Pippa Malmgren — former US presidential advisor and bestselling author (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 240 was recorded on October 8th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com. Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors. With the presidential election now less than a month away, it's time to bring back former US presidential advisor and bestselling author, Dr. Pippa Malmgren, as this week's feature interview guest. Pippa and I will discuss everything from the outlook for markets and various election scenarios, to the risk of an increase in civil unrest after the election, to Pippa's prediction that President Trump will aspire to create his own television news empire after leaving the White House, regardless of whether that happens in 2021 or after 4 more years as president. Patrick Ceresna is off this week, so Kevin Muir, author of the popular Macro Tourist blog, joins me as this week's co-host.
So be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, when Kevin and I will discuss the US dollar, inflation, and why Kevin thinks a curve steepener trade is the best way to play these macro trends.
Kevin Muir: And I'm Kevin Muir filling in for Patrick Ceresna. Erik, we certainly got a little excitement with Trump's Tuesday afternoon tweet that he was instructing his representatives to stop negotiating on the fiscal deal due to the fact that he thought Pelosi was acting in not good faith, which caused the stock market to sell off. But now we're right back to the highs of the week. What do you make of it?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think that's a microcosm of a bigger picture. You're talking about just today's action, but look back at the last couple of weeks. The President of the United States, the most powerful man in the world, gets a disease which in his age demographic has a fairly high fatality rate, and the stock market sells off for less than 3 market days before hitting a very buyable dip moment. And as you say, even in the face of a lot of news and, you know, news flow action today, Today, which should have been negative. It seems like nothing sticks to this market. It all bounces back off. So it's clear to me that market sentiment is, you know, the Fed's got our back no matter what, nothing can go wrong. And of course, those assumptions tend to last until something does go wrong.
The election is still the dominant factor. So was this little blip we had over the COVID scare when the president got the coronavirus disease just a little pause in the market and we're moving higher after a contested election is sorted out? You know, I kind of think about Jeff Snider's comment about when I said he was bullish the dollar and he says, no, don't call me bullish. I think it's going up, but not for good reasons. I feel like this market just really wants to move higher. And I think once the election is resolved clearly, so we know who's president, it probably is moving higher. Does that mean I'm bullish, like I believe in the economy and the fundamentals? No, but it seems like the market just wants to go higher and is looking for an excuse, even if I don't think that that makes sense.
The thing The thing is, we don't know that we're going to get a clear election outcome. So, I'm really looking forward to asking Pippa Malmgren in this week's feature interview what it's going to mean if we don't know at first who the new President of the United States really is.
Kevin Muir: Erik, during the risk-off move that Tuesday afternoon, we saw the US dollar get a little bit of a bid, but it seems to have stalled. What's your outlook there?
Erik Townsend: Well, what I can say confidently in my confident announcer voice, Kevin, is that the single most important issue in macroeconomics is the US dollar. And those who have it figured out have a serious edge over the lesser, intellectually weaker market participants who don't have it figured out. The next thing I can say is, uh, I'm one of those guys who doesn't have it figured out yet. I don't think there's a clear technical signal here yet. You have to rely on fundamentals, and those fundamentals are a really complex picture. There's a lot of reasons you should expect flight-to-safety trades to take the dollar much higher here. Frankly, you know, when you got the President of the United States
Kevin Muir: Right.
Erik Townsend: And then he gets infected with a disease which is often deadly in people in his age demographic, although he— if he's faking the recovery, he's certainly doing a very good job of faking the recovery. It seems like he's off the hook already, and we don't know where this election is headed.
So it's a really complex picture. I don't know what the answer is. Jury's still out in my mind. As far as I'm concerned, you'd need a daily close above 95 or below 92 to get a really solid technical indication as to to where the market's headed, and we don't have that yet. Let's revisit this though in more detail, Kevin, because I know you've been writing about this in the Macro Tourist blog, and I want to go into more detail than we have time for in the market wrap after the feature interview with Pippa Malmgren.
Kevin Muir: Sounds great, Erik. I'm looking forward to that. In the meantime, why don't we move on to what I always tune into MacroVoices with the most excitement each week, which is your views on crude oil. Where do you see this market headed?
Erik Townsend: Not only are we rallying on the front month today— now the front month flat price is not quite back to that $41.72 level, which was the previous cycle high set back in the middle of September. But here's what I think is actually more important. The back of the curve time spreads are already breaking out to new levels, considerably higher than their previous highs. And also outside, they've, they've broken through trend lines that existed on the charts during the previous cycle. So we're seeing the breakout occur not first on the flat price but on the back of curve time spreads Longtime listeners know that I have been long the Z1-Z2 spread— that's long the December of 2021, short the December of 2022 crude oil futures contract— in size because I think that's the best way to play an expectation of a return to backwardation in 2021.
I've been talking about I've been talking about that on MacroVoices for 6 months. I see now that some of the biggest names in the crude oil financial media are starting to tweet about that Z1-Z2 spread and what's going on there.
So we're seeing a breakout which hasn't been confirmed yet in the flat price, but it's definitely there in the back of the curve, and I tend to put more credence in that.
Now, there is a caveat, which is, why is crude oil in general breaking out? Well, we've got a number of factors, some of which might be temporary. One of them is, of course, the storm in the Gulf of Mexico, a hurricane about to hit the Gulf Coast. And of course, that means they have to shut in production in the Gulf. That tends to drive the price up, but only in the short term. We've also got OPEC jawboning the market. Today they said the worst is over for the oil market and OPEC sees higher prices ahead. Well, why are they saying that on this particular day? Pardon my cynicism, Kevin, but I think the reason is because these OPEC guys are pretty darn smart and they know that we're approaching a very key technical level at $41.72. And if they can jawbone the market to get a daily close above that price, it's probably going to have legs and will move much higher.
So OPEC, I think, is very clearly trying to manipulate this market higher. And frankly, you know, that doesn't mean it's not going to last. They're often successful. When they do that. So we do need, because these things are to some extent based on circumstance and propaganda, I think we need a few days of this trend to continue before it's really confirmed. But it looks to me like we could be on the cusp of an upside breakout. And of course, a breakout above the previous high on the flat price. The previous high again was $41.72 on the front month WTI contract. We need to see a higher price as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon, just after the
Kevin Muir: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And if we look at the NYMEX close, we're looking at $41.18. So we're still half a dollar below the level that we need to be in order to really cement this. But it looks to me like something is afoot toward a move higher.
Moving on to inventory this week, crude oil building, a surprise build of half a million barrels nationally. But that is also offset by a drawdown of 1.1 million barrels in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. So the net is still a drawdown of 0.9 million barrels. 1.6 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, building 470,000 barrels. The drawdowns were on finished products. Gasoline drawing down 1.4 million barrels. Distillates drawing down 962,000 barrels. US production ticking up substantially, 300,000 barrels this week to 11 million barrels. So we're not seeing the decline in US production that Art Berman has spoken about. But as we had Art back on the program last week, he said, hey, That might not come until the end of Q4. Just 'cause he said Q4 doesn't mean now we're in Q4, it's gonna happen. Could be Christmas before that happens. That's gonna be the thing to watch. And I think that when we see confirmation in terms of the actual EIA report, let's say not because of a tropical storm shutting in production, but just because of natural forces in the market, when we see that US production number drop below 10 and particularly below 9.5 million barrels, I think that's where you're really going to see some acceleration of price to the upside and a return to backwardation in the term structure of the crude oil market.
And again, that Z1-Z2 spread is my favorite way to play that.
Kevin Muir: That's some great stuff, Erik. For the technical people, they'll be watching those levels. And for the fundamentally inclined, you've given them some great things to watch for. Let's move on to gold. It doesn't seem to be getting anywhere near the traction that many of the gold bulls were hoping. What do you think's going on there?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm a gold bull and I'm hoping for downside so I can buy some more at a cheaper price. You know, we do have some reasons to expect a further consolidation and maybe a further correction to the downside. Now, we're still holding above the 100-day moving average. Remember what I said last week was, okay, the gold price was selling off pretty sharply, hit the 100-day moving average and bounced. And I said, okay, is it just a bounce, dead cat bounce, or is that really a reversal of trend? So far, it's looking more like it was
Kevin Muir: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: I don't know if this was just a bounce because it came off the 100-day, went up and perfectly tested twice, actually, 2 daily candles perfectly testing the 21-day moving average. But we're still holding above the 100-day, right about on the 13-day moving average as we record on Thursday afternoon at $1,897, just below $1,900.
So there's definitely, I think, a case to be made that maybe the 100-day moving average is going to hold it. I hope it doesn't. Because if it breaks, there's more support right around $1,800. But then it's not till you get about $1,758 is the 200-day moving average. And I think we have a real chance of getting there, particularly if there was a clean sweep in the election. So a lot of people are fearing that there's gonna be a contested election. Nobody's sure who's president. The Supreme Court gets involved. If those things don't happen, I think gold is gonna sell off and it's gonna create a buying opportunity. And I think under those circumstances, we would Very likely get to $1,758, or at least to the 200-day moving average, which by then will probably be above $1,758.
The problem is, I don't think it's terribly likely that we're not going to have a contested election. I think we will have a contested election, and that might be the impetus for gold to move higher. If so, the number to watch on the upside is around $1,937. A close above that level would represent an upside breakout in the descending triangle pattern that's been in play really since the beginning of August, and that would suggest that a bullish breakout is occurring.
Kevin Muir: And finally, Erik, 10-year Treasury yields. They've been sleepy forever, but there seemed to be some excitement this week. Do you think this is the start of a bigger move lower?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I don't know if it's a big move lower. I don't really have a short-term opinion. As we look out longer term, I'm coming more and more to the conclusion that inflation is coming. I just don't know how soon. And I want to revisit this topic in the postgame segment after the feature interview because I know you've been writing about it. It seems clear to me that the bond bull market ends and bond yields go up once it's confirmed that inflation is not just a twinkle in a few people's eyes, but it really is happening and nobody questions whether it's happening. We're not quite there yet. So is it just a few months off or is it a few years off? I'm leaning more and more toward a few months as opposed to a few years. I think maybe that low yield, whatever it was on an intraday basis on the 10-year, 35 basis points or something, maybe that That really was the end of the 38-year bond bull market.
Let's come back to that in the postgame segment.
Kevin Muir: This week's featured interview guest is former US presidential advisor, Dr. Pippa Malmgren. Erik, why did we invite Pippa back to the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, it's less than a month until the election. Pippa used to actually work in the White House advising the US president. You know, this is the time to get Pippa on the show to get her perspective, not only on what's going on, but what this will mean And I think you'll be surprised at some of the market prognostications that she has. They're not consensus views. So I'm really looking forward to this interview. Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure.
Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: Erik's interview with Pippa Malmgren is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com. And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is former US presidential advisor and bestselling author, Dr. Pippa Malmgren. Pippa, holy cow, where to start with this interview? I don't think there's ever been a better month for a Dr. Pippa Malmgren interview. You used You used to work in the White House advising the President of the United States. You worked as a part of a team which, among other things, advised the US President on how to appear presidential in the public eye.
Why don't we start with the recent debate? How would you say that both candidates did in terms of upholding that presidential image?
Pippa Malmgren: Well, I thought it was just fascinating that the single most Googled phrase during and right after the debate was how to move to Canada, which kind of tells you everything. It's really interesting watching this because in a way, the public wanted reality TV to come into politics and now it really has.
And it's just emotional with no substance. It's just interruption with no points being made. It's kind of, you know, everybody's in search of an argument. And while sort of fascinating at one level, it's not fascinating enough. And it was really interesting to see how few people watched it and how many people tuned out once they had started.
So neither one of these men came off being inspirational or inspirational leaders in any way.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the Supreme Court and what's going on there. I guess there's a pretty big divide between— some people are saying that the president's job is to immediately propose a replacement for a deceased justice. Others are arguing that, well, no, it's really the end of his term. We should wait and see who the next president is and let them decide who's on the Supreme Court. What is the real legal precedent? Who's supposed to decide this?
Pippa Malmgren: Well, this is not just true for the Supreme Court. This is true for all presidential appointments. And every presidency I've ever observed has always moved to put their own appointee in as soon as possible and to deny that place on the chessboard to the opposing team. You don't see that graciousness that says, oh well, you guys are going to be in charge next. Why don't we hold it open for you. I've never seen that happen with any kind of presidential appointment. But the Supreme Court obviously has more visibility and more scrutiny because of its extraordinary importance in American society. And we're at this moment in history where the court is turning in a particular direction that many want to see and many others definitely don't want to see. And so it's more contentious than usual.
And of course, now it's even more complicated because we've got a couple of the members of the actual Judiciary Committee themselves are now down with COVID And so, will they even be able to come in to vote is an open question. And it's such a tight margin, it's like a really open question. So again, everybody's on tenterhooks.
One little thing could change the outcome so dramatically here.
Erik Townsend: The thing that was most striking to me about the debate was the last question where the moderator asked both candidates, are you willing to firmly tell your supporters right here and now, don't turn to violence if I don't win? And neither one of them was willing to do that.
And meanwhile, we have other politicians who have actually gone so far as to use words like, we need you to be ready to fight.
Pippa Malmgren: Right.
Erik Townsend: If ever there were fighting words, be ready to fight is them. Are we headed toward a situation, Pippa, where, I mean, it seems like an almost certainty that there has to be some kind of contested election.
Are we going to get to a situation where obviously there has to be some civil unrest, but is it going to reach the point where the candidates are actually encouraging that from their supporters as opposed to what I would consider to be the more responsible thing of telling them that violence is never the solution to any kind of dispute?
Pippa Malmgren: Yeah. So, you know, here's the thing. Let's back up a little bit before we even get to these questions and understand what's happening. What's happening is COVID, it's a very interesting disease in that it initially reveals the underlying and preexisting conditions initially in a human, but then it also reveals it in companies, in economies, and now in society.
Now, one of the previously existing conditions in American society was that the African American community had not achieved a place in that society commensurate with their rights, with their size, with the hard work that they've engaged in. The sense of injustice is palpable. And certain events contributed to that even more.
But I think everybody's had a kind of underlying sense of discomfort. I know that I'd give speeches to big companies in America, huge corporates, and I walk in and in the last decade, I've seen many more women in every room, but I've still not seen people of color. And I wonder, where is everybody? Where are all the people that I went to university with who are educated and bright and part of the economy, but they're not in the establishment?
At least not to the degree that I think probably makes sense.
Anyway, that community of people who are worried about this issue have felt the pressure of COVID the realization that time has run out. We've had enough time to address it, and so something must be done. That's where your question comes in, what to be done. And, you know, the gracious approach, the Martin Luther King approach, the Mahatma Gandhi approach, the Nelson Mandela approach. And Mandela approach is the nonviolence and stand for your principles. And there are many people in that camp in the United States today.
But in all heated situations, there's also a group of people who aren't so measured, aren't so reflective and thoughtful, aren't so disciplined, maybe bring a different philosophy to the table. And that has ended up in confrontation. Now, I think the confrontations that we're seeing in America are not exclusively about this issue. It's also tied up with the gaps between the rich and the poor. I think there are arguments too between the urban and the rural, which is not a color-based— it's not a color-based issue. That's just to do with different geographical priorities.
So the bottom line is there is a lot of Anger at this time for a whole bunch of reasons. And COVID itself is definitely bringing out— if you had mental issues before, they're more visible now. If you didn't, but you're experiencing stress, well, COVID is magnifying all of that. So we have people who are not in their usual frame of mind. And I think just taken all together, yes, what you get is civil unrest. And as you know, So I started writing about the prospects for the resurgence of civil unrest back in about 2015 with a couple of books that I wrote at that time trying to explain why.
And a lot of it has to do with we have been taking the rules of the game very much for granted and that they are not fixed. They are fluid. They can change. And right now, all of these pressures from a weak economy, from COVID from The stress between the left and the right, suddenly the rules are up for grabs. Now, when the rules themselves, right, when you don't know what is the game we're playing, is it football or is it tennis or is it neither? It's actually a new kind of civil war. Like, what is it we're dealing with? In that environment, it pays to fight the rules, break the rules, reshape them, reframe them, reform them.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Pippa Malmgren: And that's what people are doing. And they're doing it with different levels of anger, different levels of energy. So the question is, what are people in leadership positions doing about this? And so one of the things I've written about in my new book, The Infinite Leader, that's only just come out, in fact, this week, is that leadership is not always about that other guy over there.
It's about you. And every one of us exercises leadership in a personal capacity every single day. And the decisions that you make about how you're going to behave and what issues you're going to take a stand on definitely have an impact.
And I think part of what's happening is because people don't feel confident in our political leaders on either side, they're starting to take power into their own hands and make their own decisions. And by definition, that means we're going to get a whole range of decisions falling out of that. Some people are going to say that means I pick up a Molotov cocktail and I burn down a building. Some people are going to say that means I walk with dignity through the street to make my protest clear and known.
And we're going to get a huge array of different responses. The question is, can anybody in the top of politics then say anything that causes a particular outcome. And I think right now, the Democrats don't have enough confidence in Joe Biden. The Republicans don't have enough confidence in Donald Trump as a leader, as a uniting force to be affected by anything they say. And in a way, because both of them are being so partisan, none of them are arising above politics to say, let us unite the nation.
They're saying, let us divide the nation. Well, it just encourages more of the same.
So I think that we're in for a period of social protest. And I don't mean things getting burned down necessarily, but I do mean real social protests where people object, they try to change, they try to create a new rule system. And usually the end of that process is very positive because You end up with a new agreement, a new social contract as to what is the way we're going to go forward. I know it's a painful process to go through, and I'm not advocating violence in any way, but usually when you get to the end of this kind of social stress period, you get stability out of it. So I'm optimistic about where we're going. The way we're getting there isn't very easy.
Erik Townsend: I wanna pick up on a phrase you used just a minute ago, a new kind of civil war. Tell us more about what you mean, because it seems to me we do have scope for, for this unrest to grow to a scale that really is a civil war. But obviously, this is not the 1800s. We're not gonna dig trenches and have soldiers on either side with muskets trying to shoot at each other. It seems like we're already seeing burning things down, major arsons are So, you say that cyberattacks are one of the elements of these new tactics of what I think could escalate into this new kind of civil war. What are the other attributes? What is this new kind of civil war? What does it look like?
Pippa Malmgren: Well, another attribute of it is its digital quality. And there's a lot of writing about, and you and I have talked in the past about the changed balance of power between states and citizens and the use of data And digitization, the use of mobile phones, for example, to track behaviors. And again, COVID has totally accelerated that process with the introduction of track and trace and ever larger powers and freedoms by governments to keep an eye on the citizens using their electronic technology. And every nation does this differently. Recently, I think just this week, we saw in Hong Kong the Chinese authorities blocked off a few city blocks and everyone inside those few city blocks basically had a data search done and it heavily targeted young people because they're trying to find who are the protesters, who are the organizers of the protests against the Chinese state.
And so basically your digital identity, which is in your phone, gives away so much information about you, who you connect with, where you've physically been. It's capable of being used as a microphone to record everything that you say. There's a record of all your emails, all your communications, all your text messages. So, you know, this is Because the new war zone is a data space. And I don't think that we've reached an agreement about what's a reasonable amount of data for governments to have access to and what's not. I don't think we've reached that in China, and I don't think we've reached it in the West either, because it's all so new. People still don't even understand that they're giving away that information. They still will have conversations in front of an Alexa and think that that's still private when in fact all that data is easily auctioned off on the net and available for sale. So I think data is the second war space or war zone where this civil unrest is unfolding.
And then I think another area of it has to do with morals.
Erik Townsend: Mm-hmm.
Pippa Malmgren: This is such a super controversial area because everyone takes the high ground and says, my morals are better than your morals. But the point is they're all arguing about what's the right set of morals. And I think that's a really fascinating fight about philosophically, what are the right set of morals for modern society? And that's why, again, the Supreme Court issue is so important. And we just saw this opinion being released by Justice Clarence Thomas that calls into question the case that allowed gay marriages.
And, you know, such an interesting question because, you know, for me, when I was growing up, a conservative was liberal in the sense that the view was once you get to your own front door, anything you want to do should be allowed inside. You know, within a certain reason. But, you know, basically the freedom to be who you were was protected.
Today, that's not considered the conservative position. And the liberal position has moved to, we're entitled to come into your house and tell you what you can and can't do. It's like a complete reversal of where things used to be. So some of this is navigating in a moral space, which is a bit like the 17th, 18th centuries, particularly 18th century, where those were the kinds of issues that we had civil unrest over. They were moral issues, and we're seeing maybe a repeat of history on that front.
Erik Townsend: Now, a lot of Americans focus on the domestic aspects of this and the domestic policy aspects of this. I think more about this in a different context, which is I feel that for many years now, China particularly, and a number of other nations have been waiting for their moment of opportunity where there's a vulnerability in the strength of the American nation to where they could do something to change the dynamics and particularly to try to displace the US dollar as the world's reserve currency.
Are we headed toward a situation where an uprising of civil unrest in the wake of a contested election could create a moment of opportunity for China or other nations, either militarily or I think more likely financially, to make an attack, so to speak, on the United States?
Pippa Malmgren: Well, look, geopolitics is alive and well, and we are definitely seeing the superpowers facing off against each other. And they're doing it in lots of different ways, some of which are visible, some of which not so visible. There's definitely a race for the command of space, meaning outer space. And there's a race for the command of data.
And there's a race for resources. So some of the most intriguing geopolitical conflicts now are occurring in really obscure places like the border between India and China, where there's a big argument about water. So I think this traditional way of thinking that China wants to displace the US dollar, yeah, I get it, but it's not necessarily the highest priority. I think a higher priority is how to achieve domestic security, and that's more about resources and relationships.
And that's what the Chinese focus on is deepening their access to resources, energy, food, water, and deepening the relationships that they can rely upon at the expense of the United States. Now, what goes along with that is the building of payment systems. And the Chinese have been very active in talking about their new digital currencies, which they do see as being global in nature. And, you know, Is displacing the dollar over time part of that? Sure, definitely. I'm just saying it's not like they wake up every morning going, let's displace the dollar. It's more that they wake up every morning going, let's make sure that we have enough food.
And part of that is food security and the ability to pay for it wherever it is in the world. I think Russia's a bit different. And it was the United States that really called into question Russia's ability to manage its affairs in the world economy. Because once we started to say that we would use SWIFT, the payments mechanism, as a geopolitical tool, so if the Russians behave badly, we would deny them access to the SWIFT bank clearing system. So they said, fine, we'll just create our own SWIFT, which they now have.
So it wasn't that they woke up saying, let's displace the dollar. It was more that a geopolitical event occurred and they realized their vulnerability to the US dollar and found a way to diminish that vulnerability. And I do think that the commercial warfare between Russia and the United States or the West is definitely intensifying. And we can see that in companies like, you must be familiar with Wirecard and the big fraud that happened at Wirecard. It's a multi-billion dollar fraud.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Pippa Malmgren: And it turns out that the finance director was not only a Russian, but someone who's taken refuge and is considered an ally of President Putin's. And it's raised lots of questions like, what was that really about? Was that really just a commercial enterprise that went wrong, or was that a geopolitical strategy to create a payment system in the West that was fraudulent and use it as a means of extracting information about how business is conducted in the West, maybe compromising information about people using that payment system?
Like, what was that objective? Or is it just coincidence that the finance director appears to now be in exile under President Putin's protection? Maybe it is, but it's an open question. We don't know. What is this modern geopolitics about, especially in the commercial arena? Which is kind of a very different way of thinking about geopolitics than we are used to.
Erik Townsend: Pippa, how should investors be thinking about this election and particularly the accuracy of the polls? Because according to the polls, it's pretty darn clear that Biden is strongly in the lead. Some people have suggested, however, that really there's a lot of room for things to change, and there's also a lot of room for those polls to be wrong. because of biases that are built into them. Is this thing a done deal? Is this election in the bag for Biden at this point, or is that not the case?
Pippa Malmgren: So I think the first thing that really matters is the demographics of America are changing so rapidly that I don't think these polls are able to capture what's really happening. So for example, we're seeing an exodus of people from both California and New York into the interior of the United States, particularly into Texas. And places like Arizona. So this is really interesting. Arizona starts to look like it's going to be a Biden-supporting state.
And traditionally, that's not where Arizona's been. So it's the morphing of the demographics of politics inside America as the coastlines migrate to the interior. And it changes the flavor of politics. And I think you'll see this in Texas as well. Texas is becoming a less wholly conservative state and becoming more liberal and left-leaning. And again, in part because Austin has become, in my opinion, the new Silicon Valley, the epicenter of innovation in technology in the United States. It's an incredible collection of the brightest minds in the country now all ending up there.
And that's put a very liberal bent on that community. So naturally they vote differently than they used to vote in Austin. So I personally think that these old notions about what the people are like in any given state are just outdated and the polls are not catching this.
And I also think that the silent Trump vote is probably bigger now than it was in 2016. People find that quite shocking and surprising, but I think it is. And one of the things I've been watching closely is the African American vote for Trump, which has been rising and really rising substantially in recent weeks. And everybody goes, well, what? How can that possibly be? So let me put it in stark terms.
When people talk about the Black vote in America, they assume it's one
Erik Townsend: Mm-hmm.
Pippa Malmgren: Unified bloc. Well, this is crazy. Nobody says the white vote in America is one unified bloc. It certainly isn't. And the Black vote isn't either. So what we're seeing is a differentiation and it's the middle-class mothers kind of over the age of 40 who it turns out are remarkably pro-law and order and often in communities where the whole police force is principally African American.
And so they're the opposite of the defund the police crowd. They're the fund the police because that's my son, that's my daughter, that's my nephew, that's my niece. And those people, their vote for Trump has clearly been going up as a result of the social unrest. And so that's shocking to a lot of people. How can you have anybody who's in that African American community voting for Trump? And the answer is, well, Well, some people are putting that as a higher priority than you would've guessed.
Equally, the Trump-supporting white community is— I think there are a lot of silent Trumpers there as well and a good deal of distaste for how he conducts himself. But when they look at the policy, they go, ah, but I still I don't want to bring in Biden because what he represents is a significant move to the left potentially.
And people are nervous about, well, what does that mean in a COVID world where I'm already taking a big hit? The economy's already down. COVID is already a huge challenge. Do I want to add to that more regulation, more red tape, bigger government, more aggressive tax policy? Is that really what I want? So they might hold their nose and say, well, I don't really like Trump, but I really don't know what I'm going to get on the other side, and I'm not too comfortable with that.
And I think that there is a lack of clarity, and probably if Biden does win, we're going to find it takes probably at least 2 years, maybe a year, but probably 2 years for the Democrats to sort out exactly what their policy really will be because they're so divided between a very far left by American standards and a center position, which isn't really strongly supported. So how far to the left are they going to go is a seriously open question.
So to that end, I think all these polls are going to miss all the stuff I just walked you through. So I think it's wide open.
And the key thing is to try to get a sense of who are the silent supporters. And where are they? And finally, will they be able to vote? I mean, COVID is starting to roll again, right? We're coming into the autumn. People are going to start getting flu, just like regular normal flu. But anybody who gets the flu, you know that they're going to be suspected of having COVID.
And so the question is voter turnout. How much voter turnout is going to occur? How much is not going to occur? because of COVID how much is not going to occur as well because of the supposed voter suppression tactics, how much voter encouragement is going to work or not work compared to usual.
All of these are wide open questions. I don't think we can assume anything.
Erik Townsend: Let's try to translate the various possible outcomes to what they mean for markets because it's interesting to me that these things have changed so much. For a while, the There was a very, very strong opinion expressed by financial professionals that, look, if Biden wins, it's got to be very negative for markets because it's going to be more taxes and more burden on the economy. Now, what I'm seeing is a lot of financial pundits are saying that a Biden win is positive for markets.
What are the actual drivers here? What, what does a Trump win mean? What does a Biden win mean? And what is just getting this over with
Pippa Malmgren: You know, I have to tell you, I've got a funny view on this. My view is that it doesn't matter whoever wins. We already know that half the country isn't going to like the outcome, and it's the same on both sides. So what we will have is certainty, and I think markets like certainty. So I personally think that markets might rise either way.
The real danger is that if we don't get certainty, if we end up where the voting system is challenged, if we end up with a situation where the president refuses to leave, which a lot of people have talked about as a scenario, if we end up— imagine if Biden ends up winning, but he's down with COVID right?
Like, so is he going to make it? Is he going to be the next president or is he on a ventilator?
Erik Townsend: Right.
Pippa Malmgren: You know, all of these are possibilities that, you know, we have to think about. And I think it's the uncertainty that will cause markets to really come unstuck. Anything that's certainty, markets will be like, okay, phew, at least we know that. And again, because everyone's built in the worst possible outcomes, they're so sure that, you know, it's the Great Depression all over again.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Pippa Malmgren: Again, any good news is going to go a long way.
So I'm still leaning on the optimistic side here that either way, the markets settle down and half the country doesn't like the new leader and half the country does. And we've been in this position for quite some time. In a sense, not a lot changes.
Erik Townsend: Let me understand this a little better, Pippa. I agree with you, first of all, that uncertainty is what markets don't It seems to me that a high degree of uncertainty is a certainty, if that's not a contradiction of terms, in the sense that you know the election will be contested. That's for sure. Are you saying that's already priced in? Because I think it's likely that we don't know right up until inauguration day. There's a big Supreme Court battle, and, you know, neither side is willing to concede, probably with a healthy dose of of civil uprising from both sides, you know, violence in the streets over both sides feeling like their guy won and the other side is trying to undermine democracy by taking the election away from the fair and square winner. If that happens the way I just described it, are you saying, well, that's already kind of priced in, or are you saying that that would be a negative surprise
Pippa Malmgren: No, I'm saying that would be a negative surprise for markets. What I'm saying is as long as we know who wins and it's not contested, either way, we know the outcome. Half the country likes the person, half the country doesn't. And then we just carry on as we have been for some years.
If there's uncertainty about who is the new person or when are they coming to power, that is a definite, you know, that knocks markets sideways. That's going to be a big challenge. And the question is, I think you sound very confident that we're going to get a contested outcome. I think markets have not priced in that it's inevitable, but the probability is much higher than I've ever seen in my lifetime.
So I think it is possible that we'll get a contested outcome or an uncertain result, because I would add into those scenarios not just the obvious ones that that it's a challenge of— it's like the hanging chad period where the votes themselves get challenged. I'm saying it could be that COVID comes into play and affects the people involved in politics, and that could be a whole new degree of uncertainty.
Erik Townsend: It's interesting to me. It sounds like you're not as convinced as I am. The reasons that I feel so convinced that this uncertainty is a certainty, or that it's certain to be uncertain, is both sides have said very clearly they're not going to concede. And when challenged in the debate to say, will you at least tell your supporters not to resort to violence as you're not conceding, neither one of them was willing to make a declarative and clear statement to that effect. So it seems to me like it's pretty darn certain that nobody's going to concede. Both sides are going to say that they won, and their supporters are likely to take to the streets. Am I missing something? Why do you disagree with that, if you disagree?
Pippa Malmgren: So do you remember a couple of months ago when George Floyd incident happened, when he died, and there was a guy who's called Magic Mike who came on to Twitter and he gave an amazing speech. An African American, a very articulate fellow who's someone very well known in the world of Instagram and Facebook and has come from an athletic background. Anyway, he gave this remarkable speech where he basically said, I know you're mad, but don't burn down your own neighborhood.
And it was so moving. He also had reference— he made reference to the fact that his relatives were all on the police department, and it was utterly wrong that this had happened to this poor man. But at the same time, so he totally supports the police, and he did not support this murder.
