Mike Green — Logica Funds co-founder and Chief Strategist (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 255 was recorded on January 21st, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by SS&C Eze, delivering cutting-edge cloud, mobile, and on-premise solutions to optimize operational and investment alpha across the entire investment process.
After more than doubling in price in recent weeks, Bitcoin is pulling back a bit this week, trading just over $31,000 on Thursday afternoon as we record this episode. So we're finally going to cave to the many listeners who have been pleading with us to do an episode on Bitcoin and where it's headed. Logica Funds co-founder and Chief Strategist Mike Green returns to discuss the digital currency revolution generally and Bitcoin specifically in this week's feature interview. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment where we'll weigh in with an update on my own reactions to Mike Green and my own views on Bitcoin and the digital currency revolution. And then we'll take on another of Patrick's famous postgame chart picks, this week titled Exuberant Markets.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into this S&P 500 because we started this week just with a big blastoff to the upside. We are trading at 3,800. 3,850 at the time of recording. And it really looks like the bulls want to really just find one more level higher, particularly breakouts in a number of these FAANG stocks. What's your take here? Is there more upside on this S&P 500?
Erik Townsend: I think there is, and I don't think it's just one more level higher that the bulls are after. I don't think it's based on healthy economic fundamentals. I think it's a crack-up boom. And on one hand, there has been a very, very persuasive case made by Jeremy Grantham and others saying, hey, we're just way overdue What do you need to do for an overvalued market to reverse?
The thing is, we've got completely unprecedented new uncharted territory of fiscal stimulus. Janet Yellen in her confirmation hearings this week saying, hey baby, bigger is better. Let's really figure out how to pump this thing up. You know, they print enough money, they print enough bonds and print the money to buy them with. They can hold interest rates low, they can make money cheap, and they can drive that money into asset markets.
As much as I think it's a dangerous game because of the longer-term inflation risks that are involved, for the moment, I think things are just pushing higher.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to that US dollar because it really has been quiet. I mean, we're right now pretty much trading right at the 90 handle. And really, it's the same price level where we were back in late November, early December. I mean, what's the next move for the dollar in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, the chart looks to me as though maybe this bounce off of key support is ending. It's too early to tell, though. I think the key is to watch whether or not we break to fresh lows on the dollar index. And if so, maybe it's the beginning of a move much lower. But frankly, in order to really confirm a reversal of trend to the upside, we'd need to see a series of higher highs and higher lows. And we don't have that yet. So I think it's early to tell. My leaning is towards maybe the bounce is ending.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's get to crude oil. We're trading at $53. The trend has been pretty distinctly higher, and we had a little bit of a pullback, but the bulls seem to be dragging it right back to the top end of that range where it was trading late last week. Is there more upside on oil in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, the key resistance here is the 200-week moving average at $53.68 on the March contract for WTI crude futures. And that's been tested 3 times now on January 12th, January 14th, and then yesterday, January 20th. We need a decisive break above that layer to really greenlight the next significant move higher. And I do think that we're headed by summertime back up to, you know, probably $60 plus, maybe $65 even by midsummer.
The thing is that, boy, the market has come up so far so quickly. There's a lot of reasons to make an argument for a technical correction, or at least a pause here. And, you know, it seems like for now, 3, 3 pretty good attempts so far have been rejected at the 200-week moving average. Let's see if we get a close over that. But frankly, in order for there to be a new downtrend, we'd need to get at least past the 21-day moving average at $50.49, and we're quite a ways above that now. I'm leaning toward thinking that maybe an upside breakout is in the cards, and if so, I think we could move up pretty quickly from there to those previous highs around $56 or so. But the $53.68 is gonna be the key resistance. There is no inventory data to report this week. Crude oil inventories from EIA were delayed until Friday because of the combination of Monday's holiday and Wednesday's inauguration.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's touch on gold here. I mean, we had some pretty heavy selling for 2 weeks straight, and it seems like we found a little bit of support near that 200-day moving average, a little bit of reversal. We're back to about $1,868 on the gold futures contract. Do you think that's it for the selling for gold, Do you think there could be a little bit more downside?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think that it's very possible that we could see a new uptrend just starting now that could have some legs to it. And that would be if Bitcoin is going to correct further lower. Where we are right now on Thursday afternoon, Bitcoin has pulled back considerably from where it peaked at, what was it, $42,000 or just below $42,000. We were fully $10,000 per coin lower than that at below $30,000. We were down to $32,000 earlier today, I think, and now we're back up as we're speaking to what, $32,500, $32,600, in there somewhere. A lot of volatility. We haven't quite broken down below that key level at $32,000. We did on an intraday basis, but we haven't actually closed below that level. It's gonna be interesting to see whether or not we do. Let's wait till the postgame segment when we can get back to a chart on Bitcoin. But there's a few things going on there that suggest to me maybe the, the at least short-term top is in.
We'll see what happens. In any event, if there is a short-term topping event going on in Bitcoin, well, it's time to test my hypothesis that I've been talking about for weeks, which is I've been thinking that what's holding gold back is Bitcoin taking the market share, so to speak. If Bitcoin is going to have a pause here and is not going to resume its exuberant rally fairly immediately, that could be exactly what's needed in order to ignite the next significant rally in gold. That seesaw that I talked about. about in previous weeks' episodes. Let's see if that happens. But of course, the jury's still out on what Bitcoin is going to do next. So I think we need to see confirmation that Bitcoin really is entering a correction phase. And if it does, we'll find out whether or not that's the catalyst to take gold higher.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's finally touch on the 10-year Treasury yield because, I mean, we had the big breakout and we saw the yields pressing toward 1.20% last week. And really, we've been consolidating since. Is this just like a little consolidation before Are yields headed higher? What's your take on the continuation of this trend?
Erik Townsend: I doubt it. I mean, from a technical standpoint, you could look at the chart and conclude that it's temporary, you know, catching a breath before moving higher in a continuation pattern. I doubt that's gonna be the case because I think what pushed yields higher was the, oh my gosh, look at all this deficit spending that's planned. That means they're going to have to just flood the Treasury market with all kinds of new issuance of Treasury bonds. That's gonna crash the market. And of course, The next part that they didn't really consider is, yeah, but what is the Fed going to do in terms of stepping in to buy a lot of that new issuance? If you listen to Janet Yellen in her confirmation hearings, and of course now she's Treasury instead of the Fed, but it just seems like they're all on their game. They're talking about stimulus, Fed balance sheet expansion, buying more Treasuries.
I think that what we're likely to see is actually a return back toward sub-1% yields.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: That's my leaning, but frankly, I don't have really strong conviction on that. Certainly, there is reason to think that the deficit spending is going to dump a whole lot of Treasuries in the market. I just don't think the market has to absorb them. I think the Fed is going to absorb most of them. We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Logica Funds Chief Strategist, Mike Green. Erik, why did we invite Mike back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Mike has wanted to talk about Bitcoin on MacroVoices. When I had him recently on Smarter Markets, he said, when can I do a Bitcoin conversation? And it was just as we had several listeners hitting us up for a Bitcoin conversation. So it was just a confluence of Mike wanting to talk Bitcoin and a lot of listeners asking us to do a Bitcoin show, and we decided to give it a shot.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Mike Green is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how the markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. My interview with NEO Stock Exchange founder Jos Schmitt is available now at smartermarketspod.com. My guest on Smarter Markets this coming Saturday morning will be commodity legend Mark Fisher, who's literally been trading commodity futures markets for decades. We'll be discussing everything from how Mark uses the Hudson River as a risk management tool to the future of commodity trading exchanges, what needs to change, what could be improved, and what unfair advantages exist for some traders versus others. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to receive this free new podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Logica Funds partner and Chief Strategist Mike Green. Mike, it's great to have you back on the program. I want to talk about the digital currency revolution that I predicted in my book 2 years ago. And actually, I'd like to expand that because I don't think it's just a digital currency revolution.
I think we eventually get to where currencies are digital and also where we have a fully tokenized financial system, meaning that stock markets, commodity markets, real estate markets, registries of deeds, everything eventually, I think, is tokenized. And that's not next week or next month. That's over the next 25 years. I predict that's what happens. Do you agree with that general view? And with respect to digital currencies, Is it just one great big global digital currency, or is it lots of different digital currencies that make up the future economy?
Mike Green: So I share your view that we are unquestionably heading towards some type of a digital series of currencies and that almost all securities are heading in the same direction. We already have elements of that, as you know. And for those who think about the difference between a gold coin and a dollar bill, right, that serial number on a dollar bill is kind of the first attempt at digitizing It's the first attempt at trying to create an audit trail.
We have very few features that track that unless it makes its way through the banking system. And so, we can see that. But I don't think there's any question that we will embed greater power and flexibility into the currencies going forward. And the easiest way to do that is to move to the digital realm.
If I think about the importance of that, or what that could mean, for example, There's a wide variety of ways it can be used. It can be used in a manner that creates greater restrictions, effectively creates the Chinese social credit type dynamic where every piece of currency can be tracked.
But we could also choose not to do that. And that's actually part of the reason why I wanted to come on and speak about this, because I do think that we are broadly missing an opportunity to have an informed discussion around what are the choices that we make as we go through this process.
Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more with that. But before we even get there, I want to start with digital currency itself, because you'll hear a lot of people who don't understand this will say, look, what's all this talk about digital currency? The financial system's been digital for 30 years. And I think that those people are mistaking digital or computerized accounting systems, which keep track of conventional currency, which is anything but digital.
With this new innovation, and we have to credit the inventors of Bitcoin for this breakthrough in both computer science and in finance of inventing secure digital bearer assets that allow the actual title and ownership of an asset to be conveyed electronically through a computer network. We didn't have that 15 years ago. It didn't exist. Now it does, and we're just starting to get our heads around what that means. I think where you're headed is, boy, we really ought to be having some public discussion about how to embrace this technology for the benefit of society. Before we even get to that, let's just talk about what the benefit is of having secure digital bearer asset-based currency, as opposed to just using digital accounting systems to keep track of fiat currency that we've been doing for the last 30 years. What's the significance of that difference? Why is it important?
Mike Green: Well, among other things, it allows you to break from just the traditional financial system itself. Right. So the way that we have tried to digitize or create these accounting systems are inherently built around the limitations of a non-digital currency. If I deposit a dollar into my local bank, the only way I can have access to that via an ATM is through the accounting systems and records associated with that banking system. So if my bank systems are down and the ATM cannot verify There are systems that might allow me to tap into credit, right? But ultimately, that system is broken unless my bank is able to respond with its accounting systems and say, yes, this is here.
Right? When you talk about the innovation of Bitcoin, for example, what I would argue is that its primary innovation was in decentralizing that database so that everybody has a record of what I have, whether I can spend that digital dollar or digital Bitcoin. So that's, I would argue, is the single biggest criteria difference is it takes away some of the scale advantages, for example, that exist in the traditional banking system where JP Morgan is able to more efficiently offer those accounting systems and those credit approval systems simply by virtue of scale than my local bank. It changes that calculus quite dramatically.
Erik Townsend: Mike, I would just add my own perspective to that, which is there's a huge difference in terms of disintermediation and elimination of counterparty risk. If you wire A million dollars into my bank account with XYZ Bank in New York City. What I've got is I, as an unsecured creditor of that bank, now have an additional million dollars in my account balance, which I can get out of that bank if they don't default, as long as everything goes my way and the bank doesn't fail in a colossal way where my, you know, at a million dollars, it's well over the government insurance limit. So I would be potentially losing some money. Whereas if you send me electronically a transfer of digital currency for $1 million, I've got the cash. It's exactly as if you handed me $1 million in, you know, freshly printed $100 bills. I've got it. Once I'm in possession of it, I don't have to worry about any counterparty.
So it's almost like holding physical gold, because when you hold physical fiat currency, you still have a counterparty, which is the government.
Mike Green: Right.
Erik Townsend: When you hold gold, you don't have a counterparty. And I would argue that when you hold a digital currency, which everyone universally agrees has value, and we're not at that point yet, because there's a lot of people that think that Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies have value. A lot of people think that they'll eventually go to zero or be outlawed or what have you. When we eventually get to the point where there is widespread and uniform agreement and acceptance that a One or more digital currencies have purchasing power and value and store of value capability, then we can eliminate all kinds of counterparty risks, disintermediate, eliminate the middlemen, and the financial system just gets much better. Now, here's the crazy thing about how this is going down, as I think a bizarre manifestation of the fact that it was the inventors of Bitcoin who deserve credit for inventing the technology needed to make possible digital bearer instruments.
What we have is there is no conversation going on about how to adopt that technology and how it should be best adopted to benefit society and improve the financial system. Instead, you've got what curiously seems to be almost a generational divide based on age. Older investors just tend to have this attitude of, I don't believe in all this crypto, whatever it is stuff. I'm gonna ignore it. It's not real money. And then you've got very, very, I would call them zealots almost in the Bitcoin community, the so-called Bitcoin maximalists, who are absolutely convinced that if there is going to be a future where digital currency systems are the center of the financial system, well then surely since Bitcoin is where it all got invented, then it just has to be Bitcoin that becomes that currency. Let's start with whether or not that is a smart assumption.
The people who assume it has to be Bitcoin, but then move on to, okay, if you don't have that assumption, how come we're not having the public discussion or discourse about how we should adopt this technology?
Mike Green: Well, I, I, there's a lot to unpack there. First, your addition to my point in terms of the elimination of the credit risk, right? The way that we have chosen to do that to this point, as, as I'd highlighted, is through economies of scale, right? So if I'm going to send $1 million or I'm going to send $1 billion, I want to deal with a large counterparty to whom that is a small risk. I wouldn't use the local bank, right? So, so it's driven consolidation of the banking system in the same way I was referring to before.
Your point about the dynamic of older versus younger investors, and I would remove the word investors, right? Because I don't think that there's an awful lot of investment that's happening in this space yet outside of the venture capital investments that are occurring around the components of decentralized finance.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: And some of the innovative processes that are— that people are attempting to recreate the traditional financial system that again is predicated on this economy of scale and addressing things like counterparty risk and the cost through economies of scale.
Many could argue that those have created diseconomies of scale on a social basis now, which is part of the reason I think this is an important discussion. When you talk about investment as distinct from speculation, That's where I think we actually have to kind of draw the line. I think there's an awful lot of people in Bitcoin who are speculating that, like other Silicon Valley type inventions— and we have no idea whether Bitcoin came out of Silicon Valley or whether it came out of, you know, a Chinese viral lab— the reality is, is that that is speculation.
We don't know if Bitcoin is going to be the solution. We don't know if Ethereum is going to be the solution, or any of the other tokens that are out there. People are speculating as to their value. And I think that's a really important distinction to make, right?
When we look at something like Bitcoin, there's a very excited group who adopts the kind of Bitcoin maximalist approach that says, if we make it large enough, then they have to accept It can't be shut down. And they have some evidence for that. The models that have functionally broken the laws and grown to a certain size have been allowed to flourish. And so, you know, we can point to Netflix and Twitter and Facebook becoming communications companies, YouTube becoming a communications company without seeking communications licenses, growing to a scale that it would be unthinkable for the most part to shut them down.
Same thing happening with Uber and Lyft in transportation, where they have grown to a size that it became, quote unquote, unthinkable to shut them down, even though they were very clearly in violation of the regulations that were required to obtain taxi medallions or various other components.
Airbnb in the lodging industry is unlicensed lodging and has grown large enough that it is, quote unquote, unthinkable to shut it down. That fundamentally is the Bitcoin maximalist argument, that if it becomes large enough, that the authorities will be unwilling to shut it down because of the public outcry.
I think, as I said, there's evidence to support that, but I do think that money is actually a very different construct. Because while a local government can benefit from the dynamics associated with the sale of taxi medallions and can benefit from the revenues associated with It's really only when you get to the state level that you start to deal with the consequences of attempting to disintermediate the state from money.
I don't think it's the same calculus.
Erik Townsend: Mike, as you say, the Bitcoin movement has gained a huge amount of momentum. And one of the things I said in my book is, although I predict that Bitcoin will be outlawed, because frankly, it does pose a very serious threat to government's monopoly on the issuance of money, and therefore it is very much in the interest of government to outlaw When it gets to a certain point, when it gets to the point where there's significant institutional adoption, it becomes politically inexpedient to outlaw it. I think 2021 is going to be the year that this comes to a head. I think by the end of 2021, either there are major, major concerted efforts by governments all around the world to dramatically regulate and potentially completely outlaw Bitcoin and other privately minted cryptocurrencies, Or we get to a point where it really has become impossible to outlaw them.
And if that happens, then I would predict that the distinction they put on it is they say, okay, look, these crypto assets are not money. Only the government can issue money. If you want to have your crypto assets, you can have them. But as soon as they start to behave like money or are used like money, that's the part that we're not going to allow.
Because I just don't see how governments are going to stand by and say, oh, some really smart guys invented this cool thing that really is very innovative and really smart. And so therefore, we're just going to give up our monopoly over the issuance of money and let these guys that invented Bitcoin be in charge of issuing money for the entire planet and its financial system. That's just crazy to me.
So how do you see this playing out? I just described what I see as kind of a conundrum that I think has to resolve in some way. ways by the end of the year, but I don't ever see it going to the point where governments just say, okay, well, we missed our chance to be in charge of money. Now Bitcoin's in charge of money. We're gonna stand down and just adopt Bitcoin to run our economies on.
I don't think that ever happens. How do you see this playing out?
Mike Green: As you know, I actually am incredibly skeptical on Bitcoin. I think that one of the wonderful things about it is that it is the proverbial all things to all people. It is a mirror that reflects what you want to see in it, right? So some descriptions are it is a commodity that has extraordinarily low storage and transportation costs. Some descriptions are that it is money. Some is that it's a store of wealth that magically makes you money.
So to me, I think one of the underlying features of Bitcoin is this idea that it has survived. I don't think that's true. And I actually think that 2021 is going to be a year in which we discover that what we think is today Bitcoin is actually not Bitcoin, and I know that sounds cryptic, and I'm not prepared to reveal a lot of the work that I've done in this area.
But I do think that the general theory that Bitcoin is going to evade the response from the U.S. government for long enough for it to become fully established is misplaced. And I would suggest that in the process of the enthusiasm for Bitcoin. As a mechanism for protecting your quote-unquote wealth from the US government or other major sovereigns, that one, you're opening— there's a very clear avenue open to attack, which is simply to declare that fine, you want it to be a currency, Bitcoin's a currency, therefore taxes are no longer against a realized gain as you would have in a security. Your taxes have to be marked to market on an annual basis. And so if Bitcoin goes from $20,000 to $40,000, even if you didn't sell, you owe taxes on that difference.
That at minimum, I think is coming. And ironically, it's the worst nightmare for Bitcoin because it would create a tremendous supply of Bitcoin, particularly in the United States, that I would suggest the Bitcoin maximalists have underappreciated.
I think the second thing is, is that this focus on Bitcoin and the idea of the separation of money from the state which does not work in the simplest form. It's predicated on a failed Austrian view that there is some inherent intrinsic value to money, that money is the most marketable commodity.
That dynamic, I think, is actually distracting us from the ability to have that deeper conversation about what features do we want in money. What is it important to us to have anonymity? Is it important to us to not have tracked what we purchase with that money? It's important to establish the ownership of that money, but what I do with it may not be the government's business, and there may be very valid reasons for that. But we're not having that discussion because we're so enthusiastically embracing the get-rich-quick dynamics of this store of value and taunting the no-coiners with the have fun staying poor. that we're doing what we're doing in many other aspects of our society. We're shutting down the communication that allows us to engage in a discussion about what are our shared objectives and aspirations.
Erik Townsend: I think that right there is the most important point in this whole digital currency situation, Mike, and it's one that nobody's talking about, which is you've got people who are assuming that Bitcoin or Ethereum or whatever, some cryptocurrency invented by people who have no governmental license or Or endorsement or approval to be coining money. They think their invention is going to become the new money that runs the whole global economy. And then you got people who are ignoring this, this worthy revolution. And I think you and I agree, there is a breakthrough here that warrants a revolution in a redesign of the way that money itself works.
I think this is bigger than the internet. I think it's bigger than the personal computer. I think it is a Massive change. But what's going on right now is we've got the technology and the people who understand it are not engaging in a public debate about how society broadly should adopt this. They're assuming that it's their place to go and try to invent their own currency system, which they'll push as becoming the new global currency or the center of the financial system to replace the US dollar. because it sounds good to them to, to have that outcome. That's kind of crazy. So how do we get to an actual public discussion about how this technology should be adopted in order to advance the economy and the global financial system?
Mike Green: Well, I think part of the challenge is that we have ceded so much control to the technologists at this point, whether that's in the form of wealth, or whether that is in the form of control of public discourse. I would simply highlight the deplatforming of Donald Trump as an example of that type of ceding of control.
When we do that, we're engaged in a decision to suggest that some people have more merit in that discussion than others simply by virtue of the power and affluence that they have collected under the current regime. And, you know, if you, if you glance back to Socrates, for example, and, or dig yourself deep into philosophy, you know, the, the theory under Socrates and, and Plato's Republic was the idea that the philosophers should actually be the governors, right?
Well, you know, @Jack is not a philosopher. Certainly may fancy himself one, right? And we've got lots of pseudo-philosophers that operate throughout our society at this point, that drop down from the mountain and bestow us with their wisdom.
But the reality is that we are not having a conversation about what we want as a society. We've effectively ceded that discussion to a subsegment of our population. And that focus on the technology, I think, exposes us to extraordinary risks in terms of how it moves forward. It directs our society towards one that is functionally corporatist, directs us to a society that is inherently lacking in empathy and understanding of the needs of the average citizen.
We need to involve the lawyers. We need to involve the philosophers.
We need to actually have this discussion in the same form of framework that we would've had it in the negotiations around the US Constitution. What do we actually want? That was what was unique about the United States was that it was founded during a period of the Enlightenment in which those discussions were hammered out.
Out. You know, you and I had the discussion. What is really needed is a series of Federalist Papers, right? The idea that we're going to have a brilliant exposition of how things can be, and that that can be brought into the public debate as we discuss things like digital currency.
And it's not easy because there, there are features of digital currency that seem at their core inherently good, right? Should we be able to track all purchases Because we want to make sure that we can capture the criminals in our society. Absolutely, right? That sounds like a great idea until you realize that that feature also may prevent American citizens from making purchases that might be frowned upon, right? So, and cause them to make purchases that display virtue.
So do suddenly we see an increase in tithing and giving to churches because we are concerned that the government is watching what we're doing? That sends a false signal to the markets, right? The price of church goes up, price of alcohol or drugs go down, right? Now, those could be viewed as good, but as a society, we should have that conversation.
Erik Townsend: Mike, what we are seeing very clearly is governments are responding, sort of, kind of responding. They're definitely engaging in the design and in some cases the deployment and rollout of CBDCs, central bank digital currencies. And it seems like, to my own dismay, they're focused on the need that I think they correctly identified to figure out how they're going to participate as central banks to issue digital currency. They got that part right, but they're not engaging with the crypto community to learn anything from what the crypto guys have figured out, or at least not very much. And they're certainly not staging a public discussion to invite a public discourse about how this should work and what degree of privacy we should trade off for security?
You know, this— the way Bitcoin was designed was to eliminate most government controls and prevent governments from being able to monitor and oversee private financial transactions. As you've said, there's an argument that goes the other way. When do we get to the point where the public has a say in this and we the people get to decide what we want our new digital money system to look like.
I don't hear the Bitcoin crowd being the slightest bit open to considering the needs of what it would take to have governments actually endorse what they see in Bitcoin as the future of money. And I don't see central banks really extending any kind of interest in what the public wants in terms of how these trade-offs between privacy and security are made.
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: When do we get our say?
Mike Green: Well, I, I think that's ultimately a, a big part of the challenge, and it's one of the reasons why you're hearing me raise my voice with increasing stridency around this, right? This is similar to the dynamics for those who have heard me talk about the active manager versus passive manager dynamic.
Vanguard and BlackRock now spend more lobbying the US government individually than the rest of the industry does in total. And as a result, you know, similar to a Cantillon-type effect, they have access to the government first. They control the dialogue. I would suggest the same things happen happening with the Facebooks, Googles, et cetera, of the world. It is presumed that because they have the most engineers and because they have exhibited success, that they have the best vision and the best capability to deliver on this.
I've even heard people suggest that, oh, Google should build a cryptographic currency that can then be licensed to governments around the world. These are patently absurd ideas. What we need to actually do is start to raise our voices into a dialogue that allow us to do that.
And as I said, the Federalist Papers allowed us to do that by publishing into the common domain insights and thoughts on the structure of the Constitution and the government that allowed the population and the public to think about how to elect their representatives to the Constitutional Convention. It turns it into a negotiation and a discussion.
As we exist in America today, and America is ultimately going to set these standards, it's unrealistic to think that it's going to happen elsewhere. As it exists in the United States today, I would suggest that those conversations are largely captured by the technological elite, the academic institutions, and the focus is not on the features that would be valuable to the construction of growth and independence and price formation.
It's being focused on the idea of how do we take a banking system and convert that directly into a digital currency, embedding things like KYC into the currency itself. Right. Now, that creates a really interesting type of question.
So KYC stands for know your customer. It's the reason why we have this within the banking system is the banking system has a unique characteristic. It can multiply money. It can take the currency that is created by the state and under license, it can expand that. When we talk about trying to embed those characteristics into the currency itself, I think we're making a mistake.
Now, again, that's just my voice, but the banking institutions do play a role. The ability to make credit-based expansion— I'm going to, as a banking principal, extend risk of my institution by taking capital and lending it to another individual, creating deposits and expanding the money supply in that manner.
That is hugely valuable as long as it is done well and it is done with responsibility But when we try to take that away and we embed it in the currency, what we're effectively doing is taking all the knowledge of how the— effectively the use of proceeds and handing it back to the state.
And there's a reason why it should be separated. There's a reason why currencies, as I indicated, or spending— and you highlighted this idea of the digital bearer asset, right? The anonymity around that is hugely valuable. It helps in the formation and the efficient processing of capital.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Mike Green: That people don't necessarily need to know who is doing what. They just need to see the price signals and volume signals that allow the aggregation of that information.
The only way I think this happens is for individuals to begin to raise their voices, vote better, put in place elected representatives that actually are considerate of this and not purely subject to the corporate lobby.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about what's going on in the Bitcoin space, particularly with respect to institutional adoption, because I think you and I see this very similarly. We both agree that there needs to be a digital currency revolution. We need to move off of paper money to digital money in digital bearer asset tokenized, cleared on a distributed ledger kind of technology. The stuff that was invented by Bitcoin. You and I have both agreed that there's lots of reasons we think that Bitcoin as a private invention, which was designed with features that were intentionally conceived in order to offend governments, in order to make it much more difficult for governments to trace financial transactions and so forth. We thought that that would not be successful and that CBDCs, or what I call SVDCs, Silicon Valley companies designing digital currency systems, but not for the purpose of selling them or making them appeal to the same libertarian crowd that loves Bitcoin, Bitcoin, but rather designing them for the purpose of selling them to the central bankers, saying, look, we've designed the technology so that you can create your central bank digital currency using our Google Bucks or Apple Bucks or whatever the technology is.
It seemed to me like Facebook's Libra project was potentially the first Silicon Valley digital currency. It's kind of flopped, at least temporarily, but I think it will be resurrected, and I think other companies will do But you know what, in the meantime, Mike, we see big institutions buying into Bitcoin in size. It's not just, you know, guys that are speculating, retail guys buying a few Bitcoins to see what happens. We see major corporations putting tens or hundreds of millions of dollars into Bitcoin positions as a store of value. We see major financial institutions taking big positions in Bitcoin.
These are people that are smart enough to understand the hesitations that both you and I have expressed about why Bitcoin is not likely to ever become the, the center of the financial system. There are people who did hesitate to invest in it for years because they had that understanding, but just in the last year or so, they've started buying in size. What the heck is going on?
Mike Green: Well, I think in simple terms that the participation of large financial institutions or financial speculators, and we tend to presume that they have quote unquote done the work. My experience, I mean, as you know, the way that I approach things is a little bit different. I tend to look deeply into the market structure to understand why something is behaving. I think about a market as a series of transactions, which ultimately represents a series of constraints as compared to some form of information.
The institutional space is by and large doing an analysis of Bitcoin where they look at the price behavior that is exhibited historically, that it is largely an uncorrelated asset that has risen sharply, and they presume that the information contained in that history of prices suggests that Bitcoin has value within a portfolio construct.
They're doing nothing differently than they would if they were looking at any individual company or ETF and saying, okay, this seems to have value in terms of a diversifying component associated with our portfolio. In the case of a security like Coca-Cola, there may be some perfunctory analysis around, you know, what does their 10-K say? What does the management team say, et cetera? But they certainly aren't digging in and trying to understand the formula of Coca-Cola. They're not trying to understand, you know, doing their own independent research on the acceptability of sugared drinks or caffeinated drinks, So the level of research, I think people tend to underappreciate how little research is done in these decisions.
And I would just highlight people's excitement around things like Paul Tudor Jones putting a small amount of money into it or MFS putting $100 million into it. MFS is an institution with, I believe, somewhere in the neighborhood of $300 billion in assets. For them to put $100 million into something is really the equivalent of you and I buying a $2 lottery ticket. And that sounds insane, But that is pretty darn close to the level of scrutiny that I would suggest that it came through.
The flow of money into this space, I think increasingly is taking on the character of once you do your homework, then you'll understand. And your homework consists of talking to somebody else who you think did their homework and speaking to somebody else who you think did their homework.
And I realize how offensive that can sound to people in the industry who, who work very hard and think that they do a good job. But the simple reality is, is that very little due diligence is being done in this space. And unfortunately, the involvement of institutions creates a self-fulfilling component. It's very similar to something that we spoke about, or we wrote about in a paper from Logica called Policy in a Time of Pandemics, Social Media, and Passive Investing, where it's presumed that the price going up is evidence of the validation of something like Bitcoin.
And I would just suggest that right now we're caught in the speculative mania where people are moving assets into Bitcoin under the expectation that it has asymmetric payoff, similar to a St. Petersburg type paradox, where what price do you put on something that affect— that potentially has a small probability of an infinite valuation?
Right. So an infinite valuation of something, even if it's at a very small probability, implies an infinite valuation of the asset itself. That's not right, but it is a way of thinking about it. And I would argue that that's what people are doing.
Erik Townsend: That's actually very consistent with my view, Mike, because I think what you're saying is they're looking at this, institutions are saying, look, this whatever it is thing, Bitcoin, whatever you want to say about it, it's gaining lots and lots of of capital. Whatever it is, people are investing in it, and we don't wanna be left out. We wanna be part of it.
I don't think that analysis, I don't think that the purchase of Bitcoin that most of these institutions are engaging in is based on a contemplation of, number one, there needs to be a digital currency revolution where we replace paper fiat currency with digital currency. And number two, I think that Bitcoin is going to win the contest and it's not gonna be CBDCs, it's going to be Bitcoin. I don't think that analysis is occurring in the minds of institutions. It's occurring in the minds of Bitcoin maximalists who are investing, or speculating, I should say, with retail-sized capital flows. And that's driving, you know, what I think is a fantasy about Bitcoin is going to replace the US dollar at the center of the global financial system.
I don't think that ever comes true, but I also don't I don't think that the institutional investors who are buying Bitcoin believe that that's even a consideration.
Do you think that they're buying Bitcoin because they think it might be the replacement for the US dollar? Or is it just because it's something that for whatever reason seems to have a lot of capital flowing into it? Let's play this momentum trade and make a buck on it while it's working.
Mike Green: Oh, I think unquestionably it's the latter right now. There are any of those portfolio managers that are making that choice will have analysts that are effectively Bitcoin maximalists, right? Those Bitcoin maximalists that work for them will fervently believe that their boss's choice to allocate some capital to this idea that they have presented as having this infinite upside is evidence of their boss's belief.
But having done this for a very long time, I can assure you that their bosses will flip on a heartbeat if it moves in the opposite direction. And by the way, the analyst will likely lose their job.
Erik Townsend: What I think is missing from all this is when do those big boys, the portfolio managers, wake up and recognize, hey, wait a minute, there really does need to be a digital currency revolution where we literally replace the entire planet's money system with digital currency systems that are not likely to be Bitcoin. They're likely to be something else. And that's a much more important trend that we need to start to get our heads around. I don't think that's even begun to start yet. Do you? And if so, to what extent has it started?
Mike Green: I, I agree with you. I don't think it has started. I also think that you are focusing on the wrong group for those insights, right? Portfolio managers and macro investors are, for the most part, not currency theorists, right? They are not— even economics in and of itself, right, is largely an applied science as it's currently practiced, as compared to a deep theoretical science and a thoughtful about what do we want to accomplish as a society, right?
An economy, you've probably heard me say this before, is functionally just people doing favors for other people in exchange for tokens. What we incentivize and how we try to shape that economy, how we choose to allocate those resources is largely assigned in most free market economies or free type market economies. It's assigned to the market to send those signals. And economics is the study of that. It's not the design of that system.
And so, you know, and that's economics far before you get to finance, which is ultimately truly just applied economics, right? A combination of accounting and applied economics that is designed to profit from the system as it exists. None of these people are the people you should be turning to for the design of the system.
Erik Townsend: I'm not suggesting that we should be turning to them for the design of the system, but at some point the financial community needs to recognize that a redesign of money itself is coming. It's necessary. It could arguably be described as slightly overdue because it's been more than a decade that the underlying technology has been known, and it's being adopted by a bunch of people who are so excited about it that they just can't help themselves, and they think it's their place to coin their own money. And I just don't see that being the end solution. So how do we get to the point? And I think you're seeing it in decentralized finance, not in the currency space, but in other asset markets.
Abaxx Technologies, a company I'm involved with, is using tokenization to modernize commodity futures markets.
Other people are doing the same thing with stock markets. But in terms of the recognition that we need a tokenized currency system to replace paper fiat Money for the whole planet. And I don't think it's necessarily one great big global currency. I think it's several different central bank issued or central bank endorsed digital currencies where the technology probably comes from Silicon Valley, but the actual issuer of the currency is a central bank.
