Eric Peters — One River Asset Management CIO (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode open and dedication to healthcare workers

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 214 was recorded on April 9th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is dedicated to healthcare workers all over the world who without a doubt are the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com. A podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases.

One River Asset Management CIO Eric Peters returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the recent performance of the Long Volatility strategy and trend following as risk hedges and how well they've worked in protecting portfolios during the present crisis. We'll also discuss the arguments for a return to secular inflation and what that means for And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment, when we're going to go into more detail on crude oil storage, contango in the crude oil term structure, and how those 2 things are related, and where the trading opportunities lie for both futures and equity investors as we navigate these difficult times when storage is at an extreme premium.

And just a quick reminder for any listeners who are not checking the website regularly, we have produced 3 special episodes of MacroVoices earlier this week with feature-length interviews. The first was a crude oil special featuring petroleum geologist Art Berman and Professor Nate Hagens, which we published on Monday morning. The next was a brilliant appearance by Dr. Pippa Malmgren on Tuesday. Then on Wednesday, CPM Group founder Jeffrey Christian debunked some of the common myths and misconceptions about the physical precious metals markets. All of those interviews can be found free of charge on our homepage at MacroVoices.com, and our thanks go out to the listeners whose donations made this extra content possible.

S&P 500 after Powell: peak-infection rally

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, listeners, you'll— we'll have a detailed update of the COVID-19 coronavirus crisis in our postgame segment after the feature interview. Now, Erik, let's jump right into the S&P 500. Here we are at 2,800. We've got a Powell basically announcing a big stimulus and that drove the S&P right up to that 50% retracement. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, fortunately for me, I covered my S&P shorts at the futures open on Sunday evening. I didn't know what Powell was gonna do next. The reason that I had a change of heart is that I've kind of changed my mental model for how I think this coronavirus crisis is going to unfold in terms of stock market psychology. Originally, I thought, okay, people are not gonna understand exponential growth. They're going to see things getting much worse very quickly, just as we approach the peak of infections. That's going to create the greatest amount of fear and panic.

That's where the market lows are going to come in. And that would suggest the market lows happening maybe into the beginning of next week sometime. We're seeing the opposite. Why is that? I think the reason is that one of the very few things the Trump administration is doing quite well is their messaging. They're telling everybody, look, everybody, this is the week from hell. It's this week and next week. That's going to be the worst of it until we get to that point of peak infections. And because of that messaging, I think that the market is discounting that ahead of time, saying, okay, the light's there at the end of the tunnel. It's going to be really, really bad for the next week or two, but then they're saying it's going to get better. Time to start buying stocks. Now, I think that's faulty logic because frankly, we don't know for sure that we're going to hit peak infections.

That's based on other countries that frankly have done a better job. at implementing non-pharmaceutical interventions, or NPIs, which is the social distancing and various other measures which are used to contain the crisis outbreak. So I think it's quite possible that things are worse than they appear, and so maybe it's not really going to be all better after all.

And frankly, peak infections is not peak crisis. It is true from an equipment management standpoint, if you had enough ventilators to get through peak infections, then you probably got enough for the rest of the crisis. So from a logistics standpoint and overwhelming the hospital system, it's very important.

But the economy still has to stay shut down until we contain these infections and we get to no new infections, or almost no new infections. So this is not over yet. And I think that what is likely to happen, Patrick, is probably sometime next week, if the analysts' expectations are fulfilled, what we'll see is a peaking and a gradual reduction in the daily number of US cases of COVID-19 that have been detected and diagnosed. That is going to cause the market to rally very sharply. I think we'll see an acceleration of the rally that we've already seen as everybody says, okay, that's it, we're past peak infections, this thing is finally ending. That will be the sell-the-news moment, in my opinion, and I wouldn't be surprised if we get a blow-off top there.

The 61.8 Fibonacci retracement of the move down is 2,930. If you're all the way past 2,900, hey, you know, round number is kind of appealing there at 3,000. I wouldn't be surprised if we got back to 3,000 on that blow-off, but I don't think this is anything close to the end. As we'll discuss later in the postgame segment, we'll go into detail about the COVID crisis, but it's not ending just because the peak of the first wave of infections has been reached. So from an economic standpoint, this is nowhere close to over, but I think the stock market's gonna to be celebrating as if it were over when we get to that peak infection moment. And I think that's your sell-the-news opportunity.

US dollar pullback

Patrick Ceresna: Right. Well, you know, for me, at least on the S&P 500, we've started to already put on some option positions for the turn. But because of the strategies we use, we have a little more forgiveness about not having to be perfect with our timing. But it certainly is a very interesting level on the markets right now. Let's move on to that US dollar.

And obviously not a positive reaction on Powell's announcement. What's your take on the dollar here?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, until the last couple of days, it looked to me like the, the rally was in healthy shape. Now kind of rolling over here. I think, as you say, maybe it's a reaction to Powell. We'd really have to get below that prior low to establish an ongoing trend of lower highs and lower lows. I don't really see that happening. I think that the general narrative here is you have some Fed accommodation, whether it was the big monetary intervention or you have a fiscal stimulus bill that's passed by the Congress, and everybody says, oh my gosh, they're going to print so much money to pay for all this, it's got to be bad for the dollar, and the dollar knee-jerks down. And then the market kind of shakes that off and realizes, hey, wait a minute, everything going on in the world is really pretty darn dollar positive, and you see that recovery.

So the way I interpret this chart, Patrick, is we had the, the big pullback after the unlimited monetary intervention, and now it looks like we're getting a little pullback from additional So, I think the pattern is there is an uptrend, but it gets interrupted every time there's more accommodation.

Maybe there's going to be a lot more accommodation. It'll bat it down. I don't know, but I don't think that the fundamentals for a stronger dollar have left the market yet. I think that the argument is still there. And of course, the big test will be a test to 104. We're a long way from that.

Crude oil: OPEC cut meeting and inventory build

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil now. We're going to have a continued conversation about this in the postgame, but my take on this is that I think the expectation was simply built too high and it's like we're selling off on that OPEC news. How do you interpret all of this, Erik?

Erik Townsend: Well, there's so much to unpack here, Patrick, and we will go into more detail in postgame. First of all, for anybody who doesn't know all about the OPEC meeting, we did a full hour-long podcast with Art Berman and Nate Hagens that was published on Monday, and we talked about what we expected. Now that the big event has happened, I see it very differently. And frankly, I smell a rat here, Patrick.

As much as the, the OPEC people are frankly, uh, I think a lot more fluff than substance in a lot of the things that they do, they're good at fluff. They know how to jawbone the market. They are very, very good at showing up 10 minutes before the pit close with some kind of headline that sounds good, that, you know, their ministers are working toward a cut or whatever, and it ends up just banging the close higher. They're really good at playing that game. They know what they're doing. Today's big cut meeting was punctuated by all kinds of released— they had presentations and so forth that were supposed to be for this meeting that were released through the media. And the language in them talking about, we have to do something, the fundamentals are horrific, we're going to face single-digit oil prices if we don't act, the situation is that dire.

Patrick, when have you ever heard OPEC publicly using messaging like that?

It feels to me like maybe what's happening here is they had to go through the motions of this cut meeting because President Trump really leaned on them to do so. But it almost seems like they're kind of throwing the game here because at about 20 minutes before the, the pit closed today, Crude oil futures were plummeting, just dropping like a knife through melted butter, straight down. OPEC is usually just so good at throwing in that headline that hits the tape just at about 20 minutes after 2 o'clock, 10 minutes before the close.

There was actually a tweet that came out from one of the journalists saying, oh yeah, the, the OPEC ministers are taking a coffee break. They announced that 10 minutes before the close. I have never seen OPEC screw up their PR. anywhere close to this badly, and it makes me think they're doing it on purpose. Now, they have agreed supposedly to a 10 million barrel cut.

Art Berman and Nate Hagens explained why this is basically irrelevant. Anas Alhajji had an article in Forbes today making the same argument that basically what's going on is people who are forced because of market conditions to cut back on their production because there's no place to put the oil. They don't have any tanks left to store the oil in. There's nobody to sell it to. What those people are doing is saying, okay, we know we have to cut production. There's no choice about it. Rather than do that and make it look like the market forced us to do it, let's have a meeting and let's announce with a lot of hype and hoopla, we're leading the charge toward market stability with a cut. And this cut is going to involve what?

Basically, each one of the OPEC+ members committing to make a cut of production, which is probably smaller than what they're going to have to make. because of market conditions. So it's meaningless. It doesn't have any effect. Normally what I would expect, and what we described in the podcast on Monday, is I thought they were going to finesse the jawboning of this and tell everybody, you know, the biggest cut in history, and, you know, OPEC is stabilizing the market, blah blah blah. Instead, they're talking about horrific fundamentals and single-digit prices if we don't do something, and they're using that language publicly. So I think something is just very fishy about that. In any event, Patrick, that's the OPEC story. It's just unwinding this afternoon.

The other thing is there was no official briefing. So we only know kind of indirectly from journalists who were privy to what was going on in the meeting. There was no press conference and there's supposed to be G20 meetings tomorrow. They did say that the cut is not contingent on G20 cutting. They do expect at least 5 million barrels from the United States and other non-OPEC countries. And of course, one of the challenges there is the United States doesn't have any legal way to mandate that anyone cut oil, although it may be that the Texas Railroad Commission does have that authority, at least within their own state boundaries.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, how did the inventory numbers come in?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, we saw a build of 15.2 million barrels. Now, that would normally be an epic, just holy cow, you know, biggest build in years. It was basically expected. Everybody knows that we've got at least 20 million barrels of demand destruction because of the global COVID-19 coronavirus crisis. So it really is not a big surprise. Cushing, Oklahoma, building 6.4 million barrels gasoline, building a massive 10.5 million barrels distillates, building 500,000 barrels. So it's a build every place. And that's, you know, what, 26 million barrels between finished products and crude oil.

So huge, huge, huge builds. The move down on prices in reaction to that was significant, but it was delayed. It wasn't the instantaneous move we usually see when the data comes out. What that implies to me is maybe the algorithms that, uh, the computer trading algorithms that trade the headline releases have been turned off because the fundamentals are a little bit out of whack with usual. So they're letting the human traders trade with their own human discretion. That's all I can guess, because there was a significant move down, but it normally— it happens within milliseconds of the data coming out because the computers are reading the headline. Didn't happen this week.

Gold breakout

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold. What's your take on this breakout? Is it for real, Patrick?

Erik Townsend: I think it is, and this is kind of a 2-part answer from me. What I've described before, which is I think when the stock market really, really goes down a lot, it's gonna drag gold down with it. I still think that, but the thing is, as I described earlier, I think the timetable for the stock market has changed. The stock market's direction is very clearly up, and we've just broken on gold today above a key technical level. You can make the argument that there was an inverse head and shoulders pattern that broke. Normally, head and shoulders is a reversal pattern. This really wasn't a reversal, so maybe you disqualify it. I don't know. But, you know, it's looking really good. So I do think that the pullback that happens in gold will occur when the stock market sells off hard, which I do think is coming.

But at this point, I think it's more likely that we break maybe back to fresh all-time highs. I believe the number in 2011 was $1,922. That head and shoulders, if you qualify it as a head and shoulders, targets about that number. So I think we might be heading up to around $1,900.

And maybe what will happen is the big pullback that I've been talking about for weeks will happen after all, but it'll be a pullback from $1,900 back down to $1,700, and then we move up again from there. Uh, it certainly is not something that I'm planning to wait for anymore. I added to my own gold position at $1,625, which was about a 50% retracement of that correction down where I saw that it looked like the head and shoulders pattern was likely to complete. So I was a little bit late to buy the right shoulder there. And, uh, I think that we're, we're going places. Now, as a technicality, we haven't really broken the neckline of the head and shoulders pattern, but as I said earlier, the head and shoulders is normally a reversal pattern, which is not the circumstance here. In general, it looks to me like everything just looks terrific. The fundamentals are incredible. I do think the stock market is going to put a dent on gold and pull it back at some point, but maybe not until we move considerably higher than we are from here.

And finally, Patrick, I just want to mention we got a lot of feedback from about 2 or 3 weeks ago when I quickly breezed over some concepts about the physical market and how it works. We did a full podcast with Jeffrey Christian on Wednesday this week. We talk all about physical delivery, the real reasons why there's a premium in the market for physical coins and retail-sized bars and so forth. So for anyone interested in that, be sure to check out the podcast with Jeff Christian on our homepage at MacroVoices.com.

10-year Treasury yields

Patrick Ceresna: Let's talk 10-year Treasury yields here, Erik. They continue to be under quite a bit of pressure. We can't seem to muster up any meaningful bounce in them, and inflation expectations may continue to be quite pinned due to the weak oil prices. What's your take here? Are we going still lower on yields?

Erik Townsend: There's really no change to my view that I've expressed for the last couple of weeks, which is there is a good macro argument for higher bond prices. The thing is, the US Treasury is negotiating, or it's close to negotiating, negotiating the zero bound on the 10-year. We got down to what, 35 basis points or something at one point?

Frankly, how relevant the zero bound is, is it just another number on the way to negative yields, or is the zero boundary really a boundary that can't be negotiated without extraordinary circumstances? Frankly, I don't know. What's important in my mind is to ask all of our feature interview guests whether or not the scenario that I've feared for years, which is where bonds and stocks start selling off together, breaking their usual That unusual inverse correlation is a risk. And so I'm going to continue to asking our guests that. Until then, I don't personally have a whole lot of strong conviction about the direction of Treasury yields.

Why Eric Peters is this week's guest

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is One River Asset Management CIO, Eric Peters. Now, why did we invite Eric back as our guest this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Eric is a super guy. He's a very smart macro thinker. He's an out-of-the-box guy, so he's good for an unusual situation like this. But frankly, his funds have been in the trade press quite a bit lately. You remember when we had Chris Cole on the program and he told us about long volatility strategies as well as trend following strategies as diversifications and hedges for risk in equity portfolios.

Well, Eric Peters runs both a long vol fund and a trend following fund. Both of his funds are up on the year. The vol fund is way up to the point where it's making headlines. So it just seems It seemed like getting the guy who's been really acing the calls on the show was really relevant. The other thing is I know he's been watching inflation on the radar screen. The last couple of times that we've talked to him about it, he said, you know, I think we need to start thinking about inflation yet. It's not time, but I think it's coming.

Erik Townsend: Well, I think we're a little closer, and I'll ask him about that in this interview.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out TopTradersUnplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Eric Peters is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Virus as catalyst: a decade of built-up fragility

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Eric Peters, founder of One River Asset Management. Eric, I guess obviously the question that's on everybody's mind is this coronavirus crisis and how long it's gonna last and so forth. Was the coronavirus the cause of this market dislocation, or is it more the case that the virus was the pin that popped a bubble that was already ready to pop? And either way, how do you see this crisis

Eric Peters: Hey, Erik. Nice to be back. Thanks for having me again. Always good, particularly in really interesting periods for markets like this. I mean, clearly this virus is the catalyst for this move, and that's obvious. But in terms of the move itself and kind of the market structure, I would say that we've been building into the market structure a lot of fragility over many years. That were, largely speaking, just underappreciated. I think that people looked at the 2008 crisis and just said that was caused by too much speculation, lots of securities that were tied to housing and over-leverage, and the banks were too aggressive in terms of all kinds of their activities.

And as a result, once we fixed that, got to the heart of that crisis, given that it was really a financial crisis, albeit tied to housing, once we got to the heart of that, then it'd be highly unlikely that we would have another crisis of a material magnitude. And so just generally speaking, the combination of CEOs believing that we would not have another great crisis again, we could have periods of economic slowdown, but not a great crisis, and investors also agreeing that we would not have a great crisis again.

It got kind of everyone around the table to start engaging in activities that, in essence, levered corporate balance sheets and used investor capital and portfolios to help corporations do that, and that ultimately created the fragility in the system. how I tend to look at it is we had all the major players in the economy gear themselves to one common factor, which was economic stability. So corporations felt like the likelihood of them having any type of real disruption in their cash flows is very low. And if and as the economy slowed down, the Fed had the appropriate tools. And because the banking sector was relatively healthy, there wouldn't be a real disruption to their ability to access credit, nor would there be a real interruption to consumers' ability to access credit.

And consequently, the economy should chug along reasonably well. And in that environment, you might as well just lever your balance sheet, which is what corporations did. They borrowed a lot of money and bought their stock back and became highly levered.

And investors did the same thing. Well, they didn't do the same thing. They allowed corporations to do that. Investors, in their hunt for yield, were looking to lend or engage in all kinds of activities to get higher returns than they probably otherwise would've been able to get. They engaged in riskier activity, got involved in less liquid types of securities, and basically funded the corporations levering on their own balance sheet. And inasmuch, we became less robust as a system and more fragile. But that was not apparent, I would say, to most people.

And so this crisis came along, and this is about the worst catalyst that you could hope for that type of structure because it robbed— it really robbed everyone of the revenue to pay its debt. And that's exactly what we've accumulated over the last decade or so is just a ton of debt.

And so something like this is just— there would have been some type of catalyst inevitably, It just so happened that we got really unlucky, and this is the worst possible one, I would say.

The Fed's role and the debt response

Erik Townsend: Eric, the response from governments around the world, particularly the US government, has been to respond in many ways with bailout policies that involve creating a whole bunch of new debts. In some cases, those are debts that are forgiven if certain goals are achieved. So I guess those are more grants than debts, but in other cases, it's guaranteed loans in order to facilitate bridge capital to keep the economy going and to keep businesses from failing. Doesn't that just create even more debt and potentially set us up for an even worse fall further down the road?

Eric Peters: Yeah, that's a good question, Erik. I would say that, I guess, let's start and look at what the Fed did. And I think what they did actually was vital. So, if you take what I mentioned just a few minutes ago, about what got us here, we basically got ourselves into a position as a society where we were far more leveraged than we realized. And that leverage came through corporate balance sheets. It came through investor portfolios and the types of leverage that they had embedded into those portfolios.

And let's forget about the government balance sheet for a minute. Consumers obviously have reasonable amounts of debt. Perhaps they're not as much as they have at various points in the past. But you have a very leveraged economy. And all of a sudden, because of this catalyst, meaning the virus, people needed to gross down quickly.

And so you had way too many people selling essentially everything, which is why you saw not only stocks fall, but you saw stocks fall, you saw bonds fall, you saw gold fall. Everything fell all at the same time. And if the Fed had not come in and drawn a line underneath that with the policies that they implemented, we would've seen a crash that was far worse than what we've seen.

I think we had the US equity market fall 35% from the highs or something like that, which may sound dramatic, but it was only down 25% on the year. So I think just unambiguously, we would've been down at least 50% and perhaps 80% had the Fed not done what it did. And it essentially just looked at the overall structure and pretty quickly came to the, I think, the appropriate conclusion, which is that if everyone is overleveraged and they all need to gross their books down in one way or another at the same time, there literally is not a buyer. There's just no buyer. There's no strong hand out there. There's only one hand, and that was the Fed. So that's what they did. And we can argue about whether or not that's fair, right, I think they prevented a complete market collapse, and that would've accentuated the economic collapse that we're in.

So we're in a depression right now. The only question is how quickly we get out of it. And in a depression that has such a high economic and human toll, taking debt up to try to mitigate the impact of that seems to be reasonable policy. The question is, what does that lead to ultimately? I think there are a lot of open questions about that, and a lot of those are dependent on what some of the next policies are. A lot of them are dependent on how CEOs act and consumers.

There are a lot of questions. I mean, we could talk about a few different scenarios that come out of that, but there's certainly a lot of open questions about that right now.

One River's long-volatility and trend strategies

Erik Townsend: Eric, let's talk about managing portfolios and preparing them for events like this. Obviously, we hope that this pandemic will be a once-in-100-years event, but I don't think financial dislocations on this scale are anything close to a once-in-100-years event. I think they're going to get more and more frequent. So one of the most popular guests we've had on this year is Chris Cole from Artemis Capital, who's talked about the benefits of using long volatility and commodity trend following as components of a modernized portfolio, replacing the 60/40 portfolio, adding those components in order to create much more resiliency in a crisis. Eric, your firm, One River Asset Management, runs both long volatility funds as well as trend following funds. And I know for regulatory reasons, you're not at liberty to tell us about the performance of those funds. But frankly, you know, you guys are famous now. It's in the news. You're up huge in your long vol fund.

So talk to us a little bit strategically, because one of the things Chris Cole told us is there's lots of different ways to skin a cat when it comes to long vol strategies. How do you approach providing a risk hedge with your long vol funds? Obviously, it's worked extremely well for your investors to hedge losses in their other assets. How did that work out? How do the correlations work? And what's your approach to that strategy?

Eric Peters: Yeah. So we have a few— so we have 5 strategies as a firm. So we have a discretionary long volatility fund, which trades volatility across asset classes on a global basis. And we look for what we think are the most attractively priced markets in which we can buy vol and hopefully profit from a rise in those levels.

We run a systematic long equity vol strategy that's called Dynamic Convexity that focuses exclusively on equity vol with an emphasis on US markets. And then we run a volatility relative value strategy, which is really a market-neutral, high-alpha type strategy that's generated very very high Sharpe over its life and it's truly market neutral. And we're just looking for dislocations globally and have done well doing that. Our trend strategies, we have one that's a classic trend that looks at 60 of the most liquid global markets across asset and follows those trends. And then we have one that's focused on more esoteric markets, 104 different global esoteric markets, which are are pretty interesting to try to capture trends on.

All of those strategies are built with an eye toward mitigating risk. And I think that having been in this industry for 30-plus years at this point, I've learned through seeing so many dislocations and different strategies really struggle or blow up at times that if you don't embed really good risk mitigation into what you do, either on the strategy level like our 5 strategies, at the broader portfolio level, like a lot of investors, sooner or later something happens and you suffer really substantial losses.

And so we've had a particular focus on what we felt was going to be a pretty material market turn as this cycle ended. And remember, this is the longest bull market in US history and the longest economic expansion in US history. And A lot of the behaviors that naturally come out of that certainly imply, and now we've seen it really play out, but imply that the turn will be pretty dramatic.

In terms of how our strategies have been used, we look at everything that we do as not really hedging, but making money. We just think that we're at that stage in the cycle where we could make a lot of money being long vol. It did so happen that our investors use that for hedges in their portfolios.

I'd say the really interesting thing over the last few years, and I think that this is going to be amplified now, but the really interesting thing is it's become increasingly difficult to build robust portfolios because interest rates are very low and the classic 60/40 portfolio or even the leveraged version of that, It just— when interest rates get really low, it makes it extremely difficult to build a robust portfolio because it's just harder and harder for your bond portfolio to offset the losses embedded within your equity portfolio or whatever risks you have in your portfolio.

And so we felt like, well, number one, trend following historically has done a good job of helping offset some of those risks in big bear markets, but it's also a strategy that can make money in And big bull markets as well, it's following large trends.

But long volatility in particular, we think is a super interesting place because number one, vol, the levels of vol just got so low that they presented good value in terms of helping offset risk in your portfolio. But because so many people were short, it also is a place where you could say, in a market stress environment, vol levels are probably going to go very, very high, maybe higher than they ever have in history. And so we really focused on that opportunity and thankfully had investors that invested alongside of us in that.

Straddles versus tail hedging; rotation into FX volatility

Erik Townsend: When we've covered the long vol strategy in other interviews on MacroVoices, we've talked about breaking it into separate concepts, one of generally trading volatility. And so you're looking at things Things like straddles, you know, buying them when they're cheap and selling them when they're expensive, versus something like an express tail hedging strategy where you're really specifically buying tail hedges in order to hedge against those unlikely outlier events. It sounds like primarily what you guys are doing, and I just want to verify this, is the former. You're trading volatility not to plan for a specific outlier event, but just because it's not that hard to have a strategy that systematically trades volatility and is profitable and can be profitable in a way that's not only independent of other asset classes, but inversely correlated with them.

Eric Peters: Yeah, that's right. We focus on the former. So, we're not specifically in the business of tail hedging. And it's not that there's anything specifically wrong with that. I think for investors and their portfolio constructions, that can make sense. But we felt that vol is at levels where you could make a lot of money on the upside without having to bet on a tail event. And oftentimes when you bet on a tail event, you may endure a market dislocation, but you don't really make money unless you get some kind of really wild tail. So we're more interested in looking at at opportunities in various straddles globally in all kinds of markets, but having some directional risk as well. So that's been our approach on the discretionary side. And so what we really are doing is just we're hunting for the most convex ways that we can find in the global markets to make money in certain types of dislocations.

And when you look at a crisis like this, I think that in my experience and studying history, they tend to come in waves. So it tends to be the case that one area will be the epicenter of the first stage in the crisis. And in this case, it was equities, which is where we had our risk focus.

And then they tend to spread out. And so we think that there's likely to be very high foreign exchange volatility on a forward-looking basis, because that's one of the few areas where countries can have some type of ballast to help their economy if they can't actually go out and borrow money and print money as aggressively as the US and the Europeans and Japanese have done. So some of the countries that don't have the same level of flexibility in their domestic policies I think the shock of what's happening in economies will be reflected in changing foreign exchange rates.

So we think that that's an area that represents a lot of opportunity. And so a week and a half or so ago, we actually rotated out of most of our equity vol, thankfully, because those vols have come down a long way, but rotated into foreign exchange. And I think that I think after this wave, there will be additional waves to this crisis. And I think a big one will come when we start seeing some of the political ramifications of what's happening right now. We haven't really seen that yet, but that's on its way.

You don't get a dislocation of this size in financial markets and then the real economy without having very material political repercussions within countries and then between countries. And so those are some of the things that we're thinking about how to preposition for right now.

How One River approaches trend following

Erik Townsend: Eric, let's move on now to the subject of trend following. For any of our listeners who are not already familiar with the concept, I did a full hour-long interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen introducing this strategy and what it's about. You'll find the link to that episode in your Research Roundup email. Look for Niels' picture down near the bottom of the page. And I highly recommend that as an introduction to the strategy. But one of the things One of the things Niels taught us in that interview is there's lots and lots of different strategies that are all kind of being lumped into one by the industry. You know, they call it commodity trend. Well, a lot of these trend-following funds really are not at all focused on commodities. They're following trends using commodity futures contracts in many cases, but very frequently it's interest rates or it's It's currencies or stock index futures. So how do you guys think about trend following? Is it a commodity-specific strategy?

Is it broader than that? Is it entirely computerized algorithms? Do you use any discretionary decisions at all? How does it— how do you bake this, this whole concept of trend following in your firm?

Eric Peters: So our approach to trend, in fact, our approach to anything that we ever do in markets is to first ask the question, why do you get paid to do something. Why is the market paying you? Who's on the other side of your trade? And I think that's super important to think about no matter what type of investment activity you engage in, because in essence, you're trading against people who are not dummies. In the case of trend following, our approach is to trade medium to longer-term trends. There may be people who have figured out how to make money in very short-term trends. I just don't understand why someone would get paid a significant amount of money to try to follow short-term trends.

But long-term trends is different because I think when I observe pretty much everything in the world, there are medium to longer-term cycles, whether they're political cycles or economic cycles or monetary cycles or innovation cycles or weather cycles or just general market cycles. And so we try to focus on medium to longer-term trends because I kind of observe them throughout society and nature.

And I think it's difficult for most people to hold on to trends and hold on to positions for a very long period of time. The biggest trends that I've observed in my career essentially are reflecting some type of fundamental shift that's taking place in the world that people don't yet fully appreciate.

That's why you have a long-term trend. And so in periods of a lot of change, it would make sense that you have longer-term trends that persist for quite some time. So those are the ones that we focus on. Trends tends to work when you have a really diversified mix of asset classes and instruments and expression globally, just across markets.

One of our trend strategies is focused on the 60 most liquid markets across the 4 major asset classes, so currencies and equities and commodities and interest rates. And then our alternative markets trend is focused on 104 more esoteric markets globally that are expressed in those same asset classes, but then also in credit indices. And so in our core trend, for instance, you might see a commodity like copper, and in our alternative markets trend, you might see something more esoteric like iron ore, for instance. And so at any rate, they're 2 different sets of markets that we focus on, but that's our approach. And I think one of the most interesting things to me about trend is that we've built some very good strategies that have done well and beaten peers largely across the board in an environment where trend has not been a great performer over the past decade. In fact, if you look statistically, the last decade has been about the worst decade that you've seen in the last 120 years.

And the question is, why is that the case? And I think that it's probably the case that it maps to this period of a lot of central bank intervention and extremely low levels of volatility. Where we had a lot of economic stability, we had policy stability, and as a consequence, not as many things really moving a whole lot.

We have been waiting for this inflection point in markets. And I think now that we have this inflection and we start seeing some of the changes that I think will roll out over the coming decade, it wouldn't surprise me if trend is it goes from having had one of its worst decades of the past 120 years to one of its best. And so we think it's a nice addition to a portfolio, particularly in a world where when you think about constructing a portfolio, there's very little that a big investor can do to create balance in their portfolio and have some type of offsetting exposure to a bear market or a real dislocation.

Interest rates won't do it anymore. Bond yields are so low right now that they can't help offset risk. Historically, trend strategies have done a very good job of helping mitigate risk in a broader portfolio in times of disruption, and then just make a lot of money in times of really big trends. The 1970s was the best decade of the past 120 years for trend. Hopefully, that's what we have to look forward to.

Erik Townsend: Well, I wanted to give you a chance to talk about those strategies because I know they've been the performers in this environment. You're up here. Huge on the year in your long vol fund, and you're making money on the year on your trend

Knock-on effects: deglobalization and inflation

Erik Townsend: fund, which is a lot better than most of the industry can say. But I want to talk now about where we're headed with the fallout from this crisis, because it seems to me that, you know, obviously it's a really big deal. It's, it's affected the whole world, but the monetary and fiscal policy bazooka shots That we've seen in reaction. I mean, it was first unlimited monetary intervention. The $2 trillion fiscal intervention was, I think, the biggest fiscal stimulus ever contemplated in the history of the United States. And that only lasted a day until they came up with another one of the same size and doubled it. And who knows when they're going to double it again.

So, Eric, it seems to me that regardless of what your opinion is on whether it was prudent to have this type of policy intervention. We've got it, and it seems to me like probably the long-term impact is not going to be the coronavirus crisis, but it's going to be the results of this just totally unprecedented intervention. So, what are those consequences and knock-on effects going to be of suddenly having bigger monetary and bigger fiscal stimulus than we've ever seen before?

Eric Peters: There are a whole range of of knock-on effects that I think lie in our future. And a number of them are really dependent on some of the political choices that are made, and they're dependent on whether or not we can avoid material conflict over the coming years. And when I say that, I just mean that there's some really big open questions that I have, and I think that they're the right questions to be asking. One is, One of them is, okay, so we have just done one of the most breathtaking monetary interventions in history, and at the same time, the largest fiscal intervention. To your point, it's not over. We're not talking about a trillion-dollar infrastructure spend as well.

My guess is before this is over, that we will have spent many, many more trillions of dollars than than we've currently announced. That would be my guess.

So the question is, how do corporations and how do consumers respond? How do markets respond to that? The truth is we don't really know. There are a number of different directions that we could go in. I think one of the optimistic scenarios is that all of this intervention really does fill the hole that was left by this massive decline in people's incomes and corporations' revenues, and that somehow, some way, we push through this psychological disruption and this stay-at-home crisis that we have right now, and the economy can restore balance reasonably quickly, and we just carry on.

That's probably the most optimistic scenario that we could have here. I think Somewhere in there needs to be a pretty scalable treatment for COVID-19 followed by a vaccine. I think in a lot of respects, the markets are pricing that to a degree. You look at where equities are right now, they're really not down very far from the highs. They're certainly not down a whole lot from the start of the year. It might feel like it's been a big disruption, but the equity market is I think, really trying to look through this crisis.

Some of the other possibilities though are that we get ourselves into a spot where we just trudge through this and consumers and corporate CEOs are so reluctant to spend money or make capital investments that we just get stuck in a bit of a depressionary-type bunker mentality by all the major economic actors here.

And this existing depression that we're in right now turns into something that's just more chronic. And while the policymakers feel that their tools are sufficient to get us out, it's just much harder than expected to reverse that type of bunker mentality that people grind themselves into. And so that's a much more dangerous scenario. I think that's the type of scenario that could could lead society to start looking for all kinds of scapegoats and could lead to just darker scenarios. And we've seen what some of those are historically. That happens when you have big economic disruptions. Sometimes you have very large political disruptions and you have geopolitical disruptions.

Within that, I would say inflation becomes a consideration that we all need to think about. So in an environment where the government throws a lot of money at the economy and people just save it, that's not a particularly inflationary type setup. And I think it's probably where we are right now, roughly speaking.

But in an environment where you throw a lot of money at the economy and things really start picking up quickly, there are inflationary risks there for sure. But the big inflations of the world, stripping out the 1970s, the big inflations in the world are really caused by a major decline in supply. Combined with some type of monetary mischief by countries.

That's something that could be pretty interesting.

The question is, what's the big disruption in supply? I would say that historically, wars destroy supply, the ability to produce things. So you combine that with monetary mischief or printing, and you get a lot of inflation. But in our case, one of the possibilities is that this deglobalization destroys a lot of capacity just in that if we make a decision as a society that we want to just essentially trash our international supply chains, that's just a huge productive capacity that we've built up over the last 20 years.

If we make the decision on the backside of this crisis that we need to build a lot more redundancy here in the US, Then by definition, we have destroyed a lot of capital and productive capacity, and we need to rebuild it here. And so an economy that starts to get its legs back with a decision to have to rebuild productive capacity domestically, that would be a very strong case for a really material inflation. And I think that would catch the market by surprise because people have just grown so accustomed to thinking there just will be no inflation.

Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree with you more. And this is something that I've been musing on for 10 years now, is I have no idea what the event was going to be that would eventually overcome this massive wave of deflationary backdrop and get us to inflation. But I've always said, you know, that's where the game changes, because once you've got secular inflation, all of a sudden the printing press is not the solution to everything, because the consequence of more quantitative easing is exacerbating the inflation that we didn't have in 2008. Eric, would you agree with me that the toolbox central bankers have to work with in terms of intervention gets taken away, or a lot of the tools get taken away if we move to a secular inflation environment?

Eric Peters: They don't get taken away per se, but they become much more difficult to use. And that scenario becomes a very dangerous, vicious scenario economically. I absolutely agree with that. And look, it might even be less complex if those tools actually got taken away. The difficulty will be that the central banks have the tools that they have. They want to maintain economic growth, low employment, et cetera, et cetera.

And if they discover that we start to see higher levels of inflation and they're trying to support economic growth and lower unemployment, and yet the tools that they're using seem to be increasing inflation, but the removal of their policies or the reversal of their policies would at a minimum create much more unemployment and amplify the problems that they're that they're trying to address, that's where you really get into trouble because it's just a terrible choice for these guys to have to make.

And that would come against this political backdrop that I think is going to be a really challenging one. I mean, I think domestically and internationally, we have a number of years ahead where we are going to be having to contemplate really stressed political backdrops like we just have not— none of us have seen in our lifetime, at least in the developed world, and maybe in some of the emerging markets.

There have been the types of disruptions that we're about to have to face. But anyway, probably moving off of your question too far, but I think that policymakers and central banks, it's pretty likely over the next few years that they're going to have some of these very difficult choices to make. They will have the tools to continue to stimulate, but that may amplify inflation, and that's where they get into a really difficult spot.

The end of equity dominance and pension returns

Erik Townsend: Sounds like you're going to need an inflation fund in addition to your long vol and trend following funds in order to round up the toolbox for the coming environment. What else is on the horizon? We've talked about inflation as a major theme of what might change as a result of this crisis. What are the other major implications of either the coronavirus crisis or just the general economic environment that we're looking at right now?

Eric Peters: I think something that people perhaps don't appreciate enough is that the market— or is the overall environment for the dominance of equity investing has just been incredibly supportive for almost as long as most of us have been in trading and investing. And it appears to me that that is really drawing to a close, meaning that the tax structure that we have, the capital markets structure, the kind of investment cult mentality behind investing in equities, all of these things have led people to lean heavily on persistent and strong equity returns to meet their investment needs.

And you need to look no further than the US state, in many cases, corporate pension plans that need 7%, 7.5% returns forever to avoid becoming insolvent. Now, these types of firms and funds are going to be looking at an environment where The government bond yield is close to zero.

Certainly, the Fed is going to muscle almost the entire curve as close to zero as possible and then shrink mortgage spreads so that people can refi. But the consequence is they're not going to be able to earn material returns on their bond portfolio.

And the question is, are equities going to be able to make up for it? And what I've described over the course of this discussion is an environment where everyone was at peak leverage going into this. And the question is, are the policies coming out of it going to either, one, just allow for resumption of that same level of leverage or even increase it, or will they decrease it?

And I think that you can make a very strong argument that the policies that are going to be implemented in the aftermath on the backside of this crisis they are going to have the effect of decreasing leverage on the real economy.

So corporate CEOs who have levered their balance sheet and levered their economy to very low levels of economic volatility and done everything possible to increase the value of their equities through buybacks, et cetera, et cetera, worked their way into very high margins, very high leverage. And I think you make the case that that's not going to be the case going forward. That they're going to have to build more redundancy into their business models, into their capital structure. And so they'll, by definition, become more resilient, but less profitable. So I think that that will happen.

I also think that investors simply can't— even if they wanted to take the same levels of risk, they can't do it because their risk models will show a lot more risk. With the government bond yield down close to zero, they don't have anything that they can scale. trend, they can scale to a degree, but not as big as buying tons of bonds. They don't have anything to scale that's going to allow them to take the same level of leverage. So in an environment where the corporate sector is running at less leverage and the investor community is operating their portfolios at less leverage, there are going to be big issues that arise with just levels of returns that people need, and we're just not going to It seems highly unlikely we're going to be able to achieve the types of returns that are required to make the pension system in the US work, and that's going to create a lot of problems.

But I think what it will also do is it'll just cap the value of equities. I think we'll move to a much lower equity valuation plateau. And that's not to say that equities can never go up. They'll go up and they'll go down. But these years of equities just going up all the time, I really think are over.

And when you look around the world, the US has really been the outlier. I mean, Japan, The Nikkei is still where it was in the late '80s, if you just look back, and Euro Stoxx are where they were 20 years ago. They haven't moved. They've gone up and down, but they haven't moved.

The US has really been the only market that's really moved. There have been a couple other markets, but in terms of the really big major markets, the US has been a huge outlier. I strongly suspect that that period is in the process of ending. Policies will be much more friendly toward labor, much less friendly toward capital, and that will impact the financial markets in a really profound way.

One River overview and sign-off

Erik Townsend: Well, Eric, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview this week. Before I let you go, please give us a quick overview of what you do at One River Asset Management.

Eric Peters: So we run 5 funds. We run a discretionary long volatility fund. We run Dynamic Convexity, which is a systematic long equity volatility strategy. We run a market-neutral volatility RV strategy. And then the opportunity set for that is just going to be wonderful going forward. And then we run 2 systematic trend strategies, one focused on the most liquid 60 global markets across asset class and one on more esoteric markets.

And we work with very large institutional investors all over the world. And I think our strategies are really They're really well-built for the environment that I think is beginning to unfold on the backside of this crisis.

Erik Townsend: And of course, for regulatory compliance reasons, I'm not allowed to ask you about the performance of your funds, but the trade press is doing it for you. So congratulations, Eric. You guys are up huge this year, and there's very few people who can say that. We're going to leave it there, folks. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here Here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame takeaway: the return of secular inflation

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Eric Peters back onto the show. You know, whenever we're talking about these managers that were long volatility into this crash, I can name even 3 or 4 of them that just did great jobs hedging this downside, And it was really great to hear his insights on how things are developing. What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: The thing that stood out for me, Patrick, was the discussion about inflation. And it's something that I've said for years is I don't know when we get a return to secular inflation. I'm not smart enough to know that. It's beyond my pay grade. What I do know is I think that's where the game changes, where suddenly central bankers can't solve every problem. with printed money, and all of a sudden the rubber hits the road, so to speak.

