actually be transformed and shifted somewhere else. Instead of the banks thinking, hey, we need to make money off of, you know, all these people doing the things for us, it switches it to, hey, if we stake, you know, the most popular of these proof-of-stake Cryptos, we actually are going to make yield anyway. We don't have to worry about putting our thumb down on these folks or these folks.
Pippa Malmgren: Totally. It's like a bit of mind melting that we're talking about. You have to unlearn what you know about money and finance and rethink, is it true that you must charge interest with a loan? answer no, it's not true. It's just the way we've chosen to do it for the last few millennia, but that doesn't mean that it has to be done that way.
Clint Cox: And the other thing, when you get to interoperability, you know, once you have credentialing and you have all these other things where someone can bring value from other things, it might not be something that you would get paid in US dollars to pay the bank back with, but they may have some kind of credentialing, some kind of trust, something that they can trade In exchange for, and it, you know, basically translates and goes into that payment system to repay a loan. There's a lot of different ways to look at this.
Pippa Malmgren: And that's what I mean by barter. I, you could almost imagine, you know, if, uh, if a, you know, super famous, uh, rock star says, you know, in the end, I, I tried a venture, uh, it didn't work, so I'm not paying the money back because I can't. But I will provide the lender with something I do with them that brings them a fan base and a followership that they never would've had otherwise.
Actually, that trade may be more valuable than getting paid back interest on the thing. Like, you can now have a— you can turn your voice into currency, literally. A human can turn their network effect into a valuable currency. It doesn't have to be that you can only pay back with money and financial interest. Suddenly a whole lot of things become monetizable in this environment.
Erik Townsend: Next, I want to talk about my vision of a digital sovereign bond market. That's coming up right after this message from our sponsor.
Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com. And eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF.
and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN. Let's move on now to the second idea that I'd love both of your feedback on, which is my
Erik Townsend: contention that a digital sovereign bond market is an absolutely essential aspect of the DeFi revolution. To understand this, we have to take a big step back and consider the purpose for which central bank reserve assets exist in the first place. Why do they exist? And how do the problems that are solved today with the US dollar— could they be better solved? And I contend that DeFi enables an entirely new invention, a digital sovereign bond market that works completely differently than conventional sovereign debt, and which could be vastly superior to US Treasury bonds, Or any other conventional central bank reserve asset. Now, the reason that this is so important is that it implies that the advent of this digital sovereign bond market and the availability of these digital sovereign bonds that are a better central bank reserve asset than US Treasuries that I'm describing would essentially terminate the US dollar's hegemony over the global financial system, unless that new system was a digital dollar that the US government was in control of.
So central banks would presumably favor that superior asset. And I contend there's enough people that are annoyed with US foreign policy right now around the world that they would have already ditched the US dollar as the central bank reserve asset if there were a viable alternative. And there has been no viable alternative to the US dollar. I contend when somebody invents one, central bankers around the world will be quicker than the US government thinks to abandon the US dollar. And eventually, Robert Triffin's dilemma that was posited more than a half century ago will be resolved in favor of a digital currency system replacing the US dollar as the global reserve system. But it's not even just replacing the currency, it's replacing the reserve system with a smarter, better reserve system based on digital sovereign bonds. which could have features using smart contracts and so forth.
So, you know, if you've got an oil-producing nation, you could potentially tie the repayment of its sovereign debt to its oil income so that there are controls and abilities to prevent the next guy that takes office, if there's regime change, from defaulting on the last guy's debt.
What do each of you think of this notion that a new digital central bank reserve asset could be engineered for the purpose of displacing the US dollar as the global reserve currency by creating a superior reserve asset that Treasuries could never compete with. And for Pippa in particular, I'm really thinking about, boy, what are the geopolitical consequences if somebody invents something which is basically handing the other central banks around the world an easy way to move away from the US dollar? Not what the US government wants to hear. Pippa, why don't we start with that? And I know Clint's got a lot to say on the technology and what can make this work.
Pippa Malmgren: Well, I think that it's easy to imagine the creation of an instrument that investors would have more confidence in than sovereign debt because these days, frankly, what's the capacity to repay? You start looking at small African nations and realizing that actually they ought to have a higher credit rating than the US government or frankly many Western European governments. Our whole methodology for deciding who's got a high credit rating and who's got a low one is kind of crazy and doesn't really match reality. But so let's imagine for a moment you create something that's blockchain-based, that's dispersed, and therefore a high degree trustable that the market could have more confidence in that than any sovereign debt instrument. So I, that's not hard to imagine.