Nobody seems to really be thinking about that. And even the— I've talked to the IMF guys that were doing the study on central bank digital currency. And You know, they don't even see the picture. The opportunity to design digital currency systems with radically enhanced monetary policy tools that go way beyond anything that we do now with monetary policy is such obvious low-hanging fruit opportunity that not a one of these central bank guys that's looking at digital currency technology has even woken up to the possibility of yet.
How do we get to the point What's the point of getting the non-Bitcoin— you know, the Bitcoin guys, you got to give them credit. They've got the right vision. They just think that they can coin their own money, which I don't see happening. How do we get their passion somehow transfused into central bankers and people who are looking at these digital currency systems and get them to do something smart to design the right digital currency system of the future?
Mike Green: So, I think you and I disagree a little bit on this. First, I would suggest the idea that this needs to come out of the private sector is a uniquely— is a byproduct of you and I having grown to maturation in the aftermath of the Reagan Revolution.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: The idea that the government would license effectively a technology that is produced by Google or by Microsoft, in my view, is is very deeply flawed.
At the end of the day, what we're talking about is a system that needs to be built within this public sphere in an environment of public service, which is a longstanding principle of democratic governments. It's the idea behind serving in Congress. It's the idea behind being appointed to become an ambassador or being appointed to the National Security Advisory Committee.
You need to separate your responsibility to the corporation to produce something that can be made profitable with something that can be produced for the benefit of the public, for the benefit of your fellow citizens. And I don't think that's possible within a corporate environment. So I actually disagree with the very simple view that this is going to come out of Silicon Valley. I think that the people that do it could come out of Silicon Valley, but I think it's a very different statement than saying it's It's going to come out of the corporations in Silicon Valley.
The second thing that I would draw attention to in this framework is the idea that the central banks themselves have the capabilities and the skills. I would say that we're defaulting it to them. And again, by not putting it into the public sphere and not discussing what the features that we want, we naturally gravitate towards statist solutions that result in increased surveillance.
Effectively try to achieve the objectives of the state as stated in the simplest forms. I want to prevent crime. I want to use this to reduce the amount of nefarious influences that can be done. But there's often very little consideration.
I think we see this explicitly in the behaviors of central banks. There's very little consideration of the unintended consequences of that. Again, very simply, if you make a currency truly traceable and transparent in terms of its uses, You are going to see citizens move to accommodate that. They will reduce their consumption of things that are frowned upon by the state, sending false price signals to the state for the supply of things that are perceived as virtuous within the state. And different states can have different views of what's virtuous and what's frowned upon, right? Russia has a very different view than I would hope the United States has. China would be an example of a society that has a radically different view of what should be encouraged and what should be frowned upon.
And again, I think the design of the currency should reflect the objectives of the country. And that can only— in a democratic country, that can only be obtained by effectively putting it to the people and their elected representatives.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So far, we've been talking about what needs to happen, what should happen in order to get to the eventual digital currency revolution That replaces government-issued money with new money that's digital, and I think is probably government-issued. I think we agree on that point. Some people think it's, you know, Bitcoin takes over the world. Let's come back though to Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies like Ethereum, because I know a lot of our listeners are gonna be focused on, okay, so, you know, what are you actually saying about Bitcoin? Is it a good thing or is it a bad thing? Are you bullish or are you bearish? Whether we agree or not, there's a lot of people who think that Bitcoin is on its way to becoming the digital currency system of the future that's going to take over the whole planet. And they think that the growth in Bitcoin is being driven by a growing recognition or belief system that Bitcoin does have a realistic chance. of replacing government-issued currency as the center of the global financial system.
Do you think that there is any truth whatsoever to that? And if not, well, okay, what does that mean considering that right now the price trend is very strongly up in Bitcoin and also in Ethereum and other cryptocurrencies? What do you tell people who are trading this stuff?
Mike Green: So I'll be very clear that I don't know what is going to happen to the price of Bitcoin, whether it goes to zero or whether it goes to $100,000, $500,000, $100,000, $10 million. I have absolutely no idea. What I would suggest is that we tend to lump all of these things together without considering how they take their basic form. And I would describe Bitcoin as a speculative commodity that has a unique asset, a unique feature to it. It is the only commodity that can be produced from electricity alone.
Right. That is its defining feature, that it is exactly the same thing as making aluminum. You just skip the bauxite. You dump a ton of electricity in and you get Bitcoin out. That Bitcoin can be stored or it can be sold for fiat. Those are your 2 choices. In the framework of storing it, we refer to it as a store of wealth.
We call it digital gold. And that is a fundamental— it is predicated on a fundamental misunderstanding of the role of gold in financial systems, it is based on this Austrian framework that money has some inherent value associated with it. That's very far removed from the reality, right? Money, as we think about it in terms of coinage, is simply an accounting system. It goes back to the beginning part of the discussion we were having about what is the difference between having digital and non-digital currency.
Digital currency just makes that accounting system infinitely easier. And as a result, it loses many of the requirements of the features that we have. So serial numbers on dollar bills or coins that have ridged edges so that we can more accurately identify if people have shaved the edges of them, reducing the counterfeiting type dynamics.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: But at its core, when we think about Bitcoin, to me, it's just a terrible commodity in the simplest form. Ethereum is something different, and I think it speaks to the broader decentralized finance and tokenization type dynamic. Ethereum is a base layer on which effectively contract law can be written, and the tools for editing and efficiently writing those contracts, I think, are inherently valuable, right? Effectively, an Ethereum-based smart contract can replace an S-1 prospectus. It can replace a credit document. It can replace a mortgage application.
What should be happening in Ethereum is, I think, a very different conversation than should be happening in Bitcoin.
Bitcoin, it becomes a question of does the commodity have value and does the commodity— is the support for the commodity, does it in some way represent risk to the society and the state as it's currently constructed? And I think the answer to that is unequivocally it represents extraordinary risk. And not to tease people, but I do think that we will discover that the reason that Bitcoin is shut down is surprisingly not simply because of the threat that it represents to the state's ability to tax, but because of an actual national security threat associated with it. And I unfortunately have to leave it at that.
The dynamics around Ethereum, I think, speak to this broader issue of how should we be focusing our resources? And involving people in building the tools that provide the very effective evaluation and auditing of those smart contracts within the construct of a legal system that exists within states, right? How do we escalate and effectively move away from the extraordinarily firm arbitration of a smart contract that delineates this is exactly what will happen?
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: happen to a common law or a judicial-based system in which we can have a discussion around, was this the intent of the parties?
Did a hidden clause represent fraud? How do we identify those types of dynamics? And that, I think, is a very fruitful discussion to be having around the questions of decentralized finance, tokenization, smart contracts, et cetera. Bitcoin, I think, is— I mean, to me, it's certainly fascinating to watch the price adoption of it, but it's actually quite uninteresting.
Erik Townsend: Mike, as we close, our accredited investors know that you run a fund which is only available to accredited investors. They can contact you for information about investing. But I also know that you're working on a series of writings that are going to address not just digital currency, but everything from gold to digital currency to the role of the state and the issuance of money and so As you alluded earlier, some of those things you're not ready to publish yet, but it's all coming, I believe, on your website. So please tell our listeners, where can they subscribe or tune in to make sure they don't miss that when it comes out?
Mike Green: Sure. You can sign up on our website at www.logicafunds.com. We have a tab that would allow you to sign up for the release of our white papers. We try to regularly publish on interesting thought dynamics, whether that's the components that have led to the underperformance of the value factor to— I referred to the dynamics of policy setting in a world of information being obscured by passive investing and other stuff.
And this series has been one that is overdue for the very simple reason that as I began to think about the role of gold and began to focus on how to explain how I think about the role of gold in a financial system, it rapidly morphed into a much broader dynamic, trying to understand the Bitcoin And I'm excited to start getting this out there, but in the simplest form, like I want to always emphasize on this, that nothing that we put out is investment advice. It's the thinking of one of the principals who's involved at the firm and largely represents a thought experiment more than anything else.
Erik Townsend: And for the benefit of the accredited investors and qualified purchasers in the audience, you can also find information about the funds That Mike is involved in managing there at LogicaFunds.com.
Erik Townsend: We're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor.
Run your operations like a well-oiled machine with SS&C Eze. Automate daily tasks, eliminate manual processes, and minimize errors. Minimize risk. SS&C Eze has been providing award-winning solutions backed by unparalleled client service for over 25 years. Today, they're helping 1,900 hedge funds, family offices, and asset managers transform their investment process and grow their business. SS&C Eze delivers cutting-edge cloud, mobile, and on-premise solutions to maximize efficiencies across the entire investment process. Process for all asset classes. Their solutions are easy to use with friction-free integration into your downstream systems. Meet investor regulatory and due diligence requirements, all while lowering cost of ownership. Set your business up for rapid growth and download their free guide at ezesoft.com/macro. That's ezesoft.com/macro.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Mike Green back on the show, and particularly it was nice to focus just on the cryptocurrencies with him.
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it's interesting that you put it that way. I don't focus on that at all. What I focus is the coming digital currency revolution that is going to completely reshape the face of finance. I think the cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin are gonna play a fairly small role, although still an important role, in that overall story. And what I think this is really about is in the next 25 years, we're going to see a revolution where all fiat currencies, conventional currencies, are replaced Replaced by digital currencies. And I should draw a distinction, Patrick, because some people will say, well, isn't the financial system already digital? It's all been digital for 30 years. No, it really hasn't been. We've used digital accounting systems to keep track of conventional currency. There's a big difference between digital bearer instruments where you can actually transmit value over a computer network, as opposed to sending sending checks and ledgers and IOUs over the computer network, which is what we've been doing for 30 years.
And there's some very important distinctions in terms of disintermediation and counterparty risk inherent to that change. So it really is important.
And eventually we're going to see financial markets, whether it be stock markets, commodity futures markets, bond markets, all markets will eventually be tokenized and re-architected on this completely new technology platform, which is emerging of decentralized finance. So I think it's really, really incredibly important. So the thing that I really want people to take to heart is, look, there's going to be a digital currency revolution where we replace the existing currencies of the world with digital currencies. Now, the Bitcoin maximalists like to believe that that means it's a fait accompli, that for sure Bitcoin is going to become the currency that replaces everything. I think that's very foolish thinking. A much more rational statement would be, we're going to have a competition like no competition you've ever seen before. People are all going to figure out that there is a race for who controls the digital currency that's going to replace the conventional US dollar at the center of the global financial system.
And I think there's going to be a combination of central bank digital currencies vying for those roles, and there'll be a space race of different countries, each wanting their digital currency to become the predominant digital currency that replaces the US dollar as the world's global reserve currency. The cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum Ethereum will be trying to promote themselves as becoming real currencies in the global financial system. Some people are more optimistic that they'll succeed in that than I am. But the point is, understand we don't know the outcome yet.
There's going to be a race for who controls the currencies, and there's also going to be a race for the redesign of financial markets in this decentralized finance model. We know The big picture that we're going to digital currency and tokenized financial markets. We don't know who's going to be in charge. We can just try to identify who the apparent early movers are and who potentially is going to have a role. So I think the central bank issued digital currencies, just because governments have the ability to force their use, are likely to seriously challenge Bitcoin and Ethereum and the other cryptocurrencies. And I also anticipate that Silicon Valley digital currencies, along the lines of what Facebook began with Libra, will try to compete for that eventual role of who gets to replace the US dollar at the center of the global financial system. It's going to be a very interesting time. And contrary to what a lot of our listeners seem to think, I really don't have anything against Bitcoin.
Bitcoin will always have a role as an alternative.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: to government-issued currency. It's the people who think that it's a certainty that Bitcoin is going to become the center of the global financial system that everybody uses for everything that I think are frankly deluded in their thinking. It's much more likely that a government-sponsored digital currency system will replace the US dollar as the world's global reserve currency, and Bitcoin will continue to exist. as an alternative to government money for as long as it's allowed to exist and to whatever extent that it is not regulated out of having a useful purpose, which is still a very real possibility.
And for reasons I don't want to spend time going into, the business that you'll hear about how it can't be outlawed or it was designed to be impossible to outlaw is just plain nonsense. The people who think that really haven't done their homework.
In any event, Patrick, let's move on to this week's postgame chartbook, which is titled Exuberant Markets.
Erik Townsend: Talk about an understatement with this week's stock market action. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, then by all means, go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, sign up for it by clicking the red button that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, chart 2, Bitcoin versus US Dollar. Well, boy, that's a little bit of a scary looking, maybe the beginning of a blow-off top. What do you make of this chart?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I think back to when we were doing our episode of MacroVoices back in late 2017, early 2018, when we had the original top. And one of the things I shared with listeners at the time was that when things go into their parabolic phase where everything is so frothy and everything is just going up thousands of points every single day, the one thing that the market inevitably has a date with is some sort of mean-reverting correction. It's just gravity takes over something that's going up that quickly. And what we have is a scenario where we have the exact déjà vu of that. I mean, through late 2020 into this first few weeks of January, Bitcoin went full-on parabolic.
And this is— we don't even have to have an opinion as to whether the merits of Bitcoin itself, just purely the technicals and the behavior of price. And this applies to any and every every market that goes into the same type of a parabolic rise. And one thing we were just asking over the last 2 weeks was, when do we finally see the blow-off tops in both Bitcoin and in the case Tesla? And I think it's very important to identify because I think it will shift sentiment that could actually ripple into the broad markets. And I think that they're sort of like the generals of this bull market. And what's interesting is even though Tesla has stalled, and I don't have the chart of Tesla here, It hasn't really begun correcting, but Bitcoin, on the other hand, has.
And we've already seen a considerable correction. But what was the big warning sign to me was not that it had that 3-day market correction where we saw Bitcoin drop. There was that 20% down day that it had in just 1 day from top to bottom of the move. But I always say it's not about the sell-off, but whether or not the bulls are capable of breaking it to higher highs. And what we've had was a rally back towards $40,000, and they failed to break it to higher highs, and we're right back down to those lows that we saw several weeks ago.
And this is now showing the behavior of distribution. And what I circled there in red, if we go to page 3 and page 4 where I have the circles, you see a similar style pattern, which is once the parabolic rise finished, there's a second attempt to rally and break to a higher high. And when it fails, it turns and begins a distribution cycle. And you see it— we saw that back in 2019 in the summer, and we saw it again in 2000 and the original top, big top, which was the 2017-2018 peak. And each time Bitcoin began a considerable and quite deep mean-reverting correction of its excesses. And I just asked the question, have we just seen the short-term high in Bitcoin? And I mean, at this point, it's using the analog of those, it really does look like the same type of pattern. And it'll be really interesting for us to track in the next couple weeks whether that analog continues to develop that way.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, there's also some fundamental news that has affected this tape. So let's talk about this next, and I'll go back Page 2 in the slide deck where we're looking at the current move. As you say, there was just a parabolic rise that was due for a blow-off top anyway. So this could be just a technical move. But the thing that occurs to me is what might have brought about that sudden reversal where it was just straight up to straight down? Well, that happened about 4 or 5 days before Christine Lagarde made her comments. Right. Comments that she basically was calling on all central banks to aggressively regulate Bitcoin. It makes me wonder if somebody had early access, inside information that that was coming and started trading it. So that was something that was kind of a question in the back of my mind anyway.
And sure enough, right around the time that Christine Lagarde actually made that statement, it became a, you know, sell the rumor, buy the news Uh, kind of event where we started to rally again and it seemed like the market wanted to recover.
But then there was another very sudden reversal to the downside that just happened in the last week or so. Well, what might be driving that? The news that's come out, and frankly, I don't follow cryptocurrency stuff that closely, so I'm a little bit out of my lane here, Patrick, but I do want to provide our listeners with at least some background information as to what's going on. You can draw your own conclusions. The news that's come out has been an analysis. There was a couple of articles that have been published where people have said, look, what has been driving this huge rally in Bitcoin over the last several weeks as we've doubled in price? It's not Bitcoins being purchased in US dollars or being purchased in Korean won or being purchased in Japanese yen or euros. It's Bitcoins that have been purchased with Tether, with another cryptocurrency.
Okay, what is Tether? Tether is a stablecoin. The sales pitch for Tether says what that means is that it is backed. Every single Tether token is backed by a US dollar that is on deposit in a bank. Therefore, it is basically guaranteed that that stablecoin, hence the name stablecoin, will always be redeemable for $1 worth of value. It's supposed to track the value of the US dollar so that it doesn't go up and down in price, but it's a reliable store of value because it's backed 1-to-1 by good old-fashioned US dollars on deposit. That's the sales pitch.
The internet rumor mill— and of course the internet rumor mill is subject to its own forms of manipulation— but what people are starting to To allege, and I frankly have no way of verifying or proving or disproving this, is that Tether is a giant Ponzi scheme. They supposedly have backing dollar for dollar. Every token has a dollar behind it on deposit. Where is it on deposit? Is it Chase Manhattan? Is it Citibank? No, it's Deltec Bank in the Bahamas. And everybody knows that financial scams never happen in the Bahamas. So the backing of Tether is dubious, to be sure. And people are starting to allege that what's going on here is Tether has been printed somehow where there's not really a dollar behind it. There's a whole bunch of essentially phony baloney Monopoly money, Tether, that has been used to prop up the price of Bitcoin, and the scam has just been revealed. Now, I don't know whether any of that is true.
The The point is, that's the latest rumor that's circulating. There have been several articles written about this. Frankly, my position on cryptocurrency is I ignore all things crypto to the maximum extent possible. So I really have no idea whether Tether is a scam or Tether is completely legitimate and it's scammers that are saying it's a scam. I don't know. But I am convinced that what's going on is this fear, uncertainty, and doubt associated associated with Tether has resulted in this next knee-jerk down.
The market's going to decide either whether that's a real problem or just, you know, a fantasy problem. And I think the real question is either Bitcoin moves to yet another fresh high in the next few weeks, or it's probably done for quite a while. So I don't think that the final tell is in. I'm leaning towards it's done for a while, but I think we need to wait out the next couple of weeks. As a technician, based on those fundamentals that I described, what would you say in terms of what are the signals that you watch for to get confirmation as to which way this thing is headed next?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, the pattern of distribution essentially is that all rallies now get sold. So there will be periods where we will see a $2,000, $4,000 rise, maybe even more, but the pattern that that really shows that this has turned the tide is that every rally starts being sold and distributed as smart money is realizing that the gig is up and it really starts to make sure that they try to unload as much as possible at the highest prices they can. And so that one thing I'm gonna just be watching is whether that pattern persists.
Like, there's still a chance that this is just a Fibonacci retrace and we find support above $30,000 and the bulls just find a new catalyst to lean on break this thing to all-time highs. It's possible. And that's sort of the art of reading the tape and seeing how it develops. I think that we shouldn't see prices above like $36,000 if in fact this is a topping formation. Maybe a quick little poke above there temporarily, but if we stay below there, it's going to increase my conviction that that top is in.
Erik Townsend: And again, I have no way of knowing whether this Tether story is real or not real, but boy, if it is real and what's really been propping Bitcoin Bitcoin up has been purchases of Bitcoin with monopoly money that everybody assumed was backed one for one by US dollars, but it really wasn't. There could be quite a bit of downside if that is actually proven true. I have no idea if it is or it isn't, but it'll be interesting to watch, to be sure.
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, so moving on to page 5, I just wanted to talk the S&P 500. We already in the last couple weeks talked about the progressive rally of the S&P 500, but really that, that isn't where the bubble in equities occurring, right? We were talking about those other sectors within the markets where all the parabolic rises are going.
Even the auto industry is going through this huge parabolic rise at this moment. So the S&P is doing its crawl. There are targets up to 3,900, even one target that measures out to 4,000 on the upside on the S&P. And so there's room for the S&P to crawl higher here in the coming days and weeks. But what is amazing is just some of the warning signs that we're seeing that typically are associated with the froth that comes along a short-term market top or even an intermediate market top.
And what is interesting is on page 6, I have a chart of option activity. This one is a chart that was provided by SpotGamma. Brent over there did a great job putting together this chart. And what this is showing Showing is looking at the amount of options that are bought to open minus the amount ones that are sold to open, and so it's looking at how retail and institutional investors are positioning themselves with options. And the blue line is showing equity call options, and this ratio is making a fresh new high, which is showing that there is a lot of froth about buying call options and buying gamma to the upside of the market. So in general. General, you have all of this energy that's coming where dealers are going to have to literally be buying equity and futures in order to keep themselves delta neutral while all the call buyers continue to press the upside.
But what is also interesting, which is circled in red, is the fact that for put options, we are now seeing that that ratio has turned negative, which means there is much more interest to sell options. For premium to open than there is to buy those puts as insurance or protection from a market drop. And we saw this conveniently also below zero back in January, just a month before the market turned for the coronavirus decline crash. And we saw the same circumstances back in August before the last short-term market top. Now, that's no guarantee that this is going to lead to a market crash or some big liquidity event. But a lot of those characteristics that showed this kind of option activity along the last 2 highs is all here right now.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, you've got a couple more sentiment charts on page 7. What kind of sentiment are these things measuring?
Patrick Ceresna: The one on the left is the one we shared last week that Charlie McElligott had out there talking about just how the different readings at Nomura were at extreme sentiment. But there was an interesting chart that was put out that's put together together by Haver Analytics and Citi Research. And it's the Panic/Euphoria Model. And that shows just how much froth is in there in terms of the 12-month forward return on investment. And what you can observe here is that we have now hit such a euphoric overshoot that we have now exceeded, based upon this calculation, the euphoria at the 1999-2000 peak in the equity markets. I never thought we would see us reach these kind of euphoric But here we are having exceeded them. And again, that doesn't guarantee that a market decline has to start imminently any day, but it really does show how everyone has really gone all in on this and the belief that Yellen and the Fed will just continue to keep this party going with more and more liquidity to keep driving the trend.
Yeah, I asked the question, what could possibly go Well, it's—
Erik Townsend: I don't think there's any easy calls here, Patrick. You would think normally, you know, if you, if you showed either one of us these charts, you know, 5 years ago and said, what if you got to a point where sentiment reached these extremes, even greater than, than 2000? You know, you'd say in a heartbeat, obviously it's time to short the market. It's about to crash. It's way overdue. The thing is, we've never had a time in history where sentiment was so high. history when this kind of unprecedented central bank stimulus and monetary policy intervention was being contemplated. And if anything, if there's anything that the market's proven to me in the last 10 years, it's when they print enough money, it has to go someplace, and it usually goes into financial markets. So it seems totally crazy to think that the market still has a lot of upside left in it, but I don't dare short it. I'm not frankly all that excited about being long either.
I think it could go either way.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, one of the things where I'll push back a little bit on is if we move on to page 8 and it shows the margin debt and really how much the borrowing in the market has increased. And the reason looking at how much margin is being utilized in the markets, why it's so important, is that that's the part of a portfolio that is renting the upside. Because during a liquidity event or some pull pullback, often it's the margined parts of the portfolio that have to be liquidated, and it's forced selling that could draw and create that negative feedback loop that just feeds a market decline. And the fact that we are seeing, especially at these incredibly low interest rates, more and more investors continuously tapping margin to leverage up that upside, that is really, I would argue, the fuel that could create the volatility. Now again, we don't need to be calling a bear market, and we don't have to be calling some devastating crash like a repeat of March of 2020.
But whenever we have these types of excesses, if any trigger creates a sell cycle, the fact that we are so leveraged up on margin and things like this in the broader market, that adds fuel to creating that very volatile correction that could happen on the other side.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we're going to need to leave it there for this week's episode. Listeners, if you want to follow Patrick's play-by-play on this, sign up for a free trial of Big Picture Trading. You can find the information on slide 9 of the deck or at bigpicturetrading.com. And this episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by SS&C Eze, delivering cutting-edge cloud, mobile, and on-premise solutions to optimize operational and investment alpha across the entire investment processes.
Listeners, if you haven't yet taken advantage of a free subscription to our Research Roundup email newsletter, please do so. You can do that by clicking the red button that says Looking for the Downloads on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Patrick, tell them what they're missing in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Mike Green, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a recent Felder Report article on what the boom in fraud says about the current market environment, and a link to an article about the record Wall Street euphoria. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distribution.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That is Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free Account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Luke Gromen — Forest for the Trees founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices Episode 254 was recorded on January 14th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. The US Dollar Index is bouncing this week, but so far not by enough to negate the precipitous decline that we've seen since mid-October.
Is this the beginning of a trend reversal to the upside or just a dead cat bounce? Forest for the Trees founder Luke Gromen returns as this week's feature interview guest to answer that question and many more about where the dollar is headed and what that will mean for other markets. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment where we'll take a look under the hood and see what markets are doing with another of Patrick's signature chart decks.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, Treasury yields are usually the last item we cover in our weekly market wrap, but you wanted to start this week with Treasuries. So why the change?
Erik Townsend: Well, the reason for the change, Patrick, is I think Treasury yields are kind of driving everything else this week. And here's how I see it. You know, clearly Treasury yields have backed up considerably in the last couple of weeks. What's going on? Why is that? Well, I think it's all about the stimulus expectations, the spending expectations. President-elect Biden is expected to speak this evening, and different estimates suggest that he's going to announce anything between a $1 and $2 trillion with a T like tango, dollar stimulus bill. So markets are saying, okay, trillion dollars of spending. Janet Yellen's Fed is gonna have to issue a trillion dollars of new government bonds in order to finance all of that deficit spending. That's a heck of a lot of Treasuries that are gonna be flooding the market. That has to drive the price down and the yield up.
And certainly that is true, at least in the immediate sense. But I think that that by itself leaves out any consideration of, okay, but what is the Fed going to do in terms of stepping in to make up for all of those extra Treasuries by being the buyer of last resort in order to prevent yields from going too much further? Right now, what's going on is we are seeing the anticipation of that big Treasury issuance pushing yields up on Treasuries, particularly at the back end of the curve, and that's affecting All of the other markets. So that's the reason that I wanted to start there. And I think the big question is, okay, but what do you really expect is going to go on in the long term? And what I think is gonna go on long term is there is going to be a huge balance sheet expansion by the Fed. The Fed will be the buyer of many of those trillion dollars of Treasury bonds.
And I don't think that yields are headed markedly higher anytime soon. Now, of course, if President-elect Biden were to Also announce after the $2 trillion of stimulus or whatever the number's gonna be, that his next agenda item is to, you know, insist the Fed stop stepping in and we just have to be more accountable and pay for everything with taxes and revenue this time and throw out the MMTers. Well, then obviously Treasury yields are headed to the moon. Frankly, I think the sun rising in the west tomorrow is a more likely scenario than that happening. And the much more likely scenario is the sun rises in the east and President Biden supports the MMT crowd in printing lots of money to pick up this big Treasury issuance, and the central bank is the principal buyer, and yields don't really back up dramatically. Right now, what we're having is the shock effect where yields do back up, and that's affecting everything else.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that S&P 500 because at least the last few days have been a bit of a trade range right around this 3,800 level on the, on the S&P. What's your take on the markets here?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think part of the pause is coming from what's happening in Treasuries. Of course, one of the reasons that you can justify such crazy high valuations is because bond yields are so low. And if bond yields are going up, and particularly if there's expectations that they're gonna continue to go up, well, that really starts to make an asset allocation question of whether you can allocate more to bonds and perhaps less to stocks. I don't think it's going to make any big difference in the end. I think that what we're ultimately going to realize My sense here is there's gonna be lots of money printing, lots of support for both bond and stock prices, just as we've seen over the last few years. And I expect the S&P will probably continue its relentless grind higher on all of these stimulus expectations. But right now, I think the backup in Treasury yields is kind of causing a brief panic, which I don't think is gonna last very long.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because it's been more or less a week off of its worst levels hovering around this 90 handle. What's your take here on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, this bounce began from, as you know, a very key technical support range. And, you know, this is really kind of Luke Gromen's specialty as our feature interview guest this week. So, I don't want to steal too much of Luke's thunder. Let's save most of the dollar discussion for him. But my own focus is on absolute, not relative performance of the dollar. I don't really care that much about the dollar index, a measure of the dollar's relative performance compared to other Treasuries. I think about loss of purchasing power, which to me, it's just inevitable. The dollar has to go down dramatically in coming years in terms of its purchasing power. And that's got to be good for things like gold in the long run. So that's how I see it. As far as how the dollar does relative to other currencies, frankly, I don't care that much.
This is Luke's specialty. Let's save the rest for Luke in the feature interview.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil, which just hasn't quit. I mean, once we got above $50, it's just been almost methodically crawling higher, where on the February contract around $53.61 at the time of recording. What's your take here on oil?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, of course, Art Berman predicted $65 this year in last week's episode. The very next day, Goldman Sachs came out with a call for $65. I'm assuming the Goldman team is listening to MacroVoices late on Thursday nights and issuing their research guidance accordingly. That or great minds think alike. I'm not sure which. They're actually saying by summer though, not just by end of year. As far as where we stand, Patrick, for the last week and a half, 10 days in there somewhere. The front month WTI futures contract has never even gone below the 5-day moving average for 1 tick. Today was a big day. It traded below the 5-day moving average for all of about a couple of hours and then moved above and closed above. So, you know, it looks like maybe we're starting to see the market finally maybe pause for a breath. But I don't think there's any reason to conclude that the uptrend is over, at least not yet.
We haven't seen any—
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Closes below the short-term moving averages, which would be the sign of a trend reversal. Maybe we're getting a little closer to it. That does feel to me like we're due for some kind of a technical correction, but I think it'll be short-lived. I think that we're ultimately heading higher. My own favorite trade, as our longtime listeners know, is the Z1-Z2 time spread. Entered that trade at -320. It topped 280 this week. So that's a $6 move in a time spread, is a really big move for a time spread. And I don't think it's done yet. I won't be surprised I wouldn't be surprised if we get to a $10 total move by the time this thing is over sometime in the summer.
Inventory-wise this week, crude oil drawing down 3.2 million barrels, Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 2 million barrels, but that was offset by big builds in finished products. Gasoline building 4.4 million barrels, distillates building 4.8 million barrels. US production unchanged for yet another week at 11 million barrels flat. Tape action, there was a brief bounce higher on the drawdown news, but then the tape was kind of flat, back and forth, up and down. And as we're speaking Thursday afternoon, we're just moving above the price level that we saw before the inventory data came out. It'll be interesting to see if we move back above the 200-week moving average, which appears to be what arrested the rally, at least temporarily. And if we can move back above that, get above the, the highs from a few days ago, you know, maybe we just never have that, that technical correction and keep on charging towards $65. I think we're headed there eventually, but we are overdue for at least a correction.
We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because no sooner did we finish recording our episode last week, the day after, gold goes down $80 an ounce in a very rapid breakdown. What's your take here on gold?
Erik Townsend: Well, again, this is why I wanted to start with Treasury yields. I think it's all about the backup in the 10-year yield. And of course, the cardinal rule of gold investing is that in increase in real interest rates, that is adjusting the Treasury yield for inflation. That's the enemy of gold, because most institutional investors consider Treasuries to be as safe, if not safer, than gold, which I don't agree with, but that's the way the industry thinks of it. And they're saying, hey, if I can get a real rate of return on Treasuries that is significantly positive versus gold yielding nothing, Yeah. You know, boy, it's hard to stay in gold when I could switch to Treasuries that give me a little bit of real yield. So real yield is really, really important to the gold market. What's happening, I think, is the Treasury yields are backing up right now.
To my thinking, it's just very shortsighted thinking that the gold market is saying, oh no, that means real yield is moving up. Bad news for gold. Time to dump the gold. Well, wait a minute. Why is the Treasury yield backing up? 'Cause the government's about to spend $2 trillion in stimulus. You don't think that's gonna be just a wee bit inflationary eventually? And that that real yield isn't gonna come back down? Remember, real yield is Treasury yield adjusted for inflation. So once you get inflation into the equation, it brings the real yield back down to negative again and gold becomes favorable. So I don't think the market is really seeing the forest for the trees, to coincidentally quote the name of Luke Gromen's company. I think they're missing the fact that, yeah, sure, Treasury yields are backing up, Real yields right now, this instant, are backing up, but that's because we haven't felt the effects of all this yet.
Once we see the Fed monetize most of this debt issuance and we see all of that stimulus money start to lead to inflation in the real economy, I think it's really, really good for gold. But for now, the markets go in the opposite direction, and I think it's until we see those real yields turn around again that we're spooked for the time being.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's featured interview guest is Forest for the Trees founder Luke Gromen. So, Erik, why did we invite Luke back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Luke has been Mr. Dollar Decline, and I won't say dollar crash. Luke has never said that, but he's the guy who has for years said, look, we're headed toward a secular change where the US dollar loses its reserve currency status, falls from favor the way the British pound sterling did, you know, back after the end of the Second World War, and it's gonna be a major change in the whole balance of power in the world. I've always felt that Luke would be proven right in that forecast in the end, but I used to tell him I thought he was early. Maybe his time has come. So I wanted to get an update and see how he sees this situation and what he makes of both the Treasury rates and the transmission to other asset classes.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Luke Gromen is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how the markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. My interview with former US Ambassador to Singapore, Frank Lavin, is available now at smartermarketspod.com. My guest on Smarter Markets this coming Saturday will be Jos Schmitt, founder of the NEO Stock Exchange. We'll discuss how privatization of stock exchanges has led to unfair advantages for high-frequency traders on most exchanges and why Jos saw the need to design a smarter stock market to level the playing field. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to separately subscribe to Smarter Markets in your podcast app in order to receive this new podcast. More information is available at smartermarketspod.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Forest for the Trees founder Luke Gromen. Luke, it's great to get you back on the show. You've been on my mind lately because I have been saying for I don't know how many years it's been now, I'm absolutely certain Luke Gromen will be proven right in the end. But I kind of thought in the beginning you were a little bit early. Maybe, I guess you were, as history has proven out. Are we at the point where we have the so-called Luke Gromen moment where the US dollar really does start a decline that's a one-way direction, beginning to lose reserve currency status.
It's the beginning of the end kind of moment. And if so, I think a lot of people, including myself initially, had maybe misunderstood you on that. Some people thought you were predicting a dollar crash, and I really don't think you are. I think you're predicting more of a slow process. So how do you see this playing out, and where are we in the story at this point?