I've noticed a pattern, Patrick. A lot of the smartest people that we have on the show recently, whether it's Eric Peters in this interview, Pippa Malmgren earlier this week, several other feature interview guests, are starting to talk about not just a little whiff of inflation, but a shift back towards secular inflation and the possibility that the COVID-19 crisis and the The resulting government stimulus, which is just beyond belief, is what takes us there and gets us out of this deflation that we've been in for more than a decade now and into a new round of secular inflation.

So I want to continue asking our expert guests about that topic. I think it's going to be incredibly important to follow. But for now, Patrick, we've got another of your famous postgame chartbooks. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email.

Chartbook: S&P 500 and the 2008-09 analog

Erik Townsend: Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means that you haven't yet registered for a free account at MacroVoices.com. No problem, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads right next to Eric Peters' picture.

Patrick, diving into the post-game chart book on page 2, we've got the S&P trajectory. I think you and Kevin Muir We were down at what, like 2,250, 2,300 when you guys said it's time for a bear market rally to take us back to 2,800. So congratulations on the call, we're there.

Patrick Ceresna: Oh yeah, it's, uh, well, I mean, the, the chart here is just, uh, the analog of, of what would it look like if we did 2008, 2009. It wasn't necessarily a forecast, but that was certainly the way we were positioning in the market. Like, we were just so oversold A reflexive rally is just par for the course for the way the market naturally behaves. But for the first time since the market top, this is a very— this level on the stock market is high interest to me because it's starting to get asymmetric to explore the downside, especially as volatility is contracting and those crazy vol premiums that we were seeing in the 60%, 70%, 80% ranges have backed off quite a bit. Anyway, just That's it. All I wanted to keep doing on this chart was just keep showing members, uh, an analog of, of 2008-9 and see whether or not this compares or will work out similar to the post-Lehman period. Not necessarily a forecast, but it'll be interesting to see how it plays out.

One thing I do think is though that the market is still likely to go lower. I think a lot of what usually happens during bear market rallies is the rally lasts long enough to convince everyone it's real. And only when everyone starts talking like it's going to keep going up and I missed it and all these different things, usually that's from a sentiment perspective when you can really realize that it's run its course. And that's certainly something we're going to continue to watch.

Erik Townsend: What do you think about my theory that next week-ish, maybe end of next week, possibly into the following week, we get a reduction in the number of new COVID-19 infections, and that I think is potentially the trigger for the last blow-off top before reality sets in. How does that jibe with what you're predicting here?

Patrick Ceresna: That certainly is possible. The one thing that almost always happens is that there has to be huge volatility, both higher and lower, to whipsaw, to drive and knock out stop losses and the weak hands. This is not going to be an easy top to catch on this. I think that there's a number of fakeouts. Maybe we'll see next week start with a big sell, and then suddenly what we'll do is, uh, there'll be a huge jump maybe towards 2,900 just to wipe everyone out that went short, and then it'll roll.

So I— the market has a tendency to, um, to make it very difficult to catch this turn. So I think maximum volatility is, is what we should expect Moving on to page 3, my favorite topic, crude oil.

Erik Townsend: What do we got here?

Crude oil term structure and super contango

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I just wanted to show the chart. I mean, overall, for the fact that we were talking this big production cut and all of these different things like Trump's tweets, oil is not far from its key lows, right? Like, I'm actually just reflecting and taking a step back and looking at this chart, and crude looks incredibly distributed.

It's a very weak-looking chart, and so it's just not impressive to me at all. This chart shows that we're heading right back down to the base, almost near the lows, right?

Erik Townsend: Exactly, Patrick. And the thing is, this is just the flat price chart, the front-month price of crude oil, and this is where it gets deceptive. We've had so many listeners that have said on Twitter or in emails that they've sent us, you know, how can I possibly go wrong? It's going to hit $20 again.

If I buy that low, if I buy oil for $20, okay, even if it goes to $10, I can ride it out and, and I know it's going to go back to $50 someday. The problem is there is nothing that's just called oil that you can buy with a symbol and get that $20 price and sell it when it's $50. Now, we covered this a couple of weeks ago, but we've got quite a bit of confusion, I think, and questions on Twitter and so forth. So I want to move on to page 4.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: Which is showing the crude oil term structure. That little dot at the bottom there, that is the May 2020 delivery contract, and that's expiring next week. The next dot above it is June, and then July, then August, then September, and October, and so forth. Now, if you go about 6 or 8 months out, you see how the dots are all close together. Normally, if you're that guy who said, I, I bought $20 because it just seemed like a great deal, If you bought one of those dots that's further out on the curve and you had to roll it forward to the next month's price, which you have to do at the end of each month, well, gee, you know, those dots are just really close together. What's the difference there? It's like 20 cents or something.

You know, I, I can just eat that as a little bit of a friction cost, cost of trading. Forget about it. What happens is it's not too important to the speculator who's long crude oil that there's that little bit of roll premium that it's called every month until you get a situation where storage is in extremely high demand. In this case, it's because we've got too much oil and no place to store it. And then what happens to the term structure is this shape you see here, which we call super contango— huge amount of vertical space between those dots.

The easiest way to explain why this happens and how it happens is to think about it from the perspective of the different traders in the marketplace. The guy who bought the May contract for $20 because it just seemed like such a bargain really was just thinking about, you know, having crude oil for the next umpteen couple of years or something and selling it later.

When he goes to roll that contract at the end of the month, normally the person on the other side of that might be one of the commercials. Those are people who have great big tanks full of oil, so they're long physical crude oil. And they're short futures contracts. So when you want to sell your May contract and buy a June contract, the guy who is buying your May contract and selling you the June contract is usually somebody who owns physical oil in one of these storage tanks.

Under normal circumstances, that guy with the tank is saying, okay, that profit of 20 cents or so, well, you know, that's about all I can get. If I were to deliver my oil into the market, instead of rolling my futures contract forward, if I were just to deliver the oil that I have, that I'm short, into the market, my tank would be empty and I might not be able to find anything to do with it.

Well, in this environment right now, Patrick, if you control a physical oil storage tank, the mafia is probably talking to you because they want to have a conversation with you about your tank. So these guys know that they're in a position of power, and what they say is, you know what, so you, you, Mr., Mr. Retail Trader, you've got to roll your May contract into the June contract, which normally costs a premium about 20 cents.

Uh, this month, right now as we're recording, Patrick, let me just look, it's $5.99 for the May to June contract. That's 6 So you're losing almost 1/3 of the value of your investment just in the 1-month roll forward. Well, if you're the investor, you say, hey buddy, you're trying to take advantage of me. I'm not going to do that. Here's the thing, Patrick, you have to close your May futures contract by the end of next week, or you have to accept physical delivery of 1,000 barrels of crude oil.

Patrick Ceresna: Wow.

Erik Townsend: Those are your only choices. The retail trader doesn't have a tank to put that oil in. He has to do it. Now, the other guy, the commercial, he's got the oil in a tank and he has the option to deliver it into the market. So the retail guy says, I won't do it. That's, that's too much. $6 just to roll my position for 1 month. That's crazy.

The guy on the other side says, yeah, it's really crazy and it's going to be $6.50 in, in the next hour if you don't act right now. Because the closer that we get to expiration, when there's just no storage available, the guy that owns the tank basically owns the gold. So what happens is in 1 month, you're readjusting your basis from $25 to $31.

You're giving up almost 1/3 of the value of your investment in that roll premium.

And that's the reason that it's possible to buy oil for $20 and then go to sell it when oil is at $40 and still lose money on the trade because you lost money on those contango rolls. And what we can expect is for this super contango structure to continue for the next several months because of the shortage of storage capacity.

Now, this creates tremendous trading opportunities, Patrick. If you take a look at— let's go, well, 1, 2, 3, 4 dots from the bottom up on this chart on page 4. Let's suppose that you were to short a 1-month futures time spread. In other words, you might say if that's May at the bottom, June is the next one, July is the next one. Let's say you're going to sell August and buy September. Well, they're only what? It looks like, uh, at this moment they're about 40 cents apart. So you're shorting it for an entry price of 40 cents. You'll wait a couple of months until that thing's about to expire And if the same storage conditions still exist then which exist today, that spread might have blown out, as has happened on the May-June spread, to $6, and there's a huge profit there.

So this contango expansion trade can be very profitable. Now, of course, eventually when the storage crisis goes away, when the economy is restarted and everything's back to normal, that contango is very quickly going to come out of the market and the trade can reverse on you in a moment's notice. So you've got to stay on top of the headlines and make sure you know what's going on. In the world. But from a futures trading standpoint, this can be a very effective trade.

Contango trades: futures spreads and floating-storage tankers

Erik Townsend: Now, the thing we've gotten a lot of listener interest in is they're saying, look, Erik, you got to be able to trade futures spreads. That's kind of professional trader stuff. It's really not within the reach of the average retail trader. Is there a way for retail guys to get involved in this same basic trade, and not by doing the futures spread, but instead Instead, by buying shares in the companies that own the tanker ships, which are being used to store oil in addition to the on-land storage.

Now, that's another way of thinking about this trade. I personally am a futures trader. The way I put this trade on is with futures spreads. Patrick, I know that you've looked at the tanker trade, and I think you, you and your members are actually in that trade. Tell us a little bit about the stock trader approach to trading this same basic concept here and how it plays out.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so first of all, I want to do a shout out for Harris Kupperman and other hedge fund managers like that that have been all over this shipping story, because really I didn't originate the idea, but it is just a great way of expressing this trade. So on page 6, what we have is the crude tanker rates, which are showing the daily charter rates for, for these ships that, that store the crude, and they're north of $200,000 a day. Just to put it in context, last year the average rate was about $40,000 a day for the crude tanker at spot rates. And so these, these tankers, uh, what they're essentially— a lot of traders like the ones you're describing are literally doing is, is buying spot, loading it up on these ships, going selling forward into the futures market, locking in much higher prices and then just paying the charter rates to actually just have this as floating storage.

And what's interesting is Morgan Stanley did an interesting interview with a number of the CEOs of these tanker companies. And we linked an actual article from Oil & Gas Journal that actually was on that conference call and detailed it. But it was just talking about that these companies, because they were really dealing in the spot market going into this entire period, as much as anywhere, some of the CEOs were saying 87% to 95% of their vessels are available now to be booked into these, um, at these higher charter rates. And so long as, uh, there's a, a lack of land storage, these ships are going to start being used as floating storage and actually reduce the fleet available and cause these charter rates to continue to skyrocket, as, as there's a no-brainer for a lot of these companies to just buy the spot, pay that charter rate, and in the end deliver at a much higher price in the future.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's just explain why these tanker ships come into the equation and what they have to do with oil storage. Let's go back to page 4 again, listeners. Look at that bottom yellow dot on $25. That's the May delivery contract. for WTI crude oil. Now look, not the next dot up, but 2 dots up. That's the August contract. That's at about $33.

So there's at least $8 of difference. That's called the calendar spread or time spread, just for those 2 months.

Well, wouldn't it be cool, without taking any speculative risk at all, if you could just say, hey, wait a minute, why don't I buy the May contract today And I'll sell the August contract today. So I lock in a price of about $9. And if you move on to the next page, on page 5, we actually show what that May to August spread looks like. And since this chart was printed, it's actually moved higher. It's, uh, $10 right now as we're recording on Thursday afternoon.

Well, the idea is you buy the May contract. The thing is, if you just had a place to put that oil in your back pocket and store it someplace for a couple of months, you could then deliver into the August contract, and that difference called the contango of $10 per barrel, instead of losing that to those guys that take advantage of you on the roll, you could keep that profit. In fact, you could lock in that profit without even having to know what the future price of oil is going to be, because you can use today's prices to lock in both the purchase and the May contract and the delivery on the August contract. And you can lock in both prices right now today and get a $10 differential. The thing is, you got to have someplace to put the oil, and all of the storage tanks on land are completely booked. So the idea is you lease a ship which is normally used to deliver oil from one continent to the other, and you're just using it as a floating gas tank.

You fill it up with crude oil, tell the captain to go anchor for a couple of months and bring it back when we get to the delivery dates for that August contract. And oftentimes what you'll do is you'd just end up calling the captain back and saying, hey, Cap, stay at anchor. We just rolled that spread forward because the August to September and September to October spreads had widened out. We were able to roll that position for August delivery into October. So just stay on the anchor there. We'll call you when we need you.

If you have the sophistication to rent out a tanker ship, you can make a fortune. And the thing is, Pat, Patrick, it's not speculation. You can lock in that profit by chartering that tanker ship, and you know how much you're going to make. You're not speculating as to what the price of oil is going to be in August. You're using today's price for delivery in August. So that's how the trade works, but you got to have a ship that can store crude oil in order to do it. So I just wanted to explain that. Please continue with the story.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, that's the whole point. And so the charter rates for these ships are actually susceptible to price discovery. And so the wider the spread is, the more profit there is. And the more profit there is, the more they can bid up the ships to lock them in so that they can actually make this trade. And so these, these ships have been— some of them in the last couple weeks have been going for $200,000 plus a day.

And so it was interesting, if one has a speculation that this contango is not going away for months and it's going to stay, then, then these shipping companies are literally printing money. And it was interesting is that in that conference call on Morgan Stanley, the Euronav CEO Hugo De Stoop basically said that they have the potential to generate profit greater than the company's market cap this year if these rates persist throughout the year.

So essentially you have a scenario where these— if one is making a call that the contango is going to stay in there and these charter rates will stay there, these companies are completely mispriced for the amount of profit that they're about to print. Now, it's still a speculation, but if any of that—

Erik Townsend: Now, you're saying that's profit. So the earnings per share, the EPS, is the same as the share price.

Patrick Ceresna: Yes. Isn't that insane? Oh, now obviously this is a speculation that those charter rates will stay there the rest of the year. Obviously, if the contango disappears and the charter rates in a couple months go back to $20,000 a day, then they had a nice profit. boost, but the idea of how much profit they can make, they would have to sustain for the whole year for that number to be cracked.

Erik Townsend: Now, my question, Patrick, is everybody, not everybody, but a lot of smart people know about this already. It seems like these charter rates that we're looking at were way up just in the last few days because of this OPEC cut nonsense. And again, listen to the interview with Art Berman if you want to understand why this cut really doesn't have as much relevance as the media would like to suggest that it does. There was a dip there, but it was very short-lived. We're back up to those high rates. So at this point, is the share price pretty much already baking in the value that's there, or is there still an opportunity to make money by buying these shares?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, there's a lot of smart people out there putting some heavy money at this thinking that it's not priced in. But really, the most immediate reaction over the last week has everything to do with the fact that, uh, supply cuts have a negative impact on the tanker market. So when that big headline from Trump came out, the first impulse is to hit the tankers the moment there's an idea that there's going to be a production cut. And so this is why the speculation really is on how much you really believe that OPEC is going to stick with this and that, that, that oversupply isn't going to be there. So long as there's going to be a huge amount of oversupply of oil and the lack of demand these ships are going to get filled up pretty quick. And so this is a, this is a great way of playing the contango in the market.

Gold chart: heading toward $1,900

Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to the gold chart on page 7 here. You've got the price from earlier in the day here at $1,746. That was pretty close to the, the high of the day. It did close a little bit lower than that, right around where that head and shoulders neckline would be at around $1,730 or So it looks to me like this chart's looking awful bullish. And I don't know about you, but I'm thinking $1,922, which was the 2011 low, is not that far away.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. On the short term, the path of least resistance for gold remains heading upwards to $1,800 or so, even higher. Like, we could go back to fully retest the 2011 highs. I do think that this will be still very volatile, though. So if we enter another period where the stock market goes into a liquidity event, it's going to be hard pressed for gold to kind of decouple from that broader noise that's going to come in the whole entire marketplace. So on the short term, I continue to think that gold is going to edge higher, but I don't think it's a free ride to just stay long. So we'll have to definitely see how it continues to develop.

Fed buying junk bonds and credit spreads

Erik Townsend: Patrick, moving on to page 8, I had to catch myself today because I thought that I had drifted off. asleep at my trading desk and I was having a dream. Because it's only when you have dreams that crazy things happen, like public officials that are supposed to be grownups decide that what the Fed, the Treasury, the central bank of the United States ought to do is buy junk quality credit in order to support the junk bond market. Now, when Michael Milken was playing crazy games in the junk bond market in the '80s, he went to jail and he was a sinister bad guy. I think he was even one of the characters that they based the bad guy in the Wall Street movies about. Now we've got Jay Powell doing it and nobody's arresting him. What the heck is going on here? Let's start with the story on what's happening with the Fed and junk bonds and then move into this chart.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I just really wanted to point out the credit spread, like, 'cause what ended up happening was the junk bonds just blew out. Like, I mean, you had an 800-plus basis point spread over Treasuries. And the moment the first wave of QE came in, in and they tackled the investment-grade quality and government bonds, the spread just blew out even worse because they weren't touching the junk bond market. But what I think is happening is the Fed is realizing that they need to stabilize the entire credit market in order to prevent this from avalanching down the side of the cliff. And so they came in and they're buying high yield. Obviously, we're, we're already 200, 300 basis points off of the, the highs. But what is interesting to point out is the credit markets had such a drastic event that the only time we've seen credit spreads blow higher than this was 2008. And it's— I just think it's really, you know, you can step back and reflect on, on how this has developed.

Now, obviously, with the Fed creating now an artificial market because they're going to be a buyer They're keeping yields suppressed. It's gonna be really interesting whether or not credit risk has really been tamed or not. And that's something that I think we're gonna have to watch in the coming months. Maybe we should bring a high-yield guest on just to really kind of size up what this means to the market, because this is unprecedented. I don't think I've— I wouldn't have ever thought— well, I mean, there are certainly people that would've speculated that we'd be here, but it is here. And it's amazing that we are. And I'm not sure how to interpret it. Yeah.

Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, I still have some old leftover accounts receivable invoices for delinquent receivables from a business that I owned in the 1980s. I wonder if I can sell that to the Fed for 300% of original principal. I mean, it's just— what part of the word junk doesn't register for these people, that they're spending public money to buy junk bonds? It absolutely amazes me that this is actually happening.

Patrick's live options session with George Gammon

Erik Townsend: I think that this coronavirus response In my opinion, folks, is much worse than the virus itself.

On a happy note though, let's move on. You're doing a live trading session with our friend George Gammon for listeners who went to our MacroVoices live event in Vancouver. George was the principal organizer behind that event, did all the legwork in order to make that possible, negotiating with the hotels for us. A live trading session online with you. What's it about and how can people join in?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I'm just doing it for all my paying members, but also George has promoted it on his end. But George wanted to learn more about options. So I said, well, why don't we just hold a live trading event where it's me and you and we're going to go through a bootcamp and educate all of our members just on all the amazing things you could do with options. We have— we put a real focus on gold on it. And we're— so we're going to spend a lot of time talking about collaring and how to create synthetics in the gold market and to leverage this beautiful uptrend.

Erik Townsend: And of course, you get what you pay for. So that one is only for paid members of Big Picture Trading. You can find the information in signing up right here on the slide on page 10.

COVID-19 update: peak infections, US response and testing

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's go on to the COVID-19. What's going on here? And give us an update as to how things have developed since you gave

Erik Townsend: Patrick, there's so much to cover. Let's start with the general market narrative. As I said when we did equities in the market wrap, I think that the White House has done a pretty good job of messaging to set expectations with the public that we're approaching peak new infections in the United States sometime in the next week, maybe 10 days. And the way it's being portrayed is, okay, that's the worst of the crisis. So, okay, finally we're almost through this, this awful experience, and soon we'll be able to get back to work, according to President Trump. I think the market is already anticipating that event. They think it's only a week away. The rally has already started because the crisis is ending. There's a few inconvenient truths associated with this, Patrick. I don't think the crisis is ending. Even if the pandemic were ending, the economic damage is really just starting. You can't reboot all of these failed businesses.

A whole bunch of businesses have gone out of business. Employees have been laid off or fired. There's lost jobs. That stuff doesn't get turned back on when you start the economy.

Frankly, the United States has done a terrible job with the non-pharmaceutical interventions, containment mitigation strategies, and so forth. Initially, you know, one of the most important things is to. Get testing in place very early on and do it on a widespread basis. Initially, the CDC was blocking independent laboratories and prohibiting them from getting involved in testing. When it became clear the CDC was not going to get its act together, it seems like the president intervened and insisted that independent labs be allowed to contribute. You know, if you look at how China handled this, you never during that crisis saw Xi Jinping in public without a face mask on. That's called leadership by example.

Trump doesn't just not wear the face mask, but he emphasizes in his press briefings that he doesn't think it's necessary and he refuses to wear it himself. So that's not leadership by example, that's bad example. They're reopening beaches in Georgia, I heard, when we still are not yet at the peak level of infections and contagion. We're doing a lot of really dumb things, quite frankly. And there's a lot of people that are not taking the precautions seriously. I feel sometimes like the CDC is watching Chris Martenson's videos on a 2-month lag. They just figured out that asymptomatic transmission is a really big thing and that we need face masks because of it. Well, Martenson was talking about that in January. Martenson first introduced hydroxychloroquine and the research around hydroxychloroquine and zithromax. In early February. You know, there's just so many things that have come up that the government's way behind on.

So I don't think that the assumption that if we just take other countries' experience and project how many days we think it should be to the peak based on the experience of other countries— we've done a lot of things not as well as other countries.

We haven't really implemented the social distancing measures as effectively as other countries, particularly in Asia. So I don't think we should expect to have the same results as someplace like Singapore or South Korea. So the first point, Patrick, is I'm not persuaded that that peak number of infections is necessarily assured to happen in the next 10 days. Good chance it'll happen then. Seems like that's what the models seem to say. But I just think there's reason to be suspect that it doesn't necessarily have to go that There's several other reasons, though, that the crisis is probably not ending.

First of all, once you get to peak infections, that's just peak infections. There's at least a 17-day lag until you would get to the peak in deaths, and the amount of time when people are still contagious after initial infection can be up to 14 days. So from the peak infection date, you can't even think about reopening the economy for at least 14 days after that.

But even, you know, 14 days after that, you've still got people that may not have been at the peak but were just after the peak. They're still contagious. We can't reopen the economy. You look at Italy, just extended the closure of their economy. Their lockdown has been extended to May 3rd, and they were considerably ahead of us in terms of the timing of everything.

Second waves, vaccine and reinfection questions

Erik Townsend: There is also the possibility that you get something very Yeah. And we're seeing something that's very common in epidemiology, which is it feels like you're getting a reduction in the number of infections, but then there's a final wave of infections and the numbers go back up again. Well, we haven't even had the numbers come down for more than one day before going back up again. But when that does happen, it doesn't mean that there can't be another wave. The other thing is the Spanish flu came in 3 major waves several months apart. It looks like China is having its second wave right now, and maybe also Singapore. So it seems like there's a good chance that there are multiple waves coming, and particularly it seems like it's at least a year until we have widespread availability of a vaccine. Unless we can get to full herd immunity, which seems unlikely, there's probably going to be several more waves to come.

And everything that we've seen so far seems to not confirm the idea that temperature and humidity would kill the, the virus off. A lot of coronaviruses, unlike the influenza virus, are not killed off just because there's warm weather. Now, Dr. Fauci did say that maybe we'll have only 60,000 instead of 200,000 deaths, but that's the deaths in the first wave, and it sounds frankly optimistic to me.

I think that President Trump is going to rush to reopen the economy. It's very, very clear from his press briefings that he's very focused on that. Well, it's called the dance for a reason. The whole idea of that Hammer and Dance article, which I really recommend our listeners read if you haven't already, is after the hammer, the big containment, which is the lockdown, it's a dance. It's a nuanced, careful process to see how you slowly start to open things up without allowing the reproductive number to creep above 1 again. President Trump's not talking about doing a dance. He's talking about a wholesale restart of the entire economy, which doesn't sound very prudent. Now look, that's what China tried to do. Now they're into their second wave. South Korea looks like it's having a second wave. As I said, Italy just extended their lockdown.

Bill Gates suggested this week that there should be no mass gatherings, no football games or any of that Until we have a vaccine, which could mean no sports events and so forth for a full year or longer.

There's troubling new data that came out this week, Patrick. Chris Martenson has a video, it's called Wait, You Can Get Reinfected. I recommend you check that out on his Peak Prosperity YouTube channel. But there's a couple of things that have been discovered. One is, it's— they call it NAb deficiency. NAb is medical slang, I guess, for neutralizing antibodies. That's the stuff you get in your blood after you've had the virus that fights it off the next time. Well, what they're finding is that with this particular SARS-CoV-2 virus, some people, about 5% of the study group, didn't ever develop any antibodies. They had it, they recovered, but they didn't get any antibodies, which means that they're not any less likely to get it again.

And furthermore, that could mean— and this is, you know, this is new research, it hasn't been peer-reviewed yet, it's not conclusive, we're dealing with information which is not completely decided yet— but the initial indications are that that would probably mean that vaccines would not work on those people, because the way the vaccine works is it's introducing what's basically a dead virus into your bloodstream so that your body can produce the antibodies for it. Well, if your body is not producing antibodies for the real virus, it's not going to produce antibodies for the, the dead virus. So if there's 5% of the population that basically the vaccine doesn't work on, that's a really big deal.

There's also this question about reinfection. Now, there was a study out of China in mid-February saying that the second reinfection— so you get it, you recover, Then you're exposed to it again and you get it a second time. That most viruses, you know, you don't get it the second time because you have immunity.

They're saying that you can get this one the second time and that it could be a much worse infection the second time around than the first one. Now, that study came out in mid-February. It was later criticized, and a lot of doctors thought, well, I don't think it's really a reinfection. It's more likely a latent infection, meaning. Hmm. You get it and it becomes dormant in your body and it comes back and you have a second event where you have symptoms for a second time. But it's not that you re-contracted the virus again, it's that you had it the whole time and you went through 2 waves of symptoms. Now that opens the possibility, and again, this is not conclusive, it's not peer-reviewed yet, insert all your disclaimers here, it's an outlier case. But it could be that we're about to learn that this virus works like HIV or herpes, meaning once you get it, you've got it for life.

You can't get rid of it, and you have recurring outbreaks that occur every so often where you experience the symptoms. We don't know that; that is completely speculative. But they think that that's one of the possibilities. So my point is, there's a lot of reason to question. Is there a second wave and a third wave? Do we really get to the point where we can fully reopen the economy until after we have a vaccine? Once we do have a vaccine, what if 5% of the population, the vaccine doesn't work on them because of this NAb deficiency issue?

These are all reasons that it doesn't make sense to equate, we think the peak of new infections is coming next week, to that means the economy is gonna be fully back to normal next month.

Antibody testing and herd immunity

Erik Townsend: I think that we could have a number of partial shutdown of the economy effects that last for years, potentially, until we get to a full vaccine or full herd immunity. New York City's peak is what's expected in the next 7 to 10 days. Well, that's not the national peak. Think about how things went down in China. Big, big deal in Wuhan. They were finally starting to get it under control, and then they And then they had outbreaks in all these other cities, and that's when they had to go to lockdowns all across the country. What if New York City was just the first really bad cluster, and we're about to have Chicago and Detroit and San Francisco and, and a bunch of other places take off into New York City-like events? That's not certain to happen, but it is possible. I don't think markets are discounting any of these possibilities. Yeah. Everybody seems to be focused on okay, we can see the light at the end of the tunnel.

This thing's almost over, and I don't think that's the right way to think about it.

Antibody testing is super duper important, and the reason is we just plain don't know how many people have had this thing, and we don't know how close to herd immunity we are. If you can't depend on a vaccine anytime in the immediate future, if you could get to herd immunity where at At least 80% of the population has had a mild case of it and has started to develop natural antibodies.

Then you get to where there's resilience, and it's okay to start to open the economy back up. The thing is, you don't know that until you test for it. Antibody testing is not to see if you're sick with the virus, it's to test whether in the past tense you already had it. So if you— a whole bunch of people, myself included, have been sick in the last several weeks. Did I have a mild COVID infection, which means I've had my, my light version of this, I've developed antibodies, and that means that I'm not likely to ever have it again?

Or does it just mean that I had a common cold and I'm just as susceptible as anyone else? The antibody test is what tells you that. In order for it to be effective, you have to use what's called surveillance testing. In other words, you can't just give it to people who want it and say, well, you've got symptoms, you're suspicious, you, you think you might have it, because then there's a selection bias where only people who probably do have it take the test. You have to administer this kind of surveillance testing to everyone in society equally, asking people to take it, which means it has to be super easy to administer, so it just takes a couple of minutes and you can ask everybody to do it

Market roadmap and an entrenched recession

Erik Townsend: to find out whether or not they already have antibodies for this virus.

So my roadmap for where the market is likely to take us is I think the rally in the stock market continues for the next week to 10 days until we get to the point where we reach that peak of infections and the daily infection count that's being reported is coming down. Then I think there's a major upside acceleration for a couple of days until you get to a blow-off top, and I think that's your sell the news event Because eventually we're going to figure out that was just peak infections. The crisis is still in full swing. If we make the mistake of trying to reopen the economy, which I think President Trump is prone to doing, I think it's going to result in a whole bunch of new clusters, more New York City-sized events in other major cities all around the country. So I think that rushing to reopen the economy could bring on a huge Huge second wave, and you're already seeing economic impacts that are irreversible, Patrick.

JP Morgan has halted all non-government guaranteed loans to small businesses. So all of a sudden, small businesses can't borrow money in credit markets. Those kinds of things are creating just all kinds of havoc in the economy, and just allowing people to, to go outside of their homes again is not going to get those businesses back online. Even when you do reopen, I think the recession is entrenched.

I think there's going to be payback for these mask wars where the United States has been accused by everyone from Germany to Italy to Canada of hoarding all of the N95 masks and not sharing them with other countries. That's going to lead to some foreign policy tensions, both with China and with others. And I think there's knock-on effects That all of this stuff, the knock-on effects are really going to kick in. And we've got a long, hard, challenging road to plow ahead of us. So I don't think it's anywhere close to over. And I think we're about to go through a false sense of it being over in the next 2 weeks.

Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo.

Research Roundup and sign-off

Erik Townsend: Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the charts we just discussed in this postgame. You'll also find a link to the article we referenced in the postgame from the Oil and Gas Journal about the tanker rates reaching record levels, as well as a link to Great interview with one of our favorite guests, Russell Napier, about how much debt is too much. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@jdiresearch.com. Up at MacroVoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please Register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library, and the more registered users we have. the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and. Do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Josh Crumb — headed up the precious metals research group for Goldman Sachs before moving on to found Goldmoney (as introduced on the show)

Announcer open, episode preview and dedication

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 213 was recorded on April 2nd, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by my own vacation rental on the coast of Maine, which I'm repurposing as a COVID-19 safe haven for a family that wants to escape city life for a few months during this crisis. The house is available right now, and I'll tell you about it later on.

This episode of MacroVoices is dedicated to healthcare workers all over the world who, without a doubt, are the true heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic crisis. Last week, we were treated to infinite monetary policy accommodation in the form of unlimited quantitative easing at the pace of $625 billion billion per week, plus a $2 trillion fiscal stimulus bill. Just when everybody thought surely it was over, this week President Trump suggested another $2 trillion of fiscal stimulus, this time in the form of a massive infrastructure spending initiative. Should we expect the new normal to include $2 trillion per week of new fiscal stimulus in addition to unlimited monetary stimulus going forward?

Well, one thing's certain, and that is that the government's actions are going to debase the value of fiat currency. So the long-term fundamentals for precious metals couldn't look much better. Who could be a better feature interview guest than Josh Crumb on such an occasion? Josh headed up the precious metals research group for Goldman Sachs before moving on to found Goldmoney, and he's currently involved in launching a new Singapore-based commodity exchange. We'll discuss the gold-oil ratio, Pricing models for gold relative to both crude oil and real interest rates, and we'll talk about what lies ahead for precious metals from here. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when we'll discuss why buying what seems like a generational low in oil prices isn't really the trade it might appear to be. We'll explain contango, super contango, and roll-forward premia in futures markets, and we'll explain why you can get stuck with the same underperformance in long crude oil trades regardless of whether you trade through futures or an ETF.

We'll also have an update on the coronavirus crisis. I'd like to once again thank everyone who's donated to make additional content possible during this crisis. We couldn't produce any extra episodes this week, but we're working on 2 for next week. First, by popular request, we'll have a crude oil special with Art Berman, and then we're gonna do an expanded special on the mechanics of the gold market, going into much more depth in the discussion that we had in last week's market wrap, about physical product premiums and some of the things that I discussed in the market wrap last week, which we got a lot of questions and comments on.

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now listeners, we're going to adjust our show format starting with this week's episode in order to keep the length of the market wrap under control. We're moving our COVID-19 coronavirus update to the postgame segment at the end of the podcast so we can give the subject the time it deserves without turning our 15-minute market wrap into an hour-long affair.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude oil, gold, 10-year yields

Patrick Ceresna: So now, Erik, let's dive right into it. S&P 500 has more or less muddled all week long. What's your take? Are we still going higher here in the short term, or is it a very bearish scenario in your mind here?

Erik Townsend: Well, as we'll discuss later in postgame, the worst of the virus news is still to come. I think that the bottom is not yet in for the market. A lot of other smart people, Jeff Gundlach, Jim Rogers, have been coming out publicly saying the bottom is not in yet, much lower to go. The virus was just the pin that popped the bubble and so forth.

If you want to know the most bearish scenario that I can think of, well, let's start with the 3,398 top in the S&P. We went very quickly all the way down to 2,174, and then we got, you know, the 38.2% Fib retracement would have taken us up to 2,642. We got to 2,635. I'm going to call that close enough. Let's say that that was the top of a bear market rally and it's downhill from here. Well, if we apply a measured move to that 2,635, the target is 1,411 on the Now, that frankly sounds too low even for my bearish taste. I would think the 1550 highs from 2007 would provide pretty formidable support. So I do think that numbers in the teens, maybe high teens, are possible in the S&P in the next month or two.

The thing is, if we were still in the pre-2008 market normal where markets were driven by economic fundamentals, I'd say, okay, I think it's very likely that we go well below 2000 here. The thing is, today we've got the government spending trillions of dollars per week like money's going out of style. And the Fed has very clearly signaled that they want to be able to buy stocks, even though that's not allowed by the Federal Reserve Act currently. They seem to be trying to figure out a way to make it happen. So, you know, if you've got an unlimited amount of money coming off the printing press and you want to support asset markets, you can do just about anything.

So I don't think anything is certain here. I don't have that strong of a bearish conviction simply because I don't know what's going to happen in terms of government intervention. Absent such intervention, I would say $1,550 to $1,700 is probably where we're headed from here. I'm still short for now, but again, as I say, I don't have really strong speculation in terms of how to trade this crisis. Other trades like short oil have played out much better. Well, Maybe until today. We'll talk about that in just a minute.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to the US dollar because we have a euro that's weakening quite a bit, but not all the currencies have reversed. Do you think the dollar's going higher from here?

Erik Townsend: I think so. It seems to me that a pattern is emerging. You know, the Fed prints insane amounts of US dollars, the Fed does some kind of extremely accommodative thing, the market says, oh my gosh, surely this has to be the end. You know, it's got to be the end for the dollar. This has got to be the final high. It's all downhill from here. The market knee-jerks down in reaction to that news, but then reality sets in and people realize, wait a minute, this crisis is dollar-positive. People all around the world are raising dollars to service their dollar-denominated debts. There's a safety trade into dollars, and there's lots of reasons to expect more dollar strength. Goldman Sachs agrees with that view. They've been saying to expect a disorderly dollar appreciation from here. So clearly, the big test is a daily close, or better yet, a weekly weekly close above 104 on the dollar index. That's still way above us, but hey, we're back over 100 now, so it looks to me like we're on the way.

The big test is 104.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, so let's move on to crude oil because everything looked like it was just going downwards, and then we got the big news. Is this reversal for real?

Erik Townsend: I don't think so. What a day, Patrick, in the crude oil market today. But let's, let's take this in order and cover the other stuff that happened earlier in the week first, and we'll come back to today's crazy action. WTI found strong round number support right at $20 a barrel 2 solid weeks ago on the 18th of March, and there's only been a few brief dips to a $19 handle. No closes below, with the one exception of the last day just as the April contract was expiring. That doesn't really count because by then it's no longer the actively traded contract. So in terms of what the active contract was, we haven't closed below $20 yet.

My prediction had been that what the market needed to see was these expectations everyone has about a storage crisis being confirmed by EIA data, really big inventory builds. Well, we got that this week. Crude oil building 13.8 million barrels. It's the biggest one since, I don't know, 2000-something. Cushing Oklahoma building 3.5 million barrels. Gasoline building 7.5 million barrels. Distillates was the only drawdown on the board at 2.2 million barrels. US production still still holding strong, at least according to the data, at 13 million barrels. Kind of hard for me to believe that nobody's cut back production at all during this crisis, so I really suspect that data. But the thing is, as much as I thought that that confirmation was going to be what was needed for the price to move lower, we got a whole flurry of news coming out at the same time, just after the inventory data, which I'm sure was no coincidence.

Trump announced that he was going to meet on Friday with the CEOs of several oil companies, talk about maybe a Saudi tariff, some way to support the industry, and was suggesting or implying that Saudi Arabia and Russia were close to resolving their differences.

Then Wednesday night, we got more news, which was China has plans to fill its Strategic Petroleum Reserve that could consume up to 100 million barrels in total over the next couple of months. That got us back to the 13-day moving average by Thursday morning. Unemployment claims put a damper on that. We were headed straight down and then whammo! The President Trump tweet from beyond. President Trump announced that there was going to be a 10 to 15 million barrel per day cut in crude oil production that Saudi Arabia and Russia were apparently agreeing to. Now, the notion that anyone anywhere took that seriously for more than 30 milliseconds just defies logic. That would mean that both Saudi Arabia and Russia would have to cut their production by about 2/3 and stand by while the US continues to produce full tilt.

Now, consider the history here. They couldn't agree on a half-million-barrel additional production cut when Russia walked out of the meeting several weeks ago. So the notion That it's even plausible that they would agree to a 15 million barrel production cut is just crazy. But that's what the president tweeted. That's what the market algorithms reacted to. And we went straight up to the 21-day moving average on the continuation chart at $27.40. $27— actually, I think the last print was $27.39.

Wow. Really big move. Tremendous opportunity for anybody who read the tweet and realized what nonsense it was to short it, which Which is what I think a lot of us did. This doesn't make any sense whatsoever. Now, it didn't take long for both Saudi Arabia and Russia to refute it, but they're being smart about it. They're not really refuting it in a confrontational way because that would just help the oil price go back down. They just said that they think that the president's number has not been agreed to as of this time or something, and then later they said it was possibly exaggerated.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: No kidding. It was absolute fantasy. So I don't know what the president is smoking. There's not going to be a 15 million barrel production cut. Finally, when they announced this afternoon that the president's number was exaggerated— it was, I believe, Saudi Arabia tweeted that— that allowed the market to sell off very, very sharply, back down to about $23.35.

And then just before the close, seems like somebody wanted to hammer the close higher. We went $2 straight up in the last 15 minutes of trading. That happens a lot on the end of the quarter or the— sometimes the end of the month when somebody is trying to force the price higher in order to get their accounting for the month to look better or something. It's very unusual to see it on the second day of the month that somebody's trying that hard to monkey hammer the price higher. I'm pretty sure that there was no news for it. It's just somebody really wanted to push the closing number higher and was buying like crazy for the last 10 minutes or so.

So, it seems like there's a lot going on in this market, a lot of attempts to manipulate it higher. I don't think that there's any reality to this nonsense of a 10 to 15 million barrel production cut. What Saudi Arabia has said is exactly consistent with everything they've said before. They were happy to have a meeting to talk about this, but they're not going to cut unless everybody else cuts. And so far, nobody else was willing to cut half a million barrels, never mind 15 million barrels.