And so was he able to calm the community? And And allow them to be angry, but prevent them from being destructive.
Yes, he was. And he wasn't like a community leader. He wasn't a political leader. He was just a person who— it's a good example of exercising personal leadership. And he just stepped up to the microphone and said very honestly how he felt. He was crying, his emotions were high. You could see how much he was moved by this very, very awful situation. But he kept repeating that the solution is not violence. So I think there are a lot of people who have that view. And when the pressure really comes, they will just appear out of nowhere and they'll step up to the microphone and they'll say, What the president and the presidential candidate probably should have said.
But it's not that it won't be said. It will be said by someone. I'm very confident of that.
In America and our history, civil unrest and real destructive violence, it happens, but it usually doesn't last that long because people kind of come to their senses and realize that that's not the way you solve stuff. How you solve stuff is getting involved in the making of the rules and the policy and all And there are lots of switched-on Americans that will get that. So I don't know, maybe that's just me being an optimist about human nature.
Erik Townsend: Well, I definitely hope that you're right. I can't help but sort of feel like, first of all, I agree that was a very, very moving speech that that gentleman made. A whole bunch of folks did burn their neighborhoods down after that. And I hope you're right and I hope I hope it doesn't happen anymore. I want to move on though to a prediction, or not really a prediction, but an insight that you shared with MacroVoices listeners several years ago. I think it was before President Trump even won the 2016 election. And your comment was that you thought that a significant part of the reason that President Trump chose to run for the presidency and the reason that he emphasized so heavily in his first campaign, his frustrations and annoyances with the press, was that you thought really his ultimate objective was to create the Trump News Network.
And you thought that there was a possibility he might not even run for a second term, or that if he did run and lost his second-term election, his next move would be to create his own news network. Now, Pippa, in your wild wildest dreams could you ever have imagined a better setup to launch the Trump News Network than for President Trump to win reelection in the eyes of his supporters, but then have that election taken away from him by the Federal Election Commission concluding that he didn't actually win, even though half the country thought that he won?
Because perhaps, as Jim Bianco explained to us, this notion of a mirage where it looks like the president won until they count all of the mail-in ballots and so forth, and then he didn't win. If that were to happen, in your wildest imagination, be a better setup for the Trump News Network to be launched? And do you still see that as a distinct possibility if he is not confirmed as being reelected?
Pippa Malmgren: Yeah, I think that this is coming either way. If he is reelected, he's still going to be building that and preparing it for when he does leave office. And if he's leaving office at this juncture, then that's the platform I would expect him to go to. And I think that after he leaves the White House, he's going to have as big a voice in media and maybe bigger than he's had in the White House. And that, that was always the objective.
I mean, it might be you could say that his objective was always to have the maximum impact voice no matter what, and you would just pick the best platform for that. And it happened to be the White House most recently. But I would say, no, it's actually even bigger than that. It's been a deliberate strategy, a belief that what Ted Turner did with CNN was the smart thing, because not only do you then get a way to broadcast yourself and your views, but you get paid a ton of money for it at the same time. Like, for someone like that, what's not to love? And, you know, globally, there's all kinds of signs that conservative news is starting to, you know, get backing and funding. We're seeing new television stations being created here in the UK, for example, the new GB channel for Great Britain.
There are several others. And so there's financing, there's money, there's a recognition that there's a conservative community that the traditional media wasn't really serving and that there's a need for the stories to be told in this more conservative way.
And so, I think the real question is, do I think that if he launches this, it'll make money? Will it be a success? Will people watch it? My answer is it will. People will watch it. And it's not that I approve of the way the president You know, uses media to make splashy headlines that, you know, are not substantively serious. It's just, you know, if you're going to be in that game, winning is about money and it's about eyeballs. It's about influence.
And he has always been remarkably good at that. And I wouldn't underestimate his ability to do that very, very well.
And again, why was he even running for the presidency initially? It was to get the ratings on this television program up back in 2016. And I still don't think that he or any of his team really thought he was going to win. And then he did. They're like, wow, okay, well, let's use this platform then. And when this platform goes, they'll say, but let's have another platform. So I still bet money on that. And I do think it's going to change American politics because whatever TNN is, I expect it's going to be It's going to be more shocking, racier than anything we've seen on television so far. It may be a kind of, I don't know, cross between Fox News on steroids with a bit of porn thrown in.
You know what I mean? Like, he will not have any hesitation to put things up which are going to shock and surprise. He will go to the limits of what the law allows, and who knows, maybe a bit further.
Erik Townsend: Let's imagine one year from today that Joe Biden is in the Oval Office and Donald Trump is at the helm of TNN and on a regular show where he expresses his views in his own unique way. From your perspective as a geopolitical consultant and former presidential advisor, who's the more powerful influencer in that scenario? Who's got more power?
Pippa Malmgren: I hate to say it, but I think it's not Trump personally, but anyone with that kind of platform, that may be more powerful than the White House. I do think that the power of the West Wing was never what people assume it is. And you know, my dad worked for 4 presidents, Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon, Ford, and the limitations of power in the West Wing have always more severe than people realize. It's not like you can just say anything you want or accomplish any task. It's very difficult to navigate the system of law and rules and tradition and public opinion, how to balance public opinion.
It's quite a difficult task to manage from the Oval Office. To manage from a media platform, all you have to do is say and show whatever is going to get the biggest shock factor. You know, it's an easier task to just shock people, and they'll pay you for it, and they'll pay you with the time looking at it with their eyes, which leads to advertising dollars.
So I think that's an easier task, and Trump is better equipped to make it work with that kind of a platform even than the White House platform.
Erik Townsend: Pippa, I want to shift gears now. Your book, Geopolitics for Investors, written in 2015, was, I think, your first book that I'm aware of. 2016, you wrote Signals, which was just incredibly incisive, gave investors a perspective on how to interpret various different signals that go on geopolitically, what they mean for investors and markets. 2019, You got the Best Business Book of the Year Award and also an International Press Award for your 2019 book, Leadership Lab. You've got a sequel to The Leadership Lab that just came out called The Infinite Leader. Give us a refresher on what The Leadership Lab was about and what the sequel is about and how people can get ahold of it.
Pippa Malmgren: Well, so I co-authored both of them with Chris Lewis, who runs runs Lewis Media, which is the 2nd largest privately owned PR firm in the world. And Chris is a Brit living in America, and I'm an American living in Britain. So we just started to collaborate on our views because we're advising a lot of people in the world of politics, and we saw that there's been a terrible breakdown of leadership. We've seen so many leaders get things wrong.
And the number one reason why CEOs have left their position in the last couple of years has been ethical lapses. You're like, what's causing that? Why is this happening? So in The Leadership Lab, we started to review how to run organizations and why it is that the leader needs to have a better understanding of what is actually happening in the world and not coast on what they think, because what they think is happening might be like 10 years out of date.
The Infinite Leader is more about the individual and the idea that the dialogue the individual has with themselves is what defines their capacity to lead. And that's why leadership is personal. And it's something that I exercise and you exercise and every one of us exercises every single day. It's not only about who is the president. It's about all the choices and decisions you make in the course of your day.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Pippa Malmgren: Like what you buy and how you spend your time and what you prioritize. And so, The Infinite Leader is really written for individuals to start thinking about how they could manage their own lives better, especially in light of all these extraordinary, truly historic pressures being brought to bear on us all, like COVID, like a collapsing economy all around us.
And how to reach a place where you can begin to be creative and innovative and build something new. Because that's how we're going to get out of all these troubles. It's going to be people building something new. And I'm very confident that this is definitely happening. The media won't write about it until the stories are so obvious. But I think that it's definitely happening. And it's actually a very exciting time in history.
Painful, but I think it's going to result in quite a good outcome ultimately.
Erik Townsend: And the title is The Infinite Leader, available right now on Amazon. Pippa, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. Kevin Muir and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade, but the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland.
I recently did a full-length interview with farmtogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio.
You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests You can send us your requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts.
Kevin Muir: Erik, that's a terrific interview with Pippa. It's great to hear from a geopolitical analyst this close to the election.
Erik Townsend: Well, Kevin, I'm really looking forward to our postgame segment because I've been reading your Macro Tourist blog with great interest. Now you've been writing about the subjects that I think are most important. Regular MacroVoices listeners already know what's on my mind, but for anyone who's new, I'm convinced that if you can figure out where the US dollar is headed from here, and you can figure out whether or not the bond bull market of 38 years has actually ended, or if US Treasury rates can go negative at the 10-year maturity.
And you can figure out whether or not we're about to make a secular shift toward inflation, you've totally nailed the macro picture and you've got tremendous edge because frankly, most of these idiots in finance have no clue what the answers to those questions are. Just one little issue. I'm one of those idiots, Kevin, who really has no clue what the answers to those questions are because It's a really complex macro landscape. You've been writing about all 3 of these things, and not only do you have a view on them, but it actually leads you to a trade that we're going to talk about. Let's start with the high-level big picture. Tell us about US dollar, bond yields, and whether they can go negative on the US 10-year, and inflation. Let's start with the high-level outlook on that, and then from there, go to how that gets you to a specific trade strategy.
Kevin Muir: Sure. Well, thanks, Erik. I think a lot of people that look at whether it be the US dollar or inflation and come to the conclusion that the US dollar is going to rally or that we're not going to get any inflation and we're going to get an implosion of prices, they're all using an old construct. They're all stuck on this idea that debt of a currency issuer is the same as debt of a currency user.
And if there's one thing that's happened during COVID it's been the fact that we've had this kind of watershed moment where the marketplace has woken up to the idea that governments are actually much different and they are not financially constrained and they can actually create as many dollars as they want.
And once you kind of accept that and put aside for a second whether this is morally correct, or whether this will end badly. It doesn't matter. You have to ask yourself what's going to happen. I always say you should trade the market that is, not the one that you want to be.
So if we stop and think about this and realize that the governments can create the dollars whenever they want, it kind of makes all of a sudden all these questions that you're asking about where this is going to go much easier. So let's just take the US dollar. I look at the US dollar and say, whose interest is it for it to go up?
I think there's almost nobody. The global economy will do better with a lower US dollar. We all need the liquidity. And so I'm confused as to why everyone thinks the US dollar will go higher. I look at it and say, the Fed and the government is going to create all the dollars that they need to send it lower.
And in terms of inflation, I look at it and say, You know, again, does deflation benefit anyone?
Erik Townsend: No.
Kevin Muir: So therefore, I look at the government and the central banks and say they're going to create enough dollars to make inflation. And I think that everyone that's continuing to to use those old playbooks are are kind of assuming that the only way to create dollars is through the private sector.
And there's no doubt that over the past thirty years we have relied. On private sector credit creation as the main way to create dollars. Every time there's been a recession, what's happened is the Fed's come and cut rates, and we've basically tried to encourage more bank loans to rejuvenate the economy until finally when we hit the great financial crisis, we hit the zero bound. And at that point, basically private sector credit creation was no longer. And of course, we tried some extreme measures. We tried quantitative easing. We tried a million different other things. Even look at what they do in Europe. They went to negative rates, all these insane policies.
Well, I think that what 2020 has shown and with the advent of the COVID is that they realize that governments can spend money into existence and create the inflation and the demand that they need. Now, again, you might think this will all end bad. Who cares? The reality is that if you were one of those people that were in the camp that the Fed wasn't going to be able to create the liquidity in March or April and May, what's happened is everything's rallied in your face.
So I've always said that we can always create inflation whenever we want. It's only a matter of political will. And I think what's happened is with the COVID crisis, we've finally gotten that political will that we've needed. So for me, I look at it and go, I think the dollar's headed lower and I think that inflation's headed higher.
Erik Townsend: Kevin, I have to agree with you. I don't like it, but you know what's on top of my reading list right now is Stephanie Kelton's The Deficit Myth. And I don't think it's really a myth, but I do know that Stephanie Kelton has a heck of a lot more influence on public policy and monetary policy than I do, or anyone that I know. And it's important to understand, as you say, what's coming, not what I wish was coming.
Kevin Muir: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: But what is coming. But Kevin, here's the thing I find interesting. You'd expect with that setup that you were going to dive into a gold trade because that's the way a lot of people think about responding to this idea that governments around the world, including the United States, are going to print more money. But you prepared a really great chart deck. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices. MacroVoices.com.
Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads right above Dr. Pippa Malmgren's picture. Kevin, the title is not Buy Gold, Be a Gold Bug, it's Yield Curve Steepening. So why is it that you see a yield curve steepener as the trade to play this?
Kevin Muir: Well, Erik, I don't want to lose my status as a gold bug as well. You can also— I think gold will be a beneficiary of what we just discussed. But I think that a lot of people are missing the opportunities that are presented in the bond market. And I still contend that before this is all through, that the yield curve is going to go to record wides. Now, in the meantime, what's happened is that the bond market is— I joked the other day that if you went and looked, if the bond market chart was someone's pulse, you would've pulled that person into the morgue long ago because it had gotten so sleepy.
And I look at this and I think that there's a great opportunity. But before we get to that, I actually want to talk about quantitative easing. And I wanted to talk about why this time is different than the previous times.
And you touched upon the deficit myth and Stephanie Kelton and the MMT folk. And so one of the things that happened in the advent of the great financial crisis, if you remember when they— we did the first quantitative easings, everyone was worried about all this hyperinflation that was going to be created.
And then in the second one, we actually— the second quantitative easing, we actually got to a point where some very bigwig kind of economists and market strategists took out a full-page ad, an open letter to Ben Bernanke telling him how it was going to end badly. Well, even the third, people were still convinced that it was going to create inflation, and none of those created inflation. And then what was interesting about this, Erik, was that although they were worried it was going to create inflation, and it actually caused the bond market to rise in yield as the Federal Reserve was doing its quantitative easing, every time the Fed stopped doing QE, bond yields fell.
And I have this great chart that goes through them all, and it shows the first quantitative easing where yields rose from 2% to 3.95%, and then the moment the quantitative easing fell or stopped, yields fell. Quantitative easing 2, the QE2 program, yields rallied from 2.5% to 3.75%. Then again, the moment it stopped, yields fell. Finally, quantitative easing 3, which was QE infinity because there's no end to it, it rose from 1.60% to 3%, and then they tapered it. And as they tapered it, the yields went down.
And what that was, was a function of the market coming to terms with the idea that quantitative easing Can't actually create inflation, and and I know that that seems kind of counterintuitive to what a lot of people believe because you see all this money going into this into the economy and you think to yourself, oh geez, that money is going to create inflation. But I'd like to go through kind of the plumbing of it to really understand this. Let's just kind of think about when J.P. Morgan sells a bond to the Federal Reserve. So the Federal Reserve comes and they buy a bond from J.P. Morgan. So let's say they buy you know half a billion dollars. $500 million.
So now all of a sudden the Federal Reserve has $500 more million on its balance sheet and J.P. Morgan has $500 million more cash. But if you think about J.P. Morgan, are they any more inclined to make a loan because all of a sudden they sold some bonds to the Fed?
Was that really what was stopping them from making the loans in the first place? Or does J.P. Morgan make loans based upon proper borrowers and then their own balance sheet, whether the equity and the capitalization of it? The reality is that quantitative easing would've never ever created inflation.
You hear people talk about it being an asset swap, and this is why, because it ends up being that J.P. Morgan takes that money, that's sitting on their balance sheet and they just deposit it back into the Fed and it goes up. And that's why interest on excess reserves keeps going through the moon. Now, I think it's interesting though that in the first 3 times we had quantitative easing, yields rose as the Federal Reserve was buying bonds. And that was because the market was convinced it was going to create inflation.
And it wasn't just me that thought this. I actually have a great quote from Stanley Druckenmiller, who I view as one of the best traders of all time. And he says, and my theory was QE, the buying of bonds by the government, would cause risk to go and therefore decrease the demand for bonds from other entities.
It took about 5 weeks, but it worked. Then we stopped QE, and sure enough, the day we stopped QE, bonds went up, stocks went down. Everyone blamed it on Boehner and Obama having a hissy fit with each other in the White House, but I have followed this for 8 years, and it was 7 for When the government buys bonds, bonds go down and stocks go up, and vice versa.
Now I have a little bit of a quibble with Stanley Druckenmiller. I think that the reason bonds went up in yield was because there was a yield curve shift within the kind of bond community. Meaning if you're a bond manager and you're seeing quantitative easing and you're seeing future inflation, you will go and you will sell your long bonds and buy short bonds in the hopes of reinvesting them later at a higher inflation Now, on the first 2 quantitative easings, they went straight up. Yields went straight up the moment they announced it. The 3rd one took a little longer.
Now, let's fast forward to today. The corona crisis comes, and this time yields don't go anywhere. We don't get any sort of reaction at all. And now risk still went bid. So according to Stanley Druckenmiller, people should be moving from bonds into risk. risk, and that should be causing yields to go up, but they're not. Now, obviously the government is buying some, and that's keeping a bid to it. But I would argue that more importantly is that people haven't— they've come to the conclusion that quantitative easing doesn't cause inflation.
And so therefore they're not worried about it. Now, I think that the 2020, the COVID crisis has changed the landscape. Whereas before in In the great financial crisis, we tried to fix everything with more and more monetary stimulus, and the government was actually doing pro-cyclical fiscal cuts. This time, we've had massive fiscal stimulus at the same time.
And the punchline of all this is that if you go and do quantitative easing along with fiscal stimulus, that is going to create the inflation that was missing the previous time.
So ironically enough, the previous quantitative easings caused the bond market to sell off, for yields to go up, and this time it didn't. But this time it's actually more likely that we're going to get inflation than any of the previous times because this time it's been married with spending.
Erik Townsend: Kevin, when you talk about a yield curve steepener, are we talking 2s-10s, 5s-30s? What steepener are we talking about.
Kevin Muir: So I love the 5/30, Erik. That's kind of the, the meaty part of it for me. I look at it and I think the Fed's on hold for a long time. I have this interesting chart where if I go back and look over the past, uh, kind of 50 years, 40 years, and look at— and whenever you had a recession, what happened coming out of the recession? Well, in the early '90s recession, yields actually fell.
Again, in the 2000 dot-com bubble, out of— coming out of the recession, yields fell, in the 2008 yields went sideways. But then if we go and look at that same chart and we look at the 5/30 spread coming out of those recessions, we'll see that each time the yield curve got significantly steeper. So I look at this and I think to myself, this is the place that I want to play. I want to be long the 5-year, 30-year yield spread.
Erik Townsend: Now let me understand why a spread as opposed to an outright trade on one of the legs, because normally the reason that you favor a steepener trade is because you're leaving room for either a bull or a bear steepener. In other words, it could be that the longer duration yield goes up, or you could make money if the shorter duration yield goes down. But here's the thing, Kev, if we look at the 5-year US Treasury right now, it's only yielding 33 basis points. How much down could it go from there?
Kevin Muir: Well, Erik, you should never say never, right? And the thing is, who We could get a situation where they go negative. They're negative 50 basis points in Europe. And one of the things is that I just look at this and say, yes, maybe being outright short bonds is an easy— is a good trade. I just think that this is a much better risk-reward scenario.
If I'm wrong, then I suspect the 5-year will be going down to stupid kind of low-level yields, and it won't hurt as much. And then if I'm right, I think that the Federal Reserve is gonna continue to leave the short end pinned. And I don't think that the 5-year is gonna rise in yield that much.
Erik Townsend: So it sounds like really the way you're thinking about this is it's not so much the usual steepener trade where you're not sure if it's a bull or a bear steepener. It's more of you're bearish on long-term Treasuries, But you're not so confident that you don't want some kind of hedge, and your hedge is to be long short-dated Treasuries.
Kevin Muir: Bingo. Completely agree, Erik. I think it's a great trade. I think it's probably one of the best out there. I know that the 5-year seems to have no upside, but as I said, if 2020 has taught us anything, it's that anything can happen. And I feel a lot more confident being long 5-years against my short 30s.
Erik Townsend: Kevin, before we wrap up this week's show, our listeners already know about Patrick Ceresna's Big Picture Trading, but not all of them are familiar with The Macro Tourist. Tell us about it briefly.
Kevin Muir: Well, thanks, Erik. It's, uh, I write a letter, I call it my almost daily letter, talk about a variety of different topics. I, uh, I try to make it fun, interesting. I know this isn't politically correct, but I call myself the playboy of financial newsletter writers because, uh, everyone says that they're subscribing to read the articles, but we all know they're just looking at the pictures.
And for those who are interested, check it out. It's themacrotourist.substack.com. And if you want to see an old— a couple old versions or copies of it, feel free to shoot me an email, kevin@themacrotourist.com.
Erik Townsend: I can't recommend it highly enough. And although there's lots of really great macro letters out there, nobody has better pictures than you do. I definitely will agree with that.
Erik Townsend: point. We're going to leave it there for this week's show, folks. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors. And by toptradersunplugged.com.
Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguides. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. And folks, be sure to check your Research Roundup email. Patrick is not with us to do his expert rundown on what you can expect there, but as usual, you'll find a link to the transcript from today's interview with Pippa Malmgren, as well as all of the best research that our volunteer research team could find.
Kevin Muir: So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag us with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
Erik Townsend: And if you'd like to support the show, please visit our website at MacroVoices.com.
Kevin Muir: You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and Patrick @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend, Patrick Ceresna, and myself, thank you for listening and have a great week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment. purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Town. Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Art Berman — petroleum geologist (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 239 was recorded October 1st, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors. When I interviewed petroleum geologist Art Berman back in June, Art told us to expect U.S. oil production to fall off a cliff in Q4. Well, today is the first day of Q4, and it's no coincidence that we're bringing Art back for an update on his outlook on the oil market. We'll discuss What's changed and what hasn't changed since Art's last interview back in June. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick will present another of his famous postgame chartbooks, this one evaluating whether the reflation trade has ended or not.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into that S&P 500. I mean, more or less we can define the last week as the market bouncing. We've obviously put some sort of a short-term swing low in the markets and we've been retracing towards this 3,400 level. What's your What's your take on all of this? Is there more upside or is this it for this little rally?
Erik Townsend: I have no idea, Patrick. I certainly do agree that it's very likely, you know, described as a bounce as opposed to necessarily a trend reversal. It was a perfect touch of the 100-day moving average, which is a key technical level. A lot of people, you know, bought that thinking it might be the bottom. We're bouncing.
Has it gone far enough to begin a new trend? No. Have we seen any sign of it reversing back to the downside? So, I don't think we know what's going on. As far as the big picture, I think that we're definitely in for some volatility by year-end in one direction or the other, driven by what I think is almost an assured contested election. On the other hand, everybody knows it's an assured contested election, which means that maybe it's already priced in. And of course, we don't know what's priced in. Is it the downside potential of uncertainty as not knowing who's president, or is it the upside potential of near-certain accommodation from from the Federal Reserve in reaction to whatever might go wrong. So I don't think we know. I think we're gonna have to wait and find out.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index because we had the breakout last week and this week we're giving a little bit of it back, but we're still more or less hovering a stone's throw away from the 94 handle. What's your take on the dollar here?
Erik Townsend: I wish I had a stronger take with more conviction. I can tell you with absolutely firm conviction, this is the most important issue that there is in macro. If you can figure out what the dollar's gonna do, to do next, you've got serious edge over the market. Do I have that edge? No, afraid not. The contested election and the Fed stimulus response are clearly a bearish setup. If we don't know who the President of the United States is, the rest of the world starts to lose confidence in the US dollar. And if that situation ensues, it's pretty certain we're gonna get more stimulus from the Fed. That greater stimulus from the Fed is, of course, dilutive to the value of the dollar. There's lots of reasons to think down. On the other hand, if things really get crazy
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And if the markets go crazy in the wake of a contested election and that spreads globally, well, then you've got a flight-to-safety trade. And I put safety in air quotes. A lot of people still think the US dollar is the safest currency on earth. I think gold is a safer bet myself, but a lot of institutional finance people don't think that way. So, you know, if there's a flight-to-safety trade, that's potentially bullish for the dollar. And of course, you've also got the dollar squeeze argument that Jeff Snider has made so eloquently.
Know what to say.
So if I don't know how to interpret the fundamentals, let's look at technicals. Well, technicals, you could argue that Friday's high was a new higher high in the short-term trend that began at the end of September, or you could go the other way and say it's a fresh lower high on the larger, longer-term trend that goes back to June. So the jury is still out in my mind, and frankly, I think you'd need a daily close above $95 or below $92 in order to get a really clear technical signal of which way we're heading. So, jury's still out. I think we have to wait and see.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because it had a big downdraft today. I mean, at one point we were down under $38. We're back above there at the time of recording. What's going on here in crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm going to save the big picture, what's going on in crude, what does the next year bring us, for the feature interview with Art Berman. So, for this week's market wrap, let's just focus on the inventory and short-term outlook, and we'll defer to Art Berman for the long-term outlook. I'll also We'll have more to say in reaction to the interview with Art Berman in our postgame segment after the feature interview.
Let's start with inventory. Crude oil drawing down 2 million barrels, plus another 1.8 coming out of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, so the total drawdown was 3.8 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma building 1.8 million barrels. Gasoline building 683,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 3.2 million barrels. US production, which as we've discussed in the past with Art Berman, and I'll discuss with him again today, That's the thing to watch as we go into Q4. What's it doing this week? Unchanged from last week, 10.7 million barrels, which is also exactly where we were before the tropical storm hit the Gulf of Mexico.
As far as, as what I think is going on, I was really leaning toward there still being more downside in this correction, and that's still my view, but maybe without a huge amount of conviction.
The weakness that we saw today was consistent with that. I think if we can get a daily close below the 34-week moving average, which is at $36.12 on WTI, that really is a setup to get us down to the target that I've been looking for for the past few weeks, which is somewhere in the low $30s, between $30 and $33 on the WTI front-month contract. Now, you know, we've seen more resilience than I expected, and that's been the theme for the last several weeks. Are we going to going to see a change in terms of weakening demand hitting the tape first, which probably get us down to that $30 number? Or are we going to see a decline in U.S. production hit the tape first, which might take us higher and lock us out of ever getting down to that $30 number anytime soon? I'm not sure.
It kind of depends on timing. Let's wait and see what Art Berman has to say in the feature interview about what we can expect in terms of timing for that reduction of US production to occur.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So let's move on to gold because gold has last week corrected down towards the $1,850 level. And really this week we've just had a bounce off of those lows. I mean, we're back above $1,900 here on the bounce. What's your take on gold? Is that enough of a correction or is there more to come?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, our regular listeners will remember that last week I said I was really hoping for a deeper correction down to $1,800 or so where I've got resting limit orders to buy more gold. But I also offered a caution, which is that we were We're just coming up on that 100-day moving average, which just might hold it. Well, clearly, at least so far, it's holding it. Now, is that just a bounce off the 100-day moving average? We're back up to the 13-day, which is, you know, the, the highest of the short-term moving averages. Is that the, the top of the bounce and we're going to end up below that 100-day at $18.68? If that happens, a daily close below $1,868 would suggest to me that we probably are headed down to that, you know, approximately $1,800, maybe even down as low as $1,750, which is where the 200-day moving average is.
On the other hand, if we get an upside breakout and a daily close above $1,950 or so, that would be the technical indication that we've got a new bull trend in play and we're maybe headed up to test the all-time highs again. So I think $1,868, below that number or above $19.50, is the place where you see the technical signals that ought to suggest a further move in that direction. Until we get one of those I'm not sure which way it's headed from here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, I wanna finally touch on this 10-year Treasury yield. I'm actually quite surprised how narrow the range has been in this 10-year yield because we have stock markets that are buzzing. You have all of the talk of these fiscal stimulus packages and you have commodities whipping around, the currencies whipping around, and yet the 10-year yield doesn't seem to wanna move more than a couple basis points higher or lower. And we're in this tight range hovering around 68 basis points. Like, how do you make sense of all this?
Erik Townsend: Well, I'll give you my guess, and it's not really strong conviction. I think what's been going on for the last few months is most people are stuck where I am, which is, boy, are we— you know, we've pretty much made the move down to almost zero at one point on the 10-year Treasury. Can it go negative? Are we headed there, or is the 38-year bond bull market necessarily over? I think everybody's got that question in their mind. Nobody knows the answer. And I think that what we're finding here at around 70 basis points on the 10-year is sort of the Yeah, I think it's kind of the sweet spot for everybody to wait this out. And, you know, it's kind of the balance point until we get a clear indication of whether inflation is really going to start to run away, whether we're going to see a backing up in yields associated with that, or if deflation can take us even further into negative yields.
And of course, what does the Fed do? What is the, you know, how does the contested election work out? There's a lot of things that the market is waiting for. And I think that it's found a balance point at around 70 basis points.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: The longer we consolidate in that narrow range, the more the market becomes coiled up and the more we're in a position for a fairly pronounced move when we get one in either direction. Which direction that's going to happen in, frankly, I've got no clue.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, why did we invite Art to the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, as I mentioned in the opening monologue, Patrick, one reason is it's the first day of Q4. Art made a lot of predictions about what would happen to US production in Q4. I want to find out if he still holds those convictions as strongly as he did in June. The other reason, though, is there's a lot that's happened since then that really brings the question to mind is, what if demand drops off even more than production does? So I want to get Art's take on that as well. I think it's a really important time in the oil markets. We've been coiling at this level right around $40 on WTI. I think we're beginning finally an overdue correction to the downside, but I'm not sure how deep it's going to go. At some point, I think there's a lot of upside in this market, but is that really starting in Q4? Does it not really come until 2021?
I want to get Art's perspective on when these things that he's predicted since June are really going to start to take hold in the market and be felt in the price of crude oil. Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us.
We haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure. Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time.
You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide. And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Art Berman is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is petroleum geologist Art Berman. Longtime MacroVoices listeners know it wouldn't be an Art Berman interview without an Art Berman slide deck. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not registered yet, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, looking for the downloads, right next to Art's picture.
Art, last time we had you on in June, what you told us was the shale patch was gonna get through the summer just fine because there was an inventory of drilled but uncompleted wells wells that could be completed, brought online. Production could probably be held up, was your prediction. And sure enough, that has very much played out. You also told us that the vicious price rally that was still in play when we spoke in June was about to top out. You nailed that call perfectly. It ended up within a week topping out. You said it was probably going to roll over and there would be a downside correction over the course of the summer. I guess that's pretty much played out. It hasn't been as deep of a correction as you and both expected, but their correction has been there. But what you told us, Art, was put your seatbelt on for Q4, because you said with the rig count depressed, there's just no way that anything else could happen but US production eventually falling off a cliff, probably in Q4.
I assure you, Art, it is no coincidence that we brought you back on the very first day of Q4 for an update on that prognosis. So do you still expect US production to fall off a cliff, which of course would be bullish for prices in Q4, or maybe do we need to get worried about demand falling off a cliff too, which would be bearish for prices?
Art Berman: Well, Erik, that's, uh, those are 2 very important questions, which of course I don't know the answer to, but my, my data and my, my sense of, of history and experience says that The answer to both is probably yes. The demand picture is easier, I suppose, to to talk about because we we get weekly updates, and I can tell you right now that the demand recovery in the United States is it's absolutely stalled. It's been stalled since the beginning of August, and looking at the critical numbers, which we'll discuss later, which are really. diesel or distillate and kerosene jet fuel. Those numbers continue to go down and are, you know, at a fraction, like maybe 60% of what they ought to be right now. So demand, definitely a problem.
As far as the shale patch, you know, you can't produce oil if you don't drill wells. And we are currently at a rig count of 143 in the tight oil horizontal plays. As of the end of August, we were at 613 in November of 2019. We're at about a third of what we need to maintain the production that equates to 11 or so million barrels a day U.S., which is what EIA and everybody else forecasts throughout the year.