The second thing is that this has happened before. And here's an example I know that you and I have talked about before, Erik, which is when John F. Kennedy started to tax US bonds, US corporate bonds in 1962, because he thought he had a massive government deficit and he wanted to generate revenue to fix the deficit.
And some guys at Morgan Stanley in London basically said, hey, what if we sold these US corporate bonds out of London? Then it wouldn't attract the tax and everybody would want to buy from here. And that's literally what created the now trillion-dollar eurobond market.
So this is not a new idea. You can create new debt instruments. It's just we don't do it very often. And I think the biggest constraint is not the technical ability. The biggest constraint is imagination. And people in finance have been so heavily trained to be analytical and to think that their quantitative assessment skills are where the juice is, that they forget that every single innovation in finance is always fundamentally an act of imagination. You imagine new financial assets into being. And that's exactly what you do in government, right? When there's a crisis of some kind, you literally like, okay, let's make something up. And that was the origin of Brady bonds to deal with the Latin American financial crisis, right? You literally just make up a new category In order to attract capital. So this is completely doable. It will definitely happen.
The question is then what do governments do when it happens? And we're witnessing the early stages of that where government comes out and tries to shut down Binance, tries to shut down to a degree Bitcoin by saying you shouldn't be dealing in this and it's really a bad actor thing to do. But The thing is, the utility is so high, it survives anyway.
So we're seeing right now this lashing out at the technology, hoping it'll just go away. It isn't working. It isn't going to go away. And so will it culminate in something that causes the majority of humans on the planet to say, I'd rather hold this digital asset because I trust it more than I trust this sovereign entity?
Yeah, what are you going to do? Hold them at gunpoint and say, no, you have to buy my bonds? This is when the fundamental question arises, what gives a bond market value? Is it the military? And that's a really interesting question in history. Is your military strong enough to enforce the adherence?
Some people say, yeah, that's what it all comes down to. Others go, you know what? You can hold a gun to their face and they're still going to buy the thing that makes more financial sense. So it's a very interesting question of geopolitics.
Erik Townsend: Clint, what would it take to get this DeFi revolution to the point where we're actually looking at central bank reserve assets as the thing that's being replaced with digital assets?
Clint Cox: See, I think this is a great question. I think you're really, you know, you're touching on a subject that I think is going to change everything. Right. And that is when we start looking at sovereign bonds, when we start looking at the US dominance of this entire system and the US dollar and world reserve status, you know, I think it's important. We always refer to, you know, the dollar as the world reserve currency, and that's true, but it's not the only reserve currency, right? So when you look at the, you know, the IMF's SDR, you're looking at the US dollar, the euro, Japanese yen, Chinese RMB, and the UK pound, right? So this is not in a world by itself.
Um, and, and we also trade a lot of, you know, Australian dollars, Canadian dollars, Swiss francs. So, you know, it's, it's not just displacing the US dollar, it's, it's how do you become a player in that realm of those, say, 8 to 10 different global reserves. And I think that's going to be the first step, is breaking into that group.
And I honestly, I think Bitcoin is really fascinating because This is all about trust. And, you know, I think Pippa hinted at this, you know, when, when we're talking about trust, you know, part of it comes down to your military. You know, you can trust that the US is going to take you out if you do something stupid along the lines of trying to take out the US dollar. Maybe that's true. But if you look at the history of world reserve currencies, it's also dependent on the strength of your financial system, your laws, your trade dominance. You know, your resources.
So I think when we're looking at that, it's really important to understand that trust is really key. So is your economy. And that's where something like Bitcoin, you know, that's amazing because it is highly trustworthy. You know, this thing has never been hacked. So, you know, in a world where all of our banks, all of our government agencies are getting hacked on a regular basis, you've got something That hasn't been hacked. That's pretty amazing. That creates a lot of trust. So that's like the baseline.
But then you're talking about DeFi, right? How do we get to this next level? Well, you know, you could pool some of these bonds maybe in a particular, you know, fund. You could digitize, you know, the ownership of them, and then you could put those out there and start creating new instruments. I think Pippa's exactly right. You have to have creativity. And if nothing else, the US has been phenomenal at financial creativity and creating financial instruments. You know, I mean, that's— we've been great at that. Uh, so I think there's still a lot of hope that something could come out of this, that there will be some system that comes out of DeFi where we figure out, okay, we can leverage this into this, we can hold this as a core asset, leverage that into this.