It remains to be seen what the president tweets tomorrow, but so far, you know, it's— despite all of this, we closed up $5 on the day, even though anyone who really understands the market understands there's no way that what the president described is actually going to happen. So as much as it may not be based on reality, it's working at pumping the price higher.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold, because gold's been pulling back for most of the week, and then today we have a pretty big update, close to $50, and pretty Pretty much undid the last few days of selling. Really feels like gold wants to press that 52-week high. Do you think that's going to break out this time around?

Erik Townsend: You know, it seems like what's going on is when we have really aggressive selling going on in the stock market, that phenomenon I've described kicks in and it pulls the price down. But as soon as you get any other kind of news, gold's just looking for an excuse to rally. So the idea of getting back down to $1,350 based on stock market weakness, I don't see that happening anymore. I don't know where it goes from here, frankly. I think there's still reason to expect a lot of volatility. But hey, that's why we've got Josh Crumb on this week's feature interview. Josh is a much heavier-weight gold guy than I am. He's got a lot to say about this. He models gold not only on real interest rates, as do a lot of other people, but he has a model that uses both real interest rates and oil prices. So we'll talk about how oil prices and what comes next in the oil market is going to play into the gold market.

That's all coming up in the feature interview.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yields, which continued to deteriorate. I mean, we're a little bit up today, but I mean, we were trading at spot 6.0 earlier. Do you think interest rates just keep weakening here?

Erik Townsend: You know, I had thought that before, but then we've seen all of this volatility recently, and I don't mind admitting that a lot of it caught me by surprise. As I've said before, the really big burning question on my mind is I know someday we're going to get to the point where stocks and bonds sell off together and interest rates back up in a secular fashion.

A lot of people on Twitter seem to think that I've predicted that on the show. I never said that, folks. What I've said is that's the important thing to watch for. That will happen someday. When it does, watch out, because the implications are staggering in terms of what the knock-on effects could be. I'm not saying that's happening now. I don't know if it's happening now. At the moment, it looks like it's not.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: I hope not, but I think we really need to watch it carefully. This is beyond my pay grade, frankly. We need to get some, some more guests, Dr. Lacy Hunt level people, to really get into the details of this and talk about what it would take to bring about a secular sell-off in the bond market and whether or not we're seeing signs that one's coming. I don't know the answer to that question, but I know it's the most important question to focus on in fixed income.

Patrick Ceresna: This week's featured interview guest is Josh Crumb. Why did we invite Josh back to the show as a guest this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Josh is just a wealth of knowledge on precious metals markets, and we're going to be focusing on bringing more and more precious metals experts. I'm also going to do a precious metals special talking about the mechanics of the market next week because we had a lot of inquiries from my comments about some of the games that are played by the physical metal dealers, and I want to expand on that and get into it with an expert. So we're going to do an extra show on that. We're going to try to bring more Precious metals-oriented guests into the program because it's such an important topic. And, you know, who better to start it with than Josh Crumb, who really has a heavy background, you know, ran the, the precious metals research department for Goldman Sachs, went on to be a co-founder of Goldmoney. Now he's working on launching a new commodity exchange, which I think is really exciting.

So he's a super talented guy, a lot of background, and it's time to get more precious metal guys onto the show, and we're gonna be bringing you more of them in coming weeks.

Patrick Ceresna: Thanks.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out TopTradersUnplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Josh Crumb is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Gold's tug-of-war and the real-rate model

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Josh Crumb, who formerly was the head of precious metals research for Goldman Sachs, went on to found Goldmoney, and has since gone on to found Abaxx Technologies. We'll talk about that at the end of the interview. But first, Josh, it's great to have you back on the show. So much to talk about with so much going on in the gold market. Josh, help me navigate the current opportunities in the gold market. I'll just start by telling you how I see it. On one hand, I really think, first of all, when there's a panic, people rush into gold. We've kind of seen what's looking like a blow-off top. It's starting to correct lower. I think there's a really good argument that says that the stock market is not done with the downside from the COVID-19 crisis yet.

What we saw in 2008, it seems like there's a lot of good reason to think it's coming back, which is Correlations go to 1 in a crisis. Everything sells off, even though the fundamentals for gold are improving. People are selling it to raise cash, and the price ends up going down, even when you would hope it would go up under those circumstances.

So I see lots of reasons to think that a dip is coming. But holy cow, the Fed just basically put up a buy gold sign and announced their intentions to illuminate it. by spending $625 billion a week on lighting. You know, with this monetary policy intervention, it's kind of hard not to just say, okay, the fundamentals are so good, you can't wait, you just got to dive in here.

Which is it, or is it a combination of both? And how do you navigate this tug-of-war in the gold market?

Josh Crumb: Hi, Erik. Thanks. Good to be back. One thing that I would say probably right up, right up front is I actually don't believe so strongly in this narrative of, you know, sell everything, you know, dollar short squeeze and this sort of, this sort of view. And, and I'll, I'll sort of explain how I look at it, which ultimately comes out to be something, something similar, I would say, but there is a fundamental, there, there is a fundamental behind it. So when I look at, at gold, gold trading markets, gold price markets, there's a couple things that are, that are important to look at. What's the actual physical flow for, for gold and, and, and the gold demand, you know, call it on Main Street or the, or the real economy. And then what's the demand for, for futures and just gold exposure on, on Wall Street?

And so if you look at what the demand for gold exposure is, it's actually still extremely well correlated with, with real interest rate expectations. So even when we saw that spike up to $1,700 in early March that, you know, subsequently collapsed very quickly to, you know, I think it was $1,550 or $1,520. $1,225, and it was a pretty dramatic swing in the gold price, it actually still matched up extremely well with the pricing of real interest rates as seen in, say, the 10-year TIPS market. So what was happening is the dollar short squeeze wasn't just a sort of physical commodity short squeeze where you're selling everything, but also the models and people that trade the gold price futures based on metrics like real interest rate expectations and TIPS correlations. So that also happened. So, so that, that's sort of what's happening and call it the paper, you know, paper gold market, the machines, the algorithms.

So when we saw that, that happened, we actually very quickly saw those. So, so real interest rates actually went up because essentially the market was pricing deflation very, very quickly because of the zero lower bound. If you, if you price that the world's going into a deflationary, say negative 2, you know, 2% inflation, negative 1% inflation, but you're trapped at that zero bound, it That actually means that you have positive real interest rates, even though growth may be negative. So this is, this is one of the hardest sort of concepts for people to think about, particularly when they're thinking about gold. And so we actually saw a very fundamental sell-off on that real interest rate spike. However, that got unwound very quickly, not just with Fed actions, but, but in general, you saw it across many assets.

So gold rebounded very quickly back into the $1,650 type of range, which is actually very well predicted by the model that I actually helped develop. And Goldmoney Research put out an update to that model back in June of last year, where basically $1,650 was the sort of target price back when it was $1,300. So despite all the craziness, the model is actually holding up extremely well. And for anyone that's interested, I do have those models and that research pinned to my Twitter profile right now because I try to keep that information front and center.

Because again, there's a lot of narrative, there's a lot of talking about fear and dollar short squeezes and all of these things. But I think it's important to always always have it still in a real fundamental model. And basically, what's happening is this fundamental uncertainty is actually quite significant. We don't know if we're going to have -2% inflation or if we're going to have +2% inflation. So that uncertainty, that window, is actually quite fundamental. And I don't think there's anybody that has a perfect model for where we're headed.

So again, that volatility, I think, is fundamentally going to remain for a long time. But In my view, in general, I think it's very dangerous to play this game of, I'm just going to wait for a dip. Now, if you see a dip, buy it, in my view.

Sorry, in the model's view. I don't want to make short-term trading recommendations because that's never been my framework. But it's really just to help people understand why prices are moving where they are and what that macro framework looks like in the future. So, I'm not making short-term advice, but I do think that this dollar short squeeze narrative is overstated in my view.

Model range: real rates plus energy

Erik Townsend: Now, when I read a recent Twitter thread that you posted, it sounds like your model actually is predicting a fairly wide range of possible prices. Is that because of uncertain expectations around interest rates or inflation or both or other factors? And what is that range in terms of what you see as being possible for the gold market in coming weeks?

Josh Crumb: Exactly. So, you know, again, I just sort I'm not sure how well I explained it, but part of it is the real interest rate portion. And this, again, is very important because this is the way Wall Street trades gold. And it basically trades it like a currency cross. So real interest rate models and interest rate differentials are also the way that Wall Street trades, say, the euro versus the dollar. So essentially, what's happening there when you're pricing real interest rates, you're pricing the demand for gold as basically a neutral or zero carry foreign exchange, right? So, so if it costs money to carry currency, people would rather be in gold than, you know, paying a negative real interest rate on, you know, holding currency. So, so again, this, this range is, is very uncertain right now because, you know, yet again, we're in this huge dilemma. Are we going to have inflation or deflation? Is it going to be short-term deflation followed by long-term inflation? There really is a very wide range in that.

Now, the other factor that plays heavily into our model which differentiates us from probably just about all the other models out there, and particularly on Wall Street, is we also have a, have an energy component to our, our gold price framework. And so when, when I, when I talk about real interest rates, we're really talking about the demand for gold as a money stock or as a, as an alternative currency. Again, when, when other currencies are having a negative real carry. So that's more of a demand for gold type issue.

On the supply side, energy is, is your key component. This determines the marginal cost of gold and really the fundamental anchor price of how we create new supply of gold. Because gold is so energy intensive to produce, it's got a very high energy correlation. And when I say that, I'm not looking at the front month $20 a barrel of oil. I'm actually looking at the long-dated energy futures and the expectation of really what marginal cost of gold is. And if you look at the forward curve of oil, we're still in the $50 a barrel range. And again, we can get into the whole oil dynamic later.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Josh Crumb: later if we want, but essentially the model is pricing real interest rate expectations and energy price expectations. So those are the 2 big components to the model.

And so again, going back to your question of how big that window is, that range is, is actually quite incredible, right? Because we don't know, just 6 months ago, long-dated energy futures were around $70 a barrel. Now they've just like the front month, that's collapsed to about $50 a barrel. I mean, obviously not extreme as going from $60 in front month down to $20. But, but we still have relatively, you know, we still believe we need oil in the future, right? This is a, this is a temporary supply glut. But the uncertainty is, do we really create such an economic depression that, that, you know, the, the oil price curve keeps shifting down? That would be negative for gold. And if, again, if we enter a deep recessionary environment, that would also be negative for gold. So basically what you have is you've got this window of So we have 1,200 on one side based on those 2 factors and 2,100 on the other, which is just incredible.

And it sounds like an analyst cop-out to have such a wide range. But again, based on our model, that window is that big. And that's actually very consistent in a lot of other markets if an analyst is being honest. We have such a fundamental uncertainty right now of what comes out the other side that we're just going to have this heightened volatility for a long, long time.

Gold-oil ratio, the oil curve and gold's richness vs. commodities

Erik Townsend: Let's go a little bit deeper on this subject of the gold-oil ratio, because it's something that, at least when most analysts look at it, they really are looking at the spot price of oil and the spot price of gold. And I think we're already either close to or at an all-time record on the gold-oil ratio in terms of, you know, dollars per barrel of oil to dollars per ounce of gold. I think it's going to go much farther than it has already, but it's all about what happens in the front month. I think what we're about to see is an all-time record super contango in the oil market, where right now we're at about $46 for long-dated futures, you know, 8, 9 years out into the future. If I look at today's spot market or front month futures price, we're We're right on $20, just barely above $20 as we're recording on Tuesday morning. I think we're headed much lower, maybe as low as $10 on the front-month futures price.

But if that happens, it's gonna happen in a super contango condition where still, if you go 2 or 3 years out on the curve, you're back up over $35. So with that outlook, does that mean that that in the short term, gold prices get pulled way down with it, or is this function of energy in your model operate in a way where it's almost immune to that super contango condition and really only discounts the later-dated futures?

Josh Crumb: That's a great question, Erik, and one that I've been fielding a lot because I think as our energy-gold framework has been picking up more steam in the market, a lot of people have been reaching out exactly on that point. And I think you're right. So, so first, a couple numbers around the front month oil to gold ratio, because that, that's the one that generally gets posted, you know, on Twitter and, you know, in, in the, uh, in, in the general macro sphere.

And it is quite incredible what's happened. So, you know, generally the last, you know, 30, 40 years, the oil to gold ratio, you're looking at somewhere between— it's, it's a pretty wide window, again, for the reasons of the backwardation and contango in oil markets. But generally it's, it's ranged between 10 barrels per ounce to 30 barrels per ounce, with the average right around 20. So you actually have this pretty neat, clean range for gold over oil. And that, by the way, is not just a modern phenomenon.

If I look back in the 1920s and 1930s, at the height of the Roaring '20s, you had oil at around $1.90 a barrel, which translates— and gold, the fixed $20.67 per ounce. And so you're around $10. $10, $11. And then in the, you know, in 1931, it's sort of the, you know, in, in the market collapse, we moved up to about $30. So again, we stayed in that $10 to $30 range, and we've always been in that sort of $10 to $30 range.

So where are we today? We're over $70. So, so this is really an unprecedented collapse in, in oil prices, you know, measured to something like gold. And so we're, we're just way off the charts at this point. But again, back to your point, And if I look at what's happening in our price model and in the gold market, again, it's still pricing that long-dated future.

Now, I think you said $46. You must be using WTI. I think I usually use Brent in my model, but essentially similar mechanics. I think the Brent price is $48, $49, something like that, at least when I looked at it a week or so ago. And so yeah, we still believe gold is pricing that expectation.

Because gold, in our view, prices like a money stock, it prices like a currency, or it prices like a 10-year TIPS. So, that's the way that we look at gold. And that framework seems to be holding up. So, it has not been directly impacted by the collapse in front-month prices. It's still looking at expected values of currency and energy, perfectly in line with our model.

Erik Townsend: So would it be fair to say then that your opinion is that even though most people look at the spot gold-oil ratio, what would make more sense would be to divide the spot price of gold by the back end of the futures curve, whatever the longest-dated futures are pricing at, which right now is $47.37 on WTI, and it sounds like $48-something on Brent?

Josh Crumb: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: something on Brent. Is that the model? Is use the back end of the curve?

Josh Crumb: Exactly. It's the back end of the curve. And why is this? Because this is actually where you're getting industrial price signals into the market is through forward hedging, not necessarily on spot market hedging or flows. Spot markets, whether you're talking about gold or you're talking about oil, are all about actually what the current inventory and current supply chains are needing as sort of a buyer and seller of last resort market. So the front end of the curve really has to really only with what inventories are and what very near-term spot markets are doing. But again, if I'm a— whether I'm a mining company that's hedging or I'm an oil company that's hedging, that price information about our real marginal cost is coming into the futures curve, not into the forward price. So yeah, not into the near-dated futures. So that's why we look at the futures curve.

And again, it holds up very well in our model.

Erik Townsend: Now, Josh, you just said something that really caught my attention because a minute ago we were talking about the back end of the curve. That's 8 or 9 years out into But what you just said is the important economic signal comes from where people are hedging, where producers are hedging their forward production. As I understand, at least the US shale industry, that's normally about 2 years out on the curve. And if I look 2 years out on the WTI curve, I see the March of '22 contract trading at $38.74. So that's almost $10 higher than it is today.

Josh Crumb: Right.

Erik Townsend: lower than the number we were talking about at the back end of the curve. Which one of these is actually the relevant signal to use?

Josh Crumb: No, that's a great question and one that I'd say the whole industry is struggling with a little bit, and particularly some of the frameworks we developed at Goldman. There's a couple reasons why this is happening. First off, the balance sheets of the banks and what they could actually take as far as inventory for these types of hedges, the world has changed significantly since '09 and a lot of the bank reforms.

dynamic you've heard in bond markets and the destocking of inventory of bonds on bank balance sheets. Same thing when you're talking about gold, and we can get back to gold, talking about how the whole dealer inventory has been destocked significantly.

Same thing with long-dated futures. So, what's happening currently in this curve is a lot of these shale producers in particular have just been dumping, just selling and selling and selling Sort of that midterm future, exactly as you pointed out. So we think that that longer-term price signal has been lost a little bit in the market, very much like an illiquid bond might lose its pricing signal. But fundamentally, we still believe that marginal costs are really anchored in expected marginal costs, right? You don't build a new project and create new swings in supply based on what the near-term price is. It's always about expectations.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Josh Crumb: So that's where the actual industry practical application is sort of running into theory at the moment. But ultimately, we still believe that it's the expected marginal cost that matters for producers to make production decisions, not just the spot price.

Erik Townsend: Okay, Josh. So if we look at where the spot gold-oil ratio is, which you said is the number that probably doesn't make that much sense to pay attention to, but what everybody looks Looks at, it's like 70 barrels per ounce. And just based on the conversation that we've had, if I look at the 2-year out where the shale hedgers are hedging and I use that number, I get about 42 barrels per ounce. And if I use the very back end of the curve, I get about 34 barrels per ounce. That's still beyond the 30-barrel top end of the range. So it seems like no matter how you slice We're looking at what could be considered a situation where oil prices are putting a drag on gold prices, or perhaps artificially constraining the gold price. Is that true? Is that what's holding gold back from responding to what seems to me like an incredibly bullish impetus from central bank policy action in the last few weeks?

Josh Crumb: Yeah, I actually think that's a great— I hadn't run those numbers myself, and I actually think that's extremely helpful. agree. We're still in this very unprecedented expensive gold relative to the other commodity economy. And our view is that gold has always been a money that stays even. So when you get these spikes above even, it could be a short-term squeeze or a short-term rush for gold. And you can also see that in something like the copper market, or platinum, or silver. So we do seem to be having this run to gold, that seems excessive compared to some of the other, other metals and commodities. And so, yeah, that, that would, that would give me some pause on, on chasing a gold price here. Now, again, that, that said, I still believe all of those, those commodities that I mentioned are going to be, you know, are likely to be much higher a year or 2 years out because of inflationary reasons.

But it's never good to chase a, you know, chase a squeeze either.

Physical disruptions in the gold market

Erik Townsend: I want to move on to another topic that's gotten us a huge number of questions and inquiries. inquiries from listeners, which is the physical disruptions in the gold market. To be sure, the coronavirus crisis has brought about physical disruptions. It's difficult to take delivery of physical gold on the LBMA. There's been some disruptions in the COMEX.

Something I've noticed over decades of following precious metals is anytime that there's any real physical disruption in the market. That also leads to imagined physical disruptions where the precious metals dealers, particularly the guys that are selling retail-sized bars and coins, start publishing articles about how the world is coming to an end, the paper markets are collapsing, you better rush and just pay whatever premium you have to to get those physical Gold Eagles in your hand because the entire COMEX, LBMA, It's, it's all going out of business next week.

Help us navigate, or help our listeners navigate, okay, what's really happening? What are the real physical dislocations in the market? What do they look like? And what are some of the things that we should not be taking seriously in terms of inflated predictions and, and descriptions that some people have put forth?

Josh Crumb: Yeah, I generally agree with your, your statement on that, that, uh, that, that it gets exaggerated. Yes, in very short-term rushes for— rush for silver or gold, you do lose retail dealer inventory. And that's because you still have to mint it and all of the supply chain that goes into the mint, into the distributors, into the retail dealers, into the US Postal Service, all of that, that's a real supply chain. And just like any other supply chain, the surges of supply and demand And it's very hard to manage that. So that is real. I wouldn't understate that these shortages are real. And I would say what we've seen in the last couple of weeks is pretty much just an epic— just like this oil-gold ratio blowing out so significantly, we're also seeing that in real physical inventories.

So if I look at something like silver coins, that one usually happens first. Again, that's very real. Because it's a sort of a high cost to carry commodity, there's not a lot of inventories of silver coins, even in the best of times. But when we actually get that kind of squeeze on, say, kilo bars in the gold market, or 100-ounce bars, 400-ounce bars, that's really the wholesale level. And that's pretty extreme. We have not seen that before. So what we saw last week with even my former company, Goldmoney, which holds about $2 billion worth of client metal. And again, so operating at a much higher scale than, say, a coin dealer. There was an absolute shortage of kilobars. There was absolute shortage of kilobars in New York, in Switzerland, in Singapore. So this is real.

Now, is that just an issue of very short-term transportation and moving inventories around because of coronavirus shutting Likely, but that said, we have you know as I alluded to earlier, we really have destocked you know even investment-grade bullion over the last ten years from dealer inventories and the financing for the the people that the wholesalers the financing has been getting tighter and tighter and more more difficult to come by. So I believe that squeeze is real. I believe those shortages are real. Now I'm not saying that there isn't gold in in you know in the LBMA vaults or there isn't gold in Fort Knox or something like that, right? But the ability for somebody to give that up is becoming more and more severe. So even if that gold's sitting there, it may need a much higher premium to clear. So I would caution that I'm generally in your camp that it's usually oversold by the dealers, but this one does seem quite different than past squeezes.

Paper vs. physical gold, COMEX spreads and the silent bank run

Erik Townsend: Okay. I want to draw a distinction. One of the things that I think we can agree is happening here is clearly there is a premium for retail-sized coins and bars. So whether it's a 1-ounce bar or a 1-ounce coin or even a kilo bar, which is probably the biggest, you know, the top end of the retail spectrum in terms of size, there's clearly a shortage of that stuff that creates a premium, and the price of those retail-sized physical products is higher higher than the wholesale price for physical metal. No doubt about that. But what this has led to is a lot of commentary that supposedly the physical price of gold has decoupled from the paper price of gold. And usually the way the narrative goes is this decoupling is going to continue. The paper price of gold is a fantasy. You'll never be able to actually get physical metal and so forth. And I just don't think that that's true, Josh.

I think what's really going on is the paper price of gold is still an accurate reflection of the wholesale price of London Good Delivery bars, 400-ounce bars, with the caveat that there may be a delay in taking physical possession of them because of this crisis.

But I don't perceive any to a disconnect or a breakdown between the paper price of gold and the physical price of gold if we're talking about the physical price as measured by the wholesale market for 400-ounce bars. Am I missing anything there? Is there really a disconnect that's forming between paper and physical that I'm missing somehow?

Josh Crumb: Not necessarily. I mean, again, I, I tend to side, you know, towards your view, but, but that said, I, I wouldn't say that there's absolutely no shortage. Again, there, there's a shortage at $1,650. Or $1,620. Now, would there be a shortage at $2,200? That's a very different story. I do believe that we have seen unprecedented shortages again in places like New York and, and, and, uh, Switzerland and Singapore, that it still seems a little odd that more gold's not leaving those LBMA vaults and basically feeding some of the largest markets in the world. That to me doesn't, doesn't add up. So I, I would be I'd be careful to say that there's plenty of gold, because at this price, there is not plenty of gold. That's what we're seeing. Even if you look at the current spread on COMEX, you're looking at the April to June spread, I think we're still running at a $25 backwardation. And even that whole term structure is higher than the LBMA price. So, the market's still pricing all the way out to June, and in the April-June spread, that there's a shortage of wholesale financial bullion.

So again, I would be a little bit careful to say that there's plenty of gold because we would have seen it flowing out a lot more.

And another point that I would say is that this has not been happening only the last couple of weeks. This is the other thing that I think even if you're reading some of the sort of shock articles on ZeroHedge or some of these, one of the things that I can tell you is this institutional run on gold started back in Q4. Really, during the whole not QE spike and repo madness, that is actually when we saw the largest vault movements in LBMA and London export history. We have seen major, major financial gold, wholesale gold leaving the system.

That silent bank run has been happening for almost 5, 6 months So, so that's another thing that's, that's played into this recent short squeeze on, on the, on the COMEX.

So again, we're in a very different situation than '08. I don't think you can, you can make analogies to '08 because there was so much wholesale dealer inventory. There was so much dealer, you know, bank and bullion bank inventory. There was a lot of scrap, and all of those categories have been heavily destocked the last 10 years. So again, It's very analogous to certain bond markets where, yeah, it looks like you have a price until spreads really blow out because people can't actually arrange the inventory. I'm not saying that the gold's not there, but it's in much stronger hands than it was 10 years ago during these squeezes.

Why gold sold off in March

Erik Townsend: Well, that's very interesting to me because one of the things that I've been struggling with is it seems to me like we have seen in the last several weeks, 2008-like price movement. And what I mean by that is, as the stock market was crashing, we saw the gold market crashing with it, even though the gold fundamentals were only getting better. And it seemed to me that that price action was confirming what I had feared, which is that correlations move to 1 in a crisis. And even though people don't want to sell their gold, they were being forced to sell their gold to meet margin calls or something. So it sounds like You don't think that's what was going on. How would you interpret that big move down? Was it entirely about interest rates and real interest rate expectations? And I was just maybe looking at the wrong signal when I concluded that it was about gold moving in sympathy with the stock market?

Josh Crumb: So I think it probably is a little bit of both. Again, these things have fundamental reasons and feedbacks between each other, but I still believe that it really was related to these algorithm-type sell-offs with real interest rates. Not only that, sorry, also rising volatility. Again, that is a similar function of the dollar short squeeze. When you're having rising volatility, people's risk models and their cross-asset risk models say to withdraw risk, take down risk. It's not necessarily that they're short of dollars to make margin. Right. Margin, but they're scared that they might be in the future, right? So, so they're, they're taking down risk, uh, overall. And, and that, that likely happened in the, the TIPS market. So that— so, so yes, that would probably be more in line with your thinking. But I'm, but I'm saying it's all sort of related, and it does tie back to fundamentals.

And so what we've seen is we've seen, you know, like the COMEX has been raising margin requirements on gold futures, you know, like, like a lot of futures, because of the higher, uh, the higher pricing of You know, again, I don't have these numbers directly in front of me, but I think gold has been trading in a, you know, 30-plus vol when it's usually down at, you know, at 12, you know, 15 vol.

So we're still seeing heightened volatility, which means that people are trading it on margin and in futures are going to be, uh, you know, less, less risk exposure. And so, so yes, that's sort of the dynamic that's been, that's been playing out.

But again, I think particularly with what's happened in the COMEX and the real physical wholesale dealer inventories, I'd be very surprised to see people dumping gold because they may view that they can't get it back again. Again, there's feedbacks in both the psychology and what's happening that, again, at the margin, I'm going to take down risk. I may not want to take down risk in an asset that I want that I know I can't get back again at the same price.

I think we've set a higher floor than what we saw a few weeks ago. But that, that's how I would read it using that framework.

Crypto: Bitcoin is not digital gold

Erik Townsend: I want to move on to another topic that I know you've done a lot of work on, Josh. There's a whole new generation of investors who would listen to this entire conversation and say, guys, you're stuck in the dark ages. The new asset to think about in terms of safe haven protection is not gold. That, that's, that's old school. The The new thing is crypto.

Where does digital currency fit into all of this? Needless to say, we haven't seen the strength in digital currency recently that some people would have expected if you thought it was going to be the new safe haven asset. What does all of this mean and what's your outlook for cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum and so forth?

Josh Crumb: First off, you know, I'm not opposed to cryptocurrencies. I find them very interesting. I think it's been an incredible innovation in sort of the history and the technology of money and just the narratives that are spreading through the crypto community that are actually quite in line with people in the hard money communities, I think that's generally been a good thing. That said, I do not believe that Bitcoin is digital gold. I don't believe it ever will be based on my model of what a commodity and a proof of work of energy looks like. So again, that's a long rabbit hole to get into.

But what I, what I in general don't like is that more and more, as more and more use cases have really not come to fruition, they keep sort of just anchoring back to its digital gold. And essentially, they're just selling the gold narrative, right? And that to me is quite worrisome. And when you see price swings, as we've seen in the last year, and the whole drop gold campaign, I mean, I don't know of a worse macro call. That's been made than to sell gold right when it was at $1,300 and about to go on its run at the same time digital currencies collapsed.

And also, another point that I'd point out is usually the people that say, oh, gold, we've moved on from gold, younger generations are all digital, they always make this narrative. And they always end with the point, you're going to buy it later at a much higher price, which tells me they don't understand money. You don't look to buy money to speculate. You look to buy money to store value. And so, again, they're trying to have it both ways. They want it to be digital gold, but they also want it to be the next Amazon or Facebook or Google as far as capital gains. And that's not what money is supposed to do. It's not supposed to have high volatility capital gains. So, again, I do not like the digital gold narrative. But that said, I think it's still a very interesting asset class. I think it has very important use cases if we really get into a financial repression scenario that we may be headed down with what's happening with central banks.

So again, I think there's still a commodity utility to digital assets, but it's not digital gold in my view.

Sovereign digital currency, custodians and Libra

Erik Townsend: I wanted to start with a cryptocurrency question before moving on to what I think is a more interesting aspect of digital currency, which is the future of sovereign digital For any listeners who have not read my book, Beyond Blockchain, my outlook for several years now has been, as much as, you know, the Bitcoin guys have a novel idea, I don't think that they're going to be allowed to just take over the world's monetary systems. I think governments will continue to assert their monopoly over money. And what I've predicted was that eventually, someday, as the dollar's role as the world's global reserve currency came into more and more question, that other governments around the world, and possibly the United States itself, would develop a new digital reserve currency, a global reserve currency, which is a sovereign-issued digital currency. That's been my prediction for several years. It seems to me, Josh— first of all, I'd be curious to get your general reactions to that.

Josh Crumb: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: But it seems to me like, okay, interesting long-term prediction, but what's going to be the impetus to actually bring around that kind of change and governments getting involved in something that radical? Well, it would have to be the US dollar's reserve currency status really coming into serious question because the dollar is at serious risk because of excessive largesse on the part of the Federal Reserve printing too much They just announced unlimited QE forever. Seems to me like maybe now is the time for that possibility to come into scope and for other governments to start working on a new global reserve currency, which is a digital currency. What do you think about that outlook? And what do you think the prospects are for something like that happening?

Josh Crumb: Yeah, it's very, very interesting for sure. And it's funny, it kind of takes us back in time to the first time we talked, we actually got into this as well. So it's interesting how the world continues to come full circle. continues to move in this direction. One interesting take that I would probably add to the discussion, because this is a very, very tricky discussion and all the different steps that would be needed to get there. But one interesting discussion, my co-founder of Goldmoney and BitGold, Roy Sebag, had a very interesting conversation with Marty Bent recently. And basically, he was presenting that what the Federal Reserve did was sort of a man-in-the-middle attack on gold, right? And the slow sort of taking gold from being a monetary asset To disintermediating it with gold certificates and Federal Reserve dollars.

And eventually, here we are now. What's interesting is something similar could be happening in the Bitcoin and the digital currency realm as well. So, for as much as we just spent time on, is there really gold at COMEX and LBMA, the same could very much be said about the big crypto custodians, right? A very large percentage of retail crypto crypto is still being held at the likes of a Coinbase and a Xapo. And if you look at, you know, and particularly since those have now merged. So if you look at developments like that, that looks very much like the LBMA system where you have just a number of players sitting on all of the vault and in a very difficult way to go in and out. So again, I just wanted to raise that point because I think it's very interesting and a lot of people aren't talking about it because there's a lot of people in crypto saying things like, look how much of a mess the physical delivery of gold is.

This is why crypto is so much better. Yeah, well, again, in theory, sure, it's much easier to transport if you know how to store your own keys, but most people aren't doing that. Most people are stuck in their LBMA-style vaults with cold storage.

So, just wanted to point that out. But that then leads to the next question of, as Roy presented the Federal Reserve as a man-in-the-middle attack on gold to eventually create the completely unbacked US dollar, That similar thing could happen in crypto as well, where some of these big crypto dealers really start almost partnering with the governments to create these digital currencies. And of course, we saw that developing at Libra, and we're of course seeing that developing in China. So it could be very interesting when sort of the large players in the crypto industry start merging with the central bank initiatives to drive basically fiat stablecoins, but supported by the Treasury, the Federal Reserve, the Bank of China, et cetera. So I think that's a path that we're likely on right now. And so again, it kind of comes back to the conversation you and I had a couple of years ago, and that seems to all be accelerating right now.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, certainly my view on this is it's going to be a different category. And I think of the first generation of digital currency as cryptocurrency. That was a bunch of guys who came up with some just absolutely absolutely brilliant software engineering. And they naively thought that just because they invented something really cool, that they could usurp the authority of government and create something that was government-proof. And in the end, the government still has the guns and the badges. And unfortunately, I don't think they're going to let go of their monopoly. The next thing to happen was Facebook's Libra came along, and I call it a whole different category, which I'm calling Silicon Valley digital currencies. Now, Zuckerberg got it all wrong. He didn't understand that if you want to take over the entire planet's money supply, you have to bribe all the politicians first. So he didn't do that, and as a result, he got the reaction that he got.

My prediction is what happens next is Google or someone else in Silicon Valley does their own Libra, but they do it only as after buying off all the politicians so that they get unanimous support rather than opposition from Congress because of a whole bunch of campaign contributions that they astutely made before introducing their new product.

And I think there is scope for a Silicon Valley digital currency to become the new de facto global reserve currency. If you want to engineer something better than the US dollar in the form of a digital currency that will appeal to more central banks around the world more than the US dollar does. It's not a difficult engineering task to undertake. What we haven't yet seen is a Silicon Valley company recognize the political reality of who you have to bribe before you can pull something like that off. Zuckerberg tried to do it without bribing anybody first, and look where that got him.

That's what I think is coming next. Any comments or reactions to that?

Josh Crumb: I think you said it perfectly. I agree that that's the path. I think as I set it up with the man-in-the-middle attack, I think that's very similar and it leads to that same outcome. I agree with you. You're right about Mark Zuckerberg, but I would say the person that has been very good at playing those circles is David Marcus. David was the former CEO of PayPal. He left to join and build Messenger and tried to create a WeChat or Alipay Out of out of Facebook Messenger, his new project is Libra, and it's all it's for all the same reasons that you just pointed out. So I would say that that yes, that is ongoing in the background, and I think you're you're probably right. That's the path it's going to ultimately take. As you know, the Federal Reserve and a number of the governments realize they can't do this themselves; they need Silicon Valley. And I see I see a merger of that sort of happening as well.

I think yeah, 100% in agreement.

Erik Townsend: And for any listeners who are not aware, I wrote a whole book about this stuff a couple of years ago. It's called Beyond Blockchain. You can find information at MacroVoices.com/BB, or just go on Amazon and look for Beyond Blockchain.

Abaxx Technologies and a Singapore exchange

Erik Townsend: I want to move on now, Josh, because you've been a step ahead of a lot of things throughout your career. You were a precious metals guy at Goldman Sachs. You headed up the precious metals research There. You went on to found Goldmoney, very successful with that. You've since moved on from Goldmoney. The next thing, as I understand it, that you're looking at is the commodity exchange landscape. Now, as a member of NYMEX, you don't want to get me started on what's wrong with commodity exchanges because I won't shut up for an hour. So, uh, what in your mind is wrong with the current landscape of commodity exchanges and what is Abaxx Technologies about?

What are you doing in order to change that landscape?

Josh Crumb: Great. No, I appreciate that. Yeah, and I have to be a little bit careful because we're in a bit of a regulatory blackout and obviously some very big industry players that we want to challenge. So I can't really get into all of the details, but yes, I mean, my view is is essentially the increasing digitization of commerce in general. We think that that trend is not going to slow down anytime soon. If you look at something like the development of ICE that came out of nowhere to challenge the NYMEX at the time and the old London oil pits and so forth, it really was a mixture of new big changes in global energy combined with big changes in technology. I think we have both of those conditions right Big changes in technology and digitization for all the things that we were just talking about, and big changes in energy markets with what's happening with US shale and US energy exports and sort of the reordering of global energy supply chains that have been taking place the last 5, 6 years and will continue over the next 10.

So yeah, I believe the opportunities are right to create a new exchange, and we're basing ours in Singapore.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Josh Crumb: Singapore, which is also another macro trend of commodity markets increasingly moving east. And so, yeah, I mean, I'd say that's the overall landscape. But yeah, I mean, if you look at what's happened in COMEX the last few weeks, if you look at what's happening in a number of commodity markets that have been quite dislocated from fundamentals, I think there's always room for improvement to serve the physical industry. And that's our view. We're not there to serve the financial industry, but to serve the physical industry in really needing true buyer and seller of last resort type markets.

So yeah, that's probably as much as I can say right now. But yeah, we think there's a huge, huge white space there.

Erik Townsend: Well, I look forward to getting you back on the show as this project evolves some. And at some point when you're at liberty to tell us all the details, I can't wait to find out what kind of technology innovations Abaxx is going to bring forward to advance the state of the art beyond what we have with the existing exchanges. Meanwhile, Josh, please give our listeners your Twitter handle and how they can follow your work for people who want to keep up with what you're doing.

Josh Crumb: Thanks, Erik. Yeah, I'm just @JoshCrumb, J-O-S-H-C-R-U-M-B, on Twitter. Again, I'm quite active and try to post anytime updated models and that sort of thing. Again, I'm building businesses, so I'm not obviously doing full-time research or anything, but generally in short bursts and when there's interesting things happening in macro, I'll usually

Erik Townsend: Fantastic, Josh.

Erik Townsend: We'll look forward to getting you back in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message.

This episode of MacroVoices was sponsored by my own vacation rental on the coast of Maine. It's a 5-acre oceanfront family cottage. compound with a deepwater dock, 2 separate residences, 2 kitchens, and 8 king and queen bedrooms. But with all the pull-out sofas and bunk beds, we can actually sleep upwards of 30 people in a pinch. You couldn't imagine a better safe haven to ride out the COVID-19 crisis than this property. It's extremely rural. You couldn't ask for better social distancing, and it features sunsets over the ocean and has a great big Rec room with a pool table, home theater, and super-fast 100-megabit cable internet to keep you connected to both Netflix and financial markets. I'd like to find a tenant for the duration of the COVID crisis. This property would be ideal for someone with a big family who wants to get out of New York City and ride the crisis out in the countryside.

To be clear, this property is currently booked in July and August. So I'd have to renegotiate with my current reservations, but I don't think that would be too hard given the circumstances. Now, this is a big place— 5 acres of oceanfront, 2 residences, and accommodations for up to 30 people. So it's not cheap— $1,000 a night during high season. But if your family can afford to live in New York City or Boston, you can probably afford to get out of the city for this crisis, which I strongly recommend. If you're interested, please email me via info@macrovoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: chart deck, S&P rally and the oil futures curve

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Josh on the show. It's always great to have some rational kind of a perspective on gold and just what are some of the real drivers behind gold prices and how to model

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more. Josh is a super guy. And again, folks, we're going to be bringing you more and more precious metals content on MacroVoices in coming weeks. Let's move on now to our postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says Big Picture Trading Chartbook. Patrick, as we dive in here on page 2, you're showing the S&P chart and basically the, the big sell-off that we had, 36%. in 32 days.

You had projected that maybe we would see a bear market rally up to a 50% Fibonacci retrace, which would be around 2,800. Now, I noticed that, you know, it looks like it's starting to roll over, and we got almost exactly to a 38.2% Fib retrace. Do you think that was it, or do you think we're still headed up to 2,800 before the bear market rally is over?

Patrick Ceresna: Right, so the key to this chart is I'm not actually forecasting that that will play out this way. What my goal here is Simply by me overlaying that, it'll be fun for us in the coming postgames to just kind of see how much the analog plays out to how the price action develops. It's never going to be the same, nor is it a forecast, but it's just going to be interesting. And the point really behind it is that it is very likely that the bear market is not over. And it's interesting, there's no shortage of very well-known people out there that are in that same camp. We should have David Rosenberg come back onto the show in the coming weeks or something to, 'cause he's also in that camp. And really what it is, is that when you have such an overextended market, you're gonna have a retrace.

