Luke Gromen — Forest for the Trees founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Opening: episode preview and sponsors

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 235 was recorded on September 3rd, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by toptradersunplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by farmtogether.com, Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors. Forest for the Trees founder Luke Gromen is back as this week's feature interview guest. And of course, I'll be asking Luke the same question I've asked most of our other recent interview guests: is the US dollar having that Luke Gromen moment that he's been predicting for years?

We'll also discuss the stock market, US fiscal situation, gold, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, when Patrick and I will take a deep dive on the question of whether or not we're seeing a stock market top, or if this is just another buy-the-dip opportunity as stocks sell off sharply today on Thursday, the day that we're recording. We'll look at the tech stocks, and we'll also move on and take a look at term structure of both crude oil and natural gas futures.

Market wrap: S&P 500 reversal day

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's talk equities. The S&P 500 at the time we're recording is down 120 S&P points on what is the first major reversal day since start of the summer. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Reversal day. I totally agree with that. This is a reversal day by, by any measure, that's for sure. But I'm blown away by some of the headlines that I'm seeing online. The stock market is crashing! It's crashing! Okay, wait a minute. Let's define crashing. What the stock market has done today is it sold off sharply all the way down to levels that have not been seen since Wait for it— a week and a half ago when they were all-time highs. And by the way, they were all-time highs hundreds of points above the previous all-time high. So, you know, there was another ZeroHedge headline today I was really surprised by. It said the S&P 500 is inexplicably selling off.

Patrick Ceresna: Inexplicably?

Erik Townsend: I think the explanation is because it's been in a parabolic rise for several weeks with almost all green candles, and it was way overdue for some kind of technical pullback. So the real The real question we've got to focus on, Patrick, is not what's the crash, because that's silly, but rather, are we seeing a topping process beginning? Is there reason to expect that, or is this just a simple technical pullback and a buy-the-dip opportunity? That's going to require some more time, so let's save it for the postgame segment.

Market wrap: US dollar bounces toward 93

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US dollar, because it looked like a week ago that the dollar was ready to start a new leg of its downtrend, but really in the last few days has worked its way back toward the 93 handle, not yet above it, but I mean, are we going to still see more weakness in the dollar? What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: I think it's too early to say. What we're seeing so far is a textbook bounce off a very oversold condition, and you'd expect a bounce here. The question is, is that a dead cat bounce, or is there actually a bottom being put in here? I'm not sure yet. I think we need to wait and see what happens. Certainly though, Luke Gromen is the man who's been calling for years now for a very, very significant secular decline in the US dollar. Has one started? Is that what this is about? Or is that still over the horizon? Let's ask Luke in the feature interview.

Market wrap: crude oil breakdown and inventories

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because for pretty much the entire month of August, we were within a $2 range, a 5% range on crude oil. And suddenly, in the last few days, we've finally seen some volatility. It broke to the downside, but is this the start of a big sell-off in your mind?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I wanna say, boy, okay, finally. Let's look at the chart after more than 2 solid months of consolidation. We're finally seeing clear signs of that move to the downside that I've been predicting for, what, 3 months or something now? Okay, but wait a minute. Regular listeners know how many times in the last 2 months have I said, okay folks, it looks like we're finally seeing the beginning of that move to the downside, and it turns out that we put in a very buyable bottom and that was it. So it does look again on the chart to me, looks like, hey, this is, uh, maybe looking pretty serious here. We are from a seasonality standpoint, we're past August, we're past summer driving season. This is usually when the oil market tends on a seasonality basis to top and to start to move down. And there's a lot of concern in the marketplace now about refinery runs last week in the EIA data report.

And also, just in general, concerns about weakening demand in the face of the coronavirus crisis clearly not being over as people had thought. So, seems like lots of reason to think the sell-off is upon us. But frankly, Patrick, as much as the last couple of days of tape action look like it's all to the downside. This market bottomed at $7.30 this morning before the US session even opened, and it's been up all day. Now, we haven't gotten back quite— I would say $42, which is the 34-day continuation chart moving average. I'd say that if we had seen a close above that figure, above $42 today, I would have said, okay, uh, this was a, a bear trap, we're going to see a recovery here.

Where we stand right now is we're recording just after the pit close on Thursday afternoon at 41.41. We're right on the 55-day moving average. I could see this going either way. Maybe this is just a dead cat bounce, so there's still lower numbers to come. Maybe we are actually seeing that recovery. Normally I'd say, as I read this chart, looks to me like there's more downside to come. But boy, how many times have I said that in the last couple of months and been proven wrong? So maybe this will be just another buyable dip. We'll see what happens. But I think this one, just from a seasonality perspective, maybe has more room to go to the downside.

Let's move on to inventory. Wow, huge numbers this week, and it wasn't bearish data. It was actually what should have been bullish data. Crude oil drawing down 9.4 million barrels from officially designated commercial storage and another 1.3 million barrels from the government's Strategic Petroleum Reserve. But remember, that's been leased out for commercial storage. So I think that that whole number of more than 10 million barrels—10.7 it works out to—was probably effectively the commercial drawdown.

That should be. That would normally be a very bullish indication. Cushing, Oklahoma building 110,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 4.3 million barrels. Distillates drawing down 1.7 million barrels. So with the small exception of a de minimis build in Cushing, Oklahoma, it was drawdowns across the board. That would normally be very bullish news. But frankly, it wasn't enough to overcome selling that had already begun.

A lot of analysts think that it was the reports of lower refinery runs indicating weakening demand, as well as the outlook around the COVID-19 pandemic crisis. US production was down dramatically to 9.7 million barrels. That's more than a million barrels down from last week. Sounds like, oh my gosh, boy, it must be that Art Berman is being proven right in spades. Well, wait a minute, folks. This was numbers that were impaired by a huge, massive storm in the Gulf of Mexico, temporarily shutting in almost all Gulf of Mexico production. So it So it comes as no surprise that we had a massive temporary shortfall of US production. I expect that number to bounce back up as that production comes back online. Storm's over now. Tape action wasn't nearly enough to offset selling that was already in motion before the data came out, and we continued to sell off for the rest of the day. $3 move down before it was all said and done as of 7:30 this morning from where we started a couple of days ago.

But, you know, it's going to be really interesting to see what the next couple of days bring because this bounce we saw today day was pretty darn formidable.

Market wrap: gold consolidation

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to gold. So during the early part of the summer, we saw that huge surge almost to $2,100 on the upside of gold. And since then, for the last month, we've just been consolidating, giving a chunk of it back. And we saw a false rally earlier this week, and it looks like gold is still very weak. I mean, do you think there's still more to the downside correction, or, or is this almost over?

Erik Townsend: It's not clear to me whether this correction has farther to go to the downside. Frankly, I hope it does. I think it would be good to clean out the system, so to speak, and pave the way for a healthier bull market going forward. One thing I feel very confident of is there's no doubt that the long-term picture here is governments are gonna continue to debase fiat currency. It's a bull market for gold, and I think it's gonna stay a bull market for gold. But hey, we're way overdue for a serious technical correction. I know I've been saying that for months and months, and it hasn't happened. Is it finally starting, or is this just a temporary little blip?

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: And time to buy right now? Well, it's hard to say. We'll see what happens. I'll certainly be asking Luke Gromen because he's been bullish gold for years and years.

Market wrap: 10-year Treasury yield and the bond bull market

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's just touch on the 10-year Treasury yield because it really looked like yields were breaking out. I mean, we were almost over 75 basis points late last week. And since then, it's been giving it all back. We're almost back down to 60 basis points. What's next for Treasury yields from here?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, as our regular listeners know, I really don't have any opinion short-term what's going on here, but I think that the uncertainty you're seeing in the market is probably because a lot of other people are wrestling with the same question that I'm wrestling with, which is my view is that the 35-year bond bull market is going to end with a shift to secular inflation sometime between tomorrow morning and 3 years from now. Okay, is it starting now or is it not time yet? Well, my focus going forward is gonna be to try to refine that timeframe. But my basic view is we're gonna see an end to this 35-year bond bull market.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: market will probably move into at least a significant consolidation period and then eventually a bond bear market. But does that start now, or does it start next year, or does it start the year after that? I'm going to continue asking our feature interview guests.

My inclination is it's not quite time yet. So I think there may still be more downside room in yields before eventually we see a secular reversal.

Why Luke Gromen is back

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks, Erik. So this week's feature interview guest is Forest for the Trees founder Luke Gromen. Now, Erik, why did we Luke back on the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, our regular listeners know the question that I've been asking all of our feature interview guests is, hey, is the US dollar having that Luke Gromen moment that Luke's been predicting for years? And we've gotten quite a few different reactions to that. Everybody is familiar with Luke's views. Is he going to be proven right, or is he still early? We've got lots of different views. I thought it was well past time to ask the man himself. Does Luke think This is the moment where he begins to be proven right, or is this just one step along the way? I think you're going to find Luke's answers very interesting. Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve.

And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure. Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.

Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment. books of all time.

You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Luke Gromen is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Luke Gromen: is this the 'Luke Gromen moment'?

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Forest for the Trees founder Luke Gromen. Luke, as our regular listeners know, I've been asking all of our featured guests the same question recently, which is Boy, weakness in the US dollar relative to other currencies caught some of us off guard. You're the guy who has been saying for years that the US dollar was headed for not just a little move down, but eventually a secular decline, a loss of reserve currency status, a sunsetting, if you will, of the dollar's hegemony over the global financial system. And what I've been asking All of our other guests is, okay, with this weakness in the dollar, is this just a little move down, or are we seeing the beginning of that Luke Gromen moment where you're proven right? And we've had a number of different views. It's an interesting coincidence that on Tuesday morning, as we're recording this interview, the dollar index broke at least intraday well below 92 for the first time in what, more than a year?

So I want to get your take from the man directly. Do you think that this is the beginning of the big move? that you've expected for quite a while, or is this really not deterministic yet to make that conclusion?

Luke Gromen: Well, I think the short version is it's too early to be deterministic. I think really when you look at what we've been saying, it's been that the— not necessarily that the dollar will lose reserve status, but that the dollar's reserve status as structured since 1971 will end. And not only will it end, but it's in the process of ending because historically, That system was we export dollars and those dollars are recycled back into treasuries. And basically a system where global central banks sterilize US dollar outflows by buying treasuries.

And so when you go back to, you know, 1971 to 1985, foreign central banks sterilized about 20% of US deficits. And then from 1985 to 2002, global central banks sterilized Call it 25%, 30% of US deficits. And when I say that, I mean in aggregate. In other words, for every dollar that the US debt increased, if I had 30 cents of that dollar ended up on foreign central bank balance sheets. And so basically what this amounted to is that Treasuries were the primary reserve asset of the world. The US government was basically emitting gold, or what used to be gold. And so, Treasuries were basically the primary reserve asset. From 2002 to 2014, foreign central banks sterilized 50-plus percent, 53%, I believe, of US aggregate debt increases.

And from 2014 until today, that number is -4%, which means the way the US dollar's reserve status worked for 50 years almost, already stopped. And what they've done instead is reserve gold. And you've seen, even as they've stopped buying Treasuries, they— foreign central banks have stopped buying Treasuries, they've been buying gold. So, my views has been, continues to be that the structure of the dollar's reserve status is already 6 to 7 years into changing. I think the pace of that is accelerating. When you then look at this particular move in the dollar relative to that longer-term view, I have sort of 2 thoughts.

The first is, given the way the world— that system worked, the US had to, by definition, run the biggest deficits in the world to supply the dollars to the rest of the world. So understanding that, we know that whenever this system starts to break down, the endgame is that the US has to print the mostest. And it's not even close. Because basically, as that system breaks down, Every nation has to finance their own deficits. And the only nation used to running really big deficits by virtue of the way the old system worked is the US. So we've always known that the US would have to print the mostest. The question has always been, and where the vigorous debate between myself and others that have been on the show is, is do they have to print the fastest? And that I think ties partly into what we've seen in this latest dollar move down, which is, We've all known the endgame, which is the US has to print the mostest, but the US was not printing the fastest over the last couple years until COVID.

And now when you look at what has happened since COVID the US has been printing the fastest and the mostest, and the dollar's responded.

The other thing I think within this particular dollar move that is noteworthy that most commentators that I have seen on the topic are not talking about, but which I think is a monumental move and which a number of other financial analysts that I've talked to think is a monumental move is what the Fed did back in April when they exempted Treasuries from the supplementary leverage ratio calculations for the US banking system. And so basically what that means is that the banks can buy effectively an infinite amount of Treasury bonds And it doesn't count against their capital ratios, which was the case under Basel III up until that point. And so, it was in a way, a way of doing infinite QE through the US banking system without the Fed having to call it QE with the wave of a regulatory wand. And what's interesting is since the day that the Fed exempted Treasuries from the SLR, The US dollar, the trade-weighted dollar index is down, I think in 5 months, 5 months as of today, 7%.

So you're talking about almost a 15% annualized rate of decline in the dollar, maybe a little bit more. You've seen gold go up about 20% or 25%, gold miners up a lot more than that. So there's been, I think to summarize, the answer is we've been in this change of the dollar reserve status system. I think the dollar's gonna stay the reserve currency. I think the structure of that reserve currency has been changing. And I think if you look within that, then in terms of the tactical side of this dollar move down, the US is printing both the fastest and the mostest, whereas before we just knew they were eventually going to have to print the mostest. And then this SLR rule change that continues to not get enough airplay, in my view, I think is a really important thing in terms of also helping to explain this tactical move down in the dollar.

Why the US must 'print the mostest'

Erik Townsend: Luke, I've been transfixed for the last couple of minutes with one particular snippet of what you just said. You mentioned that you have said in the past that the US in the endgame will be forced to print the mostest. I'm gonna ask you to just briefly give our listeners a refresher on that, because some of our newer listeners may not remember your descriptions of that previously. But particularly, what really caught my ear was you said, and we're nowhere close to that yet.

Luke Gromen: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: So it sounds like even in the face of, you know, the heights of the COVID crisis with trillions of dollars a week in new central bank accommodation, you don't think that even gets to the printing the mostest that you define as a necessary part of the US dollar endgame. So, so how big is the mostest? But let's start with why the US will eventually eventually have to print the mostest?

Luke Gromen: Well, so why the US will eventually have to print the mostest is if you just look at a global ranking of current account deficits by nation. And I've put it on Twitter before, I can put it up there again. But if you look at the chart, you end up with the current account surpluses, surplus nations and regions over on the left.

The, the, by far the biggest current account surplus region actually is the European Union. Then you're followed by China and Japan. From there, things start to sort of get very plus-minus, right? A little bit of a surplus, and you have a whole probably 10 or 15, 20 nations that are a little bit of surplus. Then you get into a bunch of nations that are basically flat. Then you get into a bunch of nations that are tiny deficits. And then you get into 2 big deficit, current account deficit nations.

One is the UK, and as big as they are, they are dwarfed by current account deficit nation number 2, which is the United States of America.

And this isn't because the US is bad or because we're particularly profligate or any, any more than any other nation. It's, it's just a vestige of the way the post-1971 dollar system worked, which was we We ran these massive current account deficits and we ran capital account surpluses. And in other words, we emitted dollars. We became the Saudi Arabia of money. Saudi Arabia of money, as the Financial Times termed it in early 2019. And so, we had to emit dollars and then those dollars were emitted in payments.

So, let me back up. After 1971, we outsourced our jobs and our factories abroad. Those to foreign countries. Those nations would make stuff, send it to us. We would then emit dollars to those nations in payment. And then they would recycle those dollars back into our financial markets, into our capital account. And then that capital account recycling would help provide, number one, it would finance US government deficits at the Treasury buying Treasury bonds, ties into that point I made earlier about how many of our— or how much of our deficits were sterilized by foreign central banks. They rolled into US agency markets providing cheap credit to the US housing market. They rolled into US subprime markets, basically funded consumer lending so that US consumers could turn around and buy more of the goods those countries were producing. And so, the producers were on the current account surplus side. The United States was down at the biggest current account deficit side.

Now, all this works as long as those surpluses they're running are being recycled back into our capital account, into our capital account surplus. But my first point I made was in 2014, they stopped doing that at the Treasury bond level. They stopped buying Treasuries. So now, suddenly, our current accounts deficit, which is by far the biggest in the world, and which is more than 100% made up of US government deficits, not trade deficits, suddenly, we've got to finance our own deficits for the first time in 50 to 70 years. And there's no one around with enough balance sheet to do that other than the Fed. And so, we tried to finance it ourselves at first, and that describes what happened from 2014 through last year when you had this period of a rising dollar and you had rising LIBOR. And then last year, you had Fed funds rates get squeezed over interest on excess reserves.

And as the US banking system got force-fed Treasuries, and finally, the banking system ran out of balance sheet to buy these Treasuries last September. And that was the repo rate spike. And once the repo rate spike happened, the Fed had to begin growing their balance sheet again. And at that time, we said they're probably never going to stop.

And then we had COVID, and they tried to stop earlier this year. We had COVID, and that's why we have to print the mostest, is if you just look at that current account chart, we run the biggest deficits. And so, if we run the biggest deficits and the people financing our deficits stop financing our deficits, which they did 6 years ago, then we have to print the mostest.

How big is the Fed balance-sheet endgame?

Erik Townsend: Luke, you said that even in the face of current events, the COVID crisis, trillions of dollars a week, that we're, if I remember exactly what you said, nowhere close to printing the mostest yet. So how do we quantify? What does printing the mostest look like? What amount of balance sheet expansion are we really considering there?

Luke Gromen: Well, I would say, when I say no one's close to having to print as much as we are, in the endgame, no one's gonna have— no one has to print as much as we do because of what I just described.

Now, when we look at what the US did at the height of COVID in April, I think the number was a $35 trillion annual rate rate that the Fed's balance sheet was expanding at. I think if I remember right, and you smooth it out over April and May, I think the number was a $20 trillion annual rate. So that's over 2 months growing the Fed balance sheet at a 100%, nearly 100% of US GDP rate. That's pretty meaningful.

How much will we eventually have to do, I think, is dependent on a couple of factors. I think it's dependent on, the biggest one is US nominal GDP growth. And part of that also depends what happens to the dollar. So the problem ultimately, as Jeff Snider eloquently lays out, is you've got this Eurodollar system with all these dollar loans, and the Fed can't really address the problem, not directly at least, as things are structured now.

And he highlights that, hey, this is why things are going to be deflationary. That's why the dollar should rise, et cetera.

My view has long been that A, Jeff is right that that will cause a big problem. But where I and Jeff differ is when push comes to shove, and push will eventually come to shove, the Fed will just buy the whole year. They'll bail out the whole Eurodollar market. They'll have to. They won't have a choice.

And to me, one of the big aha moments of this year was a year ago, 2 years ago, 3 years ago, if I would've said, Luke, there's no way the Fed's going to grow their balance sheet, enough to bail out the entire Eurodollar market. It's estimated at anywhere from $60 to $100 trillion. There's no way they'll do that.

And I would've said, yeah, they will, or the system will collapse. And I think one of the big aha moments of this year was they grew the balance sheet at a $35 trillion annual rate for a month and a $20 trillion annual rate for 2 months. And so, I think it was very— when you say, how much will they have to do?

I think they've showed us they'll do whatever it takes. And the question then is, is what will it take? And that, like I said, is dependent on what's the economy doing.

If we don't get a recovery, then basically the Fed's balance sheet over time is going to have to move toward fully reserving the entire global Eurodollar system. So whatever that number is in your mind, that's the price target for the Fed's balance sheet. Now, if the US economy is able to begin growing nominally again, whether that is in real terms, or that is in inflation-adjusted terms, where the dollar weakens meaningfully, and inflation really picks up, and the Fed caps yields, then the price target for the Fed's balance sheet at the endgame is probably something meaningfully south of the total Eurodollar market needing to be bailed out.

Out. If the US is able to post real growth, significant real growth, or a massive acceleration in productivity, we come up with some new nuclear fusion, portable nuclear fusion energy source, and all of a sudden, the US economy just broadly accelerates massively, productivity growth massively accelerates, our entitlements are easily affordable, then the price target for the Fed's balance sheet comes down even further.

So, really, where do we go when we say how much is the most as if the Fed has to print depends on the inputs of, okay, what's the global economy doing? What's nominal GDP growth doing in the United States? What's productivity doing? What's the dollar doing? As it sits now on all those fronts, I would take the over on most price targets for where the Fed's balance sheet's eventually going. over the next couple years.

MMT, Stephanie Kelton and the Fischer BlackRock paper

Erik Townsend: Luke, unfortunately, Professor Stephanie Kelton has so far not responded to our invitations for an interview on MacroVoices. But if I could guess what she, as essentially the poster woman of Modern Monetary Theory, might say if she were in this conversation, it would be, Luke, you're missing the point. What you're calling the endgame is not an endgame. It's a long overdue social justice event where we finally figure out that what you're calling printing the mostest is the key to delivering social equalities and a better standard of living for the entire country. And we have been suffering from decades of misplaced policies. And what we need to do in order to get to where we should have been decades ago is to continue to expand balance sheets and do what you're printing the mostest.

And the argument that she's been making is, you know, obviously you have to worry about that leading to inflation. There are ways to contain inflation, such as raising taxes, that the MMT crowd tends to favor as a technique of controlling inflation. And there are ways to make this printing the mostest event not some dreaded endgame, but maybe the beginning or a new beginning. How would you respond to those arguments?

Luke Gromen: I, by and large, would agree with a lot of what she says. I don't think it's necessarily a dreaded endgame either. I think it's a dreaded endgame if you're long a lot of dollars. I think it's a dreaded endgame if you've got too much of your net worth in Treasury bonds yielding 65 basis points for 10 years, or JGBs yielding less than that, or Bunds yielding less than that. Yeah, that's pretty dreaded for those people. But I think bigger picture, I think that's where this is going. And I would one-up it or I would layer onto it away from what Professor Stephanie Kelton says.

I would direct listeners back to this BlackRock Institute white paper that we highlighted to our clients last August and have been highlighting, continually highlighting ever since. And this was written by former Fed Vice Chair Stan Fischer, who Harald Malmgren called— no less than Harald Malmgren called the ultimate behind-the-scenes actor. One of our best relationships on Wall Street has long called Fischer the godfather of central bankers. It was also co-authored by Swiss National Bank President, former Swiss National Bank President Philipp Hildebrand and former Bank of Canada Governor Jean Boivin. And the punchline of this report is this, is that they said in the next downturn, in the next crisis, We are going to go direct. We are going to do our version of MMT.

And then we're going to also expand the balance sheet. We're going to do direct monetary financing and deficits, MMT. And then we're going to cap yields to offset any rise in interest rates that would hurt the stimulus or that would hurt the stimulative effects of direct monetary financing. And so that's to me, when I see what Kelton has written and what she would say, which I think I agree with your assessment of what she would say, and I agree with her assessment. And then I layer on what Fischer, the godfather of central bankers, is saying.

I think that's where this movie is going. And in the aftermath of COVID we're seeing signs that that is rapidly being put in place. And that to me is, like I said, it represents a significant change to the structure of the dollar's reserve status. And I think it would be arguably, probably would be a really good thing.

I mean, the system we have now has people rioting in the streets. So, that's probably the biggest tell there is. We can hedonically adjust whatever we want. But the fact of the matter is you've got multiple American cities burning all over the country. Something's not working anymore. And so, when you see this white paper saying effectively exactly what Kelton's saying, except it's coming from the godfather of central bankers and the BlackRock Investment Institute, to me, the gravitas associated with that in terms of policy circles, and then what we've seen since March, I think it's already underway.

Does the dollar need a catalyst? Events walking up the fairway

Erik Townsend: I'm going to take this opportunity to ask our listeners to help us persuade Professor Kelton to come on MacroVoices. both by encouraging that on Twitter and through other channels. Luke, I want to come back to the reactions I've gotten from our other guests to my question, you know, is this the Luke Gromen moment?

What Brent Johnson told us last week was, look, Luke's going to be proven right in the end for sure. The thing is, some kind of big catalyst is needed. You've either got to have a viable alternative to the dollar as reserve currency, or you've got You have, you know, a revolt where a whole bunch of countries stop doing business with the US and, you know, stop trading in dollars.

Something, some event has to happen in order to bring about the magnitude of change that you've been forecasting. Other guests that we've had on this program have said similar things. I can remember Dr. Lacy Hunt, not on this podcast, but on an interview with Grant Williams, said, you You know, watch for the emergence of a digital currency that threatens the dollar's hegemony and monopoly over the global financial system. That certainly echoes the predictions I made in my book, Beyond Blockchain, back in 2018.

It seems though, from what you said, you don't really see a need for a catalyst or an event to occur because you see the process as already in motion for several years Now, is that correct? Is it important to wait for or to watch for some big event that brings about a secular decline of the dollar? And is there any legitimacy to this argument that that's a prerequisite to your predictions becoming true?

Luke Gromen: No, I think it's— as you look, a lot of these things, they tend to happen little by little and then all at once. And so I think these guests are correct in saying I'm looking for the all at once.

What I would say is that it was an interview that was given by former CEO of Nike back in, I think, 2000. And what he said was, everybody's looking for the next Michael Jordan on the basketball court, but what they don't get is that he's walking up the golf fairway.

And he was, of course, referring to Tiger Woods. And so, I would equate that the metaphor here is everybody's looking for the event, in the events of 1944 or 1971, whatever their event might be. But the events are walking up the golf fairway. They've been walking up the golf fairway.

When global central banks stop buying US Treasury bonds on net for the first time in 70 years, that's an event. When China, with the digital currency that they are very far along and they're testing it, rolling it out over the That's an event. When you see Russia stop storing, the biggest energy exporter in the world, stop storing Treasuries and instead reserve gold, that's an event. When you see the article we saw last week, which showed that for the first time, the majority of trade between Russia and China is not being done in dollars. It was 80% to 85% share of trade in '85. its 45% share of trade between Russia and China.

And some people would say, well, those are just 2 rogue nations. Maybe they are, maybe they aren't. I try to look at it more objectively and just say, those may be rogue nations, but they're also the world's biggest energy exporter and the world's biggest energy importer and energy consumer. And when you have the biggest exporter and importer of anything, that's called a market.

And so the market is moving away from the petrodollar. That's a fact. That's just— you just described what it is, right? So, it's one of these things where people are looking for the all at once.

And then I guess when you talk about events, and are they looking for Michael Jordan or are they looking for Tiger Woods? We had this little thing that happened in March. It was a global pandemic. They shut down the global economy. Global GDP fell 50% in the United States in the second quarter.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Luke Gromen: You know, Lacy Hunt had a great point. The net national savings as a percent of gross national income, it's negative as a result of COVID The other 2 times in which that chart was negative was 2008 and 1933, 1932. Only other times in US history going back to 1905 or something. And I look back and go, okay, well, what happened in 1930? That happened in '32. What happened in '33? Oh, the dollar was devalued 75%.

Right. What happened in 2008? Oh, the Fed went from an $800 billion balance sheet to $4.5 trillion over the next several years. And so I just think that there's— it's as I listen to these conditions that people attach to it, I tend to agree with almost all of them. I just think I'm watching the conditions as it's happening. I'm watching Tiger Woods walking up the fairway and they're looking for Michael Jordan on the basketball court, the next Michael Jordan on the basketball court. And so I really think it's more that type of of that type of dynamic.

I mean, even when you look at Lacy saying, hey, the Fed can lend, but they can't spend, I agree. But the US government can spend. And suddenly, if you look at the treatment of SLR, the SLR treatment of Treasuries after April, boy, the frictions between Fed and Treasury lending spending start to get blurred, best case. So, I think we are— is there still an event to come? Probably.

Patrick Ceresna: Probably.

Luke Gromen: But I think a lot of these preconditions that people think haven't even happened yet have already happened.

US fiscal condition and 'Moneyball' true interest expense

Erik Townsend: Luke, you just mentioned the US government's ability to spend. Let's move on to US fiscal condition. You know, it's so tempting when you have a major crisis like this pandemic, people kind of glaze over and say, hey, you just don't question it. It's a crisis. You know, the thing is, the borrowing and spending is really accelerating. I'm not sure if I should ask when or if. If that eventually comes back to bite us? So, what are the consequences and how do you see this situation developing from here?

Luke Gromen: Yeah. So, if you go back to 2018, about this time, and I'm sure we probably talked about it at that time, Erik, but at that time, we were noticing, and I'm almost positive I would've brought it up at the MacroVoices conference in Toronto 2 years ago, because we were writing a lot about it at that time for our clients. But the point is that Back then, we had 2 different, we'll call them investing graybeards. If I told you who they were, everyone would know who they are. And they've been at this game a very long time that are relationships of mine. And the thing they said to me as we were discussing the US fiscal situation, and they said something I thought was really interesting, which was historically, fiscal problems aren't a problem until the sovereign nation in question has to print the interest on the debt. And the US, again, nominally, looking for the Michael Jordan on the basketball court view, is that we're still a long way from that.

And what we looked at 2 years ago was, we called it the Moneyball view, the US's true interest expense.

And so, if you remember Moneyball, the whole premise of the book was basically the Oakland A's were able to build a competitive team on a very shoestring budget. Because baseball systemically underpaid guys that walked a lot relative to guys that hit a lot of singles, even though functionally there's no difference between a single and a walk. So what we said was the U.S.'s Moneyball expense or true interest expense to arrive at that number, you can't just look at the U.S.'s interest expense as given. You have to look at interest expense plus the pay-as-you-go portions of entitlements.

And once you start lumping the pay-as-you-go portions on as entitlements, because ultimately, the pay-as-you-go portions are really just the interest expense on those really big entitlement numbers, you got into a much more troubling picture for US fiscal situation. You got much closer to that point where the US government was going to have to— or the Fed was going to have to print the interest, print the money just to pay the interest on the US's true interest expense.

So, I give all of that by way of background, because as a result, basically, our point was 2 years ago is in the next crisis, the US fiscal situation is going to get irrecoverable, and the Fed will basically always have to be involved from that point forward in some way, shape, or form.

Fast forward to the COVID crisis, and in June of this year, if you look at interest expense, net interest expense, not even gross, net interest So, if you look at the true interest expense plus the pay-as-you-go portion of entitlements, which entitlements, healthcare, and veterans benefits, what you got was that the United States was spending 106% of tax receipts on true interest expense on those items.

And that's the point where you have to print 6% of tax receipts just to pay the interest on the cost. Now, in July, we had a bolus of receipts, tax receipts, because of the shift of tax payments from April to July in the US. And so that number ticked back under 100%. It'll be interesting to see what happens when the August numbers come out and going on. And again, this is a fluid number because it depends on some of those factors I talked about before. What's nominal GDP growth do? What's productivity do? What's the dollar do? What's global growth do?

But the point is that COVID blew a gigantic hole in the US budget. And we're now at that over 100% of tax receipts, true interest expense being over 100% of tax receipts. And this is a problem that is around the world, around the world having a similar type of problem. And so again, when you tie back to the, well, we need some sort of big event, we had the event. At least on one level here, you needed an event to push sovereign debt as a percent of tax receipts into these irrecoverable situations to provide the political cover. Because to your point, Erik, there's no pushback from anybody on either side of the aisle anymore. Just spend the money, right?

So, I think we've reached a point. I think COVID pushed us into a point of no return. And when I say point of no return, again, it's what's normal for the spider is chaos for the fly. If I'm long a bunch of US 10-years at 65 basis points, And we start doing what I think we're going to do, which is what Stan Fischer wanted us to do and which Stephanie Kelton thinks we should do. And yeah, I'm feeling a bit more like the fly than the spider. If I own a lot of gold and a lot of the right types of equities, long-duration equities, we've seen obviously with the Nasdaq, I'm feeling more like a spider than a fly. So again, what I'm trying to do is just help clients be spiders, not flies, because we can't change the situation. The COVID crisis blew a hole in it. And it's We're sort of into the flat spin, to mix my metaphors.

It very well may be irrecoverable.

Why stocks rise in a crisis

Erik Townsend: Luke, I want to pull this into big picture perspective. What you're telling me here is we're into that kind of point of no return with the US fiscal situation. And it's clear enough that smart finance guys like you can see it clear as day. We know we got really serious problems here. Meanwhile, we're having a global pandemic that is crippling global GDP. It's a really big problem. Meanwhile, as you've said, US cities are not figuratively but literally burning as we speak. There are riots in the streets. Things are really, really bad right now. And the S&P 500 rallied to new all-time highs on the news.

Luke, please explain.

Luke Gromen: I remember Marc Faber one time saying, when things get really bad, the price of everything goes up. And that comment has always stuck with me. And I think that was— I think it was Marc Faber. But I think ultimately, I think there's a lot of people, a lot more people than a lot of investors think, looking at the world through the lens that I just described, which is COVID made the situation irrecoverable.

And there's one of two outcomes. The first outcome is the authorities don't do enough and monetary authorities and fiscal authorities don't do enough. And what we see in the streets now is a modest warmup to what comes because ultimately you see GDP decline further, the debts that are out there become in large part unpayable. You see US government and global sovereign government defaults on sovereign debt, on promised entitlements. It just depends where, how bad you want to paint the picture in your mind. But that's the first option. And we saw just a little glimpse of this in March when the S&P peaked, I think February 27th, 12 days later after falling just 12 days, it fell a lot in 12 days, but it fell only 12 trading days, US Treasury bond markets started crashing alongside the US equity market, which in my career had never happened. When the market went down big, Treasuries were bid. And this time it crashed.

The Treasury market was crashing almost tick for tick with the equity market. And the problem was the thing that's really different this time is the US's net international investment position, or NIIP, is negative 50% to 55% of GDP. And in plain English, what that means, when you compare that to 2008, That number was -8%. When you compare that to 1999, that number was -2%. And what that means is foreigners own on-net assets, dollar assets equivalent to -50% or 50% of US GDP or $11 trillion.

These numbers were much smaller in the past. What it means we did is we hocked our family silver from 2008 to present to fuel the economic recovery we've had since then. And so, when you have a problem anywhere, because of the setup, foreigners are going to dump dollar assets to acquire the dollars they need. And so, your option one is this deflationary spiral if monetary and fiscal authorities do not do enough at any point. And March, at first, they didn't do enough, and we saw what happens.

Now, the other side is that they do do enough, and then It's sort of the opposite side. It's a very big— it's good for gold, it's good for equities. Nominally, it's fine for bonds. Bond yields don't have to go anywhere per se. It's good for commodities. And again, depending on what the fiscal side does, it'll be inflationary. So far, it's been primarily asset inflationary, but the US ran an $865 billion deficit in the month of June alone. And so, if the US comes out and says, listen, we're going to spend $865 billion every month until further notice, and the Fed's going to take it all down, that's going to be CPI inflationary too. We haven't seen that yet, but that's something I'd be looking for when you talk about what could be an event, a quote unquote event. So, those are 2 options, right? The deflationary spiral or what I just laid out.

The question then is trying to handicap what's more likely. And to me, a very powerful motivator is, or understanding of handicapping was put out by the Dutch National Bank at the end of, I think, 2019, where they said, look, if the whole system collapses, we own gold because if the whole system collapses, gold will be used to rebuild the whole thing.

And if that happens, it's not going to be with gold at $2,200 or $2,500 or $1,800 or $1,200. It's going to be with gold at like $22,000. So policymakers probably don't want to see that because ultimately, if they screw this up, gold is going to be used, and they, they, they're allergic to that. And so I think they would rather err on the side of doing too much.

Now again, so far it's just been asset inflationary. To really make it inflationary inflationary, CPI inflationary, you got to do some, uh, the fiscal authority has to do some irresponsible things in terms of deficits, and then the central bank has to effectively monetize it. And we're not there

Erik Townsend: Well, Luke, I for one have complete faith in our elected officials to do irresponsible things with respect to deficits. No lack of confidence on my part there in any event.

Luke Gromen: Mine either.

