Viktor Shvets — Heads up Asia Pacific and Global Equity Strategy for Macquarie Investments in Hong Kong (as transcribed; later 'Macquarie') (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. And now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 279 was recorded July 8th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend, and this is my new microphone, thanks to our many listeners who alerted us to the problems with the old one. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
Viktor Shvets joins me as a first-time feature interview guest this week, and I think you're really going to love this interview. Viktor is as well-respected as they come in the world of macro, but he disagrees with my view that we're beginning a 1970s-scale secular inflation event. We'll discuss why not in full detail. Then be sure to stay tuned for our post- postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck is titled Talking Charts. And a quick housekeeping announcement. This episode will air as usual by 8 PM Thursday evening, but a last-minute glitch in our bulk email system has our production team scrambling today, and there's a very good chance that this week's Research Roundup email will be delayed by several hours or possibly as long as a few days. You can log in to our homepage at MacroVoices.com using the account that you registered with and gain access to all that Research Roundup content on the website, or you can wait until we get the email out to you.
And by next week, we'll have this fixed.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to that S&P 500. We got our first sell day in, in what it seems like several weeks, a bit of a reversal. Do you think this is a big turn?
Erik Townsend: No, I think if anything, you know, the first part of what you said is what scares me. The fact that we actually had a down day and it's freaking everybody out because everybody's used to the stock market only goes up. You know, that story's gotta end badly someday, but I don't think there's any reason to think it's I think the trend is up. I think it's strong. And I don't think at this point we're seeing anything other than a buyable dip. I'm not buying it because I'm frankly not excited about this equity market. I do my investing in other asset classes. But as far as I can see, the melt-up continues.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the dollar index. We are still holding decisively above the 92 level, but a little bit of weakness, at least in this morning's session, but really a lot of the same from what we saw last week. What's your take on it here?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, my view really hasn't changed much in the last few weeks. I think that the market is trying to assimilate what the latest Fed policy as well as ECB policy really means with respect to this currency pair. I don't think it's really as important as a lot of people are making it out to be. And as long as we're above 89, I don't think there's any reason to have a downside panic. And frankly, I don't see any reason for a huge upside risk either. I think that the market is still trying to figure out what all this means. If you look at bond yields, on the other hand, which we'll come to in a minute. I think there's a signal there that says maybe people are starting to calm down.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil. On Tuesday, we almost hit $77 on the upside on the August contract, but a little bit of profit taking, at least over the last couple of days. How do you interpret crude oil's price action and how did the inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't interpret it as profit taking. Here's what's going on in the crude oil market. The big news of the last couple of weeks is OPEC+ trying to have a meeting, which was supposed to happen not this week, but last week. And they, in typical OPEC+ style, They tried to have their meeting and they couldn't come to an agreement and they postponed it and tried to have another one. And that one didn't really happen. And at this point, they've really never quite finished that meeting. At first, okay, if there's no OPEC meeting, there's no decision to increase production. Well, that's super bullish. And of course, when the meeting resolved with no result and then no real plan to have a result, people at first said, this is super bullish. Then ZeroHedge had a piece that was posted saying, look, what this really means, guys, is OPEC is failing.
It's crumbling. It's about to fall apart.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And when OPEC fails, it's going to be a free-for-all.
All of the Gulf producers are going to just open the floodgates, produce all that they can, and the market's going to crash. Frankly, as far as I'm concerned, what's really happened here is greed very briefly yielded to fear and doubt because a bunch of people got all upset over nothing. What's really going on here? I think if you want to understand OPEC+, although I've never had children myself, I think it's parenting skills.
You see, what really happened is the United Arab Emirates came to this meeting and Said to the rest of the OPEC delegates, we want an increase in our baseline and we're going to have a big hissy fit if we don't get it. And so Saudi Arabia and Russia responded saying, well, neener, neener, neener, we're bigger and tougher than you, so we don't have to give it to you. And then the United Arab Emirates delegate responded by saying, we're going to take our marbles and go home. F you. Okay. Any mother who's been a mother for more than 3 weeks understands this situation. These children are tired, they need a nap, and they need to be fed. And then Everybody will be happy on the playground tomorrow. But that's not the way the crude oil market interprets this. They take this all seriously, treat these people as grownups, and assume that maybe it really is true that OPEC is failing.
I don't think that's the case. I think this was a gift to bulls to buy right at the lower channel line. And I think that we're very rapidly going to recover from this and continue back above $80. As we're speaking, Patrick, on Thursday afternoon, we've just passed the futures pit close.
Viktor Shvets: RBOB gasoline.
Erik Townsend: And gasoline closed above all of its short-term moving averages. The 5, 8, 13, 21-day moving averages are all below the market now. RBOB has been leading this move, and I think that's a sign of more to come. With respect to WTI crude oil, it's still below that cluster of short-term moving averages, but it's recovered above the volume-weighted moving average and the 21-day moving average. I think that the panic fear is over and it's up from here, and people are going to realize that, you know, the boys and girls at OPEC will eventually get their nap. Fed, and they'll come back and be happy on the playground next week, maybe next month. We'll see what happens. But as far as the sky is crashing and the world is ending and OPEC is about to fail and not exist anymore, I think somebody is reading just a little bit too much ZeroHedge
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, how did the inventory numbers come in though?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, it's more of the same, and I think more of what's to come. Big drawdown on crude oil, 6.6 million barrel draw, and a big draw on gasoline, 6.1 million barrels. Distillates was a build, 1.6 million. But on the whole, we still got more than a 10 million barrel drawdown on petroleum products, both crude oil and finished products net. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 614,000 barrels. I think that what we're going to see is more weekly drawdowns of, let's say, between 5 and 10 million barrels for the rest of July. And I wouldn't be surprised if we see some significant draws of bigger than 10 million barrels net. That's both crude and finished products in August. I think August is going to be a really exciting time in the market. Meanwhile, U.S. production Up 200,000 barrels to 11.3 million barrels. So the predictions of some analysts that we were going to see a big drop-off in US production don't seem to be happening now.
And in the past I've said, well, you know, we've got plenty of time left. Well, okay, look, summer's here. If we're going to have a situation where there's a squeeze on prices because of declining US production, it would be in the July-August timeframe where the big vulnerability was. Looks to me like that feared decline of US production probably is never going to happen.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold at least has put together a week of upwards price action, retracing a lot of the initial selling. I mean, we got above $1,800 temporarily and are trading about $1,800 right now as we speak. What are you thinking in terms of what's next for gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it does look on the chart like a nice recovery so far, but you have to ask yourself, okay, is this just a dead cat bounce and we're headed to lower numbers, or are we really beginning a recovery? Well, we're above the 5, 8, and 13-day moving averages. We're above the 21-day moving averages, the short-term ones, but only by a little bit. We're above the 100-day moving average, but still on a closing basis have stayed below the 21 and well below the 55 and 34, as well as that 200-day moving average, which is a really important one. The 55, 34, and 200 are all clustered together between 1829 and 1841. So when we see numbers above 1842, that's when I'm going to say, okay, it really looks to me technically like the, uh, the, the reaction to the Fed sell-off is over and the, uh, the bull market has At this point, I still think there's potentially room for a reversal in lower numbers before this is over.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's wrap up by talking about these 10-year Treasury yields, because we finally see some almost acceleration in rates to the downside as bonds are outright breaking out. And we're trading below the 1.30 on the yields here. What's your take on what's going on in the bond market?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this pretty much confirms what I've said in the last few episodes, which is now that we're comfortably below 1.50 on the 10-year yield, I think basically everybody got the message to just chillax about the bond market crash that's not really happening. The bond market has maybe topped out, but if you look at what happened the last time interest rates bottomed, it was like 10 years before there was really a significant trend in the opposite direction. I don't think there's any reason to think that. I think we had a big scare that is now ending about bond yields, you know, going to the moon because of the amount of money that the Biden Administration is going to spend. People have woken up to what we said on MacroVoices months ago, which is Don't worry, they're not going to tax people to spend that money.
They're going to print more. And I think that's exactly what the market is finally digesting.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Viktor Shvets. Now, Erik, why did we invite Viktor on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Viktor has been around this industry for a long, long time, far longer than you and I have, Patrick. He's a very well-respected guy, and most importantly, he disagrees with us, and that's what we look for. Best investor practice is never to look for people who agree with you so you can feel smart. It's to look for smart people who disagree with you so you can find out what's wrong with your own view. Viktor's a guy who sees a lot of the world the way I do, but he does not share my secular inflation view at all. And I was so excited to really get a strong, credible guy who understands what this is all about, who can really make a cogent argument as to why he doesn't see the runaway inflation risk that I see in coming years. So that was really my focus. And frankly, And frankly, Viktor exceeded my expectations. We covered that and a number of other topics.
I think you're going to love this one, guys.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Viktor is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy is live now at smartermarketspod.com, and you can look for another terrific interview every Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Viktor Shvets, who heads up Asia Pacific and Global Equity Strategy for Macquarie Investments in Hong Kong. Viktor, it's great to have you on the program as a first-time guest. I've been asking all of our guests to tell me about inflation versus deflation, which, boy, it seems like it's just the big debate in finance that keeps coming back. How do you see this? Are we, as many of us think, headed into secular inflation, or is it just a false alarm?
Viktor Shvets: Well, it's neither of those things. I personally think that inflation-disinflation pendulum, in other words, swinging from one side to the other and returning very quickly back to disinflation, will be the story of almost the rest of our lives. If you have a career that is going on for at least the next 10 years, that's going to be your story. And the reason for that, Erik, is very simple. The last 20 years was very straightforward from my perspective.
This was a period of extreme financialization, a period of extreme digitization, and also extreme globalization. All of those forces were incredibly disinflationary. And so the only time inflation had any chance was during recoveries, like when you recover suddenly from global financial crisis or dot-com. But otherwise, inflation really had no chance at all. Now, the next 10, possibly 20 years will be different. We're not going back to the 1970s. Today's world is so dramatically different. Demographics is different. Debt levels, financialization are different. Government policies are different. Technology and its impact is different. So we're not going back to the 1970s. But whatever is going to happen in the next 10, 20 years will be different to the previous period. Why is that? Well, we still have a lot of disinflation. The backdrop remains disinflationary. 20 years from now, everything will be at zero. And where does it come from? Well, demographics is mildly disinflationary. You have financialization and debt, which is highly disinflationary.
And of course, we have technology and information age.
But unlike the previous 20 years, Going forward, there are some inflationary elements. What are they? Well, essentially three. Number one, unlike the previous twenty years, where we essentially just were manipulating digits of information and data, the next ten to twenty years will be much more capital intensive. In other words, we'll be starting to manipulate physical matter atoms. Its example of that will be alternative energy and transportation platforms. Elimination of factories on a global basis and supply and value chains. It's going to be infotech merging with biotech. It's going to be robotics, automation. So it's a completely different environment. Now, it requires a lot more investment. The last 20 years, there was no need to invest much money other than into intangible assets. The next 20 years actually requires more investment.
Now, that investment which we're going to make in this digital age, creating physical things, such as I said, elimination factories, supply chains, robotics, automation, that investment ultimately will be very disinflationary. But initially, it could actually be inflationary. So that's number one.
Number 2, fiscal policies. Remember, the last 20 years, fiscal policy was playing second fiddle. It really didn't play a major role. Going forward, essentially, societies demand that the government takes the excess capital that we have accumulated— and today, we have at least 5, 10 times more capital than we need— and put it exactly where people want it, rather than sort of remaining in the cloud of finance the way it had been over the last 20 years. So, the government will be more aggressive in fiscal policy, whether it's universal basic income guarantees, whether it's going to be healthcare spending. Whether it's going to be some infrastructure spending, whether it's going to be basic research and fundamental research, they're going to be spending money in a number of areas. Again, that's more inflationary.
And the third element is deglobalization and localization. That's going to continue to strengthen. So what you have in the next 10 to 20 years, 2 very powerful forces are going to struggle. One is very strong long-term disinflationary forces. Force, which ultimately is going to win. And the other one is more inflation created from various things we're going to do over the next 10 to 20 years. Now, the interesting question, Erik, is who is going to decide whether inflation or disinflation wins at any given point in time?
Now, my personal view for quite some time has been that private sector will never walk again unassisted. That is, velocity of money will never be— will never improve through private sector. Now, we can debate why I think private sector will never walk again. But if you take it for granted, that, that only leaves the public sector as an arbiter, as a determiner, whether inflation or disinflation will win in any given 6-month or 3-month period. So, if you were to ask me, do I believe there is systemic inflation? No. Do I believe there is systemic disinflation? Yes. Do I believe that there will be times when inflation will be stronger than disinflation? Yes. And the swings in the pendulum from one to the other in the next 10, 20 years will be much stronger, in my view, than what we experienced in the previous 20 years.
Erik Townsend: You made some really excellent points, and I'm going to want to come back to several of them in a minute. But first, there was something you said in there. Maybe I misheard you, but I thought at one point you said in the next 20 years, because of disinflation, I thought you said everything goes to zero. What exactly do you mean by that? I mean, assets all cost nothing? I mean, what do you mean?
Viktor Shvets: No. Well, essentially what I mean, one of the things technology does very successfully— and remember what we've done with financialization that we embarked on in the 1980s and carried on to today and will continue to carry on. One of the things financialization does is massively reduces cost of capital. And technology itself is a human spirit. But the pace, the speed with which technology propagates really depends on the cost of capital. So if one agrees with me that cost of capital must fall forever, then it's like pouring kerosene on a bonfire of technological age.
And what technology does incredibly well is reduce marginal pricing power of both labor and capital and corporates and brands. And so what happens over time, those reductions in marginal pricing power converges into average pricing power, which also declines. And eventually almost everything becomes free. There is no prices, just like information today is almost entirely free, just like publications today almost entirely free, just like trading on the New York Stock Exchange quite— not quite, but almost entirely free.
Free, just like a lot of music is almost entirely free. So, we already have massively reduced marginal pricing power in a lot of industries. We already reduced marginal pricing power of labor. Part of the reason why Phillips Curve doesn't work is that every day you sit in that chair, your price— marginal pricing power declines. Eventually, those declines in marginal pricing power will translate into average pricing power. And so almost everything will gravitate towards zero. Now, at that point, you don't need corporates. Why do you need corporates for? They're there in order to reduce transaction costs. They're there in order to mobilize resources. But if transaction costs are next to zero, and we have excess capital, which I said earlier, at least 5, 10 times larger than what we require, why do you need corporations that live in their own names for hundreds of years?
So all I'm saying is that everything goes eventually to zero. And that's— you can call it communism if you want. One of the ideas of Karl Marx back from the 1850s was that eventually we'll come to the stage that what he would describe as a slavery of labor or capital would just disappear. And the reason it disappears, not because you have a socialist revolution, but simply because productivity rates are so incredibly high that basically there is nothing to do. John Maynard Keynes in the 1930s was discussing something very similar, that within 4 generations, our sort of future generations, the biggest test they will have is what to do with themselves and how to feel satisfied and valuable in a world where they contribute very little. If you think of Peter Drucker in the 1980s, '90s, they were discussing the same thing. So, whether it's Karl Marx of the 1850s, John Maynard Keynes in the 1930s, or Peter Drucker in the 1990s, the idea was similar.
That eventually productivity will mushroom to a stage that neither capital nor labor are required in the same magnitude, neither they are priced the same way, the jobs as such evaporate. And I think we're within 2 decades, maybe 3 decades of reaching it.
But that progression is incredibly tough. The way I describe it in one of my books is to say, if you landed in London in the early 1800s and found Luddites just about to smash a loom. And if you came to those Luddites and said, you know what, please don't do it. Within 30, 40 years, everything is going to be fine, they probably will smash your head. Because for them, that 30, 40 years was the entire lifespan.
And so, when people say those sorts of transition in capital and labor that we are experiencing have been experienced many times before, very true. But number one, we don't feel the pain of people who physically had to go through it. And it just happens to be our life that we will experience now. And number 2, the waterfront of changes is so dramatically wider. So, we're not just reducing marginal pricing power of cotton or steam or railways. We're not just reducing marginal pricing power of chemicals or pharmaceuticals. We are reducing marginal pricing power of everything. That's why McKinsey in their review was estimating that the impact of Information Age could be 3,000 times. The impact of industrial age. In other words, much broader and much faster. 300 times broader, 10 times faster. And so, when I say everything goes to zero, eventually, the productivity growth rates will be so high that there will be no need to value any of that stuff.
And economies are not going to function the same way as they've done over the last 200, 300 years. But that is decades away.
In the meantime, we're living in a twilight zone. Right. Zone. We still have our old-fashioned liberal capitalism ideas, what the market's supposed to be like, what the corporates are supposed to be like, what the industry is supposed to— how they're supposed to function. And the new world, and the new world already making its impact felt. For example, as I said, look at what happened to all the digital industries and what they've done to marginal pricing power of labor and capital over the last 20 years. Just imagine Imagine what manipulation of physical matter and atoms will do over the next 20 years. And so to me, that's what I meant by zero. It's a society of incredibly high productivity.
Prior to the First Industrial Revolution, productivity only grew about 10 bps per annum. After the First Industrial Revolution, call it 1850s, 1860s, it increased about 100 basis points. After the Second Industrial Revolution, it increased to 200 basis points. Today, we're back down to only about 50 basis points.
And the reason for that, when you are at an early to middle stage of that evolution, whether it's First Industrial Revolution, Second, or Information Age, productivity actually goes down, not up. And the reason for that is very simple. Part of the economy becomes so efficient, so productive, so at the front of everything that they effectively cut everybody in the economy down one piece at a time. And you have to wait for the overall economy to get to a certain stage before aggregate productivity will start accelerating again. And to me, that's probably 10, 20 years out, but eventually we're going to get to that point.
Erik Townsend: Okay. I see a theme in what you're saying that I'd really like to understand because in your answer just now, you said a number of things about a trend that we're going to see. Toward much less independence of private business and much more centralization. And then earlier you said, you made a prediction that the private sector will never, I think you said, walk unassisted ever again. So we're describing a change from a type of society that focuses on individual responsibility and self-sufficiency and moving in the direction of collectivism and More social support programs, more in the direction of socialism. I totally, completely agree with you that that's exactly what's happening. It's the big trend. I can't figure out what it is that drives this. I mean, when I was a kid, it seemed like individualism was in. Now all of a sudden everybody wants collectivism.
And when I was a kid, no American would say, hey, you know, we'd be better off to really look at socialism as being better than capitalism.
Viktor Shvets: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: What is causing the change in, I don't know if it's economic behavior or just social attitude that suddenly, all of a sudden, right now socialism's in, communism might be the next?
Viktor Shvets: Yeah, you're totally correct, Erik. There is quite a few influences, very powerful influences that drive it. You have to remember that in the second half of 1940s, 1950s, and call it the first half of the 1960s, there was a very strong consensus in the US and most other Western societies. And that consensus was essentially about the government, that the government has a very special role to perform, that private sector generally should be mistrusted, and that you as an individual are prepared to sacrifice certain freedoms in order to see whether it's middle-class creation, Healthcare opportunity, educational opportunity, and the rest of it. And so, US was not a liberal society. You have to remember that in the 1950s, if you're deviant in any form, whether it's political, socially, sexually, you could go to prison very easily. If you were against ideology of the United States, in some states, that would have led to capital punishment.
If you were found to be a member of certain undesirable groups, groups, you would lose your job. I mean, Secretary of State in the 1950s proudly declared that they fired one homosexual every day. And society as a whole accepted certain limitations.
And the reason they accepted certain limitations, because those societies remembered the 1920s and '30s. And they remembered how bad private sector can be, how misallocation of capital could be so horrible. In a private sector-driven world. And so the first macroeconomists to come through, including John Maynard Keynes, including Galbraith, they never believed that public sector is always necessarily not as good at allocating capital. They never believed that public sector necessarily always inferior to private sector.
And then around mid-1960s, the baby boomers started their uprising. And basically, what they've done is ushered the new world, the way I describe it, the world of freedom, choice, and efficiency. And they basically were saying, look, you don't tell me who I should marry or who I shouldn't marry. You can't tell me what job I should take. You can't just keep me down and not allow me to immigrate or move from country to country or take my money with me.
And so, baby boomers ushered a different age. Now, between 1965 and 1980, complete chaos ruled. And the reason you had chaos is because society couldn't agree. There were part of society that wanted a baby boomers agenda, but there was another part of society which was extremely conservative and still looked back to the 1950s and 1940s rather than into the 1970s.
Around 1980, a new consensus was formed, and it's really on baby boomers' shoulders that Milton Friedman and Raoul Pal become very famous. On their shoulders, Ronald Reagan, Maggie Thatcher, and all the rest of them got elected. And a new consensus formed. And the new consensus was basically baby boomers' consensus: choice, efficiency, freedom. And that was the age when suddenly public sector was the enemy, government was the enemy. It was also that if there is any problem, private sector solution to that problem is always better than a public sector solution.
Now, that consensus started to break down around global financial crisis. And we've really been living in chaotic times for at least the last 12 years, 13 years. And we have another at least 10 years to go. And the reason we have this chaotic stage is that the Millennial and Z generations basically reject the baby boomers' bargain. They argue much more in favor of what I describe as fairness, equality, and no waste. This is a very different way of looking at it compared to freedom, choice, and efficiency. And millennials and Z generations increasingly have electoral pull.
So, for example, in the US, about 20% of the votes in the latest election was cast by those people. But if you wait another 8 years or so, they will become a plurality. And at that point, an AOC-style presidency will be almost guaranteed.
And so do you have this generational change? Yes, very similar what happened in the '40s, '50s, '60s, and then to baby boomers from the '80s onwards. We have another major shift. Now, part of the reason why younger generations feel like that, because just like people in the 1940s who remembered the 1920s and '30s, younger generations have seen global financial crisis. They saw They saw unwinnable wars. They saw dot-com crisis.
They saw pandemics. And so for that younger generation, government is not an enemy. It's a guardrail that actually helps you, that actually supports you. Whereas private sector, they understand, is not always best in solving the problems.
Now, part of the reason we have all of this as well is that in the 1980s, we decided to financialize. In the '50s, '60s, and '70s, even into early '80s, US only needed— and pretty much any other country in the world— only needed about $1, $1.50 of debt and liquidity for every dollar of GDP.
And then we decided to financialize. It started with Paul Volcker. And then the real push forward was the Greenspan put, which was put in after Black Monday in 1987. And after that, we've gone berserk. Money supply has been growing much faster than nominal GDP everywhere around the world. And so today, in some countries, we need $5 of debt and liquidity for every dollar of GDP. If you think of financialization, even in the US, it's almost 10 times you need. And so part of the problem we're experiencing is that we've decided to inflict on ourselves a sort of a self-inflicted wound. Financialization is not something thing we should have done. But we never really debated that in the 1980s and '90s. We just stumbled into it.
Now, why is it bad? Well, financialization massively distorts income and wealth inequalities. If you happen to have assets, you're doing incredibly well, particularly if they are digital assets. If, on the other hand, you're basically relying on nominal GDP, wages, and household chattels, you're doing very, very poorly. And the gap between the two are rising. The other thing which financialization does, not only income and wealth inequality, it crushes the cost of capital. That by itself starts accelerating massively technological innovation, not inventiveness, innovation, two very different things. And as technological innovation started to proliferate, technology started to have a massive disintermediating impact. Impact on labor, on capital, on products, on brands.
And so what the new generation is seeing is a negative impact of financialization. What they're seeing is a negative impact of technology and information age. What they're seeing is massively distorted labor markets where there is no clarity of professions, jobs, progression paths. What they're also seeing is geopolitical and social pressures. Because when income and wealth inequality increase dramatically, and when you have the problems of disintermediation, that creates Maslovian disappointment. In other words, people within the same country move at different speeds. It's your Ohio versus New York, or Sydney versus Brisbane, or London versus Birmingham. And also different countries move at different speed. Now, that basically creates geopolitical and social tensions at the same time.
And so this younger generation is basically saying, oh my God, we're facing so much stuff. The only party that can actually make a difference in this game is the government. And that is why the role of the government will continue to increase. And by the way, I think the younger generation is correct. We will know ultimately how inefficient or efficient it's going to be. But there's no question that the government role will rise.
Erik Townsend: I'm very curious whether you're familiar with Neil Howe's work in The Fourth Turning, the book that he wrote in 1998, which I'm a big fan of. Seems to me there's a lot of echoes here in that he says things are mostly about generational cycles. His prediction has been that the 2020s would basically be the decade where people lose faith in and tear down old and dated institutions. And the younger generation rebuilds a new future, very similar to what happened after World War II, where a lot of both social and business norms were kind of abandoned and we invented new ways of doing things. Is that consistent? Is that kind of how you see this? And are there any differences in the way Howe looks at this versus how you see it?
Viktor Shvets: Yeah, I know the book and absolutely generational change makes dramatic difference. But to me, what makes generational change count is really finance, economy, and technology. Those things don't necessarily move at the same speed as generations. It's very easy to rationalize it looking backwards. But to me, those are the drivers. Those are the key components. So for example, if in the 1980s, I've come out and said, you know what, US productivity has been falling since 1960. '70s. You really don't deserve the money you're making, and you really don't deserve to have the wealth you have. But believe me, by not insisting on the growth rates that you're insisting on, we're all going to be better off. Now, how many votes would I have attracted? Probably myself and my mother. That's about it.
And so the easiest thing back in those days was to say there is a solution, and a solution is financialization. It's assets. We're going to hook ourselves to an asset train. Now, that's a decision that didn't have to be made. It's a decision that we've decided to make. And so the question always becomes, what would have happened if we didn't make that choice? Or maybe that was already predisposed by baby boomers because they insisted on forever growth. They insisted on forever wealth. So I always have difficulty necessarily spacing it like Howe does and saying, well, there are periods, there is this period, there is this period, because there is, I think, quite a lot of of free will involved as well.
And things could have been different. The timings could have been different. But the basic essence that as economies fluctuate, there are times of massive significant shifts. On the other hand, there are times when everything is incredibly placid. And we are going into much stronger change. I think it's, as I said, I think it's 3,000 times the impact of Industrial Revolution.
And so what happens to generations after millennials in Z generation? I don't think that can be predicted because societies will be so fundamentally different. Economies will be so fundamentally different.
Think of it this way: the essence of capitalism is capital and labor. If neither capital nor labor function the same way, it's no longer capitalism; it's something else. And the only question is, what is it? And you can put a label of socialism. You can put a label of communism. You can put a label of enlightenment. There are many labels you can put together, but it certainly is not going to be something that we've experienced over the last 300 years. So I'm not totally sure how that will change what the following generations actually will experience.
Erik Townsend: Viktor, something that's always fascinated me. I'm in my mid-50s, and most of my peers in my age group in finance, they roll their eyes and they just say, oh, you stupid kids, they don't understand anything. They don't appreciate the importance of capitalism, and that's what made America strong, and they'll learn someday. And I just listened to 'em. I think, you know, I happen to agree with the capitalistic view, but I think they're kind of missing the story. What's going on here is the younger generation is sick of this, and they're going to rebuild things, whether old guys like me like it or not. And it's fascinating to me how much of the finance community, I think, underestimates Underestimates the willpower of millennials and younger generations to just say no to the status quo. Now, Viktor, you are known as a thematic outlook kind of guy.
With this backdrop that we've talked about, where there's kind of a new generation that's not in power yet, that we both think is headed into power, it's a very different social attitude of what kinds of institutions they would like to implement. Where does it take us both in terms of—
Viktor Shvets: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: In terms of capital markets, as well as something like Fed policy, most people are still in a waiting game of, okay, when are they going to start the taper to normalize their balance sheet back down to zero? And I think about, when does it hit infinity? I'm not sure there's a reason it ever goes the other way.
Viktor Shvets: That's right. That's right. The way I basically describe it, people say, when is it going to become obvious? We've done so many terrible things, the price must be paid. Why? Why should it be paid? Well, we can't just carry debt. It must be repaid. I basically say to those people, have you ever heard of BOJ? Have you heard of Federal Reserve? We accumulated in various financial instruments well over $400— one could argue $500, $600 trillion piece of paper globally. Do you ever think any of that ever going to get repaid? The answer is absolutely no. And so what Federal Reserve and other central banks have gone through is a process of just using financialization to spice up growth rates and deliver what societies want to be delivered, to understanding that now we are hooked on asset prices.
That household decision whether to consume or to save, investment decisions by corporate whether to invest or do share buybacks, are much more driven by asset prices rather than anything else. And so the more you hook yourself on asset prices, the less volatility of asset prices you can tolerate. So when I was a younger man, and I'm older than you, but when I was a younger You know, moves of 100, 200 basis points were very common. Today, we can't even survive 20 basis points, forget anything else.