It's gonna be a bounce. It's just so oversold that the market naturally backfills the move. And really at this stage, it's will we see 2,800? I still think that there's room for us to have one more surge in the coming week or two that could potentially go as high as 2,800. But really, I'm not gonna deviate from your view, which is that there's another leg in this bear market coming very likely in the coming week

Erik Townsend: Well, something that occurs to me, Patrick, after watching today's action in crude oil is, you know, maybe part of President Trump's motive— maybe he's actually not so crazy as to believe the nonsense that he tweeted. Maybe it was a little bit of an intentional flub where he knew that that tweet was gonna pump the oil market. We're coming into what everybody knows is kind of the really gonna be the hardest 2 or 3 weeks of the COVID-19 crisis. Maybe what the president's trying to do is pump markets up so that they've got further to fall as we get through the worst of the crisis. And maybe that's what he tried to do with the oil market today. Now, if that is his motive, presumably he might be trying to do something to get the stock market up another leg too. So maybe that 2,800 will still happen.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so let's move on to chart 3, page 3, where we have the crude oil chart. And, you know, this is where I want you to do a little bit of talking in terms of explaining how this also works from you, because you're, you're the one that trades oil markets far more than I do. But when a lot of retail investors and listeners engage a crude oil chart or look at that chart, they often associate it with a stock chart, something like Apple or, um, or an index like a SPY. And then they assume that wherever the price is and you buy buy it, then you have all the upside from there. And they don't understand the dynamic of how futures markets have monthly expiries. And these charts are often showing just the spot price, which is the front month oil contracts. And the contangos in the curve, which we'll talk about in the upcoming charts, actually influence whether or not you make money.

Like, you basically would need a very big percentage move in a very short period of time on that front month contract in order for that chart to, to show that gain there. And so we have on here that showing that May, June, July, August, and September oil contracts, you can see it goes $24.50 to $27.50 to $29.50 to $30.50 to $31.50 on those oil contracts. And each one of them are moving at different rates of change. Like for instance, when we see Donald Trump sending out that tweet, the Front month spot oil has actually popped $4.25 on this chart, but yet the September contracts are up barely $2, right? So what is it that our listeners need to understand about this and how do you always approach it?

Erik Townsend: Yeah, we've gotten a huge number of inquiries, whether it be emails or Twitter or what have you, with people saying, okay, you know, $20, this has got to be an incredible buying opportunity. Okay, maybe it's going to get down to $15, maybe it's going to get down to But I don't care. I can afford to buy it for $20. I know it's going back to $40 in the next couple of years. I know I'm going to double my money.

Well, the thing is, you don't double your money in commodity markets. If you buy at $20 and the price goes to $40, it doesn't mean you made $20, even though it kind of feels like you should have.

On page 3, you see that the May, June, July, August, and September contracts contracts are quoted. And the last trade price is showing you that, you know, each of these different 1-month contracts has a different price. It's a lot easier to see this if we move on first to slide 4. This shows you what the term structure usually looks like. So the leftmost yellow dot there at the very top of the chart, that would be the current expiring futures contract, what we call the front month. Then the next dot next to it the next month after that and the next month and so forth.

Once you get 2 or 3 months into it, generally speaking, the prices get lower and lower. There's a discount as you go further out in the curve. That condition is called backwardation, and it tends to be the, the most common shape of the crude oil futures market.

What we have when the market sells off dramatically is a situation called contango. or super contango, which is just a very exaggerated contango. Moving on to slide number 5, that's the same curve, but you see what's happened is, is the front month has sold all the way off to $20.

The very next month is like $4 higher, and the next month after that is another $3 higher. What that means is that if you buy that thing for $20, at the end of the month you're gonna have to roll it forward and you end up giving up $3 or $4 of price. So now you've rolled into the new contract, the price went from $20 to $24, but you didn't make anything on that. You, you're flat. And then a month later it goes from $24 to $27.

You still didn't make anything because each time that you roll forward you're losing that contango between the first and second month.

Postgame: oil ETFs, contango roll costs and tracking error

Erik Townsend: Now, a lot of people have said, wait a minute, that might be true in the futures market, but if I'm buying through an ETF, what does it matter? I've just, you know, there's only one price for the ETF.

Patrick Ceresna: So Erik, when I look at this deep contango curve that we see on the oil structure, it reminds me a lot of obviously the VIX futures, the volatility, and they're always trading contango. They have the negative carry as the, somebody who's long volatility has to continuously be rolling and is being essentially taxed for being long volatility. So a lot of people ask that question, you know, well, I can— I'm just gonna avoid having to deal with futures and I'll just buy the oil ETF. And that's where a lot of people don't get that those oil ETFs are rolling those futures inside those ETFs, right?

And so what we have on page 6 is I overlaid the crude oil chart, which is the candles, and then we overlaid 2 ETFs, which one is the USO, which is the unleveraged United States Oil Fund, and then the leveraged ProShares Ultra Crude Oil contract. And the point of looking at this chart in 2019 is it's showing the tracking during a period when there's backwardation. That's why we had that November 2019 chart that we were showing is it was showing that in backwardation, in fact, they can pretty well track oil half decently throughout this period, right?

What we find though is that, and like you were referencing earlier, Erik, is that on page 7, when we go back to when in 2016, when we saw that huge contango in oil as crude oil crashed down to $26 a barrel back then, as soon as that contango appeared in the curve, all of these ETFs materially underperformed the actual price of crude oil because they're rolling those futures in there, right?

Erik Townsend: Exactly. And if all of this business about rolling contracts is confusing anybody, a simpler way to think about it is this. In order for you to buy oil, you got to have a tank to store the oil in, and the cost of that storage is reflected by the contango in the market, the difference between one price and the next. Somebody has to pay that storage fee. And when we get to a crisis like this, the storage is at a super high premium in price, and it's the storage cost that's killing you. Now, if you buy the ETF, the ETF does all of the fancy footwork of the trading, but they still suffer those same losses. The point is, you can't buy $20 oil now and wait till the oil price is $40 and have doubled your money. It's actually possible to wait till the oil price has doubled and to have lost money. Now, that's probably an extreme case, but it has really tricked a lot of people.

They thought they were going to double or triple their money. The oil price doubled or tripled, but they only made 15% or 20%. It's called tracking error, and it's inherent to any ETF that tracks the price of a physical commodity.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: commodity, and it's particularly pronounced in a situation like this where crude oil has reached a super contango condition. And finally, moving on to slide 8, folks, don't forget you can get a free trial of Big Picture Trading. Just go to bigpicturetrading.com and sign up for your free trial.

Postgame: COVID-19 update and the China response

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, now let's move on. I've been waiting all show to get that update from you on the COVID-19. So what's going on? What's new?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we broke 1 million cases and 50,000 deaths today. So 2 big important psychological milestones there. Good news, if there is any here, is Italy and maybe also France appear to be finally starting to peak in terms of new infections. That's new infections. That doesn't mean the crisis is over. The crisis still goes on for a few more months, and the peak in deaths will come several weeks later. But at least there's a light at the end of the tunnel for Italy.

The worst is still to come for the rest of the world, and particularly the United States. The next 2 to 3 weeks is when the exponential acceleration occurs until we finally reach the point of peak infections, which should come mid-month for New York City, a little bit later in the month for the rest of the United States, and for most other countries in the world. The crisis is going to continue for several months after the peak, but at least markets will have a light at the end of the tunnel when we see that the virus has peaked in terms of new infections. What we're going to be facing, unfortunately, a completely overwhelmed hospital system and the need to triage patients. Potentially, that's going to lead to that reflexive feedback loop that causes the case fatality rate to increase increase dramatically after the healthcare system is completely overwhelmed. But at least we'll know there's a light at the end of the tunnel.

We've reached the peak level of infections, and it's a matter of time until it gets better. The ongoing crisis, though, I think that we're going to realize is bigger than most people have expected. So a lot of these V-shaped recovery charts floating around where they're anticipating what's going to happen in terms of oil demand or in terms of economic activity. And they have this giant V-shaped chart that centers on mid-April. So they appear to be picking the target for peak infections and saying, okay, there's going to be, you know, a drag until we get to peak infections, then it's all going to get better.

Wait a minute, why would you expect it to get better? When we have peak infections, we have an overwhelmed healthcare system, we have a lot of people that are very sick, we have people dying, we have an economy that's shut down and needs to stay shut down for several more weeks. So at least when we get to the point where we're not just to peak infections, but we've really got new infections under control, like Fauci said, I think today, when there are no more new infections, that's when we can reopen the economy. But it's not going to be mid-April. It's going to be well into May before we get to that point. So I think everybody that's expecting expecting a V-shaped recovery on asset prices, on demand for energy and so forth, is going to be surprised.

I think it's more likely to be a U-shaped recovery. There's more and more news coming out, Patrick, that China's recovery is faltering. It looks like they may have tried to restart everything in China too soon, and now they're seeing a recurrence of new infections. So they tried to do exactly what President Trump is promising to do: get the economy back online as soon as possible. And it looks like it's starting to blow up in their face.

My own greatest concerns in this crisis, Patrick, have shifted now from the virus itself to the response to the virus, maybe leading to some really scary international conflicts. The last couple of days, a blame game has erupted. In the US political machine where all of a sudden they're blaming China for everything. Frankly, folks, the US has badly botched its response to the virus. Yes, it's absolutely true that China has not been truthful about its cases and so forth, but we all knew that. The US government has done a horrible job of responding to data that it's had since January and that has been very well known.

I think As it's blowing up in their face, the Trump administration doesn't want to admit they screwed up, so now it's going to be China's fault. I think that scapegoating China, even though it's true that China is guilty for sure, 100% guilty of fabricated statistics and understating the number of cases and infections and deaths that they had— they did all that stuff, it's true— but to scapegoat them for the United States botched response to this is really, really dangerous.

We have to remember that China is not Afghanistan. It's not Iraq. If we get into a shooting war with China, we're dealing with an adversary that literally has the nuclear capability to destroy the United States at the push of a button. Everything that we used to fear in the Cold War with the Soviet Union, China has enough submarine-launched ballistic missiles to destroy the entire United States. It is widely believed that China has so-called carrier killer hypersonic missiles that are capable of overcoming defense systems and sinking US aircraft carriers. The last thing that we want to do, whether China lied about their data or not, is to start a war with China. And I really hope that this blaming China And it doesn't escalate to the point where these words eventually lead to hostility between these superpowers, because I think it could get really scary.

And to be sure, it's the United States' response which has been embarrassing. There was just a governor, I forget which state, today tweeting saying there's new news that it's possible for there to be asymptomatic transmission with this virus. And they say that the news has only come out in the last 24 hours.

Patrick Ceresna: Wow.

Erik Townsend: Look, you heard about that on MacroVoices along with a cogent explanation of why it was so important and why it dramatically increased the risk of widespread contagion back on the January 30th episode of this podcast. It's not new news, and people in our government are acting just astonishingly incompetently in terms of their understanding of this situation.

The event that's about to happen to the United States is one of our own making. It was our government's botched response to known information. Yes, China lied, but that's not the reason this is about to go as badly as it's going to go. It's going to go this way because we screwed up, not because China lied.

Finally, I just want— and those are my opinions. I certainly respect the prerogative of many listeners to disagree. I respect your right to your own opinions. I hope that everyone, though, regardless of whether we agree or disagree on the fault of the U.S. government in this crisis, will join me in saluting the true heroes of the day, which without a doubt are our healthcare workers who are facing an incredible challenge. They don't have the personal protective equipment that they need, and they're risking their lives in order to save ours. So if there are any healthcare workers in your life, please do everything that you can to support them.

Research Roundup, sign-off and disclaimer

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for the update, Erik. For our listeners, we're gonna continue doing this coronavirus update always here in the postgame at the end of the show.

Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at TopTradersUnplugged.com/MacroGuide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in

Patrick Ceresna: In the Research Roundup, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the charts we discussed in the postgame. Also a link to an article from David Rosenberg that there's only a 20% chance that we've hit a bottom on the stocks, as well as an article from Jesse Felder titled Got Gold? So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback.

Erik Townsend: Thank you, Patrick.

Patrick Ceresna: feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests, and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes. MacroVoices is MacroVoices presented for informational and entertainment purposes. is a production of Bloomberg Television and MacroVoices only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Simon White — Variant Perception co-founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode 212 opening: monetary and fiscal stimulus

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 212 was recorded on March 26th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by my own vacation rental property on the coast of Maine, which I'm repurposing as a COVID-19 safe haven for families who want to escape city life for a few months during this crisis.

It's been said that in finance there are decades when nothing happens and weeks when decades happen. This has been a week when decades happened. Monday morning saw the biggest monetary policy intervention in world history, with the US Federal Reserve embarking on a new program of quantitative easing with an unlimited asset purchase budget. Then on Wednesday evening, the Senate unanimously passed the biggest fiscal policy intervention in U.S. history in the form of a $2 trillion fiscal stimulus deal.

The bill had not passed in the House of Representatives when we taped today's podcast, but imminent passage is widely expected. Meanwhile, President Trump has announced aggressive plans to begin reopening the U.S. economy by Easter. But several signs suggest he may be losing the confidence of his medical advisors, with Dr. Anthony Fauci commenting in a separate television interview that you don't get to set the timeline because the virus sets the timeline. So what does all of this mean for markets? Are all the ingredients in place to drive a sustained recovery from here, or would it be more accurate to say that both epic monetary and epic fiscal stimulus are now fully priced in? Leaving the government with no further ammunition to support asset markets should they fall farther from here.

Variant Perception co-founder Simon White joins me to answer that question as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the situation and what it means for the market outlook in coming weeks and months. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment. Patrick has prepared another of his famous postgame chart decks to talk us through where we currently stand in the evolution of the market's reaction to these historic events.

Unlimited QE, the $2 trillion stimulus and corporate bailouts

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, before we even get to the coronavirus update in markets, let's start with this week's historic monetary and fiscal stimulus interventions. What happened? What does it mean?

Erik Townsend: Well, Monday at 8 AM, the Fed announced unlimited quantitative easing to begin immediately, and it expressly includes buying corporate bonds in addition to Treasury bonds. Now, in my opinion, that undermines the intention of the Federal Reserve Act. They, they did They did some fancy footwork and figured out a way to kind of follow the letter of the law, if not the intent of the law. I think they want to include buying stocks, but in order to do that, they're going to need an actual act of Congress. A lot of people thought they needed an act of Congress just to buy corporate bonds, but they seem to be doing that, making up their own rules, if you will.

In perspective, QE2 was that great big controversial quantitative easing program that spent $500 billion in just 8 months. And it was considered very, very controversial at the time because that was a heck of a lot of money. The Fed spent more than $500 billion so far this week, and they've said that their intention is to continue spending more than the size of QE2 every single week starting this week, next week, and the week after that, indefinitely.

Then on Wednesday evening, the Senate passed a $2 trillion $2 trillion fiscal stimulus bill. The House is expected to pass it. We had Bernie Sanders, and you know, I never, Patrick, in 3 million years would have thought that I would say this on the show, but I'm actually in agreement with Bernie Sanders, who says, hey, wait a minute, what's with all this corporate welfare? Why are we bailing out the cruise ship industry? The private jet industry wants a bailout. This doesn't make any sense. I think for the first time in my life, I agree completely with Bernie Sanders, but nobody else seems to see it that way.

So So once we get past Bernie's objections, passage of this $2 trillion stimulus is expected from the House, and of course the president is waiting to sign it. There's no apparent concern for who eventually is going to pay for all of these bailouts. And, you know, why the heck are we bailing out the cruise ship industry? I sure don't get it, Patrick.

Coronavirus update: Hammer and Dance, Ferguson and timing of the bottom

Patrick Ceresna: Now let's touch on the coronavirus situation. Once again, you produced a full hour-long coronavirus update podcast that we released Tuesday morning featuring Lenore Hawkins reporting from northern Italy and Dr. Steve Bickel reporting from Florida, which is now becoming quite the hotspot for the coronavirus. Listeners can find that podcast free of charge on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. But Erik, what has changed since that Tuesday morning when you recorded that?

Erik Townsend: Well, a whole lot has changed. First of all, there was a lot of news reports that maybe Italy is starting to peak in terms of new infections. That was a great sign of relief. But now after today's numbers, it seems like maybe they're not peaking after all. Maybe there's another wave in Italy.

The US and the rest of the world, of course, is considerably behind Italy, so there's still plenty of time to go before anyone else gets to a peak.

There's a really important article that came out the end of last week called The Hammer and the Dance, and we have it linked in your Research Roundup email, or you can just Google Hammer and Dance. Briefly, it's not really new information, but I think it's the most concise, well-written article to date. laying out what the real challenge is that we face and why it's so important. The metaphor of the hammer and the dance says basically what's needed right now is a really, really big, strong policy action, locking things down, getting people to just stay home and not interact with other people to get this viral outbreak under control. So that's the hammer part. The dance is then once you get R-naught, which is that transmissivity index that measures the contagion of the virus. Once you get that down below 1, where you're not growing the size of the epidemic anymore, the dance is how do you start to reopen the economy while doing it in a careful way that doesn't push R-naught back above 1 to the point where the epidemic goes out of control again?

Quite frankly, President Trump wants to go straight to the dance without suffering the pain of the hammer, and I think that that is going to end very very badly. I don't think that the governors and mayors of the country are going to allow it. I think they'll take matters into their own hands and impose their own hammers where they're necessary if the federal government is not going to stand up and lead the way.

And I'm convinced, Patrick, the reason for today's 200 S&P point rally was because of news coming out that Professor Neil Ferguson had supposedly admitted that he was wrong and changed his mind about the report that was very widely circulated a couple of weeks ago. Now, if you dive into this, he's not really wrong about anything. What he is reporting is that he now believes that the virus is even more contagious than previously thought, and therefore already more people have it than previously thought. Now, he's saying that this may lead to a different set of expectations around how long of a lockdown is needed in order to get us through this. There were a lot of reports out that seemed to imply that what this means is we're not gonna have any problem with overwhelming the healthcare system. I don't think that's accurate. I think that Professor Ferguson is right, that the R-naught value is higher than he thought it was.

It's not just 2.5, it's at least 3, maybe 4 or even 6. That means that this is even more dangerous and we need a hammer even more than ever. It may mean that we're closer to herd immunity than than we previously thought, but I don't think it's cause for the huge amount, you know, the 200 S&P point rally that happened in reaction to it. I don't think it's really cause for that.

So restarting the economy by Easter, as President Trump wants to do, in my opinion, would be a grave mistake that would ultimately cost thousands of lives. Because if you rush things, as Dr. Anthony Fauci said later in a separate interview, you know, the virus controls the timeline. You don't get to set the timeline. The virus sets the timeline.

I don't think President Trump is going to stay the course. I think he was just trying to provide reassurance. Maybe he'll come to his senses. If not, the governors and mayors will impose their own hammers. But we need the hammer before we can get to the dance. And I really encourage you, if there's just one article that you read about this crisis, it's the hammer and the dance. We're still in the exponential growth stage.

Predictably, the numbers are gonna get a lot worse from here. We haven't even gotten to the point of overwhelming our healthcare system in the United States. I still think it's coming. And I do think I don't think that Professor Ferguson's announcements— I mean, just look at what's going on in Italy and Spain. They're having to triage to the point of literally cutting people over a certain age off from life support, giving them sedatives, and allowing them to die because they don't have enough equipment to respond to this crisis. So there's no reason to assume we're not going to see the same things in the United States, but people seem to want to interpret Professor Ferguson's statements this morning to mean that, and I don't think that's correct. So I think this big rally is going to come back out of the market pretty soon. If we don't have the hammer now, if we try to reopen the economy by Easter, it's just going to make the problem worse, and it's going to take longer to ultimately recover.

The reality of the situation is not plan to restart the economy by Easter, but rather prepare for the reality of triage, having to not be able to help all of the people in the United States that need medical care. Care and being forced to cut some of them off and allow them to die because you can't help everybody. That's what's already happening in Italy and Spain, and I don't think Professor Ferguson's new views are going to change that for the United States. I still think it's coming.

I am going to change my market view though. I had previously said I don't think that the market bottoms until the end of May, which would coincide with really the, the peak hospital overload. The thing is, it's more likely now that I've I've reevaluated my view. I think the market probably bottoms when we hit peak infections, new infections on a daily basis. Peaking is probably in the end of April. So I think the market bottom comes a little earlier than I previously predicted. But, you know, if, if we go through this Easter Bunny nonsense and delay the hammer, it's going to take longer and it's going to be much worse. So it depends a little bit on policy from here.

S&P 500: the 2,174 low and 2,642 retracement target

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the S&P 500 because we're going 3, 4 trading sessions off of the low. We're testing 2,600 on the top end on the S&P 500. This bounce is definitely underway and it's probably going to lead to another short, but where do you think this is going?

Erik Townsend: Well, what a week, Patrick. We have been, you know, we started locked limit down at 2,174 on Sunday night because based on the weekend news with the virus reports getting worse, you know, over the weekend. Everybody seemed to be thinking, okay, it can only go down from here. And then of course, Monday morning, you get the Fed announcing astonishingly the biggest monetary policy intervention in recorded history. We're going to do a bigger QE than all of QE2 every single week from here out. And the market, of course, goes straight up.

The really amazing thing, Patrick, and I think this is such strong evidence that the Fed put has finally expired. That big spike up in asset prices in reaction to the monetary policy announcement only lasted 2 hours before it had fully retraced. But then you get the combination of the fiscal stimulus bill and particularly President Trump telling everyone in the Monday press conference that his plan is to restart the economy by Easter and we're not really going to, you know, it's not going to affect us, it can't happen here. As Dr. Fauci says, you don't get to set the timeline, the virus sets the timeline. timeline. And I don't think President Trump's fantasies about Easter are realistic. But that's what he's telling people. That's what the market's reacting to.

And that really got the rally going. So we came off of those 2,174 lows shooting all the way up to 2,400. And then it was the news this morning that I think has been misinterpreted in the way it's been reported. Professor Ferguson did change his view, but he said the virus is more contagious. It's worse than we thought. And that may mean that more people already have it. And therefore, in order to get to herd immunity, maybe you don't need the 18-month lockdown that he once thought might be necessary. That's not to say that we don't have a problem. And it's not to say that the US healthcare system is not going to be overwhelmed the way Italy and Spain's healthcare systems have. So right now, I don't know how much farther we have to go.

You don't get to the 38.2% retracement of this great big huge move down from 33-whatever it was until about 2642, I believe, is the 38.2 fib retracement. So that would be a good target for where this might top out. I'm not sure it's done there either. But as we get to more bad news on the virus front, I think eventually this tops out and we end up— I don't think the low is in yet. I think we're going below 2174. I think we're going to go probably to 2000 or lower before this is over. But right now, everybody's got the idea that everything's better and President Trump's going to open the economy by Easter. Ain't going to happen, folks. But for now, the market, the combination of this getting us to 2,400 and then the, I think, misinterpretation of what Professor Ferguson has said got us to 2,600. Do we go to 2,800 on the next bit of fake news?

I'm not sure. But eventually, I think we move much lower.

Dollar index versus gold and fiat currencies

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the dollar index because it's more or less paused its advance and particularly driven by A significant euro bounce. We have the dollar index now retracing that big breakout. Do you think this is a buy on dip on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it would be perfectly normal to see the dollar pull back. The 104 level that it just barely touched would be the previous multi-year high. It's not an all-time high, but I think it's— I don't know how many years it goes back, bigger, more years than the chart that I've got in front of me right now.

So does it break higher from here? Probably. I've made the case before, Patrick, for this global pandemic to be dollar positive. But hold on a second. We've got unlimited quantitative easing forever, upwards of $500 billion, not for the whole program, but per week for an unlimited amount of time. And that's to buy assets, including corporate bonds. And I think it's going to include stocks as soon as they can pull off the act of Congress that they need in order to include stocks as well. So this has got to be very, very dilutive to the dollar. Do we still have what I've predicted, that the dollar appreciates relative to other fiat currencies? Probably, but it depends on what other central banks do, because if they don't follow suit and it's just the Fed that's printing money like crazy, it's got to be dollar negative relative to other currencies.

What I am sure Is that gold is going to outperform all fiat currencies. 'Cause we're diluting the value of the currency in order to bail out cruise ship industry and maybe the private jet industry and everybody else that seems to want or expect a bailout. $2 trillion fiscal stimulus package and unlimited monetary stimulus, that's just got to dilute the value of fiat currency, and gold is gonna be the big winner. Whether or not other fiat currencies do better than the dollar or worse than the dollar, It's not as clear as it was a few weeks ago.

Crude oil: super contango, EIA inventories, SPR purchases

Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to crude oil. What's going on?

Erik Townsend: Well, based on extreme weakness in RBOB gasoline, I thought we were gonna get to the teens this week, but then Trump's Easter Bunny story and the dual stimulus was, you know, obviously a major bump higher. I was actually surprised we didn't get higher than we did. Then Pompeo asked Mohammed bin Salman to rise to the occasion and end the price war with Russia. MBS didn't make any commitment to do that. But the market is pricing in at least some possibility that he might. We saw some very interesting action where RBOB gasoline, which normally is a very good predictor of what crude oil is going to do next— RBOB was straight down while crude oil was straight up.

The only explanation I can come up with to explain that is somebody, and I mean somebody really big, is puking crack spreads, which of course is a trade that involves opposite direction positions on crude oil and gasoline. That action seems to have ended, Patrick, and we're seeing particularly today on Thursday, just as I predicted on this program, the market is really breaking into a super contango condition with about $3.20 on the May-June spread. The June-July spread is about $2.50 or so. And this is— these are numbers earlier this afternoon. I'm not looking at the screen right now. And $1.50 on the July-August spread. So we're seeing a big, big super contango developing.

I think that that is going to continue to get wider and wider with those time spreads blowing out to record proportions as front-month prices crash. Now, they're not crashing yet. I think that that's coming. We saw weakness late this afternoon in WTI crude, and I think that that phenomenon is going to continue until we reach the point of peak infections in the United States, probably toward the end of April.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, I can tell you just from the chart on crude that the price action remains very distributive, so it'll be really interesting to see if we get into the teens by next week. Anyway, how did the EIA inventory come in this week?

Erik Townsend: Crude oil building 1.6 million barrels, not as big of a build as you would expect. You know, the, the whole story here is about an expectation that the storage tanks are going to fill up because of weak demand in this coronavirus crisis. 1.6 million barrels is a build on inventory, but it's not a massive one. Cushing, Oklahoma Oklahoma building 858,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 1.5 million barrels. Distillates drawing down 679,000 barrels. How in the heck is it possible that finished products are drawing down in, in this environment when demand is weakening? The answer is there was a big increase in finished product exports, up 600,000 barrels this week alone. So that's what's happening is the finished products are getting sent overseas. Why only the small builds in crude? It's coming, folks. Wait for it. I think that the market needs to see confirmation, though. A lot of people, a lot of traders are saying, wait a minute, okay, the EIA is not reporting this super huge crude oil build phenomenon that everybody was expecting.

Maybe it's not really going to happen. You know, I spent a lot of time wishing that this virus thing maybe wouldn't really happen. Maybe the builds won't really happen. Well, well, they're coming, folks. When they do and we actually have the numbers in front of us, I think that's what's going to cause the market to make the next major leg down. And I think in the $16 to $17 range in WTI is where we're headed, but maybe not until next week's inventory report.

US production ticked down just 100,000 barrels to 13 million barrels even, just below the record level that we were at previously. Imports, 6.1 million barrels. Exports, 3.9 million barrels.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: Tape action— well, that smaller-than-expected build gave us a rally, but frankly, it was a rally that didn't even get us to the previous overnight low, and it just barely got as far as the 8-day moving average. So that build didn't take us very high, and the tape has turned weak again this afternoon.

Now, Patrick, the US government had previously announced intentions to fill the Strategic Petroleum Reserve by buying crude oil from US producers. They withdrew those plans today. Apparently, they need to save their money so they can bail out the private jet business and the cruise ship business, and they don't have budget to fill up the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, taking advantage of bargain prices and helping out the hardworking men and women that keep the US shale industry alive.

Go figure on that one. It seems like apparently it just didn't pass somehow when they tried to push it through.

Gold recovery and the Bridgewater rumor

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to gold because what a recovery this week. Gold basically now erasing the majority of the losses from the prior week's sell-off. And what's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: People have said that the fiscal stimulus was bullish for gold. That's not right. Bullish is not right. Super bullish is not right. Uber bullish is not right. Patrick, there is no adjective in the English language that adequately describes how incredibly bullish the dual fiscal and monetary policy stimulus is for gold. You can't get more bullish than this. So I would say what's amazing is not the fact that we had this massive $200 rally just in a matter of a couple of days. I'd say what's amazing is how small it was, because there's plenty of fundamental rationale for this news to take us well north of $2,000 an ounce.

So why didn't that happen? Well, it's the same reason that I've described before. We're still in a crisis situation. Now, right now, at this moment, stock market prices are just racing higher on what I believe is a misinterpretation of Neil Ferguson's latest announcement. And it actually looks, as we're recording, like maybe a top is in. It started to retrace about 20 points just in the time that we've been speaking. So, we're going to have another big move down in stocks. At least, that's my prediction. And when that happens, it could pull gold down with it for the same reasons it has before, which is correlation. Go to one in a crisis.

There are rumors of Bridgewater puking gold, and perhaps Bridgewater is facing a lot of large redemptions from Saudi Arabia. That's the rumor anyway. That would mean that by the end of the month, Bridgewater has to sell a certain amount of gold, and they're certainly going to take advantage of high prices and sell. So that might be putting a cap on the move where it is.

What's clear, though, is after the panic lows are in for stocks, after we get through this stock market crisis because of the coronavirus situation, Eventually, gold is going to scream higher, and not just to its recent highs, but much higher than that. The big question, of course, is do we still go down first, or do we just go straight up from here because this news is so profoundly bullish it just defies any adjective? I don't know.

You know, I, I want to say there's still a chance that we're going to get a significant pullback, but my belief that we were going to get below $1,350 because of the impact that I saw coming to the stock market Now that this news is out about the fiscal and monetary stimulus, I think it's hard for gold to go much lower than its recent lows.

Physical versus paper gold

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, we got several listener emails, and at the same time, we had seen several articles published this week about the breakdowns in the physical gold market and the paper price decoupling from the physical metal price. What's going on there?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, that answer comes in 2 parts. The first part is an old story repeating that we've been through many times before. I can't believe that people keep falling for it, frankly. But current events do bring about a new story. So let's cover both halves of this.

The old story is this: anytime that there's any kind of crisis which creates a lot of demand for retail gold and silver coins and bars, the small silver and gold rounds and, you know, Gold Eagles and, and so forth, the various retail products, what happens is the physical dealers start peddling the This bullshit story about how supposedly the paper price of gold has decoupled from the physical price because the system is failing and the end of the world is coming and the sky is falling and the secret cabal that is trying to manipulate the gold price is finally disintegrating. It's all a bunch of unadulterated bullshit. What's going on is the physical price of gold and the paper price of gold are exactly the same as long as we're talking about the physical price for 400-ounce London Good Delivery bars, the wholesale-sized piece of gold.

What happens is those retail products, the small coins and retail bars, are in short supply. So, what the dealers do is they price gouge. They mark them up dramatically. So, suddenly, there's a huge differential between the price of gold to buy London Good Delivery bars, the 400-ounce bars, and that's the same as the paper price that you see quoted. It's the same as the price that's reflected by the GLD.

You have to pay a great big premium in order to order Gold Eagles and other retail-sized coins because they're in short supply due to a temporary condition of strong demand. Rather than stock up and be ready for that strong demand, the dealers are smart enough to go the other way. They publish articles talking about how there's a breakdown between the gold price, the paper price, and the physical price. They make up all kinds of bullshit. It's not real, people.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Don't fall for it. So, that's the first part of the story.

But in this coronavirus crisis, we really do have a part 2 to the story, which is there really are bona fide issues with getting good delivery bars, the 400-ounce bars, out of the London Bullion Market Association, because London, the City of London, is locked down because of the coronavirus crisis. So, you can't deliver more 400-ounce bars from LBMA.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: to the refiners that actually create those small retail coins and bars. If they can't buy more 400-ounce bars as their wholesale stock to make more coins and, you know, retail products from, then obviously the shortage intensifies. That allows them to price gouge even more and mark those retail products up to a huge premium over the actual price of gold. And in order to make you feel like you're not getting price gouged, they tell you this ridiculous story about how there's a breakdown.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: Down going on between the physical price and the paper price, and you better move quick and pay that big upload in order to not miss your chance because it might be impossible to ever get physical gold again if you don't act right now.

It's all a bunch of nonsense. If you want to buy physical gold at the current paper price, it's very easy to do. You buy the GLD ETF. And by the way, folks, the physical gold that's owned by the GLD ETF is just as physical as the physical gold that you can buy in coins and bars. You sit on your GLD shares for a few months until this crisis has passed, and at that point you sell the GLD shares and you use the money to buy your retail coins and bars at reasonable prices when that big premium comes out of the market.

You have to believe that the, the whole system is failing and the world is coming to an end in order to not be able to see that that approach is Therefore, the dealers will tell you that the whole world is coming to an end, the sky is falling, and you better move right now and pay that big premium. Otherwise, you're gonna miss your chance. It's all a bunch of bullshit. Don't fall for it.

10-year yields, risk parity and the lead-in to Simon White

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's talk 10-year Treasury yields. I mean, things have stabilized, but it still looks like those yields are holding their own. And are we going for another shot at zero here?

Erik Townsend: I don't know where we're going, Patrick. I'm at the point where I'm not trying to figure out that I know the answer. I'm better at asking the right question than knowing the answer myself, and I'm trying to ask it of the smartest people I can get my hands on. The question, and I'm convinced this is the question to ask, is, are we seeing the beginning of the long-feared event where both stocks and bonds are going to sell off together at the same time, backing Treasury yields up considerably from where they are here? I don't know the answer. I do know the consequences are staggering. Staggering. If that is starting to happen, it means the whole institutional risk parity complex will have to be unwound, and that's going to have a really, really ugly impact on markets. So let's ask Simon White that question. He's better qualified to answer it than I am.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, so this week's featured interview guest is Variant Perception co-founder Simon White. Why did we invite Simon back as our guest this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, the Variant Perception guys in general are very data-oriented. They don't just go by the seat of their pants. They work from hard data and they do a lot of really great analysis. And they're also very good at understanding not just macro but fixed income markets. And I think, as I just said in the discussion about where Treasury yields are headed, that's a really important topic this week. So I'm looking forward to asking Simon about the monetary policy intervention. Now, the fiscal stimulus had not been announced when we taped this interview on Tuesday morning, but the discussion that we had about the monetary stimulus, I think, stands as a good proxy

Erik Townsend: for how we can interpret the significance of the fiscal stimulus as well.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macrovoices.

Guide, and be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out TopTradersUnplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Simon White is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Fed's unlimited QE and the market reaction

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Simon White, co-founder of Variant Perception. Simon, there's an old saying in finance that sometimes nothing happens for decades and then there are weeks during which decades happen. I think this is one of those weeks. Monday morning, just after 8 AM this This week, we got news that the Federal Reserve made what I think was the biggest monetary intervention announcement in recorded history, announcing unlimited quantitative easing to react to the coronavirus crisis. And specifically, you know, it was very, very controversial when QE2 was introduced several years ago. That was a spending program of $500 billion over the course of about 8 months, and it was very controversial. A lot of people thought that was just too much and they They shouldn't do it. What the Fed announced this week is, first, they're gonna spend more than that this week alone, and they're gonna continue spending at that rate indefinitely.

The thing that I think is even more— you know, we could do a whole show about that announcement, but what I think is even more newsworthy is the market's reaction. Of course, asset markets had to jerk higher on the news. That lasted, Simon, less than 2 hours before—

Simon White: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: before the move up in asset prices had fully retraced, which really speaks volumes in my mind. It says that the Fed put has finally expired worthless. Please give us your interpretation of these events and what are the knock-on effects and consequences as you expect them to play out in financial markets?

Fed facilities, swap lines and solvency risk

Simon White: Well, thank you, first of all, Erik, for, for having me. I think that's an excellent starting question and one that We could probably go down many different avenues, but I think the first thing you say is absolutely correct.

This is a gargantuan move from the Federal Reserve. What really this virus has exposed, in the same way it ruthlessly exposes the comorbidities, that's existing conditions of people, it's exposed the comorbidities of the market. In terms of broader Western markets that have been on a secular decline, aging societies, essentially the virus is now just the trigger for the Japanification of the United States and of most of the Western countries.

It also was the trigger for many of the underlying imbalances that all of us probably in the markets knew were building, essentially one giant short volatility position. So when it comes to the Fed, monetary policy, it's been clear for some time, has been running out of road. And what happened over the last week is essentially threw the kitchen sink at everything.

As you said, even this in this particular situation was not enough to salve people's confidence, which has been shaken. The damage done to sentiment over the last few weeks is vast.

As part of the Fed's facilities, as you mentioned, we've now got QE infinity. We've got forward guidance. I would be surprised if we ever leave the zero rate regime for the foreseeable future for many, many, many years. As a reminder, by the way, in Japan, when it went through this kind of seismic shift down in rates.

The proximate cause there was the Kobe earthquake in 1995. They responded to that by slashing interest rates much lower, and interest rates have never seen these sort of levels again. You know, that was obviously 25 years ago. Fast forward to the US, you know, we've had a similar trigger event. No one knows what it's going to be, but it was vulnerable and markets were fragile to that event.

So the Fed has introduced swap lines. You know, we've been talking to our clients about the offshore dollar funding pressures that have been building. So far, this is— in that sense, it's not like 2008. 2008 was, was, it was a broader dollar funding issue onshore and offshore. And thus far, it's primarily been concentrated as an offshore problem. So the Fed has expanded its swap lines to, to kind of deal with that.

We've had all sorts of the usual bowl of alphabet soup if you like, of different facilities, commercial paper facility, the money market facility. And this was something that we were watching for again is the PMCCF and the SMCCF, which is the primary market corporate credit facility and the secondary market corporate credit facility. These are really seismic moves. They've managed to get around not adjusting the Federal Reserve Act. They're in special investment vehicles.

This really is the Fed stepping in straight to investment-grade businesses and essentially lending their to them.

And I think one fundamental difference with 2008 is 2008, it was primarily a liquidity issue, and therefore the government or the central bank could rely on the banks to provide that liquidity to where it was kind of needed, and obviously to themselves that needed it. This time around, you know, even with all the guarantees, we have a solvency issue. So we have a whole bunch of companies and people essentially who, you know, money in, money out, and the money in was more than the money out, and they could keep things ticking taking over. Now, we essentially have a whole bunch of companies that are essentially now just liabilities.

In the UK, for instance, we had a loan guarantee scheme. I don't think that'll work, because the banks still have to keep 20% skin in the game. Now, if I'm a bank, and a company comes to borrow from me, and they say, look, we're losing £40,000 a week, or whatever it might be, and that no one really knows how long this is going to go on for, even if I only got 20%, I'm probably not going to lend to them.

So the logical conclusion of this is kind of what the Fed's just done, is you just have to lend to them direct. The same way in the UK, you know, there's no point in— the US had a facility where essentially the government would lend companies money for them to pay their employees. Probably not going to work. They're just going to lay them off anyway, and the government has to pay them the unemployment benefits. In the UK, we just went straight to the shortcut, and we're paying them direct. So again, you know, momentous changes are happening in front of our eyes and things that are going to— we're going to be living with the aftereffects for a huge amount of time.

Go back to the credit facility in the Fed. As I say, I think that's a seismic shift as well, but it's also what needed to be done. The credit markets are the most direct link between markets and the economies. It's when you get these nasty feedback loops developing between the two that you get recessions.

If the credit markets were allowed to run rampant and allowed to continue to blow out as they were, then that's going to mean the recession is going to be much deeper and longer than anyone would like.