Gold: spiders versus flies and negative real rates

Erik Townsend: We cannot have a Luke Gromen interview without going deeper than— you just alluded to gold. We got to really go to that. But I want to start with a different perspective than we usually talk about. You just mentioned 22,000 $22,000 gold in passing, and I can just feel the gold bugs saying, oh boy, this is great. Luke Gromen says $22,000 gold. This is great. Look—

Luke Gromen: Yeah, please don't use that as the title of this, of this interview. That's not what I want to be on record on. I do not need that. I'm just saying hypothetically, if they really let this thing get out of hand, it'd be, you know, you could see that kind of a thing.

Erik Townsend: Luke, what scares me is that I agree with you emphatically. I am overweight gold myself, as well as overweight gold But here's the thing. I think that if you understand macro, what you understand is that the only reason to ever expect a really big secular move up in the price of gold is if you expect a situation to eventuate where all of the smartest people who are able to understand the economic situation conclude, holy shit, I wanna get my money the hell out of the financial system. I don't want to participate. Participate anymore in the efficient formation of capital to support the growth and expansion of American businesses and to make the economy a better place. I want to protect myself by getting the hell out of risk assets into something that is going to be safe, even if the currency itself experiences a significant devaluation.

I'm not at all disagreeing with you that gold is the smart place for a self-serving investor to put But doesn't the outlook that we both share that's very bullish on gold prices going much higher, doesn't that necessarily portend a very, very negative outlook for what the next several years are going to bring for the global economy?

Luke Gromen: I think it depends. I think it could. Absolutely, they could. Because I think on one level, you're absolutely right. That is, I would say, one leg of a decision tree of why own gold. Gold. I think the other leg on the decision tree is sort of this dynamic of what's normal for the spider is chaos for the fly.

And I go back to this system we've had since 1971. The spiders in this situation were Washington, DC, where in 2012, the Washington Post noted that 7 of the 10 richest counties in America were around Washington, DC, even though Washington, DC, I think, only emits its deficits on net. That's what they do. They're in the dollar export business. They're in the Treasury export business. They did very well. However, for real median wages in the United States, real median family income in the United States has been largely flat since 1971. They were the flies in this situation. And so, to me, it comes down to the reason why if gold really works, Is it because the whole system has chaotically collapsed? And in which case, that's pretty bad, that's ugly. And you're going to want probably some doomer-prepper type stuff to go alongside that and all the kind of things that you hear of sort of the worst of financial Armageddon.

The other side of it is something we saw happen in 1971, something we saw happen in 1946, something we saw happen And we hear it periodically throughout time, which is that the currency system as structured sees a major change.

And so, if the reason we see gold at a much higher price is because suddenly gold is being used again as the primary reserve asset to settle imbalances or to settle— if basically gold takes the place of Treasury bonds as the primary reserve asset, then in the global financial system, then what you're going to see is the reason for gold rising is going to be really good for the global financial system. It's just going to be that the spiders are going to be the flies and the flies are going to be the spiders to a certain degree. In other words, the Fed could be doing what Fischer said, which is directly monetizing US deficits and capping interest rates, what Fischer said in that white paper and gold could be going through the roof. US wage growth could be growing through the roof. And if wage growth is growing 10%, 15%, 20%, and bond yields are 65 basis points, that's actually a really good scenario.

It amounts to basically a soft default across, or a jubilee across dollar debt markets.

But remember, the problem of the world that Brent Johnson and Jeff Snider and everyone says, there's this dollar shortage. Well, this would resolve the dollar shortage in a big way. Nominal global GDP growth would explode to the upside. Bondholders would not be real happy with the outcome. But boy, if I'm a wage earner in America and my wages grow 15%, 20%, my mortgage doesn't move, boy, after a few years of that, my mortgage is eminently more affordable. I probably go out to eat a little bit more. I probably spend some more money on some other consumer goods. You basically have a one-time, what amounts to a one-time significant devaluation of dollar debt globally over some span of time.

And this sounds crazy on some level, but you saw exactly this happen in the countries, in Western countries after World War II, where you saw a span of years where real rates in Europe, Japan, some other places were anywhere from -15% to -40%. -15% to -40% real rates. People are freaking out in the US at -1.5% right now. And so, can you imagine what the price of gold would be in the United States if real rates were -10%, -15%, -20% for a couple of years? It'd be significantly higher. But that's a situation where, again, I think it's really good for part of the economy. I think it's really bad for part of the economy. But I think in net, because the world's short dollars, you would have probably the biggest nominal global GDP boom since 1946.

A contested election: dollar, risk assets and capital flight

Erik Townsend: Yeah. Luke, final question. I want to talk about the election outcome. What would it mean for markets if hypothetically the result of the election is— drum roll, please— we don't find out for weeks or even months? And potentially we get into a situation where January 20th, Inauguration Day, is rapidly approaching and there is still a massively heated debate and nobody is in agreement as to who the next president is. Would that drive the S&P to yet another all-time high, or would we be in another, at least temporary, COVID-like stock market down scenario? What could happen? And also, do you think that that's a realistic scenario? I'm starting to really get concerned about it.

Luke Gromen: I would defer to other more political people on how realistic it is, but to me as a tourist, I agree. I think it's starting to become more Or if it was a far tail risk, far out tail risk a few months ago, I think it is at the very least a fat tail risk and it might be moving into sort of the realms of real possibility in a normal distribution curve.

As far as what it means for markets, I'm torn, I guess, 2 ways, or I think about it 2 ways. The first way is I go back to summer of 2017 And if you remember at the time, there was a— I think it was a French election where there was a far right, at least is how I understood it, a more far right French politician competing for office there. And I can't remember the French president's name at the time, escaped my mind. Anyway, the point is this, it was routinely used as a reason to be short the Because if this far-right politician gets elected in France, the euro's going to break apart, or there's more stresses, and, and, and.

Fast forward to today, and we have a similar situation where it's suddenly becoming, as we just said, actually credible that you could have some sort of contested election or something. And so, I guess in the short run, it makes me think, why step in front of that train in terms of the dollar? It probably is not supportive of the dollar tactically, the possibility of this happening as we move into the election. And then if it happened, I think it would further be bad for the dollar. I think on the other side, if it's clean cut and nobody accuses anybody of impropriety and Trump leaves office without— if he loses without event or vice versa, and there's just— it's a clean cut election, then you probably would see a big rebound in the dollar, I would think, just given a relief A reversal of positioning and just a reaffirmation that, okay, America can handle a transfer of power just like they always have.

And it's been one of the big attractions for capital flows here.

In terms of what it means for risk assets, if the dollar goes down more, the more the dollar goes down, the more the global GDP is going to go up. We've seen that. We saw it in 2017. When the dollar fell 12%, we came into 2018 and most strategists on Wall Street were talking about global coordinated growth. It wasn't global coordinated growth. It was a dollar down 12% in 2017. And we saw that as soon as the dollar stopped going down, because as soon as it started going back up, all those, you know, the global coordinated growth narrative faded away.

And so in the short run, if the dollar gets weaker as a result of this, it's probably good for global growth and it's probably good for risk assets broadly, as well as commodities and gold. Ultimately, Where it gets a little trickier, and I just don't have a great answer for it, is the capital flight side. The capital's already here. Remember, we talked about that net international investment position of -50% to -55% of GDP.

All that capital's here. And so, if the dollar falls too far or gets really disorderly, then you have to start worrying about capital flight-related selling of assets. And that's I think probably the Fed's worst-case scenario, because then what do they do? They basically have to let the market crash, or they have to completely destroy the sanctity of markets, or destroy— maybe more apropos— destroy the remaining vestiges of the illusion of the sanctity of markets by stepping into supporting stocks, supporting credit spreads, supporting corporate bonds, et cetera, to stem that capital flight, because there's no If you get a crash on capital flight because the dollar's weak, Fed's got to raise rates to stop the dollar being weak. And that's not going to help a market crash. That's not going to help an economy crash.

So, I don't know, but those are the framework that I'm thinking about. But I would say, gun to my head, I would say it's probably bad for the dollar between now and the election, depending how it's handled.

If the election goes okay, it could be good for the dollar. And I think weak dollar is in the short run good for risk. It's good for global economy. But beyond some unknowable tipping point, you start running risks of capital flight out of the United States. And that could be bad for asset prices and put the Fed in a real bind. So, that's how I would think and talk through it.

Erik Townsend: Luke, before I let you go, please tell our listeners what they can expect to find on your website and your Twitter handle.

Luke Gromen: Absolutely. So, if you're interested in learning more about us, hearing more, I'm on Twitter @LukeGromen, L-U-K-E G-R-O-M-E-N. And if you're interested in learning more about our various research product offerings, you can go to FFTT-LLC, Forest for the Trees-LLC, FFTT-LLC. And you can see what we're up to in terms of appearances and, and research product offerings there, both retail, IRA, institutional as well.

Erik Townsend: Luke, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our Thank you, David.

Luke Gromen: Thank you, David.

Patrick Ceresna: And now a word from our sponsor.

Erik Townsend: Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade. But the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with farmtogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland Might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your research roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out farmtogether.com today.

You'll be glad you did.

Postgame: takeaways from Gromen, Snider and Johnson views

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Luke back on the show. I was actually thinking he was going to be a little bit more bearish toward the dollar. He seemed to be kind of still straddling the opinion a little bit, but I mean, the dollar has had a pretty big move. What did What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think that Luke's perspective is spot on, which is to say, look, you can't look at this current move down and say, okay, oh my gosh, this is it. This is the Luke Gromen moment. The point Luke made, I think very eloquently, is the Luke Gromen moment is a slow-motion event that's been in process for a couple of years now. And I think he makes a very good argument. The thing that I freely admit that I don't understand is, I think Jeff Snider's arguments are really excellent as well, and I was really thinking that we would see a squeeze higher in the dollar relative to other currencies. I thought that Jeff Snider and Brent Johnson were going to be proven right first, and then eventually Luke was going to be proven right in the long run. Well, the, the Jeff Snider-Brent Johnson view, although it logically still makes a lot of sense to me, sure isn't what the tape is telling us is So, as Brent

told us last week, you know, if we don't see a reversal pretty soon here, it's time to just say, hey, it's not working the way we thought. And does that mean that Luke's view is being proven right? Well, of course, according to Luke, it's been right all along. It's just happening slowly, and it's happening progressively. In any event, what is not happening slowly or progressively is the reversal candle that we saw today on the S&P 500.

Postgame: S&P 500 reversal candle and Labor Day seasonality

Erik Townsend: Let's dive into the postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup. Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you haven't registered yet for your free account at MacroVoices.com. Shame on you. You can get one by looking for the red button on our homepage at MacroVoices.com, just above Luke's picture, that says, looking for the downloads. Patrick, let's dive into slide 2. Boy, look at that big, bright red reversal candle.

And of course, that's today's tape action. What does this tell you as the technician in

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, the big question I wanted to simply ask, one day never makes a new trend. And there's no way that, I mean, those people that are looking for the big crash in itself, it always starts with a big down day, but it doesn't always have to end in it being a crash. And so what I was really illustrating here was the fact that when you look back to February, when that crash candle started the sequence that began then the COVID crash, it spent basically 2 days downwards and then never was able to recover. But if you look at what corrections we've had in the market since, and I only circled one of them, but you can see it at least on 4 or 5 different spots since the bottom where the markets had what are these typical 2 to 3 day market corrections, and they often will give back a chunk of the prior They'll pause and they get bought on dip.

So I think the biggest puzzle piece for us to solve in the next week is, does this create a new feedback mechanism that creates some big new market event to the downside, or is this just going to end up being a buy on dip? And while I certainly feel that there are a lot of risks in the markets, and certainly we're starting from a very elevated level, which in itself can heighten the chance of this being deeper than expected. I think the jury's still out as to what we're about to see. And I think that maybe by Monday or Tuesday next week, seeing how the market behaves after the selling is— that's kind of 24 to 48 hours of selling is dissipated, how the market reacts is going to be a real big tell.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I agree with that. And I'd also point out that if you just look at long-term seasonality in the stock market, Right around Labor Day is oftentimes a turning point or an acceleration point. So, the notion that— what are we, 2 trading sessions before the Labor Day holiday? The fact that that might be the time when things either start to reverse or make a head fake before actually accelerating in the prior direction, it all fits in. It's very consistent with what you tend to see this time of year. And I think I'm willing to wager that September will be a very interesting month. I'd say now through the election is going to be a very interesting time in markets.

Postgame: FAANG+, Tesla and options gamma

Erik Townsend: Is that an interesting downside time or an upside time? Well, I guess we'll wait and see. Let's move on now to page 3. You've got the FAANG+ index. That's the expanded darling tech stock index.

Boy, sure looks like the beginning of a blow-off top, but I guess it's too early to call it. What do you think?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, first of all, I just wanted to make the observation of just simply seeing the magnitude of this rise that we've witnessed since the March bottom versus even just the 2019 into early 2020 rise. This has just been an unprecedented rise in those tech names. And Erik, I'll ask you, is a 30 to 40% market correction a big deal? Because in my mind, that's what we saw in the S&P 500 just back during the, the COVID drop. And what's amazing about this rise is that if the FAANG stocks index just had a 30 to 40% decline, it would just be approaching its pre-COVID highs.

It's just amazing to put into context of just how far the FAANGs have, uh, have shot to the upside and how much room there is for mean reversion, even if it's not breaking the bigger picture uptrend that's now been very clearly established.

One of the big leaders in that big parabolic rise, and I want to talk about this in greater detail, and particularly some of the fuel that's been driving it, is on page 4, the Tesla chart. And similarly to the statement I was making, I mean, I'm not trying to forecast Tesla going down there, but if Tesla right now experienced a 60% decline it would just be reaching the highs it put in prior to the COVID correction. And it's just amazing how far these stocks have shot higher. And so it asks the question, you know, was this the Fed, right? Everyone, every person I hear saying is like, you know what, the Fed liquidity surge came in driving the stocks. You can't fight this. These stocks are gonna keep going up.

And while I, in principle don't deny or wouldn't even push back on the notion that that massive liquidity surge that the Fed put into the markets was in fact very real and driving the stock markets, and at least drove stability in the stock markets.

The one thing that I feel that people are very quick to, or not discounting properly, is that while the Fed provided a certain amount of liquidity, liquidity. It's the speculators that have driven this move, and particularly there are different accelerants within this market that have driven the rise in these tech stocks. So going to page 5, we were talking last week about that chart that basically showed that now 75% of all options volume is now at 30 days or less, and often 2 weeks or less till expiration.

Which basically means that all of these options, and particularly the growth in call option volume, has now created huge gamma pull on the front of the markets. And this has been even further accelerated in the last week or two. On page 6, I have a couple quotes that were out there, one from Citadel, one that says that over the past few weeks there has been a massive buyer in the market of technology upside calls and call spreads across a basket of names including Adobe, Amazon, Facebook, Salesforce, Microsoft, Google, and Netflix.

Over $1 billion of premium was spent in upwards of $20 billion of notional through strike. This is arguably some of the largest single stock flow we have seen in years. The average daily options contract traded on the Nasdaq stocks to rise from $4 million a day average to in April to $5.5 million a day on average in August, a 38% jump in volume.

So that's from Citadel. The point that they're making is that some monstrous institutional buyers are coming in with real money. This isn't Robinhooders that are coming in driving this call buying volume, and this is creating a huge gamma pull on the upside of the market, acting like a fuel or accelerant to the upside of the market. It's sort of like, uh, hitting nitro in a car that's already going 100 miles an hour. But the one thing is, is that a lot of people are trying to say or suggest that this is now the new speed of the market. And well, the one thing that, uh, I, I look at this when you're talking about such short-term gamma driven by these options At some point, that accelerant runs out and the rate of change of the vehicle would slow down.

In the same way, there's going to be some counterreaction to this. And while I don't want to already be joining the camp that there's some new bear market that will take the markets to all-time new lows, I think we are long overdue for a proper and deep market correction that reverts and backfills this big extraordinary move that we've

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I just want to add a comment to what you're saying. You know, a lot of people would probably hear you and say, you know, what are you talking about Tesla having a, what, a 60% decline? That's crazy. That's, you know, that's one in a million years kind of downside event. Look, for any stock to return back to the price it was at at the beginning of the current year is not a once-in-a-lifetime event. It's a perfectly typical, normal thing to have happen.

So yeah, it would be a huge percentage. I think it would take about a 75% downside correction or bear market in Tesla just to get back to its January 1st opening price for this year. And, you know, what goes up must come down eventually.

This is a stock that, if you value it based on the viability of its business plan, has never been worth more than $4 a share. Forget about $450 a share. So, you know, there's a lot of fluff and excess in this market. Does it mean it's going to come out, or is it just going to be fueled even higher by even more liquidity in the marketplace? Well, I guess we'll find out.

Patrick Ceresna: You know, the one thing that I will put a thought out there, there's a new truism that is passed around today in the markets, which is that don't fight the Fed. The Fed will always provide the liquidity, and therefore the stock market can only go up because they're not going to let it go down. down. So you can accept that truism to be true, but there's another truism that conflicts with that in the market, which is that there's a long, rich history of the stock market separating fools from their money. And what you have to ask yourself is which truism do you believe to be more true? Because only one of them is going to be right.

Postgame: crude oil chart and intermarket view

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I don't want to be on the hook for answering which one's going to be right. So let's move on to something I actually know about, which is crude oil on page 7. As you can see here, although the last couple of days were pretty vicious. Boy, isn't that— I mean, you're the technician here, but doesn't today look like it could be the beginning of an upside reversal candle? It wasn't a perfect doji, but it was pretty darn close. And normally I would say, hey, look, this market is just way overdue to roll over to the downside. We need a sizable correction. We're overdue for one. It's got to be the beginning of much more downside. But look at all of the times since June or So where I thought that was starting and it turned out to be just a false breakdown. And after a couple days, it turned out that buying the dip was the right thing to do.

Is this another one? Or maybe we're past the seasonality of summer driving season and it really is time to have that correction down to, say, $35 or so that frankly has been overdue for quite a while. I'm not sure yet. I think the next couple days, next couple market sessions are going to be very Very telling. How do you see this chart?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I don't want to look just at the crude oil chart alone. What one has to do is put it into the context of the broader intermarkets because what if, and so let's just do a what-if exercise. Well, what if the stock market just began a risk-off period where this period between now and the elections, the stock market has a lot of challenging periods and a lot of volatility. Let's not go much more beyond that. But during that period, We see money flow into risk-off assets. We see yields dropping as money flows into the 10-year Treasury bond. We see potentially a short-term low and a mean reversion in the dollar. If we start seeing that kind of an intermarket environment, I think that oil may still have more to drop. I do believe the major lows in oil are in. I don't know if we'd ever see negative oil prices ever again, but I do feel that if we go into a risk-off risk-off period, that could be something that drives oil to pull back into the mid to low 30s.

But that would mean that those other markets would have to be doing that. If those things aren't happening, then oil could very easily bounce right back and just stay within this range, and this could be a fake out. But we'll see. The one thing I wanted to talk to you though about on page 8 is the crude oil term structure. And often we see some bumps in there that create some form of backwardation, but this is a very clear contango in the entire oil curve.

Postgame: crude oil term structure and contango

Erik Townsend: What do Well, I'll also point out, it's not shown on this particular chart, but if you see that bend in the term structure, which is right around June of 2021, about 9 months out on the curve, you see the angle of the line changes pretty abruptly there. That wasn't there. Well, it was there a little bit, but it wasn't nearly as pronounced a week ago. So, as we're seeing the market start to sell off, what the market's telling us is, okay, contango is steepening about out to June of 2021. And then the term structure from there kind of follows a much more steady trajectory all the way out to the end of the curve. So I think that what that's telling us is the market's trying to figure out, okay, it's probably going to be that the market is rebalanced by June of '21. That's 9 months But what happens from here? Are we about to see a bunch of more downside down to the low $30s or even below?

And I think you could make an argument for as low as $26 a barrel from here. I don't think it would last very long, but that's plausible. I think in the low to mid-$30s is probably a more likely downside target if this becomes substantial. Already, the term structure is starting to signal that possibility. at the front end of the curve, but you're noticing the back end of the curve isn't budging because it so far is discounting this, saying it's just short-term for now. The, the front of the curve is moving on it, the back of the curve isn't.

It's important to watch whether or not that continue— that this line continues to hinge at that same point. And if we do go down a little more, does the front of the curve steepen its contango and the back stays the same, or does the back start to come off too, which would suggest that the market thinks this could be longer lasting than just a short-term correction. So, it'll be very interesting to see what happens as this situation develops over the next few weeks.

Postgame: natural gas term structure and ETF roll costs

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to page 9 because I wanted to talk natural gas. We're always talking oil, and I wanted to just take a look at this natural gas chart. And what we've seen throughout the majority of the summer of 2020 2020 is a pretty clear bottoming formation establishing itself. And what many technicians are observing is a legitimate and proper bull breakout of natural gas prices. And they've sort of been marching to the beat of their own drum. But what's particularly interesting, and we'll talk about it in the term structure in a moment, is that we're going into the seasonal period where natural gas prices are actually rising. So, Erik, let's have a quick look at that natural gas term

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this crazy pattern you see, this sawtooth pattern in the natural gas term structure, is actually to be expected. It always looks that way. The reason for that is because natural gas has a much, much higher storage cost than oil does. You can't just throw it in a salt cavern or a simple unpressurized metal tank and let it sit there for 5 years the way you can with crude oil. Once natural gas has been produced, meaning that it's been taken out of the natural well or reservoir that it has been sitting in for millions of years, in order to store it, it's much more expensive because you have to worry about temperature and pressure and specialized tanks and liquefaction and refrigeration and so forth.

So what happens is because there is a seasonal use pattern and a seasonal demand pattern, the price and the expected price in the future tends to just be up and down like a sawtooth. And so this is entirely about annual seasonality. Each one of these big sawtooth patterns that you're seeing here is one year's worth of seasonality in the chart, and it always looks like this. What that tells you, though, is that if you're buying natural gas

Patrick Ceresna: Yes.

Erik Townsend: Just because you were looking at a chart like the one on page 9, you're saying, hey, it looks like it bottomed there in July and it looks like it's headed up, maybe it's going to continue heading up. Well, this chart on page 9 is kind of misleading because if you're buying an ETF, they have to trade the actual futures contracts, which are shown on page 10, the little yellow dots. And sure enough, there's just a super steep contango right now. So that means each time they roll their contract They're rolling forward, let's say, from $2.50 now in the immediate delivery month to about $2.93 in the next month, and then $3.30 the month after that. It doesn't mean you're making that profit. It means you're losing ground. The, the new entry price is that much higher, and you didn't make any profit for reinstating your trade at that next higher price.

So what happens is there's a really big tracking error between what appears to be happening on the price chart on page 9 and what the actual performance of an ETF or another instrument that invests in rolling natural gas futures. Now, unlike USO, which is the crude oil ETF that completely changed its composition to focus on a number of different contracts across the term structure, for the most part, the ETFs still roll that front-month futures contract. So you're going to be subject to really big tracking errors. And it's important to really, really understand how those products work before you try to speculate on the price of natural gas based on a chart like the one on page 9.

Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, I couldn't agree with you more. The one thing the UNG does still only roll, it's front-month contracts. And so there is going to be a big tax on that roll, and it's going to be tracking quite poorly against natural gas in the next few months as we see these continuous contracts heading all the way to $3.40 on the upside in the next few months. What is interesting though is the considerably higher prices this year for natural gas versus the long term, because during this kind of 2021 to 2026 period, they're still forecasting and pricing in $2.40 to $2.80 natural gas prices. And yet here at the front of the curve, we are going towards $3.40 here into the tail end of the year. Do you have any ideas on what that is? My speculation is that obviously with all the well shutdowns in the fracking space, that is creating some short-term supply issues that many traders don't believe will be there in a few years.

Do you think that that could be the catalyst behind that, or do you have any other speculations

Erik Townsend: Yeah, in general, storage of natural gas is much, much more complex and involved than storage of oil. And for that reason, a lot of natural gas gets flared off. That's— if you've ever seen a picture of an oil field and you see that thing that looks like a big blowtorch pointing up at the sky, what they're doing is they're burning off the perfectly good natural gas that's being produced because it's actually more economic just to burn it, throw it away, and wait waste it than it is to capture it and have to deal with the complexities of storing it. Oftentimes these oil fields are out in remote locations. You know, you don't have all kinds of equipment and electricity and so forth to be refrigerating liquefied natural gas. So it probably has to do with both the pandemic situation further encumbering the complexity of logistics and the fact that natural gas storage is inherently cumbersome. cumbersome and expensive to start with.

As far as the particulars of exactly what's going on right now in this natural gas market today, I'm not a natty guy. You know, you've got to really be one of the traders who focuses on and specializes in nat gas in order to really understand that, and it's outside my field of expertise.

Postgame: euro and dollar intermarket check

Patrick Ceresna: Well, if any of our listeners have some insights on that, please feel free to share it with us. We'd love to know. Nonetheless, I want to move on to page 11 where I have the chart of the And one of the things I referenced earlier when we're talking crude oil is just what are we about to witness on a broader intermarket basis? And what's interesting to me is that while we have had a pronounced US dollar decline, which is to the opposite, a very strong euro, what we've seen in the last month is a number of times that the euro has tried to break to a higher high and rally, and each time it failed to hold the break.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Patrick Ceresna: Breakout and has reverted back. While it's very premature to already be trying to suggest that this is somehow a huge topping formation, there's no denying that many topping formations start by looking like this. And I think one of the bigger things to watch here in the coming days and weeks is whether or not at least a short to intermediate move in the dollar has played out. I mean, obviously a lot of our guests come on and talk the big picture, what's really in store for the next year or two. But I think that this is going to be a really important moment to find out what happens here on the next, you know, 1 to 3 month swing. And especially if the stock market feels very heavy, it'd be interesting to see if we have a dollar up, kind of risk-off impulse here in the currency.

Postgame: Bitcoin reversal and the dot-com analogy

Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to page 12. Boy, an abrupt reversal in Bitcoin as well as other assets this week. What's your interpretation of this?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, there'll be a lot of technicians that are going to be trying to call that a head and shoulders. There was an attempt just a few days ago for that flagging formation to bullishly break out, which should have arguably given the tailwind and impulse for Bitcoin to head toward $14,000 on the upside. And instead, not only does it reverse, but it reverses right at a key overhead resistance and subsequently breaks the consolidation on the downside. And so it's really interesting to find out whether or not this has solidified at least a short to intermediate top. I don't want to try and make the big call on that, but what's your take?

Erik Townsend: Well, I would liken this to dot-com stocks in the late 1990s, and I think it has to do with the sophistication of the market versus the complexity of the underlying asset. The market was right in the late '90s to think, hey, the internet's going to be a really big deal. This is a place to invest. They got that right. The way it got interpreted was a whole bunch of people who had no clue about any of the technology involved, just started buying anything that has dot-com in its name without thinking about it. And that, of course, resulted in the dot-com bust in 2000.

I think what you're seeing now is it's very, very clear that the digital currency revolution is going to be a defining aspect of the next 25 years of human history. There's no doubt about that in my mind. Right now, most people think, just like the sophistication of the stock market in 1999 was, well, we're not really sure what all this internet shit actually is. So let's just buy anything with a dot-com in it. Bitcoin is clearly the most pervasive and popular cryptocurrency. So it must be a good thing to buy, right? I guess so, whatever. Frankly, I don't think people really understand the digital currency revolution that's coming, or what it's about.

We've got a lot of requests for why don't we talk more about it on MacroVoices. Well, frankly, MacroVoices is about macroeconomics. It's not really in scope for us. I am doing a full-length interview. I think it's going to be a really good one with a guy named Yan Pritzker, who wrote a book about Bitcoin. Yan and I agree on a lot of things, disagree on others. That's going to be next Wednesday, September 9th, and it's on the Swan Bitcoin YouTube channel. And as I understand it, it's going to be actually airing live. So if you want to tune into that, I'll have lots and lots to say about digital currency, about Bitcoin, about the reasons that I don't think the market is correctly interpreting what's going on at this stage of the digital currency revolution. But it really doesn't fit into what we do here on MacroVoices.

So that's why we're not covering it on this particular show.

Postgame: 10-year Treasury yield as canary

Patrick Ceresna: Listeners, if you want to tune in to listen to Erik, do that. We'll include the link in the Research Roundup email. So Erik, let's move on to China. Chart 13, page 13 of the chart on the 10-year Treasury yield. And I just really wanted to point out something we talked about in the market wrap earlier, which was it really looked like those yields were trying to break out last week. And there was a lot of people that were talking about the fact that the Fed was gonna let the inflation run hot and it was starting to kind of spook everyone on the 10-year Treasury yield. And then suddenly in the last 5 days, It's just been straight down from there. And we're down right now about those 62 basis points. It'll be really interesting to see whether or not bonds confirm a sort of a risk-off. I still think that they're the canary in the coal mines. And if we see yields breaking down to 50 basis points or lower, I don't know how the stock market is going to like that.

So, I mean, this is something that's at least something I'm going to be watching very closely next week.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, before we wrap up for this week, I want to just mention to our listeners, we didn't have time to go into detail on the calendar straddle strategy, which Patrick has been working with his Big Picture Trading members. For Big Picture Trading folks, you guys, my hat's off to you. You've been raking in the dough with that strategy because you rolled your straddles up right at the top of the market, and I know that's been very profitable. For anyone who is interested in that, we don't have time in today's show to really dive into it, but if you move on to page 14, you can get a free trial to Big Picture Trading where you can find all about that. Patrick does 4 webinars every single week, and recently they've been focusing on that calendar strategy and how to roll it up and really maximize profits in what Patrick very accurately called as at least a short-term market top.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: The information on that is on page 14, or you can just go to bigpicturetrading.com and sign up for a free 14-day trial.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com. Making farmland investing a trillion-dollar asset class available to all accredited investors. And by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorship.

Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a a link to that Stanley Fischer BlackRock article Luke referenced during the interview, as well as a link to a David Rosenberg article that no matter how you slice it, markets are in a bubble of historic proportions. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup.

So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer outro and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could. Find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult your financial advisor. And now back to the program. Consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented. On MacroVoices, MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Brent Johnson — Santiago Capital founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Opening and sponsors

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 234 was recorded on August 27th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity within reach of of all accredited investors. Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the US dollar in depth, including why Brent thinks that dollar bears are a little premature in declaring victory. We'll also discuss stocks, gold, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick has prepared another of his famous chart books. We'll go a little bit deeper on some of the things that are going on in the market and what's driving them.

Market wrap: S&P 500 breakout and the dollar

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's talk about that S&P 500. No sooner did we go past the option expiration that we did get volatility, but it was to the upside, and everything seems to be just running full throttle. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's exactly what I predicted last week, Patrick. Remember what I said is it's perfectly natural to see a pause here as you hit a technical resistance level of the previous all-time high. Some people thought it was gonna be a double top. They had to sell it. We had to go through that little bit of, uncertainty there. But as soon as we broke out to the upside, we saw a dramatic acceleration of upside momentum, exactly what I described last week. So the fact that we're up another 100 points almost in a week since we spoke last week doesn't surprise me at all. I think that this clearly proves, to my mind at least, that, you know, markets are being driven by central bank stimulus expectations more than underlying economic fundamentals. And quite frankly, that's been the case since 2009. If it hasn't been clear until now, it certainly has to be clear by now.

But interestingly, Brent Johnson has a different view, and he's challenging the very commonly held belief that it is central bank money buying bonds that puts the money in the hands of banks that they can go use to bid up the stock market.

Brent's got a different view. We'll get to that in the feature interview.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US dollar because more or less the entire month of August was pivoted off the 93 handle, up a little bit, down a little bit, but really finally the selling has somewhat subsided and we're in this sideways trade range. Is this where a dollar bottom comes in or do you think there's more downside?

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm going to get into a lot of detail with Brent Johnson on this one in the feature interview, but briefly, my take here is, you know, it's very interesting to me that you hear the talking heads on the cable networks and, and the pundits talking about how Horrible, horrible it is for the US dollar, how it keeps on selling off. Wait a minute. Come on, guys, let's look at the chart. It was almost 2 weeks ago that the market bottomed, at least so far, at just about a perfect 92 handle on the dollar index. Now, that doesn't mean it isn't going lower, but what it's been doing since then for the last couple of weeks is consolidating. People are still talking about it as if it's selling off viciously when that's not really what's happening. Suggests to me that there's plenty of room for an upside reversal. As so many people have become so obsessed with this idea that the dollar is crashing.

Dollar has definitely been weaker than I expected it to be, but it's not crashing. That's just not reality. Maybe it's about to crash, I don't know, but it's not crashing yet. In any case, Patrick, let's get Mr. Dollar Milkshake himself, Brent Johnson, to comment on this in detail in today's feature interview.

Crude oil: Gulf storm effects and inventories

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, Erik, let's move on to crude oil, 'cause crude oil is just doing a lot more of the same. It tries to break out to the upside and then just doesn't follow through and then just kind of muddles back down towards its trade range. What's next for oil here?

Erik Townsend: Well, as you say, we've had 2 solid months of sideways consolidation in a very narrow trading range, what traders call a coiled market, probably getting ready to make a big move in one direction or the other. Now, the strength this week kind of makes it look like, okay, it's an upside breakout that's coming. The thing is, you've got to understand, the strength this week has been entirely about the tropical storm activity in the Gulf. It's important for people to understand, though, that's a— it's a double-edged It's a double-edged sword. It's not as simple as a lot of people outside the oil market. You know, they, they think it's just you get bad weather, hurricanes makes the price of oil go up. It's not that simple. Bad weather in the Gulf of Mexico, which forces shut-ins of producing rigs, offshore rigs that are out in the Gulf of Mexico at risk, they have to be shut in because the storm is coming. That takes production offline. That pushes the price higher.

But when there's a risk of a storm surge causing flooding, which could cause a lot of serious damage to the refineries on the Gulf Coast. If you have the risk that refineries could be taken offline for, say, 6 months at a time because of a whole bunch of flood damage, that is crippling demand for crude oil because that refinery capacity coming offline means the refineries can't use the crude oil. So that tends to have a downward effect on the price of crude oil and an upward effect on the price of RBOB gasoline futures.

That's exactly what we saw through Tuesday. RBOB gasoline through the roof. to the upside, taking out all the technical levels, looked like there was just no tomorrow. Well, really, crude oil wasn't reacting nearly as much. Why is that? Because everybody knows gasoline is going to be in demand. They can't get too excited about crude oil prices because you don't know what's going to happen to the refineries. We got to mid-session or so, just about. I think the peak was right around 10 a.m. on Tuesday, and it's been downhill, sharply downhill since then for RBOB gasoline futures, probably because people are interpreting the weather data to say, okay, This is a bad storm, but it's not going to put the refineries out of business for the next year. It's not that bad. And I think that was feared at one point. So that's why gasoline prices have come back down through most of their key moving averages, through the 5, through the 8, sitting on the 13-day moving average as we're speaking.

Crude oil, on the other hand, bouncing up and down, kind of following in sympathy with RBOB gasoline, but not nearly as volatile. And again, the reason for this is you've got this So, there's this two-pronged effect of normally the bad weather causes prices to go up unless it's compromising refining capacity into the future, then it's different. So, that's the big picture of what's happening with the fundamentals.

As far as inventory is concerned, crude oil drawing down 4.7 million barrels plus another drawdown of 1.8 million barrels on the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. That's a 6.5 million barrel drawdown.

Patrick Ceresna: Wow.

Erik Townsend: million barrel net drawdown on crude oil inventories. Now, normally we don't count the SPR because that's government oil, it's not commercial oil, except they started leasing it out to private interests. So I treat that whole 6.5 million barrels, at least in my head, that's the commercial storage drawdown for last week, and it's a doozy. That would normally be a really big upside in prices, and we didn't really see a big upside on oil prices. It's kind of suggesting that, that this market's not ready to break out to the upside yet. Maybe once the weather event is over, we're headed back down, is probably my gut feeling at this point. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 279,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 4.6 million barrels, great big draw there. Distillates building 1.4 million barrels.