And so the the question really is. You know how many, how many deactivated wells are going to be reactivated, and how do we fill in the gap? I think you called them ducks. That's fine. Call them whatever you will. They're productive wells that are not currently producing. That will keep us going for a while. I said fourth quarter. I never say specifically beginning or end of because I don't know. But my guess is it remains. By the end of fourth quarter, or certainly in the fourth quarter, we ought to see production declines. We've already seen them decline, so they will decline more. That's my story, and I'm sticking to it because that's what the data tells me. It's it's not a story that I I'm happy about. It's terrible for every aspect of the United States, its economy in particular. So I'd I'd love to be wrong.
Erik Townsend: Let's quantify these numbers a little bit more closely, Art, because when you say that by the end of Q4, US production should fall off perhaps dramatically, how dramatically are we talking about? How big of a number is that in terms of millions of barrels per day of production? And is this something where the likely fall-off in demand could maybe balance it out, or is it a bigger production decline than we could ever expect to see demand offset?
Art Berman: Right. Well, certainly US demand, well, it's a little complicated because obviously the US is a big importer of oil. And so there's a simple solution. I mean, the US currently imports something like 6 million barrels of crude oil a day. So it's not as if our demand is anywhere close to being met. Right. By our field production.
So that's, you know, that— and that's the way it's been pretty much forever, certainly since, since 1970. So let's just say, for instance, that demand doesn't fall any further than it has and production continues to fall as it has, or as I, as I expect that it will, then, uh, you know, it's not like there's an emergency or something. We just have to import more oil from Canada, basically, which will make the Canadians very happy, and it won't cost us any more to buy the oil from Canada or Saudi Arabia or someone else than it does to buy from a producer in the Bakken or the Permian Basin. It will send money out of the country, which is not an ideal circumstance, but, you know, we were doing that year after year after year up until about 2011 or 2012, another 4— then the Great Recession, you know, the U.S. economy was reasonably okay with all that going on.
So bottom line, I fully expect globally that demand will not recover anywhere close to levels that a lot of people think it will. It certainly won't recover as fast as many people think it will. And that, that will be adequately balanced by a decrease in production, which, I mean, you know, markets are not perfect, but they're, they're pretty damn efficient. So as long as the balance, as long as the supply-demand balance is in, you know, some sort of slight surplus or slight deficit, everything's fine. Price stays where it is.
Erik Townsend: Okay, so now you're saying that even though we're going to be forced to import more oil because we're not going to produce it in the US, You're saying it's going to cost us the same as if we produced it locally. That seems like a pretty big change from our conversation in June. At that point, we were talking about this phenomenon of US production falling off a cliff, creating a supply-demand imbalance that would, we both thought, push prices substantially higher. It sounds like now you're saying, yeah, the production is definitely still going to fall off a cliff. But maybe between demand falling off and other supplying countries making up for that deficit, probably the bullish price impetus that we thought was coming maybe isn't coming, or is it coming but just not yet? How do we pull this demand-supply equation together and end up with a prognosis of where oil prices might be headed?
Art Berman: Sure. Well, let's go back. It was almost exactly 3 months ago, I believe, that we talked last. And 3 months ago, I think I said that I was skeptical, certainly skeptical about a V-shaped recovery in consumption and demand. And I think you pretty much agreed with me on that. But let's face it, 3 months ago, we didn't have any idea what that might look like. And now, 3 months later, I think we have a very clear idea of what that looks like. And what that looks like is demand is not recovering anywhere near as rapidly or as fully as might have been the case, or certainly was a probabilistic case in my mind 3 months ago. So that's changed. We have data that, that says that.
And most importantly, Erik, as I said in the beginning of this discussion, you know, you can look at total petroleum consumption and that's great, and I do, But as long as diesel is way down, that means that the economy is damaged because it's diesel that we use to transport goods. Diesel runs trains, diesel runs trucks, diesel runs ships. And if diesel production— if diesel consumption is down, that means people aren't placing orders. Diesel price is relatively insensitive In other words, if the price of oil goes to $100 and diesel price climbs up along with it, as long as people are placing orders, that's fine. You know, we'll just pass those extra costs along to the consumer.
When diesel consumption is low, that only means one thing, and that's the economy is in trouble. So as long as the economy— and of course jet is a whole nother thing, and we all expect I think we all expected jet consumption to be down because, you know, who the heck wants to get on an airplane even once there's a vaccine? But, you know, jet fuel is something like 8 or 9% of global consumption. And then you start adding in how many people work in that industry and, you know, associated industries, travel business. And so, so that picture is, is kind of bleak. So So the demand side has changed.
The other thing we didn't know 3 months ago was how compliant OPEC+ was going to be on their agreement. Let's remember, you know, there's something like 7 to 10 million barrels per day that's being withheld from the market. And so US production can fall off a cliff and OPEC alone has plenty of spare capacity.
To fill that gap, so you know I'm not changing the story. I don't think at all. Not I mean believe me I would. I would gladly change the story if the data told me to.
But what has changed, just to summarize, is demand is going to be much lower, and we see now that there is plenty of spare capacity to fill the gap. So that that that that's that's the way I see things. Will oil price ever get much higher? Sure, it will at some point. But in the near term of the rest of this year and probably most, well, certainly the first half, if not all of next year, I would be very surprised to see oil break significantly out of the range boundaries that it's been in now for a couple of months.
Erik Townsend: Now, when we spoke in June, you expected that at some point, as demand did recover, it would set up a situation where, you know, demand Demand recovers fairly quickly. It's when planes start flying and diesel starts getting consumed and so forth. Of course, the US shale industry would respond to that and the rig count would come up, but there's a delay of several months. You expected that there was a necessary price spike in oil coming, because at some point demand resumes, drilling resumes, but the completion of wells is lagged by several months.
Art Berman: Right.
Erik Townsend: And that means there's an oil price spike. It sounds like you still expect that, but the expectation that we had that it might come as soon as Q4 is really pushed out to the second half of next year. Is that accurate?
Art Berman: Well, it is. And so when we talked last, I showed a graph that is in this slide deck. I believe it's slide number 11 that shows the correlation between the tight oil rig count which drives all of US production, and the lagged tight oil production. And that lag is something on the order of 10 to 12 months depending on, on which play you're specifically talking about. So, you know, the number of, number of wells drilled from a pad, the length of the laterals, the depth to the objective, all that figures in to make it a little bit longer, a little bit shorter for different plays. But But since we had that conversation, I have done substantial research to convince myself that that empirical fit is in fact legitimate, because it seems like a long time, and 12 months is a, is a huge lag. And so in the deck, looking at slide number 8, what I did here was I went into the database. This is for the Permian Basin.
This is for wells drilled in 2019 and '20 and just asked the question, queried the database, what is the time delay between beginning to drill a well, spudding a well, and first oil production? And the answer was about 5 to 6 months. Okay, looking then at slide number 9, this is a, a sort of a familiar display by now. Uh, which just shows the decline rates. Uh, this is again the Permian Basin, the decline rates of, of the what we call the vintage years, the wells that had first production in 2010 versus '11 versus '12, etc. And we all know they, they decline at rapid rates, and those rates seem to increase through time. Great, yada yada. But then I took that exact same data, and in slide 10 I deconstructed it to see exactly how each one of these vintage years of production increases and decreases.
And what I learned from this is that, okay, it takes 5 or 6 months between beginning a well and first production. This, this slide 10 shows that it takes about 5 or 6 more months before that production builds to a sufficient level to offset the decline of all the rest of the production. So in fact, something like 12 months is indeed legitimate. If you add to that that it takes about a month or 2 to get a rig once a price signal has told producers, okay, price is high enough, you know, we're talking at least a year here, Erik. And so that's the problem. The problem is, is that when the rig count is a third of what it needs to be, we could have everybody in the world write oil companies a check tomorrow and every oil company get on the phone and, and contract a rig tomorrow, and it would still be a year before there was enough production to make a difference.
Erik Townsend: Okay, now it's really coming together in my mind, Art. I want to just summarize this and make sure that I've got it right. What I'm hearing you say, if we go back to our conversation in June, we were talking about at some point At some point, we're going to see a resumption of normal demand. And when that happens, with the rig counts so low, it's a setup for a price spike to occur in oil. And it sounds like we're still saying that's true, but it's not yet. And what we should look for as investors is when we get to the point where it becomes clear that, okay, the economy is really restarting, we can expect demand to go back to normal or close to normal levels because all the planes are flying again, all the diesel's being consumed again. If we're still looking at rig counts of less than 300, say, then what it tells you is it's gonna take the shale industry a year to catch up.
And we know that it's not gonna take a year for demand to pick back up once it starts picking back up.
That's the point where you really expect, okay, now is time to speculatively go long and expect that big move up in price. Once the rig count really recovers back to where it's supposed to be, 600 or 700, that's where you start to say, okay, the industry is about to catch up. Maybe it's time to take profits on that long trade. That whole story doesn't start until sometime next year when we get back to normal demand expectations. Is that a good summary?
Art Berman: That's a perfect summary, Erik. And that, of course, is predicated on the notion that sometime next year we do in fact get back to that level. And I think that is, you know, again, I certainly hope that is the case. It would be good for everybody's business, including mine, if there were more business. So, you know, I'm sometimes accused of being pessimistic. And And that's that that's really not true. If the data tells me that it looks a certain way, that that's what I say.
But let's keep in mind something very important here, and that is that most of the the recovery in oil consumption has been driven by gasoline, and that wasn't meant as a pun. We we do drive with it, but and that's to be expected because the greatest portion of every barrel of oil is refined into gas. Gasoline, but back up a minute and and say well okay so where are people getting the money to buy gasoline? And the answer is they're getting money from in the United States from unemployment benefits, from you know paycheck protection, and all that is is going away or has gone away, and it doesn't look to me like anything is going to happen from the U.S. Congress until after this election, and so all of a sudden those people that were happily filling up their gas tanks and and buying goods. Let's face it, you know small goods consumer spending has recovered more quickly in this recession or depression than in any of the last five according to you know data I've looked at from from Pew Research.
But let's remember that a lot of that spending has been fueled by checks that come in the mail, and those have stopped. So that's, that, that, that's the concern.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'm going to share my own entirely conjecture-based prediction here, which is, first of all, I think it's probably going to take longer than most people expect before this is over, before we get to the point where the stage is set for demand to really resume. When it starts, I predict it is going to be vicious. I think that when you get people that have been cooped up for 18 months or 2 years or however long it's been at that point, and you tell them that they're allowed to go out and enjoy their liberty again, they're not going to look at the price of gasoline and say, hey, you know, let's not take the trip, the first trip that we've ever been allowed to take in the last 2 years because gasoline is $5 a gallon. It's a little expensive.
They're not even going to think twice. They're going to say, "We're getting the hell out of Dodge. We're going to go enjoy our vacation." And I think you'll see a very, very rapid increase in demand when the conditions permit that increase in demand to occur. And there's just no way that the oil industry will be able to keep up with the pace that that demand increase occurs on. And that's where you see the big up.
Sounds like it's probably the second half of next year at the earliest. And, you know, if there's no vaccine, it could be 5 years. But the longer we wait, my prediction is the bigger and more dramatic that spike in demand becomes.
Art Berman: And I agree with you notionally. Let's take a look at slide number 7, Erik. So this is showing all of the various components of oil demand. Of the refined products that come out of a barrel of oil. And so the, the big stack of, of columns on the left of center is total product supplied. So you can think about that as, as total consumption of, of oil.
And what that tells you is that we're at about 55% recovery. Recovery to date. This is as of last week, a week ago today, in fact, Wednesday's storage report. So on the one hand, you know, it kind of looks encouraging. On the other hand, we're only 55% from the low in April or whatever that was compared to the 5-year average. So, you know, when we look at the kinds of stuff that gets published in you know, the mainstream press, they're going to show you, oh well, gasoline or, you know, oil consumption is at 85 or 90% of normal. What that is is 85 or 90% relative to the 5-year average, but that's not what's important. What's important is how far have we come from the bottom, and that's what I'm showing here, and that's a, a much more diagnostic number.
Okay, so your argument that I agree with is that people are sick and tired of being at home, and they're going to get out, and they're going to fill up their cars, and they're going to drive. Well, this graph says they're already doing that. Look at gasoline on the left. Gasoline consumption has recovered 83% as of a week ago today. So gasoline consumption is, you know, it's not almost where it needs to be, but it's way ahead of everything else. Else. So they're already doing that to some extent.
Diesel— I've already explained why that's so important economically. 60%. It's only 60% recovered. Go down the, the chart to kerosene jet over near the right— 27%. Now, people, the, the response, the demand response to making major I'm not talking about, you know, ordering a new piece of electronics on Amazon. I'm talking about major equipment purchases, durable goods. That is not going to spring right back into action once everything is recovered. I mean, corporations are going to be very cautious about how quickly— I mean, they don't have the same pent-up sort of You know, angst that, that consumers do.
So I agree with everything you said, but let's be careful because as a petroleum geologist, I'm telling you that gasoline is not the only measure, and it's, it's the measure that has the least far to improve. You know, we're at 83%. Before the economy gets rip-roaring, we need to get diesel up from 60. We need to get jet kerosene up from 27.
Erik Townsend: I'm gonna go out on a limb here and disagree with you, Art. When you say it has the least far to go, you're— it sounds like you're assuming from 83% that you've only got 17% to get as far as you can go. That's— I assume 100% is previous, before the crisis numbers. I think you're gonna see a boom in travel and consumption, discretionary consumption of everything When people get unlocked and let out of prison, so to speak, I don't think we go back to 100%. I think we go back to— I don't know what the number is, but 100-something percent.
Art Berman: Well, that's, you know, 100% is, is again the difference between the low and the 5-year average. So we might go above the 5-year average for, you know, a certain amount of time, you know, a couple of months, maybe 6 months, whatever. But, you know, in the course of the year, The 5-year average is what it is, and it's going to average out as things always do. So, you know, I'm going to disagree with you there, Erik.
I don't think that, you know, maybe people start driving like crazy. I would be very surprised if people start traveling like crazy. I mean, there was a very good article. I can't remember. I think it was in the New York Times Sunday edition by Tomas Pueyo. This is the guy that you know wrote The Hammer and the and the Dance way back in March, which was by far the most accurate prognostication other than yours, of course, as to how COVID would affect things going forward. Well, Tomas has written another article just a week or two ago in which he explains that most of the resurgence of COVID Whether it be in US states or in countries around the world, is because of travel.
And this article's, you know, it's titled something like Build Fences. And so his point is, is that there is no way, even with a vaccine, that we're going to get control of this virus until we are very, very tight on letting people move across state boundaries in their countries and international boundaries, meaning quarantine. So I want to agree with you, but I, I think that, you know, discretionary travel will be limited by regulation, and it will be limited by people being afraid to, to take the risk.
Erik Townsend: Art, let's switch to slide 3 in your deck now, which of course is the comparative inventory chart. Any new listeners that we may have who are not familiar with this concept of comparative inventory and Art's system for forecasting oil prices, which has been incredibly accurate over the years, I encourage you to go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, type Art Berman into the search page, and look for some of Art's first interviews on MacroVoices where he describes and explains this comparative inventory system in detail. We're going to assume you understand the basics now.
Art, as we take a look at slide 3, I'm kind of curious. It seems like there's a trend here that, you know, the, the red curve, which was 2013, uh, or I guess it was 2014 through June of 2017, that red curve really showed a lot of price sensitivity to inventory. You had a change in comparative inventory of just a few thousand barrels, and boy, it could really do a number on prices. Then in the blue curve from July of 2017 through 2018, the end of 2018, on that blue curve, you know, it still was basically the same shape, but it was a lot less price sensitive to changes in inventory. Now it seems that we're into a new curve, a new yield curve, so to speak, which is the green one, 2019 and '20, that you have drawn in here. And it's showing even less price sensitivity to changes in comparative inventory.
Why is that? What's, what's going on here? And why is it that, that price is no longer as sensitive to comparative inventory as it used to be?
Art Berman: Well, that's a great question, Erik. And so first of all, some people say, well, the fact that you're your yield curve, your curve fitting, if you will, changes means that it, you know, that your method doesn't work. Well, okay, that's really kind of ridiculous because the bond yield curves change. Yeah, of course they do. You know, all these kinds of things change when the market reprices a commodity. It's just that simple. And so the red curve was, you know, originated in a time when oil prices were super high. We're over $100 a barrel for several years back in 2011 through 2014. And so there was a lot of urgency, and that's what that, that steep curve says. It says the market perceives a lot of supply urgency. So, you know, Libya goes offline, we lose a million barrels a day, and price of oil goes way up.
All right, so then we go to the blue curve, and this is after the price collapse. Perhaps in 2014 through '16, and the world says, well, you know, um, we don't feel quite the same sense of insecurity. And so, you know, maybe something happens like, uh, uh, Ghawar refinery gets bombed by whomever, Iranians or, or whoever. And what happened to the price of oil? It went up about $5 for a couple of days and then went back down. My goodness, if that would have happened in 2013, the price of oil would have gone to $200. Everybody would have said, oh my God, you know, we're losing the biggest oil fields in the world, the price has got to go to the ceiling. No, in, in, in April, uh, or I guess it was, uh, April of 2019 when that happened, price of oil went from, you know, like $60 to $65, no big deal, because oil had been repriced and the market knew there's a lot Lots of spare oil out there.
Well, once COVID came in and world demand dropped, the market repriced oil again. They said now we feel even less insecure about what interruptions in supply might mean. And so, you know, and that works both ways. So in other words, when that curve has a flat slope, as it does right now, then you can change comparative inventory by a whole lot. And it doesn't change the price very much. And that's exactly what we're seeing.
Erik Townsend: I'm going to go back to my prior prediction. I'm very curious if you'd agree with me. And admittedly, this is, this is all speculation at this point. But I think that when you get to the point— and clearly it's not now, it's, it's sometime next year or later than next year— when you get to the point where you fully reopen the economy, let's say there is an effective vaccine, you can go back to everybody can fly as much as they want to and and so forth.
I think we go back to a slope probably close to where the red curve slope was. And the reason I say that is, you know, right now, let's face it, if you have a deficit of supply in Cushing, Oklahoma, which would normally worry people about upside in oil prices, look, everybody knows that OPEC+ has plenty of spare capacity. They've been fighting with each other about, you know, who's in compliance and who's not in compliance with the cuts they've agreed to. We all know that they could turn up the volume if they wanted to.
If we get to a situation where you've still got a very low rig count, and all of a sudden demand is increasing exponentially, and you know that there's that 11 to 12 month lag time for US shale to catch up with demand, that's where I think you get back to that urgency. And everybody's saying, boy, if Cushing draws down, We don't know where we're going to get more oil to replace it. We got a problem, Houston.
That to me suggests that we're headed back towards a much steeper slope when everything is fully reopened, not just partially reopened. Would you agree with that?
Art Berman: So, Erik, I agree with you notionally. Everything you said is perfectly logical. And the question where I have some reservation is whether or not we can— not whether we want to— whether we can get back to full oil consumption. And I say that because we are, I believe, near the end of a 50 or 60-year debt cycle. And for those of you that don't believe me because I'm not an economist, you know, go read what Ray Dalio has for free on The Changing World Order on the And he talks about this at considerable length and with far more authority than I have. But the point is, is that debt productivity has gone to very low levels, and the level of debt is so high that we're at a point where, you know, we just can't do much more to goose the economy by creating money.
So looking at slide 13, this is a slide That is U.S., admittedly. Some people will chafe at that, but that's where the data is. And what this shows is is really two things: it shows credit growth or negative growth, and it also shows something which is called the credit impulse. And the credit impulse is just the change in flow of credit compared to economic activity or GDP.
And what we see in this graph. And it goes, you know, clear back to, uh, you know, to the 1960s. It's a very— I mean, this, this covers the whole debt cycle— is that the big spike, the blue spike that's on the right, uh, right underneath, uh, the text 2020, that was the positive credit impulse that has resulted from all the US government spending since COVID COVID. And that's the, the highest level of both credit impulse and credit growth, you know, in certainly decades. And now look what's happened in the second quarter. We've now gone to negative credit growth, one of the deepest negatives ever, if not the deepest. And we've gone to a very low level of credit impulse. And so what's happening, what this chart tells me, is that it's credit that runs the real economy.
And what we can anticipate, at least in coming quarters, is there going to be a whole lot less credit available because there already is to get the economy back to where it needs to be. So that's, you know, this can change and hopefully it does. But, you know, this is the data we have. And the data tells me that an economic recovery and an oil consumption recovery is not in the near-term cards. And you may be right, you know, that out there in 2021 all of this goes away, but I'm, I'm a little skeptical.
Erik Townsend: Art, I just want to compare the sentiment that you're expressing now because it seemed to me in June like you were really kind of saying, hey, look, you know, not yet, but, but once we get to Q4, you know, prices are going straight up, baby. And now you're saying, I'm not sure we're going to get back to to that full oil utilization. Now, I understand the logic of what you're saying, but how do I reconcile that with what I see in the EIA weekly data reports? Because frankly, we were— for a while, there were a lot of builds and everything. Now we're seeing consistent drawdowns on inventory, you know, basically bullish signals. Not super urgently bullish, but it seems like a trend is developing in the data that looks like it's, you know, a resumption of a bullish trend, which might take a while to play out, but it looks pretty bullish. On the other hand, you went from what felt to me like more bullish in June than you are now.
What's going on? Is the comparative inventory model not accurately forecasting the same things that the EIA models are forecasting, or what?
Art Berman: Another good question, Erik. So first of all, yeah, we've had like 2 months of comparative inventory and crude oil and everything else, withdrawals, meaningful drawdown by any measure you want, you know, for, you know, every week. This past week, the report that came out today was about half the average, but, you know, the week before was one of the largest reductions. So, so all that's, you know, all that's, that, that's very positive.
But what's driving that? Okay, we've already discussed that consumption isn't driving that. And when I say consumption, I mean domestic U.S. consumption, which is a little different than demand because demand includes exports. And so what I would argue here is a couple of things are going on. That if you look at, let's say, slide number four, slide number four shows. US crude imports— imports in red, exports in black, and net imports in the orange bars. And what you see is that net imports of crude oil have been decreasing consistently pretty much since the middle of June, since the last time we talked. Okay, so that means that we're importing less in exporting somewhat more. So this is driving the crude oil drawdowns. If we look at the next slide, which is 5, it's the same kind of slide except with refined product exports, imports, and nets. And so again, uh, you know, it's, it's mixed from week to week, but overall petroleum product exports have come back pretty strong.
So this is what is principally driving the drawdowns of crude oil and refined products, is that we're, we're sending it overseas either to places whose demand is stronger than ours, or— and this is key— to China. And I think what has changed in my thinking— it was in my thinking the last time we talked, but China has formed, uh, you know, call it a, uh, a buyer's club. You know, it's like Costco, it's, it's like, uh, Walmart. And, and what China has done, China has driven the crude oil recovery by buying tons of everybody's oil at very cheap prices. And that is what drove prices back from you know, the, the hubs of hell, you know, back up to $40 a barrel. It was largely the impulse of China buying. Well, China turns around and it dumps products on the world. And China's not alone in doing this.
They've got their friends and neighbors. And so what's, what's happening, I think, is this sort of colossal battle setting up between the world's producers, OPEC+, if you will, who have tried their best to dictate price to the market in one way or another now for 40 or 50 years, and the consumers of the world, the have-nots, who are mostly in, in Asia, who are saying, wait a minute, guys, um, we're the customers here.
You don't care about us. And so we're going to control the price of oil by our flow with our cash of buying crude and exporting products. And so we had a very nice rally that got us up to WTI of something like, you know, $43, $44.
And for no particular reason, it just went away. We went down below $40, at least no particular reason I could see other than sentiment. What was that sentiment about? That sentiment was about Oh my gosh, demand isn't recovering as quickly as possible. What was the root of that sentiment? China's not buying oil at the same rate they used to. So I think it's speculative right now to say that China has and its friends have effectively checked OPEC Plus. Not that OPEC Plus was hugely successful to begin with, but I think there's a force out there to be considered that is equally potent. in controlling oil price. Price gets too high, they just stop buying crude and it goes back down.
Erik Townsend: Art, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. Before I let you go though, I wanna just remind our listeners, if you're not already subscribed to all of the terrific free content at artberman.com, if you wanna see slides like these much more frequently, that's the place to get it. There's also a blog there. But Art, you've also expanded your services. When I first met you, you really only did consulting for, you know, producing oil companies. You help people drill oil wells and so forth. You weren't really offering services directly to investors, and that's changed in the last few years. Tell us a little bit more about your product offerings.
Art Berman: Sure, Erik. So I have a weekly offering. It's called Oil Comparative Inventory and Storage Report. Every week I tell my subscribers what I'm telling you right now, only in much, much more detail. And specific to this week's report. That's available for about $50 a month if you buy it on an annual basis. I do the same for natural gas, again once a week, same price. And then for those that are a little bit more casual in their interest in investing in oil, I've got a newsletter and rig count subscription which is about $200 a year.
You know, that tells you every week the details of how the rig count is being distributed across the shale plays and other plays, and a monthly letter that summarizes my sense of where the market, the oil market's going. So those are all available, but you're right, everything else is completely free. You gotta sign in, gotta give me your, you know, your login and a password, but it's absolutely free.
Erik Townsend: And our listeners can find more information about all of those services at artberman.com. Art, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message.
Erik Townsend: Message from our sponsor. Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade, but the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor. To invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with FarmTogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio.
You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was so great to have Art back on the show. It's always great to get an objective view on the oil markets, but I know that you have some additional opinions on crude. What, what's on your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, let's take a look at the November WTI futures chart in order to frame this discussion. Listeners, you'll find our postgame chartbook linked in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you haven't yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads right above Art Berman's picture.
As we look at this chart on page 2, we see, you know, the, the big sell-off all the way down. Now remember, this is the November contract, so even though the price of crude oil went all the way down to minus $37, that was isolated only to the May contract that went negative. The later contracts never got down. In this case, below about $24 was the low on the November contract, and it's recovered It recovered very briskly since then, right up into June. Art Berman pretty much almost to the day called the flattening out, and of course the price did still continue to drift a little bit higher, but not at nearly the, the same precipitous rate that it was recovering through May and June.
We had anticipated that there would be some kind of a sell-off or correction. Seems like that was beginning at the end of August, beginning of September, and it looked like, boy, it was much less than we thought. Now it looks to me like we really are headed back down. The correction is probably not over. I'm still targeting the low 30s for the short term in terms of this move. And as far as the longer term, I think at some point you definitely have a huge setup for a massive spike much higher in prices. That happens when economies around the globe get fully reopened, meaning that people feel comfortable traveling on airplanes, everybody is out and about and spending money. And my prediction is, and this is entirely speculation and conjecture on my part, but I think that this is gonna take longer than most people expect before there's a vaccine that meaningfully changes anything. Eventually, we're gonna get to the point where people have been cooped up for a couple of years and they don't care what the price of airfare is.
They're going to go out and travel and spend money. And I think there's going to be a very brisk recovery in energy prices at some point.
As Art described in this interview, I no longer think that that's necessarily going to happen in Q4 of this year, which was my original view. In fact, I think it's very unlikely that a big recovery in oil prices is coming in Q4. I think it's sometime in 2021, maybe the second half of 2021. At that point, by the end of 2021, I'll be surprised if we haven't touched at least $80 and maybe even $100 on WTI crude oil. But that would be if we get a full recovery of everything's back to normal. I'm not sure we're going to get a full recovery of everything's back to normal. Now, what Art said, the one place I disagree with him slightly, he said, Look, maybe you're gonna get the end of the crisis, but Art feels like we're at the end of a debt supercycle. I agree with him on that.
But wait a minute, if we're at the end of a debt cycle, what that's gonna mean is the shale patch is not going to be able to get the money they need to aggressively increase the rig count and increase US production.
And that's a setup for oil prices to really just make a moonshot to the upside. At least $80, maybe over $100 a barrel, I think is coming on WTI when you get a full reopening of the economy sometime later.
Well, what about between now and then? I think we're headed back down to somewhere between $30 and $33. The big question on my mind is what hits the tape first? Are we going to have the expected fall-off on US production that Art predicted, maybe that still happens in Q4 before we get any really deep, meaningful decrease in demand. In that case, I think it gets us up to new highs, maybe $45, $46, and maybe even upwards of $50 on WTI. On the other hand, if we see U.S. production continue to hold steady, but the demand situation continues to weaken, As we move into the end of this year and early 2021, then I think potentially you get a sell-off down to $26 again, which was the previous low going back to, to 20— was it 2015 or 2016? I think it was early 2016 was when we saw that $26 low. Strong technical level right there.
I think it's actually $26.08. So I think there's scope for potentially this sell-off that's begun to continue all the way down to $26. But that's only if US production continues to stay strong and demand continues to weaken. If US production falls off before we get those confirmations of demand weakening, I think there's plenty of room for more upside. So it's hard to really tell which way we're going in the next 6 to 9 months. I think as you get in the 9 to 18 month horizon, There's a pretty strong argument for higher prices, but obviously, the further out you go, the less conviction you can have, and we'll have to revisit those predictions as we get into the middle of 2021.
Meanwhile, Patrick, I do want to focus on the green box that you added to this chart. I assume what you're highlighting there is the volume profile in that green box. Well, gee, we got a breakdown below that green box just on today's candle in the chart.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: From a technical analysis perspective, what does that tell you as the technician in the house?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. Well, I mean, it's convenient that that also lines up where that big gap happened to occur on at least this November contract, which also lied around this $40 area. For me, the narrative was like, we had this big drop in September and we had a bounce, and the bounces are very natural. But in order for me to already be thinking that a new bull phase was underway, You wanted to see the price action beat something more than just a little Fibonacci bounce on the upside. So far, it was really a 3-4 day rally in early September, and it just rolled right over, and we're back down below there. That becomes now a key overhead resistance level. And right now, just very similar to what you're talking about, the likelihood that we still see a little more weakness coming down into the mid to low 30s on this November contract November contract, in my mind, is entirely possible. The areas to watch are the Fibonacci zones down in the $32 to $34 area, possible place where we could be heading if this, uh, does accelerate on the short term.
I remain optimistic or bullish the energy market over the longer term, but it may just mean that going into the elections into like November, December, oil may end up, uh, doing a lot of chop here and backfilling a lot of that rally off of the, uh, April
Erik Townsend: I agree, Patrick, and I think there's a lot of uncertainty because if you get the weakening demand from maybe a breakdown in economics and lowering demand expectations because of the contested election and the other things that are going on, yeah, definitely low 30s easy, and maybe in an extreme case, 26. On the other hand, if Art's original prediction about US shale Shale production really falling off a cliff in Q4. If that materializes, and now Art's hedging a little bit saying maybe at the end of Q4 or even into the beginning of 2021. Well, if that happens at the beginning of Q4, let's say during the month of October, if we go from 10.7 down to 8.7 million barrels of US production, I think we're back above $50 pretty quickly. So I could see this going either way from here, Patrick. But let's move on to page 3, S&P 500.
Erik Townsend: What do you see in this chart and what should investors think about what's coming next?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, first of all, page 3 is a chart in the past. We're looking at the 2018 Christmas massacre sell-off. And I wanted to put context on this because when we look at what we've been going through over the last 5 or so trading sessions is the stock market has been backfilling the initial market correction.
And a lot of people have this question: Was that it? I mean, could the market just start to rally from here? Is it all over, or is there more selling to come? And what I felt was relevant about the late 2018 market correction, which started in September of 2018, was it started in a similar fashion. It started with an 11% market correction that happened over 18 trading sessions.