And so, central banks are caught in a system that they have created, but nevertheless, something that baby boomers asked them to create. So, when people say, who is the guilty party? I usually say, look yourself in the mirror, it's you. And so, they've created a system that essentially cannot be hooked. And the more we relied on asset classes, the less volatility central banks can tolerate. Eventually on that path, the only acceptable answer is zero volatility. There is no other acceptable answer that you can find. And so central banks have to continuously generate more liquidity and capital for ever-diminishing returns, which means that the cost of capital must continue to fall. Fall forever. Now people say, well, it can't go on. Well, why, why it can't go on? It can go on, uh, and it will go on. And so, so the question then becomes, okay, uh, so what happens to asset prices?
And I say, look, it's very simple. Uh, if you have zero risk-free rate and zero risk premium, what is the value of an asset? Well, theoretically it's infinite. And I said, well, think about— just keep that in the back of your mind and think of asset classes.
Now, there will be, however, a significant differentiation in performance. And what I mean by that, I don't like growth label, I don't like value label, I don't like quality label. I think all of that is obsolete, because something that you think is growth could become value, something which is value could become growth, etc. But what is important is whether you're new economy driven or whether you are old economy driven. And some of the old economy companies can do much, much better by embracing the new economy. But most companies don't have a capability of doing that. They're fossilized, or everything they do is so big that whatever new comes in, it just doesn't move the needle.
And so the interesting thing to me is, in all of that, is that it's highly disinflationary, what I've just described. A government occasionally will step in, and more and more as we go forward. And governments, through a variety of things they do, will generate more inflation. But then it will fall off again, and disinflation will get stronger and stronger and stronger. At the end of this process, there is no capital markets effectively, because everything is either infinite or zero. You're either worth everything or you're worth nothing. Corporates will no longer be 100-year institutions, but they will be like flashes in the sky. A good idea comes up, burn out in 6, 12 months, off you go, the next one comes on. So, it's going to be a very different market.
But having said that, as I said, in the shorter term, if you start looking more like 6 months, 12 months, 2 years, 3 years out, it is still the case that whatever government does will switch you between different asset classes. But if you don't want to try to anticipate what the government will do, if you feel you don't have any edge There is a way of investing in not necessarily just cutting-edge technology, but in companies that embrace the new age, embrace the new economy.
The other thing to highlight, I think, is important. Whenever people say, I think we need to rebase the economy, my answer to them, OK, do you understand that your 401 then will be worth nothing? Are you OK with that? Because the whole idea of money supply growing so much faster than nominal GDP GDP is the difference between those 2 numbers, is really assets. So, are you okay if we try to converge those 2 lines, that your 401 is worth nothing? Most people will say they're not okay with that. Are you okay that your house that you might have bought for $100 probably is not worth more than $30? Are you okay with that? Most people will argue no. So, everybody who argues about resetting the economy basically need to confront the fact that social, economic, and political consequences of doing it, it's just astronomic and cannot even be contemplated in any rational sense.
So, to me, ultimately, capital markets will be nationalized in various forms. They're already too dangerous to be left to private sector to regulate itself or to even participate. Think today, if Federal Reserve fixed the price of money and they don't like the quantity that private sector gives them, they just create quantity. If they create quantity, they don't like the price, they fix the price. So, if you fix both price and quantity, why do we need the primary dealers for?
Well, the answer is there are still some private sector signals we want to maintain. The same applies to fiscal policy. Why fiscal policy generates debt? Does it need to generate debt in any meaningful form. And so we can go through the list and basically argue that a lot of those private sector signals that already atrophied in the last 15 or 20 years will continue to atrophy.
And as those signals atrophy, who will take the place of private sector? Well, the answer is public sector will take the place. Now, is it going to be a disaster? And people say it's going to be like 1970s. Well, it could But on the other hand, it doesn't have to be. And so, one of the things I keep on discussing, whether we need freedom in order to be wealthy, prosperous, innovative. The answer over the last 500 years, absolutely yes.
But is it still the answer as we go forward?
Erik Townsend: Viktor, you did such a great job of answering a question that was about, can it go on forever? forever that I just can't resist asking you the big question. So many people in macro will tell you, look, Viktor, you've been in this game a long time. You remember 15% Treasury yields in the early '80s. We've gone from 15% to zero. Well, almost zero. What was the low? Was what, 35 basis points or something?
Viktor Shvets: Right.
Erik Townsend: Surely this has got to be the time to just back up the leverage truck and massively short Treasuries because the only possible direction for interest is up. Now, I personally don't agree with that at all, but a lot of people do. What do you think?
Viktor Shvets: Well, it reminds me what people were saying about Japan. Remember in the 1990s and early 2000s, the view was that if, God forbid, Japan ever ignites inflation, they immediately go bankrupt because the government will be spending 50%, 60%, 70% of their budget just servicing the debt. Now, how much do we think Japanese government today is spending on servicing debt, 4%, 4%, not 50%, not 40%, not 80%, 4%. And the debt burden is much, much larger than what it used to be. Now, a lot of people say, well, Japan is unique.
OK, let's look at Eurozone. How unique is Eurozone? Look at the UK. How unique is the United Kingdom? And if you think of US, one of the things that is becoming very clear is that what happened in Japan since the early '90s, what happened in Eurozone since global financial crisis, Over the last five or six years, started to happen in the U.S. as well. And a basic sort of signal that the U.S. is sending now, just like the other economies do: it's not about supply of money; it's about demand for money. It's not about supply of credit; it's about demand for credit.
And increasingly, the more we leverage, the more we financialize, the more we erode marginal demand for credit. Now, what that implies is that interest rates not only they cannot go up, but they will not. Go up. And by the way, if they do, remember, we always have perpetuals, which have no value at all because they're never redeemable. On the horizon, we have MMT or Modern Monetary Theory. We already have BOJ. Remember, BOJ has been monetizing more debt than the government of Japan has been issuing.
That's why they're sitting on 52%, 53% of JGB market. Eventually, you don't need the JGB market at some point in time. Why do you need the bond market at all? And so to me, when people say that surely it must break out, yes, if we live in a liberal capitalist economy, absolutely. The way I looked at people in the 1990s who were projecting that yen will balloon to 300, 400 as the only way to reflate, the way I look at them is to say, your prescription or your view what yen is going to do or interest rates are going to to do, it was absolutely appropriate for 1960s, '70s, '80s. We do not live in 1960s, '70s, '80s. And to assume that this is immutable truth that is true in any era is just wrong. So my answer is, look at Japan. And if you look at Japan, ask yourself, how different is US to Japan?
Now, a lot of people say US have a younger demographics. Well, actually, the US demographics today is equivalent to Japan of 1990s, when Japan had huge deflationary bust. Also, by 2030, US demographic deteriorating so fast that it will be equivalent to Japan's demographics in 2010. And Eurozone is only slightly worse than the United States is. So demographic is not the question. Secondly, people say debt level. Yeah, fair enough. Japan had 4 times the debt to GDP in 1980s. US only had 2. But today's US at 4 And remember, US has a lot of unfunded liabilities. If you include that, US is actually closer to 6 times. So that's not really the argument. The third thing people say, what about public versus private sector? US is much more private sector oriented. Well, actually, US public sector spending is now 48% of GDP, higher than in Japan, higher than the UK, and only slightly lower than the likes of France or Germany have.
A lot of people say US is more productive. Well, not true. Multifactor productivity in the US over the last 10 years was lower than either in Germany or in Japan. And so if you look at inventiveness, well, US is much more inventive. But innovation is actually not that dissimilar to what you have in Eurozone and Japan. So I can't see why US will be so much different to either Japan or Eurozone. And it's not even clear how do you fix the problem, because if fiscal spending was a way to fix the then Japan would have done it, right? They had 30 supplementary budgets. A lot of people say mixing fiscal and monetary aggressively is a way to go forward. Well, if that was the case, Japan again has been doing it for quite a period of time. Paul Krugman's been arguing being incredibly irresponsible is a way to go forward. Well, since 2012, Eurozone was fairly irresponsible.
Again, that did not fix the problem.
So to me, I understand what people say, and I myself lived through the ages when interest rates were 15% or even higher in some of the countries I lived in. And that's why I was saying 100 basis points move or 200 basis points move were OK. But that is not our world. And that world is not going to return. The only way to try to reset the economy is either you have to have understanding that we're going to bust it up and have a massive deflationary bust, irrespective of the consequences.
Or we have a war. That's the only way you can actually do it.
Erik Townsend: Viktor, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Before I let you go, though, I know you basically head up the Asia-Pacific and global equity strategy at Macquarie in Hong Kong. For our institutional audience, how can they follow your work, get in contact with you, and so forth?
Viktor Shvets: The best way, Erik, is of course Macquarie. I published a variety of documents. Some of them are reasonably well known and regular. What Caught My Eye comes out a couple of times a month. I publish Rights, Wrongs, and Returns 3 or 4 times a year, which looks more at portfolio allocation and strategy. We also do a lot of ad hoc pieces. So Macquarie Bank will be the best way to follow it.
Erik Townsend: And of course, the research products that Viktor just described are institutional research only available to institutional investors. For our retail audience, I cannot strongly I cannot strongly enough recommend Viktor's book, The Great Rupture: 3 Empires, 4 Turning Points, and the Future of Humanity,
Erik Townsend: which is available on Amazon and other booksellers. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales. It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com.
escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Viktor on the show. He just brings to light so many of the disinflationary pressures that still exist in the system. And maybe there is still a lot of the same kind of returning Japanese pressures that may still prevail in this cycle. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, I thought that Viktor's metaphor of the swinging pendulum and applying it to this particular scenario was just particularly pertinent because that really is what this comes down to. If you don't think that we're seeing some kind of inflation trend here, frankly, you're blind. So, what's going on? Either it's just the beginning of a big secular trend or the pendulum has already swung too far. We're at extremes, which is exactly where markets Markets like to trick people in and get them to make the wrong decision before the pendulum swings the other way.
That's exactly the right way to think about this. And it happens that Viktor and I have opposite views of which of those is true. But listening to why it could be just a pendulum swing situation, which is, you know, how many times in the last 10 years have I thought about the risk of secular inflation? Because I think once it does start to run away, it really ties the central bankers' hands and we have a big problem. I've been very concerned about this for more than a decade. Am I just biasing myself to say, okay, I'm sure I see it happening, when really it's just a pendulum swing? Or is it more the case that no, actually, it really is a secular trend? I'm still on my case, but I really learned a lot from Viktor's perspective, and it helped me to see the other side of this argument much more persuasively than I'd understood it previously.
In any event, Patrick, I want to get on now to our postgame chart Listen, listeners, you know you normally can find the download link in your Research Roundup email. That Research Roundup email, we hope to get to you just as soon as we can. We're having a technical problem. If you need to get to it, you can just log in to the website at MacroVoices.com. Use the same username and password that you registered with when you first set up your account. You'll be able to find all that content that's supposed to be in Research Roundup right there on the website. And the Research Roundup email will go out just as soon as we can.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: get our bulk email system fixed, hopefully not too long after this episode airs. Patrick, the chart deck is called Talking Charts. Let's talk charts.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, I just wanted to first start off with some reference to the S&P 500. And obviously, we started the day with a pretty big red candle. We've been able to retrace at least half of the early losses and ask the question as to whether we're beginning some sort of market correction. I think the first thing I want to really address is that market corrections happen, and it's not about being super bearish or that the market has to go through a COVID-style market crash and a 20%, 30% wipeout. But very commonly, the stock markets will have these 5% to 10% market corrections in the process of trading. And so we're simply identifying the different cycles that we're in. The way I kind of perceive it is that this market is a little bit overdone and the market breadth is actually deteriorating. And the stocks that were the leadership, which are the FAANG stocks, and I know the acronym of FAANG doesn't include Microsoft, but really we're just talking about these big growth companies that are the big behemoths in the NASDAQ, have truly been the leadership and they still continue to be.
Like even with today's down day, Amazon was still at new highs and Apple and Microsoft. Microsoft both holding, all of them are holding near their highs. And we haven't seen them yet begin the correction. But in my mind, we are in the summer doldrums and it's very likely that we're going to see some sort of mean reverting correction from this impulse higher simply because there isn't enough momentum in the broader markets to keep this going.
So it'd be interesting. I put on a 50-day moving average just to just give an idea of where all the corrections throughout the year have initially found support. But what is interesting is, is that when we get into a more meaningful market correction, often we spend some prolonged periods such as several weeks below the 50-day moving average in a correction. And it'll be really interesting to see whether the sell-off that began here today, whether this is the beginning of one of these corrections that will create sort of a summer consolidation period in the markets. And this is one of those interesting turn points where something like this can happen.
So we're going to be watching to see whether this follows through. I think one of the key levels to watch is what happens below 4,300 on the S&P. If we see that, that really does kind of leave it quite wide open for us to head down to that 50-day moving average for a test. So that's what's going to be on my mind going into next week.
Erik Townsend: Now, looking on page 3 at the dollar index, you're the technician in the house, Patrick. I have to ask, is that— would you interpret this as a double bottom that potentially— you know, I'm just looking at this chart. We got a bottom there right at the beginning of 2021. We got about the same bottom in the middle of May or beginning of June. And now we're above that 50-day moving average and seems to be staying there. Is this— bottom's in, or what do you think?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's beyond even a double bottom. This kind of 89.90 level is actually the bottom end of that 5-year range on the dollar index. And just because that bottom support of the trade range is held does not necessarily imply that there's a new US dollar bull market, rather that simply that the bear market in the US dollar simply wasn't strong enough to be taking the dollar to all-time new lows, or at least decade lows. And so what we're watching here is simply now that the dollar has rebounded, where is it heading on the short term in terms of the upper boundaries of resistance? Throughout the last 6 months, the dollar index found some overhead resistance in this kind of 93 to 95 zone. So I think the dollar can continue to remain in its upward movement towards some of these overhead resistance levels, but I wouldn't— I think it's a little premature to be already calling it, let's say, a new US dollar bull phase.
I think it's simply more like a ping pong match where the dollar index found some key support underneath and is heading to test the top end of the range.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more with your analysis. I don't think it's at all clear what the real direction of the dollar is because I don't think that the interpretation of monetary policy is uniform yet.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 4 though. Bloomberg Commodity Index futures. Boy, looking at this chart, Seems like we're beginning some kind of consolidation, or at least a pause in, in the ferocious rally. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so if we go back and take it from a perspective that really since the start of the year, the US dollar bear stopped declining and started basing. And at the same time, the commodities, since that November reflation trade kicked in, had an extraordinary run on the upside. And what we've seen is as those really hot inflation prints started coming in over the last couple months, it actually surprisingly corresponded with commodities sort of hitting a lot of their short-term peaks. But what is interesting is the Bloomberg Commodity Index, because it's so heavily weighted toward the energy basket, has really continued to hold up very much along its highs. And And to kind of illustrate, obviously we're seeing a bit of resistance and consolidation in there. But when we look on page 5 on that actual crude oil chart, we can see what's really been the tailwind behind holding that commodity index higher, which is, is that crude oil kept plugging upwards toward that 77 level.
And like you were suggesting, there is no evidence that a new downtrend in any way is underway. Way, often these types of dips in crude oil would be bought. And we're going to be approaching some, uh, interesting support levels where, uh, as we kind of get towards $70, that may end up actually being bought on dip.
And so watching what happens next on crude oil is going to be a really important tell what is going to play out in that broader commodity index. And I think the, the way to best illustrate that is to look on page 6, where what I did was in the black line have the commodity index that we were just talking about overlaid with lumber. And I just chose one of the grains, in this case the soybean, and copper just to represent some of the industrial metals. And what we really have seen is that it was in early May that we saw peaks in all of these other commodities. And we are now going slowly onto 2 months of actual commodity consolidation outside of the energy space. And this is a really interesting divergence. Usually, you know, crude oil really is kind of marching to the beat of its own drum here.
And it'll be really interesting to see what happens next in crude because really there is nothing holding the commodity index up outside of crude. And that really may set in motion a much broader commodity correction that can last much longer if for whatever reason crude oil did follow through on its selling. So that's one of the most important things to watch is will crude oil be bought on dip? I know you believe it will be, but I certainly think it's the most important thing to watch here going into next week.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I want to go back to your lumber chart just because this one's near and dear to my heart. I've been watching lumber futures not because I trade them, but because I want to build a house and And I've been very concerned that the cost of all construction is just crazy through the roof with this panic reaction to all kinds of people in cities moving out and buying houses in the country and so forth. I look at this chart and I say, it looks to me like this lumber price deviation is probably over and maybe planning to build a house in the next couple years is not such a bad idea. What do you think?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what I mean, the multi-decade range for lumber was down in the $200 to even $500 range. And so lumber went parabolic to $1,700 on the upside. And we're— while we're back down to under $800, we still are more than double the kind of decade trade range. And so while I think there— we've seen a point where lumber is incredibly oversold, it'll be really interesting to see whether or not it still weakens a little bit from here. But we've certainly seen that that short-term supply shock that seemed to drive that parabolic rise has now been kind of worked through the system. We're starting to approach the kind of more reasonable prices. Even I don't know whether anticipating lumber to return back to, you know, 2019 and '20 prices is realistic anymore, but certainly approaching the ranges where that excess has been really worked out of the price.
Erik Townsend: Well, this really goes back to Viktor's comment then, doesn't it? Because if you've got Viktor's view, which is that this is a pendulum swung too far and is about to return, then really we can expect cost of construction and building materials and all that stuff to come back down on the deflationary theme that Viktor's told us about. If I'm right in that we're at the beginning of a big 1970s-sized secular inflation, right now is the buy-the-dip on building anything because prices are about to get a whole lot higher in the next decade or so. So I guess it's a toss-up. Let's keep going though and continue on to page 7 and everybody's favorite market, which is gold.
Erik Townsend: Just looks like kissing the 50-day from the bottom side. What do you make of this?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. It's interesting because, yeah, we've talked about how gold has kind of bounced and, and worked its way toward this $1,800 level. Still not in any uptrend by any means. Obviously that big Fed hawkish tilt really took the wind out of the sails of gold.
But what is interesting is we've had many, many guests come on to MacroVoices talk about the correlation of gold to real yields. And one of the interesting observations on page 8 to make is that real yields on the 10-year Treasuries have actually returned to being very close to -1% again. And all of that little scare that happened earlier, um, several months ago that, that spooked the, the gold market in the first place has, uh, been almost entirely reversed. And it'll be really interesting to see whether these negative real yields stay down here and whether gold finally actually stays within its correlation and bullishly responds to that. And, uh, with real yields down where they are, it'll be really interesting to see whether gold can beat above these moving averages and get back to like $1,850+ where the price action will start to turn more bullish here.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield, not the real yield but the nominal yield on page 9.
Patrick Ceresna: Right, and so we were talking about in the market wrap and just how, uh, that, uh, 1.50 on the rates finally gave out and we really see a bond rally underway as rates are just starting to break down. But what is noteworthy and what I really wanted to highlight is going beyond the US yields, because is this a bigger global trend? And, you know, is this something that is being almost a disinflationary sign that is happening globally?
And so on page 10, I have that German Bund. And what we see is that while throughout much of the year we went went from, you know, almost, uh, -70 basis points on the German 10-year to, uh, to almost going back to zero. And here we are back to -30 basis points, and, and that German bond yields once again rolling right back down. And we take a look at the Japanese, uh, 10-year yield, which was, uh, near zero at the start of the year, had that quick jump to 20 basis points in the early first few months of the year, and we're right back down to zero.
Point being here is that that kind of bond bear that reared its head in the last 6 months, it really is showing that right around the world yields are declining. And I kind of asked the question, is, you know, that pendulum swing that Viktor talked about, are we seeing the signs on a global basis that the pendulum just started to swing the other way and that the reflation trade in fact has played itself out. And I think that's one of the big puzzle pieces to solve here in the coming weeks.
Erik Townsend: And listeners, you can get Patrick's chart decks not just once a week, but every day when you sign up for a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading. You can find the information on page 12 of the chart deck or just go to bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Aalo Atomics Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what they'll find eventually in this week's Research Roundup when the email comes through, or what they can find right now by logging into the website MacroVoices.com.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. You'll also find a link to an interview from Bill Blain on the importance of the 1.34 level on the yield, as well as a Knowledge Leaders Capital article asking if the reopening and value trade is over. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback. and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices. for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Voices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to Mailbag@MacroVoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our Mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices is produced MacroVoices, by Bloomberg Television and produced by Bloomberg Television's partners and is available on Bloomberg TV and radio.
its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Eric Peters — One River Asset Management CIO (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 278 was recorded on July 1st, 2021, Canada Day, and I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow.
One River Asset Management CIO Eric Peters has been in the news quite a bit lately as his new venture, One River Digital, has become one of the most voracious buyers of Bitcoin. Eric returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss secular inflation and the digital currency revolution in detail. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck is titled Looking Under the Hood.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's talk about these markets. S&P 500 finally made it above the 4,300 level as time of recording here. What's your take on this market?
Erik Townsend: Same thing, different day as far as I'm concerned, Patrick. All of the smartest logical arguments that anybody makes all say the market's way overvalued and it keeps going up anyway. Sounds to me like a crack-up boom and incipient secular inflation. And I think probably we, We've got a long ways to go. I think if this is inflation-driven, which is what I suspect, there's room for plenty of more upside. Eventually, this has to end very badly. I don't think these valuations make sense, but for now, the trend is up. Don't fight it.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's talk the US dollar because that continues to edge upwards and looks like at least the trend that shifted in the post-FOMC has not really been given back. And we're trading around 92.5 at the time of recording. It's a fresh multi-week high. What's your take on this?
Erik Townsend: Well, certainly the chart pattern, you know, looks visually kind of bullish looking, almost looks like a little micro timeframe cup and handle pattern that's starting to form there. But overall, Patrick, I really don't have any strong view and I would never trade the dollar index here. You gotta remember, it's relative to other currencies. That's what we're measuring. And this is so policy dependent. And, you know, as far as I'm concerned, the only people that have any business trading the dollar index are going to be people who think they have inside information about upcoming policy decisions. I don't see how you could win that game without that information.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's talk crude oil because we had that fresh breakout today. We're at north of $75 at the moment, actually. This is really almost accelerating to the upside. What's your take on this oil? What was the reason for the move?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, we were above $76 briefly this morning, and I won't be surprised to see us get back up there. What's going on? Most of this week has been about anticipation up to the OPEC meeting. And so we had another big drawdown on crude oil inventories, 6.7 million barrels coming out of commercial Yeah. 8.1 total if you include the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. And of course, regular listeners know I think that's commercial oil, not government oil coming out. So I count all 8.1 as the drawdown. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 1.5 million barrels. Gasoline building 1.5 million barrels. Distillates drawing down 869,000 barrels. US production ticking down 100,000 barrels to 11.1 million barrels. Overall, Patrick, the way I look at this oil market is we're getting into some very, very Very excited concern about physical supply of deliverable WTI in the summertime. So what the heck is with this UV spread, as traders call it? The difference in price between September and October is $1.30 as we're speaking today.
That's a, a really huge differential. What's going on there? I think what this is about, Patrick, and a lot of people are struggling to figure out what it's about, I think it's about The grades of oil which are stored in Cushing not being deliverable against the WTI contract. In other words, the WTI contract specifies Cushing, Oklahoma as the location of delivery of oil, but it's not just any old oil. It has to meet a certain technical specification. And it just doesn't make sense that the time spreads are as wide as they are with so much oil in storage. The only explanation would be a lot of that oil in storage is not the right grade to deliver against WTI. That's my theory at the moment.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: And frankly, it's a speculation. I welcome any critical feedback on Twitter if people disagree. That's the best I can come up with to explain what's driving this. Because normally these summertime blowouts in the spreads really are driven mostly by physical supply disruptions, things like pipeline spills.
And we don't have that here. But I think it has to do with what kind of oil is in the tank. We'll see what happens with these. But right now, $1.30, that's a really, really wide spread. Although, Generally speaking, those UV, the September, October, are often the widest spreads because that spread actually closes, ends up finishing trading in the middle of August, right at the potentially the seasonal height of the oil market. So it's gonna be really interesting to see how much further this one has to go at $1.30 here of backwardation.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's touch on gold because gold's been trade range bound for several weeks after that big move on after the FOMC. And it really doesn't seem like the bulls or bears have shown their hand for the next move. What's your take on the next move on gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, I strongly agree with the commentary that you just embedded in your question, Patrick. I think what's going on here is we kind of felt like, boy, the bull market is on. We took out the 100-day, then the 200-day moving average has really taken off. And then that FOMC statement really, really threw a monkey wrench in the works. And I think everybody's shell-shocked now. The bulls are afraid to go back to being bullish. And I think maybe the, the bears are afraid after that big rally that we had ever since March of how bearish they want to be. I think we're waiting to see what happens here. And I I think it's probably gonna be policy-driven. Personally, I'm hoping the next number's lower so I can buy some more, but I'm quite convinced the long-term outlook for gold is extremely bullish.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, and let's touch on that 10-year Treasury yield, which also continues to be just pinned just below the 1.50 level on the yields. What's your thinking here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I've said before, I think the key is we're well below 1.7, which is about where people start freaking out. And as long as we stay down here, I don't think it matters that much. I'm not trying to trade any kind I'm not a big fan of yields from a speculative standpoint. I just watch them as a macro signal. As long as we're in between 1% and 1.7%, it's almost all the same to me. Although I would say that we're seeing more and more of what I would describe as a calming. More and more of the market is saying, okay, that fear we had of interest rates backing up and going to 5%, okay, that was probably a false alarm. I think that's where the sentiment is. Let's see what happens in coming weeks.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Eric Peters. Erik, why did we get Eric back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Eric Peters is one of the smartest macro guys that we know, and he kind of defected to the dark side of the force about a year or so ago, launching One River Digital. It really has become one of the most prestigious institutional custodians of cryptocurrency. Now, Eric Peters is a macro guy who I respect. I think he's very smart.
And it's very interesting to me because I see the digital currency revolution, which is very real, a little differently than the Bitcoin maximalists. And I was surprised a little bit. Eric Peters was not the guy I would've expected to turn into a Bitcoin maxi. So I wanted to understand what was driving that, where he was coming from, and where he sees the inflation question that we've been pondering for, what, months now here on MacroVoices.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Eric Peters is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole.
Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy is live now at SmarterMarketsPod.com. And you can look for another terrific interview every Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to listen to this
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Eric Peters, Chief Investment Officer for One River Asset Management. Now you know that part, but Eric is now also the CIO for One River Digital. And we'll be asking him about that too. Eric, it's great to have you back on the show. I have been asking almost every guest that we have the same opening question, which is, look, inflation. Janet says transitory. I say secular. I've been asking a lot of guests this, but I really want to point something out. A rule of mine, Eric, is you don't listen to the most well-spoken, cool-sounding, pretty girl on CNBC. You listen to the people who actually saw stuff coming before they happened. You told me, I think 2 years ago, that you guys had become convinced at One River that secular inflation was coming. And I think you were launching a fund just to focus on inflation as a trend, a thematic inflation fund.
Is that right? And I guess what I'm most interested in, what were you thinking back then when nobody was talking about inflation? Why did you see it as an issue? I guess Hugh Hendry was telling me about inflation then, but not too many people. You saw it before then. How is what you thought was going to happen then compared to what has happened? And What do you guys think is coming next since you kind of got it right so far?
Eric Peters: Erik, it's great to chat again And thanks. Thanks for having me back. And yeah, I'm sure I'm not the most articulate person. So I guess I'd rather be a little early than articulate. But, you know, on the topic of inflation, it seemed, it seemed to us inevitable. And but to really to explain that, I think we kind of have to go back into what had caused disinflation, or at least very, very low and stable inflation, which is really the paradigm that we were in.
And there are a few major macro drivers that have played out, honestly, over the course of my entire career. And so I started in 1989. And so at various points in time, we've— and it's accelerated post-2000, but we've seen increased globalization. We've seen successive use of monetary policy to support the economy at every bout of economic weakness.
We've seen this incredible proliferation of ever-accelerating technology. And so, all of those things together have created an environment where there's been a lot of leverage that's been built into the system. Wages have come down for the average worker. And a lot of jobs have been moved offshore. And yet, financial assets have done incredibly well, because these dynamics are really— they really are beneficial to capital over labor.
And the consequence of the complicated interaction between all these different forces— so globalization, the rise of faster technology, without which incidentally globalization wouldn't really have been possible at this scale, the offshoring of jobs and just pressure on labor relative to capital with a central bank that was prepared and maybe even eager to step in and just support the economy at every wobble, led us to a place where asset prices were very— financial asset prices were very expensive. The distribution between capital and labor was distorted heavily to capital over labor at a level that we haven't really seen since the late 1920s. And monetary policy had largely become impotent, meaning that lowering interest rates or doing more QE wasn't really supporting robust economic growth. It was becoming less and less effective over time, even as it was reasonably effective at pushing up asset prices. And so when you look at that overall setup, you go, well, Wow, we're really approaching this major pressure point where the dominant policy of the last few decades, really my whole career, no longer is really working very well.