One problem, of course, is all the kind of credit that's been issued or offered, sorry, to these companies, it's only investment grade. So that still leaves high yield leveraged loans. Leveraged loans is now a bigger market than high yield. These aspects of the market are still in the lurch, you know, and as we speak, we're watching high yield spreads continue to blow out.

Leveraged loans they're harder to track because they're very illiquid, which is another major issue with where we've been in recent years. They are considerably under pressure as well.

Exogenous shocks versus recessions; pandemics and what markets need

Erik Townsend: Simon, you mentioned recessions. Now, I know you guys at Variant Perception do a lot of work modeling history and evaluating how economic transition changes occur. It seems to me a recession is different from an exogenous shock, which is the way I would describe this event. Tell us a little bit about that. How do recessions and exogenous shocks compare, particularly with respect to whether the market anticipates them or not?

Simon White: Yeah, I mean, that's a very good question. And obviously, where we are today, you know, very, very relevant. This is obviously a huge exogenous shock that may precipitate a recession. The way recessions Recessions tend to develop, as you say, we've done a lot of work in this, is they're not very linear processes. Economies don't go from a non-recessionary to recessionary state in a linear fashion. They do so in a highly nonlinear fashion. That's because you get these feedback loops developing between the real economy and between markets.

Now, when it comes to an exogenous shock, that's obviously something like a true black swan event.

How markets respond to the two is actually very interesting. If you look at previous historic For instance, if you look at World War I or Pearl Harbor or even the first Gulf War, what you tended to— needed to see was a material improvement in the exogenous shock before the market actually turned up. With recessions, however, the market basically is quite happy to kind of front-run the business cycle.

Markets are kind of quite comfortable, if you like, with a sort of run-of-the-mill recession where you basically have the business cycle has turned down for one reason, say there's been a housing market blow up, and then you go through this recessionary process, and then the market begins to turn up. So what you'll often see is the market tends to bottom before the recession is officially deemed to have ended. But with exogenous shocks, it doesn't work like that. So in World War I, they closed the market. They closed the market for, I think, 9 months. And actually opening the market was the kind of positive exogenous shock. The market kind of sold off for a little bit after that, and then it rallied, and it actually rallied all through the rest of the First World War, right through into 1918.

Also, when you look at Pearl Harbor, obviously, that was an exogenous shock in 1941. The market didn't begin turning up until there was a subsequent battle where the first tactical advantage the US got over the Japanese. After that, again, the market continued rallying all through the rest of the Second World War. Similarly, in the First Gulf War in early 1990, the market didn't really start turning up until Operation Desert Storm.

But with recessions, as I say, what you always see is that the market tends to turn up beforehand. And, you know, it's obviously— it might be a moot point right now whether we're going to see a recession. Obviously, the question is, is how deep and how long the recession is going to be. But, you know, we looked historically at pandemics. So there's been 3 major pandemics in the 20th century. Obviously, the Spanish flu in 1918-1919, The so-called Asian flu in 1957, and the Hong Kong flu, which was in 1967.

All of these preceded recessions. Obviously, you never know exactly why the recession happened. Certainly, the one coming out of the end of the First World War, the economy was in a different state back then because of the war, but certainly, the 3 previous pandemics we've had, there's been a recession that's closely followed.

What's different today, of course, is we've never experienced such draconian response to a pandemic. That's really going to really forge how different the dynamic goes forward. Where we are today in terms of what's the market fixating on, the market seems to be fixating on the virus itself. That's one of the reasons why, to your first question, Erik, about why was what the Fed did, why did the market not immediately jump on that? Obviously, we're up today. But why did the market not immediately jump in that?

I think what the market really needs to see here is 3 things, really, a coordinated response between monetary policy. As we've discussed, monetary policy has probably now shot all its bullets. We need to see fiscal policy. Unfortunately, there still seems to be some disagreement in Congress about getting a proper fiscal package through. We are hopeful it happens relatively soon. This happened back in 2008. The TARP bill didn't go through, I think September 28th, 2008, but a week later, October 3rd, it did go through. But also, third prong of that, there needs to be a real virus coordination response in the US. That's obviously something that we haven't had so far. We've had very draconian lockdowns in much of Europe, and so far, that's not been the case, certainly on a national basis in the US. I think that's what's really needed to be seen before we get to any chance of what's going to be a probably intermediate bottom, because I think we, given the damage done to sentiment, the chances are now we're in a bear market.

That means it's going to be very difficult to see a proper rise in markets for some considerable time.

Risk parity unwind and stock-bond correlation

Erik Townsend: Simon, a prediction that I've made for several years, I just had no idea what would cause it to someday come true, is that eventually, we've been blowing simultaneous bubbles in both stock and bond markets for the last decade. And I thought someday something was going to happen that would cause both stocks and bonds to sell off at the same time, forcing the unwind of the institutional risk parity trade. Now, needless to say, risk parity is, is like the biggest thing in institutional finance. If it became necessary for institutions to unwind that trade, the market implications could be just profound in the sense of setting up a vicious cycle that reinforces that selling in both stock and bond markets. Now, in the beginning of this crisis, it seemed like not only could Treasury yields only go down, but it was just— even for those of us who saw this event coming, we were just shocked at how quickly Treasury yields collapsed.

But all of a sudden, they started backing up. And it makes me wonder if we're seeing the beginning of that event where stocks and bonds both sell off, causing yields to back up considerably. Do you think that could be in play now? And, uh, you know, how would we decide and, and monitor that? What, what clues should we watch in order to gauge whether that's starting to happen?

Simon White: I think that's an excellent question, Erik, and I think, um, it really gets to the heart of the matter. At the start of this conversation, you know, I mentioned that really the virus had kind of exposed a number of kind of imbalances within economies and within markets.

Really, one of the biggest imbalances that's been brewing within markets has been this essentially a short volatility position. One of the biggest, most egregious exemplars of that is the risk parity trade. Now, these guys are essentially vol targeters, and they've been responsible for really keeping the market look like it's calm, if you like. They're creating this illusion of calm.

And that's essentially because they are, to use the parlance, they're long gamma, which basically means that every time volatility goes down, they have to buy, and as they buy, that means volatility goes down further. There's this illusion of stability, but adhering to the work of Minsky, stability breeds instability. This has been brewing for several years now.

The risk parity strategies and risk parity-like strategies, they're not in significant, they are vast. Some estimate put them around about $1 trillion.

I think some of the more violent down days that we've seen in this selloff have really been the risk parity guys de-risking. Interestingly enough, one of the worst days that we saw over the last few weeks was when the S&P breached 20% on a close-to-close basis. Now, this didn't happen in December 2008. 2018. If it had happened, we probably would have seen something similar back then, but we managed to just escape through the skin of our teeth. The S&P didn't quite sell down more than 20%. This time, it did. We just saw this cascade move taking us right through. We're now obviously roughly down 30%. We're just seeing this very big unwind happening. You mentioned the bond yields, that's part of it. Essentially, you have liability matchers, you have mortgage hedgers, and these guys have what's called negative convexity. Essentially, what that means is when bonds go higher, they have to essentially buy more to match their liabilities.

Now, what happened over recent weeks is the safe haven buying obviously fueled higher debt, and then these guys have to come in. Every time you got yields making a new low, you had them going through that low quite considerably. Essentially, these guys were short gamma. That's what happened, as I say, to use the parlance, is if everybody's long gamma, it's self-equalizing. You have a stable equilibrium, if you like. When everybody goes the other way, and you have these short gamma trades, it means when price moves away from its equilibrium, people have to chase it away from that equilibrium. Stock buybacks is another example of that. That was something that was really keeping the market looking like it was stable. Basically, you had every time the market fell a little bit, these guys were in there always on the bid, always buying, and they support the market, so adding to that long gamma thing.

What this really is dependent on, and this is what you mentioned in your question, Erik, is the fact that stock-bond correlations over the last 20 years have basically been negative. That allows these strategies like risk parity to work. They work in the fact that one counterbalances the other, one asset counterbalances the other.

If you look back over history, stock-bond correlations being negative is an anomaly, probably over the last 100 years, only 30% of the time have stock-bond correlations been negative. This is something we've been writing about. This gradual shift to MMT, which has now overnight become a pretty much very sudden shift, is going to help push that stock-bond correlation more and more positive. That's something that we've been seeing over recent days.

We've had days where stocks and bonds have sold off at the same time. This is just something that the market is not used to seeing. This has very long-term implications. If we're moving towards a more MMT-like world, then there's certain relationships that everyone has got very used to have come to an end. We're in a different regime now. The long boom in financial assets will draw to a close and real assets will begin to outperform.

Perform. Obviously, things like precious metals, things like land, real estate, equities of companies that have access to real assets, so certain sectors like potentially like industry, we should also expect to see cross-asset volatility should rise on average, and also be subject to much more frequent episodic bursts higher, because we just don't have these same people, the risk parity guys, your convexity hedgers, there to stabilize the market like they once did.

It also means over the longer term that this whole leverage game is up. Basically, borrowing on a short-term basis, taking on leverage, it's going to become over the next few years a much more dangerous game because the risk of real rates rising is much higher because the risks of inflation rising is now much higher. You have unprecedented amounts of stimulus that's going to hit economies and markets over the next— in the coming years, and that's going to have a momentous effect on the economy, on the markets, and how people trade the markets.

Why Treasury yields rose: term premium, inflation and gold

Erik Townsend: Let's just talk about some of the mechanics of how this occurs, because what seems at the surface to just plain not make sense here is we had Treasury yields trading on their own before there was any stimulus introduced, lower and lower and lower. We just couldn't believe it. 10-year US Treasuries getting down, I think it was 31 basis points was the low. I don't remember what the number was, but really low. Now we've got the biggest monetary bazooka shot in recorded history. We've got unlimited spending from the Fed, and it's buying up bonds. Now, of course, it's lots of different maturities and so forth, but somehow that event has caused Treasuries, at least the 10-year yield, to move up. So is that, that all of the buying that the Fed is doing is in other maturities, and it's leading people to the conclusion that it has to lead to inflation. And that's why the 10-year is backing up.

It just seems unbelievable that there could be so much government money being spent to buy bonds and bond prices are going down on the news, at least some bond prices are. How does that work?

Simon White: It's exactly as you say. I mean, we're having to get used to inflation expectations. Again, for so long, they've been absent from longer-term yields. If you look at the term premium, which is a reflection of inflation expectations, it's just been driven lower and lower and ever more negative in recent years. That's one of the reasons why the curve couldn't steepen, the yield curve couldn't steepen. Even when the Fed was cutting rates, say last year, we didn't see the curve steepen because every time they cut rates, term premium fell as well, and overall, the curve didn't really do the that much.

Now, we're in a different regime. Term premium now is going to start heading higher, because people are going to start factoring in inflation expectations once again, because the entire investment universe, the entire structure of the financial world has now changed. You essentially have governments are going to step in, we're going to see most likely true forms of helicopter money, not pretend helicopter money, actual handing out checks to people to go spend, we're seeing the Fed step directly in to lending to companies.

All these things are going to lead to obviously a significantly higher budget deficit and significantly higher debt to GDP. At that point, that's where you have to see inflation expectations rise. Now, gold, unfortunately, always gets buffeted around here. It's a bit like a kite in a hurricane sometimes, because a lot of your risk parity guys who we just discussed, their inflation hedge, unfortunately, was gold. Gold and probably silver as well are not particularly big markets. These assets got knocked down pretty severely, but if you look at the way they've been trading over the last 2 or 3 days, they've been steadily rising.

I think this is just a reflection of the fact that we are moving to a different world. Inflation is going to be back. That's not to say it's going to be there permanently, or that's going to shoot up drastically higher straightaway, but it means that the tail risks have shifted away from disinflation and deflation, which is essentially what central banks have spent the last 20 years micromanaging, and the tail risks are now going to shift to higher inflation. We need to price inflation again. The whole investment world over the last 20 years was predicated, all the investment strategies was predicated under the fact that inflation was tamed, and inflation was never going to be a problem again, but that's not going to be the case over the next 10, 15, 20 years.

Erik's thesis: Trump, Fauci and a false relief rally

Erik Townsend: Simon, I'd like to lay out my own personal thesis for what I think the next chapter of the coronavirus story is going to look like for the United States. Admittedly, some of this is my own opinion, but I'm really keen to get your reaction because you guys are so good at thinking through scenarios and tell me how this might play out in markets if I'm right.

Simon, what I see is the following. On Monday's press conference, all of a sudden Fauci is not present, Birx is not present, and the Trump administration has changed their tune. Looks to me like maybe Lloyd Blankfein somehow got to Trump and persuaded him it's time to reopen the economy. So Trump makes a bunch of announcements saying, look, we're not going to shut down America. America was not meant to be shut down. And the reporters start asking him questions. Does Dr. Fauci agree with you on this? How come he's not here? And he was very evasive. He was intentionally saying, well, he didn't not disagree with me. You know, he wouldn't really answer the question directly as to why it feels to me like there has been a falling out between the medical advisors and the Trump administration members who are more concerned about the economy.

What I'm afraid of, Simon— I've done a lot of research on this this virus, I think we're headed down a path where the Trump administration is going to ignore its medical counsel and take us down the approach of we have to save the economy first, we can't shut down.

I think unfortunately that will lead us to a situation where the outcome in the United States is not like Italy but considerably worse than Italy, because as much as the situation in Italy is awful, once they realized what was happening, they were pretty darn proactive in locking things down. The US has taken the opposite approach of kind of making it optional, and I'm very concerned that if the Trump administration continues on the tack that I think they're on, we could have a closer to Wuhan level of event in the United States before they eventually realize the errors of their ways and lock things down and follow the hammer prescription from the Hammer and Dance article, which by the way, listeners, is linked in your Research Roundup this week.

Simon, if I'm right, I think what happens is we get a false relief rally because in reaction to what Trump says is going to happen, everybody thinks, okay, we're not going to have the shutdown after all. Eventually, it's going to lead to a much deeper shutdown, which is going to damage the economy even more, and I'm convinced, do even more damage to markets. My question for you is, if I'm right about what I think is going on between Trump and his advisors, how far up can asset markets go on, you know, the leadership indicating that their intention is not to do this shutdown before the market eventually figures out that the shutdown is happening and will only be bigger as a result of this policy error?

Lockdowns, household size and where bear markets bottom

Simon White: Yeah, I mean, it's It's something that is— obviously, every country is trying to find their own way through this. I think right now, we're clearly in uncharted waters, so no one actually knows. I know that the UK was trying to steer the middle course the same way that the US is right now, in terms of trying to delay the onset of more draconian measures with the belief that you only use them when you really need to, because if you start to too early, and you enforce very rigid quarantines, people tend to relax after a while. That's exactly the point when you don't want them to, because that's perhaps when the health service begins to become overwhelmed. I think what people are now watching quite closely, because if you like, this is where the virus went global, is Italy.

Really, as I say, we don't know, no one really knows how this is going to play out. The one thing is, I guess, that all of us in financial markets tend to trace data, we tend to follow data. That's something that we can look at and at least have some potentially vague idea about what we think is going on. The only thing I think that might be mitigating in terms of places like the US and the UK, in terms of assumptions they've used, so you mentioned the hammer and the dance that used an Imperial College paper that is basically what's guiding UK policy right now.

Some of the assumptions, we don't know, but I think we have to be aware that every country is different. In Italy, for instance, the spread may have been greater for a number of reasons, more interpersonal contact, more intergenerational contact. They've got the second highest median age. Also, even if you look at, quite interestingly, if you look at the size of the household, when you go into a lockdown, essentially, your R-naught, your transmission rate, really, it becomes much more important about who's in the household. You try and limit people's activities outside, then obviously, that part of your R-naught is less relevant, and the part that's more relevant is how many people live in your house. Now, in Hubei, in China, the average household has 3 people, which is quite high.

In Italy, it's 2.58, whereas in the US, it's 2.52, slightly lower, but there's a big range there. In Utah, there's 3.12, all the way down to Maine, which has 2.18 people. The one that's worrying to me is California is quite high. Obviously, California being the most The most populous state is 2.96.

We have to see exactly how that plays out, like the strength of the quarantining needs to be more serious, more aggressive, if you like, in the places that have a higher household number, because the WHO estimated that China, 80% of transmission after lockdown came from households, from people in the households.

How it's going to play out in different countries is, I think, going to vary, and that's something that will come very apparent in 2 weeks. hopeful, we're all on the same page that we just don't want to see it get into the Italian stage where what happens is once the health service becomes overwhelmed, then your death rate rockets up, not purely because of the disease itself, but because anyone in a fragile state, whether they have COVID or not, suddenly becomes hugely more vulnerable.

I think as far as the market goes, it will be keeping a close eye obviously on what happens in Italy, the UK, and the US. US, but I go back to my exogenous shocks analogy. Yes, I think we need to see a material improvement before the market can actually have any chance of bottoming. The problem with this exogenous shock is no one really knows how long it's going to go on for. In that sense, we're really in bear market territory, because in bear market territory, people's confidence gets shot so many times, we see so many rallies, and the rallies in bear markets can be massive. In the 1990s, in Japan, we saw 30% to 50% rallies, but they ended up being nothing and the market reversed. Bear markets do a huge amount of damage. The average bear market length in the US is 18 months, and the average decline is 42%. I think we're roughly 30% now, but in terms of timeline, this has happened very, very swiftly.

I think we're in agreement, Erik, in terms of if there is going to be some bottom. There's a good chance it's an intermediate bottom.

The real bottom comes when everybody has tried to buy the market. They've been massively disappointed. And we get to the point of revulsion. You won't touch the market even with a full hazmat suit on. And that's the point where you really want to buy the market. But it does feel like we're a long way from that just yet.

Bear market rally view and Variant Perception

Erik Townsend: Well, I strongly agree with you on that. I don't think that we're anywhere close to the bottom. What I'm starting to think is that we're maybe at the beginning of a significant bear market rally driven by what seems to me to be a change of sentiment in the Trump administration, that they're going to maybe not pay as much attention to the medical advisors and focus more on the economic advisors. And I fear that that is going to be a very fatal strategy. But it could allow markets to correct up on false hope considerably from here. Simon, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Before I let you go, for any listeners who are maybe not familiar with Variant Perception and what you guys do there, tell us a little bit about the firm and the services that you offer.

Simon White: Oh, thanks, Erik. Yeah, so Variant Perception, we've been around for about 10 years now, and we really emphasize the fact that we have a data-driven approach and we sort of take the outsider perspective to stuff. So, you know, rather than us trying to pretend to be experts in X, Y, and Z, we really take a very agnostic approach to markets and to economies and use that to really come up with some of the best ideas. So we have many subscribers across the whole gamut, you know, from asset managers to hedge funds to high net worth individuals. And, you know, we write regular reports and we also have regular contact with our clients. And really, we're trying to really help them try and find the best trading ideas. So if If you're interested, have a look at our page, variantperception.com, and you can sign up for a trial there.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. We look forward to getting you back on in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices Was sponsored by my own vacation rental on the coast of Maine. It's a five-acre oceanfront family compound with a deepwater dock, two separate residences, two kitchens, and eight king and queen bedrooms. But with all the pull-out sofas and bunk beds, we can actually sleep upwards of thirty people in a pinch. You couldn't imagine a better safe haven to ride out the COVID-19 crisis than this. It's extremely rural. You couldn't ask for better social distancing. And it features sunsets over the ocean and has a great big rec room with a pool table, home theater, and super fast 100 megabit cable internet to keep you connected to both Netflix and financial markets. I'd like to find a tenant for the duration of the COVID crisis.

This property would be ideal for someone with a big family who wants to get out of New York City. and ride the crisis out in the countryside. To be clear, this property is currently booked in July and August, so I'd have to renegotiate with my current reservations, but I don't think that would be too hard given the circumstances. Now, this is a big place— 5 acres of oceanfront, 2 residences, and accommodations for up to 30 people. So it's not cheap— $1,000 a night during high season. But if your family can afford to live in New York City or Boston, you can probably afford to get out of the city for this crisis, which I strongly recommend. If you're interested, please email me via info@macrovoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: how high do bear market bounces go

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Simon. I put together this chartbook in the postgame. And it really was inspired by when I was listening to Simon, he was talking about the average length of bear markets and the duration of bear markets. And also the idea of, you know, the sentiment that is associated around them. And so I wanted to just take a dive into that.

Erik Townsend: And listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Click the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Simon White's picture. Patrick, let's go ahead and dive in here on page 2. This is definitely the operative question: how high do typical bear market bounces go? Because I'm convinced that's what this is. This is a bear market rally, and boy, it's a screamer of a bear market rally. 200 points just today on what I think was a misinterpretation of Neil Ferguson's statements. How much higher can we go from here?

Postgame: 1929 and 2008 analogs

Patrick Ceresna: I approach the markets a little bit differently than you. I mean, to you, it's really important, each headline on this. For me, I really kind of look at market structure a little bit differently and the reflexivity of markets from when you have such an extreme move, then what's their natural responses the other way? And so, to me, one of the best ways to approach this is to really just take some of the past bear markets and how they played out. And what I thought was important, like Simon was talking about it, just what the average length of a bear market has been. And let's be realistic, if this bear market ended just like one month in, it would probably be one of the shortest bear markets of all time. And I just, I'm with you that this hasn't fully played out, but we are definitely in a bear market bounce. And what was interesting, I was looking at the 1920s 1929 analog, but I mapped on page 3 the 2008-2009 one.

But both of those had one characteristic that was particularly interesting to kind of compare to today. In 1929, while it took the first wave of selling 2 months to fully play out, it was a 45% decline over 2 months. In the middle of it was this 3-week decline that wiped out about 35% in a very short order. And after that first wave of, of massive selling in 1929, it also had afterwards a 50% retracement of the prior sell-off. And similarly, on this page, what I'm showing is the Lehman moment of 2008-2009. And some will argue that I should have been measuring the bear market from its highs when it started in late But really what I wanted to capture was the Lehman moment was a 35% drop in the stock market that started through September into October that lasted 21 days, wiping out 35%.

What happened in the subsequent days after was a 3-day bounce that erased 50% of the drop. It was a 27% rise off of the bottom. Bottom to the top, and that was just a reflexive move. Nothing dynamically changed in my mind during that Lehman sell-off. It's just what markets do after you have such a severe sell-off. The market has an opposite reaction that retraces that way. And what's interesting is, is that within a couple weeks, not only was the S&P 500 back down to the lows, but it was even making lower lows within a month. And the entire sell-off that followed that Lehman moment took almost 6 months to reach the ultimate bottom, which from, from that, the start of that move was a 48% decline that took about 168 days, just, just under 6 months in length.

And so what I thought was really interesting is, is that here you had this big, huge bounce that was just reflexive from the magnitude of the selling, but it still didn't stop the bear market from continuing on once that bounce ran out of steam. And so what I did on page 4 was to kind of just over Overlay what would be the analog if it played out the way it did in 2008, 2009. Now, immediately, I just need to make this clear to listeners.

I do not— I'm not forecasting that it's going to play out the same as 2008, 2009, but I think it's a really interesting storyline to kind of allow yourself mentally to think through what are the different scenarios and how they're likely to play out. And so what we had was this 32-day sell-off that basically wiped out the 36% on the downside during this COVID-19 moment, we call it. And we are in the midst of some sort of a bounce. And if we followed the same type of a 50% retrace that we have seen in both 2008 and 1929, in each scenario, if we did a similar bounce that this rally that we're seeing that's now north of 26%, 2,600 will end by 2,800 on the S&P. And if you think about it, we're almost there. I mean, there isn't much left in the tank. I mean, yeah, we made 200 points in one day. I mean, we might be, even if it does manage to muster up another 100 or 200 S&P points, there isn't much left to be made on the upside relative to what we've already seen off of the low.

And so one has to taper their enthusiasm of how much you're pressing the upside from here because it's no longer asymmetric in catching the anymore. But if it followed that, then by April into early May, we would be making still a lower low, and then it would bleed out into August if it followed that storyline. Again, it's not a forecast, but it'll be interesting to see whether or not a bear market driven by this COVID-19 has in some sort of like echoes to what we saw back then.

Postgame: COVID-19 event or popped bubble

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, my reaction to that is I think we really have to focus on the question of, is this just a COVID-19 event? Or is COVID-19 the pin that popped the bubble and therefore it started a process in motion which has to play out because it's already begun? If you think it's just a COVID-19 event, then I think the time schedule has to be compressed a little bit because even as much as you might say, oh, okay, well, it takes 6 months according to your chart here on page 4 to really get to the ultimate bottom.

I think what's going to happen is we are going to be absolutely horrified by what's about to happen in the United States. We're going to get to triage where we have to shut people off and literally allow them to die because we can't give medical care to everyone. That's all coming by the end of April. And I think that it's around the end of April where we get to the maximum point of new infections. Infections that probably brings about the COVID-19 market bottom, I think probably by the 1st of May. Now that doesn't mean that you don't get, just as you have here, a bounce to where everybody thinks maybe it's over, and then you realize, now wait a minute, it's not just about COVID-19. COVID-19 is what popped the bubble, and we've still got further to go. So whether or not you get that last red arrow down on page 4 that you've got drawn in here, I think depends entirely on whether or not popping the bubble is going to have a life beyond just what the virus itself does.

Because I think the virus crisis will be ending by the time we get to this, you know, 6-month timeframe that you're showing here.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So I do believe, though, that this is going to be more than about the COVID-19, because it's going to take a while to restart the economies. And even though we're to see huge fiscal spends coming in globally. This is not even about the fiscal spends in the US. There's just going to be huge government spending to try to restart the global economy. And, uh, it's— I just don't think it's going to happen as fast as everyone thinks. And so we're going to have to get used to a lot of negative data and things moving a little bit slower than everyone expects. And that could be an emotional drag that keeps the sentiment pretty negative and, and a lack And that allows a bear market to perpetuate.

Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more, but I just think it's a question of separating what the virus does and then what the market does, not directly driven by the virus. The part that's driven by the virus, I think that plays out through April and May, and by the end of May, hopefully it's ending. Let's move on to gold on page 5.

Postgame: gold and silver decoupling

Patrick Ceresna: Right, and that's just showing the gold chart that you already covered quite extensively in the, in the market wrap, so I don't have too much more to say on that. But I wanted to, uh, really was show page 6, which was the material decoupling of, uh, gold and silver. Now, during that crash, silver more or less— well, not more or less, it did crash below its, uh, bear market lows throughout 2015 and '16. I mean, you have to go all the way back to 2008 to see silver prices where we were trading. And what's amazing is that while gold fully recovered on that bounce, silver is still down on the year and has had no relative strength whatsoever to that. And one of the more interesting things that I'm going to be watching is how long does silver materially underperform gold, and will we see a situation where, let's say, gold first begins to rally and silver just lags and lags, and then suddenly everyone just all at once brings silver to, you know, one big epic rally back up toward gold.

It'll be interesting. It's one of the things that we're definitely watching. What's your take on that?

Erik Townsend: Well, I definitely think it's very important for our listeners to pay attention to, you know, if you feel like, boy, uh, I, I didn't buy my, my gold at $1,450. I was hoping that maybe weakness in the stock market was going to pull it lower, and I just missed that rally. Well, it didn't— you missed a rally in silver, but the rally in silver only took you back up to, you know, a long way, a long way down from where you would expect it to be. So it seems like— I think the gold-silver ratio actually hit an all-time record recently. It seems like maybe the value play is to buy silver instead of gold if you feel like you're a little bit late to the party at these gold prices.

Patrick Ceresna: Oh, that has to be the case for sure, assuming that silver inevitably will play the role of the little cousin to gold, then, uh, silver is definitely the value play for sure.

Postgame: 10-year yields and the 2s10s steepener

Patrick Ceresna: So, uh, what I wanted to move on is, uh, chart 7. I wanted to look at those 10-year yields, and there's no shortage of the bulls on the bonds taking a victory lap. And, and now there's a, a number of them that are suggesting that we could see zero interest rate yield on the 10-year. And listen, I've been a bond bull for a long time, and I'm not ready to, um, turn on the bond bulls, but I've slowly am curtailing my enthusiasm. I'm taking an incredibly neutral state. I'm not bearish bonds outright yet, but I'm not that bullish either. And one of the reasons I wanted to show is on page 8, which is looking at inflation expectations. This is just using that ProShares Inflation Expectation ETF. But since the QE infinity was announced, we saw inflation expectations just rocketing higher.

And the way I always look at it is, is that there are 2 major, at least to me, there are 2 major things that I track for, for influences on bonds. And that is number one, monetary policy, but number two is commodity prices such as oil and stuff. And so right now what we're seeing is commodity prices continue to be incredibly Even though inflation expectations, because of the monetary policy, are rocketing higher. And so what's really interesting is, could we see a scenario still where financial repression allows or pushes the 10-year yield towards zero? Or is it that we're gonna see finally inflation start creeping in from all this money printing and that this very bearish-looking 10-year yield curve chart just does not end up making that move to zero. It's certainly something that I'm going to be watching.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, on page 9, you've got the 2s-10s yield curve. And boy, as I look at this, I can see Charlie McElligott's bearded face saying, fear the steepener. What's going on here?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, that's exactly it, right? The steepener's on. And so what we had was obviously the bull steepening kick in as we saw the

Erik Townsend: Right.

Patrick Ceresna: Zero. So now this is all about the long end of the curve. And so if and when inflation starts to rear its head, and it at some point when it starts to be pressed into the 10-year yield, we can see the steepener really start to kick in. And we've seen a legitimate breakout. And it's one of the things that I'm watching, 'cause like Charlie said, right, you fear the steepener. And is this a true breakout of the steepener?

Erik Townsend: It really feels Well, Patrick, it sure looks that way to me. If ever, as I said, a chart looked like the steepener was on, this is the one. I want to call our listeners' attention also to page 10, where we've got information about

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: your own services, Patrick. If anybody hasn't tried a free subscription to Big Picture Trading yet, I highly recommend it. You get a webinar with Patrick almost every single day, a live Q&A session, Q&A and weekly position summary and a whole bunch more. So be sure to check that out on page 10. Go to bigpicturetrading.com and sign up for a free trial. This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com.

Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research

Patrick Ceresna: So this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Simon White, as well as the link to the charts we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to an article from Nouriel Roubini titled A Greater Depression, and an article looking back and ahead on this liquidity crisis. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners. And we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer outro and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests, and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. And now back to the program. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, do not assume any responsibility for any investment decisions made by listeners. MacroVoices is a production of Bloomberg Television and Radio. shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Jim Bianco — Bianco Research founder (as introduced on the show)

Show open: episode 211, sponsors and donations

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 211 was recorded on March 18th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by toptradersunplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases. And by my own vacation rental on the coast of Maine, which I'm repurposing as a COVID-19 safe haven for families who want to escape city life for a few months during this crisis.

What a week in markets after the Fed's epic emergency intervention last weekend. We needed to get a Fed policy guru on the show this week, and with bond yields backing up to the surprise of many investors, we needed a fixed income guru to help us Diagnose what's going on, particularly with respect to whether or not the long-feared phenomenon of both stocks and bonds selling off at the same time is finally upon us. And clearly, we need an expert on the coronavirus numbers to keep us abreast of the core driver behind all of the fireworks in the market.

There's only one man on earth who is all of those people in just one person, and that's Bianco Research founder Jim Bianco, who joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Hi, Jim. We'll cover The COVID-19 projections, bond yields, monetary policy, and much more. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Macro Tourist newsletter author Kevin Muir returns to talk to us about what just happened to gold mining stocks and what we can expect next.

I'd also like to thank everyone who's donated to MacroVoices in the last couple of weeks to support our additional content during this crisis. We got our first $5,000 donation this week, along with quite a few $250 And we really appreciate your support. Your generosity directly enables adding additional episodes during this crisis, such as yesterday's COVID-19 update. And I should also mention, for the benefit of listeners who only get notice of our podcasts from the Research Roundup emails, you're only getting notified of the weekly Thursday podcast in that email. We've actually had about 5 episodes in the last week. So if you've missed them, please be sure to go to MacroVoices.com and catch up on all the episodes. And we're also going to be episodes that you missed.

Market wrap: COVID-19, S&P 500, dollar, oil, gold and Treasuries

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, you already did a full hour-long COVID-19 coronavirus update, which you released on Wednesday afternoon. But for anyone that missed that, please give us the Reader's Digest version of the virus update.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think we'll make this a tradition going forward. I, I've got so much to say every week. I'll probably do a long podcast just about the COVID-19 situation. I don't know if it'll always be on Wednesday, but we'll get it out before the regular MacroVoices podcast so we can keep it short here in the Market Wrap. The good news, Patrick, is at least according to Dr. Steve Bickel, who was kind enough to give me a phone consultation, Dr. Steve thinks I probably don't have COVID-19. And for any confused listeners, I explained in yesterday's podcast that perhaps I do have COVID-19. It seems like I've got a lot of the symptoms. Now, what's interesting, Dr. Steve thinks that I really don't. He says it sounds to him like a tracheobronchitis, and he says the symptoms are different, not really consistent with COVID-19.

I got an insane number of emails and tweets from listeners saying, yeah, I got exactly the same symptoms that you described in yesterday's podcast, particularly that burning in the chest, that feeling of a persistent burn underneath the sternum, the chest plate. Never had that when I got sick before. I got it exactly the way you described it. One of the people who said that was Lenore Hawkins, who is at ground zero in the center of the crisis in northern Italy. So I think the jury is still out. Good news. The answer is probably, I don't have it, I've got something else. But boy, is there another bug going around that everybody— I got emails from Ireland, I got emails from Italy, I got emails from Australia. A whole bunch of people have the same symptoms I do. And is this the symptom of a mild COVID case or is it not? I guess the jury is perhaps still out.

The big news, Patrick, this week that's freaking everybody out is the Imperial College study out of the UK. I'll give just the executive summary. There's not a whole lot new here for MacroVoices listeners because Dr. Chris Martenson told you almost everything that it says back on January 30th. The thing is, this is mainstream now. It's got the attention of the White House. The White House was not listening to Chris Martenson on MacroVoices on January 30th. So it seems like they're finally waking up. I think there's a lot of things they still haven't woken up to, and I don't think that the world at large really has their head around the full extent of this crisis. I'd encourage listeners to listen to the full-length podcast that I released yesterday, where I go into all of the reasons that I think What's about to happen is probably quite a bit worse than what the general public has begun to come to terms with.

There's more and more evidence in my mind that the market has only just barely begun to price in what's coming. I think we're at the tip of the iceberg moment, and I don't think the crisis has really even gotten started yet. Now, at the same time, it does seem like a lot of market sentiment is okay. This must be the bottom. So I think there's a good chance that we're going to see a relief rally here. I don't think it's the final one. I don't think the final. bottom comes really until late May, early June. That's about when we should see the viral pandemic itself peak, and that would be when the most pain is in the system, and that's when I would expect markets to maybe actually bottom.

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, let's talk the S&P 500. On Thursday, we hit a low of 2,262 on the S&P, and more or less each day of selling in the last 3, 4, 5 days seems to have some sort of intraday reversals. And even though we haven't really seen a big bull breakout in any way, It seems like the selling is at least tapering. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, what I see, you know, I am short S&P futures now. I don't usually trade stock index futures, and the volatility is just amazing to me. Every time, you know, the president today had a press conference where he announced that chloroquine is an effective treatment against the COVID-19 illness and that that's an important development. Well, Chris Martenson told us that in his videos more than a month ago. There's no news here, but, you know, the market is rallying like crazy. I don't think the markets have really begun to price in what's about to happen, but I'm seeing more and more signs that maybe the market thinks the bottom is in and perhaps we're about to start a big relief rally. Really looking forward to talking to Kevin Muir because last time we had him on the show, I said, I don't think the bottom's in. He said he thinks it's time to buy. He was right at first, and then he called the top too, because he was right for a week or two, and then he said, okay, I think this is the top.

He put that out on Twitter. And that just about was the market top. So I'm very, very curious tactically to know what Kevin is thinking. In the end though, I don't think that the market actually bottoms until the end of May, beginning of June.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to the US dollar because for the longest time we were like, oh, there's nothing new to talk about on the dollar. But I mean, the last month we not only had an extraordinary drop in the DXY, but now we've had this face-ripping rally that basically has sent the dollar index from its '95 lows to now, Almost at a 103 handle, and it just seems to be gaining momentum here. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, a couple of weeks ago, I made an admission on the podcast and I said, okay folks, I guess I'm just good old-fashioned wrong. I don't understand this. And I made a joke. I said, you know, it'd be tempting to explain this as just the market participants are too stupid to recognize that even though the Fed just made an emergency rate cut, which could be considered dollar negative, that they did it for a reason, and that reason is an incredibly dollar positive story. And I made the joke saying, well, if I said that, I would probably just sound like some guy trying to justify why he got it wrong. You know, I'm coming back to that story. I think that's what's happened. We had the Fed rate cut. People looked at that from an interest rate differential standpoint and said that has to be dollar negative.

And I think the whole market was just blind to what should have been obvious, Which is the reason the Fed did that is because we have a global crisis of epic proportions, which is going to be super dollar positive.

And it seems like that reality has finally hit the tape. So as far as I can see, it was just a knee-jerk in the wrong direction all the way down to 94 and change on the dollar index because people weren't seeing the big picture. I think they're finally starting to see the big picture, and I think the dollar rally has only just begun.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil, 'cause I mean, we got down to the $20 handle. I didn't think we were gonna break those lows at $26 from back in 2016, but here we are. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the fact that we took out the 2016 low so quickly without even a bounce is a really bearish sign. It says that this market is even weaker than I thought it was. I had been tweeting all week that RBOB gasoline being below its 2016 low I knew that the Brent crude oil low meant that crude was probably going to follow lower. But even though I've been tweeting saying I think we're headed towards $20, I didn't think we were going to get there in one day. And sure enough, we did. Now we're having a huge bounce off of that. There's been a little bit of posturing from Saudi Arabia that maybe they're going to rethink their strategy. And in general, we've got, you know, the president talking about how chloroquine is a treatment. It's only a treatment. It's not a cure for anything. It seems like It looks like we're in the middle of a bounce in all risk assets.

I don't think it's gonna last, Patrick. I think that we're ultimately headed into the teens, and I think that $10 oil is entirely possible. The reason is, I don't think the world has come to terms yet with the economic— not even slowdown, the economic full-stop event, which is about to be necessitated by the COVID-19 crisis. If we get down to $10 oil, or even to the teens, it's gonna be super contango. There's going to be a massive contango in the market. As far as inventory this week, crude oil building 2 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma building 563,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 6.2 million barrels. Distillates drawing down 2.9 million barrels. Tape action was down after that. Perhaps you could say that's in reaction to the, the crude build. But frankly, the tape action had been down all day. I don't think inventory made that much difference. It really was the market starting to come to terms with what's about to happen to the economy that was taking oil prices lower.

And that happened before, during, and after the inventory release. US production ticked back up to its previous all-time record high of 13.1 million barrels.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold, because even a week or two ago, gold was a safe haven. But when the real crash obviously begins, the correlation of all assets goes to 1, and gold was not spared in all of this. We are currently trading at $1,472. What's your take here on gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I've been saying for weeks, and as you just said, correlations go to 1 in a sell-off. What you've got is people having to raise cash to deal with a crashing market, to deal with margin calls and so forth. And they gotta sell what they got. And I think that's going to continue. If I had to guess what the price is where it bottoms, I really don't have a guess. If I have to guess when the price bottoms, End of May. That would be my guess as to when both the stock market and the gold market bottom. If we look at 2008 as maybe being the pattern that we want to follow, the gold market bottomed quite a bit before the other asset markets did. So maybe it's earlier than that. But I think that as the real panic comes into the market, and I don't think it started yet, gold is probably going to get dragged down with it.