Luke Gromen: Sure. No, thanks for having me back on, Erik. It's great to be here, and Happy New Year, everybody. I think we are Really getting into the process, I think COVID accelerated things meaningfully. We've been saying that we think that it's a process of a change in the structure of the dollar's reserve status, which effectively is the key hallmark of which is foreigners ceasing to grow their holdings of Treasuries as the primary reserve asset in favor of gold in particular, but other sovereign bonds as well, basically balancing things out. And there was actually an article on Bloomberg this morning highlighting that for the first time ever, Russia's gold holdings in their FX reserves are higher than their dollar holdings. And the number one reserve asset they have in FX reserves is euros, followed by gold, followed by dollars, followed by yuan. And I think that's sort of where the world is moving, where it's if you can buy commodities and energy in particular in Euros or yuan, which you absolutely can buy the marginal barrel of oil globally in either of those currencies.
And that means the world needs structurally significantly less dollar reserves over time. And so I think where the world is going and where we continue to be in is this multi-currency energy pricing, multi-currency FX reserve system. Where gold takes share from the Treasury bond as the world's primary reserve asset. And the flip side of that is since the world doesn't need to hold as many dollars and as many Treasuries structurally, if they can buy energy in their own currency increasingly over time, then the flip side to that is because most countries, and in particularly Europe, China, Japan, the big creditors of this entire system, their biggest deficits are in energy and in commodity imports, then the flip side is they don't need to hold as many treasuries and somebody else needs to finance US government deficits, which are big and rising cyclically because of COVID and rising structurally because of demographics and the promises we've made to the baby boomers.
And our case has long been that the marginal financier of US deficits as this happens will have to be the Fed. And that's what's been happening. And I think it's gonna continue happening.
Now, what does that mean for the dollar in the near term? This, I think, is a different discussion. I think I wouldn't be surprised if we get a bit of a bounce here. I think the Fed is pretty concerned about what the dollar has done in the last 12 months or the last 9 months. And I think they're a bit cornered, but I think some of what they could do might actually see a dollar bounce in the short run.
Erik Townsend: Luke, with respect to your outlook, obviously, there's 2 aspects to this. One is dollar losing real purchasing power against, you know, a basket of whatever somebody's buying. The other is the relative measure against other fiat currencies, which tends to be more about the race to the bottom, so to speak, in a competitive devaluation scenario. Is it both of those things? Is it one of those things predominantly? What is it that you really see going on here in terms of the outcome that you're predicting? Is it a loss of purchasing power or is it a relative decline relative to other fiat currencies because of the dollar's changing role in the global financial system?
Luke Gromen: I think it's both. I think it's both. I think relative to other currencies, if you look at what China, Russia, or excuse me, the creditors of the system as they stand now, which are really the big 3, it's China, it's Japan, and it's Europe. And if all 3 of them, and in particular China and Europe, the 2 biggest, can buy energy in particular, commodities more broadly, in their own currency, increasingly on the margin, then that system is one where basically every major player has to finance their own deficits, as opposed to a system where all Commodities are bought in dollars and everybody finances the US's deficits for them, for the US.
And so if everybody has to finance their own deficits, it comes back to a relative game of who has the biggest current account deficits to finance. And the Europeans have the biggest current account surplus in aggregate. That's primarily Germany, but EU has the biggest current account surplus. China has the second biggest current account surplus. The Japanese are third. There's a bunch of countries that are slight surpluses, slight deficits. And then there's the UK, which has a really big deficit. And then the United States, which has an enormous current account deficit.
And so effectively, what has to happen if these creditor countries can basically buy their biggest deficit items, which are energy and commodities, generally speaking, in their own currency, is everybody's got to finance their own deficit. And Europe and China and Japan don't have deficits. The UK and the US do. And so they're gonna have to print the money. Basically, they have to find someone to finance those deficits. And if our view has long been that the way those will be financed is by the central bank with printed money, and that's what's been happening. And so basically, you would reorder the global currency system along the lines of, in order of current account balance. Which is the way the currency system worked for pretty much all of history up until 1971. And so, I think you'll see the dollar weaken structurally against the euro, against the yuan, against the yen over time. I think the sterling or the pound sterling will weaken against the euro, the yuan, and the yen over time as well.
The question then just tactically is always the US has to print the most, but will they print the fastest? And in 2020, they printed the fastest as well as the most. And the question is going forward, will that be the case? And there are signs that as of right now, the US won't— the Fed won't print enough or fast enough relative to what they need to, which would be good for the dollar. Because we saw in 2018, the US didn't print enough, it was good for the dollar. They didn't print enough in 2019, at least until the very end of the year, it was good for the dollar. And so that's really It's really both against CPI and against foreign currencies as well.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the political situation in the United States and the Democrats having just taken control of the Senate. A lot of people are connecting this with the increase in bond yields. And the argument is basically, if you've got an expectation of a whole lot more deficit spending, that means the government's going to have to sell a whole lot more bonds. If you're selling more bonds, That means there's more supply, less demand, the price goes down. It seems to me that that kind of misses the question of, okay, but what's the Fed going to do to intervene and not allow yields to go too far in the other direction? How do you see this playing out in terms of what the Democrats taking control of the government, the expectation of more spending, how does that play into this whole picture?
Luke Gromen: So I think it's interesting to see that US tax receipts have begun declining again on a year-over-year basis when you look at it on a trailing 12-month tax receipts. And it coincides with the roll-off of stimulus. And so, if the US economy can bounce back strongly, then that's one set of outcomes. But as it looks now, it looks like the US economy can't survive really without increasing government stimulus. And I think at least in the near term until we fully recover from COVID that's probably the case.
And so then you get to the point that you just made, which I think is the right one, that by all accounts, it sounds like the Democratic control of the White House and Congress is going to result in increased stimulus spending.
And all else equal, if I was a bondholder, that would make me want to sell bonds, make me want to sell Treasuries, and yields up. And I To your point, the $64,000 question is, what is the level of yields that, A, freaks out the Fed and/or breaks something systemic in markets? And I think realistically, that's probably one and the same thing. The level that freaks out the Fed is the level that causes something systemic to break.
And so I think basically, we're likely to continue to see yields rise in the US until something systemic breaks. And what's interesting is it's been linear to this point. I think we're now getting to yield levels where at some point in the not too distant future, those linear increases in yields will start to become nonlinear. It'll be more of a gamma trade where it just feeds on itself for hedging, et cetera, as people hedge further risk of yield increases, et cetera. And I think We could go from sort of a linear orderly rise in yields to a disorderly rise in yields. And at that point, I would expect the stock market or portions of the stock market or something somewhere else to break.
And at that point, I would expect the Fed to do exactly what you noted, which is come in with yield curve control of some description or increase the monthly levels of QE to get that under control.
What's been interesting to me in this whole process has been that The dollar hasn't responded to these yield increases at all. And I think Louis Gave said it best a couple of weeks ago in an interview. He said, when I see a nation who has rising yields and a falling currency, alarm bells go off.
That's a symptom of a balance of payments problem.
And I think that's away from the yield increases, which I think the Occam's razor explanation for why yields are rising, particularly post-election, is on expectation of the stimulus. I think the reason behind the reason is that the reason we need the stimulus is because the US has a balance of payments problem in the aftermath of COVID When you look at the hole that was blown in the US fiscal budget after COVID, it really looks to our eyes irrecoverable without some massive stimulus or a big devaluation in the dollar or something of that sort.
Erik Townsend: Now, a phrase that I've heard you use a lot before, Luke, is deficits don't matter until they do. The implication being that at some point, if you no longer have the position of prominence that the US has enjoyed with the rest of the world buying up its debt, all of a sudden the game is different. But, you know, on the other hand, you can spend pretty much an unlimited amount of money if the Fed just buys all the Treasuries and you don't have to depend on outside investors for that. How do you see this increased spending, lots and lots of stimulus planned, a growing political sentiment around MMT to sort of say, let's just spend whatever we need to, we can always print the money to buy the bonds if necessary. How long does that game go on until deficits do matter?
Luke Gromen: I think they've started to matter already. I think they started to matter in 3Q14 when Global central banks stopped buying Treasuries on net. If you look at what they have bought from 3Q14 to present on net, they have not added any Treasury bonds on net to their FX reserves, which I think that is really the kickoff of when they started to matter.
And there've been on this front, a couple of interesting op-eds in the Wall Street Journal in the last month, one by former Goldman CEO and Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson, One by former Fed Governor Kevin Warsh last week. And both of them, I think, are really important op-eds because they both suggest that the Fed and the US government have a problem, which is that the US needs to refinance, call it $7 to $8 trillion net this year.
In 2020, the Fed bought more than 100% of net issuance. of US Treasury. And so the Fed financed more than 100% financed the US government effectively last year. And we saw that in the response of the dollar. But for 2021, at this point, the plan, and this is as far as I know before any additional Biden stimulus, the plan is that the Fed is going to buy, or the net issuance is going to be $1.8 trillion more than what the Fed is going to buy.
And so, the issue is that now you're back into this dollar short squeeze mechanic. And so, the US government will be in a position to crowd out other global private dollar markets, send the dollar higher, send yields higher. And so, that's one side of the coin. The other side of the coin that both Paulson and Warsh talked about, Paulson's article, I think it was titled Beijing Wants to Be the World's Banker.
And Warsh has talked about the same thing, which is that China is putting pressure on the US.
They're keeping us honest. And for the last 40 years, 30 years since the Berlin Wall came down, we haven't had anybody else to keep us honest, which is to say both Paulson and Warsh noted that you can get 3%, 3.25% in a Chinese 10-year versus whatever we're getting. And so, you're seeing capital flows to China away from the US. At the same time, China has recently signed this massive trade deal, the RCEP across Southeast Asia and the European investment deal. And so, you have 2 stalwart US allies in the EU and Japan signing on with these big trade deals with China in the last month. And so, there's this capital flow issue that Warsh and Paulson identified, You've got the Fed needing to help the US government finance these deficits, but the dollar sitting right at a crucial level where if the Fed does do more, you run the risk of what I would say is truly the Fed's worst-case scenario, which is the dollar starts falling and the equity markets start falling in response to a falling dollar as opposed to rising like they did again last year.
In which case the Fed is really hamstrung. And so I think the Fed is sort of caught between a rock and a hard place where you're seeing capital flows away from the US. You see it in the performance of Chinese stock market. You see it in the performance of the EU stock market. You can see the relative interest rates higher in China. Domestically, you're seeing capital flight into Bitcoin and gold. The gold volumes have been physical gold volumes, I think I saw one the other day up 700% year over year.
You've got this financing problem where you need to finance it. If rates rise too much, you cause stocks to fall. But if you help too much financing it, then the dollar falls and you could have stocks fall because the dollar's falling too fast.
So I think the Fed's really pretty cornered. And I think it all points to this. When do deficits matter? I think they started to matter 6.5 years ago, and I think they're I think we're getting to the point of the game where we wrote a report the other day is sooner or later everybody sits down to a banquet of consequences. It's a quote by Robert Louis Stevenson. And I think 2021, we're all gonna sit down to this banquet of consequences. The Fed's gonna have to make a choice of what they wanna do.
Erik Townsend: And what's the trade-off in that choice that will confront us in 2021?
Luke Gromen: Crush the economy or crush the dollar.
Erik Townsend: Luke, expound on that. How do we crush the economy? How do we crush the dollar? What are the mechanics of each of those options?
Luke Gromen: So, crush the economy is effectively let the Fed stand aside, does whatever they're going to do in terms of QE or even taper QE, and force the global private sector dollar markets to finance US deficits and let interest rates just rise and rise and rise and go to wherever they're going to go find their level until something really breaks. And crush the dollar is effectively Have at that point, either at that point or prior to that point, have the Fed say, whatever the Biden administration wants, we'll supply. Or yield curve control. It's just another way of saying yield curve control, really. It's just saying, we're not going to let yields go over X, and whatever the Biden administration wants to do, they can do. Yields are not going to go over X. And what yield curve control will do will effectively create the Lacy Hunt scenario of the Fed will be lending to the government who will be spending.
And yeah, they'll be separate entities, but they'll be married. And if the husband's lending and the wife is spending, the household is spending, and it'll be the same type of thing. So, those are really, I think, the 2 paths that the Fed's going to have to choose here in 2021, the banquet of consequences.
Erik Townsend: Do you have a view on what their choice is likely to be?
Luke Gromen: I think they would love to keep riding 2 horses with one ass for as long as they can. And I think they've done a very nice job of it. I think these Paulson and Warsh op-eds are a sign to try to defend the dollar and the dollar system for a little bit longer. You've seen the Fed over the last— a couple different Fed officials over the last several days talk about, well, maybe we can start to think about tapering here or there. And so there's some jawboning going on to that effect.
Ultimately, I don't think they have a choice. The only politically palatable choice is to supply whatever the Biden administration wants. And part of that is because of what we saw in 2019 and 2020 with the repo rate spike and then how the Treasury market Because the thing that very few people are talking about is because of how dependent on the stock market the US economy has become, once the stock market falls enough, it starts to reflexively reverberate back into the Treasury market. And so, we saw back for 9 days in March of 2020, we saw from March 9th to March 18th, 2020, we saw the Treasury market begin to crash alongside the US equity market, nearly tick for tick.
And that wasn't— that was not an accident. That was something that I thought would eventually happen. I was surprised how fast it happened. Some of that has to do with how severe the sell-off was related to COVID.
But the issue is with the US government's debt as high as it is, with foreign central banks not buying Treasuries the way they used to, with the US's net international investment position at negative 60% of GDP, which means foreigners own $40 trillion gross, $12 trillion net of dollar assets with the foreigners being as short dollars as they are relative to their dollar borrowings. And of course, relative to Jeff Snider's ongoing point about the eurodollar market, the point is, is basically as soon as the dollar gets too high, they begin dumping dollar assets and they dump what they can, not necessarily what they want to. And what they can dump are Treasuries. And so, Paradoxically, something that we've begun to see, and which I think we will see in spades in each cycle going forward for the foreseeable future, is that once the stock market falls too far, Treasury yields will start rising, which is the complete opposite of everything we've seen throughout our entire careers.
I've been doing this 25 years, and up until March of 2020, when stocks fell, yields went down. And March 2020, stocks fell and yields went up. And that's a classic emerging market thing, the balance of payments problem, yields. And we saw it again in October. Dow was down 800 points one day in October, I forget which day, and the TLT was down, yields were up. So long-winded way of saying is the Fed has a choice, but it's really a Hobson's choice, which is to say they don't have a choice.
Because they can pretend to try to defend the dollar, they can try to defend the dollar, they I think they might even be about to here for a little bit. But the second the dollar gets too strong, you're going to start to see stocks sell off. You'll see the economy start to weaken as a result of declining stock market consumption through the consumption link. And you can't have GDP decline when you're running debt-to-GDP at 130% because you'll default on your debt. So it really is just a question of path. My bet is that they probably try to defend the dollar here for a little bit, But that ultimately, they're going to have to acquiesce and basically use yield curve control sometime later this year to provide the Biden Administration with what they want.
Erik Townsend: Well, I have to confess, Luke, it was a trick question because I knew the answer would be, it's really hard to tell and we're not sure exactly when each decision's going to be made. With all of that in mind, how do you translate this back to an investment strategy when clearly, there's a lot of moving parts here and it's not clear exactly which direction is going to happen when?
Luke Gromen: Yeah, it's hard. It's very political. It comes down to not just the domestic politics, which I think people are very focused on, but these international geopolitics that I think people are at this point still relatively less focused on than they are, at least here in the US, of the domestic politics. Look, for me, because I'm of the view that any whoosh or any down move down is likely to be a whoosh move down, I continue to be positioned as I've been positioned all through last year, which is I own gold, I own Bitcoin, I own gold miners, my 3 largest positions. And then I also own a lot of equities and I own no bonds. And that's how I've been positioned over the last, well, really in December actually, when Bitcoin broke above $20,000, I added quite a bit to that position actually. And so I am completely cognizant that The risk is that they try to strengthen the dollar or support the dollar.
And if they do that, that's not going to be good for any of my positions. I'm unlevered. And so, I'm willing to take that pain.
If I was running a book where I was managing money on a monthly basis, I would probably be de-risking a bit right here relative to those positions to give myself a little bit of cash and some dry powder and some cushion. Basically, that I think they may try, like I said, to defend the dollar system as advocated by Warsh and by Paulson in the last month. But the holes in the system are just so big and the holes in the fiscal position are just so big after COVID.
And when I say that, I should probably define what I mean. What I mean by that is if you look at the 3rd quarter TBAC, Treasury Borrowing Advisory Committee report, It shows that the US's big 3 expenditures, entitlements, defense, and interest expense/Treasury spending are 140% of tax receipts. If you look at that same report, it shows you that US's true interest expense, which is interest expense plus the entitlements and the pay-as-you-go portion of entitlements, it's 120% of tax receipts. So what that tells you is that if the US tries the austerity route, they try to strengthen the dollar, they try to squeeze out adversaries, It's not going to be very long before the US doesn't have the money to pay entitlements, defense, or interest. And the US is not going to default on any 3 of those for lack of money, for lack of printed money. They will get that money. And so, that's my point there in terms of that.
What it all points to with the debt being where it is, is the US needs significantly negative real rates for an extended period of time and increasingly negative real rates. And so, consensus to me still appears to be that US real rates bottomed in August at -1.1%. I think they're probably, I think at a minimum on the way to -5 and maybe on a way to -10 or more.
Erik Townsend: Now that is just fantastically bullish for gold in the long run. But what we're hearing this week, and I certainly agree with it, is some analysis saying, look, the reason that gold is off this week and likely still has room to go to the downside is specifically because rates are backing up right now. And at least short term, the trend is higher real yields. How long do higher real yields last? And I think that's explained, as we talked about at the beginning of this interview, by the expectation of a lot of stimulus spending resulting in the Treasury having to sell a whole bunch of bonds to finance that government spending.
Luke Gromen: Right.
Erik Townsend: For the moment, the trend is higher real yields, gold down. Do you wait this out for that to, you know, get to some better buying opportunity, or are we already there? How do you play this with respect to gold and where you think real yields are going to go?
Luke Gromen: It's a great question. I think it just depends on your time horizon, but I think ultimately the US is so levered to the stock market, the US is so levered Period. We're talking about basically if real rates keep rising, do you want to buy gold here with, I don't know, 5 to 7% downside, 5 to 8% downside and a whole bunch of upside? Or would you prefer to wait and maybe pick it up 5 to 8, maybe 10% cheaper? I'd be shocked if it got 10% cheaper, but certainly I suppose possible and buy it there.
To me, It feels cute because the flip side to that is when you're talking about a trade that has 5% to 8%, let's say 10% downside max and 50% to 100% upside, because the flip side of it is if Biden comes out and says, we're going to do $2,000 to everybody. And by the way, I'm also going to do an executive order where we're going to forgive $50,000 of student debt for everybody.
You're never going to get gold better than here again, probably for the foreseeable future. So to me, I don't trade month to month. I would rather just— I'm a buyer of it here. I'm a buyer of Bitcoin here. I'm a buyer of gold miners here. If you're a trader with real rates doing what they're doing, I get it. But to me, it just feels trying to be cute.
Erik Townsend: I want to touch on the Bitcoin versus gold subject because I know that you have for a long time been investing in both Bitcoin and gold. It seems to me that you could argue this 2 ways. Well, you could say, look, gold is really in a soft patch here.
And well, at least until last week, Bitcoin was having an incredible bull run. It was time last week, maybe not as much this week, to take profits and rebalance. You know, if you see you've got 2 assets that have the same goal and one tremendously outperforms the other. The rebalancing theory is you lighten up on whatever has done better because you figure that it's a good time to shift that allocation so that you're selling the high asset and buying the low asset. The other argument that I guess you could make is, now look, this is happening because gold is old-fashioned. It's your father's Oldsmobile. You know, Bitcoin's the new thing. You don't want to be taking away from your Bitcoin position to be buying gold. If anything, you should go in the other direction because gold's on the way out.
Which way do you see this or is it something completely different?
Luke Gromen: I see it as, I think there are a number of things that Bitcoin does better than gold. And there's a number of Bitcoin proponents that would tell you what those things are. I think there are 2 things where Bitcoin underperforms gold or it does worse than gold. Those 2 things are, number one, gold is final payment. It does not have any additional energy debt owed to it. In other words, you hold a gold coin in your hand, you don't need electricity to make that gold coin work, to make it stay.
It is final. It's a reserve asset with no additional energy debt owed to it. Whereas Bitcoin has an ongoing energy debt owed to it in the form of the the grid and the amount of energy it will take to keep all the miners and all of the network and nodes all going.
So that's one way. The other way that I think gold is better, or at least needs to be in portfolios alongside Bitcoin, is that gold sits on central bank balance sheets. Gold sits on the US government and other sovereigns' balance sheets, and Bitcoin doesn't.
And I think this is relevant, particularly now when you get to a point where the center of the system, the United States, is as cornered as it is fiscally and from a debt perspective. And what I mean by that is we wrote to our clients recently, if you look at the Warsh interview or the Warsh op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, it's fascinating because it lays out that, okay, we need to refinance all this debt. We need the Fed to do more. But if the Fed doesn't do more, Then rates will rise and risk assets will eventually fall. If the Fed does do more, then the dollar will fall and it's getting to a level where it could get disorderly fast. And then we could see asset prices fall because the dollar's falling so fast.
And we need to raise rates to defend or to compete with China because they're offering 3.25% and we're offering 1.15%. And they've got this trade deal that now they've signed up. up with people. So, there's actually going to be more demand for their bonds as it is. And we've got this Bitcoin thing going on in the US where there's very clearly starting to be a bit of a jailbreak with US investors, US retail investors, US corporations saving in Bitcoin instead of in Treasuries.
So, basically, we need to do the Paul Volcker playbook and raise rates to defend the dollar. But if we do that, we'll break the system and rates will rise anyway. Which is we're sort of in trouble because unlike when Volcker ran his playbook, US debt to GDP was 30%. It's 130% today. So, the thing that's very, very different now versus 1980 is if the US runs the Volcker playbook, the entity that will go broke relatively quickly will be the US government without Fed-printed money, which defeats the whole purpose.
And so, what I think is the other big advantage or the other reason I think you need to have gold alongside Bitcoin is The way out, if you read the Warsh op-ed, is for the US needs to delever its own balance sheet in order to normalize rates without bankrupting the US government to be able to defend the dollar.
So what do you do? There's a playbook where the US Treasury could instruct the Fed, I want you to remonetize gold at some really big number. And basically every $4,000 on gold is about a trillion dollars that would be deposited into the US Treasury General Account, because that's how it works. So basically, if Treasury tells the Fed to remonetize gold, the funds show up in the TGA, the Treasury General Account. And the Treasury could then spend that into the economy however they want to spend it.
And so let's say the US government, the Treasury says, I want to put $5 trillion into the TGA. $5 trillion divided by 1 per 4,000. So that's 5 times 4,000. It's $20,000 more on gold, but gives me $5 trillion. into the TGA. So now the TGA is sitting at $5 trillion plus.
And the Fed's data in terms of the stimulus around the COVID stimulus was that it was about a multiplier of 1.5. So we take the $5 trillion, we spend that on a variety of stimulus infrastructure in the US with a multiplier of 1.5. So it's $7.5 trillion, $5 trillion times 1.5, $7.5 trillion. $7.5 trillion on a $22 trillion GDP is gonna significantly delever the US's economy. By the time that's said and done, you're going to be talking about debt-to-GDP that's gone from 130% to probably something well below 100%, at which point the Fed then could raise rates, normalize rates, and away you go.
And so, the punchline is that basically, because the Fed is so cornered, because the Treasury is so cornered by the factors I described, it's increasingly looking like the only way out is to use the gold to delever the Fed's balance sheet and then raise rates.
And so, I think that's why you need to have both gold and Bitcoin on your balance sheet. And in terms of balancing, I think it's a personal preference. Obviously, you can see the relative volatilities are very, very different. But for me, I like having them both in pretty good size alongside each other.
Erik Townsend: Let's tie this back into the stock market. I can make the argument that, hey, look, it's 10 years of straight up for the stock market. It's way overdone. We're at the final blow-off stage of very, very late-stage bull market, which surely must be about to end. Or I can make the opposite argument that based on the amount of stimulus and the political will to create more and more money, balance sheet expansion and so forth, could be just the beginning of a crack-up boom that takes the stock market, at least in nominal terms, straight up from here. Which side of that argument would you pick? Or Is it even possible to know?
Luke Gromen: I shade towards the crack-up boom. And the reason that is, is for a number of years now, I think investing has become increasingly a relative game. I guess it's always a relative game. But what I mean by that is, yes, stocks are expensive. Yes, real estate's expensive. Yes, there's a bubble in everything.
But the biggest bubble of all by far is in sovereign debt and specifically in US Treasury bonds. And US Treasury bonds are the risk-free asset underpinning everything. And what I mean by that is, yes, the NASDAQ is expensive at whatever it is. It's how many times earnings, how many times sales, home prices at however many times income. But if you take a look at US Treasury bonds, you have the US government is an entity that has— we're not going to look at— we always quote debt to GDP at whatever, 130%, 70-year high.
I think it's relevant if you want to look at the comparative bubbles, look at the US's debt to revenues. US's revenues are about $3.3 trillion. We've got $27 trillion in debt. And so right now, the US government, US Treasury bond sells at 9 times revenues. So then you say, okay, the US government, the US Treasury has the valuation of their OPEB liabilities or pension and entitlement liabilities. US owes somewhere between $100 and $200 trillion there off balance sheet. So, the Treasury is, again, $100 to $200 trillion divided by $3.3 trillion in revenues. Treasuries are trading at somewhere between 33 and 60 times revenues.
Furthermore, since the US has not run a surplus since 2000, we have not turned a profit in quote-unquote profit in over 20 years. And so, when you look— and what's more is our biggest creditor, our biggest bankers cut us off in 2014, in 3Q14, when foreign central banks stopped growing their holdings of Treasuries.
And so, when I look at the valuation of everything, I have to start with the asset that underpins all of it, the risk-free asset and the capital asset pricing model, is arguably the biggest bubble in the history of mankind. And if I start there and say, okay, well, if the safe asset is in ludicrous range of valuation, then it comes down to, I want to own stuff that's more finite. And so, would I rather own a US Treasury bond, or would I rather own a share of Microsoft? Would I rather own a share of Amazon? Would I rather own a share of Intel? Would I rather own a share of Parker-Hannifin, Eaton Corporation, Boeing.
And to me, the answer has long been and continues to be, I'd rather own the latter because there's just— unless there is a significant political change shading towards austerity, I just don't see how this doesn't continue and make— I think it forces this crack-up boom dynamic within all other asset markets.
Erik Townsend: Well, I agree with you on the crack-up boom being the more likely outcome. And it seems like really the environment we're in is If the only way out of this for the government is to depreciate the value of the currency, that means the price of everything has to keep going up. But that begs a question, Luke, which is so far, curiously, despite many predictions of runaway inflation dating back 10 years now, what's really happened is there's been this explosive appreciation of financial assets, but really in terms of consumer price inflation, It's been a lot more muted than what some people expected. Are we finally at the point where we're getting close to transmission of this into the real economy and runaway wage and price inflation?
Luke Gromen: I think we're getting closer. Yeah, I think we're almost in between 2 trapezes. If you look historically, and Professor Richard Werner's done a lot of really good work on this, there's 2 components of inflation basically. There's the asset price inflation and then there's sort of real economy inflation. And we have structured our economy to basically sterilize what the central banks have with the government spending through asset markets a number of different ways. And so, that's where the inflation has shown up. Now, I think the reason that's changing is twofold.
Number one, Lyn Alden has a great chart showing QE and the fiscal deficits in 2008, 2009, 2010, and last year. And it's night and day. In '08, '09, '10, the deficits did not blow out. So basically, the government did not spend to stimulate, and this time they did.
And so we did start to see some CPI inflation metrics rise off of low levels in the back half of last year in particular. But I would argue that was still just filling in a hole. What is starting to be harder, or why I think it may have more legs than most people think, is because of the damage of COVID because the US government, the debt is as high as it is, because aggregate debt is as high as it is, it means no one can afford a recession without touching off a death spiral across the system.
And because the US government is now such a big part of GDP at 20% or 22% of GDP, they can't pull back. And so, People say, well, you need the banks to lend to drive inflation. And I think that's true. Then you take a look and see at what happened in 2020, which was that US bank loans to the US government were up about 35% year over year, which is to say their holdings of Treasury bonds rose 35%.
And so you're seeing banks lend very aggressively to the government. Ostensibly, some people, I know Jeff Snider says that's just 'cause they wanna be safe. Maybe that's true. But at the end of the day, Functionally, there's no difference between a bond and a loan.
And so, the banks are lending to the government, and the government is absolutely spending. And so, it really is a political question then of, are we about to get that inflation? And to me, the politics all point in one direction, which is yes, whether you look at what happened last week, whether you look at the unrest over the summer, et cetera, et cetera. To me, It seems pretty clear that the political winds are suggesting that the, that the government increasing their spending of Fed and federal bank lending, US commercial bank lending, will continue and accelerate. And if that happens, and I think we will see that inflation show up.
Erik Townsend: And do you have a timeframe? You know, generally speaking, when inflation starts, it's good news in the beginning until you start to get to the wage and price part that tends to be more of a draw on the economy. And usually the beginning of inflation, it's good for the stock market, and it becomes bad for the stock market only when the real economy starts to suffer. How far away are we from the point where it becomes a significant stock market headwind as opposed to the tailwind that it always starts as?
Luke Gromen: I think we're a long way from it. And the reason I say that, there was a, there was a great tweet by, uh, by Mike Krieger last week, or maybe the week before, and it was Let me make one thing clear. There is no Paul Volcker coming this time. And it was a great, great tweet. And the reason I think it's such a great tweet is you can see how this is going to go.
US debt to GDP is at 130%. When Volcker showed up to control inflation, it was 30%. And our demographics are much older. And our economy is significantly more financialized, which is to say every interest, every 100 basis points higher is a much more pronounced negative impact on the US economy than it was back in 1980.
And so the way I think this goes down is I think my base case is the Biden administration comes in, they spend more, the banks, US commercial banks and Fed increase their holdings of Treasuries. The government then spends more and that goes on. Eventually we start to see it show up in CPI. The bond market backs up to a point, And the bond market's going to back up to a point when CPI does something. And unlike when Volcker showed up, he stomped out inflation. What the Fed's going to say is, okay, that's it. The 10-year's not moving any higher than 2%, no matter what we do. And then the Biden administration comes out and says, hey, it's $3,000 checks this quarter, guys. And the Fed buys more 10-years. 10-year doesn't move over 2.
Wages start rising, CPI higher.
Erik Townsend: 2%.
Luke Gromen: And so basically, at some point, not too far along that whole process, the Fed's balance sheet goes $7 trillion, $8 trillion, $10 trillion, $15 trillion, $30 trillion, as the entire bond market starts to realize, oh my God, they're not going to stop this. They're going to delever on the back of my purchasing power. And so, it's a very slippery slope. It's one I think that has the Fed scared to death. I think it's one that's inevitable the Fed's going to have to do.
And what it speaks to is that I think the reason they're so coy about yield curve control is that I think they know that after Treasury yield curve control, 2 months later comes corporate curve control. And then after that, mortgage curve control. And then after that, junk bond curve control. And it's a very slippery slope where by Christmas 2022 or July 4th, 2023, the Fed could own some gigantic percentage of the entire dollar bond market globally. And that's, I think, why they don't want to start yield curve control if they can avoid it. But I think that's where this movie's going.
Now, once inflation runs high enough for long enough, and if you run wage inflation at 10 or 15% for 5 years and everyone's mortgage is pinned at 3, that's a debt jubilee. And everyone in 5 years wakes up and their mortgage is, instead of being 40% of their monthly income, it's 5% of their monthly income. And at that point, you can raise rates and you can normalize the curve.
And in theory, you probably have to take some draconian steps at some point to bring inflation back under control.
But I think that's where this is all going. And to me, really the biggest question is just, are we going to start that process right away under the Biden administration? Or are we going to run through the charade of we're going to try to defend the dollar system one last time and blow up risk markets and then have the give the Fed the cover to come in and start this process after sort of a whoosh down? That to me is really the biggest question in my mind.
Erik Townsend: You mentioned a debt jubilee, and that got me curious because back when Paul Volcker was still alive, he was very outspoken publicly in saying his own prescriptions that fixed inflation in the early 1980s would never work today because of exactly the reason that you stated, that we have of a dramatically higher federal government debt level. So does that mean that when we someday, and I do not think it's coming tomorrow or anything like that, I think it's still quite a ways off, someday we're going to get to runaway inflation, where inflation is running outta control and something has to be done to contain it? Volcker's prescriptions clearly will not work, per Volcker's own admission before he died. Does that mean a debt jubilee is the only choice that's left, or are there other options?
Luke Gromen: No, there's another option. That's option 1. Option 2 is what we talked about before, which is Treasury says, Fed, we want you to bid for gold at $50,000 an ounce. And let's use $40,000 for round math. At $40,000 per ounce, the math we laid out before, that's $1 trillion into the TGA for every $4,000 in gold. So there's $10 trillion into the TGA. $10 trillion into the TGA at a multiplier of 1.5 that we talked about before with the Fed's own math would give you an impact of $15 trillion spent into the economy.
And if you did that, the US economy would basically— that money in the TGA would represent an increase in US government spending without a commensurate rise in US government debt.
And it's a way to delever. It's a debt jubilee. You do it all at once. It would result in a massive one-time surge in inflation, but you'd wake up and US GDP would be, I don't know, $35, $40 trillion in 2 years, and debt would still be sitting at $27 trillion. And so we would be at 60% debt to GDP, call it, for easy math. And at 60% debt to GDP in a couple years, and really you could probably start all along, but at that At that rate, you could take Fed funds from 0 to probably 3. And you could take the 10-year from probably wherever it is today, 1.15%, 1.2% to 5%. And the banks are healthy because they're making a positive spread. The inflation in the economy nominally is preventing anyone from defaulting, which otherwise would occur if you tried to raise rates in that fashion without first doing something this draconian.
But that's the other way you can do it. So, it's really their choice is, in my view, the only politically palatable choices are to sort of do it in a process over 5 years or do it all at once in this sort of remonetizing or using the gold to basically do a one-time massive increase in the TGA, using the gold to basically fund a massive infrastructure and stimulus spend instead of funding an infrastructure and stimulus spend with further increases in debt, which is just chasing your own tail.