And we have this distortion in the division of the economic spoils between capital and labor. And so whenever we get the next recession, God forbid depression, we're going to have to enter a new policy paradigm because monetary policy is simply not going to work. It's not going to be effective enough.
And so what will that policy paradigm be? It really could be a couple of things. One, we could really have a huge debt write-off and just start all over again. And yet, it was pretty obvious that the appetite for that politically is close to zero, or zero, effectively zero.
And so if that was not a possibility, then what else would happen? And really, the only big scalable answer is we'd need to have some kind of wild productivity boom, new technology, or we'd have to have a major fiscal stimulus. And so by default, it seemed to us that it was obvious that it would— well, we'd hope for a major technological breakthrough, but certainly nothing like that was on the horizon at the time. And so it seemed inevitable that we'd have a major fiscal stimulus. And if we had a major fiscal stimulus, that it would inevitably be supported by the central bank buying debt aggressively because that's what they had been doing and the world seemed to have adjusted to that paradigm.
So in that environment where you see a large fiscal expansion supported by an aggressive central bank with the intent to alleviate the debt burden for society overall, that definitionally you'd have to have higher inflation because the policy objective actually would be to create inflation, meaning it would be to debase the enormous pile of debt that had come to burden the economy and do that through just issuing more debt, stimulating the economy, creating deeply negative real interest rates, and ultimately debasing the currency. So those things just seemed inevitable.
And I don't want to say thankfully, it's how it's played out. Certainly thankfully for our portfolios, but I think it's neither good nor bad. It just was an inevitability.
Erik Townsend: Eric, I'm going to make the argument that maybe the easy work is behind you and it gets hard from here, because I agree with you completely. I do think this is a secular inflation, but we all have to think as professional investors about what if it turns out that we're wrong?
The thing is, I just think right now, oil and copper and all of these other inflation hedge trades really look fantastic unless Janet's right. If inflation is transitory, the reflation trade has already overshot, and all of these things are a screaming short if we're wrong about this. But I don't think we are wrong about this.
What do you do? Do you hedge these things with optionality in your portfolios? How do you handle that? What if actually Janet got something right and this really is transitory inflation?
Eric Peters: Well, look, Janet's a very smart, smart person. And my guess is she'll be both right and wrong, meaning it all depends on your time horizon. Inflation, if you look at the inflations of the past, certainly in the beginning stages of them, but even kind of in the meat or even toward the end, they're volatile periods. So the inflation rate doesn't climb a steady path like the S&P did for all these years, really. Inflation as it rises is very volatile. And prone to people probably overhedging and then getting squeezed out of those positions.
And so, there clearly are aspects of this inflationary period that we've entered that are going to be transitory. Used car prices are not going to go up 50% every year. It's just— and if they do, that would be a real problem. They're obviously not going to. And so there will be supply responses to these higher prices in various commodities. And so there will be periods where it will appear that inflation is moderating. But I think you have to stay focused on the policy objective here. The policy objective is to— is, I think, quite clearly to unburden the economy. And this is not just the US. This is more of a global phenomenon, really. Certainly, some countries are more subject to it than others in various degrees. But the policy objective is to unburden economies from a multi-decade extraordinary debt expansion.
And the way you do that is either through a massive deflationary event, which is a huge credit write-down, Or it is through either a short burst of hyperinflation or a longer period of controlled inflation. And I would define controlled by a period where governments attempt to and succeed at engineering a rate of inflation that's pretty meaningful. Let's call that north of 3%. And at times, it could go up Right now, it's higher than that, right?
But a long period of material inflation while also keeping interest rates artificially low and well below those rates of inflation. And if you do that for 10 or 15 or 20 years, then before you know it, your whole economy becomes less burdened or even unburdened from these debts. And if you're lucky, somewhere along that path, you get some type of real productivity burst that lifts the economy and things get better. So, I think that's the objective. And so, when there's such a clear objective, I think to think that it's going to be transitory, it just doesn't make sense to me. Now, I think if you believe that it's going to truly be transitory, what you're saying is that you think that policy will fail in its intent.
And I think at this stage, With a government that's been willing to run deficits of 15%, really, for 2 years in a row, fully funded more or less by the Fed, I think to think that these guys are going to fail and just succumb to the Japanese experience seems highly unlikely.
Erik Townsend: Eric, let's carry that forward and talk about how it might play out, because I agree with you completely. Let's assume the government's intention is what some people call slowly inflating away the real purchasing value of the national debt, of the public debt. That's what we're talking about here. If that's going to be the agenda and it's going to lead to ongoing systemic and secular inflation, how long does it take, do you think, before there are potentially adverse consequences of maybe that not going quite the way they planned it? And what are those consequences? What are the things that could go wrong with that plan?
Eric Peters: Well, that's where it gets interesting, right? So, and I say interesting I'd say where it gets interesting to me, just being a student of the history of money and markets, and it's interesting because we live in a world of fiat currency. There's nothing backing currency other than people's faith in it. And so, we're running a major experiment. We're running an experiment where we say, well, We think— I say we, meaning policymakers, politicians— we think that we can attempt this experiment, meaning we can engineer inflation that is at a much higher rate than the interest rates that we suppress and create this negative real interest rate, which is effectively a huge tax on capital.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Eric Peters: Because if you own these bonds or if you Unless you're investing in something that is creating a return in excess of that inflation, your capital is really being taxed. And so they're running this experiment at scale in a world of fiat. And yet we don't really understand for how long people will have faith in this paper money system. We just don't know. I definitely don't know. And I think what happened post-'08 was that there were an awful lot of smart people who thought that once we entered this world of QE, that actually we would have a huge inflation. And really, the reason for that was because they thought that people would lose faith in fiat.
And that ended up being wrong. And so what happened was the Fed did do QE. They bought a lot of bonds, created a lot of money, but that money just had no velocity in the banking system. And so I think what's happened post-'08 is that the voices that were concerned about a major inflation were more or less silenced just because they were wrong for a significant period of time.
And that has given policymakers and politicians the courage to just say, well, we think that we can do this experiment. And we can actually not only do QE, but also do it with massive government deficits. And it probably still won't create runaway inflation.
Erik Townsend: Or—
Eric Peters: and let's call it what a runaway inflation— a runaway inflation is really people losing faith in a currency. So I think that the politicians and the policymakers, having experienced this unique episode post-'08, where they created a lot of money, and there was no velocity of that money, and it didn't create a real loss in faith in the currency, they feel that they can push that experiment a step forward. And I would argue that they've now done something that is just— it's so unorthodox, it's hard to even characterize it, really, and put it in a historical perspective, what's happening right now. From a policy perspective. But that's the bet that they're making. They're making the bet that they can do this without people losing faith in the currency. And if they're right, then I think it will be a reasonably— then it's a smart policy. And we'll look back and say, that was good. They unburdened the economy from all this debt.
They taxed capital, meaning the people that have a lot of money that had saved it in various forms, they've taxed that. And so they've they've restored greater balance between the rich and the poor, and the economy is just healthier. Let's close your eyes and say that that's where we are in a decade. That will have ended up working out really well. The risk is that somewhere along that way, people go, you know what? I'm tired of my capital being taxed, and I'm going to move it out of bonds and move it out of this currency into other things. And that's where you get a real discontinuous market event. And we don't know whether that will happen, but that's the risk.
Erik Townsend: I'd like to run a couple of thoughts by you because a lot of people, myself included, have been a little bit skeptical of current policy because we feel that, you know, they really are trying to solve a lot of problems with a printing press that I don't think can be solved with a printing press.
My peers and colleagues who hold this view are telling me, you know, it's all gonna blow up by next year. It's gonna be a mess. I don't think so, Erik. I think that if you do this agenda that we've begun on already, it's not might happen. It's already clearly the wheels are turning.
I think what happens is it looks absolutely beautiful for the economy for several years before everything blows up. And I do think everything blows up eventually, but I think it could be lots of years before that happens. And I know how politicians think, which is if it happens on the next guy's watch, I don't care.
Would you agree with that? And the big question I try to get my head around is how many years are we talking about before the, the good inflation turns into really bad inflation? Do you agree with the premise to start with?
Eric Peters: Well, let's start with the position of humility, which is that this is an experiment. It's at a scale that we have never seen. And so we don't know how it'll play out. And anyone who says they know exactly how it'll play out is either too confident or just pretending.
So look, we're throwing an incredible amount of money at the economy. And it's just, it's a bit difficult for me to see how that in the end isn't good for the economy. There's a difference between what's good for the real economy and what's good for financial asset prices. And so that's one of the interesting things that we'll have to contend with. In other words, it could be the case that we end up with, with a reasonably strong economy or potentially an overheating economy, real economy. And that actually ends up being quite good at achieving one of the other objectives that politicians and policymakers have right now, which is to restore balance between how the economic spoils are divided between capital and labor.
And one of the ways you do that, if you think about it at the extreme, one of the ways that you really do that is you get people who are workers paid a lot of money, And that, in effect, creates a form of tax on capital, right? Because if everyone has to pay their workers lots of money and/or has to somehow give them more benefits in some kind of way, and even if they don't do it directly, the corporations do it because they're taxed, and then the government provides those services or those economic supports.
If all that happens, you could imagine— you could easily imagine an environment where labor does well and capital does not do well. Capital at the highest level, meaning maybe equities don't do well. Maybe imagine a world where bonds have deeply negative real rates, and that goes on for a long period of time. It means anyone who owns bonds ends up losing real purchasing power over time. And imagine equities don't do well because profit margins are perpetually shrinking because either through taxation or higher wages or higher input costs, they just earn less money. And then over time, those multiples decline because investors look at it as more or less a more permanent feature. And then as the years roll on, they start worrying that not only is it more or less a permanent feature, but ultimately, it leads to a bad inflation. And so, Why do we want to own stocks, which are a long-duration asset, in advance of something that we think is going to go wrong a few years hence?
So those are all— those are not forecasts. Those are just— I think those are the inputs into how to think about the coming years.
Erik Townsend: Eric, I want to talk about where all this is headed because as you said, what has to happen, it seems, is we're probably going to have secular inflation that debases the US dollar and other fiat currencies. Fiat currencies haven't gone away as the gold bugs predicted, but I'll tell you, there's something that's very, Very clear to me, which is the invention of the secure digital bearer asset, originally invented by the Bitcoin crowd, is a game changer. And it's a game changer, which I'm going to argue the finance industry hasn't even begun to figure out yet, because frankly, they're still fascinated with these cryptocurrencies that I think are a waste of time. I know you disagree, and I wanna get your view on that in just a second. But I think digital currency is going to really, over the next 25, 30 years, Completely change the entire face of finance. And it's going to redefine not just— we're going to replace the paper money with digital money, but what money itself is.
Its functionality is going to evolve and change at computer speed. If you think about how things in the real world change versus how quickly things on websites change, I think how money works is going to start evolving. What I'm going to argue is maybe too fast, because the people who understand it are going to exploit that understanding, not to the benefit of the rest of society around them. And quite frankly, you know, I was a tech CEO, a software CEO in the '90s. I thought it was impossible for finance guys to be more confused about technology than they were in the late '90s. I didn't think it was possible. But boy, crypto sure has confused them, hasn't it?
Do you agree with me that digital— and I don't want to get to crypto versus CBDC yet, but would you agree that digital currency, regardless of whether it's government or private minted, is likely to long-term replace all fiat currency. That's my outlook. Would you agree? And if so, why do you think it's true?
Eric Peters: I think it's inevitable. So I, you know, rarely or almost— yeah, rarely do I say something is 100% certain. But what you just said, I think, is 100% certain.
Erik Townsend: They don't get much closer than this one, do they? I mean, in terms of those certainties.
Eric Peters: Yeah. But look, our The whole world is moving into a digital age. And we see it all around us. It's advancing, and it's advancing at a really swift pace. And in fact, our kids are more and more living in— spending a decent amount of time in their lives living, literally living in digital virtual worlds. And that's only going to going to increase. And so, part of it is just the world is just moving in that direction. It's more efficient. But there's also the issue that paper money, for all of the concerns that people have and that the media has around Bitcoin, for instance, paper money is really— it's difficult to trace.
And so, governments like the ability to create money. It gives them the power of seigniorage, meaning they can just create money out of thin air and then use it. And they do. Every year, they do to a large degree or relatively small degree, depending on the country. But they can still do that in a digital world, of course. In fact, it becomes easier. And so by transitioning to a digital world, they don't give up power. In fact, they gain power. And And one of the great powers that they gain is through being able to track and trace every transaction that happens.
And so, it's no surprise that, at least no surprise to me, that in 2015, '16, '17, a bunch of really smart young Americans and Canadians traveled around the world talking to every government that was willing to listen. About these new technologies and how they could be applied to finance and money. And of all the governments in the world that listened to them, it's the Chinese that took it most seriously. And they more or less right out of the gate said, all right, we need to start working on a digital currency. Why? Why would they do that? And it wasn't because they wanted to save money on paper. It was because by digitizing currencies, if you can control them in a centralized way, which is the choice that the Chinese have made, then you have enormous amounts of data. You actually can, and you can use that to dominate your people, you know, all the way to the end of the road.
And so that, so that's what the Chinese have done. So I think they answered the question for you.
In other words, the reason that the Chinese want to do this is because it gives them power, and governments Governments throughout history rarely shed power. They accumulate it. And so these new technologies give governments more power. Now, they can be— governments can choose to limit their access to this data and things like that. And hopefully, the US will not use this data the way the Chinese are using it against their people.
Erik Townsend: No, the US has never used data against its own people. That's ridiculous. You're talking about America.
Eric Peters: Come on.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Eric Peters: But OK. And I get it. Look, these are going to be some of the issues that we really have to contend with. in the coming years and decades. But at least in the US, you still need a search warrant for certain things. China doesn't need any of that at all. And so they truly can use these technologies to dominate their citizenry. And the US and every country in the world will have similar or the same ability, and hopefully in more more democratic nations, there'll be, there'll be healthy checks and balances. But this is going to give governments enormous new powers. And so they're going to take it. And that's the end of the day. That's why, right? Paper's cheap. Printing money is not super efficient relative to just, you know, clicking a button. But it won't be because of efficiency at the government level. It will be because of power, I think.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Eric, I think that you and I agree very strongly that what's going on here, when you look back to the invention of Bitcoin years ago, the way I looked at it and the way it sounds like you looked at it is very similar, which is, hey, it's kind of cool that these libertarians invented this thing that's all about not having the government track all of your transactions. But in the process of doing so, they invented and published the instructions for how to use technology that governments are gonna get their hands on. And they're going— it's very easy to predict, they're eventually going to do what's now called CBDCs, central bank digital currencies, where the government is the issuer of the digital currency.
Eric Peters: Right.
Erik Townsend: Seeing that same view that you and I both have, 'cause you just expressed it, 3 years ago when I wrote my book, my take was, look, everybody is just super hyper-focused on the first example of this, which is Bitcoin. But really the likely trend is that governments are going to assert their power. They'll probably outlaw the cryptocurrencies at some point. Of course, they won't go away. They'll still be used illegally even if they're outlawed. But probably governments are gonna kind of take over and say, now we got the monopoly on issuing money. Forget about all these cryptocurrencies. We're going to issue government-issued ones. Sounds like you and I both see that future as the most likely outcome. Yet my reaction to it was, therefore, everybody's overpaying for this Bitcoin stuff. It's not going to be nearly as popular as they think it's going to be in the future. So if anything, you know, you don't want to be really chasing Bitcoin.
You took the same data and you didn't just buy some Bitcoin for yourself, Eric. You made news becoming the mover of the market who, at least according to ZeroHedge was buying more Bitcoin in that last rally than anybody else.
So you've definitely got a view that Bitcoin is going to benefit despite the fact that I think we see it the same way, which is eventually governments are going to, I think, crowd out the cryptocurrencies and sovereign digital currency is going to be the big winner here. Why do we see it differently? Or what am I getting that's different from the way you see this?
Eric Peters: Well, Well, there's a lot there. So, okay, a few things. Central bank digital currencies are likely in many countries, but they're not inevitable in every country. I think that there's a very material probability that the US does not issue a central bank digital currency, and that rather the US allows for private sector equivalents. And so that That will be highly regulated by the US, but that we don't actually implement a central bank digital currency itself.
If that's the direction that the US goes in, functionally, from a consumer standpoint or banking standpoint, they'll be pretty similar, meaning that you'll just operate with digital currency as opposed to paper currency, and the settlement process and all these kinds of things will be much more efficient, much cheaper, and all that's great.
But if you have a central bank digital currency, really, when you think through what that means, inevitably you end up having a banking relationship with the central bank. And I think the US, the Fed, hopefully— well, I think the Fed doesn't really want to have a direct banking relationship with individuals. But it also creates a lot of complications in the whole banking system because if you have a vibrant private banking system, and you have a central bank digital currency. And what will happen is anytime people get worried about the solvency of the banking system, they'll just plow their money into their central bank digital currency account, and the banking system will face a run on the bank. And so those are kind of more technical reasons why they're There are more complications with that structure than you might think. And why I also think that the US probably ends up with a private sector solution. It doesn't mean that private companies are just creating money and doing whatever they want to do.
They'll all be heavily regulated, but I think it probably remains in the private sector. So that's what I see on the central bank digital currency side, but that's very fluid. And so, Who knows what decisions ultimately are made? There's not going to be a US central bank digital currency anytime in the next year or 2, anything like
Eric Peters: that at scale. So, if we go down that path, it'll be over many, many years.
In terms of how to think about something like Bitcoin next to that, or replacing it, I really don't think that the US is going to make Bitcoin illegal. If I did, I wouldn't have invested. We wouldn't have made the investments that we did. And incidentally, the investments that we made were in early November, just after the election, with Bitcoin around $15,000.
So anyhow, I, like you, saw the invention of Bitcoin and kind of marveled at it.
To me, when I looked at it years ago, it was so obviously the future of money. that I thought it would be highly unlikely, not a zero probability, but highly unlikely that it would be allowed to coexist next to fiat currency, just because it seemed that Bitcoin in its full expression would be a viable competitor to the US dollar or any other sovereign currency. And therefore, sovereigns just wouldn't want it to exist and would therefore try to stop it from existing. And so in many respects, I thought the beauty of the invention was so substantial that in it contained the seed of its failure.
But what I think has happened over the years is that either through neglect or— let's call it neglect and not incompetence, but perhaps through neglect, governments just didn't stop it in time. And so now it's actually It's big enough that the cost to governments, more or less, of trying to make it illegal— because governments can't shut it down, to your point. Even if you made it illegal, the whole network would still operate. The price would be lower, for sure, for a time anyway. But you can't stop it. So, you have to look at what are the costs and the benefits to governments of making it illegal.
And the costs are that Number one, there's something like 140 million people around the world who own Bitcoin right now. And they're not all in the US, of course, but there are an awful lot of people in the US and their institutions and their futures that trade on this. A lot of people would lose a lot of money. And there are a lot of strong advocates in Washington, DC for Bitcoin. And it forms one of the core assets of this whole new asset class that contains tons of innovation that if embraced, I think will benefit the whole US financial system, the US economy, and our place in the world. And so, if you try to shut that down, you cede an advantage to your competitors internationally and also your adversaries.
So, that's the cost is that you cede that advantage. There's also a cost that if you see that advantage and others start to overtake you, that you then have to reverse that policy. And that's deeply humiliating for a government. So there's a significant cost to the government of shutting it down. So then how do they think about mitigating that? And if they feel like these assets perhaps threaten their power, what would be the logical response?
And I think what you're seeing in regulation now is that logical response. What you then try to do is say, OK, if we, if we could theoretically make it illegal, but we're not, but we don't want to bear that cost, how can we, how can we mitigate it? And what they do is they go, well, let's make it transparent. So let's, let's make sure that we understand who owns what. And once they do that, then they, they, the government always holds the right to tax these assets at even exorbitant rates if they choose to. And so Ironically, it doesn't behoove the government to shut these assets down now that they've gotten past this point where they're widely adopted. What they do need to do, though, is figure out who has them, who owns them, how much do they own. And now they have this huge pool of capital gains that they can tax. And so, we know governments like to have huge pools of capital gains to tax.
And so, this is just another one of those.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about where this is headed in our views. I think they're very similar. I talked in my book about what I call SVDCs, Silicon Valley digital currencies. And what I mean by that, I think, is a little different than what you described. I think the way you were describing this was maybe the government would be in charge of things and would kind of say, okay, we're going to invite contractors to come give us a bid to do X, Y, and Z.
I don't know if that's what you meant, but I don't see it going down that way. What I see is enterprising Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, and certainly Facebook with the Libra project is a is an early example of this, saying, hey, the whole world is trying to figure out that clearly the US dollar as the world's reserve currency is going to be replaced by a digital currency, and nobody can figure out which one it is or how it works yet. Let's make it us.
And I think it's a power grab. I think it, you know, the folks that are in charge of social media already control too much influence on the world. I think they're about to get a whole lot more if they can do And I don't know if this is what you were thinking, but the way I see it going down is these things start out as a private payment system.
And then as you get pressure on the US dollar, as more people are using digital, there's kind of a deal that gets made between Facebook or Google or whoever owns the digital currency system, the US government saying, look, we'll make this the digital dollar, you'll license it, and we'll operate it for you. Is that kind of what you were thinking, or do you see it going down differently?
Eric Peters: I think it's a bit differently. But I think the dynamic that you just described is partially what I see. So, I see, like in any kind of quasi-free market, I don't think we have a perfectly free market, but we still have a market that invites innovation. And there will be various firms that come up with different ways to create a digital dollar. There are already those. Tether is the biggest one, but it operates offshore. And I think that the US government is becoming increasingly uncomfortable with that structure where there's— it's almost like a shadow banking system that is creating dollars that are used in the digital ecosystem. Now, right now, those dollars are not used to go out.
Those digital dollars that are called Tether, they're not being used to go buy coffee or groceries. They're being used in crypto exchanges to exchange from, let's say, Bitcoin into Tether and then Tether into into Ethereum or Ether rather. So, they're being used in all kinds of ways in this digital currency system.
But the government is, I think, has looked and has been really surprised at how quickly these forms of private sector digital dollars have grown. And the velocity in these is just stunning, meaning there are $60 or $70 billion worth of Tether out there. But the velocity is just wild. So, these things are changing hands multiple times a day.
So, the government is paying attention to this. What I'm saying is that they're not going to go out to private— I don't see them going out to private companies and saying, listen, we want a digital dollar. You guys run this for us, and we'll bid it out, and we'll pay you to do it. I think there'll be different types of digital dollars. That spring up in the private sector. And the US government will say, listen, if you want to operate in dollars, then you're going to have to fall under our regulatory umbrella. And we're going to make sure that the way you operate, we're comfortable with the security of that. We're comfortable with the collateral that underpins that. And that all of those things are going to be built such that a dollar is worth a dollar is worth a dollar, whether it's digital or paper. And eventually, it'll all become digital. But that's just different from a centralized central bank digital currency like the Chinese are doing.
It's not that it's decentral, it's just it's operated by the private sector as opposed to operated by the US government. In this case, it's just regulated by the US government.
Erik Townsend: Now, One River Digital is not just in this market. You're a big player in the crypto market for Bitcoin. Are you also investing in DeFi companies that are looking at using distributed ledger technology to do other things in finance? Is that part of it in your vision, or do you see this as mostly a currency play?
Eric Peters: We are not investing in private companies at our firm. I think that there are other firms, obviously, that are doing a lot of that. And I think some of those firms will have enormous success because what's happening now, and What has happened with the invention of Bitcoin, I think, should be viewed as a true black swan, meaning this is a new type of technology that allows for something that humans have not to this date in our history been able to do, which is just decentralize these trust systems. So, our entire society and Most of our economies are built on this notion that we need to have centralized control of some sort so that there can be a trusted central authority on whatever it is that we're doing. And so, imagine a stock exchange. Imagine the New York Stock Exchange is that central authority that allows all sorts of people to come together and trade stocks, and they're sitting there in the middle of that.
And a credit card company is some type of centralized company. Art gallery is a centralized type of structure. So is government. And so, there are all sorts of different organizations and structures throughout society that we have just, as a species, have come together and said, well, this is the right way of organizing our activities, is to have the central control or authority on something. And now, these technologies have come along and said, those are we actually don't need to do it that way. And we have the technology that allows us to do it in a different way. And I don't know what that will all lead to, but it's fair to say that when we look back in a few decades from now, we'll look at this as being an absolutely earth-shattering moment where a lot of the assumptions we've made over hundreds or even thousands of years around how we have to organize ourselves and build these trust systems was changed through these new technologies.
And so, what that will lead to, I don't know. I don't. But I think a lot of these DeFi apps or DeFi protocols, a lot of them will end up being worthless, but some of them will end up being incredibly valuable. And I think the digital assets that we're investing in, Right now, we're an institutional asset manager, so we're not trafficking in really obscure little protocols. That's more for venture capital type investors. We're focused on the bigger assets in this space.
We think that they'll be worth a lot more money as the things that I just described become to be more apparent to people. I think that process is only just beginning. There's a ton of skepticism. There's still this regulatory uncertainty. There are way more questions than answers, but like anything, those things start getting answered and uncertainty starts lifting.
As that happens, I think these assets will become much, much more valuable.
Erik Townsend: Well, Eric, I can't thank you enough, as always, for a terrific interview. Before I let you go, I want to talk a little bit more because it's changed. Last time we talked to you, it was just One River Asset Management. One River Digital is just a brand name or it's a separate company? And what else is going on? Tell us, is the inflation fund happening? Give us the rundown.
Eric Peters: Yeah. So we started One River Digital Asset Management as a subsidiary of One River Asset Management. And so we're still one cohesive firm. We thought that some of our clients might, just due to the uncertainty around digital assets, they might value us separating that part of the business out into a different entity. But I think ultimately where all this leads is asset management becomes fully digital in time. So I started that thinking that we would be the leading, or we would certainly aspire to be the leading asset manager in digital assets.
And what I've, I think, increasingly come to realize is that all really successful asset managers in the future will be digital asset managers. Even if they operate across all asset classes. And we are a firm that operates across every asset class. So we're growing quite quickly, and it's a lot of fun. It's just so interesting to be involved in new things. And this new asset class, while it is a new asset class, it feeds into this whole macro story. So I really don't think that you can understand fully— well, no one can understand fully. I don't think you can understand properly what's happening in macro markets without really understanding what's happening in digital assets and these new technologies. And then on the inflation strategy, it took time, but we've gotten it off the ground. So really excited about that. That, like anything, it's harder to raise money and get backing for a strategy if not that many people see that risk as manifesting.
But now that it's becoming more apparent, we have gotten that off the ground, which is terrific. And we're seeing a lot of interest in that.
Erik Townsend: Eric, I look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value: cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. Escrow.com is the world's most secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales.
It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. escrow.com is a subsidiary of freelancer.com. Listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Eric Peters on the show just because getting his update just on his views on inflation. I know he came on to the show in the years past and talked about that big inflation narrative. And so really interesting to see some of those themes finally come to fruition. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I agree with Eric with respect to inflation I definitely think we have a secular inflation coming. On the other hand, I see the crypto stuff a little differently, but it's very interesting to me to see how people are processing this. It's very clear to me, we have a future ahead of us where the entire finance industry to be transformed so that we replace both the currency and all of the exchange-traded financial instruments are all going to be replaced with decentralized finance someday. Probably not blockchain-based is my prediction, the way everybody else thinks it is. I think it'll be a better distributed ledger that doesn't require proof of work. But, you know, it's going to be really interesting to see how this folds out. And I don't think there's really any more important question in finance long-term Then how is the decentralized finance revolution going to unfold? That could be a podcast unto itself. Anyway, Patrick, let's move on to the postgame chart deck.
Listeners, you'll find the link to the chart deck in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not registered yet at MacroVoices.com.
Erik Townsend: Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, the topic is looking under the hood. What's under there?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's, let's take a look. The interesting part that I want to point out Yeah. And so one of the things that I wanted to talk about is everyone's looking at these 52-week highs on the S&P 500, on the NASDAQ, but it really is not a very broad rally. So let's start with chart 2 and look at the S&P 500, which has followed the pattern that it's been for the last 6 months, which is we've had a correction. It came down towards a 50% retracement in this 50-day moving average, found support, immediately broke higher, and is now making those 52-week highs.
Just following the typical pattern all year long. But what's really interesting is when we look at page 3 and we look at the S&P 500 equal weight ETF, what you can observe is, is that when we take out the overweight in those largest companies, particularly the FAANGs, we haven't even made higher highs on that equal weight S&P 500. And that's the case even on page 4 when we take a look at that Russell 2000. And so what we really have is a rally that isn't as broad as, uh, as everyone thinks. And what's interesting is that the, the best and most evident way to, to illustrate that is on page 5 when we look at the New York Stock Exchange's percentage of stocks that are above their 50-day moving averages. And what's interesting is that in spite of the S&P 500 making these fresh highs and this beautiful trend, we actually have a breakdown in the breadth of the market.