US production ticking up just 100,000 barrels, one tick up to 10.8 million barrels. I think the The big catalyst for much higher oil prices is when you see US production fall off a cliff, as Art Berman has predicted it would in Q4. It's not Q4 yet. It's not time for that. I think before the end of the year, we may see a dramatic decrease in US production pushing prices higher, but it's not happening yet. We're going the other direction, at least in a small way for this week.

Gold, 10-year yields and why Brent Johnson is back

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold actually popped earlier today. It looked like we were gonna take a stab back at $2,000 and then it reversed and we're heading right back to the bottom of that trade range. It doesn't seem like gold is ready to commit yet to the upside. What's your take here on what gold is doing?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's still unclear whether this correction that we're seeing in gold has farther to go to the downside. And as a gold bull, I hope it does. What would help to clean out the system, so to speak, and make for a healthier bull market is to have a more significant downside correction to shake out those weak hands and set the stage for the market to move much higher. So I I really hope we get at least down to just over 1,800. I'm going to ask Brent Johnson, you know, he— Brent for a long time was really sticking to thinking it was going all the way back to maybe 1,377 or at least 1,400 before this was over. I wonder if Brent still thinks that. We'll ask him in the feature interview

Patrick Ceresna: All right. And finally, let's just touch on the 10-year Treasury yields. We've obviously seen yields rising here in the last little bit. What's your take on all of it?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, as our regular listeners know, I'm not even paying attention to the short-term moves in the 10-year. The big questions on my mind are, are we headed toward a return to secular inflation, or is deflation going to continue for a while longer? And are negative interest rates on the US 10-year a possibility? Those are the things I'm thinking about. I'm gonna have quite a bit of conversation with Brent Johnson about those. As far as the recent backup in the yield in the last few days, No opinion as far as I'm concerned.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson. Now, Erik, why did we invite Brent back on the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Brent Johnson and Jeff Snider have been the 2 voices that have been most outspoken in explaining why a US dollar squeeze was likely to push the dollar index higher, US dollar appreciating against other currencies. Clearly, that's not what we've seen in the last month. We're seeing the opposite. I really wanted to get Brent back to find out, does that change his fundamental view? At some point, there's got to be a level where you say, okay, this proves that I got the call wrong. Is Brent there yet? Is Brent ready to concede that maybe Luke Gromen is finally being proven right in his outlook on the dollar? Or are we not there yet? Let's find out what Brent has to say in today's feature interview. Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us.

Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure.

Erik Townsend: Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email. This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades.

To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com. And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following.

The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Brent is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with This week's special guest. Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Brent Johnson: why the dollar fell and why it is not over

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Santiago Capital founder Brent Johnson. Brent has prepared an excellent slide deck to accompany today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Brent's picture.

Brent, it's great to have you back. But you know, buddy, we gotta start with the US dollar because we've been— both you and I had a view that likely the dollar was maybe going to head higher. It hasn't yet. It's going the opposite direction. What's happening?

Brent Johnson: Well, we've kind of had, you know, there's that famous book, A Tale of Two Cities. We've had a tale of two dollar moves so far this year. And yeah, you're right. You know, things were really moving higher in Q1. We thought it was likely we'd get a little bit of a pullback in Q2. We did not expect it to pull back as far as it has. So I'm happy to address all this. And I will say, just to make it absolutely clear, because I know there's a number of people who are going to ask, is it over? And I will state my case very clearly. It is not over. There is much time left in this game that we're playing, but happy to walk through some of these slides and tell you why I feel that way. All right.

Erik Townsend: Let's hit it with slide 3. What's going on with the dollar index?

Brent Johnson: Well, this just basically shows what I just talked about, about the different moves so far this year. So we started the year around 96.50, something like that. In early March, we had a very quick pull down and an enormous move the other way. And that's one thing I'd like to point out is on March 9th, the dollar index was around 94. 11 days later, it was 103. So these moves, when they happen, can happen extremely quickly and come out of nowhere. And that's kind of the nature of the design of the monetary system. And we'll get into that a little bit later. But since then, we've had a huge move the other way. Now, we thought we'd get a pullback, but maybe to the 95, 97, 96, 95 level. We did not expect it to pull back down into the 93, 92 level, which is where we're at now. And so, that's about a 10% move that we've had from the N2 year high, which is a big move.

And so, I'm not going to sit here and be oblivious to that fact. I don't think it changes the endgame, but it has certainly changed the middle of the game.

So, I've had a number of people kind of over and over, whether it's emails, Twitter messages, DMs, phone calls, insisting that the dollar trade is over, the milkshake has melted and spilled and it's gone sour. And it was the dumbest idea that anybody's ever had, et cetera, et cetera.

I think what I would say is the day of the dollar high, I actually sent out a tweet because at that time, I was getting all kinds of messages the other way. Oh, I'm on team dollar. This thing's going to 120. It can't be stopped. And the point I wanted to make was that, listen, I very much believe that that is the case. And I very much believe that we are going to all-time highs in the dollar, but this is not going to happen in a straight line. There are going to be moments of pain along the way. And I sent out this tweet that said, if you're new to this, you have to be ready for a pullback. The Fed is going to do something. The monetary authorities are not just going to sit back and let this happen. And when they do, it's going to hurt. And you know what? That's exactly what they've done.

They've been more successful at it than I initially thought that they would be, but it is what it is. And so, I am of the belief that if you have a portion of your portfolio that is allocated to speculative capital and some asymmetric-type returns. This is a fantastic opportunity to put some of these trades on.

And so, one thing on page 6, I wanted to just show some of how dramatic this dollar pullback has been. We had the big move up in the first 3 months of the year. The next 2 months or next 3 months kind of started to give that back. But then we had a huge— July was one of the worst months in a decade for the dollar.

I think the last time that it had a month like that was 2010. That was as a result of early QE. It might have been QE2, I can't remember. But it is what it is. And so, the reason that I think that now is a good opportunity is severalfold.

Now, first of all, if we look at page 7, I put a couple different charts using technical analysis. Now, again, I'm not oblivious to what happened. I mean, the dollar just sliced through that short-term support that we saw at around the 95, 96 level on the weekly and the monthly charts.

And it's fallen all the way to 10-year support levels on both the weekly and the monthly charts. And we think that that is very strong support. Now, if something happens and they push it through that, then we're probably going to the mid-80s. And I can't sit here and say that's impossible. Anything's possible.

I would say that everybody, regardless of asset class, needs to be ready for anything. So for me to come in here and say that it can't happen would be wrong. It can certainly happen. I don't think it will, but it can. But if we go to the next—

Luke Gromen's case, the Plaza Accord and being early-wrong

Erik Townsend: Hang on one second, Brent, before you move on from this slide. You talked about the technical analysis side of it, and I understand that, but I want to touch on the fundamentals here because if we did see a breakdown below these trend lines that you're seeing now, something you and I have discussed in, in the past is our mutual friend Luke Gromen has a view that the US dollar is going to fall out of its preferential status at the center of the global financial system, lose its reserve currency status, and really, really be in big trouble. And you and I have both agreed in the past that Luke will be proven right someday. We just thought he was way early.

Why wouldn't you interpret what's happening now, and especially if you broke through the technical levels that you have illustrated on Page 7. Why wouldn't that be interpreted as the signal that says, okay, the dollar is having its Luke Gromen moment, it's the beginning of the end?

Brent Johnson: Well, I think the answer to that, Erik, would be the reason that it broke through that technical level. Now, if the reason that it breaks through that technical level is because a new Plaza Accord is announced and they come out and say that we have an agreement among nations that we are going to devalue the dollar over the next 2 to 3 years, Then Luke would absolutely be right.

If that happened, if it broke through that level because 4 other countries got together and said, we are no longer going to trade with the United States and we make up a big enough percentage of the global economy that it will drive the dollar lower and the US will see its worst days ahead of it, then that may be a reason to do it. If a new global dollar payment system or a new global payment system that is non-dollar is adopted by the rest of the world, and that's why It breaks through that level, then Luke would be right. But if it just breaks through it because the Fed comes out and makes some comment, or because the ECB comes out and bluffs and says that we are in fantastic shape, then I would just say it's been delayed.

And that's one thing I was going to address at some point here is, first of all, you can be completely wrong. And it's possible I'm completely wrong. I can't rule that out. The other type of wrong is you can be early wrong. Now, don't get me wrong. In this business, if you are early, you are still wrong. But being early wrong doesn't kill you. And it annoys you. It's frustrating, but it doesn't kill you. But if you're just early wrong and you're eventually right, like many people in the gold world, many people in the gold world were early wrong for the last several years. Now they're looking pretty smart today, right? They got the timing wrong, but now they're looking pretty smart. Same thing here. I can be early wrong, but early wrong, if you've sized things correctly, if you have risk management tools, it doesn't kill you.

And it still gives you the opportunity to make it back later on. And that's kind of where I think we are right now.

Why a dollar bounce is due: sentiment, positioning, DeMark

Erik Townsend: Brent, if I look at the technicals again that you have on page 7, it seems like, okay, the obvious setup is this is a buy. We're hitting that support line. What's the fundamental argument that would take us higher? Why would we expect a bounce from here?

Brent Johnson: Well, there's a couple other things, Erik. And one thing I would say is the huge sell-off in the dollar has caused the relative strength to just plummet. If you look on slide 8 on the right, that's the relative strength of the dollar. Again, the relative strength on the dollar hasn't been this low in over 20 years.

It got down into the mid-teens, which is extremely low for RSI. Now, the other thing to remember is that the dollar index, the DXY, is about 57% euro. So really, the DXY is almost a proxy for Euro yen versus dollar. You know, I didn't put up the trade weighted dollar and the Asian dollar index. If you look at those, the dollar is actually doing pretty well against most world currencies. It just so happened to be falling against the euro. But as the dollar index sentiment got completely washed out, the euro sentiment, the euro relative strength again is at the highest it's been in 20 years since it started trading.

So you know, we've got these extreme moves in relative strength. And then on the next page, this is a service that basically just tracks sentiment. And as of yesterday, the sentiment on the euro was 75 and on the dollar was 19. Now, 10 days ago, or about 2 weeks ago, the euro daily sentiment index was in the high 80s and the sentiment on the dollar index was 8.

Again, anytime you're over 80, 85, or below 15 or 10, again, these are extreme moves in sentiment. So that would be another argument.

And then if you go to page 10, this shows since the euro started trading in 1999, the speculative long position on the euro has never been higher. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean that it's going to turn down. I'm just pointing out that the big trade, the consensus trade is that the euro's going higher and that the dollar's going lower.

And then ZeroHedge put an article out the other day talking about how short dollar is now the world's most consensus trade. And they showed the net speculative position on the dollar to be the biggest dollar short position, just trading position in like 20 years.

And then finally, another way to track sentiment and technicals and kind of a combination of things is DeMark analysis. And a week ago, There was both a DeMark setup and a DeMark countdown indicators that were both triggered. And historically, when these have triggered, it's led to a pretty decent bounce in the dollar. Now, Erik, any of these things I've talked about in the last 3 or 4 slides and in the last few minutes, taken alone, doesn't mean a lot. But when I have this many things lining up and I have a fundamental belief that the dollar is going higher long-term, it just shows me that in the short-term, we're due for a bounce. Now, does it guarantee that we're going to have a bounce? Absolutely not.

It does not guarantee anything. I'm just pointing out that we have a very good setup for a bounce in the dollar. What happens after that? I don't know.

The funny thing about this business is a lot of people are afraid to say they get it wrong. But think about this. Our job is essentially to predict the future. Now, anybody who thinks that they can predict the future, and never get it wrong has to have an ego the size of Mount Everest. That's why I don't mind saying when I get things wrong. I'm going to get a lot of things wrong. I can't predict the future. All I can do is play the probabilities. And right now, I think the probabilities are for a dollar jump.

What would prove him wrong; Milkshake portfolio sizing

Erik Townsend: Okay, but the best of the best who know that they can be wrong also think about what it would take to prove them wrong so they know what to watch out for. What are you looking out for that would tell you, hey, got this bounce thing wrong, it's time to switch positions here and it really is going lower.

Brent Johnson: Yeah. So this kind of relates to what we talked about just a few minutes ago. And one of the biggest questions I get all the time, people email me or Twitter DM me and say, what's your stop? Do you have a stop price? And the reality is, is I don't have a stop price, but I have events that would cause me to stop. And this is kind of what we were talking about earlier. I think if there was a new global payment system that was developed and adopted by the rest of the world, that would be something that would stop me out.

If the rest of the world no longer wanted to sell goods to the United States consumers and no longer needed to trade in dollars, that would tell me that maybe I need to get out. And when the rest of the world does this stuff while they're fighting the US military and they successfully do so, that would tell me to get out.

But the other way to control risk is if you size the trade appropriately, the risk is already contained. So, I sent out a tweet back in March. This is on page 16. Someone asked me, what does this Milkshake overall portfolio look like over the next 2 to 3 years?

And I said, I think if I had to start right now, I'd have about 20% in short-term US Treasuries or fixed income, 20% in precious metals, 20% in real estate, 30% in US blue chips, and 10% in global macro or volatility. Now, that 10% global macro volatility, that is the area where we have a fund where we're playing these very asymmetric opportunities if the dollar gets stronger. Now, let's pretend for an example. Now, with that fund, I'll tell you that fund was up dramatically in the first quarter and it was down a lot in Q2.

It's still positive for the year, but let's pretend it wasn't positive for the year. Let's pretend it lost 100% of its money and the 10% allocated to global macro, Went to zero. Well, how is blue chip US blue chips done? How's gold done? How's the short-term treasuries done? So my point is, is even if I get it 100% wrong, if you size the trade appropriately and you get the other stuff right, you're not going to be hurt. You're actually probably still going to make some money.

The other thing is that if you can look at page 17, I show that you can't be static. You have to be open and you have to understand that things might change. And I've used this chart to kind of explain to clients how I think things will progress over the next few years. Now, again, this isn't a guarantee. Things might change, which causes me to change this. But if somebody came to me with $10 million and asked me how I would allocate it now and how I think it would develop over the next 3 years, this is kind of how I think it would do and how I would change. Now, maybe I have to change some of it along the way. Maybe I have to— maybe the timeline gets moved up. Maybe it takes longer. But the point is, is that If you size your trades appropriately, if you have a diversification and you have a plan, the risk is contained.

The other thing is that unless you want to bet big on one individual asset class, which is a good way to get rich or a good way to get poor, but if you want to have a diversified portfolio, the whole point of diversification is so that it doesn't all go up or all go down at the same time. So, if you have a diversified portfolio, the first question you should ask is, where are you making money? And the second question you should ask is, where are you losing money? And if the answer to the second question is you're not losing money anywhere, well, then you're probably not diversified. So, I think that's an important thing to remember as well.

And then the last thing I would say regarding the dollar, as far as the thesis, is that my Milkshake Theory, which again, it's a theory, Erik. This isn't the milkshake fact. I don't know whether it's going to play out. But the theory is not based on technical analysis. It's not based on relative strength and it's not based on the COT data of a futures trader, how they're positioned. It's based on a long-term fundamental call that is based on the design of the monetary system and the fact that there is a flaw in the design of the monetary system.

And that gives me a way to match my 2 to 3, 4-year time horizon with the time in which I think this theory will play out.

Digital currency, MMT and the next monetary system

Erik Townsend: Brent, you got me curious because great minds think alike, I guess. And I think quite a bit about this lately, specifically the comment that you just made about changing the monetary system. It seems to me that the, the mood internationally has shifted from everybody knows the US dollar is the global reserve currency forever to everybody knows we're stuck with it because there's no viable alternative. But a lot of People are thinking pretty hard about how to come up with that viable alternative.

Now, I have taken a view, which is the most likely way this eventually resolves, and I don't think we're there yet, is a digital currency system emerges, unlike the cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin that were designed to defeat monetary policy. Instead, somebody designs one which is intended to enable a whole new style of monetary policy.

Brent Johnson: Mm-hmm.

Erik Townsend: It's a digital currency system designed to appeal to central bankers so that whoever develops it can sell it to central bankers and say, look, this is your replacement for the US dollar that you've been waiting for. Now, that's my personal take. When you say, well, if the monetary system changes, what are you thinking? What kinds of things could come about that would provide a viable alternative to the US dollar as the center of the entire global financial system?

Brent Johnson: Well, you know what? That's a fantastic question, Erik. And my guess is that you and I could sit here and talk about this topic for 2 or 3 hours, maybe more than that, and not exhaust it. But in short, I will say that the design of the monetary system ensures that it's going to fail. It's just math, and it's not even difficult math. I don't have time to go through that all right now, but there is a design flaw in which the system will fail. So, it's not a question of if, it's just a question of when. And it's my opinion, which I think is also yours, is that we're getting much closer to that end and transition to a monetary system than many people would like to believe. My guess is that it will be in some form, we will move to some form of a digital currency.

I'm actually a big fan of Bitcoin, but I don't think Bitcoin is going to be adopted by a government. I think governments are going to issue their own coins. I don't think governments are going to willingly cede one of the biggest tools of policy that they have. It might be forced on them, but I don't think that they will willingly choose it. So, I think before that happens, they will try their own digital coins.

And the interesting thing is that this coincides with another battle within the monetary system, which I think is taking place. And that is central banks deciding monetary policy versus governments deciding monetary policy. And it gets into the whole central bank Keynesian system versus the MMT crowd, which says, you know, you don't need to loan money into existence. It can just be spent into existence.

And to your point about digital currencies, one of the— again, if you're taking the view from the government, not necessarily taking the view from an individual, but if you're taking the side and looking at it from a government's point of view, digital currencies would be a good way to get money directly to the people, to directly institute these MMT policies. to skip the banks where the money gets trapped and doesn't lead to the policy changes that they're hoping for. And so I think that's where we're headed. Now, I don't think we're there yet. I think we've still got a couple more years. And I actually think that this whole transition is going to take a little bit longer than a lot of other people, but there's no doubt in my mind that it's happening.

S&P outlook and why QE is deflationary

Erik Townsend: Boy, Brent, you're right. We could go on for hours and hours talking about this one, but I'm going to resist that temptation as much as I'd like to because we're We're halfway through the interview and haven't even talked about the stock market yet. So let's come back to page 23 in your slide deck, talk about the S&P. Boy, looking at this chart, on the one hand, it looks like we're breaking out to the upside from the channel you've drawn here. On the other hand, the last time that happened didn't turn out so well. So what comes next?

Brent Johnson: Well, you know, when we had the lows in March, you'll remember earlier in the year I was hedged and expecting a sell-off. I was expecting a sell-off to the bottom of that red channel. Well, it actually went further than that, but we got fairly aggressive for our clients who have exposure to equities. We got fairly aggressive in March and we had a nice bump, but I thought we might bounce up back to the top of that red channel and then turn back down. But boy, it just continued rocketing higher. And now it's even broken out from the green channel.

I am of the belief that we are going to have a retracement. I don't know if we will go all the way back down to the bottom of that red channel, but I think it's possible. And I'll tell you why.

For people that are following along with the slides, on slide 19, I think that the mechanics of QE are dramatically misunderstood. And my point here is that the stock market has rallied strongly on the belief that inflation is now here forever. And I think that that is incorrect. I will make the argument that QE is actually deflationary. as opposed to inflationary. Now, this is not to say that the government won't change what they're doing, the central bank won't change what they're doing and do a new policy that will be massively inflationary. I'm just saying that as it's currently designed, it's not inflationary. And I'm happy to walk through and tell you why that is.

Erik Townsend: Brent, let me just insert a question here about QE, because one of the things that you'll hear a lot, Ray Dalio says this quite a bit, is The way this all works, when the central bank, the Fed, gets into quantitative easing, they're buying bonds from bankers. So the banks are receiving money for those bonds. And what the banks end up doing is taking that money. And of course, maybe the intention of it was to create more lending or something. The banks are not using it for that. The banks are taking the money they get for the Treasury bonds that they're selling to the Fed, and they're using it to buy stocks, and that's pumping the stock market higher. Now, I think you have a different view. Why don't you agree with the very common description that I just went over?

Brent Johnson: Well, you're right. The description that you just explained is the completely accepted narrative right now. It is not technically correct, and I'll tell you why. On this page here, I've kind of showed the whole process by which cash gets moved around and the way Treasury funds itself. And we don't have time to go over the whole slide, but essentially, like you said, the theory is that the big banks buy Treasuries and then the Fed comes in. And in blue at the bottom of this slide, I've showed that the Fed sends cash created out of thin air for the T-bonds to the big banks, and the banks send the bonds back to the Fed in exchange for the cash.

Now, I've put this in here just as a way to explain it, but But it's not technically correct. Well, it is correct. The banks do receive cash from the Fed, but they don't— it's not like a checking account.

What happens is the big banks, they have an account at the Federal Reserve, just like you and I have an account at Bank of America or Wells Fargo or Bank of Montreal. The banks also have bank accounts. Their bank accounts sit at the Federal Reserve. So, when the Fed buys a bond, They do not send cash to the bank that the bank can go out and spend. What they do is they deposit cash into the reserve account that sits at the Federal Reserve. Now, this is the key right here. This cash that is deposited into the reserve account at the Federal Reserve, by law, cannot be used. It cannot be— I should hold on. It cannot be withdrawn. Like a checking account.

It can be used as collateral off of which they can create new loans, which is kind of, if you look in the chart from the, you know, down the bottom right up to the top right, they can use the collateral that they have in their account at the Federal Reserve to create new loans. And if they were doing that, that would be inflationary, but they are not doing that.

And they are— they cannot take cash out of that Federal Reserve account and go buy stocks with it. This again would be against the Federal Reserve Act.

So, if you think that they are doing that, you also think that the banks are in violation of the Federal Reserve Act. Now, again, I'm not saying that they won't eventually get there. I'm not saying that the Fed and the banks won't get together and eventually completely and totally monetize the debt directly. I'm just explaining from a legal perspective, they are not doing it currently.

And because the cash that the bank is getting for those bonds is not able to be used other than to create new loans, QE is actually deflationary because it is taking liquidity out of the system, not putting more liquidity into the system. These loans, I got a couple slides here which I can show you.

Erik Townsend: Hang on a second. Before you move on from this slide, I want to ask a clarifying question because what you're saying is When the Fed buys Treasury bonds for cash, that cash is credited to the bank's account with the Fed. It means that essentially that bank now has more bank reserves on deposit with the Federal Reserve, which is what they need to have in order to make loans. And you're saying, well, so it can't be used to buy stocks in the stock market. But hang on, Brent. Banks are in the business, at least to some extent, of making loans, and they're required by law to take money that they do have and put it on deposit with the Federal Reserve as bank reserves in order to collateralize those loans. So isn't it true that they've got money that they didn't have to put on deposit with the Fed because they got another source of funding the Fed?

And so there's money that they've got that they can go buy stocks with because they don't have to take the money in order to collateralize their loans and create bank reserves because their bank reserve requirement is being funded by the, the T-bonds that they're selling. So does it really work out to, to being, you know, just an alternative source of funding something that had to be funded anyway?

Brent Johnson: If the banks can source cash from a source other than the reserves they're getting from the Fed, they can do whatever they want with it. But they cannot take the funds they are receiving via QE and go buy stocks or go buy more Treasury bonds. That cash has to sit at the Fed and it cannot be withdrawn. It is like a trust account. Pretend you're an 18-year-old kid, your dad's a millionaire, and he gives you a trust account. You know it's there, it's your money, you own it, but you cannot withdraw it. It's possible you can go convince somebody to give you a loan against it, and you can get some liquidity that way, but you cannot withdraw that cash.

Implications for equities, Treasuries, gold and commodities

Erik Townsend: Okay, Brent, what are the implications? You're saying there's a very widespread misunderstanding that people think that the Fed's buying bonds for cash and banks are using that cash to go buy stocks. And you're saying can't happen, that's not true. What are the consequences and implications of that misunderstanding? In terms of how assets are either being mispriced or whatever it means to the market?

Brent Johnson: Well, the first implication is that the general market believes that the Fed is flooding the market with liquidity, and that changes their behavior. And so they go out and they buy stocks, and therefore you end up with a situation like you showed— well, like we showed earlier with the stock market, you know, being much higher. And so, we've had this significant rally in risk assets based on a false belief.

But the point I'd like to make is the fact, because it is in fact not inflationary, even though the belief is that it's inflationary, dollar liquidity, funding liquidity, liquidity in the markets is not as high as many believe.

And in fact, it's tightening. If you look at page 20, despite the popular narrative, Banks are raising their lending standards. This idea that there's all this money in the system and all you have to do is go out and grab it is completely wrong. Banks are raising lending standards and liquidity is tightening.

And that's not just with the banks. If you look at the shadow lending market and the peer-to-peer market, lending there, liquidity there is also drying up. And then I show this slide where Missing their inflation targets has become a way of life for the Fed and for central banks.

Now, Powell is giving a speech tomorrow morning at Jackson Hole, and I think the whole topic is how they're now going to let inflation run hot, which I think is funny because they want to let inflation run hot, but yet they can't even meet their target. But that will no doubt have some kind of a market impact, whether he exceeds expectations or misses expectations. But regardless of what he says, The fact is, is that lending has tightened and liquidity is tightening, not the opposite.

And so, the implications I believe are that equities are going to have a pullback. The other implications I believe is that Treasuries, I think yields will continue to go down on the US Treasury. If we get a hard pullback in the stock market, I would expect Treasury yields to go higher.

Now, listen, Treasury yields at this point are just a short-term trade. We're approaching the lower bound. I think I'm not convinced we're going to go negative on treasuries. But my point is that I think we're going to have another move down in treasury yields and a rise up in prices. But then at that point, I think the next— when the central banks have to come out again and do another program, that will be when yields potentially start to rise and when we actually get some inflationary pressures.

And so I think gold is extremely important. It's sitting at a very important role right here now too. It's basically back to its high from 2011. I continue to think that everybody should own gold. I've actually helped clients buy gold, physical gold, last 2 or 3 months. Now, that's not our speculative capital. That's our long-term insurance capital. I continue to believe that everybody should own it, but I also continue to believe that when we get in these periods where the dollar spikes, that gold will be seen as a source of funds. Again, I don't think people will sell gold because they want to. I think they may have to sell gold because they have to.

And if gold does pull back, I would then expect gold to rally quicker than everything else, just like it did the last time. But I don't think it keeps gold from getting sold in the very short term.

Another implication is that I think that this big rebound in commodity prices is off. I don't think we're going to continue to see a continued rise in commodity prices. I put a chart here that basically shows a 25-year head and shoulders. It broke through the base, and now it's come back up and it's retesting the base as resistance.

I don't think it's going to break out from there.

But can I be wrong on this stuff, Erik? I can. I always say I can be wrong. And if I'm wrong, let's think about if I'm wrong. Go back to the Milkshake Theory portfolio. It says to own gold, and it says to own equities, and it says to own risk assets. I just happen to think you should own those things for reasons other than most people think. But if I'm wrong and the dollar goes lower and, you know, gold goes higher and equities go higher, you know, we're actually going to do pretty well. So that's kind of where I see things. I think the market in general has the narrative wrong, but it's going to be interesting to see how things play out, you know, going into the election and the end of the year.

Gold outlook and commercials' positioning

Erik Townsend: Let's come back to the gold chart on page 25. I don't want to gloss over this because we've had so much conversation in the past, Brent, about, boy, you know, you and I are both super bullish long-term on gold. We've also both been astonished at just how strong this strength has been. What was the, the $1,350 to $1,377 support line lasted like 5 years, and all of a sudden in 5 months it seems like we've just doubled from there. But boy, it almost It feels like it. Are you still thinking— last time we spoke was quite a while ago— you were still thinking at that point that maybe a retest of that 1,377 was still in the cards because we haven't really seen a full technical correction yet. On the other hand, boy, just look at the money printing. It's hard to imagine coming all the way back down to 1,350 from where we've been.

What do you think? How big of a technical correction is still in cards for gold if one comes about?

Brent Johnson: Is it possible to go $1,350? I— yes, I would say it's possible. And it's, again, it's not because it should happen, it's just based on the design of the monetary system. Now, can it happen? Yes. Will it happen? I think it's probably unlikely at this point. I think, you know, going back to $1,500, $1,600, $1,700 is easily possible. Going back to $1,300, $1,200, that's, you know, that's going to be a bit difficult. It could happen in some kind of a very, you know, 1 or 2 day or a week spike lower event that gets recovered in 2 or 3 days. I think it's unlikely, but I can't rule it out.

Again, I don't own gold for speculative purposes. I own gold as insurance. I think it's going to go much higher. I think every interview I've given for the last 10 years, I've said gold is going to $5,000. I haven't changed on that. I still think that it's more likely than not that we're going to have a pullback from here, back down into the $1,600, $1,700 range seems very easy to me. potentially higher, but I don't think it should necessarily keep you from owning gold unless you have a very, very short-term time horizon.

Erik Townsend: A lot of traders really put a huge amount of emphasis and, and trust in the Commitment of Traders reports. And what we're seeing here on page 26 really is the commercials, which tend to be the, the smart money in terms of getting the trade right. They're kind of at a high open interest level here. What does this portend? What does it tell us about what could be coming next?

Brent Johnson: Well, it's a couple things. Like, typically what has happened over the last 10 years is as the net short position of the commercials rose, it would eventually correct, and that would— or it would eventually fall, and that would fall as the price of gold fell. Now, what's been interesting here is over the last call it month, we've actually seen the net short position as a percent of open interest has actually started to fall and gold has risen a little bit. Now, some people have interpreted that the banks are covering, they're getting short squeezed, they're closing their contracts at a loss.

And so, I can't rule that out. That's possible. But again, because of this large short position by the commercials, I tend to believe that But more likely than not, that is going to resolve itself with a lower gold price rather than a higher gold price. If I am wrong and the commercials have to cover their shorts, gold is not going to be at $1,900. It's going to be at $2,900.

Commodities: head-and-shoulders retest

Erik Townsend: Brent, let's go back to page 27 where you're showing on the long-term commodity chart, you see a 25-year head and shoulders pattern and you're showing the correction below the red line here. Looks like, you know, typical technical analysis formation is you break through a level on the downside, you kind of climb back up and kiss it, gives you one last chance to sell that level. Looks like that's what's happening right now. And if the pattern continues, which is not a certainty, then you'd expect new lower lows. Is that your outlook, new lower lows for commodities?

Brent Johnson: That's my very short-term outlook, yeah. I do think that we're going to get— over the next couple years, I think we're gonna come back, we're gonna break out of that, and And then we're going to be in a very long-term, very bullish market for commodities. I just don't think we're there yet. As long as the potential for this dollar spike remains, which until the monetary system is completely redesigned, the chance for a dollar spike always remains. That is what a credit crunch is. A credit crunch is the lack of dollar liquidity leading to a dollar spike. That's what a recession is. That's what deflation is. That's what a credit crunch is. So, until that is redesigned, and that is no longer possible, then that remains. And I think when we get a dollar spike, that will be negative for commodities. Now, it might not last long. They may come out and do some new program or new design or whatever, which, which changes things.

But as of right now, I am of the belief that the dollar gets stronger and commodity prices remain under pressure.

Can US Treasury yields go negative?

Erik Townsend: I want to come back to Treasury yields for a minute because something you said there really interested me. So many people say this same sort of narrative, which is Look, the world's global reserve currency cannot possibly go to negative yields on its 10-year maturity government bonds. That just isn't possible. And, you know, it sounds good. I, I like the ring of it, but I'm not really sure what the logic is to that because frankly, the same people said the same thing about the German Bund 5 years ago and look what happened there. But what is it that is so special about the fact that the dollar is the global reserve currency? Certainly, it does mean that central banks all around the world have to hold US Treasury bonds. So, is the logic of that, that somehow because central banks are holding them, the yield can't go negative? Why is it that so many people think the US 10-year cannot go to a negative yield?

And what's your view? Do you agree with that?

Brent Johnson: You know, I don't necessarily. I think it certainly can. I'm not convinced that it will. A lot of my friends who are big bond bulls and have been completely right, by the way, forever, are convinced it's going negative. I'm not convinced they're going negative because I'm not convinced they need to go negative. But I don't think that it is impossible. I think anybody who says anything is impossible is probably going to get proven wrong over the next 3, 4, 5 years. I think a lot of things that people don't think are possible are going to happen. Well, the one thing I would say is I don't think the Fed will take them negative, but the market might take them negative.

I think for the most part, the Fed understands that taking rates negative are a trap from which you cannot emerge. And I think that that is going to manifest itself in Europe over the next short while. And I don't think the Fed wants to get put in that same trap that Europe is in or that Japan is in. But the market could bid for treasuries in such a manner that it takes them negative. And that would not surprise me at all. I don't see the Fed setting them negative, but it would not surprise me at all to see the market take them there.

Because everybody, again, it's not that people want to buy Treasuries. It's not that people want to buy dollars. They have to in order to operate in the world today as it's currently designed. Now, can that design change? Of course, it can change. But until it changes, you have to have dollars.

US election and market implications

Erik Townsend: Final question. US presidential election is obviously getting nearer. What are the implications of a sweep on either side? What happens if Biden takes this? What happens if Trump keeps it? Is it clear what the implications are for markets? And if so, what are they?

Brent Johnson: Well, I think the popular narrative again is that if Biden wins, that's bad for markets. And if Trump wins, that's better for markets. You know, it's important. I don't want to diminish it's important. But I largely think, Erik, that the die has been cast. This is going to play out.

Regardless of who's in office, the speed with which things play out may change a bit. I'm of the belief that Trump is going to win again. Now, I remember giving an interview a week before the election last time, and I was pretty confident that Trump was going to win, and that turned out to be right. I don't have that same level of confidence this time. I still think he's going to win, but I don't think it's as sure as it was last time. With all that's going on with the protests and COVID, I think things are very, very up in the air.

I think that Trump is going to do better than the left and right coast and the traditional media thinks he's going to do, but I don't think it's going to be easy. And I think regardless of who wins, Erik, I think November and December are just going to be absolute crazy because regardless of who wins, the other side will not accept it, guaranteed. There is no way the Democrats will accept it if the election says was run by Trump, and there is no way The Republicans will accept it if it says Biden won. It's going to be decided by a lawsuit. I'm convinced of that.

Erik Townsend: Brent, before I let you go, please tell our listeners how they can follow your work and what you do at Santiago Capital.

Brent Johnson: Yeah. So Santiago Capital, it's a wealth management firm. I don't have model portfolios where everybody comes in and does the exact same thing. I've only got a couple, less than 2 dozen clients. I customize everything to the individual and they're all kind of fairly significant net worth clients. In addition to that, we run a fund, which again is playing the dollar asymmetry trades specifically.

My contact information can be found at santiagocapital.com. You can feel free to follow me on Twitter, Santiago Capital. Also, Santiago AU Fund is the handle. Feel free to email me. Feel free to send me a direct message. I get a lot of them, and I've kind of failed in responding to all of them lately because there's so many of them. But I do enjoy interacting with people. I'm happy to answer if I have the time to do it. So feel free to reach out.

Erik Townsend: Thanks, Brent. We look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor.

Erik Townsend: Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade. But the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with FarmTogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage. At MacroVoices.com.

Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction to the interview

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was so great to have Brent back onto the show. You know, his views on the dollar, I agree a lot with, uh, in principle, his core views on the dollar. And when he was referencing the technicals, the one thing for me, you know, while he does that trend line that suggests that there's a key support here, I still think there's room for the dollar to even weaken down to retest those 2018 lows and still not violate the bigger uptrend that's still in play. And so while he's certainly looking for this to be a key support, I still think that if the dollar even weakened down to the 90 handle and then bounced back, that it still would be uninterrupted in its trend. But nonetheless, what did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, I really agree a lot with Brent, and particularly what I respect about Brent is, you know, he's one of the grownups in this business. He knows that nobody's right all of the time. Brent and I have both had a dollar— I don't want to say dollar bullish view. As Jeff Snider has said, it's a view that the dollar is likely to appreciate. It doesn't mean the dollar is healthy and strong and wonderful. It means that for technical reasons, it's broken in a way which is likely to make it appreciate relative to other currencies. You know, it's at a point where we're getting pretty darn close here to a technical level where you just have to say, look, It looks like we're wrong about this. I really am looking forward at some point to getting Luke Gromen back onto the program because I'd like to get his take on this. He's the guy who's been calling for dollar down and the end of the dollar's hegemony over the global financial system for years now.