And then we bounced, and the market bounced and retraced more than half of the prior sell-off. And it lasted for the the rally lasted for six seven days in a row. But really, what we ended up just seeing was over a month of just chop back and forth, whipping down, whipping back up, and then it ended with some very aggressive selling that ended up making this entire market correction. One of those 20-plus percent drops that lasted almost 3 months in total duration.
And I feel that this is an interesting roadmap. While the market will never correct the same way twice, it's an interesting roadmap or thought process of what would it look like if the current market correction played out that way.
And so when we go to page 4, we can see that this drop that we've gone through since the early September was that we've gone through 14 trading sessions and 11% correction. And since then, we've been now going on this like 5 days of market rallying off of the low, but we're not even 50% retraced the drop. And so the question I'm asking, you know, is there enough evidence to say that a legitimate short-term bottom is in? I, and I don't think so. I think the market here is still highly vulnerable that once this reflexive bounce off of that oversold condition finishes, the market is still vulnerable for at least another trip back down to the low. And if the elections add some new additional volatility, which is entirely possible, that trip still down to 3,000 on the S&P is entirely on the table in my mind.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as I said in the market wrap at the beginning of the show, if there's a way to figure this out and of get an idea of what's coming. It's to figure out the US dollar first. Let's move on to page 5. You're looking at the dollar against the euro. Now, looks like we've got a pretty clear head and shoulders pattern here. What's this tell you?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So let's go back to the title of the whole presentation, which is that, is the reflation trade over? And one of the greatest drivers, or the largest precipitating driver of a reflation narrative, is a bearish dollar. And we typically will see a dollar declining, and the byproduct of that is all the cross currencies are doing very well, and more importantly, all the commodity markets are doing very well, which drives an inflationary impulse and gets all of that start being priced in. And so what's interesting is there's no shortage of technicians out in FinTwit that are observing the head and shoulders or rounding top there. They The old call it a different thing, but ultimately it's a period where the euro has paused that advance. And really the question that we're asking, was that a legitimate top? Because what's interesting about corrections is often simply a natural zigzag wedge correction in a prior rise can often be deceptively, from a technical perspective, look like a head and shoulders pattern.
And we're such at a critical moment, an important crossroad to determining whether or not this dollar move is legitimate. And one of the biggest things for all of our MacroVoices listeners to be watching in the coming week or two is will the euro fail to beat 118 on the upside? I mean, if we can see the euro beat 118 and get back into that range of where the topping formation was in the 119 range, give or take, take, then that kind of neutralizes this topping formation. And then we have to really actually table the idea that the dollar sell-off may not be over. At the same time, if we see by early next week that this is rolled right over and we're heading to 116 or lower on the euro,
Patrick Ceresna: that basically you can start grabbing a handful of nails to put in the coffin on the, um, euro bull trade.
And that, I think, is going to be one of the single biggest
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, another aspect of this reflation trade is commodity prices. We've seen a pretty significant rally in a lot of commodities, including copper, going back to, you know, the March lows as the coronavirus crisis was kind of bottoming out. Seems like we've broken the trend line here on page 6 of the chart book. What does that tell you?
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so it's interesting because we were talking about the crude oil chart, and crude oil is the most important commodity to watch. Watch from an impact on inflation. But copper is also a really good bellwether you can kind of keep an eye on. And some people are saying that this was influenced by the Chinese holiday, but to me it's no coincidence that this break is happening in line with when we're seeing the dollar strength and weakness in a lot of other commodities. And so to me, with the fact that the copper is breaking down here, oil's breaking down, it's going to continues to support the idea that at least at minimum, we've paused the reflation trade. And more importantly, the one big thing to ask is that, is it actually legitimately over where for several months we may just be backfilling all of these prior rallies that have been in place since March?
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 7, you've got silver as opposed to gold to represent the precious metals complex here in this reflation discussion. Why silver?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I just think that we talk gold so much and we've covered it in the market wrap that I figured we'd just take a look at its little cousin. And what's interesting is that that sell-off in silver, which was pretty aggressive on the downside, stalled pretty much right at the 61.8 retracement of its summer rally. And often it brings in buy signals and turns things around. But this is the, the same sort of storyline on the upside towards $25, the same way the euro is in terms of a move back toward 118. While we certainly have bounced from a very oversold condition, I think as early as next week's show, we're going to start to see whether or not this was just a bounce or whether there was a legitimate short-term trading bottom that was established here. And so, uh, I'm watching this as to whether silver can actually put something together north of $25.
But the longer we stay just consolidating down below here, there might still be one more trip lower in, in the commodity.
Erik Townsend: And to give us a broader perspective on commodities, we've got the Bloomberg Commodity Index on slide number 8. And boy, that really is looking like at the end of August there, like maybe a top and the beginning of a new With a series of, you know, lower highs and lower lows.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, that's exactly it. And this is the single biggest puzzle piece, like you were saying earlier, was the dollar. What it's going to come down to is, has the dollar established a short-term bottom? And are we going to see a US dollar that strengthens into the elections? I think that commodities will have a very hard time to buck the trend that the dollar establishes. And I think that's going to be the one key thing to watch through all of this. And that's definitely what I'm going to be keeping my eye on. But one of the things I wanted to really show on page 9 was the 30-year breakevens. And so this really shows where the market is anticipating inflation. And obviously when the dollar peaked, we saw that at the same time that corresponded with where the lows on these inflation expectations came in in that early March. March, and since then, this the 30-year breakevens have been an upwards pattern.
What's interesting is that we put in that high last month on this, and right now we're trading more or less, or at least attempting to bounce down up to about the one spot seven eight on these 30-year breakevens. And one of the key things I'm going to be watching is when do the markets start to price in the commodity correction? Because I think that if the crude oil and copper and all of these other commodities continue the trends that were established this week, then we will start to see this reflect in these breakevens. And I think that's the one thing to keep a very close eye on.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, thanks for another terrific post-game chartbook. Listeners, if you want to get a similar chartbook from Patrick every single day instead of just once a week, be sure to check out his service, Big Picture Trading. The information for getting a free trial of that service is on page 10 of your chartbook or at bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by FarmTogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors. And by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at TopTradersUnplugged.com.
For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Art Berman's slide deck and the chartbook that we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to a Variant Perception blog on the ECB's focus shifting to bank lending, as well as a link to Jesse Felder's article, It's Time to Get Greedy in the Energy Sector. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter. Twitter, and we will include it in our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Erik Townsend: Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account today.
Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to provide you with valuable information. be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll Answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily. Reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading dot com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Alex Gurevich — HonTe Investments CIO (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 238 was recorded a day early this week on Wednesday, September 23rd, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors. We've got a MacroVoices doubleheader on tap for you this week, folks. First, HonTe Investments CIO Alex Gurevich joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss Treasury yields and whether the US 10-year can move to negative nominal yields, whether a secular shift to inflation is afoot, Whether the US dollar has begun a secular decline, and Alex's model for predicting stock prices based on historical bond yields, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Bianco Research founder Jim Bianco joins Patrick and me in the postgame segment when we'll take a deep dive into the election polls and compare these figures to betting markets.
I'm going to be making some very bold predictions about civil unrest escalating after the election, so be sure to stay tuned for those as well.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to the S&P 500. Some people were speculating that that Monday was going to be a low, and it didn't take long for us to be almost right back down to the week lows. Do you think we head lower from here? What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, clearly what we saw this week was more selling. You know, the, the rally that people thought was coming to reverse this didn't happen. On the other hand, we're not crashing either. I really think that the election civil unrest story is going to be Probably the most important thing to understand. The crazy part is I can't figure out whether it's good or bad. I mean, certainly it ought to be bad, but of course it's always possible that expectations of more Fed stimulus will cause any dip to be bought and, uh, you know, another rally ensues. I want to definitely get into this more with Jim Bianco, but before we go on, I'm curious. I think you guys at Big Picture Trading were playing this with that straddle strategy. How's that playing out? What are you guys up to?
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, we remain short the market. We didn't, uh, cover on the bounce, and so we're still looking for a further breakdown in the market. I think, uh, at this stage, a trip down towards 3,000 is entirely possible and something that we're continuing to monitor here on a day-in, day-out basis in our webinars to kind of just get an idea of whether that momentum is in the market for that one more downdraft. Nonetheless, Erik, let's talk the US dollar because, uh, we got a breakout. Uh, is this for real?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I had been waiting for a daily close over $94 before saying that maybe we're actually seeing a change in direction as opposed to just a consolidation. Looks like we're getting that today. We're actually speaking a little bit before the close, but we're looking at $94.35 on the December contract as we speak, almost at the end of the session on Wednesday afternoon. Looks to me like we're going to get that close. Now, is this a, a real secular reversal, or is it just a bounce here? I think that's That's still undecided. We'll see what comes, but I also think it's important to consider this in the context of what may be on the horizon in terms of escalating civil unrest and the election bringing maybe some more downward pressure on the dollar. We'll save the discussion of that for Jim Bianco in the postgame segment.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because we obviously had a pretty good bounce at the tail end of last week, a little bit of a rollover here. Do you think oil has one more trip down to the mid-30s, or is it still a buy on dip here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I'm really on the fence. As I said in last week's show, we had what technically was a breakout to the upside last week, but I said beware of a reversal because I think what caused that breakout was a lot of jawboning by OPEC. And, you know, maybe that's more propaganda than reality. Sure enough, we got a stumble, but it wasn't really a reversal of direction. We didn't see that breakout continue. We saw it retrace a bit, but You know, we still only got back down to the bottom of the short-term moving averages and now we're consolidating again.
Inventory helped to fuel a relief rally this week. We got a drawdown in crude oil in 1.6 million barrels. Now, that was after API, the private data service, had reported a build the day before. So a drawdown should be bullish to start with, but especially when it comes on expectations that were set the day before of possibly a build and it turns out to be a draw, that supported the market. But, you know, even as much as that caused a bounce in price, it came back out before the close on Wednesday afternoon. Cushing, Oklahoma, building a de minimis 4,000 barrels. Gasoline and distillates both drawing down substantially— 4 million barrels on gasoline, 3.4 million barrels on distillates. US production ticked down 200,000 barrels per day to 10.7 million barrels per day. That's exactly where we stood before the tropical storm hit the Gulf. So we haven't seen the big decline of production that Art Berman said to expect in Q4.
But then again, it's not Q4 yet. It's going to be Q4 pretty soon. So, we ought to get Art Berman back on the show pretty soon to talk about whether or not he is still forecasting a dramatic decline of US production in the final quarter of the year. But it certainly hasn't materialized yet.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to gold because, well, you're getting the dip. Are you going to buy it?
Erik Townsend: Oh, I'll buy it. The question is how much of a dip and at what levels do you buy it? So until today, we were stuck in that descending triangle pattern. And we just today saw a decisive breakdown below that $1,900 level that would have been the bottom of the triangle. The next target that I have is just over $1,800, maybe $1,812 or so is where I see the level. I might start buying a little bit above that around $1,820 or so. There's a caveat, which is $1,859 is the 100-day moving average. Maybe I'll be proven wrong again and, you know, we'll find that the bottom comes at the 100-day moving average and we never get back down to that support level I'm looking for. I've got resting limit orders starting around $1,825 or so to buy more.
Now, if we want to go and look at this from the other perspective, which is how deep could the correction go, I think the deepest correction you could possibly expect or hope for would be back down to $1,377 which was the top of the major breakout zone that we never really did come back and test as support. Frankly, at this point, I'll be surprised if we get back down to that level. If we did, I'd certainly be buying hand over fist there, but I'm gonna start buying around 1,825 and buy some more if we get down to 1,800.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because you would think with this market volatility, dollar breakout, all of these things happening, that this would even have a pulse, but it looks like we're stuck in this sideways range for the yield. It's like dead like a corpse. Do you think we finally break out here?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, as our longtime listeners know, Treasury yields lately have been a subject where I just really haven't had a whole lot of conviction. So, I'm going to answer your question and the next question, which is, why did we bring Alex Gurevich in, with one answer. What's the story on Treasury yields? It's the most important thing to understand. What's the answer? I don't understand it. What am I going to do about that? Get Alex Gurevich on. One of the best bond guys and just really visionary macro thinkers. Long-term picture, you know, big picture kind of guy. We've got some really really smart people that come on the program like Charlie McElligott. But, you know, Charlie is usually looking at what's happening this week or this month in the market. Alex is a really big picture kind of guy. And I think that to answer these questions about the 10-year yield, can it go negative? Are we facing a return to secular inflation, of course, which has a major impact on the bond market?
And also, where is the US dollar headed? We really have to understand all those things in a concerted You know, logical framework of what's going on and where the macroeconomy is headed. I think Alex is a terrific guy, and it's been— I was surprised— almost a year since we've had him on the program. So I'm really looking forward to this one with Alex.
Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure. Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test.
But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Alex Gurevich is coming up next as MacroVoices continues. Right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is HonTe Investments founder and fund manager, Alex Gurevich. Alex, I am really, really looking forward to this interview with you specifically, because as our regular listeners know, and I know you're a regular listener to yourself, you know, there's 3 macro questions that I, number one, am convinced you have to answer in order to understand where we are at this particular moment in markets. And number two, which I personally have no clue what the answer is, and that's why I rely on smarter people than myself, such as you. So let's just recap those. Our regular listeners already know these. The first is, okay, here we are. At almost zero interest rates. We've been below 50 basis points. We're back up to wherever we are this week, 60, 75, whatever. We've been close enough to zero that if you believe there is a zero bound on the US 10-year, then by definition, the 38-year bond bull market has to be ending.
So is it ending, or is it true that negative rates are possible? And if so, how negative are they possible? Question number 2, are we on the cusp of a secular shift from disinflation toward inflation? And if so, could it be as big as the inflation that began in the late 1960s? And particularly, if that is true, is that something that really starts to run away in 3 to 6 months or 3 to 6 years? How long does it take for that inflation shift to happen, if it's happening? And finally, number 3, US dollar. Are we looking at the beginning of a secular decline as some people have predicted, or is this just noise that we've seen so far? Where do you want to start with those 3 big issues, Alex?
Alex Gurevich: Okay, well, first, it is very good to be back. It's always a pleasure. And the questions you're asking are, of course, paramount and central to understanding at least US markets. But as always, US markets are central to understanding the whole world. So, I would probably like to start with first 2 questions because they're very interlinked. And the 3rd question regarding the dollar is definitely also connected with the first 2. But let me first think through the interest rate market.
One of the things that I believe really helps long-term profitability is looking at historical pattern. The power of historical pattern never ceases to surprise me. An example of that would be just to step aside for a second. I even posted that tweet, and it got a lot of reaction. I said, somehow, the inverted yield curve in 2019 has predicted the COVID recession. We don't know how we did it, but somehow we did it.
So, when certain things happen, then certain things happen after them. And that is the pattern. They don't have to happen every time, but they skew the probabilities quite a bit. So, when I'm looking at the pattern of US interest rate behavior, What I've seen in the past is when there is a recession comes, we have shock, rates fall dramatically, usually in a steepening fashion.
Then there is some relief, liquidity, things get better. And then very quickly, market reprices actually into a new wave of tightening, as if like, which actually quite irrationally reprices into tightening. That happened both in '09 and '01, '02, that after recession, markets started to think like, oh, rates are going to go up in a few months again. That actually never happens. And that's a great opportunity to bet against rates going up in the near future. And then we have a second wave, then, well, we're not actually out of the woods, we're muddling through. Stock market starts a new grinding bear market and rates really go down.
This would be my instinct to look for that, but we already have a lot of divergences from this pattern. First of all, the original rates rally was much more flattening than it is historically. Even to my surprise, the curve moved much more in parallel. And stock market did not really act the way it usually acts. If people looked for a second wave of sell-off, maybe it is coming, but it definitely was not in a hurry to come, with new highs being made. And everything just looks funky and different in this environment. And we could touch about what things are different, but it is still important to remember that massive sell-offs, massive sudden sell-offs in fixed income markets happen at that juncture.
And that doesn't answer your question whether we can go to negative rates, but this is just a word of warning that even if you do think that we're going to go to negative rates, there is a scope for sudden, very rapid sell-off in the US fixed income market, which could be— eventually will trigger accelerating convexity sell-off. I have not seen it yet, but it might happen. So, that's the first caveat.
The second caveat, obviously, we know that there is a lot of resistance to introducing negative interest rates in the United States. It may or may not happen in the future. Honestly, it is hard for me to say, but I am increasingly thinking that we might be able to muddle through without negative interest rates. And that links to your second question.
Do we have to have a catastrophic rise in inflation That is definitely something that is being discussed, because sooner or later, if you make more of something, it loses value. If you make more dollars, cash dollars, sooner or later, cash loses value. So far, all of this loss of value was loss of value in terms of assets. That is, cash has been devalued relative to assets. It has not been actually devalued relative to services yet in any meaningful manner.
But I think there is a scope for that. In the environment of limited supply of services, and a lot of fiscal and monetary impulse actually letting people spend money and some pent-up demand for services. Because even though you can make an argument that people cannot have dinners out for all the dinners they missed over the last 6 months, but still, if you let people go out now, they will spend probably more than they would normally spend because they will be like, yeah, I want to catch up on my travel. I want to catch up on seeing my friends. I want to catch up on all my favorite venues. Venues, and all of a sudden, they see all those venues operating at 25% capacity, that does create some supply logjam.
So, whether it is real inflation, inflation to be concerned as hyperinflation, but in terms of showing up in headline numbers, I think there is a lot of scope for high inflation showing up in headline numbers. In this environment, will the Fed really need to lower rates? I don't think they need to go below zero if we're showing high inflation headlines. Staying here would be pretty easy.
And in this way, I am totally in agreement with your recent guest, Juliette Declercq, who I have a lot of respect for in terms of her intellectual framework, that real rates could go way, way down. We could very easily see 3% headline inflation, 3% headline inflation, and meanwhile, Fed staying very close to zero.
This is not saying that I think that hyperinflation is unavoidable, but it is saying that headline inflation at least has very large scope to tick up. And in this environment, yes, we might have seen the end of the rapid bull market, because if inflation goes back up, there is really no reason for Fed to become any easier.
Furthermore, very surprisingly, it's a contrary way of thinking, but I think if inflation does go higher than we think, and there is overheating going on on that side, there might be some scope for interest rate hikes even before people think.
And this goes back to my old thesis that I even put forward in my book, which was written 5, 6 years ago. There is a negative predictive power to interest rate markets. Whenever interest rate markets predict hikes in the future, like not in the immediate future, because usually, the policy predictions are correct for the first 3 or 6 months, But policy predictions out to 3 or 4 years, usually, whatever the market predicts, the opposite happens.
When in the past, market predicted rapid returning to tightening environment, that never happened. Nowadays, the market predicts us staying at zero forever. Maybe we'll be surprised and the hiking environment will come sooner than we think.
And the last caveat, again, to throw another wrench in this perfect machine, if you look actually at the 30-year bonds instead of 10-year bonds, The yield is still fairly high, 1.4% relative to global bonds. And there is quite a bit of price appreciation left if they do happen to go to zero.
That's because of convexity, or if they go negative, then of course, all bets are off. They could still double in price.
That makes the betting on interest rates in the US somewhat complex, even if you have a bias towards My bias right now is towards high inflation, but also Fed staying put, which means that it's hard to make money in the long run by shorting bonds. It is risky to be long them. It is risky to be short them.
And even the very simple carry trades, like buy 7-year sector and carry it because rates will not go up in the next 7 years, I don't think they're entirely safe. I don't know if it helps at all or not, because I just throw stones in every single direction.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the 3rd big question, US dollar. Are we looking at the beginning of a secular decline, as some people have predicted and opined, or is this just noise that we're seeing right now?
Alex Gurevich: I think the dollar decline is quite reasonable and expected. And I would think that, again, looping to what I spoke before, Given that if we go into this paradigm of very negative interest rates in the US, if we continue going through very easy policies, I think that there is a lot of— and based on historical pattern, I think there is a scope for further dollar decline. I am a little bit reluctant yet to call the major secular bear market on dollar, but I think there is at least a cyclical bear market on dollar. I think we're in it, and I don't think we're done. That is, in my mind, it is very reasonable for euro, for example, to go to 130, 135 level.
It is not a high conviction for me, but if you put a gun to my head and ask me, Erik, where is it going to be next, 135 or parity? I'll say 135. So, I think it is very much aligned with everything that I see for dollar to continue its It's bear market.
And one of the counterarguments to dollar bear market is a kind of cleanest dirty shirt argument, the argument that, well, other countries are also debasing their currencies. Yeah, that's true. But I also— again, I'm sorry, I'm kind of parroting one of your recent podcasts, but I'm also agreeing with Juliette's view that it's much easier for US to debase its currency than for other countries. There is more scope for debasement on one side. On the other side, there are still forces of current account which are working against the dollar right now.
And there is also— dollar benefited over the last few years a lot from capital account surplus, that is money flowing in US Treasury bonds and US stocks from overseas. And that has been a bit maybe overdone. And maybe with this flow reversing, it could be dollar negative as well. So, I think there is definitely a scope for another 10%, 10%, 15% on dollar decline. And then there is a scope for a more pronounced and bigger bear market even.
I do not yet see the dollar completely collapsing relative to other currencies, but I do see potential for strong rise in precious metals, which is also a form of being short dollar because precious metals— this is something that I talked on the podcast a year ago, precious metals, I expressed when you're long gold, in dollars, you are by default short dollars when you're buying gold.
So, if you feel it like, well, other currencies might be debased as well, then precious metals complex is a good place to go to express continued short dollar view. And this is the way I'm leaning.
Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on that conversation that we had, boy, almost a year ago. You talked at that time about the connection between bonds and gold, and you talked specifically about the denominator issue of the dollar in understanding the gold price. Why don't we For the benefit of any new listeners who didn't hear that interview last November, give us a quick recap of what the conversation is about, and then give us an update on your perspective and how it's changed since the last time we spoke to you.
Alex Gurevich: Yeah. So, last time the conversation started with a discussion that I heard from a lot of sources when people were puzzled by the fact why dollar was performing well relative to other currencies, and meanwhile, gold was performing well as well, because historically, it seemed to people that there is this negative correlation between gold and dollar. And what I pointed out, that there is no real meaningful negative correlation. It's what I call a pathological correlation. The correlation between gold and dollar just stems from the fact that gold is, as it trades, expressed in dollars.
While if gold was trading in euros, there would be no correlation between gold price and dollar. Well, I don't know, maybe there would be, but I don't see it necessarily happening. So, there is a difference one must draw between meaningful correlation and just pathological correlation, which doesn't give any new information.
So, you cannot just assume that because dollar is a well-performing currency, gold cannot be even a better-performing currency. So, in this case, in 2019, dollar performed well. It was one of the better currencies, and gold performed even better, being an even better currency. So, that's all that meant that both dollar and gold went up. And there is no rule or mathematical principle why both of those currencies could not be performing well.
And this is definitely shifting this year when gold is still a better-performing currency and dollar no longer is.
So, all the more reason. So, while in 2019, it made sense to me while I was long gold, but in reality, The dollar was taken out of that equation for me because I was long gold in terms of dollars, but I was long dollars in terms of other currencies. So, what I was really long is gold in terms of Swiss franc, Japanese yen, or any other— or Australian dollar, mostly currencies that I really wanted to be short. This year, I'm more inclined to actually be long gold and silver versus US dollars.
So, that is a shift of the discussion. I think there was an interesting thing that I said back then that I got quoted on, though it was maybe slightly misquoted. What I said during the interview, the way people quoted me, that I said, when you're listening to this interview, you should hit the pause button now and go just buy gold.
Don't even listen to the end of the interview. You have to go buy gold. What I was really saying is that not that an investment advice that people should buy gold, but what I was saying is that if you espouse a certain view, and that was the view that was expressed by you, which was expressed by Grant Williams, I think, who you talked to at that time, about the long-term prospects of gold. What I was saying that if that is the view you have, you should just pause, click the pause button and go buy gold.
Because the future and the path of gold was very uncertain. And even before COVID we had a lot of shakeups and weird things happening lots of ways. If you were not in the trade, you could have been stopped out of the trade or stopped in on the trade multiple times.
Erik Townsend: That call proved remarkably prescient, Alex. People who paused your interview and bought gold did incredibly well. Now, as we fast forward— that was November of last year— as we fast forward to this week, gold has been consolidating for the last couple of months almost. And just on an intraday basis today, temporarily, gold poked its head down below some technical support levels, although it's back above them as we're speaking now on Monday afternoon. Is it still, uh, that kind of, boy, just pause the interview, buy gold, don't think twice? Or has gold already moved up so much that maybe it is time to think twice before adding to a gold position in this current market environment?
Alex Gurevich: I think this is definitely a good time to have a position that you want to have, whether from a technical perspective you choose that this is the spot to add or not. That is not really my strong specialty level because I'm not very good at technicals. And very often when things go against me by a few percent, I actually actually choose not to add because I don't want to be in a position of it falling further and putting undue pressure on me. Like, if my portfolio or position is already under pressure, depending upon how much risk space I have, I might add on the pullbacks, or I might just try to sit it out and not put myself in a more difficult position.
And I would also point out that when I say gold, it's my euphemism for the whole precious metal complex that includes silver, platinum miners, mining stocks. And I think investors should do their own analysis and choose which of those assets they like best. But those are all assets that benefit from increased liquidity.
I think that it is quite reasonable for this complex to consolidate. It has consolidated before in the previous markets, and the previous bull markets took us much further in relative terms. And I see no reason why this bull market would not. Of course, there are many ways It may fail, but the probabilities, I think, are skewed still to this bull market continuing much further. And my bias is towards not only gold seeing new all-time highs, but silver seeing new all-time highs, and eventually platinum seeing new all-time highs, and related mining stocks seeing all-time highs. And all of them are very far away from those. So, from that perspective, I'm just cautioning gold looks actually expensive relative to the rest of the precious metals complex, and it typically leads it in the bull market. So, maybe it is time for gold to consolidate and some other things to pick up the torch.
Erik Townsend: Alex, you're mostly known as a bond guru. That's why I wanted to start with the questions about bonds, interest rates, and US dollar and so forth. But in this environment, everybody's got their eye on the stock market, and as we're speaking on Monday afternoon, We're seeing a new wave of selling causing some people to panic and say, okay, this is it. This is the big one. The, the, the big rally that we had off of the COVID lows that took us to new all-time highs, that was just a bear market rally on steroids that went to new all-time highs, but we're actually headed lower than the, uh, the March low. And, uh, today's the big day where it all falls apart. I know that while equities are not usually Your specialty, Alex. Talking to some of your staff, they sent us a chart that I want to share with our listeners. Listeners, you'll find a download link in your Research Roundup email.
If you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Look for the red button above Alex's picture. It says, looking for the downloads. Can you talk to us about this chart, Alex, and how you see the situation for equities? And are people right to be thinking, okay, we're about to have a crash of the stock market?
Alex Gurevich: I start with going back to what I already mentioned a couple of times in this interview, talking about historical pattern. And indeed, if you look at the regular historical pattern, it would be very likely that sometime about now, or even earlier, or a little later, we'd start a new wave of bear market.
And because that has happened several times in the past, I'm assigning a pretty high probability to that happening. There is nothing particularly about today as a day that looks to me that today should be a turnaround day. There have been a few, even in this recent pretty relentless bull market, there were a few pullbacks.
But I can see how looking at the charts and momentum indicators, you could see that stock market is beginning to lose momentum. And I'm appreciative of that. But in itself, it does not hugely worry me unless I take into account the general pattern of studying starting the second wave of bear market, and top it off with election anxiety, possibility of uncertain election outcomes, and all of those things, and just generally bad seasonality, at least for the immediate future. You combine all of this, and I can see some anxiety around it.
What I think was unusual about this cycle and why equities acted in a way which befuddled many people buyers, recovering so quickly and going up so far is the difference in liquidity.
In a moment, I will explain how it ties up to the chart I'm talking about. If we go back to a very fundamental question, why stocks go down in recessions at all? Why do stocks go down? Because, of course, every recession affects very hard some specific sectors. For example, the global financial crisis meaningfully hit bank stocks, and some of them, like Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, Never came back. Some of them, like Citibank, got diluted beyond hope.
In this recession, obviously, various travel-related, hospitality-related stocks got hit really hard, and some of them might be not coming back ever. They declared bankruptcy. They had the equity wiped out or not wiped out for some reason. That's a separate conversation, but probably will be. However, when you look at stock market as a whole, for other companies, companies which survive down cycles shouldn't actually be valued any differently in recession than otherwise. If anything, low interest rates should offer them support for their long-term discount models, and the death of their competition makes the moats only deeper.
But we never saw it before, but we see, at least not so immediately and strongly as we see it in this cycle, where the companies with moats started to actually perform extremely well right away. So, why intellectually, if you have companies with ongoing multi-decade concerns. We see people saying like this, look at whatever, how unreasonable it is that stocks are performing so well relative to blah, blah, blah, where the economy is, where the GDP is, where the employment is. But why did connection exist to begin with?
My framework is that it exists because of liquidity. What happens in recessions is that liquidity dries out, and hence, people have less money to buy stocks. I can't really go through all the mechanisms of that, but you can imagine it. Less money to buy stocks, there are always sellers, stocks go down. It has nothing to do with any intellectual long-term projection for stock market. But that pattern became so pervasive that people starting to trade that pattern, that in recession, stocks should go down.
What happened in this recession, there was indeed a liquidity shock, very short, which really crested in March, but the policy response was so unprecedented that liquidity shock was reversed into positive liquidity shock. And all of a sudden, people started looking at stocks and saying, well, whether rationally or irrationally, as a system acting as one irrational, one beast that just mechanically responds to impulses, but the cohort of investors decided that, well, looking through, COVID will be gone.
This whole pandemic will be over, but there is this ocean of liquidity in the market, and their discount rates are low, and companies with good moats will just continue staying in business. So, why not buying them at a higher price? And that's what started to happen. So, that is, to me, the explanation of why people were so befuddled by rising stock markets.
And this is going back to our earlier conversation when I mentioned the fact how cash— we are having inflation already in the form of cash being devalued relative to other asset classes. And that totally makes sense because a lot of cash is being printed. The supply of cash is increasing relative to other asset classes. So, cash is an asset class, which is, by the way, not a risk-free asset class. It's just as risky as any other asset classes.
Cash is only risk-free as measured in cash. If you measured cash in Bitcoin, cash would be very risky. If you measured cash in gold, it would be very risky. If you measured cash in stocks, it would not only be risky, but continuously declining asset class, like an awful asset class to be in.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Alex Gurevich: reversed it and saw that stocks are your benchmarks, and look how your cash is performing. And you look at several hundred years of performance, would you ever want to hold this asset? Probably not, not even when it looks technically good.
So, that risky cash asset became in oversupply, and it started to go down against every other asset. So, people who try to short stocks and whatever name those stocks, even if they short some stocks that they think are tremendously overvalued, They are shorting Tesla, for example, and think Tesla is overvalued, or whatever else they hate.
They're selling stocks of that company, but what are they asking for it? They're not asking gold for it. They're not asking buildings for it. They're asking US dollars for it. They get US dollars. And by doing this, by definition, whenever you are shorting, selling a stock and asking for dollars, basically, you are going to the Federal Reserve and asking them, Please, can I have some of your dollars?
Please, can you give me some of this asset that you can print out costlessly in as much quantity as you want? And what does the Federal Reserve do? They say, please, have your dollars as much as you want to. Oh, you want to short some more? Here's some more dollars for you.