We're basically reaching a point where only 50% of stocks on the New York Stock Exchange are maintaining above their 50-day moving average. This type of divergence is just demonstrating how narrow of a rally this really is.
Erik Townsend: Now, I want to push back on that one, Patrick, and ask you for a little bit more perspective on what that means, because I could say, well, okay, that sounds like a sign that maybe what's going on here is this market's about to crash. There's been this breadth divergence, which historically is a sign of problems in stock markets. We know there's a lot of people that have made very cogent arguments for why this market's overvalued and ready for a big correction, if not a bear market. But look, I think the biggest macro factor here is secular inflation driving a crack-up boom. So how do you make sense of what you just said, which is, okay, there's this big big divergence with respect to breadth in the market. Is that necessarily a bearish signal?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I don't know if I would interpret it as outright bearish. What it really is telling us is, like on page 6, when we look at that NASDAQ chart, what we had is sector rotation. What we had before was a very broad market rally that had all of the cyclicals, all of the— particularly the energy sectors, the mining sectors, the financial sector, and there was a of this huge, uh, rally where the broad part of the market was participating on the upside. But since that FOMC, like we talked about over the last 2 weeks, uh, what we have seen is corrections ensue in all those, uh, sectors, the cyclical sectors, and almost all of the money flow heading toward the FAANG stocks. And it's really been this robust rally in the primary FAANG stocks— the Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, Google stocks. They've really been— and because they're such huge market cap behemoths, they're driving the 2 indices higher just because of their sheer size and weight.
And so I think that this breadth is reflecting that rotation, the fact that we are seeing that cyclical part selling. Now, the bigger question from your inflation perspective, I mean, if we are going to see another impulse in the reflation trade, We would see that money start to flow back into those cyclicals, and that would strengthen the breadth of the market. And so I don't necessarily want to imply that this is bearish and that the market has to crash because of this divergence, but rather it's simply reflecting the fact that there's only one part of the market that's rallying, and that's really the big behemoth FAANG stocks, and everything else is really stuck in the mud.
Erik Townsend: And that's the part that really just puzzles me about this market is I think back, at least, you know, I haven't done a lot of research on this, but historically off the top of my head, it seems like Like, when you've got those popular stocks, the Apples and, you know, the FAANG stocks and so forth, and that's what's rallying, what it means is the smart people stopped buying stocks and it's just the dumb people that only know about the big names that housewives know about that are buying anything. And it's time to, you know, short the market and get ready for the big crash. I don't think it's time to short the market, Patrick. I think there's more melt-up risk than there is crash risk, even as much as I think think we're overvalued. So what do we do with that? Or how do you navigate that in terms of putting the trades on that take advantage of what edge we do have here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think that rotation is not just mom-and-pop retail investors chasing FAANG. I actually think that it's a bigger rotation where there was a substantial overweight amongst investors and money managers into those cyclicals. And I think that it might just simply be a rebalancing of going from from overweight cyclicals to even just equal weight and just money rotating back into that growth narrative. Like Harley Bassman when he was on the show talking about those, those kind of growth momentum stocks being the equivalent of like 70-year duration bonds. It's this idea that, uh, once we've seen yields backing off and, and bonds really basing, it may very well be that, uh, that there's speculation that we're going to see this part of the market once again outperform. And that at least certainly has been the case for the last 2 weeks. And it's one of the biggest puzzle pieces to solve as to whether this is just short-term, you know, a 1-month trend, or whether this is going to become something bigger or more sustained throughout the rest of the year.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to page 7 and the Nikkei, the Japanese stock index. What's going on there?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is just in the same theme. What I was trying to illustrate was, is that while it feels like the stock market is rallying. Somebody who's been invested globally and you have a pretty diversified portfolio of developed markets, emerging markets, and even let's say equal-weight S&P, you've simply not seen any real equity participation on the upside over the last month. It really has been either you own the NASDAQ or you don't. And so to illustrate this, you can see like the Nikkei has has more or less been stuck in a sideways trade range for almost the entire year.
When you look at the Euro Stoxx on page 8, while it's certainly been an uptrend, really the last month has been just a, a correction and consolidation downwards in, in Europe. But take a look on page 9 when we look at the China A50, and China put in its top in February and has just been in a deep consolidation, not being able to find any buying And at the same time, this very similar to that chart on the Nikkei when you're looking at just the emerging market space with the EEM ETF as well, just been stuck in the mud trading sideways for close to 6 months.
And so you have a scenario where equity participation has been in a very narrow space. And now I kind of look at it 2 ways. Number one, maybe that is telling us that things could be potentially a toppy and that some sort of a correction may be imminent. But alternatively, one could look at it bullishly and say, well, the market just hasn't participated yet. So if any of these markets start to join the bull party, then maybe the bull leg hasn't even begun. You know, I guess that's all about whether you want to look at the glass half full or half empty. But really, I think the theme of, uh, what I really wanted to capture in these charts is that there is only a bull market in the NASDAQ, and everything else has just been stuck in the mud, and it probably will continue to be a very quiet summer until a catalyst emerges to wake up these markets and begin something.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, slide 11 is a familiar one to me because we're looking at a comparison of the various different ETFs that can be used to invest in the energy sector, not in oil itself, but in the companies. So we've got the XLE, which is probably the most popular energy-related ETF. Then we've got several others. The OIH is the ETF that tracks companies that provide services to oil and gas companies like Schlumberger and Halliburton and so forth. And then we've got XOP. Now, that's not XOM, ExxonMobil. Don't make that mistake. XOP is the oil exploration ETF. So that's companies that are looking for oil as opposed to companies that are actually producing oil. And then CRAK. No, that's not crack cocaine, and it's not even the crack spread, which is a relationship between futures prices. This one And the final one is actually the refiners ETF, if you want to invest in the companies that refine crude oil into gasoline and other finished products.
Patrick, what do we make of all the price action and the different performance in these different categories?
Patrick Ceresna: You know what, what I wanted to capture by overlaying them is actually a thought that from— to build upon what we talked about at the first part of the show, which was that oil was breaking $75, almost hit $76. on the upside, and it seems like oil itself is accelerating. Typically, one of the things that I've noticed in the past is that when we are seeing big moves in the commodities, sometimes you would see these energy components of the market actually front-run the breakout, and you tend to have people positioning themselves long the energy markets to participate. But what's interesting is that as oil breaks to these fresh new highs and is running on the upside, What we're actually seeing is a lack of participation at all amongst the energy stocks in the last few weeks, and it's it's almost like that traders are are using the strength in oil to do a little bit of rebalancing or even some outright selling in their energy exposures.
And I don't know if I want to overread into it, but I'm something I'm going to continue to watch. I mean, if oil is autopiloting up to eighty dollars and the energy stocks don't participate, then it might be a tell that it's time to potentially hedge or even reduce energy stock exposure into that strength.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I concur with your conclusions, but I get there in a different way, which is I really think that we are in something of a physical supply squeeze right now. And it's an unusual one because there's plenty of oil in the tanks in Cushing, Oklahoma. If it turns out to not be the right grade that can be delivered into the WTI contract, that can put a squeeze on the WTI contract. But I think there's actually more oil there than people realize. But in any event, Patrick, we're going to leave it there for today's show. Listeners, be sure to check out page 12 where you can sign up for a free 14-day trial of Patrick's
Erik Townsend: service. Get Patrick's chart decks every day, not just once a week. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole.
And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook that we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an interview with Jim Carson on the Fed will lose complete control of the long-term rates, and a link to a Variant Perception article, Housing: The Inflation Dog That Has Yet to Bark. You'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend, that's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna.
Erik Townsend: Thanks, Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com. The internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet. Each week, you'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device. Each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions.
The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Daniel Lacalle — fund manager for Tressis Asset Management (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 277 was recorded on June 24th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by AbraSilver Resource Corporation, a premier emerging silver and gold exploration company, Ticker ABRA on TSX Venture and ABBRF in the United States.
Daniel Lacalle is back as this week's feature interview guest. Daniel says inflation is coming, but he doesn't worry about it running away or becoming a major economic challenge. We'll also explore Daniel's thoughts on both cryptocurrency and sovereign digital currencies and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck is titled Post-FOMC postmortem.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's get to that S&P 500. Obviously, a quick sell-off that happened right at the tail end of last week stopped right at its moving averages. And here we are, pretty much almost making a 52-week new high. It seems so much more of the same. Anything new on your views on the S&P?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, if I just look at the chart, what I see in the technicals is all of a sudden the stochastics are really taking a nosedive. But still, if I look at the tape action, Down to the 34-day moving average. Big deal. Every dip is being bought here in this bull market. I am absolutely persuaded by the argument that these valuations are crazy and this market is nuts and it ought to crash. But you know what? I was saying that before anybody else, and I was wrong 5 years ago when I said that, and 4 years ago, and 3 years ago.
I'm quite convinced now that the trend is up. The fact that I don't think that makes sense does not change that the trend is up, and it's gonna continue being up until something changes it. Of course, now that I said that so vehemently, that means the market's crash tomorrow and I'll look like an idiot, but we'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: I'm sticking with it. That's what I feel.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik. Well, we could put up some charts on that in the postgame, but let's move on to the US Dollar Index, which obviously had quite the reversal in the post-FOMC and gave it a little bit back this week. But overall, we're hovering around this 92 handle on the dollar index. Do you think this is a trend change or just short-term noise?
Erik Townsend: No, I think it's all noise. And the reason I say that, Patrick, you know, when this first backing up of interest rates first started, I said on MacroVoices, look, folks, what's going on is everybody's trying to make sense of a new situation that we haven't had before. The Federal Reserve is going to be printing a huge amount of new debt to finance an insane amount of government borrowing. That ought to be bearish for the bond market until you consider the reflexivity, which says the Fed is likely going to be doing a lot of that Buying of those Treasury bonds. And, you know, it's gonna be more of an intervention story. So this whole what's going on with the dollar, as far as I'm concerned, is a series of panic knee-jerk reactions as everybody tries to figure out what the combination of a macro environment that would normally promote much higher bond yields means in an environment where the policy is not at all towards higher bond yields, but lower bond yields.
What does that mean for the currency when it's the reserve currency of the world? Nobody frigging knows.
Patrick Ceresna: That's right.
Erik Townsend: That's what's really going on. And that's the reason we see all this noise in the market. And we try to make up stories that make sense in the short term. But the big picture here, I'm convinced, is nobody knows because this is a really complex, unusual situation. And I think it's all noise until we get a break below 89, or I don't even know what the number is on the north side. It's probably at least 94, but it would have to be a really high number to convince me that there's a real uptrend in play. I think we're consolidating in uncertainty.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because it's interesting 'cause most of the commodity markets have turned in the post-FOMC. A lot of these commodities have dropped, but crude oil continues to make 52-week highs. I mean, we punched north of $74 on an intraday basis. We're trading around $73 in spot 14 at the time of recording. Do you think this continues? Are we still piloting toward $80 or has your view on oil changed?
Erik Townsend: My view has not changed in the direction you're implying. If anything, I think that we've gotten so far so fast. Almost $75, and we're barely through the first half of June yet. Well, I guess it's past the first half of June. We're in the final quarter of June now. Hey, it's spring. We haven't even gotten to summer yet. We just had a really, really epic event in the time spreads at the front end of the curve. Now, this is fairly complex stuff that usually only oil traders really understand, so I don't wanna spend a lot of time on it for 2 reasons. Number one, it's fairly complex. Number two, I have no frigging clue what's going on. Nobody can figure it out because These dislocations in the market normally occur when there is a physical supply interruption, a pipeline spill, something like that into Cushing blows up the spreads at the front end of the curve.
The other thing that will do it is a war or something where people are just afraid that all of a sudden the oil supply is gonna dry up. This happened with no apparent explanation and now it's reversing and I don't know why, but at some point when we figure it out, we'll cover that. What it says to me is there's a lot of uncertainty in the market and I think there's plenty of room for a lot more backwardation.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And a lot higher prices. And maybe 90 is even a low number before this year is out, is what I'm starting to feel. On the other hand, this Delta-plus COVID thing is real. So I think the pandemic's gonna get worse. Does that reduce demand? Because hey, look what happened last time. Or is it totally different because now the world has changed to the point where the public sentiment is such that they're gonna say, hey, it's unsafe to travel and we're gonna reopen the economy anyway because it's just been too long.
We need to get the economy open. That's my base case. I think that's what happens. We open whether there's Delta Plus or Delta Plus Plus Plus. I think that the pandemic will get better, but that we will continue with vaccination to reopen travel. And that means that oil demand goes through the roof. And, you know, I think the upside this summer could be really big.
On the other hand, if I got that wrong about the COVID stuff and it really does damage demand, it's a whole different story. It's going to change things. For that reason, I am beginning to hedge some of my very large long positions.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Exposure, but it's, it's hedge. I still think it's headed upside. I'm just protecting a little bit more for a significant correction if the Delta Plus strain of COVID turns out to be worse than I thought.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, how did the inventory numbers come in for oil?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's another big drawdown on crude oil inventory. 7.6 million barrels would be 8.2 if you include the small draw from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 1.8 million barrels. Gasoline drawing down 2.9 million barrels. Distillates is the only build on the board. at 1.75 million barrels added to inventory on distillates. Big picture here, Patrick, on inventory.
Okay, we've seen a couple of big draws in a row. I think the big series of summer inventory draws that's going to push prices higher and dramatically steepen backwardation is upon us. Okay, that's the prediction, is if these 7 or 8 million barrels a week continue through the summer. That's my scenario where I'm saying prices are going higher than even Goldman is predicting.
If I've got that wrong, it's a totally different story, obviously. So we gotta continue to watch those. I'm actually reading some analysts that are saying they expect in the month of August alone, there could be more than 100 million barrels drawn out of inventory in the US. If that prediction, it's not my prediction, it's somebody else. If the prognostication of 100 million barrels being drawn out in one month is actually real, Yeah. I guarantee you backwardation is gonna be screaming by the time we get to the end of August. So I think this summer's gonna be really interesting, but the big wildcard is we don't know about the Delta Plus strain and what it means for demand.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold really did get hammered pretty hard in the post-FOMC hawkish tilt. And we dropped down to like the $1,760 area on the downside. And really gold has not been able to even get a bounce off of these lows. We've been just consolidating sideways I mean, in your mind, has anything changed in gold?
Erik Townsend: You know, the answer is almost the same as what I said for the dollar index. The way I see this is gold took an absolute body slam. Why? Because the FOMC made a statement that sort of alluded to an intention they might have in the future to do something that nobody's even sure about what it would mean anyway.
The market is panicking because everybody knows that if there is even the appearance of dramatically increasing real yields, That's gonna tank the gold market. And my answer to that is, oh gosh, I sure hope so. Because if you stop and actually think about this stuff, you can see very clearly what's happening here, Patrick.
The reason that we might be in a situation where the Fed is going to do exactly that and, you know, taper and so forth, it's going to create a situation that eventually leads to more stimulus and more bailouts and more so forth. If you think the Fed's got this all under control, they're gonna taper, they're gonna reduce their balance sheet back down to what it was was pre-2008 and everything's going to go fine with no bumps in the night through that process, then for God's sake, sell your gold because your gold is going to zero. But you know what? I'm willing to bet that's not going to happen. I think the government's going to keep acting like the government. And any weakness in gold prices that comes out of fear associated with maybe there's going to be some tapering or tightening, it's just an opportunity to buy at a better price. It's the way that I see it.
So I love this drop. I haven't bought more yet because I'm crossing my fingers for an even deeper drop. I did actually buy some more Equinox, Equinox, EQX, which was a Marin Katusa recommendation, but it was an old one. I'm not getting it out of his current newsletter, so I don't think his paying subscribers will be offended.
Equinox below $8, I think, is a bargain here. But really, I'm hoping that we continue to have people freak out for no good reason and it pushes gold prices lower so I can buy even more.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's finally touch on those 10-year Treasury yields, because obviously yields in general Well, at least the shape of the curve dynamically changed in the post-FOMC. But really, we're hovering around 1.50% right now, and there doesn't seem to be much direction other than consolidation for the last couple months. What's your thoughts on yields here?
Erik Townsend: Well, the way I read the yield tape in general is basically nobody cares until it starts to approach 1.75%, at which point everybody freaks out and jumps out of buildings as if the sky was falling. I think the way to look at this is We haven't had any threats of getting back close to that panic number of 1.75 for a few weeks here. So everybody is getting comfortable. If it stays that way, they'll get more comfortable. If that comfort turns into complacency, maybe it sets us up to go the other way. Right now, what I'm feeling like is probably the, oh my gosh, if the Biden Administration spends lots of money, surely that could only mean that bond yields have to go up. That thinking, that mentality has finally evolved to where people thought it through to what we told you on MacroVoices as soon as that announcement came out, which is, look, it's first gonna have this reaction until people think it through and realize the long-term implications.
And then they're gonna see that inflation is coming, guys. At the end of the day, Patrick, I think as long as we're below 1.7% and nobody's panicking, we kind of stay in this consolidation zone. I don't see any reason to expect substantially higher or substantially lower yields anytime soon. But frankly, I'm not following that So I'm watching that carefully. The only thing I really worry about is if it goes back over 1.75, I get concerned about everybody freaking out for no good reason again.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is Daniel Lacalle. Now, Erik, why did we invite Daniel back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Daniel is a brilliant macro thinker. He wrote a book with Diego Parrilla a few years ago. Energy guy, very smart outlook on a lot of things. And he's also in Europe and kind of has that perspective of, you know, the ECB's role in the global monetary policy equation and so forth.
It's also been— I think it's been more than a year since we've had Daniel on the show. So it was just overdue. Super smart guy.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Daniel is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole.
Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy is live now at smartermarketspod.com, and you can look for another terrific interview every Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Daniel Lacalle, fund manager for Tressis Asset Management. Daniel, it's great to have you back on the show. It's been too long. I've been asking everybody about inflation. A lot of people, myself included, think maybe this is the beginning of a secular inflation. Of course, Janet assures us it's just transitory. What do you think?
Daniel Lacalle: Thank you very much, Erik. Thanks for having me. Always a pleasure. I don't think that inflation is transitory. More importantly, I think that perceived inflation, what you and I, what our listeners do see in terms of inflationary pressures are not going away anytime soon because it was a trend that already existed before COVID-19.
The Fed always, the Fed and central banks always look at inflation thinking that it's transitory, that it's going to be, that it's because of supply chain disruptions, et cetera. But when you look at the components, what you see is that, for example, we are seeing many commodities and many metals in which there is ample capacity, in fact, overcapacity, like for example, aluminum going through the roof anyhow.
And we're seeing that the food prices and the food price index that the FAO publishes reaching new highs that were already reached before COVID-19. So the first question that we need to ask central banks is what do they measure as transitory? 1 year, 2 years, 3 years? And the second thing that we need to ask central banks is, are you really taking into account all the inflationary pressures? Because they're not taking into account house prices. They're not taking into account in some developed economies taxes, for example, in utility bills, et cetera. So I think that the inflationary pressures that we have seen throughout the recovery are more sticky than what many would fear.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the recovery itself then, because, you know, on the one hand, it seems like maybe we've got a significant risk of this Delta strain and the continuing mutation of this virus. Maybe it's going to be worse than we thought. But I'll make a prediction of my own, Daniel, which is I think that maybe even if it is worse than we thought, I think public sentiment has shifted to Open the economy, period. Whether it's safe or not, it's just too much time to open the economy.
If I'm right, I think that's gonna lead to a lot more tension between different people. Some people, of course, feel that we shouldn't have closed the economy ever. Some people, you know, think it should stay closed. I think that tension's gonna get greater, and I can't decide what it's gonna mean for demand, 'cause I think the economy does continue, but I think that the pandemic's gonna continue too. Well, how do we make sense of this?
Daniel Lacalle: I think you're absolutely right. First, if we look at the history of pandemics, we know that there is always a second wave. And one of the mistakes that many people have made in the first part of last year was to believe that we had 2 waves of the pandemic, even 3, in 2020. That was a mistake. It was all the same.
And now what we're seeing is, as you very well mentioned, a number of variants that so far are impacting the not so developed economies or the emerging economies. But they're gradually reaching some of the most important economies in the world.
And what we know from the first wave is that markets and governments don't truly react until it reaches the developed economies. Even when it reached Italy or Spain, reaction was still very subdued. So what I do agree with you is, and I think it's that the mentality of the population have shifted.
Having severe lockdowns for 12, 16 months in many cases has led to many people The vast majority of the population, I would say, in developed economies to say absolutely that they will not tolerate drastic lockdowns as a measure that has, by the way, proven to be extremely ineffective.
France implemented very severe lockdowns with 150 cases per 100,000 inhabitants and maintained those lockdowns with 500 cases. So what we need to do is basically to understand that it's going to be very difficult politically for governments to justify the severity of the lockdowns that we have seen in the past. What I think is that the same way that we saw a dramatic, let's say, easing of the exuberance post the 3rd quarter of last year, We will likely witness a similar situation in the fourth quarter of 2021, probably in the third quarter itself.
Once the sugar high of the reopening of the desire of the population to spend and to enjoy life outdoors, etc., fades away, it is true that people tend to be significantly more conservative about their purchasing. And investment decisions afterwards.
And the virus, coming back to the point that you were mentioning, the virus is very seasonal. So we all remember that last summer, the situation in general seemed to be completely under control and fantastically improved. And then we saw that the cases started to ramp up throughout autumn, beginning of winter.
So, you know, I would be extremely cautious about this tendency that we're seeing in consensus to replicate the reopening effect and the base effect that we're living right now in the economy throughout the 3rd, 4th quarter, let alone 2022.
Erik Townsend: I wanted to start with that framework, Daniel, before moving on to talk about the central bank policy trend, which at least in terms of the lip service that they give it is all turning to tapering. Now, help me understand this. We're probably going to have the pandemic get worse, and there's going to be a lot of discontentment and disagreement among people in society about that. And there's going to be more health issues and more government spending, and that's going to be the reason that central banks don't need to keep printing money and it's okay to taper?
I'm missing the logic. What's going on?
Daniel Lacalle: You're not missing the logic. The tapering debate is completely nonsensical. There's not going to be any tapering. Either, either you believe in a robust recovery with healthy inflation and strong jobs recovery, which will inevitably not lead to tapering, but to the end of stimulus, and therefore a very significant impact on financial assets, or you believe in what is most likely to happen, which is that the recovery will be weak, as it has been in every recovery since 1975, by the way.
Weaker levels of growth, weaker levels of productivity growth, and with it, real wages, weaker levels of recovery of employment. We have to remember that with massive reopening and GDP estimates being revised upwards by 30 40%. The employment picture remains pretty similar to the pre-review estimates.
So I think that it's very, very unlikely that central banks end up tapering. And that's why the Fed is mentioning 2023. 2023 first is probably not even the members that are currently in the Fed will be there, or at least half of them.
But the other element about it is that If the picture of the economy that the Fed paints is correct, then tapering will be faster, and that is unlikely to happen. And if the economy remains relatively weak, very indebted, deficit spending continues to be very significant, it is virtually impossible to believe in tapering.
Sovereign issuers would not be able to sustain or to accept that level of increase in borrowing costs.
Erik Townsend: Are we at a point yet where we have to worry about all of this money printing really starting to get to not just the secular inflation I see coming, but a true runaway inflation where it's beyond the ability of central bankers to control it?
Daniel Lacalle: I don't think we're going to see runaway inflation. I think that the disinflationary pressures that exist before COVID-19 remain. Aging of the population in developed economies, very high levels of debt, very high levels of government spending, which are deflationary in principle, and the advance of technology. All of those elements are disinflationary and put a little bit of a brake on runaway inflation.
Think about what type of inflation the world would have and developed economies would have if those pressures did not exist.
Now, that doesn't mean that the things that matter in our day-to-day spending for our families, utilities, food, healthcare, education, the things that truly generate our concerns about affordability of the cost of living, those things are not only rising in a period of recovery, they were already rising as well in a period of so-called crisis. So that's why I'm concerned about inflation and inflationary pressures in general, but not runaway inflation or hyperinflation.
Erik Townsend: Daniel, as we look forward through this recovery and, you know, into what comes next after the pandemic, it seems that ESG— environmental, social, and corporate governance aware investing— is really becoming a big trend. And I got to tell you, I don't think there is anything more noble or a better cause that I've ever heard of in my life than the owners of capital taking responsibility for seeing that it's used responsibly to make the world a better place. So I wanna make sure that I am crystal clear that I'm very much in favor of the concept. But frankly, I think this ESG trend on Wall Street is all about separating people from their money and has almost nothing to do with environment, society, or governance. What do you make of this ESG stuff, Daniel?
Daniel Lacalle: I think that you have said it perfectly. We all are 100%, and me the first as well, in favor of capital allocators taken responsibility and being conscious about the environment, about social issues, about corporate governance. And this is a trend. And this is important to understand as well. This is a trend that has been going for decades.
I remember when I started in the buy side at Citadel that we had environmentally conscious and activist policies towards investments, et cetera, all of those things.
So environmental, social, and corporate governance action is something that we all agree with, and that is a trend that is absolutely unstoppable. Now, we have to discern between the trend and the improvement in the view about stakeholder capitalism that Wall Street might be taking. Relative to and compared with this fashion about putting an ESG label on almost anything. To the point that, for example, you can see some of the ETFs that are so-called ESG or socially responsible investments and see that they're mostly comprised of energy companies and oil and gas companies. There are some of them there that you can see.
Out there. And the other thing that we need to understand is that the idea of ESG and socially conscious capitalism and the idea of socially responsible investment and sustainability is that there is nothing that is more sustainable than a profit-based economy. So when the first thing that we need to understand as investors is that there's sustainability without profit. And that trying to make investors think that an unprofitable and weak business idea is going to be sort of a great investment and reach high valuations simply because it has the ESG label is a huge mistake.
So you have to be extremely careful about the use of a label in which in many cases what investment banks or brokerage houses are using that label is to try to disguise unprofitable and very weak businesses. That one thing has to be made very clear is that what everyone that truly understands socially responsible investment is looking at is for businesses that generate good profits, good cash flows, and good margins to retain and increase those profits, cash flows, and margins with a socially and environmentally sound policy, but not to make something that is unprofitable and probably obsolete simply acceptable as an investment because it uses the label green or SRI or ESG.
We all remember the wave of bankruptcies in solar companies. Now, there was this big fashion about everything being— everything that had the renewable label as something that was going to be rising in value in the stock market all the time.
But the reality shows that when you had a bad business that was extremely levered and had weak margins and that depended too much on increased debt, it ended up going bankrupt anyhow. So the same way that being environmentally conscious, that focusing on renewables, that liking the technology is one thing and looking at any renewable stock is a completely different thing. We have to do exactly that same exercise with the label of ESG.
We have to remember that bubbles do not persist if there is— if it's based on basically just marketing. What we need to understand is that companies that are conducting their businesses in an environmentally, social, and good corporate governance framework will perform better, and they do perform better, but only when they're profitable and when they have a good long-term strategy.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about some of those environmentally related investment opportunities and where the markets are, because I think a lot of people now are looking at energy markets saying, hmm, okay, here we are at $73 and change as we're speaking on Wednesday, and it seems like we've come awfully far, awfully fast. If you believe the secular If you buy the secular inflation narrative, as I do, you can make an argument for much higher oil prices, over $100. It's also a pretty good argument for they're already way too far and need to retrace back down to a fair value. What do you make of energy markets and where are we headed?
Daniel Lacalle: I think that we have seen the effect of 3 things in energy markets. The first is that despite the reopening and the improvement of demand, Supply cuts have remained exactly the same way as they were when the market was flooded with oil. So the market has tightened very quickly, but supply cuts remain. And when we analyze the oil market, we need to always have in mind that there is a significant level of capacity, productive capacity out there that is idle because of a conscious decision of OPEC and its partners.
So oil prices may go higher because of the reopening, increased demand, the monetary factor. Obviously, when you have increased money supply growth, there's more liquidity going to scarce assets. And the fact that these were parts of the financial asset basket that were heavy underweight by investors, therefore simply moving to equal weight has generated a significant inflation in prices.
Those things might persist. What I think is that we also have to look at the risk to the economy. Oil price impact on the economy is not necessarily because it goes up, but how quickly it goes up relative to the economy. And for example, if we look at oil prices, they're up about 40-odd percent year to date.
That is creating already tensions in terms of disposable income, in terms of consumption, et cetera. So I think that the energy market is very tight right now, that two things: a change in OPEC. Supply cuts and an agreement with Iran might alleviate that tightness, but not necessarily entirely because the monetary and the financial asset perspective that I mentioned remain.
But we need to understand that, remember in 2008 when oil prices went through the roof, they reached $120, $130, I think that they touched, is that if they go up too far, What they also do is to hinder the prospects of the economic recovery, and they can actually generate a significant impact in terms of expectations of growth, consumption, and investment.
