Simon Hunt — China expert (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend.

Simon Hunt: Hello, everyone.

Announcer: Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan.

Episode preview and Erik's Real Vision screen test

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 34 was recorded October 6th, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. When I spoke to you last week, the Chinese yuan was not yet part of the International Monetary Fund's Special Drawing Rights system, or SDR. This week it is, and accordingly, we have a China-centric show planned for you this week, with China expert Simon Hunt joining me as this week's featured interview guest. Simon and I will be discussing the massive credit expansion that's occurred in China since 2008, what drove it, and why it's starting to come under control. We'll also discuss the yuan's inclusion in the SDR, inflation, the dollar index, and much more.

Aaron Chan: And I'm Aaron Chan Before we dive into this week's markets, I'm sure the Real Vision television viewers in our audience were surprised to see you make your TV debut this week, interviewing Real Vision founder Raoul Pal for an update on many of the topics you discussed with him here on MacroVoices just 3 weeks ago. So Erik, what's going on here? Do you have aspirations for television fame?

Erik Townsend: You know, I really enjoyed meeting Raoul in person and spending some time with him. I think he's one of the absolute best macro thinkers of our time. And frankly, getting to know Raoul on a personal level is just as compelling as listening to him talk about macro. We share a lot of things in common. We both retired in our 30s thinking we were going to move to the beach and found out that that wasn't the panacea that we thought it was going to be. We're both sailors, we're both scuba divers, and we're both rum drinkers. So we didn't do any sailing or scuba diving on this trip, but I'm not going to come I don't want to comment on their rum drinking. In general, though, yeah, Real Vision is looking for more video interviewers to cover different geographies, and I find the work that they do, and particularly the guests that they're able to attract, absolutely fantastic. So, this was something of a screen test for me.

They didn't announce that publicly. If anybody in the audience liked that, please let them know, because they're deciding whether or not to give me an opportunity to do some more interviews for them, which I would very much enjoy doing. I want to just reach out to Twitter users John Shippen and Bill Hein, who both were very kind in their tweets about this particular episode. And it really touched my heart when I got home after 14 and a half hours on airplanes and found those tweets in my notifications.

Aaron Chan: Right. And we should remind our listeners that you can get a 1-week free trial of Real Vision Television by going to www.realvisiontv.com/discount/macrovoices. The free trial will allow you to watch Erik's interview with Raoul, plus hundreds of other fascinating interviews.

S&P 500 range and election debate volatility

Aaron Chan: All right, moving on to markets. So even as presidential election drama heats up on both sides, S&P 500 stock index futures have managed to muddle through the last week, rarely trading outside of a fairly tight band between 2,140 and 2,160. Now, by Thursday's close, the E-mini S&P futures contract was trading at 2,155. Erik, any change to your outlook on equities?

Erik Townsend: Well, not a whole lot has changed. What I said last week is that I think we're in a consolidation range as the market waits for an indication as to who's likely to win this election. And as we haven't seen any definitive indication of that this week. That's narrowed the trading range a little bit. I think that we're likely to see very considerable volatility on Sunday evening during this next presidential debate. Now remember that not only do the markets trade on Sunday evenings, but it's a very thin liquidity time. It's the kind of time when you can expect very big moves to occur even on small amounts of news. So if there is an obvious winner, if somebody is really kicking butt in the debate. If that's Hillary, I think markets move sharply higher. If it's Donald, markets sharply lower. And I've— as I've described before, when I say markets sharply lower if Donald is winning, it doesn't mean that the market is saying Donald's the wrong guy.

What it means is that the market is saying Hillary would mean business as usual, where Fed policy is basically for sale to Wall Street in exchange for campaign donations. Donald has shown signs of maybe not supporting that any further. So, So, for that reason, I think that if it appears that Donald is gaining in popularity, it's going to hurt the markets, at least in the short term.

Once that outcome becomes clear, whether it's on debate night or not, before or after the— or at the time of the election, I'd expect a fairly big move in equity markets. But frankly, I don't think it's the beginning of a major trend. If Hillary wins the election, I would expect a move much higher to what could be a blow-off top and maybe just all downhill from there.

Aaron Chan: Okay.

Crude oil, the OPEC deal and inventory draws

Aaron Chan: Well, Erik, crude oil has been on fire with front-month WTI futures topping $50 for the first time since June. Erik, what happened? I mean, what launched crude oil prices into orbit? Is this all fallout from the OPEC deal?

Erik Townsend: No, I don't think it's a result of the OPEC deal. As I've described before, the OPEC deal is utterly irrelevant to supply and demand because all they've agreed to do— they haven't actually agreed to do anything. They've agreed to maybe at the November meeting, at that point, agree to a production cap at a level

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: Which represents essentially an all-time record high of production. So, it doesn't mean anything other than the symbolic importance of people are finally starting to work together to stabilize markets, which they weren't doing before.

The thing is, as much as I think the OPEC deal is utterly irrelevant to supply and demand, inventory reports, on the other hand, most assuredly are relevant. And despite the expectations that not only Art Berman and I have had, but also Goldman Sachs has been very vocal about saying, Q4 Oh, baby, you're going to see massive builds in inventory. Well, guess what? It's not only is it not happening, but it's going the other way.

This week, we saw a 3 million barrel drawdown on nationwide crude oil inventories. Meanwhile, Cushing, Oklahoma, 569,000 barrel build on inventory. That's going in the other direction. But, you know, compared to 3 million barrels nationwide and also a drawdown last week, really, Cushing is just treading water. Gasoline, 222,000 barrel build. Okay, that's going in the other direction, but it It pales in contrast to a 2.4 million barrel drawdown in distillate inventories. So net of both distillates and gasoline, big drawdown in finished products, big drawdown in crude oil. And it's ironic that, you know, at the time of year when we were expected seasonally to be drawing down on inventories, we were building inventories. And now that we've moved into the time of year when seasonally one would expect builds in inventories, we're getting drawdowns. So it's like seasonality is working in reverse this year. And again, it's not just Art Berman and me who have had this view. Goldman just a couple of weeks ago said that a move back into the $30s was inevitable because of all of the builds in inventory that they saw coming in Q4.

Well, if that's going to happen, it better happen soon because Q4 is upon us and we're just seeing drawdown after drawdown after drawdown. Sam Madani tells me he thinks that exports are a big part of it. There has suddenly been a rash of exports of both crude oil and finished products out of the United States. The East Coast gas I think the gasoline pipeline disruptions may have explained part of that. There may have been gasoline that was landlocked that got exported because there was no good way to move it someplace. I'm frankly not even sure of that because I've been traveling for the last week and haven't been able to really dive into it.

As far as how much farther this could go, as far as the OPEC effect, I think that's probably played out as much as it can. But it was time for everyone to, you know, hunker down and get ready for all the builds on inventory, and we're going in the other direction. 5 weeks now of inventory That's sure starting to sound like a trend to me, very much unexpected. So, if the view that I've had and that Art Berman has had and Goldman Sachs has had, that prices are headed much lower in Q4 because of inventory builds, is going to be proven true, we better start getting those inventory builds pretty darn soon.

Gold breaks below $1,308

Aaron Chan: Well, Erik, if it's any consolation, you sure got the call on gold right. Finally, I don't have to introduce the topic of gold with the same old broken record about a consolidation range between $1,308 and $1,377. But Erik, last week you declared that the pattern actually looked more like a descending triangle, and you said that a downward resolution of that triangle was looking more and more likely. You went on to say that would probably portend a much more bearish outlook for gold. Now, you sure nailed that call. The barbarous relic traded as low as $1,252 on Thursday morning and closed Thursday's session at $1,256. The chart looks pretty ominous. Is there farther to go on the downside, and what's your intermediate to long-term outlook for gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's hard to say where the downside target is. I think that Fed policy is driving this. Increasing rate expectations for the next meeting probably was the catalyst. Once we broke that support, I was not the only one watching 1308 as key support. As soon as we saw a decisive breakdown below that level, it accelerated. And in the last few days since that's happened, there's been more downside. Is there going to be even more downside? What's the final bottom? I don't know. I think it's going to depend on the news flow more than anything else. Certainly the The technicals suggest that there could be more downside, but in the grand scheme of things, we're headed towards a buying opportunity here. And I think that the long gold, long dollar index pairs trade that Raoul Pal and I talked about both in our interview 3 weeks ago on this program and then again in the Real Vision interview just this week is probably going to be the way to play this because, as we'll get to in a minute, we're also seeing considerable upside in the dollar index this week.

Right.

10-year Treasuries: Raoul Pal versus Gundlach

Aaron Chan: For the last few weeks, we've been reflecting on your decision not to buy the dip, as you'd originally planned, by buying 10-year Treasury futures when the yield dropped briefly below 1.70% about 3 weeks ago. Well, guess what? The market is giving you a second chance, Erik, with 10-year yields trading at 1.72% on Thursday afternoon.

Are you going to pull the trigger this time?

Erik Townsend: No, I don't think I am. Actually, I'm pretty much decided not to. And it's tempting. It's very possible this 1.7, 1.73 or so percent Treasury yield has clearly been a resistance level in yield, a support level in price. So, a technical trader would definitely be tempted to buy here.

The thing is, I listened to Jeff Gundlach's interview on Real Vision Television recently. He makes exactly the same argument that Raoul Pal makes. Raoul Pal makes a bullish argument saying it's time to go long 10-year Treasuries. Gundlach makes the opposite argument, saying, for almost the exact same reasons that Raoul stated, it's time to go short 10-year Treasuries. And I called Raoul out on this in the video interview we did with Real Vision. And he said, well, it's a matter of timeframe. He's looking at a shorter time horizon than Jeff Gundlach is. And I totally agree with Raoul's logic and rationale there.

The thing is, I think that Gundlach makes a very good point, which is we're at the end of a 35-plus-year bull market in bonds.

Aaron Chan: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Do you really want to try to jump into this trade at the very tail end of it and make a profit on that ride from, let's say we go from 1.72% all the way down to 1% on the Treasury yield? Do you really want to try to take that risk right now? Or is it time to say that whether it's over right now or not over right now, eventually we're headed towards much higher yields and it's probably a little bit late in the game for this?

Gundlach makes an excellent argument, which is, if you wanna make a trade, there's probably other trades to make where you're not getting in on the very tail end of a 35-year-old trend. So I think Raoul is probably going to be proven right. I think he's going to make money on his trade in the short term, and then eventually Gundlach will be proven right in a longer timeframe. I don't really want to jump into this one right here.

US dollar index above its 200-day average

Aaron Chan: And finally, a topic you and Raoul discussed at quite some length, the US dollar. It broke above its 200-day moving average this week, trading on a 96 handle as we're taping this show Thursday afternoon. And it looks like it may be poised to retest resistance somewhere just above 97. I mean, is this the beginning of the big move to the upside?

Erik Townsend: I think it could be. The breakout above the 200-day was clearly significant. We're 96.71 as we speak Thursday afternoon, just after 4 o'clock on Eastern time. And, you know, the breakout above the 200-day moving average has already happened. We were seeing a bunch of resistance right there around 96.5 or so. We're above that. We're going to have a closing print above that today.

97, I think, was it 97.39 or 97.89? I can't remember what the high print was on this cycle. That's going to be the next thing to watch for. And I won't be surprised if we break above it. I do think, as Raoul and I have discussed both on this program and on Real Vision, this is a hard one to call. Every time you're sure you know where it's headed, it seems to reverse and go the other way. So, I'm still waiting it out, but I think that we may be headed for the beginning of the big move here.

Aaron Chan: Well, great. Thanks for the market update. Simon Hunt is a recognized expert on China. And since the yuan was just incorporated in the SDR, the International Monetary Fund's Special Drawing Rights, we're bringing you Mr. Hunt for some perspective on the backstory that got us here. Erik's interview with Mr. Hunt is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Simon Hunt: China's credit expansion, Xi and the anti-corruption drive

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Simon Hunt. And Simon, thank you so much for agreeing to help us out with this interview on short notice. I wanted to get a China expert on the show this week because of the upcoming inclusion of the Chinese Renminbi in the Special Drawing Rights of the IMF. But before we dive into that minutia, let's take a big step back because I think a lot of Westerners, myself included, don't really have a clear picture of how we got here with China. Since 2008, there's been a massive credit expansion in China. So give us the backstory. What's going on with China? Where did this credit expansion come from? How did we get here?

Simon Hunt: Big question. You have to remember that the government in place in 2000, in that period, came from the Chinese Youth League, whose power base is in the local governments and provinces. And it was assets in that area that suffered from the initial reverberations of the 2008-2009 global recession.

They pumped in enormous amounts of credit, much of which fed back into not the real economy but into the kleptocracy that was governing the country. When President Xi came into office there was a severe risk that the party was losing control because the mass was beginning to rebel against the corruption that was taking place at the center.

He decided that in order to— in order for the party to retain control and to get the masses back on board, There had to be a significant restructuring of the economy based on the center taking power and based on a very powerful anti-corruption drive.

So in order to do that, President Xi has had to get control of most of all, if he can, the levers of power. This is what's been going on the last three odd years. Part of that, part of what happened was global. Global growth slowed to a snail's pace. Commodity prices collapsed, and it left the Chinese financial system with enormous stroke enormous undisclosed debts.

This new government, led by President Xi, Xi decided that the issue had to be confronted, and this came out very clearly in the famous or infamous letter in the People's Daily of the 18th of May this year, written by an undisclosed writer but purportedly President Xi's personal. Economic advisor.

And it was made very clear in that letter, and anybody who read the entirety of it knew what was coming, which was that we cannot continue with the policies that were pursued by the previous government. Debt cannot go on forever. We have to restructure. There will be pain.

It took a long time for President Xi's clique to appreciate the depth of the problem. And this was because the size of the debt, not just as a total figure, but between companies with— if within different supply chains, was simply enormous.

And I can give one personal example. Example, a company that I was very close to earlier this year got into very serious trouble because many of its clients in Beijing and in the provinces went bankrupt and left them with huge debts on their books. But the bank supported them because if they had allowed that company to go, then the chain reaction right down that whole chain of supply would have been enormous.

So the government has realized that rather than taking a sledgehammer to the debt problem, which many in the Western world have been saying they should do, decided that this was not something you could successfully accomplish in 1 or 2 years. It has to be a very thoughtful slow process. And that's what's happening now.

So to take a recent example, a state-owned steel company was made bankrupt. The creditors pushed it. And the main creditor, of course, is the government. So what this signals is that credit markets are going to do the job that they have been designed, designed to do. So we are going to start to see state-owned enterprises that have little chance of survival being made bankrupt with the full support of its creditors.

What we are seeing also in the private sector is the banks have got very tough. Where banks see little sign of recovery, bad management, indebtedness, etc., etc., they're pulling the plug. The world is now saying China has this huge debt problem, it can't resolve it. Not true. They are, but the process is being very painful.

And the pain is also being experienced not just in China, but in the West, as the companies that banks were previously supporting are finding that the credit that they did have in the West is no longer there.

So that's where we are today. The question now is what happens? Well, it's very interesting because what we are now seeing in the last few months is in the private sector as well as in the SOE sector, profits are starting to improve as bad credit is expunged, as cash management has improved by necessity.

And in fact, in the latest 2 months' figures, you've seen a surge in profitability. So what I submit is that China is on the right path, that government knows that it has to continue to restructure and reform. The restructuring and reform has been slowed down by this political battle between the Chinese Youth League, of which Premier Li is the current leader.

And the president's clique, which basically says the center, i.e., Beijing, is the overall authority and that the provinces should obey that authority. So we have seen also monetary policy is accommodative, true M1 is rising quite rapidly, profitability of industry is improving.

Infrastructure spending is increasing. The government, the NDRC, recently released 25 infrastructure projects. 22 of them were frozen earlier this year because of corruption. So you are now getting the combination of accommodative monetary policy Fiscal policy is also being accommodative. The fiscal deficit will probably rise to somewhere between 3.5% and 4%. So what we can see is a recovery coming through. It's already started and will gather pace through the rest of this year and certainly into next year.

Erik Townsend: So to summarize, we've got a massive credit expansion in China since the Great Financial Crisis, getting out of control at one point to where it was just fueling corruption, kind of a crackdown this spring, and the government taking proactive action to get it under control. And you think that they've got their handle on it and it is headed in the right direction now.

Simon Hunt: Right.

Yuan joins the SDR: dollar and inflation outlook

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the SDR. With that backdrop of what's going on in China, why would the IMF consider including the Renminbi the SDR? What's the backstory? What— why— what's the significance of this? How did it come about?

Simon Hunt: That is a very, very big question. I think one can surmise that there was a huge internal battle within the IMF to allow the RMB to be included in the SDR, which happened on the 1st of October. The protagonists led by America, or primarily America, probably voted against its inclusion.

From what I understand, Lagarde was a very brave person and fought against their opposition. One can guess that China also used various levers to ensure that the RMB was included. It. Now that it is in the system, and if you look back every time that the Fed has indicated that it might increase interest rates, the PBOC ensured that the RMB had a dive.

One can argue, and some now do in, in high places, that real monetary policy is no longer being managed out of Washington, but now out of Beijing. So what do we see happening? First, I think that over the next few months, you are going to see an even stronger dollar, which will prick commodities, commodity-producing countries, and asset values.

My guess is that various support measures will be introduced by many governments, including the United States, and that the real underlying new financial structure masterminded by the few big people is that we now shift from a deflation environment into an inflation environment. which will be supported by global fiscal deficits to finance infrastructure expenditure.

Inflation, commodity boom and the 2019-2021 plug

Erik Townsend: I'd like to expand on that topic of inflation because a view that I've had for a long time has been, you know, we're in this environment of money printing, of central banks just conjuring money out of thin air to solve their problems, which I contend cannot go on forever. Well, what would stop it from going on, of course, would be if we started to have a problem with runaway inflation. First, would you agree with that view? And second, if you do, how long do you think it takes before we get to an environment that's sufficiently inflationary that it starts to tie the hands of central bankers?

Simon Hunt: First of all, central bankers initially will welcome any form of inflation. But as we all know, central bankers are basically behind the curve. Having thrown— what is it— $12 trillion, having bought $12 trillion of assets globally since the Lehman crisis, there is a huge amount of money sitting within the financial system earning very little returns.

What we see coming through is that with fiscal deficits expanding to help finance infrastructure spending, that— and this is supported by global M1 data— we are going to see a faster recovery in 2017 than is the consensus forecast and that of the IMF, World Bank, etc., etc., which makes me very happy.

This in turn will lead to an inflation of commodity prices which bankers will welcome. And I think that the combination of what you are also going to see is funds that have been stuck within the banking system will suddenly find that better returns will be found by investing outside the banking system— infrastructure projects, etc., etc.

So unexpectedly, you are going to see the start of inflationary pressures. These could well be augmented by developments like oil prices rising far beyond the consensus view because of developments in the Middle East, metal prices doing what they have always done, which is that the real turning points both up and down in metal prices come from the huge inventory chain of finished products, components, semi-fabricated products, etc., within the manufacturing chain.

That is what has always caused the peaks and troughs in metal prices. So as the global economy recovers and prices begin to pick up, then you are going to the inventory chain in the manufacturing sector being filled again as it's been depleted. And thus you see a switch from inventory being held at the raw material stage into the manufacturing stage. And that lays the groundwork for the big rise that will happen over the next 2 to 3 years in commodity prices.

This is not going to be a sustainable rise. In my view, it will last for two to three years because the masters of the global system, to coin a phrase, know that the current financial system is totally unsustainable. You cannot have debt continuing to rise faster than GDP.

So either the system itself will implode, or else they pull the plug. As things currently stand, I think. that, that plug is pulled somewhere between 2019 and 2021, and it will then be followed by really severe deflation of asset prices. So the coming period of rising asset prices, which will last 2 to 3 years, should be used to prepare for the disaster that is then going to unfold.

Will China devalue the yuan? Bass versus Hendry

Erik Townsend: Okay, let's go back to the renminbi for a minute. I've been watching with interest kind of a proxy battle of the Great hedge fund managers through their Real Vision interviews on Real Vision Television, as well as your own interview recently. Kyle Bass has opined very strongly that the PBOC will be forced to markedly devalue the yuan in order to deal with the unwind of this massive credit expansion. Hugh Hendry has countered that that's utterly ridiculous, that the consequences of a major devaluation would be so extreme that they cannot possibly They can't afford to do that. There's no way it's going to happen.

And then recently, I think Grant Williams put that comment from Hugh back to Kyle, and Kyle said, Hugh doesn't understand. I'm not predicting that they're going to want to do this. I'm predicting this is going to happen to them against their greatest resistance. There will be no stopping it. They will be forced to recapitalize their banks as all the bad credit starts to unwind. And in that recapitalization process, they'll be forced to devalue dramatically. Who's got this right? Or perhaps neither of them do. And there's another view.

Simon Hunt: Well, I think my own view, let's put it that way, is that people forget that China's long-term growth, like over the next 10, 15 years, is going to be double that of the advanced economies of the Western world. So we're talking 4 to 5% versus about 2%. So growth is going to be one way that debt can be washed out.

Secondly, if China wanted to tomorrow to completely wash out the debt, it's got the resources to do it. But if it did it, the consequences on the rest of the world would be extremely dire and probably more dire than within China itself. Most of China's debt is internal, and this is something, as I said earlier, that President Xi's group have now got firmly in hand.

Secondly, there is a— how can one call it— an emotional element to this whole discussion about the RMB. The president feels that a strong RMB means strong leadership and a strong economy. They're not going to allow it to collapse. And now that the RMB is within the SDR. They can use the SDR system if they so wanted to defend the RMB.

On another note, the PBOC or the Chinese government has a firm commitment to continue reducing its holdings of U.S. Treasury securities and other American debt. As they see it. It's a nil long-term investment. The proceeds of selling that debt does not altogether go back into China, as people have assumed.

A lot of it is being held in cash, probably still in dollars, which at the appropriate time will be put to better use, either in infrastructure projects or in Asian currencies where they see. better long-term returns.

Why China stockpiles commodities

Erik Townsend: Another topic I'd like to get your opinion on. I had a fascinating experience back in 2012. I was traveling around the world. In Australia, I met a fellow who actually is an engineer on one of the big ships that delivers coal and iron ore to China from Australia. And we were talking about the significance of those exports to the Australian economy. And he looked at me and he said, Erik, it's in the harbor. And I said, what? And he said— he described to me a scene that he has seen dozens upon dozens of times, which is they pull into port in China, they unload thousands of tons of coal and iron ore that, you know, cost millions of dollars. This is very expensive stuff. And as they're pulling away from the pier, they observe the Chinese literally bulldozing it into the harbor, just stockpiling all these commodities that they're purchasing apparently for later use. What's going on? What is the backstory?

Why in the world is China stockpiling raw commodities literally to the point of bulldozing them into the harbor because they have no other place to put them?

Simon Hunt: I, I can add to that. I think that in other metals too, China has been deliberately stockpiling putting the material into unreported locations. The sums are very large, enormous. I think there are several reasons for this. First of all, they are an importer of key commodities to drive their economy.

Should relationships with America deteriorate any further, It's quite possible that America could turn off one or more of the sea route choke points. So if you're a planning nation, which China is, you have Plan B. And Plan B is we have to have these contingency plans.

So I think that what has been going on and is ongoing is that it's not just the coal and the iron ore or whatever. It's actually the finished metals as well, which are basically bought through the the SRB, the State Reserve Bureau. And my guess, and it's only a guess, is that they will be significantly larger buyers over the next two years than they have been over the last two years.

Another point: China doesn't basically does not want dollars. So stockpiling metals, buying natural resources is a part of the dollar diversification program. So, and finally, the Chinese financial system would very much like to see higher commodity prices because the severity of their non-performing loans in that sector sector, both to producers, fabricators, importers, traders, etc., is simply enormous.

So yeah, they have built big resource reserves and they're going to get bigger.

The China-Russia alliance

Erik Townsend: I think that's a good segue to another topic that I find profoundly interesting, and I'm surprised that no one in the West seems to pay attention to it, which is what appears to me to be a rapidly growing alliance between China and Russia. We see this in the South China Sea with the disputed islands. And as you just alluded to, this de-dollarization campaign that Sergey Glazyev in Russia has masterminded, trying to encourage people to stop conducting trade in US dollars and use other currencies— China seems to be very rapidly warming up to that. So what's your take on this apparent alliance between China and Russia?

Simon Hunt: I think it's a very deep strategic alliance. It's military, it's economic, it's financial, and it's cultural. And I think it's been brought about by force of circumstances. Both countries realized that America wanted to contain what Halford Mackinder called the the center, which was the whole of Central Asia, from becoming a global power.

So they've been forced into this alliance, which they now find to be mutually profitable. Parts of the alliance, Russia will be the leader, and other parts, China is the leader. But they are working together very closely. To give one example, Syria.

China has actually sent or is in the process of sending what they call peacekeepers to Syria to support Russia. I mean, this is a— there's a mega, mega change in the global chessboard, and it's centered around Russia, China, Iran, Iraq, the other BRICS countries, and now I understand even Turkey. So you then have— think about it— you've got that whole rim of countries stretching from China China, through to India, Pakistan, Iran, and into Turkey, and through into the Middle East as one, one alliance.

Erik Townsend: It's the anti-NATO.

Simon Hunt: It's anti-NATO. It's anti-America. And the real question is, how does America respond? It doesn't want to lose its unipolar status. What's it going to do? And I think that we could, over the next couple of months, get a horrible shock. Quite what it is, I have no idea, but I think that shock is probably going to come before the presidential election.

Erik Townsend: I've been trying to ask all of our guests, without taking a stand yourself, to just objectively opine on what the consequence to global markets would be of either a Trump or a Clinton presidency.

Simon Hunt: I'll answer that by saying outside my discipline. Okay, but I, I do I do think that with Trump, you'll get the initial emotional knockdown. And when sanity returns, I think it'll be very positive. But I think that if Hillary gets in, you'll get the initial emotional uptick. But when people look at things carefully, I think they'll get extremely worried. And I would suspect then that equity markets will be dumped.

Dollar outlook: near-term strength, then a secular fall

Erik Townsend: Okay. Let's move on. I'm particularly keen to understand your view on the US dollar, because frankly, we've had so many guests on this program that have all taken a bullish view, although it has not played out as the bulls have expected it to. I believe that you have a structural bearish view on the US dollar, which is a welcome change just to get a contrasting viewpoint. Please explain.

Simon Hunt: Yeah, I think, though, that as I mentioned earlier, that over the next month or two, we're going to see a very strong dollar driven by Washington antics. It's almost the last throw of the dice. But I think that by the middle of next year, and timing is elusive, but I think by the middle of next year, you are going to see the beginnings of a secular fall in the dollar, which will be pretty massive.

Why? Because a very large part of the world has grown wary of America's arrogance. Its financial antics. I was with people today. I'm in Singapore. People today in Singapore say we can't open a bank account if there's an American partner there. A family friend of mine in Switzerland is opening a new art gallery.

His partner is an American, and he said, "I cannot open an account in a big international Swiss bank because they don't want to have anything to." do with anybody who's connected to America. That's the sort of thing that is going on globally. People— excuse my language— are just thoroughly pissed off with what America is trying to do. It's being bully boy tactics. And they're now saying enough is enough. And more and more of world trade is going to be conducted outside the dollar system.

A system reset around 2020 and gold's return

Erik Townsend: Okay. And I'd like to move on now to a prediction that I think you made in your recent Real Vision television interview. I believe that you said You said that the global economic system is within 5 years of a major reset. Can you explain what you meant by that? And, you know, that's obviously a big—

Simon Hunt: Well, I'll do it in very general terms because I can't do it specifically. The current system is completely unsustainable. You cannot continue to have global debt rising faster than global GDP. Something has to give. But you can't restructure in a semi-okay environment. You've got to have a crisis because no government is going to play ball in a sort of okay environment.

So one way or another, you are going to have a mega crisis within the years around 2020, and then you will see a new system being introduced which will include the reemergence of gold into the monetary system.

Erik Townsend: Simon, before we close, for people who'd like to follow your work, I know you did an excellent interview on Real Vision Television just this last week. Where else can people follow your work?

Simon Hunt: Yeah, I have a website, Simon Hunt Strategic Services, and anybody can contact me on my email, which is simon@shss.com.

Erik Townsend: Well, Simon, thanks so much for joining me on the program. Aaron Chan and I will be back as MacroVoices continues

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. We'd love to hear from you. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan.

Postgame: Erik's failed collapse call and what ties central bankers' hands

Aaron Chan: Great interview, Erik. You know, there are quite a few aspects of this interview that I enjoyed. In particular, I was struck by Simon's prediction for the next stock market crash in 2020. Now correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think we've ever had another guest come on with a specific year for the next great crash. So 2020, is it time for us to pack up our stuff and head to the mountains?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it's interesting. My reaction to that was first one emotionally of sort of solidarity. I felt a connection to Simon because it's been exactly my prediction. Within 5 years, the whole thing falls apart. Just one problem. That prediction is one that I made 7 years ago. And so I've obviously been proven wrong or early, depending on how you want to look at it. And it hasn't fallen apart.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: So I have to question, I think that the notion that this cannot go on and that it has to end badly, as so many smart people have said, there's just no way we can solve our problems by papering over with printed money and not really addressing the root cause of any of the issues that are affecting the global economy. So it has to come falling apart someday. But to say it has to happen within 5 years, how do you know it's not 10 years? I got that one wrong. The one place where I would agree very much is that—

Aaron Chan: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: The way I've come to look at this is the charade is going to continue indefinitely for as long as central bankers and governments are able to get away with it. As long as there's a deflationary backdrop that allows them to conjure money out of thin air and use it to prop up asset markets, they're going to do that.

And it's gonna keep going. It will probably get bigger before it gets better, in the sense that as they continue to get away with this, they become more brazen and more complacent and are likely to do even more of it.

Aaron Chan: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Nothing is going to change that, and they will succeed at propping up asset markets using these techniques until something ties their hands. And there's two somethings that I can think of. The big one is runaway inflation, and clearly we don't have that now. I don't see any immediate signs of that. But when we get to a situation where the macro backdrop is one of runaway inflation—not just a little bit of inflation, which central bankers would welcome with open arms—but runaway inflation—now all of the All of a sudden, they can't get away with this stuff anymore. They'll be forced to tighten monetary policy in order to combat the inflation and prevent it from developing into hyperinflation.

They won't be able to offer all of this excessive accommodation, and the whole house of cards comes crashing down. The thing is, this deflationary backdrop has been much stronger and has lasted much longer than I ever expected. How am I to know, and how is Simon Hunt to know, that it's going to change? Well, his prediction— and I think this adds a lot of credibility to his argument— His prediction for why he thinks it's going to change is he sees inflation on the horizon sooner than I do, frankly. If he's right about that, first we'll get the happy kind of inflation that they've been trying so hard to create, and the central bankers will declare victory and proclaim themselves to be geniuses because they succeeded at creating their beloved 2% inflation. Then we'll get to 3% and 4% and 5%, and all of a sudden we'll figure out that it's running away and that it requires a Paul Volcker monetary sledgehammer kind of reaction. action in order to contain it.

And that's where the party is over. Is Simon correct that that's some— you know, to say the timeframe for that is to be between 2019 and 2020? That's a bold call. I have learned that I am certainly not able to put time parameters around these things with any kind of accuracy. I have been either way early or way wrong, depending on how you want to look at it, when I thought it would have happened by now. So I've learned to watch and wait. And I think it's entirely possible that his timeframe could prove right. I think it could start tomorrow, and I think it could go on for another 20 years. We're in uncharted territory here, and we don't know how long central bankers and governments can get away with what I consider to be reckless monetary policy. We haven't even gotten to reckless fiscal policy. That probably comes next.

So, you know, I don't think it's clear when the endgame starts, but it's going to be scary when we get to it.

Who funds the next cycle: fiscal stimulus after the election

Aaron Chan: Well, Erik, since you brought up inflation, I want to press you on Simon's deflation-inflation-collapse timeline. Now, it's clear Sure, we are in a disinflationary environment, and despite all the central bank asset purchases, but I'm wondering who picks up the slack in the next inflationary cycle if it were to happen in the first place? So many of the largest economies in the world have mammoth debt-to-GDP ratios. So who's left to do the infrastructure spending or the deficit spending? And is Simon basically calling for QE4 in 2017?

