Marin Katusa — Natural resource investing guru (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. And now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 274 was recorded on June 3rd, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Masterworks.io, bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Natural resource investing guru Marin Katusa returns as this week's feature interview guest. We're going to focus this week's interview specifically on the private equity deals that are only offered to accredited investors, allowing them to buy precious metals mining stocks directly from the issuing company off the listed exchange, and often at a discount to the price everyone else is paying for the same shares on the open market. We'll discuss private placements and financing in gold mining stocks, as well as other speculative natural resource investments such as uranium and even carbon credits. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when we'll be talking charts with Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's get to the S&P 500. We started the day with a quick little drop, but we're back to 4,200. Like, these buy-on-dips just keep coming right back into the market. I want to talk about some charts, but what's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the froth continues. We're still above all of the short-term moving averages. As much as I agree with the overvalued arguments, I wouldn't wanna be short here. Glad I'm not long either and happy to be trading oil instead.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index 'cause it suddenly has come back to life. I mean, after almost 2 weeks of trading in that, like a 50-cent range between 89.5 and 90, we finally have a pretty decisive breakout on the upside. Do you think this is a legitimate turn in the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, maybe in the very short term, there's been a change of direction to the upside in the last couple of days, Patrick. But, you know, big picture, I think everybody is just getting wound up about what really is a pretty boring consolidation pattern. We're consolidating sideways until we get a breakdown below $89 or a really decisive break upwards substantially higher. It's a little easier to say there's a clear line in the sand on the downside at $89. I'm not sure exactly what the line in the sand is on the upside, but frankly, I think this is a situation where the market really, you know, it's digesting a new presidency. If you look at the chart, what's going on is ever since the election, there's a broadening pattern. That means the market is exploring uncertainty, unsure what the Biden presidency means. We'll figure it out and we'll see where we go.
But for now, we're just chugging along, consolidating.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, the one market that isn't stuck in a trade range is crude oil, which broke out to fresh 52-week highs. What's your take on the oil market and how did inventory numbers come in?
Erik Townsend: Well, very consistent with my expectations and the prognostications I've talked about here on MacroVoices for the last few weeks, there has been a breakout, and I believe that the second major leg of the epic 2021 crude oil bull market has begun. Now, Patrick, you're the technician in the house, but if I apply my most simplistic measured move analysis, I get a target potentially as high as $92 on front-month WTI, uh, as far as where this could go. My previous estimate had been at least $80. So I think my new outlook is a high price on WTI for the year, peaking somewhere between $80 and $92 by Labor Day. And frankly, it's very possibly on the way to $150 by the end of 2022. But that scenario would require quite a few more dominoes to fall into line and, and line up exactly the right way. So I'm not so sure about that one. But I think we're headed to $80 to $90 oil before the summer is over.
As far as inventory is concerned, we had another big Big drawdown on crude oil this week, 5.1 million barrels, another half million barrels coming out of the SPR for 5.7 total. Cushing, Oklahoma building 748,000 barrels. But the builds that really counted this week were on finished products. Gasoline building 1.5 million barrels and distillates with a massive 3.7 million barrel build. US production ticking down a couple of ticks to 10.8 million barrels from 11 million barrels previously.
Uh, one tick is not a trend, but we'll be watching it to see see if we get that expected slowdown in production later this year.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on gold because gold for 2 months has been up almost every week. And today we come into recording this with one of the biggest gold down days we've had in several months, even though $36 isn't necessarily that big of a move. But do you think some sort of a gold correction may be underway here, or is this just going to be bought on dip and the trend continues?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I explained in last week's show, this is good news and very much expected. What I said last week is the chart looks fantastic longer term, but the thing is we just broke through that 200-day moving average, and you know as well as I do that a very common pattern when you break through a major level is that you end up going back down and retesting it as support. That's what happened this morning, is gold went back down, didn't get quite to the 200-day moving average at $1,854, got down to about the 21-day moving average, which Which is at $1,863, maybe just a little bit above it. Maybe it's got a little bit more to go down. And of course, you know, you never know. Maybe Treasury rates are going to run away to the upside and we're going down to $1,200 gold. I don't know. But Patrick, the point is the most likely outcome in this scenario is that we're retesting the 200-day moving average as support.
And this is a buy right now. The final confirmation will be when we move higher to new highs beyond that recent high of $1,910 or whatever it was just a few days ago.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on the 10-year Treasury yield because this week might have been the tightest one-week range of the yields that, at least that I remember. I mean, we haven't seemed to move off this 1.62 level. What's your take on Treasury bonds?
Erik Townsend: Well, the fact that you're seeing less volatility tells me that there's less panic. I think there were a lot of people who were kind of freaking out about bond yields backing up and not sure what they were gonna do in terms of repositioning if they did. I think that those people I think those people that were panicking are at least calming down. Now, whether or not they should be coming down, I'm not so sure, but I think that the panic that rates are about to run away has kind of come out of the system, and that's resulted in less volatility in Treasury yields. You remember back in the old days, Treasury yields used to be very boring. You know, they didn't change other than once every couple days or so.
Needless to say, those days are long gone.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Marin Katusa. Now, Erik, why did we invite Marin back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, we had a listener question a few weeks ago saying, why don't I reveal the names of the stocks that I'm buying when I buy gold mining shares? And I explained the answer is most of them come out of recommendations from Marin's newsletter service. And out of respect for his other paying subscribers, I can't really be telling you what they are on the air.
Somebody wrote back and said, well, if you're not going to tell us on the air, why don't you get Marin on the air to talk to us about this? And what we decided to do, Patrick, is a repeat of something we first did with Rick Rule several years ago, which was
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. Was to do an interview explaining for the benefit of those accredited investors who may not realize that there are special deals where you can sometimes buy stock at a discount price, at a better price than what it's being offered on the public markets,
Erik Townsend: if you buy it directly from the company in a deal that only accredited investors are eligible for. There's a lot of accredited investors who are eligible for those deals and don't know that they're there or how to find them or what exists. Now, what I'd originally intended was to kind of cover the landscape of the industry and how this works and so forth. Marin is a natural-born salesman and a good one, so he ended up talking quite a bit about his service as opposed to the industry on the whole.
But in addition to what Marin does, you know, there's a whole industry of capital introduction brokers that hook accredited investors up with opportunities only offered to accredited investors. So I wanted to just cover that subject matter because I certainly think, as, as an accredited investor myself, that's where the opportunities are in the gold market is to buy the mining shares at a discount to what they're trading for in the public markets.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Marin is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Michelle Dennedy's interview with Greg Lavender, Chief Technology Officer at VMware and former Managing Director of Cloud Architecture at Citigroup, airs this morning. And you can look forward to another terrific interview every weekend On Smarter Markets. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to listen to this free new podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Katusa Research founder Marin Katusa. Marin, it's great to have you back on the show. I know that you've got a brand new book out which just hit the number one bestseller list on Amazon. I want to talk to you about that before this interview is over. But what I really want to dive into, because people have asked for it, is to talk about the options that exist for accredited investors in the gold market, precious metals market. And let's expand that to, to natural resources generally, uranium and other kinds of mining. Where those opportunities exist, because what I do when I'm buying gold is I do it in the futures market if I want the bullion. And if I want the mining shares, frankly, and I want to make sure that we're fully disclosing this to our listeners, we do have a business relationship. What I do when I buy the mining shares is I am a subscriber to your newsletter and I participate in a lot of your recommendations.
Not— you do recommend buying stock on the open market, and I've done that on your recommendation from time to time, but mostly what I've participated in is special opportunities that are only offered to accredited investors. So I want to educate anyone who is accredited but might not understand what the options are about the marketplace and talk about what's possible. So give us the, the background on this market. Why accredited investors? Why is the deal different for accredited investors? And why does this industry in particular seem to do so many financings that are offered only to accredited investors?
Marin Katusa: Thanks, Erik. Let's go back when I started out about 20 years ago. I knew nobody in the business. I grew up in East Vancouver and by total fluke, Vancouver is the epicenter for resource and commodity capital. It's where things get financed. And that goes back almost 100 years. Why?
But when I started out, it was right at the beginning of the big BRICS growth, China growth, the commodity bull market. Gold started at $350 an ounce. And you go through the CFA program, And they don't even talk about private placements or warrants. And I'm sitting there, you know, at these investment conferences and listening to the big players at the time. And they would talk about, you know, just passively, oh yeah, you know, I did that financing at $0.25, stock went to $5, I blew out the shares and, you know, I ride the warrants. And I was like, what the hell are they talking about? You know, I was just a young kid at the time and going, well, when I go onto E-Trade, I don't get any access to this. How do I participate in these financings that the biggest names in the business are doing?
So as I built my way up, walked up the ladder in the industry little by little, in about 2005, I started going, wait a second, this is crazy what's going on. And it really made sense from the outside. But you have a geologist who's got zero business sense, zero business experience. And because of the nature of the beast, the geologists were asked to be presidents and CEOs and chairmen of these companies. And then more of the advanced mining companies, it was the engineers.
When geology and engineers, they don't take business courses. And generally speaking, most of them don't have business experience. So what happened was these stockbrokers who would rotate from selling bags of shit to used cars to whatever it was to make a finder's fee and a transaction fee jumped on this trend where a lot of brokerage firms would jump onto these companies And they were paying 10% cash, 10% broker warrants. So think about this, Erik. A company raises $10 million to go raise money. $1 million of that goes to the investment bankers, and then they get $1 million warrants on top of that.
And because it was a bull market, that's just the way it was.
So I was the first guy that said, wait a second, these investment bankers are not that sharp. These brokers are morons. They literally couldn't pass a grade 10 algebra exam, but they're dictating terms on these things. So I got involved in building companies early on, Copper Mountain, which became Canada's 3rd largest mining company for copper production, Cuadrilla, which became Europe's largest shale gas company. And I was involved. Wait a second, we're not going to do it that way. And so I became persona non grata in the finance world with these brokerage firms. It got so bad, Erik, that I was not invited to investment firms' research days where they would host companies where my companies were the biggest companies at the show. Think about that, right?
And my advantage was this. I teamed up early with a guy named Doug Casey, and Doug made his score, and he asked me to manage his money. And I said, well, if I bring in the subscribers in at the same time, at the same price, plus my personal capital, plus Doug Casey's capital, I can compete with these big banks. And that's what started happening.
So in lieu of finder fees, because I don't take any finder fees, I said, I want warrants. And then we created the Katusa Warrant, which is the 5-year listed tradable warrant. And it was a way for my subscribers to get involved, and it became a smashing success. We've raised billions of dollars doing this. Some of the biggest companies in the gold market like Equinox and the big energy companies like Alterra. We've all used this mechanism like the Katusa financing where my subscribers and I and yourself all participate at the same time at the same price. And there's no finder fees paid to anybody, but we get these juicy warrants that list and trade. So that's kind of where it came about.
And the reason why it became for accredited goes back to Actually, the 1929, in the 1930s, they brought in a Securities Rule Act that people got fleeced in America. And at the bottom of the Great Depression, they brought these rules that you had to be accredited. So generally speaking, not always do you have to be accredited, but generally speaking, if you're an American, you have to be accredited.
And if you're a non-American, meaning European, Asia, Canada, Australia, You can be accredited and get in. And in some cases, most cases, if you're a Canadian non-accredited, you can get in if the companies file the right paperwork. But why did the brokerage firms not do this? Well, because the big secret of the mining sector is there's like 20 funds that are 90% of the pool of capital. So these investment bankers want to take the best deals to their main guys. And investment bankers don't want 1,000 subscribers. They want 10. They want to have 10 meetings to get their million-dollar finder fee, not 1,000 phone calls.
And that's the big difference between what I'm doing and the bankers.
And the biggest difference, Erik, is on a deal that I'm doing, I'll put up— so for example, one right now that we're doing an IPO on, I did my numbers. I was there. Everyone had the data set. I did my homework a bit faster than the other bankers. And I said, I'll tell you what, these are the terms that I'm willing to do.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Marin Katusa: I will personally commit to a $10 million check, but I want my subscribers to have this much if they choose. It could be zero, it could be $50 million, but they get in at the same terms and price and there's no fees paid to anybody.
But I want these terms and the terms come with a Katusa warrant. And that's how I'm able to structure these deals. So I'm usually, most cases, the largest investor in these deals. And in the business, Erik, a lot of the times, the company have no idea what the company will be financed at because it's at the mercy of the market. So the bankers will do a roadshow. The funds who are in there are going to manipulate the stock. They're going to short the stock. And until the night before the book is done, the company has no idea what price it's going to be.
So if you're a shareholder and you see that, you have to understand what's going on. That's another advantage that the companies know. I don't do that because I put out to my subscribers that they can sell first before I do. And there's no games being played. I'm going for the big score. And if any one of your viewers look at any one of the deals that we've talked about, that we've presented opportunities, you're not sitting at 50% gains.
The uranium deal that we did, the IPO, you're up over 400%. The one from a year ago, you're up over 500%. And the gold markets and the uranium markets haven't been that great. And if you play this right and you know how to do it, There's no better way to invest than in private placements and financings.
That's a strategic way to do it. It's not the only way to play it, but that's generally my strategic advantage in this market, and it's how I go about investing big sums of money in the sector.
Erik Townsend: I want to stop you right there, Marin, because first of all, I agree with you emphatically, but I think we really need to clarify financings and private placements. What that terminology means in the context of precious metals mining shares versus what it means in, let's say, the software industry is completely, totally different. So I think we need to clarify and I think explain how this works in the precious metals business for people whose knowledge is in other markets. Because, you know, in the software market, the way this works is there's angel investors are the only opportunity really for accredited individuals to to play in the software capitalization game. And they become angel investors. So accredited investors become angel investors in startup companies, but then the rest of the capital formation process is usually managed by venture capital firms that do the rest of it until you get to the IPO point.
In the precious metals space, it doesn't work that way. You don't really have precious metals venture capital firms, as far as I know. The way it works is that there are various offerings that are made only to accredited investors, that it's not really the same thing as a private placement in the most strict definition of that term. Because when I think private placement, I'm thinking angel investment. It's a brand new company. A lot of the deals that I've done with you, Marin, it's a company that's already trading on a stock exchange. It's not a private company. It's a public company. But you're buying shares on the private market from the public company, which frankly is something that doesn't normally happen in most markets.
So give us a little bit more of an understanding of how all of this works and what the role is that accredited investors play in the capital formation process, who they're buying from and who they're selling to in the end.
Marin Katusa: Great question. So the last large transaction— see, I don't do many deals either, Erik. Like, I'll do maybe 2 or 3 of these a year, but they're big checks and takes a long time to do the due diligence and meet the criteria. The last big financing we did was on the New York Stock Exchange. That's a big board.
It was trading and you did not have to be accredited because the company filled out the proper forms. They were organized. They were guys that understood the market and all the stock was free trading and the warrants, and you did not have to be accredited. in the US or non-US. So it's not always accredited. You know, every deal is specific.
Secondly, the reason why it's called private placement, it sounds like it's a placement or a financing in a private company. The reason why the lawyers in the industry of mining called it that, it was a transaction between the company and specific investors that were not available to the public market, meaning not everybody in the stock market had access to it.
But think about the insanity of this. Sometimes these are trading at doubles and triples in the open market, Erik, because the company and the bankers do something called price protection. One financing that we're doing, it's trading 4 times higher in the market than what we, me, you, my subscribers can pay with the warrant because it was price protected.
And it's a private transaction. It's called a private placement because that's not everybody can get access to it. It comes down to Are you directly investing in the company? So the company issues the shares. They give you the shares after you give them their money. They'll give you a certificate that has shares and warrants. And everything I do has warrants. Not always do the bankers have warrants.
And then you take that and usually, not always, but usually there's a 4-month hold or a restriction of selling your paper. And that's why it's called a private placement.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Marin Katusa: But almost everything I do is always publicly listed on a big board stock exchange that you can go on, on your phone or on your desktop or laptop, log in and see what it's trading at during market hours.
IPO, initial public offerings, same thing. Then there's something called a short form versus a long form. A short form is when the company fills out the proper documentation to have no restricted paper. So it all comes down to You know, what stage is the company, who's leading the financing, and what terms are they dictating?
There are certain funds out there that think warrants are stupid. Okay, that's their prerogative. I think that that logic is stupid. If I can make 5 times my money, but with a warrant I can make 8 times, I think you have to be stupid to think that 8 times is not better than 5 times. But the reason why they want to do that is they want to price out other competitors who want warrants, right? So it's all about competition and everyone's competing to put, you know, get into the deals.
And what I have found, Erik, is when gold is hot and all the bankers are flying around on private planes and geologists are being wined and dined at fancy dinners, that's when I shy away from the business and go do something else. You don't want to compete with the bankers. Why? They're not putting up any money. The brokers aren't putting up any money. Remember, they're using your money and they're going to take whatever terms they can to get the deal done. They get paid cash and they get paid broker units, meaning they get stock for not paying for it in lieu of fees. And sometimes it works out to be like 15%, 20% warrants. So My good friends in the business have made an incredible career doing this. Guys like Rick Rule and the Sprott Group and all these private brokerages, Goldman Sachs. How do you think they make so much money without putting up the capital?
And all I'm trying to do is say, I'm going to disrupt this industry and I just want better terms. And the company doesn't have to pay finder fees. They don't have to pay broker warrants. They get the money. They get a guaranteed lead order from me. And yeah, am I an alligator and want the best deal possible? Of course. It's my money. I'm allowed to do whatever the hell I want with my money. I'm always going to get—
Erik Townsend: Hang on, Marin. I'm going to interrupt you there because I do want to get to the details of how you structure your deals, but I want to start by just introducing our audience to how this market works and how people gain access to it. Because frankly, Marin, most normal, reasonable people would assume that if you look at E-Trade or whatever and you say, what's the price of a gold stock like Equinox, very well-known stock, EQX is the ticker. It shows you the price, whatever it's trading at. A normal, reasonable person would assume, well, that's the price. That's what's the going price is. That's what you gotta pay.
The fact that that same stock might be being offered at a better price on better terms to some people who know about the deal, but not to other people who don't know about the deal, frankly seems to me like a huge injustice in the way the whole system is designed. I think It's a betrayal of the existing shareholders that that even happens. But the thing is, if those are the rules and that's how it happens, if you want to buy Equinox and you can buy it for what it says on the screen, or you can get a much better deal if you're an accredited investor and you know which form to fill out, obviously you're going to do the latter.
So for people who want to do this, there's a whole brokerage industry. They're called capital introduction brokers, people who introduce accredited investors to deals that are only offered to accredited investors. Tell us the ups and downs of that industry, Marin.
Marin Katusa: Sure. So whenever a company does a financing, they have to put a press release out. So everybody does have the same information at hand. The difference is, is do you know how to value that company versus what the value in the open market is? Just because, you know, you mentioned Equinox. When we were We're putting in hundreds of millions of dollars into the company.
I've been to the projects. I knew how to value it, and I could act quickly. So the average person has the same information as me. It's all public disclosure information, but are they able to piece it together and value it and move the capital quickly? Secondly is, you know, if a smaller company is doing a private placement, you can have a broker, but does that broker have a way into the management team who do the press release.
Because generally speaking, a deal in a financing, you know, if they're going to raise $10 million, very rarely do they go and go, okay, we're going to do $10 million and we have no idea where we're going to get the money from. Please, we'll take money from you. They got a good idea. They have a broker involved, a banker involved. The banker is involved in setting the price and he's got a good sense of where the appetite for the financing will be. Doesn't always happen that way. There's been many, many deals done by banks that get what's called hung. A deal that— a financing that gets hung, meaning it doesn't get done.
Now, the other aspects here are, you know, remember, a broker, that's why they're called brokers. They're not called wealth creators or this or that. The average broker, Erik, does not have a degree in finance, does not have experience in it. It's like a 3-month online program to become a broker. They're glorified car salesmen.
There's some great brokers out there, don't get me wrong. And I'm going to— people are going to hate me in the industry for saying this. But you know, when I got heart surgery, the surgeon spent years in school and years apprenticing and years as a surgeon.
You want to follow someone who has years of direct experience, not someone who's just going to throw, oh, cannabis is hot. Let's do these cannabis deals. Crypto's hot. Let's do crypto. Because they're not investing their money. They're investing your money. And they take fees off of placing your money. They've already made money before you even get your shares from the company you're investing in. Those are the brokers and the investment bankers. So always, it's just so simple, Erik.
Ask yourself this. Does this person have the same skin in the game ratio as me? Do we win together or do we lose together? Or is he one up on me regardless of what happens? Happens to me. And generally just stick to people whose interests are aligned with yours. You're at the same price as you and just run with it. Doesn't mean it's always going to work. Not everything I do is a success. I've lost lots of money in lots of deals, but overall the track record's been very impressive because I stick with financing deals as cheap as I can with management teams who are the largest shareholders in sectors that they have an advantage in. Focusing on tier 1 assets in politically stable jurisdictions. It really is that simple, Erik. I don't need to take crazy risks. And if management's cost is $1 and you're going to finance this at $10, even if they're great guys, they're 10 up on you.
Why bother? So I don't.
Erik Townsend: Okay, let's talk through for people who may not be familiar with it, how some of these deals work, because I really don't think they have parallels outside of the precious metals industry. I mean, The legal structures may be there, but I don't think they're frequently used. So I want to use a— we used an example of Equinox a few minutes ago. There's another company that you organized a financing for more recently. Because I learned about that through your newsletter, out of respect for your paying subscribers, I'm not going to mention the name of the company, but very similar company, I think, to Equinox when you first got involved with Equinox. It's not a startup. So the opportunity for me as an accredited investor is not to be an angel investor in a startup. startup that's nowhere close to being public.
It's a company that's already trading on a public stock exchange that I can see trading on a screen, you know, on an E-Trade quote in front of me.
But the opportunity that's being offered to accredited investors is the opportunity to buy the stock at maybe a tiny little discount below what the market price is, but usually only a small discount. The thing is, it's not just the discount. You also get a half warrant, which is an option to buy more shares at a fixed price, but effectively a call option for free with the deal. So by buying through this mechanism as an accredited investor, you get basically, you know, buy one, get one free. You buy shares and you get free warrants just for exercising your privilege of being an accredited investor. That's the advantage of these structures. And there's 2 ways to get introduced to a deal like that. One is through a broker that makes a commission on introducing you to the deal.
The way that you do this, Marin, is different. The way that you organize it is you're participating in these financings yourselves. You organize them for your own benefit so that you can invest in them, and then you charge a fee for people who want to get your newsletter to know about the deal so they can invest alongside you. The way I look at it, honestly, is if I deal with a broker, I would be a complete fool not to do very thorough due diligence because brokers cause people, somebody to go broke, usually not them. And I don't want it to be me.
So if I invest with your deal, frankly, I ought to be doing my thorough due diligence anyway. But you know what? I usually don't. If you have more at risk, if more of Marin Katusa's money is going to be lost than Erik Townsend's money, If it turns out that you screwed up this deal, that's enough for me. That's your skin in the game proves to me that you wouldn't be selling this deal if you didn't believe in it, because you're going to lose more than I do. That seems like a better way to do this than paying the brokers a commission for it. Why doesn't everybody do it the way you do? And are there other people who— financiers who structure these deals the way you do, where it's basically—
Marin Katusa: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Basically, pay me a fee to get— instead of the companies getting the middleman fee, it's pay me a fee to get my newsletter and then I'll just tell you what I'm doing and you can do it too.
And there's no middleman fees after that. Why doesn't everybody do it that way?
Marin Katusa: Yeah. So the key part here is, is I do not have a private placement service. My newsletter, these are just things that I'm doing. And what the whole newsletter is about, we provide all the research interviews, the site visits, interviews with the management team. And I'm going, look, I'm putting $10 million in. And I've done it to organize my own investment.
And then I tell the company, look, I have no idea if Erik Townsend is going to click the link, read the report, watch the video, and go, yeah, I like this idea with Marin, or I think Marin's smoking crack and I think it's a stupid idea. I have no idea what an Erik Townsend's going to say. But if Erik likes it, he can contact the company and invest directly if he meets the criteria. In certain instances, you've got to be accredited. In other ones, it's not. Every deal's different. Then I say, hey, if they come in, there's no fees paid to anyone. Treat everyone the way you treat me, the way you treat my crew. And it's been a great experience.
The reason why other companies can't do this, they have private placement services, which I do not. And all they offer is private placements. Now, Erik, Like I said, I'll go eight months without a deal, and because I'm looking to place my own money. But if I was forced, if Erik Townsend subscribed to my newsletter because every month on Monday of the first month I have to have a new deal, how good do you think the deals are going to be after a while if you're forced to find new deals?
In addition, the big publishing companies don't allow their their authors and analysts to own the stocks that they talk about. So right off the bat, they're forced to come up with deal flow. And number 2, they're not allowed to buy it themselves. Even if they wanted to, they're not allowed.
In the long term, how do you think that that's going to do when there's no skin in the game and it's all about volume? It's not going to do well. Secondly, a lot of publishing businesses are about rotating from hot sectors because they're in the business of selling subscriptions, newsletters.
I do this to publish, to get access to deal flow. Because I've published all this material, this deal that I'm doing now, these guys approached me a year ago and it's about getting access to deal flow that I don't get to maybe meet these guys because they're on the other side of the world in Australia or wherever. And in today's world, if you publish or perish. So they know that I'm willing to write a big check and play in a big way.
I may— the alligators may or may not show up, but if they show up, they get treated the same as me at the same time, at the same price, and there's no fees. So it's a total advantage for everyone.
It's gotten to the point where the biggest players at the brokerage firms are bypassing their own rules to participate in the financings that we structure. Individuals that you've had on your podcast play in big ways because for them, There's a rule for brokers. They have to give their clients deals first if it's brokered, and then they can't even get in their own deals. So a lot of the big deals, the good juicy ones, are done non-brokered by the brokers so they can do it themselves.
I know it sounds screwed up, but that's how it goes. And think about it, even if you're a publisher or not a publisher, if it was so good and you believed in it, wouldn't you put your own money in before you tell anyone else? It's such a simple strategy that it blows my mind that more people don't focus on this.
Erik Townsend: Well, I feel like we're missing something here, Marin, because if you look at the hedge fund industry, it is very, very standard. You got to eat your own cooking. The fund manager who has not invested a very significant percentage of his own personal net worth into his own fund so that his money is at risk, that guy doesn't get taken seriously. And you have to be willing to make that investment in order to have that job.
I don't know anyone, and I hope there is someone other than you who structures it this way, but as far as I know, the capital introduction industry, and I don't mean just in precious metals, I mean for everything, for software, for whatever, it's entirely about middlemen who don't have skin in the game hooking deals up. And sometimes they hook up some really good deals. There are some capital introduction brokers who only work with very well-heeled people who do amazing things.
But it seems to me that just as the hedge fund industry has learned that there's no substitute for skin in the game, what a benefit it is to me as an investor, Marin, that I can invest in one of your deals and I can reduce the amount of my time and energy that is necessary for due diligence by whatever amount of trust I'm willing to put in the fact that I know you're going to lose more than I am if we lose.
And frankly, that goes a long way with me. It saves me a lot of time and energy.
I would like to invest in a whole bunch of decentralized finance software deals in the same structure that I get somebody who I think knows more about that industry than I do, who wants to tell me what their deals are, and I'll pay them a fee in order to do what they're doing because I don't have time to research it myself.
I don't know where to find that. I know where to find an army of cap intro salesmen who want to introduce me to the next complete total Pain in the ass, waste of time DeFi idiot scheme that none of them have any idea what they're doing because it's just, life's too short to spend trying to find those gems.
So why doesn't the entire capital introduction industry, why doesn't the buy side just insist on only dealing with people who have skin in the game? I don't get it.
Marin Katusa: Well, look, I think a lot of it comes down to just volume. If you're a broker, You can't survive if you're an investment bank, take any of them. I don't care which one. I'm agnostic. To me, they're all the same. You can't survive if you're doing 2 or 3 deals a year. I can, Erik. To me, it's irrelevant. I put my time in. I have a whole staff, geologists, engineers that I pay for, but I position myself that I take a big swing personally on these after it meets my criteria.
There's guys that you know and admire in the mining world that I've done the due diligence on their projects, gone to site, signed CAs, and I passed on the deal and I don't talk about it, right? No big deal. But there's so many deals that I go through and find something like fluorine in the concentrate that I know the smelters are going to do a massive discount on that no analyst has picked up.
Or for example, in my book, I have a chapter about, wait a second, I have not read a single research report in the world, in the resources, where any analyst in the NPV and the future cash flow valuations has incorporated the future carbon cost that is coming, and it's going to be put onto their balance sheet as a liability.
But because I'm putting huge amounts of my personal net worth and my children's money— I don't do this for the money. Like, money is obviously the the score and all that. But if I stop, I'm done. Like, I've had a great career, but I protect this money. It's my children's and my wife's after I'm long gone. I'm protecting what I've built. And you have to model this stuff. And because this is my money and I'm the lead order, and whether people come with me or not, it's irrelevant to me because I'm doing it myself.
I need to calculate these things that I'm not going to rely on an analyst who makes $110 grand a year.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: He doesn't give a shit. He's analyzing 50 deals. He physically cannot do this because they're in the business of trying to give 1-inch-high, a mile-wide research, but the depth, they just physically can't do that.
They can't— like, Erik, I booked a private plane last summer during the quarantine on a deal that you invested in and many of your viewers.
I put up the cash for that. I put up the cost of my team for months of research.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: I'd be out of the whole $300 grand if it didn't work out, and that's the cost of business. On top of that, I was away from my family for a week in the summer, and when I got home, I had to be away from them for 2 weeks. That's psychologically hard to be away from your family for 3 weeks in summer, right? Like, if you want a happy wife, that's not the way you do it. With the hope of, don't worry, babe, if this works out, we're going to make lots of money. After a while, she's tired of hearing that, right? My point is, is no firm can succeed by doing that model because they need deal flow and finder fees to keep the business going, right? I don't need that.
Erik Townsend: So you're basically saying that your own business model is not scalable beyond a one-man show?
Marin Katusa: It can't be. Well, it's not a one-man show. We're a big shop. Just to put it in perspective, I do more financings than all the other banks in the business in Canada combined. Think about that for a second now. You take all the brokerage firms in the commodity sector, add them all up, and the financings that I do are bigger than all of them combined versus a guy that's just doing his own thing with his team. And I've got a great team.
So that's what I mean. The brokerage firms can't do that because they have hundreds of brokers. And if they only had 3 deals, they wouldn't have the business.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Marin. So big picture, the way this industry finances itself relies on the participation extensively of accredited investors who are sometimes able to buy shares and warrants on better terms than they're offered for on the public market. And it's very important if you're an accredited investor, obviously, to benefit from that. The ways of doing that are either to deal with a middleman or to deal with someone like yourself who's doing it as a newsletter.