Is Luke finally being proven right? I agree with Brent that there's a long list of things that could happen, such as the emergence of a digital currency that provides a viable alternative to the dollar as global reserve currency, that would just put the death knell in the dollar overnight. And you could see a big crash situation if there was really a viable alternative that central banks started to really jump on as a new trend. I just don't see that happening yet. So I'm still leaning with Brent that there's plenty of room for this to turn around. The thing is, we've been wrong for the last month. This can't go on a whole lot longer before it's time to just say, okay, some reason it's, it's not working the way we thought. In any event, Patrick, I want to get on to your chartbook.

Chartbook: options gamma and cheap put protection

Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says Big Picture Trading Chartbook.

What are we looking at today, starting with page 2, S&P futures? Ta-da! There's that acceleration I talked about in last week's market wrap to the upside.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. That's right. And so we've, we've seen the, the S&P consolidate into the option expiration, the gamma pin that was going in. We were looking for volatility. My bias was that it was going to be the downside, but clearly the volatility came back and it was with a big breakout to the upside. And what's interesting about that breakout, we've, uh, put on ourselves just the calendar straddles that we've done in the past. And, uh, while it really does help that this market is starting to move quickly, it doesn't really matter which direction. And the fact that this market is moving this way, I kind of asked the question, well, what is the drivers behind it? And this is where I thought was really interesting on chart 3. And this was a Goldman Sachs chart that they put out that was actually showing a really amazing phenomenon that's been happening. And that is the fact that in the options market, we are seeing that now 75% of the total open interest volume now lies in the weekly options that have 2 weeks or less till expiration.

And so what we've seen is this speculative fever really grasp investors that are playing this rocket momentum that's happening in the markets by playing these front-month options. But there's an interesting byproduct of that, is the fact that the dealers who are often on the sell side of these call options in fact, uh, have all of this gamma risk. And in fact as the market rallies, it's actually forcing them to be the marginal buyers of the stocks to stay delta neutral. And so we've found this real kind of fuel or accelerant that is actually accelerating the markets. And what's amazing as well, if you look on the right-hand side, what you can observe is the fact that the volume of call option buying is skyrocketing while the growth in volumes in put option buying is actually substantially curtailing from the highs. And you would think that with the market up along their highs, it would actually increase the desire to hedge some of that risk.

And instead, everyone is just piling more and more into these call options on the upside. And this continues to drive and be that momentum, like throwing gasoline on a fire.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, moving on to page 4. Holy cow, look at the size. of that spike in the premium for S&P puts. Obviously, it's easy to say that's because of the pandemic crisis emerging, but wow, look at the size of that. What's going on and what is the significance of coming back down to that red trend line?

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, when looking at this chart, what is amazing is that obviously when the market was crashing, the cost of buying out-of-the-money puts as insurance skyrocketed, and that's what you're observing But prior to the corona crash, generally what we saw was that the cost of put options was relatively cheap, and especially in when everyone's short gamma, and generally it was a period where buying insurance was relatively cheap. Now in the post-corona period, we've seen volatility start to normalize. We see the VIX heading back down toward the 20 handle at this stage. But generally, as we showed on the previous chart, there isn't a structural demand for puts. No one seems to be worried about the downside risks of the market. And generally, the cost of these out-of-the-money puts are actually now coming to levels that are historically reasonably priced. I mean, we're to like the, uh, 85th percentile in terms of where we've been trading. But more importantly, since the coronavirus, uh, February, the median premium was 1.9% over the past 6 months.

And so with us now being very close to 1%, it hasn't been much cheaper than, uh, in the last 6 months to buy put protection with the stock market up at long its all-time highs. So it's interesting that we're up here. And if you wanted to keep staying along the stock market and pressing up, it doesn't cost as much. Uh, it's, it's never been cheaper in the last 6 months to buy put protection on your portfolio.

Erik Townsend: So the strategy of a long protected by a protective put, what some people call a synthetic call strategy, is cheap again, which it hasn't been since the crisis began.

Patrick Ceresna: That's right. And so it's just a thought that, you know, those people that want to continue to participate on the upside of the market, starting to put in some hedges, it might seem like a reasonable proposition after we're going almost, uh, 5, 6

Nasdaq 160-day rally versus 1999-2000

Patrick Ceresna: months of pretty much straight up on the market, right? And so, uh, another interesting thing I wanted to look at on this page 5 and 6, and I just really wanted to put in context the magnitude of the rally that we saw on the NASDAQ over the last 5 months. And so what I wanted to start with on page 5 is just looking at the fact that when you go back to the 1999-2000 blowoff of of the Nasdaq. When it broke out, it rose in 100% or doubled in its value in 160 days.

And what's interesting is we are now approaching the 160-day mark off of the coronavirus low in March. And so on page 6, what we can see is that we've now seen a 70% rise in those 160 days. And so I just, it's interesting to put context in terms of just magnitude of the rally. Now admittedly, there's a reflexivity to the fact that the Nasdaq crashed in the prior month before this rally is being measured. So I'm measuring off of an incredibly oversold low, but it is just showing you also though the magnitude of this rise. And I mean, it's second only to one of the greatest bubbles we've seen. And it's really interesting to see how long the bulls can keep this momentum running before we see that mean reversion that inevitably happens on every one of these types of rises.

Erik Townsend: Well, it certainly is fascinating, Patrick, to see just how dramatically the recovery has been. And I think it makes perfect sense. You know, the Nasdaq, primarily tech stocks, which are, you know, less affected— there's a lot more people buying stuff on Amazon and watching their Netflix accounts because of the crisis— boy, straight up. And new all-time highs, and it's just amazing. Not only is it interesting to me that 70% has happened in 160 days, but look at the difference between the March bottom.

You got back up to the previous all-time high, and then you went more than— than that's, you know, the distance from the March bottom to the all-time high. You went more than that much up.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Lumber, remote work and real estate

Erik Townsend: up again in order to get to the current high. So it's a really profound move. Speaking of profound moves, let's move on to page 7. Lumber futures— oh, wait a minute, is this Tesla or lumber? Yeah, it's lumber futures. That's it.

Patrick Ceresna: Everyone's talking about this parabolic rise or this big huge rise in the Nasdaq and technology stocks, but there is one market that has actually been outperforming the Nasdaq, and, uh, and that is lumber futures, which are limit up today, and they off of their March lows are up 250%. And so this has been just a stunning trade for anyone who's gone long lumber. And what's amazing to me about what's happened here is that intuitively on one side, I would've thought that with a huge rise in unemployment, now generally that would've actually decreased the demand for new homes and real estate But in fact, what we've seen is the opposite. You know, we've had Josh Steiner and Kevin Muir talking about this idea that inevitably the millennials are going to enter the housing market and start to buy homes, and that there was going to be a boom driven by the millennials making that move. And what we're finding, at least the speculation is, is that with the coronavirus basically shutting down cities, it actually has acted like the trigger or the fuse to actually begin this transition.

And the demand for homes has actually been skyrocketing. At the same time, we're seeing that many of these mills have just not been running at full capacity because of the coronavirus. And this has created like a perfect shortage in lumber. And it's going to be really interesting to see how this plays out.

Erik Townsend: I mean, this thing is just going Patrick, I think the trend that underlies all of this has a long, long ways left to go. Now, I don't know if it manifests itself in even higher lumber prices or not. You'd have to do some analysis on exactly where the bottlenecks are in that market, but I don't see it quite the way you and Kevin do, where you're talking about accelerating a trend that might have already been in play with, let's say, a millennial generation You know, move out to the suburbs and that creates some more demand for housing.

I think that the coronavirus crisis potentially is going to change the world forever. And the reason is it's the catalyst that really brought about a change that was already enabled by technology. We've had the ability, let's say, take New York City, the most expensive real estate, or maybe second most expensive.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: of real estate next to Hong Kong in the world. Why would you pay, you know, $2,000 a square foot or whatever it is to buy an apartment in New York City where a little studio apartment costs upwards of $1 million?

Well, the reason is if you wanna work in the finance industry, which is probably the best paying jobs anywhere, it's where you physically had to be. And Second of all, in terms of restaurants and being able to enjoy your wealth, New York City is the place. Best restaurants on earth. It's it.

You can go to a few, just a few places around the world, like Aspen, Colorado, where they have bordering on New York City quality of restaurants and quality of amenities for life.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: But there aren't many places like that. Usually, the trade-off is you move out of the city and you end up with crappy restaurants and not the kind of selection that city dwellers get used to. I think that what we're seeing is the beginning of a trend whose real enabler is technology. It's the fact that we can work from anywhere over the internet that is going to make it possible for people to move out of big financial centers like New York and London and so forth. And live in the countryside.

And if I was a real estate guy, you know, you got to invest in what you know and understand, and real estate is not my thing. But if I was a real estate guy, I wouldn't be looking at building the next hotel or the next little, you know, bunch of tract houses. I would be saying, look at a map, find me closest to New York City that I can get where I can buy a lake and 10,000 acres minimum, and I can develop a new high-end Aspen, Colorado-like place that is out in the sticks where everybody gets a 2-acre lot and it's on the lake and they've got their little dock with their boat and the whole living in the country bit, but it's got restaurants that are like New York City and it's got solid public transit and it's— we're gonna build that whole village.

I would be looking at that kind of project because I think the move out of New York and move out of London and move out of Los Angeles trend is going to be huge, and it's going to depress property values in inner-city environments, which used to be the most valuable real estate.

And I think it's going to put demand, especially on high-end housing, in resort areas. And you're already seeing it with places like Whistler, Canada, and Aspen. The, the best ski resorts that are also summer vacation destinations are going to turn into full year-round destinations. And you're already seeing that. And I think the building in those areas is going to go through the roof.

Iron ore, breakevens and the 2-10 steepener

Erik Townsend: But let's move on to page 8, Patrick, and talk about iron ore. Why did you pick this chart to add to the book this week?

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, I want to actually talk a little bit about inflation. And one of the biggest inputs in inflation are commodity prices. And the biggest one, of course, is crude oil, but we already talk about that on every single show. What I really wanted to do was touch on some of the other ones that we rarely touch on. And so we talked there about lumber, but now I want to talk iron ore. And iron ore continues to gravitate toward 5-year highs. And it'll be really interesting to see whether big breakouts in these types of basic materials really start to emerge and really reconfirm this idea that some sort of material rise in commodities is underway, which will inevitably translate to some transitory inflation. That will start to reflect on the charts.

And so what's interesting is that when we go to page 9, I have the 10-year breakevens. And what we can see is not only are we seeing the high of the year printing right now, but we're actually approaching the 2019 highs up around 180. And so it'll be really interesting to see whether or not these inflation expectations continue to edge higher. And when we go to Page 10, we can really see what I have is the 2-10 steepener. And not only were we negative and inverted on the curve back in 2019, but we now are finding ourselves putting in what was clearly a bottom along there, and we're making higher highs and rolling up. The particular interesting thing about this yield curve steepener and the idea is that it really would have to be a bear steepening. The Fed is not to take their foot off of the front of the curve, pinning it down toward zero.

And so really what this is going to be all about is whether or not inflation expectations rise and it starts to be baked into that 10-year yield. And it'll be really interesting to see whether we're in the midst of a new breakout in the steepener.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, you make excellent points. I think it is important for us to point out in the case of iron ore, at least iron ore comes from Australia and And Brazil, 2 countries very, very badly hit, particularly Brazil, by the COVID-19 crisis. So one of the things that remains to be seen is, first of all, how long does the crisis last? Because nobody really knows. When we do get some degree of recovery from the COVID-19 situation, do those iron ore prices come back down because they were driven so much higher by mining difficulties of production because of the crisis? Or Or were they set to, to have this move anyway because of inflation and the COVID crisis just provided the catalyst to turn their direction around? That's going to be really interesting to see, but I think the inflation breakevens suggest maybe it's more likely to be the latter. Meanwhile, Patrick, the latter slide in the deck, slide number 11, tells our listeners how they can get a free trial to

Sign-off, Research Roundup and closing

Erik Townsend: your service, Big Picture Trading.

Folks, you can get Patrick's commentary just about every day, 4 days a week, on bigpicturetrading.com. Be sure to check it out and get your free trial. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors, and by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written At toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo.

Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads of associated with our guest appearances as well as, of course, our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to Brent's charts and the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an article asking, is the euro living on borrowed time? And a link to a Talking Data interview with Jim Bianco on what's next for inflation. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distribution.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Erik Townsend: That concludes this week's episode of MacroVoices.

Announcer: This edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com.

Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile. interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time. And we'll see you next week. Time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, Visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Jesse Felder — Former hedge fund manager (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Opening: sponsors and episode preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 233 was recorded on August 20th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by toptradersunplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by masterworks.io, which brings investment in fine art within reach of all investors. Former hedge fund manager Jesse Felder returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from the stock market to the US dollar to gold and even digital reserve currencies. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick and I will discuss equity markets, credit spreads, volatility, and the extraordinary contango in the gold market.

Market wrap: S&P 500, US dollar, crude oil, gold, 10-year yield

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's just jump right to the S&P 500, 'cause yesterday on the FOMC, we had a quick dive in the market. It wasn't that crazy. I mean, 50 S&P points or so. So, and more or less today we've made most of it back. We're about 3,380. I have some charts to share in the postgame, but what's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it's perfectly normal, even independent of the Fed minutes and everything else going on. You know, it's perfectly normal when you hit a resistance level, and certainly the prior all-time high is always a resistance level, you expect to see some consolidation for a while before you either break higher or lower.

You know, the— you know, it's got to at least slow down when it gets to that price because some of the people think it's a double top. They're going to be selling it. It's going to turn down. Some people are going to get sucked into that. You know, you have to see what happens. So I think that it's perfectly consistent with an expectation of perhaps much higher prices to come that we would see a pause here at the previous all-time high, which is what we're seeing.

Now, Charlie McElligott had a note out today saying that he sees a couple of different catalysts that could really go in either direction. So he's predicting next week potentially a significant move in one direction or the other. And of course, Charlie tends to I would take a fairly near-term view. Longer term, I expect we're going to eventually get through this level. If you look at what the other indices have done, the Nasdaq and the Dow and so forth, they're already at new all-time highs. So why wouldn't the S&P get there too? I don't see any sign of central bankers letting up on their stimulus, and that is what I think has been fueling this. And of course, I'll ask Jesse Felder in today's interview.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to the US dollar because we started the week with a break on the DXY to a fresh multi-month low. And then again, we had a big reversal candle on Wednesday after the FOMC minutes. What's your take? Do you think we're starting to get oversold enough to put in a bottom here, or is there more weakness to come?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's definitely oversold here. There's no doubt about that. The thing you got to remember is crashes don't start from overbought levels. They start from oversold levels. So oversold is just a technical term that refers to, if this is not the big one, Then it's probably done being the little one. Well, we don't know if it's the, the Luke Gromen moment, the, the big one, or not. I doubt it. Uh, it seems to me like it is technically oversold. We're due for at least a bounce. But the thing is, I have to admit, I wasn't really expecting this much weakness.

I thought that the dollar shortage, dollar squeeze argument that Jeff Snider talks so much about was going to take us to a higher dollar index, and that has certainly not panned out. I'll ask Jesse Felder as well, but, uh, so far, you know, I don't really see reason to conclude that Luke is finally about to be proven right, but we could be seeing the beginning of that. Let's see what happens.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because we started to sell earlier today and we made it— we're almost back to $43 on the upside on that October contract. What's your take on what's going on here in the crude oil markets?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's 2 solid months now of sideways consolidation in a very, very narrow trading range. This is what a lot of traders call a coiled market. The analogy is to a snake that's coiled up ready to strike. The question is, in which direction? Is it going to be a sudden big move up or a sudden big move down?

And frankly, you can make the argument in either direction. Big picture, Art Berman tells us to expect US production to fall off a cliff in Q4. Well, it's still Q3, it's not Q4 yet. US production is holding steady at 10.7 million barrels this week, so we're not seeing that yet. But Art says it's coming. That would say at least in the next few months, higher prices should be ahead.

The counterargument is from a seasonality standpoint, you know, end of August is usually where the seasonal top comes— last week of August, first week of September. Then September, the rest of the month tends to be a sell-off. Now, that's seasonality that's based on a pattern that has to do with summer driving season, which may or may not be relevant in the midst of a global pandemic.

With respect to the COVID-19 outlook, I see reason for probably, especially as we get into Q4, to expect higher prices. And the reason I say that is A lot of people are expecting a second wave to hit around October or November. And the more that I've seen in terms of data, there's lots of reasons to think that in places like Australia and New Zealand that have not really allowed their first wave to burn through yet, that there's still more to come. In places like most of the United States where the first wave now finally has really burned through, there's a lot of new evidence saying that the T-cell immunity is going to hopefully save the day, and maybe it's not gonna be as bad as we think.

If that proves correct and the feared second wave in the fall— a lot of people think, well, when the weather gets colder, that's going to be what does it. If you look at the data, this particular virus doesn't really show a lot of correlation with temperature. It does show some correlation from the standpoint that when you get to either extremes of temperature, very cold or very hot, where people have to be indoors, that's what seems to make it worse. But as we get into the autumn, there's no reason to think that temperature is going to, you know, make things worse, even though a lot of people seem to be assuming that. So I think we could have a favorable surprise in terms of not getting the second wave a lot of people fear. And I think that could result in increased demand at a time when supply is still really beginning to fall off significantly as a result of the lower rig count.

Moving on to inventory this week. Crude oil drawing down 1.6 million barrels. Now, that's the number everybody focuses on. And, you know, it's a significant drawdown. The thing is, the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which normally is the government's oil storage, but they've been leasing it out for private storage. So it really is kind of private storage at the same time. That was another drawdown of 2.7 million barrels. So net 4.3 million barrels of crude oil coming out of storage this week. Another 607,000 barrels, or I should say 607,000 thousand of those barrels came out of the Cushing storage facility in Cushing, Oklahoma. Gasoline drawing down 3.3 million barrels. Distillates was the only build on the entire board, and it was a de minimis 152,000 barrels. So you got drawdowns across the board. The drawdown on crude oil is bigger than it looks if you consider the SPR.

Meanwhile, US production, as I mentioned, is holding steady at 10.7 million barrels, unchanged from last week. Tape action, you know, that was a pretty significant bullish signal, you would think. Really big, or reasonably big, drawdowns across the board with the small exception of distillates. That causes the price to bump up as soon as the news comes out, and it lasts all of an hour or so. By the time we get to Thursday morning on the Fed minutes news, we're down $1.50. So it didn't last.

And this market has really been frustrating a lot of people because it's been really showing a lot of signs that it wants to break out to the upside, but as soon as the move gets going, it always stumbles and fails and ends up trading back down below those key resistance levels. So it just doesn't seem like the energy is there for that upside breakout. Eventually, we're going to get some kind of move here, and I think it'll be significant. My guess is the market is waiting to see what happens with the second wave, and it's waiting to see what happens with U.S. production, whether those expectations of U.S. production decreasing dramatically as a result of the lower rig count and production declines really kicking in is going to be realized. And I think it will be realized, and I think that's going to bring us higher prices, but probably not for another month or two.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's talk gold because we've obviously for the last several weeks been talking about not only the parabolic rise, but inevitably that some form of a market correction was going to occur in the gold markets. And we will now are several weeks into that, including a Pretty nasty break yesterday on the downside. Do you think the correction in gold is over, or what's your take on all this?

Erik Townsend: Well, it looks like maybe it's not over after all. And to me, I mean, as a gold bull, that's terrific news. The breakout area that this move, you know, started from was right around $1,800. So I'd really like to see, in terms of cleaning out the system, if you will, a nice technical correction back down to just around $1,800. And I've got limit orders resting just above $1,800. $1,800 to buy some more gold. There's more downside possible beyond that, but I think it would take a catalyst of some kind to really get a sell-off going below $1,800. From where we are now, as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon at $1,955, you know, to come down $100, $150 from here, get to $1,800 or just a little over $1,800, wouldn't surprise me that much. I think it would be good news in terms of strengthening this bull market by clearing out some of the excess that's existed for the last

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's just wrap up by touching on the 10-year Treasury yield because we did pop above the 70 basis point level. And since then, we've been backing off. We are now about 4 or 5 days into pulling back. We're about 0.64 right now on the yield. What's your take on where we are with interest rates?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think everybody can't decide what's going on here. Is this just a pause that we're seeing in the bond bull market because the market's got to get through the psychological factor of, oh my God, Gosh, negative interest rates are coming? Or are we seeing signs that inflation really is on the rise? I'm seeing lots of those signs. They're early signs, but it looks like inflation expectations, and certainly the rapid increase in the price of gold is one of the signals that tells us that. If we do think inflation is about to make a comeback, that suggests that bond yields are likely headed back up and prices coming down. So I think the market's It's kind of waiting to try to figure it out. And we seem to be stuck again in this very narrow trading range.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, this week's featured interview guest is former hedge fund manager Jesse Felder. Now, Erik, why did we invite Jesse back onto the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Jesse's a really bright guy and he's been one of our listeners' favorites for years. We wanted to get him back because Jesse has been a stock market bear for several years. And, you know, as we look at the current situation of maybe breaking out to new all-time highs, I wanted to get an update from Jesse on his perspective. on the market, what's driving this, how long it can last, whether it's about the Fed or something else, and just seemed like a good time to get him back.

I also want to remind our listeners, it really helps us a tremendous amount if you can rate and review us on iTunes, help get us back into the top financial podcast list that we used to be at the very top of. The instructions for exactly how to do that, if you're not familiar with ratings and reviews on iTunes, is in your Research Roundup email.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by Masterworks.io.

See disclaimer at Masterworks.io/disclaimer. And by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Jesse Felder is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Jesse Felder: bubble versus mania

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is former hedge fund manager turned Felder Report publisher Jesse Felder. Jesse, it's great to have you back on the program. On the day that we are speaking, the global pandemic appears in some ways to be worsening across Europe with case counts on the rise, although we don't yet have death counts on the rise across Europe. A lot of question marks as to whether that's coming. There are a number of experts that are warning that as we get into the fall, fall, colder weather in the Northern Hemisphere, we could be looking at a vicious second wave of the pandemic. Stocks meanwhile rallied to new all-time highs on the news. Jesse Felder, please explain.

Jesse Felder: Well, it's, uh, it's absolutely astounding. I mean, you know, we talked, I think last time you had me on the show, Erik, was February, right before the decline began. And, um, you know, you and I both were very bearish, thought that that decline, uh, initial 10% decline was going to continue. And it's, you know, I think Even at the bottom in March and after, you know, a few weeks afterwards, nobody would've guessed that we would see the fastest. And a lot of people were calling the shortest bear market in history, which I tend to disagree.

I think there's a good chance we're still in a bear market. But I do think, I'm thinking a lot about this quote from George Soros recently where he talked about bubbles. He said, stock market bubbles don't grow out of thin air. Under normal conditions, misconceptions are self-correcting and the markets tend towards some kind of equilibrium. Occasionally, a misconception is reinforced by a trend prevailing in reality, and that's when a a boom-bust process gets underway.

Eventually, the gap between reality and its false interpretation becomes unsustainable and the bubble bursts. I think there's just so many misconceptions right now driving this bubble. And it's also important to distinguish between a bubble and a mania. And I think the bubble is just price going 2 standard deviations out of its historical range, à la Jeremy Grantham. We're well beyond that in the stock market.

But I think it's more interesting to look today at these narratives or misconceptions that are driving the mania. Mike Green has done some work on the passive parts of this bubble and how passive investing is driving it. But there's also a mania in day trading that we're witnessing right now. And I think that these 2 things helped explain what's going on.

Passive investing and investor misconceptions

Erik Townsend: Let's start with the Mike Green perspective. For any listeners who are not familiar, Mike Green has just gone from not a lot of people knew who he was to everybody talking about it. And I think that an interview that he did recently with Bill Fleckenstein and Grant Williams probably has led To a lot of that. To all of you guys that are bombarding us with, get Mike Green on MacroVoices, we've got it lined up. It's coming, guys, in September. So, so stand by for that.

But I want to get your perspective on this though, Jesse, because Mike laid out a thesis about passive investing and flows, basically saying, you know, this has gotten mechanical to the point where it's really not about anybody making some value decision and saying, hey, I really think I think the stock market is undervalued here and I'm going to buy more. It's more of just flows that keep coming into the market through passive investment strategies. Did you hear that interview and what was your reaction to it? Do you have any disagreement with Mike's perspective on that?

Jesse Felder: Well, I absolutely agree. And I've been writing about passive for a long time. Passive investing has undermined its most basic assumption, which is that the market is efficient. Well, when passive becomes the market, it loses that efficiency by definition. And so there's a bunch of problems with passive and the fact that so much money is flowing into it is absolutely distorting the markets.

But I think it's those misconceptions that are most interesting to me. One of those is the price you pay does not determine your rate of return. People think I can literally pay any price for the broad stock market and I deserve a historical rate of return, which is exactly the opposite of what made Buffett such a successful investor. The belief that The price you pay is what determines your rate of return.

There's also this belief that low interest rates justify higher multiples for valuations for those that are looking at valuation. But I think low interest rates help explain why valuations are extreme, but they don't justify extreme valuations. And all you have to do is understand a simple discounted cash flow analysis to understand this. Essentially, what investors are doing when they say, low interest rates justify higher valuations is they're lowering the discount rate, but they're not also lowering the growth rate of earnings. And historically, I mean, this is something Cliff Asness proved a long time ago, that the discount rate and the earnings growth rate are essentially locked at the hip. You don't get faster growth without also raising the discount rate. And so that's just a misconception.

And then if you look at markets like Europe and Japan, where you have negative interest rates, valuations there are much lower than the United States valuation. So To me, that's another clear misconception.

Finally, you have this belief that if your time horizon is long enough as a buy-and-hold passive investor, you'll always be made whole, that you'll never lose money. And even the history of the US market kind of disproves that. You look at 1929, it was 20-plus years of being in the red from the peak there.

The late '60s, early '70s was another time where nominally you were in the red and then in In real terms, you're in the red for 20-plus years. And then just look at the Japanese market peaked in 1990 and still remains substantially below that peak made 30 years ago. So these are all misconceptions that are driving people into passive, but they won't be, I guess, obviously proven to be misconceptions until we come to the other side of this bubble.

Retail mania, options flow and quant funds

Erik Townsend: Jesse, there's another aspect of this I know that you're watching, which is one of the signs that we're taught to look for is at the In the late stages of a bull market, it's when you tend to get a lot of new novice retail investors coming into the market wanting to, you know, get on the coattails of this big move that's already happened. And a lot of times that tends to mark the top. Now, at this point, it's a little different this time in the sense that retail mania actually has an elected poster boy named Dave Portnoy, who seems to be the representative of of less than completely experienced retail investors entering this marketplace.

Is that part of this? How much of a part of it is it? And what message does that really tell us? Because, you know, at the same time, there's also an argument that the reason it's working and the reason that a lot of these very inexperienced traders are making money is because there's a macro backdrop with what the Fed's doing that supports it. And maybe it's smart for, for these dumb guys that don't really know what they're doing. It's working for them now. Why shouldn't they keep doing it?

Jesse Felder: You're absolutely right to point out Dave, and I hate to probably call him out by name, but he reminds me of another online personality during the late '90s bubble. Tokyo Joe was a famous— was actually brought up on SEC charges for a pump-and-dump scheme, but he became so popular for buying up stocks, small little internet names, then promoting them through his huge audience and then selling when the audience started buying. And I think it was early 2000, he was actually busted by the SEC. And that kind of was right around the top of that market. But we see a very similar kind of retail mania today. And I think we talked about it back in February.

There was a great piece Luke Kawa wrote for Bloomberg about the options trading, the retail activity in options, and how they believe that they've found kind of a perpetual motion machine, I think is the term Luke used, where if they pool their resources, buy a bunch of call options, forces market makers to go essentially sell them the calls, they're short calls, they got to go buy underlying. They can actually manifest profits as long as they're doing that.

But I think there's another Soros quote related to bubbles that I think also helps explain what's really going on with this. And Soros said, when I see a bubble forming, I rush in to buy, adding fuel to the fire. That's not irrational. And I think there are a ton of quantitative hedge funds right now that are piggybacking on top of this retail flow. I think, you know, to me, the greatest, I guess, signpost in this regard was when Robintrack was shut down because Robinhood wasn't sharing their data anymore publicly.

I think last week or the week before, Steve Cohen's hedge fund and a couple others came out, mainly quantitative funds, and said, we're putting out an urgent request to replace this data that we lost, you know, with E*Trade and all the other types of brokers. They need that to see that order flow for their quant models. And to me, that suggests that What a lot of these quant funds are doing is they'll see investors rush into Apple shares and they'll just see the very beginnings of that and know that that's going to carry on for a period of time. And so what they're going to do is they're going to rush into Apple or whatever it is and add fuel to the fire, potentially through the options market. I've been amazed to see days where Apple trades 500,000 call options in a day of at-the-money strikes that expire that same Or on that Friday. And so to me, that's 50 million shares of underlying demand for a stock for options that expire in a day or two.

We're talking about Wednesday, Thursday demand.

So there's this other dynamic where retail investors are pouring into the market because they believe this is a buy. The March 2020 crash was a buying opportunity on par with March 2009, even though valuations at the bottom of March 2020 were 100% higher. than March 2009. There's this other belief, Dave Portnoy may be the one really promoting this, stocks only go up.

And it feels like that since March, but obviously that's patently not true. There are times when they don't.

And finally, there's the belief that Fed money printing guarantees profits in the stock market. And I think that's the buy the dip mentality that we've seen for 10+ years now.

And where I think that is going to be proven to be a misconception is something And the other thing that got a little bit of attention when Stan Druckenmiller brought it up a few months ago, but people have completely forgotten about it, is that it's not just Fed liquidity that matters. It's net liquidity. What is the Treasury doing?

You need to see what is essentially the growth in the Fed balance sheet, less growth in the Treasury, because that's what net liquidity looks like. And the Treasury needs to sell $2 trillion of new debt in the second half. If the Fed doesn't monetize that completely, That's all net liquidity for the stock market.

So I do think it's these twin manias. And I do think this is where I disagree a little bit with Mike is that we've seen, I think this is where retail is picking up the mantle from passive. I think it's been passive for the past 10 years, but we've seen significant net outflows from equity funds, domestic equity funds this year and over the past 18 months or so. So when you have net outflows out of the market, how does the market go up? How do we get new highs?

I think the only way to explain that is through this retail mania that's being magnified by quantitative hedge funds.

Tesla as poster child of the mania

Erik Townsend: Jesse, let's talk about a specific situation that, to my thinking, kind of epitomizes this market. Just looking at my Tesla chart, it's not quite 2,000 today, but I mean, heck, it was, I don't know, just a month ago or 6 weeks ago that nobody could believe It was already $1,000 a share for Tesla. Now we're looking at $2,000 a share, and it seems like one of the most ridiculous things you ever see in any market, which is when a stock split, which really doesn't mean anything substantive, it's just a change in the number of shares and it means that the share price changes.

The announcement of a stock split appears to have been the catalyst for a big move up in the price of Tesla shares. And that to me suggests a lot of very inexperienced hands in this Tesla market. But, you know, as much as it might be tempting to say, oh, it's a ripe short, a lot of smart people were saying that at $1,000 because it was a crazy valuation at $1,000. That was 6 weeks ago and the stock has doubled.

What, what do you make of this and what does it say about the market?

Jesse Felder: Well, a lot of really smart, experienced shorts were saying Tesla was a great short at $200 a share.

Erik Townsend: I was saying it at $75 and I still think it was right, but it didn't work out.

Jesse Felder: Yeah, no, I absolutely agree. And I think Tesla may be, when this whole mania is kind of in our rearview mirror, we'll look back at Tesla as the poster child of both of these manias that I was talking about.

There's another quote that I love from Scott McNealy talking about the dot-com mania. I won't read the whole thing, but in 2001 or 2002, after Sun Microsystems systems. His stock had gone from $5 a share to $65 and back to $5. He did an interview with Forbes, I think, and he said people were crazy to pay that for his stock price. It's interesting to me too, because Elon Musk recently tweeted Tesla stock price is too high a month or two ago.

So it kind of reminded me of this. And he said basically at 10 times sales is what people were paying for Sun. He'd have to pay out 100% of revenues for 10 years in order to give them a payback. That's really, hard for a computer company that makes hardware and has a lot of costs of doing business. I mean, this is even more important for Tesla, right? Because they have even greater costs of production, even lower gross margins than Sun Microsystems, and it trades 14 times sales.

So this is even so much more ridiculous than the poster child of the dot-com mania was. People are going to look back and go, what were you thinking buying Tesla? And to me, it's a testament to this retail mania, right?

How do you get a stock like Tesla going through the roof? And And I think it sort of disproves the theory that this is all passive investing too, because Tesla isn't in the index. So how does the stock go up if it's not in the S&P 500 index? Well, it has to have an incredible amount of manic buying. It also doesn't hurt that it has low float because Elon owns most, you know, a big chunk of the shares. So it's very low trading float. But then, you know, you have to have this retail mania of investors just buying the stock thinking that the price is gonna go to the moon forever. And then, you know, there's this also this other misconception too, which I think helps prove the passive investing mania also, which is that, you know, they're buying it thinking that the price is going to go up when it goes into the index.

And just the fact that the S&P 500 would be forced to pay, you know, to make this one of the top 10 holdings in the index potentially at a $350, $360 billion valuation and pay, you know, 14 times sales for it regardless of the fact that it literally has zero sales growth right now and there's no possible way to justify this multiple is to me just the perfect example of that price-insensitive buying that proves passive investing is a mania in itself.

That the system is going to force you to pay $1,800 a share for Tesla after it's put into the index. So I think it's a really interesting example of what's going on and will prove to be the poster child of the current bubble that we're

Erik Townsend: Jesse, I want to come back to stocks always going up, as our friend Davey Day Trader likes to say.

Nominal melt-up and currency crash

Erik Townsend: You know, I was actually surprised in that series that Grant and Bill did where Mike Green was featured and there were several others in the series. It was a dollar endgame series, which we did on MacroVoices back in— I can't remember if it was 2016 or 2017, I think 2017 as our year-end series. And they did a very similar series. I was surprised actually to hear Both Grant and Bill expressed the sentiment of, you know, it has to end badly for the stock market someday.

And I certainly agree, there's no free lunch and the story has to end badly.

But I'm no longer persuaded that the way it goes down is a stock market crash at some point. It seems to me like we're on a path that's pretty darn clear from a social perspective that we're headed toward a lot more quantitative easing. Eventually an MMT model where we're pumping more money into the real economy that leads to inflation. It seems to me like there's plenty of room for a melt-up in the stock market where nominal prices just continue to go up, making Davey Day Trader look as if he knows what he's talking about, when in reality what's really going on is it's the precursor to a currency crash.

And we can come back, I've got some thoughts on how the currency crash currency crash might occur. But what do you think about the possibility that, yeah, the story ends badly, but it never results in the stock market selling off dramatically in nominal terms?

Jesse Felder: I think that's a very interesting concept. And the first person I saw propose that a couple years ago was Luke Gromen. And afterwards, I reached out to Luke to discuss it with him personally, because I do think it's an interesting idea. And even Warren Buffett has said, if interest rates stay low, zero forever, then stocks are incredibly undervalued. He said that a little over a year ago on a CNBC interview. But in that same interview, Charlie Munger said one of the greatest things that he fears is that governments around the world embrace money printing. This was May of last year. And obviously since then, the US government and the Federal Reserve have dramatically embraced money printing. And the And the reason he said he fears that so much is because you inevitably get a Venezuela-type situation.