It's going to be really interesting to see what happens. I mean, I guess the 2 things that have brought, you know, world reserve currencies to an end and that might challenge the most are, you know, in the past it's been war or collapsed global trade. And I think those 2 things, war and collapsed global trade, those have been the dictators of, you know, the collapse of a world reserve currency. Now, there's also been one example of, you know, and that's the Netherlands, which with the Dutch East India Company and the creation of the corporation, it can be something positive too.
So I think the real question here as we look at this is, can the US innovate and do something great that creates a new value in the US dollar, maybe a digital dollar, and can we avoid global war? You know, so I think those are kind of the questions that, you know, I think about in A lot of different ways.
Pippa Malmgren: By the way, can I just point out that SDRs were also made up out of thin air? That concept of creating special drawing rights in the world economy and the IMF, this was all in 1969 when we were having that Triffin overhang that you referred to before, Erik. Again, you have a practical problem and what you bring to it is creative imagination. And Clint, you're so right. What the US has excelled in for all of modern history is this creative, imaginative approach to finance. And I think this is absolutely going to persist. And this is why this podcast is actually, to me, really valuable to have the opportunity to talk at length about this and to help people understand this question about crypto. It's not technical. It's an act of imagination.
It requires an active imagination to understand it. This is not something where there are clear and simple rules of the game, and if you just analyze it correctly mathematically, you'll figure it out. No, this is about imaginative capacity.
Clint Cox: And Pippa, there's no reason why, when you look at the IMF and the special drawing rights, that is an amazing innovation, right? And that has changed the way we look at global finance. You know, the BIS, the IMF, all these groups are looking at crypto. They're looking at CBDCs. It is quite possible that out of one of those organizations comes something new, comes a new innovation where they say, okay, a number of the G7 has agreed to do this, or, you know, OECD has agreed to do this. There's a lot of different ways that this could play out, and there's a lot of meetings happening in back rooms to discuss this exact topic.
Erik Townsend: I want to activate both of your imaginations now, because the reason I brought up these 2 topics of re-engineering the fractional reserve banking system and a digital sovereign bond market is they're examples of things that I think will be incredibly important that almost nobody has even bothered to start thinking about yet. So now I want to ask both of you, Pippa, what are the consequences and implications of this digital finance and decentralization revolution that has already begun that nobody's thought of and that maybe people need to start thinking about?
Pippa Malmgren: Well, I go back to what I said earlier. I don't want to repeat, but I really do think that the consequences will be genuinely cultural and societal. We will no longer have careers that are sequential and linear. Will have a life of portfolio of activities working for many different kinds of organizations, solving many different kinds of problems.
The legal system will dramatically change because you won't need contracts to reinforce deals because money itself becomes so trustable that the money is the contract. I just think Culturally, the way we think about power relationships will change because we won't need to work for firms anymore.
The whole concept that has been around since the East India Company was introduced, that you need to work for an organization that provides a roof over your head, no, you don't. And people will fluidly come together More like in swarms or like a— they call it, I think it's called a murder of starlings. It's a very beautiful murmuration of starlings. When you see birds, they all flock together and create shapes in the sky.
This will be what business looks like, that beautiful structures created just because groups are moving. And in fact, data is already doing that by itself. So the humans are just going to follow the data into this highly fluid state. In fact, there's a really interesting writer, can't remember his name off the top of my head, but he writes about the liquid economy where he's talking about the speed, the pace of change is so great, it runs so hot and so fast. The economy isn't just fluid, it's actually liquid. And managing in the sea of that kind of liquid flux— is a whole different way of living than one in which you still have some— it's like going from being a sailor on an open ocean to being a scuba diver that's permanently in the water. It's just a different way of behaving.
So to me, that's what this whole digital currency phenomena is about, the broader societal changes that it necessarily will create. And whether we like it or not, we'll have to live with those consequences. And I think some of them will be really good. Some of them may not be so good. And what we have to do, this generation, everyone listening on this podcast needs to think about what part will I play in defining this new vast digital kind of holographic space that we are now all in, but there's kind of no established rules of the game yet.