I also think that from the perspective of energy prices, we need to be at least aware of the fact that with All this push from the IEA, from investors and some of the energy companies to do something which I find absolutely outrageous now, which is to say that there needs to be no more capital expenditure increases in the sector, might generate a very big problem in the economy and lead to stagflation the way that we lived in the '70s.
Is that we can have a situation by which abruptly impacting capital expenditure in the energy sector leads to a very negative effect on the economy. One thing is to believe, as I do firmly, in energy transition driven by competition, by technology diversification, and the technology advances. And another completely different thing is to be too ideological and to force companies to stop investing in things that we need every day as we do way before the transition and at least the ability of the market to substitute technologies is fully implemented. So that I'm concerned about. I see that the level of CAPEX in energy companies is not just going down too fast, is that at the same time it is going down into things in the areas in which there are the higher levels of bottlenecks, whilst these energy companies in order to give— and I go back to the ESG situation— to give an image of green energy, etc., the part in which they're increasing investment is not enough to offset the negative impact that can be created by a CapEx slump in the energy sector.
I'm very, very concerned about being too ideological and too quick to say I thought that the IEA message of no need for more capital expenditure in oil and gas was not just empirically wrong, But extremely dangerous.
Erik Townsend: I want to move on now to another trend that I think is going to be important, which is the market needs to come to terms with digital currency. And, you know, back a few years ago when crypto was first getting popular, I used to tell people, I said, look, if you really love this digital currency stuff, just wait till central banks get their hands on this technology, because when they do, they're not going to have the same goals that Satoshi had. And the prediction I made almost 10 years ago now— I'm not, not that quite that long, maybe 8 years ago— was I said what began as a libertarian pipe dream is going to end as an Orwellian nightmare when central banks completely re-engineer money itself using digital currency technology. I guess I'm the only one who's, who's really convinced that, that that's the risk.
What do you think of that? And more importantly, you know, that's just my take, broader spectrum, where's this whole thing headed? Started with crypto, now CBDCs are coming in. Where are we headed with digital currency?
Daniel Lacalle: I think your prediction 8 years ago was spot on. We cannot—
Erik Townsend: Nobody seems to be worried about the Orwellian nightmare though. I don't get it.
Daniel Lacalle: Well, you know, it's very interesting how naive investors can be and economists.
Erik Townsend: Oh, sorry.
Daniel Lacalle: Yeah, sorry, go ahead. It's, it's, it's very, very surprising how naive investors can be when you know, you know, you have the facts that central bank independence has all but gone out the window. Central bank independence doesn't exist. Central banks have maintained very aggressive expansionary policies in growth periods with record Record levels of employment because of political interference. Central banks have been maintaining financial repression at any cost in all types of economic environments, and you truly believe that central banks are going to implement a digital currency without any of the secondary negative effects?
That's that's being extremely naive.
The biggest risk of central bank digital currency, to start with, we already know, is that it's surveillance disguised as currency, is that you are giving all the power to central banks that have been at least questionable in their independence to know exactly what you pay, what you invest, what you save, which you're giving all the power to those central banks. Banks to wipe out your savings when they believe that savings are too high. You are giving them all the power to elevate money supply without the limiting factor and the brake that the credit mechanism implies in monetary policy.
Because today, the reason why we may still have a debate about why quantitative easing was not massively inflationary in is the entire difference, the entire reason why quantitative easing is not as inflationary as direct money printing Argentina style is because the mechanism of transmission of monetary policy is driven by demand of credit. And if credit demand doesn't go up, then that whole process is eliminating the risk of massive inflationary pressures in goods and services prices. Now, think for a second, if you eliminate the transmission mechanism and the intermediation in which demand works as a brake for the increase of supply of money, the limit is endless.
Central banks and governments can decide how and where to increase money supply. They can decide who gets, in a way, penalized for being a bad citizen, who gets some kind of a reward for being a good citizen. It's very dangerous to give entities that have proven not to be fully independent a further and higher control of the money supply. So those are important risks that we need to talk about. We can talk about the benefits. The benefits are obviously transparency, quicker access, but you don't need to have a central bank digital currency to achieve those benefits. So we need to discuss those important negatives.
And you mentioned one thing that I think is critical. The libertarian idea of a cryptocurrency might never be fully implemented. Because what we at the same time are allowing is a level of control of the monetary system of central banks and governments that every time that cryptocurrencies become not even a threat to the monetary system, but a mild headline, they can immediately implement measures to. To ban them, to put limits to their utilization, et cetera. But at the same time, the central bank of the major, especially the central banks of the major economies and governments do look at cryptocurrencies and think, hmm, what a great way to quote unquote improve the transmission mechanism of monetary When central banks say that a central bank digital currency will improve the mechanism of the transmission mechanism of monetary policy, what they're basically saying is that they will be able to generate more and more persistent inflation quicker and without any control.
Erik Townsend: Oh, and it's worse than that. I mean, as I described in my book 3 years ago, the central bankers haven't even begun to figure out how much opportunity this technology affords to create new super-duper powerful central banking tools that I, for one, do not advocate central bankers or anyone else having. But the technology has been invented, and once it's been invented, somebody usually ends up using it.
Daniel Lacalle: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: So, I want to actually react to something you said in the beginning of your response there, Daniel because to paraphrase, I think you said something like your biggest fear or the worst thing that could go wrong would be with all this digital currency technology would be governments getting a hold of it and using it in a way that has too much of a burden or impairs the individual rights to privacy of individuals and so forth. That's exactly what I used to think myself when I wrote my book. That's exactly what I said about this. I've changed my mind. I think that that's actually the second worst risk. I think the worst You know, governments, for all of their failures, they're big and bureaucratic and slow-moving, so they don't do damage all that quickly. They just do a lot of damage.
On the other hand, Silicon Valley, the industry that I came from, software, is already out of control with how much power it has over the world. Facebook literally affects the outcome of elections all over the world. You know, there is a problem with power and society and Silicon Valley having too much of it. And frankly, there are people that are smart enough to design systems of a whole new way for money to work that would be cool, that would be engaging, that would make people want to use it because it's simple and easy and it's just drag-and-drop simplicity on your phone or tablet or whatever. And what you don't really realize, because it's kind of hidden underneath the, the veneer, is guess what? Actually, Silicon Valley is engineering a way to really create A power structure for the designers of those currency systems, which gives them the power of a government themselves. I think that— and the thing is, unlike the government central bank digital currency thing, they're gonna screw it up for the first 10 years, 'cause they screw everything up for 10 years, 'cause they're governments.
The Silicon Valley boys know what they're doing. They know how to do damage.
Daniel Lacalle: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And I think it's a much bigger risk. Libra got shut down, but it's trying to make a comeback. back. There will be more. I think a Silicon Valley digital currency that tries to somehow kind of win public support and take over the world is a very real risk. And, uh, I, I don't think it could be stopped once it got to a certain point.
Daniel Lacalle: That is a great point that I actually had not thought about, because a central bank digital currency controlled by governments, be it because people understand that there's no real independence of the central bank or because it's even widely known, will always have a certain level of suspicion from citizens. Completely agree with that. That is truly a great point. However, a very easy-to-use tool in a mobile phone that is cool and at the same time attracts a younger audience, et cetera, that is a much more, at the same time, attractive, but also dangerous proposition if badly used. So I actually kind of agree that that could be an important risk. I think that if I may, as we think about this subject, look at a sort of devil's advocate way, I would think that right now technology giants, depend too much on central bank action and on central bank loose monetary policy to destroy the power of central banks and their monetary policy.
Erik Townsend: Daniel, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, I want to talk about your YouTube channel, which is Daniel Lacalle, or if you're an English speaker, Daniel Lacalle. I guess, does it automatically sense which way you pronounce it and speak to you in English or Spanish? Do you have that feature?
Daniel Lacalle: Well, if you say it, it immediately finds me. I don't think it's— even if you misspell it, you will find it quite easily. And there's 2 channels, one in Spanish and one in English. Daniel Lacalle in English is the name of the English channel to make it simple and easy. And that's where you're going to find all of my videos with my comments about the economy, conversations with different people. People and the latest conferences that I give.
Erik Townsend: Well, we'll look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Looking for exposure to rising silver and gold prices? AbraSilver Resource Corporation, ticker ABRA on the TSX Venture Exchange and ABBRF in the United States, is rapidly emerging as one of the premier silver and gold-focused exploration companies. AbraSilver has an advanced-stage project with a large resource base of over 140 million ounces on a silver-equivalent basis and continues to announce several very high-grade silver and gold drill With more results still pending. AbraSilver is very well funded with a strong shareholder base and excellent exploration upside potential. You can find a link to the latest press release in the Research Roundup email. Visit abrasilver.com for more information. That's abrasilver.com for more information on this silver and gold exploration stock.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Daniel back on the show. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, my thinking about inflation has evolved in the following way as a result of the series of interviews that we've done with Daniel and a lot of other guests. The question that was on my mind is, okay, are we looking at a coming impending Are we trending secular inflation? Big deal inflation, like late 1960s, early 1970s. Are we going through that again? And I wanted to ask the people that are smarter than I am in the macro world that. I've now asked a lot of really smart people that.
My conclusion is yes, secular inflation is certainly my base case. Everybody gets something wrong. Maybe I'll get this one wrong. I really think it is a major decadal, you know, we're headed for another 1970s. worth of inflation. Question is, in the 1970s, that stagflation was a major economic dislocation event that changed the world. It completely changed everything. Daniel's saying in this interview, yeah, don't see that happening again. This inflation's not gonna be the problematic kind.
Okay, I'm not smart enough to know who's right, but I am smart enough to know that that's the operative question.
We don't know for sure that there's gonna be a secular inflation, but that's my base case. That's what I'm banking on. That's what I'm betting on. Now, The question is, is it ever going to run away to the point where it's out of control and we get into a late 1970s pre-Paul Volcker situation where everybody's actually starting to fear hyperinflation? Are we really going to have a risk of that? Or is the underlying deflationary backdrop that started before all of this enough to offset it, as Daniel's suggesting? Logically, that makes plenty of sense, Patrick. But guess what? Take a look at your history of all the major inflation throughout history, including the Weimar inflation, the hyperinflation in the Weimar Republic, those all were preceded by whiffs of very strong deflation just before the major inflation took off as a result of, drum roll please, excessive policy reaction from the government to the deflationary backdrop that existed at the time.
We do have the ingredients in place for a major runaway inflation.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I'm not smart enough to know whether that runaway risk is a real risk or just me reading too much Zero Hedge. So I'm going to find out by asking lots more smart people in coming weeks.
Erik Townsend: Right now, though, let's move on to the postgame chart deck, which this week is titled Post FOMC Postmortem. Registered users, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email in your inbox, that means you haven't yet signed up for a completely free account at MacroVoices.com, which you can do by going to our homepage and clicking the red button that says, looking for the downloads. Patrick, we're looking on page 2 here at the S&P continuous chart with the 50-day moving average under it. What's going on?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, we were in the last couple weeks and going into the FOMC in the quad witch and gamma pin period where volatility is compressed and we had these average 20-day S&P point ranges for high lows. And really things were quiet. And one of the themes was that in the post-Quad witching roll-off that the volatility would return. The question we were trying to ask though, would that volatility be some big move to the downside or simply finally a market that's unpinned to continue a trend higher?
And what's interesting is that we started that Friday with a quick drop drop that followed the textbook drops that we have seen in the last 6 months, which is it consolidates down to an average point, in this case the 50-day moving average, which was also about a 50% retracement of, of the prior rally, immediately found support. Buy-on-dip traders came back and immediately punched it back to 52-week highs. And so we have, uh, the prevailing uptrend still quite intact And the big question right now is, are we about to see that S&P 500 punching that 4,300 or 4,400 on the upside and finally get another kind of 5% kick to the upside
Patrick Ceresna: on the S&P?
And while the S&P is doing that, really, I think the story is actually when looking under the hood in terms of what is driving this. And so it's on page 3 that I have that NASDAQ 100 chart. And while the S&P S&P is toying with breaking to a 52-week new high. What we can see here is that the NASDAQ has broken a 52-week high and it's been staying up there over a week now as we see relative strength in the NASDAQ.
And what's interesting about that is that where is that relative strength coming from within the NASDAQ? And that's in the FAANG stocks. And so when looking at page 4, we can see that while the FAANG stocks during that entire higher since the start of the year essentially have been materially underperforming. And while the cyclicals and financials have been roaring higher, almost all of those FAANG stocks, everything from Apple to Amazon to, to Microsoft, have just been far more range-bound and, and chopping around. But what's really interesting in the last month is that we have seen these FAANG stocks roaring, using this FAANG index futures, up about 17% percent in the last month and been the relative strength outperformer amongst the sectors. And that, that really is an interesting change of events because ever since the reflation trade kicked in back in November, where almost all of the performance has been— at least outperformance has been in being long financials and long cyclicals and long value.
And what we really seen is that in the post-FOMC FOMC period when we saw the yield curve get hammered and yields getting pressed down and a lot of these commodity markets turning over. Suddenly, just like Harley Bassman was talking about these FAANG stocks being like 70-year duration bonds, now when we see yields coming back down, it seems that there's rotation or sector rotation back into these kind of growth names. And, and this is the— this is one of the big questions to ask is, are we seeing this rotation now going to be a sustained new trend, or was it just these oversold conditions and suddenly this, like, an elastic that's been stretched too far? This is just like a reactionary snapback, or is this a bigger trend? And I think that's such a big puzzle piece to solve here in the coming weeks.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, we look a lot at the gold charts. Let's take a look more broadly at metals and mining, not just precious metals, but all metals mining. That's represented by the XME ETF on page 5.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so this is where I really wanted to point out that what was working during this reflation trade and, and the— where the big question mark is, is that you can see that since November, this metal mining ETF has been just on a tear, up pretty much 100% since November. And really, you can see in the post-FOMC was the first legitimate sell-off that we had in a while. And similar to sell-offs that we saw in January and in March, almost immediately they got bought on dip and they quickly rallied back. And I think one of the biggest things that I'm watching into next week is that, was this a more meaningful change in trend or was this a big buy on dip? And I don't know if I'm ready to stick my neck out definitively and make a bold call here, but it's really up to the bulls here to quickly recover this back up toward their highs to keep it going.
A failure and continued consolidation in this space in the coming weeks will really start to solidify that some kind of bigger sector rotation has really gotten underway.
And when we look at page 6 where I have the financials ETF, the XLF ETF, you can see the reaction was the same. The first initial highs on both the financials and on the metals and mining tightening all came on those really high CPI prints. But really when the FOMC took their hawkish tilt was where they all broke badly. And whether this is just a short-term noise and an overreaction or whether it's a change in trend is 100% the question I'm trying to solve.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm gonna give you my answer to that, which obviously is totally opinion and could be wrong. But as I look at almost all of these charts, whichever page, I'll just look at page 6 'cause it's in front of me right Right now. They all look the same to me. What I see is to the left of June 1st, I see a trend that's driven by the fact that most of the major governments around the world are in over their heads in a money printing experiment that is a no way out situation ultimately, but we're a long way from the final endgame. And then I see for the last few weeks, a handful of people that were stupid enough to think that when they said they might tighten, that they actually They meant it this time. And it actually took the market down for a good whole couple of weeks before people came to their senses and realized that that's crazy and governments are gonna continue to recklessly print and spend beyond their means, just like they always have, which means that this reflation trade is gonna continue.
So if the reflation trade just ended because of the FOMC statement, I'm gonna go double, triple, quadruple out on my— out on a limb here and just say I'll be super duper wrong. If it turns out that what really happened is the reflation trade is over because central bankers turned responsible and intend to stay that way. I don't buy that one.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what? I certainly won't rule that out, but I'm going to read the tape and see whether or not the price will be confirming your view. But let's move on to the dollar index on page 7, because I really wanted to visualize what we talked about in the market wrap at the beginning of the show.
I mean, what we're really showing here is that since the start of that COVID period back in March 2020, there's been more or less an incredibly pronounced downtrend in the dollar. The dollar bear has really kind of very distinctly worked its way lower till the start of the year. But really, the last 6 months of 2021 has been far more of a sideways trade range rather than a downtrend.
And this is why I think the dollar is going to give a big tell here. I mean, you were right that, that kind of 89 to 94 zone is sort of one big trade range. And we've seen the highs and lows within there. And we're pretty much right in the dead center of that range. But will, will the dollar be able to muster up a more pronounced breakout out of this sideways trade range is one of the kind of big puzzle pieces to solve into the back half of the year.
Erik Townsend: Let's take a look at gold on page 8.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, really all I wanted to point out on gold here was just how distinct of a drop that was that happened last week. And really, while, you know, a lot of people are getting nervous about the gold trade very quickly, just on one quick bad break, but I think it's incredibly premature to be defining the next big trend move after that reaction.
I think one of the key things I'm going to be watching for—I think gold can easily bounce to like 18.25 to 18.50 on a reaction—but will there be a sustained buy on dip that develops here on gold, or does this turn into a distribution cycle that goes and retests those March and April lows? I think that the tell will come once we get a bounce, and we'll see how how the bulls behave on the on the.
Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, the technical analysis is the way to watch this. But if you want my gut feeling, I say gold goes down, down, down, down, down until people who are not able to see the big picture start to see the picture, come to their senses, and realize that gold needs to go up, up, up, up, up, up, up. Not everybody, including really smart people who are good at details, understand big pictures. And I don't think most people get it.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: But I really, really, really think that this is one of the best secular trades of our lifetimes, Patrick. The central bankers are gonna make gold worth more and people are gonna get, I think, spooked out in the meantime thinking it's worth less. And that's just a great buying opportunity. So I'm crossing my fingers for lower numbers.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil on page 9. The one thing that I really wanted to highlight, 'cause we're gonna put up a chart here on copper and we're gonna put a chart up on lumber and even, I don't have charts up here, If you look at the grains or right across entire commodity complex, we basically see crude oil still very distinctly in this bull trend higher, and it's an uninterrupted, very clear bull trend that that remains in place.
But other than the little quick pop we've seen on RBOB gasoline that joined the crude oil party on the upside, we really have seen the rest of the commodity complex correcting on the downside. Side. And I asked the question, I mean, can crude oil, first of all, just kind of march to the beat of its own drum and really not play along with the whole commodity complex? Or is crude oil just delaying on this? I mean, at this stage, the trend very distinctly points toward higher crude oil prices, but that divergence from the rest of the commodity complex leaves a big question as to what's next here. And I think So I think that on the short term, I'll be watching whether or not the bulls can sustain these higher highs in crude oil in the coming days.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to copper futures. I've been thinking about this one a lot. You know, the macro argument for why copper keeps going much higher is really strong, but boy, the argument for look how far it's already come, you know, new money buying new longs now, kind of hard to justify, but I want to. What do you think?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is the interesting thing. Like the high of copper pretty much came in on that really hot CPI print. Broke really badly on the FOMC. Now, the one thing that we can definitively say about copper is when it was near its highs, it was single-handedly the most consensus trade out there. I mean, finding anyone that was making a bearish copper argument, it was very, very hard to find anyone that would stick their neck out there. But what we really have seen now is a shift in the trend where typically you would see a buy on dip on copper, which should have came around $4.50, That broke quite definitively on the downside.
Now, I don't want to already suggest that copper is going to do something outright bearish, but often these commodity cycles can last many, many months. And if we've seen kind of peak sentiment and peak short-term copper prices, the question here is, are we seeing this not as a multi-week correction but a multi-month correction? And if that's the case, will we temporarily rarely see copper back under $4 to create another good buying opportunity down the road. So, you know, this again just shows how many of these copper plays, including, you know, the copper has been pressured, uh, lower by China, at least, uh, verbally, you know, them talking about trying to, to bring these commodity prices back under control. It'll be interesting to see whether that will end up being a key high there.
And another example of that is in lumber prices on page You know, lumber was one of the most inflationary forces out there back throughout the first and going into the second quarter of the year. But after lumber just going parabolic to $1,700 on the upside, I mean, this is as clear of a breakdown of that bull trend as you're going to get. I mean, we had a 50% wipeout in lumber prices in just 2 months off of those peak levels. And that just kind of shows just how divergent oil is from the rest of the commodity complex. Complex that has really already been distributing. And it'll be really interesting to see, uh, what the knock-on effects of, of this kind of a shift are.
The one thing that I'm going to be watching for for sure is if there— if for whatever reason, if oil's given a catalyst to begin a correction, that could definitively turn the commodity index futures. Because when you look at something like the Bloomberg Commodity Index, it's so heavily weighted into the energy that the uptrend in those indices has been very distinctly higher, largely because oil's holding up. And this is why I think oil is going to be such an important market to watch here in the coming weeks.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I don't mind admitting that where Treasury yields are headed has been a mystery to me. I don't believe in the meltdown scenario some people fear, but I don't know either. What do you think? Where are we headed? Not just, you know, next week, but long-term?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's interesting because the inflation theme has been so dominant. And while there's no denying it, I'm not I'm not trying to say that I'm against the inflation storyline, but what is interesting is is how bonds no longer seem to be nervous about it. I mean, I've heard a number of people, whether on Twitter or some really smart guests, have been talking about the decoupling of of yields from inflation, and obviously that's going to influence gold because of real yields. But one thing for sure is that we're now three plus months into. Yields just consolidating and backfilling on the downside. And this has been doing it through some of the hottest inflation print numbers that we have seen in, in years. And I, I continue to think it's really interesting, and particularly on the hawkish tilt. If we go back to, uh, or go to page 13 when we're looking at the 5s-30s yield spread, you can really see— I mean, we wiped out 6 months of steepening on this And what's
interesting is you would think that we would at least get some sort of a meaningful reaction bullishly on the upside, and we find ourselves still trading very close to the bottom end of this range. And it really shows that the bond market is saying something different is happening here. And I just don't want to ignore this. I mean, definitely the bond market is taking the Fed a little more seriously than a lot of people who are trying to already say that it was just noise.
Erik Townsend: And listeners, don't forget, if you enjoy Patrick's chart decks, you don't have to wait for MacroVoices Thursday night. You can sign up for a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading, and get a webinar with Patrick every single morning. You'll find information on page 14 or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants And by AbraSilver Resource Corporation, a premier emerging silver and gold exploration company, ticker ABRA on TSX Venture and ABBRF in the United States.
Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an article The Unintended Consequences of Punishing Big Oil, and a link to a Variant Perception article on Capital Gains Tax: Announcement Effects and Sector Rotation. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets, and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from our generous listeners. From BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. All-Star Brent Johnson. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on. MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Philip Verleger — Energy economist (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 276 was recorded on June 17th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com, the world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in In escrow.
Energy economist Dr. Phil Verleger debuts as this week's feature interview guest. Our past crude oil specials have focused on oil production, rig and frac spread counts, and comparative inventory. Dr. Verleger is a formally trained economist, not an oil man, so he'll give us a completely different perspective on the economics of the energy industry, including his views on the coming secular inflation. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will examine the sucker punch the reflation trade just took from the Federal Reserve. So if you're wondering what the heck happened to that beautiful gold rally that looked so promising just a few days ago, stay tuned for the postgame segment when we'll tackle that question in full detail.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, as Erik said, we're dedicating the entire postgame segment to the hawkish Fed surprise. But for the sake of guiding the rest of the market wrap, let's start with a high-level summary before we even dive into the stock market. So Erik, what the hell
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the Federal Reserve had one of their famous meetings, and as often happens, there was a knee-jerk response in markets. It seems like a lot of things reversed, and it appears at the first glance as though the inflation trade may be reversing suddenly. I doubt it. I am fading this move, and frankly, I haven't even read the full FOMC statement. The reason is the market tends to freak out on these things. Did they do something like, I don't know, start selling assets to reduce their balance sheet?
Patrick Ceresna: No.
Erik Townsend: balance sheet and start cleaning up the mess they've been making for the last decade? No, of course not. All that they did was to kind of allude that maybe they would be a little bit more hawkish and think about raising rates a little bit sooner rather than later.
That's really not that big of a deal. And all of a sudden the world is panicking. If there can be any question left, Patrick, does anybody still believe that this market is not being supported almost entirely by monetary policy? So, you know, what happens with Fed policy and particularly, I think, how the political process, especially in the next presidential election cycle comes back and affects all of that. Well, that's going to be really interesting to watch. What matters now, Patrick, is not the viciousness of that knee-jerk move down, but what happens next. It's a question of whether it's just going to all be shrugged off and we move higher tomorrow, or if this is actually going to change the direction of the market. One day is not a new trend. We need to wait and see what happens.
Put another way, today was a big so what. The what matters part is what comes next. Either all of these things that suddenly turn down retrace back to the upside or they move to new lows in coming days. That's what we need to keep our eyes on.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on that S&P 500 because while the volatility has been in the inner markets on everything— currencies, commodities, and bonds— the S&P 500 has not been volatile at all. I mean, we remain pinned in a very tight range going into the quad witching. What's your take on the S&P here?
Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, you know, considering a lot of other parts of the market are freaking out and panicking, the S&P didn't even take out the 34-day moving average. No big deal. So I don't think that there's really any reason to think that the rally is in danger. It's probably a buyable dip. Now, that doesn't change my opinion that stocks are very badly overvalued here, but so far as I can tell, the trend is set to continue.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, then we definitely have to touch on the dollar index because after almost a month of trading along that 89.90 support of the 5-year lows, We have a pretty distinct US dollar uptick. I mean, we are now trading very close to the 92 handle on the dollar index, up almost 2 full handles since the FOMC.
Do you think that's a big turning point in the dollar or is it just noise?
Erik Townsend: Well, obviously it's a huge event. The thing is, it's so obviously the most directly related thing to the FOMC, which is what everybody's freaking out about. Is it the same thing? It doesn't matter that we had a knee-jerk move in reaction to FOMC. The question is, does the market shrug it off? Or do we push to even higher highs on the dollar index?
That we need to keep paying attention to. It's really gonna be the same thing for every asset class almost this week in terms of, you know, the big question is, is this all just a panic and a knee-jerk and it's all gonna be shrugged off or is it gonna stick? I'm leaning towards it gets shrugged off.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on crude oil 'cause I wanted your take on this. We traded up to $73 around the FOMC meeting period and we reversed. I mean, it's not exactly a crazy reversal, but we're almost back at $70 on the downside. What do you take of the little short-term reversal on crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, just as we predicted here on MacroVoices, we've been in a face-ripping rally. I think that we've been through our consolidation period at the halfway point of the rally. We're now in the second big up leg of the rally. And what I said in my previous predictions was I predicted that by Labor Day we ought to see a peak price between $80 and $92. Well, Patrick, right now we've come down because of the Fed, but before that we were almost to $75 and it's only the middle of June.
So if anything, I would say the rally has moved further, faster than even I expected. And I now start to think about the higher end of my, my target zone toward $90 instead of $80 as being the more likely possibility by the end of summer, because I think the fundamentals are in place for the rally to continue through the end of the summer.
Now, I've also had this overwhelmingly strong hunch that there's a reason that demand is going to continue to be strong through the second half of '21. You know something, Patrick, as an engineer, I hate I don't like hunches. I like data. I like logical deductive reasoning. And I haven't been able to put my finger on this. Phil Verleger gave me that light bulb moment in this week's interview. So try to catch it yourself. See if you pick up where the light bulb went off for me in this week's feature interview. In case you miss it, I'll tell you in the postgame segment.
The Fed news definitely made a dent, took us back down to the 13-day moving average. That's a very, very typical technical pattern in the crude oil market. When you get a knee-jerk move, you go to the lowest of the 3 short-term moving averages. That's the 5, 8, and 13-day moving averages. The lowest one is the 13. That's exactly what got tested today on the freakout reaction to the Fed. I expect we're probably going to trade back up towards $75 within the next week, probably. I don't think this is going to last. If it does last, I don't think it's going to derail the long-term rally. So I added to my long positions in time spreads in the crude oil market this week, and I will continue to add if there is further weakness.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, we gotta touch on gold because, I mean, gold has been for the— since April in a beautiful uptrend. It's been holding most consolidations, but in this post-Fed period, we wiped out about $100 to the downside in about 24 hours as we're trading around $1,780 at the time of recording here. Do you think this is a major reversal in your mind on gold?
Erik Townsend: I think this is a very typical gold market panic attack freakout and buying opportunity. What's going on here is, you know, the Fed is showing They're showing one very small sign of maybe actually exercising a little bit of responsibility and trying to get their balance sheet under control. And people are freaking out. I have absolute confidence in the Federal Reserve and the people running it to resume their prior pattern of fiscal irresponsibility on an ongoing basis. And that will only help to cause gold to retrace and move much higher. For the moment though, as it looks like they might actually, you know, do their job and act like grownups at the Federal Reserve, gold is freaking out because gold is It's the anti-Federal Reserve. So, I think this is a buying opportunity, nothing more, Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, we have to talk about the 10-year yield because certainly very volatile in the post-Fed period, almost 10 basis points higher on the first reaction and gave it all back very quickly. What's your take on the 10-year?