Erik Townsend: I don't know whether he's calling for QE4, but I think the answer is that the next president of the United States is going to be very comfortable with deficit spending, and I think that you're going to see fiscal stimulus in size. And there's certainly an argument that eventually that comes back to bite you, and I think it will come back to bite us. But I think it will be successful at least in the short term, or it depends on how you define the word successful. If you're setting up for a very terrible outcome further down the road, is that success? Well, it'll be perceived as success at least in the short term because they will be successful. They're both successful at boosting the economy, kind of getting things going so at least the numbers look good for a while. And there will be a perception of economic improvement with either outcome in the presidential election.

They've both pledged to spend ridiculous amounts of money. Clearly, there's no tax revenue to support that spending, so it has to come from deficit spending. And you can get away with it in this environment of ultra-low interest rates. When the long bond starts to back up, When inflation starts to rear its ugly head again, that's where we're in trouble. And we haven't seen any sign of that yet. I definitely think it's coming, but time will tell how long it takes for it to show up.

Controlled demolition of debt: Duncan versus Bernanke

Aaron Chan: Well, Erik, I want to pivot over to politics. Simon's expertise in Chinese politics was interesting to hear. And from the sounds of it, he thinks the government has the situation under control, even alluding to the fact that they are allowing certain companies to fail. Now, this reminded me of your conversation with Alex Gurevich from a couple weeks back about there being no historical precedent for a debt unwind of this magnitude. Now, can you successfully conduct a controlled demolition of something for which there is no precedent?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think the key is your own words in the question of there is no precedent. Nobody knows the answer to that. I will be the first to admit that my view has I've been cynical. I look at— there's no precedent for ever having had this kind of ridiculous credit expansion. I look at the risk of a cataclysmic unwind, and I think that that risk is so high and the consequences so dire that, in my opinion, the policy actions that we've seen to date have been reckless. Now, you could take a different view. One that comes to mind in particular would be Richard Duncan, who we interviewed on this show several months ago. And his view was basically that central banks are doing exactly the right thing. This is unprecedented action, but it is necessary because if they didn't take these unprecedented actions, then we would have a dramatic collapse now instead of later. And at least by trying this, there's a chance to see if it's going to solve the problem.

Can you somehow pull this, this tightrope act off of walking a tightrope in a hurricane and not falling off either the inflation or the deflation side of the tightrope as the wind cranks up to Category 4 or Category 5 hurricane-force winds? I don't think so. I fear a really horrific outcome of either an inflationary depression or a deflationary depression, depending on which way it plays out. And I think that all of this monetary policy has exacerbated that risk.

The counterargument, the Ben Bernanke argument, is no, as long as they manage to keep their balance, they can magically use all of This printed money and all of this debt to save the day, and then unwind it, mop up all that liquidity, and, you know, gracefully bring the economic system back into equilibrium, having averted a crisis through all of this government intervention. If that actually happens— and I don't mean in the, you know, just there's no crash in the next year or two— but if we get to 20 years from now and they pulled this thing off, there was no cataclysmic consequence, and it all came out just fine, then Ben Bernanke deserves not only the Nobel Prize—

Aaron Chan: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Nobel Prize, but, you know, 200 Nobel Prizes. Unfortunately, I'm very skeptical that that's going to happen. I think there's going to be a really, really bad ending, and I'm not the only person who thinks that. You listen to Ray Dalio, you listen to George Soros, you listen to Stan Druckenmiller.

All of these super accomplished people are saying, hey guys, this party is coming to an end. I'm not smart enough to declare, okay, right now, today's the day, it's ending, this is the beginning of the endgame. I've made that declaration several times since 2009, and I've been So I'm not going to make it again. But at some point, the endgame starts, and I think it's going to be ugly.

US relations with China and Russia, war risk

Aaron Chan: Well, Erik, lastly, I wanted to get your take on the geopolitical theater. One of the reasons Simon cited for China's stockpiling of base metals and commodities was a hedge against the event that relations with the United States were to deteriorate. Now, this obviously hinges on who is elected president in November, but instead of the question we've been asking our guests on how each candidate will affect markets. I want to ask you, Erik, how do you see either candidate affecting relations with China?

Erik Townsend: Oh boy. Well, certainly Donald Trump has been most outspoken about China. What remains to be seen is how that rhetoric in campaign time leads to actual actions in office, assuming that he were elected. So I am concerned.

Frankly, my cynical joke has been, we got to wait till November to find out whether Hillary is elected to go start World War III with Russia, or if Donald is elected to go start World War III with China. Now, I say that as an exaggerated joke. I don't really have any reason to believe that Donald is going to start World War III with China. But certainly, the rhetoric that he's been slinging has been one of, let's get tough, let's make China pay their price, let's be tough with China. And I think that if you look at the history

Aaron Chan: I think that's a good point.

Erik Townsend: And the escalation of the U.S. involvement in the South China Seas with these freedom of navigation exercises challenging China's creation of these artificial islands, which I think are really all about creating artificially gas and oil drilling rights. Donald has been very outspoken. He's going to take a tough stance with China, and I fear that that could lead to a dramatic escalation with China. Hillary, I don't think, is likely to start with China. I think she's going to go pick a fight with Vladimir Putin. to be a personal vendetta there between Putin and Clinton. So one way or another, as Simon talked about in this interview, there is a growing alliance between China and Russia. And I think that if the US picks a fight with either one of them, it's going to grow into a fight with both of them. And I think it could end very badly.

I think that both the American government and the American people have developed a complacency where they kind of feel like, you know, if you look at all the wars of the last 20 years, the US basically goes in and kicks ass.

And of course, there's been a huge amount of collateral damage and difficulty and blowback, frankly, from all these wars with the Middle East. But, you know, you go into a country like Iraq and you're the strongest military force on Earth. It's a David and Goliath game. And obviously, the US is going to be the military victor in a conflict. conflict like that. China and Russia are military superpowers. They have both developed missile technology designed to sink a U.S. aircraft carrier. They are not playing with Monopoly money. They're not playing with— what's the analogy with—

Aaron Chan: They're playing for keeps.

Erik Townsend: They're playing for keeps. This is not a proxy war. This is not— and, you know, if we get to actual military conflict with China Russia, I think that we have greater risk of total nuclear winter, end-of-the-world scenarios than we ever had during the Cold War with the Soviet Union. And it seems like it's not registering for anybody. People just don't see it as a big risk. I see it as a tremendous risk.

Listener appeal and this week's Research Roundup

Aaron Chan: Well, Erik, that's all the time we have for this week, but anything else you'd like to add?

Erik Townsend: Well, our regular listeners know the broken record. It really helps us, folks, the way we get the very best guests on the program is by growing our listener base and our reputation. So if you can help us out by telling your friends about MacroVoices, retweeting our announcements of the show so that other people see it, forwarding your Research Roundup email to your colleagues so that they'll want to get their copy too, all these things help us to get more registered users. More registered users is a statistic that Aaron uses to recruit the very best guests for future interviews on the program. The benefit of registering, of course, is you get our Research Roundup email every week. If you don't want it, it takes one click to opt out of it. But so far, we've had a very, very low opt-out rate. It's basically a compendium of free links to all the best research we could find on the internet.

We'll have to get a link in there this week to the Real Vision interview that I did with Raoul Pal. Certainly, if you liked that, please let Real Vision know. They're deciding— that was my screen test. They're deciding whether they want me to do more of those. So your help is definitely appreciated there. Aaron, tell them what they can find in this week's Research Roundup.

Aaron Chan: Right. And this week we've got a full lineup of articles, including Crescat Capital's Q3 investor letter highlighting the topping and rolling over of a key macro indicator that measures the valuation of all global financial assets owned by US persons relative to their after-tax income. Now, Jesse Felder of The Felder Report also shared an interesting video in which Jason Cummins, a former Fed senior economist, in a rare bout of self-awareness for an orthodox economist, articulates the fact that Central banks are far from independent and, in fact, are dependent on public faith that is quickly waning. Finally, we've gotten ahold of Art Berman's 17-page slide deck from his presentation at the recent Houston Geological Society dinner. You'll find all this and much more in this week's Research Roundup.

So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we've gotten and continue to welcome your suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For our listeners who write or blog about global markets and would like to share that content with our pro-finance community, shoot us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag, and we'll include it in our weekly distribution. If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for the latest updates and interview releases. You can also follow Erik @ErikSTownsend, Erik with a K, and myself @_AaronChan_.

For Erik Townsend, I'm Aaron Chan.

Erik Townsend: Thank you.

Aaron Chan: We'll chat with you next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at www.MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week, which never includes advertising or marketing.

You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we're able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can also subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to Mailbag@MacroVoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our Mailbag segment.

MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Michael Lebowitz — 720 Global (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Hello, everyone. MacroVoices episode 33 was recorded on September 29th, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. Michael Lebowitz from 720 Global will be joining me as today's featured interview guest. Michael and I will discuss his very popular article describing the breakdown of the virtuous economic cycle of savings leading to investment leading to increased productivity and, again, back to more savings, and also what the impacts of that breakdown will be on global financial markets.

First presidential debate and election-market risk

Aaron Chan: And I'm Aaron Chan. Now, before we dive into this week's markets, the subject that's been on everyone's mind is the U.S. presidential debate. Opinions as to who won the debate vary widely and seem highly dependent on the political orientation of the person opining. So, Erik, what's your take on the influence of the election on financial markets?

Erik Townsend: Well, as we get into the thick of it with silly season here between now and the election, we're going to introduce a new policy on MacroVoices, which is that we're going to ask all of our guests, as well as myself, not to opine on their personal views about who should be president, because you didn't tune into MacroVoices to hear our personal opinions, but instead to try to comment objectively on what either presidential election outcome would mean for financial markets. And I'll kick that off by saying that I think Donald Trump really boxed himself into a corner with this debate, because by being so sharply critical of Janet Yellen and the Fed, he has accused them of essentially inflating an asset bubble by keeping interest rates too low for too long. Now, although I I don't agree with Mr. Trump on a lot of things, I couldn't agree more with him on that particular point.

But I think it's kind of political suicide for him, because what's going to happen now is markets will expect that if Trump is elected, that he's going to put a stop to this, or try to, you know, replace Janet Yellen, do whatever he's able to do as president to get the Fed to stop blowing asset bubbles.

And I happen to think that that's the right thing for the president to do, so I'm not disagreeing with that. But it means that the bottom is going to fall out of this market. So if there's any politician in the history of the world who knows how to play this in her favor, it's got to be Hillary Clinton. So I think that each time Trump surges in the polls, the market's going to take a nosedive. Each time Hillary surges in the polls, the market is going to be very strong. And Hillary is going to put a spin on that, saying, look, the market is smart. The market is telling you that Donald Trump should not be president. All of you Republicans who have assets in stock markets, you should recognize that if you go ahead and vote for Donald Trump, you're going to lose half of your net worth because the market is going to crash.

And, you know, there's some substance to that. The market likely will crash if Donald either wins or appears to be about to win. And it's not because the market is saying that Donald Trump is a bad guy. It's because the market is saying if Hillary is elected, it's business as usual, and government policy will continue to be for sale to the highest bidder— read Wall Street— in exchange for bribe money in the form of campaign contributions. So I don't think it's really the market saying Trump's a bad guy and Hillary's a good guy, but boy, Hillary is going to spin it in that direction. I'm going to ask today's feature interview guest, as well as all future interview guests until the election, to opine similarly on what they think the outcome is going to mean for financial markets.

Equities: S&P futures and the Deutsche Bank scare

Aaron Chan: Yeah, Erik, I definitely agree with you there. I was watching the dollar-peso cross and also looking at the Japanese Nikkei futures as the debate was going on, and it definitely corroborates with what you were saying. Moving on, the S&P 500 stock index futures definitely saw a pronounced bounce on debate night. Then almost fully retraced the next day. Well, since then, the rally had been strong but was off again today. What's happening over here, Erik?

Erik Townsend: Well, overnight Wednesday into Thursday, we hit 2167, getting close on the way back towards that 2191.5, which was the high print so far back in August. And it looks like Deutsche Bank took a plunge. I'm not sure what brought about that plunge, but it seems like the market panicked in reaction to that shortly after noon on Thursday afternoon. It's bounced back. By the close to about 2,146 on E-mini S&P futures at the close of trading on Thursday. And I think we're going to see more of this volatility, banking stocks leading the way here. I don't know what the news was about Deutsche Bank that kicked this whole thing off, but, you know, we're definitely seeing this pattern of September volatility, which sometimes precedes a big downside event in October. I think, though, that from here to the election, election outcome is going to be the biggest influence on equity markets. And, you know, as I've said before, it's tempting It's tempting because I think Mr.

Trump probably does have a better chance of winning than the market and everyone is giving him credit for. It's tempting to be short here, but boy, you could get clobbered if Trump sticks his foot in his mouth, which is not something that he's not known for doing, and Hillary suddenly looks like a shoo-in. So a shoo-in election result, or the perception of one in either direction, could cause the market to go wild. Upside if Hillary looks like she's got it, downside if Donald looks like he's got it. Okay.

Crude oil: OPEC freeze and US inventories

Aaron Chan: All right, well, crude oil has to be the next biggest news story of the week after the election, with OPEC tentatively announcing a production cap at 32.5 million barrels per day, but they said the deal wouldn't be finalized until November. So, Erik, what's your take on oil, both the news from OPEC and this week's inventory data?

Erik Townsend: Well, this is the long-awaited moment that we've predicted on this show for a long time, that eventually OPEC would come up with some kind of freeze which would be utterly and totally irrelevant to supply and demand. They're talking about freezing production at 32.5 million barrels per day, which is, you know, that was the all-time record high level of production just a couple of months ago. And they're acting like this is somehow meaningful. Now, it is meaningful in the sense that symbolically, a year ago, it appeared that Saudi Arabia was intentionally trying to beat the price of oil down in order to damage their competitors. Clearly, now the sentiment has changed, and that has a symbolic importance. But as far as supply-demand fundamentals, it doesn't It doesn't matter at all, because they're still peddling as fast as they can. It is widely known that there's a lot of cheating that goes on in the OPEC-producing nations in terms of these quotas. So, they're going to continue to produce as much oil as they possibly can, and now they're going to say that their production number is 32.5 million barrels per day.

And even since that tentative announcement was made from the OPEC meeting, Iraq has already come back and said, hey, based on what the numbers list our production supposedly as, we would not agree to this. If we get to the November meeting where this is supposed to be finalized, we will not agree as it's currently drafted. You've got to change our numbers. Who knows who else is going to come back? So, this, as far as I'm concerned, didn't really mean anything to actual supply-demand fundamentals, but was obviously very emotionally and symbolically important. Goldman Sachs had just yesterday had a research piece out saying there's nothing, including an OPEC deal, that could possibly stop oil prices from rolling over to the downside. Then today, they came And then they came out with another one saying, this ought to be good for $7 to $10 of upside. Okay, Goldman, which is it? Even an OPEC deal wouldn't prevent the downside, or the OPEC deal is good for $7 to $10 of upside?

So far, it looks like it's good for upside, at least from what we're seeing in the tape action on Thursday afternoon. Meanwhile, you know, Art Berman and I have predicted— Goldman, by the way, had said by Q4 there would be massive builds in inventory and a storage crisis. Now, Art Berman and I have been predicting that that storage build would occur before then, like by now. And guess what? Another 1.9 million barrel drawdown in national crude oil inventories. 631,000 barrel drawdown in Cushing, Oklahoma inventories. Gasoline, meanwhile, 2 million barrel build on inventories. Well, that sort of goes in Art's and my direction, but after several weeks of drawdowns, I'm not sure that it really matters for that much. And besides, distillates this week, 1.9 million barrel drawdown. So if we've got a 2 million build on gasoline, a 1.9 draw on distillates, net-net in terms of finished products, it's basically flat this week. Front-month WTI crude oil futures now back trading earlier this afternoon above $48.

That of course is a reaction to the news out of OPEC. As we come into the close on Thursday afternoon, we're looking at $47.74, still up almost $5 from where it was before the news came out of OPEC. So we're seeing We're seeing a huge bounce here. Is it going to be temporary because this really doesn't matter to the supply and demand fundamentals? Or is it going to go another $5 or $10 higher? Because we've certainly seen rhetoric and emotion and sentiment drive oil prices all year.

You know, the whole buildup that we had going into the Doha meeting this spring was all about sentiment. So maybe this has got further to go. So, So, the view that Art Berman and I have had, which is that we still have a bunch of big inventory builds coming, the one that Goldman echoed with their research note earlier this week, still stands room to be proven right. But boy, if it's going to be proven right, we need to see those inventory builds start in earnest pretty soon here. And so far, we're just seeing inventory drawdowns. I traded emails with Samir Madani this week at #OOTT.

He said what's going on from their tracking activity is suddenly exports, both crude oil and finished products, exports are suddenly off the charts. So it is actually the export of product from the United States that is causing this change in inventories from what we expected. Sam's view is that that is distorting what analysts are concluding from all this, because people are used to the idea that the US is an importer. So you look at a change in inventory and you say, okay, that reflects a change in US domestic demand. Sam's take is it doesn't reflect a change in increasing domestic demand. It just says that we're exporting. exporting products suddenly, which kind of caught everybody by surprise. He even made a joke that if you look at the charter page of OPEC's website that describes the membership criteria for being in OPEC, according to that, the U.S.

qualifies to join OPEC. So, go figure.

Gold: consolidation range or descending triangle

Aaron Chan: Yeah, that's pretty interesting. Well, at this point, regular listeners know the broken record that comes next. We're still locked in a consolidation range in gold between $1,308 and $1,377. And it seems like every week we flip-flop from testing the high to the low side of that range. Now, I think it's the low end of the range this week. So how's the gold chart looking, Erik?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it's interesting. You mentioned this consolidation range between $1,308 and $1,377. That's what we've been describing this as, but as I look at the chart now, I realize that we've seen 3 reaction highs and 3 reaction lows that would support relabeling this chart pattern as actually a descending triangle. And that, of course, would portend a much more bearish outlook as opposed to the previous description that we had.

So if you look at the chart that way, maybe it's a little bit more bearish. And yeah, you're right, we traded below $1,320 earlier today on Thursday, looking at $1,323 right now. So we traded within $10 at the bottom of that range. It would be a closing print below $1,308 which would say that that bearish view really is confirmed. And if you wanted to look at this as a descending triangle, the new key resistance level would be about $1,347. So that's going to be a number to watch if we see a closing print above of that, it kind of invalidates at least the version of this that says we're actually looking at a descending triangle pattern.

10-year Treasury yields

Aaron Chan: Yeah, it's something that'll be interesting to watch, Erik. And it looks like this descending triangle is converging right at the election. So it'll be fascinating to observe. Now, 10-year Treasury yields gave up another 5 basis points since our last show, yielding 1.57% on Thursday afternoon. Erik, you said a couple of weeks ago that you'd been waiting to buy the 10-year futures when the yield touched 1.70%, but chickened out after a chorus of people, including Real Vision's Raoul Pal, said it might have been farther to go to the upside before eventually rolling over. So do you think you missed the boat by not buying the dips as you originally planned out?

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm not too worried about it. Obviously, the way the tape action's been, I did— what I had planned to do would have worked and it would have been a profitable trade so far. But I think that there are so many moving parts here, so many variables with all this election stuff going on, and particularly with Mr. Trump being so critical of the Fed, that's going to lead to a lot of speculation as to how a Trump presidency, if he were elected, might change monetary policy going forward. So I'm happy to be on the sidelines until the picture gets a little bit clearer. But yeah, so far I missed the trade.

Dollar index, the Fed and the election

Aaron Chan: So lastly, on the dollar index, the big volatility we were seeing in the dollar index seems to have calmed down now, now that there are no more FOMC meetings until after the election, with the DXY trading on a 95 handle ever since last week's show. So any change on this outlook?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I think, again, election outcome risk is going to be the driver of everything for the next couple of months. I think that there's no reason for the Fed to admit that their hiking cycle is over, which I think it is, until after the election. I think that the Fed is going to try to be as apolitical as possible and not say anything more than they have to until the election is over. The question is, you know, if Trump surges in the polls, what speculation that might lead to. Certainly, if Donald were to make it clear that he intends to put pressure on the Fed to allow interest rates to rise substantially, substantially from where they are and stop suppressing interest rates, and at the same time he were to surge in the polls, now you could see the dollar index really take off on speculation that a Trump presidency would mean higher interest rates. And that, of course, would lead to a stronger dollar.

That could cause gold to take a real hit. So, it's very interesting, the comment that you made earlier, too, about the convergence that is coming up.

I think one of the things a lot of people miss in technical analysis, when you see a wedge or a triangle, looking at that convergence point, as you just And saying, okay, what event that we know is coming on the geopolitical horizon is this chart pattern pointing to? And I think you got it exactly right. The gold descending triangle, if that's what it is, is pointing to the election, saying once we know, you know, if Trump is elected president and the dollar is going to take off and interest rates are going to move higher, gold is going to take a nosedive. There's no doubt about it. On the other hand, it could go the other direction. So I think that once the election results get clearer, all of these markets are going to resolve their consolidation patterns.

Aaron Chan: Okay. Well, thanks for the market update, Erik. Michael Lebowitz writes for institutional advisor 720 Global, and an article Mr. Lebowitz published back in June about the breakdown of the virtuous economic cycle has gotten a lot of attention from investors. Erik's interview with Mr. Lebowitz is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Interview: Michael Lebowitz, 720 Global, on the virtuous cycle

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Michael Lebowitz from 720 Global. And Michael, normally I like to start these interviews with the US dollar rally because everything else is priced in that. But I want to take a little deviation this week because you wrote a fantastic article back in June that's gotten a lot of attention called The Death of the Virtuous Cycle that really takes a step back and looks at the macro picture in probably a broader timescale. So I'd like I'd like to talk about that article first, and then we can move into our usual macro subjects. Why don't we start with The Death of the Virtuous Cycle? What's the premise of this article? What's it about?

Michael Lebowitz: So the purpose— and first of all, thank you for having me— the purpose was to provide a much more in-depth explanation on why economic trends are so poor, why they're stagnating, why productivity has ground to a halt, you know, real median wages are are still at levels from late 1990s. And there's all kinds of answers on a very short-term basis. We haven't fully recovered from the financial crisis, blah, blah, blah. But we believe there's much more to it, and we wanted to educate our clients and educate many others as to why this is occurring.

Erik Townsend: So, the death of the virtuous cycle. Let's start with what was the virtuous cycle? Describe the virtuous cycle that existed before it died.

Michael Lebowitz: So the virtuous cycle is an economic cycle that feeds on itself. It is basically— it's based on the discipline of saving. You save money, that money is invested, it's invested ultimately into production. Consumers invest it into various ways, but ultimately it's channeled into better means of production, more productive means of production. And as you get more productive, You get a couple things coming off that. You get higher earnings for corporations. You get higher wages because there's more money to go around.

With the higher earnings, with the higher wages, you also get a couple things. You get more consumption, but you also get more savings, and those savings go right back into this the virtuous cycle. So it's a organically self-sustaining cycle where you're consistently getting more and more production. And you're increasing wages, you're increasing earnings, and you're creating a more prosperous country. And if you look at the U.S., we were, you know, we started off as, you know, some guys landing on the shores of Plymouth Rock, and now here we are, that the U.S. is far and away the largest economy.

There's no question about that. And we've done it through all these incredible innovations that were a result That's the result of the virtuous cycle and the discipline that we had and the fortitude that we had to not just spend everything we had, but save it and invest and, and try to create a better tomorrow. And here we are now where this generation coming up is most likely not going to be as prosperous as the one before it, and that's going to be the first time that's happened.

How the virtuous cycle broke

Erik Townsend: So the cornerstone of the virtuous cycle is savings. Savings enables investment. Investment in investment in turn enables more productive, more efficient ways of doing things. That allows consumers' needs to be met with more leftover savings, and the cycle just feeds on itself. Why do you believe it's broken down, and how has it broken down?

Michael Lebowitz: So it's broken down over time, and certainly can't blame anyone specifically. You know, I do think the Federal Reserve has a lot to do with it. Certainly some rules out of the government have a lot to do with it. Basic mentality, consumer mentality, behaviors has a lot to do with it. But essentially what started happening in 1971, Nixon took us off the gold standard and that gave the Federal Reserve flexibility.

We wrote about this in an article called August 15th, and it gave the Federal Reserve flexibility to really screw around with the money supply, boost Boost it up, boost it down, or bring it down without having to worry about gold backing such moves.

So over time, and not immediately, the Fed became more and more aggressive. And what they really started doing, especially in the later '80s and the '90s, and aggressively more so after that, is trying to remove— trying to get rid of the business cycle. They were trying to alter recessions. And recessions are a good thing.

They eliminate bad investments, they enforce discipline on lenders and borrowers, and they have repercussions. It allows the business cycle that at times can get stretched, it allows inventories to come down. But in trying to get rid of recession, they didn't allow the recessions to fully play out. And there are many means of doing it with a series of low Lower and lower interest rates.

So as you bring down interest rates, people stop saving. They don't— they're not— they're not as incented to save. So you're starting to erode the virtuous cycle and essentially skipping— you're short-circuiting the whole virtuous cycle and you're going to the endgame, consumption, because consumption is 70% of economic growth. It's 70% of GDP.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Michael Lebowitz: 70% of economic growth.

And the feeling is that an expedient way to get ourselves out of recession, cut a recession short, is let's get people to borrow. They're going to borrow, they're going to spend. And if they spend, that's great because consumption is going to go up and it's going to look like economic activity.

And it does look like economic activity. And I would argue that for a long time it's hard to whether it's virtuous cycle economic activity or unvirtuous cycle economic activity. It kind of looks the same. But underneath, there's telltale signs.

Like I mentioned earlier, the flat earnings, flat wages, or negative wages. Productivity has been declining, and most likely productivity is going to be going negative. Some signs of labor productivity have gone negative. And total factor productivity could likely go negative at the next update. And I would also mention, this is not just a United States thing. This is going on in almost every developed nation.

Erik Townsend: You know, I agree with everything that you've said. I would add to that that I think there's a cultural shift that's occurred, certainly in my lifetime. When I was a kid growing up in the 1970s, you know, you get all of the messages from parents and teachers and school principals about how you're supposed to be, you know, don't do drugs and be a responsible citizen. Be a good citizen, don't be a criminal. And one of the strongest messages that we got, you know, every single time we went to school was personal responsibility. Be accountable for yourself, be responsible for yourself, and save for a rainy day.

We were given piggy banks when we were kids and taught to save. And now you've got congressmen on the floor of the United States Senate that are proposing why we need to change laws to punish savers and create debit cards that expire if you don't use them by a certain date so that people won't be selfish and save, which they think is wrong for society. So we've had this, this dramatic swing in terms of the public sentiment and what our children are taught about responsible financial planning.

Michael Lebowitz: I just wanted to add one more thing on more of the behavioral front too. It's also this short-termist attitude we have that we need everything today. We want everything today. And corporations are the same way. It's all about next quarter's earnings. Forget the future. What can we do today to make our lives better, make our company look better, or whatever it may be, without any regard for the future?

Debt-driven growth and tapped-out borrowers

Erik Townsend: Let's move to the consequences of this change. I agree with you completely that that virtuous cycle where society values savings and investment as the cornerstone of what enables prosperity. That message has gotten lost. I agree with that. So what are the consequences? How does it play out in markets? And, you know, if you're wanting to trade this, what would you look for in terms of trends that are actually actionable?

Michael Lebowitz: So it's essentially what we've done is turn the economy into a Ponzi scheme where basically more and more debt is needed to keep economic growth going, because at the end

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Michael Lebowitz: At the end of the day, there's really 3 components to economic growth. It's productivity, which is basically flatlining now. It's demographics, which helped our country immensely as the baby boomers were going through their 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s, but that's starting— that will become a headwind at some point.

And it's credit growth. So we have an economy that's highly dependent on credit growth. In fact, of a personal consumption, which again is about 70% of GDP, there's close to 40% to 50% of that is coming either directly or indirectly from debt. That's a massive amount of our GDP that is reliant on debt and not underlying organic economic growth. So you get to a point where you keep pushing debt, you lower rates, you make debt more affordable, but at some point, the debt is not serviceable. With wages, wages incomes have really lagged, and that's where you start seeing signs.

We saw that hit the consumers in 2008, and they've been very slow to increase again their debt. They're basically, to a large degree, tapped out.

Now we're starting to see it with corporations that are they're running they're running cash flow deficits because they're using their money. To do kind of silly things like stock buybacks. They're increasing dividends. They want to increase the share prices as much as possible. They're not investing in the future. CapEx spending— the age of their capital stock is increasing to 40, 50-year highs. They're not investing in the future.

They're cutting wages, and they are essentially killing their future, all to make this quarter's earnings look wonderful. So, so I think the sign is basically like 2008. When do— when does the marginal user of debt that's using debt to consume get to the point where they're tapped out? And I think we are very close to that.

Debt monetization and central-bank credibility

Erik Townsend: I want to talk more about how this ends and how close we are to that point. Something that I've felt for a number of years is when you get How did we get to the point where we are now, where this irresponsible live-beyond-your-means-on-borrowed-money attitude is not just something irresponsible people in society do? It's literally government policy to endorse and promote that kind of behavior. My contention is that with the government promoting it, it's going to go on until something breaks and ties the central bankers' hands so that they cannot continue to effectively monetize debt. And I realize The argument is that QE is not technically debt monetization, but it's only because there's an intermediary between the Fed and the government issuing the bonds. In all real intents and purposes, it really is debt monetization. I would contend this goes on until something breaks in the night, and the only thing I can think of is at some point we get to runaway inflation, and at that point the Fed has to stop doing all of this crazy money printing, otherwise we get into a hyperinflation.

Would you agree with that view, first of all? And more importantly, can you think of any other scenarios besides runaway inflation that would tie their hands and prevent central bankers from conjuring the next couple trillion dollars out of thin air?

Michael Lebowitz: Well, no. So I agree with you. They're going to keep trying to do what they're doing. They're going to get into negative rates. But the game is quickly coming to an end because as we're seeing here, we're seeing it in Europe, we're seeing into Japan, especially Europe and Japan, rates are negative. There are actually companies borrowing at negative rates or, you know, very, very low interest rates measured in basis points.

And it's not creating economic growth.

And so what I think is a very important issue is trust and confidence and faith in the central bankers. And as long as they can continue continue to make politicians, to make consumers, and probably most importantly, make investors in the financial markets believe in their voodoo, they can keep the ball rolling. They can keep kicking the can. But as we approach negative rates, I think it is quickly coming to an end. And I think what's interesting is the criticism on the Federal Reserve has been increasing, and it's not

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Michael Lebowitz: Not just guys like me and you that, that, that are viewed as alternative, that they, they look at things differently, they don't get it. This is coming from Lawrence Summers, has been very vocal. I actually just listened to an incredible interview from the Peterson Institute from Jason Cummins, and I apologize, I forgot where he's from, but he used to work for the Federal Reserve as an economist. He's basically an insider, and he's calling calling the Fed out in this interview, and it's truly amazing.

Erik Townsend: Well, I hate to find myself agreeing with Larry Summers, but—

Michael Lebowitz: No, but, but I think people are finally figuring out that the Fed does not have the answers. And I don't think they've gotten to the point yet, but I think they'll get there soon, that is it possible the Fed is actually causing these problems? And when that happens, it changes things drastically, because we both know that these financial markets are not priced at these levels based on their own merits.

Negative rates and the war on cash

Erik Townsend: Let's talk about negative interest rates some more, because, you know, as much as you and I might think, okay, this is crazy, because what it does is it basically creates a financial incentive for anyone who has any savings to spend it and not save it. So you're effectively creating a financial incentive for the entire nation nation to deplete itself of its savings, erasing the wealth of the country in terms of personal savings, which is crazy. But as much as you and I think it's crazy, you've got really, really high-level government officials that with a perfectly straight face are saying we need urgently to ban cash.