And this is something mainstream economists are absolutely aware of. If you go back to 2013, Paul Krugman wrote about the trillion-dollar platinum coin, if you remember that. He wasn't the only one where he said, look, we could mint a platinum coin and say it's worth $1 trillion, and then we could spend that money into the economy and get our way out of this. And so, it's gimmicky, it's wonkish, it would absolutely work, The question just really is one of how they want to go about it and what sort of political processes would they need before they did it.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about something that a lot of people think could be very, very near-term on the horizon in the Biden administration, which is a forgiveness of student loan debt. That would be, in a sense, debt jubilee light. Is that coming? And if so, what are the consequences And knock-on effects in terms of financial markets?
Luke Gromen: I don't know if it's coming. I have been following it with great interest. I saw something that Biden allegedly said that he thought the legal basis for him to do that was arguable. In other words, he wasn't sure he had that authority. I've seen others say he could do it via executive order on day one. So I just don't know.
In terms of if he did it, I think it would be enormously bullish for stock markets broadly. I think it would be quite bearish for the dollar. I think it would probably be bearish for bonds. I think it'd be bullish for gold. I think it'd be bullish for Bitcoin. It would on one level be opening a Pandora's box, but on another level, it's probably the right thing to do relative to where we are politically, divisively. Basically, having a bunch of young, highly indebted, angry people is suboptimal, as we're seeing. And I don't know how much longer we need to see this for before we start doing something like this, because this is going to be the endgame no matter what. We can We can choose the happy way of doing it or we can do it the hard way. But that's how I think from a financial market perspective, it'd be stocks up, bonds down, dollar down, gold up, Bitcoin up.
Erik Townsend: Luke, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Before I let you go, tell us a little bit about what you do at Forest for the Trees.
Luke Gromen: Absolutely. So we do unique investment research. We aggregate a large amount of information from publicly available sources. And put it together in a unique manner, trying to identify developing economic bottlenecks for our clients. And we publish reports weekly for our clients. We've got an institutional product. We have a retail and small investor product, both of which are quite popular. And if you want to learn more about either one of them, you can check us out at our website, fftt-llc.com, or you can look us up on Twitter @LukeGromen, L-U-K-E-G-R-O-M-E-N.
Erik Townsend: And again, that's fftt-llc.com. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. After being completely sold out of advertising capacity for months and months, we finally have some MacroVoices ad inventory opening up. There's still just one episode per month available for the remainder of Q1. And then in Q2, we have more ad capacity opening up. We prefer to find a single advertiser who wants to advertise in all 13 episodes in Q2, but if we don't book one, we'll probably continue offering 1-week-per-month packages for advertisers who only want to advertise in 3 or 4 episodes during Q2. For rates and details, please email us at sponsorship@macrovoices.com. Now let's get back to the show.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was so great to have Luke back on the show. Really enjoyed his interview.
Erik Townsend: I really enjoyed talking to Luke too. And of course, listeners, don't worry, we understand Luke is one side of the equation. We're working on getting other guests too. tell the opposite side of the story, because certainly there are different views on where the dollar is headed and what might be next. Meanwhile, I'm certain of what's next on this episode of MacroVoices, which is Looking Under the Hood of Markets, the title of this week's postgame chartbook. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not a registered user yet and don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says Looking for the downloads above Luke Gromen's picture.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's look under the hood of this market. Page 2, S&P 500 futures. Boy, sure looks like the relentless climb is continuing.
Patrick Ceresna: The climb is definitely continuing, and some of these different measured moves that we do are targeting levels toward 3,900 and 4,000. So I mean, the market edging higher is definitely on the table. The interesting part is, is that we're going into a major option expiration. Usually we've had Charlie McElligott on the show before talking about the gamma pins and, and some of the variables that come in. So it's entirely possible we're going to be closing somewhere around this 3,800 level going into there. But it'll be really interesting to see whether or not the volatility returns next week. And what we find is a very interesting circumstance where even Even though the rally has been very methodical and just slow in its grind, I want to talk about some other charts that just tell a little bit of a different storyline. But what is interesting on this particular page is how bullish the sentiment has gotten. We're now seeing a situation using everything from the breadth of the market to momentum and put-call ratios.
We've now reached a point of sentiment to the 98th percentile going back to 2004. This is from— Um, Nomura Research. And really, we just have a market that is incredibly bullish from sentiment perspective. A lot of, uh, people ask me, well, why does the top have to even be considered here? Because the market hasn't really started to melt up yet. We haven't seen this S&P really accelerate to the upside. So why, why are there risks in the market? So I wanted to put a little bit of context on that. And on page 3, what I wanted to do is look at the performance of different parts of the market in this, uh, kind of post-market crash period. So everything's starting in that March-April period, and the, uh, the black line at the very bottom is the S&P 500 performance. And what you can really see is that the majority of the performance has come in a lot of the secondary kind of areas, like for instance semiconductors are up at this stage, you know, 117% off of their lows.
But then you take something like the copper producers up almost 200%. Then I decided to put ARK Investments, Cathie Wood's ETF out there, up, you know, 260%. And of course the TAN index, which is the solar ETF, up almost 400% off of those lows. So there's all sorts of these sectors that are doing these much accelerated parabolic rises in a span of less than a year. And what it reminds me a lot of, and I wanted to kind of go through the thought exercise of on page 4, looking at what happened back in the 1998 to 2000 period. And what we have here in the black and yellow line is the Russell and the S&P 500 performance, which were doing pretty good and all right on their rise, and in fact were not impressively strong in the final 6 months of the rally. But it was the NASDAQ that went parabolic, up 300% in that big bubble blowoff.
And so even though we're seeing, we're seeing all these bubble kind of price action in some of these, uh, different markets, but it doesn't have to— I mean, necessarily mean that the S&P has to rally in order for some sort of a market top and mean reversion to begin on many of these moves.
Erik Townsend: Yeah. This chart really speaks to me in terms of how much farther the craziness in Bitcoin could continue. And I do think it's a speculative mania. I don't think there's any fundamental justification for this big rally that we've seen in Bitcoin. But if you look at what happened in the late '90s, you had what were frankly some pretty darn simple concepts that for some reason Wall Street guys just couldn't get straight.
The web is going to be a big deal, and that means that websites that actually make money are going to be really, really valuable. Somehow that got translated to anything that has .com in its name is selling at a zillion times earnings.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Or it doesn't have to have earnings, or it has no plan to ever have earnings, or what have you. And it was just crazy. And eventually they sorted it out and they figured out that, yeah, the web is gonna be a big deal, but that doesn't mean that people who have no business plan and are just putting companies together based on nothing should be rewarded. And it took a long time for them to figure that out. And the thing is, it was pretty simple.
Now, if you take what's going on with digital currency, which is going to completely change the world, And you really try to get your head around it and understand why there is a big difference between saying that digital currency is the way of the future, which I'm convinced that it is, versus saying Bitcoin is going to be the predominant digital currency, which is what the, the so-called Bitcoin maximalists think. That's a much bigger piece of technology to get your head around and understand than what we were wrestling with in the late '90s, by, by at least a full order of magnitude.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And if it took us a few years in the late '90s to figure out that these valuations were nutso before it finally had a blow-off top, it says to me that the crypto craze probably could run for quite a while longer. Most people don't understand it at all.
And I think there's lots of room there. In any event, I know crypto is not where you were headed with this, but I'm curious to get your perspective on that, Patrick?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I just wanted to add to that because I think that while crypto is in a— is certainly got all the characteristics of that bubble parabolic rise, there's no shortage of sectors within the markets, and especially in the EV space and the solar stocks. And there's a whole series of different sectors within the market that are seeing the same parabolic moves. It's just the typical froth that's associated in the easy money environment that comes in, in these kind of bubble phases.
And one of the things though that I, I wanted to kind of think through and, and, and really debate on page 5, what I was showing was the bear market that followed. And what I really want to capture, not this as an analog of what I believe is imminently going to happen to the stock markets, but rather the sector that performed the best on the way up was the one that underperformed the worst on the way down or had the most room to fall. And while because of all the inflation expectations, there's a lot of people arguing that this time around we're not going to have a bear market the way, the way we did, let's say, back in 2000 to 2002, because stocks are an inflation hedge and inflation is coming and therefore the stock market will do well. But I, I, I kind of look at this chart and see that the NASDAQ dropped, you know, 80% off of its highs, while the Russell and S&P, you know, corrected a much more modest 30-some-odd percent.
And what I'm thinking in this time around, what if, uh, we don't have a bear market on the primary stocks, and stocks do do what many people anticipate as be an inflation hedge, but that doesn't mean that these bubble sectors in the market won't have a very deep mean reversion.
This overshoot that's happening in this space can still have many of those stocks in those sectors wipe out 50% on the downside, and, and us, uh, still on the broader equity indices see the market doing just fine. It's a, it's a really interesting moment in the markets where these parabolic rises can't last forever, otherwise These companies will all within months be multi-trillion-dollar companies. And so really what it comes down to is, is what will it look like in a period where we— they finally exhaust themselves to the upside and mean revert? And that's probably one of the more interesting things we're probably going to see in 2021. And trying to solve the puzzle pieces to when it begins is going to be really interesting.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to page 6. Boy, you can see the 200-day really looks like That's what's filling in and holding the gold market up. Do you think it breaks and we test that lower support zone, or do you think that this is going to hold?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's interesting because Luke Gromen was just talking about the idea that, you know, 5% or so on the downside potentially of gold. And it's interesting that that's a level that lines up with the consolidation from April to June where there's some high-volume nodes that create that consolidation. And if we broke the 200-day moving average, that's that 5% downside probably that Luke was referencing to. And I think that's the single biggest thing to watch here is, is that was this simply just a short-term correction that comes to the support line like back in, in during the March crash and once again in the sell-off in November? Each time the area or zone around the 200-day moving average did mark the low of, uh, for a swing low of gold, and then gold turned and rallied from there. And watching whether this, this time around acts as a support is also one of these really important moments, because either this is an extraordinary buy on dip, or there's going to be a lot of technicians that are going to have the red flag waving as 200-day moving average is broken, which for many traders is a sign the bull market may have exhausted itself and, and maybe spur on some liquidity selling in the gold.
I personally remain optimistic on gold, but it'll be— it's a very critical moment technically.
Erik Townsend: Well, and I think the thing that would get you that breakdown below the 200-day would be if we continue to see real yields, at least in the immediate term, continuing to trend higher. That's gold's biggest enemy. And it's amazing to me that people can't see the forest for the trees and recognize that it's not likely to end very long. But frankly, you know, it's fine with me if we get a big dip down to, you know, looks like this support zone bottoms out around $1,680 or so. Maybe we go even deeper than that on a break below the 200-day.
There's a chance to buy more gold as far as I'm concerned, because I know at the end of the day, or the end of the decade as the case may be, I've got Janet Yellen and Jay Powell on Team Fed and Treasury in order to make sure that the government prints enough money to debase the dollar and make that gold worth more. So, I'm just not worried about it long-term, but I could easily see if we did have this continued trend of real yields trending higher, that it could take gold lower.
Erik Townsend: In any event, Patrick, let's move on to broader commodity indices on page 7.
Patrick Ceresna: Really, uh, what I was just trying to capture here is just that this, uh, this impulse higher in oil is not the only commodity that's hot. And I know, I'm sure many traders and listeners have already been tracking them, but it's, it's a very broad commodity rally at this stage. I have here corn and soybean and copper and iron ore, but there's no shortage of these commodities that are all up, uh, and have more or less been in a pretty decisive uptrend, particularly many just beginning to accelerate in November on the upside. And, and this has been a very hot sector. There's a whole array of these commodity stocks that are just doing extraordinarily well and then just continuing to feed more and more sectors that are doing these almost parabolic rises on the upside. And this is, this is obviously feeding the, the reflation trade, you know, weak dollar, rising commodities, and kind of creating that feedback loop.
And it's really going to be interesting to see how long these trends can still continue through January.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 8, let's take a look at the 10-year Treasury yield. Boy, Patrick, we're talking about 10-year yields over 1%, as if that were a big number. Uh, it's amazing how times have changed. But as I look at what's happening here, it seems like the bottom of that green box that you have would be the logical target for maybe where this goes before it reverses.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And I mean, there's a lot of people asking that question as to, you know, how high can yields go before the stock market starts to care? And, you know, where is it that we start seeing yield curve control messaging coming from the Fed? And what I kind of look at is like, really almost all of the markets have started to return back to their post-coronavirus levels. And it's like, is it really out of line for Treasury yields to come back to 1.5%, a level they were trading at just a year ago? I mean, is that really a crisis? I still think there's plenty of room for bond yields to go without it actually causing a lot of havoc in the markets. But the one interesting thing, and I think it's the one way to perceive it, is that I think that as so long as yields are slowly crawling higher, the market won't react to it. But I think that if we continue to see very rapid jumps in yields and the rate of change of the yield starts to accelerate, I think that that would be what would make the market nervous.
And so I think it's just the way it does this rise that will be far more important than the actual level. And I think that's gonna be really interesting to see what really was triggered when this 1% was broken out over the last week.
Erik Townsend: And moving on to page 9, boy, take a look at that 2s-10s yield curve. Remember Charlie McElligott's words of fear the steepener. Looks like the steepener's coming straight on at us.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, and it doesn't seem like anyone's scared of it, is it? But I mean, we did have an inverted curve back in 2019, And really, this has now turned up. And I did a long-term chart going all the way back to the 1990s just to kind of look at the last few times we've seen the steepeners kicking in and is asking the question, have we seen the beginning of a sustained rise in the steepener? And it really does look like a legitimate roll-up and a potential beginning of a rise. And it'll be really interesting to see. I mean, If with the front of the curve being pinned at this stage, the bear steepener, even if we saw the 10-year yield getting back towards like that 1.5% that we were just talking about, I mean, we could get right back into 2011, 2013 ranges on the steepener. So it's definitely going to be really interesting to see. And it's certainly been the tailwind for a lot of securities that benefit from these wider spreads.
And so it's, uh, it's definitely the thing to watch. But what I wanted to really highlight on page 10 though is those inflation expectations, like your 30-year breakevens on it, and they're really starting to slowly break out on the upside. And I think that this is where we want to really be watching, because if we start seeing that these inflation expectations really start to spike, I think that that's What's going to make a lot of investors and traders nervous about this move?
Erik Townsend: Well, I mean, just look at it. This huge, huge downtrend in inflation expectations. It bottoms on a crisis where there's a huge stimulus expectation that could easily provide the fundamental impetus for a secular reversal of trend. And so far, the very first step to see if that's going to come true is to get to the The short-term previous peak, which was, you know, back at the beginning of 2020. We're already above that one. We're just barely flirting with the 2019 high right now. And if we break above that, the next test is the 2018 high. And if we get above that, boy, it's hard to say that we don't have a secular
Erik Townsend: trend reversal in terms of inflation expectations. And of course, inflation expectations drive inflation. Let's move on to Junk bonds on page 11. What's going on here, Patrick?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I find it really interesting that junk bonds haven't got the memo that the rest of the bond market is selling. And obviously junk bonds tend to have a strong correlation with equities, just the nature of what we've seen in the past. But what we continue to see is that Treasury bonds are selling, which is the blue line over there. And even we started to see the investment-grade corporates start to get very heavy and roll over. But the junk bond market continues to be very quiet and holding up along its highs. And I think one of the more interesting things, like when we look at the corporate bond options-adjusted credit spreads on page 12, you can see that we continue to hover both on investment grade and high yield very close to, you know, the decade lows or multi-year lows, definitely. And the question is, is that at what point do these corporate bonds start to price in some sort of risk?
And, you know, I mean, there's potentially with the continuation of this coronavirus, there, there has to be some potential risk of increased defaults on some of these periphery companies. And clearly this credit spread is not pricing in much worry at all. It's going to be really interesting to see when, when we see the junk bond market start to turn a little bit. It certainly is not showing any sign of that now.
Erik Townsend: No, it sure isn't. And it's tempting to say, okay, there's a trade there. But boy, how many times in the last few years have we looked at junk bonds and scratched our head and just said, boy, they're not pricing in the risk, but that didn't change. You don't really want to bet against it until you can see it actually start to move. Moving on to page 13, of course, you can get a free trial to Big Picture Trading and get Patrick Patrick's chartbooks, not just once
Erik Townsend: a week, but almost every single day, 4 days a week. Information is there on page 13. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. Patrick, what can they expect to find in this week's Research Roundup?
Patrick Ceresna: Today, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also an oilprice.com article on Exxon's mega oil find, and a link to the Variant Perception article on sweep elections and sector mean reversions. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all of the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend, and that's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big. BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints. Points presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Art Berman — Petroleum geologist (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 253 was recorded on January 7th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Masterworks.io, bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Regular listeners have heard me say it 100 times. If the declines in US crude oil production that Art Berman has predicted are actually realized, we could be looking at a moonshot in oil prices before 2021 is over. But where do we stand with respect to those predictions, considering the fact that Art Berman originally thought the decline would have begun by now, which it clearly hasn't, per EIA data? Petroleum geologist Art Berman returns as this week's feature interview guest to answer that question and many more. We'll discuss the coming domestic production decline, which Art Berman still predicts, when it will happen, as well as this week's OPEC.
Plus meeting and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's Chartbook addresses the question, can 2021 be even crazier than 2020?
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, we usually use this market wrap segment to cover the past week's developments in the markets and what we see on the near-term horizon, but for our first show of the year, our tradition is to take a step back and talk about the longer-term outlook for each of those 5 macro asset classes. So let's start off with the equity markets, which basically are at all-time highs in the middle of this pandemic. Erik, what, what's your thinking here on stock prices and where we're heading here in 2021?
Erik Townsend: I think we're looking at one of two possible scenarios. Number one is the possibility that we're at the late stages, that parabolic, you know, euphoria stage of a late-stage bear market where we're getting close to the final blow-off top and everything reverses and heads downhill from there. Jeremy Grantham, a very famous stock market analyst, published an article this week saying essentially that. That article is linked in your Research Roundup, so if you want that perspective of why this might be, be a very late-stage bull market coming to its end. That perspective is in the Research Roundup. The other possibility, though, and frankly, I'm starting to think it's more likely, is what Ludwig von Mises called a crack-up boom. The scenario where governments just go crazy with printing more and more money. That money has to go to someplace, and where it ends up going is into asset prices, causing everything from real estate to stocks to commodities, and eventually, The goods in the inflation basket, you know, the cost of gasoline and bread and butter and so forth, all goes up.
So the crash in that scenario comes in the form of a crash in real purchasing value of the currency. You never see a crash in nominal stock prices. And I think that may be the situation that we're in. I don't know which it is. It could be either one of those 2 scenarios. But frankly, the former is no longer my base case. I'm kind of leaning toward the latter scenario. What I can say with confidence is the market is not rallying because we've got a healthy, strong economy. Look, if we had a healthy, strong economy, short-term interest rates would be somewhere between 5% and 10%.
We have short-term interest rates somewhere between 5 and 10 basis points. That is not a healthy economy. So the question is, are we coming into the end, blow-off top kind of end of a late-cycle bull market? Or is this really just the beginning of a crack-up boom that eventually ends in a debasement of the currency and a loss of purchasing power. I'm leaning toward the latter, but hey, there's famous people like Jeremy Grantham calling for the former, so you got to consider both possibilities.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US Dollar Index because 2020 can be summarized now as about a 10% decline from the top to bottom throughout the year, and we find ourselves now trading very close to the bottom of that range. What's your thinking for the dollar here in 2021?
Erik Townsend: Well, interestingly, you said 2 different things there. You first said the dollar index, and then you said, what's your thinking for the dollar? Let's really focus on the dollar. The part that I have extreme conviction about, very strong conviction, is the US dollar will lose real purchasing value over the next several years as governments around the world continue to create more money out of thin air, debase the value of fiat currency. It's really the only viable choice at this point. We've backed ourselves into a corner where governments don't have any choice but to do that, as we discussed in our year-end special with Ronni Stoeferle and Grant Williams. So I think we're eventually getting to, you know, heading toward the, the day where a loaf of bread costs $20.
Now, the dollar index is another question entirely. That's a relative comparison of the value of the dollar to other fiat currencies. Look, don't underestimate Christine Lagarde's ability to print with reckless abandon. You know, it's not just the United States Federal Reserve that can play this game. So I don't know, I don't really have any strong conviction about the long-term, where's the dollar headed relative to other currencies, because we're in a competitive devaluation situation where other central banks are gonna be devaluing their currencies as well. The part that I have strong conviction about is the US dollar loses real purchasing value going forward. At some point, we need to get Luke Gromen back on the show because I'd love to talk to him about this distinction between the dollar versus the dollar index and which one is really headed south from here. I say it's the dollar, not necessarily the dollar index.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because we just had the OPEC meetings and we have Art Berman on the show. But what's your kind of bigger take here as the oil seems to be edging to a fresh high here?
Erik Townsend: Well, we are edging to a fresh high. And, you know, boy, we've almost completely retraced the COVID-19 sell-off. I think we're going to get to $65 to $75, and I'd say more likely $75 by the end of 2021. If, number one, Art is right about a significant decline in US production, and two, if we stay on present course and speed approximately in terms of recovering from the pandemic. In other words, if the vaccines mostly work, I think there's very clear we're going to have some mutations and some complications and so forth. But if we continue to see progress being made toward reopening the economy, eventually getting global air travel, you know, flying again by the end of the year, I think you see at least $75 on WTI front-month futures before the year is out. Certainly, if you had a major complication in the pandemic and everything was shut down again, that could change it. And likewise, if Art is wrong about the production decline, that would change my outlook as well.
The thing is, we're always already overdue for a technical pullback of some kind. I was targeting $52 to $55 as high as I thought we could possibly go on this move before there was a significant pullback of $8 to $10. Well, we're already almost at $52 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon. So, you know, we're really pushing it. But I think what's coming in terms of a pullback will be fairly short-lived because as much as I do think there's going to be some mutation complications for the virus, I also think that the Reflation dynamic is gonna be more important than just normal supply and demand inputs to oil prices. And I think ultimately prices of all commodities, including oil, are headed much higher. We'll save the rest of the fundamentals for Art, but I wanna quickly just cover inventory because we're not gonna discuss that with Art. Crude oil drawing down 8 million barrels. That's a really big drawdown. Of course, normally that big 8 million barrel drawdown would be a super bullish signal for prices.
The thing is, it was offset by really big builds in finished products. Gasoline building 4.5 million barrels, distillates building 6.4 million barrels. So between them, more than 10 million barrels of finished product builds offsetting 8 million barrels of drawdown on crude oil. Cushing, Oklahoma building 792,000 barrels. Overall, that still led to higher prices despite the big finished product builds. And the rally really looks like it just wants to continue indefinitely. I don't think it can continue indefinitely. We've come up so far, so fast. I would expect that this runs out of steam somewhere between $52 and $55.
And at that point, I think we're due for a technical correction of $8 to $10, but probably not for long. And eventually we start pushing north towards $65, but not until we start to see the beginnings of this production decline that Art has talked about. And let's save the rest of the discussion about where that's headed for the feature interview with Art Berman.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold started the year in a very strong bull impulse, but really the last half of the year, we saw gold giving back a chunk of its gains and consolidating. And then here at the start of the year, it looks like we got a fresh breakout up until yesterday. And the question is, is this a breakout for real? What's your take on gold in the much bigger picture and what's in store for us in 2021?
Erik Townsend: Well, in the much bigger picture, I think we get to a minimum of $5,000 per ounce on gold before 2030. And that sounds like a really big number, but really, that number of years on an annual percentage basis, that's not that big of a number. I think we do get at least that high by 2030. And I would say probably we get to $2,300 on the current run sometime in 2021. Then there's a cyclical pullback. Of course, there normally always is. I still think that Bitcoin is taking scarcity trade market share away from gold. Now, at some point last year, I think we were actually seeing significant downward price pressure. Price of gold goes down substantially because Bitcoin is stealing the market share. That seems to have played out fully. At this point, I think what's going on is the rally that should be occurring in gold because of all the stimulus expectations is being suppressed.
Gold is rallying, but only a little bit, as Bitcoin skyrockets, as more and more younger investors are turning to Bitcoin as their favored scarcity asset rather than gold. Now I predicted here on MacroVoices before the holiday that if Bitcoin broke out past its previous all-time highs, I thought it was a setup for it to accelerate very quickly to the upside. Well, it's up more than 100% since I said that less than a month ago, so I guess that call was right. I think Bitcoin eventually is headed toward a blow-off top just like 2017, where it just goes crazy up until eventually. Eventually it runs out of steam and then it goes crazy down, down hard. But that probably doesn't happen until much higher numbers. Could that number be $100,000? Sure, anything's possible. When it eventually blows off, that would probably be a catalyst. Once it's clear that it really was a blow-off top and Bitcoin prices are collapsing, that's the point where I think it becomes a catalyst to push gold very quickly up to what might become a cyclical high.
Let's say up to $2,300 or whatever the number is.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Is there then another cycle, like a seesaw between gold and Bitcoin, where gold continues to really go up as Bitcoin crashes from that blow-off top, and that sets up another cycle where eventually gold's rally is suppressed as Bitcoin starts another leg higher? I'm not sure, but it certainly seems like so far that's kind of been the pattern that we're seeing. We'll do a show on Bitcoin and where it's headed at some point this month in January.
You know, the momentum has been huge here, and there definitely was an An asymmetric trade entry opportunity on that breakout from the previous all-time high for people who are good at momentum trading. Now, I don't for an instant believe that it's because there's any real intrinsic value to Bitcoin. It's the same kind of mania that you saw in the South Seas bubble or that you saw in the late '90s tech stock bubble. But the momentum is there, and if you know how to play it, you can certainly make money on it.
The thing is, we're already up 100% from when we talked about that setup last month. So it's a little bit late for that entry. But there'll be more entries. And even though that one is no longer ripe, I do think eventually there's probably more upside in Bitcoin before this crazy mania blows off. And I do think it's a crazy mania, very, very similar to the late '90s dot-com boom. But frankly, if you go back to that late '90s dot-com boom, what needed to be understood that for some reason Wall Street guys just couldn't understand was pretty darn simple stuff. E-commerce and websites were gonna be a major part of the future, but no, that didn't happen.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: didn't mean that Pets.com was a good idea. They couldn't seem to distinguish, and they would just pay through the nose for anything with .com in its name.
Frankly, really understanding the coming digital currency revolution and the reasons that Bitcoin is not likely to be the ultimate winner in the contest for the dominant digital currency system, something I wrote a book about back in 2018, that's much more complex. So it stands to reason, if they couldn't understand fairly simple stuff, back in the late '90s, it's going to be an even longer amount of time before they come to understand more complex subjects like what's going to happen with digital currency. So it's going to be a really interesting ride. We'll do a show about it this, this month. But I think that if you're playing this, understand that it's a speculative mania. And as long as you understand that you're making a momentum trade and it's eventually going to reverse and go the other way, hey, if you can make money on it, that's great.
Just remember, anything that can go up 100% in a month can go down 50% in a month just as easily.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's wrap things up here with talking about that 10-year Treasury yield. Obviously, bonds have been very quiet for a while, but we are getting a little bit of action. I wanna talk about it in the postgame a little bit, but what's your bigger picture outlook here on the 10-year yield?
Erik Townsend: You know, honestly, I think the big picture is from a trader's perspective, there really is no tradable picture that I see. Interest rates are already super duper low, so there's no trade to be had by betting on them moving lower. They can't frankly be allowed to rise very much because it would cripple the economy and bankrupt the US government. So I don't think there's any big trade to be made on betting that they go substantially higher either.
You know, the fact of the matter is we're at a moment in history just this week where the big news being discussed in the financial media is that the 10-year Treasury has moved up to this massively large number of 1%. You know, just a few years ago, people would laugh at you if you said it was possible for it to ever go as low as 1%. Now we're talking about that as if it's a big number.
I think we're stuck with super low yields for many years to come. So if you want to say what's the trading opportunity, I don't think it's on a move in yields directly. I think it's rather what are the second-order derivative effects of being stuck at low yields? It's inflation or stagflation. What does that mean? You know, it probably means commodity prices are set to rise very dramatically. You know, that's where the trades are. It's not in the 10-year yield itself.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is petroleum geologist Art Berman. Now, Erik, why did we get Art back on the show to start the year?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as our regular listeners know, I have been very interested in Art's forecast of a very sharp decline in US production. Originally, Art thought that was going to have happened last quarter. He told us at the beginning of last quarter that it might get pushed out into Q1. I want to see where Art stands and whether he still holds that view, because if he's right about that, where we've already got a lot of macroeconomic effects that are pressing all commodity prices, including oil, higher, if we really get into a major decline in US production, that could create a moonshot scenario by the end of the year for oil prices. So I'm really anxious to get an update on this from Art.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Art Berman is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. My interview with Logica Funds CIO Mike Green last Saturday is getting rave reviews, so be sure to check it out on Smarter Markets if you haven't yet. MacroVoices listeners remember Kyle Bass telling us just before the holiday that Singapore is heir apparent as the new Asian financial center. So this coming weekend, my guest on Smarter Markets will be Frank Lavin, former US Ambassador to Singapore. We'll take a deep dive on the country's history, its suitability to replace Hong Kong as Asia's primary financial center, and Frank's assessment of MAS, the Singaporean equivalent of the SEC.
But you won't get Smarter Markets episodes on your MacroVoices feed. You have to subscribe separately to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to receive this exciting free podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is petroleum geologist Art Berman. For anyone who doesn't know, Art is famous for his graphs and charts, so you're You're going to want to be sure to download the chart deck that accompanies today's interview. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, look for the red button above Art's picture that says, looking for the downloads.
Art, our regular listeners know that I'm dying to ask you about the production decline that you have been predicting, but before we even get to that, I want to start with And I want to start with this week's OPEC+ meeting, when Saudi Arabia surprised a lot of people by essentially resolving a deadlock where they couldn't agree on what to do about production cuts. And Saudi Arabia kind of volunteered to go it alone and unilaterally cut on their side in order to allow other OPEC+ countries not to have to cut.
What's going on there? What do you make of this? What brought that about? And what do you make of this meeting in general?
Art Berman: Well, I think it's a very interesting Erik, of course, I'm speculating, but my sense of this is that we're looking at classic game theory, that OPEC+ has been trying to manage the world's largest commodity, the world's largest traded commodity now for pretty nearly 5 years, and that just can't be done. And so they've reached a point now where Russia doesn't really feel like doing this much anymore. And honestly, I don't think Saudi Arabia does either, but they tried a different path back in March with catastrophic results. And so that's not really where they want to go. So the, you know, what the prisoner's dilemma says is that as long as nobody changes their stratagem, we just continue doing whatever we were doing. And I think Saudi Arabia is now saying, okay, we're in control here and this is what we're doing. And, uh, they're, they're basically saying we can't afford another catastrophe and we're tired of cajoling. Last time around we threatened you guys, uh, with, you know, flooding the market, and this time around we're saying, you know, give it a break.
Well, we've got this under control, and after all Saudi Arabia has been the— they've really been OPEC all along. So leading into where you and I want to go with this conversation, the real question is, is it necessary? And there's no question that the prime motivation is that Saudi Arabia and many others see demand for oil as being lower, perhaps much lower than expected just a month ago or so.
And so they're kind of taking preventative preemptive action right now to cut supply, where I think— I mean, I'm certainly happy that they're doing that if they want to, although it hasn't worked very well for the last 4 or 5 years. But I also believe that they're, they're probably following EIA's forecast for US production, and I'm I'm more painfully aware than almost anyone of, you know, how wrong even my forecasts can be. So, uh, not saying anything about it, but if EIA says that US is going to produce 11 million barrels a day for the rest of '21 and it's only 10, well, maybe Saudi Arabia didn't need to do what it did. That's, you know, that's kind of where I'll leave it for now.
Erik Townsend: I see this as very significant, Art, because a lot of Western analysts who frankly have been second-guessing all along— we don't really know what the, the I don't know what the mindset of the Saudis has been, but a lot of people were saying, look, what's gonna happen here is the Saudis are not gonna let oil prices get back up to the level where you could have a restart of the US shale boom. They don't want oil prices to recover back to $75, 'cause then US shale would take off again. It seems like they're not worried about that. So what I'm trying to figure out is, is that because Saudi Arabia is no longer concerned not wanting to see the US shale industry recover and, and, you know, become its former self? Or is it more the case that they've decided that the US shale industry is so badly damaged that it can't recover even if they do allow prices to recover substantially, let's say back up to $60 or $70?
What do you make of this in terms of what it means for the US shale industry's ability to recover or maybe not have the big decline in production that you and other people have predicted?
Art Berman: That's a great observation, Erik. And obviously, we don't know, but a couple of things come to mind. The first is that whatever happens or doesn't happen to the US shale industry, the price of oil, the amount of capital available to the US shale industry, that's all Way into the future.
If you know, if tomorrow everybody in the shale industry decided okay, we're gonna we're gonna hire as many rigs as possible, it wouldn't make any difference to production for pretty nearly a year. So surely Saudi Arabia understands that. The second thing though, I guess that is the maybe the more the more salient factor is that without other people's money. Nothing's going to happen. And certainly the overwhelming sentiment in world markets is that oil is pretty nearly uninvestable, to use somebody's terrible, terrible phrase.
But I mean, the money has clearly fled far away from E&P and particularly US shale. And so perhaps the Saudis are saying, Geez, you know, I mean, even if price gets to $60 or higher, there's so much inertia or negative momentum by investors that the money is just not going to flow back to the shale players anywhere near quick enough to make a difference. What do you think about that?
Erik Townsend: Well, Art, the thing that strikes me is that we're seeing so much easy money policy and So much continued printing of money that on one hand, I agree with you that, you know, oil is kind of out now. And also there's an extra headwind, which is not only is it kind of out because it's hard to make money on that, but it's also very much out from an ESG perspective. A lot of people think that investing in fossil fuels is irresponsible if you're a responsible ESG investor.
Art Berman: Right.
Erik Townsend: I don't agree with that mentality, but a lot of people feel that way, and that's going to hurt the amount of capital that's available. The other side of that argument, though, is there's a heck of a lot of capital that's going to be available for a heck of a lot of things as we get into this MMT world with central banks just printing money like it's going out of style.