Erik Townsend: Well, you're right, Patrick. We definitely have to talk about the 10-year, but frankly, it's too important to cram into the minute and a half that we have here in the market wrap. I cheated. I looked ahead at the slide deck. I want to talk to this when we get to your slides. So, let's save this conversation for the market wrap.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Phil Verleger. Now, Erik, why did we invite Phil on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: I was really looking forward to this one. You know, we've done oil specials before with petroleum geologists and people who are expert in oil production and so forth. Phil is an economist, but he's an economist who has focused on energy and oil markets for like 50 years. And he writes what are probably some of the most respected research reports on oil economics. Anywhere. So he's a super highly respected guy. I've been looking forward to getting him on the show because what I noticed the last time we had Art Berman on— the reason I think I disagreed a little bit with Art is he was driving his price outlook primarily by those oil fundamentals, things like comparative inventory that have been very reliable in the past. I think this is a macroeconomic inflation-driven rally as much as it is a resumption of demand-driven rally. And so I I really wanted to talk to an oil guy who's also a macroeconomics guy.
You can't do better than Phil Verleger in terms of that.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Phil is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy is live now at smartermarketspod.com, and you can look for another terrific Terrific interview every Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Phil Verleger, founder of PK Verleger LLC and also editor And author of Notes at the Margin. Phil, I've really been looking forward to getting you on the show because you have been analyzing the oil business literally for 50, 5-0, years. So you're a veteran of this business. Let's start with the really big picture of, hey, there are people telling us that this entire industry is going away. There are people that have been saying for decades, of course, there's problems with fossil fuels, but now we've actually gotten to the point where the IEA, the International Energy Association, which is supposed to be our Their own industry body to promote this industry is telling the world that the entire industry needs to forever stop looking for new oil. Just keep the wells we've got and then we're going to shut— I guess the idea is suicide, shut down the entire industry and make it go away in favor of something else.
I do think, Phil, we've got to get eventually off of fossil fuels, but I don't think it's going to go down the way a lot of people seem to be talking. How do you assess this?
Philip Verleger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Is the industry really coming to a slow-motion end, or what's happening here?
Philip Verleger: No, the industry— well, the industry is probably past its peak. I don't think we will see oil consumption ever get back to the levels we saw, say, in 2019. The International Energy Agency is an intergovernmental organization that Henry Kissinger formed. And I actually, I was working at the Council of Economic Advisers under Jerry Ford. When it was formed. So it was designed to deal with energy shocks. And what they have done is been following the oil market and energy markets for 50 years.
They came out with this net zero 2050 forecast. I don't know why. And I've done a lot of forecasts. And one of the things I was taught when I started looking at economics after doing my economics degree was if you're going to forecast, forecast often. Well, this is this is just kind of a one-time forecast, which is a mistake. The other thing we always teach students is never put a number and and a date on the same piece of paper, and they really blew it here. Now, if you read through it in the back, they also have a scenario where we get to net zero maybe by twenty twenty one hundred, which is probably more likely. But it's a disconcerting. Projection. It has knocked people off.
It has really affected industry. I think it's going to make it harder to raise capital when capital is going to be needed. And it's just wrong. Oil use is going to go down. It won't go down as rapidly as they think it will. The economic assumptions they have in it are probably wrong because you can't forecast out 30 years with any accuracy.
And there's probably going to be a good deal more carbon capture because if oil prices keep going up as they are right now, it will become more and more profitable to sequester oil the way Occidental Petroleum wants to do in the ground. That's what we've been doing with enhanced oil recovery for as long as I've been around.
And so, what the IEA said is a distraction, I guess, is the way I say it, a real distraction.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk then about what should happen and what's likely to happen, because the way I see this, Phil, is there's so much pressure, and I think it's very counterproductive, frankly. ESG is a good thing in the sense of making the world a better place. You know, environment, we only got one planet, we gotta take care of it. I'm all for that. But punishing extractive industries and disfavoring them and treating them as bad guys just because they're involved in doing something which really is the only known way of meeting the planet's energy needs right now until we, you know, come up with better ways, with newer ways of doing it.
It seems to me, at least my prediction of what's gonna happen here, is we are disfavoring investment in this industry so much because of the ESG pressure that I think what eventually happens is we get to a crunch. Yes, the industry is slowly, very slowly going away. Fossil fuels are being replaced slowly. But what is happening much more quickly is decline of existing productive assets that are not being replaced with new production because the investment didn't happen. So where a lot of people see a price crash at the end of oil, I think the final price crunch to the final all-time high actually comes as the industry is winding down in the grand scheme of things because the investment's not there. And that's very much non-consensus. What do you think? Am I onto something or am I crazy to think that?
Philip Verleger: Your scenario is more realistic than the scenario that's been put forward by the IEA.
Erik Townsend: Well, that's not saying much.
Philip Verleger: Well, no, it's, again, I think you're onto something. What is gonna happen is investment by companies that are domiciled in the EU, in the United States, and Canada is gonna stop. The arrival of Gary Gensler at the SEC is going to put a lot of pressure on companies listed on US stock exchange. And having spent some time with Gensler during the Obama administration, when he was running the CFTC, he is a very tough hombre, and probably is the best chairman of the SEC since Arthur Levitt. So, I mean, he's going to make these companies disclose.
Investors are going to move away. That doesn't that doesn't mean that Equinor in Norway isn't going to keep investing. Saudi Arabia will invest. The Russians will invest some, and so that there will be oil production. And you know that if you come back to your scenario, so we're going to be importing more and more oil, or a higher percentage of the oil we're we're using, and those countries will have more and more monopoly power, and they'll try to use.
The one question in this whole scenario is China. China sits out there, and if they decide they want to depress commodity prices, they have the power to do it. They've just done it with copper and some aluminum. So it's— yeah, I think you're right. I think that as— and those countries are going to look and say, well, we've got one last chance to get some money, and they'll try to do it. Now, the risk is as the US companies die, and the European companies die, and And let me be clear, BP and Shell and Total are not going to become new energy companies.
Economic history shows that companies like Kodak that are really good in film die. So, what'll happen is the consuming countries will have less and less of an incentive to use oil, because their companies at home aren't using it. So, that will then mean that there's an accelerated pressure to get off oil. But yes, you're absolutely right. I mean, the price of oil is going to— is likely to go up as we get off oil.
Erik Townsend: Phil, we usually focus on macroeconomic subjects here on MacroVoices, such as secular inflation. And I'm very much convinced that we're at the beginning of what I think could be an epic secular inflation. So as I prepare for an interview with you, I got to get out of macro mode into energy mode. I look at your newsletter. What's the first thing you're writing about? It's inflation. So it's— I think great minds think alike. Tell me your view.
Why are you You got inflation on your mind. I think we're potentially looking at a major secular event over the next decade. Is that what you're thinking about, or are you just thinking about a whiff of inflation here?
Philip Verleger: I'm worried about a major secular inflation. Now, I'm an economist. I've spent a lot of time focused on oil, but I started out working at Data Resources, which was the first timesharing economic forecasting firm. And that was in 1971. So, I lived through the inflation of the '70s. I spent 4 years at the US Treasury working for the Assistant Secretary for Economic Policy and the Secretary of Treasury when Paul Volcker came in. And so, I have seen inflation.
And if you want to understand oil, you want to understand any commodity, you have to start by understanding the economy. So, I pulled off my shelf a 1982 book by Barry Bosworth and Bob Lawrence, called Commodity Prices and the New Inflation. And it was published by Brookings. And it looked at the '70s.
And they go back to the late '60s. What happened then? People didn't invest in the capacity to make copper. They didn't invest in the capacity to make steel and so on. And guess what? We had commodity shortages and we had a commodity price run-up. History doesn't repeat, but it rhymes. And so, So, I started looking at that.
Then to add to that, there is a paper by Andrew Haldane, who is the chief economist at the Bank of England, a very smart economist and everything. And he laid out a case for more inflation because one, the labor force seems to be down. We don't know why, but the number— I mean, you talk about macro views, the number of workers coming back, we're short.
And what's happening? Well, people are trying to offer bonuses to get people to come back to restaurants. In Pittsburgh, they found a great solution. They paid— started paying restaurant workers $15 an hour. They got plenty of people. So, we're going to get some wage push inflation.
And you take that and you start adding that, you've got shortages, a lumber shortage, lumber prices have come down, but they're still 70%, 80% above a year ago. You look at other— copper and so on, And then you have this ESG, all the using all this copper and so on in, in the electric cars and so on and the chips. We have a problem. And yes, inflation is gonna be a problem unless the Fed raises rates and squeezes the economy the way Volcker did in 1981.
Guess what? We have inflation and it's gonna be around for a while.
Erik Townsend: Phil, the thing that really concerns me about this coming secular inflation, and frankly, this is my biggest concern about all financial markets, I don't think there's any replacement for experience in any field. And frankly, the number of guys, Phil, like yourself, who were working in this business as adults in the late 1960s and remember the onset of secular inflation and everybody saying it's transitory, don't worry about it. Maybe back then they called it transient because they hadn't invented transitory yet. I'm not sure. But, you know, it was no big deal and nobody's worried. And then come the 1970s and guess what? It's a big deal.
Philip Verleger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I don't think that the number of people that are still working in the industry who were working in the industry in the late 1960s when you would need to in order to have that experience, I don't think that number of people is more than a couple hundred guys. What could go wrong here? Because you've been through this when back in the '60s nobody had seen inflation for 50 years. What happens when a secular inflation that— and you've clearly got the backdrop right now. CNBC and Bloomberg, they tell us it's transitory. Just listen to Janet Yellen. Everything's fine. Fine. What could go wrong, Phil, if it turns out, number one, that it's not transitory, but number two, that every single one of the professional oil traders in the universe was in diapers the last time this happened and has never been through it and doesn't know what to make of it?
Philip Verleger: Well, it's not just oil traders. It's—
Erik Townsend: I said the whole financial world.
Philip Verleger: The whole financial— it's just all these guys. A lot of— I mean, a lot of Weren't even around. Their parents were in grade school. It's disconcerting. Jeffrey Garten's got a great book that's coming out, 3 Days at Camp David.
And I'll give him a plug because I have a piece in the International Economy that looks at it. August 15th, 1971, this August, it'll be 50 years. President Nixon took people up there. He took George Shultz. He took the Secretary of Treasury, John Connally. He took Pete Peterson. And a few others up. And on the Sunday, August 15th, he announced a price freeze, 90-day price freeze.
And he also broke the connection between the dollar and gold. And I think it was very important. I spent a number of years at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, because had we not done that, we would have had a run on the dollar. We would probably have had a major recession, because you have to defend the dollar And you have, you know, all the kinds of effects that my teacher Charlie Kindleberger talked about in his books, Manias, Panics, and Crashes, and his other books on economic history.
So that's a hugely important event. One of the outcomes of that event was price controls on oil, which they kept and stayed and became worse and more pernicious, and caused all sorts of distortions. And one of the reasons that the energy sector. Gets treated badly in policy sites, the IEA, same thing, is nobody with experience in energy is allowed to be an energy policymaker.
One little anecdote, Claude Brinegar was the Secretary of Transportation to Richard Nixon. He'd been an executive vice president at Unocal. So Nixon brought him in. He was there in '71, '73 when the price kept rising, but they'd very carefully said, you can't do anything on energy because Because nobody with energy or nobody from the big bad oil industry can can affect oil policy in the government, and so he joked because he and I and several people at Treasury—I think Mike Blumenthal was the secretary—met at the time, and when we were trying to get decontrol, Treasury in '79 really wanted decontrol of oil, get out of these Nixon, Ford, Carter programs to defend the dollar.
And Brinegar just joked that when he was in the cabinet meeting. Meaning, after the Yom Kippur War, he was the only member of the cabinet who knew that there were 42 gallons in a barrel. And that is the state of knowledge of energy policy officials.
I've just done— I'm gonna use it someplace— a table that looks at the background of energy secretaries versus Treasury secretaries. And what you see is, in the case of Treasury, you have people like Paulson, Henry Paulson, He headed Goldman Sachs. He knew about financial markets. He knew how all these things came. So when you had a crisis in 2008, he brought all the bankers in and he said, you're all taking TARP money because we don't want to identify which banks are bad. And they all did.
We have nothing like that in energy. It has never happened.
We come back to this, the IEA forecast. Well, the head of the IEA was the chief economist at OPEC before there. He has no experience in the thing. None of our energy secretaries. Ernie Moniz is a great nuclear physicist. He was really helpful in the Iran negotiations in the Obama administration. But he's not experienced in the energy side. He's gone to a lot of meetings. And the energy industry, and it comes back to your point, is treated, and particularly oil, like a stepchild.
We want academics or something like that to figure out oil policy. without knowing anything about it. And guess what? We get all the disasters we keep getting.
Erik Townsend: Phil, it really is amazing the way politicians just have no idea what's going on. The one that you mentioned, you know, not knowing how many gallons are in a barrel of oil. The one that is striking to me is the inability of politicians to have any cognizance that all crude oil is not fungible and created equal. Light sour and heavy sweet are 2 different things.
You can't— because we have lots of one in the Bakken doesn't mean we don't need any more of the other from the Middle East. And that concept is just too hard for Maxine Waters to process, no matter what you do. And I don't know how we move on beyond that. It's really an interesting world that we live in. Something I've noticed though, you know, you'd think is, okay, supposedly the petroleum industry, if not the whole energy industry, is supposed to come to an end. You'd think I thought that what I'd be hearing in pitches I'm getting in terms of investing in energy would be alternatives, the wind, the solar, the photovoltaics, all that stuff. I just listened to a pitch this morning for yet another carbon credit company. And what I'm noticing is, as the petroleum industry at least starts to wind down, it seems like both the carbon sequestration, but more so the carbon credits, are where the money is.
So So what do you make of this, and where is it all headed?
Philip Verleger: Well, OK, you put a great point in there. I'd like to, for just a second, go back. You're talking about light sweet crude, and then I'll go to the carbon credit. So when you ended it with Maxine Waters and light sweet crude, that caused a major part of the 2008 recession.
And nobody understands it. And it points to this very issue. Because what happened was in 19— sorry, not 19— in 2005, 2006, we started switching to ultra-low sulfur diesel fuel. The industry didn't have enough refining capacity, and the European— Europeans just barged ahead and did the same thing. So what happened is in 2008, when crude got to $130 a barrel, the refiners were all looking for light sweet crude, and they couldn't find it. And diesel prices were pulling crude up and up and up. Meantime, heavy crude, the Iranians had heavy crude sitting on ships and they were trying to sell it and nobody'd buy it. So, I mean, the failure to understand this contributed maybe half a percent, maybe a percentage point to the GDP decline in 2008. Mostly it was housing, but it was there.
Now, let me go to the— in terms of carbon credit, I I left teaching at Yale and went to Drexel Burnham and helped create the NYMEX contract in 1983. NYMEX crude contract. They had the heating oil contract. I think that this carbon trading is going to become a very big deal because the only way the world gets towards net zero in 2050— it's not going to get there, but it gets towards there— is with good sequestration.
Now, Occidental talks about putting in the ground. That works. Planting trees is not a, you know, that's a Ponzi scheme. But if you have devices that can take carbon out of the air, or other ways, as Exxon's talking about on the ship channel, that actually gets CO2 out and it puts it in the ground. And I can make a blockchain. And so you can sell it just the way you sell other things like Bitcoin on a blockchain. And that's meaningful. It's expensive right now. It's expensive. If they do more of it, I think they'll bring the cost down.
And so that comes back to saying, well, yeah, there are going to be all these different proposals to trade carbon. A lot of them are going to be Ponzi schemes. A few of them are really going to work. And the few that really work are going to take off. Somebody from Vitol said yesterday, I think at the FT conference, that they think that the carbon trading market will become bigger than the oil market.
And the oil market's huge.
So now, if that's the case, what happens is you've got a price of carbon, then I can buy carbon credits or I can sell carbon credits. And that then facilitates, that's the market facilitating the transition to net zero rather than somebody in Paris at the IEA saying, this is how you have to do it. It's a market system rather than the old Soviet command and control system. And we've seen the market system work since August 15th, '71. Reuters got invented after that, and we started getting the Reuters machines so we could trade currencies. It's going to be the same type of adjustment, and I think it'll come pretty quickly.
Erik Townsend: Now, Phil, you focus almost entirely on the petroleum industry, yet people who read Notes at the Margin are reading about China selling metals. What do metals have to do with the petroleum industry, and why is China selling them so interesting?
Philip Verleger: Well, the first thing you can say is the price of a commodity— you're trying to forecast the price of commodity is very difficult, because the price elasticity of demand is low, price elasticity of supply is low. So, you can have an equilibrium price, in case of oil, any place from $30 to $50 to $80 to $90.
Then when you add inventories, the problem becomes intractable, because if there are significant inventories, If there's a shortage of a commodity, and traders choose to buy more for storage, they push the price up a lot. Call it hoarding. If traders choose to unload their stocks, the prices come way down, the liquidation. And government stockpiles are the biggest random variable in this whole thing. The Chinese have a metal stockpile.
And if they start choosing to put some of the copper back in the market, they can send the price down a lot. Yeah. And they already have. There were rumors they were going to do this. They have huge oil inventories. They have over a billion barrels of oil.
And it's, you know, they have more oil inventories relative to consumption than the United States does. If they decide that the price is too high and the Chinese are really worried about inflation, they can start, A, telling people not to drive so much, but B, telling companies to use oil inventories or selling oil from their strategic stocks instead of buying it from OPEC. And that can alter the global supply-demand balance a lot for quite a while. So, I mean, it is a big deal, and the Chinese are much more willing to intervene in the market to get their way than the United States has been.
Erik Townsend: Phil, a lot of people are saying that, hey, it's all going to change any day now. They're going to lift the sanctions on Iran, and that It changes everything and the price goes shooting right back down to, I don't know what the number is 'cause I don't agree with them. But at the same time, I don't hear anybody really talking about the fact that, you know, a lot of Iranian oil really never came off the market. There's gray market leakage of that oil no matter what. How big of a deal is this really, Phil? I mean, people are acting like it's a big deal, but when it happens and they say, okay, you know, the Biden Administration has come to new terms, they've reinitiated the nuclear deal with Iran and there's no more sanctions on Iranian oil.
Philip Verleger: Right.
Erik Townsend: Is that a huge price shock that changes everything, or is that more of a, you know, already priced in, been there, done that, let's move on?
Philip Verleger: It all depends on what Saudi Arabia does. And it's, it's not production, it's how much oil Saudi Arabia sells into the market. They were willing to take an extra million barrels a day off the market. I forget exactly when, I think about just about the beginning of the year. And that really firmed up the market. Prince Abdulaziz is the most educated in economics of any of the Saudi oil ministers.
And he has his finger on the pulse of this thing. You know, back in 2019, when there was the attacks on the Saudi oil facilities, I thought we were going to see a big jump in the price. Well, the Saudis went And bought oil from Iraq to sell to their customers to make sure the price didn't jump.
I mean, one of the things he talks about is how Greenspan dealt with a stock market drop in the '80s. So I think the reentry of Iran, one, the volume won't come out as quickly, and two, the Saudis will try to adjust, as will other producers.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Philip Verleger: I mean, the more interesting indicator is what's happening with the UAE, because they're pushing this futures market, and they're really going to a totally market-oriented deal rather than— they've taken off their destination limits on where crude goes and so on. So they're really doing what the NYMEX did to crude in 1983. So I think that the Iraqis can't push a lot of oil out, although they evidently have maybe 60 million barrels of oil in storage they can sell.
And I think it's less of an event because people will react to balance it. So I'm not as convinced that it's a big deal. And I think the Iranians also have a habit of messing up some of these things just when the opportunity is right coming to them.
Erik Townsend: Phil, I'm hoping that you can fill me in because frankly, there is a big piece of this energy future story that doesn't add up for me. I hear the ESG story of, hey, fossil fuels, problem, carbon. I get it. We gotta solve that problem. Okay. I would think a logical, rational person would say, therefore, the way we're gonna get more energy is we're gonna do this, this, and this. And of course, there are discussions that are going on and there's activity going on in photovoltaics, in, you know, wind farms and so forth. But frankly, I mean, it pales in contrast to the amount of energy production that would be necessary to actually replace fossil fuels. So I get this whole— essentially the whole world government seems to be behind this idea of we gotta get rid of fossil fuels. We all seem to agree on that. Carbon is the enemy, but nobody seems that interested to me in finding viable alternatives.
We know that windmills don't work when the wind's not blowing. We know that photovoltaic Solar cells don't work at night. Now we do know that nuclear could be the solution, but there's a huge political opposition to nuclear. I think we need a nuclear renaissance. A lot of you know it's very hard to sell that. I talked to my friend Robert Friedland, who's very involved in this geothermal thing. He's saying if we could just get a breakthrough to a new level of geothermal drilling technology to where. we drill deeper into hotter rock than we know how to drill into now, we could solve the energy problems of the whole world forever. I don't hear very many people talking about realistic solutions such as deep geothermal or non-uranium-fueled nuclear, things that I think about. Nobody seems to focus on that, but they're very focused on getting rid of the carbon.
Am I missing something, Phil, or is nobody actually looking for the solution that replaces the petroleum?
Philip Verleger: People are looking all sorts of places.
Erik Townsend: But the focus of the investment industry is not, as far as I can see, on the hot prospects.
Philip Verleger: That's— well, not the focus of the investment industry is not on the hot prospects. We're not training the people. I mean, take the geothermal example. That's a— you know, I hadn't heard of that. It's a great idea. It would take a lot of engineers Look at the engineering schools. They're turning out software engineers. They're not turning out petroleum engineers who could easily do that kind of drilling. We're not investing there.
Turn to the nuclear industry. I think nuclear does need a restart. And Bill Gates has said it's a great idea. I think he's right. You ought to invest in it and so on. Nuclear engineering is the toughest engineering course in a college. Electrical engineering is hard. Chemical engineering is very hard. Nuclear is really hard. There aren't many. We're not training nuclear engineers. They've closed down the engineering nuclear engineering departments at many colleges.
Okay, so how do you go to a nuclear engineering business if you don't have the nuclear engineers? The answer is you don't. China is turning out a number of nuclear engineers. But now it turns out they have some problems with their technologies, and it takes years and years to build a nuclear plant.
I mean, if you know, if you look at the Georgia Power one, it's I think it's ten years behind. So nuclear doesn't nuclear is out. Geothermal, it's a great idea. We need the engineers. We don't you know we don't have the people to do this, and everybody misses this. And so. So, yeah, I'm with you. I don't know how we get there. And you come back to the oil industry. Well, the oil industry is— we're going to need it. But the trouble is, there aren't many people left.
I mean, they're— most— when I talk to younger students, you talk about— when I was teaching in Calgary, do you want to go into the petroleum industry? No. These are 30-year-old, 25-year-old people, engineering degrees, because the engineering— it's such a cyclical business. You take a job, they pay you a lot.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Philip Verleger: But then suddenly you're fired. You look at what happened after 2014.
So, the industry is eating its own children. And I'm not sure it's got the manpower to— man and woman power to keep going ahead. So, we got a big, big problem. That comes back to your original question, inflation. If we don't have the capacity to add, you get more inflation.
Erik Townsend: See, this is the part of this, Phil, which concerns me the most, and which I think most people What people don't get is it's about the natural resources of intellectual capital more than anything else. It might be possible to use thorium rather than uranium to have a nuclear renaissance that completely solves all of the energy problems for the world.
If that happens, it's most likely to be a Chinese company that does it because that's where they've got the engineering talent.
Philip Verleger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And Robert Friedland might be right that you could get to deep geothermal and solve all the energy problems of the whole world that way. But it's not gonna be US engineers that have this problem. Meanwhile, in the country that I was born in, we have the very best social media engineers that create Facebook for us.
Philip Verleger: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And you know what? That is making way more money in the short term than you'd ever make being in the energy business. But I think it ultimately, long-term, is going to put the country at a huge disadvantage and change our standing in the world completely, because we lost the engineering talent that we used to have in the United States. And it's—
Philip Verleger: I can't agree with you more. I mean—
Erik Townsend: I want you to disagree with me. I really badly disagree.
Philip Verleger: No, but— so I grew up in California. In a town that's La Cañada, that's right next to JPL. And I remember when Sputnik went up. I think I was 8 or 9 or 10. And suddenly, you know, I, I was really good at math and I could read, but I couldn't spell. Suddenly, the fact that I couldn't spell didn't make any difference because I was good in math. Everybody, they wanted engineers. And I mean, the push to get engineers and the push to get mathematicians and science people was just enormous. And it led all the way through to when I went to MIT to get my PhD.
I mean, there was a focus, we need these engineers, we need chemical engineers, we need aeronautical engineers, we need electrical engineers, we need nuclear engineers. And then suddenly, we stopped building the nuclear power plants. So, I have a nephew who has a nuclear engineering degree. What's he doing? He's working at Goldman Sachs trading We're writing programs to calculate option values.
I mean, we diverted all our talent to financial engineering, and we're gonna pay for it.
Erik Townsend: Unfortunately, I'm afraid that we're in violent agreement on that point. Phil, I want to move on though, because the oil traders in the audience will kill me if I had you on the show and I never even asked you for your outlook for the market. So we've been talking about a high-level big So, that's the big picture. Where do we go over the next 20 years? Let's talk about the next year or two. What do you see on the horizon? Because with your inflation outlook, maybe you're super bullish, but I know you've also had reason to concern that this market may have gone too far too fast. So how do you see this?
Philip Verleger: So, you know, you read everybody's forecasts, and I contribute to a British Consensus Economics thing. I've long since moved past modeling to try to think about prices. And what I do is I rely on the decision of investors. Particularly, I watch the share price of the BP Royalty Trust. Because if you buy shares in it, what you're doing is you're buying a cash flow tied to the price of WTI. That's all you get. It dies eventually when the costs that they factored into the unit It back in 1989 exceed the price for 2 years. And it looked like it was going to go away. And now it's— and suddenly it's bounced back. And so it looks to me like investors and most people see kind of the price edging upwards slowly, maybe at about a 12% per year rate from the current levels. That says we're at $70, $72, $73 for the rest of the year.
And it goes up further from there. And I can't argue with that.
I think the OPEC+ ministers are working really hard to keep prices going up. It helps the Saudi economy. It helps the Middle Eastern economies, helps the Russian economy. And so that unless— if it gets too far, I think China will come in and dump some of their huge inventory on the market to keep the price from, say, going past, say, $80.
But you know, it's it's it'll hold in this range for some time to come, particularly with the demands of investors that companies like Pioneer and others increase their their dividends to shareholders and this recent shareholder revolt at Exxon. So I find it hard to find a way really going steeply down unless unless the Fed or somebody else. Throws a monkey wrench into the economy.
Erik Townsend: Phil, I want to ask you about finished product demand because Goldman Sachs made big waves a couple of weeks ago, 3 weeks ago, I think, saying, okay, 5.2 million barrels of additional demand coming on the market, baby. Here we go. Demand's coming back. Vaccines are out. Let's do it. Well, Phil, I'm looking at my, my crude oil going through the roof and I'm looking at my RBOB gasoline. And I'm looking at gasoline on the bottom of its trading range, barely struggling to stay alive. And I'm thinking, it's not the products that are pushing the price higher. What's driving this market? Why is the crude oil market so hot when it seems like gasoline, that normally is the driver behind it, hasn't been as hot?
Philip Verleger: Well, the crude oil is hot because there's a lot of speculative money coming in. As I've been doing since, oh Lord, the late '90s, we've seen a big push of speculators into it. They have managed to push backwardation up by about $2, $2.50 a barrel. So they've lifted the whole curve. Gasoline demand hasn't recovered, and gasoline demand is not going to recover, probably this year and maybe next year, for a couple of reasons. One, workers are not rushing back to the office.
People will go back to the office, but people figured out how to do things more efficiently. Productivity's up. And one of the ways productivity is up is because people don't go into the office as often as they used to, and they won't. But the other thing about gasoline demand and diesel demand is it's tied to the housing industry.
People don't notice this. They always say the summer's the summer driving season. Well, it's not the summer driving season. It's the summer homebuilding and construction business. People build a lot more during the warm months.
Erik Townsend: Well, and they build a whole lot more when the pandemic just ended and scared a whole bunch of people out of cities, too.
Philip Verleger: Yeah, well, that's true. But the housing start data that came out today don't show a big jump, because there's this other problem that we talked about at the start of the show, the lumber shortage. So housing starts, the cost of lumber has become so large in the construction of housing that builders are holding back because the buyers aren't— buyers can't come up with the money. So, if you look at the seasonally unadjusted data, housing starts are about where they were at this time 2019. So, that says, okay, you're not getting this big incremental push from the construction business.
You're getting some from the travel business, but not as much as you— it doesn't matter as much much, and people aren't going back to work.
So we're 9% down, I think, in gasoline demand in terms of the actual way, not the way DOE measures it, but taxable gasoline demand. Electric cars may be cutting it a little bit, but not much yet. The same thing's true in Europe. In India, demand is— motor fuel demand is down about 15% to 20% from 2019 levels because COVID is still strong there. So product demand's gonna come back, But I don't, I don't see the number that Goldman Sachs comes up with.