Even Ken Rogoff, who's very well respected for his work on the unsustainability of the national debt, has got a new book out trying to encourage the banning of cash, supposedly to stem criminal activities and terrorism and so forth. But if you get to, you know, any serious discussion of economics, people understand the reason for banning cash is to overcome the incentive that's created to hoard cash and potentially create a run on the fractional reserve system if you were to go to deeply negative interest rates. And you've got central bankers around the world talking about the need for negative interest rates, deeply negative interest rates sustained over a long period of time, because they believe that that is an effective and appropriate policy tool. So, guys like you and me see the lunacy of this, but, you know, the people that are in charge don't. What do you think would change that?

Michael Lebowitz: Well, first of all, I think it's downright scary, this call for getting rid of cash. Summers came out with that, I think it was during the summer, maybe 6 months ago or so, and he took the same approach as Rogoff, that criminalizing cash Criminal activity thrives off cash, which is okay. There is some degree of truth to that. But we also know, and HSBC has been caught up in this, that criminal activity also uses wires and they barter. And there's many ways that criminal activity occurs without cash.

And it's funny to me that Summers and Rogoff and others all of a sudden are concerned with criminal activity.

Yeah. But we both know the real reason that they want to do it is that if you, if you go to negative interest rates, people will hoard cash and they can't have that. So if your bank today was to call me and say, hey, we're gonna— your deposit rate that right now is zero or right around zero, we're gonna start charging you 5% a year to keep your money in our As soon as I get off this interview with you, I'm going right to that bank and I'm taking my cash out. And that cash is out of the system, which means I'm removing leverage from the system due to our fractional banking system.

And they know they can't have that, so it's a big impediment towards negative rates. But there's no common sense in negative interest rates.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Michael Lebowitz: Rates. We've never had negative interest rates. And there's this thought that's been going on in my head, and it's that interest rates are implying that the future— positive interest rates basically imply that the future is more uncertain to set. There's a risk premium. Now, there's other, there's other parts that go into the pricing of interest rates too, but can we also say that negative rates imply more certainty than today?

That's complete illogic. That doesn't make any sense.

And they're trying to keep this, for lack of a better word, debt scheme or Ponzi scheme going. They're to the point where we need negative rates now to generate very, very little growth. And the more they do it, the more they're eroding that virtuous cycle, that the productivity gains, the innovation, the new forms of production.

And it's— they're suffocating the economy all to get out another quarter of slightly better growth or to avoid a recession for another quarter or 2.

Erik Townsend: It's absolutely amazing. And, you know, something I don't think they've thought about— they use this scapegoat They're using the scapegoat of criminal activity as the reason for doing this. But if you actually think this through, it's true that if they ban cash, criminals will be forced to start transacting their business in something like precious metals, which is the obvious alternative. And can you imagine if we were to ban cash, essentially to enable negative interest rates? Eventually, those negative interest rates cripple the economy. You have a meltdown of the global sovereign debt market. And the only real The only wealth that's left in the world is precious metals, and criminals have all of the precious metals because the government banned the cash. I mean, it's, it's just absolute insanity.

Michael Lebowitz: So, so this is what bothers me. It's— we get it, and we're having a conversation about how insane it is, but the common person, the, the citizen, doesn't raise a stink about it. They don't Okay, it's negative rates. I get it. The economy is bad. They don't get it, and there's not more of a backlash And maybe there is a backlash and they just don't know how to economically talk about it or understand it. But they're starting to get it.

It's like that with inflation too. Why is the Fed demanding inflation? As a citizen, I don't want inflation. I don't want to have to pay more for whatever I'm. To buy tomorrow than today, but they accept it. And I'm really hoping that, you know, what we saw with Bernie Sanders, what we're seeing with Donald Trump, that we're starting to— the people are starting, finally starting to not only realize that things are wrong, but to take action.

Public anger, Brexit and European fracture

Erik Townsend: So maybe there is some hope, and maybe that's what Sanders and Trump are a signal What scares me is when you had something like World War II, okay, you know, the Nazis' agenda is very easy for everybody to understand. It's basically people of a certain race need to be executed in genocide. Okay, that's wrong. Everybody gets it.

When in order to understand what the battle is about, you need almost a degree or the equivalent amount of personal interest in macroeconomics to really understand the issues, then what happens is people just trust the government and let things go until the point, which I think we're reaching now, where they intuitively sense that something is deeply wrong and they start throwing Molotov cocktails at government buildings because they don't know how to explain what's wrong or what to do about it. They just know that it's unjust and corrupt. And I think that's what you're seeing with the political situation is most of the people in Occupy Wall Street, which is, you know, one political bent, or Or Tea Party is the opposite political orientation, but neither side really understood the issues very well. They just knew something was very deeply wrong, and they got upset about it.

And I think we're headed to more people being upset, and unfortunately the issues are complex enough that only a very small percentage of society listens to shows like this and cares to understand the details and the inner workings of it.

Michael Lebowitz: So here's one of the problems, and that's really bothers me is that it's not really that complex. Economics is not that complex. But most economists, and myself in my writings, they're not the easiest things to read, tend to be very technical and use jargon and are very confusing to the public.

Frequently, you know, my mom will call me and say, what did you mean by And I'm trying to, to make it as simple, and it is simple, but I think we really need more, more people like us to just simplify this and spread the word that this is not right. And negative interest rates should be the tip-off that it's not right.

Erik Townsend: We actually have negative interest rates and have had them for some time now in Europe, and a lot of people are getting worried about Brexit maybe being just the beginning and European exit contagion. Being a major macro risk over the next few years. What's your outlook? Was Brexit just a flash in the pan or was it the beginning of something that's only just begun?

Michael Lebowitz: Well, I think it all goes back to Sanders and Trump. People want something different. They're looking for anything different. And I think the fact that they voted to remove themselves from the euro region was stunning. Granted, they haven't The legislators have yet to pass what's called Policy 50 or Article 50, which starts the process in motion. But we are seeing fractures in the euro system, and I think these will continue as the people get upset. And there's also some geopolitical concerns as well. This immigration crisis is a big deal. And while they're trying to do the right thing and try to shelter people that are, that are in harm's way and living miserable lives, they are, they are letting in some terrorists as well. And it's a very touchy issue, and both sides have very good arguments, but it is just further leading to fracture.

But I think underneath all this fracture is the economy. Its wealth distribution has been horrendous. Wages aren't going up, but the wealthy are getting incredibly The very wealthy, and it's largely a function of central bank policy around the world, has been to inflate asset prices. And who owns assets? The wealthy, at the expense of productivity, which helps everyone.

Japan: demographics and yield-curve control

Erik Townsend: People who look at the long-term outlook for financial markets and asset prices in the United States are in many cases concerned about the retiring baby boom generation because it changes the demographics. backdrop of the country and points towards lowering productivity in the future. Japan, though, is really the poster child. Of all the countries, Japan is worst in terms of those twin forces of demographics and productivity. So what do you see for Japan, and do you think it's a harbinger of things to come for the United States as the baby boom generation ages and we get into this demographic change?

Michael Lebowitz: Yeah, I mean, they really have a worse than everyone. Their demographics are worse. They also have loaded up the boat on credit, and their productivity is now in decline, and it will most likely go further into decline. And they are really not allowing immigration into their country, which could change some of the demographics a little.

So they are the poster child, but they are also the poster child for central banks because somehow they have staved off a deflation.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Michael Lebowitz: —fall to bankruptcy despite numbers that are just stunning, debt-to-GDP type numbers. But again, I think they're starting to hit the end of the line, that they just can't keep doing what they've been doing. They're going deeper into negative rates. And one thing they just did, which is very, very concerning to me, is targeting the yield curve, targeting 10-year rates.

The yield curve is a barometer. It's what so many, so many economists use, so many corporations use to help them better understand where they should or shouldn't invest their capital into growth. And essentially, I feel like what they're doing is they are the equivalent of, say, like solving global warming by distorting thermostat or thermometer readings.

They're getting rid of the tool that we could use to help efficiently allocate capital. And that to me is extremely scary. It's also scary that they've been buying equity. It's scary to me that the Europeans were buying corporate debt. And then yesterday or 2 days ago, I saw various people noting something to the effect that down the line, Yellen could see potentially buying equities. It's frightening to me.

That's nationalization.

Bonds, precious metals and the 'bullish bear' view

Erik Townsend: So based on the things that you've said in this interview, it sounds like you agree with the view that equity prices are definitely extended and stretched here, but also bond prices, although they may still have further to go, are probably overvalued in the long-term picture of things because we've seen all of this artificial policy pushing yields So, what does that leave in terms of alternatives for savers? Are we looking at precious metals or something else? Where do we go at this point?

Michael Lebowitz: I do prefer precious metals. That being said, it can't be 80%, 90% of a portfolio. But I think it is an alternative, and it's not looked upon highly by many investors, so it's not widely owned. But if you're looking for something to protect your money, something that has done It's a viable alternative. It is a rock, I get it, but money is also not backed— money is paper.

So, uh, you know, I prefer to go with history and thousands and thousands of years of history and have an allocation to gold.

I am on the fixed income side. I guess I would call myself a bullish bear. I think yields can go down lower.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Michael Lebowitz: I think any kind of crisis, especially Europe, Japan, could send the dollar flying, and it could send so much money into the United States it could push yields much lower.

Fundamentally, we do have very low inflation, very low growth, so you can make somewhat of a fundamental case. But at the bottom line, these rates are not sustainable, and I think in the long run rates will be much higher. So it's, it's actually created quite the conundrum in the Treasury market. Rates are so low that even if you're bullish, is, is the risk-return skew really worth it?

And it's the bond market.

One of my biggest concerns with the bond market is that the marginal transactors are traders. They're not investors. When rates were at 5 5, 6, 10, 12%, investors were buying bonds. Grandma and grandfather and parents and everyone were buying bonds, and they didn't care about bond prices or changes in yield. They were going to hold it to maturity and they were going to make their set interest rate.

As rates go lower and lower, you get less investors that really buy— who's going to buy a 30-year bond at 2.3%?

Erik Townsend: That's right.

Michael Lebowitz: Hold it for 30 years. That's, that's an insane bet. So you end up with more and more traders. Traders are interested in price. They want to buy it at par, they want to sell it at 102. They don't have any intention of clipping a coupon, or the coupon they clip is meaning, you know, is not that great.

And there's also, because it's not that great, there's very little cushion for error. So My concern is that when the bond market turns, and I'm not— I don't think it's going to turn necessarily anytime soon, that traders exit en masse and there's no one left to pick up, to pick up the pieces. So you could have a pretty bad downdraft in bonds and yields, which has pretty big repercussions for a debt-driven economy.

Long gold, long dollar

Erik Townsend: I'd like to ask you about a trade that I discussed a couple of weeks ago on this program with Raoul Pal from Real Vision Television. Raoul and I both have been looking at the same trade, which is long gold futures and long dollar index futures at the same time. And of course, normally that trade wouldn't make sense because they're inversely correlated assets, and, you know, it doesn't seem to make sense. But Raoul and I both see the potential of a home run for both gold and the dollar appreciating, mostly because of flight capital capital going out of other markets around the world into both precious metals and US Treasuries as a safety trade. And of course, we could be wrong about that. You could have one go up as the other one goes down, which happens most of the time. But the scenario where they both go down at the same time, neither Raoul or I can see how that could happen.

So, it seems like a fantastic asymmetric return trade. What are your comments on that? Can you think of any scenario where both gold and the dollar index could trend downward at the same time?

Michael Lebowitz: I don't think the dollar index can trend. I think the dollar has been in consolidation now for well over a year, given that the Fed is still in a— I guess you could call it a hawkish mode, but they're the only central bank that's somewhat hawkish. And I use that term loosely, but they are talking about raising rates when everyone else is talking about new and creative ways to lower rates. And frankly, our economy is doing a little better than most of those countries.

So the dollar is the place to be, and it's hard for me to see the dollar selling off drastically. You know, a few points here or there, that's fine.

Gold, I'm a big supporter of it, but what bothers me, keeps me up at night, is what happened to gold in 2013. 2014, where there were massive orders to sell gold during illiquid markets. Why that occurred, who knows? What I do know is that central banks do not like the signal that gold sends, and they're trying to break signals.

You know, just like we discussed earlier with Japan and their 10-year, they're trying to break signals. If gold were at $2,500 right now, I am pretty sure that there would be a lot more concern about the Federal Reserve and what they're doing, what other central banks are doing. So, by however it can be done, by keeping a lid on the price of gold, they can keep a lid on a signal that all is not right.

So, I can't say that, you know, the dollar could go down a little and I could see gold getting smacked down a little. But that said, I agree with you guys.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Michael Lebowitz: I agree with you guys. I think there is the potential for them both to rally and rally significantly. Again, especially if something happens in Japan and Europe overseas, the flight to quality back to dollars could be amazing, and that could show up in Treasuries but also in gold.

Clinton, Trump and owning volatility

Erik Townsend: I'd like to move on to a topic that's on everybody's mind this week after the debate on Monday, which is the U.S. presidential cycle. We're asking all of our guests on the program to try to comment objectively on either outcome, Clinton or Trump. What do you think either outcome would mean for both the US stock market and generally global financial markets?

Michael Lebowitz: So I'll start with Hillary, I guess. She is kind of the status quo. She is the establishment. So in general, I think she would continue to push Obama policies. Be protective of the Fed. She'd probably push for some sort of infrastructure. So I think for the market, she's a safer bet. I think Yellen is safe with Hillary, at least to finish the term.

That said, Lawrence Summers is lurking in her shadow, and he's been critical of the Fed raising rates. I think he was out there this week too, again criticizing their rate hike in December.

Erik Townsend: Sure.

Michael Lebowitz: So on the margin, I don't think Hillary, at least initially, is a huge negative for equity prices.

Donald Trump, on the other hand, I like to say he has the ability to break the trade. Yellen could resign, he could release her, and he could really put a dent in Fed confidence, Fed credibility. Right. That's actually a big deal. And, you know, we saw the market get a little volatile. We saw things like the Mexican peso get volatile around the results of that, the perceived results around that debate.

So I think that Donald Trump has much more of an ability to upset the apple cart, so to speak. He's also, you know, very early on in that debate, and actually throughout the debate, kept talking about trade deals and renegotiating, restructuring trade deals. Well, many trade deals, the prime beneficiary of those trade deals, besides the people in these other countries that are getting jobs, are the corporations.

They're employing cheaper labor than they can employ at home, and they're getting rid of tariffs that allow them to sell their products. So Trump also has the potential to fundamentally hurt companies by by restructuring some of these trade deals.

What I think is amazing though is that the complacency in the market, and you can measure it a number of different ways, but the most simple way is the volatility index, VIX, has been very low. And we recently wrote about it and it's lower than, or when we wrote about it a month ago, it was lower than at any point in any, like the last 6 or 7 years. Elections at that point in time.

So the market, like everything else, is complacent. But I think there's a real risk here that there could be some extreme volatility. I actually saw Howard Marks' quote, I think it was yesterday, something to the effect that the riskiest thing out there is to believe that there's no risk.

And I think that sums it up well, that there is a lot of risk out there with the election. And you throw on top of that stagnating economic data, and I see no reason not to own volatility here. Obviously trade it because it's a tough instrument, and/or hedge your portfolios. But to me, again, you know, we talked about the skew in bonds. There's not that much upside and a whole lot of downside.

I think, uh, very similar on equities. Yeah, the markets could go up more. It's hard to see them going up much more because valuations are already beyond stretched, but, uh, the downside could be tremendous.

Erik Townsend: Unfortunately, we've run out of time. Before we close, please tell our listeners who'd like to follow more of your work what you do at 720 Global and where they can find out more information about it.

Michael Lebowitz: So we like to think that we're outsourcing CIOs, CIOs for hire. We basically offer consulting advice to professional investment advisors, and we basically want to help them make better decisions, providing them with unique research and guidance. I think most importantly, we're independent, as you've probably gathered through this conversation, and we share plenty of views that a lot of times are not popular, and we're beholden to nobody.

Uh, currently we publish research. We've put out there 50, 60 pieces. Some of them, like the Death of the Virtuous Cycle, as you mentioned, are very macroeconomic-based. Some will discuss specific numbers. We put out one recently on GDP, but we also discuss investment strategy and behavioral aspects as far as investing goes. So we really try to help advisors Help money managers, help endowment funds, help family offices provide their clients something, something better than what everyone else is doing.

Erik Townsend: And for our registered users at MacroVoices.com, this week's Research Roundup email will contain links to a couple of sample articles that Michael has written, and particularly the Death of the Virtuous Cycle article. Michael, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. We really appreciate it. Aaron Chan and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time. in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program.

Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan.

Postgame: Dwight Anderson's Real Vision interview

Aaron Chan: So Erik, for this postgame, I actually want to get your take on a recent Real Vision TV episode that Raoul Pal recommended back when we interviewed him 2 weeks ago. Now, the specific must-see interview that I'm referring to is Dwight Anderson's conversation with Dan Tapiero. Now, I thought it lived up to everything Raoul said, and it's definitely something that I'm bookmarking for future viewing. In listening to Dwight Anderson's background as a manufacturing consultant to ultimately becoming a commodities investor, I couldn't help but notice parallels between you and him.

How has your business background helped you to become a better investor, and how did you go about developing your framework for viewing the world?

Erik Townsend: Wow. Excellent question. Just for the benefit of anybody who's not a regular listener and didn't hear that interview with Raoul Pal, we are talking about a Real Vision television interview that Raoul had recommended Real Vision, of course, is a paid subscription service, but if you haven't already used up your free trial subscription, you can get a free trial just for being a MacroVoices listener, and you can hear this interview that Aaron is asking me about.

But to go back to your question, Aaron I enjoyed this interview. I always like finance guys that actually have a background in really and truly running a business first before they get into finance. Maybe that's just because it's how I relate to it, but something that I always noticed before I got into finance and was involved in the corporate world is, you know, You see these guys that are super duper smart, Ivy League, Harvard MBA types, and they're just saying, what is wrong with this stupid CEO? Why doesn't he see that to get his ratios where he needs to be, he needs to increase his revenue? These dummies. And you sort of say, you know, there's this thing called a customer who has to consent in order to get revenue increased.

Aaron Chan: Oh, right.

Erik Townsend: It's not something you just turn a dial up on. And I often feel like even the smartest finance analysts, guys that have been studying business for all of their careers but never actually ran one, are kind of at a disadvantage.

And frankly, I think that the country is dramatically disadvantaged because the whole corporate management just preoccupation with short-sightedness and focusing on next quarter's earnings, never paying attention to the next 10 years' strategic strategy— it's not because the CEOs are stupid, it's because they are being compensated and paid based on how Wall Street Wall Street responds to them and what happens to the stock price. And they have learned that all that Wall Street cares about is next quarter's earnings, not the strategic prospects for the company. So it's very interesting to me to make the transition from the corporate culture into— I don't know I'm really part of the Wall Street culture, I don't want to be— but, you know, into the world of investment management and investment analysis. So it has It has helped shape my view of the world. And I think that people who've actually run a business are better qualified to invest in them than Ivy League guys that never actually ran one.

Inflation versus deflation

Aaron Chan: Yeah, the tangible experience definitely sounds useful. Now, I want to pivot to an economic issue here. Now, we've all heard the deflation versus inflation debate. And Dwight sees both sides of the argument. On the one hand, there is the debt load, demographics, declining productivity, the viability of the E.U. All that leading to deflation. But he also sees the erosion of the good faith of paper currencies, and in particular the dollar, and the subsequent march towards inflation. So, Erik, where do you stand on the spectrum and how do you think about this position?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think about it in a different paradigm than what you just described, because you're kind of talking either/or. Is it an inflationary or a deflationary story? And the way I look at it is history teaches us that every epic inflation in history was preceded by a really strong whiff of deflation.

And I think we're in the deflation that comes before the big inflation. Without a doubt, the people that have said that the US dollar is doomed to collapse someday because fiat currency has been stretched beyond any reasonable limit, it's not backed by any hard asset, and the US debt is just so phenomenal that, you know, this whole house of cards has to come crashing down and the dollar is doomed, they're going to be proven right someday.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: But before that happens, I think the US dollar is headed much higher against other currencies because of the whole best-looking, you know, dirty shirt in a very dirty laundry pile, or cleanest shirt in dirty laundry pile, whatever the analogy is. So, I think what we're going to see is a continuing deflationary force, a very pro-US dollar, dollar index probably moving substantially higher from here, especially if a dollar Trump presidency scenario were to cause the Fed to stop keeping interest rates artificially low.

I think at some point that dollar collapse scenario becomes real, but we're in uncharted territory. And the worst mistake you can make is to think that because something has to happen someday, that that means it's going to start happening tomorrow. So, I don't look at it as an either/or. I look at it as a question of where are we in the timeline? At some point, we see the bottom of the deflationary pressure and we move into an inflationary period. And eventually, I I think we have to combat runaway inflation. Are we getting close to the turning point? I have no clue, and I don't think anybody does.

Electric vehicles and the WTI term structure

Aaron Chan: Got it. So you look at this temporally, and then there's some sort of inflection point. Now, Erik, I want to pivot to something that's in your wheelhouse. And Dwight brought up a thesis that I thought was variant and different from anything else I'd ever heard. And it's that the penetration rates of electric vehicles will lead to higher crude oil prices, because oil companies will be concerned about where oil prices will be, given the inroads made by electric vehicles. So, in response, they'll cut major production projects. And I want to get your take. What do you think about this opinion?

Erik Townsend: I'm so glad that you asked me about that one, because I wanted to crawl through my Real Vision viewer and strangle Dan Tapiero for not asking the obvious follow-up question.

Aaron Chan: Erik, easy. We want to interview Dan hopefully someday.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I meant to say, as we look forward to inviting Mr. Tapiero onto the show, one of the questions I'd like to ask him is. He didn't ask about the term structure of what would be going on, or they didn't talk about the term structure of the crude oil futures market, because the assertion that was made by Dwight is, look, the CEOs of oil companies are gonna be spooked out by a growing acceptance of the electric vehicle revolution, and they're not gonna wanna invest in really expensive projects. Well, look, they don't care what the future of electric vehicles is. They care whether or not they can justify their projects. based on what they can hedge today. So, if you were to have a situation where electric vehicles had taken over sentiment of the markets, and there was an expectation reflected in the term structure of WTI crude oil futures specifically. So, let's say it's a year from now or 2 years from now, front-month WTI is trading, let's say for sake of argument, at $120 a barrel.

But the 5 or 6 or 7-year-out contracts are down at $50 a barrel because the market is expecting a collapse. Okay, now, yeah, that would lead to even higher short-term prices because nobody is going to build any projects. But no, it doesn't matter how convinced you are that electric vehicles change everything. If there's still contango in the market and the 5, 6, 7-year-out futures are trading at $140 or $150, you're gonna do that super deepwater Arctic, whatever it is, frightfully expensive project because you can sell forward right now, hedge your future production, and eliminate your market risk. So it's not about what electric vehicles are going to do. It's about what the term structure of WTI futures looks like. And I was shocked that Dan didn't think to bring up that question.

Aaron Chan: Well, hopefully, if we can get Dan Tapiero on, you can ask him that question, Erik. Well, I've got quite a few more questions I'd like to ask you, but we'll have to save it for another time. Guys, I highly recommend you check out this interview if you're a Real Vision TV subscriber.

And if you're not, don't fret. You can trial the program for free and even get a 10% discount on your subscription by signing up at www.realvisiontv.com/discount/macrovoices. So, Erik, that's all I've got for this week. Anything else to add?

Research Roundup and sign-off

Erik Townsend: Well, our listeners already know the broken record. We really appreciate it when you help us promote the show, because the more that people have heard of MacroVoices, the easier it is for Aaron to recruit the very best guests to put on the program. So please help us out by retweeting our announcements if you're on Twitter. Tell your friends, forward your Research Roundup emails to your colleagues so that they can get interested and sign up for it too. And of course, most importantly, register your free account at MacroVoices.com. You get a benefit of a free weekly Research Roundup email. Let's tell them what's in it this week, Aaron

Aaron Chan: Right. I'd like to start by highlighting an excellent research note from Shannon McConaghy of Horseman Capital on why Why Japanese Regional Banks Are Ultimately Going to Zero. Now, we've all heard about how negative interest rates are killing the banks, and with Governor Kuroda recently committing further to cutting short-term rates, as well as introducing yield curve control, this is one of the most succinct and comprehensive treatments of this issue in a mere 3 pages that I've ever read. So you definitely don't want to miss this. Now, next up is an excellent note from Daniel Oliver of Myrmikan Capital, in which he discusses where we currently stand in the gold mining recapitalization cycle, and why asset developers might be the place to be in the medium term. He then quotes Senator Root's extraordinary 1913 speech in opposition to the Federal Reserve Act and provides data in support of the inevitable economic laws of credit expansion. Finally, one of our biggest proponents on Twitter, Michael Medici, put together an excellent slide deck which organizes what our past guests have articulated on various topics they've discussed with Erik, and I highly encourage you to check this out.

Personally, I think it's a huge value add because it's a great way to view our past content in a way that is comparable and actionable because you can also compare the different trade strategies that are brought up. So big thanks to Mike, and anyone who is interested in this project should reach out to him on Twitter @MikeRMedici. You'll find all this and much more in this week's Research Roundup.

So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we've gotten and continue to welcome your suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For our listeners who write or blog about global markets and would like to share that content with our pro finance community, shoot us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag and we'll include it in our weekly distribution. If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for the latest updates and interview releases. You can also follow Erik @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna.

Erik Townsend: Thanks, Patrick.

Aaron Chan: For Erik Townsend, I'm Aaron Chan. Chat with you next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at www.MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup. Up email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week, which never includes advertising or marketing.

You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we're able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can also subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag Bag segment.

MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's host. Or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Alex Gurevich — author of the book The Next Perfect Trade (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik.

Episode set-up and Aaron Chan's opener

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 32 was recorded on September 22nd, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. We've got a great guest lined up for this week's feature interview. Alex Gurevich, author of the book The Next Perfect Trade, is also one of the most prolific and regular guests on Real Vision Television. Alex and I will be going around the world of macro, covering this week's FOMC decision, the US dollar rally, Treasury yields, gold, China, Japan, European and exit contagion, and much, much more.

Aaron Chan: And I'm Aaron Chan. Last week, the S&P 500 had been beaten down a bit from its all-time high a few weeks back, and we wondered if maybe the big correction so many industry luminaries are predicting had finally begun. But once again, a little accommodation from the Fed goes a long way to cure all stock market ills, or so it would seem this week. The FOMC did not hike rates yesterday, consistent with most analysts' predictions, and that seems to have begun a rally in stocks, gold, and Oil and just about everything else except the dollar itself. So, Erik, what's your take on the FOMC decision and the equity market outlook?

Market wrap: FOMC, equities and the election

Erik Townsend: Well, it's interesting. I think that for the most part, the no rate hike should have been priced in. The expectations among analysts were pretty darn low. I think it was clear that there was not going to be a rate hike. Frankly, it's clear to me that I don't think that any more rate hikes are coming in this cycle. I think we've gotten to the point where the Fed has realized that they don't really have room to hike. The macro data is looking worse and worse.

And I think they're afraid to admit it because, you know, to say they're in a rate hiking cycle, they only had one hike and there's no second hike in the cycle, is kind of a loss of face and could inspire a loss of confidence.

As far as where things go from here, you know, it's really hard to call. I am so tempted emotionally. I have to admit I want to be short this market because I have so much respect for some of these industry luminaries that are just saying the valuations here are way overextended. We're due for something really big to the downside.

The thing is, what I— the reason I've chickened out of that, and, you know, if we hit 2190 again, it'll be really tempting to go short. But the reason so far that I have chickened out of a short trade on the S&P 500 is just that I really think the election outcome is going to have a tremendous effect.

And that means not just after the election, as soon as it becomes clear from polls who's most likely to win. Right now it's close enough that it's hard to say. You know, if Hillary Clinton is elected, I think it's pretty much assured that it's business as usual. The government is for sale to Wall Street for a price, and they can expect to be able to get more accommodation from the Fed and so on and so forth. If Trump is elected, it's such a wild card, because on the one hand, he's been really outspoken in saying that the Fed is just propping up markets so Obama will look good for the rest of his term.

Well, if he gets elected, it certainly doesn't behoove him to do something that causes the market to crash. His Republican supporters would not like that. On the other hand, it would be kind of disingenuous for him to not put some kind of pressure on the Fed to stop doing what he's criticized them for doing.

So how would that play out? It's such a huge wildcard. I don't think anybody knows. And, you know, I'm not a political pundit or expert on evaluating campaign, you know, election outcome risks. And the other thing is there are so many wildcards in this because we know that WikiLeaks has a bunch of dirt on Hillary Clinton that they're going to wait until October to release when they think it has the most effect. Well, how much dirt do they really have? Are they bluffing? We don't know yet. Similarly, Donald Trump seems like he could really pull a rabbit out of a hat if he doesn't stick his foot in his mouth and pull off a landslide win.

Guess what? Donald Trump's pretty good at sticking his foot in his mouth. So I think that the election has so much of a wildcard effect in either direction. If I were going to trade this, it would probably be to buy out-of-the-money puts on the S&P. And that's a lottery ticket trade. You've got to be ready to lose 100% on that trade.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: And just figure if you get lucky and called it right, maybe there's a big percentage win. But you've got to have a small enough size in order to not get clobbered if it goes the other way.

Market wrap: crude inventories and Cushing

Aaron Chan: Right. And let's turn to oil for a second here. 2 weeks ago, we had a massive 14.5 million barrel drawdown in nationwide crude oil inventories. Then last week, there was a much smaller draw. And we've been waiting for a big rebound in the form of a big inventory build now that Tropical Storm Eileen is behind us. How'd the numbers come out this week?

Erik Townsend: I got to tell you, Aaron, I am absolutely dumbfounded this week. Another huge drawdown, 6.2 million barrels. Now, it's tempting to look for this pipeline disruption on the East Coast and the leak and everything and say, well, maybe that caused it. Well, I could rationalize that in the other direction.

You know, if you couldn't use the pipeline, you had to stop refining, then you're going to stop using crude oil. And maybe in that case, you get a bigger build. But we got a big drawdown against analyst expectations. Of a 3-point-something million barrel build, we got a 6.2 million barrel drawdown. I don't get it. I can't explain it. I can't figure it out. Cushing, Oklahoma, 526,000 barrel build on inventory.

That one makes a little bit more sense. Might be associated with the pipeline stuff. I'm not sure. Gasoline, 3.2 million barrel massive, massive drawdown on gasoline inventories. Now there was a 2.2 million barrel build on distillate inventories, but still that nets out. Out to more than 1 million barrels of net drawdown on finished products. Not what I was expecting with summer driving season behind us. So prices unsurprisingly are up on the news. I should point out that our friends at hashtag OOTT have been predicting that next week will bring the really big build on crude oil inventories. We'll have to see whether or not that happens. But until it does, prices are up. And also The time spreads, which I watch very carefully, are narrowing, suggesting that fears about an inventory crisis around fall maintenance season are abating. So, it appears for now that, you know, looks like the call that Art Berman and I made that there would be a bunch of large builds on inventory hasn't happened yet.

I don't think that the jury is out yet, but we'll see what next week brings.

Market wrap: gold consolidation range

Aaron Chan: All right, Erik. And I don't even know if I should say it at this point, but we're still locked in a consolidation range in gold between $1,308 and $1,310. Now, when we taped last week's show, we were flirting with the bottom of the range. So I guess this week it must be time to retest the top of the range again?

Erik Townsend: Seems that way. It feels like a real just roller coaster week to week. $1,341 as we speak, right, just almost to the close on Thursday afternoon. $1,347.80 was the high trade on the day. Clearly, this is being fueled by reaction to the FOMC announcement yesterday. Dollar index taking a Tumble on no rate hike as a result, gold seeing to the upside. Frankly, though, I don't see this as a big bullish indication. That confirmation of no rate hike, I would have expected maybe even a bigger pop. $1,347, that's $10 less than we saw, what was it, 2 weeks ago when we had a test of a higher number. And, you know, now we've confirmed no rate hike and, you know, we didn't even get to that. So, I still am leaning slightly towards a downside resolution to this trading range, but definitely this one has confounded me.