So I don't know how to reconcile that one, but the one thing that this OPEC meeting definitely speaks volumes to me is The Saudis aren't worried about it. They're not concerned about allowing the price to come up to a level where it could allow the US shale industry to recover. Maybe that's because they think it can't recover. Maybe it's because they don't care if it does recover. I'm not sure which, but it's clear to me that they're not concerned about it.
Erik Townsend: Why don't we go ahead and jump into your slide deck? Starting on page 2, you're talking about the expected decline in in demand, which you believe is maybe the reason that Saudi Arabia took this action in this week's meeting.
Art Berman: So let me say, first of all, that analysts, journalists, producers are just absolutely obsessed with demand. And frankly, while I appreciate that, I honestly don't understand it because oil markets don't run on demand. They run on supply. And there's a simple reason for that, and that is that that markets can't do anything about demand, but they sure can about supply by changing the price. And so my perspective after looking at these things for for a few decades is that as long as supply adjusts to demand, demand is not the problem. The bigger problem is when demand, which moves very slowly, increases and supply lags behind it as much as it does in the modern world, then you end up with a, with a supply shortage.
But in any event, this slide number 2 shows OPEC's supply and demand forecast— demand in orange, supply in green, and then the supply-demand deficit below it in either blue for positive and red for negative. And what it shows is that the supply-demand balance going into 2021 was not too bad. It's about balanced, but it increases to 1.38 or so by the 3rd quarter. And so you'd say, well, you know, that's not too much. Well, that's certainly enough to, uh, to put things in, into, into pretty bad money territory.
Now I think what they're doing is they're saying, wow, we, we were, you know, really probably overly aggressive on the demand side. And, and instead of believing that we're going to have You know, 95 or 94 million barrels per day of demand in the first half of 2021. Geez, we're thinking now it's probably going to be more like 91 or 92.
And so that changes everything. That says that your supply-demand balance, instead of being 1.3 or 1.4, is now going to be 2.5 or 3, which is about what it was when oil prices collapsed way back in 2014, '15.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Art Berman: So, that's my sense. I haven't worked out those numbers precisely, but you get the general direction of them.
Erik Townsend: Art, let's move on to slide 3. Longtime listeners immediately recognize this chart as the comparative inventory yield curve. Just for the benefit of any new listeners we may have, if you don't know about this comparative inventory system, which is kind of Art's trademark, be sure to go back to some of Art's earliest interviews on MacroVoices. Just put Art Berman in the search box at MacroVoices.com, and this system of comparative inventory analysis is explained fully in some of those early interviews. What do we see in the comparative inventory yield curve here on page 3?
Art Berman: Erik, what we see is that everything is behaving just exactly as it should. It's behaving as I forecast that it would way back in April or May when WTI. Weekly price was, you know, $5 or so. I'm showing $3.32 was the lowest that it got for the week in late April. But way back when, I had pretty much the same green yield curve drawn in here, and I was saying, you know, at these levels of surplus, I think WTI is going to work its way back up to, you know, $41 or $42 or $43. And that's pretty much exactly what it did. It dropped down a bit Sort of you know about halfway through there, the green dots or the green circles are what we're following. Sort of under underpriced for a while because of concerns about COVID over near where it says January first to the right of that started climbing back up just about as soon as vaccines were announced and made its way back to the yield curve a couple of weeks ago.
And the yellow dot is from today. I see I've got a an extra digit in forty seven. 48, but you know that's this. I think y'all you understand that we're plotting right exactly where it should be. So the implications of this are that all things being equal, prices aren't going to get to $60. That we're going to draw down stocks in the world as we have been now for months and months and months. And at the five-year average, which is the y-axis, will you know be at about 49 or you know $50 WTI.
Now, the other thing that I have to say though is, yeah, but what about excursions? I mean, we've just been on the biggest yield curve excursion in the history of man. And so that works the other way too. And there are examples circled on this graph that show precisely that. So the more concern the market has about supply, the higher above or the larger the excursion above the yield curve we might get. So if oil price goes to $55 or $60, somebody's sure to say, Oh, Art, you were wrong. And I said, well, no, that's, that's what price discovery is about. That's, that's the way the market works. So the message from this chart, Erik, is everything is A-okay. It's just exactly as it should be.
Erik Townsend: Well, it's exactly as it should be now, but let's talk about where it's headed and move on to slide 4, because what I think about is you've been talking about a very significant decline in US oil production, which hasn't started yet. But if that is to occur the way that you've projected, presumably that means instead of this great big huge oversupply, we're going to have negative comparative inventory at some point. So is that on the radar? And if so, how far out is it? And what is that going to mean?
Art Berman: Absolutely. And it's not very far out at all. So this, this, this graph in slide number 4 is US comparative inventory. And I will anticipate All of the smart people, many of them not from the United States, that say, "Oh well, that's a very parochial thing to look at." And I do look at you know at OECD and everything else too. But my experience is is that U.S. storage reporting has the highest frequency. It's weekly as opposed to monthly, and it's got the most accuracy for whatever reason, and it's a darn good proxy. So if If you know, if if anybody's worried that that U.S. comparative inventory is somehow skewed from world comparative inventory, it hasn't happened so far. So leave it there. But looking at this graph, what it says to me is that the at the current decline rate in comparative inventory, which is now pretty nearly five million barrels per week, we will be at the five-year average. In a matter of six weeks, now you know that changes a little each week as we get a bigger draw or a bigger add.
But it's been marching in that direction ever since mid-July. And back to your original comment, we don't have a great big oversupply right now—not in the United States and and not in the world.
We are fast approaching the five-year average. We're only thirty million barrels above it as of today. We were five times that. a couple of months ago in mid-June. So will we get there barring some, you know, totally external event that I can't predict? Absolutely. Will we get into negative comparative inventory? I don't see how it's possible we won't.
Erik Townsend: Now, I want to ask a question about what this reflects, because as I understand it, this positive comparative inventory that we're showing here, this has to do with the reported numbers coming out of EIA inventory reports, which does not include floating storage. The, the, during the crisis when there was no storage available, a bunch of people were chartering tanker ships and filling them up with oil and using them as great big floating gas tanks. Has that oil been delivered back into the market, or do we have, you know, a stealth oversupply that doesn't show up in these charts, but there's actually still a bunch of ships that are full of oil someplace?
Art Berman: Right. Well, so the, the way that this works, and, and, and it's a really excellent question, and nobody really knows the answer to it, but the way that all this works is, is that it starts with production. Okay, so, so this is storage, but EIA has a very good, I believe, understanding of how much oil is produced, and that comes from the states.
And they have a very good understanding of it because they get tax revenues from it. So it may not be 100% accurate this week, or you know, might take might take several weeks or even a few months to get it all properly balanced. But but they want their tax money, so they're going to get it right.
And so there's there's production, which we know there's. Oil that flows into the pipes, which we know— I mean, as far as I know, nobody is able to go from the wellhead to an offshore, an offshore tanker. They've got to put it in a pipe. They've got to send it somewhere, whether that be to Cushing, Oklahoma, or to the coast to put on a tanker. And so we know what's produced and we know its disposition.
Okay, we know how much goes into the flow, and then we know how much ends up in official storage. And so the the numbers are are are massaged a little bit to include all of that, and that's where we get this thing called unaccounted for oil.
Unaccounted for oil is oil that EIA knows to be there because it was produced, but it hasn't shown up in the flow. So the answer to your question is, if that floating storage originated from a well in the United States, it is accounted for whether or not it shows up in the storage number or not. It is known. And so my sense is that I'm not disputing that it's there. I'm just saying that it wasn't a big factor as far as I can tell back in 2015, '16, '17. It has not been a big factor yet. So I'm not losing sleep over it. I acknowledge it, but I don't know.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 5, you're moving now into US consumption recovery. And, you know, this is something I think about a lot because it seems to me that on one hand, even though there might be more mutations of the virus and more complications and, and more issues with the pandemic, it seems that society has become extremely intolerant of lockdowns. And, and if we have more lockdowns, they'll be minimum in duration, and we'll continue to operate as much of the economy as we can despite the situation with the virus. So in many ways, it feels to me like we're gonna, you know, get back to normal consumption. But I do think international air travel will probably stay very, very subdued for a while to come. How much of the consumption does aviation fuel account for? And, you know, if we have everything come back except for aviation, what would that look like in terms of a recovery for demand?
Art Berman: Right. It's roughly 6%. Okay. So, if the world produces or produced 100 million barrels a day, 6 million of that is for air travel. So, it's a significant number for sure. But it's not that big of a percentage, and especially within the context of the kind of reductions that we've seen. And so if you look at the graph in slide number 5 and you look at kerosene jet, which is the second 3 columns toward the right, you see that its recovery is 57%.
And for background, that number until just a few weeks ago was half that. So the recovery was, you know, actually for a while it was below 20%. It, you know, it rattled around 20-25 for a while. And so contrary to the public belief or opinion, I see this number coming up just about every week. 57% is terrible compared to 100, but it's It's more than double what it was not very many weeks ago. So based on consumption, based on what comes out of US refineries, I see kerosene jet recovering.
It'll lag behind everything else.
The one that I worry about more than anything else is gasoline. And I would've thought many, many months ago when, you know, you and I first started talking about COVID and what its effect on demand might be, I would've thought that gasoline would be the first to come back. You know, people get really tired of sitting around at home and they're going to go out and drive their cars even if they got nowhere to go.
And at first that, that seemed to be what was happening. But what I've seen now since, oh, you know, 2, 3 months ago, gasoline consumption recovered to about 84, 85% of— and when I say recovery, I mean between the minimum and the 5-year average. We can talk about that a little bit more later if you like, but that's the way I define recovery. And so what I've seen though is it's actually been dropping or it's staying below the maximum that it reached.
And so to me, in the past, I always used to say, oh, well, diesel is the, you know, that's the real barometer of the US economy. And the way this crazy pandemic has worked, I guess we're all ordering so many packages from Amazon and you name it that, I mean, diesel is 134% of recovery right now. So it's above the 5-year average and it's been higher in recent weeks with the holidays and whatnot. So if gasoline remains stalled at, let's just say, 80%, that's telling me something about US mobility, that it just isn't what it was for whatever reason.
And that is a huge volume. I mean, that is, you know, gasoline is like, you know, 40% of the barrel. So it's, you know, it's a big number.
Erik Townsend: Now, it's hard to put any hard numbers in this, Art, but it seems to me like a trend that a lot of people are talking about is, hey, we've learned how to work from home with this pandemic. And, you know, we don't need to go back to work. We can save money on office space. So clearly, the gasoline has to do with personal vehicle transportation. So does it ever go back to 100%? Or do we decide not to drive to work as much because we can work from home?
Art Berman: No one knows. But I can't imagine that we're ever going to all go back to the way we were, because we found that it's, it's not necessary. And more importantly, the The companies that most people work for, why should they spend so much money on commercial office space when they only need half of it or a third of it?
The other factor, though, Erik, is gasoline is the most elastic of all of these numbers. That we're really seeing in gasoline consumption a reflection of discretionary spending. There are just limits to how how much the economy could function without something like like diesel or or propane or some of the others on there. But gasoline is something where if an American family is hurting, you know hasn't worked for a while or is only working part time, even though gasoline prices are dirt cheap right now, that's a place where they can conserve. So I think there's some kind of a balance. I think that so many of the analysts and journalists who look at these things are reasonably well off. I mean, they at least have jobs, and they tend to forget that there are 30, 40 million Americans who just don't have enough money to put food on the table regularly, and they're going to watch their spending.
And if they don't need to drive somewhere, they won't.
Erik Townsend: Art, let's move on to the headline event. When we had you on the show back last June, you first told us that you were predicting that probably by the end of 2020, we'd be seeing the beginning of a decline in US production. And it was, since you anticipated that might begin in Q4, it was no coincidence that it was the very first day of Q4.
Art Berman: That's right.
Erik Townsend: Q4 that we had you back on. And at that point you said still have the same outlook, but it probably will slip into Q1 of 2021. It is no accident that you're back on MacroVoices on the very first show of 2021. Is the outlook still the same? Does it start in Q1? What kind of decline? Because I— boy, I saw some Twitter interactions between you and people that were talking about 5.5 million barrels. That would be half of what we're producing now. That seems possible to me. So what is the prediction? And is it still on? And when does it happen?
Art Berman: Well, it's happening right now, Erik. You know, we'll move on and look at the slides. But everybody thinks that the US is producing 11 or 11.3 million barrels a day, because that's what EIA says in their STEO, their Short-Term Energy Outlook reports. You know, I caution people that that's an estimate. It's an estimate based on God knows what, but mostly a survey of producers.
And every month when they issue their, their 9/14 numbers, which are the gold standard, and it's also lagged back a few months, it's always much lower. So they just released the October numbers and they're barely above 10 million barrels a day. So we're talking about a decline from the beginning of the year or the end of last year of almost 3 million barrels a day. That's a, it's a pretty healthy decline. And then, so slide 6, Erik, I've— my experiment, my thought experiment, my forecast was wrong. It wasn't notionally wrong. The timing of it was premature.
And the main thing that I guess I didn't expect was there were a lot of wells that were shut in in April, May, June of 2020. I did not anticipate that they would be reactivated as quickly as they were, nor as many as they were. It was wrong because I based it exclusively on tight oil decline and just used a ratio to extrapolate to US production.
And in retrospect, I tied it too rigorously to the rig count decline, which up until this time had worked just perfectly fine, but obviously it didn't going forward. So what I've done differently, which probably I should have done to begin with, hindsight, is I've used all the wells from the 4 states in the Gulf of Mexico that account for 80% of US production.
I've carefully calibrated what production decline would be if we drilled no wells, looked at all the number of producing wells. The rig count and the drilled uncompleted wells. And the conclusion is that the output decline has begun, but the serious decline will probably not begin until the late, late in the first quarter or early in the second quarter.
The answer, the conclusion is I've got 3 cases that I'll show you, and those suggest that we could reach below 8 million barrels a day. It dip a little bit below 10. Most likely is it'll be somewhere in between.
Erik Townsend: Art, let's move on to slide 7 where we can see this graphically. What's going on here?
Art Berman: Erik, slide 7 is the, the orange line is exactly what I showed you the last time in, uh, I think it was early October, late September. I've taken off the, the rig count because I can't I can't fit the scales on with it, but that production curve is exactly what it was then. And what I'm showing in blue is the time-shifted US production rate. So we're looking at, you know, one is tight oil, the other is US. And what you can see is that up to the present, which is the end of the blue line, the correlation is actually quite good. What you also see is that the divergence between the, the tight oil and the US production has increased. And that's, that's, that's part of the reason that, that the forecast was wrong. So that's, you know, just to be fair and honest, you know, that's, that's where we were.
This is where we are. But if we move on then to slide 8, this is the full picture. And so slide 8, I'm showing the time-shifted US oil-directed rig count in blue, and I'm showing production to date up to where it says October 2020. That's the 914 number that I mentioned.
And then beyond that are a series of dashed lines. The red is EIA's forecast, which says that we'll be at about 11 million barrels a day forever with no significant increases or decreases. The next one down is the green. That's the high case of my scenarios where we'll get below— we'll stay about where we are, maybe go up a little bit and then go down below 10 million barrels and climb back to 10.5 by the end of the year.
The base case, I think the most likely case, is we drop down to about 9 And the low case, which is, you know, was one of the numbers in the last time around, I still think that's— I say it's not the most likely, but my gut tells me it is, that we'll get below 8 million barrels a day. So that's the answer as I see it right now.
Erik Townsend: Let's translate this picture into what it means in terms of OPEC's ability to compensate. You get to some level and it's like, hey, it doesn't matter what OPEC does. They can turn the screws up as high as they want. They still can't make enough oil to make up for the deficit. And we got a real problem. But frankly, until you get to that point, there's probably, you know, for a smaller deficit, it's just, hey, a chance for OPEC to make a little more money. It doesn't really change the supply-demand dynamics that much because they can easily turn up the screws. Where do we get to a sensitivity where it really puts price pressure on because OPEC can't just make up for whatever the US is not producing?
Art Berman: So there's really 2 answers in your single question. The first is just based on pure supply and demand. And the answer to that is, I think, as you stated, that if we go down to 10 million, round numbers, from 11 million, well, that's what OPEC just said You know, last night that they're going to cut. So obviously that's there right now. That doesn't last forever, but certainly neither does U.S. production decline, at least according to this view. This view says that I mean the rig count is already increased down at the bottom from 178 to 234. I mean that's that's in the books; that's not changing.
And so as far as this graph goes. Short of needing to shut hundreds or thousands of wells in again for reasons of inadequate storage or, you know, disastrously low prices, production will, you know, will reach a bottom and it will have to go back up some.
So in the high-case scenario, I don't think it's a big deal. In the base-case scenario, it's, you know, basically another 3/4 of a million barrels a day, which is a bigger deal. But I also believe that OPEC+ has the spare capacity to, to cover that. Uh, the low case, you know, now we're getting into some dicey territory. But I think more important is the market perception.
And when I was back on, on the slide, slide number 3, looking at comparative inventory, I spoke about the way that markets use price as a lever to encourage more drilling. And oftentimes They will— markets will increase price even though there's no imminent supply crunch in the near term, because markets know that with the rig counts being what they are, that the price has to be higher to encourage more drilling.
And so my sense, Erik, is that— and I wasn't equivocating— but once US production disappoints the forecast, I think you're going to see price go up pretty aggressively, or the pressure for price to go up, because that's not what the market's expecting.
Erik Townsend: Now, I agree with that very much, and that's kind of my personal base case, is I think the market's going to be surprised and that much higher prices are likely before 2021 is out. But let me take the opposite side of this and kind of do my journalist job here of playing devil's advocate. Look at how substantially that rig count has turned up. And remember, this is a 13-month lag. So that's going from September to October of '20, not '21, where, where that actual uptick in the rig count occurred. And hey, I mean, you know, sure, money's a little bit tight these days, but frankly, there's lots of money being printed. What's to say that this rig count doesn't go back up to 900 in the next 3 months? Right.
Art Berman: Because it can't. It just—it doesn't happen that quickly. I mean, if you believe, if you believe EIA, it went down that quickly. Oh well, it's real easy to let a rig go. You know, you've already got the rig on contract. It's not that easy to to get one back again, particularly when they're stacked, which is where they are right now. So there's there's the there's the physical equipment. Of the of the rig, which is stacked, and then there's the crews.
You know, these rigs don't run by themselves. I mean, they are far more automated than they were five or ten years ago, but you still need you know several dozen people to actually make it happen. And and the the quality of those people is another issue. I I drilled a well with you know with my my company and partner back in. 2015, late 2015, early 2016. And we had to run off 2 or 3 of the crews because they just, they weren't any good. They were, I mean, the companies were going out and hiring people who were getting out of prison, for crying out loud, because at least those guys could pass a drug test. They couldn't drill a well worth, you know, worth anything.
So, so there are some substantial lags involved in just getting the rigs out there. And then you've got the frac crews and, you know, all the, all the support, the mud, the, you know, I mean, everything else you've got to have, you know, you got to be able to bulldoze a location, you got to permit a well. I mean, there's a myriad of things. But, but EIA says that the lag between a price signal and a rig on location is 4 months. And frankly, I think that's kind of a long time. But that's what they say. All right. And I'm not endorsing their perspective, but it gives you some idea. Is it 4 months? I don't know. I mean, I think I could get a rig in 2 months. I don't think I could get it faster.
Erik Townsend: Well, let's pretend that you and I are wrong about an inadequacy of investment capital to support this. Let's suppose they can find the money. How quickly could the industry recover the rig count right back up to what's necessary to get us back to, you know, know, 12 million barrels and, you know, go up from here instead of down.
Art Berman: Right. Well, remember, this is happening— I mean, the production behind it is now out in 2022, right? Okay. I mean, this, this, this graph ends in December 2021. So the, the rig count that we have today, the monthly rig count for November of 234 oil-directed rig count, that's already in the books. And we won't see that production until sometime towards the end of this, this year we're in now. So the lag is what's important, Erik, that you can do all kinds of things. You can get, you know, the government can just say, okay, from now on, the Fed is making available infinite money to the oil and gas industry.
Erik Townsend: So, so, so we can see a recovery of US production in 2022, but it's impossible in 2021. Is basically what you're saying.
Art Berman: It's impossible beyond what I show on this graph.
Erik Townsend: Okay, so we're looking at production has to come down some. It's a question of how much. Even the EIA says— now, why does EIA say it only comes down, what do they say, 100,000 barrels or something? Uh, why do they have a flat line here?
Art Berman: That's a really great question, and you should— maybe we should ask them. Um, but I have I mean, I respect EIA. I'm not into EIA bashing. None of this that we're talking about, we couldn't have this conversation if it weren't for EIA. They provide me with all this information. However, I don't think there is one geologist or geophysicist who works at EIA.
I doubt there's a drilling or completion engineer. These are mostly economists and accountants. None of these guys— and I, I'm gonna be generous here and say I don't know that there's none, but I'm betting that none of these guys has ever drilled a well or been involved with drilling a well.
And so they just don't have any idea how this works. And, and we can argue about why, or should they, and, and frankly, that's, that's irrelevant. They don't. And so what they is that it takes 2 months from a rig-on location to first oil production.
And so a lot of what they're, what they're doing here is based on that assumption. Now, I've got data that I'll show you a little bit later in this, in these slides. Maybe we can go to that now, which shows that that is patently untrue. I mean, it's not my opinion. That's what the numbers tell you.
The numbers say that the average time between starting to drill a well and first oil production is 5 months. That's the weighted average for the United States. So EIA thinking it's 2 months is way, way short of what it ought to be just based on data. And I think they're completely delusional Or just, they just don't know in terms of how long does it take once you've got oil coming out of the ground to begin to offset the horrendous declines that are already in progress before you even, you know, staunch the flow and get back to zero. And when you add that in, that's where you get to the 13-month shift.
Erik Townsend: Art, since you teased the audience, let's jump ahead for a minute to slide 11. And visually look at the lag that exists between getting the rig on site and actually producing and selling oil out of that well.
Art Berman: Slide 11 has a lot of information on it, and let me start with the answer to your question. If you look at the table in the lower left-hand corner of, of the slide, I have taken these 4 states and the offshore Gulf of Mexico, which account for 80% of US oil production, And I have used data from Enverus, which comes from the States, as to how many days it takes from beginning of drilling a well to first oil. And I show New Mexico, Oklahoma, North Dakota, Federal Offshore Gulf, and Texas. I show the number of barrels in 2019 and the average days. And at the very bottom where it says weighted average well start to first oil, it's 140 days. That's the average, the weighted average by production for the United States.
Erik Townsend: So, and EIA says the number is 60?
Art Berman: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Okay, I guess they're wrong.
Art Berman: Well, they're wrong, as you know. Yeah, they're wrong in my experience. And honestly, Erik, I mean, again, I'm not, I'm not criticizing them. The only reason I did this was because I said, wait a minute, that's impossible. I mean, all the things that have to happen from the time you start drilling a well until you get it down.
If you're really, really lucky, you know, maybe the average time to get a well down is 30 days. Everything goes perfectly. You've got to log it. You've got to test it. You've got to take the location— the rig off. You got to put a new one on. You got to put pipe in the hole. You have to cement it. You have to wait for the cement to dry. You have to perforate it. You have to frack it. You have to flow the water back. You have to flow test it. You've got to do a whole bunch of stuff. You got to get the state out there to witness the test, and then you gotta build a pipeline to get it to the nearest pipeline.
If you can do all that in 30 days, I mean, you are smoking, man. I mean, I just— it's just, you know, I've talked to a lot of people about about this who have done what I have done, and everybody says that's just nuts. You might be able to do it for one well, but you can't— that's not an average number, not even close.
Erik Townsend: Art, I want to come back and talk about the decline rates also on this chart, but first let's jump back to where we were. So as we look again at slide 8, it makes perfect sense what you're saying. Why could EIA have that flat line where you've got those big dips? Well, obviously, if they're not taking real-world world lag times into account in terms of how long it takes to start producing oil after you drill the hole in the ground, obviously, it's going to throw their numbers off. So, this makes perfect sense. We see your numbers. Let's move on to slide 9. What does this chart show us?
Art Berman: Well, slide 9 is, again, sort of a calibration. This just shows starkly, this is the 9/14 data. It shows you we are down 2.3 million barrels a day from March. That's the latest data. And this shows you what EIA thinks. EIA thinks that we're not even going to get down again to the level that we were in October.
And if you believe anything that I just showed you, you've got to shake your head and say, no, I don't think so. So that's all that's in this slide.
Slide 10 simply shows where the decline in production is coming from. And what you see here is that the biggest, the biggest declines in absolute numbers, maybe not surprisingly, are the Gulf of Mexico and Texas, where between the two of those we've lost 2 million barrels a day.
Moving back to slide 11, I didn't talk about the actual decline rates, which I will just for a second. In the, the top center graph, this is actually showing for each one of those 5 areas and the rest of the United States what the rate of decline is, and it is a breathtaking 42% per year annual decline rate. That shocked me, Erik. I didn't believe that. That is, that is such a big number.
If we go on to slide 12, this is the kind of chart you see in, you know, Enno Peters and, you know, and Rystad and all these kind of guys where, where they're going to show you the, you know, the every year's production decline and then stack together by year. The, the, the graph on the left is 2008 through 2020, and if you go and you measure those things, you will find that the current decline rate, or the 2019 decline rate, was 43%.
Go back to 2014, the last time this happened. The decline rate back then was half. It was 22%. So people are going to go back and they're going to look and say, well, you know, we lost a gazillion rigs between 2014 and '16, and production only dropped a million barrels a day.
And I'm going to say 2 things. First, the decline rate was half what it is today. And second, you're declining from a much smaller base, and therefore you don't need as many wells drilling to, to support, to support the maintenance.
So slide number 13 then puts all of those things, I hope, into perspective. Here we've got the time-shifted rig count going all the way back to 2014 in blue, and we've got the production through— I'm showing a projection in, into November. And you can see that the correlation between the end of 2016 and recently was quite But you know, you go look then at where it says production on the left, lower left. April 2015, we went from 9.66 down to 8.53. So we only lost 1.1 million barrels a day. So people say, well, why do you think we're we're going to lose two or three this time around? Well, for all the reasons I showed you. The other thing, of course, you have to take into account is that giant drop in rig count.
Most of those that never came back, those were vertical rigs that just—they just—they threw them away. Okay, those were outdated; they were never used again. So this is not like 2013 and 14. I guess nothing is ever quite like something in the past. But there are there are good reasons, data-driven reasons, to understand why the production should drop more today than it did then. And then you know really the the last slide I want to say anything about. Is, is number 14.
And this does the exact same thing as those previous graphs, the stacked vintage production declines, except this shows the number of rigs— I'm sorry, the number of producing wells, not the number of rigs. Same data, same 4 states plus Gulf of Mexico. And what you see here is that the number of active wells in the US has fallen by 34,000 and a little bit since August of 2019. That's a 12% drop in active wells.
The last time we had a price collapse, it fell by 8,800, which was only 3%. So what's going on right now is it's just a— it's, it's a level higher than anything we've seen before. And if you analyze and think about this chart, what you'll understand is that most of those retired wells are the older wells. They're the blue ones. They're the previous years, which is to say before 2014. But that's a big part of the production base. So these are all the reasons that I think that it's reasonable to expect a bigger drop than EIA's 11— flat 11 million barrels a day, and why it's reasonable that you can choose Choose one of my cases, whichever the one you think is more reasonable.
Erik Townsend: Art, now I want to go back to our earlier conversation about price and the comparative inventory yield curve that we discussed all the way back on page number 3. And what you said at that point was, based on where we are in the story right now, hey, it's priced exactly where it's supposed to be. If anything, the futures market at almost $51 as we're speaking on Wednesday afternoon, is maybe a little over what you think the, the yield curve is telling you fair value should be.
I don't want to talk about right now. I want to talk about based on your projections of what's going to happen with the fall-off in production and what you expect the impact of that to be on comparative inventory. What's your guess for where we go before— let's, let's— what do you think the high highest print is on WTI in terms of price before 2021 is out?
Art Berman: So the answer to your question is I, I think it, it easily could be $65. Now that's a guess, obviously, but it's based on, it's based on analogy. And if, if you look in slide 3 at the, the red circles, those are the past price excursions from the yield curve. And again, the yield curve is not meant to be, you know, some sort of an arithmetic regression. It's a fit, and it's fitting a lot of human behavior in there. So if you want to criticize it, you know, go ahead, but just understand what it is. But if you go look at those 3 ovals in the right-hand side of the curve, I mean, those are in the last few years. Those excursions were up to 30%. From the yield curve mean. So if we are at, let's just say, 50, 30% of 50 is, uh, you know, 30% deviation is, is going to be $65 easily, right?
And we've seen that. We've seen that. We saw, you know, going up to the blue, the blue, uh, yield curve, and you'll see above it in the white area it says April-October 2018 Iran sanction optimism. We deviated off that blue yield curve clear up into the red yield curve, all based on anticipation of lost supply.
That's what the market does when it fears that there will be inadequate supply in the future. It raises price today so that people get their butts out there and start drilling wells to cover the supply crunch down the road whenever that is—3 months, 6 months, 9 months. So that's what I think.
Erik Townsend: And that's exactly the scenario that I'm expecting, Art, is I think what happens as we get toward the end of 2021 is you get to a scenario where that rig count, I'm sure, will be higher than 230 or whatever it is now, but it won't be 900 or 1,000 or certainly not 1,800, whatever it was at the high. And I think at some point when people say, wait a minute, what do you mean that Cushing, Oklahoma is almost empty again. You know, we, we had this big crisis where we didn't have enough storage capacity. Now we don't have any oil to put in, in the tank. Nobody thought that was coming so quickly. And I predict that the crisis is not over yet. We're still in the pandemic, but everybody knows by then, okay, we're getting much more stability around these vaccines. Within another year or so, it really is going to be over.
And then where's the rig count going to come from? from. And that's where if you get people panicking and saying, wait a minute, we can't recover, then the price can be emotionally driven to a significant deviation away from the yield curve. And I'm thinking toward the end of '21, maybe into the beginning of '22, is about where that deviation happens. And it's the combination of a brighter light at the end of the tunnel than we have now. If we're not dealing with all these mutations and other things, but it really does look like the vaccine situation is fully in hand.
And we've got comparative inventory showing us not that we're running out of storage, but rather we're running out of oil to put in those big empty storage tanks. I think that's where people start to panic. Would you agree?
Art Berman: I would agree, Erik. And I'd add back into where we started this conversation, you know, you were talking about all of the ESG-motivated shift from oil to, you know, other more sort of soft subjects, and we're kind of done with oil. I think, I think this is going to be a big wake-up call. And I don't say this as an oil partisan by any means. It's just I think that, that the world and investors are so completely ignorant of the fact that the economy runs on oil. And they honestly believe they don't need oil. I mean, What kind of critical thinking goes into that? And again, that's, you know, you don't have to like oil.
You can hate it, but that is the reality. It is the productivity, the multiplier effect that you get from a barrel of oil that makes economic growth possible.
And right now, because things are so depressed and everybody's so bummed out and the economy's down, everybody's thinking, well, you know, I guess we don't really need it all that much. Wait until economic growth hits the skids, and you'll see that long before when people start freaking out about, well, where's the oil coming from? We cannot grow an economy without oil. Not today, not in the near future. Maybe we'll figure out how to do it sometime. We are nowhere near that. And if oil doesn't come back into vogue for oil investing, for purely opportunistic reasons, then I guess I don't understand human nature because you can make money.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think the key to that, Art, is oil production does continue to move out of vogue in the sense that people don't want to invest in it. It's not the cool thing to do anymore. It's not ESG-friendly. It's all these things are wrong with it. So you do have capital drying up, but at the same time, you still need oil in order to run the economy. And what that does is maybe it hurts the bottom line of the producers, the companies in the oil industry. But in terms of the price of oil, it goes up, not down.
Art Berman: And when the price of oil goes up, the share price of the companies goes up. And when the share price of the company starts going up, investors say, wow, we could make some money. I mean, you know, I refuse to believe that people put as much money into the oil and gas business in 2016, '17, and '18 because they thought oil was a really lovely thing. They did it because they could make money.
That oil share price gave them a multiplier on WTI, and they're not stupid. If that opportunity presents itself again, particularly in a zero-interest-rate world, You don't think people are going to do it? I mean, I think if they don't, then they absolutely defy my understanding of human nature.
Erik Townsend: Speaking of making money, for people who want to make money trading this stuff, you offer some services at artberman.com. Tell us real quickly, we're already over time, but give us the quick rundown on what they can find there.
Art Berman: Yeah, I offer monthly subscriptions to my read and all the data on the oil inventory report and comparative inventory. I do the same for gas. I've got a monthly newsletter and I do a weekly rig count kind of thing. They're all pretty inexpensive. And if you want to know the details, just the facts, you want to know my interpretation, it doesn't cost you very much. Go to artberman.com and sign up. If you want the free pass, just see me on @AEberman12 on Twitter. And if you can understand it all between all the apples people throw at me, most of the data is there.
Erik Townsend: Well, Art, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor. The Fed has committed to keeping interest rates low for the foreseeable future. That means bond yields, already at record lows, will continue to stay near 0%.
So where should you put your hard-earned income? Well, according to a new report from Citi Private Bank, contemporary art returned 13.6% per year over the last 25 years, compared to only 8.9% for the S&P 500. Contemporary art also has a lower loss ratio than gold, with almost no correlation to the stock market. Masterworks.io is the first and only platform that lets you invest in blue-chip art from artists like Monet and Picasso. Recently, Masterworks.io sold their first Banksy masterpiece for a 32% return net of fees to investors. To learn more, head to Masterworks.io today. See important information at Masterworks.io/disclaimer.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have an update from Art. It's always good to have him on the show. But did your bigger view of oil change in any way after that interview?
Erik Townsend: It didn't really change. What it did for me was it gave me an update on the timing. I wasn't sure when the price was really likely to, to make its final move higher, and it sounds like it's not till sometime in the second half of the year. I wasn't really sure when this was all going to kick in. What I think is very interesting is originally I thought it was going to be the decline in production that Art is talking about that was going to get us back up to $50. Well, we're already at $50 just on inflation pressures and other things going on in the market without even, you know, thinking about a decline in US production. When that decline in US kicks in, I think that it could really accelerate the pace. Now, of course, if demand is collapsing because the entire economy is shut down after a massive new wave of the virus, well, you know, that changes things.