Now, what do you think is going to happen to this asset class in this situation? When there is no resistance from the Fed from supplying dollars to all people who want to have dollars instead of assets, clearly, sooner or later, the dollar will decline on average with regards to most assets.
So, in fact, what I did in my second quarter investor letter, I did this experiment when I replaced the word cash dollars by the word Beanie Babies. And then I started to rewrite typical investment statements by using the word Beanie Babies instead of dollars, because Beanie Babies is a classic example. They're almost costless. You can produce them, as many as you want of them. They could be in vogue, but do they have to be in vogue forever? But if an asset manager is saying, you know what, I'm being really prudent right now, I'm keeping all my portfolio in Beanie Babies and waiting for things to stabilize. And when they stabilize, I'll have plenty of chances to sell my Beanie Babies and buy gold, or stocks, or real estate. Maybe I'll miss the absolute bottom, but I know I'll always be safe in Beanie Babies.
So, that sounds totally ridiculous.
The same ridiculousness occurred with cash. And it happened twice in history. It happened in March '09, when people piled into cash and got nailed. And they piled into cash in 2020 and got nailed. And I would argue that being in cash at times like this could be viewed as violation of fiduciary responsibility, because you put all your money in an incredibly risky asset that is currently being
Alex Gurevich: devalued.
Now, from this philosophical speech, I want to go to the chart. The interesting thing about this chart that I posted is that I created it in 2014 by trying to understand how liquidity changes and interest rates affect stock market. And if you look at the chart, there are this blue line and orange line, and they go up to the shaded area. The reason why I separated shaded area is that's how far I published the chart when I wrote my book.
And what was happening after was— so, the chart was fitted back then, and it was incredibly crudely fitted. It's just a point different. I'll explain what it is in it, but before I'm explaining what the chart does, I'll just say that it was just the first very simple, crude, not calibrated analysis. And even that very crude analysis provided a very good fit, which continued for the next several years.
So, there is a blue line on this chart, is the momentum on interest rates. What it tells us where 10-year yield is now relative to where it was 2 years ago. So, if the yield is higher, we go into negative area. If the yield is lower, we go into the positive area. So, positive momentum on yields is when yields have fallen down. So, then blue line goes above zero, On the right side of the chart is a scale for the blue line. On the left side is a scale for the orange line.
And what orange line does, orange line does, it's 2 years shifted forward. This is what will the stock market do 2 years from now? What will be the change in the S&P 500 2 years from this point? So, again, we're looking backwards what has happened to the yields. And we are trying to see what will happen 2 years forward. If you notice, orange line stops 2 years before today, because we don't know from any point of time over the last 2 years, we don't know how the orange line will resolve.
Now, the reason why I constructed this chart, I wanted to avoid the fallacy that a lot of people are falling into. I hear a lot of people saying things like, well, we look historically, and actually, lower yields do not imply higher stocks, if anything, the opposite, or lower yields do not imply multiples expanding. Actually, historically, multiples contract during low yields. This is an absolutely fallacious— and I will be very strong about this.
These are fighting words. I think that it's a totally fallacious way of looking at the world. Because, of course, lower yields typically occur historically at times of crisis, when multiples contract, whether for a good reason or not, and stocks fall. This is not the questions we should be asking. We should be asking not where stocks are when yields are low, but where they will be after yields are low. That's the only interesting question for investors. Does that make sense?
Erik Townsend: Perfect sense. How do we extrapolate from this chart in order to make money in the markets?
Alex Gurevich: Okay. So, this is the chart. So, the chart, the blue line tells us where we are and the orange line tells us where we will be. Now, as you see, the chart starts in 1992, and this is the last time in the early '90s when the orange chart is meaningfully below the blue blue line.
As you see, there is no perfect fit with those charts. That's not like perfect one correlation, but you see orange line almost always stays above blue line. It's not perfect. You saw like in '08, when there was a very massive stock market sell-off, it managed to drop below the blue line. And also notice, this is very uncalibrated. What we're doing internally with real math is much more sophisticated and calibrated. But if you look at this very crude chart, you'll see that orange line is always above blue line. What does it tell us?
It tells us that we have now 30 years of history that whenever yields have fallen, stocks typically don't go down in the next 2 years. If the yields have fallen over the last 2 years, stocks do not go down over the next 2 years. Not that they don't go down interim, but eventually, they perform well. So, the reason why I shaded the area in 2014, because that's when I discovered this chart. That's when I posted it. And let's think of what happened afterwards.
We had a 2013, 2014 time of taper tantrum, interest rates have risen. What has followed? What followed was the period of stock volatility of 2015, 2016. As you see, orange line, when you look at 2015, 2016, it spikes up, but then goes down, shows a little bit volatility, but Well above the blue line, it does not do not allow it to fall below the blue line.
So what happens afterwards? 2015, 2016, and you see the spike in the blue line, right? Spike in the blue line 2015, 2016. And this is what post Brexit interest rates, and it's very it's very confusing because you have to stagger things a little bit. The spike in the blue line of 2016. Corresponds to the dip in the orange line in 2014.
And I know people will have to study it and think it through, because what we see on the orange line is 2 years looking forward. What we see on the blue line is 2 years looking back. So, in 2016, we had a big fall in interest rates. And what orange line shows us, the peak in orange line, is how well stock markets have performed afterwards.
And you see that it corresponded to a big spike in performance in stock market, which was the bull market of 2016 to 2018.
Now, when we look in 2018, we'll go back to 2018— forward, sorry, to 2018, you see blue line going below zero. And that was because we had a bear market for 2 years, and rates have actually risen significantly. And see what happened in the next 2 years between 2018 and 2020, stock market had quite a dip, but not to cross the blue line. So, now, we're seeing the blue line going crazy up, up.
Why? Because bond yields have fallen down dramatically, which tells me that if this pattern persists, if the orange line stays above the yellow line, it means that S&P 500 2 years from now should be more than 750 points above where it is today or so. That's the rough conclusion.
So, if you believe in this chart and this pattern, it should make you very bullish on stocks.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So, the outlook based on how you interpret the chart now is the S&P has about 750 points of upside from here over the next 2 years if this chart proves true.
Alex Gurevich: Correct. But this is just one analysis, and each such analysis is just one little impact on your life. And this is when, you know, I'll be honest with you, I was getting a little more bearish skeptic on stocks over the last few weeks.
But then I started to rehash this chart, and I'm saying, well, but how can stocks really go down? Because what really this chart shows, this change in yields could be really a proxy for the change in liquidity. You added liquidity, so assets are going to go up. And it seems to be as simple as that. And you take away liquidity, then you tighten, and assets go down. And what matters is not the absolute level of rates, but the change in rates. It seems that a change in rates produces a lagging impact on risk assets. And as you hike, hike, hike, and concurrently, risk assets might still be going up, but at the end of the hiking cycle, when rates are now higher than they were before, that poses more risk for stock market underperforming, but no risk The underperformance is not a certain thing over the last 30 years. It's the outperformance that always happened. That is, whenever we drop the rate, stocks almost invariably picked up.
And with the only meaningful except— there were a couple of exceptions that they lagged a little bit in '01, '02, and '08, '09, when the drop was so high that it took them a little longer to get up. As you see, stocks actually do lag quite a bit below the blue line there. So, maybe we could— so, that would be like the scope for the error on this analysis. Those Those 2 situations. And both of them happened in the event of the double dip. So, that is the error scope. But even within that scope of error, given how high the blue line is, it's hard to imagine stocks being too negative from today forward if that analysis holds. And that is one incremental thing that makes me a little more constructive on risk assets going forward.
Erik Townsend: Let me just play devil's advocate on this, Alex, because what's coming to my mind is if this is all about liquidity, it seems like Like, one argument you could make is, okay, well, if we see what the Fed's been doing lately and their reaction to the crises that we face and the possibility that we've got more crises ahead of us, boy, they're gonna keep on providing more and more liquidity. That really fuels your argument that stocks ought to head much higher. I suppose the counterargument, though, would be that there's a growing political frustration with this notion that the bailouts are going to Wall Street, not to Main Street.
And I think there's a big political component of the support for MMT where people are saying, look, we've gotta do more central bank balance sheet expansion, but we gotta stop pumping that money into the financial system, pumping up the stock market. We ought to be using it to help people on Main Street instead. So, those are maybe 2 opposite direction arguments for how liquidity could be affected by policy. Do you factor those kinds of things in, or how do you think about—
Alex Gurevich: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: where we are in the current geopolitical and US political environment and how that might affect some of your prognostications about liquidity in the market?
Alex Gurevich: It's a good question, but I'm sympathetic to the fairly commonly held view that Fed liquidity goes directly, more directly to assets and less so to goods prices and wages, while fiscal impulse have more potential to go into actual consumer inflation. It would have to, I guess, after a certain point, fiscal impulse would have to go into consumer inflation one way or another. That's the commonly held belief, and I somewhat subscribe to it. So, those shifts, but if we're having consumer-driven inflation, I think it's also positive for stock prices, at least on a nominal basis. At least nominally, stocks are going to look good. And also, being able to raise prices is not necessarily a bad thing for stocks even as wages go up.
And asset prices inflation, if it's more on the side of the Fed, will probably be supportive in other ways. And I think it's like a water pressure system, water is going to pour one way or another. If, for example, we have some gridlock in DC, and there is not enough fiscal impulse, well, the Fed will have to do more.
If there is more of an MMT view, then maybe Fed will have to do less. And there'll be more spending, but either of those things will be probably supportive to certain trends continuing. That's what I feel like. I feel like even though I fear legitimately what the next few months can bring, I feel that if this next few months' commotion will restrict the fiscal impulse, then the Fed will continue being aggressive, especially if we go in any kind of other down wave in terms of risk and economy, Fed will only do more. And on the flip side, they may not have to do so much if the fiscal side is coming through stronger.
Either of those cases, I think, is in the long run constructive for at least nominal price of assets.
Erik Townsend: Alex, before we close, for the benefit of our institutional qualified purchasers who are eligible to invest in your fund, tell us a little bit more about what you do at HonTe Advisors.
Alex Gurevich: We run a macro fund. Our focus has been always long horizon discretionary global macro. That is, we choose trades that are likely to work over the long horizon. It's mostly discretionary fund with some systematic assist. People who want to find more information about how we work, there is a website, honteinv.com. So, it's like the name of HonTe, H-O-N-T-E, HonTeInvestments.com. And there is some public information available there, which is any interviews or any other piece of information which are available broadly, but also qualified purchasers can try to register on the website and get more. If you're interested in investing, you can get more information from us on what we do.
Erik Townsend: And for the benefit of our retail audience who is not eligible to participate as qualified purchasers, I think your book, although it was written several years ago, is probably just as relevant to today's environment. As the day it was written. Tell us a little bit more about The Next Perfect Trade.
Alex Gurevich: Yes, The Next Perfect Trade. It had a subtitle, The Magic Sword of Necessity. But yes, The Next Perfect Trade. In this book, I qualitatively described the system of selecting trades that goes into my strategy, that as I described the sequence of objective parameters, which makes a trade likely to make money over the long horizon.
And this system became, in a much more rigorous and formalized way, is actually how I'm running the portfolio. It's a way of looking at trades and thinking what type of trades are likely to make money. And this is my forecast-agnostic approach to constructing portfolio. And in this book, I don't give any investment recommendations. I just go through giving some maybe examples of trades from my past and my thoughts. I go through chapter by chapter about various principles, which I think on a qualitative level makes trades to be more profitable in the long run. And when ideally, when all of those align, you get the perfect trade.
Erik Townsend: Well, Alex, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. We look forward to getting you back in less time than it's been since last time for another update.
Erik Townsend: Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor. Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade, but the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich.
FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with farmtogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio.
You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now, back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, that was a great interview with Alex, but joining us now in the postgame is Jim Bianco from Bianco Research. How you doing today, Jim?
Jim Bianco: I'm doing good. Thank you.
Patrick Ceresna: So, Jim, you put together a great chart book that listeners can find in the Research Roundup email. Or if you're not yet registered, you can just go to the homepage of MacroVoices.com and click the big red button that says, looking for the downloads. Now, Jim, in this chartbook, you start off by talking about the national polls and where things stand. So why don't you take us through what you're seeing here?
Jim Bianco: Yeah, in the handout on page 2, I start off with probably the metric that everybody looks at the most, which is the least relevant of all, and that is the national average polling. This is the average from RealClearPolitics, and Joe Biden has a 6.5-point lead in the polls, down from a 10-point lead in late June. And it goes all the way back a year, and Biden has always led. Now, the reason I say that this is a useless statistic that everybody looks at is we don't vote on a national basis. We vote on 50 state elections, and we know that Biden is going to win California and New York, in Massachusetts by +25 or +30.
And that's how you could wind up with Trump losing the popular vote like he did in 2016 and winning the Electoral College. If you look at the polls, slide 3, what's interesting is let's look at the poll analyzers. The Charlie Cooks of the Cook Report or Nate Silver 538 or even The Economist magazine has their Electoral College betting. Now what they do is they analyze the polls.
It's over. Biden has won the race. And, you know, FiveThirtyEight's got a 23% chance that Trump is going to win. The Economist magazine has a 13% chance Trump is going to win. Charlie Cook says he can't figure out how Trump's going to get to 270 Electoral College votes. Slide 4 shows you, if you look at the polls, you're looking at Biden 353 Electoral College votes to Trump 185.
So that's what the polls say. But if I go to slide 5, let's look at the betting markets. Now let me say a quick word about the betting markets. Let me give you a little history on the betting markets. Before George Gallup invented modern polling in the 1930s, we had betting markets in this country pretty much from the end of the Revolutionary War until the Great Depression. That if you were in the 19th century looking at your local hometown newspaper and there was an election coming up, They regularly quoted the betting markets that traded on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, which could be 30 or 40% of the volume of the New York Stock Exchange in the 19th century. So we've done this for a long, long time. The betting markets, let me talk about what they are real quick. They are nothing but an aggregation of all known information into one probability.
They normally do not diverge from the polls. And I've got the detail on the modern betting records, betting markets since 1988. Until now. Slide 5 shows Trump— I'll go from the incumbent point of view— has a 45% chance of winning the election, where The Economist magazine has, according to the polls, 13%.
Nate Silver is 23%. Betting markets have it at 45%. They've got it a lot closer. Now what you're looking at on slide 5 is PredictIt, which is the largest betting market in the United States. Slide 6 shows you the London bookies and a lot of the foreign markets. They have it 46%, exactly the same. Is this market manipulated? If you think every single betting market worldwide is being manipulated constantly for a year, then yeah, it's going to be manipulated. Now, the reason I say it that way is no, they're typically not being manipulated. For what end would you manipulate it? Do you honestly believe that the election will turn because somebody looked at a betting market and said, oh well, they've got Trump at as winning, so I guess I'm going to change my vote.
No, this is the way the bettors believe. They believe it's essentially a 50-50 race, even though the polls are telling us something different. Slide 7. There are betting markets on all 50 states, and the betting markets are showing that it's 248 Electoral College votes for Trump, 290 for Biden. And I'll mind you, if you're looking at this map on slide 7, Everything here is from the incumbent point of view. Arizona's 38% Trump, Wisconsin's 35%, Pennsylvania's 38%.
Those are not that far off. Trump is behind, but if he could pick off 2 of those 3 states, he wins the election. The reason I say it that way is Biden is in the lead either way you look at it, the polls or the betting markets. But in the betting markets, it's a lot, lot closer than the polls. Slide 8 just shows you how the betting markets are shaping up in the 50 states.
Really, there's only about 4 or 5 states that matter: North Carolina, Florida, Arizona, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, maybe Michigan. That's really it. In fact, between now and Election Day, I'd be surprised if any of the candidates did not go to went to another state other than those five because remember, that's all that matters is the Electoral College vote.
And then on slide nine, the betting market I just wanted to show you the orange line on slide nine shows you the 45% chance on PredictIt that Trump will win the election. The blue line says, will he win the popular vote? He's never been above 50%. He's only at 19%.
Just like in 2016 when he lost the popular vote by 4%, there's no expectation he's going to win the popular vote. That's not how we keep score. We keep score via the Electoral College, and that's why he's got a 45% chance to go there. Finally, the last, last couple of charts I'll throw out here is on slide 10, which party will control the Senate? And I'll go again from the incumbent point of view because the Republicans are the incumbents. 47% chance they keep the Senate.
That's a coin toss. So the Senate is a coin toss. The House on slide 11 is 85% Democrat. They're the incumbent there. They're looking for no change in the House. That's pretty much set to stay the way it's going to stay.
Finally, the 2 charts on 12 and 13, I thought were rather interesting. Trump's approval rating on 12. This is over 50 polling sources aggregated together to show his approval rating. It has been rising. It has been rising since late July. It's at 42.9%. There's a couple of ways you can look at it. It's well below 50. Yes, but he's been below 50 every single day of his presidency. But it is in the upper end of his range. Interestingly about Trump, if you look at this chart, essentially about a 5-point range determines his approval rating for his presidency. There's a couple outliers here and there, but basically most of it's been within a 5-point range. Now, is it the narrowest it's ever been? It's by far the narrowest it's ever been, meaning— and I've heard some pollsters say this— probably 95%, if not 98% of the American public has already decided who they're going to vote for.
And that this is really not an election about trying to convince somebody to vote for me, but about 60% of the American public actually votes. This is an election about saying, okay, you've made up your mind to vote for me. Now, how do I get you to fill out a ballot? That's really what this election is about. Please fill out the ballot in one way or another. That's why the mail-in ballot has become such a contentious issue as well too.
And then finally on slide 13, there is a poll that they do called the generic ballot. They just ask people, are you more inclined for Congress to vote for the Democrat or the Republican? They don't ask you a specific name. And the Democrats blue, the Republicans red, but the bottom chart shows the spread. It has been narrowing quite a bit in favor of the Republican. Now, the Democrats have always been ahead. They peaked with a 9-point advantage in mid-July.
They now have a 6-point advantage, which is the lowest it's been in 7 months. So it has been narrowing towards that. And what I find that's interesting about this is when you ask, are you going to vote for Trump or are you going to vote for Biden? You know, you get that 6, 7-point lead. But when you start looking at his approval rating and you look at the generic ballot, everything's trending either for Trump Or it's trending towards the Republicans. The Democrats are still leading.
So the bottom line is, if you watch the polls, polls are telling you that this is over and Biden has won. And the polls are probably telling you too that we're going to have a blue wave and we're going to have the Democrats take the Senate. If you look at the betting markets, and the betting markets again I think are an aggregation of opinion, they've got it far, far closer than the polls do right now. Now, last word for you.
The polls always ask the question, who would you vote for today? The bettors are looking at who do they think is going to win November 3rd, and they're factoring in the expectation that some unforeseen event, otherwise known as an October surprise, or something will come along that will change the equation. I think part of what we're seeing with the bettors is that they think that whatever comes along might be a pro-Trump event more than an anti-Trump event, which is why they're leaning a little closer towards a toss-up election this year.
Erik Townsend: Jim, please explain the concept of a red mirage. What does that phrase mean and why is it important?
Jim Bianco: So we've got mail-in ballots this year nationwide to a degree that we've never seen before. And the expectations are that mail-in ballots are going to skew Democrat. People that show up at the polling place on November 3rd are going to skew Republican. So election night, it has been postulated that you'll be watching the returns. Trump will have won all these states. He will have gone over 270 Electoral College votes. He will give an acceptance speech. I win.
Then comes the mail-in ballots. And one by one, as they count more and more Democrat votes, he loses this state, he loses this state, he loses this state, that by Thanksgiving it flips and that maybe Biden has won. That's the so-called red mirage.
Is there precedent for it? Well, sort of. In 2018, the last election, Martha McSally was run— she's a Republican, and she was, uh, running against Kyrsten Sinema, the Democrat, in Arizona for the Senate. Election night, Martha McSally was up by about 15,000 votes. Then they started counting the mail-in ballots because Arizona has had mail-in ballots.
By Thanksgiving, Kyrsten Sinema was leading and became the winner of the race. And Martha McSally, you may know, is currently a senator because John McCain passed away and she was appointed to his seat and she's running again for reelection. So bear in mind, the red mirage is, is that election night, should skew Republican.
And then when we start counting in the mail-in votes, that should skew Democrat. And we'll have to see if the Republicans have a big enough lead that the Democrats can't pull it back, or a small enough lead that the Democrats can pull it back. That's what we'll have to determine on election night.
Erik Townsend: Jim, I've been feeling a huge sense of déjà vu going back to late January when you and I, one Saturday morning, I believe it was January January 25th, had an email exchange and you kind of said, Erik, look at these charts, look at my projections of what I see from the exponential growth of the case counts in China, which at that time were still very, very small. We had dozens of cases, not hundreds, and certainly not thousands.
And you and I both looked at those charts and scratched our heads and said, if this is real, you know, this is the beginning of literally something just huge, a global pandemic. And I think we were both sort of feeling like that's what the data tells us. But boy, to make that prediction publicly and be wrong about it, you better double-check your data 3 or 4 times. And what I've been feeling really recently, Jim, is I feel that we have a very similar situation, although this one is not being driven by data.
It's more being driven, I admit, by my own speculation and admittedly conjecture. And what I see here is a setup. And the red mirage you just described perfectly explains the reason that I'm so concerned, where if you look at what's likely to happen, I think it is more than 90% assured that most people in the country will become convinced that their candidate, the guy they voted for, is who won. And they'll feel that half of the country is trying to undermine the democratic process. And steal the election in favor of their candidate. And the red mirage perfectly sets that up. First, the Republicans have the experience of winning on election night. It seems clear that Trump won. And of course, the Democrats are outraged by that. And then the mail-in ballots come in, the Democrats become convinced, no, in actuality, once you count the votes, Biden won. And the Republicans are saying, you guys are trying to steal the election after the fact.
Everybody feels like their candidate won, the other guy didn't win, or the other guy who's being a sore loser is trying to steal the election. And you get a situation which by itself could escalate even without the encouragement from public officials.
But I listened, Jim, to what's going on just over this past weekend. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez went on social media and told her followers It is time to radicalize and get ready to fight. Okay, get ready to fight. If ever there were fighting words, those are fighting words. I think we have a setup for a dramatic increase in civil unrest and violence across the United States as a fight breaks out where everybody believes that their candidate won and they feel That half of the country is trying to undermine the democratic process and steal the election in favor of the other guy.
Jim, I know this, and I've thought carefully about whether I wanted to say this on the air, but I'm gonna go ahead and stick my leg out here. I think that the risk of this election mushrooming into an all-out civil war, no exaggeration, civil war, Civil war. I think the possibility or the probability of that outcome is now higher than 10%. I'm gonna say somewhere between 10% and 20%.
So, just to be super clear, folks, I'm not predicting that outcome. I didn't say it was certain to happen. I didn't say it was likely to happen. But frankly, when you consider how big of a deal a civil war would be, if you understand the backdrop of the global geopolitical situation, China is just waiting for an opportunity for the US to have a really bad moment that can be exploited.
A civil war breaking out in the United States would have profound implications on the development of the history of the entire planet. And I didn't say it was going to happen, but I do think it's more than a 10% possibility at this point.
Jim, am I crazy to think that? And where would you put the percentage possibility of literally a civil war developing as a result of this contested election getting out of control?
Jim Bianco: Well, let me define what I believe civil war means. And I think it does not necessarily mean that we're going to take up arms and Americans are going to start shooting Americans. But I do think that a civil war, if you want to define it as a loss of faith in institutions and a loss of faith in the country to the point that there are states and maybe regions of the country that are looking to secede from the United States, openly talking about, I don't trust the government, I would put it at 10 or 20% at that point.
For instance, you're right, the red mirage. If Trump looks like he's won on election day and then it gets pulled back with the mail-in ballot, and to your point, I agree with you 100%, Whoever wins, half the country is going to be angry, is going to be not just disappointed or not just, oh, what's on TV? I guess that guy won. No, they're going to be angry that their candidate lost. And so you're going to have a big, big division right there. If it's won by the red mirage argument that I have, then it becomes even angrier that it looks like it was stolen.
Even if the election is close, as I said, and everybody's been following the polls on the other side, the Democrats will think it was stolen because the polls told us it was supposed to be a runaway election in the first place. So I agree with you that. And then what will come of that is look at some of the language we're getting. Take up to arms. Let's pack the Supreme Court. Let's vote D.C. and Puerto Rico as states. Because we know that they'll skew Democrat, and we could get more Democrat senators into this Senate.
And then there was a guy from Texas I just read recently who's saying, "Fine, we'll break up Texas into every county in the state, and we'll make them 80 states if you want." And I mean, he was he was trying to you know be ridiculous to prove a point. But this is how you have a loss of confidence in the government, and this is how you have people to stop listening to the government. And you have people searching for alternatives to the federal government. If that's what we mean by civil war, yeah, I would put it at 10 to 20%.
If we mean no Americans are going to take up arms and start shooting other Americans, no, I don't think that that would be the case. It would really be about a loss of institutional belief. And I think that that's a real possibility as we go forward. Has this summer not shown us that we've got a lot of that already in this country to begin with?
Erik Townsend: What if we talked about not a matter of people shooting each other, but this escalating beyond just individuals? You know, it's not just Black Lives Matter versus, you know, Proud Boys versus Antifa, but let's suppose that the California legislature were to adopt a resolution to say the state of California rejects the federal government's, the election committee's decision that Donald Trump won the election. We do not accept that. The state of California is, by action of state government, decrees that we reject that and that Joe Biden won the election. So that it's not just people getting upset, but it is states taking action to say, we reject the action of the federal government. We will not accept the president that— and it could go the other way. It could be that Biden has supposedly won, and it's Texas that is objecting. We get to the point where it's not individuals, it's not just people that are angry, but it is states taking action to try to usurp the authority of the federal government.
It sounds like— I mean, I certainly think that's a likely outcome at this point. I would go much higher than 20% that you have at least some political grandstanding along those lines. Whether it gets to actual secession from the nation, that's another matter.
Jim Bianco: Got to be careful about grandstanding because, yeah, I could definitely see that states one way or the other could pass non-binding resolutions to express their displeasure and that they don't believe that, you know, Biden or Trump won either way. But then, you know, you start doing this enough and people then start demanding that you act on it.
Alex Gurevich: It.
Jim Bianco: And if you start acting on it, if you don't believe Donald Trump won and you're California and you say that we're not going to recognize the election, then I guess California has left the United States. I, I don't know what else it means at that point, that then there's no more federal assistance on any way, shape, or form in California. Maybe, maybe California will have to put together a passport to allow them to, you know, visit the rest of the, uh, 49 states. I know that sounds silly right now, but But you can't make those kind of statements without the natural follow-up to that.
If you don't believe X, Y, or Z is the duly elected official, then you're not part of the country anymore. And so, yeah, I could see that kind of bitterness coming out of this election. You can see that kind of anger coming out of this election and that kind of sharp rhetoric. Look, this past weekend, Ruth Bader Ginsburg died, and the Democrats are so upset that the Republicans might fill her seat before the election, they're talking about we'll make D.C. and Puerto Rico states. We're going to add 2 more states so they can add 4 more Democrat senators. That's the only reason that they want to do it. We're going to pack the court to 13 if Biden wins so he can just appoint 4 more people to overwhelm whatever happens and who gets to replace Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Now, maybe they're— they think they're saying this just to, you know, satisfy the fringe elements on their side, to give them some red meat to be excited about.
Well, boy, you start saying this stuff too much and people are going to actually expect you to do it. And if you don't do it, they're going to start voting people in that will do it. And then you're going to have a real problem on your hands holding the country together. So it's very dangerous talk.
Erik Townsend: I want to come back to the civil unrest. First of all, I agree with you that I would not predict that you have a sudden breakout of, okay, we're gonna just take up arms and, you know, Democrats shoot Republicans on sight and Republicans shoot Democrats on sight. I don't see that. But what I do think is very possible is that after the election, there's a lot of disagreement as to who has won. You see, let's say, in some Democrat-controlled cities, you see major protests that are more violent than what we've seen, more arson, more burning down of buildings, more looting, more of that sort of thing.
And there is a certain amount of demands saying there has to be law and order, we have to get this under control. And Democrat politicians say, look, the reason that these people are rioting or protesting is because they're fighting for democracy, because the election that there is being contested was unfairly decided in favor of Trump. Trump responds by invoking the Insurrection Act, and we suddenly have— because the Democrat-controlled mayors and governors might refuse to take action against the protesters, President Trump takes matters into his own hands and brings the military in under the Insurrection Act. Now the other side accuses Trump of trying to use use the military in a coup to steal the election from Biden, who, as far as they're concerned, won it fair and square. And you get an escalation of more and more violence, which I agree with you, I don't think it comes in the form of let's try to kill all of the citizens on the other side, but let's burn down major cities because we're not getting our way.
It seems pretty darn clear that people are ready to do that. They've talked very publicly on social media and discussed plans to burn cities down if they don't get their way, or even if Republicans try to replace Justice Ginsburg on the Supreme Court before the election. People have said they would start burning cities down just to protest that. So it seems to me that we have a setup where really it's not now until the election, but it's really from election to inauguration day that it seems to me, like just a setup for an explosion of increased domestic violence. Am I missing anything?
Jim Bianco: No. And as a matter of fact, one of the things that we learned about the violence this summer— now, you know, there were protests and there were lots of peaceful protests, but there was violence. Most of the violence was directed at government institutions, police stations, courthouses, other government buildings and stuff like that, that they were They were expressing their displeasure at the government because the government is run by Donald Trump. Most of the yes, and along the way, you know, regular businesses and homeowners got caught up in the process as well too. But that's where I think you've got to bear in mind that yeah, we're going to have if we have those kind of protests and we have those kind of and they break out into violence. Well, you know, where do the protests go? They usually go in front of the courthouses or city hall or those types of institutions to protest to begin with, if not the governor's mansion or some federal buildings as well.
That is all about arguing against the legitimacy of the government. And that is what is going to be a big, big problem. So yeah, I definitely can see that picking up either way. I do think though, you know, let's not discount that on the other side of the equation, There are a lot of people that are just as passionate for Donald Trump as there are people that are just as passionate against Donald Trump or for Joe Biden. It's the people that are passionate for Donald Trump don't get as much press coverage, but they're there too. And so you could wind up seeing them lose faith in institutions as well.
If we get into a case, the red mirage case, where they start pulling back on the mail-in ballots, And we start getting lawsuits and we start getting federal judges involved with this and we start getting kind of Florida 2000 100 times worse or 50 times worse. We have each one of the 50 states has its own Florida 2000 kind of hanging chad type of thing. Again, you could wind up so sullying the whole process that nobody believes anything and that even people that voted for the winner think it was illegitimate, but my guy won, so it's okay, I guess, because I got what I wanted in the long run.
Very dangerous type of thing. And I think that that is going to be a real problem as we move forward from here. And I hope that we wind up having what is considered to be a clean election. We wind up having a peaceful transfer of power and we don't wind up with all this acrimony that we are fearing. But I would agree with you, 10% to 20% possibility. Is a real possibility that we could see something like this again. It's well less than 50, but in my lifetime, in your lifetime, Erik, I never even thought I'd ever see it above 2, you know, at that point in the United States. But now it's something you have to really start to consider.
Erik Townsend: I was alive, although just a very small child, in the late 1960s, and I don't think the risk then was anywhere close to as high as it is now.