I really don't know where it's going.

Market wrap: 10-year yield and the dollar index

Aaron Chan: Got it. Last week you said you'd been waiting for months to buy 10-year Treasury futures if the yield touched 1.70%, but you chickened out when it finally did last week because you feared it might have further to go. Now we're back down to a 1.62% yield as we're taping the show on Thursday afternoon. Erik, are you regretting your decision to pass on buying that dip?

Erik Townsend: Well, hindsight's always 20/20. You know, I suppose I should regret it because it would have been a profitable trade so far, but I am not a day trader. I tend to put on longer trades. And I think, as Raoul Pal said last week, there's room for this to go to 2%. Who knows? I do think we eventually get to 1% yields. Did I miss my opportunity to buy the dip? Maybe, probably, I don't know. But I don't really have enough conviction to say that I regret it deeply. I'll ask Alex in today's interview what he thinks.

But I think there's plenty of room for more volatility, especially with uncertainty that we already talked about around the election and everything. I'm not too excited to dump into a speculative trade when there's plenty of room to see a pretty big move in the other direction before it eventually resolves, as I think it will, to lower yields.

Aaron Chan: Okay. And finally, even in the wake of the FOMC decision not to hike rates, the dollar index has managed to hold on to a 95 handle. So, Erik, any new thoughts on the dollar this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, yeah, it's, it's interesting. I'm surprised with how quickly Equities responded to the upside and dollar to the downside. We were just over 96, just barely into a 96 handle. We touched 95 even very briefly today, back up to 95.34 as we're speaking now, just before the close on Thursday. So I think we're still in that consolidation range. The thing that I'm waiting for— it seems like most people's reaction to yesterday's news was, oh, that means the rate hike is going to come in December instead of now.

I think what could send the dollar temporarily lower, maybe retesting the bottom of this range around 91 or so, would be if the Fed admits that we're not going to hike in December either. It's, it's time to just admit that the hiking cycle is over. So what would cause them to do that? Maybe a preemptive move if they think they're eventually going to have to have a cut next. They probably don't want to announce that all at once. So we'll see what happens.

Aaron Chan: All right. Thanks for the market update, Erik. Alex Gurevich has been an extremely popular guest on Real Vision Television, and we're excited to have him on this week's program as a first-time guest. Erik's interview with Mr. Gurevich is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Gurevich on the FOMC reaction

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now on the program is Alex Gurevich, author of The Next Perfect Trade and the founder of HonTe Investments. Alex, thanks so much for joining us on the program. I like to start these macro interviews usually with the US dollar, but this week, boy, FOMC— I'm really surprised. I thought that I think that it was pretty much baked in. Everybody knew there was not going to be a rate hike. But boy, we've really seen a pretty big run-up in everything, really— stocks, gold, everything rallying, except of course the dollar index. Were you surprised by this? And I wonder particularly if you would agree with me, because I'm starting to feel like the Fed has really trapped themselves here. I don't think they can hike rates, but I don't think they can admit that they can't and save face at the same time. So how do you see this whole monetary policy situation in this week's announcement?

Alex Gurevich: Well, Erik, thank you for having me here. This is, of course, a complex and long question, but I'll try to see some sense in this. It is hard to predict generally how market would react to any given policy meeting, but I am not surprised by the rally that occurred because the market was a little bit trapped, as you say, but in this case it was trapped in bearishness in bonds.

But the reality was that The two things that if Fed was to hike, it would probably create some risk-off shock, catastrophic flattening of yield curve and rally in the long end of the yield curve anyway, and maybe temporarily rally in the dollar index and temporarily sell-off in stocks.

But that might have not lasted. On the flip side, I think there was a lot of technical pressure, for example, on the yield curve. And on the bond markets coming from, we just came from ECB and BOJ, and we have established over the last year a very strong pattern of ECB and BOJ disappointing.

And after their meetings, typically the rates yields rise. They rose, and there was a recent pretty significant yield rise in Japan, and I think that pulled U.S. yields up. And then when there was this relief. That nothing is happening with the Fed. I think there was a snapback. And yes, I agree, hike was highly unlikely. The market was pricing around 20% in terms of Fed funds futures.

And I personally thought the likelihood was more like 3% because I could not imagine Fed hiking when the probability is so low.

In fact, they have not done it since 1994. There has— have not been any surprise hikes for 22 years on the markets, which is a long time. It could have been the first day today, but I just— I mean, whatever, yesterday, but it was unlikely. And however, I think a couple of dealers who put— primary dealers who put out their research and a couple of other thinkers managed to scare people a little bit and kept everybody on their toes by putting out opinions that Fed might hike after all.

So I think that there was certain psychological pressure which was beyond actual market pricing that got relieved once this meeting rolled off.

Long dollar as a dominant trade

Erik Townsend: I want to move on to the US dollar, one of my favorite topics, because of course everything is priced in US dollars. I just had Raoul Pal on the show last week. And, you know, Raoul and I both expected the US dollar rally to continue. But boy, it's taken longer. This pause, if that's what it is, consolidation, has taken longer than we expected. And now I sort of think, boy, I think the Fed is close to having to admit that the rate hiking cycle, if a single hike counts as a cycle, is over. And if that's the case, you know, maybe that's a bear factor for the dollar. So where do you see the US dollar? Do you think that we're just in a pause and the rally is going to continue, or do you think the tops are in?

Alex Gurevich: Well, this is, of course, as you point out correctly, a very crucial point and very crucial conversation. I think of these things, I think, slightly different than most macro thinkers. For those who have read or will read my book, I think of things in terms of concurrent necessity. So I do not think of dollar as a single asset performance.

I think of dollar— to me, long dollar is a dominant trade. The reason I'm long dollar, because dollar is a concurrent necessity with respect to rate hikes, and I will explain it in a moment. So majority of people, if you go back even a year, majority of people who were saying that the dollar rally is over were predicating their view on the fact that the hiking cycle is over, which may or may not be correct.

And I can actually go a little bit further to discussing the hiking cycle, but right now I just want to outline my overall logic. However, the yield curve was pricing a hiking cycle, and in fact it's still pricing it. The yield curve in the U.S. is upward sloping, and more so than in other developed world countries.

So you cannot price one asset based on non-market projections of another asset. So if you want to understand correct pricing for the dollar currently, you have to yield current yield curve. Now, if your view is that yield curve will rally, that is, hikes will be all taken out and maybe the next move is an ease, then the correct trade is to be long bonds.

If you think that is not the case, then correct trade is to be long dollar.

But the beauty of the long dollar trade, as it has proven over the last few years, that it actually can succeed without hiking cycle by the Fed. Because the other central banks— and when I'm talking about long dollar, I'm talking about long dollar developed markets, because long dollar versus emerging markets, it's a very different kind of trades and has to do more with risk and growth in the world. While Developed relative exchanges of developed market currencies. It's a policy game, and the policy is very easy in Japan, in Switzerland, and and of course in Eurozone. Switzerland obviously the easiest with a carry on dollar Swiss currently is at two percent even before any more hikes because if you factor in the cross currency basis swap, it is two percent, which is actually huge if you look at the. Volatilities, ever since the pegging of Swiss franc, the volatility on dollar Swiss was pretty contained. So 2% is really meaningful.

And if you look at 10-year forwards, what I always like to tell people, look at 10-year forwards on euro. That is pricing current US yield curve. 10-year forward on euro is currently around 1.35, which is pretty high relative to what I think is the equilibrium value of 1.20.

So So in this policy divergence situation is still supportive for dollar.

So we don't necessarily need to have much more hiking for dollar doing well, at least on total return basis. However, if we do hike more, I think at any point when hiking comes in, especially if it comes in faster than currently projected by the market, I think we can reasonably expect dollar to rally.

So we have a Dollar will rally definitely if we do have hiking cycle. Dollar may or may not rally when we don't have hiking cycle. So we have long dollar as a dominant trade. And correspondingly, long US bonds, long-dated bonds is another dominant trade because it will perform well if we don't have any hikes because you'll just keep earning carry. If you do have hikes, the yield curve will flatten and dollar will rally and it will support the long end.

So that is my broad picture. So I'm not thinking of dollars just— I'm not trying to project exact hiking cycle right now. I think the dollar is a dominant trade, but it actually does not mean the dollar will make money. I just think it's the right trade to have on in the long run.

Historical Fed hiking cycles end in an ease

Erik Townsend: I want to get back to your long view on Treasury bonds, but before we go there, you said you had more to say on the hiking cycle, and I'm particularly interested in that.

Alex Gurevich: Yes. So one interesting observation about the hiking cycle over the fairly long period of time now, that once we have a hiking cycle interrupted, virtually every time the next move is an ease. So we can look at several decades of data, and I've actually looked pretty carefully at this data and marked out all the surprise eases, all the hiking cycles, all the periods between easing and hiking. And I think other people have done those studies even in more detail.

Yeah. What is interesting is that it's very rare for the Fed to have a hiking cycle, pause, and then next move is a hike. Typically, you pause and next move is an ease. Moreover, an ease comes much faster than people expect after the last hike, typically within nine months.

So historically, right now, we're kind of due for an ease rather than for a hike. People don't have to. Happen exactly on historical patterns.

But my intuition behind that is because of the lagging effect of Fed policy, whenever you see Fed hiked enough to be able to pause, they really already have done enough to roll the cycle over. It is just lagging. And those rollovers typically happen much faster than people expect.

So based on historical pattern and what I point out in my book, that historical pattern is a good way to gauge gauge things which are just more likely to happen. Things don't have to repeat, but if something has happened every time over the last 30 years, it's likely to happen again. So historical pattern tells me that the hiking cycle is more likely over than not, and the next move is more likely to be an ease of a kind. However, that does not contradict the possibility that next move is a hike, because besides historical pattern, there are other factors like clearly the Fed wants to hike.

So I think we should be prepared for either, but do not blind ourselves to the possibility that the curve might already roll over and next move can be an ease.

Cheap Treasuries and the long-bond trade

Erik Townsend: Thank you. Let's move on to that long bond trade because, you know, I have predicted for some time that we would eventually see 1% yields on the 10-year, and a lot of other people have thought the same thing. I've also been telling myself for more than a month now that if we saw a dip in bond prices and a rise back up to 1.7%, 1.70 on the 10-year yield, that I would buy it because I've regretted not being in that trade. You know, I chickened out last week, and the reason was just because so many big names have come out recently. Jeff Gundlach declaring that the 35-year bond rally is over, that the bottom is in for yields, that it's all uphill from here. Ray Dalio saying the credit cycle is over.

Goldman Sachs had a note out last week, and I got intimidated. I chickened out, and I'm starting to regret it. What do you think? It sounds like you still are committed to the long trade in Treasury

Alex Gurevich: Yes, I'm committed. And in fact, I was increasing it, especially the best point I got was on the night after BOJ when there was a dip. So I was definitely increasing my position into FOMC meeting, but I was only increasing it to the size which I would consider core.

I was running below core since the July rally when I took some profits. And the reason is So basically, I disregard what anyone says. To me, that just carries no information, what the big names are saying, because whatever they are saying, there is like positives and negatives to that. Okay, so some huge bond manager says that they're now short, well great, and that means that they'll have to buy at some point.

None of them have the logic of concurrent necessity, so none of them have done as well on the bonds as I have. Because they do not have the tools of concurrent necessity that I do. Their logic could be totally fine in the short run, and no, anybody who went short in July, and which even Gundlach was talking about, is he had the right timing, I think. So he's a good trader. I'm not going to argue with that. If somebody got short in July and covered now, or maybe they're still running short, who knows, I'm not going to say it's not a good trade.

But over the long run, I think the logic is still working.

The logic that I've outlined to you is still working. One of the things I pointed out yesterday is that if the Fed is even going to continue hiking cycle but hike once a year as it's currently doing, 10-year notes are still cheap. That is, if you hold and fund 10-year notes and, and the Fed will make one hike a year for the next 10 years, you still make money or break even on 10-year notes. That's how cheap I think Treasury market is.

I think Treasury bonds are enormously, egregiously cheap because they are very cheap relative to any of their counterparts in developed markets based on historical basis, and they're very cheap to swaps. And I think this is a separate subject, but I think we need to distinguish between talking about U.S. interest rates and U.S. Treasury bonds.

Because U.S. interest rates is defined by the swap market, but interest rates is defined by U.S. Treasury bonds, and Treasury bonds, which could be either explained technically or by explaining that Treasury bonds have started to price credit risk. And we can go into this in more detail too.

Erik Townsend: Before we get away from the long bond trade, I wanted to ask you a question because I've often thought about, you know, I really believe that we are headed still to lower yields, but I also have to kind of think, boy, you know, We're 35 years into this bull market in bonds. You know, it can't go that much further. Do you think there's a pairs trade or a hedge, maybe say short German bunds or something that's already negative yielding, that would make that trade safer? Or do you think it's, it's best just as a naked long?

Alex Gurevich: So in general, I do not hedge just for the sake of hedging. I only do— when I do what could be sort of pairs trades, I only do those if I I like each leg as an individual trade. And then if they're negatively correlated, all the better. In the case of bonds, I don't really think they're going anywhere. And I think any trade there would be purely tactical. And I typically don't engage in tactical trading.

I think in terms of, is it the end of the 35-year bull market? I don't know. At some point, the end of all— the end of everything comes. I see no sign of it and no particular indication of it. And there is a lot of things which typically happen at the end of secular trends which does not happen. Like, there is no euphoria, no bullishness, no parabolic rally. Everything is more or less on the same trade channel it has been for the last 35 years. So to me, there is no sign of imminent doom. Yet there are, of course, things you can think about and risks you can think about.

And in some sense, pairing Pairing with long dollar could be a good trade, and that's a good hedge against very hawkish policy. But it's not a hedge— pairing long bonds with long dollar does not hedge against more like a fiat weakness and steepening. Like, if there is some kind of like a global fiat weakness and people just start losing faith in paper money and yield curves are steepening a lot, Right. So that's more of like a risk of actually easy policy, in which case dollar may be weak or not stronger than other currencies, and yield— the end of the yield curve could flop out.

This is a real risk. I think a very good hedge against it is gold, because I think this is a scenario in which gold should perform well. If there is any kind of weakness of fiat currency and concern over central banks losing control over paper money, then I would think gold would rally a lot.

Gold, Nikkei and a long-everything portfolio

Erik Townsend: I agree with you completely. Let's go ahead and stay on the gold topic since you brought it up. A trade that Raoul Pal and I talked about last week, which I find particularly fascinating, is that pairs trade which is long gold and long dollar index at the same time, which, as you say, aren't usually negatively correlated. Raoul and I both see a good argument for both and love that trade. I spent a lot of time pondering what could go wrong that could cause both gold and the dollar index to both sell off at the same time over a sustained period, and I just can't come up with a scenario. Have you thought about this trade, and what do you think? Am I missing anything?

Alex Gurevich: Well, first of all, things sometimes move for technical correlations, break down for technical reasoning and reasoning of market positioning. What I really like about gold trade is that given location, I think upside is bigger than downside. If you just like don't even know what's going on in the world, gold is, say, $1,300. Yes, it can go to $600, $700, but it also can go to $3,000 or $4,000 over the next decade, and I think this risk-reward is good. And gold is clearly— has been clearly negatively correlated with the rest of my portfolio, the rest of it being— so my portfolio— so you're talking about portfolio just long dollar and long gold. My portfolio is long bonds, long stocks, long dollar, and long gold.

So I'm long everything, to the chagrin of many people who want to be short stocks, I know.

Erik Townsend: Why don't we pick up on that? There's obviously a growing chorus of very famous people, whether it be Carl Icahn or Stan Druckenmiller or George Soros, all basically calling for gloom and doom, the stock market's going to crash, but the tape just keeps marching higher. What do you think about all of this bearishness? Is it, uh, is there anything to it, or is it just setting us up for a lot of short-covering rally, a short squeeze, when it's proven wrong?

Alex Gurevich: Well, I don't really, I don't claim to really fully understand the technical positioning of the stock market, who is short and who is long. I'm not, I do not think that U.S. stock market necessarily is the best place to be.

My favorite stock market right now is Japan, and I've been long Nikkei. And this trade on a relative basis has been performing tremendously over the last few months if you look at relative to the performance of dollar-yen. So we had a 20% strengthening— or maybe this year it was not from the very top, but maybe like 15% strengthening of yen.

And meanwhile, it was accompanied, if you start from February, with very strong actually positive performance of Nikkei, which makes Nikkei unbelievably robust. Imagine what will happen If BOJ actually gets traction and yen will weaken, I think the upside of Nikkei is tremendous.

And it is interesting that I, I hear all about what people are saying about overall stock markets being overvalued and falling earnings and all this, but my strategic principles keep staying positive for the stock market. So my sort of necessity still dictates to be long rather than short, or at least neutral.

So I'm actually not in my personal portfolio. I don't have a lot of weight on U.S. stock market. I have some, but my in my liquid trading portfolio, I'm only long Nikkei. But I'm still biased that way because the parameters that I see are still positive for stock market.

But I but having said that, I do not look even at P/E valuations. That's not my Part of my strategy.

Dollar-yen outlook

Erik Townsend: While we're on Japan, let's also cover the dollar-yen cross. What's your outlook there?

Alex Gurevich: I think dollar-yen cross— first of all, dollar-yen was one of the best historical trades being longed from 2010 to 2015. It was one of my most successful trades. I have run this trade for several years. I've taken majority of profits on it. And then it started to go— on the residual, it started to go against me. And as it got now to these levels, I'm building again a long dollar-yen trade. I actually think that dollar-yen is a decent long here.

The carry, once again, as I will mention, is very good. We seem to have found some line in the sand somewhere around 100. So the basing is beginning. Can it break down and go a few more percent down? Yes. Can it go to 70? I don't think so. I don't think dollar-yen is again going to 70. Now, you ask a lot of macro thinkers Including Gundlach, who— and he said, like, well, eventually it'll go to 200.

So people actually— a lot of people, when they see the really long horizon on dollar-yen, they see it much higher. And so do I, because I think this continues— because when people think, like, about— on a given meeting, they think, like, oh, BOJ didn't do enough, they didn't shock us enough.

But actually, they are very easy. They keep expanding their monetary base. And And I'm a big believer that if you keep printing something, eventually it'll get cheaper. If you keep making more and more of something, eventually it has to get cheaper. So I think eventually yen, one way or another, will get cheaper.

But there is a lot of technicals and a lot of technical positioning and flow stuff that will happen in between. So in the long run, I think dollar-yen is a very good long here.

China private debt, RMB and no signposts

Erik Townsend: While we're in Asia, let's move over to China in terms of both outlook for economic growth, the general economic situation, situation in China equity market. And of course, the RMB devaluation is a big question. Some macro thinkers are saying it's just getting started. Other people think it's overextended already. So China in general, what's, what's your take?

Alex Gurevich: So China, again, this is a very interesting part of the world right now. Obviously, I don't need to say that. It's a huge economy and a lot of interesting things are going there. There is a lot of uncertainty about China outlook. That is, as you There are total doomsayers about China that are total bulls.

The only kind of people that I don't understand are people who are totally sanguine on China. Like, I don't see the sanguinity. And this is why.

When there is uncertainty about government data, uncertainty about statistics, uncertainty about situation, I try to stick to facts which are certain. Like something which you can see for sure. What I can see for sure is the amount of private debt in China which is approaching $30 trillion. Which is the largest private debt of any country ever, including the United States. It's probably the largest, one of the largest relative to GDP private debts. It is also the largest pace of growth of debt, both on the absolute and the relative terms. So we have 4 records for China: absolute total size, relative total size, absolute growth, and relative growth for private debt.

There has been no historical precedent of such a growth in debt not ending in some kind of catastrophic unwind.

Furthermore, people can say that China is different. Well, let's look at the history of China. China has several thousand years of history of imperial rise and very bad collapse. So every time China was— began to sort of imperial power in the world, as if it has found a way to self-destruct.

And I could give you more historic several historical examples, but there are China history scholars who should probably do better than I would. But so we have two historical patterns going in our favor in the favor of serious risks to China: the historical pattern of debt unwind and historical pattern of China specifically to self-destruct.

What we have to remember that those cycles are very long, especially in China. So timing such a cycle is extremely difficult. When people talk about It has to happen next year or next 2 years. And some people have been calling for it since like '08, '09 for this China unwind. And now they're almost 10 years in the hole. That is actually not a long period. When I talk about those imperial China cycles, those like century-long cycles, those are dynasties we are talking about, not just single even reigns.

So how soon, how long China can last on how— like, I believe that the probability is very high of at some point catastrophic unwind. But I cannot put any time on it.

Now when it comes to specific trades, so I have to go from this cautious view to specific trades. I do think RMB is a really good trade and it has proven to be a really good trade. Why is it proving to be such a good trade is because, well, if you just simply long dollar RMB, if you're not buying out-of-the-money options as some people do, if you're not staking your money on specific timing or specific magnitude RMB has been in steady devaluation trend relative to its trading counterpart, relative to the basket.

It may look like it's not going down very fast against the dollar, but it's because dollar has been fairly weak over the last year. So if you compare performance of dollar index with performance of dollar-RMB, dollar-RMB is performing much better. Yes, you have to beat some carry, and carry varies. Sometimes it's— the forwards have been very volatile.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Alex Gurevich: And if you got— if you grabbed the highest forwards, which were at the beginning of this year, and locked yourself into 4% of negative carry for a year, you had a lot of carry to beat, and you probably wouldn't make any money up to this point.

But then again, you could have been long dollar-yen, and you could have lost 15%. So to put things in perspective, it is very important not just to think whether a trade makes or loses money, or how it may— or how it performs relative to other trades expressing the same view. That's why I mentioned Nikkei. Yeah. Being a great trade. That's why dollar RMB has proved to be a really good trade. I think the trend is there. I think deval can go much further, can go much further. I think the typical way to deal with that cycle unwind is devaluation. So, and the capital flows pressure is still outward. So I think the odds are skewed in that favor. I think what's going to happen is that if you're wrong, If you're wrong and RMB will get stuck at the current levels, you'll lose whatever carry you lose. You'll lose 2 or 3%. If you're right, they might devalue a little faster than forward projected, and you can make 3 or 4%.

So a trade which looks almost symmetric, but you also have that whole upside of a windfall of catastrophic devaluation. So if you are in just simple vanilla forwards trade, you probably can lose a little or make a little, or you can make a lot. I see a very low probability of losing a lot.

That's what, what, that's what makes this trade, in my opinion, of a very good characteristic.

Erik Townsend: I couldn't possibly agree more with you on 2 points that you made. Number one, that the credit growth in China is just unprecedented and that it has to eventually lead to a catastrophic unwind. But also, number two, that there's no reason to think that that unwind is imminent starting tomorrow, is a mistake that so many people have My follow-on question is, okay, if we both agree it's not imminent, what are the signposts that you're looking for? What would tell you that that catastrophic unwind is beginning or is imminently about to begin?

Alex Gurevich: You know, to be honest, I think we will not see any signposts. If you can see them, that they're not there. I think it will catch everybody by surprise. It will be something that we cannot predict, cannot foresee. Things will play out in a way we cannot expect. Anything that we can expect will be controlled.

Because China has a very organized central government which tries to control everything. So anything that could be observable, they will take care of and they will control.

So it has to happen in a way that nobody can predict. If you remember, like the global financial crisis, how did it start? It started with sudden seizure of financial assets in August 2007. Retrospectively, you could see that as a clear signpost of what happened afterwards, but nobody could predict that what happened in August 2007. Nobody would predict that LIBOR would go up instead of down in an easing environment, that the spreads between LIBOR and funds would blow out the way they have since early '70s.

All the stuff that happened was hard to predict.

Now, for example, look at dollar-yen. Earlier I said that I was on a trade for 5 years. What would have been— dollar-yen seemed to be stuck like at 80 and even 70, up higher 70s and even down to 75. Nothing seemed to have been able to move it. What was the catalyst was the fall of DPJ, and nobody could have predicted. Nobody could have predicted, or at least I couldn't have predicted the sudden dramatic change of political scene in Japan, which happened in 2012. By the time that happens, you have to really have your sleeves rolled up and just run with the trend. And it's better if you already had the trade on.

For me, like, I had the trade on already and I increased it as it started running in my favor. But if I was not ready for it at all, you could have missed the whole move.

So the same thing, I think, with China. It is going to be— the mechanism is going to be something that we don't see see something unpredictable if it were to happen, and there will be no clear signs that we will see that in advance.

Brexit, European politics and the euro

Erik Townsend: Okay, fantastic. Let's go around the world now to Europe. We've had so many different views on this program. Grant Williams told us that he thought Brexit would be remembered eventually as the first step in what would eventually be the complete demise of the European Union. We've had other guests tell us that Brexit was just a flash in the pan, it's a— it's over with, it didn't really matter because the U.K. was never in the euro to start with. So what do you think? Is European exit contagion a serious risk? And based on that answer, what do you think it means in terms of euro/USD?

Alex Gurevich: I think European exit— Brexit is a serious risk. I was probably in the minority of people. I kind of had the unpopular opinion that Brexit was the right thing to do. I was— I thought that for U.K. U.K., it was the right thing to leave the European Union because I'm probably more pessimistic on European Union than other market players.

I'm not— I was not actually a huge pessimist in the European economy or even in European stock market, but I think the migrant problem and political problems in Europe just made me more pessimistic on the situation there. I think politics— this is a whole separate subject— but developed world politics are becoming to be much more of a risk than they It used to be that you pretty much can ignore elections in countries and referendums and all this stuff. That was all just noise.

I mean, the most important referendum was for Sweden whether to join Euro, I think maybe like 10 or 12 years ago, and who cares, right? But nowadays we're actually having like real referendums. Like Scotland is having a real referendum. Like then all of a sudden Brexit is happening and European politics is getting dicey, especially with migrant problem.

Right. Problem. And I think there are some serious problems happening there because we have declining population in core of Europe and meanwhile strong inflow, very different culture. And it's very different from regular US immigration. I don't have to tell you that. This is a major migration. So major migrations are typically highly destabilizing for the countries which are receiving the inflows of So I'm not like one to call absolute doom and gloom on this, but I think there are very serious risks and there are some maybe other countries not wanting to be there.

Now, how will it— how will potential splintering of Europe affect euro? It's actually hard to tell because it's kind of paradoxical. Imagine that every country leaves Europe and euro will be just Deutsche Mark. Then actually it has to get stronger because Deutsche Mark actually would be stronger if we would just use Germany as a currency benchmark.

benchmark, it will be stronger against dollar than it is now. Because for Germany, euro is actually too weak. Germany has a huge surplus, trade surplus, current account surplus. So it's very hard to play out the politics in my head, but the destabilization, I think, still probably net negative.

But to me, I don't even have to see necessity for destabilization to be short euro. Okay. Euro on this concurrent necessity basis, because if U.S. were to proceed with the same yield curve as it currently priced, and Euro is to proceed with the yield curve that is currently priced, then Euro is about to head to seriously negative real interest rates. If you just look at the central bank's projections, ECB is projecting 1.5-2% inflation in the next 2-3 years, and they're still projecting zero to negative interest rates. So we're going to be heading to negative 2% inflation— sorry, negative 2% real interest rates in Europe, while in U.S., again according to curve projections, we're going to be pulling to much more benign negative real interest rates and possibly at some point to zero interest rates if Fed were to proceed hiking. However, if they are not, I'm still making money on the bonds.

Don't forget that. So I think as a combination, short euro is still Still a high-expectation trade, but not necessarily short European stock markets because that's a harder thing to predict.

Clinton or Trump: Treasuries and swap spreads

Erik Townsend: Okay. Let's come back to the United States and particularly the election. Something I've been thinking a lot about lately is, boy, the leading candidates are just so opposite in their policies. Donald Trump has been so outspoken in criticizing the Fed, and it seems clear that he would likely put pressure on the Fed to stop trying to support asset markets with quantitative easing. Hillary would probably have a very very different policy view. What do you see in general, whether it be on that issue or other issues, in terms of the effects on global financial markets of either a Clinton or a Trump presidency?

Alex Gurevich: Well, I don't know if I can say something particularly intelligent about the effects of Clinton presidency. I think everybody, pretty much everybody, thinks of Clinton presidency as business as usual on the general scheme. Like, you kind of just go back to your to your macro textbook. Because that's what I typically do. Typically, I ignore political and geopolitical risk. I ignore elections in any country. I just look at my principles, my strategic principles, and choose trades according to them. And elections come and go, and things typically still work out according to the basic logical principles of the world. And I think working with Clinton is basically just going back to the drawboard.

For example, remember when Obama became president, we had a huge sell-off actually for the next few months. And then a huge rally began. So how would you even say, was it bad for the markets or good for the markets? Obama presidency, how would you interpret it? I think it's very— such things are very hard to interpret. For example, you could have Clinton presidency could cause relief rally in stock markets or some kind of disappointment sell-off that nothing has changed.

You can have relief rally in the bond markets However, Trump presidency, as you said, is a very interesting thing. I actually don't quite understand his rhetoric on the Fed and what he's going to do with it on that. It doesn't seem very consistent to me.

And by the way, I just want to point out, I'm not being partisan, and I don't think no candidates that I've seen ever made any sense on economics. So in terms of the logical, logical consistency. Of what people are saying or actually macroeconomic meaningfulness of what they're saying. I've never seen any candidate for presidential candidate during my time of living in this country make any sense whatsoever. So theoretically, everything they said could be just replaced by blah, blah, blah, blah, whatever sounds good for the electorate.

So that's first premises.

However, when they say something really outlying, we have to pay attention. And that's what makes it interesting with Trump, that he says things that actually make— you cannot just ignore the complete nonsense noise. He wants to increase infrastructure spending, which potentially could be heavy for the long end because it increases debt.

He's also mentioned at some point the fact that he would be even open to work out on US Treasuries and not paying 100% on them in case we're overburdened with debt, while in practice it seems very unlikely that it would create some sort of fear factor. I think it's very hard to tell what specific presidency will do in the long run, but I think you cannot disregard the fear factor associated with this election.

And honestly, what I've noticed is that as Trump odds surged over the last few weeks, we had this push down on US Treasury bonds.

And what is specifically interesting to look at is, again, not just at the absolute levels, but at the swap spreads. The civilian Inverted swap spreads—the fact that longer-dated treasuries are trading at LIBOR plus 50, and even medium-term like six-seven-year treasuries may trade at something like LIBOR plus 10, LIBOR plus 15—that's really unprecedented.

It can be explained technically by the lack of balance sheet created by Dodd-Frank and other regulations, and that is part of it. But that could be discussed in more detail how much that is an effect and where the asset managers. Could neutralize this effect by putting more assets, more bonds into their portfolio. It seems just people don't have the tools to neutralize this effect of reduced balance sheets. So that's probably technical, but I'm beginning to worry that market is pricing real credit risk in US Treasuries.

And once you start pricing real credit risk in bonds, it's very hard to call for the exact downside. That will not, I think, derail the long-term bull trend because if we do have a major sell-off in long bonds due to credit fears, most likely what it does, it creates just artificial tightening of economic conditions and actually rates end up lower in the long run.

And assuming that US will not default actually, which I think it won't, you probably in the long run still make money on bonds, but there are some serious volatility. volatility risks associated with that. And what I think might happen— may happen is— so my one prediction is that if Clinton wins, the swap spread situation might start rectifying and swap spreads might start moving to the right. That is, Treasury yields will stop being so high relative to swap rate yields.

The Next Perfect Trade and HonTe Investments

Erik Townsend: Okay. Well, I would love to continue this conversation, Alex, on a number of topics for another hour, but unfortunately we are out Before we close, your book, The Next Perfect Trade, could you tell our listeners what that's about and where they can find it?