I will be buying at $1,350 if we get there, just because it's a key technical level and it's kind of foolish. I encourage not to, but I won't be the slightest bit surprised if we go considerably below $1,350. It really depends on how big the washout is in equity markets and how desperate people are to sell everything in order to raise cash. As far as what might be driving this right now, I do think it's margin calls and so forth. A couple listeners wrote to me and said, hey, Erik, why don't you think, or why can't you see this is all Ray Dalio's fault? His fund has been long gold. His fund is blowing up. He's facing a lot of redemptions from Saudi Arabia and elsewhere.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: elsewhere. This is all about Dalio. I certainly think that it's entirely possible that Bridgewater is part of this. Dalio has been long gold. They are under a lot of pressure.

Maybe that's part of this, but I don't think he's the only one who is being forced to sell his gold, even though he probably doesn't want to, in order to deal with this situation. I know that Kevin Muir has some views on some of the mechanics as to what exactly happened to the GDXJ ETF, which crashed much harder than gold itself did. Let's get Kevin in, in postgame, in order to talk more about that.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's go to 10-year Treasury yields. And it's interesting that bonds stopped rallying. I mean, in the last week, while the rest of the stock market continued to sell, bonds joined the party. And it really seems like it's all asset classes other than the dollar are selling here. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: I think this is scary, Patrick. You know, what I said a few weeks ago is, boy, we Such a quick move. It was— I said, I, I want to say that, that bonds should be a buy given what's going on here, but they made such a quick move and they were almost at zero. And, you know, I said that's a little above my pay grade. I think this is still above my pay grade, frankly, and that's the reason I really look forward to interviewing Jim Bianco this week. What's on my mind, though, is really clear.

We've been predicting for years, Patrick, that someday the day would come when we'd have a financial crisis where both bonds and stocks started selling off together at the same time. And we predicted that if that ever happened, if that inverse correlation between stocks and bonds ever broke down, it would force the unwind of the risk parity trade, which is the biggest single trade or biggest strategy in all of institutional finance.

I'm wondering if that's That's actually started to happen. That one is pretty intense stuff. It is a bit over my pay grade. Jim Bianco is the man to ask, so let's get him in for the feature interview.

Why Jim Bianco is this week's guest

Patrick Ceresna: This week's featured interview guest is Jim Bianco. So, Erik, why did we invite Jim back as this week's featured guest?

Erik Townsend: Jim is the best guy for what we're looking at in the market right now. He's the only guy I can think of in finance who's been constantly 2 steps ahead of me with respect to this Coronavirus COVID-19 situation. He saw it before I did. His charts were a big part of what woke me up to the whole situation. He's a fixed income guy, he's a macro guy, and he's a monetary policy guy. And boy, we've got a big dose of all those things. So we need to really get to the bottom of what happened with what I think was probably the biggest central bank intervention in recorded history last Sunday, what it means that the market still managed to trade down despite that action. What are the implications of that? I just can't think of a better guy than Jim Bianco, and I'm really looking forward to this interview.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out TopTradersUnplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Jim Bianco is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: With this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Feature: central bank interventions and dealer balance sheets

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is the one guy in finance who was all over the coronavirus story even before I was. That's Bianco Research founder Jim Bianco. I want to refer our listeners— we don't have a slide deck today because Jim has just been flat out with the various situations and markets. Jim's timeline on Twitter has some of the best graphs and charts showing the case growth of of COVID-19 cases around the world. So I encourage our listeners to check that out. Jim, I want to start with the, the big picture of, okay, monetary policy 2 weeks ago versus today is a very, very different story. I think some of our listeners have been overwhelmed. We know there was a massive intervention last weekend. We know there's an alphabet soup of new accommodative facilities, but almost nobody can keep track of all Give us the big picture summary.

What has happened? What are central banks doing? And what's the summary of all the actions that they've taken?

Jim Bianco: What central banks are doing, let's first of all go to the top and say there's going to be a pre-virus world and a post-virus world. And that I think this virus, I'm with you, I think is going to be the defining thing of this generation. The marketplace— we have to talk about that more later— but the marketplace right now is saying that the post-virus world is a completely different set of valuations. It's going to be deglobalization, de-risking, higher inflation, lower multiples, restrictions on trade, restrictions on travel, and the whole nine yards along with that.

So we've got to change the way that we are doing business, and that means all prices have to come down. Now that all prices are coming down, central banks are seeing what's happening and they're trying to stop it, and I don't think they can. So they've been pushing out this set of rules and regulations and new programs. In fact, Christine Lagarde actually Put out that the ECB will have no limit on her Twitter account at 1:30 in the morning in Paris. So they're like doing this stuff 24 hours a day right now. The Fed made their announcement of a money market liquidity fund facility at 11:30 at night last night.

Now, what's happening, simply put, is as the selling began at the beginning of the month, late in February, The dealers that make markets were seeing everybody sell to them. They were buying from them. They bought to the point of their balance sheet. They couldn't buy anymore. Everybody's continuing to want to sell to the dealers, and the dealers are stuck, and they're having a very difficult time making markets.

That is primarily showing up in the credit markets. The Federal Reserve and some of the other central banks Seeing the problems that the dealers are having, their balance sheets are full, everybody sold to them, they can't buy anymore, said, look, we will offer you repo at $1 trillion a day. Now, that's really meant to just be an eye-popping signaling number, $1 trillion. The real number is actually infinity. They will offer as much as the dealers can take, but they put a nice big round eye-popping number on it as well. But if they wanted $2 trillion, they would give it to them. They wouldn't just stop it at $1. Right. But the problem with the dealers is they're not taking any of this repo infinity, if you want to call it that.

The reason they're not taking it is the last 12 years in the post-crisis world, what we've been doing is creating these regulators have been putting out all these rules to prevent banks from leveraging up. That was the problem in 2008. So it's Basel III, it's the BIS, it's the European Banking Commission. It's the ECB, the Fed, the FDIC, the OCC, MOUAC. All of them together have put all these rules. So the Fed says, here's a trillion dollars. And the banks come back to them and say, I got all these rules. I'm not allowed to take any of the money. Yesterday they took $10 billion of it. $10 billion of a trillion dollars is what they wound up taking in total.

So the Fed then said, okay, your balance sheets are full. And you can't expand them anymore through taking my trillion dollars of repo. So I'll drain your balance sheet. And that's QE. They were through yesterday buying $40 billion of Treasuries a day, plus some mortgage-backed securities on top of that. In other words, I'll reduce your inventory by $40 billion. I'll drain it. And then you can refill it.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Jim Bianco: This morning, the Fed announced they're going to $75 billion starting today and $75 tomorrow, plus more MBS. And the ECB yesterday announced that they're going to do something similar. We're going to try and drain their balance sheets so that then they can refill them by making markets.

The problem is, and I put this on my Twitter timeline just in the last 24 hours, If you look at the ETFs, the bond ETFs, they are trading at enormous discounts to the NAV, the net asset values. So the net asset values of these— and I'm talking about the 5 largest bond ETFs, not some random ETFs. I'm talking about AGG, BND, Vanguard's Total Bond Fund, TLT, which is the 20-year Treasury, LQD, which is the Large Corporate Bond Fund by iShares, and HYG, as well, those types of funds. If you look at them collectively, they're trading at massive discounts, meaning here's the price of all the bonds in their portfolio, here's where the ETF is trading, up to as much as a 4 to 6% discount, which is incomprehensibly big for the bond market to see those kind of discounts.

And the reason that you're seeing those level of discounts is That is the market telling us that the real fair value in this post-virus world is far lower prices. And the dealers, even though they're being drained and being told to make markets, they're still stuffed with all these securities. They don't want to mark them down and take gigantic losses. So that's been the rub, and that's why the market has been so dysfunctional the last several days. See, that makes sense.

Feature: market makers working from home and the 30% fall

Erik Townsend: It makes a lot of sense. Now, I got an email this morning from a very well-connected CEO, a regular listener to MacroVoices, telling me that one of the issues that a lot of the banks are dealing with is market makers. They're trying to send people home to work from home wherever they can, but by law, FINRA Series 24, I believe, market makers cannot make markets from home. That's against the law, and apparently there's no waiver for that. And they think that one of the issues is, you know, there's people getting sick on trading desks and they can't send them home because the market makers are not allowed to work from home.

Hopefully that will change. But I don't wanna focus on that specific issue, but it seems to me like it's indicative of a much bigger problem, which is, I think you and I agree, this crisis is just barely getting started in terms of what's coming to the West. What happens when we wanna keep financial markets I think it's important to keep financial markets open, but the key players are unable to work from home and it's not safe to have them in institutional trading floors anymore.

What kind of systemic risks does that create that perhaps nobody has ever thought about?

Jim Bianco: Yeah, to your first point, that's just more of the same. We've put together these rules and in fairness to the regulators and everybody else, no one before January ever even contemplated what if there was a global pandemic that required a complete shutdown of the global economy. That was something out of science fiction and not something that you would have to consider when writing regulations. And the problem with all regulators is they're very slow after years of putting together rules, whether it is you can't make markets at home or you can't change your leverage rules for the banks, or even if it's the CDC telling the flu campaign in Seattle, you're not authorized to do COVID-19 tests, even though you single-handedly found the clusters in Seattle. You have to shut down because you're just not per our regulations. That's the way all regulators think. And so it's going to be difficult for them to give away that power and say, okay, we're going to have to change all of this.

In the meantime, that just means that markets will stay dysfunctional. They'll stay problematic. Markets will continue to try and sink lower and lower as we go from here, and the risk is an overshoot, an overshoot on the downside. The S&P is now down 30% in exactly a month. One month ago today, February 19th, was the all-time high, and now we're 30% down, the fastest From all-time high to 30% ever, not even close. 1929 was the old record. The fear is that metastasizing to 40% or 50% in short order. And I don't think the financial system can handle that kind of a decline without there becoming a full-blown financial crisis. Look, we might be on the verge of one right now because of all of these losses. I think the only reason people don't think there is one, I think there's a lot of shock. I can't believe what's happening. This isn't really happening. This market has to rebound, Erik, right?

Please tell me it's going to rebound and it's going to be okay. But so that hasn't really sunk in to everybody just yet.

Feature: the Fed put has expired

Erik Townsend: Jim, I think the reason it hasn't sunk in is because I would argue that this entire 10-year greatest bull market in the history of the stock market that began in 2009 To me, the enabler of the entire thing is what used to be called the Greenspan put, and more recently, the Fed put. The notion that, hey, things get really turned south, the Fed's got our back, they're going to bail the market out. Jim, I would argue that the Fed put expired at about 6:15 PM on Sunday evening. And what I mean by that is on Sunday, we had what I think was the biggest monetary policy intervention in recorded history, as I understand it. And everybody thought, okay, well, surely that's gotta just send markets to the moon to the upside. We ended up with futures limit down within 15 minutes of the Sunday futures open.

Opposite expectation. Jim, to me, that was the moment where the market's confidence in central banks to be able to solve any problem failed, and it failed spectacularly and instantly.

Jim Bianco: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Would you agree with that? And if so, what are the consequences and implications of the Fed put having expired?

Jim Bianco: I completely agree that it did expire at that point, or maybe even a little bit before, but that was definitely, you know, the, the, the whack to the face that it, it doesn't work. And the reason the Fed put expired is because fundamentally we've got the wrong prices. Fundamentally, I think the market thinks that the proper price is still lower.

And we're unwilling to accept that that is the case. Erik, maybe you've seen the same thing I do. All my friends that offer their opinion about the market to me, almost 95% of them are trying to pick a low. I can't find anybody at this point that still thinks that this market should still be sold. Everybody's still trying to pick a low right now. No one can conceive of this idea that no, maybe it's a new era. It's a new post-virus era. And the post-virus era means that we are now in an era of lower prices.

So the Fed put only works if your prices are somewhat near fair value. Then if the Fed comes in and your markets are functional, and the Fed comes in and it does things aggressively, then it can help boost markets, the buy-the-dip mentality. But when you've got the wrong prices, and you know that because your markets are dysfunctional, you could announce infinity. The Fed could just say infinity and beyond on everything. It's not going to change the reality that it's just the market thinks it's just in the wrong place, and it could wind up going lower.

Feature: closing markets versus free fall

Erik Townsend: Jim, I could not agree more. The one thing that I get from all of our listeners on Twitter, I get emails saying, My God, haven't you covered your shorts? Don't you see this is the bottom? And my reaction, Jim, is, wait a minute, the market hasn't even begun to come to terms with what's about to happen. Everybody is finally starting to realize, okay, we've got a problem. They haven't come to realize that it's entirely possible that Hubei Province could be a proxy for what's about to happen to the United States. And I made the case in my podcast yesterday for why I think I think that is entirely possible. So, I'm your one guy that you know who thinks that this is not a time to look for the bottom. It seems painfully clear to me, if you look at page 8 of the Ferguson report that I talked about in yesterday's podcast, it seems clear to me that when would the logical time be to be buying the bottom?

End of May, first of June. I think that's when the market bottoms.

But I want to come back to the Fed put having expired, because the question then is what are the consequences and implications and what will happen next and what should be done next? Something that you've said publicly, Jim, is if the prices that— the low that we've seen doesn't hold, and it looks like it's not holding, you think that regulators are likely to shut down financial markets entirely. What I haven't heard from you publicly is, do you agree that that should happen? And if so, why?

Jim Bianco: You're right. Let me be clear on this. When you start talking about shutting down the financial markets, you're down to 2 terrible options. Option 1 is let the markets free fall and let the damage that they may cause ensue. Option 2 is to halt the markets from having that free fall and the damage that they ensue.

There is no option 3. The market bottoms and it goes back up and the problem goes away. So you're stuck with 2 very bad options.

I think regulators do not want to close markets. I think there's going to be a progression of how they'll attempt it. Progression one is they throw everything but the kitchen sink at them, which is what they're doing now. And by the way, Erik, as we're talking, the Bank of England just cut interest rates just 3 minutes ago.

And option number 2 will be they'll ban short selling. They'll ban leveraged and inverse ETFs. They'll allow only liquidation trades only. They might ban stock index futures or maybe shorting of stock index futures. They might ban put buying or something like that. They did versions of that in 2008, and that's already taking place in Europe that they've started to ban short selling and the like.

And then option 3, if it's— if that doesn't work and the market keeps going down, they have to look at some of their big banks, some of their big financial institutions, and say, We can't let this keep going. They're going to fail. We're going to have 10 Lehmans on our hands. So shut it down, and you shut it down to the time that you wind up saying, "Now we've tested enough. Now we understand what the problem is.

Now we know where the economy and market should be. Let's reopen them and price to that level, and then hopefully, even if that is a lower level." It's one time marked down, and then we could spend that time figuring out what we're going to do and then go forward from there.

So I understand it's not an ideal situation. I fear that that's what they're going to do. I'm sympathetic to that argument because I'm also not thinking that the other thing is just let it go to hell and we'll figure it out after that.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Jim Bianco: Might actually be worse from there.

Erik Townsend: Jim, I hear you loud and clear, but I see those 2 options a little bit differently. As you said, option number one, allow things to melt down, and my prediction would be that I don't think Americans have even begun to come to terms with what's happening. I think the people that are looking to buy a bottom are completely missing the story, and I think there's a lot of downside still to come. So I agree with you, that's very ugly.

It potentially leads to systemic problems that are not just about people losing money in the market, but that really affect the national economy and so forth.

But I see option number 2 differently. As I see it, the choices are either you can continue to have transparent price discovery and watch prices go down, or you can close markets and values continue to go down exactly the same way. But But it's exactly the same as an ostrich digging his head into the sand. What you're doing is you're not able to see what is still happening. And the other consequence of that is it means that you cut the people who might need to tap their savings the most off. The guy who needs, even though he's selling at a very unattractive price, the guy who needs to sell some of those stocks in his portfolio, because he's got to feed his kids and he lost his job because of the virus, that guy loses access to the markets. So I don't see option number 2 as being any better than option number 1.

I want to give you a chance to tell me if I'm wrong and why I'm wrong.

Jim Bianco: Well, see, the thing is, is you're not wrong. The problem is, is that, uh, again, I want to emphasize, you're down to 2 terrible options here is what, what we're down to. So there is no, you know, sunshine and flowers option that we haven't considered there. I just wonder which one would be worse in the long term. Now, again, I'll also mention that they'll do this in stages. Like I said, the next step will be ETFs and they'll ban short selling and stuff like that.

When we say shut down the market, I do think that they will probably put some kind of facility in place for people to maybe borrow against those holdings or money market funds would still be around to allow liquidation.

But it is an option to be considered. I don't think that markets are quite bad enough now that that's there. But if we have another serious down leg, I think that that's on the table. So I am not going to defend the close the markets to my dying breath because I think we can agree, Erik, that we're talking about 2 terrible options here and there isn't a 3rd one.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Jim Bianco: Let's hope that we don't have to be having that discussion, but it is one that people should consider if things turn much lower as we continue to move forward, that that is probably going to be discussed. I understand the Philippines tried it last night. They closed their market. It reopened today and it fell 24%.

So there is that risk, like you said. It just keeps getting repriced and it just reprices lower.

Feature: stock-bond correlation, inflation and the 60/40 portfolio

Erik Townsend: And I just want to point out for the benefit of our listeners, all of the research shows that speculators reduce volatility in markets, not increase it. Short-selling bans not only don't work— has been proven over and over again in research and analysis— but they can actually be counterproductive and exacerbate the problem. So I don't think that's a good thing, but that doesn't mean it's not going to happen.

Jim, I want to move on to another major subject, which is on MacroVoices for years now we've talked about a specific scenario that I've been very, very concerned with, which is, you know, there's a rule in finance which is the things that you have to worry the most about are the things that most professionals agree are not just unlikely but impossible. And one of the things a lot of people think is impossible is a breakdown in the historic inverse correlation between stocks and bonds. And what I've said for years is someday we're going to have some kind of crisis where we've blown these bubbles in both the stock and bond market. They're both going to start selling off at the same time. And when that happens, watch out, because it's going to force the unwind of the entire risk parity complex, which is the biggest institutional trade in existence.

I am very, very intrigued by this backing up in yields. You are a fixed income guru. I fear that what we're starting to see is that breakdown of correlation where stocks and bonds are starting to sell off at the same time. Is that what's happening? And if so, what does it mean?

Jim Bianco: Yeah, I think that's exactly what's happening, is that the correlation is breaking down. Let me go with what it means, and then I'll tell you why. It means that on the institutional side, risk parity trades and risk parity strategies are not working. A risk parity strategy, if you're not familiar with it, is you're trading the relationship between stocks and bonds, swapping back and forth between them.

But when the relationship changes, you're just trading one losing position for another losing position. You just keep going back and forth. The biggest risk parity trader is Bridgewater. They reported last week that they lost 20%. And so you've started to see that started to play on the retail side.

The whole modus operandi of the wealth management business, which is booming in the United States, of 400,000 wealth managers that are driving the market, is everybody needs to be in the 60/40 portfolio because the 60/40 portfolio has that 40% fixed income leg that's supposed to protect you on the downside. Well, that isn't working either. Is what's happening? That's been falling as well too. So that's been creating a lot of pain on the retail side.

Now why is that happening? The answer I think is inflation. The reason first of all the stock bond relationship is not stable. It does change over time. It goes from being both of them move together to both of them moving inversely or negatively correlated to both of them moving together. The current stock bond relationship we have started between. '98 and 2000. And that is where stock and bond prices move opposite, or yields and stocks move together. And the reason it started around '98 to 2000 is you'll remember that that was Long-Term Capital, the Asian financial crisis, and the tech bubble.

And coming out of all of those events, the word deflation became a front-and-center idea for 20 years. We worried at varying degrees for deflation. In a deflationary fear, in a deflationary mindset, when stock prices go down, we're afraid about deflation, you run the bonds. When stock prices go up, we are not as afraid of deflation, you get out of bonds. And so that relationship held.

But if you go to an inflationary environment, and that was the '70s and the '80s, when you fear that inflation is returning, mainly the '70s, Bond prices, bond prices and stock prices both go down. That or yields go up and stocks go down. Same thing. And that is bad for them. And when you when you're relieved that there is no inflation, the the eighties, they both go up together.

I think what's happening is that the market is saying that twenty-year deflationary era is coming to an end, and the era we're about to transition into. Is going to be an era of inflation, and that you're now going to see stock and bond prices go up and down together.

And that is going to take a while for— first of all, it isn't a light switch. Well, this is the old relationship, this is the new relationship. When we switched from '98 to 2000, it was fully 2 to 3 years where it seemed like it broke down, it reconnected, it broke down, it reconnected, it broke down, and then it stayed broke down.

This one will be the same way. The stock-bond relationship is changing, that stock and bond prices will move together, not opposite each other, so that when you see a hint of inflation or you see a hint of problems, they both fall. When you see things getting better, they both rise. And that is going to change the whole way that— the whole way that 36 million people have their money with wealth managers, and it's in some version of a 60/40 portfolio. 36 million accounts need to be changed. The whole way that Wall Street hedges itself and views the markets in a risk parity framework, that's got to change. Doesn't have to change today.

That relationship will vacillate over time. But I think that it is about that we finally are transitioning to an inflationary period, something we haven't seen in at least 20 years. We're not there now. That's a post-virus thing, and we're about to head there as, uh, we get through this initial crisis with the virus.

Feature: risk parity unwind and the missing hedge

Erik Townsend: Jim, I want to make sure that we put this in perspective because we had a major blowup in markets at the beginning of 2018. And what happened was the whole volatility complex basically blew up in one day. And the reason that happened was a very very small little clique of guys figured out how to monetize the contango yield in the term structure of VIX futures. And it was a picking up nickels in front of a steamroller trade. You know, it produced just terrific returns until the day it blew up. And they all got their fingers burned. That was a tiny, tiny, tiny little small minuscule percentage of the people in financial markets that were even involved in that trade, and their activities caused an event that sent ripples through the entire financial system.

What we're talking about here is not that. We're talking about everybody who's got a 60/40 portfolio. That's basically 99% of retail investors, plus most of institutional finance, most of the big hedge funds like Bridgewater and so forth. What they're all about is kind of a turbocharged version of that 60/40 portfolio. They've got equity, And then they use leverage to lever up the bonds. The only way, Jim, that they can justify having that leverage, because normally leverage involves an extreme amount of risk that would not be appropriate for an institutional portfolio, the way they justify that leverage is that that risk of leverage is hedged by the equity portfolio and the inverse correlation.

What it means, and this is the part I really want you to tell me if I've got it right, wrong, because you're much closer to these institutional guys than I am. What I understand is the way that they do business, if the correlation breaks down, they're forced to unwind their trades. It's not a question of anybody panicking. It's a question of, oh, the numbers say this, I'm now forced to do that. And that, in this case, is sell all the bonds and all the stocks. Is it really as simple as that, or am I reading too much ZeroHedge

Jim Bianco: It is. Roughly, the framework is right. And first of all, the 2018 period you referred to, I love the word, is Volmageddon. And that was what we referred to it as. But let me put it to you more basic. They're allowing themselves to leverage and be aggressive because there is a belief that there's this gigantic asset class, the Treasury market, that I could run to for a hedge.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Jim Bianco: I could be way out there on the edge, risking it all, because in a heartbeat, I can go and protect myself in the Treasury market because it moves in the opposite direction all the time. But if on the other side, you start to realize I'm way out there on the edge, and if something goes wrong, there's no net now. There's no, oh, just go engage in buying some derivatives based on Treasuries or swaps or something like that. And therefore, if I lose on this primary trade, I will offset it on this hedge. There is no hedge. There is no thing you can do to protect yourself.

There is one thing you could do to protect yourself. Sell out of your position is liquidate your position. So yes, that's exactly what's happening is that they're starting to realize, I don't have a way to protect myself anymore. Or I do. It's called liquidate and go to cash. And I think that that's part of what's also driving the immediacy of these trades right now, that they can't do it. Like I said, I saw this in the 4th quarter of '18.

In the 4th quarter of '18, when the stock market, you recall, the Fed was talking about hiking rates, and then the market sold off 20%, and everybody's screaming to Powell that you had the wrong strategy. The bond market, the high yield market was looking a little bit wobbly, but nobody sold anything in the high yield market because they said, hey, we've got HYG, I could short that. We've got credit default swaps, I could protect myself on that. I could be put options on HYG. And so I'm not going to sell my big massive portfolio of illiquid securities. I'm just going to ride it out with a hedge. And then when I think it's all done with, I'll get rid of the hedge because the hedge is easier, more liquid to put on and take off.

You don't have that now. You don't have that now in dysfunctional markets. You only have liquidation. And that's where I think that mentality is there in some places. The hope is that those hedges will return and that that risk can come back. But if these relationships have changed, those hedging opportunities are not going to come back.

Erik Townsend: Okay, Jim, I want to put this in perspective because on one hand, what we're saying is with this change in correlation, It forces people to liquidation. They don't really have another choice. Meanwhile, not only can they not hedge anymore, but we also agree that the Fed put has expired. Now, you say the only option is liquidation. I just want to be really clear. Liquidation is not a solo act. It takes two to tango. Liquidation means selling something for which somebody has to buy.

If we've got all of institutional finance and all of the panicking retail complex selling both stocks and bonds at the same time? Who are the buyers in that scenario?

Jim Bianco: Well, there isn't. And that's why, as we talked about in the beginning, the dealers are full, the markets are dysfunctional, and we've seen the biggest collapse ever recorded off of an all-time high in markets. This is, you know, and like I said, it especially shows up in markets that are not traded on regulated exchanges. like in the credit markets and stuff. So this is why these markets are so stressed. And this is why these markets are trading at such difficult levels right now. And why I think that it's still a little early to call for a low in the markets. You're just, you know, just trying to catch the proverbial falling knife. Maybe you get lucky, but it's never a good strategy to do that.

Feature: why not to pick a bottom

Erik Townsend: I really want to pick up on that point, Jim, because I couldn't agree more. And something that I keep hearing that The biggest bit of feedback I'm getting both on Twitter and emails from listeners is, okay, surely, you know, this has gone all the way down 30%, and it's got to be time to buy the bottom. What should I buy here? That's the question I get. The other thing that I hear a lot is, it's interesting the way this one went because we've gone all the way down now, but what was curious about it is it happened much faster than previous crises. Previous crises at this At that point, timewise, we'd only be 1/3 of the way through the crisis. And I think what people are missing is, what if we're only 1/3 of the way down? What if this is only the first third of the price movement?

And the reason I say that, Jim, is I really don't think in the United States of America that hardly anybody has come to terms with what's about to happen. If you look at Ferguson's report, which we talked about in detail on yesterday's What it shows is we're at a point now where we haven't even gotten to beginning to overwhelm healthcare systems. We haven't gotten to the point where the reflexive feedback loops start to kick in. We haven't gotten to the point— and when people ask me, well, what's— if you don't think this is it, what's the number? And I tell them, there's no number. I don't know the number. But when I think it's logical to expect markets to maybe start to bottom, would be the end of May, beginning of June, because that's the peak point on page 8 of the Ferguson report. That's when we're going to have the, the most blood in the streets in terms of the virus effects peaking.

And what we've seen so far is this market is not anticipating ahead of time what's going to happen. The market only reacts to these virus events after they've occurred.

You and I were talking about this in the end of January. You know, market kept going up. It wasn't until the case started happening outside of China, even though all the smart people knew that was going to happen. Markets didn't move until the evidence was there. And so by that logic, I don't see why you would expect markets to bottom until the end of May.

Uh, what's wrong with that logic? Because I, I, I want to make sure that I don't say that and, and have our listeners not hear the other side of the story.

Jim Bianco: There's nothing wrong with that logic. For those that want to buy a bottom, I've gone to, okay, the market's fallen a lot, and that's your definition that we need to make about them. What's the consequence of this? What happens when the virus goes away? And I think most of these people, their answer is we go back to work and everything returns, quote, to normal.

What if it doesn't? Then you have to start to contemplate that maybe that's what these markets are trying to tell you, is that coming out of this is not going to be the same as it was going into it. Even if we find a vaccine, I don't think it's going to be the same. I think things are going to change in a lot of different ways as well too. Let me turn to when I say it's going to change before we even find a vaccine.

The Neil Ferguson report, by the way, I mentioned this to you offline, I mentioned this to every one of the listeners, he announced yesterday he tested positive for COVID-19 as well too.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Jim Bianco: He talked about all of the suppression techniques that we could use to flatten the curve and not overwhelm the healthcare system.

But what was the thing that supposedly got Trump in the White House really eye-opened was this returns in the fall, this returns next year. So that it isn't we flatten the curve, we try to lessen the burden on the healthcare system, And then it burns out and goes away forever.

It only goes away when one of two things happens, according to the report: herd immunity, which is 70% or 80% of the population of the planet gets this and builds up an immunity to it, or a vaccine. So we're all preparing to work at home. We're all preparing to have our kids be homeschooled online.

We're going to do this again in the fall. We're going to do this again in the spring of '21. Until either herd immunity or a vaccine comes. I bring that up hoping that is not the case, but the reality is, why do you think markets are doing what they're doing? This is what they're afraid of. So why are you in such a hurry to pick a bottom?

You would be only if you think this is going to be temporary. It will go away and then it'll be right back to January 2020 as if it never happened. I cannot imagine that that would be the case.

I can see in the post-virus world that we're going to do this not only over and over till this is over, but the next one. Every 2 to 3 years, there's some kind of pandemic that comes out of Africa or Asia— SARS, Ebola, MERS, H1N1, bird flu. Right. We didn't take any of those seriously.

Well, when we're past this one, 2022, 2023, and the next one comes, because there's always another one, we're going to shut everything down all over again. And then we're going to say, well, nothing came of it. Nobody got sick. And we're going to say, aha, it's because we shut everything down. Or maybe it wasn't that serious. Not after 2020. We're not going to pretend that these things aren't serious anymore. So my point is, we're not going to go back. to where we were before. So that's why I think that we need to understand what these markets are trying to tell us. And I don't disagree with them. I don't think that these markets are wrong in their assessment of where we're going next.

Feature: the virus as the pin that pops the bubble

Erik Townsend: Jim, so far we've been discussing this in terms of the virus, as if it's all about the virus. I'd like to introduce another possibility, which is I would make the argument that for the last 10 years, we've had what a lot of people have criticized as a completely unsustainable system, one in which the, the previous free trade, free market capitalism was kind of replaced by central banks and central bank liquidity fueling a massive bubble in both stocks and bonds at the same time.

And because that correlation was working, it allowed people to just keep laying leverage on, leverage on more and more. It, you know, that just the bubble kept getting bigger. What if it turned out that although the virus is a really, really big deal, I think we agree on that, what if the, the main effect of the virus on financial markets was not its direct effect, but rather that it's serving as the pin that pops a bubble that systematically needed to be popped or was going to pop someday anyway? Maybe this was just the catalyst that brought about a collapse of of what's been built for the last 10 years, I would argue, on kind of false pretense.

Jim Bianco: I, I think that's exactly what it was, was it was the pin. And I'll remind everybody, let's look at some previous examples. Well, you know, they'll say, do you remember SARS? I don't. Yes. Do you know what day SARS was announced as a global pandemic? 2 days after the Iraq War began. We were preoccupied. With other things. And that was April of 2003. The markets had already— we were just completing a recession. They were just coming off of a 40% decline. There was a risk attitude in markets best summarized by the Federal Reserve.

In March of 2003, the Federal Reserve used to offer this assessment of the economy. And they said the assessment of the economy was so uncertain that they couldn't offer Well, if you're going to have a pandemic in that environment, when everything is already depressed and you have fear, you're not going to get much more of a depression in markets.

1918 was the same thing. Markets were depressed and feared because we had just fought a terrible war. That's why the Spanish flu did not wind up having, you know, some kind of a negative effect on markets. This one came at the height of a raging bull market. This one came at the height of a market that supposedly had the perfect hedge. Go ahead, risk the farm on everything, and you could run into liquid Treasuries in 3 seconds to protect yourself if it doesn't work. And this was the one where everybody's got to buy stocks, the famous Trump tweet of January of this year. Stock market's up 90%. Why aren't you in your 401? It's not too late. And I'll only say, don't totally blame Trump on that. He was reflecting a mentality that a lot of people had.

It was when this one came, not what it was. SARS might have done this if it came in January of 2020. The Spanish flu might have done this if it came in 2020, but they came when markets were already depressed. And near recessionary levels to begin with. This one came in the 11th year of an expansion when the President of the United States is running on reelection, that you need to reelect me because the stock market's up. That was the belief that we had on it. So yeah, this was the big pin. You never know what the pin is, but you know the balloon is ready for a pin, and this just happened to be it.

Feature: China's case and death counts

Erik Townsend: Jim, before we close, I want to first salute you because you're the only guy I know of in finance who has been consistently 2 steps ahead of me on this whole coronavirus issue since day one. You were on top of this, and your graphs and charts and your projections of the exponential growth curves have been incredibly insightful. So as the guy who kind of saw this before everybody else, my final question to you is this: what do you see that maybe nobody else is seeing yet? What are your new theories that maybe aren't fully vetted yet, but you're thinking about that maybe no one has seen that might be of interest to our listeners?

Jim Bianco: Okay, I've got one about China, and, uh, I'm gonna throw out a big number and let me define it. China says that there are 81,000 cases. I think they're off by orders of magnitude, and I think that they're off by 1,000x. Now let me explain that. I think there's 81 million cases in China.

Let me rephrase that. That's 6% of the population, meaning 94% of the population did not get this. That sounds entirely reasonable that 6% of the population of China got this, not 81,000 but 81 million. Remember, it's a country of 1.4 billion people. They say that they had 3,400 deaths.

I think that that's off. By 1,000x. I think it's more like, you know, millions. Now the reason I say that is, well, wait a minute, a death is a binary thing. You're either dead or you're not dead.

Keep in mind that in the Chinese healthcare system, they do things a little differently. And there was an exact example of this came around in February. An 85-year-old man with a heart condition contracts SARS. He's in his house under quarantine and he's feeling deathly ill. He leaves his house from quarantine to walk to the nearby clinic, has a heart attack, and dies one block from the clinic. And there was a famous picture of him laying on the street or on the sidewalk.

The healthcare system in China will list him as cause of death, heart attack. It's accurate because he died of a heart attack, but they don't list a secondary cause like we do in the West. So I think they're grossly underestimating the number of people that have died from this. Yeah. Now, why is that important? Because I do think that they've finished a wave and that they've probably flattened out, but at a much, much higher level.

They are trying to restart their economy. And I'm going to give you one statistic.

TomTom is the GPS tracking system that is in a lot of cars. TomTom has real-time tracking of congestion indexes for major cities around the world. You could go to their website and find out to this minute what is the congestion patterns in any city. If you look at Milan and you look at Rome, in Rome and Milan, they are showing congestion patterns are down 20-ish percent, maybe 25%, thereabouts, depending on what time you measure it.

In China, where the government is still trying to announce we are restarting, we are getting back to business, they're still down 40 to 50%.

I think the biggest story that we're missing about, oh, it's all over with in China, we don't understand the amount of emotional and psychological damage that this did to the Chinese economy. You don't shut down the Chinese economy. For 81,000 people that caused 3,400 deaths in a country of 1.4 billion. You do it because it's far, far worse, and that emotional damage is far, far worse in China.

And you also see it in social media, and you also pick it up that the amount of, of social unrest, the amount of complaining to the government, the amount of complaining online is the highest that they've ever seen. That people are very angry that this happened to them. This is leaving a mark in China, and that's what I think we need to understand. It's going to leave a mark in Italy, it's going to leave a mark in Iran, it's going to leave a mark in Europe, and it's going to leave a mark in the United States. We don't know what that mark is going to be, but we can see that China is really struggling to get back to normal, even if their caseloads are as low as they say, but it is much more damaging than anybody thinks. They just did not sit at home and watch endless hours of streaming videos, and then they're going to go back to work like nothing changed.

Feature: Bianco Research and where to follow Jim

Erik Townsend: Jim, before we let you go today, please tell our listeners what you do at Bianco Research. You've got a day job that's not solving the world's problems and being the first guy to see the coronavirus situation. What's your What's your normal day job and how can our institutional investors find out more about what you offer?

Jim Bianco: Bianco Research is an investment service that is primarily designed for institutional investors. It really revolves around macro and the fixed income markets. I am affiliated with an institutional brokerage firm called Arbor Research and Trading, has a bunch of bond brokers that do trades, or you can purchase subscriptions to our research as well too.

In these unusual times, I've really turned up the volume on social media. My LinkedIn account at James Bianco or @BiancoResearch, you'll find a lot of what we're doing now because markets are so fast moving. And you know that when you put out a daily letter, it's like, wow, look at this, I can't wait 20 more hours to let the world know about this. So I've been doing a lot more of that on social media and probably will until things calm down. I won't go to zero when it comes down, but I'll do a little bit less of it there. And then there's our website, biancoresearch.com, and you can request a free trial on our website and you can get right in and see some of the stuff that we do.

Erik Townsend: Well, Jim, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. We look forward to getting you back in the future. And again, listeners, @biancoresearch is an absolute must-follow on Twitter.

Erik Townsend: Twitter to stay abreast of Jim's latest graphs and charts regarding the coronavirus crisis. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message.

This episode of MacroVoices was sponsored by my own vacation rental on the coast of Maine. It's a 5-acre oceanfront family compound with 2 separate residences, 2 kitchens, and 8 king and queen bedrooms. In addition to that, there's a whole bunch of pullout sofas and bunk beds and stuff. So we can actually sleep upwards of 30 people in a pinch, including all of the bunk beds. And it's super duper popular. We were completely, totally sold out for this entire season. But my expectation is that the entire rental season is probably gonna be a write-off. We have people planning to fly in from California and Seattle, and obviously that's now in serious question. I think we are or should be headed toward a national travel ban.

You could not imagine a better safe haven to ride out the COVID-19 crisis than this property. It's extremely rural. You could not ask for better social distancing. Has sunsets over the ocean, has a great big rec room with a pool table and a home theater. and super fast 100 megabit cable internet to keep you connected to both Netflix and the financial markets and so forth.

At this point, I think that the vacation rental season is going to be a write-off. So I'd like to find a tenant. Hopefully I can help somebody too. The ideal tenant would be, you know, a family in New York City who wants to get the hell out of the city to ride this crisis out in the countryside. Now, to be clear, the property is currently booked in July and August.

I would need to renegotiate with my current reservations if I was going to rent it to someone else, but I've got a feeling that would be easy to do. So if you or anyone you know is looking to find a safe haven to spend the next few months out of New York City or whatever city you live in, I would suggest that unless you do it really soon, that you be close enough to drive to Midcoast, Maine. It's right on the, on the oceanfront. It's got west-facing views, so you see the sunset over the ocean. It's a fantastic place to be. Normally, this is early season, but it's available starting right now, and I've got a feeling it's available all the way through the end of August. Now, it's totally booked, but I think it's going to get unbooked as this crisis unwinds. If anybody's interested in that, please contact me via info@macrovoices.com.

Send me an email, and I'll let you know more about it.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: how the risk parity unwind unfolded

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Jim Bianco. And but joining us now in the postgame is Kevin Muir, the Macro Tourist. And we really wanted to look at some of the more technical and quantitative perspectives of what's going on in the markets. And I couldn't think of someone that understands this more than you, Kev. So welcome to the show.

Kevin Muir: Great to be with you guys.

Patrick Ceresna: So our listeners, you can download the chartbook that we're going to be referencing in the Research Roundup email, or you can click the download button on the website. Now, first thing I wanted to go to on chart 2 is a chart that I added, which is going back to Chris Cole's Volatility and the Alchemy of Risk that they wrote at Artemis all the way back in 2017. And when we had him on the show in 2018, right before the vol event, he was talking about that explicit short vol as well as the implicit short vol. And the implicit short vol was all the risk parity, vol control, risk premium harvesting funds.

And of course, he talked about also the impact of the share buybacks and how this is all an implicit short gamma trade. And what took 2 years, you know, after the big vol event, we had Chris on, he said, well, that was just the appetizer and the main course is coming in terms of this this implicit short gamma risk. And it happened here the last month. It was that. And so, uh, what we have on page 3 and 4, some of just what happened in this risk parity segment of the market. Why don't you talk us through what you saw happen here and, and how did this all unravel?