You're actually kind of a special That's a one-off case. Let's talk about, regardless of whether it was brokered or you're doing it, let's talk about the structure of one of these deals. How about if we use an example from something you're actually working on?
Marin Katusa: Tomorrow, all the alligators, today's what, June 1st? On June 2nd, I'm publishing on a deal that has been a year in the works, lots of due diligence, lots of phone calls, me doing my thing, and the company is raising a big amount of capital. Bankers, Goldman Sachs was there, the biggest banks in the business were there. But there's a pandemic going. And as I'm asking all these questions, when's the road tour? They're, well, we can't leave. We don't know how we're going to do this. The bankers were all kind of stuck. And public information, I used all the publicly available data on their website. I crunched my numbers and this is what I did after spending many, many months doing this. I took a 50% discount to the commodity price at spot.
Then I took a 40% discount to its free cash flow. And then I put a 12% discount on the NPV. Okay. And I said, all right, I'll tell you what, I'll put up $10 million, but I also want a Katusa warrant. And, you know, management were up in arms going, are you crazy? It's worth 3 times more, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. I said, okay, well, what are the bankers offering you? And he came back and said, the bankers haven't offered me anything.
We have to do a roadshow. When? I don't know. Oh, who are you going to meet? I don't know. What price? I don't know. It's going to be assessed after the roadshow. And I go, but you have a window to acquire something here that you've already told the bankers you need, but they can't give you anything firm.
I'm just willing to give you $10 million US guaranteed personal check right now on these terms. But I'm going to put an alert out. If my subscribers want some and they're accredited and they meet the criteria after reading it and they want to go directly to you, make sure you treat them the way you treat Marin Katusa. And they said, they had their board meeting, they went back and they said, you know what? We think you're getting a great deal. And I said, great. Why don't you guys invest a big chunk of your own money?
So they are. So I got the skin in the game from the management. They're going to be the big investors. I'll be probably the largest individual shareholder of this company. My subscribers get a chance to come in. And the way this— it's again, the way it trades in the open market, since the deal was agreed on the price protection, it's trading at multiples of what the financing's at. And it trades.
So what I'm trying to get at is I was there, I did my homework, I stepped up like an alligator, I gave them a firm offer. And it doesn't matter which financing, even if the bankers went around, whoever writes the biggest check.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: dictates the terms, and that's how this deal happened.
Erik Townsend: So essentially what you're doing is you're saying to the company that's talking to the bankers and brokers and so forth, they're getting ready to go do the roadshow, try to raise some money, and you're saying, look, I would like to tell you that my name is Marin Katusa and I am such a big fat cat that I've got enough money that I can do your whole deal myself, just one guy. But since I'm not quite that big of a fat cat, What I do have is friends and friends with money that listen to me. And if you want to do a deal right here, right now, we can close the deal today, or you can spend the next 6 months on a road trip screwing around with the investment bankers and hopefully get a deal.
And you're better off to just do the deal with me. You, Marin Katusa, are not rich enough to do those deals with those companies as one individual because you don't have enough money to finance these things.
Marin Katusa: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: All by yourself. But with your subscribers, you can do that. So that's basically your business model, is you figure the deal out, your subscribers get the same deal as you do. What you get from your subscribers is 2 things. One, they pay you a pretty darn generous subscription fee for getting the newsletter in the first place. And number 2, they make you effectively have more purchasing power than you would have had otherwise. So you can do deals single-handedly that normally only an investment bank could pull off. Is that basically the gist of it?
Marin Katusa: Exactly. And on top of that, the company doesn't have to pay massive banker fees. Up to 20% of the capital raised stays in the company.
Erik Townsend: Okay. Well, this model works for me personally, resonates for me. I do want to do a good job for our listeners though, and make sure that we explain. Look, there's another way of doing this. You can get access to a larger selection of deal opportunities, a much larger selection than Marin offers by working with a private placement capital introduction broker. They can introduce you to far more deals, many, many more deals than Marin will ever offer you.
They're middlemen and Marin's got his own skin in the game. I prefer to work with your business approach, but it's only because I'm lazy. You know, I would actually rather broaden my horizons and consider the deals the brokers are offering in addition to your deals, Marin, If I had the time to go do the due diligence that's necessary in order to do that, but I don't. So that's how I approach it.
Let's talk about the benefits. How much of a difference does this make? You know, suppose you've got an investor who could just, you know, read a newsletter like yours and invest in the public market in stocks. How much of a difference does this whole access to private placements and financings make for investors compared to doing it on the public market?
Marin Katusa: So these are all large deals that I'm doing. I don't do early stage. I don't do a $20 million market cap or $50 million. These are very big companies that have big cash flow. Even, Erik, even though a company may be a billion-dollar market cap or a $2 billion market cap, if I personally wanted to invest $10 million in the market, which is like my starting ticket for these deals, I can't do it in even 2 weeks. My broker has to sit there. There's the bid-ask. I got to deal with a broker, which I generally don't like doing to begin with. I got to pay them a fee. You know, there's just a transaction fee that you have to pay brokers, and I don't get a warrant in the market.
Now, by doing a financing, yeah, I've spent a lot of time on this, but I do that anyways before I go into the open market. I get a discount to the market. I'm able to allocate my first and second tranche if I want in one check. In one transaction. And I get the Katusa warrant, which, you know, if you look at the numbers, there's a reason why I have the number one track record for many years in the sector. And it's why my competitors, I'm their go-to guy for this stuff. They don't talk about that publicly, but these are all my buddies that I've known for 15, 20 years. And I don't care. I just want to make sure that I get my money and my family's money into the best deals.
And you nailed it. You know, in the resource junior world, I've kind of outgrown the the juniors. So I'm in that mid-tier and big caps, and I don't have enough capital to do this on my own. And I don't want to go and create a new hedge fund and deal with all that stuff. So I said, screw it. I've got the reputation. I've got the KRO alligators, the newsletter subscribers. I've got the most powerful and best subscribers in the world in finance, and they read my stuff, and it's up to them if they want to participate. It's— it is the best model I can think of to participate in, in the commodity sector.
Erik Townsend: Well, it has certainly worked for me. I am up significantly, and I mean 500%, I think, on one of the deals that, uh, I've done with you, and the others are all up as well. So it works for me. I want to move on though to another subject, which is, in addition to that business, you're also a best-selling author. What's up all of a sudden with the new book? Why the new book? What's it about? What's going on?
Marin Katusa: I started it last year and my first book was a result of my heart surgery. I had to stay home by doctor's orders, so I wrote a book. I guess you can call me a busybody. After I was in quarantine last year for 2 weeks away from my family, I couldn't go into the office.
I thought, I'm writing a lot of interesting things. When I had my swap line concept and all these different unique ideas on the resource sector. And I had guys like Tom Kaplan, some of the smartest successful resource guys, reach out to me and want to pick my brain on these ideas. And I had guys like Rich Dad Poor Dad call me, get my number from people that I don't even know how they got my number and pick my brain. And when a guy like Tom Kaplan or Robert Kiyosaki are saying, hey, you need to really write a book about this. And you're like, ah, And I've been there, done that, went through the whole dog and pony show of book tours and all that. And ironically, one of the guys that I worked with on my first book started reading my stuff and said, there's a book here. And I said, ah, come on.
And then I was toying around with the guys in the office and I said, I think this anti-American— America's at its absolute low for trust in government, absolute low in trust in media, the political division. You look at the commentary and the momentum on the US dollar, the belief in the resource sector and the gold sector, which I'm a big player in, on the anti-America movement, the US dollar's trash. It's all about China, this G2 argument. And I said, you know, I've got an interesting idea. And it just hit me, the rise of America. So I went on godaddy.com and I went, geez, I wonder who owns that URL and how much does it cost? It was available. Incredible, Erik. I bought it for $1.99, and then I bought the .ca and .com, all the different URLs. And I went, this is a really contrarian indicator that riseofamerica.com is available for 10 bucks in every country that I want to have the URL in.
And as I started digging into the data, I got more and more convinced. And I know it's a contrarian idea, And I'm not trying to be contrarian for the sake of contrarian. And Erik, after it hit number 1, the amount of abuse I've been getting from the gold bugs and the resource sector investors who know me thinking, what the hell, has Marin become a tree hugger? And what, he's joined the New World Order? And I'm like, oh my God. It's math. It's data. It's follow the money. Look at the sectors.
I present a very unique take. It's about twice as long as my first book, Erik. It's over 450 pages. And I start with, how did we get to where we are?
And everyone's talking about MMT and I'm saying, no, you got to look at the present. A lot of people— what's the name of the Federal Reserve building? Eccles Building. Who is Eccles? He's got a cool name.
Erik Townsend: Marriner
Marin Katusa: Anyone with a name with Marriner, I'm going to pay attention to. And he truly was the most powerful Federal Reserve in America's history. Yet the average person who talks about MMT or the anti-US movement or the Fed is dead and all these stupid things against the Fed have no idea who this guy is or what FMC is, Fiscal Monetary Coordination.
He was the most powerful guy in the Fed for 40 years. They named the building after him, and he brought in FMC. Then you look at where we are today. We're not at MMT yet. Everyone thinks we are. We're at FMC, and it's going to happen much more. If you think that the printing presses— people say, how could it get any worse?
You haven't seen anything yet. They're going to print much, much more. The attacks that I'm getting on the book tell me that people are not keeping this in a relative basis, when you compare the US to Japan or Canada or the EU or China, you'll realize that America has much more running room than anyone's giving it credit for.
That's just on the fiscal and monetary aspect. Then you look at the pools of capital, you look at the cost of electricity, you look at all these different factors that are going to really reinvigorate the American economy. green industrial revolution. I'm not just talking green energy. I'm talking about cost of energy, cost of capital. America has a lot going for it.
And, you know, I'm not saying that China is going to go to zero. I'm saying that the rise of America will rise the rest of the world, including China. Okay. And there's a lot that the book— there's a lot of myths I break down why is 2% the Fed's inflation target. I break down the history of that. A lot of people just say there's a 2% target. No one asks why.
So really what I broke down is after many, many bottles of wine late night, I'm not allowed to go anywhere. My family's in bed. I don't sleep much. And it's 8 months of staying up till 2 o'clock at night, just researching, reading, and entertaining myself. So the real summation is the last chapter called The Forbidden Chapter. And every chapter builds upon the framework that I have for the forbidden chapter and where I think things are going. So that's kind of how it happened, why it happened.
Did I think it was going to be a number one bestseller? I did not, Erik. We haven't spent a dollar in marketing yet on it at all. My publisher had the number one bestseller with David Goggins before that. We've beat him now. The publisher is surprised. And I guess I'm not the easiest guy to work with because they had a lot of suggestions. I said no.
They didn't want it 450 pages. I said too bad because I put in the contract that it's my terms in what I wanted in the book. That's why I did it and it's my last book. I think it's the framework where I'm betting a lot of money on.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm reading it now, quite enjoying it and looking forward to the forbidden chapter, which I haven't gotten to. But I've gotta be honest, I'm actually a bigger fan of a different publication, which is your newsletter. In the interest of full disclosure, I am a subscriber to the newsletter. I am a participant in several of your deals. So I do have my own vested skin in the game in some of your offerings. But please tell us a little bit more. Uh, frankly, the newsletter's not cheap. This is not for the retail investor who's a newbie who's got a financial net worth of $10,000. Who is it for and how much does it cost normally and how much of a discount did we manage to talk you into this time for MacroVoices listeners?
Marin Katusa: The newsletter is $3,500 US a year. I have no idea what the discount is with Suede. I think you guys probably did $2,500, I'm assuming. It really is for the people who want to educate themselves and have actionable advice. If you don't want to invest into this sector and educate yourself, Think of this as a very expensive private trainer that you want to get very fit. There's absolutely no point of buying this product if you don't want to invest the time to read it. And my reports are not narratives and catchy stories to sell a newsletter. That's the opposite. It gets into cash flow models. I get into real deep financial analysis on the sector using my own indicators, the math background that I have.
Is it the most entertaining read? Probably not. I believe it's the most informative read where other brokerage firms use my data and charts in their reports. But this is not something that you read passively. It's for the person that wants to expose their portfolio to this sector. And the average length of a report is about 40 to 50 pages every month.
Erik Townsend: Marin, I hope you won't be offended at my saying it, but frankly, it's overpriced for small investors. If you don't have at least $50,000 or so that you want to invest in the resources sector, in my opinion, something like this— it's not that it's not a good value, but it's just beyond a reasonable price range for that kind of investor. For accredited investors, I can't speak highly enough about it. Thank you, Patrick. We're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Monetary and fiscal measures by governments and central banks are inflating asset prices globally. As investors prepare for future inflation, demand for scarce real assets is rising. How does the 1% prepare for this? They invest in art. Masterworks.io is the first company that lets you invest in multi-million-dollar paintings at a fraction of the cost from artists like Basquiat and Keith Haring. 84% of ultra-high-net-worth individuals collect art, according to a 2019 Deloitte survey. And it makes sense. According to Citi Private Bank, contemporary art returned to the 13.6% year over year in the last 25 years versus 8.9% for the S&P 500. Over the same period, art had the lowest correlation to the stock market of the 10 major asset classes. Masterworks.io is making art investing accessible to everyone, regardless of accreditation. Start diversifying your net worth today. Visit Masterworks.io to learn more. See important information at Masterworks.io/disclaimer.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Marin back on the show. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, I really think that Marin has the right business model. I think that other capital introduction people should do it the way Marin does, which is, you know, show your own skin in the game. And it works for me. Frankly, the reason that I favor him, it's not that I don't like the brokers that offer these deals. The reason that I do these deals with Marin is because I know he's done the due diligence because he always has more of his own money to lose than I have of my money. And frankly, you know, he just turned around one deal in a private placement that returned 350% in a year, another deal that's up 15%. So every deal that I've done with him, Patrick, I've been entirely happy with. I can't get him out of salesman mode sometimes.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: But other than that, the guy's a moneymaker. In any event, Patrick, let's move on to talking charts in a chart deck that you have titled— wait for it— Talking Charts.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, you can just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, chart 2 here, S&P 500 continuous chart. And you got it, the gamma trampoline on the bottom.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so on the S&P 500 chart, I mean, the observation that has to be made is, is that we remain in bull trend. That 50-day moving average that is there has contained all the price action in that bullish upwards trajectory. But the one interesting part here is, is that the S&P is struggling to make 52-week highs. And the question really is, is that what will be the tailwind in to drive higher prices. And that's where I want to take the conversation next few charts.
But before we move on, I did want to highlight the gamma profile going in here to the tail end of the June expiry. And what we have is currently the gamma flip level lies about 4,168. Those are numbers provided by SpotGamma Brent over there. And the interesting part is, is that the last time we had that gamma flip, that, that was where we had a big spike in volatility. And, uh, today's lows, intraday lows, came in right around that level. So we're at an interesting moment where the market hasn't been willing to break out to new highs, and yet right below us lies, um, the levels where we could see some volatility return. And so be really interesting to see which way this market breaks in the coming while. My intuition as to which way it goes, uh, actually is a slightly bearish tilt to it, and I'll explain why here on the second chart.
On page 3, we have the chart of the NASDAQ, and one of the things that is a part of my thesis right here is the fact that I don't believe that the market can make its next kind of 5% advance, a 200-300 S&P point advance higher, without proper participation of the NASDAQ and the FAANG stocks. The financials and cyclicals have done so well for the markets and have been really where the leadership has been. But one of the interesting things is the NASDAQ is dogging it. When looking at this chart, it has failed to retest their highs, incredibly heavy rolling over.
And it gets worse if you look on page 4, when you actually target the actual FAANG stocks. And you can observe that on the FAANG stocks, the rally was just outright weak. And when you go to some of the individual components like Apple, Microsoft, and Amazon, They simply can't get any traction, or Tesla, or Netflix. And we really are seeing these big market cap behemoths that simply can't get out of their own way. And the question really is, is can the S&P break out and make that next advance without these— this one important, very market cap heavy sector participating? And I personally feel that this is something that is actually giving some bearish tones to the marketplace, even though the S&P chart on the surface looks quite bullish.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's take a look at volatility in the stock market with the VIX on page 5. And boy, you know, we're just coming off of what seems like— is that a multi-year low?
Patrick Ceresna: No, I mean, it's the post-COVID lows.
Erik Townsend: That's been more than a year now, buddy.
Patrick Ceresna: It has been more than a year. But I think the observation that I wanted to point out here along that key support line is that when we got— had that May spike in volatility that saw us shoot up towards 28 to 30 on the upside was the last time we had again that gamma flip. So when we talked about it on the S&P chart on page 2, just really trying to identify what could arise if we just had any 50 to 100 S&P point correction kick in, it would certainly potentially have another proper spike of volatility into the mid-20s at minimum. And this is why it's such a critical moment, because the contracting volatility has actually been an important tailwind to the market up until now.
Nonetheless, I wanted to move on to page 6 and just show that breakout candle on the dollar index that we talked about in the market wrap. And while one day never makes a new trend, and it's certainly— we've had 2 false start breakouts on the dollar in the, in the last couple weeks, and each time the sellers came back pretty quickly and the price action has been relatively weak. But, uh, I think that the support line that we— the multi-year support line on the dollar index we talked about even last week, I think on first test will hold. And so it would be very natural for the dollar index to bounce back toward 91 to 92, but the jury will still be out even on a rally like that whether that's enough to change the predominant bearish trend that's been so dominant for all of the last 6, 7 months.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it'll be interesting to see how that plays out. Frankly, I think that the more that I hear of the bearish trend that's been dominant, what I hear is a lot of bearish rhetoric coming out of people who in a lot of cases are making arguments for why they think the currency should be weak on an absolute basis.
But they're making a forecast that has to do with its outlook on a relative basis, relative to other currencies. And although I think the absolute outlook for the dollar is horribly bearish, I think it's completely— jury's out on whether it's up or down for the dollar relative to the other currencies. It's competition between central bankers, and we don't know how it's gonna play out yet. In any event, let's move on to crude oil, my favorite subject, on page 7.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And this is where I wanted to just kind of observe some things beyond the fact that crude oil is breaking to a fresh high. So we clearly have a technical breakout to that 52-week high. And crude oil looks like at this point moving to $70 to $72 in the next week or two, it would be a very natural thing to occur.
But what I find particularly interesting is if we go to page 9 and look at gasoline futures, uh, we have not seen gasoline futures break to higher highs. And often we see the correlation between the two. Now, that doesn't have to always be the case. I mean, that's why crack spreads widen and narrow. But it'll be really interesting to see whether other markets like this start to confirm the oil breakout or not. And this hasn't happened yet.
Uh, another really interesting thing about the crude oil breakout is, is that we're not really seeing it move the entire term structure. And this is where I wanted you to come in and give us some more context on this. But we continue to see all the longer-dated crude oil contracts still trading in the mid-50s, and it really continues to just be a steepening of the backwardation in this curve that is being driven here. I mean, how steep can this curve get in your mind, Erik?
Erik Townsend: It can get steeper in my mind. We do have finally the Z1/Z2 spread that Or what some people call Dec-Red-Dec, the difference between the price of crude oil that is delivered in December of '21 and December of '22. The difference between those prices is back over $5 this week. It had been trading below that for the last couple of weeks in this consolidation. We're back above that.
I think it goes considerably higher. Now, there have been times when the crude oil market Which has really seen substantial backwardation because usually of geopolitical stresses, where you get a difference between months where the average is more than $1 per month. So in other words, it would be $12 of difference between December of one year and December of the next year if the average difference is $1 per month of price. Right now, it's less than 50 cents on average. It's running less than $6. I do think it has further to go, and I don't think that there is any reason to interpret the back-of-the-curve prices not coming up as being bearish. The, the fact that the term structure is steepening is a sign of increasing bullishness in terms of market participants and outlook.
I expect the steepness of the term structure to continue to steepen as we continue to move on into next year. And I think it potentially gets dramatically steeper between 2022 and 2024 if a number of things all happen to line up the way I think they might. It's too early to call that one yet. But as far as right now, I do think it gets steeper from here. And I don't think we're done yet.
Patrick Ceresna: What do you think would be the circumstances for us to see the entire term structure level rise like a tide coming in where we see $60 or something at the belly of the curve?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I can't help but wonder why you're asking that question or what insight you think is revealed by answering that question. I mean, unless you actually want to make plans to take delivery of crude oil yourself 10 years from now and you want to lock in your price right now, we're looking at this in terms of what does it mean for the front month.
I don't think that what happens in those back month prices really tells you very much. The back month prices really are a product of market expectations that lead to certain amounts of backwardation or contango. And then they're all anchored to the front of the curve where the price discovery occurs on the front month contract. So Patrick, as far as what happens to the price of crude oil in 2027, it matters from the perspective of analyzing the shape of the term structure, but I don't think that absolute number is meaningful in the way that you're alluding to.
But Patrick, going back to page 7, I want to ask your opinion because you are the resident technician. Look at this chart. Obviously something big changed in November. That was the beginning of an epic rally that took us through the beginning of March. Then we consolidated for a couple of months and now we're breaking out.
Uh, how do you think about this chart as a technician? In terms of trying to choose a target for where the market might be headed, I mentioned a simple measured move technique that I've applied. You're the better technician. What techniques would you apply? How would you set price targets for where this rally might ultimately top out?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think the shorter target lies in the $70, $72, but that's like something that could be achieved within, within a week. Weak on the upside. But if this is a legitimate bull breakout on that, then definitely the targets all lie in that kind of $80 to $90 range on the, uh, on the upside. I think the, the most important thing when you get a breakout like this is to actually see whether the bulls can hold it. And what often is the, a bearish sign is if we saw the entire breakout given back in its entirety and more and we go back to trading, you know, down into the mid-60s. If we saw that, then that would put a kind of a big damper on this breakout. So really, I think going into next week, you want to see whether or not the bulls keep the price action bullishly advancing. Lots of confirmation from other markets. I want to see the energy stocks also starting to participate with more velocity.
And if we see that kind of price action, Then your targets up into the, toward 90 are all achievable if they can keep building the momentum on this.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 10 and lumber futures. Boy, what an interesting chart. We've kind of got a, looks like a blow-off top and then an echo blow-off top.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so one of the key things that I was watching, obviously we came in with a pretty significant short-term parabolic blow-off on the upside, back at the start of May, and we saw the lumber futures give back close to $500 off their peak highs on the downside. But when we got that reversal approaching $1,500, that was actually a very important moment to see whether or not the bulls had enough gas in the tank to make another run towards all-time highs. And the fact that we failed and have more or less been very very distributive in the price action. There's an increasing chance that we have seen peak lumber on this intermediate high level, and it's entirely possible that we're going to see it work its way down toward $1,000 on the downside. And it's not a crazy thought to go back to $1,000 because if you go back and look at several years, even a decade of price action on lumber, We have not seen 1,000 until this breakout.
And so for us to actually consolidate down to and stay above 1,000 would still, in the much, much bigger picture, be bullish for lumber. But it's simply at this stage that short-term high is now leading to this distribution cycle.
And that's where on page 11 we have that lumber term structure. And again, we're in a similar situation in terms of backwardation, the You were describing it in, in the oil market as well, which is that front month lumber contract is trading up there in the $1,300+ level. But, uh, almost, uh, all of the contracts in November and farther out are all, uh, trading at $1,000 or less. And really, uh, kind of goes to show that this entire lumber surge may very much have been, um, dare I say the word transitory in terms of short-term demand. versus the supply that was available. And maybe we'll see a bit more of a normalization in lumber prices in the next half a year or so.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, what do you make of the very sharp turn down in gold? And of course, it was commensurate with a turn up in the dollar index. Some people, I'm sure, are saying, that's it, the gold market's gonna crash from here. I don't think so. What do you think?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think that gold, after that really solid 2-month run, needed to have a point where the rally was checked and just to wash out the weak hands that were chasing this market higher. But what's interesting is, is that much of the entire consolidation of gold that happened over this 6 months prior to the breakout saw the price action trading below all of its moving averages. And so what's interesting is that this correction lines up where a 50% retracement comes for a test right into the moving averages and its December lows. And so I think that a pullback in gold towards $1,800 would be actually quite natural.
But the real tell will be whether the bulls buy the dip and hold the line in those support lines. If we see another, you know, $50 on the downside of gold and the buy-the-dip traders solidly defend it and reverse it off those levels, that actually would only reinforce the fact that gold has shifted into a new bull phase.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I just wanna clarify what you said about the $1,800 level as the 200-day moving average. My chart has the 200-day moving average around $1,850 and has the 100-day moving average at $1,800. Are we talking about the same 200-day moving average?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. Thanks for bringing that up because we have to clarify that. Yeah, you're looking at the simple moving averages, which is actually quite commonly used. It's not wrong, but I, in this particular case, I have the 50 and the 200-day exponential moving averages, which are just trading at a different level. And so it is, I guess, important to observe where that simple moving average is in there. But the support line that I was talking about, where the 50% retracement Fibonacci retracement level is, is all around that $1,800 level.
Erik Townsend: Well, that makes perfect sense. And of course, listeners, for any of you who want to be on top of this stuff and know the difference between an exponential moving average and a simple one, check out page 13 of the chart deck where you can sign up for a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading, and learn all about it with Patrick's Chart Techs every single day of the week. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by masterworks.io, bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Patrick, tell them what's in this
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the chartbook that we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a ChartPoint article titled Bulls and Bears and a link to an article discussing militant ESG on oil will trigger consequences elsewhere. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend, that's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com. MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend, Patrick Ceresna, and Jonathan Tepper, and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Larry McDonald — New York Times bestselling author and curator of the Bear Traps Report (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices, episode 273, was recorded on May 27th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by AbraSilver Resource Corporation, a premier emerging silver and gold exploration company ticker ABRA on TSX Venture and ABBRF in the United States. New York Times bestselling author and curator of the Bear Traps Report, Larry McDonald, joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss inflation, bond yields, market outlooks, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck will be titled Touring the Commodity Stocks. We'll take a look at the various different commodity stocks and see where the trading
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, let's jump into that S&P 500 because we're back very close to the 52-week high and the market's just muddling along up here. What's your take? Do you think we punch to new highs from here?
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't know, Patrick. We've gone almost 2 whole weeks without a new all-time high on the stock market, and we've reached a point where most people think that's an unusual circumstance. So yeah, I think we go higher and I think we keep going higher and higher and higher until someday this all breaks. And when it breaks, I think it's gonna be really ugly. But I don't think that day is anytime soon. And I'm leaning towards the melt-up continuing.
It will be really ugly someday. But, you know, right now I think the conditions warrant further melt-up before there's any catalyst I can see that would cause all of this overvaluation to actually have an effect on the market.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's move on to the US Dollar Index. I mean, we're more or less pivoting right off that 90 handle. It's pretty much unchanged from where we were closing last week when we were recording. What do you think is the next move here on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we traded for a good solid week there below the 90 handle on the dollar index. And I think that's kind of a first. Yeah, we're back above it now, but by what, like 3 basis points as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon? We did test 89.50, which has been a critical level. We didn't close below it, but boy, you know, we're getting closer to it. It feels to me like we've kind of reached a moment of truth here, Patrick. This market's either going to continue consolidating sideways like it has been, or we're going to see a breakdown below $89. Which one's it going to be? Well, I'm not sure, but why don't we ask this week's feature interview guest, Larry McDonald, that very question.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik. Well, let's get to the crude oil markets because we're very close to a 52-week new high. Quick recovery off of that dip the other week. Do you think we're heading towards $70 here?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I do think that we're headed toward $70 and higher, but it's not quite time yet. And the reason is I think the market is still just a little bit preoccupied preoccupied with this question of what happens when Iranian supply comes back on the market. And my answer to that is it's already been priced into the market. Everybody knows this was coming. What we didn't know is the exact timing of when it would come. Looks like maybe it's going to happen a little bit sooner. Maybe that's going to affect the price a little bit, but I really don't think it's big and important. It has been holding the market back, and right now we're fighting critical resistance right at $66.60. As we're speaking now, we're only a nickel shy of that, so it's possible that we'll close above $66.60, and I hope we do because that would be the indication that maybe that breakout that I'm expecting above not just $66.60 but eventually breaking out above the previous cycle high at $68— I think it's all coming, Patrick, but I don't think it's coming until June, you know, until we get into the first or second week of June.
I think that's when the rally starts and it continues, and eventually by Labor Day we end up with a high oil price on the year, somewhere between $80 and $90, which is where I think we're headed.
So that's my outlook. But I don't think that all happens until people stop being preoccupied with whether or not Iranian supply is going to be an issue or not. And so far, that seems to be what's on everybody's mind. But we're right on the edge of breaking past $66, spot $60. And I think if we get a daily close above, it's likely that the upside will continue from there. We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, how did the inventories come in?
Erik Townsend: It was another drawdown this week, Patrick. Crude oil drawing down 1.7 million barrels. Now, that's going by the number everybody follows, which is the one that excludes the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. And the logic for why we exclude the Strategic Petroleum Reserve is that's not commercial storage, that's the government storage of oil. Well, wait a minute. In this circumstance, it really is private storage. There was an exemption made because of the COVID crisis allowing Private storage in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, and that's what's being unwound here. So I think we really had a drawdown of 3.3 million barrels.
That's the number including the SPR, but the official number is only 1.7 million. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 1 million barrels, gasoline drawing down 1.7 million barrels, distillates drawing down 3 million barrels. So between 3 million barrels distillates, 1.7 gasoline, and 1.7 crude, you've got a total petroleum product build of 6.4 million barrels.
Patrick Ceresna: Wow.
Erik Townsend: Needless to say, that's bullish and it's been helping the price action.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's talk gold because another week, another set of multi-month highs as bullion has now temporarily seen highs above $1,900. Does this keep going or are we overdue for a little pullback?
Erik Townsend: Well, I definitely think it keeps going, at least in the big picture sense of things. But hey, we just broke through the 200-day moving average and a very common pattern in technical analysis is when you break through a major level, you see that breakout, And then you go down and test that level as support before moving higher. We still haven't had that back down to the 200-day moving average, test it as support, and then move higher from there. Doesn't mean we're going to get it, but if it does happen, don't let it spook you out. It's a good sign, not a bad sign. Where I think we're eventually heading though, Patrick, is to new all-time highs in gold, well over $2,000, probably well over $2,500 within the next couple of years.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's touch on that 10-year Treasury yield. So we had high inflation print, we have a big new fiscal deal We have all these different data points and some yields just don't seem to be reacting to it and actually in fact backing off. We're at 1.60 here at the time of recording. What's your take on where we are with interest rates?