But short of that, it seems to me like we're set up for that $75 print before the year is out. In any event, Patrick, let's move on to our postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage and look for the red button above Art Berman's picture that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, can 2021 get crazier than 2020? I say yes.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it is, uh, definitely a crazy start to the year, and we got full momentum in so many of the kind of bubblish stocks. I want to start off here on page 2, just the S&P 500, which doesn't really feel too much like a bubble. I mean, it's slowly crawling higher, but I don't think it's the, the major components of the S&P 500 that are taking so much of the money flow. But with this breakout on the S&P 500 to a higher high, I mean, the most immediate coming week or two could see us finishing off moves towards, uh, even 4,000 on the upside. Certainly we are long overdue for some sort of a consolidation or correction of this huge rally that's happened since March. But it's probably on the short term likely to first go a little bit higher before we, we start looking for the next kind of swing high in this market.
But what I want to really touch on is taking a look under the hood for what the different stocks or sectors within the markets are actually doing. And what I've continued to find fascinating is on page 3 that we have finally seen a true rotation and outperformance of the Russell small caps over that of the NASDAQ technology. And maybe that rising yields is playing into that as, as we are seeing a bit of that rotation into the cyclicals doing very well. But really, a trend that's been in place very much so over the last 3+ years has been that NASDAQ and technology outperformance. And it really seems now that you can find a lot of that performance in a much broader base of securities outside of those darling tech names that have truly been the rock stars over the last year or 2.
But what's also interesting is looking at what are the bubble stocks in page 4. And what's amazing is that, you know, we have Tesla here approaching $800, making Elon Musk the richest man in the world. Making Tesla, if I did the math right, have a market cap greater than the next 11 largest car companies combined. We really have this froth and parabolic rise. But you can see in orange, when we're looking at that Tesla, really Bitcoin has been playing catch-up in terms of percentage gains on the upside. Both of them now approaching 600% off of their March lows. And so it's going to be really interesting to see who wins this race for ultimately where we see some sort of a short to intermediate high. But certainly Bitcoin at this moment has really gained the accelerated parabolic rise element that may actually shoot it past Tesla.
It'll be really interesting to see.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, to me it's very interesting to see that the biggest performing names anywhere in finance are both things which frankly, uh, I I respect the prerogative of other people who have different opinions, but at least some of us hold the opinion that neither one of them has any value whatsoever. And clearly the momentum is there, the story is there. People love the story behind both of them, whether or not it really makes sense for Tesla to be worth more than car manufacturers that actually manufacture lots
Erik Townsend: of cars, all of them combined.
It just, just blows my mind. In any event, let's move on to the US dollar. We're coming back down into that key support zone where, boy, if that doesn't hold, look out below.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, sure, but, you know, I think that at minimum, the first go-around, we're going to find support along those lows. I mean, there might be a much bigger picture trend in play that will see the dollar index still break lower, but a number of these little measured moves are coming into this key support line.
But the interesting part is that I'm using the Commitments of Traders reports, the commercial dealers versus speculators. And I know that in the currency markets, that it's a little trickier to use COT reports. But it kind of gives a bigger idea of the sentiment, which is that generally everyone is quite bearish the dollar here. And while that in itself doesn't give a fundamental catalyst for a turn, it certainly offers a liquidity-driven short squeeze potential that once we reach the support, if, uh, if there's any reversal in this, a short squeeze could quickly drive a counter-trend, a very sharp counter-trend move that may have no fundamental backing behind it. And so it'll be really interesting to see along the support line in the coming weeks whether or not it holds and a reversal emerges off of here.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 6, Patrick. Boy, look at that. above the $50 line on crude oil. And that's where we were exactly, at $50 on February 1st, when, well, MacroVoices listeners knew that a global pandemic was coming because we told you on January 30th. But most of the world wasn't paying attention yet. It certainly wasn't being priced into markets. We're above that number now.
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, that's for sure. And, you know, the one thing that I'm going to be watching in the next week is, is whether or not this is a false start. Now, I don't necessarily want to make that call today, but if we found ourselves quickly back below $48 in the coming week, then I would consider that to be at least where we could run out of some short-term momentum. But that'd have to be only after the fact. From— with a breakout like this, typically what you would see is the follow-through target those previous highs. And so barring some immediate reversal, which would have to happen in the next couple trading sessions, I think oil following through toward those December and February highs up along that $54 to $56 range are entirely on the table here. But moving on though, what I wanted to really talk about was some of these other commodities, and particularly that, that kind
Patrick Ceresna: of parabolic rises that we're seeing in Bitcoin and in Tesla are not alone in their, you know, in that EV space and in the crypto space.
What's amazing is that while copper is breaking to higher highs, we're really seeing, if we go to page 8, some true parabolic rises developing in the copper miners. And we're seeing just some of these parabolic rises in everything from Freeport-McMoRan to Southern Copper or Ivanhoe Mines or any of these other plays that are just running to the upside. And it'll be really interesting to see whether or not all of these markets reach their short-term swing high peaks in a similar window of time. It's funny that it's all happening at the same time. But another example of that is on page 9, that North Shore Uranium Mining ETF. See the miners just starting to really run on the upside. Just, uh, it seems to be that there's this big acceleration in so many commodities, ag stocks, everything from, from the beans to, to corn and all the other types of commodities are just running on the upside. And it's really feeding that inflation or reflation narrative.
At least it has been for the last month or so.
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't know. You could look at that the other way and say this entire move up on URNM is because they chose to advertise on MacroVoices. in the 4th quarter and drove the entire market for uranium higher. I'm sure that was it.
Patrick Ceresna: I'm sure it was.
Erik Townsend: No, I think it actually had something to do with the United States government declaring a uranium— strategic uranium reserve in addition to the strategic petroleum reserve. Let's move on to government bonds on page 10.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And this is just where I wanted to just touch on the fact that we had a considerable overhead resistance at the 1% yield level onto 10-year bond, and at the start of this year, we had a clear breakout of it. We're now trading at 1.08% on the upside. But what's particularly interesting is, is that it was an outright breakout on a whole number of the steepener trades. I particularly highlighted the 2s-10s, which we had an inverted curve for a little while back in August of 2019, and we now are clearly seeing this new uptrend emergent on this. And that's whether you're looking at the 5s, 30s, or, or any of the other ones. Obviously, this is all a bear steepening based upon inflation expectations rising, which I think the commodity rally is obviously playing a key precipitating role in driving that.
But that's where on page 12, we can really see that breakout on, on inflation expectations. This ProShares ETF that I have here is anchored record off of the 30-year breakevens. And so you have a clear breakout happening here. And it'll be really interesting to see with a breakout like this, how far does it go? I mean, are we going to see now finally Treasury bonds and yields pressing back into those ranges? Like, for instance, using crude oil as an example, crude oil is almost back to its highs from the start of the year in the pre-COVID period. And yet yields have not gotten nowhere near their highs, which were somewhere just a stone's throw away from 2% back then. I mean, are we about to see the yields get to like 1.5% plus on this impulse? It'll be really interesting because those bonds have been quite boring and there's been a lot of bond bears waiting for this break.
And so it'll be really interesting to see if in the coming weeks this continues to follow through.
Erik Townsend: Well, and of course, we have interviewed some very, very smart people like Mike Green and Dr. Lacy Hunt, who still see deflation as the name of the day. But boy, as I look at charts like this, I really think inflation and certainly commodities are the place to be. I want to make sure before we close, Patrick, that we hook our listeners up with the webinar that you did over the holidays that was about trading the commodity cycle. If they missed it, can we still get it on the website? And if so, where do we find it?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So we did over the holidays that Tactically Trading the Commodity Cycle webinar, and the recording is still available in the member section. So if you didn't have a chance to sign up and watch it and are still interested in, in watching it, the recording is on the site. You just have to sign up for a free trial at bigpicturetrading.com.
We're gonna leave it there for today's episode.
Erik Townsend: This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Masterworks, Bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Patrick, what can they expect to find in this week's Research Roundup?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Art's slide deck and the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a GMO article on waiting for the last dance and a link to the Variant Perception article comparing today's markets with 2009. and 2017. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVTV hashtag. #CRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account today.
Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to provide you with valuable information. We'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll Answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily. Reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 252 was prerecorded back on December 14th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF Ticker URNM, a focused play on miners and holders of uranium. There won't be any market wrap or postgame segment this week. Instead, we'll be bringing you part 2 of our holiday special, in which we're taking a deep dive on the topic of fiat currency being debased in real value. Patrick Ceresna hosts the series, and I'll be acting as a panelist alongside both Grant Williams, author of The Things That Make You Go Hmmm newsletter and producer of the Grant Williams Podcast, and Ronnie Stoeferle, publisher of the In Gold We Trust report, and fund manager for Incrementum. In last week's episode, we began with a review of the major events of 2020, then discussed the topic of fiat currency debasement at a high level before moving on to distinguish fiat debasement from inflation.
Then we discussed which trading strategies are appropriate to hedge each of these separate and distinct phenomena. We even pondered whether Bitcoin is replacing gold as the favored store of value hedge against fiat debasement. This week, this week, we're going to return to the distinction between inflation and fiat debasement and talk through the long list of hedging trades against each of those 2 risks, ranging from precious metals to Bitcoin to farmland to base metals to crude oil. We'll be back to our regular format with a market wrap and postgame segment next week on January 7th. Patrick, let's dive right back in where we left off last week.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, so now let's go back to Jeff Currie's distinction between fiat debasement and monetary inflation and talk about the best trading strategies for those 2 outlooks. Specifically, I think we really owe it to ourselves and our listeners to question what could go wrong with the trading strategies we each favor. So here's how I want to do this. First, we'll discuss fiat debasement and fiat debasement alone. And setting the topic of inflation aside for now, let's focus on how to trade debasement. I want each of the panelists to state their views and their own hesitations or reservations about what could go wrong. But then I want to ask everyone to critique everyone else's view so we can really challenge ourselves to consider how things could play out differently, where things could backfire. So Erik, let's start with you.
Erik Townsend: Well, if we're talking debasement, that means what you have to do is trade into your scarcity asset of choice, which has gotta be either gold or crypto. And I don't think I can bring myself to do the crypto thing because frankly, I just think This is a very, very misplaced trend. So, and it's not just gold, it's really gold and other precious metals. That's a little bit of a stretch though, because the big argument for silver is more of an inflation argument, and particularly that silver is likely to be consumed in the build-out of solar capacity in green infrastructure building. So I think gold is really the asset for me as far as fiat debasement. If I was gonna consider anything with crypto, it would be maybe calls on Bitcoin just to participate in what I think is a crazy tulip mania of Bitcoin. But if it breaks out above its previous all-time high and starts to show some upside momentum, I think it could easily double from here.
And it's a double on silliness and insanity, not on any logical fundamentals. But, you know, it's got a lot of momentum behind it. There's a lot of people that are very hyped up about it. To not participate in that just because you've got some judgment about the rationale of it.
Maybe I don't wanna be in Bitcoin, but I'd consider some Bitcoin calls.
But that's really the speculative side of it. The hedge, I think it's all about gold. And my personal hope is that the action in Bitcoin will cause a significant— a big breakout in Bitcoin, I think, could cause a big downdraft in gold because people start giving up on gold. Maybe that gets us all the way back down to $1,350. And if so, I think it's a fantastic buying opportunity.
Patrick Ceresna: Ronnie, what's your take on that?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think one of the most important things that we haven't talked about yet is the US dollar. And from my point of view, we are at the beginning of a big dollar bear market. I know, of course, that the concept, the Milkshake Theory of our mutual friend Brent Johnson, but just having a look at the chart of the dollar index, but also just the US dollar against the Japanese yen, against the euro, against the Canadian Canadian dollar, against the Australian dollar, but also against the British pound and the Russian ruble.
I think that the US dollar will go lower. Of course, at the moment, I think if you have a look at positioning, net short positioning on the US dollar is at record highs. And I think that the sentiment in general is pretty negative.
But from my point of view, it is primarily the US dollar weakness Which is the main trigger for this commodity bull market. Let's face it, the fundamental case for copper, for uranium, for iron ore, for silver is there for a while. But now I think the US, the weakness in the US dollar has really been the trigger for those bull markets emerging. And we always said it is gold that moves first. Then it is the silver market. Then it is the broader commodity space. And then it's energy. And now even uranium is rising big time. So I think also having, of course, a look at the upcoming new administration in the US, I think we're at the beginning of a big bear market in the US dollar. And let's face it, that's for economic growth, for emerging markets, for commodities. That's a pretty good environment.
And actually, it seems that the whole world wants and needs a weaker US dollar.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's go to Grant now. What's your way of approaching the debasement? And what do you think of both Erik's and Ronnie's view?
Grant Williams: Well, I had a very interesting conversation with, as I mentioned earlier, with Fred Hickey a couple of weeks ago. And Fred was talking about how he morphed from a technology analyst, uh, you know, writing a letter called The High-Tech Strategist, which he did right the way through the internet madness, right the way through the, you know, '99 dot-com boom.
And he talked about how in, in essentially the early 2000s, he took a look at what had happened. He, he called that bubble well, he traded it spectacularly and made himself an awful lot of money. And he, he recognized in, in 2001, I think it was, that, that the problem he was going to face going forward was one of debasement, was one of protecting the purchasing power of his wealth. And it was that recognition and that realization that, that made him look at gold. It made him realize that gold was the answer to that problem and that the gold mining shares were, if you like, call options on that problem.
And so what he did was he took a look and he realized that that was going to be his problem for decades to come. And here we are, 2 decades later, Fred's still writing The High-Tech Strategist He's still facing the same problems. And having that understanding that this was going to be a 2— a multiple-decade problem, Fred has had a core position in gold which was designed to protect him from debasement. And he's been able to, to trade around that in, in the mining shares at times of great stress. He's been a buyer at times of Great strength. He's been a seller.
But I think having that understanding, that long-term view of what the problem he was trying to ameliorate was, has enabled him to have the right position and trade around it rather than chase things up and down, which is something that anyone new to the precious metals markets almost has to do as a kind of entrance fee into the game. I mean, it's a very painful space to try and learn without understanding history.
So I think if, if, if we're right that the problem we are going to face is currency debasement initially followed by inflation, and we try and put some kind of time frame on that, then it helps us understand what the right course of action is.
And to me, gold remains the best core asset to provide that protection that you want against these twin problems, uh, one which is likely to follow the other. But understanding that gold is the solution to that debasement problem actually frees you up to then think about tactical positions in inflation hedges, whether it is copper, whether it is energy, whether it is raw materials.
It allows you to view them as, as tactical allocations because you've, you've really set aside a portion of your portfolio to deal with what you really believe to be the main threat. And that is debasement. So I think once you do that, you look at these things in a wholly different light. You can look at raw materials, you can look at industrial commodities, you can see the froth in them, and you're not wedded to those positions because you, you've got your protection on in gold from the debasement issue. You can trade the inflation wave knowing that that gold will actually help you if, if the inflation becomes a problem. Yes, okay, maybe it won't be the single best hedge against it, but I guarantee it won't hurt you in an inflationary environment.
So I think that the most important thing is to understand the problem you're facing, put a timeline on it. How long do you think it's going to be a problem for? If you think it's only going to be a short-term problem, then do you really need to take these precautions?
I suspect it's going to be a long-term problem, and and that dictates the the action you take. And to me, that's a very pragmatic and a very sensible way of dealing with the issues we face right now.
Erik Townsend: Ronnie, I want to ask you about the dollar view, because first of all, from an economic standpoint, I get it. Like, the argument for the dollar debasement, yep, makes sense. I understand. I think I agree with you. But from a trading standpoint, I can't bring myself to even think about shorting the dollar. And the reason is simply that, am I smart enough to figure out that the dollar is going to underperform against other fiat currencies when I'm not exactly sure between With Janet Yellen at the Fed and Christine Lagarde at the ECB, who knows who's going to win the competitive devaluation war?
What I do know is that fiat currencies all around the world are going to be devalued in real terms against precious metals. So as much as I wanna agree with you and say, yeah, I think the dollar's probably headed down, I almost don't care from a trading standpoint because to me, the trade has to be long precious metals And I invest in dollars, so it's gold against dollar. If you like gold against euro, fine. But I don't see why you would want to make the bet on dollar underperforming against other fiat.
Ronnie Stoeferle: I see your point. And it is definitely having a bearish view on the US dollar or having a positive view on the euro is definitely not that contrarian anymore. I always do my 10 forecasts at a big precious metals conference in Munich. Last year I said that the euro will trade to the US dollar at 1.17, and I was kind of ridiculed. And I thought, okay, that's a pretty good sign. Now everybody was talking about the euro breaking below parity and so on, and it became differently.
But I think now we are seeing, and that's what Madame Lagarde already said at her last press conference, that They are closely monitoring the continued appreciation of the euro. Now, of course, it is pretty difficult for the ECB to generate inflation while your currency is appreciating. Because the ECB has only one mandate. And this is price stability. So we have to be very careful with that view. I totally agree. And I think when it comes to gold, for example, We see that fiat currencies are devaluing versus gold at a different pace. So this year, for example, gold is up in euro terms, I think 12%, while in dollar terms it's up 21%.
But on average, over the last couple of years, the devaluation of currencies, be it the US dollar, the British pound, which was obviously a bit weaker, But also the euro, the Swiss franc, the Canadian dollar was roughly 10% per year on average.
So I agree to your point. But I think, you know, technically, if we have a look at the dollar index, at how it's trading recently, I think this looks like a really horrible chart. And I see it really breaking down below this 89.9 support level. Now, I think that when it comes to the currency question, I totally agree. You want to have currencies that cannot be inflated at will. And that of course brings us to gold, but also perhaps to Bitcoin. But going forward, I just see that there's so many measures taken in the US that would confirm my bearish view for the US dollar. It is this move from monetary QE to fiscal QE. It is the move of average inflation targets. That we don't see in the eurozone, for example. It is this very, very aggressive expansion of the broad monetary aggregates, which is slightly more aggressive in the US than over here in the eurozone.
And I think this MMT gaining in popularity—and by the way, I thought it was brilliant to invite Stephanie Kelton—I really enjoyed listening to to her view. And and I think. I think it's very, very important to exactly listen to those people that don't confirm your view, that have an opposite view. But I think this MMT trend gaining so much in popularity and also the fact that Janet Yellen will become the new head of the Treasury, which is another sign for this MMT development becoming more mainstream. I think this all sounds Pretty dollar bearish to me.
So on a relative basis, I think that we will see more weakness of the US dollar, but structurally, I'm not a big bull in the euro or any other fiat currency.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay. The whole discussion we just had was about fiat debasement specifically. Next, I want to do the same thing on the topic of inflation. That's coming up next, right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Abaxx now trades in Canada under symbol ABXX, priced in Canadian dollars. But more importantly for our American listeners whose brokers don't offer access to Canadian exchanges, the American depository receipt priced in US dollars is now trading on the US over-the-counter market under symbol ABXXF. That's Alpha Bravo X-ray X-ray Foxtrot. Be sure to catch my interview with Blockchain.com Chief Strategy Officer Charlie McGarraugh on last weekend's Smarter Markets. And be sure to tune in this coming weekend for my interview with Logica Funds' Mike Green, which airs on Saturday, January 2nd.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, that discussion was specifically about fiat debasement, but now let's do the whole thing over again for inflation. So we'll start with each panelist's view on how to best hedge the inflation we think is likely coming, then we'll do a group critique of what could go wrong. So, Erik, let's start with you on your take on inflation and how to hedge it.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think this is really, really important because on one hand, I think that the certain thing right now is the fiat debasement side. I really am convinced this time around that it is gonna lead to inflation. But I said that 10 years ago, and I'm not gonna say I'm wrong. I'm really, really, really early when I said that 10 years ago. So if we're really gonna have the inflation now, and I think that it has the potential to become bigger than 1970s degree of runaway inflation and stagflation, it's going to be a really big deal and it's going to be really, really important to be on the leading edge of that.
On the other hand, I've been wrong for a lot of years thinking it was about to start any day now. So the way I'm approaching this is oil is a position that I have a huge long exposure in already because I'm primarily an oil trader. And a lot of my oil trades are not long-term buy-and-hold positions, but I do have buy-and-hold positions in back-of-curve time spreads, Z1/Z2 spread on West Texas Intermediate crude oil futures for people who are following that trade, which has performed incredibly well since we first talked about it on MacroVoices.
That's as much inflation exposure as I want until I see inflation really starting to happen. And not just I think it's coming, but I see it's really coming. And when that happens, I want to be in a position to really pounce on it and be ready to really put on all those inflation trades once I get confirmation that it's really happening.
I'm spending a lot of my time right now really thinking about exactly what that means, because I think it's heavy exposure to mining, but not more precious metals, more focused on copper, particularly because I think that we're going to see infrastructure Buildouts that are very much about electrifying the economy. That's gonna require a huge amount of copper. I think that silver is gonna be a more important precious metal because as solar energy gets more and more important, silver gets consumed in producing some types, but not all types of solar panels. That's gonna be an important inflation hedge. But really, I feel like I don't have the, the portfolio figured out in terms of exact allocations of what percentage to this and what percentage to that. And some of these things like base metal mining, you know, I don't know the difference between Freeport-McMoRan and other mining companies. I don't know enough about fundamentals of those industries to really be a stock picker myself.
So I'm trying to figure out exactly how I'm going to approach it.
But my feeling is you want to be in the currency debasement trade right now. You wanna have some kind of inflation hedge and you wanna be ready to dramatically increase your inflation hedge on confirmation that that big wave of inflation that I and a lot of other people expect really does show up the way we expect it to. So that's the way I think about it. I'd be particularly interested in Grant and Ronnie's perspective, both on that strategy, but also how do you really figure out how to build out that inflation hedge strategy That's not about precious metals and currency debasement, but it's about the expectation of a pickup in the velocity of money and eventually getting to the point where we have a self-reinforcing wage and price inflation spiral.
When that starts, my prediction is it's going to take a lot of people by surprise and accelerate very quickly, and you're not going to want to be left behind. You're going to want to be ready and say, I planned for this. I know exactly what my trades are, I'm ready to put them on. And I'm not ready. I want to be ready and I'm not there yet.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's go to Ronnie first. And what's your inflation trade in the way you'd put perspective and as well what you think of Erik's perspectives?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, Erik touched on the topic of velocity. And I think this is really something crucial going forward. I had a conversation with Mark Bristow, the CEO of Barrick Gold. And he asked me, well, do you think once we get the vaccine against COVID, that should put an enormous amount of pressure on the price of gold. And I said, yes, short term it will, because there will be major shifts happening in allocation. It will be this back-to-normal trade. But it also means that velocity will pick up at one point. Because what we're facing now is this uncertainty, this loss of trust in the future. Nobody is making big investments at the moment. Nobody is, you know, traveling any— making any travel plans. So I think now with the vaccine, all this uncertainty will disappear over the next couple of months. And this will mean that the velocity, or as the Austrian School of Economics would call it, the demand of hold money will change.
And it will meet an enormous amount of liquidity that was created over the last couple of months. So from my point of view, This should definitely be inflationary. While at the moment I think more and more people are getting a bit concerned when it comes to inflation, but it is not really on the radar screens yet.
And I think that few people— that's what our friend Luke Gromen once said— few people believed the Fed could tame inflation in 1979, and few believe that the Fed can spur inflation in 2020. So we are seeing some sort of a reverse Volcker. I think that this move to average inflation targeting was really something that was kind of underreported because it happened in August and nobody really cared about it. But I think this move from an inflation target to an average inflation target is really big news.
Back in the days, we had 2% inflation as the ceiling. Now, As inflation was undershooting over the last couple of years. The Federal Reserve is very, very open. And it's saying we want inflation rates to overshoot. And once we go to 4 or 5%, it will not automatically mean that we will raise rates.
So this is basically the recipe for negative real rates over the next couple of years. Of course, that should provide a pretty positive environment for gold, but also And that's what we are playing as a diversified inflation portfolio. It should be pretty beneficial for commodity currencies. It should be positive for emerging market equities. It should be very positive for the silver space.
We are sometimes putting on trades long commodity producers versus short importers. We have got some TIPS. And I think that, you know, of course, gold is a pretty obvious inflation hedge. But by creating some sort of a diversified inflation portfolio, I think you're just reducing the volatility that you're seeing, for example, in the gold mining market.
So our approach is clearly diversified. Now, why am I so positive for a kind of a new commodity cycle? I think first of all, investors are deeply underweight. I don't know any big investors saying we are massively overweight real assets such as commodities. And then I think, you know, they're just generationally cheap, both compared to their own history, but especially compared to other assets. So I think, you know, real assets over financial assets, that's really the big shift that we are seeing for the next couple of years as one of the big trends.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Grant, let's circle to you. Inflation trades and what's your impression on both Erik's and Ronnie's views?
Grant Williams: Well, I think, look, I think the interesting thing here is that we're talking about a major paradigm shift here. We've been investing in a deflationary environment for essentially 40 years. And what we're talking about here is a secular shift back to an inflationary environment, which we haven't seen, realistically speaking, since the 1970s, apart from that kind of little spike we saw in commodity price inflation in the 2000s.
And if you look at a chart of interest rates going back thousands of years, you'll see that inflation spike in the '70s was absolutely the outlier. I mean, interest rates, as one can quite understand, have trended down always, because man is always looking for cheaper money and finding ways to produce that.
So the inflation spike is the outlier. And so because of that, you've You've actually been given a great opportunity. And what is, if we're pragmatic about it and step back and be pretty basic about it, a pretty simple opportunity. If I told you you were going to have inflation, what would you do? Well, you know what? You'd short the long end of the Treasury curve and you'd buy commodities. Well, guess what? The short— the long end of the commodity— of the Treasury curve is at or near all-time highs, and commodities are at or near all-time lows. I mean, you have the perfect setup. And the reason you have the perfect setup is precisely because people have been expecting this to happen for the last 40 years and it hasn't.
So we're at a point in time where, you know, Erik said he wanted confirmation, and I think he's right. But you really, if you look at the price commodities are at, I think you can start to position yourself in energy, in natural gas, in oil. You can start positioning yourself in, in basic materials, you can start putting that position on now to the extent that you have tolerance to be wrong for, you know, a period of months. You will get plenty of chances to get in. But if you look at the charts of basic materials, the CRB Raw Materials Index, you'll see it's turned and it's definitely broken out of a trend and it's starting to move higher. So I think I think it's safe to start easing your way into these positions. If you want to wait for confirmation like Erik did, that's fine. But for me, the one side of that trade that you're going to have problems with, even though it's an incredibly appealing prospect, is being short the long end of the curve.
Being short the long end of the curve, you are going to be somewhere where I don't think that's a position you can set and forget, because you're going to have to fight the Fed every step of the way. There will be some tremendous profits to be made. But you'll have to be ready to take those profits off the table because we'll end up with yield curve control. We'll end up with all kinds of things because given the state of US government finances, there is absolutely no way they can let interest rates rise past a certain point. And that certain point is actually not that far away from where we are now. So even though you've been given a 5,000-year positioning opportunity, that's something you're going to have to be very nimble with. And you're not going to be able to ride a 5,000-year trade all the way back the other way. The commodities, on the other hand, I suspect offers a much better and potentially more peaceful ride north than the bond yields do south.
So I'd certainly be looking at that. I think being positioned in gold right now, oil, natural gas, even uranium's finally started to move. But unlike Erik, I don't think it's too early to start establishing position in these things. And obviously the one advantage that you have now that you didn't have in the '70s are ETFs, which give you a very simple way for low cost to be quote unquote long commodities. You don't need to go into the futures market. You don't need to go into the commodity space. You don't need to get complicated trades on. You can buy low-cost ETFs which give you broad exposure, and you can pick and choose the kind of parts of the commodity spectrum you want to be exposed to and do it very, very simply. And, and, and I would suggest If you're ready, then I wouldn't lose any sleep over starting to establish positions.
And if you're not ready, then I would start, as Erik said, trying to understand which commodities you want exposure to and working out the most sensible way for you to gain the exposure you want.
Erik Townsend: Grant, I just want to clarify one point, which is I'm already very, very long energy, and therefore I'm already in the inflation trade because I'm an energy trader. What I said was simply, I don't want to go into a lot of other assets that I have less familiarity with for the sake of diversifying my inflation trade until I've seen that confirmation. But the other point I want to come to is one I think you actually clarified at the end of what you were saying when you said long commodities and short the long end of the curve.
If we go back to the day that rates bottomed after World War II, if you got it right exactly perfectly to the day, you picked the low moment in interest rates because you're a perfect bottom caller, you would have waited 10 years for interest rates to meaningfully appreciate from there. So I think for the reasons you said, we're stuck with low interest rates for a long time. Shorting the long end of the curve, as much as it's appealing, it feels like we're at a 5,000-year low in interest rates and it's time to do that.
I think you could be waiting a long time. Because if you see trillions of dollars of infrastructure build-out, that is already basically a done deal. You can't build infrastructure without raw materials. That means copper and other commodities are going to come into very strong demand very soon. So I just think the commodity side of what you said is much more timely than the short the long end of the curve side of it.
Grant Williams: Yeah, which is exactly what I said. I said, if you were looking for the perfect trade, it's a very simple trade. It's short the long end, long commodities. long end of the curve is not going to be an easy place to be. And the commodity side is way, way easier, and you've got so many more vehicles to do it in. So yeah, I agree.
The trade is simple, but one half of that trade is not going to be an easy place to be in. And you're going to be fighting the Fed the whole way, so why bother?
Erik Townsend: Okay. It's the why bother part that I didn't hear the first time. So yeah, we're in agreement. The trade here is long commodities. And at some point, When that momentum gets going and you really think that there's reason to be on the short side of the long end of the curve. Wait till that trade really starts happening. But I don't see how it can happen for the next 10 years. We're stuck with low rates for the reasons you said.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay. From the discussion, it seems that precious metals, cryptocurrency, base metals like copper, and energy all come into consideration here. So next, I want to go into more detail about those markets. So let's start by talking about what's going on in these precious metals and whether gold, silver, and other precious metals are the best plays. And so Ronnie, is this story all about gold or is silver the better play? And if so, why? And what about platinum and palladium?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think, you know, starting with gold, it's been a pretty good year and gold perfectly did its job. It's up 21% in US dollar terms. It's up 13% in euro terms. It's up 18% in Canadian dollars and so on. And I think what is even more important is the fact that gold perfectly stabilized your portfolio in the extremely volatile weeks in March and April. So I once said, you know, I'm from Austria and I, for some reason, I really enjoy watching Austrian football or soccer, as Americans would say. So I made the comparison, gold being a very, very reliable defender in your portfolio. I don't know, Grant, what are the best English defenders? I don't know, Sol Campbell, Rio Ferdinand, John Terry, something like that.
Grant Williams: We don't have many good defenders.
Ronnie Stoeferle: But they're better than the goalkeepers. So I think gold perfectly did its job. And I was a bit confused when people in the last couple of weeks, they were really frustrated the price of gold. And I said, you know, guys, don't be too greedy. It's been a fantastic year for gold. And I think it's just taking a breather.
Actually, when gold hit new all-time highs, I would say like 95% of the comments I got from friends and colleagues was, okay, now it's already too expensive. I will wait for the correction. Of course, now in the correction, nobody's buying. But it is a relative game. And, you know, relative to monetary growth, relative to other asset classes, from my point of view, gold is still dirt cheap. So I think that the point in time when I would really become bearish gold would be the point when we see real rates rising significantly.
But I just don't see that coming. Now, Going forward, I think the big story is investors' demand. We saw in 4th quarter until December, ETF holdings, for example, were down around 4 million ounces. But in general, 2020 has been a year with a tremendous amount of investors' demand. And I think that longer term, the investor base for gold has clearly broadened. And positions have been pretty resilient. We are seeing over here in Europe that more and more investors are adding gold to their strategic positions to protect portfolios in this negative real rate environment and also perhaps to hedge against the weak dollar. So I would say that the renaissance of gold in institutional portfolios is really the big trend and the big shift that we are seeing in 2020. And as I've said, the big driver going forward will become inflation.
You know, I think the number that we just saw of negative yielding debt, that's now $18 trillion. And I think that we just saw Portugal joining the club of 10 years at negative yields. So I think once inflation really becomes a concern, there will be an exodus out of this $18 trillion in negative yielding bonds. And of course, it will flow into the traditional inflation hedges like gold, for example.
Now, when it comes to silver, silver is some sort of a derivative of gold. It is up 34% in US dollar terms and 24% in euro terms. So not too shabby. And I think what Erik said before, that's totally right. The fundamental case for silver is probably even more compelling than for gold.
This year, for the very first time in its history, we had a special chapter on silver that our mutual friend Emil Kalinowski helped us writing. And I think the fundamental case for silver is fantastic, especially when it comes to this whole green stimulus theme. All those environmentally orientated fiscal policies should mean a very, very supportive environment for the solar industry.
And from my point of view, it will create much, more demand for silver in the whole clean energy chain. So that's one of the points why I'm pretty confident regarding silver on a relative basis. And I think it's interesting that the gold-silver ratio held reasonably well despite the sell-off that we saw in gold in the 4th quarter. And we're also seeing silver ETFs have shown some resilience in the face of the sell-off in gold. So I think once gold makes the next leg up, I think silver will probably trade above $30. And, you know, now the gold-silver ratio is trading at 76. So 1 ounce of gold, you get 76 ounces of silver.
I think that gold can easily trade at $2,500 in the next 12 months. If the gold-silver ratio comes down to 40, that would mean a silver price of $62. So So I think from a risk-reward perspective, silver might even be the better trade at the moment.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Grant, what's your take when we're talking about broader precious metals? Is silver the better play, or what about platinum and palladium?
Grant Williams: Yeah, look, again, I think it's really important to understand what we're trying to accomplish here because we spent an awful lot of time here today talking about strategies to protect yourself from what are potentially multi-year, multi-decade-long problems. Certainly debasement has been for several decades now. And then there is the trading side of this.