And so this is kind of what I think this idea of the stock market going up in nominal terms, but possibly down in real terms looks like. But I think before you get to that stage, before you get to hyperinflation, there'd be a lot of other signals to suggest that you're there. And those would be commodity prices rising. We're not seeing that. We would have to see the dollar really tank against other currencies. And I I'm a dollar bear. I think that's probably where we're headed. But I do think the only way that we're going to see that type of a scenario where you have a hyperinflationary environment that drives the stock market higher as a part of driving everything else higher is if the Fed is able to get away with monetizing— essentially right now we're looking at $4 trillion, $5 trillion annualized. If they get away with directly monetizing that much fiscal profligacy indefinitely.

If they can get away with that without the dollar tanking, then possibly it means, yeah, the stock market is going to just keep going straight up. Now, I don't think that's possible, but some clearly do.

Bond vigilantes, repo crisis and fiscal dominance

Erik Townsend: Jesse, something else that surprised me from that series with Grant and Bill is Bill's still talking, and this is a tagline that I used to use years ago, watch out because the bond market's going to take away the keys to the printing press at point. And I was surprised to hear Bill use that expression because as I think about it now, and I was very much of that same mindset for years, but what I've realized is there's a strong argument that bond vigilantes, that's people who start selling bonds when they see that the government is being irresponsible, they can take away a government's ability to continue recklessly deficit spending. And in an environment where there is no central bank balance sheet expansion and no quantitative easing.

But it seems to me that it's a completely false premise to say the bond market is going to take away the keys to the printing press, because in reality, it's the printing press, which is the enabler that makes it possible for central banks to essentially, I would say, take away the keys that the bond vigilantes normally have to allow them to keep governments in check. Because it doesn't matter if the bond vigilantes are selling bonds, the central bank is going to print up some more money and buy them and support the bond market and support the government's ability to continue to borrow and spend recklessly.

So I just don't buy this argument that the bond market will take away the keys to the printing press. The only way I can see that the keys to the printing press gets taken away is when you get runaway inflation, and that definitely takes the keys away and you got a really serious We're not there yet. And frankly, we're not close to that yet. Do you see it differently? What am I missing here?

Jesse Felder: I agree with you. And I think Bill's probably revised his view in light of the prospect of yield curve control. I think it's clear that the Fed is looking at yield curve control. They're not going to allow interest rates to go to a level that would be damaging to the economy. What I believe we're in a situation now, and I think this is what differentiates, this is a very important distinction, I think, between the money printing we're seeing today, really since last fall, since the repo Crisis last fall, there's been a dramatic change in the the nature of the money printing. You know, the money printing up until that point was really discretionary on the part of the Fed to try and boost the economy, try and lower interest rates, encourage people to take on mortgages and people to push them out on the risk curve, push up stock prices, create a wealth effect.

What we saw with the repo crisis last fall was demand for Treasury bills just wasn't there. We had a trillion-dollar fiscal deficit during an economic expansion. We haven't seen anything like that since. Anything close. I think we had a 2.5% deficit during an expansion in the late '60s during the Vietnam War. This was pushing 5% of GDP during an economic expansion, totally unprecedented. And the only way we were financing it was through Treasury bills. And the only people buying those Treasury bills were leveraged hedge funds putting on the basis trade, borrowing tons of money in repo to buy Treasury bills.

When repo kind of started buckling, that trade came under pressure and the Fed had to say, there's nobody buying, to buy these Treasury bills, we have to come in and monetize this. And to me, that wasn't a discretionary move on part of the Fed. That was the Fed being forced to come in and monetize debt that couldn't be bought by normal demand in the markets. And so that to me is a huge distinction. That to me was the beginning of so-called fiscal dominance where the central bank can no longer decide what they want to do for the economy or inflation. They're essentially 100% beholden to whatever the fiscal authorities deem necessary. We saw it again when Congress essentially voted to spend $3 trillion several months ago and the Fed had to come in. And why did their balance sheet go from $4 to $7 trillion? Because they're forced to monetize that. And so we're now in a situation of fiscal dominance where the Fed is essentially under the thumb of fiscal policymakers.

And that's, like I said, a huge distinction. And I I think this is where it's not going to be the bond market, because if they're forced to keep interest rates lower, it's going to be the dollar.

Like Robert Kaplan, Dallas Fed head, said a week or two ago, that there is a limit to the money printing we can do. And essentially, the dollar is going to show us what that limit is. That fiscal authorities are going to do X, Y, and Z. We're going to be forced to monetize it. This is me reading between the lines. And the dollar is going to tell us how much we're allowed to monetize without the dollar really, really tanking. And I think this is why we started to see the dollar sell off this year.

Foreign investors concerned that the amount of money printing is getting out of hand. You look at our— the growth in our monetary base was so much bigger in reaction to the pandemic than any other country on the planet. And people wonder why the dollar's going down.

To me, it's gonna be the dollar takes the printing press away. And this is what I don't think a lot of people in the stock market appreciate currently. They think Fed money printing means the stock market goes up. Well, if the Fed doesn't print as much as the federal government issues, then the stock market has negative liquidity situation. And if they do print as much or more in order to create a positive liquidity situation for the markets, the dollar could really, really sell off. And, and that would, you know, I think that's already making the Fed think twice about what they're able to do.

Felder's near-term dollar scenario

Erik Townsend: Well, first of all, I agree with you very strongly that the dollar has the ability to take the keys to the printing press away, whereas I would have said the bond market doesn't. Now, you, Jesse, have been expressing You've been expressing a long-term secular bearish view on the dollar for, I don't know, 4 or 5 years now. It seems like for a while, maybe you were making a good argument, but, you know, it wasn't really happening yet in a big way.

And certainly our mutual friend Luke Gromen has been expressing this very, very bearish dollar view that, you know, I've always been convinced Luke would be proven right in the endgame. I just wasn't sure when the endgame starts. So are we actually having that Luke Gromen moment where, you know, we saw 92 even on the dollar index on Tuesday of this week. That's a fresh low, and we're oversold here. Is that the bottom and the big bounce starts? You know, markets crash from oversold, not from overbought. Is this the beginning of something big, do you think, or are we pretty much done with this move? Because certainly that's an overcrowded trade at this point to be short the dollar.

Jesse Felder: Absolutely. And I have been dollar bearish since late '16, early '17, really. And, you know, the dollar had a nice down move, and then, you know, since early '18 It's been in what I viewed as a countertrend rally. And I've felt wrong, certainly wrong in being bearish to the dollar for the past couple years. But this renewed sell-off, I do think is just essentially a renewed down leg in the bear market that started in '17. Now, it absolutely is super overcrowded trade. There are technical indicators to me that suggest it probably should rally in the short run. I think that could coincide with kind of a risk-off period for markets.

But it's probably more of just a short-term, another short-term countertrend rally in the dollar.

And so how I would envision this playing out, and this is not a forecast, this is just how I, if I had to guess, this is how I would see it playing out. We're going to see a dollar rally for the next several weeks, coincides with the risk-off, maybe stocks pull back 10%.

People are calling for the Fed, whose the balance sheet hasn't expanded for 3 months. Fed's essentially on the sidelines. So stocks are going to have renewed sell-off, dollar rallies, and that's going to make everybody call for renewed Fed money printing, quantitative easing, whatever you want to call it, in light of the stock market sell-off and in light of dollar strength. And that's when the Fed's going to have to choose, okay, is it time now to monetize this $2 trillion the Treasury needs to issue over the— by year end. And if they do make that decision to monetize the $2 trillion, then that's when we probably see the real big move down in the dollar. And so I think it's like I said at the beginning of this year, the first market comment I wrote in January was this is the year to watch the greenback. It's the most important chart in the market. And I still believe that over the next several weeks, months, it's going to be, it is the one to watch.

So that's my dollar view in a nutshell. But I'm curious to know your thoughts about the dollar.

What could replace the dollar: Erik's SVDC thesis

Erik Townsend: Well, Jesse, what I thought was actually missing from that conversation that Grant and Bill had is to really ask the question of, okay, what does it take in order— they both said, you know, it seems like in the end it's the currency that fails. I just don't know how that comes about. Well, here's how I think that ultimately comes about. Why has the dollar been so strong and lasted so long and surprised so many people? The answer is because it's the global reserve currency.

Jesse Felder: Right.

Erik Townsend: Well, why is the dollar the global reserve currency? I contend it is global reserve currency for one reason and one reason only, which is there is no viable alternative. So the process of logical deduction leads you to say, okay, if that's the situation, lots of people around the world are frustrated with the dollar's hegemony over the global financial system, but we're not going to go to euros and we're not going to go to yen and we're certainly not going to go to Russian rubles or Chinese yuan as the new global reserve currency.

So, the question becomes, what could happen to bring about, perhaps even suddenly, a viable alternative to the US dollar as global reserve currency? That's the $64 trillion question, as far as I'm concerned, or $64 quadrillion question, is where do you get a suitable replacement for the US dollar From to replace the dollar as the global reserve currency. And as soon as one emerges, I think the, you know, it's game over for the dollar. Luke Gromen gets proven right and the world changes in dramatic ways. Well, what could bring that about? And I think the big surprise, the fat tail surprise event that nobody's really watching closely enough for is the emergence of a digital currency. And I don't mean Bitcoin and Ethereum and the other cryptocurrencies. Cryptocurrencies, but a digital currency which is designed not to appeal to anarchists who are trying to do government-proof money, which is what Bitcoin was designed to do, but rather a digital currency which is designed expressly to displace the dollar.

Somebody saying, let's engineer a digital currency system, use a lot of the ideas of distributed ledger and so forth that were invented invented by the Bitcoin crowd. But let's combine those technologies in a completely different way with almost opposite design goals of what cryptocurrency tries to achieve. And let's create something that appeals to the central bankers of the world. And, you know, it's easy to say, well, you know, there's nothing like that going on. Well, look at how quickly Facebook Libra came out of nowhere, had a big splash, flash in the pan and ended up dying out. Frankly, I think that's because Facebook had no idea what they were trying to do. You're basically trying to propose a new digital currency system which could eventually compete with government-issued money as a preferred medium of exchange and store of value.

You can't do that without bribing a few politicians first. I think that Facebook forgot Who knows what Google is working on behind closed doors? Who knows what Apple has in mind after Apple Pay?

So where I think the big surprise could come from is what I call an SVDC, Silicon Valley digital currency. Somebody in the Valley who's looking at all of this digital currency technology and saying, forget about cryptocurrency, that's just a little flash in the pan. Let's use these technologies in a different way to design something that's something that really does provide a viable alternative to the US dollar. And let's sell that to central bankers so that we, the creators of that digital currency, basically take on godlike status and are in charge of, you know, things that we shouldn't be in charge of. No doubt in my mind that that's what was probably in the back of Mark Zuckerberg's head. He did a very incompetent job of trying to promote Libra, and it was shut down very Very quickly. I bet there's other people in the Valley, Jesse, that watched that all go down, learned some lessons from it, and have plans of their own.

And I think it's when they show up with a digital currency system— and by the way, the pandemic, you know, the old expression of never let a crisis go to waste— the pandemic provides a perfect venue for somebody to introduce something they can sell to governments that provides a way to take MMT, you know, helicopter money, and digitally distribute it to the populace. Well, we've got to adopt this new money system and give it government endorsement because it gives us the ability to, you know, basically achieve UBI and, you know, all kinds of entitlement programs, debit cards for social benefits and so forth are all gonna be tied into this thing and it's gonna be all cool and technology's great.

It's a great smokescreen to introduce a new digital currency whose real goal is to usurp the dollar's role at the center of the global financial system. I gotta believe there are very powerful, well-heeled people in Silicon Valley working very hard on that.

And I'm watching to see who's next. Clearly, Facebook's Libra was not meant to be. Okay, what's Google up to in secret? What's Apple up to in secret? What's coming next? That's what's on my mind.

Jesse Felder: You know, that's a really interesting point. And it's probably— I think you're absolutely right. That's how technologies evolve, right? I mean, Bitcoin is one. I'm not a Bitcoin believer, Just to kind of put that out there. And part of the reason is because you just look at how technologies evolve and there are a lot of benefits to Ethereum. And why is Ethereum not a better cryptocurrency than Bitcoin? But you're right, all of these cryptocurrencies could prove to be the MySpace of an eventual Facebook that comes around that is the one that's adopted by governments, which I think is the point that you've made in your book, which is without the backing of major governments, none of these cryptocurrencies have a chance in hell at usurping the dollar as reserve currency or even taking off and becoming widely adopted. I think the other point that I would make is that every time the dollar begins a bear market, people start talking about the reserve currency status and it being at risk.

I mean, there's been plenty of times where the dollar has sold off 40% over a number of years and it hasn't lost its reserve currency status. I don't know whether it's going to remain reserve currency or lose that status. I think I agree with Luke. Over time, it probably loses that status, but it's my belief that the dollar could fall 40% from its highs over the last few years without it having to lose its reserve currency status for that to happen. Now, if it were to lose 40% again, as it's done in the past, that might be what precipitates this transition away from the dollar and finally creates enough angst towards the dollar that people do look for a useful alternative.

Gold outlook and Felder's positioning

Erik Townsend: Jesse, let's move on to precious metals. Uh, gold market really breaking out to some astronomical highs, and then of course we had a significant correction, although frankly it wasn't that significant. We didn't even get back down to the $1,800 breakout level that, uh, had been the, the most recent, uh, proximal move up in the market. And frankly, we had never had a retracement back down to the prior breakout level before that. So, what do you think's going on? Are we seeing a topping process here in gold, or is this just a little pullback and a buying opportunity?

Jesse Felder: I've been bullish on gold for several years, and it's part of my— that dollar bearishness thesis is part of this. But a big part of the reason I was so bullish gold and really took an interest in it back in 2015 was that famous Wall Street Journal piece calling it a pet rock. And when any asset class becomes that out of favor, usually a good buying opportunity. But then, you know, when you look deeper at, you know, what drives gold prices, it's real interest rates and it's the fiscal situation in the United States. And so I think what's been driving gold is that deteriorating fiscal situation paired with, you know, negative real interest rates in the United States. Those are, you know, essentially the ideal backdrop for gold bulls. And I do think this gold bull market probably has a lot longer way to go over the next several years. I think, you know, we talked about if the Fed through this fiscal dominance is forced into yield curve control and just monetizing a significant amount of debt indefinitely, that is the ultimate bull case for gold.

And then I think in that scenario with yield curve control and the Fed monetizing trillions of dollars of debt every year, those crazy sounding forecasts of $10,000 an ounce or whatever immediately become not very crazy at all and become very realistic. But I think in the short run, I think we've seen so much bullish sentiment towards gold. It's become a crowded trade. We've seen money pour into ETFs, a lot of retail investors get involved. And I do think real interest rates potentially going forward could become a headwind instead of a tailwind.

And by that, I suggest that essentially I think inflation could disappoint to the downside, that I think we, with the velocity of money so weak and GDP so weak, that that tailwind tends to lead core CPI by a year to 18 months. And so I think inflation over the near term could disappoint to the downside. And at the same time, interest rates are starting to try and tick up. And so that is a recipe for rising real interest rates, which would be bearish for gold prices in the short run.

So I think the combination of it being overcrowded and the possibility of real interest rates going the wrong direction in the short run makes me more cautious. I think we could have a corrective period that could last. I mean, even in the last gold bull market, from the early 2000s to 2011, you saw 20% pullbacks. And a lot of times that's what it takes in a bull market to shake out the weak holders.

And I wouldn't be surprised to see that type of a thing over the next several months in the gold market.

Erik Townsend: Do you have enough conviction about that to take profits up here and look to buy back in at a lower price? Or is it more Or are you more of just hold your current position and maybe add to it if there's a really big dip?

Jesse Felder: Yeah. So for me, I like to have a core position. I think gold's in a bull market and it's so easy in a bull market to just sell out your core position and never get a chance to reenter. So I'm definitely holding onto my core position, but trading around that with a more tactical type of position, I would— I don't have any— I'm not tactically bullish on gold right now. Have any tactical positions on in that market right now. That leaves me vulnerable to missing. And to be perfectly honest, I've been cautious towards gold over the last several months. So I started buying it at $1,050 an ounce and started turning cautious around $1,600-ish. And I've missed this last move up from a tactical perspective, but I'm fine with that because to me, it's about putting the probabilities in favor. And I'm happy to just keep that core position on and, and look for, uh, a better opportunity to, to become tactically bullish over the next few months.

The Felder Report

Erik Townsend: Jesse, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview this week. Tell our listeners about what they can expect to find at thefelderreport.com. And particularly, a lot of people have been a huge fan of your podcast. It's not quite as regular as MacroVoices. What's the strategy there? How often can we look forward to a new episode?

Jesse Felder: Well, yeah, not yet. I think I've recorded one this year. They're great when you do 'em. Yeah, for me, I have to be really, really curious about a certain topic and reach out to somebody to do that. It's probably a huge compliment to you that I think I've done 2 with you. And so, you probably represent 10% of my total library, Erik. But yeah, no, the Felder Report, basically, I put out a Saturday morning email, which has become pretty popular. And it's basically, I do so much reading during the week. I usually tweet a lot of the stuff that I'm reading, charts and articles, but I kind of curate the 5 best things that I found during the week and put those into a Saturday morning email. And at the Felder Report, you can sign up for that. Goes out Saturday mornings and it's totally free.

Erik Townsend: Jesse, thanks so much for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor. Are you interested in an alternative asset class that delivers 10 to 25% historical returns? Masterworks.io makes it possible for anyone, retail or accredited, to invest in shares of the world's most valuable paintings from artists like Monet and Basquiat. From 2000 to 2018, art outperformed the S&P by 180%, with almost no correlation to the stock market. Deloitte estimates that there's $1.7 trillion in total wealth held in art, growing to $2.6 trillion by 2026. I recently interviewed Masterworks CEO Scott Lynn. I highly recommend you give that episode a listen. We covered the macro argument for investing in fine art and why it should be part of your portfolio. To learn more, head to masterworks.io, select podcast, and use code macro to skip the 25,000-person waitlist today.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: Felder takeaways and gold stance

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Jesse back on the show. It was interesting to get his take on the gold market. It's interesting that he already already is a little concerned that the gold market has gotten ahead of itself. I don't know if I'm so sure that it's— I think there might even be a tactical opportunity to get in at these levels as it pulls back. But, you know, time will tell. Anyway, what was your takeaway from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm ahead of him then because I have been quite certain for months and months and months now that a major technical correction to the downside was coming in gold. And I've also been dead wrong about that. So, I'm not gonna continue fighting the tape. I do think we, you know, any investor in gold has got to be ready to understand there's been so much upside that there is plenty of room for a big technical correction to the downside. But, you know, it's a buying opportunity. The gold bull market is here to stay, and any significant downside from here is just a buying opportunity as far as I'm concerned.

Postgame: S&P 500 momentum divergence

Erik Townsend: Let's move on though to our postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't yet have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, look for the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, right above Jesse's picture.

Patrick, as we dive in and look here at page 2, you've got your usual S&P 500 chart, but this week you've added panels for momentum and rate of change subgraphs. What's going on there? Well, I think it's important to remember that the with this particular chart?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, you know, over the last several months, we've been talking about the parabolic rises in many of these FAANG stocks. And usually what you see is an acceleration in the rate of change as they're rising. And I thought it was particularly interesting that we're seeing quite a divergence from what we're seeing in the broader markets. Now, of course, in the very first reaction off of the March lows, when you have such an extreme oversold condition like we saw during that historic market crash, the reflexivity of an immediate bounce is always going to have a very rapid rate of change. And so expecting the rate of change to shoot higher in the most immediate impulse after a crash is expected. But what we continuously are seeing month after month is the rate of which the stock market is rising is slowing. It's just getting exhausted from this rise.

And as it's slowing and slowing, we're seeing all sorts of divergences in the momentum since its July highs, as well as the rate of change is making a sequential series of lower highs and is heading down to the zero line.

And traditionally, and one of the really interesting things to watch, is traditionally this has and can precede some form of a market correction. And it'll be really interesting now that we're going into the— out of the summer doldrums and going into not only the post-Labor Day when there's typically very large amounts of volume, but we also have a big options expiration roll-off. There's a big gamma pin pinning the S&P in this 3,350 to 3,400 zone. And so as we roll that off, go into Labor Day, and now several months away from a US election, are we finally going to see some material volatility? I mean, you were referencing the fact that Charlie McElligott was talking about that, and it really, I think, has a very good chance of happening. But when I look at a chart chart like this, spidey senses are telling that we're probably first going down before we go up.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I couldn't agree more that when you see a divergence where the most common names are performing very well and the lesser-known names are not performing so well, that breadth divergence is usually a very bearish signal.

Postgame: FAANG+ concentration and narrow breadth

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 3 where we're looking at a chart showing that the outperformers performance of the FAANG stocks: Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google.

Now, what is this chart telling us? Because on the one hand, I can see that, okay, clearly for the last month there's been huge outperformance of the FAANG stocks compared to other stocks. But, you know, if I look back over the last, you know, going all the way back to March, it seems like there have been lots of periods where there was a big outperformance of the FAANG stocks, and that would have been that same breadth signal that maybe would've been bearish, but it didn't really have a bearish outcome. So how should we interpret this now?

Patrick Ceresna: First, most basic observation is just how much those 10 companies that make up the FAANG+ index, and this is the index future, so it's the normal FAANG stocks plus it adds Alibaba, Baidu, Nvidia, Tesla, and Twitter into the FAANG basket. And That has been where the vast majority of the performance has happened. And particularly, it's noteworthy that since July, this FAANG index has been making higher highs and it's been driving the market higher. But what is particularly interesting to me is that since those July highs, only 3 of these 10 stocks made higher highs.

And 2 of them have the stock split momentum of Apple and Tesla as well. Yeah. Nvidia, and the other 7 have actually not made higher highs. So it's not only that it's a more narrow breadth and it's only the FAANG stocks rallying. Actually, in the last month, it's only been a part of the FAANG index that's been driving this momentum. And so whenever you see those kind of divergences where fewer and fewer stocks are driving almost all the momentum, to me, that's a red flag. And this is something that I'm— it's gonna be high on my watch list over the next, week or two.

Postgame: global equities lag the S&P 500

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 4 where you're bringing global equity indices outside the United States and comparing those to the S&P 500.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And everyone is continuously anchoring off US equity markets to already call that the end of the bear market and that we're in a new bull market. But when you really look at the global equity markets broadly, they have been massively underperforming and very few have actually even approached their previous highs.

So I mean, when we're looking in the S&P 500 retesting those February highs, it's definitely there. But when you look at something, for instance, take the London FTSE or the Euro Stoxx, they're still materially down and nowhere near their year-to-date starting levels. And at the same time, the Nikkei and even the Canadian TSX, or even if we had up here, let's say the Aussie 200, they're all actually lagging quite considerably. And what's interesting is the emerging markets have done very well, particularly driven, at least on a relative basis, driven by India and Brazil and a few of these other markets that actually have been doing half decently recently. But just today, we saw some material breakdowns in the emerging market ETF. And so we're starting to see the global equity feel very toppy and almost rolling over. And it's really the US equity equity market held up by fewer and fewer stocks that is holding this whole thing up. It would not surprise me at all if we began some sort of mean-reverting correction.

I don't want to necessarily all be saying something overly bearish, like we're going all the way back to previous lows, but it would not surprise me if the break was to the downside coming into the post-Labor Day period.

Postgame: Treasury yields and credit spreads

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 5. You're showing the US 10-year Treasury yield, just taking a nosedive, of course, with the pandemic crisis, bottoming out in the bottom of March, great big dead cat bounce back down and retesting that low with a double bottom, then kind of consolidating, looking like it was going to recover up into the middle of June. And then we're back down to new lows as we got into August. So what is going on here with the 10-year and where are we

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, the one thing, like, I wanted to use the 10-year just simply as a reference point because I want to talk about actually corporate bonds. And so I— the real takeaway here is that we've been very much stuck in a trade range, but the sequence of lower lows and lower highs has been quite uninterrupted for quite a while. And anyone that's already counting on a major reversal, there isn't— we haven't seen a change in this pattern. I mean, maybe if there's the inflation expectations expectations start to rise in some meaningful way, maybe the yields will start to reflect it. But I don't think that this is yet enough technical evidence to say that some major new trend is developing. But really what I wanted to anchor off of this is the fact that yields are generally pinned lower. And I want to talk about the break that we have seen in the investment-grade and junk bond markets over the last couple weeks.

So when we go to page 6, you can see the chart there on the investment-grade corporate bonds, which had a pretty significant break, wiping out much of the last one month's rise in one fluid motion and has not been really able to start to recover in the last few days off of that.

And what's particularly interesting is that that first reaction down was very much in line with that recent little pop in the 10-year Treasury yield. But what's interesting and what will be something that's gonna be on my watch list is on page 7, when we were looking at those OAS credit spreads. And you can see those investment-grade credit spreads, while they shot up from about 100 basis points to about 400 basis points on the— during the crisis, ever since the Fed stepped in to stabilize the bond markets, those credit spreads have narrowed almost back down to the levels where they were prior to the crisis. And what would be interesting to see is if we see the market start to get nervous and whether or not these credit spreads start to widen again. We haven't seen that break, and that's something that's on my watch list to see whether or not we finally see a turn and whether these start to rise.

No sign of it yet.

Postgame: junk bonds and the Fed backstop

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to junk bonds, high-yield corporates on page 8. You know, it seemed like we were finally getting that break, I guess because of the crisis. I wasn't really expecting junk credit to recover from there the way it has. I mean, we're not quite back up to the previous highs, but we're pretty close. What's going on here?

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, when we're looking at high-yield junk bonds, the one thing that I find really interesting is that they continue to look like they're correlated with the broader equity markets. And when we were showing that rate of change and momentum on the S&P chart earlier, if we were to put them on this high-yield corporate bond chart, you would see the same divergences. And there continues to be the rate of change of the rise slowing. And this to me makes it very toppy. It's a market that could very easily roll over. So when we, again, when we go to page 9 there, we can see that the credit spreads on junk bonds over that of the Treasury before the crisis was around 350, 400 basis points. And we have more or less erased this. In spite of all of the risks associated with so many of these high-yield junk bonds, especially in this post-COVID period where many of these companies that are on the periphery could still realistically default, and there is all sorts of risks associated.

Much of that risk has not been— is not being currently priced into these. We're about 500 basis points above Treasury, which is to me a very calm and orderly junk bond market, which I don't think will

Erik Townsend: Well, why don't you think it would stay that way if the Fed is going to continue to bail it out? I mean, it seems to me like what changed here is the Fed announcing that they're going to buy junk bonds with taxpayer money, which I think is completely immoral and illegal, but it doesn't slow them down.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think there's a difference between the Fed providing liquidity to keep an orderly market versus them directly trying to manipulate junk bond yields so that low-grade credit companies can access the debt markets and borrow at rates much lower than they should be. I don't actually think that there's a lot of moral hazard, just like you're suggesting. And I don't think it's the intention of the Fed necessarily to somehow manipulate these interest rates lower. Rather, I think it was the fact that the ETFs have just become so big that there was a real liquidity risk if they didn't provide liquidity into that market. So I actually still think that there's plenty of room for junk bonds to actually have a freakout I think everyone's getting a little too complacent about that.

Postgame: VIX, implied versus realized volatility

Erik Townsend: Well, we'll see what happens. Let's move on to volatility on page 10 with the VIX index. What's going on here and what's the blue consolidation range telling us at the bottom? Looks like we're coming back into it.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is the thing. When you go back and look at even the last 2, 3 years of the bull market prior to this drop, we saw volatility stay consistently in the 10 to 20% range where it consolidated in that period where we saw everyone generally being short gamma in a very big way. Since the crisis, volatility has been narrowing or coming off of its major crash highs. And the question now is, is this now going to stay at an elevated level of volatility or are we genuinely in some sort of new bull market where volatility volatility will come back into this traditional long-term range. I personally think that this is a very important moment. And when you look on page 11, what I did here was compare the S&P 500 implied volatility and compare that to the 30-day and 100-day actually realized volatility. And what we can see is what's been dragging on this lower has particularly that 30-day volatility because of this narrow range the stock market has been in into the summer has been dragging realized volatility down, which is keeping implieds very low.

But going into a US election and a post-Labor Day liquidity surge that I think will potentially drive some material volatility, I think that this realistically could be the bottom end range of implied volatilities in the VIX, and we could potentially see volatility return in the coming months.

Postgame: gold chart and buy-the-dip levels

Patrick Ceresna: And so this is one of the really interesting

Erik Townsend: Patrick, we got to touch on gold before we finish. On page 12 here, you've got the gold chart, and you tell me, but you know, as I look at this chart, I can see the consolidation range, and you know, it looks to me like the top of that consolidation range— you could call it anywhere from $1,765 up to $1,800, but let's say just because the market has been strong, I wouldn't want to pick a low number to wait for it to come down to, but seems to me like it's reasonable to expect a technical correction to come back down to something just above 1,800 before this market marches higher. What do you think?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I'll tell you, my intuition is that the bull market's not over. And what I feel like in a traditional consolidation, and especially if it zigzags downward, you can see one more drop here that could potentially see like 1,850 and definitely Definitely, if it was a bull market, we should stay above those consolidation highs of April and May. So printing below 1800, even if it temporarily drops below 1850, shouldn't—it shouldn't stay down there very long if it is going to be bullish. The characteristic that you typically want to see in a proper bull market is—is that all dips are being aggressively bought, which is that they don't stay down very long even if they do break. And that's actually what I'm going to be watching for—is that characteristic of buying dips. Going to remain there, or is this going to become far more distributive in its price action, which means that maybe some sort of bigger or more prolonged intermediate high is in place that will lead to a multi-month correction in gold?

And I'm not totally sure I'm sold on which one. I— my intuition and benefit of the doubt goes to the fact that the bulls will buy the dip here. And I think that if the market was to gift a, a technical drop down to like $1,800 $1,850. It's an interesting place to be buying, calling for the next leg higher. So that's definitely what I'm watching. But I wanted to, on chart 13, ask you, you asked us to put this chart in there. What are you showing here on page 13?

Postgame: gold futures contango beyond full carry

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this gets a little bit more technical. We're getting now into the term structure of the gold futures market, the difference between one delivery contract and the next in terms of price. And it astonishes me what it is about the gold market that causes there to be more misinformation than accurate information on the internet. I just don't know. I was really disappointed to see ZeroHedge run an article recently by some clown talking about how the deep backwardation in the gold market portends a signal of shortages and so forth. There's absolutely no backwardation in the gold market. The gold market is not only in a very steep contango, it's in a situation where the contango is greater than what's known as full carry, or in the oil market, what a lot of people like to call super contango. In other words, if you were to buy the December 2020 gold futures contract and take delivery of gold on that contract, put it in storage, well, what's it gonna cost you to store that gold?

Somewhere around 50 to 75 basis points if you're an institutional account. So you figure that we're talking So, we're talking about between $10 and $15 an ounce that it's gonna cost to store the gold for a year. You've gotta finance the purchase of that gold if you're gonna evaluate the carrying cost. But the cost of Treasury bills now is, what, 10 basis points or something? So, it's almost negligible. So, you would expect that the maximum contango, what's called fair value or full carry, is somewhere around 15 to 20 basis points.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: If the 2021 gold contract is more than about $15 to $20 higher than the 2020 contract, it's creating a risk-free arbitrage where you can make a guaranteed profit without taking any risk on what the price of gold does, simply by buying the 2020, selling the 2021, which means you make what was at one point a $46 difference.

Patrick Ceresna: Wow.

Erik Townsend: differential. You put that in your pocket and all you gotta do is pay to store the gold for a year, which is gonna cost you $15 or $20.

You end up pocketing $25. That's a guaranteed return of about 2%. Now, 2% doesn't sound like a lot, but this is essentially a risk-free guaranteed return. In order to not make that return, the exchange has to completely collapse. And so if you look at the other risk-free returns, which are Treasury returns that are yielding just a few basis points, it's a really big deal.

How do we get down to the point where there was a $46 difference between the '20 and '21 December contracts? I talked to Kevin Muir a little bit off the air about this. He did some checking around. Kevin thinks what's going on here is the traders who know how to put that trade on are mostly bullion bank traders, and a lot of those guys have kind of had their Capital chopped off because of the Volcker Rule and just restructuring of their banks. You can make guaranteed money on this, but it's capital intensive. You gotta buy a whole bunch of gold and sell the futures contract, and you end up making a guaranteed return of 2%.

Well, they don't have their own company's capital, and they have to go out to their customers and try to find somebody that wants that 2% guaranteed return, and they're apparently not finding it. Looks like what happened Is that got to the point where the extreme contango was so far beyond a full carry at $46. Somehow that trade finally caught on. A bunch of people realized, hey, there's free money on the table here to arbitrage this inefficiency. And that's why you see this steep recovery.

I think the reason that this is interesting to retail investors and sophisticated private investors is the usual trade-off is, you know, you can buy the ETF or you can buy physical. Physical has a lot of advantages. It means you're completely independent from the financial system. You're not dependent on the stock market still being there for your ETF shares to be worth something. But if you're talking about just a few thousand dollars that you could store in your home, then I guess it doesn't cost you anything. For any appreciable amount of capital, you would never want to store it in your home, because bad guys will find out you got gold and come and kill you and your family. in order to get it. So you got to pay about 75 basis points to store it. So if you want physical, it always costs more than paper gold. For the first time, really, that I can remember, physical costs cheaper.

The carrying cost of buying and storing physical gold in a private vault where you own it and you're completely independent of the financial system is actually lower than buying the futures contract or a paper instrument that trades the futures contract. So where a lot of people used to be just totally, you know, it's gotta be physical metal stored in a vault. And I used to say, look, I just don't think the COMEX is gonna go outta business. I'm comfortable making my gold investments by carrying futures contracts. It's actually cheaper to do it in the physical market now. Or even with an ETF, actually, like GLD, which owns all of the gold as opposed to using futures. Futures contracts. Futures have become very efficient because of this arbitrage that hadn't been taken. Now it is starting to come back out. It's going to be very interesting to see whether it comes completely back out. Patrick, before we close, let's hit page 14.

What can our listeners do if they want to get in on a free trial to your service, Big Picture Trading?

Patrick Ceresna: If anyone is interested in just, uh, seeing what I do on a regular daily basis where I analyze the macro markets and call all sorts of trades. You can sign up for a free trial with no credit card required at bigpicturetrading.com.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: We're going to leave it there. This episode of MacroVoices was brought to you by masterworks.io. See disclaimer at masterworks.io/disclaimer. And by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our post-game discussion. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a number of Jesse Felder reports, as well as a link to a great interview with Russell Napier about central banks having become irrelevant. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always We're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com.

Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests. And the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge.

You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Vincent Deluard — StoneX Global Macro Strategist (as introduced on the show)

Announcer opening

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik's open and guest preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 232 was recorded on August 13th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases. StoneX Global Macro Strategist Vincent Deluard joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Vincent says the 60/40 portfolio is headed for a nuclear winter. We'll also discuss inflation, social unrest, the European market outlook, and precious metals. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview. This week, Patrick has prepared a chartbook all about how to use options to manage risk in precious metals markets.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude, gold, 10-year yield

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to that S&P 500, which is toying with its, uh, retesting its February highs. What's your take on the S&P

Erik Townsend: Yeah, you know, I guess we've closed above the previous close, although I'm not sure if we're at an intraday match to the previous intraday high. We're right teetering on it. And, you know, the way I see it, Patrick, why wouldn't it keep going? You know, people are saying, oh, what if it's a double top? Look at what's going on with the Nasdaq. Look at what's going on with the FAANG stocks. They're already well into new all-time highs. So I don't see why the index wouldn't follow. I do think it's all being driven by central bank liquidity and by all of the accommodation that the government's providing. But, you know, I think they're going to continue providing it. And although there may be a little bit of a reprieve here in the COVID-19 crisis, I think this thing's going to last longer than most people think. I think it'll get better, but it's not going to completely go away, probably for a matter of years.