Erik Townsend: Well, the short answer is I don't know. I don't have any strong conviction, but my kind of thinking here, my initial thought is I think that what's happening is a lot of people got spooked out by the government spend and, oh my gosh, it means they're gonna have to float all these bonds. And, you know, that, that, that's what led to that backing up of yields. I think the market has sort of thought it through now and realized, wait a minute, you know, the Fed's going to be involved in buying some of that debt.
They're not going to let rates get to a certain point. And the market, I think, has processed, yeah, as much as they're going to issue a whole bunch of debt, they're also going to probably buy up a lot of that debt. It probably is not going to lead to the backing up of rates that some people feared. Now, Now, that's a guess on my part. It could go the other way, which is I and a bunch of other people could find out that, yeah, it really can lead to a backing up in yields of, you know, we're looking at 4% next year. I don't think it's going to go that way. I think it's going to go the other way. But I'm going to keep asking our feature interview guests because frankly, it's still a mystery to me.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Larry McDonald is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. The first episode in Michelle Dennedy's 5-part series about the role of digital innovation in advancing the ESG economy features Gajen Kandiah, CEO of Hitachi Vantara, and is available now. The second, featuring Greg Lavender, Chief Technology Officer of VMware and Managing Director of Cloud Architecture at Citigroup, airs this Saturday morning. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Larry McDonald, the man who wrote the New York Times bestselling book on the collapse of Lehman Brothers. These days, Larry writes the Bear Traps Report. Larry, it's great to have you with us. Let's start with a question I've been asking just about everyone because everybody's changing their story, which is Inflation versus deflation. So many of our formerly devout deflationists have turned inflationista on us. Where do you stand? What do you see on the horizon?
Larry McDonald: Yeah, I'm in the inflation camp as well. It's, you know, if you think about the previous decade and the investment community globally, I think that, you know, we're looking at $100 trillion of bonds that are below 2% in yield and close to $17 trillion in the NASDAQ 100. And so net, net, net, the entire investment community of the planet Earth is essentially in a 2010 to 2020 portfolio allocation.
And I think what's been happening over the last like 60 days to 90 days is we've had these tremors, these growth-to-value tremors in the market, and they've been just, just like tremors before a quake, they've been picking up with intensity. And it's clear that to me that there's just literally trillions of dollars that's misallocated that's going to have to migrate. And right now there's probably already a trillion that's already moved, but, you know, 3 or 4, maybe 5 more trillion has to move in the next 6 months. And so that's where, uh, you know, the system is buckling a little bit, but What we're looking at is the previous decade, we had Brexit, trade wars, obviously COVID, austerity in Europe, austerity because of obviously Greece. We had a Grexit and a Brexit, massive austerity in Germany with incredible surpluses, and austerity in the United States.
We had a sequester that took the deficit from $1.1 trillion to $500 billion. Over three years between 2011 to 2014 or so. So I mean, this is just we had supply chains that were smooth as silk, and so we have like ten or twenty things from 2010 to 2020 that fostered this incredible deflationary period, this just mind-boggling bull market and bonds to the point where.
In the fourth quarter of 2019, bonds were bid without in September, October, no offer. I mean, just incredible. And that was before COVID So now as we look forward, we're looking at a Biden administration that is so determined. I mean, they lost the 2010 midterms by 63 seats, Obama-Biden. And they're going to spend like there's no tomorrow, especially in the third, fourth quarter of this year with A new, you know, enhanced powers of reconciliation, which you only need 50 votes.
And at the same time, there's just more fiscal largesse around the world. And so the pressures on inflation are substantial, much more substantial than they were 10 years ago. And especially if you look at the Fed as well.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about what this means for Treasury yields, because some people have been saying, hey, if we've got inflation coming, it has to mean that we're headed toward a regime of higher bond yields. Other people say, no, wait a minute. It's nothing about inflation that causes higher bond yields. It's policymakers reacting to inflation that caused the higher bond yields. And there's a lot of reasons to think they're not gonna do that this time. So how should we think about the relationship between the coming inflation, if you think an inflation is coming, which I certainly do, and what it's gonna mean for the regime of Treasury yields that we have?
Larry McDonald: So, you know, so the Fed is doing $120 billion a month. QE. And there's some talk— we run a Bloomberg chat with about 650 institutional investors on the buy side, so pension funds, mutual funds, hedge funds. And I'm hearing more and more talk about a shift toward— because the mortgage, the housing market's on fire, and they're buying $120 billion a month of mortgage-backed securities and Treasuries. So I think one of the surprises looking forward that will— if yields get out of control, which they should toward the end of the year, I think passionately and with the highest conviction that politicians are going to force the Fed into some type of yield curve control.
And we're talking about another $2 trillion to $2.5 trillion of spending. And we're talking about a $5 trillion fiscal plan that's already been passed. So, Interest on the debt now is almost 10% of the budget, and entitlements and interest is close to 70% of the budget.
So there really isn't a lot of room for the Fed and Treasury. So at some point in the— I think within the next 6 to 9 months, the Biden team in their quest to win that 2022 midterm and really spend the way they didn't spend in 2000, you know, I guess 10. They feel like they didn't go big enough.
They're going to force the Fed into some type of yield curve control. And the first stage of that will probably be they just pull back on the mortgage purchases and put that allocation over to Treasuries. And, and that should be very supportive of metals, gold, silver. And I think that's why we've had this big turnaround in, in gold and silver. You know, clearly growth expectations have come down because we've had, you know, a tough jobs report. And but at the end of the day, the market's starting to look forward to, uh, this, this more fiscal globally. And, uh, the Fed— and, and if you just look at all the Fed speak, Rich Clarida has, you know, talked up, uh, Operation Twist-type operations and This would be like a new type of Operation Twist. So yes, I see real yields going much higher later in the year, and then the Fed trying to, you know, pull creative levers to arrest that ascent.
Erik Townsend: Larry, let's talk about where we stand with respect to this global pandemic that is upon us. On the one hand, it seems like at least the pandemic is starting to come under control. But the other side of this, which not too many people are talking about, is the US government has finally come out and officially recognized something And then he also said something which I think has been obvious from the beginning, which is that the most likely explanation for where this virus came from is a lab leak, not a natural source. And it's not a crazy debunked conspiracy theory. It's actually the most likely explanation for how this happened. That seems to me to set the stage. Now that we have the US government officially saying that this virus may very well have been leaked from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, possibly.
Larry McDonald: Possibly.
Erik Townsend: from research that was being funded by the US government. Boy, it just seems to set the stage for maybe another round of significant geopolitical tension with China in coming years. How do you see this unfolding? As I know, you're something of an expert on US-China relations.
Larry McDonald: Yes. I mean, it's, it's amazing. If Trump says it, it's pooh-poohed. But now it's kind of gone mainstream. And it's almost better that Trump's not saying it because now people are taking it, you know, much more serious. And, um, you know, this— there's 2 things really. There's the— there's that dynamic around, around the COVID origination. And then this— I think another backdrop to this is this— the insults that are— that, that China has put forth on the Paris Climate Accord are just— I mean, just off the charts.
You're talking about 1,000 coal plants that are in operation now in China and another 25 to 30 that are in planning stages. And you're talking about a substantial, you know, whatever Europe's done around Europe last year took 17 gigawatts off the global stage in terms of carbon. And China just put that on and then some. And so there's a real conflict coming up here where I think we, we're going to have to have— like in the Trump days, we had the trade war.
And at some point, there's going to be, uh, I think over the next year, more sanctions toward— green sanctions on China. And, um, you know, the big winner there would be U.S. nuclear power, uranium. But, um, that's one thing that, that I think is, is becoming very, very You know, obnoxious. It's India, China, especially China, the amount of coal plants that are, that are coming online relative to their promises of 2016.
And then, uh, this COVID situation around this news cycle around information coming out of Wuhan, uh, both of those things set up for, uh, you know, a much higher level of, of tensions between the US and China.
Erik Townsend: So let's translate all of this backstory into a market outlook. What is the Big picture macro outlook in terms of equities, bonds, everything else. What do you see? What do you expect?
Larry McDonald: Well, the big thing is the reopening. So India a month ago was in a horrific COVID cycle. And now cases are crashing in India, crashing in Europe. We're going to have much better vaccine distribution in India. India is a colossal diesel fuel user, oil user. You're talking about 6% of the global consumption, up from 3%, maybe 8 or 9 years ago. So, and growing fast. I mean, India population is growing 3 times faster than the European continent. I should say more so Germany and Italy, for example. So you're talking about 1.4 billion people that's growing at a very strong clip.
And You're talking about a large group of people that are still vastly addicted to diesel fuel and oil. And so this sets up for, with vaccine distribution, with a much better situation in Europe in terms of reopening and vacations.
I just think this ESG situation in the United States and around the world in terms of oil and shale is just unbelievable and cold. I mean, we're going to have in the next 12 months the most spectacular ESG backfire because we're going to have a vast reopening. Demand's going to come back really strong, especially in countries like India as they come back online. I mean, think about India. India and Europe were just in a horrific lockdown and oil was essentially ouch for a month or two. I mean, oil should have been off 20% on that news. So that tells you that there's a pent-up demand problem and the US doesn't have the ability to— the last 10 years, Erik, because the ESG backdrop was so liberal in the United States and wasn't there as vigilant as it is today, the last 10 years, the US could ramp up production very fast.
And now because of ESG. I mean, I talk to a lot of bankers in our chat, in our Bloomberg chat, our institutional chat, and around the world. And it's just the ability of coal companies and shale companies to finance projects has just collapsed.
And this, the snapback in the United States, the United States has lost the control of the production snapback. And that's going to put more price control in the hands of the Saudis and the Russians. And they're just going to drive, you know, I think we could have $100 oil and much higher coal prices over the next 12 months, like, and especially in the ESG side on coal, because coal, met coal is the steel producer of the world right now. I mean, we're years and years and years away from hydrogen-produced steel. So you're talking about companies like coal, Arch Coal, ARCH, That I think would be a double over the next 12 months, trading at 3.5 times EBITDA, dividend increase probably coming by year-end. So we're looking at, we have a basket of what we call our ESG backfire basket. And that's kind of the focus of it is energy, it's oil and coal.
Erik Townsend: Larry, I couldn't agree more on higher oil prices coming. Talk to me a little bit about what the drivers are that you see there, but also where do you see the energy plays specifically? Is it just in oil and natural gas, or are other things like renewables and nuclear going to come into the fray? Where do you see the energy trading opportunity in this market?
Larry McDonald: Yes, so exactly. So on the energy side with oil, just the backdrop of the ability to come back online with production in a faster format is that that's much more limited. So we see really a vast supply problem climaxing in the first, second quarter of next year. Second quarter of next year as the summer driving season approaches. But from a perspective of China and India and the amount of coal plants on the earth and their relative pickup of nuclear power, there's tremendous pressure on China and India to take down their additional coal plants. And put more of a nuclear component into that mix. At the same time, you've got in the United States John Kerry that's flipped on nuclear power, Jennifer Granholm at the Department of Energy, she's flipped dramatically. The Biden team's flipped dramatically in terms of energy support for the U.S. nuclear power industry. So there's just once again, this is a similar to the oil dynamic, but. Times 10, the world
in 2025 to 2030 is short about 10 million pounds of uranium, I think, because China has to double their stated plan to bring at least, I think, probably 60 nuclear power plants online over the next 8 years, an additional 60 in China and an additional 25 to 30 in India.
And then the United States, the US, you know, the Biden administration and the Trump team both in agreement where uranium has been a, like a national security problem because we're not producing our own uranium in the United States. And, and so what happens is when you have this ESG dynamic around fossil fuels like natural gas, we're seeing much higher natural gas prices, higher coal prices. That makes nuclear power much, much, much more competitive.
And this ESG dynamic around natural gas is powerful. You've got, I think the new handle is 3 to 5 on natural gas. That's been a real, that created this 10-year, helped create this 10-year bear market for nuclear power and uranium. So if you're a uranium purchaser, like at a power plant for the last 10 years, you could sit back.
You didn't have to prop what we call You didn't have to front buy or proprietary trade your uranium inventory. You could just sit back and purchase. And we're seeing all kinds of indications that the power plants in the United States and around the world are starting to prop uranium. And we're seeing some institutional clients trying to front run this process.
And we've seen China already, you know, they're upset about the iron ore stocking. And so what happens in a dynamic like this when you have just tons and tons of unintended consequences from government policy, we call it the cobra effect. But what happens is in the free market, a lot of market participants will try to front-run demand and that'll force a lot of these power plants to pay up and then start to buy forward uranium. And so the uranium industry is only $21 billion in size. I mean, it's an absolute joke. I mean, Bitcoin is still close to half a trillion dollars in size. Dogecoin is like, I think, $50 billion in size. And the entire uranium industry is worth $21 billion, $22 billion. I mean, this is the easiest the best risk-reward trade I've seen in probably my life. I think you have like 5 to 8 times upside and clearly 40% downside, but your risk-reward to being long URNM, CCJ, URA, these ETFs in the uranium space is just the best I've ever seen.
And on top of it, The Edge, the U2's famous player there in the famous U2 group, You've got celebrities like him that just in the last 2 weeks are coming out nuclear. So the wokest of musicians on the planet Earth have now switched to supporting nuclear. It's the only way to get to the green meadow. It's the only way for China. It's the only way for India. It's the only way for the United States. And I think that the world is just vastly supplied about 10 million pounds short over the next 10 years. So So we're going to just see one of the best trades of our lifetimes in this space.
Erik Townsend: The URNM ETF has more than doubled in the short period since they advertised on MacroVoices. I'm personally attributing the entire turnaround in the nuclear space to MacroVoices advertising, but I also respect that there are other macro drivers, which I suppose could have had
Erik Townsend: something to do with it. Let's talk about where the real opportunity is going to be for investors. Is it nuclear? Is it going to be, you know, some people are saying The copper demand has got to be just off the charts to build out the electric grid that's going to be necessary in order to support electric vehicles. Where are the best trades in the greening of the global economy?
Larry McDonald: One of the trades that we like the most is in the hydrogen fuel cell space on the metal side. So Impala Platinum, a South African company, trading at a very, very cheap multiple, about 2.5 times EBITDA, and trading at a 20% free cash flow yield. You're talking about platinum in the production of hydrogen, which is a major component. And so right now, in the entire dynamic of demand for platinum, there isn't a hydrogen demand element right now.
But if you think about electric vehicles and you think about big and large vehicles, much larger vehicles like buses and trucks and ships, hydrogen is your answer there, much more so than electric vehicles. So electric vehicles is your copper play. And we definitely see, you know, a massive global shortage in the copper space. But for larger vehicles, Last week there was a Shell deal, and we're seeing more and more large-scale transactions on the hydrogen fuel cell side. And it's just a matter of time, like this time next year, there's going to be a much higher demand element in the platinum space.
And so Impala Platinum, Stillwater, SBSW, those 2 equities are You know, once again, I see 300%, 400% upside, you know, 40% downside. But just the greening of the large-scale buses, trucks of Europe and the United States are going to go hydrogen. That's going to create a new 20% additional demand for platinum. And the amount of platinum on Earth relative to, say, gold is just literally like 1/100th in terms of In terms of annual mining, and so we just don't have a lot of platinum out there. At the end of the day, Erik, there's something going on that is just so you know what despicable around the media's focus on this green revolution, and nobody's doing the math on how we're going to get there in terms of the metal side. And our team has spent a lot of time in the last like six months.
But companies like Teck Resources on the copper side, we think that that stock's a double from here with their properties in the copper space. And then Impala Platinum and SBSW Stillwater on the platinum side.
Erik Townsend: Larry, I want to move on to an advanced terminology topic that I got from your newsletter. For anyone who is not familiar with your writing, please help us understand the new financial terminology, Alpha Male Central Banker. What does that mean?
Larry McDonald: Well, if you think of like the 2010 to 2020 period, the alpha male central bank was the Federal Reserve, and the Fed was pounding their chest hawkish in 2011, '12, '13, created the taper tantrum in 2013, and then they robustly proclaimed in 2018 that they could take $50 billion a month of balance sheet off the Federal Reserve balance sheet, down $50 billion a month at one point. That's what they were claiming they could do.
And then in 2015, '16, once again, they were promising us, pounding the table, they were going to deliver 2015, '16, 8 rate hikes. And each time, the dollar ripped, the amount of trade in the world that is in dollars is just enormous, potential 60%, 62%. The amount of debt on the planet Earth that's in dollars, emerging markets, essentially, the Federal Reserve blew up the global economy 3 different times.
Countries like Brazil were in flames with massive political risk in 2018, because you had oil prices moving higher with the dollar. So, if you're in a country like an emerging market country where there is no rail system and major commodities are transported by trucks. I mean, this is just a devastating blow to countries like Peru, Chile, and Brazil. And it created incredible amounts of civil unrest to the point where it looked like Ciro Gomes was going to win the 2018 election in Brazil.
And it's a real radical leftist. So these things have massive repercussions. And then we go into COVID. Where the central banks and the governments of the emerging markets had nowhere near the bandwidth to take on this beast of COVID and to spend their way through it. So essentially what happened behind the scenes is— and we're convinced, we said this to clients last year— the only way out of this is a globally coordinated alpha male handoff from the Fed, who was the alpha male in 2013, 2015, '16, and 2018, to the PBOC in China, the Bank of England, and lo and behold, the Bank of Canada is the big taperer now.
So we have, we have a situation where the Federal Reserve has transferred the reins of the alpha male central bank to other central banks. This is putting tremendous pressure on the dollar, and it's something that investors just haven't seen, aren't used to, and they're all waking up to it. At the same time, the global economy is reopening. That's why there's just been so much relentless pressure on the dollar. And we see a major break here. We think the dollar's, you know, it's been on 2018 support for much of the last 2 weeks. And this is the second time it's been down there. And when it breaks, it's going to be an incredible flush and it should break as we reopen globally.
And as these alpha male central banks around the world are far, far more hawkish, pulling back accommodation much faster than the Fed, the Fed is now a woke central bank, a social justice Fed that is dedicated to fighting inequality. Looking at U6 unemployment in the United States at near 11%, you're talking about 8.5 million Americans. That are still unemployed out of the US labor force relative to January 2020.
8.5 million people. So the Fed has to dig in here in their woke social justice inequality Fed regime. They've been thoroughly embarrassed of the previous decade. You could make the argument that the Fed helped put Trump in office by those dollar moves decimated middle-class voters in Michigan, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania, those states flipped to Trump. So this whole dynamic of a social justice Fed and alpha male central banks in Canada, in the United Kingdom, and China has flipped the switch and has put tremendous pressure, secular pressure on the dollar. It's going to make new lows as we speak.
Erik Townsend: Tell me more about that breakdown that you see coming in the dollar, what drives it, and how far can it go? Because as I look at this chart, you get below 89 on the dollar index, at least from a conventional technical analysis standpoint, there's not a lot of technical levels to look at there until you get much lower.
Larry McDonald: Yeah, exactly. And this is why you need to reallocate the portfolio out of tech and growth and into more value names. We've seen these growth-to-value tremors over the last couple of months, and they're getting stronger and stronger. And portfolios like the EWU ETF, that are long companies like Glencore, Rio Tinto, big commodity producers, oil companies like Royal Dutch Shell and BP.
You want to be long a portfolio that has exposure to global value stocks— Vodafone, Glaxo, IBM names. I mean, these names have just been dreaded. I mean, massively under-owned. And there's a couple trillion bucks that's going to come out because we're going back to more of a 1970s, 1980s regime where value outperforms growth. And the dollar, once it breaks, the forces are just so many now because once again, the Biden team, it's the opposite of 2012. In 2011, '12, you had the sequester coming in. Where Republicans were taking that budget deficit from $1.1 trillion down to $500 billion through— they forced the sequester onto President Obama. And the Democrats don't want to lose that midterm, that 2022. At the same time, the Fed was, you know, in a, you know, taper regime, and now we're in a social justice regime.
And at the same time, you have $64 trillion of gross domestic product globally, $64 trillion of GDP that's outside the United States. There's only $20 trillion in and $64 out. And guess what? That $64 trillion is reopening at a much faster pace now. So the US, what they call American exceptionalism, that was like January, February where the US had the fastest mover advantage on the vaccines, on distribution, on COVID tests.
But now as the world reopens and as COVID fleets, this is what's going to break the back of the dollar. At the same time, the Biden team is going to come up with this spending plan in the 4th quarter. And it's just— I just see this. It's going to be just a colossal flush. And that will break the back of these tech stocks. And it's going to be the biggest portfolio reallocation of our lives because everybody is set up for the previous decade. Everybody's set up in deflation portfolios and everybody's going to rotate into value names that really have been unloved for a very, very long time.
Erik Townsend: Well, if you're right and this event happens, I mean, I think you and I agree that a breakdown below 89 on the US Dollar Index, that's a once in every so many decades event because that's such a key technical level that if it breaks that, it's probably going not just a little bit lower, But a whole lot lower. So what are the implications of this? Obviously, you just mentioned a couple of them. It means we need to be thinking about having things like gold and oil in our portfolio, because those are the things that are going to benefit from a weakening dollar. What are the other consequences and implications of this change that you see on the horizon?
Larry McDonald: Yeah, exactly. So it's been 10 years of owning financial assets. Every family in America, every wealthy family in the United States of America is long financial assets, and they don't own any hard assets. The allocation of commodities and portfolios and value stocks is at 20-year lows. And so that's the biggest change.
The other is— the other to really look forward is this dynamic around— and our next book is on this subject— around the generational conflicts that are going to come up the next 10 years are You know, just blood-curdling because the millennials have been handed $170, $160 trillion of unfunded liabilities. They now have $30 trillion of federal debt. You have the top 100 companies in the United States, the top 100 control 91% of the profits. And when I was growing up in the '80s, that number was like 65, 70.
And you just have this raging inequality that, um, that is, it's just, you know, underneath the surface, there's just the social bubbling is coming forth. Now, the good news is the millennials are going to inherit the next 15, 20 years $70 trillion of wealth, right? So you're going to inherit the $70 trillion of wealth, but that wealth is in tech stocks. Bitcoin, property, you know, growth stocks, 401s. So if that wealth gets a hit and that, that, that millennial group that has been saddled with this colossal pile of debt, at some point there is a risk of what, you know, we call in the Bible. We look back to the Bible and you can go back thousands and thousands of years. We've seen multiple debt jubilees where one generation is handed, you know, a really bad deal financially and just walks away from— and we're already seeing with student loans, you know, there's just a social movement, you know, not to pay.
And, um, you know, one thing the woke movement does and doesn't do is it doesn't stop from one topic to the next. It keeps going. These people don't stop, my friends. So they just keep going. So they'll go from, you know, student loans, and they'll eventually work their way into some type of mortgage debt or government debt. And in some respects, you can see some of the point because this generation is being saddled with a colossal financial obligation that they really didn't have anything to do with.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit about what we should expect from this reopening. So many people that I hear, analysts, pundits, saying, well, you know, There's going to be very, very compromised demand for travel. People are going to be afraid. They're not going to want to go out. You know, Larry, I'm just not buying it. I just take the way I feel, which is, look, I'm waiting for this thing to be over. I don't want to go travel if it's still endangering my life to do so. But as soon as it's safe, if anything, this pandemic has taught me time is precious. I want to go travel like I've never traveled before. And I predict most of the world is gonna feel that way. Of course, not everybody can afford to, but to the extent that people can afford to— and by the way, they're gonna be getting, a lot of them, a significant amount of stimulus payments and other transfer payments— people are, I think, are going to spend money and travel and, you know, party like it's 1999 as soon as the borders reopen.
I guess that's a very non-consensus view. What do you think?
Larry McDonald: I agree. I'll tell you, so our book came out. It's now in 12 languages, and it's one of the best-selling business books in the world. It was just voted by the CFA Institute one of the top 20 books of all time. So when you have a bestseller, I tell my wife once a month, if we sell a million books, we'll break even on our Lehman stock. As a former Lehman trader, and I'll tell you some fascinating data. So The Bear Traps Report typically in a year will spend, because of the speeches around the world, will typically have 4 or 5 to 6 speeches.
And many times those speeches are paid for in terms of travel, but we're seeing clients, we're doing things. So we'll spend, call it $150,000 a year of travel, and we'll typically do events in maybe 6 countries. Each year, 6 to 8. And so last year, that budget went down from, say, $150,000 for our small company to $9,000.
And now this year, the amount of events that we've seen come back online, we're going to spend— we're not going to spend back to $150,000. You know, it's a small company. But I could see us up at $100,000 by year end, and I could see it's well over $150,000 by next year. So when you talk to families, and we have like a lot of different— we probably have 700 wealth advisors that are our clients, and they're, they're going to do like at least 2 times the vacations that they, that they didn't do last year. And there's a real feeling around the people that suffered, you know, the people in the hotels, the chambermaids, the, the bartenders, You know, you want to get out there and take some time and spend and support some of the people that went through an extremely difficult time. At the same time, you want to get out, you know, get rid of this cabin fever.
So that's where this dynamic around energy prices and this unintended consequences of ESG has taken so much supply offline that if this travel revolution really picks up, and granted, there's places in the world like in France, mobility isn't as easy as it once was.
But, you know, especially in airports, but you can drive through Europe. So you're going to see a colossal pickup in energy demand and, and a real reopening demand. And I completely agree. I think we're going to have a much, much bigger surprise on the upside in terms of travel demand.
Erik Townsend: Larry, before we close, I want to ask you a final question on the energy sector, because I know you have a lot of background on the credit side of markets. And I wanna talk specifically about what the end of the age of oil is going to look like in terms of its credit dynamics. And what I mean by that is very specifically, a lot of people are saying, look, we're in the final decade or the final 2 decades. Nobody's really sure how long, but we're gonna shift away from fossil fuels to electric vehicles and so forth. And well, therefore it can only mean one thing, which is energy prices are gonna eventually crash. And I think the opposite, Larry. I think what's gonna happen is we're gonna run outta credit to invest in new production and so forth because everybody agrees that it's a go-nowhere, dead industry.
And we're gonna end up unable to supply and meet that last demand for petroleum because everybody assumed the whole energy industry was going outta business and nobody invested in anything. And you end up with a crisis at the end where there isn't enough because you haven't completed the transition soon enough and nobody wants to invest in the old stuff. How do you see this playing out? Do you think we have a situation at the end of the age of oil where there's too much of it, we produce too much, and we're just never sure what we're gonna do with all that extra oil that we dug up? Or are we gonna have a shortage?
Larry McDonald: Yeah, exactly. I mean, this is a classic unintended consequences ESG overdose that it's going to have the most spectacular cobra effect, uh, where, you know, we talked about in India in 1890 they had the cobra problem in the, in the countryside and the communities and the towns and the cities. So there was a coordination with the King of England and they put a £1 bounty on every cobra.
And lo and behold, it worked for a little while. You actually had an arrest of the cobra dynamic. So the cobras were captured. But then all of a sudden, a number of creative cobra, you know, farmers started farming these cobras and selling them back to the United Kingdom and the Indian government. So you had this dynamic where the government actually had to come in and cancel the whole regime policy plan of cobras. And what did the farmers do?
They released all the cobras into the wild. So 8 years later, 6 years later, you had 3 times the amount of cobras. So this is the unintended consequences of government policy.
And with the energy space, I completely agree. I think it's worse with coal. Like, coal prices could triple because you just have had such little access to capital markets financing.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Larry McDonald: And so that's why we really like the Arch Resources names and things like that.
But on the energy space, this is so important because I spent— before our book, A Colossal Failure of Common Sense, I ran one of our distressed businesses at Lehman. And so I lived through a lot of credit cycles with the commodity names. Commodity names were always big high-yield bond issuers.
And what has happened over the last year— this is once again the unintended consequence The Fed has been so accommodative on the asset purchases for such a long period of time. They're not allowing the business cycle to function. So the traditional business cycle, which has a cleansing process where companies, if they don't finance themselves correctly, they'll run into a credit market that starts to shut down and there's a huge default cycle.
This whole dynamic has been dramatically changed with this incredible amount of accommodation. And this sets up, I think, a spectacular opportunity on some of the equity sides and equity plays in the commodity space, because these companies have been able to extend maturities much further and much more profound than they have in previous decades.
And what that does, Erik, to the equity Your equities have become essentially a long-term cheap option or a warrant. In other words, the normal cycle of debt financing and near-term debt maturities in the commodity space, the typical default cycle that we saw— that massive default cycle we saw in the energy space and coal space in 2016. PBD, one of the most profound— 2016, '18, some of the most profound energy companies went bankrupt.
Now all these energy companies have extended maturities vastly, in an incredible profound manner, which I've never seen before. And so your equities in the commodity space, and in any cycle, the first move is into the quality thing. So think about the commodity cycle. I've seen this in the high yield market, investment grade market. The first move is into quality names and then the mid-quality. So you look over the last year, everybody went into gold first. And then toward the spring and summer of last year, people moved into copper. Then they moved into oil in the 4th quarter when we started to get the vaccines. And now uranium and coal are the plays. So you will always see this cycle of the tertiary parts of the commodity space. The demand will start to pick up. And we're investors. Move from the higher quality names to the lower quality names.
And I just think that the credit market backdrop is so supportive for the commodity equity space now, much more than— you're talking about a sector that went through a colossal, horrific default cycle in 2016, and then another in the 4th quarter of 2018, and then a COVID default cycle.
So the commodity space has been through 3 You know, massive default cycles. These companies are lean and mean. And we have a model portfolio. People can check it out on our beartraps.com website. But I think that's one of the most sexy stories for the next couple of years is some of these commodity equities with much cleaner balance sheets.
Erik Townsend: Well, Larry, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Listeners, we have a treat for you, which is in your Research Roundup email. You'll find a link to download sample issue of the Bear Traps Report, which is Larry's newsletter. I think you'll find it extremely informative and very much worth the read. Larry, before I let you go, I want to touch on your book. Now, your first book, A Colossal Failure of Common Sense, was pretty much the book to read on the collapse of Lehman Brothers. New York Times bestseller, very, very successful book. You've written another book. What's that about?
Larry McDonald: Okay, so we're, we're, you know, I think we'll— I think it'll be out by hopefully by the 4th quarter, 1st quarter next year. But it's— it starts at the Lehman era and it connects the Lehman. If you think about global populism and markets, this Lehman event triggered just a crazy dynamic between the millennials, the Gen Xers, and the baby boomers, right? So The Lehman event created such a horrific financial crisis. To get out of that, the Fed and more the US government took on a decent amount of debt. And then as we move toward COVID, so you've had the Lehman-COVID connection, those 2 events have dramatically increased unfunded liabilities and just the national debt of the United States. So we go back to Lehman, we start there.