And so they're 2 very, very different things. And if you understand that you want to start trading the mining stocks, for example, you have to understand the kind of heartache that that can bring you. And so having that long-term understanding of of what you're trying to accomplish, I think will help inform you better in terms of your entry points and exit points. Because you can look at the gold mining stocks, you can, when they're beaten down, you tend to have an understanding of the longer-term picture. And so they look more valuable to you because you're looking at a long-term problem. Likewise, when they've run too far, you have a reference point in what you're trying to accomplish and you can see how they've overrun And it's easy to take things off the table. So with that being said, I think here today with gold having come off, having kind of failed at $2,100 back to $1,800, Erik thinks he can see a path down to $1,350.
I don't see that path. I'm not saying he's wrong, but I don't see that path myself. I'm looking at the long-term opportunity that gold offers at $1,800. If it gets down to the $1,700s, it offers an even better opportunity to me. So I'm very happy to buy the mining stocks here. I think the mining stocks have dramatically improved their businesses. They're in much better shape than they've been probably at any time in the last 25 years. And more importantly, I think the management understand the mistakes they've made.
Now, that's not to say if we get a really frothy gold price and we get the kind of, you know, if we had the kind of move into gold we've seen into Bitcoin and the attendant press and coverage that it gets, then I guarantee you some of these mining CEOs would revert to some of their, some of their bad habits. But I think for the time being, they understand this. And so owning some of the gold miners, some owning some of the Newmonts, the Agnico's, the Kirkland Lakes, the Pretiums of the world make an awful lot of sense right now. The silver, as Ronnie said, it's, it's, you know, turbocharged gold. You're gonna have to be able to stomach a lot more volatility. But again, if you have a long-term view about inflation, then that volatility in the gold mine— in the silver mining stocks against the context of what you're trying to achieve by being long silver as an inflation hedge makes it easy to stomach those, those downturns. So anyone that's thinking of investing in these, if you're looking at individual companies, you have to get to understand the assets, the countries they're in, the mines themselves.
You have to understand the management Don't ever invest in a mining stock where you don't hold the management in high regard. Be very careful in mines whose assets are in somewhat shakier jurisdictions. There is a whole checklist. And if you read people like Fred Hickey, if you read some of the more prolific gold commentators, you'll start to understand those. But going into precious metals mining stocks as a simple way to express inflationary view, It's a lot more complicated than that. There are excellent companies and there are poor companies, and you want to make sure that you own the former and steer well clear of the latter. And that doesn't come without doing an awful lot of reading and research. And I think it's beholden on everybody who wants to do this to, to do that research. It will pay off in spades in the long run.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, uh, what's your take on, uh, the precious metals? How would you want to add to that?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, actually I have a couple of questions for Grant and Ronnie first on the metals themselves before we come back to the As far as gold is concerned, it's my largest position. I really believe strongly in it. Slight correction, Grant. I'm hopeful for $1,350. I think it's very unlikely. The, the only way I could see it happening at this point would be if Bitcoin really takes off and gets a lot of press and a lot of people are just like, oh my God, Bitcoin is the, the new gold. It's the thing. And people panic out of their gold. That's where I think we could maybe, if we're lucky, get that chance. And boy, I sure hope it happens. I don't think it's the base case though. I don't think we're necessarily going there. I'm just hoping for it.
Going back to gold versus silver though, I really wanna ask you guys about this because, you know, there's nothing more important than invest in what you actually understand. And I'm not sure I understand this one because I had read articles years and years and years ago saying silver is Really, really important because it's a precious metal, but it's also used in, you know, photography and this long list of things, including solar cells.
And then a few years later, I remember reading something that said, yeah, you know, they used to use it in solar cells, but not so much anymore. And now I'm seeing articles saying green revolution, solar energy, silver's the place to be because silver is used. So are we really sure that silver is still used in modern generation solar cells? Or does it just used to get used in solar cells? Because I don't have a fully clear understanding of that one.
Ronnie Stoeferle: I think it's a good point. And I think when it comes to silver loadings in PV cells, for example, you can see the technological advance. Currently, we only need 20 to 25% of what we needed a decade ago. So I would never say that silver is my— the metal that I see as most attractive just because of this whole green stimulus wave. I think it is one feature, but primarily I'm seeing it as some sort of a momentum play on gold. And I know that many in the silver industry will hate me for that, but I agree. I think that I just cannot see gold, you know, going to $1,350 and the price of silver skyrocketing. I don't see that decoupling. So primarily from my point of view, I see it as a monetary metal. I see it as more of an inflationary metal.
But I think all those supply-demand issues are just an additional driver. And we have explained those drivers from the supply side. But also from the demand side in our last report. And I think they are interesting for the fundamental case, but I think they are not the primary drivers, if that makes sense to you.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So I need to learn more about how much fundamental demand really exists on the green side of silver. But I do need to diversify. I've got way too much concentration on gold, which I really should diversify into Silver and gold, and I need to learn more about the fundamentals of the green energy aspects. Platinum and palladium, I go back to my rules, invest in what you understand. Platinum and palladium, as far as I'm concerned, is for people who really are knowledgeable about how they get used in catalytic converters and diesel, whatever it is that the palladium gets used in. And I don't know about that stuff, so I don't touch it.
So as far as the metals are concerned, for me, It's all been gold. I need to diversify into silver, and I'm intentionally not touching platinum and palladium because I don't know enough about it. Moving on to where Grant was going, which is the mining shares.
Erik Townsend: I have to admit, this is an area where I'd really like to get the other guys' perspectives on, because I feel like a lot of people, the reason they favor the mining shares over the metal itself is they see it as a leverage Okay, a lot of people are not comfortable trading with leverage. I trade oil futures all day long, so I'm very comfortable using leverage in commodity futures. If what I want to accomplish is leverage on the price of gold, I just increase the number of gold contracts that I have in my account. I don't see that it makes sense for that reason.
The reason primarily that I've started investing in the mining shares is I think a lot of the private Private placements that are available in new junior companies that are just getting going really offer a significant opportunity to get a better deal than you would get in public markets.
So as an accredited investor, being able to participate— I just participated in one of Marin Katusa's private placements in a company that, you know, I could have bought it. It's already trading on the public exchange, but it was basically the same price as what it's trading right now for in the public exchange. I could buy it in a financing where, as an accredited investor, I get a half warrant for free in exchange for taking a 4-month lockup on the shares. So I can't trade the shares for 4 months. In exchange for giving up that liquidity, I get a free half warrant, which is very, very significant in value to me. I wasn't going to trade the shares for those 4 months anyway. So it didn't cost me anything and I get free value.
I favor the mining shares when I can get a private placement on them. I'm not sure that I understand, other than a leverage play, why I would want to diversify beyond the metal itself into the shares, other than if I can buy them right in a private placement. And I'd love to get feedback from both Grant and Ronnie on what I might be missing there.
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I agree. I mean, we do for our funds, we do lots of private placements as well. But, you know, I think when it comes to the mining space, I just had a look at the The sentiment, the Gold Miners Bullish Percentage Index, is down to 34 at the moment, a level that we haven't seen since March. Then we are seeing that the tax loss selling season will be over pretty soon. So I think it's a pretty good point in time to reconsider gold and silver miners from a technical point of view. If we have a look at the performance of the mining shares, I think they did pretty well.
I mean, the HUI, the gold miners index started the year 2020 at 230. Then it dropped to almost 150 and more than doubled within 6 months to 360. So that already shows you this enormous volatility of, of the market.
Now it is trading at 290 roughly, which is the same level like in the year 2013 when gold was trading at $1,350. So I am seeing a pretty interesting valuation when it comes to the miners. If you have a look at price to cash flow over a period of 30 years, it was only in 2019 that price cash flow for the miners was lower. If you have a look at price to EBITDA, same picture.
And I have had, I think, hundreds of meetings with mining executives this year. And, and, you know, there are so many virtual conferences nowadays, and I was really impressed with, I would say, most of the meetings. So the producers are, are expanding their, their margins. We are seeing that dividends are being raised. We're seeing that most companies are pretty disciplined when it comes to their gold price assumptions today. They see the price of gold over the next couple of years at $1,300 to $1,500.
I think that the sector has weathered the whole COVID crisis very, very well. So we have seen, of course, temporary shutdowns, but I think they managed it really well. We are seeing that ESG is taken very, very seriously. So from my point of view, the gold mining industry is probably at its healthiest shape in a decade. And valuations don't really reflect it yet. Now, it is still a pretty small sector. We have seen lots of private placements and some of them were really, really rubbish, I have to say. But still, you know, I had a look at that just yesterday. The top 15 North American gold producers have a market cap so small that Apple currently is 10 times larger and Facebook is almost 4 times larger. So if there's really big investment flows coming into gold mining equities. I think it will have an enormous impact.
And let's face it, we saw Berkshire Hathaway buying a stake in Barrick Gold this year. We know that Buffett has a complicated view when it comes to gold, but obviously he sees tremendous value on the balance sheet of Barrick Gold. So, so I think the, the sector really learned its lessons. I think they, they are now at a very, very healthy position. And, and therefore, we have been over the last couple of weeks, we have put in some, some stink bids for, for high-quality names that we like. We got filled for, for some. And, and I'm really, really confident when it comes to gold miners, and, and many of them will make decent free cash flow. They will pay out nice dividends. Even if we stay at the similar price level like now. So we don't need gold to go 30 or 40% higher. I think those companies at the moment are really, really stable.
They're solid and we are seeing tremendous value.
Patrick Ceresna: Grant, do you have anything to add to that?
Grant Williams: Let me just add to that point of Ronnie's that Buffett trimmed his position in Barrick by half within, I think, a month of of buying it, which I thought was interesting. But it's so true, Ronnie. You know, these companies are in great shape. I mean, they really do offer as good a value as I've seen in terms of the health of their balance sheet, the mental health of their management, and also the beaten-down sentiment. I mean, these things are still somehow unloved despite what's going on.
And if you do, I keep harping on the same point, but if you do stand back and think about The problem that gold is a solution to— Erik, you're exactly correct, they are leverage on owning gold. But given the level at which these companies are trading, the good companies, you can, you can buy leverage at a really respectable price. And, and if you, if you have the right viewpoint, it's, it's easy to trade that leverage, take profits, spin the profits into the metal itself, and trade these things the right way. The problem comes when you, you think that gold mining stocks are a get-rich-quick scheme.
They're a bring-you-to-tears quick scheme and a get-rich-slow scheme.
Patrick Ceresna: That covers precious metals. Next, I want to move on to real estate and other hard assets. That's coming up next, right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Uranium, the fuel for nuclear power, is a contrarian investment whose returns are historically uncorrelated to other asset classes. Low uranium prices lasted for many years after the Fukushima meltdown, leading to substantial supply destruction. At today's prices, uranium mining is uneconomical even for the world's lowest-cost producers. Uranium demand is already estimated to exceed existing supply, and future demand growth is expected. New mines aren't economically viable at today's prices, leading analysts to predict that the price of uranium may need to double to over $60 per pound to incentivize sufficient new mine supply to meet expected demand. The NYSE-listed North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, offers investors exposure to both miners and holders of uranium. For more information, visit urnmetf.com.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, so let's move on to hard assets now, everything from farmland to the basic materials, Copper, iron ore, battery metals, even energy. What's your position on all of that? Let's start off with you, Grant.
Grant Williams: For me, I love the idea of farmland, but as a productive investment, not— I think owning farmland via ETFs, which you can do through private equity vehicles, there are ways to do it through farmland funds. And there are some really good ones, including one run by my old boss in Singapore, Steve Diggle. But I love the idea of of owning farmland, of owning a farm, of giving yourself the chance to be self-sufficient. And you look at guys like Mike Krieger, who left New York City 10 years ago and moved out to Colorado and bought a farm and is farming it. Look at Chris Martenson, similar. There are plenty of people who've done this.
And it not only provides you a tremendous hedge, but it also is an extremely positive life change for people, I think. With the ability to work from home now so dramatically increased, I think that the possibility for farmland as an investment is going to be a really, really good one going forward.
I think commercial real estate, there are vehicles you can do that through, including some companies which are remarkably cheap, good commercial real estate companies. But I think you have to be very careful with real estate. I mean, Ronnie talked there about the correlation with real estate and inflation. So real estate as an inflation hedge, particularly at the point in the cycle we're in, I think is tricky.
And I think we've covered the basic commodities. I think they do offer good inflation hedges. And I think it's both a very simple and a very complicated trade.
It's as complicated as you want to make it. You have the ability to buy ETFs, which gives you very simple exposure to exactly the commodities you want or the basket you want. Or you can, if you have the expertise of someone like Erik, you can construct very complicated trades to squeeze every ounce of alpha out of them. It really depends on how you want to do it.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. So let's go to you, Ronnie. What's your take on looking at all these hard assets in one basket?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think there are tremendous opportunities. We don't have a strong view on farmland, for example. I just had a look at the Bloomberg Agricultural Index. It's now trading at 43. In 1997, it was trading at 140. I see some some uptrend, but it's clearly not something that we are seriously investing at because it's not our expertise.
I think when it comes to base metals like copper, iron ore, but also the battery metals, I think there is some really nice opportunities. I talked about this vegan climate ETF already, but from a value point of view, it is absolutely clear that this green revolution will have an And if you have nickel mines, for example, some of them trade at free cash flow yields at 10%. So if you compare it to Tesla, for example, that's like 30 times more expensive.
Without nickel, there would be no batteries for Tesla. If electrification is really happening, we'll need lots of nickel and lots of copper. And we are seeing similar valuation gaps between the producers of solar panels or wind turbines and producers of iron ore aluminium or silver, for example. So from my point of view, some of the mining stocks are really some sort of free options on this green revolution.
Let's have a quick look at different commodities. We like copper at the moment, but, but still, I think from a technical point of view, we're a bit ahead of fundamentals. We have rallied to an 8-year high at $3.50. I think from a fundamental point of view, We expect deficits in the copper market to widen. But at the moment, there might be some destocking coming from China, which would be some headwind for the next couple of months.
When it comes to the battery metals, I think it's pretty interesting that once this whole COVID topic is getting less interesting for markets, I think one of the big topics will of course be this build back better. And I think that, for example, over here in the euro, in the European Union, That's basically the only thing that Madame von der Leyen stands for is really this green wave, this green movement. So they're putting in a tremendous amount of government subsidies and it works.
When it comes to EV, the EV share in France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the UK, it has increased to 15% in November. So 15% of all new cars that are being sold are electric vehicles. That's a pretty big chunk of the market. Germany has the lead with a 20.5% share, followed by the UK at roughly 17%. So we are seeing big moves in this direction. And, and my tax accountant, he said, well, if you want to buy an electric car, Do it now because it's so heavily subsidized. It's incredible.
So I expect this trend to continue. Obviously, cobalt should should profit from it. But but we don't have a very strong view on cobalt. It's it's a bit of a tricky market with most of the supply coming from from from DRC. Obviously, I like the the lithium market at the moment. It seems that prices have bottomed, and I I really like the nickel market. And I think. If we assume 40% of new car sales in 2030 to be EVs, I think this will be a big, big driver for nickel demand. It should more than double until 2030. So I think it's important to understand this market because on the supply side, only 50% of all mines can actually produce a battery-ready product. So most of the supply growth is coming from Indonesia, but most of the parts is actually not usable for batteries. So we see some sort of a supply squeeze ahead in the nickel market.
When it comes to energy, well, Erik, I think you know the market much, much better than I do. But I think, you know, just having a look at the numbers, energy stocks at the moment make up roughly 2.5% of the S&P. Which is the smallest percentage of any group relative to the size of the S&P.
We have seen this big shift out of fossil fuels because ESG obviously is the very, very big topic. And don't get me wrong, this whole green wave is a wonderful thing. And as a father of 3 kids, I really appreciate the efforts. But I think sometimes people tend to forget the math. So this isn't something that takes 20 years and it won't happen in 2 years. So the whole Green New Deal, I think, scared many people in the energy space to death. And I see many, many institutional players, they were just selling off everything that rhymes with fossil fuels because everything in this area is evil.
And it's creating pretty nice opportunities from my point of view.
So going forward, I think that, well, if I would say I see oil trading at $80, I think most people would probably ridicule me. It is very, very much of a contrarian view. From my point of view, I see US shale production, the growth from shale production, let's put it that way. Being quite constrained. We're seeing that the rig count remains depressed. We have seen many years of high grading. I think perhaps we have already seen some sort of peak shale and we probably would need prices to go to $65 or even $70 to bring back a lot of these wells.
I think that the combination of optimism over the COVID vaccine, falling crude inventories, and the extremely defensive OPEC+ should lift oil prices going forward. So I'm seeing it as one of our biggest convictions. And we're seeing for the service companies, but also for the large producers, we're seeing pretty attractive valuations.
And that's the last thing when it comes to commodities. We're seeing very, very interesting developments in the uranium sector. We are running one uranium fund for many years now. It's been very frustrating, but now it really seems that— yeah, I'm a bit hesitant to say, but that this time might really be different and that this fundamental case for uranium now is kind of seen by markets. So we're seeing some pretty convincing breakouts in the uranium space.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, do you have anything to add to that?
Erik Townsend: Yeah, let me first thank Ronnie for the credit I didn't quite deserve. I'm very knowledgeable about about crude oil trading and particularly time spread trading in crude oil. But honestly, when it comes to really understanding energy markets and particularly understanding the transformation which is about to occur in this ESG world into greener energy markets, LNG, liquid natural gas, is gonna play a huge role, which I'm frankly still just learning about. So I'd say that learning about I'm curious about the role of LNG and the companies that are going to benefit from that. If you listen to my interview on the Smarter Markets podcast with Tom McMahon, that gives a little bit of insight, but I'm really eagerly looking forward to learning more about that.
As far as the other assets are concerned, I think farmland is going to be super strategic. We've got, you know, the biggest problem the world faces is overpopulation. There's not enough food to feed everybody. We need We need that farmland. We need it desperately. The thing is, if ever there was an asset class that falls into that category of, you know, only invest in things that you actually know about, farmland, first of all, from my interviews with Artem Milinchuk from FarmTogether, I really learned that this is an asset class where you need to know what you're doing because they think about diversifying. You know, there's types of farmland that are for crops like almonds that are really a luxury market that are not essential to feed the world. And they tend to diversify in certain economic events against the soybeans and the corn and the, you know, the other kinds of farmland. You gotta know about the different kinds of soil that are appropriate for different kinds of crops. And there's a whole lot to it and I don't know anything about it.
So it's an asset class that you need active management by somebody who really knows what they're doing.
A lot of people say to me, well, buy the farm ETF. You know, I don't know if that's just an ETF that a bunch of guys are shotgun approaching, just buying farmland without knowing it, or if a lot of thought goes into that. I'm impressed with the work that Artem and those guys do in terms of the fractional ownership market of farmland. I think when Grant spoke about farmland, he was really talking about the lifestyle choice of living on a farm. That doesn't suit my personal taste. I wouldn't live on a farm. But as far as owning farmland that's rented to farmers, I think it's an important asset class that I don't know enough about in order to do the investment myself.
Erik Townsend: I would do it through a fund.
Battery metals, kind of the same story there. I think battery metals are gonna be super important, but the big mistake everybody makes is to not recognize that battery technology evolves just like other technology. Yeah. Everybody's assuming right now that lithium-ion is forever. It won't be. There's new battery chemistry technologies that are being developed that don't use lithium. What do they use? Well, I don't know, 'cause I don't know enough about it. I imagine someday I'm gonna listen to a podcast where this, you know, kind of reclusive genius type with the sort of Chris Cole energy comes on, but he's an MIT PhD in batteries. Yeah. And he's running a fund and knows all about the fundamentals of where the chemistry is headed, which metals are gonna be important, and knows all about it, and he's running a fund to profit from it. I wanna find that guy.
Until I do, what I do know about this is nickel gets used in almost all of the different battery chemistry combinations. Cobalt gets used in some of them. I don't know enough about that market, but I think that These are things that I'd really rather invest through a vehicle that somebody else is managing who knows more about it than I do.
On the other hand, copper is something where I can just look at, you know, I know we have to build out a new electric grid. I know that electric vehicles, no matter who makes them, are going to need copper. I feel like copper has to be in our future. But as Ronnie said, right now at this moment, at the end of 2020, copper's had a really good run to What is it, Ronnie? 6-year highs, something like that?
Ronnie Stoeferle: 8-year highs, I think. Yeah, even.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, it's— this is not the buy-the-dip moment right now in copper. I wish I hadn't missed that one. So the next time we get a buy-the-dip moment in copper, I want to be really diving on it hard. But I don't feel like right now is the moment to pounce on copper.
Patrick Ceresna: In the interest of time, we're going to have to wrap things up. I want to thank both Grant and Ronnie for joining us. Thank you, Ronnie.
Ronnie Stoeferle: Thank you very much, gentlemen. It's been a pleasure and Merry Christmas and a happy, healthy, and prosperous 2021. Thank you.
Patrick Ceresna: And thank you, Grant.
Grant Williams: Guys, thanks for having me on the show. I really enjoyed the conversation.
Patrick Ceresna: And Erik, that's a wrap for our holiday special.
Erik Townsend: Thanks everyone. We'll be back next Thursday, January 7th, with our regular format and a terrific guest. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants And by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, a focused play on miners and holders of uranium.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests, and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com. MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, Patrick do not assume any responsibility for any investment decisions made by listeners. Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, related earlier MacroVoices episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 251 was prerecorded back on December 14th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, A focused play on miners and holders of uranium. There won't be any market wrap or postgame segment this week or next. Instead, we'll be bringing you a 2-part holiday special in which we're going to take a deep dive on the topic of fiat currency being debased in real value because of accommodative central bank monetary policy and expectations that the growing popularity of Modern Monetary Theory among policymakers will accelerate the pace of fiat debasement. And we're bringing in the big guns. Guns for this special series. Patrick Ceresna will host the series, and I'll be acting as a panelist alongside both Grant Williams, author of Things That Make You Go Hmmm and producer of the Grant Williams Podcast, and Ronnie Stoeferle, publisher of the In Gold We Trust report and fund manager for Incrementum.
In this week's episode, we'll start with a review of the major events of 2020, And then visit the topic of fiat currency debasement at a high level and consider whether there's anything that could change the view all 3 panelists share, that governments around the world are going to continue to debase the real value of paper money.
Then we'll distinguish fiat debasement from inflation and consider which trading strategies are appropriate to hedge each of these separate and distinct phenomena. We'll revisit the question of whether Bitcoin is replacing gold as the favored store of value hedge against These topics alone consumed more than a full hour of discussion and will complete this week's episode, but that's only half of our overall conversation. I'll be back at the end of this episode to tell you what to expect in the second and final part of our year-end series, which airs next week. Then we'll be back to our regular format with a market wrap and postgame segment on January 7th.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna, your host for this special series. Now, gentlemen, let's dive right in. It's easy for us to all declare that the government money printing is running out of control, and we've been all saying that for years, and it's a theme that resonates for most of our listeners. But let's face it, guys, 2020 has been a year where the central bank stimulus game took on entirely new proportions. Just a few years ago, the entire financial industry freaked out when the Fed expanded its balance sheet by half a trillion dollars in a single year. But in 2020, we saw that much central bank balance sheet expansion in a single week in reaction to the coronavirus crisis.
So as this historic year draws to a close, let's begin by taking stock of where we stand at the moment in history with respect to the subject of fiat currency debasement. Ronnie, let's start with you.
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, thanks, Patrick. It has been quite an interesting year. Let's put it that way. I just tweeted out just one thing that is so 2020. I just learned that there's a vegan climate ETF and the biggest positions are Tesla, Apple, Microsoft, and Mastercard. So I think this says quite a lot about the market that we are in. And I think that When it comes to 2020, it will go down in history books when all taboos have been broken.
Grant Williams, I think he once made a fantastic presentation called Nobody Cares. And it seems when it comes to debt and monetary discipline, nobody cares anymore.
Just to give you some comparisons between the COVID stimulus versus the 2008 financial crisis. In Germany, the stimulus was 10 times bigger than in 2008. In Japan, 9 times bigger. And in the US, 4 times bigger. Western European countries alone have allocated a stimulus almost 30 times larger than today's value of the Marshall Plan. And just in the first 2 months of this COVID crisis, governments worldwide announced a staggering $10 trillion Of stimulus. So I think it is really all about those taboos that have been broken. And let's say the narrative surrounding deficit spending has completely changed. So all the deficit hawks have basically been silenced. Now, as you know, I'm based here in Europe. And just to give you a few examples, France is now ruling out the return to the previous rules of the EU Stability Pact, the so-called Maastricht criteria. In Italy, we just had some senior Italian officials, including the Prime Minister's economic advisor, suggesting that basically the ECB should forgive government debt buying through quantitative easing.
Mario Draghi came out in the Financial Times a while ago and he said much higher public debt levels will become a permanent feature of our economies and will be accompanied by private debt cancellation. So I think that really this year is quite special. I've been writing a diary, a journal for the whole year. And I think it's really gonna be interesting in the next couple of years to reread all the things that have happened.
And just one more thing. I think the fact that Janet Yellen is nominated as the head of the Treasury is a highly, highly symbolic thing. Shows us that this relationship between fiscal policy and monetary policy, it is not a flirt anymore. It is basically a marriage, a wedding that we are seeing. So therefore, I think that when it comes to putting a term for 2020, it would be the break of all taboos.
And the second term would actually be the beginning of a crack-up boom. I think really if you read Human Action by Ludwig von Mises starting on page 400, he is writing about this crack-up boom, this flight into real goods. In German it would be Sachwerte. And he coined the term crack-up boom, but I think in German it is even better. It's called Katastrophenhausse.
And I think this is really what we are seeing now. People are losing confidence in paper money. They are rushing into real assets. And that's really From my point of view, that's the most important driver for investors going forward.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. So let's go to Grant. So Grant, from your perspective as well, where do we stand at this moment in history with respect to the subject of fiat currency debasement?
Grant Williams: Well, it's interesting. And Ronnie made a couple of really interesting points there. First of all, it's this marriage between central bank and Treasury, which I think is absolutely crucial. And it gives the ability to do things which are important and necessary and, and will be done. And I'll, I'll come on to those in a second. But I think, um, I think we have to take a step back as, as people who are focused on finance.
We have to— when we talk about what this year's meant, our view is very narrow. And, and if we, if we put aside what it's meant in markets, we put aside what it's meant in risk asset prices, you know, there are billions of people around the world for whom this year has nothing to do with stock markets, has nothing to do with bond prices. This is a year where they've faced personal loss, whether it's family members, friends who've actually lost their lives, or it's loss of job, it's loss of income, it's loss of business. And so what most people are going to remember 2020 for is wholly different for what we as practitioners in financial markets are going to remember it for. And that, I think, is a really important thing to try and step back and understand because—
Ronnie Stoeferle: Yeah.
Grant Williams: You're going to realize when you do that, that solutions being offered which play into the needs and desires of real people with real jobs in a real-world economy are very different to how we look at them through a financial lens.
And I think that point that Ronnie made about the Fed and the Treasury in a marriage now is important. And if you look at Australia, for example, you'll see the Treasurer down there, Josh Frydenberg, is talking about QE, which is—
Erik Townsend: QE.
Grant Williams: A new thing in Australia this year. I mean, several people, including myself, have been talking about how they were on a road to that. It was going to happen in Australia. Even when rates were at 3%, 4%, it was clear the path they were on. But they're now talking about asset purchases continuing until they become contingent upon the unemployment rate reaching a certain level.
And I suspect that's what you're going to see. I've had interesting conversations with James Aitken about this this week. You are going to see contingencies put upon asset purchases that impact the real world, i.e., we are going to keep buying X billion dollars of bonds a month until unemployment rates reach 4% or 5%, whatever it may be.
And the importance of that is clear. It allows policymakers the chance to essentially support Wall Street, support asset prices, but in a way that's very palatable to Main Street.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Grant Williams: Once they are told, oh, we're going to continue supporting things and continue applying stimulus until the unemployment rate reaches a certain percent, the transmission mechanism of that is just opaque enough that it'll give people comfort and they won't really understand what it means. Ultimately, I think we as financial practitioners understand what it means. It's more of the same. The game is going to continue to the heavily skewed benefit of Wall Street. As opposed to Main Street, but it's going to play very well on Main Street.
So I think Ronnie's point about the loss of faith in fiat currencies is true, but I don't think it's really begun yet. I still think we're not at the stage where people are losing faith in it. At the bleeding edge, people are, people who understand currency debasement, who understand loss of purchasing power. But realistically, it's the concept which By the time the masses wake up and understand what's being done to them, it really switches to panic very, very quickly. And we're definitely not seeing panic yet. We're seeing a rush into alternative assets. We're seeing a rush into real assets. We're seeing a rush into gold, into Bitcoin, all these things that can provide you with protection from that loss of faith. But I don't think the real loss of faith has occurred yet. I think we're going to need to see real inflation.
And more importantly, perhaps a nascent fear of real inflation before we start to see that part of this whole thing play out.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's circle to Erik here. Now, Erik, that you've listened to Ronnie and Grant give their perspective, how do you look at it differently? Do you have anything that you want to add to that?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's actually Kyle Bass's comment on last week's MacroVoices that comes to mind. We've crossed the Rubicon to a point of no return. And I guess for the last several years, you could have made the argument that it's hard to see how you could go anywhere other than the path that we're now on. But there was a little bit of room there. You could say, look, Trump was trying to put Judy Shelton on the Fed board, who's a believer in Austrian economics. Maybe, maybe, maybe somehow we could have grown our way out of some of the debt problems that we had. Changed our ways and gotten the Fed's balance sheet under control and so forth. But just as, you know, I'll just draw an analogy to a young person who goes out of control in spending money on their credit cards, living beyond their means.
For a while, it's plausible that they could get themselves out of it. And then you get to a point where they realize, they know perfectly well, eventually they're headed toward bankruptcy or, you know, some—
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Some very bad outcome.
And they stop worrying so much about what it's gonna take to pay off the debt or whatever, because they know it's never gonna be paid off. We've reached the point where any fantasy that we're gonna somehow not have any runaway inflation in real terms, we're gonna repay the national debt, we're gonna get into some kind of fiscal responsible state, it's out the window. We're past the point of no return. We cannot go back to that. And I think you see it from a monetary policy standpoint that there's no getting around the fact that we're going to see more and more central bank balance sheet expansion, more and more money printing, as some people call it. And it's not just going to be to create bank reserves anymore. We're gonna move across another Rubicon to creating money for the purpose of supporting the broader economy. And it's gonna do some good to help some people in need.
I'm for that part of it. But it's also going to unleash inflation, which eventually is gonna be unstoppable.
And I think the other crossing of the Rubicon is on the political front. We've gotten to a point now, and I talked to Pippa Malmgren about this 2 weeks ago on MacroVoices, where, you know, you've got— it's pretty clear that President Trump's efforts to stay in the White House are not going to work. President Biden is going to be the president. And the thing is, President Trump is not going to just go away quietly. He's probably gonna start Some kind of news network where he's going to continue to press his agenda. So the division that we already have in society and the tension between the extreme left and the extreme right in political circles is only going to get worse. And that getting worse eventually, I think, leads to the things that Ronnie alluded to and that Grant spoke about, which is— I agree with Grant that we don't quite yet have a situation where the masses are ready to give up on fiat currency.
And I agree very much with Grant that they don't really understand the shortcomings of fiat currency, most of them, well enough to get that. But the train has left the station. Everything is in motion to eventually get to this major societal breakdown that Neil Howe wrote about in The Fourth Turning. And I think it happens in the 2020s. I think it eventually gets much better in the 2030s. But I think it's gonna get pretty ugly. And it's clear to me, we're past that point of no return. There's nothing that can be done to stop it at this point. We know we're going to continue to debase fiat currency until something blows up the system. And it's just like a young person who says, okay, I know it's too late to pay it off. I'm gonna just keep on partying like it's 1999 until I eventually go bankrupt. And hopefully I can party for a while longer.
I think that's where we are.
Patrick Ceresna: Now I want to move on to our core topic of fiat debasement and ask each of our panelists to weigh in on where we stand in this story and whether there's anything that could possibly change our outlook. That's coming up next, right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how the markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Many of you have been asking when Abaxx stock will begin trading publicly, and that trading began last week. Abaxx now trades in Canada under symbol ABXX, priced in Canadian dollars. But more importantly for our American listeners whose brokers don't offer access to Canadian exchanges, the American Depository Receipt priced in US dollars is now trading on the US over-the-counter market under symbol ABXXF. That's Alpha Bravo X-ray X-ray Foxtrot.
Be sure to catch my interview with Abaxx co-founder Tom McMahon on last weekend's Smarter Markets. And be sure to tune in this coming weekend for my interview with Blockchain.com Chief Strategy Officer Charlie McGarraugh, which airs on Saturday, December 26th.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, now we've all been talking and writing about fiat debasements for years, and it's a theme that resonates for most of our listeners. But as a professional investor, our job is not to look for people who agree with us so we can just sit around and pat ourselves on the back. Our job as professionals is to constantly question our own investment narratives and consider what could make us wrong or what could cause investment strategies to fail. So I want to start with what will probably be the hardest question of the entire special series, which is with Janet Yellen as Treasury Secretary, And with MMT growing in popularity with policymakers, it's easy to jump to the obvious conclusions. The harder question is what could possibly happen that would invalidate our assumptions that governments will continue to debase the value of fiat currency relative to hard assets, or what might cause the investment strategies we pursue based on that belief to fail?
So let's start with Grant. What's your thought on that?
Grant Williams: Well, I think Erik really summed it up there when he talked about crossing the Rubicon. That's where we are. So at this point, realistically speaking, the only way out for the policymakers to not do what we're talking about, and by do it, I don't mean through choice, I mean being forced to do it, is growth.
If they somehow manage to generate 3% growth, the world looks very, very different and they've got something they can lean into and wind some of that some of that policy back. But if that's the downside, it's great if the world is growing organically genuinely. But there are so many variables stacked against that right now, it's very difficult to see how that happens. So for me, I'd be looking at signs that we were seeing real growth and not growth that was purely propped up by stimulus, which is— in effect what we've seen, obviously.