And what part are we going to play in defining the rules of that game?
Erik Townsend: Clint, what are the most innovative ideas and projects that you've heard of in this DeFi revolution that's already begun? And what are the most innovative and disruptive ideas that you can think of for things that maybe haven't started yet but ought to?
Clint Cox: Boy, that's a, that's a mouthful there. Um, first of all, I am horrified, Erik, just thinking about us listening to this podcast 3 years from now. It's gonna be completely embarrassing, right? Because so many things are gonna happen between now and then, uh, that change, uh, all the things that we're talking about today. But, uh, it's definitely exciting to think along these lines. So, you know, there's a lot of projects, there's a lot of things that have happened that already exist in this market, you know, that allow for innovation and things that change everything. I mean, first of all, let's just talk about what does DeFi do? How does that change things? And I think looking at what, um, Pippa just talked about, you know, the new ways to think about work, the new ways to think about payments— we haven't even touched on the metaverse, and I certainly don't want us to go down that road, uh, too far.
But when we start thinking about You know, when I talk with my son about how he views— you know, we watched The Matrix, and, you know, I was like, hey, do you take the red pill or the blue pill?
And he's like, man, you stay inside the Matrix. You see how nasty it is outside of the Matrix? You know, it's like, wow. So for the younger generation, they're looking at the digital world as an entirely different place. Their digital identity is often as important as what we would call our analog or real identities in the world, right? Because they spend their time in these digital worlds.
So I think what DeFi is going to do is it's going to level the playing field. And I would say this, you know, in an emotional way for sure, because if you're somebody in whatever digital world you're in that provides the same amount of, you know, real uplift as maybe doing that in the real world, being in relationships in the real world, it's a different thing altogether. And of course, you know, I'm sure some therapist would say I need to stop talking at this point. But, you know, I think there's a lot to be said for how we now create relationships and how much of those social networks are involved in that and how much we need to consider those, you know, the way we're changing as people in our social relationships.
So how does that apply to DeFi? Well, you know, I think, uh, you know, Pippa brought up Rally. I think Rally is really interesting because it allows for people who are creative, who do have influence, to use that influence to allow for new ways to create ecosystems that actually bring some kind of independent economy, independent of what, you know, the world says you have to use. So I think those are coming. But when we think about, you know, the innovations as far as financial innovations, part of it is taking responsibility again. And I know this is somewhat esoteric, but we have basically given responsibility for managing our finances to banks and the Fed and the Treasury.
And I'll tell you what, you only have to lose, you know, $1,000 worth of Bitcoin once because you sent it to the wrong address to realize, I have to take responsibility for what I'm doing here. And I think that idea of taking responsibility again as individuals is a seismic shift. And I know that seems small, but I think it's really big. I think, you know, as we start looking at accountability and trust— like, I don't know about you, but you can go to Twitter and find 100 people that have 100 different ideas on any topic. You know, you, you go to crypto and you say, okay, I'm going to look up crypto on Twitter, you're going to find, you know, thousands and thousands of people that all have definitive ideas of what crypto is going to be or not be, or DeFi.
And as we do that, I would love to know, well, you know, how trustworthy is this person? And so I think accountability and trust are going to start to get built into these systems because you're going to see, okay, this person is credentialed this way, this person is credentialed that way.
This all comes back to DeFi because those financial systems are going to build more and more on these systems of trust, these decentralized autonomous organizations that have individuals that create more trust, that have influencers that create more trust in systems. And so I, I know that that's not exactly the financial side of it, but I think that's really important as far as organizationally and who we are as humanity, how we relate to each other. We're going to see a much more customized economy that's based on individual ideas and people that actually have followings, but also understand things and can speak the truth. Like, for instance, if someone says, this is what just happened, you know, in at this earthquake site here, and if that person has location data that shows that they're there, that gives them a little more wherewithal than the person who says, this is what's happening over there, and they're just spouting off rumors. There's a lot of ways to create trust, but all that's going to be brought into this DeFi system.
All of it. And I think that that's going to be monumental because I don't think our legacy systems, our legacy governments, our legacy financial systems are prepared to deal with the speed at which that is already happening.