And we look forward at the next, you know, 30 years. And, you know, Alexander Tytler and Alexis de Tocqueville, some famous economic philosophers that go back to the 1700s and 1800s, always talked about a cycle that my dad brought up to me when I was about my teens, late teens. And if you think about the cycles of republics and democracies over the last 3,000 years, you always— there's a startup, there's an origination. Think about the United States as an origination in bondage, and then you move to patriotism, uh, entrepreneurship, abundance, you know, massive wealth creation phase, and then a dependent dependency phase, and then an apathy phase. And then invariably, um, these cycles end up back in bondage. Because when the voters realize they can vote themselves and raid the public treasury, at some point in time, too many people in societies, whether it be in Rome over 1,000 years ago, to the Mayan civilizations, to Argentina, to Venezuela, even Puerto Rico, you've had these cycles where, you know, if you look at Venezuela now, you're back in bondage.
And if you look at Buenos Aires, and you're talking about one of the most beautiful, pristine gem cities in the, in this, in the 1800s on the planet Earth, you know, the wealth in Buenos Aires is just incredible. So these cycles have been going on for thousands of years. And, um, the United States has the blessing of the Federal Reserve and MMT that's extending the cycle. So instead of having to sell bonds, the US voters are voting themselves to raid the public treasury, and the Federal Reserve is financing that. And so the question is, does that extreme financing weaken the dollar this year and next year? And then eventually we go back toward this cycle. And I'm not saying we're going to be in bondage or anything like that in the United States, but it's clearly— you can see that we're in the middle to later innings of the dependence to apathy stage, where an incredibly large percentage of Americans are supported by, um, transfer payments.
And, you know, we're talking about, you know, the largest percentage in the last 100 years. And so these, these events have dramatic consequences. And that's what our book is all about, is looking forward and how do we invest in that type of, uh, regime.
Erik Townsend: Well, Larry, we look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Looking for exposure to rising silver and gold prices? AbraSilver Resource Corporation, ticker ABRA on the TSX Venture Exchange and ABBRF in the United States, States, is rapidly emerging as one of the premier silver and gold-focused exploration companies. AbraSilver has an advanced-stage project with a large resource base of over 140 million ounces on a silver-equivalent basis and continues to announce several very high-grade silver and gold drill results, with more results still pending. AbraSilver is very well funded with a strong shareholder base and excellent exploration upside potential. You can find a link to the latest press release in the Research Roundup email. Visit abrasilver.com for more information. That's abrasilver.com for more information on this silver and gold exploration stock.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Larry finally on the show. You know, he really has some strong convictions about things like the dollar and, and on so many of these different commodities. So I decided to put together a chartbook just to kind of talk about all of these things. Looking forward to, to kind of going through it all here. Uh, what did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I thought the most important thing about this interview was the extent of Larry's conviction on the dollar bearish outlook. I'm not agreeing or disagreeing with him. I really don't know. But what struck me about this is, you know, the market's going to tell us because frankly, that 89 level really kind of has to hold on the dollar index. If you just look at the chart from a technical analysis standpoint, if it doesn't hold, the next support is way the heck below that. There's lots of room for it to just crash from there. So it kind of has to hold. In case it doesn't, And the way I'm looking at this is I don't think I'm smart enough to really have a view. I don't have the confidence that Larry does, but I do think we're gonna find out pretty soon here. Either the dollar's gonna break below 89 in the next few months or it's not.
And if it doesn't, I think it kind of makes an important point. And if it does, well, then I think it's probably gonna keep going. I don't really have any strong conviction about where that's going or what the outcome's gonna be, but it does make me think, Patrick, that I really ought to be getting my thinking around the US dollar kind of together and be ready for it when it does happen, if it happens. So let's go to the postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com.
Erik Townsend: Just go to the homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads right above Larry's picture on the homepage. Patrick, let's take a look at page 2 where you've got the US Dollar Index. What are your thoughts if we did get a breakdown below that 89 level.
What do you think the next logical target is? Seems to me like it's not just a little bit lower, it's a lot lower.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. I mean, I want to make a couple of bigger observations and then talk about some targets. I mean, one of the interesting things is that a lot of people, when they hear about the idea that the US dollar is going to have some big bear market breakdown, they immediately associate it with the US dollar losing its world reserve currency status. This, and somehow it's, it's the breaking of the dollar. But, you know, when you go and look at the last, you know, 30, 40 years of charts on, on the dollar, there have been 2 occasions where the US dollar lost 40-plus percent of its value in these kind of like half-decade-long trends. And we really have been in a very sideways trade range-bound market for the last 5 years, and we have not had a big currency move. And it really does ask the question of whether one is coming here.
And more importantly, if we did have a dollar breakdown, I mean, especially for something like the dollar index, which is trade weighted against predominantly the euro, it by default implies that the euro would strengthen immensely over that period. And the question is, in a period where they have themselves all sorts of issues with debt and things like that, will they, can they sustain a much much stronger currency on a relative basis. And one way or another, we are at a pretty critical moment. And this is the something that Larry was talking about and yourself. And it is a moment where we're going to find out whether this trade range that's been in place more or less for the last 5 years is finally broken. Obviously, a retest of lows that we saw from 2008 to 2014, which are all around the 80 level on the index, are entirely on the table. If we have a breakdown, and this is, I think, one of the bigger macro questions to solve.
I think almost all the major commodity bull markets that we have seen in the past often came on the back of a weak dollar cycle. And so a breakdown here of this 90 level would certainly be a tailwind for that commodity bull market story, which we're gonna be talking about.
Erik Townsend: I definitely agree that it would be a major tailwind for the commodity bull market. I just haven't decided if it's gonna happen yet.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think the market will tell us. We don't have to decide for it, right?
Erik Townsend: Well, and that was exactly my point before, is I think the market's going to tell us and tell us in a big way. And in the case of the dollar index, I think we're going to get that decision from the market relatively soon. I mean, in the next few months.
Patrick Ceresna: For sure. And so on page 3, I wanted to just show that crude oil chart. And crude oil has respected that 50-day moving average very well. I mean, it's, it's interesting. It seems, uh, that that 50-day moving average has worked worked well for all— not only commodities, but obviously the stock market and a whole array of different stocks. And what we had was a scenario where we had a very quick dip on the downside of crude oil, and it immediately got bought on dip and worked its way to the, to the upper end of this range. What's particularly interesting about this is that crude oil seems to be poised for that potential breakout, but not very many other commodities are. And it's interesting that, uh, that crude oil is such a huge market on a relative basis to the other commodities This certainly is gonna be one of the big questions as to whether or not there's still a little bit more left in this reflation trade.
If we see that punch to $70-plus on the upside, that will certainly get things buzzing in the markets.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, and notice also, Patrick, the tops all being aligned. Going back to the March high that we had in crude oil, that actually got up to $67.98 on the front-month contract, not on the July contract, 'cause back then, you know, in the beginning of March, At that point, the April contract was the front month, but the July contract never got above that. And we're right back up to pressing the same highs or, or testing the same resistance level on the contract chart that we were testing back in March. When we get through that level, the way I look at this is, even though it doesn't quite visually look like it on the chart, we've really been consolidating since March trying to get above that $66. $66.60 level on the current July contract. And I think that when that breakout happens, it probably sets the stage for a pretty significant move up from there.
The thing is, I don't know if that move starts next week or not for 2 or 3 more weeks. We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, I wanted to just touch on some of the energy stocks themselves. On page 4, I have the XOP, which is the oil and gas exploration ETF, and I particularly chose this over the XLE, which is very heavily weighted in the majors. And what we have here is a chart that looks actually somewhat similar. It's pressing toward its 52-week highs. And I actually think that this could break out here in line with oil.
But one of the interesting observations I was gonna make was we're starting to see divergent price action amongst the basket of energy stocks, particularly a few of those majors like ExxonMobil, which has been in the press and a number of these other ones that are transforming themselves. And we're starting to see less and less energy companies actually breaking out. And so the breadth is thinning and I'm trying to figure out whether or not that's significant, the fact that we don't have a very broad-based participation on the upside. But certainly in the case of the XOP, I think it looks like it's poised to follow through if oil breaks out.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, it's noteworthy too that the closing print is what's most important, the closing price. And I just want to let our listeners know, I've described earlier in today's podcast in the market wrap, hey, it's not quite the close yet. We're still below $66.60, and that's the critical level. As we're speaking right now, Patrick, we've still got 45 seconds left until the pit close, but the price is shooting up through $66.88 as I speak.
Patrick Ceresna: Wow.
Erik Townsend: In other words, we're getting the closing print above 66.60, and I think that's a signal that maybe a breakout is beginning that's going to take us much higher. We'll let you know next week whether that was right or not.
Erik Townsend: In any event, Patrick, let's move on to page 5 where you've got the Metals and Mining ETF, XME.
Patrick Ceresna: Right, and this is a broader basket of mining stocks. It has steel stocks and aluminum stocks like Nucor and Alcoa. And it also has a number of gold miners like Newmont and Royal Gold in the baskets. And so this, after just consolidating for a week, looks like it's ready to go for another attempt at a 52-week high.
And it's really working higher. And so these mining stocks really don't seem to want to quit. And it really does feel like there's— they have at least the price action continues to be very bullish and all dips seem to be bought. And it looks like they're going to at least take a stab at making a 52-week high early next week.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I agree. I think that both precious metals and other mining, like copper mining, looks pretty darn good here. And sure enough, on page 6, you've got a copper chart. Tell us more.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, well, this is the Global X Copper Miners ETF, the COPX. And what's interesting here is, is that we once again are finding that 50-day moving average being tested on pullbacks. And in the typical fashion that we see price action work is that you have 52-week new highs and then it mean reverts and corrects back toward the average, finds support, and then bullishly breaks out. And here we have that same scenario playing out. It'll be really interesting to see whether this is where a brand new bull advance in copper can begin.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, you've got the URNM uranium ETF on page 7, which has more than doubled since I bought it when they first advertised on MacroVoices. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And I, you know, Larry was talking about uranium quite a bit, and I thought it was worth putting up some charts on this. And again, almost all of these cyclical-style resource companies and ETFs for them have just remained so very bullish. This uranium ETF made a fresh 52-week high in May. The entire consolidation has been just sideways holding at above all of its previous highs that made in February and March, and once again is attempting to break out higher. I know Larry mentioned companies like Cameco, which continue to press 52-week highs as well. And so the uranium space continues to behave very well.
And so with the uranium doing well, what's interesting is we move on to page 8 there, Erik, we have the gold miners ETF, the GDX. And what's interesting is the gold miners were the ones in the doghouse through much of the start of the year. The first quarter of the year, they were just not participating while almost every other resource sector was. And what we've seen is since the start of April, that really clean bullish breakout on the upside, and the gold miners have really joined the party. And it's interesting to see that during the pullback that we've seen in copper and a few of these other areas, gold has just held up like a champion. It'll be really interesting to see whether when we inevitably get some sort of a market correction, whether it's rapidly bought on dip to show the characteristics that are very typical of something that has begun a new bull cycle.
Erik Townsend: Now, Patrick, Larry also emphasized the importance of coal mining. Is that why ARCH Resources is here on page 9?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I just wanted to put some context into where the coal miners were. They were one of the last best spaces to start joining the commodity bull market party, right? And, and when we look at Arch Resources the ARCH, we can really see that it spent an extended period of time consolidating through almost all of 2020. And just recently here in the last month have we broke above all of those previous highs around the $50, $52 range that were there for the last 6 And so it really does look like the coal miners are getting a little bit of a breakout, and we'll see whether that leads them to heading back toward their 2019 and early 2020 highs. What I also wanted to show though was another coal miner in Peabody, and this is a far more volatile one, symbol BTU, on page 10. And what's really interesting is just shows the devastation that the coal miner have been under during the last 2, 3 years that saw the stock wipe out from $45 basically down to under a dollar.
And we're really now seeing an extended basing formation establish themselves and they're just starting to turn up. It'd be really interesting to see whether that view by so many people, including Larry, that these coal miners are turning really starts to gain some traction.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's a really interesting story because the ESG movement has essentially shamed the professional investment community out of investing in coal, even though it's actually a profitable investment.
Erik Townsend: That leaves opportunity for other people. In any event, for our listeners who want an even better deal, you can get Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading, completely free of charge— well, for the first 14 days anyway— by signing Sign up for a free trial at bigpicturetrading.com. Details on page 11. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole.
And by AbraSilver Resource Corporation, a premier emerging silver and gold exploration company, ticker ABRA on TSX Venture. Venture, and ABBRF in the United States. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: You're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to download Larry's Bear Traps Report and the link to the chartbook that we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to Zoltán's latest shocker, The Taper Will Be Bullish If... as well as a link to Seth Levine's article, Inflation, is shortages and thankfully transitory. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with MVR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Erik Townsend: Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research. Library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management. LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
David Rosenberg — David Rosenberg, founder of Rosenberg Research (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 272 was recorded on May 20th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Freelancer.com, the internet's premier website for putting independent freelance contractors in touch with employers who need their services.
Our search for credible deflationists continues with David Rosenberg returning as this week's feature interview guest. Rosie will explain why he still sees deflation as the governing force and why he disagrees with the suddenly all-popular inflation narrative. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick's chart deck will be titled Talking Charts on Commodities and Crypto.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's get to this S&P 500. I mean, more or less we've been chopping around going into this option expiration, more or less holding pretty close near the highs with the S&P 500 close to 4,200. It's at 4,157 right now. What's your take on the market here?
Erik Townsend: You know, I don't have much conviction at all about where stocks are headed from here. I will say we seem to be testing that 50-day moving average, or the time between tests of the 50-day moving average is getting shorter. And we certainly did see Instead of getting another rally off that last test, you know, we have, we have 2 tests of the 50-day now with no rally to new all-time highs in between. And that might be a change. So I am seeing more and more signs that this market is getting toppy, tired, heavy, and so forth. But frankly, you know, as much as I want to make the argument that everything's overvalued and we need a cyclical bear market here, I've been thinking that for years and it's not happening. And I think the reason it's not happening is we also have that crack-up boom force in the economy.
And I don't think Making any big short bets on indices is a good move here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because the US dollar continues to be very weak, gravitating to those 2021 lows that were put in at the start of the year. Do you think the dollar's gonna find support here?
Erik Townsend: Well, certainly things are getting real now, Patrick. We're back into the danger zone, if you will. There's only been 5 daily closes below 90 on the June Dollar Index contract. So, you know, out of the entire year of 2021, only 5 daily closes, one of them We've had 2 closes this week, and we're going to have a second one today unless there's a miracle. So, you know, we're getting to pretty close to that 89 critical support level. We still need to get below it. Daily close below 89 would certainly change the game and say that there's maybe a lot more downside still to come. That won't surprise me, but, you know, the signal's not there yet. We're still waiting for it.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, now we gotta talk crude oil because crude temporarily at the start of the week was toying on an intraday basis with a fresh year high, and then suddenly things reversed. That has reversed very quickly in the last couple of days. What's going on?
Erik Townsend: Well, that sudden reversal in the last couple of days is entirely about several different leaked comments from various different officials alluding to the idea that the US sanctions on Iranian oil exports are about to be lifted or under discussion to be lifted. In other words, essentially what they're saying is that President Biden is about to undo what President Trump did with Iran. Iran will be back in the business of selling oil. And on the one hand, you know, that is a really big deal. Iran's oil production is very significant. And if it were true that that oil were all off the market and all suddenly coming back onto the market, it would be a very significant supply and demand imbalance story. Frankly, I don't think it works that way, Patrick.
I think that all of that Iranian oil has been being sold all along on the black market. A lot of it's probably going to China. Now China's going to have to pay market prices for their Iranian oil rather than getting it, you know, On the QT, so to speak, from Iran or through who knows what intermediaries. They're gonna have to come out of the shadows and do it in the lit markets, and it's gonna cost 'em a little more. But in terms of supply-demand balance, I don't see it suddenly changing anything. It's not like a couple of years ago where Iran had, you know, tens of millions of barrels of oil literally just in tankers and floating storage sitting there waiting to send someplace. That's not the case right now. So I don't think this signal is as big of a deal as everybody else seems to think it is.
But that is And that is the factor, Patrick, which has been jerking the market lower this week.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what did the inventory numbers come in at?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, we had a build this week of 1.3 million barrels of crude oil. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 142,000 barrels. Gasoline and distillates were the big drawdowns, 2 million barrels in gasoline and 2.3 million barrels on distillates. So those finished product drawdowns exceeded the size of the crude build. So on the net, it was still a drawdown in petroleum products this week. US production holding unchanged at 11.2 million barrels.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, I wanna talk about gold because it's just been great price action. It seems every little sell-off is being immediately bought. Gold keeps working its way higher. We're at $1,881 at the time of the recording. What's your take here on gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, I really wanna hand it to you, Patrick, for that Chart Tech we had several weeks ago, which you titled, Hey, It's Time for Gold. And I remember you told me off the air, like you thought this is the moment. You nailed that call because this chart just looks so bullish. We went right through the 100-day moving average. down at 1,800, climbed up over a fairly short period right through the 200-day moving average without really pausing even. So far we've had a total of 4 daily closes over the 200-day moving average, which is just around 1,863. And although there was a brief intraday dip back below it, it's pretty much held above it. As soon as it broke above, it stayed above and it stayed there for several days. These are all really bullish signs.
I did get a couple of listener questions this week, Patrick, people saying, Hey, you told us last week you're not buying any more mining stocks because you've already got enough. How about telling us the ticker symbol so we can buy the same stuff that you've got? The reason that I don't tell the ticker symbols of what I buy in terms of mining stocks, Patrick, is primarily because I get those recommendations mostly out of Marin Katusa's newsletter. It's a paid subscription newsletter, and out of respect for his paying subscribers, you know, I don't want to tell people what his calls are. But Now, the structure of those deals also, the reason that I choose those stocks is because Marin negotiates great deals for accredited investors. If you're not an accredited investor and you don't have access to those deals, I'm not sure that the stocks that I've chosen because of the special deals I was able to get through Marin are really, you know, even the best stocks for people who aren't buying them that way.
So that's the reason that I don't give any ticker symbols.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's get to that 10-year Treasury yield because I really thought that that high inflation print, if there was ever a catalyst that could drive yields to a fresh year high, that would've been it. And instead, more or less, we've been muddled. I mean, we're at 1.63 on the 10-year yield and doesn't seem like bonds wanna go anywhere. What's your take on the price action over the last week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I'm gonna qualify this to say I don't have really strong conviction. You know, don't blame me if I get it completely wrong. But the way I feel about this is I think people were really starting to freak out and think, oh my gosh, you know, the big secular trend in secular bond bear market The end has begun. The sky is falling. The world is ending. Look, at the end of World War II, when rates bottomed and turned up again, there was a decade between bottomed and turned up again before they meaningfully started to turn up. I think it's gonna be a long, long time before we have 5% plus Treasury yields. And I think that people were starting to freak out about that. Seems like everybody's calmed down and the scare is over, but I wouldn't be surprised if we just test that 1.7%, level again on the 10-year if there's another scare, another wave of it.
And so let's see what happens. Fear and greed, Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is David Rosenberg. Now, Erik, why did we get David back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, as our regular listeners know, we have been on a quest to find credible, intelligent, smart people who are still deflationists to share that view because so many people have turned inflationists. David Rosenberg is one of the best respected economists in the entire industry, and he's probably One of the last deflationists standing. I think Dr. Lacy Hunt, who's just as prominent and just as well-known and just as well-respected, also a deflationist. We'd like to get Dr. Hunt back on the program. But until then, I think David Rosenberg's about as prominent as they come, and he is very much still in the deflation camp. So let's find out why.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with David Rosenberg is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole.
The 3rd and final episode in Todd Buchholz's 3-part series, Crossing the Bridge to Renewable Energy, is available now and features an in-depth interview with Josh Crumb, founder and CEO of Abaxx Technologies. Michelle Dennedy will be back in the host chair on Saturday morning to chat with Gajen Kandiah, CEO of Hitachi Vantara. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is David Rosenberg, founder of Rosenberg Research. David, I've really been looking forward to this interview with you, specifically because all of our best macro experts that used to be devout deflationists have turned inflationist, to the point that we literally really have to go looking to find a deflationist left. Tell us your view. Has the world changed? Is it all inflation from here?
David Rosenberg: Well, I mean, that certainly has become the narrative in the markets and in the media. I personally find it difficult to believe that the first global pandemic in over a century managed to unleash the inflationary forces that we couldn't generate over the course of the past 4 decades, that somehow it's the pandemic.
And the policy response to the pandemic, which has been to basically try and fill a leaky boat and preserve social stability, that we somehow now have in our hands a sustained inflationary experience to deal with. I think that we've just swung the pendulum the other direction. This time last year, we had 3 months in a row of negative CPI readings. We had 3 months in a row of declines in producer prices. Commodity prices across the board were plunging more than 20%. And if you remember, there was a day where the front month contract on WTI actually went negative.
So did we get an outright pernicious sustainable deflationary experience? The answer is no. What we had was we had a global shock, the pandemic, and the shock created the conditions where initially The plunge in demand more than offset the reduction in supply, and that created the conditions for several months of negative pricing.
We fast forward to the current environment, and we have this situation now where, courtesy of the economy reopening, the vaccinations, all the fiscal juice that's in the system, demand has come back vigorously. And at the same time, the supply side has lagged behind. So we have this disconnect right now in the opposite direction. between supply chains and demand. And it is creating— I mean, nobody in their right mind could tell you that we don't have inflation right now.
Inflation in the sense that we do have a temporary period where pricing is accelerating in several of the COVID-related sectors and in parts of durable consumer goods where there are shortages.
To me, it is borderline disingenuous to say, well, the vaccinations and the reopenings are going to create the conditions for a surge in demand, but somehow the supply side won't come back. The supply side will come back. All you have to do is take a look at the dramatic increase we're seeing in shipments and exports out of Korea and Taiwan, and all they really do is make semiconductors.
So with the lag, that's going to help ease the pressures everybody's talking about in the chip industry. And you just have to take a look at the container ships that are filled to the brim outside the ports of LA and Long Beach, which are the 2 busiest ports in the United States. They haven't been unloaded yet, and partly because of the lingering impacts of the COVID But to suggest that the supply will not come back to me is ridiculous.
To start talking about labor shortages indeed, because you do have some people that do fear going back to work because the pandemic is not over, not even in the United States. And I say that With over 40% of the population having been fully vaccinated, we will get there in probably 4 months if you're talking about herd immunity.
The lingering impacts of the pandemic, the variants, are keeping people at the margin reticent to going back to work.
Of course, we have these extended, extremely generous jobless benefits that are paying people more to stay at home than to go back to their old jobs. This will all fall out of the data come September, October, where I expect the supply side is going to play catch-up to the demand side. We have to keep in mind, what is the story on the demand side outside of the vaccines is fiscal stimulus.
But all the fiscal stimulus is just all very temporary. As we saw with the April retail sales data, everybody blew their brains out on the spending in March.
We have a stop-and-go economy on our hands. The fiscal policy and the short-term nature of the stimulus has just accentuated the volatility in the data. I actually believe that come the fall, we will start to see the reopenings having a positive impact on aggregate supply at a time when we're going to see fiscal withdrawal having a downward impact on demand. A lot of the inflation we're seeing today is going to reverse course, I expect, either by late summer or early fall.
Erik Townsend: Now, one of the arguments that a lot of people are positing here is that we've got a situation where there's been a political shift, where the last 10 years of QE has resulted in inflation, in a sense, in asset price inflation. The reason that these people have suggested that it didn't go into consumer price inflation is because the money didn't go into the real economy. Now we've got a shift where the government aid money is being much more directed toward Main Street than Wall Street. Doesn't that change the calculus?
David Rosenberg: I keep hearing about that we're into a new era and that I keep hearing these words of regime change, but I heard the same things when Barack Obama got elected in 2008. Regime change, a socialist, Out of Illinois, going to shift everything to the left. And of course, we got Obamacare.
And then we had the bailout of the banking sector. That really put the lows in for the stock market back in March of '09. And then we had Ben Bernanke, who was and is a Republican with repeated QEs, zero interest rates. I mean, keep in mind that by the time the last expansion was 6 years old, The Fed was keeping the funds rate at zero and relentlessly expanding its balance sheet.
So you could have argued back then that we had big regime change on our hands, but where was the inflation when all was said and done?
And then we have Donald Trump being elected in November 2016, and tell me that we didn't have regime change on our hands. Do you remember how many times we were told to read that book, Hillbilly Elegy? And Stephen Bannon, and we had a new era. Unless I'm mistaken, didn't we not have a new era with Donald Trump? Protectionism, isolationism, nationalism.
In Donald Trump's inaugural speech in January of 2017, he used the word protection 9 times, and he surely went ahead with trade barriers and tariffs and restricted immigration. And so where was the inflation? Where was the inflation? I remember everybody talking about inflation after Donald Trump got elected and we're going to have fiscal reflation because of course he cut taxes and ultimately took the deficit up to $1 trillion by the end of the last cycle. And $1 trillion, I guess at that point we viewed as a pretty big number.
So I hear regime change all the time whenever we get a political shift. We get regime change. If I'm not mistaken, we were supposed to have regime change all the way back with Bill Clinton back in 1992. What happened to that regime change? Look, I've made my living and a career out of fading just the phraseology that comes out. Where is this regime change? We were talking about that we didn't have trickle-down, all the gains in the stock market, the real estate market, But someone's got to explain to me how it is that Donald Trump didn't get reelected more because of character and personality issues than it had to do with how he handled the economy because his approval rating on the economy right till the bitter end was his strongest point.
Where does this come out about the haves and the have-nots and there was no trickle-down? When month in, month out towards the end of his presidency, all Donald Trump talked about was how the unemployment rate for African Americans and for Hispanics and for Asian, for all minority groups, youth, women, they all went to historic lows, all-time lows.
The reality is that the data are where the data are. Those were areas where he was actually correct. We went into this pandemic, if you don't mind me saying so, And I would throw the question back with unemployment rates among minority groups and the youth and women, the lowest levels on record.
So explain to me again what was broken. We had a 10-year economic cycle and we had the lowest unemployment rate at 3.5% in 50 years. And at the peak, inflation was barely more than 2%. So what am I missing exactly in terms of this so-called regime change that we're seeing right now? How is that going to cause inflation. You get these people out there and these are smart people. They're economists. These are people I know, many I'm friends with who will tell you, well, look at the money supply numbers.
I come back and say, but for the past 20 years, the money supply numbers have had no correlation with anything except maybe asset prices. You're quite right. We've had dramatic asset inflation. Well, look, there's different ways, even regulatory, That we can deal with that if that's a big problem. But you cannot predict inflation with just the money supply because you have to take a look at money velocity. And money velocity has been contracting for decades because we're choking on too much debt and it has impaired the credit multiplier.
So I don't see that that's changed.
David Rosenberg: Money supply against money velocity is not leading right now to an inflationary conclusion. Oh, people are now saying, well, look at wages. Look at all these companies announcing wage increases. Of course, to lure these people that work in the consumer cyclical industries, whether it's restaurants or in the hotel business or theme parks.
Once again, a little history goes a long way. I remember back after Trump cut taxes on the corporate side and allowed companies to repatriate tax-free their earnings from abroad back home. All these companies, I listed 20 of them in my morning note the other day. 4% of the corporate sector announced wage and bonus increases back in early 2018.
Some bellwether companies too. So where was the big inflation coming out of that? And now all of a sudden, you can't read a headline without some company raising wages.
But where is that really inflationary? How do you just basically say wages go up, inflation goes up, when you know as an economist that it's unit labor costs, it's productivity-adjusted wages that will drive inflation? That was the 1970s. The 1970s, wasn't that wages went up 10% a year. It's that wages went up 10% a year in a decade where productivity was stagnant.
Here we have a situation which nobody talks about what's really important, which is that we just got last week a first quarter productivity number that's showing that productivity is running over a 4% annual rate.
Now, whether that's a secular or structural change, I'm not sure. Everybody talks about regime change in an inflationary way, but nobody talks about the fact that that in the weakest year for the US economy since 1946, it was the best year for productivity in a decade. Companies actually realized, for all the lamenting of shortages and job shortages and job shortages and job shortages, the reality is that the corporate sector actually had its best productivity performance in a decade in the same year that we had the worst year for employment since the 1930s.
But we had the numbers for the first quarter and past the eye of the storm for the pandemic. Productivity, even with employment coming back, we had a situation with over 60% of the jobs that were lost have come back.
And yet, even with that, productivity is running over 4%. Now, it's hard to really judge whether that's noise or whether that's a fundamental shift. But let me just tell you that if you have productivity running over 4%, and let's say that that's what the data are showing right now.
You could have wages running at 5%, and they're not even running at 5% yet, and you still wouldn't get the inflation because what drives the inflation is productivity-adjusted wages, not nominal wages on their own. I can't believe how many people can't wrap that simple economic theory around their head.
They come out and say, well, look at the fiscal stimulus, all the fiscal stimulus. Yes, indeed. We have rampant But you can't take a look at the overall inflation and interest rates without looking at national savings. This is the problem people had in Japan, who basically paved more riverbeds and built more bridges to nowhere in the name of fiscal stimulus than Japan, where they've had blowout fiscal deficits for 20 years. And yet, look what interest rates and inflation have done there, because nobody pays attention to what's happened with private sector savings, which has been an offset to the de-savings in the public sector. Everybody's taking this very myopic and narrow view on what drives inflation and what drives interest rates.
So you can't look at fiscal policy without looking at the context of what's happening in the household sector and in the business sector. You look at the business sector, there's been a negative financing gap of over $100 billion in the past year. Companies— and there was an article on this on the front page of the Wall Street Journal the other day— and how companies are retaining cash on their balance sheet.
Okay. So in taking a look at retained earnings, you're taking a look at corporate cash flows, and taking a look at capital spending intentions, there's no signs here that the corporate sector is doing anything but raising its de facto savings rate.
What about the household sector? Everybody's talking about, well, look at this 30% personal savings rate that's out there. That's dry powder for future spending. Well, I don't know. That didn't work so well with April retail sales, did it? It didn't. We don't know where the personal savings rate's going to end up. What we do know And the New York Fed has done the work for us, is the New York Fed has shown that only one quarter of these stimulus checks, and there's been 3 rounds so far dating back to last year, have gone into the real economy.
The other 3 quarters are split pretty evenly between savings, and a lot of that savings is indeed going into the market, which is why you've had this explosion of Reddit accounts and Robinhood accounts. But a third of the money is going to pay down debt.