Alex Gurevich: So The Next Perfect Trade can be found on Amazon, and it's, it's my book on selecting trades. Basically, it's my strategic principle of selecting what I call superior trades, that is trades that work in the broadest range of economic scenarios. What I like to say is that I don't focus on forces that drive markets rather than forces that drive successful trades.

So that's what the book is about.

Erik Townsend: Now, I, I know you also run HonTe Investments, which is a commodity trading advisor. As a fellow CTA and CPO, I'm very familiar with the obligations that you're under, so I know that you're not at liberty to discuss the services that your commodity trading advisor offers except to accredited investors, but we do have a large accredited So could you please tell our accredited audience where they could find out more information about your CTA offerings?

Alex Gurevich: Yeah, you can look us up on our website, www.honteinv.com, which is short for HonTe Investments. And you can also follow me on Twitter as my first initial and last name, @agurevich23. That's my handle, and this Twitter profile will give you a link to my book and to my fund.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. Well, we cannot thank you enough for a really great interview, Alex. Aaron Chan and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program.

Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan.

Postgame: will the Fed signal the end of hiking?

Aaron Chan: Well, fascinating interview, Erik, and it was definitely interesting Alex's varying opinions. I want to start by touching on Alex's views on the hiking cycle. Now, you mentioned, and I completely agree, that the Fed has boxed itself into a corner essentially, and raising rates just isn't in the cards no matter what they're saying. So are we at a point where we need to roll over from the rate hiking cycle or expectation, or are you waiting for something specific to signal this rollover?

Erik Townsend: Well, it's a very interesting question to contemplate because you're trying to read the minds of essentially politicians, which is what I consider central bankers to be for the most part. And it's always a very difficult proposition. But the way I think about this is let's assume that the next policy change is actually going to be a cut at some point, not a hike. And let's assume that they know that, that they've figured out that they're not going to get away with any more hikes.

Does that mean that they are going to be preemptive and proactive and say, hmm, we can't shock the market after we've been telling them that a hike is coming and just cut out of, out of the blue. So what we need to do is get a message out, whether they want to leak that through The Wall Street Journal, through, you know, John Hilsenrath writing an article or something saying the next policy decision could be in either direction.

Are they going to give some hint that the hiking cycle is over, or are they going to go back to language about being data dependent and stop saying that they're in a hiking cycle? Or are they just going to wait until conditions warrant cut and hope that the market figures it out without proactively setting expectations that the next move could be in either direction.

From what I've seen out of Janet, I think they're more likely to try to give some indication that it could go either way so that people are not completely shocked if the next move is a cut. Would they do that in, in the next press conference? Would they do it through The Wall Street Journal, through a Hilsenrath article? I don't know. It's total guesswork. So I think we've just got to, you know, keep our ears glued to the wire and see what comes next.

Postgame: billionaire bears and short-squeeze risk

Aaron Chan: Right. And on the topic of the billionaire bears that have come out with negative prognostications for bonds and the stock market, you know, it was actually really refreshing to hear Alex pay essentially no regard to what he calls the noise coming from these experts and instead focus on his own strategy. But as these billionaires have trotted out their bearish calls, and now that we've had a couple of guests broach this topic and broach this question, Erik, where is your present thinking on these proclamations?

Erik Townsend: You know, it's interesting. I have a lot of respect for Alex's philosophy about not listening to anybody, trusting his own judgment, and, you know, not being influenced by other people's views. So doing your own homework and deciding what you think yourself about fundamentals rather than listening to people that are talking their own books, I really respect that.

The place I have to disagree, and this is something that I've really learned in the last few years, is even so, the market internals are really important. And when there are people that have as much money as these billionaire bears all talking up this story, that means they are levered way up to the short side. And that means if they're proven wrong, there is going to be a short-covering rally or short squeeze extraordinaire. So I do take that seriously. And I think without a doubt, if I was not concerned about about the uncertainty that the election brings into this, I think I'd be going short here because emotionally, for sure, I want to be on the same side of the trade as Stan Druckenmiller and George Soros and Carl Icahn and all of these guys that have just phenomenal track records.

They're often early, but they're almost always proven right in the end when they have this much conviction. The thing is, with, with this much short interest in the market. If those guys get proven wrong and all have to cover their hedges and cover their speculative shorts, there could be a real big short squeeze. And I think that, you know, it usually takes a pretty good catalyst to bring on a short squeeze like that. What could be more ripe than an election surprise to bring on that short squeeze? If all of a sudden Trump really screws himself and it becomes clear that Hillary is a shoo-in, I think that could easily trigger that short squeeze, and I don't want to get caught on the wrong side of it. So as I said earlier, if I was going to play this equity market, it would be out-of-the-money puts on the S&P in a small size.

Postgame: China unwind, inevitable is not imminent

Aaron Chan: So on China, Erik, it was a fascinating discussion you had with Alex, and we all know the individual investors from the likes of Mark Hart and Kyle Bass who've been predicting the eventual $30 trillion credit unwind and what that'll do to their RMB. However, do you agree with Alex that this Sometimes one is going to come from left field. I mean, it seems to me that similar to what Raoul was saying about the business cycle, more and more debt fertilizes the soil for something bad happening. So even though we don't know what to wait for, even where to look, would you say that the likelihood is increasing?

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm in very strong agreement with Alex on part of what he said, but I differ respectfully on other parts of it. If there's anything that I've learned about this investing game, on one hand, it's absolutely true that what caused 2008 to happen was There's too much debt. And when you see something that is unsustainable and cannot go on forever, it means it will not go on forever. So, I couldn't possibly agree more with his statement that this eventual cataclysmic unwind of the massive, massive credit expansion that's happened in China, it is inevitable, absolutely 100% guaranteed.

But right behind that, the next most important lesson that I've learned is the worst mistake you can make is to think that because it's inevitable, that that means that it's imminent. It's not imminent. And I think Alex said that as well.

Go back to 2009. If you looked at what happened, what took down the whole mortgage market, there was too much debt that was undercollateralized, and it all came collapsing down at once. You could have very persuasively made the argument then, hey, mortgage-backed securities were just the first salvo, and that means that Treasuries are coming next, and it's time to go short short the 30-year long bond because for sure we know that long-term this United States debt situation is unsustainable. Well, on the one hand, I think that the logic there is actually correct in that it's not sustainable, and sometime in our lifetimes the, the U.S. Treasury debt is going to have a horrific collapse. But guess what? If you had made that decision back in 2009 and gone short long-dated Treasuries, you would have been absolutely annihilated since then. So the fact that you know for sure that it's coming someday does not mean it's time to put the trade on today.

That much of what Alex said I agree with emphatically, violently, couldn't possibly agree more.

The part where he said the Chinese government can control all of this, I think you have to qualify that. The Chinese government can control a certain category of risks and will control it, and for that And so, for that reason, this coming totally out of left field is much more likely. But there's a whole category of risks that are foreseeable, say, pertaining to a war breaking out between China and another country that puts the entire country's national security at risk. You could see that coming, and that would be an example of something the Chinese government wouldn't have the ability to simply control. So, I think that there are categories of risk that fall into what he said. There are other categories that don't.

But I agree very strongly with him. This credit expansion The inflation in China is crazy by any measure. It's going to come undone someday. And the question that I asked him, and I think his answer was correct, you know, how do you know when it's almost here? You don't. You see it when it starts to break apart. And hopefully you've done your homework and you've thought carefully about how you want to trade it. So when you wake up one day and say, oh my God, it's happening and it's now, you know what to do.

Postgame: European disintegration and the euro

Aaron Chan: Right. Well, jumping from one collapse to another, European disintegration is something that I've been thinking about a lot recently, and 2017 seems poised to be a spicy political year, given the French and German elections, just to name a few. Now, as I play out the disintegration in my mind, and if we're left with Germany, but also a whole bunch of euro-denominated debt that'll probably need to be written down in one form or another. So given the strong credit that is the German sovereign and the amount of outstanding euro debt, debt. Do you agree with Alex that the German-backed euro, or effectively the mark, will be stronger or weaker?

Erik Townsend: Well, Alex was describing one very specific scenario as to how a disintegration of the European Union might come about, where Germany effectively is the last man standing. And that would perhaps, as Alex suggested, surprise everybody, because if the euro essentially becomes the Deutsche mark, there's an argument that it The thing is, that was just one scenario. Consider this: what if Germany were the first country, even before the U.K. finalizes its decision, to leave the euro because Angela Merkel commits political suicide, which she seems to be doing a pretty good job of at the moment, and there is some radical regime change in Germany and a change of political sentiment, and suddenly the Germans are the first ones to bail?

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: on the euro. That would, you know, completely change the scenario that Alex described. So, I don't think that it's fair to say Alex predicted that outcome. He gave that outcome as an example of something that could happen that would result in a completely different strong euro rather than weak euro outcome.

In general, my view is I think that Brexit was probably just the beginning. But just as we talked about for the Chinese credit unwind. It doesn't mean anything is imminent. We could easily go 10 more years before the next, you know, big thing happens in Europe, or the whole shebang could be over by the end of 2018. I don't know. These things tend to happen very slowly and then accelerate very rapidly and happen all at once when they hit a certain tipping point. It seems like so far post-Brexit, the— we haven't hit any tipping points. There may be more things coming, but they're not coming

Aaron Chan: Well, Erik, what is imminent is us running out of time for the show, unfortunately. So, anything else before we wrap?

Closing: ZeroHedge thanks and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Well, I want to thank Tyler Durden again at ZeroHedge They covered Raoul's interview last week, and that resulted in a whole bunch of traffic. It's helping us to grow the show. And folks, remember, the more that we can popularize MacroVoices, get more name recognition, the more that helps Aaron to recruit the very best guests to come on the program. And as you've seen in recent weeks, we're starting to really up the ante and get some fantastic guests on the program. So please help us out. Help us promote the show. Tell your friends, tell your colleagues, and most importantly, please register your free account at MacroVoices.com.

When you do so, you get our free Research Roundup email. Never includes spam or marketing. It's basically a compendium of links to supporting information for our feature interviews, as well as the best free research that we could find on the internet every single week. If you don't want it, it takes one click on the safe unsubscribe link in order to turn it back off. Again, registering helps us to increase our number of listeners and recruit the very best guests that we can. For those of you getting the Research Roundup, Aaron what can they expect in this week's email?

Aaron Chan: So in addition to the great documents provided by Alex from HonTe Investments this week, I'd like to start by highlighting Nassim Taleb's Medium post entitled, quote, The Intellectual Yet Idiot. Now, given the rise of populism, it's encouraging to read that not all elites are penning articles about the ignorant masses, but are demonstrating some self-awareness about a trend that really has no signs of abating. Now, for what I call the tyranny of the experts, this phenomenon will come under greater pressure as the Fed-tainted economic pie continues to shrink and the populace awakens to their economic fleecing. Now, additionally, we've got a response to Ken Rogoff's War on Cash from Peter Vikmeyer of Sprott Money, and a long-form report and gold projection from the research team at Goldmoney.

Finally, we've got 2 great submissions from our subscribers. Joshua Hall of Truevine Investments returns with his outlook for silver prices, and Aidan Gharib of Pavilion Capital Markets has a research note on the gold-dollar pairs trade. You'll find all this and much more in this week's Research Roundup.

So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we've gotten and continue to welcome your suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For our listeners who write or blog about global markets and would like to share that content with our pro finance community, shoot us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag and we'll include it in our weekly distribution.

If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for the latest updates and interview releases. You can also follow Erik @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. For Erik Townsend, I'm Aaron Chan. Chat with you next week.

Announcer closing and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at www.MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly newsletter. Weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week, which never includes advertising or marketing.

You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we're able to recruit high feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can also subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.

MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Raoul Pal — founder of Global Macro International and Real Vision Television (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Hello, everyone. MacroVoices episode 31 was recorded on September 15th, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. We're bringing back one of our most popular guests ever this week. Raoul Pal is the founder of Global Macro International and Real Vision Television, and an extremely well-respected macro analyst. Regular listeners know that Raoul always gives a great interview, but he really knocked it out of the park this week. We'll be discussing the U.S. dollar, Treasury yields, precious metals, the business cycle, European exit contagion, systemic risk in the European banking system, sovereign credit risk, soft commodities, and much more. You're not going to want to miss this one, folks.

Market wrap: equity volatility and Fed rate-hike doubts

Aaron Chan: And I'm Aaron Chan. Last week, the S&P 500 had managed to go 2 whole weeks without breaking out to yet another new all-time high. But Erik, you were quick to observe that when we taped the show last Thursday afternoon, we were still within 10 points of the all-time high. And boy, did that change in a hurry. The market took a nosedive starting right after we taped last week's show in Thursday night's overnight futures session and continued all day Friday and into the Sunday futures session, eventually testing 2,100 even, fully 80 points lower than where the index stood when we taped last week's show. But then on Monday, it retraced more than half of the move, testing 2,150 before rolling over again to the downside, again trading below 2,110 earlier this week. But as we're taping today's show, E-mini S&P futures have rebounded and are trading at 2,140 with a few minutes left in Thursday's trading session.

Erik, what's going on with the sudden volatility in equities here?

Erik Townsend: Well, you said it, sudden volatility, and I think it's a lot of data scares. You know, the real question is, will she or won't she? Are we going to see a rate hike? The expectations have been up, down, backwards, and forwards, and I think nobody really knows what's going on. My take is I think the Fed has reached a point where they've realized that they probably can't hike rates, but it's such a loss of credibility to admit that their hiking cycle was It's gonna be a cycle of only one hike. So, we'll see what happens. But, you know, I think back to, you know, in August when everything was hunky-dory and we were breaking out to new highs every week. I made a comment which was that a lot of people think that market crashes tend to happen in October. And if you look at the actual historical data, really the way it tends to play out is the high happens sometime in August, the top happens in August, then you get crazy volatility in September, and it's the final shebang that happens in October.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: And that's what everybody remembers. Well, boy, it's starting to play out that way. We saw a top in August, and if this isn't crazy volatility in September, I'm not sure what is. It doesn't mean that the market's going to crash in October, but I'm starting to get more and more concerned.

Really, I think a lot of it has to do with rate hike expectations. I'm going to definitely be asking Raoul about this in today's feature interview as well.

Market wrap: crude inventories and the oil outlook

Aaron Chan: Right. And last week, we reported an utterly massive 14.5 million barrel drawdown on nationwide crude oil And you even said that Tropical Storm Hermine shutting in production in the Gulf and delaying the arrival of tanker ships was the probable culprit. So how did we do on this week's inventory numbers, and what else is affecting the oil market this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, it was another soft inventory report. I guess I say soft in the sense that I'm looking forward to some big builds on inventory, which I think are coming. This was another half-million-barrel, actually 560,000-barrel drawdown on national inventory, 1.25 million-barrel drawdown in Cushing inventory, which is very critical. Critical in terms of what would affect the price of the WTI crude oil futures contract. Gasoline, on the other hand, and distillates, big builds, 570,000-barrel build on gasoline. It would normally be a very large build. Of course, in the face of an utterly humongous one last week, it doesn't seem so big. 4.6 million-barrel build in distillate inventories, though, was utterly massive. And production ticked up this week, breaking a 3-week downtrend. So U.S. production is increasing. Obviously, the effects of Tropical Storm Hermine are still being felt. I think a lot of people just watching the tape action, a lot of people thought that, you know, first they went crazy last week on the 14.5 million barrel draw.

Then they figured out it was weather-related and calmed down a little bit. A lot of them were expecting a massive build this week, as if just one week later, all of a sudden, the 14 million barrels was gonna come back again or something. It doesn't work that way. You know, there were producing rigs in the Gulf that were shut in in advance of the arrival of that storm. It takes a lot of time for this stuff to clear out of the system.

Our friends at #OOTT tweeted this week that they're predicting still 2 weeks out, you know, 2 more Wednesdays ahead of us, is when we're going to have the really, really big build on inventory. And that's based on their tanker tracking and the other work that they do to analyze flows of imports and movement of oil around the globe. To be honest, I haven't even gone into detail, and I can't tell you why they think it's still 2 weeks out, but we do have a link to #OOTT. You can, of course, just type in #OOTT on Twitter, or if you want to find Sam Madani's homepage where his pinned tweet has all kinds of information, there's a link to that in your Research Roundup email.

Art Berman this week had an excellent post about what he's calling a glut bomb, both IEA and EIA revising their estimates, saying that they think the oil glut is going to persist. Into 2017. It's not going to be resolved as quickly as they had previously thought. Meanwhile, Thursday morning we saw both Nigeria and Libya news coming out suggesting that there will be increased production from both of those countries. That led to a big down spike. $43.26 was the low print. That was fairly quickly retraced. It's been a real roller coaster ride today on Thursday, all the way up to about $44.35 was the intraday high, and we're back back down to a 43 handle, 43.82 as we're speaking, just a little bit before the session close on Thursday afternoon.

By the time this podcast is edited, it may have moved a dollar in either direction at the rate that things are going. In terms of the big picture here, my judgment is that the bearish factors outweigh the bullish factors. There are a lot of bullish factors, but they're short-term bullish factors, weather and so forth, and the bigger picture is more bearish. I think the market is waiting for confirmation. They want to see that big rebound in inventory to prove that it was just a one-off event when we had that really big drawdown last week. And again, the #OOTT guys think that that big, big inventory build might still be 2 weeks away. So follow them on Twitter in order to find more on that one.

Market wrap: gold's trading range and the gold-dollar hedge

Aaron Chan: Right. And Erik, at this point, I've basically lost count of how many weeks in a row that I've announced yet again That we've been watching a technical consolidation range in gold between $1,308 and $1,377. So 2 weeks ago, it looked like we were right on the hairy edge of a breakdown below that key support level at $1,308. And we even saw $1,306 briefly on the intraday basis. And then last week, the market surprised us by trading as high as $1,357. After that unexpected strength last week and Jeff Christian's bullish outlook, I thought maybe this week we'd be discussing a breakout above, say, $1,377. But instead, we actually tested $1,312 on Thursday morning, only a few dollars away above key support at $1,308 Erik, any visibility on when I am getting out of this broken record loop?

Erik Townsend: I don't know. We're still there. You know, last week, I was actually a little surprised by how bullish Jeff Christian was. I was leaning towards more of a bearish view. I was starting to get persuaded of that. And sure enough, as we're speaking now, just before the close on Thursday, $1,316 is where we're, we're looking at right now. And as you say, $1,312 was the low print this morning. So, we're back to flirting with It's the bottom of that trading range. I definitely want to talk to Raoul Pal in today's feature interview about this and get his take. I would not be tempted to buy here, even though we seem to, you know, if you listen to what Jeff Christian said, you know, look for a buying opportunity. Well, we're right at the key support level. That would seem to be a buying opportunity, and if you want to follow Jeff Christian's advice, it's time to buy here. I don't know that I would quite take that leap without hedging it, and the hedge, as I've talked about before, is a pair trade long the gold futures contract and long the dollar index at the same time.

Those are normally inversely correlated, but as Raoul and I discussed, there are some reasons why I think there's a possibility of a home run with both of them moving to the upside. Both moving to the downside at the same time, really hard for me to find a scenario where that could happen.

Market wrap: 10-year Treasury yields

Aaron Chan: Yeah, looking forward to Raoul's take on that trade. So 10-year Treasury yields jumped more than 10 bps higher this week, priced to yield about 1.71% on Thursday afternoon. So, Erik, any change on your outlook here?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it's— I don't know if there's a change in my outlook, but a little bit of a change of course of action. I was waiting for 1.70 because I thought that was going to be a resistance level in yield, a support level in price. And I thought maybe that was the time to put on the trade that I have regretted not having on earlier this year, which is a long position in 10-year Treasury futures, not because I think that they're a smart long-term investment, obviously. Loaning money to an arguably insolvent borrower for 10 years unsecured at 1.5% interest is pretty darn crazy, but it's a trade for the sake of expecting lower yields still to come.

I chickened out of that this week, and the reason is there are just so many really smart people, whether it be Jeff Gundlach, who's a very, very prominent hedge fund manager, Ray Dalio, even more prominent hedge fund manager, saying this week that the credit cycle is over. Jeff Gundlach had said that he thinks that the high in bond prices, low in bond yields is in, and that it's going to be, you know, heading higher from here in yields, 2% by the end of the year.

Goldman Sachs had a research note out this week. We've got a link to that in your Research Roundup email where they're presenting 3 arguments for why they think bonds will continue to sell off, yields will continue to move higher. I chickened out. I was going to buy the dip. I thought 1.70 would be a resistance level in yield, and we would roll over and eventually head back towards 1%.

Definitely, I want to catch up with Raoul Pal on this, because last time we spoke to Raoul, he and I both thought that we were headed for 1%, or he thought even half a percent on the 10-year yield. I'm very curious to find out whether or not Raoul still has that view and what he makes of this. But for now, until I talk to Raoul, at least, I'm chickening out of buying the dip.

Aaron Chan: Yeah.

Market wrap: the US dollar index and the Fed

Aaron Chan: All right, makes sense. And last week we were back down to a 94 handle on the dollar index, and I see it's recovered to a 95 handle this week. So what's going on with the dollar here?

Erik Townsend: 95.225 as we speak, just before Thursday's close. And yeah, you know, it's been up and down. I think as far as immediate tape action, we're kind of in a trading range, a consolidation range. I don't have anything particularly noteworthy to say about the tape this week. What I would say is it's really a question That's a good question. That's a good question for me. I have expressed a bullish view about the U.S. dollar eventually resolving to the upside, moving above 100. And I think that there is a strong argument for the U.S. dollar rally to resume in earnest. But the thing is, if I look at the short to intermediate term, you know, what do I see on the radar macro-wise? I think we're getting closer and closer to the point where the Fed throws in the towel and finally admits that the economy is not strong enough for them to continue on this rate hiking cycle that they claim to be in, although So, it's actually been longer between rate hikes than any other cycle in recorded history.

So, it's hard to even say that we're in this cycle. But they haven't admitted that they're going to give up on trying to hike rates. If they were to give up on it, that really could send the dollar lower, at least on a temporary basis. I think maybe creating a buying opportunity. Again, the dollar is something that I have tremendous respect for Raoul Pal's view on. So, I'm going to be listening very closely to his take as we get into the feature interview

Aaron Chan: Not sure if we can get this trending, Erik, but #AskRaoul. Thanks for the market update, Erik. Real Vision Television co-founder and Global Macro International founder Raoul Pal was one of our most popular interviews ever when we featured him back in April. So we're delighted to have him back with us as this week's featured interview guest. Erik's interview with Mr. Pal is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Raoul Pal: the dollar rally and the DXY

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is one of our all-time most popular guests. Raoul Pal is, of course, the founder of Real Vision Television and Global Macro International. Raoul, thanks so much for joining us again on the program. We're really delighted to have you back. I want to start with the US dollar rally. You and I both thought when we spoke back in April that the dollar was taking a pause, but likely to resume its rally in earnest. And so far, it's taking at least longer than I expected. Has your view changed at all? What do you see on the horizon for the dollar?

Raoul Pal: No, my view hasn't changed. But like you, I've noticed that it's taken longer than I expected, too. It's been kind of coiling for some period of time. There's been virtually no volatility, which was true of many asset classes until maybe last week. You know, I still think that that's— that the dollar is going to rise. We've seen some really interesting things happening in the LIBOR and Eurodollar funding markets, which It means that US interest rates have shot higher, and the interest rate differential between the US, for example, and Europe would suggest that something like the euro should go back down to parity. Obviously, it's not happening yet, but I still think the balance of probabilities lies with the fact that this is still a pause in the dollar rally, and the dollar goes much higher over time. I think as we've—I think we talked about in the past—is I think in a situation where the global economy and the US economy slows, I think. I think the dollar goes higher because US rates are still relatively high, and there's more opportunities on a relative basis there.

I think that as rates get cut around the world, which I think they will do at some point, again, the interest rate differentials mean that if Europe— if the US is bad, the rest of the world is worse, so the dollar goes higher. This funding issue means it's actually very hard to get hold of dollars outside of the US. And that's creating a problem where we could see some real pressure on people who borrowed dollars and need to pay some of those back. So I'm really still focused on the dollar. You know, I'm getting a bit bored of the trade, waiting and waiting and waiting. But I think it comes.

Erik Townsend: I agree completely with everything that you just said. But I want to ask a follow-up question because I'm almost thinking that maybe we're in for, at least temporarily, another dip in the US dollar index simply because it looks to me like, you know, the macroeconomic data keeps getting worse. And I think eventually Janet Yellen is going to have to chicken out and basically admit that this rate hiking cycle didn't work, isn't working, and isn't really going to happen. And I think if the market concludes that there's no more rate hikes coming, at least in the short term, that would probably cause a pretty big downside move in the dollar index and probably a buying opportunity. Would you agree with that, or do you see it differently?

Raoul Pal: Yeah, I think that's possible. You know, I think people are confusing the dollar price action only with the fact that the Fed are hiking rates. I think it's a much more structural issue, as we've talked about again in the past, and I've talked about frequently, the $10 trillion short position that's out there, and the funding pressures that are there for those short positions as well mean that regardless of what happens to interest rates, the dollar goes higher. But I do think very much so that there is a risk that as the Fed start coming out of the equation, that the dollar weakens for a bit, goes back down to the bottom of the range. It's possible. I don't really know. You know, it's, you know, as it's been coiling like this, you usually get a break one way or the other. We may get a false break lower.

Maybe the DXY goes back down to the 92.5 level or so. But really, I think, you know, the larger move, you know, the next 10-point move is higher as opposed to lower in the DXY.

Raoul Pal: Treasury yields and the case for long bonds

Erik Townsend: So I, in the dollar, I want to move on to another topic we talked about back in April, which is Treasury yields. At that time, yields were quite a bit higher. I think that they are now. And you and I both thought that they were headed lower. I thought I was bold in predicting 1% on the U.S. 10-year before this is over, although I don't know that it would happen this year. You were even bolder than that, saying maybe 50 basis points before it's over.

And that's kind of been the view that I've held on to. But boy, I'm starting to get a little bit intimidated. We've got some pretty big names like Jeff Gundlach declaring that interest rates have bottomed The, you know, the top is in for bonds. That's it. Ray Dalio commented just this week that the credit cycle is over.

Do you think that these guys are onto something? Is it time for us to revisit our view, or are you still hanging on to the view that Treasury yields will eventually move considerably lower than they are now?

Raoul Pal: Yeah, I mean, tactically, for my Global Macro Investor clients, I closed out all of my bond positions, which I've had for 2 years now, the end of last month. Thinking that there would be this backup in rates. It's very typical to have this backup when the market gets overpositioned ahead of what I think is a recession still to come.

We've seen that in the economic data. I've been looking for this stab higher. I don't know how much higher it goes. Could it get to 2%? Possible in the 10-year. However, I think that is sowing the seeds for strengthening of my recession case, and in which case, then I think bond yields do come much lower.

There's no reason to believe that in a recession that US 10-year bond yields wouldn't get down to 50 basis points. We've seen it absolutely everywhere else in the developed world. There's no reason the US escapes it. Does it matter if it gets to 70 basis points, 100 basis points? No. The balance of risk rewards over time, even if it backs up to 2%, From here, that's you know thirty basis points with a hundred basis points of downside. Even in your case scenario, in my case scenario, it's you know it's a hundred fifty basis points. So the risk reward is very much in the long term setting up for for a better trade being being long bonds.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I definitely agree with you. I had been watching 1.70 as you know what I as high as I thought this bounce was going to go. I would have told you a week ago that if we saw 1.70, I would. probably buy 10-year Treasuries there. I chickened out after Goldman was out with a research note this week. We've got a link to that for our registered users in the Research Roundup email that came with this interview. You know, I think that, as you say, the bounce could go higher, but I agree with your long-term view for sure.

Raoul Pal: And also, you know, referring to the great and the good of the world saying the rate cycle's turned, we need to look at, okay, what are the things that turn the rate cycle? It has to be either inflation or credit risk. Neither of those look at this point in time to be an issue.

I don't see a reason for that to happen. Unfortunately, the great and the good got the JGB market wrong for the last 20 years. I've seen them all, every one of the most famous investors in the world get that market wrong. It can happen. I think they're unlikely to be right.

I think the demographic tailwinds and all the other things that go with why the bonds are where they are, I think, are not going away.

Raoul Pal: business cycle, ISM and recession odds

Erik Townsend: I want to go back to another view of yours, which I think came after our last interview. You published a fantastic video on Real Vision Television about the business cycle, and I'll summarize it to say your view is the business cycle is pretty darn long in the tooth here, and probably it's time to start really seriously looking at recession risk. That was now several weeks or even a couple of months ago, I think, that you put the video out. How has your view evolved since then? What's the update on that view? What do you see coming?

Raoul Pal: Yeah. So, I use the ISM survey in the US as my guide to the global business cycle. You know, there are differences elsewhere in the world. But what we saw is that the business cycle had been ticking up after being particularly weak into the back end of last year. It had been ticking up as the ISM ISM hit into the 54-ish level, and then suddenly, it dropped in one month below 50 again, which is suggesting that GDP growth is somewhere around 1%.

The business cycle usually has finished around this period of time. This is the 3rd longest business cycle in history. I think the probability is still that the cycle will continue to fall and play out to be a full recession, which would be the ISM going below 45. There's a lot of things that back that up. If we go through various sectors, whether it's the retail sector, whether it's restaurants, whether it's durable goods, whether it's freight, whether it's world trade, most of these things are all in recession now. There's very few areas of the US economy and the global economy that aren't in recession.

The likelihood is that the overall economy shifts towards a recession. The other thing to bear in mind is that I went back and looked at every single presidential, 2-term presidential election, i.e., when the incumbent changes, there is a 100% track record of a recession within the next 12 months. It either starts just beforehand or starts afterwards, but within 12 months, we're 100% chance of recession.

Raoul Pal: equity positioning and his short after Brexit

Erik Townsend: Well, I want to follow up on that then, because last time we spoke about equities, I think you and I had about the same view, which is we were out of our long positions but didn't dare to go short yet because, you know, we've just seen this market march higher and higher in the last couple of months, we've just seen a rapidly growing chorus of incredibly famous people, whether it be George Soros, Ray Dalio just coming out this week saying the credit cycle is over, Carl Icahn saying that he is more hedged than he's ever been in his career. A lot of people are really, really saying that something nasty is about to happen in the stock market.

Would you say it's time to be short now? Are you still waiting and watching? What do you think?

Raoul Pal: I made a decent mistake of shorting over that Brexit period and then saw everything bounce again. So I've got some short positions on and I'm kind of holding on to them because, you know, the relationship between the business cycle and the equity market says, again, the balance of probabilities are that they come lower.

I could have got a better location on the trade. So I was really patient all year, kept out of the trade, kept out of the trade, kept out of the trade than I thought the Brexit thing really was a bigger deal. And I think it is a big deal over the long term. But I got it wrong. So, I am short now and just holding on to the trade. The market's not going anywhere, really. Even though it drifted higher, it's not significantly higher that's pressurizing me on the position, because my views tend to be of the longer-term view. But I do think it comes lower.

Raoul Pal: European exit contagion and political risk

Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on the European exit contagion. I want to go back to the backstop situation topic since you mentioned it. When the Brexit vote first happened, you and Grant Williams both said, hey, this is likely to, in the long run, be remembered as sort of the first step in the collapse of the European Union, potentially. But you were also very careful to say that doesn't mean there's an imminent— it's all going to fall apart tomorrow. This would play out over a period of years. We haven't had a period of years yet, but we've had a period of several How has your view about European exit contagion developed since then? Do you still see it as a serious issue? Is it getting better? Is it getting worse? What do you think?

Raoul Pal: I think we can see from the political situation across Europe, whether it's what's happening with the German right, what's happening in Italy, and what's happening with the French right, is that there is a populist movement growing. And it's coming from discontent. And they blame it on immigration, but there's a general discontent with the working population in America. Many of the developed countries.

I think the chances of people looking for a different way out and pushing towards something with Europe is definitely a high chance. Which way is that? Is that the Germans forming their own bloc, or is it the weaker countries getting ejected? I just don't know. This is really beyond any of our predictive abilities, but we can say that the likelihood is for something bad.