And that means stimulus is going to keep on rolling in. So I don't see any reason that that won't continue to push the market higher.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index because we put in a low in the early part of— or at least a retest of that low in the early part of August. And since then, the dollar's just been more or less muddled, trading sideways. What's your take here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, at least the precipitous drop seems to have stopped, at least for now. The question on my mind is, okay, I wasn't really expecting this. Is this just a reaction to the amount of central bank accommodation? Or are we really getting to that Luke Gromen moment that we've been fearing for years, where eventually the US dollar really does lose its reserve currency status? A lot of people are talking about that, including mainstream people, where it used to be just a, a wild conspiracy theory.

The thing is, I still don't see a replacement for the US dollar. There's no fiat currency that would be suitable as a replacement for the US dollar as the global reserve currency, and there's no digital currency yet that's up to that task. So I don't see it happening anytime soon.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because it looks like crude oil keeps wanting to break out, and then every time it starts to gain some strength, it just pauses and then just backfills a little bit, and we stay in this tight range. When is oil ever going to make the big move here?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's not only that, Patrick, it's everything you said, but also when it finally does start to show signs of a breakdown to the downside, you know, it just barely starts to get going. It breaks away from those short-term moving averages And before you know it, it's back up again.

So we've been— I think it was about the 22nd of June was when we kind of broke the straight-up rally, and we've been consolidating sideways on price ever since then, almost 2 months now. You know, there's an old saying, Patrick, the longer the base, the higher in space. And the longer that a market gets coiled up like this, trading in a narrow range, when it finally does make a move in either direction, it usually tends to be a big move.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: I was originally thinking the next significant move was down, but I'm starting to think that we're just going to consolidate sideways until it's time for the market to eventually move back up. So the question you have to ask is, okay, what's the catalyst that would bring about a significant move to the upside? Going back to our discussion with Art Berman from a couple of months ago, the answer is when US production starts to fall off a cliff the way Art predicted that it might start to in Q4. Now, US production has been holding steady, nice and steady for the last several weeks. We're down 300,000 barrels per day this week to 10.7 million barrels. Now, that's a significant one-week change considering how stable it's been. Is it the beginning of a new trend? We don't know yet. We'll have to find out. Meanwhile, inventory crude oil drawing down 4.5 million barrels. The SPR also drawing down 2.2 million barrels where it had been building as commercial storage had been added to the SPR in recent weeks.

Cushing, Oklahoma building 1.3 million barrels. Remember, it had been drawing down with a lot of that oil flowing out of Cushing, apparently making its way into the SPR. Looks like that's turned around in the other direction now. Gasoline drawing down 722,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 2.3 million barrels. And again, US production 10.7, 300,000 barrel decrease. Let's watch that carefully in coming weeks because if something is going to set this market off to the upside, it's gonna be a steep decline in US production. Art Berman thought that wasn't set to happen until Q4. Maybe it's here early or maybe this was just a blip on the chart this week. Let's keep an eye on it next week.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's get to gold 'cause we were talking about it extensively last week and asking how long will that trend last? And it didn't take long to answer that question. So the bigger question is, is this the start of something much bigger Or is this a very quick buy on dip? What's your take on this whole gold move?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, my biggest take on this is, thank heavens, finally good news for gold bulls, which is this is starting to look a little bit closer to a healthy bull market. As we discussed last week, you don't want to see those parabolic rises because they set up these big ugly reversals like we just had. I do think it was a buy-the-dip moment. I did buy this dip, but I'm not convinced that it's over yet. What I would like to see, what would make me feel much more comfortable as a gold bull, would be if we got a retest all the way down to the breakout level, which was around $1,800 on this move. So if we can come down and retest that $1,800 resistance, test it as support, and then resume a nice healthy bull rally from there, That really makes me feel confident in this market moving higher. I don't know, maybe this is over already.

That was it. Certainly what we've seen in recent months, this market's been so strong, it's, it's crazy. Maybe it's all done. I'm hoping there's still a little bit more downside so we clean up some of the choppy space on the volume profile chart and get looking a little bit more like a healthy bull market. But this pullback that we had was a healthy sign. It's much better than what we were seeing, and it gives me even more optimism for the long-term prospects for this market, which I couldn't be more bullish about long term. Now, Patrick, let's come back to this subject in the postgame segment because I want to talk about the conversation we started to have last week. We told our listeners, hey, we're going to come back next week, we're going to tell you how to use options to protect yourself in case there's a big pullback after this big parabolic move up.

Well, it's a little bit late to have that conversation, but let's discuss what options strategies do fit and how that would have fit into the strategy.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, for sure. We'll circle back to that after Vincent's interview. So let's just wrap up by talking about this 10-year Treasury yield, which with some inflation numbers coming out seems to have had that pop in yields after sitting below 60 basis points for several weeks. We finally got a bump here in yields. We're now approaching 5.71% on the upside. Anything that you're looking at in that Treasury bond market?

Erik Townsend: Now, the short-term signal, I really don't have any opinion. I, I look at it as we've sold off from over the last 35 years from, you know, 15% 10-year yields all the way down to almost zero. We got below 50 basis points at one point, so I'm going to call it close enough to zero. Does that mean it's over and that we're seeing the beginning of a secular shift to a reversal and it's time for a bond bear market to begin? Or is this just a natural pause at a very important psychological level of zero before this market eventually marches on to negative interest rates?

That's the big macro question.

Erik Townsend: I think a whole lot rides on getting that question right. I don't have the answer. I'm going to keep asking our future interview guests.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Vincent Deluard is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Why the 60/40 portfolio faces a nuclear winter

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Vincent Deluard, global macro strategist for StoneX. That's formerly known as INTL FC Stone. StoneX, I guess, is the new name of your firm. Vincent, it's great to have you on the program. Thanks for joining us.

Vincent Deluard: Well, thanks for having me. I've been listening for many years to this podcast and it truly is the best financial market podcast. I mean, you give a ton of content that used to be the privilege of a happy few and you give it away to everyone and you're doing a great public service mission here. And I'm glad to be here.

Erik Townsend: Listeners, Vincent has prepared a slide deck to accompany today's interview. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not registered yet at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com. Look for the red button that says looking for the downloads right above Vincent's picture. Vincent, I want to give you credit as well because, well, we've had a lot of really smart guests talk about the shortcomings of the 60/40 portfolio design, which of course has been the gold standard of portfolio design for the last several decades. A lot of the smartest guys on the street have been talking about the reasons it's not likely to perform as well in the future as it has in the past, but you get the title for the best name, calling it the nuclear winter of the 60/40 portfolio. So, what do you mean by that? Why is it a nuclear winter and what are the implications?

Because it's really what almost the entire industry recommends to most individual investors.

Vincent Deluard: Well, thank you for the kind words. So, if you start on the deck on page 4, you will kind of understand the term nuclear winter because what the the chart does is a long-term view of the nominal and real return over a 10-year trading period of a 60/40 portfolio. And what I find amazing about this chart is how steady it has been. I mean, if you have the time to wait for pretty much my entire life and probably several decades before that, you would be pretty certain that over 10 years, you would average real returns of about 8% to 9% with a 60/40 allocation.

I mean, the only dip, and it was very brief, was after the oil crisis when briefly the 10-year trailing return went negative before obviously becoming very positive as we had this massive rally in both long-term Treasuries and equities. And if we look at where we are today, we are right, actually a little above average. For the past 10 years, a 60/40 portfolio has delivered real return of close to 10%, which is a bit higher than the average of 8%.

In large part because inflation has been lower than what it has been. So, the real return has been boosted by the lack of inflation. And I'm sure we'll get into this later in the conversation that that's something that I expect will change. But I also expect that even the nominal return of a 60/40 portfolio, that trailing 10-year return of about 10% annually is a complete misrepresentation of what's likely going to take place over the next 10 years. So, that's why the term nuclear winter, which would include in my view, a decade of negative real return for traditional asset allocation, something that really no one whose career started in the past 50 years has experienced. Maybe that happened in the '70s, but outside of that, that's not something that any one of us has seen.

Repricing of assets and the pension-fund return gap

Erik Townsend: Now, what are the implications of that? If we say that for the next decade, the 60/40 portfolio, you just don't think it's going to work. Presumably, for the first couple of years of losing money, everybody just says, oh, well, it's just a blip. These things things happen, just wait it out, buy and hold stocks for the long term. At what point does the world figure out that it's really not working? And what are the implications when they do figure it out in terms of people moving out of the asset classes that they've become accustomed to as just the standard for so many decades?

Vincent Deluard: It will be a very messy process because as you pointed out, the entire industry is designed for a world where bonds deliver about 4% or 5% return, equities around 10%, 11%, And you take the average of that, and they are negatively correlated, and you get some diversification. Risk parity strategies rely on that. Pension funds rely on that. Individual investors rely on that. Robo-advisors build that into their own assumptions. So, the entire world is really based on that framework. So, as you take it off, the adjustment will be painful. I think that the quicker it happens, the better it will be. I mean, the way to restore the expected return of such a portfolio is to have lower starting price. I mean, over time, one of the biggest drivers of your return is, you know, what was the valuation of an asset when you bought it. So we need these valuations to come down so that we can restore that portfolio. So the effect would be a massive repricing of financial assets, and it will be messy.

I think you would probably see bubbles in other assets. I mean, I think gold is probably obviously a beneficiary of this nuclear winter of the 60/40 portfolio. And I think we're just at the beginning of that process. Maybe other things will benefit from it, whether it's Bitcoin or other more nontraditional assets. I mean, money needs to be invested somewhere. So as money leaves these strategies, others will benefit. And really only time will give us the answer.

One thing that we know for sure, though, is that the people who rely on these return expectations, specifically I'm thinking about pension funds in the US, I think on the latest survey of the American Association of Public Pension Funds, the median return assumption was 7.25% a year. That's what these guys expect to get. Well, you have 50 basis points on the 10-year yield. You have a P/E of close to 30. So, that converts to an earnings yield of around 4%, even with buybacks on top of that. Junk bond yields, I would say around 5%, and investment grade yield close to nothing. So, you take the average of these assets, and that's probably around 3%, 4%. And yet pension funds tell you, well, by mixing all of that, I'm going to get to 7.25%.

Yeah. I mean, this is not going to happen. Maybe some of them are going to be super smart and they're going to earn a trading return and they'll do the right thing at the right time. But collectively, the industry cannot earn the returns that it expects to earn.

The six horsemen of inflation

Erik Townsend: Vincent, another theme that I've noticed with some of the smartest guests that we have on MacroVoices is a lot of people are saying, okay, look, we're either beginning now or we're going to begin a transition towards secular inflation in the next few years. And it seems like a whole lot of smart people are telling that basic high-level story, but each one of them has their own version of it. So, moving on to slide 11, what's your take on why inflation may be on the horizon and what does it look like?

Vincent Deluard: Well, I think inflation has been a question that most strategists and investment managers have preferred to avoid or not think about because it's uncomfortable. And it's also been a sure way to look like an idiot. People who worried about inflation after QE1, QE2, QE3 have all been proven wrong. So I think there's a lot of resistance now to make the inflation call. The burden of the proof is indeed on the inflation camp, but I think we have enough evidence that now is different.

And in the presentation, I mentioned what I call the 6 Horsemen of Inflation, which are signs of inflation that you see across time and across countries that have always led to inflation. And I would say that all 6 Horsemen are here in the US today. I'll briefly name them, then we can just jump into any of them. The first one is asset price bubbles, which by any definition, if you look at the forward P/E ratio of the Russell 2000 Index at something like 100, if you look at the price-to-sales ratio of Microsoft at 11 or 12, the fact that Apple is You know, has almost doubled in the past 6 months. I mean, you see these bubbles literally everywhere. Of course, these bubbles are not as impressive measured in terms of gold. I mean, you could already argue, by the way, that gold has outperformed equities for the past 5 years, which in a way can be seen as a definition of an inflationary bull market, a period where financial asset returns lag that of gold, which is an asset that produces nothing.

So, asset price bubble is the first one. The second one is the great central bank bubble. Of course, we've discussed that many times before. This explosion in liquidity, which has accelerated in the past 6 months. Eventually, if there's any truth to the MV= PT equation I mean, the increase in M has been so large that eventually you should see some impact on prices.

The next one is this protectionism and what I would describe as a cost shock. I think that when all is said and done, COVID will be seen for an increase in the cost of stuff, the same way that after 1973, the price of oil increased. So, the price of Everything that you saw went up. Well, COVID, with all its restrictions on you know how people can work, how they can travel, will increase the cost of doing business in around the world. Then the fourth one is debt. We came into this with a huge corporate debt problem, a huge profitability problem in the United States, and on top of that, we've added now much more public debt. So we really have too much debt, and inflation has been historically a way to deal with debt in a politically not so painful way. Which then brings me to the next horseman, which is manipulated prices. I mean, typically inflation does not last in free market economies because the price mechanism ensures that, you know, resources are allocated where they're needed.

Humans are smart and creative, and that tends to bring price down. However, when you have a system where prices are no longer set by markets, but they are set by, you know, central banks or political committees, it's much harder to squeeze inflation out of the system. And that's the experience of Soviet Union, Venezuela, and other countries that have tried. You cannot state-oriented markets, which I think is where we're going in the US.

And then the last one, which is probably the most important, I think, if we think about secular inflation, is generational divide. I think one of the biggest crises in the US is wealth and income gap between the young and the old generation. And in a curious way, I think inflation is going to be the only feasible solution to bridge that gap.

MMT, fiscal policy and generational transfers

Erik Townsend: And how do you see that gap being bridged by inflation? What are the policy changes that you expect that would bring about that change?

Vincent Deluard: A lot of it would have to do with MMT or what I think Ray Dalio calls that Monetary Policy 3.0, maybe, where you see a transition from really QE for the rich. I mean, that's kind of what we had. We already have, we have 10 years of MMT behind us. It's just been spent for the benefit of asset owners. I mean, typically when the central bank uses the common resource, which is the currency issued by the government and uses it to buy assets, well, it subsidizes the asset owners. So, we had already since '08, really 10 years of MMT.

We just gave it to whoever owns Treasuries, mortgage-backed securities, now junk bonds, corporate bonds, and so forth.

And I think what we are witnessing progressively, but I think COVID has accelerated that shift, is a transition towards fiscal policy. Direct deficit monetization and an MMT that actually is more about sending money to people, whether that's through unemployment benefit or eventually through UBI or through just goodies. Could be better healthcare, which the US badly needs, could be the cancellation of student loan debts. So, I think that is that transition that will prove inflationary and in a way solve some of these generational

Erik Townsend: Vincent, let's move

Dollar outlook: secular bear market, not collapse

Erik Townsend: on to the US dollar. We've seen the dollar index test a low 92 handle intraday recently, and we're still just barely above 93. A lot of people thought, you know, for— it seemed like 96 was really good support, and all of a sudden the bottom fell out. Is this the beginning of the big move that Luke Gromen and others have predicted, you know, the end of the dollar? Or is this more of just a cyclical move that's likely to eventually retrace to the upside?

Vincent Deluard: My answer would be somewhere in the middle. I think it's certainly too early to proclaim the death of the US dollar as a reserve currency, although that will probably happen someday. I mean, that has happened to hundreds of currencies before, but it's probably too early to call it that way.

I also think it's probably— I would not underestimate this as just a short-term cyclical move. I think we are entering a secular bear market for the dollar, not necessarily one where the dollar loses its exorbitant privilege, but something more like what we experienced between 2002 to 2007, where the euro went from probably parity to close to 1.6 at the peak, and the dollar lost ground against major currencies, including the Brazilian real, which usually is not a currency that appreciates.

So, I think that's where we are. The dollar has gotten to be massively overvalued. International assets have been repressed compared to dollar assets. And there's a little bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy, right? Because as the dollar weakens, it makes it easier for emerging markets borrowers to service their debt. It improves global growth, it improves their profits, it improves commodity prices. So, this loop really is just starting between the weak dollar and the outperformance of international assets. And typically, these things last for You know, 5 to 7 years. Now, time will tell if this will lead into a complete demise of the dollar or if it's just one of these normal kind of healthy cycles of dollar weakness.

Europe: cautious optimism and cyclical value

Erik Townsend: Vincent, I know that before moving to StoneX, you were with Ned Davis Research where you created their European research product. Talk to us a little bit about how Europe fits into this big macro picture. We've clearly got, you know, the US, markets are recovering, even if the US economy isn't. What's your outlook for Europe, both markets and the economy?

Vincent Deluard: I would say to some extent cautiously optimistic. In the first phase of the pandemic, it looked like Europe was really going to be the biggest victim of it, and for good reason. I mean, we had the most deaths, we had the harshest lockdowns, and then we have an economy in Europe that is heavily dependent on tourism, on mobility. You look at a European index, it is basically no tech. It's car manufacturers and service-related stuff that was going to be badly impacted by COVID. So, for a bit, it looked like Europe was going to really suffer the brunt of this.

And that lasted up until the US really messed it up. And now, in comparison, you're like, well, Europe looks pretty good. Germany and most of Northern and Eastern Europe did actually okay containing the pandemic. They are opening up. I mean, yeah, we're seeing a little spike of infections here and there, but I think that compared to where we are in the US, it's under control. So, you know, this is probably a good moment for Europe. There's certainly been this massive fiscal impulse, which people have been— Europe has been dying for 10 years from thriftiness and the North's refusal to engage in fiscal spending.

And it's as if the COVID crisis has led to some sort of collective realization of pragmatism. Hey, this could take us all down. We are, you know, I don't think the Germans or the Dutch are doing this out of their heart. But they realize that their economy requires Spain and Italy and Greece not to fall off the cliff. And that's where we're going to go.

So, I think people have— and I think in a way, the departure of England, Brexit, has helped that because England has always been a Trojan horse. So, now that England's gone, well, Germany doesn't have much of a choice. It has to turn back to France, and it has to do some of these fiscal stimulus measures, more integration. I still think there are severe issues with the euro over the long term, but over the short term, it's cheap.

The economy is somewhat recovering. We are seeing political momentum, so I would see an opportunity provided, and that's a big big if, provided the virus doesn't get worse. I mean, if there is a vaccine, I think Europe is a fantastic value opportunity. If we have a second wave, I don't think the European economy can survive operating in a COVID world where people have to social distance and can't go on vacation, can't go on hotels and all that stuff. So to me, the vaccine to cover that is in Europe. If you're not in the US, I know all the Robinhood day traders, you try to buy airlines or cruise ships, whatever. You would do much better buying cyclical European stocks for much cheaper and much further along the way of the recovery.

Political unrest and the generational divide

Erik Townsend: Vincent, I want to come back to the subject of political unrest and this generational crisis that you alluded to a few minutes ago. You've got a series of slides talking about this starting on page 19 of your slide deck. This is a topic that is near and dear to my heart. I've spoken quite a bit about it on MacroVoices, but I want to get your take. How do you see this situation? Why do we have all of this political unrest? What's driving it? Is it the Fourth Turning that Neil Howe talks about or something else? What's driving it? Where is it headed? And how does it eventually get resolved?

Vincent Deluard: Well, I think the, the biggest driver is really that, that first chart we see on page 19, which looks at the ratio of the S&P 500 index to the minimum wage. And basically what it tells you is how many hours you need to work at the minimum wage in order to buy one share of the index. In the 1970s, when the boomers were growing up, leaving their homes, starting their jobs, you know, starting households, that was about 2 weeks. Today, it's closer to 2 months.

And a fourfold increase in this ratio.

And the way I interpret this ratio is that it really measures the terms of the trade between generations. I mean, you can think of the young generation As a generation, for the most of us at least who don't have trust funds, we need to offer work in order to buy assets. And typically, our work when we're young is not that qualified. It's closer to minimum wage than end of career, right? So, we earn the minimum wage and we try to build assets with that. Conversely, you can think of the old generation as a generation whose human capital is mostly depleted, right? I mean, if you're past 65, usually you retire. So, really, your goal now is to convert the capital that you accumulated over your career into work that will be provided to you by other people. So, the term of the trade has increased by fourfold in favor of the old generation. They can buy a lot more labor with their assets.

And conversely, the young generation can buy a lot fewer assets with their labor than they used to.

Not only that, but we also have what I call differentiated inflation problem. So, the Bureau of Labor Statistics report only one inflation number, or at least we only care about one, the CPI-U. which is the basket of urban, whatever, typical basket of an urban consumer. Now, in that basket, some of the very big weights are things like housing, about 20% to 30%, the owner's rent equivalent. Then the next best thing aggregated is healthcare expense, and then it's education. Well, if you think about where these expenses fall, they fall very differently across generations. For the old generation, they don't pay for housing. Most people own their home. If anything, they may even be able to rent it out, have an Airbnb people, so that the house price inflation for the old generation is actually positive for them. Conversely, of course, the young, typically a young household pays, you know, if you live in a major city, it's going to be 30% to 40% of your salary is going to be spent on rent.

Same thing with healthcare. I mean, in the US, if you are past 65, it may go down to 60, you get Medicare, so you don't have to pay for it. So, you're insured against the risk of healthcare inflation. Conversely, if you're young, typically you don't consume a lot of healthcare. I mean, I never see a doctor because I'm never sick, yet my premium, my insurance premium goes up by 10% every year.

So, you keep paying more for something that you really don't consume.

And then last, education. Well, obviously, if you're retired, you're not going to pay college debt. You're not going to pay to go to college, but if you don't, you need to build your skills. That's what we've been told by society, and that's what we've done. And if you have college debt, you really go to high interest. And as far as I'm aware, it's the only debt in the US that you cannot default upon. So, you have this unextinguishable debt, usually at a high interest that an entire generation carries.

So, what I did in the chart on page 9, in the second chart, is I fixed the CPI-U, and I created a boomer consumer index, which is indeed deflationary, because what it captures is the fact that the cost of shopping at Walmart has gone down because of China, the cost of travel has gone down because of globalization, the cost of a European cruise vacation has gone down. The things that old people buy have gotten cheaper. And then I've built another index, which is much more heavily skewed towards housing, education, and healthcare, which is much more representative of what the young generation is spending, is experiencing. And that has increased by 5 to 10% every year for the past decade. So, in a way, I would argue we already have inflation. It just only hit one group. One group has had inflation, another group has had deflation, and on average, we had like 1.5% inflation.

But that average does not capture the reality of anybody. And what we need to do if we want to have proper economic growth If we want to restore some semblance of cohesion in society, is we need these trends to invert. We need the stuff that the young people pay for, the price needs to go down, and conversely, maybe an increase in the cost of living for old people. That is the solution. And I think to some extent, broad inflation because of MMT, because of rising wages, and then falling asset prices will bring that outcome.

Why inflation has not yet appeared

Erik Townsend: Vincent, let's come back to inflation and specifically why it hasn't happened. You've got a series of slides in the deck coming up. up that talks about that starting on page 21.

Vincent Deluard: Yes. So, back in 2009, 2010, when we started this massive monetary expansion and QE programs, a lot of people were worried about inflation. Basically, it was MV equals PT. We increase M, eventually P will increase. And that didn't happen. And I think the reason that didn't happen is because monetary policy was doing one thing, but fiscal policy was doing another thing. Especially in Europe, prudential policy was doing another thing. So, the central bank was easing, but at the same time, we had massive fiscal tightening. I mean, in the US, I think in '09, the budget deficit was close to 10% of GDP. By the end of the second Obama mandate, it was down to 2%.

Europe, even more insane experiment with fiscal contraction because we eventually went to a surplus because Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, the virtuous countries actually had a budget surplus. We went from -10% to a surplus. So, massive fiscal contract retrenchment at the time we had this monetary easing.

And then also in Europe, which I think is the better case for the deflationary economy, we also had prudential regulation that forced the bank to deleverage. I mean, going into '08, European banks had tier 1 capital ratio of like 2%, and now they're around 12%. So, in order to do that, you had to do a tremendous amount of deleveraging of banks' balance sheets. And given how essential the banking system in Europe, in the intermediation process, that really shrank the economy. So, the monetary liquidity injections did not reach the intended effect for the past 10 years.

Now, I think that we already have experienced a shift. I mean, in the US, people are being paid $1,000 a week to play the PlayStation. We are seeing the €750 billion relief package in Europe that's going to be spent on unemployment benefits, on direct aid, and so forth. Now, it hasn't been inflationary yet, mostly because these things take time.

I mean, the system is not set up for Treasury issuance of $3 trillion in 3 months. This is where we've been in the past 3 months. Usually, that takes 3 to 5 years. So, it takes time for things to be spent. I mean, if you look at the general government account at the Fed, 25% of the Fed balance sheet is effectively on the Fed balance sheet because the Treasury hasn't spent the money. It's issued the debt, the Fed bought it, but then the cash has come back on the balance sheet because the Treasury hasn't had time to spend money. Just give it time. Now we we get this impression that oh we can spend and it's free and there won't be any inflation.

Well, that's because the money hasn't been spent. A lot of it also has gone into money market funds, which is typical what you typically see in a flight to safety after a wait. We saw an increase of 1.5 trillion money market funds. Now it's more been like 2 trillion. So it's almost it's a crazy economy where the government issues debt to send money to people, and then the people take this. take the money the government sends them and they buy Treasury debt. So, as long as that happens and we have this very high savings rate, yeah, we can keep going. There won't be any inflation.

But when the economy starts to normalize, when the government actually starts to spend the money and spend it will because that's what governments do, when the economy reopens, I mean, the savings rate is going to fall down and you'll see the velocity increase. And that's when we'll have the inflation problem. Just give me time. My estimate is that it's going to start to happen by the end of the year. And in 2021, you will already see inflation above the 2% target.

At the beginning, I think the Fed will welcome that. They say, look, it's working. We're saving the economy. This is great. And then it would just keep creeping up, up, up, up, up until it becomes a problem.

Gold after the sell-off: the case for buying

Erik Townsend: Let's talk about what to do about that problem. Gold and precious metals are the obvious investment answer. Now, until very recently, it had been starting to feel almost like a blow-off top that I was really getting concerned about. We're recording this interview on Tuesday, a couple days before our listeners will hear it, and we're finally seeing the first significant down day in the gold market in months and months.

Down, boy, almost $100 as we're speaking on the day. Where is this headed? Is this a buy-the-dip moment? Should we be jumping at this, or is the gold market maybe a little bit ahead of itself? And it's better to wait for a bigger dip.

Vincent Deluard: I will say both. I'm totally on board with you that it's not healthy for, I mean, what was it, like 7 or 8 days to go, it was like up, up, up, up, up. And even as a gold bull, you really don't want to see that because that creates the risk of a dip. And it could be that we have that dip. I'm not smart enough to predict how big it's going to be, how long it's going to last. But what I know, if your investment horizon is more than a year, I think you just buy it.

The case for gold remains. In a weird way, the case for gold today is almost— it's the same argument that used to be made against gold 5 years ago work now in favor of gold. Let me explain that a little bit. One argument against gold is that it has no intrinsic value. You can't do a discounted cash flow analysis. It's in the eye of the beholder.

You can make that an argument for the upside as well. Like, is gold overvalued at $2,000? I don't know. No one knows. It depends on how much people want to own gold. So, there is no limit to the upside or the down other than zero on the price of gold. The other argument that people make against gold is that, well, it doesn't produce any cash flow, doesn't pay dividend, doesn't do a buyback.

Well, we are going to be in a world where dividends are going to be cut. Buybacks are already being hammered everywhere. So, gold is not suffering for that because there's no dividend or buyback to cut. And then finally, the usual argument is that gold doesn't produce anything, doesn't generate cash flow.

Well, guess what? There's $15 trillion of bonds that have a negative yield. So, gold is a high-yield asset compared to government bonds at this point. Real yields are collapsing all around the world. I mean, you look at the 10-year inflation-protected Treasury security in the US, I mean, you're going to get negative 60 basis point yield. So, over the course of the— if you want to hold it to maturity, you're going to lose 6% of your purchasing power if you buy TIPS.

As long as you have that, gold is a better alternative and this can keep going.

Latin America as a weak-dollar trade

Erik Townsend: Vincent, I know a lot of the work that you do at StoneX focuses on Latin America. Does that play into the gold story or why is Latin America such a big part of your work?

Vincent Deluard: Absolutely. And I think it's an answer to your earlier question about, or your earlier concern, which I think is totally valid about gold having run up too quickly, too fast, and the risk of a blow-off top in gold. Well, what can you do if you're concerned about that? But you're still concerned about inflation. You're still concerned about the weak dollar. I think Latin America is a Latin American assets in general and equities in particular are a way to capitalize on that and buy an asset that is still trading at generational lows. So you don't have the froth in the market that you see in the gold market, and you have the very much same dynamic. I mean, Latin America is a weak dollar trade on crack. I mean, these are economies that. Borrowing dollars, so they have a massive net short dollar, and they earn revenues in inflation-sensitive assets, typically commodities.

Usually, that's a horrible thing to do, and that's why Latin American assets are usually a bad idea. But if you expect the dollar to go down, and if you expect to see inflation, you get it from both ends, and you get it at secular lows in terms of valuation.

I mean, here's just one last stat I'm going to mention on this. Amazon as a company, is worth 3 times more than the MSCI Brazil Index. You can make a joke about the Amazon River and Amazon the company if you want to make that punch. But anyway, the point is one US company is worth 3 times more than a continent-sized economy with amazing natural resources, with earnings. I mean, if you look at earnings over the past 10 years on inflation-adjusted basis, Brazilian stocks have earned 10 times more than Amazon. And yet they trade for a third of the price. Of course, there's plenty of risk with Latin America, political risk, especially in Brazil, COVID risk. But if the concern is weak dollar, inflation, and you want to hedge with cheap assets, Latin American equities is where you want to go.

Deluard's research reports and close

Erik Townsend: And finally, Vincent, we have links in our Research Roundup email to several sample institutional research reports which you've recently written. Please tell our listeners what they can expect to find there. What are these reports about and what should they expect when they open the

Vincent Deluard: Absolutely. So, there are 4 reports that will be made public. One is on this generational divide, which is called Not Okay Boomer, and it goes into this differentiated inflation measure between boomers and millennials and Gen Zers and how to solve it and how I expect it to be solved via MMT. There's another one, which is The Case for Inflation, just going through the 6 Horsemen. There's another one on the nuclear winter of the 60/40 portfolio, breaking down where the decision comes from. Can the FAANG really grow into their valuation? What's being baked in the market? How can we achieve it? What would happen to bond prices if yields went negative? All these things generally suggest that we cannot get good returns equal to portfolio, by the way. Then the last one is something that I call the bull market cult is endangering the economy, which basically goes into a a view that what's good for the stock market is now bad for the economy.

And conversely, if we had a good economy, we'd have a bad stock market. So this is an example of the work I produce for StoneX. If people are interested, they should reach out to me on Twitter. I will put a link to a page where they can sign up for my work. The best way to get it, of course, is to trade with us. We trade a lot of stuff. We have offices around the world. But even if you are not into StoneX, level with an account at StoneX, you can reach out to me and we can figure out a way to get you the research.

Erik Townsend: Vincent, I want to thank you for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction to Deluard, 60/40 and reflexivity

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Vincent on the show. I mean, it was really interesting, his take on the 60/40 portfolio. There's no shortage of incredibly smart people talking about What comes next after we hit the zero bound on interest rates where bonds no longer have that hedge built into them that they typically have provided that balanced portfolio and what is the alternative to that? And so it was really interesting to get his take on all of that. What did you take away?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, the 60/40 portfolio has already been broken for years. If you just look at interest rates are and look at the usual argument for why you would have bonds to balance the stocks in your portfolio and to essentially provide a buffer when the stocks go down, the bonds go up. They don't— the bonds don't have a lot of room to go up when you're already at zero interest rates. So it's already not working. The thing is, that has not caused the wholesale abandonment of that strategy by the mainstream finance community.

So the question that's on my mind is the George Soros reflexivity question of, okay, what does it take to get to the point where it's not just a few crazies on MacroVoices that have been pointing these things out for the last couple of years that 60/40 doesn't really work anymore? But when do you get to the point where even the robo-advisor crowd, the mainstream finance community recognizes that it's not working and realizes that they need to change to something else?

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: What are they going to try to change to, and what is the result of that going to be in markets? I think that's the $64 trillion question, is what happens when the whole industry figures out that it's not working. We're probably still a few more years away from that, but that's what I've been thinking about, and frankly, I don't know the answer. What I do know is that you put together another terrific post-game chart deck.

Postgame: gold and silver correction and buy-the-dip debate

Erik Townsend: Now, listeners, what we discussed last week was With gold at all-time record highs and having moved up so quickly, we really thought that you ought to be thinking about using option strategies to protect against downside in case there was a sudden pullback in the market. Well, guess what? That was really good advice, but we told you we'd wait till this week to tell you how those strategies work. Hopefully some of you tuned in to Big Picture Trading. Certainly Big Picture Trading members got the full story from Patrick and had time to act on it.

For everyone else, Patrick, how do we adjust course to talk about what maybe is a better fit now that we've had this correction and it's already— is it behind us completely or is it just partly behind us? I'm not sure. What do we do from here?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, let's start off actually just talking about gold and silver on the charts and what's happening. And then I really want to take a dive into the way that the options market on gold and silver work. And it's a— I find it a a really amazing market to trade in, and I want to share with all of our listeners, uh, what— why I feel that way about it. And even though maybe the initial hedge of this correction may have been missed, there's lots of opportunities moving forward to utilizing options on gold and silver and building all sorts of really neat asymmetric trades using them.

So on chart 2, I've got gold, and really, um, what I wanted to highlight both on gold and on page 3, silver, is that what we witnessed over the span of a several-day market correction was pretty much a 50% retracement of the most recent swing higher. And so this retracement fits all of the typical characteristics of a buy-on-dip. Usually in the normal ebb and flow of markets, you have a rise and then the rise is checked with a retracement and it's bought. Often you'll have the trail trailing moving averages sitting just below, which a lot of technicians will be buying the test of moving averages. And what's particularly interesting is gold has had this characteristic going back a year or two that almost all dips tend to be bought within about 5 days off the high. And, you know, some are a little bit longer, some shorter. But what I'm, what I'm very curious about in the coming days is to find out whether Whether this is a dip that was bought no different than every other past one.

And if it is, it's an asymmetric moment because often the bases that come off these types of corrections reset the momentum and often put in motion a brand new upleg. And will we see that in gold and silver? That's one of the more interesting puzzle pieces for us to solve in the coming days. But I mean, at this stage, I think giving the benefit of the doubt, I think that this potentially was a key buying opportunity?

Erik Townsend: Well, I certainly bought more on this dip, and I've got resting limit orders in place to buy even more if we get closer to $1,800, which was where the breakout zone started. So I think there's an argument technically to say we could get back down there, although just watching the tape in the last day or so, it looks like maybe this thing's already over. So, you know, you got to buy a little on each dip and be ready to buy a little more if it dips further.

Don't rule out the possibility, folks, that there could be even more downside to come.

Postgame: dealer gamma in SLV options

Patrick Ceresna: So, so, Erik, I wanted to move on to page 4 where I have a chart courtesy of Brent over at SpotGamma. Brent, thanks for sending this over. But what he calculated here was actually the amount of call buying that's happening on silver has put dealers being short gamma on a large amount of call options, and it's showing this chart. It's a very kind of Charlie McElligott kind of chart to, to look at, but specifically focusing on the SLV options. And what's interesting is that the, the dealers being short a whole whack of gamma as the silver is rallying, it's actually forcing dealers to chase the market higher by having to buy the SLV and contributing to the actually the momentum to the upside. A good example An example of where this was recently seen was when Tesla was ripping to the upside. All the out-of-the-money call buying on Tesla had the dealers short gamma and actually contributed to actually accelerating the upside. And now we're seeing actually a very similar characteristic on SLV.

What's interesting is that that gamma really gets going all the way up to the $30 strike on the SLV, which still lies $4 or $5 higher from where we are. It'd be really interesting to see with the current structure whether or not some of that volatility gives silver another go on the upside.