I'm looking at the bank lending numbers and look at the bank lending reports. The banks beat their earnings. Yes, capital markets activity, wealth management, trading. Look at the loan books of the major banks in the United States. They're shrinking. There's credit contraction in the private sector. You're seeing it in the bank lending data.
So what I'm saying is that you have to take a real holistic view. Inflation and As is the case with most broad economic variables, it's very complex.
But I'm just finding people are either doing partial equilibrium analysis or they're just taking a very narrow view to what ultimately is going to drive inflation down the road. We have tremendous distortions and disturbances in the data. I mean, take a look at what happened in the April CPI numbers. I mean, come on.
The CPI sports ticket price subindex went up a historic 10%. In one month. In one month. But meanwhile, if you took a look from July to December of last year, the BLS wasn't even reporting what prices were doing at sports events from last July to December. The next thing you know, stadiums, arenas, baseball parks, they're filled with 5,000 or 10,000 fans, or they're selling out in Texas because you're talking about people that will pay anything now to watch any game.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
David Rosenberg: Oh, and there's big inflation. This is not anything that's sustainable. You had, uh, what, you had a 10% surge in, in airfares? Yes, they've cut capacity. People are dying to fly. Are you going to tell me like in 6 months the airlines are going to be raising prices 10% again? This is a— this is the one area I do agree with Jay Powell.
There is tremendous noise and disturbance and dislocation in all the data right now because guess what? But we are still living with a global pandemic. There's all sorts of offsets between the reopenings and the vaccines and with fiscal policy, which is very short-term in nature. I'll just hazard to say that this time last year, we're talking about deflation. Now, this time this year, we're talking about inflation. I will tell you with a virtual guarantee, we'll be talking about something else in 4 or 5 or 6 months' time. I'm saying it will not be about today's inflation.
Erik Townsend: But with respect to today's inflation experience, it sounds like what you're saying is the Fed actually has it exactly right in describing this as a transitory phenomenon. We've got some inflation right now because the economy is having trouble getting started up and responding quickly to demand. It'll all come back out and we'll be back to what we've been used to for the last several years. That's the way you see this playing out. If that's right, it means a whole bunch of people are really, really worried.
David Rosenberg: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: wrong, and that means market opportunity, because a whole bunch of things have moved quite a long ways in an inflation is coming, and not just inflation, but secular inflation is coming. If people are wrong about thinking that and we don't really have secular inflation coming, what's the best trade to kind of play that crowd's got it wrong?
David Rosenberg: Well, look, let me just say that I'm not going to actually say that the markets have anything particularly wrong. What I'm saying is that the narrative that you're reading and hearing about day in, day out, that narrative is wrong. Look, the Wall Street Journal runs with an editorial that uses as its inflationary thesis the 1-year inflation expectation component out of the University of Michigan Index, which just came out on Friday.
What they don't tell you is that if you back out the 2 to 5-year inflation expectation, because the 1-year is just— if you plot the 1-year inflation expectation against gasoline prices, that's your story. But the 2 to 5-year, the 2 to 5-year hasn't moved. It's still in the range. For that particular metric, it's 2.7%. It's still in the range, the 2 to 5-year. If you go into taking a look at the TIPS market or the breakeven inflation levels out of the out of the bond market, you'll see that most of the inflation expectation is still very near-term, really out to the next 2 years.
If you're taking a look at the breakeven spreads between 2s and 5s and 5s and 10s and 2s and 30s, you'll see that there's been no big outbreak of longer-term inflation expectations. That's actually very encouraging. It's just telling you that right now, we have a tremendous dislocation. Yes, it's probably going to last a few more months. It's not just year-over-year base effects. There is some real price increases coming into the fore, but what would you expect? I mean, look, we just had a 10% increase in airfares in the CPI index. They're still down 20% from where they were pre-COVID.
The sports tickets and the like that were up 10% in April, They're down significantly from where they were pre-COVID. There's still tremendous amount of distortions. Yes, you're going to find that some companies will continue to raise prices while they can to preserve their margins.
Remember, inflation is a long-term process. There's nothing in there and there's nothing actually in the markets telling you that it's going to be long-term in nature. We have a short-term dislocation on our hands. I do believe that it's going to be resolved for the reasons that I've discussed, which is that demand will slow in the second half of the year, I think materially, once the fiscal stimulus runs out.
I think that April's retail sales, which nobody talks about because everybody's so consumed about inflation, nobody's talking about the fact that core control retail sales were down 1.5% in the month of April. That's a pretty big deal. It's telling you that people already spent what they want to spend out of that fiscal stimulus. There's no pent-up demand in merchandise goods, that much is for sure.
We're not getting another round of stimulus checks. Then we're going to have the jobless benefits that are going to term out. That has to be your expectation.
We're going to have different contours. We will not continue to hear stories of there being labor shortages. beyond the end of the 3rd quarter. That's my expectation. If I'm right on this, I guess that you'd say that whatever inflation expectation that is in the market will come out. I think that that would mean that the Treasury market undergoes a bull flattener.
I'll just say this much. It's interesting that when I'm taking a look at the Cleveland Fed's 5-year Inflation expectation measure. So the Cleveland Fed actually has a model. What's the model for TIPS breakevens? It's not a model, it's just a residual, and it's correlated to the CRB index. And that's all people in the markets look at for their inflation view as they look at the CRB index.
And so you've got these measures, say, in the TIPS area that are at least, call it roughly 2.5%. for inflation expectations in the bond market. The Cleveland Fed's 5-year inflation expectation measure is actually 1.48. It was 1.37 in March, so it's not as if it stayed static, but you see that the Cleveland Fed actually has a model.
I've actually found that their numbers actually do have at least some correlation with the labor market. There is no correlation with the labor market In the TIPS breakevens. It's all the CRB index.
So when you're asking me how to be positioned, look, if the breakeven inflation expectation metrics in the Treasury market converge on the Cleveland Fed's inflation expectation measure, you'd be talking about at least a 25% total return in the long bond in the next 12 months if the convergence happens that the ends up gravitating towards where the Cleveland Fed is, keeping in mind that the Cleveland Fed's model is a real model.
I'd say that if I'm right on this call, because a lot of it is premised
David Rosenberg: on the economy slowing down. Nobody talks about the fact that the Citigroup Economic Surprise Index today just hit the lowest level in 11 months. Okay? Did you know that?
Erik Townsend: I didn't know that.
David Rosenberg: I don't think anybody knows that. Nobody knows that. Well, because why? Because everybody has inflation on the brain. But inflation is really all about a supply and demand curve, aggregate demand, aggregate supply. And we have supply constraints right now. Inflation is going to rise near term. It already has.
And I think the operative— and everybody rolls their eyes when you use the word transitory today. People just laugh at you. But what else could it be? Demand is going— we borrowed so much growth from the future with these rolling temporary fiscal stimulus packages.
We just borrowed all this growth from the future. Look, we just hit 1 million units on new home sales in the month of March. Well, I got news for you. We built— they're up 60% year on year. Now, you'll say, well, that's coming off really depressed numbers in 2020. That much is true, but even if you corrected for that, People talk about, well, housing, there's shortages here. Shortages, they talk about shortages of labor in housing. Meanwhile, residential construction employment in March and April together were up over 30,000. It's just finding people are just making things up.
The reality is that we have no pent-up demand. Autos, 18.5 million units. When you hit 18.5 million units in any cycle in the past, that is peak autos. They are down substantially in the next 6 to 12 months.
Home sales, like I said, over a million units. Last time we were there was in the summer of 2006. Home sales were down 30% in the next 12 months. Housing starts were down 20%. It's very interesting to me that we don't have pent-up demand for the things that normally carry the expansion through the recovery phase. This is how unusual. We're relying on demand to come back with the reopening in airlines and restaurants and theme parks and movie houses. Basically, we're talking about 4% of GDP is where this V-shaped recovery is going to come.
At the same time, because we have no pent-up demand in durable goods, which is a $2 trillion business, that I think is what people are going to be surprised at how weak demand is going to be once we see the emperor disrobed.
When I say the emperor disrobed, I mean that This economy has been medicated so many times on fiscal stimulus. What happens when you take the candy away? Joe Manchin has already said, and there's no more important person in Washington than Joe Manchin, has already said he's not signing on. He is not signing on to more stimulus checks, especially to people that don't need them, which is how this fiscal policy has been constructed.
You're talking to me about haves and have-nots and about inequalities. Here you have the Biden— this is the irony. This is the irony.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
David Rosenberg: Is Joe Biden has only exacerbated those inequalities by giving fiscal stimulus, by stimulus checks to people that don't need it. The New York Fed has already come out and said only a quarter of this money is actually going into the real economy.
3 quarters is not. And about half of that 3 quarters is going into the market. And here we're talking about that we have a new regime of leveling the playing field really by giving money to people to open up Robinhood accounts and to drive equity prices even higher.
My head is spinning over that concept. But the point I'm making is that what people can't see around the bend is that demand is going to be weakening, I think significantly after the second, maybe third quarter, and supply is going to come back and people will be surprised how low inflation is.
So I said bull flattener in Treasuries, And I would say that growth will reclaim its leadership over value since value is so deeply cyclical. Value really needs higher interest rates, higher inflation, which it's been getting for the past, call it, 6 months. But they call it a value trade for a reason because it's a trade. And there's a reason why growth stocks outperformed value 80% of the time in the last expansion.
And it's because the structural factors at work that have kept inflation at bay haven't gone away because of the pandemic or the policy response to the pandemic.
We're talking about aging demographics, which is disinflationary, not inflationary. When you're taking a look at the whole demand-supply effects of aging demographics and you look country by country, we did the cross-sectional analysis on this. Somebody wrote a book and a client of mine sent it to me about how demographics are inflationary. It's like everybody's got inflation on the brain.
No, aging demographics are not inflationary. And aging demographics, disruptive technology, and that's ongoing. And that we did not have in the 1970s. And we're choking on too much debt. That's why money velocity is going down. That's why people are choosing to save most of the stimulus. And so when you have an all-economy, when you look at households, businesses, and governments together, So because we all own this debt, we all own this debt. This debt is all ours.
We can talk about the government sector all we want, but the government represents the people. Debt at all levels of society in the United States has never been as high as it is today, 366% of GDP. That does not include, by the way, the unfunded liabilities in the system.
366% of GDP. I cannot believe how people are not alarmed at that number. It's up 40 percentage points in the past year. Well, of course, we had to fight a pandemic, but you see, we've never had a year where that ratio went up 40 percentage points.
But if you notice in the past 40 years, we peak at a new debt ratio, and yet inflation is peaking at lower and lower levels. Bond yields peaking at lower, lower levels because this is a tourniquet. This is the most pervasive constraint on aggregate demand in the future.
is the grotesque level of debt we have on our hands right now. Now, people will say, oh, but we can afford the debt because interest rates are low. Yes, of course. That's exactly the story. Interest rates can't rise with that level of debt without sending the economy back into a destabilizing recession.
Erik Townsend: David, I'm still having a hard time understanding what seems to me like a dichotomy here, because on one hand, you're saying something which I agree with very much, which Which is the Biden Administration should not be paying people to stay home and not work. And that is what they're doing. But wait a minute, that's the reason I think we do have an inflationary impulse here, is specifically because the government is paying people to, to not work. And, and you're losing supply of labor to people who are collecting a stimulus check.
How, how is it that I get a conclusion that's inflationary and you don't? I feel like I'm missing something.
David Rosenberg: Well, because it's more to do with our timeframe. So if you're going to tell me that the Biden team has taken out blank number of people permanently out of the labor market, I'd say, uncle, I submit. But that's not the case, right? These extended benefits end in early September. So the answer to your question is yes, That's part of the temporary supply constraint. Will the Biden team turn this into a UBI, a universal basic income? Well, let's wait and see for that to happen.
Now, we have at least 10 states run by Republicans that are terming out these extended and overly generous benefits earlier than scheduled. Maybe they'll serve as some useful templates in terms of what's happening to their participation rates and unemployment rates and what's happening with labor competition and wages in those states. So we'll have a few months of a template.
But what I'm saying, I never said to you that we're not going through a short-term dislocation. And part of that is the policy response. But I said at the very beginning of the show that we had 3 months of outright pernicious deflation. Right. A year ago, did it last? Why didn't it last? Was every was everything permanent?
It wasn't permanent. You know, we found out that actually the COVID-19 was not the bubonic plague. It was not the bubonic plague. That this is not going to be a repeat of the Spanish flu that killed so many other people and young people in 1918, 1919. And then we had the vaccinations, which was a huge game changer, obviously.
So if the deflation a year ago wasn't permanent, why do you think that the inflation we're seeing right now is going to be permanent? That's what I'm saying. I'm not saying— I mean, I do have 2 eyes. I do see what's happening in front of me, but I guess it comes down to your question before.
David Rosenberg: I'm not the least bit embarrassed. And believe me, I have disagreed with Jay Powell in his tenure more than I've agreed with him. I probably agreed with him a lot more when he was governor than when he took— but then when you take the reins at the Fed, you become somewhat of a politician.
Be that as it may, I think that the Fed has got the narrative right. I think that they've done a stellar job actually in their communication skills. I'd actually, if I was Jay Powell at the next press conference after the meeting, I would wheel out a blackboard and explain to people what inflation truly is.
And inflation is not 4 months of accelerating prices or wages. That's not what it is. Would you say that Paul Volcker was a big inflationist? Would you say that he was?
Erik Townsend: I would not say that.
David Rosenberg: I don't think anybody would, right? But what if I told you that the price level in his 7 years at the helm of the Fed, the price level, the CPI under the inflation dragon slayer, the CPI went up 60%? Has your mind changed? About Paul Volcker? The price level went up 60% under his tenure.
No, because the rate of inflation, the second derivative, because inflation is a process that went from 12% down to 4%. The inflation rate went from 12 to 4 and he's viewed as the world's most significant inflation dragon slayer of all time, but the price level went up 60%.
But how can you not call that inflation? But he's the inflation dragon slayer. Well, you asked before about anomaly. Is that not an anomaly? It's not because the inflation rate went down. And Ben Bernanke, who tried to create more inflation than Ben Bernanke? His helicopter— his nickname is Helicopter Ben.
He was at the Fed, at the helm of the Fed for 8 years. And did you know that in his tenure, the price level went up like 15%? It went up a fraction of what it did. Under Volcker. Volcker tried to create disinflation and he got it, even though the price level rose.
Who tried harder? I mean, you talk about regime change. I mean, I'm asking you once again rhetorically, there was no regime change with Ben Bernanke.
Who even knew what QE was before 2008? I was at Merrill Lynch back then. I had to do teaching lessons on QE. And they didn't just stop at one QE.
Patrick Ceresna: And ZIRP.
David Rosenberg: Zero rates. And so that wasn't— quantitative easing wasn't regime change. And where was the inflation? Well, all the structural factors I was talking about, which have gone even more disinflationary, acted as a massive offset to anything we ever saw cyclical.
David Rosenberg: I will come back again. The optimist and the pessimist meet for a cup of coffee and the optimist says to the pessimist, things can't possibly get any better. And the pessimist says, you know what? You know what? I think you're right.
So I guess somebody's got to explain to me that if we— how it is, how it is that we got to a 3.5% unemployment rate by early 2020 and late 2019. Lowest unemployment rate in 50 years, coming off a 10-year expansion, a fivefold increase in the equity market, a booming residential real estate market.
And inflation was barely above 2% with a 3.5% unemployment rate, the tightest labor market in 50 years. And the last time we had an unemployment rate that low, the inflation rate was more than double where it was this time around. But yet somehow because of the pandemic, we just miraculously created— we waved a magic wand that we got a new inflationary experience on our hands.
I'm just saying, how is that possible? You're talking to me about temporary dislocations.
I'm saying that in reality, we have a U6, the broadest unemployment rate measure is 10.4%. But I only know my history. You know what? Maybe it's different this time. Maybe it's different this time. But I know from the past that full employment, a really fully employed economy is when the U6 is at 8%. We're at 10.4.
Oh, but we got some big, big wage inflation coming, big inflation with a 10.4% U6. How does that make any sense to anybody? And then of course, we have a cap-U rate in industry, in manufacturing, that's 74%. 74. But I know historically that metric's got to get to 78 to get real inflation, not 4 months inflation, 4 years of inflation. Let's just talk about inflation is not a 4-month phenomenon.
You cannot judge if you're in a bull market or bear market just on 4 months.
Time is every bit as important. Duration is as important to making these calls as magnitude. I'm trying to say here that, well, boy, when I'm taking a look at the unemployment rate in the labor market and where it usually is when we have meaningful inflation, and I'm taking a look at the unemployment rate rate in the manufacturing sector, the cap-U rate, and where it normally is when we actually get more than just a few months of inflation, but a few years.
I get that we still have an output gap in this country of over 2% of GDP, and we're already halfway through the biggest fiscal stimulus we've ever seen before with the stimulus checks that looks to have already been spent in the month of April. So what am I missing? What am I missing? How is it? I'm looking at the supply of labor. I'm not talking about what is temporarily held back for reasons due to COVID or the policy response to COVID. I'm looking and I'm seeing the total supply of available labor in the United States is 17 million.
Before the pandemic, it was 10 million. We have a labor pool that is 7 million. The delta is 7 million over where it was before the pandemic. But all of a sudden, all of a sudden, we have this radical hitting the wall on labor supply.
And I'm thinking, well, that might be the story right now for a variety of reasons that have temporarily held back this labor supply. But I don't spend my time talking about what's happening right now. I talk about what will we be talking about 6 and 12 months down the road. That's how I spend my time because that's what's most important. Because if the markets are forward-looking, why would they care about what's happening at this very moment in time? It got priced in already.
So I'm saying, yeah, what I see is that we're going to see a supply response and we're going to see a demand slowing that is going to rectify a lot of these imbalances that we're seeing right now in the data, especially the inflation data.
Erik Townsend: You mentioned a bull curve flattener as a potential trade here. I assume that means you don't think that 10-year Treasury yields are going to continue backing up the way some people Some people are afraid we're headed to 5% from here. Where do you see Treasury yields headed?
David Rosenberg: Look, I remember turning on CNBC after Trump got elected and Larry Lindsey, who was governor of the Fed, was talking about 5% Treasury yields. I mean, we barely at one point in late 2018 got above 3%. Who wasn't talking about all of this? Who wasn't talking about— when Trump got elected, that's all you heard was about inflation.
That's all you heard. Restricting immigration, wage inflation, tariffs, trade barriers, nationalism, protectionism, all the stuff Steve Bannon was all about. I mean, what am I missing? I mean, it's coming back and asking, weren't these same people talking about inflation after Trump got elected? Am I mistaken about that? So I think that it's very interesting is that, um, Treasury yields seem to have peaked.
You couldn't have thrown much more in the way of data Million jobs a couple of months ago, 0.9 on core CPI, another big number on PPI, and the bond market right now is just in a range.
I would say that there's certainly a high level, an elevated level of inflation uncertainty, and I think that there will be a premium in the Treasury market until that gets resolved. But you see, I'm saying the inflation uncertainty will get resolved in a certain direction that I do think that the consensus has gone the other way. But that doesn't— what the consensus is saying is, uh, look, I'm, I'm waiting. I'll tell you the truth, I read vociferously, voraciously.
I read all the newspapers, I read all the periodicals, I, I read as much as I can my competitors' research. I'm dying for somebody to put out something insightful that will get me to change my view. I haven't seen it yet. I just see a lot of partial analysis. I don't see any general equilibrium analysis.
I don't see how nobody's even talking about how is it that we can get an inflation with a U6 of 10.4. Who's explained that? And so, everything, it's just all very short-termism. I admit it. I admit it. We have inflation now and for the next several months, admittedly, admittedly, just like we had deflation a year ago for a few months.
And I asked the question, if the deflation wasn't persistent, why would you think the inflation is going to be persistent? What is it that's going to take inflation higher that wouldn't have done it last cycle? We finished the last cycle with negative real interest rates. If I'm not mistaken, Powell cut rates 3 times in 2019, re-expanded the balance sheet as the repo market blew up in his face.
And we had ongoing trade frictions. And tariff barriers and tariff increases and a 3.5% unemployment rate.
What do you do for an encore? And now people are talking about we're going into a new inflation cycle. But you see, they said that after Clinton got elected in '92, the big socialist from Arkansas, going to rewrite the social contract. Really? You know what happened to Bill Clinton? What happened to Bill Clinton was called the 1994 midterms. Oh, and then we had We had regime change, inflation regime change with the other socialist from Illinois, Barack Obama. Didn't you know? Big inflation coming and Bernanke is on his side, which he was. Explain to me, where was the inflation from that regime change? What got in the way of a Barack Obama once again was the midterms in 2010. Oh, let's see, Donald Trump.
Donald Trump was supposed to be massively inflationary and that was actually the mantra at the very beginning and bond yields went up.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
David Rosenberg: Cut taxes at a time of full employment. Where was the inflation? Tariff increases. We're going to have tremendous cost pressures from tariffs. Okay. Did it last a month or two? Was it a pernicious month-over-month inflationary environment? We finish off the cycle with a 3.5% unemployment rate and inflation's barely above 2%.
So it is all very interesting. And what gets in Donald Trump's way, of course, on regime change is the 2018 midterms. So people are just, you know, I don't know, do they, do they, do they look at history? Do they understand history? Do they not know that there is no regime change in a country that has a 2-year political cycle?
Do people not understand? And they don't because everybody lives in the here and now and they can't see past the tip of their nose.
There is no regime change. In a 2-year political cycle. So everybody's talking about we're going to have modern monetary theory, we're going to have ongoing fiscal expansion, never-ending, we're going to go to universal basic income. Really? Well, I think people don't quite understand how lucky Biden was to have emerged with those victories, razor thin in the House and the Senate. And my assumption is that they're going to go, they're going to flip, both houses are going to to flip, but all you need is one in the 2022 midterms, which all of a sudden is just next year. So explain to me where the regime change is in a 2-year political cycle.
Erik Townsend: Well, David, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. Before I let you go though, I do want to change the subject to Rosenberg Research because you have become an iconic figure in the industry in the last several decades for writing Breakfast With Dave. Your daily newsletter. But you've expanded your offerings now with Rosenberg Research. For people who don't know what's new at Rosenberg Research, please bring us up to date.
David Rosenberg: Sure. Well, you know, I would invite everybody to go on the website, just Google Rosenberg Research and it'll take you right there. And we have the capacity, actually, we have group deals and we have discounted packages, but if you wanted to create your own à la carte You just have to talk to one of my client representatives and they'll help you construct something that is going to be relevant for you.
And it's true, we have a— you know, I used to be, when I was at my previous jobs, it was always just Breakfast With Dave. But now we have a monthly Strategizer. It's called the Strategizer and it's a very active equity market, fixed income and currency market idea generation on how to invest. You know, in my missives, I'm usually 20,000 feet up in the air. The Strategizer is for the active investor who's more like maybe 20 or 100 feet up in the air.
We do that monthly. I do a variety of webcasts as well.
I've had Howard Marks on the call. I've had Jeffrey Gundlach on the call. I've had Leon Cooperman on the call and Niall Ferguson and the like. I do those pretty well once a month. There's a variety of other written materials, special reports that we try and cover everything quite often.
It's our clients that give us ideas on what to write on. Also doing special reports that we'll do a couple a month on big picture issues. We just finished one on the outlook for emerging markets, as an example.
We cover a lot of ground. I invite everybody to go on the website. Just go to Rosenberg Research. You can always email me directly at drosenberg@rosenbergresearch.com. That's drosenberg@rosenbergresearch.com. And we offer free one-month trials. So we always want to have people come in and kick our tires. They can either buy our basic or premium packages, or quite often just say, no, I like this, that, and the other. Can you mock up what makes sense that could work? So we also have that custom. But we'd like everybody to come on, have a full-month experience, and then make up their minds what it is that they would that they would like to purchase. The business has gone great. We're up to 3,000 relationships in 40 different countries. So it truly is global in nature and it's been a lot of fun.
Erik Townsend: Well, folks, Rosenberg Research may or may not be for you long-term, but you can't go wrong with the free trial. So I strongly recommend that. And certainly Breakfast With Dave is one of the best known and best respected letters in the entire industry. Listeners, we have a treat I have a treat for you in your Research Roundup email. There's a link to a chart deck from David. Now, I didn't tell you about it at the beginning of the interview because we didn't go through the chart deck in the interview. Why didn't we go through the chart deck? It's 142 pages of really fantastic macro graphs and charts, high-quality stuff that you usually have to pay for. It's good stuff free if you get it from MacroVoices. So be sure to download that chart deck. We didn't discuss it in this interview, but it's really worth your while. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. David, we look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for an update.
Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Freelancer.com is the world's largest crowdsourcing marketplace. with over 50 million freelancers and 20 million projects posted in 34 languages and 39 currencies. The future of work is now online, and at freelancer.com, you can get any job you can possibly think of done over the internet by a global workforce of skilled freelancers, whether it be web design, graphic design, software development, writing the copy for this backtesting trading algorithms, or building financial models. No matter what the gravity or complexity of the work, definitely give Freelancer a try. Freelancer.com is used by consumers all the way up to large organizations such as NASA, Airbus, Deloitte, Unilever, Facebook, and IBM. To gain investment exposure to the world of work online, Freelancer.com just listed over-the-counter under the ticker symbol FLNCF and is listed on the Australian Securities Exchange under ticker FLN.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have David back on the show, and he certainly put a lot of thoughts in my mind in terms of really whether this is going to be transitory or whether this is that secular inflation that we were looking at. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, I really enjoyed this interview, Patrick, and the reason is, frankly, I have a lot of respect for David Rosenberg. So I do disagree with him. The idea that I don't agree with someone as prominent and intelligent as David Rosenberg really makes me take pause and say, hmm, maybe I ought to reconsider. What am What am I missing here? After listening carefully to David, I understand, I think, exactly where he's coming from. I understand why he's still in the camp that he's in. I understand why I'm in a different camp, and I still think I'm right, frankly. And I think the crux of this is what he said at one point in the interview, that, look, he's a data-driven economist, formerly trained economist, and he's going by the data. What I'm talking about is a social change.
I perceive a major change in the attitudes of both elected officials and the people electing them. I think that we're moving much more in the direction of socialism and an increased amount of government support and stimulus and support transfer payments and so forth. I think that there is a major secular political social change that's going to drive this inflation. And so my prediction of inflation isn't reflected at all in the data yet. I wouldn't I don't expect it to be. When it is, I would expect David Rosenberg to catch up and say, hey, it's right. You know, it's just a question. I'm speculating about something I don't know with any certainty because I've got a really strong opinion about a secular political trend. David's saying, hey, I don't go by, you know, political trends. I go by what the data is telling me. The data is not telling me that inflation is happening now. And he's right. That's not coming till I look forward to interviewing David again once I've been proven right, or after I've been proven wrong,
Erik Townsend: in which case I'll listen even more closely.
In any event, Patrick, I want to move on to the post-game chart deck. Now we've got a special one for you this week, folks. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Of course, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not registered yet. Just go to MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads, and we'll get you all signed up. up. The title of this week's chart deck is Talking Charts on Commodities and Crypto. So Patrick is going to be absolutely silent and the charts are going to speak. Get ready, here it comes.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, well, I'm going to have to do all the talking. So let's, uh, jump, uh, to page 2 where I just want to have a quick look at the S&P 500 before we start talking crypto and commodities. And again, that 50-day moving average continues to be the support where a lot of traders continue to focus on. And right now, so far, the S&P has just looked like a typical market correction, very similar to what we have seen in February and March on numerous occasions testing that zone. Be really interesting to see with us going into this big option expiration and where this gamma pin usually tends to prevail, whether or not some big volatility comes next week and whether that volatility is breaking breakout to the upside or whether or not that 50-day will be tested once again. And that's for sure something that's going to be on my mind going into next week.
Patrick Ceresna: But on page 3, I wanted to talk the cryptos and start here with Bitcoin.
And it was interesting because we both put up those charts last week and talked about, uh, the— what's going on in the price action. And the one thing that I was talking about was the fact that, that all of the crypto traders needed at this moment for momentum to stay. Like, whether, uh, you have a strong belief in crypto or not, in order for prices to stay at these elevated levels, they need that positive emotional sentiment that drives that price action and keeps everyone interested. And Bitcoin was suffering from the fact that there was just a lack of real price progress, which, uh, usually weans interest in it. And the price action was deteriorating early or late last week, and then this week suddenly we obviously get some China headlines and the selling came in pretty hard.
This chart now on Bitcoin, some serious technical damage, and overall there's easily going to be a bounce on Bitcoin that could make it back to $42,000 or even $45,000, but there's a lot of technical repair work now that the bulls will have to do to turn this chart back up. And if this is anything like 2018 and the 2019 corrections, once this starts, this creates a prolonged period of consolidation. And it doesn't have to be some big fundamental shift, but really, if we don't see the bulls turn this around rapidly here, very, very quickly, odds are that this is going to be a a systematic distribution cycle that could last many months before Bitcoin attempts a bigger low.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I agree with you, Patrick. I would just add that things happen a little faster in cryptocurrency than in the rest of the world. So I wouldn't be surprised if the norms that we usually apply for how long corrections typically take in other markets, I think regardless of whether it's a big down or a little down, I think how long it takes to play out in crypto is gonna be shorter than in other markets. And we'll see what happens pretty quickly if that's right. I'm particularly interested to see if we get more weakness in Bitcoin, if that leads to further strength in gold, which so far it looks like at least some of the money coming out of the crypto space is going into the gold space. Is that the main thing driving the strength in gold and the weakness in Bitcoin? I have no idea.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. Well, I do wanna point out that I was not referencing other types of charts, but rather like, For instance, back in 2018, it was almost a 400-day correction that Bitcoin went through. And in 2019, the correction that Bitcoin had back then also lasted almost 260 days. And so these corrections have happened in crypto before, just prolonged consolidations. But one way or another, such a rapid drop certainly takes the wind out of the sails. And we're going to see whether or not there'll be able to recover it in short order.
On page 4 and 5, I have those charts of Ethereum and Dogecoin. And again, all of these cryptos, just, it's obviously a devastating drop, a big blow to the bulls, wiping out 50-plus percent in a very short period of time on these. And really, again, it would be very natural for us to see snapbacks. There's always reflexive retracements that occur after such devastating drops. But what will certainly be the thing to watch is that after we get a snapback rally, let's say Ethereum going to $3,000+, will it just roll over again and begin another distribution cycle? Or will the bulls be able to just put together consecutive up periods and start to repair the chart? I don't want to jump to too many conclusions this early after such a drop, but it's a very sensitive moment in the price action to determine whether or not this chart has begun some sort of a more prolonged distribution cycle.