Pippa Malmgren: You know, Clint, what you're saying so reminds me of that wonderful film, Frank Capra film, It's a Wonderful Life with Jimmy Stewart. And if you recall in that movie, which is— when was that made? Is in the I don't know, the '40s. And Jimmy Stewart plays kind of the bank manager, and money goes missing at the bank, and the whole community knows him, loves him, trusts him, that in the end, the whole community pitches in to replace the amount of money that's missing so that he doesn't go to jail.
And it's that kind of fundamental faith in who a person is as interpreted by the community they live in, that now this DeFi crypto system will allow the monetization of that kind of trust. So, you know, you go to apply for a mortgage and the fact that everyone in your community knows you, loves you, trusts you actually plays a part in whether you get the mortgage. And if you don't pay your bills on time, then actually your capacity to get a mortgage is affected. So again, it cuts both ways.
In China, what we see now is this social credit system means if you date the wrong people, if you don't pay your bills on time, if you express opinions that are contrary to the government, You basically get locked into a digital prison and you're not able to use your credit card outside of your neighborhood. You can't buy a plane ticket because the system won't sell you one.
And you can get locked into a place of only 4 square blocks because of your behaviors. But equally in contrast, if you are doing all the right things, you can benefit in immense ways. And Even internet dating sites in China are now driven by what is your social credit score. And so you want to hang out with or date people who are equally elite to you, then your behaviors are going to be good.
So this is where I start to get nervous. When you use the word humanity, I think you're dead right. The question for humanity is what behaviors are we corralling people into? And are we sure that we want to corral them all into the same behaviors? Are we sure that these behaviors are the correct and right ones?
And I go back to quoting Frank Zappa because he put it so beautifully when he said, progress comes from deviating from the norm. If you don't deviate from the norm, you can't get progress. And so it does concern me that as we give the algorithms and the data interpretation the authority to decide who gets what, are we really sure that these decisions are going to be made on a basis that gives us the best outcome for individuals, for society at large?
This is a moment when Karl Popper, who wrote so much about the open society, How open is this society? This is a society where everything is open. And does that actually make us stronger as a society, or might that impinge on the freedom of individuals to stretch and test the boundaries, to deviate from the norm? These are the kinds of questions that I mean when I say this is the Wild West of our time. We We need to really think about what the right outcome is here, even if some of the benefits can be fantastic. What is the society that we want?
Erik Townsend: Pippa, I think that is an excellent place to close. So why don't we leave it there? But before I let both of you go, I want to ask you both to tell our listeners a little bit more about what you're doing and how they can follow your work. Pippa, we know you as a bestselling author, expert. presidential advisor, but now you've got this new gig going on in Monaco. What's up there?
Pippa Malmgren: Yes, I'm a partner of the Monaco Foundry, which is a startup incubator. It's fantastic because I get the chance to work with all these really cool young people who are building things that are going to change the world and help them make those startups work better, faster, connect them, to clients and to capital. And I have to say, it's just the most wonderful thing to have a kind of seat at the cutting edge of the world economy and see what the innovators are doing.
But I'm also writing, I'm starting to work on a sequel to my old book, Signals, which I think I'm going to be calling Signals and Sensemaking, which is all about how to make sense out of things enough to see the signals and prepare for the future, which is very much what we've been doing in this podcast.
And I've been a little quiet on Twitter and social media while I've been incubating these ideas through lockdown, but we're starting to come out of it. So I look forward to talking to everybody on social media. I'm on as Dr. Pippa M on most of my social media.
Erik Townsend: Clint Cox, you are actually in the Wild West investing for investors in assets in this area. Tell us a little bit more about what you're
Clint Cox: Yeah, so I'm co-chief investment officer with Jeremy Epstein of Crypto Futura Fund, and we're at cryptofuturafund.com. But, you know, for the most part, I keep a pretty low profile. I'm not out there on Twitter. I'm not out there, you know, I don't have a lot of commentary. So this is— I came out of this because Pippa said it would be a good idea. So I generally, like I said, I keep a pretty low profile. But yeah, I would love to, you know, talk with anyone if they want to contact us through the website.
Erik Townsend: Well, I want to thank both of you for a fantastic summer series. Listeners, we'll be back to our regular format starting next week. For the MacroVoices Podcast Network, I'm Erik Townsend.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests, and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com.
If you haven't already, you can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, do not assume any responsibility for any investment decisions made by listeners. MacroVoices is a production of Bloomberg Television and Radio. shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.