Erik Townsend: Well, Phil, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Before I let you go, though, I want to talk to you about Notes on the Margin. And for our listeners, we've got a treat for you this week, folks. Be sure to check your Research Roundup email and you'll find a download link for several complimentary issues of Phil's newsletter, Notes on the Margin, which I quite enjoy reading. So I strongly encourage you to check that out. Phil, tell us a little bit about what people can expect to find inside Notes at the Margin when they get there. And for those who are interested in subscribing, how do they contact you?
Philip Verleger: Well, I call it a report rather than a newsletter because newsletters are kind of newsy. Newsletters don't have footnotes, and I run to about 20 footnotes an issue. This is an economic report, and I'm just trying to think about the economic issues. I created it years ago at the request of several people. I keep talking about economics and they say, would you write it out? And that's what I do. And it's an economic focus. It's almost geeky economics. I try to keep the modern stuff out because sometimes I don't even fully understand the modern.
But I mean, it is laying— I've tried to integrate what we know from the economic frontier into the energy markets. And I guess I'm influenced a lot by Gillian Tett, who is an editor at the Financial Times who wrote The Silo Effect. She's an anthropologist and how we all live in our individual silos. And I try to get out and look at the economics and energy. So it's looking at the economics and it's— I rarely stick a forecast in because everybody's got forecasts. What I have that I bring to this uniquely is the connection to the inflation and the potential for an economic slowdown if the Fed moves And what that does to energy.
You know, it's, it's trying to look at the whole body. As far as getting in touch with us, we have a webpage. It's www.pkverlegerllc.com. That's pkverlegerllc.com. There's a spot on that to contact us. And, uh, my editor, Kim Peterson, who's down in, uh, Key West, Florida, picks all that up and responds or sends things to us.
And it's most of the, uh, uh, this is aimed for major, larger oil companies or larger energy companies or banks that have big concerns about the energy sector and are trying to look kind of past the day-to-day events and kind of look forward to kind of what the big trends are. So, you know, I, I take on things like this IEA forecast of net zero and try to say, here's where it, here's where the big problems
Erik Townsend: Well, Phil, we look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update.
Erik Townsend: Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Escrow.com is the payment system for buying and selling anything of value— cars, boats, airplanes, jewelry, gemstones, fine art, collectibles, intellectual property. Property rights, domain names, bringing in shipping containers from overseas, or even buying and selling entire businesses. It's simple to use. Either party sets up the transaction, then the buyer sends the funds to escrow.com. The seller is then instructed to send the goods to the buyer to inspect. Within the inspection period, the buyer can return the items for any reason. After that, escrow.com pays the seller immediately. Escrow.com is the world's secure payment system from a counterparty risk perspective because the funds sit in escrow. Over 2 million customers have transacted over $5 billion on escrow.com, and eBay and Shopify use it for cars, boats, luxury watches, and business sales.
It's available in the United States, Canada, and Australian dollars, euros, and British pounds. Never buy or sell anything online unless you use escrow.com. Escrow.com is a subsidiary of Freelancer.com, listed on the OTCQX Best Market under the ticker symbol FLNCF and the Australian Securities Exchange under the ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Phil on the show. You know, I actually really enjoyed the interview. It's really a great high-level view of how the energy markets are going to evolve. But now you've been saving your little epiphany of what you took away from the interview. Why don't you share it with us?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I've had this just nagging feeling that there's gonna be really strong continuing demand through the rest of this year, and I don't like nagging I like data and facts, and I couldn't put my finger on it. And what suddenly clicked for me was when Phil Verleger said, okay, what's going on is everybody thinks the way that summer market works is about summer driving season. That's summer driving season in air quotes, most famously spoken words of every oil analyst. What Phil is saying is it doesn't really work that way. It's the summer home construction season.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: Which is using up the diesel and the various other products. And that's the reason that we have all this extra demand between Memorial Day and Labor Day. Well, guess what? Every single homebuilder that I have ever heard of, and I have tried to contact some around a project on my vacation home, tell me that everybody's booked for like 2 years. There's absolutely impossible to hire anybody or to get building materials because Because everything is in short supply. I think that home construction is the secret stealth zombie fundamental driver that is really going to make Goldman Sachs actually proven right against what everybody else thinks in terms of what happens with demand in the oil market. Now, ironically, I get this insight from Phil, who doesn't agree with Goldman Sachs, but I think that that home construction trend is going to use more energy than any analyst is really figuring into their equations. And I think demand is gonna be stronger than expected.
And it really, to me, provides an explanation for this feeling that I've been having about why I'm extremely bullish. And also it explains why the tape action has been so incredibly strong, stronger than even I expected. And I've been super bullish. That was long-winded, Patrick. Let's move into the chart deck.
Erik Townsend: Did the Fed kill the reflation trade? Listeners, you'll find the download link to the chart deck in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, don't feel left out. Just go to our MacroVoices.com homepage and click on the red button that says, looking for the downloads. We'll get you signed up and send you the links. Patrick, before we get to the S&P 500, let's talk about the reflation trade in a little more detail than we had time for in the market wrap.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so I just really wanted to comment on one thing in the market wrap that you said, which is actually so true. Through, which is that one day does not make a new trend. And watching how the market develops here in the next week or two has— is in my mind incredibly critical. And so this chart deck that we put together here, it's really just looking at the first 24 hours in the post-Fed period and the trend moves that have broken and the things that have to be watched in the coming week that are going to show the hand as to whether in fact the reflation trade has reversed or whether it was just noise. And so let's dive into it.
The first thing that I wanted to touch on is the S&P 500 on page 2. Out of all of the global macro markets, it's the S&P 500 that actually made the smallest and most muted reaction. For me though, I don't think that that is something that traders and investors should overread into. We are going into a quad witching expiration on Friday. And the gamma pin is as big as it gets. And the S&P 500 staying within a 50-point range into Friday's close, even on a surprise announcement from the Fed, was the base case. And though that we're gonna end the week probably in a very tight range, what will be the real question next week is when volatility does return, and it will return, is it going to be a sort of a delayed reaction to this idea that there's a Fed tightening. On balance, I mean, look, the market could go either way, but it is more vulnerable to the downside on this.
And I wouldn't expect it today or tomorrow in order to make that reaction. So Monday, Tuesday, by the time then, definitely by the time we're recording next week's MacroVoices interview, I think there's gonna be a lot of really important information in terms of whether or not the downside volatility actually kicks in.
The interesting part about this reflation trade passing out in terms of, or potentially rolling over, is the idea that maybe the FAANG stocks actually finally turn back up. And those are the large behemoth names in the index. And while we could end up seeing selling in everything from financials to cyclicals, the interesting storyline will be, can the index remain more muted on the idea that maybe we see rotation And rotation back out of the cyclicals and into these kind of growth FAANG stocks that play a very defensive role in a period where we have some sort of disinflationary surge. And that's 100% the thing to watch next week.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I could not possibly agree more. Next week is what we need to watch. What happens on a quad witching day tomorrow is not really going to tell us where this market market is headed next.
Well, Patrick, as we review the various different asset classes that we cover in the Market Wrap with the benefit of charts, I think you've already covered the S&P 500.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 3 and the US Dollar Index. Boy, look at those 2 green candles. Is that the beginning of something, or is it just maybe a little false alarm?
Patrick Ceresna: Again, one day doesn't make a new trend, so we don't want to commit to a massive trend reversal just 24 hours after the Fed announced But the, uh, one thing that we know is that there was a major support line, that 5-year support line that we've talked about week after week on the show, uh, that held.
And, uh, typically after a support line holds, there's typically some Fibonacci-style retracement or some mean-reverting correction that happens the other way. A punch up to this 92 level is actually a very natural reaction. What really is going to be the tell is whether or not the bulls can hold these I mean, if we find ourselves by the end of next week back down to under 91 and heading down toward 90 again, and it was just one big fake out, then nothing has changed in the bigger dollar view that we had. And so really, after a big move like this, it's really about whether this has shifted the buying and money flow and capital flows, and whether the US dollar under a more hawkish Fed could potentially start to see a strengthening And certainly the breakdown in the euro was a big tell. And then with the yen almost pressing, the US dollar-yen almost pressing north of 111, the dollar trend could emerge.
And so that's 100% something that has to be watched into next week.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to the Bloomberg Commodity Index chart. Boy, look at that big gap.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And instead of going into a lot of the individual commodities, I wanted to just show the bigger commodity index. Because we've seen massive turns in lumber, all the grains have rolled over, copper has broken down through short-term retracement levels. We actually see an incredibly broad break on the downside in commodities. The only commodity that's held up is crude oil, which is on page 5. And even though that has had that one-day reversal candle, but that's actually what's held held because of the weighting in the commodity index. That's what actually has held this chart up pretty well. And, uh, the fact that the commodity index has broken those May lows and has really rolled over without oil contributing to the selling is a red flag. Again, one day doesn't make a new trend, and, uh, and the best thing that could happen for the bulls is a quick and rapid reversal where this ends up proving to be a buy on dip and they quickly rally it back to $92. $93, $94 on the upside in the coming week.
If that happens, then that could neutralize it. But this kind of a break is a big red flag, like a canary in the coal mine. We have to see whether that begets more selling and whether there's a dynamic and deep retracement of that now 6-month rally off those November lows.
With that said, Erik, let's go and actually look at that crude oil chart on page 5. And you can see that red reversal candle. It's certainly nothing that changes the primary uptrend. There are numerous occasions over the last six months where we've had these two, three, four, five day sell-offs where crude oil pulls back five dollars, and it just is just a buying opportunity on the dip that reverses back up and becomes a new trend. And so it's far too premature to already be calling a major top in crude, but at minimum some sort. Of a profit-taking cycle or small correction back to some moving averages is entirely on the table. But really, the bigger question I have is that, can crude oil buck the trend? If we are seeing a broader turn in the entire commodity complex, can oil just march to the beat of its own drum? I mean, gasoline futures did not confirm with a higher high.
There's all sorts of divergences in a number of the other commodity markets. Can crude oil just avoid succumbing to all of that and keep the trend higher? And that's one of the bigger questions I have in my mind. Do you have an opinion on it?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think we should really quantify this around where the different risk scenarios are, Patrick, because there's different ways that this could play out. I think what we both agree on very much is what we see here is very consistent with exactly what you would see if it was a top and a reversal. reversal of trend, a very sudden change in a fairly dramatic, you know, downward move, but it hasn't moved very far yet.
That is what a top looks like. If this was the beginning of a topping and, you know, reversal down to $30 or something, it would look exactly like this. You and I both have a pretty strong hunch that that's not what's happening here, and that if anything, the trade is to fade this. Now, I would love to see crude come back down. What are we at?
Patrick Ceresna: $77.
Erik Townsend: Spot 13 on this chart. I'd love to see it come back down to 68, to the breakout zone there, just to sort of test that breakout zone as support, because that just gives the market more strength to move higher. If I see that further weakness down from 70 down to 69, down to 68, even down to a 67 handle, doesn't bother me at all. I look at that as great news for the bulls, buying opportunity to add to my positions. Everything's Good. Now, if you start getting daily closes below that March high, which was what, around 66 and change, and it stays there for a few days, it really starts to paint another picture. But going back to what you said, Patrick, you said if the reflation trade is already over. Frankly, I think you and I agree that the reflation trade probably is not really over. But if the reflation trade is over, which we both don't think it is, well then look, this is probably the beginning of a reversal.
That probably was the top and there's probably a whole lot lower to come in oil prices. I don't think it's going to go that way though.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, so Erik, we do have to then touch on gold, right? On page 6, I have that gold chart and what a nasty break that was. I mean, we were overdue for a gold correction after such a run, but my first approach to it was that there was a buy on dip whenever, whatever gold break we had. But the velocity to the downside in this post-Fed period is just is mind-boggling. I mean, the, the fact that we wiped out this much this quickly, it makes buying the dip a little more challenging. The big question really is, is in this kind of $1,775 to $1,800 level, can the bulls hold it in along this line? Because in order for a bull trend to really be in play, you should see a sequence of higher highs and higher lows. Any real further further selling in gold really does open the window for a full retest of the, uh, of those March-April lows. And if we're going and retesting bottoms, then it's not an uptrend.
And so the gold is about to give a really big technical tell. I mean, uh, the big question, of course, is, is its correlation to real yields. And right now, while we see the long, uh, end curve— we'll get to bond markets and yields in a moment— But what's happening is inflation expectations got hammered, and inflation expectations being dropping at a at a pace faster than the yields are moving on the long bond is actually means that the real yields are are getting really wobbly here, which I think is spooking the gold markets a little bit. But whether or not inflation expectations are going to really reverse in a more meaningful way, and more importantly, whether or not that long bond really starts to, uh, to move in a big way. It's going to be, uh, the big puzzle piece. I think gold is going to, uh, stick with that correlation, and the next big move is going to be a tell on that.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think gold and crude oil are almost the same story. Basically, if we're right that the reflation trade is not over yet, then what's happening here is a gift. It's a buying-the-dip opportunity, and I would say Of course, you can never call these things exactly, but at $1,772 where we are on this chart, I think that's probably a pretty good spot to think about buying the gold market if we're right and this is the knee-jerk and nothing more. Now, obviously, if we're wrong and the reflation trade is really dead, I think it's a lot lower than just the recent lows. I think it's like $1,400 is the next stop. Frankly, I'd welcome that because I'd buy that too. I'd say if there If there's a trade here right now for me, and I'm not planning to put it on, but if I was going to consider putting a trade on, it would be out-of-the-money protective puts to protect my existing long position so that if we do get a really hard break below, let's say, $1,675 where the previous lows are, it takes us all the way down to $1,500 or something because everybody's convinced the reflation trade is not happening.
Or maybe to 1,400, I don't know. I'd love to be hedged against that so that I can afford to buy even more to add to my longs when we get there. So that's the trade that appeals to me here if I was going to put one on.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, we have to wrap up this entire postgame by talking bonds because what's interesting here is that it's no longer just a story about the 10-year yield. It's a story about the yield curve and more importantly about whether or not the steepener that's been in place for a better part of 6, 7+ months, whether or not we've entered a bull flattening of the curve. And what an interesting reaction we've seen in the bond markets. And so what I put on pages 7, 8, and 9 is the 5-year, 10-year, and 30-year US government yields, bond yields. And what we have is you can see that the 5-year government yield popped from 70, 75 basis points to close to 90 basis points on the first reaction. The big move in yields was in the belly of the curve. And while we saw that 5-year move, when we go to the 10-year, we are pretty flat on the reaction to the Fed.
But if you go to the 30-year, we have yields actually outright breaking down versus where the 5-year was breaking out. This has really flattened the curve, and this is what actually I think is contributing to spooking the markets. So just to kind of show that on pages 10 and 11, I have the 2/10 spread, which is just starting to roll over. But look on page 11 where we have the 5/30s.
Really, with that 5-year yield breaking the way it has and the 30s actually breaking down, down, we have had a complete and total reversal in this and a complete flattening. And this is not just a knee-jerk reaction. This is wiping out literally 6 months of steepening in 2 days. And so this is an extraordinary move. And this is actually the one thing that, uh, that we can't take our eyes off of because the entire reflation trade often has the steepening as a key component to it. And if we have a flattener kicking in here. What does that mean? I don't— again, I don't want to overread into 1, 2 days of price action, but boy, we can't ignore this. And that's something I want to continue to have the conversation in weeks to come.
Erik Townsend: I'd love to know what our friend Juliette Declercq is doing here. She trades 5s-30 spreads a lot and has a pretty good track record. We'll have to get her back on sometime and see what she thinks and what's behind this. Patrick, we've looked so far at the So we've looked at yields and we've looked at the spreads in yields. Let's translate that to what you can actually trade, which is the TLT ETF, which of course is 20-plus-year average maturity Treasury bond fund or ETF.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And we had like a month ago David Rosenberg on the show, and he actually was calling going into that 3rd quarter that bullishness in the long bond. This Fed hawkishness really put this in play. That Treasury bond, you know, during that bond bear market, we saw that, you know, $30-plus wipeout of the TLT during what was just a bond bloodbath. There was no other way to put it. But after several months of basing and now this turn, it'll be really interesting to see whether the long bond is going to actually trend higher. And again, if we We see that, that, you know, you— like we were saying earlier, one day doesn't make a new trend. But if we have a US dollar that starts to trend north of 92, and at the same time the long bond starts to push higher, those are red flags and canaries in the coal mine that the reflation trade may begin struggling, and we have to really reevaluate, uh, our positions on this.
And again, one day doesn't make a new trend, but boy, is this, uh, for the first time in, in months we have a market that's interesting and some big moves are happening, and, uh, and you can't take your eyes off of it now.
Erik Townsend: I don't know, Patrick. The crude oil market's been pretty interesting for the last few months.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, outside of crude.
Erik Townsend: Okay, the, the, the little markets are getting interesting again. And of course, if you want to be a big picture trader on these big markets, you need to sign up for a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading, where you can get chart decks like You get tips like this almost every single day from Patrick. Information is on page 13 of the chart deck. We're going to leave it there for this week's show.
Erik Townsend: This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by escrow.com. The world's most secure online payment system from a counterparty risk perspective, because the funds sit in escrow.
Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, today you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to Phil's newsletters and the chartbook we discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an article titled, Did You Feel the Judder as the Fed Warned Rates Will Rise? As well as a link to a Felder Report article on Markets Have Bought the Fed's Transitory Narrative Hook, Line, and Sinker. So you'll find this and so much more in this This week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to record Recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, please visit MacroVoices.com. Visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Steve Keen — Professor Steve Keen (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 275 was recorded on June 10th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by FarmTogether.com, bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors.
Professor Steve Keen returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss why Steve says inflation is definitely coming, but it won't be the runaway inflation feared by many people, myself included, nor will it be the hyperinflation that some folks fear, myself not included. Steve says the inflation is inevitable, but it doesn't pose a great threat, and he rejects my own suggestion that an Austrian crack-up boom has already begun. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, Patrick and I will take a quick look at yields in the bond market.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's talk S&P 500. I mean, just keeps crawling higher, but it's been so trade range-bound. I mean, we had almost 3 or 4 closes in a row that were within a point of each other. It doesn't seem like the market has any momentum to wanna go anywhere. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, honestly, Patrick, the notion that the market has no momentum to go anywhere because we haven't had a new all-time high in like almost 3 weeks now, I think means that we've gotten to the point where this market I think the market is pretty darn complacent. I think the arguments that this market is just so overvalued and this has to end badly are very well placed. But, you know, I figured out that end badly doesn't have to mean down. It can mean an Austrian crack-up boom. And that's exactly what I think is happening.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to the US Dollar Index, which again has been pinned along that 5-year low, trading in that 89 to 90 range on the dollar index. What's your view on the dollar? Has it changed much from last week?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, no real change. We're in a situation where until we get a close below 89, there's really no bearish indication. And frankly, it would take a lot to get a solid bullish indication here. No, no real change. And frankly, no conviction as to where it's headed next.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's talk crude oil, because obviously over the last couple of weeks, crude oil has been incredibly strong. Then we saw a quick nosedive this morning on the downside of oil. And just as quickly, it reversed and is back up toward the 52-week high.
Erik Townsend: What the heck Well, this was another case of Twitter having more influence on the price of financial assets than actual reality. What really happened is the United States relaxed sanctions on one individual in Iran, an oil-related official. It had nothing to do with the negotiations or any of that stuff. It was just a kind of a matter of fact that, you know, the The thing had expired or something. It was time to take the sanctions off of one person whose sanctions were expiring. And that tweet got misinterpreted because of the way somebody worded it as the United States has lifted all sanctions on Iranian oil, which is not what happened. So the market started to crash and then it retraced very quickly. I think today was a gift to oil traders, Patrick, because frankly, in reality, the fact that the Iranian sanctions are Going to be lifted is already priced into the long-term futures.
It's already there. Everybody knows it's coming. What the market taught us today though is that when that real announcement happens, and it really is the sanctions have been lifted because the Biden administration is going to undo everything it possibly can that the Trump administration did, well, what's the result going to be?
We saw it today. The market's going to crash and that's gonna be an incredible buyable dip opportunity. So I am waiting for that one with Bated breath, Patrick. When Iran sanctions are lifted, which I do think is coming, it's gonna be a huge panic and it's gonna be over nothing. It doesn't mean anything as far as I'm concerned in the overall course of this bull market, but it will be a buying opportunity.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, how did the inventory numbers come in this week?
Erik Townsend: Crude oil drew down 5.2 million barrels or 6.6 million if you include the SPR. Now, that would normally be a pretty significant drawdown for crude oil. The thing is, there were much larger builds in finished products, gasoline building 7 million Distillates building 4.4 million barrels. So you got, you know, almost a 5 million barrel net build on petroleum products, both crude oil and finished products. Cushing, Oklahoma building 165,000 barrels. US production 11,000 even. That's back up 200,000 barrels from last week.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold has over the last 2 weeks had 2 quick little dips, each time reversing pretty quickly right back toward the highs. We're trading right near $1,900 at the time of recording. What's your take on gold here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we got the test of the 200-day moving average that we predicted last week. Happened, I think, in the overnight right after our show went live last week. And it's recovered back up above the short-term moving averages. So we've got the completion almost of this technical pattern. We got a nice breakout above the 200-day. We got up to, what was it, $1,918, just almost $1,920. And then we went back down and tested that 200-day as support. Check. That's the next thing. Now there's only one more hurdle to clear, and that's a daily close above the previous high at $1,920, and we're only about $20 away from it. I definitely think there's lots more upside to come in this gold market, and we've just seen, so far at least, what I think is kind of a perfect completion of that technical pattern. You know, breakout, drift down perfectly, almost to the tick, testing that 200-day simple moving average, and then rallying off of it.
You're the technician in the house, Patrick. How do you see this market?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I mean, gold has continued to be well accumulated. All dips are being bought very quickly. The price action remains structurally bullish, and and we're seeing both real and and nominal yields backing off, which is acting a bit as a tailwind. So right now, gold continues to behave very well. Now, but let's move to that ten-year Treasury yield because just like I was saying there, we have quite the break on the downside of rates as we're now trading around the one spot four six five level on the ten. 10-year Treasury yield. I have some charts I want to talk about this in the postgame, but what's your take on this?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think it is significant that we're back below 1.5% on the 10-year. Let's wait for the postgame chart deck where we can take a look and discuss this in more detail.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is Professor Steve Keen. Erik, it's been a while. Why did we get Steve back on the show?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as you know, the big question that's really on my mind is, are we on the cusp or perhaps already beyond the beginning Of a shift to a new secular inflation, like in 1960, late '60s, 1970s kind of inflation, really big one? I think we are. And the thing is, I've heard people who agree with me. I've heard people who disagree with me, who kind of hold my same mindset that that inflation would be a horrible thing. So I wanted to talk to someone on the opposite side of this ideological divide in terms of what the role of central banks should be and what monetary policy should be and so forth. I think we're headed toward a political regime where people like Steve Keen and people who have Steve's political ideology are going to be in charge of making the decisions for the major institutions. So even though I don't happen to personally agree, I don't wanna know what people like I think.
I wanna know what the people who are gonna be in charge of pulling the levers think. And I think it's guys that think more like Steve than think like me who are coming into power. So I wanted to get Steve's perspective just for that reason. Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Professor Steve Keen is coming up as MacroVoices continues, right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole.
Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy is live now at smartermarketspod.com, and you can look for another terrific interview every Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Professor Steve Keen, formerly a professor from a university in London, now professor at large teaching economics on the internet via Patreon. Steve, it's been way too long. It's great to have you back on the show. But, you know, you have been one of the most outspoken guys talking about why too much debt really leads to a macroeconomic prognostication or diagnosis or forecast, whatever you want to call it, of ongoing deflation. My big question to you is, boy, it seems to me like the politics have changed and we maybe are back to the late 1960s and facing an incipient, not just a little whiff of inflation, But I think secular shift to a really big inflation, that's going to be a big deal.
Am I crazy? What do you think?
Steve Keen: Well, we've certainly got a shock coming through from the supply side of things. I mean, COVID's obviously disturbed global production chains around the planet. We're seeing signs of that as well with climate change, with Taiwan running out of water and therefore not being able to supply the chips to the world. So you've got an increase in essential goods. Highly transformed manufacturing input. And you have a range of other commodities. I believe copper and nickel are 2 that are showing signs of supply disruptions. So all this stuff is meaning you're going to get a supply kick, a cost of production kick coming through, which you could actually liken to what happened back in 1973, '74 with the Yom Kippur War, the OPEC blockade, and the increase in oil prices from $2.50 a barrel to $10. And then the same in 1979, '80 when they went from $10 to $40. So that's the— Definitely, there's a price hit coming through from the supply side of the economy.
But what is different this time around is that when that happened in the '70s, you had an absolute mother of all booms on, which was credit financed. And you also had unemployment so low. I mean, it was, in terms of recorded level in America, it was running at about of the order of 4%, 3% to 4%, which is comparable to what they're calling the unemployment levels these days. But frankly, The numbers were more honest back then. There's been so much hiding of unemployment in the not looking for work section of the statistics that I don't try— I think you've pretty much got to double the unemployment rate there to make it comparable to what was actually being properly recorded back in the '70s.
But with the very tight labor market and the booming credit conditions in the '70s, that meant that that supply shock was passed on to prices. So you had— and this is where endogenous money thinking comes in— you had a huge increase in the price of particularly, obviously, oil. That was then covered by firms accessing their lines of credit to pay for it, which gave a stimulus courtesy of the cost boost into the economy as well. Workers, particularly when you had trade unions, which had been decimated in the last 40 years, 40 to 50 years, they could bargain for higher wages as well. So you got a flow-on from the supply shock of the increase in the oil prices to an increase in wages. And you then had this income distributional battle, the wage-price supply spiral, which went on for a while until it was crushed by the massive increase in interest rates under Volcker. Now, you don't have anything like the credit demand anymore, nor do you have the bargaining power of the working class.
They've been destroyed. They were bad enough in the '70s in terms of political power in America. They've been crushed in the last 40 years. So I don't think you're going to see the aggregate demand follow through to that supply shock. So I expect an increase in prices, quite a sharp one, particularly in raw material prices and also CPUs.
But then that will peter out because the demand won't be there. So I see the price hit leading to a decline in the numbers being sold rather than an increase in the money being borrowed to purchase those and keeping the price momentum going. So if you look back at the 19— '70s and take a look at what the unemployment rate was before the crunch began in the oil price rise. In 1972, you had an unemployment rate of 6%, which fell to 4.6%. And that's a genuine recording of the unemployment rate. And at the same time, credit was running at about 11.5%, 12% of GDP.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Steve Keen: Which is quite high. It's only been higher 3 times, 4 times, pardon me. The 4th time being the beginning of the 2007 crash. Now, when you think of it from the point of view of capitalists and investors, when you have a huge increase in wage costs and raw materials, you have a drop in your profit margin.
So the credit demand plunged from that point. It went from 12% of GDP down to 5.5%. And that's when you had the huge rise in unemployment. At that stage, and you had inflation and unemployment. I think you're going to have not a large downturn, but I just don't think the kick to inflation is going to be there.
Erik Townsend: Steve, talk to me about the relationship between inflation and bond rates, because I'm noticing a lot of investors acting as if inflation caused bond rates to increase. And I would argue it doesn't work that way. Inflation sometimes inspires central bankers to take actions, which Which cause bond yields to increase. But I don't think the inflation is causing it. I think it's the inflation is inspiring the central bankers to make policy actions that do it. How is this relationship? How does it really work between inflation and bond yields?
Steve Keen: Well, the point which endogenous money theory and modern monetary theory as well, and this is stuff which you find central banks confirming these days rather than denying, points out is that the central bank can set any rate of interest it likes fundamentally. It's the controller of the base rate of interest. It can't control the far end. It can't control long rates, but at the short rate end, it basically sets the price. And therefore, it's determining— it's not a market-driven system. It's the decisions of the central bank as to what that short-term rate could be. And we saw Volcker putting it up from what, 8% to 17% as a policy move to try to suppress the inflation back in the late '70s, early '80s. So it's a policy instrument at the short end. It's more market-driven at the long end. But overall, in terms of certainly short-term bond yields, if the central bank doesn't think the inflation that they're seeing is sustained, then they won't be putting up their short-term rates, and you won't see a follow-through from inflation to interest rates.
Erik Townsend: How would you interpret what's happened so far to the US 10-year Treasury yield? Because it seemed at first like people were really freaking out and afraid that it was running away. And somehow we hit about 1.75%, and all of a sudden, it seems to have just settled down. Are we done, or are we just pausing before moving higher?