Patrick Ceresna: With that said, I want to get to some commodity charts here, Erik, and let's start with that crude oil. On page 6, I have, uh, the crude oil chart. And, uh, even like I was saying earlier, even earlier this week, it looked like, uh, crude was ready to make a fresh, uh, high. It was looking like it was turning up. And then obviously the— those headlines had us quickly begin a correction down towards $62, where we're trading now at the time of recording. We're testing right along that 50-day moving average. It's gonna be a really interesting moment to see whether or not the bulls dig in and hold the line here, or whether this becomes a bigger turn in crude where we could see a correction down into the mid-$50s. What's your take on this?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as you can see from the chart, we have a price channel drawn in, and the price has been moving since the middle of March very neatly in that 90-day channel. Nice narrow $4-wide channel. And yesterday it broke down out of that. Okay, does that mean we're going all the way back down to the recent lows around $57 or even lower than that to around $53, which is around where the, the next support layer ought to exist? Or are we already done? I really have no idea here. My base case has been that that channel was going to hold and take us all the way back up to a breakout to new all-time highs. It's not going that way. We're gonna go down first before that happens.
How far down? Frankly, I think it depends mostly on the sentiment reaction to headlines that are probably gonna come out next week. We'll get some kind of announcement that says essentially the Iran nuclear deal is back on, the, the sanctions are gonna be lifted, Iran's gonna be able to sell its oil, not now, but in the future at after some future date when this all gets implemented. I expect headlines like that will probably shock us down to some final low shortly after those headlines come out next week. And that's probably a very buyable bottom. And I suspect that the market is gonna shrug this all off because I don't think this Iran thing is nearly as important as everybody else seems to. If I'm wrong about that, who knows? Maybe we're headed down to $53. I doubt it.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to page 7 where I have the chart of gold. And I also kept that 50-day moving average on there to highlight that, you know, we've now spent, uh, almost, uh, 2 months consolidating above the, uh, that 50-day moving average. But often that moving average will get tested on pullbacks. And one of the things I just want to highlight is that at any one time, we could easily have a $50, $60 pullback in, in the precious metals. And if this is in fact a new bull market, those, uh, should be all bought on dip. And I think I think that's the one thing that I'm actually waiting for to really confirm that we are right on this call is that we want to see what a correction looks like and how quickly the buy-on-dip traders come in, whether it's very well supported and turns back up.
And that's definitely the thing to watch in my mind.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, lumber futures have really, really just been probably the most parabolic chart of any market in this recovery. What's going on here? Did we get to— is that a dead cat bounce that we see beginning, or is it actually bottomed and maybe heading to a new high?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, we really saw that parabolic rise in lumber that just saw us just head right up to those early May highs near $1,700. It triggered finally a correction, and a correction that saw us drop a solid $500. In literally a week. And we came right down to that 50-day moving average, and that has spurred at least a bullish reaction off that low. This is actually the really important moment in lumber in my mind, because if lumber manages to muster up a rally back up to the highs, then it means that the bull phase is not over. But any failure here to make any progress north of 1,500 off of this bounce would give it a lot of price action characteristics similar to what Bitcoin had before it turned.
And so we're— it'll be really interesting to see how much gusto the bulls have here and whether they can really start getting it right back to the previous high or whether or not this is going to start topping.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, this is going to be fascinating to watch play out because frankly, I don't know where this is headed. I can make a strong argument for why I I think there's a good chance the final high is not in yet, or the final top is not in.
I think that what you see here is really an out-of-control supply chain situation. All of a sudden, it's impossible for builders to get some things. People are freaking out about pandemic risk and wanting to buy new houses and move out of the city and so forth. And you just literally can't buy materials. And if you can buy the materials, then the delivery supply chain is encumbered by COVID. So I, I, as much as it looks like it's a parabolic top and surely the price can't go any higher than there, I think it probably can. We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, I agree. And, uh, it's too early to write off the bulls. I mean, when lumber got so ahead of itself, it was very natural for at some point us to enter some sort of profit-taking cycle, something that washed out the, the, those that were late to the party. But, uh, the jury's out. I think think early next week's price action is going to be really important for me to make a, a higher conviction call on what's next for lumber.
Patrick Ceresna: But I wanted to look on pages 9 and 10 where I have a couple of the other commodities, copper and, uh, and corn. And what is interesting to me is that whether, uh, like lumber, the grains, and copper all seem to have put in their highs pretty much within a stone's throw of that inflation number that came out. I thought it was really interesting that, you know, we have this big report of inflation coming in super hot, and suddenly commodities all begin some degree of a correction since that moment.
And, um, one of the interesting things that I'm watching here is that all of them are just correcting what we would define as a typical mean-reverting correction, something that, uh, is all above its moving averages. Everything that typically in the past has been bought on dip. And, uh, it's not just lumber that we're watching. I think the entire commodity complex outside of gold is at a very sensitive moment to, to see whether or not these trends that have been in place since November continue. And that's, uh, 100% on my mind. You know, when I'm looking on page 9 at that copper chart, well, I mean, it does look just like a correction. But the one thing that, uh, you know, I ask, uh, and think about is that I can't find anybody that actually has a bear argument on copper. This is probably one of the single most consensus trades to be bullish copper out there. And, uh, and the thing is, is that when it's that consensus, that's usually where, uh, a trade is very crowded and it doesn't have that much further to go because simply everyone's already fully in.
Uh, it'll be interesting to see whether that, that this very bullish sentiment toward these commodities does in fact mark some sort of an intermediate high versus what we can only confirm as short-term highs right now.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I certainly could not agree more that I do not know any bearish argument for copper other than it's way too crowded of a trade on the bullish side. That's the only reason, and it's a significant reason to be concerned. The thing is, the fundamental demand argument for copper is so Incredibly strong. The bearish arguments that have kept me out of it are exactly what you said, which is, you know, when we got it like $3 or so and I said, boy, you know, the prices, you know, come up so much since the March low. You want to be buying copper around $2, not around $3. You know, I'll wait for the dip. I'll wait for the dip. And we're at prices already where, you know, as we come back down to, let's say we get back down to $4.40 or so. Hey, that's It's pretty darn close to your 50-day line. It's very tempting. And now the idea that 4-spot-something is a buy in copper for a medium to long-term trade was unthinkable just a few years ago.
But I think that's part of this inflation. And I wouldn't be surprised if it's, you know, double that before this inflation is over. For those of you who don't want to be left out every step along the way, you can sign up for
Erik Townsend: a free trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading, where you can see chart decks like this from Patrick almost every single day. You'll find the information on page 12 of the chart deck or at BigPictureTrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Freelancer.com, the internet's premier website for putting independent freelance contractors in touch with employers who need their services. Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to David Rosenberg's slides, as well as the chartbook we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to a Jeffrey Snider article on Inflation Huge: Jay Powell Did Blink, But It Had Nothing to Do with the Taper, and as well as a link to Jesse Felder's article an epic set of alligator jaws. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets, we'd like to share that content with our listeners. Send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter And we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend, that's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account today. At MacroVoices.com, once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library, and the more registered users we have, the more we'll be. Able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge.
Announcer: You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll Answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily. Reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Harley Bassman — Harley Bassman, 'perhaps best known as the inventor of the MOVE Index' (w2195); Convexity Maven (w1716); now with Simplify Asset Management (w2503) (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 271 was recorded on May 13th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Genesis Volatility, provider of institutional-grade crypto options analytics. Harley Bassman returns as this week's feature interview guest. For years, Harley's been on a personal mission to figure out how to make institutional hedging tools available to retail investors, because Harley sees a risk of a long-term interest rate backup in coming years that could create a much worse threat than the 2008 financial crisis. We'll talk about the risk Harley sees, why he thinks it's so important to hedge against, and the new ETF that he's just launched in order to make runaway interest rate insurance available to retail investors. to everyone who wants it. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will discuss Tesla, cryptocurrencies, and much more.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to the S&P 500. Volatility is back. I mean, we had a pretty quick sell-off here down toward that 50-day moving average, and lots to talk about even in the postgame. But what's your take on the markets here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, let's see. What I said last week is, hey, as long as we stay above the 50-day moving average, seems to me like every time we hit it, they buy the dip. Now, it seems like they did buy the dip when we hit the 50-day moving average yesterday. And then maybe they stopped buying a little bit later on this afternoon. Let's see what the rest of the week brings and what next week brings. But I think as long as we stay either above or only a little bit below the 50-day moving average, I don't think there's any reason to think that this is anything other than another buyable dip. It's when we get below and stay below the 50-day that I start to think maybe there's a trend change.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because, uh, on that CPI number we had quite the, uh, breakdown in the dollar. We now bounced off of, uh, where all the lows of the year came in, just, uh, around that 90 level, a little bit higher. We're back to almost approaching 91, but still in a pretty clear downtrend. You think, uh, the dollar's got more downside, or is this going to be a support that comes in here?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, no change in my outlook. I think we're in a sideways consolidation. And frankly, what is accelerating in the background is the longer-term picture, the big question of whether the US dollar is gonna lose its reserve currency status, potentially to a digital currency. We're seeing more and more things starting to gain momentum. And so I think that the dollar question of where the US dollar itself is headed strategically and its role in the monetary system is definitely gonna come under serious That's a serious question in coming years. But as far as dollar index, value of the dollar versus other currencies, it's consolidating sideways. I don't think there's any reason to expect anything else until we see a technical sign that something's changed.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's move on to that crude oil because we were just yesterday approaching those year highs and looked like oil was doing great on there. And then today, just as we're recording this, we're having this $2-plus breakdown in crude oil. Is this, in your mind, this a big reversal or is the upside still the path of least resistance
Erik Townsend: Well, we are testing key support right now. And so if it breaks, obviously, that's another story. I don't think it's going to. My base case is I think we're just bottoming here on a test. And I think that we're headed higher, but we'll see what happens.
The thing to understand is crude oil has been trading in a fairly narrow channel since the middle of March. And we were right almost at the very top of that channel, as you said, yesterday. And Then what happened really is inventory— first, API kind of got things going, setting expectations for maybe a fairly big, significant drawdown in crude oil inventories, which of course would be bullish for prices.
Well, that was the API private inventory data. By the time the official data came out from EIA on Wednesday, the buying in the wake of API's announcement had already taken the market pretty much to the upper limits of how far it could go.
And then what happened is the EIA data came in saying, yeah, there's There's a drawdown, but only a very tiny one of 427,000 barrels, much, much smaller than the drawdown that API had predicted. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 421,000 barrels. Gasoline building 378,000 barrels, much smaller build than API had anticipated there as well. And distillates drawing down 1.7 million barrels. US production ticking up 100,000 barrels to 11 million barrels even. So at first, the prices held.
At least for the first few minutes after inventory came out. But I think then the market realized, hey, you know, we didn't really get a big drawdown. The news coming out of India about the coronavirus crisis getting worse, you know, maybe demand's not going to recover quite as quick as Goldman thinks it is.
It took us back down to the bottom of that established price channel and we got there very quickly. But where we are is at the bottom of the established channel. We're still in the channel. We traded out of the channel for about 15 minutes this afternoon. And as we're speaking, still It's still 45 minutes before the pit close, so anything could happen here. But we're right at the bottom of the channel and the 5-week moving average, which are right around 63.47. The top of that channel is around 67.50 right now. So I think that this is a bottom and that we're about to move higher. But if we break lower from here, it would mean that the game has changed and that maybe this sideways consolidation is going to last longer.
My base case, though, is we're bottoming here. Then there's going to be a A little more resistance between $66.60 and $68. Probably take us a couple weeks to get through that resistance, and eventually we break out to the second major leg of a bull market fairly soon. If we see a breakdown here, and definitely this is the deciding moment right where we are today on Thursday afternoon at the bottom of the channel, if that channel breaks, then it means that that sideways consolidation is going to last a bit longer before we can look for the breakout that I eventually still see coming as this bull market continues.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold and precious metals. I mean, overall, gold has held up. I mean, a little bit of a pullback in the last day or two, but really we're still north of $1,800 and still working our way generally higher in the trend. Do you think that this continues for gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's interesting. You know, I'm surprised that some people seem disappointed that the price is pulling back a little bit here. Let's remember what we talked about last week and what gold bulls should expect, desire, and want, which is a very, very common pattern in technical analysis, which is when you get a breakout through a significant level such as the 100-day moving average at $1,800, also round number resistance, then oftentimes what happens is there's a breakout and then you get a retest of that same number as support. We almost got it this morning, but not quite. So the fact the price of gold might go back down to $1,800 all fits the bull narrative and is therefore good news, not bad news. And the real pro move is to buy that move down to $1,800 as you get the retest of a previous resistance level now holding as support.
I'm not buying anymore here only because I bought quite a bit a little bit lower, uh, just around $1,690 or so. And in terms of both bullion and mining shares, I've pretty much got my fill at this point. But, uh, this would be the technical buy spot right here, would be that retest of $1,800 as support. You buy that if, uh, if it proves right and it wasn't a fake breakout, which I don't think it was. I wouldn't be surprised if there's a really big move up from here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury note because, well, the inflation numbers came in pretty hot and certainly now we have the Treasury bonds starting to reflect that with a little bit higher yields. You think this is a breakout where yields can start punching toward 2% or is this gonna just stall out along its previous highs?
Erik Townsend: I have to be honest, Patrick, and say I have no idea what's happening here. It's the most important thing in macro to watch is are we in a new regime of increasing interest rates? and potentially the beginning of a secular bear market in bonds. I don't think so. I don't think that's happening here. I think we're in a trading range and probably this 1.7% or so that so far has been the top is gonna hold for a bit longer. But if it doesn't, it's gonna bring, and especially if it goes through 2%, it's gonna bring a lot of other asset markets like stocks and gold down with it.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is the Convexity Maven, Harley Bassman. Now, Erik, why did we invite Harley back to the show
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this is an unusual one, and I approached this interview differently than most of the other ones that we do. Normally, the guests we get on MacroVoices, you know, I talk to them about the markets, and at the end of the interview, they get something they want to sell. Harley is the one guy who never had anything he wanted to sell. He's retired. He's a very, very successful man who invented the MOVE Index, had a very successful career in finance, and he's retired, and happily so. And he's actually gone back to work Because he's so passionate, and I've been talking to him about this for years offline.
He's so passionate about the idea that he has is that there is a really big macro risk on the horizon that could wipe out the savings of a lot of people. And he is just passionate about wanting to make the tools that exist in institutional finance, but not in retail products available so that everybody has access to an ETF to protect them against a major increase in long-term interest rates in coming years.
And what I think is fascinating is why is this guy who invented the MOVE Index, obviously no slouch when it comes to the bond market, so preoccupied with this macro risk of a backing up in interest rates that he literally is coming out of retirement in order to create a product to make it better for people? So I think it's just a fascinating story that I wanted to approach a little bit differently than the average MacroVoices interview.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Harley Bassman is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on all the major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. The second in Todd Buchholz's 3-part series, Crossing the Bridge to Renewable Energy, is available now, and the series will conclude on Saturday morning with Josh Crumb, founder and CEO of Abaxx Technologies. Josh is on a mission to reimagine our global market systems so that we're able to achieve the 2030 Paris Agreement objectives a year ahead of schedule. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to listen to this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Harley Bassman, perhaps best known as the inventor of the MOVE Index, which is basically the VIX for the bond market. Harley prepared a slide deck to accompany today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. Harley, it's great to get you back on the program, sir. It's been way too long.
Harley Bassman: Thank you very much. Great to be here.
Erik Townsend: I'm going to do this interview a little bit differently today because, uh, just to put my perspective on this one, for as long as I've known you, You've been a little bit different from most of our guests. You haven't had anything to sell because you basically retired from the finance industry several years ago after being very successful at an early age and are kind of enjoying life retired and continue writing about finance just because you enjoy it and find it rewarding.
You've also been preoccupied for as long as I've known you with this obsession of what's gonna happen someday if interest rates explode and nobody is protected. And I know you and I have talked about We've talked about this quite a bit over the years where you've expressed great frustration that the tools needed to hedge against what you think is the biggest risk that anybody's ever, you know, seen coming in a lifetime, that may be coming in the next few years, the instruments are there, but they're only available to institutional investors.
And the way I'm interpreting recent events is basically you kind of threw a tizzy fit and said, look, I'm not going to stand for this. I'm going to create a product to solve this problem. And you hooked up with our friend Mike Green. You guys both went to Simplify Asset Management in order to pull this all off. Is that right? Do I have the gist of it? And I guess we should probably dive into what is this problem that you're so worried about that's possessed you to go off and create this new product?
Harley Bassman: You got this thing exactly right. There are options or other derivatives, other ways of getting either getting risk or enhancing risk, reducing risk, tends to be available on listed form. And options on it are very short-term, 1 to 3, maybe 6 months. There's some extraordinary risk profiles available in the longer-dated option market or derivative market. And those are only available to professionals who have an ISDA, I-S-D-A, contract. What we've tried to do over here is to pierce the ISDA veil and offer what I will call civilians, non-professionals, access to these products. And these kinds of products can really offer incredible risk management, especially options, because a 5 or 10 or 7-year option will decay in a much slower pattern than a 1, 2, 3-month option will. And we've devised a way with the help of the team at Simplify to offer These products, and we have a new one out that got launched this week.
Erik Townsend: Okay, let's talk about what the risk is that we're hedging against. What you're worried about is basically we've had a, I don't know, 35 to 38-year, whatever it is, bond bull market. We're not quite positive that it's completely over, but it seems like it. It sure feels like it is. And someday it's going to reverse, and you're worried that a blowout in interest rates could would basically destroy everybody who's not ready for it, that you'd have a whole bunch of people that have variable rate financing that's gonna, you know, get adjustable rate financing that gets adjusted up and all of a sudden everybody's crushed. Is that the basic scenario that you think is coming?
Or I should— maybe I should ask, is it something that you think is coming or is it just a risk you think people should be protected against?
Harley Bassman: I think we can go to the bar and kick around whether rates are going up or down and the path they're gonna be in the next year or 2 or 3 and have a fine discussion But that actually is not what really worries me. The greater risk is not that rates go up or not, although they can.
And the single purpose of rates go up, so bond prices go down or discount rates change. It's that if we get interest rates above a certain level, the correlation of stocks to bonds will flip.
And that's been the biggest deal in the last 20 years. Is that you've seen stock and bond prices go in opposite directions. So stocks up, bonds down, and vice versa. So they kind of hedge each other. This not only has underpinned the 60/40 portfolio, right, 60% stocks, 40% bonds, but it's actually grown this business called risk parity. Bridgewater was the biggest user of this. Congratulations, it was a genius idea. And what they would do They wouldn't take $100 and do 60/40. They'd take $100 and do $130 of bond and $70 of stock, or some other ratio depending upon the correlation, and offered a levered return to people using this inverse correlation of stocks to bonds.
And turns out this correlation is very— seems to be very much related to interest rates or inflation or both. So if you look at page 3 of the handout, here's one version of the stock-to-bond correlation offered by our friend Gerard Minack, who's been on your show.
If you go to the next page, here's another story about the stock-to-bond correlation from a different vendor. And what the result is, is that if rates go somewhere above 3.5%, 4.5%, somewhere in there, you will see this stock-to-bond correlation flip, and you'll see stocks and bonds go up and down in unison.
There'll no longer be any hedge value to your bond portfolio. And if you're a levered investor where you used— where you have $200 of assets supported by $100 of money, well, now things can get really scary. And if you go look at the last 2 times we've seen real market drawdowns, Last March, year ago March, and then before that 2018, you saw stocks and bonds go down together. And when that happens, things went really haywire because all of a sudden all these various funds that were levered would have to delever themselves. And of course, if people are not hedged properly, that can get rather bothersome. And so what I see over here is, do I think rates are going to go up? Yes. Why do I think that? We could talk about that in a few minutes.
But the big idea is this. If we get rates above a certain level, let's call it 4.25%, you're going to see this correlation reverse. And if that happens, it's going to be a financial tsunami. I mean, I can't tell you how concerned people should be about this because everything will go down. And many of your past guests have spoken about margin and leverage and short out there, all these various things about how we're levered up, the debt we have in the country overall, public and private. All this leverage is kind of based upon this correlation in the last 20 years. And if that reverses, that's the problem. And so I want to find a way to go protect myself against that.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So we've got kind of a double whammy here because first of all, if interest rates back up, that causes a bunch of problems by itself. Money's getting more expensive. But on top of that, if it leads to this reversal in correlation, well, now I got the value of my bond portfolios going down because interest rates are rising.
And all of a sudden stocks are going down at the same time because the correlation has flipped. And that's where I've really got— and if that's not just happening to me, but happening to everyone else around me, all of the other market participants are having that same experience. That's the financial tsunami that you're talking about. How big of a tsunami are we talking about? Bigger than the 2008 financial crisis?
How big of a tsunami is it? And how much of a difference do you think you can really make by hedging against it?
Harley Bassman: I have not put pencil to paper on how big this could be, how much stocks can go down by. I just know that when you reverse that, people are going to lose the ability to go and ride their portfolios, because all of a sudden you're not going to have offsetting gains to dampen the overall present value of what you own. They'll both be going down. And people are not going to be used to that. People are pretty much used to there being, you know, you see a bad headline, but they'll make money on one side of the portfolio and not make it on the other. So I haven't sized this yet. But the evidence is when we've seen this correlation reverse. So stocks and bonds move in unison. Those have been the biggest moves we've seen in the last number of years. And I would say in particular that the high-value or high-number FAANG stocks will be especially susceptible.
Because if you think about it, theory has been proposed that your big tech stocks, the big growth stocks, they're going to make a lot of money someday, someday being 10, 20, 30 years from now. Okay, that's fine. I mean, we've seen Amazon go from doing nothing to being gigantic, so that kind of worked. If you have these companies with very distant cash flows and you're discounting those cash flows back 30 years at 1%, well, that's worth a lot of money.
You discount it back at 4%, it's worth a lot less. And so if you had a situation where equities were going down and the high-value, long-duration stocks went down, that would be a real problem to people, which worries me. I mean, I kind of view these FAANG stocks as being like 70-year duration bonds, and they've performed very well with that consideration. But if rates really go up, I suspect they will have a significant headwind.
Erik Townsend: Now, you said in passing, you know, you wanted to protect yourself from this. You already knew how to protect yourself from this. You've got the institutional background to know how to put this trade on. trade on, and you have a personal ISDA account. So obviously this has become something of a mission for you. You don't just want to protect yourself, you want to make this tool available to everybody so they can protect themselves too.
What's driving that? I mean, was it just got bored with retirement, or is this just a passion of yours that you want people to be able to protect themselves? You see this as a really big risk. What's driving you to have kind of come out of retirement in order to do this project?
Harley Bassman: I will not be drawn into any kind of discussion of politics. That's a loser no matter what I say. But I do have a public policy bent where I do think that we should offer ways to help people optimize or at least protect themselves against various outcomes that they're not prepared for. And this is a way to go and do that for lots of people. And these products are available in the market.
And what's this actually in some sense is a market benefit because these options are so very inexpensive because there's no buyers of them, but there are sellers. Why there are sellers is a different story, but there are sellers out there and have made options extraordinarily cheap. And we might want to go through that in a little bit.
Erik Townsend: Harley, let's talk about What this product, this ETF that you and Mike Green are developing, is it for people like me? Is it for investors? And how would I use it? Do I basically buy a proportion of, you know, a certain percentage of my net worth in order to hedge myself against future higher rates? How does it pay off and who is this for?
Harley Bassman: I'll try to be careful over here, seeing as our regulations, what I can and can't say. We have a new ETF that's come out there. It was launched this week. You could find it on the Simplify website. And what it is, it's launched at $50 a share. It's $25 of a 7-year option on the 20-year interest rate. It's kind of like buying a 7-year option on a 20-year Treasury struck at 4.25%. And it's $25 of a 7-year Treasury security, which is not going to move all that much.
Erik Townsend: Okay.
Harley Bassman: And the idea is, is you buy this thing, it has roughly, let's say, $1,000 of option per share. So if you bought 1,000 shares, that would be equal to owning options on $1 million of bonds, and it would perform as such.
And if you go look at my latest commentary on page 4, you'll see a modeled profile of this ETF relative to a futures contract. And it's rather fancy in terms of what it does. The downside's about the same. The upside is triple what it can do. It's very transparent. We're not hedging it. We're not managing it. You are just basically buying almost straight through processing to owning a 7-year option. And what's fancy about this is the implied volatility for a 7-year option is almost 10% below that for a 5-year option. So the volatility actually goes up. So the decay of this is relatively small over time. So the idea is to buy this trade, put it in your book, hold it for, you know, a number of years— 2, 3, 4 years is the idea— and, and as a giant insurance policy against a financial portfolio.
But you could also, if you were a contractor, a developer, and you're building a mid-sized multifamily, and you get your construction loan, and you can't get permanent financing for 3 years until the project's complete, the value of that project is very dependent upon where you get your permanent financing. And if rates went up by, you know, 2 points, that might wipe out the entire profit of this thing. If you are a homeowner, and you have an adjustable rate mortgage, and it's going to go and reset in 3 years, You could buy this and hedge your portfolio out.
It solves all the problems of— there's nothing else out there that has this consistency, transparency, stability, and directness. The only thing that's even close would be futures contracts. And that requires a lot of accounting, separate accounts to do it. And you have to roll the contract every quarter. It's very, very problematic. So this really solves so many problems.
Erik Townsend: So essentially what you've done is you've done the analysis to look at where you think the macro risks are, and you're saying the instrument, if people had access to institutional finance instruments, that they ought to buy for their own portfolios, if they had access to that market, is basically a put on Treasuries at approximately a 4.25% interest rate where it's paying off if at the end of 7 years, if interest rates have moved Moved above 4.25%, there's a big payoff there.
It's a protective insurance policy. What you've done is just dialed in the parameters and turned it into an ETF so that anybody on Robinhood can buy it in their Robinhood account if they want to. I would imagine the Robinhood crowd probably doesn't understand what it is. But anybody who understands what it is can just buy it as an ETF and they've got that protection. You've taken care of dialing in the right parameters to get the right It is point and click right into a regular account.
Harley Bassman: And yeah, it is piercing the ISDA veil and allowing civilians access to professional products.
Erik Townsend: Harley, let's talk then about why individuals would need to pierce that veil in the first place. Specifically, what could go wrong in terms of systemic risks in the market if institutional rates start to run away in the next few years? And what do we need to be concerned with? What do we need to watch for in terms of why that might be coming?
Harley Bassman: I mean, the case for why rates may go up in the next 2 or 3 years has been explained over and over again on this show. So, there's no reason to repeat that. What I will say is this, the people who push back and say the Fed doesn't want that, I disagree.
I think the Fed actually does want a steeper curve, and they do want higher long-term Not the front end, but I do not think you're going to have yield curve control of 1950s where they hold the back end of the curve down. And there's so many good public policy reasons for this. If you steepen the curve, you help the banking system.
Now, I'm not going to call the major banks the good guys here, but the financial system will improve with a steeper curve. You will increase profits. You will expand their capital cushion. And that is a public policy good. And so that's supportive. And we are a financial economy. We're a levered financial economy. And making sure the plumbing works is very important.
It'll improve the pension systems that we have, right? Pension and insurance are long liability people. They owe their money out way in the future. Higher rates, higher long-term rates will reduce the funding gap in pensions and insurance companies. So that's good. To the extent that we have a huge cohort of people who are retiring soon, by taking rates down as they have for the last decade, you kind of robbed Peter to pay Paul.
People who are savers have not— have had their savings, the income they get reduced, and that benefit's gone to borrowers. A steeper curve, higher rates in the back end, would be helpful to people who are retiring because they'd have earned more interest. And that in turn would perhaps reduce the government cost of public assistance for people who are retiring.
Finally, most important for, I think, the people on this show, who are probably all in pretty good shape, is a steeper curve will pass along information about the market. The yield curve has been Historically, the best predictor of the economy. You might recall that I predicted a recession for the first quarter of 2020 at the end of 2018 when the curve inverted, first inverted, and lo and behold, 18 months later it happened. Now, does it count that a virus occurred? I maybe not, but it did happen, and this has been the best prediction is the yield curve, and so therefore. However, allowing the curve to move via market conditions will cue people into risks coming or not.
It'll improve— it'll make people more cautious and they'll hedge. They won't be as exposed. And so that's a public policy good also.
Erik Townsend: Tell me about the pricing of this. Presumably, if you're using institutional traded products, there's some efficient price discovery. So I would imagine there's reasonably efficient price for this protection that, that this ETF offers?
Harley Bassman: Well, I guess there might be if the Fed didn't have their big finger on the scale. Uh, in the same manner that the yield curve has been the best predictor correlation to the economy, so has the yield curve been very well correlated with implied volatility. The cost of risk, the cost of insurance, the cost of options is driven by implied volatility. And if you look at page 7, One of my favorite charts, you can see that the yield curve has steepened a lot. That's the orange line. But implied volatility, the purple line, has not gone up.
I think this is because the Fed has basically, well, one, been supporting the market, but they're supporting it with both words and deeds. But I don't think this is actually long-term viable.
I think implied vols have to rise as people become more and more concerned. And what's really strange is this. Going to page 8, this is the term surface, the implied volatility level for a 3-month option, a 1-year, a 5-year, a 10-year option. Look at that green line, at the slope of the green line and how it goes up. Because as you go more into the future, it's further away. You can't see as well. And you have more uncertainty.
And therefore, the price of insurance, the price of uncertainty, should also rise. And it did. But look at the most recent snapshot. See how this vol is flattened out? You've seen long-dated options, 10-year options come down. This is totally anomalous considering that we've gone through massive increase in the Fed balance sheet with this double-barreled fiscal program, soon to be maybe one or two more of them. It is greatly uncertain what's going to happen.
We've never seen us grow the balance sheet and spend this much money, grow this much debt before. Will it be higher or lower rates? We can argue about that. But the uncertainty has to have gotten greater right now. And therefore, it's totally anomalous that vol has come down for long-dated options. Next page. This is options on the European SX5E, the Dow 50.
See how much that vol's come down. In Japan, currency options, same thing. They've come down very hard.
And then finally, page 11. This is where the real value proposition is. This is the implied volatility of interest rates. Implied volatility of the 20-year interest rate going from a one-month option. out to a 10-year option. And notice how it's actually inverted. It's a longer story about why this is the case, market conditions, this and that. All you have to know is it's pointing south. As far as I'm concerned, it should be going north.
And when you get this inverted volatility term surface, it becomes very inexpensive to buy this insurance against a great uncertainty.