I think we also have to get through the period where the bills for the pandemic come due. We've seen what's been happening to central bank balance sheet. We've seen what's been happening to government finances in terms of deficit spending. And the results have been truly extraordinary. We are in places, just about every country in the world, particularly in the Western world, are in places now that They've never been before, nor did they ever consider they'd be. The US with $3.8 trillion in deficits, the UK close to $400 billion. These are numbers that don't just go away. You're going to have to try and plug a hole in these finances. So without that growth I talked about, you've really got 2 other answers, which is inflation and taxation.
And sadly, I suspect that taxation is going to be the most appropriate and the most straightforward road to be taken.
We are at the point where wealth inequality is enormous. And no matter what the Federal Reserve says, and it's so disingenuous of them to continually reinforce the fact that they don't see any direct linkage between their policies and income inequality. I mean, it's shameful, frankly. But we've reached the point where the only way they're going to fill these holes now is to take money from people that actually have it. The printed money won't work anymore. So we've already had Rishi Sunak, the English Chancellor of the Exchequer, British Chancellor of the Exchequer, put the country on notice that taxes are going to have to rise. He says in 2022, which I presume is to hopefully calm people down that the tax raises will be coming sooner than that.
But the longer this goes on and the longer it takes to kind of right the ship in terms of the pandemic and the damage it's done to economies, the more extreme these budget deficits are going to have to get. And that's necessarily going to mean the more extreme the taxation becomes. And we're going to be looking at wealth taxes. We're going to be talking about increased capital gains taxes. We're going to be talking about countries talking about global taxation like the US does. We're going to be talking about inheritance taxes. There are going to be all kinds of necessary grabs for people's— wealth that are going to put any recovery back.
So whilst it's not impossible, for me, the big threat, and I put that in inverted commas, is genuine organic growth in the economy. That's the threat to the policies we see being pursued at this point. But I think, as I said, Erik summed it up when he talks about them crossing the Rubicon. They really have no choice at this point but to continue pursuing this stuff.
Patrick Ceresna: So let's move back to Ronnie here. Now, Ronnie, you've obviously just heard what Grant was saying, but how could this play out differently than the basic narrative that we've been building up until now?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think that we sometimes tend to overcomplicate things. And this is also what my wife is always telling me. You're making things too complicated. Perhaps we should say, well, our view is not a mainstream view. When I talk to former colleagues, I think that 99% of them have no idea about the stuff that I'm thinking and writing about. Stuff like de-dollarization, CBDCs, MMT. Dollar milkshake theory, a monetary reform, a remonetization of gold.
Those are not mainstream views, and we should not overemphasize our egos. I think you know we have to be honest in the traditional investing world. Our names aren't extremely well known. So so so unfortunately, we still have. Pretty much of a contrarian position, I would say. And we tend to overestimate the filter bubbles that we are all in on Twitter, in podcasts that we listen to, newsletters, and books that we consume.
So I think that we definitely have off-consensus views that are slowly going into the mainstream, I would say. Because stuff like MMT, for example, We wrote about MMT already 4 years ago. Now it is really becoming mainstream. MMT is exactly delivering the message that people want to hear. It is a bad idea whose time has come. And I think that MMT might have sounded unbelievable a couple of quarters ago, but similarly, the idea that currency would be completely unbacked by anything real would have seemed ridiculous after the Second World War, for example. So therefore, I think that, as I've said, our view is becoming much more of a consensus view.
Now, coming back to markets, I think, you know, we have seen this year that the market is conditioned like a Pavlovian dog and it needs more and more stimulus. And any attempt of withdrawing liquidity or just even slowing it down risks pricking this valuation bubble. So of course, a deflationary bust can happen anytime. And the more bubbles and the bigger these bubbles, the less it takes to make them burst.
But I think it was really interesting if you have a look at inflation expectations in 2020 and if you compare it to 2008, 2009. This year, it took us exactly 6 months to recover when it comes to breakeven inflation rates. Just 6 months to recover from the whole deflationary bust. So in February 2020, we stood at 1.6%, then we collapsed to 0.5%, and then we recovered by August to 1.7%.
If we compare it to 2008, We dropped from 2.5% breakeven inflation to basically zero in November 2008. And then it took us until mid-2010 to come to pre-crisis levels. So this tells me that this time around, it is not only very, very aggressive monetary stimulus, but it is also very aggressive fiscal stimulus. And we're seeing that it has a much more direct impact on inflation expectations. And I think to answer your question, I think if we should really see this paradigm shift from a deflationary, disinflationary environment to an inflation environment, as for example Russell Napier, one of the strategists that I probably most enjoy reading and listening to, as he suggests, and he has been a deflationist for ages.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ronnie Stoeferle: Then I think we're still very, very early in this game. And I think that markets are already telling us that inflation will become one of the main triggers going forward.
Now, what does it mean for your portfolio? At the moment, the average age of a portfolio manager is 49. So basically no professional really knows how to navigate in an inflationary or stagflationary environment. So this is why I really enjoy talking to money managers from high inflation countries like Brazil, like Turkey, like Russia. They've got a completely different attitude when it comes to portfolio construction. And I think this is really something that, as I've said, we're still early on in this game, but we shouldn't overcomplicate things. I think that many of the things that we have been forecasting for a while, those are really materializing now.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, do you have anything to add to that?
Erik Townsend: I want to go back to your original question and really break it into the 2 separate parts that you asked it in. You said first, is there anything that could possibly happen that would invalidate our assumption that governments will continue to debase the value of fiat currency? I can't think of anything. I mean, even if you had some miracle invention, somebody invents cold fusion, makes it work, and all of a sudden all energy is Frankly, at least for the first few years, that would just screw up employment in the energy industry and cause more problems than it would solve right away. So I don't think there's any magical miracle cure. I think we're on a path where we've crossed that Rubicon. There's no turning back.
But the second part of your question, Patrick, is you said, or which might cause the investment strategies that we pursue based on that belief to fail. That's where we've gotta be the most careful, because the trap here is to say, look, this is the surest bet I've ever seen in my life. We know that fiat currency is going to continue to be debased, therefore gold can't lose. Well, wait a minute, stop. The market loves to make fools out of the maximum number of people possible, and there's a whole lot of us who have tended to believe that gold can't possibly lose in this environment. So that's where I think we have to really be circumspect and say, wait a minute, gold is really important historically.
For 10,000 years, it's been the go-to default scarcity asset that everybody kind of thinks of as what you invest in in order to hedge against the debasement of fiat currency. You know, yeah, 10,000 years is a long time. That's a big history. But you could say that for hundreds of years in medicine, Bloodletting was an accepted practice, or, you know, I can't think of another good example. But the point is, there's lots of things that do change with modern times. So is it possible that somehow this time around, even though they do continue to debase fiat currency, that it turns out to be that gold isn't really the big benefactor or the most effective hedge anyway? Because really, in today's society, Gold gets used in a few very specialized aerospace electronics applications, and it makes really pretty jewelry, but we don't really use it to run the economy.
If we think that we're gonna see this build-out of the green economy, Green New Deal, whatever you wanna call it, infrastructure spending, trillions of dollars of infrastructure being contemplated, that's gonna benefit copper, not gold. So I think it's the part of the question that's about The investment assumptions that we make, no doubt in my mind, we have to see an explosion of debasement of fiat currency. Are the assumptions we've made that gold and other precious metals are the right way to hedge against it the right assumptions? That's where I think we have to really question ourselves.
Grant Williams: Patrick, can I just jump in here and add to something Erik said there? And I think, you know, what you say is right, Erik, but I think in terms of gold specifically, you know, I think this Let's face it, the debasement of the dollar began in 1971. And realistically, in terms of central bank reaction function and the concerted efforts they're making to debase the currency, you could argue began around the turn of the century when they started bailing out LTCM and after Greenspan dropped rates essentially to the floor in 1999, 2000.
So had you looked at that point in time and said, they are going to debase the currency, I need to own gold. Well, you were buying gold at $250 an ounce. And here we are close to $2,000 an ounce. So over that period, gold has done exactly that.
Now, if we're looking to work out, okay, what's the best way to make money? What's the way to maximize my return under these inflationary policies, under these debasement policies? I think that's a completely different proposition for people. And so there's this idea that, okay, I want something that is going to protect me from debasement.
And it's not just gold, but there are other real assets that would have done a similar job, but gold is an easy benchmark to do that. But again, I think we as financial professionals aren't necessarily always looking to find something that will protect our purchasing power, but it's, okay, what's the best way? And what we mean, generally speaking, by the best way is the thing that's going to give me the highest return, not the safest hedge, if you like.
And I think it's an important distinction for people to make because you could have seen this coming at the turn of the century, bought some gold with a part of your portfolio, and really not had to worry about it at any point, even during that bear market we saw between 2000 and late 2011. And, uh, 2018, you were still in line or ahead of the protection that you'd bought it for. If you'd been trying to pick and choose the assets to give you the best return at a possible time and outpace the others, it's a, it's a much more stressful exercise. I think we can all agree on that.
Patrick Ceresna: That's right. And to continue on with that, then, Erik recently interviewed Goldman Sachs' global head of commodity research, Jeffrey Currie, on that new Smarter Markets podcast, and Jeff said something I thought was really important. He explained that we had a strong case for fiat debasement, and we also had a strong case for a return of inflation. But Jeffrey made a really big point saying that they're not necessarily the same thing, and he went on to emphasize the hedging strategy against inflation is different than the hedging strategy against fiat debasement. So I think we have to stop and really ask ourselves whether we're concerned about the return of inflation or the continued debasement of the fiat currency or both. And if it is both, I think we need to stop and think about the degree to which we have the confidence and conviction about each outcome and therefore how much risk exists to our hedging strategies if we are wrong.
So now, Erik, since you were the one who interviewed Jeff Currie, let's start with your view on this one. Are you worried about fiat debasement, wage-price inflation, or both? Or how would you approach the different trading strategies with each view?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think this ties in very much to the last point that Grant made just a minute ago, which is it really depends on whether you're trying to accomplish the safest hedge or derive the best return from a speculation, which is based on this understanding that fiat currency's gonna be debased. The debasement, and I think Jeff makes this really important distinction, which is debasement and inflation are 2 separate things. So let's start with the debasement argument.
I think hands down, the way you achieve the safety trade that Grant is talking about has got to be with gold, because you know that gold's not going to zero. As much as it may not be popular with a young generation, it's got a 10,000-year history. You know it's not going to zero.
On the other hand, if you said, I know that the fiat currency debasement is gonna continue. And as a speculator, I want to wager on this and make as much money as possible if I'm right. I'm starting to think, and I can't believe I'm saying this myself, folks, but if you look at all of the misplaced attention that's going into Bitcoin right now, and I do think it's misplaced, I don't think it's a smart idea, but that's what's happening. That's where the trend is right now. So I think especially if Bitcoin breaks out to new all-time highs as of when we're recording this, which is a couple weeks before it airs, folks. So that may have already happened now. If Bitcoin breaks out to new all-time highs and really gets some momentum going in a rally, I think you could easily see that even though Grant and I would probably agree gold is the smarter hedge here, where the action's gonna be is in Bitcoin.
But there's also plenty of room that Bitcoin could be outlawed by governments and crash to zero or crash to near zero. Gold's not going to crash to near zero. So I think it's a question of whether you're trying to achieve a safety hedge or if you're trying to speculate for maximum gain.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Grant, let's go to you. Do you have a different perspective? Is it just nuance between debasement and inflation? How do you think about it, or do you approach it differently?
Grant Williams: Well, I thought Erik did a great job with that interview. It was a really, really interesting conversation with Jeff. But I listened to it and I understand the distinction he was making between debasement and inflation. But I think it's important to understand the part of the cycle we're in. Because if you look at, if you look at the inflation of the '70s, it was triggered by debasement. The inflation we saw in the '70s was triggered by the debasement of the US dollar when Nixon closed the gold window in August of '71.
If you look at the inflation we saw in the 2000s, there was a lot more of that inflation that was driven by growth. It was China's insatiable appetite for commodities, which is a big reason behind that Behind that spike of inflation we saw, it wasn't overt debasement, even though that was going on to some degree through low interest rate environment. But I think the point Jeff's making is somewhat moot in this case, because the inflation that I suspect we are going to see in the next year, 18 months, is the kind of inflation we saw in the '70s that is a direct result of debasement.
So whilst I understand the point he's making, that debasement inflation aren't the same thing, I think the kind of inflation we're in for is the inflation where Ronnie made that point earlier on about the panic that sets in when people realize and they start buying goods, they start hoarding. It's the road to hyperinflation we've seen in so many banana republics over the years, to say nothing of Weimar Germany in the '20s. It's that kind of inflation that results Not from strong growth and a desire for raw materials to build infrastructure, even though we may get that. It's basically this time, it's going to be triggered by debasement. So that is, I think, that makes them one and the same thing in this particular instance.
Patrick Ceresna: Ronnie, do you have anything to add to that?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, I think it's a very, very interesting thought by Jeff Currie, and I really have to think about it. But I think when it comes to— it is pretty similar, I would say. So what I always do with people telling me, well, gold has risen too far, I tell them, no, it's not the price of gold that is rising. You just need more units of euros or US dollars to buy one unit of gold. And it's the same with real estate, with stocks, with commodities, and so on. So once you convert your thinking. It gives you a totally different perspective on this devaluation and the debasement. A friend of mine, he's from former Yugoslavia, and he only calculates prices for real estate, for example, in ounces of gold.
And I think once we change our thinking in that direction, I think everything makes a bit more sense.
Now, when it comes to inflation, how to hedge from inflation, we just published a paper called Inflation: The Boy Who Cried Wolf. It is 40 pages about our inflation case for the next couple of years and how to basically stabilize your portfolio and to structure your portfolio. And we crunch the numbers and it is pretty clear. The highest correlation coefficient between a change in the 10-year breakeven inflation rate and various sectors. First of all, it's commodities, 0.7% correlation. Then it's energy, 0.67%, materials, industrials, and then down to real estate, which basically has no correlation to inflation. Negative correlation to inflation, obviously long-dated treasuries. -0.5 and the US dollar -0.44. So if you want to hedge against inflation, obviously commodities, energy, and precious metals are a pretty good bet.
Many people often tell me, well, equities are the perfect inflation hedge. And, and then I think you really should have a very, very close look at the sector. There's a brilliant article by Warren Buffett. He wrote it in 1977. It's called How Inflation Swindles the Equity Investor. So if you want to hedge against inflation with your equities, you should have a close look at average profit margins, labor share of costs, nominal debt levels, and of course if it's a cyclical or a defensive stock.
So how do we structure our inflation portfolio? We've got one fund that focuses on inflation with basically our proprietary inflation model that tells us when to play defense and when to play offense. And we've been playing defense for quite a while, which is really hard for a fund manager. But now our signal gives us maximum inflation signals. So we have structured a diversified inflation portfolio consisting of Commodity currencies like the Russian ruble, the Canadian dollar, the Australian dollar, a financial index on commodities, the Bloomberg Commodities Index has a future on it. Of course, equities from commodity producers in the gold, silver, and diversified space, also uranium and copper plays, and some options. So this is basically our way to hedge against inflation and perhaps to profit from inflation. And I think, you know, When it comes to commodities, you have to be very careful with rolling costs. So, you know, I see many charts that are a bit misleading telling us how cheap commodities actually are.
And it's not that easy hedging against inflation with commodities. So you really have to do your homework.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I'd like to add a few more comments here because honestly, as I was listening to Grant speaking, I realized my first answer, I was really reacting to what he said on the previous Great. So coming back to Jeff Currie's distinction between inflation and fiat currency debasement, they really are 2 different phenomena.
And I think the trap here for investors is you can say, as we've already said, I think all 3 of us agree, there's just no getting around the fact that we're on a path toward more fiat currency debasement by governments. It's coming. It's so tempting To in the very next breath say, therefore, there has to be runaway inflation. And those are not the same thing. And if anything, the last 10 years of quantitative easing have taught us so many people, myself included, incorrectly concluded when QE1 was announced, okay, this is gonna be wildly inflationary. And it wasn't, because what ended up happening, well, it was wildly inflationary to asset prices, but But not to wages and prices because that money never got spent into the real economy. It got spent into financial markets. So I think you do have to think of them separately.
And what Jeff said is, if you're thinking or worried about hedging against fiat currency debasement, gold almost by definition is your hedge trade there. But if you're thinking about hedging against inflation, oil and copper and things that actually are in the inflation basket are much more important.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And the way I think about this is the trap that we don't wanna fall into is we know for certain that there's gonna be a lot of fiat debasement. We don't wanna make the assumption of saying, therefore, inflation has to start tomorrow. We don't know that. It seems very likely to me that we're on the hairy edge here of a big return of secular inflation. That's kind of my base case, but we can't assume that with anywhere near the same degree of certainty that we can assign to the fiat debasement.
So the way I see this is, you know, gold, or if you are one of those people who believes that crypto is a better hedge against fiat debasement, then go with crypto. But whatever your fiat debasement hedge is, that's the trade that you know is certain right now. You've got to be in that. As far as whether inflation is really happening, I sure think it's coming soon. But, you know, I need to— to see it start to happen in order to make sure that I'm proven right before I put a whole lot of risk on the table. Whereas I feel very differently about my degree of conviction about the fiat debasement side of it. I'm very curious, Grant, with that explanation, do you feel any different than what you said? Because I was surprised by your answer.
Grant Williams: Well, no, as I said, I just— I think you're right. I think the question here for investors is, what exactly are you looking to achieve? And perhaps more importantly, Erik, is over what timeframe? Because this inflation bogeyman, Ronnie calls the report The Boy Who Cried Wolf for very good reason. We've had these inflation scares so many times.
And obviously QE1 was a big one of those. Everybody assumed it would happen. I think once we got to understand the function of QE, how it would work, and more importantly, the reaction function of it, we understood why the inflation didn't show up.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Grant Williams: But as I said, I suspect the point we're in right now is the inflation we get will be, as I said, the kind of inflation that is driven by currency debasement. It's a kind of, I need to spend this money and buy things with it before it starts to lose its value. So whilst I completely understand Jeff's point about the function of gold and the function, say, of oil Or copper, depending on what you want to hedge against. My point was you need to understand what it is you're trying to do.
If you're just trying to protect yourself from currency debasement, regardless if you think it's going to be inflationary, it's clear the path that central bank and policymakers are on is currency debasement. If gold is your natural hedge for that, then that's what you should be owning. If you also think you're going to get inflation, fine, allocate to oil and gold. As a, as either a hedge against that or a trade which you think you can, you can actually make returns on.
But understand your timeframe and understand what your primary goal here is. If it's to protect purchasing power against debasement, it's gold. If it's to hedge against inflation, it may well be other things. But I think in this case, gold will do a good job simply because the inflation we're going to get is going to be debasement-driven.
Patrick Ceresna: And now it's time to deliver a Christmas present to our many listeners who have been asking for more coverage on cryptocurrency topics. That is coming up next, right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Uranium, the fuel for nuclear power, is a contrarian investment whose returns are historically uncorrelated to other asset classes. Low uranium prices lasted for many years after the Fukushima meltdown, leading to substantial supply destruction. At today's prices, uranium mining is uneconomical even for the world's lowest-cost producers. Uranium demand is already estimated to exceed existing supply, and future demand growth is expected. New mines aren't economically viable at today's prices, leading analysts to predict that the price of uranium may need to double to over $60 per pound to incentivize sufficient new mine supply to meet expected demand. The NYSE-listed North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, offers investors exposure to both miners and holders of uranium. For more information, visit urnmetf.com.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Gentlemen, let's tackle Bitcoin next. Now, Erik and Grant both have expressed skepticism about the merits of Bitcoin as a true store of value, and they both make excellent arguments that are quite thought-provoking. But meanwhile, Ronnie has been raking in profits for his investors by holding the precious metals and crypto as a fiat debasement hedge. So my question is whether it's time to revisit that question of Bitcoin's role and There's a whole new generation of investors who are saying gold is outdated and Bitcoin is the modern-day replacement for it. So Ronnie, you're the one holding Bitcoin. Let's start with you. What's your take on all of this?
Ronnie Stoeferle: Well, obviously, it's both. Bitcoin and gold is very, very emotional. I remember I had presentations making the case for gold and people— I was lucky that they didn't shoot eggs or tomatoes at me. And then you've got, of course, those hardcore gold bugs, those groupies, but they tend to be male and most of the times above 60. So it is not something that makes my wife jealous. But I think that everybody has or really wants to have an opinion on gold and on Bitcoin. So if you go to a cocktail party and say, I like Bitcoin, Everybody will just say something. Nobody will say, I don't get it. I don't care about it. And it's pretty similar with gold, I would say.
Now, when it comes to Bitcoin, I think that 2020 is really the year when Bitcoin is moving into a new phase. It has kind of, let's say, graduated from college so that the heydays of youth are over. And we are seeing on our ends much, much more institutional demand. And this is coming especially from smaller entities with lean hierarchies that are entering the field. Those are family offices, those are smaller wealth managers that tend to be, you know, more pragmatic, more open. And I think the bigger those institutions get, the more topics like career risk and those biases become important. So we are clearly seeing much, much more interest from the institutional side. Something that we haven't seen in 2017, for example. It is also the year when big names like Stan Druckenmiller, Paul Tudor Jones are entering the market. I mean, Paul Tudor Jones, he said Bitcoin reminds him of gold in 1976 when he first got into business.
Then we've got insurance companies entering the market like MassMutual buying $100 million worth of Bitcoin. We have seen MicroStrategy basically investing all their cash on their balance sheet into Bitcoin. From my point of view, it's a pretty risky position for a CEO. But of course, now he's like the big guy, Michael Saylor.
But we are seeing many of those signs that it's really becoming more and more accepted in the traditional investment space. I think what we are doing in one of our funds, we are trying to rebalance between gold and Bitcoin. And for some reason, I got lots of criticism for that. I think people know our In Gold We Trust report. And we are writing about Bitcoin in the report since 2014. We are comparing the stock-to-flow ratio of gold and of Bitcoin. We are talking about all those gold-backed digital currencies. Most of them, I would say, are rubbish. We're talking about all the scams in the industry. So I think we've been really open to this idea, but still we get lots of criticism, especially from the gold camp, I would say. And, you know, it reminded me— somebody said it reminded me of cheating on my wife with my mother-in-law. And I thought, yeah, well, that's not the idea, but I am not married to gold and I'm not in love with Bitcoin.
It's just the result of our thought process and our research. And I think with Bitcoin at the moment, I think it's really something that gives your portfolio a positive skew. So we hold in this fund gold for the stability and digital gold, which is Bitcoin in that case, for the convexity. We've got a strategic asset allocation of 25% in Bitcoin and 95% in gold. We use the volatility of the market. Volatility for us isn't something bad, it's, it's, it's something fantastic. So we are writing options and make use of that volatility.
And from my point of view, you know, I think going forward we, we should not forget that, you know, when you talk to younger market participants, like for example Our neighbor's boy, he's like 12 years old and his whole world is in a digital sphere. So it is just normal for him to trade certain goods in this Fortnite game. For him, you know, things like Bitcoin is just something natural for him. And we shouldn't forget that this asset class is still extremely young and it is developing. So there are lots of scams around. There will be bubbles that will burst. But from my point of view, Bitcoin really did a tremendous job over the last couple of years. And the dominance of Bitcoin versus the rest, all those altcoins, or they are sometimes also labeled shitcoins, I think that Bitcoin really came out as the best coin, as the best store of value coin. And therefore, I think It is not something that will be forgotten over the next couple of years.
I think at some point it will just be normal to have digital assets as a part of your portfolio.
Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, let's go to you there. What's your take on where we stand with Bitcoin as an investment asset?
Erik Townsend: Well, let's step back to what we're trying to accomplish. If you want to hedge against fiat currency debasement, The way that you do that is you buy whatever scarcity asset you think society would be most likely to turn to if the whole system collapsed, the fiat money lost all of its value, you had to go back to something that has tangible value because of its scarcity.
You have to realize that if you're going to a scarcity asset because systems are collapsing, you know, it's kind of a tradition question. Why is it gold? Well, it's always been gold for 10,000 years because gold is the element in the periodic table, which is— it's very scarce. It's something that's been treasured culturally for hundreds of years, thousands of years. People make jewelry out of it. Everybody just kind of agrees that it's worthwhile. On the other hand, if you were to say that gold's got 10,000 years of history, blah, blah, blah, blah, it sounds Great.
Look, in 1993, if you said, forget about this internet stuff, newspapers have for hundreds of years been the de facto go-to source for news and information. Nobody's gonna use this new internet thing. Forget about it. Well, no, actually, modern times modernize things, and things like newspapers get put out of business by the internet. So Bitcoin is, and cryptocurrency in general, is the new age invention for a virtual, only exists in cyberspace, digital scarcity asset. It is the replacement for gold as a scarcity asset. So do you think if society collapsed that we would go back to gold or that we would go back to Bitcoin as the store of value because we're in a new era where people don't really care about shiny gold metal? And we need something to transact on, and we've got this established thing that works on the internet called Bitcoin, and a lot of people believe in it.
You could make an argument for either one. Now, the reasons to be concerned about Bitcoin, number one, and these, as I laid out in my book 2 years ago, the number one reason to be concerned about Bitcoin as a long-term investment is that it's very much in the best interest of governments to figure out what an The incredibly huge threat it poses to their power and authority over society, and to outlaw it for that reason.
And to be clear, I'm not personally advocating outlawing Bitcoin. I think it would be wonderful if Bitcoin took over and we really did replace government-controlled money with, with an alternative that's private sector. But I don't think governments are going to let that happen long-term. So a lot of people will tell you Bitcoin was designed to be completely impervious to being outlawed. That's nonsense. Governments could outlaw the conversion of fiat currency to and from Bitcoin, and they could just make it illegal, which would cause institutional holders to be unable to invest in it. And they would never be able to completely eradicate it, but they could certainly cause major problems for Bitcoin if they wanted to. So far, to my complete astonishment, governments don't seem to get it. They just don't understand why it's a threat to them. They don't understand the risk it poses to them, and they're not doing anything about it.
Now, the other thing that I did acknowledge in my book two years ago is I said the longer this goes and the more institutional investors and well-moneyed investors start buying Bitcoin, then the less politically expedient it's going to be to outlaw it someday.
It becomes more and more difficult to outlaw it the more people hold it, and as As Ronnie said, we've got the Paul Tudor Joneses and the Stan Druckenmillers of the world starting to invest in Bitcoin. If that trend continues and governments continue to stay, just lay asleep at the switch, not paying attention here, it's going to be politically very, very difficult to outlaw it. And that's going to change the game.
The other risk to Bitcoin is that it's based on a distributed ledger architecture called blockchain, which relies on proof of work. It's very inefficient. People are inventing better ways to skin a cat. Now, the problem that Bitcoin has is cultural. The Bitcoin miners are kind of in control of the Bitcoin system. This goes back to Upton Sinclair's famous quote that it's very difficult to get a man to learn something when his salary depends on him not learning that thing.
What's going to happen is we're going to get to the point where cryptocurrency doesn't need mining anymore. Have faster, better, more reliable digital currency systems that don't need mining and don't need proof of work and are much more efficient. But is Bitcoin, which is controlled by this culture of miners who are able to essentially, if they have the right kind of computer equipment, print their own money in Bitcoin, are they going to give it up and allow their precious Bitcoin network to transition to something that basically puts all the miners out of business because they're obsolete? And is it possible that as they take that question on, that that makes them vulnerable to another currency system which doesn't have mining coming and taking all the market share and basically wiping them out because something better came along?
Those are the big risks to Bitcoin. And I'll be the first to admit, I thought 2 years ago when I wrote my book about this, that by now governments would be taking strong action to outlaw Bitcoin. They're not. So, and I think the other thing to consider is from a momentum standpoint, we're getting more and more people are convinced that it's the way of the future. And that means that in terms of price appreciation, the momentum is going to be in Bitcoin and it's going to take away from price appreciation in gold. I think it creates a buying opportunity in gold. I wouldn't be surprised if when Bitcoin breaks out above its previous all-time highs, If that results in maybe a correction all the way down to say $1,350 or so in gold. And if that's the case, I'll be buying more gold, not buying any Bitcoin.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's go to Grant. And now that you had a chance to hear both Ronnie and Erik, do you have different perspectives on Bitcoin?
Grant Williams: Well, I always kind of chuckle when people ask me about Bitcoin because I am self-confessed, professed, whatever you want to call it, I am not a Bitcoin expert. What I find interesting is I understand, having spent so much time looking at precious metals, understanding the gold market, understanding the history of gold as money and as a store of value, I completely understand the case for Bitcoin. So the reasoning behind it, the rationale makes perfect sense to me. I get it. I understand it. I believe in it. Check that box.
The part where I struggle, and Erik touched upon it, I basically, I'm yet to be convinced there aren't some really meaningful hurdles to this thing that make it far more risky than people who cheer about it from the rooftops think.
It seems to be a very simple thing to kill in terms of adoption. And Erik again touched upon that a short while ago. And I think what's happened recently is the confusion of something as the savior of the financial system versus something which is a tremendous speculative instrument in which you could make an awful lot of money.
It is absolutely most categorically the latter at the moment. And whilst I understand the case for it being, you know, this, this revolutionary new money, I think of Bitcoin as perfect money in an imperfect world. You know, I think it is perfect money, but unfortunately the world we live in is imperfect and There is no chance that our world will ever be perfect.
And unfortunately, as far as Bitcoin is concerned, the people it will ultimately be competing against, should it realize its potential, are in charge of making the rules in that imperfect world. And so it faces enormous challenges, I think, not to make inroads, which it's clearly doing, not to gain significant market cap, which it's also doing, not to create a lot of wealth, which it's also doing. But to survive.
That's going to be, I think, the challenge. And look, for every Bitcoin fan out there now throwing things at their screen telling me this guy doesn't know what he's talking about, that's absolutely fine. I hold my hands up to that.
I'm really going on the reading I've done, the understanding I've done. And I am keen to understand it better, but I struggle to understand a rational case for people putting their entire investment portfolio into Bitcoin, for example. Now, you know, Michael Saylor, who I'm incredibly impressed with, I think he's a, he's a very, very smart guy. He's a great speaker. He's very eloquent. He communicates his message very effectively. But he's become— I think, Ronnie, you touched upon it— he's become something of a Bitcoin Jesus.
And this thing becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, you know, raising $400 million in convertible notes paying 75 basis points of interest to buy Bitcoin. Is genius, right? When you already have half a billion dollars in Bitcoin and you have such a small market cap and you want to force more money into that market cap, it's great. This thing is going to go around, it's going to keep going up, it's going to keep feeding on itself.
But when I look at 95% of the Bitcoin is held by 2% of the accounts open, it just gives me pause. And, and I'm not saying I know what's going to happen, but what I am saying is I have serious questions which I'm very keen for people to understand it better than me to give me answers to, and I'm perfectly open-minded to be proven that these are concerns that I don't need to have.
But until someone can do that, until they can lay my concerns at rest, until they can answer to my satisfaction the fears I have about on and off ramps being made illegal, about Bitcoin being outlawed, about conversion into certain fiat currencies being outlawed. I view it as a great speculation, but I have trouble contemplating how it survives when it becomes the kind of threat that the people who admire it so much insist it's going to be. I hope that answers the question. As I said, I'm by no means any kind of Bitcoin expert.
Erik Townsend: Grant, I'd like to just ask a follow-on to that, because it plays back to something we talked about earlier. Would you agree with me that if you're talking about hedging, meaning safety, protect myself, my answer is no way on Bitcoin. It's all about gold, baby. On the other hand, if what you're talking about is I see fiat currency debasement and I want to gamble as a speculator and try to make as much money as possible if that turns out to be right, it seems like Bitcoin kind of has to be part of that strategy.
Grant Williams: Yeah, no, look, I completely understand. I mean, and I think you're 100% right there, Erik. And again, if you think about that as a strategy, then your next step is to understand the amount of protection you want and the amount of appreciation potential you want and calibrate accordingly. Ronnie's got 75/25 allocation gold/Bitcoin, which would seem to follow the rationale that you and I have.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Grant Williams: Some people would want more Bitcoin. Some people want all of it in Bitcoin. Some people want all of it in gold. I, I totally understand every single strategy here depending on your risk tolerance. But I think at the moment, at least, Bitcoin being touted as a store of value, I think, is— has yet to be proven. I mean, the volatility in it suggests there are any number of times that you could have bought Bitcoin as a store of value and seen 85% of your value wiped out.
And yes, people will say, well, if you'd bought it and held onto it the whole time, you'd be fine. But very few people who are looking to protect the value of their investments can stomach an 85% downdraft without either some point along the way or at the bottom cutting it because they can't stand the volatility. They're looking for a store of value, not a store of value that causes them sleepless nights.
So I think Bitcoin's got a lot of work to do, but right now, and I would add that I think that the run we're seeing now, which in many ways echoes what we saw in December 2017, this time I think it is different. And I talked about this recently, I think with Bill Fleckenstein and Fred Hickey. It feels different to me because it's because of what Ronnie's point about institutional money coming in. But I don't know how much of that is is. Smart investors understanding what a tiny free float there is in this thing and just how easy it is to push it up with a few headlines about $100 million here, $100 million there. What you won't read, I guarantee you, is if some of these guys who put $100 million in, whether the Druckenmillers and the Tudor Joneses of the world, quietly exit their positions in Bitcoin.
You won't hear that. That will not be a headline. But these guys, let's not kid ourselves, are savvy enough to look at the, look at the size of the market, look at at what headlines do and understand, you know, there's a very, very easy way to make some serious money here.
And good luck to them.
Patrick Ceresna: Gentlemen, this has been a great discussion so far, but unfortunately we've run out of time for this week's episode. Erik, before we close, please give our listeners a sense of what's coming up in part 2 of this series, which airs at 9:00 AM Eastern time on New Year's Eve.
Erik Townsend: Next week, we're going to start by revisiting Goldman Sachs commodities chief Jeffrey Currie's important distinction that fiat debasement and inflation are actually 2 separate risks which require 2 separate hedging strategies. Then we'll go through all the various fiat debasement and inflation hedging trades, from precious metals to crypto to crude oil to base metals to farmland, and compare notes between our panelists on which trading strategies make the most sense. All of that is coming up next week in part 2 of this series. And airs on Thursday, December 31st at 9:00 AM. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, a focused play on miners and holders of uranium.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account. At MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.
MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, related earlier MacroVoices episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.