Erik Townsend: Let's quickly— we're running out of time, Jim, but very quickly, before we wrap the show up for this week, how do we translate this to an outlook for markets? Because you could say, okay, well, boy, civil war. I mean, it's, it's got to be a market crash. But by the same token, you can say guaranteed the, the Fed is going to turn up the, the pace of stimulus. It could potentially, you know, support a market melt-up. How do you translate this into a market risk outlook?
Jim Bianco: You know, there's 2 things I think that are really weighing on the markets right now. One is this election that we've discussed, and the other one is there is a serious surge of cases coming out of Europe right now. Not the United States, but out of Europe. And there's a fear that there might be another set of lockdowns in Europe, and maybe US is going to follow Europe in the next month or 2 in terms of a surge of cases. Both of those instances would lead you to be very, very bearish. But you, you hit the nail on the head.
You've got something here in that you've got the Federal Reserve and you have the federal government, you know, basically passing bailouts for the airline industry and the cruise ship industry, and we're not willing to go down without a fight.
So I think what you should be looking at is heightened volatility and you maybe a 10 to 15% correction, which we've already had. And I think as we get close to 15%, you're going to or should expect some kind of a reaction out of the Fed. Or out of the federal government to try and support the market. Or as I've been referring to it as, they'll throw a kitchen sink at it like they did in March.
Then they just kept throwing one kitchen sink after another until they eventually got a bottom in the market.
So they're going to fight this. And so heightened volatility. Let me give you a fun statistic. September 2nd was the all-time high. And on that day, the VIX closed at 26.57. That is the highest VIX level in history on the day of an all-time high. Usually the VIX moves inverse to prices. So when you're at all-time highs is when the VIX should be very low. It was moving up and make it very high levels in late September, signifying that even market participants through the options market were expecting a lot of volatility. So yeah, I could see us doing a 15% correction. I could see the Fed stepping in, and I could see these kind of 2%, 3% days that we're starting to see again, reminding everybody of the spring, sticking around for a while as we sort this out.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Jim, thank you for joining us and giving us this great update. Look forward to having you back on the show.
Jim Bianco: Thank you.
Erik Townsend: We're going to leave it there for this week's show, folks. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by FarmTogether.com. Making farmland investing a trillion-dollar asset class available to all accredited investors. And by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at TopTradersUnplugged.com/MacroGuide.
For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as the link to Alex Gurevich's slide deck, as well as the chartbook we just discussed in the post-game with Jim Bianco. There's also a link to an article on the ECB calling on Brussels to make the recovery fund permanent, and a link to an interview with Brent Kochuba about weaponized gamma. You'll find this and so much more in this week's research roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.
Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening. Thank you. And we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of. online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device Each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.
MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making any investment decisions. And now back to the program. Making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Juliette Declercq — JDI Research founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 237 was recorded on September 17th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity within reach of all accredited investors. JDI Research founder Juliette Declercq is back as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the potential outcomes of the US presidential election and their impact on markets, inflation, the US dollar, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview. Patrick's chartbook this week is titled, Is That the Best the Bulls Can Do? And we'll revisit those those 50-day moving averages that we talked about last week and see how a number of different stocks and other markets are performing compared to the levels that we discussed in last week's postgame.
And a quick housekeeping note, MacroVoices will be released on Wednesday, the 23rd of September next week, instead of our usual Thursday schedule in order to accommodate travel schedules.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, that S&P 500 was quite oversold last week when we were talking, and It did muster up a bounce, and yet here we are back to levels where we were trading last week. What's your take on the S&P 500 here?
Erik Townsend: Well, clearly that relief rally, or maybe you just wanna call it a dead cat bounce, failed today. And it really remains to be seen as to whether we get to a new lower low, which would be the next technical signal. I still think the big story is going to be from now to the election and really through Inauguration Day is going to be the escalation of unrest, which I expect to occur. And a very likely contested election. What that means for markets, you know, uncertainty is usually not good for markets. It remains to be seen. I'm gonna ask more and more of our guests about the presidential election outlook and particularly the potential implications of a contested election where nobody knows who the President of the United States actually is for potentially several weeks after Election Day. And we'll start that with Juliette Declercq in today's interview.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US dollar because obviously the US dollar's been in a substantial downtrend for the last 5+ months. But really, we are going on almost 2 months of the dollar index being pinned in this kind of 92.5 to 93.5 tight range. Which way does it break out from here?
Erik Townsend: Well, we're still consolidating. There's no confirmation in either direction yet from a technical standpoint. So it's a coiled up market. I think it's probably ready to make a significant move one direction or the other. If we do see a dramatic increase of civil unrest in the United States, and particularly if more people develop the opinion that I have, which is that a contested election, a very strongly contested election, is essentially a certainty at this point, that maybe could be quite bearish. On the other hand, there's a lot of reasons to expect that dollar squeeze thesis to play out. So, I really don't have any conviction on which way, but I definitely think this market is Coiling up, ready to move one way or the other.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil, Erik. And I just have one question. Was that a buy on dip?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, until today, Patrick, my base case was that we were only halfway done with the downside move that was in play. I was targeting somewhere in the low 30s for WTI. Now, we had a rally off of what would be a reasonable, you know, halfway through the move, you tend to get that countertrend rally. That's what I thought was going on Until today. And inventory certainly helped with the rally this week. Crude oil drawing down 4.4 million barrels. It's really 6.5 million barrels if you include the additional 2.2 million barrel drawdown on the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which I think is really commercial oil, not government oil that's coming out. Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 74,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 381,000 barrels. Distillates was the one build on the board this week, and it was a big one, 3.5 million barrels. Now, US production is way back up, almost a million barrels on the week. But of course, what that really is, is we're bouncing back to pre-tropical storm levels, actually a couple hundred thousand barrels higher.
Pre-tropical storm, we were at 10.7. Now we've not only regained that, but we're even a couple hundred thousand barrels higher.
The tape action in response to inventory was fairly strong, and it really got stronger today on Thursday. Now, Patrick, if I was looking at this market purely from a technical standpoint, I would say, look, there's a really strong argument here that, you know, it's a technical breakout to the upside. The correction is over. That's it. The bottom is in. We're headed back to new cycle highs above $43.
That's what the technical read of the tape tells me. The thing is, today was the meeting of OPEC+, the Joint Ministerial Monitoring Committee, and their press conference included quite a bit of rhetoric, kind of trying to scare shorts out of the marketplace. There's a possibility that what we're seeing today, because OPEC is so good at jawboning the oil market, that this was the OPEC jawbone. Maybe it's not going to last. Maybe tomorrow it's all going to reverse. And that really was the top of a countertrend rally. And we've still got more downside before we're done, which was my original base case. I'll tell you though, Patrick, if it turns out that this was really it, That the long-awaited, after 2 months of a coiling market, all we got was a sell-off down to not even $36.
It only lasted a week or so, and we're already retracing. If we go from here back to above $43, you know, moving toward a new cycle high, it really, to me, just cements an incredibly bullish longer-term outlook. Because the prediction that Art Berman shared with us back in June when we last interviewed him hasn't even begun to play out yet. Remember what What Art told us was expect over the course of the summer through the end of Q2 that you might see a downside move in the market like the one we just saw. Although I think both Art and I thought it would be a bigger one than the one we just saw. But he said, just wait for Q4. That's when we're going to have consumed the inventory of drilled but uncompleted wells. We'll get to the point where the dramatically lower rig count catches up with us and you'll see US production fall off a cliff in Q4.
Now, Right now, we've got US production back up to 10.9 million barrels, 200,000 higher than before the tropical storm. So, there's no sign of US production falling off a cliff. If Art is right about that, and of course he said it wouldn't start until sometime in Q4, if he's right about that, and we're already seeing this much strength in the market, I think as we get toward the end of 2020 and into the new year, we're gonna be looking at sharply higher prices. Still remains to be seen though, whether or not this is really over the way it feels.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: feels like today, or if maybe this is a pop and drop as a result of the OPEC+ JMMC press conference, which certainly seems to have scared the shorts out of the market.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's get your take on gold because gold really, over the— just very similar to the dollar, gold has been more or less in a $50 range for almost 2 months. It's been just in the sideways range and we're right in the middle of that range around $1,150. I mean, it doesn't seem to want to commit either direction. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, and it's also in a wedge or triangle formation, depending on how you want to interpret the chart, which means, you know, eventually it runs out of time. It breaks through one trend line or the other. We did briefly on Wednesday, at least on an intraday basis, gold poked its head above that top trend line, the resistance line, but didn't get a close there. So, it really wasn't a signal. And, you know, now we're back in the middle of that zone. We'd need to see a daily close above $1,972 or below $1,910. In order for me to interpret that the consolidation pattern that you just described has finally ended. Can't go on for too much longer. These trend lines converge. They eventually come to a point. We gotta come out on one side or the other. I'm still hoping it's a downside resolution because as a gold bull, I, first of all, I wanna buy more at a lower price. But I really do think that this market has gone too far, too fast to the upside.
And I think that the more consolidation and—
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: downside corrections that we get, the more it just increases the longer-term health of this secular bull market in gold.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, and let's wrap up by talking about that 10-year Treasury yield, which, like the other markets, is in this sideways trade range for at least a month now, pinned somewhere around this 68 basis point area, give or take. Which way are we gonna break?
Erik Townsend: I have no opinion short-term, as our long-term listeners know. I think the real question is, Can we get to negative yields? Is that possible? And can we get to a secular shift to inflation? If so, how long will it take to bring about? I'm leaning more and more toward the inflation is coming view. I'm convinced inflation is coming. I just can't decide if it's the next quarter or 3 years from now before it really starts to hit the tape in a big way. Let's see what Juliette Declercq says in the feature interview.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, this week's feature interview guest is JDI Research founder Juliette Declercq. Now, Erik, why did we invite Juliette back onto the show this week.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, Juliette has been a listener favorite for years, and it's been too long since we've had her on the show. She's also really good with fixed income markets. She's made a lot of good Treasury calls. I wanted to ask her about inflation, and particularly, I think it's very useful to get a very, very bright analyst like Juliette, who is completely unbiased in terms of personal politics, to look at this US presidential election cycle. Juliette is a French woman living in London. She doesn't have You know, the one side or the other American viewpoint. And I think it's so important to look at the presidential election cycle objectively. So, I want to ask her about the election cycle and what it portends for markets.
Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So, your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure. Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test.
But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Juliette is coming up as MacroVoices continues. Right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is JDI Research founder Juliette Declercq. Juliette has prepared a slide deck to accompany today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com, just go to our homepage, Look for the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, right above Juliette's picture. Juliette, it's great to have you back on MacroVoices. It's been too long. Now, I know we usually talk about Europe and some of the things that you specialize in, but I also know from reading some of your work that you're actually focused primarily right now on the US presidential campaign. So, tell us a little bit about what your prognostications are. What do you see? It's great to have an outsider's perspective on what we can expect in this election.
Juliette Declercq: Hi, Erik. So it's a pleasure for me as well to be back on your show. So with the COVID crisis largely fading away in the United States, I was not really surprised to see Trump catching up to Biden. After all, I think everybody thinks that the ace up Trump's sleeve is really the economy.
And of course, it's not my personal opinion. My personal opinion is that short-termism, and obsession for rising equities and basically financialization of the economy will eventually cost the US economy greatly in the long run. But I have no vote in that contest. And clearly his personal trademark is that of a businessman who can drive the economy back to prosperity rather than bankruptcy.
So undeniably, the reason this year's events have not permanently damaged Trump is the V-shape Asset recovery, and so my bet is that we will not hear about firing Powell for a while now. There's a bigger question mark, though, because job-wise, we've only recovered to the worst of the global financial crisis, with year-on-year hours worked still down 7.5 percent, and that was basically the worst we've seen in the last crisis.
So will Americans look at the NASDAQ all-time highs and their lack of jobs and suddenly realize that they've been duped all along? If you have a continued slump in equities on top of a shallow jobs recovery, which is what we think right now into the election, I think it will be game over for Trump economically, e.g., in real life.
I would say that the issue we have today is the loss of additional unemployment benefits from the end of July.
I think those unemployment benefits were withdrawn much too fast and clearly a lot faster than employment could recover. This is literally threatening to pull the rug out from under the hardest hit after the COVID crisis. The risk is one that I'm really highlighting on chart 1 of my chart package. And you can see here that we might end up having income expectations converge down to the level of unemployment, and therefore the potential for a deflationary loop, instead of employment converging to higher income and demand expectations, which really is the only path to a sustainable recovery.
Of course, that's a circular issue, which is well illustrated on my chart. But it's really what I want to say here is that income subsidies and a continuation of social subsidies is really essential at this point. If you look at what we've had in Europe, and that's on top of already generous social benefits in normal time, So, you look at Germany, they've agreed to lengthen the job protection program, which covers 80% of wages until the end of 2021.
France has also introduced a furlough program, and that could last up to 2 years. Spain has basically gone all the way to extend its furlough scheme indefinitely. And I think it's really this lack of fiscal cliff in Europe that's allowed consumer confidence to slowly but surely recover. And that's Despite the current resurgence of COVID cases in Europe, to the contrary, what you've seen in U.S. is the fading of the COVID crisis starting from August, and that's not really allowed consumer confidence to continue higher at all. In fact, what we've had in August, and you can see that through like Conference Board numbers, which I will be looking forward to in the future, is that we're actually making new lows in August and I think it's got everything. to do with the expiry of the CARES Act employment subsidy.
So, one would argue that Trump promised an extra $300 per week versus $600 before by executive order. But for me, that's really a short-term bridge that's also quite flimsy.
So, my conclusion here is really that it's absolutely crucial for Trump and And probably for markets as well, to see consumer confidence rise from here, and that we should not be seeing a lowering for a continuous slide. Some will argue that the employment benefit is a double-edged sword because keeping workers on a drip alleviates short-term pain and it does boost confidence levels, but it also delays the reallocation of labor resources.
I would completely agree with that, but it's really a fine line. And the key to my view here is that it's really too early to pull the plug on employment subsidies because employment has only just recovered to the worst of the global financial crisis.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, so why have the Republicans not yet folded on the next relief package?
Juliette Declercq: So that's a great question. And I think it's really on everyone's mind. There's 2 possibilities. Perhaps Trump is complacent because he actually believes that the regular new equity market highs up until recently accurately mirror the state of the economy. In this case, I would say that we're probably going to see a compromise on the relief bill, perhaps somewhere between $1 and $2 trillion, which is what the Democrats want. And that could be just around the corner on the recent tightening in financial conditions.
The other possibility, of course, is that he will just wait until just before the elections to send the second round of checks to households signed with his name. It's also possible that he does believe that the executive order fills the fiscal gap until 2021. But in my mind, that would be a miscalculation.
I think short-term delays in payroll taxes, which is what's happening right now, and on which by the way, companies are reluctant to cooperate, and also the extension in wobbly employment benefits where states really lack the firepower to deliver. Well, that really pales in comparison to the 5 to 10% fiscal stimulus, which is really necessary to drive the US back towards full employment.
So, if it's the case that it's complacency about what is really needed into 2021, then I'm afraid, I think it will cost him the election.
Erik Townsend: So, it sounds like you're 50/50 on the outcome here. No real clear view as to what's likely to happen.
Juliette Declercq: I actually spent considerable time studying polls and digesting the best political analyst research. I would say that my conclusion is that it's really too close to call, which might be a problem in itself, of course. My best guess is that if Trump ends up accruing the benefit of a fiscal relief package, so before the election, then it's really 50/50. But perhaps more importantly for markets, which after all is my job, my job's not really to call the election, but to call markets over the elections.
It might be a bit controversial to say this given how polarized the population is in the United States.
But my belief is actually that neither potential president is a short-term game changer as far as the economy is concerned. What I've learned through years of experience analyzing underlying macro trends in relations to markets is that macroeconomics almost always wins over politics. And what I mean by macroeconomics, I mean the underlying macro trends. And that's especially true in developed markets.
Political events generally create noises and end up offering investment opportunities, but they rarely, like really rarely, are medium-term market drivers themselves.
So think about it. The truth is that both candidates want a fiscal stimulus. I think they will have different fiscal stimulus, but what really is true is that they want it and they want to own it, which is why we have the fighting in the election campaign. So reflation is very much the name of the game, whoever is elected, and perhaps even more so if financial conditions tighten.
And that's because the remedy to an equity rout and tightening in financial condition will be strongly biased to the fiscal side now that the Fed is effectively just a liquidity facade.
So that's the reason why my A trade, Remains paying 10-year US breakevens. So, 10-year breakevens, just to remind your listeners, is basically being long real yields and short nominals. And that effectively gives you a position on inflation as priced by markets. They've actually been trending higher since I almost nonstop since I recommended the trade at 1% at the end of March.
Against conventional wisdom, fixed income is not a dead asset class, but one where you really have to embrace trading TIPS or real yields this year if you want to express a macro view in the fixed income asset class. So in short, my view on the election is that Trump is more friendly to corporate earnings, and that's potentially great for equities short term.
Eventually, the lack of aggregate demand risks stopping the recovery right in its track. And that's what we've seen in his first mandate.
That will eventually be an issue as well for assets. Biden stands for social stability and more redistribution. It would greatly benefit aggregate demand in the long run. And that's a main challenge globally, but also especially in the US. But it would also potentially justify increased volatility as far as equities are concerned in the short term on the potential for higher corporate taxes and potentially increased regulation.
The risk with Trump is a return to trade wars eventually, which would most likely also include Europe. And that would risk slowing the dollar slide and stopping the global recovery in the process. But for me, that's really tomorrow's story rather than today's story. I really don't see Trump going back to tariff at a time when the global recovery is so fragile and really risk sending back the US into the abysses of the crisis, into a double dip.
Conversely, Biden would lower the world's geopolitical temperature and accelerate the recent cyclical recovery through further fiscal stimulus, which would widen the US trade deficit and further accelerate dollar downside. So I guess really your perfect market outcome would be Biden at the wheel with a Republican Senate preventing a tax hike. But what really matters for me right now is that the US and the global economy are still gaining momentum with central banks heavily focused on increasing asset purchases.
And that's really the main message that I want to get across.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, I wanted to start with your perspective on the elections, but what I'd like to do now is describe my own perspective on it to you and get your reactions. Because something I'm finding very interesting, I guess I see this differently than most analysts. The vast majority of smart people that I follow are saying something very similar to what you've said, here today which is, boy, this is hard to tell the outcome in terms of what it's gonna mean for markets at this point, 'cause it does kind of look 50-50 in terms of the poll odds.
I see it very differently. I think there's about an 80% certainty as to what the outcome is going to be. And the outcome that I'm talking about is the one in which almost everybody in the United States is in agreement. That That their candidate won the election. Not should have won, but did win. My guy won. And anybody who says the other side won is trying to undermine democracy. And that's fighting words. And I'm not gonna stand for it.
So, what I see, and I don't see how we could possibly avoid it, is a situation where you have almost everyone certain That their side won. Neither side is willing to concede. And you've got everything tied up in a major Supreme Court battle between Election Day and Inauguration Day. And nobody is sure who the president is or who the president-elect is. Now, that's obviously an extreme view, but frankly, I think it's pretty darn clear that that almost has to happen. What am I missing? Or why wouldn't you see that as the likely outcome? And if you do think it's a possible outcome, What would it mean for markets if I was right?
Juliette Declercq: Well, I tried to avoid this question because it's indeed a difficult one to answer, but you are absolutely right that it's on most of my clients' minds. Indeed, with such a close call, my understanding is that Trump may win on the night, but because a much larger proportion of Democrats vote by post compared to Republicans, There is indeed a really high chance that nobody concedes on the night or even right up to inauguration day. And I completely agree with you on that. Inevitably, we will see a rise in violence. Some even talk about the risk of civil war, which will be a grave problem, especially given I've just explained how confidence is such a crucial key to the outlook and violence would would inevitably undermine confidence and jobs in the prospect and bring back the spectrum of a deflationary loop.
So, this is important, of course, and it's key to a continuation of the recovery. All I could say is that I'm acutely aware of this, and the risk is on my strategy radar. This is another reason to probably add a long volatility hedge to my portfolio of recommendation.
There is no question that there's a chance that the US election is an inflection point this year in global assets. However, the one thing I would like to really say here is that in my framework, such riots would be more likely to be the spark that starts a global fire.
In other words, they would not be a game changer unless they came in tandem with a worsening global cyclical outlook. And on this, what I'll really be looking at is the Chinese credit impulse, German IFO export expectations, the OECD diffusion index. They all tend to lead the global cycle by a few months, and they're still shining a green light. Well, if I'm starting to see those indices showing the way to a loss of momentum into 2021, Combined with riots in the US, that would certainly make me much more conservative on assets and potentially could turn everything from inflation to deflation.
So in other words, difficult to call from here, but it's clearly something that you need to have on your radar, especially if it's combined with a loss of momentum globally.
Erik Townsend: Well, Juliette, it sounds like from what you've said here and also in your prior answer, the one thing that we can probably agree on is Regardless of which president is elected, or even if we're not sure which president is elected, one thing you can probably count on is we're eventually gonna get to some kind of fiscal package. So, what would stop a vicious cycle from developing where lower confidence leads to higher unemployment in the short term? And, you know, if we're gonna potentially have a pause before we know who's president, then that's gonna delay that fiscal package.
Juliette Declercq: Right.
Erik Townsend: That maybe allows even more time for a vicious cycle to get started. What are the potential consequences of all this?
Juliette Declercq: So, that really brings the Fed back into the forefront really. And in terms of looking for who has my back in the meantime, well, obviously the Fed can't really help Main Street, but it can still help Wall Street. And we have seen now what happened this year in terms of the deluge of liquidity. That's already considerably loosened financial conditions. And that's something that you can observe for yourself on chart 2 of my package.
As far as the Fed is concerned, we've seen a shift to flexible average inflation targeting and an associated de-emphasis of the NAIRU, which is basically nothing short of a revolution.
I really want to highlight that it's a paradigm shift away from more than 2 decades of monetary policy. In a nutshell, the Fed is basically moving away from a rules-based reaction function to a more discretionary one with past inflation misses and employment shortfalls. So shortfalls, not deviations. In other words, you only react to employment when it keeps you dovish. And that basically becomes the whole equation. So just inflation misses and employment shortfalls give you the whole reaction function with basically indefinite flexibility.
Practically, this means that the Fed is looking to overshoot its 2% inflation target whilst completely ignoring Phillips Curve effects. And And that's really important because theoretically, this should avoid a repeat of the past Fed pro-dollar, massively pro-dollar policy mistakes when monetary policy was tightened preemptively, tanking inflation expectations and any chance of hitting the 2% inflation target in the process. So for me, really, that's a shift that should and could, could or should also mark the end of the dollar upward trend. Because we could see real yields easily reach -2% to even like -3% in a recovery. So global financial conditions will continue to ease, but there's obviously a catch.
The Fed is increasingly important to affect the real economy. And what's the point of having an inflation target and moving it around if you're no longer the master of inflation's destiny? And that's where the Fed's newly found flexibility will greatly matter. Because thankfully in this cycle, the trickling down theory, the trickling down theory is the theory that basically pushes central banks to inflate assets in the hope that it eventually creates jobs and trickles down to the poorest cohort. Well, that's no longer the one in use, or at least not the only one in use.
So, the real macroeconomic earthquake is not just the Fed's revolution, but it's that fiscal authorities have plugged this hole by going direct or people's QE. I've actually called it Casa de Papel. So, it's the money printer. The money printer. The money printer, which goes with direct loans to small businesses and direct financial supports to households.
So, the Fed has really just become a liquidity facade, and that promises fireworks and a swift macro revival. Think about it. Before, we had central banks all molded in the same school of thought in charge of the underlying macro trends globally. This power has literally now been transferred to politicians. because they are the ones that are controlling spending. So central banks are now just in charge of monetizing or not.
Needless to say, with such a framework that the Fed's new flexibility is a gift from the gods because it will be greatly needed to respond to various politicians' tantrums.
The other consequence of a sharp increase in what I'm calling economic interventionisms where fiscal policy drives underlying macro trends is much greater volatility in the whole system. So one can no longer take financial stability as a given and be complacent. So forget about risk parity funds and their reliable yearly gains.
I think what we will see eventually is central banks' independence be threatened as governments inflate their debt load away. Or we're going to see their hands tied by much higher inflation prints and they're having to shrink the balance sheet, raise rates, and potentially crash assets in the process.
My point here is that you will not get smooth portfolio returns and should not even assume that they're possible. Passive investments should, in my opinion, be relegated to the past. And my real So, my recommendation today is be in charge of your investment process, invest in your education, understand every drawdown because the macro landscape has changed radically over the COVID-19 crisis. And there's really no return to the sleepy past 2 decades where the only trade in town was effectively selling vol in whatever form you could find.
Erik Townsend: Well, Juliette, thanks for your political and election perspective. Let's move on now to the US dollar, an asset class that you've done a lot of work on and made some really excellent calls on in the past. I got to admit, I'm completely baffled here because I can make a very strong macro argument for why the dollar should appreciate with flight-to-safety trades and so forth. We've got a global pandemic. There's a lot of good reasons to be dollar positive, except for, you know, little minor things like the impending threat of a civil war in the United States, which I certainly don't think is a high-probability outcome. But it's actually a realistic possibility for the first time in my life. Is this dollar positive or dollar negative or dollar volatility or what?
Juliette Declercq: So, I mean, really for me, the dollar outlook fits almost perfectly into the inflation outlook. I think what will drive the dollar going forward is the Fed and US fiscal authorities' ability to debase the dollar through higher inflation. And I should probably add not only their ability, but also their willingness. But I think that at this point, there is no question about the willingness from the Fed and US fiscal authorities to debase the dollar.
As I like to say, as a central bank, you can't just talk the talk, but you must also walk the walk.
Well, in today's macro framework, the Fed is the only developed market central bank with the ability to just do this by breaking the link between forward US interest rates and a recovering outlook. This is really an unprecedented break in years of a really tight correlation. That you can observe for yourself on chart 3 of my chart package.
This is something the ECB or the BOJ do not have the luxury of doing. They cannot loosen domestic financial conditions by keeping the curve flat for the good reason that their respective yield curves were already as flat as a crepe before the crisis hit.
So we really have a divergence between what the Fed can do, And what other central banks can do. The second thing is that even if European countries finally got their act together in issuing euro bonds, and they're basically unlocking the fiscal side, we'll still have the so-called frugals dragging their feet on spending.
What it means is that cooperation between the US fiscal authorities and the Fed is potentially much more powerful and potent in terms of generating inflation than their counterparts in Europe or Japan, which means that you shouldn't be looking at nominal yields driving the dollar going forward, but real yields.
And whoever can generate the most inflation and debase their currency is going to be the one winning a sort of FX war. So I really think it's no surprise to hear Fed members scrambling to call for forgetting deficits for now. What I mean here is that US real yields may well collapse further, possibly towards like -2.5%. I wouldn't rule out -3%.
And that the ECB and BOJ will be much better at preserving your purchasing power, not because they want it, but because they have no other choices. So, I mean, if you look at euro and Japan real yields, they're already much much higher than US real yields. In fact, Japan real yields are positive and you could argue quite attractive.
The last thing I would like to add is that all the ones who have rightly called for the dollar to weaken in the past 3, 4 months have mostly now recommended to take profits, whether because the ECB will resist the move or because they consider that the adjustment has happened.
For me, this is really completely the wrong way to look at things because the dollar is literally a momentum animal. You can see that on chart 4 that I'm providing in the chart pack. Dollar upside momentum has literally collapsed. And I think that's really a game changer because the dollar is an object in motion that stays in motion. And the reason, I'll explain it shortly, is that it's the world's reserve currency.
Basically, that means that a dollar move is self-reinforcing and it basically changes the trend and gives this trend staying power. Why? Because it's involved in a large majority of transactions globally. So that literally means that a dollar decline increases global liquidity, loosens financial conditions abroad, and especially in emerging markets where funding vulnerabilities improve linearly with lower dollar prices.
We obviously also get higher commodity prices worldwide and rising global prices. And that also means domestically that import prices will increase. My point here is that the dollar is a heavily countercyclical asset, as you can verify for yourself on chart 5. So the looser global financial conditions improve the cyclical outlook, and in turn, it also weakens the dollar in a move that becomes almost self-fulfilling.
So to the question, I've seen many commentators saying that Christine Lagarde looked a bit soft. On pushing back against euro strength and effectively dollar weakness at the last ECB meeting, I would reply that it's completely the wrong narrative. I think she was soft on purpose because she knows that global financial conditions are much more important even in Europe than domestic financial conditions.
In other words, a broad dollar slide is much more beneficial to European growth than a one-off 10% euro devaluation. And the same goes for Japan. In other words, I really think that the ECB's failure to answer to the recent euro appreciation is intentional and part of what we may call in a few months the Plaza Accord 3 or something. But I really think that the dollar slide has only just started, that it's not only the way forward, But the only way forward. And I think really all the main central banks are going to be jumping on board and not push back except for smoothing the trend.
You're probably going to be asking on my view on risk in general. I'll say that as far as stocks are concerned, even after the recent 5-month rally, I still don't really see valuation as an obstacle to much greater gains. What I think though is that we need a much broader leadership. For the move to remain sustainable.
And I think that's, that's what really is happening in the past 2 weeks. I think we could see the rally rotate to become more centered on cyclicals and also non-US stocks, because relative valuations are completely out of whack with my view of a strong cyclical and earnings recovery into 2021.
If you add to that view of earnings recovery, my view that real yields will continue to fall and that will basically keep multiples elevated. I think the greatest risk still at this point is perhaps to be too conservative into the election because of higher volatility and get caught naked, e.g., having to chase financial assets higher.
But the message that I really want to come across and that I will repeat here is that this view could change quickly because we're headed to a much more unstable macro environment.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, I want to go back to what you said about US real yields possibly collapsing further down toward -2.5% to -3%. Give us a little bit more color both on when you say real yields, obviously that's the nominal yield adjusted for inflation. What kind of nominal yields are you talking about? Are you talking about, say, the US 10-year going negative and that's how we get after inflation to that -2.5%? Or are you saying inflation grows to the point where positive yields on a nominal basis still result in a -3% on a real basis because the inflation is running higher than 3%?
Juliette Declercq: So, what I'm talking about is basically nominal staying capped by whether it's going to be QE, whether it's going to be YCC, or whether it's going to be really strong forward guidance, which I expect will be announced tomorrow. So literally 10-year yields capped below 1%. And I really see real yields collapsing on inflation going higher. So if you just get the Fed managed to overshoot its inflation target, we are talking about potentially like 2.5%.
So that would basically take real yields down to 2%. But obviously what they want is actually to overshoot. So you could get to like 3% on 10-year breakevens with like nominals still below 1. That takes you closer to 3%. And obviously, you know, all I'm seeing— and, you know, I can't show you like all my charts here— but what I'm saying from the end of this recession is much stronger inflation trends than we have seen in the past, which is really completely in agreement with my view that the macro landscape has really been revolutionized. And that's really on the back of central banks not being in charge anymore, but governments.
Erik Townsend: And obviously that's the door open Juliette, before we close, I know that at JDI Research, you primarily focused on institutional clients only when I first met you, but I know you've actually got several high net worth families and family offices who are MacroVoices listeners that are now subscribing to your products. So, tell us a little bit more about what you do, who it's for, and what's involved.
Juliette Declercq: Yes. So, I founded JDI Research 5 years ago now. What's been actually really interesting this year is you can see a much increased interest from high net worths. And I can certainly see that a lot of Americans particularly are at home ensuring that their retirement is going to be sufficient.