So it's really not a matter of predicting that rates are going to go higher. Or that things are going to go and get crazy. It's a matter of the insurance is so cheap relative to a very costly risk outcome, you should buy it.
Erik Townsend: So how do you envision this product being used? Is it primarily individual investors putting it in their portfolios, or is it institutional portfolio managers saying, okay, I need, you know, X number of shares of Harley's ETF in order to hedge this particular risk? in some other fund that they're managing, for example?
Harley Bassman: The 2 largest buyers I expect are going to be family office or high net worth individuals who have significant exposure to higher rates. I mean, people who don't have large bank accounts or large investment accounts, I suppose they can get hurt by higher rates, but that's very indirectly.
It's people who have assets. Insurance and pension companies are not going to buy this because they actually want higher rates, right? Because they discount their liabilities and collapses that asset liability gap for them. Hedge funds tend not to be buyers because they're very short-term oriented. They don't have a macro thought where they're looking out into the future. I mean, some of them do, but most are very short-term, nips to blips. So you're going after people who have assets, who have risk, and have the capability to go and appreciate the risks of doing this. That's probably the target audience here. And the sizing is fairly simple. 1,000 shares is roughly an option on a million-dollar of options. So it kind of, in your head, kind of works pretty easily.
Erik Townsend: So is the prescription then that, uh, you, you base it on your net worth? If your net worth is $5 million, then you need 5,000 shares, or, or how does that work?
Harley Bassman: Well, I'd love that, but no, I, I think, I think you would base it on— you'd look at the asset portfolio you have and, and how many of those assets would be at risk If rates went up by two or three hundred basis points, I think most people who have reasonable assets kind of have an idea of what's going to move and what's not going to move relatively. So if you own, I mean, if you have a lot of commercial real estate, things that trade in Class A buildings, which is a different animal entirely, but people who have any kind of rental property, they could be seriously harmed with higher rates if they ever wanted to sell.
If they're going to hold it to maturity forever for the family. Forget it. But if you might want to sell this asset someday, the cap rate is going to change. And these are very long-duration assets, and they will go down in price pretty hard if rates go up a lot and you have to go and try and sell them.
I mean, ultimately, this strategy is not for someone who's certain rates are going to go up. Those people have already sold the market. These are people— it's insurance against an outcome that is not It's not, you know, a certainty, but it's a very expensive outcome. I mean, you don't buy home insurance because you think your house is going to burn down. You buy it because if it did, you'd be very sad.
Erik Townsend: Okay, Harley. So this is not designed to speculate on the direction of interest rates. We use futures for that. This is a hedge designed to protect my portfolio against an unexpected move if it happens.
Harley Bassman: The word speculative or speculate has weird connotations to it, most of them negative. If you want to use the word speculate in the term of a 2-year horizon, this is fine. This is a longer-term macro exposure to higher interest rates. So, if you want to go and bet that rates are going to be higher a year or 2 or 3 from now, this is almost the only way you can do it.
If you want to go and trade Friday's payroll number, don't call me on this. Go and trade futures. So it's really, it's more of a horizon concept than it is something else.
Erik Townsend: Harley, we haven't talked about inflation yet. That seems like a big part of this equation because an expectation of inflation is certainly a reason to expect increasing interest rates.
Harley Bassman: You know, this whole idea of inflation and interest rates kind of gets conflated with each other. They're kind of two different things. It is possible to have inflation and not have higher rates. The Fed can control interest rates by buying them, which is what they've been doing. Right now we have a negative interest, negative real interest rate here, as well as in Europe and Japan. So they don't go hand in hand. But in this particular product that we're talking about, it pays off as interest rates go up, not as inflation goes up. So there is the scenario where if the Fed really, you know, bought every bond available, that you could have inflation go up and rates not move. So that is something to be careful about.
But I do want to make one more comment here that I'm greatly disturbed by this idea of people saying there has not been inflation. We've had people who, you know, 10 years ago talking about if the Fed prints this much money, we're going to get inflation. And I'm a UChicago graduate, man. I believe in monetary theory.
MV equals PQ equals GDP. And we have taken M's way up here. And the idea that we have not had inflation is totally, completely false. I can't be more clear about that. It is totally bogus. We have had inflation, just not in CPI. We've had inflation in housing. And you can see that on page 1.
Look at this over here. You've seen housing prices explode higher. They're well over where they were at the peak in '06.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Harley Bassman: Yet the owner's equivalent rent that they use for CPI, that hasn't gone anywhere. We've had inflation in stocks, in bonds, in gold, in art, in jewelry, everything. I mean, there's been massive inflation. Now, unfortunately, as a public policy concept, inflation has gone towards assets that 1% owns. So that really hasn't worked. The Fed's idea was to create inflation for middle-class wages.
And that has so far has not occurred. But to say we haven't had inflation is false. It just wasn't in CPI. What I think is going to happen is the Fed working with the fiscal policy, this time it's going to go and work. When they increased assets before, it stayed in the financial system and inflated stocks and bonds and other assets like that.
The money did not go to the people who spend. It went to people who have money, whose propensity to spend the extra dollar is rather thin. These fiscal policies are going to go to people who have to spend money and will spend it. A Fed study from a few years ago showed that 40% of the population could not conjure up $400 for an emergency.
That's terrible. That's just really terrible. But nonetheless, it is a fact. And if these people go and get money from the fiscal policy government, it will get spent. And I think that's what's going to go and finally drive inflation, CPI inflation higher and interest rates higher. So that's my core thought on this.
And there are others who disagree, but, you know, that's why we have bars to go and drink at.
Erik Townsend: Harley, tell me a little bit more about how you and our friend Mike Green got together, because frankly, last I knew, you mean you've been retired a few years. You've retired officially from finance, enjoying your retirement and talking, as long as I've known you, about how badly this product is needed. Is this just something you had to do? I mean, is this about making a buck for you, or is this about really wanting to see this product come to realization?
Harley Bassman: Oh, the latter. I want this product to exist. I mean, I'm making money, but I mean, I would like this to exist because as a public policy good, it is helpful to people. If you really look at what an ETF is, the original idea is you're taking some kind of open-end fund, which you can only trade at 4 o'clock every day, and putting it onto an exchange so you can trade it whenever you want all day long.
That's the first generation. The next generation was people like buying puts or selling calls on these embedded ETFs as a very static strategy. That was a little helpful. It kind of bent the edges of the profile of ETFs. Simplify why I joined them, and I can show you why Mike Green joined also with me. And we are personal friends, by the way, for quite a while.
Is that you're taking this next level of actually really moving dynamically the profile of an asset by looking at the options and managing the options that you have in them, or by offering these long-dated options via piercing the ISDA veil. This is entirely new. This is a this is a brand new area. And it suits both of us very well because we both really appreciate the dynamic of unbalanced leverage, right? When you buy an option, you have limited loss, unlimited gain. And we're both pretty good at locating where value is and then sizing it appropriately. So I think Simplify Asset Management, this could be the real deal, man. And I mean, Was I retired?
I wasn't earning a W-2. I'll give you that. Retired, not quite. I was publishing, but I did. You know, I'll say it: get back to a real job because it's just so interesting. This is a startup operation. I'm employee number ten. Mike's employee number twelve. It's really exciting to go get involved in this and really create new products that are actually interesting and viable. And by the way, our fee structure, if you go look at that, is like, is very low compared to other products out there that even try to replicate what we're doing.
Erik Townsend: Well, Harley, my hat is off to you and Mike. So the gist of it is basically it's 1,000 shares per million of principal that you want to protect against the risk of higher future interest rates. And it's a 7-year embedded option that's behind Harley, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. For our listeners who want to find out more about the ETF or more about what you and Mike are doing, where can they contact you?
Harley Bassman: Well, you can find us at simplify.us. That's our company website. You can find my commentaries still published independently at convexitymaven.com. If you want to get on my list, just send me an email. I'd be glad to do it. And I'll tell you that you should keep your eyes open because, you know, Mike and I and the team there, we have some very clever ideas about how to offer some products that'll have much better path dependency outcomes, as well as offering some new ISDA-type products for foreign currencies or other things where you get access to long-dated options, long-dated investment profiles. So these are all coming up very soon. Keep your eyes open, and I think you'll be very pleased.
Erik Townsend: Well, Harley, we look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Yes, cryptocurrencies do have options. Both Bitcoin and Ethereum have active options markets. Genesis Volatility, also known as GVOL, as an institutional-grade crypto options analytics provider. You can view option skews, implied volatility, open interest, and volume metrics for free by visiting their website, gvol.io. That's gvol.io. Professional traders can also choose to upgrade to a paid account to access historical data, model realized volatility, Monitor block trades, and much more using GVOL's professional tools. GVOL is a leader in the crypto options space and is used by the largest professional firms currently making crypto markets.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Harley back, and I actually am really excited about his product. You know, the ability to actually get the convexity of options in an interest rate play that has this kind of duration is something that I've never had access to because I don't have an ISDA account. So this is definitely something that's perked my interest. I'm going to be looking into it, uh, as we, uh, go forward.
Erik Townsend: Anyway, yeah, let's, uh, take a look at some of these Listeners, you'll find the download link for the postgame chart deck in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you haven't registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads on the homepage.
Patrick, let's dive in. The chart deck is titled Sector Rotation or Start of a Bigger Correction. Well, we hit the 50-day, actually the 55-day moving average Pretty perfectly yesterday on the S&P. Uh, what's the, the story here? Is it a sector rotation or the start of a bigger correction?
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, you're absolutely right. We hit that 50-day moving average. It was something you talked about at the market wrap, and all throughout the start of the year, we've repetitively in this, in the segment of the show, talked about what happens when the market approaches this level, and it often has emerged as a buy-on-dip opportunity. And so the big question is will we see the markets do this again where we're going to have a new buy-on-dip opportunity emerge here? And, uh, you know, one of the things that worries me about this is that when we go to page 3 and look at that NASDAQ, we are now definitively broken below that 50-day. And one of the things that we've seen on the NASDAQ was that it has acted in the past as the leadership sector. And so while we continue to watch this S&P 500 approaching that support, it does have to be be a red flag, the fact that, uh, a major index with so many of those mega-cap tech names in them not being able to hold the line in that area.
And more importantly, it wasn't even able to really make any progress above its February highs on that upside. What is interesting, and one thing that I want to continue to watch closely, is on page 4 when we actually look at the NASDAQ over the S&P 500 ratio. And we— one of the things that has been in place for many, many years has been the structural outperformance of the NASDAQ over that of the S&P 500. And that has generally been a great trade to just be long the tech. And what's— what we've seen, and, you know, Harley talked about it as well, is that, you know, a lot of these tech names are considered long-duration assets. And with interest rates pressures and other things, we're seeing sector rotation being so dominant. And, uh, the question now is, are we seeing a bigger picture, a more secular turn in this, uh, trend where the NASDAQ may no longer outperform the S&P 500 moving forward?
Patrick Ceresna: And I think that, uh, whether or not inflation is transitory or whether it's more secular is going to be an important
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's look at an inflation chart then on page 5.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so we obviously had that really hot print of inflation come in, and more importantly, it's a very big print. It's on a 10-year chart, the, the biggest, uh, breakout in inflation that we had. And, uh, many people are just, uh, trying to suggest that it is transitory, and rightfully so. Commodities have been very hot, and it has been creating that short-term pressure on pushing inflation numbers higher. But what if some of our guests that talk about this being more of a secular trend, what if they end up being right and that we in fact do have a lot of pressure on inflation continuing moving forward? And that's where I want to go back to that Harley comment when Harley was talking about that the FAANG stocks, which I have on page 6, are considered in his mind something like 70-year duration. bonds. They're these growth assets that discount all their future earnings, and when you have interest rate pressure, the multiples get pressured on them and, and they suddenly have huge headwinds.
And so when we're looking at that NASDAQ over the S&P chart on page 4, and then we look at what's happening in these FAANG stocks, it's going to be one of the single most important questions to answer as to whether or not this almost decade-long trend of NASDAQ outperformance, whether that has come to an end and whether we're going to see the cyclicals really continue to take over as the leadership in the stock market moving forward.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I love chart 5, and the reason is it's finally starting to show that the data are reflecting something that all the smart people in the room have known for a long time, which is a secular inflation. Stagflation is beginning. And sure, it's been true that it hasn't been reported in the data yet. Well, now we're finally starting to see it in the data. And the reason that's so significant is all the people that are blind to the macro factors that have just been saying, you guys talking about inflation are crazy. There's nothing in the data to say that. Now, people who think that way are finally gonna have the evidence they need to start recognizing something that's obvious to people who understand cause and effect. which is big inflation coming. So I think the fact that it's finally showing up in the data is really significant because it's gonna wake up the part of the market that hasn't been paying attention to what a lot of us think is obvious.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so on that point, what I wanted to do is show page 7 where we have the Metals and Mining ETF over the S&P 500 and to almost the exact opposite of the NASDAQ over the S&P, the metals and mining ETF, has massively underperformed the S&P 500 for many, many years. And what we've seen is that as all of these commodity bull markets have started and all these commodities have turned, suddenly we're seeing that this sector, the cyclical sector of the stock market, has materially outperformed. And again, is it transitory? Is this a short-term thing? Or is this going to be the trend that may even last for years and this sector outperform over that of the major indices? And whether this rotation is underway and whether this shift in the markets is obviously a lot to do with answering that inflation question. But this is certainly something I think is important because so many people are not positioned in their portfolios for this.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I don't know how you can say not positioned in their portfolios. We have some portfolios like the ARKK ETF that are prepared for an entirely new paradigm. That's beyond my comprehension. But I did see an interview where I know that ETF in particular has got superior portfolio construction and can't lose.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, what I really wanted to talk about when we were putting up this ARK Innovation ETF chart was just to really show that sector rotation has really come underway. I mean, the ARKK ETF was taking huge money inflow throughout most of 2020. Money and has been— was one of the best-performing funds out there during that cycle. But since that January, February highs, this has been just actively distributed. And one of their largest holdings, which is still a 10% weighting, is Tesla, which is on page 9. And one of the big things to watch is as we see all these cyclicals and financials and and value plays all take all the money inflow. Have we seen major tops in these stocks? And is this distribution that has been going on for several months just the beginning of a much deeper correction in these?
I mean, Tesla at this stage is under $600. And if the— if this type of distribution cycle continues, it'd be really interesting to see whether or not we see a correction that can have this down even in the $500s.
$100 and $400 range in the coming months. And so that's gonna be something to watch, particularly with the type of attention that Elon Musk is getting today. Now, Erik, one of the things that Elon Musk has been doing recently has been talking crypto.
Patrick Ceresna: And certainly he's been one of the torchbearers, you know, to the whole movement of crypto over the last half a year and really kind of changed his tune a little bit and certainly creating some controversy in that space that caused Bitcoin to, to reverse on the downside. We were trading near $50,000 at the time when I snapped this chart, and it really looks like Bitcoin is getting incredibly heavy. One thing with these cryptos that are— in my mind anyway— that is required is momentum, because there has to be that excitement and the froth and that air of easy money that keeps momentum there. And Bitcoin really has seemed to run out of a little bit of, of that momentum and juice, and it'll be really interesting to see Whether this is where that resistance really establishes itself on the crypto.
What's your take on it?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think it's pretty clear that the factors that are affecting crypto markets are similar to the factors that were affecting the dot-com market in the late '90s. You got a whole bunch of people who have no clue how any of this stuff actually works, guessing, trying to figure out what's important.
And obsessed with trying to get on the next thing, whatever is hot. This most recent nonsense from Elon Musk about how he supposedly just developed a conscience about the amount of electricity which is wasted by Bitcoin is just utter nonsense. It has nothing to do with the big picture. We are in the very early stages of a digital currency revolution. It's a story that's much bigger than Bitcoin. And frankly, what's happening right now in terms of every single cryptocurrency trade which has ever occurred is it's all very early-stage speculation in a very unpredictable and wild market. Where this is really headed is not clear yet. But what's clear to me is the odds of Bitcoin being a big part of the story are much lower than the Bitcoin crowd seems to think they are.
Patrick Ceresna: You know, what's interesting about that, Erik, is that Bitcoin has always been the largest and one that has gained the most attention, but there is now rifts between many coiners that are basically either supporting Ethereum or Dogecoin. And so I have charts on page 11 and 12 of the other cryptos out there. And what's interesting is that there has been very clear bullish momentum in Ethereum, which has still remained very decisively in trend. And certainly, Dogecoin has certainly also been getting a lot of attention on page 12 and working as well. So it's interesting that while we can argue that Bitcoin has lost a lot of that momentum, what is interesting is that there are still cryptocurrencies out there that are doing half decent.
Erik Townsend: Well, and I think if you wanted to analyze this in any meaningful way, the comparison of the relative performance of these different currencies is much more interesting. Interesting than the absolute performance of the group. And certainly looking at the contrast between page 10 and page 11, I think you're finally starting to see a little bit of market realization of something that's frankly been obvious to anybody with a technology background for years, which is Ethereum has always been technologically superior, more functional, more flexible platform for For not just digital currency, but an entire decentralized finance future, which is coming. Ethereum has always been better. The number of people who knew that was small enough that the price of Bitcoin, which has always been more popular and which certainly was first, was ahead. So now we see a little bit of market recognition of technological superiority, but you don't even know if that's really what's driving it. Because frankly, the Dogecoin thing, as I understand it, Patrick, Dogecoin is literally just another cryptocurrency.
Somebody literally just took the source code and copied it and made a joke out of it and said, look, I created my own cryptocurrency. And they said, hey, did it as a joke but made money on it. And, you know, all of a sudden it's back really just because Elon, I think, says it's back. So you look at what I think is driving the Ethereum price, I think that really is a recognition by smart people that Ethereum is more suitable than Bitcoin as being the basis of decentralized finance solutions in the real world. The Dogecoin thing, I think, is Elon talking up nonsense, something that never made any sense and suddenly got popular because Elon started talking it up. So we're at a very, you know, we're at the infancy of this market, and it's still being driven by factors that have very little to do with logic and rational assessment and much more to do with herds and trends and people getting excited about things they don't understand.
Erik Townsend: Very similar to the late '90s with the dot-com stocks.
I just want to remind everyone as we close that if you want, you can get Patrick's chart deck not just once a week, but every day. with a free trial of Big Picture Trading, Patrick's service. You could find out more at bigpicturetrading.com or on page 13 of the slide deck.
We're going to leave it there for this week's episode. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Genesis Volatility, provider of institutional-grade crypto options analytics.
Patrick Ceresna: Thank you.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, tell them what's in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, where you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the Harley Bassman slides and the chart book we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to an Oil Price article on America's multi-trillion-dollar infrastructure security crisis, and as well as a link to a Jesse Felder piece on gold's recent headwind shifts to a tailwind. And so you'll find You can find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter. Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account today. Account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more We'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll Answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily. Reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Dylan Grice — formerly of SocGen fame and now co-founder of Calderwood Capital (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 270 was recorded on May 6th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Masterworks.io, bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Dylan Grice, formerly of SocGen fame and now co-founder of Calderwood Capital, joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from inflation versus deflation to how far bond yields can go to the outlook for asset markets. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick has prepared a slide deck titled Sector Rotation or Start of Bigger Correction. Question mark. We'll have that right after the feature interview.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's just jump to that S&P 500, which up about 9 points at the time of recording. We're at 4,170. Really, it's just the market's been more or less sideways for several weeks now after approaching 4,200. You think this is just a consolidation in your mind?
Erik Townsend: You know, to me, anything that's above the 50-day moving average is just noise. This market has really, I think, ignored a lot of fundamentals and charged higher. And I think it's gonna continue doing exactly that. And I do think it's more crack-up boom than fundamentals-driven, but I don't see any reason not to expect higher numbers.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, we can take a deeper dive into that in the postgame when I have some charts that kind of covers the topic of how these sectors are breaking down. So let's move on to that US dollar, which really continues to just muddle along. Like, it's been more or less distributive over the last month. We're about the 91 handle, and just, it doesn't seem like the dollar wants to do anything any conviction. What do you think's in store for the dollar from here?
Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, Patrick, we're still consolidating sideways, and that's the way I look at this chart. I look at that whole month-long excursion above 92 is really just probably a short squeeze-induced anomaly. I think we're really in a sideways consolidation that's going to last however long it's going to last and doesn't really show any signs of changing right now.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because crude approached those February-March highs near $67. And we've a little bit of selling here. We're about $65 at the time of recording. What's your take here on crude? Do you think it's just going to keep plowing higher?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it was the API inventory report that really kind of got things going on Tuesday afternoon. They called for a big drawdown on crude oil inventories, about 3 times bigger than consensus analyst expectations. That really got the party Yeah. So the market was already going with a big move to the upside this week in crude oil. It was mostly all ahead of inventory, though, ahead of the official EIA inventory. When EIA inventory came out, sure enough, they confirmed an 8 million barrel draw on crude oil inventories.
That would actually be 9 million if you included the additional 1 million that came out of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. Cushing, Oklahoma, building 254,000 barrels. Gasoline building 737,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 2.5 million barrels. 10.9 million barrels, with US production holding steady at 10.9 million barrels. Overall, Patrick, at the time that the data came out, I think by then the, the market was already above the trend resistance line. It was overbought, and by the time the data came out, it was a sell-the-news event, and it's been selling off since then.
But I think this is just a case of the market catching its breath. We're back down to the 5-day moving average as we speak now on Thursday afternoon, just a It's about exactly on it at $64.84. And I think this is still a strong uptrend. I think we're headed back to probably find some resistance at the previous high around $68. Eventually we'll get through it. That puts $70 in the sights. And once we get a close over $71 or so, then $75 comes into view.
And then I think $80 by the end of summer. I do have a scenario, Patrick, where I think we could go much higher, like $147 a barrel plus, new highs, All-time highs, but that would require a number of factors kind of lining up together. And I think it would probably be more like in the summer of 2022 rather than this summer that I would see maybe a really big upside excursion in oil prices. But I think we're headed for $80 this summer and probably higher than that.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because we broke out of that multi-week consolidation and above $1,800 where that 200-day moving average was. Is this breakout in gold legit in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm looking at my notes here, Patrick, and what I had planned to say today is gold has just one more thing to do in order to really lock in the story that this is a confirmed new uptrend, and that is to get above the 100-day moving average and have a closing print there. Sure enough, we got that today, and it was a very decisive one. It's not only above the 100-day moving average at $1,800, but it's like $15 above it. It's not right on the line or anything, so it was a very Decisive breakout.
At this point, I wouldn't be at all surprised to see a little bit of relief selling to go back down and test that $1,800 as a support level, and then I would expect to see new highs to happen from there. So I think we're headed higher in gold. The one caveat I have to throw out is if it turns out that it's not over for the 10-year Treasury yield and we start seeing the 10-year yield back up over 2%, that's going to change everything, and I think we'll be plumbing new lows for But shy of something going wrong with the 10-year, I think it's all up from here.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, since you're talking about the 10-year yield, let's touch on that. I mean, we're trading around 1.57% right now on the yield, and more or less, and it really hasn't moved much in the last couple weeks in spite of a pretty strong commodity rally and some inflation pressures. Really, the 10-year yield doesn't seem to wanna get anything going. What's your take on it over here?
Erik Townsend: Well, it seems like at least we've found where the comfort zone is. It seems like below 1.6, and we're just barely below 1.6 now, seems to be where the market's finding that comfy zone where people are not freaking out and everything's happy. As soon as we get above 1.7 or so, people start freaking out and other markets like gold and stock market starts to take a nosedive. So it seems like we know Kind of the 1.7 is about where the, the red line in the sand is.
I really have no idea what's going to happen next. And I'm finding that the more I ask different macro analysts, I don't think anybody's really sure exactly what comes next. I'm not hearing a lot of conviction about directional calls people are making on where the 10-year is headed from here. And I don't have one myself. So I guess we'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Calderwood Capital founder, Dylan Grice. Now, Erik, why did we invite Dylan on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Dylan's name has been really big in macro since his days as an analyst at SocGen, Société Générale. And he's since had a couple of other positions, and then he went to launch his own fund and co-founded Calderwood. Really smart guy. Had never had him on MacroVoices before. He's kind of one of those names where you kind of come across and say, how the heck did we never invite this guy? So we decided to give him a shot.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Dylan Grice is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies. In addition to sponsoring MacroVoices, Abaxx also produces Smarter Markets, a weekly podcast that airs every Saturday morning on Spotify, YouTube, and all the other major podcast platforms. Smarter Markets Smarter Markets brings together the leading minds in macroeconomics, technology, and commodities to explore how capital markets can be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Todd Buchholz's inaugural episode of the podcast with Stefan Weiler is available on smartermarketspod.com now, and Todd will be back on Saturday morning with Arjun Murti as we continue to explore the transition to carbon neutrality. Arjun has been analyzing the global energy sector for nearly 30 years and spent over 20 years as an equity research analyst and partner at Goldman Sachs. But you won't find Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to receive this free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, Next, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Dylan Grice, who's probably best known from his days at SocGen, but these days he's co-founder of Calderwood Capital. Dylan, great to have you. First time on the show. Let's start with a question I've been asking just about everybody, which is, boy, all of our favorite deflationists have turned into not just inflationists, but many of them secular inflationists who really say this is maybe Another late '60s, early '70s beginning of a big event. Would you agree with that? And if so, what are you doing about it?
Dylan Grice: Well, hello, Erik, and thanks for the big opening question. It's a tough one. So to rewind for 10 years, to be brutally honest, I was very much in the structural inflation camp. I was very much of the opinion that we were about to see the whites of inflation's eyes.
And that it was going to be the defining characteristic of financial market behavior, really, across the asset classes. It was going to be the driver of asset returns, really, over the next decade. Of course, I was thinking this in 2010.
And I was writing about it a lot. And the fact is, I was completely wrong. And so I'm kind of very hesitant to make the same mistake again. And I think, and I definitely look back on it, and I look at some of my reasoning 10 years ago, when I kind of thought that inflation was about to take off.
I actually kind of retraced my steps, and I reread some of the stuff that I wrote. And what I actually said was, so back in 2010, the one I remember, the prediction that I remember making that I wrote, I said, in 10 years' time, we will be looking at the whites of the eyes of an inflation problem. And not an inflation, not by 100 or 200 basis points, but Inflation, which is becoming uncontrolled, inflation, which is getting out of control. And so inflation of a kind of 4% to 5% rate, and a rate which was accelerating.
So that was my kind of prediction in 2010 for what the world in 2020 would look like. And pandemic aside, 10-year breakevens were 50 basis points lower on the eve of the pandemic than they were when I was making my prediction.
So I was just horribly, horribly wrong. And I think you got to try and understand why you were so wrong before you try and make the same prediction again. So I guess the summary answer is, I don't really know. The simple answer is, I'm not quite sure.
Erik Townsend: Well, I was reading your work, Dylan, in 2010, and I agreed with you emphatically. And we were both emphatically wrong together as a result. So here we are. And it seems to me that at this point, The evidence is just so overwhelmingly clear that we're headed toward a secular inflation event. But, you know, I kind of thought that 10 years ago too, and we both got it wrong. So what do you do from a process standpoint when, you know, you know, you've got a really important view on the market that happens to be the same one that you got really badly wrong not that long ago?
Dylan Grice: Yeah, well, that's— I mean, okay, so that's, that's a great question. And I think, how do you build a portfolio on the assumption that some of your key inputs might be completely wrong? In other words, how do you build a portfolio which is robust to your ignorance? So that's what we tried to do at Calderwood That's what I've been doing, really, for the last 7 or 8 years at the family office.
When I left SocGen, I went to work at a family office in Switzerland, one of the largest family offices in Europe. And I kind of helped establish their liquid investment division. And the kind of starting point for our investment process was really one of accepting your ignorance and not trying to— which I think is very consistent with the capital preservation mentality.
Right. So if you're trying to, you know, if you're trying to kind of 10x or 20x or 100x your money, then that's a different kind of mindset. You know, you're actually making bets on things that you that you think you know, because you're trying to get rich. Whereas when you're in a kind of family office, and you're helping to build a family office, the family's already rich. They just don't want to be poor.
So the focus isn't trying to kind of 10x or 20x or 30x the capital. The focus is on keeping, maintaining its real purchasing power, first and foremost. And secondly, hopefully growing that purchasing power in real terms. But it's a different mindset. And the mindset is set The starting point is ignorance. So I think if you're doing that properly, it shouldn't really matter whether you get inflation right or wrong.
Right. And so that's kind of where we're at from a money management perspective. In terms of your— to answer your kind of question specifically on inflation, you said that today it's more compelling now than it even was then. And I completely hear you and completely understand. But I think that there's just something about— we clearly didn't understand. We clearly don't understand inflation as well as we think.
And by the way, that's not just guys like us who've got it wrong. That's not just the guys who saw QE, put 2 and 2 together, and came up with 7, and got completely the wrong answer.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: I think what that episode demonstrates is that People just— guys like us didn't understand inflation as well as we thought.
But you can flip it over. And I think that a lot of the MMT guys and girls, Stephanie Kelton, for example, their premise is that they do understand inflation. Their premise is that we can spend all this money, we can print all this money, and we can print this money, and we can do lots of good stuff with this printed money, and it's not going to cause inflation.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: Because we just know, because look, it hasn't caused inflation in the past, so it's not going to cause inflation in the future. So they're the ones who equally, I think that they're also deluding themselves into thinking that they understand inflation. And I think that maybe an advantage that we have, or certainly an advantage I feel I have, is that I actually kind of know that I don't understand it. And I can kind of build a portfolio that doesn't need me to understand it. Right? I just have to understand that it's a risk that may or may not materialize.
Erik Townsend: Well, it seems to me like what we know is pretty clear, which is that there is a huge amount of fiscal stimulus and, and money being created. The mistake we made last time was that QE was creating bank reserves that didn't really go into the real economy and create competitive demand for goods and services. Seems pretty darn clear to me that the list of people that are being offered Handouts of some kind, transfer payments, some kind of stimulus support, is pretty darn long. And there are not conditions attached to what you have to spend the money on. You know, you get your stimulus check, you can spend it on whatever you wanna spend it on.
So it seems pretty darn clear to me, but you know, as you say, we were kind of wrong last time. What do you do? Are you a big investor in inflation hedges? like gold and crypto and other things that people who are inflationists invest in, or how do you approach it?
Dylan Grice: Yeah, that's a really, really good question. I mean, so the simple answer is— so, okay, so I mean, by the way, I mean, yes, I agree with you, right? This kind of money is actually going into people's pockets, whereas before it was going into the financial system, i.e., bankers' pockets. And it was also going into rich people's pockets, right? Because it was inflating asset prices.