Then we look for catalysts, and we know we've got the catalysts of these various elections around Europe, and we have to take them very seriously. The Spanish have not been able to hold a government together now for 9 months. Looks like they're going to their 3rd election, and I think they're going to fail to get a government again. Spain is basically ungovernable right now.

Let's see what happens with the other European countries. The US election is also part of the same situation, and Brexit was part of it too. It makes it complicated. Brexit also shifted the odds of something else happening in Europe. Europe higher because it showed that people can reject the status quo.

And I think that, again, adds pressure in a country like Spain where Catalonia is still pushing for something differently. Maybe the Basques will too. And maybe in the end, another country will. Maybe Greece decides it's had enough of the pain it's been forced to take. Maybe it does something. So it really isn't clear. But these are not inconsequential probabilities.

Raoul Pal: risk parity and VIX selling

Erik Townsend: Something I've noticed just in the last week is a kind of unusual movement in that we're seeing both equities and bonds selling off at the same time. And of course, that breaks the usual theory that, you know, one is selling off and the money's going into the other one. One of the theories that's been posited out there by some of the bloggers is that risk parity funds are unwinding and that's causing this. What do you make of this? Do you see it as significant? I think it's significant.

Raoul Pal: Yeah, listen, when there are overcrowded strategies, you create risk, and there's a lot of overcrowded strategies out there right now. Risk parity is one of them. It'd have been a great trade to be long bonds and long equities. There is an issue if both sell off, causes both positions to sell off. The amount of money in that strategy is very high. It's much higher than people think because banks are also creating synthetic hedge fund or synthetic risk parity trades for underlying clients as well. It's not just the funds that we know of, there's a lot more money indexed to these strategies. I think that is certainly an issue out there. There's a lot of money in those strategies. Can that cause some forced selling? Of course, it can.

I'm also very concerned about the amount of VIX selling that's gone on. The open interest in short positions in VIX futures is the highest in all recorded history. That's coming from yield enhancement trades by pension funds who are trying to pick up any yield they can, and they think the smart way is to sell volatility. I think obviously, that's a pretty dangerous trade because when volatility explodes, everyone's got a margin call and actually, they end up selling equity and doing all the things they didn't want to do because they thought they were going to be a buyer of equities into a dip, but they end up because of the amount of margin, end up having to sell equities. I think that's problematic too. I think there's some concentration of positions in various strategies. That is not good. I also don't like the fact there's a lot of illiquidity out there, and a lot of people are in illiquid strategies.

I think that is something that can all feed on itself. That being said, none of these are going to be meaningful unless the economic cycle is proven to be heading towards or in recession, in which case, then bad things tend to happen. If it's not, and the economic cycle is still lackluster, but still relatively expanding, expanding, then the chance of this being a short-scale event, which is what it looks like in the bond market right now, is more likely.

Erik Townsend: Boy, you talk about a vicious cycle. If you have pension funds that are forced to sell equities in order to try to combat a runaway upside move in the VIX, that feeds on itself pretty darn quickly.

Raoul Pal: gold and the long gold / long dollar pairs trade

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to a topic that I know is a favorite of yours and mine as well, which is gold. I was actually a little bit surprised. Jeff Christian, when he was on earlier this year, had a bearish view. We had him back on the program last week, and even Jeff is very bullish now on gold, sees it moving higher. But boy, this, this trading range we've seen post-Brexit between $1,308 and $1,377— 2 weeks ago we were testing the low end of it with an intraday below $1,308, last week $1,357, and we're back to $1,312 on Thursday morning. So what's going on with gold here?

Raoul Pal: Well, I actually took profits on my shorter-term term gold positions at the beginning of September, as well as I did with my bond position, noting the correlation between bonds and gold. My thesis for owning gold over this period was that negative rates meant that gold was becoming more and more attractive over time. There's the long-term story of gold and fiat currency, we all understand that one.

Really, for me, the big driver was going to be the negative interest rates. If I thought bond yields were going to back up, which they've done, I thought gold would come lower, which it's done.

Now, I think both of those states of affairs are temporary. Can gold go a bit lower than here? Possibly. Or is this a tight wedge that it's forming, and it breaks higher? That's probably true too. I'm actually long gold versus the dollar, and I'm also long gold versus a basket of global currencies, 2 different ways of having that trade on. I was long gold versus the dollar in the normal gold way before But that was the, that was the trade that took off. But I've still got the other 2 trades on.

Erik Townsend: That brings me to a trade that I've been considering very seriously, which is the pairs trade, long gold and long the dollar index at the same time. And of course, most people will tell you, well, that's, that doesn't make sense. Those are opposite. But I think that we do have a backdrop forming where both could move higher at the same time. Or I could be wrong and one could go up and one or the other could go down. So that's a perfect hedge. But boy, the scenario where both go down at the same time. I just can't find it. Am I missing anything? Can you see a scenario where they both go down?

Raoul Pal: No, I've had this trade on for 3 months or so now. It's one of my favorite trades in the world because of the risk reward, as you point out. I can't see them both falling. I can see them both correcting at the same time, but I can't see a trend where they both fall over time.

In which case, as you say, if we're wrong, you're going to have to adjust volatility, adjust the trade because gold is much more volatile than the DXY. I think it's probably too half the amount of gold versus the DXY to give it a rough volatility hedge, in which case, then you can sit it out.

And if they continue in the normal way that they do things, i.e., gold falls when the dollar goes up, fine, we're all pretty safe. You limit your losses pretty much so. But I think there's a chance of a home run over the next couple of years in that trade by holding on to the position.

I love these risk— these lopsided risk-reward trades. I think they make tremendous sense. And I think it's a great trade that you don't put on too big a size, but you can just leave on and let it work over time. Don't use it as a trading position, because there's a lot of noise in that kind of trade, but you keep it as a longer-term structural trade.

Raoul Pal: Goldman's bond view and Asian flight capital

Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more. Something that interested me this week was Goldman's note, where they were listing reasons they think that the bond sell-off, the Treasury sell-off, is going to continue. And one of their views, one of the 3 reasons they cited in that piece that we, we sent a link to our subscribed users in this week's Research Roundup was they think that European volatility, China and Japan and so forth, is all calming down, and that the flight capital that was coming out of China, Japan, and Europe into the United States is pretty much played out. Would you agree with that view? Particularly, we haven't talked about China and Japan yet in this interview. How do you see things going there, and what do you think it means in terms of the flight capital situation?

Raoul Pal: I think they're going about thinking about this in the wrong way. The reason the flight capital is subdued right now is because the dollar's subdued. If the dollar starts going higher, then suddenly the flight capital situation across all of Southeast Asia and emerging markets increases again. I've just come back from Hong Kong. I was there last week. Most people there are pretty bullish on the region. When pushed why they're bullish, they basically think that in the event of nothing happening, then emerging markets do okay. That's the bullish thesis. Then when I question them about, well, what happens if the dollar goes up, they say all bets are off.

I think that's the same with partly with Treasuries, but there is no growth. The ISM is below 50.

You need to be very careful extrapolating growth and therefore a higher interest rate market. If that were the case, the Fed would find it easier to raise rates. I think they're finding it particularly difficult to look for any window of opportunity to raise rates because the economy is just too weak. I don't really buy the Goldman argument that it goes on for any particular structural reason. Yes, if the dollar remains stable and the ISM remains around these levels, can bond yields drift higher a bit as we talked about up to 2%? That's possible.

Is it a more meaningful structural cyclical trade? No, it's the wrong part of the business. cycle. Bond yields tend to go up when the business cycle has turned from a recession and going higher. We're just not at that point. We're looking for the opposite. So I don't think the balance of probabilities lies in favor of Goldman's view.

Raoul Pal: the Fed, excess reserves and bank regulation

Erik Townsend: Speaking of monetary policy, what do you think is going on in terms of— it's been so many times now that, you know, trust us, trust us, really, we're about to hike rates next meeting. It's a live meeting. Trust us, really, really, we're They're going to. It feels to me like maybe we've gotten to the point where the Fed has figured out that the economy just won't allow them to raise rates, but they have to keep saying they're going to because people would panic so much if they didn't. What's your take?

Raoul Pal: You know, I really have no idea what they're trying to do. And I hear 1,000 different stories of what they're trying to do. I guess one thing is useful is to try and create a positively sloping yield curve, which I think is one of the things they're trying to do, because that stops the banks getting into a terrible mess. We've seen once yield curves start flattening, and the US yield curve flattened massively, that banks start getting into huge problems. Maybe that's their way of trying to keep the yield curve positive without people starting to panic about future growth and future inflation, and therefore killing the banking sector again.

Maybe that's their game, but at some point, the market's going to give up with that view. For me, I step back and I tend to filter a lot of this noise out. A lot of people spend too long looking at the Fed.

I look at the business cycle and understand what the Fed can and can't do. If I look at the business cycle again where it is, then the probability of them being able to do anything is pretty low. Therefore, it still makes me like bonds over time. I think there's going to be a fantastic setup in the bond market soon, as we talked about, to be long bonds, and everybody's out of the trade. It'll be a lovely clear position, economic weakness will be there. And the Fed won't raise rates. Even if they do raise rates, the yield curve will flatten like crazy. So I think, you know, I think the Fed is almost an irrelevance at this point.

Erik Townsend: And on the same topic of the Fed, something Jeff Christian brought up on last week's program was, you know, the situation with paying 50 basis points on excess bank reserves. There's plenty of reason to think that that could come under political pressure. Essentially, the Fed is creating what, when you think about it, is really a financial disincentive for banks to loan money to hardworking American consumers. They're better off to just take the 50 basis points, keeping their excess reserves with the Fed.

If they were to change that policy, which certainly you could easily imagine how there could be political pressure to do so in an election year, that potentially really changes everything. And Jeff thought it could be profoundly negative for equity markets if it happens. Any comment on that theory?

Raoul Pal: I don't think whatever they do, they can encourage the banking system to lend. I think the Basel III regulations, the general banking regulations globally mean it's much more difficult for banks to actually lend money in the manner they were before. Clearly, there's a lot of lending where the government has stepped in and forced lending, whether that's the auto sector, or whether that's some parts of the housing market, and also the student loan market.

I don't think even if you gave people money to borrow that they would borrow.

I don't think the banks are in a position to lend money, and they don't want to lend money, and regulatory reasons stop them lending money. So, I don't think there's any particular changes that will happen. I think people have— everything has gone through a structural shift. And I think pretending the world was like it was in the past, where it's all pent-up borrowing, is probably not true.

Raoul Pal: European banks, derivatives and sovereign collateral

Erik Townsend: I want to move on to a topic I know that you've done a lot of work on, Raoul, which is the European banking system. and the risks that exist there. You know, it seems like a lot of U.S. investors hear about Deutsche Bank and the potential message that we're getting from the European banking system, but nobody other than you seems to really be paying close attention. Give us the full backdrop on what's going on and what it means.

Raoul Pal: Yeah, I mean, I noticed this maybe 3 years ago that Deutsche Bank was looking concerning when people were telling us everything was okay. Deutsche Bank share price didn't look good. The other one that didn't look good was Credit Suisse UBS was somewhat similar, but that changed a little bit. Then it rolled into the Italian banks and back to the Spanish bank. Nobody talks about the Spanish banks. And some of those maybe 2 months ago hit new all-time lows again.

And yet nobody talks about a systemic problem in the Spanish banking system.

But if I look back and just think about what's going on, there is a big issue in the European banking system. Part of this is negative rates. Banks can't deal with negative rates. Secondly, it's regulation. They can't deal with regulation. Thirdly, it's bad loans, and they've got tons of them. So bad loans are still stacking up. There's still bad loans in Spain that have not been declared. The Italian banking system's completely saddled with bad loans.

Deutsche Bank, on the other hand, has enormous derivative books. It's got positions that it can't get rid of. Rid of. It's got an inability to— well, it has problems with its collateral because it requires so much collateral for all the derivative stuff that's on its books. It's creating distortions in the market.

We're seeing some huge distortions going on in LIBOR right now. That was partly based on the money market funds, the shift in regulation putting money market funds into Fed funds. But this story of what's been going on with the tightness in the Eurodollar market, Eurodollar being Eurodollar interest rate market, has been going on for some time. And that's being driven from the European banks that are under tremendous funding pressure. And it's less and less easy for them to get money. And this is why some of the swap lines have been— well, they were tapped actually in Japan recently. The Europeans haven't tapped the swap lines, but the swap lines are in place with the Fed to try and supply dollars to the offshore market, the Eurodollar market. Market, because it's really, really tight right now. What I have noticed is as LIBOR, 3-month LIBOR, 1-year LIBOR keeps moving higher and higher and higher every day right now, it has been highly correlated to firms like Deutsche Bank, because obviously, the lower credit banks, lower credit quality banks, or ones where there's a risk perceived to be in the system, find it harder and harder to borrow money.

Now, does this end up in a full-blown banking crisis? Prices again, I don't really know, but what I do know is it's unsustainable for the Italian banks and the Spanish banks, particularly to continue falling as fast as they have.

Deutsche Bank is something that's complicated. There's rumors swirling almost every day now that Deutsche Bank are going to get some bailout, whether they get— whether the state take them over, something will have to happen. The problem is, is why I'm really interested in them is how the ECB or the states, the individual states deal with a bailout of a bank, because they claimed in the Cyprus situation that bail-ins was the way that things were going to get done, i.e., that depositors lost their money. I'd love to see the Germans try and take depositor money away from Deutsche Bank. I don't think they'll allow it. I think this ties well into that story of Europe is how are you going to hold Europe together if suddenly what was told to one country isn't applied to another, and particularly if that country is Germany? I think it's a really complex situation. I think it's a very interesting situation. And we need to be very aware of what's going on, because at any point, it could get ugly.

Now, again, going back to my key theme and how I look at the business cycle, bad things happen in recessions. So, if we are heading towards recession, the European economy is weakening. France is basically at recession point. Italy's in recession, and Germany's now weakening. Spain's still looking okay. But if we start to weaken significantly, then the probability explodes of a bad thing happening, and the bad thing happening. happening in Europe is twofold. One is the banks, and one is the political situation. So, that's why I think people just should not lose focus on this, because it is a really big deal.

Erik Townsend: That brings to mind a follow-up question, because something I think a lot about, and I've only really researched it relative to the US banking system, is netting of derivative exposure risk. And I know you're familiar with that, but let me just explain for our listeners' benefit. When banks evaluate their risk, they tend to net their exposure. So if they're, you know, short 1,000 or a zillion and one contracts of whatever it is, and they're also at the same time long the same number of contracts of the same thing with a different counterparty, they net it all together and they say, well, we're almost flat. We don't really have any risk. What that ignores is that if you're talking about over-the-counter derivatives, where you have a number of different discrete counterparties involved, If one of those counterparties fails and defaults on their obligations under that over-the-counter derivative contract because they're bankrupt, all of the sudden everything else in the whole system is completely out of kilter because everyone else now they they're they what they thought was a net flat exposure is actually a massively leveraged naked exposure that isn't hedged the way they thought it was, and they don't always account for this risk the way.

they should.

When I listen to you talking about the European banking system, I'm just thinking, boy, what if one country really gets into trouble? Where does that leave all the other banks in Europe in terms of their derivative exposure to whoever is failing?

Raoul Pal: There's a much bigger risk than all of that. I spent a long time looking into— and I've talked about this on Real Vision before— I spent a long time looking into the clearing and custody system and the 2 systems, basically the DTCC in America and Euroclear in Europe. Those government bonds that are at the heart of the derivative industry, they're the collateral for everything in the entire loan industry. Those things are re-lent out something like 30 times within the system to allow for this leverage.

The problem is nobody actually has the full claim on those bonds within the system and custody system. If one of the countries in Europe defaults, or something happens where it's— let's say Santander goes bust, and Spain goes bust on the same day, the systemic problems within the custody system, the derivative industry, all the collateral, the settlements is beyond anybody's imagination.

The system cannot allow there to be sovereign risk, because if there is sovereign risk, then there's no risk-free collateral. And that is a real, real issue. And that would break the entire global banking system in one day, which is one of the reasons why they were so careful back in 2012 not to let anybody technically default.

Because had they done that, basically, it takes down everything that we know of as a banking system. And we would have to reprice what we understand to be the risk-free rate. We wouldn't have a risk-free free rate. And, you know, there's a really complicated thing within that. So, yeah, it's a big problem if one of the banks goes under, particularly something like Deutsche Bank. That's the other side of a lot of derivative transactions for the rest of the street.

But also, if something else happened in Italy or Spain where the sovereign credit is taken into question, then we've got a real big problem.

Erik Townsend: So what you're saying, Raoul, you know, I think our listeners are all familiar with the concept of too big to fail. They had to save AIG because the whole system would have fallen apart if the counterparty risk had exploded. You're saying that really Europe has a problem, that every single country in the union is, is too big to fail. If any one country has a sovereign debt crisis that just, you know, really goes nonlinear, the whole European Union falls apart because the counterparty risk is so great in terms of everybody holding everybody else's sovereign debt exposure. Is that right?

Raoul Pal: Yes. Sovereign debt exposure and banking exposure. You know, there's big problems So, let's say it's Spain. Well, the problem is the Spanish pension system is now 90% in Spanish government bonds. So, the whole country starts falling apart if this happens. And the knock-on effects, as you say, I mean, yes, there's not huge amounts of leverage on Spanish government bonds, but there's a huge amount of bank leverage that has Spanish government bonds underneath it. And that may be Santander, and Santander is very active in the swap and derivative markets. So, suddenly, Santander's position doesn't have the collateral that it had, or it can't fund it. itself within the capital markets. So, yeah, it really is a huge problem should that happen.

Raoul Pal: soft commodities and the La Niña turn

Erik Townsend: Wow. I want to move on to another topic I know that you follow a lot, which is soft commodities. You know, I think a year ago everybody was talking about the grains and they just can't sell off any more than they already have because they're just so low and they keep going. What's going on with the soft commodity market?

Raoul Pal: Yeah. So soft commodities are getting interesting to again. Now, they got hit by the stronger dollar, as you'd imagine, but they can break from the stronger dollar because these are really supply and demand-driven stories, and they're much less macro stories.

There is a big macro backdrop in grains, which is as the world moves towards higher protein diet, it uses a higher consumption of grain. As people go to high calorific diet, you consume more of this stuff. Okay, that's all well and good, but what we had, we had a perfect setup where we we had fantastic few harvests in the US.

We had decent harvests around in the Southern Hemisphere. Then we had an interesting situation where we had an El Niño last year. The El Niño meant that the US had a great crop. That's collapsed grain prices. Grain prices generally trade, or soft commodity prices generally trade on the US crop. However, in Brazil and Argentina and some other countries, the crops didn't do so well.

They had a shortfall. Brazil's been a net importer of some commodities now, soft commodities now. What it's done is shifted the stocks-to-use ratio globally and brought it down.

Okay, that's all well and good. The US crop has been bumper crop, the harvest is coming out now, prices are falling to reflect that. I'm more interested in what happens next year. Is there a trade to be set up? Should we be focused again on soft commodities from the long side?

And what I do note is that there is a relatively high chance that the El Niño turns to a La Niña. And the La Niña is the opposite weather pattern to the El Niño. And so just to simplify it, it tends to mean a dry season for the US. Now, obviously, California has had a tremendous drought. The El Niño barely did anything for it.

Fruit and veg basket of the US. There's problems that will come from that. The aquifers are already low. Aquifers low in California are also the same aquifers that feed some of the grain states. That's problematic in itself, but also, it means many of the grain-growing areas will be dry.

Suddenly, you get a situation where there's been an abundance, the Southern Hemisphere suddenly drew down on that abundance, And then it's a potential for the US to also struggle. The La Niña tends to also play havoc with the Southern Hemisphere crops, bizarrely enough. We tend to get flooding in many places as well.

There tends to be higher rainfalls in the Southern Hemisphere where the crop-growing areas are, and it can create problems. So we're setting up a position where suddenly we go from the embarrassment of riches to a short And I think that is possible to come out of corn, soybeans, and wheat.

And if those turn, they tend to go up 100% plus. So there's usually a really good opportunity when it happens and when it starts to turn. We haven't seen that turn yet.

But one thing that interests me from a macro standpoint is that soft commodities in inflation-adjusted terms are the cheapest. Cheapest they've ever been in history. Food is just basically too cheap versus everything else. Considering the secular backdrop of the move to proteins, we know that the volatility risks remain to the upside. Yes, I understand the prices have been falling over time, but grains, I think, will get more volatile with much higher price spikes higher as people scramble in short supply times for the right amount of foodstuffs. I think we're setting up in a position So, we're in a situation where something could happen with the weather. It could create a huge opportunity in some of these markets. Clearly, the positioning is going to be hugely short after the falls we've seen in most of these, and that makes it a very, very good opportunity to make some money out of this.

Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more with everything you've said, but I also feel compelled to point out you've just made an excellent cyclical and weather-related argument that says maybe it's not quite time yet, but what's coming up is a long trade in Soft commodities. But earlier in this interview, you also made a very excellent argument that the business cycle is way long in the tooth. We ought to be headed into a recession cycle next. And of course, you know, normally that would be bearish for commodities. How do you reconcile those?

Raoul Pal: Well, I think the way to reconcile it is you can be short industrial commodities and long soft commodities because they, you know, that spread does change, much like we'd rather be long gold than we would be long industrial. There's a whole trade there. People like to construct a long-short, less volatile trade. Well, I think you could be short industrials, and that would include oil and copper. I think you could be long precious metals, gold and silver, and I think you can start to look at being long soft commodities.

That whole trade actually sets up as a really nice portfolio of more balanced risks, so you're not just trading the dollar going up and down, which can be the case in commodities. Soft commodities don't necessarily fall in recessions. They fell terribly in 2008 because of farmer funding. As the funding markets dried up, it became very complicated for farmers, so that and also margin calls in futures positions and all sorts of issues came But this time around, we haven't had a bull market going into recession. We've had a bear market going into recession. So, maybe there's the opportunity of the reverse of what we've seen.

Raoul Pal: Real Vision update

Erik Townsend: Okay. I want to move on finally to a topic that I know is a favorite of yours as much as it is, or perhaps even more so than a favorite of mine, which is Real Vision Television. I think all of our listeners know that we are huge fans. We're also delighted We're delighted to be able to offer MacroVoices subscribers a discount of 10% if they want to subscribe to Real Vision, which of course is a paid video-on-demand service for professional finance.

But if there was one thing that I ever could have criticized about Real Vision, something I've learned in the podcast business is you've got to be able to provide people with the ability to subscribe on their mobile device through iTunes so it gets automatically delivered every week. If people had to go to MacroVoices.com to get the podcast, every week, they wouldn't remember to do it. There's such an advantage to having it automatically delivered. You guys didn't have that, but I think recently, you've just introduced an iOS app. So, what does it do? And how does it improve the Real Vision service?

Raoul Pal: Yeah, we did. We in fact released a whole load of technological things, because one of the things we do is, as much like with your podcast, is when you spend time digging into people's minds, and getting a much more in-depth look at how they think, you take a lot of time up.

You're then asking a lot of somebody's day to sit down to MacroVoices or to sit down to a Real Vision interview, you're going to need 45 minutes, an hour of somebody's time. Even if they'd love to do it, sometimes people don't have that time.

What we did is we did a number of things. Firstly, we now provide transcripts, so people can just download the written version. A lot of people like to write— to read written word because they can skim it faster than they can listen an interview. We did that. We also have the ability to listen to audio downloads of the actual things, and I know you guys have broadcast some of our audio downloads as well.

Then we decided, well, the app was the real way because people's time to consume this stuff is in the gym, on the way to work, on a plane, on a train. And so the new app allows people to listen offline or watch offline these fantastic interviews. So basically, you can watch these things whenever you want, wherever you want. And that's made it very, very accessible. And people have raved about it because it's just opened up a whole new world for them in the way they consume Real Vision.

Erik Townsend: I think you've also introduced a feature where those people who wanted to skim and go a little faster than the interview, can't you speed up the interview in the new application as well? So you can listen to the faster version of it?

Raoul Pal: Yeah, exactly. You can listen at 1.5x speed or 2x speed, just again, just to give people a chance to get through an hour-long interview in an hour, because to the human ear, it's easy to understand something at twice the speed. And it takes you a couple of times to get used to it, but you can digest information a lot faster. So we've just tried to make it really easy to consume some of the world's best financial Because we understand it's a time commitment, but we know the quality is there and people just need to be given the opportunity to get through as much of this content as they can because they learn so much from it that it is really valuable.

Erik Townsend: Well, it is an absolutely fantastic service. There have been rumors floating around the world of financial broadcasting that there might be even more coming from you guys. Anything you're at liberty to talk about as far as what might be on the horizon?

Raoul Pal: Nothing that I can disclose yet, but put it this way, we've launching 5 or 6 new businesses over the next 18 months. We raised some external capital from some rather famous folks that I'm sure your listeners will know, who are very keen on what we're doing with Real Vision. They love the fact that we're bringing truth back to finance and some integrity and honesty back to the financial markets, much like you're doing with your own podcast. We've got about 5 or 6 different businesses launched, the first one will That will come out probably in October, maybe November. There's always technology delays in these things. But most of these things are going to be hugely disruptive, as disruptive as Real Vision was to the video industry, to the financial video industry or financial media. We're doing things elsewhere as well that are going to be, I think, very interesting to people.

And hopefully, we can continue our revolution.

Erik Townsend: Well, I will look forward to telling our listeners about those when the news becomes public. And in the meantime, as I've always said, we are extremely I'm extremely proud of the work we do here at MacroVoices. But if there's one place where you can get even better content than what we do, buy a Real Vision subscription because you guys have, you know, the benefit of full-color video and you also are able to attract higher-profile guests than we've been able to get on the program thus far. So it's the only financial journalism source that I think exists that I just have to throw in the towel and say, yep, those guys are better than we are, but they're the only ones.

My hat is really off to you.

Raoul Pal: Thank you so much. It's really kind of you. We're big fans of what you're doing as well. We're all very aligned with what we're trying to achieve. I tell you, we're talking about soft commodities, and we're talking about fantastic content. I'm not sure when this is going to be released, but on Friday, this Friday, so that's the 16th of September, there's an incredible interview you will never get anywhere else, and that is Dan Tapiero, who is a macro investing legend and a good friend of mine. He worked for Julian Robertson at Tiger, Stan Druckenmiller at Duquesne, Michael Steinhardt, and Stevie Cohen.

Dan is one of the world's great macro guys, worked with all the greats. He's interviewing his friend, Dwight Anderson. Dwight is the head of commodity— was the head of commodity trading at Tiger, and also had the largest commodity hedge fund in the world. He's another legend, and those 2 together are chatting about commodities. Soft commodities comes up in that interview, and I think people will love it. You just don't get this content anywhere.

Erik Townsend: Well, and to be sure, if anyone is new and hasn't done it yet, you definitely want to go to realvisiontv.com/discount/macrovoices. If you haven't already had your free trial, you can get a 1-week free trial of Real Vision, and you can also use the MacroVoices discount. discount code if you want to subscribe to get 10% off on the actual subscription. And it is one of very few things that I don't hesitate to pay for and recommend to others. So, I can't recommend it highly enough. Anything else you want to add before we close?

Raoul Pal: I think that's it. I think we've covered an enormous amount of ground, and I look forward to hearing the feedback. You can also find me on Twitter at @RaoulPal.

Erik Townsend: Okay, well, we'll certainly encourage our listeners to follow you on Twitter and definitely check out Real Vision Television, folks, if you haven't done so yet. Aaron Chan and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program.

Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan.

Postgame: is the Fed an irrelevance?

Aaron Chan: Wow, that was a great interview, Erik. And, you know, I've had this interview circled on the calendar for some time now, and I really grab at any chance to listen to Raoul share his his concise and thorough takes on global macro and investing. So it was great to have him back on the program. And as usual, when I listen to Raoul, I'm left with some questions I haven't thought of before. So let's get right into it. Now, you and Raoul went on this tour d'horizon of global macro topics, but I want to start with Raoul's response to the Fed's near or medium-term impact on the dollar. Now, he said, quote, the Fed is almost an irrelevance at this point. And I happen to believe in this view as well, because they've basically backed themselves into a corner, right? Walking at tightrope, or whatever metaphor you'd like, with depression on the one end and hyperinflation on the other. All the while, the structural integrity of the rope upon which they are balanced is fraying with each additional economic or political catalyst.

But it appears the market's reaction function to Fed speak still remains strong. But what sort of signs would you look for to see the market pricing in irrelevance? I mean, would it be something akin to the yen rallying when NIRP was introduced in Japan? I mean, do you agree with this view? And if So, what are you looking for specifically?

Erik Townsend: Wow, that's a tough one. First of all, do I agree with the view overall? I have a really tough time deciding because I want to. I want very much to. I think that it's very well-reasoned. And I think that, you know, Raoul's not the only one. There's a lot of really, really smart, famous people that are saying, okay, folks, we are at the end of the game here. Ray Dalio was just out this week saying it's endgame. It's game time for this credit cycle, folks. You know, it can't go any further. So, I really respect these people. The thing is, I have been wrong so many times since 2009. I made, frankly, this same argument several years too early, saying that QE1 was an act of desperation, that the Fed was going to lose credibility, that markets would see through all of this and recognize that they're not solving anything by papering over our problems and extending and pretending.

I said in the summer of 2009, that by Christmas time of 2009, the market will have seen through it. Well, it's 6 years later, and I was dead wrong about that. So I tend to think in terms of what would actually tie their hands, because let's suppose that, you know, things start falling apart here and equity prices start to tank. What would stop the Fed from doing what they've done every other time, which is to conjure a few trillion more dollars in another major round of quantitative quantitative easing out of thin air and use it to prop up financial markets. Well, as we've discussed several times in the past, if you had runaway inflation, that would tie their hands. Another thing that would tie their hands, and I think that it may be that what we're seeing affecting equity markets is actually the presidential poll numbers. If Donald Trump were elected president, he's been fairly outspoken critic of this Fed policy.

I think he might put political pressure on the Fed to stop propping up markets, and the market could totally tank in that case. And maybe, as Hillary's fainting episode caused Trump to surge in the polls, that kind of coincides with this big dip that we took in equity prices.

But aside from something tying their hands, I kind of go back to every time I thought they were going to lose credibility and the market was going to wise up and see what I think has been obvious since 2009, which is that these are acts of desperation that don't solve anything, they conjure a few trillion bucks out of thin air and they succeed at propping markets up. Now, as far as what the signal would be, if they do provide accommodation and it doesn't work, market prices fall off a cliff anyway, even in the face of an announcement of another round of QE, that would be the really big signal. You know, I don't know if it's happening. The way I've looked at it is I'm so tempted to be short I think we are seeing, you know, what could be a dead cat bounce. The timing is about right, as I said, for this to be the volatility bout in September before the really bad fireworks start in October.

But, you know, I've felt this way so many times since 2009. Every time the market really starts moving to the downside, the Fed comes in and saves the day with more printed money. And what would stop them from doing it this time? So that's, that's the conundrum. Okay.

Postgame: is QE money printing?

Aaron Chan: So I guess you'll know it when you see it. While we're still on the Fed, we had a listener ask whether QE is technically money printing. And Erik, I think I know what you're going to say here, but for the sake of our listeners, why don't you clarify this once and for all?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think it's really just arguing semantics. Did Bill Clinton lie when he said that he had never violated the drug laws of the United States? Well, he didn't lie because he was in another country when he was violating their drug laws. You know what? It is a true statement that quantitative easing is not money printing in the most literal sense of there are no printing presses creating more dollar bills.

What is happening with quantitative easing is the Fed is conjuring new money supply out of thin air that didn't exist before, and they're using it to buy Treasury bonds. Now, another related question. Is, is quantitative easing effectively monetization of debt? Well, in a form of truth that only Bill Clinton could compete with, it's not monetization of debt simply because they're not buying those new Treasury bills directly from the government. They're going through a middleman, which is one of the primary dealers. And that technically means, just as Bill Clinton didn't technically violate the drug laws of the United States, that it's not debt monetization. But what it really is, is creating new money out of thin air. Whether you call it money printing or not, I think it's a metaphor. I don't think it's really that important of a distinction, honestly.