Postgame: gold and silver option skew versus equities

Erik Townsend: Patrick, moving on to page 5, it looks to me like you've designed a ramp to ride a skateboard down to do the gamma flip as you come off the end of the jump. Maybe it's something else. Explain the chart.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, what I wanted to really talk about is why I love trading options on gold and silver and why it's such a great market to do all sorts of hedging on. And in order to understand why there's this edge, at least in the character of the way the options markets trade on gold and silver, is to see what a typical options market skew looks like.

And what you can observe here, this is the SPY, for the S&P 500, you have what's known as the fat left tail, which is as you move to the left side of this chart, the implied volatilities are higher and higher on out-of-the-money puts. And that's typical because the stock market tends to have that nature of that old saying of it rises on an escalator and drops on an elevator. You always have to have a price in a higher implied on the downside risks within the market. And typically because of this, what it means is that building a zero-cost collar or some other way of hedging risk doesn't allow you the opportunity to do it near zero cost. Often you're collecting a very small call premium for income and a very— you have a very expensive put to buy as insurance, and it doesn't give you the ability to build asymmetric payoff.

And even though people do do it because of the nature of the market, this is just the way that the typical skew looks for majority of stocks.

But if we go to page 6 and 7, you can see the skews on both SLV and GLD for gold and silver. And what you can observe is, is that the characteristic is actually the opposite, where what you have is that the implied volatilities on options are actually higher as you're going out of the money. And as you go out of the money on puts, the hedging is actually relatively cheaper as measured by the implied volatility priced into these options. And this now gives you a whole array of amazing option strategies that you can implement, particularly to silver and gold, that you don't have the same opportunity to get the same kind of payoff profiles as you would in the traditional market.

Now, one of the strategies that I've been doing quite actively, and the one we talked about last week, is the idea of building a collar, which is the idea of buying a protective put and then using an out-of-the-money call to— covered call to pay for it, and being able to do so at a zero cost and have your ability to hedge wrap your risk in there. But what is also really neat about a market that trades this way with their skews is that if you are bullish and you're looking for upside, you can really get some compelling payoff profiles on just very traditional debit spreads or other vertical or even diagonal spreads that you can put on, on the upside, just because those really far out-of-the-money calls are still paying very robust call premiums. Giving all sorts of really amazing option strategies you can build upon it.

Postgame: Big Picture Trading webinar and SLV bull call spread

Patrick Ceresna: And so I wanted to share some of these. Obviously, with the gold correction underway, it didn't make a whole lot of sense explaining an existing SLV collar.

But what I wanted to do was just share with our listeners, anyone who wants to take a dive into the live markets and see what these kind of trade setups look like, I was going to be doing on Monday Monday on August 17th, a special live webinar for all of my free trialers and members at Big Picture Trading, where we're going to go into that live market and actually look at these options chains and build all sorts of these really neat different option strategies around gold and silver, taking advantage of these skews

Erik Townsend: And that's coming up this Monday, August 17th, 1 to 2 PM Eastern Time. You've got to sign up at Big Picture Trading either for free trial or be a member of Big Picture Trading in order to participate. Now, if you're not available Monday exactly between 1 and 2 PM, is it possible to watch it after the fact as a replay?

Patrick Ceresna: For sure. The recording is going to be available on the website almost immediately after we do it live. So everyone that wanted to watch it will be able to get access to it. But it's the— in the live session, I have the opportunity to interact real-time with them. And so questions and other that members have can, they can throw them at me and I'm taking my very best stab at answering all of the really interesting particulars about using options in gold and silver.

But just to give a very quick sample, right now if you let's say went out on SLV, so let's just say that that gamma skew that we talked about on chart 4 stayed true and there was an opportunity for for silver to be bought on dip, and maybe we see an impulse higher that can see us moving toward, let's say, $30 on the upside. Well, right now, if you go out 36 days on a September 18th expiry, doing a, let's say, $26 to a $30 bull call spread out for 36 days, giving you a $4 upside spread, you can pretty much open it very close to a And so you could get a 4-to-1 payoff profile like this for continuing to kind of play the bet that the upside on silver's there and still have a very defined and limited risk if it doesn't materialize.

It's just an example of some of the really neat things you can do in that gold and silver market.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: And listeners, of course, you can sign up for a free 14-day trial of Big Picture Trading at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week. This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our research Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Vincent's slides and the chart deck we just discussed in the post-game There's also a link to an interesting article titled Nothing Is Rock Solid, Even Yellow Metal, and a link to the Jeffrey Snider article, Inflation Hysteria 2: Because Reasons. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write If you have a research roundup or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna.

Erik Townsend: Thanks, Patrick.

Vincent Deluard: @PatrickCeresna.

Patrick Ceresna: On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer closing and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Jim Bianco — Bianco Research founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 231 was recorded on August 6th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases. Bianco Research founder Jim Bianco has arguably been the most prescient voice in the world of finance with regard to predicting the COVID-19 crisis. Yet the rumor on the street is that notwithstanding the worsening new case counts, Jim has turned bullish on the stock market. Jim returns as this week's feature interview guest, and we'll start with this apparent contradiction before moving on to fixed income markets, the US dollar, gold, inflation, digital reserve currencies, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick has prepared yet another of his famous postgame chartbooks.

Wrap: S&P 500 and the COVID second wave

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, that S&P 500 has just not let up. A slow crawl every single day, just a little bit higher. I'm looking forward to putting up a chart on it in the postgame. But what's your thinking here on the S&P?

Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, we're less than 100 points away from a new all-time high again. And I don't really see the fundamentals in place that would justify a double-top pattern in the chart. I think we're climbing up toward a retest of the previous highs. I think that in many ways it appears that although I'll score So, I think the coronavirus is right during the time we've been off. My predictions have been confirmed that the COVID-19 crisis would get worse before it got better.

Well, the thing is, it did get worse, but it seems like we're peaking out on that second wave. Actually, there's an argument to say it's not really a second wave, but a different geographical occurrence or a different location of the first wave occurring in different parts of the country. Regardless of how you wanna slice that one, the second peak in new cases seems to have peaked out. for this wave. And I think that as that's confirmed and the death rate, which is still trending up, starts to roll over and flatten out or turn downward, I wouldn't be surprised if that takes us to new all-time highs. I don't think that a strong economy is driving this move higher. I think it mostly has to do with central bank accommodation. But it is what it is and looks to me like we're still going to keep on heading higher here.

We'll see what happens. In any case, Patrick, Jim Bianco was the one guy who's consistently been 2 steps ahead of me on this COVID-19 crisis, and he's turned bullish on the stock market.

Patrick Ceresna: Oh, really?

Erik Townsend: So we'll get to that as my first question in the feature interview.

Wrap: US dollar breaks support

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index, because the last time me and you chatted about the dollar index, we were all the way up at the 96 handle asking the question of whether that support line could hold. And really, in the last couple weeks, we gave out everything and we're trading down around the 93 handle on the downside with a very distinct downtrend. How do you interpret all of this, what's going on in the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Whoa, baby. To be sure, it's time to sit up and pay attention to the dollar here. And, you know, a number of key support support levels that we've talked about in previous shows have all been broken to the downside. So the question now is, okay, what's going on? Is this just a reaction to the accommodation by the Fed and the money printing and so forth that is seen as weak for the dollar? Or is it bigger than that? Could we be seeing, you know, what I'll call a Gromen-level event? I've said for many years now that Luke Gromen's view that the US dollar would eventually lose its reserve currency status and dramatically devalue against other currencies.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: I've always said Luke would be proven right someday, but I just thought he was several years early. Could it be that it's time for Luke Gromen to be proven right? I'm not sure, to tell you the truth, but I'm going to start asking our feature interview guests, starting with Jim Bianco today.

Wrap: Crude oil, Beirut and the Q4 view

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's talk crude oil. I mean, we've been more or less trade range bound, but over the last couple of days, oil's been trying to break out above those highs around that $42 level. What's your take on crude?

Erik Townsend: Well, yes and no. I think we might disagree on that a little bit, although we may be headed in that direction. We've been consolidating sideways here for coming up on 2 months now, and it looked just a few days ago like maybe again we were finally starting to see the market roll over to the downside. Then Beirut blew up, and if you haven't seen the pictures, don't expect to, to go online and find a picture of the damage done to the seaport in Beirut. What you'll see is a picture of the crater where the seaport in Beirut Yeah. And as the news started to come out about how big the Beirut used to be, it's really, really big. They're saying this is 1/5 of the size of the Hiroshima nuclear explosion. It's, I think, the biggest non-nuclear manmade explosion in history or something. And it was all a result apparently of a mistake.

But of course, when anything in that part of the world blows up in a massive explosion, the first thought is, oh boy, are we headed toward, you know, terrorism, maybe something that could be a major upset for the oil market.

Well, maybe it was actually just a really negligent mistake of storing a bunch of very volatile chemicals in the wrong place. The very next day, we had the market in the United Arab Emirates blow up, and everybody's wondering, okay, what the heck is going on here? So it's really, I think, ruffled the feathers of the oil market and sent us to some panic upside. It looked to me like this afternoon, particularly into the close, That panic upside is coming back off as we've realized that both of these events were not apparently terrorism or new wars or anything, but they were just dumb mistakes that happened. But let's zoom out, Patrick, to the really big picture. When we had Art Berman on the program, what we discussed is at that point we were just coming through $40.

Art and I both expected the rally to top out around $41 or $42, which it did. We expected it to roll over and move back to the downside. But Art was very quick to say, look, it's a temporary reprieve. Reprieve because we're going to have a bunch of drilled but uncompleted wells that get completed and so forth. That's going to sustain U.S. production levels. And that's exactly what we've seen in the data is we're sustaining about 11 million barrels a day of U.S. production very consistently in the last several reports. Art said wait in Q4 for that number to just fall off a cliff and for prices to move higher. Well, we're kind of running out of time. You know, if we thought there was going to be a big downdraft before eventually, you know, the down comes in Q3 and the up comes in Q4, well, we're already halfway through Q3 and we haven't seen any significant downside. So if it's going to happen, it needs to happen pretty soon.

Now, the counterargument would be August is usually, from a seasonality perspective, when oil prices top out. But that seasonality is driven by a normal summer driving season, which we don't have this year. So I'm not sure if those seasonality factors really come into play. What I do feel more confident with is Art Berman's going to be right sooner or later. By the end of the year, I think it's very likely that we'll be looking at higher oil prices as a result of US production declining. So do we get any meaningful downside between now and then? I'm still leaving open that possibility, but it's looking less and less like it. Eventually, we're going to get much higher prices once US production declines. Moving on to inventory. Well, maybe US production declining is being signaled here because crude oil drawing down 7.4 million barrels, even though we are still showing a US production report of 11 million barrels, which is pretty much stable.

The builds on the Strategic Petroleum Reserve have fallen to zero now. So it seems like the effort to move oil out of Cushing into the SPR seems to have been curtailed. Cushing, Oklahoma, building 532,000 barrels, just over a half million barrels. Gasoline Building 419,000 barrels. Distillates building 1.6 million barrels. And again, US production holding steady. Actually, it's down 100,000 to 11.0 million, but it was up 100,000 last week. So, you know, we're hanging in right here around 11 million barrels. The thing to watch for— and Art Berman says it's coming in Q4— is for that 11 million to fall precipitously through 10 million and we get to a 9-point-something. That's where you can look for oil prices to really start to move up. Obviously, the situation in China China is very tense with everything going on with the coronavirus crisis and the US administration and so forth. And those China oil buying dynamics are going to be very important.

So how goes China's economy is definitely going to have a significant impact. For now, I'm still sort of waiting this out thinking maybe there's a chance for some more downside, probably not quite as much as Art and I predicted. If certainly if we got to low 30s or even $30 a barrel, I think it's time to start buying in anticipation of higher prices in Q4. Maybe we never even get the dip and we just continue to consolidate sideways before eventually resolving higher. So far, what we saw in the last couple of days looks like it was a false alarm, but there's still room to see what happens. So we'll keep a close eye on it.

Wrap: Gold above $2,000, silver surges

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik. Well, I was looking forward to this. Let's talk gold. I mean, when we were last chatting, it was near $1,800 and we were asking that question of whether it was going to break out. Well, I mean, that's definitely a breakout. What's your take on how, uh, gold has developed over the last couple weeks?

Erik Townsend: Well, actually, Patrick, last time we spoke, it had already broken out to $1,800, and it had closed above $1,800. And you and I were both confused, saying, boy, really thought that a daily close over $1,800 would be the signal that would really ignite a rally that would have some gusto to it. And we went for more than a week with really nothing happening— no real downside, no real upside. We were both scratching our heads saying, What the heck? I, I guess it was just coiling up and getting ready because boy, as soon as we took our summer break, off it went. We're now up 15% from that $1,800 close that we were discussing last time you and I spoke on the program. So clearly the move is on. And, uh, you know, we're over $2,000 now. So not only did we get to the previous all-time high of $1,923 per ounce on an intraday basis, I think it was, uh, 1889 or so on a closing basis and 1923 on an intraday basis.

We took those out very quickly. Now we're above 2,000. So we really need to talk quite a bit about gold in upcoming shows. And boy, talk about gold, look at silver. That's just really taken off like a rocket ship. I'll tell you what, let's come back to this, get into some silver charts and some more detail in the postgame segment when we have more time. And certainly in coming weeks, we need to talk about cup and handle versus no cup and handle. Looks like we're skipping the handle on this one, going straight up. How long can it last? Let's come back to this in postgame.

Wrap: 10-year Treasury yield and negative rates

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's wrap up by touching on the 10-year Treasury yield, which continues to just slowly crawl lower. I mean, we almost hit 50 basis points at one point here. What's your take on interest rates?

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm still looking really at the long term primarily. I don't have any short-term view other than it appears that you've been proven right. I'm sure your Big Picture Trading members must be doing well trading US Treasury futures and so forth. As far as the macro picture, though, I want to ask Jim Bianco about this because you've really got to believe in negative interest rates for the US 10-year as a real possibility in order to get very excited about this bull market going much further. So does it reverse? Do we get a backing up in yields in the next year or two as inflation starts to hit the stage, or is that still a few years away? That's the question on my mind. I don't know the answer. I'm going to ask Jim Bianco. He's smarter than me when it comes to this stuff.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay. We have a quick housekeeping note, folks. Our feature interview transcripts have been delayed due to an illness from our production team. Bear with us. We're working on getting caught up on the transcripts and look forward to returning to our usual policy of having the transcripts up on the website within 48 hours after the show airs. Now, this week's feature interview guest is Bianco Research founder, Jim Bianco. Now, Erik, why did we get Jim back on the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, first of all, Jim is the one guy in finance that's been several steps ahead of me throughout this COVID-19 crisis. We're at a really, really important inflection point in the market here.

As predicted here on MacroVoices, we have had a second wave of infections, if you want to think of it that way, or an occurrence of a wave of infections in a different part of the country that creates the appearance of a second wave on the chart, if you want to think of it that way. By the way, check your Research Roundup email. You'll find an excellent video from Dr. Chris Martenson Martinson linked, which provides more context on what's going on with COVID-19. But in terms of finance guys that have been on top of this, Jim has been just leading the pack. We're at a turning point, I think, where we may be getting to the worst is behind us, at least for this first major wave of the COVID-19 crisis. So what does that mean? And of course, the other thing is Jim has turned bullish on the stock market, getting a lot of people caught off guard and by surprise.

So we want to get some perspective on what brought that about. Folks, before we go to the feature interview, please be sure to rate and review us on iTunes. Makes a huge difference in terms of getting us back to where we used to be as the best investment podcast on the internet. Detailed instructions for exactly how to leave a review on iTunes are in your Research Roundup email.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Jim Bianco is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Bianco: Money printing, not fundamentals, drives stocks

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Bianco Research founder Jim Bianco. Jim, the, the big rumor on the street is, hey, have you heard? Bianco turned bullish on stocks. I want to really ask you what's going on here, because I'm reminded of interviewing Jeff Snider once, and I described Jeff as being bullish on the dollar. And he interrupted me and said, wait a minute, wait a minute, stop. Bullish means you believe in something, you really believe in the fundamentals. Please don't call me bullish on the dollar. I think the dollar system is broken. I think it's broken badly. It just happens to be broken in a way where a shortage of dollars will cause dollars to appreciate against other currencies. But it's not bullish. It's broken in a way that makes it go up. So what's behind this rumor of Jim Bianco turned bullish? Are you bullish and believing in stocks, or do you think the market's broken in a way that makes prices go up?

Jim Bianco: I think it's more of the latter, that the market is somewhat, you know, I don't know if I'd call it broken, but it was around late May into the middle of June I started talking about all of the money printing that the central bank was doing. Initially, I thought, okay, this will give you a Pavlovian response that they're doing money printing and that the markets would go up. And they did, you know, through April and May, but then they didn't stop. And I started looking at the, the extent of the money printing, and I said, this is going to be a more powerful force than we think it's going to be, and that is going to drive markets higher. And so just like Snider would argue, I would say Yeah, I think markets are going up because of the money printing, but I am not arguing here comes the economy back, here comes earnings back, let's break out into a chorus of God Bless America, everything is great.

No, I, I think there are a lot of problems. Or to say the same thing, there is the economy and the fundamentals, and then there is the markets, and let's not confuse the two.

And right now I do think it is not only money printing because I don't want to stick it all in the central bank, but I also think that it's also got another factor in there too, and that is that you've got the federal government promising. When Trump is tweeting out, we're going to bail out our airlines and we're going to bail out our cruise ships and everybody's going to get money and stimulus checks and I'll do it by executive order if I have to, I understand why the markets are going higher, and I suspect that until something changes, that's what they're gonna continue to do.

Bianco: Coronavirus case peaks and lockdown trade-offs

Erik Townsend: Jim, I've gotten a lot of credit in the world of finance for being one of the earliest people on the coronavirus crisis to see what was coming. There's only a few people that were earlier than me, and you're one of them. You and Dr. Chris Martenson come to mind. Give us an update. What are you seeing now? You've been watching this thing since before I, I was in January. Your charts and graphs have been the best in the industry in terms of tracking What do you see? What conclusions do you draw? How do we interpret where we stand now in the story of the global coronavirus pandemic?

Jim Bianco: Well, a couple of things. It appears— I'll say it this way— it appears that the virus is an indoor virus. Wherever you get people that congregate indoors seems to be where you get some kind of a case count rise. So in February, March, April, that was in the Northern Hemisphere when it was cold outside and everybody was inside.

When you get into May, June, July, that is in the southern hemisphere where it's unbelievably hot outside and everybody goes and seeks the shelter of air conditioning. And so that's been where you've seen the rise in cases. Now lately, it seems like we might be having a peak in the case count in the United States. It looks like it peaked about 10 days to 2 weeks ago. The one exception to that might be the upper Midwest. Where I'm located in Chicago, right in the middle of it, there seems to be a rise in cases there, but it's at from a low level. But there's a bigger drop in cases in places like Florida, Arizona, California, and Texas as well too.

Away from the United States, the two countries that seem to be most problematic are Mexico, which might have also been promoting the case counts in Texas as well too, and India. In fact, India is getting set to pass the United States since. Early June, the United States has led in the number of at least reported cases every day.

But we're just a few thousand away from India overtaking the United States to become the country that is getting the largest number of cases on a daily basis. So they continue to be there too. South Africa is another country as well. So it looks like we're possibly worldwide peaking at around the 250,000 case level a day as well too.

And on the good news front, while there's been an uptick in the number of deaths both worldwide and in the US, we, we've been well over 1,000, about 1,200 a day right now is what we've been averaging. It is a lot smaller in terms of the number of confirmed cases to deaths, even on a lagged basis, than we saw back in the spring. And that's probably due to better medical techniques, better understanding of the virus from where we were in March, and also a lower age that is getting the virus now. It's no longer people in their 70s or 80s. It's a lot of people in their 40s and 50s that don't have the comorbidities and that they are able to fight it off. But that I said, let me give one warning here or one caveat.

A lot of people think that the only statistic that matters is deaths. Okay, people get sick, and so less people are dying, so that's good. And that is good, but this is a disease you definitely don't want to get because there— while there's not been formal studies, there's been a lot of informal studies showing that people that get this disease, they could take months to get over this, and they could just be in a brain fog for weeks on end and be sick and just have all kinds of problems. This is not the flu. You get it, you feel like crap for a week, you get over it, you move on with your life. You get this, you feel like crap for a week, and it takes a lot of people 2 or 3 months before they start to really feel normal. So let's not discount that this is not a serious disease.

It very much is.

Erik Townsend: Jim, one of the other people that has been really prescient on this is our mutual friend, Dr. Chris Martenson. Now, to my surprise, Chris seemingly kind of changed his tune, or maybe it would be more accurate to say the best analysts change their view when the data changes, and Chris is changing his view. He has a video that was published just Tuesday of this week, August 4th. The title of that one is Lockdowns: Doing More Harm Than Good, and we've got it linked in your Research Roundup email.

Jim, what Dr. Martenson is saying here is he's saying, look, everybody's got this perception that the U.S. is going through its second wave of coronavirus. And what he's saying is when you really dig into the data, that's not true. What happened was the New York City tri-state area had its first wave a few months ago, and it peaked, and it came down, and it stayed down. There has been no resurgence in that area. What happened, according to Dr. Martenson, is there are other very high population density areas of the United States, like California, Texas, and Florida, which really hadn't yet had their first wave, and they have just had their first wave.

But the point is, the way he's evaluating this data is really there's one really big wave of COVID-19 coronavirus crisis that needs to happen in any geographical area. Once it's happened, it seems like it's kind of done in that area. And there— as much as people thought there would be a second wave, he's saying we're not really seeing those second waves. What we're seeing is the first wave happening in different subgeographies of the same country, in this case the United States.

Now, it was very interesting to watch his video because he's saying what he thinks it means for the United States is things are probably better than we thought. But ironically, for countries like Australia that were standing up as the pinnacle of one of the best-managed countries in the world, he's saying, wait a minute, they, they did such a good job with their lockdown, or such an effective job with their lockdown being early, that they prevented the first wave, which might be something that's just inevitable, and they may have done nothing more than to delay something which is still going to happen. So he has some concern for where Australia, previously perceived to be one of the best-managed COVID-19 countries, was headed, and he's becoming more optimistic for some of the worst places like the United States and Europe because he's got a different spin on the data.

I know you saw that video. What do you make of it? Do you agree? Do you disagree? Is Dr. Is Dr. Martenson missing anything? Do you see anything differently?

Jim Bianco: No, I largely agree with it. I mean, you know, what he was arguing in the video is something that I've seen in the data too. If you go into a lockdown and you restrict mobility and you demand that people wear masks and social distance and not congregate in groups, it largely works to hold down the virus spread. But the economic cost and pain is so high to do a lockdown. That it almost becomes that the cure is worse than the disease.

And the lockdown will only delay but not end. So in a country like Australia, they go into a lockdown, guess what? They've got no cases. Well, they can't let their economy collapse all the way to zero, so they back off on the lockdown and then their wave 1 reappears. It just comes right back as soon as you let off on the lockdown.

And I think what he was saying is something that I've been arguing too. This is a serious disease and we need to take it serious and we need to wear masks and social distance and do all of the things that— wash our hands and do all the things we're supposed to do. But we have to learn to live with it. We have to learn to deal with it. As long as we do not overrun the healthcare system— that was the original intent of lockdowns, was to keep the, the bed counts from going above 100% of available beds, then we just have to learn to deal with this and maybe make appropriate situations for older people and people with comorbidities. But if we're going to go into lockdown and say that that's all we could do, we can never leave it. We can never leave a lockdown unless there is a highly effective vaccine. And there might not be one for months, if not years, if ever.

Because the latest thing that they're talking about with a vaccine now is it might be only 50% effective, and that might be not enough to actually end a lockdown as well. So I agree with the idea that this is a serious disease and that once it runs its case, like you see in New York City or you see in the— in a lot of the northern European countries, that it's been hard to see another rise in case counts, that we need to weigh that against the damage that we're doing to the economy. in terms of lockdowns, and that that damage might be greater than what we're trying to prevent with trying to stop the spread of the disease.

Bianco: Economy versus markets and the wealth effect

Erik Townsend: Jim, I wanna go a little further on that point and come back to something you said when we were talking about the stock market, which is to distinguish the difference between what's happening in markets and what's happening in the economy. So a mistake that I made, and I think a lot of people made, was when we saw stocks starting to recover, we said, ah, just a bear market rally. You know, we know there's further to go to the downside. For stocks here because this is a serious problem. Turns out that the central bank policy reaction is so strong that it seems like stocks really are recovering, and we are seeing a V-shaped stock market recovery. At least so far, that's what we're seeing out of this coronavirus crisis. I think that's leading a lot of people to the assumption that, okay, so that means that the stock market always leads the economy, so the economy is going to recover V-shape from the coronavirus crisis as well.

Is that true, or is there a big fallacy there that we need to understand?

Jim Bianco: Oh, I think there's a big fallacy there. And I think, first of all, let's talk about the economy. The signs are that the economy did recover from the 2nd quarter slowdown, the -32.9% annualized, annualized GDP. But about mid-June, it seemed to have stalled in terms of its recovery. The initial claims numbers bottomed out and started to creep higher. The mobility numbers, the OpenTable numbers showing restaurant reservations, the Homebase numbers showing the amount of activity among small businesses, all kind of stalled. I'm not going to say reversed, but they stalled. They've stalled well below the pre-virus levels. So we never quite made it all the way back in terms of where we were going from there. And in our work, when we look at it, if you break it down by state and you look at the states that are seeing a resurgence of the virus versus the states that are not, it seems like there's a very strong correlation between where the virus is resurging and the states that are seeing more and more slowing of the economy, meaning that while the governors of those states didn't lock them down, people in those regions know what's going on.

We see that our case count in my state or my city is going up and they react in kind. They say, okay, it's getting bad here, I'm going to self-quarantine myself or I'm going to travel less or do less economic activity. And you see that in the data when their case counts have stayed low, they've seemed to have risen a little bit more. That's what's happening in the economy.

Let's talk about what's happening in the markets. The markets have been recovering because of central bank intervention, And again, I want to also put the federal government in there too with all of the stimulus that they have been plowing into the into the markets as well.

But there's a fallacy there, and that fallacy is the wealth effect. In fact, Jay Powell said this again in his last press conference last week. If we put a I'm going to paraphrase what he said. If we put a floor in markets and markets recover, that will help the economy recover. What he's saying is they have completely believed in the wealth effect. In other words, let me say this bluntly: no market can ever be overvalued because if we shove a stock market or a bond market into the stratosphere, they then expect that people will feel wealthy because of that increased wealth, spend more money, be more economically active. To justify those higher prices.

And that is what is driving the whole idea behind what the Federal Reserve and the government is doing. The way that we're going to increase economic activity is to make you feel wealthier through higher prices.

Now that's backwards. You and I have been taught that the way that it works is we hire a bunch of analysts And they look at the economy, they look at a stock or a security independently and come up with an intrinsic value. Then they compare it to what the financial markets are offering as the price for that security to determine whether or not it represents an overvalued or undervalued situation.

In other words, the economy drives the markets. The Fed has turned that around and is saying the markets drive the economy. And that's where I think they're going to get themselves into trouble over the long haul, is that this whole idea that if we push markets enough, we're going to work on it, it's going to work in the short term, the short term being several months, which is what we talked about at the beginning, which is why I think markets are going to go higher.

But I do fear that that is not the way that it usually works. I don't start my day by deciding how much I'm worth by my portfolio and then adjusting my behavior. I start my day by looking at how I'm doing in my career and in my business, and hopefully that is reflected in my portfolio. It works the other way around.

And I fear that what we're going to see over time is malinvestment. Malinvestment meaning that we're propping up a bunch of companies that shouldn't be propped We're going to see inflation, and we're going to see problems on the line. Now, I don't think that's going to be a 2020 problem. I think that's going to be a 2021 problem, or maybe a 2022 problem as we move forward from here. So I I do worry that you know we got to look at what the economy is doing. It stalled in mid-June.

There is a V bottom in the stock market, but do not assume that the V bottom in the stock market. will immediately translate to a V-bottom in the broader economy. Because if you do, then you're arguing that what drives everything is the wealth effect. How wealthy do I feel is what drives my— is how it drives it. Usually it works the other way, not going in that direction.

Bianco: Fed endgame, QE, the TGA and MMT

Erik Townsend: Jim, it sounds like we are in strong agreement that markets are V-shaped recovering because of central bank policy. The economy is not V-shaped recovering. What concerns me a lot is, you know, as much as you and I agree that it's central bank policy driving this market, frankly, a lot of mainstream finance guys think that's a conspiracy theory, and they believe in what they've been trained in, which is the S&P 500 is a leading economic indicator. If the market is recovering, the reason is because the market is predicting a recovery in the economy. And I would make the argument that what's really going on here is central bank policy is distorting the efficacy of what were previously very reliable leading economic indicators, in this case the stock market indicating where the economy is headed. I think that leads, as you say, to malinvestment, a lot of bad decisions.

Let's talk about the central bank policy that gets us here. How do we get to this? It feels to me Like somehow because of this crisis, all of a sudden, hey, trillion dollars here, a trillion dollars there, it's nothing. We'll just expand the Fed's balance sheet in ways that even in the era of quantitative easing for the last 10 years, the magnitude of change that we're seeing now. When QE2 was introduced, oh my gosh, it was really, really big. Then all of a sudden in this latest round, we're talking about $650 billion.

Jim Bianco: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: per week at one point that we were going to. So it's a whole new order of magnitude. And it seems like each new round is a new order of magnitude bigger. When does this ever end and what does it potentially lead to? What's the endgame here?

Jim Bianco: Well, I think the endgame is gonna be, let me say this, we're on the precipice of a major change in economic thought one way or the other. You know, when you talked about QE being really big, you know, QE2, when it was announced in 2011, was $600 billion. And people were blown away by that size. You're right.

Erik Townsend: That was for the whole thing.

Jim Bianco: The whole week. Yes. Yes. And then in 2020, we were doing that per week. You know, just like I'll give you another statistic. We've talked a lot about the $600 a week that we're giving everybody in unemployment benefits. Do you know what the number was in 2009 that had everybody freaked out? It was $25 a week is what it was in 2009. It's 24 times larger this time. Around than it was before as well too. So we're doing everything in bigger and bigger mode, and that's because the central bank believes that they had a successful outcome in 2009. They stepped in with all of this massive stimulus and they stimulated us out of a financial crisis, or maybe we were coming out of it anyway because we were 2 years into it, and they believed that it worked and they believed that they could do that again.

Now, what I mean by that we're on the precipice of a major economic thought is that one of two things is going to happen. Either, as I've teased before, I think it leads to malinvestment and/or inflation in the next year or two, and then these policies get repudiated because they've made things worse, or worse yet, they've created massive inequality, which is what they're probably doing in a big way right now. Or when Ben Bernanke testified before Congress last week, he said there will be no inflation. This will be just fine. And when Jay Powell testifies, he says we're doing these extraordinary actions. But then when when everything calms down, we're going to put these tools back in the toolbox. No, you're not. If you're going to do this, and all you think is going to happen is higher prices, more wealth. A good feeling of everything is fine, more jobs, more GDP, only good things, no bad things like inflation or malinvestment.

This is the new world we live in.

Let me give you one statistic. The Treasury's general account, the TGA, is the checking account of the federal government. Typically, they keep about a week's worth of operating profits in that account. So that's about $200-300 billion. As of the end of July, it had $1.8 trillion with a T in it because of all of the massive borrowing and the $3 trillion deficit. Yes, we've run a $3 trillion deficit through the year ending in June. The July numbers will be out in about 10 days. And so we've ballooned that account up to $1.8 trillion from an old peak of $200 or $300 billion. How big is that number?

All of the 1040 tax returns in the last year have generated to the Treasury about $1.4 to $1.6 trillion in tax receipts. They are sitting with their Treasury general account with a year's worth of tax receipts in that account. If all good stuff is happening, you can borrow and the central bank can print and buy that paper, and you could create out of thin air a whole year's worth of tax receipts without anything bad happening, then great, let's go full MMT.

Let's put Stephanie Kelton in charge of everything. And the first act we're going to do is we're going to eliminate the 1040 form. We don't need it anymore. We've just borrowed a whole year's worth of taxes. And so this is going to be the new way we're going to do stuff.

The new way the Fed is going to operate is they're going to be in the permanent market manipulation business buying ETFs. Buying corporate bonds, buying municipal bonds as well too. That's going to be their job under MMT. And I do think MMT's got an argument here, is that they would argue that the you can't borrow forever. They kind of get that bad rap, and even Jay Powell kind of tagged that to them. That they say that you can borrow forever. No, they say you can borrow an extraordinarily large amount, but at some point you create inflation. And their argument is. The way you really deal with an inflationary problem is you raise taxes. So in their world, interest rates are low and stable somewhere around zero and never move. The tax rate goes up and down and fluctuates like with the cycle of the economy—the opposite of what we have now. Interest rates go up and down and fluctuate with the cycle of the economy, and tax rates never move.

So if we can pull this off, we can we can borrow trillions of dollars. And only good stuff happens, then MMT's won and we should go full MMT.

But if it doesn't and it creates malinvestment and inflation, and that's my bet that that's what we'll see, then we're going to have a repudiation of these policies. What I think is going to be the least likely outcome is what Jay Powell said. He says what he plans on doing. I'm going to come in with all these extraordinary tools and I'm going to single-handedly fix everything. And once it's fixed, I'm going to go away.

No, you're going to come in with all these tools and you're either going to make it worse and then you're going to go away, or you're going to fix everything and then that's going to be the new way we're going to operate under an MMT world. You're not going to go away if it's all good, but you'll be asked to go away if it's all bad. And so I think that either way, we're going to wind up with some kind of a major rethinking of economic theory.

Bianco: Repudiation versus free money; inflation as the test

Erik Townsend: Okay, wait a minute, Jim, because the way this is falling on my ears, uh, it sounds awfully polarized. I'm hearing you say there's 2 choices here, could go either way. Option one is we repudiate the policies which have been very damaging. What it takes to get there is you've got to get a significant portion of the broad population to understand the intricacies of why the creation of M0 money supply didn't translate to bank lending. spending that expanded M1 money supply and all of this central banking theory concept stuff that geeks like you and I think are interesting, but most people would just glaze over. Option 2 is you sell everybody on the idea that there should be more free stuff and free money for everybody.

I got a feeling the second one's gonna sell better. Am I missing something there?

Jim Bianco: No, the second one will sell better because that's why I said the second one is you created all this free money and free stuff and nothing bad happened. So why are you going to stop? The first one, yeah, you're right. I'm not going to geek out about the velocity of money and all of that other stuff that no one understands. And heck, most economists don't really understand it as well too. I think the way that the public will understand that will be inflation. It will be that the inflation, which has not been a case for probably 30 years, returns in a big way. And how do I know that inflation will return in a big way? If I'm the public, interest rates will go up and go up a lot.

Now, the central bank is a powerful force that they can suppress markets and interest rates. As we pointed out, they were buying $600 billion a week in March of bonds. They have bought $3 trillion of bonds since March, an astounding number that they've bought, and they can suppress interest rates.

But there is one group that is larger than them. Them, and that is the collective of the financial markets. Right now we don't have a collective of financial markets. We've got a lot of different opinions in the markets. Some are bullish, some are bearish, some think spreads are going to widen or tighten, in, out, up, down, forward or backward.

So in that environment, when the market is fragmented in its opinion, the central bank rules. But if we get inflation and everybody in the market gets of one mind, Here comes inflation. The Fed's policy is creating it. I have to get away from this market because it's a loss of money to own a fixed income asset in a rising inflation environment, and they all start to sell. They can overwhelm the central bank then, and you would see rising interest rates.

So how do you get the public to repudiate this? They see inflation. They see higher interest rates. That should translate into lower risk markets, meaning the stock market. Market as well too. That's how you get your repudiation of these policies. But you're right, if you stand at the street corner and start talking about, you know, showing people the charts of the velocity of money and that this is all going to end bad, you know, they're going to want to take you to the loony bin right now. No one wants to hear that. Everything is getting— the stock market is getting better. We're hoping that everything is going to get better right now. It's only when it has turned bad that you will see that repudiation.