Although there's plenty of that this time around as well. But yes, you're actually helicopter dropping money into people's bank accounts. And that's different.
And ultimately, I think if you can conduct a thought experiment, this idea that central banks can't create inflation, which you hear a lot of and you used to hear a lot of, I've always had a problem with that argument. Because if you just think of the following thought experiment, suppose you put $1 billion into every American's bank account, right? You printed $1 billion for every single bank account. What do you think would happen to inflation? Right? Obviously, it's going to go up. It has to be, right? And then you say, well, that's obviously stupid because they would never do that. And you say, okay, well, suppose it wasn't $1 billion. Suppose it was $1 million.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: Right? And then you say, well, now what do you think the effect would be? Do you think the effect would be inflationary or not? And of course, the answer would be inflationary, right? People would just suddenly start going out and spending money, and there wouldn't be the kind of supply to meet that demand. And so prices would go up. And then people say, well, they're not going to do $1 million either, right? And then you say, well, OK, well, what if it's $500,000? Or what if it's $100,000?
Or what if it— at some point, it has to become inflationary.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: And so we've now opened up that door, and we're now walking down that path. And I'm not quite sure what the way back is from it. That's now become a policy tool. So I totally agree with you that that does actually— that's a tick in the box for the inflationists. That's going to be inflationary. And then the second thing is, well, even if it's not inflationary this time around, then there's no constraint on them doing it even more next time around.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: So they do even more. So where's the constraint on this? And the answer is, I don't think there really is much of a constraint. And so I totally get the inflationists' argument and their fears. And frankly, I have huge, huge sympathy with them. But I think that the irony is that what that means is the inflation trade, if you like, or the inflation protection, is kind of easy.
I don't think it's difficult to get inflation protection in your portfolio. As you said, gold, crypto. Someone this morning, some fund advisor gave feedback on our fund, and they said that they didn't think our fund was worth it because you could get inflation protection from inflation-protected Treasuries.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: So, you know, okay, you're locking in a negative return if you buy TIPS today. What's the yield? Negative 70, negative 80 basis points on the 10-year, I think. So that's a guaranteed loss of purchasing power if you buy TIPS. So, you know, arguably the inflation hedges, they're easy to get, but they're arguably quite expensive, right? They're not that attractive. So I think you have to think kind of carefully about what you're doing there. So that's the first point.
The second is, in the 1970s, during a kind of stagflation, you get recessions as well as inflations. And so you want that. You still actually want some kind of protection for that deflationary tail. When you see a market crash or a market event, what that is typically pricing in is some kind of recession or some kind of credit event or some kind of depression.
So in other words, these kind of left-side tails are kind of pricing in deflation. And so if you want tail protection and tail hedging, what you're also saying is you want deflation hedging. And so that's a difficult thing to get.
And so in terms of the challenge of building a portfolio, the kind of inflation-deflation argument, I don't actually think it's as difficult or as fruitful because ultimately, we're all guessing. The question is, well, okay, what is the inflation trade or what's the tail protection? I think that's the most difficult one to answer. I'm not sure I've got good answers to it, by the way, but I think that's the more difficult question.
Erik Townsend: Well, since we've taken the unusual approach, Dylan, of starting this interview talking about things we're clueless about, let's move on to Treasury yields. Something that, I mean, I can tell you, I agree unequivocally that the US 10-year yield is the most important thing to figure out in the world of macro right now today. I personally have no clue where it's headed next. Do you?
Dylan Grice: No, I don't. But I think that there's a pretty obvious asymmetry, right? I mean, I said that the thing that actually engages me or has engaged me and my partners for the last few years is What does the world look like when you have a bear market in bonds? And I don't just mean over the last quarter, which was a big move. We saw a very big quarterly move, I think 80-odd basis points in the 10-year.
It was actually an outlier. If you go back 120-odd years of data, it was kind of— I think it was 3rd percentile or something like that, 3rd or 4th percentile.
So that was a big move. But that's not a bear market, right? That's just a bad quarter. A bear market is when you say, well, in 5 years' time, the 10-year Treasury yield will be 5%. And 10 years after that, it will be 15%. And 10 years after that, it will be 25%. In other words, a structural bear market, which grinds higher, sees yields grinding higher and higher, and really defines this the current generation and the up-and-coming financial generation's careers. That's the kind of bear market that you're talking about. And in terms of the probability distribution of what happens, the range of outcomes, clearly, you're not going to get— in 20 years' time, I'm willing to bet quite a lot of money that you're not going to see -20% yields.
But I do think There's a very good chance you'll see plus 20% yields. So it's massively skewed. And I think it kind of bothers me, really. It does. I think it's quite scary to think about what— what do you think the equity market looks like when government bonds are at 20%?
What do these private equity funds— what do their IRRs look like when you're looking at a 20% bond yield? Right. On the journey to that 20%, what does venture IRRs— what do they look like?
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: In this kind of world, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Where's real estate? I think that that's kind of quite a worrying idea. And I think if you're not thinking about how to protect it and you're a fiduciary or something, you're not really doing your job properly, frankly.
Erik Townsend: Dylan, you recently penned an article saying that there is plenty of room for a big rally in crude oil. I happen to agree with you, but I'm very curious to get your reasons.
Dylan Grice: Well, you've just seen a complete collapse in capacity. You've seen a collapse in CAPEX. So I think that the oil markets are going to be incredibly tight, basically, over the next few years. And that tightness, I think, is something which is going to really bite. The oil markets haven't recovered since the shale gale, really, of '14. And just as they were getting back on their feet, '18, '19, they got hit by the pandemic. And negative crude prices is the kind of The poster for just how kind of crazy that time was.
There has been absolutely no investment in the supply chain. I think CAPEX is probably about half what it was pre-shale. Even the shale guys who are kind of notoriously poor capital allocators are kind of saying that they've now got this kind of new religion, which is kind of shareholder value. And they've kind of realized that Shareholder value isn't the same as kind of drilling at every opportunity. So I think there's been this kind of change in the mindset and the kind of swing players. And as I said, just more kind of prosaically, there's just not going to be the supply to really meet future demand. And then so that's why I think you get higher crude prices from here. I think in the kind of markets, like in the stock market, Or private markets and credit markets. Obviously, there's this whole kind of move towards the energy transition. And obviously, that's a thing.
And so I think people have been very, very quick to kind of conclude that oil demand growth is going to be a thing of the past and that oil is kind of yesterday's commodity.
And I think it's kind of difficult really to see that, certainly on a 10-year view. I think that you're probably going to see more oil vehicles on the road over the next 10 years rather than less. In fact, if you actually back out Bloomberg's numbers from Bloomberg's New Energy Finance survey, I think the implied growth rate for combustible passenger vehicles is something like 70 basis points a year annualized over the next 10 years. So in 10 years' time, there's going to be more petrol-fueled passenger cars, not less. And of course, you've still got heavy-duty trucks. There's no non-hydrocarbon solution for trucks, for heavy-duty vehicles. And you still have petrochemicals.
And by the way, I'm not saying that this is a good thing. That's just what it is. But oil demand is going to grow from here. So you've got growing oil demand at a time when you've had an absolute collapse in the capacity of the supply chain. So I think that we need more The world needs more oil supply capacity, and the only way you get that is with higher prices. So I think it's a pretty standard commodity cycle, really.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, this is something that fascinates me quite a bit. I think there's no doubt that we are in the beginning of a process that takes us to decarbonization and eliminating the need to operate vehicles with fuels that are derived from petroleum. But boy, you talk about people en masse underestimating the size of a transition.
And I just, I can't believe, you know, people are talking about 5 years from now, there won't be any more vehicles, you know, oil or gasoline or diesel-driven vehicles. I think this is gonna take longer than anybody takes. And particularly what I don't hear any public discussion about is the necessary build-out of the electric grid that would be required in order to support all these electric vehicles people think are coming tomorrow morning. How do you see this playing out? And what are the, what are the gotchas, things like the build-out of the electric grid that nobody's talking about, that maybe you're seeing that other people aren't?
Dylan Grice: Well, I think, you know, I'm not sure that we have any kind of great insight into the kind of specifics of of the energy infrastructure, to be honest. We've looked at a lot of energy. So we're a fund of funds, right? So we look across the whole kind of spectrum. We've looked at a lot of kind of energy-specific managers, but they're typically very niche and very kind of narrow domain kind of sectors of the energy market. And so I'll kind of make that excuse before I kind of give my answer.
I suppose the conclusion we've reached is that I think there's just probably a More broadly than just oil, I think we're looking at the commodity bull market again, because what we've seen really since the kind of GFC, and certainly since the collapse of oil in 2014, has been this real collapse in capacity. It's not just true in oil, but it's true in most commodity markets. Uranium, I think, is a kind of obvious decarbonization one that I think is very interesting. But just more generally, I think that we're probably looking at a commodity bull market for the battery, for the batteries that are going to need to be built, for the grid infrastructure that's going to need to be built. So I think that that's kind of— in terms of making bets on the future, that would be one that— and obviously, I've just kind of spent time talking about how we try not to make those bets in the future. But if we can kind of put ourselves in a position where if that happens, we're going to do well, And if it doesn't, we're still going to be okay.
That would be one of those areas. The commodity markets more generally, I think, are probably set for— I mean, they're already on fire at the moment, but I think that they're set for probably a multi-year bull run from here.
Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on the way you've said a couple of times that you really try to focus on not making assumptions or making bets on things. You kind of feel like inflation is where we're headed, but you don't want to place that bet because you could be wrong. And you don't want to make the wrong bet on electric vehicles because you could be wrong. What do you end up doing in a portfolio then if you're trying to avoid a directional commitment?
Dylan Grice: So maybe I haven't been articulating it maybe as clearly as I should. It's not that we try and avoid the bet because frankly, you can't avoid the bet. Right? You know, it's like you can't avoid risk. If you get out of bed in the morning, you're taking risk, right? But of course, if you stay in bed, then you're just taking a different kind of risk. You spend the rest of your life in bed, and you're risking all sorts of kind of you know muscle atrophy and certain diseases and you know horrible.
So there's no way to avoid risk, and so there's no real way to avoid certain bets. What what I'm actually saying is that. We're kind of looking for just very, very skewed return profiles. So the way I kind of think about the portfolio, suppose you want to take a bet on— all right, we've talked about inflation. And I think we're on the same page. We think it's something that we're both worried about.
We both want to— suppose we both want to take that bet on inflation. Well, we could say— here's the obvious thing. Inflation is going to go up. Yields are going to go up. We're going to enter a bear market in duration. Why don't we just short government bonds from here? We'll short Treasuries. We'll short JGBs or something.
And actually, maybe JGB is not the best example.
We'll short Treasuries from here. The problem with that is if we get it wrong, we're going to lose money. If we get it right, fantastic. We're going to be heroes. And I'm sure in 5 or 10 years' time, there will be plenty of heroes who got that call right. But the problem is there's plenty of people who've been putting that trade on who have ended their careers or who've got themselves into trouble because they have been wrong, right? Because it's actually quite a symmetric bet, right? If you're right on inflation, you're going to make a lot of money. But if you're wrong on inflation, you're going to lose a lot of money. So the typical way to get around that is some kind of derivative structure where you've got the option, right? So you buy an option. The problem is you buy options you have to pay the premium.
And typically, the premium is priced so that it's actually quite difficult to make that money consistently by just buying options all the time. The guys who make the money from options are the people who are selling the options typically. So it's just, how do you have your cake and eat it? How do you get yourself in a position where you say, well, OK, if inflation rips from here, we're going to be fine. We're actually going to do pretty well. But if inflation doesn't rip from here, we're still going to be fine. Right? We're still going to do quite well.
And I think that's what we try to do. And I said, I think that's the challenge. That's where the intellectual challenge becomes a bit more interesting.
Anyone could buy gold or go short gold if they're a deflationist. Anyone can do that. But it's very symmetric. Building in the asymmetry, I think, is much more interesting. So that's what I meant.
Erik Townsend: And where do you see the most opportune asymmetric trades in the market right now?
Dylan Grice: Well, it's not necessarily a trade so much as a strategy. I said we're a fund of funds. So we invest in different types of managers, and they do different types of things. And if you think about the types of managers we invest in, you say, well, you've said you don't want duration in your portfolio. So you don't want any fixed income.
And actually, if you broaden out that idea with TIPS at a negative yield, Because it's not just that nominal duration has been on a tear, but real duration. It's actually been real duration.
Inflation expectations have been quite stable over the last 10 to 15 years, arguably actually over the last 20 years. So the bull market has been in real duration, not nominal, not just nominal duration. It's been in real duration. And it's gone to such an extent that real yields are now negative and the inflation Protected securities market. So suppose you say, well, we don't just want nominal duration, we don't want any real duration either. Okay, well, that means we don't have any nominal fixed income, we don't have any government bonds, we don't have any corporate bonds, we don't have any credit really, certainly fixed income credit, but we don't have any real duration either. Well, that's equities, right? And it's obviously TIPS. But if we are saying we don't want any real duration in the portfolio, we don't want any nominal duration, We're also saying we're worried about inflation risk. We're worried about duration risk here.
This is not a train that we want to be on. But if we don't want to take that risk, that means we can't take equities. We can't take credit. We can't take government bonds. We can't take anything that looks like those things. So we can't take private equity. We can't take venture. We can't take long-short equity. We can't take event-driven.
We can't take vanilla structured credit, because that's all basically just equity in disguise. We can't take risk arbitrage. And you're like, well, hang on. What can you take? Because you just named 85% of the alternative investments universe. So that leaves us with that 15% of the alternative investment universe, which isn't any of those things.
So that's what we do. And if you get Once you start thinking in those terms, it leads you on a particular path that we've been on for a few years now.
And that is, as I said, it is hedge funds. It is niche strategies. It's very, very high expertise, narrow domain managers who frankly don't know a whole lot about much, but they really, really know what they do inside out. And it allows us to create a very idiosyncratic portfolio, really, as well, a portfolio of very orthogonal idiosyncratic risks.
But we get to be very precise about the risk we want to take. So if we don't want to take duration risk, we don't take duration risk. And so I don't know if that answers your question. I'll stop there. But that's how we do it. It's not the trade. It's what's the strategy or what's the portfolio construction strategy? That's how we answered the question.
Erik Townsend: Dylan, since you're in Europe, I want to get your perspective on the ECB under its new management and just big picture. Where are we headed in terms of what I think is a competitive devaluation between central banks? But where do you think central bank policy is headed globally from here in this this new era that we have with new leadership in both the ECB and the Fed?
Dylan Grice: I think these things typically move in tandem. And one of the things I found quite astonishing— I know your question was on the ECB, but just to kick off with the Fed, because I think the ECB is really kind of— Lagarde, I think, in many ways is echoing Powell, but Powell really set the running I think it was at Jackson Hole last year when he really made a big thing about how he thought it was their job to do more good in the economy and to do more good in society.
So I don't know if you saw or how much you read directly on his speeches, but he made a big deal about how the problem of unemployment is unevenly distributed and it particularly hurts disadvantaged minority communities. And he saw it as the Fed's role to really, really ride to their rescue. And so part of his kind of thinking is that unemployment needs to be lower, and the Fed therefore needs to drive unemployment much lower than it has been in the past, because this is the way that the Fed can really help these disadvantaged, poorer minority communities.
All right. So there was this kind of social aspect to Fed policy, political motivation to Fed policy that you're kind of seeing. And I just kind of feel— obviously, he's been more explicit. But I think Lagarde is— she's a politician. She's a former French finance minister. She's been at the IMF. She's political. She's intensely political.
I just feel that we're seeing a kind of echo of Powell's sentiments at the ECB, really. So I feel that we're actually just seeing a huge kind of policy mistake, a global kind of policy mistake being led by the Fed. But I think all the other central banks are kind of falling into line. And that policy mistake is kind of hiding from making the big decisions, hiding behind the CPI. And hiding behind this idea that the CPI is not a problem, so policy is fine.
The CPI is not ripping here, so everything's going to be fine. CPI is still roughly 2% or 1.5% or whatever. And therefore, the fact that credit spreads are crazy tight, the fact that underwriting is being done on crazy terms, the fact that you've got signs of froth and excess in pretty much every market you look at, whether it's SPAC markets, crypto markets, credit markets, none of that matters. We don't have to pay attention to that because the CPI is just fine. I think that's the kind of policy mistake that we're seeing at the moment.
Erik Townsend: Let's come back to what you said about the ECB and the Fed both becoming politicalized or politicized, I guess is the word. Christine Lagarde has made comments. I make I make the joke, you know, the Fed has a dual mandate of steady employment and so forth. I think the ECB has taken up a dual mandate of solving climate change and racial inequality.
Dylan Grice: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: She's almost come out and said that, not quite, but pretty darn close. It sounds like you and I agree that there's a trend here, which is there are politicians, people like Jerome Powell and Christine Lagarde, who are politicians at heart, Who are in positions where they really ought to be focusing on the ball that's in front of their face, which is the economy. But as a politician, they know what's appealing right now to reach out. And, you know, if you're trying to win political points, you definitely want to do it on social justice in some way. And they're somehow, you know, there's this, this charter or, or, uh, mission scope drift that's going on where central bankers are saying, you know, I might be a central banker, but at the end of the day, I'm a politician. And politicians always look for the, the social justice win they can make in order to be more popular politicians.
What are the risks of our central banks turning into politically motivated mouthpieces, if you will, for, for politicians, which is what these people really are?
Dylan Grice: I mean, to actually kind of go back to One of the things we were talking about earlier, which is inflation risk, and kind of wary of sounding like all roads leads to Rome, all roads lead to inflation risk discussion. But when I did go back, remember I said I was kind of confident that we were in the foothills of an inflation crisis 10 years ago.
And here we are. We still haven't seen it. So I went back, and I tried to try and pick apart my thinking and what I got wrong.
And one of the things that I'd really underestimated was the role of central bank independence. And the notion that more money printing must invariably lead to higher inflation, like next year or the year after, because historically it has been. But there were plenty of episodes historically where that had been the case. In previous episodes where that had been the case, the central banks were run really badly, like really, really badly. And certainly in the UK, the central banks were overtly nationalized.
Right. And so it wasn't the central bank that set interest rates. The central bank was basically just— the central bank governor was basically just a guy pulling the lever whenever the finance minister, the chancellor of the exchequer in the UK, told him to.
Right. So it was the finance ministry. It was the chancellor who decided when to change interest rates. And of course, the chancellor was a politician. He was an elected politician. And it was a huge advantage to the incumbent prime minister or to the incumbent political party in the UK that you controlled interest rates, because what you could do is you would basically keep interest rates too low in the run-up to an election.
Because obviously, you would generate, create that feel-good factor, and the feel-good factor typically benefited the incumbent. Once you'd won the election, once you'd kept interest rates too low, you won the election, the economy is overheating, inflation is rising, then you jack up interest rates, and then you create a recession, because you think, well, obviously, this is going to hurt, and everyone's going to be really irritated and annoyed at us, but they can't vote for another 4 or 5 years. So we might as well get it out the way now.
In other words, there was a huge political cycle in interest rate setting, and arguably the political cycle was the dominant cycle. It was the dominant kind of informational input into interest rate setting.
Right. So the political cycle of interest rates, I think, was one of the real reasons why you had such an inflation problem in the '70s. And the removal of that was that the removal of that political interference was one of the reasons why I think inflation actually went on this secular downward path. And I think if you reread the literature of the '70s and the '80s on central bank independence and inflation targeting, I think it's kind of obvious that that had just such a hugely powerful effect on the structure of inflation expectation setting and the structure of interest rate setting, the dynamic of interest rate setting.
And I think that that really— because the underlying idea is that, which I think is true, is that economies are fundamentally deflationary. It's part of the human condition to try and do more with less.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Dylan Grice: Ever since some caveman or Neanderthal picked up a spear and threw it at an animal, He was trying to do more with less, because it was much easier to throw the spear than it was to chase the animal. And then when he put some kind of a piece of flint and sharpened flint on the end of that stick, and so on and so forth. So I think it's very much who we are. We try and do more with less. And that's basically, in modern terms, that's deflation. So the economy is deflationary. And by the way, yes, I've never really quite understood this fixation with deflation being this terrible thing that we all have to be really scared of.
Anyway, if the default position of an economy is deflation, when you introduce this political calculus into interest rate setting, then you start to create inflation. So I think the removal of that political calculus, which is what we saw with central bank independence, is really what allowed economies to start behaving a bit more like their usual selves, which is kind of deflation machines.
So that's kind of the first part to this kind of politicization of central banks. What does it mean that the central banks I think we now have virtue signaling central banks, certainly for the first time, maybe in history. In other words, we have highly politicized central banks who are trying to achieve political goals. I think that this is a huge step backwards, and I think that this undoes a lot of the benefits to having an independent central bank, because Greenspan was clearly political.
Any notion that Greenspan was not a politician— I actually once had a a dinner with Sebastian Mallaby, who wrote the biography on Greenspan. He spent 4 years with the guy. And someone at the table said, what's the one thing you've learned about Greenspan that you didn't know before and that you think would really surprise people? And he said, straight off the bat, the one thing that people don't understand about Greenspan is that they all think he's some kind of technocrat economist. He's a politician. He's ultimately deeply political. He loves Washington. He loves the power.
And so central banking— Bernanke was exactly the same. I think that central banking attracts that type of personality. And increasingly with this virtue signaling that you're seeing in the ECB or at the Fed, I think that you're actually seeing the renewed politicization of central bank calculation. And therefore, I think that that ultimately creates a kind of inflationary impetus into kind of policy setting. So very long-winded answer, but I I think that's where it does ultimately make me much more nervous about inflation. I think even aware of the mistakes I made 10 years ago, I can see how this is a new piece of information. The growing politicization of central banks and this new unconstrained tool of the printing press, I think this is a new data point that we didn't have 10 years ago.
Erik Townsend: Yeah. Dylan, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. But before I let you go, I want to talk about Popular Delusions, the newsletter that you write. This is one of the better ones. It's not a free one, unfortunately. I guess some of your investors in your fund get it for free, but you do have to subscribe. We got a free sample for our MacroVoices listeners. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not registered. Just go to the homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says, looking for the downloads above Dylan's picture. Dylan, tell us about Popular Delusions, what it is, what people can expect to find there.
Dylan Grice: Yeah, well, it's— you know, I said we— I think we see a lot of very interesting stuff in financial markets. You know, as you know, you know, we— our primary focus is in running the fund. We invest in very niche strategies, very niche managers. And so kind of informationally, we're at a very kind of— we sit at a very interesting juncture. We're active in reinsurance markets, life insurance markets, synthetic credit markets, credit markets, private credit markets, cryptocurrency markets, litigation markets, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, and a whole bunch of other stuff as well. And of course, We kind of pay attention to the more vanilla asset classes. A lot of our subscribers are institutional asset managers.
So I think that we've set a very interesting kind of informational vantage point. And we write about it. We write about what we see in the fund. We write about some of the opportunities. It is geared towards actionable investment ideas. Right. So it's more than just a kind of commentary on whether we think that central banks are doing the right thing or not, or any of that, these kind of higher-level conversations, which is why we do actually charge for it and don't give it out for free. But we leverage really the research that goes into the fund and we publish it so that even people who don't invest in the fund can still get access to our thinking and hopefully get some value from that.
Erik Townsend: And the sample issue here has both an article about uranium as well as an article about what will happen if Treasury yields continue backing up. And will it burst or derail the bubble in equities? Dylan, for people who are interested either investing in your fund for accredited investors or just contacting you if they want to subscribe to the newsletter, how should they do so?
Dylan Grice: Well, the easiest way to get a hold of me is on Twitter. So I'm there, Dylan Grice. I think you should be able to find me easily enough. I'm kind of in and out. I'm not super active on it, but I'm active enough to reply to messages pretty quickly.
Erik Townsend: Fantastic. Well, we look forward to having you back for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Monetary and fiscal measures by governments and central banks are inflating asset prices globally. As investors prepare for future inflation, demand for scarce real assets is rising. How does the 1% prepare for this? They invest in art. Masterworks.io is the first company that lets you invest in multimillion-dollar paintings at a fraction of the cost from artists like Basquiat and Keith Haring. 84% of ultra-high-net-worth individuals collect art, according to a 2019 Deloitte survey. And it makes sense. According to Citi Private Bank, contemporary art returned 13.6% year over year in the last 25 years versus 8.9% for the S&P 500. Over the same period, art had the lowest correlation to the stock market of the 10 major asset classes. Masterworks.io is making art investing accessible to everyone regardless of accreditation.
Start diversifying your net worth today. Visit Masterworks.io to learn more. See important information at Masterworks.io.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Dylan on the show, but I'm looking forward to diving into the chart deck to kind of talk about how the rotation's been occurring in these equity markets.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link for Patrick's chart deck in your Research Roundup Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. So just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says Looking for the Downloads just above Dylan's picture on the homepage. Patrick, sector rotation or bigger correction? Which is it?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I wanted to start off just by looking at page 2 in that S&P 500 chart because what all of us have been seeing when just looking at the surface is a market that's been relatively flat. The S&P 500 more or less has been trading at the same price level for, for the better part of 2, 3 weeks. And really, it looks and just feels like the market is pausing. But there's something really big happening under the surface of the market. And I really wanted to use this chartbook to kind of explore how there's this rotation happening and what conditions would change in order to make this into a bigger market correction.
And so on page 3, what I have here is the, the just a chart of the NASDAQ with that 50-day moving average on there. Really, I wanted to just use the 50-day to kind of highlight where the average price is and just to show the magnitude of the pullback on a relative basis. And what we can see is that while the S&P has been flat, the NASDAQ has been correcting over the last week, and we've more or less, uh, approached approached, uh, even close to a 50% retracement of that April, March-April rally.
And we have the NASDAQ selling, and it's happening actually in a number of the subsectors within there. And particularly on page 4, when we look at the— this is the FAANG futures, which is, uh, all of the big behemoth tech companies like the Apples of the world in this ETF. And what's particularly interesting about the FAANG stocks that in spite of strength in Google and Facebook, we have not seen the FAANGs in April manage to make it back to their previous highs the way the NASDAQ and the S&P has been able to. And more importantly, these FAANG stocks have now fully rolled over and are trading well below their moving averages. And so we're continuing to see weakness in this tech space and distribution really coming in there. And, and that story continues when we go to page 5. We can see, uh, the SPAC ETF, and the SPACs have been one of the hottest bubble sectors in, in the market in the, uh, late last year going into the first few months of this year.
And really since the February high, most SPACs have, uh, had a substantial and deep mean reversion, and they certainly have stopped really driving any of the momentum behind in this market, and we continue to see rotation out of there.
And so this theme continues. For instance, on page 6, when we talk about those stocks that did incredibly well when COVID came around and we had the big lockdowns, and so the Pelotons and the Zooms and all of these other stocks associated with everyone staying home and locking down, oh, it had extraordinary runs in in the summer of 2020. But I'm just using Zoom's chart here, uh, but whether you're talking Peloton or any of these other ones, they have just been outright selling, and there's been full-on distribution in this entire space. And even, uh, another sector that's been aggressively, um, distributed has been the social media space. I'm using here the social ETF SOCL And this social media ETF has really failed to be making higher highs and just been rolling over. And so you— we have this, and while it looks like this S&P is holding up, what is really interesting is that this entire kind of tech space and NASDAQ space has really just stopped getting any money flow, any rotation.
Even like ETFs like Cathie Wood's ARK Investment has just been incredibly weak. Tesla has been incredibly weak. All of these stocks just have run out of all momentum.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, something's holding this market up. So if those stocks are running out of momentum, let's take a look at the various different sector ETFs and figure out what's actually holding the market up. Let's start on page 8 with the value ETF.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so one of those things, I mean, we talked about it last week when we were talking about momentum versus value and Charlie was on. But really, I wanted to just highlight the actual value factor ETF, the VLUE. And what we continue to see is, is that the value stock basket continues to make 52-week highs and continues to get momentum to the upside as well. Uh, and, and the space that has truly been, uh, some of the leadership is on page 9 when we're looking at the metals and mining ETF, the XME, which has broken decisively to a fresh high. And whether you focus directly into spaces like uranium, or whether you go into those copper stocks, or you go zinc, or any of these other basic material metals, they've all just been doing incredibly well and continue to get substantial amounts of rotation as commodities such as iron ore commodity, or steel, or copper, all are making fresh highs in this cycle.
Now let's move on to page 10, where there's another sector that has been doing incredibly well and taking quite a bit of rotation of the money, and that's the the SPDR Financial ETF, the XLF. Even when you're looking even at the KRE, which is the regional banks ETF, the financials also continue to get substantial rotation, and they continue to plug 52-week highs. And so while the S&P 500 is holding up here along these highs, under the hood, there's a very big rotation underway and it doesn't seem to be slowing. And so really it's about what is the right sectors to be in in order to be making any performance in this market environment.
Another place that's been incredibly hot on page 11 is looking at the home construction ETF, the ITB. Obviously lumber prices have just gone absolutely parabolic to the upside, but that doesn't seem to have slowed down these home construction companies, which continue to just plug along doing very, very well. And including the energy space, which on page 12 we have that SPDR Energy ETF, which is the XLE, and it's almost right back to those 52-week highs, ready to break out.
Patrick Ceresna: And so The theme really continues to be that value and cyclical and financials are all getting all of this money flow, and anything associated with tech and FAANG and SPACs and any of those things that were incredibly hot late last year into the start of the year continue to be actively distributed.
Back to the very question that we were asking at the very first slide, is this a sector rotation? Rotation or the start of something bigger, I actually think we have to not take our eyes off of these value and cyclicals because they're very mature and they have— this move is already quite overbought. And I'm not trying to predict that they're imminently going to stop going up, but in order for this market to turn into like one of these bigger market corrections where the S&P 500 starts to really sell and mean revert, this big correction, we would need to start seeing highs coming in in some of those cyclical spaces. And there, there's no sign of that yet. And so that's certainly something that I think we have to watch in the next week or two as to whether that space starts running out of momentum on the upside or whether this rotation just continues.
Erik Townsend: Well, that's what we need to watch. And for any listeners who want to watch it closely, you can get Patrick's service every single day, not just once a week, by signing up for a free trial of Big Picture Trading at bigpicturetrading.com. The information is on page 13. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by masterworks.io, bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Patrick, what can they expect to find in this week's Research Roundup?
Patrick Ceresna: You're going to find a transcript for today's interview with Dylan, as well as a link to the chart book that we just discussed here in the postgame. You're also going to find a link to an Oil Price article on copper prices could double from here, as well as a link to a Bill Blain article on failing global politics and inflation will be a nasty shock. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account, @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in Each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit Big Picture Trading dot com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices dot com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly. Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register. Your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.