Postgame: risks to the gold-dollar pairs trade

Aaron Chan: Okay. Thanks for clearing that up. Moving along. One of the great things about Raoul is that not only does he give you the analysis, but he also speaks to how you might trade on this analysis. And I'm specifically referring to the gold-dollar pairs trade that you guys discussed. So gold hedges against NIRP and inflation, while the dollar hedges against deflation and global deleveraging. And I think it was Grant Williams who said that the fact that this is a great trade in the first place tells you all you need to know about where we stand in the endgame.

However, I recently heard Jim Rickards speak about a paper authored by Professor Marvin Goodfriend of Carnegie Mellon University that was presented at the Jackson Hole Central Bank in what I call summer camp, basically, a couple weeks ago. And it basically proposed an exchange rate between bank deposits and physical cash, or essentially placing a premium on cash deposits deposit in the bank while penalizing those who hold physical notes. Now, we can probably agree that this is nothing more than a proposal to further NIRP but say something like this were to become official monetary policy, and given the long-term nature or horizon of this pairs trade Erik, could you envision a scenario where, say, there's a limitation on gold holdings and let's call it they impose a dual value on cash?

I mean, where is this trade? I mean, could you see it backfiring to the downside?

Erik Townsend: I think the key to this, Aaron, is Raoul's comment that this trade has a lot of noise in it. I love this idea. I love it when I discussed it with Grant Williams several shows ago. I love it when I talk about it with Raoul this week. But hey, I loved it last week. Now, the dollar index and gold are both considerably lower than they are— particularly gold— than last week. And so, as Raoul said, you've got to be willing to ride some volatility. And I think particularly you want to consider that if we were to break below that $1,308 key support level. You could see gold take a bit of a nosedive down to say $1,250 to $1,280 or so. And particularly if we do see some reversal from the Fed at some point where they acknowledge that they're not going to be able to hike rates any further than they have with really just one hike in their so-called rate hiking cycle, that could cause the opposite reaction where the dollar tanks At that point,

gold should see some significant upside out of that.

So, those are 2 scenarios where both assets could see significant downside. It probably wouldn't happen at the same time. Now, it's tempting to say, oh, well, gee, that's really great. I'll leg into this trade by first waiting for gold to take a dip. I'll buy the long side of the gold trade. Then I'll wait for, you know, Janet to fess up that she can't hike rates. And when the dollar takes a dip, I'll buy that side and I'll have the perfect trade.

Usually when you try to leg into a pairs trade, you outsmart yourself and end up getting screwed. So you've got to pick a point to go long both assets at the same time. This week looks better than last week, but what if next week, you know, looks still better and you're down on the trade if you go into it? So as Raoul said, I think you've got to be ready to put that trade on small enough in size that you can ride out some volatility. But from a structural argument standpoint, can I Can I think of a reason why a trend would begin where both dollar index and gold consistently move lower over time? No, I can't see it. I can see one or the other going down, and I can see why they might both go up, but I can't see them both going down over a sustained period.

And that's why I love the idea of this trade.

Postgame: European bank derivatives and the doom loop

Aaron Chan: Speaking of being screwed, I thought your conversation with Raoul about the European banking sector was fascinating. And I remember reading a Bloomberg article I saw an article about, I think, a month ago reporting on how Citi plans to purchase a $380 billion portfolio of credit default swaps from Credit Suisse. And this is after having purchased $250 billion from Deutsche Bank last year with the intention of netting out their own derivatives book and lowering their derivatives exposure. It's been reported that Deutsche Bank sits on a derivatives book somewhere close to $75 trillion. Yes, trillion. And last month, Benn Steil and Emma Smith from the Council on Foreign Relations, published a piece highlighting the doom loop of national banking systems in Europe being increasingly exposed to the debt of their governments as a percentage of total assets. I mean, Erik, it seems like there's no way out for them here.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I think you're right. And as much as it would be nice to think that Credit Suisse is being responsible and reducing their risk exposure by offloading some of this stuff, maybe they're giving Citi a bargain price to offload all this potentially toxic and risky counterparty exposure. I think that might be giving him too much credit. I don't think that they're being responsible and diligent. I think they're, they're probably responding to doing what they have to do. The banking system in Europe, as Raoul described, is in big trouble. And I think they should be reducing their exposure. But I don't have any hope that they're going to do some active diligence that makes everything better again. And all of a sudden, the system is safe. I think we've got pretty serious problems. And I don't I don't really see a clean way out to it.

Postgame: oil versus soft commodities

Aaron Chan: Yeah, it's interesting that we're talking about this actually on the 8th-year anniversary of Lehman going bankrupt. So last question, Erik. We recently had Art Berman on the program where he described his moonshot thesis for oil prices once the supply glut is worked through and the supply destruction finally kicks in. Now, having heard that, and now considering what Raoul is saying about a possible moonshot in soft commodities, I mean, it sounds like it could be a double whammy for consumers going forward. And I mean, this is without even factoring a decided downturn in the business cycle and hence recession. So, Erik, how are you thinking about these different hypotheses in parallel?

Erik Townsend: Well, I don't really think about them in parallel because they're, they're 2 different fundamental arguments. Raoul is talking about a commodity cycle event that's mostly about weather, the El Niño cycle reversing into a La Niña and changing weather And that basically creating a bullish argument for soft commodities in the future. Art makes a very persuasive case about a moonshot coming in oil prices, but it has nothing to do with El Niño and La Niña. It has to do with when we eventually work through this supply glut, all of the supply destruction that has occurred as a result of this price sell-off is eventually going to catch up with us.

Those are two totally different things. And I think that these two moonshots in prices would not likely happen at the same time. If they did, it would be pure coincidence. And again, as you said, you've got to look at the recession cycle also. Business cycle appears to be rolling over, and you know that potentially will prolong the oil situation longer than the same recession effect would prolong a more weather-oriented analysis that Raoul is providing. providing for soft commodities.

So, I think they're really 2 separate cans of worms, so to speak.

Aaron Chan: All right. Makes sense. And unfortunately, we're out of time, but Erik, anything else before we wrap up the show?

Sign-off and Research Roundup preview

Erik Townsend: Well, our regular listeners know the usual broken record here. If you want us folks to continue to bring you really fantastic interviews like this week with Raoul, we need your help promoting the show. And we're right on the hairy edge of starting to gain traction to where we can get some bigger names on the show. I know you just finalized one really big name that we have coming up next month. We need your help. So please retweet us, sign up, particularly register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Your benefit from that is the free Research Roundup email. If you don't want it, it takes one click to opt out of it. Aaron, let's tell everybody what they can expect this week.

Aaron Chan: Right, Erik. The Delivering Alpha conference was held earlier this week, and it hosted many big-name investors presenting their thoughts on global markets, monetary policy, and investment ideas. And for that, we've got full audio interviews from Jim Chanos and Paul Singer. We've also got a hold of the large slide deck from Jeffrey Gundlach's most recent investor webcast for DoubleLine clients. It's chock-full of great charts, and you'll definitely want to check it out. Finally, on monetary policy, I'm sure many of you have heard of, or at least read, Ken Rogoff's pro-cash ban piece. Well, this week we're happy to bring you James Grant's teardown of proposal in his Wall Street Journal article. You'll find all this and much more in the latest Research Roundup newsletter.

So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we've gotten and continue to welcome your suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For our listeners who write or blog about global markets and would like to share that content with our pro-finance community, shoot us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag, and we'll include it in our weekly distribution. If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for the latest updates and interview releases. You can also follow Erik @ErikSTownsend and myself @_AaronChan_. For Erik Townsend, I'm Aaron Chan. Chat with you next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at www.macrovoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week, which never includes advertising or marketing.

You'll also gain Access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we're able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can also subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.

MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by Funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Jeffrey Christian — precious metals expert (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Hello, everyone.

Host opening: episode preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices Episode 30 was recorded on September 8th, 2016. I'm Erik Townsend. Precious metals caught me by surprise this week, with gold touching $1,357, up more than $50 an ounce from its intraday low just a week earlier. Silver briefly traded above $20 this week, which I sure wasn't expecting.

So, we're taking advantage of the opportunity to bring back renowned precious metals expert Jeffrey Christian. as this week's featured interview guest. In addition to the precious metals outlook, Jeff and I will also be discussing a number of macro factors ranging from Treasury yields to excess bank reserves to inflation versus deflation. All of that and more is coming up in this week's featured interview.

After our feature interview with Jeff, Aaron and I will be discussing reserve currencies— what they are, how they work, and why the U.S. dollar's role as de facto global reserve currency is so important.

Stocks: why a sudden crash is unlikely

Aaron Chan: And I'm Aaron Chan. For the second week in a row, the S&P 500 stock index did not, I repeat, did not break out to yet another all-time record high. And somehow the fact it didn't actually seems like news after so many weeks of new all-time highs. Erik, could this be the beginning of the end for the stock market, as so many notables like George Soros and Carl Icahn have predicted?

Erik Townsend: Well, I don't know about that, but what I would say is markets generally don't crash when a lot of people are predicting that they will. So is it possible that this Was a top and it's all headed downhill from here? I suppose that's possible. What I will predict is that we're not going to see a sudden and dramatic crash. And the reason I say that is simply if you understand the mechanics of how a stock market crash happens, it's when nobody's expecting it and all of the sudden some catalyst causes a loss of confidence and everybody starts panicking and selling because they're not hedged.

The thing is, so many people have been talking about how precarious these valuations are for so long that a lot of people People have hedges on. Carl Icahn has been very vocal about saying he's more hedged than he's ever been before.

So I don't think that the ingredients exist for a sudden and unexpected market crash, precisely because so many people are predicting exactly that outcome. And, you know, the other thing is, where are we this week? 10 points or so below that all-time high from a couple of weeks ago. So, you know, maybe we're seeing a topping process here. I don't know. But I certainly don't see the ingredients for a sudden and dramatic crash, despite the chorus of voices that are saying that's coming. I could be wrong, but I just don't see the market unexpectedly crashing at a time when too many people are predicting that outcome.

Crude inventories: 14.5M barrel draw and Hermine

Aaron Chan: Right. And on our Labor Day weekend oil market special last week, you and Art Berman both predicted that some really big inventory builds might be coming this fall. So any sign of that yet, Erik?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think in that show I said specifically that I was expecting some really large large inventory builds. I think I may have mentioned the number 5 million barrels in a single week. So if I were to tell you that this week's number was actually 14.5 million barrels, that is the biggest one-week change in inventory ever since, uh, 1999. So that's 17 years. Boy, I would look like a genius for saying that. Until— wait a minute, let's give it a couple more seconds. I like sounding like a genius. Let's let that sink in.

Okay, now we have to reveal the news.

It was a 14.5 million barrel drawdown on inventory, the opposite direction of what Art and I predicted. Meanwhile, Cushing, Oklahoma, always critical because it's where the WTI futures contract is settled. Drawdown 434,000 barrels. More space available in Cushing this week than last week. Gasoline, meanwhile, massive Massive 4.2 million barrel drawdown on inventories, offset by a very large build on distillate inventories of 3.4 million barrels and a slight decline in production 3 weeks in a row. Well, boy, listening to just drawdown after drawdown after drawdown sounds like Art and I really screwed up and got it wrong.

Well, hold on, guys. This is almost, you know, I don't want to say almost certainly, this is absolutely without a doubt a weather-related anomaly.

Aaron Chan: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: in the data. Tropical Storm Hermine in the Gulf is resulting in shut-ins. It's resulted in the lowest level of imports of crude oil to the United States on record ever in a single week. Well, what's going on? Did those ships that were coming not come? Did they sink at sea? No, they're still stuck at sea because of bad weather. They're still coming. They're delayed by a week or two until the weather gets better. So I think that this massive, massive drawdown in inventory is an anomaly that is a result of weather. And of course, there's a real impact from these weather events. You know, they screw the system up. But for the most part, it's a delay effect. The, the oil's still coming.

So yeah, we saw this massive drawdown. We'll see a big build when the weather clears.

I don't think it's a big deal. Meanwhile, West Texas Intermediate crude oil rallying dramatically, a dollar instantly within the first 2 seconds of that inventory number coming out, and more than $1.50 in the ensuing few hours after that. It's as if the bulls are just jumping for joy that this inventory number has changed everything. It's changed everything until the weather clears, guys. So I really don't think it's nearly as significant as the tape action is suggesting. But we're looking at $47.41. We were at $44 and change before first API reported the large draw. They were anticipating a 12 million barrel draw, and then DOE confirmed it at 14.5. And, you know, the, the market has just been going straight up. It's the weather. Pay attention, people. I don't think this will last, but it probably will last until we get another inventory report. Will it be a big build on inventory next week?

It depends on how long the weather takes to clear.

Gold, Treasury yields, Fed hike odds and the dollar

Aaron Chan: All right, so shifting over to gold, we've been watching a technical consolidation range between $1,308 and $1,377 for so long now that our regular listeners are probably sick of hearing me say that over and over again. But last week, it looked like we were right on the precipice of a breakdown. below key support at $1,308, and we even saw $1,306 briefly on an intraday basis.

Now, Erik, I was pretty sure this week we'd be discussing the breakdown below $1,308, but it went the other way, trading as high as $1,357 this week. So what's your outlook for gold here?

Erik Townsend: Well, definitely it's taken me by surprise. I think that, you know, the combination of the dollar weakness resulting from the jobs report, nonfarm payrolls last Friday, rate hike expectations are weakening, and of course, if you don't hike rates, that's the competitor to gold because Treasuries offer, most people think, similar safety, although I would disagree with that myself, and they produce a yield. If that yield is going up, it's competing with gold. If it's not going up, it's not competing with gold. So, that explains the short-term tape action.

But the more important question is, you know, when Jeff Christian was last on our program in May, he and I both thought this market was rolling back over towards $1,200 or so, and that clearly has not happened, looking at about $1,341 right now as we speak. And as you mentioned, testing $1,357.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: Earlier this week. Clearly, this calls for an expert, so let's save the rest of the gold conversation for our feature interview with Jeff Christian, who's going to have a whole lot more to say about it.

Aaron Chan: Yeah, sounds good. 10-year Treasury yields are about where they were last week, priced to yield about 1.60% on Thursday afternoon. Any change in your outlook, Erik?

Erik Townsend: Not really. I guess what I would say, as I've said before, is my initial post-Brexit opinion, which is maybe this is just a quick dead cat bounce post-Brexit and we're going to see lower yields, I still think we're headed towards lower yields, but it's clear now that it's not just a dead cat bounce. It's going to take longer to play out. And I think really we've got to see some resolution of, you know, will she or won't she? Is Janet Yellen really going to hike rates ever? And if so, when is that going to happen? It looks like it's probably not at the September meeting at this point, or at least expectations of that are collapsing. We'll see what happens.

Aaron Chan: Right. And we've been expecting more U.S. dollar strength, but really the chart looks awfully soft, back to a 94 handle again. So what's going on with the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, of course, it is the result of the nonfarm payroll report and the expectations of a rate hike collapsing. And I think that's the reason we're seeing the dollar softness. And of course, the mechanism of injury there is that when you hike interest rates, it makes the dollar more competitive with other currencies, brings international capital in. If you're not expecting that rate hike to happen, the capital inflows don't happen and the dollar weakens. So it's all very much to be expected in reaction to the news that we've had. And I'm I'm going to definitely ask Jeff Christian again for his view, because he's certainly been more right than I have on the dollar in the last year.

Aaron Chan: So, thanks for the market update, Erik. CPM Group founder Jeffrey Christian is one of the most renowned precious metals experts in the industry. So, we're delighted to have him back on the program to shed some light on the unexpected strength in the gold market since we last interviewed him back in May.

Erik's interview with Mr. Christian is coming up as MacroVoices continues, right here at MacroVoices.com.

Jeffrey Christian: dollar outlook

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is CPM Group founder and renowned precious metals expert Jeff Christian. Jeff, of course, is best known for his precious metals work, but Jeff, I'd like to start with a couple of macro backdrop issues before we get on to gold and silver, which I'm sure our listeners are looking forward to hearing your view on. So let's start with the U.S. dollar. The last time we had you on the show, my My view was I was expecting the U.S. dollar rally to continue. You said you thought it was more likely to kind of muddle along and tread water. And I guess you got the call on that one because that's exactly what's happened. So, since you got it right, what do you see from here in terms of the U.S. dollar? Because obviously gold and everything else is priced in dollars.

Jeffrey Christian: Well, I think that the dollar will continue to tread water. You know, I think there is an upward bias on the dollar, but, you know, what One of the things that we were looking, expecting to limit the dollar's upward momentum was that we thought that investors would be cycling away from investing so heavily in the U.S. market and they would be moving back to a more balanced global focus on their investment portfolio. And in the first half of this year, we didn't necessarily see that, but I think that in the third quarter, we've seen investors starting to shift. Shift. Yeah, they're not abandoning investments in the U.S. by any shake of the wand, but we are seeing investors starting to reinvest in emerging markets in Europe and China and in other economies, which is, I think, removing some of the upward pressure on the U.S. dollar.

We think that those trends are going to continue so that we don't necessarily see the dollar rising sharply. Don't necessarily see it collapsing, but we see it sort of moving sideways in a relatively more volatile fashion than it has been over the last 4 months.

Brexit, exit contagion and the devolution of power

Erik Townsend: The other item that I wanted to touch on is European exit contagion, because quite a few people, at least the side of the argument that thinks that exit contagion is a serious risk, are saying that that's going to be maybe the next big catalyst for precious metals. So do you think that there is serious risk of of Brexit leading to other nations leaving the European Union? And if so, would you agree that that potentially is a catalyst for gold and silver?

Jeffrey Christian: I think there's some real risks there. I'm not sure that they'll be realized, at least for the next several years. You know, I studied political science in school, and, and when I was in school, you know, really from the 1950s through into the mid-'80s, the overriding political impulse was toward consolidation, ever bigger governments, ever bigger government and international organizations. And from the '80s forward, we started seeing really a devolution of power to ever smaller operations and governments and entities. And I think that I take Brexit and the vote for Brexit within that context. Now, obviously, there's this tremendous anti-government anger and frustration that was behind the British exit vote. It's behind the changes in the German electorate over the last few months and last weekend. It's behind votes that we've seen in the United States, the Philippines, Austria, and a number of other places. So there is a lot of anger there.

But I think that, you know, my view of Brexit is that it's a sign of the times. That it's part of this greater devolution. And, and the risk that we have on a global basis is that the bureaucrats and politicians don't see it as such. And, you know, the reason why the British voted to leave the European Union was because the European Union had declined every opportunity to accommodate the British desire for a revised agreement between Britain in the EU. And I think that if you find that the politicians and bureaucrats sort of catch on to what's going on around the world and they start responding to voters and the populations, then maybe you don't see that so much. But, but there is a risk there because, quite frankly, you know, with modern technology, with debit cards, with instant payment systems in places, The value of a European Union is far reduced from what it was, say, 30, 40, 50 years ago. So, I think there is a scope for devolution.

I'm not sure how fast it will come.

Gold and silver outlook after Brexit

Erik Townsend: Moving on to the main event of precious metals. When we spoke back in May, it was about 3 or 4 weeks before the Brexit referendum. You predicted at the time that if Brexit passed, that it would result in a spike in gold and silver to the upside, and, of course, that's exactly what happened. But you and I both thought at that point that maybe that would be short-lived, that once the flash in the pan was over, similar to the way equities, you know, were way down but then corrected within a few days, we both thought that it might roll back over to the downside, down toward $1,200 or so. And I thought until very recently, you know, it looked like maybe this trading range we've seen post-Brexit with support around $1,308, we almost took out last week, But boy, we're up to, what is it, $1,355 or so as we're speaking on Wednesday afternoon. So has your view changed on gold?

Where do you see it going from here?

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, definitely our view has changed. You know, the realities that we're facing has changed. We thought that, yeah, you'd see a spike in the gold price going into the Brexit vote. If they voted to exit, it could be a slightly greater spike, but then we thought it would come back. It hasn't come back. We've seen investment demand in the United States, Canada, Europe, and a number of other countries hold up much more strongly than we had expected. Part of that is post-Brexit and post-Brexit anxiety.

Part of it is, I think, a lot of anxiety about other economic and political factors, including the U.S. election. And I think that you know what we had been expecting was. Maybe a pause and a decline in gold prices in July, August, September. We're now into September. We haven't really seen that. We've seen a pause, but we haven't seen a decline.

I think there is some scope for the gold price to drift down to $1,300 or even $1,280 over the next couple weeks. But I think with the enormous array of political and economic issues that are confronting investors around the world, Gold will probably stay up higher. So, you know, we've said where we thought there would be a pause in the 3rd quarter and then gold prices would rise a little bit more modestly in the 4th quarter and into 2017, we have the gold price staying higher now and actually continuing, probably rising at a somewhat more accelerated pace between now and, say, 2018.

Erik Townsend: So, it sounds like it's a buy signal from your standpoint.

Jeffrey Christian: Well, yeah, we've seen a really strong move off of the base, so I don't expect— just as I don't expect the dollar to rise as strongly as it was in 2015, I don't expect the gold price to rise as strongly as it did in the first half of this year. But I think that, you know, I divide investors in gold into different categories, and from a shorter-term capital appreciation perspective, I think gold makes sense because it's more likely to be higher in the next year or two or three than it is to be lower.

And I think from a longer-term investment or capital preservation perspective, gold probably makes sense simply because of the economic and political and currency market unrest that we're likely to see. So yeah, we're telling investors to buy gold. We're telling I would encourage them to be ready that if they see the price dip over the next few weeks, that that would probably be a very good buying opportunity, but that from a longer-term perspective, it probably makes sense to continue to hold your gold and to add to your gold portfolio.

Erik Townsend: And we're seeing silver also back at, well, just below $20 as we're speaking on Wednesday afternoon, but it had been above $20 over the last few days. Do you also see silver as a buy, or do you think it's maybe a little bit overdone It's like, it's probably a little bit more overdone than gold.

Jeffrey Christian: There is a tremendous amount of investor interest in silver right now. The price probably is, in our view, more likely to move sideways to slightly higher than it is to rise significantly sharply from here. Yeah, I think that a price in the $18 to $22 range over the next 12 months is a likely trading range. So right now we're right in the middle of that, and it's sort of like a hold but don't necessarily run out and buy. But if you see the price, you know, drift back down to $18, it's probably a buy on a, on an intermediate-term basis.

Erik Townsend: Okay, and I assume that your view you described already in the short to intermediate term, long-term view for gold and silver is higher in terms of macro drivers, or I don't want to assume that.

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, I think there are a couple factors there. I mean, there are fundamentals that are kicking in, uh, that, that are more supportive of gold, also supportive of silver in the long term. Uh, and then I think the— you have to look at the macroeconomic environment. You know, the big fundamental that drives gold and silver prices higher or lower is investment demand, and investment demand is driven by economic in financial and political developments and expectations of developments. And our view is that, you know, over the next couple years we're facing some problems, but in the longer term we're probably facing even larger fundamental economic and financial market problems that are going to cause wobbles in the stock market, wobbles in economic growth, problems in the currency markets, and that all of those factors Probably will cause investors to buy more gold and silver going forward than they, they are right now.

So, we expect gold prices and silver prices to rise in the long run.

Global and US growth: muddle-through

Erik Townsend: Let's go ahead and move on to some of the other macro issues then, and we can relate some of them to how they might affect gold as we continue. In terms of growth prospects, you know, we've heard an increasing number of voices really expressing concern about GDP growth, both domestically in the United States and globally. What do you see in terms of global growth outlook?

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, you know, the way we look at it is we, you know, world global growth right now is about 3.0, 3.3% of real GDP. In the U.S., we're probably looking at about— well, the most recent figure was about a 1.1% growth, uh, in the second quarter of this year. And so our view is that we probably are going to continue to see this sort of muddle-through economic growth, subpar economic growth compared to what we saw in the period 2000 to 2007, and even lower than the growth that we saw in the 2010 to 2015 recovery.

What we're looking for on a global basis is economic growth in the 3% to 3.3% range, which is what economists call a non-inflationary sustainable long-term growth profile. In the United States, we're looking at growth in the, you know, 0.5% to 2.0% growth rate over the next 10 years, which is again non-inflationary, but it doesn't necessarily get us out of the malaise that we're in right now.

And we're sort of looking at that. And the problem is that when you have an economy, either a national economy like the U.S. or a global economy, when you have an economy that is just muddling through, it renders itself vulnerable to economic and financial shocks that can throw it back into a recession or can cause a spike higher in unemployment and other factors like that. So that is— That is one of the factors that we're looking at that make us think that there will be periods of time over the next 10 years when investors will say economic conditions are really in dire straits. I should be adding more gold and silver to my portfolio.

Negative rates and the excess reserves puzzle

Erik Townsend: And let's talk about interest rates, because obviously that definitely has a bearing on precious metals. What do you see? I mean, it seems like everybody keeps saying, well, surely this has to be the bottom in interest rates, and then interest rates just move lower from there, deeply negative. across a lot of Europe, and there's now more than $10 trillion of negative-yielding sovereign debt around the world. Can this trend continue?

Jeffrey Christian: I think it can. You know, I think one of the problems is that we're in uncharted territories in terms of financials and economic environment, and we've never really seen an extended period of time with massive negative interest rates on sovereign debt. And negative interest rates on excess reserves in the monetary system in Europe, Japan, United States, just about every major economy. And there's a lot of things that are there that just have never been seen before.

And part of the problem for everyone is to stop and say, you know what, we are in, in fact, new territory. And the rules that we thought we could live by for 40, 50 years probably have changed. They probably— some of those rules don't necessarily apply. So I look at the period of low real interest rate or low nominal rates in the United States, negative real interest rates, negative nominal rates in Europe and Japan and Switzerland, and I say, On a theoretical level, this probably isn't sustainable, but the theories probably no longer apply here. And the reality is that I think we could see an extremely long period of time with extremely low interest rates, simply because the system as we knew it in the postwar era no longer is operable.

Erik Townsend: Well, and certainly negative real interest rates bode very well for precious metals because it means precious metals no longer have the objection of having to compete with something that's yielding. These other things are not yielding anything. What about the excess banking reserves? The banking system is carrying a large excess of reserves over what's required. What are the implications of that on economic growth?

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, we've spent a lot of time in the first half of this year, the first 8 months of this year looking at negative interest rates, low interest rates, and excess bank reserves, trying to make sense of it. And frankly, we can't make sense of it. And when we talk to people at others, at various central banks, and we talk to other economists, they can't really make sense or explain these things too. I mean, if you look at the excess reserves in the United States right now, we have about $2.3 trillion in excess reserves held primarily by large banks, half U.S. banks, half foreign banks in the U.S. banking system. And the Fed is paying 25 basis points interest on that. It makes no sense to me for the Fed and everybody to be saying we need to stimulate growth, but yet we're paying people 25 basis points to hold excess reserves that other Otherwise would be lent out.

And if you look at U.S. banking, or, and the same is true in Europe and Switzerland and Japan, you never had excess reserves before 2008. And in 2008, in the midst of the global financial crisis, the Fed started paying interest rates on monetary reserves. It didn't quite make sense to me then, and it certainly doesn't make sense to me now.

And And when you start talking to Fed policymakers and you say, why is it that you're paying 25 bps? If you want to stimulate lending, it doesn't make sense to raise your interest rates the way you've been saying to, based on a theory that's never been proven empirically to hold water.

It makes sense to stop paying 25 basis points to banks for holding excess reserves and to jawbone them into increasing their lending. And the Fed has done neither of those things. So there's this big disconnect that we just don't understand. And, you know, like I said, $2.3 trillion in excess reserves in the United States, about $600 or $700 billion in excess reserves in Europe, about $600 billion in excess reserves in Switzerland, and then excess reserves in Japan and the U.K.

Hey, it just doesn't make sense for this to be going on. And I think that the, the matrix of interest rates and excess reserves is going to be a key factor in trying to determine how global economic conditions unfold going forward and what it means for stock market, for the bond market, and for gold and silver and other assets.

Inflation versus deflation in an aging world

Erik Townsend: And I couldn't agree with you more. The Fed talks so much about how they want to get the banking system lending again. While simultaneously they're providing a financial incentive to the banks not to lend, which just blows my mind. The backdrop, though, that we've been in for the last several years here is disinflation, if not outright deflation. Some people have opined that that is set to continue, that a deflationary spiral is beginning and will last for several years. Other people have said, hey, wait a minute, all of the major inflations in history were preceded by a whiff of deflation first, and we're about to see the reversal into runaway inflation.

Jeffrey Christian: Right.

Erik Townsend: What do you think? Is it one of those? Is it somewhere in between? What's your outlook for deflation, inflation?

Jeffrey Christian: I think it's one or the other. You know, as long as we have this muddle-through economy, I think we can have the disinflation that we've been seeing in the United States and the deflationary pressures that we've been seeing in Europe and Japan. And again, I think that one of the keys to understanding what's going to happen in the future is to understand that the past is not going to continue into the future.

I mean, if you listen to policymakers in the industrialized world, they keep talking about, well, we should have 2% inflation, we should have, you know, 3% real GDP. And the reality in Europe, Japan, and the United States is we have aging populations. And those metrics, those metrics Those economic targets that people used were valid for growing economies with with young populations. As the populations and the economic structures in the industrialized worlds mature, we should be seeing less inflationary pressures and slower growth, and that's what we're seeing. So I think part of the problem that we have is slower. Economic growth. But part of the problem that we have is policymakers who have expectations of too high of economic growth. So I think they're expecting too much of maturing, aging economies.

And so they're putting undue pressures on it and they're managing fiscal policy inappropriately. They should be gearing down and moving toward a slower growth, lower inflation period.

In terms of inflation versus deflation, inflation comes from 2 places. One is excess money creation, and we have seen excess money creation, but all that money sitting in excess reserves. And the reason why we've been paying attention to excess reserves is if those policies change and those excess reserves become mobilized That could have inflationary pressures, but we don't necessarily see monetary authorities changing those policies at least for the next several years. So we think that those inflationary pressures are unlikely to come out at least for the next several years.

The other source of inflation is in the real economy. You know, the relationship between supply and demand of goods of services, and again, with a slow aging. Population and maturing economic structures, you're seeing continued growth in supply of goods and services and a slowdown in demand for those goods and services, which is causing deflationary pressures and disinflationary pressures. So we think that what we're going to see is continued low inflation, deflationary pressures, deflationary risks, and inflation is postponed indefinitely until something major changes, both in the way fiscal policy is run and the way monetary policy is run.

Erik Townsend: So, just to summarize what you've said so far, to make sure I've got it straight, it sounds like for a number of reasons— growing geopolitical tensions, the fact that we have this negative interest rate environment— there's a lot of good reasons to think that gold and silver are going to continue to do reasonably well But the moonshot in prices that would occur if there were a sudden reversal from deflation into a runaway inflation trend where gold would suddenly outperform dramatically, that's really not on the radar, at least near horizon-wise. That might be coming several years down the road. Is that a good summary?

Jeffrey Christian: I think that's a good summary. It's, it's a real risk, but it's a low-probability risk, and we're watching it, and we're telling We're advising our clients and we're behaving, you know, personally, saying, look, you should have some insurance policy, i.e., gold and silver, set aside in case that money does become mobilized. But it's probably a low-probability issue for the next several years, so the insurance policy should have a low premium at this point.

Soros and Icahn bearishness, excess reserves and stocks

Jeffrey Christian: Okay.

Erik Townsend: There's another growing opinion out there, a growing chorus of people, some very famous people, George Soros, Carl Icahn, Stan Druckenmiller, who have all come out and basically taken extremely bearish views on U.S. economy and U.S. equities. But, you know, frankly, Soros has had this opinion for a good solid year now, I think. And, you know, the tape just keeps marching higher. Do you think these guys are onto something? Are we looking at maybe this fall a major tail risk of some kind of, you know, the beginning of the next 2008 kind of event, which it seems like a few people Do you think the Fed is on to something that people are predicting, or do you think this is overblown?