Kevin Muir: Well, the main thing to realize about risk parity is that they adjust their exposure to different asset classes based upon the volatility of the market. So when the market was, uh, going up nice and steady, they were increasing exposure and it was kind of the best of both worlds. Bonds were rallying, stocks were rallying, they kept increasing their exposure. Then the virus hits and all of a sudden we get a kind of a shock to the system. And that shock causes the kind of volatility to increase. And that in itself causes them to cut back on their exposures, which then causes more volatility, which then becomes a feedback loop until ultimately you have I have a kind of this chart from Nomura that shows the gross risk parity estimated exposure, meaning based upon the volatility of the market, how much exposure should they have? And you can see that going into the— before the crisis, it was supposed to be 500% or 550%, and we're now down to 250%.

So this volatility shock has forced managers to delever by approximately 50%.

Patrick Ceresna: And Kev, like the other thing to add there is that they have to also deal with assets under management shrinking. Like there was, I think, a rumor that there was, uh, like sovereign wealth funds and other things drawing huge amounts of capital out of these risk parity funds. That, that just even adds to that selling, right?

Kevin Muir: That's right. There's the one, the biggest of the risk parity funds, they're supposedly, uh, one of their biggest clients is the Saudi Wealth Fund. And when we had the shock to the system with the kind of the change in their policy, with the undercutting of the pricing of the Russians, we saw them withdraw a lot of money, and that caused a lot of redemptions at that fund. And if you go look here at this next chart, we have the S&P Risk Parity 15 Vol Index. Basically, this is a portfolio if you manage it to 15% vol. What's interesting about this, Patrick, is that if you look at it in 2018, in that sell-off, it handled it pretty well. It was basically unchanged or down maybe a little bit. But you can see that in 2019, it was rocketing higher But has given up all the gains and then some.

So now you're starting at a situation where you've given up the past 2 years and you're underwater.

Postgame: GDXJ discount to NAV and are ETFs broken

Patrick Ceresna: Kev, now obviously risk parity blew, and this is, this is crazy because it affected all asset classes. I mean, you're talking currency, bonds, gold, everything got impacted by it. But what was interesting is, is that how this has impacted the ETFs. And so on page 5, I'm asking the question, Are ETFs broken? And while this happened in a whole array of ETFs, you wrote about in your recent Macro Tourist blog piece there about the GDXJ. And so what I started with here on page 6 was just a chart showing this. And what was crazy is a 3x leveraged NUGT there also just imploded. It went also some from $40, like, to $5 or something crazy like that.

Kevin Muir: Yeah.

Patrick Ceresna: But here the GDXJ went from $46 down to under $20 at one point, just an incredible drop. But those 2 days where it basically dropped from $34 down to $20, something broke. And you showed in your blog some really interesting charts that explain it.

So why don't you take us through what you saw happening in the GDXJ?

Kevin Muir: Right. This was one of the first ETFs that I saw that was under Big pressure that actually caused dislocations and arbitrages that usually kind of get fixed up and brought into line right away were not being brought into line. So I noticed this on the 11th of March. You saw some selling later in the day, and for the first time, the GDXJ traded at a slight discount to the NAV, the net asset value. Then the next day on the 12th, you saw it trade okay all day, but And later in the day, there was a big sell order. And when someone sells late in the day at just any price, that really reeks of just get it off the sheets, like just get this position off, or the margin clerk or your prime broker blowing the position out. In this case, it's probably a prime broker because this was a size trade they were doing. And what you saw there was that it traded at a discount to NAV in the last hour, but then towards the end of the day, it was kind of brought back into line by the arbitrageurs.

Then on Friday, it just— the stuff hit the fan, man. It just went and it started trading below NAV. It stayed below NAV all day and culminated with a monster sell-off into the close where it went to an almost 20% discount to NAV.

Now, in a perfectly efficient market, this shouldn't happen. You could go buy that GDXJ, Short all the stocks in the index and earn 20% instantaneously, no risk. So, I worked on an institutional equity desk that did derivatives like this. We would've never let this get there. And this is why I wanted to highlight this. The market is broken and there's too many traders sitting at home in their pajamas, or the risk managers in another room in Connecticut instead of in the New York office.

And what's happened is the system is broken. It's just not able to operate efficiently. So whereas usually you'd have a trade like this that get arbitraged, there's now no one to take the other side. And, you know, I've been pushing and I thought that they should have actually closed the exchange. I get labeled kind of a crybaby and that I should let it go down. I didn't think you should close the exchange because the prices were going down.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Kevin Muir: I thought you should close the exchange because things were no longer functioning, because just the physical proximity of people being around each other and running these machines, it was necessary and it was no longer working. So, this GDXJ was sold by this big institution and ended up causing way more pain than it should have, because the fact is there was no one to take the other side of the trade.

Postgame: bond ETF discounts and the 60/40 drawdown

Erik Townsend: Kevin, let's move on to page 8. This chart looks a little different than what we're used to. What's going on here on this Bloomberg screen grab we're looking at?

Kevin Muir: Well, it's one thing when GDXJ, which is an index of gold miners, junior miners, trades at a discount. It's another thing when the Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF trades at a wicked discount. And that's what we're looking at here. Whereas last week it was kind of relegated to, you know, these obscure ETFs, this week it blew out and it went into the kind of bigger ones. This BND is almost a $50 billion market cap ETF.

And it was trading at a 6% discount to NAV this week. This is a signal that the market is extremely broken. Now, some people will say that this is a problem with the passive and this was inevitable. I argue it has more to do with the fact that there's no arbitrageurs and that the systems aren't able to operate correctly in this environment.

Erik Townsend: Now, on page 9, the next chart, uh, we're looking That big PX, it says on the Bloomberg. I'm assuming that's Big Picture Trading has made it to Bloomberg.

Kevin Muir: No, that's the BlackRock 60/40 portfolio mix. And one of the things that I wanted to highlight was the fact that although this did start off as a risk parity slash other vol targeting fund sell-off, it is kind of morphed into a mom-and-pop sell-off now. And we're seeing all portfolios and even the kind of classic 60/40 portfolio getting absolutely crushed. And so this index, you know, has gone from 14 down to 11.15. I've been kind of inundated with calls from friends, family members worried about the market. It has gone from being something that was just kind of an esoteric sell-off to now full-fledged panic across the board.

Patrick Ceresna: And when you look at page 10 though, that's a Nomura chart there. Again, it's showing that this drop in that 60/40 portfolio, at least on their chart, it was a 15% drawdown in 18 days. That was an 8-sigma move. It's extraordinary that in the chart here of 20 years of history, there was no point even during 2008 that we had a move of this magnitude in a 60/40 portfolio.

Postgame: is it time to buy?

Erik Townsend: Okay. Now I want to get to what I really want to talk to both of you guys about, and I'm going to do this a little differently. I'll explain why I'm so interested in your view after I get it, but I want to start with, what do you guys think? Are you feeling like we're at a bottom here where it's time to start buying?

Kevin Muir: Well, I wrote a piece on, I guess, Tuesday saying that I was sticking my finger in and starting to nibble on the long side. And I was kind of laughing, Erik, because when I did that, you retweeted something saying that I might be a little early and don't see the big picture. And have you ever seen that, you know, when a lion is eating a gazelle and after they're done, there's all those hyenas that are waiting to come and eat the rest of the gazelle?

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Kevin Muir: And once the lion walks away, they jump on that carcass That's what I felt like. I felt like I was just getting lambasted for the idea of buying stocks here. And I must say that I understand the pessimism, but I think that that's fully baked into the market and that you got to start with the blue tickets and put away the pinks now, I think.

Erik Townsend: And Patrick, what's your take?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, our Big Picture Trading members covered their shorts on Tuesday and Wednesday and We're poking in going long as of yesterday. Now, to me, this is purely a technical reactionary move, and no way am I getting bigger picture bullish just yet. To me, the market is incredibly oversold, and a number of quants that are out there are pointing out the huge roll-off of the March 20th options. There's something close to like $500 billion of short put gamma or delta, sorry, that basically has an expiration of March 20th. And it has to be either rolled and it's gonna either be rolled at an 80 vol, which I seriously doubt, or it's gonna start to be closed. That's gonna in itself put a little bit of buying pressure on the short term. So I think these incredibly oversold conditions can have a reflexive rally, but I'm not yet convinced that that's somehow a meaningful long-term buy.

Erik Townsend: Okay. The reason I wanted to ask both of you guys that question is I really think there's a huge value to teamwork among people who have different talents. And I really want to give Kevin credit. The last time he was on the show, we disagreed. Kevin said he thought, you know, it's time to start buying here. And I was— I said, you're crazy. You don't even see the big picture. You don't know what's going on. Kevin's call proved right. And it's funny because Kevin's been crediting me for being right on Twitter.

Kevin Muir: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: What happened is Kevin— Kevin said long the stock market here. Stocks went up. And about a week later, Kevin said, I think this feels like the top. And he went short and he got the top of the market perfectly. So for that, being one step ahead of the market, I respect both of you guys as having more skill than I do. And I really take to heart what you say, because if you both feel like it's time for the market to go up, I bet you're gonna be right.

Now that we've covered that, you and everybody else are totally, completely missing what's really about to happen here, which is this COVID-19 crisis is gonna be way bigger than the great financial crisis. It is, uh, something that the world hasn't even come to terms with the scope of. What's about to happen in the United States is gonna be scary. As far as where the bottom comes in the S&P, I have no idea on the number, but I think the date is around June 1st.

And I don't think that the whole country has even begun to come to terms with what's about to happen. So it says to me, if you guys think that it's time for market to go up, I bet you're going to be right in the short term. I don't know how far up, but I think it's an opportunity to sell it when we get to whatever that top is, because I think there's a lot of downside still to come.

Postgame: stimulus and liquidity versus fundamentals

Kevin Muir: Well, Erik, you might be right. Listen, I've made the mistake of underestimating how large this will be. And you, I give you all the credit in the world. You were out there in front of it telling everybody that it was going to be bigger. And the fact that you're still telling people that leads me to worry a little bit. Having said that, for the longest time, your view was not accepted. And it was something that only kind of the elite few in the MacroVoices listeners were getting the inside information, but it was not accepted in the regular community.

At this point now, you know, the other day I watched on CNBC a hedge fund manager get on there and I thought he was gonna, you know, break down emotionally 'cause he was so upset. And then he was talking about how stocks were gonna go to zero.

I see that the VIX closed above 70 every day for a week. We have credit spreads blowing out. We have off-the-run govies, you know, trading at spreads not seen since the Long-Term Capital. We have these examples of these ETFs trading at wicked discounts. It just feels to me like they say buy when there's blood in the streets, especially if that blood's your own. I was a little early, so I am bleeding all over the street, but I do think that we've hit that point of maximum pessimism.

And I do notice that Patrick is a really smart guy, and there's other smart guys that are also picking away on the long side, or at the very least closing their shorts. I noticed that Raoul Pal from Real Vision, he closed all of his shorts in HYG, equities and oil and everything.

Yeah. Gundlach actually tweeted the other day that the first time in years he's not net short any US stocks. This was a massive margin call that caused prices to get to points that were really kind of almost ridiculous. And I think that you very well might be right from a health perspective. I just wonder if you're going to be right from a stock market perspective. And one of the things is I would be more inclined to kind of use your view if I saw the politicians not doing anything.

I always say that once the politicians start panicking, the market can stop panicking. And that's really what I've been waiting for is the politicians to panic. And I see that the amount that they're throwing at this just gets larger and larger and larger. You see the Fed coming out and cutting and doing QE. When that's not enough, they do a corporate paper buyback. When that's not enough, they go do their swap lines. They are doing whatever it takes. The same with the ECB, with all of these things.

And then on the fiscal side, I really think we've been talking about this, Erik, you and I, for a long time, that eventually MMT or MMT-like policies are coming. Well, I feel like they're here. So although I completely defer to you on the health side of it, and I don't deny one bit that it's going to get a lot worse, I just wonder if the amount of liquidity and stimulus that's thrown at this makes it diverge from fundamentals. Don't forget, it was only kind of, you know, 6 months ago that everyone was saying it makes no sense that stocks are trading so firm given the kind of the underlying strength of the economy.

And I think that we could once again see a situation where we're saying it makes no sense that stocks are trading so firm given that the carnage that is happening in the economy. And that's, uh, that's, that's my main point, is everyone thinks that this is the, this is the period where fundamentals of stocks and, uh, you know, and the economy converge. And I'm saying that I'm not so sure you're correct. And at the very least, I would be wary of being short, looking for it to go significantly down with them kind of printing and spending so much money.

Erik Townsend: Well, I take that very seriously, and I value your opinion, and it definitely makes me tempted to cover my shorts and wait for a better location to reenter at a higher number. I don't think we've seen anything close to the bottom, but if you guys both think, and you know, you mentioned some really big names, Jeff Gundlach, uh, these guys are all covering their shorts. It doesn't matter whether they're right long-term. If you've got those kinds of people with the kind of influence they have on markets all covering at the same time, that makes the market go higher. So it sounds to me like maybe we do have a tactical rally, that it's time to trade. I'm still convinced that this— it's not a question of over or not over. It hasn't even started yet in a meaningful way. People haven't even begun to get their heads around what's about to happen. So I don't think it's a question of over or not over.

It's a question of has it started? And the answer is no.

Postgame: bear market duration, June 1 view and Macro Tourist free issue

Patrick Ceresna: And Erik, it is incredibly rare if a bear market of this magnitude was just to be over in a month. Even if there is a tactical rally, often bear markets can last six months or a year or even longer as everything starts to break, and it takes a while for everything to fully wash out. And so very likely that there'll be another leg down at some point. So it's not that you want to be outright bullish and just load load you know your portfolio up like it's a new bull market. It's just it's pretty oversold and so extreme on the end. that a reflexive rally would be incredibly natural here.

Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more.

Kevin Muir: Erik, you've been very kind to me and saying some really nice things, but I'm going to return the favor because I think you made the call of my lifetime when we were chatting off air after I was on the line with you the last time. And you said to me that you thought this was the greatest mispricing of risk that you had ever seen in your lifetime on the And kudos to you because you were spot on correct. The market completely missed it and you were right. And, you know, it does make me worry that you're once again saying the same thing. And so maybe I'll be right for a week again, and then we'll be talking and we'll be doing this again from 1,000 S&P points lower.

Erik Townsend: We'll see what happens, but I don't think that the pandemic reaches a peak level of pain until June 1st. And, uh, I think that what's coming in terms of the amount of economic shutdown that will be required to contain the virus is bigger than anybody's reacting to it. It's fascinating to hear you guys talk, because when you said a few minutes ago, you said it's when you see the politicians panicking that the market doesn't have to anymore. I agree with the logic of that. The thing is, what I see here is politicians not yet even beginning to take this situation seriously. You guys see it as them panicking. So needless to say, we think there's a different perspective on what's needed. I'll tell you what else is needed while we've got you, Kevin. You have gone the way with the Macro Tourist newsletter, which has been one of the most popular newsletters in the industry. You started the way a lot of people do with a freebie.

And of course now it is a paid subscription. How about just for that one issue that I had reacted to on Twitter, which was really excellent. Can we talk you into sharing that one with our MacroVoices listeners as a free trial?

Kevin Muir: Sure. Sounds great. We'll include it in the Roundup.

Erik Townsend: All right. So the Research Roundup will have a link to Kevin's paid subscription newsletter that I was reacting to. And I totally get where you're coming from. And I want to make sure I emphasize to our listeners, when it comes to having your pulse on the market and knowing one step ahead of the market where they're headed next, you're much better at that, Kevin, than I will ever be. And I really respect your view. If you say up is the next move, I bet you're going to be right. And, uh, one of these days you'll see the big picture, and so will the rest of the market, and then it's going to be a big down.

Kevin Muir: Well, thanks for having me, Erik and Patrick. It's been a pleasure being on your show.

Outro and disclaimer

Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: In the Research Roundup, you're going to find a transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the charts we just discussed with Kevin in the postgame. There's also a link to an article discussing Charlie McElligott's quantitative look at today's market, as well as a Jim Bianco article on this being one of the biggest moments of truth in financial market history. So you'll find this And so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distribution.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.

MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.

For more information, visit MacroVoices.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Axel Merk — Merk Investments founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Preview, donation-funded extra episodes and sponsor appeal

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 210 was recorded a day early this week on Wednesday, March 11th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases. Merk Investments founder Axel Merk joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from the stock market to bond yields and whether they can go negative in the United States, to gold and why gold mining shares haven't done as well as the metal itself. And of course, our postgame segment will feature yet another of Patrick's famous chart books. We'll do the postmortem analysis on what happened in the market on Monday and discuss possible scenarios for what might come next.

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, I've been bracing myself for one of those half-an-hour market wraps where you go deep into the coronavirus. Is that what I should be expecting this week?

Erik Townsend: Hey, you brought your pillow with you, huh? I was afraid it was gonna go even longer this week, Patrick, because there is a lot to talk about on the coronavirus story and also, of course, epic events in the crude oil market.

But there's good news. We had a couple of requests on Twitter over the weekend for more special episodes dedicated just to COVID-19 and to crude oil. And I explained as politely as I could on Twitter, like, hey guys, sorry, but our policy is only to produce extra episodes when we have either ad revenue or donations to pay for the production costs. So unfortunately, no extra episodes planned this week.

Well, wow, as soon as I said that on Twitter, the donations started rolling in, including several $250 donations and one $500 donation. So in total, those donations that we received pay for 2 more episodes. We weren't planning to do any more this week, so we're kind of reshuffling here. I'm going We're gonna try to get 2 more out before the week is out. One all about COVID-19 coronavirus commentary because that can fill a podcast by itself. There's so much going on. And then another one, the $500 donor requested Tracy Shuchart. So you asked for it, you got it. We will have Tracy hopefully airing on Friday, or at least that's the plan right now. Please bear with me if the schedule changes.

Again, we're shuffling things around at the last minute here. So the moral of the story, folks, is that for those of you who either made money or saved money that you otherwise would've lost in the market thanks to our recent market calls. The moral of the story is ask and you shall receive a Twitter answer saying no, but donate and you shall receive extra podcast content. Hint, hint. And if you really want to leverage your resources, use your professional network to help us find more long-term strategic sponsors for MacroVoices so that we can bring you even more content in coming months.

MacroVoices is a fantastic opportunity for advertisers 'cause we've got a very sophisticated audience of finance professionals and ultra-high net worth individuals and family offices. Top-grade stuff here. But we need your help getting the word out because frankly, the sponsors or prospective sponsors that I'm talking to keep asking me what it would take to get Jim Cramer on the show. And I can't answer that politely. So we really need your help getting people who understand what we do, what we're about, and what audience we address. We need to find some sponsors and we'd really appreciate your help.

Coronavirus: Erik says the worst is still ahead

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, well, I'll believe that you can do an abbreviated coronavirus update only after I hear it, so I'm starting my stopwatch right now, Erik.

Erik Townsend: Okay, well, the first and most important point, it is still totally not priced in. What's coming is going to be really ugly, folks, and it's not a question of if, it's a little bit more on the when, but it's not far off at this point. The next month is going to be where this turns really scary, and it was easy to see coming a month ago, but it seems like the market's not going to react until it happens. The market's ability to anticipate How they didn't anticipate this one completely baffles me. So the worst is yet to come. I'll do a whole podcast explaining what I mean by that and why I think the worst is yet to come and what I think is coming and so forth. What the market is doing now is it's responding to just fluff news.

Dr. Fauci was on the air today saying that this is 10 times more deadly than the seasonal flu. Well, first of all, that's wrong. The real number's between 28 and 55 times more deadly, but that's been known for a month. This is not news. The market reacts to headlines like that. that as if that was the big news. Big news has yet to come. It's going to be a lot uglier than what we've seen so far. So markets are still completely in denial. I know, Patrick, that you've been talking about, oh my gosh, we got to do a postgame chart book to talk about the huge move on Monday. I think Monday was an itsy-bitsy teeny-weeny little sample of what is still to come.

So the peak of this crisis won't occur until April and May, but I think the next 2 to 3 weeks is when the shit's going to hit the fan in a way that finally the market wakes up and realizes, okay, The United States is not immune. We're gonna be looking just like Italy. Our hospital systems are gonna be overwhelmed. It's all coming and it's coming soon. So Monday was just a dress rehearsal for something much bigger still on the horizon.

Okay, what's the time on the stopwatch?

S&P 500 sell-off and where the downside trade worked

Patrick Ceresna: Let's go on. So the S&P 500 is pretty much trading right along its week lows. I mean, we're just a stone's throw from 2,700 at the time when we're recording this. How are you sizing up the situation?

Erik Townsend: Well, on Jim Bianco's list of the top 20 down days in world history for the S&P 500, there are 8 separate days from the 2008 crisis that all stand in that top 20 list. 5, 6, 7, 8% down in one day. Monday was just the first, and I think almost certainly not the biggest of the COVID-19-related big down days. So yeah, Monday was a big deal. It was, I don't know, it was number 7 or something on the all-time list of down days.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Down days on the S&P. There's a lot more still to come because we're still in denial about what's coming. Even as recently as, I think, Tuesday this week, yesterday, President Trump was still tweeting saying it's all going to blow over, it's going to go away on its own, there's nothing to worry about.

You know, I don't know that worry and fear and panic are good emotions, but there's a whole lot to be concerned about, and we're going to go through something very difficult that's going to have profound economic implications that are not priced in.

So I don't know, by the end of the week I think maybe we'll see new lows, certainly by the middle of next week as we see this exponential case count growth in Europe. Just today alone, Patrick, on Wednesday, 2,313 new cases— not total cases, but new cases— just reported today alone in Italy, bringing Italy's total up to 12,462 cases. They were at about 2,000 cases total a week ago. Meanwhile, we've got a lot of other countries in Europe Spain at 2,200 cases, Germany at 1,900 cases, France up to 2,200 cases today, Switzerland coming up on 1,000 quickly here. There's lots and lots of countries that are about where Italy was a week or two ago. They're gonna be where Italy is today in the next couple of weeks, and so is the United States. So I don't think you've seen anything yet.

I would also say that as far as what's coming, I don't think stocks have been the best way to play the downside. Certainly you wanna hedge any risk against exposure that you have if you're long in the stock market. But, you know, I have added puts and outright shorts on the S&P now. And in hindsight, I wish that— I wanted to diversify. I put most of my downside bets on this in the crude oil market. That was clearly the place to be. I think I called the virus thing correctly. It was not possible for me to see the OPEC and Russia falling out coming. But needless to say, that helped my trade. I put about 90% on crude oil and about 10% on shorting the S&P. I should have put that on long bonds. That was a better trade. So I think if you're trying to, you know, speculate on this event, shorting stocks has so far been the least effective way to do it.

Bonds and crude oil have been where the trade is. And I think that both bond yields and crude oil are also going lower.

US dollar: Erik's crisis-bullish dollar call proved wrong

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the dollar, because obviously that funding currency issue caused the dollar to have a pretty heavy break. And now We're getting a bit of a reaction. We're slowly bouncing. We're not yet at the 97 handle, but certainly well off the lows. Do you think that's it for the selling on the dollar, or do you think the US dollar has a little bit more to go?

Erik Townsend: I'm still putting myself in the handicap booth on this one, Patrick. I got the dollar call totally wrong. I thought that this event was going to be extremely dollar bullish. As you say, the reserve currency funding issue explains parts of this, the fact that the Fed has kind of taken some panic moves here. Undermines confidence in the dollar. Lots of reasons that I can explain this away. But frankly, Patrick, I got this one wrong and I got the other parts of the virus story very, very right. So I'm trying to focus on what I seem to be good at and not what I'm bad at. And I'm not sure where the dollar's headed.

Crude oil: Saudi-Russia price war and inventories

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to crude oil. And the first thing I wanna point out is I saw some trolls on Twitter calling you out for having covered your S&P put options at the market top, and which of course you did, moving a majority of your funds over to a crude oil short. And all I wanna say is, well, you know, The S&P is down 20%, but crude oil since your call was down 50%. So kudos to you.

Erik Townsend: Well, thanks. I can't take credit for that. I do credit myself for having very accurately seen what was coming with the coronavirus situation more than a month ahead of time. But frankly, if anything, I got that one wrong by being too early with it. I was too early putting those S&P shorts on.

And as far as the 50%, I didn't see I did think we were gonna get to $26 on crude. I still think we're gonna get back down there as a result of the coronavirus situation. That's been accelerated dramatically by the falling out between Saudi Arabia and Russia. So I can't really take credit for seeing that one coming, but the trades have worked out. I want to— I don't want to brag about success in the market though on this one, Patrick. We have, as Javier Blas pointed out on Twitter, you know, we've got a lot of listeners who work in the oil patch who are going to be absolutely screwed over by these events. And this is not a happy time.

I did make money on it. I wish I had made money on something else because frankly, I wasn't expecting this falling out between Russia and OPEC+. I thought it was going to be coronavirus that was going to do damage to the oil market. And unfortunately, I think that the worst is still ahead. And likewise, the whole country is going to suffer through a lot more than most people think is coming with coronavirus. So my heart goes out to the people who were adversely affected. I wish that if I was going to be successful trading something, it was something else. In any event, let's get to oil, the really big story. Certainly, I've already explained the coronavirus and why I think that is going to take oil prices lower.

The big story is the falling out this week between OPEC+ and Russia. As I reported in last week's market wrap, basically there was an OPEC+ meeting. They said, we got to cut, everybody's got to join in. Russia said no, left the meeting. They tried to spin a press release saying, okay, we're gonna announce that there is a cut contingent on Russia coming to their senses and joining in with us. Russia confirmed they still said no on Friday afternoon. That really brought the market down. And then on Saturday, Mohammed bin Salman surprised everybody by basically saying, okay, if you wanna play that way, fine. We're going to totally ramp up our production, dramatically increase production, and allow the oil prices to crash to teach you a lesson. Wow. Listen, Russia, and you better come back to the negotiating table. Russia has not come back to the negotiating table. Everybody's standing their ground, and it looks like that's going to exacerbate the price-down action, which I thought was already gonna be very strong because of the coronavirus.

Now, if Russia could be somehow coerced to come back to the negotiating table, that might happen as early as next week. On the 18th, there's an OPEC+ meeting. Russia has agreed to send a delegate. If somehow Russia caved and said, okay, We want to play ball now. We're going to agree to whatever production cut, 1.5 million barrels you want to do in Q2, we'll participate in full. That would certainly reverse the direction of the oil market in the short term. But I think that's because the market is yet to price in what's really coming with respect to the coronavirus story. I think we're going to get back down to $26 either way, but we'll get there much more quickly if Russia continues to stand their ground and not agree to the big production cut that Saudi Arabia wants.

Patrick Ceresna: So how did the inventory numbers come out in, Erik?

Erik Townsend: They came in today at crude oil building 7.7 million barrels. That's a much bigger build than was expected, so that would normally be very bearish. The thing is, it was offset by drawdowns in finished products— gasoline drawing down 5 million barrels, distillates drawing down 6.4 million barrels. Meanwhile, Cushing, Oklahoma building 704,000 barrels. So between gasoline and distillates, you got 9 million barrels of drawdowns on finished products against A crude oil build of 7.7. They kind of cancel themselves out and you ended up with down action on the tape, but it was muted. And just 20 minutes later, it was back up to where it was before the news came out. Very interesting to me, though. RBOB gasoline went straight down with crude oil. Normally you would expect when you have a big crude build and a gasoline draw, normally you would get a crude price down and a gasoline price up on that. We didn't see that today. I don't know if that means anything.

US production, 13 million barrels, ticking down 1 tick. It was 13.1 million barrels last week, which was a new all-time record. We're back down to the previous all-time record of 13 million barrels.

Gold: bullish long term, margin-call risk near term

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to gold, because I would have thought that, uh, with the market weakness, that gold may have still acted like that risk-off asset. But really, since bonds have seemed to peak out, gold seems to have peaked out with it a little bit from that correlation. What's your take on, uh, gold trading here around $1,638?

Erik Townsend: Well, everything that's happening right now is super-duper bullish for gold in the long run. There's no doubt in my mind about that. I think that gold is going well over $2,000 an ounce in the next several years, certainly probably in this year. I wouldn't be at all surprised if by the end of this year we're above $2,000. The thing is that if the stock market crashes, and I think it's likely to, but frankly, you know, in this crazy world of central bank intervention, I suppose anything's possible.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: Monday didn't count, though. That was not a stock market crash. If we had several days in a row the size of Monday, that would be a stock market crash. It's in those circumstances where traders are up against really serious margin calls where you could see gold sell off dramatically, as it did in 2008, not because the fundamentals are bad, but just because people have to raise cash to cover their margin calls and they're selling whatever they got.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: So, it is not guaranteed to happen. It's just a maybe. But if it does, you want to be ready to take advantage of it and buy more gold, because it's going up. It's just a question of whether it goes down first. And the reason it would go down first is because of that phenomenon in a stock market crash, which I think is entirely possible. You could see gold trade off pretty hard, and that would be a fantastic buying opportunity. So, you want to own gold here. Don't sell your gold. But you also want to have some dry powder ready to buy more gold if we get a crash and better prices. Okay.

10-year Treasury yield approaches zero

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, let's talk 10-year yields, because at least on my chart, it printed spot 36 on the downside. Now, both of us agreed that yields were going lower, but I just couldn't believe how fast we got down here. What's your take on all of this?

Erik Townsend: Well, when I said last week that I expected 50 basis points or lower, maybe even down to 25 basis points before the coronavirus crisis was over, I meant the whole crisis, the one that that's barely even gotten started so far, that hasn't really happened yet. We got in one week not quite to 25, but I think 36 might have been an end-of-day low because I could have swore that I saw lower prints on an intraday basis. I don't know what the intraday bottom was, but I think I saw 31 at one point. Anyway, holy cow, low yields is what we saw this week. So I think the market event that coronavirus is going to create I think the rate for the economy and for financial markets is way less than half over.

I think we're just barely getting started. If you figure that we've already come down more than 100 basis points on the 10-year yield, and we really haven't even gotten started yet, well, that ought to mean there's at least another 100 basis points before it's over. Well, wait a minute. If we're already down to 36 basis points, that means in order to go another basis point, you'd be going into negative yields on the US 10-year to the tune of 65 basis points or so.

Wow. I have to admit, I'm not an expert on the zero lower bound and whether it really is a bound, so to speak, or if it's just another number along the way to the negative yields that Danielle DiMartino Booth has predicted for more than a year now on MacroVoices.

So, the conviction that I do have is this market event is just getting started. It's got a long way to go. And I think there's a lot of reason, if we were starting from a higher number, However, I would say there's a lot of room for yields to move farther. Can they move farther when they've only got 35 basis points to go before they turn negative? I'm going to ask Axel that question in today's feature interview.

Why Axel Merk is this week's guest

Patrick Ceresna: So this week's feature interview guest is Axel Merk. So why did we invite Axel back onto the show this week?

Erik Townsend: First of all, it's been a long, long time. I think it's been a year and a half, 2 years since we had Axel on the program. He's a very well-known, well-respected guy. But particularly, the reason I wanted to get him on now is he's a currency guy. He's a macro guy, but he's got a particular focus on currencies. I think he runs a couple of currency mutual funds. I'm trying to remember exactly what products his firm offers. He's got a lot of background in areas that I think are very relevant to the events that are going on right now, because something that I've even just begun to try to get my head around is, okay, what are the forex implications of this whole coronavirus thing? And what happens when we have some countries that are more adversely affected than others, and how does that affect their currency pairs, and so on and so forth.

Erik Townsend: Axel's a really great guy to bring on for that kind of commentary.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once Again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment strategy. books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Axel Merk is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Axel Merk: catalyst vs. valuation, risk management and rebalancing

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Axel Merk, founder of Merk Investments. Axel, it's great to get you back on the show. It's been way too long. I'm really looking forward to this interview. Let's start with the high-level big picture of what's going on, both stock market coming off of its all-time highs, new All-time lows in bond yields. Is this all about the coronavirus crisis, or is the coronavirus just a catalyst that brought something else about?

Axel Merk: Well, great to be with you. In this industry, we always love to give a story to the action, and by all means, let's fit that story, right? I mean, clearly we've had many a bull market. Stocks were at an all-time high. They may have been due for a correction according to many, and then sure enough, we, we got a shock and it helped us. And so, I mean, ultimately ultimately, does it really matter? One of the things, if you've been around the block a few times, notice that there's a storyline that starts these things and then these stories evolve. Remember in, in 2000, for example, or whenever you've had a crisis or bear market coming, it starts somewhere, but then suddenly there are ripple effects that you don't foresee. And the challenge with focusing on one item is that then precisely you forget the big picture, that maybe stocks are expensive, maybe this happens or that happens. Now, does that mean I have a crystal ball what's going to happen tomorrow?

Absolutely not. I don't think anybody has. What we can do is risk management and pursue the plan that we have.

Erik Townsend: And what do you think about the current valuations on the stock market? What we're seeing is we're recording on Tuesday afternoon, haven't quite retested the lows from the last couple of days. We're about 2,750 on the S&P right now. Are the lows in or is this just the beginning? How do you see this playing out from here?

Axel Merk: Well, forecasts are difficult when they deal with the future. What we, what we do know is that volatility in recent days has been extreme. Historically, that's been an indicator that we're trying to find a bottom. We know that the earnings yield in the, in the S&P 500, or the cash flow yield, is high. Now, the earnings may be coming down because of the shock we have, and aside from corona, obviously the, the oil surprise we've had there. But even if if cash flow is cut in half relative to the yields in Treasuries, stocks are attractive. Now, as we also know, stocks tend to overreact on the upside and on the downside. So I'm not going to be there trying to catch a falling knife if that's what it is. That said, as I indicated just before, it's about sticking to a strategy. So, and most people don't. So if your strategy is, let's say you have a 60/40 portfolio, well, what you ought to have done on the way is gradually take some chips off the table and move it to the quote-unquote safer bucket.

And we can talk about that safety bucket, how it's not safe anymore, but still there's a strategy, right? And so similarly then, as the market tumbles, you might want to rebalance back in whether there's a low or not, just so that you have this consistent layout.

What has happened in practice is investors have wanted to have their cake and eat it. So they don't want to take gains. Maybe it is because they, they don't want to pay the taxes on the gains. But instead, the way they have to cake and eat it, they're adding a tiny component to a portfolio that's super volatile but diversified. I'm thinking about gold, gold mining type of thing. And that's certainly not safe. But they think that that's how they can get the diversification. If people were already spooked, they would be moving to cash. And so, we've seen obviously some of that in recent days, but a lot of the action we've had in this extreme volatility has been a deleveraging of leveraged players, Which obviously happens after a period of extended low volatility. People gear up and then it blows up in their faces.

Why the dollar fell: high-yielding dollar, euro as funding currency

Erik Townsend: Axel, you're known as a currency expert, among other things. Quite a few people, myself included, held a view about the US dollar in this coronavirus crisis. We felt that, hey, this thing's gonna affect the whole world, and it seems like it's gonna affect the United States last. It's got to be super bullish for the US dollar as safety trades go out of other assets and into US dollar-denominated assets. Market says we got it dead wrong. And I'll be the first to admit, I don't understand why. What the heck is going on that all of this is so dollar negative?

Axel Merk: Well, market teaches us to be humble. Whatever prevailing view there may be, we may have on just about anything, we're proven wrong. And it could be technicals, it could be fundamentals. But let's keep in mind that the dollar is a high-yielding currency these days. It's the highest yielding G10 currencies. As of a few weeks ago, the real yields based on the breakeven rates, 10-year rates are negative. That's unusual for the dollar. But still, the dollar is a high-yielding currency. And so when you have a risk-off environment, the high-yielding currency gets sold and the funding currency gets bought. Historically, that was only the yen, maybe the Swiss franc. These days, it's the euro as well. And if you talk about the dollar, it's usually the dollar index. And the dollar index has a heavy overweight of the euro. And the euro was hated by everybody going into this virus. And so sure enough, people took down leverage, which means they had to buy the euro, sell the dollar.

And so usually when you have these crunches, it kind of goes that everybody needs to get their funding in US dollars and so forth. But this time around, that's how it played out. And if you want to have a story, that's the story that explains why it is. But obviously, as we talk on the specific day, it's the other way around, right? So all these things They work for a while and then there is again a storyline that will take over.

Treasury yields, flight to safety and the zero bound

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to Treasury yields because this is another area where I guess it's one that I got right, but I've been amazed at how right. It doesn't really jibe with my expectations. I think it was 3 weeks ago, I told our audience, I think we're going below that record low from 2016 of 1.34% on the 10-year yield. And everybody thought I was crazy. We got lots of emails from listeners saying that's not A week later, we were there. I said, I think we're going sub-1%.

A week later, we were at 92 basis points. That was last week. I said, I think we're going to 50 basis points before this coronavirus situation is over. I didn't think it was gonna happen in less than a week. And boy, what did we get down to? 27 bps or something? I mean, just crazy. So, first question is, why is the yield on Treasuries crashing so hard when the stock market— I mean, yeah, it's down and it was a very significant day, on Monday this week, but nothing in my mind compared to what's going on with Treasury yields. Why so much action there and can it continue?

Axel Merk: Well, many questions and there are several that you didn't ask. One is the speed. I think the hallmark of this correction, if you want to call it such, is the speed. Markets have been functioning properly. There have been no big gaps other than there's some very quiet Asian hours. These markets have been working well and we can talk about the functioning of the market as well.

And yes, the bond market has been screaming, but the equity market has held up reasonably well except for Monday, the 9th of March, where we've had this amazing plunge. And it's— we talk about these crocodile jaws where you have these correlation charts and suddenly they diverge and then they snap back together. And so, you can have these dislocations or these anomalies in the markets for an extended period, but then they have to meet somehow. And obviously, I mean, the reason why Treasuries rally is because there's a flight to safety. And when you have a flight to safety, you go to the one that's most liquid. And so that tends to be Treasuries. That also happens to be the yen, right? When you need to have quote unquote safety immediately, and I'm not making an endorsement of anything safe here, the yen is something that's liquid. So people pile into it, and the yen was up over 3% on Monday the 9th, right? And so those sort of things can happen.

And yes, in my view, that, that is extreme. Now, at the same time, you can also say, hey, maybe that's the new normal, maybe that is how I'm going to be, maybe we're going to be living in a world where we all are working remotely and are never going to consume anything anymore. We can talk about that. I happen to disagree on that. But the market seems to be taking the most recent news as the most important one. And eventually, is it all the coronavirus? Well, maybe we, we price in a, a different type of government in the US that's not as business-friendly, right? There are all kinds of things that the market might be pricing in going forward, that when the glass is half empty, well, darn it, it is half empty. And obviously you can be at the other side of that trade and see an opportunity.

More broadly speaking though, and if I can make that broader point, with yields as low— and Monday tonight is probably going to prove me wrong on that— but can bonds really provide that sort of diversification that you want them to People buy bonds rarely because they love them, but because in that 60/40 portfolio, that 40 bucket is providing them that sort of diversification. And the Wall Street Journal several weeks ago kind of had an analysis that in the eurozone, bonds don't rally as much anymore in risk-off environments. Now, one day they rallied again, but, but still, can you still get the sort of diversification you used to get in bonds? I think that is the sort of thing that investors should chew on. How the hell do you diversify going forward? Because ultimately, you I mean, of course, you can have a crystal ball and know what's going to happen, but if not, you want to have some safeguards in your portfolio.

And are the traditional safeguards still working?

Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the zero bound on Treasury yields and whether it really is a magic line in the sand. There's a lot of people who have made the argument that because the US dollar is still the world's global reserve currency, it's impossible for the US 10-year to actually trade at negative yields. I have to note that the exact same people said the same thing about the German Bund a couple of years ago and were wrong. But let's discuss, is there a magic number at zero or is it just a step along the way as we see potentially a move into negative yields for the US Treasury bonds?