Steve Keen: I just can't see it moving higher because, I mean, the bond rates, if you're talking government bonds, then government can pay effectively any rate it wants to pay on the bonds. If it issues its own currency, it's, you know, in effect, the Treasury can borrow from the central bank and pay zero interest on that borrowing to pay the interest they then pass on to bondholders. So there's no mechanism to force the government's hand in that sense. And when you look at the level of ...of debt that the private sector is carrying, there's no way I think the private sector can handle an interest rate even 1% higher than things are right now. Because the corporate sector in America right now is carrying the highest level of private debt compared to GDP in its history.
That's been driven by COVID, of course, a giant spike in the level of private debt for corporations, which I think I would expect it was being caused by having to Access lines of credit and overdrafts to cope with the cut of cash flow from COVID So just to give you those numbers, the corporate sector's private debt to GDP ratio when 2020 began was 75% of GDP. By September, it was 84% of GDP. That's almost a 10% jump in 9 months. So that is not a corporate sector that can handle a large cost increase in its interest rate costs. So I just don't think we've got momentum for interest rates to go much higher.
Erik Townsend: Steve, let's come to the subject of modern monetary theory. You have expressed what I would describe as a proponent position. You like this idea of MMT. I personally have concerns with it, but I'll tell you, I'm convinced of one thing, which is whether I like it or not, it's happening. You've been following this for quite a while. How do you see what I think is really a political power change? All of a sudden, the people who are in power are very friendly to what I would describe as maybe your monetary politics as opposed to my monetary politics. Now that your team's kind of got the power, how do you see this going down? What happens in terms of how these MMT concepts are adopted now that the people who have been supporting them seem to be in power?
Steve Keen: Well, it's not so much people who support a policy as saying that what MMT shows is simply using accounting to say, what are the consequences of government debt? What are the consequences of government spending and borrowing and so on? And it's realism about that versus, you know, we're all going to be ruined stuff. If you read the macro textbooks of the mainstream, people like Gregory Mankiw will argue that government First of all, if the government borrows money, if the government increases its issues of bonds, which is what it actually does, then that is going to take money out of the private sector. So more government borrowing reduces the amount of money for private investment. That's literally out of Mankiw's textbook. And I think most a lot of people listening to what we're talking about now would say, "Yeah, that's what I learned. That's that's true." And then also saying that it's this this spending, a large amount of spending and a high level of government debt puts an unconscionable burden on future generations, which you'll also find in. Mankiw and all the usual neoclassical textbooks.
Now, from an accounting point of view, that is just wrong. Okay? I've forgotten Paul Krugman's usual favorite way of putting it, but it is just simply a fallacy when you look at the accounting. And that's what MMT is based upon. It's saying, let's look at the actual cash flows that are involved. Where does the money come from and where does the money go to when the government borrows? And what actually happens when a deficit is run? Now, you read the economic textbooks, the deficit takes loanable funds away from the private sector and therefore reduces the rate of investment of the private sector and causes the economy to slow down, while government spending boosts other parts of the economy. That's the way that the textbooks talk about it. But if you look at what actually is involved in banking, and of course, the last people you should ask about what banks do are conventional economists, because they haven't got a bloody clue.
They've lived with a set of models, the money multiplier.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Steve Keen: Fractional reserve banking and loanable funds, all of which are fallacies. And finally, I think I've said this numerous times, the Bank of England and the Bundesbank have both come out and said, these are simply fallacies. That is not how banks operate.
The banking sector, the point of view of what the banks do is rather than banks lending out deposits, bank lending creates deposits. So that's a complete change in how we think about the private credit system.
Now, what MMT is doing, and it's complementary to what I do in terms of analyzing credit, is saying, well, let's do the same thing with looking at what the government does. So what happens when the government runs a deficit? Is it borrowing money from the private sector that the private sector would otherwise spend, which is what neoclassical economics teaches you? No, it's not. When the government spends more than it taxes, it increases the amount of money in private bank accounts. To do that, it also has to increase the amount of money in bank accounts, private bank accounts at the central bank. So the act of putting money in your deposit account, if you got a COVID check from the Biden Administration or even the Trump Administration, When it existed, that, you know, say $600 check to you would be matched by a $600 increase in the reserves of the private banks that you bank with. Otherwise, their assets and liabilities would be unbalanced.
So that's simply accounting. Now, when you look at that, you see, okay, the deficit has created money. So you, as a private banking account holder and the private banking system in general, you have more money in your bank account when the government runs a deficit.
Now, how are the bonds bought? What happens with the bond buying? Well, just because the increase in deposits of the banks caused by deficit spending is matched by an increase in the reserves of the banks, the private banks at the central bank by the same act, those private central private banks now have excess reserves, which normally earn them no interest. So when the government, the Treasury then says, we're going to issue bonds or sell bonds to the private banking sector to cover the size of the deficit. Those bonds are purchased using the excess reserves created by the deficit. Now, there's all sorts of timing issues involved, and the government can be estimating ahead of schedule what it expects to do and sell the bonds before it does the spending and so on. Yada, yada, yada. But fundamentally, the deficit creates the money in the private bank accounts, and it creates the excess reserves that are used to purchase those bonds by the banking sector.
Erik Townsend: So...
Steve Keen: So there is no problem. First of all, there's no problem about burdening future generations. In fact, you're enriching current ones, at least monetarily, because they're going to have more money in their bank accounts. And the debt that is created, which is bonds, is simply changing non-income-earning reserves for the banking sector to income-earning bonds for the banking sector. So all the scare stories that are a common part of saying we've got to control the deficit, et cetera, et cetera, are simply scare stories. They're not accurate as an accounting vision of a monetary economy.
Erik Townsend: Steve, you've emphasized very strongly over the years that the number one biggest problem we face is too much private debt. I wonder, obviously, MMT by its definition involves more public debt, because that's kind of what it is, is a prescription of using public debt in order to accomplish public spending more effectively. It seems to me that there is an extension of that that MMT policies really tend to also encourage more private borrowing and more private debt accumulation, which seems to me adds to the problems you're talking about. Would you disagree with that, or is it just a question of needing to separate those? That yeah, we do need MMT, we just need to be careful.
Steve Keen: Yeah, I think we need to separate them because— and this is like MMT is a— as I said, they call it Modern Monetary Theory because it's a modern development. You can trace it back to the 1990s. Initially with Warren Mosler, talking about how governments don't tax to spend, they spend to tax. And equally, my work on credit is a modern innovation. I began doing that in the '90s with my models of Minsky's financial instability hypothesis. And I've only recently built a sort of general theoretical explanation for how credit adds to aggregate demand. So they are 2 new elements. Now, MMT, from what I can see of what most of the authors have written on MMT, haven't yet got their heads around the role of credit properly.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Steve Keen: That doesn't apply to, say, Stephanie Kelton, for example. Stephanie's— I mean, if you read between the lines in her book, The Deficit Myth, you can see awareness of the role of credit there, but the focus is still on government spending. But there was a debate, not a debate, a slanging match really, between Randy Wray and Doug— I think it's Doug Henwood. Doug Henwood put out an attack on elements of MMT.
And as part of that, he said that the strange thing to him was that there's no role for credit in what he sees in MMT. Right. And Randy Wray's reply said that, well, overall, he regarded the endogenous money revolution, where people like myself developed an analysis of the role of credit, how banks create money by lending rather than banks lending out deposits. He said the impact of that was trivial, because all it did was say that rather than the government controlling the quantity of money, it controls the price of money, and the market sets the quantity. That is incomplete.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Steve Keen: When you have a new set of ideas like MMT on one hand and my analysis of credit on the other, it takes time for people to put them together. So I believe that they are compatible. And then when they are compatible, it means you have to worry about there being too much private debt. If MMT, you should be focusing on reducing the level of private debt, as well as saying there should be more fiat money creation and less credit money creation. So it's possible to combine the two together, but that hasn't actually intellectually happened yet. I hope it'll happen in the next couple of years. So they're not incompatible per se. They're not like Austrian versus post-Keynesian economics or anything like that, or Austrian versus Marxian, heaven forbid.
They're compatible, but they haven't yet been combined.
Erik Townsend: Steve, when we've spoken in the past, at least in my perception, I would summarize what you've said as, look, we've got such a problem with private debt that if this goes too much farther, we're eventually going to get to the point where it's not just that maybe we might have to go to a debt jubilee someday, but eventually you get to the point where there's kind of a point of no return where there's no other option. Are we there yet? Or is this a zombie economy that is facing a debt jubilee someday that's unavoidable? Or is there still a way to avoid that?
Steve Keen: The way to avoid it is by continuing being stupid. And Einstein used to say that the 2 things that are limitless, the universe and human stupidity. He wasn't sure about the universe, but he was sure about human stupidity. I've got to agree with him, I'm afraid, on that front.
Yes, I do think that we've reached a point of no return because again, if I look at this just in terms of the history of America and say, what's the level of private debt now versus its previous peaks? The current level of private debt, again courtesy of COVID is about 160% of GDP. It peaked at 170% back in the financial crisis in 2009. The highest before that was 130% during the Great Depression. And then you go back to 70% in the 1910s.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Steve Keen: America is at its absolute ceiling in terms of its capacity to carry private debt, given the other dynamics of the economy. Other countries have had higher levels, but they're all carrying peak debt, certainly in comparison to any time since the end of the Second World War.
So what that means is with so much private debt accumulated, the potential for any credit-driven demand is minor. But a healthy capitalist economy does function better if you have credit demand, particularly if it goes to entrepreneurs to enable innovation to take place. So you have something which is cutting off the potential for innovation, which is the thing which gives capitalism a reason to crow about itself as a social system versus any other. So we have so much private debt accumulated, so much inability of both banks to extend further credit and borrowers and individuals to take on that credit. credit, that you have credit stagnation. And also, it means people spend the money they have in their pockets more slowly. You have a lower velocity of money because you want to hang onto the money you've got to pay the debt you've got. But by hanging onto the money, you don't spend it, and therefore the turnover is lower, and you get very low bang for your buck out of the greenback in your pocket.
So there's all sorts of reasons why we face permanent stagnation unless we reduce the level of private debt. And COVID has come through on top of that. And I think climate change will come on later and just mean that unless you reduce the level of private debt, you're going to have mass bankruptcies.
Erik Townsend: Steve, a few years ago, you wrote a book called Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis? And when we talked about that at the time, I was thinking financial crisis, that means stock market crash. I'm starting to think the next financial crisis that the economy faces is more likely to be an inflation, a runaway inflation, where if anything, what you're worried about is upside risk to the stock market as opposed to a downside risk. And the risks that you get concerned with are not stock market crash. They're completely different.
That probably is very much at odds with the deflationary conclusion that you, at least in the past, have drawn from this excessive overhang of debt. So how does this work? Do we need to be worried about a financial crisis that's more of like a crack Or runaway inflation? Or is that not really in the cards?
Steve Keen: I can't see runaway inflation just because I can't see runaway aggregate demand. And that's what you need to have a supply shock like we've got coming through because of the COVID supply chain disruptions and mineral shortages as well coming out. And I like even hardwood in America, apparently there's a shortage there at the moment. But to have that turn into sustained inflation, you've got to have it being Something that then leads to wage rises, which then lead back to more price increases and more wage rises and so on. And you simply don't have the bargaining capacity in the working class in America anymore to enable that to happen. Nor do you have the credit-based demand that used to exist, which could mean that companies would absorb a price rise by borrowing, extending their lines of credit and their overdrafts, and therefore keep the momentum going of the price. Cost increase through the price system. So I can't see that happening.
What I can see are massively overvalued stock markets courtesy of Federal Reserve intervention. And to me, that's given you a fragility in the financial sector, which just basically requires good news to happen all the time to avoid a downturn. Now, of course, the Fed can dive back in and rescue those markets anytime it likes, so long as those crises don't look like they're— They're existential. But I overall just can't see stagflation. I can see a stock market crash and the Fed diving back in to rescue the markets again, which is what it's been doing ever since 2010. But it's not something I'd be trying to explain in the 1960s and '70s inflationary surge ways.
Erik Townsend: Steve, I've been particularly looking forward to talking to you about ESG, environmental, societal, and And corporate governance, cognizant investing is the theme. Frankly, I don't think on one hand that I've ever heard a more valiant, more legitimate, more honorable concept than for owners of capital to exercise their social responsibility to be responsible with it. So in principle, I love the idea. And I know as kind of a left-leaning political guy, I've gotta believe you I do like it too. But you know what? I think ESG is a scam. I think that most of what's going on is a bunch of Wall Street guys ripping off people who wanna be responsible by selling them greenwashed nonsense that has nothing to do with solving climate change and everything to do with separating rich people from their money. That's pretty cynical. You are a guy who follows this climate change stuff pretty darn carefully.
Am I right to be that cynical about the way the investment industry has addressed this problem of climate change?
Steve Keen: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I'm involved with a group called the Biophysical Economics Institute that's trying to bring a bit of realism to ESG and to tie it into as well into energy return on energy invested and point out the importance of that. And we want to have some validity coming out of the ESG. But fundamentally, anything like this is another reason for the wolves of Wall Street to start prowling Main Street. And that's how it's being bundled and packaged, just like carbon offsets have, as if we can fix up climate change by paying an extra $20 on our airfare from New York to London? No, we can't. But it works out nicely for the companies marketing those offsets.
Erik Townsend: It certainly does. And it's on a much bigger scale than that. I've been reading these stories about people who were buying carbon offsets from people who didn't do anything. And the people that didn't do anything are polluting in a way that just doesn't happen to be being counted within that particular jurisdiction against them, even though it should be. And, you know, this, this ESG thing, it, as far as I can tell, it is really mostly about Wall Street scamming investors into thinking that they're being responsible. The good news is investors want to go to sleep at night feeling like they've been responsible and not just greedy with their money. That's got to be an advance for society. Unfortunately, Wall Street is in between those well-meaning investors and actual do-gooding. And unfortunately, I don't think that is going to change. How do we eventually get past this, Steve? Because you and I both, I think, agree that climate is super important. We only got one planet.
We got to take care of it. But frankly, I don't think that the people that are on the crusades on either side are really dealing with the straight facts. I think this is a very politicized thing, and the economics of it, I think, are making a mess. And the investments that supposedly fix it, I don't think fix it. Are there investments that really do help? Are there things, without going through ESG funds, that investors should be thinking about just how to be responsible investors and do good things with their money?
Steve Keen: Even on that front, I mean, most investors are buying shares of other investors. You're driving up the price of the share. You're not giving any money to the company involved in Whatever green technology you are allegedly supporting. So to me, I think we really need a wake-up call about just how serious climate change is, because I don't think it can be done. I don't think it'd be handled by a profit-oriented private sector. I think the scale of this is so great that we're going to be forced into going backwards in size of the economy, and firms are going to need cash support from a government to be able to stay solvent.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Steve Keen: Relevant in the whole process. And one of the major reasons why we haven't taken it seriously is economists like William Nordhaus, who have completely and utterly distorted the dangers we face with climate change by the shoddiest work I have ever seen.
I published a paper on that in a magazine— a journal called Globalizations last year. And the title of it was The Appallingly Bad Neoclassical Economics of Climate Change. Bottom line is anybody who's taking the numbers that economists have pumped out about what climate change means to the economy are deluding themselves by an order of 1 or 2 magnitudes as to how serious climate change is going to be. So all this ESG stuff is just more greenwashing.
Erik Townsend: Steve, I'm not going to let you pick on Nordhaus without substantiating your argument. What specifically did Nordhaus get wrong that would cause you to make such a scathing statement on a public podcast?
Steve Keen: 2 things in particular, like an overall orientation, which is just believing that climate change can't be bad because capitalism can handle anything. Therefore, climate change can't be too serious. I'm not joking. That seems to be his mental processes.
But in terms of trying to add up what the damages to climate change will be, he assumed that 87% of American economy would be unaffected by climate change because it happens in what he called carefully controlled environments. Now, the industries he said were not going to be affected were all manufacturing, all services, all government activity. He even included overseas GDP as part of the— Trade-exposed sectors of the American economy as unaffected by climate change. And that's become a common assumption for all the economists working in this field. Now, that is basically saying that climate is weather. And so if you're not exposed to the weather, you're not exposed to climate change. That is nonsense. That is garbage. The simple reason being, and we can see this with the example of Taiwan right now, one of the examples he gave of a carefully controlled environment was microprocessor manufacturing. Why are we finding the microprocessors becoming more expensive right now?
It's because there's a climate change-related drought in Taiwan that means these enormous factories can't get enough water to do the processing. So the cost of microchip processors is going through the roof, as well as the disruptions from COVID So literally mistaking climate for weather and doing that in 2 ways. Also arguing, and I've seen one of his fellow travelers on this front, a guy called Richard make this argument that you can use as a proxy for what's going to happen to climate change. You can use the current relationship between income as a gross— let's say gross state product in America and temperature. So if you look at Maryland, for example, and find that Maryland is 10 degrees colder than Florida, and that Florida has got a 20% lower GDP than Maryland, therefore you can say that a 10-degree increase in temperature would reduce the GDP of Maryland by 20%.
Now, a 10-degree increase in global temperature would drive the human species extinct, period. And there's plenty of scientific papers to give reasons to believe that. The simplest one being, for example, that one reason we have the temperate zone where most of the agriculture occurs these days is because there are 3 circulation systems in each hemisphere. You have what's called the Hadley cell, which is the circulation of air between Between 0 and 30 degrees, from the equator to 30 degrees north. You then have 30 to 60 where there's what they call the temperate zone. And then you have the polar, 60 to 90 degrees.
If we increase the global temperature by 10 degrees, which is seriously what was considered by one of his acolytes, that according to physicists and atmospheric physicists is twice the level of temperature increase that would put enough energy into the atmosphere to mean we went from 3 cells to 1. It's like turning up the oven Turn on the temperature on your stove on a bowl of soup, and you've got these little bubbles, they're called Bernoulli cells, circulating and you can see them. Increase the temperature and the whole thing bubbles, and all the Bernoulli structure breaks down. Well, imagine that happening and what happens to Western agriculture. What it would mean is all the rain would be occurring around the equator and around the pole. The pole would be 22 degrees Celsius. In the middle, you'd have pretty much an extremely hot, dry area.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Steve Keen: ...drought-stricken part of the planet. You simply can't use those assumptions to make up the data for climate change.
And yet that's what they've done to argue, as Nordhaus does, that a 6-degree increase in temperature on the globe would reduce GDP by 8.1%.
Now that is nonsense, absolute nonsense. And it only got through to be published because economists fundamentally are climate change deniers, most of them. And they don't think you can criticize You can't criticize a theory because of its assumptions, which is crap methodology. So we have got nonsense numbers being used to give corporations the apparent guidance that there's only going to be a minor impact from climate change. It's all stuff economists have made up talking through their asses.
Erik Townsend: Well, I would say that that succinctly addresses my request that you clarify why you would make such a critical statement, Steve. Let's move on from there. I got to tell you, I really enjoy your perspective on economics, listening to you speak, and also And also reading your books. It's been a few years though since, I think it was 2017 that you published Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis? My Amazon is spying on you. I've got a secret message here.
Steve Keen: Oh yeah.
Erik Townsend: It says there's a new one. It's called The New Economics: A Manifesto by Professor Steve Keen, available for preorder, but there's no look inside, so I can't see what's in there.
Steve Keen: It's really saying that neoclassical economics is the phlogiston Of the modern era. It's the Ptolemaic astronomy in the time of moonshots. It's a theory which is neat, plausible, and utterly wrong, which shapes how we think about how capitalism functions and is actually making capitalism dysfunctional. So we need a new economics that is not obsessed with equilibrium thinking. So we understand complex systems that doesn't pretend that we're a barter economy, which have never existed in the first place. It's a monetary system where you have to look at money.
And it's one where energy is absolutely essential to production, whereas mainstream economics leaves energy out and it's sinking completely, and imagines you can have an economy with no energy input, which is total nonsense. And all this has come out of a methodology which ran into all sorts of problems, mathematical problems, where various things that neoclassicals would like to have concluded were proven to be mathematically false. And their answer was, let's make a simplifying assumption.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Steve Keen: And jump over the problem. So for example, one of my favorite simplifying assumptions by Paul Samuelson to try to explain how you can take the theory of an individual having a downward sloping individual demand curve to get a market downward sloping demand curve. He literally assumed that America is one big happy family.
One big happy family that allocates income before trade so that everybody's happy with the distribution of income before trade goes ahead.
Erik Townsend: Literally.
Steve Keen: I've got that. That's what I quote in the book.
So we have a moribund failed paradigm still dominating how we think, and it's time we got a new one. And what I explain in that book is how you can have a new approach to economics based around complex systems, monetary analysis, and being realistic about the role of energy in enabling production to occur in the first place. And then of course that ties up climate change as well. So it's a pretty heavy read. Mind you, I do use the word bullshit at one point inside the book. So not as heavy as you might think.
Erik Townsend: I can't imagine that coming from you, Steve.
Steve Keen: Of course not.
Erik Townsend: Of course not. Well, it is available for preorder right now on Amazon, so I am clicking as we speak. Steve, before I let you go, I want to bring our listeners up to speed, and frankly, it's a story I don't even understand completely myself. When I first met you, you were a university professor. That means guy gets up in the morning, goes to a university, stands in front of a bunch of people in a room and gives a lecture.
You changed all that. Basically, you were one of the first guys to call the 2008 financial crisis, got kind of famous because of that, got a big following. Now you've kind of basically changed the rules to where you're still a professor of economics, but you don't work for a university. You kind of do it freelance. How is that even possible? What's going on? And who are the students? Are we talking about student-aged, you know, kids that want to learn economics from somebody other than a university? Or are we talking about middle-aged people who are investing? Who signs up to say, Steve Keen, I want you to be my university-less professor?
Steve Keen: Good question. It's an interesting combination because it's all through Patreon. So without Patreon, I couldn't do what I'm doing now. And I've got about roughly 1,500 subscribers on Patreon. And there are people paying everywhere from $1 a month, which would mainly be the student end of the spectrum, to $1,000 a month. And if I look at the $1 end and the students, They're people who want an alternative perspective of what they're getting in the textbooks and what they're getting at university. So that's students getting an alternative education.
I actually had a marvelous conversation, by the way, just to mention this, which is on my YouTube channel, where a group of school students got in touch, a brilliantly informed group with a little website called Politics with Nick. And I had a conversation with these, even including a 13-year-old who had his head around Sraffa and all sorts of advanced critiques of mainstream economics.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Steve Keen: That I didn't get my head around until I was in my 20s.
So that's the student end of things. And I think a lot of the others are people who would like to be doing what I'm doing, but are caught in jobs where they can't. So they're providing me with more than they need to give me to enable me to continue doing my work. So most of the stuff I put up on Patreon, I make freely available. So you don't have to pay my Patreon to read what I'm writing there. And that was with the agreement of my patrons that I do it that way. But there are some things that I give to people who pay the $1 and above. Like for example, I've given a copy of the manuscript of The New Economics to all my subscribers. Then there's a $10 a month podcast with a great mate of mine and great radio guy, Phil Dobbie, as well. But I've got people paying $30, $100, $300, and $1,000.
And they're not doing it because they have to. They're doing it because they want to. And my interpretation there is that they would like to be doing what I'm doing. They can't manage to do it themselves because of their own commitments or their own industry. So helping me do it is their way of, you know, doing one for the team.
And I completely and utterly applaud them and thank them for their support because without it, I'd be stuck back at home living on my retirement earnings and, you know, scabbing out what I could manage to do. And do this work, I can be full-time productive and it's been far, far better than being stuck at a university where I've got to answer to bureaucrats all the time.
Erik Townsend: Now, if you want my prediction, the unexpected positive consequence of the COVID crisis is the whole world is going to change with more people like you abandoning the structures like universities and saying, hey, I can do it all on the internet and I don't need all of that bureaucracy and all of that nonsense. And I think that makes the world a better place. Steve, we're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time.
Erik Townsend: Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade, but the high cost of buying an entire farm puts this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor. investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did an interview with FarmTogether founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk.
We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview Now, we've got a free resource for you to learn why farmland investing just might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland in the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: Now back to your host, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Steve back on the show. It's always interesting to hear the different perspectives on how the monetary system works and debt is considered on the balance sheet. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think Steve is one of the smartest guys, and in fact, I'll say he's the smartest guy I know of whose views I respect, despite the fact that he is very much on the opposite Opposite side of an ideological belief system about the role of government in managing money systems and so forth. So I really wanted to hear that view, and I think that the MMT crowd is definitely coming into power, and I think it's gonna be very interesting. The inflation will be good for markets and feel good to the economy in the beginning, no question about that. It's a few years into it that it starts to get scary.
Erik Townsend: In any event, Patrick, I want to move on to our postgame chartbook, which is titled Looking at Bonds and Yields. What's going on here on page 2 as we look at the S&P 500?
That's not bonds and yields.
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, well, just wanted to do a quick update going into next week on the S&P 500. I mean, we have the big quarterly quad witching OPEX roll-off coming up next week. And like we've heard from Charlie McElligott many times when he's been on the show, So this is a period where there tends to be a lot of gamma pinning by dealers. And it's— you can really see how the daily ranges have completely tightened up on the S&P. And barring some big catalyst, it's probably going to be a little bit more of the same going into next week's option expiration. And so it'll be interesting to see. But this level right in this zone, 4,200 to 4,250, is going to be an area that the market is likely to bounce around within in the coming week.
Patrick Ceresna: Nonetheless, I wanted to go and actually talk about these bond yields because obviously Steve was— gave us a great interview and had the perspective that he didn't think yields were going to go too much higher than where they currently were.
And I thought it was really interesting because some people in the past have made the correlation that higher inflation typically would manifest with higher nominal yields. But really, we've seen that ever since these high inflation numbers, including the one that came out earlier, another monthly— month-over-month high print on the CPI, and the bonds don't seem to be reacting to it. In fact, they are outright breaking down. And it's interesting, it looks like some sort of a bond bottom may very well be in, and it'll be interesting to see how low yields go in this impulse.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, we've got the 2s-10s spread on page 4, and it looks to me like the same kind of breakdown. Down?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, really, uh, we've seen the, um, the bear steepening and the bull flattener, uh, really kicking in. Obviously, the front of the curve is pinned by the, the Fed, and so really this is now just a mirror image of, of the 10-year nominal yield as, uh, as we're moving. And so it's interesting that the steepener trade, which has worked so well for almost, um, a year going into March, has really now seemed to have run out of upside momentum and continues to be reversing very much in line with that 10-year yield.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we're looking almost at the same chart upside down on page 5, aren't we?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is exactly it. And so I wanted to just flip it over and really ask that question. I mean, most people have been generally avoiding the long bond and obviously with the risk that we could have much higher yields. And there was the fear that we were gonna go well north of 2% on the 10-year yield. And that's kept most people sidelined on this bond. Now, after seeing several months of consolidation, we're seeing an attempt for the long bond, in this case the TLT chart that we're showing here for the 20-plus-year Treasury bonds, really reversing up. And that asks the question as to whether or not we're going to see a little bit of a bond rally. Nonetheless, that breakout has also happened if you look on page 6 on corporate bonds. And so we saw We saw the lows on investment-grade corporate bonds on the— using the LQD happen in March. And we're really seeing an attempt to break out on the upside.
It looks like at this stage, these corporate bonds could easily head up towards the 135 level and test all of those September, October, November consolidation lows in this push.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I'm tentatively starting to come around to the view that the scare that we saw in Treasury yields was just that, a scare, that it's over, that it's behind us, and we really are gonna find out Just as I expected, that the reasons that all of the spending that the Biden Administration wants to do might have caused yields to move higher are going to be offset by policy actions to keep them lower. And that's what we predicted here on MacroVoices months ago, and that's exactly what seems to be happening now. Patrick, let's take a look at the BBBs. That's the high-grade credit spreads.
Patrick Ceresna: Normally, we would always show the junk bond credit spread. Just wanted to really touch on both of them, including the investment grade and the junk, we continue to see multi-year lows in terms of those credit spreads. Now, there's, by part, it's a function of the fact that interest rates are so low that it's very easy for the spreads to be more narrow. So I don't wanna overread too much into that alone, but we have entered a real period where there's a lot of complacency towards the credit risks associated with corporate bonds versus that of US Treasuries. And so it'll be, it's interesting to watch and see whether or not at some point something spooks the market and actually forces the market to start pricing in some additional risks in these credit spreads. It's worth noting that the bond market has really calmed down in general, and a lot of that fearful selling that we really saw taking place since November through March, really everything has calmed down, and the entire bond market has really started to turn up a little It'll
be interesting to see how long that lasts.
Erik Townsend: And folks, if you enjoy Patrick's chart decks, be sure to check out a free 14-day trial of Big Picture Trading. You can find the information on page 8 or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to keep it tight this week and leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by FarmTogether.com, making farmland investing a trillion-dollar asset class available to all accredited investors. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a great interview with Options Positioning Godfather, Cem Karsan, as well as a link to the Jeffrey Snider article titled The inflation emotions. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter. Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelt with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account.
Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-value guests to join us on the show. profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag Bag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.