Jeffrey Christian: I think they're on to something. Again, like everybody else, I think they're struggling with trying to understand what's changed this time around. And so, if you look at the stock market and the economy and the relationship between economic activity, interest rates, inflation, monetary aggregate and the stock market, you would say that the stock market does seem overblown and that we are at a great risk of another major financial crisis and economic downturn. But a lot of this all comes back to those excess reserves, you know. And I think one of the things— well, I'll get, I'll get back to that. And instead of this cataclysmic thing there may be a higher probability that what we see is continued muddle-through, continued disinflation, and continued blah economic activity instead of a cataclysmic resolution.

We do think that there'll be a recession in the United States, probably in 2018, you know, is the most probable period that we're looking for. But we think it could be a relatively mild recession. Especially compared to the last one. So while the risk of a big recession and a major financial crisis is real and it's out there, we think a more likely scenario will be a less dramatic recession and some financial problems, but not as cataclysmic as we saw in 2008-2009.

Now, going back to those excess reserves, we can't understand why the central banks central banks are doing this, we can understand why the banks, the commercial banks, are doing it. A, in the United States, they're being paid to hold this stuff. You don't make a lot of money at 25 basis points, but if you have excess reserves, your required reserves are sort of quarantined, and those are what you have to keep and all, but the excess reserves can be hypothecated.

And what you do is you lend out those excess reserves in a variety of high-yield products. So, we think one of the reasons why you're seeing the stock market go from strength to strength or height to height is because of those excess reserves being available for large investors, private equity firms, and large corporations to take over mergers to do stock buybacks, and to invest in the stock market in a variety of ways that yield them 5%, 6% or more on these excess reserves.

And, you know, you go to Europe, the European Central Bank has said that the bond-buying program that it will do, because there's a— there are starting to be questions about how many sovereign bonds are out there that the European Central Banking System can buy from investors to undertake quantitative easing and provide large-scale asset purchase programs to pump money into the European thing. The ECB has said that they will consider new corporate bonds. So as you look at Bayer looking to buy Monsanto, Bayer legally could go to the Bundesbank and sell it Bayer corporate bonds and use the proceeds to buy Monsanto, which will keep Monsanto shares and the Dow Jones that much higher.

Yeah, and, and I think that when you look at the, the disconnect between falling interest rates and, and weak economic activity and, and, and low inflation and still high unemployment and very high underemployment, and you say, how is it that the stock market can be rising in this economic environment?

I think a big part of the answer has to do with the mobilization of those excess bank reserves. And I think Soros and Druckenmiller and Icahn and everybody else are correct to be worried about it, but I also think that you have to take it into the context context of what's really going on with all of these, all of these excess reserves at this time to understand, yes, there is an increased risk of this cataclysmic development, but unfortunately what we might see is a continuation of what we've seen over the last 15 months already.

Erik Townsend: Well, so it sounds like although perhaps it is a low-likelihood possibility, if something were to change— let's say we get a new president who, you know, proclaims that they're going to start pressuring the Fed to stop paying banks for holding excess reserves because they want to get the banks lending to the people again, which would certainly be a popular message, that could be a really huge up signal, you know, buy signal for gold and sell signal for stocks based on what you're saying.

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, you know, one of the things that amazed me was a few months ago Donald Trump was asked about, you know, his concerns about the Federal debt. And he said, look, you know, we have incredible ability to borrow more money. Investors around the world are continuing to buy Treasuries. And then he said, and if they ever don't want to hold these Treasuries, we can renegotiate cents on the dollar.

Now, that's a really frightening idea for the Treasury. You know, basically what you're saying is the Treasury would default and reschedule and say, look, Guys, we're just not good for this. We'll give you 50 cents on the dollar or whatever. And when he said that, the markets didn't even blink. But if you had a new president who said, you know, look, this is what we got to do, yeah, it could really upset the apple cart very quickly.

Failing global cooperation and declining US stature

Erik Townsend: I want to move on to some other geopolitical issues. You know, something I've noticed is just a general trend around global cooperation starting to fail. If you look at the G20 meeting last week, Obama shows up and it appeared that the Chinese intentionally forgot to set up an airstair for him to get off the airplane with. Meanwhile, they're greeting Putin with the red carpet treatment.

What do you make of this trend in terms of failing global cooperation?

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, as I go around the world, I talk about— and I've talked about it for 20-some-odd years now, I think. The idea that you're moving to a period— through a period of ever greater breakdown in the post-war economic and political cooperation. Now, when I talk in the United States, I talk about reduced international cooperation. When I talk overseas, I talk about reduced U.S. hegemony over political, economic, currency, and financial issues. And that's what they understand. And what you're seeing is that the U.S. has been losing stature really for about 20 years, probably since the late Reagan era and the George H. Bush period. Clinton actually helped rebuild it by running surpluses for a few years. George W. Bush Bush definitely hurt it, and Obama has definitely not helped it.

And so the US has continually lost status. I mean, it's no— doing as much work as I do in China, it is beyond a doubt in my mind that the Chinese consciously snubbed Obama. And then you had his face-to-face with Putin, where they were mimicking prize fights In the pre-fight press conference, and then you had the problems with the Philippines president. So you definitely are seeing a diminution of respect for the U.S. government, and that's probably going to continue regardless of who wins the presidential election.

And, and you're definitely seeing a breakdown in international cooperation.

Erik Townsend: Well, it's amazing too, you know, I just saw today Mexico is firing the finance minister who set up the meeting with Donald Trump coming to, to meet the President of Mexico. There was a— an intercept— Russian aircraft intercepting a U.S. spy plane over the Black Sea, supposedly 10-foot separation on a fast flyby. There was Iranian fast attack boats harassing U.S. military vessels.

I mean, boy, it just seems like things are heating up.

Jeffrey Christian: Well, you saw NATO ran military exercises in the East Baltic last month, and the the the Russians expressed their their discontent by flying over the plane the ships that were in the East Baltic very closely. And the U.S. expressed chagrin that we would you know sail our boats right next to their shore, and they would take umbrage with it. At the same time we were doing that, we sailed two aircraft carrier battle. Battleships into the South China Sea. Now, the thing to remember is this: if you look at military hardware, the U.S. has like 19 aircraft battle, uh, ships and aircraft battle fleets.

Russia has one. They can't even protect both of their coasts at the same time with the aircraft battle fleet. And China is building its first. So for the U.S. to send 2 aircraft carrier battle fleets into the South China Sea is to say to them, look, you may be building these islands, you may be claiming all of this sea for yourself, but let's look at who's got the power.

Socialism, cronyism and fascism

Erik Townsend: It's a scary trend, and certainly the presidential candidates, both of them, don't seem to be pacifists in terms of their foreign policy stance. I want to come back, though, to the trend that I'm concerned with in the United States, which is a lot, a really large number of young adults in the United States have begun to favor socialism. And I put socialism in quotes because frankly, I'm not sure that they even understand what the word means. Something I've noticed is the view seems to be capitalism, which is what we have now, isn't working and therefore we should try socialism. And, you know, I feel the opposite way, which is capitalism is what we should go back to. Because the system that we have now of increasing corruption and cronyism isn't working. But it seems like younger people really have this view that capitalism is bad and we need socialism.

Are you concerned? And what do you think the impacts of that are going to be on financial markets going forward?

Jeffrey Christian: Well, I think I agree with you. I mean, you know, I'm not so much concerned with socialism because I I guess socialism has always been something that a lot of young people idealistically say they favor. You know, I do think that we need a purer, more cleanly regulated form of capitalism. And my biggest concern is not with, you know, socialistic tendencies, but with fascist tendencies.

And fascism is what you call cronyism. I mean, fascism Capitalism really is state corporatism. The state exists to protect corporations. And we're seeing that, and we've seen it, you know, ever since the 1950s. I mean, Eisenhower warned about it with his military-industrial complex speech on his way out the door. He was seeing it take hold in the 1950s, and it's just gotten worse in the '60s '70s and up until now, and it's gotten much worse.

And it's not just in the United States, it's around the world. And you can call it fascism, or you can call it cronyism, or you can call it corrupt government, but it's all the same thing. And it actually gives capitalism a bad name. So, you know, I kind of worry a little bit about socialistic tendencies. But I'm much more concerned about the older people and the people who are actually running the economy and the government right now and their fascist or cronyistic tendencies, because I think that those are, are much more detrimental, both in terms of overall economic activity, but also in terms of creating a political environment that doesn't lend itself to credible and healthy reform. In terms of restoring capitalism and, and sort of a well-regulated capitalist system, which is what we really need.

Erik Townsend: Actually, Jeff, I remember you told me a story off the air about this. Why don't you share it with our listeners?

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, in, in March of 2009, I, I was giving a speech at the World Bank commodities conference at the World Bank. This was about 2 weeks after Obama was inaugurated. It. And every place in the paper, all of the Republicans were talking about how Obama was a socialist and he was pursuing socialist policies, things like, you know, healthcare and democratization of government, things like that. And I was talking to a very prominent Republican that I knew in Washington, and I said, you guys know that what he's proposing is not really socialism. And he said, of course. I said, so why are you saying it?

And he said, well, in the 1930s, the National Socialists in Germany, they started gaining power in the Bundestag, and for 4 years between elections, they kept saying, you don't have to vote for the Nazis, you can vote for the Socialists. And 4 years later, they took power in the Bundestag through the vote.

And, you know, I mean, they didn't take over the country, they were voted They were voted into power, which is something that's very important to remember when you talk about this cronyism and the rise of fascism and the rise of Nazism. They were voted into power. And they were voted into power by saying, you don't have to vote for us, you can vote for the socialists.

So this Republican was telling me this. And I said, so you guys, the Republican Party, are taking your cues from the Nazis as to how to run your campaign? And he said, yes. They said it worked for them. So, you know, when I listen to all this talk about, oh my God, you know, Hillary's a socialist, Obama's a socialist, and I know what socialism is, and that's not socialism, you know.

It's more like cronyism, what we're seeing right now. You know, if you talk about healthcare reform, talk about the healthcare reform that Obama put in place and what it did for the insurance companies by basically demanding that everybody pay insurance but not opening up the insurance companies to competition on an interstate basis for health insurance. You know, that's cronyism. That's not socialism. That's cronyism, and it's a payoff for the health insurance industry.

You know, and, and so yeah, I mean, when I hear all this talk about socialism, it's not socialism. What it is is Republicans trying to scare people who don't know socialism from cronyism.

Erik Townsend: Well, and to be sure, I agree with you that it's not socialism in a real definition of socialism, but what we have now sure ain't free market capitalism like we once had in this country. That's for sure.

Jeffrey Christian: Absolutely not.

Clinton versus Trump for gold

Erik Townsend: Let's move back to your comments about the military-industrial complex and the impact that that's had. Hillary versus Donald in terms of who takes the presidency. What would you see the implications being for markets and particularly for gold?

Jeffrey Christian: Let's start with Donald because he's the harder one to respond to. You have no idea because you have no idea who this guy is and what he's going to do and what kind of policies he would pursue. I think that he would be problematic for the global economy and for the U.S. economy. He seems to be a very very uninformed person who tends to shoot from the hip, and I would be very much concerned about that.

I did, in a speech in South Africa last month, say that I thought that Hillary would probably be more bullish for gold, and I say that because I look at her as part of this cronyism that's been growing for decades. And I think that she would be— she would not do anything to help the global economy or the U.S. economy or U.S. middle-class families or the unemployed and the underemployed. In addition to which, she's extremely militaristic, and she has basically promised starting 1, 2, 3 fights, you know, wars during the primary season.

And you look at the people that she's gathering around her, they're all militaristic. You know, she's got the support of people within the CIA and the military who really want to attack Syria. They even want to send in snipers to shoot at Russian and Iranian soldiers in Syria. And they've talked about how they should be targeting Assad with bombs, which is illegal. It's a war crime on a global basis.

So I think that she would be extremely detrimental for global peace. She would be extremely militaristic. We'd see more wars. We'd see more U.S. interventionism. And we would see a further deterioration in U.S. stature around the world. All of which would help accelerate that investor conclusion that investors should hold fewer dollars and more gold. So, I think that she would probably be much more bullish for gold than Donald would be, at least initially.

You know, it could be that once Donald got into power, he would be doing things that would drive gold wild, but you just don't know. With her, you can pretty well Well, be sure that she'd be good for gold.

Future of energy: EVs, fuel cells and hydrogen carriers

Erik Townsend: And I want to move on to another topic before we get too political here, which is just the future of energy. You know, I think a lot of our listeners understand that although right now we're in a major glut of too much crude oil in the market, it's a temporary phenomenon, and eventually we are going to face a peak oil scenario. What do you see in the long run in terms of hydrogen economy, fuel cells, and

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, yeah, there's a lot of talk right now that fuel cells and electric cars and hydrogen economy are going to keep oil prices down forever, and that's not going to happen. And, and I almost should defer to you on the oil market because I know you spend a lot of time looking at it. But the reality is that we're going to be very much dependent on hydrocarbons, oil and natural gas, for decades and decades to come. And, you know, electric vehicles— our projection is that 10 years from now, electric vehicles might represent 10% of new car sales. Or, I mean, I'm sorry, 5%.

So that's a very small chink in the hydrocarbon market. There are some developments with hydrogen that are interesting. Fuel cells don't make sense to us. Battery technology Still doesn't make a lot of sense to us. It's gotten better, but it's still very problematic. I think that the transition away from hydrocarbons to other energies is going to be extremely slow. We are seeing a lot of technological developments, but those technological developments are competing with each other, so it's hard to say how it's all going to shake out.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, it's something I definitely have noticed is I think a lot of people And a lot of investors are just so affected by the experience of the computer revolution that they perceive technology as inherently advancing very quickly. And the thing they don't understand is there's no Moore's Law for batteries. You know, that has to do with getting more semiconductors onto a chip. It doesn't help with the battery problem. And I look at something like Tesla, and yes, Teslas are really cool cars. You know, if I, if If I was going to buy a car, I would consider having one. But if you look at the market capitalization of that company, the market is basically anticipating that they're going to make more cars than Ford. And, you know, it's, it's not going to happen. There's not enough lithium to build all the batteries for that. So, you know, it's, it's going to be a long, long time before we see the kind of adoption of electric cars that so many people seem to think is just around the corner.

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, I mean, electric cars are coming. But they're coming very slowly, and the technologies are all up for redefinition. I'm a pessimist about fuel cells. I just think the technology is is unproven and too expensive and cumbersome. I'm much more interested in hydrogen engines. There's been a lot of interesting research done on hydrogen engines. We're actually involved with a company that has the technology to. Use liquid organic compounds to carry hydrogen. So you can hydrogenate these organic compound liquids.

You can ship the hydrogen as hydrogenated organic liquids that are actually less flammable than gasoline. You can use filling stations to pump and recover the stuff. And, and that saves you the $40 trillion of hydrogen distribution and storage facilities that you need to build to have, you know, hydrogen vehicles. But that technology is unproven. It's still in the laboratory stage.

There's one company that has moved a little bit forward on it, but they're using hydrocarbons to carry as the liquid organic carrier. So you can't, you know, you can't get a byproduct of gas gasoline refining and use it to replace gasoline. It doesn't work that way. But that technology is decades and decades away. And in the meantime, we're still going to be using hydrocarbons, petroleum, natural gas, and nuclear power. So I think, you know, it's interesting and there's going to be some very disruptive technologies. They will come about fast by the Their standards, but that fast is going to be defined in decades, not years.

CPM Group research and services

Erik Townsend: Jeff, you know, there's about 20 more topics that I would just love to dive into with you, but unfortunately we are out of time for today's interview. Before we close, I know that at CPM Group, most of your best research is really reserved for your paying clients. A lot of people don't realize, though, that you have a section on your website where you make a lot of your research papers actually free to anyone who wants them. Can you tell Can you tell us a little bit more about that?

Jeffrey Christian: Yeah, if you go to our website, which is cpmgroup.com, there's a, there's a section across the top called Our Market Views. And, and in that section, we have presentations that we've made, some of our older reports, press releases on some of our yearbooks and things. And there's also special sections so that, you know, because, as you know, I Yeah. And even though they hate to talk about gold and silver conspiracies, we have sections debunking, providing evidence that debunks the gold and silver conspiracies. So, when people say, well, talk to me about these things, say, no, just go to our website. There's free stuff there. You can read it and download it. But there's all sorts of other things. There's stuff about, there's an article like, Why Bullion Banking Explained, which explains how bullion banks trade.

Big Gold and Silver, which is something that a lot of people don't understand. There's another section, I think, on, on why derivatives don't matter to you and me. So there's a whole lot of free reads there in the Our Market View section of our website.

Erik Townsend: And I think we've got a sample of one of those pieces that we've already sent our registered users at MacroVoices.com in their Research Roundup email this week. We'll try to get a link into, to that section of the website. For our institutional listeners that might be interested in some of your research products, give us a quick overview of what you do at CPM Group.

Jeffrey Christian: Right. Well, we do a lot of research. We do research on precious metals, but we also do specialty metals. We're doing some work on— right now we're talking to a major institution about work on what we call energy metals, because lithium, vanadium, manganese, cobalt, all of these metals could go one way or the other dramatically depending on whether or not the technologies that would use them get commercialized or get replaced with other technologies.

We do a lot of basic research. We also have a group that will help investors invest not only in the basic commodities, but also in commodity-producing companies. We have another group that works works on hedging strategies for producers and consumers of commodities. And we have a couple investment banking professionals who help match interested institutional and high-net-worth individual investors with interesting projects. So we're working on a variety of investments in gold, silver, hydrogen, a thing called compressed air energy storage right now, which is a very Interesting technology that's been grossly overlooked for about 130 years.

Lithium, iridium, you know, so there are a variety. And helium, interestingly enough. So we have a lot of stuff that's actually oriented at the financial management of exposure to commodities.

Erik Townsend: Well, Jeff, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Aaron Chan and I will be back as Macro MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program.

Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan.

Postgame: what reserve currency means; trade settlement

Aaron Chan: Great interview, Erik. Jeff Christian is obviously best known as a precious metals expert, but I really enjoy his perspective on the broader macro picture as well. So we announced a few weeks ago that we'd be taking listener requests for topics that we'll discuss after the featured guest interview, but we haven't received many requests. So listeners, be sure to let us know if there's a topic you want us to cover.

Meanwhile, I'm going to seize the opportunity and focus this week's discussion on one of my own favorite topics, reserve currencies. Now, you hear the phrase reserve currency thrown around all the time, but frankly, I think most people, including professionals on Wall Street, don't have a clue or even a very deep understanding of its meaning. So, Erik, let's start with what the phrase reserve currency means and why it's important in the first place.

Erik Townsend: Well, there's really 2 common uses of that term reserve currency. And I agree with you that most people only seem to know the first one. So, let's take them in order. The first definition really would be better termed the International Trade Settlement Currency. In other words, if you're going to have international trade, it would be very inefficient to do it in all of the different currencies of all of the different countries involved. If you were going to import your wine from France and pay for it in French francs, or now in euros, and import your tea from China and have to pay for that in Chinese Renminbi, and import your tacos from Mexico and have to pay in pesos for that, that would mean everybody has to have a whole bunch of every single different currency lying around in order to resolve international trade. This was more important 50 years ago than it was today, because in those days, if you didn't have any pesos and needed to buy something from Mexico in pesos, it could be a complex transaction to go and get some pesos.

So for that reason, basically, it was agreed that everybody needed to pretty much pick one currency that would be used to settle most, if not all, international trade. The US Dollar serves in that role, and it really is the international trade settlement currency, although people often use the phrase reserve currency to refer to that meaning. I would also observe that it's not as important as it used to be, because these days you can buy those pesos if you wanted to do business with Mexico in pesos.

At the click of a mouse, in less than a second, you can buy those pesos and do the international foreign exchange transaction on a computer terminal. So, I don't think that function of having to have all international trade settled in the same currency is nearly important in modern times as it was a few decades ago when we didn't have this immediate ability to transact forex transactions.

Aaron Chan: Right. So, the first definition is that the global reserve currency is what's used to settle international trade transactions. It could be in cash or US Treasury bills and bonds. Regular listeners will recall from Jeff Snider's excellent interview on the global Eurodollar system that global Treasury holdings are actually falling. So that's interesting to point out. But you said that the second definition was actually more important. So what's that second definition and why is it more important?

Reserve assets, Bretton Woods, the petrodollar and exorbitant privilege

Erik Townsend: This is where we really get to the phrase reserve currency. What it's referring to is central banks of all the governments around the world have to hold reserve assets. Think of that as the savings account for a country. Why do they need to have that savings account? If something happens, if something goes wrong with international trade, and suddenly that country's currency is losing value against other currencies, it's collapsing in value, the central bank has to intervene to defend the currency. The way they do that is by buying their own currency on the open market. Well, they can't buy their own currency unless they have some other currency to pay for it with.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: Back in the good old days, gold was the central bank asset of choice. The way that central banks held reserves was to have gold bullion in a vault someplace. So, it's an interesting story of how the U.S. dollar became the reserve currency. And the answer is, back in 1944, the Bretton Woods Accord basically made the U.S. dollar interchangeable with gold. So, it was effectively U.S. dollars are as good as gold.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: And that was accomplished through the Bretton Woods Accord, where the United States made a promise to the rest of the world that forever and all time, you can trust us, we'll never renege on our word. The U.S. dollar will be convertible by international holders to gold bullion for anybody who wants to convert it at a fixed rate of exchange of $35 per ounce, which will never change. We promise absolutely, cross our hearts, hope to die, no matter what.

Until, that is, President Nixon in 1971 said, we were actually only kidding about that. And actually, what President Nixon said at the time was that he was going to suspend temporarily the convertibility of US dollars into gold by international holders because it was necessary in order to thwart the wrongdoings perpetrated by speculators, who he was blaming for this action. Of course, in reality, it was the US overspending on the Vietnam War That was resulting in a lot of people realizing that U.S. dollars were not worth as much as the gold they were convertible for. And so there was essentially a run on the gold holdings of the United States. So, the U.S. basically broke its promise. Why then? Well, what a lot of people thought this would mean back in the '70s— it was August 15th, 1971 that President Nixon made that announcement— was basically, okay, this means that the U.S.

dollar will no longer be the reserve currency.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: Because it's not convertible into gold anymore, and that was the whole reason for making it the reserve currency back in 1944. The thing is, TINA, there is no alternative. If you're not going to use US dollars as the world's reserve asset currency, what would you use instead? I suppose the argument might have been to go back to gold bullion, but as we talked about in a previous show, Henry Kissinger was successful at negotiating the petrodollar agreement.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: with the Saudis and with other Arab oil producers. And the U.S. dollar has remained the de facto reserve currency, even though the Bretton Woods agreement broke down with Nixon slamming the gold window in '71. And of course, as we talked about after, I think it was Gary Shilling's interview, there's a gentleman in Russia called Sergey Glazyev who wants very badly to change that. But for now, the U.S. dollar is and will likely remain the world's reserve currency.

Aaron Chan: Yeah, Erik, hearing you describe it just sounds like the world's biggest bait and switch. So the second and most important definition of reserve currency is that it is the currency in which central banks' reserve assets, effectively the savings account of a sovereign nation, are denominated, and hence the name reserve currency. But let's not stop there.

What are the implications of the US dollar being the reserve currency, both for the US and for other nations around the globe?

Erik Townsend: Well, what happens is it creates a massive artificial demand for the reserve currency. Everybody needs to have dollars because both to settle international trade and to have that savings account, they have to have dollars. That artificial demand for dollars effectively allows the issuing country, the United States, to run huge current account deficits. So you can have a massive trade deficit importing all kinds of stuff from other countries, not balancing that by exporting the same amount of stuff.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: Off to other countries. Normally, that would have horrific adverse consequences. But essentially, the United States gets a get-out-of-jail-free card and gets away with running a huge current account deficit without having to pay the penalty for it. And as we've discussed before, this is what Valéry Giscard d'Estaing, the former finance minister and later president of France, called exorbitant privilege. The United States' unique ability to effectively go into debt for free And he didn't like that, but he couldn't do anything to change it.

Glazyev, the Triffin dilemma and the yuan's SDR inclusion

Aaron Chan: Erik, you said d'Estaing didn't like the fact that the U.S. had this, as you say, exorbitant privilege, but he couldn't do anything about it. And our regular listeners will recall that we talked about Sergey Glazyev and Robert Triffin after Gary Shilling's feature interview a couple of weeks ago. And I'd recommend that interested listeners go back to that conversation for more perspective and details on how this fits into the story. But for the sake of listeners who missed that conversation, We just barely have time for a quick summary. So, Erik, give us the Coles Notes here.

Erik Townsend: Oh boy, it's a big topic to do Cliff Notes on, but Sergey Glazyev, again, a Russian scholar, advisor to Vladimir Putin, very well-known man in Russia, ran for President of Russia, I think it was in '94, sometime in the '90s, and he's very well-known there. It was actually interesting. We brought him up, I think it was on the Gary Shilling Show, and we got 2 emails from listeners One guy in Russia said, thank you so much, I'm so impressed that you know one of the most important and well-respected scholars in our country. Thank you for mentioning him, that's great. Another guy, I assume is a Russian living somewhere other than Russia, because he said, back home, that guy Glazyev is so badly not respected, you shouldn't even mention him because you'll lose credibility with Russian listeners if you do.

So—

Aaron Chan: Wow.

Erik Townsend: From these 2 contrasting things, I can only conclude that Russia has politics too, and Glazyev is either loved or hated depending on who you talk to in Russia.

In any case, what his recent fame has been associated with is he's proposed this de-dollarization strategy, effectively trying to persuade the other BRICS countries to abandon trade settlement in US dollars and transact business in some other currency. Now, I think that's because Glazyev's a very smart guy. He knows the more important issue is not trade settlement, but reserve assets. The thing is, that's a tougher nut to crack because there's no other alternative. You know, there's no bond market deep and liquid enough to absorb central bank-sized capital flows other than the U.S. Treasury market. So he's focusing on the easier nut, trying to persuade other countries to do their transactions not in dollars, but in something else.

And I think eventually he probably will lobby for reserve assets. There's been some speculation that China and Russia might jointly sponsor a gold-backed currency. You know, nobody in the West takes any of this stuff seriously. Frankly, I think they should. It's not going to happen overnight, but we've got 2 massively important countries that are starting to work together to try to undo the hegemony that the US dollar enjoys in the international monetary system.

I think that's an important thing.

Who's Robert Triffin? 1950s economist. He described a paradox. What's the paradox? Essentially, what Triffin said is, how do you decide what's going to be the reserve currency in the first place? Well, it has to be, what's the best credit? Without a doubt, in 1944, time of Bretton Woods, the United States dollar was clearly the best credit, because the United States was the biggest creditor nation in the world.

Aaron Chan: Right.

Erik Townsend: Well, what did Triffin predict? He said, if you make a country the reserve currency issuer, what it does is it enables that country to basically engage in massive overborrowing, living and borrowing and spending beyond their means, and engaging in what Triffin, when he predicted it back in the 1950s, he termed military adventurism. And starting with Vietnam, needless to say, the U.S. has had its share of military activity since then. Triffin predicted that this would result in the reserve currency issuer, that is the United States, transitioning over time from being the best credit to the worst credit, and therefore no longer worthy of that reserve currency status. And of course, what's happened in that time? The U.S. has gone from being the biggest creditor nation in the world to the biggest debtor nation in the history of the world. So, Triffin got it right. What he predicted is eventually Unfortunately, the reserve currency issuer has to lose that reserve currency status someday because it will eventually become the worst credit and no longer worthy of that status.

Sergey Glazyev knows this, and he's trying to be the guy that is the catalyst to start the international movement that would eventually strip the United States of its exorbitant privilege and its reserve currency status. Obviously, big ships take a long time to change course. course. So, this is not going to happen overnight. Nobody takes Glazyev seriously in the West, and I think they should. He's not going to change the world overnight, but, you know, he might be the guy who started something. Does that make Glazyev a terrorist of economic warfare, or does that make him a freedom fighter who's engaged in righting a terrible injustice of the U.S. having this hegemony over the rest of the global financial system? Well, I guess that depends on your perspective and which country you're sitting A lot of people in the world would probably see him as the freedom fighter.

The United States is going to see him as a threat.

Aaron Chan: Erik, that's fascinating stuff. And really, no matter the perspective you take, I think what's for certain is that the tectonic plates of the global monetary system are in motion. And with China's upcoming inclusion in the SDR on October 1st, the yuan's ascension as a global reserve currency will be, I think, one of the most important storylines of this century. Now, having said that, we're looking forward to interviewing some China-centric experts in the near future to discuss this monumental shift. Well, unfortunately, we're out of time. Listeners, we're not quite sure what to make of the fact that you guys aren't requesting topics for the segment. Is that because you preferred the old format with Erik and I discussing the feature interview guest, or maybe you didn't realize we were taking requests in the first place? We'd really love to hear from you in our listener discussion forum at MacroVoices.com.

Erik Townsend: Thanks, Patrick.

Aaron Chan: where there's a very quiet thread titled Request Thread: Post Guest Interview Topics. Please make a request for future topics there. You can also reach out to us directly on Twitter. If you don't enjoy the new format, let us know why not so we can consider changing it. Erik, anything else before we wrap up the show?

Listener housekeeping and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Well, just the usual broken record. I want to start with a shout-out to thank Tyler Durden at ZeroHedge ZeroHedge once again picked up our Labor Day weekend with Art Berman. And did a feature article on that, which we tremendously appreciate. It brought us some additional traffic to the website. And that additional traffic, you know, the more that we grow, the more that that helps us to bring bigger and better guests to the program. We need your help too, listeners. Please retweet us when we announce the show. Tell your friends about MacroVoices, particularly those of you who have access to some of the people we're trying to get to. What we're finding is that a lot of guests— Art Berman sent me an email saying he's hearing from his clients.

Aaron Chan: Hmm.

Erik Townsend: That the MacroVoices interviews are by far the highest quality interviews of any of the stuff that he does anywhere else. So it really feels great to have that positive feedback.

The problem is, when we reach out to a guy like Kyle Bass, his handlers have still never heard of us. So for those of you, and I know you do exist in our listener audience, who have access to Kyle Bass, who have access to some of the other big names that we've been trying to get to, Let them know that MacroVoices is a little bit different than the average podcast run by a teenager and that it really is worth their time, because that's where we need your help the most, folks, is getting through those people. One of the biggest ways that you can help us, whether you have those contacts or not, is to register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefits of registering: number one, you help us. The more registered users we have, the more able Aaron is to recruit the very best guests for the program. Number two, Second benefit, you'll automatically receive our Research Roundup emails.

That gives you a compendium of links, both to presentations from our featured interview guest, as well as to the best free research that we could find on the internet every single week. If you don't want it, it takes one click to opt out of it with the safe unsubscribe link. So don't let that stop you from registering. Aaron, let's let people know what's in this week's Research Roundup.

Aaron Chan: Right. So this week we've got a full course of links that includes investor letters and company presentations to share with you guys. Now, I particularly enjoyed Hummingbird Partners' investor letter, tennis analogies notwithstanding, in which they not only present some interesting statistical data on the 162-year trend of lengthening expansions and shortening contractions, but also delve into why this might be the case and shine a harsh light on the questionable statistical assumptions that underpin traditional economic and financial thought. I highly recommend this read. And for those of you who are more interested in the oil and gas sector, gas space, we have Enterprise Products Partners' slide deck from their recent presentation at the Citi MLP Midstream Infrastructure Conference. Finally, we've also got the latest from Jeff Snider, Jesse Felder, Marin Katusa, and Rick Rule.

So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we've gotten and continue to welcome your suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For our listeners who write or blog about global markets and would like to share that content with our pro-finance community, shoot us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag, and we'll include it in our weekly distribution.

If you haven't already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for the latest updates and interview releases. You can also follow Erik @ErikSTownsend and myself @_AaronChan_. For Erik Townsend, I'm Aaron Chan. Chat with you next week.

Announcer outro and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this week's episode of MacroVoices. This concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. Please register your free account at www.macrovoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial Content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week, which never includes advertising or marketing.

You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we're able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can also subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.

MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Aaron Chan, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top