Axel Merk: Well, the financial crisis and the years since have taught us to be humble, that policymakers can come up with the craziest of ideas. And so, on the 10-year, I would say absolutely not. There is no magic line. The question to me is more, is there a magic line on the short end. Can the Fed funds rate be negative?

And in, in the Eurozone, we have negative rates as, as an example, and I don't think they're terribly happy with it. I, I have a hard time imagining that we'll go negative in the US simply because of the structure of the market. Just think about money market funds. They would yield negative returns for retail investors.

In Europe, the negative rates are felt by institutions but not by retail. It's, uh, that's a big, big leap to take. And as, as you noted, the Swedes, for example, they got rid of the negative rates. They say it's stupid. I mean, they didn't use other words, but that's effectively— it doesn't work. And so the sort of chatter I hear right now, I first heard it in Europe, I heard it, uh, as we speak this morning in, in the US on, on a major news channel, is, is that, well, why not ease the capital standards of the banks?

And so get rid of some of these very tight standards in this environment to make sure that money flows to the small and medium-sized enterprises. And so in the sort of environment we're in, I would think those sort of policies would be more effective. I mean, more effective as fiscal policy. But if you want to do something on the monetary side, easing the standards for the banks in a way that they can provide more money to where it's needed is going to be more effective than cutting rates. But to the question, can the 10-year be negative?

I would think absolutely it can.

Pandemic scenarios and the policy response

Erik Townsend: So with that in mind, would you say at this point in the crisis— I think that the coronavirus situation, unfortunately, we're really only looking at the beginning of the crisis. Europe is just starting to really hit the, the inflection point in that exponential growth curve. Italy's hospital systems are completely overwhelmed already, but really it's only Italy. I think the same is coming for the rest of Europe, and then ultimately And some people have estimated that by the second week of May, every hospital bed in the United States will be overbooked. And, you know, there will be a necessity of triage to turn away some people that need hospital care. And I think that could occur globally. So with those kinds of things, I guess the first question let's start with is, do you agree that those kinds of risks are on the table?

Axel Merk: Yeah, before I answer that, let me do one more comment on the TINA. Year. Negative yield on a 10-year means that people rather give money to a government than invest in any other project. And to me, that is not necessarily a monetary phenomenon. It's a regulatory phenomenon. It's a, it's a phenomenon where people just don't see possibilities to invest in something.

And that's very, very odd to me. And I don't think a virus can even stop that. If you have a well-functioning economy, and I'd be the first to say Europe has lots of problems. In the US, that shouldn't be the case. You should be able to have a yield curve where the 10-year is not negative. So it should be possible, but obviously in times of panic and so forth, it can't be.

Now, yes, healthcare systems being overwhelmed, absolutely, that's possible. I mean, there are stories coming out of Italy that hospitals get revamped, every single patient has the same diagnosis, everything else is put on the sideline, and lots of challenges. Now, that said, the Chinese say they have gotten things under control. We obviously always have to take these things with a grain of salt. I like to look at the South Korean data. The South Korean appears to have been the most meticulous, and they have more trustworthy data. The South Koreans have drive-through tests these days.

And so there you can get a hunch of mortality rates and whatnot. But put differently, if people are still around, Some people might go bankrupt in this environment. Let's say in fracking, right? Oil prices plunge and suddenly you can't sell anything anymore. You might go out of business, but that means the debt holders will take over the, the equipment and they can operate it. And if the marginal cost is higher than the cost of running this thing, or if it's too expensive to shut it down, we'll continue to keep this running. Similarly, if you don't— if you sit at home and save the money on fuel, or you save money on fuel because you spend is you will have higher savings and you can spend that elsewhere. Eventually people will do it. The question to me is that what will happen in the interim period as we transition to this sort of environment? Will systems be overwhelmed in the interim?

Absolutely, that's very likely. And so certain sectors of economy will be affected. I actually traveled the last, um, 2 weeks a little bit. I was in Europe as well. And depending on the folks I was with, they have a very different attitude towards the coronavirus. And obviously, people are complacent about it until it hits them.

But can this induce a severe slowdown? Absolutely. There's a saying that the markets will recover when the policymakers panic, or the markets will stop panicking when the policymakers start panicking. And so, if we— and that's part of the reason, as we talked, there was a rumor we'll have a fiscal fiscal response in the US. And not too surprisingly, it's going to take a little while to get that in shape. And so if we have the sort of leadership that gets people confident that we can get the grip on that, then we can go back to life as normal, or the new normal. So we've had a dramatic correction in the market. Is it enough, or will we go down another 20, 30, 40%, right? I don't know. I don't think anybody knows. But it's the role of, of policymakers to help instill confidence and I think while we'll all be critical of the response, over time, they'll get a better handle of it, just as they did in China.

In the beginning, very critical, and now Xi just went to Wuhan to show that everything is in order. Obviously, we don't know what it is, but it's those sort of things that will help to regain the confidence of people.

Junk bonds, negative carry and the Fed put

Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on something you said a minute ago, and this relates to what some of our other guests like Jeff Snider have said on MacroVoices, which is we've gotten to the point in this zero-yield environment where US Treasury bonds are no longer a sensible investment. They're a very important balance sheet management tool for institutions, but for an individual, if it's paying zero, it doesn't really make sense to have it in your portfolio. What most of the retail universe has done is they've shifted where they used to have a 60/40 portfolio with Treasury bonds. Now they have it with high-yield bonds. And this is just my personal opinion. I think most of them don't understand that there's a reason this stuff is called junk bonds. A lot of people, myself included, have made the mistake of being early to short high yield. And of course, that's a negative carry trade, and it was painful to be early to that.

Is it finally time to short high yield, and what could go wrong here?

Axel Merk: Well, you said it, the negative carry can go wrong, right? I mean, that's the challenge with shorting in general. Most shorts are negative carry. And so you've got to get the timing right. I mean, that's, that's the gist of that. You just have a battle against time. And so you, you better be darn good or darn lucky to be able to short. That's why for most people, cash is the more prudent diversifier, unless you do some long-short strategy where you can mitigate the impact of the short by having a systematic or some other sort of strategy that allows you to, to, to kind of balance that.

We do, of course, have the bailout-in-chief, the Fed, that makes these high-yielding things appear safer. And until a few weeks ago, I was one of the few ones that was cautioning about an overheating economy. Now, you can throw all the egg in my face that you want to, but the challenge we have is, or had until recently, we had near-full employment, tight labor market, right? And we have accommodative monetary policy. Even now, you could argue we're providing a stimulus on top of that. That what happens if the bad-case scenarios don't unfold? And at some point, if we're at the tail end of this— I don't know whether it's in 3 months, more likely in 6, 9 months, or is it in a year or 18 months, or maybe the world is falling apart— but let's assume that people in the high-skill industry may not be laying off people because they might be afraid of getting them back.

And so the economy might be chunking along. And so then let's say you have an overheating And obviously, that's not the concern of the day. But how do you deal with that? Because then the Fed does have to hike rates. And what you do then— and the reason I mentioned this in context— what do you do then with the high-yielding stuff? What do you do with the companies that are at that brink?

You cannot hike rates without toppling them over. So, the Fed put, so to speak, has locked them in. And so, I actually think a hot economy is a much bigger risk these days. Space. If you have a plunging economy, we know what the Fed does. They can pretty much guarantee everything that's out there, and all the zombie enterprises can continue living happily ever after. And of course, the flip side of that is, yeah, investors are piling in on that stuff. Now, what they may have realized is, yeah, high-yield stuff is highly correlated with risk assets. Now, we've had spreads widen in the high-yield space, but because the yields on the safe stuff has come down so much, the overall borrowing cost actually hasn't gone up that much. Now, I'm not suggesting that people were able to issue a lot of debt at the peak now, as some of these tumultuous days. But, but the, the overall yields, while they, they have gone higher, we are nothing yet as far as kind of a system that might be seizing up.

And already are we talking about, oh, we need to bail out the airlines, we need to provide help here and there. So as a reminder, we have an election year, so it's in the administration's interest to keep the economy rolling. And so maybe by the time this broadcast, we know more, but odds are we'll have this, this trickle effect of, of having one help announcement after the other to try to buffer the downturn in economy. Now, I'm not suggesting that's necessarily going to be able to, to keep the markets up if the forces are bigger, but policymakers are very willing to dole out bailouts, I think. And, uh, and the only kind of pushback against that is it's an election year, and so congressional things may come late. But things like easing capital requirements of the banks, I think that, that's a— that's something that's well within the cards.

of how the executive might be reacting to the environment we are in.

Shale bailouts and perma-bailouts

Erik Townsend: Just as you were speaking, and this is Tuesday that we're recording this, I saw a headline go by that President Trump has indicated a willingness to provide a federal bailout to shale oil producers. That's an interesting one, and it certainly speaks to what you're saying, that governments are going to be very open to bailouts. As you said, it's an election year.

Axel Merk: But let's talk about this. This is completely useless. The shale producer is a marginal producer. They tend to be smaller guys. They tend to have higher costs. And so, the last time we— a few years ago at Thanksgiving, OPEC decided to pump more oil, prices plunged. And we currently are producing, I think, about 13 million barrels a day. The US is the largest oil producer in the world. Does it matter if it dips down a little bit? Saudi Arabia is jumping in. Does it really matter if some of them go out of business? No.

Those those rigs will be there. The the folks who own the debt can take it over and continue operating that stuff.

But if we do these bailouts, we are further eroding the discipline of of capitalism. I mean, who on earth should be surprised that people are storming to Bernie Sanders and say capitalism is rigged? I can't blame those guys because does it really hurt so much to to change? That. And it's— I have more sympathy for that if it's, it's something that's in the national security of the country, right? You might have to save an airline, but even an airline can go into Chapter 11. They can continue operating. You can wipe out the shareholders and save the operation of the airline. And so I think it's, it's, it's a dangerous road we've been on in the last 10 years on these, these perma-bailouts. And I don't think it's healthy for society as a whole because we're We're promoting it aside from the fact I mean we are complaining about the low growth environment we had for many years after the financial crisis. It's because we kept the zombie enterprises alive, and guess what?

They are not as productive as if we had reinvested that capital into into new new businesses.

Sanders, Biden and the election odds

Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit more about how this could progress because although most political experts have opined at least in the past they thought it would be very very difficult for Bernie Sanders to win. win the presidency because to get Americans to abandon capitalism and vote for a guy who openly embraces socialism seemed like too tough of a pill to swallow. Now, the way I look at this is, okay, hang on.

That was then. I think what's going to happen between now and election time in the United States is it's very, very likely that the United States will go through what Italy is going through right Suddenly, the guy that wants to give away healthcare to everybody for free sounds pretty darn good to most people.

You and I might agree that government-controlled healthcare would probably do less to keep Americans safe, but most people are not going to see it that way. I think that this coronavirus crisis really creates a very significant opportunity for Bernie Sanders to actually take the presidency, something I would have thought impossible. before this occurred. Do you think that that is plausible? And if so, what would it mean for capital markets?

Axel Merk: I guess I give you the same response as to the 10-year yield going negative. Is it likely? No. Is it possible? Yes. And a few years ago, we would have thought it's impossible for Donald Trump to become president. And then he won the nomination, he became president, right? And so, I would say it's possible for Bernie Sanders to become the Democratic nominee. Well, is it really impossible? No, of course not. Now, if you look at the current trend at the prediction market, they now fully bet on Biden. And to me, that's the more plausible scenario. Is it impossible? No. What we do know is that, yes, as the coronavirus has escalated, the prediction markets— and I'm talking about the betting markets— have given a decreasing chance of Trump being reelected. These odds were above 50% in the high 50s, and, and now he's pretty much tying with, with Biden as, as the next president. Now, mind you, these, these betting markets are, are most volatile, and so they can change on a dime.

But still, as you point out, if or when this crisis worsens— the health crisis I'm referring to— then it really depends on the leadership that we're seeing. And if it's perceived not to be good, that can slow down the economy, but obviously that can also reduce the election odds. And, and yes, Um, I mean, one of the things that US healthcare has some pros, but it has deficiencies, right? If you are undocumented worker, you're going to get tested. If you're— one of the things that President Trump talked about in his Monday news conference is that if you're an hourly worker, we'll think of something, right, that you can go get tested.

Because otherwise, why would you get tested? Because you're dependent on the paycheck. If you're a single parent and are juggling a gazillion priorities, are you going to get tested? Are you going to take your kid to, to, to the next, uh, whatever, dance studio event or, or this or that, right? And so in, in Europe, I just talked to a bank this morning in Europe, and, uh, I, I don't think I've had a time when this fellow that I tried to reach hasn't been sick. I've been calling him for 10 years every couple of months. Every time he's sick and he's back in 2 or 3 days. You don't have that in the US because you don't have that, that safety net. And, and so yeah, that can spread a virus and That can have an impact. And it's a— historically, you elect the populist on the right after a financial crisis, and then it's quite plausible to do a sharp turn to the left.

Right now, looks like we might, quote unquote, only get a Biden if we kick out Trump. But absolutely, the public can get disenchanted with one view, and the coronavirus might well be a catalyst for that.

Erik Townsend: What would a Biden presidency mean for markets?

Axel Merk: Well, I have a team of analysts that I've been sending out going through the policies. I mean, the good news about American— the way American politics work is usually you have gridlock. So, you can deal with whoever you have. And the challenge always comes in when you have both the House and the Senate and the White House be of the same party, because then they can really do change. And Biden, by the way, is in favor of keeping the filibuster. And so that is— that shows that the changes— the odds are the changes would be more marginal. And obviously you have a lot of rhetoric during, during the campaign, but ultimately things don't change all that much.

I happen to think that monetary policy has a bigger impact on the fabric of, of the nation than, than fiscal policy does. And, and in big chunk, that is because it is not so easy to change things. And obviously what that means in practice, you do a lot of things on the executive side. And the things that you can do on the executive side, Trump has figured out, is immigration and trade. And it's in the news. The more scandalous something appears, the bigger the headline, and the happier he is, so to speak. But at the same time, now we have an election year, so it's in his interest to calm things down. And obviously, with the virus in there, it's in his interest to ease policy where he can. And he obviously has a big impact on the regulation. And I mentioned one example on the banking But there's a lot of regulations that can be eased to provide a stimulus in case Congress doesn't come along.

And so, to answer your question, it really depends on whether the House and the Senate would all be on the same party. Right now, the odds of that happening have increased, but they're still in the 20% range in the betting markets.

Lagarde, Powell and policy accommodation

Erik Townsend: I think one thing we could agree on is regardless of who's president, there's very likely to be considerable more policy of accommodation, monetary and possibly also fiscal. So let's talk about another area where you're regarded as an expert, which is precious metals. What do you see on the horizon for gold with everything that's going on?

Axel Merk: Oh, first, I disagree with you on the first one. So let me talk about that first.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Axel Merk: The policy accommodation. We have in Europe a new ECB chair as of last fall, Madame Lagarde. And since day one, she's been talking about climate change. Change. And when I think of monetary policy and climate change, the one connection I would make is, well, you've got to figure out that if you had a big natural catastrophe, that, that financial institutions don't topple over because of whatever payout they have to do or because business goes out of business. That is not how Lagarde thinks about it. She thinks about coercing banks to favor green investment over other investments. There's obviously a huge ESG wave around the world. And she seems to be very open to the stuff that you call, I think, modern monetary theory, where you hook up with fiscal policymakers to print money to support jobs.

So there is more room for monetary accommodation. If you look at Powell in the US, he obviously doesn't go as far or extreme as I would say as Lagarde does, but he is turning on a dime when there's a tweet on trade, when the market panics And so if we have a very bad-case scenario on this virus, I wouldn't rule out that he is very open to cooperating with fiscal authorities to make money available. And so never say never. We've broken many taboos in the financial crisis, and when push comes to shove, monetary policy is is going to be there to support what the fiscal authorities want.

Gold, real interest rates and liquidation risk

Axel Merk: So that's that's just on that point.

Now on the precious metal side, obviously it's been an interesting roller coaster. The The price of gold historically isn't really correlated to anything. That makes it so beautiful. The one thing it's more correlated than many other things is real interest rates. When you hold cash and get compensated for holding cash, then obviously why should you hold this brick that doesn't pay any dividend?

But if you look at the correlation to real yields, look at the 10-year in comparison, the price of gold has been reasonably highly correlated. And as real yields have come down, the price of gold has come up. And so there, it's, uh, I mean, you tell me, if real interest rates are going to be high, then you may not want to hold gold. If you think that real interest rates are going to go low, below, then I think gold is very sensible.

The other thing, of course, is that in every bear market since the early '70s, with the big exception of the early '80s, the price of gold has done very well. Well during a bear market in risk assets. And part of that is the lack of cash flow. When volatility goes up, the lack of cash flow provides less discounting to a cash flow that doesn't exist in gold. So that does well. But obviously, because real interest rates tend to go down as interest rates go down, and in the early '80s real interest rates by Volcker were pushed very high. So that is, that is why gold historically has been a good diversifier, and that's why we also A lot of people buy gold as a diversifier.

Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on that point where you described gold as being a good diversifier against a move down in risk assets. I certainly agree with you, couldn't agree more, in fact. In the long run, I think that this pressure downward on risk assets has to be positive for gold, and I'm very bullish in the long term. But what we saw right around the 24th of February really reminded me of 2008, When in 2008, with the stock market crashing, even though it had to be bullish in the long term for gold, there were people that just had to sell everything to meet their margin calls. Are we going to see that again if this market really crashes? It seems like maybe what we saw in the last 2 or 3 weeks might be a precursor to a repeat of 2008 where, you know, correlations go to 1 regardless of the fundamentals.

Axel Merk: Well, in the long run, the correlation of the price of gold versus the S&P 500 is 0. It's not -1. And so that means it doesn't always work when things go down, right? And remember, price of gold has also gone up when the S&P has gone up. And so I think the market's goal is to frustrate investors, and it's very good at that. And so I would be reluctant to say something is necessarily going to happen one way or the other.

One of the things leading into this was that speculators were very long gold. And when you're long gold as a speculator, when you use derivatives to buy something thing. You tend to be leveraged. You have a risk-off environment, you need to liquidate. And so you need to take down your positions, you need to flush those out. So it is not surprising when people are piling in on a trade that when things go rough, well, they get out of that trade, right? I mean, it might be a good idea, but when you go into something with leverage, you may need to delever when volatility goes up. And, and that was exactly what we saw. And so these sort of things, when, when you know 100% that this is the thing you need to do to diversify, and everybody else does it, well, then it doesn't work the way you thought it would. And so it's a— that sort of thing can happen. And then of course the question is, what will policymakers do and so forth?

But I mentioned earlier the scenario of a hot economy. Well, if we were to have a hot economy, odds are that the Fed would hike rates. But the Fed has promised not to hike rates. Would they do it? Would they not do it? And so what you get in the end is a volatile environment. The, the one other thing to add about gold Partially because there aren't so many fundamentals on gold, it attracts a lot of technical traders. And those guys were gone during the bear years in gold to a significant extent because gold didn't do anything. Now that gold is more volatile again, you have all these technical traders back in the game, and you have more coming in every day.

And, and so we talk about it more in the news, but that will also exacerbate some of those moves. And you can call it noise.

All the more important is that you have a strategy, right? If you have a strategy to outwit the day trader, good for you. If you're a long-term investor, well, good for you, right? It's like the sort of trends— if you have it as a long-term diversification, if you have it, if you have it because you think that real interest rates have a difficult time moving higher, I think investors may want to consider it as a diversifier in their portfolio.

Why gold miners lag the metal

Axel Merk: But if you're a short-term trader, yeah, you better have a good

Erik Townsend: Gold itself has, on the net, done pretty well through this coronavirus crisis. It did have that, that big dip down as we saw equity markets sell off sharply, but it came back. On the other hand, gold mining shares, they went down, but they didn't come back, or haven't so far. What's going on there, and what's your outlook?

Axel Merk: Well, over a 12-month period, gold mining shares have gone up quite substantially, and in some ways you You have similar things here. Well, first of all, compared to the last bull market—I call it bull market—we have in gold mining. Several things have changed. One is that at this stage, companies are still fairly prudent. They don't try to increase ounces at any cost. You have energy cost—that's about a good 20% of the cost of mining—has come down. So that should reach for margin expansion. Expansion. Beyond that, the big companies have underinvested for, for many years, so they may need to acquire companies downstream. Now, what hasn't changed is that especially downstream, the smaller companies, they're always in notorious need of capital because they always fund the next, the next exploration and so forth. And so obviously, when capital markets are at risk of drying up, people are saying, oh my God, there's not going to be money around for us, right? And, and so that, that provides a challenge to the industry And because

there's this periodic financing requirement with many of these mining companies in periods of risk-off, it can well be that they get whacked just like everybody else.

And so historically, and also in a liquidation, a broader liquidation, those things get sold as much as anybody. And the smaller companies are more volatile. It is a notoriously volatile space. And so people shouldn't expect that thing to explode to the upside every day. It's been a very good year and we have come back somewhat from that.

I would think that as we get used to this environment, there are amazing opportunities in there. I mean, these smaller plays in the mining sector, they're obviously highly speculative. They're like options, right? Whether you strike gold, literally speaking. And so, the market will reward them over time, but make no mistake about it, right? This is a volatile space, and people better be comfortable with the risks that come with it.

The Fed: emergency cuts and what is priced in

Erik Townsend: Axel, let's talk about what's coming next from the Federal Reserve. They've obviously already had an emergency 50 basis point cut that occurred between regularly scheduled meetings. Markets are already pricing in, at least according to some estimates I've seen, as much as 75 basis points of additional cuts coming at their next meeting. That would be kind of unprecedented to first have a 50-point emergency cut and then, you know, normally 75 is bigger than you would ever get in a single meeting. Is that realistic? And what should we expect?

Axel Merk: Well, Powell has been very willing to cut, obviously. I mean, the argument for cutting is, hey, we don't have inflation. And why not? We don't want the yield curve to invert as we speak. We're currently under 3-month, 10-year, 30 basis points, so we're not at the risk of inverting right now. But why not? Why not cut? The argument against it is that, hey, you can't cure a virus with a rate cut.

We have as our senior economic advisor Bill Poole. He until 2008 was the president of the St. Louis Fed, and he recently said that— and he was considered a hawk, so he certainly was not in the cutting camp— but he said, well, the Fed should do it. That doesn't mean they will do it. But what he said the Fed should do is, yes, they should go down with the market and cut, cut deeply, but indicate that they're cutting because they don't want to drain liquidity from the market, and that they will be just as willing to normalize again should these markets come back. And so cutting, not so much saying, hey, we're gonna now go to 0% and there and, and stay there, but saying we do it so that we are not a kind of an obstacle to liquidity. And that kind of makes sense.

As you point out, 75 basis points seems to be priced in. I don't know whether they'll do 50 or 75. If you look at historically, most of the time when you've had an intermeeting rate cut, then you had a follow-up rate cut of— you had an intermeeting rate cut of 50 basis points, and then at the, at the actual meeting, you had another 50 basis point rate cut.

Obviously, when we had the intervening cut, the market tanked anyway. And that's obviously the risk.

Now, obviously, if you're in Powell's shoes, there's no way to win this. If he had done nothing, then he may be accused of inaction. Had he gone 25 basis points, it wouldn't have been enough. At 50 basis points, it's wasted ammunition. So, the Fed is not there to get praise from anybody. Mostly, the Fed's role should be to be out of the way. And if they do what Bill Poole says, then then that's as good as anything, right? If I look in what's priced in, the market is firmly betting on on deep deep cuts.

Questions of course: Hey, what happens next and so forth? I would continue to argue that you can't cure disease with this. But I mean, with any of these things and anything we discuss, it doesn't really matter what you or I think. It matters what the policymakers will do. And Powell has shown that he. obliged to what the market demands. That's, that's been his history. He hasn't been around that long, but that's, that's his history. And that's, that's what I'm working with at this stage.

What Merk Investments does

Erik Townsend: Well, Axel, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Before I let you go, please tell our listeners a little bit more about what you do at Merk Investments. I think you guys run a couple of ETFs and have some other products. For our listeners who are not already familiar with Merk Investments, give us the rundown.

Axel Merk: Sure. Well, come to merkinvestments.com and browse around. We do all kinds of little things. One of the things, if you want to get my last live opinions. I am active on social media, @AxelMerk on Twitter, where you get that live interpretation on the news. But yes, we run some investment products on the— both on the precious metal side, the physical one, and the mining side. We have a currency fund as well. We do a lot of macro work, deep dives into central banks.

We publish research reports. Actually, we have a research service as well where we publish consistent chart books. We're actually relaunching a Well, not relaunching, we're launching a new website pretty soon in that where it's going to be a little spiffier than the little arcane format we've been publishing in.

And then we have a systematic FX program as well where we— it's one of the things that we used to have a mutual fund on it, but it wasn't popular. I happen to think it was the best thing since sliced bread. We don't deploy it for the retail space these days. But one of the things you can do in the long-short currency space is you can generate uncorrelated returns with a very well-defined risk profile. Which is ultimately something I think investors would be longing for if this market is not going to be an eternal bull market.

And so we do all kinds of little things. We have a lot of technical capabilities. But for most folks, it might be the most entertaining to follow me on social media. If you want to dive deeper, from merkinvestments.com, you can, you can get links to the various little things that we do.

Erik Townsend: Axel, we look forward to getting you back on the program in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: are Sanders' chances still alive?

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Axel back on the show. And, you know, and what I really loved was when you guys started talking high yield and corporate bonds, because I really wanted to spend some time in this postgame talking about it. But was there anything else that stood out for you in that interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I want to update some of my own comments on this one because we did tape this interview earlier in the week and it's a little bit stale because what's happened since we taped this is Bernie Sanders' positioning in the polls has fallen to the point where actually at this point Hillary Clinton is ahead of him, and I'm not sure that she's technically even running. So I think a lot of people are completely, totally writing Bernie off at this point. He did say he wants to stay in the debate and debate Biden, Biden. A lot of people are kind of assuming he's dead man walking, zombie Bernie, can't possibly have a chance.

I still think he has a chance, and the reason is he has made so much of his campaign in the past about free healthcare. What I think is about to happen, Patrick, and I'll explain this in more detail in tomorrow's podcast, is a healthcare emergency that will start over the next month or two. By the middle of May, we're going to have every single hospital in the United States overwhelmed to the point that they have to triage and turn some people away and just say, The hospital's full. We cannot help you. We can't give you any medical care. People, even if you just had a car accident, whatever, go home and try to take care of yourself. The hospital cannot help you because we're overwhelmed with coronavirus patients. When you get to that kind of a change in what's going on in the country, I think there's a chance for a guy like Bernie Sanders who wants to give away free healthcare to everybody to make a comeback.

So I wouldn't rule him out quite yet, even though Although all other indications seem to suggest he's totally out of the picture. But speaking of the picture, we've got another Big Picture Trading chartbook.

Chartbook: S&P technical targets and March 20 options expiration

Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says Big Picture Trading chartbook. If you don't have the Research Roundup email, it means you're not registered yet. Just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, let's dive into the markets on page 2. Chart 2, you've got— looks like the S&P. Tell us what's going on here.

Patrick Ceresna: Chart 2 and 3 are just talking points. Like, Chart 2 is a snapshot of what we showed last week, which was the analog of if this was to play out similar to 2000 and 2008, what we should expect going into April. What's amazing is that on Chart 3 is that we're already approaching that 12 to 16% decline that would have typically taken Anywhere from 2, 3 weeks to even 6 weeks to fully play out. We've gotten there in 2, 3 days, right? Like the speed and momentum from which this market drop is happening is pretty amazing. And while I'm just showing the technical targets that are just based on a methodology, what is gonna be the most interesting thing to watch is whether the technical levels even hold. I mean, you have that opinion. I'm going to stand on the side that the bounce will come off the technical levels. And I think that once we hit these kind of levels around 2,600, and maybe there's one measured move that even goes down to 2,500, I mean, odds are we're heading down there.

But I think that a short-term reaction going into the March 20th expiration has a very good chance.

Erik Townsend: Okay, I'll buy that. One thing I certainly have to disqualify myself on is I thought that the stock market was going to show this coronavirus thing sooner and bigger than it has. And what we've seen is the stock market seems to just wanna I'm not going to look for any reason to interpret the news to mean that there's some kind of accommodation coming that's going to help support new highs. Clearly, if you wanted to play the bearishness that I feel because of the coronavirus situation, the stock market has not been the place where it's played out most efficiently. You did much better either shorting crude or long bonds. So we'll see what happens. I think the bet was that— I think that you did anticipate getting to $2,600 at some point. But you thought not by the end of March. I think by the end of March, we're going to be there.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, what I also wanted to just reference was the fact that there is a pretty interesting options delta influence coming into the March 20th expiration, which Charlie McElligott was pointing out, was that there was a very, very large amount of options that were up in the higher strikes that all have the March 20th expiration. That have built massive delta to the tune of like $500 billion.

Thing is, to roll those in this high vol condition is very difficult, and even then rolling them to at-the-money is incredibly expensive. And so if there is, as we approach the March 20th date, if there's a substantial amount of profit taking on these options, then that actually creates a tailwind from dealer buying as they unwind a lot of their futures hedges that are short. And so maybe that becomes a liquidity catalyst for a face-ripping rally into that expiration. I'm more of an observer. We'll see whether or not that actually plays out.

High-yield spreads and junk bond ETFs

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I have been dying to talk to you about high-yield spreads. As I think a lot of our listeners know, I am probably guilty of having been early to shorting junk credit way too many times. I think I actually We discussed the junk bond trade with Jim Rogers on episode number 1 of MacroVoices 4 years ago, 4 and a half years ago. And Jim and I weren't sure if it was right now or next week that we should start shorting junk. Is it finally time?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, really what I wanted to talk about was just how bad of a blowout this is, but in much bigger picture, how much worse it can still get. And so the credit spreads, just for clarification to our listeners, is the spread of what you earn on interest rates on high yield versus that of Treasury. And so right now we're trading at 638 basis points, but we were consolidating, you know, under 400 at one point. And so a pretty significant blowout.

I mean, clearly at least a 50-plus percent increase in those credit spreads.

But what I have here is a chart going back 20 years, and it shows not only the peak of the recession of 2000 to 2003, the peak of 2008, 2009, but also the 2011 and 2016 blowouts in credit spreads. And what's amazing is that each one of those blowouts all blew out anywhere from 900 to 1,100 basis points. And then in the crisis of 2008, it went to over 2,000 basis points. So there is room for even another 50% to even a, you know, 100% doubling of the credit spread if the risk of defaults and credit spreads— well, risk of default grows inside there, that has to start being baked into the case.

Erik Townsend: Right. Okay, Patrick, so this page 4 is showing us credit spreads, which is the differential in yield between junk bonds and Treasury bonds. Moving on to page 5, we're looking directly at junk bond yields as opposed to the differential between junk bond yields and Treasury yields. Why this slide? What is this picture telling us? And boy, that's a big move, isn't it?

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, no, I mean, we, we saw a jump from 5% to 7%, and really what I wanted to do is just show how that translated into the drop in many of those junk bond yield ETFs on page 6. And so what we had was this big jump in yields on those high-yield bonds that are rated, uh, BB or worse. And what's amazing is when we look at a, a longer-term chart going back, you know, 5+ years, you can see that, uh, junk bonds had a devastating drop during the oil crisis, started peaking out in 2014, and it obviously bottomed at that 2016 level where, where we, we saw, you know, a 30% wipeout in bond bonds.

But what's amazing is that this drop that just happened in the last week and change has basically brought us back down to the price levels we've only seen back in 2016 and during the 2018 little dive that we had during the Christmas Massacre. And what's interesting here is if this is just the beginning, how low does this go, right? Like, we haven't started seeing any real blowout of spreads to the levels we've seen at their final culmination points. And so really, I mean, could see this thing down to $90 or lower when, when this is all said and done? It's going to be really interesting to watch, right?

BBB downgrade risk and investment-grade credit (LQD)

Erik Townsend: Definitely. It's going to be really interesting to watch. But what I think might be even more interesting, Patrick, on page 6 here, we're looking at actual junk-rated credit, the bonds that have already been given a junk rating by the rating bureaus. But moving on to page 7, you're showing BBB-rated credit. That's the lowest investment bond trading that there is. And of course, the speculation, which we've discussed in past episodes of MacroVoices, is if there's a credit dislocation, these BBBs could get downgraded from BBB to junk. Once they're junk, there's a reflexivity there. All the institutional holders are forced to sell them whether they want to or not, and it creates a bloodbath. Is that something we should be thinking about, this event maybe being the trigger for?

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. Well, I read a headline and I didn't fact-check it, but it's something on the tune of like $100 to $150 billion of BBB energy bonds are at risk of a downgrade here because of this massive drop in oil. And that certainly has brought a lot of fear now into the investment-grade space. This was a really interesting spot because one of the, referring back to the Chris Cole interview, he's talking about this idea of where you could buy buy tail risk that has correlation and is not priced in an expensive way.

And what I found fascinating was that in investment-grade bonds, everyone was treating them and they continued to, at least last week, trade like they were paired and sistered with Treasury bonds. And to me, they weren't accounting for any of the credit risks that really they were vulnerable to. And so that was a great place where we put on at Big Picture Trading some ratio showed put spreads, buying some nice tail risk insurance on the downside. And well, again, that was— it's just started working really well. I mean, we saw going— just jumping to chart 9, you can see that that's just the LQD, which is the investment-grade corporate bond ETF. And you can see up until last week, it was just correlated to Treasury bonds. And as Treasury bond yields were declining and you your bonds like the TLT and IEF and everything ripping higher, you basically had LQD jumping on to the coattails and going for a ride like it was all investment grade and there was no problems.

And suddenly this week, investment grade started to care. That oil drop basically broke its spine. And it's going to be fascinating to watch how bad these can break in this environment, right? And especially if Treasury bonds have hit a short peak as the, maybe the bond yields at least are a little bit overdone on the short term. The question is, will we see this move accelerate considerably in the investment-grade space, right?

Crude oil: Erik's view that the Saudi crash was engineered

Erik Townsend: And I think time will tell because the big question, just hearing you talk about this, to my mind, is one that's a little bit hard to know, which is some people think that what's going on between Saudi Arabia and Russia right now is the so-called escalate to negotiate.

You know, they're making all of these really, really bold threats, and a lot of people are saying they couldn't possibly actually mean this stuff. Surely they're gonna come to the table and make a deal, and there's gonna be a production cut, and everything's gonna be all better any day now.

If that doesn't happen, Patrick, we could easily see oil prices in the teens, and the credit in the US shale drillers is going to be completely no-bid at that point. And I think anything could happen.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: happen in terms of downgrades and so forth. But on that note, let's go ahead and move on to page 10, my favorite subject, crude oil. What do you got going on here?

Patrick Ceresna: I just really wanted to share a chart of just how crazy of a drop we just witnessed. Like, do you remember seeing— like, I know that 2016 was ugly, but that was a systematic sell-off where oil was just down every day. But for us to move from $46 down to $27 in literally a 2-day window is just unbelievable. Have you ever seen something like this?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think this was engineered. First of all, you said 2016, that's where the bottom happened. That selling started in 2014. But I think this one was engineered, Patrick, because the first thing that you had on Friday, and it was entirely coronavirus-driven, was a breakdown and a close on a weekly basis below $42.36, which was the previous low that it held for almost 4 years, I believe. So we already had a setup where I thought that the coronavirus crisis was going to take us back to $26 oil. $26.05 was the intraday low back in early 2016.

I thought it would take a couple of weeks to get there, and we'd have to wait for more bad news to come out on the Coronavirus front.

I think that Mohammed bin Salman understood all of that. So when Russia walked away from the negotiating table, I think bin Salman looked at this situation and said, "I know we're going lower, and I can't stop it from going lower. And I look like the dummy right now because I'm the one who's pushing for a production cut. And if we can't come to a production cut, prices are going to slide back down to 26 bucks, and I look like I'm losing."

Makes much more sense for me to save face and not look like I'm losing control and make this my idea. So he announces on Saturday— that's after we saw that signal on Friday's close, which was a strong technical signal that we were probably headed back to $26 no matter what. I think he said, if we're going back to $26, I'm gonna make this look like I did it intentionally. And he says, we're gonna ramp up production dramatically. Russia, we're not gonna take any more. of this. You either play ball with us or we're going to compete head-to-head and allow prices to collapse, and we'll just try as best as we can to make it up on competing with you for market share.

He knew he was going to crash prices, but at least it looks like he's in control of the market as opposed to it looking like he's losing control of the market, which is how it would have appeared otherwise. So instead of getting to $27 over over the next month. We got to $27 almost at the open. I think there was actually 2 halts before trading could even begin, and then we very quickly traded down to $27.

We're bouncing now. Now, if Russia were to come back to the table and start to talk about a cut, then they could maybe salvage this, and it would look like bin Salman was in control of everything and on top of everything all the while, and then they could engineer a rally.

I don't think it would get very far. They might close that gap, but it would roll over shortly thereafter, and we'd still get to $26 on coronavirus-related news taking the market lower. So I think that we got here sooner than we otherwise would have, but we were coming here anyway.

The thing is, Patrick, if Russia stands firm and doesn't come back and agree to a cut, and Saudi Arabia stands firm, and they're not just bluffing, but this is really what they want to do, real, and we get the outlook that I see coming for coronavirus, these things all compounding together could easily take us to $15 oil before this is over.

Emerging markets, Euro Stoxx 50 and S&P immunity

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, what I wanted to just end the chart book with is I wanted to do just a quick shout-out to the rest of the world. And so I just grabbed 2 charts. One, just the emerging markets ETF on a weekly chart that kind of encompasses a good chunk of the world outside of obviously some of these core developed nations. And what was really interesting to me on this is that we have now broken below the September-December 2018 lows. And it really looks at this stage that with a failed rally throughout a good chunk of 2019, well, at least a rally that failed to go anywhere near its 2018 highs, this usually from a— as a technician is quite bearish. And it really does open the window for emerging markets to underperform and continue Considering what's happened in much of the commodity space and the global growth slowing, you have to think that the emerging markets remain quite vulnerable going here in the months ahead.

And the other chart I wanted to look at was that Euro Stoxx 50 index. And what I found fascinating was just the magnitude of the drop in such short order. I mean, the Euro Stoxx was making fresh new 52-week highs, exceeding the 2018 and '17 highs on the Euro Stoxx, which all hover around 3,600 when it punched there at the start of the year. And not only did we in just several weeks now wipe out all of the progress, but we're almost back to 2016 lows in just like 3 weeks. And so while we think we've had a bad in North American markets, this Euro Stoxx had just a devastating drop that basically wiped out several years of performance in one like this. It's just amazing to see.

Erik Townsend: Well, think about what's going on though with the coronavirus story, Patrick. It's happening for real right now in Europe. Now, it's coming to the United States in just as big of a way as it's happening in Europe. It'll be just as big in the US in the next 2 or 3 weeks as it is in Europe now. But everybody seems to be in denial about that. So the question in my mind is, is this Euro Stoxx chart an indication of what the S&P is going to do Or does the S&P have a certain degree of sovereign bank immunity, if you will, in the sense that it's very likely that a big drop of this magnitude in the S&P would be met with intervention from the Fed? So that's going to be, I think, really interesting to watch.

Also, listeners, if you don't already know, you can get a free membership.

Outro: sponsor tag, Research Roundup and sign-off

Erik Townsend: You can watch Patrick every single day with his play-by-play on the markets by going to bigpicturetrading.com and signing up. Signing up for a free trial. This episode was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.

For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they missed in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Axel, as well as the links to that chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an article discussing what Ray Dalio thinks needs to be done to fight the coronavirus, as well as an article discussing the liquidity problem of passive investing. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. For those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@researchroundup.com. Roundup at MacroVoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: Thank you. That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top