So, there has been a move away from just institutions, to like a more personal advisory. What I do really is publish reports that help you navigate markets with very specific recommendations that this year have been quite successful. And I'm quite proud to see that my framework is continuing to produce exceptional returns. If you want to get in touch, you can reach me at juliette.declercq@jdiresearch.com, or you can visit jdiresearch.com website and contact us through there. As usual, I'll make a small effort of an offer for MacroVoices listeners, and that's something I only do once a year. So really all I can say is get in touch to see if our interests can converge.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, thanks so much for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor. Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade. But the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with FarmTogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com.
Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Juliette back on the show. And, you know, when, when she started talking about breakevens and the idea that real yields could see, you know, -2, -3% levels. It really resonated with me because that's— I've had a lot of similar views in this kind of bigger financial repression regime that we're moving into.
And so, it just was really nice to see her perspective on that. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I picked up on the same conversation that you did, and I think she actually said -3.5% on negative real yields in the United States. Of course, my first reaction as a gold bull is to say, okay, nothing is better for the gold market than negative real returns, negative real yields. So, it certainly portends a very positive message for gold. And I think her logic is really spot on. The US 10-year, I don't know if it can go negative, but I agree with Juliette that there's a lot of policy reasons that they're not going to let it go back up a lot. They really can't afford to. And it is within the Fed's control to stop that from happening.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: happening. Now, the usual argument for why they wouldn't be able to stop it is they have to let it go higher in order to prevent inflation from running away. The thing is, the Fed's not afraid of inflation. The Fed is wishing for inflation.
So, I think she's right about that. And I think she's right that inflation will pick up.
Erik Townsend: Remains to be seen how long that will take. Meanwhile, Patrick, I want to move on now to your postgame chartbook, which is titled, Is That the Best the Bulls Could Do? Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com. Look for the red button that says, looking for the downloads, just above Juliette's picture. Patrick, let's look at this S&P 500 chart. Was that the best the bulls could do?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, we talked about the bounce at the 50-day moving average, and almost always there's a buy-on-dip reflexive rally that typically happens at key oversold moments on intraday markets. I was expecting expecting there to be even a rally that could have gone up to 3,450 to 3,500 on a quick reaction. Instead, the rallies kept getting faded. Even the initial strength that came on after the Fed meeting was almost immediately hammered to the downside. That type of price action usually suggests that there's more selling to come and that the distribution cycle is not fully played out.
Now, one of the things that I want to talk about in the theme here is talking about the big FAANG stocks, the Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, Google crowd. And really one of the big things is that they've been very weak. We'll get to those charts in a moment. And there's a lot of people talking about rotation and saying, well, that's just an asset rotation and that we're going to move into cyclicals and other types of assets as they move away from these and that this is just healthy. But the thing that I kind of reflect on and is like, well, that's not going to help the indices at all because when you look at how how big of a weighting the FAANG stocks have on both the S&P 500 and the NASDAQ, I don't know how much broad market breadth the rest of the indices would have to have to make up for the pummeling that would be happening if we continue to see distribution in the FAANG group.
And so just as an example here, you can see the S&P 500, 20% of the weighting is in just the top 5 stocks that are all FAANG stocks essentially. And so it's such a huge market cap weighting. I even If there is just a sector rotation, I just don't see how the indices are going to be able to hold up in that kind of a rotation.
When we go to chart 3, page 3, sorry, and you look at the NASDAQ, the top 6 stocks, which adds Tesla into the mix, account for 45% of the weighting of that index in just 6 names. And so to me, if these 6 stocks, 5, 6 stocks have started to sell, the indices have a lot more to go on the downside. It's just going to be so hard, even if we see those sectors like potentially the energy stocks or other cyclical mining stocks doing well, I just don't think they'll be able to help these broader indices.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I definitely see a story forming here because if I look at page 2, the S&P 500 might have just barely poked below that 50-day moving average, but only on an intraday basis. You haven't got to close below it. We haven't got a confirmed signal yet. Yet that it's going lower. But then as we look at the NASDAQ on page 3, okay, it's already today, you know, got a closing print clearly below the line. That's more of a tech-heavy stock. But if we then move on to page 4, where we start to get into the actual FAANG stocks, we've got entire candles below the line. So, it seems exactly as you're saying, that it's the FAANG stocks that are leading the way lower. And the FAANG stocks, if they're going to be the controlling force in this market, you care about what they're doing.
And they're already showing closing prints below the line.
Patrick Ceresna: Very oversold, but also incredibly weak and heavily distributed charts on all of the FAANG stocks. You got Facebook breaking to fresh lows. The only thing Facebook's going to lean on is the fact that the June-July highs are all just below around the 245 level. So that with it so oversold, maybe they'll, they'll leave room for a little bit of a bounce in that area. But a very negative breakdown of this chart. And you can even just imagine that ascending trend line connecting all of the lows being violated and broken. It really does feel like some bigger correction in these, these NASDAQs and FAANG stocks is underway. When we go to Apple on page 5, break of the 50-day moving average, breaking that trend line slowly on the downside. You take Amazon on page 6, same thing, breaking below the 50-day moving averages, has already broken its ascending trend line connecting those bottoms. It's the same story on every one of these.
I don't think we have to overtalk each one. You can see that on the Microsoft chart breaking down. You can see it on the Google chart start breaking down. This does not look healthy at all.
It really, to me, is saying that there's more for this correction. I mean, the bigger question is, is this a correction or can it materialize into a far more ominous liquidity event that could actually really downdraft the market? And while there's always a possibility of that, I think still my base case right now is that this is just going to be a proper and deep mean reversion of this robust rally. But I mean, when these things take a life of their own, as we have CTAs start flipping and all these vol-targeting funds having to start adjusting positions and all the quarterly rebalancing that's happening in so many of these different portfolios, who knows how much selling pressure can really start to feed on itself and if there's a negative feedback loop that kicks in, especially next week after the gamma pins start rolling off on the option expiry.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to slide 9. Here's the Euro Stoxx Index again. Boy, still right in the middle of that sideways range. sideways consolidation pattern that really has been in place since the beginning of June.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And I think this is the other key thing to watch. For me, right now, all we've really seen is a blow-off top of a lot of these FAANG stocks that really kind of took the momentum of the Apple and Tesla stock splits and this kind of little gamma drag higher on the upside that was happening. And it kind of blew off and put some short-term tops in all of those tech names. But the broader markets have not broken. We haven't seen a big breakdown in the Russell. We haven't seen global equity, and this is why I put the Euro Stoxx up here, break.
And I think that this is actually the canary in the coal mine to watch, the Euro Stoxx or any of the other major global indices. Because if this is just the NASDAQ stocks correcting and it doesn't spill into everything else, then maybe this is not going to be as deep of a correction as I feel it will be. But if we start seeing the developed markets around the world kind of catch the cold and start getting sick from the turning of these markets and we start seeing the breakdown in the developed markets, I think that that could actually add the fuel to make this a much deeper and more pronounced market correction. And so, so long as these stay stable and trading sideways, this could just be a NASDAQ move.
Patrick Ceresna: And that's why I think watching this into next week is going to be so important. With that said, Erik, how could we not put together a chart book without a couple oil charts here?
So you also have one on the term structure. So let's talk about this. What's your thinking here on this chart on oil?
Erik Townsend: Well, as you've drawn in here, we've been above the 50-day moving average all the way since, you know, the middle of May, the end of May, and it's been holding very well. We've been coiling up, waiting for some kind of move. I've been, you know, anticipating a move down to lower prices, not because I'm bearish long-term, but just because I think the rally was a little overdone. We needed some kind of natural correction. I thought it would go deeper than it did. And as you see, yesterday we got right back up to the 50. That would be your classic retest the previous support level as a resistance level. I was expecting it to stop there and for today to be another down day. Now, today was the JMMC meeting. So it may be that this is a pop and drop, a false breakout back above that 50-day, all about to retrace still to get to lower numbers.
I was originally expecting somewhere around $32, $33 be where the final low was going to be on this move before into Q4 as US production starts falling off, catching down to the rig count, so to speak, that we would eventually get a move much higher.
So, that's kind of the way that I see the flat price chart. Now, as far as trading this, my favorite instrument is actually not to trade the front month contract because it's so volatile and it's so subject to a A lot of gyrations when OPEC does their jawboning and so forth. So, moving on to page 11, this is my favorite instrument for trading the long side of this market, which is what is known to futures traders as the Z1-Z2 spread, the difference between the price of December 2021 futures and the price of December 2022 futures. There's a number of reasons that I prefer to trade the time spread as opposed to the outright futures contracts, the flat price or the front month price as it's known in the industry.
The first reason is that, as I said, it tends to be less volatile and less subject to short-term disruptions. You get a little storm in the Gulf of Mexico, it's not going to have a really big impact on a time spread that's, you know, a year and a half, 2 years into the future.
But more importantly, Patrick, what this bet really is, is a bet on a move back to backwardation.
And I'm convinced that we will get back to structural backwardation as the oil market rebalances after this crazy dislocation that we've had as a result of COVID-19 creating a short-term excess of oil. So that we've got too much oil, not enough tanks to store it in. I'm convinced that situation will rectify itself and we'll get back to Structural backwardation, which is what makes this trade pay off. What I'm not convinced of is whether that's going to happen at much higher oil prices, or if we might just get that shift into backwardation at current oil prices. Because although on the one hand, there's a lot of supply destruction leading to higher prices, it may be that we have some economic downside, which tends to result in lower prices. Even if the price doesn't go up that much, I still think we get back to a structurally backwardated market, and that will cause this spread to appreciate potentially considerably more than the front month price would be appreciating in sympathy with it.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to chart 12, Patrick, you've got a natural gas chart. And boy, if you want to find one that the 50-day moving average didn't support, I guess you found it, didn't you?
Patrick Ceresna: Oh yeah. But what's interesting is that what's happening in natural gas and particularly the term structure, because this is the October 2020 contract, which last trading day is just like 10 days away. It's September 28th is the last trading day and they're hammering it. But the whole term structure isn't selling, it's just the front month. And what we are seeing is that it's pushing the term structure into like super contango.
And so when we go on to page 13, we can see just how big of a collapse this is. When we're just going out 1, 2, and 3 months out from here into the futures contracts, we still have natural gas trading almost at actually over $3.20. And so this is going to be an interesting thing as they roll it up. And so I asked the question, why is this happening? And what's interesting is that immediately I think back to what happened with oil.
And I'm thinking that that UNG ETF is still only rolling front-month natural gas contracts. And I'm wondering whether this is the market basically playing the ETF roll What's your take on all of that?
Erik Townsend: Well, it could be that people are gaming the ETF roll That certainly is a favorite pastime of energy traders, as we know from the experience with the USO ETF. But I think I think there are other explanations here. At this time of year, the reason that the later months are not selling off is we're coming into the time of year where there's going to be more demand for natural gas for heating, whereas the inventory that's available right now, because storage costs are so high and storage logistics are so complex with nat gas, it could be that the last of that summer gas has gotten No place to go. Nobody wants it. They feel that they have got plenty of supply, and it's just a short-term imbalance in the physical market. This is one of those things, you know, to be a gas trader, you've really got to understand the physical market. And most people in energy trading either become expert in this stuff or they have the wisdom not to touch it because they're not expert in it.
I count myself in the latter group. I don't know enough about nat gas logistics and storage concerns and so forth to tell you what's going on here. But it feels to me like it's about a short-term imbalance in the physical delivery market and somebody not having enough space to store
Erik Townsend: that gas in. And speaking of making yourself expert in a subject, for anyone who wants to get more of Patrick's terrific chart books, he does this almost every day of the week, 4 webinars a week. And Big Picture Trading. You can find information on how to get a free trial on page 14 of the chart deck. We're going to leave it there for this week's episode. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors, and by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit macrovoices.com/sponsorinfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our post-game chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Juliette's slide deck and the chartbook that we just discussed in the post-game. There's also a link to an article discussing JP Morgan's near-term risks for the stock market, as well as a link to a Bloomberg article discussing Bridgewater's recent losses. So, you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup.
So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Of MacroVoices, be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to Mailbag@MacroVoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our Mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com. MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Mike Green — Logica Funds Chief Strategist (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 236 was recorded on September 10th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors. Logica Funds Chief Strategist Mike Green joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Mike's received quite a lot of attention for his research on the reflexive effects of passive investing on market price action, so we'll start there before moving on to the US dollar, inflation, gold, digital reserve currencies, and much more. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will discuss everything from the S&P 500 to gold, Tesla, and a whole bunch more.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, where do we start this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, I want to start before we even get to stocks with the, the big picture that I'm thinking about is I'm really convinced that unfortunately the political unrest, the civil unrest in the United States is most likely to escalate really from now through Inauguration Day, not Election Day, but Inauguration Day. And in fact, I think it's the period from Election Day to Inauguration Day that is probably going to be the most tumultuous. And the reason I say that is we've got a situation here where both sides have already said they're not going to concede the election when it appears that they've lost. And I think the setup for now is, of course, we're already seeing an escalation of unrest, but For now, everybody can kind of hope that their guy wins. Once we get to Election Day, I think that for the first time in years, the whole country will agree on one thing, which is my guy won. Whoever I voted for won the election.
Everybody will be convinced that their candidate won, and they'll be convinced that it was clear and obvious and everyone should agree, and they won't. And that really sets up what I think could be extreme contention, first in the nation's history, which is really there's not that much time for court cases and so forth to play out between Election Day and Inauguration Day. So from Election Day at the beginning of November until Inauguration Day on the 20th of January, I think we really are looking at the potential for a situation where there is extreme disagreement, division, and unfortunately violence in the United States because everybody disagrees about who is really the president at that point. Now, what does it mean for markets? Obviously, the instinctive intuitive thing is, well, that must be very bearish for markets. Realize that if you look at history and what it teaches us, civil unrest like occurred in 1968 really is not that much of a negative influence on markets and sometimes very similar to what happens when a war breaks out.
Everybody says, oh my God, a war, sell everything quick, it's a war. Then they realize, wait a minute, if you look at history, wars are generally positive for the stock market. After a brief panic down, you end up seeing a steady climb. Certainly, if those predictions play out, it's going to mean more accommodation from the Fed. Potentially, that leads us to asset prices, including stocks, moving even higher. So I don't pretend to know how it's gonna play out, but unfortunately, my prediction is it's gonna be a lot of turbulence between now and the middle of January.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's jump into that S&P 500. The correction continued at the start of the week. We finally got the bounce. What's your take on the S&P here?
Erik Townsend: Well, clearly the correction itself is no surprise after the parabolic rise that we were seeing. The correction could be over, but, you know, as I look at the chart, I mean, you're the technician in the house, Patrick, but as I look at this chart, I see about a 3,230 level on S&P futures as what seems to me like the logical test of support where resistance used to be. That was, you know, the previous high that we had a few months ago.
I would expect to maybe retest that level. So it feels to me Like this is the dead cat bounce and the correction's not over yet. But frankly, we've had a lot of surprise strength in this stock market. Maybe it's over, I don't know.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, we'll talk more about that in the postgame 'cause I have a chart that I wanna talk about on the S&P. But anyway, let's move on to that US dollar because it really felt like the US dollar was gaining some traction. Definitely some volatility in the last 24 hours, particularly on this ECB monetary policy statement. But overall, the dollar is nowhere near the lows It was at the start of September. Do you think we're forming a bottom or is there more downside?
Erik Townsend: I don't think you can make an argument based on technicals that we're forming a bottom. Clearly, we're seeing a textbook bounce off of that low close below 92, or I guess it was an intraday below 92. We never closed below 92 on the dollar index. At 93.18 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon mid-session, I think you got to see a daily close above 94 to make a technical argument that says a trend reversal is in play. This looks to me like a consolidation. Maybe it's ending, maybe not. Can't tell. Certainly, if my civil unrest predictions prove true, that potentially could be a negative catalyst for more downside, and perhaps the bottom is not in yet.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to crude oil because I really wanted your take on this. And we were just hovering above that 50-day moving average last week when we were doing the session, and suddenly it gave out, and we saw definitely some heavy selling that saw us solidly below $40 and heading now down, at least on the October contract, down to the $37 handle. What's your take here on crude?
Erik Townsend: Well, finally, the downside correction that I've been calling for, for what, better than 2 months now, is finally upon us. I don't think it's over yet. I mean, you certainly in the last 24 hours, we've got a pretty voracious bounce here that's, that's going on. That bounce was arrested when we got inventory data today. The expectations people had was for another drawdown in inventory, but it turned to be a build. Now remember, we're still coming out of the tropical storm action, and for the weeks immediately after any kind of big weather upset, the data is always a little bit suspect. But what we're seeing is a crude oil build of 2 million barrels, Cushing, Oklahoma building 1.8 million barrels, the finished products drawing down substantially, gasoline drawing down 3 million barrels, distillates drawing down 1.7 million barrels. US production bouncing back up because, of course, The big, big drawdown last week of more than 1 million barrels was because of the tropical storm shutting in most of the Gulf of Mexico.
We're back up 300,000 barrels this week to 10 million even. I think it's got further to bounce to the upside, and it's probably not going to be until we get into Q4 that that real decline that Art Berman has talked about starts to set in and hit us. The tape action, you know, it looked like we maybe had the beginnings of a healthy recovery from this big sell-off. I really don't think it's over yet. I think we've got further to go to the downside. But to whatever extent there was a recovery, the inventory report kind of stopped it. But it didn't bring about a resumption of selling to new lows. So I think the market's just consolidating, trying to figure out what's next. My best guess is the bottom is not in yet. I think this is that bounce that you typically see halfway through a big move. We come from 43 down to what, 36 spot 25 or 30 was the low.
And I think we're gonna see this bounce play out and probably get down into the low 30s before it's over. As far as what's driving this, all of the most knowledgeable people that I follow are really focusing on refinery runs. They're saying, yeah, there's a lot of reason to expect that US production is going to decline into the 4th quarter. But guess what? Refinery runs are telling us that demand might be declining even faster than expected declines in supply.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Supply in coming months. So that demand destruction concern really being driven by reported refinery runs seems to be what's driving the bearishness in the market. As I said, I doubt the bottom is in. We ought to get Art Berman back at some point because he certainly had predictions that in Q4 US production was going to fall off a cliff. We thought that would be bullish. But of course, if demand is going to fall off a cliff, well, that complicates the situation.
So we'll have to look into getting Art back at some point.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's, uh, get an update here on gold because there was obviously a top and a quick correction in the first 2 weeks of August. But really since then, gold has been more or less within like a $50 trade range, give or take, up or down. And we really haven't seen a resolution to— in any directional trend. What's your thinking on where gold is headed next?
Erik Townsend: Well, we certainly have seen some upside this week, but as far as I'm concerned, as you said, it's still a consolidation pattern. We haven't broken above that upper resistance line on the wedge or triangle formation, whatever you want to call this, this formation that has occurred since that sudden correction to the downside. Frankly, I hope as a gold bull that this correction is not over yet. As a bull, I would really like to see this market clean itself up, a nice healthy big correction back down to test $1,800, which was the most significant recent resistance level on the way up. Let's go test that as support before continuing this secular bull market. I I'd like to see that happen. I'd buy a little bit more just above 1,800. As far as where we are right now though, it's a consolidation pattern. It's not clear whether it's gonna break up or down from here.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's leave off by just touching on those 10-year Treasury yields because I personally thought we'd see a bit of a, more of a reaction considering that the markets have started this volatile break to the downside. But really we've been pinned in this incredibly tight range. We're now trading around 68 basis points on the 10-year US Treasury yield. Do you have any opinions here?
Does this make a big move here?
Erik Townsend: Well, if I'm right about civil unrest increasing, it probably would suggest lower Treasury yields during that event. The counterside of that is I think it's going to become very clear that people will demand that there be more accommodation to Main Street, not to Wall Street. I think MMT is definitely coming, and that maybe sets the stage for a return of inflation expectations, which would have the opposite effect. So I really don't have a strong view. As our regular listeners know, I'm trying to ask all of our featured interview guests their views on this, and certainly Mike Green is a perfect guy to ask. I'll be asking him these questions as well.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's featured interview guest is Logica Funds Chief Strategist Mike Green. Erik, why did we invite Mike onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Mike is a guy who, frankly, most of our listeners probably never heard of before. He's been kind of locked away behind a compliance wall in his previous jobs. Now, in his role as Chief Strategist at Logica, he's doing some writing and getting out and doing media interviews. And boy, I really have to hand it to our good friend Grant Williams and his cohort Bill Fleckenstein, who did just a terrific interview with Mike, which really goes into depth on the research Mike's done on passive investing and its reflexive effects on the market. We're going to do a quick summary of that because I think it's very interesting, but we're actually going to defer to Grant's interview. He did such a beautiful job. I'm going to encourage our listeners to listen to that. You'll find the link to Grant's interview with Mike in your Research Roundup email. We're going to do a quick summary of that topic to start this interview, and then we'll launch into a number of other topics that Mike hasn't been talking about in his other media interviews.
Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, We haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure. Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test.
But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Mike Green is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Mike Green, Chief Strategist and Portfolio Manager for Logica Funds. Mike, it's great to get you on the show. This one is, I think, overdue. You've really gotten a lot of popularity lately since you came out from hiding behind the compliance wall that you used to hide behind. Let's start with a topic that I know you've touched on recently in another podcast you did with our good friends Grant Williams and Bill Fleckenstein. They did a series called The Stock Market Endgame, or I guess it was just called The Endgame. And it was fascinating to me to listen to because I used to say the exact same thing almost that Bill said in that series, which is, hey, look, this whole stock market rally since 2009, it's been artificially propelled by monetary policy, not by economic fundamentals. It's artificial, and therefore it has to end badly someday. There has to be eventually a crash of the stock market or something, because there's no free lunch in finance.
That's just not how it works. I've changed my view. I don't really think that's true anymore. I think that it has to end badly, but it's not necessarily nominal down in the stock market. Now, you've done a bunch of research that I think is maybe a little different. I was thinking on the MMT lines of why maybe we just end up seeing more money printing and more inflation and asset prices going up, not down in nominal terms. You've got maybe a different explanation for why we might see that upside. So first of all, do you think I'm right to consider that maybe the stock market doesn't really have to crash ever? after all, just because of this so-called artificial stimulus. And how do you see it? What are the drivers? Let's review some of the research that you've done on active-passive.
Mike Green: So I definitely think that you are both actually hitting on a key point, which is that the market is quote unquote unhealthy, right? So the behavior that we're seeing, most of us who have been involved with markets for an extended period of time, can rationally look at it and say something is off. And a lot of people put it at the feet of the Fed.
My analysis suggests that a more important force is actually the change in market structure driven by the growth of passive investing. And in just really simple terms, the introduction of passive investing changes the character and the behavior of market participants, moving it from a discretionary purchase decision where cash is a legitimate asset that can be held when valuations or economic fundamentals suggest that investing in securities would be unattractive, When you move to a passive framework, it becomes rules literally as simple as, did you give me cash? If so, then buy.
And in reverse, did you ask for cash? If so, then sell, with no consideration for the underlying fundamentals or the economic backdrop in which the events are occurring. That change and the reduction in cash that those funds hold versus traditional vehicles, in our analysis, is actually responsible for the vast majority of the price increase that we've seen relative to the fundamentals. Absolutely, there was an improvement after 2009 as the global financial crisis came to an end that supported recovery in asset prices. And certainly, activities like corporate share buybacks have contributed, as others have noted.
But by far, the dominant feature appears to be this dynamic of passive investing. And as a result, I tend to think that we need to consider both. I think it would be silly to say that markets can't crash. Roughly 5 months after they just did. But I also think that it's very difficult to argue that until those dynamics change, until the flow of money into passive changes, that we're going to see a significant change in the character of this behavior. And I do think there's a very real risk that we break markets by having them go too high.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little more about what you just said. You said the mechanics here are there's no thought to economics. It's basically investors give asset managers money. If so, buy. Why, if investors took money away from asset managers, then sell? Well, the second half of that, I think if we go back to Bill Fleckenstein's logic, is, okay, that means at some point you get a self-reinforcing vicious cycle of withdrawals where investors are taking money away from asset managers. A driver of that might be something like demographics around aging baby boomers, you know, leading to the beginning of something. That develops into a self-reinforcing vicious cycle. So does there have to be, you know, a bad ending for the stock market when eventually that process reverses? And what you're seeing is investors taking money away from asset managers is somehow something changes in the world and passive is no longer the thing anymore?
Mike Green: Well, first, I think it's very difficult to have passive no longer be the thing because I think the arguments for it and the regulatory advantage that have been conferred on it are so extraordinary at this stage. That we're probably going to see this to its logical conclusion. So in really simple terms, most people think about passive in terms of an aggregate share where it's somewhere between— most would say somewhere between 40% and 45% of the total market. We think it's about 44% right now.
If you look at those characteristics and split them by demographics, for those in the younger generation, the vast majority of their exposure, in excess of 90% plus of their exposure to markets as we know them, is through passive products. For those in the older generation, it's much closer to 20%. And so the dynamics in terms of passive penetration suggest that we're going to move increasingly rapidly to a world that looks more and more passive.
And under that type of framework, the models that I have suggest that you should largely expect to see an inflationary condition, right? Not inflation in terms of consumer prices, but inflation in terms of the price that people will be willing to pay and the prices that we'll see in securities markets.
On the other side of that equation, though, is when that is happening, effectively, you could be thinking about the velocity or the volatility of those events as accelerating.
So I've used the analogy, it's like trying to explain to people that the brakes are broken in a car that is traveling uphill. It's actually somewhat irrelevant until you start to head downhill. And then you hit a moment of panic and you're fine as long as the road turns back up at some point. But if you've crested the mountain and come down the other side, and you have no brakes, it becomes a very scary situation. We saw something like that, I would argue, in March.
That characteristic, there's no absolute level that you can point to and say it has to turn down from here when you're talking about this type of dynamic of moving from a population set that holds the majority of the assets that are roughly 20% passive, to a population set that will slowly accumulate those assets through contributions to 401s, bequests, et cetera, that doesn't necessarily have to turn down.
But the dynamics of gravity or the dynamics of how markets are structured suggest that at some point, it's actually likely to.
Now, the simple example for that would be those who are buying in and contributing are doing so in a somewhat linear fashion, right? Their contributions are tied to their incomes. On the other side of the equation, those who are making withdrawals, whether it's because they're hitting retirement age demographics, as you suggest, they are typically taking a fraction or a percentage of their profit or percentage of their securities out.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: When they do that, it means that ultimately you have an increasing mismatch between the contributions coming in from incomes and the withdrawals that are coming out from withdrawals. And that would suggest that there will be a topping point. Right? That's going to happen. Now, that of course has happened in the past. And actually, that's very much what happened in 2002. And you saw the stock market crash over the summer of 2002 into July, August, September.
In response to that, we have repeatedly seen central banks or policymakers step in to create substantive changes, whether that is inflating the value of bonds by cutting interest rates, directly purchasing securities, as we've seen in other geographies, changing the 401 rules, right, so that contributions can be delayed for a longer period of time or that they can be increased, or to create tax incentives for employers to increase their contributions and thereby raise the quantity of money that is going in. Those are all actions that I think that we should anticipate.
Ultimately, it's a question of will you be aggressive enough to stop it, right? And will you permanently break the markets at some point? To me, that's unknowable, right? So we remain agnostic. The trading position that we take at Logica is effectively we buy straddles. We want to participate in both directions.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, I'm going to take a quick break here. I wanted to start with this topic of the influence of passive investing on the market, give you a little bit of a teaser of that, because Mike's work in this space is obviously Really, really groundbreaking, I think. We've got a couple of resources for you to go further on this. The first is a slide deck you'll find linked in your Research Roundup email, which gives a bunch of graphs and charts supporting this discussion of the influence of the transition from active to passive investing.
Now, we could easily spend the rest of today's interview entirely on that topic. The thing is, our good friend Grant Williams did such a fantastic job of that on a podcast that's already been recorded. I'd really like to get to new ground with— With you. Mike in today's podcast. We're going to just go ahead and give you a link to Grant Williams' podcast along with Bill Fleckenstein interviewing in much greater detail Mike on this subject of the transition from active to passive and its systemic and reflexive impacts on the market. It's really fascinating stuff. I recommend that you download the chart deck from the MacroVoices Research Roundup, have that in front of you when you listen to Mike's interview with Grant and Bill.
Mike Green: Thanks, Patrick.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on, Mike, to a few other topics. Now, you think about this whole stock market, where is it headed, what's the ultimate endgame in terms of the passive trend? A lot of people, and I'm not sure if they're right or wrong, I've definitely kind of gotten on board with this myself lately, have felt like, look, since 2009, ever since quantitative easing has been the thing, it seems like the stock market can only go up. So there's some transmission mechanism, although people seem to disagree on the extent to which it exists, how much of it is just expectation versus reality. Somehow it seems like when the Fed expands its balance sheet, the money all ends up in the stock market. And a lot of people are thinking that with the rapidly growing political popularity of MMT, that probably that trend is set to continue. How do you see this? Are the people who think QE drives the stock market Right?
Are they wrong? If so, in either direction, why? And what about MMT? How does that change the game?
Mike Green: Well, so in simple terms, like, there's nobody who's right or wrong until history tells us which— what's the right answer, right? So we have our view on that. There is obviously an impact from QE, right? There is, uh, when, when the Fed goes out and expands its balance sheet, in particular if it is using the expansion of that balance sheet to purchase assets from the private sector, it's doing 2 things. One is it's raising the price of those assets because they become protected to the downside. Effectively, you're abrogating the left tail.
You're also, in some situations, forcing people to find alternate uses of that capital. So, if I buy a corporate bond from a hedge fund, they now have cash that they have to deploy And potentially have more cash than it was marked on their book or the way they were treating it if they had had to sell it to a third party into an illiquid market.
So those dynamics absolutely create stimulus and absolutely support asset prices. The question is, does that actually flow through in any meaningful way into economic activity? And we're not seeing any meaningful evidence of that. Right. Among other things, if we look at the pace of growth associated with those dynamics, we don't see an awful lot of evidence of it.
We see market-based measures like inflation expectations as proxied by TIPS. Those tend to show the sort of recovery that people would refer to. But there's an alternate explanation for that that's embedded in terms of how those are calculated. TIPS themselves have a premium associated with volatility in one form or another.
So I'm skeptical that it does what people think it does.
On the MMT front, I completely agree that that is growing in importance and credibility. We have not yet meaningfully seen the impact of that. The supports that we've seen in terms of a variant of universal basic income for those who are on unemployment was a very brief and fleeting experience that we've seen for, give or take, 4 months in the United States and in some other geographies to a lesser measure.
But we're a long way away from a world in which everybody is receiving a significant guaranteed income from the government, and the government has almost no considerations for how that actually plays through. So if that MMT world were actually in place, I would expect that we would've seen a much more aggressive expansion of corporate profits, of household incomes, et cetera.
And the evidence is weak at this stage that that's in play.
Erik Townsend: Going back to your comment about quantitative easing not feeding through to the real economy, only affecting asset markets, proponents of MMT would say that was the injustice of bailing out Wall Street at the expense of Main Street. And the whole idea of MMT is it's going to use balance sheet expansion of the central bank in order to deliver real benefits and results to the broader, actual real economy. Skeptics of MMT have said, yeah, that's true, but it's going to result in runaway inflation because as you're delivering money into the real economy, not just into the financial economy, now you're going to start to experience runaway consumer price inflation. Are those arguments right? And what are the potential consequences for markets as MMT gains traction, as I expect it will, in political circles?
Mike Green: So I share your view that MMT ultimately will gain increased traction. And I do think that that is likely to be an inflationary force. In its simplest form, we can think about price behavior, which is what we're trying to measure in inflation, inflation being technically an increase in the general price level.