Erik Townsend: Well, let's take that a little bit farther, Jim. What happens— let's suppose that what sells to the guy on the street corner is not the velocity of money chart, but it is rather the, the list of bullet points of free college tuition, forgiveness of previous student loans, there's going to be increased social benefits for everybody, there's going to be universal basic income That is considered a basic human right, so everybody gets a working wage whether they're working or not. All of these things are going to be delivered. Stephanie Kelton is going to be in charge of the Fed, and their strategy, as you said earlier, is as soon as inflation starts to run away, what they do is they punitively tax the rich in order to arrest inflation. And those SOBs deserved it anyway.

Let's, let's give that And that's got some credit. There is some legitimate thinking behind that. The aggressive taxation of the wealthiest taxpayers would have some effect on muting inflation. What's wrong with that strategy? Why shouldn't we let Stephanie Kelton take over the Fed and be in charge of a whole new era of economic policy, which does deliver all of these benefits of socialism and apparently do it without any adverse consequence. What goes wrong? Why does it go wrong? And how does it go wrong?

Jim Bianco: Well, it's inflation that makes it go wrong. If the answer is let's give everybody free stuff and let's just do what we've been doing, and to some extent we've already got that experiment working, we're giving $600 a week to everybody who's unemployed. We've been sending $1,200 checks out to everybody who's, who makes less than $100,000 a year.

And as I look at the financial markets, I don't see them particularly upset with this policy, meaning that we've got this massive budget deficit in order to finance this, and the bond market and the stock market doesn't seem to be particularly upset. So if that continues to be that the markets aren't upset, they'll continue to send that money out. Now you get inflation, and you're right, all the rich SOBs raise their taxes. Well, what we're assuming here is it's It's, oh, well, we're going to raise their taxes for one year, drain some money out, hold down the inflation rate, and then it's going to go back down.

But if instead we raise their taxes and we have to keep raising their taxes or keep them at a high level to try and hold down inflation, then we're back to the 1940s or 1950s when we had a 91% marginal tax rate at its peak in the, in the late 1940s. It retards investment, it retards growth, it retards business formation, and the public sees, okay, you've given me enough money so that my Netflix account is free, I can order a couple of fun things from Amazon, but I don't have a job, I don't have any purpose, I don't have any opportunity to really move forward from here. This is not enough for me to continue to want to say that this is a good idea.

And the rich are going to say, I can't create new businesses in this environment. I can't create investment and opportunities in this environment as well too.

So it really comes down to inflation. If inflation comes back, then your response would have to be that these policies are not working. If Bernanke is right and there will not be inflation, and he was emphatic about that last month, then we're not going to stop doing this. Why should we stop doing Why should we give everybody free stuff and there's no inflation and there's nothing bad? Why would you stop it? You're not going to. You're going to continue to do it in that regard. So it really comes down to that whole inflation argument. And that's why I said either way, we're either going to get inflation or something bad from these policies. And that's my bet. But I'm trying to be open-minded to say, look, if I'm wrong on that and we don't get this inflation and this bad stuff and it's all good, I don't see why we would say, okay, we're only going to give you free stuff in a pandemic.

But now that the pandemic's over, you don't get free stuff. No, you're going to keep giving it to me all the time. That's where we're going to go. So I think that it really is about inflation. And I think if it comes back, it's not going to be, we're just going to jack taxes on them for one year and that will get rid of the inflation problem. It might be that we're going to have to jack taxes up a lot and leave them there in order to deal with the inflation problem. And that will create a whole host of problems.

Erik Townsend: And what are those problems and how does that affect the person who, you know, hey, tax the rich, the hell with it. with them. I'm not the rich. Let them pay the bill. It's about time that they paid their fair share. What can go wrong for the guy on the street as a result of that taxation policy?

Jim Bianco: What you're giving them is something on the margin. You're giving them UBI, universal basic income, a couple of hundred bucks a week, maybe $1,000 a month if you go full Andrew Yang as well too. And that helps them. Like I said, you pay for your Netflix account, you go out to dinner with your family a little bit, put a little bit away in savings. As well, and that helps. But what it's assuming is I also have a job.

I also have a job and a purpose as well too, that this on top of that would help. You know, backing off on college tuition costs or making college tuition free, that's great. Once my kids get to 18 years old, that would help as well too. So all of that helps at the margin, assuming I have a job. But if all of this creates such dislocation in financial markets that it imperils the ability of me to have a job in the first place, then you become a net loser on this. Yeah, they give you $1,000 a week and a couple of other things as well too. Maybe they'll throw in free internet, you know, to kind of get you all excited. But I would rather have a job than to have free internet, $1,000 a week, if I had to choose between the two. But what they're trying to promise you now is you can have both a job and all of this extra stuff as well too.

And that is what we're going to have to find out whether or not that is sustainable. For the moment, for the moment, it appears to be that it is because the markets are not rejecting this policy. But I do think that as we move forward from here, I think that it might start to, especially when the calendar turns to 2021.

Erik Townsend: Before moving on from this topic, I just want to mention I would love nothing more than to get Dr. Stephanie Kelton on the show to tell her side of this story. We have invited her several times. She hasn't responded to our invitations. I do have a reputation for, for really allowing my guests to tell their story without interrupting them or arguing with them. If anyone in the audience has Dr. Kelton's ear, please encourage her to accept our invitation and come tell her story on Massil. MacroVoices. I would love to interview her and really get into this in detail.

Bianco: Treasury yields and yield curve control

Erik Townsend: Jim, let's move on to your specialty of fixed income markets. Based on this very tentative, you know, the big risk is inflation, but it looks like it's not happening yet, but it could happen. It could happen in a big way, but not yet. How do we translate that to what to expect in terms of bond yields?

Jim Bianco: Let me start off with the bigger picture. March 9th was an extraordinary day in the bond market. And you saw the 10-year yield hit an intraday low of 31 basis points. You saw the 30-year hit an intraday low of 69 basis points. For those that are not steeped in the bond market right now, we're at 55 basis points in the 10-year and we're at 1.21% in the 30-year. So we're well off those levels, but they've been trending lower.

The Fed has been buying a lot of bonds. They're the largest buyer of bonds. And I think it's just been a mere lack of selling by the public, and that is what's been giving you that downtrend in bonds as well too. I would argue about 2 things about the bond market.

One, what we talked about earlier, do not think that what's happening in the bond market is a reflection of economic activity or a belief about economic activity. The central bank is so distorting in the bond market right now that yes, yields are going low because they're buying them, But I'm not ready to make the leap that that means that the economy is doing X or Y or Z. I think it's more about about the central bank as well too. So I I could see yields kind of meandering lower, but I don't see them taking out those March ninth lows. I think the 39-year bull market ended on March ninth with those lows. At most, maybe we retest them, but that's about it at this point.

I do see that, like we've talked about before, a resurgence of inflation and that the risk is of higher yields, not of negative yields as we go forward from here. I think that the risk is that interest rates go up once everybody gets their mind around it. And yes, we overwhelm the central bank.

When interest rates start up, they will probably announce some version of yield curve control. That's nothing more than price fixing. That is where, you know, take what the Bank of Japan calls yield curve control. They have said that they want to target— I'm talking about the Bank of Japan now— their 10-year yield at zero, and that they will step in and buy as much as necessary to push rates down to zero. If they go below zero, they stop buying to let them drift back up to zero. Our central bank would do something similar when we get into a rising rate environment, but if that comes because of inflation, then I don't think that they alone can stop it if the market is of all one mind. So yields trend lower a little bit, but the next big move is up into next year is what I'm thinking about. On the back of inflation is where it comes, and the central bank will try and fight that along the way.

But if it comes with higher yields on the back of inflation, I don't think they'll be successful.

Bianco: Dollar weakness and reserve-currency status

Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the US dollar and what happens to the dollar relative to other currencies in the face of everything that we see For years now, there's been a group of people— I'll say Luke Gromen, in my mind, is probably the best spoken of the bunch— who hold the view that the US dollar's days are numbered as the global reserve currency. And their expectation is that the dollar is eventually going to devalue dramatically against other currencies in the same way that the pound sterling did after it lost its reserve currency status. And they don't see just a little bit of down in the dollar, they see huge down in the dollar. You know, I've always said I fully predict that Luke Gromen and others will be proven right in that someday, but there's got to be a viable alternative to the US dollar to serve as the global reserve currency before that can happen. And I've always thought those guys were early.

Now we're seeing a pretty darn significant downside momentum event in the US Dollar Index. Is this that Luke Gromen moment where we're seeing the beginning of the end, or is this just a knee-jerk and it's still too early for Luke to be proven right?

Jim Bianco: I, I'd say it's too early, and I would also lean on that it is not that moment. I think what's happening with the dollar is during the, the height of the panic in March and in April, You had people viewing the dollar as a safe haven currency. You had tremendous flows to the dollar. You even had the central banks start dollar swap lines to try and meet that excess demand for the dollar. That is reversing right now. That people are now saying, "I don't need to own dollars as a hedge against the end of the world," and that they've been moving out of it. And that's why you've seen the dollar weaken. This. As far as the dollar losing its reserve currency status, I've been astounded by the number of stories that says, well, the dollar's going down, it's going to lose its reserve currency status. To who?

We're going to get out of one fiat currency because the central bank is printing money recklessly called the dollar and go into another fiat currency where the central bank is recklessly printing money called the euro or the yen? You know, if you're talking about is the dollar going to go down If you asked if you drew that larger against all fiats, yes, because that's why you're seeing the price of gold rise and maybe the price of commodity other general commodities rise. I'm with you there that it's going to go up against those and maybe even against the price of cryptos.

But to argue that it's going to swap from one fiat, the dollar, to another fiat, the euro, other than on a tactical basis because we're unwinding. That flight to quality trade, which is what I think we've been doing lately. Yes, that'll happen. But I don't think it's the sign that we're going to move to a new reserve currency.

The next reserve currency, I believe, will be a crypto. I don't think that crypto exists right now, but it's not going to be pick among the existing fiat currencies. That's going to be the next reserve currency, either the euro, the yen, the yuan, take your pick. I think they're all equally bad is what's basically what I'm trying to say. That's not your fix. So I see this as a cyclical move that's more of an unwind of what we saw in March when we saw that dollar strength. Then I see this as some kind of a terminal move.

All of the fiats will go down against cryptos and against like gold, which I heard somebody once described as the natural crypto, which I love that description. I think that those will go up in price and they have, and I think that they will continue to But I don't see this as being some kind of a massive shift out of dollars and into euros or yen or British pounds or some other fiat.

Bianco: A Silicon Valley digital reserve currency

Erik Townsend: Jim, you just touched on a subject that's very much near and dear to my heart because I published a book called Beyond Blockchain back in 2018 predicting that the US dollar would eventually be replaced by a digital global reserve currency. Now, I want to touch on when you say a crypto exactly what you mean by A crypto, because as I see it, there's 3 possibilities for what could replace the US dollar as global reserve currency. Could be a first-generation cryptocurrency like Bitcoin or Ethereum that was invented by anarchists whose goal was to create an alternative to government-issued money. The second possibility would be it could be a government-issued digital currency, a central bank digital currency, or CBDC. CBDC. As they've come to be called, which I had anticipated in my book. And then a third possibility would be some Silicon Valley billionaire, like certainly we saw the beginnings of this with Mark Zuckerberg's foray into the digital currency world with Facebook's Libra project, which has been shut down at least for now, but you never know, you know, what Google's working on that they haven't told us about.

Maybe Silicon Valley comes up with a digital currency, which they've designed for the purpose of replacing the dollar. And it's not designed to appeal to libertarian, you know, Bitcoin enthusiasts. It's more designed to appeal to central bankers who are sick of the dollar's monopoly over reserve currency status. Of those 3, or invent your own if there's a 4th one, what kind of digital currency do you think potentially replaces the dollar long-term? I think it's the third one.

Jim Bianco: I think it's going to be some kind of a Silicon Valley type of operation. You're right. The first one in Bitcoin and in what the anarchists invented is more of a store of value, but it cannot be really a medium of exchange because I don't think we're quite there yet to be able to handle hundreds of thousands of transactions a minute if you wanted to make it a true medium of exchange. Okay. Reserve currency.

If we're going to get rid of the dollar, I think it is part and parcel that it is repudiation of government running a currency, and that going to another government running a currency is not going to be the answer. So when people talk about that there's going to be a digital yuan or a digital euro or digital dollar, that's not going to fix anything. That's just changing— taking the same problem and just changing its stripes.

The third option you gave me, the Silicon Valley, they're looking at whether it's in the DeFi area or they're looking in some of these other areas at some kind of a stable currency, stablecoin actually exists, that can be used in massive numbers to as a medium of exchange. And remember that we already have all of the ingredients to make this work.

So maybe you've got a Google trying to cook up this thing within their area of expertise. You've got a Facebook that's got 2 billion plus users of Facebook. As the professor, New York University Professor Scott Galloway likes to say, remember that there's 2.2 billion Christians on the planet and there's 2.3 billion people that have a Facebook account. Facebook is more popular than Christianity right now. So if you come up with something that either Facebook comes up with it with their Libra project or Google comes up with with it. You've got widespread adoption through Facebook, and then you've got Amazon, which Amazon is, is what, 60% of the American public has an Amazon Prime account. So as soon as you give them something that they could use, if Amazon accepts it as payment, it's immediately got legitimacy to it almost overnight as well too. But that's where I see it, I see it Now, are they working on that idea? Yes, I think they are working on that idea.

Is it imminent that's going to come out? I don't know if it's imminent that it's going to come out, but I think it's a lot closer than we think it could be.

Finally, I'll mention one other thing too. When you talk to Americans and you say about a digital currency, whether it's backed by the government or not, as being the new reserve currency, a lot of people roll their eyes and say, oh, that's not going to work. But bear in mind that Americans have among the among the developed world and even parts of the developing world the lowest percentage of digital payment usage that we've seen anywhere else.

In Kenya, they've got a thing called M-Pesa where these people live in mud huts in little villages and they all have they all have smartphones. It's the 3rd generation smartphones we gave away 2 years ago. And they all at night, they're all being hooked up to a Honda generator charging these 100 phones. They transfer money back and forth to each other through this M-Pesa platform in Kenya. They transfer money back and forth to each other in India. They transfer money back and forth to each other through their phones in Europe in greater numbers than the United States. So we might talk to people and go, yeah, but I just pulled this $20 out of my pocket. Why would I need this digital currency? But the rest of the world's ready for it. You just got to give, you know, we just got to invent the platform.

They'll adopt it and then they'll force us to adopt it much faster. But if we're waiting for a 50-something in the United States to say, I'm going to stop using those 20s in my wallet for a currency, that's not where it's going to come from.

They'll be the last one to adopt it because everybody else will force that on them. So that's where I see the next reserve currency coming right now. Like I said, I don't think we're there yet, but that's where it's going to come I just wanna emphasize, I just don't buy this argument that we're all gonna basically bail on the dollar for the euro. I don't think that fixes anything. I think you just transfer from one to the other and you still got the same problems that you had with the dollar. You're just using a different currency and you haven't really made it much better.

Erik Townsend: Well, once again, Jim, we are exactly on the same page. When I first wrote my book in 2018, I was leaning a little bit more toward the central bank bank-issued digital currency, a sovereign digital currency replacing the dollar. But the more that I've seen, the more I'm convinced it comes from Silicon Valley. And I'll just add the caution to our many crypto enthusiasts in the audience. Those of you guys who just roll your eyes and laugh off something like Libra, saying it's not decentralized, it doesn't meet the design objectives that are valued by cryptocurrency designers, you've got to understand that they have different design objectives. They're trying to solve a different problem. Never underestimate the ability of a sociopathic child billionaire to screw the world up. And I'm really glad that Libra got shut down. I think that we are not done seeing Silicon Valley invent digital currencies with the ambition of replacing the dollar as the world's global reserve currency.

And I think that the problems that that creates in terms of people in Silicon Valley having even more power than they already have over society really need to be taken seriously.

Bianco: Why gold goes higher

Erik Townsend: Anyway, that's a subject for another podcast. We can't end this one, Jim, without touching on gold.

Jim Bianco: Higher. I think gold is going to go higher. Gold is largely a way to get your money out of the financial system. Now, it's not a perfect fit. You know, it's still tied up in the financial system somewhat. The most popular way to own gold is through an ETF like GLD. And so you're still trapped in the financial system when you do it, but it's the way you get your money out. Now, why do you want to get your money out of the financial system? You fear inflation, you fear deflation, you fear financial crisis, you fear all of the above. Something is not right. That's why you try to get your money out of the financial system. That's why I think gold has been going higher. Lastly, When I look at the measures of speculation, either the Commitments of Traders Report or the flows into ETFs or even the shape of the forward gold futures curve, it's, you know, there's some signs of speculation.

It's not absent, but it's also at a new all-time high, but it's not out of hand. So usually I think gold goes because what drives gold more than anything else is demand. People want it or they don't want it. And right now they want it, and it's going up and it's making new highs. And when I look at the signs of speculation, I say they're not out of hand right now, so it's going to continue to go higher until such time that it does become out of hand. I don't know if that's in 2 weeks or in 3 years, but right now it seems to be wanting to trend higher. And if you ask me, well, what's the, the story behind it? An unease that there's some problems somewhere. They can be inflation, they can be deflation, they could be financial crisis, they could be too much money They could be all of the above, but that there is some fear of it.

And what do I do when I fear that there's problems? I try and get my money away from those problems. And it's not perfect, but the option you have is gold.

Erik Townsend: Jim, before we close, let's bring our listeners— I can't believe anybody doesn't know about biancoresearch.com and also @biancoresearch on Twitter. Tell people what they can expect to find there if they're not already tuned in.

Jim Bianco: Yeah, so we are an institutional investor service. Our clients are mainly institutional investors around the world that subscribe to us. If you go to our website biancoresearch.com, or mainly I would direct you probably to my Twitter feed @biancoresearch or LinkedIn under my name Jim Bianco. I try to post examples of what we do. There are links that you can request a free trial of our research. to kind of get under the hood and see a lot more of what we do. So go ahead and take a look at all of those venues, probably starting with Twitter, which is probably the main venue that I use. And if you like what you see, there's always a link at the top of my Twitter feed that you can request a free trial to see more of what we do in our research.

Erik Townsend: And I can't recommend it strongly enough. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Peterson and Jonathan Tepper. Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: S&P 500 futures and double-top risk

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Jim back on the show and get an update on what his thought process is. Anything that you took away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, everything really. I, I really enjoy talking to Jim. He's one of my favorite guests that we have on the show, and I, I really am in strong agreement with just about everything that he said. I want to get into more detail on some of those topics though, so let's get into our post-game chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says Big Picture Trading Chartbook. Patrick, let's go ahead and hit it here with page 2. We're looking at S&P 500 futures. Why this chart, and what are these yellow lines showing us?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, all I really just wanted to do was do an update from the last chartbook we had, just showing that we were looking at the time at the overhead resistance levels, uh, just above that 3,200 level, and the market really has just gone right through that and continues to crawl higher toward the next major resistance level, which is its previous highs. Now, will we see an all-time high? I, I think a lot of it has to do with where the leadership comes from on the market. I mean, we certainly saw very strong reaction on earnings on a number of these different FAANG stocks, and if that creates a tailwind pushing the NASDAQ to all-time be very hard for the S&P not to be dragged higher with all of that as those market cap behemoths finish off some of these bigger moves. But it is, um, the S&P is a very distinct uptrend. And one pattern that we've seen, even when I break it down, uh, to more intraday charts, is every dip is so far being bought.

And it's a very systematic process higher. And we haven't seen the technical break or the damage that are the warning signs I typically look for for a turn. And doesn't mean it can't emerge in the coming weeks, but at least at this moment, the market has been pretty systematically behaving in its upward trajectory.

Erik Townsend: Now, Patrick, there's a very well-known pattern called a double top in technical analysis. Do you see reason to think that this is about to be a double top and maybe, you know, it's, it's time to sell here, or is that not really called for with what you're seeing in the chart?

Patrick Ceresna: You know, the interesting part is, is that it's all about, I think, the way that the NASDAQ and those FAANG stocks trade. Because right now the NASDAQ looks incredibly bullish, and those breakouts that we've seen on a number of those stocks like Apple and Amazon really continue to show that the trend may continue. And if that's the case, it's going to be hard for any of these other major US indices not to get some of a tailwind from that that can push it higher if we still see a little bit more on the upside there. But what is interesting is that we're getting a lot of divergences in a lot of the other developed markets, you know, especially European equities just don't seem to be participating at all. And so really this continues to be a US-driven rally, and some of the periphery markets like the KOSPI in South Korea continues to get a lot of that tailwind from a lot of these semiconductor kind of stocks that have been working so well in this environment.

I mean, there is a chance we're going to see a double top, but at least at this moment, I think the most immediate thing that we want to watch is, are we going to, A, approach it, and 2, does the NASDAQ break out? I mean, I think those are 2 very important things to watch that will answer that question.

Postgame: US Dollar Index breakdown

Erik Townsend: Let's go ahead and move on to the US Dollar Index on page 3. Boy, look at that support level at 96 that really held reliably going back almost 18 months. And all of a sudden, once we took it out, boy, look out below. What's your take, Patrick, on what comes next here? Uh, are we gonna see a bottom here at $92.50, or are we, you know, still headed back down to $89, which looks like the previous low?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, on the daily charts, there are some short-term measured moves that are finishing right around this $93 level, more or less, which means that there could be some some short-term stall in the selling, but the breakdown here is pretty distinct. And one of the reasons I really just wanted to capture in this chart was just to show the rise and the fall of the dollar from 2016 to 2018. And, you know, for a lot of the people that are ready to put the nails in the coffin on the dollar, I mean, it wasn't that long ago that we saw a pretty significant drop in the dollar and it didn't really change anything. And so while there's no denying that there's there's a very distinct downtrend on the most immediate short term, and that may very well even drop a few more handles on the downside during the selling. But I don't know whether I'm ready to write off the dollar just yet. I think that once the selling subsides, we'll see where, where everything calms down.

But certainly this dollar selling has been the fuel that has driven a lot of the commodity bull market, particularly the movement we're seeing in gold and silver over the last little

So though, Erik, let's move on to chart 4 where we have the crude oil chart.

Postgame: Crude oil, natural gas and energy stocks

Patrick Ceresna: And really, this is where, you know, I wanted your take on this as well. Like, I was anticipating that at minimum we should have seen some backfilling, stalling of the price action, something that bring it into the mid-30s to create a buy-on-dip opportunity. But it's— it seems like the tight trade range we've seen in oil is almost unreal. It's just so tight.

It's almost boring to watch oil over the last little while, but, you know, it was sort of boring watching gold around $1,800 until it exploded. I mean, do you think that this really has the potential for a leg higher into that 4th quarter?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, that's an excellent analogy. Just as gold surprised us by consolidating longer than we thought and then really took off, you know, what I see here, the, the V-shaped recovery off of the panic Bottoms was very predictable, went higher than I thought, above $40. I thought we were going to get a meaningful downside retrace, let's say back down to $25 or $26.

That would be about the right level to be, you know, a 50 or a 61.8% Fib retrace, and then we go up from there and see the typical kind of volatility that you'd expect. I think what's going on here is people see what Art Berman sees, and they They know it's not time yet, but they know that eventually US production really is going to fall off a cliff as a result of the damage that's been done to the economy, and that that's going to push prices higher eventually. Not yet. And I really thought we would see some downside. You know, if you look at a seasonality perspective on this, August tends to be the highest month, and it's usually right around the first week of September That the market tops out and then it sells off through September and October, and eventually it's in the winter sometime that the price bottoms, or early winter.

You know, does seasonality really even matter if seasonality is driven mostly by the consumption that occurs in summer driving season, and we haven't really had a summer driving season because of the crisis? Or maybe we're done consolidating and it's up from here. But the 2 potential options options that I see. Number one, we got the rally up to $41, $42, whatever it was, consolidate, and then straight up from there. The other is a bit of a downside correction before the big move up, which might not start until the middle of Q4. It's looking more and more like this market is just looking for an excuse to move higher. So maybe we're just going to consolidate sideways until that move higher begins. I've started buying the, the short-term dips as opposed to waiting for a really big dip. You know, we may have to weather some, some volatility if I get surprised and there's a big move downside, but I was thinking before I'm going to wait for $30 before I start buying.

No, I'm not going to do that. High 30s feels like a good number to buy at, at this point.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, an interesting note is, is that natural gas has actually broken out And because of the steep contango in the curve, it— as we get into the seasonality of the winter, uh, we're going to roll up the term structure of that, uh, of that contango. It's going to drive some higher prices there. But what's also interesting is that all the, um, oil and gas stocks, the energy companies that trade on the exchanges, all of them have actually been going through quite a substantial correction over the last 2-3 months. In fact, we've seen many of them them doing full 50-plus percent retracements of their prior rises. And so it's interesting that we didn't see the correction in oil, but we certainly have seen them in energy companies. And it would be really interesting if oil broke out, whether that proved to being a, a buying opportunity on many of these energy companies that have already consolidated so much.

Postgame: 10-year Treasury yield

Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, moving on to chart 5, I have here the 10-year Treasury yield.

And Really, I don't think we have anything more to really add than what we talked about. But it's pretty interesting that the yield— and it doesn't matter that commodities are rising and even some, a little bit of inflation fears are popping up as a weak dollar tends to do that. But it doesn't seem to be at all a concern for the Treasury bond market as the yields continue to edge lower, almost like this recession that we're in is just such a powerful deflationary impulse that maybe the bond market just doesn't believe that this is enough to drive inflation. I don't know. Do you have any other insights on that?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think we've got to put this in perspective. You don't see it on this chart, but that same approximate downslope that you see from, you know, high left to low right on this chart, that doesn't just go back the 2 years or a year and a half that you've got shown on this chart. It goes back 30 years to the early '80s, you know, we were at 15 or 16% returns on Treasury bonds. So, you know, from a big picture standpoint, you're down to 53 basis points. For all intents and purposes, you've hit, you know, approximately zero. You've gone all the way from high interest rates to zero interest rate. So either that means that, okay, that's it, it's over. We got all the way to zero. You can't go any further. Right. Or we're pausing here because people think you can't go any further, and it turns out that despite what a lot of experts have said, yes, the world's reserve currency sovereign issues really can go negative in their 10-year issue.

You know, a lot of people think that's completely impossible because the U.S. dollar is the world's global reserve currency. Well, a lot of people thought it was impossible for the German Bund. to go negative on the 10-year maturity. And they were right for a while until they got proven wrong, and then they got proven a lot more wrong. So are we headed to negative US Treasury yields, or is there really a lower boundary at zero that has to be respected? That's the question on my mind. I already asked Jim Bianco today. I'll continue asking our other guests in future programs.

Postgame: Gold parabolic and blow-off top risk

Patrick Ceresna: All right, so moving on to chart 6, I have a chart here of Tesla. Tesla. Oh no, no, sorry, that's gold. Uh, but okay, so when we're looking here on gold, I mean, it's really over the last year it appears that we're almost getting into a parabolic phase of this rise as, as gold is going up. And what's particularly interesting is, is when we look at the bear market of gold, the one that lasted from 2011 through, uh, all the way to 2000, arguably to 2016 was where the real low was. But we had this long extended basing formation on gold, and really this breakout on the upside has now, based on the, the measured techniques that I use, was only targeting the initial impulse up to about $2,200 on the upside. So it's like we're at this stage where gold has accelerated and has broken to all-time highs and is doing so in this almost parabolic fashion. And while I remain much bigger picture bullish gold, the big question mark for me is, is that, uh, are we about to at least hit some intermediate high that is going to, to kind of pause gold?

And, or are we going to go into like some big extended move that could print $2,500+ in this impulse? And it's one of the bigger pieces, but to me this is, uh, pretty much already a very mature breakout. I'll explain it further when we get to the silver charts here in a moment, but did you have anything that you wanted to add on this gold chart before we move on?

Erik Townsend: Well, it really is an extension of the same thing that I've been saying since 1350 or so, and I know a lot of our listeners are sick of hearing me say it, but a healthy bull market is one that has its share of healthy corrections. And the reason those corrections are so important is they shake out the weak hands. We have a market now that's full of weak hands that have made a lot of money and have added to their positions higher and higher. And you end up with a situation where if the market starts going down significantly, there's a whole bunch of inexperienced investors who are going to panic and sell, and that's going to accelerate the downside. So there's a lot of risk resulting from this. I'm reminded of an interview I heard with Jim Rogers at least a decade ago, and this was the last time that gold was really taking off, you know, in the 2010-2011 timeframe.

And the interviewer says to Jim Rogers, you know, and he's obviously very excited and very optimistic about gold, he said, Jim, do you think that gold could move up even another $100 from here in the next few weeks? And Jim said, God, I hope not. I'd have to sell it if it did that.

And that really is what comes to mind here. We're getting to a point where this is looking more and more like a blow-off top. And I know I've been saying that for a long time and it hasn't happened, but at some point, if you get this much upside this quickly, there has to be a natural correction. So I hope that we don't get a move from here, that we're not looking at $2,300 or $2,400 gold prices in the next 2 or 3 weeks, because that's an almost sure sign of a blow-off top. What I'd much rather see is a consolidation or a correction back down to 1,800, retesting the previous breakout zone as support, and then moving higher. That's what a bull market that's healthy looks like. What we're seeing here are more and more signs of a blow-off top setting up.

Postgame: Silver history and corrections

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so what I want to do though is, is actually overlay that or show how how the chart on silver looks. And during that same cycle that we just showed on gold, where the original silver bull market from— at least on this chart— that advanced from 2009 through 2011, that kind of blow-off on the parabolic rise of silver, and that period from 2015 through to 2020 where silver just traded sideways in almost a purgatory for 5 years before we just broke out over the last month or more, and this seems like a very early-stage breakout, which is that like it's just begun.

And yet on gold, we're talking about that it seems like it's almost blowing off, and which one is going to prevail? And I wanted to use this opportunity to kind of reflect on the last major extended bull market of silver. And so on page 8, I wanted to capture that entire 2000 to 2011 bull advance in silver where we went, you know, from $4 or $5 to $50, a 1,000% rise over a decade, which was a very healthy time to have owned silver and just buying and holding it throughout that entire period. What looks like a chart, at least at first glance that kind of starts on the bottom left and ends on the top right.

I circled here a number of these advances in silver, particularly 2004, 2006, and 2008 advances that I wanted to zoom in and really demonstrate the behavior you just described, which is you were saying earlier that, you know, what's healthy in a bull market is that the rise is checked and that there's, there's the, there's these kind of pullbacks along the way. And so, uh, looking on page 9 was the first and legitimate breakout of silver in 2004.

Now, prior in 2001 through 2003, gold was already rallying those 3 years and advancing. And very similar to what we witnessed in the last few years, silver silver just didn't participate. Silver was just dogging it in a sideways range. And then in mid-2003, we saw the breakout in silver in what was a very distinct, almost parabolic rise, very much echoing the type of advance we've seen today, that saw silver pretty much run almost double. It basically went from like $4 to $8.

And in the process of doubling, everyone was so sure that was a great bull market, and it was, but it didn't stop in 2004 from that blow-off top, seeing it give back 30% of that entire rise. And we saw it pull back from $8 back down toward $5.50.

And this is a, I think, a very good example of what we may very well experience, particularly in silver, which is incredibly volatile. It doesn't mean that the gold and silver bulls that say over the next decade, the MMT and all the policies and all the debt and everything will cause inflation and gold and silver will continue to rise over the next decade. I'll agree with that. But the thing is, is that that didn't change the fact that there's going to be these corrections along the way. And I think that this is a very good example of what could potentially happen.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I couldn't agree more. And I think the big challenge we have, as you say, is the fundamentals The fundamentals are so good, so incredibly good, because it's so clear to so many people that we're headed toward a major debasement of fiat currency just around the world. The fundamentals are so good for gold that it just can't seem to stop. And the problem anytime that happens is, is, you know, the more it goes up quickly without any significant consolidation or corrections, the more that you get weak hands into the market that are eventually going to be the source of panic selling when things do turn around for whatever reason. So I really hope that we get a 30% correction in gold. We're overdue for one, and, uh, that would really make me a lot more comfortable about buying more of it. I couldn't be more excited about the long-term fundamentals, but just, you know, look at how far we've moved, how quickly here.

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, what I wanted to then do is just continue on and, and demonstrate the same characteristic over again on pages 10 and And so while again that bull market, decade-long bull market was well underway, that saw a thousand percent rise in silver over that decade, back in 2005 through 2006, silver did the same thing. It began around six seven dollars and proceeded to double, going up toward fourteen dollars an ounce. And again, another parabolic rise that followed just a few years after that 2004. Rise.

And again, the same pattern happened. It blew off a top and dropped 30%. And then when we look on page 11, this time it did again a similar scenario where in 2007 into 2008, we saw it almost double, going from, you know, $11 to $21 in a span of, of just about half a year to create that top that occurred in early 2008. And this time the correction was much deeper, probably exacerbated by the financial crisis and the liquidity event that caused probably the correction to be much deeper than it probably should have been. But there, silver dropped 50% of its value. It went from $20 back down to just under $10, and that ended up being also a compelling buying opportunity. But very similar, just echoing exactly what we've been talking about, that this bull market probably will last a decade or more into the future. But along the way, there are these corrections. And whenever we get to these short-term periods where the impulse higher is going parabolic this way, it is often that these types of mean-reverting corrections happen.

Postgame: Collars and options for gold and silver

Patrick Ceresna: And this is where, you know, our listeners need to kind of taper their short-term enthusiasm on how much more there's on the upside. It doesn't, to me, feel very asymmetric at this moment to be going into new positioning on gold and silver. And in fact, this is a, a stage where one of my favorite option strategies of collaring in on gold and silver becomes one of the most important tools in a toolbox on how to manage this. Because one of, one of the biggest advantages in gold and silver is that they don't have a fat left tail skew on their options chains. And so it's really easy to build these amazing option collars on gold and silver and continue to have further upside on them, and yet locking in the gains as you're going, allow you the conviction to stay with your positions, but yet at the same time know that you're not going to give back a chunk of your profits by holding too long.

And so that's a very healthy alternative to the, the idea of selling your long-term holdings in gold and silver. And that's currently what we're doing with our members at Big Picture Trading.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, the collar strategy is a really powerful one, but I think there's another side of this we need to talk about. We don't have time this week, so maybe we can come back to it in next week's postgame segment. And that is for people who just, you know, can't bear to not get involved here.

Maybe they didn't have enough gold or they didn't have any gold and they feel like they've missed out and they want to get in on this market. I think I think there's probably a strong argument for using an options-based strategy, at least initially, because, as you say, there is all of that significant downside. If you buy calls on gold here, you participate in the upside, but you can't lose any more than you spent on the calls. And boy, we've come up an awful long way, awful quickly. I'd also like to talk to you about some other aspects of this in terms of how much gold is too much gold. think about gold as a currency, or should we think of it as a speculative investment, and so forth? Let's come back to that in next week's postgame segment. Meanwhile, folks, if you want to see Patrick actually putting on these collar trades on gold and silver, just go to bigpicturetrading.com, check the information on page 12, sign up for your free 14-day trial of Big Picture Trading.

And, uh, you're going to have any gold and silver collar trades coming up? the next 14 days, Patrick?

Patrick Ceresna: Oh, absolutely. We're already positioning. We've been long gold and silver the entire ride up, and our priority here is how to keep the gains we've made. And that's, that's going to be what we're going to be covering in the next couple weeks for sure.

Outro and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: So keep the opportunity to participate in more upside while still locking in the gains that you've already got. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in this postgame. There's also a link to Blain's Morning Porridge titled The Gathering Wave, and a link to the Felder Report article generational opportunity in commodities. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on And we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Erik Townsend: Thank you.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please Register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have. The more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com.

And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and. do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top