We can think about that as having 2 separate sources. One is the type of support that you're describing, which is effectively consumption subsidy. So a fiscal transfer to households without significant strings or expectations of a clawback in the form of increased taxes, that is going to lead to an increase in consumption.
And so on net, that is going to shift outward an aggregate demand curve. It is unclear how the supply will respond. And that ultimately is what holds the key to this. If we start to move in a pattern that restricts supply on a systematic basis, that would include things like increases in corporate taxes, increases in interest rates, a reduction in the ability to execute global free trade or subsidize trade from foreign countries in the case of China.
If we are unwilling to allow those sources of supply to rise to meet the increase in demand, then sure, you'll see an increase in the general price level. If that increase in the general price level is in turn met by additional consumption support, additional subsidies, an increase in the minimum universal basic income that is distributed to households, then yes, you can set off an inflationary cycle.
But that's several steps into the future. We're not there yet. And if anything, most of the behavior that we're seeing, particularly coming out of the coronavirus experience, has been that households have taken that additional income and used it to purchase things like durable goods, new houses, new cars, or used cars are in high demand because of the reduction of supply, appliances of various types, leisure craft, Those have exploded, and those are one-time purchases.
You're not going to buy a second RV next year if you bought one this year. You may increase some aspects of it, but actually, ironically, you're less likely to stay at a hotel next year because you now have an RV. You are less likely to do many of the activities on the services front that you might have done historically when you take a vacation.
You're less likely to travel in an airplane, for example. So it's not at all clear that we have created a permanent outward shift in demand.
What there has largely been to this point is a significant substitution of durable goods for services. We're not going back to the restaurant anytime soon. I'm certainly not going to eat 2 steak dinners next year to compensate for the one I missed this year. So we've seen a component of that, but it's not at all clear to me that that's sustainable. And if anything, it may set the stage for recessionary conditions in 2021.
Erik Townsend: A lot of people are debating the question of whether we are on the precipice of a shift that might take a few years, but a shift to secular inflation, and that perhaps MMT would be the catalyst that would get us there after this— what is it— 35-year bond bull market now. Some people are saying, okay, we got all the way to almost zero. It's time for that to reverse. But frankly, people have been saying that for like 15 years, and so far they've been wrong. How do you see this? Is the bond bull market coming to an end? Is there a secular shift to inflation? And are those things necessarily even correlated?
Mike Green: So they tend to be correlated to the extent that policymakers respond to them, right? So if the Fed responds to an increase in inflation by hiking interest rates to try to stop that inflation, then obviously you will generate correlation, although the causation will be reversed, right? That was largely the story.
I can flip the story of the bond bull market for the past 40 years on its head and— obviously not quite 40 years, but I can flip it on its head and say the reverse of that is that we had inappropriately tight monetary policy over the time period from 1965 to 1982.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: And so instead of thinking about it from the framework of we have had this extraordinary recovery, I would actually suggest that we had an extended time period in which monetary policy ran way too tight relative to the expansion of the labor force and the population and the desire for consumption of durable goods under that setting.
So people tend to confuse the story of the 1970s. They think of it as a hyperinflationary type environment that the US was losing control. What was really happening in the 1970s was that we had an unprecedented expansion of households and labor force. All of which needed new durable goods to meet their consumption objectives. The Fed misinterpreted that information, hiked interest rates to levels that they never should have been hiked to, and in response created the conditions of the resurgence that we've seen over the past, give or take, 35 to 40 years.
Erik Townsend: Mike, I want to pick up on the word hyperinflation that you just used because I notice a resurgence in popularity of this term. And particularly a phrase you just alluded to. You'll hear people say, look, we're going to have hyperinflation, just like the hyperinflation we had in the 1970s. Now, to my understanding of the textbook definition of that phrase, hyperinflation, what happened in the 1970s has nothing to do with hyperinflation. Please define exactly what does hyperinflation mean? Was the 1970s event or other similar periods of inflation running up into the teens on an annual basis?
Mike Green: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Is that hyperinflation or is hyperinflation something different?
Mike Green: Hyperinflation is something totally different. So I'm going to get the technical definition wrong because it's somewhat irrelevant, but the technical definition of hyperinflation is somewhere in the neighborhood of 15% inflation per month, not per year. And so by an order of magnitude, we never came close to achieving hyperinflation in the United States.
What we saw in the 1970s was a fantastic shift outward in the aggregate demand function tied to the baby boomers, tied to women entering the labor force, tied to minorities entering the labor force and the simultaneous restriction of supply that was created by the Fed's inappropriately tight monetary policy, right? So they effectively prevented the supply curve from shifting outwards. And we had the really unfortunate dynamic associated with the oil shocks, et cetera, that took roughly a third of the production capacity in the US, combination of the less unfortunate Clean Air Act and the oil shocks of the 1970s, That had the unfortunate impact of shifting inward the US production curve. About a third of production going into the 1970s was tied to oil-fired generators.
That dynamic is just radically, radically different than the collapse of a currency and the collapse of a social system, effectively the ability to tax to recover currency that occurs in hyperinflationary environments.
People tend to completely conflate the two. I agree with your pushback We did not have hyperinflation. I think it would be extraordinarily unlikely that we have hyperinflation in the United States, although we certainly could have higher levels of inflation for the reasons we've been talking about. But the underlying characteristic is just a radically different environment.
Erik Townsend: I think this is really important for listeners to understand because a trend that I'm seeing is people, for good reason, think that there is a macro argument that we may be headed for a secular shift back toward inflation from disinflation. I think they're right about that. What they're doing is they're going and researching the Weimar hyperinflation and various other hyperinflations like Zimbabwe that have happened throughout history. And I would argue a hyperinflation like Weimar or Zimbabwe is a completely different phenomenon from secular high inflation like we had in the 1970s.
It's the collapse of a currency system. Prices are not going up. The value of money is collapsing, and it creates the illusion of prices going up. But I think what's missing here is okay. There's really no sane reason to think that the U.S. dollar, at least while it still holds its title as global reserve currency, that's something I want to I want to come back to a little bit later on. But as long as it's still the global reserve currency, I don't think true hyperinflation is even possible.
But a return to secular inflation along the lines of what we really did have in the 1970s seems entirely possible, especially in the wake of MMT. So what if we shouldn't be trying to compare this to Weimar Germany or Zimbabwe? What is it that investors should really be looking at? What do we need to get up to speed on here?
Mike Green: Well, I would suggest that you actually want to look at time periods where we have had inflation driven by the forces that you're talking about. And so a good example of that would actually be the US environment And post the Roosevelt depreciation of the dollar, Luke Gromen and others talk about that dynamic. I think it's important to understand that you can't actually have that type of depreciation. You can't have a devaluation of a currency that has a flexible exchange. That happens in the markets.
And so you would have to see that currency fall significantly versus other currencies, including gold. That would be one example. But it's very difficult to actually execute that in a system in which you have a floating system, because the market would do that for you before you decided to do it. It would recognize that this dynamic existed.
If you look at the 1930s, basically after, give or take, 1934, we tend to think about that period as one that has deflationary characteristics, but actually average CPI inflation over that time period was north of 4%. And it was driven by precisely the features that we're talking about, restriction of supply, The forcing of crops to be fallow, of croplands to be fallow, the FDR administration paying people to not plant, restrictions on production in terms of what was allowed to be produced in factories.
Those types of dynamics led to inflationary conditions. But that type of moderate inflation is both largely benign and highly unlikely to show up in a bond market. In terms of a Federal Reserve policy response. And 2, I think largely people misunderstand the dynamics or the importance of that, right? Because that type of inflation, by and large, is just a modest loss of purchasing power. It's not a collapse of the currency.
It's not an impetus to rush off into alternative currencies or to try to protect your assets.
I think you need to be just very cognizant that we could enter into a regime that because of restrictions of supply, i.e., reduced supply from China or other regions, that we could have inflationary conditions. Now, some of those conditions are also very difficult to point to and say that they're equivalent. So global population was growing rapidly over that time period. Over the time period of the 1930s, the US labor force and population grew by roughly 25%.
We just don't have those conditions in the developed world. If anything, we're actually seeing negative population pressures in most regimes. And that tends to result in an inward shift of aggregate demand. That would be even worse if we're talking about a situation where aggregate supply is restricted and therefore purchasing power or surplus is reduced.
So I think you could actually end up with a low inflation, but very stagnant type environment for an extended period of time if that's the outcome. That tends to lead to increased political pressure for even more MMT and conflict for finding somebody else to blame. I do think that there are features of that that exist.
Erik Townsend: Now, what a lot of people are predicting is that if that type of inflation resurfaces and there is still an impetus for the government to try to to maintain the lowest interest rates that it possibly can, which seems to be the policy directive for now. That leads to negative real rates. That has to be good for gold. Gold bugs are jumping for joy, expecting $10,000 gold prices by the end of next year. Or maybe that's an exaggeration, but certainly by the end of the decade, a lot of people think we're going to, you know, somewhere between $5,000 and $10,000 an ounce gold. Because of these policies and this potential inflation shift that they see on the horizon. Is that sane thinking? Is that the right way to think about this, or are they missing something?
Mike Green: Well, I think it's certainly possible, right? I mean, for gold to go to, give or take, $5,000 within a decade would really only be a rate of appreciation somewhere in the neighborhood of 7%, right? Is that impossible? No.
Is it a probable outcome? It really depends, right? I mean, one of the things that we wrote about in March was the dynamics of policy response. And we're seeing that play out in real time, where increasingly policymakers turn to risk markets and say, what does the expectations channel tell us about forward economic activity? In March, it was very clear that we were facing the worst recession in history. We'd had the biggest stock market, the most rapid stock market collapse outside of what we saw in the market event of 1987.
And since then, we've seen the most rapid recovery. And as a result, we're seeing policymakers dither in terms of their response function. Do we need another significant correction to get them to take that next step? I would suggest that it's much harder for policymakers to behave in a radical fashion unless we receive those types of signals.
And so I would just broadly suggest that the answer is it depends. If events conspire to force a very aggressive response, then yes, gold will probably appreciate quite significantly. Will it go to $10,000? And would we expect $10,000 to— would we expect the behavior that we're seeing in terms of multiple expansion, would that be consistent with gold going to $10,000? Actually, it's one of the things that we're doing some work on right now. History would suggest the opposite is true, that if gold is going to go to $10,000, that actually an equity risk premium or the PEs you would expect to contract dramatically. Because you don't pay a lot for property rights, which is really what you're doing when you buy an equity. You don't pay a lot for that in an unstable system. And it's part of the reason why emerging markets tend to trade at a discount, despite what many view as better growth opportunities.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: You just— the stability of the system is not such that you can look at an equity and say, I'm going to pay 10 years' worth of revenue or 100 times earnings, For a company. It just doesn't make any sense.
Erik Townsend: Mike, something I've been thinking about for more than a decade is whether the US dollar's days are numbered as the world's global reserve currency. And it seems like that topic has gained a lot of popularity lately. Seems to me like what this really comes down to is the US dollar remains the world's global reserve currency for one reason and one reason only, which is there simply is no viable alternative Seems to me like a lot of people around the world have increasing impetus or motivation to try and find one. Would you agree with that? And if so, what do you think the greatest threats are in terms of what other nations might do to look for an alternative to the dollar?
Mike Green: So I, I think your observation that there is no alternative is probably the right one. And there are always risks to the replacement of the reserve currency. But again, it tends to be the function of a violent shift.
And so the transition from the British pound to the US dollar was a result of the aftermath of World War I, where the British were forced to borrow in large size from the Americans. And ultimately, that meant that the supply of pounds to the global regime was far greater than could be maintained. And simultaneously, the UK tried to move back to the gold standard levels, which created inappropriately tight monetary policy, et cetera.
That type of transition, of course, can occur if there's an event of that type of magnitude that changes the US status in the world, but that's hard to achieve. I mean, it would require a legitimate repudiation of the dynamics of the Pax Americana where it became clear that the US was no longer able to enforce property rights or claims in regions around the world. We still are a long way away from that. That. While there are potential rivals in the form of a unified Europe, which took its strongest form under the euro and has created its own challenges, also you have to consider China as a somewhat legitimate threat to that dynamic.
They're just far from clear replacements. And if anything, while people talk about the loss of reserve currency status, the US share of global trade, when properly measured, right, by looking across regions, not necessarily states, has continued to rise, right? It's become more dominant, not less dominant.
Now, in terms of the incentive structure that you refer to, the US has also become much more aggressive in terms of using or weaponizing the dollar. And that does create incentives for people to respond. But it's very difficult to openly mount a challenge to the global hegemon. It would require an overt act that would have significantly negative impacts on most of the countries that are talking about this, which by and large are running current account surpluses, which means that they are beholden to the US to buy their goods and services. It's going to be really, really hard to replace that.
Erik Townsend: Mike, here's my contention on how that might be replaced. And I wrote a book about this a couple of years ago. I think that the invention of the secure digital bearer asset, which was invented by the Bitcoin crowd several years ago, is a game changer. I think it's going to completely change the course of human history. Now, I don't mean that I think Bitcoin is going to replace the dollar in any capacity. What I do mean is that the underlying technology, a digital bearer asset, which can securely operate in a decentralized global network and truly act as a bearer asset. I think that provides the foundation for the creation of a digital currency system with the opposite objectives of Bitcoin. Bitcoin was designed to defeat monetary policy, to essentially resist the existence of the fractional reserve banking system. I anticipate that Silicon Valley will eventually invent a digital currency system designed to be sold to central bankers, one that delivers radically enhanced monetary policy capabilities, whereas Bitcoin was designed to defeat monetary policy, something that is designed to be sold to central bankers as a superior alternative to the US dollar.
And although that unto itself is a pretty compelling sales pitch to replace the US dollar, but boy, it's hard to replace something that's as entrenched as the dollar is. Look at the number of countries around the world that are so frustrated by the weaponization of the dollar that you just described.
And I think that provides the adoption catalyst needed to adopt that digital currency. If that were to happen, and suddenly the US government didn't have its position of hegemonic control over the financial system, I think things could get ugly. It could easily start a war. But I don't think that that war would necessarily prevent the new currency system. from taking over.
Those are obviously some pretty extreme out-there views. I'm very curious to get your perspective. Am I crazy to think these things?
Mike Green: I don't think you're crazy to think these things. I think that like most futurist views, it's somewhat perpetually 10 to 20 years off into the future. And by the time we get there, we realize it was 100 years off into the future. The challenge with that view is, I would say, twofold. One is it doesn't matter how many countries are upset about stuff. It's a little bit like children on the playground. They can be upset about the school bully, but until one of them hits puberty and can legitimately challenge him, it doesn't really matter. He's still going to take your lunch money.
And the US has been by and large quite benign in its behavior relative to prior global hegemons.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Green: Frequently cite the dynamics of the Roman Republic and its transition to the Roman Empire. One of the best examples of that type of dynamic is one of the kings of a neighboring kingdom donated, quote unquote, his country upon his death to the Romans. And you look at this, you're like, well, why in the world would you give the country to the Romans? The reality is you gave it because otherwise they were going to take it. And you were hoping to secure better and more favorable terms. I think by and large, the world has taken for granted that the US is going to behave in a benign fashion if those types of challenges occur.
And the US is somewhat uniquely positioned globally as controlling its own island. If you think about it from the dynamics of a castle, we've got the world's best moats on the east and the west. We have a somewhat incompetent barrier to entry to the south, and we've got a frozen tundra to the north with its denizens huddled around our village gates.
If we decide that we're going to get serious about exploiting our position as the global hegemon, I don't think there's a chance that the rest of the world is prepared for that, at least yet. If they decide to build their own militaries, if they decide to finance those components, if they decide that they're going to risk their women and children, Then sure, that can happen.
But I think it's a long way away.
Erik Townsend: And if I correctly understand, this is about military dominance. And certainly history teaches us that the global reserve currency status has gone to the country with the strongest military. Doesn't the emergence of hypersonic carrier killer missiles from China and some of the other military developments that suggest the US no longer is an undefeatable force of power in the world. Does that change the game or do you really need to get to the point where the US is not only undefeatable, but has actually been defeated in some capacity before the currency can change?
Mike Green: Yeah, I would lean towards that dynamic. And I would suggest that while those are certainly impressive military technology, as were German V-2 rockets and the dynamics of blitzkrieg, We'll eventually figure out solutions to them, right? The US tends not to go out and broadcast what it is capable of doing.
I would be surprised that the, you know, the local bully reveals all of his— at least if he's a smart player— reveals all of his capabilities. It's much more likely that there's a fake challenger that's trying to point to their strengths in the hope that they will get others to follow
Erik Townsend: Mike, you're describing military might as the key determinant here. Are you expecting a military conflict? Obviously, we have big escalation of tension between US and China and so forth. Do you think that a shooting war between the US and another sovereign nation is on the horizon? And if so, who are the potential combatants and what does it look like and what does it mean for the world?
Mike Green: So I actually hope that we don't have that. And I would say to expect that would be somewhat foolish. My biggest fear, as I describe the dynamics that I refer to, is that the US inappropriately responds and more aggressively responds to defend these dynamics that I've described than they have to. The biggest risk that we have as the United States is that we cease being what we have historically represented, a beacon of freedom. And you can debate that all you want, but the US has historically been one of the primary destinations for those who are choosing to leave unfavorable conditions in the hope of a better life. There's a very real chance that we break that system as we're moving to defend what we perceive to be our strengths. I hope that's not the case.
Erik Townsend: Mike, before we close, I want to shift gears here and talk about some of the work that you're doing at Logica. I think that you're just an absolutely brilliant thinker and you've got a lot of terrific perspective on markets and where they're headed. You used to be kind of locked away behind a compliance wall and couldn't talk to anybody. These days at Logica, you've got the freedom to do some writing. So please tell our listeners what you do at Logica. Certainly, we do have a very large accredited investor base who may be interested in some of your investment offerings. But for everyone else, I think there are some very interesting white papers and other resources available at LogicaFunds.com. Please tell us about that as well.
Mike Green: So we use our website to provide access to our research and our white papers. We've written on the dynamics of policy in the time of pandemics. We've written about the value growth or value momentum debate that's currently in play. We recently put out a piece talking about the dynamics of the option skew, the call option skew that's caught a lot of attention and explained that largely in the form of reduced supply combined with the aspects of demand that has been well telegraphed.
And we're about to put a piece out talking about the dynamics of the gold market. And so I would encourage people to check that out. From a product standpoint, our flagship product is the Logica Absolute Return. product. It is only available to accredited investors and institutions. We do partner with a couple of other groups to provide access to our vehicles. And so people are more than welcome to register and reach out in terms of that information. We encourage them to do so.
Erik Townsend: Well, Mike, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade. But the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with FarmTogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage. at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com today.
You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now, back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Mike on the show. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, I really enjoyed it. Frankly, I would've loved to go deep on the passive investing topic because Mike's research is so compelling. He and I talked off the air and we both felt like, hey, he's done that a couple of times. He did it with Demetri Kofinas, he did it with Grant Williams, and I'd rather just let our listeners listen to that topic where Grant did such a beautiful job with that interview and get to something else.
As far as the passive investing effects, boy, figuring out what the catalyst is for the unwind of that passive investing trade. As Mike said, the rules here are pretty simple. Money's flowing into asset managers, they buy. Money's flowing out, they sell. So what is it that causes redemptions? Is it a demographic wave of baby boomers retiring?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: You know, what, what is it that brings about that self-reinforcing vicious cycle of selling that I think could be coming someday? Or do we see this go the other direction where some of those other factors we talk about cause a melt-up to occur before we can ever get to the unwind of this massive buildup that's a result of passive investing? I don't know what the answer is, but let's go ahead and dive into our post-game chart Patrick, you put another great deck together. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, page 2, S&P futures. Boy, the last time we got a correction that panicked everybody and made them say, oh my God, oh my God, the sky is falling, the bear market is resuming, it only lasted a few days and it was over.
Now, is this one over? No, I don't think so.
Patrick Ceresna: That's a really great question. I titled this week's, uh, entire chart book as Was It Enough? And really what's interesting is, uh, I, I typically don't put moving averages and things like that on the charts, but I think the 50-day moving average is particularly interesting when you're going right across the entire spectrum of stocks and markets. And I wanted to really reflect on that. So what we typically have seen in the past is market corrections will, you know, do 50% retracements of prior rises. They'll come down to the moving averages, and the buy-on-dip traders systematically buy the dip. And it usually lasts, you know, these 3 to 5 days, and the traders come back in and, and start their accumulation. And so we got exactly that in a textbook fashion. And really, this is actually an incredibly important moment.
The way I would describe it is it's like the market walked to the edge of the cliff and looked over the side, but didn't lose its footing. And this is a really important next few trading sessions because the bulls would typically, and did in first reaction, put together the rebound. The this update we saw 80 S&P points rebounding off the low. The question now is that enough to trigger the buyers a feedback loop where the buyers now buy the dip and accumulate it? And it's so important to. To find that out because the gamma flip zone and all of these technical sell signals are all just right below the zone. And I know you were suggesting that support line around the 3,225 area where those highs came in in June, but in my mind, if the bulls don't hold the line here, there's an air pocket sitting right underneath.
And I'm not trying to say it has to be the next bear market crash Or even though I think that there's a reasonable chance it could happen, I do think that the market correction will quickly tack on 200 to 300 S&P points lower if this support line doesn't hold. And so watching what the market does here in the next 24 to 48 hours is gonna be really important.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to chart 3, which is Tesla. Now, our good friend Jim Bianco at Bianco Research has written quite a bit about Tesla, observing that probably what's been driving this fierce upside speculation was a lot of belief on speculators' part that Tesla would be added to the S&P 500 stock index. And it was the event of that not happening, the fact that Tesla was passed over and not included in the index, that appears to have marked the top here. Are we seeing a meaningful bounce?
Is the reaction to the S&P non-inclusion over and the rally set to continue? Or is this just a little dead cat bounce off a technical level before the bottom falls out?
Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, it's noteworthy to also point out that Elon Musk did that capital raise right at the— near the market tops, taking advantage of those very high prices. The observation that I wanted to make on Tesla is twofold. Well, first of all, it bounced off the 50-day. It seems to be a recurring theme in so many of these charts. That the corrections mean revert back to its 50-day averages, which technically is common. And we see that Tesla made that drop. But what I'm curious about, and if you notice those 3 red arrows, I marked the key tops that happened on Tesla during each prior advance. And what's particularly interesting is after one of those highs are put in, there's often some form of a retest test of those highs. And I'm really curious whether Tesla will be able to muster up a rebound back towards its highs to mark some sort of a short to intermediate top. But there's also a lot of technicians out there talking about this kind of $400 to $425 area.
And it'll be— if all the bulls muster up on Tesla is just a small rebound up to those levels levels, it may very well be that not only a top is in, but a, a much deeper, more meaningful market correction may be underway. And so I think that's really interesting.
And using that as a theme to go to chart page 4, the chart of Apple. Again, Apple corrected. It was about a 50% retracement down to its 50-day moving average, a very typical place where one would anticipate a buy-on-dip to happen. And so we're seeing all of these markets all coming to the same edge of the cliff moment. And initially, the buy-on-dip traders did show up and they did rebound it off their lows. And now the big question in the next few days, will they be able to make any rally stick? Because if the bears sense that there's no more buying pressure to take it higher, they'll start hammering it pretty hard. And I think that that's going to the big theme. And by the time we're on the next MacroVoices episode next week, we're going to have a lot revealed in terms of what these trends are that have emerged, right?
Erik Townsend: Now, I think it's really interesting to look at page 5 because what a stark contrast between the shape of the S&P 500, you know, really just accelerating into what might have been a blow-off top, or maybe it was just a little correction, but we've seen really Since June, nothing but trading sideways on the Euro Stoxx 50 index. What's going on there?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, if I told you that this was the crude oil chart, would you have believed me?
Erik Townsend: It looks like it, except it doesn't have the down move that we just went through.
Patrick Ceresna: Exactly. And it's interesting, but it really goes to show that the vast majority of the equity price action was very much focused on the American markets. Market, and a lot of these other major developed markets have really been just dead money. I mean, if you look at the charts on the Aussie 200 or on the London FTSE, very weak charts. The, the— this certainly has not been a very broad global equity rally. This has been very US-centric. And what will be interesting is, uh, is we're hovering right along that 50-day, no different than that crude oil chart. It'll be interesting if the market was to break, whether the Euro Stoxx will break with it, and whether this was just a topping formation in at least a bear market in the Euro Stoxx. And that's something that I'm going to be watching definitely in the next week.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to gold futures on page 6. It seems like that moving average line that you've got drawn in red, you know, we're pretty much always holding above it. But then And then the excursion in March was at least a short-term move below it. Are we gonna see another one of those in gold here, or are we gonna just head higher from here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, again, I think that the whole theme of the chart book was to see how all these different securities are all lined up with this 50-day moving average. And this is why I was describing at the beginning is everything seems to be at the edge of a cliff, hasn't gone over, but did take a peek over the side.
And we're gonna find out here in the next week whether or not these key support lines give out. You were pointing out in the market wrap at the beginning that triangle formation that seems to be forming us into a— this coiling wedge.
And usually these wedges resolve with some sort of an explosive move. And we can speculate on which direction that is, but I mean, if the whole market starts to sell here, We've seen in the past that gold does succumb to some of the correlation to the markets and does at least initially sell if it is a bit of a broader liquidity event. I know I've heard a number of people speculate that they think that gold will decouple this time around and not participate in a correction, but the jury is still out. I'm curious which way this will break. So far, gold has done a pretty good job holding that 50-day moving average.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I really have to disagree with some of the views that you hear out there, and I've heard them too. You know, it doesn't matter how strong the fundamentals are to the upside for gold. If people are panicking and markets are crashing and there's a rush to liquidity, people end up panicking and selling everything, whether it makes logical sense or not, and whether it jibes with fundamental Arguments or not, it just— stuff gets sold off. I'd love to see that happen to gold. It would be a great buying opportunity to pick up some more.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. So what I want to do is move on to chart 7, and particularly I wanted to focus on that EUR/USD. I know you were talking about the DXY and the fact that the dollar index really needed to break above 94 to really kind of advertise a bottom as being in. But what I, what I'm particularly watching today is the fact that we had the ECB come out with their press conference and their monetary policy, and the first reaction was the euro went higher. But what I have, through my years of trading, noticed is that usually the first reaction to a central bank announcement tends to be faded the other way. And what will be interesting to see is that if this attempt to rally the euro and, and we find ourselves trading back below 118 and heading lower, that could really be the first sign that US dollar bottom is in place, especially considering the weighting that the euro has inside the, the dollar index.
But we saw a pretty big breakdown in the pound sterling and all sorts of, uh, other things starting to happen. Maybe, uh, the short-term bottom may be in on the dollar, and this is something that I, I'm looking for the cue from the
Patrick Ceresna: euro in the next few trading sessions.
Anyway, Erik, though, I wanted to move on to crude oil because I know you did a great job describing it in, in the, uh, market wrap, but I really wanted to just show how that consolidation just broke to that downside. And now I particularly show now the October contract because whenever we show the continuous contract, it shows that -40 print, which Just mutates the chart. But when you're looking here, I mean, we put some pretty meaningful bottoms in oil back in March and April, and clearly oil has the— or is at least advertising that it's going for some form of a retest to establish a longer-term bottom. But do you feel that generally that the major lows of oil are in and that this is just a retest of some form along the bottom end?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think what's probably going on here is a change of analysts' fundamental sentiment. Now, I certainly agree that the bottom is in at -$37 or whatever we saw on the May contract. We're not going to -$47, you know, on the October contract. That's not going to happen. But let's just talk about why is it that we saw such a brisk rally off of the April lows and then the consolidation that we've seen ever since the middle of June or the beginning of June, there's been a steady drift higher, even when you would have expected some kind of natural retracement.
Well, I think what was going on there is most analysts are looking at this saying, look, they see the same thing that Art Berman told MacroVoices listeners back in early June when we had him on the program, which is, look guys, there's plenty of room for this market to go down over the summer, but eventually in Q4, we're going to see US production fall off a cliff. Because the rig count just has not recovered. They're not making new ones anymore. We gotta go through the inventory of drilled but uncompleted wells. Maybe there's room for downside in the summer, but you get to Q4 and you're gonna see US production falling off a cliff. I think the fact that everyone knew that Q4 was eventually gonna bring us a sharp decline in US production is what was holding the market up and allowing it to just very slowly edge higher. All throughout the summer in anticipation of a move up as US production declined.
Then what actually happened is, oh my gosh, these refinery runs are telling us that, yeah, we may still expect US production to decline, but first of all, it hasn't declined that much yet. And what has declined a lot is demand as measured by refinery runs.
So people are saying, oh my gosh, this is going to be a demand story, not a supply story. And it's an ugly one. Now, how bearish is that? How much farther do we have to go? I don't think it's minus 37 again. Is it back down to 30 or low 30s? I won't be at all surprised by that. In fact, that's my base case is somewhere between $30 and $34 is where this market bottoms. What would it take to get it to $26? Just a little bit worse demand picture and maybe a little bit of laziness in the data so that we don't see that decline. in US production as soon as people thought, we could easily get back down to $26. $26 is a pretty significant support level. To get markedly below that, I think you'd really have to have some significant news or change in outlook. But whether we're done here, you know, having tested $36, or we get to $26 or something in between, I'm not really sure.
Lower than $26, I think it would It's going to take something pretty big to make that happen.
Erik Townsend: But Patrick, I want to come back to lumber futures, which we talked about last week or the week before on page 9. Now, when you and I saw this just runaway rally to the upside, we both thought, okay, what must be going on is because of the pandemic, there is a rush for into high-end construction. People want to build that house in the countryside to move out of the city. And probably with the logistics of the crisis, it's really putting a huge demand on lumber. All of the sudden, everything turned around and went into reverse, and we've seen several limit-down days where the market was just locked at a limit-down condition. 1, 2, 3, and we're way back down here. I've got to be honest, Patrick, I have no clue what brought this about.
Do you have any insight on what might be the fundamental driver?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I don't know about the fundamental driver, but it certainly was that lumber went parabolic. We joked about the fact that this was the Tesla chart, and it's really been going parabolic during the same time as the Apple and Tesla moves were happening. And it was just, I think, just this risk-on impulse in lumber through the home builders and everything. That's just a place where all the money was flowing. What's amazing is, I don't know if there— I don't think there is any correlation to it, but the coincidence But lumber literally put in its top the same day that Tesla did, and it really—we've seen the same type of pullback.
And what's amazing is we don't too often get the opportunity to see these limit down days where, like there were in the good old days of futures trading, where literally you'd go lock limit down day after day, giving no window for traders to be able to get out. And to see this happening in the lumber futures. This many days in a row is certainly a little bit for the history books. But nonetheless, definitely a mean reversion. We lost like 25% on lumber prices in a span of just 5, 6 days. And so it's certainly something that I'm going to be watching here in the days to come. As to a fundamental reason, I just, I think everything was just so overbought that I think that it's just so natural from a reflexivity perspective for things to just take a break and backfill and some profit-taking to be done, right?
Erik Townsend: Listeners, if you want to look over Patrick's shoulder while he watches this and other markets in coming days, be sure to get a free 2-week trial of Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors. And by TopTradersUnplugged.com.
Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at TopTradersUnplugged.com/MacroGuide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup Up email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as of course our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as the link to the Mike Green slide deck and the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a CNBC interview with Stan Druckenmiller calling stocks an absolute raging mania, and a link to a Jeffrey Snider article on re-recession not required. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup.
So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening. Thank you. And we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com the internet's premier source of. Online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device. Each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.